23.07.2013 Views

→ GSTP ANNUAL REPORT 2011 - ESA

→ GSTP ANNUAL REPORT 2011 - ESA

→ GSTP ANNUAL REPORT 2011 - ESA

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

<strong>→</strong> <strong>GSTP</strong> <strong>ANNUAL</strong> <strong>REPORT</strong> <strong>2011</strong>


GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS<br />

F EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY<br />

ROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY<br />

OSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING<br />

CTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION<br />

NHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> &<br />

ATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN<br />

ECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES<br />

UPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON<br />

EPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE<br />

OMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL<br />

UPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF<br />

UROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY<br />

ROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY<br />

OSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING<br />

CTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION<br />

NHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> &<br />

ATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN<br />

ECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES<br />

UPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON<br />

EPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE<br />

OMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL<br />

UPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF<br />

UROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY<br />

ROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY<br />

OSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING<br />

CTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION<br />

NHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> &<br />

ATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN<br />

ECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES<br />

UPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON<br />

EPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE<br />

OMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE<br />

ENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE<br />

OMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE<br />

ENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS<br />

F EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY<br />

ROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY<br />

OSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING<br />

CTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION<br />

NHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> &<br />

ATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN<br />

ECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES<br />

UPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON<br />

EPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE<br />

OMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL<br />

UPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF<br />

UROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY<br />

ROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY<br />

OSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING<br />

CTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION<br />

NHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> &<br />

ATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN<br />

ECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES<br />

UPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON<br />

EPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE<br />

OMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL<br />

UPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF<br />

UROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY<br />

ROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY<br />

OSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING<br />

CTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION<br />

NHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> &<br />

ATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN<br />

ECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES<br />

UPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON<br />

EPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE<br />

OMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL<br />

UPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF<br />

UROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY<br />

ROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY<br />

OSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING<br />

CTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION<br />

NHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> &<br />

ATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN<br />

ECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES<br />

UPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN NON-DEPENDENCE


• The best way to predict the future is The best way to predict the future is to invent it<br />

The best way to predict the future is to invent it to invent it<br />

“Man must rise above the Earth—to the top of the clouds and<br />

beyond—for only thus will he fully understand the world in<br />

which he lives”<br />

Socrates 469 BC - 399 BC<br />

<strong>→</strong> <strong>GSTP</strong><br />

AnnuAl rePorT<br />

<strong>2011</strong>


2 | <strong>GSTP</strong> Annual Report <strong>2011</strong>


A <strong>GSTP</strong> Production<br />

A. Tobías<br />

U. Becker<br />

J. Amador Monteverde<br />

E. Adamou<br />

<strong>GSTP</strong> Planning and Implementation Section<br />

<strong>GSTP</strong> and Product Development Division<br />

Systems, Software and Technology Department<br />

Directorate of Technical and Quality Management<br />

<strong>ESA</strong> - ESTEC<br />

Keplerlaan 1 - P.O. Box 299<br />

2200 AG Noordwijk<br />

The Netherlands<br />

Contents<br />

<strong>→</strong> Year in review ............................................................................................................. 4<br />

<strong>→</strong> Summary of Achievements & Challenges<br />

<strong>GSTP</strong> activities closed in <strong>2011</strong> ............................................................................................................... 8<br />

<strong>GSTP</strong> activities initiated in <strong>2011</strong>............................................................................................................ 10<br />

<strong>GSTP</strong> market-oriented activities: A.O. closed and initiated in <strong>2011</strong> ........................................ 12<br />

Performance enhancements for trace gas monitoring (ANITA II) ........................................... 14<br />

Development of core technological elements in preparation for future Optical<br />

Atomic Frequency Standards (OAFS) and clocks (OAC’s) in space ........................................... 15<br />

Nodding Mechanism on the ISS .......................................................................................................... 16<br />

<strong>→</strong> Annexes<br />

Annex 1: List of <strong>GSTP</strong> Documents to the Industrial Policy Committee (IPC) ..................... 20<br />

Annex 2: <strong>2011</strong> <strong>GSTP</strong> Budget Distribution by Themes ................................................................... 21<br />

Annex 3: Complete list of <strong>GSTP</strong> activities initiated in <strong>2011</strong> ....................................................... 22<br />

Annex 4: Complete list of <strong>GSTP</strong> activities closed in <strong>2011</strong> .......................................................... 25<br />

<strong>GSTP</strong> Annual Report <strong>2011</strong> | 3


4 | <strong>GSTP</strong> Annual Report <strong>2011</strong><br />

<strong>→</strong> YeAr in review<br />

From invention to innovation<br />

Often used interchangeably, invention and innovation are not the same. While an invention<br />

is a new and promising idea, innovation is a mature idea whose early promise has been<br />

fulfilled – found valuable and put to work.<br />

<strong>ESA</strong>’s challenge is to turn inventions into innovations, and do it in a systematic way. To<br />

successfully accomplish this, <strong>ESA</strong> relies on its tools, the Technology Programmes, which serve<br />

both to help define <strong>ESA</strong>´s future technology needs and eventually fulfil them.<br />

The <strong>ESA</strong>’s General Support Technology Programme (<strong>GSTP</strong>) relies on technological innovation<br />

to accomplish <strong>ESA</strong>´s main goals: enabling novel space missions and applications of the<br />

future, boosting Europe’s industrial competitiveness, fostering innovation, and increasing<br />

and preserving our non-dependence in space technology.<br />

The <strong>GSTP</strong> converts promising engineering concepts into a broad spectrum of mature<br />

products – everything from individual components, to subsystems, up to complete satellites<br />

– right up to the brink of spaceflight or beyond.<br />

Its objective is to bridge the gap between having a technology proven in fundamental terms<br />

and making it ready for <strong>ESA</strong> and National Programmes, the open market and, eventually,<br />

space itself. The <strong>GSTP</strong> allows such transitions by developing technology concepts into<br />

engineering models or ‘breadboards’, which involves testing their performances in all<br />

conceivable scenarios.<br />

The <strong>GSTP</strong> Programme, as its name suggests, supports general technology, covering all <strong>ESA</strong><br />

Themes 1 except for Telecommunications, which has its own ARTES Programme.<br />

The <strong>GSTP</strong> is an optional programme, open for <strong>ESA</strong> Member States (including Canada as an<br />

Associate Member State) which choose whether to participate or not, and up to which level.<br />

1<br />

Earth Observation, Space Science, Robotic Exploration, Human Spaceflight, Space<br />

Transportation, Navigation, Security and Generic Technologies and Techniques


The past year <strong>2011</strong> has seen a continuation of the <strong>GSTP</strong><br />

efforts to achieve the previously described objectives.<br />

This <strong>GSTP</strong> Annual Report <strong>2011</strong> presents a brief description<br />

of this work, together with some examples of the<br />

corresponding achievements.<br />

These efforts and achievements are illustrated<br />

throughout this report under the form of successful<br />

technology developments, as well as innovative projects<br />

progressing under the Programme’s support.<br />

In particular, a set of general technology activities closed<br />

and initiated during the year <strong>2011</strong> are presented showing<br />

the progress in some areas like fuel cells, the<br />

development of new devices in support to astronauts<br />

and the support of the <strong>GSTP</strong> to Earth Observation data<br />

management.<br />

Furthermore, within the frame of the <strong>GSTP</strong> Programme,<br />

the objective of the permanently open Announcement of<br />

Opportunity (AO) for market-oriented activities is to<br />

support the competitiveness of European industries,<br />

enhancing their position to face the worldwide space<br />

market in the near term.<br />

Nine AO activities were initiated and seven were closed<br />

in <strong>2011</strong>, including pixel detectors, the use of GNSS-R<br />

signals for Earth Observation, and augmented reality for<br />

astronaut operations, among others.<br />

The <strong>GSTP</strong> In-Orbit Demonstration facilitates to fly either<br />

dedicated demonstration satellites –Such as the PROBA<br />

or EXPERT re-entry vehicle, or non-mission critical guest<br />

payloads in flight opportunities. Additionally, it is worth<br />

mentioning the Nodding Mechanism, which was<br />

developed and launched in <strong>2011</strong> as part of the Space<br />

Station Precursor Technology Initiative. The Nodding<br />

Mechanism allows astronauts to take exceptionally<br />

sharp pictures of the Earth at night from the ISS Cupola.<br />

The development of the Space-Based Automatic<br />

Dependent Surveillance Broadcast (ADS-B) payload was<br />

also initiated in <strong>2011</strong> and will allow to vastly expand the<br />

