10 <strong>The</strong> <strong>Altamont</strong> <strong>Enterprise</strong> – Thursday, May 17, 2012Out of 103 write-in candidates,Hubbard, Centi, and Morriseysecure Guilderland library postsBy Melissa Hale-SpencerGUILDERLAND — <strong>The</strong> publiclibrary’s $3.4 million budgetpassed with two-thirds of thevote — 2,103 to 1,072.“We’re happy that the communitycontinues to support us,”said the library’s director, BarbaraNichols Randall, yesterday.<strong>The</strong> library has never suffered abudget defeat.No candidates submittedpetitions forthe three openings onthe library’s 11-memberboard of unpaidtrustees. <strong>The</strong>refore,the posts will be filledwith write-in candidates.Altogether, 103candidates were writtenin for the posts,according to NeilSanders, the schooldistrict’s assistantsuperintendent forbusiness, who oversawthe tallying ofvotes on Wednesday.<strong>The</strong> top three votegetterswere PeterHubbard, who got 34votes; Daniel Centiwith 33, and DouglasMorrisey with 27.H u b b a r d r a nunsuccessfully forGuilderland TownBoard in 2011 onthe Republican line.A Guilderland andUniversity at <strong>Albany</strong> graduate,he works in the financial industryand also owns Sam Wilson’sIce Cream in Troy.“Matt Nelligan was supportinghim,” said Nichols Randall of therecent write-in campaign. Nelliganis chairman of the GuilderlandRepublican Committee.Centi, a lawyer specializingin business and estate litigation,says he’s a frequent libraryuser. He said that, on Tuesdaymorning, Election Day, “Someoneasked if I’d be willing to serve.”Centi, whose wife is the townclerk, agreed he would and toldfriends who he surmised musthave told other friends. Centisounded surprised yesterday“It’s a timewhen peopleshould getinvolved inall publicinstitutions.”evening to learn he had won aseat with 33 votes.“In the next few years, thepublic institutions will have atremendous struggle because ofthe economic climate,” he said.“It’s happening in Californianow….It’s a time when peopleshould get involved in all publicinstitutions.”Douglas Morriseyis currently the presidentof the libraryboard and initiallywasn’t planning torun for re-election,said Nichols Randall,but changed hismind.Morrissey wasappointed to theboard in 2007 whena trustee resignedand then was electedto the post thatMay. At that time,he was the directorof school counselingat CanajoharieHigh School, andhad lived in Guilderlandfor threeyears. He has twoyoung daughters,Nichols Randall saidearlier.Hubbard and Morriseycould not bereached for comment.At its June meeting,the board willdiscuss perhaps changing thefive-year term for trustee, tothree years, which would involvechanging the library’s charter.“With how busy we all are, it’svery hard to get someone for fiveyears,” said Nichols Randall.<strong>The</strong> board has previously discussedreducing the 11-memberboard to fewer members, shesaid. “But,” she said, “the trusteesfelt, with the possibility of expansion,if that happens they’ll needas many hands as possible.”<strong>The</strong> board is planning a $13million expansion that wouldnearly double the size of thecrowded library. A public vote ona bond issue to pay for the expansionis scheduled for June 26.<strong>The</strong> <strong>Enterprise</strong> — Melissa Hale-SpencerScrutinizing the numbers: School board members huddle as Judy Slack, left, points to unofficial votingresults from the <strong>Altamont</strong> Elementary School polling place while board President Colleen O’Connell,center, and Emilio Genzano look on. Genzano was defeated in his bid for re-election.<strong>The</strong> <strong>Enterprise</strong> — Melissa Hale-SpencerBeaming leadership team: Guilderland’s top administrators stand together and smile broadly onelection night after voters passed next year’s $89 million budget with over 70 percent voting “yes.” Fromleft are Superintendent Marie Wiles and the three assistant superintendents — Demian Singleton forinstruction, Lin Severance for human resources, and Neil Sanders for business.At GCSD…Budget passes in surprise landslidefer Charron, a businesswomanalso making her first run, wasthird with 1,574 votes, just 24votes ahead of incumbent EmilioGenzano who garnered1,550.<strong>The</strong>se numbers wereobtained Wednesdayevening from AssistantSuperintendent forBusiness Neil Sanderswho had spent the daywith staff members,tallying results. <strong>The</strong>rewere a massive numberof write-in ballots,largely because manyvoters were unfamiliarwith the electronicallyscanned paper ballots.(See related story.)<strong>The</strong> budget vote reportedWednesday was 2,258 to 954.“I’ll be interestedto look at the exit surveyto see if people thinkwe should challengethe levy limit next yearin order to preserve programs.”Guilderland’s budget passagewas part of a statewide trend asvoters approved over 96 percentof school-district budgets, accordingto the New York StateSchool Boards Association; theaverage passage rate since 1969is 84 percent.This was the first year thatdistricts had to deal with a taxlevycap, widely publicized as 2percent, but actually adjustedaccording to an eight-step formula.Ninety-three percent of thestate’s 765 budgets were belowthe state-set cap, according toNYSSBA, and, of those districts,99 percent passed budgets onTuesday.