10.10.2013 Views

FISHERIES AND MARINE SERVICE Translation Series No. 4334 ...

FISHERIES AND MARINE SERVICE Translation Series No. 4334 ...

FISHERIES AND MARINE SERVICE Translation Series No. 4334 ...

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

•■■<br />

<strong>FISHERIES</strong> <strong>AND</strong> <strong>MARINE</strong> <strong>SERVICE</strong><br />

<strong>Translation</strong> <strong>Series</strong> <strong>No</strong>.<br />

<strong>4334</strong><br />

Contribution to the evaluation of herring fillets<br />

designated as Matjes herrings from the point of<br />

view of food regulations<br />

by J. Wurziger<br />

Original title: Beitrag zur lebensmittelrechtlichen Beurteilung<br />

von Heringsfilets mit "Matjes" - Bezeichnungen<br />

From: Fleischwirtschaft (10): 1831-1834, 1977<br />

Translated by the <strong>Translation</strong> Bureau (KMF)<br />

Multilingual Services Division<br />

Department of the Secretary of State of Canada<br />

17 pages typescript<br />

Department of the Environment<br />

Fisheries and Marine Service<br />

Halifax Laboratory<br />

Halifax, N. S.<br />

1978


'11<br />

DEPARTMENT oe THE. SE'CRETARY OF STATE<br />

TRANSLATED FROM - TRADUCTION DE<br />

German<br />

AUTHOR - AUTEUR<br />

PUBLISHER - ÉDITEUR<br />

PLACE OF PUBLICATION<br />

LIEU DE PUBLICATION<br />

TRANSLATION BUREAU<br />

SECRÉTARIAT D'ÉTAT<br />

BUREAU DES TRADUCTIONS<br />

MULTILINGUAL <strong>SERVICE</strong>S DIVISION DES <strong>SERVICE</strong>S<br />