scope and improve service efficiency of the current<br />

ground-based air traffic surveillance ADS-B systems.<br />

Promoting the Programme is a task to accomplish<br />

and a key to succeed on finding new opportunities for<br />

Europe. The Technology Events, coordinated by <strong>GSTP</strong>,<br />

are regularly held in participating States as one of the<br />

Programme tools to strengthen relations with<br />

Industry and make it aware of the current <strong>ESA</strong><br />

opportunities on technology.<br />

Particularly three Technology Events took place in<br />

<strong>2011</strong>: one in Norway in March, one in Sweden in April,<br />

and one in Finland in November. <strong>ESA</strong>’s participation<br />

included representatives of TRP, CTP, <strong>GSTP</strong> and ECI.<br />

These events were organized by the corresponded<br />

National Delegations, and included both<br />

presentations and face-to-face meetings.<br />

Overall, the <strong>GSTP</strong> efforts in supporting technology in<br />

<strong>2011</strong> were remarkable, representing 81 new activities<br />

(worth around 57 M€), 57 activities closed (worth<br />

around 28 M€), and around 260 other activities<br />

running during the year (worth ~208 M€). All the<br />

activities were to develop breakthrough technology<br />

and to support innovative projects and in-orbit<br />

demonstrators like ADS-B, and other underdevelopment<br />

missions like PROBA 3 and PROBA V.<br />

All this has been achieved with the participation of 18<br />

<strong>ESA</strong> Member States, Canada as Associate Member<br />

State and an annual budget of ~80 M€.<br />

<strong>GSTP</strong> Annual Report <strong>2011</strong> | 5


6 | <strong>GSTP</strong> Annual Report <strong>2011</strong>


<strong>→</strong> SummArY<br />

of AChievemenTS<br />

& ChAllenGeS<br />

<strong>GSTP</strong> Annual Report <strong>2011</strong> | 7


<strong>→</strong> <strong>GSTP</strong> ACTiviTieS CloSeD in <strong>2011</strong><br />

In <strong>2011</strong>, 57 activities were completed, achieving the technology developments<br />

originally targeted. Some examples of the last achievements are presented hereafter.<br />

With the participation of Norway and Greece 2008 - <strong>2011</strong><br />

> Solid Oxide Fuel Cell (SOFC) Stack<br />

> FCV Engineering Model undergoing vibration testing<br />

> Picture of the cathode of a typical cell in the active part of<br />

the stack<br />

With the participation of Denmark 2008-<strong>2011</strong><br />

> 10 W and 50 W planar transformers mounted on the test rig.<br />

8 | <strong>GSTP</strong> Annual Report <strong>2011</strong><br />

high Temperature fuel Cells<br />

The reversible fuel cell system shows great potential for replacing batteries in<br />

some space related energy storage systems like exploration missions. For<br />

application on Mars, the reversible Solid Oxide Fuel Cell (SOFC) with carbon<br />

monoxide (CO), CO and oxygen (O ), as the energy carrying elements, is one of the<br />

2 2<br />

most promising technologies. CO is easily available on the planet as a component<br />

2<br />

in the atmosphere and can be easily split into the required reactants CO and O by 2<br />

means of solid oxide electrolysis in the SOFC.<br />

The objective of this activity was to manufacture a Breadboard Demonstrator of a<br />

High Temperature Solid Oxide Fuel Cell (SOFC) after modification of terrestrial fuel<br />

cell units, to solve the construction material incompatibility with reactants like<br />

pure carbon monoxide (CO).<br />

During this activity continuous operation on CO for 1000 hours without significant<br />

degradation and no change in the stack performance was achieved, and the<br />

highest power obtained was 182 W on 35 cells. High operation temperature (><br />

900oC) was required to avoid deposition of carbon, to get high power density and<br />

better tolerance for H S poisoning. For this high operation temperature, ceramic<br />

2<br />

interconnects were used. Traditional Sr or Ca doped lanthanum chromite with up<br />

to 20 % doping could operate with up to 90 % CO as long as the production<br />

quality was maintained. Finally, traditional Ni/ Yttrium Stabilized Zirconia (YSZ)<br />

were used as anode materials. The new ceramic anode materials required<br />

improved current collection before they could be used in an application.<br />

Even if the activity’s focus was on applications for Mars, such system may be very<br />

relevant for buffering of renewable energy here on earth, by using biofuel as<br />

reactant in combination with air as oxidant. As a result of this activity, the high<br />

temperature SOFC technology is ready to be tested in a reversible closed loop<br />

system including both fuel cell mode and electrolysis.<br />

Study, Development and verification of a Planar<br />

Transformer<br />

The goal of this activity was the production of a family of cost- and weightcompetitive<br />

planar transformers according to <strong>ESA</strong> standards of design and<br />

manufacture. This was one of the first attempts in Europe to qualify such a product<br />

for power applications.<br />

Miniaturisation can be achieved by using lower profile cores than conventional<br />

wound transformers. Planar transformers tend to have higher surface-to-volume<br />

giving a higher power density. Planar transformers have very interesting electrical<br />

characteristics for many DC/DC converters: compactness, repetitiveness, accurate<br />

control of technical parameters and low leakage inductance.<br />

Three transformers in different size (10 W, 50 W and 100 W, two of which are<br />

presented), with different winding technologies and for different converter<br />

topologies, were designed, built and tested. The planned standard tests were<br />

extended with experiments and additional pre-qualification tests to ensure a<br />

successful qualification.<br />

The results has been successful since the prototypes have proven a very good<br />

overall performance. The design process has been established and all necessary<br />

materials and tools have been identified. The second phase with the objective to<br />

qualify the process for producing planar transformers for power range of 10 W to<br />

500 W (whereas the current maximum power is 100 W) started in 2012 also<br />

funded by <strong>GSTP</strong> and is foreseen to be finished during 2013.


memS rate Sensor Phase 2<br />

The developments in the area of MEMS rate sensors have reached the stage where<br />

they are of interest for use in space. The goal of this activity (Phase 1,2 &3) is to<br />

develop a very low mass, low power and low recurrent cost 3-axis rate<br />

measurement sensor for space use based on terrestrial MEMS technology, provided<br />

that the envisaged methods of performance enhancement and radiation hardening<br />

of the electronics can be demonstrated to work.<br />

During Phase 1, which was completed in 2007, a MEMS detector to support this<br />

concept was successfully designed, prototyped and tested, and an Electronic<br />

Breadboard of the critical elements, primarily the analogue/front-end/timing<br />

circuits, was developed.<br />

Phase 2 has successfully completed the following activities:<br />

• Design of 3-axis MEMS gyro using the concepts demonstrated in Phase 1.<br />

• Design, build and test of a flight prototype within 12 months of unit level<br />

PDR. This was successfully integrated onto Cryosat-2, providing valuable inorbit<br />

experience and test data.<br />

The final unit level activity within Phase 2 of the MRS development was the build<br />

and test of an Engineering Qualification Model (EQM). A major activity was<br />

performed at detector level to update the Phase 1 prototype design, build and test<br />

a batch of Flight Model prototype detectors. This was successfully completed with<br />