<strong>The</strong> average levy increaseacross New York for next year’sbudgets is 2.3 percent, more thana full percentage point below theaverage for this year, accordingto NYSSBA.Forty-eight districts, or 7 percent,this year had budgets thatwent over the tax-levy limit,requiring a supermajority — or60 percent — of the vote to pass;of those, 60 percent passed theirbudgets, according to NYSSBA.One of them was the neighboringdistrict of Bethlehem.Unofficial figures released by thedistrict yesterday show that the$88 million budget passed 4,035to 2,405, with over 62 percent ofthe vote. Bethlehem cut morethan 57 jobs to bridge a $7.7million gap; the tax levy willincrease by 3.99 percent.Guilderland’s $89,259,860budget passed handily at all fivepolling places. It was adoptedafter months of public discussionthat involved “CommunityConversations” on how to bestclose a $2.6 million gap.To meet a state-set tax-levycap, the plan cut roughly 29 jobs;this followed the 100 jobs thathad been cut in the two previousyears.<strong>The</strong> $89 millionbudget for next yearrepresents a .34-percentincrease over thisyear’s spending plan.It will raise tax rates2.2 percent, meaningGuilderland residentswill pay an estimated$21.14 per $1,000 ofassessed valuation inschool taxes, so someonewith a $100,000 homewould pay $2,114.“We worked reallyhard to strike a balanceof respect for our taxpayers andwhat’s best for kids,” said WilesTuesday night when asked towhat she attributed the landsidevictory. “It shows we struck agood balance and used a responsibleand respectful approach.”District leaders and boardmembers decided not to propose abudget that went over the statesetlevy cap, which would haverequired a supermajority to pass.Guilderland hadn’t surpassed60 percent since the recessionstarted.Asked Tuesday night if she hadany regrets, given the 70-percentpassing rate, about not goingover the limit, Wiles said, “Nonewhatsoever…We tried very hardto match resources to needs…Ithink we did a pretty good jobwith that. We’re reshaping butnot eliminating programs so thatstudents walking through theschool doors next year will stillbe getting the sort of educationGuilderland parents expect.”Similarly, school board PresidentColleen O’Connell said, “Idon’t regret that we took thispath. I think challenging the taxlevylimit in the first year wouldnot be respectful of the spirit ofthe legislation.”O’Connell went on to referencean exit poll in which voters wereasked how they voted and why.“I’ll be interested to look at theexit survey to see if people thinkwe should challenge the levy limitnext year in order to preserveprograms,” said O’Connell.She also said she was gratifiedwith the results and appreciatedthe community’s support.
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Altamont</strong> <strong>Enterprise</strong> – Thursday, May 17, 2012 11Electronic voting leads to day of counting mismarked ballotsBy Melissa Hale-SpencerGUILDERLAND — Guilderlandwas the first schooldistrict in <strong>Albany</strong> <strong>County</strong> to useelectronic voting rather thanthe old lever machines, whichcaused problems in tallying thevotes for school-board candidatesthis week.A handful of school workersspent the day Wednesday sortingand tallying piles of paperballots in consultation with thedistrict’s lawyer.In the end, the results werethe same as those announced onTuesday night in the four-wayrace for three seats: ChristinaHayes won followed closely byCatherine Barber while JenniferCharron came in several hundredvotes behind at third and EmilioGenzano trailed by 24 votes, losinghis seat.“I’m not at all uncomfortablethat there are any flawsin the process,” said AssistantSuperintendent Neil Sanders onWednesday evening; he oversawthe tallying process. “I’m verycomfortable on the outcome ofthe election,” he concluded.Voters were required to fill inbubbles on paper ballots next tothree of the school-board candidates’names, which were listedon a grid. Below the four nameswere four blank spaces, each witha blank bubble, where voterscould write in other names.Many voters wrote in namesof candidates that were alreadyprinted on the ballot. Many othersfilled in the bubbles beneaththe candidates’ names, whichwere actually in the write-inslots.Still others, said Sanders,put “X” marks or circles for thecandidates of their choice ratherthan filling in the bubbles.<strong>The</strong> machines automaticallytook care of many of the inconsistencies,said Sanders. “If peopleover-voted,” he said, meaningthey voted for more than threecandidates, “the machine wouldtell them. <strong>The</strong>y would have achoice to vote again.”Some people, said Sanders,filled in a bubble for a particularcandidate and then, filled inanother bubble for that samecandidate below the name. “Youcan’t get two votes,” said Sanders.In those cases, one vote wascounted for the double-bubbledcandidate.Still others, said Sanders,didn’t fill in a bubble at all, butjust wrote a candidate’s name inthe write-in spot. “We countedthose,” said Sanders.