PSSC-08-28A-LB - Armagh City and District Council

Application O/2008/0063/F in the Name of Vinecash Presbyterian ChurchIn fully supporting the above application, Councillor Speers explained that the nature ofthe work to be undertaken was such that the Applicant wanted it completed during thesummer months and was required to undertake a contractual process to appoint acontractor. For this reason he enquired how soon the approval could be issued.AGREED: that the approval notice would be available for Wednesday 9 April.(ii) Applications Recommended for RefusalAGREED: acceptance to the opinion of Planning Service in relation to refusedapplications subject to the following:Application No O/2006/0532/O in the Name of S HughesApplication No O/2006/0577/F in the Name of Mr & Mrs L MoneApplication No O/2006/0656/O in the Name of Mr & Mrs J RaffertyApplication No O/2006/1016/F in the Name of Mr S MullenApplication No O/2006/1037/O in the Name of Mr G DunnApplication No O/2007/0395/O in the Name of Mr M HutchinsonApplication No O/2007/0628/O in the Name of S MackleApplication No O/2007/0667/F in the Name of Mr MurphyApplication No O/2007/0695/O in the Name of Mr J McAleeseApplication No O/2007/0714/O in the Name of Mr J McClellandApplication No O/2007/0716/F in the Name of Mr M O’CallaghanApplication No O/2007/0718/F in the Name of Mr S McNultyApplication No O/2007/0719/O in the Name of Mrs D KeysApplication No O/2007/0758/O in the Name of B HughesApplication No O/2007/0766/O in the Name of Mr P CallaghanApplication No O/2007/0769/O in the Name of Mr J McHughApplication No O/2007/0774/O in the Name of K SintonApplication No O/2007/0778/F in the Name of Mr B BeaganApplication No O/2007/0801/F in the Name of Mr N AdairApplication No O/2007/0802/O in the Name of Mr B HughesApplication No O/2007/0819/F in the Name of Mr & Mrs S MoleyApplication No O/2007/0832/O in the Name of Mr P McKinneyApplication No O/2007/0838/F in the Name of Mr P O’HareApplication No O/2007/0871/F in the Name of Mr A RedpathApplication No O/2007/0872/O in the Name of Mr S GarveyApplication No O/2007/0876/O in the Name of J DowzellApplication No O/2007/0890/O in the Name of H AndersonApplication No O/2007/1006/F in the Name of Mr J HaganApplication No O/2007/1026/F in the Name of Mr & Mrs L McAtarsneyApplication No O/2007/1029/F in the Name of McClincheAGREED: that the above applications, being presented with an opinion to refuse underPPS 14, be deferred for reconsideration following the implementation of the new policy.Application No O/2007/1029/F in the Name of McClincheIn response to a query from Councillor E Speers regarding the above application, MrsStoops advised that she was not in a position to discuss this application in any detail asshe did not have the file with her.2

AGREED: that Councillor E Speers contact Mrs Stoops the following day regardingthe above application.Application No O/2007/0716/F in the Name of Mr M O’CallaghanCouncillor O’Hanlon referred to the above application which was linked to ApplicationO/2007/0728/RM presented with an opinion to approve and requested that bothapplications be deferred for submission of further documentation.AGREED: that the above applications be deferred for consideration of furtherdocumentation.Application No O/2006/0256/O in the Name of S CoyleApplication No O/2006/0440/O in the Name of Mr J CrozierApplication No O/2006/0899/O in the Name of Mr B KielMrs Stoops advised that Planning Service had received additional information whichsatisfied the criteria for deferral of the above applications for consideration at officemeetings if this was the wish of the Council.The Council supported deferral of the applications for office meetings.AGREED: deferral of the above applications pending consideration at office meetings.(iii)Deferred ApplicationsAGREED: acceptance to the opinion of Planning Service in relation to deferredapplications, subject to the following.Application No O/2006/0157/O in the Name of Mr K MorganIn support of the Applicant, Councillor Campbell explained that there were seriousissues associated with the above application. He advised that the haulage business hadmoved to Dungannon. He reported that the proposal was for agricultural purposes andthat the company was involved in the storage and distribution of fruit and had economicimplications for the area. He requested that the Council as a corporate body write toPlanning Service in support of the application.Councillor Irwin supported Councillor Campbell, confirming that the haulage businesshad been relocated and adding that the applicant came from a long established familywho had been growing apples in the area for a number of years.Councillor J Speers also supported the application adding that the proposal had beensubstantially reduced from that initially submitted. He suggested that the Officersdiscuss the contents of the Council’s letter with Councillor Campbell with a view toincluding the necessary details, facts and figures as supporting evidence for theapplication.Councillor Corrigan supported Councillor Campbell and the Morgan family.AGREED: that a letter of support for the Applicant be forwarded to Planning Servicein respect of the above application.3

Councillor Irwin proposed that if it remained the opinion of Planning Service that theabove application be refused following reconsideration of the addition information thenthe Council would request that it be referred to the Management Board.Councillor Campbell supported Councillor Irwin’s proposal.Following a query from Councillor Campbell, Mrs Stoops advised that the PlanningService would consider the new information supplied and if the opinion remained thesame, the Divisional Planning Manager would have to write to Headquarters advising ofthe Council’s request for referral to the Management Board.NOTED.Application No O/2006/0351/F in the Name of Mr J LockhartIn response to a query from Councillor E Speers, Mrs Stoops explained that recentPlanning Appeal Decisions that private lanes could be deemed a vantage point hadcontributed to the Planning Service’s opinion to refuse the above application.Councillor E Speers stated that he did not agree with the Planning Service’s opinion.AGREED: that a letter of support for the Applicant be forwarded to Planning Servicein respect of the above application.Application No O/2007/0609/F in the Name of Mr A TopleyNOTED: Councillor Turner’s appreciation that Planning Service had approved theabove application.Application No O/2006/0088/F in the Name of Mr HodgenCouncillor Turner reported that he had spoken with the Agent in respect of the aboveapplication and that he was in the process of preparing an additional plan which it washoped would meet with approval. He requested that the decision notice be held until theend of the week to allow this information to be submitted.Councillor Irwin supported Councillor Turner’s request.AGREED: that the above application be held for 5 days.Application No O/2006/0272/O in the Name of Mr HughesThe Chair requested that the above application be held for 5 days to allow furtherinformation to be provided for consideration.AGREED: that the above application be held for 5 days.Adoption of ReportAGREED: that the Planning Schedule for April 2008, PSSC-08-28A-LB, be accepted,subject to the above.4

