Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
Pedicled Vascularized Bone Grafts for Disorders of the<br />
Carpus: Scaphoid Nonunion and Kienböck’s Disease<br />
Alexander Y. Shin, MD, and Allen T. Bishop, MD<br />
Abstract<br />
The use of reverse-flow pedicled vascularized bone grafts from the dorsal distal<br />
radius makes it possible to transfer bone with a preserved circulation and viable<br />
osteoclasts and osteoblasts. The resultant primary bone healing without creeping<br />
substitution within the dead bone is an alternative to conventional bone grafting<br />
in aiding or accelerating healing, replacing deficient bone, and/or revascularizing<br />
ischemic bone. Recent advances in understanding the anatomy and physiology<br />
of vascularized pedicled bone grafts have increased their use in treating a<br />
variety of carpal maladies. A basic understanding of the vascular anatomy, as<br />
well as the surgical principles and experimental and clinical results of pedicled<br />
vascularized bone grafts from the dorsal distal radius, is critical to understanding<br />
the use of these grafts in the treatment of scaphoid nonunions and<br />
Kienböck’s disease.<br />
J Am Acad Orthop Surg 2002;10:210-216<br />
The use of pedicled vascularized<br />
bone grafts (VBGs) in the reconstruction<br />
of bone defects or osteonecrosis<br />
is nearly a century old. In<br />
1905, Huntington transferred a fibula<br />
with its nutrient artery pedicle in<br />
the reconstruction of a tibial defect. 1<br />
Sixty years later, Roy-Camille transferred<br />
a pedicled VBG (scaphoid<br />
tubercle) on an abductor pollicis<br />
brevis muscle pedicle to a delayed<br />
scaphoid fracture union. 2 VBGs,<br />
unlike conventional bone grafts,<br />
preserve the circulation as well as<br />
viable osteoclasts and osteoblasts,<br />
which allows primary bone healing<br />
without creeping substitution within<br />
the dead bone. 3 Use of pedicled<br />
VBGs in a variety of carpal maladies,<br />
including scaphoid nonunions,<br />
Kienböck’s disease, and<br />
failed arthrodesis, may aid or accelerate<br />
healing, replace deficient bone,<br />
and/or revascularize ischemic bone.<br />
The results reported to date have<br />
been promising, 4-15 especially in the<br />
treatment of scaphoid nonunions<br />
and Kienböck’s disease.<br />
Background<br />
Sheetz et al 16 published a comprehensive<br />
study of the extraosseous<br />
and intraosseous blood supply of<br />
the distal radius and ulna in 1995.<br />
Based on their descriptive anatomy<br />
of the radial blood supply, they<br />
identified several new reverse-flow<br />
pedicled VBGs from the dorsal distal<br />
radius and clarified the anatomy<br />
of pedicled VBGs. The use of these<br />
reverse-flow pedicled VBGs in the<br />
treatment of difficult scaphoid<br />
nonunions and Kienböck’s disease<br />
has been clinically promising. 17,18<br />
The technical ease of harvesting<br />
these dorsal grafts, the reliability<br />
and robustness of the bone nutrient<br />
vessel blood supply, and the long<br />
vascular pedicle length have all<br />
been factors in increasing the clinical<br />
use of these grafts.<br />
Experimental studies have provided<br />
scientific validation for the<br />
use of reverse-flow pedicled grafts<br />
from the radius. Using a canine<br />
forelimb model, which closely models<br />
the human vascular anatomy, a<br />
variety of retrograde-flow pedicled<br />
VBGs were fashioned. 19 Immediately<br />
after graft elevation, bone<br />
blood flow measurements were<br />
obtained in undisturbed bone and<br />
in free grafts without a vascular<br />
pedicle, at the time of surgery, and<br />
after a 2-week survival period. 20<br />
Immediate blood flow in a pedicled<br />
graft was 51% of the undisturbed<br />
contralateral radius (8.42 versus<br />
16.53 mL/min/100 g, respectively).<br />
A hyperemic response at 2 weeks<br />
increased the flow fourfold, to twice<br />
the undisturbed radius value (33.72<br />
