Storage pumps and reversible pump-turbines - Renewables Grid ...
Storage pumps and reversible pump-turbines - Renewables Grid ...
Storage pumps and reversible pump-turbines - Renewables Grid ...
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
LMH Laboratory for Hydraulic Machines<br />
<strong>Storage</strong>Pumps<br />
&<br />
ReversiblePumpTurbines<br />
Scientific<strong>and</strong>TechnicalChallenges<br />
Prof.FrançoisAvellan,Dr.Eng.,<br />
EPFLSchoolofEngineering<br />
InstituteofMechanicalEngineering<br />
Hongrin Dams<br />
FMHL SA<br />
RGI<strong>Storage</strong>Workshop,Montreux Jan.27,2011
LMH Laboratory for Hydraulic Machines<br />
Scope<br />
Pumped<strong>Storage</strong>PowerPlants<br />
TodayTechnology<br />
Science<strong>and</strong>TechnologyChallenges<br />
Introduction<br />
Computing Domain of the<br />
HYDRODYNA Pump-<br />
Turbine
LMH Laboratory for Hydraulic Machines<br />
SwissPowerGeneration<br />
Swiss Electricity Data:2009Survey<br />
70'000<br />
[GWh]<br />
60'000<br />
50'000<br />
40'000<br />
30'000<br />
20'000<br />
10'000<br />
<strong>Storage</strong> Hydropower Plants<br />
Pumped <strong>Storage</strong><br />
Plants<br />
AnnualPower<br />
Generation<br />
Run-off Hydropower Plants<br />
NuclearPower Plants<br />
Annual Power<br />
Consumption<br />
Fossil FuelPowerPlants<br />
<br />
1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010<br />
Switzerl<strong>and</strong>tobeProudofaNearlyCO 2FreePowerGenerationMix
LMH Laboratory for Hydraulic Machines<br />
PowerGenerationMixinSwitzerl<strong>and</strong><br />
Fossil Fuel<br />
Power Plants<br />
5.1 %<br />
Nuclear<br />
Power Plants<br />
40.8 %<br />
63 971GWh PowerGenerationin2009:<br />
Pumped<br />
<strong>Storage</strong><br />
Power Plants<br />
3.9 %<br />
<strong>Storage</strong><br />
Hydropower<br />
Plants<br />
32.9 %<br />
Run-off<br />
Hydropower<br />
Plants<br />
25.2 %<br />
2009:11 734MWHydropowerGeneratingCapacity;1 699MWPumpingPowerCapacity
LMH Laboratory for Hydraulic Machines<br />
HongrinLéman PSP<br />
Hongrin Lake(1969):<br />
52millionsm 3 Capacity<br />
Veytaux PowerStation<br />
(1972)<br />
4HorizontalTernary Units<br />
256MWPumpingPower<br />
240MWGeneratingPower<br />
850mWC Head<br />
600min 1<br />
Hongrin Lake<br />
Léman Lake<br />
EarlyDevelopments:Veytaux Pumped<strong>Storage</strong>Plant(FMHLsa)
LMH Laboratory for Hydraulic Machines<br />
<strong>Storage</strong>ofEnergyinExcess<br />
AvailabilityofHVAC<strong>Grid</strong>(220kV&380kVinCH)<br />
Reservoirs<br />
<strong>Grid</strong>Control<br />
GeneratingMode<br />
PumpingMode<br />
MitigatingtheFlow<br />
Changes<br />
Reservoirs<br />
Pumped <strong>Storage</strong>PowerPlants<br />
Services<br />
> 60 GW Wind Power in EU!<br />
• 22 GW in Germany;<br />
• 15 GW in Spain.<br />
InternalRateofReturn:SpotMarketvs.Servicestothe<strong>Grid</strong>
LMH Laboratory for Hydraulic Machines<br />
LastOutst<strong>and</strong>ingPumped<strong>Storage</strong>Plants<br />
Commissionedsince12Years<br />
Pumped<strong>Storage</strong><br />
Unit<br />
PowerPlant Capacity Units Power Owner Country Year<br />
Yangyang 1'032MW 4 258MW KOMIPO SouthKorea 2006<br />
Kannagawa 2'820MW 6 470MW TEPCO Japan 2005<br />
Goldisthal 1'060MW 4 265MW VATTENFALLEurope Germany 2002<br />
Kazunogawa 1'648MW 4 412MW TEPCO Japan 2001<br />
Tianhuangping 1'800MW China 2001<br />
Guangzhou 2'400MW 8 300MW CLP,Guangdong China 2000<br />