not shown<br />

REQUESTING DEPARTMENT Environment — Fisheries<br />

MINISTÉRE-CLIENT<br />

BRANCH OR DIVISION<br />

DIRECTION OU DIVISION<br />

YOUR NUMBER<br />

VOTRE DOSSIER re<br />

not shown<br />

DATE OF REQUEST<br />

DATE DE LA DEM<strong>AND</strong>E<br />

Johs. Wurziger<br />

TITLE IN ENGLISH - TITRE ANGLAIS<br />

CANADA<br />

DIVISION MULTILINGUES<br />

INTO - EN<br />

Scientific Information &<br />

Publications<br />

1486846<br />

9.5.78<br />

YEAR<br />

ANNÉE<br />

1977<br />

English<br />

DATE OF PUBLICATION<br />

DATE DE PUBLICATION<br />

VOLUME<br />

ISSUE NO.<br />

NUMÉR O<br />

10<br />

TRANSLATION BUREAU NO.<br />

NOTRE DOSSIER N 0<br />

TRANSLATOR (INITIALS)<br />

TRADUCTEUR (INITIALES)<br />

elm 4(334<br />

Contribution to the evaluation of herring fillets designated as Matjes<br />

herrings from the point of view of food regulations.<br />

TITLE IN FOREIGN LANGUAGE (TRANSLITERATE FOREIGN CHARACTERS)<br />

TITRE EN LANGUE ÉTRANGÉRE (TRANSCRIRE EN CARACTÉRES ROMAINS)<br />

lleitrag zur lebensmittelrechtlichen Beurteilung von Heringsfilets<br />

mit "Matjes"—Bezeichnungen.<br />

REFERENCE IN FOREIGN LANGUAGE (NAME OF BOOK OR PUBLICATION) IN FULL. TRANSLITERATE ,FOREIGN CHARACTERS.<br />

RÉFÉRENCE EN LANGUE ÉTRANGÉRE (NOM DU LIVRE OU PUBLICATION), AU COMPLET, TRANSCRIRE EN CARACTÉRES ROMAINS.<br />

Die Fleischwirtschaft<br />

REFERENCE IN ENGLISH - RÉFÉRENCE EN ANGLAIS<br />

PERSON REQUESTING<br />

DEM<strong>AND</strong>É PAR<br />

SOS-200-10-6 (REV. 2/85)<br />

7530-21-029-5333<br />

Meat Industry<br />

Dr. Ackman<br />

PAGE NUMBERS IN ORIGINAL<br />

NUMÉROS DES PAGES DANS<br />

L'ORIGINAL<br />

1831 — 1834<br />

NUMBER OF TYPED PAGES<br />

NOMBRE DE PAGES<br />

DACTYLOGRAPHIÉES<br />

17<br />

1486846<br />

KMF<br />

JUL 2 597B


I + Secretary Secrétariat<br />

of State d'État<br />

MULTILINGUAL <strong>SERVICE</strong>S<br />

DIVISION<br />

DIVISION DES <strong>SERVICE</strong>S<br />

MULTILINGUES<br />

Client's <strong>No</strong>. - NO du client Department - Ministère Division/Branch - Division/Direction City - Ville<br />

Environment, Scientific Information & Ottawa<br />

Fisheries Publications<br />

Bureau <strong>No</strong>. - NO du bureau Language - Langue Translator ( Initials) - Traducteur (initiales)<br />

1486846 German KMF<br />

SEC 5-25 (2/78)<br />

Die Fleischwirtschaft (Meat Industry) <strong>No</strong>. 10 (1977) pp. 1831 - 1834<br />