versus 16.53 mL/min/100 g, respectively)<br />
and 54 times the minimal<br />
flow seen in an identical conven-<br />
Dr. Shin is Assistant Professor, Orthopedic<br />
Surgery, Division of Hand and Microvascular<br />
Surgery, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN. Dr.<br />
Bishop is Professor, Orthopedic Surgery, and<br />
Chair, Division of Hand and Microvascular<br />
Surgery, Mayo Clinic.<br />
Reprint requests: Dr. Bishop, 200 First Street<br />
SW, Rochester, MN 55905.<br />
Copyright 2002 by the American Academy of<br />
Orthopaedic Surgeons.<br />
210<br />
Journal of the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons
Alexander Y. Shin, MD, and Allen T. Bishop, MD<br />
tional nonvascularized graft (33.72<br />
versus 0.62 mL/min/100 g, respectively).<br />
20 These data demonstrate<br />
that after elevation, reverse-flow<br />
pedicled grafts from the canine dorsal<br />
distal radius have significant<br />
immediate blood flow that is not<br />
only maintained but that substantially<br />
increases over time. Application<br />
of such grafts to experimental<br />
osteonecrosis and nonunion in a<br />
canine model has demonstrated<br />
their superiority to conventional<br />
grafting techniques. 21 These important<br />
experimental data, together<br />
with published clinical results, validate<br />
the use of such grafts for carpal<br />
pathology.<br />
Vascular Anatomy of the<br />
Dorsal Distal Radius<br />
RA<br />
dRCA<br />
1,2 ICSRA<br />
2,3 ICSRA<br />
4 th ECA<br />
5 th ECA<br />
aAIA<br />
AIA<br />
dICA<br />
UA<br />
dSRA<br />
PIA<br />
pAIA<br />
Figure 1 Vascular anatomy of the dorsal<br />
distal radius. RA = radial artery, dRCA =<br />
dorsal radiocarpal arch, 1,2 ICSRA and 2,3<br />
ICSRA = 1,2 and 2,3 intercompartmental<br />
supraretinacular arteries, 4th and 5th ECA<br />
= fourth and fifth extensor compartmental<br />
arteries, aAIA and pAIA = anterior and<br />
posterior divisions of the interosseous<br />
arteries, AIA = anterior interosseous artery,<br />
PIA = posterior interosseous artery, dSRA<br />
= dorsal supraretinacular arch, UA = ulnar<br />
artery, dICA = dorsal intercarpal arch.<br />
(Adapted with permission from the Mayo<br />
Foundation, Rochester, MN.)<br />
Sheetz et al 16 demonstrated a constant<br />
pattern of dorsal radius blood<br />
vessels with consistent spatial relationships<br />
to surrounding anatomic<br />
landmarks. Proximal arteries contributing<br />
to the distal radial and ulnar<br />
blood supply include the radial,<br />
ulnar, anterior interosseous, and<br />
posterior interosseous arteries (Fig. 1).<br />
Of these, the posterior divisions of<br />
the anterior interosseous artery and<br />
the radial artery form the primary<br />
sources of orthograde blood flow to<br />
the dorsal distal radius. Four vessels,<br />
branches of these arteries, are<br />
important in the design of pedicled<br />
grafts. Two of these are superficial<br />
to the extensor retinaculum (supraretinacular),<br />
supplying nutrient<br />
branches to the bone underlying<br />
bony tubercles between extensor<br />
tendon compartments (intercompartmental).<br />
The other two are<br />
deep vessels, located on the floor of<br />
extensor compartments (compartmental).<br />
The two superficial intercompartmental<br />
vessels, the 1,2 and<br />
2,3 intercompartmental supraretinacular<br />
arteries (1,2 and 2,3 ICSRAs),<br />
are located between their numbered<br />
compartments. The two deep vessels<br />
on the floor of the fourth and<br />
fifth compartments are the fourth<br />
and fifth extensor compartment<br />
arteries (fourth and fifth ECAs).<br />
The 1,2 ICSRA courses from the<br />
radial artery approximately 5 cm<br />
proximal to the radiocarpal joint<br />
and lies beneath the brachioradialis<br />
muscle to emerge on the dorsal surface<br />
of the extensor retinaculum. In<br />
the anatomic snuffbox, the 1,2<br />
ICSRA anastomoses with the radial<br />
artery and/or the radiocarpal arch.<br />
