28.07.2013 Views

Intensive Survey Report - USDA Forest Service

Intensive Survey Report - USDA Forest Service

Intensive Survey Report - USDA Forest Service

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

Prepared for:<br />

ROUND IDLL RESORT INTENSIVE SURVEYREPORT<br />

ROUND HILL PINES, DOUGLAS COUNTY<br />

LAKE TAHOE, NEVADA<br />

<strong>USDA</strong> <strong>Forest</strong> <strong>Service</strong><br />

IBET Province-Eldorado National <strong>Forest</strong><br />

100 Forni Road<br />

Placerville, California 95667<br />

Prepared by:<br />

Judith Marvin<br />

Foothill Resources, Ltd.<br />

Post Office Box 2040<br />

Murphys, California 95247<br />

March 2002


ACKNOWLEDGMENTS<br />

The author would like to gratefully acknowledge the following people who shared their<br />

expertise on the history and construction ofthe Round Hill Resort: Susan Lindstrom,<br />

Truckee, California; Penny Rucks, Reno, Nevada; Rebecca Ossa and Mella Harmon, State<br />

Historic Preservation Office, State ofNevada; and Mike Weichman, U.S. <strong>Forest</strong> <strong>Service</strong>,<br />

Lake Tahoe Basin Management Unit, South Lake Tahoe, California.<br />

2


TABLE OF CONTENTS<br />

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS 11<br />

ABSTRACf 1<br />

SURVEY METHODOLOGY 4<br />

THEMATIC RESEARCH<br />

a. Historical Overview 5<br />

b. Designers, Engineers, and Builders 9<br />

c. Notable People 13<br />

SURVEY RESULTS 13<br />

RECOMMENDATIONS 16<br />

a. <strong>Survey</strong> and Research Needs 16<br />

b. National Register Listing and Detennination ofEligibility 16<br />

c. Threats to the Resources 16<br />

EVALUATIONS 16<br />

Significance Criteria 16<br />

Conclusions 17<br />

MITIGATION 17<br />

a. Documentation 17<br />

b. Salvage ofArchitectural Elements 17<br />

c. Historic Context and Popular History 18<br />

d. Rehabilitation and Preservation ofRepresentative Resources 18<br />

REFERENCES CITED OR CONSULTED 19<br />

APPENDICES<br />

A. Historical Resources Inventory Fonns<br />

B. Photographs<br />

C. Round Hill Resort Time Line<br />

D. Nevada SHPO National Register Eligibility Letter<br />

FIGURES<br />

1. Project Location 2<br />

2. Sketch Map ofProperty 3<br />

3. Applegate Insurance Map ofProperty, 1945 15<br />

3


Figure 1. Project Location. (South Lake Tahoe CA-NV Quadrangle, USGS 1992.)<br />

5


Figure 2. Sketch Map ofProperty.<br />

6


It was precious metals that provided the impetus for most ofthe visitors to the Tahoe Basin.<br />

The discovery ofgold on the American River in January of 1848 spurred would-be miners<br />

and entrepreneurs from ''the States" and virtually every country in the world to rush to the_<br />

rich gravel bars on the rivers and tributaries ofthe Sierra Nevada foothills. The movement<br />

that ensued has been called one ofthe greatest mass migrations in human history, as<br />

thousands poured into the region in search ofthe elusive metal. Many ofthe argonauts who<br />

came overland to the gold fields crossed the Sierra via Lake Tahoe, traveling either the Scott<br />

Route (later the Placer County Emigrant Road) on the north shore of the lake, or the<br />

Placerville Road along the south shore.<br />

Early development at the lake, however, was precipitated by the discovery ofsilver on the<br />

Comstock Lode in Nevada. The rich forest reserves ofthe Lake Tahoe basin were tapped to<br />

provide timbers for the ever-deepening mines around Virginia City and for the construction<br />

ofhomes and commercial enterprises in the surrounding communities. The rich placer<br />

diggings in the California gold country had been played out and the area was experiencing a<br />

depression; disillusioned gold miners rushed to the Comstock strike, again passing by Lake<br />

Tahoe on their return route.<br />

While the major timber companies were located on the Nevada side ofthe lake (the Carson<br />

and Tahoe Lumber and Fluming Company at Glenbrook and the Sierra Nevada Wood and<br />

