27.10.2014 Views

Book 1.indb - Ele-mental

Book 1.indb - Ele-mental

Book 1.indb - Ele-mental

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

D A N C E D Y N A M I C S<br />

E F F O R T & P H R A S I N G<br />

WORKBOOK<br />

& DVD COMPANION<br />

V E R A M A L E T I C<br />

© 2005<br />

2 2 E A S T 1 7 T H AV E | C O L U M B U S , O H 4 3 2 0 1 | ( 6 1 4 ) 2 9 9 - 9 9 9 9 | W W W. G R A D E A N O T E S . C O M


C O N T E N T S<br />

Preface / iii<br />

About the Author / iv<br />

Acknowledgements / v<br />

INTRODUCTION<br />

The Significance of Dance Dynamics / 1<br />

Rudolf Laban’s Contribution to the Field of Movement and Dance / 7<br />

Notes / 8<br />

P A R T A / T H E E F F O R T T H E O R Y<br />

INTRODUCTION / 9<br />

Fig. I. The Effort Graph / 12<br />

VARIATIONS WITHIN ONE MOTION FACTOR / 13<br />

Space / 14<br />

Weight / 16<br />

Time / 18<br />

Flow / 20<br />

COMBINATIONS OF TWO MOTION FACTORS / 23<br />

Space and Time: The Awake State / 24<br />

Weight and Flow: The Dreamlike State / 26<br />

Space and Flow: The Remote State / 28<br />

Weight and Time: The Near State / 30<br />

Space and Weight: The Stable State / 32<br />

Time and Flow: The Mobile State / 34<br />

Recommended Reading / 36<br />

EFFORT–SPACE (SHAPE) AFFINITIES / 37<br />

Fig. 2. The Effort Cube / 38<br />

COMBINATIONS OF THREE MOTION FACTORS / 41<br />

Space, Weight, Time: “Action Drive” or Basic Effort Actions / 42<br />

Flow, Weight, Time: “Passion-like Drive” / 46<br />

Space, Time, Flow: “Vision-like Drive” / 48<br />

Space, Weight, Flow: “Spell-like Drive” / 50<br />

Recommended Reading / 52<br />

COMBINATIONS OF FOUR MOTION FACTORS / 53<br />

Notes / 55<br />

CONTENTS / i


PART B / P H R A S I N G C L A S S I F I C A T I O N<br />

INTRODUCTION / 57<br />

Classification of Phrasing / 59<br />

Notes / 63<br />

EIGHT PHRASING TYPES / 65<br />

( I ) Even Phrasing / 65<br />

( I I ) Increasing-Intensity; Impactive / 66<br />

( I I I ) Decreasing-Intensity; Impulsive / 67<br />

( I V ) Increasing-then-Decreasing Intensity / 68<br />

( V ) Decreasing-then-Increasing Intensity / 69<br />

( V I ) Accented / 71<br />

( V I I ) Vibratory / 72<br />

( V I I I ) Resilient / 73<br />

SEQUENCING OF PHRASING / 76<br />

( A ) Consecutive / 76<br />

( B ) Concurrent / 77<br />

( C ) Overlapping / 78<br />

EIGHT PHRASING TYPES ANNOTATED WITH EFFORT SIGNS / 79<br />

( I ) Even Phrasing / 79<br />

( I I ) Increasing-Intensity Phrasing / 80<br />

( I I I ) Decreasing-Intensity Phrasing / 84<br />

( I V ) Increasing-then-Decreasing Intensity / 85<br />

( V ) Decreasing-then-Increasing Intensity / 87<br />

( V I ) Accented / 90<br />

( V I I ) Vibratory / 91<br />

( V I I I ) Resilient / 92<br />

SEQUENCING OF PHRASING / 96<br />

( A ) Consecutive / 96<br />

( B ) Concurrent / 97<br />

( C ) Overlapping / 98<br />

SUMMARY / 100<br />

APPENDIX I: Methodological Considerations / 103<br />

APPENDIX II: C.G.Jung’s Influences On Laban / 113<br />

APPENDIX III: Phrasing of Dance Qualities in Labanotation Scores / 117<br />

BIBLIOGRAPHY / 127<br />

D V D C O M P A N I O N & V I E W I N G G U I D E / 1–22<br />

ii / DANCE DYNAMICS


P R E F A C E<br />

This Workbook supports studio work in dance dynamics by facilitating interaction<br />

between the presentation of the content and the reader. Opportunities for<br />

students to generate movement examples and images accompany the introduction<br />

of every new concept. Notes about the feel of various dynamic patterns<br />

and specific movement qualities in performance and viewing are encouraged.<br />

Observation outside the class is facilitated by means of the DVD companion<br />

with video excerpts from various works.<br />

Since Rudolf Laban provided a comprehensive system for identifying movement<br />

and dance qualities, his framework is the basis for this text. Laban’s main<br />

concepts are identified and explained by means of descriptions, examples, diagrams,<br />

tables, and figures. Movement qualities are referred to as “Efforts” (the<br />

term used in the English tradition), denoting the motivation and exertion of<br />

movement. Laban’s propensity for synonyms is also pointed out.<br />

Among special features of the Workbook is the fact that the text is informed by<br />

the tradition of Laban's teaching in Europe, as it was originally formulated and<br />

reformulated by his students, as well as the development of Laban’s theories<br />

in the USA. In addition, based on Laban’s foundation, the classification and<br />

notation of Phrasing has been developed by the author, Vera Maletic. A brief<br />

review of literature clarifies the distinction between the terms “phrase” and<br />

“phrasing” in dance, and the rationale for using “phrasing” is explained. Eight<br />

types of Phrasing are defined and exemplified by way of description, notation,<br />

and video excerpts.<br />

Presentation and discussion of the two major components of dance dynamics<br />

constitute the main sections of the Workbook. PART A discusses movement<br />

qualities, or Effort, and PART B investigates Phrasing types. Rather than working<br />

through them in a linear, sequential manner, the two sections can be used<br />

concurrently.<br />

Three Appendices elaborate on the following issues:<br />

(I)<br />

(II)<br />

(III)<br />

Some methodological approaches to the teaching-learning processes<br />

A consideration of C. G. Jung’s influences on Laban<br />

The application of Effort and Phrasing in qualitative annotations of<br />

Labanotation scores<br />

A general Bibliography concludes the text.<br />

A DVD viewing guide complements the disc in the back of the book.<br />

PREFACE / iii


A B O U T T H E A U T H O R<br />

VERA MALETIC is Professor Emerita in dance at The Ohio State University.<br />

She earned her M.A. from the University of Zagreb, Croatia (history of art<br />

and culture), and Ph.D. from The Ohio State University (interdisciplinary).<br />

Having received her initial Laban training from her mother, Ana Maletic, one of<br />

Laban’s disciples in Europe, Maletic subsequently studied at the Laban Centre<br />

in England, where she earned the Laban diploma.<br />

While in Zagreb, she was the choreographer and artistic director of the Studio<br />

for Contemporary Dance, creating works for stage, film, and television in former<br />

Yugoslavia, Austria, and Sweden.<br />

During her subsequent teaching appointment at the Laban Centre (1966–77),<br />

she classified Laban’s manuscripts, which contributed to her insights into the<br />

roots of the Laban theory. Since the late 1970s, her background was expanded<br />

and informed by interpretations and developments of Laban’s theories in the<br />

United States, particularly through the work and writings of Irmgard Bartenieff<br />

and Martha Davis, as well as professional exchanges with the late Robert Ellis<br />

Dunn. Her book, Body-Space-Expression: The Development of Rudolf Laban’s<br />

Movement and Dance Concepts, was published by Mouton de Gruyter in<br />

1987.<br />

At The Ohio State University’s Department of Dance (1980–2000), Maletic<br />

developed the curriculum in several directions. She taught courses based on<br />

Laban’s framework dealing with the spatial structure and dynamics of dance.<br />

Maletic also developed courses in analysis of choreographic style and in postmodern<br />

dance. She spearheaded the dance and technology area, including<br />

Videodance and approaches to CD-ROM for dance documentation. Maletic<br />

was primary co-investigator in two multimedia projects funded by the National<br />

Initiative to Preserve America’s Dance.<br />

Currently she divides her time between activities in Columbus and Zagreb,<br />

Croatia. This includes bilingual writing and projects in dance documentation<br />

by means of technology.<br />

iv<br />

/ DANCE DYNAMICS


A C K N O W L E D G M E N T S<br />

The author wishes to thank:<br />

Melanie Bales, Associate Professor, for her collaboration particularly in providing<br />

dance examples for various Effort qualities and Phrasing types.<br />

Lucy Venable, Professor Emerita, for the annotation of scores in Appendix III,<br />

and comments on Phrasing symbols in general.<br />

Vickie Blaine and Odette Blum, Professors Emeritae, for their input regarding<br />

both the contents and the form of the text.<br />

Certified Movement Analysts Melanie Bales, Peggy Berger, and Jeff Friedman for<br />

their responses and suggestions from the points of view of the American Laban<br />

dialects.<br />

Clark Leavitt, Professor Emeritus, for challenging some assumptions based on<br />

dance theory.<br />

Warren Lamb, for providing the opportunity to view a copy of a letter written to<br />

him by Laban in 1952.<br />

Edward Luna, MA candidate in dance, for redesigning the workbook and contributing<br />

suggestions from a student’s point of view.<br />

The Dance Preservation Fund at The Ohio State University Department of Dance,<br />

for funding the production of the 2005 revised edition of the workbook.<br />

Motus Humanus, for a seed money grant towards the production of the DVD<br />

companion.<br />

Jeanine Thompson, for giving her time and talent for recording the DVD voiceover.<br />

Special thanks are due to the following choreographers and performers for permission<br />

to include excerpts of their work in the DVD companion:<br />

Melanie Bales: choreographer and performer; Balinda Craig-Quijada: choreographer<br />

and performer; Karen Eliot: choreographer and performer; Zvi<br />

Gotheiner: choreographer; Susan Hadley: choreographer; Irene Hultman:<br />

choreographer; Kristina Isabelle: choreographer, improviser, and performer;<br />

Rosalind Pierson: choreographer; Noel Reiss: choreographer; Susan<br />

Sanborn: choreographer and performer; Jeanine Thompson: choreographer<br />

and performer; Susan Van Pelt: choreographer and performer.<br />

The following Ohio State University MFA and BFA students gave permission for<br />

the inclusion of their work:<br />

Joe Alter: composition; Robin Anderson: composition and performance;<br />

Lauren Bisio: performance; Ama Codjoe: performance; Teena Custer:<br />

performance; Michael Estanich: composition, improvisation and perfor-<br />

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS / v


mance; Keren Ganin-Pinto: performance; Luke Gutsgell: performance;<br />

Chad Hall: composition and performance; Kristin Hapke: composition<br />

and performance; Jason Hedden: juggling; Kamilah Levens: performance;<br />

Scott Lowe: composition, improvisation, and performance; Christina<br />

Providence: improvisation and performance; Michelle Stortz: performance;<br />

Marc Woten: improvisation and performance.<br />

Notations and graphs on LabanWriter by Gina Jacobson.<br />

—V. MALETIC, December 2004<br />

vi / DANCE DYNAMICS


I N T R O D U C T I O N<br />

THE SIGNIFICANCE OF DANCE DYNAMICS<br />

Past and present<br />

For centuries dance traditions of various cultures were based on demonstrating<br />

and replicating movement sequences. This left in abeyance not only the<br />

development of consistent vocabularies for describing the strands of dance but<br />

also comprehensive notation systems, and theoretical frameworks. Even now<br />

at the beginning of the new millennium, many significant components of dance<br />

are taken for granted within the practice of teaching-learning, choreographing,<br />

and coaching; a certain reluctance to identify them verbally and discuss them<br />

theoretically still survives. Granted, it is not easy to pin down and define this<br />

ephemeral art form that has its own means of non-verbal communication. This<br />

may be the reason for the scarcity of theoretical considerations of the dynamics<br />

of dance.<br />

Questions of terminology<br />

Dynamics as related to movement and dance is interpreted in many different<br />

ways. A recent publication—Dance Words 1 —contains entries that have been<br />

collected from various sources, such as classes, rehearsals, workshops, publications,<br />

texts on dance films, and interviews. Collecting entries for the section on<br />

movement as such proved to be most problematic, perhaps due to its non-verbal<br />

nature. Great variations in approaches and descriptions are found in entries<br />

under the title of “Dynamics and Energy” but have in common references to<br />

texture, coloring, and expression of feelings and emotions. The term dynamics<br />

is also used interchangeably with the term energy. 2<br />

Ana Maletic, for instance, makes the distinction between “dynamics” and<br />

“dynamicity.” While “dynamics” refers to the intensity and weight aspects of<br />

movement, “dynamicity” refers to “the energy as a result of all motion factors.”<br />

3<br />

In this text the term dance dynamics is used as an overall designation pertaining<br />

to the phrasing of movement energy. Movement qualities, on the other<br />

hand, denote specific colorings or the textures of movement. Both terms refer<br />

INTRODUCTION / 1


to movement intent or expression. Issues of emotional, kinetic, conceptual,<br />

and other motivations are discussed with reference to contemporary theatrical<br />

dance, and various other dance traditions.<br />

Dynamics as part of some dance traditions<br />

In many dance traditions, terminology is generated from movement qualities<br />

and dynamics that characterizes various dances. Here are some examples:<br />

In Javanese traditional dance there are three basic principles that address dance<br />

dynamics. The first one is wiraga, described as a way the dancer controls the<br />

movement while traveling smoothly and evenly as a breeze through a palm tree<br />

(for female) or flowing water (for male). The second principle, wirasa, deals<br />

with the dancers’ capacity to express feeling that would be communicated to<br />

the audience. The third principle, wirama, refers to tempo and rhythm which<br />

are considered indispensable elements of dance. 4<br />

Different emotions embodied through breathing rhythms are an intrinsic aspect<br />

of traditional dances of Korea. Breathing is a central force that influences the<br />

body movement and creates different qualities. Ogae Jit<br />

(shoulder movement)<br />

makes the breathing visible through a slight rise and fall. For instance in Salpuri<br />

Chum the emotion of Han, including sadness, anger, and discontent, may be<br />

marked by deep exhalation. It has to be overcome by the dancer to achieve<br />

Heung, a state of joy, pleasure, and excitement. 5<br />

The qualities of resiliency, bounciness of the whole body, has been observed in<br />

many forms of a ritual dance performed in the Central Philippines, called sinulog.<br />

This quality is seen as linked to some healthy patterns of life, and can be<br />

found in both traditional and non-traditional dancing. 6<br />

Resilient step patterns, the so-called drmez, in dances of Croatia, have been<br />

among the most characteristic motives in circle dances—kolos of plains or flat<br />

ground regions. They are reminiscent of ancient work motives imitating treading<br />

and crushing corn. The vertical emphasis of resilient shifts of weight, alternating<br />

with lively vibration, both gives in and resists the pull of gravity. 7<br />

Capoeira Angola, an Afro-Brazilian game/dance/fight, is often ironically called<br />

vadiação (or “doing nothing in particular”); indicating a relaxed but highly<br />

alert attitude appropriate to a street-oriented form. This attitude is demonstrated<br />

dynamically in a series of casual feints called mandinga (or “sorcery”), used<br />

to distract the opponent and disguise one’s true intentions. Likewise, a player<br />

adept at malícia (“treachery” or “double dealing”) may collaborate closely with<br />

the opponent, only to interrupt the game with a surprise attack. 8<br />

2 / DANCE DYNAMICS


The terminology of classical ballet contains some basic forms of dynamic movement,<br />

in other words dance vocabulary, such as battu or battement (“hit” or<br />

“thrusting”), coupé<br />

(“cut”),<br />

glissé<br />

(“glide” or “slide-like”),<br />

fouetté<br />

(“slashed”<br />

or “whipped”), and jeté (“thrown”), are named according to the quality of their<br />

performance. This terminology, created by French dancing masters of the 18th<br />

century, inspired Laban to name his basic Effort actions, such as thrusting, gliding,<br />

slashing, etc. 9<br />

The staccato, hard and fast angularity of urban American street-dance (as seen<br />

in the work of Rennie Harris Puremovement, for example) demonstrates the<br />

fluidity and multirhythmic ease found in much of West African vernacular<br />

dance. 10<br />

Moreover, in the culture of hip-hop dance, many terms have dynamic<br />

connotations. “B-boy” or “b-girl” break dancers may have taken their name<br />

from the “break”; a percussive interlude found on many funk recordings of the<br />

1960s–’70s, which is often “broken” and remixed by a DJ. Other terms, such as<br />

“popping” and “locking,” describe impactive gestures fragmented by stillness.<br />

The term “hip-hop” itself (perhaps derived from “hep,” or fashionable) betrays<br />

the importance of pelvic movements which are readily visible in the form. 11<br />

This brief survey has shown how various motivations—such as representing<br />

gender differences, particular emotional states, some healthy patterns of life,<br />

work actions, combat-like dance tactics, and descriptive language—have created<br />

patterns in different traditions and served as the basis for movement and<br />

dance-derived terminology.<br />

Some theoretical considerations of Dynamics<br />

The first theoretical reflections on the expressive aspect of Western theatrical<br />

dance started to emerge in periods of “expressive crises.” The decline of the<br />

courtly ballet in eighteenth-century France motivated Jean George Noverre<br />

(1727–1810) to write his Letters on Dancing and Ballets, a severe critique of<br />

the use of sheer virtuosity, stereotyped movement and mask; he urged that the<br />

link between movement and meaning be visible and that expression should be<br />

given preference over virtuosity. 12<br />

The Industrial Revolution and subsequent<br />

periods of decline of theatrical dance in the second half of the nineteenth century,<br />

prompted persons such as Delsarte and Duncan to address expression<br />

in performance, practically and theoretically. Francois Delsarte (1811–1871)<br />

formulated principles, laws and orders of movement expression with particular<br />

reference to actors and singers. Several of his American disciples and followers<br />

(such as Genevieve Stebbins, and Ted Shawn) applied Delsarte’s principles<br />

to dance. 13<br />

The foremost endeavor of Isadora Duncan (1878–1927) was the<br />

desire to express her being in movement and dance; she “sought the source<br />

of the spiritual expression to flow into the channels of the body filling it with<br />

vibrating light. . . .” 14<br />

INTRODUCTION / 3


The development of technology between the two World Wars, and the emergence<br />

of modern dance in Europe, was the background of Rudolf Laban’s<br />

investigations into the common denominators of the dynamics of movement<br />

expression referred to as Effort. Because of its systematic classification, his<br />

theory is “one of the most important for modern dance thought.” 15<br />

Since the 1940s several American dance educators and choreographers have<br />

also acknowledged the significance of the constituents of dance dynamics. For<br />

instance, Margareth H’Doubler states that “to execute any movement, we<br />

must make an effort; this effort consists of an expenditure of energy. . . . Since<br />

energy is a determining factor in the character of expressiveness of movement<br />

it is interesting to consider actions with respect to the way energy is released to<br />

produce them.” 16<br />

Doris Humphrey refers to dynamics as the ingredient that adds spice and interest<br />

to living as well as dancing, and argues that “dynamics is the lifeblood of<br />

the dance, and is ignored at the peril of your existence as an artist.” 17<br />

Alma<br />

Hawkins discusses the perceptual dimensions of dance qualities, and maintains<br />

that the aesthetic quality of dance movement is determined by the flow and<br />

control of energy. She further explains that:<br />

Energy, or force, is the source of movement, and it is also the basic<br />

ingredient in the aesthetic qualities of dance. The choreographer controls<br />

the dynamic flow of the dance through a sensitive organization of<br />

movement tension. The play of forces set in action by the structured<br />

movement tensions evokes a kinesthetic response in the perceiver and<br />

thus enables the dancer to communicate. The tension aspect of the<br />

movement causes the observer to empathize or “feel into” the dance<br />

and thus perceive its import. 18<br />

Drawing on her experience as a dance viewer and philosopher of art, Susanne<br />

Langer wrote in the 1950s that:<br />

In watching a dance, you do not see what is physically before you—<br />

people running or twisting their bodies; what you see is a display of<br />

interacting forces, by which the dance seems to be lifted, driven, drawn,<br />

closed, or attenuated, whether it be solo or choric, whirling like the end<br />

of a dervish dance, or slow, centered, and single in motion. . . . The<br />

forces we seem to perceive most directly and convincingly are created<br />

for our perception; and they exist only for it. 19<br />

4 / DANCE DYNAMICS


Descriptions of Dance Dynamics in various contexts<br />

Within their mode of description, dance critics, historians, theorists, and filmmakers<br />

frequently depict movement qualities, for example: (Emphases are the<br />

author’s.)<br />

[Sara] Rudner likes to play off opposites against each other. One is the<br />

disparity between an inward, nonspecific focus and an outward, alert<br />

riveting of her attention. We see it in the first dance as she oscillates gently<br />

inside her body, feeling a flow,<br />

nothing more, then suddenly straightens<br />

and looks to the side as if an alien noise had surprised her. (Marcia<br />

B. Siegel, The Tail of the Dragon, New Dance, 1976–1982. Durham,<br />

NC: Duke University Press, 1991. 17.)<br />

[Blondell] Cummings’ performing presence is intensified by her quick<br />

hand gestures and split-second changes of facial expression that contrast<br />

dramatically with her slower, more fluid<br />

shifts of weight. ( Ann Cooper<br />

Albright, “Auto-Body Stories: Blondell Cummings and Autobiography<br />

in Dance.” Meaning in Motion, J. Desmond ed. Durham, NC: Duke<br />

University Press, 1997. 191.)<br />

As the dancers attempt to extend the duet encounter, movement phrases<br />

lengthen and the quality of movement extends beyond passive free<br />

falling. At times, dancers control the movement in order to guide the<br />

momentum of an encounter or keep it going. They also direct their<br />

movement with intentional strength or lightness in order to guide a<br />

fall. (Cynthia Novack, Sharing the Dance: Contact Improvisation and<br />

American Culture. Madison, WI: University of Madison Press, 1990.<br />

66.)<br />

She [Meredith Monk] poses sharply,<br />

rooted in a wide stance: one outstretched<br />

arm points up, and her face is startled, startling. Then care-<br />

fully,<br />

she removes her wig, jumps off the platform, and moves to the<br />

middle phase of her life/dance. (Leslie Satin, “Being Danced Again:<br />

Meredith Monk, Reclaiming the Girlchild.” Moving Words: Re-writing<br />

Dance. New York: Routledge, 1996. 134.)<br />

Slowly the man touches the woman beside him, . . . the restless thrash-<br />

ing body before them suddenly seeming to communicate as anguish<br />

that complements their drowsy affection. (Jennifer Dunning, “Images of<br />

Light and Dark Connect East to West.” Review of Akram Khan’s Kaash.<br />

The New York Times, Oct. 18, 2003.)<br />

INTRODUCTION / 5


An admirable and fairly unique quality of Dan Wagoner is his weight. .<br />

. . in the way his movements are weighted. It looks as if he were press-<br />

ing against heavy water rather than air. The effect is quite different from<br />

the kind of dancing that gives the illusion of flitting<br />

or<br />

floating. The<br />

viewer is involved in seeing the energy that pressed into the floor or lifts<br />

out of it. This is a quality of his that shows consistently, whether he is<br />

moving slowly or quickly, in the air or on all fours. You see this and are<br />

glad that gravity can be a dancer’s partner. (Paul Taylor, “Down with<br />

Choreography.” The Modern Dance: Seven Statements of Belief. S. J.<br />

Cohen ed. Middletown, CN: Wesleyan University Press, 1966. 92.)<br />

Movement qualities are the result of personality, of height and weight,<br />

of involuntary mannerisms, or rehearsed efforts, of musical response,<br />

of the whole body, or of only isolated parts, and on and on. So much<br />

goes into the making of the qualities that define the particular artwork<br />

that is the dance itself. One must see and think a good deal to see subtle<br />

movement qualities. (Gerald Myers, “Do You See What the Critic Sees?”<br />

Philosophical Essays on Dance, 1981. 48.)<br />

Meaning [in film] is conveyed—or should be—by the quality of what is<br />

seen rather than by what is said. The more attention is paid to stylizing<br />

the screen, to making the quality of how it looks convey the meaning,<br />

the closer you get to dance, which is precisely that—the communication<br />

of meaning through the quality of movement. (Maya Deren, quoted by<br />

Leslie Satin in “Movement and the Body in Maya Deren’s Meshes of the<br />

Afternoon.” Women & Performance: A Journal of Feminist Theory, vol.<br />

6, no. 2, 1993. 41.)<br />

As the eight performers come and go, thrashing<br />

or<br />

worming<br />

into move-<br />

ment, heads cock, hips and elbows jut, backs sway, shoulders roll<br />

and<br />

hike, knees collapse, feet strike out<br />

into space . . . either simultaneously<br />

or in rapid succession, as if the dancers were trying to direct<br />

their body<br />

parts toward various directions in space. (Deborah Jowitt, “How Many<br />

Ways To Twist It?” Review of “The Room as it Was,” performed by<br />

the Ballett Frankfurt, choreographed by William Forsythe. The Village<br />

Voice, October 8–14, 2003.)<br />

Assignment<br />

Pay attention to descriptions of dance qualities in dance books, journals, and<br />

newspaper articles. Sample the descriptions that you find helpful in visualizing<br />

the dance.<br />

6 / DANCE DYNAMICS


RUDOLF LABAN’S CONTRIBUTIONS TO THE FIELD OF MOVEMENT AND DANCE<br />

Who was Laban?<br />

Rudolf Laban’s (1879–1958) multiple experiences as artist-designer, dancer,<br />

choreographer, director, teacher, work-study adviser, and remedial consultant,<br />

provided a foundation for the formulation of his theoretical framework.<br />

Laban’s acquaintance with the heritage of dance and traditional thinking on<br />

one hand, and his exploration of anatomy, psychology, and crystallography on<br />

the other, significantly contributed to the forming of his theories. Contrary to<br />

traditional approaches to the study of dance, such as learning steps and movement<br />

sequences, Laban believed that in order to gain a mindful approach to<br />

movement and dance, their underlying principles must be understood. His view<br />

of modern dance as human expression connected with universal forms of movement<br />

brought him to seek movement elements as common denominators of all<br />

types of movement—in everyday life, work, and the performing arts.<br />

His major contributions<br />

Three major systems of movement and dance classification constitute Laban’s<br />

theoretical framework:<br />

(i)<br />

(ii)<br />

(iii)<br />

A comprehensive movement analysis and description that also underlies<br />

his system of notation—Kinetography Laban or Labanotation 20<br />

The theory of spatial relationships of movement and dance referred to<br />

as Space Harmony or Choreutics 21<br />

The theory dealing with the dynamic structure of movement known as<br />

Eukinetics and Effort 22<br />

Laban’s funda<strong>mental</strong> view of the unity of all movement components is apparent<br />

in his concept of a general movement harmony; it considers the affinities<br />

between the movement’s energy or Effort and its placement or unfolding in<br />

space. 23 This concept was later developed into the “Effort/Shape” methodology<br />

of movement observation and training in the U.S.A. 24<br />

INTRODUCTION / 7


Notes for Introduction<br />

1. Valerie Preston-Dunlop, compiler, Dance Words (Choreography and Dance Studies,<br />

Vol. 8, 1995).<br />

2. Preston-Dunlop, Dance Words, 268–273.<br />

3. Ana Maletic, Pokret i Ples (Zagreb: Kulturno-prosvjetni sabor Hrvatske, 1983) 45.<br />

4. Sal Murgiyanto, , “Seeing and Writing about World Dance: An Insider’s View,” in<br />

Dance Critic’s Association News (Summer 1990) 7.<br />

5. Si-Hyun Yoo, Young-Sook Han’s Salpuri Chum: Labanotation and Stylistic Analysis of<br />

a Traditional Korean Dance (Master’s thesis, The Ohio State University, 1995).<br />

