National, International, Armenia, and Community News and Opinion
National, International, Armenia, and Community News and Opinion
National, International, Armenia, and Community News and Opinion
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
Arpa Film<br />
Festival to<br />
feature The<br />
River Ran Red<br />
See story on page 6m<br />
World-renowned<br />
doctors to perform<br />
50 life-changing<br />
surgeries<br />
See story on page 14m<br />
All that<br />
jazz<br />
See story on<br />
page C10m<br />
Western U.S. Edition<br />
Number 82<br />
October 4, 2008<br />
the armenian<br />
reporter<br />
Soldiers from the United States (far right), <strong>Armenia</strong> (far left), <strong>and</strong> other countries at the opening ceremony of NATO exercises in <strong>Armenia</strong>. Photo: Armen Hakobyan for the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter.<br />
Cooperative Longbow/Lancer<br />
NATO military training exercises<br />
commence in <strong>Armenia</strong><br />
Reporter.am<br />
See story on page 16 m
The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | October 4, 2008<br />
We’ll cut the<br />
closing costs.<br />
You cut<br />
the grass.<br />
Save over $1,000 on mortgage fees. *<br />
Whether you’re planning to buy or refinance a home, HSBC can provide the mortgage solution you<br />
need <strong>and</strong> the simplicity you want.Talk with an expert HSBC Mortgage Loan Consultant about your<br />
mortgage needs <strong>and</strong> get advice you can believe in from the bank with over 150 years of experience.<br />
PeterYuval - Sr. Mtg. Consultant<br />
818-471-7287<br />
peter.r.yuval@us.hsbc.com<br />
*Subject to credit approval. Actual savings may be more or less than those shown, but generally will exceed $1,000. Offer can b<br />
cannot be combined with other discounts <strong>and</strong> promotions <strong>and</strong> does not apply to broker originated mortgages. Offer cannot exceed t<br />
be applied at time of closing. Costs covered in offer are application fee, origination fee, commitment/underwriting fee, docume<br />
appraisal, credit report <strong>and</strong> MERS fee. Not available on all mortgage products or to HSBC employees.<br />
e cancelled <strong>and</strong> is subject to change at any time,<br />
otal allowable mortgage closing costs <strong>and</strong> will<br />
nt delivery, recording fee, flood certification,
Number 82<br />
October 4, 2008<br />
Editorial<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter endorses Obama-Biden<br />
“Seldom do we face such a straightforward<br />
choice,” the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter<br />
notes in its editorial this<br />
week. “As we compare the records<br />
of the c<strong>and</strong>idates for president<br />
<strong>and</strong> vice president of the United<br />
States, we find that, as U.S. citizens<br />
<strong>and</strong> as <strong>Armenia</strong>n-Americans,<br />
we have every reason to throw our<br />
strong support behind Senator<br />
Barack Obama <strong>and</strong> Senator Joe<br />
Biden.”<br />
The Obama-Biden ticket also<br />
enjoys the strong support of the<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n <strong>National</strong> Committee of<br />
America (ANCA) <strong>and</strong> the U.S.-<strong>Armenia</strong><br />
Public Affairs Committee<br />
(USAPAC).<br />
See editorial on page 18 m<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong><br />
World-renowned doctors to perform 50 lifechanging<br />
surgeries in <strong>Armenia</strong> this week<br />
<strong>Community</strong><br />
More than a dozen doctors, nurses,<br />
<strong>and</strong> other specialists are in Yerevan<br />
this week to perform 50 lifealtering<br />
operations on clients with<br />
cleft lip, cleft palate, or both, Paul<br />
Chaderjian reports.<br />
The operations will be realized<br />
through Project Smile. Project<br />
Smile was initiated by the Cafesjian<br />
Family Foundation, Hope for<br />
the City, <strong>and</strong> the Smile Network<br />
which leads similar projects around<br />
the world. The three Minneapolisbased<br />
organizations have come together<br />
to address cleft-care needs<br />
in <strong>Armenia</strong>.<br />
See story on page 14m<br />
A profile of Armen Stepanian, the Christopher<br />
Columbus of recycling<br />
Armen Stepanian began promoting<br />
recycling at a time when the<br />
United States was gripped with<br />
an energy crisis brought on by<br />
the OPEC oil embargo. As he witnessed<br />
the long lines in front of<br />
gas stations, he realized that the<br />
country’s energy future would be<br />
in peril without conservation <strong>and</strong><br />
sustainable consumption practices.<br />
It was in 1975 when Mr. Stepanian<br />
<strong>and</strong> a group of volunteers initiated<br />
Organizers of the William Saroyan<br />
Centennial Celebration are calling<br />
their year-long tribute to the Pulitzer<br />
Prize–winning author a success.<br />
A group of Saroyan enthusiasts<br />
from Fresno have spent three years<br />
planning the almost 100 individual<br />
projects in honor of Fresno’s native<br />
son. “It’s been extremely rewarding,”<br />
said Larry Balakian, one of<br />
the lead organizers of the Saroyan<br />
Centennial Celebration. Saroyan<br />
<strong>Community</strong><br />
<strong>Community</strong><br />
Barack Obama with Joe Biden on April<br />
8. AP Photo: Pablo Martinez Monsivais.<br />
<strong>and</strong> successfully implemented the<br />
first recycling program in Seattle.<br />
The initiative was to be the first<br />
of its kind in the United States.<br />
Hailed as a hero for both pioneering<br />
the recycling movement <strong>and</strong><br />
educating people to adopt conservation<br />
<strong>and</strong> recycling practices, Mr.<br />
Stepanian is unhappy with how the<br />
movement has evolved.<br />
See story on page 7m<br />
From lower left, Hratch Abdulian, Hratch Hovsepian, <strong>and</strong> Raffi Pilavian serving up<br />
prpoor at the second annual Gr<strong>and</strong> <strong>Armenia</strong>n Festival in Fresno.<br />
See story on page 8 m<br />
Saroyan centenary continues with Fresno events<br />
lived a good portion of his life in<br />
California’s San Joaquin Valley,<br />
drawing a great deal of inspiration<br />
from its agricultural communities.<br />
“Saroyan is one of the great giants,”<br />
said Edward EmanuEl, theater director<br />
at California State University,<br />
Fresno. “His work has reached<br />
millions. Saroyan is still as valuable<br />
today as when he was writing.”<br />
See story on page 9 m<br />
the armenian<br />
reporter<br />
Holy Muron is blessed at<br />
Etchmiadzin in ancient ritual<br />
Pilgrims joins<br />
bishops from around<br />
the world<br />
by Antranig Dereyan<br />
VAGHARSHAPAT, <strong>Armenia</strong> – It<br />
is an ancient ritual that typically<br />
takes place every seven years. In a<br />
ceremony that combined solemnity<br />
with pageantry, the Mother See<br />
of the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Church on Sunday,<br />
September 28, replenished its supply<br />
of muron, or chrism, the holy<br />
oil used for baptism, ordination,<br />
<strong>and</strong> other rituals.<br />
“It is the unity symbol of the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
Church,” said Archbishop<br />
Nerses Bozabalyan. The bishops<br />
come together to bless the chrism,<br />
<strong>and</strong> then each takes some of it to<br />
his diocese, where he distributes it<br />
to all the churches in his jurisdiction,<br />
the archbishop explained.<br />
The day was dark <strong>and</strong> gloomy,<br />
<strong>and</strong> rain seemed inevitable. But<br />
the ceremony would go on, rain or<br />
shine, at the open-air Saint Trdat<br />
altar at Etchmiadzin.<br />
Continued on page 11 m<br />
Abp. Barkev Martirossian holds a sacred relic, the right h<strong>and</strong> of Saint Gregory the<br />
Illuminator, while Catholicos Karekin II adds an ingredient to the muron, on Sept.<br />
28 at Etchmiadzin. Photo: Photolure.<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide Museum<br />
litigation moves to discovery phase<br />
Experts to examine<br />
books <strong>and</strong> records<br />
of Assembly <strong>and</strong><br />
AGM&M<br />
WASHINGTON – The U.S. District<br />
Court for the District of Columbia<br />
has confirmed the schedule for discovery<br />
<strong>and</strong> depositions in the ongoing<br />
litigation over the future of<br />
the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide Museum<br />
<strong>and</strong> Memorial (AGM&M) in Washington.<br />
The parties will be required<br />
to respond to interrogatories <strong>and</strong><br />
requests for the production of documents<br />
by mid-October. Depositions<br />
will begin in late November or<br />
early December, <strong>and</strong> be completed<br />
by mid-January.<br />
The project to develop <strong>and</strong> build<br />
a museum <strong>and</strong> memorial was<br />
launched over eight years ago, in<br />
2000, when Anoush Mathevosian<br />
<strong>and</strong> Gerard Cafesjian donated<br />
the funds to acquire a site in<br />
Washington.<br />
In November 2003 the project<br />
was transferred from the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
Assembly of America to a newly<br />
formed entity, the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide<br />
Museum <strong>and</strong> Memorial, Inc.<br />
The Assembly, however, was given a<br />
trustee position on AGM&M board.<br />
At that time, Mr. Cafesjian donated<br />
four additional properties, acquired<br />
at a cost of over $12,500,000, to exp<strong>and</strong><br />
the project site.<br />
Mr. Cafesjian <strong>and</strong> the Cafesjian<br />
Family Foundation are the largest<br />
supporters of the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide<br />
Museum <strong>and</strong> Memorial project,<br />
with pledges <strong>and</strong> donations of over<br />
$17,500.000. Mr. Cafesjian <strong>and</strong> CFF<br />
Trustee contributions to the AGMM<br />
Financial contributions by former <strong>and</strong> current members of the Board of<br />
Trustees of <strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide Museum <strong>and</strong> Memorial (AGMM) for the<br />
benefit of the AGMM as of September 2006.<br />
are entitled to three of the six votes<br />
on the AGM&M Board of Trustees.<br />
However, Mr. Hovnanian <strong>and</strong> the<br />
Assembly have used their board<br />
positions to block Mr. Cafesjian’s<br />
work on the project. Since May<br />
2007, Mr. Hovnanian <strong>and</strong> the Assembly<br />
have excluded Mr. Cafesjian<br />
<strong>and</strong> CFF from all AGM&M decisions,<br />
in breach of all donor agreements<br />
<strong>and</strong> the AGM&M by-laws.<br />
“Mr. Cafesjian donated over seventeen<br />
million dollars, <strong>and</strong> significant<br />
time <strong>and</strong> effort, in an attempt<br />
to help build the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
Genocide museum,” said Cafesjian<br />
Family Foundation Vice President<br />
John Waters. “Unfortunately, Mr.<br />
Cafesjian’s contributions have been<br />
met with no comparable support.<br />
Mr. Cafesjian still supports development<br />
of a museum project that<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>ns can be proud of.”<br />
The discovery stage of the litigation<br />
will require AGM&M <strong>and</strong> the<br />
Assembly to turn over their books<br />
<strong>and</strong> records to CFF. The Cafesjian<br />
Family Foundation’s legal <strong>and</strong> financial<br />
experts will then examine<br />
those books <strong>and</strong> records in detail,<br />
in order to determine the precise<br />
nature of the Assembly’s actions<br />
in breaching its donor agreements<br />
with Mr. Cafesjian.<br />
“We are looking forward to telling<br />
our story, under oath, including<br />
our motivations <strong>and</strong> efforts in<br />
planning <strong>and</strong> designing the museum.<br />
We are confident the truth will<br />
emerge <strong>and</strong> the issues will be resolved<br />
so that the project can move<br />
forward,” said Mr. Waters. f
The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | October 4, 2008<br />
<strong>National</strong><br />
Washington briefing<br />
as a text sent to the ANCA on February<br />
1. Both communications<br />
acknowledged the <strong>Armenia</strong>n community’s<br />
contributions to America<br />
<strong>and</strong> <strong>Armenia</strong>’s cooperation<br />
with the United States, but did<br />
not promise any positive changes<br />
in U.S. policy on matters of significance<br />
to <strong>Armenia</strong>n-Americans,<br />
such as the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide<br />
issue.<br />
Levan<br />
Gachechiladze<br />
with Zeyno<br />
Baran of Hudson<br />
Institute. Photo:<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
Reporter.<br />
by Emil Sanamyan <strong>and</strong><br />
Lusine Sarkisyan<br />
U.S. Ambassador-<br />
Designate to Turkey<br />
clarifies position on<br />
Genocide<br />
U.S. ambassadors to Ottoman Turkey<br />
Henry Morgenthau (1913–16)<br />
<strong>and</strong> Abram Elkus (1916–17) <strong>and</strong><br />
other contemporary U.S. diplomats<br />
described in their communications<br />
“an attempt to exterminate the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
population,” ambassadordesignate<br />
to Turkey James Jeffrey<br />
noted in a written response<br />
to questions for the record from<br />
Senate Foreign Relations Committee<br />
Chair <strong>and</strong> vice-presidential c<strong>and</strong>idate<br />
Sen. Joe Biden (D.-Del.)<br />
The exchange, released by the<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n <strong>National</strong> Committee of<br />
America (ANCA) on September 26,<br />
was part of the Senate committee’s<br />
consideration of Mr. Jeffrey’s c<strong>and</strong>idacy<br />
to be the next U.S. ambassador<br />
to Turkey <strong>and</strong> a congressional<br />
effort to correct the Bush administration<br />
language on the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
Genocide.<br />
Mr. Jeffrey promised that if<br />
confirmed he would continue to<br />
encourage “Turkey to come to<br />
terms with the dark spots in its<br />
history <strong>and</strong> establishing an honest<br />
dialogue within Turkey on these<br />
events,” as well as support normalization<br />
of relations between Turkey<br />
<strong>and</strong> <strong>Armenia</strong>.<br />
Meanwhile, Senator John Mc-<br />
Cain of Arizona, the Republican<br />
presidential c<strong>and</strong>idate, released<br />
a statement to <strong>Armenia</strong>n-Americans<br />
on September 29. The statement<br />
was substantially the same<br />
Says scope of<br />
program shrunk<br />
because of dram<br />
appreciation<br />
by Emil Sanamyan<br />
Ambassador Nabi Sensoy of Turkey,<br />
who attended an Independence Day<br />
reception at the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Embassy<br />
in Washington. Photo: Embassy of<br />
Turkey.<br />
Senior U.S., Russian,<br />
<strong>and</strong> Turkish officials<br />
mark <strong>Armenia</strong>’s<br />
independence<br />
U.S. Assistant Secretary of Commerce<br />
David Bohigian, the U.S.<br />
State Department’s coordinator<br />
for Eurasian energy, Ambassador<br />
Steven Mann, newly appointed<br />
Russian ambassador to the United<br />
States Sergei Kislyak, <strong>and</strong>, significantly,<br />
Ambassador Nabi Sensoy<br />
of Turkey were among more<br />
than 100 guests at a reception on<br />
September 30 at the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
Embassy in Washington to mark<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>’s independence.<br />
According to present <strong>and</strong> former<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n Embassy staff, this was<br />
the first time since the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
Embassy in the United States was<br />
established that a Turkish Ambassador<br />
attended one of its formal<br />
functions. Ambassador Sensoy’s<br />
unprecedented gesture comes<br />
weeks after the first-ever visit to<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong> by a Turkish president.<br />
(One source told the Reporter<br />
that in 1999 Turkish Ambassador<br />
Baki Ilkin together with Azerbaijani<br />
Ambassador Hafiz Pashayev<br />
visited the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Embassy to<br />
pay an informal farewell to outgoing<br />
Ambassador Ruben Shugarian.<br />
But neither Turkish nor Azerbaijani<br />
diplomats have attended Independence<br />
Day or Armed Forces<br />
Day receptions regularly held by<br />
the Embassy.)<br />
WASHINGTON – In public remarks<br />
at the headquarters of the<br />
Millennium Challenge Corporation<br />
(MCC) on October 1, Alex Russin,<br />
the corporation’s resident country<br />
director for <strong>Armenia</strong>, outlined the<br />
program’s goals, while sharing his<br />
concerns about <strong>Armenia</strong>’s continued<br />
eligibility under the good-governance<br />
criteria.<br />
Mr. Russin said that only about<br />
$20 million has been spent in nearly<br />
two years since the $235 million,<br />
five-year program was launched.<br />
Another $4.7 million request for<br />
funds is now pending.<br />
The work so far has included<br />
the completion of one canal system,<br />
the repair of 24 kilometers<br />
of mountainous rural roads just<br />
Prime Minister Tigran Sarkisian of<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong> will visit Washington October<br />
9–14.<br />
Coming up: <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
prime minister plans<br />
U.S. visit<br />
Prime Minister Tigran Sarkisian<br />
will visit Washington between<br />
October 9 <strong>and</strong> 14, U.S. <strong>and</strong><br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n officials familiar with<br />
the visit’s planning told the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
Reporter. Mr. Sarkisian,<br />
for whom this will be the first<br />
visit in his capacity as prime minister,<br />
will meet U.S. officials <strong>and</strong><br />
participate in the annual meetings<br />
of the World Bank <strong>and</strong> the<br />
<strong>International</strong> Monetary Fund on<br />
October 11–13.<br />
Georgian opposition<br />
leaders flock to the<br />
United States<br />
Levan Gachechiladze, the main<br />
opposition c<strong>and</strong>idate in the Georgian<br />
presidential election in January<br />
2008, this week became the<br />
latest Georgian pro-Western opposition<br />
leader to visit the United<br />
States.<br />
Speaking at the Hudson Institute,<br />
a conservative think tank,<br />
on September 30 about the recent<br />
developments in his country,<br />
south of Gyumri, <strong>and</strong> the training<br />
of about 15,000 farmers, with a total<br />
of 60,000 farmers to be trained.<br />
Mr. Russin said that the tempo of<br />
the program will ramp up in the<br />
next three years.<br />
Significantly, because of the<br />
decline in value of the U.S. dollar,<br />
coupled with <strong>Armenia</strong>’s strong economic<br />
growth, which has strengthened<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>’s currency, the MCA-<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong> has been forced to scale<br />
back the scope of work, with 350 kilometers<br />
of roads now planned for<br />
renovation instead of the original<br />
goal of 900 kilometers.<br />
Mr. Russin has also expressed<br />
concern that the political situation<br />
in <strong>Armenia</strong> hangs like a “cloud”<br />
over the program. When asked<br />
what steps from the government<br />
he is anticipating that would keep<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong> eligible for MCC aid, Mr.<br />
Russin generally pointed to the<br />
Mr. Gachechiladze argued that it<br />
has become “impossible” to unite<br />
around the current Georgian leader<br />
Mikheil Saakashvili since he<br />
makes “wrong decisions” <strong>and</strong> there<br />
are serious questions about his<br />
leadership since Georgia’s brief but<br />
militarily disastrous war with Russia<br />
last month.<br />
Mr. Gachechiladze warned that<br />
unless Mr. Saakashvili promptly<br />
restores democratic freedoms <strong>and</strong><br />
shares power with the opposition,<br />
“destabilization” will follow.<br />
Georgia’s former acting president<br />
<strong>and</strong> parliament speaker until<br />
earlier this year Nino Burjanadze,<br />
David Usupashvili of the Republican<br />
Party, <strong>and</strong> David Gamkrelidze<br />
of the New Rights Party have all<br />
visited the United States since the<br />
August war.<br />
In a September 8 commentary,<br />
the Washington Post’s Jackson<br />
Diehl revealed that “American<br />
officials are still seething at Saakashvili<br />
[over] his impulsive <strong>and</strong><br />
militarily foolhardy attack on<br />
South Ossetia,” provoking the<br />
Russian counter-attack <strong>and</strong> thus<br />
causing an “embarrassment” to<br />
the West.<br />
“The truth is that it would be<br />
considerably easier for the United<br />
States to defend Georgia <strong>and</strong> its<br />
democracy if it did not have to defend<br />
– <strong>and</strong> depend on – Saakashvili<br />
himself,” Mr. Diehl argued.<br />
Although both President George<br />
W. Bush <strong>and</strong> Mr. Saakashvili were<br />
at the United Nations General Assembly<br />
last week, no meeting between<br />
the two has been reported.<br />
Russia touts selfdetermination<br />
in “miniempires”<br />
Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov<br />
of Russia, who was in New York<br />
last week for the United Nations<br />
General Assembly, offered Russia’s<br />
views on relations with the United<br />
States <strong>and</strong> international developments<br />
in light of the war in Georgia<br />
in an extensive presentation to the<br />
MCC <strong>Armenia</strong> rep.: $20 million disbursed in two years<br />
Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov of<br />
Russia advocated self-determination.<br />
Photo: Wikimedia.<br />
Council on Foreign Relations on<br />
September 24.<br />
Mr. Lavrov spoke at length on<br />
nations’ right to self-determination,<br />
which the Russian minister<br />
recalled has long been the “mantra”<br />
of U.S. foreign policy <strong>and</strong> was<br />
described as “one of the noblest<br />
ideas in our world” by Vice President<br />
Dick Cheney during his visit<br />
to Italy on September 6.<br />
Mr. Lavrov argued that in addition<br />
to major empires, “there exist<br />
mini-empires <strong>and</strong> the same attitude<br />
ought to apply to them. If we are to<br />
be guided by principle rather than<br />
bias <strong>and</strong> political conjecture, the<br />
size should not make difference.”<br />
He went on: “The relevant issues<br />
are those of oppression, of threat<br />
of genocide, of central authorities’<br />
inability or unwillingness to bring<br />
the minority into the fold peacefully<br />
by way of persuasion, creating<br />
a climate of confidence <strong>and</strong> trust,<br />
providing a decent <strong>and</strong> caring government<br />
for all citizens.”<br />
Speaking of his country’s actions<br />
in support of South Ossetia <strong>and</strong><br />
Abkhazia, Mr. Lavrov suggested<br />
that “Russia is now an advocate of<br />
such principles of America as live<br />
<strong>and</strong> let live, give <strong>and</strong> take, helping<br />
the underdog!” Minister Lavrov’s<br />
remarks in full can be found at<br />
http://www.cfr.org.<br />
f<br />
need for reforms that would satisfy<br />
local civil-society groups as well as<br />
an effective fight against corruption<br />
pledged by the government.<br />
Previously, during a visit with<br />
the <strong>Armenia</strong>n community in Detroit<br />
on August 5, MCC Chief Executive<br />
Officer Ambassador John<br />
Danilovich told the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter<br />
that the <strong>Armenia</strong> program<br />
was “moving ahead in all respects.”<br />
He also sounded optimistic about<br />
the <strong>Armenia</strong>n government’s ability<br />
to implement needed democratic<br />
reforms.<br />
In his September 3 speech to<br />
the <strong>Armenia</strong>n diplomatic corps,<br />
President Serge Sargsian underscored<br />
MCC’s importance for <strong>Armenia</strong>,<br />
while also noting “certain<br />
foot-dragging with regard to the<br />
program’s” implementation. Mr.<br />
Sargsian expressed hope that the<br />
“efforts of the <strong>Armenia</strong>n authorities<br />
so far will be understood correctly,<br />
<strong>and</strong> the opportunity will be<br />
given to continue the project jointly<br />
agreed to.”<br />
The MCC Board of Directors held<br />
its quarterly meeting on September<br />
17. No new decisions on <strong>Armenia</strong><br />
were announced. The meeting<br />
focused on provision of a possible<br />
$100 million in additional aid to<br />
Georgia.<br />
On September 29, the MCC welcomed<br />
legislation that would make<br />
it possible to extend compact implementation<br />
from five to up to<br />
ten years <strong>and</strong> would also authorize<br />
conclusion of concurrent <strong>and</strong> additional<br />
compacts. MCC also praised<br />
efforts of members of the House of<br />
Representatives to keep the corporation’s<br />
total funding at about $1.54<br />
billion in Fiscal Year 2009. f<br />
connect: www.mcc.gov
The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | October 4, 2008<br />
<strong>National</strong><br />
John McCain writes to<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n-Americans<br />
Barack Obama emphasizes the<br />
importance of U.S.-<strong>Armenia</strong> relations<br />
<br />
The following letter was issued on October<br />
1, 2008.<br />
Dear Friends,<br />
The <strong>Armenia</strong>n-American community<br />
has contributed richly to the<br />
American fabric <strong>and</strong> has been instrumental<br />
in ensuring that a terrible<br />
tragedy is never forgotten.<br />
It is fair to say that one of the<br />
greatest tragedies of the 20th century,<br />
the brutal murder of as many<br />
as one <strong>and</strong> a half million <strong>Armenia</strong>ns<br />
under the rule of the Ottoman<br />
Empire, has also been one of<br />
the most neglected. The suffering<br />
endured by the <strong>Armenia</strong>n people<br />
during that period represented<br />
the prologue to what has come to<br />
be known as humanity’s bloodiest<br />
century. It is our responsibility to<br />
recognize those tragic events <strong>and</strong><br />
to ensure that our world never experiences<br />
the impact of the bloody<br />
conflicts that so filled the 20th<br />
century.<br />
In light of that history, the rise<br />
of the independent Republic of<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong> from such painful experiences<br />
is inspirational, as is the<br />
vibrancy of the <strong>Armenia</strong>n diaspora.<br />
In particular, I deeply admire<br />
both <strong>Armenia</strong>’s support of coalition<br />
operations in Iraq <strong>and</strong> NATO<br />
peacekeeping efforts in Kosovo. In<br />
my visits to <strong>Armenia</strong>, I have been<br />
deeply impressed by the resilient<br />
<strong>and</strong> hard working <strong>Armenia</strong>n people<br />
who have made tremendous<br />
progress in very difficult circumstances.<br />
Our country is greatly enriched<br />
by the descendents of the victims<br />
<strong>and</strong> survivors of the horrific tragedy<br />
that befell the <strong>Armenia</strong>n people.<br />
Republican presidential c<strong>and</strong>idate Sen.<br />
John McCain of Arizona, accompanied<br />
by his running mate, Alaska Gov.<br />
Sarah Palin, during a campaign rally at<br />
Capital University in Bexley, Ohio, on<br />
Sept. 29. AP Photo:Paul Vernon.<br />
Today <strong>Armenia</strong>n-Americans represent<br />
that indestructible spirit of a<br />
people <strong>and</strong> embody the principles<br />
of freedom <strong>and</strong> democracy that all<br />
Americans prize above all else. I am<br />
grateful for all of the contributions<br />
that <strong>Armenia</strong>n-Americans have<br />
made to our wonderful country<br />
<strong>and</strong> I greatly value the opportunity<br />
to st<strong>and</strong> with the <strong>Armenia</strong>n-American<br />
community in my campaign<br />
<strong>and</strong> as the next President of the<br />
United States.<br />
Sincerely,<br />
John McCain<br />
f<br />
The following statement was issued<br />
on January 19, 2008.<br />
I am proud of my strong record on<br />
issues of concern to the one <strong>and</strong><br />
a half million Americans of <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
heritage in the United States.<br />
I warmly welcome the support of<br />
this vibrant <strong>and</strong> politically active<br />
community as we change how our<br />
government works here at home,<br />
<strong>and</strong> restore American leadership<br />
abroad.<br />
I am a strong supporter of a U.S.-<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n relationship that advances<br />
our common security <strong>and</strong><br />
strengthens <strong>Armenia</strong>n democracy.<br />
As President, I will maintain our<br />
assistance to <strong>Armenia</strong>, which has<br />
been a reliable partner in the fight<br />
against terrorism <strong>and</strong> extremism.<br />
I will promote <strong>Armenia</strong>n security<br />
by seeking an end to the Turkish<br />
<strong>and</strong> Azerbaijani blockades, <strong>and</strong><br />
by working for a lasting <strong>and</strong> durable<br />
settlement of the Nagorno<br />
Karabagh conflict that is agreeable<br />
to all parties, <strong>and</strong> based upon<br />
America’s founding commitment<br />
to the principles of democracy<br />
<strong>and</strong> self determination. And my<br />
Administration will help foster<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>’s growth <strong>and</strong> development<br />
through exp<strong>and</strong>ed trade <strong>and</strong><br />
targeted aid, <strong>and</strong> by strengthening<br />
the commercial, political, military,<br />
developmental, <strong>and</strong> cultural relationships<br />
between the U.S. <strong>and</strong><br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n governments.<br />
I also share with <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
Americans – so many of whom<br />
are descended from genocide survivors<br />
- a principled commitment<br />
to commemorating <strong>and</strong> ending<br />
genocide. That starts with acknowledging<br />
the tragic instances<br />
of genocide in world history. As<br />
a U.S. Senator, I have stood with<br />
the <strong>Armenia</strong>n American community<br />
in calling for Turkey’s<br />