Lumber Company at Crystal Bay), other smaller operations were developed along the north<br />

shores ofthe lake during the boom period between 1860 and the 1890s. By the late 1890s<br />

the forests had been logged out and the companies ceased operations.<br />

Soon after the loggers, however, came the recreationists, men who saw the possibilities of<br />

Lake Tahoe as a pleasure and health resort. Fishing and hunting were the earliest<br />

recreational pursuits, soon followed by boating, bathing in the hot springs, swimming, and<br />

gambling on the Nevada shore. The first permanent settlements were at the mouth of<br />

McKinney Creek, Ward Creek, Glenbrook, and Tahoe City, where the Tahoe House was<br />

erected in 1864. When the Central Pacific Railroad reached Truckee, a wagon road was<br />

constructed to the lake and the tourism boom was on.<br />

Beginning in the early 1860s, resorts had been established at Lake Tahoe as fashionable<br />

summer retreats for the well-to-do. Some ofthe earliest resorts on the California side of the<br />

lake included the Lake House at Al Tahoe, Rubicon Point Lodge, Grand Hotel at Tahoe City,<br />

and the Bellevue Hotel at Sugar Pine Point (Woodward Architectural Group 1993:42-43).<br />

After the turn ofthe century, when Tahoe had become more accessible due to the completion<br />

ofthe Tahoe Railway, which connected Truckee with Tahoe City, tourism boomed and<br />

additional resorts were constructed. Two ofthese, E. J. Baldwin's Tallac and the Bliss<br />

family's Tahoe Tavern in Tahoe City, were extremely luxurious for their time.<br />

Due to the inadequacy ofthe roads in the Tahoe Basin, most travelers to the lakeshore resorts<br />

and cabins traveled to their destinations by steamer or sailboat, primarily the Governor<br />

Stanford and the Tahoe, each ofwhich followed a set schedule, making stops at Glenbrook,<br />

Tallac, Emerald Bay, Carnelian Bay, and Brockway (Woodward Architectural Group<br />

1993:44).<br />

9


With the advent ofthe automobile in the twentieth century, the need for good roads became<br />

imperative. Increasing pressure from travelers and tourists, coupled with the passage of the<br />

Federal-Aid Road Act in 1916, provided the impetus for the State ofCalifornia to upgrade<br />

the roads into the Tahoe Basin. Finally, the road ringing Lake Tahoe, the Brockway<br />

Highway (State Route 28), was completed in 1931, enabling travelers to reach Nevada's<br />

north shore ofthe lake, and providing an impetus to development ofthat region. During the<br />

mid-1930s the Lincoln and Victory coast-to-coast highways had been completed and the<br />

Lincoln Highway (present U.S. 50) became the major access to the basin. All the roads<br />

connecting Lake Tahoe to Nevada and California had been paved by 1930 and by 1935 a<br />

passable auto route had been completed around the lake (Woodward Architectural Group<br />

1993 :44-45).<br />

The development ofa viable transportation corridor around Lake Tahoe, coupled with the<br />

popularity of the automobile, was to forever alter the character ofthe basin. The region was<br />

now readily accessible to the public, including the middle class, who created another rush to<br />

the area to camp, build modest cabins, and utilize the lakeshore for numerous forms of<br />

recreation. From the beginnings oftourism in the basin, however, the lakeshore was utilized<br />

almost exclusively during the summer months, with resorts and cabins opened on Memorial<br />

Day and shuttered on Labor Day.<br />

In recent years, however, the Tahoe Basin has seen increasing use during the winter months,<br />

especially since the development ofSquaw Vailey for the Winter Olympic Games in 1960,<br />

and the subsequent construction ofnumerous other ski resorts. Small, family-oriented, rustic<br />

cabins have given way to modern year-around subdivisions, the remodeling ofolder<br />

structures, and the demolition ofmany others, as present-day lake dwellers increase the size<br />

and usage oftheir properties.<br />

Round Hill Pines. Round Hill, also known as Folsom's Knob and Peak, Round Mountain<br />

and Mound, is bounded on the north by Marla Beach and Zephyr Cove, and south by<br />

Edgewood.<br />

The first owner ofrecord ofthe land in the project area was John Marley, a native of<br />

England, who pre-empted 160 acres surrounding the bay in the spring of 1864. There Marley<br />

built a log cabin, planted timothy hay, scythe-cut his crop and baled it with a hand press. He<br />

also planted potatoes and other vegetables, which were sold to travelers along the Golden<br />

