Corporate Advisory & Restructuring Services - Grant Thornton LLP
Corporate Advisory & Restructuring Services - Grant Thornton LLP
Corporate Advisory & Restructuring Services - Grant Thornton LLP
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
<strong>Corporate</strong> <strong>Advisory</strong> &<br />
<strong>Restructuring</strong> <strong>Services</strong>:<br />
Fresh Start Accounting<br />
______________________________________________________<br />
<strong>Advisory</strong> <strong>Services</strong><br />
Fresh Start Accounting is a service to assist<br />
entities emerging from bankruptcy with the<br />
adoption of the appropriate emergence<br />
accounting, as governed by the Financial<br />
Accounting Standards Board (“FASB”)<br />
Accounting Standards Codification® (ASC) 852,<br />
Reorganizations. Emergence accounting,<br />
specifically Fresh Start Accounting, is the last<br />
step in a successful emergence from Chapter<br />
11, and can be extremely complex. It is often<br />
one of the most difficult tasks management will<br />
face during a bankruptcy, and planning for<br />
Fresh Start Accounting should begin well in<br />
advance of the emergence date.<br />
Company to prepare financial statements in<br />
what is commonly referred to as the “Four<br />
Column Approach.” The first step is to prepare<br />
the books and records of the predecessor entity<br />
for audit. The next step is to record the Effects<br />
of the Plan of Reorganization. This includes<br />
recording the extinguishment of pre-petition<br />
liabilities (“Liabilities Subject to Compromise”),<br />
extinguishment of the common stock of the<br />
predecessor entity, recoveries to creditors, and<br />
the reorganization gain/loss provided by the<br />
above activities. Step Three involves the<br />
revaluation and balance sheet adjustment of the<br />
assets and liabilities of the entity. The final step<br />
is to prepare the financial statements of the<br />
new entity to reflect all adjustments made<br />
during this process.<br />
<strong>Grant</strong> <strong>Thornton</strong> <strong>LLP</strong>’s integrated approach,<br />
combining the skills of our <strong>Corporate</strong> <strong>Advisory</strong><br />
& <strong>Restructuring</strong> <strong>Services</strong>, Accounting, Tax,<br />
Valuation and Strategic Information<br />
Management professionals, helps companies<br />
emerge from bankruptcy prepared to move<br />
forward.<br />
The results of Fresh Start Accounting are<br />
similar to purchase accounting, but require the<br />
© <strong>Grant</strong> <strong>Thornton</strong> <strong>LLP</strong><br />
All rights reserved<br />
U.S. member firm of <strong>Grant</strong> <strong>Thornton</strong> International Ltd
At its core, Fresh Start Accounting is much<br />
more than an accounting exercise. The Fresh<br />
Start Accounting service is broken into four<br />
phases:<br />
Assessment – Define the scope and<br />
develop the plan for accounting for the<br />
emergence.<br />
Review the Plan of Reorganization.<br />
Review the capabilities of a Company’s<br />
general ledger and sub-ledgers and<br />
understand any complexities that may affect<br />
the program for Fresh Start.<br />
Review every account on a company’s trial<br />
balance to determine need for valuation<br />
procedures.<br />
Review tax issues for each entity, including<br />
local, state, federal and any foreign statutory<br />
requirements.<br />
Development of implementation<br />
procedures – Based on the results of<br />
Phase 1, creating the necessary<br />
information and adjustments to<br />
support the emergence.<br />
Identify financial adjustments required to<br />
record the Effects of Plan and the<br />
anticipated impact on the general ledger.<br />
Perform valuation of assets and liabilities of<br />
every entity within a company’s structure (all<br />
Debtors and non-Debtors are revalued in a<br />
Fresh Start scenario), and establish new<br />
balance sheet values, including goodwill.<br />
Design and test processes and plans for<br />
making adjustments in the accounting<br />
systems, including preparing for a possible<br />
mid-year close and making changes to<br />
carrying values and useful lives.<br />
Assist with preparation of preliminary<br />
journal entries and documentation to<br />
support the emergence transactions, and<br />
review them with a company’s auditors to<br />
ensure buy-in and understanding.<br />
Implementation – Prepare the required<br />