3.2 Planning Appeals Lodged – April 2008(21PL10)PREVIOUSLY CIRCULATED: report of Planning Appeals Lodged for April 2008.(PSSC-08-29-LB)NOTED.3.3 Planning Appeal Decisions Notified – April 2008 (21PL10)PREVIOUSLY CIRCULATED: report of Planning Appeal Decisions Notified for April2008. (PSSC-08-30-LB)NOTED.3.4 Application No O/2007/0749 – Erection of 7 Houses – The Huntsman’s Inn (21PL09)PREVIOUSLY CIRCULATED: letter dated 22 November 2007 from Mr H NArmstrong outlining his objection to the above Planning Application on the grounds thatthe houses would have no architectural merit for a focal site in the village opposite thelisted church and ignored a private right of way to the adjoining plot.NOTED.3.5 Application No O/2007/0601/F - Site between No 1 Oaklands and 24 Derryhale Road,Portadown – Proposed Housing Development consisting of 10 Luxury Apartments in 2Blocks of 5 (21PL09)PREVIOUSLY CIRCULATED: letter dated 1 March 2008 from Derryhale Residents’Association advising of its objection to the above Planning Application and enclosing acopy of same for consideration.Councillor J Speers advised that he and Councillor Irwin had received representationsregarding the above application and that it had been listed on the March Planning Scheduleas a refusal.Mrs Stoops confirmed that the decision of the Planning Application listed on the MarchPlanning Schedule had been issued.Councillor J Speers pointed out that Derryhale was a rural area and stated that he believedthat apartments were not in keeping with this or any rural area.Councillor Irwin concurred with Councillor J Speers and stated that he was delighted thatthe planning application had been refused.NOTED.3.6 Non-determination Appeals Under Article 33 of the Planning (NI) Order 1991(21PL09)PREVIOUSLY CIRCULATED: letter dated 5 March 2008 from Planning Serviceadvising that a non-determination appeal under Article 33 of the Planning (NI) Order 1991had been lodged with the Planning Appeals Commission (PAC) in respect of theInstallation of Telecommunications Apparatus on lands at adopted footpath adjacent toMaxol Filling Station, Railway Street, Armagh in the name of O2 (UK) Ltd. The5

Department was required to inform relevant interests of its view on the proposals. TheDepartment’s view on the proposal was that planning permission should be granted subjectto the conditions outlined.AGREED: that the Council adhere to its policy of objecting to such equipment.3.7 Armagh to Portadown Rail Line (31CT04)PREVIOUSLY CIRCULATED: letter dated 14 March 2008 from Planning Serviceadvising that investigations relating to the Councils query had been initiated, however, dueto the Data Protection Act 1998 the Department was not currently in a position to providespecific details about the case. It was confirmed that the old railway line did not appear tohave any specific protection attached to it by the Armagh Area Plan.Councillor Mrs McRoberts expressed her concern that there was no Protection PreservationOrder on the old railway line as she had always believed this was the case and requestedthat a review of the early correspondence be undertaken. She explained that she had raisedthis issue from time to time over the past 10 years, always coming from the premise that theline was protected. She felt that the portion of the line that had been excavated may havelost the right to a Preservation Order. She believed that when the line was abandoned GreatNorthern Railway had said that the railway bed would be maintained.Referring to the portion of the line which had been excavated, Councillor Mrs McRobertsfelt that it was important to take steps to ensure the preservation of the remainder. Shereported that Fermanagh District Council was looking at a strategy of engaging with theExecutive to re-open the current railway tracks and she felt that the Council should also bedoing this. She believed that Armagh had suffered because of the lack of rail link andcoupled with the issues associated with too many cars, overuse of motorways etc she feltthat the Council should be bringing forward a campaign to have the railway re-opened.Councillor Mrs McRoberts proposed that the Council look towards bringing forward astrategy to have the railway between Armagh and Portadown re-opened.Councillor Irwin felt that if the railway line was to be preserved it should not have been soldoff, for very little, to farmers. He stated that there was a larger area behind the DobbinChurch which had been levelled off 15 years previous. He felt that it was sad that the landhad been practically given away and pointed out that there were buildings on the railwayline and nothing had been done to try and stop it.Councillor Mrs McRoberts stated that most of the rail bed between Portadown and Armaghwas still there and not built up. She advised that about 10 years ago the University of Ulsterhad conducted a survey when only one house had been built quite close to the railway line.Councillor J Speers referred to a planning application some 15-20 years previous when ithad been proposed to build a house on the railway line in the vicinity of Crewcatt Road andthat it had been turned down on the basis that the railway line was a protected route. Hesuggested that an investigation of the planning history would be prudent.In terms of Councillor Irwin’s comment regarding the area to the rear of the DobbinChurch, Councillor J Speers pointed out that part of the railway line tracks were still inexistence at this location.Councillor J Speers referred to the nature of the works carried out to the rear of StonebridgeFactory and felt that this had not caused an awful lot of damage to the railway line.6