acknowledgement of the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
Genocide. Two years ago, I<br />
criticized the Secretary of State<br />
for the firing of U.S. Ambassador<br />
to <strong>Armenia</strong>, John Evans, after he<br />
properly used the term “genocide”<br />
to describe Turkey’s slaughter of<br />
thous<strong>and</strong>s of <strong>Armenia</strong>ns starting<br />
in 1915. I shared with Secretary<br />
Rice my firmly held conviction<br />
that the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide<br />
is not an allegation, a personal<br />
opinion, or a point of view, but<br />
rather a widely documented fact<br />
supported by an overwhelming<br />
body of historical evidence. The<br />
facts are undeniable. An official<br />
policy that calls on diplomats to<br />
distort the historical facts is an<br />
untenable policy. As a senator, I<br />
strongly support passage of the<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide Resolution<br />
(H.Res.106 <strong>and</strong> S.Res.106), <strong>and</strong> as<br />
President I will recognize the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
Genocide.<br />
Sen. Joe Biden<br />
(D.-Del.), left,<br />
talks with Sen.<br />
Barack Obama<br />
(D.-Ill.), prior to<br />
the start of the<br />
first Democratic<br />
presidential<br />
primary debate<br />
in Orangeburg,<br />
S.C., on April<br />
26, 2007. AP<br />
Photo: J. Scott<br />
Applewhite.<br />
Genocide, sadly, persists to this<br />
day, <strong>and</strong> threatens our common<br />
security <strong>and</strong> common humanity.<br />
Tragically, we are witnessing in Sudan<br />
many of the same brutal tactics<br />
– displacement, starvation, <strong>and</strong><br />
mass slaughter – that were used by<br />
the Ottoman authorities against<br />
defenseless <strong>Armenia</strong>ns back in 1915.<br />
I have visited Darfurian refugee<br />
camps, pushed for the deployment<br />
of a robust multinational force<br />
for Darfur, <strong>and</strong> urged divestment<br />
from companies doing business in<br />
Sudan. America deserves a leader<br />
who speaks truthfully about the<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide <strong>and</strong> responds<br />
forcefully to all genocides. I intend<br />
to be that President.<br />
I look forward, as President, to<br />
continuing my active engagement<br />
with <strong>Armenia</strong>n American leaders<br />
on the full range of issues of concern<br />
to the <strong>Armenia</strong>n American<br />
community. Together, we will build,<br />
in new <strong>and</strong> exciting ways, upon<br />
the enduring ties <strong>and</strong> shared values<br />
that have bound together the<br />
American <strong>and</strong> <strong>Armenia</strong>n peoples<br />
for more than a century. f<br />
ANCA Capital Gateway Program opens public policy doors for<br />
Fall 2008 participants<br />
WASHINGTON – The <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
<strong>National</strong> Committee of America<br />
(ANCA) Capital Gateway Program<br />
welcomed five new participants<br />
to the nation’s capital this month,<br />
each eager to embark on careers in<br />
politics <strong>and</strong> public policy.<br />
Now in its fifth consecutive year,<br />
the Gateway Program helps applicants<br />
attain exciting internships<br />
<strong>and</strong> challenging full-time public<br />
policy jobs in the nation’s capital.<br />
To date, over 40 fellows have gone<br />
through the program <strong>and</strong> secured<br />
positions in dozens of Congressional<br />
offices, as well as media <strong>and</strong> political<br />
institutions such as Congressional<br />
Quarterly, the U.S. Chamber<br />
of Commerce, Export-Import Bank<br />
(EXIM), SRCP Media, <strong>and</strong> the World<br />
Bank.<br />
The five Fall 2008 participants hit<br />
the ground running in Washington,<br />
l<strong>and</strong>ing Congressional internships<br />
within weeks of their arrival. “Being<br />
in D.C. for only a week <strong>and</strong> having<br />
already secured internships on<br />
the Hill is very exciting for both<br />
me <strong>and</strong> my colleagues,” said Meri<br />
Telelyan, a recent University of<br />
California, Santa Barbara graduate<br />
currently interning for Rep. Mike<br />
Thompson (D.-Calif.) “Of course,<br />
our ultimate goal is to find permanent<br />
positions working in Congress.”<br />
Joining Ms. Telelyan is fellow<br />
UC Santa Barbara graduate Grigor<br />
Mirza-Avakyan, who is interning<br />
with Rep. Sam Farr (D.-Calif.)<br />
Mikael Kourinian <strong>and</strong> Shant<br />
Nahapetian, both from California<br />
<strong>and</strong> both with master’s degrees in<br />
public administration, have also set<br />
in motion their careers in Washington<br />
with internships for Rep. Joseph<br />
Crowley (D.-N.Y.) <strong>and</strong> Rep.<br />
Howard Berman (D.-Calif.), respectively.<br />
A fifth participant, from<br />
Detroit, Aleek Kahramanian, was<br />
the final fellow to arrive <strong>and</strong> join<br />
her new roommates at the Gateway<br />
house, located just a stone’s throw<br />
from the White House. Ms. Kahramanian<br />
is interning with Senate<br />
Armed Services Committee chair<br />
Carl Levin (D.-Mich.)<br />
“It is often difficult to pick up<br />
one’s life, leave family <strong>and</strong> friends,<br />
<strong>and</strong> move across country to pursue<br />
a dream,” said Mr. Nahapetian. “But<br />
the ANCA Capital Gateway program<br />
provides the resources, mentoring,<br />
<strong>and</strong> encouragement to significantly<br />
ease the burdens such a drastic life<br />
change may entail.”<br />
In addition to excelling academically<br />
<strong>and</strong> having a passion<br />
for politics, each of the five fellows<br />
has demonstrated a track<br />
record of commitment to the <strong>Armenia</strong>n-American<br />
community.<br />
Mr. Kourinian recently wrapped<br />
up a summer internship with the<br />
ANC-WR <strong>and</strong> looks forwarding to<br />
ANCA Capital<br />
Gateway<br />
Program Fall<br />
2008 participants<br />
Grigor Mirza-<br />
Avakyan, Meri<br />
Telelyan, Mikael<br />
Kourinian, Aleek<br />
Kahramanian,<br />
<strong>and</strong> Shant<br />
Nahapetian.<br />
ANCA photo.<br />
h<strong>and</strong>ling <strong>Armenia</strong>n-American issues<br />
as one of his main tasks for<br />
Rep. Crowley. “I am grateful to the<br />
ANCA Capital Gateway Program<br />
for giving me the opportunity<br />
to make my dream of working in<br />
Congress <strong>and</strong> addressing <strong>Armenia</strong>n-American<br />
issues a reality,”<br />
said. Mr. Kourinian. He is also interning<br />
with the Hudson Institute<br />
in his pursuit of a policy position<br />
in a think tank.<br />
As in the past, Washington-area<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n-American policy professionals<br />
have reached out to the<br />
ANCA Capital Gateway fellows, offering<br />
them valuable advice <strong>and</strong> encouragement.<br />
Among community<br />
activists always ready to share insights<br />
is Senate Banking Committee<br />
Senior Counsel Dean Shahinian,<br />
who brings insight both from<br />
the Congressional <strong>and</strong> U.S. government<br />
agency perspective.<br />
“It’s wonderful how many doors<br />
suddenly appear in front of you<br />
when you get here,” said Mr. Mirza-Avakyan.<br />
“Regardless of what<br />
preconceptions you might have<br />
had, it’s hard to have anything but<br />
confidence that you’re in the right<br />
place at the right time.”<br />
Established through a generous<br />
donation from the Cafesjian<br />
Family Foundation, the Capital<br />
Gateway Program over the years<br />
has benefited tremendously from<br />
the generosity of donors committed<br />
to creating public service opportunities<br />
for young <strong>Armenia</strong>n-<br />
Americans. The leading financial<br />
contributor to the program has<br />
been the family of Hovig Apo<br />
Saghdejian, a 23-year old youth<br />
leader <strong>and</strong> community activist<br />
from Fresno, California, who lost<br />
his life in 2004 in a tragic car accident.<br />
His family established the<br />
Hovig Apo Saghdejian Memorial<br />
Fund in his memory. Substantial<br />
support has also been provided by<br />
longtime ANCA benefactors Frank<br />
<strong>and</strong> Barbara Hekimian <strong>and</strong> the<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n American Veterans Post<br />
of Milford, Massachusetts (AAVO).<br />
For more information, email<br />
ANCA Capital Gateway Program Director<br />
Serouj Aprahamian. f<br />
connect: serouj@anca.org
4 The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | October 4, 2008<br />
<strong>Community</strong><br />
Donna Evans <strong>and</strong> Hranush Hakobyan to address aiwa Buenos<br />
Aires Conference in November<br />
The Fifth <strong>International</strong> Conference<br />
of the <strong>Armenia</strong>n <strong>International</strong><br />
Women’s Association, to be convened<br />
in Buenos Aires November<br />
9 to 12, will have as its overall focus<br />
“Continent to Continent: <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
Women Interacting in Worldwide<br />
Arenas.”<br />
In keeping with this theme,<br />
two special guests, one from the<br />
United States, the other from <strong>Armenia</strong>,<br />
will join the conference<br />
participants gathered in the capital<br />
of Argentina. Each will bring her<br />
particular expertise.<br />
The keynote speaker, Donna J.<br />
Evans, of Washington, acquired a<br />
unique perspective on the lives of<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n women when, from 2004<br />
to 2006, she engaged in various<br />
charitable, educational, <strong>and</strong> development<br />
projects in Yerevan as wife<br />
of the U.S. ambassador to <strong>Armenia</strong>,<br />
John M. Evans.<br />
Special guest Hranush Hakobyan,<br />
longtime elected member<br />
of <strong>Armenia</strong>’s parliament, has come<br />
into special prominence in recent<br />
weeks as the head of the newly<br />
formed Ministry of Diaspora Affairs<br />
in <strong>Armenia</strong>.<br />
The goal of AIWA’s international<br />
conferences is to provide a forum<br />
for <strong>Armenia</strong>n women from all<br />
parts of the world to come together,<br />
share experiences, <strong>and</strong> create<br />
short- <strong>and</strong> long-term strategies to<br />
improve their status.<br />
The program in Buenos Aires<br />
will include sessions on <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
women in politics, business,<br />
education, health, family life,<br />
culture, history, arts, <strong>and</strong> more.<br />
Previous conferences were held<br />
in London (1994), Paris (1997),<br />
Yerevan (2000), <strong>and</strong> Geneva<br />
(2004). Complementing the program<br />
in Buenos Aires will be a<br />
number of optional social activities<br />
designed to explore the<br />
dynamic <strong>Armenia</strong>n community<br />
in Buenos Aires <strong>and</strong> the cultural<br />
richness of this first AIWA<br />
conference site in the Western<br />
hemisphere.<br />
Donna J. Evans<br />
As president of the World Affairs<br />
Council of Washington,<br />
Ms. Evans managed a membership<br />
organization of over 2,000<br />
local business leaders, foreign<br />
diplomats, young professionals,<br />
teachers, students, <strong>and</strong> seasoned<br />
policy professionals. She developed<br />
<strong>and</strong> implemented programs<br />
on international affairs for the<br />
general membership <strong>and</strong> educational<br />
programs for teachers<br />
<strong>and</strong> students. She has served on<br />
World Affairs Councils of America<br />
leadership delegations to Israel,<br />
Taiwan, <strong>and</strong> Germany.<br />
Ms. Evans also worked as development<br />
consultant at the Hermitage<br />
Museum in Saint Petersburg,<br />
Russia, <strong>and</strong> as regional country<br />
director for Northwest Russia of<br />
the <strong>International</strong> Executive Service<br />
Corps. She is the founding<br />
executive director of the American<br />
Chamber of Commerce in Prague,<br />
<strong>and</strong> served as associate director<br />
for external relations in Eastern<br />
Keynote speaker Donna J. Evans,<br />
community activist <strong>and</strong> wife of the<br />
former U.S. ambassador to <strong>Armenia</strong>.<br />
Europe for the Center for Strategic<br />
<strong>and</strong> <strong>International</strong> Studies, Washington.<br />
Ms. Evans is Board chair of the<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n American Cultural Association<br />
<strong>and</strong> honorary chair of<br />
the <strong>Armenia</strong>n American Wellness<br />
Center. She serves on the board<br />
of the Children of <strong>Armenia</strong> Fund.<br />
She is a member of the American<br />
<strong>News</strong> Women’s Club, the Women’s<br />
Foreign Policy Group, <strong>and</strong> the <strong>National</strong><br />
Museum of the American<br />
Indian.<br />
Hranush Hakobyan<br />
Hranush Hakobyan has held several<br />
prominent political positions<br />
in <strong>Armenia</strong>. In addition to her<br />
election to parliament as representative<br />
from the Gavar region<br />
in several recent elections, she is<br />
one of only three women to have<br />
held cabinet-level position in independent<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>; she served<br />
in 1996–98 as minister of social<br />
security.<br />
Before her current assignment<br />
to head Ministry of Diaspora Affairs,<br />
Ms. Hakobyan chaired the<br />
parliamentary St<strong>and</strong>ing Committee<br />
on Science, Education, Culture,<br />
<strong>and</strong> Youth Affairs. For several<br />
years she headed <strong>Armenia</strong>’s delegation<br />
to the international Inter-Parliamentary<br />
Union, <strong>and</strong> has<br />
attended meetings in many countries<br />
in that capacity.<br />
For the past several years Ms.<br />
Hakobyan has been president of<br />
aiwa’s <strong>Armenia</strong> affiliate, <strong>and</strong> she<br />
served as the <strong>Armenia</strong> chair of<br />
aiwa’s <strong>International</strong> Conference<br />
held in Yerevan in 2000. She is<br />
also co-president of the American<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n Wellness Center.<br />
Trained as a mathematician,<br />
Ms. Hakobyan also holds<br />
a doctorate in law, teaches at<br />
Gavar State University, <strong>and</strong> is<br />
the author of two monographs<br />
Diocese prepares for January<br />
pilgrimage to Jerusalem<br />
<strong>and</strong> several articles. She rose to<br />
prominence in the Soviet era as<br />
the head of Komsomol, the Communist<br />
Youth Union.<br />
Final preparations<br />
The aiwa East Coast Committee,<br />
chaired by Eva Medzorian,<br />
<strong>and</strong> the West Coast Committee,<br />
chaired by Lily Ring Balian,<br />
working in conjunction with the<br />
local Buenos Aires committee<br />
headed by Madlen Tcherian,<br />
are currently engaged in the final<br />
planning for the conference. Enthusiasm<br />
<strong>and</strong> interest to attend<br />
the conference in Buenos Aires is<br />
very high, <strong>and</strong> the response has<br />
been encouraging.<br />
aiwa was established in 1990<br />
as an independent, nonprofit,<br />
nonsectarian organization designed<br />
to advance the visibility<br />
of <strong>Armenia</strong>n women. Open to all<br />
who share its goals, aiwa has supported<br />
health, educational, <strong>and</strong><br />
social programs in <strong>Armenia</strong>, held<br />
numerous lectures, workshops,<br />
<strong>and</strong> programs dealing with issues<br />
of interest to <strong>Armenia</strong>n women,<br />
instituted a scholarship program,<br />
published several books, <strong>and</strong> established<br />
an <strong>Armenia</strong>n women’s<br />
network.<br />
Further information regarding<br />
the international conference<br />
or other activities is available by<br />
contacting aiwa at 65 Main Street,<br />
#3a, Watertown, MA 02472; email:<br />
aiwainc@aol.com; web: www.Aiwanet.org;<br />
telephone: 617-926-0171 or<br />
562-943-1081. <br />
Stephanie’s Art Gallery to feature<br />
koko’s Allegory + Motif<br />
LA CAÑADA FLINTRIDGE, Calif.<br />
– koko, a Los Angeles–based<br />
contemporary artist, will be exhibiting<br />
at Stephanie’s Art Gallery here<br />
from October 3 through 18. An architect<br />
with a master’s in advanced<br />
architectural design from Columbia<br />
University, he works in Frank Gehry’s<br />
architectural firm. His artwork<br />
– primarily oil on canvas, but also<br />
drawing, film, <strong>and</strong> physical/digital<br />
constructs – is profoundly influenced<br />
by his experience as an architect.<br />
He paints in his private studio,<br />
where, according to the gallery, he<br />
Nassaus Hudson<br />
oil on canvas<br />
24x24 inch.<br />
explores “the dialogue between art<br />
<strong>and</strong> architecture.”<br />
According to the gallery, his<br />
paintings are “driven from the aesthetics<br />
of abstraction <strong>and</strong> expressionism.”<br />
In the collection “Allegory <strong>and</strong> Motif<br />
,” koko explores thematic observations<br />
<strong>and</strong> developments of the city<br />
through the relationship of the human<br />
figure to physical constructs. <br />
connect:<br />
www.stephaniesartgallery.com<br />
1-818-790-4905<br />
NEW YORK – A group of 26<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n faithful from the New<br />
York metro area traveled on a pilgrimage<br />
to the Holy L<strong>and</strong> from<br />
August 21 to 31, during the Feast<br />
of the Assumption of the Mother<br />
of God. Under the guidance of Rev.<br />
Fr. Mardiros Chevian, dean of<br />
Saint Vartan <strong>Armenia</strong>n Cathedral,<br />
participants visited ancient sites,<br />
including the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Quarter<br />
in Jerusalem, Bethlehem, <strong>and</strong> the<br />
Sea of Galilee. The pilgrims also<br />
had the opportunity to meet twice<br />
with Archbishop Torkom Manoogian,<br />
the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Patriarch<br />
of Jerusalem.<br />
During the visit, Fr. Chevian<br />
had the opportunity to finalize<br />
plans for the upcoming <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
Christmas Pilgrimage to the Holy<br />
L<strong>and</strong>, organized by the Diocese of<br />
the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Church of America<br />
(Eastern), under the leadership of<br />
Archbishop Khajag Barsamian,<br />
Primate. This winter pilgrimage<br />
– scheduled for January 13 to 22,<br />
2009 – will feature audiences with<br />
the Patriarch <strong>and</strong> an invitation to<br />
a special reception in his honor.<br />
Participants will tour the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
Quarter in Jerusalem <strong>and</strong> the<br />
Patriarchate Complex.<br />
In addition, participants will<br />
receive guided tours of Jerusalem,<br />
Jericho, the Sea of Galilee, the<br />
Dead Sea, the Jordan River, Tiberias,<br />
<strong>and</strong> Qumran, <strong>and</strong> participate<br />
in onsite Bible study <strong>and</strong> religious<br />
services. On January 18, pilgrims<br />
will travel to Bethlehem to celebrate<br />
the birth of Christ with a<br />
Christmas procession <strong>and</strong> a midnight<br />
Divine Liturgy.<br />
“Having returned from an enriching<br />
experience this summer, we<br />
are looking forward to this special<br />
Christmas pilgrimage to the Holy<br />
L<strong>and</strong>,” Fr. Chevian said, “And we<br />
encourage all of our faithful to participate.”<br />
The deadline for registering for<br />
the January pilgrimage is October<br />
15. The package for this ten-day pilgrimage<br />
includes air travel, lodging,<br />
two meals daily, a group guide, bus<br />
tours, <strong>and</strong> airport transfers.<br />
For registration information,<br />
please contact Nadia Charchyan<br />
at Educational Opportunities<br />
Tours at 863-648-0383, ext. 1+287,<br />
or visit www.armenianchurch.net<br />
to download an application. <br />
College<br />
student<br />
needing cash<br />
for books<br />
Part-time<br />
sales positions<br />
available. Email<br />
jobs@reporter.<br />
com
The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | October 4, 2008 5<br />
<strong>Community</strong><br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n Church Youth Organization holds first Senior<br />
Sports Weekend in San Diego<br />
SAN DIEGO, Calif. – The <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
Church Youth organization<br />
(acyo) held its first annual Senior<br />
Sports Weekend event in San Diego.<br />
Over 200 members of the organization<br />
gathered in the beach city<br />
to embark on a three-day sporting<br />
event that featured competitions<br />
such as basketball, volleyball, tennis,<br />
<strong>and</strong> swimming. Not only did<br />
the games aim to challenge the<br />
physical prowess of participants,<br />
but the event stood as a testament<br />
that the <strong>Armenia</strong>n church is re-focusing<br />
its energies on playing a central<br />
role in the cultural <strong>and</strong> spiritual<br />
life of the <strong>Armenia</strong>n youth.<br />
“This event creates a revival<br />
in the heart of youths <strong>and</strong> it is<br />
a call to renew their devotion to<br />
the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Apostolic Church,”<br />
Archbishop Hovnan Derderian<br />
said. “The success of the event is<br />
the latest triumph in the restructuring<br />
of the acyo in its goal to<br />
create distinct venues for the Junior<br />
<strong>and</strong> Senior acyo divisions,<br />
so that they may grow independently<br />
through age-appropriate<br />
programming.”<br />
anc-wr 2008 Annual Banquet sold out<br />
acyo Sports Weekend events<br />
began in 1965, first taking place<br />
in Los Angeles <strong>and</strong> later in Fresno.<br />
This year the acyo Central Council<br />
launched a second sports weekend<br />
(September 19-21) that would exclusively<br />
cater to the 18-<strong>and</strong>-over<br />
members of the organization. “The<br />
acyo-Western Diocese has all the<br />
aspects of a strong organization,”<br />
said Central Council Chairwoman<br />
Sossi Iocovides. “It provides the<br />
youth <strong>and</strong> young adults of today<br />
with a spiritual foundation, a dedication<br />
to service, <strong>and</strong> fellowship<br />
among their peers.”<br />
As the organization continues<br />
to evolve, its 18-<strong>and</strong>-over membership<br />
will be led by the Central Council<br />
while juniors (ages 12 to 17) will<br />
be led by local parish priests <strong>and</strong><br />
youth directors. “We hope that this<br />
transition will allow us to tailor the<br />
spiritual <strong>and</strong> fellowship programs<br />
for each age group accordingly,” Iocovides<br />
said.<br />
Mary-Ann Yaghdjian-Yaldezian,<br />
27, has not participated in<br />
a Sports Weekend tournament in<br />
over nine years. This year she came<br />
LOS ANGELES – The <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
<strong>National</strong> Committee-Western Region<br />
(anc-wr) has announced that<br />
the organization’s annual banquet,<br />
to be held on October 12 at the Ronald<br />
Reagan Presidential Library in<br />
Simi Valley, California, is sold out.<br />
“We are very excited for what again<br />
is a sold out banquet,” said anc-wr<br />
Banquet Chairwoman Aida Dimejian.<br />
“The anc-wr Annual Banquet<br />
allows all of our community leaders<br />
<strong>and</strong> activists to come together with<br />
government officials <strong>and</strong> policymakers<br />
to reflect on a year of tremendous<br />
accomplishments.”<br />
Honorary chairs of the event<br />
include U.S. Congress members<br />
Adam Schiff, George Radanovich,<br />
Ed Royce, Jackie Speier,<br />
<strong>and</strong> several others. Those being<br />
honored include vice-presidential<br />
nominee Senator Joseph Biden,<br />
Los Angeles Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa,<br />
the late President Ronald<br />
Reagan, <strong>and</strong> Mrs. Ashkhen<br />
Pilavjian.<br />
Senator Biden, set to receive the<br />
anc-wr’s Freedom Award, has provided<br />
friendship <strong>and</strong> support to<br />
the <strong>Armenia</strong>n-American community<br />
dating back to his first days<br />
in public office, the anc-wr said.<br />
As chairman of the U.S. Senate Foreign<br />
Relations Committee, Biden<br />
has cosponsored numerous <strong>Armenia</strong>n-Genocide<br />
resolutions <strong>and</strong><br />
most recently presided over the<br />
confirmation hearing of Ambassador<br />
Marie L. Yovanovitch.<br />
The anc-wr 2008 Man of the<br />
year is Antonio Villaraigosa. As<br />
mayor of Los Angeles, he has repeatedly<br />
demonstrated his steadfast<br />
support for the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
community, the anc-wr said. In<br />
2007, at the urging <strong>and</strong> support of<br />
the mayor, the Los Angeles City<br />
back to play volleyball on a newly<br />
formed alumni team.<br />
“Having a Senior Sports Weekend<br />
for the older members creates a forum<br />
where those who were heavily<br />
involved in their teens can still feel<br />
a part of the organization,” Yaghdjian-Yaldezian<br />
said. “Even if you are<br />
married or a working professional,<br />
the acyo is very much relevant to<br />
the older age group.”<br />
Yaghdjian-Yaldezian, who has<br />
been an acyo member for 15<br />
years, speaks fondly about how<br />
the organization has enriched<br />
her spiritually <strong>and</strong> given her a<br />
sense of connectedness to her<br />
church. “[The acyo] is a place<br />
where not only I met my husb<strong>and</strong>,<br />
but formed deep friendships with<br />
other <strong>Armenia</strong>ns from all over<br />
the Western United States,” she<br />
said. “It was a place where I could<br />
learn about my faith <strong>and</strong> share<br />
the common experience of growing<br />
up bicultural.”<br />
At the San Diego high school<br />
which Yaghdjian-Yaldezian attended,<br />
there were no other <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
students. She explained that<br />
Council passed a resolution calling<br />
on the House of Representatives to<br />
pass House Resolution 106.<br />
Following his election to the<br />
presidency in 1980, Ronald Reagan<br />
became the last U.S. president to<br />
acknowledge the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide<br />
as “genocide.” President Reagan<br />
will be honored with the Woodrow<br />
Wilson Award of the anc-wr.<br />
Mrs. Ashkhen Pilavjian, a longtime<br />
supporter of the anc-wr, will<br />
be honored with this year’s Legacy<br />
Award. The anc-wr said that over<br />
the years Pilavjian has supported<br />
several <strong>Armenia</strong>n organizations including<br />
the Western Prelacy, <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
Cultural Foundation, <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
<strong>National</strong> Committee, Homenetmen,<br />
<strong>and</strong> <strong>Armenia</strong>n Relief Society as well<br />
as many <strong>Armenia</strong>n Schools. <br />
connect:<br />
(818) 500-1918<br />
the acyo was a “comfortable place”<br />
where she came across positive<br />
role models who helped inform her<br />
identity as an Orthodox Christian<br />
<strong>and</strong> an <strong>Armenia</strong>n.<br />
The Senior Sports Weekend,<br />
which was hosted by St. John Garabed<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n Church in San Diego,<br />
comprised an array of sports<br />
tournaments, a gala banquet on<br />
Saturday evening, Divine Liturgy<br />
on Sunday, <strong>and</strong> an awards barbecue<br />
luncheon on Sunday Afternoon.<br />
In his remarks during the gala<br />
banquet, Archbishop Derderian<br />
encouraged the youth to “become<br />
apostles of Christ <strong>and</strong> put their<br />
faith in action <strong>and</strong> have the vision<br />
of becoming wise leaders of<br />
the community.” The archbishop<br />
thanked the acyo Central Council<br />
<strong>and</strong> members of the St. John Garabed<br />
Church by gifting them with<br />
memorabilia, as tokens of appreciation.<br />
acyo Youth Director Fr. Avedis<br />
Abovian spoke about the importance<br />
of the youth functioning as<br />
a source of vitality <strong>and</strong> service. The<br />
young priest urged the attendees to<br />
“embrace their maturity within the<br />
context of the church.”<br />
Fr. Datev Tatoulian, parish<br />
priest of St. John Garabed <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
Church in San Diego, said he<br />
was pleased to see so many young<br />
members of the church come to<br />
San Diego to engage in a festive<br />
weekend. “San Diego is considered<br />
one of the most beautiful cities in<br />
the world <strong>and</strong> it became so much<br />
more beautiful to see so many<br />
acyo members <strong>and</strong> their families<br />
convene for a weekend <strong>and</strong> reconnect<br />
with each other through<br />
sports <strong>and</strong> friendship,” the enthusiastic<br />
priest commented. “I really<br />
feel that the acyo is growing in the<br />
right direction <strong>and</strong> we are making<br />
sure that we create forums, sports<br />
events, <strong>and</strong> spiritual conferences<br />
to reach out to our youth <strong>and</strong> our<br />
community as a whole. We feel it<br />
is our responsibility to engage our<br />
youths <strong>and</strong> be a spiritual anchor as<br />
they grow into adults.”<br />
Upcoming acyo events include<br />
the annual Assembly Convention,<br />
which will take place in Oakl<strong>and</strong>,<br />
California, November 28-30. <br />
Let us know what’s on your mind.<br />
Write to us at<br />
letters@reporter.am<br />
SEARCHING FOR ADAPAZAR FAMILIES<br />
I am an award-winning investigative journalist writing a book about my gr<strong>and</strong>father <strong>and</strong> his hometown<br />
of Adapazar. I am looking for any information about the families listed below. These people were friends<br />
with my gr<strong>and</strong>father. If you have any information, please call, write, or email as soon as possible. I’m also<br />
looking for all memoirs, books or other written material about the town. Please help me with this<br />
endeavor. And thank you very much for your time.<br />
Nerses Aghajanian of Adapazar<br />
Haroutiun Atanasian of Adapazar<br />
Vartan Choulerian of Bardizag.<br />
Hagop Chavoushian of Adapazar<br />
Vartan Chullerian from Bardizag<br />
Bedros Dimijian of Adapazar<br />
Antranig Giumiushian of Adapazar<br />
Hagop Hadimosian of Adapazar<br />
Asadour Istefanian of Adapazar<br />
Dikran <strong>and</strong> Garabed Kabadayan of Adapazar<br />
Mardiros Kesoghluyan of Adapazar<br />
Murat Kesoghluian of Adapazar<br />