Phase 2 detector being incorporated into the first build of the EQM.<br />

Phase 2 will be followed by Phase 3 funded by TRP and EOEP. The MEMS Rate<br />

Sensor has been selected to be part of Sentinel 3-A and B.<br />

Adaptive Digital Beam forming Techniques for GnSS<br />

receivers (ADiBeAm)<br />

The ADIBEAM project aimed at providing high accuracy ground stations, in order<br />

to meet the navigation accuracy and integrity demanded by Galileo and its future<br />

evolution.<br />

During this activity emphasis was given to the design of an antenna array based<br />

on a planar rectangular deployment of micro-strip elements. The proposed array<br />

configuration was a 2-dimensional array of 6x6 elements, as this was considered<br />

a feasible and ready to-use solution for practical implantation thanks to the<br />

reproducibility of antenna conditions, ease of calibration and manufacturing.<br />

An online (and real-time) calibration mechanism was introduced aiming to<br />

compensate the spurious differences between the radiating elements and receiver<br />

channels from their nominal parameters. The proposed mechanism allows for the<br />

simultaneous operation of the GNSS receiver and the calibration.<br />

Robust digital beamforming techniques were proposed, able to cope with the<br />

residual perturbations and the particular difficulties associated with the signal<br />

scenario in ground stations.<br />

Different deterministic and adaptive beamforming solutions were assessed and<br />

additional improvements in the state of the art of beamforming algorithms applied<br />

on GNSS were proposed. On the one hand a deterministic approach based on an<br />

iterative procedure (DET) was presented. The proposed beamformer provided a<br />

high flexibility in terms of array gain vs. sidelobe attenuation trade-offs and the<br />

possibility of tailoring the beam pattern to specific scenarios. On the other hand an<br />

adaptive beamformer based on the Iterative Adaptive Approach (IAA) approach<br />

was proposed. Differently from other adaptive beamformers presented in the<br />

literature, a robust beamformer able of efficiently managing coherent signals was<br />

proposed. IAA was able of cancelling multipath components with deep attenuation<br />

levels.<br />

With the participation of Belgium 2007 - <strong>2011</strong><br />

> Inside view of MEMS rate sensor<br />

> Experimental MEMS rate Gyro aboard Cryosat- 2<br />

With the participation of Spain and Germany 2009 - <strong>2011</strong><br />

> ADIBEAM GNSS ground tracking station Beam Former<br />

<strong>GSTP</strong> Annual Report <strong>2011</strong> | 9


<strong>→</strong> <strong>GSTP</strong> ACTiviTieS iniTiATeD in <strong>2011</strong><br />

During <strong>2011</strong> 81 activities were initiated under the frame of the <strong>GSTP</strong>.<br />

Highlights are presented.<br />

With the participation of Switzerland, France and Norway<br />

> Next Generation Radiation Monitor device<br />

With the participation of of Belgium, United Kingdom, Austria, Czech<br />

Republic, Italy, Netherlands, Germany and France<br />

With the participation of Germany, France, Luxemburg and Czech Republic<br />

> 8 channel ADS-B receiver which is the baseline for the IOD space design.<br />

10 | <strong>GSTP</strong> Annual Report <strong>2011</strong><br />

next Generation radiation monitor (nGrm)<br />

Spacecrafts are exposed to a complex radiation environment which is<br />

highly variable and at times very strong. Some space system failures and<br />

disturbances in recent years have been concluded to be due to radiationinduced<br />

malfunction of critical electronic parts.<br />

The aim of the activity is to make the necessary developments to create<br />

a general-purpose standard low-mass device suitable for most space<br />

radiation environments and with capabilities beyond those presently<br />

available.<br />

The NGRM instrument will provide measurements of the energy spectra<br />

and temporal variations of energetic protons and electrons encountered<br />

in space, with some additional sensitivity to ions. It is a follow-on and<br />

improvement to the previous <strong>ESA</strong> Standard Radiation Environment<br />

Monitor (SREM) project..<br />

Decision Support and real Time earth observation<br />

Data management (DreAm)<br />

This technology development project will address the architecture and<br />

interfaces of the Payload Data Ground Segment needed to streamline<br />

the feasibility analysis, planning, ordering and access to <strong>ESA</strong> and third<br />

party missions Earth Observation (EO) products for two European<br />

institutions: the European Maritime Safety Agency (EMSA) and the<br />

European Union Satellite Centre (EUSC) .<br />

The project aims to support all the issues which arise when a decision<br />

process on the side of the user, needs to exploit information based on<br />

EO data from multiple missions including high resolution commercial<br />

optical ones. The project will as well identify and collect desirable<br />

requirements over sensor, missions and data provision such as additional<br />

radar data for EMSA and in particular optical high resolution data for<br />

EUSC. Finally the project will demonstrate possible interfaces and<br />

components within the multi mission ground segment infrastructure in<br />

support to end-to-end scenarios.<br />

Space based ADS-B Payload Development for Air<br />

Traffic Surveillance<br />

Automatic Dependent Surveillance Broadcast (ADS-B) are signals<br />

broadcasted by an aircraft on a regular basis at low L-band frequencies<br />

with a power of up to several hundred Watts. The signal includes flight<br />

related information such as position, speed, flight number and direction.<br />

Compared to a radar, the ADS-B offers more precision and additional<br />

services, such as weather and traffic information. This information is also<br />

available in areas not covered by radar, for example over oceanic<br />

airspace.<br />

The goal is to develop a space-based ADS-B receiving system and to<br />

demonstrate its functionality under representative space environmental<br />

conditions in orbit, compliant to requirements defined for spacecraft<br />

units and experimental payloads.<br />

The ADS-B IOD payload will consist of two main subsystems: a<br />

dedicated antenna and a receiver unit.


non-Conventional Carbon nanotube Skeleton reinforced<br />

Composites follow on (nACo2)<br />

NACO2 aims at manufacturing and characterising unambiguously the most<br />

promising materials identified within NACO (2007-2010). The main objective of<br />

NACO2 is to scale-up the material developments and thereby increase the<br />

technology maturity for Carbon Nanotube (CNT) skeleton based ceramic and<br />

polymer composites.<br />

As a first step the manufacturing routes for the CNT-skeletons alone will be<br />

stabilised to provide to the composite developers raw material with well-defined<br />

and reproducible characteristics. In a second step the composite manufacturing<br />

processes will be further developed on sample level and in parallel the<br />

dimensions of the CNT-skeletons will be scaled-up to 0.lm x lm with thickness<br />

ranging from few tens of micrometres up to few centimetres. In a third step, the<br />

CNT reinforced composite manufacturing will be stabilised on scaled-up<br />

dimensions, suitable for manufacturing technological demonstrators.<br />

Feasibility for processing large CNT buckypapers has been demonstrated while<br />

the different composite developers have verified compatibility of their processes<br />

with the CNT skeletons.<br />

Advanced integration and Test Services<br />

A number of different Electrical Ground Support Equipment (EGSE) systems<br />

exist in industry (e.g. Columbus CGS system) and have been in operation<br />

for many years supporting <strong>ESA</strong> and National space programs. Some of them<br />

are reaching their end of life and need to be replaced with better performing<br />

systems using state of the art technology, enabling an augmented portfolio of<br />

functionality.<br />

The goal of this activity is to provide a new ground software product line with<br />

reusable services and building blocks, applicable for all new projects, reducing<br />

the cost and risk for system development and production, which will improve the<br />

system competences and will enable seamless transfer of mission information.<br />

During this activity software building blocks will be designed and developed in<br />

an open, collaborative environment using open source tools. The Agile process<br />

principle will be applied, which aims at reducing costly overheads. The procedure<br />

will be iterative and incremental, producing running software right from the<br />

beginning of the project.<br />

Design and Development of a reconfigurable Telemetry<br />

Transmitter for earth observation Satellites<br />

Recent years have witnessed the ever increasing demand for high data links rate<br />

for Earth Exploration missions driven by the adoption of high resolution sensors,<br />

like the Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR) or multi-spectral imagers.<br />

The main objective of this activity is to design and develop a flexible telemetry<br />

transmitter targeting Earth Observation missions and potentially Data Relay Satellite<br />

(DRS) applications implementing the <strong>ESA</strong> Serial Concatenated Convolutional<br />

