What is landscape character Assessment - Roscommon County ...
What is landscape character Assessment - Roscommon County ...
What is landscape character Assessment - Roscommon County ...
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
<strong>Roscommon</strong> <strong>County</strong> Council<br />
LANDSCAPE CHARACTER ASSESSMENT<br />
OF<br />
COUNTY ROSCOMMON<br />
June 2008<br />
By
Section 1:<br />
Table of Contents<br />
LANDSCAPE CHARACTER ASSESSMENT OF COUNTY ROSCOMMON<br />
1<br />
1.1 The Brief 1<br />
1.2 <strong>What</strong> <strong>is</strong> Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong>? 1<br />
Section 2 : OBJECTIVES AND GUIDELINES 6<br />
2.1 Introduction 6<br />
2.2 Opportunities Presented by the Unique<br />
Landscape Character of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> 6<br />
2.3 Consideration of General Landscape Objectives 7<br />
2.3.1 Influences 7<br />
2.3.2 Objectives 9<br />
2.4 Development Controls to Ameliorate Landscape<br />
Constraints and Facilitate Sustainable<br />
Development 10<br />
Section 3 LANDSCAPE APPROACH TO BUILT DEVELOPMENT 13<br />
3.1 Introduction 13<br />
3.2 Housing 13<br />
3.2.1 Housing in Ex<strong>is</strong>ting Settlements 13<br />
3.3 Rural Buildings and Alternative Enterpr<strong>is</strong>e<br />
Proposals 17<br />
3.4 Quarries 18<br />
3.5 Wind Farm Development 20<br />
3.6 Forestry and Bio-fuels 23<br />
Section 4 LANDSCAPE ASSESSMENT STUDY 28<br />
4.1 Introduction 28<br />
4.2 GIS Analys<strong>is</strong> and Desk Study Mapping<br />
of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> 28<br />
4.3 Landscape Character and Values Mapping 39<br />
4.4 Detailed Landscape <strong>Assessment</strong> 44<br />
Appendices<br />
APPENDIX 1: Map of Scenic Routes and Scenic Views<br />
APPENDIX 2: Minutes of Stakeholder Consultation Meetings
SECTION 1:<br />
LANDSCAPE CHARACTER ASSESSMENT OF COUNTY<br />
ROSCOMMON<br />
1.1 The Brief<br />
The aim of the project was to carry out a <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong> assessment that will provide<br />
the technical background for the Planning Authority to formulate a set of Landscape<br />
Objectives and Policy Recommendations for <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong>. These objectives and<br />
policy recommendations strive to achieve a balance between the proactive need to<br />
accommodate change, optim<strong>is</strong>ing of <strong>landscape</strong> aesthetics and due reflection of the<br />
sensitivity of various <strong>landscape</strong> (including social and economic) related values, involving:<br />
‣ The conservation and enhancement of the <strong>landscape</strong> diversity, <strong>character</strong> and quality of<br />
the <strong>County</strong>;<br />
‣ Protection of sensitive areas from development that would detract from or be injurious to<br />
the amenity of the area;<br />
‣ Prov<strong>is</strong>ion for development and change that would benefit the economy of the county<br />
including the rural economy while protecting and enhancing the <strong>landscape</strong>;<br />
‣ Identification of suitable ‘working’ <strong>landscape</strong>s where there <strong>is</strong> potential to accommodate<br />
development.<br />
The <strong>landscape</strong> objectives and policy recommendations focus on the following five specific<br />
development types:<br />
‣ Housing (including housing in ex<strong>is</strong>ting settlements as well as single rural dwellings<br />
relating to the guidance set out in the Sustainable Rural Housing Guidelines for Planning<br />
Authorities);<br />
‣ Quarries 1 ;<br />
‣ Wind farms;<br />
‣ Afforestation; and<br />
‣ Rural buildings and alternative enterpr<strong>is</strong>e proposals (an increase of farm buildings <strong>is</strong><br />
anticipated as a result of the recent EU Nitrates Directive 2 ).<br />
1.2 <strong>What</strong> <strong>is</strong> Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong>?<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> (LCA) <strong>is</strong> a study of a given <strong>landscape</strong> to ascertain its<br />
‘<strong>character</strong>’. Landscape <strong>character</strong> <strong>is</strong> the combination of physical, as well as, perceived<br />
aspects of the <strong>landscape</strong>. Landscape <strong>character</strong> maps and an accompanying document with<br />
descriptions and recommendations <strong>is</strong> the end product of the assessment process. The aim of<br />
the <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> LCA <strong>is</strong> to provide a tool for dec<strong>is</strong>ion making regarding development<br />
control and to influence <strong>landscape</strong> policy at Local Authority level.<br />
There are two stages in the LCA process. The first <strong>is</strong> ‘<strong>character</strong><strong>is</strong>ation’ and the second <strong>is</strong><br />
‘making of judgements’ about <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong>.<br />
Definition of ‘<strong>landscape</strong>’?<br />
Landscape <strong>is</strong> understood to be a combination of the physical, the ‘seen’, the cultural and the<br />
perceived elements that merge together to form the general <strong>character</strong> of an area. Landscape<br />
has been defined as:<br />
All that <strong>is</strong> v<strong>is</strong>ible when looking across areas of land 3 ;<br />
1<br />
Under Section 261 of the Planning and Development Act as amended, the Planning Authority are retrospectively granting<br />
perm<strong>is</strong>sion to ex<strong>is</strong>ting sites or requiring them to apply for planning perm<strong>is</strong>sion.<br />
2 National Action Programme under the Nitrates Directive. Department of the Environment, Heritage and Local Government<br />
(DEHLG) and the Department of Agriculture and Food (DAF), 2005<br />
3<br />
Department of Environment, Heritage and Local Government (2000), Draft Landscape and Landscape <strong>Assessment</strong> Guidelines<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 1
The relationship between people and place…The term does not mean just<br />
special or designated <strong>landscape</strong>s and it does not apply to the countryside…It<br />
results from the way different components of our environment – both natural<br />
and cultural – interact together and are perceived by us 4 ;<br />
Landscape means an area, as perceived by people, whose <strong>character</strong> <strong>is</strong> the<br />
result of the action and interaction of natural and/or human factors;<br />
Why do a Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong>?<br />
Section 10, Planning and Development Act 2000 5 requires that all Local Authorities consider<br />
‘the <strong>character</strong> of the <strong>landscape</strong>’ when drawing up objectives for their new county<br />
development plans, in the interests of proper planning and sustainable development.<br />
The European Landscape Convention (ELC), which Ireland ratified in 2002, requires<br />
signatories to assess and map their <strong>landscape</strong>s in the interest of wider European <strong>landscape</strong><br />
planning and sustainable development. An important aspect of the ELC was to engage in<br />
widespread public consultation when assessing <strong>landscape</strong> value, which <strong>is</strong> a key component<br />
of the <strong>Roscommon</strong> LCA.<br />
LCA Stage 1: Character<strong>is</strong>ation<br />
Character<strong>is</strong>ation <strong>is</strong> the first stage of the process and involves a desk study to ascertain from<br />
ex<strong>is</strong>ting available information with the use of Geographic Information Systems (GIS) the<br />
landform and landcover of a given <strong>landscape</strong>. Other aspects such as nature designations<br />
and h<strong>is</strong>torical monuments are also taken into account. Initial draft maps of the <strong>character</strong><br />
areas and <strong>character</strong> types are produced based on professional interpretation of the desk<br />
information and field work <strong>is</strong> then conducted to ‘ground truth’ the maps. The refinements are<br />
made to the maps accordingly.<br />
Landscape Character Type<br />
Landscape Character Types are d<strong>is</strong>tinct <strong>landscape</strong>s that are relatively<br />
homogeneous in <strong>character</strong>. They are generic in nature in that they may occur in<br />
different areas in different parts of the country, but wherever they occur they<br />
broadly share similar combinations of geology, topography, drainage patterns,<br />
vegetation, h<strong>is</strong>torical land use and settlement pattern. For example drumlins<br />
and mountain moorlands are recogn<strong>is</strong>able and d<strong>is</strong>tinct <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong><br />
types 6 .<br />
Landscape Character Areas<br />
Landscape Character Areas are unique, geographically-specific areas of a<br />
particular <strong>landscape</strong> type. Each has its own individual <strong>character</strong> and identity,<br />
even though it shares the same generic <strong>character</strong><strong>is</strong>tics with other areas of the<br />
same type. Th<strong>is</strong> d<strong>is</strong>tinction <strong>is</strong> reflected in the naming of types and areas:<br />
<strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong> types have generic names, but <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong> areas<br />
ake on the names of specific places. Example might be the south Leitrim<br />
drumlins and the Wicklow mountain moorlands 7 .<br />
4<br />
The Countryside Agency and the Scott<strong>is</strong>h Natural Heritage (2002), Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong>: Guidance for England<br />
and Scotland<br />
5<br />
Part II, s10(e) of the Local Government Planning and Development Act 2000<br />
6<br />
The Countryside Agency and the Scott<strong>is</strong>h Natural Heritage (2002), Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong>: Guidance for England<br />
and Scotland<br />
7<br />
Ibid<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 2
LCA Stage 2: Making of Judgements<br />
The second stage of the process <strong>is</strong> to record the value placed on the <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong><br />
areas. The <strong>Roscommon</strong> LCA has put huge weight on the importance of consulting widely<br />
with both local and national interest groups and, more importantly, the people of <strong>Roscommon</strong><br />
to d<strong>is</strong>cover what <strong>landscape</strong>s are valued and why.<br />
Mapping of Landscape Value<br />
A number of different studies were undertaken to classify <strong>landscape</strong> values in <strong>County</strong><br />
<strong>Roscommon</strong>. These involved to varying degrees Community Groups, <strong>Roscommon</strong> <strong>County</strong><br />
Council and the Consultants. An outline of the stepw<strong>is</strong>e procedure used <strong>is</strong> provided below.<br />
Desk Reviews<br />
The Landscape Consultants first carried out a literature review of the most pertinent<br />
documents relating to <strong>landscape</strong> value and sensitivity, including the current <strong>County</strong><br />
Development Plan.<br />
Consultation with Planning Staff<br />
All available members of the <strong>County</strong> Council Planning staff were invited to take part in an<br />
exerc<strong>is</strong>e to map (1) <strong>landscape</strong> quality and (2) the location of scenic views and scenic routes.<br />
They were provided with maps of the county and asked to map roads currently not<br />
designated in the CDP as Scenic Routes but which are perceived to be of such high quality<br />
that they might warrant designation.<br />
Initial Field Work<br />
Following the consultation with Planning staff, the Consultants spent a number of day’s inthe-field<br />
examining the <strong>landscape</strong>s of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> and assessing them in terms of<br />
value. The field work also enabled the Consultants to examine those locations identified by<br />
the Council Planning staff as being potential scenic routes and scenic views. The outcome of<br />
th<strong>is</strong> latter study was the preparation of a draft Scenic Routes and Scenic Views Map, a copy<br />
of which <strong>is</strong> depicted in Appendix 1.<br />
Community Consultation<br />
The Consultants placed a high priority on consulting with local community groups on their<br />
aspirations and concerns for the <strong>Roscommon</strong> <strong>landscape</strong>. In total three community focus<br />
group meetings were held, one in Boyle, the other two in <strong>Roscommon</strong> Town. Those<br />
community groups deemed to be most relevant to the <strong>landscape</strong> study were selected from<br />
the Community Forum database and invited to attend the events. There was also some<br />
public advert<strong>is</strong>ement of the events in local newspapers as well as on local radio.<br />
Following introductory presentations by the Consultants, the focus group attendees were<br />
organ<strong>is</strong>ed into tables compr<strong>is</strong>ing 5 to 6 individuals. They were then asked to engage in a<br />
mapping exerc<strong>is</strong>e with the principle aim of identifying <strong>landscape</strong>s of high value. They were<br />
asked to highlight those <strong>landscape</strong>s they most value using coloured markers and to indicate<br />
in writing why those <strong>landscape</strong>s are regarded as being special. The Consultants deliberately<br />
provided no guidance on how <strong>landscape</strong>s should be judged. Instead, the attendees were<br />
encouraged to approach their assessment of <strong>landscape</strong> with a broad appreciation of what<br />
makes certain areas more special, whether for aesthetic, cultural, natural or environmental<br />
reasons.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 3
The mapping exerc<strong>is</strong>e proved to be a very effective medium for highlighting the <strong>landscape</strong>s<br />
perceived to be most valued in <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong>. The open and informal forum also<br />
encouraged much debate within and between groups as a representative from each group<br />
had to present an overview of their table’s deliberations on <strong>landscape</strong> value. Despite the<br />
wide ranging views held by different individuals and groups (ranging from pro-development to<br />
conservative), common ground could be recogn<strong>is</strong>ed when all the maps were collectively<br />
reviewed.<br />
In addition to mapping of special <strong>landscape</strong>s, the focus group attendees were asked to<br />
openly debate a number of forces of change, including single rural dwellings, forestry and<br />
wind farms. The main <strong>is</strong>sues which emerged during th<strong>is</strong> d<strong>is</strong>cussion are noted in the minutes<br />
of the meetings, presented in Appendix 2.<br />
Preparation of Draft Landscape Values Map<br />
The marked-up maps prepared by the three Focus Groups were collated and reviewed by<br />
the Consultants. In the majority of locations, there was broad agreement between the<br />
professional judgement of the Consultants and the mapping prepared by the attendees. As a<br />
practical example of th<strong>is</strong>, the Rathcroghan and Lough Key areas were identified early on in<br />
the study by the Consultants as being of exceptional <strong>landscape</strong> value. Th<strong>is</strong> judgement was<br />
later supported by the fact that practically all of the groups in the community meetings<br />
highlighted those same areas as being particularly special.<br />
Landscape value can be a mixture of criteria that combine to make an area special. Many of<br />
the focus group attendees described the places they valued using these same criteria, as<br />
follows:<br />
‣ D<strong>is</strong>tinctiveness – A <strong>landscape</strong> that <strong>is</strong> highly d<strong>is</strong>tinctive from its surrounds as being<br />
easily identifiable in its own right (Drumlin Lakelands in the north east of the county).<br />
‣ Quality – Landscapes of very high quality and which are in good condition tend to be<br />
highly valued (Lough Key Forest Park)<br />
‣ Rarity – whether at a national or international level (Rathcroghan archaeological site)<br />
‣ Representativeness – The area might represents such a particularly good example of a<br />
given <strong>landscape</strong> type that it <strong>is</strong> highly valued (Esker <strong>landscape</strong>s in the south and north<br />
west of the county)<br />
Regarding the classification of <strong>landscape</strong> value, the Consultants decided to use the following<br />
four levels:<br />
‣ Exceptional Value<br />
‣ Very High Value<br />
‣ High Value<br />
‣ Moderate Value 8 .<br />
Those <strong>landscape</strong>s of Exceptional Value tend to be generally sensitive to forces of change<br />
and development should be more restricted in such areas. Landscapes of Moderate Value,<br />
on the other hand, tend to be less sensitive and are therefore more tolerant of change. Each<br />
of the 36 <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong> areas were classified according to the above four levels of<br />
<strong>landscape</strong> value, the result of which <strong>is</strong> presented later in Section 4.<br />
8<br />
In the study pertaining to <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong>, the Consultants chose not to use the ‘Low Landscape Value’ classification as it<br />
<strong>is</strong> felt that there are be no <strong>landscape</strong>s of low level.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 4
LCA Stage 3<br />
Landscape Policies and Recommendations<br />
The final stage <strong>is</strong> to combine the physical and perceived elements of <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong><br />
and interpret these with regard to built development. In other words, how sensitive the<br />
<strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong> areas are to built development. Th<strong>is</strong> information <strong>is</strong> often presented in<br />
matrix format. In th<strong>is</strong> study, however, a prescriptive matrix <strong>is</strong> not proposed. Instead, detailed<br />
recommendations are made for each of the 36 <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong> areas.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 5
SECTION 2:<br />
OBJECTIVES AND GUIDELINES<br />
2.1 Introduction<br />
The public consultation aspect of <strong>Roscommon</strong> Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> has<br />
identified places that are of most value to the people of <strong>Roscommon</strong>. The study will help to<br />
ensure built development will have regard to the surrounding <strong>landscape</strong>. By integrating new<br />
development sensitively with <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong> a strong sense of place will be maintained<br />
and the quality of life of the people of <strong>Roscommon</strong> improved. When describing the places of<br />
most value many people identified the quiet, remote spots (like bogs, lakes, forests or<br />
elevated view points) as well as places with strong built heritage (such as archaeological<br />
<strong>landscape</strong>s, old demesnes, castles and stonewalls) and nature conservation areas. People<br />
valued these not least because of their tour<strong>is</strong>m potential, but because they are proud of<br />
them. Generally speaking, people were open to all kinds of development in different types of<br />
<strong>landscape</strong>s, but also recogn<strong>is</strong>ed the need for balance and restraint where appropriate. Many<br />
expressed concern at the quality of housing from both a design and environmental<br />
perspective. There was widespread agreement that design guidelines were necessary in th<strong>is</strong><br />
regard. Increasing biodiversity through tree and hedgerow planting in towns, villages and<br />
rural areas was repeatedly mentioned.<br />
Overall, it would be fair to say that the people of <strong>Roscommon</strong> are very proud of their<br />
<strong>landscape</strong> and feel that it <strong>is</strong> an untapped resource, which <strong>is</strong> in danger of being eroded by<br />
insensitive development. People would like to see the quality of their <strong>landscape</strong>s improved<br />
and their built heritage recovered or preserved as an everyday v<strong>is</strong>ible reminder of what it<br />
means to live in <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong>.<br />
The <strong>landscape</strong> policies that will be recommended seek to address insofar as practicable the<br />
concerns expressed by people at the focus group meetings. They will focus on key<br />
development types such as single rural dwellings, farm buildings, wind farms, quarries<br />
(particularly in relation to eskers) and forestry. The tour<strong>is</strong>m potential of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong><br />
cannot be overstated, given its rich water based amenities and opportunities for tranquil<br />
nature based activities. These <strong>landscape</strong> resources must be highlighted and developed<br />
where ever possible.<br />
2.2 Opportunities Presented by the Unique Landscape Character of <strong>County</strong><br />
<strong>Roscommon</strong><br />
The urban and rural <strong>landscape</strong> of <strong>Roscommon</strong> offer many opportunities for sustainable<br />
development. These have been identified during the public debate:<br />
1. There <strong>is</strong> a spread of towns and villages within the county that are already serviced<br />
with water and waste water treatment systems. An audit of physical and social<br />
infrastructure will identify where there <strong>is</strong> spare capacity to accommodate expansion of<br />
the urban footprint.<br />
2. The heritage quality of towns such as <strong>Roscommon</strong>, Boyle and Elphin <strong>is</strong> highly valued<br />
and viewed as an opportunity to provide a quality living environment if developed<br />
sensitively.<br />
3. Certain <strong>landscape</strong> types found in the <strong>County</strong> provide a good opportunity to<br />
accommodate change without comprom<strong>is</strong>ing the <strong>landscape</strong>. Landscape <strong>character</strong><br />
types such as Drumlin Lakeland, Wet Farmland and Bog and Farmland Complex can<br />
often absorb the impact of new development due to their v<strong>is</strong>ual complexity created by<br />
variation in both landform and landcover. A <strong>landscape</strong> v<strong>is</strong>ual capacity matrix <strong>is</strong><br />
attached in Appendix 1.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 6
4. There <strong>is</strong> a major opportunity to bring about an improvement to the quality of single<br />
rural dwellings in the countryside through the introduction of <strong>character</strong>-specific design<br />
guidance. Such guidance could build on the work initiated in <strong>County</strong> Cork through the<br />
inclusion of recommendations regarding low energy and even Passive House<br />
standard design.<br />
5. The mix of rare <strong>landscape</strong> features including bogs, turloughs, callows and eskers<br />
create a unique <strong>character</strong> to <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> and provide a valuable opportunity<br />
for geo-tour<strong>is</strong>m.<br />
6. The considerable extent of waterways including rivers, turloughs, wetlands and fens<br />
offer a rich and varied resource offering sites of significant ecological importance and<br />
scenic value as well as considerable potential for f<strong>is</strong>hing and tour<strong>is</strong>m development.<br />
7. Remnants of earlier settlements at Rathcroghan, Tulsk, Rindoon and the various<br />
O’Connor’s castles bring a sense of continuity to the county. An appreciation of the<br />
heritage value and tour<strong>is</strong>m potential of these sites was well highlighted in public<br />
consultation sessions.<br />
8. There are areas of agriculture, forestry and bogland that may in the future offer<br />
sustainable resources for new enterpr<strong>is</strong>e, for example:<br />
‣ Eco Tour<strong>is</strong>m with walking trails in cut-bogs and forests.<br />
‣ Bio-energy including the wider use of anaerobic digesters to produce bio-fuel from<br />
the waste streams of abattoir slurry and sewage sludge.<br />
‣ Ash tree afforestation.<br />
‣ Commercial production of sheep wool for high quality insulation.<br />
9. The v<strong>is</strong>itor centre at Arigna provides sound evidence of the potential to develop<br />
tour<strong>is</strong>m enterpr<strong>is</strong>es based on previous industrial land uses. A similar project could<br />
perhaps be inspired by the bogs and electricity generation plant at Lanesborough.<br />
10. The development of wind energy projects was generally welcomed and could be<br />
facilitated by the high voltage grid connection found at Lanesborough in the east of<br />
the county.<br />
11. There are opportunities to improve degraded areas with potential to develop an<br />
economy of small scale rural enterpr<strong>is</strong>e and tour<strong>is</strong>m.<br />
12. If details of access can be agreed in conjunction with private owners and the Local<br />
Authority, new areas may be opened up for the enjoyment by the public (examples<br />
include national monuments and lesser known archaeological sites).<br />
13. Particular locations were highlighted by members of the local community as being<br />
highly valued for the rare tranquility qualities that they offer. Whilst <strong>County</strong><br />
<strong>Roscommon</strong> may not offer many and varied dramatic scenic <strong>landscape</strong>s there <strong>is</strong><br />
clearly a great love of intimate scenic places such as wetland <strong>landscape</strong>s and the<br />
<strong>is</strong>olation of blanket bog areas, particularly in the north east of the county where<br />
attention was drawn to the ‘rare quality of the light’.<br />
14. As part of th<strong>is</strong> study ex<strong>is</strong>ting and proposed Scenic Routes and Scenic Views have<br />
been drafted to provide opportunities to improve the quality of life for residents and to<br />
encourage tour<strong>is</strong>m. Such places can encourage passing tour<strong>is</strong>ts to stop and enjoy the<br />
<strong>Roscommon</strong> <strong>landscape</strong>. The mapping of such locations will provide an opportunity to<br />
protect the most important views<br />
15. There are greater opportunities to develop readily v<strong>is</strong>ible ‘gateway’ features on entry<br />
to the county, such as the notable warrior sculpture on the N4.<br />
2.3 Consideration of General Landscape Objectives<br />
2.3.1 Influences<br />
Valued Landscapes<br />
Certain views are particularly valued by the local community for their local amenity and<br />
tour<strong>is</strong>m value. A draft map of Scenic Routes and Scenic Views has been prepared identifying<br />
these. The focus group meetings identified a number of special places where it was<br />
considered that the quality of the <strong>landscape</strong> requires particular protection. The most highly<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 7
valued <strong>landscape</strong>s are l<strong>is</strong>ted below, but a fuller d<strong>is</strong>cussion of the outcome of the focus group<br />
deliberations <strong>is</strong> presented later in Appendix 2:<br />
‣ Lough Key Forest Park and surrounding area, including Boyle and the Curlew<br />
Mountains.<br />
‣ Rathcroghan archeological complex.<br />
‣ The Shannon and Suck river corridors which flow in a north-south direction on the<br />
eastern and western side of the county.<br />
‣ <strong>Roscommon</strong> Town and surrounding areas, including Skrine Hill to the south, due to<br />
its unique built heritage.<br />
‣ Castlerea bogland area retains a unique sense of <strong>is</strong>olation and tranquility which was<br />
particularly highlighted by the public as a quality that needed protection as a<br />
d<strong>is</strong>tinctive feature of the <strong>landscape</strong> in <strong>Roscommon</strong>.<br />
‣ Eskers were considered sensitive to quarrying. Th<strong>is</strong> <strong>is</strong> further supported by<br />
d<strong>is</strong>cussions held with staff working at the GSI.<br />
Section Four of th<strong>is</strong> document describes each <strong>character</strong> type and <strong>character</strong> area in detail,<br />
highlighting the key physical, cultural and ecological features. Each section will recommend<br />
ways in which the <strong>landscape</strong> quality can be protected by judicious strategies for<br />
development. There are also a number of other drivers of change that will need to be<br />
considered, particularly in relation to the natural environment of the <strong>County</strong>, which <strong>is</strong> mapped<br />
and described in Section Four of th<strong>is</strong> report.<br />
Bio-diversity Plans<br />
The need to protect biodiversity <strong>is</strong> becoming increasingly stringent and policies within the<br />
<strong>County</strong> Development Plan will need to have regard to a number of international, national and<br />
regional plans, including Ireland’s commitment under the Convention on Biological Diversity<br />
to ‘Halt the Loss of biodiversity by 2010’. The newly opened National Biodiversity Records<br />
Centre, attached to Waterford Institute of Technology, may be able to contribute to providing<br />
baseline studies of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong>.<br />
European Directives<br />
Recent opinions and legal proceedings from the European Court of Justice over failures to<br />
fully apply EU Directives requires much higher levels of compliance with European<br />
environment policy. Thus where development <strong>is</strong> proposed close to a designated ‘Natura<br />
2000’ site it will be necessary to prepare an appropriate assessment under Article 6 of the<br />
Habitats Directive (92/43/EEC), normally an Environmental Impact Statement to confirm that<br />
no damage will occur to the habitat as a result of the development. It <strong>is</strong> also a requirement<br />
that the habitat value of undesignated and other known sites of significance are protected<br />
from damage.<br />
Water Framework Directive<br />
There <strong>is</strong> a particular need to carefully consider the water abstraction needs of new<br />
development in a <strong>landscape</strong> replete with watery fens and turloughs. Th<strong>is</strong> will take on greater<br />
import as the Water Framework Directive <strong>is</strong> implemented in <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong>.<br />
An objective to produce Environmental Impact Statements for significant developments likely<br />
to impact on water tables will be appropriate to establ<strong>is</strong>h how much water can be abstracted<br />
before there <strong>is</strong> significant impact upon these ecologically valuable areas.<br />
The constraint of development on flood plains and the creation of 50m set backs from rivers<br />
will be necessary to protect water quality and watery habitats such as the Ballinturly SAC<br />
where wintering geese and swans are v<strong>is</strong>ible from the Athleague Road.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 8
2.3.2 Objectives<br />
In response to <strong>is</strong>sues ra<strong>is</strong>ed in the public consultation and other expert advice the following<br />
general objectives relating to <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong><strong>is</strong>ation may be appropriate. More specific<br />
recommendations for each Landscape Character Area will be presented later in Section 4.<br />
Policies are not designed to repeat national planning policy or regional planning guidelines<br />
but should explain how they apply to local circumstances. They will recommend the<br />
circumstances in which planning perm<strong>is</strong>sion may or may not be granted in order to protect<br />
the countryside for the sake of its intrinsic quality, beauty and tranquility, the diversity of its<br />
<strong>landscape</strong>, heritage and wildlife, and the wealth of its natural resources, so that it may be<br />
enjoyed by all.<br />
1. Policies should reflect the spatial v<strong>is</strong>ion for the county, which will aim to channel new<br />
residential and commercial buildings into the towns, villages and rural areas as<br />
appropriate where necessary infrastructure can be provided. New development in the<br />
rural hinterland away from ex<strong>is</strong>ting settlement will be encouraged where it supports<br />
the rural community and rural economy and <strong>is</strong> appropriate in terms of scale, <strong>character</strong><br />
and location.<br />
2. Infrastructural development (including roads, public transport facilities, new bioenergy<br />
production units such as anaerobic digesters, waste management facilities),<br />
applications for forest and bio-fuel crops, wind turbines, and necessary quarries<br />
should also be encouraged in appropriate areas. Special attention should be directed<br />
towards the <strong>landscape</strong> values map wherein development can be expected to be<br />
constrained in areas of Exceptional Value. In the detailed <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong><br />
descriptions that follow, recommendations regarding tolerance of change for various<br />
development kinds are summar<strong>is</strong>ed.<br />
3. Tour<strong>is</strong>m economy will be encouraged by the development of the built and natural<br />
environment of the county, in particular the enhancement of waterways and <strong>is</strong>lands,<br />
the promotion of walking in scenic and tranquil areas, the restoration of architectural<br />
heritage and archaeological sites in urban and rural settings, and the protection of<br />
Scenic Routes and Scenic Views.<br />
4. Applications should be assessed in regard to:<br />
‣ The conservation of natural resources including the prudent use of land, energy,<br />
water and air quality.<br />
‣ The protection, maintenance and restoration of the varied <strong>landscape</strong> qualities of<br />
each <strong>character</strong> area. To promote a sense of place, proposals for development<br />
should take into account the local d<strong>is</strong>tinctiveness and sensitivity of each <strong>character</strong><br />
area as described in the Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong>.<br />
‣ The protection and enhancement of the <strong>landscape</strong> setting of ex<strong>is</strong>ting communities<br />
including view corridors, panoramic views from key vantage points and prominent<br />
ridgelines. The retention of separation (un-built land) between different<br />
settlements will be considered, especially where their context <strong>is</strong> regarded as<br />
worthy of preservation and enhancement. The ex<strong>is</strong>ting pattern of woodland, trees,<br />
field boundaries, vegetation and other features should inform dec<strong>is</strong>ions regarding<br />
new development.<br />
‣ The protection of the natural environment, bio-diversity and sites of geological<br />
interest. Close adherence to EU Directives and recent European Court<br />
judgements regarding priority habitats (such as limestone pavements, blanket<br />
bogs and turloughs), designated sites and other sensitive areas will be expected.<br />
‣ Development proposals should have regard to the special qualities of water<br />
courses and water bodies and their surroundings such as valley floors, in<br />
particular the River Suck and the River Shannon. Not only do their scenic<br />
qualities provide a valuable resource for the encouragement of tour<strong>is</strong>m within<br />
<strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> but they also present a rich and varied eco-system as well<br />
as providing a buffer to absorb changing rain patterns expected in a period of<br />
climate change.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 9
‣ Development proposals should have regard to the special recognition of the<br />
eskers in the west and south of the county and their inter-related geomorphological<br />
<strong>landscape</strong> and archaeological significance.<br />
‣ Development proposals should have regard to the protection of the built<br />
environment, recognizing the h<strong>is</strong>toric <strong>character</strong> and heritage value of features<br />
identified in the Landscape Character Study. Development that restores h<strong>is</strong>toric<br />
buildings will be encouraged. New development in areas of built heritage of strong<br />
<strong>character</strong> should meet standards laid out in design guidelines. These will include<br />
guidance on the use of local traditional building materials and local building skills.<br />
It should be an objective to respect the cultural value of urban ephemera such as<br />
pillar boxes or railings. Remnants of a rural culture such as holy wells or stone<br />
walls should also be valued and retained in new development where practicable.<br />
‣ Development proposals should have regard to the objective that development<br />
should not erode the rural <strong>character</strong> of <strong>landscape</strong> and settlements by introducing<br />
unnecessary light and no<strong>is</strong>e into remote and tranquil areas. Insensitive or<br />
urban<strong>is</strong>ed highway treatments, fencing and signage can erode the essential<br />
quality of these areas specifically identified by local communities as sensitive yet<br />
highly valued.<br />
2.4 Development Controls to Ameliorate Landscape Constraints and Facilitate<br />
Sustainable Development<br />
Analys<strong>is</strong> of the d<strong>is</strong>tinct <strong>character</strong> areas in Section Four provides a key to answering many of<br />
the critical questions that need to be asked when considering the opportunities, constraints<br />
and possible mitigating measures of a particular application on a particular site in a particular<br />
<strong>landscape</strong>.<br />
A number of recurring themes arose in the public consultation sessions that may benefit from<br />
further investigation. Developments that follow strategies laid out in guidance notes will meet<br />
the objective of facilitating sustainable development by ensuring that the best possible<br />
proposal can be put forward, informed by the principles of best practice.<br />
Design Guidelines<br />
The objective of <strong>Roscommon</strong> <strong>County</strong> Council, during the currency of the new <strong>County</strong><br />
Development Plan 2008 – 2014 <strong>is</strong> to adopt a set of design guidelines to assimilate new<br />
developments into the ex<strong>is</strong>ting urban and rural <strong>landscape</strong>s. Detail on how best to locate a<br />