Vahan Koyumjian of Adapazar<br />
Dikran Maghakian of Adapazar<br />
Antranig Maghakian of Adapazar<br />
Antranig Merjanian of Adapazar<br />
Khoren Mkhjian of Adapazar<br />
Boghos Potigian. of Adapazar<br />
Mihran Portukalian of Adapazar<br />
Yeghisapet Sarian <strong>and</strong> daughter Nvart of<br />
Izmit<br />
Aram <strong>and</strong> Ardashes Shalvarjian of Tarsus<br />
The Tarikian family of Adapazar<br />
Antranig Unanian of Adapazar<br />
Please send any leads to the address or e-mail below:<br />
Adapazar Book<br />
P.O. Box 26691<br />
Los Angeles, CA 90026<br />
Phone: 323-660-0483<br />
E-mail: adapazarbook@yahoo.com
6 The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | October 4, 2008<br />
<strong>Community</strong><br />
THIS ARMENIAN LIFE<br />
Camliyayla<br />
by Tamar<br />
Kevonian<br />
We awake in Camliyayla in the early<br />
morning. The hotel is at the base<br />
of the mountain below Lampron<br />
Castle. We have a long day of climbing<br />
ahead of us. Today we plan to<br />
see four fortresses – scattered<br />
throughout the region which used<br />
to be the central hub of the kingdom<br />
of <strong>Armenia</strong>n Cilicia between<br />
the 12th <strong>and</strong> 14th centuries.<br />
We begin to climb the trail behind<br />
the hotel. Very quickly we<br />
reach a vista above which loom a<br />
turret <strong>and</strong> part of the outer wall<br />
of the castle. We continue up the<br />
rocky mountain, occasionally using<br />
hidden stone stairs carved into the<br />
rock. The path disappears behind<br />
us as soon as we clear the last step.<br />
Once at the top, I look around<br />
<strong>and</strong> wonder where the fortress is.<br />
The view of the castle from the base<br />
was much more interesting than<br />
what I see before me now. Osman,<br />
a colleague traveling with me <strong>and</strong><br />
my father Nazareth, <strong>and</strong> I look at<br />
each other <strong>and</strong> shrug. “This is it”<br />
we wonder. At the edge of the crest<br />
is the stone structure we noticed<br />
from below. A hundred feet of the<br />
outer wall <strong>and</strong> two chambers are<br />
what remain of the formidable<br />
fortress. As I enter the cavernous<br />
interior to explore further, I find<br />
the walls covered in graffiti <strong>and</strong> the<br />
corners littered with plastic bottles<br />
<strong>and</strong> cola cans.<br />
On the opposite hill is Sinap. It<br />
looks so small from here. We climb<br />
back down <strong>and</strong> head over to the<br />
other side. It’s not a paved road <strong>and</strong><br />
several times a loud “clunk” sound<br />
emanates from underneath the<br />
car as we drive over a large rock.<br />
Sinap is also disappointing. All that<br />
remains is one garrison with a recently<br />
caved-in second floor.<br />
Now we’re heading further inl<strong>and</strong>,<br />
into the heart of Cilicia. The<br />
l<strong>and</strong> is flat, with a few scattered<br />
rocky mountains on which our ancestors<br />
built their fortresses <strong>and</strong><br />
castles.<br />
We reach Yilan Kalesi (which<br />
means Snake Castle). The legend<br />
is that the castle was overrun by<br />
snakes <strong>and</strong> ultimately ab<strong>and</strong>oned.<br />
In reality, the name is a derivative<br />
of Levon, the name of the king who<br />
ruled this area at the time of its<br />
construction. The castle’s entrance<br />
is on a steep embankment, with<br />
several more entrances on different<br />
levels.<br />
It’s noon <strong>and</strong> the sun is high in<br />
the sky. It’s hot. Up till now Osman<br />
<strong>and</strong> Dad have taken turns<br />
to accompany me on my climbs<br />
to castles <strong>and</strong> fortresses. At Yilan<br />
they both opt to sit in the shade of<br />
a café <strong>and</strong> wait for me to come back<br />
down. I start up the stone-paved<br />
path, which abruptly ends after<br />
200 feet. I walk the rest of the way<br />
across a rock-strewn dirt trail, <strong>and</strong><br />
then I begin to scramble over the<br />
big boulders that block the way to<br />
the entrance. Making it to the first<br />
portal wipes me out. I sit on the<br />
only shady bit of rock I can find <strong>and</strong><br />
rest a few minutes before I head<br />
back down. The view is incredible.<br />
Back in the air-conditioned car,<br />
we head to Kozan (Sis), the heart of<br />
Cilicia <strong>and</strong> the seat of the Cilician<br />
Catholicosate until the 1930s, when<br />
it moved to its present location in<br />
Antelias, Lebanon.<br />
Once a thriving religious <strong>and</strong><br />
cultural center, Kozan today has<br />
no <strong>Armenia</strong>n residents. The town’s<br />
fortress, like others in the region,<br />
sits at the crest of a mountain. We<br />
drive the steep incline through the<br />
town, where there still are vestiges<br />
of <strong>Armenia</strong>n architecture, including<br />
a scattering of distinctive <strong>Armenia</strong>ns<br />
houses. We wind up the<br />
hill until we reach the end of the<br />
residential area before the final ascent<br />
to the fortress.<br />
A flat piece of l<strong>and</strong> stretches out<br />
to our left. We park the car <strong>and</strong><br />
walk across the expanse. There is<br />
nothing left of the Catholicosate<br />
except for two partial walls of the<br />
original building – the stones were<br />
used long ago to build a hospital<br />
in the valley below. Further up the<br />
road we park the car <strong>and</strong> climb once<br />
again to the fortress. The main entrance<br />
has a Mamluk inscription<br />
dating to the time when the fortress.<br />
As for the older <strong>Armenia</strong>n inscription,<br />
it was removed (stolen)<br />
some 20 years ago.<br />
On our way to Kozan we’d noticed<br />
a sign that read “Anavarza, 5<br />
km,” pointing to our right. We now<br />
backtrack to that sign. Anavarza,<br />
another <strong>Armenia</strong>n fortress not<br />
mentioned in either our <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
or English guidebook, was not on<br />
our original itinerary. It’s the only<br />
one of the fortresses that Dad had<br />
not previously visited <strong>and</strong> he was<br />
curious to see it. I was exhausted<br />
after climbing four mountains in<br />
one day <strong>and</strong> was desperately hoping<br />
for a warm meal, a cool drink,<br />
<strong>and</strong> a hot shower.<br />
The narrow, badly paved road is<br />
marked by a simple sign that we almost<br />
overlook. Osman stops next<br />
to a man on an esheg (donkey) to<br />
ask for directions. The man points<br />
behind to the large rock outcropping<br />
on the horizon. As we approach<br />
it, we come to an archway,<br />
what remains of the Roman aqueduct,<br />
<strong>and</strong> the Greco-Roman ruins<br />
across the flat expanse. Beyond it<br />
is a very large mountain with what<br />
looks like a vast structure spanning<br />
its three crests.<br />
All of a sudden a man materializes.<br />
Tall, thin, with crystal blue<br />
eyes, Yashar is the director of the<br />
museum. He has seen us drive up<br />
<strong>and</strong> has come to tell us about the<br />
area. He leads us to the museum,<br />
which, in reality, is his house. Many<br />
years ago, while tilling his yard, he<br />
discovered two intact mosaics of<br />
what used to be the floors of a Roman<br />
bath. He hauled a few carved<br />
stones from the site, h<strong>and</strong>-wrote<br />
“Muze” on his wall, <strong>and</strong> he was in<br />
business. He is the “official” guide<br />
in these parts.<br />
There is about an hour before the<br />
sun is to set <strong>and</strong> we head towards<br />
the base of the mountain to begin<br />
our fifth climb of the day. Both Osman<br />
<strong>and</strong> Dad plan to join me this<br />
time. The mountain is steep <strong>and</strong><br />
the crest too high up. It seems like<br />
an impossible task but we start the<br />
trek, scaling rocks interspersed<br />
with 330 stone steps still intact<br />
along the path. I’m grateful for<br />
them as they make the effort a bit<br />
easier to bear. While the three of<br />
us struggle with each step, Yashar<br />
gambols over them like a mountain<br />
goat. Finally I reach the top, just as<br />
the sun hides behind the horizon.<br />
Osman is a few meters behind me<br />
<strong>and</strong> Dad is further down the mountain.<br />
His ascent is going slowly because<br />
of his excruciating back pain,<br />
but he doesn’t want to hold us back.<br />
I make my way towards the small<br />
church in the first courtyard inside<br />
the walls. The fortress is over half<br />
a mile long <strong>and</strong> it’s impossible to<br />
explore it all. The roof of the church<br />
has caved in, but the distinctive <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
carvings around the perimeter<br />
are mostly intact. Years ago,<br />
the late Archbishop Mesrob Ashjian<br />
conducted a wedding here for<br />
a couple who had met in <strong>Armenia</strong><br />
during a L<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> Culture Organi-<br />
Citizen activism stressed at anc<br />
Pasadena town hall meeting<br />
PASADENA, Calif. – Recently<br />
the Pasadena chapter of the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
<strong>National</strong> Committee hosted a<br />
town hall meeting featuring guest<br />
speaker Ardashes Kassakhian.<br />
As Glendale city clerk, Kassakhian<br />
spoke of the importance of<br />
citizen participation in the democratic<br />
process. He said all citizens,<br />
including <strong>Armenia</strong>n-Americans,<br />
have a responsibility to be involved<br />
in local government affairs. The<br />
gathering, held on September 17 at<br />
the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Center in Pasadena,<br />
drew a mix of young <strong>and</strong> old community<br />
members, some longtime<br />
activists, <strong>and</strong> others new to the<br />
community.<br />
“Our town hall meeting this<br />
zation summer campaign. Then the<br />
church was still in good shape <strong>and</strong><br />
I could imagine the three of them<br />
st<strong>and</strong>ing at the altar in this majestic<br />
location. In the growing twilight<br />
Yashar, Osman <strong>and</strong> I emerge from<br />
the entrance. Dad is 50 meters<br />
below us. There isn’t enough time<br />
to wait for him to make it to the<br />
top <strong>and</strong> over to the church. We’re<br />
hurrying down while we still have<br />
some light to see our way. We reach<br />
the car just as the night engulfs the<br />
trail.<br />
Yashar has invited us to dinner<br />
with his family. His gr<strong>and</strong>father<br />
was a Cappadocian enlisted in<br />
the Janissaries (the Ottoman infantry<br />
which conscripted the orphaned<br />
sons of families that were<br />
massacred by the Turks). Yashar<br />
has never left the area except for<br />
the time he served in the military,<br />
where he came into contact with<br />
U.S. personnel <strong>and</strong> taught himself<br />
English. He has a thirst for<br />
knowledge, history in particular,<br />
<strong>and</strong> grills us for stories about the<br />
evening was all about serving the<br />
community,” remarked Pasadena<br />
anc leader Dikran Tabakian. “We<br />
plan to hold more town hall meetings.<br />
Today we touched on the importance<br />
of grassroots action <strong>and</strong><br />
the need to be involved locally with<br />
our city council <strong>and</strong> other local officials.”<br />
“Our upcoming town hall meetings<br />
will touch on other interesting<br />
topics designed to engage our<br />
community members <strong>and</strong> get<br />
them involved,” Tabakian continued.<br />
“The idea is simple: we need<br />
to educate our community, motivate<br />
[people], <strong>and</strong>, finally, we need<br />
to [encourage] them to support<br />
worthwhile activities.”<br />
people who built the mountaintop<br />
castle.<br />
I wonder how these formidable<br />
structures, so hard to reach, could<br />
ever fall in the h<strong>and</strong>s of enemies.<br />
This is a question I ponder as I recover<br />
from a day of climbing increasingly<br />
difficult mountains <strong>and</strong><br />
scaling the walls of more fortified<br />
walls. I have no answer.<br />
Before embarking on this trek,<br />
several friends advised me to take<br />
lots of pictures during my travels,<br />
but Roger had a specific dem<strong>and</strong>.<br />
“When you get to a place where<br />
st<strong>and</strong>ing there you feel the energy<br />
of those that went before us, then<br />
take a picture for me,” he requested.<br />
I remembered his words when<br />
I first stopped the car at the ancient<br />
western border of Cilicia <strong>and</strong><br />
looked across the rolling mountains<br />
<strong>and</strong> the blue Mediterranean waters.<br />
I’ve thought about his request at<br />
each site since that first one. Every<br />
time I stood high on the ramparts<br />
of a castle <strong>and</strong> looked across the<br />
sea or the waters of a flowing river<br />
In his remarks, Kassakhian reflected<br />
on his own history of grassroots<br />
involvement <strong>and</strong> later work<br />
as the executive director of the<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n <strong>National</strong> Committee–<br />
Western Region office. He cited<br />
a number of examples of how an<br />
energized <strong>and</strong> motivated group<br />
of <strong>Armenia</strong>n-Americans can bring<br />
positive change to their local government.<br />
Kassakhian said that failing<br />
to be involved in local government<br />
affairs in Pasadena <strong>and</strong><br />
elsewhere is not an acceptable<br />
option. “If you want to play a<br />
positive role in the future of your<br />
city, you have to be involved,” he<br />
emphasized.<br />
<br />
Arpa <strong>International</strong> Film Festival to be held<br />
at the Egyptian Theatre, October 24–26<br />
LOS ANGELES – The 11th<br />
Annual Arpa <strong>International</strong> Film<br />
Festival, featuring a diversity of<br />
local <strong>and</strong> international films –<br />
including works from usc, ucla,<br />
Pasadena Art Center, <strong>and</strong> csun<br />
– will be held at the Egyptian<br />
Theatre in Hollywood, October<br />
24 through 26.<br />
The opening-night premiere will<br />
be J. Michael Hagopian’s final<br />
installment in his trilogy about<br />
the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide, titled The<br />
River Ran Red. Other highlights<br />
include a 90th-birthday tribute<br />
to screen legend Rita Hayworth,<br />
featuring the first work that won<br />
her international acclaim, Rouben<br />
Mamoulian’s 1941 Academy<br />
Award-winning Technicolor film<br />
Blood <strong>and</strong> S<strong>and</strong>.<br />
Arpa will screen 49 films from<br />
21 countries, including <strong>Armenia</strong>,<br />
Australia, Belize, Canada, China,<br />
Congo, the Czech Republic, Ecuador,<br />
France, Iran, Irel<strong>and</strong>, Italy,<br />
Romania, Sri Lanka, Switzerl<strong>and</strong>,<br />
Tobago, Trinidad, Turkey, the U.K.,<br />
the usa, <strong>and</strong> Venezuela. Among<br />
the films on the list of Arpa’s 2008<br />
Official Selection are Familiar Voices<br />
with Mia Farrow; the world<br />
premiere of Tadeh Daschi’s The<br />
Witch of Portobello, based on Paulo<br />
Coelho’s novel of the same name;<br />
<strong>and</strong> Strength <strong>and</strong> Honour, starring<br />
Michael Madsen <strong>and</strong> Richard<br />
Chamberlain.<br />
Each year, the festival recognizes<br />
individuals in the film industry<br />
with achievement <strong>and</strong> humanitarian<br />
awards. Arpa’s 2008 award recipients<br />
include Ted Braun, who<br />
will receive the Armin T. Wegner<br />
Award for his film Darfur Now.<br />
Actress <strong>and</strong> activist Mary Apick<br />
will receive the Arpa Foundation<br />
Award; <strong>and</strong> actor Marco Khan<br />
will be named Breakthrough Artist<br />
of the Year for his performances<br />
in 10,000 B.C., Iron Man, <strong>and</strong><br />
Dr. Michael<br />
Hagopian.<br />
Photo: Helena<br />
Gregorian.<br />
Don’t Mess with Zohan. Honorees<br />
<strong>and</strong> winners will be recognized<br />
at an awards ceremony hosted by<br />
ReelzChannel’s Jill Simonian, on<br />
October 26.<br />
The Egyptian Theatre is located<br />
at 6712 Hollywood Blvd., Hollywood,<br />
CA 90028.<br />
For schedule <strong>and</strong> tickets, call (323)<br />
663-1882 or visit affma.org. <br />
through the green valleys of our<br />
historic homel<strong>and</strong>, I thought, “Yes,<br />
this is the place.” Yet every time I<br />
came across a new vista, it made<br />
me rebut the previous one. Here at<br />
Anavarza, I again thought of Roger’s<br />
words <strong>and</strong> wondered if it was<br />
the ultimate place to feel the spirit<br />
of our ancestors. Once more I could<br />
not come to any clear conclusion,<br />
as each fortress <strong>and</strong> each view had<br />
its own special energy <strong>and</strong> place in<br />
history. And now they are lodged in<br />
my heart.<br />
<br />
Visit us at<br />
reporter.am
The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | October 4, 2008 7<br />
<strong>Community</strong><br />
Armen Stepanian: the Christopher Columbus of recycling<br />
How a Seattle man<br />
helped ignite the<br />
American recycling<br />
revolution. And why<br />
he’s unhappy with<br />
how things turned<br />
out.<br />
by Karin Saghdejian<br />
OCEAN SHORES, Wash. <br />
– Crouching on a counter in the<br />
middle of his ramshackle house,<br />
Armen Stepanian is browsing<br />
through his old files. He shows me<br />
typewriter-written questionnaires,<br />
flyers, <strong>and</strong> postage-paid cards addressed<br />
to Fremont (Seattle, Washington)<br />
households, asking them if<br />
they would subscribe to a garbagecollection<br />
program that might start<br />
in their neighborhood.<br />
It was in 1975 when Armen <strong>and</strong><br />
a group of volunteers initiated <strong>and</strong><br />
successfully implemented the first<br />
recycling program in Seattle. The<br />
initiative is now considered to be<br />
the first of its kind in the United<br />
States.<br />
But, after 33 years, Armen is not<br />
happy with what the recycling phenomenon<br />
has morphed into. He<br />
believes his original energy-saving<br />
idea has actually become an energywasting<br />
service.<br />
On Broadway<br />
With a hearty pari yegak (welcome),<br />
Armen greets me on the stairs of<br />
his house in Ocean Shores, a small<br />
coastal town three hours’ drive<br />
from Seattle. At an age when most<br />
people are retired, 77-year-old Armen,<br />
with his unflinching spirit<br />
<strong>and</strong> mighty h<strong>and</strong>s, is in the business<br />
of “recycling” his house with<br />
wooden planks he has collected<br />
from a remodeled local church. Every<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n can relate to Armen’s<br />
resolve to make things happen <strong>and</strong><br />
survive amid adversity, as he has<br />
done throughout his life.<br />
He was born in New York City<br />
to Napoleon Stepanian (born in<br />
Kharpert) <strong>and</strong> Zaro Hatchadoorian<br />
(born in Everek) – both had left<br />
their historic <strong>Armenia</strong>n towns in<br />
the early 1900s because of Ottoman<br />
persecution.<br />
Armen’s childhood was a colorful<br />
one. He grew up in lower-class<br />
Manhattan neighborhoods <strong>and</strong><br />
became a professional singer. Recycling<br />
was never in his repertoire.<br />
His childhood was spent in Hell’s<br />
Kitchen, a gritty neighborhood<br />
of Manhattan popularized in the<br />
1930s by the films of James Cagney<br />
<strong>and</strong> Humphrey Bogart. “I grew up<br />
there <strong>and</strong> my first taste of America<br />
comes from those struggling<br />
people, the streets, the kids, <strong>and</strong><br />
the white culture,” he says. “Every<br />
Friday night, in order to escape the<br />
terrible neighborhoods we lived in,<br />
my mother would take me by trolley<br />
six miles to Washington Heights to<br />
my gr<strong>and</strong>parents.” The ride made<br />
him nauseous. “She would tell me,<br />
‘Look up at the clouds <strong>and</strong> the skylight,<br />
they don’t move.’”<br />
Being an only child, Armen was<br />
groomed by the adults in his life<br />
to become a young-boy virtuoso<br />
violinist phenomenon. Conflicted<br />
between a mother who wanted<br />
him to attend Columbia University<br />
<strong>and</strong> a father who wanted him to<br />
take over his window-display business,<br />
Armen chose what he himself<br />
wanted: singing in choirs.<br />
He sang in New York’s St. Gregory<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n Church Choir, which<br />
led to a professional singing career<br />
with the Robert Shaw Chorale. He<br />
appeared in the Broadway musical<br />
Silk Stocking <strong>and</strong> summer stock musicals<br />
such as My Sister Aileen, Call<br />
me Madame, Carousel, Showboat, Annie<br />
Get Your Gun, Kiss Me Mate, <strong>and</strong><br />
Finian’s Rainbow. He even recorded<br />
an album with Harry Belafonte <strong>and</strong><br />
got a Juilliard vocal scholarship.<br />
Armen ended his music career<br />
after realizing that the prospects of<br />
staying in show business would diminish<br />
in case he got out of shape.<br />
In the mayor’s office<br />
After a short stint in San Francisco,<br />
where he started a window-display<br />
business following in his father’s<br />
footsteps, Armen moved to Seattle<br />
on the eve of 1970 to start a new<br />
life. He made his home in Fremont,<br />
the city’s bohemian district, where<br />
he first worked as a carpenter. He<br />
went on to serve as an honorary<br />
mayor, community activist, recycling<br />
manager, <strong>and</strong> ultimately a<br />
leader who helped transform Fremont<br />
from a seedy neighborhood<br />
into an organized <strong>and</strong> revitalized<br />
district.<br />
With his larger-than-life personality,<br />
Armen was able to change the<br />
face of the squalid neighborhood.<br />
In 1973, when an enterprising local<br />
newspaper publisher, seeking<br />
to increase sales of his publication,<br />
announced elections for honorary<br />
mayor of Fremont, Armen ran <strong>and</strong><br />
won. “I ran against 37 c<strong>and</strong>idates<br />
Armen Stepanian<br />
is “recycling” his<br />
house, in Ocean<br />
Shores, Wash.<br />
Left: Armen<br />
Stepanian.<br />
Photos: Karin<br />
Saghdejian.<br />
(among them a black Labrador)<br />
<strong>and</strong> won the title,” he recalls. But<br />
to everybody’s surprise, Armen<br />
showed his election was not just<br />
a publicity stunt: he subsequently<br />
founded the Fremont Food Bank<br />
to feed the hungry, the Well-baby<br />
Center for expectant mothers <strong>and</strong><br />
children, the Seniors Center, the<br />
Fremont Fair (still running after 35<br />
years), <strong>and</strong> the district’s first recycling<br />
station. With his show-business<br />
background, Armen was able<br />
to rally people around him. The<br />
press loved him. He stirred the media<br />
in favor of his causes <strong>and</strong> wrote<br />
the governor of Washington State<br />
to gain support for his energy-saving<br />
ideas.<br />
Father of recycling<br />
Armen began to promote recycling<br />
at a time when the United States<br />
was gripped with an energy crisis<br />
brought on by the opec oil embargo.<br />
As he witnessed the long lines<br />
in front of gas stations, he realized<br />
that the country’s energy future<br />
would be in peril without conservation<br />
<strong>and</strong> sustainable consumption<br />
practices. “I hit the recycling button<br />
<strong>and</strong> it worked,” he says.<br />
His idea was first met with suspicion.<br />
Nobody believed people<br />
would be willing to collect <strong>and</strong> give<br />
away recyclables for no return.<br />
As Armen <strong>and</strong> other volunteers<br />
began his recycling program, only<br />
a few households participated. In<br />
time, however, their numbers grew<br />
considerably <strong>and</strong> Armen’s recycling<br />
model would eventually be emulated<br />
<strong>and</strong> exp<strong>and</strong>ed by other cities.<br />
Neil Seldman, president of the<br />
Institute For Local Self-Reliance, a<br />
nonprofit organization that promotes<br />
sustainable use of resources,<br />
believes Armen was a key player in<br />
the recycling <strong>and</strong> anti-incineration<br />
movement of the 70s.<br />
“He established communitybased<br />
recycling in Seattle, [a program<br />
that] was a forerunner to the<br />
current citywide systems,” he says.<br />
Armen started off with a survey<br />
of 150 households in Fremont, asking<br />
them if they would be willing to<br />
participate in a recycling program.<br />
He was pleased that 67 said yes.<br />
“On the first day of recycling, [May<br />
6, 1975], 32 of the 67 did participate,”<br />
he recalls. “We did it every month<br />
<strong>and</strong> the 32 grew to 1,500.” The service<br />
was organized by volunteers<br />
of the Fremont Public Association<br />
<strong>and</strong> provided free of charge.<br />
Armen calculates how much energy<br />
is saved if we recycle just a portion<br />
of our daily garbage. “Recycled<br />
glass saves nine barrels of oil per<br />
ton – an average family puts out<br />
ten pounds per month,” he says.<br />
“Each group of 200 families will<br />
save nine barrels of oil per month.<br />
Aluminum cans are more dramatic.<br />
If you make an aluminum can a second<br />
time you only use 5% of the<br />
original energy, so you save 95%.”<br />
Armen boasts about the success<br />
of his recycling program, which<br />
served as a blueprint for other cities.<br />
“The recycling pick-up you have<br />
in Vancouver is a copy of this program<br />
in Seattle,” he says. “Every<br />
time you recycle, know that it’s an<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n program.”<br />
Seldman believes Armen’s role<br />
was also critical in the development<br />
of public policy. “For example,” he<br />
says, “when the city announced a pilot<br />
recycling program in several disconnected<br />
communities, he pointed<br />
out that ‘you don’t make a fire with<br />
the logs separated from each other.’<br />
He accomplished this by successfully<br />
critiquing the various plans that the<br />
city suggested. Eventually, Armen’s<br />
positions were successful.”<br />
The service was provided free<br />
of charge from 1975 until 1980,<br />
when the Reagan administration<br />
cut funding for such community<br />
projects. Armen continued the<br />
program as a private business until<br />
1988, when the city contracted big<br />
garbage-collection companies to do<br />
the work.<br />
Armen was later (1990–94) commissioned<br />
to initiate a recycling<br />
program in Indianapolis, which<br />
did not succeed, since it was a huge<br />
task for one person. “They needed<br />
a massive grassroots effort to raise<br />
awareness <strong>and</strong> implement [the program],”<br />
he says.<br />
An energy-saving idea<br />
gone wrong<br />
Today recycling is far from the original<br />
energy-saving idea Armen <strong>and</strong><br />
his volunteers designed more than<br />
33 years ago, he says. He believes<br />
a lot of what passes for recycling<br />
is not really saving us energy but<br />
rather is a huge waste of energy.<br />
He points out three major pitfalls:<br />
first, the inefficient pick-up<br />
process. He says the pick-up truck<br />
that collects trash once a week<br />
drives by even if the garbage is not<br />
placed outside, since the service is<br />
paid for based on the number of<br />
times the truck travels <strong>and</strong> not by<br />
the amount of garbage collected.<br />
“It ends up costing us at least ten<br />
times more to pick up the material<br />
than its original worth,” he explains.<br />
Second, the pricey garbage bill,<br />
which has two components: recycling<br />
<strong>and</strong> trash collection. “Garbage<br />
companies don’t tell households<br />
that they are paying for two different<br />
services, collection <strong>and</strong> recycling,<br />
lest they opt to take their<br />
garbage to the recycling centers<br />
themselves <strong>and</strong> save half of their<br />
bill,” he says.<br />
Third, the wasteful packaging<br />
industry. The “post-consumer recycled”<br />
label that cardboard boxes<br />
carry refers to the leavings that are<br />
reused after stamping out a box<br />
from a cardboard, Armen explains.<br />
“It’s salvaging, that’s pre-consumer,<br />
not recycling,” he says. “Recycling<br />
is bringing back the used material.”<br />
He wants all the packaging<br />
to be declared. “We know that 50%<br />
post-consumer boxes can be done,<br />
as a California company is doing<br />
it,” he says. “So we need the reused-material<br />
percentage to go up<br />
to 85%.” Armen also advocates the<br />
use of glass instead of plastic for<br />
the manufacture of bottles (since<br />
glass is cheaper to make <strong>and</strong> recycle),<br />
<strong>and</strong> a ban of plastic bags<br />
(as is the case in some European<br />
countries).<br />
What’s next<br />
Armen Stepanian has lived a full life.<br />
He’s hailed as a hero in American<br />
recycling circles, for both pioneering<br />
the recycling movement <strong>and</strong><br />
educating people to adopt conservation<br />
<strong>and</strong> recycling practices. “He<br />
has demonstrated that in a 15-minute<br />
conversation he would make<br />
families recyclers for life,” Seldman<br />
says. “Armen is a hero of the grassroots<br />
recycling movement.”<br />
Today Armen lives alone on a<br />
windy stretch of the Pacific coast,<br />
barely able to sustain a living <strong>and</strong><br />
undergoing his fourth divorce. Yet<br />
his imagination is teeming with<br />
fresh ideas for societal change.<br />
He contemplates the next thing<br />
in his life, which could be a campaign<br />
against a recycling regime<br />
gone wrong. “I can’t wait to open<br />
this can of worms,” he says. He<br />
even would consider moving to<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong> <strong>and</strong> raising awareness<br />
about the benefits of recycling<br />
– in a l<strong>and</strong>locked country with no<br />
space to spare. “<strong>Armenia</strong> is prone<br />
to earthquakes, <strong>and</strong> l<strong>and</strong>fills can be<br />
a double disaster,” he explains. “It<br />
would be a huge input to educate<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n people about the importance<br />
of recycling.”<br />
But for the time being it would be<br />
enough to spend an afternoon entertaining<br />
a kindred spirit. “Thank<br />
you for your visit,” he tells me. “It<br />
was a cup of water in the middle of<br />
the desert.”