Codes (SCCC) Standard .<br />

The major outcome will be a high rate TElemetry TRAnsmitter (TETRA) for the<br />

26 GHz band built around a frequency-independent digital baseband unit capable<br />

of serving a number of missions. The telemetry transmitter will be qualified to<br />

Engineering Qualified Model level, performing a complete test campaign. TETRA<br />

will enable data transmission from satellite to ground in Ka-Band and alternatively<br />

in X-Band.<br />

The digital core will have a high degree of flexibility in terms of supported alternative<br />

standard air interfaces and available data rates, enabling the transmission<br />

of information data rates between a minimum and at least 2Gbps per chain, i.e.<br />

single transmitter. Such flexibility will allow the digital core to meet the needs<br />

of several target missions.<br />

With the participation of Germany , Greece, Portugal and Austria<br />

> Doctor blade casting of CNT buckypaper, L) general view, R)<br />

SEM image of a cross section showing casting direction<br />

With the participation of Germany, Austria, Denmark, Ireland and<br />

Netherlands<br />

> AITS Demonstrator Controlling Flight Representative Launcher<br />

Hardware<br />

> Design of the Telemetry Transmitter<br />

With the participation of Germany<br />

<strong>GSTP</strong> Annual Report <strong>2011</strong> | 11


<strong>→</strong> <strong>GSTP</strong> mArkeT-orienTeD ACTiviTieS<br />

The Permanently Open Announcement of Opportunity supports the competitiveness of<br />

the European Industry, enhancing its position to face the worldwide space market in the<br />

near term.<br />

With the participation of Austria 2010 - <strong>2011</strong><br />

> Multi Chanel Protection Module board<br />

With the participation of Spain. 2009 - <strong>2011</strong><br />

> NEREO-ORFU: RF front-end and FPGA processor<br />

With the participation of Belgium. 2007 - <strong>2011</strong><br />

> <strong>ESA</strong> astronaut Frank de Winne testing the Wearable Augmented<br />

Reality (WEAR)<br />

12 | <strong>GSTP</strong> Annual Report <strong>2011</strong><br />

Ao activities closed in <strong>2011</strong><br />

Generic Power Special Check out equipment (SCoe)<br />

Protection<br />

The Power SCOE tests and simulates the critical elements for the power system of<br />

a spacecraft. In order to protect the spacecraft from possible damage due to<br />

excessive voltages, currents or temperatures, the Power SCOE incorporates an<br />

independent protection facility which is implemented in a dedicated board called<br />

Multi Chanel Protection Module.<br />

This Multi-Channel Protection was “re-launched” to cope with future demanding<br />

requirements: Higher voltages, higher currents, more sections, more flexibility,<br />

smaller size and lower cost. At the same time new features were added such as<br />

smart diagnostic capabilities for documentation and quick analysis of events. Aside<br />

from the power protection functions the board integrates a vast amount of I/Ofunctions<br />

making it also a versatile data acquisition platform.<br />

The work carried out during this activity has succeeded in overcoming a long list of<br />

difficulties. The concept was successfully implemented in Galileo and Bepi Colombo<br />

SCOEs.<br />

nereo- next Generation equipment based on Global<br />

navigation Satellites System–reflections (GnSS-r) for eo<br />

NEREO stands for “Next generation Equipment based on GNSS-R for Earth<br />

Observation.” It represents a new generation of GNSS-R instruments developed for<br />

water surface height measurement, sea-state monitoring and soil moisture<br />

estimation. In order to increase significantly the number of reflections that can be<br />

used for processing, a main objective of this project has been to upgrade the design<br />

of the instrument so that it is capable of tracking not only GPS but also Galileo<br />

satellites.<br />

The instrument is basically composed of two subsystems, the Oceanpal Radio<br />

Frequency Unit (ORFU) and the Oceanpal Data Management Unit (ODMU). The ORFU<br />

made up the RF front-end and the host board, which deals with RF signal<br />

acquisition, sampling and initial processing. The ODMU is the processing unit of the<br />

instrument, where GNSS-R processing generates level 0 waveforms. The Field<br />

Programmable Gate Array (FPGA) based solution provides scalability and versatility,<br />

together with the standalone capabilities of the different subsystems.<br />

werable Augmented reality (weAr)<br />

The purpose of this activity was the development of a wearable(mobile) system<br />

using the innovative virtualisation technology known as Augmented Reality (AR),<br />

targeting space and ground operations.<br />

WEAR is a wearable computer system that incorporates a head-mounted display<br />

over one eye to superimpose 3D graphics and data onto its wearer’s field of view.<br />

It supports crew members providing them with increased interaction capabilities,<br />

on-board item recognition and associated visual and aural information display and<br />

manipulation features.<br />

The Space configuration of the system was demonstrated in orbit late in 2009. The<br />

experiment was a success, providing very valuable feedback on the different<br />

technologies demonstrated through this project: Voice Recognition, Head Mounted<br />

Displays, Non-invasive Tracking Systems, Augmented Reality, Note Taking (audio and<br />

video) among others.


Ao activities initiated in <strong>2011</strong><br />

Development of a portable, integrated Point-of-Care<br />

Diagnostics Platform for multiplexed Assays<br />

Point-of-Care (POC) medical diagnostics have demonstrated significant utility<br />

in a variety of settings. Most relevant to <strong>ESA</strong>‘s immediate needs is the health<br />

monitoring of astronauts in space.<br />

The goal of this project is to demonstrate the technologies necessary for a<br />

Point-of-Care diagnostics platform for performing hematologic, clinical chemistry<br />

and immunological tests on whole blood. The resulting prototype will<br />

consist of a microfluidic disc, an instrument, reagents that perform a representative<br />

immunoassay and it will carry out the steps for a bead-based<br />

immunoassay with detection in a rotating flow channel.<br />

Three broad technologies must be integrated through this project to demonstrate<br />

a representative assay: bead-based immunoassays, centrifugal microfluidics,<br />

sensor technology and associated optics system. These must<br />

be brought together under unified instrument control. The default detection<br />

system will consist of a laser as an illumination source, an optical system<br />

consisting of custom and commercial-of-the-self components for delivering<br />

radiation to the disc and fluorescence from the disc and the silicon photomultiplier<br />

assembly with integrated filters.<br />

SArAS- fast Satellite Acquisition System<br />

Usually satellite positions can be calculated through the use of orbital propagators.<br />

These positions are then set in the initial pointing of dish antennas<br />

as an aid for fast acquisition. However, those techniques are generally<br />

designed for stable or final orbits, with decreasing precision in some critical<br />

scenarios where too much inherent uncertainty makes the estimation system<br />

less reliable.<br />

The main goal of this Announcement of Opportunity is to develop an acquisition<br />

aid system for large TTC antennas that can work at lower Signal to Noise<br />

Ratios (SNR) than current ones. SARAS project uses phased array antennas<br />

and digital signal processing in order to electronically get an estimate of the<br />

Telemetry signal’s direction of arrival with super-resolution algorithms. Such<br />

an estimate can be obtained in a relatively short time with acceptable accuracy<br />

even at low input SNR.<br />

This project will enable fast acquisition of satellites/launchers in Launch and<br />

Early Orbit Phase. It will allow to speed up the acquisition in operational<br />

stages of satellites in nominal orbits and to obtain the position of closely<br />

spaced satellites<br />

Advanced Particle filters<br />

The objective of this activity is the development of a family of advanced particle<br />

filters for chemical and electric propulsion, qualified for operation. The<br />

filters are developed for absolute ratings in the 2-20 μm range, and for the<br />

most commonly used gaseous and liquid propellants such as Xenon, Nitrogen,<br />

Hydrazine, MON/NTO, and High Performance Green Propellant (HPGP).<br />

The key technology behind the filter disk is MEMS (Micro-Electro-Mechanical<br />

System). The MEMS technology enables manufacturing of well-defined miniature<br />

structures with extreme precision and repeatability. For the filter application,<br />

