Minutes of Lanco Vidarbha Thermal Power Ltd. the proposed ...

Minutes of Environmental Public Hearing in respect of proposed M/s. Lanco
Vidarbha Thermal Power Ltd. the proposed 1320MW(660X2) Coal based
Thermal Power Project at Village Mandwa,Pulai& Belgaon, Tq.Dist. Wardha .
Environmental Public Hearing in respect of M/s. Lanco Vidarbha Thermal
Power Ltd. the proposed 1320MW(660X2) Coal based Thermal Power Project at
Village Mandwa,Pulai & Belgaon, Tq.Dist. Wardha was held on 17 th September
2010 at 12.15 hrs. at Project’s proposed site, Near 11 th Mile Stone, Belgaon-
Mandwa Road,Mandwa, Tq. & Dist. Wardha under the Chairmanship of Shri.
Avinash Katade, Sub-Divisional Officer / Magistrate (The representative nominated
by the District Collector, Wardha). Shri. A.T. Fulmali, Regional Officer, M.P.C. Board,
Nagpur was the member of the public hearing panel and Shri. N.G.Nihul, Sub-
Regional Officer-II, M.P.C. Board, Nagpur act as a convener. The Public Hearing
started at 12.15 hrs. with the permission of the Chairman of the Public Hearing
Panel.
First of all, the Convener welcome to all of present for the Public Hearing. He
told that, the Public Hearing is being conducted as per the provisions of EIA
Notification dtd. 14 th September 2006 and amended Notification dtd. 1 st December
2009 of Ministry of Environment and Forest, New Delhi. The project proponent after
receipt of terms of reference from MoEF, New Delhi for this project on 26 th August,
2009, has submitted their application dtd. 7 th August, 2010 to the Board requesting
for conducting the public hearing. Accordingly, the Board has issued public notice on
dtd. 14/08/2010 in Daily Lokmat (Marathi) and Daily Hitwada (English) and
Corrigendum in Daily Lokmat dated 17.08.2010, the date of public hearing was
scheduled on 17/7/2010. The copies of draft EIA and Executive Summaries in
English and Marathi were kept at the offices of District Collector, Wardha, District
Industries Centre, Wardha, Zilla Parishad, Wardha, M.P.C. Board (HQ), Mumbai,
Regional Office & Sub-Regional Office-II, M.P.C. Board, Nagpur, Environment
Department, Mantralaya, Mumbai, Regional Office, MoEF, Bhopal and Offices of the
concerned Grampanchayats namely Mandwa, Pulai & Belgaon. Also told that the
information about the project was placed on the Website of the M.P.C.Board. The
Member Secretary, M.P.C.Board,Mumbai has issued the panel order no. E-68 Of
2010, dated 27/8/2010 for the Public Hearing.
Convener of the Public Hearing further informed to the participants that, so far
152 nos. of written representations were received and the copies of the same are
made available to the project proponent. He further appealed to the participants that,
they can file their written objections/representations during Public Hearing and they
could raise their oral objections after the power point presentation that will be given
by the project proponent. He further clarified to the participants that the Public
Hearing panel is not here to accord Environmental Clearance to the project, but for
recording the objections / suggestions of the participants, which will be video
graphed and will be submitted to the MoEF, New Delhi for further necessary action.
The convener, with the permission of Chairperson, then requested the project
proponent to present their power point presentation One of the participant has
enquired that, Why District Collector is not present for Public Hearing? As such
important issue is going to be discussed here.
1

The Chairperson of the Public Hearing has clarified that, he has been
authorized by the District Collector, Wardha as Chairperson for this Public Hearing.
He further clarified that, this Public Hearing is meant for recording views of the
participants about the project.
Thereafter representative of the project proponent has started their power
point presentation and given the information about the project in local language,
Marathi.
He has given the information regarding the projects undertaken by the Lanco
group, silent features of this proposed 1320 MW(660X2) Coal based Thermal Power
Plant project at village Mandwa,Pulai & Belgaon in Taluka and district Wardha. He
told that, the Capital Investment of the project is Rs.6936 Corers. He has given
information about the location of the project. Coal consumption will be 7.5 Million
Ton/Annum and it will be brought from Coal Mines from Chhattisgarh & Coal linkage
allotment letter is procured. He further told that, the water required for the project will
be 3858 m3/hr. and it will be obtained from Lower Wardha Project. Project proponent
has entered into agreement with Vidarbha Irrigation Development Corporation in this
behalf. He has further given the information regarding requirement of 483.57
Hectares of land for the project, Terms of Reference obtained from MoEF, New
Delhi, Consultant nominated for preparing Environmental Impact Assessment
Report(EIA), Power Purchase agreement with MSEDCL, Details of EIA study as
given in the EIA Report which includes baseline Environmental status,
Environmental Monitoring Program, Anticipated Environmental Impacts and
Mitigation Measures, Environment Management Plan for Water, Air, Noise, Solid
Waste Management, Ash Handling Management & Green Belt development on 290
Acres of land etc., Technology of the Project, Risk Assessment and Disaster
Management Plan, Ecological Management, Cost provision (Rs.415 Crores) for
Environmental measures, Project benefits, Socio-Economic Impacts, Corporate
Social Responsibility Program etc. He told that the required Pollution Control
Measures are proposed for the project and hence there will not be adverse impact
on the Environment around the project site.
Chairperson of the Public Hearing has stated that, this Public Hearing is for
recording the views/objections/suggestions of the participants regarding the project.
The same will be communicated to the Government. He also clarified that this Panel
is not here to take decision for according any approval to the Project. He then
requested the participants to express their views.
Following participants have expressed their views about the project. The
details are as under:
1. Hon’ble Mr. Datta Meghe, Member of Parliament (Wardha Loksabha)
At the outset Mr. Datta Meghe expressed that he is not against the
project and never opposed to any industrial projects in Vidharbha region. He
said that the purpose of this Public Hearing is mainly to understand the project
2

