Use of Gyro-MWD Technology Offshore, a Step ... - Saudi Aramco
Use of Gyro-MWD Technology Offshore, a Step ... - Saudi Aramco
Use of Gyro-MWD Technology Offshore, a Step ... - Saudi Aramco
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
<strong>Use</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Gyro</strong>-<strong>MWD</strong> <strong>Technology</strong> <strong>Offshore</strong>, a<br />
<strong>Step</strong> Change in Drilling Performance in <strong>Saudi</strong><br />
<strong>Aramco</strong><br />
Authors: Bashaar A. Al-Idi, Hasan F. Al-Sarrani, Jeff Stewart, Abhijeet Sarka and Ge<strong>of</strong>f Smith<br />
ABSTRACT<br />
Over the past few years, <strong>Saudi</strong> <strong>Aramco</strong> has achieved major<br />
efficiency improvements while drilling and completing smaller<br />
diameter hole sections. Such improvements provided sig -<br />
nificant reductions in rig time, and consequently reduced the<br />
overall operational cost. Less attention was paid to the upper<br />
hole sections due to less exposure to third party rental tools<br />
used in them. <strong>Offshore</strong> oil wells in <strong>Saudi</strong> Arabia recently<br />
experienced major savings in the 28”/22” hole section after<br />
the successful utilization <strong>of</strong> the new gyro measurement while<br />
drilling (<strong>Gyro</strong>-<strong>MWD</strong>) technology coupled with powerful<br />
performance drilling mud motors.<br />
The normal process was to drill the 22” hole section, <strong>of</strong><br />
+/- 1,050 ft, by running gyro single-shot surveys every 50 ft -<br />
100 ft drilled until the well was in a safe path away from<br />
other wells within its vicinity. After adopting the <strong>Gyro</strong>-<strong>MWD</strong><br />
system, along with a modified 22” bit and 11¼” performance<br />
mud motor, the rate <strong>of</strong> penetration (ROP) increased by 82%,<br />
thereby reducing the cost per foot.<br />
The increase in the ROP resulted in an average savings <strong>of</strong><br />
0.9 days per well (6 to 12 wells per platform) at this stage <strong>of</strong><br />
drilling. In addition, the reliability <strong>of</strong> the gyro tool face from<br />
vertical, even when inside the casing, provided confidence in<br />
drilling operations, which facilitated an increase <strong>of</strong> the weight<br />
on bit (WOB) leading to faster drilling, thereby improving the<br />
overall ROP. Furthermore, eliminating the use <strong>of</strong> a wireline to<br />
run surveys increased the safety <strong>of</strong> the operation.<br />
The success <strong>of</strong> these 22” hole sections was substantial across<br />
the board, since it was one <strong>of</strong> the challenging areas where major<br />
improvements had not taken place before in several years.<br />
This article will evaluate the new drilling practice in more<br />
detail. It will also cover the conventional drilling and<br />
operational practices, and the thorough planning stages that<br />
resulted in these fruitful savings.<br />
Nevertheless, with the recent surge in oil prices and drilling<br />
operations, coupled with the limited supply <strong>of</strong> rigs worldwide,<br />
it has caused rig rates to increase exponentially. All operating<br />
companies are now looking to improve operation time and<br />
reduce nonproductive time to optimize drilling.<br />
BACKGROUND<br />
<strong>Saudi</strong> <strong>Aramco</strong>’s increased <strong>of</strong>fshore drilling activities have given<br />
rise to collision concerns. <strong>Offshore</strong> fields in the Kingdom are<br />
congested, and new wells on the platform are planned within<br />
close proximity <strong>of</strong> existing wells. Therefore, it has become<br />
essential to practice good wellbore placement and management.<br />
Historically, multi-well platform directional drilling has<br />
presented unique challenges, especially in the initial drilling<br />
phase. New wells must be carefully navigated around existing<br />
wells and eventually steered clear <strong>of</strong> all magnetic interference<br />
to the desired target. Figure 1 shows the well spacing between<br />
each well on an <strong>of</strong>fshore platform.<br />