MEMS technology is ideally suited to manufacture millions of small<br />

channels, passages, holes, etc. in the micron scale with tight tolerances.<br />

Adding to the fact that manufacturing is highly automated and parallel (batch<br />

processing), the filters can be manufactured at reasonable cost.<br />

The activity is in its first phase during which gaseous particle filters should<br />

be built. The second phase of the activity will be dealing with particle filters<br />

for liquid propellants<br />

Gaseous particle filters are frequently used for pressurant gases on the high<br />

pressure side of liquid propulsion systems. The pressurants are normally helium<br />

or nitrogen. Other common applications are found in electric propulsion<br />

systems and cold gas systems using xenon, nitrogen and other inter gases<br />

as propellants.<br />

> Project concept of comsumable disk with reagent<br />

> Sketch of the SARAS system<br />

With the participation of Ireland<br />

With the participation of Spain<br />

With the participation of Sweden<br />

> Bread board model of a MEMS-based stacked-disk filter<br />

<strong>GSTP</strong> Annual Report <strong>2011</strong> | 13


<strong>→</strong> PerformAnCe enhAnCemenTS for TrACe<br />

GAS moniTorinG: AniTA2<br />

The atmosphere of manned spacecraft needs to be continuously<br />

monitored for harmful trace gases, for crew safety and health. In<br />

case of accidental release of harmful gaseous contaminants (large<br />

or small amounts), extreme off-gassing of materials or malfunctions<br />

in the air revitalization system, fast response by the astronauts<br />

is mandatory. The longer the mission duration, the more<br />

compulsory is the monitoring implementation.<br />

AniTA (Analysing interferometer for Ambient Air) was an<br />

optical based FTIR (Fourier Transform Infrared ) monitoring system<br />

funded by <strong>GSTP</strong> with the participation of DE and NO, which<br />

was originally designed for a 10 days experiment on the Shuttle.<br />

ANITA was actually operated on ISS from September 2007 to<br />

August 2008.<br />

In 2009 with the participation of DE and NO, AniTA2 initial<br />

study-Phase 0 started, with the objective to critically review the<br />

complete ANITA system, draw the lessons learnt and initiate development<br />

of the second generation instrument.<br />

With the aim of improving the robustness and stability of ANITA,<br />

critical issues were identified and, modifications to hardware design<br />

and calibration models were proposed. A new design of the<br />

modulator drive for ANITA 2, able to cope with micro-vibrations<br />

was designed, developed and tested at breadboard level.<br />

I n a d d i t i o n t o i m p r o v i n g t h e r o b u s t n e s s a n d t h e s t a b i l i t yo f t h e<br />

instrument, the configuration of ANITA was critically reviewed and<br />

an updated configuration has been proposed.<br />

> Modulator Drive<br />

> ANITA 2 modulator drive<br />

14 | <strong>GSTP</strong> Annual Report <strong>2011</strong><br />

> ANITA 2 overall instrument concept<br />

The gas cell is set as an optical bench and the overall optical design<br />

is modified. A separate fan system is used for air exchange in the gas<br />

cell.<br />

This updated configuration allows a 50% reduction of volume (1<br />

Middeck Locker for ANITA2 vs. 2 Middeck Lockers for ANITA) and<br />

mass of the ANITA instrument, as well as reduced power<br />

consumption without loss of performance.<br />

A methodology to increase the robustness of the ANITA calibration<br />

models was identified and validated on some of the gases contained<br />

in the ANITA2 target gases. In addition, transfer of calibration<br />

models from one instrument to another has been addressed.<br />

AniTA2 Development<br />

The initial study-Phase 0 was completed in <strong>2011</strong>. A new development<br />

phase, Phase A, will be issued in the coming months. During<br />

this phase models and techniques for handling spectral line shape<br />

changes and variations will be optimized. A breadboard of the complete<br />

instrument will be produced and tested in terms of function<br />

and performance. Phase A will be followed by Phase B/C/D and<br />

Phase E.<br />

> Breadboard<br />

for ANITA2<br />

including blower for<br />

excitation with microvibrations<br />

> In addition to the<br />

modulator drive, a<br />

dedicated front-end-electronics<br />

(including basic<br />

control algorithms) was<br />

developed and manufactured<br />

in order to obtain<br />

a fully functional FTIR<br />

instrument at breadboard<br />

level.


<strong>→</strong> Core TeChnoloGiCAl elemenTS for<br />

oPTiCAl ATomiC CloCkS<br />

<strong>ESA</strong> is enhancing its support to scientific and technological developments<br />

in key aspects of Optical Frequency Metrology and Optical<br />

Atomic Frequency Standards. This is with a view to applying these<br />

developments to meet future requirements of Space Missions, where<br />

the required levels of stability and accuracy exceed the theoretical<br />

limits of the highest performance microwave atomic clocks. Atomic<br />

Clocks in the optical domain have today already experimentally surpassed<br />

microwave clock performance both in fractional frequency<br />

instability and inaccuracy.<br />

The overall goal of the activity is the developmental support for the<br />

preparation of sub-system elements of an Optical Atomic Frequency<br />

Standard (OAFS), flight demonstrator, meeting a predefined specification<br />

and flight envelope in Space in the coming decade.<br />

The activity was formulated to be conducted in 3 phases. Phase 1<br />

was initiated in <strong>2011</strong> with two parallel contracts with the participation<br />

of DE, UK, IE, FR, AT and CH.<br />

Each contractor proposed a different implementation approach leading<br />

to a different frequency standard. The possibilities that are being<br />

considered are broadly divided into:<br />

(a) A laser cooled neutral atom (“Lattice Clocks”)<br />

(b) A single laser cooled trapped ion (“Ion Clocks”)<br />

Lattice Clocks offer the prospect of high frequency stability, as a<br />

consequence of their superior Signal to Noise Ratio (SNR), over Ion<br />

Clocks at short timescales (1 second) whilst the single trapped ion,<br />

being essentially isolated from the surrounding environment represents,<br />

in principle and in practice, the most accurate optical frequency<br />

standard. The architecture and operation of a single ion<br />

lattice Clocks Approach<br />

> Neutral Strontium Lattice development<br />

> Compact Sr + Trap<br />

standard is the least complex of (a) and (b) above and, consequently,<br />

offers the prospect of the development of a more compact optical<br />

atomic frequency standard for space operation.<br />

It also offers the possibility to be even further simplified, and even<br />

scaled down from its current system dimensions, with the implementation<br />

of micro integration technology which has been developed<br />

in the micro-electronics industry.<br />

There are several sub-system elements that, in total, comprise a<br />

complete OAFS or clock technology and the exact description of<br />

these elements depends entirely on the clock (system) chosen. The<br />

key sub-systems of an Optical Atomic Clock include three principal<br />

elements:<br />

1. A Physics Package (PP) which will provide the trapped Ion/<br />

Atom source (and isotope) and will thus define the interrogation<br />

wavelength<br />

After<br />

and<br />

the<br />

spectral<br />

successful<br />

conditions.<br />

flight qualification<br />

2. Cooling<br />

of<br />

&<br />

PLs<br />

auxiliary<br />

and manufacturing<br />

lasers, which will<br />

of the<br />

be developed with clear<br />

goals for the<br />

vehicle<br />

achievement<br />

subsystems,<br />

of an<br />

2010<br />

appropriate<br />

was<br />

spectral performance<br />

with optimization<br />

mainly<br />

for<br />

devoted<br />

the space<br />

to the<br />

environment.<br />

vehicle<br />

3. Ultra narrow<br />

integration<br />

linewidth,<br />

and equipment<br />

frequency stabilized Local Oscillator.<br />

In terms<br />

testing.<br />

of the probe laser development/Optical Local Oscillator<br />

(OLO), the principal challenges to be addressed are the achievement<br />

of ultra-narrow laser linewidth


<strong>→</strong> noDDinG meChAniSm on The iSS<br />

A picture of our planet at night illuminates certain issues<br />

more than sunlight can. In fact, it is in the dark that our otherwise<br />

invisible impact suddenly becomes apparent: artificial<br />

light. A worldwide, high-resolution map of manmade light is<br />

a completely original concept, and would allow its effect on<br />

the environment to be examined in detail.<br />

Putting together this map from aboard the ISS is no small<br />

feat, however. The size of a football field, it travels at 7 km/s<br />

while continuously oscillating back and forth. In light of<br />

these extraordinary circumstances it followed that dedicated<br />

technology needed to be developed to obtain photographs<br />

without smear.<br />

With the support of <strong>GSTP</strong> and the participation of NL and<br />

DE, the Nodding Mechanism was developed to meet this<br />

need. Developed especially with <strong>ESA</strong> astronaut André Kuipers’<br />