<strong>Altamont</strong> Principal Peter Brabantsaid on Tuesday night thatthere were 120 write-in votesat the <strong>Altamont</strong> polling place.Sanders explained yesterdaythat number would include severalerrors on the same ballot,so it didn’t mean that 120 peoplehad made mistakes; rather 120mistakes were made.Matthew Clyne, the Democraticcommissioner for the <strong>Albany</strong><strong>County</strong> Board of Elections,when informed of the problemyesterday, told <strong>The</strong> <strong>Enterprise</strong>,“We’d have to look at it to seewhat kind of a pattern there was.We ran into that in 2010 with theSurrogate Court race.”Clyne stressed that the instructionson the ballot are clear.“To vote, completely fill in theoval in the upper right of the boxcontaining your choice,” say theinstructions. “To cast a write-invote, completely fill in the ovalin the upper right of the boxand print the complete name ofthe candidate you wish to votefor in that box above the words‘write-in.’”Clyne said that what happensnext would depend on “if it wasa systemic problem or if it wasa user issue.”If it’s a user issue, “<strong>The</strong> votewon’t count,” he said. “If it’ssystemic, remedial action couldbe anything — a new election,anything.”Asked when such a decisionwould be made, Clyne said, “We’llbe reviewing it forthwith.”Sanders noted that New YorkState Election Law is differentthan State Education Law, andthat the district’s lawyer was infrequent consultation with theState Education Department onWednesday as the ballots werebeing tallied.“<strong>The</strong>y looked at the case law,”he said, in determining whichvotes would count.Sanders said he did not regretthe district’s decision to use theelectronic voting machines. “Wehad issues with the old levermachines breaking down duringelections,” he said.And, Sanders said, it is hardto write in names in the oldmachines. <strong>The</strong> new system ledto many more write-in votes —25 people received one or twovotes each.<strong>The</strong> <strong>Enterprise</strong> — Melissa Hale-SpencerReacting to the announcement of a landslide budget victory,Catherine Barber looks happy. Moments later, Barber heard thatshe had come in a close second in a four-way race for three schoolboard seats.Election resultsAll four of the candidates supportedthe $89 million budgetproposition, but their views variedon other issues. <strong>The</strong> teachers’union made no endorsementsthis year, according to MaceoDubose, president of the GuilderlandTeachers’ Association. <strong>The</strong>unpaid posts start in July.<strong>The</strong> following results are fromthe unofficial tallies reported to<strong>The</strong> <strong>Enterprise</strong> by Sanders onWednesday evening.****Christina Hayes garnered1,855 votes, or 27.1 percent, the<strong>The</strong> <strong>Enterprise</strong> — Melissa Hale-SpencerScores of voters wrote in names of Guilderland School Board candidatesalready printed on the paper ballots in the blank squaresbeneath the names. <strong>The</strong> proper way to vote for those candidateswould have been to fill in the ovals next to their names. <strong>The</strong> blanksquares were meant for write-in votes for unlisted candidates.most, coming in first in Guilderland,Lynnwood, and Westmere,and second in <strong>Altamont</strong> andPine Bush.She waited for election resultswith her mother, a special-educationteacher, and they talkedabout how her grandmother,Stefana Fiordilino, who turned89 on Tuesday, was eager tovote for her granddaughter. “Shenever misses an election,” saidHayes.After the results were announced,Hayes said, “I will domy best job. I’m very excited. I’dlike to say thank you to each andevery one who came out.”Hayes, who graduated fromGuilderland High School in1999, said during the campaign,“I think teaching is my calling.”After working as a lawyer, shewent back to school to becomea teacher and recently did herstudent teaching at FarnsworthMiddle School.People have asked her, shesaid, why she was running ifshe doesn’t have children. “Youdon’t have to have kids to careabout the schools,” she said. “Icare about my community and Iwant to give kids a voice. I won’thave allegiance to any one schoolor any grade level. I’ll speak forthem all, from the littlest to thebiggest.”Hayes supported keeping thenine-period day at the middleschool, which became controversialafter the superintendent proposedcreating an eight-periodday to cut costs so programscould be saved. That would havesacrificed the tutorial period,which Hayes said is valuable forsupplementing learning.Hayes also said she’d like tostay under the tax levy limitwhile rewarding deserving teacherswith raises “to keep hardworkingteachers, and to attractnew, bright minds.”