with respect to pollution aspects. He expressed that company is promising
about 600 persons for likely employment in such large project, but they may
actually take only 50 persons from this area and others will be from other
state like Bihar,Uttar Pradesh etc. which may cause unhappiness among the
local peoples.
In this project, annually 75 lakh Ton of Coal will be used and about 40
lakhs Ton of ash will be generated in a year. Company has planned to
achieve 100% of ash utilization within 4 years from commissioning of the
project. What about the ash generated in first three years? What will happen
to the stored ash in the ash pond? Company has not made any agreement
with the Cement industries for lifting of the ash. He wanted to know about the
agreement signed with Cement industries. He said that Chandrapur in
Maharashtra State is ranked 4 th most polluted area in India. The ash emitted
out of the stack will spread in 25 km area and may pollute drinking Water and
agricultural fields and cause health problems like Cancer and TB. This project
may be the cause to disturb the ecological balance of the area.
As per the Government rules, no farmers should become landless after
acquisition of land. He said in this project, about 90% farmers would become
landless. It seems company has not done any provision for providing the
employment to these affected farmers or their next generation.
In this project, 4288 m 3 /hr water allocated by VIDC from Lower Wardha
Dam against the actual requirement of 2858 m 3 /hr. He wanted to know from
which quota the project has been allocated the Water, when only 10 million
m3 per annum of water is reserved for industrial use from Lower Wardha
Dam. The decision of allocation of Water for this project could adversely affect
the irrigation in this area. He also stated that, the temperature of this area is
already on higher side and by putting such Thermal Power projects, there will
be increased in the temperature of the area. He also lamented that why such
Thermal Power projects are proposed to setup in Vidarbha? Why not it is
established in other area like Chattisgarh, Andra Pradesh?. He further told
that, the funds of Rs. 50 Crores is reserved for plantation by the project
proponent, but details of tree plantation has been not given in the report. He
also told that, there is no details of distribution of Electricity. It is necessary to
have agreement in this behalf. As per the guidelines, the public hearing
should be conducted under the Chairmanship of District Collector or
Additional Collector only, which is not observed here. He further told that,
whatever commitments for control of pollution made by the project proponent
should be implemented effectively. He is in Politics and social work since last
35 years and observed that it is not happen, in general and hence opposing
the pollution that may cause due to the project. He further told that, the
3

farmers present here should know that, He came here for not to oppose the
project, but they should think about impact of the project. He has given written
representation also.
2 Prof. Mr. Bhasker Ithape, Social worker, Wardha
He said that, the poor people of this area have been deceived by the
company by acquiring the land at the rate of Rs. 2.0 Lakh per acre.
After this one of the participant objected the statement of Mr. Ithape
stating that this is the Public Hearing where the issues regarding Environment
should only be raised.
Some of the participants jointly told that this is also one of the issue
related to social environment and everyone has right to express their views.
3. Mr. Manoj Manwatkar & Milind Manwakar ,Pulai.
He raised objection by stating that the Grampanchayat has granted
NOC to the project without taking all villagers in the confidence.
On the statements of Mr. Ithape and Mr.Milind Manwatkar some of the
participants started shouting and resisted to make Political Statements which
are not related to Public Hearing. The Police Officer present has requested
the participants to maintain the discipline and peacefully express their views
one by one. Some of the statement made by the Police Officer which seems
to be in favour of the project, is objected by some of the participants and
started shouting. Chairman, Member & Convener of the Public Hearing
appealed to the Public to keep silence and to express their views peacefully
which would be recorded and submitted to the Central Government. On this
appeal, participants responded positively and come forward for expressing
their views.
4. Mr. Vivek Mathane,Environmentalist.
He told that, the participants of the Public Hearing listen the details
given by the project proponent through power point presentation. Now, the
other side of the project should also be hared peacefully by the Public, which
will described by the environmentalist and others.
4