dwelling within a site, how to work with the vernacular style of the area including the use of<br />
local materials, how to treat boundaries and how to lay out an estate to create a pedestrian<br />
friendly environment should be included. Specific advice on how to protect <strong>landscape</strong><br />
features during the construction phase of development may also be included.<br />
Design guidelines currently being developed by <strong>Roscommon</strong> <strong>County</strong> Council provide generic<br />
information that can be considered in relation to the local information provided in the<br />
descriptions of local <strong>character</strong> areas in Section Four.<br />
Landscaping Guidelines<br />
Landscaping Guidelines are needed to provide practical information to planning applicants<br />
on how to treat site boundaries by planting native species. The guidelines will address the<br />
loss of habitats and increase biodiversity. Landscape guidelines should be made a planning<br />
condition and enforced by the prov<strong>is</strong>ion of a bond by the applicant and refunded by the Local<br />
Authority upon inspection at a later date.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 10
Light Pollution<br />
Lighting <strong>is</strong> needed for the safety and security of road users and pedestrians and can be used<br />
to great effect in highlighting attractive buildings of architectural interest. However, unsuitable<br />
lighting can cause problems of shadowing and intrusion by glare and dazzle and may affect<br />
both people and the natural environment.<br />
A variety of light sources may cause pollution including street lighting, illuminated signs and<br />
advert<strong>is</strong>ements, security lighting, overspill from office/commercial prem<strong>is</strong>es and floodlighting<br />
of buildings and open spaces.<br />
'Skyglow' <strong>is</strong> now recogn<strong>is</strong>ed as a form of light pollution. Th<strong>is</strong> <strong>is</strong> caused by the refraction of<br />
light, emanating from larger settlements, by water vapour and dust particles, so creating an<br />
orange colouring of the sky, which can eliminate views of the night sky. Where unaffected by<br />
Skyglow, the darkness of the countryside can provide a welcome contrast to an otherw<strong>is</strong>e<br />
well-lit night sky. By reducing the amount of excess light spilling into the night sky, both<br />
Skyglow and energy consumption can be decreased.<br />
By considering the application of the following principles to all applications for planning<br />
perm<strong>is</strong>sion, it should be possible to achieve an attractive and safe night-time environment<br />
that minim<strong>is</strong>es light pollution.<br />
‣ All lighting should be the minimum necessary to be effective.<br />
‣ Energy-efficient installations should be used wherever possible, with consideration given<br />
to the colour of th<strong>is</strong> lighting, especially in Architectural Conservation Areas. However, in<br />
some cases, high-pressure sodium lights that generate a white light will be preferable to<br />
the more energy-efficient, low-pressure sodium (orange) lights. Th<strong>is</strong> principle should also<br />
take into account the environmental impacts of the higher energy usage and production<br />
involved with the High Pressure lighting, as well as <strong>is</strong>sues of increased light pollution and<br />
the <strong>County</strong> Council’s responsibility to provide public lighting within settlements.<br />
‣ Lighting should be designed to limit spillage above the horizontal plane.<br />
‣ Where reasonably achievable floodlights should be directed downwards onto the target,<br />
rather than upwards towards the sky.<br />
‣ In some cases, it may be necessary to install baffles and shields, for example, in order to<br />
protect residential properties from light emanating from commercial, industrial or<br />
recreation facilities.<br />
Very specific information on how to meet these conditions <strong>is</strong> now available and could be<br />
incorporated into guidance notes.<br />
Sustainable Construction Values<br />
Guidance notes may be helpful to adv<strong>is</strong>e applicants on sustainable construction values,<br />
passive housing, energy ratings and water conservation methods to meet the challenge of<br />
climate change and declining energy resources that <strong>is</strong> predicted to impact within the lifetime<br />
of buildings being constructed now.<br />
The <strong>County</strong> Council will apply best practice on sustainable construction and energy<br />
conservation by reference to guidance from the Department of Environment Heritage and<br />
Local Government.<br />
Sustainable Drainage Systems<br />
Sustainable Drainage Systems (SuDS) refers to an approach to the management of surface<br />
water drainage that involves the reduction, attenuation on site and/or slowing of surface<br />
water runoff to more closely follow the natural runoff patterns. SuDS provide a more<br />
sustainable approach to surface water management than conventional methods, which<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 11
generally involve piping surface water directly to the nearest watercourse or river. SuDS can<br />
help to reduce the environmental impacts of development and storm water runoff, provide a<br />
more cost-effective surface water drainage system and create more v<strong>is</strong>ually appealing,<br />
ecologically functional and useable open space environments and amenities in developed<br />
areas. SuDS fall into three main groups which aim to:<br />
1. Reduce the quantity of runoff from the site (source control techniques). Examples include<br />
the use of permeable car parking surfaces, infiltration trenches, infiltration basins, etc.<br />
2. Slow the velocity of runoff to allow settlement, filtering and infiltration (permeable<br />
conveyance systems). Examples include filter (or French) drains and surface water<br />
swales.<br />
3. Provide passive treatment to collected surface water before d<strong>is</strong>charge into land or to a<br />
watercourse (end of pipe systems). Examples include filter strips, detention basins,<br />
retention ponds, constructed wetlands, etc.<br />
All planning applications for developments cons<strong>is</strong>ting of more than single rural dwellings<br />
should carry out hydrological investigations as part of standard EPA tests.<br />
Useful guidance notes already publ<strong>is</strong>hed by various Government agencies<br />
‣ Requirements for the Protection of F<strong>is</strong>heries Habitat during Construction and<br />
Development Works at River Sites. Eastern Regional f<strong>is</strong>heries Board. (Th<strong>is</strong> deals with<br />
bridges and culverts).<br />
‣ Policy Statement on Development Management and Access to National roads. NRA,<br />
June 2006 (th<strong>is</strong> deals with ribbon development on regional roads).<br />
‣ Pilot Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> Clare. The Heritage Council, 1999.<br />
‣ Cork Rural Design Guide: Building a new House in the Countryside. Cork <strong>County</strong><br />
Council, 1993.<br />
‣ Landscape and Landscape <strong>Assessment</strong>. Consultation Draft of Guidelines for Local<br />
Authorities. Department of the Environment, Heritage and Local Government, 2000.<br />
‣ A Guide to Landscape Treatments for National Road Schemes in Ireland. National Roads<br />
Authority, 2006.<br />
‣ Wind Energy Development Guidelines for Planning Authorities. Department of the<br />
Environment, Heritage and Local Government, 2006.<br />
‣ Forestry and the Landscape Guidelines. Forest Service, 1998.<br />
‣ Urban Design Compendium. Rural Partnership. (Th<strong>is</strong> deals with urban design standards<br />
and l<strong>is</strong>ts criteria by which to assess the design of urban estates).<br />
‣ Farm buildings and the environment. An Foras Talunta<strong>is</strong>.<br />
‣ <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> Hedgerow Survey, by Neil Foulkes and Anja Murray. Heritage office<br />
& <strong>Roscommon</strong> <strong>County</strong> Council, 2005. Th<strong>is</strong> document presents specific policy<br />
recommendations to retain hedgerows wherever possible, particularly those hedgerows<br />
identified has having unique qualities. The document proposes that retention, relocation<br />
and re-establ<strong>is</strong>hment of hedgerows should be the subject of financial bonds as a<br />
planning condition.<br />
‣ Study of the extent and conservation status of springs, Fens and F<strong>is</strong>heries in Ireland, by<br />
Peter Foss. NPWS 2007.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 12
SECTION 3:<br />
LANDSCAPE APPROACH TO BUILT DEVELOPMENT<br />
3.1 Introduction<br />
The determination of a planning application depends not only on the receiving environment<br />
and any ameliorating measures prescribed but also on the type of development proposed.<br />
The notes below constitute the main <strong>is</strong>sues around five types of development likely to come<br />
to the forefront of planning choices within the time frame of the next development plan.<br />
These are l<strong>is</strong>ted below:<br />
‣ Housing;<br />
‣ Rural buildings and alternative enterpr<strong>is</strong>e proposals;<br />
‣ Wind farms;<br />
‣ Quarries; and<br />
‣ Forestry (and bio-fuels crops).<br />
Where the analys<strong>is</strong> of a <strong>character</strong> area throws up particular <strong>is</strong>sues relating to the assimilation<br />
of these types of development, recommendations are noted with the individual descriptions.<br />
3.2 Housing<br />
3.2.1 Housing in Ex<strong>is</strong>ting Settlements<br />
Trends<br />
Trends indicate increasing demand for new housing in county <strong>Roscommon</strong>. Th<strong>is</strong> <strong>is</strong> to be<br />
welcomed, particularly where it <strong>is</strong> concentrated in ex<strong>is</strong>ting settlements to encourage a strong<br />
urban structure which <strong>is</strong> essential to the economic well being of the <strong>County</strong>.<br />
Issues<br />
A number of concerns were ra<strong>is</strong>ed by attendees at the focus group meetings regarding new<br />
development in ex<strong>is</strong>ting settlements. These include:<br />
1. New development and in-migration generally was welcomed by the community for the<br />
diversity and energy that it may bring to <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong>.<br />
2. The importance of appreciating the architectural heritage of the built environment.<br />
There were objections to the development of housing within the grounds of heritage<br />
houses and castles.<br />
3. The monotony and sterility of some housing estate design in villages and towns does<br />
not improve the sense of place. Gated developments evoked a negative response<br />
from consultees.<br />
4. New building does not integrate well with the surrounding area.<br />
5. New developments must be pedestrian friendly, ensuring ease of connection to<br />
services and amenities by foot.<br />
6. Poor construction values and insufficient attention paid to providing low energy<br />
demand and group supply technologies (for example d<strong>is</strong>trict heating systems using<br />
wood pellets) will leave a legacy of fuel poverty for home owners.<br />
Key Recommendations<br />
General response and recommendations regarding the relationship between new urban<br />
development and the ex<strong>is</strong>ting urban <strong>character</strong> of the location are as follows:<br />
1. Include policy objectives that ensure the consideration of <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong>, value<br />
and sensitivity when assessing applications for new development.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 13
2. The National Spatial Strategy includes a valuable chart box 5.2 in chapter 5 on the<br />
location of housing in urban areas. Th<strong>is</strong> l<strong>is</strong>ts the criteria that can be used to assess<br />
new development proposals.<br />
‣ The asset test: Are there ex<strong>is</strong>ting community resources such as schools etc with<br />
spare capacity?<br />
‣ The carrying capacity test: Is the environmental setting capable of absorbing<br />
development in terms of drainage etc?<br />
‣ The transport test: Is there potential for reinforcing usage of public transport,<br />
walking or cycling?<br />
‣ The economic development test: <strong>is</strong> there the potential to ensure integration<br />
between housing and employment?<br />
‣ The <strong>character</strong> test: will the proposal reinforce the sense of place and <strong>character</strong>?<br />
‣ The community test: Will the proposal reinforce the integrity and vitality of the<br />
local community and services that can be provided?<br />
‣ The integration test. Will the proposal aid an integrated approach to catering for<br />
the housing needs of all sections of society?<br />
3. It should be an objective of the Council to establ<strong>is</strong>h a rolling programme to encourage<br />
the preparation of Village Design Statements in co-operation in with local<br />
communities for settlements in <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> that are experiencing<br />
development pressure or where the local community express an interest. The<br />
objectives of the Statement would be to Identify and describe the d<strong>is</strong>tinctive <strong>character</strong><br />
of the village and the surrounding countryside and to establ<strong>is</strong>h design principles<br />
based on that d<strong>is</strong>tinctive <strong>character</strong>. The Statement will provide a strong, locally<br />
based, adv<strong>is</strong>ory input into future development and planning policy in the area.<br />
4. Include development control objectives to encourage and promote the use of local<br />
building materials and skills.<br />
3.2.2 Housing in Rural Areas<br />
Ex<strong>is</strong>ting patterns and trends<br />
The settlement pattern in <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> may be <strong>character</strong><strong>is</strong>ed as d<strong>is</strong>persed with low<br />
levels of population across the county, particularly in the north, and a high percentage of<br />
single rural housing.<br />
The National Spatial Strategy 9 identifies an important need to support the role of rural towns<br />
and villages at the local level, as a focus for investment, economic activity and housing<br />
development, which at the same time will support the vitality of wider rural areas. The West<br />
Regional Authority Planning Guidelines 10 has an objective to minim<strong>is</strong>e sprawling<br />
development of towns and villages so as to create consolidated village form and to support<br />
development in the towns and villages in the region that <strong>is</strong> in sympathy with the ex<strong>is</strong>ting built<br />
environment, ensuring that any approved developments are in keeping with the town or<br />
village ethos which may be unique to each settlement.<br />
Whilst there <strong>is</strong> a population trend towards urban areas there <strong>is</strong> still a significant demand for<br />
single rural housing where land <strong>is</strong> cheaper.<br />
D<strong>is</strong>persed settlement pattern can constitute the least sustainable response to meeting<br />
housing demand 11 however the need for some rural housing <strong>is</strong> acknowledged in the<br />
Sustainable Rural Housing Guidelines 2006 to allow for permanent settlement in structurally<br />
9<br />
National Spatial Strategy. 2002-2020. People Places and Potential. Department of the Environment 2002.<br />
10<br />
Regional Planning Guidelines. West Region, publ<strong>is</strong>hed by the West Regional authority, 2003.<br />
11<br />
Whilst some people express a preference for rural living for the space and low crime levels that it may offer, there <strong>is</strong> a need to<br />
ensure that all the external costs of rural housing are taken into account when assessing applications for perm<strong>is</strong>sion to build.<br />
Th<strong>is</strong> will include the economic costs of providing services in rural areas, the social costs of families facing long commutes to<br />
work and the environmental costs of carbon credits where commuting patterns of residents involve long d<strong>is</strong>tances and high<br />
global warming em<strong>is</strong>sions.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 14
weak areas of the county to stop the decline of population and to provide for local demand<br />
from people needing to live outside of the towns for economic or social reasons.<br />
Issues<br />
1. The <strong>County</strong> Development Plan will define policy to manage the development of<br />
d<strong>is</strong>persed housing but the aspect that th<strong>is</strong> report specifically considers <strong>is</strong> the v<strong>is</strong>ual<br />
impact within the <strong>landscape</strong>. Th<strong>is</strong> was a matter of great concern for many members<br />
of the focus groups, particularly as the sites most in demand appear to be elevated<br />
scenic areas close to urban centres. The need to preserve valued Scenic Routes and<br />
Scenic Views was ra<strong>is</strong>ed and th<strong>is</strong> report includes a table of special views both in rural<br />
and urban areas. 12<br />
2. There was also a strong voice from the focus groups that certain areas were too<br />
precious to spoil, not least the remote and tranquil <strong>landscape</strong>s found in areas of<br />
boglands, upland forests and lakelands.<br />
3. The quality of architecture and position of new buildings in scenic areas was also an<br />
<strong>is</strong>sue of concern with an expressed preference for the use of local materials in<br />
designs in keeping with the local vernacular (Figure 1). The retention of stone walls<br />
and native hedgerows was ra<strong>is</strong>ed by consultees. These endower the countryside with<br />
a d<strong>is</strong>tinctive and attractive appearance. In particular, regional and local variations in<br />
hedgerows contribute significantly to the d<strong>is</strong>tinctiveness of <strong>Roscommon</strong>’s <strong>landscape</strong><br />
<strong>character</strong>.<br />
They make up the familiar setting that <strong>is</strong> so central to the cultural heritage and<br />
tour<strong>is</strong>m and give the impression of a wooded <strong>landscape</strong>. 13<br />
There was considerable interest by members of the focus groups in the need for<br />
design guidelines.<br />
Figure 1:<br />
Examples of vernacular architecture in <strong>Roscommon</strong><br />
12<br />
See Appendix 1<br />
13<br />
Ibid<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 15
4. Another key <strong>is</strong>sue in relation to rural housing <strong>is</strong> the impact of water abstraction and<br />
water quality. Landscape qualities described in the main section of th<strong>is</strong> report will<br />
ass<strong>is</strong>t in identifying areas where the potential to drain important wet lands or the<br />
potential to pollute ground water <strong>is</strong> most likely (for example in karst areas). The<br />
usefulness of proprietary water treatment systems to overcome the potential to<br />
pollute should be considered in the light of resources available to monitor the<br />
maintenance of these systems. <strong>Roscommon</strong> <strong>County</strong> Council should introduce strict<br />
controls to ensure that maintenance contracts on proprietary sewage treatment plants<br />
for single dwellings are applied and continued particularly in the ongoing life of the<br />
system.<br />
Recommendations<br />
Certain areas of <strong>Roscommon</strong>, for example rolling drumlin lakelands are <strong>character</strong><strong>is</strong>ed by<br />
<strong>landscape</strong> that can more easily assimilate housing and other development due to the<br />
inherent screening provided by rolling landform and dense arrangement of heavy hedgerows.<br />
In Section Four special recommendations will be made as to how housing can best be<br />
assimilated by implementing policies to direct development into the most favoured sites.<br />
In addition the concerns ra<strong>is</strong>ed by members of the public suggest a number of specific<br />
responses and objectives that <strong>Roscommon</strong> <strong>County</strong> Council could adopt to ass<strong>is</strong>t in<br />
encouraging and controlling sustainable development of housing in rural areas.<br />
1. A draft map of Scenic Routes and Scenic Views <strong>is</strong> presented in Appendix 1 and these<br />
should be taken into consideration in the determination of planning applications for<br />
development.<br />
2. The appearance of development and its relationship to its surroundings should be a<br />
material consideration in the determination of planning applications. A survey of the<br />
site should be part of an application to develop and should include a site plan, site<br />
layout and a plan of ex<strong>is</strong>ting built and natural <strong>landscape</strong> features that will be informed<br />
by the Landscape Character Study. For private single rural dwellings, the guidance<br />
notes titled Landscaping your House in <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> with Native Trees and<br />
Shrubs (2007) prepared by the <strong>County</strong> Council of rural sites should be followed with a<br />
special emphas<strong>is</strong> on using local materials and tree species found in the immediate<br />
vicinity.<br />
3. Development proposals should minim<strong>is</strong>e the loss of hedgerows, trees and woodlands<br />
and pay regard to the Hedgerow survey. Where appropriate development proposals<br />
should include landscaping schemes that reflect the <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong> of the<br />
location as identified in the Landscape Character Study.<br />
4. Applications should also include details of all services and infrastructure. Regard<br />
should be had to the prov<strong>is</strong>ion of drains, pipe lines or cable routes that may cross the<br />
path of features that have been identified as significant in the Landscape Character<br />
Study.<br />
5. The architectural design should take into consideration the vernacular style of the<br />
area and pay regard to any design guidelines adopted by <strong>Roscommon</strong> <strong>County</strong><br />
Council.<br />
6. No<strong>is</strong>e and light pollution will be taken into consideration in determining planning<br />
applications. In areas identified in the Landscape Character Study as being<br />
particularly valued for their tranquility applicants should be asked to submit<br />
management plans to limit the impact of pollution.<br />
7. Sufficient measures should be put into place to avoid adverse impacts upon features<br />
noted in the Landscape Character Study during the period of construction particularly<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 16
in relation to protecting ex<strong>is</strong>ting mature trees and hedgerows, as well as the removal<br />
and storage of top soil, on site during the construction phase.<br />
3.3 Rural Buildings and Alternative Enterpr<strong>is</strong>e Proposals<br />
Trends<br />
Future trends indicate a substantial number of new proposals for building in the rural area,<br />
possibly outside of ex<strong>is</strong>ting settlements.<br />
‣ The implementation of the EU Nitrates Directive will lead to many applications for slatted<br />
sheds and slurry pits.<br />
‣ An evolving national energy policy will also encourage innovative enterpr<strong>is</strong>e in the rural<br />
areas for new processes including anaerobic digesters and bio-ethanol plants. Unlike<br />
forestry, which requires planning perm<strong>is</strong>sion for blocks of over 50 hectares, planting bioenergy<br />
crops does not require planning perm<strong>is</strong>sion, despite the fact that they will have<br />
considerable impact on the v<strong>is</strong>ual appearance of the <strong>landscape</strong> with bright yellow fields of<br />
rape or the bright blue of flax. However the processing new crops will require<br />
considerable modern infrastructure and new building.<br />
‣ Other supports for farmers may encourage other alternative enterpr<strong>is</strong>es resulting in<br />
applications for change of use of ex<strong>is</strong>ting farm buildings, for example tour<strong>is</strong>m and le<strong>is</strong>ure<br />
projects attached to farm buildings, sawmilling and other timber based industry, large<br />
scale vehicle and machinery depots, recycling services, engineering fabrication<br />
workshops for the construction industry. Many of these require large concrete aprons and<br />
the v<strong>is</strong>ual impact would be far more significant than ex<strong>is</strong>ting farm use.<br />
Response<br />
While the most sustainable location for such infrastructure <strong>is</strong> adjacent to ex<strong>is</strong>ting settlements,<br />
the <strong>County</strong> Council are required to agree objectives and polices to regulate applications for<br />
development in rural areas.<br />
The criteria by which applications will be assessed will include the following:<br />
‣ Will the development contribute to the local economy? Can the applicant demonstrate a<br />
particular locational, process or workforce related need to locate in the rural area?<br />
‣ Are the traffic implications acceptable? Will th<strong>is</strong> location add significantly to increased<br />
dependency on motor vehicles? Are the local roads adequate to absorb increased HGV<br />
traffic? New development will not be permitted with access to national primary roads<br />
except in ex<strong>is</strong>ting settlements where the speed limit of 50-60kph applies, in accordance<br />
with NRA guidelines.<br />
‣ Does the application include strategies for the ecological management of the site<br />
including loss of habitat and potential pollutants of air, soil and water? Is there a plan for<br />
the management of waste, energy and resources?<br />
‣ How will the proposal impact on the local community? Are no<strong>is</strong>e and light implications<br />
acceptable? Is the v<strong>is</strong>ual amenity in the area degraded? Is there any impact on local<br />
access?<br />
Many of these questions can be answered by reference to the Landscape Character<br />
<strong>Assessment</strong>, particularly, but not only, questions regarding the ability of the <strong>landscape</strong> to<br />
v<strong>is</strong>ually absorb new development. These assessments are laid out in Section Four.<br />
In order to meet the objectives proposed for <strong>landscape</strong> it will be necessary to include the<br />
following policies:<br />
‣ Proposals should not negatively impact on the integrity of local amenities and <strong>landscape</strong>.<br />
Applications for development in the rural area will be assessed with regard to the<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 17
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of each area, especially regarding Scenic Routes and<br />
Scenic Views as well as those locations near features of v<strong>is</strong>ual and amenity attraction<br />
such as lakes and water courses as well as areas of strong cultural heritage.<br />
‣ It will be an objective of the council to publ<strong>is</strong>h design guidelines to ass<strong>is</strong>t applicants in the<br />
preparation of proposals. These will cover matters regarding layout and building design,<br />
car parking and circulation, boundary treatments appropriate to the <strong>landscape</strong> area,<br />
drainage, water supply, lighting, no<strong>is</strong>e and advert<strong>is</strong>ing.<br />
‣ Design controls included to minim<strong>is</strong>e the impact of farm buildings and buildings for other<br />
alternative enterpr<strong>is</strong>es in rural areas will include a requirement to provide screening and<br />
shelter belts composed principally of native species. Where cladding <strong>is</strong> used on the<br />
exterior of farm buildings, dark colours (preferably dark green, red or grey) with matt<br />
fin<strong>is</strong>hes will be preferred.<br />
3.4 Quarries<br />
Current situation and future trends<br />
Aggregates are a significant natural resource and the extractive industry makes an important<br />
contribution to economic development in <strong>Roscommon</strong>. During the last decade there has<br />
been increasing pressure to exploit eskers for sand and gravel. Many of the quarries<br />
operating today have a h<strong>is</strong>tory of operation from before the introduction of the Local<br />
Government (Planning and Development) Act, 1963 on 1 October 1964, whether<br />
permanently or on a seasonal or occasional bas<strong>is</strong>.<br />
Under the Planning and Development Act 2000 Section 261 all quarries, except those which<br />
obtained planning perm<strong>is</strong>sion in the last 5 years, must reg<strong>is</strong>ter with the planning authority.<br />
Quarries which had not previously obtained planning perm<strong>is</strong>sion may also be required to<br />
undergo environmental impact assessment and to apply for planning perm<strong>is</strong>sion where there<br />
area <strong>is</strong> greater than 5 ha or where they are situated in designated sensitive areas where their<br />
continued operation would have significant effect on the environment.<br />
However, there will be a continuing need for some new or expanded aggregate quarrying<br />
operations on land to meet regional and local requirements. There <strong>is</strong> thus a need to identify<br />
and protect aggregate resource areas through the planning system, to ensure an adequate<br />
supply of aggregates to meet the likely scale of future while at the same time protecting<br />
Ireland’s natural and cultural heritage.<br />
In addition to aggregate quarries, there will likely be a need for road building rock in the near<br />
future to construct the N5 and N4 which both pass through <strong>Roscommon</strong> and which are due<br />
for realignment in the short to medium term.<br />
Issues<br />
A number of <strong>is</strong>sues regarding quarries were ra<strong>is</strong>ed during public consultation.<br />
1. The v<strong>is</strong>ual impact of quarrying in esker regions.<br />
2. General d<strong>is</strong>-amenity created by no<strong>is</strong>e and dust, as well as heavy traffic on small<br />
country roads.<br />
3. Water pollution. Esker sand and gravel frequently contain the best source of good<br />
quality ground water in the midlands therefore it <strong>is</strong> important to take th<strong>is</strong> into<br />
consideration when assessing d<strong>is</strong>charge licenses for new or ex<strong>is</strong>ting quarries.<br />
4. Proper restoration was also ra<strong>is</strong>ed as a concern.<br />
Eskers<br />
Eskers are long narrow sinuous ridges of sand and gravel that typically formed in sub glacial<br />
river channels during the ice age. They are an irreplaceable eco-system, having unique<br />
<strong>landscape</strong> features. Ir<strong>is</strong>h eskers are recogn<strong>is</strong>ed as having European importance in need of<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 18
special protection (see Council of European Communities 1992). Indeed the word ‘esker’ <strong>is</strong><br />
the Anglic<strong>is</strong>ation of the Ir<strong>is</strong>h word E<strong>is</strong>cir. They are often bounded by ra<strong>is</strong>ed bogs and<br />
therefore form the only high and dry ground in the area. As a consequence eskers were used<br />
as route ways through the midlands since ancient times. The E<strong>is</strong>cir Riada divides the country<br />
stretching from Meath, through Westmeath, Offaly, <strong>Roscommon</strong> and Galway and <strong>is</strong><br />
mentioned in the Annals of the Four Masters 14 .<br />
The Castlesampson Esker, close to Athlone, has been identified by the NPWS as an NHA<br />
and <strong>is</strong> described as one of the best examples of eskers in <strong>Roscommon</strong>. The importance of<br />
the site lies in its almost intact structure, something that <strong>is</strong> very rare in Ir<strong>is</strong>h eskers, in its<br />
relatively und<strong>is</strong>turbed state and in the presence of good quality, species-rich dry calcareous<br />
grassland of a type l<strong>is</strong>ted, with priority status, on Annex I of the EU Habitats Directive<br />
(Special Area of Conservation). It provides a good contrast to the more acidic eskers nearby.<br />
Other eskers of particular note in <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> in LCA 24 are seen from Garranlahan.<br />
Response<br />
In order to encourage the sustainable development of quarries in <strong>Roscommon</strong> it should be<br />
an objective of <strong>Roscommon</strong> <strong>County</strong> Council to identify the location of major deposits and to<br />
safeguard valuable unworked deposits for future extraction.<br />
The GSI has begun developing a new mineral resources programme with the aim of<br />
producing a series of maps including aggregate potential maps<br />
In areas where aggregate potential has been identified, objectives should be included in the<br />
development plan in relation to the following:<br />
‣ The protection of residential amenities.<br />
‣ The prevention of pollution and the safeguarding of aquifers and groundwater.<br />
‣ The protection of <strong>landscape</strong>.<br />
Quarries will not be perm<strong>is</strong>sible on European sites (SAC’s), Natural Heritage Areas (NHA's),<br />
or other areas of importance for the conservation of flora and fauna, or in areas of significant<br />
archaeological potential, unless it can clearly be demonstrated within the framework of an<br />
Environmental Impact Statement that such quarries would not have significant adverse<br />
impacts on amenities or the environment.<br />
Special recognition should be given to the esker area in LCAs 34, 35, and 8 in south<br />
<strong>Roscommon</strong> and LCAs 24 and 25 in north <strong>Roscommon</strong> including all inter-related geomorphological<br />
<strong>landscape</strong>s of archaeological significance.<br />
The following development control objectives are extracted from the Department of the<br />
Environment, Heritage and Local Government ‘Quarries and ancillary activities Guidelines<br />
2004’ will contribute towards the achievement of more sustainable aggregates development<br />
and restoration schemes, by seeking to avoid or minim<strong>is</strong>e adverse impacts on the<br />
environment:<br />
‣ Where possible, ex<strong>is</strong>ting <strong>landscape</strong> features (such as hills and trees) should be used to<br />
screen new extractive industry development. Native species of trees and shrubs can be<br />
planted to create food reserves for wildlife.<br />
‣ Heavy traffic should not be permitted on unsuitable roads and/or other specified roads,<br />
unless suitable upgrading or other improvements agreed with the planning authority are<br />
carried out.<br />
‣ Landscaped mounds, sometimes using topsoil and overburden from the aggregate<br />
workings, can be constructed to screen unsightly excavations, plant or storage ponds.<br />
14<br />
Annals of the four masters, by Brother Michael O’Clery. The Convent of Dunagall, 1636,<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 19
Topsoil and subsoil should be stored separately after surface clearance to facilitate reuse<br />
and should also be seeded. Once work has started, it may be possible to move<br />
equipment and structures to well within the site and in some cases to locate plant in the<br />
deepest part, so as to lessen the v<strong>is</strong>ual, no<strong>is</strong>e and dust nu<strong>is</strong>ance impacts on adjoining<br />
properties. Suitable selection of colours and fin<strong>is</strong>hes for buildings and plant may help<br />
lessen the v<strong>is</strong>ual impact.<br />
‣ Restoration <strong>is</strong> a process that will enable the worked-out quarry or sand pit to be used for<br />
its original purpose (such as agriculture) or adapted for a new use (such as amenity).<br />
Restoration includes design, initial landscaping works, soil spreading, final landform<br />
construction and aftercare. Aftercare <strong>is</strong> the work done after the replacement of the soil<br />
and includes fertil<strong>is</strong>ing, planting, construction of pathways, vegetation maintenance and<br />
an ongoing long-term commitment to the restored land. For successful restoration, steps<br />
must be taken at every stage, from design through operation to decomm<strong>is</strong>sioning of the<br />
facility, to ensure that restoration <strong>is</strong> integrated into the process.<br />
‣ All proposed extractive development proposals must be accompanied by detailed<br />
restoration and after-care plans (although in the case of sites with a long working life, it<br />
may be appropriate to establ<strong>is</strong>h the need for such plans at the outset, while leaving the<br />
details to be agreed either on a phased bas<strong>is</strong> or towards the end of the extractive<br />
process). Progressive restoration should be employed where relevant and practicable,<br />
e.g. for sand and gravel pits.<br />
‣ All buildings, plant, internal roads and paved areas should be removed when extraction <strong>is</strong><br />
completed, unless otherw<strong>is</strong>e agreed as part of the restoration plan. Depending on the<br />
terrain, the ex<strong>is</strong>ting <strong>character</strong> of the area, and the nature and scale of the aggregates<br />
extraction, a variety of after-uses may be possible, including farming, forestry,<br />
recreation/amenity uses, nature conservation, or industry. Where the excavated area will<br />
be below the water table, a <strong>landscape</strong>d pond or lake may be possible. It <strong>is</strong> important that<br />
the acceptability of the proposed after-use be d<strong>is</strong>cussed with the planning authority at the<br />
pre-application stage. The aspirations of the local community should be taken into<br />
account in th<strong>is</strong> regard.<br />
‣ The planning authority may, as a matter of policy, attach planning conditions requiring the<br />
developer to lodge a financial bond to ensure sat<strong>is</strong>factory reinstatement of the site<br />
following the completion of extraction, or to pay a contribution towards the cost of<br />
upgrading or repairing the local road network;<br />
Other potential impacts such as no<strong>is</strong>e, dust, vibration, the effect on the amount of water and<br />
lowering the water table (which would be a particular problem in <strong>Roscommon</strong> with its very<br />
watery habitats,) are d<strong>is</strong>cussed in the DoEHLG guidelines.<br />
It <strong>is</strong> also recommended that planning authorities should familiar<strong>is</strong>e themselves with evolving<br />