Contribution to the evaluation of herring fillets<br />

designated as Matjes herrings from the point of view<br />

of food regulations<br />

Johs. Wurziger<br />

Chemische und Lebensmitteluntersuchungsanstalt im<br />

Hygienischen Institut der Freien und Hansestadt Hamburg*<br />

JUL `.<br />

Herring products gain in taste, aroma and tenderness with an in-<br />

creasing fat content of the fish. On the basis of the correlation<br />

between fat content and quality, special importance must be ascribed<br />

to the designations within the framework of food control. The differences<br />

between salt herrings and Matjes herrings are discussed and it is shown<br />

that the use of herrings of a certain sexual maturity* combined with<br />

mild salting, is a prerequisite for the designation "Matjes". Changes<br />

in trade practices and consumer habits have led to the preferred use<br />

of filleted herrings. The degree of maturity cannot, however, be exa-<br />

mined in fillets. A high fat content is the typical characteristic of<br />

unfilled herrings which is also easily monitored in fillets. A fat<br />

content of 15% based on the herring fillets of the raw material is re-<br />

commended as the basis for evaluation. It is shown by commercial products<br />

*Chemical and Food^Re^Fsearch Division in the Institute of Hygiene of the<br />

Free and Hanse&^r^ Hamburg<br />

' i978


(Matjes herrings and Matjes fillets in oil and other liquids) that the<br />

important factor in the evaluation of "Matjes" characteristics is the<br />

fat content of the herring meat. The salt content is a convenient<br />

factor for supplementing the assessment. - Loss of fat from the herring<br />

fillets is unavoidable during processing, storage and preparation for<br />

examination. However, the possible loss of fat does not appear to<br />

exceed 2% in fillets containing 15% fat. Thus the requirements for the<br />

designation "Matjes" fillets are still met with 13% fat in the fillet.-<br />

Word combinations with "Matjes" applied to fillets which do not meet<br />

the minimum fat content requirements for a fat herring are permissible<br />

only if mild herring fillets, cured according to the anchovy method<br />

are involved. The specific processing must be indicated in a suitable<br />

manner on the label.<br />

For the fish-processing industry the herring is of uncommonly<br />

great economic importance. Depending on fishing season and fishing<br />

grounds, herring occurs with a fat content from 3% to 30%. The fat<br />

content of the herrings which are processed here fluctuates most fre-<br />

quently between 8% and 25%. On the basis of natural fluctuations in<br />

fat content we differentiate between fat and lean herrings, although<br />

a firm limit value does not exist. For the industrial processing of<br />

herring this differentiation is of considerable significance because<br />

herring products gain in taste, aroma and tenderness with an increasing<br />

fat content of the herring. The fat content is therefore of interest<br />

not only for processing, but - due to the close relationship existing<br />

2


etween fat content and quality — it assumes importance also for specific<br />

labelling ,and information concerning the herring preparation within the<br />

framework of food control.<br />

In the case of packaged products the consumer is informed of<br />

the specific preparation of the contents through the text on the label.<br />

The name of the contents permits conclusions as to the raw material used<br />

and its composition. However, from such indications the difficulties<br />

which arise before and after processing of the fish cannot be judged.<br />

The great sensitivity of the raw material naturally makes it difficult<br />

to render the fish meat stable for a sufficient length of time. With<br />

the industrially applied methods it is therefore very important to re-<br />

duce or prevent enzymatic activity and bacterial growth. At the same<br />

time it is also important to inhibit the course of oxidative fat changes<br />

for an appropriate length of time.<br />

For this purpose one of the most essential substances in the<br />

fish—processing industry is table salt. This substance not only con-<br />

tributes to better stability but also has a favourable effect on the<br />

consistency and taste of the fish meat.<br />

While marinated herring products can all be grouped together into<br />

a class with a similar type of preparation, salted herring products must<br />

be subdivided much more extensively although salt plays a decisive role<br />

in all cases as the factor which renders the product ready to eat. This<br />

is due to the fact that herrings are first differentiated according to<br />

their state of sexual maturity and are, furthermore, salted to varying<br />

degrees. Weakly (mild) and heavily salted herrings and their products<br />

3


are generally not only evaluated differently but are also given very<br />

different labels. In any assessment the fat content is of decisive<br />

importance. This holds true for the designation as well as the stabi-<br />

lity of the herring products, especially since herring oil (like other<br />

animal fats and oils) has few natural protective substances and thus<br />

easily undergoes oxidative fat changes under the influence of atmos-<br />

pheric oxygen. Changes in fish oil also manifest themselves in fatty<br />

peroxides but the changes are more easily detectable by a taste of<br />

fish oil and a yellow to brown discoloration on the edges of the meat<br />

and particularly by discoloration of the abdominal pieces. From this<br />

it follows that the assessment of fish meat from the point of view of<br />

food law is often based on results obtained by special techniques.<br />

This will be discussed later in a different context.<br />

For fresh herring the fat content of the meat can be determined<br />

with sufficient accuracy via the water content from the fat—water—line<br />

according to C.H. Brandes and R. Dietrich (1). This method is based on<br />

the auount of fat obtained by acid decomposition and determination of<br />

the water content of the fish meat by vacuum drying. The fat—water<br />

line yields good results as long as one deals with fresh fish; however,<br />

it no longer yields comparably good results with "fresh fish" from deep-<br />

frozen herring. This holds true to a larger degree for herrings which<br />

had been treated in other ways. Preservation by salting is one of these<br />

methods. To evaluate the correlation between fat and water in herrings,<br />

fat—water lines must be determined for all treatment steps. This too,<br />

will be discussed later in a different context.<br />

4


The designation "salted herring" commonly applies to products<br />

which have been made palatable by the action of table salt and at the<br />

same time were rendered stable for a limited period of time. <strong>No</strong><br />

special requirements exist for herrings which are intended for pro-<br />

cessing into salt herrings. Fat as well as lean herrings are used<br />

for this purpose. In the Guidelines to Regulation <strong>No</strong>. 83 of the former<br />

Central Committee of the German Fish Industry of 13th October 1938,<br />

the degree of sexual maturity played a special role for the classifi-<br />

cation of herrings into various categories. This classification es-<br />

tablished at that time has been maintained unchanged until the present.<br />

The following groups therefore exist for salt herrings:<br />

1. Matjes herrings, prepared from fresh, fat herrings without<br />

any externally recognizeable traces of mut or roe. Matjes herrings<br />

are kept mild (mildly salted).<br />

2. Fat herrings, prepared from fresh, fat herrings without any<br />

externally recognizeable traces of mut or roe. Fat herrings are well (1832)<br />

salted.<br />

3. Mild, whole herrings, prepared from fresh, fat herrings which<br />

contain externally recognizeable mut or roe. The herrings are kept<br />

mild (mildly salted).<br />

4. Whole herrings, prepared from herrings which contain externally<br />

recognizeable milt or roe. Whole herrings are well salted.<br />

5. Shotten herrings, prepared from herrings after spawning.<br />

Shotten herrings are well salted.<br />

6. Wrecked herrings, prepared from damaged herrings of all cate-<br />

gories. The herrings are well salted.<br />

5


In this classification into groups we differentiate between<br />

heavily and less heavily salted herrings. These differences are most<br />

markedly expressed in the salt content of the herring meat: heavily<br />

salted herrings exhibit a minimum of 20% salt in the tissue fluid of<br />

the fish, while mild ones (according to former Regulation <strong>No</strong>. 83<br />