5. Mr. Ramkrishn Bhalerao, Farmer, Pulai , Dist. Wardha.
He said that the information about the project was not made available
to him. My village is about ½ km from the project site in east direction. The
water flow is towards east direction. So the maximum effect of pollution will be
in his village. The villagers are deceived and this is problem of survival for all
the farmers in this village. Company has not given any assurance in this
regard. We are not opposing the project but we need written assurance from
the company in this regard.
It is to be noted that the Grampanchyat has issued the NOC without
taking the people of the village in to confidence. I oppose the Grampanchyat
for hiding the documents. If one person is benefited by this project does not
mean that the whole village is benefited.
6 Mr. Nitesh Kharabe, Mandwa, Dist. Wardha
He referred to Mr. Datta Meghe’s statement,that only thermal power
projects are coming in Vidharbha region and not other industries like
automobile and computers. He would like to ask Mr. Datta Meghe, what he
has done in last five tenures of his Member of Parliament (MP)? The leaders
of this area have not done anything good to us. If company is coming forward
to help us, why these leaders are opposing the project? We support the
project and request company officials to make the affidavit of our demands
and request to compensate the farmers whose lands are bought at lower rate
by giving average rate.
We peacefully came to attend the public hearing. However, some
people who were opposing the project started disturbing the proceedings of
the meeting by tearing off the attendance register and we only tried to stop
them from doing so.
7 Mr. Sunil Gafat, Mandwa, Dist. Wardha
He said that we have not come here only to support the project but to
understand the impact of this project on the environment and health of the
people. We, on behalf of three villages (Mandwa, Pulai and Belgaon village)
have prepared one agenda on our demands and will get them fulfilled by the
company. In this regard we will get the agreement from the company.
8 Mr. Pradeep Kale, Zillha Parishad Member, Watoda ,Dist. Wardha
He said, I am a resident of the Rehabilitated area of Lower Wardha
Dam project, which is a water source of the proposed power project. During
construction of the Dam, our lands were acquired at the rate of Rs. 18000/-
per acre and further revised to Rs. 50000/- per acre. However, today’s market
rate of that land is about Rs. 5.0 lakhs per acre. The dam is mainly meant for
5

agricultural purpose and was constructed by tax payer’s money. Now by
utilizing this water in the power plant and laying 30 km pipeline in our good
agricultural land, company will be making huge profits.
9 Mr. Vijay Muley, Ex Member of Parliament, Wardha.
He said, he is not opposing the project. However, the wrong
information is given in EIA report. It is wrongly stated that there are no
reserve forests in 10km area but according to him there are 15 places are
reserved for forest located within 10-km area. It is also stated in the report that
there are no historical monuments, but one Narsamai temple is located in the
10 km area which is visited by many pilgrims. The project will pollute these
forests and temple. The 100% of ash utilization is not possible. The company
has said that about 600 jobs will be created due to the project. But, in reality,
even 50 local peoples will not get the jobs and most of the people will come
from Bihar, West Bengal and Andhra Pradesh as locals are not adequately
qualified and do not have required expertise.
On this some of the villagers interrupted Mr.Muley and told that our
villages have no. of qualified persons who have an opportunity to get
employment in the project.
Representative of the Project Proponent told that, report says that
there are 13 Reserved Forest and Protected Forest in the study area.
However, there are no wildlife sanctuary, National Parks and monuments
notified by Archeological Department.
10 Mr. Nitin Sarate, Mandwa, Dist.Wardha.
He said the purpose of this public hearing should be understood and
allows to conduct smoothly. The views expressed in this meeting will be noted
and submitted to the Government. We are not politicians and this is not
political platform to raise political issues. Please stop taking up political issues
and request villagers to express their views. He also demanded that the
jurisdiction within which the proposed project is going to setup should be
given preference to express their views and not the politicians.
11 Mr. Vilas Parimal, Mandwa, Dist.Wardha.
He said he has visited Lanco power project in Korba to see the effect of
the Thermal Power Plant. In the presentation, I noticed some difference
between existing Lanco plant at Korba and proposed Power Plant in Mandwa.
In this proposed plant, details of ESP to control dust emission is not given,
which was seen in Korba plant. In Korba, HCSD system is used for disposal
6

of ash and there is no mention of the same in this proposed project. Kindly
clarify;
Representative of project proponent replied that, the ESP of 99.9 %
efficiency will installed in this proposed project also as done in Korba project.
12 Ms. Seema Sahoo, Nagpur.
She said she is not opposing the project. In the EIA report, it is wrongly
stated that, in study area there is no agricultural land and no hills. The
maximum temperature of the area is wrongly mentioned since the in summer
season the temperature is very high. The flora & fauna reported in EIA is 10
year old data and fresh study need to be conducted by Government agency. It
is mentioned that 600 people will get employment but it is not mentioned how
many local peoples will be given the employment. The land use given in the
report is 10 year old and shown the land as barren land. How much land will
be acquired for the pipeline corridor? It is stated that 1500 trees per ha,
plantation will be carried out, the location of the plantation is not shown. The
wild life conservation plan is not prepared.
Representative of project proponent replied that, the EIA report is
prepared based on one non-monsoon season from 1 st October to 31 st
December 2009 as per EIA guidelines. In the study area there are no hills but
some small hillocks are present. In the study area, the wildlife plan is not
prepared as there are no Schedule-I.
The Census report of 2001 is referred for the land use which is
authentic document. The greenbelt will be developed along the plant and ash
pond boundary and same is shown in the layout plan. The area earmarked for
the greenbelt is 290 acres. In addition, plantation will be done along the road
side and available vacant land in the villages.
Representative of project proponent also replied to the query regarding
employment. He told that the local population will be given the preference.
The suitable candidates in the surrounding villages will be trained in ITI for
skill development and employment will be provided in the project. The
technically qualified people who are working away from their native village
and want to come back will also be given the preference.
13 Mr. Sudhir Paliwal, Nagpur.
He said this is not the only power plant coming up in Vidharbha region,
other Thermal Power Plants are also proposed in this region. Presently, 3900
MW power is generated in Vidharbha and 2757 MW is transmitted out to
different states. The power demand of Vidharbha is 1200 MW and so there is
7