Like all dorsal distal radius arteries,<br />
the 1,2 ICSRA is accompanied by<br />
two venae comitantes. The origin of<br />
the distal portion of the 1,2 ICSRA is<br />
the ascending irrigating branch<br />
described by Zaidemberg et al. 15<br />
However, the vessels lie superficial<br />
to the extensor retinaculum rather<br />
than directly on the periosteum, as<br />
originally described. This location<br />
makes its dissection straightforward.<br />
Its pedicle has a short arc of<br />
rotation, and the number and caliber<br />
of its nutrient artery branches<br />
to bone are small (average, 3.2 nutrient<br />
arteries and
Pedicled Vascularized Bone Grafts<br />
tiple anastomoses make it a desirable<br />
source of retrograde blood<br />
flow. However, unlike the other<br />
three dorsal vessels, the fifth ECA<br />
seldom provides direct nutrient<br />
branches to the radius. As such, it is<br />
often used as a conduit in conjunction<br />
with the fourth ECA.<br />
A very important series of three<br />
arterial arches crosses the dorsum of<br />
the hand and wrist and provides the<br />
distal anastomotic network for the<br />
intercompartmental and compartmental<br />
arteries: the dorsal intercarpal<br />
arch, dorsal radiocarpal arch,<br />
and dorsal supraretinacular arch.<br />
The dorsal intercarpal arch is an<br />
important part of several potential<br />
grafts because of its anastomotic<br />
connections with the 1,2 ICSRA, 2,3<br />
ICSRA, fourth ECA, and dorsal<br />
radiocarpal arch. The dorsal intercarpal<br />
arch can be used as a source<br />
of retrograde arterial flow after<br />
proximal vessel ligation and graft<br />
mobilization.<br />
Three criteria must be met for a<br />
pedicled VBG to be successful.<br />
First, the pedicle must be of sufficient<br />
length to reach the recipient<br />
site without undue tension. Second,<br />
the pedicle must include nutrient<br />
vessels supplying both cortical and<br />
cancellous bone. Finally, the vessels<br />
must have sufficient blood flow to<br />
maintain bone viability. The VBGs<br />
of the dorsal distal radius successfully<br />
meet all three of these requirements<br />
and, based on the vascular<br />
anatomy of the dorsal distal radius,<br />
allow for a number of potential<br />
pedicled VBGs to be fashioned (Fig.<br />
2). The arc of rotation of harvested<br />
grafts varies based on location and<br />
selection of vessels utilized (Fig. 3).<br />
osteonecrosis of the proximal pole<br />
fragment, and osteonecrosis of the<br />
scaphoid (Preiser’s disease). Nonunions<br />
through the scaphoid waist<br />
with foreshortening and carpal collapse<br />
are best treated with a volar<br />
wedge graft (conventional or vascularized).<br />
The value of VBG in acute<br />
fractures remains unproven.<br />
Figure 2 A number of VBGs can be harvested<br />
from the dorsal distal radius based<br />
on the nutrient arteries that perforate the<br />
radius and the robust anastomotic vascular<br />
network. The circled areas are the potential<br />
sites of VBG donors and their respective<br />
pedicles. (Adapted with permission<br />
from the Mayo Foundation, Rochester,<br />
MN.)<br />
Technique<br />
The most useful pedicled VBG<br />
for a scaphoid nonunion is that<br />
based on the 1,2 ICSRA. Before<br />
exposure, the arm is elevated for<br />
exsanguination. Use of an Esmarch<br />
bandage is to be avoided because<br />
vessel identification and dissection<br />
are more difficult when the bandage<br />
is used. A gentle curvilinear dorsal<br />
radial incision is used to expose the<br />
scaphoid and bone graft donor site<br />
(Fig. 4). Subcutaneous tissues are<br />
gently retracted, and the superficial<br />
radial nerve is identified and protected.<br />
The 1,2 ICSRA and its two<br />
venae comitantes are visualized on<br />
the surface of the retinaculum between<br />
the first and second extensor<br />
tendon compartments. The vessels<br />
are traced toward their distal anastomosis<br />