these were labelled "mildly salted") must contain less than 20% table<br />

salt in the tissue fluid.<br />

According to the classification commonly used for salted herrings,<br />

whole and shotten herrings are well salted. Due to their sensitivity<br />

towards large amounts of table salt, considerably less salt is generally<br />

used for fat herrings with delicate meat. The commonly used amounts of<br />

salt therefore result (independent of the composition of the fish meat<br />

and particularly independent of the fat content) in two groups of very<br />

different salt herrings which can be recognized already by their labels.<br />

IsKept mild" are "mild whole herrings" and "Matjes herrings". These do<br />

not differ greatly in the salt content of the tissue fluid but rather<br />

in the degree of sexual maturity. The differences which exist between<br />

heavily salted herrings and Matjes herrings are shown by the examples<br />

contained in the Handbuch der Fischkonservierung (Handbook of Fish Pre-<br />

servation) by 0. Wille (2).<br />

Designation Salt Herring Matjes Herring<br />

Salt content in the fish meat in%<br />

Water content in the fish meat in %<br />

Salt content in the tissue fluid in %<br />

Table 1<br />

Salt and water content in herring meat (2)<br />

6


Thus Matjes herring contains considerably less salt in the meat<br />

and therefore also in the tissue fluid than heavily salted common<br />

herrings. In the meat of Matjes herrings the salt content usually<br />

fluctuates between 8% and 10%. In general, 12% to 15% granulated salt<br />

is used for salting. Granulated salt is more suitable for the removal<br />

of tissue fluid. It should be noted that the herrings selected as<br />

example in Table I could only have differed little in their fat con-<br />

tent. In both cases cited the fat content in the fish meat clearly lay<br />

above 15%.<br />

As indicated earlier, the concept "Matjes" herring has the<br />

connotation of a certain quality. The special feature is the fact that<br />

Matjes herrings are prepared only from sexually immature herrings. This<br />

is also required by the "Guidelines for Fish and Fish Products of the<br />

German Food Re gulations" (3) according to which Matjes herrings are pre-<br />

pared from fresh, fat herrings without any external traces of milt or<br />

roe. The herring is de-gilled at sea or on land to drain the blood<br />

and is kept mild. According to these guidelines "keeping mild" means<br />

a minimum salt content of 12% and a maximum of 20% in the tissue fluid<br />

of the fish. Definitions of this type are commonly found in the litera-<br />

ture (2,4,5,6,7). The highest requirements are thus imposed on herring.<br />

According to P. Biegler (8), typical characteristics for suitable<br />

raw material are a broad back, a high fat content of the meat and the<br />

resulting tenderness of the meat. Where these characteristics are easily<br />

recognizeable, a trace of female or male gonads is not detrimental (roe-<br />

filled fish or miner).<br />

7


Thus the requirement for the designation "Matjes" herring is<br />

the use of herrings of a certain degree of maturity in combination with<br />

mild salting. While the salt content can also be examined in the fish<br />

fillet, statements concerning the degree of maturity can only be made<br />

on uneviscerated herrings.<br />

Designation<br />

<strong>No</strong>rdàee-Hering * •<br />

<strong>No</strong>rdsee"-Hering<br />

<strong>No</strong>rciseeHering<br />

<strong>No</strong>rdsee-Hering<br />

<strong>No</strong>rdsee-Hering<br />

<strong>No</strong>rdsee-Hering<br />

<strong>No</strong>rdsee-Hering<br />

<strong>No</strong>rdsee-Hering •<br />

Ostsee-Hering **<br />

Ostsee-Hering<br />

Ostsee-Hering<br />

* <strong>No</strong>rth Sea herring<br />

** Baltic Sea herring<br />

water Fat cholee erM cholesterd conco<br />

nt ent c cute nt content in tent. the aillAt<br />

% thafat e pçarivoelhe<br />

hp rri rig Cyr;<br />

62,1 20,2<br />

60,4 23.3<br />

62,2 20,1<br />

