Romans 16:17-27 - In Depth Bible Commentaries
Romans 16:17-27 - In Depth Bible Commentaries
Romans 16:17-27 - In Depth Bible Commentaries
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
A CRITICAL WARNING AND A GREAT ASSURANCE<br />
<strong>Romans</strong> <strong>16</strong>:<strong>17</strong>-20, Greek Text with Translation<br />
<strong>16</strong>.<strong>17</strong> Parakalw/ de. u`ma/j( avdelfoi,( skopei/n tou.j ta.j dicostasi,aj kai. ta. ska,ndala<br />
para. th.n didach.n h]n u`mei/j evma,qete poiou/ntaj( kai. evkkli,nete avpV auvtw/n\ <strong>16</strong>.18 oi` ga.r<br />
toiou/toi tw/| kuri,w| h`mw/n Cristw/| ouv douleu,ousin avlla. th/| e`autw/n koili,a|( kai. dia. th/j<br />
crhstologi,aj kai. euvlogi,aj evxapatw/sin ta.j kardi,aj tw/n avka,kwnÅ <strong>16</strong>.19 h` ga.r u`mw/n<br />
u`pakoh. eivj pa,ntaj avfi,keto\ evfV u`mi/n ou=n cai,rw( qe,lw de. u`ma/j sofou.j ei=nai eivj to.<br />
avgaqo,n( avkerai,ouj de. eivj to. kako,nÅ<br />
<strong>16</strong>.<strong>17</strong> But then I exhort you, brothers, to watch out (for) those who are causing the<br />
divisions and the causes of stumbling, contrary to the teaching which you learned, and turn away<br />
from them. <strong>16</strong>.18 For those such as these are not serving the Lord of ours, Christ, but rather<br />
their own belly, and through the(ir) kind speech and flattery are deceiving the hearts of the<br />
innocent people. <strong>16</strong>.19 For your obedience became known to everyone. Over you people,<br />
therefore, I rejoice; but then I want you to be wise people for the good, and then harmless for the<br />
evil.<br />
<strong>16</strong>.20 o` de. qeo.j th/j eivrh,nhj suntri,yei to.n satana/n u`po. tou.j po,daj u`mw/n evn ta,ceiÅ<br />
~H ca,rij tou/ kuri,ou h`mw/n VIhsou/ meqV u`mw/nÅ<br />
<strong>16</strong>.20 But then the God of peace will shatter the adversary beneath your feet with speed.<br />
The gracious favor of our Lord, Jesus (is) with you!<br />
A CRITICAL WARNING AND A GREAT ASSURANCE<br />
<strong>Romans</strong> <strong>16</strong>:<strong>17</strong>-20, Translation with Footnotes<br />
1587 1588 1589 1590<br />
<strong>16</strong>.<strong>17</strong> But then I exhort you, brothers, to watch out (for) those who are<br />
1587<br />
As we look at verses <strong>17</strong>-20, we see Paul in verses <strong>17</strong>-19 issuing a surprising, but<br />
critical warning against a certain type of Christian leaders who will not further the cause of Christ,<br />
but rather will bring division to the followers of Christ, tripping them up rather them leading them<br />
into the mission and ministry of Christ. It is a warning that is repeated in many other places in<br />
scripture, and one that we need to consider very carefully.<br />
Then, immediately following this critical warning, in verse 20, we see Paul express a great<br />
assurance–it is the assurance that God, the great Lord of History, will lead His faithful people to<br />
peace, filling their lives with the gracious favor of the Lord Jesus! What an assurance!<br />
Paul’s warning against false teachers in verses <strong>17</strong>-19 , comes unexpectedly and<br />
somewhat surprisingly, since Paul has said nothing about false teachers before this in his<br />
letter–and coming here as it does, seems like an after-thought. Moo states that this section “is<br />
858<br />
(continued...)
1587<br />
(...continued)<br />
not typical of Paul’s letter endings; only here does he launch into an attack on false teachers, an<br />
attack, moreover, that interrupts Paul’s greetings (verses 3-<strong>16</strong>, 21-23)...<br />
“Paul has not said anything in the letter to this point that would suggest that there was any<br />
problem with false teachers...[He may have] delayed specific mention of false teachers to this<br />
point because they had not yet come to Rome and / or because Paul had just heard about the<br />
threat...Identifying these false teachers [specifically] is almost impossible...They are divisive, selfcentered,<br />
persuasive, teach what is contrary to the gospel, and must therefore be avoided at all<br />
costs...” (Pp. 928-29)<br />
Wright states “Perhaps, as Paul thinks and prays about these small house-churches, he<br />
has had a sudden stab of anxiety. Do they, he wonders, need to be warned that there are fierce<br />
wolves on the loose, who will not spare the flock...?” (P. 764)<br />
As Paul gathered the leaders from the Church at Ephesus for his final meeting with them,<br />
he warned that “...After my departure savage wolves will come in among you, not sparing the<br />
flock; and from among your own selves men will arise, speaking perverse things, to draw away<br />
the disciples after them.” The warning that Paul gives here at the close of <strong>Romans</strong> is very similar<br />
to that warning.<br />
Scholars such as Cranfield and Moo have attempted to name the false teachers<br />
specifically, suggesting especially “Gnostics” and “Judaizers.” But Paul does not give them any<br />
specific name or doctrine–the false teachers are those who do not live true to the good news, they<br />
are selfish, serving their own interests, not committed to the furtherance of the ministry and<br />
mission of Jesus–by whatever name they may be called. This is the warning we need to hear, not<br />
to think of those who, for example, teach people to observe the wrong date for Easter, or who are<br />
mistaken in their teaching concerning the “form” of Jesus in relation to God. They are false<br />
teachers because they live by a false life-style and purpose in life–and that can happen to any<br />
leader, whether “orthodox” or “unorthodox”!<br />
Who are the “false teachers” in our own time? They are self-styled Christian leaders,<br />
whether Catholic or Protestant, whether conservative or liberal, who are not committed to living by<br />
the gospel, who are serving their own self-interests, who are not seeking to share in the mission<br />
and ministry of Jesus Christ. They need no more specific identity. The mark of the true Christian<br />
leaders is that they are committed, heart and soul, to Jesus as Lord of their lives, and that they<br />
are seeking in every way possible to them, to further the Kingdom of God!<br />
1588 st<br />
The 1 person singular, present indicative active verb parakalw/, parakalo, “I exhort,” is<br />
st<br />
changed to the synonymous 1 person singular, present indicative active verb evrwtw/, eroto, “I<br />
ask,” “I request,” by the first writer of Bezae and the entire Latin tradition.<br />
This variant reading hardly changes the meaning of <strong>Romans</strong>.<br />
1589<br />
Here again Paul uses the plural noun avdelfoi, adelphoi, “brothers,” but obviously in a<br />
(continued...)<br />
859
1589<br />
(...continued)<br />
broad sense to include all of these women he has just named, and therefore it is fully justified to<br />
translate in a broad term such as “family members,” or as New Revised Standard and others<br />
give it, “Brothers and Sisters.”<br />
1590<br />
The present active infinitive verb skopei/n, skopein, “to watch out for,” is changed to the<br />
nd<br />
phrase avsfalw/j skopei/te, asphalos skopeite, using the 2 person plural imperative, “carefully<br />
watch out for,” by Bezae, F, G, the Old Latin Manuscripts a (see), m and Speculum, Pseudoth<br />
Augustine (5 century A.D.)<br />
The variant reading only emphasizes the meaning of the original text.<br />
What does Paul mean by his use of the verb skopei/n, skopein, “to pay close attention<br />
to”? Sometimes this “paying close attention to” is in order to imitate what those being observed<br />
are doing (see Philippians 3:<strong>17</strong>); but here in <strong>Romans</strong> <strong>16</strong>:<strong>17</strong> it is meant in the sense “in order to<br />
turn away from them.” Similar warnings are found in Paul’s other writings at:<br />
1 Corinthians 5:9-13<br />
Do you not know that the unrighteous will not inherit the kingdom of God? Do not<br />
be deceived. Neither fornicators, nor idolaters, nor adulterers, nor homosexuals, nor<br />
sodomites, nor thieves, nor covetous, nor drunkards, nor revilers, nor extortioners will<br />
inherit the kingdom of God. And such were some of you. But you were washed, but you<br />
were sanctified, but you were justified in the name of the Lord Jesus and by the Spirit of<br />
our God. (New King James)<br />
Note that in 2 Corinthians 2:1-8, Paul adds that after a period of removal from the church<br />
body, the man should be forgiven and comforted, as the church reaffirms its love for him.<br />
2 Corinthians 11:13-15, where Paul warns against men who are]<br />
“false apostles, deceitful workers, disguising themselves as apostles of Christ. No wonder,<br />
for even Satan disguises himself as an angel of light. Therefore it is not surprising if his<br />
servants also disguise themselves as servants of righteousness, whose end will be<br />
according to their deeds.”<br />
Philippians 3:2, 18-19<br />
“Beware of the dogs, beware of the evil workers, beware of the false circumcision...<br />
“For many walk, of whom I often told you...that they are enemies of the cross of<br />
Christ, whose end is destruction, whose god is their appetite, and whose glory is in their<br />
shame, who set their minds on earthly things.”<br />
860<br />
(continued...)
1591 1592 1593<br />
causing the divisions and the causes for stumbling, contrary to the teaching which you<br />
1590<br />
(...continued)<br />
That is, Paul warns that there are immoral people even inside the church, who refuse to<br />
repent of their evil ways, and who continue to deny the teaching and mission of Christ by their lifestyle–the<br />
church must withdraw from such people, for their own good; but at the same time,<br />
always be willing to receive them back into their midst, as soon as they turn from their evil ways.<br />
He also warns that there are false leaders, who seek to take advantage of believers,<br />
pretending to be doing God’s will, but in fact following their own selfish programs, whose real god<br />
is their own appetite, their gaining of earthly wealth. Paul’s warning here in <strong>Romans</strong> <strong>16</strong>:<strong>17</strong>-18 is<br />
very similar–there are people who create divisions in the church, and cause others to stumble–<br />
who, in spite of their fine words and claims. are in fact serving their own appetites, and deceiving<br />
the hearts of innocent people, for their own selfish gain. Watch for them–be on guard against<br />
them! Don’t make the mistake of thinking that everyone who claims to be a Christian leader is<br />
truly such!<br />
The fact of Christian history is that the church throughout the centuries has been subjected<br />
to exactly this kind of danger, again and again, as self-proclaimed “Christian Leaders” have<br />
arisen, taking advantage of innocent people, as they “feather their own nests,” and as they get<br />
others to support their own selfish programs, with no real concern for Jesus Christ and the<br />
Kingdom of God. It is a warning that we need to pay attention at all times and in all places!<br />
1591<br />
The noun dicostasi,aj, dichostasias, means “standings apart,” “quarrels,” “disputes.”<br />
Paul warns that there will be people in the midst of the Church who will sow discord among<br />
them, causing them to “stand apart” from one another, and so to become divided. Such people<br />
are to be watched carefully and turned away from--lest the wonderful gift of Christian unity and<br />
oneness in Christ’s mission to the world be destroyed.<br />
When the good news of God’s saving acts in Jesus Christ is proclaimed, and people<br />
respond to that message in the obedience of faith, there the Church of Jesus Christ is born,<br />
wherever that good news is preached. And when believers in the good news seek to do the<br />
works of Jesus Christ–reaching out to the unlovely, feeding the hungry, proclaiming good news to<br />
the poor, they are united as one people, rapidly reaching out to all people, of all races and<br />
nationalities, bringing peace and hope to this hurting world.<br />
But just as soon as selfish leaders arise in the heart of the Church, leaders who have their<br />
own programs to promote, division quickly rears its ugly head. We should think of how powerful<br />
the early church was while it was suffering under the Roman Government–having to meet in<br />
house-churches, and in underground caves, becoming willing martyrs for their faith, but constantly<br />
loving and serving others. Self-serving people didn’t want to share in such a movement! It was a<br />
powerful, united movement, which allowed all sorts of beliefs and understandings and practices to<br />
exist side by side, just as long as there was loyalty to that basic, founding faith that had called the<br />
church into being–the good news of Jesus Christ, and its call to share in His mission and ministry.<br />
861<br />
(continued...)
1591<br />
(...continued)<br />
But when the Roman Emperor Constantine made Christianity the official religion of the<br />
Roman Empire, and placed the power of the sword into the hands of Christian leaders, and<br />
ordered the Christian leaders to write out a creed, and to practice the same rituals of worship all<br />
over the Roman Empire, all sorts of divisions began to sharply divide the once united followers of<br />
Jesus.<br />
<strong>In</strong>stead of being content with simply believing the good news of God’s saving acts in Jesus<br />
Christ, and doing everything in their power to live by that message, and proclaim it to others, the<br />
Emperor demanded that Christian leaders draw up a creedal statement (what we know today as<br />
the “Nicene Creed”), and to reject all Christians who refused to subscribe to that creed. Christian<br />
leaders began to debate difficult theological issues such as the nature of God, attempting to give<br />
exact definitions of the “Trinity,” explaining the nature of the “Triune God,” and the exact nature of<br />
Christ. Was Jesus Christ “of the same nature” (o`moou,sioj, homoousios) as God, or was he “of<br />
similar nature” (o`moiou,sioj, homoiousios)? The outcome of those debates was that Christian<br />
believers in Syria, and Palestine, and Egypt were labeled “heretics,” and were to be put to death if<br />
they did not change their minds and subscribe to the “orthodox” creed.<br />
We must add the sad note that in Arabia, as the divided Christian believers debated with<br />
and killed one another, their divided condition gave rise to the Prophet Mohammed (570?-632),<br />
and to the religion of Islam, which fundamentally rejected this strange attempt of Christians to<br />
exactly define the nature of God, and make it a matter of life and death, instead of doing the<br />
works of Jesus their Lord. I believe that Christianity could have swept all across Arabia, if the<br />
Christians had not been so divided over such theological issues, and instead had concentrated on<br />
mission and ministry to the poor and suffering peoples of Arabia. But Constantine had put the<br />
sword in the hands of the Christian leaders, and they used that sword to propagate their<br />
“orthodox” theories, instead of following the example of Jesus in His self-giving mission.<br />
History quickly revealed how the power of the sword in the hands of power-hungry<br />
Christian leaders soon divided the followers of Jesus from one another–and the ugliness of<br />
division and sectarian strife has continued to trouble and poison the church across the following<br />
centuries.<br />
“Power corrupts–absolute power corrupts absolutely!” Such a statement can well<br />
summarize much of the subsequent of Christian history.<br />
But we can re-word that saying: “Loving service unites–absolute love unites absolutely!”<br />
And thanks to God, throughout the twenty centuries of Christianity, for every power hungry egotist<br />
who has contributed to the division of the Church, there have been countless others who have<br />
dedicated their lives to loving and serving others, and proclaiming the good news throughout this<br />
hurting world. We need to hear that side of the story–how humble monks and nuns, and<br />
Lutherans and Anabaptists, and missionaries from the Christian denominations in America, have<br />
gone out across the world, building schools and hospitals and churches among the poorest<br />
peoples of the earth, learning over a thousand of earth’s languages in order to proclaim the good<br />
news of God’s love, translating the <strong>Bible</strong> into those native languages, calling people out from<br />
ignorance and idolatry into the knowledge of God.<br />
(continued...)<br />
862
1591<br />
(...continued)<br />
So what I am insisting on is that we need to listen to the voice of leaders who call us to<br />
loving service and ministry in our world, and turn away from egotistical, power-hungry leaders who<br />
want to gain our support for their narrow, self-serving causes.<br />
How can we identify such leaders, such “false teachers”? It is easy–by simply observing<br />
their lives, by learning what it is that motivates them–refusing to follow the power-hungry, but<br />
gladly entering into the works of those who long to follow Jesus Christ!<br />
We all know of the religious wars that plagued “Christian Europe,” and when our<br />
forefathers came to America, with the promise of religious freedom, we know how the American<br />
Church divided over one issue after another, separating faithful Christians from one another,<br />
calling those with whom they disagreed “false teachers,” and causing many a perplexed person to<br />
give up on the Christian faith.<br />
Watch out, says Paul–don’t follow leaders who have their particular axes to grind, who are<br />
concerned for power and control, but who care little or nothing for the mission and ministry of<br />
Jesus Christ in this troubled world! We are not called to power–but we are called to serve others<br />
in the name of Jesus Christ!<br />
If your deepest desire as a Christian leader is for power and control–if you want to climb to<br />
the top of the power pyramid, and exercise authority over others, you are going to get into many a<br />
fight before you get to the top, you are going to cause divisions of all sorts along the way, and if<br />
you ever get to the top, it’s going to be mighty lonely! But if you dare to look down to the bottom<br />
of the pyramid, and the endless horizons beyond, there you will find all sorts of people in need,<br />
challenging you to all the ministry and love and service that you can possibly give in your lifetime!<br />
st<br />
What we need in this 21 century is to get away from the divisions that have so plagued<br />
Christianity across the centuries–and return to simple biblical faith in the good news. We need to<br />
believe in Jesus Christ, and then follow him into ministry and mission--stooping to serve those<br />
round us, in the most effective way we can, refusing to get caught up in exact theological<br />
definitions, in creedal exclusiveness, and instead, get lost in loving and serving in the name of our<br />
Lord!<br />
1592<br />
The plural noun with the definite article, ta. ska,ndala, ta skandala, means “the traps,”<br />
or “the temptations to sin,” or “the causes of stumbling.” See <strong>Romans</strong> 9:33; 11:9 and 14:13.<br />
Notice how Paul goes on to describe them as being produced by those who are going contrary to<br />
the basic Christian teaching.<br />
1593<br />
The preposition para, para, can have varied meanings. When used with the accusative<br />
noun following as happens here, it normally means “beside,” or “because of.” However, here it is<br />
apparently used in an adversative sense, and means “against,” or “contrary to.”<br />
Cranfield comments that “...The words para. th.n didach.n h]n u`mei/j evma,qete, para ten<br />
didachen hen humeis emathete [’contrary to the teaching which you people learned’] are of vital<br />
863<br />
(continued...)
