EURELECTRIC Annual Activity Report 2010
EURELECTRIC Annual Activity Report 2010
EURELECTRIC Annual Activity Report 2010
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> pursues in all its activities the application<br />
of the following sustainable development values:<br />
• Economic Development<br />
Growth, added-value, efficiency<br />
• Environmental Leadership<br />
Commitment, innovation, pro-activeness<br />
• Social Responsibility<br />
Transparency, ethics, accountability
“While recapping <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>’s achievements over the past year, the<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> <strong>Annual</strong> <strong>Report</strong> is also a distinctly forward-looking document,<br />
highlighting the policy and regulatory issues that will be relevant for the<br />
coming 12 months and beyond. Based on the European electricity sector’s<br />
past activities, as detailed in this report, I am confident that <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong><br />
will continue to actively contribute to the important debates at European<br />
level, be it on energy infrastructure, market integration, energy efficiency<br />
or climate. I look forward to that input and to future fruitful discussions<br />
between the European power industry and the European Commission.”<br />
Günther H. Oettinger<br />
European Commissioner for Energy<br />
1
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
Table of Contents<br />
4 electricity -<br />
the way<br />
forward<br />
2<br />
Interview with<br />
Lars Josefsson, Fulvio<br />
Conti, Johannes Teyssen<br />
and Hans ten Berge<br />
10 electricity issues –<br />
our work and what we stand for<br />
12 using all<br />
low-carbon<br />
options and<br />
technologies<br />
14 <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> Renewables<br />
Action Plan:<br />
A Comprehensive Strategy<br />
for the Road to 2020<br />
17 CCS<br />
18 Biomass Sustainability:<br />
Creating a Functioning<br />
Biomass Market<br />
19 Interview with Inge Pierre,<br />
Chairman of <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>’s WG Gas<br />
19 Nuclear<br />
20 well-functioning<br />
markets and<br />
market-based<br />
instruments<br />
22 Making the Most of Markets<br />
23 <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> report on<br />
regional market integration<br />
24 Interview with Marcel Cailliau,<br />
Chairman of the <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> Task Force<br />
on Integration of Renewables<br />
24 Integrating RES into the market<br />
25 What is changing in<br />
Energy Trading rules?<br />
26 Emissions trading:<br />
Implementing the third trading period
28 an increased<br />
and better use<br />
of electricity<br />
30 Smart Grids<br />
preparing electricity networks<br />
for the future<br />
32 Interview with Jan Peters,<br />
Chairman of the <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> DSOs<br />
Directors’ Gathering<br />
33 Energy efficiency<br />
34 Electric Vehicles – ensuring<br />
the necessary public charging<br />
infrastructure<br />
36 strong, reliable<br />
partnerships<br />
and framework<br />
conditions<br />
38 Electricity Social Dialogue:<br />
Supporting the Needs of Employees<br />
39 Identifying Financing Costs<br />
and Risks<br />
39 The Effects of the Financial Crisis<br />
40 ESDR report, Climate Change,<br />
Creosote, Health and Safety<br />
41 Cooperation beyond Europe:<br />
The International Electricity Summit<br />
41 Roadmap for a Low-Carbon<br />
Power Sector<br />
42 Industrial Emissions Directive:<br />
Delivering Input on Industrial<br />
Emissions Regulation<br />
43 spotlight on<br />
eurelectric:<br />
how we work<br />
44 <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> <strong>Annual</strong><br />
Convention and Conference<br />
48 <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> Award, Blog<br />
49 Ad for <strong>Annual</strong> Convention 2011<br />
50 Partner structure<br />
51 Partner in Focus:<br />
Interview with VGB<br />
52 Organisational and<br />
Expertise Structure<br />
54 <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> Staff<br />
55 List of Member Organisations<br />
58 Board of Directors<br />
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
3
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
<strong>2010</strong><br />
As <strong>2010</strong> draws to a close, we use the opportunity to reflect on last<br />
year’s achievements – and on the challenges ahead. An interview<br />
with <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> President Lars G. Josefsson, Vice-Presidents Fulvio<br />
Conti and Johannes Teyssen, and Secretary General Hans ten Berge.<br />
4<br />
2050
Lars G. Josefsson Fulvio Conti Johannes Teyssen Hans ten Berge<br />
Electricity - the way forward<br />
Looking back over the previous year, where do you think<br />
significant progress has been made – and where have<br />
you seen less progress than you had hoped?<br />
Josefsson: It has been a very interesting year: on the one<br />
hand we had the shadow of the economic crisis and the<br />
negative result for the global climate agreement in Copenhagen,<br />
but at the same time a new college of European<br />
Commissioners has started with an ambitious work plan.<br />
Looking at <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>’s achievements, I would<br />
highlight the Power Choices study as a definite positive.<br />
Following the energy sector’s declaration on carbon<br />
neutrality, Power Choices demonstrates that we can<br />
reach carbon-neutral power generation within the EU<br />
by 2050 – with market-based solutions and openness to<br />
all climate-efficient power generation possibilities. I am<br />
particularly pleased to see the positive responses to this<br />
study and that other strong stakeholders have presented<br />
similar studies with converging results.<br />
Conti: In my view Power Choices is relevant for two reasons:<br />
first, it is an effective contribution to the public debate<br />
on climate change, adding an element of pragmatism<br />
and realism to a discussion that is too often extremely<br />
ideological. Second, the study was well-received by the<br />
Commission. I really see it as a concrete instrument to<br />
shape our role towards our institutional stakeholders in<br />
the medium and long term. It is essential that <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong><br />
is able to express a realistic, long-term vision on what<br />
the energy sector will or shall be in the coming years.<br />
Teyssen: The main initiatives launched by the Commission<br />
like the Energy Strategy 2020 or the Infrastructure<br />
Package show that the Commissioner is determined to<br />
address the right issues after conducting an adequate<br />
review of the required measures. The strategy gives all<br />
low-carbon energies an opportunity. The challenge will<br />
be to set the right incentives and ensure its financing,<br />
notably for infrastructure. This will be crucial if we want<br />
to realise the change towards a low-carbon energy<br />
system at affordable costs.<br />
Ten Berge: In addition, I would like to mention the newly<br />
presented national renewable energy action plans, which<br />
clarify how member states aim to achieve the EU 2020<br />
target on renewables. This is a very welcome step. Yet<br />
two things strike me: the low importance of cooperation<br />
mechanisms within most plans and the little attention<br />
they pay to RES in heating and cooling. I would have liked<br />
to see the plans deliver more on both accounts.<br />
Josefsson: The national renewables plans are indeed<br />
a positive development, but the great need for investment<br />
in grid capacity as well as balancing power has not<br />
been highlighted clearly enough. If this is not taken into<br />
account, renewable electricity will not reach the customer.<br />
What about markets? Are you satisfied with the progress<br />
that has been achieved so far?<br />
Teyssen: I would have wished that, 12 years after initiating<br />
European energy market liberalisation, we were closer to<br />
a real common internal energy market. Instead, there is<br />
still need for action in a number of member states. The<br />
last few years have been characterised by stagnancy and<br />
even regression, i.e. growing interventions like specific<br />
taxes, subsidy regimes or price regulation. We would thus<br />
welcome the EU taking adequate remedies to ensure<br />
compliance with European law.<br />
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
5
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
6<br />
The economic crisis<br />
has slowed down the<br />
liberalisation process of the<br />
European electricity markets<br />
Lars G. Josefsson, President<br />
Although the electricity demand<br />
is slowly recovering, there are<br />
still only weak signals on the<br />
investments side<br />
Fulvio Conti, Vice-President<br />
Josefsson: To be fair, there has been some progress on<br />
market integration, for example the launch of Interim<br />
Tight Volume Coupling between the Nordic and the Central<br />
Western Europe regions in November <strong>2010</strong>. But indeed,<br />
I too would like to see stronger development. A merger<br />
between the Central West Europe (France, Germany and<br />
the Benelux countries) and the Nordic market would be<br />
a natural step for the EU. This would set a good example<br />
for the further regional development of the market.<br />
Conti: Generally speaking, we cannot stress enough the<br />
importance of market integration and moving towards<br />
a single energy market in line with the provisions of the<br />
Third Package. As a prerequisite, we have to ensure that<br />
market zones are compatible. We should therefore start<br />
with the effective harmonisation of market conditions,<br />
for example unbundling conditions, regulators’ powers or<br />
levels of subsidies and regulated prices.<br />
Ten Berge: We need strong leadership from the European<br />
Commission regarding markets, especially regarding the<br />
integration of day-ahead and intraday markets. I think<br />
there is more scope for the EU here, and would certainly<br />
like to see the EU play a more active role in this regard.<br />
Let’s move from the present to the future. What are the<br />
main issues that the European electricity industry will<br />
need to address in 2011?<br />
Conti: Coping with the increasing penetration of<br />
intermittent renewable energy is undoubtedly one issue<br />
that will need to be addressed. Integrating renewables
will require a careful management of the mix of regulatory<br />
policies and the level of regional integration. It also calls<br />
for boosting the development of smart grids and<br />
evaluating and/or introducing reliable mechanisms for<br />
capacity remuneration. Capacity remuneration will help<br />
back-up conventional plants to cope with decreasing<br />
load factors, while they continue to perform their<br />
essential role in ensuring the proper functioning and<br />
security of the system.<br />
Teyssen: One of the main political debates will address<br />
the question on how to shape a policy that provides a<br />
market-compatible set of rules enabling full market<br />
integration of renewables whilst managing intermittency<br />
and volatility. We should avoid further interventions<br />
in existing markets since this has proven to lead to<br />
considerable market distortions.<br />
Personally, I believe we should ensure coordinated<br />
renewables support schemes on a European level. These<br />
will have a big positive impact on cost efficiency. In addition<br />
to the domestic support schemes, imports of renewable<br />
electricity from third countries should be allowed if they<br />
offer favourable locations. This issue should be subject to<br />
discussion at the European Council dedicated to energy<br />
in February 2011.<br />
Ten Berge: I think we all agree that smart grids will<br />
become more important. There is a definite need to take<br />
the next step in the development of smart grids: defining<br />
the basic functionalities, testing them, bringing forward<br />
good examples... They will also allow us to use electricity<br />
more wisely.<br />
Using electricity more wisely can also be supported by<br />
improved energy efficiency. In your opinion, what role will<br />
energy efficiency measures play in the coming months?<br />
Josefsson: The EU action plan on energy efficiency is<br />
planned for the beginning of 2011. Here I would like to see<br />
strong support from the Commission, especially regarding<br />
electrifying the transport sector and the heating and<br />
cooling of buildings. This will also have a very positive<br />
effect on decreasing CO 2 emissions.<br />
Conti: We should focus on promoting energy efficiency<br />
through the electrification of transport and of thermal<br />
uses, both in residential and industrial sectors. Thanks to<br />
major investments, the power sector has achieved quite<br />
some progress on energy efficiency, especially compared<br />
to other industries. Now we must actively contribute to<br />
shaping the proper policy and regulatory measures.<br />
Josefsson: Nevertheless, we should not forget the many<br />
other challenges for 2011. For instance, the economic<br />
crisis has slowed down the liberalisation process of<br />
the European electricity markets. There are still a lot of<br />
customers with regulated electricity prices.<br />
I would also like to see an acceleration of the licensing<br />
procedures for new transmission capacity, and further<br />
financing and strengthening of ACER, the Agency for the<br />
Cooperation of Energy Regulators, regarding cross-border<br />
transmission lines. And I would like to see sustainable<br />
biomass criteria being brought forward in 2012, when the<br />
Commission is reviewing this possibility.<br />
Ten Berge: In addition, I see the need for more progress<br />
on carbon capture and storage (CCS), especially in light<br />
of its crucial role for carbon-neutral electricity. The success<br />
of CCS depends largely on strong support from the national<br />
and regional levels. The EU’s demonstration programme<br />
will have a big role to play as well.<br />
Mr Josefsson, you briefly touched upon the economic<br />
crisis and its negative effect on the deregulation process.<br />
I would like to put this question to all of you: what has<br />
been the impact of the financial and economic crisis – and<br />
how will this impact make itself felt in the coming year?<br />
Conti: A very relevant effect is the decrease of energy demand<br />
as a consequence of the massive downturn of economic<br />
activity. Although the electricity demand is slowly recovering,<br />
there are still only weak signals on the investments side, due<br />
to recovery and policy uncertainties on the financing side.<br />
The lack of investments in new energy infrastructures may<br />
endanger not only the competitiveness of the European<br />
industry in the long run, but also the security of energy<br />
supply across Europe. Working to facilitate and promote<br />
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
7
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
8<br />
new investments in energy infrastructure should therefore<br />
be a priority for all the relevant stakeholders – governments,<br />
the European Commission, utilities, and banks.<br />
Teyssen: The economic and financial slump has indeed<br />
led to a substantial decrease of energy demand. This has<br />
actually had some positive impacts, for instance lower<br />
CO 2 emissions and reduced wholesale prices. However,<br />
we should not only focus on the short-term impact. In the<br />
long run the financing abilities of energy companies are<br />
key if we are to achieve the transformation of the energy<br />
system – a transformation that will require massive<br />
investments in the next decades.<br />
Josefsson: As mentioned earlier, the crisis has certainly<br />
resulted in a more national and competition driven focus,<br />
slowing down the liberalisation of the electricity markets<br />
and market integration. It also had a negative impact<br />
when trying to reach a global climate agreement.<br />
As a direct result of the economic crisis we have seen a<br />
greater focus on the regulation of the financial sector.<br />
I would like to reiterate that there are fundamental<br />
differences between the energy and finance sectors:<br />
energy companies use derivatives mainly to manage<br />
their exposure in the physical energy markets and<br />
thus pose no systemic risk. It is therefore important to<br />
handle the energy sector separately.<br />
EU Energy Commissioner Günther Oettinger has now been<br />
in office for almost a year. What key piece of advice would<br />
you give him for the rest of his mandate?<br />
Josefsson: The Commissioner has started out in the<br />
right direction and I would like to see him continue with<br />
a strong focus on ensuring wholesale market integration,<br />
thus advancing the well-functioning common electricity<br />
market that Europe really needs.<br />
During the last half year the Commissioner has highlighted<br />
the importance of harmonised EU support for renewables.<br />
I would like to see the Commissioner follow up on this<br />
by bringing forward a proposal on a harmonised support<br />
scheme for renewable energy.<br />
I would also call on the Commissioner to further strengthen<br />
the EU Emission Trading System as the core of the<br />
European climate policy, in particular by taking steps to<br />
bring further sectors into the system as well as expanding<br />
the system geographically.<br />
Ten Berge: Both energy efficiency and smart grids have<br />
already been mentioned, but they really cannot be<br />
stressed enough. Individuals and businesses still do not<br />
invest enough in energy efficiency measures. A critical<br />
and immediate task for policymakers would therefore be<br />
to develop regulatory, fiscal and informational tools that<br />
will overcome these blockages to mass investment in<br />
demand-side measures.<br />
Smart grids will need more support as well. The Commission<br />
has recognised their importance, but there is still some<br />
way to go in defining the basic functionalities of smart<br />
grids and analysing whom they will benefit and how.<br />
Conti: In my mind, the most relevant issues to be<br />
addressed are the rebalancing of the fuel mix and the<br />
financing of R&D. Renewable energy will play a fundamental<br />
role for a low-carbon energy mix, but it cannot be the<br />
silver bullet. We need a wide spectrum of complementary<br />
technologies, sources and approaches: energy efficiency<br />
measures, CCS, nuclear. In this context, clear support<br />
from the EU, while respecting the right of every country to<br />
determine its own energy mix, would be especially effective.<br />
The Nuclear Waste Directive is a first good example.<br />
As for R&D, the Commission can efficiently assist the<br />
private sector by increasing the EU budgets devoted<br />
to R&D, stimulating banks and financial institutions to<br />
facilitate investments in new technologies. The private<br />
sector is already increasing its own R&D budget, but it<br />
is essential to reduce the associated risks and costs, not<br />
least by setting up a stable and transparent regulatory<br />
framework that allows for the deployment of the new<br />
technology once the pilot stage has been successfully<br />
completed. I am thinking in particular of CCS.<br />
Josefsson: The coming years really will be critical for a<br />
successful development of CCS. Besides going forward with
Energy could prove to be<br />
the opportunity to give the<br />
European idea new impetus<br />
Dr. Johannes Teyssen, Vice-President<br />
Individuals and businesses still<br />
do not invest enough in energy<br />
efficiency measures<br />
Hans Ten Berge, Secretary General<br />
the demonstration plants and the financial funding, there is<br />
a great need to support the development on infrastructure<br />
and storage, not least regarding public acceptance.<br />
Teyssen: I agree. Public acceptance is key for any large<br />
infrastructure project like grid extension and modification<br />
as well as the building of new power plants. We cannot<br />
afford NIMBY or NUMBY (not under my backyard)<br />
attitudes if we want to make the change happen.<br />
Overall, however, I would like to congratulate the<br />
Commissioner on the Energy Strategy 2020. It is not a new or<br />
“revolutionary” programme, but it is consistent and provides<br />
a set of reliable measures for reaching the 20-20-20 goals<br />
in a pragmatic and efficient way. Energy could prove to be<br />
the opportunity to give the European idea new impetus.<br />
Ten Berge: The Commission is currently very active in<br />
terms of European energy policy: apart from its Energy<br />
Strategy for 2020, there is a new Infrastructure Package and<br />
three planned roadmaps on low-carbon energy, economy<br />
and transport, as well as the upcoming Energy Efficiency<br />
Action Plan. I thus expect the European Council on energy<br />
in February 2011 to provide new impetus on energy and<br />
climate issues.<br />
Over the past year Commissioner Oettinger has been in<br />
close dialogue with the electricity sector’s CEOs, not least<br />
on <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>’s latest publication, 20 Steps Towards<br />
2020, which sets out concrete measures needed for a<br />
carbon-neutral, secure and integrated European electricity<br />
market. I very much welcome this dialogue and believe that it<br />
provides a solid foundation for our work in 2011 and beyond.<br />
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
9
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
ElEcTrIcITy IssuEs -<br />
our work And whAT<br />
wE sTAnd for<br />
10<br />
Electricity remains a cornerstone of the European economy. Since 1980, demand for elec tricity<br />
has steadily increased – a trend that is projected to continue in the coming decades.<br />
As the Union of the European Electricity Industry, <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> is continuously striving to<br />
ensure the right framework conditions that allow the European power sector to fulfil the demand<br />
for a secure, market-based and low-carbon electricity supply. Confronting head-on the important<br />
challenges we face, we have not only declared our goal of achieving carbon-neutral electricity<br />
by 2050, but have subsequently shown through our Power Choices study that this goal is<br />
technically and economically feasible. The <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> publication 20 Steps Towards 2020,<br />
presented to EU Energy Commissioner Günther Oettinger in September <strong>2010</strong>, outlines the twenty<br />
concrete measures needed for the European electricity sector to fulfil this commitment and turn<br />
our vision of a carbon-neutral, secure and integrated European electricity market into reality.<br />
Promoting integrated markets, low-carbon technologies, strong partnerships, and a more<br />
intelligent use of electricity are just some of the measures that will contribute to achieving our<br />
objective. The following pages present a cross section of <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>’s varied activities in <strong>2010</strong><br />
and paint a first picture of the initiatives we can expect for the upcoming months and beyond.
