Untitled - WildAid
Untitled - WildAid
Untitled - WildAid
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
Cover photo: Jeff Rotman<br />
GLOBAL MPA CONFERENCE<br />
SAN FRANCISCO<br />
NOVEMBER 25–29<br />
welcome!<br />
It is my pleasure to welcome you to <strong>WildAid</strong>’s first ever global<br />
marine protected area enforcement conference in the city by<br />
the bay. We hope you are able to take advantage of the wealth of<br />
information and expertise presented in this conference and apply<br />
lessons learned in your respective field.<br />
We have gone to great lengths in order to ensure representation<br />
of a diverse sample of MPAs with differing complexities, resource<br />
levels, sizes, and management models among other characteristics<br />
from over 30 countries spanning six continents. We<br />
have targeted individuals from varying disciplines to enrich this<br />
experience. With us this week are fishery enforcement officials,<br />
Navies, scientists, lawyers, academics, technology firms, NGOs<br />
and foundation officers.<br />
Overall we aim to discuss the key components of the law enforcement<br />
chain and explore innovative strategies to overcome<br />
common obstacles to MPA enforcement. We encourage you to<br />
sit in on different tracks throughout the week and familiarize<br />
yourself with new disciplines and/or new regions of the world.<br />
We are confident that many models and mechanisms can be<br />
cross-pollinated with minor adjustments. Last, but not least,<br />
we encourage you to explore some of the unique sites and great<br />
cuisines that San Francisco has to offer.<br />
Sincerely,<br />
Marcel Bigue<br />
Marine Program Director<br />
<strong>WildAid</strong><br />
1
Special thanks to our supporters:<br />
Sponsors<br />
Partners & Presenters<br />
Special Thanks<br />
The Keith Campbell Foundation for the Environment<br />
Virgin Unite Foundation<br />
Marisla Foundation<br />
James H. Clark Charitable Foundation<br />
2
GLOBAL MPA CONFERENCE<br />
SAN FRANCISCO<br />
NOVEMBER 25–29<br />
Our Agenda:<br />
Sunday Nov 25: Registration and Reception<br />
3:00 pm—6:00 pm : Hotel Lobby<br />
REGISTRATION<br />
Check in at the Hotel Kabuki. Guests can collect welcome kit, check-in with hotel, and get settled.<br />
6:00 pm—8:00 pm : O Izakaya Lounge<br />
WELCOME COCKTAIL RECEPTION<br />
Mingle with other attendees over cocktails and catered hors d’ourves.<br />
Monday Nov 26: Welcome & MPA Enforcement<br />
9:00 am—9:20 am : Sakura Room<br />
Welcome & Conference Overview<br />
Speaker: Peter Knights, Executive Director – <strong>WildAid</strong><br />
KEYNOTE: YOUR MPA-WILL IT SUCCEED<br />
Graeme Kelleher is a civil engineer by trade and was the first Chairman and CEO of The Great Barrier<br />
Reef Marine Park Authority, as well as the first Marine Vice Chairman of IUCN's World Commission on<br />
Protected Areas. As a professor, an author, an Australian Officer of the Order, and project manager for<br />
various MPAs in many countries, Graeme is a pioneer in the field and still serves as an advisor to many of<br />
these organizations.<br />
Speaker: Graeme Kelleher<br />
9:20 am—10:00 am : Sakura Room<br />
BUILDING AN EFFECTIVE MPA LAW ENFORCEMENT PROGRAM<br />
Introduction by Marcel Bigue, Marine Program Director-<strong>WildAid</strong><br />
Panel disussion on MPA management and the most common obstacles.<br />
Panelists<br />
Cap. Bob Farrell, CA Dept. Fish & Game<br />
Rich Arnold, Senior Vice President, Harkcon<br />
Joseph Johns, Chief, Environmental Crimes Section, US. DOJ<br />