Matanoagawa 1'200MW ChugokuElectric<br />
Power Japan 1999<br />
Okutataragi 1'932MW 6 322MW KEPCO Japan 1998<br />
Needsof<strong>Storage</strong>Capacity:ReversiblePumpTurbines
LMH Laboratory for Hydraulic Machines<br />
500rpm,525,000kVA<br />
MotorGenerator,Hitachi<br />
2 820MWCapacity<br />
6PumpTurbines,470MWPumpingPower,625mWC Head<br />
TEPCO,TokyoElectricPowerCo.<br />
6PumpTurbines<br />
@500rpm<br />
Kannagawa PSP:WorldwideLargestCapacityPumped<strong>Storage</strong>PowerPlant
LMH Laboratory for Hydraulic Machines<br />
VerticalTernaryUnits:<br />
PeltonM/GPump<br />
MatchingbothPumping<strong>and</strong><br />
GeneratingModes<br />
LengthoftheRotatingTrain;<br />
Speed;<br />
RequiredSubmergence.<br />
HighGradeControl<br />
Pelton Turbine<br />
HydraulicByPass<br />
TurbineDriveforStartingUp<br />
1DirectionofRotation<br />
EfficientCooling<br />
SafeTransients<br />
Technology ofTernary Units<br />
FMHL +<br />
2 Ternary Units<br />
~850 mCE 120 MW @ 500 min -1
LMH Laboratory for Hydraulic Machines<br />
HydraulicBypass<br />
P<br />
MG P T<br />
P<br />
P<br />
Technology:EnablingFast<strong>Grid</strong> PrimaryControl
LMH Laboratory for Hydraulic Machines<br />
MixedIsl<strong>and</strong>edNetwork<br />
WindFarmSafetyTrippoff<br />
200MWWindFarm<br />
1'200MWNuclearPowerPlant<br />
2x250MWPumped<strong>Storage</strong><br />
Plant<br />
http://simsen.epfl.ch/<br />
C.Nicoletetal.,"<strong>Storage</strong>Units<br />
toStabilizeMixedIsl<strong>and</strong>ed<br />
PowerNetwork:aTransient<br />
Analysis".HYDRO2008,<br />
Ljubljana,Slovenia.<br />
AdvancedNumericalSimulation:EnablingFast<strong>Grid</strong>Control
LMH Laboratory for Hydraulic Machines<br />
<strong>Grid</strong>PrimaryControl<br />
thruHydraulicBypass<br />
http://simsen.epfl.ch/<br />
200 MW Wind Farm Safety Tripp off<br />
SIMSEN Numerical Simulation<br />
250 MW Hydraulic Bypass<br />
AdvancedNumericalSimulation:EnablingFast<strong>Grid</strong>Control
LMH Laboratory for Hydraulic Machines<br />
ReversiblePumpTurbineUnits<br />
TechnologyChallenges<br />
StartUpProcedures<br />
StaticFrequencyConverterofLimited<br />
Power<br />
BacktoBackarrangement<br />
TurbineorPonyMotorDrive<br />
Dewatering/WateringProcess<br />
BidirectionalMotorGeneratorSpeed<br />
AirCoolingvs.WaterCooling<br />
Pumping&GeneratingOperating<br />
RangesMatching<br />
Efficiency<br />
Cavitation<br />
Transients:Startup&LoadRejection<br />
<strong>Grid</strong>PrimaryControl<br />
Variablespeed<br />
DoubleRegulatedStages<br />
Yang Yang (ALSTOM Hydro)<br />
• 800 mWC<br />
• 4 x 258 MW à 600 min -1<br />
• Double Regulated Stages (n q 38)<br />
ReversiblePumpTurbineTechnology
LMH Laboratory for Hydraulic Machines<br />
620MWNant deDrance PSPProject(VS)<br />
Commissioningin2015<br />
EmossonLake 21010 6 m 3 Capacity<br />
VieilEmossonLake1110 6 m 3 Capacity<br />
250to390mWC HeadRange<br />
4x155MWSingleStagePumpTurbines<br />
428.6min 1 ±7%VariableSpeedDrive<br />
VARSPEEDTechnologyEnablingPumpingPowerControl
LMH Laboratory for Hydraulic Machines<br />
1GWLinthal PSPProject(GL)<br />
Commissioningin2015<br />
Limmern 9210 6 m 3 Capacity<br />
Mutt 2510 6 m 3 Capacity<br />
560mWC to724mWC HeadRange<br />
4x250MWSingleStagePumpTurbines<br />
500rpm ± 6%VariableSpeedDrive<br />
VARSPEEDTechnologyEnablingPumpingPowerControl
LMH Laboratory for Hydraulic Machines<br />
StaticFrequency<br />
Converter<br />
VoltageSourceInverter<br />
DoubleFeed<br />
AsynchronousMachines<br />