PromISS mission in mind, the Nodding Mechanism is<br />

an electro-mechanical system that lets the astronaut take<br />

exceptionally sharp pictures of the Earth at night from inside<br />

the ISS Cupola. A Nikon 3DS camera is mounted facing<br />

the down-looking window, and rotates to counteract the ISS’<br />

orbital motion, allowing for a much longer integration time.<br />

Before the Nodding Mechanism, even the very best night<br />

pictures taken from the ISS could only boast resolutions of<br />

30-50m/pixel. Although still aesthetically pleasing, they are<br />

not of a high enough quality for scientific use due to the<br />

poor signal-to-noise ratio. This is because they are achieved<br />

by keeping integration times low (1/60s) while maximizing<br />

detector gain. To compare, the Nodding Mechanism is now<br />

being used to observe manmade structures (e.g. cities, roads,<br />

sea establishments), vegetation and volcanic activity, which<br />

it does at an unprecedented resolution of about 15m/pixel.<br />

In total, the Nodding Mechanism took less than 6 months<br />

to develop and was launched for the ISS on December 21st<br />

<strong>2011</strong>. It has two operating modes: automatic and manual.<br />

Automatic mode is designed to create super-resolution<br />

maps of the Earth’s night-time surface, while manual mode<br />

gives the astronaut the power to “point and shoot” at single<br />

targets seen from the Cupola’s nadir window.<br />

16 | <strong>GSTP</strong> Annual Report <strong>2011</strong><br />

The Netherlands from the ISS<br />

They can do this because, aside from the three main pointing<br />

axes, the Nodding Mechanism was developed with an additional<br />

fourth axis to enable the camera to be directed at off-track sites.<br />

Among the targets captured are Amsterdam, London, Melbourne<br />

and Naples – Naples taken with an impressive shot of the Vesuvius<br />

Volcano. The European User Community Earth Observation<br />

of Nighttime Lighting is already delighted with the first Nodding<br />

Mechanism results, and is now looking forward to seeing an enhanced<br />

version capable of delivering even more valuable scientific<br />

returns.<br />

> The Nodding Mechanism installed on a mock-up of the European Cupola observatory


Europe seen by André Kuipers onboard<br />

the ISS<br />

17 | <strong>GSTP</strong> Annual Report <strong>2011</strong>


<strong>→</strong> AnnexeS<br />

<strong>GSTP</strong> Annual Report <strong>2011</strong> | 19


<strong>→</strong> Annex 1: liST of DoCumenTS To The<br />

inDuSTriAl PoliCY CommiTTee (iPC)<br />

<strong>→</strong> iPC 263 – Paris, 26-27 January <strong>2011</strong><br />

• <strong>ESA</strong>/IPC(<strong>2011</strong>)100 -General Support Technology Programme-Period 5 Element 1- Status Report- Information Note I<br />

• <strong>ESA</strong>/IPC(<strong>2011</strong>)4 - Update of <strong>GSTP</strong>-4 Work Plan/Procurement Plan<br />

<strong>→</strong> iPC 264 – Paris, 22-23 march <strong>2011</strong><br />

• <strong>ESA</strong>/IPC(<strong>2011</strong>)43 - General Support Technology Programme-Period 3- Status Report- Information Note<br />

• <strong>ESA</strong>/IPC(<strong>2011</strong>)54 - Update of <strong>GSTP</strong>-5 Element-4 Work Plan/Procurement Plan<br />

• <strong>ESA</strong>/IPC(<strong>2011</strong>)52 - Update of <strong>GSTP</strong>-5 Element-2 Work Plan/Procurement Plan<br />

• <strong>ESA</strong>/IPC(<strong>2011</strong>)5 - Update of <strong>GSTP</strong>-5 Element-1 Work Plan/Procurement Plan<br />

• <strong>ESA</strong>/IPC(<strong>2011</strong>)4,add.1 - Update of <strong>GSTP</strong>-4 Work Plan/Procurement Plan<br />

<strong>→</strong> iPC 265 – vienna, 11-12 may <strong>2011</strong><br />

• <strong>ESA</strong>/IPC(<strong>2011</strong>)102 - General Support Technology Programme-Period 5 Element 2- Status Report- Information Note<br />

• <strong>ESA</strong>/IPC(<strong>2011</strong>)71 - General Support Technology Programme-Period 5 Element 3- Status Report- Information Note<br />

• <strong>ESA</strong>/IPC(<strong>2011</strong>)53 - <strong>GSTP</strong>-5 Element-3 Work Plan Update/Procurement Plan<br />

• <strong>ESA</strong>/IPC(<strong>2011</strong>)52, add.1 - Update of <strong>GSTP</strong>-5 Element-2 Work Plan/Procurement Plan<br />

• <strong>ESA</strong>/IPC(<strong>2011</strong>)5, add.1 - Update of <strong>GSTP</strong>-5 Element-1 Work Plan/Procurement Plan<br />

• <strong>ESA</strong>/IPC(<strong>2011</strong>)4, add.2 - Update of <strong>GSTP</strong>-4 Work Plan/Procurement Plan<br />

<strong>→</strong> iPC 266– Paris, 29-30 June <strong>2011</strong><br />

• <strong>ESA</strong>/IPC(<strong>2011</strong>)76 - Cost Plans of on-going General Support Technology Programmes (<strong>GSTP</strong>) in preparation of draft budgets for 2012<br />

• <strong>ESA</strong>/IPC(<strong>2011</strong>)5, add.2 - Update of <strong>GSTP</strong>-5 Element-1 Work Plan/Procurement Plan<br />

<strong>→</strong> iPC 267 – Paris, 29-30 September <strong>2011</strong><br />

• <strong>ESA</strong>/IPC(<strong>2011</strong>)100 rev.1 - General Support Technology Programme-Period 5 Element 1- Status Report- Information Note<br />

• <strong>ESA</strong>/IPC(<strong>2011</strong>)5.add.3 - Update of <strong>GSTP</strong>-5 Element-1 Work Plan/Procurement Plan<br />

• <strong>ESA</strong>/IPC(<strong>2011</strong>)4.add.3 - Update of <strong>GSTP</strong>-4 Work Plan/Procurement Plan<br />

20 | <strong>GSTP</strong> Annual Report <strong>2011</strong>


<strong>→</strong> iPC 268– Paris, 24-25 november <strong>2011</strong><br />

• <strong>ESA</strong>/IPC(<strong>2011</strong>)22 - General Support Technology Programme-Period -4 - Status Report<br />

• <strong>ESA</strong>/IPC(<strong>2011</strong>)71,rev.1 - General Support Technology Programme-Period -5 Element-3- Status Report<br />

• <strong>ESA</strong>/IPC(<strong>2011</strong>)102,rev.1 - General Support Technology Programme-Period -5 Element-2- Status Report<br />

• <strong>ESA</strong>/IPC(<strong>2011</strong>)4,add.4 - Update of <strong>GSTP</strong>-4 Work Plan/Procurement Plan<br />

• <strong>ESA</strong>/IPC(<strong>2011</strong>)54,add.1 - Update of <strong>GSTP</strong>-5 Element-4 Work Plan/Procurement Plan<br />

• <strong>ESA</strong>/IPC(<strong>2011</strong>)52,add.2 - Update of <strong>GSTP</strong>-5 Element-2 Work Plan/Procurement Plan<br />

