England's dreaming equity, trust and conscience - alastairhudson.com

More documents

Recommendations

Info

The hermeneutics of Lord HoffmannHans Gadamer, Truth and Method ()‘A person who is trying to understand a text is always projecting. He projects ameaning for the text as a whole as soon as some initial meaning emerges in thetext. Again, the initial meaning emerges only because he is reading the text withparticular expectations in regard to a certain meaning. Working out this foreprojection,which is constantly revised in terms of what emerges as he penetratesinto the meaning, is understanding what is there.’ (p.269)‘In view of the necessary imperfection of all human laws, the idea of natural lawis indispensable for Aristotle; and it becomes particularly important in thequestion of what is equitable, which is what first really decides the law.’ (p.317)In relation to the interpretation of laws by judges: ‘to understand and tointerpret means to discover and recognize a valid meaning.’ (p.324)CG Jung, Letters, vol. II, p.57:‘The psyche for me is something objective that sends up effects into myconsciousness. The unconscious (the objective psyche) doesn’t belong to me; rightlyor wrongly I belong to it. By making it conscious I separate myself from it, andby so objectivating it I can integrate it consciously.’28www.alastairhudson.com | © professor alastair hudson
EQUITY AND FINANCEIntegrity and conscienceThe most successful, the most modern form of commercial regulation – the FSArulebooks – just like equity are founded on general principles which are then appliedto particular context. There is no irony in the observation that financial servicesregulation – orientated around a central principle of “integrity” – is coming toresemble equity more and more.The following discussion is taken from my book Securities Law (Sweet & Maxwell,2008):-The nature of high-level principles in financial regulation3-97 The principles of financial regulation are coming closer to principles ofprivate law all the time. In paragraph 3-94 above I considered how private lawis likely to take principles of financial regulation as the best guide to theappropriate test to apply in many private law circumstances. The differentpoint considered here is as to the methodology by which financial regulationwhich is organised around a combination of high-level principles and detailedrules will operate. As was considered in chapter 2, EC securities law isorganised around the high-level principles contained in the EC securitiesdirectives and the very detailed, technical rules contained in theCommission’s technical regulations. Therefore, at the European level there isa combination of high-level principle and detailed rules. The FSA Handbook isintended to follow this format more closely with more of the Handbook beingpresented in the form of high-level principles in the future, although at presentit already follows this format. The FSA’s Principles for Businesses constitutethe starting-point for the FSA rulebooks. Observance of the detailed ruleselsewhere in the rulebooks is only satisfied if these overarching principles arealso complied with. It is a little like the “spirit” of the rulebook being containedin the over-arching principles, and the “letter” of the rulebook being containedin the more detailed rules. Each sub-division of the rulebook begins with astatement of the application of the rules to follow and also a statement of thegeneral obligations which inform the operation of those rules – frequentlyculled from the provisions of FSMA 2000. Therefore, we have high-levelprinciples – for example the principle that regulated persons must act with“integrity” – being applicable to all observance of more detailed regulatoryrules thereafter. That is, one cannot comply with the “letter” of any given ruleunless one also complies with the “spirit” of the need to act with integrity.Indeed the guidance notes which also make up the FSA rulebooks could besaid both to inform regulated persons about the nature of their obligations andalso to reinforce the spirit of that rulebook.3-98 To an English lawyer this combination of high-level principle anddetailed rule should be familiar. It is the meat and pith of equity, for example.To some people the notion of regulated persons acting with “integrity” mayseem to be a vague notion. What might “integrity” mean? How could it applyto the hurly-burly of a trading floor, or to a large merger transaction? Howcould one know from context to context what it meant? The same could besaid, and occasionally is said, of the notion of “conscience” which is the heart29www.alastairhudson.com | © professor alastair hudson
Page 1: England’s dreamingequity, trust a
Page 5 and 6: countries in the world (except thos
Page 7: Jaffey, The Nature and Scope of Res
Page 10 and 11: As to any artificiality in equity,
Page 12 and 13: They spent an extraordinary amount
Page 14 and 15: Trusts of homesThe law on trusts of
Page 16 and 17: We need the judges to own up to the
Page 18 and 19: The only couple who sound like they
Page 20 and 21: Taxonomy is such a masculine respon
Page 22 and 23: The unbearable lightness of propert
Page 24 and 25: THE LEGAL CONSCIENCEIs it possible
Page 26 and 27: giving confession (itself that clas
Page 30 and 31: of equity. 12 And yet, the law of t
Page 32 and 33: By contrast, there are areas in whi
Page 34 and 35: EQUITY AS UNDERSTOODIN THE OTHER SO
Page 36 and 37: law device. This explanation of equ

England's dreaming equity, trust and conscience - alastairhudson.com

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

Delete template?

Save as template?