best environmental management practice as set out in Environmental Protection Agency<br />
(EPA) guidelines “Environmental Management in the Extractive Industry: Non-Scheduled<br />
Minerals”.<br />
The Ir<strong>is</strong>h Concrete Federation (ICF) has drawn up an Environmental Code for the aggregate<br />
and concrete product industries, to promote member awareness of, and commitment to,<br />
good environmental principles.<br />
3.5 Wind Farm Development<br />
Current situation and future trends<br />
The Atlas of wind Speeds 15 indicate large areas of <strong>Roscommon</strong> that meet technical<br />
requirements for the development of wind turbine sites. However, <strong>Roscommon</strong> <strong>County</strong> has a<br />
very d<strong>is</strong>persed settlement pattern and, outside of areas that may be deemed inappropriate<br />
for one reason or another, there are few sites left that are more than 400 metres from a<br />
15<br />
SEI's Wind Atlas <strong>is</strong> a digital map of Ireland's wind energy resource. It provides detailed information on wind speeds, electricity<br />
transm<strong>is</strong>sion and d<strong>is</strong>tribution networks for specific locations around Ireland at national and county levels<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 20
dwelling. Currently there are commercial wind farms in the Arigna Mountains and near<br />
Bockagh Hill north of Ballaghadereen.<br />
The Energy White Paper March 2007 from the Department of Marine sets out important new<br />
policies to reduce fossil fuel dependency. 33% of energy supply <strong>is</strong> to be met by renewable<br />
energy sources by 2020 with wind energy as a significant component of th<strong>is</strong> target.<br />
Additional government support and the proposed transfer of the electricity grid from ESB to<br />
EirGrid may result in further applications in <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong>.<br />
Issues<br />
1. Outcome of the public consultation sessions indicated that there <strong>is</strong> generally a very<br />
positive attitude towards the v<strong>is</strong>ual appearance of wind turbines in the <strong>landscape</strong>.<br />
There ex<strong>is</strong>ts the perception that the turbines contribute towards green energy and are<br />
pollution free. There <strong>is</strong> also an appreciation of the abstract sculptural qualities of<br />
turbines, which can bring a positive contribution to the <strong>landscape</strong>. Th<strong>is</strong> confirms the<br />
research undertaken previously by SEI and involving MosArt 16 .<br />
2. There were some concerns regarding the v<strong>is</strong>ual and ecological impact of necessary<br />
infrastructure. It <strong>is</strong> important that the <strong>County</strong> Development Plan achieves a balance<br />
between responding to Government policy on renewable energy and enabling the<br />
<strong>County</strong>’s energy resources to be harnessed in a manner that <strong>is</strong> cons<strong>is</strong>tent with proper<br />
planning and sustainable development.<br />
The main potential impacts on habitats that can result in the reduction, or loss, of<br />
biodiversity are:<br />
‣ Direct loss of habitat to the developments’ infrastructure, including turbine<br />
foundations, buildings, roads, quarries and borrow pits;<br />
‣ Degradation of habitats through alteration or d<strong>is</strong>turbance, in particular ar<strong>is</strong>ing<br />
from changes to hydrology that may alter the surface or groundwater flows and<br />
levels, and drainage patterns critical in peatlands and river headwaters;<br />
‣ Fragmentation of habitats and increased edge effects; and<br />
‣ Degradation and loss of habitats outside the development site, especially wetland<br />
habitats that may ar<strong>is</strong>e from pollution, siltation and erosion originating from within<br />
the development site.<br />
In particular it was noted that there has been little scientific work done on the<br />
impacts caused to Blanket Bog and Heath habitats by wind turbine<br />
developments. It <strong>is</strong> known however, that they may impact severely on the<br />
functioning of an intact peatland system. It <strong>is</strong> a widely accepted conservation<br />
policy within blanket bog areas to avoid any fragmentation of the extensive<br />
blanket bog with developments including wind farms, as these impact adversely<br />
on the wildlife, eco-hydrology and physical <strong>character</strong><strong>is</strong>tics of the peatland<br />
ecosystem. The laying of turbine foundations causes drying out and compaction<br />
of peat accompanied by habitat destruction. The infrastructure (servicing roads,<br />
power lines etc.) that must be installed causes further damage. The work carried<br />
out during construction cause major destruction to the habitats that may be<br />
irreversible. Peatlands are fragile hydrological systems that are difficult to restore<br />
once d<strong>is</strong>turbed.<br />
3. Wind Energy. Planning Guidelines 2006 propose that local authorities identify the key<br />
areas where there <strong>is</strong> sufficient wind energy potential and where wind energy<br />
development will be acceptable in principle subject to assessment regarding the built<br />
and natural environment and certain design and landscaping criteria.<br />
16<br />
Attitudes towards the Development of Wind Farms in Ireland. Sustainable Energy Ireland, 2003.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 21
Recourse to the Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> in Section Four gives a clear indication<br />
that, subject to specific controls, examples of potentially appropriate locations might be found<br />
in such places as the Arigna Mountains, Bockagh Hill and surrounds, upland near<br />
Garranlahan, Greywood Hill uplands, Slieve Bawn and high ground to the east of Lough<br />
Funshinagh.<br />
The Landscape <strong>Assessment</strong> will also offer additional information on each <strong>character</strong> area that<br />
will be necessary in order to assess the v<strong>is</strong>ual, cultural and environmental impacts of<br />
applications for wind turbines should they ar<strong>is</strong>e in any of the <strong>character</strong> areas.<br />
Response<br />
It <strong>is</strong> recommended that the following objectives and policies be adopted with the <strong>County</strong><br />
Development Plan:<br />
1. It will be an objective of the Council to encourage the development of wind energy in<br />
suitable locations in an environmentally sensitive way in accordance with Wind Energy<br />
Planning Guidelines and land use policies of the <strong>County</strong> Development Plan.<br />
2. It will be an objective of the Council to investigate the potential for relatively small-scale<br />
wind energy developments within urban and industrial areas, and for small communitybased<br />
proposals outside the key areas that are identified as being potentially<br />
appropriate for wind energy development. Community ownership of wind energy<br />
projects enables local communities to benefit directly from local wind energy resources<br />
being developed in their local areas, ensuring long-term income for rural communities.<br />
3. It should be a policy of the Council that applications for wind turbines be assessed with<br />
regard to:<br />
‣ Wind Speed Atlas produced by SEI.<br />
‣ Accessibility to the National Electricity Transm<strong>is</strong>sion and D<strong>is</strong>tribution Grid. (Th<strong>is</strong><br />
can be found in the Wind Atlas with further information available in the<br />
Transm<strong>is</strong>sion System Operators Forecast Statement www.eirgrid.com).<br />
‣ The suitability of the site having regard to other land use policies and objectives to<br />
protect all aspects of the <strong>landscape</strong> including v<strong>is</strong>ual, cultural and environmental. All<br />
wind turbine proposals, irrespective of size should be subject to full and proper<br />
Environmental Impact <strong>Assessment</strong>.<br />
4. <strong>Assessment</strong> of v<strong>is</strong>ual impact of proposals will have regard to the Landscape Character<br />
<strong>Assessment</strong> and in particular:<br />
‣ The immediate v<strong>is</strong>ual impact and long d<strong>is</strong>tance views.<br />
‣ Scenic Routes and Scenic Views depicted in Appendix 1.<br />
‣ Sites of special value for example in the bogland north of Castlerea (LCA 27) and<br />
Upper Lough Ree (LCA 6) which has been identified as of particular importance for<br />
their sense of <strong>is</strong>olation and tranquility.<br />
5. Applications should pay regard to guidance on the siting and design of wind farm<br />
projects that are included in the Wind Energy Planning Guidelines 2006.<br />
6. Applications should pay regard to the Wind Energy Planning Guidelines 2006 regarding<br />
the <strong>landscape</strong> impact of associated development (including roads and tracks, power<br />
poles and lines, the control building, wind measuring mast and the compound) and<br />
during the construction phase.<br />
7. Where wind energy developments are permitted on peatlands, the implementation of<br />
the following construction guidelines (along with others that are recommended in the<br />
Environmental Impact Statement) may serve to reduce impacts, including minim<strong>is</strong>ing<br />
habitat d<strong>is</strong>turbance and loss, hydrological d<strong>is</strong>ruption and the r<strong>is</strong>k of erosion:<br />
‣ A thorough ground investigation, including hydro-geological investigations where<br />
appropriate, and a detailed evaluation of the nature of the peat, its geotechnical<br />
properties and the associated r<strong>is</strong>k of instability and habitat loss or d<strong>is</strong>turbance<br />
during construction and operation of the wind energy development, <strong>is</strong> to be carried<br />
out where the depth of peat <strong>is</strong> in excess of 50cm.<br />
‣ Avoid construction, if possible, on wet areas, flushes and easily eroded soils.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 22
‣ Avoid the excavation of drains, where possible, unless it <strong>is</strong> necessary for<br />
geotechnical or hydrological reasons.<br />
‣ If drains are unavoidable, ensure that silt traps are constructed and that there <strong>is</strong><br />
only diffuse d<strong>is</strong>charge of water.<br />
‣ Avoid blocking ex<strong>is</strong>ting drains.<br />
‣ Where blasting <strong>is</strong> being used in or near a peatland area for borrow pits, foundations<br />
etc, the possible effect on the peat stability should be assessed.<br />
‣ Avoid stock grazing on any d<strong>is</strong>turbed peat until local peatland vegetation has<br />
recovered (e.g., by use of temporary electric fencing).<br />
3.6 Forestry and Bio-fuels<br />
Current situation<br />
Data from 2005 shows that nearly 20,000 ha of forestry has been planted, representing 8%<br />
of the total land cover in the <strong>County</strong> (Landcover Map of Landscape Character Areas in<br />
Section 4). Some 11,000 ha of th<strong>is</strong> <strong>is</strong> on private land with over 8,000 ha in public ownership.<br />
Much of th<strong>is</strong> <strong>is</strong> currently on marginal land, in particular on Slieve Bawn, across the upper<br />
Arigna Valley, close to Strokestown and around Ballinlough where it provides a significant<br />
element of the <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong>.<br />
Trends in Forestry<br />
There was a significant amount of planting in the county in the mid 1990’s and private<br />
applications for forestry are still grant driven. In the recent past demand has fallen as<br />
competing land uses, such as house building, have driven up the price of land and made the<br />
returns on forestry appear less rewarding. However if predictions of decline in the<br />
construction industry and falling prices for beef materialize there <strong>is</strong> likely to be renewed<br />
interest from the farming community for forestry, even in better quality land to the south of<br />
the county, particularly following the introduction of the Forest Environment Protection<br />
Scheme (FEPS) for farmers in REPS and greater uptake of the Native Woodland Scheme<br />
Trends in Biofuels<br />
It <strong>is</strong> too early to say whether the recent Bio-energy Action Plan for Ireland March 2007 17 will<br />
result in a change of land use towards the production of various energy crops such as<br />
M<strong>is</strong>canthus and willow. Certainly in <strong>Roscommon</strong> the underlying watery nature of much of the<br />
land will deter production of willow. Even though these crops have some effect of drying out<br />
land, heavy machinery <strong>is</strong> required to harvest the crop during wet winter months when the<br />
land may be boggy. Willow requires high quality fertile soils in low lying, sheltered areas<br />
which will place it in competition with grain production, and willow does not like peaty soils<br />
which will rule it out over much of <strong>Roscommon</strong>.<br />
M<strong>is</strong>canthus tolerates a wider range of soils and although it requires plenty of summer rain it<br />
may prove more attractive to <strong>Roscommon</strong> farmers. Best Practice Manuals produced by the<br />
Department of Agriculture and Food include references to <strong>landscape</strong> and environment. The<br />
manuals indicate that production requires large scale equipment thus grassland rides at<br />
headlands and verges will make the retention of hedgerows and grass strips likely thereby<br />
reducing the v<strong>is</strong>ual impact on <strong>landscape</strong> and encouraging a healthy eco-system. 10%<br />
uncropped land allowed for in the grant system can accommodate <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>is</strong>sues and<br />
assessors should be encouraged to refer to the <strong>Roscommon</strong> <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong><br />
assessment when considering applications.<br />
17<br />
Bio-energy Action Plan for Ireland. Department of Agriculture and food. 2007. Th<strong>is</strong> includes proposals that Peat fired Power<br />
Stations in Lanesborough and Shannonbridge be co-fired by 30% renewables by 2015. New bio-fuel obligations for transport<br />
should average 5.75% by 2009 all public buses should use bio-fuel mix.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 23
The manuals also indicate that bio-fuels should be grown close to their intended production<br />
units and there may be an increase in applications for Bio-energy Stations which will impact<br />
on <strong>landscape</strong>. These matters have been d<strong>is</strong>cussed in the section on Farm buildings.<br />
Issues<br />
Afforestation <strong>is</strong> not generally a concern for those people from the community present at the<br />
focus meetings however a number of matters were ra<strong>is</strong>ed regarding coniferous forests which<br />
are perceived to reduce biodiversity, damage eco-systems, block views and provide poor<br />
amenity for associated le<strong>is</strong>ure activity. Clear felling was deemed to be a problem. It was<br />
generally considered that more sensitive planting including increased broadleaf trees such as<br />
ash would be an improvement, together with more protection for hedgerows and ex<strong>is</strong>ting<br />
trees in the old demesnes and urban areas.<br />
The following five guidelines, publ<strong>is</strong>hed by the Department of Agriculture are the<br />
mechan<strong>is</strong>ms by which the Forest Service will ensure that the environmental aspects of<br />
Sustainable Forest Management are implemented. Adherence to the guidelines <strong>is</strong> a<br />
condition of grant aid and the <strong>is</strong>suing of a felling license.<br />
1. Forestry and the Landscape Guidelines - Presented to ensure that all new<br />
plantations complement, rather than detract from, the <strong>landscape</strong>. The objectives of<br />
<strong>landscape</strong> design are introduced, together with a <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong> type<br />
approach. The forest cycle <strong>is</strong> outlined in terms of operations and their impact on the<br />
<strong>landscape</strong>. Also outlined are measures to mitigate adverse impacts and to enhance<br />
the overall <strong>landscape</strong>, involving shape, scale, diversity, v<strong>is</strong>ual force and unity.<br />
2. Forestry and Water Quality Guidelines - Sensitive water catchment areas are<br />
defined and their management prescribed. Guidelines are given relating to the best<br />
forest management practices to ensure the maintenance of high water quality.<br />
Recommendations are also made in relation to cultivation, drainage, fertil<strong>is</strong>ing and<br />
storage, the use of chemicals, herbicides and fuels, road-making, bridges and<br />
culverts, and harvesting.<br />
3. Forestry and Archaeology Guidelines - Designed to ensure that Ireland’s rich<br />
heritage of archaeological sites and artifacts <strong>is</strong> not damaged by forest operations.<br />
They deal specifically with relevant leg<strong>is</strong>lation, sources of records of known<br />
archaeological sites, types of sites, protective measures to be employed, and<br />
contact details.<br />
4. Forest Biodiversity Guidelines - To recogn<strong>is</strong>e the importance of the maintenance<br />
and enhancement of forest biodiversity, and implement the objectives in a forestry<br />
context of the National Biodiversity Plan. They describe a range of measures to<br />
conserve and enhance biodiversity in forests, such as species and structural<br />
diversity, retained habitats and open spaces, the retention of deadwood, the control<br />
of troublesome species such as rhododendron, and the use and conservation of<br />
native provenances.<br />
5. Forest Harvesting and Environmental Guidelines - Produced to ensure that all<br />
forest harvesting operations, including felling, extraction, road and site restoration,<br />
are environmentally sustainable. They describe the impact of harvesting on water,<br />
forest soils, <strong>landscape</strong>, archaeological sites, forest health and vitality, and<br />
biodiversity, and lay down clear instructions to ensure best practice.<br />
In all cases, reference to the Landscape Character<strong>is</strong>ation <strong>Assessment</strong> will be necessary in<br />
order to implement the guidelines.<br />
Response to Landscape Character<br />
<strong>Roscommon</strong>’s <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong> varies considerably in regard to both landform and land<br />
cover. Any approach to forest <strong>landscape</strong> planning and design should therefore deal with the<br />
forest in the context of the surrounding <strong>landscape</strong>, as described in the Landscape<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 24
Character<strong>is</strong>ation <strong>Assessment</strong> in section Four of th<strong>is</strong> report.<br />
The Forestry and Landscape Guidelines provide prec<strong>is</strong>e recommendations for various forest<br />
development scenarios and for four d<strong>is</strong>tinct <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong> types<br />
‣ Rolling moorland, represented in <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> by the Landscape Character Type<br />
of Hills and Uplands and Bogland.<br />
‣ Rolling fertile farmland, represented by Wet Farmland, Dry Farmland, River Corridors.<br />
‣ Drumlins, represented by Drumlin Lakelands.<br />
‣ Mountain and farmland complex, including Bog and Farmland Complex.<br />
Planning and design criteria<br />
Many of the concerns frequently ra<strong>is</strong>ed relating the v<strong>is</strong>ual impact on <strong>landscape</strong> can be dealt<br />
with by sensitive design as outlined below.<br />
Roadsides<br />
Forests located very close to the roadside often present a continuous solid conifer wall. In<br />
order to provide v<strong>is</strong>ual variety and stimulation for road users, design along roadsides should<br />
aim to create a sequence of varying spaces and to provide views into the forest interior.<br />
Blocking views along roadsides<br />
A common critic<strong>is</strong>m of forests along roadsides <strong>is</strong> that they block views of the surrounding<br />
<strong>landscape</strong>. Th<strong>is</strong> <strong>is</strong> particularly frustrating where there <strong>is</strong> a sense of the possibility of<br />
panoramic or attractive views, such as that experienced at the brow of a hill. In scenic areas<br />
or along Scenic Routes or at Scenic Views, it <strong>is</strong> therefore necessary to retain a reasonable<br />
number of views throughout the full forest rotation for the benefit of road users.<br />
Water bodies<br />
The same principles that apply to roadsides are also relevant to aquatic zones, including<br />
streams, rivers and lakes. An informal natural layout and the inclusion of native riparian trees<br />
also play a major role in promoting aquatic ecosystems. (See Forestry and Water Quality<br />
Guidelines regarding the creation and appropriate treatment of associated buffer zones.)<br />
Houses<br />
Houses and other buildings such as churches and schools can be v<strong>is</strong>ually <strong>is</strong>olated by<br />
forestry that <strong>is</strong> located too close.<br />
‣ Planting should be kept 60 m from dwellings and associated buildings.<br />
‣ Set-back d<strong>is</strong>tance <strong>is</strong> most critical when a building <strong>is</strong> surrounded by forest on two sides or<br />
more. Where adjoining properties are 0.2 ha or less, it <strong>is</strong> recommended that planting be<br />
kept back 30 m from the property boundary.<br />
‣ Wider edge spacing and the incorporation of lower growing broadleaves such as birch<br />
and rowan will soften the forest edge.<br />
‣ In the case of ex<strong>is</strong>ting forests, the pruning and re-spacing of edge trees should be<br />
considered to allow more filtered light into the forest.<br />
‣ Forest developers should lia<strong>is</strong>e with the owners of neighbouring properties, to resolve in<br />
advance any potential concerns.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 25
Size<br />
In some situations, forests are too small in relation to the scale of the surrounding <strong>landscape</strong>.<br />
Achieving successful integration of small plots presents a considerable challenge, particularly<br />
on open ground.<br />
‣ Create a v<strong>is</strong>ual link with surrounding <strong>landscape</strong> elements. For example, a generous<br />
broadleaf margin of varying width and linked in with nearby hedgerows could be used.<br />
‣ Shape the forest with projections and recesses which reflect the proportion of the<br />
surrounding <strong>landscape</strong> context.<br />
Arrangement<br />
Due to the pattern of land ownership in Ireland, forests on hill or mountain sites are often<br />
establ<strong>is</strong>hed as long narrow belts running uphill in <strong>is</strong>olation. Where a number of these are<br />
planted in close proximity, the resulting ‘ladder’ effect involving alternate strips of forest and<br />
open ground creates a d<strong>is</strong>jointed <strong>landscape</strong>.<br />
The ideal solution <strong>is</strong> to plant the land separating adjacent forests, i.e. to undertake forest<br />
infill. However, where such land does not become available for planting, establ<strong>is</strong>hing a<br />
relationship between the forest and unplanted ground becomes critical. Th<strong>is</strong> can be achieved<br />
through; pattern variation, e.g. by creating open spaces in the canopy and recesses along<br />
the edge; and consideration of margin, colour and texture, by using species which relate to<br />
the colours of the open ground, e.g. the colour of larch during the dormant season relates<br />
well to mountain <strong>landscape</strong>.<br />
Location<br />
Due to land ownership and/or site productivity, forests are sometimes located mid-slope on<br />
open mountainsides. Failure to v<strong>is</strong>ually connect such forests with other <strong>landscape</strong> features<br />
such as field boundaries, streams, gullies or rock outcrops creates the impression of the<br />
forests ‘sliding’ downhill.<br />
Th<strong>is</strong> effect <strong>is</strong> further strengthened if the forest <strong>is</strong> lopsided or imbalanced on the mountain<br />
slope, as viewed from, for example, a public road or settlement.<br />
Where possible, extend the plot in the direction of the above mentioned <strong>landscape</strong> features.<br />
It may also be necessary to consider pattern, proportion, edge and margin to directly relating<br />
the forest v<strong>is</strong>ually to its surrounds.<br />
Shape<br />
As with the above design factors, the shape of forests in Ireland has been primarily<br />
determined by land ownership. Given that fields or properties are invariably angular in<br />
outline, resulting forests often resemble ‘blocks’ on the <strong>landscape</strong>. Th<strong>is</strong> may create an<br />
adverse v<strong>is</strong>ual impact, particularly on open mountainsides.<br />
The most effective solution <strong>is</strong> to break down the angular geometry of the forest plot through<br />
recessing and curving corners, leaving some areas unplanted and softening edges by<br />
incorporating ‘outliers’, i.e. outlying groups and single trees.<br />
Angular shaped compartments defined by, for example, straight ridgelines, should also be<br />
avoided. Where possible, ridgelines should run along the contour and should not be in line<br />
with the main view.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 26
Pattern<br />
Due to lack of variation, forests sometimes resemble homogeneous ‘blankets’ in the<br />
<strong>landscape</strong>, without variation of pattern. Such forests can often conceal the underlying pattern<br />
of the ground surface produced by, for example, rock, vegetation and water.<br />
The creation of open spaces within the canopy <strong>is</strong> particularly important in the case of large<br />
forests on mountainsides. These open spaces might include attractive rocky outcrops, land<br />
incapable of supporting a commercial crop, or areas where planting <strong>is</strong> curtailed or<br />
undesirable, e.g. areas in the vicinity of aquatic zones and archaeological sites and<br />
monuments. If no such features ex<strong>is</strong>t to prompt variety of pattern, open spaces should still be<br />
created at locations where they will be easily perceived externally. Ensure that these open<br />
areas are large enough to enable their continued v<strong>is</strong>ibility as the forest matures. Plant a<br />
mixture of species carefully located throughout the canopy to reflect and highlight ex<strong>is</strong>ting<br />
ground surface patterns.<br />
Edge<br />
Successful design of the forest edge <strong>is</strong> critical, particularly when viewed at close proximity<br />
from, for example, a road or house, or when located adjacent to an attractive feature such as<br />
a lake or river.<br />
It <strong>is</strong> essential to avoid creating a solid forest ‘wall’ and to provide views into the interior.<br />
There are several ways of opening the forest edge.<br />
‣ A diffuse edge can be created by pulling the forest back from the site boundary and by<br />
creating a zone of loosely scattered trees or ‘outliers’, using wide spacing and low<br />
growing species such as rowan and birch.<br />
‣ The incorporation of particular species into the forest margin can also enhance edge<br />
appearance. For example, the inclusion of self-pruning or lightly branched conifers such<br />
as Scots pine or larch into the margin can be of great benefit, by increasing v<strong>is</strong>ibility into<br />
the stand.<br />
Margin, Colour, Texture<br />
Some forests, mainly in upland areas, are occasionally regarded as being monotonous, due<br />
to the lack of colour or textural variation of both the margin and the main forest body. The<br />
primary objective concerning margin, colour and texture <strong>is</strong> to introduce an appropriate level<br />
of species and age variation.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 27
SECTION 4:<br />
LANDSCAPE ASSESSMENT STUDY<br />
4.1 Introduction<br />
In th<strong>is</strong> section the results of the <strong>landscape</strong> assessment are presented both in map form as<br />
well as in written descriptions and guidance. The base maps that were created in a<br />
geographic information system (GIS) are first presented, including analys<strong>is</strong> of elevation and<br />
landform, land cover, nature designations, h<strong>is</strong>torical <strong>landscape</strong>s and wind speeds, followed<br />
by maps detailing the location of both <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong> types and <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong><br />
areas as well as a classification of <strong>landscape</strong> value and a draft map indicating the location of<br />
Scenic Routes and Scenic Views (Appendix 1). In all, nine maps of the county are presented<br />
below, providing the bas<strong>is</strong> for a thorough analys<strong>is</strong> of the <strong>landscape</strong>s of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong>.<br />
Following presentation of the above maps, an outline description of each of the <strong>landscape</strong><br />
<strong>character</strong> areas has been prepared. These descriptions focus on the key <strong>character</strong><strong>is</strong>tics of<br />
each <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong> area, followed by a d<strong>is</strong>cussion regarding <strong>landscape</strong> value and<br />
forces of change and culminating in proposing area specific recommendations. A photograph<br />
depicting the essential <strong>character</strong> of each area <strong>is</strong> also included as well as a key map to<br />
illustrate county context.<br />
4.2 GIS Analys<strong>is</strong> and Desk Study Mapping of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong><br />
The initial appra<strong>is</strong>al of <strong>landscape</strong> in <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> was completed through desk<br />
studies involving mostly GIS. Th<strong>is</strong> computer<strong>is</strong>ed mapping and analys<strong>is</strong> tool enables the<br />
preparation of base maps that give the <strong>landscape</strong> assessors a detailed impression of the<br />
aesthetic, natural and cultural qualities of <strong>landscape</strong> prior to engaging in field work. The key<br />
maps prepared as part of th<strong>is</strong> study are described below.<br />
Landform and Elevation<br />
The map presented below entitled Landform and Elevation Map of Landscape Character<br />
Areas depicts a computer generated 3D model of the landform of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong><br />
overlaid with contours. The map summar<strong>is</strong>es at a glance the key landform <strong>character</strong><strong>is</strong>tics of<br />
the county including, for example, the following:<br />
‣ Upland areas in the extreme northeast and northwest as well as a ridge of high ground in<br />
the mid-east region.<br />
‣ D<strong>is</strong>tinct rolling drumlin hills and Lakeland extending from the northeast in a<br />
southwesterly direction.<br />
‣ Low lying areas and river corridors along the eastern and western boundaries.<br />
‣ Elevated plateaus and low undulating hills located in the centre region.<br />
‣ Finger-like esker ridges located mostly in the south of the county but also found in the<br />
northwest and the east.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 28
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 29
Landcover<br />
The elevation and landform map above presents what might be considered as the ‘skeleton’<br />
of the <strong>landscape</strong> upon which the ‘skin’ or land cover <strong>is</strong> draped. An overview of the map<br />
entitled Landcover Map of Landscape Character Areas <strong>is</strong> included below and an overview of<br />
the key <strong>character</strong><strong>is</strong>tics can be summar<strong>is</strong>ed as follows:<br />
‣ In the center of the county landcover <strong>is</strong> predominantly dry grassland, reflecting for the<br />
most part the well draining pure limestone bedrock geology of the area. There are also<br />
patches of reclaimed blanket bog throughout, however, indicating that soil conditions are<br />
somewhat limiting in terms of crop production.<br />
‣ The northwestern and northeastern landcover pattern <strong>is</strong> markedly different to that of the<br />
centre of the county, compr<strong>is</strong>ing a complex of mostly bogland (including ra<strong>is</strong>ed bog and<br />
reclaimed ra<strong>is</strong>ed bog) as well as wet grasslands. Similar landcover <strong>is</strong> found along the<br />
mid-east section of the county. These areas are clearly more marginal in terms of<br />
agricultural production and are a product of both landform as well as the underlying<br />
bedrock geology which includes muddy limestone as well as sandstones and mudstones.<br />
‣ The river corridors defining the eastern, southern and western boundaries typically<br />
compr<strong>is</strong>e a combination of extensive areas of bogland fringed by swaths of dry<br />
grassland.<br />
Nature Designations<br />
The wetland nature of landcover in <strong>Roscommon</strong>, compr<strong>is</strong>ing extensive bogs and lakes,<br />
creates a <strong>landscape</strong> of high nature value. There are several areas of NHA, cSAC and SPA<br />
throughout the county as can be seen in the map below entitled Nature Designations with<br />
Landscape Value of Character Areas. Not surpr<strong>is</strong>ingly, there <strong>is</strong> a strong correlation between<br />
th<strong>is</strong> map and that of landcover with many of the bogland and wetland areas being designated<br />
for their natural heritage. Often there <strong>is</strong> a strong correlation between nature designations and<br />
overall <strong>landscape</strong> value as can be seen from the map presented.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 30
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 31
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 32
H<strong>is</strong>torical Landscapes<br />
A map presenting an interpretation of the h<strong>is</strong>torical <strong>landscape</strong>s of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> <strong>is</strong><br />
also presented in th<strong>is</strong> section. A summary overview of th<strong>is</strong> analys<strong>is</strong> <strong>is</strong> d<strong>is</strong>cussed below.<br />
A total of thirteen h<strong>is</strong>toric land-use types were identified. Each type <strong>is</strong> <strong>character</strong><strong>is</strong>ed by its<br />
period of origin as well as its form and function. H<strong>is</strong>toric Landscape Character<strong>is</strong>ation (HLC)<br />
brings to the fore the effect of human activity on the <strong>landscape</strong> and how people have<br />
interacted with and manipulated the natural environment. The emphas<strong>is</strong> <strong>is</strong> on the present<br />
day <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong> as created by human interaction and perception.<br />
Towns/Villages (Early Medieval 4 th - 8 th Century): The earliest towns in Ireland often grew<br />
up around monastic settlements. There are several examples of towns/villages in<br />
<strong>Roscommon</strong> that had early inception dates and formed proto-towns: <strong>Roscommon</strong> Town and<br />
Elphin.<br />
Towns/Villages (Medieval 12th century – Modern): The concept of a true town was<br />
introduced by the Anglo-Normans. Extant medieval towns and villages in <strong>Roscommon</strong> county<br />
are: Knockvicar, Boyle, Castleplunket, Tulsk, Ballintober, Athleague, Termonbarry, Castlerea<br />
and Athlone.<br />
Towns/Villages (Post-Medieval – Modern): These smaller urban areas owe their inception<br />
to the Plantation settlements of the 17 th century, the Estate towns of the 18 th century (e.g.<br />
Strokestown and Frenchpark) and towns that developed during the 19 th century. Extant<br />
towns and villages from th<strong>is</strong> period are: Keadew, Ballinameen, Cootehall, Ballyfarnon,<br />
Arigna, Frenchpark, Ballaghaderreen, Loughglynn, Ballinalough, Cloonfad, Bellanagare,<br />
Strokestown, Lanesborough, Roosky, Castlecoote and Knockcroghery.<br />
Rectilinear Fields – Hedgerows (18 th – 19 th Centuries): Th<strong>is</strong> <strong>is</strong> the predominant h<strong>is</strong>toric<br />
<strong>landscape</strong> type in <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong>. These enclosed fields are typically rectangular or<br />
sub-rectangular in shape with relatively straight sides. The boundaries of these fields are<br />
made up of hedgerows with possible banks and ditches. Th<strong>is</strong> <strong>landscape</strong> was significantly<br />
remodeled by the work of the Congested D<strong>is</strong>tricts Board in the middle of the nineteenth<br />
century replacing the older, more informal clachan-and-rundale system. The result was the<br />
regimented ladder farms that we see today.<br />
A clachan (or baile or ‘village’) was a nucleated group of farmhouses, with landholding<br />
organ<strong>is</strong>ed communally (often on a townland bas<strong>is</strong> and often with kinship ties). The houses<br />
were surrounded by the best possible land in the area known as the infield (a large open-field<br />
unenclosed and permanently cultivated). Outside of the infield was the outfield which would<br />
be poorer land and used as commonage. Many clachans were initiated in the 18 th century<br />
(due to population increases and the ability of the potato to grow in poor soils) but were<br />
probably even earlier.<br />
Rectilinear Fields – Stone Walls (18 th – 19 th Centuries): There are several areas of the<br />
county where the material used to enclose the field systems are stone.<br />
Rectilinear Fields – Hedgerows – Cutover Blanket Bogs (19 th – 20 th Centuries):<br />
Enclosed fields bounded by hedgerows on reclaimed upland wetland.<br />
Rectilinear Fields – Hedgerows – Cutover Ra<strong>is</strong>ed Bogs (19 th – 20 th Centuries):<br />
Enclosed fields bounded by hedgerows on reclaimed wetland.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 33
Extractive Industries (17 th -20 th Centuries):<br />
These cons<strong>is</strong>t of commercial peat milling, iron and coal mining. The commercial peat milling<br />
has taken place in the 20 th century. The Arigna mine was originally in the 17 th century an iron<br />
mine but later on large coal seams were found.<br />
Mature Forest (17 th -19 th Centuries): Woods that were possibly managed for timber<br />