Councillor Irwin stated that if there were no houses on the actual line there were severalwithin feet of it. He believed that if there was any intention to re-open the railway line theland should not have been given away.AGREED: on the proposal of Councillor Mrs McRoberts, seconded by Councillor J Speersthat the Council spearhead a campaign to get railway line to Armagh re-opened.ALSO AGREED: that Planning Service be requested to provide details of the planninghistory for the length of the former railway line.In conclusion, Councillor J Speers pointed out that the railway line shut in 1956 and thatthere was a significant amount of time between that and the planning application refusedsome 15-20 years ago.3.8 Validation of Planning Applications (21PL09)PREVIOUSLY CIRCULATED: letter dated 27 March 2008 from Planning ServiceHeadquarters advising that the Council’s correspondence to the Minister of the Environmenthad been forwarded to the Modernising the Planning Process Team for consideration andresponse. A copy of the response would be sent to the Minister’s office for information.NOTED.3.9 Planning Office Meetings (21PL09)NOTED: that the Planning Office Meetings would be held on Friday 25 April 2008.4.0 ANY OTHER RELEVANT BUSINESS4.1 Statement by Councillor N Sheridan, Deputy Mayor (11CM01)Councillor Sheridan made the following statement:“Colleagues, I as Deputy Mayor of this Council wish to place on record my Party’s angerand disgust as to the conduct of certain Councillors at the Executive Meeting held on the 3of April past.During the course of this meeting the Chairperson on the day of the Executive Meeting,Councillor Mary Doyle was subjected to a series of verbal assaults by two seniorCouncillors.These Councillors called into question Councillor Doyle’s integrity, the legitimacy of herposition on the Council and subjected her to, in my view, personal abuse of a sexist nature.Furthermore it was also suggested to her, in a sinister fashion that she was, and I quote“becoming a problem”.Councillor Doyle was at all times in the course of the meeting acting in the best interests ofthe ratepayers as is her function. My Party and I have considered these events verycarefully and we wish to make a number of points we believe to be of relevance to theCouncil as a whole.The function of this Council is to ensure that the ratepayers see value for their money.Councillor Doyle was upholding that function. This it appears was not to the liking of two7

4.3 Residents’ Parking – Gaol Square (21RD03)Councillor Miss Bratton reported that she had been approached by the residents of GaolSquare regarding the possibility of introducing a residents’ parking scheme and had raisedthe matter with Roads Service which had advised that the area in question was in theownership of the Council. She explained that the parking was particularly difficult for theresidents when large events were on eg International Road Race and requested that officersconsider her request.AGREED ACCORDINGLY.4.4 Proposed Closure of Rural Post Offices (31CT05)Councillor McNally referred to the proposed closure of rural Post Offices and thedetrimental impact this would have on the social and economic well-being of the ruralcommunity. He proposed that the Council forward a letter to the local Post Mastersexpressing its support.Councillor J Speers advised that he believed that this had already been done.AGREED: that the Democratic Services Officer confirm with Councillor McNally whetheror not this was the case.Councillor Mrs Doyle seconded Councillor McNally’s proposal.NOTED: that the Consultation Document would be brought to the PSSC meeting onMonday 14 April 2008 for consideration.The business having been completed, the meeting concluded at 8.20 pm.Mayor:_______________________________Clerk andChief Executive: ________________________________Date:_________________________________9

PSSC-08-28A-LBDEPARTMENT OF THE ENVIRONMENTPLANNING (NI) ORDER 1991APPLICATIONS FOR PLANNING PERMISSIONCOUNCIL Armagh Date 07-Apr-08ITEM NO 1APPLIC NO O/2005/0949/F Full Date Valid 01/07/2005APPLICANTAPPLIC ADDRESS C/O AgentLOCATIONNorth of and adjacent to 2 Annvale Road, KeadyPROPOSAL Erection of 10 No. dwellings and associated site works (Amended Scheme).REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSA-Three Architecture Design Planning, 43 - 45 Church Street, Portadown,BT62 3EUITEM NO 2APPLIC NO O/2006/0002/O Outline Date Valid 30/12/2005APPLICANT LandholdingsAPPLIC ADDRESS C/o AgentLOCATIONOld Road, Poyntzpass (lands between 1 Old Road and 54 Church Street)PROPOSAL Site for residential development (Amended Scheme)REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMcCreanor & Macartney Architects, 85 Plantation Road, Ballydougan,Craigavon, BT63 5NJ20 March 2008 Page 1 of 55

ITEM NO 3APPLIC NO O/2006/0143/F Full Date Valid 07/04/2006APPLICANT Messrs DevelopmentsAPPLIC ADDRESS11 Dunnsmullen Road,, MarkethillLOCATION11 Dunnsmullan Road, Markethill Co. ArmaghPROPOSAL Erection of replacement dwelling and detached garage (Amended Plans)REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr N Cornett , Cornett Design Associates, 4 Hartford Place, The Mall,Armagh, BT61 9BJITEM NO 4APPLIC NO O/2006/0256/O Outline Date Valid 27/02/2006APPLICANT S CoyleAPPLIC ADDRESS130 Maydown Rd, Benburb, DungannonLOCATION70m south of 130 Maydown Road, Drumduff, BenburbPROPOSAL Site for dwelling and garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies SP6/HOU8 and DES5 of the Department's 'A PlanningStrategy for Rural Northern Ireland' in that a building on this site would not integrate into thecountryside, as the site is unable to provide a suitable degree of enclosure due to the lack ofsufficient boundaries or any other means of achieving satisfactory integration, and as aconsequence would, if permitted, have an adverse impact on the landscape as it is undulyconspicuous.2 The proposal is contrary to Policies SP6/HOU8 and DES6 of the Department's PlanningStrategy for Rural Northern Ireland in that the development when considered in the context ofexisting development, would, if permitted, result in a detrimental change to the rural characterof this area of countryside by reason of build up.3 The proposal is contrary to Policies SP6/HOU8 and DES7 of the Department's PlanningStrategy for Rural Northern Ireland in that the development would, if permitted, adverselyaffect the visual amenity and character of the countryside by the extension of ribbondevelopment along Maydown Road.AGENT DETAILSM Lavery , 58 Valley Lane, Corcreeny, Lurgan, BT66 7SF20 March 2008 Page 2 of 55

