Part I: Introduction to IntegratedEthicsIntegratedEthics Program StructureIntegratedEthics CouncilMember(e.g., Chief of Staff)Chair<strong>Ethical</strong> <strong>Leadership</strong>Coordinator(e.g., Facility Director)Member(e.g., Compli<strong>an</strong>ce Officer)Member(e.g., ACOS/R)Member(e.g., Quality M<strong>an</strong>ager)Executive DirectorIntegratedEthicsProgram OfficerMember(e.g., Chief Fiscal Officer)Member(e.g., ACOS/E)Member(e.g., Patient SafetyOfficer)Member(e.g., Privacy Officer)MemberEthics ConsultationCoordinatorMemberPreventive EthicsCoordinatorAd Hoc Workgroups(e.g., adv<strong>an</strong>cedirectives, employeeprivacy)Ethics ConsultationServicePreventive EthicsTeamSt<strong>an</strong>dingSubcommittees(e.g., Policy,Education,Ethics Readiness)in the role of <strong>an</strong> executive director, administrative officer, or co-chair. The program officershould be a skilled m<strong>an</strong>ager <strong>an</strong>d a well-respected member of the staff.The membership of the council also includes the Ethics Consultation Coordinator<strong>an</strong>d the Preventive Ethics Coordinator, who lead the ethics consultation service <strong>an</strong>dpreventive ethics teams, respectively. Each role requires specific knowledge <strong>an</strong>d skills.Finally, the council includes leaders <strong>an</strong>d senior staff from programs <strong>an</strong>d offices thatencounter ethical concerns, for example:• Chief of Staff• Chief Fiscal Officer• Associate Chief of Staff for Research• Associate Chief of Staff forEducation• Patient Safety Officer• Director, Quality M<strong>an</strong>agement• Director, Hum<strong>an</strong> Resources• Compli<strong>an</strong>ce & BusinessIntegrity Officer• Research Compli<strong>an</strong>ce Officer• Information Security Officer• Privacy Officer• Nurse M<strong>an</strong>ager
Part I: Introduction to IntegratedEthicsIn addition to overseeing the ethics consultation service <strong>an</strong>d the preventive ethics team,the IntegratedEthics Council may also oversee st<strong>an</strong>ding subcommittees (e.g., policy,education, <strong>an</strong>d JCAHO ethics readiness), as well as one or more ad hoc workgroupsconvened to address specific topics identified by the council.At the network level, IntegratedEthics is coordinated by the IntegratedEthics Point ofContact, who reports directly to the network director or the VISN Executive <strong>Leadership</strong>Council. In addition to serving as the primary point of contact with the National Centerfor Ethics in Health Care, this individual facilitates communication across facilityIntegratedEthics programs <strong>an</strong>d monitors their progress in implementing IntegratedEthics.Finally, a VISN-level IntegratedEthics Board helps to address ethical issues on a networklevel, especially those that cut across facility boundaries.IntegratedEthics Program ToolsIntegratedEthics emphasizes dist<strong>an</strong>ce learning <strong>an</strong>d combines the use of print, video, <strong>an</strong>delectronic media to provide a wide array of resources. These include reference materials<strong>an</strong>d video courses relating to each of the three functions; operational m<strong>an</strong>uals (toolkits)<strong>an</strong>d administrative tools to help program staff org<strong>an</strong>ize <strong>an</strong>d document their activities;assessment tools for evaluating program quality <strong>an</strong>d effectiveness; communicationsmaterials about IntegratedEthics; <strong>an</strong>d online learning modules to build staff knowledge ofethics topics.A New Paradigm for Ethics in Health CareIntegratedEthics builds on VA’s reputation for quality <strong>an</strong>d innovation in health care. Like VA’sseminal work in perform<strong>an</strong>ce m<strong>an</strong>agement, its groundbreaking program in patient safety,<strong>an</strong>d its highly acclaimed electronic medical record system, IntegratedEthics represents aparadigm shift. By defining ethics quality to encompass all three levels of the “iceberg,” thefull r<strong>an</strong>ge of ethics content domains, <strong>an</strong>d both rules- <strong>an</strong>d values-based approaches toethics, IntegratedEthics provides a new way of thinking about ethics in health care. And itspractical, user-friendly tools are designed to tr<strong>an</strong>slate theory into practice—to make ethics<strong>an</strong> integral part of what everyone does every day.IntegratedEthics refocuses <strong>an</strong> org<strong>an</strong>ization’s approach to ethics in health care froma reactive, case-based endeavor in which various aspects of ethics (e.g., clinical,org<strong>an</strong>izational, professional, research,business, government) are h<strong>an</strong>dled ina disjointed fashion, into a proactive,systems-oriented, comprehensiveFrom . . . ReactiveTo . . .Proactiveapproach. It moves ethics out ofCase basedSystems orientedinstitutional silos into collaborativerelationships that cut across theNarrowComprehensiveorg<strong>an</strong>ization. And it emphasizes thatSilosCollaborationrules-oriented, compli<strong>an</strong>ce approachesPunishmentMotivation<strong>an</strong>d values-oriented, integrity approachesboth play vital roles in the ethical life ofRulesRules + Valuesorg<strong>an</strong>izations.By envisioning new ways of looking at ethical concerns in health care, new approaches foraddressing them in all their complexity, <strong>an</strong>d new ch<strong>an</strong>nels for achieving integration acrossthe system, IntegratedEthics empowers VA facilities <strong>an</strong>d staff to “do the right thing” becauseit’s the right thing to do.10