Download - RPDP
Download - RPDP
Download - RPDP
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
Shop TALK<br />
Vol. 4 No. 3<br />
Getting Students to Think Scientifically:<br />
Concept Mapping and Interactive Notebooks<br />
Enhancing Student<br />
Learning Through<br />
Assessment<br />
The Self - Assessment Process<br />
Summer Professional Development Offerings
Vol. 4 No. 3<br />
Shop TALK<br />
• Listen and Learn<br />
• Administrator Highlights<br />
Contents<br />
• Meeting the Challenges of Improving Student<br />
Achievement in Rural Schools<br />
• Age of InfoWhelm<br />
• Rural Technology Use<br />
• Teacher Highlights - Technology/Elementary Literacy<br />
• Enhancing Student Learning<br />
• The Self-Assessment Process<br />
• Teacher Highlights - Secondary Literacy/Elementary<br />
Math<br />
• More Than Just Multiple Choice!<br />
• Teacher Highlights - Secondary Math<br />
• Technology’s Influence on Formative Assessment<br />
• Teacher Highlights - Secondary Science/ Elementary<br />
Science<br />
• Formative Assessment in Elementary Science<br />
• Getting Students to Think Scientifically: Concept<br />
Mapping and Interactive Notebooks<br />
Cover Photo Credit: Jeff Bostic<br />
<strong>RPDP</strong> Staff<br />
Director<br />
Bill Hanlon<br />
Staff<br />
Ahern, Cindy<br />
Chalmers, Inga<br />
Costantino, Stephanie<br />
Finney, Ruby<br />
Leon, Maria<br />
Kessler, Mark<br />
Lombardi, Doug<br />
Smith, Chelli<br />
Trainers<br />
Administrative<br />
DeFrancesco, Sue<br />
Hardy, Rick<br />
Hicks, Pam<br />
Salazar, Pam<br />
Elementary Literacy<br />
Cannon, Shanalee<br />
Kinnaird, Kathryn (Consultant)<br />
Lee, Holly<br />
Leday, Hattie<br />
Mattson, Elizabeth<br />
Sibley, Adine<br />
Technology<br />
Krieger, Glenn<br />
Mathews, Frank<br />
Mills, Brandy<br />
Kindergarten<br />
Markovic, Robyn<br />
Elementary Math<br />
Dees, Kathy<br />
Hood-Ratliff, Stephanie<br />
Pearson, Brenda<br />
Peterson, Jackie<br />
Richards, Darla<br />
Ryerson, Kristian<br />
Elementary Science<br />
Behuniak, Anna Maria<br />
Bloom, Lois<br />
Davis, Sandy<br />
Hepworth, Dorothea<br />
Meyer, Rebecca<br />
Secondary Literacy<br />
Lasley, Saralyn<br />
Raymer, Amy<br />
Richards, Rosanne<br />
Secondary Math<br />
Arizmendez, Sara<br />
Arquette,Cassandra<br />
Barnson, Cheryl<br />
Hunter, Ricardo<br />
Lawrence, Deborah<br />
Long, Carol<br />
Ortiz, Cindy<br />
Spendlove, Karl<br />
Secondary Science<br />
Bostic, Jeff<br />
Ebert, Ellen<br />
Marconi, Elizabeth<br />
Sibley, Bret
Listen and Learn<br />
by Sue DeFrancesco<br />
School improvement, student<br />
achievement and individual<br />
student progress are tracked<br />
using various data sources<br />
derived from norm referenced,<br />
criterion referenced,<br />
intervention program, districtbased,or<br />
classroom-based<br />
assessments. From this<br />
composite of indicators,<br />
teachers frame their<br />
instruction. However, other<br />
indicators not reported<br />
numerically are often<br />
overlooked. What can<br />
students tell us about their<br />
own learning and their areas<br />
of confidence or sense<br />
of struggle with content,<br />
processes, or skills?<br />
Our yearly check-up with our<br />
physician is preceded by lab<br />
work and assessment of our<br />
vital signs – blood pressure,<br />
heart beat, breathing sounds.<br />
However, the most important<br />
part of our doctor’s office<br />
visit is our opportunity to tell<br />
our physician how we feel,<br />
what symptoms we may be<br />
experiencing and discuss<br />
options for treatment as<br />
well as for maintaining and<br />
improving our quality of health.<br />
Pursuing students’ reflections<br />
on their learning, considering<br />
those responses to target their<br />
needs by providing activities,<br />
review, assessments and<br />
learning opportunities in our<br />
instruction validates students<br />
as partners in learning with<br />
us. Learning may then be<br />
perceived as not something<br />
“done to them” but rather it is<br />
a process “done with them”<br />
recognizing their voices,<br />
perceptions and ideas.<br />
Components of an<br />
Effective Lesson<br />
The first three Components<br />
of an Effective Lesson –<br />
Introduction, Daily<br />
Review, and Daily<br />
Objective- present wonderful<br />
opportunities to ask students<br />
about not only what they are<br />
learning, but how they are<br />
learning. For example, in the<br />
introduction to a new concept<br />
students will be studying,<br />
asking students about their<br />
connections, associations<br />
or experiences related to<br />
that concept will give them<br />
a sense of confidence at<br />
the outset. Once concept<br />
and skill development is<br />
underway, revisiting the<br />
references students shared<br />
in that introductory part<br />
of the lesson validates<br />
their contributions linking<br />
background knowledge to<br />
the new information and<br />
concepts in the lesson. In<br />
the text, Building Background<br />
Knowledge (2004) Robert<br />
Marzano writes, “…the<br />
research literature supports<br />
one compelling fact: what<br />
students already know<br />
about the content is one of<br />
the strongest indicators of<br />
how well they will learn new<br />
information relative to the<br />
content” (p. 1).<br />
From the “picture walks”<br />
utilized by primary teachers<br />
when introducing a book<br />
to a secondary math<br />
teacher introducing sports<br />
team statistics to draw<br />
inferences and make<br />
predictions about future<br />
performance, establishing<br />
connections with students’<br />
understandings is essential.<br />
Asking students how they<br />
processed information, how<br />
they can demonstrate their<br />
understanding and how<br />
they would like to learn new<br />
material helps students<br />
understand their learning<br />
preferences and master<br />
concepts.<br />
Daily Review can also allow<br />
students to communicate what<br />
questions or “fuzziness” they<br />
might still be experiencing.
“...teachers need to be attuned on a daily basis to who<br />
is learning what and who is not, and then teachers must<br />
find ways to make sure each and every child is learning<br />
everything in the curriculum”.<br />
Asking students to list the<br />
math homework problems<br />
that were easy for them and<br />
explain why will give insight as<br />
to the problems which were<br />
more difficult; thus the problem<br />
solving process is not punitive,<br />
but a natural part of moving<br />
toward understanding.<br />
Finally, the Daily Objective<br />
provides students an<br />
understanding why the new<br />
concept or skill is important.<br />
Asking students what might<br />
be some alternative ways to<br />
meet the objective would allow<br />
them to share how they could<br />
learn the new material or skill.<br />
Scheurich and Skrla (2003)<br />
in Leadership for Equity and<br />
Excellence write “…teachers<br />
need to be attuned on a daily<br />
basis to who is learning what<br />
and who is not, and then<br />
teachers must find ways to<br />
make sure each and every<br />
child is learning everything in<br />
the curriculum” (p.47). If we<br />
do not converse with students<br />
about what they are learning,<br />
what is difficult for them, how<br />
they like to learn, how can they<br />
best show their understanding,<br />
then we cannot ensure all<br />
students are accessing the full<br />
curriculum to master content<br />
standards.<br />
The Components of an<br />
Effective Lesson, as suggested<br />
in these examples, are more<br />
than a lesson planning tool<br />
for teachers. They provide<br />
an opportunity, within the<br />
flow of a lesson, for students<br />
to communicate their<br />
understandings, frames<br />
of reference, previous<br />
experiences and unanswered<br />
questions about concepts and<br />
skills they are expected to<br />
master.<br />
• Begin new areas of study<br />
by asking students to<br />
generate questions, make<br />
statements, or share<br />
connections to the new<br />
material to be studied –<br />
take notes or frame ideas<br />
in a graphic organizer<br />
to refer to as the lesson<br />
proceeds<br />
• Ask students how they<br />
might best remember<br />
important information<br />
presented – taking<br />
notes, placing stickies,<br />
highlighting text,<br />
summarizing verballyand<br />
allow them to use<br />
strategies they feel are<br />
valuable<br />
• Take time to look at<br />
vocabulary embedded in<br />
the new concept studied<br />
and generate predictions<br />
or guesses about the<br />
meaning and relationship<br />
of the words – record<br />
for verifying once the<br />
vocabulary is addressed in<br />
the course of the lesson<br />
• Use Daily Review<br />
to assess student<br />
understanding of<br />
new material – are<br />
students struggling with<br />
understanding content<br />
or process or applying<br />
information in unfamiliar<br />
contexts?<br />
• While previewing related<br />
chapter or text material,<br />
ask students to look for<br />
words they think will be<br />
important to know if they<br />
are to meet the learning<br />
goal for the day. Have<br />
students answer the<br />
question – “How will I as<br />
a teacher know that you<br />
know?”<br />
References<br />
Marzano, R. (2004). Building<br />
background knowledge for academic<br />
achievement. Alexandria,<br />
VA: ASCD.<br />
Scheurich, J. & Skrla, L. (2003).<br />
Leadership for equity and<br />
excellence.Corwin Press.