• <strong>ESA</strong>/IPC(<strong>2011</strong>)5.add.4 - Update of <strong>GSTP</strong>-5 Element-1 Work Plan/Procurement Plan<br />

<strong>→</strong> Annex 2:<br />

<strong>2011</strong> <strong>GSTP</strong> BuDGeT DiSTriBuTion BY<br />

ThemeS<br />

Generic<br />

Technologies<br />

44%<br />

Pilot Projects<br />

2%<br />

Space<br />

Transportation &<br />

Re-entry<br />

Technologies<br />

19%<br />

Earth Observation<br />

23%<br />

Science & Robotic<br />

Exploration<br />

4%<br />

Human<br />

Spaceflight<br />

8%<br />

<strong>GSTP</strong> Annual Report <strong>2011</strong> | 21


<strong>→</strong> Annex 3: ComPleTe liST of <strong>GSTP</strong> ACTiviTieS<br />

iniTiATeD in <strong>2011</strong><br />

ProG. referenCe ACTiviTY TiTle<br />

• AO06-05MT Development and Qualification of LHP2 based Heat Transport System (HTS) for LCT<br />

• AO06-10GS SARAS - Fast Satellite Acquisition System<br />

• AO06-11EE X-Band Downlink Antennas<br />

• AO06-12MP Advanced Particle Filters<br />

• AO06-13GS K-Band Ground Station LNA Development foe EO Missions<br />

• AO06-14GI SCOS-2000 Migration<br />

• AO06-15SE Earth Observation Based 2D Structural Parameters for 3D Virtual Landscape Reconstructions<br />

• AO06-16SW Generic Spacecraft Interfaces<br />

• AO06-18MM Development of a Portable, Integrated Point-of-Care Diagnostic Platform for Multiplexed Assays<br />

• G101-13MM New Radiometer for Optical Calibration<br />

• G213-17HF Prisma - Harvd Off-Line Experiment<br />

• G312-11MP Throttable Injector Technology Development - Phase 1A<br />

• G401-01MZ Cryosat Technology Development for Electrodynamic Heat Shield<br />

• G401-02MZ Shaker Test for Electrodynamic Heatshield (EDH) Cryosat Technology<br />

• G410-04MM High Speed Tunable Laser Interrogator for Spacecraft Health Monitoring<br />

• G511-008ET Integrated Tile Demonstrator<br />

• G511-024GR Decision Support and Real Time EO Data Management (DREAM)<br />

• G511-025GR EO Image Librarian (EOLIB)<br />

• G511-030GR Rapid Response Support Server “RARE”<br />

• G511-036ED Leon with Fast Fourier Transform Co-processor<br />

• G512-003EC Precise Gravitational Modelling of Planetary Moons and NEO Asteroids - COSMIC Vision TDP<br />

• G513-001MM Micro Laser Beam Scanner<br />

• G513-006MM Biochemical Analyser Technology (BIOCAT)<br />

• G513-012MM Enhanced Virtual Reality Stimulator<br />

• G513-024SW Authoring Environment for Interactive 3D Procedures<br />

• G513-046MC Melissa Genetic Characterisation Phase 3<br />

• G514-007MP ESPSS: European Space Propulsion System Simulation<br />

• G514-013MM Fibre Bragg Grating Experiment<br />

• G514-015QE Qualification of a New White Antistatic Coating for Thermal Protections of Launchers<br />

22 | <strong>GSTP</strong> Annual Report <strong>2011</strong>


ProG. referenCe ACTiviTY TiTle<br />

• G514-016MP Cryogenic Valve Sealing<br />

• G514-017MP Development and Commission of Mobile Propellant Analysis Capability<br />

• G517-002MM Piezo New Sources Materials, Piezoceramics Motor Qualification<br />

• G517-010MM Ground Control Station For Autonomy<br />

• G517-011SW Automatic Testing Improvement<br />

• G517-013SW On Board Operating System Upgrade for Leon<br />

• G517-014SW Qualification of xLuna Operating System<br />

• G517-024QM Joining of Composites Materials<br />

• G517-031QM Validation Testing of Glare 1 to Space Qualification Levels<br />

• G517-041SY Development and Validation of a Generic System of Systems Concurrent Engineering Model<br />

• G517-048ED High Reliability COTS based Computer Step 2 (Prototyping and Validation)<br />

• G517-050QC Establishment of a Commercial GaN Epitaxial Production Facility in Europe<br />

• G517-065MC Automated Layup of Thermoplastic Composites for Space Applications<br />

• G517-083GI Integrated Development and validation Environment for Operations Automation (IDEA)<br />

• G517-088MM Development of Core Technological Elements in Preparation for Future Optical Atomic Frequency<br />

• G517-092EC Astro-Aps Productionisation<br />

• G517-094EP Towards Performance Guaranteed Substrates<br />

• G517-099STb National Technology Transfer Initiative (NTTI) Austria<br />

• G517-107MM Development of Quality Evaluation Methods for Calomel Optical Elements<br />

• G517-112ST REDU Incubation Centre<br />

Standards (OAFS) and Clocks (OACs) in Space (Phase1) (2 parallel contracts)<br />

• G517-113EC Reaction Wheel Industrialisation<br />

• G522-001SW Requirement and I/F Definition for Future OBCP Building Block (2 parallel contracts)<br />

• G522-002SW On-Board Software Reference Architecture Consolidation (2 parallel contracts)<br />

• G522-006SW Advanced Integration and Test Services<br />

• G523-005ET Design and Development of a Reconfigurable Telemetry Transmitter for Earth Observation Satellites<br />

• G523-006EE Next Generation Radiation Monitor (NGRM)<br />

• G525-002EP Qualification and Life Testing of a SAFT LI Ion Battery based on a new Small Capacity Cell<br />

• G527-001MC Highly Efficient Stand Alone LHP based Radiator System<br />

• G528-001MS Development and Qualification of a European Pin Puller<br />

• G531-008EE FMP Breadboard Digital Processor Unit<br />

• G533-002EE EUV Solar Imager for Operations (ESIO)<br />

• G533-007EE Particle Trajectory Analyser Phase A/B 2010 <strong>GSTP</strong>5 E3 Batch 2 2010 <strong>GSTP</strong>5 E3 Batch 2<br />

<strong>GSTP</strong> Annual Report <strong>2011</strong> | 23


ProG. referenCe ACTiviTY TiTle<br />

• G533-010EE Next Generation Space Environment Information System<br />

• G533-016EC Orbit Propagation Algorithm for the Space Situation Awareness<br />

• G542-001SY Space-based ADS-B Payload Development for Air Traffic Surveillance<br />

• G601-01MP Multi-physics Valve Model<br />

• G601-69EC Second Generation APS improvements for flexible Low Cost and Mass Sensors (LCMS2)<br />

• G601-84MT Life-Test of Two-Phase Ammonia Mechanical Pump Driven Loop Critical Components<br />

• G606-15GS All European Masers<br />

• G608-27QC Adhesive Sealed sensor Reliability and Test<br />

• G608-31QT Non-Conventional Carbon Nanotube Skeleton Reinforced Composites Follow-on (NACO2)<br />

• G609-61MM Adaptive deformable mirrors for Space Instruments<br />

• G609-66MM Bimorph Adaptive Large Optical Mirror Demonstrator<br />

• G609-74MM Validation and Qualification of an Europeanized KARMA 4 Series Solar Array Drive<br />

• G609-75SY ColAIS Ops and Maintenance (FFI)<br />

• G609-76MP Lifetime Improvement of RIT Type Mini Ion Engines<br />

• G703-07ST Belgium TTP Platform <strong>2011</strong>-WO7<br />

• G511-023GR Automatic, Semantic Image Information Mining from Time Series of HR/VHR Images (ASIM) Project<br />

• G104-47GD Near Real Time GEO Annotated Images (NGI)<br />

• G514-012SN Advanced Self-blocking Electro-Mechanical System Development and Ground-to-Flight Qualification<br />

