MBB N°19 - Dec 09 - Article CERISE - Is SP profitable?
MBB N°19 - Dec 09 - Article CERISE - Is SP profitable?
MBB N°19 - Dec 09 - Article CERISE - Is SP profitable?
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
The Premier Source of<br />
Industry Benchmarks<br />
THE<br />
MICROBANKING<br />
BULLETIN No. 19<br />
Published by<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange<br />
<strong>Is</strong>sue No. 19<br />
<strong>Dec</strong>ember 20<strong>09</strong><br />
A publication dedicated to the performance of organizations that<br />
provide banking services for the poor
The<br />
MicroBanking<br />
Bulletin<br />
<strong>Is</strong>sue No. 19<br />
<strong>Dec</strong>ember 20<strong>09</strong><br />
A Publication Dedicated to the Performance of<br />
Organizations that Provide Banking Services for the Poor<br />
Copyright (c) 20<strong>09</strong><br />
Microfinance Information Exchange, Inc.<br />
The MicroBanking Bulletin is published twice annually by the Microfinance Information Exchange, Inc.<br />
ISSN 1934–3884. Copyright 20<strong>09</strong>. All rights reserved. The data in this volume have been carefully compiled and are<br />
believed to be accurate. Such accuracy is not however guaranteed. Feature articles in <strong>MBB</strong> are the property of the authors<br />
and permission to reprint or reproduce these should be sought from the authors directly. The publisher regrets it cannot<br />
enter into correspondence on this matter. Otherwise, no portion of this publication may be reproduced in any format<br />
or by any means including electronically or mechanically, by photocopying, recording or by any information storage or<br />
retrieval system, or by any form or manner whatsoever, without prior written consent of the publisher of the publication.<br />
Designed by: Macro Graphics Pvt. Ltd., www.macrographics.com
We would like to thank the following institutions for their participation in this issue:<br />
REGION COUNTRY # MFIS Name of Participant<br />
Africa<br />
(195 MF<strong>Is</strong>)<br />
Asia<br />
(283 MF<strong>Is</strong>)<br />
Angola 1 KixiCredito<br />
Benin 9 ACFB, Alidé, CBDIBA/RENACA, CMMB, FECECAM, FIDEVIE, PADME, PAPME, Vital Finance<br />
Burkina Faso 5 CVECA SOUM, GRAINE sarl, LSK, Micro Start, RCPB<br />
Burundi 3 CO<strong>SP</strong>EC, Turame Community Finance, WISE<br />
Cameroon 10 A3C, ACEP Cameroon, CamCCUL, CCA, CDM, CDS, CECIC S.A., CEC-PROM Mature, MC²,<br />
SOFINA<br />
Central African 1 CMCA<br />
Republic<br />
Chad 1 UCEC/MK<br />
Congo, Democratic 5 COOPEC/ACCO, FINCA - DRC, Hekima, PAIDEK, ProCredit Bank - DRC<br />
Republic of the<br />
Congo, Republic 2 CAPPED, FAM<br />
of the<br />
Cote d’Ivoire (Ivory 1 UNACOOPEC-CI<br />
Coast)<br />
Ethiopia 15 ACSI, ADCSI, BG, DECSI, Degaf, Eshet, Gasha, Harbu, Letta, Meklit, OCSSCO, PEACE, SFPI,<br />
Wasasa, Wisdom<br />
Gambia, The 2 GAWFA, Reliance<br />
Ghana 25 Akuapem RB, APED, ASA - GHA, Atwima Kwanwoma, Bessfa RB, Bonzali RB, CEDEF, CFF,<br />
CRAN, DQF, FASL, ID-Ghana, Juaben RB, Kakum RB, KSF, La Community Bank, Maata-N-<br />
Tudu, Nwabiagya RB, OISL, Otuasekan RB, ProCredit - GHA, SAT, South Akim RB, Union RB,<br />
Upper Manya RB<br />
Guinea 6 3A Entreprises, CAFODEC, CPECG Yete Mali, CRG, Pride Finance, RCCECG<br />
Kenya 15 BIMAS, Equity Bank, Faulu - KEN, Jamii Bora, KADET, KPOSB, K-Rep, KWFT, MCL, Micro<br />
Africa, Opportunity Kenya, PAWDEP, RAFODE, Riverbank, SMEP<br />
Madagascar 7 MicroCred - MDG, Otiv Alaotra, Otiv Diana, Otiv Sambava, Otiv Tana, SIPEM, TIAVO<br />
Malawi 5 CUMO, FINCA - MWI, MLF MWI, MUSCCO, OIBM<br />
Mali 10 CVECA Kita/Bafoulabé, CVECA Pays Dogon, Jigiyaso Ba, Kafo Jiginew, Kondo Jigima,<br />
Miselini, Nyesigiso, PASECA - Kayes, Soro Yiriwaso, UCCEC GY<br />
Mozambique 6 BOM, AfricaWorks, FDM, Hluvuku, NovoBanco - MOZ, Tchuma<br />
Niger 4 ASUSU CIIGABA, COOPEC Hinfani Dosso, Kokari, MECREF<br />
Nigeria 7 Alliance MFB, AMfB, DEC, ICMFB, IMFB, LAPO-NGR, SEAP<br />
Rwanda 7 ACB sa, CFE, COOPEDU-Kigali, Duterimbere, RML, UNION DES COOPECs UMUTANGUHA,<br />
UOB<br />
Senegal 12 ACEP Senegal, CAURIE Micro Finance, CMS, DJOMEC, MEC AFER, MEC FEPRODES,<br />
MECBAS, MicroCred - SEN, PAMECAS, SEM Fund, U-IMCEC, UMECDES<br />
Sierra Leone 4 ARD, GGEM Microfinance Services Ltd., LAPO-SLE, ProCredit Bank - SLE<br />
South Africa 4 Capitec Bank, Marang, Opportunity Finance, SEF-ZAF<br />
Swaziland 1 FINCORP<br />
Tanzania 9 Akiba, BRAC - TZA, FINCA - TZA, IDYDC, Mbinga CB, Faulu - TZA, PRIDE - TZA, SEDA,<br />
Tujijenge<br />
Togo 5 CECA, FUCEC Togo, MGPCC DEKAWOWO, Mutuelle Akwaba, WAGES<br />
Uganda 11 BRAC - UGA, Centenary Bank, Faulu - UGA, FINCA - UGA, Hofokam, Madfa SACCO, MED-<br />
Net, MAMIDECOT, MUL, REDFunds, Finance Trust<br />
Zambia 2 CETZAM, FINCA - ZMB<br />
Afghanistan 14 AMFI, ARMP, BRAC - AFG, CFA, FINCA - AFG, FMFB - AFG, Hope for Life, MADRAC, MoFAD,<br />
OXUS - AFG, Parwaz, WOCCU - AFG, WWI - AFG<br />
Bangladesh 11 ASA, BEES, BRAC, BURO Bangladesh, Grameen Bank, HEED, IDF, JCF, Sajida, Shakti, SSS<br />
Cambodia 15 ACLEDA, AMK, AMRET, CBIRD, Chamroeun, CHC-Limited, CREDIT, HKL, IPR, Maxima,<br />
PRASAC, Sathapana Limited, Seilanithih, TPC, VFC<br />
China 12 CFPA, CHWDA, CZWSDA, JXWDA, NYWDA, OI China, PATRA Hunchun, PATRA Yanbian,<br />
PCWDA, Rishenglong, XXWDA, YYWDA<br />
East Timor 1 Moris Rasik<br />
India 63 ABCRDM, Adhikar, AML, AMMACTS, Arohan, AWS, Bandhan, BASIX, BFL, BISWA, BJS, BSS,<br />
BWDC, Cashpor MC, CReSA, Equitas, ESAF, GF<strong>SP</strong>L, GOF, Grameen Sahara, GU, GV, HiH,<br />
Indur MACS, Janodaya, KBSLAB, KOPSA, KRUSHI, Mahasemam, Mahashakti, MFI, Mimo<br />
Finance, NBJK, NCS, NEED, Nidan, Pushtikar, PWMACS, RASS, RGVN, Saadhana, Samasta,<br />
Sanghamithra, Sarala, Sarvodaya Nano Finance, SCNL, SEWA Bank, SHARE, SKDRDP, SKS,<br />
SMILE, SMSS, Sonata, Spandana, SSK, SU, SFPL, SWAWS, Trident Microfinance, Ujjivan, VFS,<br />
VSSU, WSE<br />
Indonesia 36 BMT Kayu Manis, BMT Pringsewu, BPR AN, BPR Aditama Arta, BPR AK, BPR Artadamas<br />
Mandiri, BPR BBTM, BPR BKK Cilacap, BPR CAS, BPR Citama, BPR DMG, BPR Eka Ayu, BPR<br />
Eka Usaha, BPR Hitamajaya, BPR NBP 11, BPR NBP 19, BPR NBP 2, BPR NBP 30, BPR NSI,<br />
BPR Pinang Artha, BPR PKT, BPR SAS, BPR Sukawati Pancakanti, BPR SKA, BPR Surya<br />
Yudha Kencana, BPR Taman Dhana, BPR Wahana Sentra Artha, CU Kosayu, CU Pantai<br />
Prigi, CU Sawiran, Dian Mandiri, DINARI, MBK Ventura, MMS, TLM, WKP<br />
Laos 2 ACLEDA Lao, IFDP
REGION COUNTRY # MFIS Name of Participant<br />
Nepal 25 BAYOCA, BMSCCSL, CBB, Chandeshwori, CSD, DD Bank, DEPROSC-Nepal, FORWARD,<br />
GBNB, JSCCS, JVS, Mahila, Mahuli, Manushi, MGBB, MPGBB, NeRuDO, NESDO, Nirdhan,<br />
NRDSC, PGBB, Sahara Mahila, SB Bank, <strong>SP</strong>GBB, VYCCU<br />
Pakistan 12 Asasah, CWCD, DAMEN, FMFB - Pakistan, Kashf Foundation, Kashf Bank, Khushhali Bank,<br />
NMFB, POMFB, RCDS, Sungi, TMFB<br />
Papua New Guinea 2 PNG Microfinance Ltd, Nationwide Microbank<br />
Philippines 63 1st Valley Bank, ABS-CBN, ARDCI, ASA Philippines, ASHI, ASKI, Banco Santiago de Libon,<br />
Bangko Kabayan, Bangko Luzon, Bangko Mabuhay, BCB, Cantilan Bank, CARD Bank,<br />
CARD NGO, CBMO, CEVI, CMEDFI, D<strong>SP</strong>I, ECLOF - PHL, FAIR Bank, FICO, First Macro Bank,<br />
GM Bank, Green Bank, H<strong>SP</strong>FI, Kasagana-Ka, Kazama Grameen, KBank, KCCDFI, KMBI, Life<br />
Bank, Mallig Plains RB, MEDF, New RB of Victorias, NWTF, OMB, PALFSI, PBC, PR Bank,<br />
Progressive Bank, RB Bagac, RB Cainta, RB Camalig, RB Cotabato, RB Digos, RB Dipolog, RB<br />
Guinobatan, RB Lebak, RB Liloy, RB Mabitac, RB Montevista, RB Oroquieta, RB Pagbilao,<br />
RB Placer, RB San Jacinto, RB Siargao, RB Solano, RB Talisayan, R<strong>SP</strong>I, Serviamus, Siam Bank,<br />
TSKI, Valiant RB<br />
Samoa 1 <strong>SP</strong>BD<br />
Sri Lanka 8 Berendina Microfinance, BRAC - LKA, Lak Jaya, Sabaragamuwa, SDBL, SEEDS, SEWA<br />
Finance, WDB<br />
Thailand 2 Common Interest, SED<br />
Vietnam 16 Binhminh CDC, CEP, CEP BRVT, CEP Long An, Childfund Hoa Binh, Fund for Women<br />
Development - HCM, M7 Can Loc, M7 DB District, M7 DBP City, M7 Dong Trieu, M7 Mai<br />
Son, M7 Ninh Phuoc, M7 Uong bi, Plan International, TYM, VB<strong>SP</strong><br />
ECA<br />
(217 MF<strong>Is</strong>)<br />
LAC<br />
(333 MF<strong>Is</strong>)<br />
Albania 5 ASC Union, BESA, FAF-DC, Opportunity Albania, ProCredit Bank - ALB<br />
Armenia 9 ACBA, AREGAK UCO, ECLOF - ARM, Farm Credit Armenia, FINCA - ARM, Horizon, INECO,<br />
KAMURJ, SEF-ARM<br />
Azerbaijan 18 AccessBank, Aqrarkredit, Aqroinvest, Azercredit, Azerdemiryolbank, Azeri Star, Bank of<br />
Baku, CredAgro NBCO, DAYAQ-Credit, FINCA - AZE, FinDev, Invest Credit, Komak Credit,<br />
MikroMaliyye Credit, Normicro, Parabank, Umid-Credit, Viator<br />
Bosnia and<br />
Herzegovina<br />
12 EKI, LIDER, LOK Microcredit Foundation, MI-BO<strong>SP</strong>O, MIKRA, Mikro ALDI, Partner, PRIZMA,<br />
ProCredit Bank - BIH, SINERGIJA, Sunrise, Women for Women<br />
Bulgaria 24 Aetos, Agroimpuls, DSK Dobrich, Doveriye- Bulgaria, General Toshevo, Kajnardza 96,<br />
Kredo, KSK RPK, Maritsa Invest, Mikrofond, Miziya, Momina Voda, Nachala, Nadejda 96,<br />
Perelik, Pomoriiski stopanin, Popular Kasa-Kystendil, ProCredit Bank - BGR, Saglasie 96,<br />
Samokov 96, Smilyan, Solidarnost, Stopanin, USTOI<br />
Georgia 9 Alliance Group, CREDO, Crystal, FinAgro, FINCA - GEO, ImerCredit, JSC Bank Constanta,<br />
Lazika Capital, ProCredit Bank - GEO<br />
Kazakhstan 10 Abzal Kredit, ACF, A-invest, Arnur Credit, Bereke, FFSA, Kemek, KMF, MCO ‘Oral’, Moldir<br />
Kosovo 8 AFK, BZMF, FINCA - KOS, KEP, KGMAMF, KosInvest, KRK Ltd, ProCredit Bank – KOS<br />
Kyrgyzstan 14 1st MCC, Agrocredit Plus, Aiyl Bank, Bai Tushum, Bereke-credit, BTA Bank, Dirigible, Elet-<br />
Capital, FMCC, FNT Credit, Joldosh Group, Kompanion, Mol Bulak Finance, OXUS - KGS<br />
Macedonia, Former 4 FULM, Horizonti, Moznosti, ProCredit Bank – MKD<br />
Yugoslav Republic<br />
of<br />
Moldova 4 Invest-Credit Moldova, Microinvest, ProCredit - MDA, ProCredit Bank - MDA<br />
Mongolia 5 Credit Mongol, Khan Bank, TFS, VFM, XacBank<br />
Montenegro 1 OBM<br />
Poland 2 Fundusz Mikro, Inicjatywa Mikro<br />
Romania 6 CAPA, Express Finance, LAM, OMRO, ProCredit Bank - ROM, ROMCOM<br />
Russia 52 Alternativa, Alteya, Avantaj, BFSBS, Blago, BRCCC, CEF, Chita FSBS, CMFinance, Doveriye<br />
- Volgograd, Doveriye (Amursk), Doveriye-Altay, Edinstvo Yurga, Edinstvo-Volgograd,<br />
EKPA, FFECC, FINCA - Russia, FORUS, Galaktika, Gorodskoy, Impuls, Intellekt, KMB, KVK,<br />
KVK-Altay, Nadejda, Narodniy Kredit_Kemerov, Neftegaz, Obereg (Vladivostok), Partner<br />
Russia, Povoljye, Raduga, Reserv-Altay, Rezerv, Rost, Rus, WMN (Russia), SBS, Sodeystviye,<br />
Sodeystviye-2005, Sodruzhestvo, Soglasiye, Soyuz-Khimik, SoyuzKredit, Soyuz-Primoroye,<br />
Stanichnik, Tsaritsinskiy passaj, Tsimlyansk, Tverskoy, USFSBS, Vostok Kapital, VRFSBS<br />
Serbia 4 AgroInvest, MDF, OBS, ProCredit Bank Serbia<br />
Tajikistan 23 Agroinvestbank, Amlok, ASTI, Bank Eskhata, Borshud, Ehyoi kuhiston, FINCA - TJK, FMFB<br />
- TJK, Imkoniyat, Imodi Hutal, IMON, JOVID, Maqsadi dasgiri, MLF Chiluchor chashma, MLF<br />
Kiropol, MLF Madina, MLF MicroInvest, MLF Vahsh Microfin, MLO HUMO, MLO ‘Saodat<br />
Invest’, Nov Credit, OXUS - TJK, Sugd Microfin<br />
Ukraine 2 HOPE, ProCredit Bank - UKR<br />
Uzbekistan 5 ASR, Garant-Invest, Mikrokredit Bank, SABR, Umid<br />
Argentina 7 Avanzar, Columbia Microcreditos, FIE Gran Poder, Emprenda, Grameen Mendoza,<br />
Progresar, Pro Mujer - ARG<br />
Bolivia 23 AgroCapital, ANED, BancoSol, CIDRE, Coop Fátima, Coop Jesús Nazareno, CRECER,<br />
Diaconia, EcoFuturo FFP, Emprender, Fassil FFP, FIE FFP, FONCRESOL, FONDECO, Fortaleza<br />
FFP, FUBODE, FUNBODEM, IDEPRO, IMPRO, ProCredit - BOL, PRODEM FFP, Pro Mujer - BOL,<br />
Sartawi<br />
Brazil 28 Agência do Crédito, ANDE, Banco da Familia, Banco do Empreendedor, Banco do<br />
Povo ACP, Rede Novo Sol, Banco do Vale, Banco Popular do Brasil, BANCRI, Casa do<br />
Microcrédito, CEADe, CEAPE BA, CEAPE MA, CEAPE PE, CEAPE PI, Central Cresol Baser,<br />
CrediAmigo, Credisol, Cresol Central, Fácil SCM, ICC BluSol, ICC Conquista Solidária, ICC<br />
MAUCE, Instituto Estrela, Real Microcrédito, São Paulo Confia, SOCIALCRED, SOCRED
REGION COUNTRY # MFIS Name of Participant<br />
Chile 3 BancoEstado, Credicoop, Fondo Esperanza<br />
Colombia 18 Actuar Caldas, Actuar Tolima, AGAPE, Bancamía, BCSC, Comultrasan, Contactar,<br />
Crezcamos, FinAmérica, FMM Bucaramanga, FMM Popayán, FMSD, Fundación Amanecer,<br />
Interactuar, Coop MEDA, OLC, ProCredit - COL, WWB Cali<br />
Costa Rica 9 ACORDE, ADRI, ASOPROSANRAMON, CREDIMUJER, FIDERPAC, FOMIC, Fundación Mujer,<br />
FUNDEBASE, FUNDECOCA<br />
Dominican<br />
4 ADOPEM, A<strong>SP</strong>IRE, Banco ADEMI, Fundación Esperanza<br />
Republic<br />
Ecuador 47 Banco Solidario, CACMU, CCC, CEPESIU, CESOL ACJ, COAC 4 de Octubre, COAC Acción<br />
Rural, COAC Ambato, COAC Artesanos, COAC Chone, COAC Fernando Daquilema,<br />
COAC Fondvida, COAC Huaycopungo, COAC Jardín Azuayo, COAC Kullki Wasi, COAC<br />
La Benéfica, COAC Luz del Valle, COAC MCCH, COAC Minga, COAC Mushuc Runa, COAC<br />
La Nacional, COAC Padre Vicente, COAC Pallatanga, COAC Sac Aiet, COAC San Antonio,<br />
COAC San Gabriel, COAC San José, COAC Santa Ana, COAC Santa Anita, CODESARROLLO,<br />
COOPROGRESO, Credi Fé, D-Miro, ECLOF - ECU, FACES, FED, FINCA - ECU, FODEMI,<br />
Fundación Alternativa, Fundación Espoir, FUNDAMIC, INSOTEC, ProCredit - ECU, UCADE<br />
Ambato, UCADE Guaranda, UCADE Latacunga, UCADE Santo Domingo<br />
El Salvador 13 ACCOVI, AMC de R.L., Apoyo Integral, ASEI, Asociación El Balsamo, CCAMETRO, ENLACE,<br />
FADEMYPE, FINCA - SLV, Fundación CAMPO, FUNSALDE, ProCredit - SLV, PADECOMSM<br />
Guatemala 16 AGUDESA, ASDIR, Asociación Raíz, AYNLA, CDRO, CRYSOL, FAFIDESS, FAPE, FIACG, FINCA<br />
- GTM, FONDESOL, Fundación MICROS, FUNDEA, FUNDE<strong>SP</strong>E, Génesis Empresarial, MUDE<br />
Haiti 6 ACME, FINCA - HTI, Fonkoze, MCN, SFF, SOGESOL<br />
Honduras 14 ADICH, BanCovelo, CARE - CREEME, FAMA OPDF, FINCA - HND, FINSOL, FUNDAHMICRO,<br />
FUNED, HDH OPDF, IDH, Microfinanciera Prisma, ODEF Financiera, ProCredit - HND, World<br />
Relief - HND<br />
Mexico 51 ALSOL, Alternativa 19 del Sur, AMEXTRA, Apoyo Económico, APROS, A<strong>SP</strong> Financiera,<br />
ATEMEXPA, Banco Amigo, CAFASA, Caja Depac Poblana, Caja Popular Mexicana, CAME,<br />
COCDEP, CompartamosBanco, Conserva, Crece Safsa, CrediAvance, Credi-Capital,<br />
CrediClub, CrediComún, Créditos Pronegocio, CREDITUYO, Despacho Amador, Don<br />
Apoyo, Espacios Alternativos, Crezkamos Kapital, FinAmigo, Financiera Independencia,<br />
FINCA - MEX, FinComún, FINORTE, FISUR, Forjadores de Negocios, FRAC, FUNHAVI, FVP,<br />
GCM, Grupo Río La Venta, Invirtiendo, MicroCred - MEX, Oportunidad Microfinanzas,<br />
Progresemos, Pro Mujer - MEX, Red de Vanguardia, SemiSol, SolFi, Solución Asea,<br />
Soluciones Reales, Te Creemos, UNICREICH, Vivir Soluciones<br />
Nicaragua 23 ADIM, AFODENIC, ASODENIC, BANEX, Caritas Esteli, CEPRODEL, Coop 20 de Abril, Coop<br />
Avances, FDL, Financiera Fama, FINCA - NIC, FODEM, FUDEMI, Fundación 4i-2000,<br />
Fundación León 2000, Fundación Nieborowski, FUNDENUSE, FUNDEPYME, FUNDESER,<br />
PRESTANIC, ProCredit - NIC, PRODESA, Pro Mujer - NIC<br />
Panama 3 Coop Juan XXIII, Microserfin, ProCaja<br />
Paraguay 6 Banco Familiar, FIELCO, Fundación Paraguaya, Interfisa Financiera, Microsol, Visión Banco<br />
Peru 60 ADRA - PER, Alternativa Microfinanzas, AMA, ASIDME, Asociación Arariwa, Caritas, CMAC<br />
Arequipa, CMAC Cusco, CMAC Del Santa, CMAC Huancayo, CMAC Ica, CMAC Maynas,<br />
CMAC Paita, CMAC Pisco, CMAC Piura, CMAC Sullana, CMAC Tacna, CMAC Trujillo,<br />
COOPAC Chiquinquira, COOPAC León XIII, COOPAC Los Andes, COOPAC Norandino,<br />
COOPAC San Cristóbal, COOPAC San Martín, COOPAC Santa Maria, COOPAC Santo Cristo,<br />
COOPAC Santo Domingo, COOPAC Tocache, CRAC Los Andes, CRAC Nuestra Gente,<br />
CRAC Profinanzas, CRAC Señor de Luren, CRAC Sipán, Crediscotia, EDAPRO<strong>SP</strong>O, EDPYME<br />
Acceso Crediticio, EDPYME Alternativa, EDPYME Confianza, EDPYME Crear Arequipa,<br />
EDPYME Credivisión, EDPYME Efectiva, EDPYME Nueva Visión, EDPYME Pro Negocios,<br />
EDPYME Proempresa, EDPYME Raíz, Financiera Edyficar, FINCA - PER, FONDESURCO,<br />
FOVIDA, IDER CV, IDESI Lambayeque, IDE<strong>SP</strong>A, Manuela Ramos, MiBanco, Micredito SAC,<br />
MIDE, Popular SAFI, PRISMA, Pro Mujer - PER, Mentors - PER<br />
Venezuela 2 BanGente, MiBanco Venezuela<br />
MENA<br />
(56 MF<strong>Is</strong>)<br />
Egypt 14 ABA, ABWA, Al Tadamun, ASBA, CEOSS, DBACD, ESED, FMF, IDDA, Lead Foundation, NSBA,<br />
RADE, SBACD, SCDA<br />
Iraq 3 Al-Thiqa, CHF Iraq, Izdiharona Microfinance<br />
Jordan 7 Alwatani, AMC, DEF, FINCA - JOR, MEMCO, MFW, Tamweelcom<br />
Lebanon 3 Al Majmoua, Ameen, Makhzoumi<br />
Morocco 9 Al Amana, Al Karama, AMOS, AMSSF/MC, ARDI, FBPMC, FONDEP, INMAA, Zakoura<br />
Palestine 8 ACAD, Al Rafah Bank, ASALA, FATEN, PARC, Reef, Ryada, UNRWA<br />
Sudan 3 BRAC - SS, PASED, SUMI<br />
Syria 2 FMFI-SYR, Jabal Al Hoss<br />
Tunisia 1 Enda<br />
Yemen 6 Abyan, Aden, Al Awael, Azal, NMF, SFSD<br />
Abbreviations: ECA = Eastern Europe & Central Asia; LAC = Latin America & the Caribbean; MENA = Middle East & North Africa.
The MicroBanking Bulletin (<strong>MBB</strong>)<br />
The MicroBanking Bulletin is one of the principal<br />
publications of MIX (Microfinance Information Exchange,<br />
Inc.). MIX is a non-profit company that works to support<br />
the growth and development of a healthy microfinance<br />
sector. MIX is supported by the Consultative Group to<br />
Assist the Poor (CGAP), Citi Foundation, Deutsche Bank<br />
Americas Foundation, Omidyar Network, Open Society<br />
Institute, Rockdale Foundation, and others. To learn more<br />
about MIX, please visit the website at www.themix.org.<br />
Purpose<br />
By collecting financial and portfolio data provided<br />
voluntarily by leading microfinance institutions (MF<strong>Is</strong>),<br />
organizing the database by peer groups, and reporting<br />
this information, MIX is building infrastructure that is<br />
critical to the development of the microfinance sector. The<br />
primary purpose of this database is to help MFI managers<br />
and board members understand their performance in<br />
comparison to other MF<strong>Is</strong>. Secondary objectives include<br />
establishing industry performance standards, enhancing<br />
the transparency of financial reporting, and improving<br />
the performance of microfinance institutions.<br />
Benchmarking Services<br />
To achieve these objectives, MIX provides the following<br />
benchmarking services: 1) the Bulletin’s Tables; 2)<br />
customized financial performance reports; and 3)<br />
network services.<br />
MF<strong>Is</strong> participate in the MicroBanking Bulletin benchmarks<br />
database on a quid pro quo basis. They provide MIX<br />
with information about their financial and portfolio<br />
performance, as well as details regarding accounting<br />
practices, subsidies, and the structure of their liabilities.<br />
Participating MF<strong>Is</strong> must submit substantiating<br />
documentation, such as audited financial statements,<br />
annual reports, ratings, institutional appraisals, and other<br />
materials that help us understand their operations. With<br />
this information, we apply adjustments for inflation,<br />
subsidies and loan loss provisioning in order to create<br />
comparable results. Data are presented in the Bulletin<br />
anonymously within peer groups. While MIX performs<br />
extensive checks on the consistency of data reported,<br />
we do not independently verify the information.<br />
In return, participating institutions receive a comparative<br />
performance report (CPR). These individualized<br />
benchmark reports, which are an important output of<br />
the benchmarks database, explain the adjustments<br />
we made to the data, and compare the institution’s<br />
performance to that of peer institutions. MFI managers<br />
and board members use these tools to understand their<br />
institution’s performance in a comparative context.<br />
The third core service is to work with networks of<br />
microfinance institutions (i.e., affiliate, national, regional),<br />
central banks, and researchers in general to enhance their<br />
ability to collect and manage performance indicators.<br />
MIX provides this service in a variety of ways, including<br />
1) training these organizations to collect, adjust and<br />
report data on retail MF<strong>Is</strong> at the local level and use<br />
MIX’s performance monitoring and benchmarking<br />
software, 2) collecting data on behalf of a network,<br />
and 3) providing customized data analysis to compare<br />
member institutions to peer groups. This service to<br />
networks, regulatory agencies, and researchers allows<br />
MIX to reach a wider range of MF<strong>Is</strong> in order to improve<br />
their financial reporting.<br />
New Participants<br />
Institutions that wish to participate in the Bulletin<br />
database should contact: info@themix.org, Tel +1 202<br />
659 9<strong>09</strong>4, Fax +1 202 659 9<strong>09</strong>5. Currently, the only<br />
criterion for participation is the ability to fulfill fairly<br />
onerous reporting requirements. MIX reserves the<br />
right to establish minimum performance criteria for<br />
participation in the Bulletin database.<br />
Submissions<br />
The Bulletin welcomes submissions of articles and<br />
commentaries, particularly regarding analytical<br />
work on the financial and/or social performance of<br />
microfinance institutions. Submissions may include<br />
reviews or summaries of more extensive work<br />
published elsewhere. <strong>Article</strong>s should not exceed 3000<br />
words. To submit an article, please contact Elizabeth<br />
Downs, Managing Editor, at edowns@themix.org.<br />
Disclaimer<br />
Neither MIX, <strong>MBB</strong>’s Editorial Board nor MIX’s funders<br />
accept responsibility for the validity of the information<br />
presented or consequences resulting from its use by<br />
third parties.
The MicroBanking Bulletin<br />
<strong>Is</strong>sue No. 19<br />
<strong>Dec</strong>ember 20<strong>09</strong><br />
Dedicated to the performance of organizations that provide banking services to the poor.<br />
Editorial Staff<br />
Publisher:<br />
Marten Leijon, Executive Director, MIX<br />
Managing Editor:<br />
Elizabeth Downs, Director of Marketing Communications, MIX<br />
Editorial Board<br />
Craig F. Churchill<br />
Asad Mahmood<br />
J.D. Von Pischke<br />
Elisabeth Rhyne<br />
Gabriel Solorzano<br />
International Labour Organization<br />
Deutsche Bank<br />
Frontier Finance International<br />
ACCION International<br />
BANEX<br />
Chairman Emeritus:<br />
Robert Peck Christen<br />
The MicroBanking Bulletin is a publication of MIX (Microfinance Information Exchange, Inc.)<br />
To learn more about MIX, please visit the MIX website at www.themix.org
Table of Contents<br />
Feature <strong>Article</strong>s<br />
Scaling Up MicroSavings..................................................................................................................................... 1<br />
Christoph Kneiding, Ignacio Mas, Adrian Gonzalez, and Sheila Miller<br />
Saving Through the Mobile Phone.................................................................................................................. 7<br />
Olga Morawczynski, University of Edinburgh<br />
The Case for Pricing Transparency.................................................................................................................15<br />
Jessica A. Haeussler<br />
<strong>Is</strong> Social Performance Profitable...................................................................................................................22<br />
Florent Bédécarrats, Rémy William Angora, Cécile Lapenu<br />
New Financial Ratios for Microfinance Reporting....................................................................................30<br />
Drew Tulchin, Reid Sassman, Elizabeth Wolkomir: Social Enterprise Associates,<br />
for the MFI Reporting Standards Initiative of the SEEP Network<br />
Bulletin Highlights<br />
MFI Benchmark Analysis: Operating Efficiency: Victim to the Crisis...............................................39<br />
Blaine Stephens, COO and Director of Analysis, MIX<br />
Bulletin Tables<br />
Introduction to the Peer Groups and Tables..............................................................................................45<br />
2008 MFI Benchmarks........................................................................................................................................47<br />
Institutional Characteristics.....................................................................................................................47<br />
Financing Structure....................................................................................................................................47<br />
Outreach Indicators....................................................................................................................................48<br />
Macroeconomic Indicators......................................................................................................................49<br />
Overall Financial Performance................................................................................................................49<br />
Revenues........................................................................................................................................................50<br />
Expenses.........................................................................................................................................................50<br />
Efficiency........................................................................................................................................................51<br />
Productivity...................................................................................................................................................51<br />
Risk and Liquidity........................................................................................................................................52<br />
Index of Indicator Definitions..........................................................................................................................53<br />
Guide to Peer Groups ........................................................................................................................................54<br />
Appendices<br />
Appendix I : Notes, Adjustments and Statistical <strong>Is</strong>sues...........................................................................73<br />
Appendix II : Participating MF<strong>Is</strong> 2008.............................................................................................................76
Letter from the Publisher<br />
Dear Readers,<br />
We are excited to share with you the 19 th Edition of<br />
the MicroBanking Bulletin. We are delighted to be able<br />
to provide you with important findings from a global<br />
benchmark data set that covers 1,084 MF<strong>Is</strong> and a set<br />
of compelling articles that addresses some of the most<br />
pressing issues facing microfinance today.<br />
The benchmarking data set provides a first-of-its-kind<br />
look into the effects that the economic slowdown is<br />
having on MF<strong>Is</strong> across the globe. The analysis explores<br />
how the slowdown is tightening its squeeze on MFI<br />
performance through rising delinquency levels and<br />
declining operational efficiency.<br />
This edition of the Bulletin also features articles that<br />
address critical priorities for leaders in microfinance –<br />
savings mobilization, pricing transparency, the link<br />
of social and financial performance, and the evolving<br />
standardization of metrics:<br />
• Expanding savings through distribution:<br />
Kneiding et al explore MF<strong>Is</strong>’ ability to scale up<br />
microsavings, concluding that microfinance<br />
institutions in general tend to rely on distributionled<br />
growth rather than more effective use of<br />
their existing branches. Morawczynski details<br />
how mobile services enable savings, outlining<br />
opportunities to derive further benefits from<br />
mobile services.<br />
• Pricing transparency: Jessica Haeussler<br />
investigates evidence as to the impact that<br />
insufficient pricing transparency has on market<br />
efficiency and consumer choice, showing that<br />
an opaque pricing environment does appear to<br />
come at a cost.<br />
• Linking social and financial performance:<br />
Bédécarrats, Angora and Lapenu test the link<br />
between Social Performance Indicators (<strong>SP</strong>I)<br />
and financial performance. Their findings point<br />
to a positive correlation between several <strong>SP</strong>I<br />
and financial outcomes, but also key differences<br />
between variables.<br />
• Evolving standardization of metrics: Tulchin,<br />
Sassman and Wolkomir present eight new ratios<br />
from the MFI Reporting Standards Initiative of<br />
the SEEP Network. The new ratios aim to better<br />
describe financial position and performance<br />
with a particular focus on savings and risk<br />
exposures.<br />
Finally, I want to thank you for your continued interest<br />
in and support for the <strong>MBB</strong>. As we move forward, we<br />
will evaluate how we can improve the contents of the<br />
Bulletin and our delivery of it to you. We welcome your<br />
feedback and comments as we begin the evaluation<br />
process early in 2010.<br />
Sincerely yours,<br />
Marten Leijon<br />
Publisher, <strong>MBB</strong><br />
Executive Director, MIX
FEATURE ARTICLES<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
Scaling Up Micro Savings: A Matter of<br />
More Branches or Busier Branches<br />
Christoph Kneiding, Ignacio Mas, Adrian Gonzalez, and Sheila Miller 1<br />
The microfinance industry is increasingly focused on<br />
deposit mobilization. On the demand side, there is a<br />
growing sense that poor people should have a broader<br />
range of financial instruments available to them rather<br />
than only credit. On the supply side, institutions are<br />
increasingly keen to build a more stable, low-cost<br />
funding base from local deposits, especially in the<br />
aftermath of the global financial crisis. This renewed<br />
interest in deposit mobilization by microfinance<br />
institutions (MF<strong>Is</strong>) is also fuelled by the high-profile<br />
successes of certain deposit mobilizing institutions,<br />
including Bank Rakyat Indonesia (21 million savers),<br />
Grameen Bank and ASA in Bangladesh (together,<br />
14 million savers), Equity Bank in Kenya (3.9 million<br />
savers) and Banco Azteca in Mexico (4.5 million savers).<br />
Yet despite these notorious successes, the bulk of<br />
MF<strong>Is</strong> remain relatively small scale in terms of deposit<br />
mobilization. This prompts us to look into the growth<br />
strategies pursued by MF<strong>Is</strong>, large and small. Do the<br />
larger deposit-taking MF<strong>Is</strong> exhibit a more intensive<br />
utilization of their distribution network in terms of<br />
savers per branch (giving rise to what we term intensive<br />
growth), or do they simply have many more branches<br />
(which we term extensive or distribution-driven<br />
growth) In this respect, we compare the behavior of<br />
MF<strong>Is</strong> against commercial banks, to see whether their<br />
growth dynamics are different. We also compare the<br />
relationship between intensity of use of branches and<br />
the total number of customers served by the institution<br />
between the savings and lending sides.<br />
Data sources and methodology<br />
Our primary dataset is based on MIX Market, an online<br />
database of financial and operational data from MF<strong>Is</strong><br />
1 Christoph Kneiding is a Microfinance Analyst at CGAP; Ignacio Mas<br />
is Deputy Director at the Financial Services for the Poor team at the<br />
Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation; Adrian Gonzalez is Lead Researcher<br />
at Microfinance Information Exchange, Inc. (MIX); and Sheila Miller<br />
is Program Coordinator at the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation. The<br />
authors wish to thank Blaine Stephens from MIX for very helpful<br />
comments and suggestions.<br />
2 “Banking the Poor: Measuring banking access in 54 Economies”,<br />
World Bank, Washington DC.<br />
around the globe. From this database we selected<br />
all the MF<strong>Is</strong> with more than 10,000 savers reported<br />
for 2007. This gave us information on the number of<br />
savers and borrowers, the value of the corresponding<br />
deposit and loan portfolios, as well as the number of<br />
branches, for 165 MF<strong>Is</strong>. MIX Market defines savers as<br />
individuals who currently have funds on deposit with<br />
an MFI, which the MFI is liable to repay. This excludes<br />
involuntary savings linked to loans.<br />
We compare this sample with another one based on<br />
a multi-country survey of the largest five commercial<br />
banks by assets compiled by the World Bank and<br />
reported in Banking the Poor (BTP). 2 This database<br />
contains, for each institution, the number and value<br />
of savings and loan accounts, as well as the number of<br />
branches. The sample covers 235 banks in 54 countries<br />
for the year 2007. Some banks did not participate in<br />
the survey, and in some countries there were fewer<br />
than five commercial banks. We took the number<br />
of savers to be the larger of the reported number<br />
of checking and savings accounts, in order to avoid<br />
double-counting. We excluded institutions with fewer<br />
than 10,000 savers, or those with obviously deficient<br />
information. The resulting sample consists of 149<br />
commercial banks from 53 countries.<br />
This data has certain limitations. The mapping<br />
between number of savings (loan) accounts and the<br />
number or savers (borrowers) is imperfect. On the MFI<br />
data set, we are relying on the institutions´ reporting<br />
of customer numbers. On the commercial bank data<br />
set, if for a particular institution some customers<br />
had only a checking account and others had only a<br />
savings account, the inferred number of savers would<br />
be underestimated given that we take the maximum<br />
of the two. Also, there is self-selection in the MF<strong>Is</strong> and<br />
banks that are part of the sample. MF<strong>Is</strong> that are very<br />
successful at deposit mobilization have less incentive<br />
to report to MIX Market, since it is seen primarily as a<br />
vehicle for demonstrating transparency for MF<strong>Is</strong> who<br />
are reliant on external sources of funding. Equally,<br />
commercial banks’ responses to and participation in<br />
the World Bank survey may have depended on various<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
FEATURE ARTICLES<br />
incentives, such as whether they participate in World<br />
Bank-funded lines of credit.<br />
Throughout this paper we refer to the institutions in<br />
the two data sets as being MF<strong>Is</strong> and commercial banks.<br />
This is purely short-hand to distinguish the data sets<br />
(MIX Market and BTP, respectively), and may not truly<br />
reflect the legal status of the specific institutions in<br />
each data set. Some institutions in MIX Market are<br />
indeed licensed as commercial banks, and a couple in<br />
fact appear in both data sets. 3<br />
Figures 1 and 2 show the distribution of institutions in<br />
the two samples by size, as measured by the number of<br />
savers per institution. Both figures are shown on a log<br />
scale, which underscores the very large variation in size<br />
of institutions as measured by the number of savers.<br />
Figure 1, which depicts the size ranking of institutions<br />
separately for the two data sets, shows that MF<strong>Is</strong> decay<br />
in size faster than commercial banks. This reinforces the<br />
earlier point that while there are some spectacularly<br />
successful MF<strong>Is</strong>, these are relatively few: only 12 MF<strong>Is</strong><br />
in our sample have more than half a million depositors<br />
versus 50 in the sample of commercial banks.<br />
Figure 2, which shows the combined size rankings<br />
across both data sets, suggests that commercial banks<br />
and MF<strong>Is</strong> as a whole are roughly of comparable sizes.<br />
This is because the MFI data set selects the bigger<br />
MF<strong>Is</strong> globally, while the commercial bank data set is<br />
based on the largest ones per country. Thus, while in<br />
our sample commercial banks are typically larger than<br />
MF<strong>Is</strong>, there is a proportionately higher representation<br />
of institutions from small countries in the commercial<br />
bank data set.<br />
Figure 1: Ranking of Institutions by Number<br />
of Savers<br />
Number of savers<br />
3<br />
100,000,000<br />
10,000,000<br />
1,000,000<br />
100,000<br />
10,000<br />
1,000<br />
100<br />
10<br />
MF<strong>Is</strong><br />
Commercial banks<br />
1<br />
1 51 101 151 201<br />
Ranking of institutions by decreasing number of savers<br />
The reason is that an institution can be an MFI according to the MIX<br />
Market classification and at the same time happens to be one of the<br />
largest financial institutions in a country, which makes it eligible for<br />
the BTP dataset.<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
Scale in deposit mobilization<br />
Figures 3 and 4 depict the relationship between<br />
the overall number of savers per institution and the<br />
number of savers per branch, separately for each<br />
of the two samples. Note that the horizontal axis is<br />
mapped on a logarithmic scale in order to show a<br />
tighter distribution of the points.<br />
The median number of savers per branch is more than<br />
double for commercial banks than for MF<strong>Is</strong>: 5,400<br />
versus 2,300, respectively. Of course, the relative size of<br />
the median institution is different in both cases, with<br />
44,600 savers for MF<strong>Is</strong> and 116,000 for commercial<br />
banks. For an institution of half a million depositors,<br />
the trend lines on Figures 3 and 4 would suggest that<br />
an average MFI would have 5,300 savers per branch<br />
while an average commercial bank would have 6,400<br />
savers per branch. Thus, at that scale (as measured by<br />
number of savers), MF<strong>Is</strong> typically operate 20 percent<br />
smaller branches on average than the equivalentsized<br />
commercial bank.<br />
We can also observe that the number of savers per<br />
branch is higher the larger the number of savers,<br />
suggesting that larger deposit mobilizing institutions<br />
–whether MF<strong>Is</strong> or banks— are able to make more<br />
effective use of their branches. But there is a much<br />
stronger correlation between the number of savers<br />
and the number of savers per branch for banks than for<br />
MF<strong>Is</strong> (0.26 vs. 0.<strong>09</strong>, and only significant for commercial<br />
banks). Conversely, the total number of savers shows<br />
a higher correlation with the number of branches for<br />
MF<strong>Is</strong> than for banks (0.86 vs. 0.76, respectively).<br />
One hypothesis for this difference is that MF<strong>Is</strong><br />
are less able to realize inter-branch economies of<br />
scale (extensive growth). This might be because<br />
commercial banks incur larger bank-wide fixed<br />
Figure 2: Joint Ranking of Institutions by<br />
Number of Savers<br />
Number of savers<br />
100,000,000<br />
10,000,000<br />
1,000,000<br />
100,000<br />
10,000<br />
1,000<br />
100<br />
10<br />
1<br />
Banks<br />
MF<strong>Is</strong><br />
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450<br />
Ranking of institutions by decreasing number of savers<br />
<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
FEATURE ARTICLES<br />
Figure 3: Savers per Branch (MF<strong>Is</strong>)<br />
30,000<br />
Number of savers per branch<br />
25,000<br />
20,000<br />
15,000<br />
10,000<br />
5,000<br />
0<br />
10,000 100,000 1,000,000 10,000,000 100,000,000<br />
Number of savers<br />
Figure 4: Savers per Branch (Commercial Banks)<br />
30,000<br />
25,000<br />
Number of savers per branch<br />
20,000<br />
15,000<br />
10,000<br />
5,000<br />
0<br />
10,000 100,000 1,000,000 10,000,000 100,000,000<br />
Number of savers<br />
costs in the form of centralized investments in brand<br />
building, product development and information<br />
technology, to the benefit of all branches. Amortizing<br />
these costs over more customers and branches allows<br />
individual branches of commercial banks to be more<br />
competitive and hence acquire more customers per<br />
branch (intensive growth). On the other hand, branchlevel<br />
growth at MF<strong>Is</strong> may be more constrained due to<br />
underinvestment in IT or less streamlined processes.<br />
It is also possible that MF<strong>Is</strong> operate in smaller towns,<br />
and hence have less room for intensive growth<br />
at the branch level. This might be true for BRI and<br />
Grameen Bank, for example. However, most MF<strong>Is</strong> in<br />
the sample operate largely in urban environments<br />
and hence should face similar market size limitations<br />
as commercial banks.<br />
Next we look at how the customer mix varies with size<br />
of institution, focusing specifically on the MFI data<br />
set, for possible explanations for the different growth<br />
dynamics of large versus small MF<strong>Is</strong>. Size of MFI does<br />
not seem to have a significant bearing on the size of<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
FEATURE ARTICLES<br />
accounts and the mix between savers and borrowers.<br />
Figure 5 shows that the average savings balance per<br />
depositor (expressed as a percent of gross national<br />
income per capita) is not at all correlated with the size<br />
of the MFI. It seems like MF<strong>Is</strong> do not move upmarket as<br />
they expand their base of savers, which runs counter<br />
to the often lamented “mission drift” view. It is likely<br />
that as MF<strong>Is</strong> grow they simply need to cater to broader<br />
market segments, both richer and poorer, without a<br />
noticeable effect in the average customer size.<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
Figure 6 shows that larger MF<strong>Is</strong> have a slight proclivity<br />
to grow the number of savers faster than the number<br />
of borrowers (correlation is 0.03 and not statistically<br />
significant). This may be because, for a given location,<br />
the addressable market of savers is larger than the<br />
addressable market of creditworthy borrowers. Thus,<br />
as an institution grows its penetration in a market,<br />
it reaches saturation faster in its lending than in its<br />
deposit-taking activities. This effect may also be<br />
driven by the fact that larger institutions have a bigger<br />
Figure 5: Average Savings Account Balance as % of Gross National Income per Capita (MF<strong>Is</strong>)<br />
250<br />
200<br />
Saving balance (% of GNIpc)<br />
150<br />
100<br />
50<br />
0<br />
10,000 100,000 1,000,000 10,000,000 100,000,000<br />
Number of savers<br />
Figure 6: Ratio of Savers to Borrowers (MF<strong>Is</strong>)<br />
30<br />
25<br />
Savers/borrowers<br />
20<br />
15<br />
10<br />
5<br />
0<br />
10,000 100,000 1,000,000 10,000,000 100,000,000<br />
Number of savers<br />
<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
need to self-fund their lending activities in order to<br />
drive growth, and hence they may put more effort in<br />
building a healthy deposit base.<br />
Scale in lending operations<br />
Figures 7 and 8 show the relation between the number<br />
of borrowers per branch and the overall number of savers<br />
per institution, separately for each of the two samples.<br />
It is again apparent that MF<strong>Is</strong> used their branches less<br />
FEATURE ARTICLES<br />
intensively than commercial banks in terms of lending<br />
operations as well. In other words, as banks grow larger<br />
in the overall number of savers, their branches cater to<br />
more borrowers per branch than MF<strong>Is</strong>. In the case of<br />
MF<strong>Is</strong>, growth in total number of borrowers is largely<br />
driven by growth in number of branches rather than in<br />
the number of borrowers per branch.<br />
It is also interesting to compare between the savers<br />
and borrowers graphs. For both MF<strong>Is</strong> and commercial<br />
Figure 7: Borrowers per Branch (MF<strong>Is</strong>)<br />
8,000<br />
7,000<br />
Number of borrowers per branch<br />
6,000<br />
5,000<br />
4,000<br />
3,000<br />
2,000<br />
1,000<br />
0<br />
10,000 100,000 1,000,000 10,000,000 100,000,000<br />
Number of savers<br />
Figure 8: Borrowers per Branch (Commercial Banks)<br />
8,000<br />
7,000<br />
Number of borrowers per branch<br />
6,000<br />
5,000<br />
4,000<br />
3,000<br />
2,000<br />
1,000<br />
0<br />
10,000 100,000 1,000,000 10,000,000 100,000,000 1,000,000,000<br />
Number of savers<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
FEATURE ARTICLES<br />
banks, the slope and correlation coefficients between<br />
per branch intensity (both for savers and borrowers)<br />
and total savers numbers are significantly weaker<br />
for borrowers than for savers. This suggests that less<br />
intensity of branch use exist on the lending side<br />
than on the deposit-taking side. This makes sense:<br />
corporate-level branding and centralized treasury and<br />
risk management operations are more important for<br />
savings (since the institution needs to build the trust<br />
of depositors), while lending requires more local staff<br />
to screen, monitor and collect from borrowers.<br />
Conclusions<br />
The evidence presented in this paper points to the fact<br />
that MF<strong>Is</strong> are on average less able to grow intensively<br />
than commercial banks. MF<strong>Is</strong>’ growth is largely<br />
dependent on greater distribution (more branches)<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
rather than at leveraging the use of branches. The<br />
evidence also supports the well established notion<br />
that the potential for intensive use is larger on the<br />
deposit mobilization than the lending side. On the<br />
other hand, we do not see a significant relationship<br />
between the size of an MFI (as measured by number<br />
of clients) and either the average savings balance or<br />
the ratio of savers to borrowers. It seems that MF<strong>Is</strong><br />
do not move upmarket as they expand their base of<br />
savers, which runs counter to the argument that those<br />
institutions experience a “mission drift” over time.<br />
If distribution (extensive growth) is the key growth<br />
driver for MF<strong>Is</strong>, it is important to find lower-cost ways<br />
for MF<strong>Is</strong> to deploy their physical presence. Lower-cost<br />
branches and branchless banking channels would<br />
seem to offer large opportunities for MF<strong>Is</strong> to grow<br />
scalably.<br />
<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
FEATURE ARTICLES<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
Saving Through the Mobile Phone—<br />
The Case of M-PESA<br />
Olga Morawczynski, University of Edinburgh 1<br />
In the past few years there have been attempts to<br />
mobilize savings via branchless banking models in<br />
general and the mobile phone in particular. There is a<br />
recognition that savings, probably more than any other<br />
financial service, requires proximity and immediacy<br />
for the customer. There is also the recognition that<br />
savings could radically improve livelihoods. Access<br />
to appropriate savings mechanisms could help<br />
the resource poor to recover from shocks, smooth<br />
consumption and broaden investment opportunities.<br />
Much of this recent interest towards savings via the<br />
mobile phone has been sparked by the stunning<br />
success of a Kenyan mobile money service called M-<br />
PESA. M-PESA is a mobile phone based service for<br />
sending and storing money, offered by Safaricom,<br />
Kenya’s largest mobile service provider. Safaricom<br />
customers can register for M-PESA by visiting a<br />
merchant who acts as an “agent” for account opening,<br />
handling of deposits and withdrawals into the<br />
Figure 1: Use of savings instruments in Kenya<br />
100%<br />
80%<br />
60%<br />
40%<br />
20%<br />
0%<br />
Bank account Mattress M-PESA<br />
Source: FSD-Kenya.<br />
How Do People Save<br />
Savings instrument by M-PESA user<br />
M-PESA users<br />
Non-users<br />
Total<br />
Other<br />
1 I would like to thank Ignacio Mas for his substantial contribution<br />
to this paper. Also, many thanks to Microsoft Research and<br />
the University of Edinburgh for funding this research.<br />
customer’s virtual “wallet,” and customer support.<br />
Customers can then use an application on their<br />
mobile phone to check their balance, send money to<br />
other people, pay bills and purchase mobile phone<br />
airtime. Customer funds are held in a special trust<br />
account at the Commercial Bank of Africa. This service<br />
has acquired over 7 million users and extended its<br />
agent base to over 10,000 since it was introduced in<br />
March of 2007.<br />
Although M-PESA was designed as a money transfer<br />
service, there is evidence that it is also being used for<br />
savings. For example, a study funded by FSD-Kenya of<br />
over 3000 households in Kenya revealed that users<br />
were storing money in M-PESA. The research also<br />
revealed that M-PESA was one of the most popular<br />
mechanisms for savings amongst the sample, even<br />
beating out the mattress for M-PESA users. These<br />
results raise some interesting questions. In particular,<br />
why did M-PESA beat out the mattress and other<br />
popular savings mechanisms <strong>Is</strong> M-PESA becoming a<br />
substitute for these other mechanisms How are the<br />
savings patterns of the poor changing as they begin<br />
to store money with M-PESA<br />
This paper will address these questions. It uses data from<br />
a collection of financial diaries to make its arguments.<br />
These diaries captured the savings practices of 14<br />
M-PESA users for a period of one month. They were<br />
part of a 14 month ethnographic study that examined<br />
the adoption, usage and impact of M-PESA in two<br />
locations: an urban slum and a rural village. The paper<br />
will also use the empirical data to suggest how mobile<br />
money applications can be designed to better suit the<br />
needs and interests of poor savers.<br />
Evidence from the Financial<br />
Diaries of M-PESA Users in<br />
Kenya<br />
The financial diaries participants were asked to make<br />
daily entries detailing their financial practices for the<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
FEATURE ARTICLES<br />
period of one month. These entries were made in<br />
two columns—money in and money out. They were<br />
also asked to maintain a balance in the two columns.<br />
This facilitated the analysis of not only expenditure<br />
but also savings patterns. It must be noted that the<br />
majority of the financial diaries participants were<br />
frequent users. These users made several transactions<br />
per week. Some even conducted transactions on a<br />
daily basis. The results presented here thus represent<br />
more intensive usage patterns than usual. The<br />
data from the financial diaries will be used to<br />
substantiate many of the arguments presented here.<br />
Table 1 provides more information about the<br />
participants.<br />
The Findings<br />
A variety of savings mechanisms<br />
were integrated into the savings<br />
portfolios of the participants<br />
The diaries revealed that the poor use a combination<br />
of savings mechanisms to manage their limited<br />
income and to meet their unique savings needs. The<br />
average amount of savings mechanisms used by the<br />
participants for the storage of cash was just over two.<br />
The findings further illustrated that the poor were very<br />
strategic when cultivating their savings portfolios. The<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
mechanisms included usually acted as complements<br />
to the others. As will be shown below, most of the<br />
participants who were banked continued to store<br />
money at home. These home savings were more<br />
accessible, and were often used for daily consumption.<br />
The bank was appropriate for the accumulation of<br />
savings over time. This facilitated the purchase of<br />
future items, usually of greater value. It also provided<br />
the participants with an accumulated amount,<br />
which could be accessed during an emergency.<br />
Table 2 presents the advantages and disadvantages<br />
of the savings mechanisms that were available to<br />
Kenyans.<br />
Many appropriated these various mechanisms to keep<br />
track of their finances. For example, John used four<br />
mechanisms to store his cash. This includes an MFI<br />
account, a bank account, M-PESA and the home bank.<br />
For John, each of these accounts served a different<br />
function and provided him with some type of benefit.<br />
For example, the home bank allowed John to have<br />
immediate access to his cash. The bank gave him a<br />
place where he could save cash for larger purchases.<br />
M-PESA facilitated the separation of John’s business<br />
and personal finances. He explained that this made<br />
it easier for him to organize and “keep track” of his<br />
finances.<br />
Some of the informants also appropriated more than<br />
one mechanism to “spread out” their finances and<br />
Table 1<br />
Financial diaries participants<br />
Name Location Job M-PESA User/<br />
Non user<br />
Relation to Diary<br />
Participant<br />
Wyclif Urban- Kibera Barber Non User-sender Married to Eunice<br />
Eunice Rural- Chamarmar Farm work, fetch water Non user Married to Wyclif<br />
Lawrence Urban-Kibera Painter User-sender<br />
Brown Urban-Kibera Security guard User-sender Married to Betty<br />
Betty Rural-Bukura Sold goods from farm User-recipient Married to Brown<br />
Violet Rural-Bukura Not working User-recipient Betty’s friend<br />
Gaudezina<br />
Rural-Shangalangwi<br />
(near Bukura)<br />
Sold goods from farm User-recipient Betty’s Mother<br />
John Urban-Kibera Security guard and shop owner User-sender<br />
Sylvester Urban-Kibera Security guard and shop owner User-sender Married to Elizabeth<br />
Elizabeth Rural-Sikarira Sold goods on market-table<br />
cloth etc.<br />
User-recipient<br />
Married to Sylvester<br />
Martin Urban-Kibera Shoe repair User-sender Married to Margaret<br />
Margaret Rural-Masiro Sold goods from farm User-recipient Married to Martin<br />
Joyce Urban-Kibera Shop owner User-recipient<br />
Patrik Urban-Kibera Pastor User-sender and<br />
recipient<br />
<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
FEATURE ARTICLES<br />
Table 2 The savings portfolio of low-income Kenyans<br />
Savings mechanism Advantages Disadvantages<br />
Home bank - Free to transact and highly<br />
accessible<br />
ROSCA - Allows for the rapid accumulation<br />
of funds<br />
- Support to save is provided from<br />
other community members<br />
Bank - Secure method of savings<br />
- Interest provided on savings<br />
- Potential for credit<br />
M-PESA - Free to deposit and store money<br />
- Highly accessible<br />
- Secure-customer ID and PIN is<br />
needed to access money<br />
In-kind - Material interest gained on some<br />
forms of material savings (i.e. Egg,<br />
milk)<br />
- Risky-money stored in the home can be stolen by<br />
household members or outsiders<br />
- No interest is gained on the money stored at home<br />
- Risky-money can be lost if group dissolves<br />
- Time consuming-regular meetings are often required<br />
by group members<br />
- High transaction and maintenance fees<br />
- Difficult to access, especially in rural areas<br />
- No interest on money stored<br />
- Cash shortages in rural areas can sometimes make it<br />
difficult to withdraw money<br />
- Not regulated as a savings mechanism, thus funds of<br />
customer are not protected<br />
- Maintenance fees sometimes required (i.e. animal feed)<br />
- Low liquidity on some material savings<br />
- Potential loss of value over time<br />
