29.04.2013 Views

Automatic Transfer Vehicle ATV Reentry Safety Trajectory ... - Congrex

Automatic Transfer Vehicle ATV Reentry Safety Trajectory ... - Congrex

Automatic Transfer Vehicle ATV Reentry Safety Trajectory ... - Congrex

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Risk Assessment Comparison: ESA/TEC - ACTA<br />

Initial ESA/TEC Risk<br />

Assessment<br />

ACTA Risk Assessment Updated ESA/TEC Risk<br />

Assessment<br />

November 2007 August 2008 September 2008<br />

- Descending re-entry track (expected<br />

trajectory)<br />

- initial mass of 20.1 t (expected mass)<br />

- 131 surviving fragments (60% of initial<br />

mass)<br />

- Explosion occurs at 75km altitude<br />

+/-2km at 1σ<br />

- Does not consider population sheltering<br />

- Fatality Kinetic Energy Threshold = 32J<br />

- Casualty Area ~ 108 m 2<br />

- Descending re-entry track (expected<br />

trajectory)<br />

- initial mass of 12.4 t (expected mass)<br />

- 214 surviving fragments (25% of initial<br />

mass)<br />

- Explosion at 78km altitude (nominal<br />

case, otherwise between [68 ; 84km])<br />

- Considers population sheltering<br />

- Fatality Kinetic Energy Threshold = 79J<br />

- Casualty Area ~ 205 m 2<br />

- Descending re-entry track (actual<br />

trajectory)<br />

- initial mass of 13.4 t (actual mass)<br />

- 214 surviving fragments from ACTA<br />

(25% of initial mass)<br />

- Explosion at 78km altitude (nominal<br />

case, otherwise between [68 ; 84km])<br />

- Does not consider population sheltering<br />

- Fatality Kinetic Energy Threshold = 32J<br />

- Casualty Area ~ 205 m 2<br />

P F = 2.0×10 -5 P F = 2.4×10 -5 P F = 4.1×10 -5<br />

28

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!