****Catherine Barber garnered1,843 votes, or 26.9 percent, comingin first in <strong>Altamont</strong> and PineBush and second in Guilderland,Lynnwood, and Westmere. Just12 votes behind Hayes, she camein a close second after beingthe top vote-getter in her otherelections.“I’m looking forward to it,”Barber said of serving her fourthterm after a one-year hiatus. “I’mhappy people still have faith inme,” she said on Tuesday night.“I’ll do the best job I can. I missedit while I was away.”She also said, “I’m just thankfulthe budget passed by such alarge margin.”Barber, a lawyer and a musician,had retired after nineyears on the board since her twochildren had graduated but shemissed being on the board.During her campaign, Barbersaid, “I get concerned the educationavailable to the kids now andin the future might not be thesame as it was for my kids.”She also said she was disappointedin the Community Conversationformat as a substitutefor the Citizens’ Budget AdvisoryCommittee.On negotiating contracts,Barber said, “It’s hard to justifyraises…If you give a raise, themoney has to come from somewhere.With the tax cap, it meanslay-offs…You don’t want to laypeople off.”She also said she was disappointedwith “the 11 th -houropposition” by the teachers’union to the restructuring of themiddle-school day, which causeda scramble that created largerclasses.Barber believes there is “waytoo much emphasis” on statetests which “has the unfortunateconsequence of narrowing curriculum.”****Jennifer Charron got 1,574votes, or 23 percent, coming inthird in Guilderland, Lynnwood,and Pine Bush, and fourth in<strong>Altamont</strong> and Westmere. Shewas third overall, having 24 votesover Genzano.Charron, who has two childrenin Guilderland schools, said duringthe campaign that she wouldlike to use her business acumento reduce the budget withoutcutting teachers.Charron is the owner of HelderbergPartners, Ltd., a nationwideenergy research websitethat she designed and launchedand referred to as “a labor oflove”“<strong>The</strong>re might be a couple of $20million hammers in the budget…things in the budget that mightnot need to be there,” Charronsaid.Charron, who liked serving onthe Citizens’ Budget AdvisoryCommittee, said she found thetopics discussed at the recentbudget forums to be limited.She would like to stay underthe tax-levy limit in the futureand would like to see a year withno tax increase. Charron alsosaid she’d like to see the ruleson seniority changed so that newteachers aren’t fired.****Emilio Genzano received 1,550votes, finishing last with 22.7percent of the vote. He came inthird in <strong>Altamont</strong> and Westmereand fourth in Guilderland, Lynnwood,and Pine Bush.“My only thought is the budgethas got to pass,” said Genzano onTuesday night as he waited forelection results. “That’s got to befirst and foremost.”After the election results wereannounced, he was stoic. “<strong>The</strong>budget passed. That’s good; that’swhat counts,” he said. “We accomplishedour goal.”Asked for his reaction to hisdefeat, Genzano said, “We just dowhat we have to do and never failto keep doing the best we can.”Genzano has served on theschool board for three yearsbecause of two separate appointmentsand an election lastyear.He said during his campaignthat one of his goals, if re-elected,was “to subsidize whatever wecan to keep kids in extra-curricularsand athletics.” Genzanoheads the Friends of GuilderlandAthletics, which raises fundsfrom the community to pay forpart of the freshman sportsprogram, which otherwise wouldhave been cut.Genzano, a father of three,works as the assistant vicepresident for engineering andconstruction at <strong>Albany</strong> MedicalCenter and prides himself inbringing “a private-sector influence”to the board.On giving raises, Genzano said,“When the money’s there, we allshould benefit. When the moneyis not there, we have to give backand take less,” he said of schoolemployees. “<strong>The</strong> bottom line is,we have to tighten our belts.”On restructuring the schoolday, he said, “I am for changebecause I think we have to….We have to start becoming flexible.”
- Page 1 and 2: The AltamontEnterprise& Albany Coun
- Page 3 and 4: The Altamont Enterprise - Thursday,
- Page 5 and 6: The Altamont Enterprise - Thursday,
- Page 7 and 8: The Altamont Enterprise - Thursday,
- Page 9: The Altamont Enterprise - Thursday,
- Page 13 and 14: The Altamont Enterprise - Thursday,
- Page 15 and 16: The Altamont Enterprise - Thursday,
- Page 17 and 18: The Altamont Enterprise 2012Spring
- Page 19 and 20: The Altamont Enterprise - Thursday,
- Page 21 and 22: The Altamont Enterprise - Thursday,
- Page 23 and 24: The Altamont Enterprise - Thursday,
- Page 25 and 26: The Altamont Enterprise - Thursday,
- Page 27 and 28: The Altamont Enterprise - Thursday,
- Page 29 and 30: The Altamont Enterprise - Thursday,
- Page 31 and 32: The Altamont Enterprise - Thursday,
- Page 33 and 34: The Altamont Enterprise - Thursday,
- Page 35 and 36: The Altamont Enterprise - Thursday,
- Page 37 and 38: The Altamont Enterprise - Thursday,
- Page 39 and 40: The Altamont Enterprise - Thursday,