Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
2<br />
FOODNEWS THAILAND January, <strong>2006</strong>
FOODNEWS THAILAND January, <strong>2006</strong><br />
Thai<br />
focus<br />
Hungry?<br />
Yes, Siam!<br />
If you travel along any major boulevard<br />
in Europe where restaurants are found,<br />
there will be a good chance that one of<br />
them will house Thai cuisine. The last 10<br />
years have seen a huge increase in the<br />
number of Thai restaurants. Even local<br />
pubs in Britain serve Thai food.<br />
Bordering Cambodia, Myanmar, Laos<br />
and Malaysia, <strong>Thailand</strong> has 3 220 kilometres<br />
of coastline and possesses an ideal topography<br />
and climate for food growing. Blessed<br />
with large expanses of fertile land and ideal<br />
growing conditions <strong>Thailand</strong> enjoys the status<br />
of being agriculturally self-sufficient,<br />
being the only net exporter of food in Asia<br />
and eighth biggest exporter (in terms of revenue)<br />
of food in the world. It is the world’s<br />
largest exporter of canned pineapple, secondlargest<br />
seafood exporter and the world’s foremost<br />
tapioca and rice exporter.<br />
<strong>Thailand</strong> has 66 million inhabitants, GDP<br />
growth of 4.8% and its exports goods and<br />
services fuel the economy (exports accounted<br />
for 66.3% of GDP in 2001 compared with<br />
23% in 1984). The agricultural sector has<br />
long been the country’s backbone, generating<br />
food and income for Thai people. Before<br />
the manufacturing industry began to play a<br />
leading role in the Thai economy in the late<br />
1970s, the agricultural sector generated<br />
almost 100% of the country’s export income.<br />
Thai agricultural production constitutes<br />
Company<br />
Page No<br />
Champaca Co., Ltd. 17<br />
Doi Kham <strong>Food</strong> Products Co., Ltd. 2<br />
Exotic <strong>Food</strong> 7<br />
<strong>Food</strong> and Drinks Public Company Limited 5<br />
Hiwa Rotterdam Port Cold Stores 9<br />
Itohwen & Co., Ltd. 19<br />
JFC Enterprise Co., Ltd. 19<br />
Malinee <strong>Food</strong> Products Co., Ltd. 9<br />
Prunesco 15<br />
River Kwai International <strong>Food</strong> <strong>Industry</strong> Co., Ltd. 1<br />
Advertisers’ Index<br />
14.12% of the country’s total exports (in<br />
value terms) and provides employment to<br />
some 20 million people. Conversely though,<br />
as the level of its food exports grows, its contribution<br />
to the gross domestic product<br />
declines due to the rapid expansion of other<br />
sectors of the economy. The food industry<br />
will continue to play a crucial role in the<br />
Thai economy because it consumes very little<br />
foreign capital and contributes greatly to<br />
foreign earnings.<br />
Productivity has increased as has public<br />
and private investment enabling the expansion<br />
of trade in Thai produce in global markets.<br />
It also showed its importance to the<br />
economy as a whole in its response to the<br />
1997 financial and economic crises. Exports<br />
of rice, shrimp, poultry and corn all significantly<br />
increased following the crisis.<br />
The sector’s dynamism and importance<br />
have prompted a high level of government<br />
interest and participation. The Thai government<br />
has responded swiftly over the past few<br />
years to issues related to food safety and the<br />
need to diversify. <strong>Thailand</strong> is ripe for agrobusiness<br />
investment. The combination of<br />
quality, popular and safe raw materials, the<br />
long history and experience found in<br />
<strong>Thailand</strong> and the ability of the food sector to<br />
respond to global trends and needs point to<br />
the fact that this is a country deserving of the<br />
global food community’s attention.<br />
Sea Value Co., Ltd. 12 & 13<br />
Shaanxi Haisheng Fresh Fruit Juice Co., Ltd. 7<br />
Siam Fruit Canning (1988) Co., LTD. 15<br />
Stutzer & Co. AG Switzerland 19<br />
Surapon <strong>Food</strong>s Public Company Limited 9<br />
Thai Bonanza International Co. Ltd. 17<br />
Trisun (Israel) Ltd. 7<br />
Tuna and Fishes Limited 17<br />
Tuna <strong>2006</strong> 2<br />
Viriyah <strong>Food</strong> Processing Co., Ltd. 15<br />
Xiamen Kingstar Imp & Exp Co., Ltd. 9<br />
Editor: Neil Murray<br />
Chief Reporter: Kath Miller<br />
Specialist Reporters:<br />
Eugenie Bryan<br />
Richard Simpson<br />
Robert Songer<br />
Advertisement Manager:<br />
Vicky Drinkwater<br />
Advertisement Assistant: Helen Davies<br />
Market Prices: Matthew Pendered<br />
Managing Director: Michael Hobbs<br />
Contents<br />
■ Set the juice loose: <strong>Thailand</strong>’s<br />
main contribution to the world’s<br />
portfolio of fruit juices is pineapple,<br />
of which it is the globe’s leading<br />
producer. However, processors are<br />
finding it difficult to obtain the<br />
prices they want ..............................6<br />
■ The big fish in the sea: canned<br />
tuna prices rise and fall according<br />
to the quantity of the catch, but<br />
there seems to be no slowing in<br />
global demand................................14<br />
■ Sweetness weakness: the soaring<br />
price of sugar (and other key<br />
inputs) is proving a headache for<br />
canned fruit producers .................16<br />
■ The seeds of doubt: Exports of<br />
Thai canned sweet corn rose again<br />
in 2005, and are now almost four<br />
times higher than they were at the<br />
start of the decade, but poor weather<br />
has hurt production..................22<br />
FOODNEWS<br />
80 Calverley Road, Tunbridge Wells,<br />
Kent TN1 2UN, UK.<br />
Phone: +44 (0) 207 017 7495<br />
Fax: +44 (0) 207 017 7592<br />
E-mail: fneditorial@agra-net.com<br />
www.agra-net.com<br />
© FOODNEWS <strong>2006</strong>. All rights reserved. No<br />
part of this publication may be reproduced or<br />
transmitted in any form or by any means without<br />
the written permission of the publisher. Registered<br />
Trade Mark: FOODNEWS ® . Informa<br />
Group plc.<br />
Advertising in FOODNEWS and <strong>Food</strong>news supplements is<br />
accepted on condition that the advertiser will indemnify the<br />
company from any claims or actions arising from the appearance<br />
of an advertisement. Printed by Fleet Litho (Kent) Ltd.<br />
Supplement to FOODNEWS®<br />
This report was written and researched by Global Business Reports.<br />
For further information please contact info@gbreports.com<br />
3
FOODNEWS THAILAND January, <strong>2006</strong><br />
Thai<br />
focus<br />
The past 20 years have seen rapid changes<br />
and growth in the Thai food industry, especially<br />
in the processed, value added and finished<br />
sectors. The 1997-1998 Asian financial<br />
crisis presented setbacks for those producers<br />
who relied on imports and the domestic market.<br />
However, this period also presented a<br />
good opportunity for those with low foreign<br />
debt, high exports and foreign currency<br />
inflows. While their wage bill and local costs<br />
dropped, their foreign income provided them<br />
with healthier than usual margins. With the<br />
focus placed on food safety and standards,<br />
coupled with <strong>Thailand</strong>’s abundance of raw<br />
materials from local producers (<strong>Thailand</strong>,<br />
being the region’s only net exporter, enjoys<br />
the capability to produce more than it can<br />
consume) and government initiatives such<br />
as, ‘Kitchen of the World’ the future looks<br />
very good for <strong>Thailand</strong>’s food processors.<br />
At the same time there is also a need for<br />
<strong>Thailand</strong>’s food processors to import certain<br />
food ingredients that are unavailable domestically.<br />
The value of these imports in 2000<br />
was estimated at around US$1.5 billion<br />
(Agri-culture and Agri-food Canada<br />
http://atn-riae.agr.ca/asean/e3021.htm).<br />
<strong>Thailand</strong> itself is one of the leading food<br />
processing nations of the world, with over<br />
10 000 food manufacturing companies. Of<br />
these, 96% are SMEs (small and mediumsized<br />
enterprises) who (in the past) were<br />
geared to serving the domestic market. With<br />
annual exports totalling around US$10 billion,<br />
<strong>Thailand</strong>’s world share of the global<br />
food trade (as estimated by FAO – <strong>Food</strong> and<br />
Agriculture Organisation in 1998) was<br />
around 0.2%, which at the turn of the century<br />
was estimated at US$5.5 trillion.<br />
<strong>Thailand</strong>’s share in world food export had,<br />
by 2001, risen (according to The National<br />
<strong>Food</strong> Institute) to 2.28%.<br />
<strong>Thailand</strong> itself is still home to some<br />
colossal firms including Boonrawd Trading,<br />
the Charoen Pokphand (CP) Group, Thai<br />
Union and Bangkok Produce, to name a few.<br />
However, the sales revenues of these companies<br />
compared to some of their global colleagues<br />
still remain as yet modest. For<br />
instance, in 1999 the profits of Nestlé<br />
amounted to 97 times that of the most profitable<br />
Thai food company.<br />
The major markets for Thai food exports<br />
are Japan and the ASEAN countries, closely<br />
followed by the US and EU. The Middle East<br />
and Africa also constitute 10% of the export<br />
markets for the Thai producers. There are<br />
myriad reasons for this, from tariffs and<br />
duties to GSP status and anti-dumping measures<br />
in various sectors.<br />
In terms of the export structure of<br />
<strong>Thailand</strong>’s food industry in recent years, the<br />
export statistics, commodity by commodity,<br />
show that fisheries are a crucial component<br />
of Thai food exports.<br />
<strong>Thailand</strong>’s advantages<br />
It would seem an extremely pertinent<br />