6. Sally Ann Ness, Body, Movement, and Culture: Kinesthetic and Visual Symbolism in a<br />

Philippine Community (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1992)<br />

222–224.<br />

7. Ana Maletic, Knjiga o Plesu (Zagreb: Kulturno-prosvjetni sabor Hrvatske, 1986) 316.<br />

8. Edward Luna, from Master’s thesis in progress (The Ohio State University, 2004–05).<br />

9. Rudolf Laban, Choreutics (London: Macdonald & Evans, 1966) 30.<br />

10. Brenda Dixon Gottschild, Digging the Africanist Presence in American Performance<br />

Dance and Other Contexts (Westport, CN: Greenwood Press, 1996) 158-59.<br />

11. See, for example, the definition of the adjective “hip”( or “hep”) in the Fourth Edition of<br />

The American Heritage Dictionary (Boston: Houghton Mifflin Company, 2000), which<br />

refers to a the Wolof (Senegal) word hipi, or hepi, meaning “to open one’s eyes, be aware.”<br />

12. Jean-Georges Noverre, Letters on Dancing and Ballets, transl. C. W. Beaumont<br />

(London: Beaumont, 1951, first published 1930).<br />

13. Genevieve Stebbins, Delstarte System of Expression (New York: Dance Horizons,<br />

1977, originally published in 1902), and Ted Shawn, Every Little Movement<br />

(Pittsfield, MA: Eagle Printing and Binding Co., 1954, first published in 1910).<br />

14. Isadora Duncan, My Life (New York: Garden City Publishing Co., 1927) 75.<br />

15. Selma Jeanne Cohen, “Dance as an Art of Imitation,” in What is Dance? Roger<br />

Copeland & Marshall Cohen, eds. (New York: Oxford University Press, 1983) 19.<br />

16. Margaret H’Doubler, Dance: A Creative Art Experience (Madison, WI: University of<br />

Wisconsin Press, 1966) 79.<br />

17. Doris Humphrey, The Art of Making Dances (New York: Grove Press, 1959) 102.<br />

18. Alma Hawkins, Creating through Dance (Englewood Cliffs, NY: Prentice Hall, 1964)<br />

34–35.<br />

19. Susanne K. Langer, Problems of Art (New York: Scribner’s, 1957) 5.<br />

20. Rudolf Laban, Principles of Dance and Movement Notation (London: Macdonald &<br />

Evans, 1956).<br />

21. _________. Choreutics (London: Macdonald & Evans, 1966).<br />

22. _________. & F. C. Lawrence, Effort (London: Macdonald & Evans, 1947).<br />

23. _________. Choreutics, 31–36.<br />

24. Vera Maletic, Body-Space-Expression: The Development of Rudolf Laban’s Movement<br />

and Dance Concepts (Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter, 1987) 78.<br />

8 / DANCE DYNAMICS


P A R T A /<br />

T H E E F F O R T T H E O R Y<br />

INTRODUCTION<br />

Sources for theory<br />

The concept of Effort and its theory is presented in several of Laban’s English<br />

books. 1<br />

The first one, Effort, published in 1947, was an outcome of Laban’s<br />

collaboration with F. C. Lawrence, a management consultant in industry;<br />

Lawrence had invited Laban to record industrial processes and to assist with<br />

work-study. While this first book focuses on Effort in work and industry, the<br />

1948 book Modern Educational Dance proposes a new dance education or a<br />

“free dance technique,” based on the practice of Effort sequences. The 1950<br />

book The Mastery of Movement on the Stage, and its subsequent editions as<br />

The Mastery of Movement (1960, 1970, 1980), elaborate on Effort expression<br />

in mime, acting, and dance.<br />

Development of theory<br />

Laban’s first investigations into the dynamic structure of movement focused<br />

on expressive qualities in dance. In the ‘20s and ‘30s he referred to this area as<br />

Eukinetics (Eu, “good” and Kinesis, “movement”), and defined it as exploring<br />

“good movement” in terms of harmonic principles in dance. 2<br />

As a complement<br />

to Eukinetics, in the ‘40s, Laban developed the Effort theory that considers the<br />

various qualities of mind-body movement involved in human exertion in general.<br />

Laban’s term Effort differs from its common usage of denoting activity that<br />

requires substantial expenditure of energy.<br />

The concept of Effort<br />

Laban sees Effort as the inner impulse—a movement sensation, a thought,<br />

a feeling or emotion—from which movement originates; it constitutes the<br />

interface between <strong>mental</strong> and physical components of movement. This inner<br />

impulse or motivation is expressed by way of Motion Factors. Accordingly,<br />

every human movement, including thought, has the potential to engage the Four<br />

Motion Factors—Space, Weight, Time, and Flow.<br />

The particular emphasis on,<br />

or selections from, these factors make up what Laban calls the characteristic<br />

Effort patterns of a person (or an actor’s and dancer’s role).<br />

THE EFFORT THEORY / 9


More specifically the Effort patterns result from bi-polar inner attitudes of<br />

accepting, yielding to the physical conditions influencing movement or resisting,<br />

fighting against them. The moving person’s attitudes of accepting or resisting<br />

the four Motion Factors result in bi-polar Effort qualities* or Effort <strong>Ele</strong>ments<br />

of: SPACE—indirect or flexible, and direct; WEIGHT—light, and strong;<br />

TIME—sustained, and sudden, and FLOW—free, and bound. The attitudes<br />

of accepting or resisting may not always be voluntarily exercised but can also<br />

occur unconsciously and automatically.<br />

*The term Effort qualities is used to denote single or combined Effort element.<br />

MOTION FACTORS<br />

EFFORT ELEMENTS<br />

accepting<br />

resisting<br />

Space INDIRECT or FLEXIBLE DIRECT<br />

Weight LIGHT STRONG<br />

Time SUSTAINED SUDDEN<br />

Flow FREE BOUND<br />

Laban further associates four phases of the mover’s inner participation with the<br />

Motion Factors as follows: Attention is associated with Space, Intention with<br />

Weight, Decision with Time, 3 and Progression 4 with Flow.<br />

In addition, Laban also associates the emphasis on Space with a person’s power<br />

of Thinking, Weight with Sensing, Time with Intuiting, and Flow with Feeling. 5<br />

Since these powers loosely correspond to C. G. Jung’s theory of function types,<br />

there are frequent references to Jungian influences on Laban [See Appendix II<br />

for further discussion].<br />

MOTION FACTORS<br />

INNER PARTICIPATION<br />

with phases of<br />

"Powers of"<br />

Space ATTENTION THINKING<br />

Weight INTENTION SENSING<br />

Time DECISION INTUITING<br />

Flow PROGRESSION FEELING<br />

10 / DANCE DYNAMICS


How do all these strands relate to the performance and observation of Effort<br />

qualities?<br />

Movement with emphasis on the Motion factor of SPACE is associated with<br />

the cognitive capacity or power of Thinking, and can bring about Attention to<br />

direct channeling of the focus of movement or give it a multi-focused, indirect<br />

quality. This may be manifested as clarity of thought and/or performance.<br />

Movement with greater emphasis on the Motion Factor of WEIGHT is associated<br />

with Sensing and can bring about strong or light Intention. This may show<br />

in the context of <strong>mental</strong> work, and/or in a display of strength or delicacy in<br />

performance.<br />

Movement that shows predominance of the Motion Factor of TIME may indicate<br />

an Intuitive readiness for Decision making, either suddenly or with sustainment.<br />

This may manifest itself in thinking, and/or showing a good sense of<br />

rhythm in performance.<br />

The emphasis on the Motion factor of FLOW is related to feeling that can<br />

bind or free its Progression. This can show as holding back or being outgoing<br />

in communication, and/or as performing great nuances in the progression of<br />

movement or dance.<br />

The concept of the Effort Graph<br />

The innumerable variety of the moving person’s situations or actions, creates<br />

a range of dynamic qualities of movement. It arises from the choices between<br />

either an accepting, yielding attitude, or resisting, fighting against attitude.<br />

These attitudes are also visually represented in the design of the Effort Graph,<br />

that facilitates the descriptive or prescriptive application of the Effort theory.<br />

(See FIG. 1, overleaf.) For example, while the execution of an arm gesture may<br />

be described as direct and bound (Space, Flow), the qualities for an efficient<br />

performance of a long leap forward may be described as direct, sudden and free<br />

(Space, Time, Flow).<br />

THE EFFORT THEORY / 11


F I G . 1 : T H E E F F O R T G R A P H<br />

ACCEPTING<br />

RESISTING<br />

M O T I O N F A C T O R S<br />

E F F O R T E L E M E N T S<br />

Space<br />

INDIRECT<br />

OR FLEXIBLE<br />

DIRECT<br />

Weight<br />

LIGHT<br />

STRONG<br />

Time<br />

SUSTAINED<br />

SUDDEN<br />

Flow<br />

FREE<br />

BOUND<br />

12 / DANCE DYNAMICS


Predominant variations within ONE MOTION FACTOR<br />

In considering Laban’s Effort theory one has to keep in mind that the dynamic<br />

structure or quality of a particular movement gains its full significance or meaning<br />

only when it is related to what precedes and what follows. In other words,<br />

one has to view it within a movement sequence or a context of phrasing. This<br />

also points to the fact that most frequently qualities are present only for a<br />

moment before they transform.<br />

One movement quality seldom appears in isolation. A predominance of variations<br />

within one Motion Factor may, however, indicate a particular preference.<br />

Thus for study purposes we will consider each Motion Factor and the contrasting<br />

Effort <strong>Ele</strong>ments* separately, including clarification of:<br />

(a)<br />

The significance of those instances where the predominance of one<br />

Motion Factor is observed; descriptions of characteristics of the Effort<br />

elements<br />

(b)<br />

Quantitative and qualitative aspects of Effort qualities*<br />

(c)<br />

Suggested ways of engaging the body to facilitate and enhance the<br />

performance of Effort qualities<br />

(d)<br />

Affinities between Effort elements and spatial areas<br />

(e)<br />

Observations of Effort qualities in self and others (noting that qualities<br />

can be experienced as thought or movement actions)<br />

(f)<br />

Examples of instances where one quality changes to its opposite (in<br />

recognition of the momentary value of these)<br />

*In this description terms Effort elements, Effort qualities, and qualities are<br />

used interchangeably.<br />

ONE MOTION FACTOR / 13


S P A C E<br />

(a) The emphasis on attitudes toward Space can be associated with the cognitive<br />

capacities of orienting, attending, and organizing. The inner participation or<br />

faculty of “Attention” can give movement a multi-focused, indirect, or flexible<br />

quality; or channel the focus of movement into a direct, pinpointing quality. Its<br />

mastery can give clarity to dance execution, including the dancer’s alignment<br />

and his/her relation to the environment.<br />

The two Effort elements of the Motion Factor Space are:<br />

INDIRECT or FLEXIBLE<br />

accepting the 3-dimensionality of space<br />

MANIFESTED AS<br />

· encompassing<br />

· multi-focused<br />

· with all-round attention<br />

DIRECT<br />

resisting the plasticity of space<br />

MANIFESTED AS<br />

· narrowing down<br />

· focused<br />

· pinpointing<br />

YOUR DESCRIPTIONS<br />

(b) A distinction from the measurable, quantitative aspects of space, i.e. shape and<br />

size should be kept in mind:<br />

INDIRECT or FLEXIBLE<br />

is not the same as wavy, curved, twisted<br />

design, but does coincide with a plastic,<br />

three-dimensional movement<br />

DIRECT<br />

does not mean a straight line, but does<br />

coincide with linear, one-dimensional<br />

movement<br />

(c) Ways of engaging the body can enhance the performance of<br />

INDIRECT or FLEXIBLE<br />

shows a tendency toward a combination<br />

of twisting, bending-extending actions<br />

of several parts of the body (Body flow*<br />

tends to be more successive, sequential)<br />

DIRECT<br />

shows a tendency toward aligning the<br />

joints and performing bending and<br />

extending actions (Body flow* is more<br />

likely to be simultaneous)<br />

14 / DANCE DYNAMICS<br />

*Body flow refers to sequencing the movement either in a successive, sequential way, where one body<br />

part moves after the other, or in a simultaneous way, where several parts move at the same time.


(d) Affinities with areas in space:<br />

INDIRECT or FLEXIBLE<br />

open movements into the unrestricted<br />

areas of the sides of the body<br />

DIRECT<br />

movements across the body as creating<br />

an obstacle to the three-dimensional use<br />

of space<br />

YOUR DESCRIPTIONS<br />

(e) Description of bi-polar qualities as observed in self and others:<br />

INDIRECT or FLEXIBLE<br />

INSTRUCTOR’S EXAMPLES<br />

· I am alert to many points of view.<br />

· Jane is an alert person.<br />

· I am performing a spiral fall.<br />

· The Spinning of the Dervishes is<br />

three-dimensional.<br />

DIRECT<br />

INSTRUCTOR’S EXAMPLES<br />

· I am zeroing in and pursuing the<br />

problem.<br />

· He is really concentrating.<br />

· I am moving through the space.<br />

· Her arabesque is clearly designed.<br />

[Note that examples include qualities experienced as thought or movement actions.]<br />

YOUR EXAMPLES<br />

(f) Examples of instances where one quality of Space changes to its opposite:<br />

INSTRUCTOR’S EXAMPLES<br />

· From an all-round awareness of the classroom to spotting a particular student.<br />

· From a spiral fall into an elongated body shape on the floor.<br />

[Note that examples include qualities experienced as thought or movement actions.]<br />

YOUR EXAMPLES<br />

ONE MOTION FACTOR / 15


W E I G H T<br />

(a) The predominance of Weight qualities may indicate sensing or sensibility for<br />

assuming light or firm “Intention” towards an action, ranging from lighthearted<br />

to assertive. By monitoring various muscular tensions, the dancer can display<br />

strength or delicacy in performance.<br />

The two Effort elements of the Motion Factor Weight are:<br />

LIGHT<br />

accepting or adjusting to gravity<br />

MANIFESTED AS<br />

· fine touch<br />

· delicate<br />

· sensitive<br />

STRONG<br />

resisting the pull of gravity<br />

MANIFESTED AS<br />

· firm<br />

· solid<br />

· forceful<br />

YOUR DESCRIPTIONS<br />

(b) The measurable, quantitative aspects like light/weak and heavy, in terms of how<br />

much you weigh, or exert energy, differ from qualities of weight, although the<br />

quantitative aspects influence them:<br />

LIGHT<br />

is not the same as lighter weight or a<br />

weaker, passive attitude, but is adjusting<br />

to a lesser pull of gravity<br />

STRONG<br />

is not heavy weight, but deals with<br />

greater resistance to the pull of gravity<br />

(c) Ways of engaging the body can enhance the performance of opposite qualities:<br />

LIGHT<br />

shows a tendency toward lesser muscular<br />

tension, engaging the “center of<br />

levity,” chest, upper body; movements<br />

further extended; inhalation; peripheral<br />

transitions<br />

STRONG<br />

shows a tendency toward muscular<br />

tension, participation of the center of<br />

weight, pelvic area, lower body support;<br />

movement closer to body, more contracted;<br />

exhalation; central transitions<br />

16 / DANCE DYNAMICS


(d) Affinities with areas in space:<br />

LIGHT/FINE TOUCH<br />

upwards directed<br />

STRONG/FIRM<br />

downwards directed<br />

(e) Observations of opposite qualities in self and others:<br />

LIGHT/FINE TOUCH<br />

INSTRUCTOR’S EXAMPLES<br />

· I feel airborne.<br />

· Jeff is handling this delicately.<br />

· I am gently touching a kitten.<br />

· The group gracefully performs a<br />

sequence of ballet port-des-bras.<br />

STRONG/FIRM<br />

INSTRUCTOR’S EXAMPLES<br />

· I feel grounded.<br />

· Pam intends to stick to her argument.<br />

· I am gripping the wild dog.<br />

· Ron warms up with push-ups.<br />

[Note that examples include qualities experienced as thought or movement actions.]<br />

YOUR EXAMPLES<br />

(f) Examples of instances where one quality of Weight changes to its opposite:<br />

INSTRUCTOR'S EXAMPLES<br />

· Take care darling—and give up smoking!<br />

· Push the piano and gently pluck one cord.<br />

[Note that examples include qualities experienced as thought or movement actions.]<br />

YOUR EXAMPLES<br />

ONE MOTION FACTOR / 17


T I M E<br />

(a) A great frequency of Time qualities may indicate an intuitive readiness for<br />

“Decision” making, either in a sustained manner or suddenly. Its mastery gives<br />

a calm or alert approach to thought or movement actions.<br />

The two Effort elements of the Motion Factor Time are:<br />

SUSTAINED<br />

accepting the ongoingness of time<br />

MANIFESTED AS<br />

· calm or calming<br />

· prolonged<br />

· lingering<br />

SUDDEN<br />

resisting the duration of time<br />

MANIFESTED AS<br />

· excited or excitable<br />

· immediate<br />

· unexpected<br />

YOUR DESCRIPTIONS<br />

(b) A distinction from the measurable aspects of time, i.e., fast and slow in relation<br />

to clock or metronome time should be kept in mind:<br />

SUSTAINED<br />

does not mean slow, but may coincide<br />

with slow tempo of movement<br />

SUDDEN<br />

does not mean fast, but may coincide<br />

with fast tempo<br />

(c) Ways of engaging the body can enhance the performance of:<br />

SUSTAINED<br />

shows a tendency toward large, total<br />

body movements; expanded movements<br />

SUDDEN<br />

shows a tendency toward isolated<br />

gestures; smaller movements<br />

18 / DANCE DYNAMICS


(d) Affinities with areas in space:<br />

SUSTAINED<br />

movements forward and outward<br />

SUDDEN<br />

movements backward and inward<br />

(e) Observations of opposite qualities in self and others:<br />

SUSTAINED<br />

INSTRUCTOR’S EXAMPLES<br />

· There is a whole eternity.<br />

· Ann is taking her time.<br />

· I am leisurely stretching.<br />

· The introductory dance is stately.<br />

SUDDEN<br />

INSTRUCTOR’S EXAMPLES<br />

· Now is the moment.<br />

· Ron feels rushed.<br />

· Jim’s tabla playing is speedy.<br />

[Note that examples include qualities experienced as thought or movement actions.]<br />

YOUR EXAMPLES<br />

(f) Examples of instances where one quality of Time changes to its opposite:<br />

INSTRUCTOR'S EXAMPLES<br />

· Being calm and unexpectedly being startled.<br />

· Performing a developpé followed by a series of frappes.<br />

[Note that examples include qualities experienced as thought or movement actions.]<br />

YOUR EXAMPLES<br />

ONE MOTION FACTOR / 19


F L O W<br />

(a) The emphasis on Flow can be associated with the emergence of feelings that,<br />

depending on the interaction with self or others, free or bind the continuity of<br />

movement and give either a controlled and careful or exuberant and outgoing<br />

“Progression.”<br />

The two Effort elements of the Motion Factor Flow are:<br />

FREE<br />

accepting the continuity of movement<br />

MANIFESTED AS<br />

· easy, carried by<br />

· outgoing<br />

· fluent<br />

BOUND<br />

resisting the flux of movement<br />

MANIFESTED AS<br />

· controlled<br />

· inward pulling, restrained<br />

· withheld<br />

YOUR DESCRIPTIONS<br />

(b) A distinction from the quantitative aspects of flow, i.e., continuity or stop<br />

should be kept in mind:<br />

FREE<br />

is not the same as mechanical continuity<br />

but displays a tendency toward it<br />

BOUND<br />

does not necessarily stop the movement<br />

but manifests a tendency for stopping<br />

(c) Ways of engaging the body can enhance the performance of:<br />

FREE<br />

running, turning, jumping; swinging;<br />

off-balance; initiation from the torso<br />

and spreading out to the extremities;<br />

successive flow; total body movements<br />

BOUND<br />

balancing on small surfaces; center of<br />

body held while limbs move; movements<br />

starting from the extremities<br />

towards the center of the body;<br />

simultaneous flow<br />

20 / DANCE DYNAMICS


(d) Affinities with areas in space:<br />

FREE<br />

movements into the area towards<br />

open-forward (and high)<br />

BOUND<br />

movements across<br />

backwards (and low)<br />

(e) Observations of opposite qualities in self and others:<br />

FREE<br />

INSTRUCTOR’S EXAMPLES<br />

· I feel with it, enthusiastic.<br />

· Mary is finally communicating.<br />

· Running and whirling is refreshing.<br />

· Tom enjoys diving.<br />

· Karl balances with command.<br />

BOUND<br />

INSTRUCTOR’S EXAMPLES<br />

· I feel ambivalent, restrained.<br />

· Greg is still cut-off from his peers.<br />

· I hold my breath when handling<br />

crockery.<br />

[Note that examples include qualities experienced as thought or movement actions.]<br />

YOUR EXAMPLES<br />

(f) Examples of instances when one quality of Flow changes to its opposite:<br />

INSTRUCTOR’S EXAMPLES<br />

· I am carefully scrutinizing a new acquaintance until I am at ease in her presence.<br />

· Try running toward center stage, then stopping and balancing on one leg.<br />

[Note that examples include qualities experienced as thought or movement actions.]<br />

YOUR EXAMPLES<br />

ONE MOTION FACTOR / 21


Combinations of TWO MOTION FACTORS<br />

After having considered each of the four Motion Factors and their respective<br />

Effort <strong>Ele</strong>ments, we will see how the combination of two Motion Factors can<br />

create new qualities. These are observable in transitions between actions in<br />

everyday life and are frequently elaborated in dance. There are six combinations<br />

of two Motion Factors and Laban refers to them as “incomplete efforts” that<br />

are expressive of a variety of “inner attitudes.” 6<br />

Bartenieff prefers to identify<br />

them as “inner states.” 7<br />

Since the term “attitudes” is also used to denote attitudes<br />

of yielding or resisting the Motion Factors, the term States will be used<br />

in this text.<br />

While the combination of Motion Factors SPACE and TIME (of thinking and<br />

intuiting) and their respective Effort <strong>Ele</strong>ments create an alert, awake attitude,<br />

the opposite combinations of WEIGHT and FLOW (of sensing and feeling) are<br />

more dreamlike, unaware. Laban refers to the former combination as giving<br />

information about “where” (S) and “when” (T), and the latter about “what”<br />

(W) and “how” (F).<br />

Whereas the combinations of SPACE and FLOW <strong>Ele</strong>ments (of thinking and<br />

feeling) give a more abstract, remote mood, their opposites, the combinations<br />

of WEIGHT and TIME <strong>Ele</strong>ments (of sensing and intuiting) create a rhythmical,<br />

earthy, near attitude. The first combination indicates “where” (S) and “how”<br />

(F), and the contrasting one “what” (W) and “when”(T).<br />

As the combinations of SPACE and WEIGHT (thinking and sensing) are likely to<br />

produce a stable, steadfast attitude, their opposite combinations of TIME and<br />