Administrator<br />
Highlights<br />
Kenneth Wronski, Principal<br />
Steve Schorr Elementary School<br />
Mr. Wronski has been in the Clark County School<br />
District for 18 years. He taught eight years before<br />
becoming an administrator. He served as assistant<br />
principal at L. Wiener, Charlotte Hill and Beatty<br />
Elementary Schools and principal at L. Weiner<br />
Elementary School before opening Steve Schorr<br />
Elementary School in the 06-07 school year. The honor<br />
of opening a new school serves as one of Mr. Wronski’s<br />
greatest accomplishments.<br />
The secret to the success the students and staff enjoy<br />
at Schorr Elementary School is based on the premise<br />
that the school community does whatever it takes to<br />
ensure student success; there is no substitute for hard<br />
work. According to Mr. Wronski, it is the teachers who<br />
make the biggest difference, and he works hard to<br />
support his staff to be the best they can be. He has<br />
instituted a program, in partnership with South Point<br />
Hotel & Casino, to provide incentives for teachers who<br />
have achieved a WOW. A WOW is an exemplary deed<br />
presented to the faculty by a faculty member. With the<br />
generosity of the South Point Hotel, gift certificates for<br />
dinners, movies, and shows are extended to teachers<br />
who receive WOWs. This principal strives to secure<br />
additional resources to reinforce the commitment to<br />
students by his teachers.<br />
When Mr. Wronski is not working to support his<br />
students, staff and parents, he attends dog shows. He<br />
raises and trains Chows and plans to be a certified<br />
handler when he retires.<br />
Congratulations to Mr. Wronski for his extra efforts<br />
on behalf of the Clark County School District and the<br />
community of Schorr Elementary School.<br />
Holly Lepisto, Principal<br />
Floyd Elementary School<br />
Mrs. Lepisto opened Floyd Elementary School in<br />
Pahrump this school year. She spent the last two years<br />
as principal of J.G. Johnson Elementary School in<br />
Pahrump before being honored with opening the first<br />
new elementary school in six years. Mrs. Lepisto began<br />
her career in Mentor, Ohio and taught for more than 20<br />
years before becoming an administrator. She had been<br />
both an elementary and middle school principal before<br />
arriving in Nye County three years ago.<br />
This year the students and staff of Floyd Elementary<br />
School have focused on building community through<br />
character traits which includes taking care of the<br />
new building and building positive relations with the<br />
students who have been brought together in this new<br />
environment. The “Bobcat Pledge” is recited every<br />
morning as the day begins to remind everyone of the<br />
importance of building a positive school community.<br />
No outside funding or grants for ancillary programs were<br />
available for this new school; however, the teachers<br />
and Mrs. Lepisto stepped forward to ensure positive<br />
learning experiences for the students. The teachers<br />
have volunteered their time to develop after school arts<br />
and tutoring programs. The school community has also<br />
developed several programs to aid families with clothing<br />
drives, food donations and family movie nights held<br />
at the school. With the economy drastically affecting<br />
the families at Floyd Elementary School, Mrs. Lepisto<br />
has enhanced the efforts of educating the students by<br />
providing support for the families.<br />
Mrs. Lepisto enjoys making scrapbooks and all crafts<br />
associated with home projects. She and her husband<br />
have two children and one grandson with another<br />
grandson expected in June.<br />
The Floyd Elementary School community is indeed<br />
fortunate to have such a dedicated professional as its<br />
leader.
MEETING THE CHALLENGES OF IMPROVING STUDENT<br />
ACHIEVEMENT IN RURAL SCHOOLS<br />
by Rick Hardy<br />
I hate this title! I hate it<br />
because it seems to lend support<br />
to the idea that the problems<br />
facing educators in rural schools<br />
are somehow fundamentally<br />
different than the problems found<br />
in larger schools. With very few<br />
exceptions, the problems are very<br />
much the same. The difference<br />
is just a difference in scale. If this<br />
premise is true, it would follow<br />
that the ideas and programs<br />
helping students in rural schools<br />
could also be adopted or adapted<br />
to help students in larger schools.<br />
The reverse would also be true.<br />
One idea that would benefit<br />
students at all schools is the<br />
philosophy and attitude of the<br />
administrators and staff at many<br />
small high schools across the<br />
state of Nevada relative to<br />
the High School Proficiency<br />
Examination Program (HSPE).<br />
Many of these schools have<br />
formally taken the position that<br />
“No Student Fails”. This is not<br />
just lip service, but a commitment<br />
to do everything possible to help<br />
each and every student succeed.<br />
Evidence of this commitment is<br />
seen not just in additional courses<br />
designed to help students who<br />
have failed the first round of<br />
HSPE prepare for additional<br />
rounds, or in before and after<br />
school or summertime tutoring<br />
programs. It can be seen as<br />
counselors and teachers jointly<br />
identify specific low areas for<br />
individual students and develop<br />
specific remedies that address<br />
those low areas.<br />
When a vocational teacher plans<br />
activities that model reading and<br />
writing skills and then requires<br />
students to use those skills in the<br />
context of whatever vocational<br />
skills are being taught that week,<br />
the commitment becomes real for<br />
both the teacher and the student.<br />
When a coach schedules a time<br />
and a place for math tutoring<br />
for his players who have not yet<br />
passed the math portion of the<br />
HSPE and then checks with his<br />
players three times a week to<br />
make certain they are attending<br />
extra tutoring and getting their<br />
homework completed and<br />
in on time, students feel the<br />
commitment and they begin to<br />
believe the philosophy that “No<br />
Student Fails”. Regardless of<br />
size, a school staff meeting or<br />
department meeting that spends<br />
70% of the time talking about<br />
solutions to student problems<br />
and 30% of the time talking about<br />
scheduling events and activities<br />
is a great school-wide indicator<br />
that priorities are in the proper<br />
perspective.<br />
Differences in scale can be<br />
exemplified by what can happen<br />
when a family with several ELL<br />
children or with severe special<br />
needs children moves into a<br />
small rural community. The<br />
staff at a small school might go<br />
into “full-court panic”. In larger<br />
schools, personnel and programs<br />
are already in existence and<br />
the students are simply placed<br />
into the appropriate programs.<br />
Progressive small schools also<br />
have people and programs, often<br />
computer related, identified even<br />
if a current need does not exist<br />
so that if students with these<br />
needs do enroll, their needs can<br />
be met immediately. Because of<br />
their small size, rural schools and<br />
districts often establish networks<br />
of people inside and outside of<br />
the district who can be called<br />
upon to help should a need arise.<br />
In larger schools and districts,<br />
those networks often exist as<br />
district level resources. These<br />
resources are usually especially<br />
adept at dealing with identified,<br />
specific, and familiar needs.<br />
In nature and in organizations, it<br />
is often found that smaller size<br />
can result in quicker response<br />
and greater maneuverability.<br />
In smaller schools, if a need<br />
arises that has never before<br />
been experienced, a dedicated<br />
staff can quickly develop and<br />
implement multiple strategies<br />
and responses to meet a need.<br />
Larger schools might also be well<br />
served by bringing the resources<br />
of the immediate staff to bear on<br />
a new and unique problem during<br />
the time the routine requests for<br />
permission and resources are<br />
moving up the organizational<br />
ladder. As always, the student<br />
is best served by an immediate<br />
and caring response to his or her<br />
need.<br />
Large or small, rural or urban,<br />
the elements of good teaching<br />
and learning unite us all. The<br />
more we focus on solutions to the<br />
problems surrounding student<br />
achievement, the more we realize<br />
we all have something to learn<br />
and we all have something to<br />
share.
“…we live in the Age of InfoWhelm.”<br />
-(Ian Jukes)<br />
“Beyond this, we live in the Age of InfoWhelm. The amount of information in<br />
the world is growing at an exponential rate, which is reinforcing the decreasing<br />
importance of memorization, while at the same time increasing the need for a<br />
general conceptual awareness of the world.” (Jukes, 2007)<br />
Making sense of the infinite<br />
amount of the world’s<br />
information proves to be the bulk<br />
of the battle. Using alternative<br />
assessments and test data can<br />
help teachers narrow, identify<br />
and correct areas of classroom<br />
instruction where students are<br />
not learning effectively. Actively<br />
engaging and including students<br />
in the assessment process will<br />
increase their understanding,<br />
and success, with testing.<br />
Pedagogical and methodological<br />
shifts must occur to prepare<br />
today’s students with new skills<br />
for the workforce of the future.<br />
The availablilty of vast amounts<br />
of data through advances in<br />
technology allows the analysis<br />
of student assessment to inform<br />
classroom instruction in ways<br />
never before available. One<br />
can sort, classify, rearrange,<br />
and redistribute any data at<br />
the click of a button. However,<br />
there is an information overload<br />
problem: InfoWhelm (Jukes,<br />
2007). Educators need to teach<br />
students how to direct this<br />
amazing amount of information<br />
to their advantage. Teachers and<br />
students working together can<br />
explore and acquire new skills to<br />
manage knowledge productively.<br />
There are many ways educators<br />
can utilize the latest technology<br />
and access to data in order to<br />
improve and enrich classroom<br />
instruction and increase student<br />
achievement.<br />
Teachers have the ability to<br />
analyze test data from data<br />
collection software programs,<br />
like Clark County School District’s<br />
Instructional Data Management<br />
System (IDMS) to<br />
identify deficiencies in instruction<br />
and assessment. Questions<br />
the entire class missed are vital<br />
to examine for a lack of content<br />
instruction in that area or poor<br />
construction of the test question<br />
itself. Looking at specific student<br />
scores will help teachers to<br />
identify individual limitations.<br />
Teachers who endorse multiple<br />
learning styles will make opportunities<br />
for success available to<br />
students in a variety of ways.<br />
Allowing students to create and<br />
submit alternative assessments<br />
addresses the multiple learning<br />
styles of students, while illuminating<br />
key areas of low<br />
student achievement. Project<br />
and scenario-based learning<br />
combines content objectives<br />
with the application of new and<br />
varied skills. Blended learning<br />
projects encompass the physical<br />
and technological limitations of<br />
the real-world learning environment<br />
with what is possible using<br />
technology. These types of<br />
alternative assessments teach<br />
students to use higher order<br />
thinking skills (HOTS) and the<br />
more advanced cognitive levels<br />
of analysis, synthesis, evaluation,<br />
and creation (Bloom’s<br />
Taxonomy, 2001).<br />
In addition to training teachers to<br />
data mine and apply results effectively,<br />
it is necessary to teach<br />
students indispensable selfassessment<br />
skills.<br />
It is essential for students to be<br />
active partners in the learning<br />
process. Additionally, it is imperative<br />
for educators to instruct<br />
students to identify their own<br />
learning strengths, weaknesses,<br />
and learning styles.<br />
“The ability to take data - to be<br />
able to understand it, process it,<br />