8 The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | October 4, 2008<br />
<strong>Community</strong><br />
Thous<strong>and</strong>s attend Fresno’s prpoor festival<br />
by Alik Hovsepian<br />
FRESNO, Calif. – Thous<strong>and</strong>s<br />
discovered one of the Fresno <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
community’s best-kept secrets<br />
last weekend, namely the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
Cultural Foundation’s second<br />
annual Gr<strong>and</strong> <strong>Armenia</strong>n Festival,<br />
which took place on the grounds<br />
of the California <strong>Armenia</strong>n Home<br />
in Fresno.<br />
The three-day event featured<br />
a full lineup of activities <strong>and</strong> performances<br />
as well as prpoor, an<br />
800-year-old harvest celebration<br />
that <strong>Armenia</strong>ns of California’s<br />
Central Valley have observed since<br />
the 1950s. Prpoor celebrates food,<br />
music, art, <strong>and</strong> community. “It’s<br />
a combination of festivals,” said<br />
Raffy Chekerdemian, one of the<br />
organizers of the event.<br />
The heat didn’t stop the revelers,<br />
who had gathered from all over California,<br />
including San Francisco, Los<br />
Angeles, <strong>and</strong> San Diego. “We found<br />
out about prpoor last year <strong>and</strong> that it<br />
was taking place in Fresno,” said Talar<br />
Aintablian of San Mateo. “We<br />
enjoyed ourselves last year, so we<br />
made it a point to come out again<br />
this year. It was a good way for our<br />
families from San Francisco <strong>and</strong> Los<br />
Angeles to meet here in Fresno for<br />
this <strong>Armenia</strong>n tradition. I feel like<br />
Los Angeles has the Navasartian<br />
Games, San Francisco has the Food<br />
Bazaar, <strong>and</strong> this could be the good<br />
yearly tradition that people can congregate<br />
to Fresno for.”<br />
As part of the William Saroyan<br />
Centennial Celebration taking<br />
place worldwide this year, the festival<br />
kicked off on the night of September<br />
26 with a Saroyan theatrical<br />
performance by the California<br />
State University, Fresno Theatre<br />
Arts Department. The performance<br />
was followed by a dance party with<br />
the ayf <strong>Armenia</strong>n All Stars B<strong>and</strong>.<br />
At dawn on September 27, organizers<br />
were hard at work picking<br />
grapes <strong>and</strong> then crushing the fruits<br />
by stomping on them, until all that<br />
was left was the juice. The liquid was<br />
boiled to purify it <strong>and</strong> subsequently<br />
cooked until 8 that night, when the<br />
bubbling grape molasses became<br />
foamy on top – hence the prpoor. Officiating<br />
the harvest were the Very<br />
Reverend Father Barthev Gulumian,<br />
Reverend Father Vahan Gosdanian,<br />
Reverend Father Hrant Serabian,<br />
<strong>and</strong> Reverend Father Gomidas<br />
Torosian, who together blessed<br />
the four corners of the world.<br />
The prpoor was then eaten in celebration<br />
of the harvest. “I never<br />
knew what it was, it’s fantastic,”<br />
said Azad Deeb. “It’s like cotton<br />
c<strong>and</strong>y, very sweet.” Sebouh Serabian,<br />
who had traveled from Los<br />
Angeles, also enjoyed it. “It was<br />
good, it kind of tasted like fuzz,”<br />
he said. Prpoor isn’t for everyone,<br />
however. “I don’t care for the prpoor<br />
the first day,” said Pierre Pilavian.<br />
“But once it sits <strong>and</strong> it gets cooler, I<br />
like it, especially on pancakes.” After<br />
settling, prpoor turns into a rich,<br />
sweet syrup which can be eaten<br />
with bread. It can also be used to<br />
treat sore throats <strong>and</strong> coughs.<br />
Other acts performing at the<br />
festival included the San Fern<strong>and</strong>o<br />
Valley’s Hamazkayin Nairi Dance<br />
Ensemble, which captivated the<br />
audience with its performance of<br />
traditional <strong>Armenia</strong>n dances. Children’s<br />
entertainment was provided<br />
by Maggie while Tom Bozigian<br />
gave <strong>Armenia</strong>n-dance lessons. The<br />
evening concluded with a dance<br />
party by Khatchig Jingirian <strong>and</strong><br />
his b<strong>and</strong>.<br />
“I feel great today because of all<br />
these <strong>Armenia</strong>ns from all over California<br />
who came here to support<br />
Fresno <strong>and</strong> the prpoor… all these<br />
kids helping <strong>and</strong> learning about<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n culture <strong>and</strong> the tradition<br />
of prpoor,” Pilavian said. <br />
connect:<br />
gr<strong>and</strong>armenianfestival.com<br />
Above:<br />
Officiating the<br />
harvest were<br />
from left to<br />
right Reverend<br />
Father Gomidas<br />
Torosian,<br />
Reverend Father<br />
Hrant Serabian,<br />
Very Reverend<br />
Father Barthev<br />
Gulumian,<br />
Reverend Father<br />
Vahan Gosdanian<br />
Right: From Left<br />
to Right Hratch<br />
Abdulian, Hratch<br />
Hovsepian <strong>and</strong><br />
Raffi Pilavian<br />
serving up<br />
prpoor.<br />
Prelacy continues series of lectures on Christian education<br />
GLENDALE, Calif. – On September<br />
23, Rev. Fr. Muron Aznikian,<br />
co-director of the Prelacy’s<br />
Christian Education Department,<br />
presented the first lecture in a<br />
three-part series titled “Christian<br />
Education in Family, School,<br />
Social, <strong>and</strong> <strong>Community</strong> Life” at<br />
St. Mary’s Church in Glendale.<br />
The second lecture in this series<br />
(which is part of the larger, ongoing<br />
“Year of Christian Education”<br />
series) took place on October<br />
1 <strong>and</strong> the third is planned to be<br />
held on October 8.<br />
Following the opening prayer by<br />
Archbishop Moushegh Mardirossian,<br />
Prelate, <strong>and</strong> clergy members,<br />
Master of Ceremonies Mrs.<br />
Tamar Tufenkian-Seraydarian<br />
reflected on the message of H.H.<br />
Aram I, Catholicos of the Great<br />
House of Cilicia, in declaring 2008<br />
to be the “Year of Christian Education,”<br />
<strong>and</strong> emphasized her belief<br />
that the <strong>Armenia</strong>n church, school,<br />
<strong>and</strong> family are all vital to the proper<br />
development of the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
youth.<br />
Fr. Muron began his lecture by<br />
speaking of the overall mission of<br />
the church <strong>and</strong> said Christian education<br />
is at the heart of that mission.<br />
Fr. Muron went on to speak of<br />
the different stages in the development<br />
<strong>and</strong> rearing of children, <strong>and</strong><br />
of the responsibility of parents to<br />
provide the right instruction, starting<br />
at a young age.<br />
Stressing that spiritual nourishment<br />
is just as vital as physical<br />
growth <strong>and</strong> nourishment, Fr. Muron<br />
presented a number of prayers<br />
Rev. Fr. Muron Aznikian, co-director<br />
of the Prelacy’s Christian Education<br />
Department, at the lectern.<br />
Archbishop Moushegh Mardirossian,<br />
Prelate.<br />
<strong>Community</strong> members gathered at St. Mary’s Church in Glendale.<br />
which he said can be recited at different<br />
times of the day <strong>and</strong> in different<br />
circumstances to assist parents<br />
in the religious instruction of<br />
their children.<br />
The program also included an<br />
artistic portion in which highschool<br />
students from Rose <strong>and</strong><br />
Alex Pilibos School participated<br />
with songs <strong>and</strong> recitations.<br />
In his closing remarks, the Prelate<br />
spoke of the family-churchschool<br />
connection <strong>and</strong> concluded<br />
by noting the importance of the<br />
respective <strong>and</strong> collaborative contributions<br />
of clergy, parents, educators,<br />
<strong>and</strong> community leaders in the<br />
instruction of <strong>Armenia</strong>n youths.<br />
The event was followed by a reception<br />
in the hall by the Board of<br />
Trustees <strong>and</strong> Ladies’ Auxiliary. <br />
Let us know what’s on your mind.<br />
Write to us at<br />
letters@reporter.am
The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | October 4, 2008 9<br />
<strong>Community</strong><br />
Saroyan centenary continues with several events in Fresno<br />
by Sarah Soghomonian<br />
FRESNO, Calif. – A complete<br />
success – that’s what organizers<br />
of the William Saroyan Centennial<br />
Celebration are calling their<br />
year-long tribute to the Pulitzer<br />
Prize-winning author.<br />
A group of Saroyan enthusiasts<br />
from Fresno have spent three years<br />
to plan the almost 100 individual<br />
projects in honor of Fresno’s native<br />
son.<br />
“It’s been extremely rewarding,”<br />
said Larry Balakian, one of the<br />
lead organizers of the Saroyan Centennial<br />
Celebration.<br />
Saroyan lived a good portion of<br />
his life in California’s San Joaquin<br />
Valley, drawing a great deal of inspiration<br />
from its agricultural communities.<br />
“Saroyan is one of the great giants,”<br />
said Edward EmanuEl,<br />
theater director at California State<br />
University, Fresno. “His work has<br />
reached millions. Saroyan is still<br />
as valuable today as when he was<br />
writing.”<br />
Fresno State is taking part in the<br />
Centennial Celebration. EmanuEl<br />
is directing Saroyan’s play Slaughter<br />
of the Innocents.<br />
“The play is very interesting from<br />
a dramatic point of view,” Emanu-<br />
El said. “I think it’s an important<br />
piece. It’s a play that needs to be<br />
seen.”<br />
One of Saroyan’s lesser-known<br />
works, Slaughter of the Innocence<br />
is a dark, powerful piece that<br />
was written in response to the<br />
Joe McCarthy hearings of the<br />
1950s.<br />
While EmanuEl expressed his<br />
admiration for classic Saroyan<br />
plays such as Time of Your Life<br />
(which won the Pulitzer Prize in<br />
1940), The Human Comedy, <strong>and</strong><br />
Hello Out There, he said it was<br />
important to stage a play, such<br />
as Slaughter of the Innocence, that<br />
showed a different side of the author.<br />
Slaughter of the Innocence has<br />
no specific setting or time frame.<br />
For the Fresno State production,<br />
EmanuEl chose a Caribbean isl<strong>and</strong><br />
as the setting.<br />
The 33-member cast is working<br />
on overdrive preparing for the production.<br />
They’ve had only about a<br />
month of rehearsal time. The 80-<br />
minute production kicks off the<br />
Fresno State theater season.<br />
Slaughter of the Innocence opens<br />
on October 3 <strong>and</strong> runs through<br />
Slaughter of<br />
Innocents.<br />
Photos: The<br />
Collegian’s Ryan<br />
Tubongbanu.<br />
October 11, at Fresno State’s John<br />
Wright Theater.<br />
“We are extremely excited <strong>and</strong><br />
honored to be part of a celebration<br />
that honors Fresno’s greatest writer,”<br />
said EmanueEl. “Saroyan helps<br />
prove that Fresno has a lot more<br />
to offer culturally than one would<br />
think.”<br />
The centennial celebration is “really<br />
about community,” Balakian<br />
said. “It has shown the community<br />
in a very favorable light.”<br />
The Saroyan Centennial Celebration<br />
has garnered considerable media<br />
attention, through television<br />
coverage <strong>and</strong> series of articles. The<br />
Fresno Bee, for instance, ran a series<br />
of Saroyan’s writings <strong>and</strong> helped<br />
promote the different events happening<br />
around the San Joaquin<br />
Valley.<br />
The Fresno County Library has<br />
also taken an active role in the<br />
celebration, showcasing Saroyan’s<br />
work at each of its branches.<br />
Events honoring Saroyan started<br />
back in January. They peaked<br />
during August, when Saroyan<br />
would have celebrated his 100th<br />
birthday.<br />
Upcoming centennial events include<br />
a Saroyan exhibition, at the<br />
Home Arts Building, during the<br />
Fresno County Fair (October 1-12).<br />
Centenary celebrations will come<br />
to a close in November with a town<br />
hall lecture at the Saroyan Theater<br />
in Fresno.<br />
“Our years of hard work <strong>and</strong> planning<br />
paid off,” Balakian said. “It<br />
shows that when a group comes together,<br />
you can have a productive<br />
outcome.”<br />
<br />
You share the same<br />
community. Discover what<br />
happens when you share<br />
the same experience.<br />
For more information about<br />
Relay For Life or to join an<br />
event near you, visit<br />
www.cancer.org/RelayNYNJ<br />
or call 1.800.ACS.2345.<br />
Paint the Town Purple in<br />
celebration of Relay For Life on<br />
May 1, May Day For Relay.<br />
1.800.ACS.2345<br />
www.cancer.org/relayNYNJ
10 The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | October 4, 2008
The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | October 4, 2008 11<br />
<strong>National</strong><br />
Muron is blessed at Etchmiadzin in ancient ritual<br />
n Continued from page <br />
At 5 p.m., the bells of Etchmiadzin<br />
started ringing loudly.<br />
After shaking h<strong>and</strong>s with Serge<br />
Sargsian, the president of the Republic<br />
of <strong>Armenia</strong>, the Catholicos<br />
of All <strong>Armenia</strong>ns, Karekin II, took<br />
his place at the very end of a long<br />
procession. Toward the front of the<br />
procession were junior clergy, followed<br />
by more senior clergy, then<br />
bishops, then archbishops, <strong>and</strong> finally,<br />
the Catholicos <strong>and</strong> Supreme<br />
Patriarch.<br />
The clergy carried holy relics,<br />
including the right h<strong>and</strong> of Saint<br />
Gregory the Illuminator, the patron<br />
saint of the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Church<br />
<strong>and</strong> the first Catholicos.<br />
Bartholomew, the Ecumenical<br />
Patriarch, was present, as were<br />
other representatives of sister<br />
churches.<br />
Representing the Catholicos<br />
of the Great House of Cilicia was<br />
Archbishop Oshagan Choloyan,<br />
Prelate of the Eastern Prelacy.<br />
Representing the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Patriarch<br />
of Jerusalem was Archbishop<br />
Nurhan Manoogian. The <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
Patriarch of Constantinople<br />
was represented by Archbishop<br />
Shahan Svajian.<br />
The president of the Republic of<br />
Nagorno Karabagh, Bako Sahakian,<br />
as well as diplomats, ministers,<br />
<strong>and</strong> other dignitaries were<br />
also present.<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>ns from Etchmiadzin<br />
<strong>and</strong> elsewhere in <strong>Armenia</strong> joined<br />
perhaps two to three thous<strong>and</strong><br />
pilgrims from around the world<br />
to witness the ceremony. They<br />
congregated – <strong>and</strong> pushed forward<br />
– in a massive crowd waiting<br />
for the procession to come<br />
their way, so they may be blessed<br />
by the cross the Catholicos was<br />
holding.<br />
After the procession made its<br />
ways to the stage, the ceremony<br />
continued with the Lord’s Prayer.<br />
The Etchmiadzin choir sang enthusiastically,<br />
adding to the spiritual<br />
ambiance.<br />
The cauldron of pure olive oil was<br />
opened. Over 40 ingredients, many<br />
the essence of various flowers, were<br />
blessed <strong>and</strong> added, as was balsam.<br />
Senior clergymen, including Archbishop<br />
Khajag Barsamian, Primate<br />
of the Eastern Diocese, <strong>and</strong><br />
Archbishop Hovnan Derderian,<br />
Primate of the Western Diocese,<br />
made their way to the Catholicos<br />
<strong>and</strong> the cauldron <strong>and</strong> presented ingredients.<br />
As a symbol of the unity of the<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n church, Archbishop Koriun<br />
Papian added newly blessed<br />
muron from the Cilician See.<br />
And then some of the old muron<br />
was added.<br />
“In the new blessing, the old muron<br />
is poured in so the tradition<br />
going back all the way to the first<br />
Catholicos, going back to the beginning,<br />
to Saint Gregory the Illuminator<br />
is kept,” Archbishop Barsamian<br />
told the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter.<br />
He added that the muron “is the<br />
symbol of the presence of the Holy<br />
Sprit, the sign of the unity of the<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n Church, <strong>and</strong> it is the life<br />
of the church.”<br />
After the blessing, the time came<br />
for the Catholicos to speak. All was<br />
silent, <strong>and</strong> all were waiting to hear<br />
what the pontiff was going to say.<br />
The only sounds to be heard were<br />
the rain falling on umbrellas <strong>and</strong><br />
raincoats, <strong>and</strong>, the occasional mobile<br />
phone ringing.<br />
“From the heights of heaven, holiness<br />
descends once more today <strong>and</strong><br />
disperses blessing, grace, <strong>and</strong> exuberance<br />
over our homel<strong>and</strong>, within<br />
our souls, <strong>and</strong> throughout the whole<br />
of <strong>Armenia</strong>n life,” he said. “With<br />
the prayerful participation of the<br />
sons <strong>and</strong> daughters of our nation<br />
Scenes from the blessing of the Holy Muron. Above: Catholicos Karekin II with<br />
Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew. Photos: Photolure.<br />
dispersed throughout the world, we<br />
bless the Holy Muron according to<br />
the words granted from our Lord.<br />
Glory, unending praise, <strong>and</strong> thanks<br />
to our all-provident God.”<br />
He also spoke about mixing the<br />
old <strong>and</strong> new oils <strong>and</strong> the oil from<br />
the Great House of Cilicia. “We<br />
combined the previous muron,<br />
through which we transmit the oil<br />
blessed by our Lord from generation<br />
to generation; <strong>and</strong> also mixed<br />
the newly made muron of the Catholicosate<br />
of the Great House of<br />
Cilicia. We blessed it with our sacred<br />
<strong>and</strong> cherished relics – with the<br />
saving Cross of our Lord, the Holy<br />
Lance, <strong>and</strong> the Holy Right H<strong>and</strong> of<br />
our Illuminator Pontiff,” the Catholicos<br />
said.<br />
When the ceremony was all<br />
over, the Catholicos, the other<br />
clergy, <strong>and</strong> the dignitaries left the<br />
grounds; people rushed forward to<br />
touch anything they could to the<br />
now-blessed cauldron that held the<br />
blessed muron.<br />
“I was fortunate to have my scarf<br />
touched to the Holy Muron,” said<br />
Nancy Arabian, a pilgrim from<br />
Tarzana, California. “Everyone<br />
wanted their scarves to be touched<br />
by the Holy Muron; I didn’t think I<br />
was going to make it out alive. This<br />
event was something that I wanted<br />
to witness all my life. I have heard<br />
the procedure from my parents. It<br />
was a very important pilgrimage<br />
for me”<br />
Archbishop Vicken Aykazian,<br />
who is based in Washington, said<br />
he believed the laity in <strong>Armenia</strong> has<br />
a great interest in religion, perhaps<br />
because such interest had been discouraged<br />
by the Communist Party<br />
in the Soviet era. “They are getting<br />
much closer to their religion,” Archbishop<br />
Aykazian said.<br />
One of the young people in<br />
attendance was Narine Hakobyan,<br />
who lives in <strong>Armenia</strong> <strong>and</strong><br />
is in her mid-twenties. She said,<br />
“Each time a muron blessing is<br />
held, more <strong>and</strong> more people<br />
show up, of all ages. This means<br />
our faith is spreading among our<br />
people, wherever they might be<br />
living.”<br />
f
12 The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | October 4, 2008<br />
<strong>Community</strong><br />
<strong>Community</strong> in brief<br />
John Papken Damboragian's 100th<br />
Birthday.<br />
John Papken<br />
Damboragian turns 100<br />
John Papken Damboragian just celebrated<br />
his 100th birthday. A party<br />
on August 24 attended by family<br />
<strong>and</strong> friends marked the occasion.<br />
Mr. Damboragian was born in<br />
Worcester, Massachusetts, on August<br />
25, 1908. At the age of 3, he was<br />
taken to historical <strong>Armenia</strong> by his<br />
parents. He returned to the United<br />
States with his mother when he was<br />
16 years old. He father had died in<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong> during the Genocide.<br />
Mr. Damboragian’s pride in his<br />
heritage is only exceeded by his<br />
pride in his family. He <strong>and</strong> his late<br />
wife Mary were married for 54<br />
years. Together they raised four<br />
children who have blessed the family<br />
with six gr<strong>and</strong>children <strong>and</strong> six<br />
great-gr<strong>and</strong>children.<br />
After working more than 45 years<br />
in the photoengraving industry, he<br />
retired at the age of 73. Known <strong>and</strong><br />
respected today for his honesty, integrity,<br />
generosity, sense of humor,<br />
<strong>and</strong> caring nature, he still enjoys<br />
gardening, cooking, entertaining,<br />
<strong>and</strong> a daily cigar.<br />
He has been <strong>and</strong> continues to<br />
be an inspiration <strong>and</strong> positive role<br />
model to his children, gr<strong>and</strong>children,<br />
<strong>and</strong> great-gr<strong>and</strong>children. <br />
The destruction<br />
of Smyrna in 1922<br />
documented in new<br />
edition<br />
Sterndale Classics has just published<br />
a new edition of George<br />
Horton’s Blight of Asia, which was<br />
originally written with a foreword<br />
by James W. Gerard (former United<br />
States ambassador to Germany).<br />
The new edition includes a new introduction<br />
by James L. Marketos, a<br />
Greek-American attorney based in<br />
Washington.<br />
Dubbed “Gavur Izmir” (infidel<br />
Smyrna) by fanatics, Smyrna was<br />
destroyed by Turkish nationalists<br />
in September 1922. Horton was the<br />
United States consul in the city <strong>and</strong><br />
witnessed the carnage <strong>and</strong> burning<br />
first h<strong>and</strong>.<br />
According to Mr. Marketos,<br />
Horton’s account “offers a clear<br />
rationale for why the Turks would<br />
have wanted to start the fire. . .<br />
. Horton emphatically stated his<br />
belief that the fire was intended<br />
finally to exterminate Christianity<br />
in Asia Minor <strong>and</strong> to render it<br />
impossible for the Christians to<br />
return, i.e. it was an intentional<br />
act of genocide.”<br />
The book, a paperback, spans<br />
209 pages. It includes photos <strong>and</strong><br />
an index. Sterndale Classics is an<br />
imprint of the Gomidas Institute<br />
(London).<br />
<br />
connect:<br />
info@garodbooks.com<br />
Calendar of Events<br />
Hoy Lari to hold a<br />
concert for children in<br />
Hollywood<br />
HOLLYWOOD, Calif. – Hoy Lari<br />
will hold its first-ever solo concert<br />
on Sunday, October 26, at Barnsdall<br />
Gallery Theatre in Hollywood.<br />
Two performances will take place,<br />
one at noon, the other at 3:30 pm.<br />
Hoy Lari is Paola Kassabian<br />
<strong>and</strong> Janet Yetenekian. Together,<br />
they form a dynamic duo entertaining<br />
<strong>and</strong> educating kids of all<br />
ages with their fun, upbeat songs.<br />
The music is designed to encourage<br />
children to sing in <strong>Armenia</strong>n <strong>and</strong><br />
develop the <strong>Armenia</strong>n language in<br />
their formative years, while stimulating<br />
imagination, cognition, <strong>and</strong><br />
self expression.<br />
After their debut album Jamanagn<br />
eh, Hoy Lari released Getseh<br />
Pokreegner. The new album takes<br />
children on imaginary adventures<br />
with amusing songs about an elephant,<br />
monkeys, astronauts, mixing<br />
colors, <strong>and</strong> healthy foods. <br />
connect: www.hoylari.com<br />
www.itsmyseat.com<br />
1-310-600-0207<br />
Audience to laugh with<br />
Dottie Bengoian in<br />
Connecticut<br />
TRUMBULL, Conn. – “Laugh with<br />
Dottie Bengoian,” a performance<br />
by the humorist, motivational<br />
speaker, <strong>and</strong> educator, will take<br />
place on October 19, at 12:30 P.M. at<br />
the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Church of the Holy<br />
Ascension in Trumbull.<br />
Early reservations are recommended.<br />
<br />
connect:<br />
1-203-372-5770.<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>’s<br />
independence marked<br />
in New Jersey<br />
ENGLEWOOD, N.J. – Ara Papian,<br />
who served as <strong>Armenia</strong>’s ambassador<br />
to Canada from 2001 to 2006<br />
<strong>and</strong> has since resigned from <strong>Armenia</strong>’s<br />
diplomatic corps, was the<br />
keynote speaker at a New Jersey<br />
celebration of the 17th anniversary<br />
of <strong>Armenia</strong>’s independence. The<br />
event, which brought together 250<br />
people, took place at the Dwight<br />
Englewood School Auditorium in<br />
Englewood. It was organized by the<br />
ARF New Jersey “Dro” Gomideh.<br />
Pauline Dostoumian, the gomideh<br />
representative, said <strong>Armenia</strong><br />
needs to be ready to grab any opportunities<br />
presented by the complex<br />
<strong>and</strong> volatile situation in the<br />
Caucasus. She argued that <strong>Armenia</strong><br />
could potentially lay claim to territories<br />
now under Turkish rule.<br />
Mr. Papian gave a 25-minute<br />
PowerPoint presentation on the<br />
subject of <strong>Armenia</strong>n territorial<br />
claims, decisions, <strong>and</strong> treaties. He<br />
offered an argument that President<br />
Woodrow Wilson’s arbitration of<br />
Left: Arev Folk<br />
Ensemble.<br />
Below: Ara<br />
Papian meeting<br />
with ayf New<br />
Jersey Seniors.<br />
the borders between <strong>Armenia</strong> <strong>and</strong><br />
Turkey on November 22, 1920, was<br />
still in effect. Mr. Papian’s interpretation<br />
brought about a lively period<br />
of questions <strong>and</strong> remarks.<br />
The program included the performance<br />
of <strong>Armenia</strong>n songs by<br />
the Hamazkayin Arev folk ensemble<br />
of Boston. Traditional <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
instruments were played<br />
under the directorship of Martin<br />
Haroutunian. The audience appreciated<br />
Ani Zargarian’s gracious<br />
voice. Also on the program<br />
was the Yeraz dance ensemble of<br />
the Saint Sarkis Church of New<br />
York, under the leadership of<br />
Karnig Nercessian <strong>and</strong> Lena<br />
Oranjian.<br />
<br />
Northern California<br />
OCTOBER 3 & 4 - ST. VARTAN<br />
BAZAAR & FOOD FESTIVAL.<br />
Location: St. Vartan <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
Church, 650 Spruce St., Oakl<strong>and</strong>,<br />
CA. noon to midnight Admission:<br />
free. For more information<br />
contact St. Vartan <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
Church, 510-893-1671; Stvartanoakl<strong>and</strong>@aol.com.<br />
OCTOBER 4 - ISABEL BAYRAK-<br />
DARIAN, SOPRANO. Location:<br />
Herbst Theatre, 401 Van Ness<br />
Ave, San Francisco, CA. 8pm<br />
Admission: $65/$40. For more<br />
information contact San Francisco<br />
Performances, (415) 398-<br />
6449; info@performances.org.<br />
OCTOBER 12 - ALLA LEVO-<br />
NIAN IN CONCERT. Location:<br />
Saroyan Hall, 825 Brotherhood<br />
Way, San Francisco, CA. 4:00pm<br />
Admission: $35 adults $20 stude.<br />
For more information contact<br />
Hamazkayin SF Chapter <strong>and</strong><br />
HMEM SF <strong>and</strong> Walnut Creek<br />