61.3 21,3<br />

62.1 19,4 .<br />

64.0 18,2<br />

65,2 16,3<br />

62,4 19,5<br />

631 18,8<br />

68.0 15,9<br />

10,6<br />

Ostsee-Hering 70,9 10,4<br />

Table 2<br />

0,30<br />

0,23.<br />

0,29<br />

0,27<br />

0,35<br />

0,36<br />

0,38<br />

0,31<br />

0,34<br />

0,40<br />

0,57<br />

0,58<br />

60.6<br />

53,6<br />

58,3<br />

67.9<br />

65,5 ;<br />

61.9<br />

60.6'•<br />

Fat and cholesterol contents in herring fillets<br />

In season, Matjes herrings are found in special stores either<br />

loose or packaged. Because the fish meat spoils easily, prepared Matées<br />

fillets in the past were generally only available in restaurants. Accord-<br />

ing to P. Biegler, Matjes fillets were introduced into the industrial<br />

program in 1923 and have established themselves as a permanent item.<br />

In years past more changes in trade practices and consumer habits have<br />

led to a still greater proliferation of herring fillets under the label<br />

"Matjes". Because the essential quality criterion of the Matjes herring<br />

60',3<br />

,<br />

8


(i.e. the degree of maturity) can no longer be verified in fillets, the<br />

differentiation between mildly salted herring fillets and normal Matjes<br />

fillets is very difficult or no longer possible at all. A typical<br />

characteristic of unfilled herrings, however, is a high fat content of<br />

the herring meat. Like the salt content, the fat content is easily and<br />

accurately checked in each herring fillet or part thereof. It was<br />

therefore logical to tie the designation "Matjes" fillet to a minimum<br />

fat content in the herring fillet and to replace the requirement of<br />

maturity which can no longer be monitored by a minimum fat content<br />

although this enabled the fillets of fat or whole herrings with the re-<br />

quired salting to be labelled as "Matjes" fillets, thus permitting a<br />

larger quantity of herrings to be offered as "Matjes" fillets. On the<br />

basis of our own earlier investigations which we already reported else-<br />

where (9), it appears justified to establish for Matjes fillet and pre-<br />

pared herring meat with appropriate labelling a minimum fat content of<br />

15% based on the herring fillet of the raw material. Herring meat with<br />

a 15% fat content therefore corresponds to a fat herring fillet. Further-<br />

more, meat with this fat content can be processed for most types of pre-<br />

parations without any restrictions or other complications. It should<br />

be noted that with this fat content approximately 0.4% cholesterol is to<br />

be expected in the petroleum ether extract from the edible portion of<br />

the herring.<br />

The results of experiments with herring fillets of various origin<br />

and fishing seasons are compiled in Table 2. The herring oils were ob-<br />

tained by extraction with petroleum ether from the comminuted herring<br />

meat which had been ground up with sodium sulfate. The cholesterol was<br />

9


determined according to the method by P. C. den Herder (10) in the<br />

petroleum ether extracts. Furthermore, the Table contains the amounts<br />

of cholesterol calculated for each 100 g portion of edible herring parts.<br />

From the examined herring fillets, between 10% and 24% petroleum<br />

ether extracts were obtained. The Table thus comprises a range from<br />

lean to fat herrings. From these petroleum ether extracts between 0.58%<br />

and 0.23% cholesterol were separated with digitonin. It became evident<br />

from the amounts of petroleum ether extract and the resulting cholesterol<br />

values that the petroleum ether extracts from fat—rich herrings contained<br />

less cholesterol than the extracts from lean herring fillets.<br />

According to this it is generally sufficient for the assessment<br />

of the designation to determine the cholesterol content in the herring<br />

oil extracted with petroleum ether. More extensive examinations are<br />

necessary only if the cholesterol content is markedly higher. However, (1833)<br />