adjustments to be made by the<br />
company.<br />
Assist management with adjustments to<br />
financial records, including “push-down” of<br />
Plan Effects and Fresh Start Accounting to<br />
subsidiaries.<br />
Review impact of consolidation and<br />
elimination entries to ensure consolidated<br />
opening financials are in accordance with<br />
Plan of Reorganization.<br />
Assist with preparation of opening financial<br />
statements, any required reporting and<br />
financial statement disclosures.<br />
Follow-up – Assist management on an<br />
as-needed basis.<br />
Finalize valuation adjustments and<br />
allocations.<br />
Participate in discussions with a company’s<br />
auditors to ensure appropriate understanding<br />
of accounting adjustments, emergence<br />
financials, and supporting documentation.<br />
Continued tax review, structuring and<br />
planning, including:<br />
Post-emergence tax planning (year<br />
end cut-off, deconsolidations, forced<br />
consolidations)<br />
Entity tax withdrawal consulting (for<br />
liquidated entities)<br />
Reporting tax implications on postemergence<br />
tax returns and analyzing<br />
state tax implications<br />
Assisting in the withdrawal of debtor<br />
entities from state, local and foreign<br />
jurisdictions upon liquidation<br />
Representative clients for whom we<br />
have provided Fresh Start<br />
Accounting <strong>Services</strong> include:<br />
Automotive Parts Supplier<br />
Provided day to day oversight of the Firm<br />
and client teams responsible for valuation<br />
and tax adjustments.<br />
Determined applicability of Fresh Start based<br />
on the criteria set forth in ASC 852.<br />
© <strong>Grant</strong> <strong>Thornton</strong> <strong>LLP</strong><br />
All rights reserved<br />
U.S. member firm of <strong>Grant</strong> <strong>Thornton</strong> International Ltd
Prepared integrated models and schedules to<br />
support journal entries and footnotes for<br />
Plan of Reorganization and valuation<br />
adjustments.<br />
Assessed general ledger and sub-ledger<br />
impact and capability of these systems to<br />
meet the needs of Fresh Start accounting.<br />
Provided support for determining the<br />
appropriate Fresh Start emergence and<br />
reporting date.<br />
Met with auditors to discuss impact on the<br />
predecessor entity, plan of reorganization<br />
and Fresh Start adjustments of decisions and<br />
recommendations made by management<br />
related to treatment of specific accounts.<br />
Created supporting documentation for<br />
adjustments made.<br />
Bally Total Fitness<br />
Assisted with the implementation of<br />
accounting as defined by Generally Accepted<br />
Accounting Principles for the Plan of<br />
Reorganization.<br />
Provided tax advice on the recording and<br />
impact of the Plan of Reorganization.<br />
Valued the Company’s assets, including<br />
furniture, fixtures, and equipment as well as<br />
intangible assets, as applicable.<br />
Computer Hardware Manufacturer<br />
Coordinated activities of Company’s tax,<br />
accounting and restructuring professionals<br />
with respect to planning and reporting of<br />
Fresh Start Accounting.<br />
Reconciled claims reports to general ledger to<br />
ensure gains on debt forgiveness were<br />
calculated appropriately.<br />
Reviewed general ledger and sub-ledgers and<br />
discussed capabilities with the Company’s IT<br />
department to determine best methodology<br />
for recording adjustments.<br />
Discussed changes to depreciable lives,<br />
capitalization thresholds of assets, changes in<br />
inventory methods and other accounting<br />
items with management, and determined<br />
effects of the changes on the Successor<br />
Entity financials.<br />
Provided information on best practices for<br />
handling necessary accounting adjustments in<br />
the ledgers and sub-ledgers.<br />
Calculated impact of Stock Rights Offering<br />
on Reorganization Value of the emerging<br />
entity and determined adjustments required<br />
to ensure the capture of excess cash in the<br />
final equity value of the Successor Entity.<br />
Provided auditors with training on Fresh<br />
Start Accounting and discussed the impact of<br />
Fresh Start adjustments on the timing of<br />
their audit.<br />
Provided auditors with a timeline of<br />
requirements for review of financials and<br />
preparation of SEC filings.<br />
Reviewed Fresh Start Accounting financials,<br />
