10.11.2014 Views

Fredrika Shavit v. Rishon Lezion Jewish Burial Society

Fredrika Shavit v. Rishon Lezion Jewish Burial Society

Fredrika Shavit v. Rishon Lezion Jewish Burial Society

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

this will be said and will be fulfilled, provided that order and<br />

public peace is preserved. See e.g. the Meatrael case at 507-09.<br />

Our concern is with these two sets of pairs: individuals and the<br />

collective, the private domain and the public domain. Both these<br />

pairs relate to each other in certain ways. We can be sure of the<br />

following, subject to statute and constitution: neither an<br />

individual nor the collective can impose on another in the latter's<br />

private domain. Similarly, in the public domain, an individual<br />

will not be allowed to impose his or her will on another or on the<br />

collective. Our case raises a question with regard to the<br />

connection between the individual and the collective in the public<br />

domain. Is the public entitled to force its religious customs on the<br />

individual who finds himself or herself in the public domain, in<br />

its midst, and thus negate that individual’s right to freedom in the<br />

public domain? The Court touched on this issue in Meatrael [6]<br />

[as cited above – trans.].<br />

…<br />

All this is to say that the collective bears a heavy burden<br />

whenever it seeks to deny the freedom of an individual situated in<br />

the public domain; to force practices that are religious in nature<br />

on that individual.<br />

The private domain is distinct from the public domain. What is<br />

the private domain and what is the public domain with respect to<br />

freedom of religion and freedom from religion? All agree that a<br />

person’s home forms part of the private domain. Nevertheless, I<br />

believe that it is possible – and indeed proper – to expand that<br />

which is considered the private domain even beyond the four<br />

walls of one’s house and yard – though with great care. Take, for<br />

example, an observant neighborhood of alleys and narrow side<br />

streets upon which no stranger ever treads. It would not be an<br />

exaggeration to say that, regarding the public desecration of the

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!