to avoid the risk of money being lost. For example,<br />
Sylvester kept money in both M-PESA and the bank.<br />
After he was paid his salary, he would withdraw<br />
a substantial amount from the bank and would<br />
deposit the money into his M-PESA account. Sylvester<br />
explained that he did not fully trust the banks in Kenya<br />
with his money. He had heard “stories” that his savings<br />
would be lost if the bank crashed. Sylvester was not<br />
alone in his distrust of banks. Many other informants<br />
confirmed this finding during the fieldwork.<br />
This distrust was especially common prior to the<br />
presidential elections of <strong>Dec</strong>ember 2007. This period<br />
was characterized by heightened tensions between<br />
ethnic communities within the informal settlement.<br />
Informants took a variety of measures to protect their<br />
cash during the period. Some claimed that they took<br />
most, and sometimes all, of their savings from the<br />
banks and deposited the money into M-PESA and<br />
their home bank. They explained that they reduced<br />
the risk of money being lost by spreading out their<br />
savings.<br />
In urban areas, M-PESA and the<br />
home bank were the most popular<br />
savings mechanisms<br />
There were some substantial differences between<br />
financial portfolios in urban centres and rural areas. In<br />
Kibera, the most widely used mechanism for savings<br />
was M-PESA as well as the home bank. Many of those<br />
informants who had a steady flow of income also<br />
had an account with a formal bank or MFI. However,<br />
because there were no formal financial institutions<br />
within Kibera, the residents had to leave the<br />
informal settlement to transact. Many noted that this<br />
was a significant disadvantage of having such an<br />
account.<br />
In regards to frequency of transactions, the home bank<br />
was the most popular. All of the urban participants<br />
kept some money in their home savings and many<br />
would make daily deposits and withdrawals. Most<br />
often, the money was used to purchase items for<br />
household consumption around Kibera. Lawrence<br />
kept nearly half of his income at home because it was<br />
easily accessible. He did not need to leave Kibera to<br />
transact. When asked whether he was afraid of losing<br />
money stored in the home, he said no. He explained<br />
that he had “hidden the money well” and did not “fear”<br />
theft by intruders.<br />
Although the number of transactions was higher<br />
for the home bank, the value stored was lower than<br />
M-PESA. The diaries revealed that an average of 4<br />
percent of total income was deposited into home<br />
savings. This compares to nearly 18 percent that<br />
was put into M-PESA. Two of the financial diaries<br />
participants, Martin and Sylvester, stored nearly<br />
half of their income inflows with M-PESA. Both men<br />
asserted that they preferred this method because it<br />
was “safer” than the other savings mechanisms.<br />
John and Joyce also saved with M-PESA. However, they<br />
deposited a much smaller percentage of their income<br />
into their M-PESA accounts. Joyce explained that she<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
FEATURE ARTICLES<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
Figure 2: Savings portfolio of urban diarists<br />
60%<br />
% of income deposited into savings mechanism<br />
50%<br />
40%<br />
30%<br />
20%<br />
10%<br />
0%<br />
John<br />
Sylvesta<br />
Martin<br />
Joyce<br />
Wyclif<br />
Lawrence<br />
Brown<br />
Patrik<br />
Bank<br />
Home savings<br />
ROSCA<br />
M-PESA<br />
preferred to invest her cash in her small business. She<br />
would often maintain low balances in all of her savings<br />
mechanisms. She explained that money stored at<br />
home was at risk of being stolen by her husband who<br />
was often thirsty for changa [local brew]. She did not<br />
keep too much in her bank account because interest<br />
rates were low. The balance in her M-PESA account was<br />
the highest. She explained that she used this money<br />
for daily consumption and the “upkeep” of her rural<br />
relatives. Because an M-PESA agent was located close<br />
to her home, Joyce was able to accumulate money<br />
through weekly deposits. She would remit the money<br />
when she met her savings target for the month. The<br />
cash that was left over at month end would be used<br />
for home consumption. For John the balance was kept<br />
low because, as mentioned above, M-PESA was just<br />
one of several mechanisms he used for savings.<br />
Four of the urban participants did not use M-PESA for<br />
savings. Wyclif and Lawrence did not know that M-<br />
PESA could be used for this purpose. As was mentioned<br />
above, M-PESA was not designed or regulated as a<br />
savings mechanism. This is why Safaricom, the mobile<br />
service provider, never advertised this option. Those<br />
who used M-PESA for savings discovered this function<br />
on their own, or heard about it from friends. Brown<br />
and Patrik said that they knew M-PESA could be used<br />
for savings, but had no use for this mechanism. Their<br />
existing portfolio of savings mechanisms was enough<br />
to meet their needs.<br />
Some of the urban informants kept a bank account.<br />
Usually, they used the bank to accumulate money<br />
for future expenses. Many also wanted to build a<br />
relationship with the financial institution to access<br />
credit in the future. There were informants who<br />
explained that they did not keep an account by choice;<br />
rather, they had their salaries deposited directly. They<br />
explained that banks were too expensive and that fees<br />
were “eating up” their savings. Numerous informants<br />
wanted their salaries deposited directly into M-PESA.<br />
They explained that they took a risk each time they<br />
carried money from the bank, which was located<br />
outside of Kibera, to their homes.<br />
In rural areas, many preferred to<br />
keep their money in circulation<br />
rather than saving their cash<br />
In the villages, the home bank was the most popular<br />
mechanism for savings. On average, 32 percent of rural<br />
household income was deposited into the home bank.<br />
Many preferred this method because it was accessible.<br />
The majority of banks and MF<strong>Is</strong> were located in the<br />
closest town, which was more than 20 km away. Many<br />
of the rural dwellers noted that this was too far to travel.<br />
They also explained that the banks only catered to the<br />
“rich”. The monthly fees and transaction costs were too<br />
high and would quickly wipe out their “small money”.<br />
ROSCAs (rotating savings and credit associations), also<br />
known as merry-go-rounds, were also popular in the<br />
villages. Four out of the six rural women were involved<br />
in a merry-go-round. However, only 2 percent of rural<br />
inflows were stored in this mechanism. When asked<br />
why so little was stored, some of the rural respondents<br />
said that they were part of the merry go round for<br />
social, rather than, financial reasons. They enjoyed the<br />
weekly meetings with the group during which they<br />
10<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
would catch up on the village happenings. Others also<br />
made clear that these groups “forced” them to save.<br />
They were less likely to accumulate cash if they “saved<br />
alone”. Group savings, however, were also somewhat<br />
risky. Both Betty and Elizabeth had lost money when<br />
previous groups disbanded without warning. Betty<br />
explained that because of such risk, it is best to keep<br />
smaller amounts in the merry go round. It is also better<br />
to have “back-up” savings in other mechanisms such<br />
as the home bank.<br />
None of the rural participants used M-PESA for savings.<br />
Again, most did not know that M-PESA could be used<br />
for this purpose. Those who did know claimed that<br />
the application was not suitable for savings. They<br />
noted frequent cash shortages in rural areas, and were<br />
concerned that money saved with M-PESA would be<br />
difficult to access. Because the majority of the M-PESA<br />
transactions in rural areas were withdrawals, agents<br />
often ran out of cash float. Some would maintain this<br />
float by making regular trips to the bank to “top up”.<br />
Others, however, found such maintenance too costly<br />
and time consuming. They instead chose to top up their<br />
float sporadically. This resulted in cash shortages.<br />
Because accessibility to cash was vitally important for<br />
the rural dwellers, the home bank was one of the most<br />
popular savings mechanisms. As is shown in Figure 3,<br />
all of the rural participants stored their money at home.<br />
These rural respondents further expressed a need for<br />
an affordable and accessible savings mechanism. As<br />
in the urban areas, they wanted to remove their cash<br />
from the household economy where it was prone to<br />
demands of relatives and neighbours.<br />
Table 3<br />
FEATURE ARTICLES<br />
Number of transactions per<br />
savings mechanism for M-PESA<br />
users<br />
M-PESA Bank Home ROSCA<br />
John 18 13 15 6<br />
Sylvester 25 17 0 31<br />
Martin 6 0 24 9<br />
Joyce 4 3 32 4<br />
Total 53 33 71 50<br />
Mean 13 8 18 13<br />
Median 16 8 20 8<br />
M-PESA acted as a complement,<br />
rather than substitute, for many of<br />
the other mechanisms in the savings<br />
portfolio<br />
For the participants who used M-PESA for savings,<br />
an interesting trend was noted. The application<br />
acted as a complement, rather than a substitute, to<br />
these other mechanisms. It was used in conjunction<br />
with the bank, home bank and ROSCA. M-PESA had<br />
a vital place in the savings portfolio of the poor<br />
informants—somewhere between the bank and the<br />
home bank. Unlike the bank, M-PESA was appropriate<br />
for the accumulation of small savings. There were no<br />
fees to deposit money or to maintain the account.<br />
The application was also more accessible than the<br />
bank. Those living in Kibera did not need to leave<br />
the informal settlement to make deposits or access<br />
Figure 3: Savings portfolio of rural diarists<br />
80%<br />
% of income deposited into savings mechanism<br />
70%<br />
60%<br />
50%<br />
40%<br />
30%<br />
20%<br />
10%<br />
Bank<br />
Home savings<br />
ROSCA<br />
M-PESA<br />
0%<br />
Betty<br />
Elizabeth<br />
Violet<br />
Gaudezina<br />
Margaret<br />
Eunice<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
11
FEATURE ARTICLES<br />
their cash. They could also check their balance, at any<br />
time, using their mobile phone. Because M-PESA was<br />
accessible, it was used more often than the bank and<br />
ROSCA as is shown in Table 3. In some cases, deposits<br />
and withdrawals were made nearly every day.<br />
Many also noted that M-PESA was safer than the<br />
other mechanisms. Safaricom was less likely than<br />
the bank to crash. Money stored with M-PESA could<br />
also not be stolen by a husband who was thirsty<br />
for changa [local brew]. The application was further<br />
used to organize cash. For example, John used<br />
M-PESA to separate his business from his personal<br />
savings. Joyce used the application to accumulate<br />
money that would be sent to her rural relatives. Once<br />
M-PESA became integrated into the savings portfolio<br />
of the poor, there was a re-balancing of amounts<br />
in each of the savings mechanisms. For example,<br />
Martin began to store more in M-PESA and less in his<br />
home bank. Sylvester took a balance from his bank<br />
account and kept it with M-PESA. As mentioned above,<br />
many wanted to spread out their cash to decrease<br />
the risk of it being lost if one of the mechanisms<br />
failed.<br />
It must be noted that M-PESA had some disadvantages<br />
as a savings mechanism. As was explained by John, it<br />
was not appropriate for “big savings”. Interest was not<br />
paid on the money stored. Loans could also be acquired<br />
from Safaricom. M-PESA was also dependent on the<br />
Safaricom network. Thus, when there were network<br />
issues money could not be accessed. This happened<br />
several times throughout the course of the fieldwork.<br />
Many informants explained that this dissuaded them<br />
from keeping larger amounts in M-PESA. Also, as<br />
mentioned above, many did not use M-PESA for savings<br />
in the rural areas because of frequent cash shortages.<br />
They instead chose to keep cash at home where it<br />
was accessible. John explained that unlike M-PESA, his<br />
home bank “never closed”. Furthermore, money stored<br />
in M-PESA was not adequately protected. The service<br />
was not regulated by the Central Bank of Kenya. This<br />
was mainly because M-PESA was never designed to<br />
be a savings mechanism.<br />
Safaricom can take various measures to improve<br />
the current M-PESA savings value proposition. In<br />
particular, there is the opportunity for M-PESA to be<br />
more than just a mechanism in the savings portfolio.<br />
The application can become the platform from which<br />
the entire portfolio of mechanisms can be accessed.<br />
This would provide poor savers with a centralized<br />
savings base on which they could accumulate, track,<br />
and manage, their small savings. It would also allow<br />
them to work with two forms of currency when<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
organizing their finances—cash and electronic<br />
value. The latter would be advantageous because it<br />
would facilitate the movement of value across the<br />
numerous accounts. As was shown in the empirical<br />
findings, such movement has significant costs (time<br />
and money). The electronic value would also render<br />
wealth invisible, which would make it less prone to<br />
demands from friends and family. However, before<br />
M-PESA becomes a platform for savings, the system<br />
design needs to be altered and new partnerships<br />
must be cultivated.<br />
<strong>Is</strong>suance of M-PESA accounts by<br />
banks or third parties<br />
For M-PESA to become a centralized base for savings<br />
services, the opening and maintenance of accounts<br />
would have to be outsourced. This would allow banks<br />
and MF<strong>Is</strong> to tap into the M-PESA platform and offer<br />
services at scale. It would also provide customers<br />
with new opportunities to generate interest on their<br />
savings. Currently, M-PESA accounts are issued by<br />
Safaricom and thus not subject to full prudential<br />
scrutiny by bank supervisory authorities. It puts<br />
M-PESA in an unstable regulatory position, which<br />
prevents Safaricom from benefiting financially from<br />
the interest on float held. It further precludes Safaricom<br />
from paying interest on balances held, or promoting<br />
M-PESA as a savings service for fear of incurring<br />
more regulation. If accounts were formally issued in<br />
the name of a bank, or other financial institution, the<br />
arrangement would be regulatorily more sustainable<br />
as funds held in M-PESA would have the necessary<br />
prudential protections.<br />
No change to the design, operation or branding of the<br />
service would be required. Customer contracts would<br />
be issued by the bank but processed by Safaricom,<br />
in the same way as it processes contracts today.<br />
Safaricom would continue transferring all stored<br />
funds through M-PESA with the chosen bank, but now<br />
they would be stored on behalf of the M-PESA clients,<br />
not on behalf of M-PESA itself. Safaricom would still<br />
operate all individual accounts, and their collective<br />
value would be registered as a single line (pooled<br />
deposit account or account payable) in its ledger.<br />
This would be following the Smart Money model in<br />
the Philippines, where the service is operated and<br />
branded by mobile operator Smart Communications<br />
but the mobile wallet accounts are issued in the name<br />
of bank partner Banco de Oro. To make this possible,<br />
the Central Bank of Kenya would need to permit a<br />
high degree of outsourcing of bank operations to a<br />
non-bank.<br />
12<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
The customers would benefit from this arrangement.<br />
They would be able to access a multitude of savings<br />
accounts, from different institutions, via their mobile<br />
phone. The value of M-PESA as a savings platform<br />
would also grow exponentially as more institutions<br />
use it to offer their savings products.<br />
Creating savings sub-accounts<br />
Once M-PESA becomes a centralized savings base it<br />
could provide a link between people’s goals and their<br />
savings by compartmentalizing these savings into a<br />
system of sub-accounts. Each of these would have a<br />
pre-defined purpose. When making a deposit, the agent<br />
would ask customers if they had a special purpose for<br />
the funds. If so, the agent would select the appropriate<br />
item from a limited set of pre-defined options on<br />
the M-PESA menu (home savings, school fees, house<br />
repairs, funeral, remittances, etc.) when requesting<br />
authorization for the deposit. These options could<br />
be based on the most common savings objectives<br />
according to local research. It would also be possible<br />
for customers to pre-define their own objectives. When<br />
customers check balances through their mobile, their<br />
balance would be itemized by saving purpose (i.e. by<br />
sub-account). When making withdrawals or payments,<br />
customers would be able to select which sub-account<br />
to withdraw from. A ROSCA account could also be<br />
integrated. This could eliminate the need for cash<br />
exchanges at the meetings. The pay-out could also be<br />
provided in electronic value, rather than cash.<br />
M-PESA could also facilitate the movement of funds<br />
between these various accounts. For example, the payout<br />
from the ROSCA could be immediately deposited<br />
into the school fees account. A remittance transfer<br />
made into the M-PESA wallet could also be moved into<br />
the account that is allocated to daily consumption.<br />
This could eliminate the need to physically move the<br />
money between the different mechanisms. It would<br />
also allow the poor to more easily diversify their savings<br />
base by the appropriation of various mechanisms and,<br />
in effect, spread out their risk. Disciplinary techniques<br />
could also be integrated into the system. For example,<br />
a text message could be sent to remind a saver who is<br />
accumulating cash that a deposit is due. Mechanisms<br />
that deter withdrawals on some accounts can also be<br />
incorporated. These could be in the form of higher<br />
withdrawal fees. They could also be in the form of time<br />
restrictions on withdrawals.<br />
Enabling micro-transactions<br />
The lowest amount that can currently be deposited<br />
into M-PESA is 100 KES (equal to less than 1 euro).<br />
FEATURE ARTICLES<br />
This makes it more difficult for M-PESA to be<br />
used for the accumulation of “small savings”. This<br />
is where the home bank, without any minimum<br />
deposit stipulations, has a significant advantage. By<br />
lowering this minimum deposit amount to around<br />
10 KES, M-PESA could encourage poor savers to<br />
make more frequent deposits into the system. This<br />
would remove money from the household economy,<br />
where it is vulnerable to theft and demands from<br />
relatives.<br />
Managing liquidity<br />
If M-PESA is be used as a tool for the mobilization<br />
of savings, one of the greatest challenges for<br />
Safaricom would be to ensure the liquidity of M-<br />
PESA accounts. As was mentioned in the empirical<br />
findings, many rural dwellers did not use M-PESA<br />
for savings because of the frequent cash shortages.<br />
One strategy that could be taken to manage cash<br />
float is to increase the number of rural deposits.<br />
This could only be done by finding ways in which<br />
M-PESA could beat out the home bank as a savings<br />
mechanism. Facilitating access to accounts offering<br />
interest, and future loans, would be a good start.<br />
Banks could also work with Safaricom to help with<br />
liquidity management in rural areas. It is in their<br />
interest to ensure cash is readily available not only<br />
to keep customers happy but also to increase the<br />
number of transactions going through the system.<br />
As was made clear above, banks had the lowest<br />
number of transactions amongst the numerous<br />
savings mechanisms.<br />
Conclusion<br />
The empirical findings showed that the poor use a<br />
variety of mechanisms to meet their unique savings<br />
needs. These are combined into a savings portfolio, in<br />
which each of the mechanisms acts as complement to<br />
the others. M-PESA has a vital role in this portfolio—<br />
somewhere between the bank and home bank. It is<br />
more accessible and cheaper than the bank. It also<br />
provides additional security to savers by removing<br />
the money from the home and rendering wealth<br />
invisible.<br />
The paper further suggested that M-PESA can have<br />
a much greater role in the mobilization of savings.<br />
Rather than just being a mechanism in the financial<br />
portfolio, it can provide a platform on which various<br />
savings mechanisms can be accessed. This is especially<br />
the case because it utilizes a new form of value—<br />
mobile money (or electronic money, more broadly).<br />
This new form of value would make it easier for savers<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
13
FEATURE ARTICLES<br />
to organize, and keep track of, their various accounts.<br />
Rather than going from one mechanism to the next to<br />
check balances and make deposits and withdrawals,<br />
all the accounts would be centralized and made<br />
accessible via the mobile. It would also make it easier<br />
to move money between accounts. Accumulated<br />
amounts could be moved to a bank account to<br />
accrue interest; money in the bank could be moved<br />
to M-PESA for daily consumption. Mechanisms could<br />
also be built in to instil discipline. For example, a user<br />
accumulating cash could be sent a text message each<br />
time a payment is due. The user could immediately<br />
move value from one account to the next in reaction<br />
to this electronic reminder.<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
There are thus endless possibilities for the formalization<br />
and mobilization of savings with the mobile phone as<br />
a platform. Savings services can further replicate the<br />
experience of mobile payments. The frequency of<br />
savings transactions will most likely increase whilst<br />
the value per transaction will fall. However, before<br />
such mobilization occurs several measures must be<br />
taken. In particular, Safaricom should strengthen the<br />
reliability of the technical platform and the liquidity<br />
options of users. They should further increase the<br />
flexibility of the system. This will provide the resource<br />
poor with more opportunities to save. It will also<br />
make it easier for this segment to constitute savings<br />
portfolios that meet their unique needs.<br />
14<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
FEATURE ARTICLES<br />
FEATURE ARTICLES<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
The Case for Pricing Transparency<br />
Jessica A. Haeussler<br />
Introduction<br />
After decades of innovation and experimentation,<br />
microfinance sectors worldwide have achieved<br />
impressive successes. The microfinance community<br />
has joined efforts to achieve worldwide public<br />
recognition of microfinance as an effective and<br />
sustainable bottom-up approach to economic<br />
empowerment and consumption smoothing.<br />
The past years have seen equally strong efforts to<br />
provide a business case for microfinance, attract<br />
investors and access the global capital markets.<br />
As a result, the global microfinance industry has<br />
achieved a considerable record of transparency on<br />
financial performance. The true price of microcredit<br />
products, however, has never been accurately<br />
reported. As a double-bottom line industry that<br />
emerged to provide a low-cost alternative to the<br />
moneylenders, microfinance today is an industry<br />
where non-transparent pricing is common. Yet<br />
pricing transparency is critical in the marketbased<br />
economy, as it promotes efficiency, healthy<br />
competition, innovation and affordable prices<br />
for millions of clients. For financial markets to<br />
develop sustainably and prosper, transparency is<br />
indispensable.<br />
The financial crisis that has caused the collapse of<br />
the global financial system is a prime example for<br />
market failure and dramatically illustrates that nontransparency<br />
is a major market imperfection. The<br />
current crisis is the result of a lack of transparency,<br />
adverse incentive structures and inadequate<br />
competition. It underscores that bad practices can<br />
harm clients, responsible lenders, the entire financial<br />
system and the overall economy. While at the core of<br />
microfinance have been principles that could serve as<br />
an example for Wall Street, the rapid mainstreaming<br />
of microfinance makes the lessons learnt from the<br />
credit crunch ever more relevant. The collapse of<br />
the global financial system underscores the farreaching<br />
risks associated with non-transparency and<br />
offers an opportunity to reflect upon the principles<br />
of responsible finance and build a solid foundation<br />
for the sustainable and healthy development of<br />
microfinance sectors worldwide.<br />
The controversial debate on interest rates in<br />
microfinance has attracted the attention of the<br />
global community, governments, donors and<br />
investors in recent years, while the public media has<br />
often misreported on the interest rates charged in<br />
microfinance, without providing an explanation of why<br />
interest rates vary significantly among MF<strong>Is</strong>. In some<br />
markets, this has led to a political backlash resulting<br />
in counterproductive government intervention with<br />
lasting ramifications for the development of local<br />
microfinance sectors. This is particularly disturbing<br />
where governments react on negative public<br />
sentiment and intervene without understanding the<br />
implications for sustainable market developments,<br />
which is reinforced by an opaque pricing environment<br />
making it impossible to draw a line between<br />
responsible and irresponsible lending.<br />
This article highlights the importance of pricing<br />
transparency for the market-based economy,<br />
examines the consequences of non-transparent<br />
pricing based on an analysis of industry data and<br />
evaluates approaches to pricing transparency at<br />
the government and industry level. The author<br />
would like to gratefully acknowledge the support of<br />
MFTransparency.<br />
Pricing in Microfinance<br />
As the goal of MF<strong>Is</strong> is to provide financial services to<br />
micro-entrepreneurs and low-income households<br />
on a sustainable basis, the interest rates charged<br />
on microloan products have to cover operating<br />
expenses, the cost of capital, loan loss provisions and<br />
a provision for growth. While the financial cost and<br />
loan loss provision tend to be relatively flat or the<br />
same percentage irrespective of loan size, operating<br />
expenses expressed as a percentage of the average<br />
outstanding loan balance increase significantly as<br />
15 Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
15
FEATURE ARTICLES<br />
the loan amount decreases. Given this reality, pricing<br />
differentiation according to loan size is essential in<br />
microfinance. Because there is not one interest rate<br />
for every microfinance loan due to varying loan<br />
amounts, pricing transparency has been difficult to<br />
achieve.<br />
The correlation between operating expenses and<br />
loan size based on the most recent industry data<br />
from MIX Market for MF<strong>Is</strong> in Peru is displayed in<br />
Figure 1. It clearly shows that operating expenses<br />
vary significantly according to loan size. The precise<br />
operating cost curve differs across regions and<br />
countries due to the unique economic conditions of<br />
each country, but the shape of the curve is essentially<br />
the same for microfinance sectors worldwide.<br />
Figure 2 shows portfolio yield relative to loan size and<br />
as would be expected, the shape of the yield curve<br />
closely follows that of the operating expense ratio.<br />
The majority of MF<strong>Is</strong> included in this analysis appears<br />
to be generating yields within the average range of<br />
the Peruvian market, as displayed by the curve. It is<br />
interesting to note that disclosure of effective interest<br />
rates is required for regulated MF<strong>Is</strong> in Peru.<br />
A major reason for non-transparent pricing in<br />
microfinance has been the difficulty of making<br />
the public understand why MF<strong>Is</strong> charge a range<br />
of interest rates on seemingly similar microloan<br />
products. Inaccurate and inconsistent reporting of<br />
loan prices has been a significant factor undermining<br />
transparency in the microfinance industry. It is<br />
important to recognize that there is no single market<br />
interest rate for microloan products. MF<strong>Is</strong> often offer<br />
different types of loan products which – depending on<br />
factors such as product use, loan size and geographic<br />
locations – have to be priced differently.<br />
Figure 1: Loan Size and Operating Expense<br />
Ratio<br />
Operating Expense Ratio (%)<br />
50%<br />
40%<br />
30%<br />
20%<br />
10%<br />
0%<br />
(57) MF<strong>Is</strong> in Peru<br />
0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000<br />
Average Loan Balance per Borrower (USD)<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
Figure 2: Loan Size and Real Portfolio Yield<br />
Real Yield on Gross Portfolio (%)<br />
70%<br />
60%<br />
50%<br />
40%<br />
30%<br />
20%<br />
10%<br />
0%<br />
0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000<br />
The Consequences of<br />
Non-Transparent Pricing<br />
The following analysis of industry data for the Mexican<br />
microfinance sector aims to examine the ramifications<br />
of non-transparent pricing.<br />
Hypothesis 1:<br />
When product pricing is non-transparent,<br />
institutions survive in the market despite<br />
inefficiencies, as they can pass on the higher<br />
costs to their clients.<br />
Figure 3 shows the correlation of loan size and<br />
operating expenses based on the most recent MIX<br />
industry data for the Mexican sector. An analysis of<br />
efficiency for Mexican MF<strong>Is</strong> suggests that several MF<strong>Is</strong><br />
are less efficient than the market average in a given<br />
loan-size category. As the size of the bubbles indicates,<br />
some of these inefficient institutions have a relatively<br />
large number of clients. They seem to attract clients<br />
and grow despite inefficiencies, while a number of<br />
efficient institutions are small in scale.<br />
The high yields, as represented by the size of the<br />
bubbles in Figure 4, of those MF<strong>Is</strong> with an operating<br />
expense ratio above the country-specific average<br />
curve suggest that inefficient institutions may<br />
compensate for the higher costs associated with<br />
inefficiencies by raising prices and passing these costs<br />
on to the clients.<br />
Hypothesis 2:<br />
(57) MF<strong>Is</strong> in Peru<br />
Average Loan Balance per Borrower (USD)<br />
When pricing is non-transparent, some<br />
institutions can generate exceptionally high<br />
profits by charging prices above market rates.<br />
16<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
FEATURE ARTICLES<br />
Figure 3: Scale and Efficiency<br />
180%<br />
160%<br />
852<br />
30 MF<strong>Is</strong> in Mexico with Microenterprise Loans > 80% of Loan Product<br />
140%<br />
Operating Expense Ratio (%)<br />
120%<br />
100%<br />
80%<br />
60%<br />
40%<br />
12,311<br />
38,981<br />
148,733<br />
58,5<strong>09</strong><br />
20%<br />
0%<br />
0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400<br />
Average Loan Balance per Borrower (USD)<br />
Bubble size - Number of Active Borrowers<br />
Figure 4: Loan Size, Operating Expense Ratio and Real Portfolio Yield<br />
30 MF<strong>Is</strong> in Mexico with Microenterprise Loans > 80% of Loan Product<br />
Operating Expense Ratio (%)<br />
200%<br />
180%<br />
160%<br />
140%<br />
120%<br />
100%<br />
80%<br />
60%<br />
40%<br />
20%<br />
0%<br />
87%<br />
82% 86%<br />
95% 110%<br />
99%<br />
78%<br />
81%<br />
86%<br />
0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400<br />
Average Loan Balance per Borrower (USD)<br />
Bubble size - Real Portfolio Yield<br />
The correlation between loan size and portfolio yield<br />
for the Mexican market is displayed in Figure 5. The<br />
yields on gross portfolio of all MF<strong>Is</strong> reporting to the<br />
Microfinance Information Exchange, Inc. (MIX) are<br />
now available on MIX Market, which is an excellent<br />
advance. Portfolio yield offers a proxy for interest<br />
rates, although it does not consider differentiated<br />
pricing and only provides an average for the gross<br />
loan portfolio. For this reason, the present analysis<br />
only includes those MF<strong>Is</strong> whose microenterprise<br />
loans make up more than 80 percent of all products<br />
offered. As there is still little product differentiation in<br />
Mexico as compared to other microfinance sectors in<br />
Latin America and the Caribbean, the portfolio yield<br />
provided in Figure 5 offers a reasonable proxy for<br />
interest rates charged.<br />
Figure 5 reveals a wide range of yields on similarlysized<br />
loan products. Several MF<strong>Is</strong> generate yields<br />
above the market average in a given loan-size<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
17
FEATURE ARTICLES<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
Figure 5: Loan Size, Portfolio Yield, Number of Active Borrowers<br />
120%<br />
38,981<br />
30 MF<strong>Is</strong> in Mexico with Microenterprise Loans > 80% of Loan Product<br />
Real Yield on Gross Portfolio (%)<br />
100%<br />
80%<br />
60%<br />
40%<br />
20%<br />
148,733<br />
1,155,850<br />
58,5<strong>09</strong><br />
0%<br />
0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400<br />
Average Loan Balance per Borrower (USD)<br />
Bubble size - Number of Active Borrowers<br />
category. As the analysis shows, these high yields<br />
are generated by both institutions that are relatively<br />
small in scale and MF<strong>Is</strong> with a relatively large number<br />
of clients. These findings suggest that institutions<br />
are rewarded by the market and successfully attract<br />
clients even where their prices are above market rates.<br />
This analysis supports the findings of the 2008 MIX<br />
and ProDesarrollo Benchmarking report for Mexico,<br />
as it provides additional evidence for the hypothesis<br />
that intensifying competition does not put significant<br />
pressure on prices and profit margins, as new MF<strong>Is</strong><br />
take advantage of the established growth and pricing<br />
strategies of larger MF<strong>Is</strong>.<br />
As Figure 6 shows, the high yields of some<br />
institutions are not necessarily due to higher<br />
operating expenses. Several MF<strong>Is</strong> have considerable<br />
spreads 1 as represented by the size of the bubbles 2 ,<br />
which suggest that they charge prices above market<br />
rates. This strategy allows them to make exceptionally<br />
high profits.<br />
Hypothesis 3: Non-transparent pricing<br />
may result in adverse selection<br />
As Figures 3 and 5 suggest, the most inefficient<br />
MF<strong>Is</strong> in the analysis as well as those that appear<br />
1<br />
Defined as (Real Portfolio Yield – Operating Expense Ratio)<br />
2 Note: the white bubbles represent negative spreads<br />
to be generating exceptionally high profits by<br />
charging prices above market rates include several<br />
institutions serving a relatively large number of<br />
clients. Asymmetric information is a serious market<br />
imperfection, as it overrides the logics of the market.<br />
A lack of transparency undermines healthy consumer<br />
choice and the informed decision-making of a range<br />
of stakeholders, which can lead to adverse selection<br />
as the allocation of resources is distorted.<br />
Stakeholders of the Mexican microfinance sector as<br />
well as other sectors worldwide expect the coming<br />
years will see consolidation of institutions. While this<br />
may generally be desirable in terms of efficiency,<br />
growth and value to the client, in non-transparent<br />
markets this consolidation process may result in<br />
adverse selection whereby the responsible and<br />
efficient players lose out and inefficient and high<br />
profit players survive. Pricing transparency is thus<br />
indispensable in the market-based economy.<br />
Alternative Approaches to<br />
Transparency<br />
Government Level<br />
Truth-in-Lending Legislation<br />
While interest rates can be legitimately high in light<br />
of financial sustainability, there are various techniques<br />
18<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
FEATURE ARTICLES<br />
Figure 6: Loan Size, Yield and Spread<br />
30 MF<strong>Is</strong> in Mexico with Microenterprise Loans > 80% of Loan Product<br />
Real Portfolio Yield (%)<br />
120%<br />
100%<br />
80%<br />
60%<br />
40%<br />
20%<br />
47%<br />
22%<br />
23%<br />
53%<br />
28%<br />
15%<br />
0%<br />
0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400<br />
Average Loan Balance per Borrower (USD)<br />
Bubble size - Spread<br />
financial institutions can use to hide the true loan<br />
prices. As a response, governments in many countries<br />
have passed truth-in-lending legislation, requiring<br />
financial institutions to disclose the full costs to the<br />
borrower in a basic and consistent fashion, so as to<br />
allow for comparability among competing credit<br />
offers. The core approach of the Annual Percentage<br />
Rate (APR) and Effective Interest Rate (EIR) is to<br />
convert all the costs the client pays into an annualized<br />
declining balance interest rate 3 . In many countries<br />
where microfinance plays an important role, however,<br />
such legislation is either not in place or does not cover<br />
MF<strong>Is</strong>, as they operate under various and often special<br />
legal structures. In the medium-long term effective<br />
truth-in-lending legislation on a national level will<br />
be critical to ensure transparent pricing and healthy<br />
consumer choice.<br />
The Impact of Interest Rate Ceilings<br />
Interest rate ceilings have been proposed and<br />
discussed as a means of consumer protection in many<br />
countries in recent years. Despite good intentions,<br />
interest ceilings produce serious impediments to<br />
the development of a sustainable pro-poor financial<br />
sector.<br />
When the government intervenes in the market,<br />
demand and supply cannot freely determine the<br />
equilibrium price and quantity. In the case where<br />
artificial ceilings are below the equilibrium price, the<br />
3 MFTransparency provides more detailed explanation, as<br />
well as software to calculate both the APR and EIR: www.<br />
mftransparency.org<br />
allocation of resources is distorted. As a consequence,<br />
people who demand small loans remain without<br />
access to finance, as the interest ceiling makes it<br />
uneconomical to serve them, and they are forced to<br />
turn to the informal economy. Interest ceilings ignore<br />
the fact that the main reason for high interest rates in<br />
microfinance is that it is uneconomical and therefore<br />
unsustainable to make small loans at lower interest<br />
rates. MF<strong>Is</strong> may leave the market, be hindered in<br />
their growth and market outreach, and adapt their<br />
products in a way that results in limited access, such as<br />
increasing the average loan size. Interest ceilings also<br />
lead to a concentration in geographic areas where<br />
costs are lowest. This policy may even exacerbate<br />
the lack of pricing transparency, as MF<strong>Is</strong> may be<br />
incentivized to hide the true costs to the borrower<br />
by adding hidden and confusing charges. As a result,<br />
this kind of government intervention will not only<br />
limit access to finance, but also undermine efforts to<br />
enhance transparency.<br />
An analysis of the Mexican market including all MF<strong>Is</strong><br />
reporting to the MIX shows that interest rate ceilings<br />
do not effectively prevent high profits made by unfair<br />
competition and have the adverse effect of limiting<br />
access to credit for the poor (Figure 7). The interest<br />
rate ceiling would make small loans uneconomical<br />
and force MF<strong>Is</strong> providing these loans to increase the<br />
average loan size in order to be sustainable, even<br />
where the interest rates charged on these small loan<br />
products are legitimately high in light of institutional<br />
sustainability. At the same time, the ceiling does not<br />
prevent institutions from making exceptionally high<br />
profits, as high spreads can still be generated on larger<br />
loans.<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
19
FEATURE ARTICLES<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
Figure 7: The Impact of Interest Rate Ceilings<br />
120%<br />
Loan Size and Real Portfolio Yield<br />
( 42 MF<strong>Is</strong> in Mexico)<br />
Real Yield on Gross Portfolio (%)<br />
100%<br />
80%<br />
60%<br />
40%<br />
20%<br />
0%<br />
0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600 1800<br />
Average Loan Balance per Borrower (USD)<br />
Competition determines the price of loan products,<br />
not legislation. Rather than regulating interest rates,<br />
governments should implement appropriate truth-inlending<br />
legislation, stimulate competition, promote<br />
transparency and provide adequate consumer<br />
protection.<br />
Industry Level<br />
To ensure the integrity and credibility of the<br />
microfinance industry, industry-based truth-inlending<br />
is indispensable while appropriate legislation<br />
is absent.<br />
MFTransparency’s Global Transparent<br />
Pricing Initiative<br />
MFTransparency provides a venue for the microfinance<br />
industry to implement self-imposed global truthin-lending<br />
standards and publicly demonstrate<br />
its commitment to pricing transparency, integrity<br />
and poverty alleviation. MFTransparency addresses<br />
pricing transparency through three joint initiatives.<br />
It facilitates transparent communication about<br />
loan products and pricing for all microfinance<br />
stakeholders by publishing the true prices for each<br />
microloan product in a given market in a transparent<br />
and consistent fashion. As an equally important<br />
initiative, MFTransparency develops and disseminates<br />
educational material to provide an advanced<br />
understanding of product pricing in the microfinance<br />
industry. MFTransparency also consults governments,<br />
regulators, donors, investors and other stakeholders<br />
on appropriate consumer protection and pricing<br />
transparency practices.<br />
Market-driven Incentives<br />
In an industry where non-transparent pricing has<br />
been practiced for decades, there is no incentive<br />
for any one MFI to take the first step in changing<br />
its behavior, even if the majority of MF<strong>Is</strong> would like<br />
to adopt pricing transparency. As a response to this<br />
first-mover problem, MFTransparency provides an<br />
opportunity for all MF<strong>Is</strong> to publish the details of<br />
their pricing all-at-once and country-by-country. As<br />
donors and investors choose to allocate their funds<br />
to those MF<strong>Is</strong> committed to transparency, there is<br />
a real incentive for MF<strong>Is</strong> worldwide to make their<br />
pricing practices transparent. Once transparent<br />
MF<strong>Is</strong> are rewarded by the industry’s stakeholders,<br />
pricing transparency can become a real competitive<br />
advantage. At the same time, adverse behavior – such<br />
as introducing hidden costs, increasing the average<br />
loan size or focusing on areas cheaper to serve – will<br />
be prevented, as the public becomes more educated<br />
on how a variety of factors impact on loan prices<br />
in microfinance and why it is necessary to charge<br />
different prices for different microloan products.<br />
Historic Data Launch<br />
In October 20<strong>09</strong>, MFTransparency launched the<br />
world’s first extensive and accurate publicly available<br />
pricing data for microfinance products in each market,<br />
beginning with Bosnia and Herzogovina, Cambodia<br />
and Peru. The pricing data for the pilot countries<br />
confirms that smaller loans have higher prices. The<br />
data analysis for these countries also clearly shows<br />
the broad range in quoted prices. Prior to the data<br />
launch, the microfinance community was unaware of<br />
20<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
the market prices of the range of microloan products,<br />
as the actual APRs differ significantly from the quoted<br />
prices. Before product-specific pricing became<br />
publicly available with the MFTransparency data<br />
launch, the global industry relied on total portfolio<br />
yield as a proxy for interest rates. As portfolio yield<br />
provides an average of the different prices charged on<br />
all of the lender’s products, it is not a useful indicator<br />
where MF<strong>Is</strong> offer a range of different products.<br />
Conclusion<br />
According to classic economic theory, the price of<br />
a good or service is determined by the basic law of<br />
demand and supply, where the lender’s willingness to<br />
sell converges with the borrowers’ willingness to pay.<br />
A situation of information asymmetry, however, where<br />
the buyer has no chance to access and understand<br />
the information necessary to make a sound decision,<br />
constitutes a serious market imperfection. Competition<br />
is generally beneficial for clients, but this is where a<br />
market price is determined by the dynamics of demand<br />
and supply. Markets in which non-transparent pricing<br />
is common, clearly lack this market price. An opaque<br />
pricing environment allows institutions to survive<br />
in the market despite inefficiencies or to generate<br />
exceptionally high profits.<br />
A lack of pricing transparency may adversely affect the<br />
decision making of all industry stakeholders: clients<br />
cannot compare competing loan offers and make an<br />
FEATURE ARTICLES<br />
informed decision. The price of a given product may<br />
not match the client’s perception of the product’s<br />
value, as she is not aware of the actual price she<br />
pays for the benefits of the respective product and<br />
the service with which it is provided. Given the lack<br />
of information as a result of non-transparent pricing<br />
that may disguise inefficiencies and exceptional<br />
profits, donors and investors are unable to allocate<br />
resources optimally. Policymakers may intervene<br />
in ways that harm responsible lenders, as they are<br />
unable to differentiate between responsible and less<br />
responsible market players. This may consequently<br />
lead to adverse selection: Responsible and efficient<br />
lenders are threatened to fall out of business, while<br />
inefficient and high-profit institutions may stay in the<br />
market.<br />
The last decade has seen impressive achievements<br />
of transparency in the financial performance of MF<strong>Is</strong><br />
worldwide. Microfinance is increasingly recognized as<br />
an asset class in the global capital markets, achieving<br />
both social and financial returns. Yet despite the<br />
industry’s commitment to a strong social mission and<br />
double-bottom line aspirations, pricing transparency<br />
has not been widely practiced. Microfinance is a fastexpanding<br />
industry and as commercial approaches to<br />
microfinance continue to emerge, it is important that<br />
both parties gain. An opaque pricing environment,<br />
however, undermines equal transactions and consumer<br />
choice. Transparent pricing will harness the power of<br />
the market to facilitate an equitable exchange.<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
21
FEATURE ARTICLES<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
<strong>Is</strong> Social Performance Profitable<br />
The relationship between social and financial<br />
performance in microfinance<br />
Florent Bédécarrats, Rémy William Angora, Cécile Lapenu<br />
www.cerise-microfinance.org cerise@globenet.org<br />
Overview<br />
<strong>Is</strong> social performance <strong>profitable</strong> The question may<br />
be cynical, but nevertheless relevant for microfinance<br />
to keep its “promise” of being an economically<br />
viable development tool (Morduch, 1999). For years,<br />
the sector focused on sustainability and growth,<br />
measured in terms of financial performance. For the<br />
most part, social performance was taken for granted,<br />
which led many microfinance institutions (MF<strong>Is</strong>) to<br />
neglect its measure and management. Concerned by<br />
this trend, pioneer practitioners, investors and donors<br />
have taken steps to address social performance by<br />
developing tools, methodologies and assessment<br />
frameworks. As criticism of the sector has increased,<br />
social performance has been mainstreamed<br />
(Copestake, 2007). But has it been at the expense of<br />
financial performance<br />
There are contradicting viewpoints regarding the<br />
pairing of financial sustainability and social objectives.<br />
Some observers suggest an incompatibility, pointing<br />
to problems of mission drift experienced by MF<strong>Is</strong> that<br />
pursue profitability by insisting on physical guarantees,<br />
increasing loan amounts and targeting the better-off<br />
(Christen, 2001). Others emphasize synergy, arguing<br />
that social performance improves mutual trust, client<br />
participation and satisfaction, which translates into<br />
higher repayment rates and lower transaction costs<br />
(Lapenu, 2007). While these assertions draw on case<br />
studies, the research has not been extensive enough<br />
to draw sector-wide conclusions.<br />
Insufficient data has long been the main obstacle to<br />
answering this question. Reliable results are simply<br />
not easy to come by. Impact studies are limited, costly<br />
to replicate and difficult to compare (Copestake,<br />
2003). Recent works using sophisticated techniques<br />
(Cornée, 2006; Gurtierrez-Nieto & al., 2007; Cull et al.,<br />
20<strong>09</strong>; Mersland & Strøm, 20<strong>09</strong>; Lensink & Niels, 20<strong>09</strong>)<br />
have mainly used financial data and inadequate<br />
social performance indicators such as portfolio<br />
size, average loan size or number of women clients<br />
(Armendariz & Szafarz, 20<strong>09</strong>; Dunford, 2002). These<br />
proxies offer little more than a vague idea of depth<br />
of outreach – only one of the many dimensions of<br />
social performance. Moreover, they only account for<br />
credit operations, effectively ignoring other aspects<br />
of microfinance.<br />
Methodology<br />
<strong>CERISE</strong>, a microfinance knowledge exchange network,<br />
has been developing the <strong>SP</strong>I (Social Performance<br />
Indicators) tool to assess social performance since<br />
2002. <strong>CERISE</strong> has worked with the Social Performance<br />
Task Force to define Social Performance Standards<br />
(<strong>SP</strong>S) for reporting to the MIX Market . Thanks<br />
to contributions of practitioners, investors and<br />
donors, <strong>CERISE</strong> has collected the results of 230 <strong>SP</strong>I<br />
assessments .<br />
The Social Performance Task Force defines social<br />
performance as “the effective implementation of<br />
an institution’s social mission into practice. This<br />
mission may include serving larger numbers of poor<br />
and excluded people; delivering high-quality and<br />
appropriate financial services; creating benefits for<br />
clients; and improving the social responsibility of an<br />
MFI” (Hashemi 2007). This notion, at the very heart<br />
of microfinance’s mandate (“do good”), goes beyond<br />
the concept of social responsability (“do no harm”).<br />
Social responsibility applies to all economic sectors<br />
and refers to an organization’s responsibility for the<br />
impact of its decisions and activities on society and<br />
the environment through transparent and ethical<br />
behavior (Gendron, 20<strong>09</strong>).<br />
<strong>CERISE</strong> analyzed the results of 126 social performance<br />
assessments conducted between 2005 and 2008.<br />
<br />
<br />
www.themix.org<br />
<strong>CERISE</strong> acknowledges the Fondation FPH and Swiss Cooperation<br />
Agency for their financial support, as well as Foro Lac FR,<br />
Oikocredit and the other members of ProsperA for their active<br />
participation in gathering <strong>SP</strong>I data.
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
FEATURE ARTICLES<br />
Figure 1: Sample Distribution<br />
MFI region<br />
MENA=7<br />
Africa=21<br />
MFI governance type<br />
Bank=4<br />
Asia=11<br />
Credit Union=29<br />
ECA=3<br />
LAC=84<br />
61<br />
86<br />
NGO=68<br />
NBFI=15<br />
19<br />
27<br />
18<br />
13<br />
49<br />
41<br />
36<br />
Large Medium Small Mature Young New Rural Mixed Urban<br />
Size Age Type<br />
Data sets were selected for their reliability and<br />
comparability . They are representative of the sector<br />
as a whole, as the table below shows.<br />
Thirty-nine countries are represented by a wellbalanced<br />
mix of rural, urban and mixed MF<strong>Is</strong>. Latin<br />
American institutions and NGOs are nonetheless over<br />
represented compared to other regions and charter<br />
types (Figure 1).<br />
The <strong>SP</strong>I collects data on 70 indicators that measure<br />
the objectives, processes and immediate outputs<br />
of four key dimensions of social performance. Each<br />
dimension is broken down into twelve criteria .<br />
• Targeting and outreach (D1) refer to the MFI’s<br />
strategies to reach the poor and excluded.<br />
Targeting can be geographic (1.1), such as<br />
when an institution decides to operate in an<br />
area where no other financial services are<br />
available. It can be individual (1.2), when it<br />
purposely selects clients based on poverty<br />
levels or exclusion. It can be methodological<br />
(1.3), when services are designed specifically<br />
to reach the poor or excluded.<br />
• Appropriate services (D2) assess an<br />
institution’s ability to provide products<br />
tailored to clients’ needs. This entails offering<br />
Table 1<br />
<strong>CERISE</strong> sample<br />
(Median)<br />
Borrowers<br />
per Staff<br />
Member<br />
PaR-30 (%)<br />
Operating<br />
Expenses<br />
Ratio (%)<br />
OSS (%) ROA (%)<br />
Number<br />
of Active<br />
Borrowers<br />
Total<br />
Portfolio<br />
127 2.6 15.82 111.10 2.55 7,165 4,249,112<br />
<strong>MBB</strong> (Median) 112 2.7 19.20 113.60 0.60 11,041 4,800,765<br />
The assessments used the <strong>SP</strong>I 2.0. The current version (3.0),<br />
released in 20<strong>09</strong>, was revised to include the Social Performance<br />
Standards (except for the outcome indicators which are outside<br />
of the <strong>SP</strong>I’s purview).<br />
<br />
See details for the indicators at www.cerise-microfinance.org<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
23
FEATURE ARTICLES<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
4. Social<br />
responsibility<br />
1. Targeting poor<br />
excluded<br />
100%<br />
80%<br />
60%<br />
40%<br />
20%<br />
0%<br />
2. Products<br />
& services<br />
Figure 2: Means of social performance by region 6 0%<br />
4.3 SR/ community<br />
environment<br />
4.2 SR/<br />
clients<br />
4.1 SR/<br />
employees<br />
1.1 Geographic<br />
targeting<br />
100%<br />
80%<br />
60%<br />
40%<br />
20%<br />
1.2 individual<br />
targeting<br />
1.3 pro-poor<br />
methodology<br />
2.1 service<br />
diversification<br />
3. Social capital<br />
Africa (N=21)<br />
Asia (N=11)<br />
LAC (N=84)<br />
MENA (N=7)<br />
3.3<br />
empowerment<br />
3.2 participation<br />
3.1 transparency-trust<br />
2.2 quality<br />
services<br />
2.3 innovative &<br />
non-financial<br />
a range of financial services (2.1) of high<br />
quality (2.2) as well as innovative and nonfinancial<br />
services (2.3).<br />
• Some MF<strong>Is</strong> strive to build social capital (D3) ,<br />
by fostering trust and transparency (3.1),<br />
encouraging participation (3.2) and developing<br />
activities that promote empowerment (3.3).<br />
• Social responsibility (D4) extends to employees<br />
through appropriate human resource policies<br />
(4.1), to clients by guaranteeing respect of<br />
consumer protection principles (4.2), to the<br />
community and the environment by respecting<br />
the context where the MFI operates (4.3).<br />
Financial data from MIX Market and MF<strong>Is</strong> weve used<br />
to complete social performance data. The following<br />
ratios were selected for analysis: Borrowers per staff<br />
members, Operating expenses ratio (OER), Portfolio<br />
at Risk (PAR) Operational Self-Sufficiency (OSS) and<br />
Return on Assets (ROA).<br />
This data was only available for roughly 100 MF<strong>Is</strong><br />
in the sample (see Table 3). Analysis involved<br />
calculating means for peer groups defined by <strong>MBB</strong><br />
criteria, conducting Spearman tests and generating a<br />
classification tree.<br />
Social Performance Profiles<br />
Rather than focus on the aggregated score for each<br />
institution, it is more telling to look at results per<br />
dimension. Indeed, it is unrealistic to expect a maximum<br />
score for each criteria. Different institutions prioritize<br />
different facets of social performance, depending on<br />
their objectives and context. For example, analysis<br />
shows MF<strong>Is</strong> operating in remote regions where they<br />
are often the only financial institution, do not target<br />
the poorest of the poor but are frequently based on<br />
participatory models. Similarly, institutions targeting<br />
the very poor tend to have a less diversified product<br />
mix than those serving higher income populations. In<br />
the graphs shown here (Figure 2), the total surface<br />
area represents the MF<strong>Is</strong>’ efforts to achieve their social<br />
mission, while the diagram shape reveals the nature<br />
of their social strategy.<br />
Peer group analysis reveals several interesting<br />
trends in terms of region and charter type. Latin<br />
American institutions are relatively balanced in<br />
their social performance, while sub-Saharan African<br />
institutions are distinguished by their focus on<br />
geographic targeting and strong participation,<br />
and a lack of non-financial/innovative services and<br />
weak social responsibility to users. In Asia, targeting<br />
is methodological (e.g., small loan amounts, social<br />
collateral); non-financial and innovative services<br />
(insurance, transfers) are well developed.<br />
Cooperatives stand out in their efforts to build social<br />
capital. However, they are less likely to target the<br />
very poor and excluded. Commercial banks score<br />
well on product diversity and social responsibility<br />
to clients and employees, but do not serve the poor<br />
or encourage client participation. NGOs and NBF<strong>Is</strong><br />
have relatively balanced profiles. The former stand<br />
out in terms of individual targeting, while the latter<br />
distinguish themselves with high-quality services.<br />
<br />
This dimension was considerably revised in the <strong>SP</strong>I’s new version,<br />
where it appears as Benefits to Clients. The three criteria are<br />
economic benefits, client participation and empowerment.<br />
<br />
Europe and Central Asia were not included in analysis because it<br />
was too small to be significant (3 MF<strong>Is</strong>).<br />
24<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
FEATURE ARTICLES<br />
Figure 3: Means of social performance by charter type<br />
1. Targeting poor<br />
excluded<br />
1.1 Geographic<br />
targeting<br />
4. Social<br />
responsibility<br />
80%<br />
60%<br />
40%<br />
20%<br />
0%<br />
2. Products<br />
& services<br />
4.3 SR/ community<br />
environment<br />
4.2 SR/<br />
clients<br />
4.1 SR/<br />
employees<br />
100%<br />
80%<br />
60%<br />
40%<br />
20%<br />
0%<br />
1.2 individual<br />
targeting<br />
1.3 pro-poor<br />
methodology<br />
2.1 service<br />
diversification<br />
3. Social capital<br />
Banks (N=4)<br />
Credit unions (N=29)<br />
NBF<strong>Is</strong> (N=15)<br />
NGOs (N=68)<br />
3.3<br />
empowerment<br />
3.2 participation<br />
3.1 transparency-trust<br />
2.2 quality<br />
services<br />
2.3 innovative &<br />
non-financial<br />
With regard to interactions between the different<br />
dimensions, analysis of the correlation coefficients<br />
confirms what some have long predicted (Gonzalez-<br />
Vega, 1998). The four dimensions mutually reinforce<br />
each other, just as high productivity and low<br />
PAR often translate into lower costs and higher<br />
profitability. Nonetheless, there are some distinct<br />
trends.<br />
As Table 2 shows, there is often a trade-off between<br />
geographic (1.1) and individual targeting (1.2).<br />
As some studies suggest (Hirschland et al., 2008),<br />
MF<strong>Is</strong> that target geographically are more likely to<br />
emphasize client participation (3.2) to reduce costs<br />
and diversify their product mix (2.1) to manage<br />
risk . Those that target individually tend to have<br />
less diverse products, but are more likely to offer<br />
Table 2<br />
Correlation between social and financial performance (results of Spearman tests<br />
on data from 126 MF<strong>Is</strong>)<br />
1.1 1.2 1.3 D2 2.1 2.2 2.3 D3 3.1 3.2 3.3 D4 4.1 4.2 4.3<br />
D1 ++ ++ ++ ++ ++ ++ ++<br />
1.1 ++ + ++ ++ ++ + ++<br />
1.2 ++ + + +<br />
1.3 + -- + -<br />
<br />
Total<br />
portfolio<br />
D2 ++ ++ ++ ++ ++ ++ ++ ++ ++ ++ ++ ++<br />
2.1 + ++ ++ ++ ++ + ++ ++ ++<br />
2.2 ++ ++ ++ ++<br />
2.3 ++ ++ ++<br />
D3 ++ ++ ++ ++<br />
3.1 ++ ++ ++<br />
3.2 ++ ++<br />
3.3 ++ ++ ++<br />
D4 ++ ++ ++ ++<br />
4.1 + ++<br />
4.2 + ++<br />
4.3 ++<br />
++ Convergence significant at 0.01, 2-tailled -- Divergence significant at 0.01, 2-tailled<br />
+ Convergence significant at 0.05, 2-tailled - Divergence significant at 0.05, 2-tailled<br />
See Morduch (2000) and Hashemi and Rosenberg (2006) for<br />
discussion on the challenges of "pro poor" approaches.<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
25
FEATURE ARTICLES<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
Table 3<br />
Correlation between social and financial performance<br />
Borrowers/<br />
staff N=95<br />
PaR 30<br />
N=100<br />
OER<br />
N=96<br />
OSS<br />
N=83<br />
RoA<br />
N=99<br />
Total<br />
portfolio<br />
N=101<br />
1. Targeting 0.302 0.259 ++<br />
1.1 Geographic 0.381<br />
1.2 Individual 0.422<br />
1.3 Methodological 0.275 0.243<br />
2. Services -0.253 0.426<br />
2.1 Diversity -0.237 -0.290 0.204<br />
2.2 Quality 0.391<br />
2.3 Innov. Non. fin.<br />
3. Benefits 0.216 -0.245<br />
3.1 Transparency-trust -0.326 -0.220 -0.206<br />
3.2 Participation -0.255<br />
3.3 Empowerment<br />
4. CSR -0.275 0.566<br />
4.1 SR/staff -0,.200 0.404<br />
4.2 SR/clients 0.353<br />
4.3 SR/community -0.197 0.376<br />
Total Social 0.210 ++<br />
++ Convergence signif. at 0.01, 2 - tailled -- Divergence signif. at 0.01, 2 - tailled<br />
+ Convergence signif. at 0.05, 2 - tailled - Divergence signif. at 0.05, 2 - tailled<br />
non-financial services (2.3) and actively promote<br />
empowerment (3.3).<br />
Some institutions choose to emphasize pro-poor<br />
methodologies, although methodological targeting<br />
(1.3) does not preclude the other two. MF<strong>Is</strong> that allow<br />
clients to borrow and save very small sums without<br />
physical guarantees often using solidarity groups<br />
tend to be highly transparent (3.1) and committed<br />
to client protection (4.2). Unfortunately, they appear<br />
to do so at the expense of social responsibility to<br />
employees (4.1). Nevertheless, institutions tend to<br />
drop this approach as their portfolios grow.Analysis<br />
of appropriate services (2.2) and social responsibility<br />
(D4) confirms the importance of economies of<br />
scale in social performance (Copestake, 2007): large<br />
institutions clearly score higher in these areas.<br />
Individual targeting is costly,<br />
but other aspects of social<br />
performance are “<strong>profitable</strong>”<br />
By crossing data from <strong>SP</strong>I audits with financial<br />
indicators, it is possible to determine the relationship<br />
between social and financial performance.<br />
Table 3 confirms what some studies on outreach<br />
have suggested (Cull et al., 20<strong>09</strong>; Lensink et al., 20<strong>09</strong>):<br />
institutions that actively target the poor tend to have<br />
higher operational costs. Hashemi and Rosenberg<br />
(2006) explain this phenomenon by the higher risks<br />
and lack of guarantees inherent to this clientele,<br />
reticence to join microfinance programs and the<br />
challenges of providing the non-financial support this<br />
population requires.<br />
The divergence is limited to individual targeting,<br />
however. Geographical and methodological targeting<br />
approaches are correlated with higher staff productivity.<br />
This is likely because they are often associated with<br />
greater client participation (see Table 2), and they<br />
allow MF<strong>Is</strong> to operate in less competitive markets.<br />
Clearly, when social performance is understood as<br />
simply targeting the poor, its value-added is limited<br />
(Lapenu, 2007, Armendariz and Szafarz, 20<strong>09</strong>).<br />
Participatory institutions tend to have lower rates of<br />
operational self-sufficiency, perhaps due to member<br />
pressure to keep interest rates low (Ouatara et al.,<br />
1998, p. 3). This finding requires more in-depth analysis.<br />
Our analysis confirms Copestake’s (2007) hypothesis<br />
regarding the importance of economies of scale for<br />
26<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
FEATURE ARTICLES<br />
Figure 4: Factors Determining Borrowers Per Staff Ratio (B/S), organized by classification tree<br />
Low: <strong>SP</strong>I score < 50%<br />
Medium: score > 50%; 75%<br />
Mean B/S = 140.2<br />
MF<strong>Is</strong> = 91<br />
Std. deviation = 92.012<br />
Geographic targeting<br />
Low and medium<br />
High<br />
Mean B/S = 118.2<br />
MF<strong>Is</strong> = 63<br />
Mean B/S = 189.6<br />
MF<strong>Is</strong> = 28<br />
Outreach<br />
Service diversification<br />
Medium and large<br />
Small<br />
Low and medium<br />
High<br />
Mean B/S = 160.3<br />
MF<strong>Is</strong> = 26<br />
Mean B/S = 88.6<br />
MF<strong>Is</strong> = 37<br />
Mean B/S = 225<br />
MF<strong>Is</strong> = 13<br />
Mean B/S = 133<br />
MF<strong>Is</strong> = 15<br />
Service diversification<br />
Social responsibility. towards. staff<br />
Low<br />
Medium and high<br />
Low and medium<br />
High<br />
Mean B/S = 217<br />
MF<strong>Is</strong> = 6<br />
Mean B/S = 143.3<br />
MF<strong>Is</strong> = 20<br />
Mean B/S = 95.3<br />
MF<strong>Is</strong> = 6<br />
Mean B/S = 158.1<br />
MF<strong>Is</strong> = 9<br />
improved social performance. MF<strong>Is</strong> with the largest<br />
loan portfolios score highest in range and quality of<br />
services (2.1 and 2.2) and social responsibility (D4).<br />
These same institutions have the best repayment rates<br />
and lowest operational costs. Finally, high scores in<br />
social responsibility, especially to employees and the<br />
community, are correlated with lower PAR. It would<br />
appear that when employees and the community feel<br />
respected by the MFI, they are willing to respect the<br />
MFI in return.<br />
Crossing variables<br />
Simple correlation analysis of each social and financial<br />
variable is limited. Microfinance institutions must<br />
make choices based on a multitude of factors that<br />
are intertwined and not necessarily independent of<br />
each other. Classification trees help make sense of this<br />
complexity by selecting variables, taking into account<br />
their interactions and combining them to classify<br />
institutions into groups.<br />
In a classification tree analysis, a dependent variable is<br />
identified along with all the factors likely to influence it.<br />
Statistical analysis then ranks the factors with the most<br />
influence on the variable. In this example (Figure 4)<br />
selected for its performance prediction (84 percent<br />
of MF<strong>Is</strong> in our sample), staff productivity is analyzed<br />
based on institutional characteristics and social<br />
performance results (by dimension and criteria).<br />
Geographic targeting emerges as the main predictor<br />
variable. Institutions in very poor or excluded areas<br />
generally make efficient use of their workforce: almost<br />
189 borrowers per staff member. This ratio rises to 255<br />
for MF<strong>Is</strong> with little diversity and generally no savings<br />
products. For institutions with a wider product<br />
range, social responsibility to employees becomes a<br />
decisive criteria of effectiveness. Employees of MF<strong>Is</strong><br />
with an advantageous human resources policy serve<br />
<br />
Age categories, region, zone of intervention, outreach, charter<br />
type.<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
27
FEATURE ARTICLES<br />
an average of 158 borrowers compared to 95 for the<br />
others.<br />
For institutions that do not work in marginalized areas,<br />
size is crucial. Staff productivity at smaller institutions<br />
reaches only 89 borrowers per staff member.<br />
Conversely, MF<strong>Is</strong> with over 10,000 borrowers, limited<br />
product mix and no savings manage to reach 217 per<br />
employee while large MF<strong>Is</strong> with a more diversified<br />
offer reach 143 borrowers per staff member.<br />
Looking ahead<br />
Thanks to recently developed simple and reliable<br />
methods to assess social performance, we can now<br />
evaluate microfinance's ability to achieve the double<br />
bottom line.<br />
This analysis confirms what many studies have<br />
suggested based on incomplete data: social<br />
performance and financial performance are<br />
compatible. Targeting the poor clearly implies higher<br />
costs for MF<strong>Is</strong>. However other aspects of social<br />
performance—namely geographical targeting when<br />
associated with participatory models, well-adapted<br />
loan technologies and social responsibility—are<br />
positively correlated with good operational and<br />
financial performance. The correlation is even stronger<br />
for large MF<strong>Is</strong>, which benefit from economies of scale.<br />
Further analysis is needed to clarify the relationship<br />
between social performance and more complex<br />
financial performance indicators like OSS, ROE and<br />
ROA. Nonetheless, our analysis echoes the call to go<br />
“back to the basics”: the pillars of microfinance’s social<br />
utility (include the excluded, offer appropriate services,<br />
benefit clients) clearly impact the fundamentals of<br />
financial sustainability: productivity, efficiency and<br />
portfolio quality.<br />
<strong>CERISE</strong> will continue to refine this research agenda,<br />
as our database of social performance assessements<br />
grows and the new social performance reporting<br />
format on MIX Market gets underway . The<br />
microfinance industry must now rise to the challenge<br />
of finding ways to exploit synergies between social<br />
and financial performance in order to truly achieve<br />
the “revolution” (Robinson, 2001).<br />
Bibliography<br />
Armendáriz Beatriz, Szafarz Ariane, On Mission Drift in<br />
Microfinance Institutions, Bruxelles, EMP, 20<strong>09</strong>.<br />
<br />
Because the <strong>CERISE</strong> <strong>SP</strong>I is fully compatible with the MIX <strong>SP</strong>S format,<br />
MF<strong>Is</strong> conducting an <strong>SP</strong>I audit can easily report to the MIX Market.<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
Christen Robert, Commercialization and Mission<br />
Drift: The Transformation of Microfinance in Latin<br />
America, Washington DC, CGAP, Occasional paper,<br />
2001.<br />
Copestake James, Simple standards or burgeoning<br />
benchmarks Institutionalising social performance<br />
monitoring, assessment and auditing of microfinance,<br />
Bath, University of Bath, 2003.<br />
Copestake James, “Mainstreaming Microfinance:<br />
Social Performance Management or Mission Drift”,<br />
World Development, 35, 10 2007, pp. 1721–1738.<br />
Dunford Chris, What wrong with loan size Freedom<br />
From Hunger, 2002Gendron C., ISO 26000: Towards a<br />
Social Definition of Corporate Social Responsibility,<br />
Chair of Social Responsibility and Sustainable<br />
Development, UQAM, 20<strong>09</strong>.<br />
Gonzalez-Vega Claudio, Microfinance: Broader<br />
achievements and new challenges, Columbus, Ohio<br />
State University, Economics and Sociology Occasional<br />
Paper, 1998.<br />
Gutiérrez-Nieto Begoña, Serrano-Cinca Carlos, Mar<br />
Molinero Cecílio, “Microfinance Institutions and<br />
Efficiency”, Omega, 35, 04 2007, pp. 131-142.<br />
Hashemi Syed, Beyond Good Intentions: Measuring<br />
the Social Performance of Microfinance Institutions,<br />
Washington DC, CGAP, May 2007.<br />
Hashemi Syed, Rosenberg Richard, Graduating the<br />
Poorest into Microfinance: Linking Safety Nets and<br />
Financial Services, Washington DC, CGAP, Focus Note,<br />
2006.<br />
Hirschland M., R. Chao-Béroff Renée, M. Harper, N. Lee,<br />
2008. Reaching the Hard to Reach: Comparative Study<br />
of Member-Owned Financial Institutions in Remote<br />
Rural Areas, Coady International Institute.<br />
Lapenu Cécile, “Performances sociales<br />
versus performances financières : peut-on<br />
être rentable en s'adressant à des populations<br />
pauvres”, Horizons Bancaires, 334, <strong>Dec</strong>ember 2007,<br />
pp. 55–66.<br />
Lensink Robert, Hermes Niels, Outreach, Financial<br />
Development, and Efficiency of Microfinance<br />
Institutions, University of Groningen, 2007.<br />
Mersland R., Strøm R. Ø. , “Microfinance mission drift”,<br />
World Development, 20<strong>09</strong>.<br />
28<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
Morduch, J. (1999), “The Microfinance Promise” Journal<br />
of Economy Literature, pp. 1569–1614<br />
Morduch Jonathan, “The Microfinance Schism”, World<br />
Development, 28(4), April l 2000, pp. 617–629.<br />
Navajas, S., J. Conning and C. Gonzalez-Vega<br />
(2003) “Lending Technologies, Competition and<br />
FEATURE ARTICLES<br />
Consolidation in the Market for Microfinance in<br />
Bolivia”, Journal of International Development, 15, pp.<br />
747–770.<br />
Robinson Marguerite S., The Microfinance Revolution,<br />
Washington DC, World Bank-Open Society Institute,<br />
2001.<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
29
FEATURE ARTICLES<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
New Financial Ratios for Microfinance<br />
Reporting<br />
Drew Tulchin, Reid Sassman, Elizabeth Wolkomir: Social Enterprise<br />
Associates, for the MFI Reporting Standards Initiative of the SEEP<br />
Network<br />
Contributions from: Ruth Dueck Mbeba (MEDA), Blaine Stephens<br />
(Mix), and Maria Stephens (USAID)<br />
Overview<br />
Over the past decade, there has been an industrywide<br />
effort to identify and implement financial<br />
reporting standards for microfinance institutions. The<br />
objective is to provide uniform financial information<br />
for all MF<strong>Is</strong>, regardless of size, maturity or geographic<br />
location to managers and stakeholders including<br />
investors, donors, raters, MIS software developers, and<br />
associations. This promotes transparency, facilitates<br />
comparability, improves decision-making, and<br />
increases investment by making it easier to observe<br />
and understand an MFI’s financial health.<br />
After extensive industry collaboration, the SEEP<br />
Network released a milestone document in<br />
2005: Measuring Performance of Microfinance<br />
Institutions, a Framework for Reporting, Analysis,<br />
and Monitoring (the Framework). The Framework<br />
includes foundational information for uniform<br />
financial statements and 18 ratios designed to<br />
measure MFI performance in four areas: 1)<br />
sustainability/profitability; 2) asset and liability<br />
management; 3) portfolio quality; and 4) efficiency/<br />
productivity. Such information is used on MIX Market,<br />
the FRAME tool, investors/donors, MIS software<br />
vendors, raters, regulators, auditors, etc. The original<br />
Framework was tailored to credit-only institutions.<br />
The MFI Reporting Standards Initiative (the Initiative)<br />
seeks to keep the Framework up to date with the<br />
evolving microfinance landscape. Its ‘Secretariat’<br />
is hosted by the SEEP Network. Practitioner<br />
involvement is facilitated by the Financial Services<br />
Working Group (FSWG), with input provided by<br />
representatives from a range of microfinance<br />
industry stakeholders. The reporting standards<br />
adoption process follows a multi-stage model,<br />
based upon that of the International Accounting<br />
Standards Board (IASB), which allows for public<br />
<br />
Website: http://seepnetwork.org/Pages/Initiatives/Financial<br />
ReportingStandardInitiative.aspx.<br />
input and transparency. The goal is to provide a<br />
formal mechanism for all MFI industry efforts to be<br />
guided by uniform standards. Financial reporting is<br />
the first effort, but the process also lends itself to<br />
social performance, donor reporting, and uniform<br />
general ledgers, among others.<br />
For the first time in nearly five years, the Initiative is<br />
leading an organized process to make enhancements<br />
to the Framework. In addition to correcting minor<br />
errata, eight new ratios are presented to better convey<br />
financial position and performance. Four ratios focus<br />
on savings, addressing the gap for savings groups,<br />
credit unions, and the trend of MF<strong>Is</strong> transforming into<br />
deposit-taking institutions. Further, increased private<br />
investment and the global economic downturn<br />
highlight the need for better information on capital<br />
adequacy, capital quality, and foreign exchange, risks<br />
particularly associated with increased integration<br />
in the global capital markets. The ratios incorporate<br />
recent developments in international accounting<br />
and financial reporting, including new standards and<br />
guidelines from IASB, Basel II, and IFRS. In the short<br />
run, this will likely add obligations to MF<strong>Is</strong>, particularly<br />
for disclosure, financial statement preparation, and<br />
reporting. It is a necessary step that ultimately will<br />
make reporting easier for MF<strong>Is</strong>. The MFI Reporting<br />
Standards Initiative seeks to ensure microfinance<br />
reporting is in line with other standards, complies<br />
with international best practices and keeps pace with<br />
progress in the field.<br />
This article describes each of the eight new ratios. In<br />
a uniform format, the ratio name, framework number,<br />
and mathematical equations are provided. Narrative<br />
<br />
<br />
For more details of the adoption process, see “MFI Reporting<br />
Standards and Adoption Process” available in English, Spanish,<br />
French or Arabic from the website cited in footnote #1<br />
Please refer to each of these entities for their specific standards<br />
and requirements: International Accounting Standards Board<br />
(www.iasb.org), International Financial Reporting Standards<br />
(www.ifrs.com), and eXtensible Business Reporting Language<br />
(www.xbrl.org)
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
follows detailing why the ratio is important, and how<br />
it is interpreted.<br />
To more fully understand the implications of the ratios,<br />
specific examples are provided with calculations using<br />
data from Banco ProCredit Nicaragua (ProCredit Nic).<br />
ProCredit Nic was chosen as an illustrative example<br />
because it is a well-established, deposit-taking MFI<br />
with a gross portfolio of more than USD132 million<br />
and 80,000 active borrowers. Nicaragua has a<br />
competitive market with active foreign investment<br />
and multiple years of data, enabling comparisons to<br />
other MF<strong>Is</strong>.<br />
The new ratios presented here are proposed as drafts<br />
per the industry adoption process for public input.<br />
Proposed revisions are intended to address current<br />
industry evolution, address the gaps of the 2005<br />
Framework, and anticipate advances in microfinance<br />
in the coming years. Input and feedback from industry<br />
stakeholders is encouraged to the MFI Reporting<br />
Standards Initiative (email: reportingstandards@<br />
seepnetwork.org).<br />
New Ratios for MFI Reporting<br />
1) Capital Adequacy Ratio: Institutional<br />
Solvency<br />
Term<br />
Capital Adequacy Ratio (CAR)<br />
Calculation<br />
Total Capital<br />
Risk Weighted Assets<br />
Why this ratio is important<br />
Capital Adequacy Ratio (CAR) measures an institution’s<br />
solvency. The indicator provides information about<br />
ability to meet long-term expenses and obligations<br />
as well as absorb unanticipated future commitments.<br />
It provides better information than the existing R8:<br />
Liquid Ratio. CAR measures an institution’s resiliency<br />
against both expected and unexpected losses, which<br />
may result from endogenous and exogenous causes.<br />
It is in line with Basel II calculations.<br />
How it is interpreted<br />
Many institutions have approximated capital<br />
adequacy by calculating total equity relative to total<br />
assets. CAR takes one more step, adjusting for risk<br />
level of asset holdings. In accordance with Basel II<br />
guidelines, CAR uses Total Capital in the numerator as<br />
<br />
MIX Market, www.mixmarket.org/mfi/procredit-nic.<br />
FEATURE ARTICLES<br />
a more complete picture of the MFI’s resources. This<br />
includes supplementary capital sources, such as loan<br />
loss reserves, asset reserves and subordinated debt.<br />
It subtracts goodwill to gauge tangible capital. The<br />
denominator is a risk-weighted aggregate of assets.<br />
Riskier assets require the institution to hold higher<br />
capital reserves, including those as a factor to provide<br />
more precise solvency than a simple liquid ratio,<br />
in which current assets are compared with current<br />
liabilities. Calculating Total Capital will be new to<br />
some MF<strong>Is</strong> and require more detailed evaluation of<br />
their financial statements, as well as more accurate<br />
tracking of adjustments. <br />
Higher CARs generally signify more capital, meaning<br />
an institution is better positioned to meet financial<br />
obligations and address unexpected losses. For<br />
regulated institutions, regulators often establish CAR<br />
floors that MF<strong>Is</strong> must maintain.<br />
CAR is particularly informative when compared to<br />
regional benchmarks. An appropriate level often<br />
depends upon the size and maturity of an MFI, as<br />
well as differing socio-political or economic contexts.<br />
For example, Nigerian MF<strong>Is</strong> are more at risk from<br />
the country’s tenuous socio-political climate than<br />
an MFI located in Costa Rica, where political unrest<br />
is less likely. Nigerian MF<strong>Is</strong> are therefore encouraged<br />
to target a higher CAR. National authorities in each<br />
country set minimum levels of capital for regulated<br />
institutions. In most jurisdictions, it is around 8 – 9<br />
percent. This is a particular improvement for investors/<br />
donors, but also valuable for national associations<br />
and managers.<br />
Specific calculation<br />
In 2004, ProCredit Nic’s CAR was 14.08 percent. The<br />
ratio has consistently declined between 2005 and<br />
2008, at which time it reported a CAR of 9.82 percent.<br />
The mathematical calculations for these years are on<br />
the following page. <br />
This is consistent with similarly sized Nicaraguan<br />
MF<strong>Is</strong>. BANEX, with a comparably sized loan portfolio,<br />
had 9.35 percent CAR. Nicaraguan MF<strong>Is</strong> with smaller<br />
portfolios but similar numbers of borrowers posted<br />
higher CARs. FDL and ACODEP had ratios above<br />
<br />
<br />
An extensive dissemination campaign will be needed to educate<br />
the MFI industry and help MFI managers make appropriate<br />
advancements.<br />
Most MF<strong>Is</strong>, including ProCredit Nic, currently report unadjusted<br />
solvency, measured by total equity to total assets. The example<br />
calculates unadjusted rates, based upon available data.<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
31
FEATURE ARTICLES<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
Table 1 Calculations - Capital Adequacy Ratio<br />
Ratio 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008<br />
Capital Adequacy Ratio (%) (Calculated using Total Equity/Total Assets)<br />
Total Equity 7,424,151 13,416,553 13,629,654 18,640,607 16,790,418<br />
÷ Total Assets 52,736,154 81,200,105 112,702,315 149,823,237 170,953,075<br />
= Capital Adequacy Ratio 14.08% 16.52% 12.<strong>09</strong>% 12.44% 9.82%<br />
17 percent. Given all of these institutions operate<br />
in Nicaragua, the exogenous variables provide less<br />
contrast than internal factors to assess performance<br />
given these ratios.<br />
2) Uncovered Capital Ratio: Portfolio<br />
Quality and Vulnerability<br />
Term<br />
Uncovered Capital<br />
Ratio (UCR)<br />
Calculation<br />
PAR>30 days – Impairment Loss<br />
Allowance<br />
Total Capital<br />
Why this ratio is important<br />
Uncovered Capital Ratio (UCR) provides a more<br />
detailed indication of an MFI’s portfolio quality. It is<br />
recommended as an enhancement to the existing<br />
R9, (Adjusted) Portfolio at Risk Ratio. UCR is a more<br />
revealing ratio to assess vulnerability and potential<br />
loss whereas the previous ratio considered loans in<br />
arrears compared with the gross portfolio.<br />
How it is interpreted<br />
Uncovered Capital Ratio is calculated by<br />
obtaining the Portfolio at Risk (PAR) greater than<br />
thirty days minus impairment loss allowance<br />
divided by total capital. When considered in<br />
conjunction with the capital adequacy ratio, UCR<br />
allows an additional dimension for understanding<br />
capital sufficiency.<br />
A low ratio suggests better risk management,<br />
indicating the MFI is less susceptible to losses above<br />
what it has already provisioned. MF<strong>Is</strong> should aim to<br />
maintain UCR as low as possible, certainly less than<br />
25 percent. As more extensive comparative data is<br />
analyzed, more revealing benchmarks will be available.<br />
This ratio is a more detailed assessment of the risks<br />
faced by a portfolio than the previous PAR>30 days,<br />
which will interest managers and investors.<br />
Specific calculation<br />
In 2008, ProCredit Nic’s UCR was -5.86 percent.<br />
Mathematical calculations for ProCredit Nic’s UCR<br />
between 2004 and 2008 are as follows.<br />
Between 2004 and 2008, ProCredit Nic maintained<br />
UCR ranging from -18.31 percent to -5.86 percent,<br />
showing ‘improvements’ from 2004-07 as the<br />
organization had more than adequate impairment<br />
allowances compared with the PAR>30 day. Portfolio<br />
quality decreased heavily in 2008, the allowance<br />
was still more than sufficient. The ratio also implies<br />
its CAR may reflect understated solvency. The<br />
institution likely has sufficient capital to insulate it<br />
from high, unexpected losses given current portfolio<br />
quality.<br />
Table 2 Calculations - Uncovered Capital Ratio<br />
Ratio 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008<br />
Uncovered Capital Ratio (%) (Calculated using Total Equity)<br />
PAR> 30 Days 589,690 1,243,369 1,599,649 1,816,406 6,415,863<br />
- Impairment Allowances 1,437,806 2,860,024 3,705,435 5,229,575 7,399,503<br />
Total Amount at Risk -848,116 -1,616,655 -2,105,786 -3,413,169 -983,640<br />
÷ Total Equity 7,424,151 13,416,553 13,629,654 18,640,607 16,790,418<br />
Uncovered Capital Ratio -11.42% -12.05% -15.45% -18.31% -5.86%<br />
<br />
These percentages result from unadjusted Uncovered Capital<br />
Ratio computations. Total Equity was used in place of Total<br />
Capital in the equation’s denominator based on the data<br />
available. A more accurate measure would be to conduct the<br />
adjustments to arrive at Total Capital.<br />
32<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
FEATURE ARTICLES<br />
3) Foreign Currency Risk Ratio:<br />
Susceptibility to Shocks for Foreign<br />
Exchange<br />
Term<br />
Foreign Currency<br />
Risk Ratio<br />
Calculation<br />
Why this ratio is important<br />
(Total Foreign Currency A Assets –<br />
Total Foreign Currency A<br />
Liabilities)/ Total Equity<br />
The Foreign Currency Risk Ratio measures the<br />
relationship between an MFI’s net foreign currency<br />
assets and its equity for each foreign currency on the<br />
balance sheet. By documenting foreign exchange (f/x)<br />
exposure, an MFI more transparently reveals its risk to<br />
such shocks.<br />
Calculating this ratio will require MF<strong>Is</strong> to compute<br />
and report net foreign currency assets for each<br />
foreign currency in which it holds assets or<br />
liabilities. This may result in additional administrative<br />
effort, at least initially, but it is an essential part of<br />
managing foreign currency risk. Reporting this<br />
additional data is critical in helping the institution<br />
mange its f/x exposure and helping investors<br />
understand the type of capital, which could react<br />
to liquidity or other crises in the wake of sudden<br />
rate shifts.<br />
How it is interpreted<br />
The lower foreign currency risk ratio a MFI<br />
maintains, the more limited its vulnerability to<br />
changes in foreign currency values. The higher its<br />
f/x ratio is, the more risk the MFI faces, which may<br />
or may not lead to negative performance. Formal<br />
industry benchmarks have yet to be established;<br />
however, a rule of thumb of no more than 20 percent<br />
ceiling has been cited, although the amount will<br />
vary depending on currency stability and may be<br />
lower. Local regulatory bodies may have specific<br />
requirements.<br />
Specific calculation<br />
The majority of MF<strong>Is</strong>, including ProCredit Nic, do not<br />
currently report foreign currency risk measures. This<br />
highlights a troubling gap in transparency, which this<br />
ratio seeks to fill. Because many MF<strong>Is</strong> have international<br />
cash flows, they may hold assets and liabilities in other<br />
currencies. An MFI with robust measures of Capital<br />
Adequacy and Uncovered Capital may still face<br />
insolvency risk due to f/x exposure. Stakeholders and<br />
investors have a particular interest in this new ratio.<br />
To provide an illustrative mathematical example,<br />
we performed calculations assuming ProCredit Nic<br />
maintains a 12 percent f/x exposure in each year.<br />
4) Average Deposits Balance per Account:<br />
Client Profile & Savings Program<br />
Take-up<br />
Term<br />
Average Deposits Balance<br />
per Deposit Account<br />
Average Deposits Balance<br />
per Deposit Account<br />
Holder<br />
Calculation<br />
Total Deposits<br />
Number of Deposit Accounts<br />
Total Deposits<br />
Number of Deposit Account<br />
Holders<br />
Why this ratio is important<br />
This new ratio, Average Deposits Balance per Deposit<br />
Account (Holder), helps an institution gauge its client<br />
base in terms of the amount of savings placed in the<br />
institution. It also reflects the degree to which savings<br />
products address client needs. Evaluation of this<br />
ratio provides insights into average deposit account<br />
size, a proxy for client wealth. Considering a client’s<br />
economic profile contributes to an MFI assessing<br />
mission adherence.<br />
How it is interpreted<br />
Average Deposits Balance can be expressed per<br />
deposit account or deposit account holder. It is<br />
Table 3 Calculations - Ratio on Foreign Currency Risk<br />
Ratio 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008<br />
Ratio on Foreign Currency Risk (%)<br />
Absolute Value of Net Foreign Assets 9 890,898 1,6<strong>09</strong>,986 1,635,558 2,236,873 2,014,850<br />
÷ Total Equity 7,424,151 13,416,553 13,629,654 18,640,607 16,790,418<br />
Ratio on Foreign Currency Risk 12.00% 12.00% 12.00% 12.00% 12.00%<br />
<br />
See Women’s World Banking Financial Management, discussion<br />
with investors, due diligence standards of investors, etc.<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
33
FEATURE ARTICLES<br />
calculated by dividing the total amount of deposits<br />
held by the institution by the number of accounts<br />
it manages, or alternatively, the number of account<br />
holders it serves.<br />
An appropriate average deposits balance target will<br />
depend on an institution’s mission and objectives.<br />
Trends over time will provide insightful information<br />
for managers, particularly as they test different savings<br />
products and move into different regions. Ratio results<br />
can also be cross-indexed with non-financial data,<br />
such as GNI per capita to allow for comparison across<br />
countries.<br />
Multiple possible explanations for ratio changes over<br />
time require managers to apply qualitative analytics<br />
to the interpretation of ratio outcomes to understand<br />
why a trend is up or down. In most cases, an institution<br />
would hope to see a positive trend, implying clients<br />
are increasingly using savings products and have more<br />
disposable capital to save. A decreasing trend could<br />
indicate savers pulling money out or a bad economy.<br />
But there could be explanations for a desirable<br />
decreasing trend in average deposits balance, such<br />
as high numbers of new account holders or an<br />
institution going ‘down market’. This contributes to<br />
risk management, as a smaller average loan amount<br />
indicates a more disperse deposit base which implies<br />
more widespread savers/less concentration, and<br />
therefore lower risk of deposit flight.<br />
Specific calculation<br />
ProCredit Nic’s average deposit account balance<br />
declined over 2004-08, as indicated in the<br />
calculations.<br />
The decrease is consistent when calculating average<br />
balance per depositor and per deposit account,<br />
suggesting most depositors hold a single account.<br />
Managers may initially be concerned over this<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
decrease as a potential sign the MFI is failing to offer<br />
desirable products. However, the total number of<br />
deposit accounts grew exponentially, from 5,329 in<br />
2004 to 276,088 in 2008.<br />
We could see this as a highly positive trend if we<br />
assume that ProCredit is seeking to provide relevant<br />
savings products to a large, low-income client-base.<br />
As the savings program matured, and likely cultivated<br />
consumer confidence, it was able to attract a larger,<br />
relatively less wealthy client-base. These individuals<br />
are more inclined to hold smaller deposit balances.<br />
5) Yield on Liquidity and<br />
Investments: Efficiency in Managing<br />
Cash and Investments<br />
Term<br />
Yield on Liquidity<br />
and Investments<br />
Why this ratio is important<br />
Calculation<br />
Financial Revenue from Investments<br />
Average Cash + Average Trade<br />
Investments + Average Other<br />
Investments<br />
Yield on Liquidity and Investment Ratio indicates the<br />
level of returns an institution is generating from its<br />
cash holdings and investments averaged over a given<br />
period. It provides a meaningful measure of efficiency<br />
in managing cash flows and investments.<br />
How it is interpreted<br />
The yield on liquidity and investments is particularly<br />
insightful when compared to prevailing local market<br />
rates. It reveals how well the MFI generates revenue<br />
from its resources outside of its loan portfolio. A<br />
higher ratio indicates comparatively higher returns.<br />
Benchmarks are best taken at the national level and<br />
vary by country and region.<br />
Table 4 Calculations - Average Deposit Balance per Depositor and Deposit account<br />
Ratio 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008<br />
Average Deposits Balance per Depositor<br />
Total Deposits 16,317,259 24,813,799 43,069,463 57,606,043 74,999,671<br />
÷ Number of Depositors 5,392 35,471 84,925 121,783 276,088<br />
= Average Deposits Balance per Depositor 3,026 700 507 473 272<br />
Average Deposit Balance per Deposit Account<br />
Total Deposits 16,317,259 24,813,799 43,069,463 57,606,043 74,999,671<br />
÷ Number of deposit accounts 5,392 43,175 112,335 158,318 276,088<br />
= Average Deposits Balance per Deposit<br />
Account<br />
3,026 575 383 364 272<br />
34<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
FEATURE ARTICLES<br />
Specific calculation<br />
ProCredit Nic, on average, earned less than 1 percent<br />
on its capital and investments over the period<br />
2004-08. Its highest yield was in 2004, at 0.5 percent.<br />
According to the data, the MFI is holding increasing<br />
amounts of cash over the period and decreasing<br />
financial revenue from investments. As the<br />
organization grows, it is logical it requires more cash<br />
on hand. However, that money does not appear to<br />
generate income for the organization.<br />
The yield on liquidity and investments ratio was<br />
computed for two other Nicaraguan MF<strong>Is</strong>. Banex<br />
earned at least one percent from 2005 through<br />
2008. 2006 was its best year, with a 1.55 percent<br />
yield. FDL earned as high as 9.9 percent in one<br />
year. This suggests that ProCredit is less efficient in<br />
leveraging its liquidity and investments to produce<br />
revenue. Ninety day Nicaraguan interest rates were<br />
often above 8 percent over that time, providing a<br />
theoretical alternative. Even overnight bank rates<br />
were generating 2 percent in local currency. The MFI<br />
did not appear to be putting its money to work for<br />
itself. More investigation into the reason for that may<br />
be warranted, particularly into its treasury policies.<br />
6) Savings Liquidity: Institutional Ability<br />
to Cover Withdrawals<br />
Why this ratio is important<br />
Savings Liquidity ratio measures an institution’s ability<br />
to accommodate withdrawals from deposits. If an<br />
MFI does not hold an adequate level of cash to cover<br />
large or unanticipated withdrawals from its deposit<br />
accounts, it risks a liquidity crunch or even insolvency.<br />
The ability to cover sudden, substantive withdrawals<br />
is particularly important for MF<strong>Is</strong> serving clients with<br />
lumpy consumption patterns, regular loan cycles,<br />
seasonal impacts and/or economic crises.<br />
How it is interpreted<br />
This ratio documents the amount of liquid assets<br />
held per unit of deposits. Regulated institutions<br />
are generally required to hold a specified minimum<br />
of total demand deposits in reserves by their local<br />
regulators. MF<strong>Is</strong> not required to hold reserves<br />
against demand deposits should maintain cash in an<br />
appropriate amount given deposit levels. Appropriate<br />
targets are derived through historical experience<br />
of the institution, local operating conditions, and<br />
national environmental factors. This ratio supports<br />
compliance with international banking standards. The<br />
reserve requirement on deposits varies widely across<br />
countries – from 2 percent in the Euro zone to 19<br />
percent in Croatia to 80 percent in Jordan. MF<strong>Is</strong> have<br />
tended to maintain levels higher than local banks, to<br />
guard against a weaker reputation and provide client<br />
confidence.<br />
Term<br />
Ratio on Savings<br />
Liquidity<br />
Calculation<br />
Reserves against deposits as<br />
required by regulator plus<br />
unrestricted cash + undrawn portion<br />
Total Demand Deposits<br />
Specific calculation<br />
The Framework, given its focus on credit, did not<br />
account for any savings ratios. The data is not<br />
currently presented by MIX Market, but it can<br />
Table 5 Calculations - Yield on Liquidity and Investments<br />
Ratio 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008<br />
Yield on Liquidity and Investments (%)<br />
Financial revenue from<br />
44,858 46,477 38,621 67,089 15,823<br />
investments<br />
Cash and cash equivalents 7,002,690 10,405,297 15,139,023 18,233,458 24,898,459<br />
Total trade and receivables 1,893,110 3,497,496 6,060,768 7,751,731 7,387,874<br />
Other investments 0 0 0 0 0<br />
÷ Sum of Cash, Trade and Other 8,895,800 13,902,793 21,199,791 25,985,189 32,286,333<br />
Investments<br />
= Yield on Liquidity and<br />
Investments<br />
0.5043% 0.3343% 0.1822% 0.2582% 0.0490%<br />
<br />
Central Bank data.<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
35
FEATURE ARTICLES<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
Table 6 Calculations - Ratio on Saving Liquidity<br />
Ratio 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008<br />
Ratio on Savings Liquidity<br />
Cash and cash equivalents 7,002,690 10,405,297 15,139,023 18,233,458 24,898,459<br />
÷ Total Demand Deposits 16,317,259 24,813,799 43,069,463 57,606,043 74,999,671<br />
= Ratio on Savings Liquidity 0.429158476 0.419335105 0.351502479 0.316519883 0.33198<strong>09</strong>1<br />
readily be added. For the purposes of this analysis,<br />
an approximated measure of savings liquidity was<br />
derived by determining the institution’s cash and cash<br />
equivalents holdings per demand deposit. By this<br />
gauge, ProCredit Nic savings liquidity ratio fell from<br />
USD$0.43 to USD$0.33 over 2004-08.<br />
At any given time, the institution can accommodate<br />
withdrawals between 31 percent and 43 percent of<br />
its total demand deposits. As a point of comparison,<br />
BANEX’s approximated ratio on savings liquidity<br />
for the same period using the same analysis ranges<br />
between USD 0.61 and USD 1.<strong>09</strong>. Ratios over USD 1.00<br />
demonstrate enough liquidity to cover all deposits,<br />
which may indicate excessive cash. BANEX would<br />
be able to accommodate a higher percentage of<br />
withdrawals than ProCredit Nic. Economic instability,<br />
reputation risk, and other factors influence what<br />
appropriate levels are. The comparative analysis is<br />
interesting, as is the trend over time. They require<br />
local knowledge to consider this performance versus<br />
normal or healthy. 10<br />
7) Effective Financial Expense of Savings:<br />
Cost of Interest Payments on Deposits<br />
Term<br />
Effective Financial<br />
Expense of Savings<br />
Why this ratio is important<br />
Calculation<br />
Total Interest Expense of Savings<br />
Average Savings Balance<br />
The Effective Financial Expense of Savings ratio<br />
measures how much interest an MFI pays out for<br />
savings. It is computed based on the total savings<br />
interest expense and the average savings balance<br />
between beginning and end of period. This considers<br />
the effective interest rate the savings pays. It allows<br />
comparison between institutions within a given<br />
market and comparison to a market benchmark.<br />
It is also an important check between the stated<br />
interest rate paid to depositors and the actual interest<br />
expense.<br />
How it is interpreted<br />
The numerical value of this ratio has little meaning in<br />
and of itself. When weighed against interest expense<br />
presented by other options, it allows an institution to<br />
evaluate the opportunity cost of its current savings<br />
program. If the savings program incurs higher<br />
expense than other market opportunities, managers<br />
may consider lowering interest rates they offer on<br />
deposits or restructuring their program. In assessing<br />
appropriate savings offerings, managers must<br />
consider product financial viability.<br />
Specific calculation<br />
In 2008, ProCredit Nic reported Effective Financial<br />
Expense on Savings Ratio of .05. This is based upon<br />
the following calculation.<br />
This implies the MFI paid USD .05 in interest to<br />
depositors for each dollar held. To evaluate market<br />
appropriateness, management could compare this<br />
ratio to interest expense they would incur from<br />
alternate activities. Management could track this<br />
rate to local prevailing interest rates, to see how well<br />
Table 7 Calculations - Effective Financial Expense of Saving<br />
Ratio 2008<br />
Effective Financial Expense of Savings<br />
Interest expense on deposits 3,844,198<br />
÷ Average Total Deposits Balance 75,<strong>09</strong>5,936<br />
= Effective Financial Expense on Savings 0.05<br />
10 These computations are rough proxies only and underscore the<br />
need for more accurate, standardized calculation.<br />
36<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
their institution does in the marketplace in terms of<br />
competition (and also in terms of the next alternative<br />
investment choice).<br />
8) Effective Operating Expense of Savings:<br />
Cost of Running Savings Program<br />
Term<br />
Effective Operating<br />
Expense of Savings<br />
Calculation<br />
Why this ratio is important<br />
Direct and Indirect Operating<br />
Expenses Allocated to Savings<br />
Average Savings Balance<br />
The Effective Operating Expense of Savings Ratio tells<br />
an MFI how expensive it is to run its savings program<br />
in terms of all non-interest expenditures, including<br />
administrative fees and personnel wages. This ratio<br />
indicates if an MFI accrues gains or losses from<br />
deposit mobilization for costs incurred administering<br />
savings.<br />
How it is interpreted<br />
The total cost of the institution’s savings program<br />
per deposit, or the combined financial and operating<br />
expenses, should be compared to other liability<br />
and equity options to evaluate the opportunity<br />
cost of savings. If the cost relative to other options<br />
is too high, the MFI can adjust the interest it pays<br />
on deposit accounts to lower its total expenditure<br />
on savings, seek to conduct its operations more<br />
efficiently, or cut programmatic costs. A high ratio<br />
may indicate prohibitively high staff time required<br />
for savings. Tracking the ratio over time could<br />
measure if adopted operational and process flow<br />
changes have shown results. There is not one specific<br />
‘right’ amount, as savings may be worth offering at<br />
a avariety of expense levels. However, it is valuable<br />
to differentiate costs by product and track trends to<br />
assess performance.<br />
Specific calculation<br />
FEATURE ARTICLES<br />
Currently, most MF<strong>Is</strong> do not report differentiated<br />
operating expenses but rather an aggregate measure<br />
of operating expense. Given ProCredit Nic’s current<br />
reporting on MIX Market, it is not possible to make an<br />
exact calculation for this ratio. This ratio will require<br />
either some form of activity based costing or fairly<br />
reliable allocation of operating expenses. MF<strong>Is</strong> entering<br />
deposit mobilization will need this information for<br />
both planning and monitoring purposes.<br />
To provide a mathematical example, an approximation<br />
is offered here based on data ProCredit Nic does<br />
provide.<br />
An approximation is provided using total<br />
operating expenses allocated per unit of savings<br />
held, which fell from USD 0.44 to 0.26 over 2004-<br />
08. Assuming the savings expense is 40 percent<br />
of the total operating budget, ProCredit Nic ratio<br />
fell from USD 0.18 to 0.10 over that period. Given<br />
2008 financial expenditure on savings (USD .05)<br />
and the estimated operating expenditure on<br />
savings (.11), the institution’s approximated total<br />
expenditure on savings per unit of deposits was<br />
0.16. Such tracking of the performance of savings<br />
programs is a new opportunity for managers with<br />
these new ratios. As the number of deposit holding<br />
institutions increases, understanding their efficiency<br />
and effectiveness at that part of the business is<br />
increasingly important.<br />
Summary and Road Forward<br />
For the first time since initial publication of the<br />
Framework, industry stakeholders are proposing<br />
amendments to microfinance financial reporting<br />
standards. The drafted eight new ratios and related<br />
disclosures presented in this paper seek to increase<br />
informative measures of capital adequacy positions<br />
and savings. Developing these new ratios relies on<br />
Table 8 Calculations - Effective Operating Expense of Saving<br />
Ratio 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008<br />
Effective Operating Expense of Saving (Assuming 40% of Total Operating Expense)<br />
Operating expense 7,176,474 9,423,456 14,828,347 18,024,910 19,822,929<br />
÷ Total Demand Deposits 16,317,259 24,825,625 43,024,305 57,627,752 75,<strong>09</strong>5,936<br />
= Effective Total Operating Expense<br />
0.44 0.38 0.34 0.31 0.26<br />
per Deposit<br />
x 0.40 0.40 0.40 0.40 0.40<br />
= Effective Total Operating Expense<br />
of Savings<br />
0.18 0.15 0.14 0.13 0.11<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
37
FEATURE ARTICLES<br />
additional disclosures around currency exposures<br />
and funding costs tracked by product. The ratios<br />
were selected based upon input from dozens of<br />
practitioners and other industry stakeholders.<br />
Establishing an on-going method for addressing<br />
standards in microfinance facilitates regular<br />
improvements to reporting. A standards process<br />
reduces transaction costs and more efficiently adopts<br />
innovations. The SEEP Network, as the Secretariat for<br />
the MFI Reporting Standards Initiative, provides these<br />
drafts and models to encourage dialogue among<br />
industry stakeholders towards a common goal of<br />
more accurate and transparent financial reporting<br />
standards.<br />
The eight new ratios add significant depth of analysis<br />
and new dimensions. The capital adequacy and foreign<br />
exchange ratios help better define the well being of<br />
the institution and require additional information to<br />
do so. As microfinance savings programs are often still<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
in their infancy, it is critical institutions adopt more<br />
precise measures of their expenditure on savings<br />
to evaluate the opportunity costs of running these<br />
programs. This will be critical to adapting, scaling<br />
and creating sustainability. Additionally, tracking<br />
savings ratios will help enable an MFI to determine<br />
an appropriate and optimal spread between the rate<br />
paid out on savings, and the rate charged on loan<br />
products.<br />
These changes to the Framework move MF<strong>Is</strong> to more<br />
accepted global accounting guidelines, including<br />
Basel II and IFRS, and serve as a ready platform to better<br />
align national reporting standards. The proposed<br />
revisions are intended not only to accommodate<br />
current changes in the microfinance industry but also<br />
anticipate evolutions the industry will undergo into the<br />
future, thus enabling faster growth and better access<br />
to affordable capital for people worldwide. Input and<br />
feedback from industry stakeholders is encouraged to<br />
the MFI Reporting Standards Initiative.<br />
38<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
BULLETIN HIGHLIGHTS<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, <strong>Dec</strong>ember 20<strong>09</strong><br />
Operating Efficiency: Victim to<br />
the Crisis<br />
Blaine Stephens, Chief Operating Officer and<br />
Director of Analysis, MIX<br />
As the world watched the financial crisis and<br />
ensuing economic slowdown unfold in<br />
developed economies in late 2008, observers<br />
of microfinance braced themselves for the fallout<br />
on microfinance institutions, some of which began<br />
to appear by the end of 2008. The exact causes and<br />
their contributory impacts will still take time to<br />
work out. How did rising food and fuel prices affect<br />
credit needs of poor households and their<br />
businesses To what extent did changes in the<br />
financial markets impact MFI growth through<br />
greater pressure on MFI capital raising and<br />
refinancing needs Would diminished household<br />
revenues from slower remittance flows and local<br />
economic slowdown put significant pressure on<br />
portfolio quality and lead to slowdown in credit<br />
growth Whatever the combination of causes,<br />
stress signs appeared in microfinance institutional<br />
performance by the end of 2008, as growth rates<br />
slowed, profit margins tightened and, in some<br />
countries, portfolio quality deteriorated. These<br />
Highlights look at the major trends in institutional<br />
performance and explore the impact of slowed<br />
growth on operating costs.<br />
The 2008 Microfinance Benchmarks capture the<br />
operational and financial performance of nearly<br />
1,100 MF<strong>Is</strong> from just under 100 countries. These<br />
reference points mark the first global data set of<br />
this magnitude to capture the impact of the crisis<br />
and economic slowdown on the operational and<br />
financial performance of MF<strong>Is</strong>. Together, 2008<br />
benchmarked MF<strong>Is</strong> served 74 million borrowers<br />
with 38 billion USD in loans, and collected 23<br />
billion USD in deposits from 67 million depositors.<br />
The subsequent analysis also makes use of a<br />
trend lines data set of 600 MF<strong>Is</strong> from 84 countries<br />
and representing 89 percent of the borrowers<br />
served in the full 2008 benchmarks data set. Taken<br />
together, the 2008 benchmarks and 2006-08 historical<br />
data offers a robust prism through which to analyze<br />
the changes in MFI performance at the onset of the<br />
financial crisis and economic downturn.<br />
2008 Performance At-a-Glance<br />
As global economic growth slowed in 2008,<br />
microfinance institutions around the globe began to<br />
feel the impact in their own portfolios and performance.<br />
The sustained expansion in borrowers served in the<br />
first part of the decade ceded to slower growth and<br />
rising operating costs by 2008. The following graphics<br />
highlight some of the more important trends:<br />
• While banks in developed markets severely<br />
restrained lending by the end of 2008,<br />
microfinance institutions continued to<br />
expand access to credit, albeit at lower<br />
growth rates than in previous periods. For<br />
the typical institution, borrower growth rates<br />
(approximately 25 percent per annum up<br />
through 2007) slowed to nearly 15 percent<br />
in 2008. Loan portfolio growth in USD terms<br />
(20 percent) fell to similar levels. Leading<br />
markets, however, did not always follow<br />
regional trends. In Asia, while borrower growth<br />
fell for MF<strong>Is</strong> in the Philippines and Bangladesh,<br />
India’s total outreach actually increased by<br />
nearly 65 percent in 2008, up from 50 percent<br />
a year earlier. At the other end of the spectrum,<br />
the Moroccan market contracted its total<br />
credit outreach by just under 10 percent in<br />
2008, faced with overlending and worsening<br />
portfolio quality throughout the portfolio,<br />
whereas Egypt, Jordan and other countries in<br />
the Middle East/North Africa region expanded<br />
access, but at slower rates. (Figure 1).<br />
• Evidence from past crises has shown that<br />
microcredit arrears do rise in periods<br />
of economic slowdown, but that these<br />
delayed payments do not translate into<br />
significant portfolio loss. 2008 MFI repayment<br />
performance confirms these findings, as<br />
portfolio delinquency increased in several<br />
regions during the year; however, a handful<br />
of markets represented much of this change.<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
39
BULLETIN HIGHLIGHTS<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
Figure 1: Growth in borrowers slows, 2006–08<br />
60%<br />
50%<br />
40%<br />
30%<br />
20%<br />
10%<br />
0%<br />
2007<br />
2008<br />
2007<br />
2008<br />
2007<br />
2008<br />
2007<br />
2008<br />
2007<br />
2008<br />
Africa Asia ECA LAC MENA<br />
Figure 2: Arrears rise, but risk coverage<br />
remains high, 2006–08<br />
6%<br />
5%<br />
4%<br />
3%<br />
2%<br />
1%<br />
0%<br />
2006<br />
2007<br />
2008<br />
2006<br />
2007<br />
2008<br />
2006<br />
2007<br />
2008<br />
2006<br />
2007<br />
2008<br />
2006<br />
2007<br />
2008<br />
140%<br />
120%<br />
100%<br />
80%<br />
60%<br />
40%<br />
20%<br />
0%<br />
Middle 50%<br />
Growth, borrowers (median)<br />
Growth, borrowers (total)<br />
Source: MIX data 2006-08. Data are for a balanced panel of MF<strong>Is</strong> and<br />
represent medians, unless otherwise indicated.<br />
Africa Asia ECA LAC MENA<br />
PAR>30 Write-off Risk coverage<br />
Source: MIX data 2006-08. Data are for a balanced panel of MF<strong>Is</strong> and<br />
represent medians, unless otherwise indicated.<br />
In some high growth markets, like Morocco<br />
and Bosnia, delinquency rose in 2008,<br />
doubling in both cases, but to levels lower<br />
than 5 percent. Other high growth markets,<br />
like India, however saw no significant change<br />
in delinquency.<br />
• Even as delinquency rose in 2008, MF<strong>Is</strong><br />
carried very low levels of uncovered credit<br />
risk exposure. Many regions provisioned<br />
at over 100 percent of portfolio at risk over<br />
30 days. This provisioning provided a cushion<br />
against immediate loss, with MF<strong>Is</strong> in markets<br />
like Morocco and Bosnia drawing down on<br />
the cushion as arrears rose early in 20<strong>09</strong>.<br />
Small scale MF<strong>Is</strong> proved an exception to this<br />
rule and carried the most uncovered credit<br />
risk, with risk coverage levels dropping to<br />
80 percent of portfolio at risk over 30 days in<br />
2008, even as these institutions faced higher<br />
delinquency levels than their larger peers.<br />
(Figure 2)<br />
• Profits margins narrowed further in 2008.<br />
Changes in MFI funding structures raised<br />
financing costs in at least two regions. MF<strong>Is</strong><br />
in both Eastern Europe and Central Asia<br />
(ECA) and in the Middle East and North Africa<br />
(MENA) witnessed a one percentage point<br />
increase in funding outlays relative to total<br />
assets, a trend that continued throughout<br />
the period. Other regions, by comparison,<br />
experienced increases of less than half that<br />
rate. This shift continued to underscore<br />
the cross-border debt and local market<br />
refinancing activity that has expanded<br />
rapidly in both regions in the last few years,<br />
replacing subsidized funding from prior<br />
periods. (Figure 3, Figure 4)<br />
• The persistent decline in microcredit<br />
delivery costs slowed by 2007 and actually<br />
reversed for most regions in 2008, putting<br />
further pressure on profit margins in 2008.<br />
Figure 3: MF<strong>Is</strong> continue to leverage capital,<br />
2006–08<br />
70%<br />
60%<br />
50%<br />
40%<br />
30%<br />
20%<br />
10%<br />
0%<br />
2006<br />
2007<br />
2008<br />
2006<br />
2007<br />
2008<br />
2006<br />
2007<br />
2008<br />
2006<br />
2007<br />
2008<br />
2006<br />
2007<br />
Africa Asia ECA LAC MENA<br />
Capital/Assets<br />
Debt-to-equity (x)<br />
2008<br />
Deposits-to-loans<br />
Source: MIX data 2006-08. Data are for a balanced panel of MF<strong>Is</strong> and<br />
represent medians, unless otherwise indicated.<br />
6<br />
5<br />
4<br />
3<br />
2<br />
1<br />
0<br />
40<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
Figure 4: Returns narrow, 2006-08<br />
35%<br />
30%<br />
25%<br />
20%<br />
15%<br />
10%<br />
5%<br />
0%<br />
BULLETIN HIGHLIGHTS<br />
Figure 5: <strong>Dec</strong>lining costs reverse course,<br />
2006–08<br />
35%<br />
30%<br />
25%<br />
20%<br />
15%<br />
10%<br />
5%<br />
0%<br />
2006<br />
2007<br />
2008<br />
2006<br />
2007<br />
2008<br />
2006<br />
2007<br />
2008<br />
2006<br />
2007<br />
2008<br />
2006<br />
2007<br />
2008<br />
2006<br />
2007<br />
2008<br />
2006<br />
2007<br />
2008<br />
2006<br />
2007<br />
2008<br />
2006<br />
2007<br />
2008<br />
2006<br />
2007<br />
2008<br />
Africa Asia ECA LAC MENA<br />
Africa Asia ECA LAC MENA<br />
Operating Expense<br />
Financial Expense<br />
Impairment Loss<br />
Financial Revenue<br />
Cost per borrower/GNI per capita<br />
Operating Expense/GLP<br />
Source: MIX data 2006-08. Data are for a balanced panel of MF<strong>Is</strong> and<br />
represent medians, unless otherwise indicated.<br />
Source: MIX data 2006-08. Data are for a balanced panel of MF<strong>Is</strong> and<br />
represent medians, unless otherwise indicated.<br />
The typical African MFI witnessed the<br />
largest increase in operating costs, with<br />
costs per borrower rising 15 percent relative<br />
to local income levels from 2006 to 2008.<br />
Only Asian MF<strong>Is</strong> held costs steady over the<br />
period, but even this flat line masks diverse<br />
operating costs across the region. Efficiency<br />
gains in Indian and Afghan MFI costs<br />
counterbalanced increases in markets like<br />
Cambodia. (Figure 5)<br />
Slower Growth Puts Pressure<br />
on MFI Operating Models<br />
The strong growth in microfinance borrower<br />
outreach over the last decade underlines the mission<br />
of MF<strong>Is</strong> focused on expanding access to financial<br />
services, particularly credit, by poor households<br />
lacking reliable access to such services. These growth<br />
rates inform all aspects of an MFI’s business planning,<br />
from projections for growth trends in start-up<br />
institutions, to operational planning for new points<br />
or services, from planning needs for new financing<br />
to the design of incentive systems used to keep<br />
staff focused on sustainably expanding the reach<br />
of credit services. Raised in a global climate of 25<br />
percent annual expansion in borrowers for most of<br />
this decade, MF<strong>Is</strong>, one can imagine, may have based<br />
their planning on similar levels of future growth. But<br />
what happens when actual growth slows down, not<br />
for a few MF<strong>Is</strong>, but across the board Indeed, what<br />
does the microfinance business look like when the<br />
majority of markets – 60 out of 85 countries tracked<br />
(Figure 6) over the 2006 - 2008 period – experience<br />
slower growth rates<br />
Improved efficiency would appear to be among the<br />
first victims of slower growth. Over the last several<br />
years, these Highlights and other reviews of global<br />
MFI performance data have underscored the gradual<br />
improvements in operating costs, which, at nearly<br />
two-thirds of total costs, represent the biggest<br />
barrier to more affordable access to credit services<br />
by microfinance clients. In the 2002–2005 period, for<br />
example, global yields on microcredit portfolio rates<br />
dropped nearly three percentage points, without loss<br />
in profitability, backed by declines in operating costs.<br />
Productivity gains played an important part in these<br />
gains in efficiency.<br />
In the beginning of the 2006–08 period, operating<br />
costs leveled off at a global and regional level. Almost<br />
all regions experienced flat cost trends between<br />
2006 and 2007, with the global weighted average<br />
staying at 4.5 percent of GNI per capita for both years.<br />
By the end of the period, this trend towards greater<br />
efficiency may have hit its first peak in this global<br />
slowdown of microfinance outreach. For all but a<br />
handful of markets that experienced slower growth<br />
in borrower outreach in 2008, costs associated with<br />
serving a single borrower increased when normalized<br />
for differences in local income levels (Figure 6). <strong>Is</strong><br />
there a link between slowing growth rates and rising<br />
operating costs<br />
Trends in staffing point to one explanation for<br />
this reversal of efficiency gains. Microfinance, a<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
41
BULLETIN HIGHLIGHTS<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
Figure 6: Costs start to rise as growth slows<br />
Growth in borrowers<br />
Cost per borrower/GNI per capita<br />
Country 2006–07 2007–08 Trend 2007 2008 Trend<br />
Africa 22% 14% Down 16.0% 18.4% Up<br />
Benin -5% 28% Up 34.8% 30.2% Down<br />
Ethiopia 12% 14% Up 4.1% 5.2% Up<br />
Ghana 15% 18% Up 22.6% 25.6% Up<br />
Kenya 57% 14% Down 19.2% 23.1% Up<br />
Mali -2% -1% Up 12.3% 14.8% Up<br />
Mozambique 25% 9% Down 76.5% 98.3% Up<br />
Senegal 7% -4% Down 18.0% 26.7% Up<br />
Tanzania -3% 13% Up 29.7% 33.8% Up<br />
Uganda 13% 9% Down 76.5% 83.5% Up<br />
Asia 23% 22% Down 2.4% 2.9% Up<br />
Afghanistan 23% -1% Down 22.7% 30.8% Up<br />
Bangladesh 14% 4% Down 2.1% 2.4% Up<br />
Cambodia 32% 31% Down 13.6% 16.6% Up<br />
India 48% 65% Up 1.4% 1.5% Up<br />
Indonesia 67% 42% Down 1.5% 1.2% Down<br />
Nepal 2% 5% Up 4.4% 6.0% Up<br />
Pakistan 29% 24% Down 5.8% 4.7% Down<br />
Philippines 37% 19% Down 3.2% 3.5% Up<br />
ECA 34% 18% Down 14.8% 17.4% Up<br />
Albania 16% 21% Up 13.4% 15.6% Up<br />
Armenia 34% 32% Down 5.6% 6.5% Up<br />
Azerbaijan 70% 29% Down 8.0% 10.0% Up<br />
Bosnia and Herzegovina 53% 22% Down 6.4% 6.4% Down<br />
Bulgaria 25% 4% Down 15.0% 18.6% Up<br />
Georgia 15% 6% Down 15.2% 20.2% Up<br />
Kosovo 38% 26% Down 31.1% 30.4% Down<br />
Kyrgyzstan 48% 35% Down 23.0% 27.1% Up<br />
Russia 25% 11% Down 14.2% 17.1% Up<br />
Tajikistan 94% 24% Down 78.0% 87.8% Up<br />
LAC 19% 11% Down 5.7% 6.6% Up<br />
Bolivia 19% 12% Down 13.9% 17.9% Up<br />
Brazil -27% -2% Up 1.8% 2.4% Up<br />
Colombia 30% 12% Down 5.6% 6.0% Up<br />
Costa Rica 10% 8% Down 6.4% 7.3% Up<br />
Ecuador 14% 14% Up 6.2% 6.3% Up<br />
El Salvador 23% 8% Down 7.0% 7.5% Up<br />
Guatemala 29% 12% Down 4.6% 5.0% Up<br />
Honduras 22% -8% Down 9.1% 10.6% Up<br />
Mexico 30% 26% Down 1.7% 1.9% Up<br />
Nicaragua 15% 6% Down 16.7% 17.9% Up<br />
Paraguay 7% 23% Up 9.3% 12.7% Up<br />
Peru 28% 4% Down 4.8% 5.9% Up<br />
MENA 34% 6% Down 2.7% 3.1% Up<br />
Egypt 34% 31% Down 2.0% 2.1% Up<br />
Jordan 45% 19% Down 3.4% 3.7% Up<br />
Morocco 34% -6% Down 2.5% 3.1% Up<br />
Source: MIX data 2006–2008. Data are for a balance panel of MF<strong>Is</strong> and represent weighted averages by region and country for all countries with more<br />
five or more MF<strong>Is</strong> reporting over the period.<br />
42<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
high touch business, currently relies on significant<br />
human resources to deliver credit to clients.<br />
Many MF<strong>Is</strong> make significant investments in training<br />
new staff on the systems and processes that help<br />
identify clients, minimize credit risk, and manage<br />
service delivery of microloans. This combination<br />
of intensive personnel use and extensive training<br />
increases the lead time necessary for an MFI to gear<br />
up to serve more clients. When slowdowns have<br />
a rapid onset, MF<strong>Is</strong> will likely have already fielded<br />
new staff based on earlier projections, leaving<br />
the providers overstaffed compared to optimal<br />
productivity rates. Staffing and borrower growth<br />
trends bear out this analysis: MFI staffing increased<br />
faster than growth in borrowers in over twothirds<br />
of all markets where growth rates slowed<br />
in 2008. Figure 7 summarizes the impact of this<br />
phenomenon on productivity. As business slowed,<br />
productivity declined.<br />
Rising arrears offer another explanation for increased<br />
operating costs. As delayed repayments rise within<br />
a portfolio, staff must shift time from building and<br />
maintaining microcredit portfolios to recovering<br />
delinquent loans. This resource shift accentuates the<br />
trend already highlighted. At a global level, portfolio<br />
quality deteriorated by more than 50 percent in<br />
25 markets. Few arrears rates moved into double<br />
digits, but such increases represented a departure<br />
from historical performance. In all but one of these<br />
countries, the cost of serving borrowers also made a<br />
marked increase. As Figure 8 shows, countries with<br />
pronounced changes in delinquency rates, such<br />
as Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Honduras, Kenya, and<br />
Tajikistan, all experienced reversals in efficiency gains<br />
as portfolio quality deteriorated.<br />
BULLETIN HIGHLIGHTS<br />
Figure 7: Productivity declines as growth<br />
rates slow<br />
Change in growth in borrowers<br />
100%<br />
80%<br />
60%<br />
40%<br />
20%<br />
0%<br />
-100% -50% -20% 0% 50% 100%<br />
-40%<br />
-60%<br />
-80%<br />
-100%<br />
Change in productivity<br />
Source: MIX data 2006–2008. Data are for a balance panel of MF<strong>Is</strong> and<br />
represent weighted averages by country.<br />
Whatever the cause of slower growth rates – whether<br />
refinancing constraints from outside the MFI or<br />
MFI management reining in growth faced with<br />
rising credit risk – the impact on the microfinance<br />
business is tangible: an increased cost of delivering<br />
loans. To MFI managers, this poses an extra<br />
challenge of maintaining their business in difficult<br />
times while positioning themselves for growth<br />
and recovery as the economy improves. Laying off<br />
excess staff would cut costs, but the investment<br />
in training and relationships would be difficult<br />
to recover when lending opportunities rebound.<br />
Likewise, running an overstaffed MFI for more<br />
than a year would maintain a springboard for<br />
relaunching its growth trajectory, but the increased<br />
cost load will either eat into equity or increase costs<br />
Figure 8: Slowed growth with rising PAR push up operating costs<br />
100%<br />
80%<br />
60%<br />
40%<br />
20%<br />
0%<br />
-20%<br />
10.0%<br />
8.0%<br />
6.0%<br />
4.0%<br />
2.0%<br />
0.0%<br />
-2.0%<br />
2007<br />
2008<br />
2007<br />
2008<br />
2007<br />
2008<br />
2007<br />
2008<br />
2007<br />
2008<br />
2007<br />
2008<br />
2007<br />
2008<br />
2007<br />
2008<br />
2007<br />
2008<br />
Afghanistan Bangladesh El Salvador Guatemala Honduras Kenya Morocco Russia Tajikistan<br />
Growth in Borrowers Cost per Borrower/GNI per capita PAR > 30 days<br />
Source: MIX data 2006–2008. Data are for a balance panel of MF<strong>Is</strong> and represent weighted averages by country.<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
43
BULLETIN HIGHLIGHTS<br />
to clients in the long term. Microfinance analysts<br />
should monitor these cost trends in 20<strong>09</strong> and<br />
2010 to see whether MF<strong>Is</strong> manage to resume their<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
relentless pursuit of lower cost service or if this<br />
slowdown in the growth model marks an inflection<br />
point for microfinance.<br />
44<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
BULLETIN TABLES<br />
Introduction to the Peer Groups<br />
and Tables<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
Setting up Peer Groups<br />
The Bulletin Tables are designed to present<br />
performance benchmarks against which managers<br />
and directors of microfinance institutions can compare<br />
their institution’s performance with that of similar<br />
institution. Since the microfinance industry consists<br />
of a range of institutions and operating environments,<br />
some with very different characteristics, an MFI should<br />
be compared to similar institutions for the reference<br />
points to be useful.<br />
The Bulletin Tables address this issue with a peer<br />
group framework. Peer groups are sets of programs<br />
that have similar characteristics—similar enough that<br />
their managers find utility in comparing their results<br />
with those of other organizations in their peer group.<br />
The Bulletin Tables present peer groups on two bases:<br />
simple and compound peer groups.<br />
Simple Peer Groups look at MF<strong>Is</strong> based on a<br />
single characteristic. This allows users to analyze<br />
performance based on a common factor, such as<br />
age, location or scale of operations. MF<strong>Is</strong> have been<br />
grouped according to the following ten characteristics<br />
for this edition of the Bulletin:<br />
1) Age: The Bulletin Tables classify MF<strong>Is</strong> into three<br />
categories (new, young, and mature) based on<br />
the maturity of their microfinance operations.<br />
This is calculated as the difference between<br />
the year they started their microfinance<br />
operations and the year of data submitted by<br />
the institutions.<br />
2) Charter Type: The charter under which the<br />
MF<strong>Is</strong> are registered is used to classify the MF<strong>Is</strong><br />
as banks, credit unions/cooperatives, NGOs,<br />
and non bank financial institutions.<br />
3) Financial Intermediation: This classification<br />
measures the extent to which an MFI<br />
intermediates between savers and borrowers,<br />
funding its assets through mobilized deposits.<br />
It is calculated as a percentage of total assets<br />
funded by voluntary savings.<br />
4) Lending Methodology: Performance may vary<br />
by the way the institution delivers its loan<br />
products and serves borrowers. The Bulletin<br />
Tables present MF<strong>Is</strong> based on the primary<br />
methodology used, determined by the number<br />
and volume of loans outstanding.<br />
5) Outreach: Scale of outreach is measured as<br />
the total number of borrowers served.<br />
6) Profit Status: According to their registration,<br />
MF<strong>Is</strong> are classified as ‘not for profit’ and ‘for<br />
profit’ institutions.<br />
7) Region: MF<strong>Is</strong> are divided into five main<br />
geographic region: Africa, Asia, Eastern Europe<br />
and Central Asia (ECA), Latin America and the<br />
Caribbean (LAC) and Middle East and North<br />
Africa (MENA).<br />
8) Scale: Institutional scale is measured by the<br />
size of an institution’s loan portfolio in USD.<br />
The measure of scale is regionalized to reflect<br />
differences in income levels across regions.<br />
9) Sustainability: MF<strong>Is</strong> are grouped according<br />
to their level of financial self-sufficiency,<br />
representing their ability to cover all costs on<br />
an adjusted basis.<br />
10) Target Market: The Bulletin Tables classify<br />
MF<strong>Is</strong> into three categories—low-end, broad,<br />
and high-end—according to the average<br />
balance of loans served. For international<br />
comparison, this balance is stated as a<br />
percentage of local income levels (GNI per<br />
capita).<br />
Compound Peer Groups use a more complex set of<br />
variables to analyze MFI performance. This creates<br />
benchmarks where institutions have a greater number<br />
of similar factors affecting performance.<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
45
BULLETIN TABLES<br />
The Bulletin Tables present compound peer groups<br />
based on three main factors: (1) Region; (2) Scale; (3)<br />
Sustainability.<br />
Peer Group Composition<br />
The quantitative criteria used to categorize these<br />
groups are summarized in Table 1. The entire sample of<br />
institutions that fall into these categories is located in the<br />
guide to the peer groups (pages 48–68). Confidentiality<br />
limits the publication of names of financially selfsufficient<br />
MF<strong>Is</strong> included in the database.<br />
More detailed information about each institution can<br />
be found in Appendix II.<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
Data Quality and Statistical<br />
<strong>Is</strong>sues<br />
Because the Bulletin tables rely primarily on selfreported<br />
data, we grade the quality of the information<br />
based on the degree to which we have independent<br />
verification of its reliability. The data quality grade<br />
is not a rating of the institution’s performance.<br />
Additionally, in the statistical tables that follow, the<br />
median values are displayed for each indicator. For<br />
more details on both Data Quality and Statistical<br />
<strong>Is</strong>sues, see Appendix I.<br />
Table 1<br />
Peer Group Criteria<br />
Group Categories Criteria<br />
Age<br />
Charter Type<br />
Financial Intermediation<br />
Lending Methodology<br />
Outreach<br />
Profit Status<br />
Region<br />
Scale<br />
(Gross Loan Portfolio, in USD)<br />
Sustainability<br />
Target Market<br />
(Depth = Average Loan Balance<br />
per Borrower/GNI per Capita)<br />
New<br />
Young<br />
Mature<br />
Bank<br />
Credit Union<br />
NBFI<br />
NGO<br />
Rural Bank<br />
Non FI<br />
Low FI<br />
High FI<br />
Individual<br />
Solidarity Group<br />
Individual/Solidarity<br />
Village Banking<br />
Large<br />
Medium<br />
Small<br />
For Profit<br />
Not for Profit<br />
Africa<br />
Asia<br />
ECA<br />
LAC<br />
MENA<br />
Large<br />
Medium<br />
Small<br />
Non FSS<br />
FSS<br />
Low end<br />
Broad<br />
High end<br />
Small Business<br />
1 to 4 years<br />
5 to 8 years<br />
over 8 years<br />
No voluntary savings<br />
Voluntary savings < 20% of total assets<br />
Voluntary savings > 20 % of total assets<br />
Number of Borrowers > 30,000<br />
Number of Borrowers > 10,000 and < 30,000<br />
Number of Borrowers < 10,000<br />
Registered as a for profit institution<br />
Registered in a non profit status<br />
Sub-Saharan Africa<br />
South & East Asia<br />
Eastern Europe & Central Asia<br />
Latin America & the Caribbean<br />
Middle East & North Africa<br />
Africa, Asia, ECA, MENA<br />
Latin America<br />
Africa, Asia, ECA, MENA<br />
Latin America<br />
Africa, Asia, ECA, MENA<br />
Latin America<br />
Financial Self-Sufficiency < 100%<br />
Financial Self-Sufficiency > 100%<br />
> 8 million<br />
> 15 million<br />
2 million to 8 million<br />
4 million to 15 million<br />
< 2 million<br />
< 4 million<br />
depth < 20% OR average loan size < USD150<br />
depth between 20% and 149%<br />
depth between 150% and 250%<br />
depth over 250%<br />
Abbreviations: ECA = Eastern Europe and Central Asia; FI = Financial Intermediary; FSS = Financially Self-Sufficient; LAC = Latin America and the Caribbean;<br />
MENA = Middle East and North Africa; NBFI = Non Bank Financial Institution; NGO = Non Governmental Organization<br />
46<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
BULLETIN TABLES<br />
2008 MFI Benchmarks - Median Values<br />
Number of<br />
MF<strong>Is</strong><br />
INSTITUTIONAL CHARACTERISTICS<br />
Age Total Assets Offices Personnel Capital/<br />
Asset Ratio<br />
Debt to<br />
Equity<br />
FINANCING STRUCTURE<br />
Deposits to Deposits<br />
Loans to Total<br />
Assets<br />
Portfolio to<br />
Assets<br />
Number<br />
of Active<br />
Borrowers<br />
PEER GROUP<br />
Units nb USD nb nb % x % % % nb<br />
Year: 2008 2008 2008 2008 2008 2008 2008 2008 2008 2008 2008<br />
All MF<strong>Is</strong> 1,084 11 6,434,037 9 87 22.3 3.1 16.7 9.1 78.0 9,013<br />
SIMPLE PEER GROUPS<br />
Age<br />
New 191 3 2,946,3<strong>09</strong> 5 53 31.9 1.6 6.7 0.7 76.5 3,781<br />
Young 203 7 4,383,587 7 64 23.8 2.7 15.4 6.2 76.7 7,026<br />
Mature 657 14 9,375,210 11 111 21.5 3.5 23.8 12.5 78.5 12,689<br />
Charter Type:<br />
Bank 82 11 162,784,104 31 691 15.2 5.3 74.2 48.0 68.8 45,858<br />
Credit Union 182 11 3,581,221 4 24 18.6 3.7 78.0 61.2 80.1 1,850<br />
NBFI 338 8 8,930,595 11 128 24.2 2.9 0.0 0.0 79.9 12,162<br />
NGO 389 12 4,334,131 9 75 33.6 1.7 0.0 0.0 78.2 9,703<br />
Rural Bank 84 21 6,877,332 5 81 13.8 6.2 83.3 61.4 72.1 6,406<br />
Financial Intermediation<br />
Non FI 398 10 4,632,395 7 56 33.9 1.8 0.0 0.0 82.3 5,990<br />
Low FI 159 9 6,063,4<strong>09</strong> 11 119 28.0 1.9 12.6 9.4 73.2 13,511<br />
High FI 393 12 8,655,520 10 116 15.7 4.8 77.8 58.7 74.3 12,214<br />
Methodology:<br />
Individual 281 10 6,302,049 6 51 20.7 3.6 40.4 27.9 82.8 4,353<br />
Individual/Solidarity 272 11 6,430,106 10 97 23.4 2.8 5.1 2.6 76.1 10,525<br />
Solidarity 67 9 4,360,894 8 80 17.1 3.4 30.4 15.0 73.7 13,161<br />
Village Banking 59 13 6,113,161 14 145 24.0 3.2 0.0 0.0 79.8 17,916<br />
Outreach<br />
Small (Outreach) 553 9 2,226,456 4 30 27.7 2.1 8.1 0.7 78.9 2,417<br />
Medium (Outreach) 241 11 9,524,429 13 142 25.8 2.6 11.6 7.8 77.1 16,077<br />
Large (Outreach) 273 12 47,378,443 41 551 16.4 4.8 30.5 20.5 77.0 70,565<br />
Profit Status<br />
Profit 414 9 11,863,846 12 151 19.0 4.1 35.4 20.8 74.2 12,740<br />
Not for Profit 665 11 4,632,395 7 58 25.6 2.3 6.8 1.4 80.2 6,804<br />
Region:<br />
Africa 195 10 4,994,906 8 88 26.1 2.3 53.3 35.0 65.8 9,143<br />
Asia 283 12 7,189,772 12 134 14.9 5.0 30.8 15.9 74.3 17,239<br />
ECA 217 9 4,721,984 6 34 22.9 2.9 0.0 0.0 88.0 2,156<br />
LAC 333 12 8,196,305 9 86 24.9 2.9 0.0 0.0 80.3 9,768<br />
MENA 56 10 9,686,430 10 107 48.5 0.9 0.0 0.0 72.1 11,785<br />
Scale<br />
Small (Scale) 428 8 1,390,311 3 24 32.7 1.7 2.9 0.0 76.6 2,130<br />
Medium (Scale) 304 10 6,571,742 9 96 23.3 2.7 19.7 12.6 77.3 10,502<br />
Large (Scale) 351 12 46,119,113 28 393 18.7 4.3 33.0 22.2 79.2 44,257<br />
Sustainability:<br />
FSS 557 12 9,417,989 11 112 21.5 3.6 17.1 12.4 80.2 13,370<br />
Non-FSS 354 9 4,491,402 9 88 22.9 2.2 3.7 2.1 74.3 8,852<br />
Target Market:<br />
Low end 425 9 4,214,670 8 88 28.2 2.0 3.0 0.1 76.3 12,628<br />
Broad 498 11 8,166,527 9 81 20.8 3.6 24.5 11.6 81.1 7,482<br />
High end 78 10 17,156,666 12 113 21.9 3.4 40.4 31.0 76.7 8,735<br />
Small Business 64 8 18,012,390 6 90 17.5 4.4 81.3 48.5 68.2 2,254<br />
COMPOUND PEER GROUPS<br />
Africa Small FSS 16 9 1,362,7<strong>09</strong> 3 24 27.9 2.6 35.8 26.0 74.4 2,570<br />
Africa Small Non FSS 34 9 1,226,420 7 39 33.4 1.4 47.0 27.7 60.2 3,453<br />
Africa Medium FSS 20 10 5,863,743 7 105 35.0 1.9 28.2 20.6 71.0 10,049<br />
Africa Medium Non FSS 29 8 6,063,4<strong>09</strong> 10 134 25.6 1.9 46.5 31.5 58.6 14,259<br />
Africa Large FSS 26 14 39,968,345 35 410 19.2 4.0 72.2 53.5 65.4 34,385<br />
Africa Large Non FSS 19 15 46,551,910 37 428 17.5 3.7 70.2 46.5 73.5 51,580<br />
Asia Small FSS 22 13 1,365,225 5 48 18.7 4.2 44.9 34.8 74.0 3,770<br />
Asia Small Non FSS 21 12 1,175,790 7 55 17.9 3.4 14.2 9.6 69.8 9,046<br />
Asia Medium FSS 45 14 5,573,514 13 126 12.9 6.8 39.6 29.0 76.0 23,134<br />
Asia Medium Non FSS 25 5 6,050,969 23 191 8.3 4.0 13.7 12.0 74.6 36,629<br />
Asia Large FSS 58 15 26,322,242 31 565 15.4 5.5 26.0 18.9 75.5 97,239<br />
Asia Large Non FSS 20 13 29,476,397 73 949 18.4 4.5 6.5 5.3 76.8 160,829<br />
ECA Small FSS 40 5 704,005 2 8 27.7 2.3 0.0 0.0 88.6 367<br />
ECA Small Non FSS 35 5 649,797 1 8 25.7 1.5 0.0 0.0 89.9 328<br />
ECA Medium FSS 23 8 5,253,748 5 40 33.0 2.0 6.4 5.7 90.1 3,143<br />
ECA Medium Non FSS 24 9 4,141,396 7 33 35.3 1.4 0.0 0.0 83.8 1,577<br />
ECA Large FSS 52 10 58,996,434 27 289 18.9 4.3 20.3 16.8 85.9 28,899<br />
ECA Large Non FSS 25 9 42,463,253 17 288 20.7 3.8 0.0 0.0 85.8 12,215<br />
LAC Small FSS 73 12 2,250,396 3 23 43.8 1.3 0.0 0.0 81.2 2,854<br />
LAC Small Non FSS 56 9 1,688,343 3 32 37.0 1.3 0.0 0.0 73.0 2,854<br />
LAC Medium FSS 64 12 8,968,032 8 78 28.5 2.5 0.0 0.0 85.1 9,391<br />
LAC Medium Non FSS 26 13 8,752,111 16 144 18.9 4.3 11.9 9.0 75.8 13,026<br />
LAC Large FSS 88 16 79,476,965 28 439 16.1 5.2 57.5 46.4 82.4 51,902<br />
LAC Large Non FSS 20 12 46,810,343 18 293 21.0 3.2 5.0 3.1 75.3 28,532<br />
MENA Small FSS 7 8 1,088,494 4 54 37.3 1.7 17.8 11.6 63.7 3,133<br />
MENA Small Non-FSS 9 6 1,792,223 4 36 37.8 0.9 3.7 2.1 54.4 2,350<br />
MENA Medium FSS 6 11 5,628,6<strong>09</strong> 10 111 57.6 0.7 0.0 0.0 79.0 15,784<br />
MENA Medium Non-FSS 5 11 4,500,308 9 168 52.5 0.9 0.0 0.0 65.2 17,818<br />
MENA Large FSS 17 12 30,641,608 17 288 47.4 1.1 0.0 0.0 82.9 37,704<br />
MENA Large Non-FSS 6 9 24,671,556 10 325 40.5 1.8 0.1 0.1 73.2 47,744<br />
For definitions of Peer Groups, refer to the Peer Group Classification section on pp45–46. For details on indicator definitions, refer to the Indicator Definitions section on pp<br />
53. “n/a” denotes results for Peer Groups with less than three observations<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
47
BULLETIN TABLES<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
2008 MFI Benchmarks - Median Values<br />
Percent of<br />
Women<br />
Borrowers<br />
Number Gross Loan<br />
of Loans Portfolio<br />
Outstanding<br />
Average<br />
Loan<br />
Balance per<br />
Borrower<br />
OUTREACH INDICATORS<br />
Average<br />
Outstanding<br />
Balance<br />
Average<br />
Loan<br />
Balance per<br />
Borrower/<br />
GNI per<br />
Capita<br />
Average<br />
Outstanding<br />
Balance/GNI<br />
per Capita<br />
Number of<br />
Depositors<br />
Number<br />
of Deposit<br />
Accounts<br />
Deposits<br />
Average<br />
Deposit<br />
Balance<br />
per<br />
Depositor<br />
PEER GROUP<br />
Units % nb USD USD % US$ % nb nb US$ US$<br />
Year: 2008 2008 2008 2008 2008 2008 2008 2008 2008 2008 2008<br />
All MF<strong>Is</strong> 60.0 9,234 4,128,377 525 36.5 527 35.4 2,547 5,262 263,063 145<br />
SIMPLE PEER GROUPS<br />
Age<br />
New 66.5 4,220 1,845,751 380 29.4 381 28.9 13 130 39,851 114<br />
Young 57.2 7,074 2,892,796 467 33.5 475 31.2 2,438 3,451 162,514 90<br />
Mature 59.4 12,997 6,577,342 676 40.8 648 38.8 5,169 8,931 445,550 178<br />
Charter Type:<br />
Bank 43.5 51,202 103,990,796 2,003 113.0 1,744 1<strong>09</strong>.4 80,741 83,566 59,762,401 733<br />
Credit Union 45.1 1,919 2,273,336 1,5<strong>09</strong> 59.8 1,329 55.3 3,340 3,695 1,418,227 412<br />
NBFI 54.2 12,279 6,299,762 631 48.2 631 47.6 0 72 0 111<br />
NGO 79.1 10,341 2,753,772 251 16.0 242 15.7 0 1,193 0 33<br />
Rural Bank 45.3 7,086 2,936,410 545 41.5 527 41.5 13,865 13,474 2,278,974 175<br />
Financial Intermediation<br />
Non FI 62.8 6,035 3,323,830 522 24.5 517 22.8 0 0 0 n/a<br />
Low FI 81.6 13,611 4,543,920 233 25.7 227 25.6 10,944 10,646 348,104 35<br />
High FI 52.4 12,336 6,147,891 905 53.1 853 49.5 22,289 23,575 4,690,311 270<br />
Methodology:<br />
Individual 46.2 4,429 4,688,212 1,404 51.3 1,292 46.5 1,108 2,445 450,226 561<br />
Individual/Solidarity 64.9 10,336 4,614,081 435 33.6 430 32.7 2,920 5,0<strong>09</strong> 72,516 108<br />
Solidarity 98.7 13,205 2,592,286 111 14.6 110 14.6 9,439 12,380 347,681 29<br />
Village Banking 86.3 18,397 4,892,976 152 14.7 158 15.5 0 0 0 46<br />
Outreach<br />
Small (Outreach) 53.0 2,466 1,388,657 722 42.1 698 40.3 391 1,193 41,128 183<br />
Medium (Outreach) 65.7 16,338 6,998,218 450 35.1 438 35.3 13,039 14,526 338,451 92<br />
Large (Outreach) 70.4 73,508 33,223,939 290 27.6 298 26.8 49,167 72,085 3,179,734 145<br />
Profit Status<br />
Profit 54.2 12,895 7,007,552 680 50.3 684 47.8 8,265 11,512 1,137,548 179<br />
Not for Profit 63.7 7,018 3,068,469 451 30.1 451 28.9 562 2,264 49,980 111<br />
Region:<br />
Africa 57.2 9,620 2,708,387 308 67.8 311 64.0 18,336 18,434 1,366,283 98<br />
Asia 93.8 16,483 3,677,827 166 17.8 164 16.7 6,700 7,453 529,766 56<br />
ECA 43.1 2,250 3,949,277 2,174 68.3 2,115 65.1 0 0 0 1,855<br />
LAC 59.6 9,844 6,715,949 780 25.5 739 24.9 950 3,716 0 466<br />
MENA 65.4 12,589 5,153,360 317 15.8 314 15.5 0 2,594 0 26<br />
Scale<br />
Small (Scale) 63.3 2,183 916,600 348 22.5 349 22.0 147 521 19,063 96<br />
Medium (Scale) 64.1 10,854 4,813,1<strong>09</strong> 485 38.2 472 37.2 10,329 12,311 903,559 93<br />
Large (Scale) 52.5 45,536 32,973,000 1,012 56.0 992 51.5 18,802 37,479 7,614,672 410<br />
Sustainability:<br />
FSS 59.2 13,450 7,359,172 764 39.8 738 37.9 3,238 6,959 357,197 261<br />
Non-FSS 62.6 8,712 3,203,964 417 34.5 414 33.4 425 1,844 68,937 105<br />
Target Market:<br />
Low end 84.9 12,628 2,575,585 159 11.4 163 11.1 598 3,331 32,561 36<br />
Broad 49.4 7,659 5,476,159 949 54.6 924 51.1 2,875 5,0<strong>09</strong> 463,306 243<br />
High end 40.0 8,746 10,992,551 2,388 190.0 2,148 182.2 13,236 22,167 3,037,117 381<br />
Small Business 35.3 2,302 9,986,706 2,841 402.1 2,638 344.6 6,161 8,154 3,882,179 563<br />
COMPOUND PEER GROUPS<br />
Africa Small FSS 56.3 2,570 1,037,793 235 40.9 267 41.9 3,503 3,503 251,132 51<br />
Africa Small Non FSS 68.7 3,537 658,150 145 35.7 131 34.8 5,0<strong>09</strong> 7,472 214,983 76<br />
Africa Medium FSS 63.7 10,067 3,8<strong>09</strong>,139 446 79.7 446 79.7 24,930 24,930 1,536,943 80<br />
Africa Medium Non FSS 59.6 14,259 3,503,663 246 51.8 244 49.3 20,359 20,412 1,468,928 69<br />
Africa Large FSS 52.3 35,125 25,219,140 930 170.4 930 166.7 148,219 160,278 23,556,784 145<br />
Africa Large Non FSS 43.4 54,425 28,705,034 591 118.2 570 118.2 94,895 98,822 18,253,841 207<br />
Asia Small FSS 77.9 4,162 1,015,750 197 11.9 197 11.9 5,342 6,118 450,226 77<br />
Asia Small Non FSS 86.2 9,046 962,207 131 13.4 131 13.2 4,900 5,156 163,312 44<br />
Asia Medium FSS 100.0 23,134 4,674,894 207 18.1 207 17.6 18,250 18,271 1,556,001 77<br />
Asia Medium Non FSS 98.0 36,629 5,001,148 117 13.7 113 14.4 24,895 24,518 464,930 19<br />
Asia Large FSS 95.5 87,045 20,<strong>09</strong>5,021 150 17.4 150 15.5 19,779 22,147 2,814,977 117<br />
Asia Large Non FSS 96.0 141,435 24,407,361 140 18.9 130 19.2 54,236 27,125 1,486,363 36<br />
ECA Small FSS 54.6 367 588,397 1,526 55.7 1,480 54.4 0 0 0 3,188<br />
ECA Small Non FSS 40.1 328 515,324 1,786 62.9 1,608 55.2 0 0 0 4,134<br />
ECA Medium FSS 47.5 3,143 4,688,212 1,145 57.5 1,132 53.2 0 896 275,060 1,237<br />
ECA Medium Non FSS 43.8 1,740 3,746,608 3,005 66.8 3,005 65.3 0 0 0 3,582<br />
ECA Large FSS 41.6 29,924 51,557,800 2,389 91.9 2,238 88.2 0 6,932 15,195,678 1,558<br />
ECA Large Non FSS 33.7 12,217 34,301,807 3,223 120.0 3,194 104.2 0 0 0 1,576<br />
LAC Small FSS 63.1 2,930 1,724,647 446 14.3 441 13.4 0 0 0 162<br />
LAC Small Non FSS 70.9 2,854 1,218,715 401 8.3 401 7.6 0 0 0 281<br />
LAC Medium FSS 58.1 9,515 7,550,565 841 27.7 810 27.6 100 1,270 0 400<br />
LAC Medium Non FSS 79.4 13,026 6,654,772 449 16.2 432 15.5 12,441 12,835 757,351 78<br />
LAC Large FSS 49.6 57,341 64,934,089 1,611 56.5 1,480 50.1 40,538 52,794 25,510,046 907<br />
LAC Large Non FSS 61.4 28,532 31,759,893 1,146 33.9 1,146 27.4 12,388 20,485 882,311 817<br />
MENA Small FSS 100.0 3,141 662,086 133 12.7 133 12.7 3,314 13,579 59,934 22<br />
MENA Small Non-FSS 82.2 2,350 1,118,154 211 17.7 211 17.7 1,534 1,534 34,318 36<br />
MENA Medium FSS 72.7 15,784 4,404,334 239 12.5 239 12.5 0 0 0 n/a<br />
MENA Medium Non-FSS 71.9 17,818 3,703,118 264 12.4 264 12.4 0 n/a 0 n/a<br />
MENA Large FSS 58.3 66,182 16,565,033 706 18.4 606 20.6 0 n/a 0 n/a<br />
MENA Large Non-FSS 45.0 47,744 18,398,215 667 35.0 651 34.3 187 822 13,077 199<br />
For definitions of Peer Groups, refer to the Peer Group Classification section on pp45–46. For details on indicator definitions, refer to the Indicator Definitions section on pp<br />
53. “n/a” denotes results for Peer Groups with less than three observations<br />
48<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
BULLETIN TABLES<br />
2008 MFI Benchmarks - Median Values<br />
OUTREACH INDICATORS MACROECONOMIC INDICATORS OVERALL FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE<br />
Average<br />
GNI per GDP Deposit Inflation Financial Return on Return on Operational<br />
Deposit<br />
Capita Growth Rate Rate Depth Assets Equity Self-<br />
Account<br />
Rate<br />
Sufficiency<br />
Balance<br />
Average<br />
Deposit<br />
Balance per<br />
Depositor/<br />
GNI per<br />
capita<br />
Average<br />
Deposit<br />
Account<br />
Balance/<br />
GNI per<br />
capita<br />
PEER GROUP<br />
Units % USD % US$ % % % % % % %<br />
Year: 2008 2008 2008 2008 2008 2008 2008 2008 2008 2008 2008<br />
All MF<strong>Is</strong> 14.0 138 13.0 1,600 6.8 5.1 6.4 38.5 1.0 5.4 113.1<br />
SIMPLE PEER GROUPS<br />
Age<br />
New 14.0 117 13.5 950 7.5 5.9 7.7 30.9 (1.2) (1.7) 104<br />
Young 10.0 81 9.0 1,600 7.1 5.9 7.0 35.2 0.3 2.5 112<br />
Mature 17.0 176 16.0 1,600 6.4 5.0 6.3 41.7 1.4 7.0 116<br />
Charter Type:<br />
Bank 32.0 667 32.0 1,655 7.1 6.8 7.8 31.2 0.6 4.6 1<strong>09</strong><br />
Credit Union 18.0 390 18.0 3,150 6.2 5.0 6.1 36.6 0.3 2.0 116<br />
NBFI 16.0 1<strong>09</strong> 16.0 1,474 7.8 5.4 7.3 30.9 1.5 7.1 115<br />
NGO 3.0 31 3.0 1,515 6.4 6.0 6.4 43.6 0.9 4.1 110<br />
Rural Bank 15.0 163 14.5 1,600 6.3 3.7 6.1 59.5 1.9 14.5 119<br />
Financial Intermediation<br />
Non FI n/a n/a n/a 2,710 7.1 5.9 6.4 40.6 1.4 4.5 113<br />
Low FI 4.0 32 4.0 950 6.3 5.2 6.4 34.3 0.4 4.5 112<br />
High FI 19.0 252 19.0 1,600 6.4 5.0 6.1 36.4 0.9 6.3 112<br />
Methodology:<br />
Individual 22.0 518 20.5 3,200 7.1 5.1 6.1 41.7 1.5 7.5 116<br />
Individual/Solidarity 12.5 102 11.0 1,590 6.4 5.4 6.5 35.2 1.2 5.8 113<br />
Solidarity 5.0 21 3.0 770 7.1 6.0 7.0 59.5 (1.1) 2.7 1<strong>09</strong><br />
Village Banking 7.0 46 7.0 950 8.6 6.0 6.4 36.5 1.3 3.4 116<br />
Outreach<br />
Small (Outreach) 15.0 178 13.0 2,<strong>09</strong>0 6.3 5.1 6.4 36.4 0.4 3.1 113<br />
Medium (Outreach) 11.0 93 10.5 1,595 6.7 5.0 6.1 34.3 0.9 5.8 112<br />
Large (Outreach) 18.5 143 16.0 1,050 7.1 5.3 6.4 43.6 1.4 9.3 116<br />
Profit Status<br />
Profit 20.0 178 20.0 1,600 7.1 5.4 6.3 34.3 1.2 7.3 114<br />
Not for Profit 11.5 106 10.0 1,600 6.6 5.1 6.4 40.6 0.9 4.1 113<br />
Region:<br />
Africa 19.0 96 19.0 560 6.1 6.0 8.0 28.1 (0.7) (2.3) 108<br />
Asia 7.0 55 6.0 950 7.1 6.0 6.3 59.5 1.3 9.6 113<br />
ECA 44.0 1,620 41.5 3,780 8.1 5.4 9.0 42.9 0.3 2.8 117<br />
LAC 15.0 439 13.0 3,340 5.7 5.0 4.0 30.9 1.8 7.3 112<br />
MENA 2.0 26 2.0 1,500 5.3 5.8 5.4 96.2 2.4 3.5 119<br />
Scale<br />
Small (Scale) 10.0 91 9.0 1,650 6.3 5.1 6.4 36.4 0.1 1.1 112<br />
Medium (Scale) 11.0 98 10.0 1,590 6.7 5.2 6.4 40.6 0.9 4.5 113<br />
Large (Scale) 29.5 402 26.0 1,600 7.1 5.1 6.1 38.5 1.4 8.5 115<br />
Sustainability:<br />
FSS 16.0 251 15.0 2,<strong>09</strong>0 7.1 5.0 6.1 38.5 2.8 12.2 122<br />
Non-FSS 13.0 100 13.0 1,505 6.3 5.6 7.0 36.0 (4.2) (11.6) 96<br />
Target Market:<br />
Low end 4.0 35 3.0 1,600 7.1 5.3 6.3 42.9 1.0 4.1 110<br />
Broad 18.0 231 17.0 1,650 6.8 5.1 6.3 36.0 1.3 6.5 115<br />
High end 36.5 327 34.5 1,175 6.2 4.9 8.6 33.5 0.8 4.2 113<br />
Small Business 82.0 457 73.5 610 7.5 6.0 9.1 29.5 0.3 3.5 117<br />
COMPOUND PEER GROUPS<br />
Africa Small FSS 10.0 51 10.0 495 4.6 4.7 6.0 31.1 2.5 6.2 124<br />
Africa Small Non FSS 16.0 61 15.0 495 6.1 6.3 10.7 29.5 (8.5) (14.5) 95<br />
Africa Medium FSS 12.0 80 12.0 535 6.2 6.0 10.0 22.7 2.9 8.7 132<br />
Africa Medium Non FSS 17.0 85 17.5 400 6.8 6.8 7.0 28.1 (6.4) (19.2) 93<br />
Africa Large FSS 34.0 145 33.5 600 6.1 6.5 6.1 28.1 1.1 7.8 123<br />
Africa Large Non FSS 35.0 191 35.0 610 4.7 4.1 5.9 31.4 (1.8) (10.2) 98<br />
Asia Small FSS 5.5 77 5.5 1,600 7.1 3.7 6.2 59.5 2.5 12.3 119<br />
Asia Small Non FSS 6.5 44 4.0 1,540 6.8 6.0 6.3 59.5 (8.2) (21.0) 86<br />
Asia Medium FSS 10.0 80 7.0 1,600 7.1 3.7 6.3 59.5 2.1 16.1 119<br />
Asia Medium Non FSS 3.0 21 3.0 950 9.1 6.0 7.6 59.2 (9.7) (12.4) 84<br />
Asia Large FSS 10.5 112 8.0 950 9.1 4.8 6.4 59.5 2.9 14.9 124<br />
Asia Large Non FSS 7.0 35 6.5 860 7.9 6.0 7.6 59.2 (2.7) (16.9) 100<br />
ECA Small FSS 42.5 3,134 41.5 4,970 8.1 5.1 9.0 42.9 2.7 6.8 133<br />
ECA Small Non FSS 55.0 3,676 48.5 4,460 8.1 5.1 9.0 42.9 (5.9) (10.6) 104<br />
ECA Medium FSS 23.0 1,226 18.0 2,710 8.2 6.7 9.0 36.0 5.3 15.8 143<br />
ECA Medium Non FSS 48.0 2,826 38.0 4,460 8.1 5.1 9.0 42.9 (4.8) (7.4) 102<br />
ECA Large FSS 45.0 1,466 38.5 2,710 8.2 5.4 6.4 33.4 2.7 13.0 124<br />
ECA Large Non FSS 51.0 1,576 51.0 3,360 7.9 5.7 9.0 36.6 (2.0) (8.2) 100<br />
LAC Small FSS 5.0 162 5.0 3,340 4.7 5.0 3.6 27.1 3.5 9.5 119<br />
LAC Small Non FSS 9.0 281 9.0 4,100 5.2 5.0 4.0 30.8 (7.4) (15.8) 81<br />
LAC Medium FSS 15.0 299 11.0 3,150 5.7 4.9 4.0 30.9 3.8 10.2 118<br />
LAC Medium Non FSS 3.0 78 3.0 3,175 3.4 5.3 4.5 35.1 (3.3) (15.2) 98<br />
LAC Large FSS 31.0 835 28.0 3,340 6.3 4.7 4.0 30.9 2.4 14.9 118<br />
LAC Large Non FSS 18.0 719 18.0 4,100 6.0 6.3 5.5 30.9 (1.5) (8.9) 98<br />
MENA Small FSS 2.0 22 2.0 1,500 7.1 8.0 7.9 96.2 5.1 5.7 139<br />
MENA Small Non-FSS 2.0 36 2.0 950 3.3 5.0 7.9 35.2 (14.1) (21.0) 85<br />
MENA Medium FSS n/a n/a n/a 1,500 6.8 5.8 7.4 96.2 3.7 6.9 136<br />
MENA Medium Non-FSS n/a n/a n/a 1,500 6.6 5.4 5.4 96.2 (2.3) (10.9) 96<br />
MENA Large FSS n/a n/a n/a 2,625 6.6 5.4 5.4 104.8 3.7 8.9 132<br />
MENA Large Non-FSS 11.0 199 11.0 1,620 2.7 3.7 2.7 80.8 (2.3) (8.9) 80<br />
For definitions of Peer Groups, refer to the Peer Group Classification section on pp45–46. For details on indicator definitions, refer to the Indicator Definitions section on pp<br />
53. “n/a” denotes results for Peer Groups with less than three observations<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
49
BULLETIN TABLES<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
2008 MFI Benchmarks - Median Values<br />
Financial<br />
Self-<br />
Sufficiency<br />
Financial<br />
Revenue/<br />
Assets<br />
REVENUES<br />
Profit<br />
Margin<br />
Yield on<br />
Gross<br />
Portfolio<br />
(nominal)<br />
Yield on<br />
Gross<br />
Portfolio<br />
(real)<br />
Total<br />
Expense/<br />
Assets<br />
Financial<br />
Expense/<br />
Assets<br />
Provision<br />
for Loan<br />
Impairment/<br />
Assets<br />
EXPENSES<br />
Operating<br />
Expense/<br />
Assets<br />
Personnel<br />
Expense/<br />
Assets<br />
Administrative<br />
Expense/<br />
Assets<br />
PEER GROUP<br />
Units % % % % % % % % % % %<br />
Year: 2008 2008 2008 2008 2008 2008 2008 2008 2008 2008 2008<br />
All MF<strong>Is</strong> 105.6 25.8 5.4 31.1 22.8 24.6 6.8 1.4 14.5 8.2 6.1<br />
SIMPLE PEER GROUPS<br />
Age<br />
New 95 28.0 (4.7) 35.5 26.3 32.5 8.0 1.7 21.7 11.7 8.5<br />
Young 103 25.5 2.9 35.0 24.5 26.4 7.8 1.2 15.3 8.8 6.8<br />
Mature 108 25.5 7.3 28.9 21.6 23.0 6.5 1.4 13.3 7.5 5.6<br />
Charter Type:<br />
Bank 105 20.5 4.3 27.1 16.3 20.1 7.3 1.4 10.0 5.5 4.7<br />
Credit Union 103 18.1 3.1 21.9 17.5 18.8 5.7 1.3 10.8 5.1 4.8<br />
NBFI 108 27.6 7.6 32.9 24.3 26.0 7.9 1.5 15.7 9.0 6.5<br />
NGO 102 27.3 2.3 33.8 25.5 27.8 6.3 1.6 18.2 10.6 7.3<br />
Rural Bank 115 24.7 13.0 33.0 26.7 22.4 5.3 1.1 12.7 6.5 6.7<br />
Financial Intermediation<br />
Non FI 104 27.9 4.1 33.3 24.7 27.0 7.3 1.5 16.4 9.2 6.5<br />
Low FI 105 26.2 4.2 34.0 24.3 27.2 7.6 1.0 17.0 9.7 7.1<br />
High FI 106 21.9 5.9 28.3 21.1 21.8 5.9 1.4 12.1 6.3 5.6<br />
Methodology:<br />
Individual 107 23.8 7.3 30.1 21.8 21.9 7.2 1.4 11.6 6.5 5.2<br />
Individual/Solidarity 106 27.6 5.7 34.7 25.9 26.5 6.8 1.5 17.1 9.4 7.1<br />
Solidarity 99 25.0 (0.7) 30.9 20.8 27.8 6.7 0.9 19.2 10.1 7.0<br />
Village Banking 107 27.1 6.4 30.8 24.2 24.8 6.6 0.9 17.8 10.3 6.6<br />
Outreach<br />
Small (Outreach) 103 25.8 3.0 32.5 24.2 26.5 6.6 1.3 14.6 8.4 6.7<br />
Medium (Outreach) 105 27.2 4.4 33.7 24.4 26.8 6.5 1.9 16.6 9.4 7.2<br />
Large (Outreach) 1<strong>09</strong> 24.2 8.4 28.6 21.3 22.2 7.3 1.3 12.5 6.7 5.1<br />
Profit Status<br />
Profit 108 25.8 7.3 31.9 23.8 23.9 7.7 1.3 14.1 7.4 6.1<br />
Not for Profit 103 25.8 3.3 30.6 22.5 25.6 6.5 1.6 14.6 8.5 6.2<br />
Region:<br />
Africa 96 25.4 (3.7) 32.6 23.1 27.6 4.8 1.6 18.5 9.2 9.3<br />
Asia 108 24.3 8.0 29.1 20.3 23.5 7.4 0.8 13.9 7.9 5.4<br />
ECA 104 24.4 4.0 29.5 19.3 24.4 8.9 1.3 12.8 7.2 5.1<br />
LAC 107 27.9 6.9 34.0 26.8 26.1 6.6 2.0 15.8 8.7 6.5<br />
MENA 107 22.8 6.8 33.2 22.7 21.6 4.5 0.7 14.6 10.0 4.8<br />
Scale<br />
Small (Scale) 100 28.0 0.4 35.7 27.3 30.5 5.9 1.3 20.4 10.6 8.3<br />
Medium (Scale) 104 27.0 4.1 33.5 24.0 27.1 7.0 1.6 16.6 9.3 6.8<br />
Large (Scale) 1<strong>09</strong> 23.7 8.4 27.6 20.2 21.6 7.1 1.4 12.1 6.5 5.0<br />
Sustainability:<br />
FSS 116 27.2 13.8 31.7 24.2 22.7 6.7 1.2 13.1 7.4 5.6<br />
Non-FSS 81 22.7 (22.0) 30.6 21.1 29.0 7.0 2.3 16.7 9.8 7.3<br />
Target Market:<br />
Low end 103 29.7 2.8 37.9 29.2 30.4 7.0 1.2 21.1 12.0 7.8<br />
Broad 107 25.1 6.8 29.3 21.7 23.3 6.8 1.6 13.1 7.2 5.7<br />
High end 106 20.0 6.1 23.2 15.6 19.8 6.5 1.4 11.7 5.5 5.3<br />
Small Business 101 19.1 0.9 23.3 16.6 19.9 7.9 1.4 10.2 5.0 4.5<br />
COMPOUND PEER GROUPS<br />
Africa Small FSS 115 30.8 13.1 36.5 27.8 28.5 3.0 1.7 24.3 10.1 14.3<br />
Africa Small Non FSS 73 26.7 (37.2) 36.0 27.0 32.5 7.0 2.2 25.3 10.0 8.9<br />
Africa Medium FSS 116 25.0 15.9 27.1 22.7 21.6 5.0 0.9 15.2 7.5 7.2<br />
Africa Medium Non FSS 81 24.4 (23.5) 37.5 28.1 32.1 4.7 2.9 26.7 12.1 10.0<br />
Africa Large FSS 1<strong>09</strong> 26.6 7.8 33.1 23.4 23.6 4.7 1.6 17.3 7.6 10.2<br />
Africa Large Non FSS 88 19.0 (13.9) 21.6 16.7 24.4 5.1 1.6 15.6 8.0 7.7<br />
Asia Small FSS 115 36.5 12.9 41.2 35.7 34.4 5.6 1.2 21.1 11.5 11.4<br />
Asia Small Non FSS 76 25.8 (32.0) 32.1 19.1 35.2 6.6 3.1 20.4 12.7 8.2<br />
Asia Medium FSS 116 24.9 14.0 30.6 24.2 20.9 6.6 0.5 11.4 5.8 5.9<br />
Asia Medium Non FSS 77 22.1 (30.1) 28.7 16.6 34.2 7.3 4.2 21.4 12.0 6.6<br />
Asia Large FSS 119 25.4 15.6 29.8 21.8 20.6 8.4 0.5 10.5 6.2 4.5<br />
Asia Large Non FSS 86 17.8 (11.5) 23.9 14.3 22.2 7.3 1.2 12.1 7.0 4.2<br />
ECA Small FSS 118 37.7 14.9 37.8 25.8 31.4 10.4 0.9 17.2 9.1 5.5<br />
ECA Small Non FSS 77 18.7 (29.4) 27.0 14.0 29.4 9.3 1.3 11.4 7.1 5.1<br />
ECA Medium FSS 123 37.9 18.5 40.3 28.5 28.2 11.4 1.3 13.7 9.1 5.7<br />
ECA Medium Non FSS 91 22.0 (10.1) 29.0 21.2 25.1 8.4 1.5 16.3 9.2 5.6<br />
ECA Large FSS 117 23.3 14.6 26.2 17.9 18.7 7.7 1.1 9.6 5.0 4.4<br />
ECA Large Non FSS 93 21.6 (7.6) 26.9 18.3 25.8 8.8 2.5 12.8 7.3 6.1<br />
LAC Small FSS 116 30.4 13.6 44.1 35.2 26.1 4.8 0.9 17.4 9.6 7.1<br />
LAC Small Non FSS 78 28.0 (27.6) 48.9 39.3 34.3 5.0 2.6 26.2 16.4 11.0<br />
LAC Medium FSS 114 32.7 12.5 35.5 29.9 28.6 6.7 1.8 17.7 9.9 7.2<br />
LAC Medium Non FSS 85 36.7 (13.3) 41.1 34.2 46.7 6.8 4.4 31.4 15.3 10.9<br />
LAC Large FSS 115 26.3 12.8 28.9 23.5 22.0 6.9 2.2 12.1 6.2 5.2<br />
LAC Large Non FSS 90 18.1 (11.3) 22.2 15.8 22.0 7.6 2.9 12.8 6.0 5.4<br />
MENA Small FSS 123 22.0 18.9 35.2 23.1 13.6 4.9 0.4 8.0 5.2 6.7<br />
MENA Small Non-FSS 55 22.8 (80.2) 33.2 23.4 41.1 0.7 (0.2) 35.8 17.5 9.8<br />
MENA Medium FSS 113 30.4 11.9 34.8 25.6 25.4 5.8 2.1 20.1 13.3 6.3<br />
MENA Medium Non-FSS 89 21.6 (12.6) 35.4 23.9 24.1 2.1 0.4 17.2 10.8 5.6<br />
MENA Large FSS 121 21.6 17.3 33.2 22.7 17.2 4.3 0.5 14.3 9.2 3.9<br />
MENA Large Non-FSS 80 21.5 (25.4) 21.5 16.5 23.7 5.1 3.7 12.1 6.9 3.4<br />
For definitions of Peer Groups, refer to the Peer Group Classification section on pp45–46. For details on indicator definitions, refer to the Indicator Definitions section on pp<br />
53. “n/a” denotes results for Peer Groups with less than three observations<br />
50<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
BULLETIN TABLES<br />
2008 MFI Benchmarks - Median Values<br />
Adjustment<br />
Expense/<br />
Assets<br />
Operating<br />
Expense/<br />
Loan<br />
Portfolio<br />
Personnel<br />
Expense/<br />
Loan<br />
Portfolio<br />
EFFICIENCY<br />
Average<br />
Salary/GNI<br />
per Capita<br />
Cost per<br />
Borrower<br />
Cost per<br />
Loan<br />
Borrowers<br />
per Staff<br />
Member<br />
Loans<br />
per Staff<br />
Member<br />
PRODUCTIVITY<br />
Borrowers<br />
per Loan<br />
Officer<br />
Loans<br />
per Loan<br />
Officer<br />
Depositors<br />
per Staff<br />
Member<br />
PEER GROUP<br />
Units % % % x USD USD nb nb nb nb nb<br />
Year: 2008 2008 2008 2008 2008 2008 2008 2008 2008 2008 2008<br />
All MF<strong>Is</strong> 1.1 20.0 10.9 3.7 139 139 100 103 245 252 104<br />
SIMPLE PEER GROUPS<br />
Age<br />
New 2.1 31.2 16.5 3.1 157 141 70 72 179 176 47<br />
Young 1.5 22.4 12.0 3.5 148 150 103 104 231 245 81<br />
Mature 0.9 17.9 9.6 3.8 136 135 110 113 262 272 124<br />
Charter Type:<br />
Bank 0.8 16.3 8.2 5.7 305 288 67 73 238 257 135<br />
Credit Union 1.3 13.6 6.9 3.3 191 186 81 82 258 265 226<br />
NBFI 1.3 20.6 11.1 4.4 169 164 92 92 226 239 36<br />
NGO 1.1 25.1 13.8 3.2 83 82 128 130 258 262 67<br />
Rural Bank 0.4 19.0 9.9 3.2 105 111 82 79 251 253 175<br />
Financial Intermediation<br />
Non FI 1.1 22.8 12.6 3.1 153 145 103 105 233 243 0<br />
Low FI 1.6 24.0 13.4 4.4 82 82 115 115 252 256 1<strong>09</strong><br />
High FI 0.7 17.9 9.0 4.5 166 158 91 93 257 267 187<br />
Methodology:<br />
Individual 0.7 15.8 8.6 3.4 233 227 75 79 222 235 63<br />
Individual/Solidarity 1.3 24.5 12.6 4.4 118 118 103 107 245 251 88<br />
Solidarity 1.4 19.7 10.7 3.2 23 26 156 171 274 278 200<br />
Village Banking 0.7 22.3 12.9 3.2 78 69 144 146 336 343 88<br />
Outreach<br />
Small (Outreach) 1.5 21.2 11.5 3.1 181 185 72 76 196 197 79<br />
Medium (Outreach) 1.0 21.9 12.0 4.4 135 135 114 115 258 258 108<br />
Large (Outreach) 0.8 16.1 9.3 4.3 83 84 156 171 321 343 142<br />
Profit Status<br />
Profit 1.0 20.2 10.4 4.3 172 169 84 84 241 249 104<br />
Not for Profit 1.3 20.0 11.3 3.4 123 123 1<strong>09</strong> 114 251 257 102<br />
Region:<br />
Africa 2.0 32.7 13.3 10.8 134 132 108 1<strong>09</strong> 288 286 228<br />
Asia 0.8 17.2 9.6 2.8 30 31 132 133 272 279 156<br />
ECA 2.0 15.0 8.2 3.9 312 293 57 59 167 167 10<br />
LAC 0.6 22.3 12.6 3.4 180 167 107 112 262 278 33<br />
MENA 0.4 21.4 14.4 3.4 74 71 118 116 211 215 0<br />
Scale<br />
Small (Scale) 1.7 26.3 14.5 2.5 118 121 87 88 212 213 81<br />
Medium (Scale) 1.4 21.9 12.3 3.9 136 135 107 111 253 263 134<br />
Large (Scale) 0.8 15.1 8.2 4.5 168 161 112 119 269 281 106<br />
Sustainability:<br />
FSS 0.7 17.3 9.6 3.8 146 142 113 115 269 282 94<br />
Non-FSS 2.7 26.0 14.6 3.8 151 135 84 86 191 195 81<br />
Target Market:<br />
Low end 1.0 27.5 15.9 2.4 64 65 142 143 276 281 98<br />
Broad 1.2 17.2 9.2 4.4 169 164 88 90 242 250 108<br />
High end 1.3 15.0 7.7 9.2 290 283 58 62 184 185 112<br />
Small Business 1.3 15.5 7.3 10.6 406 405 33 35 127 129 88<br />
COMPOUND PEER GROUPS<br />
Africa Small FSS 1.7 27.1 11.9 7.6 68 136 143 132 336 272 216<br />
Africa Small Non FSS 6.0 52.0 24.3 8.8 75 65 81 83 2<strong>09</strong> 2<strong>09</strong> 136<br />
Africa Medium FSS 1.1 24.9 10.3 9.6 138 138 112 112 335 335 285<br />
Africa Medium Non FSS 3.8 42.9 23.9 14.4 133 115 108 108 259 282 204<br />
Africa Large FSS 1.4 29.0 12.5 13.5 220 184 83 83 269 304 330<br />
Africa Large Non FSS 2.2 23.6 10.7 12.2 134 130 123 127 324 415 204<br />
Asia Small FSS 0.6 27.6 13.4 2.3 51 51 85 85 231 236 124<br />
Asia Small Non FSS 2.6 24.4 14.6 2.3 41 53 115 115 218 218 115<br />
Asia Medium FSS 0.5 16.1 8.9 2.6 35 39 146 153 321 331 244<br />
Asia Medium Non FSS 2.8 23.7 15.2 3.4 31 31 141 141 254 254 147<br />
Asia Large FSS 0.6 14.6 7.7 3.1 27 29 163 181 334 349 106<br />
Asia Large Non FSS 2.1 15.7 10.6 3.1 25 25 155 157 314 316 155<br />
ECA Small FSS 3.1 15.3 9.6 2.2 293 329 47 47 135 141 16<br />
ECA Small Non FSS 6.2 16.6 11.2 2.5 284 283 39 41 139 139 16<br />
ECA Medium FSS 3.1 15.2 9.7 4.1 147 147 94 96 213 245 4<br />
ECA Medium Non FSS 3.0 18.0 11.4 3.6 449 445 48 54 146 146 0<br />
ECA Large FSS 0.9 12.2 6.6 5.5 249 245 88 90 236 238 7<br />
ECA Large Non FSS 1.8 15.7 8.3 4.1 571 518 45 54 119 121 10<br />
LAC Small FSS 0.9 26.1 15.0 2.3 136 134 106 114 291 302 0<br />
LAC Small Non FSS 1.1 50.8 30.1 2.4 193 188 95 95 178 178 0<br />
LAC Medium FSS 0.5 21.7 12.3 3.8 159 152 122 129 295 298 3<br />
LAC Medium Non FSS 2.1 46.1 24.9 4.9 167 166 86 87 203 203 64<br />
LAC Large FSS 0.2 14.8 7.7 4.5 218 192 120 131 282 3<strong>09</strong> 114<br />
LAC Large Non FSS 2.1 16.3 10.9 3.6 286 234 81 84 197 197 49<br />
MENA Small FSS 0.3 21.5 15.1 1.4 37 37 108 108 2<strong>09</strong> 2<strong>09</strong> 37<br />
MENA Small Non-FSS 9.3 65.9 30.3 4.2 85 85 71 71 147 147 42<br />
MENA Medium FSS 2.5 25.0 16.4 3.3 52 28 142 142 253 253 n/a<br />
MENA Medium Non-FSS 2.2 32.0 20.7 2.8 69 54 105 105 169 169 0<br />
MENA Large FSS 0.1 15.9 12.4 4.0 76 74 154 165 281 292 0<br />
MENA Large Non-FSS 0.2 14.4 8.5 3.9 62 60 119 119 264 264 3<br />
For definitions of Peer Groups, refer to the Peer Group Classification section on pp45–46. For details on indicator definitions, refer to the Indicator Definitions section on pp<br />
53. “n/a” denotes results for Peer Groups with less than three observations<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
51
BULLETIN TABLES<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
2008 MFI Benchmarks - Median Values<br />
Deposit<br />
Accounts per<br />
Staff Member<br />
PRODUCTIVITY<br />
Personnel<br />
Allocation<br />
Ratio<br />
Portfolio at<br />
Risk > 30 Days<br />
Portfolio at<br />
Risk > 90 Days<br />
RISK AND LIQUIDITY<br />
Write-off Ratio Loan Loss Rate Risk Coverage<br />
Ratio<br />
Non-earning<br />
Liquid Assets<br />
as a % of Total<br />
Assets<br />
PEER GROUP<br />
Units nb % % % % % % %<br />
Year: 2008 2008 2008 2008 2008 2008 2008 2008<br />
All MF<strong>Is</strong> 136 44.5 3.1 1.6 1.0 0.8 81.0 12.2<br />
SIMPLE PEER GROUPS<br />
Age<br />
New 80 45.5 2.8 1.2 0.3 0.2 68.6 10.7<br />
Young 123 46.3 2.9 1.3 0.9 0.8 84.0 14.7<br />
Mature 163 43.3 3.2 1.7 1.3 0.9 84.3 12.2<br />
Charter Type:<br />
Bank 141 34.2 2.8 1.3 1.2 0.9 100.8 18.6<br />
Credit Union 267 31.8 3.6 2.0 1.0 0.8 54.0 8.9<br />
NBFI 107 45.5 3.2 1.5 0.8 0.7 84.0 10.9<br />
NGO 101 50.9 3.2 1.8 1.3 0.9 83.7 11.8<br />
Rural Bank 184 33.3 1.7 1.1 0.9 0.8 159.9 18.4<br />
Financial Intermediation<br />
Non FI 0 46.7 3.2 1.7 1.0 0.8 82.0 9.4<br />
Low FI 1<strong>09</strong> 50.0 3.0 1.4 0.6 0.4 77.8 14.5<br />
High FI 198 36.2 3.2 1.7 1.3 1.1 80.8 15.1<br />
Methodology:<br />
Individual 95 36.9 3.4 1.6 1.2 0.9 81.4 9.8<br />
Individual/Solidarity 113 44.9 3.4 1.7 1.3 1.0 69.6 13.3<br />
Solidarity 208 56.2 1.5 0.6 0.2 0.2 112.3 14.4<br />
Village Banking 88 55.9 1.0 0.4 0.5 0.3 147.0 10.3<br />
Outreach<br />
Small (Outreach) 104 40.0 3.7 1.8 0.9 0.7 62.1 10.1<br />
Medium (Outreach) 136 45.5 3.4 1.9 1.8 1.5 90.1 13.5<br />
Large (Outreach) 180 52.8 2.2 1.2 0.9 0.8 108.4 14.4<br />
Profit Status<br />
Profit 127 41.0 2.7 1.3 1.0 0.8 89.9 15.0<br />
Not for Profit 146 46.0 3.3 1.8 1.0 0.9 77.0 10.5<br />
Region:<br />
Africa 243 41.4 4.7 2.3 1.6 1.1 57.1 16.1<br />
Asia 169 51.9 1.5 0.6 0.4 0.4 97.9 17.3<br />
ECA 49 36.9 2.0 1.0 0.4 0.3 79.2 5.5<br />
LAC 53 43.8 4.2 2.4 2.3 1.8 93.4 11.0<br />
MENA 67 54.4 2.4 0.8 0.9 0.4 72.5 19.6<br />
Scale<br />
Small (Scale) 108 44.4 3.7 1.9 0.9 0.7 60.8 11.8<br />
Medium (Scale) 162 45.5 3.1 1.7 1.0 0.9 79.2 11.4<br />
Large (Scale) 150 44.0 2.5 1.3 1.1 0.8 105.0 13.4<br />
Sustainability:<br />
FSS 133 43.7 2.4 1.3 0.8 0.7 95.5 11.8<br />
Non-FSS 106 46.3 4.7 2.4 1.9 1.5 66.4 12.3<br />
Target Market:<br />
Low end 133 53.8 2.9 1.4 0.8 0.6 79.9 13.3<br />
Broad 140 39.9 3.2 1.8 1.4 1.1 84.8 10.8<br />
High end 171 33.2 4.4 2.6 0.9 0.7 67.8 12.4<br />
Small Business 154 25.0 2.3 1.0 0.7 0.6 71.8 16.3<br />
COMPOUND PEER GROUPS<br />
Africa Small FSS 221 48.6 4.0 1.6 1.0 1.0 53.3 13.5<br />
Africa Small Non FSS 155 45.6 5.9 2.9 2.1 2.1 48.2 16.6<br />
Africa Medium FSS 285 43.8 3.8 2.5 2.8 2.4 64.9 11.3<br />
Africa Medium Non FSS 201 45.1 5.3 2.7 2.3 2.1 74.3 16.6<br />
Africa Large FSS 331 33.5 4.4 1.8 1.2 0.9 50.9 17.9<br />
Africa Large Non FSS 242 31.5 5.5 4.5 2.7 2.7 65.3 13.7<br />
Asia Small FSS 124 47.5 2.2 1.4 0.7 0.7 85.6 18.5<br />
Asia Small Non FSS 124 51.7 4.7 3.3 1.9 2.2 57.7 18.8<br />
Asia Medium FSS 246 54.0 0.6 0.3 0.3 0.3 165.1 16.8<br />
Asia Medium Non FSS 168 58.3 4.0 3.3 0.7 0.7 90.7 17.1<br />
Asia Large FSS 1<strong>09</strong> 53.6 0.4 0.2 0.2 0.1 183.1 17.1<br />
Asia Large Non FSS 159 56.9 2.4 0.7 0.6 0.5 99.6 16.5<br />
ECA Small FSS 21 32.5 1.9 0.9 0.0 0.0 50.0 2.8<br />
ECA Small Non FSS 45 33.3 2.9 1.1 0.4 0.1 50.0 4.4<br />
ECA Medium FSS 91 37.0 1.9 0.5 0.2 0.2 79.7 5.5<br />
ECA Medium Non FSS 47 42.9 3.1 1.0 0.8 0.5 55.5 4.6<br />
ECA Large FSS 164 41.4 1.6 0.8 0.5 0.5 103.1 9.2<br />
ECA Large Non FSS 43 41.0 3.2 1.6 1.4 1.1 96.5 11.6<br />
LAC Small FSS 0 43.0 3.7 2.1 0.9 0.9 100.0 10.7<br />
LAC Small Non FSS 0 48.4 6.1 3.1 4.2 3.7 62.3 12.1<br />
LAC Medium FSS 22 45.2 4.3 2.2 2.3 1.9 95.1 9.5<br />
LAC Medium Non FSS 67 45.7 7.9 4.2 4.6 4.1 63.1 9.3<br />
LAC Large FSS 140 40.4 3.2 1.9 2.0 1.8 116.6 12.6<br />
LAC Large Non FSS 84 43.4 6.9 4.4 2.2 1.8 91.4 10.8<br />
MENA Small FSS 143 43.9 1.6 0.7 0.0 0.0 58.6 29.2<br />
MENA Small Non-FSS 42 55.0 5.7 0.6 5.6 5.6 58.0 23.5<br />
MENA Medium FSS n/a 67.4 3.0 2.6 0.0 0.0 92.1 19.8<br />
MENA Medium Non-FSS n/a 54.4 1.9 0.6 1.8 0.7 63.9 21.9<br />
MENA Large FSS n/a 54.2 1.9 1.2 0.4 0.2 74.9 14.5<br />
MENA Large Non-FSS 22 58.6 1.7 1.0 0.6 0.4 532.1 19.0<br />
For definitions of Peer Groups, refer to the Peer Group Classification section on pp45–46. For details on indicator definitions, refer to the Indicator Definitions section on pp<br />
53. “n/a” denotes results for Peer Groups with less than three observations<br />
52<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
BULLETIN TABLES<br />
Indicator Definitions<br />
Changes to MIX data standards and indicators<br />
Starting with the 2008 MFI Benchmarks, MIX has made a number of changes to the way MFI data is presented and the processes for recording and transforming that data.<br />
Readers will find differences in data due to improved account structuring, consistent with international standards (IFRS), methods for calculating and converting data into<br />
USD, and ways in which aggregate data is displayed. Users will find more details about changes to currency translation, averages, financial statement and product data by<br />
going to www.mixmarket.org > About MIX Market > About the Data.<br />
INSTITUTIONAL CHARACTERISTICS<br />
Number of MF<strong>Is</strong><br />
Age<br />
Total Assets<br />
Offices<br />
Personnel<br />
FINANCING STRUCTURE<br />
Capital/Asset Ratio<br />
Debt to Equity<br />
Deposits to Loans<br />
Deposits to Total Assets<br />
Portfolio to Assets<br />
OUTREACH INDICATORS<br />
Number of Active Borrowers<br />
Percent of Women Borrowers<br />
Number of Loans Outstanding<br />
Gross Loan Portfolio<br />
Average Loan Balance per Borrower<br />
Average Loan Balance per Borrower/GNI per Capita<br />
Average Outstanding Balance<br />
Average Outstanding Balance/GNI per Capita<br />
Number of Depositors<br />
Number of Deposit Accounts<br />
Deposits<br />
Average Deposit Balance per Depositor<br />
Average Deposit Balance per Depositor/GNI per capita<br />
Average Deposit Account Balance<br />
Average Deposit Account Balance/GNI per capita<br />
MACROECONOMIC INDICATORS<br />
GNI per Capita<br />
GDP Growth Rate<br />
Deposit Rate<br />
Inflation Rate<br />
Financial Depth<br />
OVERALL FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE<br />
Return on Assets<br />
Return on Equity<br />
Operational Self-Sufficiency<br />
Financial Self-Sufficiency<br />
REVENUES<br />
Financial Revenue/Assets<br />
Profit Margin<br />
Yield on Gross Portfolio (nominal)<br />
Yield on Gross Portfolio (real)<br />
EXPENSES<br />
Total Expense/Assets<br />
Financial Expense/Assets<br />
Provision for Loan Impairment/Assets<br />
Operating Expense/Assets<br />
Personnel Expense/Assets<br />
Administrative Expense/Assets<br />
Adjustment Expense/Assets<br />
EFFICIENCY<br />
Operating Expense/Loan Portfolio<br />
Personnel Expense/Loan Portfolio<br />
Average Salary/GNI per Capita<br />
Cost per Borrower<br />
Cost per Loan<br />
PRODUCTIVITY<br />
Borrowers per Staff Member<br />
Loans per Staff Member<br />
Borrowers per Loan Officer<br />
Loans per Loan Officer<br />
Depositors per Staff Member<br />
Deposit Accounts per Staff Member<br />
Personnel Allocation Ratio<br />
RISK AND LIQUIDITY<br />
Portfolio at Risk > 30 Days<br />
Portfolio at Risk > 90 Days<br />
Write-off Ratio<br />
Loan Loss Rate<br />
Risk Coverage Ratio<br />
Non-earning Liquid Assets as a % of Total Assets<br />
Sample Size of Group<br />
Years Functioning as an MFI<br />
Total Assets, adjusted for Inflation and standardized provisioning for loan impairment and write-offs<br />
Number, including head office<br />
Total number of staff members<br />
Adjusted Total Equity/Adjusted Total Assets<br />
Adjusted Total Liabilities/Adjusted Total Equity<br />
Voluntary Deposits/Adjusted Gross Loan Portfolio<br />
Voluntary Deposits/Adjusted Total Assets<br />
Adjusted Gross Loan Portfolio/Adjusted Total Assets<br />
Number of borrowers with loans outstanding, adjusted for standardized write-offs<br />
Number of active women borrowers/Adjusted Number of Active Borrowers<br />
Number of loans outstanding, adjusted for standardized write-offs<br />
Gross Loan Portfolio, adjusted for standardized write-offs<br />
Adjusted Gross Loan Portfolio/Adjusted Number of Active Borrowers<br />
Adjusted Average Loan Balance per Borrower/GNI per Capita<br />
Adjusted Gross Loan Portfolio/Adjusted Number of Loans Outstanding<br />
Adjusted Average Outstanding Balance/GNI per Capita<br />
Number of depositors with any type of deposit account<br />
Number of all deposit accounts<br />
Total value of all deposit accounts<br />
Deposits/Number of Depositors<br />
Average Deposit Balance per Depositor/GNI per capita<br />
Depositors/Number of Deposit Accounts<br />
Average Deposit Account Balance/GNI per capita<br />
Total income generated by a country's residents, irrespective of location/Total number of residents<br />
(World Development Indicators)<br />
Annual growth in the total output of goods and services occurring within the territory of a given<br />
country (World Development Indicators)<br />
Interest rate offered to resident customers for demand, time, or savings deposits (IMF/International<br />
Financial Statistics)<br />
Annual change in average consumer prices (IMF/International Financial Statistics)<br />
Money aggregate including currency, deposits and electronic currency (M3)/GDP, measuring the<br />
monetization of the economy (IMF/International Financial Statistics)<br />
(Adjusted Net Operating Income - Taxes)/Adjusted Average Total Assets<br />
(Adjusted Net Operating Income - Taxes)/Adjusted Average Total Equity<br />
Financial Revenue/(Financial Expense + Impairment Losses on Loans + Operating Expense)<br />
Adjusted Financial Revenue/Adjusted (Financial Expense + Impairment Losses on Loans + Operating<br />
Expense)<br />
Adjusted Financial Revenue/Adjusted Average Total Assets<br />
Adjusted Net Operating Income/Adjusted Financial Revenue<br />
Adjusted Financial Revenue from Loan Portfolio/Adjusted Average Gross Loan Portfolio<br />
(Adjusted Yield on Gross Portfolio (nominal) - Inflation Rate)/(1 + Inflation Rate)<br />
Adjusted (Financial Expense + Net Impairment Loss + Operating Expense)/Adjusted Average Total Assets<br />
Adjusted Financial Expense/Adjusted Average Total Assets<br />
Adjusted Impairment Losses on Loans/Adjusted Average Total Assets<br />
Adjusted Operating Expense/Adjusted Average Total Assets<br />
Adjusted Personnel Expense/Adjusted Average Total Assets<br />
Adjusted Administrative Expense/Adjusted Average Total Assets<br />
(Unadjusted Net Operating Income - Adjusted Net Operating Income)/Adjusted Average Total Assets<br />
Adjusted Operating Expense/Adjusted Average Gross Loan Portfolio<br />
Adjusted Personnel Expense/Adjusted Average Gross Loan Portfolio<br />
Adjusted Average Personnel Expense/GNI per capita<br />
Adjusted Operating Expense/Adjusted Average Number of Active Borrowers<br />
Adjusted Operating Expense/Adjusted Average Number of Loans<br />
Adjusted Number of Active Borrowers/Number of Personnel<br />
Adjusted Number of Loans Outstanding/Number of Personnel<br />
Adjusted Number of Active Borrowers/Number of Loan Officers<br />
Adjusted Number of Loans Outstanding/Number of Loan Officers<br />
Number of Depositors/Number of Personnel<br />
Number of Deposit Accounts/Number of Personnel<br />
Number of Loan Officers/Number of Personnel<br />
Outstanding balance, portfolio overdue> 30 Days + renegotiated portfolio/Adjusted Gross Loan Portfolio<br />
Outstanding balance, portfolio overdue> 90 Days + renegotiated portfolio/Adjusted Gross Loan Portfolio<br />
Adjusted Value of loans written-off/Adjusted Average Gross Loan Portfolio<br />
(Adjusted Write-offs - Value of Loans Recovered)/Adjusted Average Gross Loan Portfolio<br />
Adjusted Impairment Loss Allowance/PAR > 30 Days<br />
Adjusted Cash and banks/Adjusted Total Assets<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
53
BULLETIN TABLES<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
Peer Group - 2008 DATA QUALITY †<br />
SIMPLE PEER GROUPS<br />
Age: New<br />
(0 to 4 Years)<br />
Age: Young<br />
(5 to 8 Years)<br />
Age: Mature<br />
(> 8 Years)<br />
PEER GROUP–2008<br />
N * ** *** PARTICIPATING INSTITUTIONS<br />
191 84 95 12 1st MCC, ACB sa, ACFB, ACLEDA Lao, Aden, Agrocredit Plus, Al Rafah Bank, Alliance Group,<br />
Alliance MFB, Alternativa 19 del Sur, Al-Thiqa, Alwatani, AMfB, AMFI, Amlok, ANDE, Apoyo<br />
Económico, AREGAK UCO, Arnur Credit, Arohan, ASA - GHA, ASA Philippines, ASUSU CIIGABA,<br />
Avantaj, Bancamía, Banco Amigo, Rede Novo Sol, Banco Popular do Brasil, Bereke-credit,<br />
Berendina Microfinance, BJS, Blago, BMT Kayu Manis, BOM, Borshud, BPR BKK Cilacap, BRAC<br />
- LKA, BRAC - SS, BRAC - TZA, BRAC - UGA, BRCCC, CAFODEC, CAURIE Micro Finance, CEDEF,<br />
Chamroeun, COAC Chone, COAC Fernando Daquilema, COAC Padre Vicente, Columbia<br />
Microcreditos, Common Interest, COOPAC Norandino, COOPEC Hinfani Dosso, CRAC Nuestra<br />
Gente, Crece Safsa, CrediClub, CrediComún, Créditos Pronegocio, CREDITUYO, Cresol Central,<br />
Crezcamos, DAYAQ-Credit, Dirigible, Don Apoyo, DQF, Duterimbere, Ehyoi kuhiston, Elet-Capital,<br />
Equitas, Farm Credit Armenia, FinAgro, FINCA - JOR, FINORTE, FMF, FNT Credit, FONDESOL,<br />
Forjadores de Negocios, Galaktika, Garant-Invest, GCM, GGEM Microfinance Services Ltd.,<br />
GOF, Grupo Río La Venta, Harbu, HiH, IMFB, Imodi Hutal, Impuls, Instituto Estrela, Invest Credit,<br />
Invest-Credit Moldova, Invirtiendo, IPR, Izdiharona Microfinance, Kashf Bank, KBank, Kemek,<br />
Kompanion, KVK-Altay, LAPO-SLE, Letta, LSK, MADRAC, Mahashakti, Maqsadi dasgiri, MCL, MCO<br />
‘Oral’, MiBanco Venezuela, MicroCred - MDG, MicroCred - MEX, MicroCred - SEN, Micredito<br />
SAC, Microfinanciera Prisma, Mikrokredit Bank, MikroMaliyye Credit, Mimo Finance, MLF<br />
Kiropol, MLF Madina, MLF Vahsh Microfin, MLO HUMO, MLO ‘Saodat Invest’, MoFAD, Mol Bulak<br />
Finance, Nadejda, NCS, NEED, Neftegaz, NMFB, Nov Credit, Obereg (Vladivostok), OI China, OISL,<br />
Opportunity Finance, Opportunity Kenya, OXUS - AFG, OXUS - KGS, Partner Russia, PAWDEP, PNG<br />
Microfinance Ltd, POMFB, Popular SAFI, Povoljye, ProCredit - COL, ProCredit - HND, ProCredit<br />
Bank - MDA, ProCredit Bank - SLE, ProCredit Bank- DRC, Progresemos, Pro Mujer - ARG, RAFODE,<br />
RCCECG, Red de Vanguardia, REDFunds, Reef, Reliance, Rezerv, Rishenglong, Riverbank, RML,<br />
Rus, WMN (Russia), Samasta, Sarala, SEM Fund, SemiSol, SEWA Finance, SFF, SFSD, SOCRED,<br />
Sodeystviye-2005, Soluciones Reales, Sonata, SoyuzKredit, Sugd Microfin, Mentors - PER, SFPL, Te<br />
Creemos, TMFB, Trident Microfinance, Tsimlyansk, Tujijenge, Turame Community Finance, UCCEC<br />
GY, Ujjivan, UMECDES, UNION DES COOPECs UMUTANGUHA, VFM, Vivir Soluciones, Vostok<br />
Kapital, WISE, WOCCU - AFG, WWI - AFG<br />
203 62 127 14 ABCRDM, ABWA, Abyan, Abzal Kredit, AccessBank, ADCSI, Adhikar, AFS, Agência do Crédito,<br />
Aqrarkredit, Agroinvestbank, A-invest, Akuapem RB, Al Awael, Alternativa Microfinanzas, AMC<br />
de R.L., AMEXTRA, AML, AMOS, APED, APROS, Aqroinvest, ARDI, ARMP, Asasah, Asociación El<br />
Balsamo, A<strong>SP</strong> Financiera, ASR, ASTI, ATEMEXPA, Atwima Kwanwoma, Azal, Azeri Star, Bai Tushum,<br />
Banco do Vale, BANCRI, Bandhan, BAYOCA, Bereke, BFSBS, Binhminh CDC, BMT Pringsewu, BRAC<br />
- AFG, BZMF, CACMU, Capitec Bank, Casa do Microcrédito, CBB, CBIRD, CDM, CEP Long An, CEVI,<br />
CFA, CFE, CHF Iraq, Childfund Hoa Binh, CMFinance, COAC Acción Rural, COAC Ambato, COAC<br />
Fondvida, COAC Kullki Wasi, COAC Luz del Valle, COAC Santa Anita, COCDEP, Comultrasan,<br />
COOPAC Los Andes, CO<strong>SP</strong>EC, CredAgro NBCO, CREDIT, Credit Mongol, CRYSOL, CU Pantai Prigi,<br />
CUMO, CZWSDA, DD Bank, Doveriye - Volgograd, ECLOF - ARM, ECLOF - PHL, Edinstvo-Volgograd,<br />
EDPYME Acceso Crediticio, EDPYME Alternativa, EDPYME Credivisión, EDPYME Efectiva, EDPYME<br />
Pro Negocios, Eshet, Crezkamos Kapital, Fácil SCM, FIDEVIE, FIE Gran Poder, FinAmigo, FINCA<br />
- AFG, FINCA - DRC, FINCA - KOS, FINCA - TJK, FINCA - ZMB, FinDev, FISUR, FMFB - AFG, FMFB<br />
- Pakistan, FMFB - TJK, FMFI-SYR, FODEM, FORWARD, Fundación Alternativa, FUNDAHMICRO,<br />
FUNDESER, FVP, Grameen Mendoza, Hekima, Hluvuku, Hofokam, Hope for Life, Horizon,<br />
Horizonti, ICC Conquista Solidária, ICC MAUCE, IDDA, Indur MACS, Jabal Al Hoss, Joldosh Group,<br />
JOVID, KADET, Kakum RB, Kasagana-Ka, Kazama Grameen, KCCDFI, Khushhali Bank, Komak<br />
Credit, KosInvest, Kredo, KRK Ltd, Lak Jaya, Lazika Capital, Lead Foundation, LIDER, Life Bank, M7<br />
Ninh Phuoc, Manushi, Marang, Maxima, Mbinga CB, MBK Ventura, MDF, MECBAS, Meklit, MFI,<br />
MGPCC DEKAWOWO, Micro Africa, Micro Start, Microinvest, MLF MicroInvest, MLF MWI, Moldir,<br />
Moris Rasik, MUL, Narodniy Kredit_Kemerov, NMF, NovoBanco - MOZ, OBS, Faulu - TZA, OIBM,<br />
OMB, OMRO, Oportunidad Microfinanzas, Otiv Diana, Parwaz, PASED, PATRA Hunchun, PATRA<br />
Yanbian, Plan International, ProCredit - ECU, ProCredit - GHA, ProCredit - NIC, ProCredit Bank<br />
- BGR, ProCredit Bank - MKD, ProCredit Bank - ROM, ProCredit Bank - UKR, ProCredit Bank Serbia,<br />
Progresar, Pro Mujer - MEX, Real Microcrédito, Reserv-Altay, São Paulo Confia, Saadhana, SB Bank,<br />
SOCIALCRED, Sodruzhestvo, SOGESOL, SolFi, Solución Asea, Soyuz-Khimik, Soyuz-Primoroye,<br />
<strong>SP</strong>BD, SU, SUMI, TFS, Tsaritsinskiy passaj, U-IMCEC, Umid, Umid-Credit, VFC, VRFSBS, Wasasa<br />
657 191 391 75 1st Valley Bank, 3A Entreprises, A3C, ABA, ABS-CBN, ACAD, ACBA, ACCOVI, ACEP Cameroon,<br />
ACEP Senegal, ACF, ACLEDA, ACME, ACORDE, ACSI, Actuar Caldas, Actuar Tolima, ADICH, ADIM,<br />
ADOPEM, ADRA - PER, ADRI, Aetos, AFK, AFODENIC, AGAPE, AgroCapital, Agroimpuls, AgroInvest,<br />
AGUDESA, Aiyl Bank, Akiba, Al Amana, Al Karama, Al Majmoua, Al Tadamun, Alidé, ALSOL,<br />
Alternativa, Alteya, AMA, AMC, Ameen, AMK, AMMACTS, AMRET, AMSSF/MC, ANED, Apoyo<br />
Integral, ARD, ARDCI, ASA, ASALA, ASBA, ASC Union, ASDIR, ASEI, ASHI, ASIDME, ASKI, Asociación<br />
Arariwa, Asociación Raíz, ASODENIC, ASOPROSANRAMON, A<strong>SP</strong>IRE, Avanzar, AWS, AYNLA,<br />
Azercredit, Azerdemiryolbank, Banco ADEMI, Banco da Familia, Banco do Empreendedor, Banco<br />
do Povo ACP, Banco Familiar, Banco Santiago de Libon, Banco Solidario, BancoEstado, BancoSol,<br />
BanCovelo, BANEX, BanGente, Bangko Kabayan, Bangko Mabuhay, Bank Eskhata, Bank of Baku,<br />
BASIX, BCB, BCSC, BEES, BESA, Bessfa RB, BFL, BG, BIMAS, BISWA, BMSCCSL, Bonzali RB, BPR AN,<br />
BPR AK, BPR Artadamas Mandiri, BPR BBTM, BPR Citama, BPR DMG, BPR Eka Ayu, BPR Eka Usaha,<br />
BPR NSI, BPR Pinang Artha, BPR PKT, BPR Sukawati Pancakanti, BPR Surya Yudha Kencana, BPR<br />
Taman Dhana, BRAC, BSS, BTA Bank, BURO Bangladesh, BWDC, CAFASA, Caja Depac Poblana,<br />
Caja Popular Mexicana, CamCCUL, CAME, CCAMETRO, Cantilan Bank, CAPA, CAPPED, CARD Bank,<br />
54<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
BULLETIN TABLES<br />
Peer Group - 2008 DATA QUALITY †<br />
SIMPLE PEER GROUPS<br />
Charter Type: Bank<br />
(Bank)<br />
N * ** *** PARTICIPATING INSTITUTIONS<br />
CARD NGO, CARE - CREEME, Caritas, Caritas Esteli, Cashpor MC, CBDIBA/RENACA, CBMO, CCA,<br />
CCC, CDRO, CDS, CEADe, CEAPE BA, CEAPE MA, CEAPE PE, CEAPE PI, CECA, CECIC S.A., CEC-PROM<br />
Mature, CEF, Centenary Bank, Central Cresol Baser, CEOSS, CEP, CEP BRVT, CEPESIU, CEPRODEL,<br />
CESOL ACJ, CETZAM, CFF, CFPA, Chandeshwori, CHC-Limited, Chita FSBS, CIDRE, CMAC Arequipa,<br />
CMAC Cusco, CMAC Del Santa, CMAC Huancayo, CMAC Ica, CMAC Maynas, CMAC Paita, CMAC<br />
Pisco, CMAC Piura, CMAC Sullana, CMAC Tacna, CMAC Trujillo, CMCA, CMEDFI, CMMB, CMS, COAC<br />
4 de Octubre, COAC Artesanos, COAC Huaycopungo, COAC Jardín Azuayo, COAC La Benéfica,<br />
COAC MCCH, COAC Minga, COAC Mushuc Runa, COAC La Nacional, COAC Pallatanga, COAC Sac<br />
Aiet, COAC San Antonio, COAC San Gabriel, COAC San José, COAC Santa Ana, CODESARROLLO,<br />
CompartamosBanco, Conserva, Contactar, Coop 20 de Abril, Coop Avances, Coop Fátima,<br />
Coop Jesús Nazareno, Coop Juan XXIII, COOPAC Chiquinquira, COOPAC León XIII, COOPAC San<br />
Cristóbal, COOPAC San Martín, COOPAC Santa Maria, COOPAC Santo Cristo, COOPAC Santo<br />
Domingo, COOPAC Tocache, COOPEC/ACCO, COOPEDU-Kigali, COOPROGRESO, CPECG Yete<br />
Mali, CRAC Los Andes, CRAC Profinanzas, CRAC Señor de Luren, CRAC Sipán, CRAN, CRECER,<br />
Credi Fé, CrediAmigo, CrediAvance, Credi-Capital, Credicoop, CREDIMUJER, Crediscotia, Credisol,<br />
CREDO, CReSA, CRG, Crystal, CSD, CU Kosayu, CU Sawiran, CVECA Kita/Bafoulabé, CVECA Pays<br />
Dogon, CVECA SOUM, CWCD, DAMEN, DBACD, DEC, DECSI, DEF, DEPROSC-Nepal, Despacho<br />
Amador, Diaconia, Dian Mandiri, DINARI, DJOMEC, DSK Dobrich, D-Miro, Doveriye (Amursk),<br />
Doveriye- Bulgaria, Doveriye-Altay, D<strong>SP</strong>I, ECLOF - ECU, EcoFuturo FFP, EDAPRO<strong>SP</strong>O, Edinstvo<br />
Yurga, EDPYME Confianza, EDPYME Crear Arequipa, EDPYME Nueva Visión, EDPYME Proempresa,<br />
EDPYME Raíz, EKI, EKPA, Emprender, Enda, ENLACE, Equity Bank, ESAF, ESED, Espacios<br />
Alternativos, Express Finance, FACES, FADEMYPE,<br />
FAFIDESS, FAIR Bank, FAM, FAMA OPDF, FAPE, FASL, Fassil FFP, FATEN, Faulu - KEN, Faulu - UGA,<br />
FBPMC, AfricaWorks, FDL, FDM, FECECAM, FED, FFECC, FFSA, FIACG, FICO, FIDERPAC, FIE FFP,<br />
FIELCO, FinAmérica, Financiera Edyficar, Financiera Fama, Financiera Independencia, FINCA<br />
- ARM, FINCA - AZE, FINCA - ECU, FINCA - GEO, FINCA - GTM, FINCA - HND, FINCA - HTI, FINCA<br />
- MEX, FINCA - MWI, FINCA - NIC, FINCA - PER, FINCA - Russia, FINCA - SLV, FINCA - TZA, FINCA<br />
- UGA, FinComún, FINCORP, FINSOL, First Macro Bank, Emprenda, FMCC, FMM Bucaramanga,<br />
FMM Popayán, FMSD, FODEMI, FOMIC, FONCRESOL, FONDECO, FONDEP, FONDESURCO, Fondo<br />
Esperanza, Fonkoze, Fortaleza FFP, FORUS, FOVIDA, FRAC, FUBODE, FUCEC Togo, FUDEMI,<br />
FULM, FUNBODEM, Fundación 4i-2000, Fundación Amanecer, Fundación CAMPO, Fundación<br />
Esperanza, Fundación Espoir, Fundación León 2000, Fundación MICROS, Fundación Mujer,<br />
Fundación Nieborowski, Fundación Paraguaya, FUNDAMIC, FUNDEA, FUNDEBASE, FUNDECOCA,<br />
FUNDENUSE, FUNDEPYME, FUNDE<strong>SP</strong>E, Fundusz Mikro, FUNED, FUNHAVI, FUNSALDE, Génesis<br />
Empresarial, Gasha, GAWFA, GBNB, General Toshevo, GF<strong>SP</strong>L, GM Bank, Gorodskoy, GRAINE sarl,<br />
Grameen Bank, Green Bank, GU, GV, HEED, HDH OPDF, HKL, HOPE, H<strong>SP</strong>FI, ICC BluSol, ICMFB,<br />
IDEPRO, IDER CV, IDESI Lambayeque, IDE<strong>SP</strong>A, IDF, ID-Ghana, IDH, IDYDC, IFDP, ImerCredit,<br />
Imkoniyat, IMON, IMPRO, INECO, Inicjatywa Mikro, INMAA, INSOTEC, Intellekt, Interactuar, Interfisa<br />
Financiera, Jamii Bora, Janodaya, JCF, Jigiyaso Ba, JSC Bank Constanta, JSCCS, Juaben RB, JVS, Kafo<br />
Jiginew, KAMURJ, Kashf Foundation, Kajnardza 96, KBSLAB, KEP, KGMAMF, Khan Bank, KixiCredito,<br />
KMB, KMBI, KMF, Kokari, Kondo Jigima, KOPSA, KPOSB, K-Rep, KRUSHI, KSF, KSK RPK, KVK, KWFT,<br />
La Community Bank, LAM, LAPO-NGR, LOK Microcredit Foundation, M7 Can Loc, M7 DB District,<br />
M7 DBP City, M7 Dong Trieu, M7 Mai Son, M7 Uong bi, Maata-N-Tudu, FAF-DC, Mahasemam,<br />
Mahila, Mahuli, Makhzoumi, Mallig Plains RB, Manuela Ramos, Maritsa Invest, MC², MCN, MEC<br />
AFER, MEC FEPRODES, MECREF, MEDF, MED-Net, MEMCO, MFW, MGBB, MiBanco, MI-BO<strong>SP</strong>O, Coop<br />
MEDA, Microserfin, Microsol, MIDE, MIKRA, Mikro ALDI, Mikrofond, Miselini, Miziya, MLF Chiluchor<br />
chashma, MAMIDECOT, Momina Voda, Moznosti, MPGBB, MUDE, MUSCCO, Mutuelle Akwaba,<br />
Nachala, Nadejda 96, NBJK, NeRuDO, New RB of Victorias, Nidan, Nirdhan, Normicro, NRDSC,<br />
NSBA, Nwabiagya RB, NWTF, Nyesigiso, OBM, OCSSCO, ODEF Financiera, OLC, Opportunity<br />
Albania, Otiv Alaotra, Otiv Sambava, Otiv Tana, Otuasekan RB, OXUS - TJK, PADME, PAIDEK, PALFSI,<br />
PAMECAS, PAPME, Parabank, PARC, Partner, PASECA - Kayes, PBC, PEACE, Perelik, PGBB, Pomoriiski<br />
stopanin, Popular Kasa-Kystendil, PR Bank, PRASAC, PRESTANIC, PRIDE - TZA, Pride Finance,<br />
PRISMA, PRIZMA, ProCaja, ProCredit - BOL, ProCredit - MDA, ProCredit - SLV, ProCredit Bank<br />
- ALB, ProCredit Bank - BIH, ProCredit Bank - GEO, ProCredit Bank - KOS, PRODEM FFP, PRODESA,<br />
Progressive Bank, Pro Mujer - BOL, Pro Mujer - NIC, Pro Mujer - PER, Pushtikar, PWMACS, RADE,<br />
Raduga, RASS, RB Bagac, RB Cainta, RB Camalig, RB Cotabato, RB Digos, RB Lebak, RB Mabitac,<br />
RB Montevista, RB Oroquieta, RB Placer, RB Siargao, RB Solano, RB Talisayan, RCDS, RCPB, RGVN,<br />
ROMCOM, Rost, R<strong>SP</strong>I, Ryada, Sabaragamuwa, SABR, Saglasie 96, Sahara Mahila, Sajida, Samokov<br />
96, Sanghamithra, Sartawi, Sarvodaya Nano Finance, SAT, Sathapana Limited, SBACD, SBS, SCDA,<br />
SCNL, SDBL, SEAP, SED, SEDA, SEEDS, SEF-ARM, SEF-ZAF, Seilanithih, Serviamus, SEWA Bank, SFPI,<br />
Shakti, SHARE, SINERGIJA, SIPEM, SKDRDP, SKS, SMEP, Smilyan, SMSS, PADECOMSM, Sodeystviye,<br />
SOFINA, Soglasiye, Solidarnost, Soro Yiriwaso, South Akim RB, Spandana, <strong>SP</strong>GBB, SSS, Stanichnik,<br />
Stopanin, Sungi, Sunrise, SWAWS, Tamweelcom, Tchuma, TIAVO, TLM, TPC, TSKI, TYM, UCADE<br />
Ambato, UCADE Guaranda, UCADE Latacunga, UCADE Santo Domingo, UCEC/MK, UNACOOPEC-<br />
CI, UNICREICH, Union RB, UNRWA, UOB, Upper Manya RB, USFSBS, USTOI, Finance Trust, Valiant RB,<br />
VB<strong>SP</strong>, VFS, Viator, Visión Banco, Vital Finance, VSSU, VYCCU, WAGES, WDB, Wisdom, WKP, Women<br />
for Women, World Relief - HND, WSE, WWB Cali, XacBank, Zakoura,<br />
82 6 62 14 ACBA, AccessBank, ACLEDA, ACLEDA Lao, ADOPEM, Agroinvestbank, Aiyl Bank, Akiba, Al Rafah<br />
Bank, AMfB, Azerdemiryolbank, Bancamía, Banco ADEMI, Banco Amigo, Banco Familiar, Banco<br />
Popular do Brasil, Banco Solidario, BancoEstado, BancoSol, BanCovelo, BanGente, Bank Eskhata,<br />
Bank of Baku, BCSC, BOM, BTA Bank, Capitec Bank, Centenary Bank, Columbia Microcreditos,<br />
CompartamosBanco, CrediAmigo, Crediscotia, CRG, Equity Bank, FINCA - ECU, FMFB - AFG, FMFB<br />
- TJK, FORUS, Grameen Bank, ICMFB, IMFB, INECO, JSC Bank Constanta, KBank, Khan Bank, KMB,<br />
KPOSB, K-Rep, La Community Bank, LAPO-SLE, MiBanco, MiBanco Venezuela, Mikrokredit Bank,<br />
Nirdhan, NovoBanco - MOZ, OBM, OBS, OIBM, OMB, Parabank, ProCredit - BOL, ProCredit - COL,<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
55
BULLETIN TABLES<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
Peer Group - 2008 DATA QUALITY †<br />
SIMPLE PEER GROUPS<br />
Charter Type: Credit Union<br />
(Credit Union)<br />
Charter Type: NBFI<br />
(Non - Bank Financial<br />
Intermediary)<br />
N * ** *** PARTICIPATING INSTITUTIONS<br />
ProCredit - ECU, ProCredit - HND, ProCredit - NIC, ProCredit - SLV, ProCredit Bank - ALB, ProCredit<br />
Bank - BGR, ProCredit Bank - BIH, ProCredit Bank - GEO, ProCredit Bank - KOS, ProCredit Bank<br />
- MDA, ProCredit Bank - MKD, ProCredit Bank - ROM, ProCredit Bank - SLE, ProCredit Bank - UKR,<br />
ProCredit Bank- DRC, ProCredit Bank Serbia, SEWA Bank, VB<strong>SP</strong>, Visión Banco, XacBank<br />
182 99 72 11 ACEP Senegal, ACFB, Aetos, Agroimpuls, Alternativa, Alteya, AMMACTS, Aqroinvest, ASC<br />
Union, ASR, Avantaj, Blago, BMSCCSL, BMT Kayu Manis, BRCCC, CACMU, Caja Depac Poblana,<br />
Caja Popular Mexicana, CamCCUL, CCAMETRO, CDM, CECA, CEC-PROM Mature, Central Cresol<br />
Baser, Chandeshwori, CMCA, CMMB, CMS, COAC 4 de Octubre, COAC Acción Rural, COAC<br />
Ambato, COAC Artesanos, COAC Chone, COAC Fernando Daquilema, COAC Fondvida, COAC<br />
Huaycopungo, COAC Jardín Azuayo, COAC Kullki Wasi, COAC La Benéfica, COAC Luz del Valle,<br />
COAC MCCH, COAC Minga, COAC Mushuc Runa, COAC La Nacional, COAC Padre Vicente, COAC<br />
Pallatanga, COAC Sac Aiet, COAC San Antonio, COAC San Gabriel, COAC San José, COAC Santa<br />
Ana, COAC Santa Anita, CODESARROLLO, Comultrasan, Coop 20 de Abril, Coop Avances, Coop<br />
Fátima, Coop Jesús Nazareno, Coop Juan XXIII, COOPAC Chiquinquira, COOPAC León XIII,<br />
COOPAC Los Andes, COOPAC Norandino, COOPAC San Cristóbal, COOPAC San Martín, COOPAC<br />
Santa Maria, COOPAC Santo Cristo, COOPAC Santo Domingo, COOPAC Tocache, COOPEC<br />
Hinfani Dosso, COOPEC/ACCO, COOPEDU-Kigali, COOPROGRESO, CO<strong>SP</strong>EC, CPECG Yete Mali,<br />
Credicoop, Cresol Central, CU Sawiran, DJOMEC, DSK Dobrich, Doveriye - Volgograd, Doveriye<br />
(Amursk), Doveriye- Bulgaria, Doveriye-Altay, Edinstvo Yurga, Edinstvo-Volgograd, EKPA,<br />
FAM, FECECAM, FFECC, FUCEC Togo, FULM, Galaktika, General Toshevo, Gorodskoy, Impuls,<br />
Indur MACS, Intellekt, Jigiyaso Ba, JSCCS, Kafo Jiginew, Kajnardza 96, Kokari, Komak Credit,<br />
Kondo Jigima, Kredo, KSK RPK, KVK, KVK-Altay, LSK, Madfa SACCO, Mahila, Maritsa Invest, MC²,<br />
MEC AFER, MEC FEPRODES, MECBAS, MECREF, MGPCC DEKAWOWO, Coop MEDA, Miziya,<br />
MAMIDECOT, Momina Voda, Moznosti, MUSCCO, Mutuelle Akwaba, Nachala, Nadejda, Nadejda<br />
96, Narodniy Kredit_Kemerov, Neftegaz, Nyesigiso, Obereg (Vladivostok), Otiv Alaotra, Otiv<br />
Diana, Otiv Sambava, Otiv Tana, PAMECAS, Partner Russia, PASECA - Kayes, Perelik, Pomoriiski<br />
stopanin, Popular Kasa-Kystendil, Povoljye, Pushtikar, PWMACS, Raduga, RCCECG, RCPB,<br />
Reserv-Altay, Rezerv, Riverbank, Rost, Rus, Saglasie 96, Sahara Mahila, Samokov 96, SBS, Smilyan,<br />
Sodeystviye, Sodeystviye-2005, Soglasiye, Solidarnost, Soyuz-Khimik, SoyuzKredit, Soyuz-<br />
Primoroye, Stanichnik, Stopanin, TIAVO, Tsaritsinskiy passaj, Tsimlyansk, Tverskoy, UCCEC GY,<br />
UCEC/MK, U-IMCEC, UMECDES, Umid, UNACOOPEC-CI, UNION DES COOPECs UMUTANGUHA,<br />
Vostok Kapital, VYCCU, WOCCU - AFG<br />
338 99 192 47 1st MCC, 3A Entreprises, Abzal Kredit, ACB sa, ACCOVI, ACF, ACSI, ADCSI, AFS, Aqrarkredit,<br />
AgroInvest, A-invest, Al Awael, Alliance Group, Alliance MFB, Alternativa 19 del Sur, Alwatani,<br />
AMC, AMC de R.L., Ameen, AMK, AML, Amlok, AMRET, Apoyo Económico, Apoyo Integral, AREGAK<br />
UCO, Arnur Credit, Arohan, A<strong>SP</strong> Financiera, ASTI, ASUSU CIIGABA, AWS, Azercredit, Azeri Star, Bai<br />
Tushum, Bandhan, BANEX, BASIX, BAYOCA, Bereke-credit, Berendina Microfinance, BFL, BFSBS,<br />
BG, Borshud, CAFASA, CAFODEC, CAPA, CAURIE Micro Finance, CBIRD, CCA, CDS, CECIC S.A., CEF,<br />
CETZAM, CFA, CFE, CHC-Limited, Chita FSBS, CMAC Arequipa, CMAC Cusco, CMAC Del Santa,<br />
CMAC Huancayo, CMAC Ica, CMAC Maynas, CMAC Paita, CMAC Pisco, CMAC Piura, CMAC Sullana,<br />
CMAC Tacna, CMAC Trujillo, CMFinance, CRAC Los Andes, CRAC Nuestra Gente, CRAC Profinanzas,<br />
CRAC Señor de Luren, CRAC Sipán, Crece Safsa, CredAgro NBCO, Credi Fé, CrediAvance, Credi-<br />
Capital, CrediClub, CrediComún, CREDIT, Credit Mongol, Créditos Pronegocio, CREDITUYO,<br />
CREDO, Crezcamos, Crystal, DAYAQ-Credit, DD Bank, DECSI, Degaf, Despacho Amador, Dirigible,<br />
Don Apoyo, Duterimbere, ECLOF - ARM, EcoFuturo FFP, EDPYME Acceso Crediticio, EDPYME<br />
Alternativa, EDPYME Confianza, EDPYME Crear Arequipa, EDPYME Credivisión, EDPYME<br />
Efectiva, EDPYME Nueva Visión, EDPYME Pro Negocios, EDPYME Proempresa, EDPYME Raíz,<br />
Ehyoi kuhiston, EKI, Elet-Capital, ENLACE, Equitas, Eshet, Crezkamos Kapital, Fácil SCM, FAMA<br />
OPDF, Farm Credit Armenia, FASL, Fassil FFP, FATEN, Faulu - KEN, Faulu - UGA, FFSA, FIE FFP,<br />
FIE Gran Poder, FIELCO, FinAgro, FinAmérica, FinAmigo, Financiera Edyficar, Financiera Fama,<br />
Financiera Independencia, FINCA - AFG, FINCA - ARM, FINCA - AZE, FINCA - GEO, FINCA - HND,<br />
FINCA - Russia, FINCA - TJK, FINCA - UGA, FINCA - ZMB, FinComún, FINCORP, FinDev, FINORTE,<br />
FINSOL, Emprenda, FISUR, FMCC, FMFB - Pakistan, FNT Credit, Forjadores de Negocios, Fortaleza<br />
FFP, Fundusz Mikro, Garant-Invest, Gasha, GAWFA, GCM, GF<strong>SP</strong>L, GOF, GRAINE sarl, Grupo Río<br />
La Venta, GV, Harbu, HDH OPDF, HKL, HOPE, Horizon, IFDP, ImerCredit, Imkoniyat, Imodi Hutal,<br />
IMON, Inicjatywa Mikro, Interfisa Financiera, Invest Credit, Invest-Credit Moldova, Invirtiendo,<br />
IPR, Jamii Bora, Joldosh Group, JOVID, JVS, KADET, KAMURJ, Kashf Bank, Kemek, KEP, Khushhali<br />
Bank, KixiCredito, KMF, Kompanion, KOPSA, KRK Ltd, KWFT, Lak Jaya, LAM, Lazika Capital, Letta,<br />
LIDER, LOK Microcredit Foundation, MADRAC, Maqsadi dasgiri, Maxima, MCL, MCN, MCO ‘Oral’,<br />
Meklit, MFI, MFW, MI-BO<strong>SP</strong>O, Micro Africa, MicroCred - MDG, MicroCred - MEX, MicroCred - SEN,<br />
Micredito SAC, Microfinanciera Prisma, Microinvest, Microserfin, MIKRA, Mikro ALDI, Mikrofond,<br />
MikroMaliyye Credit, Mimo Finance, MLF Chiluchor chashma, MLF Kiropol, MLF Madina, MLF<br />
MicroInvest, MLF Vahsh Microfin, MLO HUMO, MLO ‘Saodat Invest’, MoFAD, Mol Bulak Finance,<br />
Moldir, MUL, NMFB, Normicro, Nov Credit, OCSSCO, ODEF Financiera, Faulu - TZA, OI China, OISL,<br />
OMRO, Oportunidad Microfinanzas, Opportunity Albania, Opportunity Finance, Opportunity<br />
Kenya, OXUS - AFG, OXUS - KGS, OXUS - TJK, Partner, PEACE, PNG Microfinance Ltd, POMFB,<br />
Popular SAFI, PRASAC, PRIZMA, ProCredit - GHA, ProCredit - MDA, PRODEM FFP, Progresemos,<br />
Real Microcrédito, Red de Vanguardia, REDFunds, Reef, Reliance, Rishenglong, RML, WMN<br />
(Russia), Sabaragamuwa, Samasta, Sarvodaya Nano Finance, Sathapana Limited, SB Bank, SCNL,<br />
SDBL, SED, SEEDS, SEF-ARM, Seilanithih, SemiSol, SEWA Finance, SFF, SFPI, SHARE, SINERGIJA,<br />
SIPEM, SKS, SMEP, SOCIALCRED, PADECOMSM, SOCRED, SOFINA, SOGESOL, SolFi, Solución Asea,<br />
Soluciones Reales, Sonata, Spandana, Sugd Microfin, SUMI, Sunrise, SFPL, Tamweelcom, Tchuma,<br />
Te Creemos, TFS, TMFB, TPC, Trident Microfinance, Tujijenge, Turame Community Finance, TYM,<br />
Ujjivan, Umid-Credit, UNICREICH, UOB, USFSBS, USTOI, Finance Trust, VFC, VFM, VFS, Viator, Vivir<br />
Soluciones, VRFSBS, Wasasa, Nationwide Microbank, WDB, Wisdom, WISE, WWI - AFG<br />
56<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
BULLETIN TABLES<br />
Peer Group - 2008 DATA QUALITY †<br />
SIMPLE PEER GROUPS<br />
Charter Type: NGO<br />
(Non Government Organization)<br />
Charter Type: Rural Bank<br />
(Rural Bank)<br />
Financial Intermediation:<br />
Non FI<br />
(Voluntary Savings/Total Assets<br />
= 0)<br />
N * ** *** PARTICIPATING INSTITUTIONS<br />
389 114 246 29 A3C, ABA, ABCRDM, ABS-CBN, ABWA, Abyan, ACAD, ACEP Cameroon, ACME, ACORDE, Actuar<br />
Caldas, Actuar Tolima, Aden, Adhikar, ADICH, ADIM, ADRA - PER, ADRI, AFK, AFODENIC,<br />
Agência do Crédito, AGAPE, AgroCapital, Agrocredit Plus, AGUDESA, Al Amana, Al Karama,<br />
Al Majmoua, Al Tadamun, Alidé, ALSOL, Alternativa Microfinanzas, Al-Thiqa, AMA, AMEXTRA,<br />
AMFI, AMOS, AMSSF/MC, ANDE, ANED, APED, APROS, ARD, ARDCI, ARDI, ARMP, ASA, ASA - GHA,<br />
ASA Philippines, ASALA, Asasah, ASBA, ASDIR, ASEI, ASHI, ASIDME, ASKI, Asociación Arariwa,<br />
Asociación El Balsamo, Asociación Raíz, ASODENIC, ASOPROSANRAMON, A<strong>SP</strong>IRE, ATEMEXPA,<br />
Avanzar, AYNLA, Azal, Banco da Familia, Banco do Empreendedor, Banco do Povo ACP, Rede<br />
Novo Sol, Banco do Vale, BANCRI, BEES, Bereke, BESA, BIMAS, Binhminh CDC, BISWA, BJS, BRAC,<br />
BRAC - AFG, BRAC - LKA, BRAC - SS, BRAC - TZA, BRAC - UGA, BSS, BURO Bangladesh, BWDC,<br />
BZMF, CAME, CAPPED, CARD NGO, CARE - CREEME, Caritas, Caritas Esteli, Casa do Microcrédito,<br />
Cashpor MC, CBDIBA/RENACA, CCC, CDRO, CEADe, CEAPE BA, CEAPE MA, CEAPE PE, CEAPE<br />
PI, CEDEF, CEOSS, CEP, CEP BRVT, CEP Long An, CEPESIU, CEPRODEL, CESOL ACJ, CEVI, CFF,<br />
CFPA, Chamroeun, CHF Iraq, Childfund Hoa Binh, CHWDA, CIDRE, CMEDFI, COCDEP, Common<br />
Interest, Conserva, Contactar, CRAN, CRECER, CREDIMUJER, Credisol, CReSA, CRYSOL, CSD,<br />
CUMO, CVECA Kita/Bafoulabé, CVECA Pays Dogon, CVECA SOUM, CWCD, CZWSDA, DAMEN,<br />
DBACD, DEC, DEPROSC-Nepal, Diaconia, Dian Mandiri, DINARI, D-Miro, DQF, D<strong>SP</strong>I, ECLOF - ECU,<br />
ECLOF - PHL, EDAPRO<strong>SP</strong>O, Emprender, Enda, ESAF, ESED, Espacios Alternativos, Express Finance,<br />
FACES, FADEMYPE, FAFIDESS, FAPE, FBPMC, AfricaWorks, FDL, FDM, FED, FIACG, FIDERPAC,<br />
FIDEVIE, FINCA - DRC, FINCA - GTM, FINCA - HTI, FINCA - JOR, FINCA - KOS, FINCA - MEX, FINCA<br />
- MWI, FINCA - NIC, FINCA - PER, FINCA - SLV, FINCA - TZA, FMF, FMFI-SYR, FMM Bucaramanga,<br />
FMM Popayán, FMSD, FODEM, FODEMI, FOMIC, FONCRESOL, FONDECO, FONDEP, FONDESOL,<br />
FONDESURCO, Fondo Esperanza, Fonkoze, FORWARD, FOVIDA, FRAC, FUBODE, FUDEMI,<br />
FUNBODEM, Fund for Women Development - HCM, Fundación 4i-2000, Fundación Alternativa,<br />
Fundación Amanecer, Fundación CAMPO, Fundación Esperanza, Fundación Espoir, Fundación<br />
León 2000, Fundación MICROS, Fundación Mujer, Fundación Nieborowski, Fundación Paraguaya,<br />
FUNDAHMICRO, FUNDAMIC, FUNDEA, FUNDEBASE, FUNDECOCA, FUNDENUSE, FUNDEPYME,<br />
FUNDESER, FUNDE<strong>SP</strong>E, FUNED, FUNHAVI, FUNSALDE, FVP, Génesis Empresarial, GGEM<br />
Microfinance Services Ltd., Grameen Mendoza, GU, HEED, Hekima, HiH, Hluvuku, Hofokam, Hope<br />
for Life, Horizonti, H<strong>SP</strong>FI, ICC BluSol, ICC Conquista Solidária, ICC MAUCE, IDDA, IDEPRO, IDER<br />
CV, IDESI Lambayeque, IDE<strong>SP</strong>A, IDF, ID-Ghana, IDH, IDYDC, IMPRO, INMAA, INSOTEC, Instituto<br />
Estrela, Interactuar, Izdiharona Microfinance, Jabal Al Hoss, Janodaya, JCF, JXWDA, Kasagana-Ka,<br />
Kashf Foundation, Kazama Grameen, KCCDFI, KGMAMF, KMBI, KosInvest, KRUSHI, KSF, LAPO-NGR,<br />
Lead Foundation, Life Bank, M7 Can Loc, M7 DB District, M7 DBP City, M7 Dong Trieu, M7 Mai<br />
Son, M7 Ninh Phuoc, M7 Uong bi, Maata-N-Tudu, FAF-DC, Mahasemam, Mahashakti, Mahuli,<br />
Makhzoumi, Manuela Ramos, Manushi, Marang, MBK Ventura, MDF, MEDF, MED-Net, MEMCO,<br />
Micro Start, Microsol, MIDE, Miselini, MLF MWI, Moris Rasik, MUDE, NBJK, NCS, NEED, NeRuDO,<br />
Nidan, NMF, NRDSC, NSBA, NWTF, NYWDA, OLC, PADME, PAIDEK, PALFSI, PAPME, PARC, Parwaz,<br />
PASED, PATRA Hunchun, PATRA Yanbian, PAWDEP, PCWDA, Plan International, PRESTANIC, PRIDE<br />
- TZA, Pride Finance, PRISMA, ProCaja, PRODESA, Progresar, Pro Mujer - ARG, Pro Mujer - BOL,<br />
Pro Mujer - MEX, Pro Mujer - NIC, Pro Mujer - PER, RADE, RAFODE, RASS, RCDS, RGVN, ROMCOM,<br />
R<strong>SP</strong>I, Ryada, São Paulo Confia, Saadhana, SABR, Sajida, Sanghamithra, Sarala, Sartawi, SAT, SBACD,<br />
SCDA, SEAP, SEDA, SEF-ZAF, SEM Fund, Serviamus, SFSD, Shakti, SKDRDP, SMSS, Sodruzhestvo,<br />
Soro Yiriwaso, <strong>SP</strong>BD, SSS, SU, Sungi, Mentors - PER, SWAWS, TLM, TSKI, UCADE Ambato, UCADE<br />
Guaranda, UCADE Latacunga, UCADE Santo Domingo, Vital Finance, VSSU, WAGES, WKP, Women<br />
for Women, World Relief - HND, WSE, WWB Cali, XXWDA, YYWDA, Zakoura<br />
84 21 62 1 1st Valley Bank, Akuapem RB, Atwima Kwanwoma, Banco Santiago de Libon, Bangko Kabayan,<br />
Bangko Luzon, Bangko Mabuhay, BCB, Bessfa RB, BMT Pringsewu, Bonzali RB, BPR AN, BPR<br />
Aditama Arta, BPR AK, BPR Artadamas Mandiri, BPR BBTM, BPR BKK Cilacap, BPR CAS, BPR Citama,<br />
BPR DMG, BPR Eka Ayu, BPR Eka Usaha, BPR Hitamajaya, BPR NBP 11, BPR NBP 19, BPR NBP 2,<br />
BPR NBP 30, BPR NSI, BPR Pinang Artha, BPR PKT, BPR SAS, BPR Sukawati Pancakanti, BPR SKA,<br />
BPR Surya Yudha Kencana, BPR Taman Dhana, BPR Wahana Sentra Artha, Cantilan Bank, CARD<br />
Bank, CBB, CBMO, FAIR Bank, FICO, First Macro Bank, GBNB, GM Bank, Green Bank, Juaben RB,<br />
Kakum RB, KBSLAB, Mallig Plains RB, Mbinga CB, MGBB, MPGBB, New RB of Victorias, Nwabiagya<br />
RB, Otuasekan RB, PBC, PGBB, PR Bank, Progressive Bank, RB Bagac, RB Cainta, RB Camalig, RB<br />
Cotabato, RB Digos, RB Dipolog, RB Guinobatan, RB Lebak, RB Liloy, RB Mabitac, RB Montevista,<br />
RB Oroquieta, RB Pagbilao, RB Placer, RB San Jacinto, RB Siargao, RB Solano, RB Talisayan, Siam<br />
Bank, South Akim RB, <strong>SP</strong>GBB, Union RB, Upper Manya RB, Valiant RB<br />
398 120 243 35 1st MCC, 3A Entreprises, ABA, ACAD, ACF, ACME, ACORDE, Actuar Caldas, Actuar Tolima,<br />
Adhikar, ADIM, ADRA - PER, ADRI, Aetos, AFODENIC, AFS, Agência do Crédito, AGAPE,<br />
Aqrarkredit, AgroCapital, Agrocredit Plus, Agroimpuls, AgroInvest, AGUDESA, A-invest, Aiyl<br />
Bank, Al Awael, Al Karama, Al Majmoua, Al Tadamun, Alliance Group, Alternativa Microfinanzas,<br />
Al-Thiqa, AMA, AMC, AMC de R.L., Ameen, AMFI, AML, AMMACTS, AMOS, AMSSF/MC, ANDE,<br />
ANED, Apoyo Económico, Apoyo Integral, Aqroinvest, ARDI, AREGAK UCO, ARMP, Arohan, ASBA,<br />
ASEI, ASIDME, Asociación El Balsamo, Asociación Raíz, ASOPROSANRAMON, A<strong>SP</strong> Financiera,<br />
ASTI, Avanzar, AWS, AYNLA, Azercredit, Bancamía, Banco da Familia, Banco do Empreendedor,<br />
Banco do Povo ACP, Rede Novo Sol, Banco do Vale, BANCRI, Bereke-credit, Berendina<br />
Microfinance, BESA, BFL, BFSBS, BISWA, BJS, BSS, BWDC, CAFODEC, CAPA, CARE - CREEME,<br />
Caritas, Caritas Esteli, Casa do Microcrédito, Cashpor MC, CCC, CEADe, CEAPE BA, CEAPE MA,<br />
CEAPE PE, CEAPE PI, CEDEF, CEF, CEOSS, CEPESIU, CESOL ACJ, CFF, CHF Iraq, Chita FSBS, CHWDA,<br />
CIDRE, CMFinance, COCDEP, Columbia Microcreditos, Common Interest, CompartamosBanco,<br />
Contactar, CRECER, Credi Fé, CrediAmigo, Credi-Capital, CrediClub, CREDIMUJER, Credisol,<br />
Créditos Pronegocio, CREDITUYO, CReSA, Crezcamos, CRYSOL, CWCD, DAMEN, DAYAQ-<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
57
BULLETIN TABLES<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
Peer Group - 2008 DATA QUALITY †<br />
SIMPLE PEER GROUPS<br />
Financial Intermediation:<br />
Low FI<br />
(Voluntary Savings/Total Assets<br />
> 0 and < 20%)<br />
N * ** *** PARTICIPATING INSTITUTIONS<br />
Credit, DEF, Diaconia, Dirigible, DSK Dobrich, D-Miro, Don Apoyo, ECLOF - ECU, EDAPRO<strong>SP</strong>O,<br />
EDPYME Acceso Crediticio, EDPYME Alternativa, EDPYME Confianza, EDPYME Crear Arequipa,<br />
EDPYME Credivisión, EDPYME Efectiva, EDPYME Nueva Visión, EDPYME Pro Negocios, EDPYME<br />
Proempresa, EDPYME Raíz, Ehyoi kuhiston, Elet-Capital, Emprender, ENLACE, Equitas, ESAF,<br />
ESED, Express Finance, Fácil SCM, FACES, FADEMYPE, FAFIDESS, FAPE, Farm Credit Armenia,<br />
FDL, FED, FIACG, FIDERPAC, FIE Gran Poder, Financiera Fama, Financiera Independencia,<br />
FINCA - AFG, FINCA - ARM, FINCA - AZE, FINCA - GEO, FINCA - KOS, FINCA - MEX, FINCA - NIC,<br />
FINCA - PER, FINCA - Russia, FINCA - SLV, FINCA - TJK, FINCA - TZA, FINCORP, FinDev, FINORTE,<br />
Emprenda, FMCC, FMF, FMM Bucaramanga, FMM Popayán, FMSD, FNT Credit, FODEM, FODEMI,<br />
FOMIC, FONDEP, FONDESOL, FONDESURCO, Fondo Esperanza, Forjadores de Negocios,<br />
FOVIDA, FRAC, FUBODE, FUDEMI, FUNBODEM, Fundación 4i-2000, Fundación Alternativa,<br />
Fundación Amanecer, Fundación CAMPO, Fundación Esperanza, Fundación Espoir, Fundación<br />
León 2000, Fundación MICROS, Fundación Mujer, Fundación Nieborowski, Fundación<br />
Paraguaya, FUNDAHMICRO, FUNDAMIC, FUNDEBASE, FUNDECOCA, FUNDENUSE, FUNDEPYME,<br />
FUNDESER, FUNDE<strong>SP</strong>E, FUNHAVI, FUNSALDE, FVP, Génesis Empresarial, GCM, General Toshevo,<br />
GGEM Microfinance Services Ltd., GF<strong>SP</strong>L, GOF, Grameen Mendoza, GV, HiH, HOPE, Hope for<br />
Life, ICC BluSol, ICC MAUCE, IDEPRO, IDER CV, IDESI Lambayeque, IDE<strong>SP</strong>A, IDH, ImerCredit,<br />
Imkoniyat, Imodi Hutal, IMPRO, Inicjatywa Mikro, INSOTEC, Instituto Estrela, Interactuar, Invest<br />
Credit, IPR, Izdiharona Microfinance, Janodaya, Joldosh Group, JXWDA, Kashf Bank,<br />
Kajnardza 96, Kemek, Komak Credit, Kompanion, KOPSA, KosInvest, KRK Ltd, LAM, LIDER, FAF-<br />
DC, Makhzoumi, Manuela Ramos, Marang, Maxima, MCN, MCO ‘Oral’, MDF, MEDF, MEMCO, MFI,<br />
Micro Africa, MicroCred - MDG, MicroCred - MEX, Micredito SAC, Coop MEDA, Microfinanciera<br />
Prisma, Microserfin, Microsol, MIDE, MIKRA, Mikro ALDI, MikroMaliyye Credit, Mimo Finance,<br />
Miziya, MLF Chiluchor chashma, MLF Kiropol, MLF Madina, MLF MicroInvest, MLF MWI,<br />
MLF Vahsh Microfin, MLO ‘Saodat Invest’, MMS, Moldir, Momina Voda, MUDE, MUL, Nachala,<br />
Nadejda 96, NBJK, NCS, Nidan, Normicro, Nov Credit, NSBA, OLC, Oportunidad Microfinanzas,<br />
Opportunity Albania, Opportunity Finance, OXUS - AFG, OXUS - KGS, PAIDEK, PASED, PATRA<br />
Hunchun, Perelik, Pomoriiski stopanin, Popular SAFI, PRESTANIC, PRISMA, PRODESA, Progresar,<br />
Progresemos, Pro Mujer - ARG, Pro Mujer - BOL, Pro Mujer - MEX, Pro Mujer - NIC, Pro Mujer<br />
- PER, RASS, RB Placer, Real Microcrédito, Red de Vanguardia, REDFunds, Rishenglong, RML,<br />
WMN (Russia), São Paulo Confia, Saadhana, Saglasie 96, Samokov 96, Sanghamithra, Sartawi,<br />
Sarvodaya Nano Finance, SCDA, SCNL, SED, SEF-ARM, SEF-ZAF, SEM Fund, SemiSol, SHARE,<br />
SINERGIJA, SIPEM, SKDRDP, SKS, SMILE, Smilyan, SMSS, SOCIALCRED, PADECOMSM, SOCRED,<br />
Sodruzhestvo, SOGESOL, Soglasiye, Solidarnost, Soluciones Reales, Sonata, Spandana, SSK,<br />
Stopanin, Sugd Microfin, Sungi, Mentors - PER, SFPL, SWAWS, TFS, TLM, Tsimlyansk, UCADE<br />
Ambato, UCADE Guaranda, UCADE Latacunga, UCADE Santo Domingo, Umid-Credit, UNRWA,<br />
USFSBS, USTOI, VFM, VFS, Viator, Vital Finance, Vivir Soluciones, VRFSBS, Women for Women,<br />
WWB Cali, WWI - AFG, XXWDA, YYWDA, Zakoura<br />
159 54 95 10 ABWA, Abyan, AccessBank, ACEP Cameroon, ACEP Senegal, Aden, ADICH, ADOPEM, ALSOL,<br />
Alternativa 19 del Sur, AMfB, AMK, AMRET, APROS, ASA - GHA, ASALA, Asasah, ASHI, Asociación<br />
Arariwa, ASODENIC, A<strong>SP</strong>IRE, ATEMEXPA, Azal, Bandhan, BASIX, BG, BOM, BRAC - AFG, BRAC - LKA,<br />
BRAC - SS, BRAC - TZA, BRAC - UGA, BRCCC, CAFASA, CCAMETRO, CBIRD, CDRO, CEPRODEL,<br />
CETZAM, CEVI, CFA, CFPA, CHC-Limited, Conserva, Coop 20 de Abril, COOPAC Norandino,<br />
COOPEC Hinfani Dosso, CRAN, Crece Safsa, CrediAvance, CrediComún, CREDIT, CUMO, CZWSDA,<br />
DD Bank, DEPROSC-Nepal, Despacho Amador, DINARI, Doveriye- Bulgaria, ECLOF - PHL, Eshet,<br />
Crezkamos Kapital, FAMA OPDF, FATEN, Faulu - UGA, FIDEVIE, FinAmigo, Financiera Edyficar,<br />
FINCA - ECU, FINCA - GTM, FINCA - HND, FINCA - HTI, FINCA - MWI, FINCA - ZMB, FISUR, FMFI-SYR,<br />
FONCRESOL, FONDECO, FORUS, FUNDEA, FUNED, Galaktika, GRAINE sarl, Grupo Río La Venta,<br />
HDH OPDF, HKL, Hluvuku, Hofokam, Horizonti, H<strong>SP</strong>FI, IDDA, Indur MACS, Invirtiendo, Jabal Al<br />
Hoss, JSC Bank Constanta, Kashf Foundation, KGMAMF, Khushhali Bank, KixiCredito, Kokari,<br />
KRUSHI, KSF, Letta, Maata-N-Tudu, Madfa SACCO, MADRAC, Maritsa Invest, MBK Ventura, MCL,<br />
MED-Net, MGBB, MoFAD, Moznosti, MUSCCO, NEED, NeRuDO, NMF, NWTF, ODEF Financiera, Faulu<br />
- TZA, PADME, PAPME, Parwaz, PATRA Yanbian, PGBB, POMFB, PRASAC, Pride Finance, ProCaja,<br />
ProCredit - COL, PWMACS, RADE, Reef, RGVN, Sarala, SAT, Sathapana Limited, Seilanithih, SEWA<br />
Finance, SFSD, SolFi, Solución Asea, Soro Yiriwaso, <strong>SP</strong>BD, <strong>SP</strong>GBB, SU, Tamweelcom, Tchuma, Te<br />
Creemos, TPC, Trident Microfinance, TSKI, Turame Community Finance, TYM, Ujjivan, VFC, WISE,<br />
WOCCU - AFG, World Relief - HND<br />
Financial Intermediation:<br />
High FI<br />
(Voluntary Savings/Total Assets<br />
≥ 20%)<br />
393 120 229 44 1st Valley Bank, A3C, ABCRDM, ABS-CBN, ACB sa, ACBA, ACCOVI, ACFB, ACLEDA, ACSI,<br />
Agroinvestbank, Akiba, Akuapem RB, Al Rafah Bank, Alidé, Alliance MFB, Alternativa, Alteya,<br />
AMEXTRA, APED, ARD, ASA, ASA Philippines, ASC Union, ASDIR, ASKI, ASR, ASUSU CIIGABA,<br />
Atwima Kwanwoma, Avantaj, Azerdemiryolbank, Banco ADEMI, Banco Amigo, Banco Familiar,<br />
Banco Popular do Brasil, Banco Santiago de Libon, Banco Solidario, BancoEstado, BancoSol,<br />
BanCovelo, BANEX, BanGente, Bangko Kabayan, Bangko Mabuhay, Bank Eskhata, Bank of<br />
Baku, BCB, BCSC, BEES, Bessfa RB, BIMAS, Binhminh CDC, Blago, BMT Kayu Manis, BPR AN, BPR<br />
AK, BPR Artadamas Mandiri, BPR BBTM, BPR BKK Cilacap, BPR CAS, BPR Citama, BPR DMG, BPR<br />
Hitamajaya, BPR NBP 11, BPR NBP 19, BPR NBP 2, BPR NSI, BPR Pinang Artha, BPR SAS, BPR<br />
Sukawati Pancakanti, BPR Surya Yudha Kencana, BPR Taman Dhana, BPR Wahana Sentra Artha,<br />
BRAC, BTA Bank, BURO Bangladesh, CACMU, Caja Depac Poblana, Caja Popular Mexicana,<br />
CamCCUL, CAME, Cantilan Bank, Capitec Bank, CAPPED, CARD Bank, CARD NGO, CAURIE<br />
Micro Finance, CBDIBA/RENACA, CBMO, CCA, CDM, CDS, CECA, CECIC S.A., CEC-PROM Mature,<br />
Centenary Bank, Central Cresol Baser, CEP, Chamroeun, CMAC Arequipa, CMAC Cusco,<br />
58<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
BULLETIN TABLES<br />
Peer Group - 2008 DATA QUALITY †<br />
SIMPLE PEER GROUPS<br />
N * ** *** PARTICIPATING INSTITUTIONS<br />
CMAC Del Santa, CMAC Huancayo, CMAC Ica, CMAC Maynas, CMAC Paita, CMAC Pisco, CMAC<br />
Piura, CMAC Sullana, CMAC Tacna, CMAC Trujillo, CMCA, CMEDFI, CMMB, CMS, COAC 4 de<br />
Octubre, COAC Acción Rural, COAC Ambato, COAC Artesanos, COAC Chone, COAC Fernando<br />
Daquilema, COAC Fondvida, COAC Huaycopungo, COAC Jardín Azuayo, COAC Kullki Wasi,<br />
COAC La Benéfica, COAC Luz del Valle, COAC MCCH, COAC Minga, COAC Mushuc Runa, COAC<br />
La Nacional, COAC Padre Vicente, COAC Pallatanga, COAC Sac Aiet, COAC San Antonio, COAC<br />
San Gabriel, COAC San José, COAC Santa Ana, COAC Santa Anita, CODESARROLLO, Comultrasan,<br />
Coop Avances, Coop Fátima, Coop Jesús Nazareno, Coop Juan XXIII, COOPAC Chiquinquira,<br />
COOPAC León XIII, COOPAC Los Andes, COOPAC San Cristóbal, COOPAC San Martín, COOPAC<br />
Santa Maria, COOPAC Santo Cristo, COOPAC Santo Domingo, COOPAC Tocache, COOPEC/ACCO,<br />
COOPEDU-Kigali, COOPROGRESO, CO<strong>SP</strong>EC, CPECG Yete Mali, CRAC Los Andes, CRAC Nuestra<br />
Gente, CRAC Profinanzas, CRAC Señor de Luren, CRAC Sipán, Credicoop, Crediscotia, Cresol<br />
Central, CRG, CSD, CU Sawiran, CVECA Kita/Bafoulabé, CVECA Pays Dogon, CVECA SOUM, DEC,<br />
DECSI, DJOMEC, Doveriye - Volgograd, Doveriye (Amursk), Doveriye-Altay, D<strong>SP</strong>I, Duterimbere,<br />
EcoFuturo FFP, Edinstvo Yurga, Edinstvo-Volgograd, EKPA, Equity Bank, Espacios Alternativos,<br />
FAIR Bank, FAM, FASL, Fassil FFP, Faulu - KEN, FDM, FECECAM, FFECC, FICO, FIE FFP, FIELCO,<br />
FinAmérica, FINCA - DRC, FINCA - UGA, FinComún, FINSOL, First Macro Bank, FMFB - AFG,<br />
FMFB - Pakistan, FMFB - TJK, Fonkoze, Fortaleza FFP, FORWARD, FUCEC Togo, FULM, Gasha,<br />
GAWFA, GBNB, GM Bank, Gorodskoy, Grameen Bank, Green Bank, GU, Harbu, HEED, Hekima,<br />
IDF, ID-Ghana, IMFB, Impuls, INECO, Intellekt, Interfisa Financiera, Jigiyaso Ba, JSCCS, Juaben<br />
RB, JVS, KADET, Kafo Jiginew, Kakum RB, Kasagana-Ka, Kazama Grameen, KBank, KBSLAB,<br />
KCCDFI, Khan Bank, KMB, KMBI, Kondo Jigima, KPOSB, Kredo, K-Rep, KVK, KVK-Altay, KWFT, La<br />
Community Bank, LAPO-NGR, LAPO-SLE, Life Bank, LSK, Mahasemam, Mahila, Mahuli, Mallig<br />
Plains RB, Manushi, Mbinga CB, MC², MEC AFER, MEC FEPRODES, MECBAS, MECREF, MGPCC<br />
DEKAWOWO, MiBanco, MiBanco Venezuela, Micro Start, MicroCred - SEN, Mikrokredit Bank,<br />
Miselini, Moris Rasik, Mutuelle Akwaba, Nadejda, Narodniy Kredit_Kemerov, Neftegaz, NESDO,<br />
New RB of Victorias, Nirdhan, NMFB, NovoBanco - MOZ, Nwabiagya RB, Nyesigiso, Obereg<br />
(Vladivostok), OBM, OBS, OIBM, OISL, OMB, Opportunity Kenya, Otiv Alaotra, Otiv Diana, Otiv<br />
Sambava, Otiv Tana, Otuasekan RB, PALFSI, PAMECAS, Parabank, PARC, Partner Russia, PASECA<br />
- Kayes, PBC, PEACE, PNG Microfinance Ltd, Popular Kasa-Kystendil, Povoljye, PRIDE - TZA,<br />
ProCredit - BOL, ProCredit - ECU, ProCredit - GHA, ProCredit - HND, ProCredit - NIC, ProCredit<br />
- SLV, ProCredit Bank - ALB, ProCredit Bank - BGR, ProCredit Bank - BIH, ProCredit Bank - GEO,<br />
ProCredit Bank - KOS, ProCredit Bank - MDA, ProCredit Bank - MKD, ProCredit Bank - ROM,<br />
ProCredit Bank - SLE, ProCredit Bank - UKR, ProCredit Bank- DRC, ProCredit Bank Serbia,<br />
PRODEM FFP, Progressive Bank, Pushtikar, Raduga, RAFODE, RB Bagac, RB Cainta, RB Camalig,<br />
RB Digos, RB Dipolog, RB Lebak, RB Liloy, RB Mabitac, RB Montevista, RB Oroquieta, RB Pagbilao,<br />
RB Talisayan, RCCECG, RCPB, Reliance, Reserv-Altay, Rezerv, Rost, R<strong>SP</strong>I, Sajida, SB Bank, SBS, SEAP,<br />
SEDA, SEEDS, Serviamus, SFF, SFPI, Shakti, SMEP, Sodeystviye, Sodeystviye-2005, SOFINA, South<br />
Akim RB, Soyuz-Khimik, SoyuzKredit, Soyuz-Primoroye, Stanichnik, TIAVO, TMFB, Tsaritsinskiy<br />
passaj, Tverskoy, UCEC/MK, U-IMCEC, UMECDES, Umid, UNACOOPEC-CI, UNICREICH, Union RB,<br />
UOB, Upper Manya RB, Finance Trust, Valiant RB, Visión Banco, Vostok Kapital, WAGES, Wasasa,<br />
Wisdom, XacBank<br />
Methodology: Individual 281 88 161 32 1st Valley Bank, Abzal Kredit, ACAD, AccessBank, ACCOVI, ACLEDA Lao, ACME, Actuar Caldas,<br />
ADRI, AFK, AFODENIC, AgroInvest, Agroinvestbank, Alliance Group, Alternativa, Alteya,<br />
Alwatani, AMA, AMC, AMC de R.L., Ameen, AMfB, Aqroinvest, ASA - GHA, ASA Philippines,<br />
ASC Union, ASDIR, ASOPROSANRAMON, A<strong>SP</strong>IRE, ASR, Avanzar, Azerdemiryolbank, Bancamía,<br />
Banco ADEMI, Banco da Familia, Banco do Empreendedor, Rede Novo Sol, Banco do Vale,<br />
Banco Familiar, Banco Solidario, BancoEstado, BANCRI, BANEX, Bank Eskhata, BCB, Berendina<br />
Microfinance, BESA, BJS, Blago, BMT Kayu Manis, BMT Pringsewu, BPR AN, BPR Aditama Arta,<br />
BPR Artadamas Mandiri, BPR BBTM, BPR DMG, BPR Eka Ayu, BPR Eka Usaha, BPR Hitamajaya,<br />
BPR NSI, BPR SKA, BPR Surya Yudha Kencana, BPR Taman Dhana, BRCCC, BTA Bank, BZMF,<br />
Caja Depac Poblana, CAPA, Capitec Bank, CARD Bank, CARD NGO, Casa do Microcrédito,<br />
CBDIBA/RENACA, CCC, CECA, CEF, Centenary Bank, CEP, CEPRODEL, Chamroeun, CHF Iraq,<br />
Chita FSBS, CMAC Arequipa, CMAC Del Santa, CMAC Ica, CMAC Pisco, CMCA, CMEDFI,<br />
CMFinance, COAC Ambato, COAC Chone, COAC Fernando Daquilema, COAC Fondvida,<br />
COAC Kullki Wasi, COAC La Benéfica, COAC Luz del Valle, COAC MCCH, COAC Minga, COAC<br />
Mushuc Runa, COAC La Nacional, COAC Pallatanga, COAC San Antonio, COAC San José, COAC<br />
Santa Ana, Columbia Microcreditos, Coop Avances, Coop Juan XXIII, COOPAC Chiquinquira,<br />
COOPAC Los Andes, COOPAC Norandino, COOPAC Santo Cristo, COOPAC Santo Domingo,<br />
CRAC Profinanzas, CRAC Señor de Luren, CRAC Sipán, CredAgro NBCO, Credi Fé, Credicoop,<br />
CREDIMUJER, Credisol, CREDO, Cresol Central, Crezcamos, CU Pantai Prigi, CU Sawiran, DEF,<br />
Doveriye - Volgograd, Doveriye (Amursk), Doveriye-Altay, Edinstvo Yurga, Edinstvo-Volgograd,<br />
EDPYME Acceso Crediticio, EDPYME Crear Arequipa, EDPYME Nueva Visión, EDPYME Pro<br />
Negocios, EDPYME Proempresa, EDPYME Raíz, Ehyoi kuhiston, EKI, Express Finance, Fácil<br />
SCM, Farm Credit Armenia, Fassil FFP, FICO, FIDERPAC, FIE Gran Poder, FinAgro, FinAmérica,<br />
FMF, FMM Bucaramanga, FOMIC, FONDESURCO, Fortaleza FFP, FORUS, FULM, FUNBODEM,<br />
Fundación CAMPO, Fundación Nieborowski, FUNDEBASE, FUNDECOCA, Fundusz Mikro,<br />
Galaktika, Gorodskoy, GV, Hluvuku, HOPE, Horizon, ICC MAUCE, IDER CV, ImerCredit, Impuls,<br />
INECO, Inicjatywa Mikro, INSOTEC, Interactuar, Interfisa Financiera, Jabal Al Hoss, Juaben<br />
RB, Kafo Jiginew, Kashf Foundation, Kashf Bank, Khan Bank, Komak Credit, KosInvest, Kredo,<br />
KSK RPK, KVK, KVK-Altay, La Community Bank, Lak Jaya, LAM, Life Bank, FAF-DC, Makhzoumi,<br />
MCN, MDF, MiBanco Venezuela, MicroCred - MEX, Coop MEDA, Microserfin, Microsol, Mikro<br />
ALDI, Mikrofond, Mikrokredit Bank, MLF Vahsh Microfin, MUL, Nachala, Nadejda, Narodniy<br />
Kredit_Kemerov, Neftegaz, New RB of Victorias, OBM, OBS, OMRO, Opportunity Albania,<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
59
BULLETIN TABLES<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
Peer Group - 2008 DATA QUALITY †<br />
SIMPLE PEER GROUPS<br />
Methodology: Individual/<br />
Solidarity<br />
(Individual & Solidarity; or<br />
Individual, Solidarity & Village<br />
Banking)<br />
N * ** *** PARTICIPATING INSTITUTIONS<br />
Opportunity Finance, PARC, Partner, Partner Russia, PATRA Hunchun, Popular Kasa-Kystendil,<br />
Popular SAFI, PRESTANIC, ProCaja, ProCredit - ECU, ProCredit - GHA, ProCredit - HND, ProCredit<br />
Bank - ALB, ProCredit Bank - BGR, ProCredit Bank - BIH, ProCredit Bank - GEO, ProCredit Bank -<br />
KOS, ProCredit Bank - MKD, ProCredit Bank - ROM, ProCredit Bank - UKR, ProCredit Bank Serbia,<br />
PRODESA, Pushtikar, PWMACS, Raduga, RB Bagac, RB Cainta, RB Camalig, RB Digos, RB Dipolog,<br />
RB Lebak, RB Pagbilao, Reliance, Reserv-Altay, Rezerv, ROMCOM, Rost, Rus, WMN (Russia),<br />
Ryada, SBS, SCDA, Siam Bank, SINERGIJA, SOCIALCRED, PADECOMSM, SOCRED, Sodeystviye,<br />
Sodeystviye-2005, Sodruzhestvo, SOGESOL, Soglasiye, Soyuz-Khimik, SoyuzKredit, Soyuz-<br />
Primoroye, Stanichnik, TFS, TMFB, Tsaritsinskiy passaj, Tverskoy, Umid, VB<strong>SP</strong>, Vostok K apital,<br />
VRFSBS, WWB Cali, Zakoura<br />
272 62 186 24 ACEP Senegal, ACF, ACLEDA, ACSI, ADCSI, Aden, ADICH, ADOPEM, Agência do Crédito, AGAPE,<br />
Aqrarkredit, AGUDESA, A-invest, Aiyl Bank, Al Awael, Al Majmoua, Alidé, Alliance MFB, AMFI,<br />
AMK, AML, AMOS, AMRET, ANDE, ANED, Apoyo Integral, ASKI, Asociación El Balsamo, Asociación<br />
Raíz, ASODENIC, ASTI, AYNLA, Azal, Azercredit, Azeri Star, Bai Tushum, Banco Santiago de Libon,<br />
BanCovelo, BanGente, Bangko Kabayan, Bangko Mabuhay, BASIX, Bereke, BOM, BPR CAS, BPR<br />
NBP 11, BPR NBP 19, BPR NBP 2, BPR NBP 30, BPR SAS, BPR Wahana Sentra Artha, BRAC, BRAC<br />
- AFG, BRAC - UGA, BSS, CACMU, CAFODEC, Caja Popular Mexicana, CamCCUL, Cantilan Bank,<br />
CAPPED, CARE - CREEME, Caritas, Caritas Esteli, CCA, CDRO, CEADe, CEAPE BA, CEAPE MA, CEAPE<br />
PE, CEAPE PI, CEDEF, CEOSS, CEPESIU, CESOL ACJ, CETZAM, CHC-Limited, CIDRE, CMAC Sullana,<br />
COAC 4 de Octubre, COAC Acción Rural, COAC Artesanos, COAC Huaycopungo, COAC Padre<br />
Vicente, COAC Sac Aiet, COAC San Gabriel, COAC Santa Anita, CODESARROLLO, Contactar,<br />
COOPEC/ACCO, CRAN, CrediAmigo, CREDIT, Crystal, CVECA Kita/Bafoulabé, CWCD, DBACD,<br />
DECSI, Dian Mandiri, DINARI, D-Miro, D<strong>SP</strong>I, ECLOF - ARM, EDAPRO<strong>SP</strong>O, EDPYME Credivisión,<br />
Elet-Capital, Emprender, Enda, Equity Bank, ESAF, ESED, FADEMYPE, FAFIDESS, FAIR Bank, FAM,<br />
FAMA OPDF, FAPE, FASL, FATEN, AfricaWorks, FDL, FIDEVIE, Financiera Edyficar, Financiera Fama,<br />
FINCA - ARM, FINCA - JOR, FINCA - PER, FINCA - Russia, FINCORP, FinDev, FINSOL, First Macro<br />
Bank, FMFB - TJK, FODEM, FODEMI, FONCRESOL, FONDEP, FUBODE, FUCEC Togo, FUDEMI,<br />
Fundación 4i-2000, Fundación Alternativa, Fundación Esperanza, Fundación MICROS, Fundación<br />
Paraguaya, FUNDAHMICRO, FUNDAMIC, FUNDEA, FUNDEPYME, FUNDE<strong>SP</strong>E, FUNSALDE, Génesis<br />
Empresarial, GM Bank, Grameen Mendoza, Grameen Sahara, Green Bank, Harbu, HDH OPDF, HKL,<br />
Hofokam, Horizonti, H<strong>SP</strong>FI, ICC BluSol, ICC Conquista Solidária, IDE<strong>SP</strong>A, IDF, ID-Ghana, IDH, IMFB,<br />
Imkoniyat, Imodi Hutal, INMAA, Instituto Estrela, IPR, Izdiharona Microfinance, KBank, KBSLAB,<br />
KEP, KixiCredito, KMF, Kompanion, K-Rep, KSF, KWFT, LAPO-NGR, Lazika Capital, Lead Foundation,<br />
LIDER, LSK, MADRAC, Mallig Plains RB, Marang, MED-Net, Meklit, MiBanco, Microfinanciera Prisma,<br />
MIDE, Miselini, MLF MicroInvest, MLO HUMO, Mol Bulak Finance, Moris Rasik, MUDE, MUSCCO,<br />
Mutuelle Akwaba, NMF, NMFB, Normicro, Nwabiagya RB, Nyesigiso, ODEF Financiera, OIBM, OISL,<br />
OLC, OMB, Opportunity Kenya, OXUS - AFG, OXUS - KGS, OXUS - TJK, Parabank, Parwaz, PASED,<br />
PAWDEP, PRASAC, PRIDE - TZA, Pride Finance, PRODEM FFP, Progressive Bank, Pro Mujer - NIC,<br />
RADE, RB Liloy, RB Mabitac, RB Oroquieta, RB Placer, RB Siargao, RCCECG, RCPB, Real Microcrédito,<br />
Reef, R<strong>SP</strong>I, Sajida, Sathapana Limited, SB Bank, SBACD, SCNL, SEAP, SEDA, Seilanithih, SFF, SFSD,<br />
Mentors - PER, SFPL, SWAWS, TLM, TPC, TSKI, Tujijenge, TYM, UCADE Guaranda, UCADE Latacunga,<br />
UCCEC GY, UCEC/MK, UNICREICH, UNION DES COOPECs UMUTANGUHA, USTOI, Finance Trust,<br />
VFC, VFM, Viator, WAGES, Wisdom, World Relief - HND<br />
Methodology: Solidarity 67 20 45 2 ABS-CBN, ABWA, Abyan, Adhikar, ARDCI, Arohan, Asasah, AWS, BEES, Bessfa RB, BG, BIMAS,<br />
Bonzali RB, BRAC - LKA, CBB, CEP BRVT, CEVI, CFA, CFF, Childfund Hoa Binh, CrediComún, CSD,<br />
DQF, Equitas, Eshet, Fonkoze, FORWARD, IDDA, IDYDC, Jamii Bora, JVS, Kakum RB, KAMURJ,<br />
KGMAMF, KMBI, KRK Ltd, M7 Can Loc, M7 DB District, M7 Dong Trieu, M7 Mai Son, M7 Ninh<br />
Phuoc, Maata-N-Tudu, Madfa SACCO, Mahuli, Manushi, MLF Chiluchor chashma, MLF MWI, MMS,<br />
NCS, NESDO, NRDSC, Faulu - TZA, PALFSI, PBC, Plan International, Povoljye, RASS, RB Montevista,<br />
RB Talisayan, São Paulo Confia, SABR, SEF-ZAF, Serviamus, <strong>SP</strong>BD, SSS, Union RB, VFS<br />
Methodology: Village Banking 59 11 43 5 ADRA - PER, AgroCapital, Alternativa Microfinanzas, AMMACTS, ASA, ASEI, ASIDME, Asociación<br />
Arariwa, Atwima Kwanwoma, BISWA, BWDC, COOPROGRESO, CReSA, CUMO, Diaconia, EDPYME<br />
Confianza, FED, FIACG, FINCA - AZE, FINCA - ECU, FINCA - HTI, FINCA - KOS, FINCA - MWI, FINCA<br />
- TJK, FINCA - TZA, FINCA - UGA, FINCA - ZMB, FMCC, FONDECO, Fondo Esperanza, Fundación<br />
Espoir, Fundación Mujer, GRAINE sarl, GU, Hekima, Indur MACS, Janodaya, KOPSA, KRUSHI,<br />
Manuela Ramos, MEDF, MFI, Mimo Finance, NBJK, Nidan, Pro Mujer - ARG, Pro Mujer - BOL,<br />
RAFODE, REDFunds, RGVN, Saadhana, Sarvodaya Nano Finance, SEEDS, SKDRDP, SMSS, South<br />
Akim RB, SSK, UCADE Ambato, Upper Manya RB<br />
Outreach: Small<br />
(Number of Borrowers<br />
< 10,000)<br />
553 238 289 26 1st MCC, 3A Entreprises, A3C, Abyan, Abzal Kredit, ACAD, ACB sa, ACCOVI, ACEP Cameroon, ACF,<br />
ACORDE, Actuar Caldas, Actuar Tolima, Aden, ADICH, ADIM, ADRI, Aetos, AFK, AFODENIC, Agência<br />
do Crédito, AGAPE, Aqrarkredit, Agrocredit Plus, Agroimpuls, AGUDESA, A-invest, Akuapem<br />
RB, Al Awael, Al Rafah Bank, Alidé, Alliance Group, Alliance MFB, Alternativa, Alternativa 19<br />
del Sur, Alternativa Microfinanzas, Alteya, Al-Thiqa, AMA, AMC, AMEXTRA, AMfB, AMFI, Amlok,<br />
AMOS, ANED, Aqroinvest, Arnur Credit, ASALA, ASDIR, ASEI, ASIDME, Asociación El Balsamo,<br />
ASOPROSANRAMON, ASR, ASTI, ATEMEXPA, Avantaj, Avanzar, Azal, Azeri Star, Banco da Familia,<br />
Banco do Empreendedor, Rede Novo Sol, Banco do Vale, BANCRI, Bangko Kabayan, Bangko<br />
Luzon, Bangko Mabuhay, BAYOCA, BCB, Bereke, Bereke-credit, BFSBS, BIMAS, Binhminh CDC,<br />
BJS, Blago, BMSCCSL, BMT Pringsewu, BOM, Borshud, BPR AN, BPR Aditama Arta, BPR AK, BPR<br />
Artadamas Mandiri, BPR BBTM, BPR CAS, BPR DMG, BPR Eka Ayu, BPR Eka Usaha, BPR Hitamajaya,<br />
BPR NBP 19, BPR NBP 2, BPR NBP 30, BPR NSI, BPR Pinang Artha, BPR PKT, BPR SAS, BPR Sukawati<br />
Pancakanti, BPR SKA, BPR Taman Dhana, BPR Wahana Sentra Artha, BRCCC, BZMF, CACMU,<br />
CAFASA, Caja Depac Poblana, CAPA, CAPPED, CARE - CREEME, Caritas Esteli,<br />
60<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
BULLETIN TABLES<br />
Peer Group - 2008 DATA QUALITY †<br />
SIMPLE PEER GROUPS<br />
Outreach: Medium<br />
(Number of Borrowers ≥ 10,000<br />
and ≤ 30,000)<br />
N * ** *** PARTICIPATING INSTITUTIONS<br />
Casa do Microcrédito, CBIRD, CBMO, CCC, CDM, CDRO, CEADe, CEAPE BA, CEAPE PE, CEAPE<br />
PI, CECA, CECIC S.A., CEC-PROM Mature, CEDEF, CEF, CEP BRVT, CEP Long An, CEPESIU, CESOL<br />
ACJ, CETZAM, CFE, CFF, Chamroeun, Chandeshwori, Childfund Hoa Binh, Chita FSBS, CHWDA,<br />
CIDRE, CMAC Pisco, CMCA, CMEDFI, CMMB, COAC 4 de Octubre, COAC Acción Rural, COAC<br />
Ambato, COAC Artesanos, COAC Chone, COAC Fernando Daquilema, COAC Fondvida, COAC<br />
Huaycopungo, COAC Kullki Wasi, COAC La Benéfica, COAC Luz del Valle, COAC MCCH, COAC<br />
Minga, COAC Padre Vicente, COAC Pallatanga, COAC Sac Aiet, COAC San Antonio, COAC San<br />
Gabriel, COAC San José, COAC Santa Ana, COAC Santa Anita, Columbia Microcreditos, Common<br />
Interest, Coop Avances, Coop Fátima, Coop Juan XXIII, COOPAC Chiquinquira, COOPAC Los<br />
Andes, COOPAC Norandino, COOPAC Santo Domingo, COOPAC Tocache, COOPEC Hinfani Dosso,<br />
COOPEC/ACCO, COOPEDU-Kigali, CO<strong>SP</strong>EC, CPECG Yete Mali, CRAC Sipán, CRAN, CrediAvance,<br />
Credicoop, CREDIMUJER, Credisol, Credit Mongol, CREDITUYO, Crezcamos, CRG, Crystal, CU<br />
Kosayu, CU Pantai Prigi, CU Sawiran, CVECA Kita/Bafoulabé, CVECA Pays Dogon, CVECA SOUM,<br />
CWCD, CZWSDA, DAYAQ-Credit, Degaf, Despacho Amador, DINARI, Dirigible, DJOMEC, DSK<br />
Dobrich, Doveriye - Volgograd, Doveriye (Amursk), Doveriye- Bulgaria, Doveriye-Altay, DQF,<br />
ECLOF - ARM, ECLOF - ECU, ECLOF - PHL, EDAPRO<strong>SP</strong>O, Edinstvo Yurga, Edinstvo-Volgograd,<br />
EDPYME Acceso Crediticio, EDPYME Pro Negocios, Ehyoi kuhiston, Elet-Capital, Emprender,<br />
Espacios Alternativos, Crezkamos Kapital, Express Finance, Fácil SCM, FACES, FADEMYPE, FAM,<br />
FAPE, Farm Credit Armenia, FATEN, AfricaWorks, FDM, FFECC, FIACG, FIDERPAC, FIDEVIE, FIE Gran<br />
Poder, FinAgro, FINCA - JOR, FINCORP, FinDev, FINORTE, First Macro Bank, Emprenda, FISUR,<br />
FNT Credit, FODEM, FOMIC, FONCRESOL, FONDESURCO, Fortaleza FFP, FOVIDA, FUDEMI, FULM,<br />
FUNBODEM, Fund for Women Development - HCM, Fundación 4i-2000, Fundación Alternativa,<br />
Fundación Amanecer, Fundación CAMPO, Fundación MICROS, Fundación Mujer, FUNDAMIC,<br />
FUNDEBASE, FUNDECOCA, FUNDEPYME, FUNDE<strong>SP</strong>E, FUNHAVI, FUNSALDE, FVP, Galaktika,<br />
Garant-Invest, Gasha, General Toshevo, GGEM Microfinance Services Ltd., Gorodskoy, Grameen<br />
Mendoza, Grameen Sahara, Grupo Río La Venta, Hekima, HDH OPDF, Hluvuku, HOPE, Hope for<br />
Life, Horizon, Horizonti, ICC BluSol, ICC Conquista Solidária, ICC MAUCE, ICMFB, IDEPRO, IDER<br />
CV, IDESI Lambayeque, IDE<strong>SP</strong>A, ID-Ghana, IDH, IDYDC, IFDP, ImerCredit, Imkoniyat, Imodi Hutal,<br />
IMPRO, Impuls, Inicjatywa Mikro, INSOTEC, Instituto Estrela, Intellekt, Invest Credit, Invest-Credit<br />
Moldova, IPR, Izdiharona Microfinance, Jabal Al Hoss, Joldosh Group, JOVID, Juaben RB, JXWDA,<br />
Kakum RB, Kajnardza 96, Kemek, KGMAMF, KixiCredito, Komak Credit, KosInvest, KPOSB, Kredo,<br />
KRK Ltd, KSF, KSK RPK, KVK, KVK-Altay, La Community Bank, LAM, LAPO-SLE, Lazika Capital, Letta,<br />
LIDER, LSK, M7 Can Loc, M7 DB District, M7 DBP City, M7 Dong Trieu, M7 Mai Son, M7 Ninh Phuoc,<br />
M7 Uong bi, Madfa SACCO, FAF-DC, Makhzoumi, Manushi, Maqsadi dasgiri, Maritsa Invest,<br />
Mbinga CB, MCL, MCN, MCO ‘Oral’, MDF, MEC AFER, MEC FEPRODES, MECBAS, MECREF, MEDF,<br />
MED-Net, MGPCC DEKAWOWO, MiBanco Venezuela, Micro Africa, MicroCred - MDG, MicroCred -<br />
MEX, MicroCred - SEN, Micredito SAC, Microfinanciera Prisma, Microinvest, Microserfin, Microsol,<br />
MIDE, Mikro ALDI, Mikrofond, MikroMaliyye Credit, Miziya, MLF Chiluchor chashma, MLF<br />
Kiropol, MLF Madina, MLF Vahsh Microfin, MLO HUMO, MLO ‘Saodat Invest’, MAMIDECOT, MMS,<br />
Mol Bulak Finance, Moldir, Momina Voda, Moznosti, MUDE, MUL, Mutuelle Akwaba, Nachala,<br />
Nadejda, Nadejda 96, Narodniy Kredit_Kemerov, NBJK, NCS, Neftegaz, NeRuDO, NESDO, New<br />
RB of Victorias, NMFB, Nov Credit, NSBA, Nwabiagya RB, NYWDA, Obereg (Vladivostok), OBS,<br />
Faulu - TZA, OI China, OLC, OMRO, Oportunidad Microfinanzas, Opportunity Finance, Otiv Diana,<br />
Otiv Sambava, Otuasekan RB, OXUS - KGS, OXUS - TJK, Parabank, PARC, Partner Russia, Parwaz,<br />
PASECA - Kayes, PASED, PATRA Hunchun, PATRA Yanbian, PCWDA, Perelik, Plan International,<br />
PNG Microfinance Ltd, Pomoriiski stopanin, Popular Kasa-Kystendil, Popular SAFI, Povoljye,<br />
Pride Finance, ProCaja, ProCredit - COL, ProCredit - HND, ProCredit Bank - MDA, ProCredit Bank<br />
- SLE, ProCredit Bank- DRC, Progresar, Pro Mujer - ARG, Pushtikar, Raduga, RAFODE, RB Cainta,<br />
RB Cotabato, RB Digos, RB Lebak, RB Liloy, RB Oroquieta, RB Pagbilao, RB Placer, RB Siargao,<br />
RCCECG, Red de Vanguardia, REDFunds, Reef, Reliance, Reserv-Altay, Rezerv, Rishenglong,<br />
Riverbank, RML, ROMCOM, Rost, Rus, WMN (Russia), Ryada, São Paulo Confia, SABR, Saglasie 96,<br />
Sahara Mahila, Samasta, Samokov 96, Sartawi, SBS, SCDA, SED, SEF-ARM, Seilanithih, SEM Fund,<br />
SemiSol, Serviamus, SEWA Finance, SFSD, Siam Bank, SIPEM, Smilyan, SOCIALCRED, PADECOMSM,<br />
SOCRED, Sodeystviye, Sodeystviye-2005, Sodruzhestvo, SOFINA, Soglasiye, Solidarnost, Solución<br />
Asea, Soluciones Reales, South Akim RB, Soyuz-Khimik, SoyuzKredit, Soyuz-Primoroye, <strong>SP</strong>BD,<br />
<strong>SP</strong>GBB, SSK, Stanichnik, Stopanin, Sugd Microfin, SUMI, Sungi, Mentors- PER, SFPL, TFS, TIAVO,<br />
Tsaritsinskiy passaj, Tsimlyansk, Tujijenge, Tverskoy, UCADE Ambato, UCADE Guaranda, UCADE<br />
Latacunga, UCADE Santo Domingo, UCCEC GY, UMECDES, Umid, Umid-Credit, UNICREICH,<br />
UNION DES COOPECs UMUTANGUHA, Union RB, Upper Manya RB, USFSBS, USTOI, VFM, Viator,<br />
Vital Finance, Vivir Soluciones, Vostok Kapital, VRFSBS, VSSU, VYCCU, Nationwide Microbank,<br />
WISE, WKP, WOCCU - AFG, XXWDA, YYWDA<br />
241 56 158 27 ABWA, ACEP Senegal, ACFB, ACME, ADRA - PER, AFS, AgroCapital, Agroinvestbank, Akiba, Al<br />
Karama, Al Majmoua, ALSOL, Alwatani, AMC de R.L., Ameen, AMSSF/MC, ANDE, APED, Apoyo<br />
Integral, APROS, ARD, ARDCI, AREGAK UCO, ARMP, ASA - GHA, Asasah, ASC Union, ASHI,<br />
Asociación Arariwa, Asociación Raíz, A<strong>SP</strong> Financiera, A<strong>SP</strong>IRE, Atwima Kwanwoma, AYNLA,<br />
Azercredit, Bai Tushum, Banco Amigo, Banco Santiago de Libon, BanCovelo, Bank Eskhata,<br />
Berendina Microfinance, BESA, Bonzali RB, BPR NBP 11, BPR Surya Yudha Kencana, BRAC - SS, BTA<br />
Bank, BWDC, CAFODEC, CCAMETRO, Cantilan Bank, Caritas, CAURIE Micro Finance, CBDIBA/<br />
RENACA, CEAPE MA, CEPRODEL, CEVI, CFA, CFPA, CHC-Limited, CHF Iraq, CMAC Del Santa, CMAC<br />
Maynas, CMAC Paita, COAC Jardín Azuayo, COCDEP, CODESARROLLO, Conserva, Contactar, Coop<br />
20 de Abril, Coop Jesús Nazareno, COOPAC León XIII, COOPAC San Cristóbal, COOPAC San Martín,<br />
COOPAC Santa Maria, COOPAC Santo Cristo, COOPROGRESO, CRAC Los Andes, CRAC Profinanzas,<br />
Crece Safsa, CredAgro NBCO, CrediClub, CrediComún, Créditos Pronegocio, CREDO,<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
61
BULLETIN TABLES<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
Peer Group - 2008 DATA QUALITY †<br />
SIMPLE PEER GROUPS<br />
Outreach: Large<br />
(Number of Borrowers<br />
> 30,000)<br />
N * ** *** PARTICIPATING INSTITUTIONS<br />
CRYSOL, CSD, CUMO, DD Bank, DEF, Dian Mandiri, Don Apoyo, Duterimbere, EDPYME Alternativa,<br />
EDPYME Credivisión, EDPYME Nueva Visión, EKPA, ENLACE, Eshet, FAFIDESS, FAMA OPDF, FASL,<br />
Fassil FFP, Faulu - UGA, FED, FFSA, FICO, FinAmigo, FINCA - ARM, FINCA - GEO, FINCA - HND, FINCA<br />
- HTI, FINCA - KOS, FINCA - MWI, FINCA - NIC, FINCA - PER, FINCA - Russia, FINCA - SLV, FINCA<br />
- TJK, FINCA - ZMB, FINSOL, FMF, FMFB - TJK, FMFI-SYR, FODEMI, FONDECO, FONDESOL, Fondo<br />
Esperanza, Fonkoze, Forjadores de Negocios, FORUS, FRAC, FUBODE, Fundación Esperanza,<br />
Fundación León 2000, Fundación Nieborowski, FUNDAHMICRO, FUNDEA, FUNDENUSE, Fundusz<br />
Mikro, FUNED, GAWFA, GCM, GM Bank, GRAINE sarl, Harbu, Hofokam, H<strong>SP</strong>FI, IDDA, IMFB, IMON,<br />
Indur MACS, INMAA, Invirtiendo, Janodaya, Jigiyaso Ba, JSC Bank Constanta, JVS, KADET, KAMURJ,<br />
Kasagana-Ka, Kashf Bank, Kazama Grameen, KBank, KCCDFI, KEP, KMF, Kondo Jigima, KOPSA,<br />
Maata-N-Tudu, MADRAC, Mahuli, Mallig Plains RB, Manuela Ramos, Marang, MC², Meklit, MEMCO,<br />
Micro Start, Coop MEDA, MIKRA, Miselini, MLF MicroInvest, MLF MWI, MoFAD, Moris Rasik,<br />
MPGBB, NEED, Nidan, NMF, Normicro, NovoBanco - MOZ, NRDSC, Nyesigiso, ODEF Financiera,<br />
OMB, Opportunity Albania, Opportunity Kenya, Otiv Alaotra, Otiv Tana, OXUS - AFG, PAIDEK,<br />
PALFSI, PAPME, PEACE, PR Bank, PRESTANIC, PRISMA, ProCredit - GHA, ProCredit - MDA, PRODESA,<br />
Progresemos, Progressive Bank, Pro Mujer - MEX, Pro Mujer - NIC, RADE, RB Camalig, RB Mabitac,<br />
RB Montevista, RB Talisayan, R<strong>SP</strong>I, SBACD, SEDA, SEWA Bank, SFPI, SINERGIJA, SOGESOL, Sunrise,<br />
Tchuma, Te Creemos, Turame Community Finance, UCEC/MK, U-IMCEC, UNRWA, Finance Trust,<br />
Valiant RB, WAGES, Women for Women, World Relief - HND, WSE, WWI - AFG<br />
273 45 181 47 1st Valley Bank, ABA, ABCRDM, ABS-CBN, ACBA, AccessBank, ACLEDA, ACSI, ADCSI, Adhikar,<br />
ADOPEM, AgroInvest, Aiyl Bank, Al Amana, Al Tadamun, AMK, AML, AMMACTS, AMRET, Apoyo<br />
Económico, ARDI, Arohan, ASA, ASA Philippines, ASBA, ASKI, ASODENIC, ASUSU CIIGABA, AWS,<br />
Azerdemiryolbank, Bancamía, Banco ADEMI, Banco Familiar, Banco Popular do Brasil, Banco<br />
Solidario, BancoEstado, BancoSol, Bandhan, BANEX, BanGente, Bank of Baku, BASIX, BCSC,<br />
BEES, Bessfa RB, BFL, BG, BISWA, BRAC, BRAC - AFG, BRAC - LKA, BRAC - TZA, BRAC - UGA, BSS,<br />
BURO Bangladesh, Caja Popular Mexicana, CamCCUL, CAME, Capitec Bank, CARD Bank, CARD<br />
NGO, Cashpor MC, CBB, CCA, CDS, Centenary Bank, Central Cresol Baser, CEOSS, CEP, CMAC<br />
Arequipa, CMAC Cusco, CMAC Huancayo, CMAC Ica, CMAC Piura, CMAC Sullana, CMAC Tacna,<br />
CMAC Trujillo, CMFinance, CMS, COAC Mushuc Runa, COAC La Nacional, CompartamosBanco,<br />
Comultrasan, CRAC Nuestra Gente, CRAC Señor de Luren, CRECER, Credi Fé, CrediAmigo, Credi-<br />
Capital, Crediscotia, CREDIT, CReSA, Cresol Central, DAMEN, DBACD, DEC, DECSI, DEPROSC-Nepal,<br />
Diaconia, D-Miro, D<strong>SP</strong>I, EcoFuturo FFP, EDPYME Confianza, EDPYME Crear Arequipa, EDPYME<br />
Efectiva, EDPYME Proempresa, EDPYME Raíz, EKI, Enda, Equitas, Equity Bank, ESAF, ESED, FAIR<br />
Bank, Faulu - KEN, FBPMC, FDL, FECECAM, FIE FFP, FIELCO, FinAmérica, Financiera Edyficar,<br />
Financiera Fama, Financiera Independencia, FINCA - AFG, FINCA - AZE, FINCA - DRC, FINCA<br />
- ECU, FINCA - GTM, FINCA - MEX, FINCA - TZA, FINCA - UGA, FinComún, FMCC, FMFB - AFG,<br />
FMFB - Pakistan, FMM Bucaramanga, FMM Popayán, FMSD, FONDEP, FORWARD, FUCEC Togo,<br />
Fundación Espoir, Fundación Paraguaya, FUNDESER, Génesis Empresarial, GBNB, GF<strong>SP</strong>L, GOF,<br />
Grameen Bank, Green Bank, GU, GV, HEED, HiH, HKL, IDF, INECO, Interactuar, Interfisa Financiera,<br />
Jamii Bora, JCF, Kafo Jiginew, Kashf Foundation, KBSLAB, Khan Bank, Khushhali Bank, KMB, KMBI,<br />
Kokari, Kompanion, K-Rep, KRUSHI, KWFT, Lak Jaya, LAPO-NGR, Lead Foundation, Life Bank, LOK<br />
Microcredit Foundation, Mahasemam, MBK Ventura, MFI, MFW, MGBB, MiBanco, MI-BO<strong>SP</strong>O,<br />
Mikrokredit Bank, Mimo Finance, MUSCCO, Nirdhan, NWTF, OBM, OCSSCO, OIBM, OISL, PADME,<br />
PAMECAS, Partner, PAWDEP, PBC, PGBB, PRASAC, PRIDE - TZA, PRIZMA, ProCredit - BOL, ProCredit<br />
- ECU, ProCredit - NIC, ProCredit - SLV, ProCredit Bank - ALB, ProCredit Bank - BGR, ProCredit<br />
Bank - BIH, ProCredit Bank - GEO, ProCredit Bank - KOS, ProCredit Bank - MKD, ProCredit Bank<br />
- ROM, ProCredit Bank - UKR, ProCredit Bank Serbia, PRODEM FFP, Pro Mujer - BOL, Pro Mujer<br />
- PER, PWMACS, RASS, RCPB, Real Microcrédito, RGVN, Saadhana, Sabaragamuwa, Sajida,<br />
Sanghamithra, Sarala, Sarvodaya Nano Finance, SAT, Sathapana Limited, SB Bank, SCNL, SDBL,<br />
SEAP, SEEDS, SEF-ZAF, SFF, Shakti, SHARE, SKDRDP, SKS, SMEP, SMILE, SMSS, SolFi, Sonata, Soro<br />
Yiriwaso, Spandana, SSS, SU, SWAWS, Tamweelcom, TMFB, TPC, Trident Microfinance, TSKI, TYM,<br />
Ujjivan, UNACOOPEC-CI, UOB, VB<strong>SP</strong>, VFC, VFS, Visión Banco, Wasasa, WDB, Wisdom, WWB Cali,<br />
XacBank, Zakoura<br />
Profit Status: Profit 414 99 268 47 1st MCC, 1st Valley Bank, 3A Entreprises, Abzal Kredit, ACB sa, ACBA, AccessBank, ACCOVI,<br />
ACLEDA, ACLEDA Lao, ACSI, ADCSI, ADOPEM, Aqrarkredit, AgroInvest, Agroinvestbank, A-invest,<br />
Aiyl Bank, Akiba, Akuapem RB, Al Rafah Bank, Alliance Group, Alliance MFB, Alternativa 19 del<br />
Sur, AMC de R.L., Ameen, AMfB, AMK, AML, Amlok, AMRET, Apoyo Económico, Apoyo Integral,<br />
AREGAK UCO, Arnur Credit, Arohan, A<strong>SP</strong> Financiera, ASUSU CIIGABA, Atwima Kwanwoma, AWS,<br />
Azerdemiryolbank, Bancamía, Banco ADEMI, Banco Amigo, Banco Familiar, Banco Popular do<br />
Brasil, Banco Santiago de Libon, Banco Solidario, BancoEstado, BancoSol, BanCovelo, Bandhan,<br />
BANEX, BanGente, Bangko Kabayan, Bangko Luzon, Bangko Mabuhay, Bank Eskhata, Bank of<br />
Baku, BASIX, BAYOCA, BCB, BCSC, Bereke-credit, Berendina Microfinance, Bessfa RB, BFL, BG,<br />
BMT Pringsewu, BOM, Bonzali RB, BPR AN, BPR Aditama Arta, BPR AK, BPR Artadamas Mandiri,<br />
BPR BBTM, BPR BKK Cilacap, BPR CAS, BPR Citama, BPR DMG, BPR Eka Ayu, BPR Eka Usaha, BPR<br />
Hitamajaya, BPR NBP 11, BPR NBP 19, BPR NBP 2, BPR NBP 30, BPR NSI, BPR Pinang Artha, BPR<br />
PKT, BPR SAS, BPR Sukawati Pancakanti, BPR SKA, BPR Surya Yudha Kencana, BPR Taman Dhana,<br />
BPR Wahana Sentra Artha, BTA Bank, CAFASA, CAFODEC, Cantilan Bank, Capitec Bank, CARD<br />
Bank, CAURIE Micro Finance, CBB, CBIRD, CBMO, CCA, CDS, CECIC S.A., Centenary Bank, CETZAM,<br />
CFE, CHC-Limited, CMFinance, Columbia Microcreditos, CompartamosBanco, CRAC Los Andes,<br />
CRAC Nuestra Gente, CRAC Profinanzas, CRAC Señor de Luren, CRAC Sipán, Crece Safsa, Credi<br />
Fé, CrediAmigo, CrediAvance, Credi-Capital, CrediClub, CrediComún, Crediscotia, CREDIT, Credit<br />
Mongol, Créditos Pronegocio, CREDITUYO, Crezcamos, CRG, Crystal, CU Kosayu, CU Pantai Prigi,<br />
DD Bank, DECSI, Degaf, Despacho Amador, Dirigible, Don Apoyo, Duterimbere, ECLOF - ARM,<br />
62<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
BULLETIN TABLES<br />
Peer Group - 2008 DATA QUALITY †<br />
SIMPLE PEER GROUPS<br />
N * ** *** PARTICIPATING INSTITUTIONS<br />
EcoFuturo FFP, EDPYME Acceso Crediticio, EDPYME Alternativa, EDPYME Confianza, EDPYME<br />
Crear Arequipa, EDPYME Credivisión, EDPYME Efectiva, EDPYME Nueva Visión, EDPYME Pro<br />
Negocios, EDPYME Proempresa, EDPYME Raíz, Elet-Capital, ENLACE, Equitas, Equity Bank,<br />
Eshet, Crezkamos Kapital, Fácil SCM, FAIR Bank, Farm Credit Armenia, FASL, Fassil FFP, Faulu<br />
- UGA, FFSA, FICO, FIE FFP, FIE Gran Poder, FIELCO, FinAgro, FinAmérica, FinAmigo, Financiera<br />
Edyficar, Financiera Fama, Financiera Independencia, FINCA - AZE, FINCA - ECU, FINCA - HND,<br />
FINCA - Russia, FINCA - TJK, FINCA - UGA, FINCA - ZMB, FinComún, FINCORP, FINORTE, FINSOL,<br />
First Macro Bank, Emprenda, FISUR, FMCC, FMFB - AFG, FMFB - Pakistan, FMFB - TJK, Forjadores<br />
de Negocios, Fortaleza FFP, FORUS, Garant-Invest, GAWFA, GBNB, GCM, GF<strong>SP</strong>L, GM Bank, GOF,<br />
GRAINE sarl, Grameen Bank, Green Bank, Grupo Río La Venta, GV, Harbu, HKL, Horizon, ICMFB,<br />
IFDP, IMFB, IMON, INECO, Inicjatywa Mikro, Interfisa Financiera, Invest Credit, Invest-Credit<br />
Moldova, Invirtiendo, IPR, Jamii Bora, Joldosh Group, JSC Bank Constanta, Juaben RB, JVS, KADET,<br />
Kakum RB, Kashf Bank, KBank, KBSLAB, Kemek, Khan Bank, Khushhali Bank, KixiCredito, KMB, KMF,<br />
Komak Credit, KPOSB, K-Rep, KWFT, La Community Bank, Lak Jaya, LAM, LAPO-SLE, Letta, Mahila,<br />
Mallig Plains RB, Maqsadi dasgiri, Maxima, Mbinga CB, MCL, MCN, MCO ‘Oral’, Meklit, MFI, MGBB,<br />
MiBanco, MiBanco Venezuela, Micro Africa, MicroCred - MDG, MicroCred - MEX, MicroCred<br />
- SEN, Micredito SAC, Microfinanciera Prisma, Microinvest, Microserfin, Mikrofond, Mikrokredit<br />
Bank, Mimo Finance, MLO HUMO, MLO ‘Saodat Invest’, Mol Bulak Finance, Moldir, MPGBB, MUL,<br />
New RB of Victorias, Nirdhan, NMFB, NovoBanco - MOZ, Nwabiagya RB, OBM, OBS, OCSSCO,<br />
ODEF Financiera, OI China, OIBM, OISL, OMB, Oportunidad Microfinanzas, Opportunity Finance,<br />
Opportunity Kenya, Otuasekan RB, OXUS - KGS, Parabank, PBC, PEACE, PGBB, PNG Microfinance<br />
Ltd, POMFB, Popular SAFI, PR Bank, PRASAC, ProCredit - BOL, ProCredit - COL, ProCredit - ECU,<br />
ProCredit - GHA, ProCredit - HND, ProCredit - MDA, ProCredit - NIC, ProCredit - SLV, ProCredit<br />
Bank - ALB, ProCredit Bank - BGR, ProCredit Bank - BIH, ProCredit Bank - GEO, ProCredit Bank<br />
- KOS, ProCredit Bank - MDA, ProCredit Bank - MKD, ProCredit Bank - ROM, ProCredit Bank - SLE,<br />
ProCredit Bank - UKR, ProCredit Bank- DRC, ProCredit Bank Serbia, PRODEM FFP, Progresemos,<br />
Progressive Bank, RB Bagac, RB Cainta, RB Camalig, RB Cotabato, RB Digos,<br />
RB Dipolog, RB Guinobatan, RB Lebak, RB Liloy, RB Mabitac, RB Montevista, RB Oroquieta, RB<br />
Pagbilao, RB Placer, RB San Jacinto, RB Siargao, RB Solano, RB Talisayan, Real Microcrédito, Red<br />
de Vanguardia, REDFunds, Reef, Reliance, Rishenglong, RML, WMN (Russia), Sabaragamuwa,<br />
Samasta, Sarvodaya Nano Finance, Sathapana Limited, SB Bank, SCNL, SDBL, SED, SEF-ARM,<br />
Seilanithih, SemiSol, SEWA Bank, SEWA Finance, SFF, SFPI, SHARE, Siam Bank, SIPEM, SKS,<br />
SOCIALCRED, PADECOMSM, SOCRED, SOFINA, SOGESOL, SolFi, Solución Asea, Soluciones Reales,<br />
Sonata, South Akim RB, Spandana, <strong>SP</strong>GBB, SUMI, SFPL, Te Creemos, TFS, TMFB, TPC, Trident<br />
Microfinance, Tujijenge, Turame Community Finance, Ujjivan, Umid-Credit, UNICREICH, Union<br />
RB, Upper Manya RB, Finance Trust, Valiant RB, VFC, VFS, Visión Banco, Vivir Soluciones, Wasasa,<br />
Nationwide Microbank, WDB, WISE, XacBankk<br />
Profit Status: Not for Profit 665 242 368 55 A3C, ABA, ABCRDM, ABS-CBN, ABWA, Abyan, ACAD, ACEP Cameroon, ACEP Senegal, ACF,<br />
ACFB, ACME, ACORDE, Actuar Caldas, Actuar Tolima, Aden, Adhikar, ADICH, ADIM, ADRA<br />
- PER, ADRI, Aetos, AFK, AFODENIC, AFS, Agência do Crédito, AGAPE, AgroCapital, Agrocredit<br />
Plus, Agroimpuls, AGUDESA, Al Amana, Al Awael, Al Karama, Al Majmoua, Al Tadamun, Alidé,<br />
ALSOL, Alternativa, Alternativa Microfinanzas, Alteya, Al-Thiqa, Alwatani, AMA, AMC, AMEXTRA,<br />
AMFI, AMMACTS, AMOS, AMSSF/MC, ANDE, ANED, APED, APROS, Aqroinvest, ARD, ARDCI,<br />
ARDI, ARMP, ASA, ASA - GHA, ASA Philippines, ASALA, Asasah, ASBA, ASC Union, ASDIR, ASEI,<br />
ASHI, ASIDME, ASKI, Asociación Arariwa, Asociación El Balsamo, Asociación Raíz, ASODENIC,<br />
ASOPROSANRAMON, A<strong>SP</strong>IRE, ASR, ASTI, ATEMEXPA, Avantaj, Avanzar, AYNLA, Azal, Azercredit,<br />
Azeri Star, Bai Tushum, Banco da Familia, Banco do Empreendedor, Banco do Povo ACP, Rede<br />
Novo Sol, Banco do Vale, BANCRI, BEES, Bereke, BESA, BFSBS, BIMAS, Binhminh CDC, BISWA,<br />
BJS, Blago, BMSCCSL, BMT Kayu Manis, Borshud, BRAC, BRAC - AFG, BRAC - LKA, BRAC - SS,<br />
BRAC - TZA, BRAC - UGA, BRCCC, BSS, BURO Bangladesh, BWDC, BZMF, CACMU, Caja Depac<br />
Poblana, Caja Popular Mexicana, CamCCUL, CAME, CCAMETRO, CAPA, CAPPED, CARD NGO, CARE<br />
- CREEME, Caritas, Caritas Esteli, Casa do Microcrédito, Cashpor MC, CBDIBA/RENACA, CCC, CDM,<br />
CDRO, CEADe, CEAPE BA, CEAPE MA, CEAPE PE, CEAPE PI, CECA, CEC-PROM Mature, CEDEF, CEF,<br />
Central Cresol Baser, CEOSS, CEP, CEP BRVT, CEP Long An, CEPESIU, CEPRODEL, CESOL ACJ, CEVI,<br />
CFA, CFF, CFPA, Chamroeun, Chandeshwori, CHF Iraq, Childfund Hoa Binh, Chita FSBS, CHWDA,<br />
CIDRE, CMAC Arequipa, CMAC Cusco, CMAC Del Santa, CMAC Huancayo, CMAC Ica, CMAC<br />
Maynas, CMAC Paita, CMAC Pisco, CMAC Piura, CMAC Sullana, CMAC Tacna, CMAC Trujillo, CMCA,<br />
CMEDFI, CMMB, CMS, COAC 4 de Octubre, COAC Acción Rural, COAC Ambato, COAC Artesanos,<br />
COAC Chone, COAC Fernando Daquilema, COAC Fondvida, COAC Huaycopungo, COAC Jardín<br />
Azuayo, COAC Kullki Wasi, COAC La Benéfica, COAC Luz del Valle, COAC MCCH, COAC Minga,<br />
COAC Mushuc Runa, COAC La Nacional, COAC Padre Vicente, COAC Pallatanga, COAC Sac Aiet,<br />
COAC San Antonio, COAC San Gabriel, COAC San José, COAC Santa Ana, COAC Santa Anita,<br />
COCDEP, CODESARROLLO, Common Interest, Comultrasan, Conserva, Contactar, Coop 20 de<br />
Abril, Coop Avances, Coop Fátima, Coop Jesús Nazareno, Coop Juan XXIII, COOPAC Chiquinquira,<br />
COOPAC León XIII, COOPAC Los Andes, COOPAC Norandino, COOPAC San Cristóbal, COOPAC San<br />
Martín, COOPAC Santa Maria, COOPAC Santo Cristo, COOPAC Santo Domingo, COOPAC Tocache,<br />
COOPEC Hinfani Dosso, COOPEC/ACCO, COOPEDU-Kigali, COOPROGRESO, CO<strong>SP</strong>EC, CPECG Yete<br />
Mali, CRAN, CRECER, CredAgro NBCO, Credicoop, CREDIMUJER, Credisol, CREDO, CReSA, Cresol<br />
Central, CRYSOL, CSD, CU Sawiran, CUMO, CVECA Kita/Bafoulabé, CVECA Pays Dogon, CVECA<br />
SOUM, CWCD, CZWSDA, DAMEN, DAYAQ-Credit, DBACD, DEC, DEF, DEPROSC-Nepal, Diaconia,<br />
Dian Mandiri, DINARI, DJOMEC, DSK Dobrich, D-Miro, Doveriye - Volgograd, Doveriye (Amursk),<br />
Doveriye- Bulgaria, Doveriye-Altay, DQF, D<strong>SP</strong>I, ECLOF - ECU, ECLOF - PHL, EDAPRO<strong>SP</strong>O, Edinstvo<br />
Yurga, Edinstvo-Volgograd, Ehyoi kuhiston, EKI, EKPA, Emprender, Enda, ESAF, ESED,<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
63
BULLETIN TABLES<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
Peer Group - 2008 DATA QUALITY †<br />
SIMPLE PEER GROUPS<br />
Region: Africa<br />
(Sub - Saharan Africa)<br />
N * ** *** PARTICIPATING INSTITUTIONS<br />
Espacios Alternativos, Express Finance, FACES, FADEMYPE, FAFIDESS, FAM, FAMA OPDF, FAPE,<br />
FATEN, Faulu - KEN, FBPMC, AfricaWorks, FDL, FDM, FECECAM, FED, FFECC, FIACG, FIDERPAC,<br />
FIDEVIE, FINCA - AFG, FINCA - ARM, FINCA - DRC, FINCA - GEO, FINCA - GTM, FINCA - HTI,<br />
FINCA - JOR, FINCA - KOS, FINCA - MEX, FINCA - MWI, FINCA - NIC, FINCA - PER, FINCA - SLV,<br />
FINCA - TZA, FinDev, FMF, FMFI-SYR, FMM Bucaramanga, FMM Popayán, FMSD, FNT Credit,<br />
FODEM, FODEMI, FOMIC, FONCRESOL, FONDECO, FONDEP, FONDESOL, FONDESURCO,<br />
Fondo Esperanza, Fonkoze, FORWARD, FOVIDA, FRAC, FUBODE, FUCEC Togo, FUDEMI, FULM,<br />
FUNBODEM, Fund for Women Development - HCM, Fundación 4i-2000, Fundación Alternativa,<br />
Fundación Amanecer, Fundación CAMPO, Fundación Esperanza, Fundación Espoir, Fundación<br />
León 2000, Fundación MICROS, Fundación Mujer, Fundación Nieborowski, Fundación<br />
Paraguaya, FUNDAHMICRO, FUNDAMIC, FUNDEA, FUNDEBASE, FUNDECOCA, FUNDENUSE,<br />
FUNDEPYME, FUNDESER, FUNDE<strong>SP</strong>E, Fundusz Mikro, FUNED, FUNHAVI, FUNSALDE, FVP,<br />
Génesis Empresarial, Galaktika, Gasha, General Toshevo, GGEM Microfinance Services Ltd.,<br />
Gorodskoy, Grameen Mendoza, GU, HEED, Hekima, HDH OPDF, HiH, Hluvuku, Hofokam, HOPE,<br />
Hope for Life, Horizonti, H<strong>SP</strong>FI, ICC BluSol, ICC Conquista Solidária, ICC MAUCE, IDDA, IDEPRO,<br />
IDER CV, IDESI Lambayeque, IDE<strong>SP</strong>A, IDF, ID-Ghana, IDH, IDYDC, ImerCredit, Imkoniyat, Imodi<br />
Hutal, IMPRO, Impuls, Indur MACS, INMAA, INSOTEC, Instituto Estrela, Intellekt, Interactuar,<br />
Izdiharona Microfinance, Jabal Al Hoss, Janodaya, JCF, Jigiyaso Ba, JOVID, JSCCS, JXWDA, Kafo<br />
Jiginew, KAMURJ, Kasagana-Ka, Kashf Foundation, Kajnardza 96, Kazama Grameen, KCCDFI,<br />
KEP, KGMAMF, KMBI, Kokari, Kompanion, Kondo Jigima, KOPSA, KosInvest, Kredo, KRK Ltd,<br />
KRUSHI, KSF, KSK RPK, KVK, KVK-Altay, LAPO-NGR, Lazika Capital, Lead Foundation, LIDER, Life<br />
Bank, LOK Microcredit Foundation, LSK, M7 Can Loc, M7 DB District, M7 DBP City, M7 Dong<br />
Trieu, M7 Mai Son, M7 Ninh Phuoc, M7 Uong bi, Maata-N-Tudu, Madfa SACCO, MADRAC,<br />
FAF-DC, Mahasemam, Mahashakti, Mahuli, Makhzoumi, Manuela Ramos, Manushi, Marang,<br />
Maritsa Invest, MBK Ventura, MC², MDF, MEC AFER, MEC FEPRODES, MECBAS, MECREF, MEDF,<br />
MED-Net, MEMCO, MFW, MGPCC DEKAWOWO, MI-BO<strong>SP</strong>O, Micro Start, Coop MEDA, Microsol,<br />
MIDE, MIKRA, Mikro ALDI, MikroMaliyye Credit, Miselini, Miziya, MLF Chiluchor chashma, MLF<br />
Kiropol, MLF Madina, MLF MicroInvest, MLF MWI, MLF Vahsh Microfin, MAMIDECOT, MoFAD,<br />
Momina Voda, Moris Rasik, Moznosti, MUDE, MUSCCO, Mutuelle Akwaba, Nachala, Nadejda,<br />
Nadejda 96, Narodniy Kredit_Kemerov, NBJK, NCS, NEED, Neftegaz, NeRuDO, Nidan, NMF,<br />
Normicro, Nov Credit, NRDSC, NSBA, NWTF, Nyesigiso, NYWDA, Obereg (Vladivostok), Faulu<br />
- TZA, OLC, OMRO, Opportunity Albania, Otiv Alaotra, Otiv Diana, Otiv Sambava, Otiv Tana,<br />
OXUS - AFG, OXUS - TJK, PADME, PAIDEK, PALFSI, PAMECAS, PAPME, PARC, Partner, Partner<br />
Russia, Parwaz, PASECA - Kayes, PASED, PATRA Hunchun, PATRA Yanbian, PAWDEP, PCWDA,<br />
Perelik, Plan International, Pomoriiski stopanin, Popular Kasa-Kystendil, Povoljye, PRESTANIC,<br />
PRIDE - TZA, Pride Finance, PRISMA, PRIZMA, ProCaja, PRODESA, Progresar, Pro Mujer - ARG,<br />
Pro Mujer - BOL, Pro Mujer - MEX, Pro Mujer - NIC, Pro Mujer - PER, Pushtikar, PWMACS,<br />
RADE, Raduga, RAFODE, RASS, RCCECG, RCDS, RCPB, Reserv-Altay, Rezerv, RGVN, Riverbank,<br />
ROMCOM, Rost, R<strong>SP</strong>I, Rus, Ryada, São Paulo Confia, Saadhana, SABR, Saglasie 96, Sahara<br />
Mahila, Sajida, Samokov 96, Sanghamithra, Sarala, Sartawi, SAT, SBACD, SBS, SCDA, SEAP, SEDA,<br />
SEEDS, SEF-ZAF, SEM Fund, Serviamus, SFSD, Shakti, SINERGIJA, SKDRDP, SMEP, Smilyan, SMSS,<br />
Sodeystviye, Sodeystviye-2005, Sodruzhestvo, Soglasiye, Solidarnost, Soro Yiriwaso, Soyuz-<br />
Khimik, SoyuzKredit, Soyuz-Primoroye, <strong>SP</strong>BD, SSS, Stanichnik, Stopanin, SU, Sugd Microfin,<br />
Sungi, Sunrise, Mentors - PER, SWAWS, Tamweelcom, Tchuma, TIAVO, TLM, Tsaritsinskiy passaj,<br />
Tsimlyansk, TSKI, Tverskoy, TYM, UCADE Ambato, UCADE Guaranda, UCADE Latacunga, UCADE<br />
Santo Domingo, UCCEC GY, UCEC/MK, U-IMCEC, UMECDES, Umid, UNACOOPEC-CI, UNION DES<br />
COOPECs UMUTANGUHA, UNRWA, UOB, USFSBS, USTOI, VB<strong>SP</strong>, VFM, Viator, Vital Finance, Vostok<br />
Kapital, VRFSBS, VSSU, VYCCU, WAGES, Wisdom, WKP, WOCCU - AFG, Women for Women, World<br />
Relief - HND, WSE, WWB Cali, WWI - AFG, XXWDA, YYWDA, Zakoura<br />
195 62 130 3 3A Entreprises, A3C, ACB sa, ACEP Cameroon, ACEP Senegal, ACFB, ACSI, ADCSI, Akiba, Akuapem<br />
RB, Alidé, Alliance MFB, AMfB, APED, ARD, ASA - GHA, ASUSU CIIGABA, Atwima Kwanwoma,<br />
Bessfa RB, BG, BIMAS, BOM, Bonzali RB, BRAC - TZA, BRAC - UGA, CAFODEC, CamCCUL, Capitec<br />
Bank, CAPPED, CAURIE Micro Finance, CBDIBA/RENACA, CCA, CDM, CDS, CECA, CECIC S.A.,<br />
CEC-PROM Mature, CEDEF, Centenary Bank, CETZAM, CFE, CFF, CMCA, CMMB, CMS, COOPEC<br />
Hinfani Dosso, COOPEC/ACCO, COOPEDU-Kigali, CO<strong>SP</strong>EC, CPECG Yete Mali, CRAN, CRG,<br />
CUMO, CVECA Kita/Bafoulabé, CVECA Pays Dogon, CVECA SOUM, DEC, DECSI, Degaf, DJOMEC,<br />
DQF, Duterimbere, Equity Bank, Eshet, FAM, FASL, Faulu - KEN, Faulu - UGA, AfricaWorks,<br />
FDM, FECECAM, FIDEVIE, FINCA - DRC, FINCA - MWI, FINCA - TZA, FINCA - UGA, FINCA - ZMB,<br />
FINCORP, FUCEC Togo, Gasha, GAWFA, GGEM Microfinance Services Ltd., GRAINE sarl, Harbu,<br />
Hekima, Hluvuku, Hofokam, ICMFB, ID-Ghana, IDYDC, IMFB, Jamii Bora, Jigiyaso Ba, Juaben RB,<br />
KADET, Kafo Jiginew, Kakum RB, KixiCredito, Kokari, Kondo Jigima, KPOSB, K-Rep, KSF, KWFT,<br />
La Community Bank, LAPO-NGR, LAPO-SLE, Letta, LSK, Maata-N-Tudu, Madfa SACCO, Marang,<br />
Mbinga CB, MC², MCL, MEC AFER, MEC FEPRODES, MECBAS, MECREF, MED-Net, Meklit, MGPCC<br />
DEKAWOWO, Micro Africa, Micro Start, MicroCred - MDG, MicroCred - SEN, Miselini, MLF MWI,<br />
MAMIDECOT, MUL, MUSCCO, Mutuelle Akwaba, NovoBanco - MOZ, Nwabiagya RB, Nyesigiso,<br />
OCSSCO, Faulu - TZA, OIBM, OISL, Opportunity Finance, Opportunity Kenya, Otiv Alaotra, Otiv<br />
Diana, Otiv Sambava, Otiv Tana, Otuasekan RB, PADME, PAIDEK, PAMECAS, PAPME, PASECA<br />
- Kayes, PAWDEP, PEACE, PRIDE - TZA, Pride Finance, ProCredit - GHA, ProCredit Bank - SLE,<br />
ProCredit Bank- DRC, RAFODE, RCCECG, RCPB, REDFunds, Reliance, Riverbank, RML, SAT, SEAP,<br />
SEDA, SEF-ZAF, SEM Fund, SFPI, SIPEM, SMEP, SOFINA, Soro Yiriwaso, South Akim RB, Tchuma,<br />
TIAVO, Tujijenge, Turame Community Finance, UCCEC GY, UCEC/MK, U-IMCEC, UMECDES,<br />
UNACOOPEC-CI, UNION DES COOPECs UMUTANGUHA, Union RB, UOB, Upper Manya RB, Finance<br />
Trust, Vital Finance, WAGES, Wasasa, Wisdom, WISE<br />
64<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
BULLETIN TABLES<br />
Peer Group - 2008 DATA QUALITY †<br />
SIMPLE PEER GROUPS<br />
Region: Asia<br />
(South & East Asia)<br />
Region: ECA<br />
(Eastern Europe & Central Asia)<br />
Region: LAC<br />
(Latin America & the Caribbean)<br />
N * ** *** PARTICIPATING INSTITUTIONS<br />
283 91 183 9 1st Valley Bank, ABCRDM, ABS-CBN, ACLEDA, ACLEDA Lao, Adhikar, AFS, AMFI, AMK, AML,<br />
AMMACTS, AMRET, ARDCI, ARMP, Arohan, ASA, ASA Philippines, Asasah, ASHI, ASKI, AWS,<br />
Banco Santiago de Libon, Bandhan, Bangko Kabayan, Bangko Luzon, Bangko Mabuhay, BASIX,<br />
BAYOCA, BCB, BEES, Berendina Microfinance, BFL, Binhminh CDC, BISWA, BJS, BMSCCSL, BMT<br />
Kayu Manis, BMT Pringsewu, BPR AN, BPR Aditama Arta, BPR AK, BPR Artadamas Mandiri,<br />
BPR BBTM, BPR BKK Cilacap, BPR CAS, BPR Citama, BPR DMG, BPR Eka Ayu, BPR Eka Usaha,<br />
BPR Hitamajaya, BPR NBP 11, BPR NBP 19, BPR NBP 2, BPR NBP 30, BPR NSI, BPR Pinang Artha,<br />
BPR PKT, BPR SAS, BPR Sukawati Pancakanti, BPR SKA, BPR Surya Yudha Kencana, BPR Taman<br />
Dhana, BPR Wahana Sentra Artha, BRAC, BRAC - AFG, BRAC - LKA, BSS, BURO Bangladesh,<br />
BWDC, Cantilan Bank, CARD Bank, CARD NGO, Cashpor MC, CBB, CBIRD, CBMO, CEP, CEP BRVT,<br />
CEP Long An, CEVI, CFA, CFPA, Chamroeun, Chandeshwori, CHC-Limited, Childfund Hoa Binh,<br />
CHWDA, CMEDFI, Common Interest, CREDIT, CReSA, CSD, CU Kosayu, CU Pantai Prigi, CU<br />
Sawiran, CWCD, CZWSDA, DAMEN, DD Bank, DEPROSC-Nepal, Dian Mandiri, DINARI, D<strong>SP</strong>I,<br />
ECLOF - PHL, Equitas, ESAF, FAIR Bank, FICO, FINCA - AFG, First Macro Bank, FMFB - AFG, FMFB<br />
- Pakistan, FORWARD, Fund for Women Development - HCM, GBNB, GF<strong>SP</strong>L, GM Bank, GOF,<br />
Grameen Bank, Grameen Sahara, Green Bank, GU, GV, HEED, HiH, HKL, Hope for Life, H<strong>SP</strong>FI,<br />
IDF, IFDP, Indur MACS, IPR, Janodaya, JCF, JSCCS, JVS, JXWDA, Kasagana-Ka, Kashf Foundation,<br />
Kashf Bank, Kazama Grameen, KBank, KBSLAB, KCCDFI, Khushhali Bank, KMBI, KOPSA, KRUSHI,<br />
Lak Jaya, Life Bank, M7 Can Loc, M7 DB District, M7 DBP City, M7 Dong Trieu, M7 Mai Son, M7<br />
Ninh Phuoc, M7 Uong bi, MADRAC, Mahasemam, Mahashakti, Mahila, Mahuli, Mallig Plains<br />
RB, Manushi, Maxima, MBK Ventura, MEDF, MFI, MGBB, Mimo Finance, MMS, MoFAD, Moris<br />
Rasik, MPGBB, NBJK, NCS, NEED, NeRuDO, NESDO, New RB of Victorias, Nidan, Nirdhan, NMFB,<br />
NRDSC, NWTF, NYWDA, OI China, OMB, OXUS - AFG, PALFSI, Parwaz, PATRA Hunchun, PATRA<br />
Yanbian, PBC, PCWDA, PGBB, Plan International, PNG Microfinance Ltd, POMFB, PR Bank,<br />
PRASAC, Progressive Bank, Pushtikar, PWMACS, RASS, RB Bagac, RB Cainta, RB Camalig, RB<br />
Cotabato, RB Digos, RB Dipolog, RB Guinobatan, RB Lebak, RB Liloy, RB Mabitac, RB Montevista,<br />
RB Oroquieta, RB Pagbilao, RB Placer, RB San Jacinto, RB Siargao, RB Solano, RB Talisayan,<br />
RCDS, RGVN, Rishenglong, R<strong>SP</strong>I, Saadhana, Sabaragamuwa, Sahara Mahila, Sajida, Samasta,<br />
Sanghamithra, Sarala, Sarvodaya Nano Finance, Sathapana Limited, SB Bank, SCNL, SDBL, SED,<br />
SEEDS, Seilanithih, Serviamus, SEWA Bank, SEWA Finance, Shakti, SHARE, Siam Bank, SKDRDP,<br />
SKS, SMILE, SMSS, Sonata, Spandana, <strong>SP</strong>BD, <strong>SP</strong>GBB, SSK, SSS, SU, Sungi, SFPL, SWAWS, TLM,<br />
TMFB, TPC, Trident Microfinance, TSKI, TYM, Ujjivan, Valiant RB, VB<strong>SP</strong>, VFC, VFS, VSSU, VYCCU,<br />
Nationwide Microbank, WDB, WKP, WOCCU - AFG, WSE, WWI - AFG, XXWDA, YYWDA<br />
217 96 106 15 1st MCC, Abzal Kredit, ACBA, AccessBank, ACF, Aetos, AFK, Aqrarkredit, Agrocredit Plus,<br />
Agroimpuls, AgroInvest, Agroinvestbank, A-invest, Aiyl Bank, Alliance Group, Alternativa, Alteya,<br />
Amlok, Aqroinvest, AREGAK UCO, Arnur Credit, ASC Union, ASR, ASTI, Avantaj, Azercredit,<br />
Azerdemiryolbank, Azeri Star, Bai Tushum, Bank Eskhata, Bank of Baku, Bereke, Bereke-credit,<br />
BESA, BFSBS, Blago, Borshud, BRCCC, BTA Bank, BZMF, CAPA, CEF, Chita FSBS, CMFinance,<br />
CredAgro NBCO, Credit Mongol, CREDO, Crystal, DAYAQ-Credit, Dirigible, DSK Dobrich, Doveriye<br />
- Volgograd, Doveriye (Amursk), Doveriye- Bulgaria, Doveriye-Altay, ECLOF - ARM, Edinstvo<br />
Yurga, Edinstvo-Volgograd, Ehyoi kuhiston, EKI, EKPA, Elet-Capital, Express Finance, Farm Credit<br />
Armenia, FFECC, FFSA, FinAgro, FINCA - ARM, FINCA - AZE, FINCA - GEO, FINCA - KOS, FINCA<br />
- Russia, FINCA - TJK, FinDev, FMCC, FMFB - TJK, FNT Credit, FORUS, FULM, Fundusz Mikro,<br />
Galaktika, Garant-Invest, General Toshevo, Gorodskoy, HOPE, Horizon, Horizonti, ImerCredit,<br />
Imkoniyat, Imodi Hutal, IMON, Impuls, INECO, Inicjatywa Mikro, Intellekt, Invest Credit, Invest-<br />
Credit Moldova, Joldosh Group, JOVID, JSC Bank Constanta, KAMURJ, Kajnardza 96, Kemek,<br />
KEP, KGMAMF, Khan Bank, KMB, KMF, Komak Credit, Kompanion, KosInvest, Kredo, KRK Ltd, KSK<br />
RPK, KVK, KVK-Altay, LAM, Lazika Capital, LIDER, LOK Microcredit Foundation, FAF-DC, Maqsadi<br />
dasgiri, Maritsa Invest, MCO ‘Oral’, MDF, MI-BO<strong>SP</strong>O, Microinvest, MIKRA, Mikro ALDI, Mikrofond,<br />
Mikrokredit Bank, MikroMaliyye Credit, Miziya, MLF Chiluchor chashma, MLF Kiropol, MLF<br />
Madina, MLF MicroInvest, MLF Vahsh Microfin, MLO HUMO, MLO ‘Saodat Invest’, Mol Bulak<br />
Finance, Moldir, Momina Voda, Moznosti, Nachala, Nadejda, Nadejda 96, Narodniy Kredit_<br />
Kemerov, Neftegaz, Normicro, Nov Credit, Obereg (Vladivostok), OBM, OBS, OMRO, Opportunity<br />
Albania, OXUS - KGS, OXUS - TJK, Parabank, Partner, Partner Russia, Perelik, Pomoriiski stopanin,<br />
Popular Kasa-Kystendil, Povoljye, PRIZMA, ProCredit - MDA, ProCredit Bank - ALB, ProCredit<br />
Bank - BGR, ProCredit Bank - BIH, ProCredit Bank - GEO, ProCredit Bank - KOS, ProCredit Bank<br />
- MDA, ProCredit Bank - MKD, ProCredit Bank - ROM, ProCredit Bank - UKR, ProCredit Bank Serbia,<br />
Raduga, Reserv-Altay, Rezerv, ROMCOM, Rost, Rus, WMN (Russia), SABR, Saglasie 96, Samokov<br />
96, SBS, SEF-ARM, SINERGIJA, Smilyan, Sodeystviye, Sodeystviye-2005, Sodruzhestvo, Soglasiye,<br />
Solidarnost, Soyuz-Khimik, SoyuzKredit, Soyuz-Primoroye, Stanichnik, Stopanin, Sugd Microfin,<br />
Sunrise, TFS, Tsaritsinskiy passaj, Tsimlyansk, Tverskoy, Umid, Umid-Credit, USFSBS, USTOI, VFM,<br />
Viator, Vostok Kapital, VRFSBS, Women for Women, XacBank<br />
333 81 180 72 ACCOVI, ACME, ACORDE, Actuar Caldas, Actuar Tolima, ADICH, ADIM, ADOPEM, ADRA - PER, ADRI,<br />
AFODENIC, Agência do Crédito, AGAPE, AgroCapital, AGUDESA, ALSOL, Alternativa 19 del Sur,<br />
Alternativa Microfinanzas, AMA, AMC de R.L., AMEXTRA, ANDE, ANED, Apoyo Económico, Apoyo<br />
Integral, APROS, ASDIR, ASEI, ASIDME, Asociación Arariwa, Asociación El Balsamo, Asociación<br />
Raíz, ASODENIC, ASOPROSANRAMON, A<strong>SP</strong> Financiera, A<strong>SP</strong>IRE, ATEMEXPA, Avanzar, AYNLA,<br />
Bancamía, Banco ADEMI, Banco Amigo, Banco da Familia, Banco do Empreendedor, Banco<br />
do Povo ACP, Rede Novo Sol, Banco do Vale, Banco Familiar, Banco Popular do Brasil, Banco<br />
Solidario, BancoEstado, BancoSol, BanCovelo, BANCRI, BANEX, BanGente, BCSC, CACMU, CAFASA,<br />
Caja Depac Poblana, Caja Popular Mexicana, CAME, CCAMETRO, CARE - CREEME, Caritas, Caritas<br />
Esteli, Casa do Microcrédito, CCC, CDRO, CEADe, CEAPE BA, CEAPE MA, CEAPE PE, CEAPE PI,<br />
Central Cresol Baser, CEPESIU, CEPRODEL, CESOL ACJ, CIDRE, CMAC Arequipa, CMAC Cusco,<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
65
BULLETIN TABLES<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
Peer Group - 2008 DATA QUALITY †<br />
SIMPLE PEER GROUPS<br />
Region: MENA<br />
(Middle East & North Africa)<br />
Scale: Small<br />
(GLP in USD, LAC < 4,000,000;<br />
Others < 2,000,000)<br />
N * ** *** PARTICIPATING INSTITUTIONS<br />
CMAC Del Santa, CMAC Huancayo, CMAC Ica, CMAC Maynas, CMAC Paita, CMAC Pisco, CMAC<br />
Piura, CMAC Sullana, CMAC Tacna, CMAC Trujillo, COAC 4 de Octubre, COAC Acción Rural, COAC<br />
Ambato, COAC Artesanos, COAC Chone, COAC Fernando Daquilema, COAC Fondvida, COAC<br />
Huaycopungo, COAC Jardín Azuayo, COAC Kullki Wasi, COAC La Benéfica, COAC Luz del Valle,<br />
COAC MCCH, COAC Minga, COAC Mushuc Runa, COAC La Nacional, COAC Padre Vicente, COAC<br />
Pallatanga, COAC Sac Aiet, COAC San Antonio, COAC San Gabriel, COAC San José, COAC Santa<br />
Ana, COAC Santa Anita, COCDEP, CODESARROLLO, Columbia Microcreditos, CompartamosBanco,<br />
Comultrasan, Conserva, Contactar, Coop 20 de Abril, Coop Avances, Coop Fátima, Coop Jesús<br />
Nazareno, Coop Juan XXIII, COOPAC Chiquinquira, COOPAC León XIII, COOPAC Los Andes,<br />
COOPAC Norandino, COOPAC San Cristóbal, COOPAC San Martín, COOPAC Santa Maria,<br />
COOPAC Santo Cristo, COOPAC Santo Domingo, COOPAC Tocache, COOPROGRESO, CRAC Los<br />
Andes, CRAC Nuestra Gente, CRAC Profinanzas, CRAC Señor de Luren, CRAC Sipán, Crece Safsa,<br />
CRECER, Credi Fé, CrediAmigo, CrediAvance, Credi-Capital, CrediClub, CrediComún, Credicoop,<br />
CREDIMUJER, Crediscotia, Credisol, Créditos Pronegocio, CREDITUYO, Cresol Central, Crezcamos,<br />
CRYSOL, Despacho Amador, Diaconia, D-Miro, Don Apoyo, ECLOF - ECU, EcoFuturo FFP,<br />
EDAPRO<strong>SP</strong>O, EDPYME Acceso Crediticio, EDPYME Alternativa, EDPYME Confianza, EDPYME Crear<br />
Arequipa, EDPYME Credivisión, EDPYME Efectiva, EDPYME Nueva Visión, EDPYME Pro Negocios,<br />
EDPYME Proempresa, EDPYME Raíz, Emprender, ENLACE, Espacios Alternativos, Crezkamos<br />
Kapital, Fácil SCM, FACES, FADEMYPE, FAFIDESS, FAMA OPDF, FAPE, Fassil FFP, FDL, FED, FIACG,<br />
FIDERPAC, FIE FFP, FIE Gran Poder, FIELCO, FinAmérica, FinAmigo, Financiera Edyficar, Financiera<br />
Fama, Financiera Independencia, FINCA - ECU, FINCA - GTM, FINCA - HND, FINCA - HTI, FINCA<br />
- MEX, FINCA - NIC, FINCA - PER, FINCA - SLV, FinComún, FINORTE, FINSOL, Emprenda, FISUR,<br />
FMM Bucaramanga, FMM Popayán, FMSD, FODEM, FODEMI, FOMIC, FONCRESOL, FONDECO,<br />
FONDESOL, FONDESURCO, Fondo Esperanza, Fonkoze, Forjadores de Negocios, Fortaleza<br />
FFP, FOVIDA, FRAC, FUBODE, FUDEMI, FUNBODEM, Fundación 4i-2000, Fundación Alternativa,<br />
Fundación Amanecer, Fundación CAMPO, Fundación Esperanza, Fundación Espoir, Fundación<br />
León 2000, Fundación MICROS, Fundación Mujer, Fundación Nieborowski, Fundación Paraguaya,<br />
FUNDAHMICRO, FUNDAMIC, FUNDEA, FUNDEBASE, FUNDECOCA, FUNDENUSE, FUNDEPYME,<br />
FUNDESER, FUNDE<strong>SP</strong>E, FUNED, FUNHAVI, FUNSALDE, FVP, Génesis Empresarial, GCM, Grameen<br />
Mendoza, Grupo Río La Venta, HDH OPDF, ICC BluSol, ICC Conquista Solidária, ICC MAUCE,<br />
IDEPRO, IDER CV, IDESI Lambayeque, IDE<strong>SP</strong>A, IDH, IMPRO, INSOTEC, Instituto Estrela, Interactuar,<br />
Interfisa Financiera, Invirtiendo, Manuela Ramos, MCN, MiBanco, MiBanco Venezuela, MicroCred<br />
- MEX, Micredito SAC, Coop MEDA, Microfinanciera Prisma, Microserfin, Microsol, MIDE, MUDE,<br />
ODEF Financiera, OLC, Oportunidad Microfinanzas, Popular SAFI, PRESTANIC, PRISMA, ProCaja,<br />
ProCredit - BOL, ProCredit - COL, ProCredit - ECU, ProCredit - HND, ProCredit - NIC, ProCredit<br />
- SLV, PRODEM FFP, PRODESA, Progresar, Progresemos, Pro Mujer - ARG, Pro Mujer - BOL, Pro<br />
Mujer - MEX, Pro Mujer - NIC, Pro Mujer - PER, Real Microcrédito, Red de Vanguardia, São Paulo<br />
Confia, Sartawi, SemiSol, SFF, SOCIALCRED, PADECOMSM, SOCRED, SOGESOL, SolFi, Solución<br />
Asea, Soluciones Reales, Mentors - PER, Te Creemos, UCADE Ambato, UCADE Guaranda, UCADE<br />
Latacunga, UCADE Santo Domingo, UNICREICH, Visión Banco, Vivir Soluciones, World Relief<br />
- HND, WWB Cali<br />
56 15 38 3 ABA, ABWA, Abyan, ACAD, Aden, Al Amana, Al Awael, Al Karama, Al Majmoua, Al Rafah Bank, Al<br />
Tadamun, Al-Thiqa, Alwatani, AMC, Ameen, AMOS, AMSSF/MC, ARDI, ASALA, ASBA, Azal, BRAC<br />
- SS, CEOSS, CHF Iraq, DBACD, DEF, Enda, ESED, FATEN, FBPMC, FINCA - JOR, FMF, FMFI-SYR,<br />
FONDEP, IDDA, INMAA, Izdiharona Microfinance, Jabal Al Hoss, Lead Foundation, Makhzoumi,<br />
MEMCO, MFW, NMF, NSBA, PARC, PASED, RADE, Reef, Ryada, SBACD, SCDA, SFSD, SUMI,<br />
Tamweelcom, UNRWA, Zakoura<br />
428 216 201 11 3A Entreprises, A3C, ABWA, Abyan, Abzal Kredit, ACB sa, ACLEDA Lao, Actuar Caldas, Aden,<br />
ADICH, ADIM, ADRA - PER, Aetos, Agência do Crédito, AGAPE, Agrocredit Plus, Agroimpuls,<br />
AGUDESA, A-invest, Al Awael, Alidé, Alliance MFB, ALSOL, Alternativa, Alternativa 19 del Sur,<br />
Alternativa Microfinanzas, Alteya, AMA, AMEXTRA, AMFI, Amlok, AMOS, APED, APROS, ARD,<br />
ASA - GHA, ASALA, ASEI, ASIDME, Asociación El Balsamo, ASOPROSANRAMON, A<strong>SP</strong>IRE, ASTI,<br />
ATEMEXPA, Avantaj, Avanzar, Azal, Banco do Povo ACP, Rede Novo Sol, Banco do Vale, Banco<br />
Santiago de Libon, BANCRI, BAYOCA, Bereke-credit, Berendina Microfinance, Bessfa RB,<br />
Binhminh CDC, BJS, Blago, BMSCCSL, BMT Kayu Manis, BMT Pringsewu, Borshud, BPR AN, BPR<br />
Aditama Arta, BPR Artadamas Mandiri, BPR BBTM, BPR CAS, BPR Citama, BPR DMG, BPR Eka<br />
Ayu, BPR Eka Usaha, BPR Hitamajaya, BPR NBP 19, BPR NBP 30, BPR Pinang Artha, BPR SAS, BPR<br />
SKA, BPR Taman Dhana, BPR Wahana Sentra Artha, BRAC - SS, BRCCC, BWDC, CACMU, CAFASA,<br />
CAFODEC, CAPPED, CARE - CREEME, Caritas Esteli, Casa do Microcrédito, CBIRD, CCC, CDM,<br />
CEADe, CEAPE BA, CEAPE PE, CEAPE PI, CEC-PROM Mature, CEDEF, CEP BRVT, CEP Long An,<br />
CEPESIU, CESOL ACJ, CEVI, CFF, Chamroeun, Childfund Hoa Binh, Chita FSBS, CHWDA, CMEDFI,<br />
CMMB, COAC 4 de Octubre, COAC Artesanos, COAC Fernando Daquilema, COAC Fondvida,<br />
COAC Huaycopungo, COAC Minga, COAC Padre Vicente, COAC Pallatanga, COAC San Antonio,<br />
COAC San Gabriel, COAC Santa Ana, COAC Santa Anita, COCDEP, Columbia Microcreditos,<br />
COOPAC Chiquinquira, COOPAC Norandino, COOPEC Hinfani Dosso, COOPEC/ACCO, CO<strong>SP</strong>EC,<br />
CPECG Yete Mali, CRAN, CrediClub, CREDIMUJER, Credisol, CREDITUYO, Crezcamos, CRG, CU<br />
Kosayu, CU Pantai Prigi, CUMO, CVECA Kita/Bafoulabé, CVECA Pays Dogon, CVECA SOUM,<br />
CWCD, CZWSDA, DAYAQ-Credit, Degaf, Dian Mandiri, DINARI, Dirigible, DJOMEC, DSK Dobrich,<br />
Don Apoyo, Doveriye - Volgograd, Doveriye- Bulgaria, Doveriye-Altay, DQF, ECLOF - ARM,<br />
ECLOF - ECU, ECLOF - PHL, EDAPRO<strong>SP</strong>O, Edinstvo-Volgograd, EDPYME Pro Negocios, Ehyoi<br />
kuhiston, Elet-Capital, Emprender, Espacios Alternativos, Fácil SCM, FACES, FADEMYPE, FAM,<br />
FAPE, Farm Credit Armenia, AfricaWorks, FDM, FIACG, FIDERPAC, FIDEVIE, FINCA - HTI, FINCA<br />
- PER, FINCA - ZMB, FINORTE, Emprenda, FISUR, FNT Credit, FOMIC, FONCRESOL,<br />
66<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
BULLETIN TABLES<br />
Peer Group - 2008 DATA QUALITY †<br />
SIMPLE PEER GROUPS<br />
Scale: Medium<br />
(GLP in USD,<br />
LAC ≥ 4,000,000 and<br />
≤ 15,000,000;<br />
Others ≥ 2,000,000 and<br />
≤ 8,000,000)<br />
N * ** *** PARTICIPATING INSTITUTIONS<br />
Forjadores de Negocios, FOVIDA, FUDEMI, Fund for Women Development - HCM, Fundación<br />
4i-2000, Fundación Alternativa, Fundación Esperanza, Fundación MICROS, Fundación Mujer,<br />
FUNDAMIC, FUNDEBASE, FUNDECOCA, FUNDEPYME, FUNDE<strong>SP</strong>E, FUNHAVI, FUNSALDE, FVP,<br />
Galaktika, Garant-Invest, Gasha, GAWFA, GCM, General Toshevo, GGEM Microfinance Services<br />
Ltd., GRAINE sarl, Grameen Mendoza, Grameen Sahara, Grupo Río La Venta, Harbu, Hekima,<br />
Hluvuku, Hope for Life, H<strong>SP</strong>FI, ICC Conquista Solidária, ICC MAUCE, ICMFB, IDDA, IDER CV,<br />
IDESI Lambayeque, IDE<strong>SP</strong>A, ID-Ghana, IDH, IDYDC, IFDP, ImerCredit, Imkoniyat, Imodi Hutal,<br />
IMPRO, Impuls, Instituto Estrela, Intellekt, Invest Credit, Invest-Credit Moldova, Izdiharona<br />
Microfinance, Jabal Al Hoss, Joldosh Group, JOVID, JSCCS, JXWDA, Kasagana-Ka, Kajnardza 96,<br />
Kemek, Komak Credit, KOPSA, KPOSB, KSF, KVK, KVK-Altay, LAPO-SLE, Letta, LSK, M7 Can Loc,<br />
M7 DB District, M7 DBP City, M7 Dong Trieu, M7 Mai Son, M7 Ninh Phuoc, M7 Uong bi, Maata-<br />
N-Tudu, Madfa SACCO, Mahashakti, Mahila, Mahuli, Makhzoumi, Manushi, Maqsadi dasgiri,<br />
Maxima, Mbinga CB, MCL, MCO ‘Oral’, MEC AFER, MEC FEPRODES, MECBAS, MEDF, MED-Net,<br />
Meklit, MGPCC DEKAWOWO, Micro Start, MicroCred - MEX, MicroCred - SEN, Micredito SAC,<br />
Microfinanciera Prisma, Microsol, MIDE, MikroMaliyye Credit, Miziya, MLF Chiluchor chashma,<br />
MLF Kiropol, MLF Madina, MLF MWI, MLF Vahsh Microfin, MLO ‘Saodat Invest’, MAMIDECOT,<br />
MMS, Moldir, Momina Voda, MUDE, MUL, Mutuelle Akwaba, Nadejda, Nadejda 96, Narodniy<br />
Kredit_Kemerov, NBJK, NCS, Neftegaz, NeRuDO, NESDO, New RB of Victorias, Nidan, NMF,<br />
NMFB, Nov Credit, NSBA, NYWDA, Obereg (Vladivostok), Faulu - TZA, OI China, OLC, OMB,<br />
Oportunidad Microfinanzas, Otiv Sambava, OXUS - KGS, PAIDEK, Partner Russia, Parwaz,<br />
PASED, PATRA Hunchun, PATRA Yanbian, PCWDA, Perelik, Plan International, PNG Microfinance<br />
Ltd, Pomoriiski stopanin, Popular Kasa-Kystendil, Povoljye, Pride Finance, ProCaja, Progresar,<br />
Progresemos, Pro Mujer - ARG, Pro Mujer - MEX, Raduga, RAFODE, RB Bagac, RB Cotabato, RB<br />
Liloy, RB Pagbilao, RB Placer, RB San Jacinto, RCCECG, RCDS, Red de Vanguardia, REDFunds,<br />
Reef, Rezerv, Riverbank, RML, R<strong>SP</strong>I, São Paulo Confia, SABR, Saglasie 96, Sahara Mahila, Samasta,<br />
Samokov 96, Sartawi, SCDA, SED, SEM Fund, SemiSol, Serviamus, SEWA Finance, SFSD, Smilyan,<br />
SOCIALCRED, PADECOMSM, SOCRED, Sodeystviye-2005, Sodruzhestvo, SOFINA, Solidarnost,<br />
Solución Asea, Soluciones Reales, Soyuz-Khimik, SoyuzKredit, Soyuz-Primoroye, <strong>SP</strong>BD, <strong>SP</strong>GBB,<br />
SSK, Stanichnik, Stopanin, Sugd Microfin, SUMI, Sungi, Mentors - PER, SFPL, TLM, Tsimlyansk,<br />
Tujijenge, Turame Community Finance, Tverskoy, UCADE Ambato, UCADE Guaranda, UCADE<br />
Latacunga, UCADE Santo Domingo, UCCEC GY, Umid, Umid-Credit, UNION DES COOPECs<br />
UMUTANGUHA, Union RB, Vivir Soluciones, Vostok Kapital, VRFSBS, VSSU, VYCCU, WISE, WKP,<br />
WSE, WWI - AFG, XXWDA, YYWDA<br />
304 82 195 27 ABCRDM, ABS-CBN, ACAD, ACF, ACFB, ACME, Actuar Tolima, Adhikar, ADRI, AFODENIC, AFS,<br />
Akuapem RB, Al Karama, Al Tadamun, Alliance Group, AMC, AMfB, AMSSF/MC, ANDE, ANED,<br />
Aqroinvest, ARDCI, Arnur Credit, ASA Philippines, Asasah, ASDIR, ASHI, Asociación Arariwa,<br />
ASODENIC, ASR, ASUSU CIIGABA, AWS, AYNLA, Azeri Star, Banco Amigo, Banco da Familia,<br />
Banco do Empreendedor, Banco Popular do Brasil, Bangko Mabuhay, BCB, BEES, Bereke,<br />
BFSBS, BG, BIMAS, BOM, Bonzali RB, BPR AK, BPR BKK Cilacap, BPR NBP 11, BPR NBP 2, BPR<br />
NSI, BPR PKT, BPR Sukawati Pancakanti, BRAC - LKA, BRAC - TZA, BRAC - UGA, BZMF, Caja<br />
Depac Poblana, CAURIE Micro Finance, CBDIBA/RENACA, CDRO, CEAPE MA, CECA, CECIC S.A.,<br />
CEF, CEOSS, CEPRODEL, CETZAM, CFA, CFE, Chandeshwori, CHC-Limited, CIDRE, CMAC Pisco,<br />
CMCA, COAC Acción Rural, COAC Ambato, COAC Chone, COAC Kullki Wasi, COAC La Benéfica,<br />
COAC Luz del Valle, COAC MCCH, COAC Sac Aiet, Conserva, Contactar, Coop 20 de Abril,<br />
Coop Avances, Coop Juan XXIII, COOPAC León XIII, COOPAC Los Andes, COOPAC Tocache,<br />
COOPEDU-Kigali, CRAC Los Andes, CRAC Sipán, Crece Safsa, CrediAvance, Credi-Capital,<br />
CrediComún, Credicoop, Credit Mongol, CReSA, CRYSOL, Crystal, CSD, CU Sawiran, DAMEN,<br />
DD Bank, DEC, DEPROSC-Nepal, Despacho Amador, Doveriye (Amursk), D<strong>SP</strong>I, Duterimbere,<br />
Edinstvo Yurga, EDPYME Acceso Crediticio, EDPYME Credivisión, ENLACE, Eshet, FAFIDESS,<br />
FAMA OPDF, Faulu - UGA, FED, FFECC, FIE Gran Poder, FinAgro, FinAmigo, FINCA - AFG, FINCA<br />
- GTM, FINCA - HND, FINCA - JOR, FINCA - MWI, FINCA - NIC, FINCA - SLV, FINCA - TJK, FINCA<br />
- TZA, FinDev, FMF, FODEM, FODEMI, FONDECO, FONDESOL, FONDESURCO, Fondo Esperanza,<br />
Fonkoze, FORWARD, FRAC, FUBODE, FULM, FUNBODEM, Fundación Amanecer, Fundación<br />
CAMPO, Fundación León 2000, Fundación Paraguaya, FUNDAHMICRO, FUNDENUSE, FUNED,<br />
GOF, Gorodskoy, HEED, HDH OPDF, HiH, Hofokam, HOPE, Horizon, Horizonti, ICC BluSol,<br />
IDEPRO, IDF, Indur MACS, INMAA, INSOTEC, Invirtiendo, IPR, Janodaya, Jigiyaso Ba, Juaben RB,<br />
JVS, KADET, Kakum RB, Kashf Bank, Kazama Grameen, KBank, KCCDFI, KGMAMF, KixiCredito,<br />
Kokari, KosInvest, Kredo, KRUSHI, KSK RPK, La Community Bank, Lak Jaya, LAM, Lazika Capital,<br />
MADRAC, Mahasemam, Mallig Plains RB, Manuela Ramos, Marang, Maritsa Invest, MBK<br />
Ventura, MCN, MDF, MECREF, MGBB, Micro Africa, MicroCred - MDG, Microserfin, Mikro ALDI,<br />
Mikrofond, Mimo Finance, Miselini, MLO HUMO, MoFAD, Mol Bulak Finance, Moris Rasik,<br />
MUSCCO, Nachala, NEED, NRDSC, Nwabiagya RB, Opportunity Finance, Opportunity Kenya,<br />
Otiv Diana, Otiv Tana, Otuasekan RB, OXUS - AFG, OXUS - TJK, PALFSI, PARC, PASECA - Kayes,<br />
PAWDEP, PEACE, PGBB, POMFB, Popular SAFI, PRISMA, ProCredit Bank - SLE, Progressive<br />
Bank, Pro Mujer - NIC, Pro Mujer - PER, PWMACS, RADE, RB Cainta, RB Camalig, RB Digos, RB<br />
Guinobatan, RB Lebak, RB Mabitac, RB Montevista, RB Oroquieta, RB Siargao, RB Solano, RB<br />
Talisayan, Reliance, Reserv-Altay, RGVN, Rishenglong, ROMCOM, Rost, Rus, Sarala, SB Bank,<br />
SBACD, SBS, SEAP, SEDA, SEF-ARM, Seilanithih, SEWA Bank, SFF, SFPI, Siam Bank, SIPEM, SMSS,<br />
Sodeystviye, SOGESOL, Soglasiye, SolFi, Sonata, Soro Yiriwaso, South Akim RB, SU, Tchuma,<br />
Te Creemos, TFS, TIAVO, Tsaritsinskiy passaj, UCEC/MK, U-IMCEC, UMECDES, UNICREICH, UOB,<br />
Upper Manya RB, USTOI, VFM, VFS, Viator, Vital Finance, Wasasa, Nationwide Microbank,<br />
WOCCU - AFG, World Relief - HND<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
67
BULLETIN TABLES<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
Peer Group - 2008 DATA QUALITY †<br />
SIMPLE PEER GROUPS<br />
Scale: Large<br />
(GLP in USD, LAC<br />
> 15,000,000;<br />
Others > 8,000,000)<br />
Sustainability: FSS<br />
(Financial Self-Sufficiency<br />
> 100%))<br />
Sustainability: Non-FSS<br />
(Financial Self-Sufficiency<br />
< 100%))<br />
Target Market: Low End<br />
(Avg. Balance per Borrower/GNI<br />
per Capita < 20% and Avg.<br />
Balance per Borrower<br />
< USD 150)<br />
N * ** *** PARTICIPATING INSTITUTIONS<br />
351 47 240 64 1st MCC, 1st Valley Bank, ABA, ACBA, AccessBank, ACCOVI, ACEP Cameroon, ACEP Senegal,<br />
ACLEDA, ACORDE, ACSI, ADCSI, ADOPEM, AFK, Aqrarkredit, AgroCapital, AgroInvest,<br />
Agroinvestbank, Aiyl Bank, Akiba, Al Amana, Al Majmoua, Al Rafah Bank, Al-Thiqa, Alwatani,<br />
AMC de R.L., Ameen, AMK, AML, AMMACTS, AMRET, Apoyo Económico, Apoyo Integral, ARDI,<br />
AREGAK UCO, ARMP, Arohan, ASA, ASBA, ASC Union, ASKI, Asociación Raíz, A<strong>SP</strong> Financiera,<br />
Atwima Kwanwoma, Azercredit, Azerdemiryolbank, Bai Tushum, Bancamía, Banco ADEMI,<br />
Banco Familiar, Banco Solidario, BancoEstado, BancoSol, BanCovelo, Bandhan, BANEX, BanGente,<br />
Bangko Kabayan, Bangko Luzon, Bank Eskhata, Bank of Baku, BASIX, BCSC, BESA, BFL, BISWA,<br />
BPR Surya Yudha Kencana, BRAC, BRAC - AFG, BSS, BTA Bank, BURO Bangladesh, Caja Popular<br />
Mexicana, CamCCUL, CAME, CCAMETRO, Cantilan Bank, CAPA, Capitec Bank, CARD Bank, CARD<br />
NGO, Caritas, Cashpor MC, CBB, CBMO, CCA, CDS, Centenary Bank, Central Cresol Baser, CEP, CFPA,<br />
CHF Iraq, CMAC Arequipa, CMAC Cusco, CMAC Del Santa, CMAC Huancayo, CMAC Ica, CMAC<br />
Maynas, CMAC Paita, CMAC Piura, CMAC Sullana, CMAC Tacna, CMAC Trujillo, CMFinance, CMS,<br />
COAC Jardín Azuayo, COAC Mushuc Runa, COAC La Nacional, COAC San José, CODESARROLLO,<br />
CompartamosBanco, Comultrasan, Coop Fátima, Coop Jesús Nazareno, COOPAC San Cristóbal,<br />
COOPAC San Martín, COOPAC Santa Maria, COOPAC Santo Cristo, COOPAC Santo Domingo,<br />
COOPROGRESO, CRAC Nuestra Gente, CRAC Profinanzas, CRAC Señor de Luren, CRECER,<br />
CredAgro NBCO, Credi Fé, CrediAmigo, Crediscotia, CREDIT, Créditos Pronegocio, CREDO,<br />
Cresol Central, DBACD, DECSI, DEF, Diaconia, D-Miro, EcoFuturo FFP, EDPYME Alternativa,<br />
EDPYME Confianza, EDPYME Crear Arequipa, EDPYME Efectiva, EDPYME Nueva Visión, EDPYME<br />
Proempresa, EDPYME Raíz, EKI, EKPA, Enda, Equitas, Equity Bank, ESAF, ESED, Crezkamos<br />
Kapital, Express Finance, FAIR Bank, FASL, Fassil FFP, FATEN, Faulu - KEN, FBPMC, FDL, FECECAM,<br />
FFSA, FICO, FIE FFP, FIELCO, FinAmérica, Financiera Edyficar, Financiera Fama, Financiera<br />
Independencia, FINCA - ARM, FINCA - AZE, FINCA - DRC, FINCA - ECU, FINCA - GEO, FINCA - KOS,<br />
FINCA - MEX, FINCA - Russia, FINCA - UGA, FinComún, FINCORP, FINSOL, First Macro Bank, FMCC,<br />
FMFB - AFG, FMFB - Pakistan, FMFB - TJK, FMFI-SYR, FMM Bucaramanga, FMM Popayán, FMSD,<br />
FONDEP, Fortaleza FFP, FORUS, FUCEC Togo, Fundación Espoir, Fundación Nieborowski, FUNDEA,<br />
FUNDESER, Fundusz Mikro, Génesis Empresarial, GBNB, GF<strong>SP</strong>L, GM Bank, Grameen Bank, Green<br />
Bank, GU, GV, HKL, IMFB, IMON, INECO, Inicjatywa Mikro, Interactuar, Interfisa Financiera, Jamii<br />
Bora, JCF, JSC Bank Constanta, Kafo Jiginew, KAMURJ, Kashf Foundation, KBSLAB, KEP, Khan Bank,<br />
Khushhali Bank, KMB, KMBI, KMF, Kompanion, Kondo Jigima, K-Rep, KRK Ltd, KWFT, LAPO-NGR,<br />
Lead Foundation, LIDER, Life Bank, LOK Microcredit Foundation, FAF-DC, MC², MEMCO, MFI,<br />
MFW, MiBanco, MiBanco Venezuela, MI-BO<strong>SP</strong>O, Coop MEDA, Microinvest, MIKRA, Mikrokredit<br />
Bank, MLF MicroInvest, Moznosti, MPGBB, Nirdhan, Normicro, NovoBanco - MOZ, NWTF,<br />
Nyesigiso, OBM, OBS, OCSSCO, ODEF Financiera, OIBM, OISL, OMRO, Opportunity Albania, Otiv<br />
Alaotra, PADME, PAMECAS, PAPME, Parabank, Partner, PBC, PR Bank, PRASAC, PRESTANIC, PRIDE<br />
- TZA, PRIZMA, ProCredit - BOL, ProCredit - COL, ProCredit - ECU, ProCredit - GHA, ProCredit<br />
- HND, ProCredit - MDA, ProCredit - NIC, ProCredit - SLV, ProCredit Bank - ALB, ProCredit Bank<br />
- BGR, ProCredit Bank - BIH, ProCredit Bank - GEO, ProCredit Bank - KOS, ProCredit Bank - MDA,<br />
ProCredit Bank - MKD, ProCredit Bank - ROM, ProCredit Bank - UKR, ProCredit Bank- DRC,<br />
ProCredit Bank Serbia, PRODEM FFP, PRODESA, Pro Mujer - BOL, Pushtikar, RASS, RB Dipolog,<br />
RCPB, Real Microcrédito, WMN (Russia), Ryada, Saadhana, Sabaragamuwa, Sajida, Sanghamithra,<br />
Sarvodaya Nano Finance, SAT, Sathapana Limited, SCNL, SDBL, SEEDS, SEF-ZAF, Shakti, SHARE,<br />
SINERGIJA, SKDRDP, SKS, SMEP, SMILE, Spandana, SSS, Sunrise, SWAWS, Tamweelcom, TMFB, TPC,<br />
Trident Microfinance, TSKI, TYM, Ujjivan, UNACOOPEC-CI, UNRWA, USFSBS, Finance Trust, Valiant<br />
RB, VB<strong>SP</strong>, VFC, Visión Banco, WAGES, WDB, Wisdom, Women for Women, WWB Cali, XacBank,<br />
Zakoura<br />
557 123 347 87 [These names are held confidential]<br />
354 130 2<strong>09</strong> 15 [These names are held confidential]<br />
425 155 252 18 A3C, ABA, ABCRDM, ABS-CBN, ABWA, Abyan, Actuar Tolima, Aden, Adhikar, ADIM, ADOPEM, ADRA<br />
- PER, Agência do Crédito, AGAPE, AGUDESA, Al Awael, Al Karama, Al Majmoua, Al Tadamun,<br />
ALSOL, Alternativa 19 del Sur, Alternativa Microfinanzas, Alteya, AMA, Ameen, AMEXTRA, AMK,<br />
AML, AMMACTS, AMOS, AMSSF/MC, ANDE, APED, Apoyo Económico, APROS, ARD, ARDCI, ARDI,<br />
Arohan, ASA, ASA - GHA, ASA Philippines, Asasah, ASBA, ASEI, ASHI, ASIDME, ASKI, Asociación<br />
Arariwa, Asociación El Balsamo, ASODENIC, A<strong>SP</strong> Financiera, A<strong>SP</strong>IRE, ASUSU CIIGABA, ATEMEXPA,<br />
Avantaj, Avanzar, AWS, Azal, Azeri Star, Banco Amigo, Banco da Familia, Rede Novo Sol, Banco<br />
Popular do Brasil, Banco Santiago de Libon, Bandhan, BASIX, BAYOCA, BEES, Bereke, Berendina<br />
Microfinance, Bessfa RB, BFL, BG, Binhminh CDC, BISWA, BJS, Blago, BMT Pringsewu, BPR CAS,<br />
BPR NBP 11, BPR NSI, BPR SKA, BPR Wahana Sentra Artha, BRAC, BRAC - LKA, BRAC - SS, BRAC<br />
- TZA, BRAC - UGA, BSS, BURO Bangladesh, BWDC, CAFASA, CAFODEC, Caja Depac Poblana, Caja<br />
Popular Mexicana, CAME, Capitec Bank, CARD Bank, CARD NGO, Caritas, Cashpor MC, CBB, CDM,<br />
CEAPE BA, CEAPE MA, CEAPE PE, CEAPE PI, CEDEF, CEOSS, CEP BRVT, CEP Long An, CEPESIU,<br />
CESOL ACJ, CEVI, CFF, Chamroeun, Childfund Hoa Binh, CHWDA, CMEDFI, CMFinance, COCDEP,<br />
Columbia Microcreditos, CompartamosBanco, Conserva, Contactar, COOPAC Norandino,<br />
COOPEC/ACCO, Crece Safsa, CrediAmigo, CrediAvance, Credi-Capital, CrediClub, CrediComún,<br />
Credicoop, CREDIMUJER, Créditos Pronegocio, CREDITUYO, CReSA, Crezcamos, CRYSOL, CSD,<br />
CUMO, CVECA Pays Dogon, CZWSDA, DAMEN, DAYAQ-Credit, DBACD, DEC, Degaf, Despacho<br />
Amador, Dian Mandiri, DINARI, Don Apoyo, Doveriye-Altay, DQF, D<strong>SP</strong>I, EDAPRO<strong>SP</strong>O, Edinstvo<br />
Yurga, EDPYME Credivisión, EDPYME Efectiva, Enda, ENLACE, Equitas,<br />
68<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
BULLETIN TABLES<br />
Peer Group - 2008 DATA QUALITY †<br />
SIMPLE PEER GROUPS<br />
Target Market: Broad<br />
(Avg. Balance per Borrower/GNI<br />
per Capita ≥ 20% and ≤ 150%)<br />
N * ** *** PARTICIPATING INSTITUTIONS<br />
ESAF, ESED, Eshet, Espacios Alternativos, FAPE, FIACG, FIDERPAC, FIDEVIE, FinAmigo, Financiera<br />
Independencia, FINCA - AFG, FINCA - ECU, FINCA - GTM, FINCA - HND, FINCA - HTI, FINCA - JOR,<br />
FINCA - MEX, FINCA - MWI, FINCA - PER, FINCA - SLV, FINCA - TZA, FINCA - ZMB, FinComún,<br />
FINORTE, Emprenda, FISUR, FMF, FMFB - Pakistan, FMM Bucaramanga, FMM Popayán, FMSD,<br />
FODEMI, FONDESOL, Fondo Esperanza, Forjadores de Negocios, FORWARD, FRAC, Fundación<br />
Esperanza, Fundación Espoir, Fundación MICROS, Fundación Mujer, Fundación Paraguaya,<br />
FUNDAMIC, FUNDECOCA, FUNDE<strong>SP</strong>E, FUNHAVI, FUNSALDE, FVP, Galaktika, GAWFA, GCM,<br />
GGEM Microfinance Services Ltd., GF<strong>SP</strong>L, GOF, GRAINE sarl, Grameen Bank, Grameen Mendoza,<br />
Grameen Sahara, Grupo Río La Venta, GU, GV, Harbu, HEED, Hekima, HiH, Hope for Life, H<strong>SP</strong>FI, ICC<br />
Conquista Solidária, ICC MAUCE, IDDA, IDER CV, IDESI Lambayeque, IDE<strong>SP</strong>A, IDF, ID-Ghana, IDH,<br />
IDYDC, Impuls, Indur MACS, INMAA, Instituto Estrela, Invest-Credit Moldova, Invirtiendo, Jabal Al<br />
Hoss, Jamii Bora, Janodaya, JCF, JVS, JXWDA, Kasagana-Ka, Kashf Foundation, Kazama Grameen,<br />
KBank, KCCDFI, Khushhali Bank, KMBI, Kokari, KOPSA, KRUSHI, KSF, KVK-Altay, Lak Jaya, LAPO-<br />
NGR, LAPO-SLE, Lead Foundation, Life Bank, M7 Can Loc, M7 DB District, M7 DBP City, M7 Dong<br />
Trieu, M7 Mai Son, M7 Ninh Phuoc, M7 Uong bi, Maata-N-Tudu, Madfa SACCO, Mahasemam,<br />
Mahuli, Makhzoumi, Mallig Plains RB, Manuela Ramos, Manushi, Marang, Mbinga CB, MBK<br />
Ventura, MECBAS, MEDF, Meklit, MFI, MFW, MGBB, Micro Start, MicroCred - MEX, Micredito SAC,<br />
Coop MEDA, Microserfin, MIDE, MikroMaliyye Credit, Mimo Finance, MLF MWI, MMS, Moris<br />
Rasik, MUDE, MUSCCO, Nadejda, Narodniy Kredit_Kemerov, NBJK, NCS, NEED, Neftegaz, NESDO,<br />
Nidan, NMF, NRDSC, NSBA, NWTF, NYWDA, OLC, OMB, Oportunidad Microfinanzas, Opportunity<br />
Finance, PAIDEK, PALFSI, Partner Russia, PATRA Yanbian, PAWDEP, PBC, PCWDA, Plan International,<br />
Povoljye, PRISMA, ProCaja, Progresar, Progresemos, Progressive Bank, Pro Mujer - ARG, Pro<br />
Mujer - MEX, Pro Mujer - NIC, Pro Mujer - PER, PWMACS, RADE, RAFODE, RB Liloy, RB Montevista,<br />
RB Placer, RB Talisayan, Real Microcrédito, Red de Vanguardia, Reserv-Altay, Rezerv, RGVN,<br />
Riverbank, R<strong>SP</strong>I, São Paulo Confia, Saadhana, Sabaragamuwa, Sajida, Samasta, Sanghamithra,<br />
Sarala, Sarvodaya Nano Finance, SB Bank, SBACD, SEAP, SED, SEEDS, SEF-ZAF, SEM Fund, SemiSol,<br />
Serviamus, SEWA Finance, SFPI, Shakti, SHARE, SKDRDP, SKS, SMILE, SMSS, SolFi, Solución Asea,<br />
Soluciones Reales, Sonata, Soro Yiriwaso, Soyuz-Khimik, SoyuzKredit, Spandana, <strong>SP</strong>BD, SSK,<br />
Stanichnik, SU, SUMI, Sungi, Mentors - PER, SFPL, SWAWS, Tamweelcom, Te Creemos, Trident<br />
Microfinance, TSKI, Tujijenge, Turame Community Finance, UCADE Ambato, UCADE Guaranda,<br />
UCADE Latacunga, UCADE Santo Domingo, UCCEC GY, Ujjivan, Umid-Credit, UNICREICH, UOB,<br />
VFS, Viator, Vivir Soluciones, VSSU, Wasasa, Wisdom, WISE, WKP, WSE, XXWDA, YYWDA, Zakoura<br />
498 145 284 69 1st MCC, 1st Valley Bank, ACAD, ACBA, AccessBank, ACF, ACFB, ACME, ACSI, Actuar Caldas,<br />
ADCSI, ADICH, Aetos, AFS, AgroCapital, Agrocredit Plus, Agroimpuls, AgroInvest, A-invest, Al<br />
Amana, Alidé, Alliance MFB, Alternativa, Al-Thiqa, Alwatani, AMC, AMC de R.L., AMfB, AMFI,<br />
AMRET, ANED, Apoyo Integral, Aqroinvest, AREGAK UCO, Arnur Credit, ASALA, ASC Union,<br />
ASDIR, Asociación Raíz, ASOPROSANRAMON, ASTI, Atwima Kwanwoma, AYNLA, Azercredit,<br />
Bancamía, Banco ADEMI, Banco do Empreendedor, Banco do Vale, Banco Familiar, Banco<br />
Solidario, BancoEstado, BANCRI, BanGente, Bangko Kabayan, Bangko Luzon, Bangko Mabuhay,<br />
Bank of Baku, BCB, BCSC, BESA, BFSBS, BIMAS, BMSCCSL, BOM, Bonzali RB, Borshud, BPR AN,<br />
BPR Aditama Arta, BPR AK, BPR Artadamas Mandiri, BPR BBTM, BPR DMG, BPR Eka Ayu, BPR<br />
Eka Usaha, BPR Hitamajaya, BPR NBP 19, BPR NBP 2, BPR NBP 30, BPR Pinang Artha, BPR SAS,<br />
BPR Sukawati Pancakanti, BPR Surya Yudha Kencana, BPR Taman Dhana, BRAC - AFG, BRCCC,<br />
CACMU, CCAMETRO, Cantilan Bank, CAPA, CAPPED, CARE - CREEME, Caritas Esteli, Casa do<br />
Microcrédito, CAURIE Micro Finance, CBDIBA/RENACA, CBIRD, CBMO, CCA, CCC, CDRO, CDS,<br />
CEADe, CEF, Central Cresol Baser, CEP, CEPRODEL, CETZAM, CFA, CFPA, CHC-Limited, CHF<br />
Iraq, Chita FSBS, CMAC Arequipa, CMAC Cusco, CMAC Del Santa, CMAC Huancayo, CMAC<br />
Ica, CMAC Maynas, CMAC Paita, CMAC Pisco, CMAC Piura, CMAC Sullana, CMAC Tacna, CMAC<br />
Trujillo, CMMB, COAC 4 de Octubre, COAC Acción Rural, COAC Ambato, COAC Artesanos,<br />
COAC Chone, COAC Fernando Daquilema, COAC Fondvida, COAC Huaycopungo, COAC Jardín<br />
Azuayo, COAC Kullki Wasi, COAC La Benéfica, COAC Luz del Valle, COAC MCCH, COAC Minga,<br />
COAC Mushuc Runa, COAC La Nacional, COAC Padre Vicente, COAC Pallatanga, COAC Sac Aiet,<br />
COAC San Antonio, COAC San Gabriel, COAC San José, COAC Santa Ana, COAC Santa Anita,<br />
CODESARROLLO, Comultrasan, Coop 20 de Abril, Coop Juan XXIII, COOPAC Chiquinquira,<br />
COOPAC León XIII, COOPAC Los Andes, COOPAC San Cristóbal, COOPAC San Martín, COOPAC<br />
Santa Maria, COOPAC Santo Cristo, COOPAC Santo Domingo, COOPAC Tocache, COOPROGRESO,<br />
CPECG Yete Mali, CRAC Los Andes, CRAC Nuestra Gente, CRAC Profinanzas, CRAC Señor de Luren,<br />
CRAC Sipán, CRAN, CRECER, CredAgro NBCO, Credi Fé, Crediscotia, Credisol, CREDIT, CREDO,<br />
Cresol Central, CRG, Crystal, CU Kosayu, CU Pantai Prigi, CU Sawiran, CVECA Kita/Bafoulabé,<br />
CVECA SOUM, CWCD, DD Bank, DEF, DEPROSC-Nepal, Diaconia, DJOMEC, D-Miro, Doveriye<br />
- Volgograd, Doveriye (Amursk), Doveriye- Bulgaria, Duterimbere, ECLOF - ARM, ECLOF<br />
- ECU, ECLOF - PHL, EcoFuturo FFP, Edinstvo-Volgograd, EDPYME Acceso Crediticio, EDPYME<br />
Alternativa, EDPYME Confianza, EDPYME Crear Arequipa, EDPYME Nueva Visión, EDPYME<br />
Pro Negocios, EDPYME Proempresa, EDPYME Raíz, Ehyoi kuhiston, EKI, EKPA, Elet-Capital,<br />
Emprender, Crezkamos Kapital, Express Finance, Fácil SCM, FACES, FADEMYPE, FAFIDESS, FAIR<br />
Bank, FAMA OPDF, Faulu - KEN, Faulu - UGA, FBPMC, AfricaWorks, FDL, FDM, FED, FFECC, FFSA,<br />
FICO, FIE Gran Poder, FIELCO, FinAmérica, Financiera Edyficar, Financiera Fama, FINCA - ARM,<br />
FINCA - AZE, FINCA - GEO, FINCA - KOS, FINCA - NIC, FINCA - Russia, FINCA - TJK, FINCA - UGA,<br />
FinDev, FINSOL, First Macro Bank, FMCC, FMFI-SYR, FODEM, FOMIC, FONCRESOL, FONDECO,<br />
FONDEP, FONDESURCO, Fonkoze, FORUS, FOVIDA, FUBODE, FUDEMI, FULM, FUNBODEM,<br />
Fund for Women Development - HCM, Fundación 4i-2000, Fundación Alternativa, Fundación<br />
Amanecer, Fundación CAMPO, Fundación León 2000, Fundación Nieborowski, FUNDAHMICRO,<br />
FUNDEA, FUNDEBASE, FUNDENUSE, FUNDEPYME, FUNDESER, Fundusz Mikro, FUNED, Génesis<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
69
BULLETIN TABLES<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
Peer Group - 2008 DATA QUALITY †<br />
SIMPLE PEER GROUPS<br />
Target Market: High End<br />
(Avg. Balance per Borrower/GNI<br />
per Capita > 150% and ≤ 250%)<br />
Target Market: Small Business<br />
(Avg. Balance per Borrower/GNI<br />
per Capita > 250%)<br />
COMPOUND PEER GROUPS<br />
Africa Large FSS<br />
(Africa; GLP > $8,000,000;<br />
Financial Self-Sufficiency<br />
> 100%)<br />
Africa Large Non FSS<br />
(Africa; GLP > $8,000,000;<br />
Financial Self-Sufficiency<br />
< 100%)<br />
Africa Medium FSS<br />
(Africa; GLP ≥ $2,000,000 and<br />
≤ $8,000,000; Financial Self-<br />
Sufficiency > 100%)<br />
Africa Medium Non FSS<br />
(Africa; GLP ≥ $2,000,000 and<br />
≤ $8,000,000; Financial Self-<br />
Sufficiency < 100%)<br />
Africa Small FSS<br />
(Africa; GLP < $2,000,000;<br />
Financial Self-Sufficiency<br />
> 100%)<br />
N * ** *** PARTICIPATING INSTITUTIONS<br />
Empresarial, Garant-Invest, GBNB, GM Bank, Gorodskoy, Green Bank, HDH OPDF, HKL, Hluvuku,<br />
Hofokam, HOPE, Horizon, Horizonti, ICC BluSol, ICMFB, IFDP, ImerCredit, IMFB, Imkoniyat,<br />
Imodi Hutal, IMPRO, INECO, Inicjatywa Mikro, INSOTEC, Interactuar, Interfisa Financiera,<br />
Invest Credit, Izdiharona Microfinance, Jigiyaso Ba, JSC Bank Constanta, Juaben RB, KADET,<br />
Kafo Jiginew, Kakum RB, KAMURJ, Kashf Bank, Kajnardza 96, KBSLAB, Kemek, KGMAMF, Khan<br />
Bank, KixiCredito, KMF, Komak Credit, Kompanion, Kondo Jigima, KosInvest, KVK, KWFT, La<br />
Community Bank, LAM, Lazika Capital, LIDER, LOK Microcredit Foundation, LSK, MADRAC,<br />
FAF-DC, Maqsadi dasgiri, Maritsa Invest, MC², MCL, MCO ‘Oral’, MDF, MEC AFER, MEC FEPRODES,<br />
MED-Net, MEMCO, MiBanco, MiBanco Venezuela, MI-BO<strong>SP</strong>O, MicroCred - SEN, Microfinanciera<br />
Prisma, Microsol, MIKRA, Mikro ALDI, Mikrofond, Miselini, Miziya, MLF Kiropol, MLF Madina,<br />
MLF MicroInvest, MLF Vahsh Microfin, MLO HUMO, MLO ‘Saodat Invest’, MAMIDECOT,<br />
MoFAD, Mol Bulak Finance, Moldir, Momina Voda, Mutuelle Akwaba, Nachala, Nadejda 96,<br />
NeRuDO, New RB of Victorias, Nirdhan, NMFB, Normicro, Nov Credit, Nwabiagya RB, Obereg<br />
(Vladivostok), OBM, OCSSCO, ODEF Financiera, Faulu - TZA, OISL, OMRO, Opportunity Albania,<br />
Opportunity Kenya, Otiv Sambava, Otiv Tana, Otuasekan RB, OXUS - AFG, OXUS - KGS,<br />
PADME, PAMECAS, PARC, Partner, Parwaz, PASECA - Kayes, PASED, PATRA Hunchun, PEACE,<br />
Perelik, PGBB, PNG Microfinance Ltd, Pomoriiski stopanin, Popular Kasa-Kystendil, PRASAC,<br />
PRESTANIC, PRIDE - TZA, Pride Finance, PRIZMA, ProCredit - COL, ProCredit - ECU, ProCredit<br />
- HND, ProCredit - SLV, ProCredit Bank - BIH, ProCredit Bank - ROM, ProCredit Bank Serbia,<br />
PRODESA, Pro Mujer - BOL, Raduga, RASS, RB Camalig, RB Cotabato, RB Digos, RB Lebak, RB<br />
Mabitac, RB Oroquieta, RB Pagbilao, RB Siargao, RCCECG, REDFunds, Rost, Rus, WMN (Russia),<br />
SABR, Saglasie 96, Sahara Mahila, Samokov 96, Sartawi, SAT, SBS, SCDA, SCNL, SDBL, SEDA, SEF-<br />
ARM, Seilanithih, SEWA Bank, SFF, SFSD, Siam Bank, SINERGIJA, SMEP, Smilyan, SOCIALCRED,<br />
PADECOMSM, SOCRED, Sodeystviye, Sodeystviye-2005, Sodruzhestvo, SOFINA, Soglasiye,<br />
Solidarnost, South Akim RB, Soyuz-Primoroye, <strong>SP</strong>GBB, SSS, Stopanin, Sugd Microfin, Sunrise,<br />
Tchuma, TFS, TIAVO, TMFB, TPC, Tsimlyansk, Tverskoy, TYM, UCEC/MK, U-IMCEC, UNACOOPEC-<br />
CI, UNRWA, Upper Manya RB, USTOI, Valiant RB, VB<strong>SP</strong>, VFC, VFM, Vostok Kapital, VRFSBS, VYCCU,<br />
Nationwide Microbank, WDB, Women for Women, World Relief - HND, WWB Cali, WWI - AFG,<br />
XacBank<br />
78 22 47 9 Abzal Kredit, ACB sa, ACCOVI, ACEP Cameroon, ACEP Senegal, AFK, AFODENIC, Alliance<br />
Group, Amlok, ARMP, Azerdemiryolbank, BancoSol, BanCovelo, BPR PKT, BZMF, CamCCUL,<br />
CIDRE, CMS, Coop Avances, Credit Mongol, DECSI, DSK Dobrich, Equity Bank, FAM, FASL,<br />
Fassil FFP, FATEN, FECECAM, FIE FFP, FinAgro, FINCA - DRC, FINCORP, Gasha, General Toshevo,<br />
IDEPRO, IMON, Intellekt, IPR, JOVID, KEP, Kredo, K-Rep, KRK Ltd, MCN, MECREF, Micro Africa,<br />
MLF Chiluchor chashma, Moznosti, MPGBB, Nyesigiso, OBS, OI China, Otiv Alaotra, Otiv Diana,<br />
OXUS - TJK, PAPME, Popular SAFI, PR Bank, ProCredit - BOL, ProCredit - GHA, ProCredit - MDA,<br />
ProCredit - NIC, ProCredit Bank - ALB, ProCredit Bank - BGR, ProCredit Bank - GEO, ProCredit<br />
Bank - MKD, PRODEM FFP, Pushtikar, Reef, Ryada, Sathapana Limited, SOGESOL, Tsaritsinskiy<br />
passaj, UNION DES COOPECs UMUTANGUHA, Finance Trust, Visión Banco, Vital Finance,<br />
WOCCU - AFG<br />
64 16 44 4 3A Entreprises, ACLEDA, ACORDE, ADRI, Aqrarkredit, Agroinvestbank, Aiyl Bank, Akiba,<br />
Akuapem RB, Al Rafah Bank, ASR, Bai Tushum, BANEX, Bank Eskhata, Bereke-credit, BTA Bank,<br />
CECA, CECIC S.A., CEC-PROM Mature, Centenary Bank, CFE, Chandeshwori, CMCA, Coop Fátima,<br />
Coop Jesús Nazareno, COOPEC Hinfani Dosso, COOPEDU-Kigali, CO<strong>SP</strong>EC, Dirigible, Farm Credit<br />
Armenia, FMFB - AFG, FMFB - TJK, FNT Credit, Fortaleza FFP, FUCEC Togo, Joldosh Group, KMB,<br />
KSK RPK, Letta, MGPCC DEKAWOWO, MicroCred - MDG, Microinvest, Mikrokredit Bank, MUL,<br />
NovoBanco - MOZ, OIBM, Parabank, ProCredit Bank - KOS, ProCredit Bank - MDA, ProCredit<br />
Bank - SLE, ProCredit Bank - UKR, ProCredit Bank- DRC, RB Cainta, RCPB, Reliance, Rishenglong,<br />
RML, ROMCOM, SIPEM, UMECDES, Umid, Union RB, USFSBS, WAGES<br />
26 5 20 1 [These names are held confidential]<br />
19 6 13 0 [These names are held confidential]<br />
20 4 16 0 [These names are held confidential]<br />
29 8 19 2 [These names are held confidential]<br />
16 5 11 0 [These names are held confidential]<br />
70<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
BULLETIN TABLES<br />
Peer Group - 2008 DATA QUALITY †<br />
SIMPLE PEER GROUPS<br />
Africa Small Non FSS<br />
(Africa; GLP < $2,000,000;<br />
Financial Self-Sufficiency<br />
< 100%)<br />
Asia Large FSS<br />
(Asia; GLP > $8,000,000;<br />
Financial Self-Sufficiency<br />
> 100%)<br />
Asia Large Non FSS<br />
(Asia; GLP > $8,000,000;<br />
Financial Self-Sufficiency<br />
< 100%)<br />
Asia Medium FSS<br />
(Asia; GLP ≥ $2,000,000 and<br />
$8,000,000; Financial Self-<br />
Sufficiency > 100%)<br />
Asia Medium Non FSS<br />
(Asia; GLP ≥ $2,000,000 and<br />
$8,000,000; Financial Self-<br />
Sufficiency < 100%)<br />
N * ** *** PARTICIPATING INSTITUTIONS<br />
34 10 24 0 [These names are held confidential]<br />
58 6 47 5 [These names are held confidential]<br />
39 7 12 20 [These names are held confidential]<br />
45 8 35 2 [These names are held confidential]<br />
50 10 15 25 [These names are held confidential]<br />
Asia Small FSS<br />
(Asia; GLP < $2,000,000;<br />
Financial Self-Sufficiency ><br />
100%)<br />
Asia Small Non FSS<br />
(Asia; GLP < $2,000,000;<br />
Financial Self-Sufficiency<br />
< 100%)<br />
ECA Large FSS<br />
(ECA; GLP > $8,000,000;<br />
Financial Self-Sufficiency<br />
>100%)<br />
ECA Large Non FSS<br />
(ECA; GLP > $8,000,000;<br />
Financial Self-Sufficiency<br />
100%)<br />
ECA Medium Non FSS<br />
(ECA; GLP ≥ $2,000,000 and<br />
≤ $8,000,000; Financial Self-<br />
Sufficiency < 100%)<br />
ECA Small FSS<br />
(ECA; GLP < $2,000,000;<br />
Financial Self-Sufficiency<br />
>100%)<br />
ECA Small Non FSS<br />
(ECA; GLP < $2,000,000;<br />
Financial Self-Sufficiency<br />
$15,000,000;<br />
Financial Self-Sufficiency<br />
> 100%)<br />
LAC Large Non FSS<br />
(LAC; GLP > $15,000,000;<br />
Financial Self-Sufficiency<br />
100%)<br />
LAC Medium Non FSS<br />
(LAC; GLP ≥ $4,000,000 and<br />
≤ $15,000,000; Financial Self-<br />
Sufficiency < 100%)<br />
22 6 15 1 [These names are held confidential]<br />
42 8 13 21 [These names are held confidential]<br />
52 3 44 5 [These names are held confidential]<br />
25 0 23 2 [These names are held confidential]<br />
23 6 13 4 [These names are held confidential]<br />
24 9 13 2 [These names are held confidential]<br />
40 34 4 2 [These names are held confidential]<br />
35 29 6 0 [These names are held confidential]<br />
88 5 41 42 [These names are held confidential]<br />
20 3 12 5 [These names are held confidential]<br />
64 11 38 15 [These names are held confidential]<br />
26 9 15 2 [These names are held confidential]<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
71
BULLETIN TABLES<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
Peer Group - 2008 DATA QUALITY †<br />
SIMPLE PEER GROUPS<br />
LAC Small FSS<br />
(LAC; GLP < $4,000,000;<br />
Financial Self-Sufficiency<br />
>100%)<br />
LAC Small Non FSS<br />
(LAC; GLP < $4,000,000;<br />
Financial Self-Sufficiency<br />
$8,000,000)<br />
MENA Large Non FSS<br />
(MENA; GLP < $2,000,000)<br />
MENA Medium FSS<br />
(MENA; GLP ≥ $2,000,000 and ≤<br />
$8,000,000)<br />
MENA Medium Non FSS<br />
(Africa; GLP > $8,000,000;<br />
Financial Self-Sufficiency<br />
>100%)<br />
MENA Small FSS<br />
(MENA; GLP < $2,000,000)<br />
MENA Small Non FSS<br />
(Africa; GLP > $8,000,000;<br />
Financial Self-Sufficiency<br />
APPENDICES<br />
Appendix I: Notes, Adjustments<br />
and Statistical <strong>Is</strong>sues<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, <strong>Dec</strong>ember 20<strong>09</strong><br />
The MicroBanking Bulletin is open to all MF<strong>Is</strong> that<br />
are willing to disclose financial data that meet<br />
a simple quality test. Participating MF<strong>Is</strong> typically<br />
have three characteristics: 1) they are willing to be<br />
transparent by submitting their performance data<br />
to an independent agency; 2) they display a strong<br />
social orientation by providing financial services to<br />
low-income persons; and 3) they are able to answer<br />
all the questions needed for our analysis.<br />
Data Quality <strong>Is</strong>sues<br />
The Bulletin has a data quality grade to represent the<br />
degree to which we have independent verification of<br />
an MFI’s data. Three star information (***) has been<br />
independently generated through a detailed financial<br />
analysis by an independent third party, such as a<br />
CAMEL evaluation, a CGAP appraisal, or assessments<br />
by reputable rating agencies. Two star information<br />
(**) is backed by accompanying documentation, such<br />
as audited financial statements, annual reports, and<br />
independent program evaluations that provide a<br />
reasonable degree of confidence for our adjustments.<br />
One star information (*) is from MF<strong>Is</strong> that have limited<br />
themselves to completing our questionnaire. These<br />
grades signify confidence levels on the reliability of<br />
the information; and in no way represent a rating of<br />
the financial performance of the MF<strong>Is</strong>.<br />
The criteria used in constructing the statistical tables<br />
are important for understanding and interpreting the<br />
information presented. Given the voluntary nature and<br />
origin of the data, the Bulletin staff, Editorial Board and<br />
funders cannot accept responsibility for the validity of<br />
the results presented, or for consequences resulting<br />
from their use. The data quality grade makes tentative<br />
distinctions about the quality of data presented to<br />
us, and we include only information for which we<br />
have a reasonable level of comfort. However, we<br />
cannot exclude the possibility of misrepresented selfreported<br />
results.<br />
There can also be inaccuracies in reporting the costs<br />
of financial services in multipurpose institutions that<br />
also provide non-financial services, in part because of<br />
difficulties in assigning overhead costs. These risks are<br />
highest for younger institutions, and for institutions<br />
with a record of optimistic statement of results. If we<br />
have grounds for caution about the reliability of an<br />
MFI’s disclosure, we will not include its information in<br />
a peer group unless it has been externally validated<br />
by a third party in which we have confidence.<br />
Adjustments to Financial Data<br />
The Bulletin adjusts the financial data it receives to<br />
ensure comparable results. The financial statements<br />
of each organization are converted to the standard<br />
financial statement presentation used by the Bulletin.<br />
This presentation can be simpler than that used<br />
by most MF<strong>Is</strong>; so, the conversion consists mainly of<br />
consolidation into fewer, more general accounts. In<br />
some instances, and where the original accounts did<br />
not have appropriate disclosure, the Bulletin’s accounts<br />
reveal more details on the financial service operations<br />
than did the originals. After this reclassification,<br />
three analytical adjustments are applied to produce<br />
a common treatment for the effect of: a) inflation, b)<br />
subsidies, and c) loan loss provisioning and write-off.<br />
In the statistical tables the reader can compare these<br />
adjusted results.<br />
Inflation<br />
The Bulletin reports the net effect of inflation by<br />
calculating increases in expenses and revenues due to<br />
inflation. Inflation decreases the value of net monetary<br />
assets, represented by the Bulletin as the difference<br />
between equity and fixed assets. This erosion in the<br />
value of net monetary assets is obtained by multiplying<br />
the prior year-end equity balance by the current-year<br />
inflation rate. 1 Fixed asset accounts, on the other hand,<br />
are revalued upward by the current year’s inflation<br />
Potential distortions may arise from: (1) unreported<br />
subsidies and (2) misrepresented loan portfolio quality.<br />
1<br />
Inflation data are obtained from line 64x of the International<br />
Financial Statistics, International Monetary Fund, various years.<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
73
APPENDICES<br />
rate, which results in inflation adjustment income,<br />
offsetting to some degree the expense generated by<br />
adjusting equity. 2 On the balance sheet, this inflation<br />
adjustment results in a reordering of equi ty accounts:<br />
profits are redistributed between real profit and the<br />
nominal profits required to maintain the real value<br />
of equity.<br />
MF<strong>Is</strong> that borrow from banks or mobilize savings have<br />
an actual interest expense, which is an operating cost.<br />
In comparison, similar MF<strong>Is</strong> that lend only their equity<br />
have no interest expense and therefore have lower<br />
operating costs. If an MFI focuses on sustainability<br />
and the maintenance of its capital/asset ratio, it<br />
must increase the size of its equity in nominal terms<br />
to continue to make the same value of loans in real<br />
(inflation-adjusted) terms. Inflation increases the<br />
cost of tangible items over time, so that a borrower<br />
needs more money to purchase them. MF<strong>Is</strong> that want<br />
to maintain their support to clients must therefore<br />
offer larger loans. Employees’ salaries go up with<br />
inflation, so the average loan balance and portfolio<br />
must increase to compensate, assuming no increase<br />
in interest margin. Therefore, an institution that funds<br />
its loans with its equity must maintain the real value of<br />
that equity, and pass along the cost of doing so to the<br />
client. This expectation implies MF<strong>Is</strong> should charge<br />
interest rates that include the inflation adjustment<br />
expense as a cost of funds, even if this cost is not<br />
actually paid to anyone outside the institution.<br />
Some countries with high or volatile levels of inflation<br />
require businesses to use inflation-based accounting<br />
on their audited financial statements. We use a proxy<br />
of this same technique in the Bulletin. Of course, we<br />
understand that in countries where high or volatile<br />
inflation is a new experience, MF<strong>Is</strong> may find it difficult<br />
to pass on the full cost of inflation to clients. These<br />
adjustments not do reflect policy recommendations;<br />
rather, they provide a common analytical framework that<br />
compares real financial performance meaningfully.<br />
Subsidies<br />
We adjust participating institutions’ financial<br />
statements for the effect of subsidies by presenting<br />
them as they would look on an unsubsidized basis.<br />
These adjustments do not intend to suggest that MF<strong>Is</strong><br />
should or should not be subsidized. Rather, they allow<br />
the Bulletin to see how each MFI would look without<br />
subsidies for comparative purposes. Most of the<br />
participating MF<strong>Is</strong> indicate a desire to grow beyond<br />
2<br />
In fact, an institution that holds fixed assets equal to its equity<br />
avoids the cost of inflation that affects MF<strong>Is</strong> which hold much of<br />
their equity in financial form.<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
the limitations imposed by subsidized funding. The<br />
subsidy adjustment permits an MFI to judge whether<br />
it is on track toward such an outcome. A focus on<br />
sustainable expansion suggests that subsidies should<br />
be used to defray start-up costs or support innovation.<br />
The subsidy adjustment simply indicates the extent<br />
to which the subsidy is being passed on to clients<br />
through lower interest rates or whether it is building<br />
the MFI’s capital base for further expansion.<br />
The Bulletin adjusts for three types of subsidies:<br />
(1) a cost-of-funds subsidy from loans at belowmarket<br />
rates, (2) current-year cash donations to fund<br />
portfolio and cover expenses, and (3) in-kind subsidies,<br />
such as rent-free office space or the services of<br />
personnel who are not paid by the MFI and thus not<br />
reflected on its income statement. Additionally, for<br />
multipurpose institutions, the MicroBanking Bulletin<br />
attempts to isolate the performance of the financial<br />
services program, removing the effect of any cross<br />
subsidization.<br />
The cost-of-funds adjustment reflects the impact of soft<br />
loans on the financial performance of the institution.<br />
The Bulletin calculates the difference between what<br />
the MFI actually paid in interest on its subsidized<br />
liabilities and what it would have paid at market terms. 3<br />
This difference represents the value of the subsidy,<br />
which we treat as an additional financial expense. We<br />
apply this subsidy adjustment to the average balance<br />
of borrowings carried by the MFI over the year. The<br />
decreased profit is offset by generating a “cost of funds<br />
adjustment” account on the balance sheet.<br />
If the MFI passes on the interest rate subsidy to its<br />
clients through a lower final rate of interest, this<br />
adjustment may result in an operating loss. If the MFI<br />
does not pass on this subsidy, but instead uses it to<br />
increase its equity base, the adjustment indicates<br />
the amount of the institution’s profits that were<br />
attributable to the subsidy rather than operations.<br />
Loan Loss Provisioning<br />
Finally, we apply standardized policies for loan loss<br />
provisioning and write-off. MF<strong>Is</strong> vary tremendously<br />
3<br />
Data for shadow interest rates are obtained from line 60l of<br />
the International Financial Statistics, IMF, various years. The<br />
deposit rate is used because it is a published benchmark in<br />
most countries. Sound arguments can be made for use of<br />
different shadow interest rates. NGOs that wish to borrow from<br />
banks would face interest significantly higher than the deposit<br />
rate. A licensed MFI, on the other hand, might mobilize savings<br />
at a lower financial cost than the deposit rate, but reserve<br />
requirements and administrative costs would drive up the<br />
actual cost of such liabilities.<br />
74<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
in accounting for loan delinquency. Some count the<br />
entire loan balance as overdue the day a payment<br />
is missed. Others do not consider a loan delinquent<br />
until its full term has expired. Some MF<strong>Is</strong> write off<br />
bad debt within one year of the initial delinquency,<br />
while others never write off bad loans, thus carrying<br />
forward a defaulted loan that they have little chance<br />
of ever recovering.<br />
We classify as “at risk” any loan with a payment over 90<br />
days late. We provision 50 percent of the outstanding<br />
balance for loans between 90 and 180 days late, and 100<br />
percent for loans over 180 days late. Some institutions<br />
also renegotiate (refinance or reschedule) delinquent<br />
loans. As these loans present a higher probability of<br />
default, we provision all renegotiated balances at 50<br />
APPENDICES<br />
percent. Wherever we have adequate information,<br />
we adjust to assure that all loans are fully written off<br />
within one year of their becoming delinquent. (Note:<br />
We apply these provisioning and write-off policies for<br />
benchmarking purposes only. We do not recommend<br />
that all MF<strong>Is</strong> use exactly the same policies.) In most<br />
cases, these adjustments are a rough approximation<br />
of risk. They are intended only to create a minimal<br />
even playing field for cross institutional comparison<br />
and benchmarking. Nevertheless, most participating<br />
MF<strong>Is</strong> have high-quality loan portfolios; so, loan loss<br />
provision expense is not an important contributor to<br />
their overall cost structure. If we felt that a program did<br />
not fairly represent its general level of delinquency,<br />
and we were unable to adjust it accordingly, we would<br />
simply exclude it from the peer group.<br />
Table 1<br />
Financial statement adjustments and their effects<br />
Adjustment Effect on Financial Statements Type of Institution Most<br />
Affected by Adjustment<br />
Inflation adjustment of<br />
equity (minus net fixed<br />
assets)<br />
Reclassification of certain<br />
long term liabilities into<br />
equity, and subsequent<br />
inflation adjustment<br />
Cost of funds adjustment<br />
Reclassification of donations<br />
below net operating<br />
income<br />
In-kind subsidy adjustment<br />
(e.g., donation of<br />
goods or services: line<br />
staff paid for by technical<br />
assistance providers)<br />
Loan loss provisioning<br />
adjustment<br />
Write-off adjustment<br />
Increases financial expense accounts on income<br />
statement, to some degree offset by inflation income<br />
account for revaluation of fixed assets. Generates a<br />
reserve in the balance sheet’s equity account, reflecting<br />
that portion of the MFI’s retained earnings that has<br />
been consumed by the effects of inflation. <strong>Dec</strong>reases<br />
profitability and “real” retained earnings.<br />
<strong>Dec</strong>reases concessional loan account and increases equity<br />
account; increases inflation adjustment on income<br />
statement and balance sheet.<br />
Increases financial expense on income statement to<br />
the extent that the MFI’s liabilities carry a below-market<br />
rate of interest. <strong>Dec</strong>reases net income and increases<br />
subsidy adjustment account on balance sheet.<br />
Reduces net operating income on the income statement.<br />
Increases accumulated donations account<br />
under equity on the balance sheet.<br />
Increases administrative expense on income statement<br />
to the extent that the MFI is receiving subsidized or<br />
donated goods or services. <strong>Dec</strong>reases net income, increases<br />
subsidy adjustment account on balance sheet.<br />
Usually increases loan loss provision expense on<br />
income statement and loan loss reserve on balance<br />
sheet.<br />
On balance sheet, reduces gross loan portfolio and<br />
loan loss reserve by an equal amount, so that neither<br />
net loan portfolio nor total assets is affected.<br />
MF<strong>Is</strong> funded more by equity than by<br />
liabilities will be hardest hit, especially<br />
in high inflation countries.<br />
NGOs that have very long-term, very<br />
low-interest “loans” from international<br />
agencies that function more<br />
as donations than loans, or transformed<br />
institutions with subordinated<br />
debt.<br />
MF<strong>Is</strong> with heavily subsidized loans<br />
(i.e., large lines of credit from governments<br />
or international agencies<br />
at highly subsidized rates).<br />
NGOs during their start-up phase.<br />
This adjustment is relatively less<br />
important for mature institutions.<br />
MF<strong>Is</strong> using goods or services for<br />
which they are not paying a marketbased<br />
cost (i.e., MF<strong>Is</strong> during their<br />
start-up phase).<br />
MF<strong>Is</strong> that have unrealistic loan loss<br />
provisioning policies.<br />
MF<strong>Is</strong> that leave non-performing<br />
loans on their books for over a year.<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
75
APPENDICES<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, <strong>Dec</strong>ember 20<strong>09</strong><br />
Apendix II: Participating<br />
Institutions<br />
ACRONYM NAME COUNTRY DATA QUALITY Year<br />
1st MCC First MicroCredit Company (FMCC) Kyrgyzstan ** 2008<br />
1st Valley Bank 1st Valley Bank (formerly Rural Bank of Kapatagan Valley, Inc). Philippines ** 2008<br />
3A Entreprises 3A Entreprises Guinea * 2008<br />
A3C A3C (Association des CVECA et CECA du Centre) Cameroon ** 2008<br />
ABA Alexandria Business Association Egypt ** 2008<br />
ABCRDM All Backward Class Relief and Development Mission India * 2008<br />
ABS-CBN ABS-CBN Bayan Foundation, Inc. Philippines ** 2008<br />
ABWA Assiut Business Women's Association Egypt ** 2008<br />
Abyan Abyan Program Yemen ** 2008<br />
Abzal Kredit Abzal Kredit Microfinance Organization Kazakhstan * 2008<br />
ACAD Arab Center for Agricultural Development Palestine ** 2008<br />
ACB sa AMASEZERANO COMMUNITY BANKING Rwanda ** 2008<br />
ACBA Agricultural Cooperative Bank of Armenia Armenia ** 2008<br />
AccessBank AccessBank Azerbaijan ** 2008<br />
ACCOVI Asociación Cooperativa de Ahorro y Crédito Vicentina de R.L. El Salvador ** 2008<br />
ACEP Cameroon Agence de Crédit pour l'Entreprise Privée Cameroun Cameroon ** 2008<br />
ACEP Senegal Alliance de Credit et d'Epargne pour la Production Senegal * 2008<br />
ACF Asian Credit Fund Kazakhstan * 2008<br />
ACFB Association des Caisses de Financement à la Base Benin ** 2008<br />
ACLEDA ACLEDA Bank Plc. Cambodia ** 2008<br />
ACLEDA Lao ACLEDA Bank Lao Ltd Laos ** 2008<br />
ACME Association Pour la Cooperation avec la Micro Enterprise Haiti ** 2008<br />
ACORDE Asociación Costarricense para organizaciones de Desarrollo Costa Rica ** 2008<br />
ACSI Amhara Credit and Savings Institution Ethiopia ** 2008<br />
Actuar Caldas Corporación Acción Por Caldas ACTUAR Famiempresas Colombia ** 2008<br />
Actuar Tolima ACTUAR Famiempresas - Tolima Colombia ** 2008<br />
ADCSI Addis Credit & Savings Institution Ethiopia * 2008<br />
Aden Aden Microfinance Foundation Yemen * 2008<br />
Adhikar Adhikar India ** 2008<br />
ADICH Asociación para el Desarrollo Integral Comunitario de Honduras Honduras * 2008<br />
ADIM Asociación Alternativa Para el Desarrollo Integral de las Mujeres Nicaragua ** 2008<br />
ADOPEM Asociación Dominicana para el Desarrollo de la Mujer Dominican Republic ** 2008<br />
ADRA - PER Adventist Development and Relief Agency International - Peru Peru *** 2008<br />
ADRI Asociación ADRI Costa Rica ** 2008<br />
Aetos Rural Credit Cooperative 'Aetos' Bulgaria * 2008<br />
AFK Agency for Finance in Kosovo Kosovo ** 2008<br />
AFODENIC Asociacion para el Fomento al Desarrollo de Nicaragua Nicaragua ** 2008<br />
AFS Ariana Financial Services (Mercy Corps) Afghanistan * 2008<br />
Agência do Crédito Agência do Crédito Brazil * 2008<br />
AGAPE Asociación General Para Asesorar Pequeñas Empresas Colombia ** 2008<br />
76 Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
APPENDICES<br />
ACRONYM NAME COUNTRY DATA QUALITY Year<br />
Aqrarkredit Aqrarkredit Azerbaijan ** 2008<br />
AgroCapital Fundación AgroCapital Bolivia *** 2008<br />
Agrocredit Plus MCA "Agrocredit Plus" Kyrgyzstan ** 2008<br />
Agroimpuls Riral Credit Cooperative 'Agroimpuls' Bulgaria * 2008<br />
AgroInvest AgroInvest Serbia ** 2008<br />
Agroinvestbank OJSC Agroinvestbank Tajikistan ** 2008<br />
AGUDESA Asociación Guatemalteca para el Desarrollo Guatemala ** 2008<br />
A-invest MCO A-invest Kazakhstan ** 2008<br />
Aiyl Bank Aiyl Bank (formerly KAFC) Kyrgyzstan ** 2008<br />
Akiba Akiba Commercial Bank Ltd Tanzania ** 2008<br />
Akuapem RB Akuapem RB Ghana * 2008<br />
Al Amana Association Al Amana for the Promotion of Micro-Enterprises Morocco Morocco *** 2008<br />
Al Awael Al Awael Microfinance Company Yemen * 2008<br />
Al Karama Association Al Karama de Micro Credit Morocco ** 2008<br />
Al Majmoua Lebanese Association for Development – Al Majmoua Lebanon ** 2008<br />
Al Rafah Bank Rafah Bank for Microfinance Palestine ** 2008<br />
Al Tadamun Al Tadamun Microfinance Program Egypt ** 2008<br />
Alidé Association de Lutte pour la promotion des Initiatives de Développement Benin ** 2008<br />
Alliance Group Microfinance Organization Alliance Group Georgia * 2008<br />
Alliance MFB Alliance Microfinance Bank Limited Nigeria * 2008<br />
ALSOL Alternativa Solidaria Chiapas Mexico ** 2008<br />
Alternativa CC Alternativa Russia * 2008<br />
Alternativa 19 del Sur Alternativa 19 del Sur, S.A. de C.V. SOFOM E.N.R. Mexico * 2008<br />
Alternativa<br />
Microfinanzas<br />
Alternativa, Centro de Investigación Social y Educación Popular Peru ** 2008<br />
Alteya Credit Consumer Cooperative Credit Union "Alteya" Russia * 2008<br />
Al-Thiqa Al-Thiqa Micro Finance and Small Business Loan Iraq ** 2008<br />
Alwatani National Microfinance Bank Jordan Jordan ** 2008<br />
AMA Asociación Mujeres en Acción Peru ** 2008<br />
AMC Ahli Microfinancing Company Jordan ** 2008<br />
AMC de R.L. Sociedad Cooperativa de Ahorro y Crédito AMC de R.L. El Salvador ** 2008<br />
Ameen CHF International / Ameen Lebanon ** 2008<br />
AMEXTRA AMEXTRA Mexico * 2008<br />
AMfB Accion Microfinance Bank Ltd Nigeria ** 2008<br />
AMFI Afghanistan Microfinance Initiative (CHF International) Afghanistan * 2008<br />
AMK Angkor Mikroheranhvatho Kampuchea Cambodia ** 2008<br />
AML Asmitha Microfin Ltd. India ** 2008<br />
Amlok Microdeposit Organization "Amlok" Tajikistan * 2008<br />
AMMACTS Acts Mahila Mutually Aided Coop Thrift Society India ** 2008<br />
AMOS Association Microfinance Oued Srou Morocco ** 2008<br />
AMRET AMRET Co. Ltd. - formerly EMT Cambodia ** 2008<br />
AMSSF/MC Association Marocaine Societe Sans Frontieres / Micro-redit Morocco ** 2008<br />
ANDE Agência Nacional de Desenvolvimento Microempresarial Brazil *** 2008<br />
ANED ANED Bolivia * 2008<br />
APED Association of Progressive Entrepreneurs in Development Ghana ** 2008<br />
Apoyo Económico APOYO ECONOMICO FAMILIAR, S.A. DE C.V. Mexico ** 2008<br />
Apoyo Integral Apoyo Integral S.A. de C.V. El Salvador ** 2008<br />
APROS Ámbito Productivo Mexico * 2008<br />
Aqroinvest Aqroinvest Credit Union Azerbaijan ** 2008<br />
ARD Association for Rural Development Sierra Leone ** 2008<br />
ARDCI Agriculture and Rural Development for Catanduanes, Inc. Philippines ** 2008<br />
ARDI Fondation ARDI Morocco ** 2008<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
77
APPENDICES<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
ACRONYM NAME COUNTRY DATA QUALITY Year<br />
AREGAK UCO AREGAK Universal Credit Organization CJSC Armenia ** 2008<br />
ARMP Afghanistan Rural Microcredit Programme (Aga Khan Development Network) Afghanistan * 2008<br />
Arnur Credit TOO MCO Arnur Credit Kazakhstan ** 2008<br />
Arohan Arohan India *** 2008<br />
ASA ASA Bangladesh * 2008<br />
ASA - GHA ASA Ghana Ghana ** 2008<br />
ASA Philippines ASA Philippines Philippines ** 2008<br />
ASALA Palestinian Businesswomen's Association Palestine ** 2008<br />
Asasah Asasah Pakistan ** 2008<br />
ASBA Assiut Businessmen Association Egypt ** 2008<br />
ASC Union ASC Union (formerly Rural Financial Fund) Albania ** 2008<br />
ASDIR Asociación de Desarrollo Integral Rural Guatemala ** 2008<br />
ASEI Asociación de Extensionistas Empresariales del INCAE El Salvador ** 2008<br />
ASHI Ahon Sa Hirap Inc. Philippines ** 2008<br />
ASIDME Acción de Servicio y Desarrollo para la Micro Empresa Peru * 2008<br />
ASKI Alalay Sa Kaunlaran, Inc. Philippines * 2008<br />
Asociación Arariwa Asociación Arariwa Peru ** 2008<br />
Asociación El<br />
Balsamo<br />
Asociación El Balsamo El Salvador ** 2008<br />
Asociación Raíz Asociación para el Desarrollo RAIZ Guatemala * 2008<br />
ASODENIC Asociación de Oportunidad y Desarrollo Económico de Nicaragua Nicaragua * 2008<br />
ASOPROSANRAMON<br />
Asociación Pro fomento de Proyectos Productivos de la Sub Región de<br />
San Ramón<br />
Costa Rica ** 2008<br />
A<strong>SP</strong> Financiera A<strong>SP</strong>, Consultores & Representación, S.A. de C.V. SOFOM E.N.R. Mexico *** 2008<br />
A<strong>SP</strong>IRE Asociación Para Inversión y Empleos Dominican Republic * 2008<br />
ASR Credit Union 'ASR' Uzbekistan * 2008<br />
ASTI Microloan Fund ASTI Tajikistan ** 2008<br />
ASUSU CIIGABA ASUSU CIIGABA Niger ** 2008<br />
ATEMEXPA Asesoría Técnica Especializada de México en Palma de Aceite, S.C. Mexico * 2008<br />
Atwima Kwanwoma Atwima Kwanwoma Ghana ** 2008<br />
Avantaj CCCC 'Avantaj' Russia * 2008<br />
Avanzar Asociacion Civil Avanzar por el Desarrollo Humano Argentina * 2008<br />
AWS Aadarsha Welfare Society India ** 2008<br />
AYNLA Asociación Ayudense y Nosotros les Ayudaremos Guatemala ** 2008<br />
Azal Sanaa Microfinance Project (Azal) Yemen * 2008<br />
Azercredit VF AzerCredit LLC Azerbaijan ** 2008<br />
Azerdemiryolbank Azerdemiryolbank Azerbaijan *** 2008<br />
Azeri Star Azeri Star Microfinance Azerbaijan *** 2008<br />
Bai Tushum Bai Tushum and Partners Kyrgyzstan ** 2008<br />
Bancamía Bancamía S.A., Banco de las Microfinanzas Colombia ** 2008<br />
Banco ADEMI Banco ADEMI Dominican Republic ** 2008<br />
Banco Amigo Banco Amigo, S.A. Institución de Banca Múltiple Mexico ** 2008<br />
Banco da Familia Associacao Brasileira para o Desenvolvimento da Familia Brazil ** 2008<br />
Banco do<br />
Empreendedor<br />
Banco do Empreendedor Brazil ** 2008<br />
Banco do Povo ACP Associação de Crédito Popular Banco do Povo Brazil * 2008<br />
Rede Novo Sol<br />
Rede Sócio Econ. Popular e Solidária de Desenv. Sustentável Novo Sol - Banco<br />
do Povo de Nova Ipixuna<br />
Brazil * 2008<br />
Banco do Vale CREDIVALE Agência Metropolitana de Microcrédito Brazil ** 2008<br />
Banco Familiar Banco Familiar Paraguay *** 2008<br />
Banco Popular do<br />
Brasil<br />
Banco Santiago de<br />
Libon<br />
Banco Popular do Brasil S.A. Brazil ** 2008<br />
Rural Bank of Santiago Libon (Albay) Inc. Philippines ** 2008<br />
78<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
APPENDICES<br />
ACRONYM NAME COUNTRY DATA QUALITY Year<br />
Banco Solidario Banco Solidario Ecuador *** 2008<br />
BancoEstado BancoEstado Chile * 2008<br />
BancoSol BancoSol Bolivia *** 2008<br />
BanCovelo Banco Popular Covelo Honduras ** 2008<br />
BANCRI BANCRI - Banco de Crédito Popular Brazil * 2008<br />
Bandhan Bandhan India ** 2008<br />
BANEX Banco del Exito, ex FINDESA Nicaragua *** 2008<br />
BanGente Banco De La Gente Emprendedora Venezuela *** 2008<br />
Bangko Kabayan Bangko Kabayan (Ibaan Rural Bank Inc.) Philippines ** 2008<br />
Bangko Luzon Bangko Luzon Philippines ** 2008<br />
Bangko Mabuhay Bangko Mabuhay (RB Tanza Inc.) Philippines ** 2008<br />
Bank Eskhata Bank Eskhata Tajikistan ** 2008<br />
Bank of Baku Bank of Baku Azerbaijan ** 2008<br />
BASIX Bhartiya Samruddhi Finance Limited India ** 2008<br />
BAYOCA Bhagawan Youth Club, Alapot, Ktm Nepal ** 2008<br />
BCB Bukidnon Cooperative Bank Philippines ** 2008<br />
BCSC Banco Caja Social Colombia Colombia *** 2008<br />
BEES Bangladesh Extension Education Services Bangladesh * 2008<br />
Bereke Kazakhstan Microcredit Organization Bereke Kazakhstan ** 2008<br />
Bereke-credit MCC Bereke-credit Kyrgyzstan * 2008<br />
Berendina<br />
Microfinance<br />
Berendina Microfinance Institute (Guarantee) Ltd. Sri Lanka ** 2008<br />
BESA BESA Foundation Albania ** 2008<br />
Bessfa RB Bessfa Rural Bank Ghana ** 2008<br />
BFL BWDA Finance Ltd. India ** 2008<br />
BFSBS BFSBS Russia * 2008<br />
BG Buusaa Gonofaa Ethiopia ** 2008<br />
BIMAS Business Initiative and Management Assistance Services Kenya *** 2008<br />
Binhminh CDC Binhminh Community Development Consulting Company, Ltd. Vietnam ** 2008<br />
BISWA Bharat Integrated Social Welfare Agency India ** 2008<br />
BJS Belgharia Janakalyan Samity India ** 2008<br />
Blago CCCC 'Blago' Russia * 2008<br />
BMSCCSL Buddha Mahila Savings and Credit Cooperative Society Ltd. Nepal ** 2008<br />
BMT Kayu Manis BMT Kayu Manis Indonesia * 2008<br />
BMT Pringsewu Sharia Cooperative Baitul Mal Wat Tamwil Pringsewu Indonesia * 2008<br />
BOM Banco Oportunidade de Moçambique Mozambique ** 2008<br />
Bonzali RB Bonzali Rural Bank Ltd. Ghana * 2008<br />
Borshud MLF Borshud Tajikistan * 2008<br />
BPR AN KBPR Arta Nawa Indonesia * 2008<br />
BPR Aditama Arta PT. BPP Aditama Arta Indonesia ** 2008<br />
BPR AK KBPR Arta Kencana Indonesia * 2008<br />
BPR Artadamas<br />
Mandiri<br />
BPR Artadamas Mandiri Indonesia * 2008<br />
BPR BBTM BPR Bekasi Binatanjung Makmur Indonesia * 2008<br />
BPR BKK Cilacap BPR BKK Cilacap Indonesia * 2008<br />
BPR CAS PT. BPR Citra Artha Sedana Indonesia ** 2008<br />
BPR Citama PT. BPR Cita Makmur Lestari Indonesia * 2008<br />
BPR DMG BPR Dana Multi Guna Indonesia ** 2008<br />
BPR Eka Ayu PT BPR Eka Ayu Artha Buwana Indonesia * 2008<br />
BPR Eka Usaha BPR Eka Usaha Indonesia * 2008<br />
BPR Hitamajaya PT. BPR Hitamajaya Argamandiri Indonesia ** 2008<br />
BPR NBP 11 PT. BPR NBP 11 Indonesia ** 2008<br />
BPR NBP 19 PT. BPR NBP 19 Indonesia ** 2008<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
79
APPENDICES<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
ACRONYM NAME COUNTRY DATA QUALITY Year<br />
BPR NBP 2 PT. BPR NBP 2 Indonesia ** 2008<br />
BPR NBP 30 PT. BPR NBP 30 Indonesia ** 2008<br />
BPR NSI PT BPR Nur Semesta Indah Indonesia * 2008<br />
BPR Pinang Artha BPR Pinang Artha Indonesia * 2008<br />
BPR PKT PT BPR Parta Kencana Tohpati Indonesia ** 2008<br />
BPR SAS PT. BPR Sejahtera Artha Sembada Indonesia ** 2008<br />
BPR Sukawati<br />
Pancakanti<br />
BPR Sukawati Pancakanti Indonesia * 2008<br />
BPR SKA BPR Sukma Kemang Agung Indonesia ** 2008<br />
BPR Surya Yudha<br />
Kencana<br />
PT. BPR Surya Yudha Kencana Indonesia * 2008<br />
BPR Taman Dhana PT. BPR Taman Dhana Indonesia * 2008<br />
BPR Wahana Sentra<br />
Artha<br />
PT.BPR Wahana Sentra Artha Indonesia ** 2008<br />
BRAC Bangladesh Rural Advancement Committee Bangladesh * 2008<br />
BRAC - AFG BRAC Afghanistan Afghanistan ** 2008<br />
BRAC - LKA BRAC Sri Lanka Sri Lanka ** 2008<br />
BRAC - SS BRAC Southern Sudan Sudan * 2008<br />
BRAC - TZA BRAC Tanzania Tanzania ** 2008<br />
BRAC - UGA BRAC Uganda Uganda ** 2008<br />
BRCCC Bolschemurtinskyi RCCC Russia * 2008<br />
BSS Bharatha Swamukti Samsthe India ** 2008<br />
BTA Bank BTA Bank (formerly Ineximbank) Kyrgyzstan ** 2008<br />
BURO Bangladesh BURO Bangladesh, formerly BURO Tangail Bangladesh ** 2008<br />
BWDC Bharathi Women Development Centre India * 2008<br />
BZMF Beselidhja/Zavet Microfinance Kosovo ** 2008<br />
CACMU COOPERATIVA DE AHORRO Y CRÉDITO MUJERES UNIDAS Ecuador ** 2008<br />
CAFASA Consultores Agropecuarios y Forestales Asociados, S.A. de C.V. Mexico * 2008<br />
CAFODEC<br />
Centre d'Appui et de formation pour le développement, l'Epargne et le Credit<br />
et l'éducation Civique<br />
Guinea * 2008<br />
Caja Depac Poblana Caja Depac Poblana SC de RL Mexico ** 2008<br />
Caja Popular<br />
Mexicana<br />
Caja Popular Mexicana Mexico ** 2008<br />
CamCCUL CamCCUL Cameroon * 2008<br />
CAME CAME Mexico * 2008<br />
CCAMETRO Caja de Crédito Metropolitana El Salvador ** 2008<br />
Cantilan Bank Cantilan Bank, Inc. Philippines ** 2008<br />
CAPA CAPA Finance S.A. Romania ** 2008<br />
Capitec Bank Capitec Bank South Africa ** 2008<br />
CAPPED<br />
Caisse de Participation à la Promotion des Entreprises et à leur<br />
Développement<br />
Congo, Republic of the ** 2008<br />
CARD Bank CARD Bank, Inc. Philippines ** 2008<br />
CARD NGO Center for Agriculture and Rural Development, Inc. Philippines ** 2008<br />
CARE - CREEME<br />
CARE de Honduras Programa de Crecimiento Económico de Microempresas<br />
(CREEME)<br />
Honduras * 2008<br />
Caritas Caritas Peru ** 2008<br />
Caritas Esteli Caritas Esteli Nicaragua * 2008<br />
Casa do Microcrédito Casa do Microcrédito Brazil ** 2008<br />
Cashpor MC Cashpor Microcredit India ** 2008<br />
CAURIE Micro<br />
Finance<br />
Caisse AUtonome pour le Renforcement des Initiatives Économiques par la<br />
Micro finance<br />
Senegal * 2008<br />
CBB Chhimek Bikas Bank Ltd. Nepal ** 2008<br />
CBDIBA/RENACA CBDIBA/RENACA Benin * 2008<br />
CBIRD Cambodia Business Integrated in Rural Development Cambodia ** 2008<br />
CBMO Cooperative Bank of Misamis Oriental Inc. Philippines ** 2008<br />
80<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
APPENDICES<br />
ACRONYM NAME COUNTRY DATA QUALITY Year<br />
CCA Crédit Communautaire d'Afrique Cameroon ** 2008<br />
CCC La Casa Campesina Cayambe Ecuador ** 2008<br />
CDM Crédit de développement mutuel Cameroon * 2008<br />
CDRO Asociación Cooperación para el Desarrollo Rural de Occidente Guatemala ** 2008<br />
CDS Crédit du Sahel Cameroon * 2008<br />
CEADe Centro Ecumênico de Apoio ao Desenvolvimento Brazil * 2008<br />
CEAPE BA Centro de Apoio aos Pequenos Empreendimentos da Bahia Brazil ** 2008<br />
CEAPE MA Centro de Apoio aos Pequenos Empreendimentos do Maranhão Brazil ** 2008<br />
CEAPE PE Centro de Apoio aos Pequeno Empreendimentos de Pernambuco Brazil ** 2008<br />
CEAPE PI Centro de Apoio aos Pequenos Empreendimentos do Piauí Brazil ** 2008<br />
CECA Coopérative d'Epargne et de Crédit des Artisans Togo ** 2008<br />
CECIC S.A. CECIC S.A. Cameroon ** 2008<br />
CEC-PROM Mature Coopératives d'Epargne et de Crédit des Promotrices Cameroon ** 2008<br />
CEDEF Calvary Enterprise Development Foundation Ghana ** 2008<br />
CEF Counterpart Enterprise Fund Russia * 2008<br />
Centenary Bank Centenary Rural Development Bank Ltd. Uganda ** 2008<br />
Central Cresol Baser Central Cresol Baser Brazil ** 2008<br />
CEOSS Coptic Evangelical Organization for Social Services Egypt ** 2008<br />
CEP Capital Aid Fund for Employment of the Poor Vietnam *** 2008<br />
CEP BRVT CEP Ba Ria - vung Tau Vietnam ** 2008<br />
CEP Long An CEP Long An Vietnam ** 2008<br />
CEPESIU Centro De Promoción y Empleo Para el Sector Informal Urbano Ecuador *** 2008<br />
CEPRODEL Centro de Promoción del Desarrollo Local Nicaragua *** 2008<br />
CESOL ACJ CESOL ACJ Ecuador ** 2008<br />
CETZAM CETZAM Opportunity Microfinance Ltd. Zambia ** 2008<br />
CEVI Community Economic Ventures, Inc. Philippines ** 2008<br />
CFA Child Fund Afghanistan Afghanistan ** 2008<br />
CFE Centre Financier aux Entrepreneurs S.A. AGASEKE Rwanda * 2008<br />
CFF Cedi Finance Foundation Ghana ** 2008<br />
CFPA China Fund for Poverty Alleviation China, People's<br />
Republic of<br />
* 2008<br />
Chamroeun Chamroeun Microfinance - Entrepreneurs du Monde Cambodia ** 2008<br />
Chandeshwori Chandeshwori Saving and Credit Co-operative Society, Ltd. Nepal ** 2008<br />
CHC-Limited CHC-Limited Cambodia *** 2008<br />
CHF Iraq CHF Iraq Iraq ** 2008<br />
Childfund Hoa Binh Childfund Hoa Binh Vietnam * 2008<br />
Chita FSBS Fund for Small Business Support in the Chita Region Russia * 2008<br />
CHWDA Chun Hua Women's Development Assosication China, People's<br />
Republic of<br />
** 2008<br />
CIDRE CIDRE Bolivia ** 2008<br />
CMAC Arequipa Caja Municipal de Ahorro y Crédito - Arequipa Peru *** 2008<br />
CMAC Cusco Caja Municipal de Ahorro y Crédito - Cusco Peru *** 2008<br />
CMAC Del Santa Caja Municipal de AHorro y Crédito Del Santa Peru ** 2008<br />
CMAC Huancayo Caja Municipal de AHorro y Crédito de Huancayo Peru *** 2008<br />
CMAC Ica Caja Municipal de Ahorro y Crédito - ICA Peru *** 2008<br />
CMAC Maynas Caja Municipal de Ahorro y Crédito de Maynas Peru * 2008<br />
CMAC Paita Caja Municipal de Ahorro y Crédito de Paita Peru ** 2008<br />
CMAC Pisco Caja Municipal de Ahorro y Crédito de Pisco Peru * 2008<br />
CMAC Piura CMAC Piura Peru *** 2008<br />
CMAC Sullana Caja Municipal de Ahorro y Crédito de Sullana S.A. Peru *** 2008<br />