FLOW (intuiting and feeling) can create a mobile, adaptable attitude. The first<br />

combination gives information about “where” (S) and “what” (W), and the<br />

contrasting one about “when” (T) and “how” (F).<br />

Each of the six combinations has a potential for four variations. For example<br />

the combination of WEIGHT and TIME includes:<br />

LIGHT / SUSTAINED | STRONG / SUDDEN | STRONG / SUSTAINED | LIGHT / SUDDEN<br />

There are thus twenty-four distinct qualities within this range.<br />

TWO MOTION FACTORS / 23


S P A C E A N D T I M E / “ T H E AWA K E S T A T E ”<br />

The four variables resulting from the combinations of Space/Time (of thinking<br />

and intuiting) produce alert, aware, awake attitudes and actions, such as are<br />

seen in Merce Cunningham’s work in the 1950s and ‘60s. Here the information<br />

about “where” and “when” is particularly evocative.<br />

Laban approximates this inner attitude as “awake” in that awareness arises<br />

suddenly or gradually and may be concentrated or embracing. 8<br />

M E N T A L A C T I O N<br />

M O V E M E N T A C T I O N<br />

DIRECT / SUDDEN<br />

(1) pinpointing<br />

darting gesture<br />

YOUR EXAMPLES<br />

DIRECT / SUSTAINED<br />

(2) prolonged focusing<br />

slow linear path<br />

YOUR EXAMPLES<br />

INDIRECT / SUDDEN<br />

(3) instantly adjusting to<br />

twirl<br />

YOUR EXAMPLES<br />

all facets<br />

INDIRECT / SUSTAINED<br />

(4) all-round lingering<br />

slow turning and twisting<br />

YOUR EXAMPLES<br />

consideration<br />

24 / DANCE DYNAMICS


The four S/T variables can be observed in various sequences, such as:<br />

Here is a brief narrative for a scene of searching:<br />

Where is it? Here? There?<br />

E v e r y w h e r e A quick glance around,<br />

and another, here it is! I s l o w l y approach it . . .<br />

Perform the scene with clear focus and shaping in gesture, turning, locomotion;<br />

in addition small, isolated and large, total body movement may enhance the<br />

time variables.<br />

Read and perform the following sequence that includes the S/T variables:<br />

Notice if your performance brought about any movement actions you described<br />

on the previous page.<br />

TWO MOTION FACTORS / 25


W E I G H T A N D F L O W / “ T H E D R E A M L I K E S T A T E ”<br />

The four variables resulting from the combinations of Weight–Flow (of sensing<br />

and feeling) bring about a less conscious, almost dream-like attitudes and<br />

actions; some Contact Improvisation sequences at times assume such attitudes.<br />

Laban approximates this combination as “dreamlike” since the lack of awareness<br />

may be bold or diffuse and exalted or gloomy. 9<br />

M E N T A L A C T I O N<br />

M O V E M E N T A C T I O N<br />

STRONG / BOUND<br />

(1) forced restriction<br />

supporting a heavy slippery<br />

YOUR EXAMPLES<br />

partner<br />

LIGHT / BOUND<br />

(2) slight apprehension<br />

delicately balancing<br />

YOUR EXAMPLES<br />

STRONG / FREE<br />

(3) powerful outgoing<br />

swinging<br />

YOUR EXAMPLES<br />

LIGHT / FREE<br />

(4) delicate ease<br />

suspension<br />

YOUR EXAMPLES<br />

26 / DANCE DYNAMICS


The four W/F variables can be observed in various sequences, such as:<br />

Here is a brief narrative for a scene about a nightmare:<br />

I am hovering on a brittle cliff;<br />

I fall into the water and emerge out of it; gradually I start enjoying a<br />

light breeze but then I fall into a quicksand patch and struggle to get<br />

out.<br />

Perform the scene with suspension, falling and rolling, swings, and pulling<br />

inward.<br />

Read and perform the following sequence that includes the W/F variables:<br />

Notice if your performance brought about any movement actions you described<br />

on the previous page.<br />

TWO MOTION FACTORS / 27


S P A C E A N D F L O W / “ T H E R E M O T E S T A T E ”<br />

The combination of Space–Flow elements (associated with attention and progression<br />

as well as the “powers” of thinking and feeling), bring about almost<br />

airborne, more abstract attitudes and actions. These may be associated with the<br />

image of dancers in the period of the Romantic Ballet.<br />

Laban approximates this inner attitude as “remote” in which detachment “may<br />

include focus on self, together with restraint or abandon.” 10<br />

M E N T A L A C T I O N<br />

M O V E M E N T A C T I O N<br />

DIRECT–BOUND<br />

(1) restricted honing in<br />

strict linear shaping<br />

YOUR EXAMPLES<br />

DIRECT–FREE<br />

(2) straightforwardly<br />

projecting a linear move-<br />

YOUR EXAMPLES<br />

streaming<br />

ment into far distance<br />

INDIRECT–BOUND<br />

(3) careful survey<br />

three-dimensional move-<br />

YOUR EXAMPLES<br />

ment with control<br />

INDIRECT–FREE<br />

(4) released dissemination<br />

turning outward<br />

YOUR EXAMPLES<br />

28 / DANCE DYNAMICS


The four S/F variables can be observed in various sequences, such as:<br />

Here is a brief narrative for a scene:<br />

In a scene from Giselle Albrecht is carefully looking for her;<br />

seeing Giselle’s specter his heart goes all out to her and he turns<br />

around in joy. But where has she disappeared? He searches again. . .<br />

Perform the scene using predominantly torso, arm and leg gestures, balancing<br />

and getting off-balance that leads into locomotion.<br />

Read and perform the following sequence that includes the S/F variables:<br />

Notice if your performance brought about any movement actions you described<br />

on the previous page.<br />

TWO MOTION FACTORS / 29


W E I G H T A N D T I M E / “ T H E N E A R S T A T E ”<br />

Rhythm in movement and dance consists of groupings of accents (Weight) and<br />

duration (Time). The four variables resulting from the combination of Weight–<br />

Time (of sensing and intuiting) thus create predominately rhythmical, down to<br />

earth, engaged attitudes and activities, such as in Flamenco and Tap dancing.<br />

Laban approximates this inner attitude as “near” in which a presence may have<br />

a sudden impact or sustained consideration, or it may express strong attachment<br />

or superficial touch. 11<br />

M E N T A L A C T I O N<br />

M O V E M E N T A C T I O N<br />

STRONG / SUDDEN<br />

(1) emphatic assertion<br />

stomp<br />

YOUR EXAMPLES<br />

LIGHT / SUDDEN<br />

(2) delicate nod<br />

touch<br />

YOUR EXAMPLES<br />

STRONG / SUSTAINED<br />

(3) enduring power<br />

drag<br />

YOUR EXAMPLES<br />

LIGHT / SUSTAINED<br />

(4) persisting subtleness<br />

slide<br />

YOUR EXAMPLES<br />

30 / DANCE DYNAMICS


The four W/T variables can be observed in various sequences, such as:<br />

Explore one of the suggested sequences:<br />

A sequence of tap dance in the style of Savion Glover<br />

OR<br />

If you are more familiar with Spanish Flamenco dancing “orchestrate”<br />

your feet with a variety of stomps and touches<br />

Read and perform the following sequence that includes the four combinations<br />

of W/T:<br />

Notice if your performance brought about any movement actions you described<br />

on the previous page.<br />

TWO MOTION FACTORS / 31


S P A C E A N D W E I G H T / “ T H E S T A B L E S T A T E ”<br />

The four variables resulting from the combinations of Space–Weight (of thinking<br />

and sensing) produce persevering, well-defined, more stable attitudes and<br />

activities. Examples may be found in gymnastics, “pedestrian” activities, and<br />

some court dances from the Renaissance.<br />

Laban approximates this combination as “stable” in which steadfastness can be<br />

resolute or receptive, as well as solid and encompassing or delicately pinpointing.<br />

12<br />

M E N T A L A C T I O N<br />

M O V E M E N T A C T I O N<br />

DIRECT / STRONG<br />

(1) convergent firmness<br />

strong clear-cut locomotion<br />

YOUR EXAMPLES<br />

DIRECT / LIGHT<br />

(2) delicate focusing<br />

tracing fine lines<br />

YOUR EXAMPLES<br />

INDIRECT / STRONG<br />

(3) strong all-round<br />

strong twisting<br />

YOUR EXAMPLES<br />

scrutinizing<br />

INDIRECT / LIGHT<br />

(4) delicate all-round<br />

delicate spiraling<br />

YOUR EXAMPLES<br />

scanning<br />

32 / DANCE DYNAMICS


The four S/W variables can be observed in various sequences, such as:<br />

Explore steps and shoulder-arm patterns in the style of a courtly processional<br />

dance from the time of the Renaissance, such as the Pavane:<br />

Advancing with two low steps, then two high transferences of weight<br />

is followed by a retreat consisting of two small steps and closes. This<br />

alternates with shoulder-arm gestures, displaying a splendid pelerine<br />

and showing off the dagger, that are performed without locomotion.<br />

This motif is repeated with variations of your own design.<br />

Perform the sequence with predominantly downward and upward as well as<br />

narrowing and widening movements.<br />

Read and perform the following sequence that includes the four combinations<br />

of S/W:<br />

Notice if your performance brought about any movement actions you<br />

described on the previous page.<br />

TWO MOTION FACTORS / 33


T I M E A N D F L O W / “ T H E M O B I L E S T A T E ”<br />

The four variables resulting from the combinations of Time–Flow (of intuiting<br />

and feeling) create changeable, more mobile, at times agitated attitudes and<br />

activities. They may appear in dramatic movement and dance scenes.<br />

Laban approximates this combinations as “mobile” in that one’s adaptability<br />

may be sticky or easy, and abruptly changing or slow forthcoming. 13<br />

M E N T A L A C T I O N<br />

M O V E M E N T A C T I O N<br />

SUDDEN / BOUND<br />

(1) startled<br />

jerk<br />

YOUR EXAMPLES<br />

SUSTAINED / BOUND<br />

(2) sustained control<br />

stalking<br />

YOUR EXAMPLES<br />

SUDDEN / FREE<br />

(3) pleasant surprise<br />

fluttering gesture (when<br />

YOUR EXAMPLES<br />

repeated)<br />

SUSTAINED / FREE<br />

(4) unhurried ease<br />

calm advancing<br />

YOUR EXAMPLES<br />

34 / DANCE DYNAMICS


The four T–F variables can be observed in various sequences, such as:<br />

Improvise the scene below:<br />

Are we going to catch our flight? On a crowded airport we are jerked<br />

several times toward the departing gate—trying to prevent falling we<br />

continue to advance cautiously. Suddenly there is an announcement<br />

about the plane’s delay. What a relief! Now we can take our time leisurely<br />

and even enjoy the forthcoming rush of checking in.<br />

Perform the scene by alternating movement that pulls inwards with agitation<br />

and control, and streams outward with ease and excitement; also include<br />

moments of withholding balance in contrast to nearly falling off-balance.<br />

Read and perform the following sequence that includes the four T/F variables:<br />

Notice if your performance brought about any movement actions you described<br />

on the previous page.<br />

TWO MOTION FACTORS / 35


Recommended reading about Combinations of Two Motion Factors:<br />

WEIGHT AND TIME<br />

Laban, Rudolf. The Mastery of Movement (1980 edition) 78–79.<br />

North, Marion. Personality Assessment Through Movement (Macdonald & Evans, 1972)<br />

252.<br />

Preston-Dunlop, Valerie. A Handbook for Dance in Education (London: Macdonald &<br />

Evans, 1980) 15–16; 9 b.<br />

Bartenieff, Irmgard. Body Movement: Coping with the Environment<br />

(New York:<br />

Gordon & Breach, 1980) 59–60.<br />

SPACE AND FLOW<br />

Laban 78–79.<br />

North 252–253.<br />

Preston-Dunlop 35–37; 194.<br />

Bartenieff 59–60.<br />

WEIGHT AND FLOW<br />

Laban 78–79.<br />

North 249–251.<br />

Preston-Dunlop 35–36; 194–195.<br />

Bartenieff 59–60.<br />

TIME AND FLOW<br />

Laban 78–79.<br />

North 254.<br />

Preston-Dunlop 35; 195.<br />

Bartenieff 59–60.<br />

SPACE AND WEIGHT<br />

Laban 78–79.<br />

North 253.<br />

Preston-Dunlop 36; 195.<br />

Bartenieff 59–60.<br />

SPACE AND TIME<br />

Laban 78–79.<br />

North 251.<br />

Preston-Dunlop 36–37; 194.<br />

Bartenieff 59–60.<br />

36 / DANCE DYNAMICS


EFFORT / SPACE (SHAPE) Affinities<br />

Before elaborating on the variables of Combinations of three Motion factors,<br />

Laban’s concept of affinities between the dynamic qualities or Effort and its<br />

spatial unfolding are considered. The concept has already been hinted at in the<br />

description of affinities of Space, Weight, Time, and Flow elements with the<br />

areas in space around the body.<br />

Laban found close correlation between Effort elements and the six dimensional<br />

directions. These were based on his observation that a light movement has an<br />

upward tendency, and a strong movement aims downward; a straight, direct<br />

movement correlates with movement across the body, while a roundabout,<br />

flexible or indirect movement is correlated with an opening outwards; a sudden<br />

movement tends toward a backward direction, and a slow, sustained one reaches<br />

forward. Elaborating compounds of these, Laban arrived at the eight variables<br />

of the Action Drive or the “eight basic Effort actions,” which correspond with<br />

the eight Diagonal directions. Accordingly, a light/indirect/sustained movement<br />

is associated with the high-open-forward diagonal, and a strong/direct/sudden<br />

one with the down-across-back diagonal, etc. 14<br />

A helpful visualization of the above can be seen in FIG. 2 (p. 38, overleaf) representing<br />

the “Effort cube” with directional and Effort symbols.<br />

EFFORT-SPACE AFFINITIES / 37


F I G . 2 : T H E E F F O R T C U B E<br />

(a) Along the edge transitions<br />

(b) Across the planes transitions<br />

(c) Diagonal transitions<br />

38 / DANCE DYNAMICS


The scaffolding of the cube also presents a device for the exploration of transitions<br />

among the eight basic Effort actions:<br />

(a)<br />

over the edge transitions, indicated by the solid line, create sequences<br />

with changes of one element, such as:<br />

or<br />

YOUR EXAMPLE of another transition over the edges:<br />

(b)<br />

across the planes or faces of the cube transitions, indicated by the arrows,<br />

create sequences with changes of two elements, such as:<br />

or<br />

YOUR EXAMPLE of another transition across two planes or faces:<br />

(c)<br />

the diagonal transitions through the cube, indicated by arrows, can<br />

embody contrasting transitions, such as:<br />

or<br />

YOUR EXAMPLES of two other transitions through the cube:<br />

EFFORT-SPACE AFFINITIES / 39


Laban’s concept of affinities was the point of departure for Warren Lamb’s elaboration<br />

of Effort and Shape relationships. Initially Laban’s student and assistant<br />

in developing the Laban-Lawrence Effort assessment test for work study<br />

purposes, Lamb evolved his own methodology. In Posture and Gesture Lamb<br />

presents his scheme for observation and analysis of physical behavior in which<br />

the emphasis is placed on degrees of affinity between Shape and Effort variations,<br />

including his elaboration of “shape flow” in addition to “effort flow.” 15<br />

The observation of actions such as “posture,” “gesture,” and their “merging”<br />

is also a significant variable. 16<br />

In the 1960s Lamb’s Effort-Shape construct<br />

contributed to the forming of Laban-Lamb-based methodologies in the U.S.A.<br />

promoted by Irmgard Bartenieff and Dr. Judith Kestenberg. While Bartenieff<br />

developed Effort/Shape with reference to research and teaching, 17<br />

Kestenberg<br />

expanded some of its concepts in context of Freudian develop<strong>mental</strong> phases and<br />

observations of infants. 18<br />

40 / DANCE DYNAMICS


Combinations of THREE MOTION FACTORS<br />

The combinations of three Motion Factors and their respective Effort <strong>Ele</strong>ments<br />

bring about a more intense movement expression that Laban refers to as<br />

drives. Taking the “Action Drive” as the point of departure, Laban identified<br />

three additional drives in which Flow replaces the other three Motion Factors.<br />

He gave them metaphorical names, such as “Passion Drive” (Flow replacing<br />

Space), “Vision Drive” (Flow replacing Weight), and “Spell Drive” (Flow<br />

replacing Time), 19 and also labeled them as Transformation I–III. 20 Marion<br />

North elaborates on them in the context of personality assessment and refers to<br />

the spaceless drive as an emotional stressed drive; timeless as a spell-like drive,<br />

and, weightless as a visionary drive. 21<br />

Bartenieff subsequently describes them<br />

as “transformation drives” and names them simply “spaceless,” “weightless,”<br />

and “timeless” 22<br />

The ACTION DRIVE combines Effort elements of Space, Weight, and Time<br />

(thinking, sensing, and intuiting), while Flow (feeling) remains latent. The eight<br />

possible combinations of the above elements are also described as “basic Effort<br />

actions” of thrusting, floating, pressing, flicking, gliding, slashing, dabbing, and<br />

wringing. 23<br />

The PASSION DRIVE arises when the Flow factor replaces the Space factor<br />

and transforms the Action drive into a more emotionally emphasized drive. It<br />

includes the eight possible combinations of Weight, Time, and Flow qualities<br />

(sensing, intuiting, and feeling) that override the clarity of Spatial placement<br />

and shaping (thinking).<br />

The VISION DRIVE emerges when the Flow factor substitutes the Weight factor<br />

changing the movement into a more weightless drive. It includes eight possible<br />

combinations of Space, Time, and Flow qualities (thinking, intuiting, and feeling)<br />

that override the bodily import (the sensing).<br />

The SPELL DRIVE appears when the Flow factor replaces Time qualities, transforming<br />

the movement into a timeless drive. It includes eight possible combinations<br />

of Space, Weight, and Flow qualities (thinking, sensing, and feeling) that<br />

override the sense for timing (intuiting).<br />

Each of the four drives has a potential for eight variables, which provides for<br />

thirty-two qualities in addition to twenty-four qualities of inner attitudes or<br />

incomplete Efforts.<br />

THREE MOTION FACTORS / 41


S P A C E , W E I G H T, A N D T I M E / “ACTION DRIVE” OR BASIC EFFORT ACTIONS<br />

Functional actions such as work, gymnastics, and dance training require clear<br />

spatial attending, an intentional use of weight, and a good sense for timing. In<br />

these cases the emotional participation resulting in bound or free Flow is not<br />

needed or even appropriate.<br />

(In this drive Laban’s question of “how” associated with Flow is in the background,<br />

while “where”—S, “when”—T, and “what”—W are in the foreground.)<br />

The combination of Space-Weight-Time elements is therefore referred to as<br />

“action drive” and to each of the eight variables Laban gave a work-like<br />

descriptive term. His first inspiration for this terminology actually came from<br />

traditional ways of describing basic forms of movement actions (“steps”) and<br />

their qualities, such as the battu, fouetté and glissé of the French ballet vocabulary,<br />

that corresponds to thrusting, slashing and gliding. 24<br />

[The Action drive, like the other three drives, can be further analyzed with<br />

regard to the inner attitudes that are embedded in each, such as S/W (stable),<br />

S/T (awake), and W/T (near) 25 ]<br />

42 / DANCE DYNAMICS


BASIC EFFORT ACTIONS<br />

DIRECT / STRONG / SUDDEN<br />

M E N T A L A C T I O N<br />

(1) PUNCHING/THRUSTING<br />

making an emphatic statement<br />

M O V E M E N T A C T I O N<br />

frappé action<br />

YOUR EXAMPLE<br />

INDIRECT / LIGHT / SUSTAINED<br />

(2) FLOATING<br />

eventually releasing<br />

gently scattering<br />

YOUR EXAMPLE<br />

DIRECT / STRONG / SUSTAINED<br />

(3) PRESSING<br />

strongly persistent<br />

slow tendu<br />

YOUR EXAMPLE<br />

INDIRECT / LIGHT / SUDDEN<br />

(4) FLICKING<br />

quickly dismissing<br />

toss of a hand/foot<br />

YOUR EXAMPLE<br />

DIRECT / LIGHT / SUSTAINED<br />

(5) GLIDING<br />

easily pursuing<br />

glissade<br />

YOUR EXAMPLE<br />

INDIRECT / STRONG / SUDDEN<br />

(6) SLASHING<br />

reckless force<br />

whipping gesture<br />

YOUR EXAMPLE<br />

DIRECT / LIGHT / SUDDEN<br />

(7) DABBING<br />

pinpointing<br />

tap dancing<br />

YOUR EXAMPLE<br />

INDIRECT / STRONG / SUSTAINED<br />

(8) WRINGING<br />

tortuous scrutiny<br />

twisting upper body against the lower<br />

YOUR EXAMPLE<br />

THREE MOTION FACTORS / 43


The eight combinations of S/W/T can be performed in sequences with changes of<br />

one, two and three elements both with WORK-LIKE or DANCE-LIKE actions.<br />

(a1)<br />

Perform the movement sequence of WORK-LIKE ACTIONS below using<br />

four of the S/W/T combinations by changing ONE element each time:<br />

FLOAT FLICK DAB GLIDE PRESS WRING SLASH PUNCH<br />

(a2)<br />

Create and write down another sequence in which you change one<br />

element.<br />

(b1)<br />

Perform the movement sequence of WORK-LIKE ACTIONS below<br />

using four of the S/W/T combinations by changing TWO elements each<br />

time:<br />

FLOAT PRESS DAB<br />

SLASH<br />

(b2)<br />

Create and write down another sequence in which you change two<br />

elements.<br />

(c1)<br />

Perform the movement sequence of WORK-LIKE ACTIONS below<br />

using all eight of the S/W/T combinations by changing THREE<br />

elements every time:<br />

FLOAT PUNCH GLIDE SLASH FLICK PRESS DAB WRING<br />

44 / DANCE DYNAMICS


By performing the instructor’s examples of the S/W/T combinations within an<br />

imaginary Effort cube around you (See Fig. 2), you can create a sequence with<br />

more DANCE-LIKE ACTIONS:<br />

(a1)<br />

First perform the sequence with transitions ALONG THE EDGES of the<br />

cube; see p. 38 Fig. 2 (a).<br />

(b1)<br />

Second, perform the eight actions with transitions ACROSS THE<br />

PLANES or FACES; see p. 38 Fig. 2 (b).<br />

(c1)<br />

Finally, perform the eight actions by connecting them with transitions<br />

DIAGONALLY through the cube; see p. 38 Fig. 2 (c).<br />

THREE MOTION FACTORS / 45


F L O W, W E I G H T, A N D T I M E / “PASSION DRIVE”<br />

There are instances in everyday life and dance when the feeling component<br />

overrides thinking. This may happen in various situations, such as emotional<br />

outbursts and in some tribal ritual dances. The “passion drive” also emerges in<br />

climactic moments of Spanish Flamenco dancing. In such instances clear Spatial<br />

attending becomes undifferentiated and the binding or freeing control of Flow<br />

is coupled with an intentional use of Weight and a sense of Timing.<br />

(In this drive Laban’s question of “where” associated with Space is in abeyance,<br />

while “when”—T, “what”—W, and “how”—F, are in the foreground.)<br />

[Further analysis of embedded inner attitudes shows combinations of W/F<br />

(dream-like), T/W (near), and T/F (mobile).]<br />

In contrast to the Action drive, no set terms have been created for the eight combinations<br />

of Flow/Weight/Time (feeling, sensing, and intuiting). Following are<br />

attempts to find descriptive words for the performance of these combinations.<br />

To start with the transformations of the basic Effort actions may be helpful. 29<br />

M E N T A L A C T I O N<br />

M O V E M E N T A C T I O N<br />

BOUND / STRONG / SUDDEN<br />

(1) (SPACELESS THRUST)<br />

shocked<br />

spasmodic contaction<br />

YOUR EXAMPLE<br />

FREE / LIGHT / SUSTAINED<br />

(2) (SPACELESS FLOAT)<br />

vague daydreaming<br />

drifitng<br />

YOUR EXAMPLE<br />

BOUND / STRONG / SUSTAINED<br />

(3) (SPACELESS WRING)<br />

hemmed in<br />

slow contraction<br />

YOUR EXAMPLE<br />

FREE / LIGHT / SUDDEN<br />

(4) (SPACELESS FLICK)<br />

quizzical<br />

light jerk<br />

YOUR EXAMPLE<br />

46 / DANCE DYNAMICS


FREE / STRONG / SUDDEN<br />

(5) (SPACELESS SLASH)<br />

blurting out<br />

wild throw<br />

YOUR EXAMPLE<br />

BOUND / LIGHT / SUSTAINED<br />

(6) (SPACELESS GLIDE)<br />

cautious hovering<br />

precarious balancing<br />

YOUR EXAMPLE<br />

BOUND / LIGHT / SUDDEN<br />

(7) (SPACELESS DAB)<br />

light irritation<br />

a gasp<br />

YOUR EXAMPLE<br />

FREE / STRONG / SUSTAINED<br />

(8) (SPACELESS WRING)<br />

menacing intent<br />

forceful shoving<br />

YOUR EXAMPLE<br />

The W/T/F combinations can be performed in various sequences, such as:<br />

Perform this study with actions you described above.<br />

Here is a proposed sequence that may help you explore the “Passion Drive”:<br />

Take the work-like action sequence (c1) from p. 44 with the change of<br />

all three elements. By introducing repetitions within pairs of opposites,<br />

and gradually replacing Space with Flow elements, transform the entire<br />

sequence into emotionally charged movement in which you lose any<br />

sense of a working-like situation.<br />

Feel free to repeat the entire sequence until you get a sense that you went<br />

through the transformation.<br />

THREE MOTION FACTORS / 47


S P A C E , T I M E , A N D F L O W / “VISION DRIVE”<br />

In this combination the feeling component manifest in the Flow of movement<br />

overrides the bodily sensing that becomes undifferentiated. The physicality of<br />

strong and light tension is transcended by the binding and freeing control of<br />

Flow and coupled with a clear Spatial attending, along with a good sense of<br />

Timing. One may suggest that Merce Cunningham’s style of the 1960s predominantly<br />

uses a selection of Space (mostly direct), Flow (mostly bound), and Time<br />

(both polarities) combinations.<br />

[Here further analysis regarding inner attitudes embedded in the drive will show<br />

that the gist of the Cunningham style has already been identified in the S/T<br />