to extract value from it, to<br />
communicate it-that’s going to<br />
be a hugely important skill for<br />
the next decades, not only at the<br />
professional level but even at the<br />
educational level for<br />
elementary school kids, for high<br />
school, for college kids.”<br />
(Varian, 2009)<br />
A key strategy is to teach<br />
students to manipulate<br />
statistics (act as statisticians)<br />
to make sense of the data<br />
and information. Teaching the<br />
students how to effectively<br />
sort through large amounts of<br />
highly available and accessible<br />
information, how to sift and<br />
authenticate information,<br />
and recognize copyright<br />
infringement, brings the power of<br />
assessment into the hands
of the students. Rubrics are<br />
the perfect vehicle for student<br />
empowerment. If the teacher<br />
provides the rubric for any<br />
assignment, project, and activity<br />
at the beginning of the project,<br />
the students will know exactly<br />
what is expected of them. They<br />
will know exactly what they need<br />
to do to receive the desired<br />
grade.<br />
Unveiling the mystery of the<br />
assessment process by showing<br />
students the test format, what<br />
type of questions, time lengths,<br />
sections, ways to prepare,<br />
how to test, how to eat well,<br />
and how to get enough rest<br />
will increase student success.<br />
Teachers who deliver successful<br />
practice testing review sessions<br />
based on recreating the testing<br />
environment with a balanced<br />
assessment, will have the<br />
most successful test-takers. It<br />
is critical to instruct students<br />
to problem solve as they are<br />
testing. Students will feel<br />
more confident going into test<br />
taking situations if they are well<br />
informed and have actually<br />
practiced within the test taking<br />
scenario. The increase in local,<br />
state, and federal testing, while<br />
trying to add traditional teacher<br />
assessments, and taking more<br />
days out of the schedule to<br />
accommodate practice testing<br />
leaves less time for content<br />
instruction. Assessment skills<br />
imparted to students will benefit<br />
them in other areas of study as<br />
well. Test scores will determine<br />
the colleges students are eligible<br />
to apply, what scholarships<br />
may be available, what fields<br />
of study to enter, and even the<br />
potential a student may have to<br />
an employer.<br />
Testing is driving instruction<br />
(<strong>RPDP</strong> BAM); both students<br />
and teachers need to be armed<br />
with the best tools to test<br />
successfully.<br />
Everyday, a new technology<br />
gadget, a new technology<br />
service, and a new way of<br />
using an existing technology<br />
emerge on a digital television<br />
ad, a satellite radio commercial,<br />
on a huge digital display,<br />
and in a pop-up online. The<br />
Kindle 2 allows for on-the-go<br />
reading in a large format with<br />
adjustable text size, a paperlike<br />
screen, storage of over<br />
1,500 books, and the ability to<br />
download new content making<br />
the device reusable, portable,<br />
and the most convenient way<br />
to access and store content.<br />
One can also wirelessly email<br />
documents to the Kindle, it has<br />
a built-in dictionary, wireless<br />
access to Wikipedia, an app<br />
for the iPhone, and even plays<br />
audiobooks. Varian refers to<br />
this period in time as a period<br />
of ‘combinatorial innovation’<br />
(Varian, 2009). The Kindle is<br />
a prime example. With nearly<br />
endless possibilities of retrieving<br />
information and combining,<br />
analyzing, and redistributing<br />
information, teachers and<br />
students need to employ new<br />
strategies to be successful<br />
in the present as well as the<br />
future. Employing the versatility<br />
of technology, educators can<br />
efficiently use extracted data to<br />
improve classroom instructional<br />
strategies and content. The<br />
best results will occur when<br />
teachers and students work<br />
in partnerships to shift skill<br />
acquisition to align with the<br />
ever-changing landscape of this<br />
technological brave new world.<br />
Online Resources<br />
Bloom’s Taxonomy Applying<br />
Assessment Strategies<br />
http://www.apa.org/ed/new_<br />
blooms.html<br />
Rubistar – Create and customize<br />
rubrics<br />
http://rubistar.4teachers.org/<br />
index.php<br />
Kindle 2 – Overview and<br />
Description<br />
http://www.amazon.com/Kindle-<br />
Amazons-Wireless-Reading-<br />
Generation/dp/B00154JDAI<br />
References<br />
Jukes, Ian (2007, January 29).<br />
Rethinking Education in the New<br />
Digital Landscape. Retrieved<br />
March 20, 2009 from Committed<br />
Sardine Website, Web site:<br />
http://web.mac.com/iajukes/<br />
thecommittedsardine/Articles_<br />
files/REITNDL.pdf<br />
Manyika, James (2009,<br />
January). Hal Varian on how<br />
the Web challenges managers.<br />
Retrieved February 14, 2009<br />
from The McKinsey Quarterly,<br />
Web site:<br />
http://www.mckinseyquarterly.<br />
com/Hal_Varian_on_how_<br />
the_Web_challenges_<br />
managers_2286<br />
SN<strong>RPDP</strong> Hanlon, Bill.<br />
Backward Assessment Model.<br />
Retrieved March 1, 2009 from<br />
Southern Nevada Regional<br />
Professional Development<br />
Program, Web site: http://www.<br />
rpdp.net/assessment.html<br />
by Brandy Kay Mills<br />
<strong>RPDP</strong> Regional Trainer
Beatty Elementary School<br />
Rural Technology Use<br />
by Gary Torstenson<br />
Beatty Elementary School<br />
Rural Technology Use<br />
Going back to the days of my college audio/<br />
video class, I remember learning how to thread<br />
a film projector, how to use an opaque projector,<br />
a filmstrip projector, an overhead projector, and<br />
how to run the ditto machine (using the solvent,<br />
methanol, and purple ink).<br />
For the most part, I couldn’t imagine third grade<br />
students in control of this equipment. Fortunately,<br />
most of what we use today can be quickly<br />
demonstrated to and used by third graders.<br />
Technology implementation today is all about<br />
increased involvement in the everyday classroom.<br />
Flip Video Cameras<br />
The Flip Video<br />
cameras are an<br />
excellent size for<br />
my third grade<br />
class. From<br />
taping the school’s<br />
homecoming parade<br />
to demonstrating<br />
how to make paper folds,or just recording an<br />
alphabetizing lesson that can be used for review,<br />
the camera’s size makes it easy to hold. Its USB<br />
output lets the students quickly see the results of<br />
their work on the computer screen.<br />
Creating a Class DVD<br />
Our class was getting close to finishing a writing<br />
unit on fiction. These were multiple page stories<br />
that took awhile to construct. It looked as though<br />
perhaps only half the class would complete the<br />
assignment, so I announced that we would be<br />
creating a DVD of the students’ writing. On the<br />
day the assignment was due only two students<br />
were not finished and one of those was hurriedly<br />
trying to get something on paper. We set up<br />
one of our Flip Video cameras on a tripod and<br />
recorded the students one after the other. The<br />
camera was hardly any distraction, since it<br />
has become just another classroom tool. Using<br />
Adobe Premiere Elements, I quickly arranged the<br />
presentations, added a menu, title, and burned<br />
a DVD that was easily copied multiple times for<br />
students to take home.<br />
Document Cameras<br />
I’ve worked with<br />
both the Elmo<br />
and Avervision<br />
types of document<br />
cameras. Along<br />
with the projector,<br />
they are in daily use<br />
in the classroom.<br />
Sometimes I am just<br />
explaining how an art project should go together.<br />
Arranging pieces and showing the class under<br />
a document camera sure beats fumbling around<br />
and dropping pieces in front of the classroom. If<br />
the class is sharing some of their writing, they<br />
can use the document cameras to show, not just<br />
tell, their story. The students love to share using<br />
the cameras. Personally, I like just being able<br />
to display whatever we are working on onto the<br />
white board. The cameras adjust to the available<br />
classroom light so viewing is rarely a problem.<br />
The ability to save pages and then recall them<br />
allows me to have a whole day’s or week’s worth of<br />
material ready to go with just a few button presses.<br />
The Avervision’s freeze button is a favorite with the<br />
students, being able to set their paper down then<br />
pressing freeze lets them take their paper back to<br />
their desk while we discuss the paper that is still<br />
displayed on the board.<br />
Students love to use gadgets. They want to push<br />
the buttons. They want to grab a digital camera<br />
and take pictures of friends. They want to get hold<br />
of the video camera and walk around. They want<br />
to play a digital recorder just to hear their own<br />
voice and say, “I don’t sound like that.” When<br />
implementing new technologies in the classroom,<br />
the first step is to demonstrate how to hold, move,<br />
and explain just why those neat little buttons are<br />
really there. Like my students, I love gadgets, but<br />
I know they have to last. Taking care of what we<br />
have is a major concern.
Duckwater Elementary/Middle School<br />
Rural Technology Use<br />
Duckwater Elementary/Middle School is a one<br />
room school in extreme northern Nye County<br />
School District (NCSD), 140 miles from the<br />
next nearest school in the district, and 70<br />
miles from the nearest town, Ely. I am the only<br />
teacher for students in Early Childhood Special<br />
Education and K-8, although I am fortunate<br />
to have a full-time classroom aide. Together,<br />
we provide all the learning opportunities for<br />
the sixteen students enrolled at the school.<br />
Teaching in a multi-grade classroom with such<br />
a wide age range is both challenging and<br />
rewarding.<br />
One of the greatest challenges of teaching<br />
in a rural setting is resources. Students do<br />
not always have a well-developed schema<br />
or vocabulary for typical urban concepts<br />
such as “skyscrapers” or “crosswalks”, and<br />
the reference section of a rural school’s tiny<br />
library does not offer a wide selection of<br />
materials. The training provided by Southern<br />
Nevada Regional Professional Development<br />
Program (<strong>RPDP</strong>) and NCSD has been the<br />
key to unlocking the learning barrier created<br />
by distance. Students now use reference<br />
materials such as online dictionaries and<br />
encyclopedias daily. A word that stumps an<br />
English Language Learner (ELL) student can<br />
be magically added to his vocabulary through<br />
the use of Google images or video.<br />
Earlier this school year, NCSD replaced<br />
satellite internet with T-1 technology. T-1<br />
speeds have allowed us to more fully utilize<br />
the internet for video conferencing, which is<br />
essential for several of our projects involving<br />
technology. SN<strong>RPDP</strong> has been able to use<br />
this type of video conferencing to provide<br />
courses through University of Nevada, Las<br />
Vegas (UNLV) and Southern Utah University<br />
(SUU) to me at my own site, meaning I am<br />
no longer limited to taking coursework during<br />
the summer at sites 300 miles from my home.<br />
Instead, I was able to complete all of the<br />
class requirements for a middle-school math<br />
certification without the extensive travel that I<br />
suffered in the past.<br />
Music is one of<br />
the few<br />
extracurricular<br />
activities<br />
available at our<br />
school. In<br />
addition to our general music program, we also<br />
offer violin lessons from a virtual studio in<br />
Kansas using the video conferencing abilities<br />
afforded us by our T-1 connection, webcam,<br />
laptop, microphone, projector, and video<br />
screen. Julie Stroud is the owner of<br />
Violinnovation©, and “meets” with students<br />
each week via webcam. The free messenger<br />
service, SightSpeed©, has been the vehicle<br />
through which we meet. Mrs. Stroud is a<br />
talented violinist and highly qualified instructor<br />
of the Suzuki© method of violin instruction.<br />
More information can be found at her website:<br />
www.violinnovation.com. NCSD’s technology<br />
department worked diligently to provide a<br />
firewalled way for the video-conferencing to<br />
happen.