question to ask ‘Why is <strong>Thailand</strong> the only net<br />
<strong>Food</strong> exporter in Asia?’ Many of its south<br />
east Asian neighbours enjoy the same climate<br />
that makes <strong>Thailand</strong>’s claim to be the<br />
‘food basket of Asia’ possible. All the rice<br />
paddies in south east Asia are well suited to<br />
the regions annual monsoons, not just those<br />
in <strong>Thailand</strong>. One is able to grow the same<br />
variety and multitude of tropical treats in,<br />
say, Vietnam as one can in <strong>Thailand</strong>. The<br />
answer is multi faceted and complex but can<br />
be answered nonetheless.<br />
Regional competition between all the<br />
Asian and, more specifically, south east<br />
Asian countries has always been fierce and<br />
has a long and colourful history.<br />
In terms of the food industry these tensions<br />
and a sense of regional competition are<br />
still keenly apparent. In terms of rice production,<br />
Asia is responsible for nearly 90% of<br />
global output and consumption, 50% of<br />
imports and 72% of exports. In shrimp production<br />
both Indonesia and Vietnam are in<br />
the top six global producers along with<br />
<strong>Thailand</strong>.<br />
Importance of food safety<br />
But there exist several factors that allow<br />
<strong>Thailand</strong>, as opposed its neighbours, to<br />
maintain its current exalted position in the<br />
global food market. But also present are possible<br />
indicators of why this may not continue<br />
to be the case forever.<br />
Steven Chia-Apar of Seafresh, one of the<br />
leading groups in the Thai <strong>Food</strong> industry<br />
explains: “One obvious advantage possessed<br />
by Thai food companies over their Asian<br />
counterparts is that of food safety”. This<br />
statement, by one of the leading figures of<br />
the Thai <strong>Food</strong> industry, highlights the one<br />
obvious advantage possessed by Thai food<br />
companies over their Asian counterparts:<br />
food safety.<br />
The government’s emphasis on food safety<br />
is illustrated by the measures put in place<br />
in 2003 and by making 2004 ‘<strong>Food</strong> Safety<br />
Year’. Strategies involved the reduction of<br />
chemical use and promotion of hygienic conditions<br />
and looking at the improvement of<br />
soil quality. The government’s food and drug<br />
administration has since 2003 enforced the<br />
law on good manufacturing practice or GMP.<br />
In effect <strong>Thailand</strong> has utilised the principles<br />
of GMP to raise the manufacturing standards<br />
to international levels.<br />
This is not a uniquely government-led initiative<br />
though. The private sector has realised<br />
the importance of reaching internationally<br />
recognised safety standards to make them<br />
attractive to overseas investors and multinational<br />
companies and, as a rule, today the<br />
vast majority of Thai food processing companies<br />
are in compliance with the host of<br />
international standards, for example HACCP,<br />
BRC, the ISO, essentially, the ones needed to<br />
export across the globe.<br />
The seafood sector illustrates the attention<br />
and focus brought upon food safety standards.<br />
The code of conduct for food safety in<br />
the shrimp sector was drawn up as long ago<br />
as 1999 by five organisations: the department<br />
of Fisheries, the Thai Frozen <strong>Food</strong>s<br />
Association, the Thai <strong>Food</strong> Processors association<br />
and the Aquaculture business club.<br />
The rules and regulations that concerned<br />
shrimp health management, waste management<br />
and the application of drugs and chemicals<br />
were enforced and confirm the importance<br />
of international sanitary and phytosanitary<br />
(SPS) standards.<br />
That <strong>Thailand</strong> is the world’s largest<br />
exporter of canned tuna, and competes well<br />
in the US market with a 60% share, indicates<br />
not only efficient production, but also a high<br />
quality safety standard.<br />
This emphasis on food safety increased<br />
after 2000 when Egypt placed a ban on<br />
canned Tuna imports from <strong>Thailand</strong> due to<br />
the presence of genetically modified soybean<br />
4
FOODNEWS THAILAND January, <strong>2006</strong><br />
Thai<br />
focus<br />
oil in the cans. Thai companies showed their<br />
flexibility by substituting sunflower oil for<br />
the offending GM oil.<br />
It costs roughly US$10 000 for a firm to<br />
obtain the ISO900 safety certificate, yet,<br />
within three years of its creation over 70% of<br />
firms in <strong>Thailand</strong> had obtained it.<br />
Thai tuna canning companies realised<br />
that by attaining high quality standards, they<br />
can differentiate themselves and their products<br />
from their competitors and overcome<br />
any cost disadvantage that may exist due to<br />
tariff barriers. As with the rice industry, it is<br />
also an admission that consumers are willing<br />
to pay slightly higher prices for safer and<br />
higher quality products.<br />
However, there exists another school of<br />
thought that suggests that the government’s<br />
focus on the food industry has more to do<br />
with clever marketing, as seen with the<br />
‘Kitchen of the World’ scheme, than any<br />
massive focus on improving food safety. Soh<br />
Chee Yong of Ice-Cremo says. “I am glad<br />
that the government has taken such an active<br />
role in promoting Thai food around the<br />
globe”. And whether one agrees with him<br />
that their role is mainly that of a good marketing<br />
agent or not, what is clear is that the<br />
major comparative advantage <strong>Thailand</strong><br />
holds over its regional rivals is that its government<br />
is playing such an active role.<br />
A comparison with Vietnam illustrates<br />
this advantage. Overall the Vietnamese food<br />
industry is blighted by a lack of up-to-date<br />
processing equipment, which in turn is holding<br />
back progress.<br />
Although in recent years the Vietnamese<br />
government has increased the attention it<br />
pays to its expanding food industry, it still<br />
needs to reduce risks to food safety and to<br />
improve quality to help the industry compete<br />
on the world market. And this reality places<br />
it a good few years behind <strong>Thailand</strong>.<br />
The comparison favours <strong>Thailand</strong>, but<br />
this advantage may not last forever. This<br />
shows why, at present, <strong>Thailand</strong> is the preeminent<br />
force in the Asian food sector.<br />
continued on page 8<br />
5
FOODNEWS THAILAND January, <strong>2006</strong><br />
Fruit<br />
juices<br />
Set the juice<br />
Pineapple<br />
loose<br />
juice – traditionally<br />
the most expensive of<br />
the mainstream juices –<br />
has seen prices take a<br />
knock of late, and <strong>Thailand</strong><br />
has been feeling the pinch.<br />
BY NEIL MURRAY<br />
It must be a frustrating time for pineapple<br />
farmers and processors in <strong>Thailand</strong><br />
right now. What has always been the most<br />
expensive ‘mainstream’ fruit juice is now<br />
around the same price as apple juice concentrate<br />
(AJC) thanks to startling rises in<br />
the price of other juices.<br />
In late summer/early autumn last year,<br />
pineapple concentrate prices were edging<br />
upwards. Elsewhere, prices of frozen concentrated<br />
orange juice (FCOJ) and AJC were<br />
heading for the stratosphere. At the time of<br />
writing, these two juices cost around<br />
US$1 700/tonne and US$1 000/tonne<br />
respectively, while pineapple is around<br />
US$1 050/ tonne, all prices c&f Europe.<br />
The problem is that demand in the EU<br />
appears weak at the moment. German interest<br />
in pineapple juice is waning because of<br />
the decline in sales of multi-fruit drinks in<br />
the country. The Spanish, traditionally the<br />
largest drinkers of pineapple juice, also seem<br />
to be losing their taste for the product:<br />
Spanish imports of pineapple concentrate for<br />
the first three quarters of 2005 (the most<br />
recent data available) show a fall in imports<br />
of 19% to 13 340 tonnes from 26485 tonnes<br />
in January-September 2004.<br />
“They are trying hard to keep the market<br />
at a certain level, but there is no strong<br />
demand, so they are struggling,” said a<br />
European trader recently, a viewpoint that<br />
was corroborated by another buyer of<br />
pineapple juice, who added: “The Thais are<br />
eyeing the rest of the fruit juice market and<br />
are trying to get some upwards price movement,<br />
but it’s not happening.”<br />
Looking at the figures in the table opposite<br />
would seem to contradict this. According<br />
to the latest trade data, Thai exports of<br />
pineapple concentrate have risen steeply this<br />
year, to the point where exports for January-<br />
November 2005 are more than 20 000 tonnes<br />
ahead of exports for the whole of 2004.<br />
However, in October and November 2005<br />
sales fell quite sharply, compared with the<br />
same months last year, confirming that the<br />
downturn has been relatively recent.<br />
In addition, there has been a definite<br />
swing towards not from concentrate (NFC)<br />
juice, and <strong>Thailand</strong> is finding it hard to supply<br />
EU (especially Spanish) demand.<br />
“The European market has been quite<br />
slow,” said one trader in Germany recently.<br />
“The Spanish market, the biggest, was stable<br />
for many years but now I hear that NFC is<br />
increasing and this is taking share from the<br />
Thais. Costa Rice, for example, is becoming<br />
more important in NFC pineapple juice.”<br />
To a degree, this is true. In 2002, <strong>Thailand</strong><br />