Road. When assessed in the first tax rolls ofDouglas County, Nevada, one wagon was<br />

mentioned, although he obviously must have owned mules, horses, or oxen to pull the<br />

vehicle.<br />

Six years after settling on the shores ofLake Tahoe, Marley lost his ranch for back taxes and<br />

the property was purchased by Captain Augustus W. Pray in November 1870. Marley,<br />

however, did leave his name on the cove, shortened to Marla over the years. Pray, a resident<br />

ofGlenbrook, was a lumberman who felled the best timber in the forests and left the stunted<br />

growth to be cut for cordwood. After all the choice timber was cut, Pray sold the land to<br />

William McFaul, a wood contractor, in 1884.<br />

10


William McFaul. The McFaul family, who had fonnerly resided at Zephyr Cove, dropped<br />

and split trees around the lake during the winter months. During the summer the family<br />

operated a dairy fann, pasturing a herd ofmilk cows in the meadow near the bay. They also<br />

smoked ham, crocked eggs, and kegged butter for the fall market in Washoe. The family<br />

soon added a two-story house, as well as two barns and a milk house, to the property (located<br />

on the eastern end ofthe meadow bordering an elbow ofthe lake road, which horseshoed<br />

around the meadow) (Scott 1957:243, 1973:58).<br />

Over the ensuing 20 years the McFauls cut cordwood, stacking it on their wharf at the bay,<br />

and loaded the pine slabs onto barges for transportation to Glenbrook. During the McFauls<br />

tenure, others, including Joe M. Short and Heinrick ''Dutch Fred" Dangberg, took over the<br />

ranch for various periods oftime. McFaul died in 1912 and the property was purchased by<br />

Louis Cowgill the following year. Three years later it had passed to Glen Cowgill (Koval<br />

1991 :4).<br />

Noonan DeVaux. By 1919 Nonnan DeVaux had purchased the property, and in 1920<br />

acquired adjacent property. In 1927 he began divesting himself ofsome ofhis property at<br />

the lake, selling one parcel to John Leslie Harvey ofZephyr Cove., and another to the Nevada<br />

Elks. Tahoe Association (the Elks Point Subdivision). Two years later he sold his remaining<br />

Tahoe property, the 125 acres that became the Round Hill Pines Resort, to Elizabeth Strom<br />

Lauder Kellum.<br />

During his ownership ofthe land, DeVaux constructed several buildings on his property,<br />

apparently as a summer residence and accommodations for guests. The lodge, the first<br />

structure to be erected on the site, was completed in 1922, with three guest cabins, a garage,<br />

wash house, gate house, and other amenities completed during his tenure (Koval 1991 : 1).<br />

The DeVaux family, including his wife Myrtle and daughter ofthe same name, also owned<br />

speedboats, the Apache I and Apache II, and possibly the Elan, two ofwhich were sold with<br />

the property (Koval 1991 :4). DeVaux also owned the Luders-built 52-foot Myrno III, placed<br />

in operation during the mid-1920s, and purchased by Arthur Bourne in 1930.<br />

Nonnan DeVaux, who arrived in the San Francisco Bay area by bicycle in 1896, began his<br />

career as an automobile mechanic. He soon became a car salesman, developing a pioneer<br />

Oakland automobile manufacturing business. By 1905 he was representing the Buick factory<br />

on the Pacific Coast, as well as handling the Auburn and Reo cars. He became a business<br />

associate ofWilliam C. Durant, and organized the Chevrolet Motor Company ofCalifornia<br />

for him. DeVaux and Cliff Durant, William's son, built the first automobile assembly plant<br />

in Oakland for Chevrolet, serving as president ofthe company until 1921.<br />

That same year DeVaux and Durant left Chevrolet to fonn the Durant Motor Company of<br />

California, producing Durant and Star automobiles. By 1928, the Oakland plant was<br />

producing 3,500 cars a month and employed 1,000 workers.<br />

In 1930 DeVaux, in collaboration with Colonel Elbert J. Hall, fonned a company to build an<br />

economy car and began manufacturing the DeVaux automobile in Michigan. The car was<br />

shown in automobile shows in New York and Chicago in early 1931, but the following<br />

11


'.<br />

January the partners were forced to declare bankruptcy, victims ofthe Depression that was<br />

sweeping the country. The Durant Motor Company also failed during the Depression, and<br />

although DeVaux remained in the industry during the 1930s, he never achieved any financial<br />

successes (Koval 1991 :4-5).<br />

Arthur K. Bourne. In 1931 the Round Hill Pines property was purchased from the Kellum<br />

estate by Arthur K. Bourne, a native ofNew York and one ofthe heirs to the Singer Sewing<br />

