09.11.2014 Views

solvent-abuse-pakistan

solvent-abuse-pakistan

solvent-abuse-pakistan

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

Section three<br />

3.6 Magnitude of the<br />

problem<br />

In Pakistan, reliable data on the prevalence<br />

of <strong>solvent</strong> <strong>abuse</strong> and related problems is<br />

extremely scarce. The issue is further<br />

complicated by the highly sensitive nature of<br />

the problem, difficulties in accessing this<br />

population, complicated group dynamics and<br />

ignorance of local authorities regarding the<br />

subjects.<br />

The methodology adopted for providing<br />

estimates of <strong>solvent</strong> <strong>abuse</strong> prevalence was<br />

based on direct and indirect estimation. Direct<br />

estimation was done by counting the exact<br />

number of street children in a specified<br />

location and determining proportions actually<br />

involved in <strong>solvent</strong> <strong>abuse</strong>. Prior to conducting<br />

this exercise, a mapping exercise was<br />

undertaken and a complete mapping of street<br />

children was done in all four cities. Thereafter,<br />

six sites where maximum mobilization of street<br />

children was recorded were subsequently<br />

selected for prevalence estimation in each city.<br />

Furthermore, to capture the entire segments of<br />

the street children population, each site was<br />

visited on different days of the week as well as<br />

on different times of the day. The detail on the<br />

locations from where data were collected is<br />

given in Table 3.6.1.<br />

Table 3.6.1<br />

Karachi<br />

1. Abdullah Shah Ghazi<br />

2. Hussainabad<br />

3. Jamshair Road<br />

4. Korangi<br />

5. Tariq Road<br />

6. Saddar<br />

Lahore<br />

1. Data Darbar<br />

2. Circular Road<br />

3. Larri Adda<br />

4. Railway Station<br />

5. Macleod Road<br />

6. Multan Road<br />

Study sites from where prevalence estimates are generated<br />

Peshawar<br />

1. Firdous Cinema<br />

2. Haji Camp<br />

3. Jhangi Mohalla<br />

4. Kabuly Bazaar<br />

5. Railway Station<br />

6. Khyber Road<br />

Quetta<br />

1. Habib Nala<br />

2. Jinnah Road<br />

3. Lower Karez<br />

4. Pushtoon abad<br />

5.Saryab Road<br />

6.<br />

Indirect estimation was done by<br />

information gathered from Key informants.<br />

Regional police and public health personnel<br />

reported the estimated numbers of children<br />

involved with <strong>solvent</strong> <strong>abuse</strong>. NGO<br />

representatives, Government hospital staff,<br />

and people working with welfare<br />

organizations reported same figures.<br />

Ironically, the exact number of street<br />

children is unknown, as no formative<br />

research among street children had been<br />

conducted in the country to provide these<br />

estimates. Anecdotal information, however,<br />

is available with organizations working for<br />

the street children. According to the<br />

information gathered from these<br />

organizations, the approximate number of<br />

34<br />

street children in various cities is as follows:<br />

1. Karachi 12,000<br />

2. Lahore 8,000<br />

3. Peshawar 4,500<br />

4. Quetta 2,500<br />

Based on these estimates the number of<br />

children involved with <strong>solvent</strong>s <strong>abuse</strong> were<br />

calculated by multiplying the probability<br />

estimate with the total number of street<br />

children in each city. The details are provided<br />

in Table 3.6.2:<br />

Table 3.6.2<br />

Estimated Prevalence of<br />

Solvent <strong>abuse</strong> among street children<br />

<br />

OVERALL<br />

Karachi<br />

Lahore<br />

Peshawar<br />

Quetta<br />

Estimated<br />

Prevalence<br />

39.6 %<br />

45.3%<br />

36.9%<br />

36.8%<br />

41.7%<br />

Direct Estimates<br />

95% CI<br />

33.1 – 46.1%<br />

32.0 – 58.6%<br />

24.0 – 49.8%<br />

23.9 – 49.7%<br />

28.5 – 54.9%<br />

Indirect<br />

Estimates<br />

(range)<br />

-<br />

50 - 60%<br />

30-35%<br />

25-30%<br />

40-50%<br />

Total<br />

Number<br />

-<br />

5,500<br />

2,900<br />

1,700<br />

1,100<br />

Care should be taken before extracting<br />

nation wide estimates from the prevalence<br />

reported from this study. The number<br />

represents a pictorial suggestion from the<br />

major cities, and takes account of chronic<br />

users only, and is based on self-reported data.<br />

Therefore the estimates can be biased<br />

downward due to a combination of under<br />

reporting and under coverage. Moreover,<br />

generalization of these results to smaller cities<br />

and females is not suggested due to nonresponse<br />

and non-participation by a significant<br />

proportion of females.<br />

3.7 Key Informant Interviews<br />

As mentioned previously, 18 key informant<br />

interviews were conducted with individuals in a<br />

regular contact with these children frequently,<br />

to gather information about the existing<br />

services available for street children, as well<br />

as to comprehend the awareness of the<br />

service providers. The details on these<br />

interviews are given in box 4. Information<br />

generated from the key informant interviews<br />

documented very unsatisfactory knowledge<br />

and awareness of issues related to street<br />

children, and more importantly the<br />

understanding of <strong>solvent</strong> <strong>abuse</strong> among this<br />

extremely high-risk group. Moreover, the<br />

perceptions and knowledge of the interviewed<br />

people related to treatment, and rehabilitation<br />

32<br />

33

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!