accounted for nearly half of all Spanish<br />
imports of NFC, then running at about 4 300<br />
tonnes annually. By 2004, the market had<br />
grown spectacularly to just under 9 000<br />
tonnes, but <strong>Thailand</strong>’s share fell to about<br />
21%. <strong>Thailand</strong> has regained some market<br />
share so far this year, but is unlikely to<br />
account for more than 40% of a full-year<br />
NFC market estimated by FOODNEWS to be<br />
about 10 000 tonnes.<br />
Indonesia has gained market share. There<br />
is little difference in pricing between<br />
Indonesian and Thai product, so the reason<br />
for this is unclear, but Indonesia now has<br />
about 10% of the Spanish NFC market.<br />
The biggest supplier to the Spanish market,<br />
however, remains the Netherlands and it<br />
is possible that a lot of this juice is Thai.<br />
Competition between newly established<br />
processors may also keep Thai prices low.<br />
THAILAND EXPORTS OF PINEAPPLE JUICE CONCENTRATE<br />
200949 (tonnes) 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 *2005<br />
Netherlands 53 708 46 016 40 434 50 789 34 473 38 653<br />
US 24 067 25 529 23 034 23 550 16 106 20 911<br />
Spain 13 023 9 935 6 248 8 874 5 704 9 728<br />
Japan 1 515 2 401 2 177 3 196 3 877 6 290<br />
Italy n/a 1 691 2 270 5 393 5 033 6 055<br />
UK n/a 675 331 854 914 2 017<br />
Canada 1 673 1 916 2 458 1 608 1 136 1 810<br />
Russia n/a 344 1 580 1 443 1 430 1 784<br />
Israel 2 487 1 414 3 026 2 250 2 749 1 452<br />
Belgium n/a 308 177 93 21 1 021<br />
South Korea 528 924 1 010 997 1 020 729<br />
Australia 2 262 2 662 3 193 3 573 1 000 662<br />
Saudi Arabia n/a 437 252 305 – 595<br />
Chile 638 1 138 959 641 – 501<br />
France 1 270 603 119 59 3 845 443<br />
Lebanon 713 614 1 589 1 353 – 403<br />
Puerto Rico 1 420 316 94 95 – 336<br />
Taiwan n/a 262 388 213 – 266<br />
Germany 1 017 1 121 132 282 6 197 215<br />
Finland n/a 820 378 467 865 189<br />
Singapore n/a 94 123 128 129 122<br />
Hong Kong n/a 95 55 110 – 81<br />
Mexico n/a – – 353 – 0<br />
Others 10 694 5 996 5 834 5 725 2081 6 399<br />
Total 115 015 105 311 95 861 112 351 81 599 100 662<br />
*January-November Source: Department of Business Economics, Department of Customs, GTIS<br />
6
FOODNEWS THAILAND January, <strong>2006</strong><br />
FOODNEWS Online Buyers Guide offers buyers a quick and easy way to<br />
search for companies by product, country or company name<br />
www.fnbuyersguide.com<br />
7
FOODNEWS THAILAND January, <strong>2006</strong><br />
Thai<br />
focus<br />
continued from page 5<br />
If proof were needed that <strong>Thailand</strong> is<br />
refusing to rest on its laurels, look no further<br />
than some of the organisations that reflect<br />
on, advise and control the industry. They are<br />
evidence of planning and strategy, and given<br />
that they have cut their teeth on years of trouble<br />
with economic restrictions, regulations,<br />
safety issues, and viruses they have evolved<br />
into some of the most dynamic organisations<br />
across the board. The National <strong>Food</strong><br />
Institute, the Kitchen of the World and the<br />
Thai Frozen <strong>Food</strong>s Association are three of<br />
the most energetic. The former covers the<br />
industry as a whole, and the latter has<br />
evolved from covering one of the most significant<br />
Thai exports – seafood, to covering a<br />
range of frozen products. Run by Panithan<br />
Vajaranant and Poj Aramwattananont respectively,<br />
they are evidence that an industry of<br />
this size and of this potential needs structure<br />
and planning to realize its potential.<br />
National <strong>Food</strong> Institute – Interview<br />
with Panithan Vajaranant:<br />
What were the reasons behind the establishment<br />
of the NFI?<br />
Actually it started as a private sector initiative<br />
around nine years ago. Many of the<br />
bigger companies involved in production and<br />
export were having difficulties with regula-<br />
Surapon Vongvadhanaroj of Surapon <strong>Food</strong>s<br />
tions. Some felt that the government arm was<br />
too slow to work with them in terms of action<br />
and reaction. Subsequently, some of the bigger<br />
players proposed to the government that<br />
we needed an organisation that would help<br />
watch over the food industry. The biggest<br />
challenge and the priority back then was the<br />
safety system. That was nine years ago. If we<br />
were to be serious about the success of our<br />
food industry, we were going to need someone<br />
to look into these issues full-time.<br />
How important is food safety to <strong>Thailand</strong>’s<br />
food industry?<br />
It is quite clear that if <strong>Thailand</strong> wants to<br />
be competitive then we have to put food safety<br />
first. We started initially with the export<br />
segment. Somebody asked, “Well what about<br />
the domestic?” But we realized that we could<br />
not do everything at the same time. So we<br />
began with the export. We can proudly say<br />
we are the only organization who has been<br />
sticking with this role since the beginning.<br />
How would you define your role?<br />
We have four missions. The first one is<br />
food safety, the second one is research and<br />
development, the third one is information<br />
and information systems and the fourth one<br />
is business development. If you look at these<br />
four missions, they present a huge task. I<br />
think I can say that this government is the<br />
first government that has tried to put this<br />
strategy into action, tried to make it happen.<br />
A lot is down to deputy prime minister<br />
Somkid. He is also very involved with the<br />
NFI and how we can achieve our objectives.<br />
The key will be in the planning and the<br />
strategy. We have a strategy. With regards to<br />
food safety, even though we began with<br />
exports, we have since moved onto domestic<br />
issues. An initiative in 2002 with the Public<br />
Health Ministry set about helping food producers<br />
obtain their GMP. There is no reason<br />
that the standards for food consumed in<br />
<strong>Thailand</strong> should be any less than those outside<br />
of <strong>Thailand</strong>.<br />
This is something that our prime minister<br />
is very keen on: every chance he has he<br />
emphasises that food safety is the priority<br />
and it needs to be applied domestically as<br />
well as internationally. Thai people deserve<br />
the same standards as everyone else.<br />
How successful have these initiatives been?<br />
“<br />
Of course, bird flu was a very painful and worrying time for<br />
us all, but it has given us an opportunity to make a lot of<br />
changes.The farmers’ attitude has been one of humility.<br />
”<br />
Panithan Vajaranant, Executive Director of the<br />
National <strong>Food</strong> Institute<br />
That was two years ago, and I would say<br />
that now the government, including the NFI,<br />
has the commitment to bring the standard up<br />
to the international level. You can see for<br />
yourself the food stalls in the street: which<br />
ones do you trust?<br />
How are today’s challenges being overcome?<br />
Well, last year for instance, bird flu hit<br />
<strong>Thailand</strong>. But on the bright side, I suppose<br />
you could say there was a degree of good<br />
timing for the country. The government<br />
began to use a lot of advertising and campaigns<br />
to try and change the attitudes of people,<br />
not only the people in the street, but also<br />
the people in the farms.<br />
Of course this was a very painful and<br />
worrying time for us all, but it has given us<br />
an opportunity to carry out a lot of changes.<br />
The attitude of the farmers has been one of<br />
humility, to the extent that they are now asking,<br />
“What can we do? How can we<br />
improve? Just let us know”. This attitude is<br />
totally different from before, where we were<br />
asking if not begging them to do this or that.<br />
At what point in the food chain does the<br />
responsibility of the NFI lie?<br />
It really is across the board, from farming<br />
to the point of sale, but our true focus has to<br />
lie in the middle of the chain. The processing,<br />
that is where we operate and is where<br />
our priorities lie.<br />
We are expanding to cover the beginning<br />
of the supply chain, we believe in the market<br />
and we are striving to understand what we<br />
need to do in order to fill any gaps. We are<br />
very pro-active.<br />
To be competitive now, you need to be<br />
very assertive.<br />
continued on page 10<br />
8
January, <strong>2006</strong><br />
With more than 10 years professional<br />
knowledge in the food industry and the<br />
updated E-commerce technology, we<br />
promise that we can create a powerful<br />
platform for food trading, provide a diverse<br />
portfolio of processing food products, and<br />
offer an efficient service to our overseas<br />
clients. Our overseas clients trust in our<br />
excellent and professional handling skills.<br />
AVAILABLE PRODUCTS ARE:<br />
• Canned Vegetables • Canned Fruits<br />
• Frozen Vegetables • Frozen Fruits<br />
• Freeze-Dried Fruits • Fresh Fruits<br />
• Freeze-Dried Vegetables<br />
• Juice Concentrates<br />
9
FOODNEWS THAILAND January, <strong>2006</strong><br />
Thai<br />
focus<br />
continued from page 8<br />
To those looking to do business in or with<br />
<strong>Thailand</strong>, I would say that <strong>Thailand</strong> is very<br />
easy compared to the rest of the world. Thai<br />
people are very open-minded. The way we<br />
do business is very different to the west; even<br />
within Asia it is different. I would say<br />
<strong>Thailand</strong> is very understanding and easy to<br />
understand. We try to understand people and<br />