Because <strong>of</strong> the proximity <strong>of</strong> other wells, it is impossible to<br />
use any magnetic based survey system in the top hole part <strong>of</strong><br />
the well. Therefore, gyro survey tools are normally used to<br />
give the directional driller the azimuth and tool face data<br />
required to orient the motor and steer it through this interval.<br />
INTRODUCTION<br />
<strong>Gyro</strong> measurement while drilling (<strong>Gyro</strong>-<strong>MWD</strong>) technology<br />
was first introduced and utilized in early 2001 to replace the<br />
gyro single-shot survey system for certain applications. Due to<br />
the high equipment cost at the time, the <strong>Gyro</strong>-<strong>MWD</strong><br />
technology was not economical to run and the gyro singleshot<br />
survey still dominated the market.<br />
Fig. 1. Well spacing and layout <strong>of</strong> <strong>of</strong>fshore platform.<br />
12 WINTER 2010 SAUDI ARAMCO JOURNAL OF TECHNOLOGY
GYRO SINGLE-SHOT SURVEY<br />
<strong>Gyro</strong> single-shot orientation tools, Fig. 2, are typically run on<br />
the wireline into the well; the tool is seated above the motor or<br />
a standard <strong>MWD</strong> system in an orienting sub to provide<br />
orientation data. Normally, the gyro single-shot orientation<br />
tool is run every 50 ft to 100 ft. This continues until the<br />
wellbore clears the magnetic interference, which can take up to<br />
10 or more runs during a complex kick <strong>of</strong>f. Run time usually<br />
averages 30 to 60 minutes per run, depending on depth. This is<br />
in addition to the 30 minute average circulating time that it<br />
takes to clean the hole prior to holding the string still and<br />
running in with a wireline and the gyro single-shot tools.<br />
GYRO-<strong>MWD</strong> TECHNOLOGY<br />
The <strong>Gyro</strong>-<strong>MWD</strong>, Fig. 3, was developed so that the directional<br />
driller could benefit from having the gyro sensor as close to the<br />
bit as possible and have the ability to get fast gyro orientation<br />
survey data real-time in minutes rather than the average 30 to<br />
Fig. 2. <strong>Gyro</strong> single-shot survey tool.<br />
Fig. 3. <strong>Gyro</strong>-<strong>MWD</strong> tool.<br />
SAUDI ARAMCO JOURNAL OF TECHNOLOGY WINTER 2010 13
60 minutes in the gyro single-shot survey case, saving<br />
considerable rig time. The <strong>Gyro</strong>-<strong>MWD</strong> tool face in real-time,<br />
while full survey data can be pumped to the surface after<br />
3 minutes still time. Both gyro and magnetic readings can be<br />
obtained, which can clearly indicate the clearance from any<br />
magnetic interference existing in the wellbore.<br />
GYRO-<strong>MWD</strong> SYSTEM VS. GYRO SINGLE-SHOT<br />
SURVEY<br />
As the <strong>Gyro</strong>-<strong>MWD</strong> technology emerged, it was essential to<br />
understand what this technology can bring that makes it more<br />
competitive and what the main applications are where it would<br />
have advantages over the gyro single-shot survey. The best way<br />
to introduce this technology is by taking an in-depth look at<br />
the nature <strong>of</strong> both systems. A recent evaluation <strong>of</strong> each survey<br />
tool was conducted in five main categories: safety, wellbore<br />
geometry, rate <strong>of</strong> penetration (ROP), time savings and other<br />
applications.<br />
SAFETY<br />
Safety <strong>of</strong> the platform, wells, rigs and the people operating on<br />
the platform is without doubt the one concern that no one can<br />
ignore. <strong>Gyro</strong>-<strong>MWD</strong> facilitates a much safer operation over the<br />
conventional wireline gyro single-shot survey system. The gyro<br />
single-shot survey necessitates wireline operations, which in<br />
turn requires additional personnel and equipment on the rig,<br />
including a wireline unit and the tools that operate with it.<br />
The rigging up and rigging down for wireline operations can<br />
sometimes be dangerous as many incidents on the rig are<br />
associated with wireline operations.<br />
Another area <strong>of</strong> safety where <strong>Gyro</strong>-<strong>MWD</strong> has a major<br />