using all low-carbon options<br />
and technologies<br />
Page 12<br />
well-functioning markets and<br />
market-based instruments<br />
Page 20<br />
an increased and better<br />
use of electricity<br />
Page 28<br />
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
strong, reliable partnerships<br />
and framework conditions<br />
Page 36<br />
11
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
usIng All low-<br />
cArbon opTIons<br />
And TEchnologIEs<br />
12<br />
Electricity in Europe is generated by the entire range of power generation<br />
technologies, from renewable energy sources (RES) and nuclear to fossil<br />
fuels such as gas, as demonstrated in our latest statistical report<br />
(see figure below).* Developing this diversified mix further will be crucial<br />
to ensure security of supply and to achieve an optimal balance between<br />
intermittent RES and flexible and back-up capacity from conventional<br />
generation sources. <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> working groups are analysing how<br />
various interrelated technologies can be deployed cost-efficiently in line<br />
with market requirements and the drive towards decarbonisation.<br />
Installed Capacity in 2008<br />
Other Renewables<br />
11%<br />
Hydro<br />
17%<br />
Not Specified<br />
0%<br />
Nuclear<br />
16%<br />
Fossil Fuel Fired<br />
56%<br />
Electricity Generation in 2008<br />
Other Renewables<br />
7%<br />
Hydro<br />
11%<br />
Not Specified<br />
1%<br />
Nuclear<br />
28%<br />
Fossil Fuel Fired<br />
53%<br />
* All figures and tables in this report are taken from the <strong>2010</strong> edition of <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>’s statistical yearbook, Power Statistics,<br />
which can be downloaded at http://www.eurelectric.org/PowerStats<strong>2010</strong>/KeyDocuments.asp.
Eurelectric Renewables<br />
Action Plan<br />
How <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> is addressing<br />
the multiple challenges of RES<br />
Page 14<br />
CCS<br />
An overview of the latest policy developments<br />
and <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> contributions<br />
Page 17<br />
Biomass Sustainability<br />
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
Highlights<br />
Creating a functioning biomass market<br />
has become the focus of <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>’s<br />
Task Force Biomass<br />
Page 18<br />
13
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
EurElEcTrIc rEnEwAblEs<br />
AcTIon plAn:<br />
A comprEhEnsIvE sTrATEgy<br />
for ThE roAd To 2020<br />
14<br />
As an integral component of a<br />
low-carbon future, renewable<br />
energy sources (RES) remain<br />
high on the agenda, both at the EU level and within<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> itself. Work is currently underway on a new<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> renewables strategy, which aims to clarify<br />
the implications of increasing RES shares for networks,<br />
generation, markets, competition, environmental integrity<br />
and sustainability.
Following a flurry of legislative activity and lobbying<br />
in the first half of 2009 in agreeing the Renewables<br />
Directive, <strong>2010</strong> was a year to take stock and look at<br />
the implications of the EU’s ambitious 2020 target<br />
for renewables. In reaction to this, <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong><br />
launched its own “Renewables Action Plan”<br />
(RESAP) in spring <strong>2010</strong>. The purpose: to develop a<br />
comprehensive industry strategy on renewables,<br />
setting the requirements for ensuring that the 2020<br />
targets are feasible, economically sound and do not<br />
threaten system security. The Action Plan has also been<br />
developed in recognition of the industry’s commitment<br />
to renewables in the longer term, as indicated by<br />
the strong role of renewables in the 2050 scenarios<br />
developed by the <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> Power Choices<br />
project. The plan is developed around four main<br />
blocks: networks, generation, markets, and competitive<br />
and sustainable renewables (see separate box).<br />
Each block of the Action Plan encompasses a series of<br />
specific tasks, most of which will lead to an individual<br />
report. In turn, these reports will be incorporated into a<br />
comprehensive renewables strategy document in June<br />
2011, and will provide input for a final overarching RESAP<br />
conference in autumn 2011. Each of the individual tasks<br />
is led by a <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> working group, co-ordinating<br />
with a defined number of working groups.<br />
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
RESAP contains four main blocks:<br />
Networks This block considers the network expansion<br />
needed to transmit renewables, and the needs for smart<br />
grids to support intermittent renewables.<br />
Generation This section looks at creating a stable<br />
investment climate for RES and the needs for flexible<br />
back-up capacity to support renewables. It also includes a<br />
task on considering the necessary development of a greatly<br />
expanded biomass market to support the 2020 targets.<br />
Markets The markets segment considers the challenges<br />
to the functioning of markets when integrating a high<br />
level of renewables and possible required adjustments<br />
to market design.<br />
Competitive & Sustainable RES This block encompasses<br />
an analysis of the EU member states’ national<br />
action plans (see box on following page) and a push<br />
for use of joint projects and other cooperation<br />
mechanisms. Accompanying studies on the feasibility<br />
of RES action plans seems appropriate. It also includes<br />
a task on the R&D needs for renewables and assessment<br />
of the life-cycle impact of RES technologies.<br />
15
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
National Renewable Energy Action Plans<br />
The 2009 Renewables Directive demanded that member states<br />
provide national plans on how they would reach their individually<br />
defined renewables target for 2020. These plans must be based on a<br />
template issued by the European Commission in mid-2009, in which<br />
they have to enter, technology by technology and year by year, the<br />
quantity of RES production that the member state intends to develop<br />
to 2020. The plan also contains a qualitative part, in which the<br />
member state has to enter the policy measures it intends to use to<br />
achieve the stated growth in renewables.<br />
The national action plans were due to be submitted by the end of<br />
June <strong>2010</strong>. However, only three plans were submitted by this date.<br />
By December, 26 out of the total 27 plans had been submitted. An<br />
initial reading shows the plans to be of widely differing quality.<br />
Many plans contain no additional policy measures to those<br />
already in place, despite proposing unprecedented growth. Few<br />
countries appear to have based their numbers on modelling the<br />
economically optimal RES mix to reach the target – indeed rather<br />
few plans refer to detailed background analysis carried out in<br />
preparing the plans.<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> is currently engaged in a detailed analysis of the plans,<br />
and expects to take a view on their feasibility, coherence and economic<br />
implications in the near future, not least within its broader RESAP<br />
ambitions (see main article).<br />
16<br />
In addition, the RESAP is supported by two newly<br />
created groups: a broad steering committee composed<br />
of the chairs from each of the involved working groups<br />
and meeting only at the beginning and towards<br />
the end of the project; and a “RESAP co-ordination<br />
group”, which will meet much more frequently and<br />
is responsible for ensuring coherence and the timely<br />
delivery of the plan. The co-ordination group brings<br />
together two representatives from each <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong><br />
committee, one representative from <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>’s<br />
partner association VGB, and four advisers from<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>’s secretariat, each responsible for one<br />
of the four blocks.<br />
The need for the RESAP as a constructive sector-wide<br />
approach towards the 2020 renewables targets was<br />
emphasised by co-ordination group chair Oluf Ulseth,<br />
Vice-Chair of the <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> Energy Policy &<br />
Generation Committee and upcoming Managing<br />
Director of the Norwegian electricity industry<br />
association Energy Norway. “There is a need for a<br />
massive increase in renewables to meet the longterm<br />
challenges ahead, where the electricity industry<br />
will play a vital role in reaching the 2020 targets.<br />
We are ready to rise to the challenge,” Mr Ulseth<br />
declared. The RESAP would allow <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> to<br />
lay out “what is needed to make the 2020 target<br />
deliverable”, including fundamental changes to<br />
networks, markets and support systems. “We are<br />
ready – but the political framework is not yet<br />
complete,” concluded Mr Ulseth.
CCS<br />
Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS) remained a hot topic on<br />
the European political agenda in <strong>2010</strong>, with a raft of important<br />
decisions taken to maintain and beef up Europe’s leadership<br />
in the field. An overview of the latest significant policy<br />
developments and <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> contributions.<br />
Fine-tuning European legislation<br />
Whilst transposition of Directive 2009/31 (“CCS Directive”)<br />
was still pending in most European Union member<br />
states, the European Commission carried out a selected<br />
stakeholder consultation on four “Guidance Documents”<br />
meant to pave the way to a harmonised implementation of<br />
the EU legislation throughout Europe. Despite applauding<br />
the Commission’s intentions, <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> assessed that<br />
the consultation documents failed to recognise, in the long<br />
term and once commercially available, the fundamental<br />
role of CCS in combating climate change by contributing to<br />
carbon-neutral power generation. Instead, <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong><br />
warned, they stipulated an unnecessary trade-off between<br />
public awareness/acceptance of CCS and operators’<br />
liability, ultimately forcing project developers to bear an<br />
open-ended liability that could prove counterproductive<br />
to the development of CCS itself. Taking a pro-active<br />
stand, <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> argued that appropriate mechanisms<br />
should favour risk-sharing between project developers<br />
and member states, so as to give investors in the CCS<br />
chain a stable, predictable and supportive framework<br />
to build up and operate their installations.<br />
Financing CCS<br />
Building upon last year’s work, <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> has<br />
been closely following the developments of the CCS<br />
demonstration funding programme in <strong>2010</strong>. It produced<br />
several papers with the aim of facilitating political<br />
agreement on a technically and economically sound,<br />
European-wide scheme known as New Entrants Reserve<br />
(or NER300): a funding tool to keep the momentum on CCS<br />
and, most importantly, master the development of ten<br />
to twelve demonstration plants by 2015. An agreement<br />
on the NER300 was eventually struck between EU member<br />
state representatives in February <strong>2010</strong>. During the<br />
scheme’s first phase, EU funds, covering up to 50% of<br />
eligible project costs, will allow companies to draw up<br />
proposals for financing eight large-scale, integrated<br />
CCS demonstration projects, as well as 34 renewable<br />
energy projects. Backed by the respective national<br />
governments, the applicants will have to be evaluated<br />
by the European Investment Bank (EIB). The EIB will also<br />
be responsible for selling the 300 million allowances<br />
set aside under the Emission Trading Scheme (EU-ETS),<br />
and for disbursing the money to approved projects.<br />
Boosting pan-European CO 2 networks<br />
While the European Commission was tweaking its Energy<br />
Infrastructure Package, <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> adopted a raft of<br />
recommendations on the inclusion of pan-European CO 2<br />
transportation networks in the new EU infrastructure<br />
instrument. Highlighting evidence from its forward-looking<br />
Power Choices study, <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> argued that the<br />
scaling-up of CCS was likely to require a change in carbon<br />
dioxide transportation, from current point-to-point networks<br />
to hub-and-spoke networks and eventually, through regional<br />
clusters, to EU-wide networks. Not only would this drive<br />
down transport costs and improve cost-efficiency; it<br />
would also ensure the market-oriented transportation<br />
of CO 2 , for example granting third party access.<br />
Next steps<br />
2011 will be a crucial<br />
year for the implementation<br />
of the EU’s CCS demonstration<br />
programme, in particular<br />
regarding developments on<br />
the NER 300 and the ongoing<br />
work in the framework of the<br />
European Energy Programme<br />
for Recovery (EEPR).<br />
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> will also<br />
assess the role granted<br />
to CCS within the European<br />
Commission’s new overarching<br />
strategy papers, i.e. the Energy<br />
Strategy 2011-2020 and the<br />
Roadmap 2050.<br />
17
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
Biomass Sustainability:<br />
Creating a Functioning Biomass Market<br />
Biomass is a lynchpin of the EU’s renewables targets for 2020.<br />
Recognising the huge expansion in biomass power generation<br />
needed to reach those targets, <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> created a Task Force<br />
on Biomass, which met for the first time in autumn 2009. One<br />
of the group’s key tasks for <strong>2010</strong> lay in addressing the topic of<br />
biomass sustainability.<br />
18<br />
While the European Commission’s 2009 Renewables<br />
Directive set down guidelines for mandatory<br />
sustainability criteria for liquid biofuels, it deferred a<br />
decision on criteria for solid and gaseous biomass to<br />
a later report. Released at the end of February <strong>2010</strong>,<br />
this report did not suggest guidelines for mandatory<br />
EU-wide sustainability criteria, but recommended<br />
instead some voluntary guidelines for member<br />
states who wished to put their own sustainability<br />
requirements in place.<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>’s TF Biomass issued a response in<br />
May <strong>2010</strong>, which also addressed the wider issue of<br />
sustainability criteria in view of the massive biomass<br />
growth needed to meet the 2020 renewables targets.<br />
While agreeing with the Commission that the existing<br />
legislation provided reasonable guarantees for<br />
most biomass currently produced within the EU,<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> argued that the expected massive<br />
growth in biomass generation meant an increasing<br />
proportion of biomass would be imported. Given<br />
significant sustainability concerns about biomass<br />
produced outside the EU, mandatory harmonised<br />
EU-wide criteria should be rapidly put in place,<br />
thereby avoiding a situation in which member states<br />
lay down their own criteria, which may or may not<br />
follow the EU’s voluntary guidelines.<br />
Commenting on the report, Jeppe Bjerg, Senior<br />
Innovation Manager at DONG Energy and Chairman of<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>’s TF Biomass, emphasised the role of<br />
mandatory harmonised criteria in averting a fragmented,<br />
inefficient EU biomass market. “Common EU rules for<br />
biomass sustainability criteria are needed to facilitate<br />
an efficiently functioning biomass market and provide<br />
assurance that biomass procured for large-scale power<br />
production does not harm the environment. The criteria<br />
will be crucial to provide a level playing field and the<br />
necessary certainty for investors in biomass plants, while<br />
ensuring sustainable biomass supply grows sufficiently<br />
to reach the EU 2020 renewables targets,” stated<br />
Mr Bjerg.<br />
The EU plans to re-visit the question of mandatory<br />
criteria in another report by the end of 2011. Meanwhile,<br />
the TF Biomass is working further on biomass<br />
sustainability as part of a more detailed report on<br />
biomass market development, expected for mid-2011.