production or as part of parkland of large estates. Mixed deciduous and coniferous species.<br />
Coniferous Plantations (20 th<br />
Coillte.<br />
Century): Trees planted as part of grant schemes or by<br />
Bogland (Preh<strong>is</strong>toric-Modern): Areas of bog with no v<strong>is</strong>ible evidence of peat extraction or<br />
land improvement. These areas often contain archaeological features with no above ground<br />
expression.<br />
Rathcroghan, Carns, Tulsk (Late Preh<strong>is</strong>tory, Early Medieval, Medieval): Settlement,<br />
ceremonial activities (inauguration site for Kings of Connaught), agricultural systems<br />
(elongated rectangular fields, dating to Early Medieval Period or earlier), roadways.<br />
Demesnes (18 th -19 th Centuries): Lands held by a large house which incorporated farmland,<br />
gardens, woods and buildings. These include: Strokestown, Frenchpark, Rockingham, Mote<br />
Park, Kilronan Castle Demesne (NGR 188110, 312821) and Cootehall.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 34
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 35
Wind Speeds<br />
The Project Brief required consideration of planning <strong>is</strong>sues concerning wind farm<br />
development in <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> and throughout the detailed descriptions presented in<br />
Section 4.3 below, reference <strong>is</strong> made to potential for development in th<strong>is</strong> regard. In order to<br />
ensure that recommendations are practicable in terms of commercial viability of wind farms,<br />
an analys<strong>is</strong> of average wind speeds was completed. In the map below entitled Wind Speed<br />
Map of Landscape Character Areas, all those locations with wind speeds of eight metres per<br />
second and above are highlighted. A summary of the key <strong>is</strong>sues relating to th<strong>is</strong> map <strong>is</strong><br />
presented below:<br />
‣ Not surpr<strong>is</strong>ingly windy areas tend to be concentrated on higher ground and ridges as<br />
d<strong>is</strong>cussed earlier under the landform and elevation map.<br />
‣ There are very extensive areas of high wind speeds on what might be described as<br />
slightly elevated land in the middle of the county as well as in the northwest.<br />
‣ The extensive bogland areas located along the river corridors on the eastern and western<br />
boundaries have very poor wind resource.<br />
Community Consultation Values<br />
As detailed in Section 1 of th<strong>is</strong> report, a number of community consultation focus group<br />
meetings took place in <strong>Roscommon</strong> during the early part of th<strong>is</strong> project. As a medium for<br />
identifying those locations of value to the people of <strong>Roscommon</strong>, the consultees engaged in<br />
a mapping exerc<strong>is</strong>e highlighting special places. A sample map annotated by one of the<br />
groups <strong>is</strong> included below for the purpose of illustration. Th<strong>is</strong> exerc<strong>is</strong>e proved most valuable in<br />
terms of highlighting <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>is</strong>sues of concern and interest to local people.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 36
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 37
Community Landscape Values, one of many maps produced during the public<br />
consultation workshops<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 38
4.3 Landscape Character and Values Mapping<br />
Following completion of a detailed GIS and desk study analys<strong>is</strong> of the <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong><br />
<strong>landscape</strong>s, coupled with the community consultation focus group meetings, the consultants<br />
prepared the following three key maps which are presented and d<strong>is</strong>cussed below:<br />
‣ Landscape Character Types<br />
‣ Landscape Character Areas<br />
‣ Landscape Value<br />
Landscape Character Types<br />
Landscape Character Types are d<strong>is</strong>tinct <strong>landscape</strong>s that are relatively cons<strong>is</strong>tent in<br />
<strong>character</strong>. They are generic in nature in that they may occur in different areas in different<br />
parts of the county, but wherever they occur they broadly share similar combinations of<br />
geology, topography, drainage patterns, vegetation, h<strong>is</strong>torical land use and settlement<br />
pattern. In <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> seven <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong> types have been identified and<br />
mapped, as follows:<br />
‣ River Corridor (located along eastern and western boundaries);<br />
‣ Hills and Upland (mostly located in the north of the county but also including relatively<br />
confined areas in the middle and west);<br />
‣ Drumlin Lakelands (concentrated in the northeast);<br />
‣ Bogland (located throughout including along river corridors as well as in the east and<br />
northwest);<br />
‣ Wet Farmland (concentrated in the northern half of the county);<br />
‣ Dry farmland (located in the middle of the county stretching from north to south); and<br />
‣ Bog and Farmland Complex (located in the south and middle of the county highlighting<br />
the interface between wetter and drier land).<br />
Landscape Character Areas<br />
Landscape Character Areas are unique, geographically-specific areas of a particular<br />
<strong>landscape</strong> type. Each has its own individual <strong>character</strong> and identity, even though it shares the<br />
same generic <strong>character</strong><strong>is</strong>tics with other areas of the same type. Th<strong>is</strong> d<strong>is</strong>tinction <strong>is</strong> reflected in<br />
the naming of types and areas: <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong> types have generic names, but<br />
<strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong> areas take on the names of specific places.<br />
In total, 36 <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong> areas have been identified and mapped in <strong>County</strong><br />
<strong>Roscommon</strong>. They are each described in detail in Section 4.4 below.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 39
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 40
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 41
Landscape Values<br />
The <strong>landscape</strong> values map presented below classifies each of the <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong> areas<br />
into one of the following four classes:<br />
‣ Exceptional Value<br />
‣ Very High Value<br />
‣ High Value<br />
‣ Moderate Value.<br />
There are two <strong>landscape</strong> classified as of Exceptional Value, namely the Tulsk and<br />
Rathcroghan Plateau in the centre of the county (LCA 28) and the Lough Key and Boyle<br />
River Network in the northeast of the county (LCA 16). Classification of the former area <strong>is</strong><br />
greatly influenced by the cultural heritage significance of Rathcroghan, whereas the latter<br />
area <strong>is</strong> valued for its aesthetic and amenity qualities.<br />
The Shannon System running along the eastern boundary of the county has been classified<br />
as of Very High Value, along with Boyle and Curlew Mountains (LCA 17) and the Arigna<br />
Mountains (LCA 14) and Lough Meelagh Drumlins (LCA 15) located in the northeast. The<br />
Shannon System <strong>is</strong> of high aesthetic and ecological quality and the other upland areas<br />
provide important scenic amenities.<br />
The River Suck corridor running along the western boundary of the county <strong>is</strong> judged to be of<br />
High Value due to its amenity, ecological and aesthetic qualities. The Castlerea Ra<strong>is</strong>ed<br />
Bogland (LCA 27) <strong>is</strong> valued for its tranquility as well as ecological importance, the<br />
<strong>Roscommon</strong> Town Hinterland (LCA 32) for its cultural heritage significance and Skrine Hill<br />
and Limestone Pavement (LCA 33) for its unusual geology.<br />
All of the remaining <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong> areas have been classified as of Moderate Value.<br />
None of the <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong> areas are of Low Value.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 42
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 43
4.4 Detailed Landscape <strong>Assessment</strong><br />
In the following section each of the 36 <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong> areas are described in qualitative<br />
terms highlighting key <strong>character</strong><strong>is</strong>tics regarding landform, landcover and overall image. The<br />
rationale for the classification of Landscape Value in each area <strong>is</strong> explained and the primary<br />
forces of change are summar<strong>is</strong>ed in order to draw attention to current and future influences<br />
on the <strong>character</strong>, quality and value of that <strong>landscape</strong>. Lastly, key recommendations are<br />
proposed for each <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong> area concerning the tolerance or otherw<strong>is</strong>e for<br />
change from various development kinds.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 44
<strong>Roscommon</strong> LCA 1: Lough Allen and Arigna foothills<br />
Key Character<strong>is</strong>tics<br />
The Lough Allen and Arigna Foothills<br />
<strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> in the very north of the<br />
county and represents the northern extreme<br />
of the Shannon system which flows from th<strong>is</strong><br />
location along the eastern boundary of<br />
<strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> as far as Shannon<br />
Bridge in the south. Th<strong>is</strong> LCA stretches from<br />
the Arigna River in the south to the border<br />
with <strong>County</strong> Sligo in the north. The area<br />
forms a d<strong>is</strong>tinctly flat region between the<br />
Arigna Mountains and Lough Allen. The land<br />
cover <strong>is</strong> predominantly peat bog and<br />
moorland, however there are areas of<br />
marginal farmland as well as small pockets of<br />
good quality arable land. The main regional<br />
road, the R280, runs north-south through the<br />
area, close to the shoreline of Lough Allen.<br />
There are very few other roads in the area.<br />
While the R280 <strong>is</strong> classified as a Scenic<br />
Route views to the east across the Lough<br />
Allen to are currently intermittent and typically<br />
blocked completely due to overgrown<br />
vegetation along the shoreline. It <strong>is</strong> possible<br />
to see Slieve Anierin to the east over the<br />
screening vegetation and there are<br />
extensive views looking west up to the<br />
Arigna Mountains from the road.<br />
The overall image of the <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> a quiet, sparsely populated broad valley defined<br />
by high mountains overlooking a very large lake.<br />
Landscape Value<br />
The Lough Allen and Arigna Foothills <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> classified as of Very High Value due<br />
its scenic setting and the f<strong>is</strong>hing and boating amenity offered by Lough Allen. There <strong>is</strong> a<br />
designated Scenic Route which runs along the R280 from its junction with the R285 in the<br />
south as far as the county boundary to the north. The rich industrial archaeological heritage<br />
in the upland areas to the west of Lough Allen <strong>is</strong> v<strong>is</strong>ible from th<strong>is</strong> <strong>character</strong> area and<br />
therefore <strong>is</strong> part of the experience to be had in th<strong>is</strong> low lying <strong>landscape</strong>. There are no nature<br />
designations v<strong>is</strong>ible from th<strong>is</strong> LCA and so it <strong>is</strong> not regarded as especially sensitive from a<br />
natural heritage perspective.<br />
Forces of Change<br />
The obstruction of views by overgrown scrub around Lough Allen and the toe of Slieve<br />
Anierin to the east <strong>is</strong> the main threat to the <strong>landscape</strong> quality of th<strong>is</strong> LCA. The majority of th<strong>is</strong><br />
vegetation compr<strong>is</strong>es broadleaf scrub which has grown naturally in the area both along<br />
hedgerows as well as along the shoreline.<br />
Th<strong>is</strong> <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>is</strong> also likely to be a popular target for single rural dwellings given the<br />
lakeside amenities and views on offer. Th<strong>is</strong> would undermine the v<strong>is</strong>ual quality and devalue<br />
its scenic quality.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 45
Key Recommendations<br />
• The quality of views on offer from the Scenic Route would be greatly enhanced by the<br />
selective thinning and removal of heaving screening vegetation located between the<br />
R280 and the shoreline. It should be an objective of the Council to explore<br />
opportunities with the local landowners for the thinning and removal of heavy<br />
screening in th<strong>is</strong> area in order to re establ<strong>is</strong>h the scenic views across Lough Allen.<br />
• An increase in single rural housing and associated traffic would undermine the<br />
tranquil lake shore amenity of Lough Allen and it <strong>is</strong> recommended that development<br />
be prohibited between the scenic route and Lough Allen to avoid the potential for<br />
pollution of the water, blocking views of the lake or creating adverse impacts on the<br />
overall <strong>character</strong> of the area. Where essential housing <strong>is</strong> required th<strong>is</strong> should be<br />
directed to the west of the scenic route if it can be demonstrated that the design<br />
and landscaping will not negatively impact on the receiving <strong>landscape</strong>.<br />
Views of Lough Allen are substantially screened by vegetation from the R280<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 46
<strong>Roscommon</strong> LCA 2:<br />
Upper Shannon and Derreenannagh Drumlin Belt<br />
Key Character<strong>is</strong>tics<br />
Th<strong>is</strong> area stretches northwest from the border<br />
of <strong>County</strong> Leitrim, at Carrick-on-Shannon, to<br />
a hill at Ballytormoyle. The upper Shannon<br />
forms the eastern boundary and the western<br />
boundary <strong>is</strong> determined by the zone of<br />
theoretical v<strong>is</strong>ibility from the river. The<br />
landform of the area <strong>is</strong> of low undulating<br />
drumlins flanking the River Shannon as it<br />
emerges from the southern tip of Lough Allen.<br />
There <strong>is</strong> one larger hill located at<br />
Ballyformoyle, r<strong>is</strong>ing to a height of 153m ASL.<br />
The other principal river <strong>is</strong> the Feor<strong>is</strong>h River<br />
which drains Lough Skean in the west to the<br />
River Shannon in the east. The land cover <strong>is</strong><br />
a complex mix of transitional woodland scrub,<br />
ra<strong>is</strong>ed bog, fens and marginal farmland. The<br />
diversity of landcover in the LCA <strong>is</strong> one of the<br />
greatest among all the <strong>character</strong> areas<br />
studied in the county. The road network <strong>is</strong><br />
compr<strong>is</strong>ed of mainly small rural roads with<br />
some third class roads and only one regional<br />
road, the R284, linking Leitrim Town in the<br />
south east to the village of Keadew in the<br />
north. While there are no major settlements in<br />
th<strong>is</strong> <strong>character</strong> area, there are a number of<br />
towns just outside the boundaries (Leitrim<br />
Town to the east and Carrick-on-Shannon to<br />
the south) from which development <strong>is</strong><br />
creeping into the area. A large portion<br />
of the southern part of the <strong>character</strong><br />
area <strong>is</strong> designated a Natural Heritage<br />
Area (NHA).<br />
The overall image of th<strong>is</strong> <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> one of a sparsely populated wooded drumlin<br />
<strong>landscape</strong> sloping down to the Upper Shannon.<br />
Landscape Value<br />
The Upper Shannon and Derreenannagh Drumlin Belt <strong>is</strong> considered to be of Very High Value<br />
as it forms part of the River Shannon corridor which <strong>is</strong> popular with both water based and<br />
land based tour<strong>is</strong>ts. Strategically, th<strong>is</strong> stretch of the River Shannon <strong>is</strong> a very important node<br />
for inland navigation in Ireland as it connects Lough Allen, the Shannon Erne Link canal, the<br />
Lough Key waterways and the whole Shannon system to the south. The sparsely populated<br />
<strong>landscape</strong> offers tranquility for pleasure craft users.<br />
Forces of Change<br />
The main forces of change in the <strong>landscape</strong> are farm marginal<strong>is</strong>ation which typically leads to<br />
downgrading of the quality of the farmland, as well as increasing single rural dwelling<br />
development pressure along roads approaching towns and villages. Poor siting and design of<br />
individual houses along the River Shannon corridor could also have a negative v<strong>is</strong>ual impact<br />
on the amenity of the upper River Shannon. Ribbon development along the R284 and also<br />
along the road leading into the village of Cootehall (located in LCA 16 to the west) erodes the<br />
tranquil <strong>character</strong> of the rural <strong>landscape</strong>. Given the extent of wet grassland in th<strong>is</strong> LCA, there<br />
may be increased afforestation of coniferous plantations in the future.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 47
Key Recommendations<br />
• There are no elevated viewpoints in th<strong>is</strong> <strong>character</strong> area which <strong>is</strong> typical of most<br />
drumlin <strong>landscape</strong>s as roads tend to travel on lower ground winding their way<br />
between the hills. Views of drumlin <strong>landscape</strong>s are rare. It should be an objective of<br />
the council to assess where views occur of th<strong>is</strong> Drumlin <strong>landscape</strong> and identify which<br />
are especially representative of that <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong> type.<br />
• There <strong>is</strong> also a trend generally in the county that single rural dwellings are positioned<br />
overlooking lakes and rivers. Th<strong>is</strong> trend can erode the v<strong>is</strong>ual quality for tour<strong>is</strong>ts using<br />
waterway amenities and could have a negative impact on the tour<strong>is</strong>m economy and<br />
the scenic reputation of the river corridor. Any applications for development<br />
located on the shoreline of lakes and river corridors should include a V<strong>is</strong>ual Impact<br />
Statement. Regard should be had to The Heritage Council’s Waterways Corridor<br />
Study 18 . Th<strong>is</strong> includes objectives supporting th<strong>is</strong> recommendation, for example<br />
“Maintain and preserve the aesthetic value of the waterways and its shoreline from<br />
the impacts of d<strong>is</strong>persed and highly v<strong>is</strong>ible inappropriate development and<br />
d<strong>is</strong>courage speculative development” (Strategic Aim 6.2.1, Objective No. 2).<br />
• In th<strong>is</strong> <strong>character</strong> area there are views of Slieve Anierin to the north and Sheemore Hill<br />
to the north east from Hartley Bridge. Such views create a sense of place and<br />
should be protected. It <strong>is</strong> recommended that it be an objective of the council to protect<br />
views from bridges.<br />
Hartley Bridge set in the drumlin wetland<br />
18<br />
Waterways Corridor Study, The Heritage Council (2005)<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 48
<strong>Roscommon</strong> LCA 3: Lough Corry Drumlin Basin<br />
Key Character<strong>is</strong>tics<br />
The Lough Corry Drumlin Basin <strong>is</strong> in the north<br />
east of the county. The southern and western<br />
boundaries of th<strong>is</strong> LCA are formed by a zone<br />
of theoretical v<strong>is</strong>ibility created by a series of<br />
drumlins which also mark a change in<br />
elevation between neighbouring <strong>character</strong><br />
areas. The majority of th<strong>is</strong> area drains north<br />
and northeastwards into Lough Corry and<br />
River Shannon. The drainage pattern reflects<br />
the general alignment of drumlins which are<br />
arranged on a southwest to northeast<br />
alignment. The predominant land cover <strong>is</strong> dry<br />
grassland but there are areas of wet<br />
grassland as well as reclaimed blanket bog<br />
throughout. The latter two land cover types<br />
are typically found in the drumlin flats and<br />
hollows. Hedgerows compr<strong>is</strong>e mostly<br />
broadleaf species including ash. In some<br />
areas there <strong>is</strong> a strong sense of openness<br />
created by loose light hedgerows. Th<strong>is</strong><br />
drumlin <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>is</strong> well drained and<br />
relatively dry compared to the drumlin<br />
<strong>landscape</strong>s found both to the north and<br />
south. The road network throughout the area<br />
<strong>is</strong> quite dense with a mix of national (N4<br />
linking Boyle and Carrick-on-Shannon),<br />
regional (R370 and R368), local class and<br />
lanes. While there are no large<br />
settlements in th<strong>is</strong> LCA, the town of<br />
Carrick-on-Shannon spills over the<br />
Shannon River into the northeastern<br />
corner and brings with it both residential<br />
and commercial development.<br />
The overall image of th<strong>is</strong> LCA <strong>is</strong> of a relatively well drained drumlin farmland, with strong<br />
tour<strong>is</strong>t amenities along the River Shannon including Lough Corry.<br />
Landscape Value<br />
The Lough Corry Drumlin Basin <strong>is</strong> classified as Very High Value to reflect the boating, f<strong>is</strong>hing<br />
and scenic amenities along the River Shannon. It <strong>is</strong> valued by tour<strong>is</strong>ts for its peaceful and<br />
largely undeveloped condition.<br />
Forces of Change<br />
Inappropriate and poorly sited development on the shoreline of Lough Corry and along the<br />
River Shannon would have a negative v<strong>is</strong>ual and environmental impact on the wetland<br />
<strong>landscape</strong>. There <strong>is</strong> increasing development pressure along the R370 leading into Carrickon-Shannon<br />
which <strong>is</strong> contributing to the erosion of the rural <strong>character</strong> of the area. Unchecked<br />
ribbon development along the R368 and other local roads connecting to Carrick-on-Shannon<br />
could have a comparable adverse impact. Increasingly marginal<strong>is</strong>ed farmland could also lead<br />
to a gradual down grading of the v<strong>is</strong>ual quality of the <strong>landscape</strong>.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 49
Key Recommendations<br />
• It <strong>is</strong> important to protect the v<strong>is</strong>ual amenities in the immediate vicinity of the Shannon<br />
system. However, in th<strong>is</strong> LCA the drumlins located in the middle and to the west are<br />
less sensitive to development generally because views do not extend from the<br />
Shannon River or Lough Corry. In other words, the depth of view <strong>is</strong> shallow and there<br />
would be greater tolerance of development generally with increasing d<strong>is</strong>tance from<br />
the wetland <strong>landscape</strong>. Therefore it <strong>is</strong> recommended that only those planning<br />
applications within the immediate v<strong>is</strong>ual catchment of the Shannon system will<br />
require a V<strong>is</strong>ual Impact Statement.<br />
Elevated view over the well drained drumlin <strong>landscape</strong><br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 50
<strong>Roscommon</strong> LCA 4:<br />
Kilglass Drumlin Lakelands<br />
Key Character<strong>is</strong>tics<br />
Th<strong>is</strong> <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> located on the eastern<br />
boundary of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> in the<br />
northern half of the county. It <strong>is</strong> defined by a<br />
ridge of high ground in the south, the<br />
Shannon and a series of lakes, the largest of<br />
which <strong>is</strong> Lough Bo Berg, to the east and north<br />
and by a cluster of three hills to the west. The<br />
area compr<strong>is</strong>es low undulating drumlins<br />
which are well drained in the north and<br />
interspersed with a number of large lakes, the<br />
largest being Kilglass Lake, in the south. The<br />
drumlins are aligned on a northeast<br />
southwest ax<strong>is</strong> and th<strong>is</strong> arrangement<br />
determines the pattern of lakes in the greater<br />
area. The lakes fan out from east to west<br />
similar to fingers extending into the rolling<br />
drumlin <strong>landscape</strong>. The effect of th<strong>is</strong> pattern<br />
of lake and hill <strong>is</strong> unique in the context of the<br />
county. Land cover compr<strong>is</strong>es mostly dry<br />
grassland and reclaimed blanket bog with<br />
patches of ra<strong>is</strong>ed bog on lower ground, with<br />
the higher ground on the southern ridge<br />
covered mostly in wet grassland as well as<br />
some areas of conifer forest. Many of the<br />
small hills defining Kilglass Lake are covered<br />
in broadleaf woodland cover. Th<strong>is</strong> <strong>landscape</strong><br />
<strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> thus complex, both from a<br />
landform perspective as well as considering<br />
landcover. There are no major<br />
settlements in the area and the closest<br />
one outside the area <strong>is</strong> Strokestown to<br />
the south. There <strong>is</strong> a dense network of<br />
mostly local roads nestled into the<br />
rolling <strong>landscape</strong>. Kilglass Lake serves<br />
boating and f<strong>is</strong>hing enthusiasts and<br />
includes a marina with pleasure boats.<br />
The image of th<strong>is</strong> <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> of a drowned and dramatic drumlin lakeland<br />
and floodplain offering a tranquil boating amenity.<br />
Landscape Value<br />
The Kilglass Drumlin Lakeland area <strong>is</strong> considered to be of Very High Value due to it its tour<strong>is</strong>t<br />
amenities including f<strong>is</strong>hing, boating and extensive scenic views. The only regional road, the<br />
R371, <strong>is</strong> located in the south of the LCA and provides elevated and panoramic views over<br />
Kilglass Lakes as far as Slieve Anerin and the Arigna Mountains in the d<strong>is</strong>tance. A section of<br />
th<strong>is</strong> road <strong>is</strong> proposed as a Scenic Route. Another Scenic Route <strong>is</strong> proposed further north in a<br />
low lying area along a local road and provides a closer view of Kilglass Lake, its wetland and<br />
a marina. Th<strong>is</strong> LCA <strong>is</strong> thus highly v<strong>is</strong>ually sensitive. The whole of Kilglass Lake <strong>is</strong> designated<br />
an NHA, increasing its sensitivity regarding natural heritage.<br />
Forces of Change<br />
The area <strong>is</strong> of very high v<strong>is</strong>ual amenity and thus tends to attract considerable interest in<br />
people w<strong>is</strong>hing to build single rural dwellings. There are several locations where houses<br />
have been built in the recent past overlooking the lakes and th<strong>is</strong> trend <strong>is</strong> likely to continue<br />
unless measures are put in place to afford greater protection to the <strong>landscape</strong>. There <strong>is</strong> also<br />
likely to be an increase in the extent of afforestation in th<strong>is</strong> <strong>landscape</strong> due to the marginal<br />
quality of farmland. The N5 <strong>is</strong> due to be realigned over a 32 kilometer length and therefore it<br />
may be anticipated that there will be increased demand for quarrying in the area.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 51
In terms of quarrying, there <strong>is</strong> a very large deep-excavation type quarry in operation on hills<br />
to the west but th<strong>is</strong> does not create a significantly adverse impact on the quality of view from<br />
either of the Scenic Routes.<br />
Key Recommendations<br />
• Development of any kind between the Scenic Routes and the lakeland <strong>landscape</strong><br />
beyond should be d<strong>is</strong>couraged due to the quality of views that are available and<br />
objective adopted to prohibit development on the lake side of the Scenic Route.<br />
• Furthermore, applications for single rural dwellings located on the opposite side of the<br />
road should include a V<strong>is</strong>ual Impact Statement which will ensure maximum v<strong>is</strong>ual<br />
integration into their surrounds with a strong emphas<strong>is</strong> on screening, landscaping and<br />
use of natural materials and fin<strong>is</strong>hes.<br />
• The rock cutting that ex<strong>is</strong>ts on the hill to the west at Greywood Hill <strong>is</strong> part of the local<br />
<strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong>. However, where further applications for quarrying ar<strong>is</strong>e<br />
dec<strong>is</strong>ions should have regard to national quarrying guidelines 19 including potential<br />
impact on the <strong>landscape</strong>.<br />
View from the proposed Scenic Route located on the elevated R371<br />
19<br />
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) guidelines “Environmental Management in the Extractive Industry: Non-Scheduled<br />
Minerals”<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 52
<strong>Roscommon</strong> LCA 5: Slieve Bawn and Feor<strong>is</strong>h Bogland Basin<br />
Key Character<strong>is</strong>tics<br />
Slieve Bawn and Feor<strong>is</strong>h Bogland Basin <strong>is</strong><br />
one of the largest <strong>character</strong> areas in the<br />
county stretching from Lanesborough in the<br />
south to Lough Bo Derg in the north. Slieve<br />
Bawn forms the western edge from where the<br />
landform gently slopes eastward draining into<br />
low lying bogland where it meets the eastern<br />
boundary defined by the meandering<br />
Shannon. The mountain <strong>is</strong> one of the highest<br />
ridges in the county, peaking at 262m ASL<br />
and creates strong v<strong>is</strong>ual separation between<br />
the Shannon River and the remainder of the<br />
county in th<strong>is</strong> area. Higher ground <strong>is</strong><br />
predominantly covered in wet grassland with<br />
extensive areas of coniferous plantation as<br />
well as transitional woodland scrub. The<br />
lower region, occupying most of th<strong>is</strong><br />
<strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong> area, <strong>is</strong> made up of<br />
cutover ra<strong>is</strong>ed bog, most of which has been<br />
commercially harvested. Elevated views from<br />
Slieve Bawn to the east are of a highly<br />
mechan<strong>is</strong>ed <strong>landscape</strong> of commercial<br />
peatland and the peat burning electricity plant<br />
in the d<strong>is</strong>tance at Lanesborough. Although<br />
much of the land in the area remains sparsely<br />
populated and <strong>is</strong>olated there <strong>is</strong> a broad<br />
network of roads leading into the cutover bog.<br />
The main settlement in the area <strong>is</strong> the village<br />
of Lanesborough from where ribbon<br />
development spreads northwards along<br />
the main regional road, the R371, and<br />
along a third class road at the foothills<br />
of Slieve Bawn. The settlement pattern<br />
associated with the village of Roosky,<br />
<strong>County</strong> Leitrim, spills over the River<br />
Shannon into the northeastern corner of<br />
the LCA.<br />
The image of the area <strong>is</strong> of mechan<strong>is</strong>ed peatland <strong>landscape</strong> of low lying cutover bog<br />
contained between the River Shannon and a ridge of high forested ground.<br />
Landscape Value<br />
The Slieve Bawn and Feor<strong>is</strong>h Bogland Basin <strong>is</strong> considered to be Very High Value. Th<strong>is</strong> LCA<br />
<strong>is</strong> one of the most varied in the entire county, compr<strong>is</strong>ing a major waterway, extensive<br />
bogland and forest upland. These elements are valuable amenity resources for locals and<br />
v<strong>is</strong>iting tour<strong>is</strong>ts. The upland area <strong>is</strong> considered valuable for its potential as a walking route<br />
offering extended views across the adjoining low lying <strong>landscape</strong>. The commercially cut bog<br />
<strong>is</strong> also considered valuable as a tour<strong>is</strong>t amenity not least for its potential as a walking route<br />
but also because it <strong>is</strong> an <strong>is</strong>olated and tranquil place. There are plans for development<br />
involving the local community for an extensive nature park in th<strong>is</strong> area.<br />
In terms of natural heritage, the lake in the north of the LCA <strong>is</strong> designated an NHA, Lough<br />
Forbes in the east <strong>is</strong> designated an NHA, SAC and a SPA and an area of bog in the south of<br />
the <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> designated an NHA and an SAC. The River Shannon provides a<br />
valuable amenity for water based activities.<br />
Forces of Change<br />
The bogland in th<strong>is</strong> area has an industrial <strong>character</strong> in parts with a view of Lanesborough in<br />
the d<strong>is</strong>tance, which gives it a strong sense of place. Th<strong>is</strong> <strong>is</strong> at r<strong>is</strong>k from inappropriate built<br />
development and should be protected. The continued use of peat for generating electricity <strong>is</strong><br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 53
unlikely in the future as pressure increases both nationally and internationally for greater use<br />
of renewable energy sources such as wind, biomass and hydroelectric. There <strong>is</strong> potential for<br />
th<strong>is</strong> <strong>landscape</strong> to revert to its original bogland state.<br />
There <strong>is</strong> likely to be an increase in the number of houses built in the area as there have been<br />
a number of houses recently built on Slieve Bawn looking east over the bogland and River<br />
Shannon in the d<strong>is</strong>tance. These can detract from the <strong>landscape</strong> quality. Several houses have<br />
been built along the R371.<br />
Key Recommendations<br />
• The industrial land use of the area <strong>is</strong> an integral part of the <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong> and<br />
the development of wind energy projects would be acceptable from a <strong>landscape</strong><br />
perspective on the ridge of Slieve Bawn. There are ex<strong>is</strong>ting infrastructural services<br />
associated with the powerstation at Lanesborough which could accommodate<br />
national grid connection for future wind turbines. There are also sufficient wind<br />
resources in th<strong>is</strong> area to make it commercially viable. Applications for wind turbines<br />
should be considered with regard to the national planning guidelines for wind farms.<br />
View of the extensive bogland area north of the R63<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 54
<strong>Roscommon</strong> LCA 6: Upper Lough Ree Bogland<br />
Key Character<strong>is</strong>tics<br />
Upper Lough Ree Bogland <strong>character</strong> area<br />
extends from the N63 and Lanesborough<br />
village in the north to the Hind River in the<br />
south. It <strong>is</strong> one of the flattest areas in the<br />
county with the western boundary delineated<br />
by the zone of theoretical v<strong>is</strong>ibility from Lough<br />
Ree. The area <strong>is</strong> predominantly covered in<br />
ra<strong>is</strong>e bog, fens and marginal farmland with<br />
transitional woodland scrub and coniferous<br />
plantation in places. There are no major<br />
settlements in th<strong>is</strong> <strong>character</strong> area and the<br />
road network cons<strong>is</strong>ts of only third class and<br />
smaller roads. As a result th<strong>is</strong> <strong>character</strong> area<br />
<strong>is</strong> very sparsely populated. Vast tracts of the<br />
area come under NHA and SAC designations<br />
and the entire shoreline of Lough Ree <strong>is</strong><br />
designated as an SPA. Although the area <strong>is</strong><br />
not elevated the open <strong>character</strong> of the<br />
bogland <strong>landscape</strong> affords an extended<br />
viewshed towards Lough Ree and it’s <strong>is</strong>lands.<br />
There <strong>is</strong> a designed Scenic Route located on<br />
the R63 heading west from<br />
Lanesborough with the feature of<br />
interest being Lough Ree.<br />
The overall image of th<strong>is</strong> <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> of an <strong>is</strong>olated flat bogland bordering an extensive<br />
lake of high nature value.<br />
Landscape Value<br />
The Upper Lough Ree Bogland <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> of Very High Value because of its nature<br />
designations and the sense of <strong>is</strong>olation. Th<strong>is</strong> <strong>is</strong> a <strong>landscape</strong> of contrasting scales and<br />
variations of enclosure. Views are intimate and enclosed in areas of birch woodland, while<br />
vast expansive views open up close to the shores of Lough Ree.<br />
Forces of Change<br />
The urban edge of Lanesborough <strong>is</strong> gradually extending westwards along the R63. If<br />
development continued in th<strong>is</strong> direction, the quality of the view over Lough Ree would be<br />
severely comprom<strong>is</strong>ed. Given the extensive nature designations, the open <strong>landscape</strong> and<br />
the limited amount of development in the area, including road infrastructure, most types of<br />
built development would have a negative impact on the <strong>character</strong> of the area.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 55
Key Recommendations<br />
• There should be an objective to prohibit development between the designated Scenic<br />
View on the R63 and Lough Ree in recognition of the high value of open views and<br />
sense of <strong>is</strong>olation across th<strong>is</strong> <strong>landscape</strong>.<br />
• Th<strong>is</strong> high quality <strong>landscape</strong> would provide a valuable resource for low-impact passive<br />
tour<strong>is</strong>m, including walking trails and cycling routes. It <strong>is</strong> recommended that a study<br />