1594 1595 1596 1597<br />
learned, and turn away from them. <strong>16</strong>.18 For those such as these are not serving<br />
1593<br />
(...continued)<br />
importance in this sentence. It is those who cause divisions and occasions of stumbling contrary<br />
to the truth of the gospel against whom Paul warns.<br />
“Sometimes divisions have to be caused for the sake of the truth (see, for example,<br />
Galatians 1:8-9; and Jesus himself was a cause of division--compare, e.g., Matthew 10:34-26)--<br />
and in certain circumstances the truth itself is a stumbling-block (see for example, 9:32b-33; Luke<br />
7:23).” (P. 798) But notice how in both of these instances, the division was caused by the<br />
insistence of Jesus and of Paul that the people of God must quit separating themselves from<br />
others, and enter whole-heartedly into ministry to the lowly and to those considered unacceptable<br />
by the “orthodox”!<br />
Moo holds that Paul is warning against “heretical doctrine...He is thinking mainly of false<br />
doctrine.” (P. 930) This kind of interpretation leads to the development of creedal statements<br />
such as the Nicene Creed, with the demand for doctrinal uniformity (see footnote 1591).<br />
We think Paul means the kind of false teaching which is not true to the good news, and<br />
which is self-serving rather than self-giving. <strong>In</strong> fact, the demand for uniformity in theological<br />
opinion, represented by the Nicene Creed, seeks to be able to define exactly mysterious things<br />
beyond our reach or knowledge, and which in fact has only lead to division, and subverts, rather<br />
than forwarding the mission and work of the Kingdom of God.<br />
Note how Paul goes on to describe these “false teachers.” “They do not serve Jesus<br />
Christ, but rather their own bellies.” This is not a matter of correct, exact definitions, but of life,<br />
and of personal commitment to Christ and his mission in the world. What do you think?<br />
1594<br />
The phrase le,gontaj hv,, legontas e, “saying or (doing),” is interpolated at this point in<br />
the text by P46 (with an additional hv, at the beginning of the phrase), Bezae, F, G, the Old Latin<br />
th<br />
Manuscript m and Speculum, Pseudo-Augustine (5 century A.D.).<br />
The interpolated phrase does not change the meaning of <strong>Romans</strong>, but adds the thought<br />
that sometimes divisions and occasions of stumbling are caused by what people say.<br />
The text without this interpolation is read by Sinaiticus, Alexandrinus, Vaticanus,<br />
Ephraemi Rescriptus, Psi, Minuscules 33, <strong>17</strong>39, 1881, the “Majority Text,” the Latin Vulgate, a<br />
part of the Old Latin witnesses, the Syriac tradition, the Coptic tradition and Ambrosiaster (366-<br />
384 A.D.).<br />
The interpolation does not change the meaning of <strong>Romans</strong>, but slightly emphasizes it.<br />
Paul uses the noun didach, didache, to describe that “teaching” which the <strong>Romans</strong> had<br />
learned when becoming Christians, disciples of Christ Jesus. Compare <strong>Romans</strong> 6:<strong>17</strong>.<br />
864<br />
(continued...)
1594<br />
(...continued)<br />
<strong>In</strong> a real sense, this reflects the beginning of the “canon,” the “rule” of Christian behavior<br />
and thought. Paul acknowledges that the Roman believers have received a body of teaching,<br />
which through believing and obeying, enables them to wear the name of “the set-apart people of<br />
God.” It is clear that Paul means “the gospel,” “the good news,” which has been proclaimed in<br />
their midst, and which creates the Church. That’s the basic “canon,” the “rule” of Christian<br />
behavior and thought.<br />
Now, to accept into their midst teachings or practices contrary to that received body of<br />
teaching, that gospel, is to dilute the original message, and eventually to divide the believers in<br />
such a way as to destroy their unity. “Don’t do that,” urges Paul. “Struggle to maintain the unity<br />
that we have as believers, on the basis of the common teaching we have received.”<br />
Cranfield comments that “The didach, didache, which the Roman Christians have learned<br />
is no special Pauline teaching; for, though some of them have indeed had contact with Paul, the<br />
community as a whole is not of his founding. We must assume rather that the reference is to<br />
what is common primitive Christian teaching.” (P. 798) Compare 1 Corinthians 15:1.<br />
The basic Christian “teaching”is the good news, the gospel–the story of what God the<br />
Creator has done for this sinful world through Jesus Christ, calling all peoples and nations to<br />
become one people, devoting their lives to loving and serving as Jesus lived and served, being<br />
willing to die for the causes of God’s coming kingdom in this life. But this basic message does not<br />
involve exact definitions of the nature of God, or legalistic rules and laws covering every aspect of<br />
life, or exact understandings of what the future may hold. When we begin create such exact<br />
doctrinal definitions, and legalistic rules for life, and “road-maps for the future,” we quickly go far<br />
beyond that basic teaching, and set up “causes of stumbling” and division among the followers of<br />
Christ.<br />
We think of the huge doctrinal statements of ‘canon law” drawn up by the Roman Catholic<br />
Church, and then later by the Lutherans, and the Calvinists, and by our own American<br />
denominations. These attempts to legislate the Christian religion, and making claims to know<br />
exactly the unknowable, have been the source of untold division and conflict among the followers<br />
of Christ. But the teaching that all of us should serve one another, and do everything in our power<br />
to reach out worldwide with the good news–that is the kind of teaching that unites the followers of<br />
Jesus, and makes the Church glorious–not divided!<br />
1595<br />
The conjunction kai, kai, “and,” is omitted by P46, Minuscule 1<strong>17</strong>5, a few other Greek<br />
th<br />
manuscripts and Speculum, Pseudo-Augustine (5 century A.D.).<br />
The omission does not change the meaning of <strong>Romans</strong>.<br />
1596 nd<br />
The 2 person plural present imperative verb evkkli,nete, ekklinete, “you people turn<br />
away,” is read by the first writer of Sinaiticus, Vaticanus, Ephraemi Rescriptus, Psi,<br />
Minuscules 6, 630, 1505, <strong>17</strong>39, 1881, 2464 and a few other Greek manuscripts.<br />
865<br />
(continued...)
1596<br />
(...continued)<br />
It is changed to the aorist imperative, evkkli,nate, ekklinate, by P46, a corrector of<br />
Sinaiticus, Alexandrinus, Bezae, F, G, Minuscule 33 and the “Majority Text.”<br />
This change from present tense to aorist does not change the meaning of <strong>Romans</strong>.<br />
The verb evkkli,nw, ekklino, means “turn away,” “avoid,” or “shun.” The only other places<br />
in the Greek New Testament where this verb occurs are at <strong>Romans</strong> 3:12 (where Psalm 14:3 is<br />
being quoted) and 1 Peter 3:11 (where Psalm 34:14 is being quoted).<br />
<strong>In</strong> each of those other occurrences, the verb “turn away” is used in a very negative sense,<br />
of “turning away” from God and his truth. Here in <strong>Romans</strong> <strong>16</strong>:<strong>17</strong> the verb is used in a positive<br />
sense, of the necessity for Christian believers “turning away” from those who are causing<br />
divisions contrary to the commonly received body of Christian teaching.<br />
Moo comments that “Paul is not necessarily implying that the false teachers are already<br />
present. His point is that the Roman Christians must be on their guard against them and be<br />
determined to avoid them should they appear.” (P. 930)<br />
We would say, “Do everything in your power to be united with all other Christians in the<br />
service of Jesus Christ. And when you select leaders in your congregation, make sure that they<br />
are honest followers of Jesus Christ, who are dedicated to furthering his mission and God’s<br />
kingdom–not to building their own little kingdoms. That the first and most important matter in<br />
choosing Christian leaders. If they are selfish and serving their own interests rather than the<br />
interests of God’s kingdom, turn away from them! Don’t dare follow them, or allow them to<br />
exercise leadership in your congregation!<br />
1597<br />
Cranfield comments that “The Roman Christians are not only to mark such people in the<br />
sense of recognizing them for the danger which they are: they are actually to avoid them, to keep<br />
out of their way.” (P. 798) It sometimes seems like a harsh, “unchristian” thing to do--but the fact<br />
of church history is that unless such people are marked and avoided, churches will be irreparably<br />
damaged and destroyed, and led away from the loving mission of Christ. Everyone is welcome in<br />
the Church of the Lord Jesus--but they are only welcome as those who believe in, and live by, the<br />
teaching of the Christian Good News. If they come into the congregation in order to deny, or<br />
subvert that teaching and that mission, they are not to be welcomed, but to be turned away from!<br />
Cranfield comments that “...One can avoid subjecting oneself to a person’s evil influence<br />
without hardening one’s heart against him or refusing him kindly help should he be in distress,<br />
though the task of responding to the deeper need which lies behind his false teaching [and<br />
manner of life] is one which the more immature Christians may well leave to the more mature and<br />
informed...Whenever a church is constrained in loyalty both to God and to men to apply its<br />
ultimate sanction of excommunication to someone, it must of course hope for, and actively<br />
seek, the repentance and restoration of the offender.” (P. 799)<br />
866<br />
(continued...)
1598 1599 <strong>16</strong>00 <strong>16</strong>01<br />
our Lord, Christ, but rather their own belly, and through the(ir) kind speech and flattery<br />
1597<br />
(...continued)<br />
Compare 1 Corinthians 5:9-13 (see footnote 1590) and 2 Thessalonians 3:6, “Now we<br />
command you, brothers, in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, that you keep away from every<br />
brother who leads an unruly life and not according to the tradition which you received from us.”<br />
What kind of life-style is Paul talking about there? He is talking about people who have an<br />
undisciplined life-style, sponging off of others, acting like busy-bodies, refusing to work and help<br />
others as Paul and his helpers had set the example (see verses 6-15).<br />
See a similar warning in 2 Timothy 3:1-7, against people who are lovers of themselves,<br />
lovers of money, boastful, arrogant...unloving...malicious gossips...lovers of pleasure rather than<br />
lovers of God, etc. These are the false teachers who must be turned away from! They are the<br />
very opposite of the embodiment of the teaching and mission of Jesus Christ!<br />
1598<br />
Such people, who come into the Christian community bringing new and different<br />
teachings and life-styles that cause divisions and apostasy among the believers may make ever<br />
so many claims to being servants of Christ--but, Paul asserts, it is simply not the case. They have<br />
another ultimate loyalty to which they give unswerving allegiance. They are seeking their own<br />
profit and advantage–not the Kingdom of God, or the mission of Jesus Christ!<br />
1599<br />
This is their true “Lord” whom they in fact serve--their own “bellies”--i.e., their own selfish<br />
appetites and desires. Compare Philippians 3:19 (see footnote 1590) and Matthew 23:14,<br />
“Woe to you, scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites, because you devour widows' houses, and for a<br />
pretense you make long prayers; therefore you will receive greater condemnation.” The reason<br />
that Jesus entered into such sharp conflict with the Jewish religious leaders is that they were<br />
selfishly feathering their own nests, but not reaching out in loving ministry to the poor people in<br />
their midst.<br />
The phrase douleu,ousin...th/| eàutw/n koili,a|, douleuousin...te heauton koilia, “they are<br />
enslaved to their own stomach,” should be compared to the similar statements in 2 Corinthians<br />
11:20 (where Paul describes so-called Christian leaders who enslave their followers, devour<br />
them, take advantage of them) and Titus 1:10-11 (“For there are many rebellious...empty talkers<br />
and deceivers...who must be silenced because they are upsetting whole families, teaching things<br />
they should not teach for the sake of sordid gain. Such people are greedy, longing to exploit the<br />
simple-minded, humble believers.” Moo comments that “These false teachers are interested in<br />
their own pleasure...They are not serving ‘our Lord Christ.’” (Pp. 930-31)<br />
<strong>16</strong>00<br />
The noun crhstologi,a, chrestologia, means “smooth, plausible speech,” and occurs<br />
only here in the Greek New Testament. Such teachers know how to use kindly, convincing<br />
language, but the end result of their teaching is that they lead others astray from the truth of<br />
Christ, and heartlessly divide the body of believers for the sake of their personal advantage. They<br />
are religious “politicians,” who know how to appeal to our desires, and who give all appearance of<br />
being genuinely sincere religious leaders. It is just this that makes them all the more dangerous.<br />
Don’t follow them, says Paul--mark them, watch out for them, turn aside from them!<br />
867
<strong>16</strong>02 <strong>16</strong>03 <strong>16</strong>04<br />
are deceiving the hearts of the innocent people.<br />
<strong>16</strong>01<br />
The phrase kai. euvlogi,aj, kai eulogias, which we have translated “and flattery,” is<br />
changed to the phrase kai. euvglwtti,aj, kai euglottias, “and fluency of speech,” by Minuscule<br />
460.<br />
The phrase is omitted by Bezae, F, G, Minuscules 33, 81, a few other Greek manuscripts<br />
and the Old Latin Manuscript m.<br />
The omission of the phrase may well have been caused by the eye of copyists or<br />
translators skipping from the -iaj, -ias, at the end of crhstologi,aj, chrestologias, to that same<br />
ending of euvlogi,aj, eulogias, resulting in leaving out the intervening phrase.<br />
These variant readings do not change the meaning of <strong>Romans</strong> in a significant way.<br />
Here Paul uses the noun euvlogi,a, eulogia, which means “fine speaking,” or even “praise”<br />
(compare our modern “eulogy”) but which is used here in the sense “flattery,” the kind of<br />
statements that sound good, but that are false--what might be called “false eloquence.”<br />
<strong>In</strong> fact, the more eloquent and appealing the speaker, the greater the need to be on guard,<br />
to watch against being led astray from the truth of God revealed in Christ. So Paul insists. We<br />
have all seen self-styled ministers, who can speak beautifully and fluently, but whose lives and<br />
ministries quickly reveal that their real motivation is their own ease, and comfort, and welfare–<br />
having little or nothing to do with the life-style and ministry of Jesus Christ!<br />
<strong>16</strong>02 rd<br />
The 3 person plural, present indicative active verb evxapatw/sin, eksapatosin, means<br />
“they are deceiving,” or “they are leading astray.” Never think that you are so grounded in the<br />
faith that you cannot be led astray. It is easy to get caught up in well-worded, beautiful-sounding<br />
teaching that sounds ever so plausible, but which in fact leads astray from the basic teaching of<br />
the good news, the teaching and life-style of Jesus, and commitment to his mission in the world.<br />
Moo comments that “Paul well knows that these false teachers are clever at dressing up<br />
their heresies in ‘smooth talk and fine words.’ Those who are not on the watch for these people<br />
and who do not listen closely enough to what they are teaching might be led astray and into<br />
ultimate spiritual ruin.” (P. 931) We re-word this to say, “these false teachers are clever at<br />
dressing up their failures in (or lack of) mission and ministry with smooth talk and fine words.” We<br />
need to watch closely how they live, and how they love, and whether or not they are furthering the<br />
mission of our Lord. That’s the real question–not a matter of specific doctrines or definitions such<br />
as Moo apparently has in mind!<br />
We are reminded of the constant danger in Israel of the “false spokespersons,” whose<br />
proclamations of “peace” were the prelude to terrible destruction. The New Testament contains<br />
similar warnings--see 2 Peter 2, a chapter devoted in its entirety to this warning, along with other<br />
related passages from the Gospels and Epistles that give similar warnings.<br />
868<br />
(continued...)