CylindricalRotorwith<br />
ThreePhasesWinding<br />
SlipRingsforExcitation<br />
Reversible<br />
PumpTurbine<br />
VARSPEEDTechnology<br />
VARSPEEDTechnologyEnablingPumpingPowerControl
LMH Laboratory for Hydraulic Machines<br />
NumericalSimulationoftheVeryFast<br />
ChangeofthePowerSetPoint<br />
http://simsen.epfl.ch/<br />
Varspeed<br />
YvesPannatier :"Optimisationdesstratégiesderéglage<br />
d'uneinstallationdepompageturbinageàvitesse<br />
variable",Thèse EPFLN° 4789,2010.<br />
VARSPEEDTechnologyEnablingPumpingPowerControl<br />
Synchronous<br />
Machine
LMH Laboratory for Hydraulic Machines<br />
Safety,Reliability<strong>and</strong>Flexibility<br />
MeetingDem<strong>and</strong>ofPeakingPower<br />
<strong>Grid</strong>PrimaryControl<br />
ShortTimeResponse<br />
FrequentStarts&Stops<br />
ExtendingOperatingRanges<br />
KnowledgeDevelopmentinHydrodynamics<br />
Sciences<strong>and</strong><br />
TechnologyChallenges
LMH Laboratory for Hydraulic Machines<br />
RotorStatorInteractions<br />
inGeneratingMode<br />
HYDRODYNA<br />
CaseStudy<br />
z o =20,z b =9<br />
Experimental<br />
Investigations<br />
ValidationofUnsteady<br />
NumericalSimulations<br />
HYDR DYNA<br />
"Dynamic"BehaviorofPumpTurbines<br />
Unsteady Pressure Field<br />
in Generating Mode<br />
Max Discharge
LMH Laboratory for Hydraulic Machines<br />
Experimental<br />
Infrastructure<br />
• Research<br />
• Education<br />
• Experimental<br />
Validation<br />
EPFLTesting Facilities<br />
Complying IEC 60193 St<strong>and</strong>ards<br />
Efficiency Uncertainty
LMH Laboratory for Hydraulic Machines<br />
Pumped<strong>Storage</strong><br />
PowerPlant<br />
IEC60193PumpTurbineModelTesting<br />
Country Owner/Manufacturer Capacity Year<br />
Ludington MI,USA Consumers Energy 6x312MW 2010<br />
XIANYOU China DONGFANGElectricalMachineryLtd 1'200MW 2009<br />
XIANSHUIJAN China HARBINElectricalMachineryLtd. 4x370MW 2009<br />
VeryHighHead R&D/ALSTOMHydro 20078<br />
ROCKYMOUNTAIN GA,USA OglethorpePower/AmericanHydro 3x370MW 20056<br />
BLENHEIMGILBOA NY,USA Rev.Eng.&ImpellerModelNYPA 4x260MW 2003<br />
CHEONSONG SouthKorea KoreaWesternPowerCo/GEHydro 2x350MW 2003<br />
Nq45 R&D/ALSTOMHydro 2002<br />
VENDANOVEII Portugal EDP/VOITHHydro 2x98MW 2001<br />
ALQUEVA Portugal EDIAoperatedbyEDP/ALSTOMHydro 2x130MW 1999<br />
TAUMSAUK* MO,USA UnionElectricCompany/AmericanHydro 2x220MW 1997<br />
EPFL:aKeyResearchCenterforHydropowerDevelopment
LMH Laboratory for Hydraulic Machines<br />
ResearchProject<br />
PumpTurbineHydrodynamics<br />
Investigating,Modeling<strong>and</strong>HarnessingUnsteadyFlows;<br />
FluidStructureCoupling;<br />
RotorStatorInteractions;<br />
Cavitation;<br />
PerformanceCurve<br />
Stability<br />
HYDR DYNA<br />
Sciences<strong>and</strong>Technology Challenges<br />
PompeturbineHYDRODYNAz o =20,z b =9
LMH Laboratory for Hydraulic Machines<br />
HYDRODYNAPumpTurbine<br />
Scale Model<br />
HYDR DYNA<br />
ExperimentalInvestigations
LMH Laboratory for Hydraulic Machines<br />
ComputingDomain<br />
HYDR DYNA<br />
FlowNumericalSimulations
LMH Laboratory for Hydraulic Machines<br />
RotorStatorInteraction<br />
GeneratingMode@FullLoad<br />
HYDR DYNA<br />
PressureFieldattheSpiralCasingWall
LMH Laboratory for Hydraulic Machines<br />
K= 2Modeof9x20RSI<br />
ExperimentalValidationofRSINumericalSimulations
LMH Laboratory for Hydraulic Machines<br />
ImpellerModalAnalysis:2DMode<br />
HYDRODYNAImpellerFluidStructureCoupling