with the radial artery (toward<br />
the anatomic snuff box). Next,<br />
the first and second dorsal extensor<br />
compartments are opened at the<br />
Clinical Application<br />
Scaphoid Nonunion<br />
The indications for pedicled VBG<br />
for scaphoid problems include<br />
nonunions, failed previous bone<br />
graft, small proximal pole fracture,<br />
A<br />
Figure 3 The arc of reach of various distal radius pedicled bone grafts is notable. A, Graft<br />
based on the 1,2 ICSRA and its branch to the second extensor compartment. B, Graft based<br />
on the fourth ECA with retrograde flow through the fifth ECA from the dorsal intercarpal<br />
arch. (Adapted with permission from the Mayo Foundation, Rochester, MN.)<br />
B<br />
212<br />
Journal of the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons
Alexander Y. Shin, MD, and Allen T. Bishop, MD<br />
I<br />
II<br />
III<br />
S<br />
R<br />
RA<br />
1,2 ICSRA<br />
SBRN<br />
A<br />
B<br />
Figure 4 Pedicled VBG for scaphoid nonunion. A, The incision (dashed line) exposes the scaphoid and bone graft donor site.<br />
Subcutaneous tissues are raised from the extensor retinaculum, and the 1,2 ICSRA is identified. RA = radial artery, S = scaphoid, R =<br />
radius. B, Branches (I, II, III) of the superficial branch of the radial nerve (SBRN) are identified and protected. Dashed lines = incisions of<br />
the first and second extensor compartments. (Adapted with permission from the Mayo Foundation, Rochester, MN.)<br />
level of the bone graft site to create a<br />
cuff of retinaculum containing the<br />
vessels and their nutrient arteries to<br />
bone. The graft is centered approximately<br />
1.5 cm proximal to the radiocarpal<br />
joint to include the nutrient<br />
vessels. Before elevation of the bone<br />
graft, and while protecting the 1,2<br />
ICSRA pedicle, a transverse dorsalradial<br />
incision is made to expose the<br />
scaphoid nonunion site.<br />
In most proximal pole fracture<br />
nonunions and more distal fractures<br />
without carpal collapse, the dorsal<br />
inlay graft is most appropriate.<br />
Osteotomes are used to prepare a<br />
rectangular slot that spans the fracture<br />
site to receive the bone graft.<br />
Curettes are used to remove any<br />
fibrous tissue from the nonunion<br />
site. In very small proximal pole<br />
fragments, the graft may be shaped<br />
to lie within the concavity of the<br />
proximal pole as an alternative.<br />
After preparation of the nonunion<br />
site, the graft is elevated. The center<br />
of the graft is located approximately<br />
1.5 cm from the radiocarpal joint.<br />
Graft elevation begins with proximal<br />
ligation of the 1,2 ICSRA and<br />
accompanying veins proximal to the<br />
graft. The appropriate graft size is<br />
measured and marked. The vessels<br />
are mobilized distal to the graft to<br />
separate them from the styloid tip<br />
and joint capsule. The radial, ulnar,<br />
and proximal osteotomies of the<br />
graft are made with sharp osteotomes.<br />
The distal cut is done in two<br />
steps, moving the pedicle first radially<br />
and then ulnarly to prevent its<br />
injury. The graft is then gently levered<br />
out to create a distally based,<br />
reverse-flow pedicle (Fig. 5, A).<br />
With the tourniquet deflated, circulation<br />
to the graft is confirmed by the<br />
observation of a pulsatile pedicle<br />
and bleeding bone surface. The<br />
A<br />
graft is resized with bone cutters or<br />
a burr and is transposed beneath the<br />
radial wrist extensors to the nonunion<br />
site.<br />
If the scaphoid nonunion is relatively<br />
stable, internal fixation is not<br />
required. However, if the nonunion<br />
is unstable, fixation with multiple<br />
Kirschner wires (K-wires) or a<br />
scaphoid screw before graft placement<br />
is recommended. The choice<br />
of K-wires or screw depends on the<br />
fracture location as well as on the<br />
technical abilities of the surgeon.<br />
All hardware should be placed as<br />