A year of dynamic developments concerning<br />
gas lies behind us. But unexpected<br />
generation developments as well as<br />
renewed efforts from the European<br />
Commission and regulators may make<br />
for an even more interesting year 2011,<br />
says Inge Pierre, Head of European<br />
Affairs at SvenskEnergi and Chairman of<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>’s WG Gas.<br />
Gas has become much more prominent in<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>’s overall strategy in recent years.<br />
How would you explain this trend?<br />
Natural gas has a particular strength: it is the cleanest of<br />
all fossil fuels, its emissions being roughly half of those of<br />
coal when used in power generation. The ‘dash for gas’<br />
experienced across Europe in the 1990s is not yet over,<br />
as electrical companies strive to reduce their emissions.<br />
In addition, natural gas will have a fundamental role to<br />
play in flexibly backing up the intermittency of renewable<br />
generation in the near future.<br />
Nuclear<br />
<strong>2010</strong> has been an important year for nuclear in Europe:<br />
several countries announced plans for new nuclear<br />
capacity, while others extended the lifetime of their<br />
nuclear installations.<br />
Nuclear-related aspects featured prominently in<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>’s activities throughout the year. The board<br />
meeting in June saw a debate on the strategic role of<br />
nuclear in a low-carbon electricity system up to 2050,<br />
including challenges related to nuclear development<br />
such as financing, waste management, and public<br />
acceptance. While concluding that nuclear will continue<br />
to contribute significantly to electricity generation, the<br />
debate thus also highlighted areas which will need<br />
interview<br />
Natural gas is fundamental<br />
for the integration of renewables<br />
Could you expand a bit on this last point?<br />
We are currently witnessing a tremendous growth<br />
in the installed capacity of renewables, primarily<br />
biomass, wind power and solar power (i.e. photovoltaics).<br />
But the last two technologies have one main setback:<br />
they are intermittent and not fully dispatchable, i.e.<br />
may not be available to produce electricity in times of<br />
higher demand. Natural gas fired plants, which enjoy<br />
quite a good degree of technical flexibility, would thus<br />
have to complement renewables, ultimately contributing<br />
to their integration into the electricity markets and<br />
systems.<br />
What about the role of the European institutions<br />
with regard to gas? Do you expect any important<br />
regulatory activities in the coming year?<br />
During the last session of the Madrid Forum, different<br />
stakeholders took part in preliminary, explanatory<br />
discussions on the development of a ‘target model’<br />
for the integration of the currently fragmented gas<br />
markets. <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> is deeply engaged in making<br />
this a success story on the electricity side. We hope to<br />
share our experience and are ready to engage in detailed<br />
discussions with all stakeholders, from European<br />
institutions to trade associations.<br />
to be addressed in more detail to allow for nuclear<br />
development.<br />
In the course of <strong>2010</strong> <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> has been an active voice<br />
in the working formats of the European Nuclear Energy Forum<br />
(ENEF). In particular, we have contributed to analysing the<br />
future role of nuclear in various electricity mix scenarios.<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> has also been closely following the<br />
agenda of the European Commission on nuclear matters,<br />
particularly the legislative proposal on management of<br />
spent fuel and radioactive waste, published in November<br />
<strong>2010</strong>. Nuclear will therefore remain very much at the<br />
forefront of our activities in 2011.<br />
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
19
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
wEll-funcTIonIng<br />
mArkETs And mArkETbAsEd<br />
InsTrumEnTs<br />
20<br />
The European electricity industry is investing significantly in ‘new’ RES<br />
(mainly wind, solar and biomass), whose capacity in 2008 was almost<br />
60 times the capacity in 1980. But to make the most of this capacity, an<br />
integrated European electricity market is needed, allowing the power<br />
sector to deliver in an optimal way – carbon-neutral, commercially viable,<br />
at affordable prices. Convinced of the merits of well-functioning markets,<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> fully supports the use of market-based instruments,<br />
including the EU Emissions Trading System (EU ETS).<br />
Generating capacity in the EU-27 in 2009 compared to 2008 and 2007 (MW)<br />
2007 2008 2009 2008/2007 2009/2008<br />
Nuclear 132,855 132,882 132,876 27 -6<br />
Conventional Thermal 436,464 446,936 456,967 10,472 10,031<br />
Hydro 140,894 141,788 142,617 893 829<br />
Other RES 77,983 93,342 107,491 15,359 14,149<br />
of which Wind 55,394 63,611 74,335 8,217 10,724<br />
Total 791,233 815,515 841,732 24,282 26,217<br />
Source: <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> Power Statistics <strong>2010</strong>
Making the Most of Markets<br />
An overview of the main issues at stake<br />
Page 22<br />
Energy trading rules<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> reactions to the latest<br />
European policy initiatives<br />
Page 25<br />
Emissions Trading<br />
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
Highlights<br />
Fleshing out the modalities of the third EU<br />
ETS trading period<br />
Page 26<br />
21
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
mAkIng ThE mosT<br />
of mArkETs<br />
22<br />
Ensuring well-functioning markets<br />
is at the very core of <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>’s<br />
activities, and represents an ongoing challenge amid the constantly<br />
evolving European economy and regulatory framework. Main issues at<br />
stake include the integration of wholesale markets and the convergence of<br />
retail markets, the integration of renewable energy sources (RES) into the<br />
grid, and the development of a regional electricity market in cooperation<br />
with neighbouring non-EU countries.<br />
Integration of wholesale markets has gained further<br />
momentum in <strong>2010</strong>, with progress made through a<br />
continued stakeholders’ dialogue on the cooperation<br />
between transmission system operators and power<br />
exchanges. The discussion helped to identify the<br />
blueprint of a centralised interface for price coupling<br />
and continuous intraday trading, to be implemented<br />
in a core market of the Central Western Europe and<br />
Nordic regions, to which neighbouring countries or<br />
regions should link up over time. With the details<br />
still under discussion, <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> is building up<br />
pressure for a concrete proposal in order to pave<br />
the way for first implementation steps in the course<br />
of 2011. The progress made should also serve as a basis<br />
for the related framework guidelines and network codes,<br />
and for the coordination of work programmes across<br />
the seven ERGEG regional initiatives for electricity.<br />
Greater attention is also being paid to the contribution<br />
that integrated and well-functioning markets will<br />
make in accommodating large volumes of intermittent<br />
electricity generation, particularly from renewable<br />
energy sources such as wind and solar. <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong><br />
has repeatedly stressed the need for prompt planning
and execution of grid investments to match EU member<br />
states’ estimated RES targets (see interview on p. 24).<br />
In anticipation of RES becoming competitive and the<br />
carbon price acting as the sole driver for policies to<br />
reduce greenhouse gas emissions, <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> is<br />
analysing whether the current market designs will be able<br />
to deliver the correct price signals despite the distortions<br />
introduced by RES subsidies on wholesale prices. The<br />
regulatory framework and resulting investment climate<br />
for the necessary investments in conventional power<br />
plants, which provide backup and flexible capacity for the<br />
grid, need to be carefully monitored to identify whether<br />
markets will be able to cope with those distortions.<br />
While the integration of wholesale markets is important,<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>’s strategy towards well-functioning<br />
electricity markets also includes the elaboration of an EUwide<br />
retail market design to facilitate the convergence of<br />
retail electricity markets. The linkage of wholesale and<br />
retail electricity markets over time, together with the<br />
phase-out of regulated prices, will be crucial to deliver<br />
all benefits of fully liberalised markets to electricity<br />
customers. The advent of smart grids and smart meters<br />
will enable suppliers to provide consumers with timely<br />
and accurate information and advice on energy savings,<br />
thereby helping them to regulate their own consumption<br />
(see separate article on p. 30).<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> report on regional<br />
market integration<br />
At the request of the 17 th European Electricity Regulatory<br />
Forum, <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> has drawn up a report contributing to<br />
the development of regional markets as enshrined in the EU’s<br />
Third Energy Package. Besides looking into actions needed<br />
to foster the emergence of integrated regional markets, the<br />
report also points to the current lack of coordination and risks<br />
of divergence between regional markets. The target models for<br />
electricity wholesale markets should thus play a crucial role in<br />
establishing a truly integrated pan-European market, acting as the<br />
backbone of any comprehensive EU market integration strategy.<br />
Such a strategy should be underpinned by real commitment from<br />
the EU member states as well as leadership from the European<br />
Commission and the EU’s regulatory agency ACER. This would<br />
alleviate predictable delay in the integration of day-ahead and<br />
intraday markets, stemming from persisting disagreement on the<br />
division of tasks between transmission system operators (TSOs)<br />
and power exchanges.<br />
The report was unveiled at the <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> markets conference<br />
on 17 March <strong>2010</strong> and will serve as a reference document for the<br />
European Commission’s review of regional initiatives.<br />
Finally, developing a consistent regional electricity<br />
market is a cornerstone of the European Commission’s<br />
strategy towards a pan-European electricity market. In<br />
this respect, <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> is paying specific attention to<br />
regional markets with non-EU borders, i.e. the Southern<br />
Eastern European region and the Baltic regional market.<br />
A close dialogue is also taking place with our Russian<br />
counterparts on the topic of cross-border electricity trade<br />
in the Nordic-Baltic-Russia/Belarus region. The objective<br />
of these talks is to create a level playing field for market<br />
players and reduce current economic distortions due to<br />
different pricing mechanisms, market models and access<br />
rules to interconnectors.<br />
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
23
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
Integrating renewable energy sources (RES) into the grid<br />
poses a number of challenges for the future development<br />
of wholesale electricity markets, explains Marcel Cailliau,<br />
Chairman of the <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> Task Force on Integration<br />
of Renewables.<br />
24<br />
Why are the 2020 targets for renewables so<br />
important for wholesale electricity markets?<br />
The EU decision to have at least 20% of its energy supplied<br />
through RES by 2020 will require a contribution of RES to<br />
electricity generation of around 35% of all sources. The<br />
increased production of renewables will be based, to a large<br />
extent, on wind and solar power. These are by their very<br />
nature intermittent, unpredictable and unevenly geographically<br />
distributed. Considering that most of the EU member<br />
states in <strong>2010</strong> are still only half-way to reaching their<br />
RES targets, the next 10 years will see a complete paradigm<br />
shift in electricity markets, affecting wholesale prices,<br />
balancing needs and costs, power flows across and within<br />
countries as well as generation and grid investments.<br />
What do EU electricity markets need to efficiently<br />
integrate these large volumes of intermittent RES?<br />
In my view, there are two key solutions to integrating RES in<br />
the most cost-effective way: large-scale grid investments and<br />
integrated wholesale markets. On the one hand, the massive<br />
development of the EU network represents the “hardware”<br />
Integrating RES into the market<br />
We need to ensure that correct<br />
price signals incentivise the<br />
necessary investment<br />
As a consequence of the EU 2020 renewables<br />
target, the share of renewable energy sources<br />
(RES) is expected to reach between 30-35% of all<br />
generation sources. The increased production of<br />
renewables will largely be based on intermittent<br />
sources such as wind and solar power, which will be<br />
far more challenging to integrate into the system.<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> has therefore analysed the effects<br />
that the increased amounts of intermittent RES<br />
production will have on both the electricity market<br />
and on transmission and distribution grids. Our<br />
interview<br />
solution, which is crucial, but will take longer and be more<br />
costly. By contrast, market integration enables a number of<br />
“software” solutions that can quickly and effectively improve<br />
the functioning of markets and grid security. Market players<br />
should in particular be able to trade close to real time on the<br />
basis of integrated intraday and balancing markets, allowing<br />
them to adapt to unforeseen deviations of intermittent<br />
generation from day-ahead forecasts. This will contribute<br />
decisively to reducing congestion, optimising generation<br />
capacity flexibility, enhancing cross-border electricity trade –<br />
and it will eventually reduce system costs for consumers.<br />
What role will conventional technologies play in<br />
the future?<br />
Greater amounts of wind and solar generation will still<br />
require investments in backup and flexible capacity (both<br />
in new and in existing plants), which will need to be<br />
quickly available at times when the wind doesn’t blow or<br />
the sun doesn’t shine. We need to ensure that correct price<br />
signals incentivise the necessary investment in flexible<br />
and backup generation capacity and encourage an active<br />
participation of consumers on the demand side. To this<br />
end, regulatory distortions such as price caps should be<br />
removed. In those cases where energy markets are unable<br />
to deliver adequate returns on investment for flexible and<br />
back-up plants, additional mechanisms to remunerate<br />
capacity availability may be needed, provided they do not<br />
hinder further integration of markets.<br />
work resulted in the report “Integrating intermittent<br />
renewables sources into the EU electricity system<br />
by 2020”, published in May <strong>2010</strong>.<br />
The report demonstrates how increasing levels of<br />
intermittent generation make market integration<br />
even more urgent to ensure a sustainable and secure<br />
power system. The greater demand for ancillary services<br />
to balance the system and redispatch services to<br />
cope with transmission congestion will require larger<br />
market areas to minimise inefficiency. Renewables<br />
targets and security of supply standards should<br />
therefore not supersede the creation of a single EU<br />
market, but rather be part of the same strategy.