investigating the possibility of providing access to the lake shore from such routes be<br />
carried out.<br />
Designated Scenic View from the edge of Lanesborough over Lough Ree in the m<strong>is</strong>t<br />
View of the edge of Lough Ree defined by bright grasses and heathers<br />
View of the floodplain of Lough Ree with shipwrecked trees and rushy edge<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 56
<strong>Roscommon</strong> LCA 7: Mid Lough Ree Pastureland<br />
Key Character<strong>is</strong>tics<br />
The Mid Lough Ree Pastureland <strong>character</strong><br />
area extends from the Hind River in the north<br />
to just north of Hudson's Bay. Its western<br />
boundary <strong>is</strong> formed by the hills to the east of<br />
Lough Funshinagh which drain in an easterly<br />
direction down to the shores of Lough Ree.<br />
The shoreline of Lough Ree <strong>is</strong> defined by<br />
secluded bays dotted with small marinas and<br />
harbours, as well as peninsulas, the most<br />
important of which <strong>is</strong> Warren Point on which<br />
<strong>is</strong> located the medieval site of Rhindoon. The<br />
extensive broadleaved forest of St. John’s<br />
Wood <strong>is</strong> situated on the headland at<br />
Blackbrink Bay. Although the <strong>is</strong>land of<br />
Inchenagh <strong>is</strong> in <strong>County</strong> Longford, it forms part<br />
of the viewshed over Lough Ree. Dry<br />
grassland <strong>is</strong> the predominant land cover as<br />
th<strong>is</strong> area <strong>is</strong> very well drained. There <strong>is</strong> also a<br />
strong stone wall <strong>character</strong> to th<strong>is</strong> <strong>landscape</strong>,<br />
especially in the vicinity of Knockcroghery.<br />
There are also extensive patches of wet<br />
grassland located mostly in the floodplain of<br />
the lake as well as areas of reclaimed bog<br />
running along the centre of a shallow valley<br />
running north. There <strong>is</strong> an esker situated<br />
between the Dublin-Galway railway track and<br />
the road south of the village of Lecarrow. The<br />
entire shoreline of Lough Ree <strong>is</strong> designated<br />
as an NHA, SPA and SAC. The road<br />
network <strong>is</strong> made up of the N61, which<br />
runs diagonally through the area linking<br />
Athlone in the south with <strong>Roscommon</strong><br />
Town in the north. The remaining roads<br />
are mostly third class in status. There<br />
are no major settlements in the area<br />
outside the villages of Knockcroghery<br />
and Lecarrow.<br />
The overall image of the Mid Lough Ree Pastureland <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> one of gently rolling<br />
good quality farmland with extensive views of Lough Ree and its <strong>is</strong>lands in more elevated<br />
places.<br />
Landscape Value<br />
The Mid Lough Ree Pastureland <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> of Very High Value due to it’s nature<br />
designations, good quality farmland <strong>landscape</strong> and extensive lake views as well as built<br />
heritage including windmill, church and graveyard and the canal connecting the village of<br />
Lecarrow and Blackbrink Bay as well as the medieval site at Rhindoon. There are two<br />
designated Scenic Views on tops of hills which provides panoramic views overlooking Lough<br />
Ree, one at Killeenrevagh and the other at L<strong>is</strong>san<strong>is</strong>ky.<br />
Forces of Change<br />
Overall th<strong>is</strong> <strong>is</strong> quite a stable farmland <strong>landscape</strong>. Despite the network of roads and<br />
availability of good quality land the density of built development <strong>is</strong> quite low and housing <strong>is</strong><br />
d<strong>is</strong>persed. However, if th<strong>is</strong> situation were to change and the demand for development was to<br />
significantly increase, the sensitive <strong>landscape</strong>s along the shore of Lough Ree would be<br />
vulnerable and ex<strong>is</strong>ting Scenic Views from elevated locations could be lost.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 57
Key Recommendations<br />
• It should be an objective of the council that development along the shores Lough Ree<br />
should be prohibited in order to protect the v<strong>is</strong>ual amenity and the natural habitats of<br />
the lake.<br />
• In recognition of the high value of open views across th<strong>is</strong> <strong>landscape</strong> it should be an<br />
objective of the council that applications for development on the lake side of Scenic<br />
Views should be accompanied by a V<strong>is</strong>ual Impact Statement.<br />
• The Rhindoon peninsula and associated bays are highly sensitive and applications<br />
for development within th<strong>is</strong> area should also be accompanied by a V<strong>is</strong>ual Impact<br />
Statement recogn<strong>is</strong>ing the high value of th<strong>is</strong> cultural <strong>landscape</strong>.<br />
• There <strong>is</strong> a d<strong>is</strong>tinct sense of elevation on the high hills in the west of th<strong>is</strong> LCA which<br />
could be further enhanced by the kinetic form of wind turbines. Wind speeds in<br />
excess of eight metres per second would make wind energy commercially viable.<br />
Applications for wind farms should be assessed with regard to the national guidelines.<br />
Panoramic view overlooking Lough Ree from Killeenrevagh<br />
D<strong>is</strong>tant view of Lough Ree from high ground at L<strong>is</strong>san<strong>is</strong>ky<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 58
<strong>Roscommon</strong> LCA 8: Lower Lough Ree and Athlone Environs<br />
Key Character<strong>is</strong>tics<br />
The Lower Lough Ree and Athlone Environs<br />
<strong>character</strong> area stretches southwards from<br />
Hudson's Bay to north of the village of<br />
Cornafulla. The western boundary <strong>is</strong><br />
delineated by the zone of v<strong>is</strong>ibility from the<br />
River Shannon. Th<strong>is</strong> low lying area <strong>is</strong><br />
predominantly made up of dry grassland and<br />
ra<strong>is</strong>ed bog, most of which <strong>is</strong> reclaimed, as<br />
well smaller pockets of wet grassland and<br />
wetland. There <strong>is</strong> a large coniferous<br />
plantation just west of Athlone Town. Two<br />
esker ridges run through the area, one<br />
running in a northerly direction towards the<br />
Hudson’s Bay peninsula, the other running in<br />
a westerly direction from just outside of<br />
Athlone Town, part of which <strong>is</strong> currently a<br />
mineral extraction site. The former esker<br />
remains in a very intact form whereas the<br />
latter as been substantially altered due to<br />
encroachment of development. Although th<strong>is</strong><br />
<strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> adjacent to Athlone Town<br />
(in neighbouring Westmeath) the amount of<br />
road infrastructure <strong>is</strong> quite low with the N61<br />
running diagonally northward linking Athlone<br />
with <strong>Roscommon</strong> Town and the N6 heading<br />
southwest towards Ballinasloe in<br />
<strong>County</strong> Galway. The main development<br />
pressure from Athlone spreads<br />
westward along the R362.<br />
The overall image of the Lower Lough Ree and Athlone Environs <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> of a periurban<br />
lakeshore area experiencing increasing development pressure.<br />
Landscape Value<br />
The Lower Lough Ree and Athlone Environs <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> of Very High Value reflecting<br />
the presence of the Shannon river corridor. The public consultation identified an area of<br />
Beech woodland just north of Athlone to be as valuable. Much of the shoreline of the area <strong>is</strong><br />
designated as an NHA, SAC and SPA.<br />
Forces of Change<br />
Development pressure <strong>is</strong> evident along the shores of Lough Ree north and south of Athlone<br />
town along the Shannon Callows, as well as along the small roads leading into the Callows.<br />
Th<strong>is</strong> <strong>is</strong> of concern not least because of the potential negative impact on the ecology of the<br />
flood plain, but also because of the negative impact such development will have on the v<strong>is</strong>ual<br />
amenity on the Shannon river corridor.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 59
Key Recommendations<br />
• It should be an objective of the council that development along the shores Lough Ree<br />
and the River Shannon south of Athlone should be prohibited in order to protect the<br />
v<strong>is</strong>ual amenity and the natural habitats of the water corridor.<br />
The harbour and hotel amenity at Hodson Bay<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 60
<strong>Roscommon</strong> LCA 9: Cloonown and Shannon Callows<br />
Key Character<strong>is</strong>tics<br />
Th<strong>is</strong> <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> located on<br />
the southern tip of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> and <strong>is</strong><br />
the flattest <strong>character</strong> area in the county. It <strong>is</strong><br />
made up of mostly ra<strong>is</strong>ed bog, a lot of which<br />
<strong>is</strong> a mix of reclaimed and cutover bog, as well<br />
as dry grassland along the shoreline with<br />
small patches of wet grassland in places. The<br />
western boundary <strong>is</strong> defined by the location<br />
where the River Suck and River Shannon join<br />
at Shannonbridge and by the only major road<br />
in the area (the R357). There <strong>is</strong> a very loose<br />
network of regional roads leading down into<br />
the Callows (grassland flooded in winter).<br />
Many of the smaller roads leading into the<br />
ra<strong>is</strong>ed bog were built to remain above the<br />
water level in times of flooding, creating a<br />
causeway effect in winter months. In places<br />
an increasing number of dwellings backing<br />
onto the River Shannon <strong>is</strong> evident. Land<br />
along the banks of the River Shannon <strong>is</strong><br />
protected by a number of nature<br />
designations. An esker ridge runs in an east<br />
west direction through Cornaveagh. A<br />
number of Scenic Views provide extended<br />
v<strong>is</strong>tas across the River Shannon into<br />
adjoining counties. One view <strong>is</strong> of a<br />
particularly high esker in <strong>County</strong> Offaly,<br />
at Clonmacno<strong>is</strong>e.<br />
Landscape Value<br />
The Cloonown and Shannon Callows <strong>is</strong> of Very High Value due to its flood plain habitat and<br />
unique ecology. Its flat landform affords extended views from the River Shannon across the<br />
ra<strong>is</strong>ed bogland <strong>landscape</strong>.<br />
Forces of Change<br />
The scenic views along the Shannon waterway are important to protect from poorly sited<br />
dwellings, farm buildings and other types of development. Building development along roads<br />
may also pose a r<strong>is</strong>k to the water quality and associated habitats as flooding can reach right<br />
up to the road side in winter months.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 61
Key Recommendations<br />
• It should be an objective of the council to prohibit further development in low lying<br />
areas of the callows in order to protect the water quality and habitats of th<strong>is</strong> very<br />
sensitive <strong>landscape</strong>.<br />
View of the Shannon callows to the left of the road showing the flood water reaching<br />
into a submerged field on the right<br />
View to the south west across the River Shannon showing an esker ridge in <strong>County</strong><br />
Offaly<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 62
<strong>Roscommon</strong> LCA 10:<br />
Suck River Source and Lough O'Flynn Boglands<br />
Key Character<strong>is</strong>tics<br />
Situated in the north west of the county, the<br />
Suck River Source and Lough O'Flynn<br />
Boglands <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> a low undulating<br />
complex mix of mostly ra<strong>is</strong>ed bog and fens<br />
which drain into the meandering River Suck,<br />
creating a subtle ‘valley’ running in an east<br />
west direction. Lough O’Flynn, the source of<br />
the River Suck, <strong>is</strong> well known for its f<strong>is</strong>hing<br />
and boating amenity. There are a number of<br />
nature designations throughout the area.<br />
There are no major settlements in the area<br />
and apart from the N60 the road network <strong>is</strong><br />
very light compr<strong>is</strong>ing mainly of third class and<br />
other smaller roads. There <strong>is</strong> a Scenic Route<br />
overlooking Lough O’Flynn, as well as Scenic<br />
Views from the lake shore. A ridge of eskers<br />
runs in an east west direction just north of the<br />
River Suck and a quarry <strong>is</strong> located very close<br />
to the south western shore of Lough O’Flynn.<br />
The overall image of the Suck River Source and Lough O'Flynn Boglands <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong><br />
of a sparsely populated wetland bogland <strong>landscape</strong>.<br />
Landscape Value<br />
The Suck River Source and Lough O'Flynn Boglands <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> of High Value due to<br />
its quiet wetland <strong>landscape</strong> offering f<strong>is</strong>hing, boating and walking amenities. The scenic views<br />
around Lough O’Flynn are valued and should be protected from inappropriate development,<br />
especially along its shoreline.<br />
Forces of Change<br />
At present the area <strong>is</strong> very sparsely populated. However there <strong>is</strong> evidence of increasing<br />
development pressure around Lough O’Flynn. As th<strong>is</strong> area has two designated scenic views<br />
(both of which overlook Lough O’Flynn), as well as nature designations, further increased<br />
development could have a negative impact on the v<strong>is</strong>ual and ecological amenity of the<br />
Lakeland.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 63
Key Recommendations<br />
• It should be an objective of the council that applications for development along the<br />
shores Lough O’Flynn should be accompanied by a V<strong>is</strong>ual Impact Statement in<br />
order to protect the v<strong>is</strong>ual amenity of the lake.<br />
• Design should have special regard to rural design guidelines being prepared by the<br />
council. Careful attention should be paid to the use of materials and colour. A natural<br />
stone colour would be preferred. Native tree planting should be used to soften the<br />
impact of ridgelines against the sky in th<strong>is</strong> low lying area.<br />
View across Lough O’Flynn illustrating the impact of brightly coloured and poorly<br />
screened housing in contrast with housing that <strong>is</strong> more natural in colour and<br />
surrounded by trees.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 64
<strong>Roscommon</strong> LCA 11:<br />
Castlerea and Upper Suck Valley<br />
Key Character<strong>is</strong>tics<br />
Situated in the west of the county the eastern<br />
boundary of the Castlerea and Upper Suck<br />
Valley <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> defined by a subtle<br />
ridgeline which gently slopes and drains west<br />
into the Suck River. The area stretches from<br />
Castlerea in the north to Derryhippo River,<br />
just south of the village of Dunamon. The<br />
predominant land cover <strong>is</strong> dry grassland in<br />
elevated places with ra<strong>is</strong>ed and reclaimed<br />
bog in low lying areas. Conifer plantations<br />
occur in pockets in the north and south of the<br />
area. The main settlements are Castlerea<br />
and Ballintober village. While built<br />
development appears to be evenly spread in<br />
the area there <strong>is</strong> increasing ribbon expansion<br />
along the third class road leading into the<br />
villages of Ballintober and Dunamon. The<br />
N60 cuts diagonally through the area linking<br />
Castlerea and <strong>Roscommon</strong> Town.<br />
The overall image of the Castlerea and Upper Suck Valley <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> of a gently<br />
undulating dry grassland farmland with the River Suck winding its way through to create a<br />
subtle river valley.<br />
Landscape Value<br />
The Castlerea and Upper Suck Valley <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> of High Value reflecting its river<br />
corridor <strong>landscape</strong> type and associated ecology and habitats. The Suck Valley Way provides<br />
quiet walking amenities much valued by local people.<br />
Forces of Change<br />
An increase in built development along the River Suck and the Suck Valley Way could<br />
adversely impact on the tranquil amenity which <strong>is</strong> the most significant feature in th<strong>is</strong><br />
<strong>landscape</strong> area, thus undermining the potential economy of walking tour<strong>is</strong>m.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 65
Key Recommendations<br />
• Where applications ar<strong>is</strong>e for development including alternative rural enterpr<strong>is</strong>e<br />
buildings and tour<strong>is</strong>t facilities, regard should be paid to design guidelines to limit the<br />
impact on the <strong>landscape</strong>.<br />
View of Dunamon Castle from a bridge crossing on the River Suck<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 66
<strong>Roscommon</strong> LCA 12:<br />
Athleague and Lower Suck Valley<br />
Key Character<strong>is</strong>tics<br />
The western edge of the Athleague and<br />
Lower Suck Valley <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong><br />
bounded by the River Suck while its<br />
eastern boundary <strong>is</strong> delineated by an<br />
elevated ridge line as far east as Skrine<br />
Hill. It <strong>is</strong> the longest <strong>character</strong> area in the<br />
county extending from the village of<br />
Castlecoote in the north to the N6 in the<br />
south. The land form gently undulates<br />
from the north to south petering into flat<br />
low land where it meets the flood plains of<br />
the Suck Callows east of Ballinasloe in<br />
<strong>County</strong> Galway. Dry grassland dominates<br />
the elevated regions in the north, while<br />
ra<strong>is</strong>ed bog and reclaimed bog, as well as<br />
wet grassland, occur in the lowlands in the<br />
south. There <strong>is</strong> a proposed Scenic View<br />
just south of Castlecoote with extended<br />
views overlooking the Suck River and<br />
farmland valley. There are nature<br />
designations all along the Suck River. The<br />
R357 and R363 are the main regional<br />
roads, and although built development <strong>is</strong><br />
generally evenly spread in the area there<br />
<strong>is</strong> an increase in concentration along these<br />
roads leading into Athleague and the<br />
villages of Ballyforan, Dysert and<br />
Taghmaconnell (north of Ballinasloe).<br />
The overall image of th<strong>is</strong> <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> of a gently undulating dry grassland farmland with<br />
the River Suck winding its way through creating a subtle valley.<br />
Landscape Value<br />
The Athleague and Lower Suck Valley <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> of High Value reflecting its river<br />
corridor <strong>landscape</strong> type with associated ecology and habitat.<br />
Forces of Change<br />
Th<strong>is</strong> <strong>is</strong> generally an area where change has been and <strong>is</strong> likely to be a gentle and gradual<br />
process. Alternative rural enterpr<strong>is</strong>e <strong>is</strong> the most likely trend to emerge in th<strong>is</strong> area.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 67
Key Recommendations<br />
• Where any applications ar<strong>is</strong>e for development they should be assessed against th<strong>is</strong><br />
rural <strong>character</strong> with a view to protecting <strong>landscape</strong> values.<br />
View of Suck River from bridge in village of Athleague<br />
View from the outskirts of Castlecoote overlooking the gentle Suck River Valley<br />
‘La Tene’ stone at Castlestrange<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 68
<strong>Roscommon</strong> LCA 13:<br />
Suck Callows<br />
Key Character<strong>is</strong>tics<br />
The Suck Callows <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> in the<br />
very southwestern tip of the county. Dry<br />
grassland in the north drains southward<br />
into large areas of ra<strong>is</strong>ed bog and<br />
reclaimed ra<strong>is</strong>ed bog and into the southern<br />
boundary of the River Suck. Th<strong>is</strong> southern<br />
boundary becomes a floodplain in the<br />
wetter months known as the Suck<br />
Callows. An esker ridgeline running in an<br />
east west direction forms a border<br />
between the dry grassland and the wetter<br />
areas of ra<strong>is</strong>ed bog. There are very few<br />
roads and no major settlement in the LCA,<br />
however the R357 cuts through diagonally<br />
linking Ballinasloe in <strong>County</strong> Galway with<br />
Shannonbridge in <strong>County</strong> Offaly and it <strong>is</strong><br />
along th<strong>is</strong> route that ribbon development <strong>is</strong><br />
evident. Large tracks of the Callows are<br />
designated as an NHA and SPA.<br />
The overall image of the Suck Callows <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> of a farming and bogland <strong>landscape</strong>,<br />
a significant portion of which <strong>is</strong> flooded in winter months.<br />
Landscape Value<br />
The Value of th<strong>is</strong> LCA <strong>is</strong> High. When flooded in winter the Suck River and adjoining ra<strong>is</strong>ed<br />
bogs become a valuable habitat for wintering birds. Th<strong>is</strong> habitat <strong>is</strong> further supported by the<br />
tranquility of the area because it <strong>is</strong> sparsely populated and there are very few roads.<br />
Forces of Change<br />
An increase in built development in th<strong>is</strong> LCA could have a negative impact on water quality<br />
and the tranquility of the area and therefore undermine the nature designations in place.<br />
There are a number of ex<strong>is</strong>ting small f<strong>is</strong>hing lodges set well away from the shoreline hidden<br />
in hedgerows and trees. These had a very low impact on the <strong>landscape</strong> in contrast with the<br />
type of holiday home generally applied for in more recent times.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 69
Key Recommendation<br />
• It should be an objective of the council to protect the designated areas along the<br />
River Suck and the callows from inappropriate development.<br />
View from elevated ground over the Suck Callows<br />
View of the River Suck close to where it connects to the River Shannon at<br />
Shannonbridge<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 70
<strong>Roscommon</strong> LCA 14:<br />
Arigna Mountains<br />
Key Character<strong>is</strong>tics<br />
Th<strong>is</strong> <strong>is</strong> one of the most elevated <strong>character</strong><br />
areas in <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong>, adjoining<br />
<strong>County</strong> Sligo to the north. The <strong>character</strong> area<br />
compr<strong>is</strong>es rolling ridges sloping steeply to<br />
lower ground at Lough Allen. Land cover<br />
compr<strong>is</strong>es a mix of mountain moorland,<br />
exposed rock, marginal farmland and<br />
coniferous forests. There are scattered and<br />
clustered homesteads on lower elevations<br />
and a wind farm on higher ground. There are<br />
a number of designated Scenic Routes and<br />
Scenic Views in the area, providing an<br />
elevated panorama of rolling farmland down<br />
to Lough Allen. Another elevated panoramic<br />
view takes in extended views of the drumlin<br />
<strong>landscape</strong> further south towards the Kilglass<br />
lakelands. Located on the southern side of<br />
Kilronan Mountain, th<strong>is</strong> view provides an<br />
elevated panoramic v<strong>is</strong>ta to the south west<br />
over Lough Skean and Lough Meelagh.<br />
Ribbon development occurs along the more<br />
elevated regional roads over looking Lough<br />
Allen, particularly between the two mountain<br />
peaks. The mountain moorland crest of<br />
Kilronan <strong>is</strong> designated as NHA.<br />
The image <strong>is</strong> one of a rugged mountain steeped in mining h<strong>is</strong>tory and providing some of the<br />
best views in the county.<br />
Landscape Value<br />
The Arigna Mountains have been classified as of Very High Value because they provide<br />
elevated views to the east over Lough Allen and are popular with tour<strong>is</strong>ts not least for their<br />
rich archaeological heritage and the v<strong>is</strong>itor centre at the d<strong>is</strong>used Arigna Mines. The Miner’s<br />
Way walking route <strong>is</strong> a valuable tour<strong>is</strong>t attraction taking in lower and higher ground, the<br />
Arigna Mines Experience and views of the area.<br />
Forces of Change<br />
Continued ribbon development in the ‘view side’ of the Scenic Routes and Scenic Views, as<br />
l<strong>is</strong>ted above, will undermine the designations and have a negative v<strong>is</strong>ual impact on the<br />
<strong>landscape</strong> and its attractiveness for v<strong>is</strong>itors. Insensitively positioned and brightly coloured<br />
housing development on lower ground <strong>is</strong> very v<strong>is</strong>ible from elevated places and impacts<br />
negatively on the quality of the viewshed.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 71
Key Recommendations<br />
‣ Planning <strong>is</strong>sues such as the capacity of local roads will provide a constraint on<br />
development. However where applications ar<strong>is</strong>e it should be an objective of the council to<br />
influence the design of new buildings to protect the scenic quality of the <strong>landscape</strong><br />
including its h<strong>is</strong>toric industrial<strong>is</strong>ed image. The policy should be to require that new<br />
buildings comply with design guidelines. The <strong>is</strong>sue in th<strong>is</strong> <strong>character</strong> area would be the<br />
views from above. Where developments are not sympathetically integrated into the<br />
countryside, for example the early 20 th century council estate near Derreenavoggy, they<br />
detract from the quality of the view. It should be possible to achieve a more<br />
sympathetically integrated scheme by having regard to the choice of colour and<br />
materials, boundary treatment, site location and soft landscaping.<br />
Extended panorama from the Arigna Mountains to the north east overlooking Lough<br />
Allen and Slieve Anierin<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 72
<strong>Roscommon</strong> LCA 15:<br />
Lough Meelagh Drumlins<br />
Key Character<strong>is</strong>tics<br />
Th<strong>is</strong> undulating drumlin LCA <strong>is</strong> located in<br />
the north of the county and <strong>is</strong> a complex<br />
mix of ra<strong>is</strong>ed bog, wet grassland, under<br />
storey forest and scrub, as well as large<br />
areas of mature forestry. Two large lakes<br />
dominate to the north, Lough Skean and<br />
Lough Meelagh and are connected by the<br />
Feor<strong>is</strong>h River which continues east into<br />
the next LCA to link with the River<br />
Shannon. The R285 runs along the foot<br />
hills of Kilronan Mountain linking the<br />
villages of Keadew in the south with<br />
Ballyfarnon in the north, and an increase<br />
in built development <strong>is</strong> evident on the<br />
approaches to these villages along the<br />
road. The R285 also runs diagonally<br />
linking the villages of Keadew and<br />
Knockvicar in the next LCA in the south.<br />
Ribbon development has not occurred<br />
along th<strong>is</strong> route. Otherw<strong>is</strong>e built<br />
development <strong>is</strong> spread lightly and evenly<br />
across the LCA. A Scenic View overlooks<br />
Lough Derrynasallagh (pictured below)<br />
which has naturally occurring birch<br />
woodland along its shoreline and extended<br />
views to Kilronan in the far d<strong>is</strong>tance.<br />
The image of the Lough Meelagh Drumlins <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> of a gently undulating forested<br />
drumlin lakeland.<br />
Landscape Value<br />
The LCA <strong>is</strong> of Very High Value. Lough Meelagh and Lough Skean and the river Feor<strong>is</strong>h are<br />
valuable for their f<strong>is</strong>hing amenity. The H<strong>is</strong>torical Trail takes in the shoreline of Lough<br />
Meelagh and links up with the Miner’s Way on Kilronan Mountian and attracts v<strong>is</strong>itors to the<br />
area.<br />
Forces of Change<br />
There <strong>is</strong> some mixed broadleaf and conifer forestry in th<strong>is</strong> area. There could be more<br />
demand for forestry here. Also, large areas of forestry may be harvested in the next few<br />
years offering an opportunity to replant with regard to new guidelines adv<strong>is</strong>ing on forestry<br />
design and <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>is</strong>sues 20 . The scenic quality of the <strong>landscape</strong> may attract new tour<strong>is</strong>t<br />
investment, for example a high quality hotel that <strong>is</strong> currently being developed near Lough<br />
Meelagh.<br />
20<br />
Department of Agriculture and Food, Forest Service (2002) Forestry and the Landscape Guidelines<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 73
Key Recommendations<br />
‣ Special consideration should be given to the <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong> of th<strong>is</strong> area when<br />
applications for development, including forestry or tour<strong>is</strong>m, are received.<br />
View to the north west overlooking Lough Derrynasallagh<br />
View to south overlooking Lough Meelagh<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 74
<strong>Roscommon</strong> LCA 16:<br />
Lough Key and Boyle River Network<br />
Key Character<strong>is</strong>tics<br />
Undulating in an easterly direction th<strong>is</strong><br />
drumlin lakeland <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>is</strong> dominated by<br />
Lough Key and a series of other loughs,<br />
including Oakport Lough and Lough Eidin, all<br />
of which are linked by the Boyle River flowing<br />
in an easterly direction to connect to the River<br />
Shannon. The ridgeline of the hills located<br />
just north of Lough Key mark the northern<br />
boundary, while the southern boundary <strong>is</strong><br />
delineated by the N4. The land cover in the<br />
northwest of the LCA <strong>is</strong> predominantly wet<br />
grassland with large areas of understorey<br />
forest, scrub and patches of heath. In<br />
contrast the south eastern half of the LCA <strong>is</strong><br />
made up of dry grassland with large areas of<br />
mature forest and patches of cut over ra<strong>is</strong>ed<br />
bog and reclaimed ra<strong>is</strong>ed bog. There are a<br />
number of designated Scenic Routes and<br />
Scenic Views which overlook Lough Key<br />
Forest Park from elevated vantage points,<br />
taking in its wooded shoreline and <strong>is</strong>lands.<br />
Built development <strong>is</strong> generally sparse in the<br />
LCA, however there <strong>is</strong> evidence of ribbon<br />
development along the R285 around<br />
Knockvicar and the third class roads leading<br />
into Cootehall village and the townland of<br />
Carrigeenree (north of Lough Key). A mineral<br />
extraction site next to Lough Fin, just south of<br />
Knockvicar has been mapped. The shoreline<br />
of Lough Arrow, just inside the county<br />
boundary to the west has been<br />
designated an NHA, SAC and SPA.<br />
Large tracts of Lough Key and the<br />
whole of Lough Eidin, as well as its<br />
adjoining wetlands to the east are<br />
designated as an NHA.<br />
The overall image of th<strong>is</strong> <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>is</strong> one of an extensive organically shaped lakeland<br />
fringed by broadleaf forest.<br />
Landscape Value<br />
The Lough Key and Boyle River Network <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> of Exceptional Value. Lough Key<br />
Forest Park <strong>is</strong> the jewel in the crown for tour<strong>is</strong>m in <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong>, attracting large<br />
numbers of v<strong>is</strong>itors for it water amenities, habitats and surrounding scenic <strong>landscape</strong>. The<br />
H<strong>is</strong>torical Walking Trail passes through the LCA taking in the shore of Lough Key and<br />
connecting with Boyle in the south and the Miners Ways further north in the Arigna<br />
Mountains. Without doubt it <strong>is</strong> one of the most scenic area in <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> and <strong>is</strong> of<br />
national repute.<br />
Forces of Change<br />
Any inappropriate or insensitively positioned development in and around the Lough Key<br />
Forest Park area could have a negative impact on the water amenity and scenic quality of<br />
the area. During the public consultation there was concern that the increase in le<strong>is</strong>ure<br />
activities, specifically high speed pleasure crafts, which are spoiling the tranquil quality of the<br />
lakeland area.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 75
Increased afforestation <strong>is</strong> a possibility. Th<strong>is</strong> presents an opportunity to enhance deciduous<br />
tree planting. Poor management of forests, however, could erode the valuable woodland<br />
<strong>character</strong> of the LCA.<br />
Key Recommendations<br />
‣ Single rural dwellings should be prohibited where they would block views from<br />
designated locations.<br />
‣ Where new applications ar<strong>is</strong>e there should be regard to the ex<strong>is</strong>ting woodland <strong>character</strong><br />
of th<strong>is</strong> local <strong>character</strong> area in accordance with the forestry and <strong>landscape</strong> guidelines<br />
prepared by the Department of Agriculture and Food, Forest Service.<br />
‣ Policies adopted by the Council to protect Scenic Routes and Scenic Views should take<br />
into account the exceptional scenic <strong>character</strong> of th<strong>is</strong> LCA.<br />
View from the R280 to the north east over looking Lough Key Forest Park.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 76
<strong>Roscommon</strong> LCA 17:<br />
Boyle and Curlew Mountains<br />
Key Character<strong>is</strong>tics<br />
Located in the north of the county th<strong>is</strong> LCA <strong>is</strong><br />
dominated by the Curlew Mountains which<br />
slope steeply into the Boyle River corridor.<br />
The Boyle River meanders its way between<br />
the foot hills of the Curlews and the drumlins<br />
to the south. The town of Boyle <strong>is</strong> the main<br />
settlement in the area and all national (N61<br />
and N4) and regional (R361, R294, R295,<br />
R294) roads going through the LCA feed into<br />
the town. Although built development <strong>is</strong><br />
sparse in the upland and river corridor areas,<br />
there <strong>is</strong> significant development pressure<br />
along the roads leading in and around Boyle<br />
Town. The uplands are a complex mix of wet<br />
and dry grassland, upland blanket bog,<br />
reclaimed upland blanket bog, heath and<br />
under storey forest and scrub. The Boyle<br />
River corridor has long stretches of wetland<br />
large portions of which are designated as<br />
NHA. The area <strong>is</strong> predominantly made up of<br />
dry grassland but patches of wet grassland<br />
and reclaimed ra<strong>is</strong>ed bog occur near water<br />
courses.<br />
The overall image of th<strong>is</strong> <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>is</strong> one of a large town nestled in the foothills of wooded<br />
upland.<br />
Landscape Value<br />
The <strong>landscape</strong> value of th<strong>is</strong> LCA <strong>is</strong> Very High. Boyle town <strong>is</strong> known for its fine examples of<br />
built heritage, including Boyle Abbey. Archaeological sites located in the Curlew Mountains<br />
are also valued. There are also views from the old railway track which are considered<br />
valuable by the community.<br />
Forces of Change<br />
Demand for additional housing on the outskirts of the town <strong>is</strong> likely. Ribbon development<br />
creeping westward into the Boyle River corridor could damage the water quality of the<br />
wetland habitats. Insensitively located and brightly coloured housing in the uplands around<br />
Boyle Town will have a negative impact on the v<strong>is</strong>ual quality of the Curlew Mountains.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 77
Key Recommendation<br />
‣ Attention should be paid to ex<strong>is</strong>ting policies that constrain sprawling development<br />
around Boyle Town and encourage a compact form.<br />
View from Curlew Mountains to the south east showing the d<strong>is</strong>persed housing around<br />
Boyle Town<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 78
<strong>Roscommon</strong> LCA 18:<br />
Plains of Boyle<br />
Key Character<strong>is</strong>tics<br />
Although th<strong>is</strong> <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> known as the<br />
Plains of Boyle in fact it undulates to the<br />
south east draining into Cavetown Lough<br />
before petering out into low lands where it<br />
meets a ridgeline of drumlins delineating the<br />
southern boundary of the LCA. In elevated<br />
places, particularly around Cavetown Lough<br />
the land cover <strong>is</strong> predominantly rolling dry<br />
grassland farmland with mature beech, ash<br />
and hawthorn hedgerows. Th<strong>is</strong> extends into<br />
low land areas, where patches of wet<br />
grassland and reclaimed ra<strong>is</strong>ed bog occur.<br />
Small areas of wetland can be found along<br />
water courses. In the very north of the LCA,<br />
just south of the N4 in the Kaeloges townland<br />
a mineral extraction site <strong>is</strong> located in an area<br />
of heath. The road network in the area <strong>is</strong><br />
very light and built development sparse. The<br />
Dublin-Galway railway line passes through<br />
the north eastern corner of the LCA.<br />
The overall image of th<strong>is</strong> LCA <strong>is</strong> one of an elevated plateau providing lake views both to the<br />
north and south.<br />
Landscape Value<br />
Th<strong>is</strong> LCA <strong>is</strong> Moderate Value. The main feature of interest <strong>is</strong> Cavetown Lough and its<br />