Chapters, 650-583-5477;.<br />
OCTOBER 19 - JOURNEY<br />
TO HISTORIC ARMENIA - IN<br />
SEARCH OF OUR ANCESTRAL<br />
ROOTS. Location: St. Vartan<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n Church, 650 Spruce<br />
St., Oakl<strong>and</strong>, CA. 12 noon Admission:<br />
$12.00. For more information<br />
contact St. Vartan Cultural<br />
Committee, 510-893- 1671;<br />
lizojakian@yahoo.com.<br />
OCTOBER 25 - ST. JOHN<br />
FOOD FESTIVAL. Location:<br />
St. John <strong>Armenia</strong>n Church, 275<br />
Olympia Way, San Francisco,<br />
CA. 12:00noon-12:00midnight<br />
Admission: N/A. For more information<br />
contact St.<br />
John <strong>Armenia</strong>n Church, 415-661-<br />
1142; nsarkiss@sbcglobal.net.<br />
OCTOBER 29 - ORIENTAL<br />
CARPETS IN EARLY RENAIS-<br />
SANCE PAINTINGS: A NEW<br />
INTERPRETATION. Location:<br />
Rugs <strong>and</strong> Carpets, Inc., 931 No.<br />
Amphlett Blvd., San Mateo, CA.<br />
7:30 p.m. Admission: free. For<br />
more information contact West<br />
Coast Chapter of the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
Rugs Society <strong>and</strong> by The S, (650)<br />
343-8585; zzlorr@yahoo.com.<br />
NOVEMBER 1 - KZV ARME-<br />
NIAN SCHOOL BANQUET<br />
WITH VARTAN GREGORIAN.<br />
Location: Saroyan Hall, 825<br />
Brotherhood Way, San Francisco,<br />
CA. 6:30 PM Admission: tbd.<br />
For more information contact<br />
Ani Ayanian; anizenop@yahoo.<br />
com.<br />
NOVEMBER 8 - ARMENIAN<br />
FOOD FESTIVAL AND BOU-<br />
TIQUE NOEL. Location: Calvary<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n Congregational<br />
Church, 725 Brotherhood Way,<br />
San Francisco, CA. 12:00 -9:00<br />
pm Admission: Free. For more<br />
information contact Calvary<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n Congregational<br />
Church, 415- 586-2000; Cacc@<br />
cacc-sf.org.<br />
NOVEMBER 9 - FASHION<br />
SHOW. Location: HYATT RE-<br />
GENCY SANTA CLARA ,CA,<br />
5101 Great America Pkwy, Santa<br />
Clara, CA. 12:30 PM Admission:<br />
TBD. For more information contact<br />
St. Andrew Cultural Committee,<br />
(650)344-4707; sylvia.<br />
baghdasarian@Lmco.com.<br />
NOVEMBER 9 - FASHION<br />
SHOW. Location: HYATT RE-<br />
GECLANCY, 5101 Great America<br />
Pkwy, Santa Clara, CA. 11:30AM<br />
Admission: $60. For more information<br />
contact St. Andrew Cultural<br />
Committee, (650)344-4707;<br />
sylvia.baghdasarian@Lmco.com.<br />
NOVEMBER 21 - FROM CON-<br />
STANTINOPLE TO TBILISI: AN<br />
ARMENIAN LEGACY. Location:<br />
St. Vartan <strong>Armenia</strong>n Apostolic<br />
Church, 650 Spruce Street, Oakl<strong>and</strong>,<br />
CA. 7:30pm Admission:<br />
$35 / $28 / $15. For more information<br />
contact Bay Area Classical<br />
Harmonies, (510) 868-0695;<br />
Info@BayAreaBACH.org.<br />
NOVEMBER 22 - FROM CON-<br />
STANTINOPLE TO TBILISI: AN<br />
ARMENIAN LEGACY. Location:<br />
St. John <strong>Armenia</strong>n Apostolic<br />
Church, 275 Olympia Blvd, San<br />
Francisco, CA. 7:30pm Admission:<br />
$35 / $28 / $15. For more<br />
information contact Bay Area<br />
Classical Harmonies, (510) 868-<br />
0695; Info@BayAreaBACH.org.<br />
NOVEMBER 23 - FROM CON-<br />
STANTINOPLE TO TBILISI: AN<br />
ARMENIAN LEGACY. Location:<br />
St. Andrew <strong>Armenia</strong>n Apostolic<br />
Church, 11370 S. Stelling Road,<br />
Cupertino, CA. 5:00pm Admission:<br />
$35 / $28 / $15. For more<br />
information contact Bay Area<br />
Classical Harmonies, (510) 868-<br />
0695; Info@BayAreaBACH.org.<br />
JANUARY 18 - CAL PERFOR-<br />
MANCES: SERGEY KHACHA-<br />
TRYAN VIOLIN WITH LUSINE<br />
KHACHATRYAN, PIANO. Location:<br />
Hertz Hall, University of<br />
California, Berkeley, CA. 3p.m.<br />
Admission: $46. For more information<br />
contact Cal Performances,<br />
510.642.9988; tickets@<br />
calperfs.berkeley.edu.<br />
MARCH 15 - CRD BENEFIT<br />
CONCERT. Location: California<br />
Palace of the Legion of Honor,<br />
100 34th Ave, San Francisco, CA.<br />
2:00 pm Admission: TBD. For<br />
more information contact Support<br />
Committee for <strong>Armenia</strong>’s<br />
Cosmic Ray Division, (650) 926-<br />
4444; anahid1@sonic.net.<br />
Central California<br />
OCTOBER 5 - AGBU-LUN-<br />
CHEON. Location: St. Pauls<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n Church, S.W. Corner<br />
of 1st <strong>and</strong> Dakota, Fresno,<br />
CA. 1:00 pm Admission: $12.00.<br />
For more information contact<br />
AGBU-Fresno Chapter, 559-970-<br />
9354; dancing_zar@yahoo.com.<br />
OCTOBER 7 - LEARN CON-<br />
VERSATIONAL WESTERN<br />
ARMENIAN. Location: Charlie<br />
Keyan <strong>Armenia</strong>n <strong>Community</strong><br />
School, 108 N. Villa, Fresno, CA.<br />
6:30 pm Admission: $30.00. For<br />
more information contact Fresno<br />
AGBU, 559-431-3054; dancing_zar@yahoo.com.<br />
Southern California<br />
OCTOBER 3 - KOKO EXHIBI-<br />
TION. Location: STEPHANIE’S<br />
ART GALLERY, 466 Foothill<br />
Blvd., La Canada, CA. 6:30 PM<br />
to 10 PM Admission: free. For<br />
more information contact<br />
STEPHANIE’S ART GALLERY,<br />
818 790-4905; stephaniesart@<br />
att.net.<br />
OCTOBER 4 - AGBU MD-<br />
SCHOOL HOLD ‘EM HYE<br />
LLL POKER TOURNAMENT<br />
FUNDRAISER. Location: AGBU<br />
MDSchool HOLD ‘EM HYE lll<br />
Poker Tournament Fundraiser,<br />
6844 Oakdale Ave., Canoga Park,<br />
CA. 7:30 PM Admission: $200.00<br />
Buy In. For more information<br />
contact AGBU MDS Alumni Association,<br />
; info@mdsalumni.<br />
com.<br />
OCTOBER 4 - DR. HAKOB SA-<br />
NASARYAN TO LECTURE ON<br />
ARMENIA ENVIRONMENTAL<br />
ISSUES. Location: Glendale Public<br />
Library, 222 E. Harvard Street,<br />
Glendale, CA. October 4th &5th<br />
Admission: Free. For more information<br />
contact Glendale Public<br />
Library, (818) 548-3288; EGrigorian@ci.glendale.ca.us.<br />
OCTOBER 4 - BIKFAYA, LEB-<br />
ANON - A LIFE-CHANGING<br />
EXPERIENCE. Location: Western<br />
Prelacy, 6252 Honolulu Avenue,<br />
La Crescenta, CA. 4:00pm<br />
- 6:00pm Admission: FREE. For<br />
more information contact <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
Church Youth Association,<br />
818-859-9081; acyaglendale@yahoo.com.<br />
OCTOBER 5 - ISABEL BAYRAK-<br />
DARIAN WITH THE ARME-<br />
NIAN CHAMBER PLAYERS.<br />
Location: Renée & Henry Seger-
The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | October 4, 2008 13<br />
<strong>Community</strong><br />
Calendar of Events<br />
strom Concert Hall, 615 Town<br />
Center Drive, Costa Mesa, CA.<br />
7:00 pm. Admission: $30-$195.<br />
For more information contact<br />
Philharmonic Society of Orange<br />
County, 949-553-2422; marie@<br />
philharmonicsociety.org<br />
OCTOBER 5, 2008 - ST. PE-<br />
TER ARMENIAN APOSTOLIC<br />
CHURCH FAMILY PICNIC. Location:<br />
St. Peter <strong>Armenia</strong>n Apostolic<br />
Church of Van Nuys. Location:<br />
17231 Sherman Way, Van<br />
Nuys, CA, 12:00 p.m. to 7:00 p.m.<br />
Admission is free. For more information<br />
contact the<br />
OCTOBER 5 - ARMENIAN MU-<br />
SICAL LECTURE & MINI-CON-<br />
CERT. Location: Ararat- Eskijian<br />
Muesum, 15105 Mission Hills<br />
Rd, Mission Hills, CA. 2:30 P.M.<br />
Admission: Free Admission. For<br />
more information contact Ms.<br />
Maggie Mangarsarian-Goschin,<br />
(818) 838-4862;<br />
OCTOBER 5 - EMILY’S STEM<br />
CELL SURGERY FUNDRAISER.<br />
Location: Palladio Hall, 1018 E.<br />
Colorado St, Glendale, CA. 7 pm<br />
Admission: 150.00 or any. For<br />
more information contact Stage<br />
1 Productions, 818-482-0358;<br />
djraymx@yahoo.com. Tickets on<br />
www.itsmyseat.com.mgoschin@<br />
mindspring.com.church office<br />
at (818)344-4860.<br />
OCTOBER 9 - ARMENIAN<br />
AMERICAN WOMEN IN BUSI-<br />
NESS EXCELLENCE AWARDS<br />
LUNCHEON. Location: Hilton<br />
Hotel, 100 West Glenoaks Blvd.,<br />
Glendale, CA. 11 am Admission:<br />
50.00. For more information<br />
contact AACC GLAC, 818-247-<br />
0196; aacc@armenianchamber.<br />
com. Tickets on www.itsmyseat.<br />
com.<br />
OCTOBER 9 - DEAD SERIOUS<br />
- OCT 9 - NOV 9. Location: Luna<br />
Playhouse, 3706 San Fern<strong>and</strong>o<br />
Rd, Glendale, CA. Various; 8 pm<br />
Admission: $20. For more information<br />
contact Luna Playhouse,<br />
818.500.7200; kathypearson13@<br />
hotmail.com. Tickets on www.<br />
itsmyseat.com.<br />
OCTOBER 9 - JAZZ PIANO<br />
STYLINGS OF VARDAN OVES-<br />
PIAN. Location: Pasadena Jazz<br />
Institute, 260 East Colorado<br />
Blvd Suite 206, Pasadena, CA.<br />
8:30 pm Admission: $20.00. For<br />
more information contact Paul<br />
Lines, 626-398-3344; paul@pasjazz.org.<br />
Tickets on www.itsmyseat.com.<br />
OCTOBER 10 - ALLA LEVO-<br />
NIAN CONCERT. Location:<br />
Glendale Presbyterian Church,<br />
125 S Louise St, Glendale, CA.<br />
8:00 Admission: $40. For more<br />
information contact ARS Glendale<br />
Sepan Chapter, 818-246-<br />
5549; emmasalmassian@yahoo.<br />
com. Tickets on www.itsmyseat.com.<br />
OCTOBER 12 - ANCWR ANNU-<br />
AL BANQUET. Location: Ronald<br />
Reagan Presidential Library, 40<br />
Presidential Dr, Simi Valley, CA.<br />
5:30 Admission: Not set. For<br />
more information contact <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
<strong>National</strong> Committee<br />
Western Region, 8185001918;<br />
teresa@anca.org. Tickets on<br />
www.itsmyseat.com<br />
OCTOBER 12 - BURBANK<br />
COMMUNITY PICNIC. Location:<br />
Robert E Gross Park, 2800<br />
W Empire Ave, Burbank, CA.<br />
11am - 5pm Admission: $3.00<br />
Adults & $1.00. For more information<br />
contact Burbank <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
Center, 818-562-1918; info@<br />
burbankanc.org.<br />
OCTOBER 13 - BOOK EVENT:<br />
“ME AS HER AGAIN” BY NAN-<br />
CY AGABIAN. Location: Abril<br />
Bookstore, 415 E. Broadway<br />
#102, Glendale, CA. 7:30 pm Admission:<br />
FREE. For more information<br />
contact Abril Bookstore,<br />
818 243 4112; info@abrilbooks.<br />
com.<br />
OCTOBER 13 - DANCE CLASS.<br />
Location: Homenetmen Ararat<br />
Chapter, 3347 San Fern<strong>and</strong>o<br />
Road, Glendale, CA. 7:30 pm<br />
Admission: $40.00 Donation.<br />
For more information contact<br />
Homenetmen Ararat Chapter,<br />
818-640-2657; arenanor@aol.<br />
com.<br />
OCTOBER 18, 2008 - ST. PE-<br />
TER LADIES SOCIETY “PUT-<br />
TIN’ ON THE RITZ” ANNUAL<br />
FASHION SHOW & LUN-<br />
CHEON. Location: Sheraton<br />
Universal Hotel, Gr<strong>and</strong> Ballroom,<br />
333 Universal Hollywood<br />
Drive, Universal City, CA. Boutique<br />
& Social Hour at 10:00 a.m.<br />
Luncheon at 12:00 p.m. Tickets:<br />
$75.00. For more information<br />
contact Manoush Devian (818)<br />
886-8950 or Hermine Mitilian<br />
(818) 988-3084.<br />
OCTOBER 24 - ARPA INTER-<br />
NATIONAL FILM FESTIVAL.<br />
Location: Egyptian Theater, 6712<br />
Hollywood Blvd, Hollywood, CA.<br />
6pm Admission: $11-$25. For<br />
more information contact AF-<br />
FMA, 323-663-1882; affma95@<br />
aol.com.<br />
OCTOBER 23 - BOOK EVENT:<br />
“WILLIAM SAROYAN: PLAC-<br />
ES IN TIME”. Location: Abril<br />
Bookstore, 415 E. Broadway<br />
#102, Glendale, CA. 7:30 pm Admission:<br />
Free. For more information<br />
contact Abril Bookstore,<br />
818 243 4112; info@abrilbooks.<br />
com.<br />
OCTOBER 24 - AESA ENGI-<br />
NEERING AND SCIENCES JOB<br />
FAIR. Location: Glendale <strong>Community</strong><br />
College, 1500 North<br />
Verdugo Road, Glendale, CA.<br />
11:00am- 3:00 pm Admission:<br />
Free. For more information contact<br />
rmenian Engineers <strong>and</strong> Scientist<br />
of America, Inc. (AESA),<br />
626.376.7420; Misak Zetilyan.<br />
OCTOBER 25 - ANC-PN AN-<br />
NUAL HAROUT BARAHANTES.<br />
Location: Homenetmen Ararat<br />
Banquet Hall, 3347 N San Fern<strong>and</strong>o<br />
Rd, Glendale, CA. 8:00<br />
pm Admission: TBD. For more<br />
information contact ANC Professional<br />
Network, ; info@ancpn.<br />
com. Tickets on www.itsmyseat.<br />
com.<br />
OCTOBER 25 – ARMENIAN<br />
PROFESSIONAL SOCIETY<br />
50TH ANNIVERSARY GALA.<br />
Location; The Sheraton Universal<br />
Hotel. Special guest, Vartan<br />
Oskanian, former Minister of<br />
Foreign Affairs, RA. Dark Eyes<br />
B<strong>and</strong>. For sponsorship <strong>and</strong> tickets<br />
information contact APS<br />
at apsla@apsla.org or 818-685-<br />
9946<br />
OCTOBER 25 - ST. JAMES AR-<br />
MENIAN CHUCH LADIES SO-<br />
CIETY PRESENT “FIESTA OLE,”<br />
ANNUAL LUNCHEON AND<br />
COUNTRY STORE: Location:<br />
St. James <strong>Armenia</strong>n Church,<br />
Gogian Hall, 4950 W. Slauson<br />
Avenue,Los Angeles. 11:00<br />
a.m. Country Store Bake Sale;<br />
12 Noon Luncheon. Donation:<br />
$35.00. Reservations: Shirley<br />
Moore (310) 670-7177; Alice Simonian<br />
(323) 465-6742.<br />
OCTOBER 26 - HOY LARI -<br />
CHILDREN’S MUSIC CONCERT.<br />
Location: Barnsdall Gallery Theatre,<br />
4800 Hollywood Blvd, Los<br />
Angeles, CA. 3:300 pm Admission:<br />
$20.00. For more information<br />
contact Horizon / Hoy Lari,<br />
(310) 600-0207; hoylari@yahoo.<br />
com. Tickets on www.itsmyseat.<br />
com.<br />
OCTOBER 26 - INSIGHT & DR.<br />
HAKOBYAN LIVE IN GLEN-<br />
DALE. Location: Glendale Public<br />
Library, 222 E. Harvard Street,<br />
Glendale, CA. 7:30 p.m. Admission:<br />
$36.00. For more information<br />
contact LNH Insight Inc.,<br />
818-230-2789; joeseifert@att.net.<br />
Tickets on www.itsmyseat.com.<br />
NOVEMBER 1 - LOS ANGE-<br />
LES 40TH ANNIVERSARY CEL-<br />
EBRATION DINNER DANCE.<br />
Location: Glendale Ararat Center,<br />
3347 N San Fern<strong>and</strong>o Rd,<br />
Los Angeles, CA. 7:00 pm Admission:<br />
$100. For more information<br />
contact LA Homenetmen,<br />
(818) 4930936; datevd@<br />
hotmail.com.<br />
OCTOBER 26 - HAMAZKAY-<br />
IN 80TH ANNIVERSARY DIN-<br />
NER BANQUET. Location: Bagramian<br />
Hall, 900 West Lincoln<br />
Avenue, Montebello, CA. 5:00<br />
p.m. Admission: $60. For more<br />
information contact Hamazkayin<br />
of Western U.S. Region,<br />
818-935-3555; info@hamazkayin.net.<br />
OCTOBER 27 - DR. HAKOBY-<br />
AN AND INSIGHT LIVE. Location:<br />
Glendale Public Library,<br />
222 E Harvard St, Glendale, CA.<br />
7:00 p.m. Admission: $40.00.<br />
For more information contact<br />
LNH Insight, Inc., 818-230-<br />
2789; joeseifert@att.net. Tickets<br />
on www.itsmyseat.com.<br />
OCTOBER 31 - GREATEST<br />
HITS BAND - HALLOWEEN<br />
BASH @ SIDE-BAR. Location:<br />
Sidebar, 1114 N. Pacific Ave.,<br />
Glendale, CA. 9 PM Admission:<br />
$10. For more information contact<br />
Greatest Hits B<strong>and</strong>, (323)<br />
365-4796; info@greatesthitsb<strong>and</strong>.com.<br />
OCTOBER 31 - AGBU HAL-<br />
LOWEEN BASH. Location:<br />
Citizen Smith, 1600 N Cahuenga<br />
Blvd, Hollywood, CA.<br />
9PM - 2 AM Admission: $25<br />
presale $30 door. For more<br />
information contact AGBU<br />
YP, ; Ani_AGBUYPLA@yahoo.<br />
com. Tickets on www.itsmyseat.com.<br />
NOVEMBER 1 - FRIENDS OF<br />
MASSIS 5K RUN/WALK. Location:<br />
Woodley Park, 6335 Woodley<br />
Ave, Van Nuys, CA. 8:30 AM<br />
Admission: $25. For more information<br />
contact HMEM Massis,<br />
(818) 554-4397; massis5k@gmail.<br />
com. Tickets on www.itsmyseat.<br />
com.<br />
NOVEMBER 2 - AKH’TAMAR<br />
DANCE ENSEMBLE OF NJ<br />
ST. THOMAS ARMENIAN<br />
CHURCH IN GLENDALE. Location:<br />
Glendale High School Auditorium,<br />
2000 W. BROADWAY,<br />
Glendale, CA. 6pm Admission:<br />
$50 - $35 - $20-$12. For more information<br />
contact Tekeyan <strong>and</strong><br />
OIA, 818-243-4112.<br />
NOVEMBER 3 - DR. HAKO-<br />
BYAN AND INSIGHT LIVE. Location:<br />
Glendale Public Library,<br />
222 E Harvard St, Glendale, CA.<br />
7:00 p.m. Admission: $40.00.<br />
For more information contact<br />
LNH Insight, Inc., 818-230-<br />
2789; joeseifert@att.net. Tickets<br />
on www.itsmyseat.com.<br />
NOVEMBER 7 - DR. HAKO-<br />
BYAN AND INSIGHT LIVE IN<br />
GLENDALE. Location: Glendale<br />
Public Library, 222 E Harvard<br />
St, Glendale, CA. 7:00 p.m.<br />
Admission: $40. For more information<br />
contact LNH Insight,<br />
Inc., (818) 230-2789; joeseifert@<br />
att.net. Tickets on www.itsmyseat.com.<br />
NOVEMBER 7 - AESA 25TH<br />
ANNIVERSARY BANQUET. Location:<br />
Renaissance Banquet<br />
Hall, 1236 S Central Ave, Glendale,<br />
CA. 8:00 pm Admission:<br />
TBD. For more information contact<br />
AESA, (818) 547-3372; contact@aesa.org.<br />
NOVEMBER 8 – “SAVE THE<br />
DATE” ST. PETER ARMENIAN<br />
APOSTOLIC CHURCH 50TH<br />
ANNIVERSARY DINNER &<br />
CELEBRATION: Location: Nazarian<br />
Center of the AGBU Manoogian<br />
Demirjian School, Canoga<br />
Park – 6:00pm.<br />
NOVEMBER 8 - ST PETER AR-<br />
MENIAN CHURCH OF VAN<br />
NUYS 50TH ANNIVERSARY<br />
DINNER. Location: AGBU-AYA<br />
Nazarian Center, 6844 Oakdale<br />
Ave., Canoga Park, CA. 6:00 p.m.<br />
Admission: $150.00/person. For<br />
more information contact St<br />
Peter <strong>Armenia</strong>n Church of Van<br />
Nuys, 818-886-8950; eilesq@aol.<br />
com.<br />
NOVEMBER 9 -THE ARME-<br />
NIAN EYECARE PROJECT<br />
WILL HOST ITS SEVENTH<br />
ANNUAL NEWPORT GALA.<br />
Location: The Balboa Bay Club,<br />
Newport Beach. The event<br />
will honor Nishan <strong>and</strong> Ruby<br />
Ann Derderian with a Lifetime<br />
Humanitarian Awards<br />
<strong>and</strong> celebrate “Bringing Sight<br />
to <strong>Armenia</strong>n Eyes” for sixteen<br />
years. Dinner is at 6:00pm,<br />
$500 per person <strong>and</strong> proceeds<br />
will benefit the Project’s programs<br />
to eliminate preventable<br />
blindness in <strong>Armenia</strong>.<br />
For advance reservations <strong>and</strong><br />
additional information, contact<br />
the AECP office toll free<br />
at 866-448-2327.<br />
NOVEMBER 9 - LEYLA<br />
SARIBEKYAN EV ARSEN<br />
GRIGORIAN(MRRO). Location:<br />
Alex Theater, 216 North Br<strong>and</strong><br />
Boulevard, Glendale, CA. 20:00<br />
Admission: Soon. For more information<br />
contact Apricot Entertainment,<br />
818 397 8479;.<br />
NOVEMBER 13 - DR. HAKO-<br />
BYAN & INSIGHT LIVE. Location:<br />
Glendale Public Library,<br />
222 E Harvard St, Glendale, CA.<br />
7:00 p.m. Admission: $40. For<br />
more information contact LNH<br />
Insight, Inc., (818) 230-2789;<br />
joeseifert@att.net. Tickets on<br />
www.itsmyseat.com.<br />
NOVEMBER 15 - ANOUSHA-<br />
VAN ABRAHAMIAN EDUCA-<br />
TIONAL FUND. Location: Palladio,<br />
1018 E Colorado St, Glendale,<br />
CA. 7:00 pm Admission:<br />
$100.00 per person. For more<br />
information contact Ofik &<br />
Roza, (818) 363-7865; ofikabrahamian@hotmail.com.<br />
NOVEMBER 15 - 50TH ANNI-<br />
VERSARY AYF MONTEBELLO<br />
& ALUMNI REUNION. Location:<br />
Bagramian Hall, 900 W<br />
Lincoln Ave, Montebello, CA.<br />
8:00PM Admission: $40. For<br />
more information contact AYF<br />
Subscription Coupon<br />
the armenian<br />
reporter<br />
annual rates<br />
U.S.A.: First Class Mail, $125; Periodicals Mail, $75<br />
Canada: $125 (u.s.); Overseas: $250 (u.s.)<br />
name<br />
street<br />
city/state/zip<br />
Montebello Vahan Cardashian<br />
Chapter, 562-760-9578; ayf@ayfmontebello.org.<br />
NOVEMBER 17 - DR. HAKO-<br />
BYAN AND INSIGHT LIVE. Location:<br />
Glendale Public Library,<br />
222 E Harvard St, Glendale, CA.<br />
7:00 p.m. Admission: $40. For<br />
more information contact LNH<br />
Insight, Inc., (818) 230-2789;<br />
joeseifert@att.net. Tickets on<br />
www.itsmyseat.com.<br />
NOVEMBER 18 - ART KNOWS<br />
NO BORDERS. Location: Safari<br />
Sam’s, 5214 W Sunset Blvd,<br />
Los Angeles, CA. 7 PM Admission:<br />
$20 suggested/varies.<br />
For more information contact<br />
Crystal Allene Cook, (310) 739<br />
1159; info@artknowsnoborders.<br />
com.<br />
NOVEMBER 23 - ARMENIA<br />
FUND ANNUAL GALA. Location:<br />
Hyatt Regency Century<br />
Plaza Hotel, 2025 Avenue of the<br />
Stars, Los Angeles, CA, 90067,<br />
7:00pm . For more information,<br />
please call 818-243-6222.<br />
NOVEMBER 24 - DR. HAKO-<br />
BYAN AND INSIGHT LIVE IN<br />
GLENDALE. Location: Glendale<br />
Public Library, 222 E Harvard<br />
St, Glendale, CA. 7:00 p.m.<br />
Admission: $40. For more information<br />
contact LNH Insight,<br />
Inc., (818) 230-2789; joeseifert@<br />
att.net. Tickets on www.itsmyseat.com.<br />
NOVEMBER 28 - THANKSGIV-<br />
ING DINNER DANCE WITH<br />
PAUL. Location: PASADENA<br />
ARMENIAN CENTER, 740 E<br />
WASHINGTON BLVD, Pasadena,<br />
CA. 08:30PM Admission:<br />
$51.00. For more information<br />
contact AGBU HIGH SCHOOL<br />
PASADENA, (818) 247-1717;<br />
PAUL@VERGINIEPRODUC-<br />
TIONS.COM.<br />
NOVEMBER 29 - ARA PROJ-<br />
ECT ART SHOW AND SILENT<br />
AUCTION. Location: Vill del<br />
Sol d’Oro, 200 N. Michillinda<br />
Ave., Pasadena, CA. 12 pm-6 pm<br />
Admission: Free Admission. For<br />
more information contact ARA<br />
Project, 626 792-4479; ckaloo@<br />
sbcglobal.net.<br />
APRIL 19 - MIKHAIL SI-<br />
MONYAN, VIOLIN. Location:<br />
Raitt Recital Hall: Pepperdine<br />
University, 24255 Pacific Coast<br />
HWY, Malibu, CA. 2:00 PM Admission:<br />
$25. For more information<br />
contact Center For The<br />
Arts, (212) 994-3540; tdorn@<br />
imgartists.com.<br />
Check Enclosed OR Charge My:<br />
Mastercard Visa Amex Discover<br />
Exp.<br />
mail coupon to: armenian reporter<br />
p.o. box 129, paramus, nj 07652<br />
or<br />
fax coupon to (201) 226-1660<br />
(credit card orders only)
14 The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | October 4, 2008<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong><br />
World renowned doctors to perform 50 lifechanging<br />
surgeries in <strong>Armenia</strong> this week<br />
Cafesjian Family<br />
Foundation<br />
takes the lead in<br />
organizing Smile<br />
Network mission to<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong><br />
by Paul Chaderjian in<br />
Yerevan<br />
YEREVAN – Every morning, fouryear-old<br />
Gayane cries <strong>and</strong> begs not<br />
to be taken to school. She covers<br />
her mouth so that people don’t see<br />
her lips. But they do, <strong>and</strong> they often<br />
react.<br />
Gayane was born with a cleft lip<br />
– a genetic defect also known as<br />
cheiloschisis. In <strong>Armenia</strong>, they still<br />
call it a “harelip,” a pejorative other<br />
cultures <strong>and</strong> nations have already<br />
retired from their languages.<br />
No matter what it’s called or the<br />
age in which we live, people on the<br />
streets here often stare at Gayane.<br />
Kids at school don’t want to be<br />
around her. Some classmates make<br />
snide remarks. Others tease <strong>and</strong><br />
bully her. Some adults here think<br />
of the split in her lip as a curse or a<br />
sign that she is mentally disabled.<br />
Unfortunately, Gayane’s story is<br />
not unique; but this weekend, Gayane<br />
tortured life will change forever<br />
thanks to a team of volunteer specialists<br />
from the United States participating<br />
in the first Smile Project<br />
mission in <strong>Armenia</strong>.<br />
More than a dozen doctors, nurses,<br />
<strong>and</strong> other specialists will be in<br />
Yerevan to examine 250 patients<br />
with either a cleft lip, a cleft palate,<br />
or both. Fifty of these patients will<br />
undergo surgery between Monday,<br />
October 6, <strong>and</strong> Friday, October 10.<br />
“The two surgeons leading the<br />
team are both renowned cleft surgeons,”<br />
said Madlene Minnasian,<br />
director of the Smile Project. “One<br />
is Dr. Les Mohler, <strong>and</strong> the second<br />
is Dr. Samir Mardini. They call<br />
him Magic H<strong>and</strong>s. We’re very lucky<br />
to have world-renowned surgeons<br />
come to this mission.”<br />
Project Smile<br />
Project Smile was initiated by the<br />
Cafesjian Family Foundation, Hope<br />
for the City, <strong>and</strong> the Smile Network<br />
– which leads similar projects<br />
around the world. The three Minneapolis-based<br />
organizations have<br />
come together to address cleft-care<br />
needs in <strong>Armenia</strong>.<br />
In addition, Project Smile will<br />
give the local medical community<br />
a chance to listen to world authorities<br />
on cleft care through lectures.<br />
Local physicians <strong>and</strong> nurses will<br />
also shadow the guests <strong>and</strong> learn by<br />
observing their American counterparts.<br />
Dr. Les Mohler. Photo: Andrew Tonn.<br />
“Coming to <strong>Armenia</strong> are expert<br />
anesthesiologists, pediatricians,<br />
operating room nurses, ward<br />
nurses, medical recordkeepers, <strong>and</strong><br />
a host of nonclinical volunteers,”<br />
said Ms. Minassian. “It’s a very<br />
good group of 19 volunteers, one<br />
of which is of <strong>Armenia</strong>n heritage.<br />
He’s second or third generation <strong>Armenia</strong>n,<br />
Dr. Robert Chantigian,<br />
anesthesiologist.”<br />
It’s estimated that one in 700–<br />
1000 kids are born with a cleft lip<br />
or cleft palate, both considered<br />
the most common birth defects in<br />
the world. While there are no thorough<br />
statistics of how cleft lip <strong>and</strong><br />
cleft palate have been successfully<br />
treated in <strong>Armenia</strong>, the need for<br />
surgical intervention became obvious<br />
when Cafesjian Family Foundation<br />
board member Megan Doyle<br />
came to <strong>Armenia</strong> for a fact-finding<br />
mission last November with Kim<br />
Valentini, the founder of the<br />
Smile Network.<br />
“The Smile Network has been operating<br />
all over the world for many<br />
years,” said Ms. Minassian. “They<br />
reach out to the international community,<br />
<strong>and</strong> if they find a need for<br />
cleft care in any country, they begin<br />
their work. Through the generosity<br />
<strong>and</strong> coordination of Hope<br />
for the City <strong>and</strong> its founder Megan<br />
Doyle, we were able to meet Kim<br />
Valentini, who is founder of the<br />
Smile Network. It was wonderful<br />
to host Megan <strong>and</strong> Kim in <strong>Armenia</strong>.<br />
The passion <strong>and</strong> love they have for<br />
children all over the world is inspirational<br />
<strong>and</strong> exemplary.”<br />
Megan <strong>and</strong> Dennis Doyle established<br />
Hope for the City eight years<br />
ago to help fight poverty, hunger,<br />
<strong>and</strong> disease around the world by<br />
utilizing corporate surplus. The<br />
couple’s organization has brought<br />
more than $40 million in medical<br />
equipment, supplies, <strong>and</strong> medication<br />
to <strong>Armenia</strong> over the past few<br />
years <strong>and</strong> was instrumental in<br />
bringing the Smile Network to <strong>Armenia</strong>.<br />
“Mrs. Doyle came to oversee <strong>and</strong><br />
visit her projects in <strong>Armenia</strong>, <strong>and</strong><br />
she brought Mrs. Valentini with<br />
her,” said Ms. Minassian. “The visit<br />
helped determine that there was a<br />
need for cleft care in <strong>Armenia</strong>, even<br />
though we have experienced, competent,<br />
very professional maxillofacial<br />
surgeons here. The problem<br />
was in the ability for the patient<br />
to pay for the care <strong>and</strong> access to<br />
surgery.”<br />
The government of the Republic<br />
of <strong>Armenia</strong> tells the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
Reporter that it offers a $700 stipend<br />
for children under seven in<br />
need of reconstructive cleft-lip or<br />
cleft-palate surgeries, which are estimated<br />
to cost around $2,000 in<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong> <strong>and</strong> upwards of $10,000<br />
if performed in the United States.<br />
One local surgeon says that the<br />
government subsidy does not cover<br />
costs for surgery, <strong>and</strong> the families<br />
are asked to pay the difference.<br />
Preparing for the<br />
mission<br />