• G544-005IN Space Station Precursor Technology Initiative: Nodding Mechanism<br />

• G517-113TF Development and enhancement of the key generic components of the SGEO Platform<br />

24 | <strong>GSTP</strong> Annual Report <strong>2011</strong><br />

• olutions


<strong>→</strong> Annex 4: ComPleTe liST of <strong>GSTP</strong><br />

ACTiviTieS CloSeD in <strong>2011</strong><br />

ProG. referenCe ACTiviTY TiTle<br />

• A19.MMM-001 Development of Optically Blind Detectors: BOLD<br />

• AO06-08EP Generic Power SCOE Protection<br />

• AO61-01MM High-Brightness Pump Laser Technology<br />

• AO63-01SW WEarable Augmented Reality (WEAR)<br />

• AO66-10EP Design and development of commercial low power system and related flexible PCV<br />

• AO67-01ST Spacecraft Training Center<br />

• AO67-03ST Germanium Pixel Detector<br />

• AO81-03ET NEREO- Next generation equipment based on GNSS-R for Earth Observation<br />

• FF05-07MP Development of a Miniaturised Xenon Flow Control System for Mini-Ion Engines<br />

• G103-05ET Adaptive digital beamforming techniques for GNSS receivers (ADIBEAM)<br />

• G103-38ED CCSDS Image Compression ASIC<br />

• G213-16HF Multi-Purpose Vision-based Navigation Sensor Architecture Definition<br />

• G304-04MC Performance enhancements for trace gas monitoring (ANITA II)<br />

• G308-11MM Development of single-walled sapphire cartridge<br />

• G401-03MC Surface Protected Flexible Insulation (SPFI)<br />

• G402-05MM Electric Actuators for Fluid Control in Launch Vehicles<br />

• G408-12AO LTAS-KIT: TM avionics sub-system kit for TM transmission via satellite links for launch vehicle<br />

applications (phase C/D)<br />

• G517-045EC Extension/Deployment of the European Mathematical NLP Solver<br />

• G532-003GR SSA Radar and Optical Sensor Data Fusion for Orbit Determination of GTO and GEO Objects<br />

• G601-04MC Thermal model reduction tool<br />

• G601-09EM Data exchange methods for Space Environment Effects tools<br />

• G601-48MC Advancement of multi-functional support structure technologies<br />

• G601-73MP Experimental Evaluation of MEMS-Based Micropropulsion for Future Missions<br />

• G601-75MP Development of a Low Thrust Bipropellant Thruster based on Green Propellant (Phase 1)<br />

• G601-82MM Development of Advanced Bellows for Chemical Propulsion Components<br />

• G601-83MP Latch Valve Development<br />

• G602-08MP Modular and Multi-Application Plasma Diagnostic Package (MMPDP)<br />

• G603-46EC GNC Development Environment (GNCDE)<br />

• G603-46ED Advanced Flexible I/O System<br />

• G604-11EP Study, Development & Verification of a Planar Transformer<br />

<strong>GSTP</strong> Annual Report <strong>2011</strong> | 25


ProG. referenCe ACTiviTY TiTle<br />

• G604-25EP Improved Ge wafer technology for Multi-junction solar cells<br />

• G607-14EM Taxonomy of system FDIR principles and development process<br />

• G607-16ED Advanced Robust Processing Architecture (ARPA) Modular Architecture for Robust Computing ``MARC``<br />

• G608-03QM High conductivity carbon fibre reinforced polymers<br />

• G608-13ES ASICs for space fabricated with DARE library<br />

• G608-24QC Space Qualification of High Q Micromachined Planar Filter Component (SQUAMFIC)<br />

• G609-034EP Engineering/Qualification Model (EQM) qualification of Generic Mechanism Controller (GMC) electronics<br />

• G609-21MM Advanced Slip-Ring Solutions<br />

• G609-37EE Terahertz Camera for Remote Detection of Material Defects and Biological and Chemical Substances<br />

• G609-38MM Stepper Motor for Space Actuator Applications<br />

• G609-46MC Exchange of TMG Thermal Models via STEP-TAS<br />

• G609-49MM Large Format SWIR Focal Plane Array<br />

• G609-54MP Ceramic Chambers for High Power Electric Propulsion<br />

• G609-56EE Basic active Array Antenna Module for Meolut applications<br />

• G609-65MP Experimental Investigation of Key Technologies for a Turbine based Combined Airbreather-Rocket Engine: PHASE I<br />

• G609-69EE Simulator for EMC Analysis at System Level<br />

• G609-70QI Exploitation of the Data Collected during the ATV Re-entry Observation Campaign<br />

• G609-72SY Enabling Technologies for Space Situation Awareness (SSA)<br />

• G703-01PT Support to space technology transfer - Finland<br />

• G703-07ST Belgium TTP Platform<br />

• G408-10MP EXPERT Advanced in-Flight Test Measurement Techniques for Plasma Characterization<br />

• NP10-08EP Qualification of RTV-S690 silicone adhesive for the solar cell cover-glassing<br />

• NP10-10MP Spark Plug Development for Next Generation Liquid Propulsion<br />

• NP20-03EP High Temperature Fuel Cells<br />

• NP20-05EP Digital Control for power management<br />

• NP30-06SY Mission and Payload accommodation Analysis for European Space-Based Maritime Reconnaissance and Surveillance<br />

System<br />

• T603-10ES,<br />

B33.ESC-200 MEMS rate sensor development Phase 2<br />

26 | <strong>GSTP</strong> Annual Report <strong>2011</strong>


GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS<br />

F EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY<br />

ROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY<br />

OSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING<br />

CTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION<br />

NHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> &<br />

ATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN<br />

ECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES<br />

UPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON<br />

EPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE<br />

OMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL<br />

UPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF<br />

UROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY<br />

ROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY<br />

OSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING<br />

CTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION<br />

NHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> &<br />

ATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN<br />

ECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES<br />

UPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON<br />

EPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE<br />

OMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL<br />

UPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF<br />

UROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY<br />

ROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY<br />

OSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING<br />

CTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION<br />

NHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> &<br />

ATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN<br />

ECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES<br />

UPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON<br />

EPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE<br />

OMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE<br />

ENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE<br />

OMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE<br />

ENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS<br />

F EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY<br />

ROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY<br />

OSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING<br />

CTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION<br />

NHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> &<br />

ATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN<br />

ECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES<br />

UPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON<br />

EPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE<br />

OMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL<br />

UPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF<br />

UROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY<br />

ROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY<br />

OSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING<br />

CTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION<br />

NHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> &<br />

ATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN<br />

ECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES<br />

UPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON<br />

EPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE<br />

OMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL<br />

UPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF<br />

UROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY<br />

ROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY<br />

OSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING<br />

CTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION<br />

NHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> &<br />

ATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN<br />

ECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES<br />

UPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON<br />

EPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE<br />

OMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL<br />

UPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF<br />

UROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY<br />

ROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY<br />

OSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING<br />

CTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION<br />

NHANCING EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> &<br />

ATIONAL PROGRAMMES - SUPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN<br />

ECHNOLOGICAL NON-DEPENDENCE. GENERAL SUPPORT TECHNOLOGY PROGRAMME: ENABLING ACTIVITIES OF <strong>ESA</strong> & NATIONAL PROGRAMMES<br />

UPPORTING THE COMPETITIVENESS OF EUROPEAN INDUSTRY - FOSTERING INNOVATION - ENHANCING EUROPEAN NON-DEPENDENCE


<strong>GSTP</strong> Participating States<br />

Austria<br />

Belgium<br />

Czech Republic<br />

Denmark<br />

Finland<br />

France<br />

Germany<br />

Greece<br />

Ireland<br />

Italy<br />

Luxembourg<br />

Netherlands<br />

Norway<br />

Portugal<br />

Spain<br />

Sweden<br />

Switzerland<br />

United Kingdom<br />

Canada<br />

Copyright 2012 © European Space Agency

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!