(awake) combination; the additional S/F (remote), and ballet-like T/F (mobile),<br />

give a more complete account of the dynamic texture of his style.]<br />

(It is also helpful to remember Laban’s reference to Flow with the question<br />

“how,” Space “where,” and Time “when.”)<br />

M E N T A L A C T I O N<br />

M O V E M E N T A C T I O N<br />

DIRECT / SUDDEN / BOUND<br />

(1) (WEIGHTLESS THRUST)<br />

taken aback<br />

precise, fast lunge<br />

YOUR EXAMPLE<br />

INDIRECT / SUSTAINED / FREE<br />

(2) (WEIGHTLESS FLOAT)<br />

indulging in fantasies<br />

slowly stirring water<br />

YOUR EXAMPLE<br />

DIRECT / SUSTAINED / BOUND<br />

(3) (WEIGHTLESS PRESS)<br />

persistently precise<br />

drawing a smooth line<br />

YOUR EXAMPLE<br />

INDIRECT / SUDDEN / FREE<br />

(4) (WEIGHTLESS FLICK)<br />

instant release<br />

quick and fluid twirl<br />

YOUR EXAMPLE<br />

48 / DANCE DYNAMICS


INDIRECT / SUDDEN / BOUND<br />

(5) (WEIGHTLESS SLASH)<br />

sudden unease<br />

quick, controlled wriggle<br />

YOUR EXAMPLE<br />

DIRECT / SUSTAINED / FREE<br />

(6) (WEIGHTLESS GLIDE)<br />

clearly considering<br />

striding purposefully forward<br />

YOUR EXAMPLE<br />

INDIRECT / SUSTAINED / BOUND<br />

(7) (WEIGHTLESS WRING)<br />

persisting overall tension<br />

precise shaping<br />

YOUR EXAMPLE<br />

DIRECT / SUDDEN / FREE<br />

(8) (WEIGHTLESS DAB)<br />

lively focusing<br />

lively darting jumps<br />

YOUR EXAMPLE<br />

The eight S/T/F combinations or selections from them can be performed in various<br />

sequences, such as:<br />

Perform this study with actions you described above.<br />

The scene below may facilitate the exploration of the “Vision Drive”:<br />

Perform the sequence of work-like actions (b1) from p. 44, with the<br />

change of two elements. By repeating it several times see if you can<br />

gradually replace Weight with Flow elements, and change from a manual<br />

worker to a visionary leader who supports her/his ideas with arm<br />

gestures and facial expression.<br />

THREE MOTION FACTORS / 49


S P A C E , W E I G H T, A N D F L O W / “SPELL DRIVE”<br />

There are rare instances in everyday life and dance that the feeling component<br />

Flow replaces the sense of Timing, and combines with Space and Weight. When<br />

we watch a horror movie we sometimes get spell bound. In dance, Japanese<br />

Butoh and some of Eiko and Koma’s work convey predominantly such hypnotic<br />

qualities.<br />

(Here Laban’s questions show that “when” associated with Time is in abeyance,<br />

while “where”—S, “what”—W, and “how”—F, are in the foreground.)<br />

[Further analysis of embedded inner attitudes shows combinations of W/F<br />

(dream-like), S/W (stable), and S/F (remote).]<br />

M E N T A L A C T I O N<br />

M O V E M E N T A C T I O N<br />

DIRECT / STRONG / BOUND<br />

(1) (TIMELESS THRUST)<br />

steadfast concentration<br />

strong, controlled resistance<br />

YOUR EXAMPLE<br />

INDIRECT / LIGHT / FREE<br />

(2) (TIMELESS FLOAT)<br />

nebulous yielding<br />

like blown by the wind<br />

YOUR EXAMPLE<br />

DIRECT / STRONG / FREE<br />

(3) (TIMELESS PRESS)<br />

powerful effusion<br />

strong, fluent advancing<br />

YOUR EXAMPLE<br />

INDIRECT / LIGHT / BOUND<br />

(4) (TIMELESS FLICK)<br />

restraint wavering<br />

delicate, controlled carving<br />

YOUR EXAMPLE<br />

50 / DANCE DYNAMICS


INDIRECT / STRONG / BOUND<br />

(5) (TIMELESS SLASH)<br />

overwhelmed but not voicing it<br />

contortion<br />

YOUR EXAMPLE<br />

DIRECT / LIGHT / FREE<br />

(6) (TIMELESS GLIDE)<br />

pursuing with light ease<br />

light, directed gestures<br />

YOUR EXAMPLE<br />

INDIRECT / STRONG / FREE<br />

(7) (TIMELESS WRING)<br />

firm, all-round influencing<br />

strong, fluent twisting<br />

YOUR EXAMPLE<br />

(8) (TIMELESS DAB)<br />

DIRECT / LIGHT / BOUND<br />

meticulous tight-rope walking<br />

YOUR EXAMPLE<br />

The eight S/W/F combinations or selections from them can be performed in<br />

various sequences, such as<br />

Perform this study with actions you described above.<br />

The scene below may help you explore the “Spell Drive”:<br />

You are working on a conveyor belt using work-like actions from the<br />

sequence (a1) with the change of one element (p. 44). While repeating<br />

it and replacing Time with Flow elements you gradually lose the objective<br />

work-like approach. Repeat the sequence as many times you need<br />

to make a transition from the Action into the Spell drive.<br />

THREE MOTION FACTORS / 51


Recommended reading for Combinations of Three Motion Factors:<br />

SPACE, WEIGHT, TIME / “Action Drive” / Basic Effort Actions<br />

Laban, Rudolf. Modern Educational Dance, third ed. (1975<br />

“Rudiments of a Free Dance Technique”) 52–84.<br />

North (1973) 255–261.<br />

Preston-Dunlop (1980) 60–79.<br />

FLOW, WEIGHT, TIME / “Passion-like Drive”<br />

Laban (1980) 80–81.<br />

North 261, 263–266.<br />

Preston-Dunlop 197–199.<br />

SPACE, TIME, FLOW / “Vision-like Drive”<br />

Laban (1980) 80–81.<br />

North 261, 263–266.<br />

Preston-Dunlop 197–200.<br />

SPACE, WEIGHT, FLOW / “Spell-like Drive”<br />

Laban (1980) 80–81.<br />

North 261, 263–266.<br />

Preston-Dunlop 197–200.<br />

52 / DANCE DYNAMICS


Combinations of FOUR MOTION FACTORS<br />

The combinations of four Motion Factors are referred to in England as “complete<br />

Effort actions,” 27 in contrast to the combinations of two that Laban identified<br />

as “incomplete Efforts.” Bartenieff, on the other hand refers to the combination<br />

of four as “full Effort combinations,” and describes them as extreme<br />

survival responses. 28<br />

As dance audiences we can also get a glimpse of an active<br />

engagement in all four Effort elements while watching peak-performances.<br />

Each of the eight basic actions can be performed with either free or bound Flow.<br />

There are only two basic actions—“floating” and “thrusting”—which due to<br />

their predominant “indulging” and “fighting” structure, may have a natural<br />

tendency toward free flow (“floating”) and bound flow (“thrusting”).<br />

The combination of Space, Weight, Time, and Flow create further sixteen<br />

distinct variations in addition to twenty-four incomplete Effort actions, and<br />

thirty-two drives.<br />

Additional considerations<br />

This text has presented Laban’s classification of seventy-two observable movement<br />

qualities. All these qualities can be further articulated in several ways.<br />

They may be performed with a greater emphasis in one of the components.<br />

This differentiation is referred to as ranking. 29<br />

For instance in emphasizing<br />

Weight in a pressing action you change it into crush, with Space emphasis<br />

it becomes a cut, and with Time it becomes a squeeze. The emphasis can be<br />

notated by placing a dot at the end of the symbol. The Effort combinations may<br />

also be varied through grading of the intensity of the performance which can<br />

be diminished or exaggerated. 30<br />

An example can be a gliding action in which Space and Time may be diminished<br />

while the Weight remains unaltered. In this case a minus sign would be placed<br />

at the end of the symbols.<br />

Another glide can have an exaggerated Time, while the Space and Weight<br />

remain unchanged. A plus sign indicates this grading.<br />

The significance of Effort qualities emerges through their placement in the<br />

sequence of actions as well as their bodily performance. Singular qualities gain<br />

meaning when they are related to what follows. As we saw (p. 39), transitions<br />

or mutations from one quality to another can occur either with the change of<br />

one element that is gradual, or more surprisingly with the change of two, or<br />

they can create opposition with the change of all elements.<br />

FOUR MOTION FACTORS / 53


Different movement styles are created through bodily performances of Effort<br />

rhythms. A movement sequence can be performed with the whole body being<br />

attuned to a particular Effort quality. On the other hand, various qualities can<br />

be performed by different body parts at the same time. Brenda Dixon Gottschild<br />

refers to the latter as “polyrhythmic” that characterizes the style of Africanist<br />

movement. “For example the feet may maintain one rhythm while the arms,<br />

head, or torso dance to different drums.” 31<br />

Polyrhythmy as well as polycentrism—where<br />

two or more body centers may operate simultaneously—are features<br />

which have made a strong impact on American dance, and are visible not<br />

only in movement styles of Trisha Brown and Twyla Tharp but also in some of<br />

George Balanchine’s work. 32<br />

How various aspects of Effort transitions and bodily performances are reflected<br />

in the eight types of Phrasing, will be discussed in Part B of this text.<br />

54<br />

/ DANCE DYNAMICS


Notes for Part A: The Effort Theory<br />

1. For full bibliographic information see Bibliography on pp. 125 / 129.<br />

2. See Vera Maletic, "Emergence of Eukinetics" in Chapter II of Body-Space-Expression,<br />

97 / 99.<br />

3. Inner participation and its phases of Attention, Intention and Decision are first referred to<br />

in Laban's Effort, (London: Macdonald & Evans, 1947, 60 / 62).<br />

4. All four phases, including Progression, are listed and explained for the first time in R.<br />

Laban's The Mastery of Movement, sec. edition 1960, 120-121; they are also referred<br />

to in the 1980, ed., 114 / 115.<br />

5. See Laban, The Mastery of Movement, 1960, 121; 1980, 115.<br />

6. See Laban, The Mastery of Movement, 1960, 82-84; and 1980, 77 / 79.<br />

7. See Irmgard Bartenieff, Body Movement: Coping with the Environment, 1980, 59 / 60.<br />

8. Laban, 1960, 83; 1980, 79.<br />

9. Laban, 1960, 83; 1980, 79.<br />

10. Laban, 1960, 84; 1980, 79.<br />

11. Laban, 1960, 84; 1980, 79.<br />

12. Laban, 1960, 84; 1980, 79.<br />

13. Laban, 1960, 84; 1980, 79.<br />

14. See Laban Choreutics, 1966, 30 / 34.<br />

15. Warren Lamb, Posture and Gesture. 1965.<br />

16. Lamb, explains on p. 16 that Posture is an action involving a continuous adjustment of<br />

every part of the body with consistency in the process of variation; Gesture, on the other<br />

hand, is an action confined to a part or parts of the body.<br />

17. See Bartenieff, 1980, Chapter 6.<br />

18. Judith Kestenberg, The Role of Movement Patterns in Development. 1967.<br />

19. Laban, 1960, 84-85; 1980, 79 / 81.<br />

20. Laban, 1960, 122-125; 1980, 116 / 119.<br />

21. Marion North, Personality Assessment through Movement. 1972, 261 / 263.<br />

North worked with Laban on movement observation during the last years of his life.<br />

22. See Bartenieff, 1980, 61.<br />

23. See Laban, Modern Educational Dance, 1975 ed., 59 / 75.<br />

24. See Laban, Choreutics, 1966, 30.<br />

25. See North, 1972, the chart on p. 262.<br />

26. See North, 1972, 263 / 266.<br />

27. See Valerie Preston, A Handbook for Modern Educational Dance, 1963, 141.<br />

28. See Bartenieff, 1980, 63.<br />

29. See Laban, 1980,170 / 172.<br />

30. See Laban, 1980, 173 / 181.<br />

31. Brenda Dixon Gottschild, Digging the Africanist Presence in American Performance<br />

Dance and Other Contexts, 1996, 14.<br />

32. See Dixon Gottschild, chapters 4 and 5.<br />

NOTES / 55


P A R T B / T H E O R Y A N D P R A C T I C E O F P H R A S I N G<br />

INTRODUCTION<br />

Phrasing is an organizing factor underlying the performance and perception of<br />

movement within the continuum of Space, Time, Weight and Flow. When we<br />

choreograph or direct a work we articulate dance movement into various phrasing<br />

rhythms that enhances the theme of the dance. Clear phrasing also facilitates<br />

the perception of dance for audiences, dance critics and researchers.<br />

Is there a difference between the notions of phrase and phrasing in modern and<br />

post-modern dance? Writings about these concepts are on the whole brief and<br />

incomplete. Several authors, such as Elizabeth Hayes 1 and Jacqueline Smith 2 use<br />

the term “phrase” or “phrasing” without defining it. Could that suggest that<br />

dancers frequently depend on the theory of music to articulate and conceptualize<br />

even those phenomena that are so funda<strong>mental</strong>ly linked with movement?<br />

In surveying handbooks for dance and dance composition, one can find only<br />

a few descriptions of the terms, such as Doris Humphrey’s definition of “the<br />

phrase” as the organization of movement in time-design, and “phrased movement”<br />

as an expenditure of energy at various rates followed by a rest. 3 Yvonne<br />

Rainer, the exponent of post-modern dance points out the distinction between<br />

a “phrase” and “phrasing.” While she sees the “phrase” as having several consecutive<br />

movements or as a metaphor for a longer duration containing a beginning,<br />

middle, and end, she associates “phrasing” with the manner of execution<br />

or the way in which energy is distributed in the execution of a movement or a<br />

series of movements. Rainer’s view of the significance of phrasing is also seen<br />

in her argument that what makes one kind of movement different from another<br />

is not so much variations in arrangement of parts of the body as differences in<br />

energy investment. 4<br />

Descriptions of the various structures of phrases or phrasing appear to have<br />

some common denominators. Humphrey gives three simple categories according<br />

to which phrases can have the high point or climax at the beginning or near<br />

the end or near the middle. 5<br />

While recognizing that “phrasing the flow of movement<br />

reigns supreme in dance,” Rudolf Laban in his English writings refers only<br />

to two possibilities of phrasing depending on the unaccented part preceding and<br />

leading up to the accent, or the unaccented part following and dissolving the<br />

accent. 6<br />

However, in the tradition of his early teaching in Germany one can<br />

PHRASING / 57


find references to movement performed with increasing or decreasing intensity,<br />

impulse, and tension. 7<br />

Sylvia Bodmer (who first trained with Laban in Germany<br />

during the twenties and subsequently in England in the forties), introduces four<br />

types of dynamic phrasing, such as impulse, swing, counter-tension, and impact.<br />

In addition, she refers to resilient or rebounding movement that is created by a<br />

combination of two dynamic qualities. 8<br />

Marion North articulates the British<br />

school of Laban’s teaching by distinguishing the length, development, rhythms,<br />

and patterns of Effort phrases. Under developments she refers to increases,<br />

decreases, resiliency, and evenness, and among rhythms she lists simple and<br />

combined accents, impact and impulse. 9<br />

The common denominator in the<br />

above descriptions is the consideration of phrasing as the patterning of energy<br />

or stress, rather than the phrase as a compositional unit.<br />

Two authors emphasize the significance of phrase and phrasing in investigating<br />

choreographic and cultural dance styles. In the seventies Yvonne Rainer<br />

and dance anthropologist Anya Peterson Royce associate changes in attitudes<br />

toward phrasing with changes in contemporary choreography; both also point<br />

to the need for further investigation. Rainer sees phrasing as an indicator of<br />

changes from modern to post-modern dance. She distinguishes the climactic<br />

phrasing of traditional modern dance from the energy equality of minimalist<br />

tendencies of the late 1960s and early ‘70s. 10<br />

Royce suggests that the length of<br />

a phrase may indicate innovative trends in choreography. She sees the lengthening<br />

or shortening of the dance phrase against its traditional conventions as<br />

providing potentially fruitful research both for the study of creativity and the<br />

cross-cultural variations in movement style. 11 It seems as though such important<br />

research should begin in the new millennium.<br />

As to the issues of developments in the terminology of phrasing, two Laban<br />

scholars in the 1970s describe the lack of its classification and analysis. In compiling<br />

a movement glossary about “pattern features” Martha Davis lists movement<br />

phrases and gives the examples of two contrasting phrasing with intensity<br />

building or diminishing. At the same time she also states that a terminology<br />

of movement phrases is virtually underdeveloped. 12<br />

Cecily Dell maintains that<br />

there is minimal research regarding a detailed analysis of phrasing. 13<br />

My own experience of teaching Labananalysis and Dance Dynamics/Effort at<br />

The Ohio State University, and conducting research in choreographic style, has<br />

motivated me to further develop the Laban-based classification and notation of<br />

phrasing. 14<br />

Discussions with colleagues Odette Blum and Lucy Venable about<br />

phrasing annotations of Labanotation scores greatly contributed to the following<br />

elaboration.<br />

58 / DANCE DYNAMICS


In summary, phrasing is an organizing factor underlying the performance<br />

and perception of movement within the Space-Time-Weight-Flow continuum.<br />

Within this framework the term refers predominantly to the qualitative rhythm<br />

of movement, or as Rainer puts it, to “the manner of execution of a movement<br />

or a series of movements.” 15<br />

CLASSIFICATION OF PHRASING<br />

The proposed classification of phrasing encompasses various groupings of<br />

movement qualities (or Efforts) in which changing or unchanging, and repetitive<br />

patterns can be identified. Eight main types of Phrasing can be distinguished.<br />

(I)<br />

EVEN PHRASING implies the performance of a quality that does not change;<br />

it therefore maintains the same intensity. This phrasing can have a variety of<br />

Space, Weight, and Flow combinations. With regard to Time, the quality of sustained,<br />

slow movement enhances the texture of evenness, while the intermittent<br />

quality of sudden, urgent movement goes against its nature. The following two<br />

examples have both sustained Time but different qualities of Space, and Flow:<br />

traveling smoothly through the space with sliding steps can be performed with<br />

a direct/sustained/free quality. On the other hand, in carefully weaving a design<br />

pattern, we can use an indirect/light/bound quality.<br />

(II) INCREASING-INTENSITY PHRASING implies the performance of a quality<br />

that changes in that it increases in intensity. When it reaches a sudden accent,<br />

we call it an Impact. Any single movement quality or combinations of qualities<br />

can increase. For instance, when speeding toward a goal there is an increase in<br />

directness and acceleration. On the other hand, an assertive statement, such as<br />

pounding a table, will result in a strong/sudden impact.<br />

(III) DECREASING-INTENSITY PHRASING also changes the movement quality<br />

in that it decreases its initial intensity. When initiated with a sudden accent<br />

we refer to it as an Impulse. Any single movement quality or combination of<br />

qualities can decrease. For instance, one can slow down one’s pace in walking,<br />

thus decelerate in time. One can also suddenly turn toward something with an<br />

impulse to approach it, and then gradually relinquish this action, thus decreasing<br />

from a direct/sudden quality.<br />

(IV) In INCREASING-THEN-DECREASING INTENSITY PHRASING quality changes<br />

occur within “one breath.” The changes in the qualities that increase and decrease in<br />

intensity can vary from single movement qualities or their combinations. For instance,<br />

while singing a lullaby and gently swinging a baby there is an Increase-then-Decrease in<br />

acceleration and weightiness.<br />

PHRASING / 59


(V) In D E C R E A S I N G - T H E N - I N C R E A S I N G I N T E N S I T Y P H R A S I N G* quality<br />

changes also occur during “one breath,” and can vary from single movement<br />

qualities or their combinations. For instance, when gradually relaxing from an<br />

intense tension and becoming tense again, there is a decrease from strength and<br />

bound flow and then an increase toward it again.<br />

* This phrasing type was included as a result of Robert Ellis Dunn’s observation that<br />

decreasing-then-increasing phrasing is “also existing as an archetypal shape both in movement<br />

and music.” (Letter of May 6, 1984.)<br />

(VI) ACCENTED PHRASING consists of a repetition of intermittent, sudden<br />

accents that form a rhythmic entity. While the quality of fast or sudden Time<br />

is constant it can be combined with other qualities of Space, Weight, and Flow.<br />

For instance, when tapping impatiently with fingers, a light/sudden quality is<br />

repeated. In contrast, when stomping in anger a strong/sudden/bound quality<br />

is repeated.<br />

(VII)<br />

VIBRATORY PHRASING consists of sudden repetitions that continue over<br />

a shorter or longer period of time. While the quality of exaggerated sudden<br />

Time is constant, it can be combined with other qualities of Space, Weight, and<br />

Flow. For instance, when mime artists imitate a butterfly they perform light/sudden<br />

hand vibrations. On the other hand, in convulsive shaking the entire body<br />

is engaged in strong/sudden/bound vibrations.<br />

(VII) RESILIENT PHRASING is a result of repetitive, rebounding qualities that can<br />

be performed with three different emphases. An Elastic, bouncy resiliency can<br />

be experienced or seen when dribbling a ball. Buoyant resiliency can be experienced<br />

or seen when jumping on a trampoline. Weighty resiliency can be experienced<br />

or seen in shaking out a heavy rug.<br />

See further movement and dance examples beginning on page 65.<br />

PHRASING / 60


Writing of Phrasing and its usage<br />

Phrasing signs can be annotated with two sets of dynamic symbols: signs from<br />

Kinetography/Labanotation, or Effort signs.<br />

(a)<br />

Phrasing annotated with dynamic signs from Kinetography/Labanotation<br />

is used for the purpose of indicating an overall performance of movement<br />

and dance energy. This less complex mode is appropriate in the<br />

beginning stages of learning. Its shortcomings are due to the nature of<br />

these signs that pertain only to selected combinations of Weight and<br />

Time, i.e. strong/sudden and light/sudden accents, and to aspects of<br />

resiliency.<br />

(b)<br />

Phrasing annotated with Effort signs is used when movement qualities<br />

need to be captured in greater detail. This more complex mode of<br />

Phrasing notation presupposes an understanding of the Effort theory.<br />

Since there are over seventy combinations of Space, Weight, Time, and<br />

Flow factors, and innumerable transitions among them, there is a potential<br />

for a great amount of phrasing variations.<br />

Phrasing can be written horizontally or vertically. The vertical notation includes<br />

the use of the Motif Writing. In contrast to Labanotation, Motif Writing captures<br />

overall movement ideas, such as body actions, spatial directions, body<br />

signs and relationship aspects. Symbols used most frequently in the context of<br />

Phrasing, are action strokes, and signs for stillness, written on an open staff.<br />

The usage of the classification and notation of Phrasing can be descriptive and<br />

prescriptive:<br />

(a)<br />

It can be used to describe performances viewed live, on film, or on<br />

videotape for the purpose of clarifying the observations of movement<br />

and dance sequences, or<br />

(b)<br />

It can also be used to “prescribe” or set different types of phrasing<br />

of movement qualities in order to heighten the performance in a dance<br />

class, a rehearsal, or in the context of a Labanotation score. Its usage in<br />

structured improvisation is also effective.<br />

61 / DANCE DYNAMICS


Explicit and implicit references to Phrasing in dance<br />

In addition to descriptions of dance qualities in dance writings (see pp. 4–5)<br />

here are excerpts that refer more specifically to Phrasing. While the first two<br />

quotations explicitly address Phrasing, the others implicitly refer to Phrasing by<br />

describing the performers’ actions and interpretive images perceived. (Emphases<br />

are the author’s.)<br />

In movement terms Bobov’s phrasing<br />

swings along more<br />

evenly with<br />

regular alterations of flow in contrast to the emphatic phrasing<br />

of<br />

Satmar or the impulsive dynamic phrasing of Lubavitch. (Jill Gelerman.<br />

“Mayim Patterns in Three Hasidic Comunities,” in Essays in Dance<br />

Research, Dance Research Annual IX<br />

. CORD 1978. 129.)<br />

Mr. Granados is a fine dancer with a distinctive style, which is as crucial<br />

in flamenco as it is in tap. His phrasing is deft and witty. . . (Jennifer<br />

Dunning. “A Dancer Shows how Rhythm can Set Fire to Flirtation.”<br />

The New York Times, Nov. 28, 2003. B3.<br />

Virtually all is flow, and continuous energy, punctuated with martial<br />

thrusts amid repeated sinking and rising bodies. (Anna Kisselgoff. “The<br />

Syncretism of Tai Chi and Bach,”by Lin Hwai-min and the Cloud Gate<br />

Dance Theater, The New York Times, Nov. 20, 2003. B1.)<br />

In response to the changing mood of the word and music, dancers<br />

walked meditatively, gazed heavenward, trembled<br />

in desperation and<br />

embraced and rejected one another. Most of all, they ventured boldly<br />

into space like people leaning to transcend their rage against injustice<br />

into a spirit of idealistic determination. (Jack Anderson. “Rod Rodgers<br />

Remembered: Lyric and Vivid Choreography,” The New York Times,<br />

Nov. 26, 2003. B15.)<br />

Slides and brushing steps<br />

were punctuated by hearty stamps. Allegro<br />

sequences resembled bursts of firecrackers. (Jack Anderson. “Feet with<br />

a Lot to Say and Ways to Say it,” The New York Times, December 18,<br />

2003.B3.) Dance review of Savion Glover’s Improvography.<br />

PHRASING / 62


Notes for Part B: Theory and Practice of Phrasing<br />

1. Elizabeth R. Hayes, Dance Composition and Production (New York: The Ronald Press<br />

Co., 1955) 31, 32, 70.<br />

2. Jacqueline Smith, Dance Composition—A Practical Guide for Teachers (London: Lepus<br />

<strong>Book</strong>s, 1976) 28.<br />

3. Doris Humphrey, The Art of Making Dances (New York: Grove Press, 1959) 67.<br />

4. Yvonne Rainer, “The Mind is a Muscle” in Work: 1961–73. (New York University,<br />

1974) 65.<br />

5. Humphrey, 68–70.<br />

6. Rudolf Laban, The Mastery of Movement<br />

(London: Macdonald & Evans, 1980) 43.<br />

7. See Vera Maletic, Body-Space-Expression: The Development of Rudolf Laban’s<br />

Movement and Dance Concepts (Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter, 1987) 94–97.<br />