Locally, I have used the digital video camera<br />
to create short 3-5 minute video clips of<br />
reading materials so students can do multiple<br />
readings. I read the materials, video-recording<br />
the text with my finger tracking the print. This<br />
allows students to become fluent by the end<br />
of the week or unit. Video clips of decodable<br />
readers, leveled readers, fluency passages,<br />
vocabulary passages, spelling words, and<br />
literature excerpts (stories from the basal<br />
reader) have all been created for each week/<br />
unit of study. While many of the materials are<br />
not available at all from the publisher in an<br />
auditory format, those that are available are<br />
often read too quickly for the recording to be<br />
of use to students. Furthermore, none of the<br />
materials available from the publisher have the<br />
added benefit of a video component in which<br />
students who get lost or distracted can selfrelocate<br />
by looking at the monitor.<br />
Completed videos can be utilized in several<br />
ways. They can be copied from the video<br />
camera to the hard drive or the server and<br />
shortcuts can be created for students to use<br />
at their desktop. Students are assigned daily<br />
to re-read materials, specific to their individual<br />
needs, as an independent learning center<br />
activity. The projector is used to show the<br />
videos in large-screen format to larger groups,<br />
and DVDs are created for use with a television/<br />
DVD player. The video-clip format also gives<br />
me a chance to reiterate important vocabulary<br />
or skills, such as cause/effect, drawing<br />
conclusions, or making predictions. In a multigrade<br />
classroom, this frees the teacher to meet<br />
with other individuals or small groups in other<br />
grade levels.<br />
For my youngest students in the Early<br />
Childhood Special Education program,<br />
I’ve also made short video clips to provide<br />
adequate repetition of pre-academic skill<br />
areas, such as counting, numerals, letters,<br />
writing their names, and colors/shapes.<br />
These clips have been burned to DVDs and<br />
sent to the local daycare facility, where those<br />
teachers continue education beyond the school<br />
day. For students who do not have a great<br />
deal of family support for homework, video<br />
clips can be created to guide them through<br />
homework assignments. The clips are then<br />
burned to DVDs that students can take home<br />
with them. It’s rather like having the teacher<br />
right at home with them each night.<br />
The ELMO and projector have also been<br />
valuable during phonics letter tile activities<br />
for students in kindergarten and first grade.<br />
Using the projector gives immediate visual<br />
clues to students who don’t respond as well<br />
to oral directions during letter tile activities.<br />
As students receive instruction during letter<br />
tile activities, they are receiving both visual<br />
and auditory prompts, and are simultaneously<br />
involved in a kinesthetic activity of moving the<br />
tiles, providing for three modalities of learning.<br />
This helps maintain the attention of students<br />
who might normally be easily distracted or who<br />
have a short attention span.<br />
I have found that when using technology, one<br />
must make a decision to acquire a “can-do”<br />
attitude. I CAN learn to use this gadget. I<br />
CAN use it to do things I’ve never been able<br />
to do before. I CAN begin to think of this as a<br />
way to solve a problem I have. My students<br />
CAN learn to use it, too. A teacher must also<br />
practice using technology before using it in the<br />
classroom, and not feel frustrated if it doesn’t<br />
go just right every single time. It’s also really<br />
great to have an ally to go to (like SN<strong>RPDP</strong> or<br />
NCSD tech guys) if you get stuck! Technology<br />
opens a door for teachers and students – the<br />
teacher’s imagination and creativity are the<br />
only limits to the paths that lead from the<br />
doorway to the world.<br />
by Lyn Huston<br />
Duckwater Elementary/Middle School<br />
Rural Technology Use
Teacher Highlights<br />
Technology<br />
Elementary Literacy<br />
Ann Hofner<br />
Bob Miller Middle School<br />
Computer Literacy - 6 th Grade<br />
Jon Jones<br />
Lowman Elementary School<br />
Literacy Specialist<br />
Ann Hofner has been teaching in Clark<br />
County for 13 years. Currently, she is teaching<br />
Computer Literacy 6 at Bob Miller Middle School<br />
in Green Valley. Use of desktop computers<br />
is a major part of her required curriculum but<br />
incorporating the use of handheld technology is<br />
a way of keeping the students interested. Power<br />
Point is now used as Step One in the creation of<br />
projects. Students save Power Point projects as<br />
JPEGS to import into Photo Story 3 or Windows<br />
Movie Maker. This allows incorporation of<br />
small portions of video from KLVX, music, and<br />
recordings of their own voices. The final product<br />
is then converted into a Podcast.<br />
My two years participating in the <strong>RPDP</strong><br />
Technology ASP Program has been great! Not<br />
only have I accomplished MA +36, but I have<br />
acquired great skills to use with my students.<br />
Meet Jon Jones, Lowman Elementary<br />
School Literacy Specialist. Mr. Jones has been<br />
with Clark County for 11 years, and is starting<br />
his second year as literacy specialist. He<br />
recently completed his MS Ed. in Elementary<br />
Science and is working on his Ed. D. in Teacher<br />
Leadership. In addition to working with students,<br />
staff development is a large part of his assigned<br />
duties.<br />
With limited time for staff development,<br />
Mr. Jones implemented an innovative method<br />
for follow up. Quick Tips are brief, fact-packed,<br />
often funny messages filled with the key points<br />
or highlights related to recent staff development<br />
topics. Teachers get repetition, humor, and<br />
personal connection- all qualities that make staff<br />
development more effective. Jon has found that<br />
posting Quick Tips provides a constant visual<br />
reminder of these key points for everyone.
“We want to be<br />
thermostats, not<br />
thermometers.<br />
Thermostats affect the<br />
climate; thermometers<br />
merely reflect the climate.”<br />
In the classroom…<br />
By setting an example of<br />
desired behavior, the teacher<br />
acts as a thermostat influencing<br />
the behavior of her students. If<br />
you are letting student behavior<br />
influence your attitude, then you<br />
are just a thermometer.<br />
In the school…<br />
Do you influence others’<br />
attitudes (a thermostat); or are<br />
you affected by the behavior<br />
and attitudes of others (a<br />
thermometer)?<br />
Remember that the job of a<br />
thermostat is to make positive<br />
changes to create a comfortable<br />
climate for everyone.<br />
Are you a<br />
THERMOSTAT<br />
OR<br />
THERMOMETER??<br />
Q<br />
U<br />
I<br />
C<br />
K<br />
T<br />
I<br />
P<br />
S<br />
Q<br />
U<br />
I<br />
C<br />
K<br />
T<br />
I<br />
P<br />
S<br />
Are you frustrated<br />
trying to figure out all<br />
the writing traits? Try<br />
thinking about it like<br />
this…<br />
Ideas…are like cars.<br />
Organization…is like<br />
roads.<br />
Voice…is how each car<br />
looks and sounds.<br />
Word Choice…is like<br />
taking your car in for a<br />
lube and detail.<br />
Fluency… is how people<br />
drive.<br />
Conventions…are traffic<br />
signals.<br />
All these traits have to<br />
work together to make a<br />
piece of writing look and<br />
sound smooth, appealing,<br />
and readable!
Enhancing Student Learning Through Assessment<br />
By Barbara Creps<br />
CRT. TerraNova. NAEP. Nevada<br />
Writing Proficiency. It seems as if<br />
students are constantly being tested.<br />
However, none of these tests give teachers<br />
the immediate feedback that they need to<br />
make students successful. In order to truly<br />
get to the heart of student success, teachers<br />
need assessment for learning. Assessment<br />
for learning often means formative<br />
assessment. However, a deeper definition<br />
begs to exist. This definition asks not only<br />
who is and isn’t meeting standards, but rather<br />
how the student is doing on his journey to<br />
obtaining mastery of the skill. Formative<br />
assessments are useful for the teacher while<br />
assessments- for- learning are useful for the<br />
student.<br />
Luckily, teachers have moved beyond using<br />
assessments only for judging students.<br />
Assessments for learning can be viewed<br />
as a type of compass that tells us in which<br />
direction to lead the students toward mastery<br />
of the concept. Teachers can then adjust<br />
their instruction so that the target goal is<br />
hit. It also allows the student to be aware of<br />
the target goal and how to get there. With<br />
an effective assessment system, students<br />
will want to learn and teachers will want to<br />
do their very best in offering instruction that<br />
makes students successful.<br />
What Teachers Need to Know and Do<br />
Rick Stiggins, Director of the Assessment<br />
Training Institute, maintains that there are<br />
two important concepts that teachers need<br />
to keep in mind when designing classroom<br />
assessments. First, they must articulate<br />
the achievement target that they want the<br />
students to hit. Second, they need to know<br />
how to transform these targets into quality<br />
classroom indicators.<br />
Teachers need to ask themselves, “What<br />
knowledge do the students need to have<br />
in order to master the concept?” and<br />
“What performance skills do we expect<br />
them to achieve?“ All teachers need to be<br />
knowledgeable of the targets their students<br />
are shooting for.<br />
Performance assessments are great<br />
instruments to use. With performance<br />
assessments, we observe students while they<br />
are completing a task or examining the final<br />
product they have created. Think of writing<br />
as an example. What does “good” writing<br />
look like? Or in reading, what makes a<br />
“good” reader? Being able to communicate<br />
to the students with clear, concise terms is<br />
key to having students master those skills.<br />
This mastery is the foundation for quality<br />
assessment. Teachers need to be given the<br />
opportunity to collaborate and define those<br />
achievement targets. “We cannot assess that<br />
which we don’t understand.” ( Stiggins, 1999)<br />
Once those target assessments are defined,<br />
teachers need to know how to transform them<br />
into quality classroom indicators. With proper<br />
indicators and documentation, teachers can<br />
gauge student learning progress from day to<br />
day. They can provide evidence of where the<br />
student was, where he is now, and where he<br />
should be in the future.<br />
Teachers need to know which assessment<br />
is best fit to meet the needs of the students.<br />
While multiple choice tests may be the best<br />
option in some assessment contexts, other<br />
times a performance assessment will provide<br />
the teacher with more information. Knowing<br />
which method to use will help teachers guide<br />
instruction and provide students with accurate<br />
and detailed feedback. Stiggins defines this<br />
as assessment literacy.