Brian Day, Social Marking Director-Global Programs, Rare<br />
Rick McPherson, Conservation Programs Director, CORAL<br />
10:00 am—10:20 am : LOBBY<br />
Break<br />
Expertise<br />
Surveillance & Interdiction<br />
Systematic Training<br />
Prosecution & Sanction<br />
Education and Outreach<br />
Sustainable Finance<br />
MPA Governance, Role of Science, and Fisheries Enforcement<br />
10:20 am—10:50 am : Sakura Room<br />
Governing MPAs: Promoting Effectivness and RESILIENCE<br />
An analysis of 20 case studies from around the world, focusing on state, people and market based<br />
approaches in MPA governance.<br />
Speaker: Dr. Peter JS Jones, Senior Lecturer-Department of Geography, UCL<br />
10:50 am—11:20 am : Sakura Room<br />
The Vital Link between Enforcement, Management & Science<br />
Exploring the relationship between effective enforcement/compliance, MPA governance, and the underlying<br />
science.<br />
Speaker: Rodney Anderson, Senior Associate-North Sea Marine Cluster & former Director of Marine<br />
and Fisheries, UK<br />
3
11:20 am—11:50 am : Sakura Room<br />
Saving the World - One Fish at a Time<br />
Examples and lessons from United States Coast Guard's efforts to combat illegal fishing through<br />
international cooperation.<br />
Speaker: CDR Daniel Schaeffer, Chief of Living Marine Resources Enforcement-USCG<br />
11:50 am—12:20 pm : Sakura Room<br />
Panel Discussion and Q&A<br />
Panelists<br />
Dr. Jones Rodney Anderson CDR Schaeffer<br />
12:20 pm—1:20 pm : Spring Room<br />
Lunch<br />
An Exploration of MPA Enforcement: Perspectives by Model<br />
1:20 pm—2:00 pm : Sakura Room<br />
Balancing Security, Narcotraffic, and Marine Protection in Latin America<br />
Panel discussion on the complex role of Navies in marine enforcement and national security<br />
Panelists<br />
COL Martin Arias, Costarican Coast Guard National Service<br />
CAP Hugo Ricaurte, Vice Director of the Ecuadorian Directorate of Aquatic Spaces<br />
Rear ADM Juan Carlos del Alamo,Executive Director of the Peruvian Coast Guard<br />
Ms. Betsabe Hurtado-Scientific Advisor, Chilean Navy Directorate of Maritime Authority<br />
Facilitators: Marcel Bigue, Oswaldo Rosero, Rich Arnold<br />
2:00 pm—2:30 pm : Sakura Room<br />
A Holistic Approach to Managing Compliance in a Large MPA<br />
How the Great Barrier Reef Marine Park (GBRMP) developed their enforcement and compliance<br />
management model.<br />
Speaker: Reg Parsons, Compliance Manager -Great Barrier Reef Marine Park Authority<br />
2:30 pm—3:00pm : Sakura Room<br />
4<br />
Enforcing Remote Marine Protected Areas<br />
The unique challenges of protecting U.S. Marine National Monuments in the Pacific.<br />
Speaker: Mark Richardson, Specal Assistant to the Executive Director-Marine Mammal Commission<br />
3:00 pm—3:20 pm : Spring Room<br />
Break<br />
3:20 pm—3:50 pm : Sakura Room<br />
Enterprise Development: An Unlikely Partner for Resource Conservation<br />
How the development of South Africa’s small scale fisheries sector has helped preserve resources.<br />
Speaker: Chiboni Evans, Executive Director-Strataconsult South Africa<br />
3:50 pm—4:20 pm : Sakura Room<br />
Fishers as Enforcers – A Community Based Approach to Management<br />
How Mexico’s fishing cooperatives became the first MSC certified fisheries program in the developing world.<br />
Speaker: Martin Castillo, President of the Vigilance Council-FEDECOOP<br />
4:20 pm—5:00 pm : Sakura Room<br />
Panel Discussion and Q&A<br />
Panelists<br />
Reg Parsons Sandra Brooke, MCI Chiboni Evans Mario Ramade<br />