What is changing in Energy Trading rules?<br />
During <strong>2010</strong> the European Commission put forward a number<br />
of legislative proposals aimed at enhancing transparency and<br />
market integrity and preventing systemic risk in energy markets.<br />
We present a snapshot of proposals and <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> positions.<br />
The proposal In September, DG MARKT issued a regulation to enhance the resilience of over-the-counter<br />
(OTC) derivatives markets, including commodity derivatives such as electricity and gas.<br />
Our position <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> agrees with the intent of the Commission to prevent systemic risk<br />
in traditional financial markets and welcomes the proposal to increase the share of<br />
standardised OTC derivatives cleared via central counterparties (CCPs). However, since<br />
energy companies pose no systemic risk to any part of the financial or energy market,<br />
they should keep the possibility of hedging the risk directly linked to their commercial<br />
activity without mandatory central clearing.<br />
The proposal ERGEG, the European Regulators’ Group for Electricity and Gas, recently prepared<br />
draft guidelines on fundamental data transparency to be adopted by the European<br />
Commission via comitology.<br />
Our position <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> believes that the introduction of binding transparency requirements<br />
across the EU will not only ensure a level playing field between market participants, but<br />
will also improve further the level of market integrity and increase consumer confidence<br />
in the proper functioning of markets.<br />
The proposal I n December <strong>2010</strong>, the Commission issued a regulation on energy market integrity and<br />
transparency, proposing a “sector specific” definition of market abuse and a related<br />
regulatory monitoring and enforcement model.<br />
Our position <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> welcomes this proposal and believes that a robust regulatory framework<br />
should be introduced consistently across the EU. Moreover, the concepts of insider<br />
dealing and market manipulation should be based on clear definitions, taking into<br />
account accepted market practices and operational arrangements.<br />
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
25
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
Emissions trading:<br />
Implementing the third trading period<br />
The review of the EU Emission Trading Scheme (EU ETS),<br />
setting the framework for the third trading period 2013-2020<br />
and beyond, was formally adopted in April 2009, but left many<br />
elements related to its implementation to be further defined.<br />
Following a preliminary consultation phase in 2009, the first<br />
half of <strong>2010</strong> was therefore taken up by discussions on the text of<br />
the draft Auctioning Regulation. As the electricity sector will be<br />
the only sector exposed to full auctioning in 2013, <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong><br />
has been at the forefront in debating key issues with the European<br />
Commission and national governments.<br />
26<br />
Given the step-change in the allocation method, from<br />
the free allocation of allowances to auctioning, one<br />
of the primary messages that <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong><br />
repeatedly put forward was the need to have access<br />
to allowances for the third trading period (2013-<br />
2020) by mid-2011. This would allow generators to<br />
cover the CO 2 exposure of their forward electricity<br />
contracts, which account for about 80% of total<br />
generated volumes. On this issue, the <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong><br />
argument was only partially accepted by the European<br />
Commission, with a specific provision in the<br />
legislation allowing for early auctioning. However,<br />
the political debate that accompanied the discussion<br />
of the draft regulation has shifted the attention away<br />
from this issue.<br />
This shift was primarily due to two reasons. First,<br />
the impact of the financial crisis has reduced carbon<br />
emissions more strongly than expected, generating<br />
a surplus of allowances banked into the next trading<br />
period. Given the uncertainties in assessing the<br />
overall impact of the financial crisis, the Commission<br />
has not defined volumes and a calendar for early<br />
auctioning. Despite <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>’s efforts in<br />
presenting figures – in line with the views of the<br />
majority of market analysts – showing that the<br />
volumes likely to be available in the market will be<br />
inadequate, detailed provisions on early auctioning<br />
are still not available.<br />
A second element that influenced the debate was the<br />
Commission communication in May which set out an<br />
analysis of the proposal to move from a 20% to a 30%<br />
greenhouse gas reduction target by 2020. Reaching<br />
the more stringent target would clearly affect the<br />
EU ETS. <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> has assessed the Commission’s
underlying analysis on the basis of an unpublished<br />
sensitivity in the <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> Power Choices study<br />
which examined the impact of moving to a -30%<br />
target. With both the Commission document and<br />
Power Choices based on the same model, <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong><br />
has probably been one of the best-placed organisations<br />
to analyse the Commission figures. The dialogue that<br />
followed strengthened the solidity of <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong><br />
arguments.<br />
At the time of writing, the draft auctioning regulation<br />
was expected to become EU law by the end of <strong>2010</strong>.<br />
In the meantime, <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> has also engaged with<br />
the Commission over the definition of benchmarks<br />
as a basis for allocation rules, with the allocation for<br />
the heating sector and the need to avoid potential<br />
distortions in this market of particular relevance to<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> members.<br />
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
European legislation on Clean<br />
Development Mechanism (CDM) credits<br />
The European Commission announced in August <strong>2010</strong><br />
plans to introduce further quality restrictions on the use<br />
of credits from industrial gas projects in the post-2012 EU ETS,<br />
citing concerns about their environmental integrity. Following<br />
the invitation from the EU Commissioner for Climate Action,<br />
Connie Hedegaard, <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> submitted a letter which set<br />
out the key principles the electricity industry would wish to<br />
see adopted when introducing any such restrictions: timely and<br />
objective criteria leaving no room to interpretation for identifying<br />
the specific CDM asset class, no retroactive application<br />
of legislation, and prior consultation supported by robust<br />
analyses/impact assessments with all relevant stakeholders.<br />
The European Commission presented its official proposal for<br />
restrictions on 25 November <strong>2010</strong>, just ahead of the climate change<br />
negotiations held in Cancún, Mexico, the following month.<br />
27
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
An IncrEAsEd<br />
And bETTEr usE<br />
of ElEcTrIcITy<br />
28<br />
Over the past decades the electricity industry has increasingly de-coupled<br />
electricity generation from fuel consumption, a trend that is expected to<br />
become even more significant in the next 20 years (see figure below).<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> is convinced that these efficiency gains provide a solid<br />
basis for a more intelligent use of electricity on the demand side as<br />
well, including the deployment of smart grids and smart meters, the<br />
electrification of transport and heating & cooling, as well as energy<br />
efficiency measures.<br />
% of 1990 Value<br />
200<br />
150<br />
100<br />
50<br />
0<br />
Electricity Generation & Fuel Consumption for electricity generation (1990 baseline)<br />
Electricity Generation<br />
Total Fuel Consumption for Electricity Generation<br />
1980 1990 2000 2007<br />
2008<br />
<strong>2010</strong> 2020 2030<br />
Source: <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> Power Statistics <strong>2010</strong>
Smart Grids<br />
Turning the concept into reality: Preparing<br />
electricity networks for the future<br />
Page 30<br />
Energy efficiency<br />
With a new EU Action Plan expected for<br />
2011, convincing consumers to invest in<br />
efficiency measures remains a top priority<br />
Page 33<br />
E-mobility<br />
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
Highlights<br />
How electricity can contribute to making<br />
transport more sustainable<br />
Page 34<br />
29
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
smArT grIds<br />
prEpArIng ElEcTrIcITy<br />
nETworks for ThE fuTurE<br />
The vision of smart grids is well-established,<br />
but turning it into reality is quite a different<br />
story. In <strong>2010</strong>, <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> has been<br />
committed to making smart grids more<br />
concrete and defining the main challenges<br />
involved in getting them off the ground. In<br />
particular, <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> has been active in<br />
contributing and coordinating the industry’s<br />
views within the European Commission’s<br />
Task Force Smart Grids.<br />
30<br />
Current debates on European electricity distribution<br />
networks inevitably focus on two main challenges:<br />
integrating into the grid the low-carbon power sources<br />
essential to reach the EU’s 20/20/20 targets and<br />
facilitating well-functioning electricity retail markets.<br />
Connecting the growing share of decentralised, often<br />
intermittent generation capacities to the distribution grid<br />
also presents unique challenges, in particular with regard<br />
to balancing the grid. The paper on “Smarter Network<br />
Management”, elaborated by <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>’s WG Smart<br />
Grids, outlines which technologies can assist distribution<br />
system operators (DSOs) in coping with this challenge.<br />
It is part of a wider exercise aimed at making the concept<br />
of smart grids more concrete for European policymakers.<br />
One advantage of smart grids is their contribution to<br />
well-functioning electricity retail markets and a more<br />
active demand. For instance, smart meters, which will<br />
be rolled out across the EU following the adoption of<br />
the 3 rd Electricity Directive, will play an essential role<br />
in fostering more active demand-side participation,<br />
allowing customers to better monitor and manage their<br />
consumption and to switch suppliers.
Yet despite these advantages, the implementation of<br />
smart grids is still beset by a number of challenges which<br />
hamper Europe’s DSOs in their efforts to get smart grids<br />
up and running. These barriers have been pointed out<br />
by <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> in its response to ERGEG’s consultation<br />
on smart grids. On smart metering, <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> has<br />
repeatedly stated throughout the year – be it in its policy<br />
statement on smart meters or in its response to the ERGEG<br />
consultation on regulatory aspects of smart meters – that<br />
reaping the full benefits of smart meters requires three<br />
conditions to be met. First, the interoperability of smart<br />
metering systems must be safeguarded. Second, smart<br />
meters should only display essential functionalities so<br />
as to reconcile cost-efficiency with customer choice and<br />
markets. Finally, national regulators should indicate<br />
that smart meter roll-outs will be tariff-financed, given<br />
that the benefits of smart metering are spread along<br />
the entire length of the electricity value chain and reach<br />
even beyond to society as a whole.<br />
Overall, investments in smarter grids will require a<br />
redesign of the current financing model applied by the<br />
national regulators to DSOs – a point stressed in this<br />
Successful <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> smart grids conference<br />
On 13-14 April <strong>2010</strong>, <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> organised a policy workshop entitled “How Will<br />
Smart Grids Change the Face of Europe’s Electricity Distribution and Consumption?”<br />
The conference brought together about 130 participants. Among the highlights were<br />
the keynote speeches by European Commissioner for Consumer Policy John Dalli<br />
and by Philip Lowe, Director General of the European Commission’s DG ENERGY.<br />
The conference also represented a welcome opportunity for European DSO managers<br />
to present their views on smart grids and regulation.<br />
year’s <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> report on Economic Regulation for<br />
European DSOs. In line with the European Commission’s<br />
intention, set out in the Energy Infrastructure<br />
Package, of assessing the need for further legislative<br />
measures to encourage the implementation of smart<br />
grids, <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> DSO regulation experts are now<br />
assessing EU regulatory ‘good practices’ in incentivising<br />
investments in order to develop policy recommendations<br />
for the EU. Currently, DSOs are indeed subject to a<br />
regulatory framework which is geared to maximise<br />
operational expenditure efficiency, with the ultimate<br />
aim of achieving price reductions for customers. But<br />
for the necessary investments to occur, the regulatory<br />
framework should allow a fair rate of return and<br />
reward both innovation and risk-taking. Several<br />
members of <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>’s Working Group Smart Grids<br />
contributed to the Commission’s Task Force on Smart<br />
Grids, in particular on issues related to the roles and<br />
responsibilities of competitive and regulated actors in a<br />
smart grids environment along with the funding of smart<br />
grids. In short, smart grids can be expected to deliver a<br />
number of benefits, but will also need smart regulation<br />
to fulfil their full potential.<br />
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
31
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
32<br />
The past year has seen several structural<br />
developments take place within<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>. Jan Peters, Director for<br />
Asset Management at Dutch Distribution<br />
System Operator (DSO) ENEXIS<br />
and Chairman of the <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> DSOs<br />
Directors’ Gathering, explains the changes<br />
and what they mean for <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>’s<br />
future work.<br />
Mr Peters, you are the chairman of the new<br />
“<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> DSOs Directors’ Gathering”. Can<br />
you explain what this body is and what prompted its<br />
development?<br />
In recent years, it has become increasingly clear that<br />
European Distribution System Operators (DSOs) have<br />
a new mission: contributing to the European 20/20/20<br />
objectives and facilitating a working electricity retail<br />
market. DSOs are increasingly going beyond their<br />
traditional role of providing quality electricity to<br />
consumers at low cost, and they are therefore facing<br />
new challenges regarding investments and operations.<br />
At the same time, DSOs have a strong desire to<br />
communicate to the European energy scene with a<br />
clear and common DSO voice.<br />
To better reflect this evolution and to tackle<br />
distribution issues more efficiently, <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong><br />
has decided to reinforce the DSO representation in its<br />
structure. We have therefore set up a new strategic<br />
body – the DSOs Directors’ Gathering – which I have<br />
the honour to be chairing. Its 20 full members were<br />
elected in June, at a meeting representing more<br />
than 2,000 DSOs across Europe. Livio Gallo, Director<br />
Infrastructure and Networks, Enel, was elected as<br />
Vice-Chairman.<br />
interview<br />
DSOs have to convince policymakers<br />
that funding of smart grid demonstration<br />
projects is vital<br />
So what is the relationship between this new<br />
body and <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>? How do you contribute<br />
to <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>’s activities?<br />
The mission of the DSOs Directors’ Gathering is simple:<br />
we aim to contribute to <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>’s overall strategy<br />
and working programme on DSO issues, bringing our<br />
unique point of view to the table and ensuring that<br />
DSO issues are represented within the overarching<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> structure. Indeed, more than 100<br />
distribution experts are actively involved in the various<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> working groups which are supported<br />
by the <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> Networks Unit. The expertise which<br />
we bring into these working groups extends to a variety<br />
of fields, including network regulation, customer<br />
relations, grid operation, smart grids, standardisation<br />
and electric vehicles.<br />
A truly wide range of issues. Which of these do<br />
you consider most pressing; what do you see as<br />
the major challenges that DSOs will need to address<br />
during the upcoming year?<br />
Looking ahead, I see two main upcoming strategic issues.<br />
The first concerns a redesign of national economic<br />
regulation. It will be absolutely necessary to ensure<br />
that the regulatory framework delivers real incentives<br />
for DSOs to increase investments, keeping in mind<br />
that today’s investments will stay in place for many<br />
decades to come, paving the way for a carbon-neutral<br />
electricity sector in 2050 and assuring future quality<br />
by replacing ageing grids. Secondly, we need to clarify<br />
the important role of smart grids in this context.<br />
DSOs have to convince policymakers that funding<br />
of smart grid demonstration projects, as proposed<br />
within the European Electricity Grid Initiative, is vital.<br />
Demonstration projects allow us to test technologies<br />
and gain knowledge before going into the investment<br />
phase. The first common target of the DSOs Directors’<br />
Gathering is therefore the publication of a communication<br />
brochure, “The 10 Steps Towards Smart Grids”.