Figure 5 A, With the graft levered out, the tourniquet is deflated and the vascularity of<br />
the graft is checked. B, The graft is gently press-fit into the scaphoid nonunion site.<br />
Supplemental fixation with K-wires or placement of scaphoid screws may be done at this<br />
time. (Adapted with permission from the Mayo Foundation, Rochester, MN.)<br />
B<br />
Vol 10, No 3, May/June 2002 213
Pedicled Vascularized Bone Grafts<br />
far volar as possible to avoid interference<br />
with graft placement. The<br />
graft is then press-fit into the prepared<br />
slot on the dorsal surface<br />
spanning the nonunion (Fig. 5, B).<br />
The wrist capsule and extensor retinaculum<br />
are replaced without<br />
suture reapproximation. A bulky<br />
long-arm plaster thumb spica splint<br />
is then applied.<br />
Postoperatively, digital range of<br />
motion and edema control measures<br />
are used. Between 10 and 14<br />
days postoperatively, the dressing<br />
is removed, and a long-arm thumb<br />
spica cast is applied for the first 6<br />
weeks. A short-arm thumb spica<br />
cast is then placed until fracture<br />
union is achieved.<br />
Results<br />
Fifteen patients with established<br />
nonunions were treated with reverseflow<br />
pedicled distal radius VBGs, as<br />
described. 18 All patients were<br />
males, with an average age of 27.6<br />
years (range, 17 to 42 years) and an<br />
average interval between injury and<br />
surgery of 36.2 months (range, 3<br />
months to 10 years). Six patients<br />
had fractures through the scaphoid<br />
waist and nine in the proximal third.<br />
Five patients had a previous conventional<br />
bone graft that failed. Six<br />
patients demonstrated radiographic<br />
and magnetic resonance imaging<br />
evidence of proximal pole osteonecrosis.<br />
Fourteen patients underwent<br />
VBG using the 1,2 ICSRA from the<br />
dorsal aspect of the radius. Twelve<br />
patients had the graft placed as a<br />
dorsal inlay, and three had an interpositional<br />
wedge graft placed to correct<br />
scaphoid malalignment. Fracture<br />
fixation was with K-wires or<br />
Herbert screws. All patients were<br />
initially immobilized with a longarm<br />
thumb spica cast, followed by a<br />
short-arm cast until healing was<br />
demonstrated by trispiral tomograms.<br />
Follow-up averaged 2.5 years<br />
(range, 1 to 4 years). All patients<br />
achieved fracture union, with time<br />
to union averaging 11.1 weeks<br />
(range, 5.5 to 16 weeks). Two thirds<br />
of the patients (10 of 15) were very<br />
satisfied with the results of surgery.<br />
Seventy-three percent (11 of 15) had<br />
occasional pain or discomfort with<br />
strenuous activity, and 53% (8 of 15)<br />
returned to their previous occupation<br />
and leisure activity with mild<br />
limitations. Eighty percent of patients<br />
(12 of 15) demonstrated a flexion/extension<br />
arc averaging 90° and<br />
a radial/ulnar deviation arc of 42°.<br />
The scapholunate and capitolunate<br />
angles averaged 58.3° and 8.8°,<br />
respectively. The average carpal<br />
height index was 0.54. The interscaphoid<br />
angulation averaged 23.6°<br />
posteroanteriorly and 24.6° laterally.<br />
Kienböck’s Disease<br />
The treatment of Kienböck’s disease<br />
depends on the stage of the disease,<br />
the ulnar variance, and the<br />
condition of the cartilaginous shell<br />
of the lunate. Options for treatment<br />
include load-altering surgeries, such<br />
as radial shortening or scaphocapitate<br />
arthrodesis; revascularization<br />
with VBG or arteriovenous pedicles;<br />
or salvage procedures for advanced<br />
disease. Revascularization with<br />
VBG can be done even in advanced<br />
(stage IIIB) cases, provided that the<br />
cartilage shell is intact, that is, without<br />
fracture or fragmentation, and<br />
that no arthrosis is found. Revascularization<br />
with pedicled bone grafts<br />
is an alternative to load-altering<br />