Machine Company. Included in the sale were the water rights and two boats, the Elan and<br />

the Myrno IlL renamedthe Reverie, eventually gifting her to the Lake Tahoe Coast Guard<br />

Auxiliary in 1956 (Scott 1957:437) .. The Bourne family, including William; his wife<br />

Alberta; sons Arthur K., Jr., John Gilbert, Stephen Howard, Douglas, and daughter Mrs.<br />

Victor Phillips, resided on the property during the summer months. A caretaker resided on<br />

the property full-time with his family.<br />

By 1931 the buildings on the site included the lodge, boathouse, pier, caretaker's house,<br />

menservants' quarters, maids' quarters, old gas house, old garage, ice house, laundry, and<br />

gate house. That same year a new highway was constructed passing the property, the<br />

original rQad moved, and a new gate house constructed. The following year the men's and<br />

maid's quarters were constructed, as well as a new dining room and kitchen for the servants.<br />

In 1935 a new powerhouse and tool shed were completed (Koval 1991 :8).<br />

The Bourne family'S primary residence was in Glendora, on a citrus ranch named Albourne<br />

Rancho, located near Pasadena. During his tenure on the land, Bourne purchased additional<br />

acreage at Lake Tahoe, eventually owning 800 acres in the basin. In 1943 he purchased a<br />

house in Reno, and in 1951 built a house one mile to the north and converted the summer<br />

place into a commercial resort (Koval 1991 :5-6).<br />

The Round Hill Pines Resort opened for the summer season in 1951, with Mrs. Pearl Stewart<br />

as hostess. Amenities at the resort included a beach terrace, heated pool, professional tennis<br />

court, badminton, tether ball, volleyball, fishing in Bourne Lake (east ofthe site), a driving<br />

range (in the meadow north ofthe site), a private beach and dock, and a boat slip rental.<br />

Motel units were constructed in 1956. By the summer of 1963, when the resort was operated<br />

by Stephen Bourne, the resort had increased to 30 units, including housekeeping cottages,<br />

and operated from June 15 to September 15 (Koval 1991:6).<br />

The resort continued in operation until 1969, when sewer improvements forced its closure.<br />

A casino development, proposed for the property in 1964, was denied by the Douglas Comity<br />

Planning Commission. The Round Hill residential development commenced the following<br />

year. In 1984 the property was purchased by the <strong>USDA</strong> National <strong>Forest</strong> <strong>Service</strong> for<br />

$8,950,000. Since that time, only the beach area ofthe resort has been used, leased to a<br />

concessionaire for day use (Koval 1991 :7).<br />

h. Designers, Engineers, and Builders<br />

Although it is unknown who designed or constructed the buildings at Round Hill Pines, they<br />

are characteristic ofSierra Nevada and Lake Tahoe vernacular architectural styles. Designed<br />

primarily by unknown builders and constructed with local materials, the buildings exhibit<br />

12


'.<br />

soon became the dominant building fonn in the timbered regions ofthe nation. The use of<br />

readily available soft woods - pine and fir - developed because the straight logs had smooth<br />

trunks that were easily cut, shaped, and carried. Logs were often left round, but were also<br />

hewn and stripped ofbark. Distinctive corner-notching styles were used by different ethnic<br />

groups. Chinking materials included mud, clay, wood, straw, shingles, wood chips, and<br />

stones. With its heavily forested areas oflarge stands ofpine and fir, the Tahoe Basin<br />

provided the materials for log buildings, their size limited only by the length ofavailable logs<br />

and the weight carried.<br />

Log structures were simple in plan and built initially upon a one-room unit, typically with<br />

two rooms up and two down, or four up and four down.<br />

Two major types ofhorizontally laid log construction were used. A framework ofroughly<br />

squared and notched logs was constructed and sometimes clad with shingles or clapboards.<br />

The Finns were famous for the precision ofthis method ofconstruction; their log buildings<br />

were not clad and didn't need chinking. The second method ofconstruction was round logs<br />

joined at the comers with overlapping saddle notches and chinked with clay or other<br />

materials to keep out the weather. Both types oflog construction can be found in the Tahoe<br />

Basin. The rough, round logs were jointed with a variety of fitted joints - saddle, square, V,<br />

half- and full-dovetail- and chinked with a variety ofcaulking mixes (Koval 1989:50-51).<br />

During the 1920s and 1930s, pre-manufactured half-log siding was used in many recreation<br />

residences to continue the log tradition without the work required in felling and peeling real<br />

logs. During this period rustic V-groove (or V -rustic) in pine or fir was used for trim and the<br />

upper gable walls on log buildings. Logs were also commonly used for porches, railings, and<br />

decorative framework for retaining walls and'trellises (<strong>USDA</strong> <strong>Forest</strong> <strong>Service</strong> 2001:63).<br />

In recent years many.residences in the Tahoe Basin have been constructed with large logs,<br />

often purchased in kits from Canadian or northwestern companies and assembled on site.<br />

These homes bear little resemblance to their predecessors, having several stories, multiple<br />

rooms, and elaborate architecture.<br />

Resort Rustic Buildings were constructed in the Tahoe Basin from the early 1900s through<br />

the 1940s. Deriveq from the Adirondack Rustic Style (1870-1930), the architecture was first<br />

developed in the Adirondack region ofupstate New York, where William West Durant,<br />

president ofthe Adirondack Railroad, developed the area for the well-to-do. Durant's<br />

architectural style used glorified log construction for rustic camps for America's upper class.<br />

The building complexes designed and built in this style were set on a lake or river against a<br />

background offorest and mountains. They were built ofreadily available natural materials in<br />

a local craft tradition. They are characterized by the use oflogs and indigenous stone,<br />

shingled roofs with broad overhangs and porches, and simply proportioned window and door<br />

openings. All ofthe features described above are also characteristic ofthe Resort Rustic style<br />

ofarchitecture found at Lake Tahoe; however, for the most part, the buildings constructed at<br />

Lake Tahoe were not built in the same grand scale as the great lodges in the Adirondacks.<br />

14


The Round Mountain Lodge, built in 1922, was constructed oflogs on a mortared stone<br />

foundation. A concrete terrace, facing Lake Tahoe, was also supported by a mortared stone<br />

retaining wall.<br />

The remainder ofthe buildings at Round Hill Pines, built in the 1920s and 1930s, were of<br />

balloon frame construction, with gabled shingle roofs, several supported with knee braces.<br />

Walls were clad in wood shingles or manufactured log siding. Doors are frame, with five<br />

horizontal panels or one light and three panels .. Fenestration consists primarily of 111 light<br />

frame sash, double-hung, although some are single light. Foundations are post on concrete<br />

pier or rock, with perimeter mudsills. Skirting beneath the buildings consists oflattice work.<br />

Most interior walls and ceilings are oftongue and groove, while the floors are wider tongue<br />

and groove Douglas fir. Kitchen floors and bathrooms have been covered with linoleum.<br />

c. Notable People<br />

The only notable people identified with the property were Norman de Vaux and Arthur K.<br />

Bourne. Their biographical information has been included in the Historic Overview, above.<br />

SURVEY RESULTS<br />

A visual inspection ofthe remnants ofthe Round Hill Pines Resort (Figure 3) resulted in the<br />

inventory and recordation of24 buildings constructed in the 1920s and 1930s, including<br />

utility buildings. In addition, three 1956 motel units, a stone gate and walls, and a brick oven<br />

were identified. One copy ofthe survey report and photographs have been archived with the<br />

<strong>USDA</strong> <strong>Forest</strong> <strong>Service</strong>, LTBMU; and another filed with the Nevada SHPO.<br />

For the purposes ofclarity, the buildings have been numbered according to the 1941<br />

Applegate Insurance Map (Figure 3); missing numbers in the sequence refer to structures that<br />

are no longer extant. The surveyed buildings included:<br />

No. Name CQnstructioniSiding Date Condition<br />

1. Lodge Log Structure 1922 Fair condition<br />

2. Office Frame, manufactured log 1920s Ruins<br />

3. Guest House Frame, shingled 1920s Poor condition<br />

4. Dining/Kitchen Frame, shingled 1932 Poor condition<br />

7. Diet Kitchen Frame, shingled 1932 Poor condition<br />

8. Toy House Frame, corrugated metal 1930s Poor condition<br />

9. New Guest House Frame,manumctured10g 1920s Fair condition<br />

10. Duplex Guest House Frame,manumctured10g 1920s Fair condition<br />

12. Cold Fruit Storage Frame, corrugated metal 1930s Fair condition<br />

13. Caretaker's House Frame, shingled 1920s Poor condition<br />

14. Garage & Laundry Frame, shingled 1920s Poor condition<br />

15. PowerHouse Frame, corrugated metal 1935 Fair condition<br />

17. Trailer Garage Frame, corrugated metal 1930s Fair condition<br />

21. Chicken House Frame, board and bat 1930s Ruins<br />

22. Garage Frame, corrugated metal 1930s Fair condition<br />

23. Boiler House Frame, corrugated metal 1935 Fair condition<br />

16


25. Gardener's House<br />

26. Employee's Cottage<br />

27. Employee's Cottage<br />

28. Employee's Cottage<br />

29. Employee's Cottage<br />

30. Gate House<br />

31. Garage<br />

XX. Gates/walls<br />

XX Root Cellar<br />

XX. Oven<br />

XX Motel Unit<br />

XX Motel Unit<br />

XX Motel Unit<br />

Frame, shingled<br />

Frame, shingled<br />

Frame, shingled<br />

Frame, shingled<br />

Frame, shingled<br />

Frame, shingled<br />

Frame, shingled<br />

Granite/concrete<br />

Frame, subterranean<br />

Brick and firebrick<br />

Frame, board '<br />

Frame, board<br />

Frame, board<br />

17<br />

1920s Poor condition<br />

1932 Ruins<br />

1932 Poor condition<br />

1932 Poor condition<br />

1920s Poor condition<br />

1920s Poor condition<br />

1 920s Poor condition<br />

1932 Good condition<br />

1930s Ruins<br />

1930s Ruins<br />

1956 Poor condition<br />

1956 Poor condition<br />

1956 Poor condition


Figure 3. Map ofBuildings in Round Hill Pines Resort, Applegate 1941.<br />

RECOMMENDATIONS<br />

a. <strong>Survey</strong> and Research Needs<br />

All the historic buildings within the Round Hill Pines Resort have been recorded and<br />

photographed.<br />

b. National Register Listing and Determination of Eligibility<br />

The Round Hill Pines Resort Complex was previously determined to be eligible for listing in<br />

the National Register ofHistoric Places under Criteria A and C (Alice Baldrica Letter,<br />

August 31, 1999; Appendix D).<br />

c. ·Threats to Resources<br />

Most ofthe resources are in poor or damaged conditions due to the vicissitudes oftime and<br />

weather, as well as vandalism. Some have been burned, while others have collapsed. Most<br />

ofthe shingled roofs on the buildings are so deteriorated that they provide no protection from<br />

the elements. Three ofthe remaining structures (office building, employee's cottage, and<br />

chicken house) are in ruins and pose a threat to the public.<br />

EVALUATIONS<br />

. Significance Criteria<br />

National Register of Historic Places. The objective ofthis investigation is to evaluate the<br />

continued eligibility ofthe resources for inclusion in the National Register ofHistoric Places<br />

(NRHP), and the Nevada Register ofHistoric Places, the standards for which are consistent<br />

with those developed by the National Park <strong>Service</strong> for listing properties on the NRHP. The<br />

evaluation allows the USFS Lake Tahoe Basin Management Unit to meet obligations of<br />

Section 106 ofthe National Historic Preservation Act of 1966 (16 USC 470), and procedures<br />

ofthe Advisory Council on Historic Preservation (36 CFR 800). Following the Secretary of<br />

the Interior's'Standards and Guidelines for evaluation, the resources were considered relative<br />

to the following NRHP eligibility criteria detailed in Title 36 CFR part 60.4:<br />

The quality of significance in American history, architecture, archaeology,<br />

engineering, and culture is present in districts, sites, buildings, structures, and objects<br />

that possess integrity oflocation, design, setting, materials, workmanship, feeling,<br />

and association, and:<br />

18


. Salvage ofArchitectural Elements:<br />

The LTBMU will remove selected architectural elements from the buildings prior to<br />

demolition to be reused in maintenance, repair, and other similar projects within Camp<br />

Richardson, Tallac Historic District, and other historic properties within the LTBMU. The<br />

LTBMU shall ensure that the items selected are removed in a manner that minimizes damage<br />

and stored at a location which is protected from weather, theft, and vandalism until the<br />

selected items are used .<br />

. c. Historic Context and Popular History<br />

The LTBMU will develop an appropriate historic context for the resort relative to early resort<br />

facilities within the Lake Tahoe Basin. A popular publication will be produced for public<br />

distribution that recounts the history ofthe Round Hill Pines Resort.<br />

j d. Rehabilitation and Preservation o(Representative Resources<br />

Following the Secretary ofthe Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation & Guidelinesfor<br />

Rehabilitating Historic Buildings (y./eeks and Grimmer 1995), the LTBMU will restore three<br />

buildings within the Round Hill Pines Resort: Lodge (No. 1.), New Guest House (No.2),<br />

and Duplex Guest House (No.3) for an appropriate use by the <strong>Forest</strong> <strong>Service</strong>, lessee, or the<br />

public.<br />

20


L<br />

REFERENCES CITED OR CONSULTED<br />

Applegate, Edwin V.<br />

1945 Round Hill, Residence ofArthur K. Bourne, Douglas County Nevada. Insurance<br />

Map. Scale 1 "=50'. Edwin V. Applegate Insurance, Los Angeles. California.<br />

Codega & Fricke, Inc.<br />

1992 Round Hill Feasibility Study. Prepared for State ofNevada Division ofState Parks<br />

by Codega & Fricke, Inc.<br />

Hoover, Mildred Brooke, Hero Eugene Rensch, Ethel Grace Rensch, and William N. Abe10e<br />

1966 Historic Spots in California. Third Edition. Stanford University Press, Stanford,<br />

California.<br />

James, George Wharton<br />

1915 The Lake ofthe Sky. Reprinted in 1992 by Nevada Publications, Las Vegas,<br />

Nevada.<br />

Koval, Ana B.<br />

1990 Historic Resources ofthe Nevada Side ofthe Tahoe Basin. Prepared for the Tahoe<br />

Regional Planning Agency by Alpengroup and Rainshadow Associates, Reno,<br />

Nevada.<br />

1991 Round Hill Resort, National Register ofHistoric Places Draft <strong>Report</strong>. On file,<br />

<strong>USDA</strong> <strong>Forest</strong> <strong>Service</strong>, South Lake Tahoe, California.<br />

Lekisch, Barbara<br />

1988 Tahoe Place Names, the Origin and History ofNames in the Lake Tahoe Basin.<br />

Great West Books, Lafayette.<br />

Lindstrom, Susan<br />

1993 A Cultural Resource Inventory ofthe GriffCreek Stream Reservoir and Stilling<br />

Basin Restoration Project, 7.5 Acres near Kings Beach, California, Placer County.<br />

Prepared for North Tahoe Public Utility District, Tahoe Vista, California, by Susan<br />

Lindstrom, Truckee, California.<br />

Marvin, Judith<br />

2000 Historic Resource Inventory and Historic Building Documentation ofthe Bliss<br />

Boathouse, 1951 Glenbrook Road, Glenbrook, Lake Tahoe, Nevada, Assessor's<br />

Parcel Numbers 01-151-01,01-070-16,01-070-17, TRPA File Number 921294.<br />

Prepared for Agan Consulting Corporation, Incline Village, Nevada, by Foothill<br />

Resources, Ltd., Murphys, California.<br />

Nevada, State of, Division ofHistoric Preservation and Archaeology<br />

2000 Nevada State Historic Preservation Office Historic Resources Inventory Fonn. On<br />

21


file, Nevada State Historic Preservation Office, Carson City, Nevada.<br />

n.d. Documentation Standards for Historical Resources ofLocal and State Significance.<br />

On file, Nevada State Historic Preservation Office, Carson City, Nevada.<br />

n.d State Historic Preservation Office Instructions for Conducting <strong>Intensive</strong> Level<br />

<strong>Survey</strong>s. On file, Nevada State Historic Preservation Office, Carson City, Nevada.<br />

Pacific Southwest Region, <strong>USDA</strong> <strong>Forest</strong> <strong>Service</strong><br />

2001 Strategy for Inventory and Historic Evaluation ofRecreation Residence Tracts in the<br />

National <strong>Forest</strong>s of California from 1906 to 1959. Heritage Program, <strong>USDA</strong> <strong>Forest</strong><br />

<strong>Service</strong>, Vallejo, California.<br />

Scott, Edward B.<br />

1957 The Saga ofLake Tahoe, Vol. I: A Complete Documentation ofLake Tahoe's<br />

Development Over the Last One Hundred Years.. Sierra-Tahoe Publishing Company,<br />

Crystal Bay, Lake Tahoe, Nevada.<br />

1973 The Saga ofLake Tahoe, Vol. II: A Definitive Pictorial Documentation ofLake<br />

Tahoe's Development Over the Last One Hundred and Twenty-five Years ..<br />

Sierra-Tahoe Publishing Company, Crystal Bay, Lake Tahoe, Nevada.<br />

Storer, Tracy I., and Robert L. Usinger<br />

1963 Sierra Nevada Natural History. University ofCalifornia Press, Berkeley.<br />

<strong>USDA</strong> <strong>Forest</strong> <strong>Service</strong><br />

1926 Eldorado National <strong>Forest</strong> (map).<br />

United States Geological <strong>Survey</strong><br />

1893 Markleeville Quadrangle, reprinted 1948.<br />

1914 El Dorado Quadrangle . .<br />

1956 Freel Peak Quadrangle.<br />

1992 South Lake Tahoe, CA-NV Quadrangle. 7.5 minute series.<br />

Von Leicht, and J. D. Hoffinan<br />

1874 Topographic Map ofLake Tahoe and Surrounding Area.<br />

Warriner, John, and Ricky Warriner<br />

1958 Lake Tahoe, An Illustrated Guide and History. Fearon Publishers, San Francisco.<br />

Weeks, Kay D., and Anne E. Grimmer<br />

1995 The Secretary ofthe Interior's Standards for the Treatment ofHistoric Properties<br />

with Guidelines for Preserving, Rehabilitating, Restoring & Reconstrocting Historic<br />

22<br />

"


Buildings. U.S. Department ofthe Interior, National Park <strong>Service</strong>, Cultural Resource<br />

Stewardship and Partnerships, Heritage Preservation <strong>Service</strong>s, Washington, D.C.<br />

Zauner, Phyllis<br />

1982 Lake Tahoe. Zanel Publications, Tahpe Paradise, California.<br />

23


APPENDIX A<br />

mSTORICAL RESOURCES INVENTORY FORMS


APPENDIXB<br />

PHOTOGRAPHS<br />

\


Jack Fulton, photographer<br />

February 27 and 28, 2002<br />

Number Facing<br />

l. east<br />

2. northeast<br />

3. south<br />

4. south<br />

5. north<br />

6. north<br />

7. west<br />

8. north<br />

HISTORIC BUILDING DOCUMENTATION<br />

INDEX TO PHOTOGRAPHS<br />

Round Hill Pines Resort<br />

Douglas County, Nevada<br />

Description<br />

overview, collapsed boathouse, from water<br />

lumber piles ofboathouse<br />

detail, board and batten siding<br />

detail, posts and lumber<br />

detail, siding, gable roof<br />

detail, bait boxes<br />

detail, beam, car track in water<br />

overview, collapsed boathouse on shore


APPENDIXC<br />

ROUND HILL RESORT TIME LINE


I '<br />

ROUND HILL RESORT TIME LINE<br />

. (Koval 1991:9)<br />

1864 John Marley purchased 160-acre property<br />

1870 Augustus Pray purchased property for back taxes<br />

1884 William McFaul purchased property<br />

1890s William McFaul sold "Round Mound" to Heinrich Dangberg<br />

1911 William McFaul aCquired the property from Dangberg Land & Livestock Company<br />

1913 William McFaul's family sold the property to Louis I. Cowgill<br />

1916 Property passed to Glen Cowgill<br />

1919 Property purchased by Norman DeVaux<br />

ca. 1922 Lodge building and first associated buildings constructed<br />

1929 Property purchased by Elizabeth Strom Lauder Kellum<br />

1931 Arthur K. Bourne purchased property from the Kellum estate<br />

The following buildings were extant: lodge, laundry, men servants' quarters, maids'<br />

quarters, old gas house, old garage, boat house (demolished), caretaker's house, ice<br />

house, pier, and gate house.<br />

1932 Mens' and maids' quarters constructed, also new dining room and kitchen for<br />

servants, and new gate and stone wall at entrance<br />

1935 New powerhouse and tool shed built<br />

1951 Round Hill Pines Resort opened, Bournes built a new summer home to north<br />

1956 Motel units constructed<br />

1964 Casino development proposed, Norman DeVaux dies<br />

1965 Round Hill residential development began<br />

1967 Arthur Bourne's death<br />

1973 Sewer hook up at Lake Tahoe<br />

1983 <strong>USDA</strong> <strong>Forest</strong> <strong>Service</strong> purchase

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!