everyone who is doing business with us. We<br />
have learnt a lot about people’s requirements<br />
(in and from this industry) and we are<br />
focused on providing the world with the best<br />
products. We want to be assertive without<br />
being aggressive.<br />
Interview with Poj Aramwattananont,<br />
President of the Thai Frozen <strong>Food</strong><br />
Association and frozen seafood guru.<br />
Could you explain the evolution of the<br />
TFFA?<br />
The Thai Frozen <strong>Food</strong>s Association is a<br />
private non-profit organization. We were<br />
founded in 1968. The Association began life<br />
as the Thai Marine Association. In 1983 we<br />
evolved into the “Thai fishery and Frozen<br />
Products Association” reflecting the fact that<br />
we also covered the frozen products industry.<br />
The current name however was adopted 11<br />
years later. The Thai Frozen <strong>Food</strong>s<br />
Poj Aramwattananont, president of the Thai<br />
Frozen <strong>Food</strong>s Association and industry guru<br />
10<br />
In Season <strong>Food</strong>s: High technology and skill in <strong>Thailand</strong><br />
Association reflects our blanketing of frozen<br />
products and it also extends the<br />
Association’s supervision from just marine<br />
products to cover other food types too.<br />
Specifically what are the aims of TFFA?<br />
The objectives of TFFA are based around<br />
the promotion of entrepreneurship of all<br />
frozen foods in <strong>Thailand</strong>. This includes<br />
informing and supporting our members<br />
through any business hurdles that may be<br />
placed in their paths. This also includes<br />
mediation, conflict resolution and information<br />
transfer between two or more of our<br />
members. We aim to promote both in qualitative<br />
and quantitative terms the fishery and<br />
agriculture industries, in response to domestic<br />
and international demand. We compile,<br />
collate and share our data to produce statistics,<br />
which benefit our members. And of<br />
course we cooperate and collaborate with the<br />
government and its relevant departments<br />
whilst retaining a neutral stance, politically.<br />
What activities are undertaken to assure<br />
these objectives are met?<br />
The TFFA has set up 3 sub-committees;<br />
take the Export Problems Solving<br />
Committee, for instance. It was established<br />
11 years ago to deal with the problems<br />
exporters were facing at that time. Back then,<br />
there were continuing rejections coming<br />
from some major markets. These problems<br />
intensified to the point that there was a total<br />
ban on imports into Italy several times. We<br />
firmly believe that prevention is better than a<br />
“<br />
The higher tariff made it very difficult for Thai shrimp to<br />
stay competitive in the EU and US markets. In the first quarter,Thai<br />
shrimp exports to the US were down by 43%.<br />
”<br />
cure. This is why we meet every two months<br />
to share information, news and problems<br />
among representatives. We conduct seminars<br />
that allow us to share our views, which can<br />
assist the whole industry. There is a good<br />
feeling of camaraderie among us all.<br />
The Data and Information Committee<br />
was established in 1993. The TFFA advises<br />
its members about the prices of fishery products<br />
etc.<br />
The NASEG Committee or North<br />
America Shrimp Exporters Group was born<br />
out of a club of several TFFA members<br />
called The Shrimp Club. Upon seeing the<br />
necessity of unity in negotiation they formed,<br />
‘The North America Shrimp Exporters<br />
Group’ or NASEG”. NASEG negotiates the<br />
cost with freightliners enabling its members<br />
to achieve lower costs than non-members.<br />
NASEG has over 90 members.<br />
Regarding Anti-Dumping measures?<br />
With the higher tariff, it became very difficult<br />
for Thai shrimp to stay competitive in<br />
the EU and US markets. In the first quarter<br />
Thai shrimp imports to the US have been<br />
pulled down by 43% year on year and overall<br />
Thai shrimp exports have fallen by 36%.<br />
A lot depended on the US ruling.<br />
With regards to GSP, a lower GSP would<br />
provide good export opportunities for<br />
<strong>Thailand</strong>’s shrimp in the European markets.<br />
You, yourself clearly have faith in the industry<br />
with your recent US$20 million investment<br />
in the new facility and Sea Value?<br />
Sea Value was formed in March 2004 as a<br />
holding company for two of the leading Tuna<br />
processors, namely Unicord PLC and ISA<br />
Value.<br />
Unicord itself has over 20 years of history;<br />
it was founded in 1978 as Unicord
FOODNEWS THAILAND January, <strong>2006</strong><br />
Thai<br />
focus<br />
Investment and changed to Unicord in 1984.<br />
Unicord produces mainly canned food,<br />
pouch packs and frozen products, Human<br />
food, pet food and value added food respectively.<br />
ISA Value also has many years of experience<br />
and is today producing 500 tonnes of<br />
tuna under strict quality guidelines.<br />
With the experience of the people<br />
involved in this project and the technology<br />
involved, this will become one of the largest,<br />
most advanced tuna operations in the world.<br />
Kitchen of the World<br />
<strong>Thailand</strong>’s abundance of food products and<br />
climate ranges, combined with the reputation<br />
of <strong>Thailand</strong> as a net exporter of foods, has<br />
meant that the promotion of <strong>Thailand</strong> as a<br />
business partner and of Thai products overseas<br />
has been essential. With this aim in<br />
mind, the Department of Agriculture, under<br />
the Ministry of Agriculture and Cooperatives<br />
spent 2003 outlining methods by which the<br />
export or fruit and vegetables as well as the<br />
processing of food could be made healthier<br />
and safer. Particular efforts were made in the<br />
reduction of chemical usage and the development<br />
of soil quality.<br />
This aim was merely one method of the<br />
multi-pronged assault on the world food<br />
markets made by the government. Yet perhaps<br />
one of the most ambitious tactics is the<br />
Kitchen of the World campaign.<br />
The Kitchen of the World is essentially<br />
aimed at increasing the number of Thai<br />
restaurants overseas. The reasons behind this<br />
are that first, <strong>Thailand</strong>’s place on the food<br />
map will be reinforced. The consumption of<br />
Thai food will increase awareness of<br />
<strong>Thailand</strong> as a food processing nation and<br />
would ideally encourage business to and<br />
from <strong>Thailand</strong>. An increased number of<br />
restaurants will provide a distribution network<br />
for <strong>Thailand</strong>’s food processors to be<br />
able to sell their products overseas. Finally,<br />
any interest in Thai cuisine will surely<br />
increase interest in the finished Thai-style<br />
products that are being manufactured in<br />
increasing quantities in <strong>Thailand</strong>.<br />
As several members of the Kitchen of the<br />
World and NFI team believe, “We think that<br />
food is one of our crowns. We want to export<br />
to the world, we have a unique product, and<br />
Thai food is already very popular across the<br />
world. This is our niche, if we can promote<br />
Thai food it means that we can increase the<br />
number of Thai restaurants overseas which<br />
means that we can increase exports of products,<br />
specifically ready to eat and ready to<br />
cook. Moreover, we can also export personnel,<br />
Thai chefs for instance.”<br />
“The Kitchen of the World initiative<br />
began in 2003. It was an initiative of Prime<br />
Minister Thaksin himself. He realised that<br />
Thai cuisine is very popular, and has a great<br />
potential for export, and so he managed to<br />
get funding for this project.<br />
“He is explicit when it comes to expressing<br />
<strong>Thailand</strong>’s skill as a food producer and<br />
exporter. We are the top exporters of many<br />
products, pineapple for instance. In terms of<br />
the technology, the know-how and the experience<br />
we truly excel.”<br />
For <strong>Thailand</strong> to truly thrive as Kitchen of<br />
the World, it will take more than premium<br />
finished products, or an abundance of exotic<br />
raw materials. The kind of challenges that<br />
<strong>Thailand</strong> is up against include meeting<br />
hygiene standards, non-tariff barriers, raw<br />
material shortages in certain sectors and epidemics<br />
such as the aforementioned AI.<br />
From the thoroughness of the National<br />
<strong>Food</strong> Institute to the camaraderie and ambition<br />
of the Thai Frozen <strong>Food</strong>s Association<br />
and its President, along with hopes within<br />
the poultry industry, it would appear that the<br />
future is bright for <strong>Thailand</strong>, its exporters<br />
and its consumers. One remaining anxiety is<br />
the fact that, although in the last decade or<br />
so, revenue gained from the export of<br />
processed materials has doubled, the farmers<br />
of <strong>Thailand</strong> still seem to be living in relative<br />
poverty. The focus on manufacturing needs<br />
to be shared with the farmers, as it is crucial<br />
that <strong>Thailand</strong> and its food industry realize<br />
that without raw materials, there is no processing.<br />
Where from here?<br />
For all the praise due to the Thai food industry<br />
and its government’s keen participation in<br />
it, it remains clear that with the development<br />
of the Chinese and Vietnamese food industries,<br />
the Thais cannot rest on their laurels<br />
and further developments need to be made.<br />