<strong>16</strong>02<br />
(...continued)<br />
2 Peter 2 uses the descriptive phrase ai`re,seij avpwlei,aj, haireseis apoleias, “heresies<br />
(meaning ‘opinions,’ ‘dogmas,’ ‘doctrinal statements’) of destruction.” We might take this to mean<br />
“wrong doctrinal opinions,” but a reading of this chapter shows that it is a matter of terribly wrong<br />
life-styles–they deny the Lord, Jesus Christ (the very heart of the Christian message); they<br />
greedily exploit people with false words; they are self-indulgent, filled with corrupt desires (they<br />
have “eyes full of adultery,” “never ceasing from sinning,” as in Sodom and Gomorrah), they<br />
refuse to submit to authority; they have hearts trained in greed, etc. This is not by any means a<br />
matter of technical disagreements over fine points of Christian doctrine, such as the nature of<br />
Christ in relation to God, etc., but a matter of false life-style and failure in mission.<br />
<strong>16</strong>03<br />
The biblical writers use the noun “heart” for the internal part of a human being, the<br />
source of thought and decision and emotion. Deep down within us, where the springs of action<br />
originate, we can be lead astray by plausible sounding teaching, but associated with a life-style<br />
and practice, which does not commit us to mission and self-giving–and regardless of its<br />
plausibility, fills with a poison that destroys genuine faith in the good news. Be on guard both<br />
intellectually and spiritually. So Paul warns the <strong>Romans</strong>, and it is a warning that we need to hear<br />
today!<br />
<strong>16</strong>04<br />
The adjective is genitive plural, avka,kwn, akakon, which means “harmless ones,” or<br />
“innocent ones,” or “unsuspecting ones.” Such people are not accustomed to religious argument,<br />
and the clash of religious ideas and teaching. They are unskilled in distinguishing genuine<br />
religious teaching from that which is selfish and erroneous. Such people, especially, must be on<br />
guard against being led astray.<br />
Moo comments that “Paul warns that the false teachers are adept at deceiving the<br />
‘innocent’ (verse 18b). And he issues this warning just because the Roman Christians have such<br />
a universal reputation for being ‘obedient,’ and are in fact “innocent.” Paul rejoices in this, for it is,<br />
of course, a good quality.<br />
But at the same time, he wants them to combine this innocence with ‘wisdom’ about what<br />
is good and to confine their ‘innocence’ to what is evil. <strong>In</strong> other words, Paul is recognizing and<br />
encouraging the Roman Christians’ ‘innocence’ in one sense—their freedom from sin as a result<br />
of their obedience to the gospel message–while he subtly warns them against another kind of<br />
‘innocence’–the kind that lacks wisdom and discernment about truth and error, an inability to<br />
distinguish between genuine Christian life-style and teaching over against self-serving, non-<br />
Christian life-style and teaching.<br />
Bruce states that they should not be “so simple-minded as to swallow whatever is offered.<br />
Understood in this way, Paul probably alludes to Jesus’ saying about being ‘wise as serpents and<br />
innocent as doves’ (Matthew 10:<strong>16</strong>), for the meaning is much the same.” (P. 932)<br />
You may have thought that in becoming a Christian, you were entering into a new world of<br />
peace and light, where there are no longer any dangers, or any people with evil intentions. But<br />
such is not at all the case. <strong>In</strong> the very heart of the Christian community there are people with evil,<br />
wrong motivations--who are taking advantage of innocent, gullible people, with teachings and<br />
(continued...)<br />
869
<strong>16</strong>.19 For your obedience became known to everyone. Over you people, therefore,<br />
<strong>16</strong>05 <strong>16</strong>06 <strong>16</strong>07<br />
I rejoice; but then I want you to be wise people for the good, and then harmless for the<br />
<strong>16</strong>04<br />
(...continued)<br />
practices and life-styles that are not genuinely rooted in God’s revelation in Christ, but rather,<br />
come from their own selfish, egotistical purposes, and who are going to do everything in their<br />
power to take advantage of you and use you for themselves. Watch out! Be on guard!<br />
Wright reflects that “The blend of wisdom and innocence commended by both Paul (verse<br />
19) and Jesus (Matthew 10:<strong>16</strong>) is needed as much today as ever. Shrewdness without<br />
innocence becomes serpentine; innocence without shrewdness becomes naivete. The laudable<br />
desire to think well of everyone needs to be tempered with the recognition that some are indeed<br />
out for their own ends and are merely giving the appearance of friendliness and piety by their skill<br />
at smooth talking. Unless this is spotted early on and confronted, trouble is stored up for later, as<br />
an untreated sore is allowed to fester.” (P. 767)<br />
<strong>16</strong>05<br />
The phrase evfV u`mi/n ou=n cai,rw, eph’ humin oun chairo, “over (or ‘upon’) you people<br />
therefore I rejoice,” is read by the first writer of Sinaiticus, Alexandrinus, Vaticanus, Ephraemi<br />
Rescriptus, P, Minuscules 81, 365 and a few other Greek manuscripts.<br />
It is changed to read cai,rw ou=n evfV u`mi/n, chairo oun eph’ humin, “I rejoice therefore<br />
over (or ‘upon’) you people,” by P46, the first writer of Bezae, F, G, Minuscules 323, 1881, a few<br />
other Greek manuscripts and the entire Latin tradition.<br />
It is changed to cai,rw ou=n to. evfV u`mi/n, chairo oun to eph’ humin, “I rejoice therefore,<br />
the (i.e., ‘that is’) over (or ‘upon’) you people,” by a corrector of Sinaiticus, a corrector of Bezae,<br />
Psi, Minuscules 33, <strong>17</strong>39, the “Majority Text” and the Harclean Text.<br />
These variant readings do not change the meaning of <strong>Romans</strong>, but may indicate a<br />
problem in the primitive text.<br />
<strong>16</strong>06<br />
The phrase qe,lw de, thelo de, “but then I want,” is changed to kai. qe,lw, kai thelo,<br />
“and I want,” by the first writer of Bezae, F, G, the Old Latin Manuscript m, some manuscripts of<br />
th<br />
the Latin Vulgate and Speculum, Pseudo-Augustine (5 century A.D.).<br />
It is changed to kai. qe,lw de, kai thelo de, “and I want, then,” by P46.<br />
These variant readings do not change the meaning of <strong>Romans</strong>.<br />
<strong>16</strong>07<br />
Following the noun sofou,j, sophous, “wise people,” the intensive particle me,n, men,<br />
“therefore,” is interpolated into the text by Sinaiticus, Alexandrinus, Ephraemi Rescriptus,<br />
Minuscules 33, <strong>17</strong>39, 1881, the “Majority Text,” the Harclean Syriac and Clement of Alexandria<br />
(died before 215 A.D.).<br />
870<br />
(continued...)
<strong>16</strong>08 <strong>16</strong>09 <strong>16</strong>10 <strong>16</strong>11 <strong>16</strong>12<br />
evil. <strong>16</strong>.20 But then the God of peace will shatter the adversary beneath your feet<br />
<strong>16</strong>07<br />
(...continued)<br />
The text without this interpolation is read by P46, Vaticanus, Bezae, F, G, L, Psi,<br />
Minuscules 6, 365, 1505, some other Greek manuscripts and the entire Latin tradition.<br />
Whether read or not makes no difference for the meaning of <strong>Romans</strong>.<br />
<strong>16</strong>08<br />
Paul assures his Roman readers that he is not saying that they are anything less than<br />
genuine Christians, or that he thinks they are “almost gone.” Quite the contrary--their obedience<br />
is heralded and known throughout the Christian world, and Paul not only believes that it is a true<br />
report, but rejoices in it (compare his earlier similar statement at <strong>Romans</strong> 1:8). It is just that he<br />
wants to share with them in an in-depth way, knowing the great power and influence that already<br />
is emanating from their position in the Capital City of the Roman Empire, and that will continue to<br />
increase.<br />
Paul stresses that he wants to be very sure that they are harmless with regards to evil<br />
things, but that at the same time they are filled with wisdom concerning good things. If they<br />
should allow themselves to be led astray, it will have disastrous effects all over the first-century<br />
world, because of the great influence the City of Rome had in that world. That is why he is so<br />
concerned to issue them this warning. Compare 1 Corinthians 14:20, “Brothers, do not be<br />
children in (your) minds, but rather be like children in regards to evil things; but with your minds be<br />
full-grown.”<br />
<strong>16</strong>09<br />
This verse contains what we are calling “the great assurance.” It is that the Lord of<br />
History is at work in Jesus Christ and His Church–leading on to ultimate victory over all the forces<br />
of evil!<br />
<strong>16</strong>10<br />
Paul has found this language concerning the “God of the peace” (compare <strong>Romans</strong><br />
15:33) in the Jewish <strong>Bible</strong>. One of its basic motifs is that of the “Divine Warrior,” the great Lord<br />
of History, who fights for his people, and who uses the armies of powerful nations for the<br />
fulfillment of his purposes--both for punishing the wicked, and for overthrowing oppressors (see<br />
especially Isaiah 14:26-<strong>27</strong>, in conjunction with the overall content of chapters 13-14 concerning<br />
the overthrow of Babylon by the Medes), in the coming of YHWH’s “day,” bringing “the end” to<br />
cities, peoples, and nations.<br />
This pervasive motif, which has not been taken seriously in much modern theology, simply<br />
cannot be eliminated from the Jewish <strong>Bible</strong>. The goal in mind of the Divine Warrior is, according<br />
to the teaching of the Jewish <strong>Bible</strong> is nothing less than universal peace--~Alv', shalom in<br />
Hebrew, eivrh,nh, eirene in Greek--universal peace for all the nations of the earth. YHWH God,<br />
the Divine Warrior, is fighting in history for one great goal--that of universal peace for his people,<br />
and for all the peoples and nations of the earth. The Jewish <strong>Bible</strong> teaches that the true and<br />
living God, YHWH of Israel, is the “God of Peace”. That’s where Paul got this teaching.<br />
Compare not only <strong>Romans</strong> 15:33, but also 2 Corinthians 13:11; Philippians 4:9; 1<br />
Thessalonians 5:23 and Hebrews 13:20.<br />
871
<strong>16</strong>13 <strong>16</strong>14 <strong>16</strong>15<br />
with speed. The gracious favor of our Lord, Jesus (is) with you!<br />
<strong>16</strong>11 rd<br />
The 3 person singular, future indicative active verb suntri,yei, suntripsei, “he will<br />
shatter,” or “he will crush,” is changed to the infinitive suntri,yai, suntripsai, “to shatter,” or “to<br />
crush,” by Alexandrinus, Minuscules 365, 630, a few other Greek manuscripts, the Old Latin<br />
th<br />
Manuscripts f, g, t, the Clementine Vulgate and Speculum, Pseudo-Augustine (5 century A.D.).<br />
The variant reading hardly changes the meaning of <strong>Romans</strong>, but makes it slightly more<br />
difficult to read.<br />
<strong>16</strong>12<br />
Paul uses the noun satana/j, satanas, which has been borrowed from the Jewish<br />
<strong>Bible</strong> (the Hebrew noun means “adversary”). If the true and living God is the only God, and if this<br />
God is the Lord of History, and if he is the Divine Warrior who is fighting to the finish with all the<br />
powers of evil (and what could stand as a symbol for all of earth’s evil forces, and opponents of<br />
the people of God, other than “satan”?), then the people of God can draw this conclusion that<br />
Paul draws with certainty. Soon--very soon--the great Divine Warrior will “trample the head of<br />
satan, the great adversary.”<br />
If Jesus is King of kings, and Lord of lords, and if he holds the future in his great hands,<br />
there can be no question of what the future holds--all the powers of evil, already defeated through<br />
his conquering of death, are going down. We may be sure of that. This is the central theme of<br />
Revelation.<br />
Cranfield states that “What we have here is a promise. Paul possibly had the [Hebrew text]<br />
of Genesis 3:15 in mind...but there are other passages which should be compared: e.g. Psalm<br />
91:13; Luke 10:18-20; Testament of Simon 6:6; Testament of Levi 18:12. It is very often<br />
assumed both by those who think that the reference is to a deliverance in the ordinary course of<br />
history and those who think the reference is to the final eschatological defeat of evil that Paul<br />
must have in mind the rout of the people mentioned in verses <strong>17</strong>-18, regarded as the servants of<br />
Satan. But this is by no means clear...That the promise refers to the eschatological<br />
consummation, and not to some special divine deliverance in the course of their lives, seems to<br />
us to be virtually certain. But this does not mean that we should see in [‘shortly’] a proof that Paul<br />
was sure that the Parousia would occur within, at the most, a few decades.” (P. 803)<br />
We insist, against Cranfield’s view, that this statement should be understood in terms of<br />
the “Day of YHWH,” that great day of divine judgment, which has come many times in the past,<br />
which is imminent in every present time, and which is coming in the future. We believe that<br />
Cranfield (along with others) is “reading in” these thoughts about “final eschatological defeat,” and<br />
“eschatological consummation.” But whatever the time of the adversary’s defeat, that defeat is<br />
certain. We are on the winning team, and victory will certainly be ours!<br />
Here once again we note that Paul does not have “road-map to the future,” or a<br />
“chronological time scale” which he is following. If he means the overthrow of the Roman<br />
persecutors, the fact is that more than 200 years would go by before that persecution of<br />
Christians ceased. Paul didn’t, and we don’t, know such things about the future. What we do<br />
know is our faith–in the Lord of History, whose purposes for good and for peace will certainly<br />
come to pass. It is out of that kind of faith that Paul writes here.<br />
872
<strong>16</strong>13<br />
Georg Bertram in Theological Dictionary of the New Testament VII, discusses this<br />
matter of “crushing” evil and says the following concerning the use of the future verb in this<br />
passage: “‘The God of peace will shortly bruise Satan under your feet,’ seems to combine two<br />
ideas: the imminent eschatological shattering of Satan by God, and the rapid victory of believers<br />
over the powers of darkness as God lets them tread Satan under their feet...The image of<br />
smashing or trampling Satan is based on Genesis 3:15, as Psalm 91:13 is the basis of the idea<br />
that the righteous will tread underfoot dangerous beasts and the demonic powers embodied by<br />
them. Compare Testament of the Twelve Patriarchs, Simeon 6:6; Testament of Levi 18:12;<br />
Testament of Moses 10:1; Jubilees 23:29. <strong>In</strong> Isaiah 11:8 the battle ends and the kingdom of<br />
peace is ushered in with the treading down of the hostile forces. For the Christian community<br />
Jesus Himself is the dragon-slayer.” (P. 924)<br />
Bertram wants to make all of this “eschatological” (as does Cranfield--see the preceding<br />
footnote), but nothing concerning the “eschaton” or “final end of time” is said in this passage.<br />
Rather, this passage expresses the very common conviction found throughout biblical literature,<br />
that God is the Lord of History, and that all the powers of evil both are being overcome, and will<br />
ultimately be overcome by the divine aid and victory that God unfailingly gives to his people, not at<br />
the very moment that they desire it, but in his own good time.<br />
The enemies faced by the Roman Christians, in the form of official persecutions that would<br />
soon arise, leading to the deaths of many innocent believers (especially in the City of Rome) and<br />
to the necessity of their clandestine worship in the catacombs in the next two and a half centuries,<br />
would not by any means be the final word in history. Rather, their “adversary” (we should think in<br />
terms of the great “beasts” out of the sea and out of the land along with the scarlet prostitute<br />
riding on the back of a monstrous dragon, in Revelation 13-18)--all symbolizing the Roman<br />
Empire with its life-threatening attack on the Christians at the close of the first century, would<br />
soon be broken, even if that “quickly” was to involve over two centuries of suffering. Paul’s words<br />
here truly have a deep theological relationship with the overall message of Revelation. This is<br />
what we are calling “the great assurance.”<br />
<strong>16</strong>14<br />
Following the name Jesus, the genitive singular noun Cristou/, Christou, “of Christ,” is<br />
interpolated into the text by Alexandrinus, Ephraemi Rescriptus, Psi, Minuscules 33, <strong>17</strong>39, the<br />
“Majority Text,” the Latin Vulgate, a part of the Old Latin witnesses, the Syriac tradition and the<br />
Coptic tradition.<br />
The text without this interpolation is read by P46, Sinaiticus, Vaticanus, Minuscule 1881<br />
and a few other Greek manuscripts.<br />
This is the kind of textual variant that is seen oftentimes when mention is made of Jesus.<br />
Whether read or not makes no difference for the meaning of <strong>Romans</strong>.<br />
<strong>16</strong>15<br />
The last phrase of verse 20, ~H ca,rij tou/ kuri,ou h`mw/n VIhsou/ meqV u`mw/n, He charis<br />
tou kuriou hemon Iesou meth’ humon, “The gracious favor of the Lord of ours (is, or may it be)<br />
with you people,” is omitted by the first writer of Bezae (probably), F, G, the Old Latin Manuscript<br />
873<br />
(continued...)