advantage over the conventional gyro single-shot survey is the<br />
avoidance <strong>of</strong> collisions. This new technology drastically<br />
reduces the chance <strong>of</strong> a collision with existing wells in the<br />
platform, and enables drillers to achieve an accurate and<br />
smooth wellbore adhering closely to the well plan due to the<br />
continuous survey information being obtained while drilling.<br />
The directional driller does not have to drill 50 ft or so to get<br />
a survey. The <strong>Gyro</strong>-<strong>MWD</strong> system is placed directly above the<br />
motor in the bottom-hole assembly (BHA), which is<br />
approximately 40 ft away from the bit. In contrast, the<br />
conventional wireline gyro single-shot system is placed on a<br />
universal borehole orientation (UBHO) sub above an <strong>MWD</strong><br />
tool, taking it 70 ft more or less away from the bit, leading to<br />
less accuracy <strong>of</strong> reading and bit projection compared to the<br />
<strong>Gyro</strong>-<strong>MWD</strong> technology.<br />
WELLBORE GEOMETRY<br />
<strong>Gyro</strong>-<strong>MWD</strong> technology also provides a better wellbore<br />
geometer as the directional driller is not drilling 50 ft to 100 ft<br />
“blind” as in the case <strong>of</strong> the gyro single-shot survey. The realtime<br />
inclination and azimuthal readings result in drilling a<br />
smoother wellbore pr<strong>of</strong>ile with no unexpected left/right turns<br />
or severe doglegs, Fig. 4.<br />
Fig. 4. Spider plot <strong>of</strong> a surface section planned vs. the section actually drilled using <strong>Gyro</strong>-<strong>MWD</strong> technology on a 10 well platform.<br />
14 WINTER 2010 SAUDI ARAMCO JOURNAL OF TECHNOLOGY
Fig. 5. Spider plot <strong>of</strong> a surface section planned vs. the section actually drilled using a wireline gyro single-shot survey.<br />
The smoother well pr<strong>of</strong>ile obtained by utilizing the <strong>Gyro</strong>-<br />
<strong>MWD</strong> technology reduces problems in running casing freely<br />
to the bottom, with more joints per hour being run. The<br />
smoother pr<strong>of</strong>ile with <strong>Gyro</strong>-<strong>MWD</strong> is evident when compared<br />
to wells drilled with a conventional gyro single-shot system,<br />
Fig. 5.<br />
RATE OF PENETRATION<br />
The gyro single-shot survey requires stopping and circulating<br />
at regular intervals prior to running the gyro in hole to obtain<br />
survey information. In these conventional operations, it is<br />
essential to control the weight on bit (WOB) to avoid<br />
excessive torque from the motor so that the wellbore does not<br />
deviate un knowingly from the planned direction, thereby<br />
limiting the optimum ROP that can be achieved.<br />
With the <strong>Gyro</strong>-<strong>MWD</strong> system’s ability to pump up<br />
continuous survey data, these limitations are eradicated.<br />
TIME SAVINGS<br />
The <strong>Gyro</strong>-<strong>MWD</strong> technology has significantly contributed to<br />
increased rig time savings. These savings are attributed to:<br />
• High ROP performance.<br />
• Negligible time spent obtaining surveys.<br />
• Elimination <strong>of</strong> standby time between connections.<br />
• Less time needed for reaming the hole and circulating.<br />
• Faster times for running casing and tripping in/out <strong>of</strong><br />
hole.<br />
OTHER APPLICATIONS<br />
Other applications for running the <strong>Gyro</strong>-<strong>MWD</strong> technology,<br />
where the economics are better, include orienting and setting<br />
whipstocks for sidetracking wells where regular <strong>MWD</strong> tools<br />
are affected due to magnetic interference.<br />
CONCLUSION<br />
The initiative to utilize the <strong>Gyro</strong>-<strong>MWD</strong> technology produced<br />
expected results. <strong>Gyro</strong>-<strong>MWD</strong> proved not only to be efficient,<br />
but also to be beneficial in increasing the ROP performance<br />
and improving the wellbore geometry. Also, the <strong>Gyro</strong>-<strong>MWD</strong><br />
system proved to be a much safer piece <strong>of</strong> equipment to<br />