procedures and is especially attractive<br />
in ulnar neutral or plus variance<br />
cases when radial shortening is<br />
contraindicated. Vascularized bone<br />
grafting from the distal radius can<br />
be a useful adjunctive procedure to<br />
radial shortening in patients with an<br />
ulnar negative variant. Contraindications<br />
include stage IV disease and<br />
lunate fragmentation.<br />
Technique<br />
The fourth and fifth ECA graft is<br />
the workhorse pedicle in the treatment<br />
of Kienböck’s disease. Although<br />
either the 2,3 ICSRA or the<br />
fourth ECA can be used as a single<br />
pedicle alone, the combination of the<br />
fourth and fifth ECAs is preferred.<br />
In such a graft, retrograde flow from<br />
the fifth ECA then flows orthograde<br />
into the fourth ECA via their common<br />
anterior interosseous artery origin.<br />
The combined fourth and fifth<br />
ECA pedicle has several unique<br />
advantages: the large diameter of<br />
the fifth ECA allows for robust<br />
blood flow; the pedicle is ulnar to<br />
any planned arthrotomy; and the<br />
combined pedicle, because of its<br />
great length, can reach anywhere in<br />
the carpus.<br />
Harvesting of the fourth and fifth<br />
ECA graft requires identification of<br />
the fourth ECA by opening the<br />
fourth dorsal extensor compartment<br />
(Fig. 3, B). The fourth ECA and<br />
venae comitantes are visualized on<br />
the radial aspect of the compartment,<br />
lying adjacent to the posterior<br />
interosseous nerve. The fourth ECA<br />
is traced proximally to its origin<br />
from the posterior division of the<br />
anterior interosseous artery. Here<br />
the fifth ECA is also identified arising<br />
from the same vessel and traced<br />
distally. The fifth ECA may be<br />
found partially within the septum<br />
separating the fourth and fifth<br />
extensor compartments but more<br />
commonly lies entirely within the<br />
fifth extensor compartment. A bone<br />
graft centered 1.1 cm proximal to<br />
the radiocarpal joint and overlying<br />
the fourth ECA will include radius<br />
nutrient vessels.<br />
Once the graft is marked, the<br />
anterior interosseous artery is ligated<br />
proximal to the fourth and fifth<br />
ECAs. Graft elevation is completed,<br />
and the pedicle is elevated to allow<br />
tension-free placement of the graft.<br />
During the surgery, the lunate must<br />
be inspected. This may be done<br />
best by an arthrotomy once the fifth<br />
ECA is mobilized and protected. If<br />
the cartilage shell of lunate is not<br />
compromised or fragmented, vascularized<br />
bone grafting is feasible.<br />
214<br />
Journal of the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons
Alexander Y. Shin, MD, and Allen T. Bishop, MD<br />
Otherwise, a salvage procedure<br />
should be done. Under direct visualization<br />
and fluoroscopic image,<br />
necrotic bone is removed from the<br />
lunate with a burr or curettes, leaving<br />
a shell of intact cartilage and<br />
subchondral bone through a dorsal<br />
opening. If collapsed, the lunate is<br />
gently expanded to normal dimensions<br />
with a small blunt-ended<br />
spreader. At this time, the tourniquet<br />
is deflated to verify blood flow<br />
to the graft. Cancellous bone graft<br />
harvested from the distal radius<br />
bone graft defect is packed into the<br />
lunate, followed by insertion of the<br />
VBG, orienting the pedicle vertically<br />
with the cortical surface placed in a<br />
proximal-distal orientation. This<br />
allows the graft to serve as a strut to<br />
help maintain lunate height during<br />
revascularization (Fig. 6). Internal<br />
fixation of the graft to the lunate is<br />
unnecessary.<br />
Unloading of the lunate is important<br />
during the revascularization<br />
process and may be accomplished<br />
by external fixation, capitate shortening,<br />
intercarpal arthrodesis, or<br />
temporary pinning of the intercarpal<br />
joint. Although external fixation<br />