adjoining water courses which <strong>is</strong> a relatively unspoilt and scenic.<br />
Forces of Change<br />
Overall th<strong>is</strong> <strong>is</strong> a stable and mature farmland <strong>landscape</strong>. The demand for single rural<br />
dwellings <strong>is</strong> the most pressing <strong>is</strong>sue for th<strong>is</strong> LCA and there <strong>is</strong> evidence of th<strong>is</strong> along the<br />
shoreline of Cavetown Lough and adjoining lakes. Any type of development on the lakeshore<br />
will have a negative impact on the v<strong>is</strong>ual quality of the scenic area.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 79
Key Recommendations<br />
‣ Any applications for development around the shorelines of Cavetown Lake and<br />
adjoining water bodies should be accompanied by a V<strong>is</strong>ual Impact Statement.<br />
‣ Applications for single rural dwellings in th<strong>is</strong> mature rolling farmland should have<br />
special regard to ex<strong>is</strong>ting hedgerow and tree cover. Applicants should plant similar<br />
native species, such as ash, hawthorn and beech trees to sustain the high quality<br />
hedgerow <strong>character</strong> of the area.<br />
View to north overlooking rolling grassland<br />
View to north overlooking Cavetown Lough<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 80
<strong>Roscommon</strong> LCA 19:<br />
Elphin Drumlins<br />
Key Character<strong>is</strong>tics<br />
The Elphin Drumlins <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong><br />
area <strong>is</strong> located in the northern half of <strong>County</strong><br />
<strong>Roscommon</strong>. It <strong>is</strong> positioned to the west of<br />
the Shannon corridor and <strong>is</strong> defined by a low<br />
rounded ridge of high ground to the west,<br />
lakeland drumlins to the southeast and the<br />
Plains of Boyle to the north. As its title<br />
suggests, the overriding <strong>character</strong><strong>is</strong>tic of th<strong>is</strong><br />
LCA <strong>is</strong> the rolling drumlins hills, sometimes<br />
described as a resembling a ‘basket of eggs’.<br />
While the drumlins in th<strong>is</strong> LCA are not as<br />
pronounced as they are in other nearby LCAs<br />
(LCA 3 and LCA 4 for example), there <strong>is</strong><br />
nevertheless a series of low rounded hills<br />
aligned on a northeast southwest ax<strong>is</strong> along<br />
with a number of small lakes. The hills give<br />
way to a low rounded ridge to the west,<br />
providing some d<strong>is</strong>tant views. On th<strong>is</strong> ridge in<br />
a townland known as Windmillpark <strong>is</strong> located<br />
a working windmill, restored by the people of<br />
Elphin. There <strong>is</strong> an interpretative centre at the<br />
windmill which provides a v<strong>is</strong>itor attraction.<br />
The principal drainage pattern in th<strong>is</strong> LCA <strong>is</strong><br />
to the northwest in the direction of the<br />
Shannon corridor. The principle river in th<strong>is</strong><br />
LCA <strong>is</strong> the Killukin River which connects a<br />
number of small lakes including Corbally<br />
Lough. While there are some patches of<br />
ra<strong>is</strong>ed bog especially in the northwest corner<br />
of th<strong>is</strong> LCA, landcover <strong>is</strong> otherw<strong>is</strong>e primarily<br />
dry grassland with some wet grassland found<br />
scattered particularly on low ground between<br />
drumlin hills. Lastly in terms of<br />
landcover, there are patches of<br />
coniferous forest in the northern section<br />
of th<strong>is</strong> LCA. The primary settlement <strong>is</strong><br />
the elevated and exposed town of<br />
Elphin which has a cathedral. Elphin <strong>is</strong><br />
served primarily by the R368 which<br />
connects to the busier N61 located to<br />
the west. There <strong>is</strong> also a small but<br />
picturesque village located in the north<br />
of the LCA at Croghan.<br />
The overall image of th<strong>is</strong> <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> one of edge of drumlin belt compr<strong>is</strong>ing<br />
hills and lakes and terminating by a continuous ridge of drumlins to the south.<br />
Landscape Value<br />
Th<strong>is</strong> LCA <strong>is</strong> of Moderate <strong>landscape</strong> value. Th<strong>is</strong> <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>is</strong> strongly anthropogenic farmland<br />
<strong>landscape</strong> compr<strong>is</strong>ed of small fields and mixed broadleaf hedgerows.<br />
Forces of Change<br />
Currently it appears that the farmland <strong>is</strong> not intensively managed as evidenced by poorly<br />
maintained hedgerows and rush infested pasture. Th<strong>is</strong> trend may change. As alternative<br />
economy in construction declines there maybe new applications for alternative rural<br />
enterpr<strong>is</strong>es such as forestry, bio fuels and small enterpr<strong>is</strong>e buildings.<br />
The trend in th<strong>is</strong> area has been for d<strong>is</strong>persed rural settlement and there <strong>is</strong> a lot of new<br />
housing along the roads around the village of Elphin.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 81
Key Recommendations<br />
‣ Drumlin <strong>landscape</strong>s typically have a reasonably high assimilative capacity for built<br />
development due to the ‘now-you-see-me now-you-don’t’ nature of the rolling<br />
landform and heavy mature hedgerows. Care should be taken, however, to ensure<br />
that views from elevated ground, for example overlooking lakes, are not marred by<br />
intrusive development. Therefore planning dec<strong>is</strong>ions should have regard to design<br />
guidelines currently being prepared by the Council.<br />
‣ Wind speeds of over 8 metres per second on high ground to the west and the<br />
presence of high voltage line in th<strong>is</strong> area may make wind turbine development<br />
commercially viable. Applications for development should have regard to national<br />
guidelines.<br />
‣ Similarly, any applications for forestry should have regard to the forestry and<br />
<strong>landscape</strong> guidelines prepared by the Department of Agriculture and Food, Forest<br />
Service.<br />
The town of Elphin as viewed from the south<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 82
<strong>Roscommon</strong> LCA 20:<br />
Breedoge Bogland Basin<br />
Key Character<strong>is</strong>tics<br />
Th<strong>is</strong> LCA <strong>is</strong> located in the northern region of<br />
<strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong>, defined by the Sligo<br />
county boundary to the north, the general<br />
catchment of the River Breedoge and<br />
landcover pattern. The landform <strong>is</strong> one of a<br />
broad shallow basin draining to the northwest<br />
serving the above mentioned river and<br />
contained by higher ground to the west and<br />
east. The Breedoge River <strong>is</strong> fed in turn by<br />
other smaller rivers including the Mantua<br />
River and the Finasclin River. The Breedoge<br />
feeds the southern extreme of Lough Gara,<br />
providing scenic views from nearby local<br />
roads. Three d<strong>is</strong>tinct shifts of surface<br />
vegetation are readily apparent. In the east of<br />
the LCA, landcover compr<strong>is</strong>es mostly wet and<br />
dry grassland complex with low hedgerows of<br />
hawthorn and willow. There <strong>is</strong> a dramatic shift<br />
to ra<strong>is</strong>ed bog and reclaimed ra<strong>is</strong>ed bog in the<br />
centre of the LCA where birch and willow<br />
woodland occurs along drainage channels.<br />
Th<strong>is</strong> eventually gives way to drier grassland<br />
in the northwestern corner where coniferous<br />
stands and high hedgerows flank local roads.<br />
The areas of bog are very extensive as can<br />
be seen from image below. The LCA <strong>is</strong><br />
served by a series of regional roads<br />
(R361, R370 and R369) linking to the<br />
north-south national road (N61). The<br />
largest settlement in the LCA <strong>is</strong> the<br />
village of Ballinameen, located on dry<br />
and slightly elevated ground to the east.<br />
The overall image <strong>is</strong> one of a broad bogland basin draining into Lough Gara in neighbouring<br />
<strong>County</strong> Sligo.<br />
Landscape Value<br />
Th<strong>is</strong> LCA has been classified as Moderate in terms of <strong>landscape</strong> value. The principle feature<br />
of interest <strong>is</strong> the vast area of bogland in the centre of the LCA, which has intrinsic ecological<br />
qualities and <strong>is</strong> remote. There <strong>is</strong> a designated Scenic View located on the N61 to the east<br />
providing a broadly panoramic and elevated view overlooking th<strong>is</strong> LCA as seen below.<br />
Forces of Change<br />
The principle forces of change in th<strong>is</strong> LCA include afforestation of bogland, encroachment of<br />
rural housing into bogland fringes and overlooking Lough Gara as well as increased<br />
marginal<strong>is</strong>ation of farmland particularly to the east.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 83
Key Recommendations<br />
‣ In an area where bogland predominates the best opportunity <strong>is</strong> for alternative rural<br />
enterpr<strong>is</strong>es. Where applications ar<strong>is</strong>e they should have regard to normal planning<br />
controls with particular attention to design.<br />
Extensive bogland of heather and grasses with d<strong>is</strong>tant coniferous afforestation<br />
Panoramic view at dusk from the N61 heading south (LCA 20 v<strong>is</strong>ible to right of view)<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 84
<strong>Roscommon</strong> LCA 21:<br />
Mullaghnashee Wet Farmland Plateau<br />
Key Character<strong>is</strong>tics<br />
Th<strong>is</strong> LCA <strong>is</strong> located in the northwest of<br />
<strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong>, defined by its relatively<br />
elevated position overlooking wetter areas of<br />
bogland to the northwest. Its landcover<br />
contrasts strongly with the extensive areas of<br />
bog located to the southwest. Landform<br />
compr<strong>is</strong>es a broad elevated and rounded<br />
plateau sweeping gradually to lower ground<br />
to the north in the vicinity of Lough Gara. Th<strong>is</strong><br />
area of ra<strong>is</strong>ed ground climaxes at<br />
Mullaghnashee where elevated and<br />
panoramic views are provided of the<br />
surrounding <strong>landscape</strong>. The largest river in<br />
th<strong>is</strong> LCA <strong>is</strong> the Carricknabraher River which<br />
flows northeast eventually connecting to<br />
Lough Gara. Landcover compr<strong>is</strong>es a complex<br />
of ra<strong>is</strong>ed bogland on higher ground near<br />
Mullaghnashee and otherw<strong>is</strong>e a patchwork of<br />
both wet and dry grassland throughout the<br />
remainder of the LCA. The quality of farmland<br />
improves from the southwest to the northeast,<br />
with the lower lands north of the busy N5<br />
compr<strong>is</strong>ing well drained pasture lands. Aside<br />
from the N5, the LCA <strong>is</strong> served by the R361<br />
and a dense network of local roads. The<br />
principle settlement in the LCA <strong>is</strong> Frenchpark,<br />
a town that appears to be rapidly expanding.<br />
Of cultural heritage interest <strong>is</strong><br />
Frenchpark Demesne located north of<br />
the N5 and the burial place of Douglas<br />
Hyde, first President of Ireland in a<br />
nearby graveyard.<br />
The overall image of th<strong>is</strong> LCA <strong>is</strong> of dry and elevated undulating farmland with pockets of<br />
cultural interest.<br />
Landscape Value<br />
Th<strong>is</strong> LCA <strong>is</strong> of Moderate <strong>landscape</strong> value, much like its neighbouring LCAs to the east and<br />
west. The main features of special value include the elevated views available from the<br />
summit of Mullaghnashee and the cultural heritage interest in the Douglas Hyde burial place<br />
and the adjacent Frenchpark Demesne with its walled estate grounds, parkland <strong>landscape</strong><br />
and folly. The abovementioned Carricknabraher River <strong>is</strong> important from a f<strong>is</strong>heries<br />
perspective.<br />
Forces of Change<br />
The N5 <strong>is</strong> due to be realigned in the medium term, with route selection studies currently<br />
underway. Whichever direction the rev<strong>is</strong>ed route will take, the new road will bring about<br />
significant change in the <strong>character</strong> of the northern end of th<strong>is</strong> LCA. The likelihood <strong>is</strong> for<br />
increased demand for alternative rural enterpr<strong>is</strong>e buildings. The village of Frenchpark <strong>is</strong><br />
currently undergoing rapid expansion and th<strong>is</strong> was ra<strong>is</strong>ed as an <strong>is</strong>sue of concern in the focus<br />
group meetings. Care should be taken that th<strong>is</strong> expansion does not comprom<strong>is</strong>e the heritage<br />
value of the parkland <strong>landscape</strong> of Frenchpark Demesne located to the west of the village.<br />
There <strong>is</strong> a scattering of rural dwellings elsewhere.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 85
Key Recommendations<br />
‣ Applications for new development including residential and alternative rural<br />
development should have regard to design guidelines. In particular policies should<br />
protect the water quality of the Carricknabraher River, the walled estate grounds of<br />
French Park Demesne and the scenic views at Fairymount.<br />
View north from elevated ground at Fairymount<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 86
<strong>Roscommon</strong> LCA Area 22:<br />
Cloona Lough and Lung River Bogland Basin<br />
Key Character<strong>is</strong>tics<br />
Th<strong>is</strong> <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> located in<br />
the northwest of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> and <strong>is</strong><br />
mostly defined by the catchment of the Lung<br />
River which drains in a northeasterly direction<br />
from a cluster of lakes close to the border<br />
with <strong>County</strong> Mayo. The largest of these lakes<br />
<strong>is</strong> Cloonagh Lough, flanked by Clooacolly<br />
Lough to the north, Errit Lough to the south<br />
and Loughglynn further to the east. Th<strong>is</strong><br />
<strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> very low lying<br />
and without spatial relief. The Lung River<br />
slowly meanders its way towards Lough Gara<br />
in the neighbouring <strong>County</strong> Sligo. There <strong>is</strong><br />
almost no sense of a valley created by the<br />
river, instead a broad floodplain or elongated<br />
shallow saucer. Landcover varies in th<strong>is</strong><br />
<strong>character</strong> area, but it <strong>is</strong> v<strong>is</strong>ually dominated in<br />
the west and east by extensive areas of<br />
ra<strong>is</strong>ed bog and reclaimed ra<strong>is</strong>ed bog. The<br />
largest area of bog can be found along the<br />
<strong>Roscommon</strong> Sligo border where the Lung<br />
River connects to Lough Gara. The extensive<br />
plane of bright straw coloured marginal grass<br />
<strong>is</strong> striking. On drier ground can be found a<br />
scattering of green farmland oases<br />
compr<strong>is</strong>ing both wet and dry grasslands. The<br />
N5 cuts through the eastern end of the LCA<br />
and the remainder of the area <strong>is</strong> served<br />
by regional and local roads. The largest<br />
settlement in th<strong>is</strong> LCA <strong>is</strong> Loughglynn,<br />
although there <strong>is</strong> considerable influence<br />
from Ballaghaderreen located on the<br />
northern edge on the N5.<br />
Overall image <strong>is</strong> one of a wide river corridor feeding an extensive bogland.<br />
Landscape Value<br />
The value of th<strong>is</strong> <strong>is</strong> Moderate. The Lung River and associated bogland and wetland corridors<br />
<strong>is</strong> the strongest asset in the area, along with the cluster of lakes found to the west. Th<strong>is</strong><br />
<strong>landscape</strong> <strong>is</strong> of high nature value and the low lying scenery of river and lake <strong>is</strong> also of<br />
considerable interest for passive recreation as well as angling. The areas of bogland<br />
particularly in the east provide a rare opportunity for <strong>is</strong>olation and tranquility as there <strong>is</strong> very<br />
little anthropogenic influence in th<strong>is</strong> area.<br />
Forces of Change<br />
The large settlement of Ballaghaderreen <strong>is</strong> exerting some influence on spread of housing into<br />
the northern fringes of th<strong>is</strong> LCA. There <strong>is</strong> also evidence of development pressure along the<br />
regional roads and in the village of Loughglynn. Otherw<strong>is</strong>e, the western and eastern fringes<br />
are very sparsely populated due to the presence of extensive areas of bogland. There has<br />
been some degree of afforestation in wet areas in the east of the LCA which threaten to<br />
block views of Lough Gara.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 87
Key Recommendations<br />
‣ Normal planning controls should strengthen the structure of Ballaghaderreen and<br />
protect the intrinsic value of the surrounding <strong>landscape</strong> and bogland ecosystem.<br />
‣ The Lung River corridor <strong>is</strong> a d<strong>is</strong>tinctive feature in the <strong>landscape</strong> therefore care should<br />
be exerc<strong>is</strong>ed not to comprom<strong>is</strong>e its quality through inappropriate development. In<br />
particular, there should be an objective to control development within the viewsheds<br />
of bridges which provide elevated views of the river.<br />
Bogland in the eastern edge of the <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong> area<br />
The Lung River slowly winding through low lying farmland near Ballaghaderreen<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 88
<strong>Roscommon</strong> LCA Area 23: Ballaghaderreen and Bockagh Hill Uplands<br />
Key Character<strong>is</strong>tics<br />
Th<strong>is</strong> <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> located in<br />
the northwestern corner of <strong>County</strong><br />
<strong>Roscommon</strong>, defined to the north and west<br />
by the county boundary and to the southeast<br />
by the R293 which defines the northern edge<br />
of planar bogland surrounding the Lung<br />
River. The area <strong>is</strong> punctuated by Bockagh Hill<br />
(227m ASL), a low rounded cone-shaped hill<br />
that provides elevated views over the<br />
surrounding <strong>landscape</strong>. Landcover <strong>is</strong><br />
extremely varied in th<strong>is</strong> <strong>character</strong> area,<br />
compr<strong>is</strong>ing an intimate mix of wet and dry<br />
grassland on lower elevations and ra<strong>is</strong>ed bog<br />
and upland blanket bog at higher elevations.<br />
There has also been some degree of<br />
coniferous afforestation at higher elevations.<br />
The <strong>character</strong> area drains both to the north<br />
and the south, the latter feeding the Lung<br />
River network. In terms of road networks, the<br />
N5 winds its way through a shallow valley<br />
connecting with the east-west R293 and a<br />
dense network of local roads throughout. The<br />
largest settlement in th<strong>is</strong> <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> the<br />
large market town of Ballaghaderreen. There<br />
<strong>is</strong> a wind farm in th<strong>is</strong> <strong>landscape</strong> of medium<br />
spatial extent and some<br />
telecommunication masts near the<br />
summit of the hill.<br />
Overall image <strong>is</strong> one of a marginal upland <strong>landscape</strong> defining the gateway to Mayo and the<br />
wild <strong>landscape</strong> of the west of Ireland.<br />
Landscape Value<br />
Th<strong>is</strong> <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>is</strong> of Moderate value. The elevated Scenic Route from Bockagh Hill of the<br />
<strong>Roscommon</strong> and Mayo <strong>landscape</strong> provides spatial relief from the predominantly low lying<br />
<strong>landscape</strong> of much of the rest of the county. The intimate <strong>landscape</strong>s of small fields and<br />
stone walls to the northwest of the <strong>character</strong> area signal the transition from the midlands to<br />
the west of Ireland.<br />
Forces of Change<br />
The N5 <strong>is</strong> due to be realigned in the short to medium term and th<strong>is</strong> <strong>is</strong> likely to bring about<br />
some change in the <strong>character</strong> of the <strong>landscape</strong>. The high ground at th<strong>is</strong> location might attract<br />
additional telecommunication infrastructure as well as wind farm development. The marginal<br />
quality of the farmland at th<strong>is</strong> location may attract additional applications for afforestation.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 89
Key Recommendations<br />
‣ Care must be exerc<strong>is</strong>ed that elevated and panoramic views from higher ground are<br />
not lost or materially altered and that the value of high nature value bogland <strong>is</strong> not<br />
comprom<strong>is</strong>ed. Any application for development on the down slope from the proposed<br />
Scenic Route should be accompanied by a V<strong>is</strong>ual Impact Statement to demonstrate<br />
that the integrity of the view <strong>is</strong> not adversely affected.<br />
‣ The intimate <strong>character</strong> of the stone wall <strong>landscape</strong> to the northwest of the <strong>character</strong><br />
area should also be considered.<br />
Panoramic view of rolling uplands in the northwest of Character Area 23.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 90
<strong>Roscommon</strong> LCA 24:<br />
Ballinlough Bogland and Esker Ridges<br />
Key Character<strong>is</strong>tics<br />
Th<strong>is</strong> LCA <strong>is</strong> located in the very west of the<br />
county taking in the village of Ballinlough and<br />
the N60 along its northern boundary and<br />
stretches south to the town land of<br />
Garranlahan. The area <strong>is</strong> predominantly low<br />
lying with high hedgerows along roads and<br />
conifer shelter belts around homesteads all<br />
contributing to shallow depth of views across<br />
the <strong>landscape</strong>. Esker ridges running in a<br />
northwest direction <strong>is</strong> the major <strong>landscape</strong><br />
feature and forms part of the southern<br />
boundary of the LCA. Slieve O’Flynn in the<br />
north east and the Clydagh hills in the west<br />
drain into the central lowland areas of ra<strong>is</strong>ed<br />
bog and reclaimed ra<strong>is</strong>ed bog. An area of<br />
ra<strong>is</strong>ed bog along the county border in the<br />
town land of Foxborough <strong>is</strong> designated as an<br />
NHA.<br />
The image of th<strong>is</strong> LCA <strong>is</strong> of low lying esker <strong>landscape</strong> under pressure from development.<br />
Landscape Value<br />
The <strong>landscape</strong> in th<strong>is</strong> area <strong>is</strong> of Moderate Value. Th<strong>is</strong> area was highlighted for its esker<br />
<strong>landscape</strong> which was considered unusual and valuable.<br />
Forces of Change<br />
The main force of change in th<strong>is</strong> <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> the partial removal of eskers for the<br />
development of single rural dwellings and for quarrying purposes. There <strong>is</strong> evidence of<br />
development pressure along the narrow third class road leading into the town of Ballinlough<br />
and the village of Garranlahan.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 91
Key Recommendations<br />
‣ Where eskers are the dominant <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong><strong>is</strong>tic of an area, the partial<br />
removal or quarrying in an insensitive manner will permanently damage the v<strong>is</strong>ual<br />
quality of the <strong>landscape</strong>. The eskers in the south of th<strong>is</strong> <strong>character</strong> area are clustered<br />
and vary height and length. The most southerly of these <strong>is</strong> the most conspicuous due<br />
to its continuous nature and high elevation. Any development of th<strong>is</strong> esker would<br />
have a significant permanent impact on the <strong>character</strong> of the <strong>landscape</strong>. Any<br />
application for development should have special regard to th<strong>is</strong> feature. In accordance<br />
with national guidelines all applications for quarrying of eskers in the area should pay<br />
careful attention to closure plans before work commences.<br />
The gorse covered esker <strong>is</strong> the main <strong>landscape</strong> feature of th<strong>is</strong> LCA and <strong>is</strong> overlooked<br />
from the village of Garranlahan.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 92
<strong>Roscommon</strong> LCA 25:<br />
Cloonfad Hills<br />
Key Character<strong>is</strong>tics<br />
Situated in the very western part of the<br />
county the Cloonfad Hills and Esker Ridges<br />
<strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> relatively ra<strong>is</strong>ed dry ground<br />
in compar<strong>is</strong>on to its neighbouring <strong>character</strong><br />
areas. It <strong>is</strong> made up of generally well<br />
managed dry grassland with low hedgerows<br />
of hawthorn and ash as well as stonewalls.<br />
Small areas of ra<strong>is</strong>ed bog and wet grassland<br />
occur in lower regions. An esker ridge<br />
delineates the northwestern boundary, while<br />
the R327 marks the change in landform and<br />
land cover to the south. Built development <strong>is</strong><br />
quite sparse throughout the area, mostly<br />
occurring along the third class road leading<br />
into Garranlahan, the R327 and a<br />
concentration of dwellings around the village<br />
of Cloonfad. Coolcam Lough in the east of<br />
the area <strong>is</strong> designated an NHA and an SAC,<br />
while an area of lowland in the west at Moigh<br />
Upper <strong>is</strong> an NHA.<br />
The image of the LCA <strong>is</strong> elevated pasture land with stone walls overlooking surrounding<br />
lower regions.<br />
Landscape Value<br />
The Cloonfad Hills <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> of Moderate Value. Marginal<strong>is</strong>ation of farmland has in<br />
places eroded what <strong>is</strong> generally well maintained farmland. In places hedgerows along field<br />
boundaries have fallen into decline. The removal of stone walls to allow for the creation of<br />
sight lines, or where they are replaced by render fin<strong>is</strong>hed walls at the entrance of single rural<br />
dwellings has undermined one of the main <strong>character</strong><strong>is</strong>tics of the area. There <strong>is</strong> limited<br />
capacity for increased traffic from sporadic development on the narrow third class road<br />
leading into the village of Garranlahan.<br />
Forces of Change<br />
There appears to be little recent change in th<strong>is</strong> area. Potential for development of the<br />
economy will depend on alternative rural enterpr<strong>is</strong>e.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 93
Key Recommendations<br />
‣ Any application for development, particularly single rural dwellings, should have<br />
special regard to the ex<strong>is</strong>ting stone walls along boundaries, as well as the capacity of<br />
the road to take increased traffic. Due to the elevated landform of th<strong>is</strong> area, any<br />
applications for development should pay careful attention to the softening of<br />
ridgelines of buildings against the sky through the planting of native species.<br />
Stonewalls and hedgerows have been removed in places eroding the <strong>character</strong> of the<br />
area around the village of Garranlahan.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 94
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 95
<strong>Roscommon</strong> LCA 26:<br />
Cloonfad Bog and Upland<br />
Key Character<strong>is</strong>tics<br />
Situated in the very western tip of the county the<br />
Cloonfad Bog and Upland <strong>character</strong> area r<strong>is</strong>es in<br />
the south east at Slieve Dairt and slopes and<br />
drains to the northwest into lowlands. Coniferous<br />
plantation, understorey forestry and scrub<br />
dominate the uplands in the southeast, providing<br />
scenic walking amenities for local residents. Areas<br />
of ra<strong>is</strong>ed bog, cutover ra<strong>is</strong>ed bog and reclaimed<br />
ra<strong>is</strong>ed bog <strong>character</strong><strong>is</strong>e the land cover in lower<br />
regions. The area south of the village of Cloonfad<br />
<strong>is</strong> very open and has weak deciduous tree and<br />
hedgerow cover, while conifer shelterbelts around<br />
homesteads punctuate the flat region. The LCA <strong>is</strong><br />
sparsely developed, although there <strong>is</strong> development<br />
pressure around Cloonfad village.<br />
The image of the Cloonfad Bog and Upland<br />
<strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> of open low lying wet grassland<br />
complex with elevated forest amenity to the south<br />
east.<br />
Landscape Value<br />
The Cloonfad Bog and Upland <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> of Moderate Value. The walking trails and<br />
views from the forests on Slieve Dairt are a valued amenity to the local people in the<br />
Cloonfad area.<br />
Forces of Change<br />
In lower regions, particularly in areas of reclaimed ra<strong>is</strong>ed bogland there <strong>is</strong> a d<strong>is</strong>tinct lack of<br />
hedgerow planting along field boundaries. There may be a future trend towards development<br />
of rural enterpr<strong>is</strong>es and conifer plantations.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 95
Key Recommendations<br />
‣ All applications for development in th<strong>is</strong> LCA should be viewed as an opportunity to<br />
bring cohesion to an area that <strong>is</strong> structurally weak in deciduous tree and hedgerow<br />
cover, especially in the low lying regions. In accordance with national guidelines any<br />
applications for forestry in low lying areas should pay careful attention to the<br />
treatment of boundaries by planting naturally occurring species such as ash, alder,<br />
birch and willow. Applications for single rural dwellings or rural enterpr<strong>is</strong>e<br />
developments should pay special attention to the treatment of its boundaries and<br />
where ever possible encourage the planting hedgerows of native and naturally<br />
occurring species such as willow, hazel and hawthorn.<br />
View across reclaimed ra<strong>is</strong>ed bog in open low lying area south of the village of<br />
Cloonfad.<br />
View to the northwest from the walking trail at Slieve Dairt looking toward the village<br />
of Cloonfad.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 96
<strong>Roscommon</strong> LCA 27:<br />
Castlerea Ra<strong>is</strong>ed Bogland<br />
Key Character<strong>is</strong>tics<br />
Th<strong>is</strong> LCA <strong>is</strong> one of the smallest LCAs in<br />
the county located towards the northwest<br />
of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> with a very striking<br />
<strong>character</strong>. The Castlerea Ra<strong>is</strong>ed Bogland<br />
<strong>is</strong> predominantly a plateau which drops off<br />
very gradually along the southeastern<br />
edge to a swath of dry grassland providing<br />
a very strong contrast in terms of colour<br />
and texture. There are no major rivers in<br />
th<strong>is</strong> LCA, however an orthogonal drain<br />
runs on an northeast-southwest ax<strong>is</strong><br />
before shifting at right angles to join to the<br />
Owennaforeeshe River. Landcover <strong>is</strong><br />
greatly influenced by the dominance of<br />
bog, compr<strong>is</strong>ing almost exclusively<br />
heather and grass. There <strong>is</strong> very little<br />
afforestation, except perhaps at the outer<br />
fringes to the northeast and southwest.<br />
There are almost no houses in or around<br />
the bogland and the only settlement <strong>is</strong> the<br />
village of Ballangare to the northeast. The<br />
eastern boundary of the LCA <strong>is</strong> defined in<br />
the most part by the N5. Otherw<strong>is</strong>e, the<br />
LCA <strong>is</strong> served by regional road R361 to<br />
the north and a local road to the south.<br />
Th<strong>is</strong> LCA has a very d<strong>is</strong>tinctive image of a remote, <strong>is</strong>olated and tranquil bogland.<br />
Landscape Value<br />
Th<strong>is</strong> <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> of High value due to the extent of bogland, the sense of<br />
remoteness and tranquility and the contrast provided with its broad surrounds. It was<br />
mentioned by a number of attendees at the focus group meetings as a special place to ‘get<br />
away from it all’. The area of bogland in th<strong>is</strong> LCA <strong>is</strong> highly valued for its natural heritage,<br />
designed as an NHA, SPA and cSAC.<br />
Forces of Change<br />
The N5 mentioned above <strong>is</strong> due to be realigned in the medium term, which could potentially<br />
involve shifting the ax<strong>is</strong> of the road inside th<strong>is</strong> LCA. It <strong>is</strong> important that appra<strong>is</strong>al of alternative<br />
routes takes into consideration the special quality of the core bog area as described above.<br />
There currently appears to be a low threat from single rural dwellings in and around the<br />
bogland itself, although some development has taken place towards the west. Any increase<br />
in afforestation would impact on the sense of openness.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 97
Key Recommendations<br />
‣ Th<strong>is</strong> <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong> area would be very vulnerable to change, especially in the<br />
central bogland area. Care should be taken not to permit housing that would erode<br />
the sense of remoteness and special tranquility that currently prevails in the central<br />
bogland.<br />
Panorama of extensive and remote bogland views<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 98
<strong>Roscommon</strong> LCA 28:<br />
Tulsk and Rathcroghan Plateau<br />
Key Character<strong>is</strong>tics<br />
Th<strong>is</strong> LCA <strong>is</strong> located in the centre of the<br />
northern half of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> and<br />
<strong>is</strong> generally higher and drier than the<br />
neighbouring LCAs. The <strong>character</strong> area<br />
r<strong>is</strong>es to the summit of a hill at Rathkineely<br />
(161m ASL), with a slightly lower hill to the<br />
east at Rathcroghan Cross Roads (125m<br />
ASL). Th<strong>is</strong> <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>is</strong> also d<strong>is</strong>tingu<strong>is</strong>hed<br />
from its surrounds due to the v<strong>is</strong>ually<br />
striking concentration of archaeological<br />
monuments located therein compr<strong>is</strong>ing<br />
mounds ringforts, ring barrows, ancient<br />
roads and field systems, megalithic tombs,<br />
souterrains. The principle feature of public<br />
attraction <strong>is</strong> the large mound located on<br />
the west side of the N5 Ballaghaderreen<br />
Road and located approximately in the<br />
centre of the overall archaeological<br />
complex. Th<strong>is</strong> site <strong>is</strong> signposted and has a<br />
small car park and information sign.<br />
Driving or walking through th<strong>is</strong> LCA gives<br />
a strong impression of a very rich heritage,<br />
one that dates from the Early Preh<strong>is</strong>toric<br />
Period right the way through into the Early<br />
Medieval Period (AD400-AD800). It <strong>is</strong> best<br />
known as a major royal settlement (the<br />
seat of the legendary Queen Maeve). It <strong>is</strong><br />
also described as a location of a great<br />
cemetery, an assembly site and an<br />
inauguration site of the Kings of<br />
Connaught. The LCA <strong>is</strong> therefore one of<br />
the most important archaeological and<br />
h<strong>is</strong>torical <strong>landscape</strong>s not just in <strong>County</strong><br />
<strong>Roscommon</strong> but in fact on a national<br />
scale.<br />
The <strong>landscape</strong> here <strong>is</strong> reasonably well<br />
drained, compr<strong>is</strong>ing tightly grazed<br />
grassland with stone walls and low<br />
hedgerows. There are opportunities for<br />
long d<strong>is</strong>tant views, particularly from the<br />
ring fort at Rathcroghan as well as further<br />
west at Toberrory. The N5 passes through<br />
th<strong>is</strong> LCA connecting otherw<strong>is</strong>e to a<br />
network of local roads and farm lanes. The<br />
only settlement in th<strong>is</strong> <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong><br />
the h<strong>is</strong>torical town of Tulsk located in the<br />
east. Th<strong>is</strong> town <strong>is</strong> strategically positioned<br />
on a major crossroads between the east<br />
west N5 and the north-south N61. There <strong>is</strong><br />
a v<strong>is</strong>itor centre there.<br />
The overall image of th<strong>is</strong> LCA <strong>is</strong> of an ancient <strong>landscape</strong> extremely rich in heritage and full of<br />
curious and memorable human-made <strong>landscape</strong> features.<br />
Landscape Value<br />
Th<strong>is</strong> <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>is</strong> of Exceptional value and <strong>is</strong> one of just two <strong>landscape</strong>s in the entire county<br />
which have been classified as such. The rich archaeological heritage to be d<strong>is</strong>covered in th<strong>is</strong><br />
LCA <strong>is</strong> of national significance and th<strong>is</strong> <strong>is</strong> fully appreciated not only by scient<strong>is</strong>ts and<br />
academics but also by the people of <strong>Roscommon</strong>. In the three focus group meetings the<br />
Rathcroghan area was time and time again highlighted as a jewel in the <strong>Roscommon</strong><br />
<strong>landscape</strong>. Rathcroghan <strong>is</strong> one of the four ‘royal sites’ that feature prominently in early Ir<strong>is</strong>h<br />
literature (along with Tara, Navan and Knockaulin) particularly in the epic Cattle Raid of<br />