<strong>16</strong>15<br />
(...continued)<br />
m and a few manuscripts of the Latin Vulgate. See verse 23 where this phrase is added into the<br />
text at its close.<br />
The statement sounds very much like Paul is bringing his letter to a close, with what is<br />
called in Latin a subscriptio, a “signature,” or “note below.” As Moo notes, “Paul’s prayer-wish<br />
that ‘the grace of the Lord Jesus be with you’ finds a parallel in every other letter he wrote; and it<br />
also takes us back to the beginning of the letter (compare 1:7).” (P. 933)<br />
Cranfield notes that “The ordinary concluding greeting written by the sender of a letter in<br />
his own hand as subscription was ev ,rrwso , erroso, or ev ,rrwsqe, errosthe, [‘farewell,’ ‘goodbye’].<br />
Just as Paul did with the epistolary prescript, so he also transformed the subscription into a<br />
vehicle of specifically Christian and theological content...<strong>In</strong> every concluding greeting in the<br />
Pauline corpus the word ca,rij, charis [‘gracious favor,’ or ‘grace’] occurs.” (P. 804)<br />
If it be true, as Paul and the Roman Christians believe it to be, that God has revealed<br />
unbelievably great mercy and grace for all humanity in Christ Jesus, what greater wish could Paul<br />
make for the <strong>Romans</strong> than simply this: that the gracious favor of our Lord Jesus be with them?<br />
Because, as Paul has emphasized in <strong>Romans</strong> 8, if the Lord is for us, who can be against us?<br />
874
GREETINGS BY PAUL’S FRIENDS, AND A DOXOLOGY<br />
<strong>Romans</strong> <strong>16</strong>:21-<strong>27</strong>, Greek Text with Translation<br />
<strong>16</strong>.21 VAspa,zetai u`ma/j Timo,qeoj o` sunergo,j mou kai. Lou,kioj kai. VIa,swn kai.<br />
Swsi,patroj oi` suggenei/j mouÅ<br />
Timothy the fellow-worker of mine greets you, also Lucius and Jason and Sosipater, the<br />
kinsmen of mine.<br />
<strong>16</strong>.22 vAspa,zomai u`ma/j evgw. Te,rtioj o` gra,yaj th.n evpistolh.n evn kuri,w|Å<br />
I greet you, I Tertius, the one who wrote the letter in (the) Lord.<br />
<strong>16</strong>.23 vAspa,zetai u`ma/j Ga,i?oj o` xe,noj mou kai. o[lhj th/j evkklhsi,ajÅ<br />
Gaius the host of mine greets you people, and the whole assembly.<br />
<strong>16</strong>.24 VAspa,zetai u`ma/j :Erastoj o` oivkono,moj th/j po,lewj kai. Kou,artoj o` avdelfo,jÅ<br />
Erastus the Manager of the city greets you, also Quartus the brother. <strong>16</strong>.24<br />
<strong>16</strong>.25 ÎTw/ | de. duname,nw| u`ma/j sthri,xai kata. to. euvagge,lio,n mou kai. to. kh,rugma<br />
VIhsou/ Cristou/( kata. avpoka,luyin musthri,ou cro,noij aivwni,oij sesighme,nou( <strong>16</strong>.26<br />
fanerwqe,ntoj de. nu/n dia, te grafw/n profhtikw/n katV evpitagh.n tou/ aivwni,ou qeou/ eivj<br />
u`pakoh.n pi,stewj eivj pa,nta ta. e;qnh gnwrisqe,ntoj( <strong>16</strong>.<strong>27</strong> mo,nw| sofw/ | qew/ |( dia. VIhsou/<br />
Cristou/( w-| h` do,xa eivj tou.j aivw/naj( avmh,nÅÐ<br />
[Now then to the One being able to establish you people, according to the good news of<br />
mine, and the proclamation of Jesus Christ, according to a disclosure of a mystery for long-lasting<br />
times having been kept silent, but then now having been made known through both<br />
spokesperson-like writings, according to command of the long-lasting God, for obedience of faith<br />
in all the nations, having been made known; to (the) only wise God, through Jesus, Christ, to<br />
whom (belongs) the glorious radiance into the ages, truly.]<br />
GREETINGS BY PAUL’S FRIENDS, AND A DOXOLOGY<br />
<strong>Romans</strong> <strong>16</strong>:21-<strong>27</strong>, Translation with Footnotes<br />
<strong>16</strong><strong>16</strong> <strong>16</strong><strong>17</strong> <strong>16</strong>18 <strong>16</strong>19 <strong>16</strong>20<br />
<strong>16</strong>.21 Timothy, the fellow-worker of mine greets you, also Lucius and<br />
<strong>16</strong><strong>16</strong><br />
Cranfield holds that “...the greetings in verses 21-23, are a postscript added in the hand<br />
of Tertius after Paul’s autograph, subscriptio [‘signature’] (verse 20b), and are, not Paul’s, but<br />
his companions’ greetings.” (P. 797) This may be the case, but the language of verse 21<br />
(continued...)<br />
875
<strong>16</strong><strong>16</strong><br />
(...continued)<br />
continues to sound like Paul’s own language, especially the phrase concerning Timothy being “my<br />
fellow-worker,” and the description of Lucius, Jason and Sosipater as “my kinsmen.”<br />
<strong>16</strong><strong>17</strong> st<br />
The 1 person singular genitive pronoun mou, mou, “of mine,” is omitted by Vaticanus,<br />
Minuscules 6, <strong>17</strong>39 and a few other Greek manuscripts.<br />
The omission hardly changes the meaning of <strong>Romans</strong>, but makes the text less specific as<br />
to whose fellow-worker Timothy was. Perhaps this omission was caused by the copyists’ sense<br />
that Paul’s part of the letter is ended, and this is the language of Tertius.<br />
<strong>16</strong>18 rd<br />
The 3 person singular present indicative active verb avspa,zetai, aspazetai, “he<br />
greets,” is read by P46, Sinaiticus, Alexandrinus, Vaticanus, Ephraemi Rescriptus, the first<br />
writer of Bezae, F, G, P, Psi, Minuscules 81, 365, 630, 1505, <strong>17</strong>39, 1881, some other Greek<br />
manuscripts, the Latin Vulgate, a part of the Old Latin witnesses and the Harclean Syriac.<br />
rd<br />
It is changed to the 3 person plural form of the verb, avspa,zontai, aspazontai, “they<br />
greet,” by a corrector of Bezae, Minuscule 33, the “Majority Text,” a few manuscripts of the Latin<br />
Vulgate and the Peshitta Syriac.<br />
The change to the plural is caused by the fact that additional subjects are mentioned in the<br />
continuation of the verse, and the copyists are correcting the original grammar of the text.<br />
<strong>16</strong>19<br />
Paul’s expressions of greeting to the <strong>Romans</strong> have ended, and now his companions join<br />
in such an expression, as a sort of “postscript” to his letter. The first to be mentioned is Timothy,<br />
whom we know as Paul’s long-time associate--see <strong>Romans</strong> <strong>16</strong>:3 and 9.<br />
Moo comments that “Timothy, whom Paul simply introduces here as ‘my fellow worker’<br />
(compare also verses 3 and 9), was Paul’s closest ministry associate...He was...with Paul during<br />
his Roman imprisonment and worked with the apostle after his release in the eastern<br />
Mediterranean again (compare 1 and 2 Timothy). As this verse makes clear, then, Timothy was<br />
with Paul during his stay in Greece at the end of the third missionary journey (compare Acts 20:3-<br />
4). Timothy’s importance can be gauged from the fact that Paul introduces him as ‘co-author’ of<br />
six of his letters (2 Corinthians; 1 Thessalonians; 2 Thessalonians; Philippians; Colossians;<br />
Philemon).” (P. 934)<br />
Moo’s conclusion that Paul was released from imprisonment in Rome, and continued his<br />
ministry in the eastern Mediterranean is controversial, based only on statements in Titus 1:5, that<br />
Paul had left Titus in Crete, and then Titus 3:12, asking Titus to come to him in Nicopolis, a city in<br />
Greece. Too little is known for sure concerning the date of writing of the Pastoral Epistles (1 and<br />
2 Timothy, Titus) to be certain concerning Paul’s release from Roman imprisonment after two<br />
years.<br />
<strong>16</strong>20<br />
Who is this Lou,kioj, Loukios, or “Lucius” as it is commonly spelled in English? Can<br />
this be Louka/j, Loukas, “Luke,” the “beloved physician,” and author of Luke-Acts? We have<br />
(continued...)<br />
876
<strong>16</strong>21 <strong>16</strong>22 <strong>16</strong>23<br />
Jason and Sosipater, the kinsmen of mine.<br />
<strong>16</strong>20<br />
(...continued)<br />
met an earlier Lou,kioj, Loukios, at Acts 13:1. Is this the same person? We are inclined to<br />
answer each of these questions in the affirmative, thinking that Lou,kioj, Loukios, is the same<br />
name as Louka/j, Loukas, which is an affectionate or “pet-name” for Lou,kioj, Loukios.<br />
<strong>In</strong> the nature of the case, there can be no proof of this, but it seems to be a reasonable<br />
and possible interpretation of the evidence. F. F. Bruce rejects this identification (pp. 264-65),<br />
while Moo thinks that such an identification is very likely (p. 934).<br />
<strong>16</strong>21<br />
The name VIa,swn, Iason, is frequently found in first century literature, and in the<br />
Septuagint as well. See 1 Maccabees 8:<strong>17</strong>; 12:<strong>16</strong>; 14:22; 2 Maccabees 1:7; 2:23; 4:7, 13, 19,<br />
22, 23, 24, 26; 5:5, 6; 4 Maccabees 4:<strong>16</strong>; Acts <strong>17</strong>:5, 6, 7, 9 and here, <strong>Romans</strong> <strong>16</strong>:21.<br />
BAGD states that “It was a favorite practice among Jews to substitute the purely Greek<br />
name VIa,swn, Iason for the Jewish-Greek Ihsou/j, Iesous, (‘Jesus’). <strong>In</strong> the New Testament there<br />
is a person by this name who is the host of Paul and Silas in Thessalonica (Acts <strong>17</strong>:5-7, 9); then<br />
this person who sends a greeting from Corinth to Rome in <strong>Romans</strong> <strong>16</strong>:21; and last, the name<br />
VIa,swni, Iasoni, is found as a variant reading for Mna,swni, Mnasoni, in Acts 21:<strong>16</strong> in the<br />
Codex Sinaiticus and in the Bohairic translation.” (P. 368) Moo holds that this Jason “is very<br />
likely the Jason who gave hospitality to Paul during his brief and tumultuous stay in<br />
Thessalonica.” (P. 934)<br />
<strong>16</strong>22<br />
The name Swsi,patroj, Sosipatros, is found in inscriptions from Athens and in 2<br />
Maccabees 12:19 and 24. He may well be the same person called Sw,patroj, Sopatros, a<br />
Christian in Berea, who was a companion of Paul on his last journey to Jerusalem according to<br />
Acts 20:4. The prefix Sws-, Sos- added to the common Greek noun for “father” would imply a<br />
meaning such as “Saving Father,” or “Healthy Father.”<br />
<strong>16</strong>23<br />
Following the phrase, “my kinsmen,” the following phrase is interpolated into the text:<br />
kai. ai` ev,kklhsi,ai pa/sai tou/ Cristou/, kai hai ekklesiai pasai tou Christou, “and the<br />
assemblies, all (of them), of the Christ,” by the first writer of Bezae, F, G, the Old Latin<br />
manuscripts a, m and Pelagius (who died after 418 A.D.).<br />
This is the phrase that is found at the close of verse <strong>16</strong>, and that has been omitted there<br />
by these same witnesses, except for the Old Latin manuscript a and Pelagius.<br />
For this phrase suggenei/j mou, suggeneis mou, compare <strong>Romans</strong> 9:3 (where Paul calls<br />
the Jews tw/n avdelfw/n mou tw/n suggenw/n mou kata. sa,rka, ton adelphon mou ton<br />
suggenon mou kata sarka, “the brothers of mine, the kinsmen of mine according to flesh“); <strong>16</strong>:7,<br />
11, and 21.<br />
Are we to understand that these four co-workers of Paul, Timothy, Loukios, Jason, and<br />
Sosipatros, were all members of his physical family, i.e., brothers and cousins, possibly uncles?<br />
(continued...)<br />
877
<strong>16</strong>24 <strong>16</strong>25<br />
<strong>16</strong>.22 I greet you, I Tertius, the one wrote the letter in (the) Lord.<br />
<strong>16</strong>26 <strong>16</strong><strong>27</strong> <strong>16</strong>28 <strong>16</strong>29<br />
<strong>16</strong>.23 Gaius the host of mine greets you people, and the whole assembly.<br />
<strong>16</strong>23<br />
(...continued)<br />
Their names are uniformly Greek names, leading to the conclusion that they were not Jewish like<br />
Paul, and therefore not members of his “Jewish family.”<br />
Can Paul mean that they were so close to him, that they had become “like family” to him?<br />
We can sense in this language of <strong>Romans</strong> <strong>16</strong> how the “family language” inherited by Paul from<br />
Israel and his Jewish roots, is being transformed into a new family language for the “New Israel,”<br />
the new people of God.<br />
<strong>16</strong>24<br />
The name Te,rtioj, Tertios, is changed to the name Tere,ntioj, Terentios by<br />
Minuscule 7.<br />
Here another author other than Paul himself breaks unexpectedly into the letter--it is<br />
Tertios, who immediately identifies himself as the writer of the letter, that is as the one who is the<br />
stenographer (“amanuensis,” one writing “by hand”) for Paul, listening to Paul as he dictates the<br />
words of <strong>Romans</strong>, and then writing them on the papyrus or leather-skin on which the original<br />
manuscript was written.<br />
Compare 1 Corinthians <strong>16</strong>:21 (“the greeting is in my own hand–Paul”; Galatians 6:11<br />
(“see with what large letters I am writing to you with my own hand”); Colossians 4:18 (“I, Paul,<br />
write this greeting with my own hand”) and especially 2 Thessalonians 3:<strong>17</strong> (“I, Paul, write this<br />
greeting with my own hand, and this is a distinguishing mark in every letter; this is the way I<br />
write”). Statements such as this point clearly to the “human element” in the writing of the biblical<br />
materials. There is no claim that these writings have come down directly from heaven (as is<br />
claimed for the Book of Mormon, or for the Koran), but they have come through human authors<br />
and their assistants.<br />
<strong>16</strong>25<br />
The phrase “in (the) Lord” can be read with what goes before it, or with what comes<br />
after it. That is, it may mean “I Tertios, who wrote the letter in the Lord,” i.e., with the Lord’s<br />
constant presence and help; or it may mean “<strong>In</strong> (the) Lord, Gaius our host greets you people.” It<br />
seems best to construe the phrase with what goes before; but the reference may be that Gaius<br />
“greets them ‘in the Lord.’”<br />
<strong>16</strong>26<br />
The masculine name Ga,i?oj, Gaios is found frequently in non-biblical Greek writings,<br />
and in the Greek New Testament we find it at Acts 19:29 (a man from Macedonia, who was<br />
Paul’s companion in Ephesus; Acts 20:4 (a man from Derbe); 1 Corinthians 1:14 (a man from<br />
Corinth whom Paul admits having immersed; this may well be the person mentioned here, since<br />
<strong>Romans</strong> was written from Corinth); 3 John 1 (the man to whom this tiny letter is addressed); and<br />
in the “Apostolic Fathers,” Martyrdom of Polycarp 22:2 (the name of the copyist of that writing;<br />
see also its epilogue, Epilogus Mosquensis 1:4).<br />
<strong>16</strong><strong>27</strong><br />
The nominative masculine singular adjective xe,noj, Ksenos has various meanings<br />
including “strange,” “foreign,” “alien,” and as used here, a substantive meaning “host,” or “friend,”<br />
(continued...)<br />
878
<strong>16</strong>30 <strong>16</strong>31 <strong>16</strong>32 <strong>16</strong>33 <strong>16</strong>34<br />
Erastus the Manager of the city greets you, also Quartus the brother. <strong>16</strong>.24<br />
<strong>16</strong><strong>27</strong><br />
(...continued)<br />
one who extends hospitality.<br />
<strong>16</strong>28<br />
The phrase o[lhj th/j evkklhsi,aj, holes tes ekklesias, literally, “whole of the assembly<br />
(or, ‘church’),” is changed to the phrase o[lai ai` evkklhsi,ai, holai hai ekklesiai, “wholes of the<br />
assemblies (or, ‘churches’)” by F, G, the Old Latin Manuscripts a (see), b (see), the Clementine<br />
Vulgate (see) and Pelagius (died after 418 A.D.; see).<br />
This variant reading hardly changes the meaning of <strong>Romans</strong>. It refers to the church in<br />
Corinth, Paul’s location while writing <strong>Romans</strong>. But whether it refers to the entire church in<br />
Corinth, or only the house-church that met in the house of Paul’s host, is unclear.<br />
<strong>16</strong>29<br />
The text is ambiguous at this point. Is Tertios continuing to write here in verse 23, or<br />
has he once again taken up words which Paul is dictating? Either may be true, but we think it<br />
most probable that this is Tertios’ continuing statement. However this ambiguity is resolved, the<br />
statement Gaios has been a “host” to the one writing.<br />
<strong>16</strong>30<br />
This masculine name :Erastoj, Erastos, like many of the names in this chapter, is<br />
also found frequently in the Greek inscriptions and literature. BAGD mentions that “A Latin<br />
inscription from Corinth...mentions an official named Erastos.” (P. 306) There is also an Erastos<br />
who is pictured as a traveling companion of Paul in Acts 19:21-22; and see also 2 Timothy 4:20.<br />
<strong>16</strong>31<br />
We have noted that many of the names mentioned in <strong>Romans</strong> <strong>16</strong> are names commonly<br />
associated with slaves and freedmen. But here we have a man of prominence--Erastos, o`<br />
oivkono,moj th/j po,lewj, ho oikonomos tes poleos, literally “the manager of the city,” or “City-<br />
Manager.”<br />
<strong>16</strong>32<br />
The name, Kou,artoj, Kouartos, is only found here in the Greek New Testament.<br />
<strong>16</strong>33<br />
Why is Kouartos identified as “the brother”? Is it because he behaves in a “brotherly”<br />
fashion to others? Or does the statement mean “The brother of Erastos”? There is simply no<br />
way to definitely answer such questions. Moo thinks this “identifies him as a fellow believer.” (P.<br />
936)<br />
<strong>16</strong>34<br />
Many later Greek manuscripts include verse 24 at this point, following the word<br />
“brother,” ~H ca,rij tou/ kuri,ou h`mw/n VIhsou/ Cristou/ meta. pa,ntwn u`mw/n, avmh,n, He charis<br />
tou kuriou hemon Iesou Christou meta panton humon, amen. “The gracious favor of the Lord<br />
of ours, Jesus Christ, (is, or may he be) with all of you people, truly,” taken from 2 Thessalonians<br />
3:18, by Psi, Minuscule 1881, the “Majority Text” and the Harclean Syriac (and these witnesses<br />
then place <strong>16</strong>:25-<strong>27</strong> at the close of 14:23.<br />
Verse 24 is changed to read ~H ca,rij tou/ kuri,ou h`mw/n/ meta. pa,ntwn u`mw/n, avmh,n, “The<br />
gracious favor of the Lord of ours (is, or may it be) with all you people, truly,” with the omission of<br />
verses 25-<strong>27</strong>, is read by F, G and Minuscule 629. The verse is read the same, but with verses<br />
(continued...)<br />
879
<strong>16</strong>35 <strong>16</strong>36 <strong>16</strong>37<br />
[<strong>16</strong>.25 Now then to the One being able to establish you people, according to the<br />
<strong>16</strong>34<br />
(...continued)<br />
25-<strong>27</strong> added by Bezae, Minuscule 630 (see), some other Greek manuscripts, the Old Latin<br />
Manuscript a and the Clementine Vulgate.<br />
The verse is read the same, but placed after verses 25-<strong>27</strong> by P, Minuscules 33, 104, 365,<br />
a few other Greek manuscripts, the Peshitta Syriac, a few manuscripts of the Bohairic Coptic and<br />
Ambrosiaster (366-384 A.D.).<br />
The text is read without verse 24, and with verses 25-<strong>27</strong>, by P46 (but verses 25-<strong>27</strong> are<br />
placed at the end of 15:33), P61, Sinaiticus (see), Alexandrinus (see), Vaticanus, Ephraemi<br />
Rescriptus, Minuscules 81, <strong>17</strong>39, 2464, a few other Greek manuscripts, the Old Latin<br />
Manuscript b, the Stuttgartiensis Latin Vulgate and the Coptic tradition.<br />
Verse 24 is read by King James and New King James; it is read, but in italics, by New<br />
American Standard; it is omitted by both New <strong>In</strong>ternational and New Revised Standard.<br />
These variant readings demonstrate a problem felt by copyists regarding the actual ending<br />
of <strong>Romans</strong>. See the next footnote.<br />
<strong>16</strong>35<br />
Verses 25-<strong>27</strong> are omitted by F, G, Minuscule 629 and by some manuscripts of Jerome<br />
(who died 420 A.D.).<br />
They are placed at the end of 14:23 by Psi, Uncial Manuscript 0209 (probably), the<br />
“Majority Text,” the Old Latin Manuscript m (probably), the Harclean Syriac and by some Latin<br />
manuscripts of Origen of Alexandria’s works (Origen died 254 A.D.).<br />
They are placed at the end of 15:33 by P46.<br />
They are placed at the end of 14:23 and at the end of 15:33, but with the omission of <strong>16</strong>:1-<br />
24, by Minuscule 1506.<br />
They are read both here and at the end of 14:23 by Alexandrinus, P, Minuscules 33,<br />
104, 2805 and a few other Greek manuscripts.<br />
They are read here and nowhere else by P61, Sinaiticus, Vaticanus, Ephraemi<br />
Rescriptus, Bezae, Minuscules 81, 365, 630, <strong>17</strong>39, 2464, some other Greek manuscripts, the<br />
Old Latin Manuscripts a, b, the Latin Vulgate, the Peshitta Syriac, the Coptic tradition, some Latin<br />
manuscripts of the works of Origen of Alexandria (who died 254 A.D.) and Ambrosiaster (366-384<br />
A.D.).<br />
This constitutes perhaps the most difficult textual problem in <strong>Romans</strong>. We think that the<br />
various locations in which the doxology is found in different manuscripts indicates that <strong>Romans</strong><br />
was most probably issued in differing formats to different locations, in which the ending of the<br />
letter varied.<br />
(continued...)<br />
880
<strong>16</strong>35<br />
(...continued)<br />
Metzger (p. 540) states that “While recognizing the possibility that the doxology [vv. 25-<strong>27</strong>]<br />
may not have been part of the original form of the epistle, on the strength of impressive<br />
manuscript evidence...the Committee decided to include the verses at their traditional place in the<br />
epistle, but enclosed within square brackets [i.e., to indicate uncertainty as to their originality]...”<br />
On pp. 533-36 Metzger states that “Paul may have made two copies of the Epistle, one<br />
with and one without chapter <strong>16</strong> (chapters 1-15 being sent to Rome and chapters 1-<strong>16</strong> to<br />
Ephesus).<br />
“According to the generally accepted interpretation of Origen’s statement in his<br />
Commentary on <strong>Romans</strong>...Marcion eliminated chapters 15 and <strong>16</strong> from his edition of <strong>Romans</strong>.<br />
“The doxology (‘Now to him who is able to strengthen you...be glory for evermore through<br />
Jesus Christ...’) varies in location; traditionally it has been printed at the close of chapter <strong>16</strong> as<br />
verses 25-<strong>27</strong>), but in some witnesses it occurs at the close of chapter 14, and in another witness<br />
(P46) at the close of chapter 15. Moreover, several witnesses have it at the close of both<br />
chapter 14 and chapter <strong>16</strong>, and in others it does not occur at all...<br />
“It is further to be observed that the benediction (‘The grace of our Lord Jesus Christ be<br />
with you [all]’) is found sometimes after <strong>16</strong>:20, sometimes after <strong>16</strong>:23, and sometimes in both<br />
places. <strong>In</strong> the last case it is found under three conditions: (1) before the doxology, (2) without it,<br />
(3) after it...<br />
“<strong>In</strong> evaluating the complicated evidence, the Committee was prepared to allow (1) for the<br />
probability that Marcion, or his followers, circulated a shortened form of the epistle, lacking<br />
chapters 15 and <strong>16</strong>, and (2) for the possibility that Paul himself had dispatched a longer and a<br />
shorter form of the epistle (one form with, and one without, chapter <strong>16</strong>). Furthermore, it was<br />
acknowledged that, to some extent, the multiplicity of locations at which the doxology appears in<br />
the several witnesses, as well as the occurrence in it of several expressions that have been<br />
regarded as non-Pauline, raise suspicions that the doxology may be non-Pauline. At the same<br />
time, however, on the basis of good and diversified evidence...it was decided to include the<br />
doxology at its traditional place at the close of the epistle, but enclosed within square brackets to<br />
indicate a degree of uncertainty that it belongs there...”<br />
See Cranfield’s discussion on pp. 5-11. Cranfield concludes that “While it would be rash<br />
indeed to assert that Paul could not have written [verses 25-<strong>27</strong>], it strikes us as much more likely<br />
to be post-Pauline...<strong>In</strong> any case, placed where it now is, it seems to us to form a not unworthy,<br />
even if non-Pauline, doxological appendix to Paul’s most weighty epistle.” (P. 809) See Moo’s<br />
discussion in his footnote 2 on pp. 936-37.<br />
Moo notes that the doxology “deliberately echoes...the language and themes of the letter,<br />
and particularly its opening section:<br />
881<br />
(continued...)