But resting on their laurels does not seem to<br />
be on the menu. The presence of innovative<br />
companies, favourable global trends and the<br />
development of existing recipes indicate that<br />
the industry is doing its utmost to remain the<br />
‘food basket of Asia’.<br />
<strong>Thailand</strong> is famed for being the world’s<br />
leading exporter of a host of products, rice<br />
and canned pineapple to name but two. Yet it<br />
is also home to several little known but innovative<br />
companies that illustrate the breadth<br />
Vilai Kiatsrichart, president of the Thai <strong>Food</strong><br />
Processors Association<br />
of products the country has to offer and the<br />
ability of the industry to use its plentiful supply<br />
of quality raw materials to create something<br />
new and exciting. Developments like<br />
this hint at a positive future for Thai companies<br />
in the arena of ‘niche’ food products.<br />
One such company is In-Season <strong>Food</strong>s. It<br />
has taken one of <strong>Thailand</strong>’s most abundant<br />
and popular raw materials, tropical fruits<br />
such as pineapples, lychees and mangos, and<br />
treated them in a way that ensures all the<br />
goodness and taste remains whether it is<br />
eaten two days after being picked or two<br />
weeks.<br />
Its innovative methods ensure that<br />
Europeans are not denied the same luxury as<br />
Asians in eating truly delectable fresh fruit.<br />
Once picked, the fruits are taken to In-<br />
Season <strong>Food</strong>’s state of the art factory and on<br />
the same day they are cryogenically frozen<br />
using liquid nitrogen to produce individually<br />
quick frozen (IFQ) fruit. The company is the<br />
only one of its kind in Asia and already in its<br />
short life has created much excitement and<br />
disbelief over the quality of the product.<br />
“Due to the nature of the project and idea<br />
only a ‘back of the envelope’ type of feasibility<br />
was possible. However the concept was<br />
developed on strong business principles”<br />
said Asraf Fancy, who owns and runs the<br />
company with his son Ali Fancy.<br />
The company is indeed built on strong<br />
business principles but also two other important<br />
ingredients – innovation and vision.<br />
continued on page 20<br />
11
FOODNEWS THAILAND January, <strong>2006</strong><br />
Canned<br />
fish<br />
The big fish<br />
Tuna<br />
in the sea<br />
catches have been<br />
erratic over the last year,<br />
but with exports up and a<br />
free trade agreement with<br />
the US in the works, there<br />
is no sign of sales slowing.<br />
BY RICHARD SIMPSON<br />
THE Hollywood screenwriter William<br />
Goldman once famously remarked<br />
that in the film industry “no-one knows<br />
anything really”, but this maxim could<br />
almost as easily be applied to the tuna<br />
business, with catch levels and fish prices<br />
proving almost impossible to predict.<br />
The last two year’s have seen both dramatic<br />
fluctuations in price for raw fish and in<br />
tuna supply, with last year’s tsunami casting<br />
a distinctly dark shadow despite only peripherally<br />
affecting the industry.<br />
Prices for raw material hit an all time high<br />
in September 2004 of US$1 180/tonne in<br />
Bangkok, heart of the tuna business, but<br />
2005 saw prices vary from US$700/tonne<br />
(towards the beginning and end of the year)<br />
to as much as US$1 030/tonne in August. On<br />
the whole, prices for the year averaged out at<br />
around US$900/tonne, an awkward price for<br />
processors to deal with as one told FOOD-<br />
NEWS back in 2005: “At around<br />
US$900/tonne it is very expensive for us<br />
buyers, especially when we look back at the<br />
prices we have had before of around<br />
US$600/tonne. However, we are all conscious<br />
of the fact prices could so easily go up<br />
and then we really feel the squeeze.”<br />
One of the major issues for the Thai tuna<br />
industry in <strong>2006</strong> will be the ongoing negotiations<br />
between the US and <strong>Thailand</strong> aimed at<br />
finalising a bilateral free trade agreement.<br />
Discussions between the two countries began<br />
back in January 2004 and are still on schedule<br />
to be completed by June <strong>2006</strong>.<br />
THAI EXPORTS OF CANNED TUNA (January-December)<br />
160414 (tonnes) 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005*<br />
US 70 564 71 497 73 634 108 085 98 472 103 591<br />
Australia 19 283 20 015 23 683 28 606 29 850 29 333<br />
Japan 21 586 19 788 23 496 24 114 28 910 26 251<br />
Canada 23 711 24 089 25 523 25 303 25 381 25 873<br />
Egypt 27 419 29 687 21 216 23 001 19 300 22 789<br />
Libya 1 258 1 698 9 540 14 233 18 290 22 743<br />
Germany 4 275 10 373 10 406 9 661 6 061 15 462<br />
UK 13 460 17 196 17 248 18 123 13 174 15 432<br />
Saudi Arabia 6 118 12 433 12 408 11 834 15 347 13 795<br />
Israel 4 876 7 286 7 635 10 255 7 779 8 256<br />
Argentina 7 448 9 330 378 6 643 8 941 7 537<br />
Switzerland 3 093 3 192 2 965 6 296 5 070 5 880<br />
South Africa 2 447 2 886 2 759 4 925 5 268 5 833<br />
Others 60 190 69 120 89 378 104 641 95 675 111 775<br />
Total 265 728 298 590 320 269 395 720 377 518 414 541<br />
*2005 exports are up until until the end of November<br />
Source: GTIS<br />
Tuna talks<br />
At five-day talks in the northern Thai city of<br />
Chiang Mai in early January 2005, Prime<br />
Minister Thaksin Shinawatra, said in an<br />
address to local and foreign business leaders,<br />
“On the Thai-US FTA, if we don’t trade with<br />
the US, we will lose. Right now, our greatest<br />
surplus with any country is with the US. We<br />
will be at a huge disadvantage to others if we<br />
lose our access to the US market, as other<br />
countries will pursue their own deals. We<br />
need to move now, before we have no more<br />
room to move.”<br />
A report by the <strong>Thailand</strong> Development<br />
and Research Institute, a Bangkok-based<br />
think-tank, estimates that, in respect to agriculture,<br />
the US and <strong>Thailand</strong> would both<br />
enjoy big economic gains from an FTA.<br />
According to their analysis, agricultural<br />
exports to the US would increase by 5-22%,<br />
while US exports would also increase by 4-<br />
67%. The gains for <strong>Thailand</strong>’s agricultural<br />
sector would result in a 2.3% increase in<br />
gross domestic product, says to the report.<br />
The US has agreed to end tariffs on 74%<br />
of all Thai imports totalling US$1.28 billion<br />
(THB51 billion) immediately after the FTA’s<br />
implementation, increasing to 85% and<br />
US$1.46 billion in five years. The items covered<br />
will reach 97% in 10 years totalling<br />
US$1.60 billion and will include canned tuna<br />
and processed fruit.“If the US comes with a<br />
lower duty for Thai tuna with no strings<br />
attached, it will certainly help,” said one<br />
major Thai trader.<br />
“But as usual with these things, strings<br />
are always attached somewhere. What we<br />
really need is for EU to drop their duties so<br />
<strong>Thailand</strong> is not at any disadvantage and<br />
everybody is on a level playing field, and this<br />
applies not only to tuna but also to canned<br />
pineapple and canned sweet corn.”<br />
Nevertheless, Thai exports of canned tuna<br />
are at their highest levels in history, hitting<br />
414 540 tonnes by the end of December<br />
2005, compared with full year sales of<br />
377 520 tonnes in 2004 and 395 720 tonnes<br />
in 2003 respectively.<br />
The US has once again boosted its intake<br />
of Thai tuna to over 100 000 tonnes, after a<br />
slight sales slump in 2004.<br />
The subject of mercury in canned fish,<br />
has sporadically reared its head in the US<br />
through media reports, but this scare seems<br />
to have had little effect on the country’s tuna<br />
needs. With one month to go in 2005, Thai<br />
exports look set to surpass the 430 000<br />
tonnes mark, even though December is usually<br />
a fairly quiet period, being a a holiday<br />
period for countries.<br />
14
FOODNEWS THAILAND January, <strong>2006</strong><br />
15
FOODNEWS THAILAND January, <strong>2006</strong><br />
Canned<br />
fruits<br />
Sweetness,<br />
weakness<br />
Sugar and labour issues<br />
have been putting Thai<br />
processors under pressure,<br />
but with supply and sales<br />
rising, optimism is returning<br />
to the industry.<br />
BY RICHARD SIMPSON<br />
SUGAR is proving to be an extremely<br />
trying issue for Thai pineapple canners<br />
as fears of a shortage in the country, which<br />
is the world’s third largest exporter of the<br />
product, has left the canned industry with<br />
a distinctly sour taste in its mouth.<br />
Overall costs have gone up substantially<br />
over the past year, as they have in general for<br />
canned foods, with fuel, labour and tin-plate<br />
all increasing in price.<br />
The Thai government is closely monitoring<br />
the production cost of sugar at present<br />
before deciding whether to remove it from<br />
the list of price-controlled goods, to prevent<br />
a shortage to the domestic market.<br />
Pineapple canners in particular will have<br />
been alarmed by recent calls by the Thai<br />
Sugar Miller Corporation, one of the country’s<br />
biggest sugar companies, to float sugar<br />
prices and regulate the amount canners take.<br />
“Supply might be tight if the government<br />
cannot fix loopholes on sugar smuggling and<br />
the amount bought by major sugar consumers<br />
such as canned fruit producers,” said<br />
Thai Sugar Miller president Vibul Panitvong,<br />
quoted in the Business Times.<br />
A shortage of skilled labour has also been<br />
an issue for processors, and came to a head<br />
back in November 2005 when canners struggled<br />