Energy efficiency<br />
The European Commission was expected to publish in<br />
<strong>2010</strong> a new Energy Efficiency Action Plan, revising the<br />
current action plan which was published back in 2006.<br />
However, Günther Oettinger, the newly appointed<br />
Energy Commissioner, postponed the release of the<br />
new action plan to the beginning of 2011. Nevertheless,<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> has actively engaged with the European<br />
Commission and relevant stakeholders throughout<br />
<strong>2010</strong>, contributing to the debate on measures to foster<br />
energy efficiency in Europe within a coherent energyclimate<br />
framework.<br />
In particular, <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> organised a conference, in<br />
cooperation with the IEA Demand Side Management<br />
Programme, on the promotion of energy efficiency<br />
measures within the electricity sector. The event<br />
was organised within the framework of the annual<br />
EU Sustainable Energy Week. <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> also<br />
participated in the Bucharest Forum on Sustainable<br />
Energy Wisdom Programme<br />
The <strong>2010</strong>-2011 edition of <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>’s<br />
Energy Wisdom Programme (EWP) was<br />
officially launched on 4 May in the<br />
European Parliament, in the presence<br />
of 14 Members of the European<br />
Parliament and the head of the<br />
European Commission’s energy<br />
efficiency unit. Featuring over 200 projects,<br />
the report showed a reduction of approxi mately<br />
180Mt CO 2 eq. emissions, and fuel savings of 18 Mtoe.<br />
Nineteen companies, accounting for more than one third<br />
of the total EU-27 power generation, participated in<br />
Energy, organised by the European Commission, which<br />
discussed the future energy efficiency action plan.<br />
In addition, the European electricity sector has played<br />
an active role in the energy efficiency debate at the international<br />
level. In June and July, <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> participated<br />
in various stakeholder meetings organised by the<br />
International Energy Agency (IEA) aimed at reviewing the<br />
current IEA Energy Efficiency Policy Recommendations.<br />
Finally, in the last quarter of <strong>2010</strong>, <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> began<br />
drafting a position paper on energy efficiency, as well<br />
as launching a survey among distribution and retail<br />
companies to assess their involvement in the promotion<br />
of energy services for consumers and to identify<br />
opportunities and barriers that need to be addressed. Both<br />
activities are expected to be finalised and communicated<br />
in the first quarter of 2011, in parallel with the publication<br />
of the European Commission’s Action Plan.<br />
this edition – more than ever before. This increase can<br />
be attributed to a number of innovations in the report,<br />
including streamlining the project to bring it in line with<br />
the 2050 carbon-neutrality objective laid down in the<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> Power Choices study, a strong focus on<br />
promoting innovation in the electricity sector, a dedicated<br />
space for individual CEO messages within a European<br />
framework, a special area for project managers, and a<br />
tailor-made promotional campaign.<br />
A voluntary initiative launched by <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> in<br />
1998, the EWP allows electricity companies to showcase<br />
their activities on improving energy efficiency and<br />
reducing greenhouse gas emissions. Preparations for<br />
the 2012-2013 edition will begin in spring 2011.<br />
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
33
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
Electric Vehicles – ensuring the<br />
necessary public charging infrastructure<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> is convinced that electricity is a solution for making<br />
transport more sustainable. Using low-carbon electricity in the<br />
transport sector can decrease greenhouse gas emissions, achieve<br />
energy-efficiency gains through the greater efficiency of electric-drive<br />
trains, decrease the EU’s oil dependence, and help to maintain the<br />
EU’s competitiveness by taking the lead in these new technological<br />
developments.<br />
34<br />
Against this backdrop, <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>’s Task Force<br />
Electric Vehicles seized the opportunity to contribute<br />
to the discussion on the future mass roll-out of electric<br />
vehicles (EVs) in general, and of the required public<br />
charging infrastructure in particular. Its concept paper<br />
on market models for the roll-out of EV public charging<br />
infrastructure, published in September <strong>2010</strong>, identifies<br />
four possible market models, taking three important<br />
roles within the value chain of e-mobility electricity –<br />
distribution, operation of infrastructure, and retail – into<br />
account. Depending on the market model, the three<br />
activities fall under the responsibility of different actors.<br />
For instance, EV charging stations can be considered<br />
either as part of the distribution infrastructure or<br />
as a separate, stand-alone part of the value chain,<br />
resulting in very different implications for the roles and<br />
responsibilities of the stakeholders involved.<br />
The paper was released at a <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> conference<br />
on electric vehicles on 27 September <strong>2010</strong> in Brussels,<br />
which brought together some 150 delegates from across<br />
Europe and a diverse range of industries. In his keynote<br />
speech, EU Commissioner for Energy Günther Oettinger<br />
stressed the role of e-mobility in decarbonising the<br />
European economy and urged participants to “work<br />
hard to make electric cars a common sight on our<br />
streets.” The conference also touched upon the issues<br />
of standardising EV charging equipment and the<br />
environmental footprint of EVs.<br />
In a separate development in line with the declaration<br />
on standardising electric drive technologies, published<br />
by <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> in 2009, the European Commission<br />
mandated the European standardisation bodies CEN/<br />
CENELEC and ETSI to develop by 2011 a standardised<br />
charging interface to ensure interoperability and<br />
connectivity between electricity supply points and EV<br />
chargers. Safety risks and electromagnetic compatibility<br />
as well as smart charging will also be considered.<br />
A Focus Group on electro-mobility has been created in<br />
which <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> is taking part.<br />
In the meantime <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>’s Task Force Electric<br />
Vehicles took part in the Expert Group on Future
Transport Fuels, set up by the European Commission’s<br />
DG MOVE in April <strong>2010</strong> to compile a stakeholders’<br />
report on roadmaps for substituting oil in the transport<br />
sector. <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> provided its views on how<br />
electricity can contribute to cleaning up the transport<br />
sector. In addition, the European Commission officially<br />
re-launched in November <strong>2010</strong> the high-level group<br />
CARS21, following the Commission’s communication<br />
on clean and energy-efficient vehicles in April. Focusing<br />
on competitiveness and sustainable growth, CARS21 is<br />
part of Europe’s industrial policy managed by DG ENTR.<br />
The box on this page presents an overview of further<br />
upcoming <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> e-mobility activities.<br />
E-mobility – what next?<br />
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
2011 promises to be a busy year in terms of electro-mobility:<br />
• The European Commission’s White Paper on Transport, expected<br />
for early 2011, will set out general transport policy measures and<br />
targets for the coming decade, thus providing the backdrop for<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>’s upcoming e-mobility activities. <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong><br />
participated in the preparation of the White Paper through a number<br />
of public stakeholders’ conferences, underlining the important role<br />
electric vehicles can play in decarbonising the transport sector.<br />
• <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> is part of the project consortium behind Green<br />
E-motion, a project aimed at developing a European framework<br />
for electro-mobility. Starting in March 2011 and stretching over<br />
four years, the project will enable participants to share knowledge<br />
and experiences of on-going e-mobility demonstration projects. It<br />
will contribute to developing a marketplace for electric vehicles,<br />
as well as advancing services, test standards and interoperability,<br />
and widening consumer awareness and acceptance.<br />
• The European Commission is due to publish a Communication on<br />
transport in May 2011, identifying pathways for oil substitution<br />
in the transport sector. The communication will rest upon the<br />
conclusions of the Expert Group on Future Transport Fuels, set<br />
up by the Commission in April <strong>2010</strong> and in which <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong><br />
was represented.<br />
• <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> has been invited by the European Commission to take<br />
part in the re-launch of the high-level group CARS21. The group’s<br />
objective is to develop a realistic vision for the EU automotive<br />
industry and sustainable mobility in 2020 and beyond. The adoption<br />
of the final report is foreseen for spring 2012.<br />
35
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
sTrong, rElIAblE<br />
pArTnErshIps<br />
And frAmEwork<br />
condITIons<br />
36<br />
A strong, reliable and well-functioning electricity sector requires solid foundations, including<br />
continuous dialogue with social partners, international cooperation, and a sound financial and<br />
regulatory framework. <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> is also working for a consistent European and international<br />
emissions framework, which will enable the sector to achieve a smooth transition to carbonneutrality.<br />
According to our latest figures, CO 2 emissions from electricity generation fell<br />
by 33% in relative terms between 1980 and 2008, and could be more than halved by 2030.<br />
% of 1990 Value<br />
200<br />
180<br />
160<br />
140<br />
120<br />
100<br />
80<br />
60<br />
40<br />
20<br />
0<br />
Electricity generation & CO2 emissions (1990 baseline)<br />
Electricity Generation<br />
Electricity-related CO2 Emissions<br />
1980 1990 2000 2007<br />
2008<br />
<strong>2010</strong> 2020 2030<br />
Source: <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> Power Statistics <strong>2010</strong>
Electricity Social Dialogue<br />
Responding to the needs of electricity<br />
sector employees<br />
Page 38<br />
The Effects of the<br />
Financial Crisis<br />
Highlights<br />
A new report shows how the European<br />
electricity industry has been hit by the<br />
constrained overall financial climate<br />
Page 39<br />
Cooperation beyond Europe<br />
A look at power sector cooperation<br />
at the international level<br />
Page 41<br />
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
37
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
Working Group Social Affairs & Human Resources<br />
Electricity Social Dialogue:<br />
Supporting the Needs of Employees<br />
As a social partner representing the employer side, <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong><br />
recognises the importance of the electricity sector’s social dialogue in<br />
addressing sector-wide issues with the European trade union bodies<br />
EMCEF and EPSU, and with the support of the European Commission.<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> social affairs representatives undertook a number of<br />
activities in <strong>2010</strong>, aimed at maintaining and improving the necessary<br />
framework for a smooth functioning of the European electricity sector.<br />
38<br />
Joint Project on Climate Change,<br />
Employment Impact and Just Employment<br />
Transition Principles<br />
Social affairs activities during <strong>2010</strong> focused predominantly<br />
on this joint project, which analysed measures taken<br />
by the electricity sector to address climate change with<br />
regard to their impact on sector-related employment,<br />
working conditions, skills and qualifications. The study<br />
also assessed the employment implications of the<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> Power Choices study, which looks at<br />
pathways to a carbon-neutral power sector by 2050.<br />
Following on from the Social Dialogue Committee’s earlier<br />
work on equality and diversity, demographic change and<br />
restructuring, the results of this joint project were officially<br />
unveiled in December at a final conference in Brussels.<br />
The study provides an important stepping stone towards<br />
anticipating future restructuring caused by climate change<br />
and developing a forward-thinking agenda to ensure a<br />
policy framework that encourages employment and the<br />
improvement of living and working conditions.<br />
EU Energy Strategy 2011-2020<br />
In addition to its input as an individual association,<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> also contributed within the electricity<br />
Social Dialogue Committee to the European Commission’s<br />
public consultation on the new EU Energy Strategy 2020.<br />
The committee’s response underlined its key role in<br />
addressing the social dimensions of future energy policies<br />
and its willingness to cooperate closely with DG Energy,<br />
not least on identifying the necessary measures to tackle<br />
job skills and needs in moving to a low-carbon energy<br />
system. The committee also stated that it would like to be<br />
more strongly involved in the impact assessment of new<br />
policy measures. With a communication from the European<br />
Commission published in November <strong>2010</strong>, this issue is<br />
likely to constitute an important bulk of <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>’s<br />
activities in 2011.<br />
Smart meters<br />
Also in the framework of the electricity Social Dialogue<br />
Committee, <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> and trade unions EPSU and<br />
EMCEF discussed the implications which a roll-out of<br />
smart meters would have on employment in the electricity<br />
sector. At time of writing, a joint position on this issue was<br />
expected to be adopted in mid-December <strong>2010</strong>, stressing<br />
that impacts could be negative, with certain occupations<br />
and jobs disappearing, but also positive, in that the rollout<br />
of smart-meters would create new jobs requiring new<br />
skills and qualifications. As a consequence, social partners<br />
underlined the need for careful planning, implementation<br />
and monitoring, as well as the importance for companies<br />
to ensure appropriate training for the workers concerned.<br />
Workers’ exposure to electromagnetic<br />
fields<br />
As of 2009, the European Commission is obliged to<br />
consult the European social dialogue partners when<br />
proposing any new policy that will have a social impact<br />
on the sector concerned. Accordingly <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> and<br />
European trade unions EPSU and EMCEF participated in<br />
the second consultation on the review of the EU directive<br />
on workers’ exposure to electromagnetic fields (EMF).<br />
Drafted by the Working Group Environment & Society<br />
in cooperation with the Working Group Social Affairs &<br />
Human Resources, the <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> response stressed<br />
that any future EU initiative should rest upon a sciencebased<br />
approach to limiting high EMF exposure, as laid<br />
down in the 2004 EMF Directive. A new directive is<br />
expected at the beginning of 2011 and will be followed<br />
closely by <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> in the coming year.
Focus Group Enterprise Risk Management<br />
Identifying Financing Costs<br />
and Risks<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>’s Focus Group Enterprise Risk Management<br />
(ERM) is currently working on a comprehensive report<br />
called “Risk analysis and recommendations on the Power<br />
Choices Study”. The first part of the study analyses<br />
markets volatility and its effect on the cost structure<br />
of the electricity sector, with a particular view to the<br />
expected effects on financing costs. It reveals that the<br />
supply-demand balance for physical oil (the so-called<br />
“wet barrel”) is not the only factor to influence oil<br />
price behaviour. Rather, other logics related to financial<br />
investments seeking higher yield and/or diversification<br />
(the so called “paper barrel”) might become even more<br />
relevant. Furthermore, the study concludes that high<br />
CO 2 price volatility is currently deterring investment in<br />
long-lived, capital-intensive, low-carbon technologies,<br />
although the <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> Power Choices study shows<br />
that those technologies will represent the most important<br />
share of capital expenditures until 2050. Remunerating<br />
those power plants in fully liberalised markets, with<br />
Focus Group Finance & Economics<br />
The Effects of the Financial Crisis<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>’s Focus Group Finance and Economics<br />
has analysed how the financial crisis has affected the<br />
European electricity industry. The report, published in<br />
December <strong>2010</strong>, shows that the sector was affected by<br />
the credit crisis not so much in terms of a reduction in the<br />
available debt volumes, but especially in terms of debt<br />
costs, which soared as companies had to pay higher risk<br />
premiums to refinance their debts.<br />
Weak electricity demand, falling electricity prices, the<br />
need to refinance debt under strained capital market<br />
conditions and stringent analysis from financial<br />
analysts and credit agencies have obliged electricity<br />
companies to reinforce their balance sheets by<br />
introducing cost-cutting programs, setting aside<br />
power prices highly dependent on fuel prices, makes<br />
investors demand a high compensation for these risks.<br />
The study’s quantitative analysis shows that a reduction<br />
in Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC) of 1% implies<br />
a re duction of almost 8% in the annual capital cost burden<br />
of the power industry in 2050. This finding reinforces<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>’s regular calls for a sound and stable<br />
regulatory framework which can reduce the uncertainty<br />
of future cash flows and thus the power industry’s cost of<br />
capital to the benefit of consumers.<br />
In a second step, the paper will explore how counterparty<br />
risk has been increasing with the financial crisis. It will<br />
quantify the cost impact of various counterparty risks<br />
on the companies’ balance sheets. Further chapters will<br />
treat liquidity, regulatory and technology risks.<br />
The paper is expected to be published in the course of 2011.<br />
assets for disposal, implementing capital increases<br />
and reducing capital expenditure.<br />
Nevertheless, companies could not make the necessary<br />
adjustments at will. Capital expenditure programmes, in<br />
particular due to their long-term licence and construction<br />
periods, were too rigid to permit prompt cutbacks. As<br />
a result, companies’ investment efforts receded slowly<br />
and their leverage ratio (debt/equity ratio) continues to<br />
increase. Compared to other sectors, the electricity industry<br />
shows a persistent tendency to increase its leverage<br />
ratio. The interim report hence concludes that the current<br />
indebtedness and the limited scope of divestment plans<br />
in relation to the amount of necessary investments will<br />
probably result in additional equity issuance operations.<br />
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
39
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
40<br />
Fourth Environment<br />
and Sustainable<br />
Development <strong>Report</strong><br />
In April, <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> published its<br />
fourth Environment and Sus tainable<br />
Development <strong>Report</strong>, building on the<br />
legacy of the previous editions.<br />
Apart from environmental data, this<br />
report broadened its scope by<br />
including additional economic<br />
and social data, thus covering all<br />
three pillars of sustainability. The scope<br />
of the report has also broadened in geographical<br />
terms: it now includes data for the whole <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong><br />
membership, which comprises the EU-27 and six non-EU<br />
states (Croatia, Iceland, the Former Yugoslav Republic of<br />
Macedonia, Norway, Switzerland and Turkey). The report<br />
illustrates the continuing decoupling between electricity<br />
generation and electricity-related emissions (CO 2 , SO 2<br />
and NO x ) and the increasing importance of renewable<br />
energy sources (RES) in the total electricity generated.<br />
The report can be downloaded at http://www2.eurelectric.<br />
org/content/Default.asp?PageID=1014<br />
Consultation<br />
on Creosote<br />
Creosote is used as a wood preservative in particular for<br />
transmission and distribution poles in the electricity<br />
sector. Participating in a European Commission<br />
consultation in 2008, <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> supported the<br />
inclusion of creosote in Annex I to Directive 98/8/EC<br />
on Biocides, allowing its use on transmission and<br />
distribution wooden poles. This year, <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong><br />
members provided further input to policymakers,<br />
when the standing committee for the implementation<br />
of the directive finally debated the creosote issue.<br />
Failing to reach the required majority for a final<br />
decision, the committee has now transferred the issue<br />
to the Council.<br />
Adapting<br />
to Climate Change<br />
In January <strong>2010</strong>, <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> launched its Task<br />
Force on Adaptation to Climate Change. Members are<br />
keen to exchange experience and build knowledge<br />
on adaptation issues, as well as prepare the power<br />
sector for the EU’s adaptation strategy, expected<br />
for 2013. <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> is also represented in the<br />
Adaptation Steering Group, established by the<br />
European Commission to guide the integration of<br />
adaptation into EU policies, define the EU’s adaptation<br />
strategy, exchange information and share best<br />
practices, and take forward the technical analysis of<br />
adaptation issues.<br />
Adaptation to climate change is also being considered<br />
in the framework of the implementation of the Water<br />
Framework Directive. <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> experts continued<br />
to make a valuable contribution to this issue and<br />
others relevant to the activities of the electricity<br />
industry, such as the drafting of Technical Guidelines<br />
on mixing zones.<br />
Health & Safety<br />
Newsletter <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>’s Sub-Group<br />
Health has developed a<br />
newsletter “Health &<br />
Energy”, aimed at raising<br />
awareness of health-related<br />
issues among <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong><br />
members. The first edition<br />
was published in October<br />
<strong>2010</strong>, with the next expected for spring 2011. The<br />
newsletter will also be one of the pillars of the online<br />
archive established by the Working Group Environment<br />
& Society to share best practices on risk communication<br />
and health issues.