no need for the power plant in Vidharbha. There is no Coal but still the Power
Plants are proposed here because of availability of the water and land. The
Coal will be either brought from Chhattisgarh, Orrisa or from foreign countries.
In Vidharbha, we do not need big Power Plant. We need only small size
Power Plants which have lower pollution level. Recently Ms. Sonia Gandhi
has said that no agricultural land shall be used for industrial development.
He wanted to know from the project proponent that where this
electricity will be supplied? How the farmers will be compensated, whose land
will be used for power transmission line? How the farmers of this area will be
compensated in case of losses due to the thermal power plant? Where is
FORM-1? In this Form-1, company is required to give undertaking for the
compensation to the villagers for loss of their agricultural yield. The fly ash
utilization details are not given in the report. In Korba, all the ash ponds are
located on the banks of the river. During rainy season, the ash is allowed to
flow in the river to reduce the burden of ash in the ash pond. Further, the
Indian Coal is very dangerous since mercury and radioactive substances are
present. The disaster management plan does not mention what will happen if
ESP fails. The incremental concentrations of pollutants are compared with
limits applicable for residential zone and not with the sensitive zone.
The desulphurization plant is not proposed in the project to bring down
the gaseous emissions. He talks about acid rains due to SO2 emission, global
warming, climate change due to CO2 emission cause due to Thermal Power
Plants.
The maximum water used in power plant is lost in evaporation. The
Vidhrabha is more concerned about availability of water. In this regard air
cooled system should be used so that significant quantity of water can be
conserved.
Representative of project proponent told that Power Purchase
Agreement (PPA) is signed with MSDCL for the supply of 680 MW of power
for 25 years. The PPA for the balance power will be signed in future.
Another Representative of project proponent has told that the FORM-1
was submitted to MoEF to obtain approved TOR. Based on the TOR the EIA
report is prepared.
He further told that during failure of ESP, the boilers will shut down
automatically and there will be no discharge of dust. If this is not adhered to,
MoEF, CPCB & MPCB have authority to initiate action against the defaulting
industries.
8

Similarly, He clarified that in the layout plan as per guidelines, space is
provided for installation of Desulphurization plant. In future, if situation
warrants, it will be installed.
Representative of project proponent told that as mentioned by Shri.
Paliwal about small size power plants, the Super Critical Boilers are not
available in smaller capacity. In the proposed project Super critical Boilers will
be installed, which has better efficiency and lower emissions. The ESP are
designed to meet the particulate matter emission below 50 mg/Nm 3 .
14 Mr. Sarang Khedakar, Mechanical Engineer, Mandwa, Dist.Wardha.
He said that the information given in the presentation is OK. If some of
the previous speakers are really concerned about environment, why they
have not approached the villagers and explained about pollution well in
advance?
He further said that if Company is supporting the capable students in
education, we will support the project. To make common villagers to
understand the information exchanged during this presentation, we request
project proponent to kindly arrange a meeting in our villages and explain
merits and demerits of the project. The greenbelt development can be
undertaken immediately in the earmarked area and in the vacant land
available in villages. We have already given our representations in writing to
MPCB. He also told that ,the local people should get preference in the
employment irrespective of any recommendation from Politicians.
Representative of project proponent told that, if any engineer of your
village working out side the village and wants to return back, he will be given
the preference in the employment. We will sponsor the scholarship to the
eligible students. The greenbelt will be developed and if required we will also
plant the trees along the roads and vacant land in the villages.
15 Mr. Ganesh Gayaki, Ex. Sarpanch, Pulai, Dist.Wardha.
He said that his agricultural land is near the plant boundary. In case his
land loses fertility in future due to the pollution from the project, what will
happen and how it will be compensated.
Representative of project proponent told that the land will not undergo
any change in fertility due to the project, if any noticed, will be corrected and
solved.
Chairman of the public hearing has told to the participants that the
issues raised by the participants are noted and will be incorporated in the
minutes and will be forwarded to the concerned for further necessary action
and declared that the Public Hearing is concluded.
9

