what are the advantages of church planting movements over against ...

St Francis Magazine Vol 6, No 6 | December 2010
This indicates that “extraction” language, whilst rhetorically powerful,
must be carefully qualified in order to preserve the nuanced,
Biblical position.
Spiritual/religious extraction always occurs in genuine Christian
salvation, as repentance reorients a believer’s fundamental allegiance
from idols to Christ. This allegiance is expressed by exclusive inward
and outward reverence, 114 an integrity stipulated by the psalmist,
115 and characterising God’s faithful remnant. 116 Inward belief
and outward expression can be divided only by recapitulating the
gnostic denial of God’s lordship over both the spiritual and the physical
realm. 117
Sociological extraction may follow spiritual extraction: it depends
on the response of the local community to the believer’s public confession
of faith.
Cultural extraction, however, is not necessary for salvation. That
many Arab believers today identify themselves as both Arabs and
Christians belies the assumption that Islam and culture are completely
inextricable. 118 This suggests, in turn, an alternative to C5 contextualisation:
by working closely with local churches, missionaries may
find that indigenous believers have already discovered acceptable,
non-Islamic cultural forms that can be used appropriately to contextualise
the gospel. 119
When evaluated against these categories, the disadvantage of IMs
becomes clear. Sociological extraction may well be minimised, but
at the cost of spiritual extraction from the saved community. MBBs
who remain “inside” the Muslim community position themselves
114 Nikides, ‘Lost in Translation’, p. 10.
115 Psalm 15; 24:3-4; 86:11.
116 1 Kings 19:18.
117 Nikides, ‘A Response to Kevin Higgins’, p. 96.
118 To be exact, “Masihiyin,” the common Arabic term for “Christians.” Stringer,
‘Of Straw Men and Stereotypes’, p. 591.
119 Smith, ‘An Assessment of the Insider Principle Paradigms’, p. 48.
905
St Francis Magazine is published by Interserve and Arab Vision