Facilitator: Rich Arnold<br />
(continued)<br />
4
GLOBAL MPA CONFERENCE<br />
SAN FRANCISCO<br />
NOVEMBER 25–29<br />
5:30 pm—6:30PM : O Izakaya Lounge<br />
Cocktail Reception<br />
TUESDAY NOV 27: TECHNOLOGY SUMMIT<br />
9:00 am—9:10 am : Sakura Room<br />
Technology Overview<br />
Introduction to a variety of technologies used in the surveillance and enforcement of MPAs.<br />
Speaker: Oswaldo Rosero, Operations Director Ecuador – <strong>WildAid</strong><br />
9:10 am—9:30 am : Sakura Room<br />
Sustainable Equipment and Maintenance<br />
Performance driven equipment acqusition and life-cycle planning.<br />
Speaker: Rich Arnold, Senior Vice President-Harkcon<br />
Electronic Monitoring/Surveillance Technologies<br />
9:30 am—9:50 am : Sakura Room<br />
IMIS Global: Marine Software Integration<br />
AIS technology and its implementation in artisanal fishing and MPA management<br />
Speaker: Ernie Batty, Technical Director – IMIS Global Limited<br />
9:50 am—10:10 am : Sakura Room<br />
ORBCOMM: Satellite AIS Use in Marine Protection<br />
A look into the many uses of AIS data in the EU, the shores off West Africa, the Chilean EEZ, and more.<br />
Speaker: Andrew Loretta, Director, Maritime Business Development-ORBCOMM<br />
10:10 am—10:30 am : Sakura Room<br />
CLS: Satelite Vessel Monitoring Systems (SVMS)<br />
Exploring the scientific and marine enforcement applications of this technology.<br />
Speaker: Michael Kelly, Vice President, Sustainable Marine Resources-CLS America Inc.<br />
10:30 am—10:50 am : LOBBY<br />
Break<br />
10:50 am—11:10 am : SAKURA ROOM<br />
IMIS Global-A Practical ExamplE<br />
An implementation of small vessel management in Turkey<br />
Speaker: Ernie Batty, Technical Director-IMIS Global Limited<br />
11:10 am—11:30 am: SAKURA ROOM<br />
Google Ocean Project<br />
Applying Google's free mapping technology to enforcement and how NOAA successfully uses it to track<br />
fishing operations in Hawaii.<br />
Speaker: Jenifer Foulkes, Ocean Manager & Kurt Schwer, Head of Ocean Engineering and Data AIS<br />
Engineer-Google Oceans<br />
11:30 am—12:30 pm<br />
Lunch<br />
Unmanned Surveillance Technologies<br />
5<br />
12:30 pm—12:45 pm : SAKURA ROOM<br />
Association for Unmanned Vehicle Systems International (AUVSI)<br />
Connecting the Unmanned Systems Community Across the Globe<br />
Speaker: Gretchen West, Executive Vice President-AUVSI
12:45 pm—1:00 pm : SAKURA ROOM<br />
Liquid Robotics-Marine Wave Glider:<br />
Wide Scale Persistant MPA Monitoring<br />
Speaker: Edward Lu, Chief of Innovative Applications-Liquid Robotics<br />
1:00 pm—2:00pm : SAKURA ROOM<br />
Panel Discussion: Innovative Enforcement Systems for MPAs<br />
Panelists<br />
Ernie Batty Gretchen West Dave Sliwa, Director of Business Development, Insitu<br />
Andrew Loretta Ed Lu Alfredo Sfeir, Founder & CEO, Shellcatch<br />
Facilitator: Rich Arnold, Senior Vice President-Harkcon<br />
2:00 pm—2:20 pm : LOBBY<br />
Break<br />
Simultaneous Afternoon tracks<br />
MPA Experiences from the Field<br />
TRACK<br />
A<br />
Technology Expo<br />
TRACK<br />
B<br />
Practitioners from around the world discuss the<br />
successes and challenges in enforcing their MPAs.<br />
2:00 pm—2:45 pm : SAKURA ROOM<br />
Latin America MPAs<br />
• Mexico-Niparaja: Meredith de la Garza<br />
• Columbia-Seaflower: Jenny Bowie & Fanny Howard<br />
• Ecuador-Galapagos National Park: Oswaldo Rosero<br />
2:45 pm—4:00 pm : SAKURA ROOM<br />
Western Pacific MPAs<br />
• Palau-Helen Reef: Delegate Wayne Andrew<br />
• Indonesia-Ayau Besar: Meity Mongdong and<br />