Cooperation beyond Europe:<br />
The International Electricity Summit<br />
The International Electricity Summit has since 1993 brought<br />
together, on a regular basis, senior executives from the<br />
electricity industry in Europe, Japan, the USA, Australia and<br />
Canada to discuss issues of common concern in an informal<br />
setting. The meetings have developed fruitful relationships<br />
between the associations and senior executives from<br />
these continents, as well as continuing to develop a real<br />
understanding of the various trends in the international<br />
electricity industry. In discussing the issues facing the<br />
sector, the objective is to work towards establishing<br />
a common voice to provide a basis for sustainable<br />
development in the industry in the future.<br />
The 12 th summit took place in Kyoto, Japan from 11 to 13<br />
April <strong>2010</strong>. The eight-strong European delegation was<br />
led by <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> President Lars Josefsson and<br />
Vice-President Fulvio Conti.<br />
After two days of intensive discussion the representatives<br />
of the five associations issued a joint statement re-affirming<br />
their common goal of achieving a low-carbon future.<br />
Calling attention to the leadership of the industry in<br />
addressing climate change, they noted that:<br />
• Electricity is key to implementing solutions to climate<br />
change.<br />
• Electricity is key to a sustainable future.<br />
• Electricity is key to achieving greater energy efficiency.<br />
• Electricity is key to economic growth and job creation.<br />
They also identified seven major areas on which to work<br />
together with their governments:<br />
• The role of the electric power industry in encouraging<br />
a shift to a low-carbon society;<br />
• Supply-side initiatives for reducing CO 2 emissions;<br />
• Renewable energy;<br />
• Nuclear power;<br />
• Thermal power generation;<br />
• Power transmission and distribution networks;<br />
• Demand-side initiatives for higher energy efficiency.<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> is currently preparing for the next International<br />
Electricity Summit, which will be hosted by<br />
Italian utility ENEL in Rome, 9-11 October 2011.<br />
Roadmap for a Low-Carbon Power Sector<br />
The International Elec tricity Partnership<br />
(IEP), inaugurated at the<br />
International Electricity Summit<br />
in October 2008, has since<br />
produced a roadmap as a<br />
global vision to be shared<br />
by electric power industries<br />
in various countries,<br />
including developing countries. IEP<br />
will serve as the platform for identifying and working<br />
together on common challenges toward a low-carbon<br />
society.<br />
Based on their joint “Roadmap for a Low-Carbon Power<br />
Sector by 2050,” the IEP was set an industry goal of<br />
developing national or regional emission reduction<br />
trajectories toward a low-carbon future. Further, these<br />
emission reduction trajectories would be based on a<br />
common measure of carbon emission intensity and include<br />
suggestions for appropriate policies and measures for<br />
each economy within governmental requirements.<br />
During the year, the IEP, led by its co-ordinator Dr Bill<br />
Kyte, has met in the context of meetings of the UNFCCC<br />
negotiating process to develop the trajectories.<br />
The meetings culminated in a joint workshop with the<br />
Mexican government at COP 16 in Cancun on 8<br />
December <strong>2010</strong> at which the IEP-drafted text on the<br />
role of the electricity sector in the mitigation of climate<br />
change was presented to the COP President.<br />
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
41
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
Industrial Emissions<br />
Directive: Delivering Input<br />
on Industrial Emissions Regulation<br />
Discussions on the Industrial Emissions Directive (IED) continued<br />
throughout the year, with the European Parliament and the<br />
Council reaching a second-reading agreement on the text in<br />
June. Most notably, legislators agreed to introduce a number of<br />
transition mechanisms for existing large combustion plants from<br />
2016 onwards, while dropping the originally planned adoption of<br />
minimum requirements for all industry sectors.<br />
42<br />
In <strong>2010</strong>, as the procedure entered into its second reading,<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> pursued its dialogue with policymakers,<br />
expressing its concerns over the new emission limit<br />
values that would apply to existing large combustion<br />
plants. The Council’s common position, formally adopted<br />
in early <strong>2010</strong>, reflected those concerns, also expressed by<br />
a number of member states. However, the Parliament’s<br />
Environment Committee, in its legislative report for the<br />
second reading, reduced the scope of the proposed<br />
measures. In the ensuing negotiations, the co-legislators<br />
reached a compromise on those highly debated issues.<br />
Under the agreed text, member states will have the option<br />
to set transitional national plans from 1 January 2016 to<br />
30 June 2020 or to exempt combustion plants from the<br />
IED requirements under a limited lifetime derogation of<br />
17,500 hours, running from 1 January 2016 to 31 December<br />
2023. Special derogations also apply to small isolated<br />
systems and to district heating. While plans for blanket<br />
minimum requirements have been dropped, the<br />
European Commission, when reviewing the directive’s<br />
implementation, will be able to decide whether certain<br />
sectors should nevertheless be subject to minimum<br />
requirements for emission limit values and rules on<br />
monitoring and compliance.<br />
The new directive also mandates that the conclusions of<br />
the Best Available Techniques Reference Documents<br />
(BREFs), which are used by competent authorities in<br />
member states when issuing operating permits for<br />
installations representing a significant pollution potential<br />
in Europe, should be adopted through the comitology<br />
process, rather than being published by the Commission<br />
as was previously the case. Within this process, authorities<br />
would only be able to set less strict values in very specific<br />
cases and after an assessment showing that achieving<br />
emission levels associated with the best available<br />
techniques would lead to disproportionately high costs<br />
compared to the expected environmental benefits.<br />
However, permits will need to include conditions ensuring<br />
that emissions do not exceed the emission limit values<br />
laid down in the directive. The joint <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>/<br />
VGB-Powertech group is currently preparing the power<br />
sector’s contribution to the upcoming revision of the<br />
sector BREF.<br />
The attempts by some MEPs to introduce a CO 2 emission<br />
performance standard for large combustion plants in<br />
the IED were unsuccessful. This rejection was in line<br />
with <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>’s argument that the EU Emissions<br />
Trading System (EU ETS) is the appropriate instrument<br />
to regulate CO 2 emissions and that the industry should<br />
not be subject to two separate sets of legislation.<br />
The IED was eventually adopted by the Council in<br />
November <strong>2010</strong>, paving the way for a rapid entry into<br />
force on 6 January 2011.<br />
A new emissions trading scheme<br />
for air pollutants?<br />
The possible introduction of an emissions trading<br />
scheme for industrial gases SO 2 and NO x was also<br />
debated in the framework of the IED, although later<br />
set aside as a separate issue. Studies commissioned<br />
by DG Environment concluded that the establishment<br />
of an EU-wide scheme would be the best option and<br />
have positive economic effects. In spite of its overall<br />
support for market-based instruments, <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong><br />
has expressed strong doubts about the desirability<br />
and applicability of such a scheme, not least<br />
because the significant emissions reductions already<br />
achieved within the sector – and foreseen for the<br />
future – raise strong doubts about the liquidity in the<br />
market. Moreover, such a scheme would potentially<br />
conflict with local air quality requirements. With the<br />
ball now in the court of the European Commission,<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> remains prepared to provide further<br />
input if necessary.
spotlight on EurElEcTrIc<br />
how we work<br />
<strong>Annual</strong> Convention and Awards<br />
Our partners: Interview with VGB<br />
Our structure<br />
Our members<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> Board of Directors<br />
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
43
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> <strong>Annual</strong> Convention<br />
and Conference - Highlights<br />
44<br />
More than 500 delegates, including policymakers, high-level industry representatives and<br />
international stakeholders from around the world gathered in Dublin from 14-15 June to<br />
discuss issues related to the “New Energy World”, the underlying theme of this year’s<br />
<strong>Annual</strong> Conference. Hosted by Electricity Supply Board (ESB) and National Electricity<br />
Association (NEA) of Ireland, the event focused on pressing industry and EU challenges<br />
for the 2020-2050 horizon which were tackled under three distinct topics – clean energy<br />
paradigm, wholesale and retail markets, and renewables. A closing CEO debate focused<br />
on the state of the energy business with respect to CO reduction, security of supply,<br />
2<br />
and liberalisation.<br />
The two-day Dublin conference was <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>’s first climate-neutral event. In<br />
cooperation with Swiss association myclimate <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> contributed financially to<br />
a specific carbon offset project aimed at offsetting the unavoidable climate-impacting<br />
emissions resulting from the convention.<br />
The <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> event also included a parallel exhibition “Elements of the New World”<br />
as well as the presentation of a <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> and student award (see article on page 48).<br />
In 2011, the industry association’s annual event will be hosted by Svensk Energi and Vattenfall<br />
from 13-14 June in Stockholm, Sweden. The focus will be on investments, in particular the<br />
current investment climate and prospects and risks vis-à-vis investment needs.<br />
Full conference proceedings of the Dublin event can be downloaded from www.eurelectric.org.
Opening Speeches<br />
Appraisal from our Sponsors<br />
We attend year in year out because the convention has the perfect balance<br />
between high-level participants and thought-provoking presentations.<br />
Luca Cesari, Utilities Global Managing Director, Accenture (Gold Sponsor)<br />
The annual <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> conference is a great opportunity to discuss key<br />
energy issues with our colleagues and clients in the electricity industry.<br />
Matt Brown, Head of London Office, Pöyry Energy Consulting (Silver Sponsor)<br />
We are pleased to attend this event as it is an ideal occasion for participants to<br />
share high-level experiences, through innovative and high impact presentations.<br />
Thierry Delmas, Ormazabal International Business Director (Bronze Sponsor)<br />
We are building the energy world of tomorrow. New technologies need to be developed,<br />
networks need to become smarter, the European energy mix will take on a new shape, and<br />
the customers will play a more active role in managing their energy consumption. All these<br />
changes are necessary to achieve a secure and carbon-neutral power supply by 2050.<br />
Lars G. Josefsson, President of <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong><br />
Climate change is a very clear illustration of the challenges posed by the growing<br />
interdependence of our world. We know that a meaningful response to climate change cannot<br />
happen in isolation and consequently there must be a well-coordinated and well-led global<br />
response … Deploying the most modern technologies is very important in controlling future<br />
energy supply and demand and integrating wind into the electricity grid.<br />
Brian Cowen T.D., An Taoiseach (Irish Prime Minister)<br />
Local authorities, EU institutions and electricity sector should work in partnership to define<br />
sustainable policies.<br />
Councillor Emer Costello, Lord Mayor of Dublin<br />
Secure and sustainable energy supplies can only be achieved within large integrated markets.<br />
Günther Oettinger, European Commissioner for Energy<br />
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
45
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
46<br />
Session 1<br />
The Clean Energy Paradigm: Meeting the Climate Challenge Together<br />
This [the sector’s 2009 CEO Declaration on carbon-neutral<br />
electricity] is not a blank cheque from the industry. In order to<br />
succeed, proper support from the institutions is needed.<br />
Fulvio Conti, <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> Vice President<br />
We are willing to collaborate with our counterparts in Europe,<br />
to strengthen international cooperation and exchange<br />
on key areas such as UHV, clean energy, grids integration<br />
and energy storage. With our joint efforts, we will share our key breakthroughs and<br />
innovative results, and make our joint contribution to combating climate change and<br />
fostering global environmental protection.<br />
Wang Min, Senior Advisor to the President of the State Grid Corporation of China (SGCC)<br />
Session 2<br />
Reaching The Customer:<br />
From Regional Wholesale to Seamless Retail Markets<br />
If we cannot create public acceptance and make stakeholders out of<br />
customers, we will not be able to roll-out smart meters.<br />
Peter Birkner, Chairman of <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>’s Networks Committee<br />
The Third Energy Package provides a firm basis for action.<br />
Philip Lowe, Director-General for Energy, European Commission<br />
DSOs should not wait for standardisation to be completed but instead use their purchasing<br />
power to incentivise smart metering manufacturers to cooperate, as this is the quickest way<br />
to reach interoperability.<br />
Andreas Umbach, President and COO of Landis+Gyr
Session 3<br />
RES – Breaking the Inertia<br />
A resource-efficient Europe is not only worth it, but essential.<br />
Janez POTOC˘NIK, European Commissioner for Environment<br />
Flexibility is key for grid integration of variable renewable energy … Large-scale<br />
integration of renewables is achievable at a cost, and will require significant investments<br />
in transmission and coordinated planning.<br />
Ian Cronshaw, Head of Energy Diversification, IEA<br />
Closing Session<br />
Executive Forum and CEO Debate<br />
For carbon costs, renewable subsidies and all investments across<br />
the value chain, about 900 billion euro investment above normal<br />
replacement expenditure is estimated for infrastructure oriented<br />
towards the 20-20-20 targets.<br />
Luca Cesari, Utilities Global Managing Director, Accenture<br />
A common market needs to guarantee free flows of electricity,<br />
investments and cash; this is not happening at the moment.<br />
Fulvio Conti, Vice-President of <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong><br />
Governments focus on sorting their own problems first, before looking at the global picture<br />