including the Fresh Start Accounting<br />
footnote, Predecessor and Successor Entity<br />
balances sheets, income statements and cash<br />
flows.<br />
Energy Partners, LTD.<br />
Engaged to perform valuation work related<br />
to emergence from Chapter 11.<br />
Interfaced with IT to discuss effects of<br />
valuation adjustments on systems.<br />
Analyzed key issues and value drivers of<br />
assets and liabilities.<br />
Identified and discussed appropriate<br />
valuation assumptions with management.<br />
Allocated values of assets to reporting units.<br />
Provided documentation and support for<br />
valuations, methodologies and assumptions.<br />
Idearc Inc.<br />
Assisted with financial statement<br />
preparations and disclosures.<br />
Prepared applicability testing of Reporting as<br />
required by Fresh Start Accounting<br />
principles.<br />
Identified entries needed to account for the<br />
effects of the Plan of Reorganization.<br />
Anticipated potential issues with external<br />
auditors.<br />
Assisted in creation of supporting<br />
documentation for the audit.<br />
© <strong>Grant</strong> <strong>Thornton</strong> <strong>LLP</strong><br />
All rights reserved<br />
U.S. member firm of <strong>Grant</strong> <strong>Thornton</strong> International Ltd
Analyzed tax implications of cancellation of<br />
debt, new legal entity structure, “push down”<br />
adjustments, and the transfer of assets.<br />
Advised the Company on statutory reporting,<br />
deferred taxes, inter-company transactions<br />
and preserving net operating losses.<br />
Assessed the scope and methodology for<br />
assets and liabilities to revalue.<br />
Provided fair value appraisals for tangible<br />
and intangible assets.<br />
Addressed impairment and valuation<br />
allowance issues.<br />
Identified necessary steps to effectuate<br />
entries to the Accounts Payable, General<br />
Ledger and Sub-ledger systems.<br />
Analyzed the effect of changes on the<br />
reporting and budgeting processes to<br />
minimize disruption.<br />
Advised on the processes to address<br />
bankruptcy and emergence reporting.<br />
Major Telecommunications Provider<br />
Created models to estimate impact of Fresh<br />
Start Accounting on consolidated entity and<br />
multiple international subsidiaries.<br />
Reviewed Plan of Reorganization to<br />
determine recoveries to creditor classes and<br />
gains on debt forgiveness.<br />
Developed methodology for determining<br />
that a change of control would occur, and the<br />
entity would qualify for Fresh Start<br />
Accounting.<br />
Directed activities of third party valuation<br />
firm related to valuation of all tangible assets.<br />
Modeled effects of various intercompany<br />
actions and created hybrid methodology for<br />
determining recoveries on intercompany<br />
balances.<br />
Prepared documentation to provide the<br />
Company and their external auditors with<br />
support for Fresh Start financials.<br />
Assessed impact on the Company’s general<br />
ledger and sub-ledgers of actions taken to<br />
effect the Plan of Reorganization and<br />
incorporate the valuation and tax<br />
adjustments.<br />
Major Grocery Chain<br />
Managed end to end implementation of<br />
Fresh Start Accounting.<br />
Reviewed balance accounts with valuation<br />
professionals to determine every account that<br />
would require an adjustment.<br />
Recommended adjustments required to the<br />
Company’s PeopleSoft Accounting system to<br />
retain historical data required for budgeting,<br />
calculating commissions and management<br />
reporting.<br />
Discussed stock options issues with the audit<br />
team to determine the appropriate timing for<br />
the cancellation of existing stock options.<br />
Created allocation model for new equity<br />
distribution to creditors based on estimated<br />
liabilities subject to compromise and Plan of<br />
Reorganization classes.<br />
Discussed Sarbanes-Oxley issues associated<br />
with changes in the accounting processes<br />
and control environment, and provided<br />
appropriate documentation to support the<br />
adjustments.<br />
Reviewed Company’s methodology for<br />
reporting book versus tax impact, and<br />
provided the tax department with detailed<br />
information on the adjustments being made<br />
to the books to understanding of permanent<br />
tax differences.<br />
Tax services provided to emerging<br />
entity<br />
Prior to filing bankruptcy<br />