Dr.Chrissy Huffard<br />
• Indonesia-Kawe: Mark Erdman & Kris Thebu<br />
• Kiribati-Phoenix Island Protected Area: Tom Redfern<br />
4:00 pm—4:45 pm : SAKURA ROOM<br />
Africa MPAs<br />
• Namibia: Heidi Currie Potgeiter<br />
• Madagascar: Alasdair Harris<br />
• Tanzania-Chumbe Island: Sibylle Riedmiller<br />
4:45 pm—5:30 pm : SAKURA ROOM<br />
North America/Europe MPAs<br />
• Canada-Gully MPA: Tanya Koropatnik<br />
• U.S.-Northwest: Deputy Chief Mike Cenci &<br />
Cap Bob Farrell<br />
• U.S.-Florida Keys: Ole' Varmer<br />
An opportunity to engage with the<br />
speakers from the morning session and<br />
learn more about how their equipment<br />
applies to your MPA.<br />
2:00 pm—5:00 pm : LOBBY<br />
TECHNOLOGY EXHIBIT<br />
This room will be open from 2-5pm,<br />
with representatives available to answer<br />
questions and interactive exhibits<br />
to explore.<br />
6
GLOBAL MPA CONFERENCE<br />
SAN FRANCISCO<br />
NOVEMBER 25–29<br />
Wednesday Nov 28<br />
Simultaneous Morning tracks<br />
Changing Behaviors of Fishers<br />
for MPA Compliance Faciliated by RARE<br />
TRACK<br />
A<br />
Creating an Effective MPA<br />
Training System Faciliated by HARKON<br />
TRACK<br />
B<br />
Increasing compliance and developing enforcement<br />
partnerships with stakeholders by educating<br />
them about the benefits of conservation.<br />
9:00 am—9:30 am<br />
Social Marketing and Communications<br />
as a Tool for Behavior Change<br />
Utilizing social marketing for behavior change<br />
and Rare's "Theory of Change".<br />
Speaker: Brian Day, Social Marketing Director,<br />
Global Programs-Rare<br />
9:30 am—10:00 am<br />
The Relationship Between Social<br />
Marketing, Behavior Change and<br />
Enforcement<br />
Engaging communities in patrols, enforcement,<br />
and surveillance operations through social<br />
marketing (including examples from the field).<br />
Speaker: Eleanor Carter, Marine Program<br />
Director-Rare<br />
10:00 am—10:30 am<br />
Case Study from Raja Ampat,<br />
Papua, Indonesia<br />
How social marketing was used to build and<br />
promote community patrols.<br />
Speaker:Meity Mongdong, Capacity Building<br />
Manager-Conservation International<br />
10:30 am—10:50 am:<br />
Break<br />
10:50 am—12:00 pm<br />
Breakout Sessions:<br />
Changing fisher behavior in Rafiki<br />
and Teman Communities<br />
How do you tailor your education and outreach<br />
approaches to the different sizes, structures, and<br />
resources of each MPA Attendees will apply<br />
lessons learned to two very different communities<br />
and work together to find what communication<br />
tools are successful in each case.<br />
12:00 pm—1:00 pm<br />
Lunch<br />
What elements are required within an effective<br />
MPA training system to instill and sustain<br />
improved operational law enforcement and<br />
resource protection capability<br />
9:00 am—10:30 am<br />
The Core Phases of Developing an<br />
Effective Training System<br />
A discussion of the key elements that foster and<br />
sustain improved operational law enforcement<br />
and resource protection capability, including:<br />
• Phase 1: Planning and Conducting a Training<br />
Needs Analysis<br />
• Phase 2: Designing and Developing Program<br />
Pieces<br />
• Phase 3: Delivery and Implementation<br />
• Phase 4: Evaluation and Measurement<br />
Speaker: Rich Arnold, Senior Vice<br />
President-Harkcon<br />
Kevin Harkins, CEO-Harkcon<br />
Laurie Mosier, Senior Vice President-Harkcon<br />
Dave Gulko, Director-Coral Reef CSI Field<br />