What Students Need to Know and Do<br />
While formative assessment contributes to<br />
effective classroom instruction, assessment<br />
for learning helps students take responsibility<br />
for their own learning, creating students who<br />
become lifelong learners. Using traditional<br />
assessment methods, a student may read<br />
the results and, seeing the signs, give up<br />
in hopeless failure. In an assessment-forlearning<br />
classroom, the same student will<br />
monitor his progress almost daily. He will see<br />
where he was in his learning and where he<br />
needs to go to reach his target. This drives<br />
the student to do better each time.<br />
Motivation is the key to success. To turn<br />
students on to the joy of learning, teachers<br />
need to turn to only three tools:<br />
• Student-involved classroom assessment<br />
• Student-involved record keeping<br />
• Student-involved communications<br />
These tools help students understand that<br />
no one is an expert the first time they try<br />
something. There is always a learning<br />
curve involved, and it’s all right to take a<br />
risk and fail. We all start low and make<br />
small steps toward achieving our goal. In an<br />
assessment- for- learning classroom, success<br />
is defined as continuous improvement.<br />
Wise teachers teach their students that<br />
improvement is always possible.<br />
Student-involved classroom assessments<br />
allow the students to succeed. They invite<br />
students to be partners in the assessment<br />
process. After teachers have defined a clear<br />
and appropriate vision of where they want<br />
the students to be, then students can learn<br />
the criteria by which their work will be judged.<br />
Students should be given the opportunity<br />
to design sample assessments and scoring<br />
criteria. They should be able to use<br />
student friendly language so that everyone<br />
understands where they need to be. The<br />
path to mastery will then become clearer.<br />
There will be no surprises and no excuses.<br />
Student-involved record keeping allows<br />
students to monitor their own progress.<br />
One of the most effective ways to do this<br />
is by having them keep portfolios of their<br />
work. In it there will be evidence of their<br />
small successes over a period of time<br />
including short self-reflection statements.<br />
Repeated student-involved record keeping<br />
helps students watch themselves grow, thus<br />
boosting their confidence.<br />
Student-involved communication allows<br />
students to share their success with others.<br />
The student-led parent-teacher conference<br />
is a well known method. Using concrete<br />
evidence, students are prepared and ready<br />
to tell the story of success to their parents.<br />
The pride they feel is very motivational. In<br />
addition, most students will work very hard to<br />
avoid having to justify their failure to achieve.<br />
In assessment-for-learning classrooms,<br />
teachers and students are working together<br />
to create a vision of where they are and<br />
where they want to be. They have an<br />
understanding of the where their learning is in<br />
relation to the standard of excellence. In an<br />
assessment-for-learning classroom, “How am<br />
I doing?” is a seldom heard phrase.<br />
Sources:<br />
Stiggins, R. J. (2001). Student-Involved<br />
Classroom Assessment. (3 rd edition). Upper<br />
Saddle River, NJ. Prentice-Hall, Inc.<br />
Stiggins, R. and Chappuis, J. (Jan.<br />
2008). Enhancing Student Learning.<br />
Retrieved March 31, 2008 from www.<br />
districtadministration.com<br />
Sparks, D. (1999). Assessment Without<br />
Victims; An Interview with Rick Stiggins.<br />
Journal of Staff Development. Retrieved<br />
March 28 th , 2009 from http://www.nsdc.org/<br />
news/jsd/stiggins202.cfm
The<br />
Self-<br />
Assesment<br />
Process<br />
by Rosanne<br />
Richards<br />
<strong>RPDP</strong> Secondary<br />
Literacy<br />
As adults, we heartily embrace<br />
self-assessment in our personal<br />
lives: reviewing our daily food<br />
intake while on a diet, standing<br />
back to admire that new IKEA<br />
bookcase we assembled (which<br />
seems to be leaning a bit to the<br />
left…) or perhaps even those<br />
four minutes between second<br />
and third period when we alter<br />
our lesson plan to better target<br />
our learning objective. We are<br />
in a constant state of assessing<br />
the quality our work; however,<br />
it’s not a skill that many of our<br />
students acquire naturally,<br />
especially as it relates to school<br />
work. Many students turn in<br />
work and expect a teacher’s<br />
grade to be the final decision<br />
on how well they completed an<br />
assignment.<br />
By teaching self-assessment as<br />
a process, we can help guide<br />
our students to become more<br />
thoughtful, more motivated,<br />
and ultimately more successful<br />
on the work they submit to us<br />
for final review. The following<br />
steps are a general formula<br />
for self-assessment which can<br />
be applied to anything from<br />
perfecting our batting stance<br />
to writing a research paper:<br />
1.) Identify the characteristics<br />
of the expected outcome, 2.)<br />
compare the expected outcome<br />
to the work produced, 3.)<br />
revise work to better reach the<br />
expected outcome, and 4.)<br />
reflect on the process.<br />
1. Identify the Characteristics<br />
of the Expected Outcome<br />
Modeling is the key to the first<br />
step of the Self-Assessment<br />
Process. By reviewing models<br />
of the expected product,<br />
students begin to understand<br />
which characteristics are<br />
strong and which are weak.<br />
For example, when beginning<br />
a research report, a teacher<br />
shows examples of how<br />
newspaper articles cite<br />
research by crediting other<br />
sources. By reading several<br />
articles that include research,<br />
students begin to make a list of<br />
what they notice in the articles<br />
that use citations correctly.<br />
Once students have a general<br />
understanding of how citations<br />
are used correctly, models of<br />
articles that are not as strong in<br />
using citations are introduced<br />
and students readily distinguish<br />
between strong, well-written<br />
articles using citations and<br />
those that do not. At this point,<br />
the teacher creates a list with<br />
the class as to what should<br />
be included in a research<br />
article. From that list, students<br />
construct a personal rubric as<br />
they begin writing their research<br />
article. This self-created rubric<br />
helps remind students what<br />
should be included in a wellwritten<br />
research article.<br />
2. Compare the Expected<br />
Outcome to the Work<br />
Produced<br />
With self-created rubrics in<br />
hand, students then monitor<br />
their progress by comparing<br />
what they have created to the<br />
expectation they have identified<br />
from the models. To make<br />
this step of the process more<br />
personal, the teacher reviews<br />
the rubric with students and<br />
instructs them to underline<br />
and circle key phrases in<br />
the rubric. Once this is<br />
completed, the students then<br />
go back and underline and<br />
circle evidence of each part<br />
of the rubric in their current<br />
draft. When the rubric calls<br />
for words to be paraphrased<br />
and cited correctly, students<br />
return to their papers, identify<br />
information that has been<br />
paraphrased and compare
what they have written to the<br />
expectation set by the rubric.<br />
3. Revise Work to Better<br />
Match the Expected Outcome<br />
Once students have been<br />
guided through the rubric and<br />
have compared their piece<br />
with the expected outcome,<br />
they then begin to revise<br />
their work. In the case of the<br />
research article, students return<br />
to their paraphrased sections<br />
and begin re-writing them to<br />
better match the expected<br />
outcome identified by the<br />
rubric. By pinpointing only<br />
the paraphrased selections,<br />
students are less likely to be<br />
overwhelmed by the revision<br />
process. To continue revising<br />
the next day, the teacher<br />
returns to the rubric to guide<br />
students through the revision<br />
of the article by addressing the<br />
tone of the piece.<br />
4. Reflect on the Process<br />
As Luanne Kowalke writes in<br />
Methods that Matter, “To make<br />
sure that children become intelligent,<br />
insightful, educated human<br />
beings, we educators must<br />
help them become conscious of<br />
their own learning and thought<br />
process. Instead of teaching<br />
students what to think, we need<br />
to teach them how to think and<br />
how to think for themselves.”<br />
(234) At this stage of the Self-<br />
Assessment Process, students<br />
reflect back on each step of the<br />
creative process and compare<br />
it to the final work they have<br />
completed. After completing the<br />
research article, students then<br />
turn in a companion reflection<br />
that addresses each part of the<br />
rubric and the overall quality<br />
of the work submitted. It is important<br />
to note that having students<br />
assign a personal grade<br />
is not really the purpose—<br />
gaining an understanding of<br />
how they worked through the<br />
process is the overall goal.<br />
Examples of Student Self-<br />
Assessment:<br />
Writer’s Logs: At the end of<br />
each class period, students<br />
reflect on an assigned piece of<br />
writing. By modeling students’<br />
logs that truly exemplify<br />
reflection compared to logs<br />
that simply summarize what<br />
was done in class helps guide<br />
students to reflecting on their<br />
writing in a more authentic way.<br />
The log also assists the teacher<br />
in designing mini-lessons<br />
that directly relate to studentidentified<br />
needs.<br />
Reflection Letters: At the end<br />
of a writing piece, students<br />
reflect on the strengths,<br />
weaknesses and process used<br />
during the writing process.<br />
This letter is turned in as a<br />
companion to the final draft.<br />
This letter should be read<br />
before grading the piece to help<br />
guide revision suggestions and<br />
provide productive feedback.<br />
Discussion Rubric: After<br />
modeling the expectation for a<br />
class or small group discussion,<br />
students work collaboratively<br />
to create a rubric that shows<br />
evidence of a thoughtful<br />
discussion. Students refer<br />
to the rubric throughout the<br />
discussion to stay on task and<br />
work toward the established<br />
purpose of the discussion.<br />
Once the discussion concludes,<br />
students reflect on both the<br />
process and content of the<br />
discussion.<br />
Secondary Literacy<br />
NEWSTALK<br />
“While no single word you<br />
teach is likely to have the<br />
life-changing effect that<br />
learning water did for Helen<br />
Keller, each word students<br />
learn will expand the limits<br />
of their minds.”<br />
Teaching Individual<br />
Words…Michael Graves<br />
SN<strong>RPDP</strong> Secondary Literacy<br />
is looking forward to two great<br />
summer institutes. This year we<br />
are hosting two summer institutes<br />
– McMillan Elementary School in<br />
the Northwest Region and Nate<br />
Mack Elementary School in the<br />
Southeast Region. Both locations<br />
are open to all Clark County School<br />
District teachers. All participants<br />
have the opportunity to earn up to<br />
two UNLV graduate credits, at a<br />
discounted rate, in less than one<br />
week.<br />
A great new book to put on your<br />
bookshelf is Teaching Individual<br />
Words...One Size Does Not<br />
Fit All by Michael Graves. This<br />
new text is a helpful tool for<br />
understanding the importance of<br />
vocabulary development, but also<br />
is extremely insightful in promoting<br />
best practices in vocabulary<br />
development with extensions<br />
for parental involvement. This<br />
would be a great addition to your<br />
professional library.<br />
<strong>RPDP</strong> Secondary Literacy has<br />
exemplary resources and classes<br />
to offer to assist all content<br />
teachers with reading and writing<br />
strategies. If you are interested in<br />
workshops, UNLV graduate credit<br />
classes or on-site trainings, please<br />
feel free to contact Saralyn Lasley,<br />
Amy Raymer or Rosanne Richards<br />
at 799-3835.