8. Sylvia Bodmer, Studies Based on Crystalloid Dance Forms. (London: Laban Centre for<br />

Movement and Dance, 1979) 5.<br />

9. Marion North, Personality Assessment Through Movement (London: Macdonald &<br />

Evans, 1972) 21–28.<br />

10. Rainer, 64–65.<br />

11. Anya Peterson Royce, The Anthropology of Dance (Bloomington: Indiana University<br />

Press, 1977) 189.<br />

12. Martha Davis, Towards Understanding the Intrinsic in Body Movement (New York:<br />

Arno Press, 1975) 41–42.<br />

13. Cecily Dell, A Primer for Movement Description (New York: Dance Notation Bureau,<br />

1970) 92.<br />

14. Vera Maletic, “Dynamics of Dance” (International Council of Kinetography Laban:<br />

Proceedings of the Fifteenth Biennial Conference, 1987) 82–101.<br />

___________ , “Issues in Phrasing and Effort Annotations of a Humphrey Score” (ICKL:<br />

Proceedings of the Sixteenth Biennial Conference, 1989) 105–126.<br />

___________ , “Qualitative Annotations of Labanotation Scores” (ICKL: Proceedings of the<br />

Seventeenth Biennial Conference, 1991) 73–103.<br />

15. Rainer, 65.<br />

63 / DANCE DYNAMICS


Note about the order of explications for each phrasing type<br />

In sections entitled “Eight Phrasing types annotated with signs for dynamics<br />

from Kinetography/Labanotation,” and “Eight Phrasing types annotated with<br />

Effort signs”:<br />

(1) Phrasing types are marked by Roman numerals (I–VIII), followed by a<br />

succinct description of their characteristics.<br />

(2) Exemplars (EX) provide verbal and notational samples of ways in<br />

which movement is patterned or phrased.<br />

(3) Examples include movement that embodies the Phrasing under<br />

consideration.<br />

(4) The assignment<br />

“Be prepared to demonstrate your example” is based on the assumption<br />

that students performed the exemplars and some of the examples,<br />

and had time to explore their own solutions and images.<br />

(5) The summarizing assignment<br />

“Describe your experience of a particular phrasing” refers both to students’<br />

experience of performing or observing various Phrasing types. It<br />

may also lead to the identification of their own movement propensities.<br />

PHRASING / 64


Eight PHRASING TYPES<br />

Annotated with signs for Dynamics from Kinetography/Labanotation<br />

(I) EVEN PHRASING<br />

Same intensity is maintained while moving or keeping still.<br />

EX 1<br />

Same intensity during an action.<br />

OR<br />

Examples: ballet développé;<br />

Tai-Chi sequences.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

EX 2<br />

Same intensity while pausing.<br />

OR<br />

Examples: holding the leg up after a développé;<br />

balancing.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

Describe your experience of Even Phrasing:<br />

PHRASING TYPES / 65


(II) INCREASING-INTENSITY PHRASING<br />

Energy builds up from a lesser to a greater intensity; it may or may not reach a<br />

climactic accent. The latter is referred to as IMPACTIVE PHRASING or IMPACT<br />

[see EX 4a, b].<br />

EX 3<br />

The increase is achieved gradually.<br />

OR<br />

Example: a modern dance side fall.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

(IIa) IMPACTIVE PHRASING<br />

EX 4a<br />

The increase builds up to a strong accent or Impact; this is also referred<br />

to as IMPACTIVE PHRASING.<br />

OR strong accent =<br />

Examples: striking as in martial arts; ballet frappé;<br />

lunge.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

EX 4b<br />

The increase builds up to a light accent; this is also referred to as<br />

IMPACTIVE PHRASING.<br />

OR light accent =<br />

Examples: ballet piqué;<br />

typing.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

Describe your experience of both Increasing and Impactive Phrasing:<br />

66 / DANCE DYNAMICS


(III) DECREASING-INTENSITY PHRASING<br />

Energy diminishes from a greater to a lesser intensity. The decrease can<br />

occur gradually or can follow an initial outburst. The latter is referred to as<br />

IMPULSIVE PHRASING or IMPULSE [see EX 6a, 6b].<br />

EX 5<br />

The decrease can occur gradually.<br />

OR<br />

Examples: slowing down a walking pace; gradually releasing from a<br />

tensely held position.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

(IIIa) IMPULSIVE PHRASING<br />

EX 6a<br />

A light sudden outburst is followed by decreasing energy; this is also<br />

referred to as IMPULSIVE PHRASING.<br />

OR<br />

Examples: tossing the sleeve in Asian dance; throwing a small ball.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

EX 6b<br />

A strong sudden outburst or Impulse is followed by decreasing energy.<br />

OR<br />

Example: a ballet sissonne ouverte; throwing a sandbag.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

Describe your experience of Decreasing and Impulsive Phrasing:<br />

PHRASING TYPES / 67


(IV) INCREASING-THEN-DECREASING INTENSITY PHRASING<br />

The increase and decrease is gradual. The length of the increase and decrease<br />

can be the same [EX 7a] or different [EX 7b].<br />

EX 7a<br />

The energy builds in intensity in the middle of the phrase and gradually<br />

diminishes towards its end. (When associated with Effort elements of<br />

Weight, Time and Flow it becomes swing-like.)<br />

OR<br />

Examples: a ballet grand jeté;<br />

modern dance swing; golf swing.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

EX 7b<br />

The increase and decrease may vary in length.<br />

OR<br />

Example: Breathing exercise in which inhaling is shorter than the exhaling,<br />

followed by a longer inhaling and shorter exhaling.<br />

Be prepared to show your example.<br />

Describe your experience of Phrasing with Increasing-then-Decreasing intensity:<br />

68 / DANCE DYNAMICS


(V) DECREASING-THEN-INCREASING INTENSITY PHRASING<br />

The decrease and increase can be gradual or be initiated with an impulse and/<br />

or end with an impact. Each phase can have a different length [EX 8b].<br />

EX 8a<br />

Energy decreases from and builds toward greater intensity gradually.<br />

OR<br />

Examples: arm circling upwards-backwards-forwards-upwards decreases<br />

from, and builds toward greater intensity; your anxiousness is gradually<br />

released but then it again builds-up.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

EX 8b<br />

The decrease and increase may vary in length.<br />

OR<br />

Example: a variation on the breathing exercise in that you exhale briefly<br />

and inhale longer, followed by a long exhalation and short inhalation.<br />

Be prepared to show your example.<br />

Describe your experience of Phrasing with decreasing-then-increasing intensity.<br />

PHRASING TYPES / 69


EX 9a<br />

Decreasing from a strong Impulse, the energy builds up to a strong<br />

Impact. Each phase has equal length.<br />

OR<br />

Example: from ballet sissonne to assemblé; jumping from two feet to<br />

one, followed by a jump from one foot to two.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

EX 9b<br />

Energy changes from a light impulse to a light impact.<br />

OR<br />

Example: picking and tossing some lint.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

EX 10a A gradual decrease is followed by an impactive build-up.<br />

OR<br />

Example: releasing from a ballet relevé<br />

into a tombé.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

EX 10b An impulse is followed by a gradual increase.<br />

OR<br />

Example: a sprinter’s start—sudden response to the start signal followed by<br />

a gradual acceleration.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

70 / DANCE DYNAMICS


Describe your experience of Phrasing with Decreasing-then-Increasing intensity:<br />

(VI) ACCENTED PHRASING<br />

Created with a series of accents together forming an entity. It implies exertion<br />

of energy that can be repeated and/or followed by a shorter or longer stillness.<br />

EX 11a<br />

Five strong accents.<br />

OR<br />

Examples: tap-dancing; Flamenco dancing.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

EX 11b Five light accents.<br />

OR<br />

Examples: ballet battements, jetés pointés; typing.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

Describe your experience of Accented phrasing:<br />

PHRASING TYPES / 71


(VII) VIBRATORY PHRASING<br />

Created by a series of sudden, repetitive movements.<br />

EX 12a<br />

It can be performed with sudden-strengths.<br />

OR<br />

Example: Savion Glover’s sequences of very fast and hard tapping;<br />

drum roll.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

EX 12b<br />

It can also be performed with sudden-lightness.<br />

OR<br />

Examples: jazz shimmy, nerve tap; fluttering arms in Chinese Peacock<br />

dance.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

Describe your experience of vibratory phrasing:<br />

72 / DANCE DYNAMICS


(VIII) RESILIENT PHRASING<br />

Created by several rebounding movements which form an entity. Its weight<br />

activation can have different emphases, such as:<br />

· oscillating between strength and lightness with ELASTICITY<br />

· rebounding with BUOYANCY thus emphasizing lightness<br />

· releasing into gravity with WEIGHTINESS and a shorter recovery into lightness<br />

The signs for the three emphases of Resilient phrasing used here are:<br />

ELASTIC, bouncy quality<br />

BUOYANT quality<br />

WEIGHTY quality<br />

EX 13a<br />

Four ELASTIC movements oscillate between downward strength and<br />

upward lightness.<br />

OR<br />

Examples: shoulder and arm movements in some ethnic dances;<br />

dribbling a hand ball.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

EX 13b Four bouncy jumps in which the light aerial phase and that of the<br />

stronger take-off or landing take an equal amount of time.<br />

OR<br />

Examples: square dancing; four consecutive ballet changements.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

PHRASING TYPES / 73


EX 14a Four BUOYANT movements which emphasize the upward lightness and<br />

briefly recover into the downward heaviness.<br />

OR<br />

Examples: arm movements in some ethnic dances; tossing a ball high<br />

into the air from one hand to another<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

EX 14b Four BUOYANT jumps in which the airborne time of elevation predominates<br />

while the stronger take-off and landing are brief.<br />

OR<br />

Examples: jumping on a trampoline; four consecutive ballet pas de<br />

chats.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

EX 15a Four WEIGHTY movements: there is an emphasis on a downward giving-in<br />

to gravity while the rebounding upward into lightness is brief.<br />

OR<br />

Examples: four grapevine steps; four releasing arm swings.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

74 / DANCE DYNAMICS


EX 15b<br />

Four WEIGHTY jumps: longer time is spent sinking downward with<br />

heaviness while the rebounding into the air with lightness is brief.<br />

OR<br />

Examples: four consecutive ballet contretemps or assemblés; hopscotch.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

Describe your experience of ELASTIC, bouncy Resilient Phrasing:<br />

Describe your experience of BUOYANT Resilient Phrasing:<br />

Describe your experience of WEIGHTY Resilient phrasing:<br />

PHRASING TYPES / 75


SEQUENCING OF PHRASING<br />

The above eight types of Phrasing can be performed consecutively or concurrently<br />

or they can overlap.<br />

(A) CONSECUTIVE PHRASING<br />

Can be performed by the same or by different body parts.<br />

EX 16a The sequence starts with Even phrasing, followed by Increasing-then-<br />

Decreasing phrasing, and ends with an Impactive phrasing.<br />

OR<br />

EX 16b<br />

Three light Accents are followed by three Buoyant movements, and end<br />

with light Vibratory phrasing.<br />

OR<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

76 / DANCE DYNAMICS


(B) CONCURRENT PHRASING<br />

Occurs when different body parts perform different types of phrasing at the<br />

same time.<br />

EX 17a Accented phrasing performed by the legs occurs at the same time as an<br />

Even phrasing performed by the arms.<br />

OR<br />

EX 17b<br />

Even phrasing performed by the legs occurs at the same time as light<br />

Vibratory phrasing performed by the arms.<br />

OR<br />

Be prepared to show your example.<br />

SEQUENCING OF PHRASING / 77


(C) OVERLAPPING PHRASING<br />

Occurs among movements of various body parts when one action begins<br />

before the phrasing of the previous one has ended.<br />

EX 18a<br />

The Impulsive Phrasing performed with the right arm starts before<br />

the Impulsive Phrasing of the left arm has terminated.<br />

OR<br />

EX 18b<br />

While the sequence starts with three Accents performed by the right leg,<br />

an Even Phrasing performed with the right arm overlaps with it;<br />

this is followed by an overlapping Vibratory Phrasing of the left arm.<br />

OR<br />

Describe your experiences of Consecutive, Concurrent and Overlapping<br />

Phrasing:<br />

78 / DANCE DYNAMICS


Eight PHRASING TYPES annotated with EFFORT SIGNS<br />

(I) EVEN PHRASING<br />

Can be associated with any Effort element or combination of elements except<br />

suddenness. (The intermittent quality of suddenness does not create evenness<br />

in movement.)<br />

EX 19a A direct/sustained quality is maintained during an action.<br />

OR<br />

Examples: ballet développé;<br />

Tai-Chi sequences.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

EX 19b<br />

A direct/bound quality is maintained while pausing.<br />

OR<br />

Examples: holding the leg up after a développé;<br />

maintaining a lunge.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

Describe your experience of Even Phrasing performed with Effort qualities of<br />

your own choice.<br />

PHRASING TYPES WITH EFFORT SIGNS / 79


(II) INCREASING-INTENSITY-PHRASING<br />

Can be performed with any Effort element or combination of elements without<br />

reaching a climactic accent.<br />

EX 20A A gradual change toward SINGLE EFFORT ELEMENTS:<br />

EX 20A S PA C E —becoming increasingly direct is followed by becoming<br />

(a)<br />

increasingly indirect or flexible.<br />

OR<br />

Examples: a forward reaching gesture; opening to the side.<br />

EX 20A WEIGHT—becoming firmer is followed by becoming lighter.<br />

(b)<br />

OR<br />

Examples: moving into a deep plié; ascending to a relevé.<br />

EX 20A TIME—gradual acceleration is followed by gradual deceleration.<br />

(c)<br />

OR<br />

Examples: from walking to running; reducing the speed to a walk.<br />

80 / DANCE DYNAMICS


EX 20A FLOW<br />

(d)<br />

FLOW—becoming more controlled is followed by increasingly freeing<br />

the flow of movement.<br />

OR<br />

Examples: approaching something dangerous; approaching something<br />

joyful<br />

Describe your experience of Increasing Phrasing toward a single Effort<br />

<strong>Ele</strong>ment of your own choice:<br />

PHRASING TYPES WITH EFFORT SIGNS / 81


EX 20B<br />

EX 20B<br />

Gradual increase toward C O M B I N AT I O N S O F T H R E E E F F O RT<br />

ELEMENTS:<br />

Becoming stronger/faster/more direct.<br />

(a)<br />

OR<br />

Examples: a modern dance side fall; becoming more assertive<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

Describe your experience of Increasing Phrasing toward a combination of<br />

Effort <strong>Ele</strong>ments of your own choice:<br />

82 / DANCE DYNAMICS


(IIa) IMPACTIVE PHRASING<br />

When the increase reaches a climactic accent or Impact, it is referred to as an<br />

IMPACTIVE or EMPHATIC PHRASING. The accent implies suddenness that<br />

can be combined with any other Effort elements.<br />

EX 21a<br />

The increase builds to an impactive direct/strong/sudden accent.<br />

OR<br />

Examples: striking as in martial arts; ballet frappé; lunge.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

EX 21b The increase builds to an impactive direct/light/sudden accent.<br />

OR<br />

Examples: ballet piqué;<br />

lightly pointing to a person.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

Compare your experience of Impactive phrasing when associated with strong,<br />

in contrast to light qualities:<br />

PHRASING TYPES WITH EFFORT SIGNS / 83


(III) DECREASING-INTENSITY PHRASING<br />

Can be performed with decrease in an Effort element or combination of elements.<br />

EX 22<br />

The initial strong-bound quality decreases gradually.<br />

OR<br />

Example: gradually releasing from a strong tension.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

(IIIa) IMPULSIVE PHRASING<br />

The decrease can follow an initial outburst or Impulse. The latter is referred to<br />

as IMPULSIVE PHRASING in which the initial sudden accent can be combined<br />

with any other Effort element.<br />

EX 23a The Impulsive Phrasing starts with a strong/sudden quality which<br />

gradually decreases.<br />

OR<br />

Example: a ballet sissonne ouverte; throwing a sandbag.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

EX 23b The Impulsive Phrasing starts with a light/sudden quality which gradually<br />

decreases.<br />

OR<br />

Example: tossing the sleeve in Asian dance; throwing a light ball.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

84 / DANCE DYNAMICS


(IV) INCREASING-THEN-DECREASING INTENSITY PHRASING<br />

Can be performed in relation to any Effort quality. The length of the increase<br />

and decrease can be the same [EX 24a, 24b] or different [EX 24c].<br />

EX 24a<br />

The action increases then decreases in the qualities of directness/speed/<br />

free flow.<br />

OR<br />

Examples: accelerating run for a long jump (ballet grand jeté;) and<br />

gradual recuperation.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

EX 24b The action increases then decreases in the quality of weightiness*/speed/<br />

free flow in a Swing-like manner.<br />

OR<br />

Examples: front-back leg swings; whole body swings from side to side.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

* = The sign for weightiness or a weighty quality uses a variation of the sign for<br />

Weight: the strong symbol changing into lightness which is drawn much shorter.<br />

PHRASING TYPES WITH EFFORT SIGNS / 85


The phases of increasing and decreasing may very in length.<br />

EX 24c<br />

After a short increase toward weightiness/acceleration/free flow, follows<br />

a longer decrease; when repeating the increase takes longer than the<br />

decrease.<br />

OR<br />

Example: performing two arm sideway swings; one with short increase<br />

and longer decrease, the second with longer increase and shorter<br />

decrease.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

Describe your experience of Increasing-then-Decreasing Phrasing in relation to<br />

two different Effort qualities of your own choice:<br />

86 / DANCE DYNAMICS


(V) DECREASING-THEN-INCREASING INTENSITY PHRASING<br />

Can be performed in relation to any Effort quality. The decrease-then-increase<br />

can occur gradually; it can also follow or precede an accent. As seen before [EX<br />

21a, b; 23a, b], both Impulsive and Impactive Phrasing can combine their sudden<br />

quality with any other Effort element. Further, the two above Phrasings<br />

can be combined with a gradual Decrease and Increase, and the Phrasing may<br />

vary in length.<br />

EX25a<br />

The decrease-then-increase occurs in relation to a light/bound quality.<br />

Both phases have equal duration.<br />

OR<br />

Example: gradually releasing from a light/bound balancing on one foot,<br />

and preparing to balance on the other foot with the same quality.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

EX25b<br />

The decrease occurs slower than the increase in relation to a light/<br />

bound quality.<br />

OR<br />

Example: a timing variation of the example for 25a.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

PHRASING TYPES with EFFORT SIGNS / 87


EX 25c<br />

A decrease, initiated by a strong/sudden Impulse builds to a strong/<br />

sudden Impact. Both phases are of equal duration.<br />

OR<br />

Example: from sissonne to assemblé;<br />

in other words jumping from two<br />

feet to one is followed by a jump from one foot to two; the first<br />

accented take off initiates the decreasing phase that subsequently<br />

increases toward the accented landing.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

EX 25d<br />

Decreasing after the Impulse takes longer than the increase towards the<br />

Impact.<br />

OR<br />

Example: in a fencing exercise you deflect your partner’s blow with an<br />

indirect/strong/sudden Impulse that decreases, and then you build<br />

towards a short attack with a direct/strong/sudden Impact.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

88 / DANCE DYNAMICS


The following two examples combine gradual increase or decrease with<br />

Impactive or Impulsive phrasing.<br />

EX 26a<br />

A gradual decrease from a light/bound quality builds to a direct/<br />

sudden impact.<br />

OR<br />

Example: releasing from a ballet relevé into a tombé; releasing from<br />

balancing and falling into a lunge.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

EX 26b<br />

A strong/sudden impulse increases towards a direct/acceleration.<br />

OR<br />

Example: a sprinter’s start: the sudden/strong response to the start signal<br />

is followed by gradual acceleration towards the goal.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

Describe some of your experiences with Decreasing-then-Increasing Phrasing<br />

in three variations of your own choice:<br />

PHRASING TYPES with EFFORT SIGNS / 89


(VI) ACCENTED PHRASING<br />

Is associated with suddenness but can vary in elements of Weight. With regard<br />

to the <strong>Ele</strong>ments or Space and Flow it can be performed more efficiently with<br />

directness and bound flow.<br />

EX 27a<br />

The group of five accents is performed with a strong/sudden/bound<br />

quality.<br />

OR<br />

Example: in the style of Flamenco dancing; the ringleader stamps the<br />

tempo for the line-dance.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

EX 27b The same rhythm is performed with a direct/light/sudden quality.<br />

OR<br />

Examples: ballet battements, jetés pointés; sending Morse code signals.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

Describe your experience of Accented Phrasing with two different Effort qualities<br />

of your own choice:<br />

90 / DANCE DYNAMICS


(VII) VIBRATORY PHRASING<br />

Is created by a repetition of exaggerated suddenness.* It also can be associated<br />

with elements of Weight and Flow.<br />

* = exaggerated suddenness<br />

+<br />

EX 28a<br />

A strong/exaggerated sudden/bound vibration.<br />

OR<br />

Example: Savion Glover’s sequences of very fast and hard tapping;<br />

drum roll.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

EX 28b<br />

A light/exaggerated sudden vibration.<br />

OR<br />

Examples: jazz shimmy; mime artists representing a butterfly.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

Describe your experience of Vibratory Phrasing with two different Effort qualities<br />

of your own choice:<br />

PHRASING TYPES with EFFORT SIGNS / 91


(VIII) RESILIENT PHRASING<br />

Is associated with rebounding* Weight and Time qualities in several combinations.<br />

* The following signs for rebounding use a variation of the Effort graph: Effort elements<br />

which serve as a preparation for rebounding or releasing from it are drawn shorter and elements<br />

which are emphasized maintain their normal lengths.<br />

Light releasing from strong<br />

Strong or heavy releasing from light<br />

Sudden rebounding from sustained<br />

Sustained rebounding from sudden<br />

The combination of light/sustained rebounding from strong/sudden<br />

creates a BUOYANT quality<br />

The combination of heavy/sustained being released from light/sudden<br />

creates a WEIGHTY quality<br />

A strong/sudden sign linked vertically with light/sudden denotes an<br />

ELASTIC, bouncy quality<br />

92 / DANCE DYNAMICS


EX 29a A group of four E L A S T I C , bouncy movements oscillating between<br />

downward and upward.<br />

OR<br />

Examples: shoulder and upper body movement in some ethnic dances;<br />

dribbling a light hand ball.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

EX 29b<br />

A group of four ELASTIC springs in which the aerial phases and the<br />

take-off or landing take an equal amount of time.<br />

OR<br />

Examples: square dancing; four consecutive ballet changements.<br />

Be prepared to demonstrate your example.<br />

EX 30a<br />

A group of B U O YA N T movements which emphasize the upward<br />

lightness and briefly recover into the downward heaviness.<br />

OR<br />

Examples: a motif of arm movements in some ethnic dances; tossing a<br />

ball high up into the air four times.<br />

Be prepared to show your examples.<br />

PHRASING TYPES with EFFORT SIGNS / 93


EX 30b Four BUOYANT jumps in which the time in the air predominates while<br />

the take-off and landing are brief.<br />

OR<br />

Examples: four consecutive pas de chats; jumping on a trampoline.<br />

Be prepared to show your examples.<br />

EX 31a<br />

Four W E I G H T Y movements: there is an emphasis on a downward<br />

giving-in to gravity with a brief recovery upward into lightness.<br />

OR<br />

Examples: four grapevine steps; a weary walk.<br />

Be prepared to show your examples.<br />

EX 31b Four WEIGHTY jumps: longer time is spent releasing downward with<br />

heaviness while the light recovery in the air brief.<br />

OR<br />

Examples: four consecutive jumps from one leg to two or ballet assemblés;<br />

hopscotch.<br />

Be prepared to show your examples.<br />

94 / DANCE DYNAMICS


Describe your experience of ELASTIC, bouncy Resilient phrasing:<br />

Describe your sequence of BUOYANT Resilient<br />

phrasing:<br />

Describe your experience of WEIGHTY Resilient<br />

phrasing:<br />

PHRASING TYPES with EFFORT SIGNS / 95


S E Q U E N C I N G O F P H R A S I N G<br />

Different types of Phrasing with various Effort qualities can be performed consecutively<br />

or concurrently or they can overlap.<br />

(A) CONSECUTIVE PHRASING<br />

Can be performed by the same or by different body parts.<br />

EX 32<br />

The sequence starts with Even Phrasing consisting of a direct/light/<br />

sustained quality, followed by Increasing-then-Decreasing Phrasing<br />

toward and away from indirect/strong quality, and ends with direct/<br />

strong/sudden Impactive Phrasing.<br />

OR<br />

EX 33<br />

A sequence of Accented phrasing consisting of direct/light/sudden<br />

qualities is followed by Resilient Buoyant phrasing, and ends with light/<br />

sudden Vibratory Phrasing.<br />

OR<br />

96 / DANCE DYNAMICS


(B) CONCURRENT PHRASING<br />

Occurs when different body parts perform actions with different types of<br />

phrasing and Effort qualities at the same time.<br />

EX 34<br />

Strong/sudden Accented phrasing which is performed by the legs occurs<br />

at the same time as sustained/bound Even Phrasing performed by the<br />

arms.<br />

OR<br />

EX 35<br />

An Even strong/sustained quality performed by the legs occurs at the<br />

same time as light/sudden Vibratory Phrasing performed by the arms.<br />

OR<br />

SEQUENCING OF PHRASING / 97


(C) OVERLAPPING PHRASING<br />

Among movements of various body parts, one action may begin before the<br />

phrasing of the previous one has ended.<br />

EX 36<br />

The light/sudden Impulse performed with the right arm starts before the<br />

light/sudden Impulsive Phrasing of the left arm has terminated.<br />

OR<br />

EX 37<br />

While the sequence starts with three strong/sudden/bound Accents<br />

performed by the right leg, an Even direct/sustained/bound Phrasing<br />

performed with the right arm overlaps with it; this is followed by an<br />

overlapping sudden/bound Vibratory Phrasing of the left arm.<br />

OR<br />

98 / DANCE DYNAMICS


Make up a sequence with Concurrent Phrasing and describe your experience of<br />

performing it. How successful are you in observing it in performances of others?<br />

