Judy Rodd - Friends of Blackwater Canyon

The Charleston Gazette - print:
March 15, 2007
Judy Rodd
Fish and Wildlife withholding documents: What can be so secret about a
squirrel?
“Ginny,” the West Virginia northern flying squirrel (glaucomys sabrinus fuscus) is a charming, big-eyed, nocturnal
creature that lives only in the high Allegheny Mountains — in seven counties in West Virginia, and one county in
Virginia.
At night, Ginny and her family glide from the trees to the moist forest floor, where they feed on underground fungi. By
day, Ginny nests and raises her young in mature hardwood and spruce forests. Her special home is the beloved
Blackwater Canyon, West Virginia’s scenic crown jewel.
Ginny is a relic of the last Ice Age. When the glaciers retreated, Ginny’s ancestors were isolated on the high mountain
ridges. Like many West Virginians (human and otherwise), Ginny evolved a remarkable lifestyle, surviving in a
demanding and specialized habitat.
Ginny has been on the federal Endangered Species List since 1985. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service staff say they have
had no funding to establish and implement a proper recovery plan for Ginny and her species under the Endangered
Species Act.
In 2006, top officials at Fish and Wildlife announced a fast-track “de-listing” proposal for Ginny. Their plan is to strip all
federal endangered species protection from the West Virginia northern flying squirrel.
To add insult to injury, just as the public comment period on their plan was beginning, Fish and Wildlife officials said
they would “withhold” more than 2,000 pages in their files relating to their “Strip the Squirrel” plan from any public
inspection!
Just what kind of hanky-panky is going on at the Fish and Wildlife Service?
Well, it looks like hiding documents about agency plans for Ginny may be part of a larger, national problem.
The March 2007 issue of Sierra magazine reports evidence suggesting that political appointees in the Department of
the Interior are subverting the species protection mission of the Fish and Wildlife Service.
Here’s how the Beltway’s “culture of secrecy” is playing out in West Virginia:
Seven months ago, the “Save Our Squirrel” Coalition asked for the documents that Fish and Wildlife relied on in
preparing its plan. Fish and Wildlife released some documents, but it also filed an official response saying that the
public could not see 2,325 pages in the agency’s files.
Fish and Wildlife officials say these pages are secret, because the documents are “pre-decisional.” That means the
documents show what people in the agency have been doing and thinking since the governmental process started —
out of the public view — more than three years ago.
Excuse me? This isn’t national security. What can be so secret about a squirrel?
And what is so wrong with the public knowing what our employees are thinking and doing?
Page 1 of 2
Of course, we don’t have to see any secret documents to realize that the “Strip the Squirrel” plan is illegal and absurd.
Fish and Wildlife admits it has no idea how many squirrels there are. The acknowledged threats to Ginny and her
habitat are growing, not shrinking. The documents that have been released suggest that the meager scientific data
have been “cherry-picked” and mischaracterized, to support an unjustified but predetermined conclusion. (Does that
sound familiar?)
The record also shows that the service’s “fast track” protection removal process for Ginny began confidentially, long
before the plan was publicly announced last year. In the past, other species’ suitability for “de-listing” has been publicly
studied and assessed over a number of years. (There’s more trouble brewing — we’ve just learned that Fish and
http://www.wvgazette.com/webtools/print/Opinion/Op-Ed+Commentaries/2007031415
3/22/2007

The Charleston Gazette - print:
Wildlife is doing an in-house de-listing review for at least three more high-mountain West Virginia forest species.)
Fish and Wildlife claims we can trust the Monongahela National Forest to protect Ginny, even without endangered
species protection, but the new Mon Forest Plan authorizes a substantial increase in logging in squirrel habitat — what
kind of protection is that?
Federal endangered species protection for Ginny is crucial. The teachings of the spirit, science, law, common sense,
and pure self-interest are agreed: we must protect this rare, high-mountain “signature species” of the West Virginia
Highlands.
Spiritually, we are partners with Ginny in the Creation — and our human species has a special duty of stewardship.
Legally, our democratically enacted and well-settled law, the Endangered Species Act, demands continued protection.
Selfishly, the Allegheny Highlands are among West Virginia’s great natural resources and sustainable development
engines. Federal legal protection for Ginny helps preserve the beauty, the clean water, the clean air and the diverse
wildlife of the region.
Most important, more than 20 years of experience proves that there is plenty of room under endangered species
protection to accommodate all reasonable private business and public needs.
The “Save Our Squirrel” Coalition is confident that the illegal, improper, and unwise Fish and Wildlife de-listing plan
must and will founder on the shoals of public opposition on every front — scientific, legal, and civic. West Virginians
and our allies will not knuckle under to Beltway machinations.
Meanwhile, Congress should immediately investigate the “Strip the Squirrel” document cover-up — along with all other
improper influence and mismanagement in enforcing and defending the Endangered Species Act.
For information on how you can help Ginny, the West Virginia northern flying squirrel, go to www.saveblackwater.org;
or call (877) WVA-LAND.
Rodd is director of Friends of Blackwater.
TALK BACK: [WRITE TO THE EDITOR]
Click to Search for Related Stories in our Library
Print this Story
http://www.wvgazette.com/webtools/print/Opinion/Op-Ed+Commentaries/2007031415
Page 2 of 2
3/22/2007