During Mrs. Doyle’s <strong>and</strong> Mrs. Valentini’s<br />
trip to <strong>Armenia</strong> last November,<br />
the Smile Project was able<br />
to secure the support of <strong>Armenia</strong>’s<br />
Ministry of Health.<br />
“We met with many different institutions<br />
in order to do a search<br />
to find a partner,” said Ms. Minassian,<br />
“<strong>and</strong> we found our partner in<br />
Dr. Les Mohler. Photo: Marc Ascher.<br />
the Arabkir Medical Center, which<br />
is run by Dr. Ara Babloyan. It’s<br />
a privately owned <strong>and</strong> the largest<br />
pediatrics hospital in <strong>Armenia</strong>. Dr.<br />
Babloyan is a very capable, brilliant<br />
person.”<br />
The Smile Project also partnered<br />
with the Health ministry’s Mother<br />
<strong>and</strong> Child Department, which was<br />
able to tap into public records <strong>and</strong><br />
its regional polyclinics <strong>and</strong> provide<br />
a list of hundreds of children born<br />
with cleft conditions since 1988.<br />
“The lists were pretty extensive,<br />
<strong>and</strong> we tried to target younger children<br />
that we thought would have<br />
not been operated on,” said Ms.<br />
Minassian. “The lists did not indicate<br />
whether these children had<br />
had surgery. We just had statistics<br />
of the birth defects.”<br />
While compiling lists of prospective<br />
patients, the Smile Project also<br />
engaged local media to reach out to<br />
families in Yerevan <strong>and</strong> throughout<br />
the republic. The media campaign<br />
resulted in hundreds of calls from<br />
parents with children who needed<br />
cleft care as well as adults, well into<br />
their 40s, who had had a series of<br />
unsuccessful cleft procedures.<br />
“We have so much support that it<br />
is surprising,” said Erik Grigoryan,<br />
project manager for the Smile<br />
Project. “<strong>Armenia</strong>ns are usually less<br />
volunteerism-oriented, <strong>and</strong> it was<br />
a surprise for me to get the type<br />
of feedback we have been receiving.<br />
For example, we went to the hotels<br />
<strong>and</strong> asked for discounts <strong>and</strong> said<br />
these doctors are coming to Yerevan<br />
to perform free surgeries. We<br />
received 25–30 percent discounts<br />
plus car service from Hotel Meg.”<br />
Another big surprise for Mr.<br />
Grigoryan has been the number<br />
of calls he has been receiving from<br />
people who want to volunteer next<br />
week. He has enlisted psychologists,<br />
speech therapists, translators, <strong>and</strong><br />
those who wants to drive patients<br />
<strong>and</strong> their parents to <strong>and</strong> from the<br />
screenings <strong>and</strong> surgeries.<br />
“One woman called <strong>and</strong> wanted to<br />
cook for the patients <strong>and</strong> the other<br />
volunteers,” said Mr. Grigoryan.<br />
One of the other businesses<br />
heavily involved with getting the<br />
word out was Cascade Insurance,<br />
which took the initiative to print<br />
<strong>and</strong> distribute posters to all local<br />
<strong>and</strong> regional hospitals, clinics, <strong>and</strong><br />
dental offices informing the public<br />
about the Smile Project.<br />
“When people call to register<br />
for the screenings,” said Yvetta<br />
Ghazaryan, project coordinator,<br />
“they cannot believe that<br />
this medical attention is possible<br />
in <strong>Armenia</strong>. Many patients <strong>and</strong><br />
their families have been waiting<br />
for this mission with a lot of hope<br />
<strong>and</strong> they trust us. They know that<br />
with the help of our mission, the<br />
children will begin a new life. They<br />
will also gain the invaluable gift of<br />
a new smile.<br />
Preparing for this<br />
mission<br />
With the health ministries of the<br />
Republic of <strong>Armenia</strong> <strong>and</strong> the Republic<br />
of Nagorno-Karabakh, the<br />
Arabkir Medical Center, <strong>and</strong> the Cafesjian<br />
Family Foundation teamed<br />
up to organize the first Smile Project<br />
mission, the Fund for <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
Relief (FAR), <strong>and</strong> the H<strong>and</strong> in H<strong>and</strong><br />
nongovernmental organization in<br />
Karabakh also joined the project.<br />
“FAR is taking care of transportation<br />
costs <strong>and</strong> food <strong>and</strong> lodging for<br />
our patients, so the 50 who are chosen<br />
for surgery will then get their<br />
transportation compensated for<br />
<strong>and</strong> will get their nutrition,” said<br />
Ms. Minassian. “They will bring<br />
food to the children who are in<br />
post-operation care, <strong>and</strong> they will<br />
also pay for the lodging of one relative<br />
if they are from out of town.”<br />
Helping locate patients with<br />
cleft care needs in the Republic of<br />
Nagorno-Karabakh was the H<strong>and</strong><br />
in H<strong>and</strong> organization, which is a<br />
partnership of several Canadian-<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n medical associations.<br />
H<strong>and</strong> in H<strong>and</strong> provides free dental<br />
care through mobile clinics <strong>and</strong><br />
several stationary clinics all over<br />
Karabakh. Since cleft children have<br />
major dental care needs, H<strong>and</strong> in<br />
H<strong>and</strong> was able to let cleft children’s<br />
parents know about the Smile Project<br />
mission.<br />
“They’ve been instrumental as<br />
our Karabakh partners.” said Ms.<br />
Minassian.<br />
First week of October<br />
After screening exams on Saturday<br />
<strong>and</strong> Sunday, October 4 <strong>and</strong><br />
5, the visiting medical specialists<br />
will meet <strong>and</strong> discuss each of the<br />
cases. The team will see 17 patients<br />
an hour <strong>and</strong> 250 patients over the<br />
weekend.<br />
“Fifty-five of the patients are under<br />
seven <strong>and</strong> are awaiting their<br />
first surgeries,” said Ms. Ghazaryan,<br />
the project coordinator. “Other patients<br />
are as old as 43, who need<br />
additional operations. There’s one<br />
patient who has had 11 surgeries<br />
already <strong>and</strong> had complications, infections,<br />
<strong>and</strong> sometimes the palate<br />
cracks were not closed properly.”<br />
Ms. Ghazaryan says patients are<br />
coming from all over the Republic<br />
of <strong>Armenia</strong>, from Karabakh, as<br />
well as Javakh in Georgia. Those<br />
patients who live in Yerevan or are<br />
a short distance away have already<br />
been prescreened by Dr. Harach<br />
Arshakyan, a plastic surgeon<br />
from the Arabkir Medical Center.<br />
Dr. Arshakyan has been organizing<br />
the clinical aspect of this first mission,<br />
<strong>and</strong> he has already seen 150<br />
patients who will be examined by<br />
the team from the Smile Network.<br />
Dr. Arshakyan tells the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
Reporter that cleft issues arise in<br />
the first three months of a pregnancy,<br />
<strong>and</strong> he tries to advocate that<br />
in addition to genetic factors, malnutrition<br />
<strong>and</strong> low folic acids may<br />
also be factors in children being<br />
born with cleft palates <strong>and</strong> lips. He<br />
said he sees a great need for the local<br />
medical community to develop<br />
cleft care services <strong>and</strong> deal with the<br />
current need.<br />
“The patients already screened<br />
by Dr. Arshakyan will meet our<br />
visiting pediatricians <strong>and</strong> with our<br />
cleft surgeons <strong>and</strong> nurses,” said Ms.<br />
Minassian. “Vital statistics will be<br />
taken, <strong>and</strong> we will make sure that<br />
the child is healthy, that the child<br />
doesn’t have any conditions or issues<br />
that would lead to complications<br />
or inability to operate.”<br />
After the initial examinations,<br />
the team will meet Sunday afternoon,<br />
prioritize the 250 patients<br />
<strong>and</strong> schedule surgeries for the top<br />
50 patients.<br />
“The highest priority is for children<br />
that have problems with<br />
nutrition,” said Ms. Minassian.<br />
“Children who have not had an operation<br />
before will also be a high<br />
priority. With a condition like cleft<br />
palate, there are difficulties in eating,<br />
so if you’re trying to feed with<br />
a bottle, <strong>and</strong> the child is very young,<br />
they can’t suckle. And most of these<br />
children end up being fed through<br />
a feeding tube. Also, drinking from<br />
a cup, even drinking from a bottle<br />
can result from the milk coming<br />
out of the nose.”<br />
After the screenings, the Smile<br />
Project team will schedule 10 daily<br />
surgeries for five days. Two different<br />
surgical teams will operate in<br />
two separate operating rooms, <strong>and</strong><br />
surgeries may take between 40<br />
minutes to two hours.<br />
“Two hundred cleft care patients<br />
will not have the opportunity to be<br />
treated,” said Ms. Minassian, “Instead<br />
of being turned away, we’re<br />
organizing a spring mission; but<br />
we’re going to need funds to do that.<br />
The funds for this week’s mission<br />
are covered, but we’re going to have<br />
to share in the Smile Network’s<br />
costs for a follow-up mission.” f<br />
connect:<br />
madleneminassian@gmail.com<br />
(818) 434 1725<br />
+374 99 00 25 30
The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | October 4, 2008 15<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong><br />
From <strong>Armenia</strong>, in brief<br />
Minister discusses<br />
potential impact of<br />
global financial crisis<br />
Tigran Davtian, <strong>Armenia</strong>’s finance<br />
minister, at a press conference on<br />
September 30 said he expected the<br />
short-term impact of the global<br />
financial crisis on <strong>Armenia</strong> to be<br />
minimal. According to Armenpress,<br />
the minister acknowledged that<br />
some negative influence might be<br />
felt over the long haul. “Our share<br />
in the world financial market is not<br />
big,” noted the minister.<br />
Serge Sargsian<br />
meets with Georgian<br />
president in Tiblisi<br />
President Serge Sargsian went to<br />
Tbilisi for an official visit on September<br />
30 to meet his Georgian<br />
counterpart Mikheil Saakashvili.<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>’s president expressed<br />
his condolences for the lost lives<br />
after the conflict in August in the<br />
country. Both men stressed the importance<br />
of the centuries-long relationship<br />
of <strong>Armenia</strong> <strong>and</strong> Georgia<br />
<strong>and</strong> underscored the necessity to<br />
further deepen relations <strong>and</strong> foster<br />
development between the two<br />
countries. According to Armenpress,<br />
the presidents also discussed<br />
a number of issues on economic<br />
cooperation <strong>and</strong> partnership including<br />
the spheres of energy <strong>and</strong><br />
transport, making special reference<br />
to border zoning activities,<br />
inter-border cooperation, as well as<br />
the facilitation of entry processes<br />
for the citizens of both countries.<br />
According to Arminfo Georgia<br />
<strong>and</strong> <strong>Armenia</strong> reached an agreement<br />
to set up a consortium on<br />
the construction of a highway between<br />
the two states that will run<br />
through Ajaria. They are hopeful<br />
that the consortium will procure<br />
the necessary funds for the construction<br />
of this highway in two<br />
months’ time. According to the<br />
Georgian president, they have already<br />
started construction through<br />
the aid of foreign finances. Almost<br />
70 percent of all <strong>Armenia</strong>n trade<br />
flows through Georgia.<br />
Mr. Sargsian also stressed that<br />
Georgia’s stability was imperative<br />
for peace <strong>and</strong> stability in the entire<br />
region. Noting that <strong>Armenia</strong> has<br />
a strategic partnership with Russia,<br />
at the same time, <strong>Armenia</strong> <strong>and</strong><br />
Georgia are neighbors. “Our commitments<br />
as partners, neighbors,<br />
<strong>and</strong> strategic allies must not bother<br />
each other <strong>and</strong> must not contradict<br />
one another,” the <strong>Armenia</strong>n president<br />
said.<br />
Hovik Abrahamian<br />
elected as Speaker of<br />
the <strong>National</strong> Assembly<br />
On September 29, Hovik Abrahamian,<br />
member of the ruling<br />
Republican Party of <strong>Armenia</strong> (RPA),<br />
was elected by secret ballot as the<br />
new Speaker of <strong>Armenia</strong>’s <strong>National</strong><br />
Assembly. Larissa Alaverdian of<br />
the Heritage Party was also nominated<br />
for the position. She received<br />
5 votes, while Mr. Abrahamian received<br />
110 votes.<br />
According to Armenpress, Mr.<br />
Abrahamian took his oath as a<br />
newly elected member of parliament<br />
<strong>and</strong> then presented his program.<br />
He stressed the necessity of<br />
mutual respect <strong>and</strong> tolerance, <strong>and</strong><br />
espoused an atmosphere of partnership.<br />
The former Speaker of the <strong>National</strong><br />
Assembly Tigran Torossian,<br />
had been ousted out by his party,<br />
which designates the Speaker according<br />
to the coalition agreement.<br />
Mr. Torossian later resigned<br />
from the RPA.<br />
Hranush Hakobyan.<br />
Serge Sargsian<br />
in Tbilisi<br />
with Mikheil<br />
Saakashvili.<br />
Photos:<br />
Photolure.<br />
Hranush Hakobyan<br />
appointed minister of<br />
diaspora affairs<br />
Hranush Hakobyan was appointed<br />
as minister of diaspora affairs on<br />
October 2 by a presidential decree.<br />
She was relieved at the same time<br />
T. Sarkisian at the Agroforum opening.<br />
of her position as chair of the parliamentary<br />
committee on Foreign<br />
Affairs <strong>and</strong> Diaspora Relations. The<br />
diaspora ministry is a new ministry<br />
that will now be fully operational.<br />
According to Arminfo, Ms. Hakobyan<br />
graduated from Yerevan State<br />
University with a degree in applied<br />
mathematics. She has been a member<br />
of parliament since 1999 <strong>and</strong><br />
served as Minister of Labor <strong>and</strong> Social<br />
Affairs from 1996 to 1998.<br />
Fruitful <strong>Armenia</strong><br />
Agroforum opens in<br />
Yerevan<br />
The fourth international Fruitful<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong> Agroforum was launched<br />
by Seda Stepanyan<br />
David Nalb<strong>and</strong>ian said these<br />
words during a press conference in<br />
Yerevan on October 2. The professional<br />
tennis player, who is ranked<br />
7th in the world, arrived in <strong>Armenia</strong><br />
on the invitation of Argentinian-<strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
investor Eduardo<br />
Eurnekian. On October 2, Mr.<br />
Nalb<strong>and</strong>ian gave master classes<br />
to young <strong>Armenia</strong>n tennis players<br />
<strong>and</strong> then played a friendly exhibition<br />
game with <strong>Armenia</strong>’s top lawn<br />
tennis player Harutyun Sofyan.<br />
The renowned tennis player said<br />
that he always dreamed of coming<br />
to <strong>Armenia</strong> but there was<br />
in Yerevan on September 30. Present<br />
at the opening ceremonies was<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>’s Prime Minister Tigran<br />
Sarkisian, who said that agriculture<br />
development is one of the top<br />
priorities of the government. According<br />
to Mediamax, the prime<br />
minister said, “Today agriculture<br />
secures 30 percent of <strong>Armenia</strong>’s<br />
GDP, <strong>and</strong> this is a quite high index.”<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong> was one of the first<br />
states from the post-Soviet era to<br />
implement radical reforms in agriculture.<br />
However at this stage,<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong> must pay more attention<br />
to infrastructure development, including<br />
irrigation.<br />
Minister of Agriculture<br />
Aramayis Grigoryan said that<br />
the primary objective of the forum<br />
is to study the experience of<br />
developed countries <strong>and</strong> effectively<br />
implement them in <strong>Armenia</strong>.<br />
Fruitful-<strong>Armenia</strong> Fund was established<br />
in 2005, <strong>and</strong> its main goal<br />
is to secure development of farm<br />
economies <strong>and</strong> expansion of prospects<br />
for stable development in agriculture.<br />
The event is organized by<br />
Argentinean-<strong>Armenia</strong>n businessperson<br />
Eduardo Eurnekian.<br />
Digitec 2008 launched<br />
in Yerevan<br />
The fourth annual international exhibition<br />
Digitec 2008 was launched<br />
in Yerevan on October 3 <strong>and</strong> will<br />
run till October 5. According to the<br />
never enough time because of his<br />
extremely tight schedule. He will<br />
be in <strong>Armenia</strong> for three days but<br />
hopes that he will be able to travel<br />
to his “first” homel<strong>and</strong> more often<br />
after finishing his career in professional<br />
tennis. “I have two homel<strong>and</strong>s<br />
<strong>and</strong> <strong>Armenia</strong> is the first one.<br />
I am proud to be able to be here”<br />
said Nalb<strong>and</strong>ian.<br />
During the press conference,<br />
Mr. Nalb<strong>and</strong>ian recalled that he<br />
won his first championship at<br />
12 years old <strong>and</strong> devoted his victory<br />
to his family, which included<br />
his father Norberto (deceased),<br />
mother Alda, <strong>and</strong> two older<br />
brothers Dario <strong>and</strong> Javier, who<br />
also play tennis.<br />
f<br />
head of the Union of Information<br />
Technology Enterprises Karen<br />
Vardanian, the objective of this<br />
annual exhibition is to create favorable<br />
conditions to present <strong>Armenia</strong>’s<br />
achievements in the sphere of<br />
information technology. The exhibition<br />
also provides companies the<br />
opportunity to discuss their issues,<br />
study the dynamics of the field, underst<strong>and</strong><br />
some of the challenges,<br />
<strong>and</strong> become acquainted with each<br />
other’s achievements. Also it will<br />
serve as a vehicle to strengthen<br />
cooperation between the state <strong>and</strong><br />
the private sector.<br />
Simultaneous events will be taking<br />
place like DigiLive. About 50<br />
local <strong>and</strong> international IT organizations<br />
will be participating including,<br />
Microsoft RA, Softline, MediaStyle<br />
<strong>and</strong> Moscow Teleport.<br />
Young <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
chess players to take<br />
part in world youth<br />
championships in<br />
Vietnam<br />
Fifteen <strong>Armenia</strong>n chess players will<br />
be traveling to Vun Tau, Vietnam,<br />
between October 19 <strong>and</strong> 31 to take<br />
part in the World Youth Championship.<br />
Officials from the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
Chess Federation said that<br />
chess players from more than 100<br />
countries will be participating in<br />
the tournament.<br />
f<br />
“I am <strong>Armenia</strong>n <strong>and</strong> we are a nation of fighters”<br />
David Nalb<strong>and</strong>ian at a press briefing<br />
in Yerevan. Photo: Photolure.<br />
Advertising Sales Representative wanted<br />
The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter has an immediate opportunity available<br />
for a dynamic advertising sales representative.<br />
Your key focus will be to support the growth of advertising<br />
sales. Duties will include prospecting for new accounts, developing<br />
ad proposals, <strong>and</strong> managing existing accounts. The<br />
successful c<strong>and</strong>idate should be a self-starter, motivated, <strong>and</strong><br />
a team player who possesses the following: good communication<br />
skills, proficiency in Microsoft Office applications; ability<br />
to work under pressure within deadlines. Bilingual (<strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
<strong>and</strong> English) a plus, but not required.<br />
Little or no sales experience is okay. Part <strong>and</strong> full time options.<br />
Qualified applicants please email resumes to<br />
jobs@reporter.am
16 The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | October 4, 2008<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong><br />
Military training aims to enhance regional trust<br />
Cooperative<br />
Longbow/Lancer<br />
NATO military<br />
training commences<br />
in <strong>Armenia</strong><br />
by Armen Hakobyan<br />
YEREVAN – Sheri Maclean is from<br />
Ontario, Canada. Even though this<br />
is her first visit to <strong>Armenia</strong>, the<br />
ancient country has already left a<br />
warm impression upon her. She<br />
has visited Republic Square, which<br />
according to her “is simply amazing.”<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n soldiers have also<br />
left a good impression on Officer<br />
McLean; some of them are able to<br />
communicate in English.<br />
The Canadian soldier is one of<br />
940 participants in the NATO Cooperative<br />
Longbow/Lancer military<br />
training <strong>and</strong> has been in <strong>Armenia</strong><br />
for the past month. Our conversation<br />
is interrupted when her fellow<br />
soldiers call her for a photograph<br />
with the Canadian flag with the<br />
Biblical Mount Ararat in the background.<br />
The fascination with Ararat<br />
is widespread, especially as today<br />
the holy mountain has pushed<br />
aside the clouds <strong>and</strong> has revealed<br />
its wondrous peak. After the Canadians,<br />
the Americans take pictures,<br />
<strong>and</strong> then the Kazakhs, the Moldovans,<br />
<strong>and</strong> so on.<br />
Officer Maclean <strong>and</strong> the other<br />
NATO soldiers are at the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
Defense Ministry’s Vazgen Sarkissian<br />
Military Institute, where the<br />
opening ceremony of the Cooperative<br />
Longbow/Lancer military trainings<br />
took place on September 29.<br />
Prior to the opening ceremony,<br />
Lieutenant General John D. Gardner,<br />
deputy comm<strong>and</strong>er, L<strong>and</strong><br />
Component Comm<strong>and</strong> Heidelberg<br />
<strong>and</strong> Major General Arshaluis Paytyan,<br />
deputy chief of the General<br />
Staff of Military Forces of <strong>Armenia</strong>,<br />
held a press conference. NATO’s<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>’s choices: Russia or NATO or both<br />
Yerevan is able<br />
to maintain<br />
good relations<br />
with Moscow,<br />
Washington, <strong>and</strong><br />
Brussels<br />
by Tatul Hakobyan<br />
YEREVAN – One of the architects<br />
of <strong>Armenia</strong>’s foreign policy of complementarity,<br />
Vartan Oskanian,<br />
used to insist that it was possible<br />
for Yerevan to maintain good <strong>and</strong><br />
equal relations with Russia <strong>and</strong> the<br />
Collective Security Treaty Organization<br />
(CSTO) on the one h<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong><br />
the European Union <strong>and</strong> NATO on<br />
the other. Mr. Oskanian also noted<br />
that the principle of complementarity<br />
is completely justified as long as<br />
relations with Russia <strong>and</strong> the West<br />
remain normal. When Georgia’s attack<br />
on South Ossetia on August<br />
8 turned into Russian aggression<br />
against Georgia, the fragile balance<br />
of Moscow/Washington/Brussels<br />
was breached. Some specialists<br />
even began talking about a return<br />
of the Cold War.<br />
Official Yerevan was able to maintain<br />
good relations with Moscow<br />
<strong>and</strong> the West. Concerns that Russia<br />
could place its strategic partners,<br />
Cooperative Longbow/Lancer<br />
military trainings are conducted<br />
annually <strong>and</strong> bring together NATO<br />
members, Partnership for Peace<br />
members as well as Mediterranean<br />
Dialog Nations <strong>and</strong> Istanbul Initiative<br />
Nations. “It is aimed at the<br />
implementation of crisis response<br />
processes within the framework of<br />
the UN’s m<strong>and</strong>ate, the main aim<br />
of which is improving the cooperation<br />
of NATO’s soldiers <strong>and</strong> those<br />
of its partner countries in spheres<br />
such as doctrine, procedures, comm<strong>and</strong><br />
headquarter systems <strong>and</strong><br />
terminology,” noted the American<br />
general. He thanked the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
side, headed by Defense Minister<br />
Seyran Ohanian, Major General<br />
Arshaluis Paytyan. <strong>and</strong> training cochair<br />
Murad Isakhanian for their<br />
efforts <strong>and</strong> the large-scale preparatory<br />
works. Gen. Paytyan said<br />
that such military trainings within<br />
NATO’s partnership are being conducted<br />
in <strong>Armenia</strong> for the second<br />
time.<br />
The current military trainings<br />
will continue until October 20.<br />
Gen. Gardner first of all noted that<br />
such military trainings create the<br />
opportunity to establish relations,<br />
exchange experience <strong>and</strong> methods<br />
of working <strong>and</strong> improve the<br />
professionalism of all participating<br />
Armed Forces. He emphasized<br />
that 900 soldiers from seven NATO<br />
member <strong>and</strong> 10 partner countries<br />
are involved in the military training.<br />
More than 360 soldiers <strong>and</strong><br />
officers from the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Armed<br />
Forces are also participating.<br />
“The military trainings consist of<br />
two phases: multination comm<strong>and</strong><br />
headquarters military trainings on<br />
a brigade level <strong>and</strong> field trainings<br />
on a battalion level. If we study the<br />
staff of the posts, we can see the<br />
multinational essence of the military<br />
trainings. For example, the<br />
Cooperative Longbow battalion<br />
headquarters consists of officers<br />
from the following countries: the<br />
comm<strong>and</strong>er is from Switzerl<strong>and</strong>,<br />
head of headquarters <strong>and</strong> the intelligence<br />
officer from Austria, the<br />
including <strong>Armenia</strong>, before a difficult<br />
choice by asking them to recognize<br />
South Ossetia <strong>and</strong> Abkhazia<br />
were not justified. President Serge<br />
Sargsian explained to Moscow, in<br />
a language that they could underst<strong>and</strong>,<br />
that <strong>Armenia</strong> could not recognize<br />
those two entities – in the<br />
same way that it did not recognize<br />
Kosovo months earlier. <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
authorities made it clear that they<br />
would not recognize them henceforth<br />
because they had not yet recognized<br />
Nagorno-Karabakh.<br />
Official Yerevan has stated on<br />
many occasions that it is realizing<br />
a foreign policy of complementarity,<br />
<strong>and</strong> deepening its relations<br />
with Russia <strong>and</strong> CSTO on the one<br />
h<strong>and</strong>, <strong>and</strong> the West <strong>and</strong> NATO on<br />
the other is not contradictory. Will<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong> be able to continue with<br />
its adopted foreign policy of complementarity<br />
of the past decade<br />
In other words, will it be able to<br />