Make up a sequence with Overlapping Phrasing and describe your experience<br />

of performing it. How successful are you in observing it in performances of<br />

others?<br />

SEQUENCING OF PHRASING / 99


SUMMARY: Phrasing and Effort interdependencies<br />

Although we examined Effort and Phrasing separately, these two aspects of<br />

movement and dance dynamics are interdependent, even united. While Phrasing<br />

can be seen as a “macrostructure” of dynamic patterns, Effort elements and<br />

their combinations constitute their “microstructure.”<br />

As shown on the chart on p. 101, Phrasing integrates Effort qualities in various<br />

ways. For instance, Even Phrasing embraces unchanging Effort qualities,<br />

and maintains their intensity under the same “breath.” With the exception of<br />

sudden Time, all single elements and their combinations can be performed with<br />

Even Phrasing. Increasing or Decreasing Phrasings and their combinations blend<br />

Efforts that either gradually change their intensity or start with emphatic accents<br />

(Impulses) or end with climactic accents (Impacts). All single Effort elements<br />

and their combinations can be integrated in the above types of phrasing.<br />

While Accented Phrasing is intermittent and repetitive, Vibratory Phrasing is<br />

continuous and repetitive. All Effort qualities except sustained Time can be<br />

performed within these two kinds of Phrasing. The three modes of Resilient<br />

Phrasing are rebounding, continuous, and repetitive, and explore the interplay<br />

between active and passive attitudes to Weight and variations in Time.<br />

100 / DANCE DYNAMICS


M A C R O S T R U C T U R E<br />

PHRASING/GROUPING/PATTERNS<br />

EVEN<br />

INCREASING<br />

DECREASING<br />

INCREASING-then-DECREASING<br />

DECREASING-then-INCREASING<br />

IMPULSE<br />

IMPACT<br />

ACCENTED<br />

VIBRATORY<br />

RESILIENT (Elastic)<br />

M I C R O S T R U C T U R E<br />

MOVEMENT QUALITIES/EFFORTS<br />

selected examples:<br />

direct<br />

light/sustained<br />

direct/strong/bound<br />

toward light<br />

toward indirect/light<br />

toward direct/strong/bound<br />

away from bound<br />

away from strong/sustained<br />

away from direct/light/bound<br />

toward and away from<br />

strong<br />

direct<br />

bound<br />

away and toward<br />

strong<br />

direct<br />

bound<br />

decreasing from sudden<br />

decreasing from light/sudden<br />

decreasing from sudden/strong/bound accents<br />

building to strong/sudden<br />

building to direct/sudden<br />

building to direct/strong/sudden accents<br />

sudden/light<br />

sudden/strong/bound<br />

several repetitions of<br />

sudden<br />

sudden/strong<br />

sudden/light/free<br />

oscillating between strong/sudden and light/sudden<br />

SUMMARY / 101


A P P E N D I X I<br />

[A] METHODOLOGICAL CONSIDERATIONS<br />

VERA MALETIC<br />

I first conceived the Workbook in the '90s as the text for my classes in Dance<br />

Dynamics. Due to my professional background the text is informed by the tradition<br />

of Laban's teaching as it was originally formulated and re-formulate by the<br />

master and his students, as well as by the development of Laban's framework in<br />

the USA. I first trained in the former Yugoslavia with my mother Ana Maletic,<br />

who was one of Laban's disciples, and subsequently with Lisa Ullmann, Warren<br />

Lamb, Marion North, and Valerie Preston Dunlop. After visiting and moving<br />

to United States, I interacted with Irmgard Bartenieff, Martha Davis, and Bob<br />

Dunn, and was a member of the Theory Network Coordinating Committee of<br />

LIMS (Laban-Bartenieff Institute of Movement Studies) in New York. At The<br />

Ohio State University Department of Dance I established a close collaboration<br />

with Melanie Bales who assisted with my courses and contributed to the material<br />

in the Workbook.<br />

(a) The demands of teaching/learning Dance Dynamics<br />

The synchrony of bodily practice and theoretical conceptualization, makes the<br />

teaching/ learning process of dance dynamics quite complex. Several simultaneous<br />

actions are required from the student:<br />

to attend to and focus on proprioceptive sensations, particularly the kinesthetic<br />

feedback during the performance of assigned sequences and the students’ own<br />

short studies;<br />

to understand the links between emphases on various Effort qualities and the<br />

attitudes toward the powers or capacities of thinking, sensing, intuiting, and<br />

feeling;<br />

to identify performance characteristics while observing others;<br />

to identify performance variants while observing videotapes of one’s own studies<br />

and assigned sequences;<br />

to become increasingly aware of one’s own propensities;<br />

to demonstrate an active willingness for expanding this habitual range.<br />

APPENDIX I / 103


Motivating students to engage in these processes of active learning and discovery<br />

is vital. Linking the material to individual student interests, such as coaching,<br />

performance, choreography, teaching, directing from scores, and other<br />

vocational interests may stimulate involvement.<br />

(b) Suggested approaches to the teaching of Dance Dynamics<br />

Movement and dance professionals teaching Laban’s concept of Effort present<br />

the content in a way that is congruent with their own experience and ideas.<br />

They sequence it according to the context in which they are teaching, such as<br />

type of students within colleges, universities, and other institutions. The length<br />

of the course or workshop, and the frequency of contact hours also play an<br />

important role in the choice of content and methodology to present it.<br />

Deductive or inductive: choices of approaches<br />

Two approaches can be taken to any complex subject, such as dance dynamics:<br />

either from the general to the particular, or from the detailed to the overall. In<br />

the summary on p. 101, Phrasing was seen as the “macro-structure” of dynamic<br />

patterns grouping the detailed Effort qualities. On the other hand, the latter can<br />

be seen as the “micro-structure” identifying individual Effort elements and their<br />

particular combinations.<br />

Here are two examples of the deductive or general-to-the-particular approach:<br />

(1) When comparing the execution of a Tai-Chi sequence it may be easier<br />

to notice first the EVEN, uninterrupted Phrasing of two performers, than<br />

the individual Effort qualities, such as direct/bound versus light/bound.<br />

(2) The most noticeable feature of the Galliarde (dance from the Renaissance)<br />

are groups of accented steps or ACCENTED Phrasing. The distinction<br />

of qualities among the performers, such as sudden/strong or sudden/<br />

bound, may require longer training. Thus where the length of the course<br />

in Dance Dynamics is short, it may be more effective to start with the<br />

Phrasing aspects.<br />

Following are two examples of the inductive method, i.e. from detailed descriptions<br />

to the overall dynamic patterns; these approaches that are drawn from<br />

working with combinations of two or three Effort elements.<br />

(1) The performance of a direct/light/sustained quality may feel and look<br />

differently if maintained in an EVEN pattern or when gradually emerging<br />

in an INCREASING Phrasing.<br />

104 / DANCE DYNAMICS


(2) The execution of a strong/sudden/bound quality may gradually dissolve<br />

in a DECREASING pattern, or may bring about a temper tantrum-like<br />

expression in a VIBRATORY Phrasing.<br />

(c) The choice of modalities<br />

[In the following text, quotations from student papers in 1998–99 are interspersed<br />

in italics.]<br />

A combination of work in and out of class is effective. It can include the following<br />

aspects:<br />

“Physicalizing,” i.e. exploring and subsequently composing movement sequences<br />

as well as short studies on assigned topics.<br />

I frequently introduce a particular phrasing type or a movement quality by<br />

either describing it in word images and sounds or by giving movement examples.<br />

After this directed introduction I ask students to explore this particular<br />

aspect of dynamics and proceed with problem solving in their own way. As a<br />

homework assignment I can ask them to select movement material from their<br />

explorations and compose sequences that they can show in class and teach to<br />

others. I see bodily experience as a vital initial stage of learning.<br />

The aspects of class I found most enjoyable and stimulating are the improvisation explorations<br />

at the introduction of the new concept, and also the showing of our studies.<br />

Another important mode of learning is Observing and recording movement<br />

sequences and studies.<br />

To sharpen the aspects of performance and of observations one can use both<br />

videotaping and notating of sequences and studies.<br />

VIDEOTAPING dance dynamics can have its limitations, as well as advantages.<br />

While the limitations lie in the loss of some nuances of movement qualities and<br />

in recording one singular performance, the advantage of observing videotapes<br />

is the opportunity to compare the proprioceptive feedback during the performance<br />

with the visual perception of the performer/spectator. The reliability<br />

of the “inner” perspective of the performer in movement and dance (where<br />

the performer and the performed are in one person) varies according to the<br />

degree of kinesthetic feedback during the performance. Therefore distancing<br />

oneself from one’s work, and looking at it from the spectator’s point of view<br />

can be more effective than only comments by the teacher and classmates. The<br />

use of both, the kinesthetic and the visual perception, the “outer” and “inner”<br />

perspective, can provide a good synergy of critical self-observation and lead to<br />

subsequent revisions.<br />

APPENDIX I / 105


Evaluating my final studies is the most interesting assignment. This process sheds the<br />

light on how a phrasing type feels, in contrast to how it looks in performance.<br />

NOTATING sequences by means of simple Motif Writing, Phrasing and Effort<br />

signs can serve as a means for clarifying students’ own compositional and<br />

performance intents. If students have had no instruction in Motif Writing it<br />

is helpful to give a general introduction to the basic staff, action, and stillness<br />

signs. Additional symbols can be introduced when the need arises. [See Ann<br />

Hutchinson-Guest Your Move: A New Approach to the Study of Movement and<br />

Dance, New York: Gordon & Breach, 1983, as a reference book.]<br />

Creating studies and notating sections of them was enjoyable, interesting, and<br />

stimulating.<br />

Describing the “lived experience” of performing various phrasing types and<br />

movement qualities.<br />

In general, the process of generating adjectives that describe the bodily experience<br />

of performed sequences brings about the awareness of how particular<br />

combinations of Effort <strong>Ele</strong>ments give different moods, expressions or feelings<br />

within particular Phrasing types. Such descriptions are suggested throughout<br />

the Workbook in both, the Effort and the Phrasing sections. In the latter students<br />

are asked to describe how the performance of a particular phrasing type<br />

makes them feel.<br />

Such descriptions serve several functions:<br />

They can create a resource that simultaneously engages the kinesthetic sense as<br />

well as the verbal representation of a particular Phrasing and Effort quality. In<br />

other words, they creates the link between the physical and <strong>mental</strong> component<br />

of movement qualities. This has been succinctly described by two students:<br />

I liked the worksheet descriptions because it helped me to form my impressions<br />

or ideas more concretely. By putting into words how a dynamic makes me feel,<br />

I have a resource to go back to when I am trying to achieve a certain quality<br />

in movement.<br />

The colorful imagery used in class is interesting and helpful in defining the<br />

phrasing types.<br />

106 / DANCE DYNAMICS<br />

In addition, the synonyms and descriptions of personal experiences, draw attention<br />

to the link between particular Efforts and various aspects of our consciousness.<br />

As described in Workbook, predominant attitudes to Space are linked with<br />

thinking or attending, those to Weight are linked with sensing, those to Time<br />

with intuiting, and those to Flow with feeling. Various emphases of these Effort


elements and their combinations significantly contribute to the expression of<br />

meaning in dance. Furthermore, these emphases also point to the dual aspects<br />

of Effort qualities that are present both in physical and <strong>mental</strong> actions.<br />

One of the most useful results of taking this course is a resource of imagery in<br />

words & ideas to help access the various Effort Qualities. This helps not only<br />

my performance when emboding notated movement, but will help in future<br />

when coaching other dances.<br />

I also see a strong link with my interest in dance criticism and analysis.<br />

Observing and understanding choreographic and performance choices in<br />

Dynamics and Phrasing will inform my interpretation of the work and ground<br />

that interpretation in something tangible/quantifiable.<br />

Viewing video excerpts from a variety of dance pieces.<br />

The DVD companion provides an opportunity for creating an objective distance<br />

between one’s own performance of various components of dance dynamics, and<br />

that of the choreographers and performers. Thus movement and dance excerpts<br />

selected from dance pieces, studies, and improvisations can be viewed on two<br />

levels:<br />

(1) an experiential, non-analytical mode (while turning down the voiceover<br />

text), and<br />

(2) as another source of information about a particular aspect of dance<br />

dynamics.<br />

The non-analytical mode can be enhanced with descriptions of the “lived experience”<br />

of what was seen. Descriptive adjectives can encapsulate the kinesthetic<br />

or emotional feel. On the other hand, reviewing the text in the DVD guide and<br />

the Workbook can support the cognitive mode. Both modes are essential components<br />

of the perception of movement and dance.<br />

Follow-up reading and discussion serve to complement all the above described<br />

modalities.<br />

Overview and summary papers (such as midterm and particularly finals) are an<br />

important aspect of the learning process.<br />

A quarter system, and even semester system, are a relatively short period for<br />

introducing and assimilating the material. Thus the final assignments give an<br />

opportunity to review and summarize both the experience and knowledge.<br />

APPENDIX I / 107


The synthesis from the final study and paper were extremely helpful. In many<br />

ways this is where it all comes together for me and can therefore be carried forth<br />

into my work beyond this term. Thus, this final discussion may be the most<br />

important modality for me.<br />

DESCRIBE class modalities that worked best for you:<br />

108 / DANCE DYNAMICS


[B] SELECTED TEACHING APPLICATIONS<br />

MELANIE BALES<br />

I was first introduced to Laban study at the University of Illinois while working<br />

on my MFA, through the teaching of visiting choreographer Bill Evans.<br />

In 1982, I participated in an Evans summer workshop in Port Townsend,<br />

Washington, taking introductory courses in Space Harmony, Effort and<br />

Bartenieff Funda<strong>mental</strong>s with CMA Gregg Lizenberry. I immediately found<br />

a place for the ideas in my teaching, especially ballet. While teaching at The<br />

Ohio State University, I organized a Certification Program in Laban Movement<br />

Analysis (LMA) through the Laban/Bartenieff Institute of Movement Studies<br />

(LIMS). I completed the course in 1994, studying with Ed Groff, Peter<br />

Madden, Elizabeth Kagan and <strong>Ele</strong>anor Weisman. I have taught summer introductory<br />

workshops to students with backgrounds in dance, theatre, and music.<br />

For several years, I assisted in Vera Maletic’s courses, and I continue to enjoy<br />

learning and exchanging ideas with Professor Maletic. Currently, I teach Dance<br />

Dynamics (Effort) and Foundations of Labananalysis (LMA). I have also written<br />

through the lens of the Laban framework in articles that bring recent dance<br />

writing into dialogue with issues about dance training.<br />

The theoretical nature of Laban’s Effort study allows for great variety and<br />

imagination in terms of application. It also necessitates continual and fluid<br />

referencing to human experience in order for it to be understood in context.<br />

Sometimes the reference or illustration can be more general, or abstract; other<br />

times, more concrete or specific. For example, introducing the Phrasing Types<br />

(macro-structure) before delineating the individual Effort <strong>Ele</strong>ments (micro-<br />

structure) is effective for dancers who will recognize and easily physicalize pat-<br />

terns like swingy or resilient movement. Later, more discrete units of movement<br />

or individual qualities can be extracted from the larger, more general patterns<br />

of the Phrasing Types. It is also effective to establish links to other content areas<br />

(in dance, for our purposes). A student might create a sequence out of one or<br />

two Phrasing Types that could be used in teaching beginning dancers, or look<br />

at a sequence from a recent technique class in terms of those same patterns.<br />

A composition course developed by Vickie Blaine (at the OSU Department<br />

of Dance) asks the mover to examine and isolate his/her relationship to body<br />

weight and gravity, and is a pre-requisite to Dance Dynamics. Because the<br />

studies for the course center around three themes—Resiliency (Weight sensing,<br />

Resilient Phrasing), strength (strong Weight, and individual variations in Time,<br />

Space and Flow), and lightness (light Weight and Time, Space, Flow variations,<br />

often the “indulging” Efforts in contrast to strength)—students come to Dance<br />

Dynamics with physical knowledge related to the Weight Factor. A next step<br />

can be the development of descriptive language pertaining to experiences and<br />

observations from the composition class. Descriptive phrases, movement illustrations<br />

and characterizations can also be ways of evoking or eliciting Effort or<br />

APPENDIX I / 109


dynamic patterns that are less familiar, or outside a dancer’s habitual qualitative<br />

range. Words or phrases can be useful and provocative for the performer who<br />

wants to expand his/her movement palette, and also for the budding writer,<br />

critic, coach or director.<br />

As outlined above under The Demands of Teaching/Learning Dance Dynamics,<br />

the student learns through several modes, including observation, analysis, selfreflection,<br />

improvisation, visualization. In making the connections between a<br />

movement experience or an inner state and the various dynamic configurations<br />

as espoused in the theory, individuals will choose whatever mode that works<br />

best for them at the time. Exercises and assignments can be designed so that<br />

students expand both the modes they use and the connections they make. Two<br />

examples of class assignments follow.<br />

Example 1<br />

At the beginning of the quarter, we filled in the answers for strong and light<br />

Weight as a group, drawing from experiences in the composition class dealing<br />

with Weight mentioned above. As we learned about the other Motion Factors,<br />

we continued adding to the chart, reflecting on the studies from class. The chart<br />

could then be helpful for accessing a particular quality through its relationship<br />

to body use or spatial content.<br />

EFFORT QUALITY<br />

BODY SPACE<br />

Strong (WEIGHT) Wide stance Low level<br />

Direct ( SPACE) Simultaneous sequencing Linear, spoking<br />

Bound (FLOW) From periphery to center Confined, small<br />

kinesphere<br />

Sudden (TIME) Simultaneous sequencing Inward/backward<br />

Confined gesture<br />

Light ( WEIGHT) Peripheral body parts Upward<br />

Indirect/Flexible (SPACE) Successive movement Spirals, twists<br />

Free (FLOW) From center outwards Expansive<br />

Sustained (TIME) Successive sequencing Forward direction<br />

Horizontal<br />

This chart shows how a particular Effort quality has a tendency to associate<br />

with certain bodily and spatial configurations.<br />

110 / DANCE DYNAMICS


Example 2<br />

The following words can be starting points for: developing group or individual<br />

movement sequences that illustrate the quality or inner state; finding which<br />

Effort <strong>Ele</strong>ments or qualities are most predominate and which are not active for<br />

each word; developing a character or situation based on the word and having<br />

the class guess the word.<br />

Calm<br />

Controlled<br />

Careful<br />

Agitated<br />

Hesitant<br />

Overbearing<br />

Sloppy<br />

Paranoid<br />

Resilient<br />

Perky<br />

Confident<br />

Stuttering<br />

ADD YOUR OWN<br />

The following illustrations also provide opportunites to extract the various<br />

Effort <strong>Ele</strong>ments and discuss which in the foreground. They may lend themselves<br />

to an examination of certain States (Near, Remote, Dream, etc.).<br />

Walking on eggshells; on hot coals<br />

Walking on a tightrope<br />

Brushing something off a child’s eyelash<br />

Big lazy fanning on a hot day<br />

Crossing a room after seeing someone you know<br />

Typing furiously<br />

Playing tug o’ war<br />

Tiptoeing into a class late<br />

APPENDIX I / 111


Example 2 (cont.)<br />

Below, the student provides the illustration. The movement issuing from the<br />

directions might be either mimetic as in the illustrations above, or more abstract<br />

as in dance movement.<br />

A strong/sudden action resolving into light/<br />

/sustained<br />

(Weight and Time)<br />

A direct/<br />

/bound action changing into indirect/<br />

/free<br />

(Space and Flow)<br />

A strong/<br />

/sustained action becoming light/<br />

/sudden<br />

(Weight and Time)<br />

A direct/<br />

/sudden action transforming into directness<br />

/sustainment<br />

(Space<br />

and Time)<br />

A bound/<br />

/light action becoming free<br />

/strong<br />

(Flow and Weight)<br />

112 / DANCE DYNAMICS


A P P E N D I X I I<br />

OPEN-ENDED CONSIDERATIONS OF C. G. JUNG’S INFLUENCES ON LABAN<br />

Psychologist Carl Gustav Jung started developing his theories during the first<br />

decades of the 20th century in the cultural milieu of his native Switzerland.<br />

Among his early publications is Wandlungen und Symbole der Libido (1912)<br />

that was translated into English in 1916 as Psychology of the unconscious:<br />

a study of the transformations and symbolisms of the libido. 1<br />

Besides some<br />

loose references to what would become Jung’s theory of introvert and extravert<br />

personalities, the book draws from mythology, religion, ethnology, art, and literature,<br />

and announces Jung’s break from Freudian psychoanalysis. Underlying<br />

the concept of personality types, Jung proposed four psychological functions<br />

by which consciousness obtains its orientation. As he writes in his Man and his<br />

Symbols, 1964: 61, “Sensation (i.e. sense-perception) tells you that something<br />

exists; thinking tells you what it is; feeling tells you whether it is agreeable or<br />

not; and intuition tells you whence it comes and where it is going.” 2<br />

In order to establish a meaningful correlation between some concepts developed<br />

respectively by C.G.Jung and by Laban, further research is required concerning<br />

Laban’s assimilations of some of Jung’s notions.<br />

During and after WW I, Laban resided in Switzerland, and was aware of some<br />

of Jung’s ideas. In Die Welt des Tanzers (The Dancer’s World, 1926), 3 he lists<br />

Jung’s Wandlungen und Symbole der Libido among the literature that could<br />

expand dancers’ insights. Apparently Laban did not take further interest in<br />

Jung’s work until the forties.<br />

About Laban’s contacts with a group of Jungian psychologists in England in<br />

the 40’s and 50’s, one can glean information from John Hodgson & Preston-<br />

Dunlop (1990), 4 Preston-Dunlop (1998), 5 and Hodgson (2001). 6 Laban was<br />

invited to establish movement therapy at the Withymead Centre, an establishment<br />

based on Jungian approaches to psychotherapy. Though Laban chiefly<br />

delegated this task to his assistants, exchanges with one of the founders of the<br />

Centre, Dr Champernowne, gave him the opportunity to get acquainted with<br />

Jung’s psychological types and the four main functions—thinking, feeling,<br />

sensation, and intuition. These contacts may explain the appearance of related<br />

terms in the 1960 edition of The Mastery of Movement. 7 On “Table VII: Survey<br />

APPENDIX II / 113


of the Type and Meaning of Motion Factors and their Combinations,” Laban<br />

presents for the first time the link between the Motion factors and what he calls<br />

“man’s powers”: the Motion Factor of Space affect man’s power of “Thinking,”<br />

of Weight—”Sensing,” of Time—”Intuiting,” and of Flow—”Feeling.” On the<br />

same table, there also is a link between “Inner Participation” with Attention<br />

and Space, Intention and Weight, Decision and Time, and Progression and<br />

Flow. While Laban elaborated on the association of Inner Participation with<br />

Motion factors, he did not explain the link between “man’s powers” and the<br />

four Motion factors. This hiatus is unfortunate since it obfuscates the origins of<br />

this significant concept in his thinking. One can speculate that the fact the four<br />

powers are put in quotation marks may be a tacit reference to Jung’s four function<br />

types. It is as though we are presented with the results of Laban’s thinking<br />

but not with the origin and process that led to them.<br />

Several documents, however, hint at permutations in his thinking that must<br />

have preceded associating the four functions with the four Motion factors. By<br />

permission of Warren Lamb, I have had the opportunity to inspect a letter and<br />

graph that Laban sent him in 1952. (At the time, Lamb was Laban’s assistant<br />

in his work in industry and started developing his own methods of movement<br />

assessment.) In Laban’s letter and graph, Inner Participation of attention,<br />

intention, decision, an precision are linked interchangeably with intuiting, feeling,<br />

thinking, and sensation. Further, Laban collaborated with Bill Carpenter<br />

(associated with the Withymead Centre) on an unfinished manuscript titled<br />

“Movement Psychology”; it was written between 1952 and ‘54. In Hodgson’s<br />

(2001) summary of its content, there is a reference to four <strong>mental</strong> factors of<br />

sensing, thinking, intuiting, and feeling and their associations with Weight,<br />

Space, Time, and Flow. Like in the 1960 edition of The Mastery of Movement,<br />

there is no mention of Jung.<br />

To gain a more complete picture of Laban’s process of assimilation and appropriation<br />

of Jung’s concepts further research is needed. Additional analysis of<br />

“Movement Psychology,” and an investigation of Warren Lamb’s archive appear<br />

as viable points of departure. The Laban-Carpenter manuscript is housed at the<br />

Laban Archives at University of Surrey’s National Resource Center for Dance<br />

(NRCD). Lamb’s archives are in the process of classification and will be available<br />

at NRCD at a later time.<br />

114 / DANCE DYNAMICS


Notes<br />

1. Carl Gustav Jung, Psychology of the Unconscious: a Study of the Transformation and<br />

Symbolisms of the Libido (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1991).<br />