to catch up on a backlog of orders, due<br />
partly to the delay in the start of the packing<br />
period.<br />
Factories were only running at about 80%<br />
of their capacity, due to the lack of labour but<br />
in the end canners were able to push on and<br />
ensure enough fruit was available coming<br />
THAI EXPORTS OF CANNED PINEAPPLE (January-December)<br />
200820 (tonnes) 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005*<br />
US 85 245 81 659 84 283 103 399 116 965 118 848<br />
Russia 920 8 825 8 525 10 102 17 952 33 803<br />
Netherlands 33 555 26 704 19 987 27 716 37 508 33 188<br />
Germany 59 600 58 701 47 314 53 813 45 978 31 828<br />
Japan 32 152 33 708 28 796 26 009 29 518 29 289<br />
Canada 18 926 21 280 21 857 22 393 22 485 20 516<br />
UK 17 503 15 432 13 975 15 706 18 394 15 275<br />
Poland 3 099 7 994 8 296 13 129 12 871 12 349<br />
Saudi Arabia 6 133 9 670 7 631 8 807 8 558 11 780<br />
France 17 039 16 705 14 201 15 906 14 716 11 624<br />
Italy 11 962 7 800 7 410 11 427 11 938 9 463<br />
Spain 12 261 10 488 9 499 12 375 11 696 8 542<br />
Australia 10 463 8 825 4 726 5 229 5 039 7 393<br />
Taiwan 7 690 6 336 6 592 6 043 7 066 7 389<br />
Yemen 3 243 4 714 5 141 6 945 6 274 6 608<br />
UAE 1 152 1 802 2 927 3 435 3 994 5 603<br />
South Korea 2 153 1 966 3 701 3 375 6 365 5 404<br />
Finland 7 995 8 306 4 295 7 079 6 438 5 369<br />
Sweden 6 259 6 474 4 915 6 762 6 296 5 341<br />
Romania 3 668 4 115 2 672 4 216 3 511 5 164<br />
Pakistan 2 410 2 278 2 794 4 370 3 265 4 931<br />
Denmark 3 583 4 420 4 270 4 913 4 671 4 599<br />
Belgium 9 401 8 935 6 881 10 425 6 812 4 543<br />
Others 71 770 61 585 64 171 91 687 69 770 63 784<br />
Total 428 182 418 722 384 859 475 261 478 080 462 633<br />
*Statistics accurate up to November Source: GTIS<br />
into <strong>2006</strong>.<br />
One trader told FOODNEWS at the time:<br />
“Labour is a major problem for many Thai<br />
industries and the canning industry is no<br />
exception. Packers are not able to reap the<br />
full advantages of the crop because it is proving<br />
almost impossible to get the workforce. It<br />
is frustrating.”<br />
On the production side of things though,<br />
<strong>Thailand</strong> is in an extremely healthy position<br />
heading towards the summer crop in<br />
March/April, despite heavy rainfall, leaving<br />
Thai pineapple farmers struggling to harvest<br />
the country’s winter crop back in September,<br />
and making raw material scarce and few<br />
offers for canned fruit.<br />
Better availability<br />
Better fruit availability has reflected in the<br />
current fairly low raw material price of<br />
THB3.00/kg, as of 16 January <strong>2006</strong>, a big<br />
drop on early-October’s price of THB4.50-<br />
5.50/kg, and packers are comfortable enough<br />
not to have to fight over produce.<br />
The wet weather was in stark contrast to<br />
the severe drought that hit <strong>Thailand</strong>’s growing<br />
areas at the start of the year, and led to<br />
substantial fruit loss (FOODNEWS passim).<br />
Thai canners are now confident that the<br />
winter crop can make up for the summer<br />
shortfall, although the disappointing summer<br />
crop was a blow.<br />
“The winter crop has almost compensated<br />
for the shortage in produce from the summer<br />
and <strong>Thailand</strong> is expected to meet the 1.85<br />
million tonnes of pineapple forecast to be<br />
produced this year. The problem is that we<br />
really needed the summer crop for the EU<br />
summer sales, so availability is not as important<br />
now, “ said one major Thai processor.<br />
The Thai canned pineapple industry, like<br />
their counterparts in sweet corn, will be<br />
crossing their fingers that the weather is<br />
kinder this year than last.<br />
16
FOODNEWS THAILAND January, <strong>2006</strong><br />
<strong>2006</strong> Media Information<br />
NOW AVAILABLE<br />
If you have not got your copy contact Vicky on:<br />
+44 (0)20 7017 7494 fnadvertising@agra-net.com<br />
17
FOODNEWS THAILAND January, <strong>2006</strong><br />
ITOH<br />
ITOHWEN AND COMPANY, LIMITED<br />
We are the Producer and Exporter with our own facilities and equipment in China of the following:<br />
FROZEN PRODUCT:<br />
Boletus Edulis, Nameko, Pleurotus, Shiitake, Morel, Cantharellus Cibarius, Champignons, Suillus Granulatus, Black Fungus, Strawberry<br />
(whole/cube), Peach, Pear, Apricot, Blueberry, Blackberry, Blackcurrant, Lingonberry, Raspberry, Lychee, Asparagus, Garlic.<br />
BRINED PRODUCT:<br />
Boletus Edulis, Champignons, Nameko, Pleurotus, Shiitake, Cantharellus Cibarius, Suillus Granulatus, Armillaria Mellea, Strawmushroom,<br />
Terreum, Garlic.<br />
DRIED AND OTHER PRODUCT:<br />
Boletus Edulis, Champignons, Pleurotus, Shiitake, Morel, Cantharellus Cibarius, Black Fungus (black/black or black/white), Strawmushroom,<br />
Apple Dice, Apple Ring, Garlic, Safflower, Hibiscus Flower, Concentration of Apple/Pineapple/Passion Fruit.<br />
Head Office:<br />
Branch Office:<br />
Flat A, 16/F., Catic Plaza, 8 Causeway Road, Room 3202, Block C,<br />
Causeway Bay, Hong Kong<br />
Bao Hai Gao Ji Gong Yu, Guan Shang Bei Lu,<br />
E-mail: itohwen@netvigator.com<br />
Kunming, China<br />
Website: http://www.itohwen.com Tel: (86) 1370 8840558<br />
Tel: (852) 2770 7168 Fax: (852) 2782 5411 Fax: (86) 871 7154937<br />
MARKET REVIEWS <strong>2006</strong><br />
MARKET REVIEW<br />
PUBLISHED<br />
The Americas 31st March <strong>2006</strong><br />
NEW<br />
Poland 21st April <strong>2006</strong><br />
Asia/Vietnam 12th May <strong>2006</strong><br />
Processed Tomatoes 26th May <strong>2006</strong><br />
Juices & Frozen Fruit 16th June <strong>2006</strong><br />
World Juice Programme 7th July <strong>2006</strong><br />
NEW Colombia 28th July <strong>2006</strong><br />
Bilingual Review published<br />
NEW Russia in Russian and English 11th August <strong>2006</strong><br />
Turkey 25th August <strong>2006</strong><br />
Europe/SIAL 15th September <strong>2006</strong><br />
Juice Yearbook 13th October <strong>2006</strong><br />
Canned <strong>Food</strong>s 17th November <strong>2006</strong><br />
Soft Drinks 8th December <strong>2006</strong><br />
Review of <strong>2006</strong>/Editorial Listing 1st January 2007<br />
For more information, please contact Vicky or Helen on:<br />
Tel +44 (0) 20 7017 7494 or email fnadvertising@agra-net.com<br />
18
FOODNEWS THAILAND January, <strong>2006</strong><br />
FOODNEWS THAILAND <strong>2006</strong> Market Review<br />
is available to download online<br />
FREE OF CHARGE<br />
www.foodnews.co.uk/marketreviews<br />
For fast and easy finding, the Contents page is<br />
linked to the article. Also, some of our<br />
advertisers have requested a hyperlink to either<br />
their website or email to enable you to<br />
contact them directly - click on the<br />
advertisements to find out!<br />
Agents — Importers<br />
Canned/dehydrated<br />
frozen/freeze dried<br />
Fruits/vegetables<br />
mushrooms/seafood<br />
Edible nuts — rice<br />
dried fruits — spices<br />
Raw materials, ingredients,<br />
for food manufacturers<br />
P.O. Box 8050 Zurich, Switzerland<br />
Phone (01) 315 56 56, Fax (01) 315 56 00<br />
E-mail: info@stutzer.ch<br />
LOOKING FOR PRODUCTS?<br />
FOODNEWS Online Buyers Guide<br />
offers buyers a quick and easy way to<br />
search for companies by product, country or<br />
company name.<br />
The World Wide Web is now the fastest<br />
growing medium for promoting products<br />
and services to a global market. Take<br />
advantage of FOODNEWS excellent<br />
value Web Packages.<br />
For more information, please contact<br />
Vicky or Helen on email<br />
fnadvertising@agra-net.com<br />
or Tel: +44 (0) 20 7017 7494<br />
www.fnbuyersguide.com<br />
19
FOODNEWS THAILAND January, <strong>2006</strong><br />
Thai<br />
focus<br />
continued from page 11<br />
Another such company is Ice-Cremo. It<br />
has seen a gap in the ice cream market that it<br />
intends to fill using, like In-Season foods, the<br />
very thing that makes <strong>Thailand</strong> an attractive<br />
proposition for foreign investors in the first<br />
place – its abundance of quality raw materials.<br />
Realising that it could not compete in the<br />
global market by producing the well-known<br />
flavours we all love to eat, such as chocolate<br />
and vanilla, it hopes to create a name for<br />
itself by producing distinctive ‘Thai<br />
flavours’. Such weird and wonderful flavours<br />
as jackfruit and mangosteen may seem<br />
strange, but have already achieved success<br />
and once more illustrates the variety of products<br />
on offer in <strong>Thailand</strong>.<br />
Excellence can be found in every corner<br />
of this industry. The shelves of the <strong>Food</strong> and<br />
Drinks Company are filled with brands<br />
instantly recognisable in any number of<br />
European and American (not to mention<br />
Australian and Japanese) retailers. As Huai<br />
Hui Lee of <strong>Food</strong> and Drinks says, “People<br />
need to know exactly what we are capable of<br />
in <strong>Thailand</strong>. We can produce absolutely anything,<br />
to the specifics and standards of the<br />
customer”. She goes on to add, “We want to<br />
make every product delicious, and with a<br />
good quality, and it’s not only a mission for<br />
Kuang Pei San, with distinctive Smiling Fish logo<br />
me, but for any Thai company. We, here in<br />
<strong>Thailand</strong> are developing together so that the<br />
industry as a whole can proceed. In sales, yes<br />
we may compete. But when it comes to technology<br />
and know-how, everybody should<br />
help out so that we can continually increase<br />
the quality of the whole industry.”<br />
And success is not only the responsibility<br />
nor the luxury of the established older companies<br />