Teacher Highlights<br />
Secondary Literacy<br />
Elementary Math<br />
Thomasina Rose<br />
Swainston Middle School<br />
English 6-8<br />
Thomasina Rose is truly a motivating and<br />
positive role model to students. Thomasina<br />
sets the pace for proficiency at Swainston<br />
Middle School. Ms. Rose is currently an eighth<br />
grade English teacher, but also has taught<br />
reading and secondary study skills. Thomasina<br />
has worked in education since 1994 in many<br />
different fields. Before becoming a classroom<br />
teacher, Thomasina worked as an adjunct<br />
professor, an academic counselor and a<br />
director of education for the private sector.<br />
Thomasina brings to the classroom a plethora<br />
of experiences and her students have gained a<br />
wealth of knowledge from her background.<br />
Thomasina sums up her success with this,<br />
“Teaching is the profession that teaches all<br />
the other professions and I give thanks to my<br />
colleagues for making everyday a joyful day.”<br />
Thank you, Thomasina, for the expertise<br />
and dedication you give to Swainston Middle<br />
School. Thomasina truly shines in the<br />
classroom!<br />
Carol Laidlaw<br />
Manch Elementary School<br />
5th Grade<br />
Thirty-two years ago Carol Laidlaw began<br />
teaching and is still touching the lives of young<br />
children today. She began her career in Arizona<br />
and has taught in CCSD for the past 26 years.<br />
Carol has experience teaching grades 3-6<br />
and is currently teaching fifth grade at Manch<br />
Elementary School.<br />
As a math teacher Carol was a late starter.<br />
It wasn’t until she was introduced to the<br />
Investigations© math program that her teaching<br />
of math was turned around. She approaches<br />
the teaching of math with the thoughts from<br />
Investigations© no matter what math program<br />
is being used at her school. She also feels<br />
that there is no better way to introduce a<br />
mathematical concept than through guided<br />
discovery.<br />
Carol’s greatest teaching accomplishment was<br />
when she ran into a former student who told her<br />
that he would soon be graduating from UNLV<br />
with a degree in electrical engineering. These<br />
are the moments that keep her believing in what<br />
she is doing on a daily basis in her classroom.<br />
Manch Elementary School and CCSD are<br />
very lucky to have such a hard working and<br />
dedicated teacher! Keep up the great work,<br />
Carol!
More Than Just<br />
Multiple Choice!<br />
by Kathy Dees<br />
The term “assessment” is defined in the NCTM Assessment<br />
Standards as “the process of gathering evidence about<br />
a student’s knowledge of, ability to use, and disposition<br />
toward mathematics and of making inferences from that<br />
evidence for a variety of purposes.” (NCTM,1995,p.3).<br />
Assessment can and should happen every<br />
day as an integral part of instruction. If one<br />
restricts their view of assessment to tests and<br />
quizzes they will miss seeing how assessment<br />
can inform instruction and help students grow.<br />
Several formative approaches that include<br />
performance-based tasks, writing, observations<br />
of students solving problems, and student<br />
diagnostic interviews.<br />
Performance-based tasks are good problem<br />
solving activities that are similar to the student’s<br />
current mathematics instruction. A task should<br />
promote learning and allow every student in the<br />
class to demonstrate their knowledge.<br />
Examples:<br />
Grades (K-1): Joseph has 5 cookies, Maria<br />
has 3, and Frankie has 4. They<br />
want to share them equally. How<br />
will they do it? Draw a picture to<br />
help explain your answer.<br />
Grades (3-5): Kate counted 15 sandwiches<br />
left from the whole batch that her<br />
mother made for the class party.<br />
Her mother asked, “If the students<br />
already ate two-fifths then how<br />
many sandwiches did I make?”<br />
Writing is both a learning and assessment tool<br />
in the mathematics classroom today. Having<br />
the students write about their own ideas in their<br />
own words can offer a chance for a teacher<br />
to assess their conceptual understanding.<br />
Writing can show evidence of student thinking<br />
more than a multiple choice test. Writing also<br />
provides a backup for students who have trouble<br />
verbalizing their mathematical understanding if<br />
they are encouraged to read entries to the class.<br />
Example:<br />
After you solved the problem today how<br />
were you sure you had the correct<br />
answer?<br />
Teachers can gather data about their students<br />
every day through observation. When teachers<br />
systematically record this information they<br />
can document mathematical understanding in<br />
such areas as problem solving, representation,<br />
reasoning, and communication. Depending<br />
upon the teacher’s style, there are several ways<br />
to record information. The teacher can keep<br />
anecdotal notes where cards for each individual<br />
student are taped on a flip chart or clip board<br />
and the teacher records observations for five<br />
students a day. An observation rubric can also<br />
be used to check for concept understanding<br />
for each student. A check list for the whole<br />
class can also be a quick way to gather data.<br />
All these methods can be used to guide the<br />
teacher’s instruction for both short and long term<br />
goals for mathematics instruction.<br />
During diagnostic interviews, the teacher<br />
gives the students a problem, and asks them<br />
to verbalize their thinking about the concept.<br />
The discussion should center on the concepts<br />
currently being taught in class. The teacher’s<br />
role is to ask questions to find out what students<br />
know and where they still have misconceptions.<br />
During these interviews, the teacher has the<br />
opportunity to redirect or reinforce the student’s<br />
thinking and their strategies.<br />
All these methods of formative assessment can<br />
measure a student’s understanding of concepts,<br />
procedures, and mathematical processes and<br />
can be used to guide instruction immediately<br />
and provide learning opportunities for students.<br />
Article: Leatham, K.R., Lawrence, K., &<br />
Mewborn, D. (2005). Getting started with<br />
open-ended assessment. Teaching Children<br />
Mathematics, 11(8), 413-419.
In this article, the definition of an open-ended<br />
assessment item includes the potential for a<br />
range of responses and a balance between too<br />
much and too little information given. Examples<br />
are included. The teacher-author (Lawrence)<br />
talks personally about getting started in her<br />
third-fourth grade class of “culturally and<br />
economically diverse” students and the values<br />
that accrued for both her and her class.<br />
T e a c h e r<br />
Highlight<br />
Secondary Math<br />
Books: Stenmark, J.K., & Bush, W. S. (EDS.)<br />
2001. Mathematics assessment: A practical<br />
handbook for grades 3-5. Reston, VA; NCTM.<br />
These three NCTM books are part of a K-12<br />
series on assessment. The handbooks offer<br />
practical advice for classroom teachers that are<br />
considerably beyond the scope of this chapter.<br />
The four chapters in each book essentially cover<br />
the kinds of assessment options that are best<br />
used, practical guidelines for implementing a<br />
quality assessment program in your classroom,<br />
and suggestions for dealing with the assessment<br />
data once gathered.<br />
Wright, R., Martland, J., & Stafford, A. (2006).<br />
Early numeracy: Assessment for teaching<br />
and intervention. London: Paul Chapman<br />
Educational Publishers.<br />
This book includes six diagnostic interviews<br />
for assessing young children’s knowledge<br />
and strategy use related to numbers and the<br />
operations of addition and subtraction. Using a<br />
series of frameworks the authors help teachers<br />
pinpoint students’ misconceptions and support<br />
appropriate interventions.<br />
Online resources: 20 Math Rubrics http://<br />
intranet.cps.k12.il.us/Assessments/Ideas_and_<br />
Rubrics/Rubric_Bank/MathRubrics.pdf<br />
Even though this site is maintained by the<br />
Chicago Public Schools’ Bureau of Assessment,<br />
you will find rubrics from many different states<br />
and national projects. Some are generic<br />
rubrics for problem solving, communication,<br />
and concept knowledge, but many have useful<br />
indicators and performance levels that can be<br />
adapted for many purposes.<br />
Sherry Pendelton<br />
Molasky Junior High School<br />
Math 6 th Grade<br />
This is Sherry Pendleton’s sixth year in CCSD<br />
after receiving her degree at UNLV. She taught<br />
science at Leavitt Middle School then moved<br />
to Molasky Junior High School. She currently<br />
teaches Math 6 and serves as the department chair.<br />
Sherry’s organized planning for instruction is evident<br />
in her strategies and use of instructional time for her<br />
classes. Her special talents include student engagement<br />
activities, specific and clear instructions, and super<br />
interactive notebooks. Her students are always busy.<br />
She organizes school-wide activities such as math camps<br />
and CRT projects. Sherry serves on the TEACH (Teacher<br />
Educational Achievement Consortium Herald) committee<br />
and is an ISP (Inclusive School Practices) coach.<br />
She loves being a teacher. Her inspiration comes from<br />
having a child who struggled in school. Each one of her<br />
students is someone else’s child and she cares for each<br />
one like she would her own; she models the <strong>RPDP</strong> ‘My<br />
Kid’ philosophy. Mrs. Pendleton provides students an<br />
atmosphere of high expectations, respect toward self and<br />
others, and safety from criticism, bullying, or put-downs.<br />
Sherry Pendleton is also recognized as an<br />
<strong>RPDP</strong> instructor for 6 th Grade Math Workshops<br />
including Applications in Data Analysis, Fractions,<br />
Decimals, Coordinate Graphing, and Geometry.