ITEM NO 5APPLIC NO O/2006/0396/O Outline Date Valid 10/03/2006APPLICANT DugganAPPLIC ADDRESS50 Clovenden Rd,, Loughgall, BT61 8LBLOCATION50m NW of 52 Cloveneden Road, LoughgallPROPOSAL Site for dwellingREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSITEM NO 6APPLIC NO O/2006/0440/O Outline Date Valid 16/03/2006APPLICANT Mr J CrozierAPPLIC ADDRESS149 Seaghan Road, ArmaghLOCATIONOpposite 149 Seaghan Road, ArmaghPROPOSAL Site for farm workers dwelling and garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies SP6/SP19/HOU8 and DES5 of the Department's 'A PlanningStrategy for Rural Northern Ireland' in that a building on this site would not integrate into thecountryside, as the site is unable to provide a suitable degree of enclosure due to the lack ofsufficient boundaries or any other means of achieving satisfactory integration, and as aconsequence would, if permitted, have an adverse impact on the landscape as it is undulyconspicuous.AGENT DETAILSMr Bell Bell Design Services, 123 Crosskeys Road, Armagh, BT60 3LD20 March 2008 Page 3 of 55

ITEM NO 7APPLIC NO O/2006/0496/RM Reserved Date Valid 28/03/2006APPLICANTAPPLIC ADDRESSMr Armstrong20 Irish Street, Richhill, Co.ArmaghLOCATIONTo the rear of 20 Irish Street, RichhillPROPOSAL Erection of 2 No. dwellingsREPRESENTATION 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr I Lenaghan Ian Lenaghan Design, 30 Moss Park, Richhill, Co Armagh,BT61 9PTITEM NO 8APPLIC NO O/2006/0507/O Outline Date Valid 31/03/2006APPLICANT J McnichollAPPLIC ADDRESS16 Corrigan Hill Road, Dungannon, BT71 6SLLOCATION40m south of 34 Causanagh Road LoughgallPROPOSAL Site for dwelling.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSITEM NO 9APPLIC NO O/2006/0519/O Outline Date Valid 05/04/2006APPLICANT Mr J McnallyAPPLIC ADDRESSC/o AgentLOCATION210 metres north north west of 94 Battlehill Road, Drumard, Richhill.PROPOSAL Site for replacement dwelling and garage.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr C Lindsey C T Lindsay, The Studio, 66 Marlacoo Road, Richhill,Co.Armagh, BT62 3JW20 March 2008 Page 4 of 55

ITEM NO 10APPLIC NO O/2006/0532/O Outline Date Valid 07/04/2006APPLICANT S HughesAPPLIC ADDRESSC/o AgentLOCATION140 metres north west of no. 49 Redrock Road, Cavangrow, ArmaghPROPOSAL Site for dwellingREPRESENTATION 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY1 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that there is apresumption against development throughout the countryside and it does not merit beingconsidered an exception to the policy nor are there any overriding reasons why thisdevelopment is essential and could not be located within a settlement.2 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY11 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that thedwelling would, if permitted result in a build-up of development when viewed with existing andapproved buildings; and would therefore result in a detrimental change to the rural characterof the countryside.3 The proposed development would, if permitted, prejudice the safety and convenience of roadusers since it proposes to use an existing access at which visibility cannot be provided to anadequate standard.AGENT DETAILSMs S Mcparland A-Three Architecture Design Planning, 43-45 ChurchStreet, Portadown, County Armagh, BT62 3EUITEM NO 11APPLIC NO O/2006/0569/O Outline Date Valid 21/04/2006APPLICANT Mr G MackleAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONC/o AgentBallyards Road, Millford (land to south side of 74 Hill Street and extending tothe Callan River)PROPOSAL Site for housing development and associated siteworksREPRESENTATION 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr S Houston McCreanor & Co. Architects, 85 Plantation Road,Craigavon, BT63 5NJ20 March 2008 Page 5 of 55

ITEM NO 12APPLIC NO O/2006/0577/F Full Date Valid 25/04/2006APPLICANT Mr & Mrs L MoneAPPLIC ADDRESS72 Ard NaGraine, Keady, BT60 2RGLOCATION150m East of No 9 Upper Darkley Road, KeadyPROPOSAL Erection of dwelling with integral garage, new gates and planting schemeREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies CTY4 of Draft PPS 14, Sustainable Development in theCountryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement and does not merit being consideredas an exceptional case as the stated need for this employees dwelling does not justify arelaxation of the strict planning controls in the countryside.2 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY10 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that: -theproposed dwelling is a prominent feature in the landscape;-the proposed site lacks longestablished natural boundaries and is unable to provide a suitable degree of enclosure for thebuilding to integrate into the landscape;-the proposed dwelling relies primarily on the use ofnew landscaping for integration;-the design of the proposed dwelling is inappropriate forthe site and its localityand therefore would not integrate into this area of the countryside.3 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY1 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that there is apresumption against development throughout the countryside and it does not merit beingconsidered an exception to the policy nor are there any overriding reasons why thisdevelopment is essential and could not be located within a settlement.AGENT DETAILSMr T Delahunt Delahunt Laverty Architects, 41-43 Downshire Road,Newry, Co Down, BT34 1EE20 March 2008 Page 6 of 55