The representations/objections received before and during the public hearing
are 193 in Nos. Which are as under;
Sr.
No.
Views/ Objections / Representation submitted by
Date
1. Shri Chandrashekar Dadaji Bhende,Wardha 04/09/2010
2. Shri Sureshrao Gaiki, Shri Manoj Manvatkar& Shri Vijubhau Mule,Pulai 07/09/2010
3. Shri Manish Rathi, Wardha 08/09/2010
4. Shri Ramkrishna Palasram Bhalerao,
At-Pulai, Post-Pewnur, Tq. & Dist. Wardha.
16/09/2010
5. Shri Ramkrishnaji Abhimanji Bhalerao, At.Pulai, Tq. & Dist.
Wardha
16/09/2010
6. Shri Vanitabai Palasram Bhalerao & other
At.Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha
16/09/2010
7. Shri Ajay Panjabrao Deshmukh & other
At-Pulai, Post-Pewnur, Tq. & Dist. Wardha.
16/09/2010
8. Shri Milind Laxmanrao Manwatkar, At-Pulai, Tq. & Dist.
Wardha
16/09/2010
9. Shri Laxman Pandurangji Manwatkar,
At-Pulai, Mouza-Mandwa, Tq. & Dist. Wardha.
16/09/2010
10. Shri Manoj Laxmanrao Manwatkar, At-Pulai, Tq. & Dist.
Wardha
16/09/2010
11. Shri Vijay Uttamrao Mule, At-Pulai, Post-Pawnur, Tq. & Dist.
Wardha
16/09/2010
12. Shri Vittalrao Abhimanji Lonkar, At-Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha. 16/09/2010
13. Shri Praveen Ashokrao Deshmukh
At.Pulai, Post.Anji(Mothi), Tq. & Dist. Wardha.
16/09/2010
14. Shri Manish Madhukarrao Kende, At. Pulai, Tq. & Dist.
Wardha
16/09/2010
15. Shri Goutam Laxman Khobragade, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
16. Shri Madhukar Balkrishnarao Kende, At. Pulai, Tq. &
Dist.Wardha.
16/09/2010
17. Shri Niwrutti Lahanuji Wagh, At.Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
18. Shri Palasram Vithobaji Khobragade, At.Pulai, Tq. & Dist.
Wardha
16/09/2010
19. Shri Umesh Manikrao Hadke, At.Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
20. Shri Uttamrao Mahadeo Mule, At.Pulai, Tq. &Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
21. Shri Vishwas Namdeorao Kanzode,
At.Pulai, Post-Pawnur, Tq. & Dist. Wardha
16/09/2010
22. Shri Khushal Keshaorao Gaynar, At. Pulai, Tq. &
Dist.Wardha
16/09/2010
10

23. Shri Arunrao Narayanrao Patarkar, At.Pulai, Tq.&
Dist.Wardha
16/09/2010
24. Sau.Alkatai Padmakarrao Deshmukh, At.Pulai, Tq. & Dist.
Wardha
16/09/2010
25. Shri Padmakarrao Vinayakrao Deshmukh,
At.Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha
16/09/2010
26. Shri Padmakarrao Vinayakrao Deshmukh,
At.Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha
16/09/2010
27. Shri Vittalrao Domaji Ghode & Tukaram Domaji Ghode,
At.Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha
16/09/2010
28. Shri Sureshrao Panjabrao Shinde, Wardha 16/09/2010
29. Shri Sureshram Tukaramji Gayki,
At.Pulai, Post-Pawnur, Tq. & Dist. Wardha
16/09/2010
30. Smt. Kaushalyabai Vinayakrao Gayki, Pulai, Tq. &
Dist.Wardha
16/09/2010
31. Smt. Sumanbai Sureshrao Gayki, At.Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
32. Shri Dilip Sheshrao Chaphale, At.Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
33. Smt. Rukhamabai Namdeorao Kanzode,
At.Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha
16/09/2010
34. Shri Pralhad Bhaduji Ramteke, At.Pulai, Tq. & Dist.Wardha 16/09/2010
35. Shri Udhhav Suryabhan Dhoke, At.Pulai, Tq. & Dist.Wardha 16/09/2010
36. Smt.Arunabai Ashokrao Deshmukh, At.Pulai, Post-Anji(Mothi),
Tq. & Dist. Wardha
16/09/2010
37. Shri Amrutrao Ramchandra Gayki,
At.Pulai, Post-Pawnur, Tq. &Dist. Wardha
16/09/2010
38. Shri Prakashrao Mahadeorao Gayki,
At.Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha
16/09/2010
39. Shri Tryambakrao Mahadeorao Gayki,
Mouza-Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha
16/09/2010
40. Shri Dhyanobaji Chaituji Dhoke, At.Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
41. Shri Amol Wamanrao Manjare, At.Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
42. Shri Rambhauji Panduranji Tiwgase, At.Pulai, Dist.Wardha 16/09/2010
43. Shri Kishanraoji Dinbaji Khobragade, At.Pulai, Dist.Wardha 16/09/2010
44. Shri Rupchand Wasudeo Dhoke, At.Pulai, Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
45 Smt. Devakabai W. Dhoke,Pulai 16/09/2010
46. Shri Dharmendra M. Sukhdeve, At.Pulai, Dist.Wardha 16/09/2010
47. Shri Vijay Mangal Sukhdeve, At.Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
48. Shri Tukaram Ambadasji Manwatkar, At.Pulai, Dist.Wardha 16/09/2010
49. Shri Punbaji Pandurangji Manwatkar, At.Pulai, Dist.Wardha 16/09/2010
50. Shri Mangal Zibal Sukhdeve, At. Pulai, Tq. & Dist.Wardha 16/09/2010
51 Shri Ashokrao Rambhauji Tiwgase, At.Pulai, Tq. &
Dist.Wardha
16/09/2010
52 Shri Nitin Sureshrao Gayki, At.Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
53 Smt. Manda Pandharinath Wagh, At.Pulai, Tq. & Dist.Wardha 16/09/2010
54 Shri Bhauraoji Gulabrao Newalkar, At.Pulai, Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
55 Mrs. Suhasini Mahadeorao Jamane, Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
56 Shri Shamrao Shravan Khobragde, Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
57 Shri Indrajit Mahadeorao Jamane, Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
11