2. _______________, Man and his Symbols (London: Aldus <strong>Book</strong>s Ltd., 1964).<br />

3. Rudolf Laban, Die Welt des Tanzers (Stuttgart: Walter Seifert Verlag, 1920).<br />

4. John Hodgson & Valerie Preston-Dunlop, Rudolf Laban: An Introduction to his Work<br />

and Influence (Plymouth: Northcote House Publishers, 1990).<br />

5. Valerie Preston-Dunlop, Rudolf Laban: An Extraordinary Life<br />

(London: Dance <strong>Book</strong>s,<br />

1998).<br />

6. John Hodgson, Mastering Movement: The Life and Work of Rudolf Laban (New York:<br />

Routledge, 2001).<br />

7. Rudolf Laban, The Mastery of Movement (London: Macdonald & Evans, 1960).<br />

APPENDIX II / 115


A P P E N D I X I I I<br />

PHRASING OF DANCE QUALITIES IN LABANOTATION SCORES<br />

Not unlike music scores, the general purpose of dance scores is the documentation<br />

of dance works within their artistic, cultural, and social context. The<br />

analysis of features, such as body movement in space and time, and the progression<br />

through the performance area, provides components for the synthesis in<br />

restaging various choreographies. In this process, the notator and/or the director<br />

attempt to capture the expression of embodiments, or the corporealization<br />

of choreographic images and ideas.<br />

Although the Labanotation system does not have many signs for dynamic qualities,<br />

the scores, however, contain information about dynamics and phrasing, in<br />

an implicit and explicit manner.<br />

Ways in which particular movement motifs and/or sequences are written can<br />

imply their performance qualities. For instance while jumping normally implies<br />

Resilient Phrasing, a slow balancing motif is likely to be performed with Even<br />

Phrasing maintaining the same quality. Furthermore, a tombé-like movement<br />

connotes increasing speed and energy, and a swing usually implies an<br />

Increasing-then-Decreasing Phrasing.<br />

A few explicit signs, such as accents and phrasing bows, have been used when<br />

particular qualities or phrasing in the score need to be enhanced. Effort signs<br />

are also used, though not in a consistent way.<br />

I have been interested for some time in elaborating on such explicit signs that<br />

can be used in annotating dance scores. (See annotated bibliography at the end<br />

of this Appendix.) As referred in the introduction to my Phrasing classification,<br />

discussions with colleagues Odette Blum and Lucy Venable about Phrasing<br />

annotations greatly contributed to my investigations in this area.<br />

This appendix contains excerpts from a paper I presented at the Conference of<br />

the International Council for Kinetography Laban (ICKL) in 1991. It is titled<br />

“Qualitative Annotations of Labanotation Scores,” and published in ICKL:<br />

Proceedings of the Seventeenth Biennial Conference. The intent of the paper<br />

was to examine the rationale for annotations of Labanotation scores using<br />

APPENDIX III / 117


Phrasing and Effort symbols, and to point out the need for an acquaintance<br />

with the Effort theory on the part of notators.<br />

The examples selected for this appendix illustrate two resources for qualitative<br />

annotations of scores. These include descriptions from the choreographer of the<br />

notated piece, and descriptions from a notator and performer with an in-depth<br />

knowledge of the work’s choreographic style.<br />

Samples representing descriptions from the choreographer are excerpts from<br />

Victoria Uris’ Breakers. The work was originally created in 1986, and restaged<br />

with the University Dance Company in the 1990/91 season. The excerpts are<br />

from two sections: the “Man’s Solo,” and “Harmonious Assault I—Sextet.”<br />

The piece was notated by Wendy Mang Ching Chu, MFA candidate at the OSU<br />

Department of Dance, in Winter and Spring 1991, under the supervision of<br />

Odette Blum. During the process of notating Breakers, Uris pointed out sections<br />

that required additional Phrasing and Effort annotations.<br />

Lucy Venable, who performed in José Limón’s There is a Time, subsequently<br />

notated the work. She was the resource for annotations of Phrasing and Effort<br />

presented here. She danced the woman’s part in “A Time to be Silent” which<br />

she learned from Lavinia Nielson who danced it in the first cast. Limón created<br />

the work in 1956, and Venable staged it with the University Dance Company<br />

in 1983. Having a thorough knowledge of the style of the piece, she considers<br />

Phrasing and Effort annotations of this score to be a historical resource for<br />

future directors.<br />

118 / DANCE DYNAMICS


The first example shows a Phrasing annotation coupled with ONE SINGLE<br />

EFFORT ELEMENT. Since one Effort quality seldom appears in isolation, such<br />

annotations are appropriate only at times when the Labanotation provides the<br />

context.<br />

In measure 28 from Limón’s “A Time to be Silent” the dancer flicks her leg<br />

with a sense of urgency, and touches the floor with precision. While “urgency”<br />

is conveyed with the sudden quality of Time, the associated quality of Space—<br />

flexibility or indirectness can be seen from the rotation of hip and pelvis. The<br />

suddenness including the innate quality of indirectness create a short Impulsive<br />

Phrasing. The direct quality of Space that denotes “precision” is associated with<br />

a slight deceleration resulting in the touch—thus an Impactive Phrasing.<br />

APPENDIX III / 119


Annotations consisting of qualities that result from COMBINATIONS OF TWO<br />

MOTION FACTORS and their respective Effort elements describe the inner<br />

attitudes motivating the dance sequence. (Each of the six inner attitudes have<br />

four combinations that amount to twenty-four qualities with distinct characteristics.)<br />

In the first measure of Limón’s “A Time to be Silent” stillness is maintained<br />

with a direct and bound quality that is one of the six combinations of Space<br />

and Flow. While the Space/Flow combinations tend to create a remote, abstract<br />

mood, the particular direct/bound quality shows a restricted honing in. The<br />

phrasing sign indicates that this quality does not change throughout the duration<br />

of the stillness.<br />

120 / DANCE DYNAMICS


In the second measure of “A Time to be Silent” the direct/bound quality changes<br />

into sustained/bound—both combinations of Time and Flow.<br />

Since Time/Flow<br />

combinations are generally characterized by a more adaptable attitude, the sustained/bound<br />

is maintained while turning and gesturing that one can interpret<br />

as remaining in control.<br />

APPENDIX III / 121


Another example of annotations with a COMBINATION OF TWO MOTION<br />

FACTORS can be found in the score of Victoria Uris’ Breakers, in measures<br />

7–10 from “Harmonious Assault I—Sextet.” The strong/sudden quality is a<br />

combination of Weight and Time characterized as rhythmical involvement<br />

with activities. Placed within the Increasing-then-Decreasing Phrasing sign<br />

this quality becomes stronger and faster and gradually fades out. The dancers’<br />

preparation for a hop emphasized by sweeping arm gestures is described by the<br />

choreographer as “seagulls diving into water.”<br />

122 / DANCE DYNAMICS


Annotations consisting of qualities that result from COMBINATIONS OF<br />

THREE MOTION FACTORS and their respective Effort <strong>Ele</strong>ments, describe<br />

externalized drives which motivate parts or sections of a dance. (Each of the<br />

four drives has eight combinations, and their qualities amount to thirty-two<br />

combinations that have particular characteristics.)<br />

In measure eight of Uris’ “Man’s Solo” the dancer advances over three beats<br />

while building up to an impact in the first half of the fourth beat. The direct/<br />

strong/sudden quality of the Impact is one of the combinations of the Action<br />

drive or eight Basic Effort Actions, referred to as punch-like.<br />

The Impactive Phrasing from the “Harmonious Assault I—Sextet” section is<br />

created by the recurring motif of a sisonne enhanced by a torso and tossing<br />

arm gesture. The quality of the Impact that is strong/sudden/free belongs to<br />

one of the eight combinations of the “spaceless” Passion drive. In contrast to<br />

the action-like punch, this combination in which the Flow factor (which Laban<br />

associates with Feeling) replaces the Space factor (that Laban associates with<br />

Thinking), expresses an emotional outburst.<br />

APPENDIX III / 123


The final example shows several Phrasing and Effort annotations that occur<br />

SIMULTANEOUSLY or CONCURRENTLY. In measure 56 from Limón’s “A<br />

Time to be Silent” the light/sudden Vibratory Phrasing maintained in the legs<br />

is juxtaposed to two short Impulses of the head and arms performed with a<br />

direct/sudden quality, terminating with a light/sudden Impulse.<br />

5<br />

A<br />

'<br />

-- (<br />

5<br />

4<br />

- T $<br />

- $ B B T -<br />

K J<br />

( & 5 " - " 4 . ' `4<br />

'<br />

(<br />

[ .<br />

4<br />

.<br />

\<br />

K<br />

K<br />

56<br />

W<br />

-<br />

&<br />

# #<br />

.<br />

Z -<br />

è `<br />

Z<br />

A<br />

-<br />

5<br />

- - [<br />

i<br />

j<br />

•i T è T<br />

=<br />

i<br />

K<br />

Conclusion<br />

The purpose of the qualitative annotations of a work by José Limón and Victoria<br />

Uris is to show the inner motivation for particular movement sequences. The<br />

annotations were based on discussion about motivating imagery and qualities<br />

with choreographer Uris, and on insights into Limón’s motivation behind the<br />

movement vocabulary from performers Nielson and Venable.<br />

124 / DANCE DYNAMICS


Annotated Bibliography of V. Maletic’s articles on Dynamics and Phrasing<br />

“Dynamics of Phrasing in Movement and Dance” (International Council of<br />

Kinetography Laban [ICKL]: Proceedings of the Thirteenth Biennial Conference,<br />

1983) 110–126. The paper contains the nucleus of my classification and notation<br />

of phrasing, developed further in Workbook for Dance Dynamics: Effort<br />

and Phrasing (1999). In addition to an excerpt from José Limón’s<br />

There is a<br />

Time (with Lucy Venable), an excerpt from Anna Sokolow’s Odes is annotated<br />

from coaching points given by the choreographer to dancers from The Ohio<br />

State University Department of Dance.<br />

“Dynamics of Dance” (ICKL: Proceedings of the Fifteenth Biennial Conference,<br />

1987) 82–101. The paper gives a historical account of the status of dynamics<br />

in Kinetography/Labanotation and presents a revised classification of phrasing.<br />

Of particular interest is a report on initial stages of a joint research project with<br />

notator Ray Cook, assisted by Lucy Venable and graduate associate Amanda<br />

Tom (89–90; 101–102). Questions, such as how do various ways of notation<br />

enhance the desired quality of the dance, and how do we interpret various<br />

dynamic symbols used in the score have been examined in segments from<br />

Sokolow’s Moods.<br />

“Issues in Phrasing and Effort Annotations of a Humphrey Score” (ICKL:<br />

Proceedings of the Sixteenth Biennial Conference, 1989) 105–126. Several versions<br />

of the performance of Doris Humphrey’s Invention are analyzed from the<br />

point of view of characteristics of Humphrey’s dance vocabulary, her concepts<br />

of “breath rhythm” and “fall and recovery,” and the dynamics captured in the<br />

Labanotation score. Additional phrasing and Effort annotations are proposed<br />

as a resource for directors and performers that are historically removed from<br />

Humphrey’s style.<br />

“Qualitative Annotations of Labanotation Scores” (ICKL: Proceedings of<br />

the Seventeenth Biennial Conference, 1991) 73–103. In addition to excerpts<br />

included in the Appendix III, the paper includes four examples of folk dances<br />

from Croatia, annotated by V. Maletic (91, 92, 97, 101).<br />

“Qualitative Annotations of Labanotation Scores revisited” (ICKL: Proceedings<br />

of the Twenty-Second Biennial Conference, 2000) 87–100. The paper includes<br />

new examples of excerpts from dance scores, such as Lester Horton’s The<br />

Beloved, and Don Redlich’s Passin’ Through, and Croatian folk dances annotated<br />

by V. Maletic.<br />

APPENDIX III / 125


B I B L I O G R A P H Y<br />

Bartenieff, Irmgard with Dori Lewis. Body Movement: Coping with the<br />

Enviroment. New York: Gordon & Breach, 1980.<br />

Bodmer, Sylvia. Studies Based on Crystalloid Dance Forms. London: Laban<br />

Centre for Movement and Dance, 1979.<br />

Cooper Albright, Ann. “Auto-Body Stories: Blondell Cummings and Auto bio-<br />

graphy in Dance.” Meaning in Motion. J. Desmond ed. Durham,<br />

NC: Duke University Press, 1977.<br />

Cohen, Selma Jeanne. “Dance as an Art of Imitation.” What is Dance?<br />

Copeland, Robert & Cohen, Marshall., eds. New York: Oxford<br />

University Press, 1983.<br />

Davis, Martha. Towards Understanding the Intrinsic in Body Movement. New<br />

York: Arno Press, 1975.<br />

Dell, Cecily. A Primer for Movement Description New York. Dance Notation<br />

Bureau, 1970.<br />

Dixon Gottschild, Brenda. Digging the Africanist Presence in American<br />

Performance Dance and Other Contexts. Westport, CN.: Greenwood<br />

Press, 1996.<br />

Duncan, Isadora. My Life. New York: Garden City Publishing Co., 1927.<br />

Gellerman, Jill. “Mayim Patterns the Three Hassidic Communities.” Essays in<br />

Dance Research. Dance Research Annual IX., CORD 1978 120.<br />

Hawkins, Alma. Creating Through Dance. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall,<br />

1964.<br />

Hayes, Elizabeth R. Dance Composition and Production. New York: The<br />

Ronald Press Co., 1955.<br />

BIBLIOGRAPHY / 127


H’Doubler, Margaret. Dance: A Creative Art Experience. Madison, WI.:<br />

University of Wisconsin Press, 1966.<br />

Hodgson, John. Mastering Movement: The Life and Work of Rudolf Laban.<br />

New York: Routledge, 2001.<br />

Hodgson, John & Valerie Preston-Dunlop. Rudolf Laban: An Introduction to<br />

his Work and Influence. Plymouth: Northcote House Publishers, 1990.<br />

Humphrey, Doris. The Art of Making Dances. New York: Grove Press, 1959.<br />

Jung, Carl Gustav. Man and his Symbols. London: Aldus <strong>Book</strong>s Ltd., 1964.<br />

_______________. Psychology of the Unconscious: a Study of the Transformations<br />

and Symbolisms of the Libido. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University<br />

Press, 1991.<br />

Kestenberg, Judith. The Role of Movement Patterns in Development. New<br />

York: The Dance Notation Bureau, 1967.<br />

Laban, Rudolf. Die Welt des Tanzers. Sttutgart: Walter Seifert Varlag, 1920.<br />

____________. Modern Educational Dance. London: Macdonald & Evans,<br />

1948.<br />

____________. “Rudiments of a Free Dance Technique.” Modern Educational<br />

Dance, third ed., 1975.<br />

____________. The Mastery of Movement on the Stage. London: Macdonald<br />

& Evans, 1950.<br />

____________.<br />

Principles of Dance and Movement Notation. London:<br />

Macdonald & Evans, 1956.<br />

____________. Choreutics. London: Macdonald & Evans, 1966.<br />

____________. The Mastery of Movement. London: Macdonald & Evans,<br />

1980.<br />

Laban, Rudolf & Lawrence, F. C. Effort. London: Macdonald & Evans,<br />

1947.<br />

Lamb, Warren. Posture and Gesture. London: Duckworth, 1965.<br />

128 / DANCE DYNAMICS


Langer, Susanne K. Problems of Art. New York: Scribner’s, 1957.<br />

Maletic, Ana. Knjiga o Plesu. Zagreb: Kulturno-prosvjetni sabor Hrvatske,<br />

1986.<br />

Maletic, Vera. Body-Space-Expression: The Development of Rudolf Laban’s<br />

Movement and Dance Concepts. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter, 1987.<br />

Maletic, Vera. “Dynamics of Dance.” International Council of Kinetography<br />

Laban: Proceedings of the Fifteenth Biennial Conference. 1989.<br />

____________. “Issues in Phrasing and Effort Annotations of Humphrey<br />

Score.” ICKL: Proceedings of the Sixteenth Biennial Conference.<br />

1989.<br />

____________. “Qualitative Annotations of Labanotation Scores.” ICKL:<br />

Proceedings of the Seventeenth Biennial Conference. 1991.<br />

____________. “Qualitative Annotations of Labanotation Scores revisited.”<br />

International Council of Kinetography Laban: Proceedings of the<br />

Twenty-Second Biennial Conference, 2000.<br />

Moore, Carol-Lynne and Kaoru Yamamoto. Beyond Words: Movement<br />

Observation and Analysis. New York: Gordon and Breach, 1988.<br />

Murgiyanto, Sal. “Seeing and Writing about World Dance: An Insider’s View.”<br />

Dance Critic’s Association News, Summer 1990.<br />

Myers, Gerald. “Do You See What the Critic Sees?” Philosophical Essays on<br />

Dance. New York: Dance Horizons, 1981.<br />

Ness, Sally Ann. Body, Movement and Culture: Kinesthetic and Visual<br />

Symbolism in a Phillipine Community. Philadelphia: University of<br />

Pennsylvania Press, 1992.<br />

North, Marion. Personality Assessment Through Movement. London:<br />

Macdonald & Evans, 1972.<br />

North, Marion. “The Language of Bodily Gesture.” Main Currents of Modern<br />

Thought, Vol. 31, no.1, September-October 1974.<br />

Novack, Cynthia. Sharing the Dance: Contact Improvisation and American<br />

Culture. Madison, WI.: University of Madison Press, 1990.<br />

BIBLIOGRAPHY / 129


Noverre, Jean-Georges. Letters on Dancing and Ballets. Transl., C. W.<br />

Beaumont. London: Beaumont, 1951, first published 1930.<br />

Peterson Royce, Anya. The Anthropology of Dance. Bloomington: Indiana<br />

University Press, 1977.<br />

Preston, Valerie. A Handbook for Modern Educational Dance. London:<br />

Macdonald & Evans, 1963.<br />

Preston-Dunlop, Valerie. A Handbook for Dance in Education. London:<br />

Macdonald & Evans, 1980.<br />

_____________________. compiler, Dance Words. Choreography and Dance<br />

Studies Vol. 8, 1995.<br />

_____________________. Rudolf Laban: An Extraordinary Life. London:<br />

Dance <strong>Book</strong>s, 1998.<br />

Rainer, Yvonne. “The Mind is a Muscle.” Work: 1961–73. New York University,<br />

1974.<br />

Satin, Leslie. “Movement and the Body in Maya Deren’s Meshes of the<br />

Afternoon.” Women & Performance: A Journal of Feminist Theory,<br />

Vol. 6, no.2, 1993.<br />

Shawn, Ted. Every Little Movement. Pittsfield, MA: Eagle Printing and Binding<br />

Co., 1927.<br />

Siegel, Marcia B. The Tail of the Dragon New Dance, 1976–1982. Durham,<br />

NC: Duke University Press, 1991.<br />

Smith, Jacqueline. Dance Composition—A Practical Guide for Teachers.<br />

London: Lepus <strong>Book</strong>s, 1976.<br />

Stebbins, Genevieve. Delsarte System of Expression. New York: Dance<br />

Horizons, 1977, originally published in 1902.<br />

Taylor, Paul. “Down with Choreography.” The Modern Dance: Seven Statements<br />

of Belief.<br />

S.J. Cohen ed.,1966.<br />

Yoo, Si-Hyun. Young-Sook Han’s Salpury Chum: Labanotation and Stylistic<br />

Analysis of a Traditional Korean Dance. Master’s thesis, The Ohio State<br />

University, 1995.<br />

130 / DANCE DYNAMICS


Dance reviews<br />

Anderson, Jack. “Rod Rodgers Remembered: Lyric and Vivid Choreography.”<br />

The New York Times, 26 Nov. 2003.<br />

_____________.”Feet with a Lot to Say and Ways to Say It.” The New York<br />

Times, Dec. 18, 2003. B3.<br />

Dunning, Jennifer. “A Dancer Shows How Rhythm can Set the Fire to a<br />

Flirtation.” The New York Times, 28 Nov. 2003. B3.<br />

_______________. “Images of Light and Dark Connect East to West.” The<br />

New York Times, 18 Oct. 2003. A24.<br />

Jowitt, Deborah. “How Many Ways To Twist It?” Review of Ballet Frankfurt’s<br />

“The Room as it Was.” The Village Voice, October 8–14, 2003.<br />

Kiselgoff, Anna. “The Syncretism of TaiChi and Bach.” The New York Times,<br />

20 Nov. 2003. B1.<br />

BIBLIOGRAPHY / 131


D V D V I E W I N G G U I D E<br />

The companion DVD provides opportunity for observing short movement and<br />

dance sequences that can be viewed repeatedly without changes in performance,<br />

unlike live performance that may change from time to time. Making distinctions<br />

between various components of dance dynamics, such as Phrasing types and<br />

Effort qualities can facilitate a conscious awareness of these strands of movement.<br />

It is as though the elusive medium of dance can be temporarily captured<br />

by means of classification and terminology. Such identification, in turn, leads<br />

to a descriptive language.<br />

The video excerpts on the DVD emphasize the visual modality and enlist kinesthetic<br />

feedback. Music accompaniment is deliberately left out as it may bring<br />

up unnecessary issues, such as contrapuntal or complementary dynamics, and<br />

interfere with the focus on movement itself.<br />

The DVD examples have been donated courtesy of choreographers and performers<br />

that are acknowledged after each excerpt.<br />

Some suggestions for viewing<br />

In addition to the sequencing and the voice-over provided by the DVD you<br />

also may explore the following approaches:<br />

View examples while turning off the voice-over to find out what you actually<br />

saw.<br />

Before trying to identify various movement dynamics and qualities just<br />

imitate or mimic what you saw.<br />

Jot down a few descriptive adjectives about the feel of the sequence without<br />

using any technical terms.<br />

Stop the DVD to repeat viewing an excerpt that appears complex to you.<br />

Reviewing related aspects of dynamics and movement qualities in the<br />

Workbook, may also be helpful.<br />

The DVD Chapter Menu gives an overview and the opportunity for additional<br />

viewing of any aspect of dance dynamics that you choose.<br />

NOTE: While the voice-over descriptions are reproduced in this guide, a more<br />

extensive analysis is added to some video excerpts.<br />

DVD VIEWING GUIDE / 1


D V D C H A P T E R M E N U<br />

The DVD provides you with the choice of playing the chapters and sub-chapters<br />

in the order they have been recorded or of selecting sections of your own<br />

choice.<br />

( 1 ) P E R C E P T I O N O F D A N C E D Y N A M I C S I N G E N E R A L T E R M S<br />

Variety<br />

Repetition<br />

Contrast<br />

( 2 ) D Y N A M I C S O F P H R A S I N G<br />

PHRASING TYPES<br />

Even<br />

Increasing<br />

Impactive<br />

Decreasing<br />

Impulsive<br />

Increase–Decrease<br />

Decrease–Increase<br />

Accented<br />

Vibratory<br />

Resilient<br />

Elastic<br />

Buoyant<br />

Weighty<br />

SEQUENCING OF PHRASING<br />

Consecutive<br />

Concurrent<br />

Overlapping<br />

PHRASING ANALYSIS OF TWO EXAMPLES<br />

Contrast<br />

Variety<br />

2 / DANCE DYNAMICS


( 3 ) E F F O R T Q U A L I T I E S<br />

ONE MOTION FACTOR<br />

Direct and Indirect Space<br />

Strong Weight<br />

Light Weight<br />

Sudden Time<br />

Bound Flow<br />

Free Flow<br />

TWO MOTION FACTORS—STATES<br />

Weight/Flow–Dreamlike & Space/Time–Awake<br />

Space/Flow–Remote & Weight/Time–Near<br />

Space/Weight–Stable & Time/Flow–Mobile<br />

THREE MOTION FACTORS—DRIVES<br />

Space/Weight/Time–Action Drive<br />

Flow/Weight/Time–Passion<br />

Space/Flow/Time–Vision<br />

Space/Weight/Flow–Spell<br />

SYNTHESIS: EFFORT and PHRASING ANALYSIS OF TWO EXAMPLES<br />

Contrast<br />

Variety<br />

DVD VIEWING GUIDE / 3


ACCOMPANYING TEXT and listing of video sources<br />

( 1 ) P E R C E P T I O N O F D A N C E D Y N A M I C S I N G E N E R A L T E R M S<br />

The following video excerpts show some easily observable features.<br />

Variety of dynamics<br />

Variety is one of the general features of dance dynamics that can be seen at<br />

first glance. Three performers interact with percussive, more languid, and some<br />

changing movement qualities.<br />

FROM: Six Tangos (2004)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER: Melanie Bales<br />

PERFORMERS: Robin Anderson, Ama Codjoe, Christina Providence<br />

Videotaped by Emily Lawrence<br />

Repetition<br />

Repetition of the same movement quality is another feature that can be noticed<br />

with ease. While the first example showed a repetitive elastic walk, the second<br />

presented a repetition of jerky movements performed with different arm and<br />

body gestures.<br />

FROM: Composition study (2004)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER / PERFORMER: Michael Estanich<br />

Videotaped by Emily Lawrence<br />

FROM: Tracking (2004)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER: Kristin Hapke<br />

PERFORMER: Michelle Stortz<br />

Videotaped by Emily Lawrence<br />

Contrasting dynamics<br />

Contrasting qualities enhance each other. The smooth interaction between the<br />

two dancers contrasts with their more agitated outbursts. The two qualities<br />

clearly stand out from one another.<br />

FROM: African Funeral Song (2004)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER: Susan Hadley<br />