ITEM NO 13APPLIC NO O/2006/0656/O Outline Date Valid 26/05/2006APPLICANT Mr & Mrs J RaffertyAPPLIC ADDRESS7 Ballymacnab Road, Tassagh, Co Armagh, BT60 2QSLOCATIONAdjacent to 48 Ballybrannon Road, ArmaghPROPOSAL Site for dwellingREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY1 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that there is apresumption against development throughout the countryside and it does not merit beingconsidered an exception to the policy nor are there any overriding reasons why thisdevelopment is essential and could not be located within a settlement.2 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY10 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that theproposed dwelling relies primarily on the use of new landscaping for integration and thereforewould not integrate into this area of the countryside.3 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY11 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that thedwelling would, if permitted result in a build-up of development when viewed with existing andapproved buildings and would therefore result in a detrimental change to the rural characterof the countryside.AGENT DETAILSMr G Rogers PDM Architects, 361a Ormeau Road, Belfast, BT7 3GLITEM NO 14APPLIC NO O/2006/0696/F Full Date Valid 12/06/2006APPLICANT Mr B GarveyAPPLIC ADDRESS9 Cashel Close, Newry, BT35 7DULOCATION500m south east of 153 Cladymilltown Road, CladyPROPOSAL Erection of replacement dwellingREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILS20 March 2008 Page 7 of 55

ITEM NO 15APPLIC NO O/2006/0739/O Outline Date Valid 23/06/2006APPLICANT Ms S DoyleAPPLIC ADDRESS45 Lagan Road, Keady, BT30 3ESLOCATION100m West of 54 Lagan Road, KeadyPROPOSAL Site for dwelling and garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr S Hagan John P Hagan, 17-21 Church Street, Portadown, BT62 3LNITEM NO 16APPLIC NO O/2006/0773/F Full Date Valid 30/06/2006APPLICANT Mr P MoneAPPLIC ADDRESS50 Caramoyle Estate, Keady, Armagh, BT60 2RNLOCATION144 Castleblaney Road, KeadyPROPOSAL Erection of replacement dwellingREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILS20 March 2008 Page 8 of 55

ITEM NO 17APPLIC NO O/2006/0899/O Outline Date Valid 05/09/2006APPLICANT Mr B KielAPPLIC ADDRESS15 Drumadd Road, Armagh, BT61 9EALOCATIONAdjacent to no. 15 Drumadd Road, ArmaghPROPOSAL Site for 6 no. ApartmentsREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposed development is unacceptable in that it would, if permitted, result in overdevelopment of the site, which is too small, narrow and restricted in depth to permit theerection of 6 apartments of reasonable design and dimensions and with adequate amenityspace.2 The proposed development fails to meet the requirements of QD1 in that it has not beenshown that:-(a) the development respects the surrounding context and is appropriate to thecharacter and topography of the site in terms of layout, scale, proportions, massing andappearance of buildings, structures and landscaped and hard surfaced areas;(c) adequateprovision is made for public and private open space and landscaped areas as an integral partof the development.(g) the design of the development draws upon the best local traditions ofform, materials and detailing;(h) the design and layout will not create conflict with adjacentland uses and there is no unacceptable adverse effect on existing or proposed properties interms of overlooking and loss of light.AGENT DETAILSMr K Mcelroy , McElroy House, 119 Bridge Street, PortadownITEM NO 18APPLIC NO O/2006/0916/F Full Date Valid 08/09/2006APPLICANT Messrs Wf PropertiesAPPLIC ADDRESSC/O AgentLOCATION4 Montague Street, TandrageePROPOSAL Alteration and extension to existing dwellingREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr D Anderson Anderson Architect, 92a Thomas Street, Portadown, CoArmagh, BT62 3AG20 March 2008 Page 9 of 55

ITEM NO 19APPLIC NO O/2006/0955/F Full Date Valid 18/09/2006APPLICANT Messrs Ct Lindsay Chartered Architect LtdAPPLIC ADDRESSThe Studio, 66 Marlacoo Road, Richhill, Co. Armagh, BT60 1JWLOCATION7-9 Irish Street, RichhillPROPOSAL Demolition of existing workshop/storage yard and erection of 2 No dwellingsREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr C Lindsey C T Lindsay, The Studio, 66 Marlacoo Road, Richhill,Co.Armagh, BT62 3JWITEM NO 20APPLIC NO O/2006/1016/F Full Date Valid 06/10/2006APPLICANT Mr S MullenAPPLIC ADDRESS84 Battleford Road, ArmaghLOCATION70m East of 7 Terraskane Road, ArmaghPROPOSAL Erection of loose stabling for horsesREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies CTY1 of Draft PPS 14, Sustainable Development in theCountryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement and does not merit being consideredas an exceptional case as the stated need for this loose stabling does not justify a relaxationof the strict planning controls in the countryside.AGENT DETAILSM Lavery , 58 Valley Lane, Corcreeny, Lurgan, BT66 7SF20 March 2008 Page 10 of 55

ITEM NO 21APPLIC NO O/2006/1037/O Outline Date Valid 09/10/2006APPLICANT Mr G DunnAPPLIC ADDRESS37 Mullurg Road,, Markethill, Armagh, BT60 1UBLOCATIONSouth of 37 Mullurg Road, Magherydogherty, Markethill, ArmaghPROPOSAL Site for one and a half storey replacement dwellingREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies CTY1 and CTY5 of Draft PPS 14, Sustainable Developmentin the Countryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement and does not merit beingconsidered as an exceptional case as the stated need for this replacement dwelling does notjustify a relaxation of the strict planning controls in the countryside.2 The proposal is contrary to Policies CTY1 and CTY5 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14,Sustainable Development in the Countryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement inthat it has not been demonstrated that the building that it is proposed to replace has ever beenlawfully used as a dwelling.3 The proposed development is unacceptable in that it would, if permitted, result in overdevelopment of the site, which is too restricted to permit the erection of a dwelling ofreasonable design and dimensions and with adequate amenity space.4 The proposed development would, if permitted, harm the living conditions of residents in No.37 Mullurg Road by reason of overlooking and consequent lack of privacy.AGENT DETAILSITEM NO 22APPLIC NO O/2006/1245/O Outline Date Valid 07/12/2006APPLICANT Mr E TurleyAPPLIC ADDRESS9 Acton Village, Poyntzpass, Newry, BT35 6TELOCATION9 Acton Village, Poyntzpass, NewryPROPOSAL Site for dwellingREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILS20 March 2008 Page 11 of 55