attention must be paid to the fact that the herring fillets may undergo<br />

changes in their composition during processing which may manifest them-<br />

selves also in a lowering of the fat content. However, these fat losses<br />

are clearly detectable only in preparations with fish parts from very<br />

fat herring fillets. Thus the type of processing is very important for<br />

the evaluation of designation containing the word "Matjes" from the point<br />

of view of food control.<br />

Table 3 lists the results of investigations which were obtained<br />

from commercial Matjes herrings.<br />

According to the additional designations in the declarations and<br />

invoices, at least one half of the listed examples involved Dutch Matjes<br />

herrings. If one proceeds from the determined salt contents, all the<br />

10


samples listed in Table 4 might be of Dutch origin and processing. The<br />

salt contents of 3.8% to 7.0% in the edible part of the herring (fillet)<br />

were very low. A salt content of between 6.3% and 10.5% can be calcu-<br />

lated for the tissue fluid of the fish from the water and salt contents<br />

of the fillets. The lower salt concentration in the tissue fluid of<br />

the fish which is necessary for adequate stability but which is desirable<br />

also for other reasons, should lie around approximately 12%. This<br />

minimum salt concentration was not met in any of the listed Matjes<br />

herrings. This proved that the products involved were kept too mild.<br />

Several of the examined Matjes herrings were filled with milt or roe.<br />

This fact alone demonstrated that not all herrings met the requirements<br />

for the designation "Matjes". However, in this connection we will not<br />

discuss this problem but concentrate onlÿ on the fat content.<br />

Designâtior} water .::,Fat Salt c-ontent<br />

Filca.voü:;;tvlatjeshèren.<br />

Filet v^r.r, fvlaljéslieringen.<br />

Filot ;4oil .hA,4it.ji sli^rirlgern<br />

Filet"üôn .Mâtjéÿhëringern<br />

Filet vôn tvt'^tjèSFièringen•<br />

*Fil1Et of Matjes herrings<br />

Table 3<br />

Water, fat and salt content in Matjes herrings<br />

The examples in Table 2 were selected to provide an insight into<br />

the fat contents which may occur - at least sporadically - in fillets<br />

from fish designated as Matjes herrings. If one proceeds from the above-<br />

mentioned 15% fat content it becomes evident that even this minimum<br />

11


equirement is not met by all listed "Matjes" herrings. The herring<br />

fillets in which less than 15% herring oil was determined can thus no<br />

longer be regarded as fat herrings. Such herrings can therefore not<br />

be offered as "Matjes", nor can they be processed into products for<br />

which the word "Matjes",is-used,as ,a 'label. From the listed examples<br />

it also becomes evident that it is imperative to establish a minimum<br />

fat content for "Matjes" fillet which must be adopted as the criterion<br />

for evaluation, perhaps even instead of the salt content because the<br />

latter (as becomes clear from the examples quoted) is frequently so<br />

low that the mild character can he est ablished already by a simple<br />

taste test.<br />

Heringsfifêts aus MatjesfiLétIri -O. :,<br />

. HeringS:filets aus AVIatjesfilet in<br />

Heringelets auS '.b.41'lâtjesfilet in Ô .I‘.„<br />

Heringsfilets aus ,Matjesfilet.in C11 ,<br />

au's .Matjesfilet in (51« Heringsfilets<br />

Heringsfilets aus ,Matjesfilet in- (31<<br />

Heringsfilets aus ,Matjesfilet in Ôk<br />

Heringsfilets aus •Matjesfilet in Ôl.<br />

Heringsfilets aus ,Matjesfilet in Ôk<br />

Heringsfilets au S ,Matjesfiiiit in (51<br />

59.9 14,2 7,9<br />

61,9 13,8 • 6,3<br />

56,8 12,9 '12,0<br />

61,0 11,5 8,7<br />

58,7 11,3 10,5<br />

61,O.. .'1O,3<br />

*Herring fillets from Matjes . fillet in oil<br />

Table 4<br />

Examinations of herring fillets from "Matjes<br />

fillet in oil"<br />

4;à•<br />

Table 4 lists the results of experiments determined for Matjes<br />

fillets in oil. With products of this kind one can generally assume<br />

that under the customary processing and manufacturing conditions the<br />

12


herring fillets do not lose any fish oil or, at most only very small<br />

quantities. Where losses do occur, they will likely be compensated<br />

for by small quantities of added oil which adhere to the surface of<br />

the fish fillet even after the most careful separation. An effective<br />

separation could only be accomplished with great analytical effort.<br />

Water, fat and sodium chloride were determined in herring fillets from<br />

preparations "Matjes in oil". Before analysis, the herring fillets were<br />

carefully cleaned of adhering oil. One can thus assume that the de-<br />

termination was performed by hydrochloric acid breakdown of herring meat.<br />