Cooley, the Táin Bó Cúailgne which was intitiated there.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 99
Forces of Change<br />
The N5 <strong>is</strong> due to be realigned in the medium term and th<strong>is</strong> could bring about the most<br />
significant shift in the <strong>character</strong> of th<strong>is</strong> LCA depending upon its ultimate routing. The ex<strong>is</strong>ting<br />
N5 passes immediately adjacent to several of the monuments that form the Rathcroghan<br />
archaeological complex and detracts considerably from the v<strong>is</strong>itor experience due to the<br />
intrusion of no<strong>is</strong>e and the irritation of constant traffic winding its way through <strong>Roscommon</strong>.<br />
When the traffic <strong>is</strong> diverted away from th<strong>is</strong> road there <strong>is</strong> huge potential to significantly<br />
improve the quality of the experience of Rathcroghan. It <strong>is</strong> therefore essential that future<br />
applications for development along th<strong>is</strong> road takes into account the exceptional heritage<br />
value of th<strong>is</strong> area.<br />
Other forces of change include afforestation particularly on wetter farmland, as well as some<br />
single rural dwellings (although th<strong>is</strong> <strong>is</strong> not as pronounced as in other parts of <strong>Roscommon</strong>).<br />
Key Recommendations<br />
‣ It should be an objective of the Council to give special recognition to the exceptional<br />
heritage value of the Rathcroghan archaeological complex. All applications for<br />
development within the vicinity should require an Impact <strong>Assessment</strong> to ensure the<br />
protection of Rathcroghan.<br />
‣ There are <strong>is</strong>sues of public access within the archaeological complex. It should be an<br />
objective of the Council to fulfill the recommendations of the Conservation Plan for<br />
the Rathcroghan Archaeological Complex and any subsequent reports.<br />
View from the Rathmore mound at Rathcroghan<br />
View overlooking the Carns archaeological site towards Slieve Bawn in the far<br />
d<strong>is</strong>tance<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 100
View of the inauguration site for Kings of Connaught, the main Rathcroghan<br />
archaeological site.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 101
<strong>Roscommon</strong> LCA 29:<br />
Strokestown Drumlin and Turlough Belt<br />
Key Character<strong>is</strong>tics<br />
Th<strong>is</strong> <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> located<br />
in the northern half of <strong>County</strong><br />
<strong>Roscommon</strong>. It <strong>is</strong> a relatively large LCA<br />
and <strong>is</strong> defined by a series of rounded hills<br />
to the east, an area of high ground to the<br />
west at Rathcroghan and otherw<strong>is</strong>e by the<br />
clustering of lakes and turloughs. These<br />
turloughs combine with the rolling drumlin<br />
hills to create the essence of the <strong>character</strong><br />
of th<strong>is</strong> <strong>landscape</strong>. The drumlin hills are<br />
aligned on a northeast to southwest ax<strong>is</strong><br />
and fade out to flatter ground in the<br />
western half of the LCA. The hills<br />
determine the drainage pattern which<br />
flows northeast in the direction of the<br />
Shannon corridor. There are several lakes<br />
and turloughs in th<strong>is</strong> <strong>landscape</strong> and they<br />
combine with the low hills to create a<br />
d<strong>is</strong>tinctive and very strong <strong>character</strong>. The<br />
<strong>landscape</strong> changes throughout the year as<br />
the turloughs fill and empty, creating a<br />
very dramatic seasonal effect. The sight of<br />
hedgerows descending gradually<br />
underwater <strong>is</strong> a curiosity and must draw a<br />
strange look from passers-by not familiar<br />
with the <strong>character</strong> of th<strong>is</strong> most fluid<br />
<strong>landscape</strong>. The pattern of drumlins also<br />
has a major influence on the landcover in<br />
th<strong>is</strong> LCA with higher ground compr<strong>is</strong>ing<br />
mostly well drained dry grassland and<br />
lower ground typically compr<strong>is</strong>ing<br />
reclaimed blanket bog and wetland. Th<strong>is</strong><br />
combination of the bright green hills and<br />
russet dips and valleys <strong>is</strong> striking. The<br />
largest settlement in th<strong>is</strong> LCA <strong>is</strong> the town<br />
of Strokestown. The town was planned<br />
around Strokestown Park House (1720-<br />
1740) and <strong>is</strong> a fine example of an estate<br />
town. It <strong>is</strong> an impressive town not least for<br />
its unusually wide main street and the<br />
axial relationship created between the<br />
grand entrance to Strokestown House in<br />
the east and the elevated church to the<br />
west. Strokestown House <strong>is</strong> currently<br />
undergoing major improvement works and<br />
will be of significant tour<strong>is</strong>t importance<br />
once completed. Of heritage value <strong>is</strong> the<br />
Famine Museum in Strokestown as well as<br />
the birth place of the renowned poet Percy<br />
French at Cloonyquin. The main street<br />
currently serves the N5. The other main<br />
road in th<strong>is</strong> LCA <strong>is</strong> the R61 to the west<br />
along with the regional road R366 which<br />
passes close to the eastern edge of th<strong>is</strong><br />
area.<br />
Overall image of th<strong>is</strong> <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>is</strong> one of a rolling wetland with a strong cultural node at<br />
Strokestown.<br />
Landscape Value<br />
Th<strong>is</strong> <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> of Moderate <strong>landscape</strong> value. The main features of value are planned<br />
settlement of Strokestown with its associated demesne developed in the 18 th century. The<br />
area <strong>is</strong> <strong>character</strong><strong>is</strong>ed by the amount of lakes and turloughs which are v<strong>is</strong>ually significant.<br />
Forces of Change<br />
The N5 <strong>is</strong> due to be realigned between Strokestown and Ballaghadereen and th<strong>is</strong> could bring<br />
about considerable change in th<strong>is</strong> LCA. The ex<strong>is</strong>ting road currently meanders on dry ground<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 102
away from lakes and turloughs and it <strong>is</strong> important that the new road makes the least possible<br />
impact on these special attributes as well as the heritage qualities of Strokestown House and<br />
grounds. Aside from th<strong>is</strong> development, there <strong>is</strong> evidence of single rural dwelling development<br />
throughout th<strong>is</strong> LCA but particularly concentrated on hills overlooking lakes and turloughs.<br />
Recommendations<br />
‣ Although the rolling landform may v<strong>is</strong>ually accommodate built development, the<br />
natural heritage value around the lakes and turloughs should constrain development.<br />
The Council should adopt an objective that recogn<strong>is</strong>es the lakeland nature of th<strong>is</strong><br />
LCA.<br />
‣ It should be an objective of the Council to prepare, as part of the LAP review, a<br />
Design Statement in order to protect the special heritage of Strokestown.<br />
View of the drowned drumlin <strong>landscape</strong><br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 103
<strong>Roscommon</strong> LCA 30:<br />
Oran Undulating Open Farmland<br />
Key Character<strong>is</strong>tics<br />
Th<strong>is</strong> LCA <strong>is</strong> located in the middle of<br />
<strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong>, just west of<br />
<strong>Roscommon</strong> Town. It compr<strong>is</strong>es a shallow<br />
saucer defined by low hills to the west,<br />
north and east. Elevation here <strong>is</strong> low and<br />
the land generally drains in a southerly<br />
direction towards the River Suck.<br />
Landform <strong>is</strong> very gently undulating,<br />
creating subtle hills and hollows, the latter<br />
of which often contains lakes or turloughs.<br />
The <strong>landscape</strong> here <strong>is</strong> remarkably open in<br />
terms of providing long d<strong>is</strong>tant views. Th<strong>is</strong><br />
<strong>is</strong> especially noticeable as one travels<br />
between Ballymoe and <strong>Roscommon</strong> on<br />
the main road in the LCA, the N60. The<br />
scale of <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>is</strong> quite large,<br />
therefore, with open fields of tight low<br />
boundaries. Landcover compr<strong>is</strong>es a<br />
combination of dry grassland throughout<br />
contrasting with significant patches of<br />
reclaimed blanket bog as well as some<br />
ra<strong>is</strong>ed bog in the centre of the LCA. It <strong>is</strong><br />
thus a <strong>landscape</strong> of considerable v<strong>is</strong>ual<br />
contrast. In addition to these two<br />
landcover types, there <strong>is</strong> also some<br />
degree of wet grassland scattered<br />
throughout. The only settlement of any<br />
significance in th<strong>is</strong> LCA <strong>is</strong> Castleplunket in<br />
the north and aside from the N60 which<br />
travels west to east and the N61 which<br />
passes north-south, all other roads are<br />
local in <strong>character</strong>.<br />
The overall image of th<strong>is</strong> <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>is</strong> one of a very open and gently undulating farmland<br />
with occasional turloughs.<br />
Landscape Value<br />
Th<strong>is</strong> <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> of Moderate <strong>landscape</strong> value. There are a number of NHA’s in the<br />
northern part of the LCA, mostly concentrated around the low lying wetlands. There are<br />
some cultural features of interest in the area, including St. Patrick’s Well at Oran.<br />
Forces of Change<br />
In common with many areas of <strong>Roscommon</strong>, there are a considerable number of houses<br />
being built in the countryside in th<strong>is</strong> area. There <strong>is</strong> also evidence of declining quality of<br />
farmland with the onset of rush particularly on wetter ground.<br />
Key Recommendations<br />
‣ Due to the open <strong>character</strong> of the area the <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>is</strong> vulnerable to the negative<br />
v<strong>is</strong>ual impact from built development. It should be an objective of the Council to<br />
assess all development with regard to design guidelines.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 104
Open farmland <strong>landscape</strong> with a large turlough in the centre of the view<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 105
<strong>Roscommon</strong> LCA 31:<br />
Scramoge River Basin<br />
Key Character<strong>is</strong>tics<br />
Th<strong>is</strong> LCA <strong>is</strong> located in the centre of<br />
<strong>Roscommon</strong>, north of <strong>Roscommon</strong> Town.<br />
It <strong>is</strong> defined to the east by the highest<br />
ridge in <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong>, namely<br />
Slieve Bawn which r<strong>is</strong>es to a height of<br />
262m ASL, to the north by a series of<br />
drumlin hills, to the west by a low ridge of<br />
high ground and to the south by landcover<br />
pattern. The centre of th<strong>is</strong> LCA <strong>is</strong> a low<br />
basin serving the Scramoge River which<br />
drains in a northeasterly direction towards<br />
the Kilglass Lakes and onwards to the<br />
Shannon system. The Scramoge River<br />
Basin <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> thus one of the<br />
most varied of all the LCAs in th<strong>is</strong> study<br />
concerning landform. The central area <strong>is</strong> a<br />
flat ra<strong>is</strong>ed bog, surrounded by a series of<br />
reclaimed ra<strong>is</strong>ed bogs. Higher ground <strong>is</strong><br />
dominated by extensive areas of wet<br />
grassland with the ridge of Slieve Bawn<br />
being mostly afforested with coniferous<br />
plantations. Th<strong>is</strong> LCA also provides huge<br />
contrast in terms of landcover, therefore.<br />
There are no settlements in th<strong>is</strong> LCA and<br />
the central bogland area provides an<br />
opportunity for tranquility and <strong>is</strong>olation. In<br />
the northeastern corner of th<strong>is</strong> LCA, the<br />
N5 passes through a gap of low ground<br />
between Slieve Bawn and a ridge running<br />
north to Kilglass. Th<strong>is</strong> pass creates a<br />
gateway experience and <strong>is</strong> readily<br />
appreciable to users of the N5. Aside from<br />
th<strong>is</strong> road, the N61 defines parts of the<br />
western boundary of the LCA and regional<br />
road R368 passes to the north.<br />
The overall image of th<strong>is</strong> LCA <strong>is</strong> one of a low river and bogland basin flanked by an elevated<br />
forest ridge.<br />
Landscape Value<br />
Th<strong>is</strong> LCA <strong>is</strong> of Moderate <strong>landscape</strong> value. There <strong>is</strong> one extensive NHA in the centre of the<br />
area which <strong>is</strong> of ecological and habitat value.<br />
Forces of Change<br />
There have been quite a number of single rural dwellings built in th<strong>is</strong> LCA in the recent past,<br />
likely driven by the proximity to the county town of <strong>Roscommon</strong> just a short d<strong>is</strong>tance to the<br />
south as well as Strokestown to the north. On higher ground, there has been a considerable<br />
amount of coniferous afforestation and th<strong>is</strong> <strong>is</strong> likely to gradually creep downhill as farmers<br />
consider their land use options.<br />
Key Recommendations<br />
‣ The bogland NHA would be vulnerable to any change of any kind. There may also be<br />
potential for wind farm development on the top of Slieve Bawn due to its elevated and<br />
exposed position. Any applications for wind farms in th<strong>is</strong> area should be assessed<br />
with regard to the v<strong>is</strong>ual impact in accordance with the national guidelines.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 106
‣ It should be an objective to direct single rural dwellings to lower ground in farmland<br />
areas where there are mature hedgerows which can ass<strong>is</strong>t in the v<strong>is</strong>ual integration of<br />
such change, away from the edges of ra<strong>is</strong>ed bogland or higher areas of land where<br />
they would be v<strong>is</strong>ually intrusive.<br />
View to south overlooking ra<strong>is</strong>ed bog with areas of coniferous plantation<br />
View to northeast overlooking reclaimed ra<strong>is</strong>ed bog and ra<strong>is</strong>ed bog complex, with<br />
Slieve Bawn in the d<strong>is</strong>tance<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 107
<strong>Roscommon</strong> LCA Area 32: <strong>Roscommon</strong> Town and Hinterland<br />
Key Character<strong>is</strong>tics<br />
<strong>Roscommon</strong> Town <strong>is</strong> the principal town<br />
and <strong>is</strong> centrally located in the very heart of<br />
the county. Outside of the town the<br />
landcover in th<strong>is</strong> area <strong>is</strong> mostly low lying<br />
dry grassland with some areas of<br />
reclaimed ra<strong>is</strong>ed bog and forestry to the<br />
south. The rolling drumlin hills in the north<br />
slope and drain in an easterly direction in<br />
the Hind River which connects to Lough<br />
Ree. Skrine Hill defines the boundary in<br />
the south. <strong>Roscommon</strong> town itself has a<br />
very d<strong>is</strong>tinctive <strong>character</strong> and compr<strong>is</strong>es<br />
many features of important cultural<br />
heritage. These include the remains of<br />
<strong>Roscommon</strong> Castle (on the northwestern<br />
side of the town) as well as the ruined<br />
Friary on the south eastern side of the<br />
town centre. Both of these features have<br />
been preserved and are open to the public<br />
in very pleasant settings. They provide not<br />
only cultural interest but are also of high<br />
amenity value. The castle <strong>is</strong> located in the<br />
context of a large public park, with lake,<br />
tree planting and playground and provides<br />
an excellent backdrop to views of the<br />
Church in the middle ground. Located<br />
close to the park <strong>is</strong> a well known turlough.<br />
There <strong>is</strong> also an important amenity area to<br />
the south of the town at Mote Park,<br />
providing walking routes in a woodland<br />
setting. There <strong>is</strong> a considerable amount of<br />
development currently taking place on the<br />
eastern and northeastern approaches to<br />
the town, involving mostly commercial<br />
buildings. The town <strong>is</strong> very well connected<br />
with a number of regional roads<br />
converging in the town. The Dublin to<br />
Westport railway line also passes through<br />
th<strong>is</strong> LCA.<br />
The overall image for th<strong>is</strong> LCA <strong>is</strong> of a nodal county town of rich cultural heritage located in<br />
the context of fertile farmland.<br />
Landscape Value<br />
<strong>Roscommon</strong> town and hinterland <strong>is</strong> of High <strong>landscape</strong> value. Th<strong>is</strong> reflects the high quality of<br />
cultural heritage features to be found in the town environs as described above. Th<strong>is</strong><br />
classification <strong>is</strong> supported by the views expressed by the attendees at the project focus<br />
group meetings who demonstrated a great sense of pride in their county town.<br />
Forces of Change<br />
<strong>Roscommon</strong> Town <strong>is</strong> expanding. New developments and population growth bring prosperity<br />
and greatly improved services for the residents. However, care must be taken to ensure that<br />
applications for development take into consideration the protection of the built heritage of the<br />
town. Objectives set in the Local Area Plan for <strong>Roscommon</strong> should include the protection<br />
and enhancement of heritage features including those small details that enrich the<br />
streetscape. In the greater hinterland, there <strong>is</strong> a high demand for single rural dwellings on all<br />
approach roads. Th<strong>is</strong> tendency for the urban area to sprawl into the surrounding countryside<br />
should be res<strong>is</strong>ted in accordance with national and regional policy<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 108
Key Recommendations<br />
‣ The Local Area Plan should include objectives to protect and enhance the ex<strong>is</strong>ting<br />
<strong>character</strong> of <strong>Roscommon</strong> Town.<br />
‣ The setting of the town within a rural <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>is</strong> also valuable and should be<br />
protected by a presumption against development outside town boundaries.<br />
‣ Development should only be permitted where it <strong>is</strong> of the highest quality of design and<br />
will not significantly adversely impact on the surrounding <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong>.<br />
‣ Three views from the town are l<strong>is</strong>ted in the current plan and it <strong>is</strong> recommended that a<br />
fourth view from the entrance to the town park overlooking the turlough be l<strong>is</strong>ted.<br />
View of the cathedral from the public park<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 109
<strong>Roscommon</strong> Castle as viewed over the lake in the town park<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 110
<strong>Roscommon</strong> LCA 33:<br />
Key Character<strong>is</strong>tics<br />
Skrine Hill and Limestone Pavement<br />
of the above mentioned peaks.<br />
Situated just south of <strong>Roscommon</strong> Town<br />
in the centre of the county, th<strong>is</strong> upland<br />
LCA <strong>is</strong> defined by its relative elevation<br />
compared to the surrounding lowlands.<br />
The landform <strong>is</strong> generally quite complex<br />
with hills and hollows and steep slopes<br />
particularly to the north. Th<strong>is</strong> LCA <strong>is</strong><br />
known locally for its limestone pavements<br />
v<strong>is</strong>ible in the photograph below. Areas of<br />
exposed flat rock as well as naturally<br />
occurring and hewn rock faces provide<br />
strong v<strong>is</strong>ual contrast with to the otherw<strong>is</strong>e<br />
softness of well drained grassy fields.<br />
Landcover <strong>is</strong> generally very well drained<br />
compr<strong>is</strong>ing predominantly dry grassland,<br />
with very small patches of wet grassland in<br />
places. The land cover <strong>is</strong> a result of the<br />
well drained limestone geology found<br />
throughout. The area <strong>is</strong> sparsely<br />
populated and served only by roads of<br />
local status. In terms of other<br />
development, there <strong>is</strong> a<br />
telecommunication tower located on one<br />
The overall image of the area <strong>is</strong> one of a well drained and complex upland with unusual rock<br />
outcrops and panoramic views.<br />
Landscape Value<br />
The Skrine Hill and Limestone Pavement <strong>is</strong> of High Value reflecting the elevated panoramic<br />
views in the direction of Lough Ree to the east and its unique limestone pavement and rock<br />
faces. A Scenic View located at the crest of Moydow Hill overlooks rolling farmland, Lough<br />
Ree and Rhindoon in the d<strong>is</strong>tance to the east. Although highly regarded at a local level for its<br />
geology and flora, th<strong>is</strong> area currently does not have any official nature designations.<br />
Forces of Change<br />
While th<strong>is</strong> LCA <strong>is</strong> currently sparsely populated, a number of houses have recently been built<br />
in elevated positions which detract from the overall <strong>character</strong> of th<strong>is</strong> otherw<strong>is</strong>e rocky upland.<br />
Scrub <strong>is</strong> encroaching onto poorer areas of farmland which may in turn have an adverse<br />
impact on the ecology of th<strong>is</strong> limestone area.<br />
Key Recommendations<br />
‣ Applications for development within th<strong>is</strong> area should be accompanied by a v<strong>is</strong>ual<br />
impact statement recogn<strong>is</strong>ing the high value of open views across th<strong>is</strong> <strong>landscape</strong>.<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 111
Limestone rock face, well drained grassland and scattered scrub located close to the<br />
top of Skrine Hill<br />
112<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 112
<strong>Roscommon</strong> LCA 34:<br />
Lough Funshinagh, Stone Wall Grasslands<br />
and Esker Ridges<br />
Key Character<strong>is</strong>tics<br />
Th<strong>is</strong> LCA <strong>is</strong> located south of the centre of<br />
<strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> and <strong>is</strong> one of the<br />
largest areas identified in the study. The<br />
landform rolls from north to south and <strong>is</strong><br />
primarily dry grassland farmland. There <strong>is</strong><br />
an area of low lying dry grassland in the<br />
south where eskers run in a northeast to<br />
southwest direction and make a significant<br />
contribution towards the overall <strong>character</strong><br />
and quality of the <strong>landscape</strong>. Lough<br />
Funshinagh <strong>is</strong> the main <strong>landscape</strong> feature<br />
in the north east. Stone walls evolved as<br />
the system of enclosure throughout th<strong>is</strong><br />
area and in places the field sizes are<br />
particularly small contributing significantly<br />
to the <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong> and sense of<br />
place. There are no major settlements in<br />
th<strong>is</strong> area and the roads in the area are<br />
generally third class.<br />
The overall image of th<strong>is</strong> LCA <strong>is</strong> of a rolling stonewalled grassland <strong>landscape</strong> with a<br />
d<strong>is</strong>tinctive esker area to the south.<br />
Landscape Value<br />
Th<strong>is</strong> <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>is</strong> of Moderate Value. There are several locations where views are provided<br />
from local roads overlooking Lough Funshinagh. Lough Funshinagh <strong>is</strong> designated as an NHA<br />
and a cSAC and so <strong>is</strong> not just of aesthetic interest but also of high ecological quality. The<br />
other features of value in th<strong>is</strong> <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong> area are the eskers highlighted in the<br />
description above. They are a poignant reminder of our glacial h<strong>is</strong>tory and in some places<br />
hazel wood cover creates a strong aesthetic and ecological interest.<br />
Forces of Change<br />
The demand for single rural dwellings on the high ground overlooking Lough Funshinagh<br />
availing of the elevated panoramic views. The impact <strong>is</strong> significant and undermines the v<strong>is</strong>ual<br />
quality of the <strong>landscape</strong>.<br />
The houses in the esker belt can sometimes also create an adverse <strong>landscape</strong> impact as<br />
they may require the full or partial removal of the gravelly ridges. Demand for quarried stone<br />
and gravel <strong>is</strong> likely to continue.<br />
Key Recommendations<br />
113<br />
‣ It <strong>is</strong> recommended that applications for single rural dwellings located between<br />
public roads and Lough Funshinagh be accompanied by a V<strong>is</strong>ual Impact<br />
Statement.<br />
‣ It should be an objective of the council to give special recognition to the esker<br />
area in LCA 34 and the inter-related geo-morphological <strong>landscape</strong> of<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 113
archaeological significance.<br />
‣ In assessing planning applications for quarrying the Council will have regard to<br />
the Department of the Environment, Heritage and Local Government Quarries<br />
and ancillary activities Guidelines 2004<br />
View to southwest overlooking Lough Funshinagh from Scenic View No.22<br />
View to east overlooking undulating fields enclosed by stonewalls<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 114
<strong>Roscommon</strong> LCA 35:<br />
Brideswell Esker Belt<br />
Key Character<strong>is</strong>tics<br />
Th<strong>is</strong> <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> located<br />
in the south of the county and has been<br />
defined to the north and south primarily on<br />
the bas<strong>is</strong> of land cover and to the east and<br />
west primarily on the bas<strong>is</strong> of subtle<br />
enclosure by landform. The area <strong>is</strong><br />
predominantly low lying and flat with just a<br />
few low hills located to the west and east.<br />
The flatness of terrain has had a<br />
significant impact on drainage of the LCA,<br />
creating extensive areas of ra<strong>is</strong>ed bog and<br />
reclaimed ra<strong>is</strong>ed bog throughout. The<br />
predominance of bogland tends to<br />
d<strong>is</strong>sipate towards the east of the LCA,<br />
being replaced by dry grassland,<br />
reclaimed ra<strong>is</strong>ed bog and some patches of<br />
wet grassland. In contrast to the planar<br />
bogs, there are a series of ridges located<br />
in the northeastern end of the LCA. These<br />
eskers fan out from the Athlone environs<br />
to the north and west. Land cover in the<br />
northeastern corner <strong>is</strong> complex, combining<br />
a mix of both wet and dry environments.<br />
There are three regional roads which pass<br />
through th<strong>is</strong> LCA and the Dublin to Galway<br />
railway line also passes through th<strong>is</strong> LCA<br />
running in a straight line from east to west.<br />
The overall image of th<strong>is</strong> <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>is</strong> one of bogs and eskers experiencing local<strong>is</strong>ed<br />
development pressure from nearby urban area.<br />
Landscape Value<br />
Th<strong>is</strong> <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>is</strong> of moderate value. There are two areas of NHA and cSAC in the eastern<br />
part and one small NHA in the southwest. Castlesampson esker <strong>is</strong> in th<strong>is</strong> LCA and has been<br />
identified as being of particular value as an NHA for its geological significance (refer to the<br />
d<strong>is</strong>cussion on quarrying in section three of th<strong>is</strong> report).<br />
Forces of Change<br />
There has been considerable quarrying activity in the esker belt of th<strong>is</strong> LCA, adjoining the<br />
boundary of LCA 34. Th<strong>is</strong> has brought about considerable <strong>landscape</strong> change. While the<br />
quarry pits themselves might be screened from public roads, the dust created by vehicles<br />
emerging from the quarry <strong>is</strong> clearly evident and creates an adverse v<strong>is</strong>ual impact.<br />
The proximity of th<strong>is</strong> LCA to the large town of Athlone brings with it pressure for<br />
development, involving both single dwellings as well as commercial buildings.<br />
Key Recommendations<br />
‣ It should be an objective of the council to give special recognition the esker area<br />
in LCA 35 and the inter-related geo-morphological <strong>landscape</strong> of archaeological<br />
significance.<br />
‣ In assessing planning applications for quarrying the Council will have regard to<br />
the Department of the Environment, Heritage and Local Government Quarries<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 115
and ancillary activities Guidelines 2004<br />
‣ It <strong>is</strong> recommended that a study of the eskers in <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> be<br />
undertaken to identify those which are most sensitive to development and to<br />
thereafter priorit<strong>is</strong>e those which warrant protection from development.<br />
View overlooking an esker farmland with scrub<br />
View overlooking an esker farmland which has been cleared and improved<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 116
<strong>Roscommon</strong> LCA 36:<br />
Ballydangan Pastures<br />
Key Character<strong>is</strong>tics<br />
Th<strong>is</strong> <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>character</strong> area <strong>is</strong> located<br />
close to the southern tip of the <strong>County</strong>,<br />
defined on the bas<strong>is</strong> of land cover<br />
compr<strong>is</strong>ing of well drained farmland and<br />
contrasting strongly with surrounding<br />
LCAs which tend to be largely dominated<br />
by extensive areas of bog. Th<strong>is</strong> LCA <strong>is</strong><br />
gently undulating, sloping very slightly<br />
from northwest to southeast in the<br />
direction of the River Shannon. The quality<br />
of farmland here <strong>is</strong> quite good, with just<br />
small patches of wet grassland located in<br />
the southwest alongside reclaimed<br />
bogland. The <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>is</strong> quite open with<br />
loose hedgerows of broadleaf species.<br />
The N4 passes in a southwesterly<br />
direction through th<strong>is</strong> LCA. The status of<br />
roads <strong>is</strong> otherw<strong>is</strong>e local. There are no<br />
large settlements in th<strong>is</strong> LCA with<br />
crossroads settlements and scattered<br />
single rural dwellings located throughout.<br />
Landscape Value<br />
Th<strong>is</strong> <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>is</strong> of Moderate value.<br />
Forces of Change<br />
If demand for new housing continues there are likely to be many applications in th<strong>is</strong> area on<br />
the approach to Athlone Town, in neighbouring <strong>County</strong> Westmeath.<br />
Key Recommendation<br />
‣ Applications for development in th<strong>is</strong> region should comply with all the usual planning<br />
objectives with particular attention to design guidelines.<br />
View to the east along the N6 of the Ballydangan pastures<br />
Landscape Character <strong>Assessment</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> June 2008 Page 117
Appendix 1:<br />
Map of Scenic Routes and Scenic Views
Ref<br />
No.<br />
R1<br />
R2<br />
R3<br />
Scenic<br />
Route/ View<br />
Point<br />
Start of<br />
Scenic Route<br />
End of<br />
Scenic Route<br />
Start of<br />
Scenic Route<br />
Intermittent<br />
views<br />
End of<br />
Scenic Route<br />
Intermittent<br />
views<br />
Start of<br />
Scenic Route<br />
Intermittent<br />
views<br />
Ex<strong>is</strong>ting/<br />
Proposed<br />
Proposed<br />
As above<br />
Proposed<br />
As above<br />
Proposed<br />
Character<br />
Type<br />
River<br />
Corridor<br />
Character<br />
Area<br />
Lough Allen<br />
and Arigna<br />
foothills<br />
Location<br />
Lough Allen<br />
River<br />
Corridor As above As above<br />
Hills &<br />
Uplands<br />
Arigna<br />
Mountains<br />
Kilronan Mt.<br />
Hills &<br />
Uplands As above As above<br />
Drumlin<br />
Lakeland<br />
Lough Key<br />
and Boyle<br />
River<br />
Network<br />
Tinarinnow<br />
Point<br />
Ir<strong>is</strong>h Grid<br />
Reference<br />
(E) 91427<br />
(N) 15357<br />
(E) 93097<br />
Direction<br />
of view<br />
Feature(s) of<br />
interest<br />
Scenic route<br />
along R280 with<br />
views across<br />
Lough Allen and<br />
Slieve Anierin<br />
and views from<br />
R280 up to<br />
Kilronan<br />
Mountain and the<br />
Arigna Mines.<br />
Forces of<br />
change<br />
Poorly managed<br />
hedgerows<br />
comprom<strong>is</strong>ing<br />
views across<br />
lake.<br />
(N) 13091 As above As above As above<br />
Elevated scenic<br />
route along third<br />
class road<br />
overlooking<br />
(E) 91427<br />
Lough Allen and Development on<br />
(N) 15357<br />
Slieve Anierin. view side of road.<br />
Action/ Control<br />
Maintenance of hedgerows<br />
and thinning of trees on lake<br />
side of road.<br />
Planning Control<br />
(E) 93097<br />
(N) 13091 As above As above As above<br />
Elevated scenic<br />
route along third<br />
class road<br />
overlooking<br />
Lough Key, it's Highly sensitive<br />
<strong>is</strong>lands and between roadside<br />
(E) 81805<br />
Lough Key Forest & lake. Stable<br />
(N) 07785<br />
& Activity Park. <strong>landscape</strong> Planning Control<br />
End of<br />
Scenic Route<br />
Intermittent<br />
views<br />
As above<br />
Drumlin<br />
Lakeland As above As above<br />
(E) 82000<br />
(N) 05500 As above As above As above
R4<br />
Start of<br />
Scenic Route<br />
Proposed<br />
Drumlin<br />
Lakeland<br />
Lough Key<br />
and Boyle<br />
River<br />
Network<br />
Kilteasheen<br />
(E) 86300<br />
(N) 06400<br />
Scenic route<br />
along third class<br />
road overlooking<br />
Lough Key, it's<br />
<strong>is</strong>lands and<br />
Lough Key Forest<br />
& Activity Park.<br />
Development on<br />
view side of road.<br />
Planning Control<br />
R5<br />
End of<br />
Scenic Route<br />
Start of<br />
Scenic Route<br />
As above<br />
Proposed<br />
Drumlin<br />
Lakeland As above Smutternagh<br />
River<br />
Corridor<br />
Kilglass<br />
Drumlin<br />
Lakeland's<br />
Carrandoe<br />
(E) 84500<br />
(N) 07200 As above As above As above<br />
Large amenity<br />
area (Marina).<br />
Lough Boderg to<br />
north east. Gently<br />
Undulating.<br />
Conifer & broad<br />
leaf woodland.<br />
(E) 00301<br />
Inlets & wetland Holiday home<br />
(N) 90244 360° habitats.<br />
development. Planning Control<br />
R6<br />
End of<br />
Scenic Route<br />
Start of<br />
Scenic Route<br />
As above<br />
Ex<strong>is</strong>ting<br />
view 4<br />
CDP<br />
Proposed<br />
new route<br />
River<br />
Corridor As above Sheenaun<br />
Drumlin<br />
Lakeland<br />
Kilglass<br />
Drumlin<br />
Lakeland's<br />
Carrownskeheen<br />
End of<br />
Scenic Route<br />
Intermittent<br />
views As above As above As above Glen<br />
(E) 99427<br />
(N) 87925 306° As above As above As above<br />
Elevated<br />
panoramic scenic<br />
route overlooking<br />
Kilglass Lakes.<br />
Quarry spoil<br />
heaps, farmland<br />
field patterns &<br />
low hills in near<br />
d<strong>is</strong>tance.<br />
Kilronan<br />
Mountain and Sensitive to<br />
(E) 98878<br />
Slieve Anierin in development on<br />
(N) 85180 220°-20° far d<strong>is</strong>tance. view side of road. Planning Control<br />
(E) 97873<br />
(N) 82677 230°-45° As above As above As above
R7<br />
R8<br />
Start of<br />
Scenic Route<br />
End of<br />
Scenic Route<br />
Start of<br />
Scenic Route<br />
View No 5<br />
in CDP<br />
As above<br />
Proposed<br />
River<br />
Corridor<br />
River<br />
River<br />
Corridor<br />
Upper Lough<br />
Ree Bogland<br />
Mid Lough<br />
Ree<br />
Pastureland<br />
Ballyclare<br />
Corridor As above Culliaghy<br />
Ballynasaggar<br />
t<br />
(E) 00126<br />
(N) 69491<br />
(E) 99000<br />
Scenic route<br />
along N63 with<br />
views to south<br />
over looking<br />
Lough Ree.<br />
Development on<br />
view side of road.<br />
(N) 69700 As above As above As above<br />
Elevated,<br />
panoramic scenic<br />
route overlooking<br />
Lough Ree and<br />
stonewalled field<br />
patterns. Athlone Highly sensitive<br />
and Rindoon between roadside<br />
(E) 95804<br />
archaeological and lake. Stable<br />
(N) 51486 50°-160° site in d<strong>is</strong>tance. <strong>landscape</strong><br />
Scenic route along N63 with<br />
views to south over looking<br />
Lough Ree.<br />
Planning Control<br />
R9<br />
End of<br />
Scenic Route<br />
Start of<br />
Scenic Route<br />
As above<br />
Proposed<br />
River<br />
Corridor As above As above<br />
Wet<br />
Farmland<br />
Cloonfad<br />
Bog and<br />
Upland<br />
Derrylahan<br />
(E) 95119<br />
(N) 50926 220°-336° As above As above As above<br />
Intermittent views<br />
from road to the<br />
north overlooking<br />
forest plantation Views blocked by<br />
(E) 53543<br />
and stonewalled forestry<br />
(N) 69498<br />
field patterns. plantation Design guidelines for Forestry<br />
V 1<br />
End of<br />
Scenic Route<br />
View Point<br />
As above<br />
Ex<strong>is</strong>ting<br />
View No 1<br />
in CDP<br />
Wet<br />
Farmland As above As above<br />
Hills &<br />
Uplands Arigna Mts Cuiltygower<br />
(E) 53057<br />
(N) 69354 As above As above As above<br />
Elevated view of<br />
Lough Skean and<br />
rolling farmland<br />
and forestry to Abandonment of<br />
the south. farmland.<br />
Tranquil and Development and<br />
(E) 88353<br />
sparsely<br />
farm buildings<br />
(N) 14028 180°-308° populated. blocking views. Planning Control
V2<br />
View Point<br />
Ex<strong>is</strong>ting<br />
View No 2<br />
in CDP<br />