PERFORMERS: Lauren Bisio, Keren Ganin-Pinto<br />

Videotaped by Victoria Uris<br />

4 / DANCE DYNAMICS


( 2 ) D Y N A M I C S O F P H R A S I N G<br />

The following set of excerpts will be observed from the point of view of<br />

Phrasing of movement energy.<br />

PHRASING TYPES<br />

[Also refer to Workbook pp. 59–60.]<br />

The author has classified Phrasing into eight main types.<br />

Even<br />

In this Phrasing type the movement energy does not change.<br />

(1) The right arm and subsequently the head of the performer move with an<br />

unchanging, Even intensity from the beginning till the end.<br />

FROM: Figuring (2004)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER / PERFORMER: Chad Hall<br />

Videotaped by Emily Lawrence<br />

(2) In the next excerpt three Even Phrasings follow one another in the performance<br />

of the two dancers.<br />

FROM: African Funeral Song (2004)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER: Susan Hadley<br />

Increasing<br />

The performance energy increases in its intensity.<br />

(1) During the turning sequence the momentum and the speed of the movement<br />

gradually increases until abruptly stopped.<br />

(2) In the second short sequence the momentum of the performer's movement<br />

becomes increasingly controlled as though approaching something<br />

dangerous.<br />

FROM: Tornado (1993)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER / PERFORMER: Jeanine Thompson<br />

Videotaped by Rosalind Pierson<br />

Impactive<br />

An Impact occurs when the Increase builds to a climax.<br />

(1) Two leg kicks and the performer's final lunge create three Impacts.<br />

FROM: Composition study (2004)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER / PERFORMER: Scott Lowe<br />

Videotaped by Emily Lawrence<br />

DVD VIEWING GUIDE / 5


(2) In the second example two motifs with a series of Impacts are performed<br />

with arm, torso and leg gestures, as well as a lunge. The somewhat agitated<br />

mood eases with a slide, which is Increasing in released fluency.<br />

FROM: Garras dos Sentidos (1999)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER / PERFORMER: Balinda Craig-Quijada<br />

Decreasing<br />

Energy can decrease from a greater to a lesser intensity.<br />

(1) The dancer's turning gradually decelerates creating a Decreasing phrasing.<br />

FROM: Lachrymae (1997)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER / VIDEOGRAPHER: Rosalind Pierson<br />

PERFORMER: Susan Sanborn<br />

(2) In the second example the tense, taut pull between the two dancers<br />

gradually Decreases.<br />

FROM: Directed improvisation (2004)<br />

PERFORMERS: Kristina Isabelle, Christina Providence<br />

Videotaped by Shawn Hove<br />

Impulsive<br />

The Decrease can follow an initial outburst.<br />

(1) Most movement actions in this sequence are initiated with a light<br />

Impulse after which the energy gradually diminishes.<br />

FROM: Figuring (2004)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER / PERFORMER: Chad Hall<br />

(2) In the second example a series of strong Impulses conveys an unsettling,<br />

agitated mood.<br />

FROM: Directed improvisation (2004)<br />

PERFORMER: Kristina Isabelle<br />

Videotaped by Shawn Hove<br />

6 / DANCE DYNAMICS


Increase–Decrease<br />

This Phrasing can occur in a variety of movement qualities and body actions.<br />

(1) In this sequence all the arm swings are performed with Increase–Decrease in<br />

speed and weightiness. Leaps and turning jumps also are performed with<br />

Increase–Decrease in speed and lightness.<br />

FROM: Chairs (2004)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER: Zvi Gotheiner<br />

PERFORMER: Scott Lowe<br />

Videotaped by Emily Lawrence<br />

(2) The second example includes a sequence of exercise-like lateral swings that<br />

precede a dance excerpt. In it a series of fast paced Increase–Decrease<br />

swings is performed with arms and torso gestures and a roll.<br />

FROM: Boxed In (2003)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER / PERFORMER: Kristina Isabelle<br />

Videotaped by Shawn Hove<br />

Decrease–Increase<br />

Decreasing-then-Increasing Phrasing can occur gradually or more abruptly with<br />

an Decreasing Impulse and Increasing Impact.<br />

(1) In this sequence the dancer gradually releases from an arching tension<br />

and returns to it.<br />

FROM: Variation based on material from Boxed In (2003)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER / PERFORMER: Kristina Isabelle<br />

Videotaped by Shawn Hove<br />

(2) In the second example the Impulse in the torso can be seen as a preparation<br />

for an Increasing side fall that is repeated several times.<br />

FROM: Directed improvisation (2004)<br />

PERFORMER: Kristina Isabelle<br />

Videotaped by Shawn Hove<br />

(3) The third excerpt shows both dancers performing two Decrease–<br />

Increase Phrasings as an Impulse into an Impact.<br />

FROM: African Funeral Song (2004)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER: Susan Hadley<br />

DVD VIEWING GUIDE / 7


Accented<br />

A sudden exertion of energy that can be repeated and/or followed by stillness is<br />

referred to as Accented Phrasing.<br />

(1) In the first sequence intermittent sudden stomps form several rhythmic<br />

entities of Accented Phrasing.<br />

FROM: Improvisation on the image of a toreador teasing an imaginary bull (2004)<br />

PERFORMER: Scott Lowe<br />

Videotaped by Emily Lawrence<br />

(2) In the next excerpts several jerky Accents are performed with the right<br />

arm and head; the subsequent Even sinking is punctuated with one more<br />

gentle accent.<br />

FROM: Kristen Come Home (1997)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER / PERFORMER: Susan Sanborn<br />

Videotaped by Rosalind Pierson<br />

Vibratory<br />

An uninterrupted series of sudden repetitions creates Vibratory Phrasing.<br />

(1) In the first example fast, repetitive hand movements shaking an imaginary<br />

red cloth in front of a bull, create a series of Vibratory movements.<br />

FROM: Improvisation on the image of a toreador teasing an imaginary bull (2004)<br />

PERFORMER: Scott Lowe<br />

(2) The second example shows that Vibratory Phrasing also can be performed<br />

by the entire body.<br />

FROM: R.E.M. (2004)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER: Joe Alter<br />

PERFORMER: Luke Gutgsell<br />

Videotaped by Emily Lawrence<br />

8 / DANCE DYNAMICS


RESILIENT<br />

[Also refer to Workbook pp. 73–76; 92–94.]<br />

Repetitive, rebounding qualities make up Resilient Phrasing. It can have three<br />

emphases.<br />

Elastic<br />

In this Resiliency there is an equal emphasis on strength and lightness—a kind<br />

of oscillation between these qualities.<br />

(1) Several rebounding or bouncy steps create Elastic Resiliency conveying<br />

a happy-go-lucky mood.<br />

FROM: Composition study (2004)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER / PERFORMER: Michael Estanich<br />

Videotaped by Emily Lawrence<br />

(2) In the second example Elastic, springy Resiliency can be seen in the<br />

performer's rebounding jumps.<br />

FROM: Is a Woman (1987)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER / PERFORMER: Susan Van Pelt<br />

Buoyant<br />

The emphasis in this Resiliency is on lightness.<br />

(1) In the first excerpts performer's hops and leaps have an airborne Buoyant<br />

resiliency.<br />

FROM: Composition study (2004)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER / PERFORMER: Robin Anderson<br />

Videotaped by Emily Lawrence<br />

(2) In the second example the juggler's manipulations also have a Buoyant<br />

resiliency.<br />

FROM: Improvisation (2004)<br />

PERFORMER: Jason Hedden<br />

DVD VIEWING GUIDE / 9


Weighty<br />

The emphasis in this Resiliency is on heaviness or weightiness.<br />

(1) The first hip-hop sequence starts with Weighty Resiliency and then<br />

becomes more bouncy, elastic.<br />

FROM: Improvisation in the style of hip-hop dancing (2004)<br />

PERFORMER: Marc Woten<br />

Videotaped by Emily Lawrence<br />

(2) The performer appears bogged down with Weighty resiliency.<br />

PERFORMER: Michael Estanich<br />

Videotaped by Emily Lawrence<br />

SEQUENCING OF PHRASING<br />

[Also refer to Workbook pp. 96–98.]<br />

Phrasing of movement actions can be performed in three different ways.<br />

Consecutive<br />

In most of the sequences observed the Phrasing was performed one after the<br />

other, i.e. Consecutively with various body parts or the entire body. The types<br />

of Phrasing can be the same or different.<br />

(1) In the first excerpt two Increasing drops of the right arm and head are<br />

followed by a Weighty Resilient lowering and rising of the entire body<br />

and continuing with a brief Decrease–Increase, ending with an Impactive<br />

squat.<br />

FROM: The Touch (1995)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER: Irene Hultman<br />

PERFORMER: Melanie Bales<br />

(2) The second sequence starts with Even movements of the legs rising that<br />

follow each other; a slight Accent precedes an Increasing drop which<br />

reverberates with some elastic Resiliency; a slight Impulse leads into the<br />

Even lowering of one leg.<br />

FROM: Kristen Come Home (1997)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER / PERFORMER: Susan Sanborn.<br />

Videotaped by Rosalind Pierson<br />

10 / DANCE DYNAMICS


Concurrent Phrasing<br />

Different parts of the body can perform different phrasing types at the same<br />

time, i.e. Concurrently:<br />

(1) The first excerpt shows fast turning steps that produce Vibratory<br />

phrasing, while at the same time the right arm raises and lowers with<br />

Impulsive phrasing; the sequence ends with an Increase–Decrease fall of<br />

the whole body.<br />

FROM: Wild Mushrooms in North America (1989)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER / PERFORMER: Karen Eliot<br />

(2) After three Consecutive moves the performer's head leans backwards<br />

Evenly while Concurrently the foot repeats several short Increase–<br />

Decrease rotations and the leg lowers Evenly; finally the entire body<br />

collapses with an Increase.<br />

FROM: Tick (2002)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER / PERFORMER: Susan Sanborn<br />

Videotaped by Rosalind Pierson<br />

Overlapping Phrasing<br />

When actions of various body parts begin before the Phrasing of the previous<br />

action has finished, Overlapping Phrasing occurs.<br />

Here is an example of Overlapping Phrasing that also includes Consecutive and<br />

Concurrent Phrasing:<br />

(1) After a fast Increase–Decrease torso movement, two Even arm gestures<br />

Overlap with the torso recovery. Even Bending and stretching of<br />

the foot initiates Overlapping eye, head, arm and finger movements.<br />

All Overlapping movements are Even except for Vibratory fingers, and<br />

a slight Impact of the hand. Consecutive leg rotations continue with<br />

Vibratory movement of both legs that is Concurrent with Increasing–<br />

Decreasing arm gestures that end with an Impact of the entire body.<br />

FROM: Girl Blue (2004)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER / CAMERAPERSON: Noel Reiss<br />

PERFORMER: Balinda Craig-Quijada<br />

DVD VIEWING GUIDE / 11


PHRASING ANALYSIS OF TWO EXAMPLES<br />

After having considered Phrasing types and their sequencing separately, we will<br />

observe aspects of Phrasing in two longer excerpts that have been seen before.<br />

Contrasting Dynamics<br />

Contrasting Phrasing types alternate in this sequence.<br />

(1) The unfolding of the first gestures and the subsequent lowering and rising<br />

of both dancers is performed with Even Phrasing. This is punctuated<br />

with the dancer in the background performing an Increase–Decrease<br />

scooping turn, while the dancer in the foreground Increases downwards.<br />

Their respective launching onto the floor is performed with Decrease–<br />

Increase phrasing, and two faster Impulses followed by Impacts; this is<br />

interspersed with Even turning over and looking around at the end. The<br />

sequencing of Phrasing by each dancer is Consecutive.<br />

FROM: African Funeral Song (2004)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER: Susan Hadley<br />

Variety of Dynamics<br />

This example has four different types of Phrasing.<br />

(1) Three Performers move first one after the other with differing types of<br />

Phrasing: an Impact with Even recovery, two Accents followed by Even<br />

moves, then at the same time with Even Phrasing punctuated with knee<br />

initiated Impulses by two performers that changes the initial grouping.<br />

The third performer then establishes herself with two pelvic Accents and,<br />

gains momentum for two subsequent Impactive Phrasings that again create<br />

changes in the grouping. The sequencing of Phrasing by each dancer<br />

is Consecutive.<br />

FROM: Six Tangos (2004)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER: Melanie Bales<br />

12 / DANCE DYNAMICS


( 3 ) E F F O R T Q U A L I T I E S<br />

Rudolf Laban developed the Effort theory that considers various movement<br />

qualities and describes specific coloring or texture of the movement.<br />

ONE MOTION FACTOR<br />

[Also refer to Workbook pp. 13–21.]<br />

Single movement qualities seldom appear in isolation. The following examples<br />

will show the predominance of qualities in one Motion Factor, and subsequently<br />

in one Effort quality.<br />

Direct & Indirect Space<br />

(1) The performer alternates direct, straight reaching gestures with indirect,<br />

flexible ones. Some changes in Time are also noticeable.<br />

FROM: Six Tangos (2004)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER: Melanie Bales<br />

PERFORMER: Christina Providence<br />

Strong Weight<br />

(1) The dancer exerts all the actions with strength or firmness while the<br />

strand of bound Flow is also noticeable.<br />

FROM: Composition study (2004)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER / PERFORMER: Scott Lowe<br />

Videotaped by Emily Lawrence<br />

Light Weight<br />

(1) This example shows a predominance of light, fine touch qualities that<br />

are associated with varying Time, Space, and Flow variables.<br />

FROM: Composition study (2004)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER / PERFORMER: Robin Anderson<br />

Videotaped by Emily Lawrence<br />

Sudden Time<br />

(1) Repetitive sudden leg gestures also show some light and direct quality.<br />

For this excerpt, Christina Providence has recalled her performance experience in the<br />

Croatian folk dance Ensemble Zivili in Columbus, Ohio.<br />

Videotaped by Shawn Hove<br />

DVD VIEWING GUIDE / 13


Sustained Time<br />

(1) In this example the sustained quality is maintained over an Even<br />

Phrasing while the performer is advancing.<br />

FROM: Tracking (2004)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER / PERFORMER: Kristin Hapke<br />

Bound Flow<br />

(1) In this scene, predominant bound Flow is coupled with sustainment and<br />

some instances of sudden Time.<br />

FROM: Breaking the Current: Ms. Toad’s Wild Ride Through the Twists and Turns of<br />

the Psychedelic Journey Called Life (1999)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER / PERFORMER: Jeanine Thompson<br />

Videotaped by Janet Parrott<br />

Free Flow<br />

(1) Free Flow and fast tempo are generated by most of the movement<br />

actions in this example.<br />

FROM: Tornado (1993)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER / PERFORMER: Jeanine Thompson<br />

Videotaped by Rosalind Pierson<br />

TWO MOTION FACTORS—STATES<br />

[Also refer to Workbook pp. 23–35.]<br />

Laban identified “incomplete efforts” as the emergence of a combination of<br />

two Motion factor’s elements. Bartenieff referred to them as “inner states.”<br />

Such combinations are observable in movement transitions and in some dance<br />

sequences.<br />

Weight/Flow—Dream-like & Space/Time—Awake<br />

(1) This scene shows a brief Dream-like or daydreaming State in which the<br />

performer engages Weight and Flow elements that oscillate between<br />

their polarities. From it she changes into an Awake sudden and direct<br />

pauncing, thus engaging elements of Space and Time, though some<br />

strength and bound Flow also are noticeable. Finally she returns to the<br />

Dream-like State again.<br />

FROM: Directed improvisation (2004)<br />

PERFORMER / CHOREOGRAPHER: Kristina Isabelle<br />

Videotaped by Shawn Hove<br />

14 / DANCE DYNAMICS


Space/Flow—Remote & Weight/Time—Near<br />

Remote<br />

(1) This ballet adagio-like sequence displays aspects of Space and Flow.<br />

From a direct/bound to more direct/free reaching, changing into indirect/free<br />

and continuing with fluctuations between direct/indirect, and<br />

bound/free qualities.<br />

FROM: Directed improvisation (2004)<br />

PERFORMER: Kristina Isabelle<br />

Videotaped by Shawn Hove<br />

Near<br />

(1) In contrast here is a tap dance sequence that shows rhythmic variations<br />

in qualities of Weight and Time. Some stronger and lighter taps alternate<br />

with sudden and sustained qualities. At times, though, some Flow qualities<br />

appear in the arms.<br />

FROM: Directed improvisation (2004)<br />

PERFORMER: Kristina Isabelle<br />

Videotaped by Shawn Hove<br />

Space/Weight—Stable & Time/Flow—Mobile<br />

Stable<br />

(1) In this ritualistic sequence, variations of Space and Weight qualities are<br />

noticeable. The predominant combinations are direct/light, direct/strong<br />

with some sustained Time, and some indirect/sustained. The quality of<br />

bound Flow is also noticeable in direct/strong combinations.<br />

FROM: Directed improvisation (2004)<br />

PERFORMER: Kristina Isabelle<br />

Videotaped by Shawn Hove<br />

Mobile<br />

(1) The excerpt shows Flow and Time fluctuations that create a Mobile<br />

State. Predominant free Flow coupled with sudden Time, occasionally<br />

changes into bound Flow and sustainment. Towards the end some<br />

Spatial directness appears.<br />

FROM: Figuring (2004)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER / PERFORMER: Chad Hall<br />

DVD VIEWING GUIDE / 15


THREE MOTION FACTORS—DRIVES<br />

[Also refer to Workbook pp. 41–51.]<br />

In movement and dance expression, clear combinations of three Motion Factors<br />

are frequently noticeable. Such combinations are referred to as Drives.<br />

Space/Weight/Time—Action Drive<br />

In dance actions and everyday activities as well, emotional participation that<br />

manifests in the Flow factor is not required. Rather, Space/Weight/Time combinations<br />

are most appropriate.<br />

(1) In the first excerpt kneading the imaginary dough includes transitions<br />

from Gliding to Pressing actions, interspersed with some Dabbing<br />

actions.<br />

FROM: Is a Woman (1978)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER / PERFORMER: Susan Van Pelt<br />

(2) The second example shows some Basic Effort Actions performed with<br />

the entire body, such as Slashing, Pulling, Punching, Wringing, Floating,<br />

Flicking-Dabbing, and Gliding.<br />

FROM: Directed improvisation (2004)<br />

PERFORMER: Kristina Isabelle<br />

Videotaped by Shawn Hove<br />

Flow/Weight/Time—Passion Drive<br />

In emotionally emphasized Drives the Flow factor replaces qualities of Space.<br />

(1) The dancer lashes out wildly as though chasing some nightmares. Free<br />

Flow, strength and sudden Time are prominent while Spatial clarity is in<br />

abeyance.<br />

FROM: Composition study (2004)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER / PERFORMER: Michael Estanich<br />

Videotaped by Emily Lawrence<br />

(2) In the second excerpt frantic tilting of the chair, temporarily loosing one's<br />

bearings, followed by vigorous gesturing and coming full tilt against the<br />

chair, shows an emotional state in which components of Flow, Weight,<br />

and Time are in the foreground.<br />

FROM: Chairs (2004)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER: Zvi Gotheiner<br />

PERFORMER: Kamilah Levens<br />

Videotaped by Emily Lawrence<br />

16 / DANCE DYNAMICS


Space/Flow/Time—Vision Drive<br />

In this Drive Space/Flow/Time are emphasized while bodily Sensing associated<br />

with the Weight factor is in the background.<br />

(1) The dancer appears pursuing an imaginary path with a direct/free Flow/<br />

light quality and some additional Time changes in terms of acceleration<br />

and deceleration.<br />

FROM: Lachrymae (1997)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER / VIDEOGRAPHER: Rosalind Pierson<br />

PERFORMER: Susan Sanborn<br />

(2) In the second example the performer stares at a situation that causes<br />

direct/sudden/bound arm and torso jerks.<br />

FROM: Tracking (2004)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER: Kristin Hapke<br />

PERFORMER: Michelle Stortz<br />

Space/Weight/Flow—Spell Drive<br />

A more timeless Spell-like Drive emerges when the Flow factor replaces qualities<br />

of Time.<br />

(1) In the first scene the performer's tentative gestures show bound Flow,<br />

lightness, and predominant directness, as though under the Spell of a<br />

nightmare.<br />

FROM: Breaking the Current: Ms. Toad’s Wild Ride Through the Twists and Turns of<br />

the Psychedelic Journey Called Life (1999)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER / PERFORMER: Jeanine Thompson<br />

Videotaped by Janet Parrott<br />

(2) In the second duet the couple is fascinated with each other as though<br />

there is an eternity for their interactions that show predominantly Space,<br />

Weight and Flow variations.<br />

FROM: Six Tangos (2004)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER: Melanie Bales<br />

PERFORMEERS: Teena Custer, Marc Woten<br />

Videotaped by Emily Lawrence<br />

DVD VIEWING GUIDE / 17


SYNTHESIS: EFFORT and PHRASING ANALYSIS OF TWO EXAMPLES<br />

Finally let us observe Phrasing—as a dynamic’s macrostructure, together with<br />

Effort—its microstructure. The examples of Contrast and Variety are analyzed<br />

further.<br />

Contrast<br />

(1) Two dancers stand next to each other facing stage right. At the start, the<br />

Even Phrasing sections of both performers are colored with sustained<br />

Time, some Spatial directness, and while turning on the floor with some<br />

bound Flow. Interrupting these sections are an Increase–Decrease in<br />

weightiness and free Flow in the turning of one dancer, and Increase<br />

in weightiness in the sinking of the other. Follow the performance of<br />

sudden/free Decreasing–Increasing into sudden/bound by both dancers.<br />

When repeated in a faster tempo some strong Weight is added, creating<br />

an Impulse–Impact. The final raising, looking, and lowering of the head<br />

and upper body by the dancer in the foreground is performed with a<br />

direct/sustained/bound quality.<br />

From the predominant combination of Effort variables one can deduce<br />

two contrasting Drives: Passion in all the outbursts, and Vision in the<br />

beginning and at the end.<br />

FROM: African Funeral Song (2004)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER: Susan Hadley<br />

Variety<br />

(1) Three dancers stand in a tight group, linked by arms. Starting with a<br />

downward arm gesture of a sudden/strong Impact that recovers with<br />

Even sustained quality, the first mover triggers two sudden/bound<br />

Accents from the second one, motivating all three performers to change<br />

grouping with Even sustained qualities; in this process the first and second<br />

performer turn with a light/sudden Impulse initiated by the knee.<br />

The third performer takes her initiative with two sudden/strong/bound<br />

Accents performed by the pelvis and gains momentum to pull both companions<br />

with an strong/sudden/free Flow Impact, followed by another<br />

sudden/strong/bound Impact that results in another change of grouping.<br />

From the predominant combinations of Effort variable one can notice<br />

that performers in this scene are coming in and out of Passion Drive with<br />

some instances of the Near State, and the Mobile State.<br />

FROM: Six Tangos (2004)<br />

CHOREOGRAPHER: Melanie Bales<br />

PERFORMERS: Robin Anderson, Ama Codjoe, Christina Providence<br />

18 / DANCE DYNAMICS


NOTE: The observation of the two strands of dance dynamics—Phrasing and<br />

Effort have been the main focus of the Workbook and DVD companion. As it<br />

can be seen in the paragraph below, the descriptions also refer to other important<br />

movement and dance components, such as BODILY ACTIONS, BODY<br />

PARTS, GROUP FORMATIONS, INTERACTION/RELATIONSHIPS, and SPATIAL<br />

DIRECTIONS.<br />

Three dancers stand in A TIGHT GROUP, LINKED by ARMS. Starting with a<br />

DOWNWARD ARM GESTURE of a sudden/strong Impact that recovers with<br />

Even sustained quality, the first mover TRIGGERS two sudden/bound Accents<br />

from the second one, MOTIVATING ALL THREE PERFORMERS to CHANGE<br />

GROUPING with Even sustained qualities; in this process the first and second<br />

performer TURN with a light-sudden Impulse initiated by the KNEE. The third<br />

performer takes her initiative with two sudden/strong/bound Accents performed<br />

by the PELVIS and gains momentum to PULL both companions with a strong/<br />

sudden/free Flow Impact, followed by another sudden/strong/bound Impact that<br />

results in another CHANGE OF GROUPING.<br />

While aspects, such as body parts, body actions, interaction or relationships,<br />

group formations, and spatial directions, are more readily identified and<br />

described, the qualitative area of dance dynamics is more subtle in its manifestations<br />

and continues to provide challenges in the study of movement and dance<br />

performance.<br />

Write adjectives describing the feel of the video excerpts illustrating:<br />

(1) PHRASING TYPES<br />

· Even<br />

· Increasing<br />

· Impactive<br />

· Decreasing<br />

DVD VIEWING GUIDE / 19


· Impulsive<br />

· Increase–Decrease<br />

· Decrease–Increase<br />

· Accented<br />

· Vibratory<br />

· Elastic Resilient<br />

· Buoyant Resilient<br />

· Weighty Resilient<br />

(2) SEQUENCING OF PHRASING<br />

· Consecutive<br />

· Concurrent<br />

· Overlapping<br />

20 / DANCE DYNAMICS


Write adjectives describing the feel of the video excerpts illustrating:<br />

(3) EFFORT QUALITIES—ONE MOTION FACTOR<br />

· Direct and Indirect Space<br />

· Strong Weight<br />

· Light Weight<br />

· Sudden Time<br />

· Bound Flow<br />

· Free Flow<br />

TWO MOTION FACTORS—STATES<br />

· Weight/Flow–Dreamlike & Space/Time–Awake<br />

· Space/Flow–Remote & Weight/Time–Near<br />

· Space/Weight–Stable & Time/Flow–Mobile<br />

DVD VIEWING GUIDE / 21


THREE MOTION FACTORS—DRIVES<br />

· Space/Weight/Time–Action Drive<br />

· Flow/Weight/Time–Passion<br />

· Space/Flow/Time–Vision<br />

· Space/Weight/Flow–Spell<br />

22 / DANCE DYNAMICS

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!