<strong>16</strong>35<br />
(...continued)<br />
‘who is able’ (power) compare 1:4, <strong>16</strong><br />
‘strengthen you’ 1:11<br />
‘(my) gospel’ 1:1, 9, <strong>16</strong>; compare 2:<strong>16</strong><br />
‘revelation’ / ‘manifested’ 1:<strong>17</strong>; 3:21<br />
‘prophetical writings’ 1:2; 3:21<br />
‘obedience of faith’ 1:5<br />
‘all the nations (Gentiles)’<br />
1:5 and throughout<br />
‘only God’ 3:39-30<br />
‘wise God’ 11:33-36<br />
“Prominent here again is the theme of the revelation of the gospel as the pinnacle of<br />
salvation history and as a message of universal applicability...Paul clearly intends to stimulate the<br />
Roman Christians’ praise of God by reminding them of what he has told them of God’s wonderful<br />
plan for their salvation in Jesus Christ...Verses 2-25 are one long incomplete sentence.” (Pp.<br />
937-38)<br />
Wright comments that “After a book like this, written by a strongly monotheistic Jew, a<br />
doxology is just what we should expect. And Paul is a Jesus-centered monotheist...A doxology<br />
that remains monotheistic while having Jesus at the middle of it, even at the cost of verbal clarity,<br />
is somehow exactly right.” (P. 768)<br />
<strong>16</strong>36<br />
Language very similar to this opening of the doxology in verses 25-<strong>27</strong> is to be found in<br />
the following passages:<br />
Acts 20:32, ”Now I commend you to God, and to the Word of his gracious favor, to the one who is<br />
able to build up and give the inheritance...”<br />
Ephesians 3:20, “Now to the one who is able to do exceedingly beyond the things we ask or<br />
think, according to his power which is working in us...”<br />
Jude 1:24, “Now to the one who is able to guard you people without blemish, and to enable (you)<br />
to stand before his glorious radiance without spot while rejoicing...”<br />
This affirmation of God’s “power” is not something new or original to the Christian faith.<br />
Quite the contrary is true. The Jewish <strong>Bible</strong> constantly speaks of the inability, the lack of power<br />
of human beings to accomplish their most desired goals--but at the same time points to the great<br />
and powerful God who can “do all things.”<br />
Reading all the passages in the Septuagint where the verb duna,mai, dunamai occurs<br />
impresses the reader with the low estimate in the Jewish <strong>Bible</strong> of human power and ability. But<br />
at the same time, that weakness and inability are set in the light of the exalted and hidden God,<br />
who can accomplish all things, and who imparts his power to those who seek him--see Genesis<br />
19:19; Job 10:13; 42:2; Wisdom of Solomon 7:<strong>27</strong>; 12:18; <strong>16</strong>:13; Daniel 3:29; 8:18 and 11:13.<br />
Of course, these verses only have to do with the use of this particular verb, and there are<br />
(continued...)<br />
882
<strong>16</strong>36<br />
(...continued)<br />
numerous passages that speak of God’s great ability and power without using this verb, beginning<br />
with the story of the exodus of the Jews from under the power of Pharaoh, who is overwhelmed<br />
by the superior might and power of YHWH God. Human beings are at their strongest, very weak<br />
and fallible. But not so with the God they serve–our God is capable of all things!<br />
<strong>In</strong> the Spokespersons of Israel, the almighty power of YHWH God over against the rulers<br />
of Assyria and Babylon and Persia is made very explicit. YHWH God is the one, the only one<br />
who, is able to accomplish whatever he desires. He is the one who “comes with the clouds” of<br />
judgment and deliverance throughout history, overturning the wicked empires and their egomaniac<br />
rulers, bringing in a new day of peace and hope for the humble, persecuted peoples of<br />
the earth. This is the God who has come to us in Jesus Christ, winning eternal victory over the<br />
powers of evil, bringing in the new day of peace and hope for all peoples upon the earth. Now,<br />
the risen Lord, sitting at the “right hand of power,” will continue to come throughout human history,<br />
furthering that victory to completion (with the initial example of his “coming” that of the destruction<br />
of Jerusalem and its temple in 70 A.D.).<br />
<strong>16</strong>37<br />
The aorist active infinitive verb sthri,xai, steriksai, means “to set up,” “to fix firmly,” “to<br />
establish.”<br />
The verb is found at Luke 9:51, used for Jesus’ fixed determination to go up to face death<br />
in Jerusalem; at Luke 22:32, where the risen Jesus tells Peter that when he has turned himself<br />
around, he is to “establish his brothers.” <strong>In</strong> <strong>Romans</strong> 1:11, Paul expresses his wish to come to<br />
Rome “so that I may give to you people spiritual gifts, in order to establish you...”<br />
<strong>In</strong> 1 Thessalonians 3:2 Paul says that he has sent Timothy to them, “in order to establish<br />
you people...” <strong>In</strong> 1 Thessalonians 3:13, in language very similar to this doxology in <strong>Romans</strong> <strong>16</strong>,<br />
Paul expresses the wish that God “...may so establish your hearts in set-apartness that you may<br />
be blameless before our God and Father at the presence of our Lord Jesus with all his set-apart<br />
people.” <strong>In</strong> 2 Thessalonians 2:<strong>16</strong>-<strong>17</strong> there is a doxology similar to this one in <strong>Romans</strong> <strong>16</strong>, which<br />
includes the words, “Now may our Lord Jesus Christ himself and God our Father, who loved us<br />
and through gracious favor gave us eternal comfort and good hope, comfort your hearts and<br />
establish them in every good work and word.” 2 Thessalonians 3:3 states, “Now the Lord is<br />
faithful, who will establish you people and will protect from the evil one.”<br />
Jacob (“James”) 5:8 urges the readers to “establish your hearts, because the presence of<br />
the Lord has drawn near.” 1 Peter 5:10-11, in language similar to <strong>Romans</strong> <strong>16</strong> states, “Now the<br />
God of all merciful favor, the one who called you people into his long-lasting glorious radiance in<br />
Christ [Jesus], when you have suffered a little, he himself will make complete, establish,<br />
strengthen, and found you people. To him be the strength (kra,toj, kratos) into the long ages--<br />
truly.” Compare also 2 Peter 1:12 and Revelation 3:2.<br />
Here again (as we have shown in the preceding footnote), this is not something original<br />
with the Christian faith--but rather, the Jewish <strong>Bible</strong> sometimes uses this same verb to speak of<br />
God’s ability to “establish” his people. See Exodus <strong>17</strong>:12; Psalm 51:12; 104:15; 112:8;<br />
(continued...)<br />
883
<strong>16</strong>38 <strong>16</strong>39<br />
good news of mine, and the proclamation of Jesus Christ, according to a disclosure of a<br />
<strong>16</strong>40<br />
mystery for long-lasting times having been kept secret, <strong>16</strong>.26 but then now having been made<br />
<strong>16</strong>37<br />
(...continued)<br />
Proverbs 15:25; Song of Solomon 2:5; Isaiah 59:<strong>16</strong>; Jeremiah <strong>17</strong>:5; 21:10; 24:6; Ezekiel 6:2;<br />
13:<strong>17</strong>; 14:8; 15:7; 21:2; 21:7; 25:2; 29:2; 38:2; Daniel 7:28; Amos 9:4; 1 Maccabees 2:<strong>17</strong>;<br />
14:14, 26; Ben Sirach 3:9; 5:10; 13:21; 15:4; 22:<strong>16</strong>; 24:10; 38:34 (the farmers, craftsmen and<br />
workers–smiths, potters keep stable or establish the fabric of the world); 39:32; 40:19; 42:<strong>17</strong>.<br />
Much more than the use of this same verb, however, is the constant teaching of the<br />
Jewish <strong>Bible</strong> that in YHWH God his people find a “broad place” in which to stand, and are<br />
established in a condition of peace and rest. This is what this doxology requests for all the people<br />
of Christ, the “New Israel.”<br />
<strong>16</strong>38<br />
The phrase “my good news” or “our good news” is found in Paul’s writings at <strong>Romans</strong><br />
2:<strong>16</strong> (“my good news”); <strong>16</strong>:25 (here); 2 Corinthians 4:3; 1 Thessalonians 1:5; 2 Thessalonians<br />
2:14 (“our good news”); 2 Timothy 2:8 (“my good news”).<br />
Sanday and Headlam comment concerning Paul’s use of the phrase “my good news,” that<br />
“St. Paul did not look upon this as antagonistic to the common faith of the Church, but as<br />
complementary to and explanatory of it.” (P. 433)<br />
It is true that Paul’s proclamation and teaching are in some ways different from the<br />
proclamation and teaching of either Jacob (“James”) or Peter (1 and 2 Peter); but all of them<br />
proclaim the same good news of Jesus as Lord, and they are simply variations on the same basic<br />
tune. Paul may center his teaching on the resurrection of Jesus, while Jacob (“James”) says little<br />
on that subject; Peter may find things in Paul’s teaching that are difficult to understand (2 Peter<br />
3:14-<strong>16</strong>), but nonetheless, they all share in the one basic message, the good news of God’s<br />
mighty act of salvation in Jesus Christ.<br />
<strong>16</strong>39<br />
For this phrase, “the proclamation (or ‘preaching) of Jesus Christ,” compare the<br />
following passages: Matthew 12:41 and Luke 11:32 (“the preaching of Jonah”); Mark <strong>16</strong>, shorter<br />
ending (“the preaching of eternal salvation”); 1 Corinthians 1:21 (“the foolishness of the<br />
preaching”); 2:4 (“my preaching”); 15:14 (“our preaching”); 2 Timothy 4:<strong>17</strong> (“the preaching”);<br />
Titus 1:3 (“his word through preaching”). Here, we think, the meaning is not the preaching that<br />
Jesus Christ did himself, but the preaching that is centered in Jesus Christ.<br />
This exact phrase is unique, and not to be found elsewhere in the Greek New Testament.<br />
However, the noun by itself, without the entire phrase, is found there, and it is the kind of phrase<br />
that fits in well with Pauline understanding.<br />
<strong>16</strong>40<br />
The noun musth,rion, musterion is used to describe the content of the good news,<br />
formerly kept silent or hidden, but now revealed. This noun is found in the Septuagint some 31<br />
times in all, mostly with reference to human “secrets.” See the following passages, of which only<br />
one, the first one is from the Hebrew (Aramaic) <strong>Bible</strong>; all the rest from the “Apocrypha”:<br />
884<br />
(continued...)