continue to deepen relations with<br />
the European Union <strong>and</strong> NATO<br />
without causing discomfort for<br />
Russia, a country which <strong>Armenia</strong><br />
depends upon strategically, politically,<br />
<strong>and</strong> economically.<br />
Arkady Dubnov, an analyst<br />
with the Russian daily Vremya Novostey<br />
told the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter<br />
that following the five-day war, a<br />
new agenda was formed which will<br />
refer initially to the Caucasus. Mr.<br />
Dubnov referred to Kazakhstan as<br />
an example (Kazakhstan is one of<br />
the seven members of CSTO, <strong>and</strong><br />
Soldiers at the opening ceremony of NATO exercises in <strong>Armenia</strong>. Photo: Armen<br />
Hakobyan for the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter..<br />
personnel officer from <strong>Armenia</strong>,<br />
the military-civilian officer from<br />
the U.S. <strong>and</strong> the communication<br />
officer from Moldova. The second<br />
part of the military trainings, the<br />
Cooperative Lancer, is a field training<br />
with the following battalion<br />
<strong>and</strong> headquarter staff: Comm<strong>and</strong>er<br />
– <strong>Armenia</strong>, Head of Headquarters<br />
– Austria, Chief Sergeant – USA, Action<br />
Officer – Bosnia <strong>and</strong> Herzegovina<br />
<strong>and</strong> rear guard officer – Greece.<br />
The battalion will work with three<br />
companies, one from <strong>Armenia</strong> <strong>and</strong><br />
the other two comprised of different<br />
nations. This structure proves<br />
the multinational character of the<br />
event,” noted Lt General John D.<br />
Gardner.<br />
He clarified that during the field<br />
trainings mostly light arms are going<br />
to be used. Gen. Paytyan added<br />
that transportation <strong>and</strong> sanitary<br />
helicopters will also be used. Asked<br />
whether the Roubezh-2008 exercises<br />
recently organized within the<br />
CSTO <strong>and</strong> Russia cooperation framework<br />
<strong>and</strong> these military trainings<br />
will not affect or damage the bilateral<br />
cooperation, he said no. He<br />
noted that both military trainings<br />
had been planned in 2007 <strong>and</strong> were<br />
implemented according to signed<br />
contracts. In essence, according to<br />
one of Russia’s closest allies), who<br />
after the war in August began to<br />
consider the expediency of transporting<br />
Kazakh gas through the<br />
Baku-Tiblis-Ceyhan pipeline, <strong>and</strong><br />
has also refused to build a gas refinery<br />
<strong>and</strong> a grain terminal in Georgia.<br />
According to the Russian analyst,<br />
the Kazakhs are taking steps that<br />
will not irritate Russia.<br />
“I don’t think that Moscow has<br />
similar expectations from Yerevan<br />
because <strong>Armenia</strong> doesn’t participate<br />
in any regional project which<br />
is unacceptable to Russia. From<br />
a geopolitical perspective, Russia<br />
will continue to be <strong>Armenia</strong>’s principal<br />
security guarantor as long<br />
as <strong>Armenia</strong> remains surrounded<br />
by enemies, at least on behalf of<br />
one of its neighbors,” Mr. Dubnov<br />
said.<br />
In his opinion, the five-day war<br />
in August demonstrated that Russia<br />
is prepared to use force to protect<br />
its interests, while the United<br />
States is not prepared to confront<br />
Russia, trying to avoid being<br />
pulled into an extensive war. According<br />
to Mr. Dubnov, <strong>Armenia</strong><br />
cannot ignore Russia’s position<br />
in the Caucasus nor the existence<br />
of a Russian military base in Gyumri.<br />
“However all of this does not<br />
mean that Yerevan is obligated to<br />
become a vassal of Moscow <strong>and</strong><br />
under this pressure relinquish its<br />
relations with the West <strong>and</strong> NATO<br />
or slow down cooperation, with a<br />
clear stipulation that <strong>Armenia</strong> does<br />
not intend to become a member<br />
of NATO in the future. I hope that<br />
in the Kremlin they realize that<br />
pressure against <strong>Armenia</strong> in the<br />
end will have a boomerang effect<br />
<strong>and</strong> can create anti-Russian sentiments,”<br />
concluded Mr. Dubnov.<br />
Aghavni Karakhanian, director<br />
of the Yerevan-based Institute<br />
for Civil Society <strong>and</strong> Regional Development<br />
(ICSRD), believes that<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong> must not change its foreign<br />
policy. Ms. Karakhanian believes<br />
that <strong>Armenia</strong> must not only<br />
maintain its foreign policy of complementarity<br />
but it must further<br />
develop <strong>and</strong> supplement it.<br />
“Today, our foreign policy of complementarity<br />
has justified itself like<br />
never before. It is possible to say<br />
that it is the only reasonable choice,<br />
<strong>and</strong> as a foreign policy principle its<br />
accurateness has been proven. The<br />
August crisis demonstrated that<br />
to ‘hang on by a single branch,’ no<br />
matter how strong it is, is not justified,”<br />
Ms. Karakhanian told the<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter.<br />
Asbed Kotchikian, a lecturer at<br />
Bentley College told the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
Reporter that the idea of complementary<br />
foreign policy was appreciated<br />
by pro-Russian circles as a euphemism<br />
for lip service to the West<br />
<strong>and</strong> a full-spectrum relationship<br />
with Russia. Other circles, on the<br />
other h<strong>and</strong>, regarded it as a positive<br />
sign where <strong>Armenia</strong>n diplomacy<br />
had finally come up with an<br />
the general’s evaluation, the effectiveness<br />
of the military trainings<br />
organized within the CSTO framework<br />
was high <strong>and</strong> best results are<br />
expected from this military training,<br />
especially when “these military<br />
trainings are aimed at the maintenance<br />
of general peace.” Even<br />
though during the planning stage<br />
it was decided that Georgia would<br />
participate in the ongoing military<br />
trainings with one battalion, as<br />
General Paytyan noted, “because of<br />
obvious reasons, Georgia’s Armed<br />
Forces are not participating. In the<br />
preliminary phase it was decided<br />
that Russia would participate, but<br />
currently, naturally, it is not participating.<br />
As far as the others are<br />
concerned, including Turkey <strong>and</strong><br />
Azerbaijan, each of them decides<br />
the level of its participation.”<br />
In a speech at the opening ceremony,<br />
Arthur Baghdasarian,<br />
secretary of <strong>Armenia</strong>’s Security<br />
Council, stressed <strong>Armenia</strong>’s complementary<br />
approach to cooperating<br />
with both NATO <strong>and</strong> the CSTO.<br />
“These military trainings are a very<br />
good example for successfully organizing<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>-NATO activities<br />
<strong>and</strong> we are sure that cooperation<br />
will continue. Only a month ago<br />
the Rubezh-2008 military trainings<br />
conducted within the CSTO<br />
framework successfully concluded<br />
in <strong>Armenia</strong>. I am sure that this<br />
military training will also conclude<br />
successfully.”<br />
During his welcoming speech<br />
to the participants of the military<br />
training, Defense Minister Ohanian<br />
noted in particular that it is<br />
not a coincidence that the soldiers<br />
of NATO’s Partnership for Peace<br />
<strong>and</strong> Istanbul Initiative Nations,<br />
17 member states <strong>and</strong> NATO’s different<br />
structures despite their diversity<br />
are preparing to jointly resolve<br />
all problems put before them<br />
during the training, as one team.<br />
“From this point of view I can only<br />
express regret that our neighbor<br />
EAPC (Euro-Atlantic Partnership<br />
Council) member states are not<br />
participating for different reasons.<br />
Unfortunately, this once again<br />
proves that security is fragile in the<br />
South Caucasus. I assure you that<br />
peace <strong>and</strong> stability are absolute<br />
values for the Republic of <strong>Armenia</strong>.<br />
We regard this military training as<br />
an important way of strengthening<br />
trust in the region,” announced the<br />
defense minister.<br />
Noting that <strong>Armenia</strong> willingly<br />
accepts any international military<br />
training whether it be within the<br />
frameworks of the Collective Security<br />
Treaty Organization <strong>and</strong> Partnership<br />
for Peace project, or the European<br />
comm<strong>and</strong> headquarters of<br />
the United States, <strong>and</strong> does its best<br />
to conduct them professionally, Mr.<br />
Ohanian said, “The hosting of the<br />
military trainings has one aim only,<br />
to raise our potential for practical<br />
cooperation in peacekeeping as far<br />
as possible, to develop their implementation<br />
methods, to gain experience<br />
<strong>and</strong> to pass it down to our<br />
subdivisions participating in the<br />
trainings. This aim is reconfirmed<br />
by the Republic of <strong>Armenia</strong>, as a<br />
full member of the international<br />
community, by it willingness to<br />
carry out its responsibilities, raise<br />
its international image <strong>and</strong> credibility,<br />
<strong>and</strong> to play its part in guaranteeing<br />
international security.” f<br />
elegant, flexible, noncontroversial<br />
formula to get things moving toward<br />
greater diversification of the<br />
country’s policy choices, while at<br />
the same time providing conservatives<br />
some room to engage <strong>and</strong><br />
own stakes in the debate.<br />
“While the concept of complementary<br />
foreign policy was welcomed in<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n circles, the international<br />
<strong>and</strong> regional community could not<br />
make sense of it <strong>and</strong> sometimes<br />
even criticized what they perceived<br />
as <strong>Armenia</strong>’s attempts to play various<br />
international powers against<br />
each other. To say that <strong>Armenia</strong>’s<br />
complementary foreign policy was<br />
successful is wrong; perhaps a better<br />
word would be it was tolerated<br />
by both sides,” said Mr. Kotchikian.<br />
Vicken Cheterian, who writes<br />
about the Caucasus in many European<br />
publications, reminds us<br />
that in the post–Cold War reality,<br />
after the collapse of the military<br />
blocs, <strong>and</strong> the development of a<br />
globalized economy, international<br />
relations functions on the basis of<br />
“complementarity.”<br />
“<strong>Armenia</strong> did not discover this<br />
approach. But early on <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
foreign policy was wisely balancing<br />
between different influences – Russia,<br />
U.S., Iran, Europe, among others<br />
– <strong>and</strong> as a result profiting from<br />
such an approach,” Mr. Cheterian<br />
told the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter.<br />
Continued on page 17 m
The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | October 4, 2008 17<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong><br />
Saralanj or Kirk Kerkorian highway opens<br />
by Armen Hakobyan<br />
YEREVAN – The Saralanj highway,<br />
which took three years to construct<br />
at a cost of about 6 billion drams<br />
(approximately $20 million), is finally<br />
a reality. The inauguration<br />
ceremony of this impressive structure<br />
took place on the morning of<br />
September 29, with the participation<br />
of <strong>Armenia</strong>’s present <strong>and</strong> former<br />
presidents, Serge Sargsian<br />
<strong>and</strong> Robert Kocharian.<br />
The construction of the highway<br />
was implemented through<br />
the funds donated by American-<strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
benefactor Kirk<br />
Kerkorian’s Lincy Foundation.<br />
The streets of Yerevan are heavily<br />
congested <strong>and</strong> the Saralanj<br />
highway is very important for the<br />
city, as it connects the Center <strong>and</strong><br />
Arabkir communities, extending<br />
to Vagharshian Street, which continues<br />
on to the Davtashen Bridge,<br />
without any traffic lights. The highway<br />
begins with a 186 meter-long<br />
tunnel on Miasnikian Avenue <strong>and</strong><br />
is six kilometers long. Along with<br />
the construction of the Saralanj<br />
highway, the Abovian-Miasnikian<br />
traffic junction has also been constructed,<br />
with 1.35 billion drams allocated<br />
from the state budget.<br />
During his speech at the opening<br />
ceremonies, Yerv<strong>and</strong> Zakharian,<br />
the mayor of Yerevan said, “Modern,<br />
quality road structures are<br />
being put into operation, where<br />
all requirements have been taken<br />
into consideration: the parallel link<br />
roads, local infrastructure, <strong>and</strong> the<br />
regulations for long-term structures.<br />
Today, projects which had<br />
been designed during Soviet years,<br />
most of which had been postponed<br />
for years <strong>and</strong> had been planned for<br />
a country with a strong state <strong>and</strong><br />
lively economy, are being implemented.”<br />
It is worth noting that former<br />
president Kocharian suggested<br />
that in order to show appreciation<br />
for Mr. Kerkorian’s contributions<br />
over the years, they should<br />
rename the Saralanj highway in his<br />
name. The current president underst<strong>and</strong>ably<br />
responded positively<br />
to this suggestion. Mr. Sargsian<br />
also noted that he highly values<br />
all the construction works carried<br />
out by the Lincy Foundation. “I<br />
am thankful to Kirk Kerkorian <strong>and</strong><br />
the Lincy Foundation for financing<br />
these works. I hope that Kirk Kerkorian<br />
<strong>and</strong> the Lincy Foundation<br />
will continue carrying out projects<br />
in <strong>Armenia</strong>. I attach great importance<br />
to projects involving the<br />
construction of roads <strong>and</strong> schools<br />
<strong>and</strong> the streets of Yerevan. It is not<br />
right to separate or compare any of<br />
them, as with the help of the school<br />
construction projects our children<br />
now study in educational establishments<br />
that did not previously exist<br />
in <strong>Armenia</strong>. Road construction<br />
projects are also very important;<br />
as life lines connecting the different<br />
communities of the republic<br />
were opened. In order to eliminate<br />
traffic jams in the capital city <strong>and</strong><br />
make streets better for the citizens,<br />
we had no choice but to undertake<br />
the project of reconstructing them,<br />
even though there were complaints<br />
during the construction works.<br />
Kirk Kerkorian’s work will be appreciated.”<br />
Robert Kocharian feels<br />
better without a tie<br />
The participation of the former<br />
president in the inauguration ceremony<br />
of the Saralanj highway was<br />
an opportunity to ask him personally<br />
about his return to the political<br />
arena, potentially as the prime<br />
minister. “This is the principal topic<br />
of rumors. I am still not bored with<br />
the freedom I finally have. I must<br />
also confess that during the past<br />
six months this is only the second<br />
time I am wearing a tie. The last<br />
time was on May 28, when I participated<br />
at the ceremony in Sardarabad.<br />
For the time being I have no<br />
desire to return to such a working<br />
regime. Once I decide to do so, you<br />
Civilitas Foundation opens in Yerevan<br />
At the opening, President Sargsian with former president Kocharian (pointing)<br />
<strong>and</strong> the mayor of Yerevan (left). Photo: Photolure.<br />
will hear it directly from me <strong>and</strong><br />
not as a result of rumors. These rumors<br />
hamper peoples’ work. It is<br />
also clear why these rumors are circulated,”<br />
said Mr. Kocharian.<br />
Regarding the sentiment that argues<br />
that in order to fix the domestic<br />
political situation in the country<br />
it is necessary to be rid of his heritage<br />
as president, Mr. Kocharian<br />
said, “It is impossible to get rid<br />
of my heritage, because you would<br />
first have to get rid of an established<br />
Republic of <strong>Armenia</strong>, a renovated<br />
Yerevan, a restored Gyumri,<br />
the Northern Avenue, the road on<br />
which we are currently st<strong>and</strong>ing,<br />
<strong>and</strong> the civil service system, which<br />
on the whole carries out its responsibilities<br />
professionally. How<br />
would we get rid of all this I do<br />
not know. If we wanted to get rid<br />
of it all, we would have to destroy<br />
everything.”<br />
f<br />
by Tatul Hakobyan<br />
YEREVAN – In one of the newly<br />
constructed buildings on Northern<br />
Avenue, the opening of the<br />
Civilitas Foundation took place on<br />
October 1. The founder of Civilitas<br />
is former Foreign Minister Vartan<br />
Oskanian <strong>and</strong> its director is Salpi<br />
H. Ghazarian. In a press conference<br />
on the day of the opening,<br />
Mr. Oskanian said that the Latin<br />
civilitas was not a name chosen<br />
arbitrarily. It has many meanings<br />
– citizen, civilization, civil society.<br />
“In this name we see the responsibility<br />
of citizens to society. This<br />
will be our foundation’s principal<br />
slogan,” Mr. Oskanian told reporters.<br />
Civilitas, which is funded by individuals<br />
<strong>and</strong> organizations, will<br />
work in two principal directions<br />
through its Council on Foreign<br />
Relations <strong>and</strong> the Democracy <strong>and</strong><br />
Development Initiative.<br />
The Council on Foreign Relations<br />
will advocate peace <strong>and</strong> stability in<br />
the Caucasus through multifaceted<br />
dialogue <strong>and</strong> open discourse. It<br />
Vartan Oskanian. Photo: Photolure.<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>’s choices,<br />
Russia or NATO or both<br />
n Continued from page 16<br />
He recalled that during the early<br />
90s, during the Karabakh war,<br />
when Azerbaijan under President<br />
Elchibey was pushing for “exclusivist”<br />
policies which are reflections of<br />
identity <strong>and</strong> not strategy, <strong>Armenia</strong><br />
profited by its military relations<br />
with Moscow (<strong>and</strong> receiving arms<br />
<strong>and</strong> ammunition), cooperation<br />
with Washington which permitted<br />
hundreds of millions in U.S. dollars<br />
in aid, <strong>and</strong> commercial ties with<br />
Iran which permitted the import of<br />
much needed diesel <strong>and</strong> sugar.<br />
“Today, more than in the early<br />
days of independence, <strong>Armenia</strong><br />
needs to fine-tune its diplomatic<br />
efforts to balance between powers<br />
that have interests <strong>and</strong> influence<br />
over the Caucasus, <strong>and</strong> especially<br />
in a time of change as it is now after<br />
the August war in Georgia,” concluded<br />
Mr. Cheterian.<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong> is deepening its cooperation<br />
with NATO in several directions,<br />
the most important of which<br />
is the Individual Partnership Action<br />
Plan (IPAP), which does not assume<br />
membership in NATO. The second<br />
direction is <strong>Armenia</strong>’s participation<br />
in peacekeeping missions. <strong>Armenia</strong><br />
has peacekeeping missions<br />
in Kosovo <strong>and</strong> Iraq <strong>and</strong> discussions<br />
are underway about the possibility<br />
of sending <strong>Armenia</strong>n doctors to Afghanistan.<br />
f<br />
will offer a forum through which<br />
to inform <strong>Armenia</strong>’s opinion <strong>and</strong><br />
policy making process as well as<br />
the international academic, political,<br />
<strong>and</strong> media communities about<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>’s foreign policy choices,<br />
options, <strong>and</strong> actions, in the context<br />
of <strong>Armenia</strong>’s national security challenges.<br />
Through public <strong>and</strong> private<br />
discussions as well as research <strong>and</strong><br />
publications, the council will promote<br />
the <strong>Armenia</strong>n perspective internationally<br />
<strong>and</strong> domestically.<br />
The Democracy <strong>and</strong> Development<br />
Initiative will work in four main directions:<br />
education, media, rural<br />
development <strong>and</strong> environmental<br />
awareness.<br />
Civilitas’ Scholarship Program<br />
will enable access to university education<br />
in <strong>Armenia</strong> <strong>and</strong> abroad for<br />
gifted <strong>and</strong> determined young people<br />
in order to increase the knowledge<br />
base, introduce national <strong>and</strong><br />
civic underst<strong>and</strong>ing, enhance<br />
strategic thinking <strong>and</strong> managerial<br />
skills, <strong>and</strong> nurture professionals<br />
for a knowledge-based economy.<br />
Selection will be need-based, <strong>and</strong><br />
will prefer those unlikely to find<br />
alternative sources of support,<br />
as well as those wishing to study<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
specific, strategically targeted subjects.<br />
The Civilitas Media Program will<br />
produce content for newspapers<br />
<strong>and</strong> television, in <strong>Armenia</strong>n <strong>and</strong><br />
English, for <strong>Armenia</strong> <strong>and</strong> the diaspora<br />
to begin to eliminate a social,<br />
political, economic <strong>and</strong> cultural information<br />
gap.<br />
The Civilitas Foundation will initiate,<br />
execute, <strong>and</strong> back projects<br />
that facilitate <strong>and</strong> support sustainable,<br />
comprehensive <strong>and</strong> even<br />
development in <strong>Armenia</strong>’s villages,<br />
enabling villagers to live a selfreliant,<br />
dignified life in <strong>Armenia</strong>’s<br />
border areas.<br />
The Civilitas Foundation will use<br />
its own high-profile to work with<br />
local <strong>and</strong> international organizations<br />
to initiate new projects <strong>and</strong><br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
back existing ones which educate<br />
the public <strong>and</strong> inform them on how<br />
to reduce impact on the environment<br />
<strong>and</strong> protect <strong>Armenia</strong>’s unique<br />
flora <strong>and</strong> fauna. The foundation<br />
will also focus on environmental<br />
programs as a means to foster regional<br />
cooperation.<br />
The honorary board of the Civilitas<br />
Foundation includes: Vartan Oskanian,<br />
former Georgian Parliament<br />
speaker Nino Gurjanadze, former<br />
prime minister of <strong>Armenia</strong> Armen<br />
Darbinyan, former Canadian foreign<br />
minister Lloyd N. Axworthy,<br />
Istanbul’s Bilgi University lecturer<br />
Murat Belge, Israel’s former Minister<br />
of Education Yossi Sarid, Ambassadors<br />
Stephen W. Bosworth,<br />
Peter R. Rosenblatt, <strong>and</strong> Jivan<br />
Tabibian, <strong>and</strong> others. f
18 The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | October 4, 2008<br />
Editorial<br />
Elect Barack Obama <strong>and</strong> Joe Biden<br />
the armenian<br />
reporter<br />
Seldom do we face such a straightforward choice. As we compare the records of the c<strong>and</strong>idates<br />
for president <strong>and</strong> vice president of the United States, we find that, as U.S. citizens <strong>and</strong> as <strong>Armenia</strong>n-Americans,<br />
we have every reason to throw our strong support behind Senator Barack<br />
Obama <strong>and</strong> Senator Joe Biden.<br />
The <strong>Armenia</strong>n-American agenda<br />
On <strong>Armenia</strong>n issues, the contrast between the records <strong>and</strong> commitments of the two pairs of<br />
major-party c<strong>and</strong>idates could not be more stark:<br />
Senator Barack Obama has repeatedly made a clear <strong>and</strong> unequivocal commitment to recognize<br />
the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide <strong>and</strong> work toward an equitable resolution of the Karabakh<br />
conflict.<br />
“As President I will recognize the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide,” he pledged in a January 19 statement<br />
“On the Importance of U.S.-<strong>Armenia</strong> Relations.” On April 24, he reiterated his strong support<br />
for the affirmation of the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide. “It is imperative that we recognize the horrific<br />
acts carried out against the <strong>Armenia</strong>n people as genocide,” he said in a statement submitted<br />
into the Congressional Record.<br />
In his January 19 statement, Senator Obama also pledged to support <strong>Armenia</strong>’s development<br />
<strong>and</strong> supported a settlement of the Karabakh conflict “based upon America’s founding<br />
commitment to the principles of democracy <strong>and</strong> self-determination.”<br />
Senator Obama’s commitment is consistent with his actions in the Senate. As a member of<br />
the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, he asked the ambassador-designate of the United<br />
States to <strong>Armenia</strong> what actions she would take to remember the victims of the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
Genocide <strong>and</strong> how she would work with her counterpart in Ankara to decriminalize discussion<br />
of the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide in Turkey.<br />
Senator Joe Biden has a record of more than 35 years of consistent support of <strong>Armenia</strong>n-<br />
American issues. He has supported <strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide resolutions introduced in the Senate<br />
since 1990.<br />
On July 29, during a meeting of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, which he chairs,<br />
Senator Biden noted, “Recognition by the United States of the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide is not the<br />
final goal. The real goal is the recognition of Turkey – of the Turkish Government – of the<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide <strong>and</strong> the establishment of a common Turkish-<strong>Armenia</strong>n underst<strong>and</strong>ing<br />
of the events <strong>and</strong> tragedy that took place.”<br />
This level of demonstrated commitment to <strong>Armenia</strong>n-American issues is a rarity on the<br />
presidential ticket.<br />
What makes Senator Obama’s commitments in matters of interest to <strong>Armenia</strong>n-Americans<br />
particularly credible is the c<strong>and</strong>or <strong>and</strong> confidence with which he has made those<br />
commitments, further bolstered by Senator Biden’s consistent <strong>and</strong> long record as an<br />
ally of our community. The more we as <strong>Armenia</strong>n-Americans get involved in the Obama-<br />
Biden campaign, support the campaign, develop relationships with campaign staff, <strong>and</strong><br />
help Senators Obama <strong>and</strong> Biden get elected, the stronger our position to follow up <strong>and</strong><br />
work with the administration to make sure these commitments are fulfilled in the best<br />
possible way.<br />
By contrast, just last October, Senator John McCain publicly opposed the Congressional<br />