At a water content of 56.8% to 67.2% the Matjes fillets con-<br />

tained between 4.4% and 12.0% sodium chloride. The lower salt concentra-<br />

tion of 12.0% in the fish tissue fluid which is desirable for adequate<br />

keeping qualities had not always been attained in the listed examples.<br />

The salt concentration in the tissue fluid ranged from 6.6% to approxi-<br />

mately 21%. Thus in one instance the upper limit of 20% for mild pro-<br />

ducts had been slightly exceeded.<br />

For commercial "Matjes" fillets salt contents between 4% and 12%<br />

were determined. Thus the examples listed in Table 4 clearly illustrate<br />

that the salt content in a commercial product designated "Matjes" is not<br />

sufficient for the evaluation of Matjes characteristics but can only<br />

serve to determine whether a mild product is involved. Therefore it is<br />

only the fat content of the herring fillets which is important for the<br />

evaluation of the Matjes characteristics. The salt content is not more<br />

than a convenient support for the evaluation.<br />

The examples in Table 4 were selected to provide an insight into<br />

the fat content of products which may be found under the designation<br />

13


"Matjes fillets in oil". The widely fluctuating fat contents are re-<br />

markable. Under industrial processing conditions Matjes herrings are<br />

customarily only washed, but not soaked. Typical components including<br />

herring oil are thus not leached out from the meat.<br />

If one regards the salt contents in the herring fillets from<br />

Table 4 from this point of view, then well—soaked fillets cannot be ex-<br />

cluded. The fat contents in the fillets may therefore have decreased<br />

to a greater extent thaà is normally the case with fat herring fillets.<br />

According to oui' own (previous) experience one can assume that<br />

from herring fillets with a fat content of 15% small amounts of fat<br />

are lost from the fillets only if they are soaked in water. It is more<br />

difficult to assess the losses incurred with herrings of higher fat<br />

content but they musttat any rate, be assumed to be higher than those<br />

of the "normal fillet".<br />

All of the "Matjes" fillets listed in Table 4 contained less than<br />

15% fat. Matjes fillets with higher fat contents which are, of course<br />

also found, were deliberately not included in the Table. Even if soaking<br />

in water is assumed, herring fillets with a fat content of 12.9% or less<br />

could in all probability not have contained 15% fat as raw material.<br />

Possible fat losses incurred through the customary processing, storage<br />

and preparation for examination should generally not exceed 2% in these<br />

"normal fillets" with a 15% fat content. The requirements for the de-<br />

signation "Matjes" fillets are therefore still met by prepared herring<br />

fillets from, for instance, "Matjes fillets in oil" with a fat content<br />

of 13% if one assumes a loss of 2%. At lower fat contents herring fillets<br />

are lacking the typical Matjes characteristics, regardless of the salt<br />

content in the tissue fluid of the fish.<br />

14


Table 5 lists results of examinations which were obtained from<br />

herring meat of Matjes products of varying type and designation. For<br />

purposes of comparison we show results of experiments which were ob— (1834)<br />

tained from herring fillets prepared in oil as well as from rollmops.<br />

The examinations were carried out in the same manner.<br />

Designation , WaterFat Tablesalt<br />

_ .<br />

% %<br />

HerinUIt aus RolIthsen -<br />

Rolimopsen<br />

Heringsifleaus<br />

Heringsfftei,aus•kieringsfilet in ÔI 2 .<br />

Heringsfi(et0eringsfilet in ÔI<br />

Heringelet àù% Heringsfilet in 0 1<br />

MatjeSfilet<br />

MatjestiYei " •<br />

Krâuterm:aties 3.;. 'q;;<br />

Matjesheringsstücke<br />

Matjesheringsstücke<br />

Table 5<br />

57,9<br />

61,0 18,8<br />

66,5 8,0<br />

69,0 7,5 .<br />

67,0 11,3<br />

13,3 11,0<br />

63,0 13,7 6,2<br />

Examinations of herring fillets of various types<br />

1. Herring fillet from rollmops<br />

2. Herring fillet from herring fillet in oil<br />

3. Herbed Matjes<br />

4. Pieces of Matjes herring<br />

Clear differences existed neither in the salt content nor in the<br />

fat content between the herring and Matjes fillets listed in Table 5.<br />

The herring fillets processed into rollmops contained even more fat than<br />

the Matjes fillets or pieces of Matjes fillets. According to the labels<br />

of the examined commercial products one would expect fillets of genuine<br />

Matjes herrings or those of mild fat or whole herrings. If one again<br />

proceeds from 15% fat in the raw material and if a 2% fat loss is tolerated<br />