58 Shri. Raju Sheshraoji Chaple, Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
59 Shri. Ramdas Baliram Chaphle, Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
60 Shri. Maroti Tulshiram Meshram, Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
61 M/s.Laxmi Devsthan, Sonegaon 16/09/2010
62 Mrs. Rukhmabai Vishanath Meshram, Pulai, Tq. & Dist.
Wardha
16/09/2010
63 Shri. Satishrao Govindrao Deshmukh, Pulai, Tq. & Dist.
Wardha
16/09/2010
64 Shri. Prabhakar Pandurangji Shinde, Pulai, Post. Pavnur, Tq.
& Dist. Wardha
16/09/2010
65 Shri. Raju Dattuji Surpan, Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
66 Mrs. Chandrakla Bhagwan Nannaware, Pulai, Tq.& Dist.
Wardha
16/09/2010
67 Shri. Shankar Bapurao Kasar, Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
68 Shri. Vitthal Saranram Patil, Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
69 Shri. Sambhaji Devaji Nikose, Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
70 Mrs. Shobha Maroti Dhole, Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
71 Shri. Devidas Atmaram Tirpude , Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
72 Mrs. Vanita Vasantrao Dhoke, Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
73 Shri. Ashok Narayanrao Thakre, Pulai, Post. Pavnur Tq. &
Dist. Wardha
16/09/2010
74 Shri. Ankush Sonbaji Lintpane, Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
75 Shri. Sonbaji Namdeo Lintpane , Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
76 Shri. Chandrashekhar Sonbaji Lintpane, Pulai, Tq. & Dist.
Wardha
16/09/2010
77 Shri Raju Haridas Meshram, Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
78 Shri. Haridas Tulshiram Meshram, Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
79 Shri. Baliram Sonbaji Bhimte, Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
80 Shri. Ajay Baliramji Bhimte, Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
81 Shri. Sunindra Baliramji Bhimte, Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
82 Shri. Chandrabhan Damaji Bhimte, Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
83 Shri. Akash Chandrabhan Patil, Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
84 Mrs. Nandabai Babarao Bhimte, Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
85 Shri. Sunil Pndurang Shendre, Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
86 Shri. Ananda Ramaji Sarode, Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
87 Shri. Ankush Walmikrao Bhondve , Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
88 Shri. Pramod Laxanrao Bhondve , Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
89 Shri. Gajanan Walmikrao Bhondve , Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
90 Shri. Kisna Shankarrao Bawne , Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
12

91 Shri. Arun Vithobaji Shendre, Pulai, Post. Pavnur Tq. & Dist.
Wardha
16/09/2010
92 Shri. Subhash Panjabrao Shinde , Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
93 Shri. Sunil Pandurangji Shendre , Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
94 Shri. Anil Pandurangji Shendre, Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
95 Shri. Roshan Rupchand Dhoke, Pulai, Post. Pavnur Tq. &
Dist. Wardha
16/09/2010
96 Shri. Sharad Namdeoraoji Raut, Pulai, Post. Aanji(mothi) Tq.
& Dist. Wardha
16/09/2010
97 Shri. Amrutrao Ramchandraji Gayki, Pulai, Post. Pavnur Tq. &
Dist. Wardha
16/09/2010
98 Shri. Pramodrao Atmaramji Tirpude , Pulai, Tq. & Dist.
Wardha
16/09/2010
99 Shri. Ambadasji Kavduji Manvatkar, Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
100 Shri. Lhanuji Nandaji Dange, Pulai, Post. Pavnur Tq. & Dist.
Wardha
16/09/2010
101 Shri. Haridas Su. Dhole, Pulai,Post. Pavnur Tq. & Dist.
Wardha
16/09/2010
102 Shri. Ambadasji Kisanji Khobragde , Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
103 Mrs. Sulochana Tukaram Ramteke , Pulai, Pavnur Tq. & Dist.
Wardha
104 Mr. Meghnath Tukaram Ramteke , Pulai, Pavnur Tq. & Dist.
Wardha
105 Mr. Sunil Madhukarrao Deshmukh , Post. Mandwa, Tq. &
Dist. Wardha
106 Shri. Arvind Krishnarao Gotekar, Gaurakshan Ward, Dist.
Wardha
107 Shri. Keshavrao Vitthalrao Kute, Post. Mandwa, Tq. & Dist.
Wardha
108 Shri. Nagoraoji Sheshraoji Patil, Post. Mandwa, Tq. & Dist.
Wardha
109 Shri. Pradip Vikramji Ramteke, Post. Mandwa, Tq. & Dist.
Wardha
110 Shri. Namdeo Kashinathji Shende, Post Umri(Meghe), Tq. &
Dist. Wardha
111 Shri. Vitthalrao Kashinathji Shende, Post Umri(Meghe), Tq.
& Dist. Wardha
112 Shri. Pandurang Laxmanrao Devdhagle, Post Umri(Meghe),
Tq. & Dist. Wardha
113 Shri. Yogesh Prabhakarrao Vaidya, Post Mandwa, Tq. & Dist.
Wardha
114 Shri. Dilip Vishvasrao Wagh, Post Mandwa, Tq. & Dist.
Wardha
115 Shri. Vinod Prabhakarrao Sabnis, Post. Belgaon,Tq. & Dist.
Wardha
116 Shri. Baba Urpha Wamanrao Naik, Post. Belgaon,Tq. & Dist.
Wardha
16/09/2010
16/09/2010
16/09/2010
16/09/2010
16/09/2010
16/09/2010
16/09/2010
16/09/2010
16/09/2010
16/09/2010
16/09/2010
16/09/2010
16/09/2010
16/09/2010
13