resolution acknowledging the U.S. record on the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide. In 1999 he voted to lift<br />
restrictions on U.S. aid to Azerbaijan over its blockade of <strong>Armenia</strong> <strong>and</strong> Nagorno-Karabakh. In<br />
1990 he opposed the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide resolution introduced by fellow Republican Senator<br />
Bob Dole.<br />
In 26 years in Congress, Senator McCain has either opposed or been indifferent to initiatives<br />
supported by the <strong>Armenia</strong>n-American community. He did introduce legislation in 1989<br />
supporting a peaceful <strong>and</strong> fair settlement of the Karabakh conflict, <strong>and</strong> he initially supported<br />
restrictions on U.S. assistance to Azerbaijan introduced in 1992; but he reversed that position<br />
in 1999. He issued a letter to <strong>Armenia</strong>n-Americans this week. But the letter gave no indication<br />
that as president he would take a different approach to <strong>Armenia</strong>n-American issues.<br />
And his running mate has no record on <strong>Armenia</strong>n-American issues.<br />
A stronger America<br />
With the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991, the United States attained such military <strong>and</strong><br />
economic superiority – <strong>and</strong> with it, influence over other countries – that many people believed<br />
American power, if managed wisely, could remain unsurpassed for generations.<br />
Strong as America was, however, it could never expect to sustain its leadership role through<br />
brute force. The countries <strong>and</strong> peoples of the world expected to see in America a force for the<br />
common good, one that would inspire friendship <strong>and</strong> loyalty. Everyone understood that the<br />
United States had to pursue its own interests, but it was expected to define those interests in<br />
a way that was inclusive, <strong>and</strong> could serve as an example <strong>and</strong> inspiration to others.<br />
Thus, for example, President George W. Bush was able to invoke the leadership role of the<br />
United States by speaking out in favor of democracy around the world. He championed the<br />
creation of the Millennium Challenge Corporation, which was established at his initiative <strong>and</strong><br />
from which <strong>Armenia</strong> is benefiting.<br />
But a succession of actions <strong>and</strong> inactions over the last several years has served to discredit<br />
American leadership <strong>and</strong> weaken the United States with direct <strong>and</strong> indirect consequences<br />
for <strong>Armenia</strong> <strong>and</strong> the U.S.-<strong>Armenia</strong> relationship. Among these missteps is America’s timid<br />
response to genocide, first in Rw<strong>and</strong>a <strong>and</strong> now in Darfur – <strong>and</strong> the support of the campaign<br />
against recognition of the U.S. record on the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide. Other missteps include<br />
the invasion <strong>and</strong> continued occupation of Iraq, a sovereign state, on a trumped-up pretext;<br />
unabashed support for waterboarding, sexual humiliation, <strong>and</strong> other forms of torture directly<br />
<strong>and</strong> through “extraordinary rendition” – the h<strong>and</strong>ing over of suspects to foreign states that<br />
have no compunctions about torture; <strong>and</strong> a refusal to cooperate with the rest of the world<br />
in key matters, witness the refusal to join the Kyoto agreement on global warming <strong>and</strong> the<br />
refusal to accept the jurisdiction of the <strong>International</strong> Criminal Court.<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter (ISSN 0004-2358), an independent newspaper,<br />
is published weekly by <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter llc.<br />
Gerard L. Cafesjian, President <strong>and</strong> ceo<br />
Publisher Sylva A. Boghossian<br />
Office manager Lisa Kopooshian<br />
Copyright © 2008 by <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
Reporter llc. All Rights Reserved<br />
Periodicals postage paid at Paramus, N.J., <strong>and</strong><br />
additional mailing offices.<br />
POSTMASTER: Send address changes to PO Box<br />
129, Paramus, NJ 07652-0129.<br />
The views expressed, except in the editorial, are<br />
not necessarily those of the publishers.<br />
Editor Vincent Lima<br />
Western U.S. Bureau Chief <strong>and</strong><br />
Arts & Culture editor Paul Chaderjian<br />
Washington editor Emil Sanamyan<br />
Associate editor Maria Titizian<br />
Assistant to the Editor Seda Stepanyan<br />
Copy editor Ishkhan Jinbashian<br />
Art director Grigor Hakobyan<br />
Layout assistant Nareh Balian<br />
Meanwhile, U.S. relations with countries in <strong>and</strong> around the Caucasus, especially with<br />
powerful states like Russia <strong>and</strong> Iran, have deteriorated, increasing regional instability. In any<br />
regional conflict, <strong>Armenia</strong> suffers.<br />
Time for change<br />
Senator McCain has supported many of these failed policies, <strong>and</strong> has expressed his intention<br />
to pursue a similar foreign policy. To his credit, he disagreed with the Bush administration on<br />
the matter of torture, but he does not give us cause to believe that a McCain administration<br />
would introduce significant changes in U.S. foreign (or economic) policy.<br />
We do not expect Senator Obama to radically transform U.S. foreign policy. Like Senator<br />
McCain, he has made it clear that in the Middle East, the United States would continue to be<br />
a strong supporter of Israel. He has joined President Bush <strong>and</strong> Senator McCain in their condemnation<br />
of Russia for its intervention in Georgia.<br />
On the other h<strong>and</strong>, however, as a c<strong>and</strong>idate for the U.S. Senate, Mr. Obama opposed the invasion<br />
of Iraq from the very start. No pacifist, he supported military action in Afghanistan in<br />
the wake of the terrorist attack on September 11, 2001, <strong>and</strong> continues to support U.S. military<br />
action there. But his early good judgment on Iraq speaks volumes. Further, he is outspoken<br />
on the need for decisive intervention to prevent genocide.<br />
Senator Obama is an advocate of alliance-building, cooperation with other nations, <strong>and</strong><br />
good-faith efforts at resolving conflicts through diplomacy <strong>and</strong> direct negotiations. An Obama<br />
administration should help rebuild U.S. credibility <strong>and</strong> influence in world affairs.<br />
Real <strong>and</strong> present danger<br />
Coming back to the neighborhood that concerns us the most, we have a real fear that a President<br />
McCain would be more inclined to assault <strong>Armenia</strong>’s southern neighbor, Iran. He had no<br />
compunctions about publicly <strong>and</strong> callously singing a song about bombing Iran [http://www.<br />
youtube.com/watchv=o-zoPgv_nYg]; moreover, it is consistent with the foreign policy approach<br />
he advocates. Such a course of action could bring about numerous potential disasters,<br />
including catastrophic consequences for <strong>Armenia</strong>.<br />
Unable to move beyond the mentality of the Cold War, Senator McCain is promising to rush<br />
along Georgia’s membership in NATO – <strong>and</strong> thereby potentially engage the United States in a<br />
new <strong>and</strong> hot confrontation with Russia – a big risk with no clear benefit. Any regional military<br />
action could easily spill over into <strong>Armenia</strong>, with potentially dire consequences. It is a result<br />
we should fight to avoid. While Senator Obama is committed to approaching Russia from a<br />
position of strength, he is also committed to diplomacy.<br />
On November 4, we, the people of the United States, will elect a new president. We have<br />
noted the stark contrast between the record <strong>and</strong> the commitments of the Obama-Biden ticket<br />
on the one h<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> the McCain-Palin ticket on the other.<br />
For us, for <strong>Armenia</strong>n-Americans, the choice is clear. Let us come together <strong>and</strong> work hard,<br />
very hard, to elect Barack Obama <strong>and</strong> Joe Biden as president <strong>and</strong> vice president of the United<br />
States.<br />
f<br />
connect:<br />
http://www.obamaforamerica.com<br />
http://www.armeniansforobama.us<br />
The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter is your newspaper. We urge you to send us your news <strong>and</strong> your<br />
views.<br />
<strong>News</strong>. Please send your news to .<br />
Letters. Please send your letters to Letters should be no more<br />
than 250 words long <strong>and</strong> may be edited for clarity. Please include your mailing address<br />
<strong>and</strong> daytime telephone number.<br />
Commentary. Please send your essays to Essays <strong>and</strong> articles<br />
normally should be no longer than 900 words.<br />
Photos <strong>and</strong> artwork. We require high-resolution originals. All photos <strong>and</strong> artwork<br />
must include a credit to the photographer <strong>and</strong> a signed statement granting us permission<br />
to publish.<br />
Advertising <strong>and</strong> subscriptions. Please direct questions to or<br />
call us.<br />
Our offices<br />
PO Box 129<br />
Paramus NJ 07652<br />
1-201-226-1995 phone<br />
1-201-226-1660 fax<br />
2727 West Alameda Blvd<br />
Burbank CA 91505<br />
1-818-955-9933 phone<br />
1-818-955-8799 fax<br />
Senate Foreign Relations<br />
Committee Chair Sen. Joseph<br />
Biden (D.-Del.), left, talks with<br />
committee member Sen. Barack<br />
Obama (D.-Ill.), on Capitol<br />
Hill in Washington on April<br />
8. AP Photo: Pablo Martinez<br />
Monsivais.<br />
1 Yeghvard Hwy Fl 5<br />
Yerevan 0054 <strong>Armenia</strong><br />
374-10-367-195 phone<br />
374-10-367-194 fax
The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | October 4, 2008 19<br />
Commentary<br />
Gül’s visit to <strong>Armenia</strong> “more advantageous to Turkey”<br />
Vartan Oskanian believes<br />
the Genocide is “not<br />
negotiable”<br />
by Tatul Hakobyan<br />
YEREVAN – On October 1, Vartan Oskanian,<br />
who was <strong>Armenia</strong>’s foreign minister<br />
from 1998 to 2008, gave a press conference<br />
for the first time since leaving office. During<br />
the briefing Mr. Oskanian said that Turkish<br />
president Abdullah Gül’s visit to Yerevan<br />
“elevated Turkey’s prestige ten times more<br />
than <strong>Armenia</strong>’s, even though <strong>Armenia</strong>’s prestige<br />
also benefited.” The veteran diplomat,<br />
who during his ten-year tenure on many<br />
occasions negotiated with his Turkish counterparts,<br />
including Mr. Gül, said that it is<br />
perhaps too soon to evaluate the steps being<br />
taken with Turkey.<br />
“For me there is one criterion of success,<br />
<strong>and</strong> that is the opening of the border or at a<br />
minimum, as a start, the start of the railroad.<br />
If one of these two things do not materialize<br />
in the coming months, I would say that<br />
Turkey was able to manipulate in the best<br />
possible way the possibilities given to it. And<br />
if in the coming months the border is opened,<br />
or the railroad begins operating, it will be<br />
possible to say that <strong>Armenia</strong>’s president’s invitation<br />
to Gül was the right decision,” said<br />
Mr. Oskanian.<br />
According to the former foreign minister,<br />
Turkey has already gotten what it wanted<br />
from <strong>Armenia</strong>: a statement that <strong>Armenia</strong><br />
has no territorial claims from Turkey; that<br />
after the opening of the border, <strong>Armenia</strong> is<br />
ready to discuss any issue with Turkey. However<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong> has not yet received that which<br />
is fundamental for <strong>Armenia</strong> <strong>and</strong> that is the<br />
opening of the border.<br />
With regard to Turkey’s possible role in<br />
the resolution of the Karabakh conflict, Mr.<br />
Oskanian insisted that Turkey has no place<br />
at the negotiating table because the border<br />
has not yet been opened; the railroad has<br />
not begun operating; <strong>and</strong> in the Karabakh<br />
issue, Turkey protects Azerbaijan’s interests.<br />
In Mr. Oskanian’s opinion, <strong>Armenia</strong>n diplomacy<br />
must do everything possible so that it<br />
not only blocks Turkey’s participation in the<br />
resolution process, but also does not allow<br />
for Turkey to leave that impression on the<br />
international community.<br />
“It is unacceptable to announce that if the<br />
border is opened, <strong>and</strong> diplomatic relations<br />
established, it is then possible to create<br />
commissions <strong>and</strong> discuss any issue,” Mr. Oskanian<br />
said in response to a question posed<br />
by the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter. It has to be made<br />
clear, he added, what exactly they mean when<br />
they say “any issue” <strong>and</strong> the Turks must realize<br />
that the <strong>Armenia</strong>n side will never agree<br />
to put the facts of 1915 into question. Mr.<br />
Oskanian emphasized that “we have nothing<br />
to concede to them; this is not only an issue<br />
for <strong>Armenia</strong>’s authorities; this is not only an<br />
issue for <strong>Armenia</strong>ns in <strong>Armenia</strong>. It is an issue<br />
for all <strong>Armenia</strong>ns.”<br />
In 2005 Prime Minister Receb Tayyip<br />
Erdogan sent a letter to President Robert<br />
Kocharian recommending the creation of<br />
a joint historian’s commission to study the<br />
events of 1915. However <strong>Armenia</strong>’s thenpresident<br />
<strong>and</strong> Mr. Oskanian declined, stressing<br />
that historians had long ago done their<br />
job <strong>and</strong> there was no question that at the<br />
beginning of the 20th century, genocide was<br />
perpetrated against the <strong>Armenia</strong>ns. That refusal<br />
was justified with the fact that if you<br />
agree to the creation of a commission, then<br />
you are unwittingly putting the reality of the<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide into question; <strong>and</strong> as<br />
long as that commission exists, other countries<br />
will avoid recognizing or condemning<br />
Turkey, citing the ongoing nature of the work<br />
of that very commission. Indeed, countries<br />
that have already recognized the Genocide<br />
will be confused <strong>and</strong> have a hard time underst<strong>and</strong>ing<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>’s position.<br />
A slip of the tongue<br />
On June 23 of this year, during a meeting<br />
with the <strong>Armenia</strong>n community in Moscow,<br />
President Sargsian announced: “The Turkish<br />
side is recommending the formation of<br />
a commission, which will study historical<br />
facts.<br />
“We are not opposed to establishing such a<br />
commission but only when the border between<br />
our countries is opened. Otherwise, it<br />
could be a means to protract the question for<br />
years <strong>and</strong> exploit it.”<br />
In Mr. Oskanian’s opinion, President Sargsian’s<br />
announcement in Moscow was “a slip<br />
of the tongue,” <strong>and</strong> he wants to believe that<br />
is what it is. “No one has the moral right to<br />
shed doubt on the fact of the 1915 Genocide,”<br />
Mr. Oskanian said. “Turkey’s desire is<br />
to start the process, <strong>and</strong> not the actual result<br />
itself. That will be an eternal process. Everything<br />
must be done to halt the process from<br />
beginning.”<br />
It is difficult to agree that Mr. Sargsian’s<br />
statement in Moscow was a slip of the tongue.<br />
First of all, the president was not responding<br />
to an unexpected question; he was reading<br />
from a prepared, written speech. Aside<br />
from that, when meeting with the <strong>Armenia</strong>n-<br />
American community in New York on September<br />
24, Mr. Sargsian said: “Days following<br />
the meeting in Yerevan, Turkey’s foreign<br />
minister announced that Turkey is ready to<br />
come to terms with its past, to face the conclusions<br />
of the presumed commission’s findings.<br />
These are the words of a courageous<br />
representative of the authorities. We have<br />
to think, how we can help Turkish society<br />
be more unbiased toward the pages of their<br />
own history.”<br />
It would be great if <strong>Armenia</strong> was so strong<br />
as to help Turkey <strong>and</strong> its citizens to look<br />
through the bloody pages of their history.<br />
However desire is not a political or diplomatic<br />
category. And the fact is that Europe, with<br />
a population of 500 million, has not been<br />
successful in forcing Turkey, a country that<br />
wants to be part of the European Union, to<br />
finally remove Article 301 from its criminal<br />
code, which allows authorities to systematically<br />
persecute all those who speak about the<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide.<br />
President Abdulah Gul of Turkey with President Serge Sargsian of <strong>Armenia</strong> in Yerevan on September 6.<br />
Photo: Photolure.<br />
It’s not a bazaar.<br />
The director of the ARF Bureau’s Central Hai<br />
Tahd Office Giro Manoyan told the <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
Reporter that while Mr. Sargsian did not<br />
directly express his agreement to the formation<br />
of a historians’ commission, “the fact<br />
remains that if <strong>Armenia</strong> agrees to the formation<br />
of any commission of historians which<br />
is to examine whether the ‘events’ do or do<br />
not constitute genocide, it will be perceived<br />
to shed doubt on the fact of the Genocide, no<br />
matter how much the <strong>Armenia</strong>n side insists<br />
that it doesn’t consider the fact of Genocide<br />
questionable.<br />
“Turkey’s 2005 proposal for a bilateral commission<br />
of historians had one goal, namely<br />
to block the efforts for the international<br />
recognition of the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide. Highranking<br />
Turkish officials continue to state<br />
that their aim for a historian’s commission<br />
is to block the international recognition of<br />
the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide. <strong>Armenia</strong> has no reason<br />
to agree to such a commission neither<br />
before, nor after the lifting of the blockade<br />
by Turkey or the establishment of diplomatic<br />
relations with <strong>Armenia</strong>.<br />
“If Turkey sincerely wants to study its own<br />
history of the Genocide period, it should first<br />
of all lift all limitations on the free study of<br />
the period; secondly, it should invite . . . genocide<br />
experts <strong>and</strong> historians to help them in<br />
their soul-searching, because Turkey is alone<br />
against the whole world in denying the Genocide.<br />
Historic facts can not be established like<br />
prices are agreed upon in a bazaar. Today, for<br />
Turkey, establishing normal relations with<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong> is at least as necessary for Turkey<br />
as it is for <strong>Armenia</strong>; so official Yerevan needs<br />
only to st<strong>and</strong> firm on its ‘relations without<br />
any preconditions’ position, thus uniting the<br />
whole <strong>Armenia</strong>n potential behind it <strong>and</strong> not<br />
giving in to Turkish ultimatums.<br />
“This is also true to all the preconditions<br />
Turkey sets forth, including those related to<br />
Artsakh <strong>and</strong> <strong>Armenia</strong>n rights from Turkey.<br />
Turkey’s aim is to capitulate <strong>Armenia</strong> <strong>and</strong> the<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n nation; official Yerevan should not<br />
take any step in the wrong direction, which<br />
would have irreversible negative effects.”<br />
It would appear that among <strong>Armenia</strong>’s<br />
ruling parties, it is only the ARF that is displeased<br />
with Turkey’s policies. In reality<br />
however, there are many that are displeased.<br />
Stepan Safarian, the secretary of the<br />
Heritage Party, the only opposition party in<br />
parliament, believes that resolving <strong>Armenia</strong>n-Turkish<br />
relations <strong>and</strong> opening the border<br />
must not contribute to the falsification of<br />
truth <strong>and</strong> history, the distortion of historical<br />
facts, <strong>and</strong> disregarding issues because these<br />
do not have any connection to our national<br />
<strong>and</strong> state interests.<br />
“After Gül’s visit to <strong>Armenia</strong>, the amount<br />
of news flowing from the Turkish media <strong>and</strong><br />
the subsequent posturing by official Ankara<br />
bears witness to the fact that they weren’t<br />
honest <strong>and</strong> aren’t honest about their motivation.<br />
They are even trying to discredit <strong>Armenia</strong>n<br />
authorities <strong>and</strong> the <strong>Armenia</strong>n president<br />
in <strong>Armenia</strong>n public opinion by stating that<br />
he was naïve to invite Gül with a weak agenda<br />
(that is to accept Turkey’s conditions to<br />
open the border). They made it clear that the<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n side didn’t properly evaluate <strong>and</strong><br />
assess all possible scenarios during the meeting<br />
<strong>and</strong> didn’t reach any tangible results,” Mr.<br />
Safarian said.<br />
To substantiate his statement, the member<br />
of parliament <strong>and</strong> political analyst notes<br />
that official Yerevan was more muted while<br />
Ankara was utilizing every available forum to<br />
proclaim its position on <strong>Armenia</strong>n-Turkish<br />
relations, which include its well-known anti-<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n, unproductive preconditions, the<br />
opening of the border <strong>and</strong> the resolution of<br />
the Karabakh conflict. “I believe that this has<br />
to be a bitter lesson for <strong>Armenia</strong>n authorities<br />
to approach similar issues with more seriousness,”<br />
he said.<br />
Impartial mediators<br />
During his speech at the UN General Assembly<br />
on September 23, Mr. Gül unequivocally<br />
characterized Mountainous Karabakh as an<br />
occupied territory. If Turkey, while being one<br />
of the 11 members of the OSCE Minsk Group<br />
<strong>and</strong> today expressing the desire to mediate<br />
in the resolution of the conflict, continues<br />
to characterize Karabakh as occupied, then<br />
what mediation are we talking about If Mr.<br />
Gül had used the wording, “Karabakh’s adjacent<br />
occupied territories” that would have<br />
been more underst<strong>and</strong>able because that is<br />
how the international community coins it.<br />
In the meantime, Mr. Gül <strong>and</strong> Turkey, which<br />
continue to consider Karabakh as occupied<br />
territories cannot act as mediators.<br />
Words versus actions<br />
Time will tell how Turkey will react to <strong>Armenia</strong>’s<br />
good intentions. But those of us who<br />
have been following <strong>Armenia</strong>n-Turkish relations<br />
for the past 15 years can attest to the<br />
fact that Ankara never moves from words<br />
to action, when it comes to its policies regarding<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>. <strong>Armenia</strong>’s first president.<br />
Levon Ter-Petrossian, never placed the<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide issue on <strong>Armenia</strong>’s foreign<br />
policy agenda; Turkey didn’t establish<br />
diplomatic relations even then. Turkey didn’t<br />
want to establish diplomatic relations at a<br />
time when the issue of Kelbajar didn’t exist<br />
<strong>and</strong> when <strong>Armenia</strong>n forces were in battle on<br />
a war forced upon them by Azerbaijan. At<br />
that time there wasn’t a security buffer zone<br />
around Karabakh; still, Turkey was absurdly<br />
talking about preconditions.<br />
Serge Sargsian finally spoke<br />
about the Genocide<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>’s third president finally spoke about<br />
the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide.<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>’s third president, like the first<br />
president, is trying to separate history from<br />
politics <strong>and</strong> diplomacy. And even though<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>’s current foreign minister Edward<br />
Nalb<strong>and</strong>ian, told this reporter months ago<br />
that the <strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide was not off the<br />
foreign-policy agenda of <strong>Armenia</strong>, there had<br />
been no evidence of active pursuit of recognition.<br />
Reviewing all of President Sargsian’s<br />
speeches <strong>and</strong> interviews that can be found on<br />
the presidential website, the word genocide is<br />
conspicuously absent. These include his July<br />
9 commentary in the Wall Street Journal, <strong>and</strong><br />
interviews with the Austrian St<strong>and</strong>ard <strong>and</strong><br />
the Turkish Radikal daily. President Sargsian<br />
talks about <strong>Armenia</strong>n-Turkish relations <strong>and</strong><br />
does not in any way mention the Genocide.<br />
Likewise, in setting out his foreign-policy<br />
priorities in a meeting with <strong>Armenia</strong>’s diplomatic<br />
corps on September 3, the president<br />
made no mention of the Genocide.<br />
But that changed on September 28. Speaking<br />
to the United Nations General Assembly,<br />
Mr. Sargsian said. “This year we will be<br />
celebrating two significant international<br />
law achievements: the 60th anniversary of<br />
the Universal Declaration of Human Rights<br />
<strong>and</strong> 60th Anniversary of the Convention on<br />
Genocide Prevention. For us, the <strong>Armenia</strong>ns,<br />
as a people who survived the Genocide, these<br />
anniversaries are more than just important.<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong> has been <strong>and</strong> will be doing every<br />
possible thing at the UN to provide for a continuous<br />
advocacy of the Genocide Convention<br />
<strong>and</strong> its enforcement. Genocide can not<br />
be worrying just one nation, Genocide is a<br />
crime against humanity.”<br />
President Kocharian had placed the Genocide<br />
on <strong>Armenia</strong>’s foreign policy agenda in<br />
1998 during his speech at the UN’s General<br />
Assembly. Mr. Sargsian also mentioned the<br />
<strong>Armenia</strong>n Genocide at the opening of the<br />
General Assembly.<br />
f
20 The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | October 4, 2008
The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | October 4, 2008
The <strong>Armenia</strong>n Reporter | October 4, 2008<br />
Fifth Annual<br />
Save a<br />
Generation<br />
<br />
Honoring individuals whose commitment<br />
<strong>and</strong> generosity help improve the lives of<br />
children <strong>and</strong> youth in <strong>Armenia</strong><br />
Friday, October 24, 2008<br />
Cipriani 42nd Street<br />
110 East 42nd Street, New York City<br />
Featuring<br />
Pulitzer Prize winning journalist for the New York Times, Nicholas Kristof<br />
<strong>and</strong> Emmy <strong>and</strong> Tony Award winning actress, Andrea Martin<br />
Private performance by Cirque du Soleil<br />
<br />
To purchase ticket(s) online please visit www.coafkids.org<br />
For more information, call 212-994-8201