… The big challenge is to drive funds into R&D to develop or improve these technologies,<br />
but the budget is just not there.<br />
Padraig McManus, CEO of ESB<br />
We don’t really need R&D. What we need is D&D: Development and Deployment.<br />
Ian Marchant, CEO of SSE<br />
We should work on finding a commonly understood trajectory in emission reductions.<br />
Committing our industry to carbon-neutrality by 2050 was a first step, but the sector should<br />
now reassure policymakers of its intention to undertake early actions for carbon reductions.<br />
Lars G. Josefsson, President of <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong><br />
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
47
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> Award <strong>2010</strong><br />
<strong>2010</strong> also saw <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> venture into the<br />
world of social media, with its blog on energy<br />
affairs going public in September. Powering<br />
the Debate offers a forum for discussion on a<br />
wide range of electricity-related topics, ranging<br />
from electric vehicles to the energy mix of<br />
the future. Posts are published on a monthly<br />
basis and have so far included contributions<br />
from academics, policy experts and electricity<br />
sector stakeholders alike. But the initial input<br />
provided by our guest contributors is only<br />
<strong>2010</strong><br />
In line with the electricity industry’s commitment to carbon neutrality by<br />
2050, this year’s <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> Award was handed to two extraordinary<br />
and visionary persons – J. Christer Ericsson, Chairman of the Board of the<br />
Swedish corporation JCE Group AB, and Luis Echavarri, Director General of<br />
the OECD Nuclear Agency in Paris. The award is recognition of these persons’<br />
contribution to the promotion of low-carbon power technologies – biomass<br />
in the case of Mr Ericsson and nuclear in the case of Mr Echavarri. The award<br />
was presented by Paul Bulteel, former Secretary General and Electricity<br />
Ambassador for <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>.<br />
A student prize was also awarded to Patrick McCartan from the Dublin<br />
Institute of Technology for his innovative proposal for a Global Electricity<br />
Community Programme – a joint forum for industry and government leaders<br />
from around the world to commonly address the climate challenge and build<br />
a worldwide supergrid.<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> Blog Goes Public<br />
48<br />
part of the picture: much of the blog’s value<br />
and relevance will stem from the interaction<br />
the posts generate in the form of thoughtful,<br />
insightful and controversial comments. We<br />
hope to further develop the blog into a platform<br />
for lively and engaging debate, and warmly<br />
invite all <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> members, as well as<br />
any interested members of the wider public,<br />
to participate in the conversation!<br />
The blog is on-line at: http://blog.eurelectric.org/
eurelectric<br />
annual conference 2011<br />
stockholm 13-14 june 2011<br />
delivering investments<br />
to meet europe’s energy<br />
& climate needs<br />
Hosted by<br />
Sponsored by<br />
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
49
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
Our Partners<br />
50<br />
Generation<br />
Distribution<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> works in cooperation with a number of associations and organisations<br />
whose expertise supports and assists our strategic analysis and policy work. Besides<br />
the many and varied instances of ad hoc cooperation with a broad range of stakeholder<br />
representatives, <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> has a formal cooperation arrangement with organisations<br />
in various fields of expertise.<br />
Renewables<br />
Social<br />
Dialogue<br />
Transmission<br />
Emissions<br />
Trading<br />
Energy cooperation<br />
EPC-CIS<br />
Standardisation<br />
Electric Vehicles<br />
Research<br />
Electric Lighting<br />
Electric<br />
Applications
partner in focus<br />
Well-organised and successful cooperation<br />
between <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> and VGB has strengthened<br />
the electricity sector in Europe<br />
The well-established cooperation between<br />
VGB and <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> on power generation<br />
issues has proved its worth. Yet<br />
the challenges ahead make continued<br />
cooperation more necessary than<br />
ever, argues Dr Karl A. Theis, Executive<br />
Managing Director at VGB PowerTech.<br />
Mr Theis, VGB celebrated its 90 th anniversary<br />
this year – a proud moment for you?<br />
Yes, very much so. VGB was founded in 1920 by<br />
representatives of the electricity and chemical<br />
industries. Their motto: “Jointly committed to safety,<br />
optimum availability, high economic efficiency and<br />
environmental compatibility!” I am proud to say that<br />
this is still very much part of VGB PowerTech’s agenda<br />
today. As the European technical association for power<br />
and heat generation, VGB currently has 483 members<br />
from 34 countries, representing an installed power<br />
plant capacity of 520,000 MW.<br />
VGB PowerTech has a formal cooperation<br />
agreement with <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>. Can you expand<br />
a bit on recent cooperation efforts between these two<br />
longstanding partners?<br />
Over the past ten years, we have established a very<br />
well-organised and successful cooperation between<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> and VGB to strengthen the role and<br />
position of the electricity sector in Europe. Generally<br />
speaking, VGB provides its skills and expertise<br />
concerning the generation of heat and power, including<br />
environmental issues, related technologies and practical<br />
research and development projects.<br />
A concrete example of recent collaboration can be seen<br />
in VGB’s support for the <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> Power Choices<br />
study, which shows that it is feasible to attain carbonneutral<br />
electricity in Europe by using the entire range of<br />
electrical technologies and applications. Meeting the<br />
ambitious targets of industry and politics will require<br />
measurements for increasing energy efficiency,<br />
deployment of new renewables, new nuclear power<br />
plants, as well as carbon capture and storage techniques<br />
for fossil-fired power plants.<br />
What about the future: what do you see as the<br />
main challenges concerning electricity generation<br />
– and are there already any new cooperation projects in<br />
the pipeline?<br />
The future electricity system will undoubtedly become<br />
much more complex and challenging. With the intelligent<br />
use of efficient application technologies, electricity will<br />
be decisive in solving important problems of the entire<br />
energy supply system. Regarding power generation, the<br />
main areas of future work include efficiency increases<br />
and process optimisation, higher operational flexibility<br />
and optimisation of back-up capacity including storage<br />
facilities. Great efforts are still necessary to further<br />
develop these technologies, convince the public and<br />
obtain political support to enable a broad mix of lowcarbon<br />
power generation technologies in the future.<br />
As for upcoming projects, VGB is currently performing<br />
a study on system stability with the goal of identifying<br />
opportunities and constraints of a low-carbon power<br />
supply system with intermittent and dispatchable<br />
generation, in particular with regard to an optimal<br />
integration of more electricity based on renewable<br />
sources. <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> will deliver the required input<br />
regarding regulatory issues and political targets.<br />
Another area of cooperation is the Industrial Emissions<br />
Directive (IED) and related reference documents.<br />
VGB is supporting <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> in the technical<br />
argumentation and has taken the lead in describing<br />
the state of the art of power plant technologies.<br />
VGB and <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> are also cooperating on a<br />
comprehensive industry strategy for integrating<br />
renewables, particularly on assessing the need for<br />
and the technical feasibility of flexible and back-up<br />
capacity.<br />
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
51
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
Organisational and Expertise Structure<br />
52<br />
Energy Policy<br />
& Generation<br />
Committee<br />
WG Energy Policy<br />
WG Prospective<br />
WG Renewables & DG<br />
WG Nuclear<br />
WG Thermal<br />
WG Hydro<br />
WG R&D<br />
TF CCS<br />
TF Biomass<br />
NE Statistics & Prospects<br />
NE Small Island Systems<br />
Coordination<br />
Committee<br />
Markets<br />
Committee<br />
WG Wholesale Markets<br />
& Trading<br />
WG Retail Markets<br />
WG Regional Implementation<br />
WG Gas*<br />
TF Integration of RES<br />
TF Retail Market Model<br />
TF <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>-CIS EPC<br />
Cooperation<br />
Board<br />
of Directors<br />
Networks<br />
Committee**<br />
WG Distribution/<br />
Regulation & Policy<br />
WG Distribution/<br />
Customers & Operation<br />
WG Smart Grid/<br />
Network of the Future<br />
NE Standardisation<br />
TF Electric Vehicles<br />
NE T&D Interface<br />
Budget<br />
Committee<br />
Environment<br />
& Sustainable<br />
Development Policy<br />
Committee<br />
WG Env. Protection<br />
WG Waste & Residues<br />
WG Env. Management<br />
& Economics<br />
WG Climate Change<br />
WG Energy Efficiency<br />
WG Env. & Society<br />
* Joint WG with Energy Policy & Generation Committee<br />
** The Networks Committee is composed of the "DSO’s Directors Gathering" (representatives of DSOs and associations representing DSOs)<br />
and the "Networks Council"(representatives of <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>'s Full Member Associations).<br />
WG: Working Group<br />
TF: Task Force<br />
NE: Network of Experts<br />
FG: Focus Group<br />
Group Managed by the Secretariat:<br />
NE Communication Managers<br />
Management<br />
Committee<br />
WG Legal Affairs<br />
WG Social Affairs & HR<br />
NE Fiscal<br />
FG Finance &<br />
Economics<br />
FG Enterprise Risk<br />
Management<br />
As on 31 December <strong>2010</strong>
Second Vice President Secretary General<br />
President Vice President<br />
Johannes TEYSSEN (DE) Hans TEN BERGE (NL)<br />
Fulvio CONTI (IT)<br />
Lars G. JOSEFSSON (SE)<br />
Environment and Sustainable<br />
Markets Committee Development Policy Committee Networks Committee**<br />
Management Committee<br />
Energy Policy<br />
and Generation Committee<br />
Marco MARGHERI (IT)<br />
Vice Chairman<br />
Luc VAN NUFFEL (BE)<br />
Chairman<br />
Manuel RODRIGUES<br />
DA COSTA (PT)<br />
Vice Chairman<br />
Peter BIRKNER (DE)<br />
Chairman<br />
Giuseppe<br />
MONTESANO (IT)<br />
Vice Chairman<br />
Owen WILSON (IE)<br />
Chairman<br />
Eric VAN VLIET (NL)<br />
Vice Chairman<br />
Gunnar LUNDBERG (SE)<br />
Chairman<br />
Oluf ULSETH (NO)<br />
Vice Chairman<br />
David PORTER OBE (GB)<br />
Chairman<br />
Emanuela PREITI (IT)<br />
WG Social Affairs<br />
& Human Resources<br />
Argyris ECONOMOU (GR)<br />
WG Legal Affairs<br />
Petter SANDØY (NO)<br />
WG Distribution/<br />
Customers & Operation<br />
Manuel RODRIGUES<br />
DA COSTA (PT)<br />
WG Distribution/<br />
Regulation & Policy<br />
Claude NAHON (FR)<br />
WG Energy Efficiency<br />
Tomas CHMELIK (CZ)<br />
WG Climate Change<br />
Roel KALJEE (NL)<br />
WG Retail Markets<br />
TF Retail Target Model<br />
Juan José ALBA<br />
RIOS (ES)<br />
WG Wholesale Markets<br />
& Trading<br />
Tomas MÜLLER (AT)<br />
WG Prospective<br />
Gwyn DOLBEN (GB)<br />
WG Energy Policy,<br />
TF CCS<br />
Michael LÄNGLE (AT)<br />
FG Finance & Economics<br />
Guido VANHOVE (BE)<br />
NE Fiscal<br />
José Luis GUTIERREZ<br />
IGLESIAS (ES)<br />
NE Standardisation<br />
Per HALLBERG (SE)<br />
WG Smart Grids/<br />
Networks of the Future<br />
Jean-Guy<br />
BARTAIRE (FR)<br />
WG Environmental Protection<br />
Walter RUIJGROK (NL)<br />
WG Environmental<br />
Management & Economics<br />
Inge PIERRE (SE)<br />
WG Gas<br />
(joint WG with EP&G)<br />
Gunnar LUNDBERG (SE)<br />
WG Regional Implementation<br />
Jozsef BAJSZ (HU)<br />
WG Nuclear<br />
Charles NIELSEN (DK)<br />
WG Renewables &<br />
Distributed Generation<br />
Vittorio D’ECCLESIIS (IT)<br />
FG Enterprise Risk Management<br />
Alan MICHIE (GB)<br />
NE T&D Interface<br />
Thomas THEISEN (DE)<br />
TF Electric Vehicles<br />
Steve WAYGOOD (GB)<br />
WG Waste & Residues<br />
Martti HYVÖNEN (FI)<br />
WG Environment & Society<br />
Marcel CAILLIAU (BE)<br />
TF Integration of RES<br />
Jan SUNDELL (SE)<br />
TF <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>-CIS EPC<br />
Cooperation<br />
Otto PIRKER (AT)<br />
WG Hydro<br />
Jörg KERLEN (DE)<br />
WG Thermal<br />
** The Networks Committee is composed of the “DSO’s Directors<br />
Gathering” (representatives of DSOs and associations<br />
representing DSOs) and the “Networks Council”<br />
(representatives of <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>’s Full Member Associations).<br />
Jeppe BJERG (DK)<br />
TF Biomass<br />
Hakon MOSBECH (DK)<br />
WG R&D<br />
Group Managed by the Secretariat<br />
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
Jan PETERS (NL)<br />
Chairman DSO’s<br />
Directors Gathering<br />
WG: Working Group<br />
NE: Network of Experts<br />
TF: Task Force<br />
FG: Focus Group<br />
Gaël GLORIEUX<br />
Network of Communication Managers<br />
David PADFIELD (GB)<br />
NE Small Island Systems<br />
Tomas MÜLLER (AT)<br />
NE Statistics & Prospects<br />
As on 31 December <strong>2010</strong><br />
53
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
54<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> Staff<br />
VERONICA WADE<br />
Personal Assistant to the Secretary General<br />
HANS TEN BERGE<br />
Secretary General<br />
Administration<br />
and Information Technology Unit<br />
Policy<br />
Coordination and<br />
Communication Unit<br />
Environment<br />
and Sustainable<br />
Development<br />
Policy Unit<br />
Networks<br />
Unit<br />
Markets<br />
Unit<br />
Energy Policy and<br />
Generation Unit<br />
MARC DENYS<br />
Head of Unit<br />
ANNE-MARIE REGO<br />
Head of Policy Management<br />
JOHN SCOWCROFT<br />
Head of Unit<br />
GUNNAR LORENZ<br />
Head of Unit<br />
ANNE-MALORIE GéRON<br />
Head of Unit<br />
SUSANNE NIES<br />
Head of Unit<br />
Events<br />
Finance and<br />
Administration<br />
Information<br />
Technology<br />
GAëL GLORIEUX<br />
Public Affairs Officer<br />
HéLèNE LAVRAY<br />
Advisor<br />
PIERRE SCHLOSSER<br />
Advisor<br />
MARCO FORESTI<br />
Advisor<br />
SAM CROSS<br />
Advisor<br />
EMILY O’LEARY<br />
Events Coordinator<br />
MICHèLE DUBOIS<br />
Advisor<br />
ROMAIN JOURDAN<br />
Advisor<br />
JULIA EICHHORST<br />
Communication Officer<br />
NICOLA REGA<br />
Advisor<br />
SOPHIE TIELEMANS<br />
Policy Officer<br />
OLGA MIKHAILOVA<br />
Advisor<br />
ARTA DENINA<br />
Advisor<br />
CARINE BUSARD<br />
Accounting Assistant<br />
DIEGO NOMEN<br />
Assistant<br />
JEANNETTE PABST<br />
Researcher (non-permanent)<br />
BRIGITTE FRANCE<br />
Assistant<br />
KOEN NOYENS<br />
Policy Officer<br />
BERNARDO RANGONI<br />
Advisor<br />
GIUSEPPE LORUBIO<br />
Advisor<br />
GEOFFREY LADEUZE<br />
Assistant<br />
FATIMA EL KADERI<br />
Web Designer<br />
PAVLA MANDOTOVA<br />
Seconded Policy Officer<br />
NATHALIE HAESEVOETS<br />
Assistant<br />
EMMA-LOUISE BEDFORD<br />
Assistant<br />
MARIE DEBOIS<br />
Assistant<br />
ANN DUBOIS<br />