15


as possible, then the requirements for the designation as Matjes fillets<br />

were definitely met by only 2 of the listed products. From the sandal-<br />

wood additives (this will not be discussed here) and the thereby strong-<br />

ly discolored meat surfaces it could be seen that herbed herring fillets<br />

had been used. For products of this type neither the designation "Matjes<br />

herring" nor the label "herbed Matjes" is acceptable. For fillets which<br />

do not meet the minimum fat requirements for a fat herring, word combi-<br />

nations with Matjes are generally acceptable only if one deals with<br />

mild herring fillets which are cured like anchovies. This special pro-<br />

cessing however, must be clearly indicated in the labelling. Even the<br />

regulations of the Food Labelling Act make it a mandatory requirement<br />

to formulate the name of the contents of the package in accordance with<br />

the products in question as determined by the type and processing of<br />

the herring.<br />

Literature<br />

1. Brandes. C. H. und R. Dietrich, VeY-<br />

OffentlichOng déS lnstituts fur iVleeresforscht.ing.<br />

Bremerhaven, 2, 109<br />

(14 2. Wille, 0., Handbuch der<br />

FiSC:hkonservierung,;gand `III, Hans A.<br />

Keune Verlag, Hamburg (1949). — 3.<br />

Franck-Nüse. Dev1sche's Lebensmittelbtich,<br />

Leitsâtzif):i Fische und Frscherzeugnisse<br />

(1873V-:— 4.• lkietzmann,<br />

U., D. Rakow, k:: Pyié b e und K. Reichstein,<br />

Seefisch à1S11bensmittel,;,Verlag<br />

Paul Parey, 8erlih(1:969).— 5. Seumenicht,<br />

K., Fisch:L_Wa>ienkunde,, Verlag<br />

Plambeck und'CeNeumün$ter/HO1stein<br />

(;I.959), S..52. —6. Ludoffli W:.;1'Fische<br />

i:inCI Fisch-ErzeugnisseYt■ilig.<br />

W. Hay.n's Erben, Berlin s'ç>, 4 (190),<br />

S. 1 qi/44.-.7. Belve, A., Ta"el*rff.ii.ich<br />

der --.::::"Fiei.k..ii,;en kOk1 .1 r hl le. Yk-,.in ... , A.<br />

Keu(le->lag, : elprrib.urg . (1 948), — 8.<br />

Bia.e.:4;.;1?..- Dr ch ,Fi..g.'44 re n-<br />

TeOliiii:4e,..ye:ii-à •-Clarpf.Wei','Élibe&'ffedlie:oii..-.<br />

1 q31 -.epi:»,;7,-ity'l.?bohs.<br />

, ,w„,e,,_esti.43?..,,ee<br />

cuêti::,-,6mt,m-yii,...,<br />

.greri.,,,.:euefyclei. s,4,,lkhof.: -<br />

deençie: ,..-1.1.i.f,.4i, zui,-,e„ .,<br />

tiidseliG-i.9. S. 28T'(:10- 9), F4i.tte Seen:<br />

AnstricMittel 62, S. 91 (1960).<br />

1 6


1. Publication of the Institute for Oceanic Research, Bremerhaven.<br />

2. Handbook of Fish Preservation, Vol. III.<br />

3. German Food Regulations, Guidelines for Fish and Fish Products.<br />

4. Saltwater fish as food.<br />

5. Fish — Product Studies.<br />

6. Fish and fish products<br />

7. Pocketbook of the monitoring and control of fish products<br />

8. The fish and the technology of fish products.<br />

9. Archive for food hygiene.<br />

Author's address: Prof. Dr. J. Wurziger,<br />

Chemische und Lebensmitteluntersuchungsanstalt<br />

der Freien und Hansestadt Hamburg,<br />

Gorch—Fock—Wall 15 — 17,<br />

2000 Hamburg 36<br />

Federal Republic of Germany<br />

17

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!