operate for both the wells on the platform and the<br />
simultaneous operations on the rig. It eliminated the need for<br />
any wireline equipment, extra personnel and riging up/down<br />
wireline operations. As a result <strong>of</strong> less standby time for<br />
surveys, the <strong>Gyro</strong>-<strong>MWD</strong> technology clearly achieved a smooth<br />
penetrated hole. In conclusion, <strong>Gyro</strong>-<strong>MWD</strong> met <strong>Saudi</strong><br />
<strong>Aramco</strong>’s goal and objectives to reduce rig time and optimize<br />
operations in <strong>Saudi</strong> Arabia <strong>of</strong>fshore fields.<br />
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS<br />
The authors would like to thank the management <strong>of</strong> <strong>Saudi</strong><br />
<strong>Aramco</strong> for permission to publish this article. Also, the<br />
authors wish to thank the <strong>Saudi</strong> <strong>Aramco</strong> <strong>Offshore</strong> Drilling<br />
Department, Halliburton Sperry Drilling and Scientific<br />
Drilling for actively supporting this work and granting<br />
permission to publish this article.<br />
SAUDI ARAMCO JOURNAL OF TECHNOLOGY WINTER 2010 15
BIOGRAPHIES<br />
Bashaar A. Al-Idi has been with <strong>Saudi</strong><br />
<strong>Aramco</strong> since 1998. He worked in<br />
various operational field assignments<br />
before being appointed a Drilling<br />
Foreman in 2005. In 2009, Bashaar<br />
moved to the <strong>Offshore</strong> Engineering<br />
division to work as an <strong>Offshore</strong><br />
Drilling Engineer.<br />
He received his B.S. degree in Mechanical Engineering<br />
from Vanderbilt University, Nashville, TN.<br />
Bashaar is a current member <strong>of</strong> the Society <strong>of</strong> Petroleum<br />
Engineers (SPE).<br />
Hasan F. Al-Sarrani joined <strong>Saudi</strong><br />
<strong>Aramco</strong> in 1997, working as a Drilling<br />
Engineer for both onshore and<br />
<strong>of</strong>fshore operations. In 2008, he<br />
became acting Supervisor for the<br />
<strong>Offshore</strong> Exploration Drilling<br />
Department, and then in 2010, Hasan<br />
became an <strong>Offshore</strong> Drilling Supervisor.<br />
Jeff Stewart has been working for<br />
Sperry Drilling since 1998. He began<br />
working in 1978 in the <strong>of</strong>fshore<br />
drilling industry in various positions,<br />
ultimately as a Night Tool Pusher. Jeff<br />
has worked in the field, principally in<br />
<strong>Saudi</strong> Arabia and previously in Oman.<br />
He is currently a Directional Drilling Coordinator with the<br />
primary responsibility for <strong>of</strong>fshore operations with <strong>Saudi</strong><br />
<strong>Aramco</strong>.<br />
Abhijeet Sarkar works for Scientific<br />
Drilling Controls Co. Ltd. in the<br />
Business Development Department<br />
where he is responsible for enhancing<br />
revenues within the region by<br />
evaluating new business opportunities<br />
and targeting new clientele.<br />
Abhijeet has 4 years <strong>of</strong> experience in the oil field<br />
industry. In the early part <strong>of</strong> his career, he was assigned as<br />
a Field Engineer to run conventional gyro services in the<br />
<strong>Saudi</strong> Arabia district.<br />
Abhijeet received his B.S. degree in Administrative<br />
Studies from York University, Toronto, Canada, and his<br />
M.S. degree in International Business from the University<br />
<strong>of</strong> Wollongong, Dubai, U.A.E.<br />
Ge<strong>of</strong>f Smith is Head <strong>of</strong> Operations for<br />
Scientific Drilling Controls Co. Ltd. in<br />
<strong>Saudi</strong> Arabia. He has over 30 years <strong>of</strong><br />
experience in the oil field industry,<br />
working in the Middle East, North Sea<br />
and Far East. Ge<strong>of</strong>f has vast<br />
knowledge <strong>of</strong> the directional surveying<br />
industry and is currently managing operations for the <strong>Saudi</strong><br />
Arabia and Bahrain districts.<br />
Ge<strong>of</strong>f studied Mechanical Engineering in the U.K. and<br />
first joined Sperry Sun Middle East in 1976.<br />
16 WINTER 2010 SAUDI ARAMCO JOURNAL OF TECHNOLOGY