ITEM NO 23APPLIC NO O/2007/0099/LB Listed Building Date Valid 26/01/2007APPLICANT Mr M ShortAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSAL45 Tullymore Downs, ArmaghMillview House, 55 Dundrum Road, Tassagh, ArmaghDemolition of rear bay, provision of new return at rear to facilitate bedrooms,bathroom, kitchen, family room,ancillary areas, and restoration (AmendedScheme)REPRESENTATION 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILS Mr P Douglas Holmes & Doran, First Floor, The Old Savings Bank, 1Victoria Street, Armagh, BT61 9DSITEM NO 24APPLIC NO O/2007/0143/F Full Date Valid 14/02/2007APPLICANT Mr M ShortAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSAL45 Tullymore Downs, ArmaghMillview House, 55 Dundrum Road, Tassagh, ArmaghDemolition to rear bay provision of new rear return and renovations to existing(amended scheme)REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILS Mr P Douglas Holmes & Doran, First Floor, The Old Savings Bank, 1Victoria Street, Armagh, BT61 9DS20 March 2008 Page 12 of 55

ITEM NO 25APPLIC NO O/2007/0188/O Outline Date Valid 02/03/2007APPLICANT Mr MccourtAPPLIC ADDRESSC/O AgentLOCATION50M North West of 36 Crossnenagh Road, KeadyPROPOSAL Erection of replacement dwellingREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr E Morton , 104 Navanfort Road, Armagh, BT60 4PSITEM NO 26APPLIC NO O/2007/0228/F Full Date Valid 13/03/2007APPLICANT Messrs Jmw FarmsAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATION52 Cortynan Road, Armagh, BT60 4QZLand approximately 275 metres south east of 35 Tonnagh Road, Killylea,ArmaghPROPOSAL Retention of 2 No. Pig Breeding unitsREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr P Marshall Henry Marshall Brown Architectural Partnership, 10 UnionStreet, Cookstown, BT80 8NNITEM NO 27APPLIC NO O/2007/0387/F Full Date Valid 09/05/2007APPLICANT Mr L Mc ConeAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSAL128 Coolmillish Road, Mowhan200m NE of 127 Coolmillish Road, Ballycawley, ColloneChange of house type to that previously approved under applicationO/2005/0448/RMREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr J Austin Holmes and Doran, First Floor Old Savings Bank, 1 VictoriaStreet, Armagh, BT62 9DS20 March 2008 Page 13 of 55

ITEM NO 28APPLIC NO O/2007/0395/O Outline Date Valid 11/05/2007APPLICANT Mr M HutchinsonAPPLIC ADDRESS101 Derryraine Road, Collone, Armagh, BT60 1LLLOCATION90 metres south east of 118 Derryraine Road, Drumachee, ArmaghPROPOSAL Site for farm workers dwelling and garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies CTY1 of Draft PPS 14, Sustainable Development in theCountryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement and does not merit being consideredas an exceptional case as the stated need for this farmworkers dwelling does not justify arelaxation of the strict planning controls in the countryside.2 The proposal is contrary to Policies CTY1 and CTY2 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14,Sustainable Development in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement anddoes not merit being considered as an exceptional case, as there are alternative developmentopportunities available on the farm holding.3 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY10 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that theproposed site lacks long established natural boundaries and is unable to provide a suitabledegree of enclosure for the building to integrate into the landscape.4 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY11 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that thedwelling would, if permitted result in a build-up of development when viewed with existing andapproved buildings and would therefore result in a detrimental change to the rural characterof the countryside.AGENT DETAILSMr Wc Cornett Cornett Design Associates, 4 Hartford Place, The Mall,Armagh, BT61 9BTITEM NO 29APPLIC NO O/2007/0415/F Full Date Valid 17/05/2007APPLICANT P McadamAPPLIC ADDRESS14 Causanagh Road, LoughgallLOCATION14 Causanagh Road, LoughgallPROPOSAL Erection of domestic garage and Agricultural Store to the rear.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMichael McCorry RIBA, 192 Old Kilmore Road, Lurgan, Co.Armagh, BT679LR20 March 2008 Page 14 of 55

ITEM NO 30APPLIC NO O/2007/0589/F Full Date Valid 18/07/2007APPLICANT Mr E MccloryAPPLIC ADDRESS58a Action Road, Scarva, BT63 6LFLOCATION58a Acton Road, Scarva, BT63 6LFPROPOSAL Replacement dwellingREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr J Richardson , 9 Shanecracken, Markethill, Co Armagh, BT60 1TSITEM NO 31APPLIC NO O/2007/0627/F Full Date Valid 08/08/2007APPLICANT Mr D SmythAPPLIC ADDRESS65 Lisbofin Road, Blackwatertown, Dungannon, BT717JHLOCATIONApprox. 40m west of no.77 Charlemont Road, Blackwatertown, DungannonPROPOSAL Erection of two-storey dwelling & detached garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILS20 March 2008 Page 15 of 55

ITEM NO 32APPLIC NO O/2007/0628/O Outline Date Valid 08/08/2007APPLICANT S MackleAPPLIC ADDRESS44 Drumcullen Road, Dungannon, Co. Tyrone, BT717JGLOCATIONapprox. 60m south west of 44 Drumcullen Road, DungannonPROPOSAL Erection of dwellingREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY1 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that there is apresumption against development throughout the countryside and it does not merit beingconsidered an exception to the policy nor are there any overriding reasons why thisdevelopment is essential and could not be located within a settlement.2 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY10 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that theproposed site lacks long established natural boundaries and is unable to provide a suitabledegree of enclosure for the building to integrate into the landscape and therefore would notintegrate into this area of the countryside.3 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY11 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that: - thedwelling would, if permitted result in a build-up of development when viewed with existing andapproved buildings;- the dwelling would, if permitted create a ribbon of developmentand would therefore result in a detrimental change to the rural character of the countryside.4 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY12 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that thedevelopment would, if permitted, result in the creation of ribbon development along theDrumcullen Road and would therefore adversely affect the visual amenity and character ofthe countryside.AGENT DETAILSPeter McCaughey, 31 Gortnasaor, Dungannon, BT71 6DAITEM NO 33APPLIC NO O/2007/0635/RM Reserved Date Valid 13/08/2007APPLICANTAPPLIC ADDRESSP Nugent89 Derrymacash Road, CraigavonLOCATIONAdjacent and north of 30 Ballybrolly Road, TassaghPROPOSAL Erection of single storey dwelling with attached garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr J Austin , 100 Ardmore Road, Craigavon, BT66 6QP20 March 2008 Page 16 of 55