LMH Laboratory for Hydraulic Machines<br />
TowardaSustainableCO 2Free<br />
PowerGenerationSystem<br />
RenewingAvailableHydropowerSchemeswithPumped<br />
<strong>Storage</strong>PowerPlantsforMaximizingValueoftheAvailable<br />
<strong>Storage</strong>Capacities<br />
MinimizingEnvironmentalImpacts;<br />
IncreasingPowerCapacity<strong>and</strong>Efficiency;<br />
DevelopingPowerControlCapability;<br />
EnhancingRobustness,Availability,Maintainability&Safety.<br />
InterconnectedElectricityNetworksOpportunities<br />
EnablingNewRenewableEnergyDevelopment;<br />
PeakPowerGeneration;<br />
<strong>Grid</strong>PowerControlServices:PrimaryControl(frequency).<br />
StrategicIssuesforDevelopingPumped<strong>Storage</strong>PowerPlants
LMH Laboratory for Hydraulic Machines<br />
Conclusions<br />
Pumped<strong>Storage</strong>Plants(PSP)arethekeycomponentfor<br />
enablingthedevelopment<strong>and</strong>theoptimumuseofprimary<br />
renewableenergy.<br />
Thebusinessmodelisdrivenbytheenergyspotmarket,the<br />
servicestothegrid<strong>and</strong>thepublicpolicy.<br />
The<strong>pump</strong>turbinetechnologyneedstobefurtherdeveloped<br />
tomeetthemarketneeds<strong>and</strong>toensure<strong>and</strong>enhance,<br />
reliabilityavailabilitymaintainability<strong>and</strong>safetyofthepower<br />
plants.Attentionmustbepaidwhenutilizingexisting<br />
hydraulicinfrastructure,e.g.penstock.<br />
TheongoingSwissprojectsofPSPareanopportunityfor<br />
furtherinvestigationsinthefieldofenablingenergy<br />
technology.<br />
EPFLSchoolofEngineering
LMH Laboratory for Hydraulic Machines<br />
EPFLDoctoralTheses<br />
NicolasRUCHONNET:"Multiscale ComputationalMethodologyAppliedto<br />
Hydroacoustic ResonanceinCavitating PipeFlow", EPFLDoctoralThesis<br />
N°4778,2010.<br />
Berten STEFAN:HydrodynamicsofHighSpecificPowerPumpsatOff<br />
DesignOperatingConditions ,EPFLDoctoralThesisN°4642,2010.<br />
PhilippeAUSONI:"TurbulentVortexSheddingfromaBluntTrailingEdge<br />
Hydrofoil", EPFLDoctoralThesisN°4475,2009.<br />
OlivierBRAUN:"PartLoadFlowinRadialCentrifugalPumps",EPFL<br />
DoctoralThesisN°4422,2009.<br />
AlirezaZOBEIRI:"InvestigationsofTimeDependentFlowPhenomenaina<br />
Turbine<strong>and</strong>aPumpTurbineofFrancisType:RotorStatorInteractions<strong>and</strong><br />
Precessing VortexRope",EPFLDoctoralThesisN°4272,2009.<br />
AdvancedEducationinHydrodynamicsofTurbomachines
LMH Laboratory for Hydraulic Machines<br />
ThanksforyourKindAttention<br />
RGI<strong>Storage</strong>Workshop,Montreux Jan.27,2011
LMH Laboratory for Hydraulic Machines<br />
Gr<strong>and</strong>eDixence HydropowerScheme<br />
400Millionsm 3 Reservoir<strong>Storage</strong>Capacity:MaximumValue
LMH Laboratory for Hydraulic Machines<br />
Gr<strong>and</strong>eDixence HydropowerScheme:<br />
GeneratingPowerStation:<br />
CollectingWaterfrom35<br />
SeasonalOperation Glaciers<br />
1'269MWBieudron<br />
685MWNendazFionnay<br />
100MWCh<strong>and</strong>oline<br />
170MWPumpingPower<br />
400Millionsm 3 Reservoir<strong>Storage</strong>Capacity:MaximumValue
LMH Laboratory for Hydraulic Machines<br />
1'269MWBieudron PowerPlant<br />
3Pelton Turbines<br />
500MVAGenerators<br />
428.5min 1<br />
14poles,35.7MVA/pole<br />
WaterCooled<br />
423MWPelton<br />
Turbines,5injectors<br />
1'883mWC Head<br />
25m 3 /sDischarge<br />
D 1 =3.993m<br />
~28tRunnerMass<br />
Bieudron PowerPlantEnablingRhôDix <strong>Storage</strong>PumpedProject
Change language