was commonly used as a method of<br />
unloading the lunate, we favor<br />
scaphocapitate pinning with two<br />
percutaneously placed 0.0625-inch<br />
K-wires, which are cut subcutaneously,<br />
for 8 to 12 weeks. The temporary<br />
scaphocapitate pinning<br />
avoids the pin site problems associated<br />
with prolonged external fixation.<br />
The wrist capsule is replaced,<br />
the extensor retinaculum repaired,<br />
and a long-arm bulky hand dressing<br />
applied.<br />
Postoperatively, the bulky hand<br />
dressing is removed at 10 to 14 days<br />
and is replaced with a long-arm cast<br />
for 2 to 3 weeks. At 3 weeks postoperatively,<br />
the cast is removed and<br />
gentle, supervised, limited wrist<br />
flexion and extension is begun. The<br />
wrist is protected with a custommade<br />
plastic splint for the next 8 to<br />
9 weeks. The scaphocapitate K-wire<br />
A<br />
Figure 6 Pedicled VBG for Kienböck’s disease. A, The anterior interosseous artery is ligated<br />
proximal to the fourth and fifth ECAs, and graft elevation is completed. After verifying<br />
blood flow, the graft is shaped to fit the dorsal opening to the lunate. B, Cancellous<br />
bone is packed into the lunate. The VBG is inserted with the pedicle placed vertically and<br />
the cortical surface oriented proximal-distal. (Adapted with permission from the Mayo<br />
Foundation, Rochester, MN.)<br />
fixation is removed under local anesthetic<br />
at 12 weeks.<br />
Results<br />
The results of nine VBGs obtained<br />
from the radial metaphysis in<br />
patients with stage IIIA Kienböck’s<br />
disease, using reverse-flow pedicles,<br />
have been reported. 17 The grafts<br />
were based on the 2,3 ICSRA in two<br />
patients, fourth ECA in four, fifth<br />
and fourth ECAs in two, and palmar<br />
radiocarpal arch in one. The procedure<br />
was used without joint leveling<br />
in four patients who had ulnar neutral<br />
or positive variance, while three<br />
patients with ulnar negative variance<br />
had a concomitant radial shortening.<br />
All but one patient had external<br />
fixation for temporary lunate<br />
unloading. Follow-up averaged 32<br />
months (range, 7 to 90 months). Grip<br />
strength improved 25%, ultimately<br />
measuring a mean of 86% of the<br />
opposite side (range, 60% to 100%).<br />
Range of motion was not significantly<br />
different from preoperative status.<br />
Radiographic measurements demonstrated<br />
no change in the modified<br />
carpal height ratio, lunate index, or<br />
scapholunate angle. Only two<br />
patients were without collapse preoperatively,<br />
based on carpal height<br />
ratio values. Both progressed postoperatively,<br />
although absolute numeric<br />
change was slight. Magnetic resonance<br />
imaging data demonstrated<br />
progressive signs of revascularization<br />
over time, with normalization<br />
of T2 images seen initially by 18<br />
months, followed by normalization<br />
of T1 images by 36 months.<br />
Summary<br />
Vascularized bone grafts from the<br />
dorsal distal radius can be effectively<br />
applied to treat carpal problems<br />
such as scaphoid osteonecrosis and<br />
nonunion as well as Kienböck’s disease.<br />
Although the vascular anatomy<br />
of the distal radius provides the surgeon<br />
with several alternative grafts,<br />
we have found the 1,2 ICSRA pedicle<br />
to be most useful for the scaphoid<br />
and the fourth and fifth ECAbased<br />
graft desirable for lunate<br />
B<br />
Vol 10, No 3, May/June 2002 215
Pedicled Vascularized Bone Grafts<br />
revascularization. Experimental<br />
studies have demonstrated robust<br />
blood flow to bone maintained over<br />
2 weeks in similar canine radial<br />
grafts. Clinical series have demonstrated<br />
the grafts’ ability to promote<br />
healing of recalcitrant scaphoid<br />
nonunions and to provide symptomatic<br />
relief and eventual revascularization<br />
of the lunate in Kienböck’s<br />
disease. Use of pedicled VBGs from<br />