ITEM NO 34APPLIC NO O/2007/0667/F Full Date Valid 30/08/2007APPLICANT Mr MurphyAPPLIC ADDRESS42 Ballybrolly Road,, Tassagh,, Armagh, BT60 2MPLOCATION30M North of 43 Ballybrolly Road, Tassagh, ArmaghPROPOSAL Erection of a farm dwelling and domestic garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies CTY1 and CTY2 of Draft PPS 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement and does notmerit being considered as an exceptional case as the stated need for this farm dwelling doesnot justify a relaxation of the strict planning controls in the countryside.2 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY1 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that there is apresumption against development throughout the countryside and it does not merit beingconsidered an exception to the policy nor are there any overriding reasons why thisdevelopment is essential and could not be located within a settlement.3 The proposal is contrary to Policies CTY1 and CTY2 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14,Sustainable Development in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement anddoes not merit being considered as an exceptional case, in that it has not been demonstratedthat:-the proposed dwelling is essential to meet the needs of the farm;-the proposeddwelling is essential for the proper functioning of the farm for a worker to be readily availableat most times;-the need for a dwelling relates to a full-time farm worker who is mainlyinvolved in agriculture;4 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY10 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that: -theproposed dwelling is a prominent feature in the landscape;the proposed site lacks longestablished natural boundaries and is unable to provide a suitable degree of enclosure for thebuilding to integrate into the landscape;-the design of the proposed dwelling isinappropriate for the site and its localityand therefore would not integrate into this area ofthe countryside.5 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY11 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that: -thedwelling would, if permitted, be unduly prominent in the landscape;and would thereforeresult in a detrimental change to the rural character of the countryside.AGENT DETAILSMr J Collins Collins & Collins, 18 Margaret Street, Newry, Co Down, BT341DF20 March 2008 Page 17 of 55

ITEM NO 35APPLIC NO O/2007/0695/O Outline Date Valid 10/09/2007APPLICANT Mr J McaleeseAPPLIC ADDRESS11 Terryhoogan Road, Scarva, Craigavon, BT63 6NFLOCATION120 metres south east of 11 Terryhoogan Road, ScarvaPROPOSAL Site for a single storey dwelling and domestic garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY1 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that there is apresumption against development throughout the countryside and it does not merit beingconsidered an exception to the policy nor are there any overriding reasons why thisdevelopment is essential and could not be located within a settlement.2 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY11 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that thedwelling would, if permitted, be unduly prominent in the landscape3 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY10 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that: theproposed site is unable to provide a suitable degree of enclosure for the building to integrateinto the landscape.AGENT DETAILSITEM NO 36APPLIC NO O/2007/0698/F Full Date Valid 11/09/2007APPLICANT Mr S LennonAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSAL& Mrs Ciara Lennon, 1 Rathmoyle Park, Keady, Co.Armagh, BT60 2XD15 metres west of 10 Annvale Heights, KeadyErection of a Split Level dwelling with integrated garage & associatedlandscapingREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr S Lennon Atlantic Architects Ltd, 22-24 Great Strand Street, Dublin20 March 2008 Page 18 of 55

ITEM NO 37APPLIC NO O/2007/0714/O Outline Date Valid 14/09/2007APPLICANT Mr J Mc ClellandAPPLIC ADDRESS19 Ballybrolly Road, Tassagh, ArmaghLOCATION17 Ballybrolly Road, ArmaghPROPOSAL Site for replacement dwelling and garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies CTY1 and CTY5 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14,Sustainable Development in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement anddoes not merit being considered as an exceptional case as;it has not been demonstratedthat the property is, or was last lawfully used as a dwelling house therefore the residentialuse has been abandoned.AGENT DETAILSMr Bell Bell Design Services, 123 Crosskeys Road, Armagh, BT60 3LDITEM NO 38APPLIC NO O/2007/0716/F Full Date Valid 17/09/2007APPLICANT Mr M O'CallaghanAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSALC/o Agent60 metres south west of 116 Armagh Road, NewtownhamiltonVariation of condition No. 3 (single storey condition) & 4 (Ridge Height of6.5m), stated on outline approval (O/2003/0474/O)REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY10 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that: it isunable to provide a suitable degree of enclosure for the building to integrate into the landscapeand therefore would not integrate into this area of the countryside.2 The proposal is contrary to Policies SP6, HOU8 and DES5 of the Department's 'A PlanningStrategy for Rural Northern Ireland' in that a building on this site would not integrate into thecountryside, as the site is unable to provide a suitable degree of enclosure due to the lack ofsufficient boundaries or any other means of achieving satisfactory integration, and as aconsequence would, if permitted, have an adverse impact on the landscape as it is undulyconspicuous.AGENT DETAILSMr J Kerr JPM Kerr Chartered Surveyors, 1st Floor, 21A Railway Street,Armagh, BT61 7HP20 March 2008 Page 19 of 55