Assistant<br />
CHARLOTTE RENAUD<br />
Policy Officer - Management<br />
Committee<br />
As on 31 December <strong>2010</strong>
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> Member Organisations<br />
FULL MEMBERS (33)<br />
COUNTRY MEMBER ORGANISATION<br />
Austria Verband der Elektrizitätsunternehmen Österreichs (VEÖ)<br />
(Association of Austrian Electricity Companies)<br />
Belgium Fédération Belge des Entreprises Electriques et Gazières (FEBEG)<br />
Federatie van de Belgische Elektriciteits- en Gasbedrijven (FEBEG)<br />
(Federation of Belgian Electricity and Gas Companies)<br />
Fédération des gestionnaires de réseaux électricité et gaz en Belgique - SYNERGRID<br />
Federatie van de Elektriciteits- en Gasnetbeheerders in België - SYNERGRID<br />
(Federation of the Electricity and Gas network operators in Belgium – SYNERGRID)<br />
Bulgaria Bulgarian Electric Power Association<br />
Croatia Croatia <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> Section – Croatian Chamber of Economy<br />
Cyprus Electricity Authority of Cyprus<br />
Czech Republic Cesky svaz zamestnavatelu v energetice (CSZE)<br />
(Czech Association of Energy Sector Employers)<br />
Denmark Dansk Energi<br />
(Association of Danish Energy Companies)<br />
Estonia The Union of Electricity Industry of Estonia<br />
Finland Energiateollisuus ry<br />
(Finnish Energy Industries)<br />
France Union Française de l’Electricité (UFE)<br />
Germany Bundesverband der Energie- und Wasserwirtschaft e.V (BDEW)<br />
(German Association of Energy and Water Industries)<br />
Greece Hellenic Electricity Association (HELAS)<br />
Hungary <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> Magyarorszagi Tagozat<br />
(Hungarian <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> Association – H<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>)<br />
Iceland SAMORKA - Icelandic Energy and Utilities<br />
Ireland National Electricity Association of Ireland<br />
Italy Unione dell’Elettricità Italiana (UNEI)<br />
(Union of Italian Electricity)<br />
Latvia Latvian Association of Power Engineers and Energy Constructors<br />
Lithuania Lithuanian Electricity Association<br />
Luxembourg Organisation des Entreprises d’Electricité du Luxembourg<br />
(National Luxembourg Electricity Association)<br />
Macedonia, Former<br />
Yugoslav Republic (FYROM)<br />
Macedonian Energy Association<br />
Malta ENEMALTA Corporation<br />
Netherlands Energie-Nederlands<br />
Norway Energi Norge (Energy Norway)<br />
Poland Polski Komitet Energii Elektrycznej (PKEE)<br />
(Polish Electricity Association )<br />
Portugal Associação Portuguesa das Empresas do Sector Eléctrico (ELECPOR)<br />
(Portuguese Association of Electric Power Utilities)<br />
Romania Romanian Institute for Energy Development Studies (IRE)<br />
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
55
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
56<br />
Slovakia Zväzu zamestnávatel’ov energetiky Slovenska (ZZES)<br />
(Union of Employers of Power Industry in Slovakia)<br />
Slovenia Slovenian Chamber of Commerce, Energy Association, <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> Section<br />
Spain Asociación Española de la Industria Eléctrica (UNESA)<br />
(Spanish Association of the Electric Industry)<br />
Sweden Svensk Energi Swedenergy AB<br />
Switzerland Verband Schweizerischer Elektrizitätsunternehmen (VSE)<br />
Association des Enterprises électriques Suisses (AES)<br />
Swiss Electricity Industry Association (SEIA)<br />
Turkey Türkiye Elektrik Sanayi Birliği (TESAB)<br />
(Turkish Electricity Industry Association)<br />
United Kingdom Association of Electricity Producers (AEP), in conjunction with Energy Networks<br />
Association (ENA)<br />
EUROPEAN AFFILIATE MEMBERS (8)<br />
COUNTRY MEMBER ORGANISATION<br />
Albania Korporata Elektroenergjitike Shipètare (KESH)<br />
Belarus Belenergo<br />
Bosnia-Herzegovina Elektroprivreda Bosne I Hercegovine<br />
Monaco Société Monégasque de l’Electricité et du Gaz (SMEG)<br />
Russia NP Market Council<br />
Serbia Electric Power Industry of Serbia<br />
Ukraine Ukrenergo<br />
United Kingdom Jersey Electricity Company Ltd.<br />
MEDITERRANEAN AFFILIATE MEMBERS (5)<br />
COUNTRY MEMBER ORGANISATION<br />
Algeria Société Nationale de l’Electricité et du Gaz (SONELGAZ)<br />
Egypt Egyptian Electricity Holding Company<br />
Israel The Israel Electric Corporation Ltd.<br />
Morocco Office National de l’Electricité (ONE)<br />
Tunisia Société Tunisienne de l’Electricité et du Gaz (STEG)<br />
INTERNATIONAL AFFILIATE MEMBERS (6)<br />
COUNTRY MEMBER ORGANISATION<br />
Japan Central Research Institute of Electric Power Industry (CRIEPI)<br />
Kazakhstan Kazakhstan Electricity Grid Operating Company (KEGOC)<br />
Mauritius Central Electricity Board<br />
Mexico Comision Federal de Electricidad<br />
South Africa Eskom<br />
United Arab Emirates Abu Dhabi Water and Electricity Authority (ADWEA)
EI ASSOCIATES (8)<br />
COUNTRY MEMBER ORGANISATION<br />
France Compagnie Nationale du Rhône (CNR)<br />
Switzerland BKW/FMB Energie AG<br />
Switzerland Alpiq Suisse SA<br />
Switzerland Goupe E<br />
Switzerland Onyx Energie Mittelland<br />
Switzerland Rätia Energie<br />
Switzerland Romande-Energie<br />
Switzerland Services Industriels de Genève<br />
BUSINESS ASSOCIATES (30)<br />
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
Accenture<br />
Alstom<br />
Amsterdam Power Exchange<br />
Areva<br />
ABB<br />
BWSC - Burmeister & Wain Scandinavian Contractor A/S<br />
CESI - Centro Elettrotecnico Sperimentale Italiano<br />
CERA - Cambridge Energy Research Associates<br />
Delta Energy & Environment<br />
D.TEK<br />
EA Technology<br />
E-Bridge Consulting GmbH<br />
Energy Insights<br />
EPEX Spot SE<br />
European Energy Exchange<br />
General Electric Power Systems<br />
IBM<br />
Itron<br />
Kema Consulting<br />
Landis+Gyr Ltd<br />
Lighthouse Consulting Group<br />
MMC Group - Oliver Wyman<br />
Nexant<br />
OMEL<br />
Ormazabal<br />
Poyry Energy Consultants<br />
Pricewaterhouse Coopers<br />
Rabobank<br />
Siemens AG<br />
Tesla Europe Ltd As on 31 December <strong>2010</strong><br />
57
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> Board of Directors<br />
58<br />
President First Vice President<br />
Mr. Lars G. JOSEFSSON<br />
Former President & CEO<br />
Vattenfall AB<br />
Secretary General<br />
Mr. Hans ten BERGE<br />
Secretary General<br />
Union of the Electricity Industry -<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong><br />
COUNTRY MEMBER SUBSTITUTE<br />
AUSTRIA Dr. Ulrike BAUMGARTNER-GABITZER<br />
Member of the Managing Board<br />
Verbund (Österreichische<br />
Elektrizitätswirtschafts-AG)<br />
BELGIUM Mr. Jean-Pierre HANSEN<br />
Member of the Executive Committee<br />
ELECTRABEL GDF SUEZ<br />
BULGARIA Mr. Krasimir PARVANOV<br />
Executive Director of NEK<br />
Natsionalna Elektricheska Kompania EAD<br />
(NEK EAD)<br />
CROATIA<br />
(local name: Hrvatska)<br />
Mr. Leo BEGOVIC<br />
President of the Management Board<br />
HRVATSKA ELEKTOPRIVREDA D.D<br />
CYPRUS Dr. Stelios STYLIANOU<br />
General Manager<br />
Electricity Authority of Cyprus<br />
CZECH REPUBLIC Mr. Martin ROMAN<br />
Chairman of the Board of Directors & CEO<br />
CEZ, a. s.<br />
DENMARK Mr. Anders ELDRUP<br />
Chief Executive Officer<br />
DONG Energy (GENTOFTE - DK)<br />
ESTONIA Mr. Sandor LIIVE<br />
Chairman of the Management Board<br />
& CEO<br />
Eesti Energia AS<br />
FINLAND Mr. Juha NAUKKARINEN<br />
Managing Director<br />
Energiateollisuus ry,<br />
Finsk Energiindustri rf<br />
Mr. Fulvio CONTI<br />
CEO and General Manager<br />
Enel S.p.A<br />
Second Vice President<br />
Dr. Jur. Johannes TEYSSEN<br />
CEO<br />
E.ON AG<br />
Dr. Barbara SCHMIDT<br />
Secretary General<br />
Association of Austrian Electricity<br />
Companies (VEO)<br />
Mr. Jan HERREMANS<br />
General Manager<br />
Fédération Belge des Entreprises<br />
Electriques et Gazières ASBL<br />
Mrs. Nelly STANIMIROVA<br />
Head of Foreign Relations Department<br />
Natsionalna Elektricheska Kompania<br />
EAD (NEK EAD)<br />
Mr. Damir PECVARAC<br />
Member of the Board<br />
HRVATSKA ELEKTOPRIVREDA d.d<br />
Dr. Venizelos EFTHYMIOU<br />
Network Development Projects Manager<br />
Electricity Authority of Cyprus<br />
Mr. Alan SVOBODA<br />
Executive Director Sales and Trading<br />
CEZ, a.s.<br />
Mr. Lars AAGAARD<br />
Managing Director<br />
Dansk Energi (Association of Danish<br />
Energy Companies)<br />
Mr. Jaanus Arukaevu<br />
Chairman of the Management Board<br />
Union of the Electricity Industry of<br />
Estonia<br />
Mr. Pertti SALMINEN<br />
Director, International & EU Affairs<br />
Energiateollisuus ry,<br />
Finsk Energiindustri rf
FRANCE Mr. Robert DURDILLY<br />
Président<br />
Union Française de l’Electricité (UFE)<br />
GERMANY Dr. Arndt NEUHAUS<br />
Chairman of the Board<br />
RWE Rheinland Westfalen Netz AG<br />
GREECE Mr. Arthouros ZERVOS<br />
Chairman & CEO<br />
Public Power Corporation S.A.<br />
HUNGARY Dr. Károly GERSE<br />
Deputy General Director<br />
EMT - Eurelectric Magyarorszàgi Tagozata<br />
ICELAND Mr. Eiríkur BOGASON<br />
General Manager<br />
SAMORKA Icelandic Energy and Utilities<br />
IRELAND Mr. Padraig McMANUS<br />
Chief Executive Officer<br />
Electricity Supply Board (ESB)<br />
ITALY Mr. Enzo GATTA<br />
President<br />
UNEI - Unione dell Elettricita Italiana<br />
LATVIA Dr. Aris ZIGURS<br />
Chairman of the Board<br />
Latvenergo<br />
LITHUANIA Mr. Vladas PASKEVICIUS<br />
President<br />
Lietuvos Elektros Energetikos Asociacija<br />
LUXEMBOURG Mr. Romain BECKER<br />
CEO<br />
Creos Luxembourg<br />
MACEDONIA, THE FORMER<br />
YUGOSLAV REPUBLIC OF<br />
Mr. Vlatko CINGOSKI<br />
General Manager - President of<br />
the Management Board<br />
JSC Macedonian Power Plants<br />
MALTA Mr. Edmund GATT BALDACCHINO<br />
Chairman<br />
ENEMALTA Corporation<br />
NETHERLANDS Mr. Hans ALDERS<br />
President<br />
Energie-Nederland<br />
NORWAY Mr. Oluf ULSETH<br />
Senior Vice President, European Affairs<br />
Statkraft Energy AS (OSLO)<br />
POLAND Mr. Tomasz ZADROGA<br />
Chairman<br />
Polska Grupa Energetyczna sa - PGE<br />
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
Mr. Stéphane MOREL<br />
Vice-Président<br />
Union Française de l’Electricité (UFE)<br />
Ms. Hildegard MUELLER<br />
Chair of the Executive Board<br />
Bundesverband der Energie- und<br />
Wasserwirtschaft e.V.<br />
Prof. Nikos HATZIARGYRIOU<br />
Vice-Chairman and Deputy CEO<br />
Public Power Corporation (PPC)<br />
Mr. István BAKÁCS<br />
Vice Chairman<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> Magyarorszagi Tagozat (EMT)<br />
Mr. Gústaf Adolf SKULASON<br />
Deputy Director General<br />
SAMORKA Icelandic Energy and Utilities<br />
Dr. Fergal McNAMARA<br />
Group Regulation Manager<br />
Electricity Supply Board (ESB)<br />
Mr. Adolfo SPAZIANI<br />
Vice-President<br />
UNEI - Unione dell Elettricita Italiana<br />
Mr. Rolands LUSVERIS<br />
Head of Regulatory Affairs<br />
Latvenergo<br />
Dipl.-Ing. Gintaras ADZGAUSKAS<br />
Specialist & Director of the Lithuanian<br />
Member Committee of the World Energy<br />
Council<br />
Lietuvos Elektros Energetikos Asociacija<br />
Mr. Claude STRASSER<br />
Secrétaire Général<br />
Société électrique de l’Our SA (SEO)<br />
Mr. Dimitar TANURKOV<br />
Manager of Generation, Member<br />
of the Management Board<br />
JSC Macedonian Power Plants<br />
Ing. Karl CAMILLERI<br />
Chief Executive Officer<br />
ENEMALTA Corporation<br />
Mr. Eric W.O. VAN VLIET<br />
Managing Director<br />
Energie-Nederland<br />
Mr. Snorre LAMARK<br />
Director<br />
Energi Norge<br />
Mr. Dariusz LUBERA<br />
President<br />
TAURON Polska Energia SA<br />
59
activity report <strong>2010</strong><br />
60<br />
PORTUGAL Mr. João MANSO NETO<br />
Member of the Executive Board<br />
EDP - Energias de Portugal<br />
ROMANIA Mr. Teodor-Ovidiu POP<br />
General Manager<br />
Verbund-Romania SC<br />
SLOVAKIA<br />
(Slovak Republic)<br />
Mr. Nicola COTUGNO<br />
Member of the Board of the Directors and<br />
Director of Power Division<br />
Slovenske elektrarne, A.S.<br />
SLOVENIA Mr. Djordje ZEBELJAN<br />
Executive Director for R&D<br />
Holding Slovenske Elektrarne d.o.o.<br />
SPAIN Mr. Gerardo HERMO BLANCO<br />
Director of Economics & Finance<br />
Asociación Española de la Industria<br />
Eléctrica (UNESA)<br />
SWEDEN Mr. Kjell JANSSON<br />
Managing Director<br />
Svensk Energi Swedenergy AB<br />
SWITZERLAND Mr. Hans Eberhard SCHWEICKARDT<br />
Président du conseil d’administration<br />
Alpiq Holding Ltd. (Neuchatel - CH)<br />
TURKEY Mr. Halil ALIS<br />
General Manager - Chairman of the<br />
Executive Board of TESAB<br />
Türkiye Elektrik Iletim A.S. (TEIAS)<br />
UNITED KINGDOM Mr. David PORTER, OBE<br />
Chief Executive<br />
Association of Electricity Producers<br />
Limited - AEP<br />
European Affiliate<br />
Member<br />
Observers<br />
Mr. Dmitry PONOMAREV<br />
Chairman of the Board<br />
NP “Market Council” / COBET PbIHKA<br />
Russia<br />
President of MEDELEC Dr. Ahmad Abdalla HIYASAT<br />
Managing Director<br />
National Electric Power Company (NEPCO)<br />
Jordan<br />
Eng. João Nascimento BAPTISTA<br />
Executive Director<br />
Associacao Portuguesa das Empresas do<br />
Sector Electrico, ELECPOR<br />
Mr. Stelian-Alexandru GAL<br />
Deputy Director General<br />
TRANSELECTRICA SA<br />
Mr. Alexander KŠINAN<br />
CEO<br />
Elektrovod Holding a.s.<br />
Mr. Ivan SMON<br />
Director of Technical Sector<br />
SODO d.o.o.<br />
Mr. Angel Luis VIVAR<br />
Director of Energy Resources &<br />
Environment<br />
Asociación Española de la Industria<br />
Eléctrica (UNESA)<br />
Mr. Staffan WESTLIN<br />
President & CEO<br />
Skelleftea Kraft AB<br />
Mr. Josef A. DUERR<br />
Managing Director<br />
Verband Schweizerischer<br />
Elektrizitätsunternehmen (VSE/AES)<br />
Mr. Fahrettin Amir ARMAN<br />
General Manager<br />
AYEN Energy Company<br />
Mr. David SMITH<br />
Chief Executive<br />
Energy Networks Association (ENA)<br />
As on 31 December <strong>2010</strong>
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> in Brief<br />
The Union of the Electricity Industry – <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong> is the sector association representing the common<br />
interests of the electricity industry at pan-European level, plus its affiliates and associates on several<br />
other continents.<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>’s mission is to contribute to the development and competitiveness of the electricity<br />
industry and to promote the role of electricity in the advancement of society.<br />
<strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>’s Full Member structure is based on national representation, via the national electricity<br />
association, where such a body exists, or the leading electricity enterprise in each country. Currently<br />
there are 33 Full Members, including all 27 EU Member States, current applicants negotiating to join the<br />
European Union, plus other European OECD countries.<br />
Membership is enriched by European and International Affiliate Members representing the electricity<br />
industry across the rest of Europe, in the Mediterranean basin and on other continents, and by Business<br />
Associate Members from other sectors with stakeholder links to or interest in the electricity industry.<br />
Publisher: Hans ten Berge<br />
Managing & Production Editor: Julia Eichhorst<br />
Design & Layout: www.generis.be<br />
Photos: <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong>, Gettyimages (pages 13, 21, 22),<br />
Dreamstime (pages cover, 4, 10, 11, 12, 14, 15, 16, 17,<br />
18, 20, 22, 23, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 33, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39,<br />
40, 41, 42, 49), istockphoto (pages 28, 30, 34)
Union of the Electricity Industry - <strong>EURELECTRIC</strong><br />
www.generis.be<br />
Boulevard de l’Impératrice, 66 boîte 2 tel: + 32 (0)2 515 10 00<br />
by<br />
1000 Brussels fax: + 32 (0)2 515 10 10<br />
Belgium website: www.eurelectric.org Design