Reviewing debt modifications for tax<br />
implications.<br />
Analyzing Chapter 11 bankruptcy versus debt<br />
reorganizations outside of Chapter 11.<br />
Pre-filing tax structuring and planning.<br />
Providing tax planning to maximize cash<br />
refunds/recoveries and minimize tax<br />
liabilities.<br />
Analyzing the state tax implications of the<br />
above items.<br />
During bankruptcy<br />
Assisting with all aspects of the Plan of<br />
Reorganization.<br />
Estimating cancellation of indebtedness<br />
income<br />
Preservation of tax attributes under IRC<br />
108/1017<br />
Analysis of ownership changes<br />
Analysis of consolidated return implications<br />
© <strong>Grant</strong> <strong>Thornton</strong> <strong>LLP</strong><br />
All rights reserved<br />
U.S. member firm of <strong>Grant</strong> <strong>Thornton</strong> International Ltd
Modeling the tax implications of various plan<br />
settlement options<br />
Calculating IRC 382(l)(5) vs (l)(6)<br />
implications<br />
Working closely with other financial advisors<br />
to advise the Debtor.<br />
Amending tax returns for carryback claims or<br />
prior period errors.<br />
Supporting management with IRS or state<br />
tax controversies.<br />
Addressing federal, state, local and foreign<br />
tax claims filed against the debtor.<br />
Supporting management or the creditors’<br />
committees with understanding the tax<br />
implications of the plan.<br />
Calculating stock basis and gains on<br />
assets/entities to be sold, foreclosed, etc.<br />
Optimizing structures for tax and operational<br />
efficiency before emergence.<br />
Addressing non-income tax<br />
issues/opportunities such as sales, property,<br />
excise, etc.<br />
Preparation of returns in bankruptcy.<br />
Analyzing the state tax implications of the<br />
above items.<br />
Post-emergence<br />
Post-emergence tax planning (year end cut<br />
off, deconsolidations, forced consolidations).<br />
Entity tax withdrawal consulting (for<br />
liquidated entities).<br />
Liquidating trust formation, consulting and<br />
compliance.<br />
Calculating or auditing fresh start balance<br />
sheet tax provisions.<br />
Analyzing bankruptcy costs for tax<br />
deductibility.<br />
Reporting tax implications on postemergence<br />
tax returns.<br />
Analyzing the state tax implications of the<br />
above items.<br />
Assisting in the withdrawal of debtor entities<br />
from state, local and foreign jurisdictions<br />
upon liquidation.<br />
Contact details<br />
Nate Vander Hamm<br />
Managing Director, Fresh Start Accounting<br />
T 816-412-2427<br />
E Nate.VanderHamm@us.gt.com<br />
Joseph DiSalvatore<br />
Managing Director, Forensic and Valuation <strong>Services</strong><br />
T 212.624.5300<br />
E joseph.disalvatore@us.gt.com<br />
Bryan Benoit<br />
Partner, Economic <strong>Advisory</strong> Group<br />
T 832.476.3620<br />
E Bryan.Benoit@us.gt.com<br />
Scott Davis<br />
Partner, <strong>Corporate</strong> <strong>Advisory</strong> & <strong>Restructuring</strong><br />
<strong>Services</strong><br />
T 704.632.3540<br />
E Scott.Davis@us.gt.com<br />
April Little<br />
Partner, Tax Accounting and Risk <strong>Advisory</strong> <strong>Services</strong><br />
T 832.476.3730<br />
E april.little@us.gt.com<br />
Forrest Frazier<br />
Partner, Business <strong>Advisory</strong> <strong>Services</strong><br />
T 704.632.6801<br />
E Forrest.Frazier@us.gt.com<br />
Paul Kanneman<br />
National Managing Principal, Business <strong>Advisory</strong><br />
<strong>Services</strong><br />
T 214.562.2256<br />
E Paul.Kanneman@us.gt.com<br />
Johnny Lee<br />
Director, <strong>Corporate</strong> <strong>Advisory</strong> & <strong>Restructuring</strong><br />
<strong>Services</strong><br />
T 212.542.9778<br />
E Johnny.Lee@us.gt.com<br />
Susan Nunamaker<br />
Senior Manager, Economic <strong>Advisory</strong> <strong>Services</strong><br />
T 704.632.6946<br />
E Susan.Nunamaker@us.gt.com<br />
David Rader<br />
Managing Director, Business <strong>Advisory</strong> <strong>Services</strong><br />
T 408.346.4330<br />
E David.Rader@us.gt.com<br />
Sharon Whittle<br />
Principal, Compensation and Benefits Consulting<br />
T 704.632.6884<br />
E Sharon.Whittle@us.gt.com<br />
www.<strong>Grant</strong><strong>Thornton</strong>.com/<br />
advisory<br />
© <strong>Grant</strong> <strong>Thornton</strong> <strong>LLP</strong><br />
All rights reserved<br />
U.S. member firm of <strong>Grant</strong> <strong>Thornton</strong> International Ltd