V3 View Point Proposed<br />
V4<br />
View Point<br />
Ex<strong>is</strong>ting<br />
View No 3<br />
in CDP<br />
V5 View Point Proposed<br />
Hills &<br />
Uplands Arigna Mts Arigna<br />
Drumlin<br />
Lakeland<br />
Drumlin<br />
Lakeland<br />
Drumlin<br />
Lakeland<br />
Lough<br />
Meelagh<br />
Drumlins<br />
Lough Key<br />
and Boyle<br />
River<br />
Network<br />
Lough Key<br />
and Boyle<br />
River<br />
Network<br />
Derryclare<br />
Derryvunny<br />
Tinarinnow<br />
Point<br />
(E) 92270<br />
(N) 14187<br />
(E) 84450<br />
(N) 09550<br />
(E) 81805<br />
(N) 07785 140°<br />
(E) 81800<br />
(N) 07200<br />
Elevated<br />
panoramic view<br />
over Lough Allen<br />
and Slieve<br />
Anierin. Long<br />
d<strong>is</strong>tance views of<br />
rolling drumlins<br />
and farmland.<br />
Sheemore Hill<br />
and beyond in far<br />
d<strong>is</strong>tance.<br />
View of<br />
Derrynasallagh<br />
Lough with<br />
naturally<br />
occurring birch<br />
woodland and<br />
heath. Long<br />
mooreland ridge<br />
to north in<br />
d<strong>is</strong>tance.<br />
Elevated,<br />
extended views<br />
over Lough Key<br />
Forest & Activity<br />
Park. Extensive<br />
natural woodland,<br />
inlets & <strong>is</strong>lands.<br />
Castle on <strong>is</strong>lands<br />
in d<strong>is</strong>tance.<br />
Highly sensitive<br />
<strong>landscape</strong>.<br />
Elevated,<br />
extended views<br />
over Lough Key<br />
Forest & Activity<br />
Park. Extensive<br />
natural woodland,<br />
inlets & <strong>is</strong>lands.<br />
Castle on <strong>is</strong>lands<br />
in d<strong>is</strong>tance.<br />
Poor afforestation<br />
on Slieve Anierin.<br />
Clusters of<br />
brightly coloured<br />
houses at<br />
foothills of Arigna<br />
mines.<br />
Large farm<br />
buildings<br />
inappropriately<br />
positioned.<br />
Development on<br />
the view side of<br />
the road.<br />
As above<br />
Planning Control<br />
Planning Control<br />
Planning Control<br />
Proposed scenic car park/<br />
picnic area
Highly sensitive<br />
<strong>landscape</strong>.<br />
V6 View Point Proposed<br />
New<br />
V7 View Point Proposed<br />
V8 View Point Proposed<br />
V9 View Point Proposed<br />
Drumlin<br />
Lakeland<br />
Hills &<br />
Uplands<br />
Drumlin<br />
Lakeland<br />
Drumlin<br />
Lakeland<br />
Lough Key<br />
and Boyle<br />
River<br />
Network<br />
Boyle and<br />
Curlew<br />
Mountains<br />
Upper<br />
Shannon<br />
and<br />
Derreenannagh<br />
Drumlin Belt<br />
Elphin<br />
Drumlins<br />
Drumcormick<br />
Mocmoyne<br />
Cleaheen<br />
Boherroe<br />
(E) 85259<br />
(N) 07126 210°<br />
(E) 79334<br />
(N) 02792<br />
(E) 93912<br />
(N) 01866 180°-360°<br />
(E) 86669<br />
(N) 93700<br />
View to south<br />
west over Lough<br />
Key Forest &<br />
Activity Park and<br />
<strong>is</strong>lands. Intimate<br />
viewshed. Highly<br />
sensitive.<br />
View of rolling<br />
farmland with<br />
some single rural<br />
dwellings and<br />
forest ridgeline in<br />
d<strong>is</strong>tance.<br />
View from Hartly<br />
Bridge to north to<br />
Slieve Anierin,<br />
Lough Eidin to<br />
the south and<br />
windfarm on<br />
Kilronan<br />
Mountain to the<br />
north west. Low<br />
undulating<br />
sparsly populated<br />
<strong>landscape</strong> in the<br />
foreground.<br />
View from third<br />
class road of<br />
undulating<br />
farmland with<br />
mature trees and<br />
light hedgrowes.<br />
Mature woodland<br />
in d<strong>is</strong>tance.<br />
Farm<br />
abandonment.<br />
Development on<br />
the view side of<br />
the road.<br />
Poorly screened<br />
and brightly<br />
coloured single<br />
rural dwellings.<br />
Poorly positioned<br />
single rural<br />
dwellings. Conifer<br />
forestry on ra<strong>is</strong>ed<br />
bog. Abandoned<br />
farmland.<br />
Increased<br />
population/traffic.<br />
Development on<br />
view side of road.<br />
Planning Control<br />
Planning Control<br />
Planning Control<br />
Planning Control
V 10<br />
View Point<br />
Ex<strong>is</strong>ting<br />
View 6 in<br />
CDP<br />
V 11 View Point Proposed<br />
V 12 View Point Proposed<br />
V 13 View Point Proposed<br />
Drumlin<br />
Lakeland<br />
Wet<br />
Farmland<br />
Dry<br />
Farmland<br />
Dry<br />
Farmland<br />
Breedoge<br />
Bogland<br />
Basin<br />
Mullaghnashee<br />
Wet<br />
Farmland<br />
Plateau<br />
Tulsk and<br />
Rathcroghan<br />
Plateau<br />
Tulsk and<br />
Rathcroghan<br />
Plateau<br />
Carrowkeel<br />
Fairymount<br />
Hill<br />
Rathcroghan<br />
Cross Roads<br />
Rathcroghan<br />
Cross Roads<br />
(E) 84008<br />
(N) 91056<br />
(E) 67959<br />
(N) 88207<br />
(E) 79627<br />
(N) 84450<br />
(E) 80000<br />
(N) 83700<br />
Elevated view<br />
from N61 to west<br />
overlooking<br />
undulating<br />
farmland with<br />
mixed forest and<br />
woodland in<br />
d<strong>is</strong>tance. Known<br />
as the Central<br />
Plains.<br />
Elevated<br />
panoramic view<br />
from reservoir of<br />
surrounding<br />
farmland<br />
<strong>landscape</strong>. Long<br />
d<strong>is</strong>tant views to<br />
the north and<br />
Farm<br />
abandonment. 1<br />
off houses on<br />
wrong side of<br />
road.<br />
Planning Control<br />
northwest. Planning Control<br />
View from<br />
Rathmore<br />
archaeological<br />
site. A prominent<br />
ra<strong>is</strong>ed rath<br />
(ringfort) or<br />
chieftain’s Poorly sited and<br />
residence dating poorly screened<br />
from the Early rural enterpr<strong>is</strong>e<br />
Medieval Period. development.<br />
The site, its views Built<br />
and surrounding development<br />
<strong>landscape</strong> encroaching from<br />
context are highly the Tulsk<br />
sensitive. direction. Planning Control<br />
Elevated<br />
panoramic view<br />
from the<br />
inauguration site<br />
for Kings of<br />
Connaught, the<br />
main<br />
Poorly sited and<br />
poorly screened<br />
rural enterpr<strong>is</strong>e<br />
development.<br />
Built<br />
development<br />
encroaching from<br />
Planning Control
V 14 View Point Proposed<br />
V 15 View Point Proposed<br />
V 16 View Point Proposed<br />
V17 View Point Proposed<br />
River<br />
Corridor<br />
River<br />
Corridor<br />
Dry<br />
Farmland<br />
Dry<br />
Farmland<br />
Suck River<br />
Source and<br />
Lough<br />
O'Flynn<br />
Boglands<br />
Suck River<br />
Source and<br />
Lough<br />
O'Flynn<br />
Boglands<br />
Tulsk and<br />
Rathcroghan<br />
Plateau<br />
<strong>Roscommon</strong><br />
Town and<br />
Hinterland<br />
Cloontarsna<br />
Willsborough<br />
Carns<br />
<strong>Roscommon</strong><br />
Town<br />
(E) 58482<br />
(N) 81121<br />
(E) 58656<br />
(N) 78448<br />
(E) 83250<br />
(N) 78258<br />
(E) 87226<br />
(N) 64685<br />
Rathcroghan<br />
archaeological<br />
site. The site, its<br />
views and<br />
surrounding<br />
<strong>landscape</strong><br />
context are highly<br />
sensitive.<br />
View from third<br />
class road across<br />
Lough O'Flynn.<br />
View from<br />
carpark across<br />
Lough O'Flynn.<br />
Flat wetland<br />
habitat. Sparsely<br />
populated.<br />
Elevated<br />
panoramic view<br />
from Carns<br />
archaeological<br />
site overlooking<br />
the surrounding<br />
undulating<br />
stonewalled<br />
farmland<br />
<strong>landscape</strong> with<br />
mature trees and<br />
hedgerows. Long<br />
d<strong>is</strong>tance views of<br />
Slieve Bawn to<br />
the south east.<br />
View of<br />
<strong>Roscommon</strong><br />
Castle and<br />
turlough.<br />
the Tulsk<br />
direction.<br />
Development on<br />
view side of the<br />
road and close to<br />
the shoreline on<br />
the far side of the<br />
lake.<br />
Development on<br />
the far side of the<br />
lake.<br />
Development<br />
encroaching from<br />
the Tulsk<br />
direction.<br />
Encroaching<br />
development.<br />
Planning Control<br />
Planning Control<br />
Planning Control<br />
Planning Control<br />
V18 View Point Proposed<br />
Dry<br />
Farmland<br />
<strong>Roscommon</strong><br />
Town and<br />
<strong>Roscommon</strong><br />
Town<br />
(E) 87684<br />
(N) 63912<br />
View in<br />
<strong>Roscommon</strong><br />
Encroaching<br />
development.<br />
Planning Control
Hinterland<br />
Town<br />
V19 View Point Proposed<br />
Hills &<br />
Uplands<br />
Skrine Hill<br />
and<br />
Limestone<br />
Pavement<br />
Knockmeane<br />
(E) 89194<br />
(N) 57705<br />
Elevated views of<br />
surrounding<br />
stonewall<br />
farmland<br />
<strong>landscape</strong> with<br />
Lough Ree in<br />
d<strong>is</strong>tance.<br />
Poorly located<br />
and poorly<br />
screened single<br />
rural dwellings.<br />
Planning Control<br />
V20 View Point Proposed<br />
V21 View Point Proposed<br />
V22 View Point Proposed<br />
V23 View Point Proposed<br />
V24 View Point Proposed<br />
River<br />
Corridor<br />
River<br />
Corridor<br />
Dry<br />
Farmland<br />
River<br />
Corridor<br />
River<br />
Corridor<br />
Mid Lough<br />
Ree<br />
Pastureland<br />
Athleague<br />
and Lower<br />
Suck Valley<br />
Lough<br />
Funshinagh,<br />
Stone Wall<br />
Grassland<br />
and Esker<br />
Ridges<br />
Cloonown<br />
and<br />
Shannon<br />
Callows<br />
Cloonown<br />
and<br />
Shannon<br />
Callows<br />
Mountplunkett<br />
Creemully<br />
and Aghagad<br />
Beg<br />
L<strong>is</strong>felim,<br />
Inchiroe and<br />
Gortfree<br />
Bunua Cunna<br />
Curraghnaboll<br />
(E) 96404<br />
(N) 56785<br />
(E) 80477<br />
(N) 61889<br />
(E) 94585<br />
(N) 50016<br />
(E) 03444<br />
(N) 34618<br />
(E) 02647<br />
(N) 32317<br />
View over Lough<br />
Ree from crest of<br />
hill along third<br />
class road.<br />
View from R366<br />
overlooking Suck<br />
River and low<br />
undulating<br />
farmland.<br />
View from third<br />
class road<br />
overlooking<br />
Lough<br />
Funshinagh and<br />
mature woodland<br />
on the opposite<br />
side of the lake.<br />
View from third<br />
class road across<br />
the Shannon<br />
callows.<br />
View from third<br />
class road across<br />
the Shannon<br />
callows and<br />
esker ridge in<br />
<strong>County</strong> Offaly.<br />
Holiday home<br />
development.<br />
Development on<br />
the view side of<br />
the road.<br />
Development on<br />
the view side of<br />
the road and<br />
along the<br />
shoreline on the<br />
opposite side of<br />
the lake.<br />
Development on<br />
the view side of<br />
the road.<br />
Development on<br />
the view side of<br />
the road.<br />
Planning Control<br />
Planning Control<br />
Planning Control<br />
Planning Control<br />
Planning Control
V25 View Point Proposed<br />
V26 View Point Proposed<br />
River<br />
Corridor<br />
Dry<br />
Farmland<br />
Suck<br />
Callows<br />
Plains of<br />
Boyle<br />
Sugarloaf Hill<br />
Cloonshaghan<br />
(E) 94779<br />
(N) 25030<br />
(E) 83558<br />
(N) 97161<br />
Elevated view<br />
from third class<br />
road overlooking<br />
the Shannon<br />
callows to the<br />
south/southwest,<br />
with undulating<br />
farmland and<br />
mature trees.<br />
View to<br />
north/northwest<br />
overlooking flat<br />
ra<strong>is</strong>ed cutover<br />
bog. Stable <strong>landscape</strong> Planning Control<br />
View from third<br />
class road across<br />
Cavetown Lough<br />
and wetland<br />
habitat. A stable<br />
farmland<br />
<strong>landscape</strong> with<br />
mature<br />
hedgerows and<br />
trees.<br />
Brightly coloured<br />
and poorly<br />
screened single<br />
rural dwellings<br />
close to lake<br />
shore.<br />
Planning Control
Appendix 2:<br />
Minutes of Stakeholder Consultation Meetings
Community Consultation as part of the <strong>Roscommon</strong> Landscape Character<br />
<strong>Assessment</strong><br />
Focus Group Meetings held on the 7 th , 8 th and 21 st of February 2007<br />
Unless otherw<strong>is</strong>e stated the views and opinions reported below are those of the focus group<br />
attendees and do not reflect the opinions of either <strong>Roscommon</strong> <strong>County</strong> Council or the<br />
consultants.<br />
Three focus group meetings were held in both the Abbey Hotel, <strong>Roscommon</strong> Town and King<br />
House, Boyle as part of the public consultation process for the <strong>Roscommon</strong> Landscape<br />
Character <strong>Assessment</strong>. Two of the meetings compr<strong>is</strong>ed of representatives from community<br />
groups and individual members of the public. The third meeting was made up of<br />
representatives from statutory agencies and other interested interest groups. In total 53<br />
people attended the three events.<br />
The meetings compr<strong>is</strong>ed of a short introduction and a slide show by MosArt and then group<br />
work and d<strong>is</strong>cussion. The attendees were divided into groups of approximately five to six<br />
people and asked to map Landscape Value. D<strong>is</strong>cussion then followed on Forces of Change<br />
in the <strong>landscape</strong> such as one-off housing, wind farms, quarries, forestry and farm buildings.<br />
Attendees had the opportunity to air their views on these types of development and the<br />
impact they might have on the <strong>landscape</strong>s of <strong>Roscommon</strong>. The main points under each<br />
heading are highlighted below.<br />
1. Overall Conclusion of Focus Group Meetings<br />
A summary of the key <strong>is</strong>sues ra<strong>is</strong>ed at each of the focus group meetings under the topics of<br />
Landscape Value, One-off Housing, Wind Farms, Quarries and Forestry are summar<strong>is</strong>ed as<br />
follows:<br />
1. The ecology, water quality, elevated scenic places, tranquil places and<br />
archaeological sites are all very highly valued by the people of <strong>Roscommon</strong>. The<br />
<strong>County</strong>’s strongest assets are it’s quiet tranquil <strong>landscape</strong>s and built heritage and<br />
these should be positively exploited for their tour<strong>is</strong>m potential and for the benefit of<br />
the people of the county.<br />
2. Eskers are valuable and important and are in need of protection from over<br />
quarrying.<br />
3. Bogs are highly regarded, providing valuable opportunities for <strong>is</strong>olation and<br />
tranquillity with tour<strong>is</strong>m potential for walking routes.<br />
4. Turloughs and Callows are considered valuable areas for wintering bird populations<br />
and are therefore sensitive to development. They are also regarded with pride as<br />
part of the defining <strong>character</strong> of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong>.<br />
5. One-off housing <strong>is</strong> generally regarded as acceptable in rural areas if <strong>character</strong><br />
specific design guidelines are introduced and implemented by the <strong>County</strong> Council.<br />
These guidelines should address the architectural vernacular, scale and siting of<br />
development, screening and replanting of native species.<br />
6. Tax incentives that encourage large scale developments in small towns and rural<br />
areas are perceived to have had a negative impact on local communities and the<br />
environment.<br />
7. Wind Farms are widely accepted as a positive development and do not have a<br />
negative v<strong>is</strong>ual impact on the <strong>landscape</strong>. Appropriate siting and design in response<br />
to local <strong>character</strong> <strong>is</strong> important.<br />
8. Afforestation <strong>is</strong> generally not considered a major <strong>is</strong>sue for the people of<br />
<strong>Roscommon</strong>. However, they could provide greater opportunities for amenity and<br />
nature if there was a lesser reliance on coniferous afforestation.<br />
9. More native tree planting <strong>is</strong> needed in the county to encourage biodiversity and<br />
v<strong>is</strong>ually improve rural and urban areas.<br />
10. Poor public access to amenity and archaeological sites <strong>is</strong> perceived to be a major<br />
<strong>is</strong>sue for tour<strong>is</strong>m potential and the people of <strong>Roscommon</strong>.
2. <strong>Assessment</strong> of Landscape Value<br />
When asked to identify the <strong>landscape</strong>s considered most valuable to focus group attendees a<br />
wide variety of areas were identified. Some identified ‘types’ of <strong>landscape</strong>s and others<br />
identified actual areas as being valuable. There was some overlap from group to group when<br />
identifying valued <strong>landscape</strong>s of a large scale. However other smaller scale <strong>landscape</strong>s were<br />
also identified by individual groups. A summary of the comments <strong>is</strong> provided below.<br />
“<strong>Roscommon</strong> <strong>is</strong> a ‘schizo’ <strong>landscape</strong>, flooded in winter<br />
and dry in summer”<br />
2.1 Ecology<br />
• Eskers are considered to be very sensitive and therefore of very high <strong>landscape</strong><br />
value.<br />
• Bogs are valued due to their beauty and <strong>is</strong>olation. Blanket Bogs provide better flora<br />
and fauna diversity than ra<strong>is</strong>ed bogs, whereas it <strong>is</strong> perceived that Cut Bogs have<br />
greater tour<strong>is</strong>m potential. Examples of beautiful wetland and bog areas are to be<br />
found in Castlerea and Ballyhaun<strong>is</strong>. The heath lands and wetlands in the east of the<br />
county are also special.<br />
• The upper Shannon system <strong>is</strong> seen as valuable for its f<strong>is</strong>hing and wetland habitats.<br />
As an example of th<strong>is</strong>, Lough Ree and Lough Allen pollen populations were<br />
highlighted as very important and should be protected. Concern for wildlife along the<br />
Shannon was expressed in connection with recent tax incentives for marinas. The<br />
River Hind was also mentioned as important as a feeder river for Lough Ree and the<br />
Suck Valley <strong>is</strong> regarded as a natural heritage area with great walks.<br />
• There <strong>is</strong> a wetland <strong>landscape</strong> between the areas of Ballygalda, Ballinturly,<br />
Carrowstellan, Carrowkeel and Stonepark near <strong>Roscommon</strong> Town. These areas are<br />
ecologically connected when the water table <strong>is</strong> high and are perceived to be<br />
vulnerable from farm pollution. Furthermore, the cluster of turloughs around the<br />
Castleturlough are very unique.<br />
• Ballinturly SCA was highlighted for the wintering geese and swans (population of<br />
approx 300), which are v<strong>is</strong>ible from the Athleague road.<br />
• Limestone pavement in the Skrine area to the south of <strong>Roscommon</strong> Town <strong>is</strong> unique<br />
and <strong>is</strong> v<strong>is</strong>ually similar to the Burren with similar rare flora. However th<strong>is</strong> area needs to<br />
be designated as it has recently come under development pressure.<br />
• The bluebells growing in the woodlands near Cootehall are spectacular.<br />
2.2 Built Heritage<br />
• <strong>Roscommon</strong> should positively exploit the wealth of built heritage in the county, not<br />
only for the benefit of tour<strong>is</strong>ts but to ra<strong>is</strong>e awareness and sense of pride in the people<br />
of <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> proud.<br />
• The Rathcroghan archaeological monuments are of national importance. However<br />
access <strong>is</strong> very poor and there was a suggestion that the Government should acquire<br />
the land should it become available.<br />
• The medieval site in Tulsk was also highlighted as important and the nearby town of<br />
Elphin <strong>is</strong> of special heritage value as it was once an ancient Cathedral City.<br />
• Boyle <strong>is</strong> special due to its built heritage as <strong>is</strong> Athleague which has lots of parks which<br />
are rich in wildlife and pleasant walks which need further development. Related to<br />
th<strong>is</strong>, the built heritage in and around <strong>Roscommon</strong> Town <strong>is</strong> very special (especially<br />
<strong>Roscommon</strong> Castle); however the more recent commercial development trends in the<br />
town are causing some considerable concern. If the Mart <strong>is</strong> moved out of the market<br />
square it <strong>is</strong> felt that <strong>Roscommon</strong> Town will loose its rural <strong>character</strong>.<br />
• Between Lecarrow and Lough Ree areas there are many examples of intact but<br />
abandoned h<strong>is</strong>torical monuments, mills and canals which are in need of care and<br />
investment. The nearby Rindoon archaeological site <strong>is</strong> highly regarded but again but<br />
the <strong>is</strong>sue of poor access was ra<strong>is</strong>ed.<br />
• Ballintubber Castle <strong>is</strong> important and should be protected and Mote Demesne <strong>is</strong> the<br />
‘Jewel’ of the county providing a very valuable amenity in terms of walking.
2.3 Tour<strong>is</strong>m Potential<br />
• It <strong>is</strong> felt that <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> will never attract big industry so it <strong>is</strong> very important<br />
therefore to positively exploit the built and natural heritage of the county for tour<strong>is</strong>m<br />
potential.<br />
• Lough Key Forest Park and surrounding scenic <strong>landscape</strong> are highly regarded and<br />
the many important views between Lough Key and route through the Curlew<br />
Mountains to Sligo should be protected. The <strong>is</strong>sue of locals having to pay for entry<br />
into the park <strong>is</strong> of some concern and the increase of water sports in the area needs to<br />
be policed better as it <strong>is</strong> impacting on the sense of tranquillity.<br />
• The waterways of <strong>Roscommon</strong> are valuable for their scenic quality (including views<br />
from waterways), habitats, bridges and old structures and <strong>is</strong>lands on Lough Ree were<br />
highlighted for their tour<strong>is</strong>m potential (views to the <strong>is</strong>lands and the archaeology on the<br />
<strong>is</strong>lands). Lough O’ Flynn was mentioned by several attendees for its f<strong>is</strong>hing, scenic<br />
views and woodlands. The Lung River and wetlands are also reputedly great for<br />
f<strong>is</strong>hing. The perceived limited access to Lough Ree needs to be addressed and the<br />
Suck Callows are sensitive and therefore valuable for tour<strong>is</strong>m. Lough Fuinshinagh <strong>is</strong><br />
beautiful but its quality <strong>is</strong> fast being eroded.<br />
• The Dublin/Sligo railway line provides a scenic journey through <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong><br />
and <strong>is</strong> a highly recommended trip (especially in winter). There are good views to the<br />
North from Fairymount near Frenchpark and long d<strong>is</strong>tance views from Slieve Bawn.<br />
The views around the Kilglass area are also highly regarded and there are long<br />
d<strong>is</strong>tance views from Skrine Hill near <strong>Roscommon</strong> Town due to the surrounding low<br />
lying <strong>landscape</strong>. There are also fantastic skyscapes in th<strong>is</strong> area. There was general<br />
agreement that all elevated areas in the county should be protected as they provide<br />
good views (due to the surrounding low <strong>landscape</strong>).<br />
• The Arigna area <strong>is</strong> valuable for its f<strong>is</strong>hing (Lough Allen), walking and megalithic tombs<br />
and its mining heritage <strong>is</strong> important for tour<strong>is</strong>m.<br />
• Forestry around the Cloonfad area has great walking potential and the Suck Valley<br />
Way <strong>is</strong> also important for walking and wildlife. The Mount Talbot forest also has<br />
tour<strong>is</strong>m potential.<br />
• <strong>Roscommon</strong> Town <strong>is</strong> regarded as a heritage town with good Eco-tour<strong>is</strong>m potential, as<br />
<strong>is</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> Town.<br />
• The warrior statue on the Sligo road <strong>is</strong> a strong landmark. There are many<br />
opportunities like th<strong>is</strong> for sculpture around the county, as it draws attention to an area<br />
and gives people a reason for stopping.<br />
• One individual expressed concern that the name <strong>Roscommon</strong> did not do justice to the<br />
county as it made the place sound ‘common’. There was general agreement that<br />
people would have more pride if they used the original Ir<strong>is</strong>h name Ros Comáin,<br />
meaning ‘Coman’s Wood’, as it emphas<strong>is</strong>ed the heritage of St. Coman who founded<br />
a monastery in the 6 th century. Another individual pointed out that when driving from<br />
Longford to Lanesborough there <strong>is</strong> no obvious ‘entrance’ or gateway to <strong>County</strong><br />
<strong>Roscommon</strong>, but instead an ugly industrial <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>is</strong> your first impression.<br />
• The light quality in <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> <strong>is</strong> very special with low light pollution at night<br />
also. The light reflection on lakes and rivers <strong>is</strong> unique. There <strong>is</strong> astrological interest in<br />
the Curlew Mountains area.<br />
• Areas of stonewall <strong>character</strong> are valuable to tour<strong>is</strong>m.<br />
3. Consideration of Forces of Change<br />
3.1 One-off Housing<br />
The <strong>is</strong>sue of one-off housing initiated a lot of debate within and between the groups. At times<br />
the debate brought in wider d<strong>is</strong>cussions about the planning system in general. There was<br />
considerable unease about the impact of larger developments as well as one-off housing in<br />
the <strong>landscape</strong>. Concerns about housing development included the v<strong>is</strong>ual and environmental<br />
impact on the <strong>landscape</strong>, as well as the perceived negative impact that tax incentives are<br />
having on communities and development in <strong>Roscommon</strong> generally.
“Nowadays you can’t build small”<br />
3.1.1 Building in Rural Areas<br />
• It <strong>is</strong> generally felt that people who work on the land should be able to build on their<br />
land and live close to where they work. It was also generally agreed that sons and<br />
daughters building on family land was sustainable, but that there <strong>is</strong> a need to limit the<br />
amount of homes built on family land. Some degree of development in rural places <strong>is</strong><br />
necessary - otherw<strong>is</strong>e these areas will go into decline.<br />
• In general there <strong>is</strong> no difficulty with ‘outsiders’ moving into an area. The problem<br />
tends to be the type of house they want to build. Some types of houses are v<strong>is</strong>ually<br />
inappropriate for the <strong>landscape</strong>. Some attendees felt that there should be no<br />
restriction on building of one-off housing in the countryside, but that strict guidelines<br />
concerning design should be adhered to fully.<br />
• It was felt that many new housing developments are too individual<strong>is</strong>tic in design and<br />
that the traditional way of positioning houses on site was best i.e.: houses nestled into<br />
the <strong>landscape</strong> for shelter, with communities living in clusters. It was agreed by<br />
attendees at all of the focus group meetings that there <strong>is</strong> need for Rural Design<br />
Guidelines similar to those produced by Cork for integrating housing in rural areas.<br />
Th<strong>is</strong> <strong>is</strong> especially important in ‘cultural <strong>landscape</strong>s’.<br />
• The removal of hedgerows for new houses <strong>is</strong> considered to be a big problem. The<br />
groups felt it should be a condition of planning in <strong>County</strong> <strong>Roscommon</strong> that people<br />
replant a certain amount of native species on their site and that a bond type system<br />
should be implemented by <strong>Roscommon</strong> <strong>County</strong> Council. Energy efficient houses<br />
should be encouraged in the planning process, including houses that incorporate<br />
energy generation (like wind turbines). There <strong>is</strong> a perceived potential for developing<br />
sheep’s wool commercially as an insulation product for the building industry.<br />
• Scenic, elevated areas close to urban centres are most at threat from what <strong>is</strong><br />
regarded as inappropriate one off housing development. Housing development<br />
should not be permitted in <strong>is</strong>olated bogs as it can have a negative impact on the<br />
tranquillity, flora and fauna of the area.<br />
3.1.2 Building in Urban Areas<br />
• Large private ‘gated’ schemes are perceived to be destroying small towns such as<br />
Tulsk and Cootehall.<br />
• Strokestown <strong>is</strong> commercially decimated; “you can no longer buy a pair of shoes in the<br />
town”!<br />
• Some individuals felt that new development should be concentrated around villages<br />
and not in rural areas. Attendees felt new developments should be built with local<br />
materials and should be in keeping with the local vernacular architecture.<br />
Furthermore, housing development should not be permitted close to Old Houses or<br />
Castles.<br />
3.1.3 Impact of building on Water Quality<br />
• There was a perception held by some that developments are granted perm<strong>is</strong>sion<br />
without adequate water treatment prov<strong>is</strong>ion. There were also genuine concerns from<br />
f<strong>is</strong>hing groups regarding the negative impact of poorly sited housing development on<br />
or nearby watercourses.<br />
• There was concern about the negative impact of building development along feeder<br />
streams to the Shannon and Lough Ree. Buffer zones restricting development along<br />
rivers are needed.<br />
3.1.4 Tax Incentives Schemes<br />
• The tax incentives in North West <strong>Roscommon</strong> are seen to be perpetuating a culture<br />
of over speculation with houses being bought for investment (buy-to-let) instead of<br />
homes. In some places it appears that it <strong>is</strong> easier to get planning perm<strong>is</strong>sion for ten<br />
houses rather that one.<br />
• Tax incentives in the Shannon Callows South of Athlone <strong>is</strong> a concern as it <strong>is</strong><br />
considered a sensitive area (wintering birds were mentioned).
3.2 Wind Farms<br />
“A tree makes more no<strong>is</strong>e than a wind turbine”<br />
“Turn off the oil!”<br />
• There <strong>is</strong> generally a favourable impression of wind farms in the <strong>Roscommon</strong><br />
<strong>landscape</strong>. Most focus group attendees commented on how ‘beautiful’ and ‘elegant’<br />
wind turbines appear and that in some areas wind farms have become features in the<br />
<strong>landscape</strong>. To some wind farms look exciting and are a sign of progress and that the<br />
appearance of wind farms doesn’t matter as they are necessary. It <strong>is</strong> good to see<br />
power being generated locally wind energy projects are considered as ‘power without<br />
pollution’.<br />
• It <strong>is</strong> felt that wind farms are not harmful to tour<strong>is</strong>m and that they are most suited to<br />
large scale <strong>landscape</strong>s with rolling hills (even in scenic <strong>landscape</strong>s) as they do not<br />
dominate in such locations. However they are not suitable in enclosed type<br />
<strong>landscape</strong>s or near archaeological sites. Landscape sale <strong>is</strong> therefore very important<br />
when siting a wind farm.<br />
• Others expressed strong d<strong>is</strong>like to wind farms, some expressing concerns about the<br />
colour of the wind turbines. It was commented that wind farms may ‘look’ clean, but<br />
the subsequent underground cables and access roads are often overlooked. Some<br />
people say that light flicker <strong>is</strong> an <strong>is</strong>sue for those who live beneath wind turbines and<br />
the power lines (and their location) required to connect to the national grid can be a<br />
problem.<br />
• From a f<strong>is</strong>heries point of view there are some concerns regarding the construction of<br />
wind turbines. Runoff on elevated sites can be destabil<strong>is</strong>ing and may pose a r<strong>is</strong>k to<br />
nearby rivers and lakes. The landslide (and subsequent f<strong>is</strong>h kill) at Derrybrien in<br />
Mayo was quoted as an example.<br />
3.3 Quarries<br />
“Eskers were the highways of the past; perhaps they will<br />
also be the highways of the future…”<br />
• Great care should be exerc<strong>is</strong>ed that the esker <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>is</strong> not “flattened”, which <strong>is</strong><br />
what reportedly happened in Kiltimagh, <strong>County</strong> Mayo. It was considered that deep<br />
excavation quarries are preferable to the quarrying of eskers because they can be<br />
filled-in afterwards. The quarrying of eskers <strong>is</strong> regarded as undesirable as it results in<br />
the removal of an entire micro <strong>landscape</strong>. An alternative to the removal (quarrying) of<br />
sand and gravel from eskers was proposed, namely stone crushing. An argument<br />
was put forward that quarrying of eskers <strong>is</strong> therefore unnecessary.<br />
• There was a lot of concern regarding the reopening of old quarries, including those<br />
for extracting valuable limestone. Development of quarries can lead to heavy duty<br />
trucks driving through scenic areas. No<strong>is</strong>e and dust are also a concern.<br />
• There were fears regarding retrospective granting of d<strong>is</strong>charge licences to pre 1964 1<br />
quarries in relation to potential limited capacity of some watercourses to adequately<br />
dilute the d<strong>is</strong>charge.<br />
• At present some eskers and turloughs are protected under the National Monuments<br />
Acts as they form part of old roads and pathways. However according to one<br />
attendee, the DoEHLG are considering removing old roads and pathways from the<br />
Record of Monuments and Places which will leave these <strong>landscape</strong>s open to<br />
development.<br />
1 Section 261 of the 2000 Planning and Development Act requires reg<strong>is</strong>tration of quarries and at th<strong>is</strong> stage a quarry<br />
could be reg<strong>is</strong>tered and conditions imposed for pre-1964 quarries
• The groups expressed caution generally in relation to quarries, but also recogn<strong>is</strong>ed<br />
the pragmatic need to quarry for building materials. On a positive note, there was a<br />
suggestion that d<strong>is</strong>used deep extraction quarries are a potential bird and flora habitat<br />
sites and could be developed as such. There was also a proposal that used hardcore<br />
and rubble from building sites should be returned to quarries for recycling.<br />
3.4 Forestry<br />
“Forestry <strong>is</strong> necessary because some land<br />
<strong>is</strong> not much good for anything else”<br />
• The groups did not express any major concerns in relation to forestry in <strong>County</strong><br />
<strong>Roscommon</strong>. They did, however, feel that there was a need for more planting of<br />
native species and tree planting in general in urban areas. Turloughs and other<br />
nature areas should not be afforested and it <strong>is</strong> also important that scenic views are<br />
not blocked by afforestation.<br />
• The perceived poor quality of coniferous plantations <strong>is</strong> an <strong>is</strong>sue as it <strong>is</strong> felt that they<br />
are too dense. There was a suggestion that if the trees were spaced to allow light to<br />
reach the forest floor that these forests would support more plant life and increase<br />
biodiversity. It was proposed that measures be taken to better manage clear felling as<br />
the result <strong>is</strong> regarded as unsightly on the <strong>landscape</strong>. There was general concern<br />
regarding the dominance of coniferous plantations in <strong>Roscommon</strong>.<br />
• A tree culture needs to be fostered in the county and there <strong>is</strong> a need for more native<br />
tree planting generally. The mature broadleaf trees that ex<strong>is</strong>t today around old<br />
demesnes where originally planted as a result of a grant scheme. Similar grant<br />
schemes would encourage planting of broad leaf trees and ensure continuity of<br />
parkland <strong>landscape</strong>s. Hedgerows are being lost to development and hedgerow<br />
planting would help to increase biodiversity. It <strong>is</strong> felt that more Tree Preservation<br />
Orders need to be put in place to protect ex<strong>is</strong>ting trees.<br />
• The county should be maintained as a GM Free zone when it comes to forestry and<br />
bio-energy crops.<br />
3.5 Other Issues Ra<strong>is</strong>ed<br />
At each meeting other <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>is</strong>sues were ra<strong>is</strong>ed by attendees that did not form part of<br />
the agenda as set out by the Consultants.<br />
“The three <strong>landscape</strong> <strong>is</strong>sues are:<br />
Access, Access and Access!”<br />
Access<br />
• Access for boat users along rivers in areas of low population <strong>is</strong> reportedly poor, with<br />
few services available. There <strong>is</strong> a need to balance the quiet and peaceful nature of<br />
these places on one hand, but also the prov<strong>is</strong>ion of services in these places <strong>is</strong><br />
important<br />
• Access for tour<strong>is</strong>ts to archaeological <strong>landscape</strong>s (Rathcroghan, Rindoon) <strong>is</strong> very<br />
poor. Also, old roads and pathways are inaccessible. The litigation concerns of<br />
farmers are preventing tour<strong>is</strong>m opportunities.<br />
• Farmers who availed of grants to develop and maintain walking routes on their land<br />
are now caught in a situation where they now find it difficult to get planning<br />
perm<strong>is</strong>sion for housing development on these routes as a right of way has been<br />
establ<strong>is</strong>hed.<br />
• When the <strong>County</strong> Council indemnified the Suck Valley Way access to the area was<br />
improved. Other important areas such as Rathcroghan archaeological sites should<br />
also be indemnified to improve access.
Built Heritage<br />
• Stone walls are generally considered valuable to tour<strong>is</strong>m and provide <strong>character</strong> to an<br />
area.<br />
• Tour<strong>is</strong>m tends to focus on large developments like Strokestown House. However,<br />
<strong>Roscommon</strong> should focus on developing smaller attractions and sites as there are<br />
many examples in the county and these could provide a unique tour<strong>is</strong>t experience.<br />
Land Drainage<br />
• Drainage works in the area North of Athlone <strong>is</strong> a concern due to the impact it could<br />
have on flooding of the Shannon in the area