<strong>16</strong>40<br />
(...continued)<br />
Daniel 2:18kai. parh,ggeile nhstei,an kai. de,hsin kai. timwri,an zhth/sai para. tou/<br />
kuri,ou tou/ uỳi,stou peri. tou/ musthri,ou tou,tou o[pwj mh. evkdoqw/si Danihl kai. oi` metV<br />
auvtou/ eivj avpw,leian a[ma toi/j sofistai/j Babulw/noj<br />
“And he commanded a going without food, and prayer, and to seek aid from the Lord, the<br />
Most High, concerning this the mystery, so that Daniel and those with him might not be given over<br />
to destruction together with the wise ones of Babylon.”<br />
The mystery that is spoken of here and in the following verses 19, <strong>27</strong>, 28, 29, 30, 47 is the<br />
mysterious dream and vision that King Nebuchadnezzar has had, and which he will not reveal to<br />
his wise men, challenging them to tell him what the dream was, and its interpretation, and<br />
threatening them with death if they cannot do so. Daniel has that mystery revealed to him in a<br />
night-time vision, and he tells Nebuchadnezzar that no wise men, etc. (including Daniel and his<br />
companions), can reveal such mysteries, only the God of heaven can, and God has revealed both<br />
the dream and its meaning to him.<br />
After Daniel tells the king the content of his dream (he has seen a great statue, with head<br />
of gold, chest of silver, waist of bronze, legs of iron, mixed with clay), he interprets its meaning:<br />
Nebuchadnezzar’s kingdom will be followed by three other kingdoms, and in the days of<br />
the fourth of those kingdoms, God will, by means of a stone cut out of a mountain without hands,<br />
destroy the earthly kingdoms, and establish his own eternal kingdom, that will never end.<br />
Nebuchadnezzar, overwhelmed by such knowledge of his dream, and its meaning,<br />
confesses that Daniel’s God is God of gods and Lord of kings, the revealer of mysteries.<br />
Compare Daniel 4:9 (Theodotian). See at the close of this footnote.<br />
Judith 2:2kai. suneka,lesen pa,ntaj tou.j qera,pontaj auvtou/ kai. pa,ntaj tou.j megista/naj<br />
auvtou/ kai. e;qeto metV auvtw/n to. musth,rion th/j boulh/j auvtou/ kai. sunete,lesen pa/san th.n<br />
kaki,an th/j gh/j evk tou/ sto,matoj auvtou/<br />
“He (Nebuchadnezzar!) called together all the servants of his and all the nobles of his, and<br />
set forth with them the mystery of the counsel of his and recounted fully all the wickedness of the<br />
earth, out of the mouth of his.” This is a legendary Nebuchadnezzar; the “mystery” is his secret<br />
plan for the destruction of Israel in the time of Judith.<br />
Tobit 12:7musth,rion basile,wj kalo.n kru,yai ta. de. e;rga tou/ qeou/ avnakalu,ptein<br />
evndo,xwj avgaqo.n poih,sate kai. kako.n ouvc eu`rh,sei u`ma/j<br />
“A mystery of a king, (it is) good to hide. But then the works of the God, to unveil<br />
gloriously, (it is) good to do; and evil will not find you people.” Compare 12:11, which is almost<br />
identical. These are the words of the angel Raphael, who has guided Tobit on his journey and<br />
given him success. He says that while it is good to keep a king’s mystery hidden, it is also good<br />
to unveil, to make known the works of God, i.e., not to let them remain hidden and unknown.<br />
(continued...)<br />
885
<strong>16</strong>40<br />
(...continued)<br />
2 Maccabees 13:21prosh,ggeilen de. ta. musth,ria toi/j polemi,oij Rodokoj evk th/j<br />
Ioudai?kh/j ta,xewj avnezhth,qh kai. katelh,mfqh kai. kateklei,sqh<br />
“But then Rhodokos, a man from the ranks of the Jews, announced the mysteries (i.e.,<br />
‘secret military plans’) to the enemies; he was sought for and was captured, and was put in<br />
prison.”<br />
Ben Sirach 22:22evpi. fi,lon eva.n avnoi,xh|j sto,ma mh. euvlabhqh/ |j e;stin ga.r diallagh,<br />
plh.n ovneidismou/ kai. u`perhfani,aj kai. musthri,ou avpokalu,yewj kai. plhgh/j doli,aj evn<br />
tou,toij avpofeu,xetai pa/j fi,loj<br />
“If you should open (your) mouth against (literally ‘upon’) a friend, do not be concerned; for<br />
there is reconciliation is possible; by contrast, insult and arrogance and disclosure of a mystery<br />
(‘hidden secret’), and a treacherous blow--in these (cases) every friend will run away.”<br />
Ben Sirach <strong>27</strong>:<strong>16</strong>o` avpokalu,ptwn musth,ria avpw,lesen pi,stin kai. ouv mh. eu[rh| fi,lon<br />
pro.j th.n yuch.n auvtou/<br />
“The one revealing secrets destroyed faith (or ‘trust’); and he will never find a friend forhis<br />
innermost being.” <br />
Ben Sirach <strong>27</strong>:<strong>17</strong>ste,rxon fi,lon kai. pistw,qhti metV auvtou/ eva.n de. avpokalu,yh|j ta.<br />
musth,ria auvtou/ mh. katadiw,xh|j ovpi,sw auvtou/<br />
“Feel affection (for) a friend, and be faithful with him; but then if you should reveal (or<br />
‘uncover’) the mysteries (or ‘hidden secrets’) of his, you should not pursue after him.”<br />
Ben Sirach <strong>27</strong>:21o[ti trau/ma e;stin katadh/sai kai. loidori,aj e;stin diallagh, o` de.<br />
avpokalu,yaj musth,ria avfh,lpisen<br />
“For a wound is to bind up, and (after) insulting speech there is reconciliation; but then the<br />
one who revealed mysteries (or ‘hidden secrets’) has no hope.”<br />
Wisdom of Solomon 2:22 kai. ouvk e;gnwsan musth,ria qeou/ ouvde. misqo.n h;lpisan<br />
o`sio,thtoj ouvde. e;krinan ge,raj yucw/n avmw,mwn<br />
“And they did not know the mysteries (or, ‘hidden secrets’) of God, nor did they hope for<br />
(the) wages of devoutness, nor did they discern (the) reward of blameless innermostbeings.”<br />
Wisdom of Solomon 6:22ti, de, evstin sofi,a kai. pw/j evge,neto avpaggelw/ kai. ouvk<br />
(continued...)<br />
886
<strong>16</strong>40<br />
(...continued)<br />
avpokru,yw u`mi/n musth,ria avlla. avpV avrch/j gene,sewj evxicnia,sw kai. qh,sw eivj to. evmfane.j<br />
th.n gnw/sin auvth/j kai. ouv mh. parodeu,sw th.n avlh,qeian<br />
“But then what wisdom is, and how it came to be, I will announce; and I will not hide<br />
mysteries (of ‘hidden secrets’) from you, but rather, from (the) beginning of creation, I will trace<br />
out (Wisdom’s path), and I will make the knowledge of her visible, and I will not pass by the truth.”<br />
What a claim this is! Can Solomon, or the author of this document, make good on this<br />
claim? We think not, and are much more in agreement with Paul’s statement in <strong>Romans</strong> 11:33-<br />
34, “Oh, the depth of the riches both of the wisdom and knowledge of God! How unsearchable<br />
are His judgments and unfathomable His ways! For who has known the mind of the Lord, or who<br />
became his counselor?” (New American Standard) What do you think?<br />
Wisdom of Solomon 14:15 avw,rw| ga.r pe,nqei truco,menoj path.r tou/ tace,wj<br />
avfaireqe,ntoj te,knou eivko,na poih,saj to,n pote nekro.n a;nqrwpon nu/n w`j qeo.n evti,mhsen kai.<br />
pare,dwken toi/j u`poceiri,oij musth,ria kai. teleta,j<br />
“For a father, being consumed by an untimely grief, having made an image of the child<br />
suddenly taken from him; what was once a dead human being, he now honored as a god, and<br />
handed on to those subject to him, mysteries (or ‘hidden secrets,’ or perhaps, ‘secret rituals’) and<br />
initiations.” This author is seeking to explain the origin of idolatry, and of the “mystery religions.”<br />
Wisdom of Solomon 14:23h' ga.r teknofo,nouj teleta.j h' kru,fia musth,ria h'<br />
evmmanei/j evxa,llwn qesmw/n kw,mouj a;gontej<br />
“For whether initiations (with) murdering of children, or hidden mysteries, or practicing<br />
banquets (i.e., drunken Dionysiac festivals) with strange customs...” Again, the author is<br />
describing the practices of those who engage in idolatry of the “mystery religions.”<br />
Then, from the New Testament there are the following 28 occurrences:<br />
Matthew 13:11o` de. avpokriqei.j ei=pen auvtoi/j\ o[ti u`mi/n de,dotai gnw/nai ta. musth,ria<br />
th/j basilei,aj tw/n ouvranw/n( evkei,noij de. ouv de,dotaiÅ<br />
“But then answering, he said to them that, ‘To you it has been given to know the mysteries<br />
(or, ‘hidden secrets’) of the kingdom of the heavens, but then to them it has not been given.’”<br />
Mark 4:11 kai. e;legen auvtoi/j\ u`mi/n to. musth,rion de,dotai th/j basilei,aj tou/ qeou/\<br />
evkei,noij de. toi/j e;xw evn parabolai/j ta. pa,nta gi,netai<br />
“And he said to them, ‘To you people the mystery (or, ‘hidden secret’) of the kingdom of the<br />
God has been given, but for the ones outside everything comes in comparisons (‘parables’)<br />
(continued...)<br />
887
<strong>16</strong>40<br />
(...continued)<br />
Luke 8:10 o` de. ei=pen\ u`mi/n de,dotai gnw/nai ta. musth,ria th/j basilei,aj tou/ qeou/( toi/j<br />
de. loipoi/j evn parabolai/j( i[na ble,pontej mh. ble,pwsin kai. avkou,ontej mh. suniw/sinÅ<br />
<br />
“But then he said, ‘To you people it has been given to know the mysteries (or ‘hidden<br />
secrets’) of the kingdom of the God; but to the rest (they are given) in comparisons (or, ‘parables’)<br />
so that seeing they may not see, and hearing they may not understand.”<br />
<strong>Romans</strong> 11:25Ouv ga.r qe,lw u`ma/j avgnoei/n( avdelfoi,( to. musth,rion tou/to( i[na mh. h=te<br />
ÎparvÐ eàutoi/j fro,nimoi( o[ti pw,rwsij avpo. me,rouj tw/ | VIsrah.l ge,gonen a;cri ou- to. plh,rwma<br />
tw/n evqnw/n eivse,lqh|<br />
“For I do not desire (for) you people to not know, brothers, this mystery (or, ‘hidden secret’),<br />
so that you may not be wise [beyond] yourselves, that a hardening has come upon part of the<br />
Israel, until the time when the fullness of the non-Jews may come in.”<br />
<strong>Romans</strong> <strong>16</strong>:25 (here) ÎTw/ | de. duname,nw| u`ma/j sthri,xai kata. to. euvagge,lio,n mou kai.<br />
to. kh,rugma VIhsou/ Cristou/( kata. avpoka,luyin musthri,ou cro,noij aivwni,oij sesighme,nou(<br />
“But then to the one being able to establish you people, according to the good news of<br />
mine, and the preaching of Jesus Christ, according to unveiling of the mystery (or, ‘hidden<br />
secret’) having been kept silent for long-lasting times.” That is, although it is impossible for<br />
human beings to search out the divine mysteries (<strong>Romans</strong> 11:33), God himself has revealed the<br />
long-hidden mystery in the good news of Jesus Christ!<br />
1 Corinthians 2:1Kavgw. evlqw.n pro.j u`ma/j( avdelfoi,( h=lqon ouv kaqV u`peroch.n lo,gou h'<br />
sofi,aj katagge,llwn u`mi/n to. musth,rion tou/ qeou/Å<br />
“And I, coming to you people, brothers, came proclaiming to you people the mystery (or,<br />
‘hidden secret’) of the God according to superiority of speech or of wisdom.” This was the basic<br />
content of Paul’s proclamation–the hidden secret, the mysterious plan of God for the world, has<br />
been unveiled, made known in Jesus Christ!<br />
1 Corinthians 2:7avlla. lalou/men qeou/ sofi,an evn musthri,w| th.n avpokekrumme,nhn( h]n<br />
prow,risen o` qeo.j pro. tw/n aivw,nwn eivj do,xan h`mw/n(<br />
“But rather, we speak God’s wisdom in a mystery (or, ‘hidden secret’) that has been<br />
hidden, which the God decreed before the ages for our glorious radiance.”<br />
1 Corinthians 4:1ou[twj h`ma/j logize,sqw a;nqrwpoj w`j u`phre,taj Cristou/ kai.<br />
oivkono,mouj musthri,wn qeou/Å<br />
888<br />
(continued...)
<strong>16</strong>40<br />
(...continued)<br />
“<strong>In</strong> this way a person should consider us, as assistants of Christ and managers of the<br />
mysteries (or, ‘hidden secrets’) of God.”<br />
1 Corinthians 13:2kai. eva.n e;cw profhtei,an kai. eivdw/ ta. musth,ria pa,nta kai. pa/san<br />
th.n gnw/sin kai. eva.n e;cw pa/san th.n pi,stin w[ste o;rh meqista,nai( avga,phn de. mh. e;cw(<br />
ouvqe,n eivmiÅ<br />
“And if I should have (the gift of) speaking for (God); and should know all the mysteries (or,<br />
‘hidden secrets’) and all the knowledge, and if I should have all the faith, so as to remove<br />
mountains, but then have not love, I am nothing.” Yes, the hidden secret, or “mystery” of God’s<br />
eternal purpose has been unveiled, made known to humanity through the good news–but<br />
knowledge of that revelation will do no good unless it is responded to in love!<br />
1 Corinthians 14:2 o` ga.r lalw/n glw,ssh| ouvk avnqrw,poij lalei/ avlla. qew/|\ ouvdei.j ga.r<br />
avkou,ei( pneu,mati de. lalei/ musth,ria<br />
“For the one speaking in a tongue speaks not to people, but rather to God; for no one<br />
hears (or, ‘understands’), but then in (the) Spirit he speaks mysteries (or, ‘hidden secrets’). Here,<br />
the plural “mysteries” or “hidden secrets” refers, we think, to the things being said in a language<br />
that the hearers cannot understand–for the hearers of such speech, it all remains mysterious! <br />
1 Corinthians 15:51 ivdou. musth,rion u`mi/n le,gw\ pa,ntej ouv koimhqhso,meqa( pa,ntej de.<br />
avllaghso,meqa(<br />
“Look--I am telling you a mystery (or, ‘hidden secret’): we will not be fallen asleep, but then<br />
we will all be changed...” Here again, Paul uses the word in a different way–not to refer to the<br />
central message in which God’s eternal purpose is unveiled, but to refer to the Christians’ hope<br />
for the future, which of course is a matter of faith, still hidden and mysterious, and which can only<br />
be seen “through a mirror darkly” (compare 1 Corinthians 13:9-12). Paul is filled with hope for<br />
the future, but the details of that future are a matter of prophecy, which can only unveil the future<br />
partially, not fully, or exactly.<br />
Ephesians 1:9gnwri,saj h`mi/n to. musth,rion tou/ qelh,matoj auvtou/( kata. th.n<br />
euvdoki,an auvtou/ h]n proe,qeto evn auvtw/|<br />
“Making know to us the mystery (or ‘hidden secret’) of his desire, according to the good<br />
desire of his, which he set forth in him...” It is the mystery of God’s good desire for the world that<br />
has been revealed in Christ, and that Paul is making known through his proclamation.<br />
Ephesians 3:3Îo[tiÐ kata. avpoka,luyin evgnwri,sqh moi to. musth,rion( kaqw.j<br />
proe,graya evn ovli,gw|(<br />
889<br />
(continued...)
<strong>16</strong>40<br />
(...continued)<br />
“...[that] according to unveiling (or, ‘revelation’) was made known to me the mystery (or,<br />
‘hidden secret’) even as I wrote in a few (words)...” Not only does Paul proclaim that formerly<br />
hidden secret, he also makes it known through his writing.<br />
Ephesians 3:4pro.j o] du,nasqe avnaginw,skontej noh/sai th.n su,nesi,n mou evn tw/|<br />
musthri,w| tou/ Cristou/(<br />
“(looking) towards which, your are able, reading, to know the understanding of mine in the<br />
mystery (or ‘hidden secret’) of the Christ...” And since Paul makes the mystery known through his<br />
writing, it is possible for those reading his writing to gain an understanding of that former mystery.<br />
Ephesians 3:9kai. fwti,sai Îpa,ntajÐ ti,j h` oivkonomi,a tou/ musthri,ou tou/<br />
avpokekrumme,nou avpo. tw/n aivw,nwn evn tw/| qew/ | tw/ | ta. pa,nta kti,santi(<br />
<br />
“and to enlighten [everyone] (as to) what is the management of the mystery (or, ‘hidden<br />
secret’), the one having been kept hidden from the ages in the God the one who created all<br />
things...” As Paul’s hearers and readers begin to understand the content of the revealed mystery,<br />
they also begin to understand God’s wise plan that has been at work in human history.<br />
Ephesians 5:32to. musth,rion tou/to me,ga evsti,n\ evgw. de. le,gw eivj Cristo.n kai. eivj<br />
th.n evkklhsi,anÅ<br />
“This, the mystery is great; but then I, I am saying (that it refers) to Christ and to the<br />
assembly (or, ‘church’)...” Not only is Christ the revelation of the long-time mystery, but Christ as<br />
he is embodied in the Church, his “Body,” the universal people, the New Israel.<br />
Ephesians 6:19kai. u`pe.r evmou/( i[na moi doqh/| lo,goj evn avnoi,xei tou/ sto,mato,j mou( evn<br />
parrhsi,a| gnwri,sai to. musth,rion tou/ euvaggeli,ou<br />
“and (pray) on my behalf, that to me may be given (the) word(s), when opening the mouth<br />
of mine, to make known with boldness the mystery (or, ‘hidden secret’) of the good news.”<br />
Because the making known of the mystery is so important, Christian prayer should be raised to<br />
God on behalf of those who have taken up the responsibility for making the mystery known<br />
through the proclamation of the good news.<br />
Colossians 1:26to. musth,rion to. avpokekrumme,non avpo. tw/n aivw,nwn kai. avpo. tw/n<br />
genew/n& nu/n de. evfanerw,qh toi/j a`gi,oij auvtou/(<br />
“...the mystery, the one having been hidden from the ages and from the generations--but<br />
then now it was made known to the set-apart people of his...” The former mystery has not only<br />
been made known to special people like Paul–it is also made known to all of God’s people (and it<br />
is their responsibility, just as it was Paul’s, to carry that revelation to their world).<br />
(continued...)<br />
890
<strong>16</strong>40<br />
(...continued)<br />
Colossians 1:<strong>27</strong>oi-j hvqe,lhsen o` qeo.j gnwri,sai ti, to. plou/toj th/j do,xhj tou/<br />
musthri,ou tou,tou evn toi/j e;qnesin( o[ evstin Cristo.j evn u`mi/n( h` evlpi.j th/j do,xhj\<br />
<br />
“To them the God chose to make known what (is) the wealth of the glorious radiance of this<br />
the mystery (or ‘hidden secret’) among the non-Jews–which is Christ among you people, the hope<br />
of the glorious radiance.” The mystery is a hidden treasure, a pearl of great price–it is Christ<br />
among all the peoples of the earth, welcoming them into undying hope of sharing in the very<br />
nature of God himself!<br />
Colossians 2:2 i[na paraklhqw/sin ai` kardi,ai auvtw/n sumbibasqe,ntej evn avga,ph| kai.<br />
eivj pa/n plou/toj th/j plhrofori,aj th/j sune,sewj( eivj evpi,gnwsin tou/ musthri,ou tou/ qeou/(<br />
Cristou/(<br />
<br />
“in order that the hearts of theirs might be encouraged, having been knit together in love,<br />
and for all (the) wealth of the full assurance of understanding (and) for recognition of the mystery<br />
(or, ‘the hidden secret’) of the God--Christ.” Paul wants all of those who have seen and heard the<br />
revelation of the mystery to grow in their understanding and recognition of its powerful truth.<br />
Christ is the specific content of the mystery.<br />
Colossians 4:3 proseuco,menoi a[ma kai. peri. h`mw/n( i[na o` qeo.j avnoi,xh| h`mi/n qu,ran<br />
tou/ lo,gou lalh/sai to. musth,rion tou/ Cristou/( diV o] kai. de,demai(<br />
“praying together also concerning us, that the God might open for us a door for the word, to<br />
speak the mystery of the Christ, on account of which I am in prison.”<br />
2 Thessalonians 2:7to. ga.r musth,rion h;dh evnergei/tai th/j avnomi,aj\ mo,non o`<br />
kate,cwn a;rti e[wj evk me,sou ge,nhtaiÅ<br />
“For the mystery (or ‘hidden secret’) of lawlessness already is working; only the one holding<br />
back now–until he may come out of (the) midst.” Here again, Paul uses the word “mystery” in a<br />
different sense. Not only is there a divine mystery or hidden secret which is now being revealed<br />
through the good news–there is also a mysterious “working of lawlessness” which is in opposition<br />
to the divine mystery, and is working its evil intentions in human history, at the very same time<br />
that the good news is working to overthrow all evil. We need never pretend that because we have<br />
seen the light of God in Jesus Christ, that there will be no more darkness, or constant attempts to<br />
put out the light!<br />
1 Timothy 3:9e;contaj to. musth,rion th/j pi,stewj evn kaqara/| suneidh,seiÅ<br />
“holding the mystery (or ‘hidden secret’) of the faith in a clean conscience.” This is a basic<br />
qualification of those who seek to serve in leadership positions within the church–a strong holding<br />
to the basic good news, with a clear conscience. Nothing else can qualify a person for leadership!<br />
(continued...)<br />
891
<strong>16</strong>40<br />
(...continued)<br />
1 Timothy 3:<strong>16</strong>kai. o`mologoume,nwj me,ga evsti.n to. th/j euvsebei,aj musth,rion\ o]j<br />
evfanerw,qh evn sarki,( evdikaiw,qh evn pneu,mati( w;fqh avgge,loij( evkhru,cqh evn e;qnesin(<br />
evpisteu,qh evn ko,smw|( avnelh,mfqh evn do,xh|Å<br />
“And undeniably great is the mystery (‘hidden secret’) of godliness–who was manifested in<br />
flesh, justified in spirit, seen by messengers, preached among (the) nations, trusted in (the) world,<br />
taken up in glorious radiance.” The “mystery of godliness” is Jesus Christ, his earthly ministry, his<br />
justification over against all the opposition that arose against him, all of which was witnessed by<br />
his chosen associates who have already in the first century proclaimed him among the non-<br />
Jewish nations, who has led people from every race and nationality to faith, and who has been<br />
raised to the right hand of God, to reign over human history. His life is the pattern of true<br />
godliness; identification with him leads believers to share in that godliness. <br />
Revelation 1:20 to. musth,rion tw/n e`pta. avste,rwn ou]j ei=dej evpi. th/j dexia/j mou kai.<br />
ta.j e`pta. lucni,aj ta.j crusa/j\ oi` e`pta. avste,rej a;ggeloi tw/n e`pta. evkklhsiw/n eivsin kai. ai`<br />
lucni,ai ai` e`pta. e`pta. evkklhsi,ai eivsi,nÅ<br />
“The mystery (or, ‘hidden secret’) of the seven stars which you saw upon the right hand of<br />
mine, and the seven lampstands, the golden ones: the seven stars–messengers (or, ‘angels’) of<br />