such as <strong>Food</strong> and Drinks. Even newcomers<br />
such as Viriyah have injected their<br />
own adrenalin into the industry. As producers<br />
of corn and awaiting its second birthday,<br />
Viriyah is more than a “new kid on the<br />
block”. Its managing director, Apichat<br />
Suttisiltum was adamant (as were his colleagues)<br />
that quality and safety were essential<br />
to success. However he differed over one<br />
issue.<br />
Whereas his colleagues in canning and<br />
vegetable production believed that the only<br />
hurdle in achieving higher quality was the<br />
quality of the raw material, Apichat was<br />
clear: “Of course a higher quality raw material<br />
will give a better quality of finished<br />
product, but we believe that skill in production,<br />
especially in our field is of similar<br />
importance. We have the processing knowhow<br />
and expertise, which allows us to take a<br />
product and ensure that it is processed to the<br />
very highest standards available. Of course,<br />
everyone needs to be using the best raw<br />
materials, but we can go one step further.”<br />
High technology<br />
High technology and know how are in abundance<br />
in <strong>Thailand</strong>, but the feeling across<br />
many of the processors is one of camaraderie.<br />
Doi Kham, for instance, is a company<br />
born out of the Royal Project, an initiative<br />
of the King himself, initially to help the<br />
farmers in the north. Today Doi Kham goes<br />
from strength to strength with a new line of<br />
tomato juices. Mrs Mayoree, the President,<br />
knows that a fair price and fair treatment of<br />
farmers will always be respected, not only<br />
within the industry but also by the consumer.<br />
Of greater importance though to the<br />
future of the Thai food exports is the<br />
favourable development concerning the huge<br />
income generator, shrimp. The last few years<br />
have been a gloomy period for Thai shrimp<br />
“<br />
People need to know exactly what we are capable of in<br />
<strong>Thailand</strong>. We can produce absolutely anything, to the specifics<br />
and standards of the customer, whatever it may be.<br />
”<br />
companies. Faced with export hurdles, not<br />
only in the EU but also the US, it has had to<br />
endure very difficult times in competing in<br />
these two high shrimp consumption markets.<br />
For years <strong>Thailand</strong> has urged the EU to reinstate<br />
tariff privileges for shrimp under its<br />
Generalised System of Preferences (GSP) to<br />
boost the competitive edge of Thai shrimp<br />
products. And success has been achieved.<br />
This year sees the return of the GSP meaning<br />
that the tariff on Thai frozen shrimp will be<br />
reduced to 4.2%, down from 12%, and 7%,<br />
down from 20%, for processed shrimp.<br />
Steven Chia-Apar still has good hopes for<br />
his industry: “There is clearly light at the end<br />
of this tunnel,” he says. That the future can<br />
be considered bright for Thai shrimp is further<br />
highlighted when set against the background<br />
of increasing exports of the previous<br />
two years. 2005 saw 430 000 tonnes of<br />
shrimp exported from <strong>Thailand</strong>. This was up<br />
from the 360 000 tonnes exported in 2004.<br />
Over the next three years it is hoped that the<br />
volume increases to 600 000 tonnes. With<br />
this favourable change in European attitudes,<br />
many Thai shrimp companies are focusing<br />
much of their attention on the European market.<br />
Anti-dumping measures<br />
Although the anti-dumping measures against<br />
Thai shrimp in the US remain, this in spite of<br />
US statements saying they would seriously<br />
look at removing them in the wake of 2004’s<br />
tsunami, the outlook is not as bleak as some<br />
may think. Last year saw exports of Thai<br />
shrimp to the US increased to 111 000<br />
tonnes, a surprising rise of 32.5%. During<br />
the same period China, which used to be the<br />
second major exporter to the US, has witnessed<br />
its exports decrease by 29 %. This<br />
combined with the fact that the Japanese<br />
market is opening up once more after the<br />
country’s decade long recession and Thai<br />
shrimp companies and by extension the<br />
whole food industry have every reason to be<br />
optimistic.<br />
One effect of the tariffs illustrates another<br />
trend seemingly being felt throughout the<br />
Thai food sector. When questioned about the<br />
consequences of the damaging EU and US<br />
tariffs Chia-Apar said that many smaller<br />
operators had gone out of business. This has<br />
had the effect of streamlining the industry.<br />
There now exist fewer players but these tend<br />
to be large in size and capable of exporting in<br />
greater volume. Therefore, increased competition<br />
on the global market is also replicated<br />
20
FOODNEWS THAILAND January, <strong>2006</strong><br />
Thai<br />
focus<br />
on a smaller scale within <strong>Thailand</strong>.<br />
<strong>Thailand</strong>’s fixation with Free Trade<br />
Agreements (FTA) has also contributed to<br />
the trend of smaller producers and exporters<br />
worrying about their future while the larger<br />
players have been able to take advantage and<br />
grow. For example, while big names such as<br />
the CP Group can benefit from zero tariff<br />
imports to China, this is not the case with all<br />
exporters. At the same time as the CP Group<br />
export revenue of fruits nearly doubled in<br />
2005 from THB100 million in 2004, due to<br />
FTA deals with China and Australia, smaller<br />
producers have not increased their share by<br />
nearly as much, due to the US$2 000 inspection<br />
cost per shipment that remains in place.<br />
Therefore, it is likely, although not certain,<br />
that the Thai <strong>Food</strong> sector will be dominated<br />
and driven by large companies such as<br />
the CP Group and Seafresh and not as used<br />
to be the case by the plethora of small to<br />
medium sized operations. If the smaller players<br />
are to gain footholds in foreign markets<br />
then they will need foreign partners more<br />
than ever.<br />
The presence of tariffs on food products is<br />
commonplace throughout the world, and<br />
with regard to <strong>Thailand</strong> are not limited to its<br />
shrimp industry. Its pineapples are also subject<br />
to anti-dumping measures in the US, and<br />
this has forced the pineapple processing<br />
industry to seek out other markets or find a<br />
US partner. This move, although hardly revolutionary,<br />
is a microcosm of the whole food<br />
processing industry in <strong>Thailand</strong>.<br />
Whilst always looking to extend its<br />
advantages in the large markets such as the<br />
US, EU and its Asian neighbours, many Thai<br />
companies are looking to the emerging food<br />
markets to export to. This is no different<br />
where canned pineapple companies are concerned.<br />
Russia is one of the fastest-growing<br />
markets for canned pineapple and Thai companies<br />
have been quick to latch onto this<br />
growth market. The first quarter of 2005 saw<br />
<strong>Thailand</strong> export 622 900, compared with just<br />
166 500 in 2003.<br />
The great advantage of Thai companies is<br />
their experience and acknowledged focus on<br />
safety, hence they are able to tap into new<br />
markets much more easily than their opponents.<br />
In being such huge exporters of many<br />
products, Thai companies are able to seek<br />
out these new growth markets quicker and<br />
better than their rivals. If the industry as a<br />
whole is to expand as the government<br />
intends, then one should expect to see further<br />
penetration into new growth markets such as<br />
Russia and China.<br />
Whilst we wait to see if the changes articulated<br />
above materialise across the board,<br />
one motor of change that is set to continue is<br />
the recent growth of ready-to-eat products<br />
and Thai sauce companies.<br />
The growth in popularity of Thai food<br />
around the globe will not necessarily lead to<br />
a growth in sales of, for example, Thai<br />
canned pineapple or Thai shrimp. The<br />
emerging emphasis within the industry on<br />
ready-to-eat Thai meals and Thai sauces is a<br />
tacit acknowledgement of this fact.<br />
Ready to eat Thai meals and Thai sauces<br />
are capable of riding the wave of popularity<br />
that exists concerning Thai cuisine. As<br />
Surapon Vongvadhanaroj of Surapon <strong>Food</strong>s<br />
knows all too well, “you cannot ignore the<br />
growing importance of ready to eat produce”.<br />
He is not alone in this view. Indeed, if one<br />
was to write a history on the vast majority of<br />
Thai sauce companies it would not amount to<br />
much. This is because so many of them have<br />
only recently been established. Jittaporn<br />
Jantarich of Exotic <strong>Food</strong>s, when studying in<br />
the US, really wanted a homemade Thai<br />
meal, but upon venturing to his local supermarket<br />
found he was not able to buy any<br />
authentic Thai sauces. Now several years<br />
later he is at the forefront of a burgeoning<br />
industry aiming to ensure that others in foreign<br />
supermarkets do not have the same<br />
struggle he experienced.<br />
Foreign palette adjustment<br />
Already the receptiveness of foreign palates<br />
to authentic Thai meals and sauces is being<br />
seen beyond the host of Thai restaurants.<br />
Exports to Europe are increasing year by<br />
year and this trend shows no sign of abating.<br />
Add to this the effect of ‘Thai Kitchen of the<br />
World’ and one can see why the Thai food<br />
processors association deemed it necessary<br />
to create a new grouping, that of ready to eat<br />