Training Program<br />
10:30 am—10:50 aM<br />
Break<br />
10:50 am—12:00 pm<br />
Breakout Sessions<br />
Interactive Breakout Session: Participants will<br />
interact with training system development<br />
experts to identify practical approaches to their<br />
performance and training needs. Come equipped<br />
with problems for our team to help solve!<br />
12:00 pm—1:00 pm<br />
Lunch<br />
7
Simultaneous afternoon tracks<br />
Sustainable Financing<br />
Mechanisms Faciliated by the CORAL reef alliance<br />
TRACK<br />
A<br />
Prosecution & Sanction<br />
Faciliated by CASE<br />
TRACK<br />
B<br />
Exploring various traditional and non-traditional<br />
funding mechanisms used to finance marine<br />
enforcement plans around the world.<br />
1:00 pm—1:15 pm<br />
Introductions and Framing of<br />
Session<br />
Speakers: Rick MacPherson & Jason Vasquez-<br />
The Coral Reef Alliance<br />
1:15 pm—2:05 pm<br />
Panel Discussion on the Current<br />
Sustainable Financing Landscape<br />
Economic Valuation of Ecosystem Services<br />
Lauretta Burke : Senior Associate-World<br />
Resources Institute<br />
Using Conservation Agreements to Leverage<br />
Conservation Investments<br />
Chris LaFranchi : Founder & CEO-OneReef<br />
The Business of MPAs: User Fees, Business Plans,<br />
and Private Sector Partnerships<br />
Rick MacPherson : Conservation Programs<br />
Director-Coral Reef Alliance<br />
Towards a Common Language in Economics and<br />
Sustainable Financing<br />
John Reid : Founder & President-Conservation<br />
Strategy Fund<br />
Case Studies in Sustainable Financing from Brazil<br />
Marcos Amend : Director-Conservation<br />
Strategy Fund Brazil<br />
2:05 pm—2:30 pm<br />
Cross Panel Discussion and Q&A<br />
2:30 pm—2:50 pm<br />
Break<br />
2:50 pm—4:15 pm<br />
BreakOut Sessions<br />
Participants will work together in small groups<br />
discussing a set of nested questions that get<br />
to the heart of financial planning for MPA<br />
operation and sustainability. Each group will<br />
explore questions independently and then bring<br />
findings back to plenary to distill common<br />
themes, novel ideas, and potential opportunities<br />
for further exploration.<br />
Integrating traditional and non-traditional<br />
disciplinary models as a means of enabling<br />
compliance, deterring repeat offenders, and<br />
strengthening the law enforcement chain.<br />
1:00 pm—1:30 pm<br />
Designing Environmental<br />
Taskforces<br />
A breakdown of key elements for success. Case<br />
samples will include: US-Mexico international<br />
fishing violations, domestic fishery law & the<br />
tactics of commercial fishers.<br />
Joseph Johns, Chief, Environmental Crimes<br />
Section-U.S. Department of Justice<br />
1:30pm - 2:00pm<br />
Rewards and Challenges of<br />
Enforcement in the Pacific<br />
Includes a discussion of agency partnerships and<br />
the advent of new technologies to aid enforcement,<br />
the application of various sanction models,<br />
and the overall effectiveness of NOAA’s enforcement<br />
efforts in various types of MPAs.<br />
Paul Ortiz, Senior Enforcement Attorney for<br />
NOAA's Office of General Counsel<br />
2:00 pm—2:30 pm<br />
An International Panel on<br />
Prosecution and Sanction<br />
Maria del Carmen : Director of Natural Reserve<br />
Chinchorro - Mexico<br />
Donna Cruz : Professor/Attorney from Guam<br />
Community College - Guam<br />
Dr.Toni Ruchimat : Director of of Marine Conservation<br />
Area & Fish Aqua-Indonesia Ministry<br />
of Marine Affairs & Fisheries<br />