the seven assemblies (or, ‘churches’) and the seven lampstands are the seven assemblies (or<br />
‘churches’).” Here again the word “mystery” is used in a different sense from its normal meaning<br />
in Paul’s writings. Now it means the truth hidden behind the graphic symbolism of the author of<br />
Revelation, in his depiction of the risen Lord holding seven stars in his right hand–the meaning of<br />
the mystery is that the seven stars represent the messengers or “angels” of the seven churches of<br />
Asia Minor in the first century, while the seven lampstands represent the seven churches<br />
themselves.<br />
Revelation 10:7avllV evn tai/j h`me,raij th/j fwnh/j tou/ e`bdo,mou avgge,lou( o[tan me,llh|<br />
salpi,zein( kai. evtele,sqh to. musth,rion tou/ qeou/( w`j euvhgge,lisen tou.j e`autou/ dou,louj tou.j<br />
profh,tajÅ<br />
“But rather in the days of the voice of the seventh messenger (or, ‘angel’), when he is<br />
about to sound (the) trumpet; and it was completed, the mystery (or ‘hidden secret’) of the God,<br />
as he promised the slaves of his own, the spokespersons (or ‘prophets’).” The divine mystery or<br />
hidden secret has not only been revealed in the good news, but it is continuing to be fulfilled as<br />
the promises made to God’s spokespersons are coming to pass in human history.<br />
Revelation <strong>17</strong>:5kai. evpi. to. me,twpon auvth/j o;noma gegramme,non( musth,rion( Babulw.n<br />
h` mega,lh( h` mh,thr tw/n pornw/n kai. tw/n bdelugma,twn th/j gh/jÅ<br />
“and upon the forehead of hers, a name having been written, a mystery (or, ‘hidden<br />
secret’), ‘Babylon the great, the mother of prostitutes and of the abominations of the earth." Here<br />
again, the noun “mystery” is used in a different sense than that central sense in Paul’s writings.<br />
(continued...)<br />
892
<strong>16</strong>40<br />
(...continued)<br />
Here it refers again to the meaning of the author of Revelation’s graphic symbolism–a great<br />
prostitute, riding a scarlet beast with seven heads and ten horns–she has a name written on her<br />
forehead, which is a mystery, i.e., it contains a hidden secret. The writing is “Babylon the great...”,<br />
but its meaning is not literally Babylon–rather, it stands for Rome, the Capital City of the Roman<br />
Empire, sitting on seven hills, with its deadly attack on the followers of Jesus in the latter half of<br />
the first-century A.D.<br />
Revelation <strong>17</strong>:7Kai. ei=pe,n moi o` a;ggeloj\ dia. ti, evqau,masajÈ evgw. evrw/ soi to.<br />
musth,rion th/j gunaiko.j kai. tou/ qhri,ou tou/ basta,zontoj auvth.n tou/ e;contoj ta.j e`pta.<br />
kefala.j kai. ta. de,ka ke,rataÅ<br />
“And the messenger (or, ‘angel’) said to me, ‘For what reason were you astonished? I, I<br />
will tell you the mystery (or ‘hidden secret’) of the woman, and of the beast, the one carrying her,<br />
the one having the seven heads and the ten horns.” As the author of Revelation gives the<br />
messenger’s (or “angel’s”) explanation of the meaning of this graphic symbolism, he makes it<br />
clear that the reference is to “the great city which reigns over the kings of the earth” (<strong>17</strong>:18).<br />
Notice how in these biblical occurrences of “the mystery” or “hidden wisdom,” we have<br />
been introduced to the thought of “the secret purpose of God” that is being brought about in<br />
human history. Here, alongside these passages concerning “the mystery,” we place other<br />
statements concerning God’s “purpose” or “plan” from the Jewish <strong>Bible</strong>:<br />
First, we mention the important passage, Genesis 50:20:<br />
h['_r" yl;Þ[' ~T,îb.v;x] ~T,§a;w><br />
hb'êjol. Hb'äv'x] ‘~yhil{a/<br />
hZ
<strong>16</strong>40<br />
(...continued)<br />
their plans–but God also has his thoughts, his devices, his plans, that are at work in the midst of<br />
human evil.<br />
Secondly, we mention the profound statement made in Proverbs 19:21,<br />
vyai_-bl,B. tAbåv'x]m; tABår:<br />
`~Wq)t' ayhiä hw"©hy>÷ tc;î[]w:<br />
Many thoughts (or “devices”) (are) in the heart of a man;<br />
and YHWH’s plan (the Hebrew noun hcî[, (etsah)–it will stand!<br />
That is, human history shows the constant making and remaking of human schemes and<br />
plans–too numerous to count–but in the long run of history, it is the divine plan or purpose in that<br />
will stand! The noun hc'[e, (etsah, means “plan,” or “purpose.” Human beings have thoughts, or<br />
plans, or purposes, which they put into effect and allow to guide their lives–but God also has a<br />
plan, a purpose–and it is only by letting that purpose guide us, counsel us, that we can become<br />
part of something that will truly last! Only YHWH God’s plan will stand in the long-run!<br />
Psalm 33:8-11,<br />
#râ tc;ä[]<br />
`rdo*w" rdoæl. ABªli÷ tAbïv.x.m;<br />
They will tremble in awe because of YHWH, all the earth;<br />
because of him let all the inhabitants of the world be in dread.<br />
Because he, he spoke, and it came to be;<br />
he commanded, and it stood firm.<br />
YHWH brings to nothing the plan(s) of (the) nations;<br />
he frustrates the thoughts of (the) peoples.<br />
The plan of YHWH into long-lasting time will stand,<br />
the thoughts of his heart to generation and generation.<br />
(continued...)<br />
894
<strong>16</strong>40<br />
(...continued)<br />
That is, human beings everywhere make all sorts of plans, and have thoughts and<br />
purposes that they intend to fulfill, but which far too often are brought to nothing. But far greater<br />
than all human plans and purposes, is the purpose or plan of YHWH God that will certainly be<br />
established.<br />
What do you think? Did the Creator God, who so marvelously designed the entire<br />
universe, not have a purpose, a plan for the universe as a whole, something that he wanted to<br />
achieve through its existence?<br />
But what is God’s purpose, what is his plan? If it is to transform human evil into good, how<br />
can that be? When will it happen? How is God bringing it about? We human beings don’t know.<br />
We sense that it is true, we deeply hope that it is true; but it remains a dark mystery, a hidden<br />
secret which we cannot fathom.<br />
God simply spoke, and the entire universe was created. His creative power is without any<br />
equal in all the universe, over which he rules, fulfilling his purposes. Nations and peoples make<br />
their proud plans--just think of Hitler’s dream of the Third Reich, the third Roman Empire, that he<br />
and his followers believed would rule for a thousand years; or Saddam Hussein’s plans for a “New<br />
Babylon.” Such human plans are not enduring–instead, they are frustrated and come to nothing.<br />
But the same thing is not true of YHWH’s plan or purpose. It stands firm for all time, and<br />
reaches out to all generations of people. But what is that plan, that purpose? What is the “eternal<br />
purpose” of God? Can we find out what it is by our human wisdom?<br />
Isaiah 55:8-9,<br />
~k,êyteAbåv.x.m; ‘yt;Abv.x.m; al{Ü yKiä<br />
`hw")hy> ~auÞn> yk'_r"D> ~k,Þyker>d: al{ïw><br />
#r WhÜb.G" !KEå<br />
`~k,(ytebov.x.M;mi yt;Þbov.x.m;W<br />
Because my plans (or, ‘thoughts’) are not your plans (or, ‘thoughts’),<br />
and your ways are not my ways–it is a saying of YHWH.<br />
Because (the) heavens are higher than (the) earth,<br />
so are my ways higher than your ways<br />
and my plans (or, ‘thoughts’) than your plans (or, ‘thoughts’).<br />
No, we cannot, on our own, know the thoughts and ways of YHWH God, or discover what<br />
his plan or purpose is for our existence. We can know that he invites us to seek him, and that<br />
whenever we turn away from our wicked ways and thoughts, he will have mercy upon us and<br />
895<br />
(continued...)
<strong>16</strong>40<br />
(...continued)<br />
pardon us. But his thoughts and his ways are different from ours, far beyond our ability<br />
to fathom or understand.<br />
If we dare to believe with Genesis that God is working behind the scenes, in the very midst<br />
of human evil, to transform evil into good, how can this be? How will it be accomplished? When<br />
will it happen? We cannot answer those questions, but we can seek God, forsake our evil ways<br />
and plans, and return to God, asking for his compassion and forgiveness!<br />
However, when God allows his servants, the Spokespersons, to enter into his counsel,<br />
they can get a glimpse of what the divine plan is for certain times and situations. This is made<br />
clear in two passages from the Spokesperson Isaiah:<br />
Isaiah 14:24-<strong>27</strong>,<br />
rmo=ale tAaßb'c. hw"ïhy> [B; ²v.nI<br />
ht'y"ëh' !KEå ‘ytiyMi ’DI rv<br />
ALê[u ‘~h,yle[]me( rs"Üw><br />
`rWs)y" Amàk.vi l[;îme AlêB\su’w><br />
#rh; hc'î[eh' tazO°<br />
`~yI)AGh;-lK'-l[; hy"ßWjN>h;dY"ïh; tazO°w><br />
rpE +y" ymi äW #[' Þy" tAa±b'c. hw"ôhy>-yKi<br />
`hN"b ymiîW hy"ßWjN>h; Adïy"w><br />
YHWH of Armies has sworn, saying:<br />
Surely [al{ ú-~ai, emphatic affirmative] just as I intended, so it happened;<br />
and just as I planned, it will stand:<br />
to break Assyria in my land,<br />
and on my mountains I will trample him.<br />
and it will be removed from them, his yoke,<br />
and his burden from upon his shoulder will be removed.<br />
This (is) the plan that was planned concerning all the earth;<br />
and this is the hand that is stretched out over all the nations.<br />
(continued...)<br />
896
<strong>16</strong>40<br />
(...continued)<br />
For YHWH of Armies has planned,<br />
and who will frustrate it?<br />
His hand is the one stretched out,<br />
and who will turn it back?<br />
Yes, YHWH God has a plan for all the earth, for all the nations, a plan that will not be<br />
frustrated or turned back. That plan includes overthrowing such powerful nations as that of the<br />
th<br />
Assyrians, who conquered northern Israel, in the 8 century B.C., carrying its people into captivity.<br />
The spokesperson Isaiah has entered into the divine counsel (see Jeremiah 23:18, 22), and has<br />
gotten a glimpse of that divine plan. Above and beyond the proud plans and ambitions of cruel<br />
nations like Assyria is the Creator God, who is the Lord of history, and who will overthrow the<br />
Assyrians, bringing the captive Israelites back home. What YHWH of Armies–the Divine<br />
Warrior–has done with Assyria is an insight into what is happening throughout the world–it is a<br />
plan that works itself out in the whole earth, in all the nations. The Divine Warrior is judging the<br />
nations and peoples of the earth, overthrowing the proud oppressors, raising up the weak and<br />
fallen. Such a process will never cease or fail to be accomplished.<br />
The second passage is Isaiah 46:8-11:<br />
Wvv'_aot.hiw> tazO à-Wrk.zI<br />
`ble(-l[; ~y[iÞv.Ap Wbyviîh'<br />
~l'_A[me tAnàvoarI Wrïk.zI<br />
dA[ê !yaeäw> ‘lae ykiînOa' yKiä<br />
`ynIAm*K' sp,a,îw> ~yhiÞl{a/<br />
tyrI êx]a; ‘tyviarEme( dyGIÜm;<br />
Wf+[]n:-al{ rvm, #r
<strong>16</strong>40<br />
(...continued)<br />
You people remember first things, from long ago!<br />
For I (am) God [‘lae, El], and there is no other--<br />
God [~yhiÞl{a, )elohiym] and (there is) nothing like me!--<br />
declaring from (the) beginning (the) future end<br />
and from long before, that which has not been done,<br />
saying, “My plan will stand,<br />
and all my desire I will do!--<br />
calling from (the) east a bird of prey,<br />
from a distant land a man of my plan (or, his plan).<br />
Surely I spoke, surely I will bring it (to happen);<br />
I formed (the plan), surely I will do it.”<br />
Yes, we human beings make many plans, and we have all sorts of intentions, some of<br />
which stand for a while, some of which are fulfilled–but many of which do not stand, and never<br />
come to fulfillment. Not so with God, the true and only God. His intention and purpose span all of<br />
human time, from the earliest beginning to the final end; God knows the end from the beginning.<br />
His plan was to raise up Cyrus, the Persian, to overthrow the Babylonians who held Judah<br />
th<br />
captive in the 6 century B.C., and through Cyrus to allow the Jewish captives to return to their<br />
homes in Israel. And what God planned, he caused to happen. Cyrus, the powerful conqueror of<br />
Babylon, enabled the Jews to return to their land, and rebuild their temple. God is the Lord of<br />
history, who raises up nations and kings, and then overthrows them, always acting to bring<br />
deliverance to his people. It is God, the great Planner, whose hand makes the final moves in<br />
history!<br />
These two passages from Isaiah throw light on the divine plan for two specific times<br />
th th<br />
in the history of ancient Israel, in the 8 and 6 centuries B.C., revealing how it was YHWH God’s<br />
plan not only to send his people into captivity in punishment for their disobedience, but also to<br />
deliver them from their captivities, raising up powerful leaders to accomplish his plan.<br />
But beyond those two specific instances in Israel’s history, what is the overall plan and<br />
purpose of God, that arches over the centuries of time? And if these two instances point to the<br />
divine plan and action for all the nations, how will such a thing be brought about? When, if ever,<br />
will this process in history reach its climax? We humans do not know. We get a glimpse of God’s<br />
mighty power at work in human history, bringing about good out of human evil, overthrowing<br />
powerful kingdoms and their rulers, setting the captives free–but is this still happening in our<br />
time? And what is its ultimate goal?<br />
Daniel 2:1-47 gives an answer to this question. It is the the story of King Nebuchadnezzar<br />
of Babylon, who has a troubling dream, which his counselors cannot reveal to him.<br />
Nebuchadnezzar calls together all his wise men and counselors, and demands that they tell him<br />
what his dream has been–knowing that they could attempt to interpret the dream if he revealed it<br />
to them, but also knowing that if they really had divine wisdom, they would be able to tell him what<br />
(continued...)<br />
898
<strong>16</strong>40<br />
(...continued)<br />
the dream itself was, before giving its interpretation. Of course, they confessedly cannot do this,<br />
and Nebuchadnezzar becomes so angry that he decrees the death of all his counselors and wise<br />
men–including the young Jewish men, Daniel, and his three Jewish companions who serve in<br />
Nebuchadnezzar’s court.<br />
Daniel goes to his companions, and asks them to join him in prayer, asking the God of<br />
heaven to make known this mysterious dream of Nebuchadnezzar, so that they will not perish. <strong>In</strong><br />
answer to their prayer, God reveals “deep and hidden things,” not only telling them what the<br />
dream was, but also revealing its meaning. Daniel and his companions go to Nebuchadnezzar,<br />
interceding on behalf of all the wise men of Babylon, and then Daniel tells the king both what his<br />
dream has been, and its meaning:<br />
“You were looking O king, and lo! there was a great statue. This statue was huge,<br />
its brilliance extraordinary; it was standing before you, and its appearance was frightening.<br />
The head of that statue was of fine gold, its chest and arms of silver, its middle and thighs<br />
of bronze, its legs of iron, its feet partly of iron and partly of clay. As you looked on, a<br />
stone was cut out, not by human hands, and it struck the statue on its feet of iron and clay<br />
and broke them in pieces. Then the iron, the clay, the bronze, the silver, and the gold,<br />
were all broken in pieces and became like the chaff of the summer threshing floors; and<br />
the wind carried them away, so that not a trace of them could be found. But the stone that<br />
struck the statue became a great mountain and filled the whole earth.”<br />
“This was the dream; now we will tell the king its interpretation. You, O king, the<br />
king of kings–to whom the God of heaven has given the kingdom, the power, the might,<br />
and the glory, into whose hand he has given human beings, wherever they live, the wild<br />
animals of the field, and the birds of the air, and whom he has established as ruler over<br />
them all–you are the head of gold. After you shall arise another kingdom inferior to yours,<br />
and yet a third kingdom of bronze, which shall rule over the whole earth. And there shall<br />
be a fourth kingdom, strong as iron; just as iron crushes and smashes everything, it shall<br />
crush and shatter all these. As you saw the feet and toes partly of potter’s clay and partly<br />
of iron, it shall be a divided kingdom; but some of the strength of iron shall be in it, as you<br />
saw the iron mixed with the clay. As the toes of the feet were part iron and part clay, so the<br />
kingdom shall be partly strong and partly brittle. As you saw the iron mixed with clay, so<br />
will they mix with one another in marriage, but they will not hold together, just as iron does<br />
not mix with clay.<br />
“And in the days of those kings the God of heaven will set up a kingdom that shall<br />
never be destroyed, nor shall this kingdom be left to another people. It shall crush all these<br />
kingdoms and bring them to an end, and it shall stand forever; just as you saw that a stone<br />
was cut from the mountain not by hands, and that it crushed the iron, the bronze, the clay,<br />
the silver, and the gold. The great God has informed the king what shall be hereafter. The<br />
dream is certain, and its interpretation trustworthy.”<br />
Then King Nebuchadnezzar fell on his face, worshiped Daniel, and commanded that<br />
a grain offering and incense be offered to him. The king said to Daniel, “Truly, your God is<br />
(continued...)<br />
899
<strong>16</strong>40<br />
(...continued)<br />
God of gods and Lord of kings and a revealer of mysteries, for you have been able to reveal this<br />
mystery!”<br />
This passage emphasizes that whereas even the wisest of humans cannot, and do not<br />
know, the God of heaven knows what is going to happen in human history long before it ever<br />
happens. He knows concerning the future rise and fall of kingdoms, and he has a long-time plan<br />
and purpose in human history–it is the building of a kingdom that will conquer all earthly<br />
kingdoms, and that will stand forever.<br />
That purpose is a mystery that is hidden from human beings, even the wisest. But God<br />
reveals it to his chosen servants who come to him in humble prayer, seeking his wisdom. The<br />
world may seem to be under the control of earthly kings and princes, who enforce their will on<br />
others, and who seek out their own selfish, egocentric purposes– like Nebuchadnezzar of<br />
Babylon, and then like Cyrus and the Persians who conquered Babylon, and then like Alexander<br />
the Great and his world-wide Kingdom, and then like powerful Rome, that divided into the<br />
Western Roman Empire and the Eastern Roman Empire.<br />
But behind the scenes is God, the Lord of History, who both raises those earthly powers up<br />
and then over-throws them, the all-powerful God who is accomplishing his hidden purpose and<br />
plan in human history, which includes the establishment of his own unending kingdom, as earth’s<br />
(“beastly kingdoms” see chapter 7) are overthrown, and God builds a kingdom that will replace all<br />
human kingdoms, and that will stand forever.<br />
That’s God’s plan, that’s God’s purpose. However, we are forced to ask, what is this<br />
mysterious, stone, cut from the mountain without human hands, that strikes the statue in<br />
Nebuchadnezzar’s dream, causing its destruction, and then endures forever? Daniel does not<br />
give the answer, and in fact, it remains a hidden secret, a “mystery” to the reader of the Jewish<br />
<strong>Bible</strong>.<br />
It is not until we come to Jesus Christ, and the New Testament’s “gospel” or “good news”<br />
that we get a solid answer to that question in very certain terms. It is the Kingdom of God that<br />
drew near in human history with the coming of Jesus of Nazareth in the time of that fourth<br />
Kingdom, the Roman Empire. Jesus himself is the “stone, cut out from the mountain, without<br />
human hands. <strong>In</strong> Jesus, YHWH, God of Israel has come into human history, to be present with<br />
his people, accomplishing their salvation and deliverance, and then sending his followers out to<br />
the ends of the earth, inviting all the peoples of the earth to enter into that Kingdom, to worship in<br />
an eternal Kingdom, with a universal temple not built by human hands, with a God-given sacrifice<br />
to take away human sinfulness forever. This is the revelation of the “divine mystery”; this is the<br />
divine plan and purpose for the earth–and this is the central content of this “doxology” or<br />
statement of praise to God, here at the close of Paul’s Letter to the <strong>Romans</strong>!<br />
This passage, <strong>Romans</strong> <strong>16</strong>:25-26 is one of the clearest and fullest statements in the New<br />
Testament concerning the revelation of the divine purpose, that had been hidden in past ages,<br />
but now has been revealed to the world in the Good News of Christ.<br />
900<br />
(continued...)