117 Shri Sanjay Mahadeo Chapde, Mouza. Ganeshpur, Tq. &
Dist. Wardha
16/09/2010
118 Shri Moreshwar Balaji Shelake,Gaeshpur, Tq.Dist.Wardha 16/09/2010
119 Shri. Motiram Mahakalkar, Mouza. Ganeshpur, Tq. & Dist.
Wardha
16/09/2010
120 Smt. Anjani Kawadu Shelke, Mouza. Ganeshpur, Tq. & Dist.
Wardha
16/09/2010
121 Shri Namdeorao Chandrabhan Shelke, Mouza. Ganeshpur,
Tq. & Dist. Wardha
16/09/2010
122 Shri Dinesh Namdeorao Shelke, Mouza. Ganeshpur, Tq. &
Dist. Wardha
16/09/2010
123 Shri Prakash Ramaji Pimple, Mouza. Ganeshpur, Tq. & Dist.
Wardha
16/09/2010
124 Shri Padmakar Bhaurao Pimple, Mouza. Ganeshpur, Tq. &
Dist. Wardha
16/09/2010
125 Shri. Dinesh Karemore, Mouza. Ganeshpur, Tq. & Dist.
Wardha
16/09/2010
126 Shri Indira Subhash Chakole, Mouza. Ganeshpur, Tq. & Dist.
Wardha
16/09/2010
127 Shri Suresh Ganpatrao Shinde, Mouza. Ganeshpur, Tq. &
Dist. Wardha
16/09/2010
128 Shri Diwakar Warluji Khadatkar, Mouza. Digras, Tq. & Dist.
Wardha
16/09/2010
129 Shri Vilas Namdeorao Shelke, Mouza. Digras, Tq. & Dist.
Wardha
16/09/2010
130 Mrs. Kiran Vilas Shelke, Mouza. Digras, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
131 Shri. Canduji Kubde, Mouza. Digras, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
132 Shri Surendra Ramchandra Mahakalkar Mauza. Borgaon, Tq.
& Dist. Wardha
16/09/2010
133 Shri Vasant Shamrao Vairagde, Mouza. Digras, Tq. & Dist.
Wardha
16/09/2010
134 Shri Gajanan Haribhau Dhabale, Mouza. Zadgaon, Tq. & Dist.
Wardha
16/09/2010
135 Shri Pramod Rambhauji Avachat , Mouza. Zadgaon, Tq. &
Dist. Wardha
16/09/2010
136 Shri Pramod Shriramji Kute, Mouza. Mandwa, Tq. & Dist.
Wardha
16/09/2010
137 Mrs. Ratnmala Raju Ramteke, Mouza. Mandwa, Tq. & Dist.
Wardha
16/09/2010
138 Shri. Dinkar G. Khairkar, Mouza. Mandwa, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
139 Shri. Prafull Keshaorao Kute, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 16/09/2010
140 Smt. Ujwala Ankush Choudhari, Mouza. Mandwa, Tq. & Dist.
Wardha
16/09/2010
141 Shri. Sandeep S. Deshmukh , Mouza. Ganeshpur, Tq. & Dist.
Wardha
16/09/2010
142 Mr.Ritesh P. Kothari, Wardha 16/09/2010
14

143 Grampanchayat, Sukali(Bai) 15/09/2010
144 Grampanchayat, Ganeshpur 15/09/2010
145 Grampanchayat, Zadgaon(Go) 16/09/2010
146 Grampanchayat, Umari(Meghe) 16/09/2010
147 Ravikant Balpande,Shiv Sena Zilla Pramukh,Wardha 16/09/2010
148 Hon’ble Shri. Datta Meghe, MP (Wardha), 135, Pande Layout
Khamla, Nagpur
17/09/2010
149 Shri. Sarang Babarao Khedkar, At-Mandwa, Tq. & Dist.
Wardha
17/09/2010
150 Shri. Jitendra Balerao Gorde, Mhada Colony, Sindhi (Rly.),
Wardha
17/09/2010
151 Shri. Gajanan Haribhau Dhabale, At-Post-Zadgaon,
Tq.&Dist.Wardha
17/09/2010
152 Shri.Kamal G. Kuldhariya, District President, BJP, Wardha,
Hawaldarpura, Ward No. 13, Wardha
17/09/2010
153 Grampanchayat Office, Umari (Meghe), Tq. & Dist.Wardha 17/09/2010
154 Nisarg Sewa Samiti, Gopuri, Priyadarshani College Road,
Wardha
17/09/2010
155 Ganeshpur Villagers, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 17/09/2010
156 Vidarbha Bachav Samiti, Wardha 17/09/2010
157 Shri. Sunil Taknathaji Jawade, At.Digras, Tq. & Dist.Wardha 17/09/2010
158 Human Right Protection Forum, Wardha 17/09/2010
159 Shri. Ravikant Balpande & others, Raje Chhatrapati Chowk,
Bachelor Road, Pratapnagar, Wardha
17/09/2010
160 Grampanchayat Office & Villagers, Mandwa, Tq. & Dist.
Wardha
17/09/2010
161 Shri. Dilip Vikramji Ramteke & Others, At.Mandwa, Tq. &
Dist.Wardha
17/09/2010
162 Grampanchayat Office, Amala, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 17/09/2010
163 Grampanchayat Office, Dahegaon, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 17/09/2010
164 Shri.Pradeep Kale, ZP Member, Wardha 17/09/2010
165 Grampanchayat Office, Lonsawli, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 17/09/2010
166 M/s.Sharda Mahila Bachat Gat, Shekapur, Tq. & Dist.Wardha 17/09/2010
167 Shri. Ravindra Deshmukh & other villagees, Dist.Wardha 17/09/2010
168 Lanco Power Virodhi Kriti Samiti, Wardha 17/09/2010
169 Shri. Madhav Kotasthane, BJP, Pratapnagar, Wardha 17/09/2010
170 Shri. Vilas N. Shelke & others, Wardha 17/09/2010
171 Grampanchayat Office, Thembri, Parsodi, Pachod,
Tq.&Dist.Wardha
17/09/2010
15

172 Shri. Anant Solanke, Kharangna & others, Wardha 17/09/2010
173 Shri. Ajay Vijayrao Jagtap, At.Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 17/09/2010
174 Shri. Wasudeo Bapuraoji Sarode, Wardha 17/09/2010
175 Shri. Kisna P. Chachane, Wardha 17/09/2010
176 Shri. Bhauraoji Yashwant Kangale, At.Pulai, Tq. &
Dist.Wardha
17/09/2010
177 Shri. Namdeo Bapuraoji Sarode, Wardha 17/09/2010
178 Sau. Kirantai Vijay Jagtap , Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 17/09/2010
179 Shri. Vijayrao Girdharrao Jagtap , Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 17/09/2010
180 Mrs. Sarubai Govindrao Dhoke , Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 17/09/2010
181 Mrs. Sarja Sonbaji Pusam , Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 17/09/2010
182 Joint representation from Villagers of Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 17/09/2010
183 Mrs . Vibha Gupta,President, Magan Sangrahalya Samiti,
Wardha.
17/09/2010
184 Shektriya Sanyojak, Rashtriy karagir Panchayat, Wardha 17/09/2010
185 Mrs Shashikla Bagde, Gramin Mahila Swaymsahayta Samuh,
Selu, Dist. Wardha.
186 Shri. Ghanshyam Chopde, Ziro Bajat Naisrgik Kheti Abhiyan,
Mandwa, Tq. & Dist. Wardha
187 Shri. Ashish M. Ambatkar, Taluka Upadhyaksha MNS, Post.
Aanji(mothi) ,Tq. & Dist. Wardha
188 Nimn Wardha Prakalpgrast Sangharsh Samiti, Salod, Tq. &
Dist. Wardha
189 Mrs. Chandrakla Hiwarkar, Sarpancha, Grampanchayat,
Tigaon. Dist. Wardha.
190 Shri. R.B. Goenka, Vidarbha Paryavaran Kruti Samiti, Dist.
Wardha.
191 Shri Prashant Nagose & others, Paryavaran Raksha Samiti,
Dist. Wardha.
17/09/2010
17/09/2010
17/09/2010
17/09/2010
17/09/2010
17/09/2010
17/09/2010
16

192 Secretary, Human Right Protection Forum,Wardha, Dist.
Wardha.
17/09/2010
193 Shri. Bhimrao Damdaji Wagh , Pulai, Tq. & Dist. Wardha 17/09/2010
Comments , if any, on this proceeding may be sent directly to the Ministry of
Environment and Forest, New Delhi, the regulatory authority and the project
Proponent.
(N.G.Nihul)
Convener &
Sub-Regional Officer-II,
MPCB, Nagpur
(A.T. Fulmali)
Member &
Regional Officer,
MPCB, Nagpur.
(Avinash Katade)
Chairman &
Sub-Divisional Officer,
Wardha
17