Technology’s Influence on<br />
Formative Assessment<br />
Assessment is an important<br />
part of any curriculum.<br />
Summative assessments<br />
are usually the first type<br />
of assessment that comes<br />
to one’s mind. This type of<br />
assessment which may be<br />
in the form of a test, quiz, or<br />
paper are used to assign some<br />
level of achievement. However,<br />
there is another type of<br />
assessment which sometimes<br />
is overlooked. This is called<br />
formative assessment.<br />
Formative assessments<br />
are used to check for<br />
comprehension and skills in<br />
order to guide instruction.<br />
Formative assessments can<br />
have the same format as<br />
summative assessments, but<br />
they may be shorter or simpler.<br />
Warm-up questions or a ticket<br />
out the door are examples<br />
of these. The increase of<br />
educational technology in<br />
the classroom has allowed<br />
formative assessments to be<br />
implemented in easier and<br />
more effective ways.<br />
The Quick Poll<br />
The TI-Navigator© is a very<br />
powerful wireless network<br />
system using computers that<br />
has many applications in the<br />
classroom. The quick poll is<br />
one of these applications that<br />
can be utilized for formative<br />
assessment. Students receive<br />
a question which can have<br />
many formats: true/false, fill in<br />
the blank, or multiple choice.<br />
The students answer the<br />
question on their calculators<br />
which are linked via hubs to<br />
the teacher’s computer. The<br />
computer displays the class<br />
answers in the form of a bar<br />
graph. When combined with an<br />
LCD projector, the results are<br />
even more impressive: students<br />
can answer a question and<br />
immediately see the results of<br />
the class up on the screen.<br />
With these results the teacher<br />
can decide the direction<br />
instruction should take. If<br />
the students did well on a<br />
particular type of question,<br />
then the teacher may feel<br />
that particular topic has been<br />
sufficiently covered and no<br />
further instruction is required.<br />
However, if the class as a<br />
whole did poorly, the teacher<br />
can immediately review the<br />
topic with his students.<br />
The quick poll is also versatile<br />
in its ability to measure various<br />
cognitive domains. It can be<br />
used for lower-level questions<br />
such as “What is the slope<br />
intercept form?” It can also<br />
be used to measure mid-level<br />
questions of an application<br />
nature; “Use the order of<br />
operations to evaluate the<br />
algebraic expression.” The<br />
applications of this technology<br />
are only limited by the<br />
imagination and ingenuity of the<br />
teacher.<br />
Student Whiteboards<br />
The TI-Navigator© is an<br />
effective tool, but with today’s<br />
dwindling budgets, it may<br />
not be an affordable choice.<br />
Another effective teaching tool,<br />
which is less expensive, is<br />
the student whiteboard. The<br />
teacher gives the students<br />
a question that they answer<br />
on their personal dry-erase<br />
whiteboard. These have<br />
some of the same benefits as<br />
more expensive technology:<br />
immediate feedback and<br />
increased engagement but at<br />
a fraction of the cost. Being<br />
able to see each students’ work<br />
on their whiteboards helps<br />
the teacher to immediately<br />
diagnose students’ particular<br />
errors or misunderstandings.<br />
Formative assessment is a<br />
critical component in every<br />
lesson. Utilizing technology can<br />
help make it easier and more<br />
immediate than ever before.<br />
by Zak Dray
Teacher Highlights<br />
Secondary Science<br />
Elementary Science<br />
Jenelle Hopkins<br />
Centennial High School<br />
Earth Science Teacher<br />
Cherri Luna<br />
Steven G. Schorr Elementary<br />
School<br />
Science Specialist 1 - 5<br />
Jenelle Hopkins started teaching for the Clark County<br />
School District in 1993 after working in industry as a<br />
mine geologist.In addition to being a super teacher at<br />
Centennial High School, she has been a leader in many<br />
professional organizations, including the Southern<br />
Nevada Science Teachers Association (SNSTA),<br />
Nevada State Science Teachers Association (NSSTA),<br />
and the National Science Teachers Association (NSTA),<br />
serving as past-president for both SNSTA and NSSTA.<br />
To hone her teaching skills and keeping abreast of the<br />
latest Earth Science research, Jenelle has participated<br />
in many professional development experiences,<br />
including a summer workshop in Costa Rica and two<br />
summers working as a Research Assistant at UNLV’s<br />
Engineering Geophysics Lab. In addition to teaching,<br />
Jenelle has worked as a Science Curriculum Specialist<br />
for CCSD and was an Albert Einstein Distinguished<br />
Educator, working for one school year as a Fellow<br />
in the Directorate for Geosciences at the National<br />
Science Foundation (NSF) in Washington, D.C. She<br />
currently is the education co-chair for the Nevada<br />
Earthquake Safety Council and a committee member<br />
for the Education and Outreach Steering Committee<br />
of the NSF Earthscope Program. She has been<br />
involved in revision of CCSD science curriculum, has<br />
written questions for the Nevada High School Science<br />
Proficiency Test and the GED, and has been on the<br />
College Board’s re-design commission for the AP<br />
environmental science exam. In 2007, Jenelle was<br />
selected by the American Geophysical Union to attend<br />
a climate change conference in Vienna, Austria. To cap<br />
things off, Jenelle became Nationally Board Certified<br />
in Earth Science at the Adolescence and Young<br />
Adulthood level.<br />
Currently she is an instructor for <strong>RPDP</strong> and also<br />
conducts Earth Science workshops where she shares<br />
the many different ideas and resources she has learned<br />
from her various workshop opportunities.<br />
This is Cherri’s 7 th year teaching in the Clark County<br />
School District, and her first year as a Science<br />
Specialist. Before she began discovering science with<br />
her kids this year, she taught first and third grades.<br />
She graduated from UNLV and received her Masters<br />
in Special Education from NOVA South Eastern<br />
University. Prior to UNLV her education specialized in<br />
Animal Science; she minored in Horse Science. She’s<br />
been happily married for over twenty years and is<br />
proud to have two very talented and wonderful children.<br />
Cherri has had many people influence her life in<br />
education. First and foremost, she has to consider her<br />
grandmother. Cherri describes her as “a wonderfully<br />
kind and patient woman who took the time to get to<br />
know everyone who has come into and out of her<br />
life.” Cherri is in awe of the blessings her grandmother<br />
counts daily, even at the ripe young age of 94. Most<br />
recently Cherri has to thank her daughter’s first and<br />
third grade teacher. She can remember helping out in<br />
the classroom, finding herself drawn into the excitement<br />
she had for learning, and how she was able to pass<br />
that love of learning to her students. One would be<br />
amazed, from the days of studying places like China<br />
and France to every bug, salamander, spider, rock and<br />
space theater – learning was an adventure. Cherri’s<br />
goal is to instill this love of learning to all her students.<br />
Although her family is number one on her list, the<br />
children she sees everyday are a very close second.<br />
The community she shares at Schorr Elementary<br />
School is very special. She enjoys every part of<br />
her life there; starting with greeting everyone at the<br />
door, discovering the wonders of science, getting her<br />
hands dirty, sitting on the floor reading a great book,<br />
investigating, asking questions and listening to the<br />
ideas of her students, watching the expressions on<br />
their faces as the “light-bulb” goes on in their heads – “I<br />
get it!”, and closing her day with a “Thanks Mrs. Luna,<br />
hope you have a great day!”<br />
Life is good and Cherri feels very fortunate to be able to<br />
spend her days doing what she enjoys - discovering the<br />
wonders of learning with her students.
Formative Assessment in<br />
Elementary Science<br />
When you hear the word “formative”<br />
assessment, does the thought of portfolio<br />
management come to mind? How about<br />
checklists that get shuffled around the top<br />
of your desk, or the backseat of your car<br />
because you just can’t figure out what to do<br />
with the information that you’ve gathered? It<br />
doesn’t have to be that way! By spending<br />
some time with your students, asking some<br />
thought-provoking questions, and listening to<br />
them talk about what they are doing in class,<br />
you can gain a very clear picture about what<br />
your students understand.<br />
Assessment “for” learning vs. assessment<br />
“of” learning - the distinction between the two<br />
is pivotal. Assessment for learning happens<br />
while learning is still underway. It isn’t about<br />
grades, but about getting better. “Effective<br />
use of formative assessment includes using<br />
assessment results to plan instruction, using<br />
assessment information and materials to<br />
involve students in their own assessment,<br />
and communicating assessment results<br />
clearly and in a way tailored to the user’s<br />
needs.” (Stiggins et al., 2004, 2006)<br />
According to Stiggins et al., the student’s role<br />
in formative assessment is to self-assess<br />
and keep track of progress, set goals, and<br />
act on assessment results. “Self-assessment<br />
by pupils, far from being a luxury, is in<br />
fact an essential component of formative<br />
assessment.” (Black & William, 1998)<br />
Something as seemingly simple as having<br />
students restate the problem or the question<br />
can lead to creativity and self-confidence.<br />
By allowing our students to talk about their<br />
solutions or their thoughts, by allowing them<br />
to talk with others, and even more powerful, if<br />
they can spend time talking with their teacher,<br />
students get immediate feedback and make<br />
connections that will in turn, facilitate future<br />
decision making.<br />
Science notebooks can be a part of ongoing<br />
formative assessment in the classroom.<br />
The writing contained in these notebooks<br />
can allow the teacher to see what students<br />
understand, how they approach problem<br />
solving, and what misconceptions they<br />
have. Before you start thinking that the use<br />
of notebooks in class means yet another<br />
thing for you to grade, they aren’t for that<br />
purpose. Formative assessment is not to<br />
be graded, but for getting better, remember?<br />
Science notebooks are more likely to be a<br />
learning tool if students feel safe to express<br />
what they know and to show how they know.<br />
When students are actively engaged in<br />
using notebooks, these notebooks have an<br />
important role in improving expository writing,<br />
vocabulary development, understanding the<br />
nature of science and math, and improving<br />
student learning and achievement. That’s a<br />
lot of bang for a small notebook.<br />
Based on brain research, teachers may be<br />
accidentally impeding thinking, intelligence<br />
and brain growth, and ultimately creating<br />
“slow learners” by the lack of feedback and<br />
the large lag time we have built into the<br />
typical learning environment. How often do<br />
classroom teachers meet with students and<br />
actually spend time talking with them? A<br />
conversation with students could be a handy<br />
proactive tool instead of being faced with<br />
re-teaching after discovering that half of the<br />
class can’t apply the math concepts needed<br />
for the constructed response.<br />
When students talk deliberately, purposefully,<br />
and perceptively, learning and thinking<br />
increase dramatically. The better the<br />
quality of the questions that we ask our<br />
students, the more their brain is challenged<br />
to think. A challenge to think should bring<br />
about disequilibrium – when we are feeling<br />
perplexed or unsure or even confused about
what we thought to be true – this is the time<br />
that the brain is motivated to make sense of<br />
the experience.<br />
This is also the most opportune time for<br />
learning! The more aware we are of how<br />
children think, the more likely we are to<br />
provide the kind of experiences that support<br />
their search for meaning and understanding.<br />
We can’t force children to understand, but<br />
through effective questioning and providing<br />
meaningful experiences, we can get them<br />
engaged. The key is to get students to think,<br />
and according to Ernest Dimnet, “Education<br />
is the methodical creation of the habit of<br />
thinking.”<br />
“Kids’ views are often just<br />
as valid as the teacher’s.<br />
The best teachers are the<br />
ones that know that.”<br />
Morley Safer<br />
As the “gatherer of information” in our<br />
classrooms, we should strive to uncover the<br />
thinking behind the answers. As educators<br />
we miss out on a huge opportunity for<br />
learning by not taking the time to diagnose<br />
the so-called wrong answers. How would<br />
our classrooms look and sound if we allowed<br />
learners to work in groups to self-assess<br />
their tests, and let them formulate their own<br />
rules for understanding information? Our<br />
challenge is to maximize learning without<br />
interfering with the child’s sense-making<br />
process.<br />
what children really know and understand,<br />
not just whether they have learned to follow<br />
directions. When teachers allow children<br />
to make sense of a task, they are actively<br />
engaged and thinking in a way that would<br />
not happen when they are directed through a<br />
task.<br />
Understanding means we make connections<br />
and see relationships. We “get it.” If teachers<br />
take the time to observe students and ask<br />
questions of them to find out what they<br />
understand, we will become aware that what<br />
is obvious to us is not always obvious to<br />
students. As it is for all learners, children<br />
must construct understanding for themselves.<br />
They must be allowed to go through the<br />
process of “getting it”.<br />
References<br />
Jensen, E (1995). Brain-based Learning and<br />
Teaching. Turning Point Publishing: Del Mar,<br />
CA<br />
Richardson, K (1997). Math Time: The<br />
Learning Environment. Educational<br />
Enrichment: Norman, OK.<br />
Stiggins, R; Arter, J; Chappuis, J and<br />
Chappuis, S (2004, 2006). Classroom<br />
Assessment for Student Learning Doing<br />
It Right-Using It Well . Educational Testing<br />
Service: Portland, OR.<br />
by Cathy Trahan<br />
According to Kathy Richardson (1997), when<br />
our focus is on how children perform rather<br />
than their understanding, we tend to simply<br />
teach children what to say or what to do;<br />
the long division algorithm comes to mind!<br />
We create illusions of learning that we often<br />
view as success but that in fact hide the lack<br />
of understanding. If we truly want to teach<br />
for understanding, then we need to know
Getting Students to Think<br />
Scientifically: Concept<br />
Mapping and Interactive<br />
Notebooks<br />
by Doug Lombardi<br />
For deep learning of scientific concepts,<br />
students must develop the abilities to<br />
understand and monitor what they do and<br />
do not know. In other words, we must teach<br />
students to think about their thinking, an<br />
idea that is commonly called metacognition.<br />
When students engage in metacognition, they<br />
are self-assessing their understanding. But<br />
teaching metacognitive knowledge (What have<br />
I learned?) and monitoring (How can I assess<br />
what I have learned?) must not occur as an<br />
independent exercise; there is far too much<br />
content that our students must know in order to<br />
gain scientific literacy and successfully achieve.<br />
It is critical that the student self-assessment be<br />
embedded within the science content we teach.<br />
The good news is that we can inject learning<br />
about metacognition into our science lessons<br />
with some simple, but effective, instructional<br />
strategies.<br />
Scientific Reasoning<br />
In our science classes, we must increase<br />
metacognitive awareness of scientific reasoning.<br />
Specifically, we need to get our students to think<br />
like a scientist. But how do scientists think and<br />
reason?<br />
Scientists are essentially experts in solving<br />
problems. Of course, solving problems is<br />
not unique to science, but scientists tend to<br />
approach problem solving using a framework<br />
for thinking. Furthermore, this framework is<br />
centered on fundamental scientific principles.<br />
For example, when considering a force and<br />
motion problem, a scientist would first think<br />
about the relevance of Newton’s Laws and their<br />
connection to understanding how objects move<br />
and react. On the other hand, students would<br />
tend to solve the problem by first finding the<br />
right equations (e.g., F = ma) and then figuring<br />
out how they could use the equation to get an<br />
answer (Anzai, 1991). Essentially, scientists<br />
solve problems by organizing their thinking<br />
around the Big Ideas that dominate their areas<br />
of research, whereas students solve problems<br />
based on superficial information.<br />
Organizing Thinking Around the Big<br />
Ideas of Science<br />
If we want to move students towards organizing<br />
their thinking around the big ideas of science,<br />
they need strategies to help them with their<br />
metacognitive understanding and monitoring.<br />
Two effective strategies are the use of concept<br />
mapping and interactive science notebooks.<br />
Concept Mapping<br />
Concept mapping can be used often during the<br />
course of the school year as a way for students<br />
to preview, review, and assess their conceptual<br />
understanding. Furthermore, concept mapping<br />
is an excellent tool for students to gauge how<br />
these concepts are linked with big science<br />
ideas. Within the first few days of school,<br />
students should experience concept mapping<br />
by reviewing the major concepts they have<br />
learned in previous years. For example, in the<br />
Clark County School District, most high school<br />
freshmen are enrolled in Principles of Science.<br />
Employing concept mapping at the beginning<br />
of the year will allow students to explore the<br />
connections between the big ideas they have<br />
learned in middle school life, Earth, and physical<br />
science. The figure below is a simple example<br />
showing how the big science idea of energy is<br />
linked to within these content areas.<br />
The concept map shown above is really a web,<br />
with the central idea in the center. To develop
this format, concept words are given to the<br />
students with the following instructions.<br />
1. Link the concept words in a reasonable and<br />
sensible matter.<br />
2. Put a circle around the concept word<br />
3. Provide a one or two sentence description<br />
that shows how the two concepts are<br />
linked.<br />
4. The linked sentences should contain<br />
the two concept words that are being<br />
connected.<br />
5. The map should be scored on the quality of<br />
the link description<br />
a. Detailed and correct link description<br />
that is evident of deep understanding (2<br />
points)<br />
b. Shallow (superficial) and correct link<br />
description that is evident of partial<br />
understanding (1 point)<br />
c. Incorrect description (0 point)<br />
These instructions are very simple, but<br />
encourage students to generate as many<br />
descriptive and accurate links as possible. Note,<br />
the focus here is on the connection, not the<br />
concept word, which is given to the students.<br />
There is no upper limit to the number of points<br />
students can get on this activity, which motivates<br />
students to create more links. These maps can<br />
be graded on a criterion scale that is based on<br />
the number of content words. For example, if<br />
20 concept words are included, an excellent<br />
concept map would include at least 20 detailed<br />
and correct links (40 points).<br />
In a preview or review scenario, concept<br />
mapping may be facilitated by students working<br />
in groups of two or three. This encourages<br />
students to think aloud as they discuss linkages<br />
between concepts. Also, the teacher acts as the<br />
role of the coach by circulating around the room,<br />
asking students to provided reasoning for their<br />
links, and providing cues to help them achieve<br />
a deeper level of processing. Students can<br />
prepare their maps on large poster size pieces<br />
of paper, which allows the entire group to be<br />
engaged in the activity.<br />
Ultimately, as concept mapping is used<br />
frequently throughout the school year, students<br />
develop the organization skills, which help<br />
the students’ metacognitive knowledge. The<br />
concept map also serves as a way to monitor<br />
this metacognitive organizational process. In this<br />
way, students are self-assessing their overall<br />
understanding of science.<br />
Interactive Science Notebooks<br />
Metacognitive knowledge and monitoring<br />
can also be developed through interactive<br />
note taking, particularly by helping students<br />
with “real-time” organization of information<br />
presented during class time. The interactive<br />
science notebook organizes science knowledge<br />
in three parts labeled, the (a) IN question, (b)<br />
THROUGH section, and (c) OUT question.<br />
More details about these sections and how to<br />
implement interactive science notebooks are<br />
found in Volume 2, Issue 2 of <strong>RPDP</strong>’s Science<br />
Dissected Newsletter. This particular newsletter<br />
was written by <strong>RPDP</strong> Regional Science Trainer,<br />
Bret Sibley, and is found at http://rpdp.net/adm/<br />
uploads.news/sciencedis/57v2i2SDInteractiveSc<br />
ienceNotebooks.pdf.<br />
Building Success on Success<br />
Using concept mapping and interactive science<br />
notebooks require initial time for training at<br />
the beginning of the school year. But such<br />
investments in time pay huge dividends later<br />
when students begin to reason scientifically by<br />
actively organizing their knowledge in a way that<br />
help them solve problems in a more efficient<br />
and accurate manner. Taking this initial time to<br />
build success on success will motivate students<br />
to engage in metacognitive processes that will<br />
deepen their understanding of science content<br />
and increase their achievement in science,<br />
especially if concept mapping and interactive<br />
notebooks are embedded within the concepts<br />
being taught.<br />
Reference<br />
Anzai, Y. (1991). Learning and use of<br />
representations for physics expertise. In K. A.<br />
Anders & J. Smith (Eds.), Toward a general<br />
theory of expertise (pp. 64-92). New York:<br />
Cambridge University Press.
Professional<br />
Development<br />
Secondary Literacy<br />
• Literacy in the Content Areas (4-12)<br />
• Effective Strategies to Teach Vocabulary<br />
(K-12)<br />
• Reading Comprehension (4-12)<br />
• Brain Compatible Learning Strategies<br />
(K-12)<br />
• Strategies to Reach All Learners (6-12)<br />
• Curriculum Mapping (Open to Reading &<br />
English Teachers Only)<br />
*************************************************************************<br />
Secondary Math<br />
• Introduction to TI-83/84<br />
• Intermediate TI - 83/84<br />
*************************************************************************<br />
Elementary Science<br />
• K-2 Science and Literacy<br />
• 3-5 Science and Literacy<br />
• Introduction to Science Notebooks K-5<br />
*************************************************************************<br />
Elementay Math<br />
• Mental Math and Algorithms<br />
• Connecting the Math Strands K-2<br />
• Connecting the Math Strands 3 - 5<br />
******************************************************<br />
Elementary Literacy<br />
• Words Their Way<br />
• K-1 Literacy Centers<br />
• State Writing Assessment<br />
• Literacy Stations 3-5<br />
• Small Group Instruction<br />
Offerings<br />
Summer<br />
Technology<br />
• Power Point Basics<br />
• Photoshop Elements<br />
• Computer Bonanza<br />
• Adobe Acrobat<br />
• The Making and Watching of Multimedia<br />
Visual Recordings<br />
• The Diverse World of iPOD<br />
• Internet Activities<br />
• Microsoft Office: Course I<br />
• Microsoft Office: Course II<br />
• Microsoft Office: Course III<br />
• Macromedia Fireworks<br />
• Macromedia Flash<br />
• Integration with Productivity Programs<br />
• Methods and Teaching the Integration of<br />
Technology with Curriculum<br />
• Internet Resources<br />
• Desktop Publishing<br />
• Web Design<br />
• Macromedia Dreamweaver I<br />
• Macromedia Dreamweaver II<br />
• Design and Application of Technology<br />
Applications<br />
• Handheld Technologies<br />
• Document Management<br />
• The Electronic Environment<br />
• Creating Video Tutorials<br />
• Video and Audio Editing<br />
• K-12 Classroom Technology Strategies<br />
Visit the <strong>RPDP</strong> website (rpdp.net) to view<br />
the <strong>RPDP</strong> course catalogs and register online.