<strong>16</strong>41<br />
known through spokesperson-like writings, according to command of the long-lasting God, for<br />
<strong>16</strong>40<br />
(...continued)<br />
As Wright states, “This gospel proclamation, the announcement of the royal news of King<br />
Jesus, is the unveiling of God’s long-kept secret...<br />
“This mystery, the long concealed plan of God, has now been unveiled, and is made<br />
known to all the nations through the prophetic writings...<br />
“When this gospel is announced, it enables people of every nation to see that in Jesus the<br />
veil has been drawn back on the eternal plan of the eternal God, and to respond in grateful and<br />
obedient loyalty and trust.” (P. 769)<br />
Sanday and Headlam state that “God who rules over all the aeons or periods in time, which<br />
have passed and which are to come, is working out an eternal purpose for the world. For ages it<br />
was a mystery, now in these last days it has been revealed...The end of...<strong>Romans</strong> is the first<br />
place where we should expect this thought in a doxology, and coming there, it exactly brings out<br />
the force and purpose of the previous discussion...” (P. 434)<br />
“The doxology sums up all the great ideas of the Epistle. The power of the Gospel which<br />
St. Paul was commissioned to preach; the revelation in it of the eternal purpose of God; its<br />
contents, faith; its sphere, all the nations of the earth; its author, the one wise God, whose<br />
wisdom is thus vindicated--all these thoughts had been continually dwelt on.<br />
“And so at the end, feeling how unfit a conclusion would be the jarring note of verses <strong>17</strong>-<br />
20, and wishing to restore to the Epistle at its close its former serene loftiness, the Apostle adds<br />
these verses, writing them perhaps with his own hand in those large bold letters which seem to<br />
have formed a sort of authentication of his Epistles (Galatians 6:11), and thus gives an eloquent<br />
conclusion to his great argument.” (P. 436)<br />
There can be no doubt as to the meaning of the doxology–it is that the hidden mystery of<br />
God’s eternal purpose has been made known in the good news that Paul proclaims.<br />
Here then is the joyful claim that in coming to know Jesus as our Lord and Savior, and<br />
committing our lives to following him, we become partakers in the long-time hidden “mystery,” the<br />
“secret” of God’s eternal purpose and plan for the ages. God through Jesus Christ makes us part<br />
of his Kingdom that will never end, as we share in a mission of loving service and compassion to<br />
all our fellow human beings on earth. That, of course, does not mean that we “know everything,”<br />
or that there are no more mysteries, hidden secrets beyond our grasp. But the central mystery,<br />
the overall plan of God for this world, has been made known to us!<br />
<strong>16</strong>41<br />
Following the feminine plural genitive adjective profhtikw/n, prophetikon, “prophetic,”<br />
or “spokesperson-like,” the phrase kai. th/j evpifanei,aj tou/ kuri,ou h`mw/n vIhsou/ Cristou/, kai<br />
tes epiphaneias tou kuriou hemon Iesou Christou, “and of the appearance of the Lord of ours<br />
Jesus Christ,”is interpolated into the text by Origen of Alexandria (who died 254 A.D.) and in some<br />
manuscripts of Jerome (who died 420 A.D.).<br />
901<br />
(continued...)
<strong>16</strong>42 <strong>16</strong>43<br />
obedience of faith in all the nations, having been made known; <strong>16</strong>.<strong>27</strong> to (the) only wise<br />
<strong>16</strong>41<br />
(...continued)<br />
This interpolation does not change the meaning of <strong>Romans</strong>, although the noun evpifanei,a,<br />
epiphaneia, “appearance” does not occur elsewhere in <strong>Romans</strong>.<br />
What is affirmed here is an important observation--that without the written Spokespersons<br />
of Israel, and the understanding of Jesus that comes through study of those writings, the<br />
“mystery” simply cannot be understood.<br />
We believe this to be the truth, and that it is illustrated by the large role which the written<br />
Spokespersons played in the earliest preaching of the Good News of Jesus, and in such<br />
passages as the story of the conversion of the Ethiopian Eunuch in Acts 8, and the words of the<br />
risen Lord Jesus in Luke 24:25-<strong>27</strong> and 45-47.<br />
Compare John 2:<strong>17</strong>, 22, which show how the disciples of Jesus, following the events of his<br />
life, came to understand their true significance through reading the Jewish <strong>Bible</strong>. How true it is<br />
that much of the life and teaching of Jesus can hardly be understood until they are placed within<br />
the context, and seen in the light of, that <strong>Bible</strong>. We think that it is one of the major short-comings<br />
of modern Christian understanding to fail to understand Jesus in the light of the Tanakh, the Five<br />
Books of Moses, the writings of both the former and latter Spokespersons, the Wisdom Literature<br />
of Israel, and its other writings–including the Apocrypha!<br />
We agree with Cranfield’s comment that “What one naturally expects to find opposed to<br />
the past hiddenness is surely the manifestation in the gospel events and the subsequent<br />
proclamation of them, not the revelation mediated through the writings of the Old Testament<br />
prophets...<br />
“But...it is when the manifestation of the mystery is understood as the fulfilment of God’s<br />
promises made in the Old Testament (compare 1:2), as attested, interpreted, clarified, by the<br />
Old Testament (compare, e.g., 3:21; 9:33; 10:4-9, 11, 13, <strong>16</strong>, 18-21; 11:2, 26-<strong>27</strong>) that it is truly<br />
understood as the gospel of God for all mankind.” (P. 811-12)<br />
We think that a study of the Jewish <strong>Bible</strong>’s teaching concerning “mystery,” and God’s<br />
“plan,” and especially Daniel’s interpretation of King Nebuchadnezzar’s dream in Daniel 2,<br />
provides an essential background, or “setting of the stage,” for an understanding of the good<br />
news of Jesus Christ. The more we see what has happened in Christ in the light of that<br />
background, the more it makes sense. What do you think? Do you think you can understand the<br />
gospel, the good news, apart from its setting in the Jewish <strong>Bible</strong>?<br />
<strong>16</strong>42<br />
See the earlier use by Paul of this exact phrase, “for obedience of faith among all the<br />
non-Jewish nations,” at <strong>Romans</strong> 1:5.<br />
<strong>16</strong>43<br />
This assertion that the good news (or the “mystery”) has already “been made known in<br />
all the nations” at the time of Paul’s writing of <strong>Romans</strong>, is paralleled elsewhere in Paul’s writings--<br />
see <strong>Romans</strong> 1:8 and 1 Thessalonians 1:8. Paul is impressed by the fact that the good news<br />
has gone out effectively and widely through the world-wide missionary effort of the earliest<br />
(continued...)<br />
902
<strong>16</strong>44 <strong>16</strong>45 <strong>16</strong>46<br />
God, through Jesus, Christ, to whom (belongs) the glorious radiance into the ages,<br />
<strong>16</strong>43<br />
(...continued)<br />
proclaimers of the good news. We need not be critical of his language in terms of exact, one on<br />
one proclamation to even the unknown areas of planet earth. Rather, we should understand him<br />
in terms of his prior narrow views of Judaism, and his present engagement in world-wide mission<br />
that had already been so successful.<br />
We must keep in mind that our knowledge of the spread of the Christian movement is<br />
largely based on our knowledge of Paul’s mission, as described in the Book of Acts and in his<br />
writings. But the fact is that there were many other missionaries of the faith (remember the twelve<br />
(tradition has Thomas going all the way to <strong>In</strong>dia!), then the seventy, and later the great host of<br />
people from all around the world converted on the Day of Pentecost; also remember all of the<br />
fellow-workers he has just mentioned in this chapter), who shared in similar missions, going out in<br />
all directions, not only in the directions Paul went, but to the south, and to the east, and to the<br />
north. It is a great mistake to think that because we do not know about it, it didn’t happen.<br />
<strong>16</strong>44<br />
The great reality of divine “wisdom,” embodied in the one God, is a basic motif of Jewish<br />
“wisdom literature,” beginning with Job, Proverbs and Ecclesiastes, and continuing on in Sirach<br />
and the Wisdom of Solomon. However this exact phrase “the only wise God,” indeed, even the<br />
shorter phrase “wise God” are both unique to this doxology in <strong>Romans</strong> <strong>16</strong>. Compare Paul’s<br />
earlier statement at <strong>Romans</strong> 11:33-36.<br />
Wright comments that the Greek has a “teasing ambiguity: ‘To the only wise God, through<br />
Jesus Christ, to whom be glory forever! Amen’...The question is, To whom does the ‘to whom’<br />
refer? God? Or Jesus Christ? I suspect that Paul’s answer would be: Yes. That, of course, is<br />
the meaning of ‘Amen.’”<br />
He adds that “It should not surprise us that the letter ends in most manuscripts with an<br />
invocation of the one true and wise God, made known in and through Jesus the Messiah...If the<br />
God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob really is the creator, the God of the whole world, and if this<br />
God raised Jesus from the dead and thereby announced that he was and is the Messiah, the<br />
world’s true Lord, then worship...is the ultimately appropriate response. Because humans are<br />
made in the image of this God, such worship renews them in this image, and indeed transforms<br />
them to bear the image of God’s son, so that he might be the firstborn among many sons and<br />
daughters (8:29)...<br />
“Part of this renewal is the renewal of the mind (12:2). Anyone who has wrestled with<br />
<strong>Romans</strong> will know the challenge of that renewal, and will discover mental muscles, as well as<br />
spiritual, that need to be stretched and trained...<br />
“This doxology challenges readers to turn that mental work, too, into praise, not to rest<br />
content with one activity for the study desk and another for the prayer desk...<br />
”Ultimately, Paul’s vision of the renewed community is of united worship, based on shared<br />
faith...” (P. 769)<br />
903
<strong>16</strong>47 <strong>16</strong>48<br />
truly. ]<br />
<strong>16</strong>45<br />
The masculine singular dative relative pronoun w-|, ho, “to (or ‘for’ or ‘in’) whom,” is<br />
changed to the personal pronoun auvtw/|, auto, “to (or ‘for’ or ‘in’) him,” by P, Minuscules 81, 104<br />
and a few other Greek manuscripts.<br />
It is omitted by Vaticanus, Minuscule 630, the Old Latin Manuscript f and the Peshitta<br />
Syriac.<br />
These variant readings do not change the meaning of <strong>Romans</strong>.<br />
<strong>16</strong>46<br />
The phrase tw/n aivw,nwn, ton aionon, “of the ages,” is interpolated into the text at this<br />
point by P61, Sinaiticus, Alexandrinus, Bezae, P, Minuscules 81, 2464, a few other Greek<br />
manuscripts, the Latin Vulgate, a part of the Old Latin witnesses, the Peshitta Syriac and the<br />
Bohairic Coptic.<br />
The text without this interpolation is read by P46, Vaticanus, Ephraemi Rescriptus, Psi,<br />
Minuscules 33, 1881, the “Majority Text,” the Harclean Syriac, a few manuscripts of the Sahidic<br />
Coptic and Ambrosiaster (366-384 A.D.).<br />
Whether read or not makes little difference for the meaning of <strong>Romans</strong>.<br />
This affirmation that the glorious radiance belongs to the Christ, Jesus, is the very highest<br />
of Christological affirmations–God’s own glorious radiance is his, seen in him.<br />
See such passages as Galatians 1:5; 2 Timothy 4:18; Hebrews 2:7, 9; 13:21; Jacob<br />
(“James”) 2:1; 1 Peter 4:11 (perhaps); 2 Peter 1:3; 3:18; Jude 1:25 (perhaps); Revelation 1:6<br />
and 5:13.<br />
<strong>16</strong>47<br />
The phrase ~H ca,rij tou/ kuri,ou h`mw/n meta. pa,ntwn u`mw/n, avmh,n, He charis tou<br />
kuriou hemon meta panton humon, amen, “The gracious favor of the Lord of ours (is, or may it<br />
be) with all you people, truly,” is interpolated into the text at this point by P, Minuscules 33, 104,<br />
365, a few other Greek manuscripts, the Peshitta Syriac, a few manuscripts of the Bohairic Coptic<br />
and Ambrosiaster (366-384 A.D.).<br />
<strong>16</strong>48<br />
The text without any subscription is read by P46, F, Minuscules 365, 629, 630, 1505<br />
and a few other Greek manuscripts.<br />
The following “subscriptions” are appended to the original text of <strong>Romans</strong>:<br />
Pro.j vRwmai,ouj, Pros Romaious, “to <strong>Romans</strong>,” by Sinaiticus, Alexandrinus, the first<br />
writer of Vaticanus, Ephraemi Rescriptus, the first writer of Bezae, G (see), Psi, Minuscules<br />
<strong>17</strong>39, 2464 and a few other Greek manuscripts.<br />
Pro.j vRwmai,ouj evgra,fh avpo. Kori,nqou, Pros Romaious egraphe apo Korinthou, “To<br />
<strong>Romans</strong>, it was written from Corinth,” by a corrector of Vaticanus and a corrector of Bezae.<br />
(continued...)<br />
904
<strong>16</strong>48<br />
(...continued)<br />
`H pro.j vRwmai,ouj evgra,fh avpo. Kori,nqou dia. Foi,bhj th/j dia,konou, He pros<br />
Romaious egraphe apo Korinthou dia Phoibes tes diakonou, “The (Letter) to <strong>Romans</strong>, it was<br />
written from Corinth through Phoebe the deacon,” by Minuscule 1881 and a few other Greek<br />
manuscripts.<br />
`H pro.j vRwmai,ouj evgra,fh avpo. Kori,nqou dia. Foi,bhj th/j diako,nou tou/ a`gi,ou<br />
Pau,lou etc., He pros Romaious egraphe apo Korinthou dia Phoibes tes diakonou tou<br />
hagiou Paulou..., “The (Letter) to <strong>Romans</strong>, it was written from Corinth through Phoebe the<br />
deacon of the set-apart Paul, etc.,” by L and a large number of Greek manuscripts.<br />
VEpistolh. pro.j vRwmai,ouj evgra,fh. dia. Foi,bhj (+ th/j, some other Greek manuscripts)<br />
diako,nou (+ th/j evn Kegcrei,aij evkklhsi,aj, Epistole pros Romaious egraphe dia Phoibes (+<br />
tes) diakonou (+ tes en Kegchreiais ekklesias, “Letter to <strong>Romans</strong> written through Phoebe (the)<br />
deacon (+ the one in Cenchraea’s church,” by Minuscule 424 and a few other Greek<br />
manuscripts). This variant reading is followed by King James, but not repeated in New King<br />
James.<br />
VEpistolh. pro.j vRwmai,ouj evgra,fh. dia. Te,rtiou evpe,mfqh de. dia. Foi,bhj th/j diako,nou<br />
th/j evn Kegcrei,aij evkklhsi,aj, Epistole pros Romaious egraphe dia Tertiou epemphthe de<br />
dia Phoibes tes diakonou tes en Kegchreiais ekklesias, “Letter to <strong>Romans</strong>, it was written<br />
through Tertius, but then it was sent through Phoebe the deacon of the assembly in Cenchreae,”<br />
by Minuscule 337, and as a variant reading in some other Greek manuscripts.<br />
At the close of this commentary, we add a personal statement. What a blessed<br />
opportunity it is to study this great foundation document for Christian theology, in which most of<br />
the major teachings of the Christian faith are set forth in unique, powerful ways, setting the tone<br />
and the tasks for later students across twenty centuries. Paul’s teachings are profound,<br />
oftentimes difficult to understand, sometimes leaving us puzzled, but also giving us great<br />
guidance and hope.<br />
Let those who criticize and disagree with Paul do so. But let them do so while taking the<br />
entire Jewish <strong>Bible</strong> into consideration–as he has; and let them show by their lives what the fruits<br />
of their criticisms and disagreements involve. Paul’s theology is not written just in words; it is<br />
written even more impressively by his life, and by this mission that has so radically and deeply<br />
transformed human history. What does the critic have to offer in place of this?<br />
905