Sangeeta Mangubhai : TNC Bird's Head Senior<br />
Technical Adivsor - Indonesia<br />
2:30 pm—2:50 pm<br />
Break<br />
(continued)<br />
8
GLOBAL MPA CONFERENCE<br />
SAN FRANCISCO<br />
NOVEMBER 25–29<br />
Simultaneous afternoon tracks continuous<br />
Sustainable Financing<br />
Mechanisms continued<br />
4:15 pm—5:00 pm<br />
Report Out in Plenary and<br />
Next Steps<br />
TRACK<br />
A<br />
Prosecution & Sanction<br />
continued<br />
2:50 pm—3:50 pm<br />
High Tech Solutions for MPA<br />
Enforcement<br />
Harnessing the power of crowd sourcing,<br />
predictve policing, and sophisticated monitoring<br />
to create a replicable model for all California<br />
MPAs and beyond.<br />
Speakers: John Fentis, CDAA Environmental<br />
Project Director & Gale Filter, CASE President<br />
& CEO<br />
3:50 pm—4:30 pm:<br />
BreakOut Sessions<br />
Interactive Breakout Session: We will explore<br />
various sanction models that include soft and<br />
hard measures as well as economic and noneconomic<br />
mechanisms to ensure compliance.<br />
TRACK<br />
B<br />
THURSDAY NOV 29: EXCURSION DAY<br />
12:00PM : KABUKI LOBBY<br />
Check out of Hotel Kabuki for all guests not attending the Sailing Excursion<br />
9:00 am—2:00 pm<br />
Networking on the Bay or Visit to the California Maritime Academy<br />
9
Conference Information<br />
Cell phones<br />
As a courtesy to all meeting attendees and speakers, cell phones and other electronic<br />
devices must be turned off or operated on silent mode during sessions.<br />
Internet Access<br />
Wireless Internet is available in meeting rooms using the login information listed below.<br />
Please limit use while conference is in session. The Business Center located on the Garden<br />
Level of the hotel has Mac computers that run both PC and Mac platforms for those who<br />
need computer access.<br />
Login: <strong>WildAid</strong>11-12<br />
Password: <strong>WildAid</strong>11-12<br />
Food and Beverage<br />
Coffee and tea will be available outside the Sakura main meeting room during morning and<br />
afternoon breaks.<br />
Breakfast is included for all attendees who are guests at Hotel Kabuki and will be served<br />
Monday-Thursday in the Spring Room from 7:30-8:30am<br />
Lunch is provided for ALL attendees and included in your registration fee.<br />
Contact Information<br />
For all hotel related inquiries, please contact the Hotel Kabuki front desk.<br />
Telephone: 415-922-3200<br />
For all conference and logistics related questions, please contact Amanda.<br />
Telephone:209-648-4775<br />
Email: globalmpaconference@wildaid.org<br />
For any emergencies, please call 911<br />
10
About <strong>WildAid</strong>:<br />
<strong>WildAid</strong>’s mission is to end the illegal wildlife trade in our lifetimes by<br />
reducing demand through public awareness campaigns and providing<br />
comprehensive marine protection. We have successfully developed a model<br />
that strengthens the key elements of the law enforcement chain: surveillance,<br />
interdiction, prosecution, and sanction in several MPAs throughout<br />
the developing world. We work with governments in the design of strategic<br />
control and vigilance strategies that use the power of technology to increase<br />
efficacy while lowering patrolling costs. Given weak judicial systems, we<br />
also work with partners to develop innovative fining mechanisms that<br />
ensure compliance.<br />
Learn more at wildaid.org.<br />
744 Montgomery St. #300 San Francisco, CA 94111 | Tel: 415-834-3174 | info@wildaid.org | www.wildaid.org