processors. This clearly illustrates that the<br />
future of Thai food is to be found in this new<br />
exciting sector.<br />
One other great change that needs to<br />
occur, and which ‘Thai Kitchen of the<br />
World’ is testament to, is that the industry as<br />
a whole needs to market itself much better.<br />
As Surapon Vongvadhanaroj said: “There<br />
was a time when Thai food companies would<br />
not market themselves at all; they would simply<br />
wait for buyers to find them.” This growing<br />
realisation, although government-led, has<br />
permeated down through the industry on two<br />
levels. Firstly, the keenness of Thai companies<br />
to travel to international trade fairs has<br />
risen over the past five years – the annual<br />
Thaifex <strong>Food</strong> Exhibition, run by the Thai<br />
Department of Export Promotion has seen a<br />
year on year increase in the number of companies<br />
wanting to show-off their products to<br />
the international food community. 2005’s<br />
show saw 866 companies present at the fair<br />
compared with 738 the year before. And secondly,<br />
the ability to appreciate that in emphasising<br />
their ‘Thai heritage’ producers can<br />
better ride the wave created by Thai cuisine’s<br />
global popularity. The past few years have<br />
seen an explosion of companies using the<br />
‘Thai’ motif on their packaging. Faced by a<br />
seemingly perpetual series of setbacks,<br />
<strong>Thailand</strong> not only remains one of the most<br />
reliable food processing nations, but is also<br />
beginning to reach out on its own. The days<br />
of Thai firms sitting and waiting for business<br />
to land on the doorstep are gone. With firms<br />
like Champaca facilitating trade between<br />
company and company and nation and<br />
nation, problems such as language barrier,<br />
price discrepancies, and quality disputes are<br />
all but eradicated. If further proof were needed<br />
of <strong>Thailand</strong>’s food processors’ ambition<br />
then simply consider their increased presence<br />
at ANUGA, or any other international<br />
trade fair for that matter.<br />
For those naysayers who believe that<br />
<strong>Thailand</strong> is destined to serve as an OEM producer<br />
for overseas firms, rather than producing<br />
its own international brands, they merely<br />
need consider the Thai Kitchen of the World<br />
project.<br />
If they still needed convincing, then the<br />
rise and rise of Red Bull makes it clear that a<br />
country that for decades has excelled in<br />
farming, manufacturing and processing, is<br />
now beginning to excel at marketing too.<br />
It is fitting that the national animal of<br />
<strong>Thailand</strong> is the elephant, because it seems<br />
that its strength and scale is more than a<br />
match for any obstacle in its path.<br />
It is likely that Thai <strong>Food</strong> exports will be dominated by big<br />
companies like Seafresh. If smaller players are to gain footholds<br />
in foreign markets they will need foreign partners.<br />
“<br />
”<br />
21
FOODNEWS THAILAND January, <strong>2006</strong><br />
Canned<br />
vegetables<br />
The seeds<br />
of doubt<br />
Sweet corn is one of<br />
<strong>Thailand</strong>’s dependable<br />
crops, but chaotic weather<br />
in 2005 hurt production and<br />
left the industry limping<br />
towards the new harvest.<br />
BY RICHARD SIMPSON<br />
THAILAND has faced one of its most<br />
stressful periods in its history in 2005,<br />
as far as canned sweet corn is concerned,<br />
with drought affecting the summer crop<br />
and heavy floods afflicting winter’s.<br />
<strong>Thailand</strong>’s problems stretch back to the<br />
start of this year, when more than 66<br />
provinces were troubled by arid weather conditions,<br />
estimated to have damaged around<br />
13.7 million rai (2.2 million hectares) of<br />
agricultural land and cost the Thai economy<br />
over THB5.5 billion (US$139.6 million).<br />
“Canned sweet corn will continue to be a<br />
major headache this year,” one leading Thai<br />
trader told FOODNEWS. “This is because<br />
during the last season’s floods, seed companies<br />
also found their fields flooded.<br />
Therefore the output of seeds needed to sow<br />
the sweet corn fields from these companies is<br />
also going through shortages. They have also<br />
raised the price of seeds by as much as 10%.<br />
Together with this and all the higher costs<br />
accumulating in 2005 with fuel and steel<br />
prices rising, Thai packers have no choice<br />
but to force higher selling prices into the<br />
market place. However, they are receiving<br />
positive feedback right now.”<br />
“The crop should start coming out again<br />
in January and more from February onwards,<br />
but supply will certainly not be as high this<br />
year and prices will be higher,” he added.<br />
Sweet corn is usually one of <strong>Thailand</strong>’s<br />
most reliable crops as, unlike pineapple, it<br />
grows all year round and has ensured<br />
<strong>Thailand</strong> has flown past traditional European<br />
producers like France, Hungary and the US,<br />
leaving many competitors heavily bruised<br />
due to <strong>Thailand</strong>’s traditionally cheaper<br />
prices, what Thai traders have insisted is<br />
“their natural advantage”.<br />
Thai shortfall<br />
Europe’s production is mainly sold to its<br />
internal markets. However, due to the recent<br />
shortages of raw material in <strong>Thailand</strong>, rival<br />
processors have found themselves in a<br />
stronger position and been able to effectively<br />
compete and even offer more attractive<br />
prices than <strong>Thailand</strong>.<br />
To say that Europe’s sweet corn industries<br />
THAI CANNED SWEET CORN EXPORTS, ANNUAL<br />
200580 (tonnes) 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 *2005<br />
UK 1 723 4 451 10 559 12 576 16 988 16 076<br />
Korea, South 4 775 7 060 8 802 10 618 9 257 8 821<br />
Germany 3 377 2 427 4 257 7 439 9 256 8 523<br />
Netherlands 685 728 1 360 3 610 7 362 8 083<br />
Russia 32 1 382 4 429 3 013 4 555 6 863<br />
Taiwan 1 068 2 391 3 855 4 741 5 313 4 443<br />
Japan 2 238 2 212 757 3 440 3 882 4 153<br />
Spain 3 0 2 998 5 198 4 241 3 573<br />
Philippines 1 065 1 640 1 534 1 787 2 613 3 004<br />
Lebanon 848 1 338 1 793 1 986 2 439 2 925<br />
US 281 1 739 1 236 3 635 5 000 2 864<br />
United Arab Emirates 93 247 391 452 746 2 457<br />
Australia 164 226 423 229 768 2 354<br />
Sweden 578 582 1 323 1 592 3 196 2 162<br />
Others 8 939 9 425 13 726 15 802 20 190 23 423*<br />
Total 25 869 35 848 57 443 76 118 95 806 99 724<br />
Source: National trade statistics<br />
*The figures for 2005 are not yet out for the entire year and so only run to November.<br />
would have prayed for <strong>Thailand</strong>’s downfall<br />
might be a bit harsh, but it is unlikely that<br />
processors in France and Hungary will shed<br />
many tears, as a number have seen their positions,<br />
sales and profits slump due to Thai<br />
competition.<br />
Thai sweet corn exports have risen exponentially<br />
over the last six years, and 2005’s<br />
exports are on course (full year figures have<br />
not yet been collated) to be four times larger<br />
than they were in the year 2000.<br />
UK imports to November are on course to<br />
pass 2004’s total of 17 000 tonnes, which<br />
means UK imports of Thai canned sweet<br />
corn have been growing at a mean rate of<br />
87%, although the really heavy increases<br />
may now be behind us, with demand levelling<br />
out. The year 2004 saw imports up by<br />
35%, 2003 showed a 19% rise; 2002 a 137%<br />
rise and 2001 a 158% rise. However, South<br />
Korea, the second-biggest destination, which<br />
has also previously shown strong growth<br />
over the five-year period shown, tailed off<br />
slightly in 2004, compared with 2003.<br />
With the figures for December 2005 still<br />
to arrive, it looks likely that 2005’s statistics<br />
will fall again.<br />
Germany is another destination whose<br />
appetite for Thai canned sweet corn is growing,<br />
and with the exception of 2001 when<br />
there was a slight drop, the growth has been<br />
steady and constant.<br />
With the raw material shortages <strong>Thailand</strong><br />
has experienced recently it would not be surprising<br />
to see exports for at least the first two<br />
months of <strong>2006</strong> down on those of 2005, and<br />
this will be the only really accurate gauge of<br />
how much havoc the weather has played on<br />
the country’s sweet corn industry. One thing<br />
is clear, though: one can never write off<br />
<strong>Thailand</strong>, but the Thai industry will be praying<br />
for an incident-free summer crop.<br />
European processors however, may be praying<br />
for more of the same.<br />
22
FOODNEWS ®<br />
GLOBAL JUICE DATA<br />
Available exclusively and free of charge to<br />
FOODNEWS subscribers,<br />
GLOBAL JUICE DATA brings you the<br />
very latest global trade statistics for orange,<br />
apple and pineapple juice from the major<br />
producing countries:<br />
✔ Latest month's figures<br />
✔ Year-to-date figures<br />
✔ Comparative figures for the previous year.<br />
Global Juice Data is available in print and online,<br />
giving you the chance to view the latest information<br />
in your copy of FOODNEWS, as well as online at<br />
www.agra-net.com/GJD<br />
where you can select and download your data into<br />
Excel format for easy analysis and manipulation.<br />
For more information on a<br />
subscription to<br />
FOODNEWS, including access<br />
to Global Juice Data<br />
please call<br />
+44 (0)20 7017 7500<br />
or e-mail online@agra-net.com.<br />
Alternatively, visit<br />
www.agra-net.com<br />
for full details.