CMAC Tacna Caja Municipal de Ahorro y Crédito de Tacna Peru *** 2008<br />
CMAC Trujillo Caja Municipal de Ahorro y Crédito de Trujillo Peru *** 2008<br />
CMCA Crédit Mutuel de Centrafrique Central African Republic * 2008<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
81
APPENDICES<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
ACRONYM NAME COUNTRY DATA QUALITY Year<br />
CMEDFI Cebu Micro-Enterprise Development Foundation Inc. Philippines ** 2008<br />
CMFinance Center for Microfinance Russia * 2008<br />
CMMB Caisse du Mouvement Mutualiste Béninois Benin ** 2008<br />
CMS Crédit Mutuel du Sénégal Senegal * 2008<br />
COAC 4 de Octubre Cooperativa de Ahorro y Crédito 4 de Octubre Ecuador ** 2008<br />
COAC Acción Rural Cooperativa Acción Rural Ecuador ** 2008<br />
COAC Ambato Cooperativa de Ahorro y Crédito Ambato Ltda. Ecuador ** 2008<br />
COAC Artesanos COAC Artesanos Ltda Ecuador ** 2008<br />
COAC Chone COAC Chone Ecuador *** 2008<br />
COAC Fernando<br />
Daquilema<br />
Cooperativa de Ahorro y Crédito Fernando Daquilema Ecuador ** 2008<br />
COAC Fondvida Cooperativa de Ahorro y Crédito Fondvida Ecuador ** 2008<br />
COAC Huaycopungo COAC Huaycopungo Ecuador * 2008<br />
COAC Jardín Azuayo Cooperativa de Ahorro y Crédito Jardín Azuayo Ecuador *** 2008<br />
COAC Kullki Wasi COAC Kullki Wasi Ecuador ** 2008<br />
COAC La Benéfica COAC La Benéfica Ecuador * 2008<br />
COAC Luz del Valle COAC Luz del Valle Ecuador ** 2008<br />
COAC MCCH Cooperativa de Ahorro y Crédito Maquita Cushunchic Ecuador *** 2008<br />
COAC Minga Cooperativa de Ahorro y Crédito Minga Ltda Ecuador * 2008<br />
COAC Mushuc Runa COAC Mushuc Runa Ltda. Ecuador ** 2008<br />
COAC La Nacional COAC La Nacional Ecuador ** 2008<br />
COAC Padre Vicente Cooperativa de Ahorro y Crédito Padre Vicente Ponce Rubio Ecuador ** 2008<br />
COAC Pallatanga COAC San Miguel de Pallatanga Ecuador ** 2008<br />
COAC Sac Aiet Cooperativa de Ahorro y Crédito Sac Aiet Ecuador ** 2008<br />
COAC San Antonio COAC San Antonio Ecuador ** 2008<br />
COAC San Gabriel COAC San Gabriel Ecuador ** 2008<br />
COAC San José Cooperativa de Ahorro y Crédito - San José Ecuador *** 2008<br />
COAC Santa Ana COAC Santa Ana Ecuador *** 2008<br />
COAC Santa Anita COAC Santa Anita Ecuador ** 2008<br />
COCDEP Consultoría y Capacitación para el Desarrollo Productivo, S.C. Mexico * 2008<br />
CODESARROLLO CODESARROLLO Ecuador *** 2008<br />
Columbia<br />
Microcreditos<br />
Banco Columbia División Microcreditos Argentina * 2008<br />
Common Interest Common Interest International Thailand ** 2008<br />
CompartamosBanco Banco Compartamos S.A. Institución de Banca Múltiple Mexico *** 2008<br />
Comultrasan<br />
Cooperativa de Ahorro y Crédito de Santander Ltda. "Financiera<br />
Comultrasan"<br />
Colombia ** 2008<br />
Conserva Conserva Mexico * 2008<br />
Contactar Corporación Nariño Empresa y Futuro Colombia * 2008<br />
Coop 20 de Abril Cooperativa de Servicios Múltiples 20 de Abril R.L. Nicaragua ** 2008<br />
Coop Avances Cooperativa de Ahorro y Credito Financiera Avances R.L. Nicaragua ** 2008<br />
Coop Fátima Cooperativa Fátima Bolivia *** 2008<br />
Coop Jesús Nazareno Cooperativa Jesús Nazareno Ltda. Bolivia *** 2008<br />
Coop Juan XXIII Cooperativa de Servicios Múltiples Juan XXIII. R.L. Panama * 2008<br />
COOPAC<br />
Chiquinquira<br />
Cooperativa de Ahorro y Crédito Chiquinquira Peru * 2008<br />
COOPAC León XIII COOPAC León XIII Peru * 2008<br />
COOPAC Los Andes Cooperativa de Ahorro y Crédito Los Andes Cotarusi Aymaraes Peru *** 2008<br />
COOPAC Norandino COOPAC Norandino Ltda. Peru ** 2008<br />
COOPAC San<br />
Cristóbal<br />
COOPAC San Cristóbal de Huamanga Peru * 2008<br />
COOPAC San Martín COOPAC San Martin de Porres - PER Peru ** 2008<br />
COOPAC Santa Maria Cooperativa de Ahorro y Crédito Santa Maria Magdalena Peru * 2008<br />
COOPAC Santo Cristo COOPAC Santo Cristo de Bagazán Peru ** 2008<br />
82<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
APPENDICES<br />
ACRONYM NAME COUNTRY DATA QUALITY Year<br />
COOPAC Santo<br />
Domingo<br />
Cooperativa de Ahorro y Crédito Santo Domingo de Guzmán Peru ** 2008<br />
COOPAC Tocache Cooperativa de Ahorro y Crédito Tocache Peru ** 2008<br />
COOPEC Hinfani<br />
Dosso<br />
COOPEC Hinfani Dosso Niger * 2008<br />
COOPEC/ACCO Cooperative d'epargne et de credit de l'assciation des chauffeurs du congo Congo, Democratic<br />
Republic of the<br />
* 2008<br />
COOPEDU-Kigali COOPEDU-Kigali Rwanda ** 2008<br />
COOPROGRESO COOPROGRESO Ecuador *** 2008<br />
CO<strong>SP</strong>EC Coopérative Solidarité avec les Paysans pour l'Epargne et le Crédit à Cibitoke Burundi ** 2008<br />
CPECG Yete Mali CPECG Yete Mali Guinea * 2008<br />
CRAC Los Andes Caja Rural de Ahorro y Crédito Los Andes Peru *** 2008<br />
CRAC Nuestra Gente Caja Rural de Ahorro y Crédito Nuestra Gente Peru *** 2008<br />
CRAC Profinanzas Caja Rural de Ahorro y Crédito Profinanzas Peru *** 2008<br />
CRAC Señor de Luren Caja Rural de Ahorro y Crédito Señor de Luren Peru *** 2008<br />
CRAC Sipán Caja Rural de Ahorro y Crédito Sipán S.A. Peru *** 2008<br />
CRAN Christian Rural Aid Network Ghana ** 2008<br />
Crece Safsa Crece Safsa, S.A. de C.V. Mexico * 2008<br />
CRECER Crédito con Educación Rural Bolivia *** 2008<br />
CredAgro NBCO CredAgro Non-Banking Credit Institution Azerbaijan ** 2008<br />
Credi Fé Credi Fé Desarrollo Microempresarial S.A. Ecuador ** 2008<br />
CrediAmigo Banco do Nordeste do Brasil S/A Brazil ** 2008<br />
CrediAvance CrediAvance, S.A. de C.V. SOFOM E.N.R. (antes DE<strong>SP</strong>ENO) Mexico * 2008<br />
Credi-Capital CREDI-CAPITAL, S.A. de C.V. SOFOM E.N.R (antes ASEA) Mexico * 2008<br />
CrediClub CrediClub, S.A. de C.V., SOFOM E.N.R. Mexico * 2008<br />
CrediComún Servicios para el Desarollo Comunitario, S.A. de C.V. Mexico ** 2008<br />
Credicoop Cooperativa Credicoop Ltda. Chile ** 2008<br />
CREDIMUJER Credito para la Microempresa y el Desarrollo Social Costa Rica ** 2008<br />
Crediscotia Crediscotia Financiera Peru *** 2008<br />
Credisol Instituição de Crédito Solidário Credisol Brazil ** 2008<br />
CREDIT CREDIT MFI Cambodia ** 2008<br />
Credit Mongol Credit Mongol Mongolia ** 2008<br />
Créditos Pronegocio Créditos Pronegocio, S.A. de C.V. SOFOL, Grupo Financiero Norte Mexico * 2008<br />
CREDITUYO Servicios Financieros de Desarrollo Comunitario, S.A. de C.V. SOFOM E.N.R. Mexico ** 2008<br />
CREDO LLC "MFO CREDO" Georgia ** 2008<br />
CReSA Centre for Rural Reconstruction Through Social Action India * 2008<br />
Cresol Central<br />
Cresol Central SC/RS - Cooperativa Central de Crédito Rural com Interação<br />
Solidária<br />
Brazil ** 2008<br />
Crezcamos Crezcamos S.A. Colombia ** 2008<br />
CRG Credit Rural de Guinée Guinea ** 2008<br />
CRYSOL Fundación CRYSOL Guatemala *** 2008<br />
Crystal JSC MFO Crystal (formerly Crystal Fund) Georgia ** 2008<br />
CSD Centre for Self-help Development Nepal ** 2008<br />
CU Kosayu CU Kosayu Indonesia * 2008<br />
CU Pantai Prigi Credit Union Pantai Prigi Indonesia * 2008<br />
CU Sawiran Koperasi Kredit Sawiran Indonesia * 2008<br />
CUMO CUMO Microfinance Limited Malawi ** 2008<br />
CVECA Kita/<br />
Bafoulabé<br />
CVECA Kita/Bafoulabé Mali * 2008<br />
CVECA Pays Dogon CVECA Pays Dogon Mali * 2008<br />
CVECA SOUM Caisses villageoises d'épargne et de credit autogérées du Soum Burkina Faso * 2008<br />
CWCD Centre for Woman Co-operative Development Pakistan ** 2008<br />
CZWSDA Chifeng Zhaowuda Women's Sustainable Development Association China, People's<br />
Republic of<br />
* 2008<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
83
APPENDICES<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
ACRONYM NAME COUNTRY DATA QUALITY Year<br />
DAMEN Development Action for Mobilization and Emancipation Pakistan ** 2008<br />
DAYAQ-Credit NBCO "DAYAQ-Credit" LLC Azerbaijan * 2008<br />
DBACD Dakahlya Businessmen's Association for Community Development Egypt ** 2008<br />
DD Bank Deprosc Development Bank Ltd. Nepal ** 2008<br />
DEC Development Exchange Center Nigeria ** 2008<br />
DECSI Dedebit Credit and Savings Institution Ethiopia ** 2008<br />
DEF Development and Employment Fund Jordan ** 2008<br />
Degaf Degaf Ethiopia * 2008<br />
DEPROSC-Nepal Development Project Service Centre - Nepal Nepal * 2008<br />
Despacho Amador Despacho Alfonso Amador Mexico * 2008<br />
Diaconia FRIF Diaconia Bolivia ** 2008<br />
Dian Mandiri Dian Mandiri Foundation Indonesia ** 2008<br />
DINARI Dian Bhuana Lestari Foundation Indonesia ** 2008<br />
Dirigible Microcredit Company 'Dirigible' Kyrgyzstan * 2008<br />
DJOMEC DJOMEC Senegal * 2008<br />
DSK Dobrich DSK Dobrich Bulgaria * 2008<br />
D-Miro D-miro Ecuador *** 2008<br />
Don Apoyo Don Apoyo S.A. de C.V. Mexico * 2008<br />
Doveriye - Volgograd Doveriye Consumer Credit Cooperative of Citizens Russia * 2008<br />
Doveriye (Amursk) Credit Union 'Doveriye' (Amursk) Russia * 2008<br />
Doveriye- Bulgaria Rural Credit Cooperative 'Doveriye' Bulgaria * 2008<br />
Doveriye-Altay Consumer Credit Cooperative 'Doveriye-Altay' Russia * 2008<br />
DQF Daasgift Quality Foundation Ghana ** 2008<br />
D<strong>SP</strong>I Daan Sa Pag-unlad Inc. Philippines * 2008<br />
Duterimbere Duterimbere Rwanda ** 2008<br />
ECLOF - ARM Ecumenical Church Loan Fund - ARM Armenia ** 2008<br />
ECLOF - ECU Ecumenical Church Loan Fund - Ecuador Ecuador ** 2008<br />
ECLOF - PHL ECLOF Philippines Foundation, Inc. Philippines ** 2008<br />
EcoFuturo FFP Eco Futuro Fondo Financiero Privado Bolivia *** 2008<br />
EDAPRO<strong>SP</strong>O EDAPRO<strong>SP</strong>O Peru ** 2008<br />
Edinstvo Yurga CCC 'Edinstvo Yurga' Russia * 2008<br />
Edinstvo-Volgograd CCC 'Edinstvo-Volgograd' Russia * 2008<br />
EDPYME Acceso<br />
Crediticio<br />
EDPYME Acceso Crediticio Peru * 2008<br />
EDPYME Alternativa EDPYME Alternativa Peru *** 2008<br />
EDPYME Confianza EDPYME Confianza Peru *** 2008<br />
EDPYME Crear<br />
Arequipa<br />
EDPYME Crear Arequipa Peru *** 2008<br />
EDPYME Credivisión EDPYME Credivisión Peru *** 2008<br />
EDPYME Efectiva EDPYME Efectiva Peru ** 2008<br />
EDPYME Nueva<br />
Visión<br />
EDPYME Pro<br />
Negocios<br />
EDPYME Nueva Visión Peru *** 2008<br />
EDPYME Pro Negocios Peru * 2008<br />
EDPYME Proempresa EDPYME Proempresa Peru ** 2008<br />
EDPYME Raíz EDPYME Raíz Peru *** 2008<br />
Ehyoi kuhiston Microloan Fund Ehyoi kuhiston Tajikistan * 2008<br />
EKI EKI Bosnia and<br />
Herzegovina<br />
*** 2008<br />
EKPA Consumer Credit Union 'Economic Partnership' Russia * 2008<br />
Elet-Capital MCC Elet-Capital Kyrgyzstan *** 2008<br />
Emprender EMPRENDER Bolivia Bolivia *** 2008<br />
Enda Enda Inter-Arabe Tunisia *** 2008<br />
ENLACE ENLACE - Servicios Financieros S.A de C.V. El Salvador ** 2008<br />
84<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
APPENDICES<br />
ACRONYM NAME COUNTRY DATA QUALITY Year<br />
Equitas Equitas Micro Finance India India ** 2008<br />
Equity Bank Equity Bank Kenya ** 2008<br />
ESAF ESAF Microfinance and Investments (P) Ltd. India ** 2008<br />
ESED Egyptian Small Enterprise Development Foundation Egypt * 2008<br />
Eshet Eshet Ethiopia ** 2008<br />
Espacios Alternativos Espacios Alternativos, S.C. Mexico * 2008<br />
Crezkamos Kapital Crezkamos Kapital Eurekasoli, S. A. de C.V. Mexico * 2008<br />
Express Finance Express Finance IFN SA (formerly CHF - ROM) Romania ** 2008<br />
Fácil SCM Fácil Sociedade de Crédito ao Microempreendedor Ltda Brazil * 2008<br />
FACES FACES Ecuador *** 2008<br />
FADEMYPE Fundación para el Auto Desarrollo de la Micro y Pequeña Empresa El Salvador ** 2008<br />
FAFIDESS<br />
Fundación de Asesoría Financiera a Instituciones de Desarrollo y Servicio<br />
Social<br />
Guatemala * 2008<br />
FAIR Bank First Agro-Industrial Rural Bank Philippines ** 2008<br />
FAM Fonds d'Actions Mutuelles Congo, Republic of the ** 2008<br />
FAMA OPDF Familia y Medio Ambiente OPDF Honduras ** 2008<br />
FAPE Fundacion de Asistencia para la Pequeña Empresa Guatemala * 2008<br />
Farm Credit Armenia Farm Credit Armenia UCO CC Armenia ** 2008<br />
FASL First Allied Savings & Loans Ghana ** 2008<br />
Fassil FFP Fondo FASSIL Bolivia *** 2008<br />
FATEN Palestine for Credit & Development Palestine ** 2008<br />
Faulu - KEN Faulu Kenya Deposit Taking Microfinance Limited Kenya ** 2008<br />
Faulu - UGA Faulu - Uganda Uganda ** 2008<br />
FBPMC Fondation Banque Populaire pour le Micro-Credit Morocco ** 2008<br />
AfricaWorks AfricaWorks Mozambique * 2008<br />
FDL Fondo de Desarrollo Local Nicaragua ** 2008<br />
FDM Group-Guaranteed Lending and Savings - Fundo de Desenvolvimento da Mulher Mozambique ** 2008<br />
FECECAM Fédération des caisses d'épargne et de crédit agricole mutuel Benin * 2008<br />
FED Fundación Ecuatoriana de Desarrollo Ecuador ** 2008<br />
FFECC First Far Eastern Credit Cooperative Russia * 2008<br />
FFSA Fund for Financial Support of Agriculture Kazakhstan ** 2008<br />
FIACG Fundación Internacional para la Asistencia Comunitaria de Guatemala Guatemala ** 2008<br />
FICO First <strong>Is</strong>abela Cooperative Bank Philippines ** 2008<br />
FIDERPAC Fundación Integral de Desarrollo Rural del Pacífico Central Costa Rica ** 2008<br />
FIDEVIE FIDEVIE Benin * 2008<br />
FIE FFP Fondo Financiero Privado para el Fomento a Iniciativas Economicas Bolivia *** 2008<br />
FIE Gran Poder FIE Gran Poder S.A. Argentina *** 2008<br />
FIELCO Financiera El Comercio Paraguay *** 2008<br />
FinAgro FinAgro Georgia *** 2008<br />
FinAmérica Financiera América Colombia ** 2008<br />
FinAmigo Financiera Mexicana para el Desarrollo Rural, S.A. DE C.V., S.F.P. Mexico * 2008<br />
Financiera Edyficar Financiera Edyficar S.A. Peru *** 2008<br />
Financiera Fama Financiera Fama S.A. Nicaragua ** 2008<br />
Financiera<br />
Independencia<br />
Financiera Independencia, S.A.B. de C.V. SOFOM E.N.R. Mexico *** 2008<br />
FINCA - AFG FINCA Afghanistan Afghanistan * 2008<br />
FINCA - ARM FINCA Armenia Armenia ** 2008<br />
FINCA - AZE FINCA Azerbaijan Azerbaijan ** 2008<br />
FINCA - DRC FINCA Democratic Republic of Congo Congo, Democratic<br />
Republic of the<br />
** 2008<br />
FINCA - ECU FINCA Ecuador Ecuador ** 2008<br />
FINCA - GEO FINCA Georgia Georgia ** 2008<br />
FINCA - GTM FINCA Guatemala Guatemala ** 2008<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
85
APPENDICES<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
ACRONYM NAME COUNTRY DATA QUALITY Year<br />
FINCA - HND Financiera FINCA Honduras S.A. Honduras ** 2008<br />
FINCA - HTI FINCA - Haiti Haiti * 2008<br />
FINCA - JOR FINCA Jordan Jordan ** 2008<br />
FINCA - KOS FINCA - Kosovo Kosovo ** 2008<br />
FINCA - MEX Fundación Integral Comunitaria, A.C. - FINCA México Mexico ** 2008<br />
FINCA - MWI FINCA Malawi Malawi * 2008<br />
FINCA - NIC Fundación Internacional para la Asistencia Comunitaria - Nicaragua Nicaragua ** 2008<br />
FINCA - PER FINCA Peru Peru *** 2008<br />
FINCA - Russia FINCA - Russia Russia ** 2008<br />
FINCA - SLV Fundación Internacional para la Asistencia Comunitaria El Salvador ** 2008<br />
FINCA - TJK FINCA Tajikistan Tajikistan ** 2008<br />
FINCA - TZA FINCA Tanzania Tanzania ** 2008<br />
FINCA - UGA FINCA Uganda Uganda ** 2008<br />
FINCA - ZMB FINCA Zambia Zambia ** 2008<br />
FinComún Servicios Financieros Comunitarios, S.A. de C.V. SFP Mexico ** 2008<br />
FINCORP FINCORP Swaziland ** 2008<br />
FinDev Finance for Development LLC Azerbaijan ** 2008<br />
FINORTE Financiera del Norte, S.A. de C.V. SOFOM E.N.R. Mexico * 2008<br />
FINSOL Financiera Solidaria Honduras Honduras ** 2008<br />
First Macro Bank First Macro Bank (Rural Bank of Pateros) Philippines ** 2008<br />
Emprenda FIS - Empresa Social S.A. Argentina ** 2008<br />
FISUR Fomento e Impulso del Sur S.A. de C.V. Mexico * 2008<br />
FMCC FINCA MicroCredit Company - formerly FINCA Kyrgyzstan Kyrgyzstan ** 2008<br />
FMF First Microfinance Foundation - Aga Khan Egypt Egypt ** 2008<br />
FMFB - AFG The First MicroFinanceBank - Afghanistan Afghanistan ** 2008<br />
FMFB - Pakistan First MicroFinanceBank Ltd - Pakistan Pakistan ** 2008<br />
FMFB - TJK The First MicroFinanceBank - Tajikistan Tajikistan ** 2008<br />
FMFI-SYR Frst Micro Finance Institution, Syria Syria ** 2008<br />
FMM Bucaramanga Fundación Mundial de la Mujer Bucaramanga Colombia ** 2008<br />
FMM Popayán Fundación Mundo Mujer Popayán Colombia ** 2008<br />
FMSD Fundación Mario Santo Domingo Colombia ** 2008<br />
FNT Credit FNT Credit Kyrgyzstan * 2008<br />
FODEM Fondo de Desarrollo para la Mujer Nicaragua ** 2008<br />
FODEMI Fondo de Desarrollo Microempresarial Ecuador ** 2008<br />
FOMIC Fondo de Microproyectos Costarricenses Sociedad Civil Costa Rica ** 2008<br />
FONCRESOL FONCRESOL Bolivia ** 2008<br />
FONDECO Fondo de Desarrollo Comunal Bolivia *** 2008<br />
FONDEP Fondation pour le Development Local et le Partenariat Micro-Crédit Morocco *** 2008<br />
FONDESOL FONDESOL Guatemala ** 2008<br />
FONDESURCO Fondo de Desarrollo Regional Peru *** 2008<br />
Fondo Esperanza Fondo Esperanza Chile ** 2008<br />
Fonkoze Fondasyon Kole Zepòl Haiti * 2008<br />
Forjadores de<br />
Negocios<br />
Forjadores de Negocios, S. A. de C.V. SOFOM E.N.R Mexico ** 2008<br />
Fortaleza FFP Fortaleza FFP Bolivia ** 2008<br />
FORUS FORUS Bank Russia *** 2008<br />
FORWARD Forum for Rural Women Ardency Development Nepal ** 2008<br />
FOVIDA Fomento de la Vida Peru ** 2008<br />
FRAC Fundación Realidad, A.C. Mexico *** 2008<br />
FUBODE Fundación Boliviana para el Desarrollo Bolivia ** 2008<br />
FUCEC Togo Faitière des Unités Coopératives d'Epargne et de Crédit du Togo Togo * 2008<br />
FUDEMI Fundación para el Desarrollo de la Microempresa Nicaragua * 2008<br />
FULM Saving House FULM Macedonia ** 2008<br />
86<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
APPENDICES<br />
ACRONYM NAME COUNTRY DATA QUALITY Year<br />
FUNBODEM Fundación Boliviana para el Desarrollo de la Mujer Bolivia *** 2008<br />
Fund for Women<br />
Development - HCM<br />
Fund for Women Development - HCM Vietnam * 2008<br />
Fundación 4i-2000 Fundación 4i-2000 Nicaragua ** 2008<br />
Fundación<br />
Alternativa<br />
Fundación Alternativa Ecuador *** 2008<br />
Fundación Amanecer Fundación Amanecer Colombia ** 2008<br />
Fundación CAMPO Fundación CAMPO El Salvador ** 2008<br />
Fundación Esperanza Fundación Esperanza Internacional Dominican Republic ** 2008<br />
Fundación Espoir Fundación Espoir Ecuador ** 2008<br />
Fundación León 2000 Fundación León 2000 Nicaragua ** 2008<br />
Fundación MICROS Fundación para el Desarrollo de la Microempresa MICROS Guatemala ** 2008<br />
Fundación Mujer Fundación Mujer Costa Rica ** 2008<br />
Fundación<br />
Nieborowski<br />
Fundación<br />
Paraguaya<br />
Fundación José Nieborowski Nicaragua * 2008<br />
Fundación Paraguaya de Cooperación y Desarrollo Paraguay ** 2008<br />
FUNDAHMICRO Fundación Hondureña para el Desarrollo de la Microempresa Honduras ** 2008<br />
FUNDAMIC Fundación de Ayuda Microempresarial Ecuador ** 2008<br />
FUNDEA Fundación para el Desarrollo Empresarial y Agrícola Guatemala ** 2008<br />
FUNDEBASE Fundación para el Desarrollo de Base Costa Rica ** 2008<br />
FUNDECOCA Fundación Unión y Desarrollo de Comunidades Campesinas Costa Rica ** 2008<br />
FUNDENUSE Fundación para el Desarrollo de Nueva Segovia) Nicaragua ** 2008<br />
FUNDEPYME Fundación de Desarrollo Empresarial de la Pequeña y Mediana Empresa Nicaragua * 2008<br />
FUNDESER Fundación para el Desarrollo Socioeconómico Rural Nicaragua *** 2008<br />
FUNDE<strong>SP</strong>E Fundacion para el Desarrollo de la Pequeña Empresa Guatemala ** 2008<br />
Fundusz Mikro Fundusz Mikro Poland ** 2008<br />
FUNED Fundación para el Desarrollo de Honduras Honduras ** 2008<br />
FUNHAVI Fundación Habitat y Vivienda, A.C. Mexico * 2008<br />
FUNSALDE Fundación Salvadoreña para el Desarrollo El Salvador * 2008<br />
FVP Fundacion para La Vivienda Progresiva A.C. Mexico * 2008<br />
Génesis Empresarial Fundación Génesis Empresarial Guatemala ** 2008<br />
Galaktika CCC Galaktika Russia * 2008<br />
Garant-Invest Garant-Invest Uzbekistan ** 2008<br />
Gasha Gasha Ethiopia * 2008<br />
GAWFA GAMBIA WOMEN'S FINANCE ASSOCIATION Gambia, The * 2008<br />
GBNB Grameen Bank Nepal Biratnagar Nepal ** 2008<br />
GCM Grupo Consultor para La Microempresa, S.A. de C.V., SOFOM, E.N.R. Mexico ** 2008<br />
General Toshevo Rural Credit Cooperative 'General Toshevo' Bulgaria * 2008<br />
GGEM Microfinance<br />
Services Ltd.<br />
Grassroots Gender Empowerment Movement Microfinance Services Ltd. Sierra Leone ** 2008<br />
GF<strong>SP</strong>L Grameen Financial Services Pvt. Ltd. India ** 2008<br />
GM Bank GM Bank Philippines ** 2008<br />
GOF Growing Opportunity Finance India ** 2008<br />
Gorodskoy Consumer Credit Cooperative 'Gorodskoy' Russia * 2008<br />
GRAINE sarl GRoupe d'Accompagnement à l'INvestissement et à l'Epargne Burkina Faso * 2008<br />
Grameen Bank Grameen Bank Bangladesh ** 2008<br />
Grameen Mendoza Fundación Grameen Mendoza Argentina ** 2008<br />
Grameen Sahara Grameen Sahara Matia Goalpara India ** 2008<br />
Green Bank Rural Green Bank of Caraga, Inc. Philippines ** 2008<br />
Grupo Río La Venta Grupo Consultor Río la Venta S.A. de C.V. SOFOM E.N.R. Mexico * 2008<br />
GU Gram-Utthan India ** 2008<br />
GV Grama Vidiyal India ** 2008<br />
Harbu Harbu Micro Finance Institution Share Company Ethiopia ** 2008<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
87
APPENDICES<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
ACRONYM NAME COUNTRY DATA QUALITY Year<br />
HEED HEED Bangladesh Bangladesh * 2008<br />
Hekima Hekima Congo, Democratic<br />
Republic of the<br />
** 2008<br />
HDH OPDF Fundación Microfinanciera Hermandad de Honduras OPDF Honduras ** 2008<br />
HiH Hand in Hand India * 2008<br />
HKL Hattha Kaksekar Ltd. Cambodia *** 2008<br />
Hluvuku Hluvuku-Adsema Fundo de Credito Male yeru Mozambique ** 2008<br />
Hofokam Hofokam Uganda * 2008<br />
HOPE HOPE Ukraine Ukraine ** 2008<br />
Hope for Life Hope for Life Afghanistan ** 2008<br />
Horizon Horizon fund Armenia ** 2008<br />
Horizonti Foundation Horizonti Skopje Macedonia ** 2008<br />
H<strong>SP</strong>FI Hagdan Sa Pag-uswag Foundation Inc. Philippines * 2008<br />
ICC BluSol Instituição Comunitária de Crédito Blumenau Solidariedade Brazil ** 2008<br />
ICC Conquista<br />
Solidária<br />
Instituição Comunitária de Crédito Conquista Solidária Brazil * 2008<br />
ICC MAUCE Instituição Comunitária de Crédito do Médio Alto Uruguai e Região Celeiro Brazil * 2008<br />
ICMFB IC Microfinance Bank Nigeria Nigeria ** 2008<br />
IDDA Industrial District Development Association Egypt * 2008<br />
IDEPRO Instituto para el Desarrollo de la Pequeña Unidad Productiva Bolivia ** 2008<br />
IDER CV IDER Cesar Vallejo Peru * 2008<br />
IDESI Lambayeque Instituto de Desarrollo del Sector Informal para Lambayeque Peru * 2008<br />
IDE<strong>SP</strong>A IDE<strong>SP</strong>A Peru * 2008<br />
IDF Integrated Development Foundation Bangladesh * 2008<br />
ID-Ghana Initiative Development Ghana Ghana ** 2008<br />
IDH Instituto para el Desarrollo Hondureno Honduras ** 2008<br />
IDYDC Iringa Development of Youth, Disabled and Children Care Tanzania ** 2008<br />
IFDP Institution Financier de Developpement de Phongsaly Laos * 2008<br />
ImerCredit MFI ImerCredit Ltd. (formerly BAI) Georgia * 2008<br />
IMFB Integrated Microfinance Bank Nigeria *** 2008<br />
Imkoniyat Microlending Foundation Imkoniyat Tajikistan * 2008<br />
Imodi Hutal Microloan Fund Imodi Hutal Tajikistan * 2008<br />
IMON LLC Microlending organization IMON INTERNATIONAL Tajikistan *** 2008<br />
IMPRO Asociación Incubadora de Microempresas Productivas Bolivia *** 2008<br />
Impuls Consumer Credit Cooperative " Russia * 2008<br />
Indur MACS<br />
Indur Intideepam Mutually Aided Thrift & Credit Cooperatives'<br />
Federation Limited<br />
India ** 2008<br />
INECO INECO Bank Armenia ** 2008<br />
Inicjatywa Mikro Inicjatywa Mikro Poland ** 2008<br />
INMAA Institution Marocaine d'Appui a la Micro-entreprise Morocco * 2008<br />
INSOTEC Instituto de Investigaciones Socioeconómicas y Tecnológicas Ecuador *** 2008<br />
Instituto Estrela Instituto Estrela de Fomento ao Microcrédito Brazil * 2008<br />
Intellekt Consumer Credit Cooperative of Citizens 'Intellekt' Russia * 2008<br />
Interactuar Interactuar Colombia *** 2008<br />
Interfisa Financiera Grupo Internacional de Finanzas SAECA Paraguay ** 2008<br />
Invest Credit Invest Credit LLC NBCO Azerbaijan ** 2008<br />
Invest-Credit<br />
Moldova<br />
Invest-Credit Moldova Moldova * 2008<br />
Invirtiendo Invirtiendo S.A. de C.V. Mexico * 2008<br />
IPR Intean Poalroath RongRoeurng LTD Cambodia ** 2008<br />
Izdiharona<br />
Microfinance<br />
Relief International - Izdiharona Microfinance Iraq * 2008<br />
Jabal Al Hoss UNDP Rural Community Development in Jabal Al Hoss Syria * 2008<br />
88<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
APPENDICES<br />
ACRONYM NAME COUNTRY DATA QUALITY Year<br />
Jamii Bora Jamii Bora Kenya Ltd. Kenya * 2008<br />
Janodaya Janodaya Public Trust India ** 2008<br />
JCF Jagorani Chakra Foundation Bangladesh * 2008<br />
Jigiyaso Ba Jigiyaso Ba Mali * 2008<br />
Joldosh Group MCC Joldosh Group Kyrgyzstan * 2008<br />
JOVID Micro-loan fund 'JOVID' Tajikistan *** 2008<br />
JSC Bank Constanta JSC Bank Constanta Georgia ** 2008<br />
JSCCS Janasachetan Saving and Credit Cooperative Society Ltd. Nepal ** 2008<br />
Juaben RB Juaben Rural Bank Ghana ** 2008<br />
JVS Jeevum Vikas Samaj Nepal ** 2008<br />
JXWDA Jia Xian Women's Development Association China, People's<br />
Republic of<br />
** 2008<br />
KADET Kenya Agency to Development of Enterprise and Technology Kenya * 2008<br />
Kafo Jiginew Kafo Jiginew Mali ** 2008<br />
Kakum RB Kakum RB Ghana ** 2008<br />
KAMURJ Microenterprise Development Fund Kamurj Armenia ** 2008<br />
Kasagana-Ka Kasagana-Ka Development Foundation, Inc. Philippines ** 2008<br />
Kashf Foundation Kashf Foundation Pakistan ** 2008<br />
Kashf Bank Kashf Microfinance Bank Pakistan * 2008<br />
Kajnardza 96 Rural Credit Cooperative 'Kajnardza 96' Bulgaria * 2008<br />
Kazama Grameen Kazama Grameen, Inc. Philippines ** 2008<br />
KBank Kauswagan Bank Philippines ** 2008<br />
KBSLAB Krishna Bhima Samruddhi Local Area Bank Limited India ** 2008<br />
KCCDFI Kasanyangan-Mindanao Foundation, Inc. Philippines ** 2008<br />
Kemek MCO Kemek Kazakhstan * 2008<br />
KEP Kosovo Enterprise Program Kosovo ** 2008<br />
KGMAMF Kosovo Grameen Missione Arcobaleno Kosovo ** 2008<br />
Khan Bank Khan Bank (Agricultural Bank of Mongolia LLP) Mongolia ** 2008<br />
Khushhali Bank Khushhali Bank Pakistan ** 2008<br />
KixiCredito KixiCredito Angola * 2008<br />
KMB KMB Bank Russia ** 2008<br />
KMBI Kabalikat para sa Maunlad na Buhay, Inc. Philippines ** 2008<br />
KMF Kazmicrofinance, LLC (formerly KLF) Kazakhstan ** 2008<br />
Kokari Kokari Niger * 2008<br />
Komak Credit Komak Credit Union Azerbaijan ** 2008<br />
Kompanion Kompanion Financial Group Microfinance Closed Joint Stock Company Kyrgyzstan ** 2008<br />
Kondo Jigima Kondo Jigima Mali * 2008<br />
KOPSA KOPSA India ** 2008<br />
KosInvest KosInvest Kosovo ** 2008<br />
KPOSB Kenya Post Office Savings Bank Kenya * 2008<br />
Kredo Kredo Bulgaria ** 2008<br />
K-Rep K-Rep Bank Kenya ** 2008<br />
KRK Ltd<br />
Kreditimi Rural i Kosoves LLC (formerly Rural Finance Project of<br />
Kosovo)<br />
Kosovo ** 2008<br />
KRUSHI KRUSHI India ** 2008<br />
KSF Kraban Support Foundation Ghana * 2008<br />
KSK RPK KSK RPK Bulgaria ** 2008<br />
KVK CU 'Cash Department of Mutual Credit' Russia * 2008<br />
KVK-Altay Consumer Credit Cooperative 'KVK-Altay' Russia * 2008<br />
KWFT Kenya Women Finance Trust Kenya ** 2008<br />
La Community Bank La Community Bank Ghana ** 2008<br />
Lak Jaya Lak Jaya Micro Finance Ltd. Sri Lanka * 2008<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
89
APPENDICES<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
ACRONYM NAME COUNTRY DATA QUALITY Year<br />
LAM LAM Rural Microfinance PLC Romania ** 2008<br />
LAPO-NGR Lift Above Poverty Organisation Nigeria ** 2008<br />
LAPO-SLE LAPO-SLE Sierra Leone * 2008<br />
Lazika Capital Small Business Development Foundation Georgia *** 2008<br />
Lead Foundation Lead Foundation Egypt ** 2008<br />
Letta Letta Micro Finance Institution Share Company Ethiopia ** 2008<br />
LIDER LIDER Bosnia and<br />
Herzegovina<br />
** 2008<br />
Life Bank Life Bank Foundation, Inc. Philippines ** 2008<br />
LOK Microcredit<br />
Foundation<br />
LOK Microcredit Foundation<br />
Bosnia and<br />
Herzegovina<br />
*** 2008<br />
LSK Laafi Sira Kwieogo Burkina Faso ** 2008<br />
M7 Can Loc M7 Can Loc M7 Can Loc (or Pro-poor Center - PPC Ha Tinh) Vietnam * 2008<br />
M7 DB District M7 HuyÇn iÇn Biên Vietnam * 2008<br />
M7 DBP City M7 TP iÇn Biên Vietnam * 2008<br />
M7 Dong Trieu M7 ông TriÁu, Qu£ng Ninh Vietnam * 2008<br />
M7 Mai Son M7 Mai S¡n, S¡n La Vietnam * 2008<br />
M7 Ninh Phuoc M7 Ninh Phuoc Vietnam * 2008<br />
M7 Uong bi M7 Uông Bí, Qu£ng Ninh Vietnam * 2008<br />
Maata-N-Tudu Maata-N-Tudu Association Ghana ** 2008<br />
Madfa SACCO Madfa Cooperative Savings and Credit Society Uganda ** 2008<br />
MADRAC<br />
Microfinance Agency for Development and Rehabilitation of Afghan<br />
Communities<br />
Afghanistan ** 2008<br />
FAF-DC The First Albanian Financial Developme Albania ** 2008<br />
Mahasemam Mahasemam India ** 2008<br />
Mahashakti Mahashakti Foundation India ** 2008<br />
Mahila Mahila Women Cooperative Society Ltd. Nepal ** 2008<br />
Mahuli Mahuli Samudyik Bikas Kendra Nepal ** 2008<br />
Makhzoumi Makhzoumi Foundation Lebanon ** 2008<br />
Mallig Plains RB Mallig Plains Rural Bank (<strong>Is</strong>abela), Inc. Philippines ** 2008<br />
Manuela Ramos Movimiento Manuela Ramos Peru ** 2008<br />
Manushi Manushi Nepal ** 2008<br />
Maqsadi dasgiri MLF Maqsadi dasgiri Tajikistan * 2008<br />
Marang Marang Financial Services Ltd. South Africa ** 2008<br />
Maritsa Invest Rural Credit Cooperative 'Maritsa Invest' Bulgaria * 2008<br />
Maxima Maxima Cambodia *** 2008<br />
Mbinga CB Mbinga Community Bank Tanzania ** 2008<br />
MBK Ventura PT Mitra Bisnis Keluarga Ventura (formerly Ganesha) Indonesia *** 2008<br />
MC² Réseau MC² Cameroon * 2008<br />
MCL Molyn Credit Limited Kenya ** 2008<br />
MCN Micro Crédit National Haiti * 2008<br />
MCO 'Oral' MCO 'Oral' Kazakhstan * 2008<br />
MDF Micro Development Fund Serbia ** 2008<br />
MEC AFER<br />
MEC FEPRODES<br />
MECBAS<br />
Mutuelle d'Epargne et de Crédit de l'Association Femmes Entreprises Rurales<br />
du Nord<br />
MEC Fédération des groupements et associations des femmes productrices<br />
de la région de Saint-Louis<br />
Mutuelle d'Epargne et de Crédit du Bassin Arachidier et de la Zone Sylvo<br />
Pastorale<br />
Senegal ** 2008<br />
Senegal ** 2008<br />
Senegal * 2008<br />
MECREF Mutuelle d'Epargne et de Crédit des Femmes Niger * 2008<br />
MEDF Mindanao Enterprise Development Foundation Philippines ** 2008<br />
MED-Net Micro Enterprise Development Network Uganda ** 2008<br />
Meklit Meklit Ethiopia ** 2008<br />
MEMCO Middle East Microcredit Company Jordan ** 2008<br />
90<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
APPENDICES<br />
ACRONYM NAME COUNTRY DATA QUALITY Year<br />
MFI Microcredit Foundation of India India ** 2008<br />
MFW Microfund for Women Jordan ** 2008<br />
MGBB Madhyamanchal Grameen Bikas Bank Ltd. Nepal ** 2008<br />
MGPCC DEKAWOWO Mutuelle des Groupements de Producteurs de Café et Cacao Togo ** 2008<br />
MiBanco MiBanco Banco de la Microempresa SA Peru *** 2008<br />
MiBanco Venezuela MiBanco Banco de Desarrollo, CA Venezuela ** 2008<br />
MI-BO<strong>SP</strong>O MI-BO<strong>SP</strong>O Tuzla Bosnia and<br />
Herzegovina<br />
*** 2008<br />
Micro Africa Micro Africa Limited Kenya ** 2008<br />
Micro Start Micro Start Burkina Faso ** 2008<br />
MicroCred - MDG MicroCred Madagascar Madagascar ** 2008<br />
MicroCred - MEX MicroCred Mexico SAPI de CV SOFOM ENR Mexico ** 2008<br />
MicroCred - SEN MicroCred Senegal Senegal * 2008<br />
Micredito SAC Micredito SAC Peru ** 2008<br />
Coop MEDA Cooperativa de Ahorro y Crédito MICROEMPRESAS DE ANTIOQUIA AC Colombia *** 2008<br />
Microfinanciera<br />
Prisma<br />
Micro Financiera Prisma de Honduras, S.A. Honduras ** 2008<br />
Microinvest JV MFO Microinvest LLC Moldova ** 2008<br />
Microserfin Soluciones de Microfinanzas S.A. Panama ** 2008<br />
Microsol Fundación Microsol Paraguay ** 2008<br />
MIDE MICROCREDITO PARA EL DESARROLLO Peru ** 2008<br />
MIKRA MIKRA Bosnia and Herzegovina ** 2008<br />
Mikro ALDI Mikro ALDI Bosnia and<br />
Herzegovina<br />
** 2008<br />
Mikrofond Mikrofond Bulgaria ** 2008<br />
Mikrokredit Bank Mikrokredit Bank of Uzbekistan Uzbekistan ** 2008<br />
MikroMaliyye Credit MikroMaliyye Credit Institution Azerbaijan * 2008<br />
Mimo Finance Mimo Finance India ** 2008<br />
Miselini Miselini Mali * 2008<br />
Miziya Rural Credit Cooperative 'Miziya' Bulgaria * 2008<br />
MLF Chiluchor<br />
chashma<br />
MLF Chiluchor chashma Tajikistan * 2008<br />
MLF Kiropol Microloan Fund Kiropol Tajikistan * 2008<br />
MLF Madina Microloan Fund Madina Tajikistan * 2008<br />
MLF MicroInvest MLF MicroInvest Tajikistan ** 2008<br />
MLF MWI Microloan Foundation Malawi Malawi ** 2008<br />
MLF Vahsh Microfin Microloan Fund Vahsh Microfin Tajikistan * 2008<br />
MLO HUMO Microloan Organization 'HUMO and Partners' Tajikistan *** 2008<br />
MLO 'Saodat Invest' Microloan Organization 'Saodat Invest' Tajikistan * 2008<br />
MAMIDECOT Masaka Microfinance Development Cooperative Trust Ltd. Uganda ** 2008<br />
MMS Yayasan Mitra Masyarakat Sejahtera Indonesia * 2008<br />
MoFAD Micro Finance Agency for Development (CARE) Afghanistan * 2008<br />
Mol Bulak Finance MCC Mol-Bulak Kyrgyzstan *** 2008<br />
Moldir MCO Moldir Kazakhstan ** 2008<br />
Momina Voda Rural Credit Cooperative 'Momina Voda' Bulgaria * 2008<br />
Moris Rasik Moris Rasik East Timor ** 2008<br />
Moznosti Savings House Moznosti LLC Skopje Macedonia ** 2008<br />
MPGBB Madhya Pashimanchal Grameen Bikash Bank Nepal * 2008<br />
MUDE Asociación de Mujeres Desarrollo Guatemala * 2008<br />
MUL Micro Uganda Ltd Uganda ** 2008<br />
MUSCCO Malawi Union of Savings and Credit Cooperatives Malawi ** 2008<br />
Mutuelle Akwaba Mutuelle Akwaba Togo ** 2008<br />
Nachala Nachala Cooperative Bulgaria ** 2008<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
91
APPENDICES<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
ACRONYM NAME COUNTRY DATA QUALITY Year<br />
Nadejda CCCC 'Nadejda' Russia * 2008<br />
Nadejda 96 Rural credit cooperative 'Nadejda 96' Bulgaria * 2008<br />
Narodniy Kredit_<br />
Kemerov<br />
Narodniy Kredit_Kemerov Russia * 2008<br />
NBJK Nav Bharat Jagriti Kendra India * 2008<br />
NCS Nirantara Community Services India ** 2008<br />
NEED Network of Entrepreneurship and Economic Development India ** 2008<br />
Neftegaz Neftegaz Russia * 2008<br />
NeRuDO Nepal Rural Development Organization Nepal ** 2008<br />
NESDO National Educational & Social Development Organization Nepal * 2008<br />
New RB of<br />
Victorias<br />
New Rural Bank of Victorias Inc. Philippines ** 2008<br />
Nidan Nidan India ** 2008<br />
Nirdhan Nirdhan Utthan Bank Ltd. Nepal ** 2008<br />
NMF National Microfinance Foundation Yemen ** 2008<br />
NMFB Network Microfinance Bank Limited Pakistan ** 2008<br />
Normicro Norwegian Microcredit LLC Azerbaijan ** 2008<br />
Nov Credit Microloan Fund Nov Credit Tajikistan * 2008<br />
NovoBanco - MOZ NovoBanco Mozambique Mozambique ** 2008<br />
NRDSC Nepal Rural Development Society Centre Nepal * 2008<br />
NSBA North Sinai Businessmen Association Egypt * 2008<br />
Nwabiagya RB Nwabiagya Rural Bank Ghana ** 2008<br />
NWTF Negros Women for Tomorrow Foundation, Inc. Philippines ** 2008<br />
Nyesigiso Nyesigiso Mali ** 2008<br />
NYWDA Ningxia Yanchi Women's Development Association China, People's<br />
Republic of<br />
* 2008<br />
Obereg (Vladivostok) Obereg (Vladivostok) Russia * 2008<br />
OBM Opportunity Bank Montenegro Montenegro ** 2008<br />
OBS Opportunity Bank Serbia Serbia ** 2008<br />
OCSSCO Oromia Credit and Saving Share Company Ethiopia * 2008<br />
ODEF Financiera Organización de Desarollo Empresarial Femenino Financiera S.A. Honduras ** 2008<br />
Faulu - TZA Faulu Tanzania Limited Tanzania ** 2008<br />
OI China Opportunity International China China, People's<br />
Republic of<br />
* 2008<br />
OIBM Opportunity International Bank of Malawi Malawi ** 2008<br />
OISL Opportunity International Savings and Loans - Ghana Ghana ** 2008<br />
OLC Oportunidad Latinoamerica Colombia (OLC) Colombia * 2008<br />
OMB Opportunity Microfinance Bank Inc. Philippines * 2008<br />
OMRO Opportunity Microfinance Romania Romania ** 2008<br />
Oportunidad<br />
Microfinanzas<br />
Oportunidad Microfinanzas Mexico ** 2008<br />
Opportunity Albania Opportunity Albania (formerly PSHM) Albania ** 2008<br />
Opportunity Finance Opportunity Finance South Africa ** 2008<br />
Opportunity Kenya Opportunity Kenya Ltd. Kenya ** 2008<br />
Otiv Alaotra Otiv Alaotra Madagascar ** 2008<br />
Otiv Diana Otiv Diana Madagascar ** 2008<br />
Otiv Sambava Otiv Sambava Madagascar * 2008<br />
Otiv Tana Otiv Tana Madagascar * 2008<br />
Otuasekan RB Otuasekan RB Ghana ** 2008<br />
OXUS - AFG OXUS Afghanistan Afghanistan ** 2008<br />
OXUS - KGS OXUS Kyrgyzstan Kyrgyzstan ** 2008<br />
OXUS - TJK Micro-Lending Fund 'OXUS' Tajikistan ** 2008<br />
PADME<br />
Association pour la Promotion et l' Appui au Développement de<br />
MicroEntreprises<br />
Benin * 2008<br />
92<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
APPENDICES<br />
ACRONYM NAME COUNTRY DATA QUALITY Year<br />
PAIDEK PAIDEK Congo, Democratic<br />
Republic of the<br />
** 2008<br />
PALFSI People's Alternative Livelihood Foundation of Sorsogon, Inc. Philippines ** 2008<br />
PAMECAS Programme d'Appui aux Mutuelles d'Épargne et de Crédit au Sénégal Senegal ** 2008<br />
PAPME Agence pour la Promotion et l'Appui aux Petites et Moyennes Entreprises Benin ** 2008<br />
Parabank Parabank Azerbaijan ** 2008<br />
PARC Palestinian Agricultural Relief Committees Palestine * 2008<br />
Partner Partner Bosnia and<br />
Herzegovina<br />
** 2008<br />
Partner Russia Partner Russia Russia * 2008<br />
Parwaz Parwaz MicroFinance Institution Afghanistan * 2008<br />
PASECA - Kayes<br />
Programme d'Appui à la mise en place d'un Système d'Epargne et de Crédit<br />
Autogéré - Kayes<br />
Mali * 2008<br />
PASED Port Sudan Association for Small Enterprise Development Sudan ** 2008<br />
PATRA Hunchun PATRA Hunchun China, People's<br />
Republic of<br />
PATRA Yanbian PATRA Yanbian China, People's<br />
Republic of<br />
* 2008<br />
* 2008<br />
PAWDEP PAMOJAWOMEN DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME Kenya ** 2008<br />
PBC People's Bank of Caraga (RB of Talacogon) Philippines ** 2008<br />
PCWDA Pu Cheng Women's Development Organization China, People's<br />
Republic of<br />
** 2008<br />
PEACE Poverty Eradication & Community Empowerment Ethiopia ** 2008<br />
Perelik Rural Credit Cooperative 'Perelik' Bulgaria * 2008<br />
PGBB Western Region Grameen Bikas Bank Nepal ** 2008<br />
Plan International Plan International Vietnam Vietnam * 2008<br />
PNG Microfinance<br />
Ltd<br />
PNG Microfinance Limited Papua New Guinea ** 2008<br />
POMFB Pak-Oman Microfinance Bank Pakistan ** 2008<br />
Pomoriiski stopanin Rural Credit Cooperative 'Pomoriiski stopanin' Bulgaria * 2008<br />
Popular Kasa-<br />
Kystendil<br />
Popular Kasa-Kystendil Bulgaria * 2008<br />
Popular SAFI Popular S.A - Sociedad Administradora de Fondos de Inversión Peru ** 2008<br />
Povoljye CCCC 'Povoljye' Russia * 2008<br />
PR Bank Philippine Rural Banking Corp. Philippines * 2008<br />
PRASAC PRASAC MFI Ltd. Cambodia ** 2008<br />
PRESTANIC Asociación Fondo Nicaraguense para el Desarrollo Comunitario Nicaragua ** 2008<br />
PRIDE - TZA PRIDE Tanzania Tanzania ** 2008<br />
Pride Finance PRIDE Finance Guinea * 2008<br />
PRISMA Asociación Benefica Prisma Peru *** 2008<br />
PRIZMA PRIZMA Bosnia and<br />
Herzegovina<br />
** 2008<br />
ProCaja Asociación para el Desarrollo de las Cajas Rurales Panama ** 2008<br />
ProCredit - BOL Banco Los Andes ProCredit Bolivia ** 2008<br />
ProCredit - COL Banco ProCredit Colombia SA Colombia ** 2008<br />
ProCredit - ECU Banco ProCredit S.A. (Ex Sociedad Financiera Ecuatorial S.A. SFE) Ecuador ** 2008<br />
ProCredit - GHA ProCredit SLC Ghana Ghana ** 2008<br />
ProCredit - HND Banco ProCredit Honduras Honduras ** 2008<br />
ProCredit - MDA ProCredit Moldova - formerly MEC Moldova ** 2008<br />
ProCredit - NIC Banco ProCredit Nicaragua Nicaragua *** 2008<br />
ProCredit - SLV Banco ProCredit El Salvador El Salvador *** 2008<br />
ProCredit Bank - ALB ProCredit Bank Albania - formerly FEFAD Bank Albania ** 2008<br />
ProCredit Bank - BGR ProCredit Bank Bulgaria Bulgaria ** 2008<br />
ProCredit Bank - BIH ProCredit Bank Bosnia and Herzego vina Bosnia and<br />
Herzegovina<br />
** 2008<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
93
APPENDICES<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
ACRONYM NAME COUNTRY DATA QUALITY Year<br />
ProCredit Bank - GEO ProCredit Bank Georgia - formerly MBG Georgia ** 2008<br />
ProCredit Bank - KOS ProCredit Bank Kosovo - formerly MEB Kosovo ** 2008<br />
ProCredit Bank- MDA ProCredit Bank - MDA Moldova * 2008<br />
ProCredit Bank- MKD ProCredit Bank Macedonia Macedonia ** 2008<br />
ProCredit Bank- ROM ProCredit Bank Romania - formerly Miro Bank Romania ** 2008<br />
ProCredit Bank - SLE ProCredit Bank Sierra Leone Sierra Leone ** 2008<br />
ProCredit Bank - UKR ProCredit Bank Ukraine - formerly Microfinance Bank Ukraine ** 2008<br />
ProCredit Bank- DRC ProCredit Bank Congo Congo, Democratic<br />
Republic of the<br />
** 2008<br />
ProCredit Bank Serbia ProCredit Bank Serbia - formerly MFB Serbia ** 2008<br />
PRODEM FFP Fondo Financiero Privado PRODEM Bolivia ** 2008<br />
PRODESA Fundacion Para La Promocion y el Desarrollo Nicaragua ** 2008<br />
Progresar Fundación Progresar Argentina * 2008<br />
Progresemos Financiamiento Progresemos S.A. de C.V. SOFOM ENR Mexico ** 2008<br />
Progressive Bank Progressive Bank, Inc. Philippines ** 2008<br />
Pro Mujer - ARG ProMujer - ARG Argentina ** 2008<br />
Pro Mujer - BOL Programas para la Mujer - Bolivia Bolivia ** 2008<br />
Pro Mujer - MEX Asociación Pro Mujer de Mexico A.C. Mexico ** 2008<br />
Pro Mujer - NIC Programas para la Mujer - Nicaragua Nicaragua ** 2008<br />
Pro Mujer - PER Programas para la Mujer - Peru Peru ** 2008<br />
Pushtikar Pustikar Laghu VPBSSS Ltd. India * 2008<br />
PWMACS<br />
Payakaraopeta Women's Mutually Aided Co-operative Thrift and<br />
Credit Society<br />
India ** 2008<br />
RADE Regional Association to Develop Enterprise in Sohag Egypt * 2008<br />
Raduga Raduga Russia * 2008<br />
RAFODE Rural Agency for Development Kenya ** 2008<br />
RASS Rashtriya Seva Samithi India ** 2008<br />
RB Bagac Rural Bank of Bagac Philippines * 2008<br />
RB Cainta Rural Bank of Cainta Philippines ** 2008<br />
RB Camalig Rural Bank of Camalig (Albay), Inc. Philippines ** 2008<br />
RB Cotabato Rural Bank of Cotabato, Inc. Philippines ** 2008<br />
RB Digos Rural Bank of Digos Inc. Philippines ** 2008<br />
RB Dipolog Rural Bank of Dipolog Philippines *** 2008<br />
RB Guinobatan Rural Bank of Guinobatan, Inc. Philippines ** 2008<br />
RB Lebak Rural Bank of Lebak (Sultan Kudarat), Inc. Philippines ** 2008<br />
RB Liloy Rural Bank of Liloy, Inc. Philippines ** 2008<br />
RB Mabitac Rural Bank of Mabitac Inc. Philippines ** 2008<br />
RB Montevista Rural Bank of Montevista Philippines ** 2008<br />
RB Oroquieta Rural Bank of Oroquieta (Miss. Occ.), Inc. Philippines ** 2008<br />
RB Pagbilao Rural Bank of Pagbilao, Inc. Philippines ** 2008<br />
RB Placer Rural Bank of Placer Philippines * 2008<br />
RB San Jacinto Rural Bank of San Jacinto, Inc. Philippines ** 2008<br />
RB Siargao Rural Bank of Siargao Philippines ** 2008<br />
RB Solano Rural Bank of Solano Inc. Philippines ** 2008<br />
RB Talisayan Rural Bank of Talisayan - Misamis Oriental Inc. Philippines ** 2008<br />
RCCECG Réseau des Caisses Communautaires de Crédit et d'Epargne de Guinée Guinea ** 2008<br />
RCDS RCDS Pakistan ** 2008<br />
RCPB Réseau des caisses populaires du Burkina Faso Burkina Faso ** 2008<br />
Real Microcrédito Real Microcrédito Assessoria Financeira S.A. Brazil ** 2008<br />
Red de Vanguardia Red de Vanguardia, S.A. DE C.V. Mexico * 2008<br />
REDFunds REDFunds Africa Uganda ** 2008<br />
Reef Reef Finance Co. Palestine ** 2008<br />
Reliance Reliance Financial Services Company Limited Gambia, The ** 2008<br />
94<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
APPENDICES<br />
ACRONYM NAME COUNTRY DATA QUALITY Year<br />
Reserv-Altay Consumer Credit Cooperative 'Reserv-Altay' Russia * 2008<br />
Rezerv CCC "Rezerv" Russia * 2008<br />
RGVN Rashtriya Gramin Vikas Nidhi India ** 2008<br />
Rishenglong Rishenglong MicroCredit Company China, People's<br />
Republic of<br />
* 2008<br />
Riverbank Riverbank Credit SACCO Limited Kenya * 2008<br />
RML Rwanda Microfinance Limited Rwanda ** 2008<br />
ROMCOM ROMCOM Romania *** 2008<br />
Rost Consumer Credit Cooperative 'Rost' Russia * 2008<br />
R<strong>SP</strong>I Rangtay Sa Pagrangay Inc Philippines * 2008<br />
Rus CCC 'Rus' Russia * 2008<br />
WMN (Russia) ZAO NDCO Women's Microfinance Network Russia *** 2008<br />
Ryada Ryada - CHF International Palestine ** 2008<br />
São Paulo Confia Crédito Popular Solidário - São Paulo Confia Brazil ** 2008<br />
Saadhana Saadhana Microfin India ** 2008<br />
Sabaragamuwa Sabaragamuwa Development Bank Sri Lanka * 2008<br />
SABR SABR Uzbekistan * 2008<br />
Saglasie 96 Rural credit cooperative 'Saglasie 96' Bulgaria * 2008<br />
Sahara Mahila Sahara Mahila Saving & Credit Cooperative Society Ltd. Nepal * 2008<br />
Sajida Sajida Foundation Bangladesh * 2008<br />
Samasta Samasta Microfinance Ltd. India * 2008<br />
Samokov 96 Rural Credit Cooperative 'Samokov 96' Bulgaria * 2008<br />
Sanghamithra Sanghamitra Rural Financial Service India * 2008<br />
Sarala Sarala Women Welfare Society India ** 2008<br />
Sartawi Fundación SARTAWI Bolivia ** 2008<br />
Sarvodaya Nano<br />
Finance<br />
Sarvodaya Nano Finance Limited India * 2008<br />
SAT Sinapi Aba Trust Ghana ** 2008<br />
Sathapana Limited Sathapana Limited (formerly CEB) Cambodia ** 2008<br />
SB Bank Swabalamban Bikas Bank Ltd. Nepal ** 2008<br />
SBACD Sharkia Businessmen's Association for Community Development Egypt ** 2008<br />
SBS Union of Bank Workers Russia * 2008<br />
SCDA<br />
Sohag Community Development and Children with Special Needs<br />
Association<br />
Egypt * 2008<br />
SCNL Satin Creditcare Network Limited India ** 2008<br />
SDBL Sanasa Development Bank Ltd. Sri Lanka ** 2008<br />
SEAP Self-Reliance Economic Advancement Programme Nigeria ** 2008<br />
SED Small Enterprise Development (SED) Company Ltd. Thailand ** 2008<br />
SEDA Small Enterprise Development Agency Tanzania *** 2008<br />
SEEDS Sarvodaya Economic Enterprise Development Services Sri Lanka * 2008<br />
SEF-ARM SEF International Universal Credit Organization - Armenia Armenia ** 2008<br />
SEF-ZAF Small Enterprise Foundation (South Africa) South Africa * 2008<br />
Seilanithih Seilanithih Cambodia ** 2008<br />
SEM Fund Sénégal Ecovillage Microfinance Senegal * 2008<br />
SemiSol Semilla Solidaria, S.A. de C.V. Mexico * 2008<br />
Serviamus Serviamus Foundation Philippines ** 2008<br />
SEWA Bank Shri Mahila Sewa Sahakari Bank Ltd. India ** 2008<br />
SEWA Finance SEWA Finance Sri Lanka * 2008<br />
SFF Sevis Finansye Fonkoze Haiti * 2008<br />
SFPI Specialized Financial and Promotional Institution Ethiopia ** 2008<br />
SFSD Social Foundation for Sustainable Development Yemen * 2008<br />
Shakti Shakti Foundation for Disadvanatged Women Bangladesh ** 2008<br />
SHARE SHARE Microfin Ltd. India ** 2008<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
95
APPENDICES<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
ACRONYM NAME COUNTRY DATA QUALITY Year<br />
Siam Bank Siam Bank Philippines ** 2008<br />
SINERGIJA SINERGIJAplus Bosnia and<br />
Herzegovina<br />
** 2008<br />
SIPEM Société d'Investissement pour la Promotion des Entreprises à Madagascar Madagascar ** 2008<br />
SKDRDP Shri Kshetra Dharmasthala Rural Development Project India ** 2008<br />
SKS SKS Microfinance Private Limited India ** 2008<br />
SMEP Small and Micro Enterprise Project Kenya ** 2008<br />
SMILE SMILE India * 2008<br />
Smilyan Rural Credit Cooperative 'Smilyan' Bulgaria * 2008<br />
SMSS Star MicroFin Service Society, formerly SYA India ** 2008<br />
SOCIALCRED SOCIALCRED - Sociedade de Crédito ao Microempreendedor S/A Brazil ** 2008<br />
PADECOMSM Sociedad Cooperativa PADECOMSM Credito de RL de CV El Salvador ** 2008<br />
SOCRED SOCRED S/A - Sociedade de Crédito ao Microempreededor Ltda. Brazil * 2008<br />
Sodeystviye Consumer Credit Cooperative of Citizens 'Sodeystviye' Russia * 2008<br />
Sodeystviye-2005 Consumer Credit Cooperative of Citizens 'Sodeystviye-2005' Russia * 2008<br />
Sodruzhestvo Sodruzhestvo Russia ** 2008<br />
SOFINA SOFINA Cameroon ** 2008<br />
SOGESOL Société Générale Haitïenne de Solidarité Haiti * 2008<br />
Soglasiye Soglasiye Russia * 2008<br />
SolFi Soluciones Financieras S.C. Mexico * 2008<br />
Solidarnost Solidarnost Bulgaria * 2008<br />
Solución Asea Solución Asea S.A. de C.V. Sociedad Financiera Popular Mexico * 2008<br />
Soluciones Reales Soluciones Reales del Norte, SA DE CV Mexico * 2008<br />
Sonata Sonata Finance Private Ltd. India * 2008<br />
Soro Yiriwaso Soro Yiriwaso Mali * 2008<br />
South Akim RB South Akim RB Ghana ** 2008<br />
Soyuz-Khimik Soyuz-Khimik Russia * 2008<br />
SoyuzKredit SoyuzKredit Russia * 2008<br />
Soyuz-Primoroye Soyuz-Primoroye Russia * 2008<br />
Spandana Spandana Sphoorty Innovative Financial Services Ltd. India ** 2008<br />
<strong>SP</strong>BD South Pacific Business Development Samoa ** 2008<br />
<strong>SP</strong>GBB Sudur Pashimanchal Grameen Bikash Bank Nepal * 2008<br />
SSK Sakhi Samudaya Kosh India * 2008<br />
SSS Society for Social Services Bangladesh * 2008<br />
Stanichnik Consumer Credit Cooperative of Citizens Stanichnik Russia * 2008<br />
Stopanin Credit Cooperative 'Stopanin' Bulgaria * 2008<br />
SU Sahara Uttarayan India ** 2008<br />
Sugd Microfin Microloan Fund Sugd Microfin Tajikistan * 2008<br />
SUMI SUMI Sudan * 2008<br />
Sungi Sungi Development Foundation Pakistan * 2008<br />
Sunrise Microcredit Foundation Sunrise Bosnia and<br />
Herzegovina<br />
** 2008<br />
Mentors - PER Mentors Peru - Enterprise Mentors International Peru ** 2008<br />
SFPL Swadhaar FinServe Pvt. Ltd. India ** 2008<br />
SWAWS Sharada's Womes's Association for Weaker Section India ** 2008<br />
Tamweelcom Tamweelcom, formerly JMCC Jordan ** 2008<br />
Tchuma Tchuma Cooperativa de Crédito e Poupança Mozambique ** 2008<br />
Te Creemos Te Creemos, S.A. de C.V. SFP Mexico *** 2008<br />
TFS Transcapital Financial Services Co. Ltd. Mongolia ** 2008<br />
TIAVO TIAVO Madagascar * 2008<br />
TLM Tanaoba Lais Manekat Indonesia * 2008<br />
TMFB Tameer Microfinance Bank Pakistan ** 2008<br />
96<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
APPENDICES<br />
ACRONYM NAME COUNTRY DATA QUALITY Year<br />
TPC THANEAKEA PHUM (CAMBODIA) LTD. Cambodia ** 2008<br />
Trident Microfinance Annapurna Financial Services Private Limited India ** 2008<br />
Tsaritsinskiy passaj Tsaritsinskiy passaj Russia * 2008<br />
Tsimlyansk Tsimlyansk Credit Cooperative Russia * 2008<br />
TSKI Taytay Sa Kauswagan Inc. Philippines * 2008<br />
Tujijenge Tujijenge Tanzania Tanzania * 2008<br />
Turame Community<br />
Finance<br />
Turame Community Finance Burundi ** 2008<br />
Tverskoy Tverskoy Russia * 2008<br />
TYM TYM FUND Vietnam *** 2008<br />
UCADE Ambato Proyecto de Salud y Crédito Comunitario de la Diocesis de Ambato -<br />
UCADE - CRS<br />
Ecuador ** 2008<br />
UCADE Guaranda Fundación Promoción Humana Diocesana de Guaranda - UCADE - CRS Ecuador ** 2008<br />
UCADE Latacunga Proyecto Salud y Crédito Comunitario Diocesis de Latacunga - UCADE - CRS Ecuador ** 2008<br />
UCADE Santo<br />
Domingo<br />
UCCEC GY<br />
FUNDACIÓN ACCIÓN SOCIAL CARITAS FASCA PROMUJER SOLIDARIA<br />
- DIOCESIS DE SANTO DOMINGO - UCADE - CRS<br />
Union des Caisses Communautaires d'Epargne et de Crédit de Guimballa<br />
- Youwarou<br />
Ecuador ** 2008<br />
Mali * 2008<br />
UCEC/MK Union des Clubs d'Epargne et de Crédit du Mayo-Kebbi Chad ** 2008<br />
U-IMCEC<br />
Union des Institutions Mutualiste Communautaire d'Epargne et de<br />
Credit DAKAR<br />
Senegal ** 2008<br />
Ujjivan Ujjivan Financial Services Pvt. Ltd. India *** 2008<br />
UMECDES Union des Mutuelles d'Epargne et de Crédit pour l'Entreprenariat au Sénégal Senegal * 2008<br />
Umid CU Umid Uzbekistan * 2008<br />
Umid-Credit Umid-Credit (Umid HSSC) Azerbaijan * 2008<br />
UNACOOPEC-CI Union Nationale des Coopératives d’Epargne et de Crédit de Côte d’Ivoire Cote d'Ivoire<br />
(Ivory Coast)<br />
* 2008<br />
UNICREICH Union de Crédito Interestatal Chiapas, S.A. de C.V. Mexico ** 2008<br />
UNION DES COOPECs<br />
UMUTANGUHA<br />
UNION DES COOPECs UMUTANGUHA Rwanda ** 2008<br />
Union RB Union RB Ghana ** 2008<br />
UNRWA UNRWA Microfinance and Microenterprise Department Palestine ** 2008<br />
UOB Urwego Opportunity Bank Rwanda ** 2008<br />
Upper Manya RB Upper Manya Kro Rural Bank Limited Ghana ** 2008<br />
USFSBS Udmurt State Fund for Small Business Support Russia * 2008<br />
USTOI USTOI Bulgaria ** 2008<br />
Finance Trust Uganda Finance Trust Limited - formerly Uganda Women's Finance Trust Uganda ** 2008<br />
Valiant RB Valiant Rural Bank (Iloilo City) Inc. Philippines ** 2008<br />
VB<strong>SP</strong> Vietnam Bank for Social Policies Vietnam ** 2008<br />
VFC VisionFund Cambodia Ltd. - formerly MED program Cambodia ** 2008<br />
VFM Vision Fund Mongolia Mongolia ** 2008<br />
VFS Village Financial Services Private Ltd. India ** 2008<br />
Viator Viator Microcredit Azerbaijan LLC Azerbaijan ** 2008<br />
Visión Banco Visión Banco S.A.E.C.A. Paraguay *** 2008<br />
Vital Finance Vital Finance Benin ** 2008<br />
Vivir Soluciones Vivir Soluciones Financieras, SA de CV, SOFOM ER, BanRegio Grupo Financiero Mexico * 2008<br />
Vostok Kapital Citizens' Credit Consumer Cooperative 'Vostok Kapital' Russia * 2008<br />
VRFSBS Voronezh Regional Fund for Small Business Support Russia * 2008<br />
VSSU Vivekananda Sevakendra-o- Sishu Uddyan India * 2008<br />
VYCCU VYCCU Savings and Credit Cooperative Society Ltd. Nepal ** 2008<br />
WAGES Women and Associations for Gain both Economic and Social Togo ** 2008<br />
Wasasa Wasasa Ethiopia ** 2008<br />
Nationwide<br />
Microbank<br />
Nationwide Microbank Ltd, (formerly Wau Microbank) Papua New Guinea ** 2008<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc<br />
97
APPENDICES<br />
MICROBANKING BULLETIN, <strong>Is</strong>sue 19, DECEMBER 20<strong>09</strong><br />
ACRONYM NAME COUNTRY DATA QUALITY Year<br />
WDB Wayamba Development Bank Sri Lanka * 2008<br />
Wisdom Wisdom Ethiopia ** 2008<br />
WISE WISE Burundi * 2008<br />
WKP Wahana Kria Putri Indonesia * 2008<br />
WOCCU - AFG WOCCU Afghanistan Afghanistan * 2008<br />
Women for Women MCO Women for Women International Bosnia and<br />
Herzegovina<br />
** 2008<br />
World Relief - HND World Relief Honduras Honduras ** 2008<br />
WSE Welfare Services Ernakulam India * 2008<br />
WWB Cali Women's World Banking - Cali Colombia ** 2008<br />
WWI - AFG Women for Women - Afghanistan Afghanistan * 2008<br />
XacBank XacBank Mongolia ** 2008<br />
XXWDA XI Xiang Women's Development Association China, People's<br />
Republic of<br />
YYWDA Yu Yang Women's Development Association China, People's<br />
Republic of<br />
** 2008<br />
** 2008<br />
Zakoura Fondation Zakoura Morocco ** 2008<br />
98<br />
Microfinance Information eXchange, Inc
ABOUT MIX<br />
The Microfinance Information Exchange, Inc. (MIX)<br />
is the leading provider of data, benchmarks and<br />
analysis for the microfinance industry. Dedicated to<br />
strengthening the microfinance sector by promoting<br />
transparency, MIX provides detailed financial,<br />
operational and social performance data on<br />
microfinance institutions, in addition to general<br />
business information on investors, networks and<br />
service providers associated with the industry. MIX<br />
does this through a variety of publicly available<br />
platforms, including MIX Market<br />
(www.mixmarket.org) and the MicroBanking<br />
Bulletin.<br />
MIX is a non-profit company founded by CGAP (the<br />
Consultative Group to Assist the Poor) and sponsored<br />
by CGAP, the Citi Foundation, Deutsche Bank Americas<br />
Foundation, Omidyar Network, IFAD (International Fund<br />
for Agricultural Development), Bill & Melinda Gates<br />
Foundation, and others. MIX is a private corporation.<br />
Visit www.themix.org for more information.<br />
Microfinance Information Exchange, Inc.<br />
1901 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW Suite 307<br />
Washington, DC 20006<br />
Tel: +1 202 659 9<strong>09</strong>4<br />
Fax: +1 202 659 9<strong>09</strong>5<br />
e-mail: info@themix.org<br />
website: www.themix.org