the distal radius adds an effective<br />
tool to the armamentarium of the<br />
orthopaedic surgeon treating these<br />
difficult carpal maladies.<br />
References<br />
1. Huntington TW: Case of bone transference:<br />
Use of a segment of fibula to supply<br />
a defect in the tibia. Ann Surg 1905;<br />
41:249-251.<br />
2. Roy-Camille R: Fractures et pseudarthroses<br />
du scaphoide moyen: Utilisation<br />
d’un greffo pedicule. Actual Chir<br />
Ortho R Poincare 1965;4:197-214.<br />
3. Barth A: Histologische untersuchungen<br />
über knochenimplantationen. Beitr<br />
Pathol Anat Allg Pathol 1895;17:65-142.<br />
4. Rath S, Hung LK, Leung PC: Vascular<br />
anatomy of the pronator quadratus<br />
muscle-bone flap: A justification for its<br />
use with a distally based blood supply.<br />
J Hand Surg [Am] 1990;15:630-636.<br />
5. Leung PC, Hung LK: Use of pronator<br />
quadratus bone flap in bony reconstruction<br />
around the wrist. J Hand Surg<br />
[Am] 1990;15:637-640.<br />
6. Kawai H, Yamamoto K: Pronator quadratus<br />
pedicled bone graft for old scaphoid<br />
fractures. J Bone Joint Surg Br 1988;<br />
70:829-831.<br />
7. Braun RM: Viable pedicle bone grafting<br />
in the wrist, in Urbaniak JR (ed): Microsurgery<br />
for Major Limb Reconstruction. St<br />
Louis, MO: CV Mosby, 1987, pp 220-229.<br />
8. Chacha PB: Vascularised pedicular<br />
bone grafts. Int Orthop 1984;8:117-138.<br />
9. Beck E: Transfer of pisiform bone on<br />
vascular pedicle in the treatment of<br />
lunatomalacia [German]. Handchirurgie<br />
1971;3:64-67.<br />
10. Beck E: Os pisiforme transfer [German].<br />
Orthopade 1986;15:131-134.<br />
11. Guimberteau JC, Panconi B: Recalcitrant<br />
nonunion of the scaphoid treated<br />
with a vascularized bone graft based on<br />
the ulnar artery. J Bone Joint Surg Am<br />
1990;72:88-97.<br />
12. Kuhlmann JN, Mimoun M, Boabighi<br />
A, Baux S: Vascularized bone graft<br />
pedicled on the volar carpal artery for<br />
nonunion of the scaphoid. J Hand Surg<br />
[Br] 1987;12:203-210.<br />
13. Saffar P: Replacement of the semilunar<br />
bone by the pisiform: Description<br />
of a new technique for the treatment of<br />
Kienboeck’s disease [French]. Ann<br />
Chir Main 1982;1:276-279.<br />
14. Shin AY, Bishop AT, Berger RA: Vascularized<br />
pedicled bone grafts for disorders<br />
of the carpus. Techniques Hand<br />
Upper Extremity Surg 1998;2:94-109.<br />
15. Zaidemberg C, Siebert JW, Angrigiani<br />
C: A new vascularized bone graft for<br />
scaphoid nonunion. J Hand Surg [Am]<br />
1991;16:474-478.<br />
16. Sheetz KK, Bishop AT, Berger RA: The<br />
arterial blood supply of the distal<br />
radius and ulna and its potential use in<br />
vascularized pedicled bone grafts.<br />
J Hand Surg [Am] 1995;20:902-914.<br />
17. Mazur KU, Bishop AT, Berger RA:<br />
Abstract: Vascularized metaphyseal<br />
bone grafts from the distal radius in the<br />
treatment of Kienböck’s disease. Orthop<br />
Trans 1997;21:442.<br />
18. Steinmann SP, Bishop AT, Berger RA:<br />
Abstract: Vascularized bone graft for<br />
scaphoid nonunion. Orthop Trans 1997;<br />
21:441-442.<br />
19. Tu YK, Bishop AT, Kato T, Adams ML,<br />
Wood MB: Experimental carpal<br />
reverse-flow pedicle vascularized bone<br />
grafts: Part I. The anatomical basis of<br />
vascularized pedicle bone grafts based<br />
on the canine distal radius and ulna.<br />
J Hand Surg [Am] 2000;25:34-45.<br />
20. Tu YK, Bishop AT, Kato T, Adams<br />
ML, Wood MB: Experimental carpal<br />
reverse-flow pedicle vascularized<br />
bone grafts: Part II. Bone blood flow<br />
measurement by radioactive-labeled<br />
microspheres in a canine model. J Hand<br />
Surg [Am] 2000;25:46-54.<br />
21. Sunagawa T, Bishop AT, Muramatsu K:<br />
Role of conventional and vascularized<br />
bone grafts in scaphoid nonunion with<br />
avascular necrosis: A canine experimental<br />
study. J Hand Surg [Am] 2000;<br />
25:849-859.<br />
216<br />
Journal of the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons