WILDERNESS WATCH v. USFWS - Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals
WILDERNESS WATCH v. USFWS - Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals
WILDERNESS WATCH v. USFWS - Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
20328 <strong>WILDERNESS</strong> <strong>WATCH</strong> v. <strong>USFWS</strong><br />
U.S. SPORTSMEN’S ALLIANCE<br />
FOUNDATION; ARIZONA DESERT BIG<br />
HORN SHEEP SOCIETY; ARIZONA<br />
DEER ASSOCIATION; ARIZONA<br />
ANTELOPE ASSOCIATION;<br />
No. 08-17406<br />
FOUNDATION FOR NORTH AMERICAN D.C. No.<br />
WILD SHEEP; YUMA VALLEY ROD & 2:07-cv-01185-<br />
GUN CLUB, INC.; SAFARI CLUB MHM<br />
INTERNATIONAL; SAFARI CLUB<br />
INTERNATIONAL FOUNDATION;<br />
NATIONAL RIFLE ASSOCIATION; and<br />
STATE OF ARIZONA,<br />
Defendant-Intervenors-Appellees.<br />
OPINION<br />
Appeal from the United States District <strong>Court</strong><br />
for the District <strong>of</strong> Arizona<br />
Mary H. Murguia, District Judge, Presiding<br />
Argued and Submitted<br />
December 10, 2009—San Francisco, California<br />
Filed December 21, 2010<br />
Before: A. Wallace Tashima, Susan P. Graber, and<br />
Jay S. Bybee, <strong>Circuit</strong> Judges.<br />
Opinion by Judge Graber;<br />
Dissent by Judge Bybee
Change language