ITEM NO 39APPLIC NO O/2007/0718/F Full Date Valid 17/09/2007APPLICANT Mr S McnultyAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSALC/o Agent170 meters south west of 65 Cladymilltown Road, MarkethillRemoval of conditions 3 and 7, variation to condition 4 to allow 7.5 meter ridgeheight and variation to condition 5 of current outline approval.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY10 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that:theproposed site lacks long established natural boundaries and is unable to provide a suitabledegree of enclosure for the building to integrate into the landscape.2 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY11 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in thattheproposed dwelling is a prominent feature in the landscape,AGENT DETAILSMr A O'Hare O'Hare Associates, The Master's House, Abbey Yard, Newry,Co Down, BT34 2EG20 March 2008 Page 20 of 55

ITEM NO 40APPLIC NO O/2007/0719/O Outline Date Valid 17/09/2007APPLICANT Mrs D KeysAPPLIC ADDRESS145 Tirnascobe Road, Richhill, BT619RFLOCATIONAdjacent to 145 Tirnascobe Road, RichhillPROPOSAL Site for DwellingREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies CTY1 of Draft PPS 14, Sustainable Development in theCountryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement and does not merit being consideredas an exceptional case as the stated need for this dwelling does not justify a relaxation of thestrict planning controls in the countryside.2 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY1 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that there is apresumption against development throughout the countryside and it does not merit beingconsidered an exception to the policy nor are there any overriding reasons why thisdevelopment is essential and could not be located within a settlement.3 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY11 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that: thedwelling would, if permitted result in a build-up of development when viewed with existing andapproved buildings and would therefore result in a detrimental change to the rural characterof the countryside.4 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY12 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that thedevelopment would, if permitted, result in the creation of ribbon development along TirnascobeRoad and would therefore adversely affect the visual amenity and character of thecountryside.5 The proposed development would, if permitted, prejudice the safety and convenience of roadusers since it would not be possible within the application site to provide adequate sight lineswhere the proposed access joins Tirnascobe RoadAGENT DETAILSMr K Mcelroy , McElroy House, 119 Bridge Street, Portadown20 March 2008 Page 21 of 55

ITEM NO 41APPLIC NO O/2007/0728/RM Reserved Date Valid 17/09/2007APPLICANTAPPLIC ADDRESSMr M O'CallaghanC/o JPM Kerr, Chartered SurveyorsLOCATION60 metres south west of 116 Armagh Road, Newtownhamilton, Co ArmaghPROPOSAL Erection of a single storey dwellingREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr J Kerr JPM Kerr Chartered Surveyors, 1st Floor, 21A Railway Street,Armagh, BT61 7HPITEM NO 42APPLIC NO O/2007/0758/O Outline Date Valid 27/09/2007APPLICANT B HughesAPPLIC ADDRESS93 Kinelown Street, Keady, Co. Armagh, BT60 3TLLOCATION300 metres south east of no. 47 Ballymacnab Road, Armagh.PROPOSAL Site for dwelling.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies CTY1 of Draft PPS 14, Sustainable Development in theCountryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement and does not merit being consideredas an exceptional case as the stated need for this dwelling does not justify a relaxation of thestrict planning controls in the countryside.2 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY11 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that: thedwelling would, if permitted not respect the traditional pattern of settlement exhibited in thatarea and would therefore result in a detrimental change to the rural character of thecountryside.3 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY12 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that thedevelopment would, if permitted, result in the creation of ribbon development alongBallymacnab Road and would therefore adversely affect the visual amenity and character ofthe countryside.AGENT DETAILSMr A Hughes , 93 Main Street, Keady, Co Armagh20 March 2008 Page 22 of 55

ITEM NO 43APPLIC NO O/2007/0766/O Outline Date Valid 02/10/2007APPLICANT Mr P CallaghanAPPLIC ADDRESS15 Carrickabolie Road, Derrynoose, ArmaghLOCATIONAdjacent to 15 Carrickabolie Road, Derrynoose, ArmaghPROPOSAL Site for dwelling and garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY1 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that there is apresumption against development throughout the countryside and it does not merit beingconsidered an exception to the policy nor are there any overriding reasons why thisdevelopment is essential and could not be located within a settlement.AGENT DETAILSMr Bell Bell Design Services, 123 Crosskeys Road, Armagh, BT60 3LDITEM NO 44APPLIC NO O/2007/0769/F Full Date Valid 02/10/2007APPLICANT Mr J MchughAPPLIC ADDRESSC/o AgentLOCATIONNo.32 Derrygavad Road, Portadown.PROPOSAL Erection of rural replacement dwelling and detached garage.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies CTY1 and CTY5 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14,Sustainable Development in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement anddoes not merit being considered as an exceptional case as; it has not been demonstrated thatthe property is, or was last lawfully used as a dwelling house therefore the residential usehas been abandoned.2 The proposal is contrary to Policies CTY1 and CTY5 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14,Sustainable Development in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement anddoes not merit being considered as an exceptional case in that;the proposed replacementdwelling would have a visual impact significantly greater than the existing property;theproposed replacement dwelling is not sited within the established curtilage of the existingproperty and it has not been demonstrated that the alternative position nearby would result inclear landscape, heritage, access or amenity benefits.AGENT DETAILSMr B. Mckevitt B & D Property Services Ltd.,, 261 Dublin Road,, Killeen,,Newry,, Co. Down., BT35 8RY20 March 2008 Page 23 of 55

ITEM NO 45APPLIC NO O/2007/0774/O Outline Date Valid 03/10/2007APPLICANT K SintonAPPLIC ADDRESS14 Moyrourkan Road, Tandragee, Co. ArmaghLOCATION80 metres north east of 21 Moyrourkan Road, TandrageePROPOSAL Site for dwelling and garage.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY1 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that there is apresumption against development throughout the countryside and it does not merit beingconsidered an exception to the policy nor are there any overriding reasons why thisdevelopment is essential and could not be located within a settlement.2 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY10 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that: theproposed site lacks long established natural boundaries and is unable to provide a suitabledegree of enclosure for the building to integrate into the landscape and therefore would notintegrate into this area of the countryside.3 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY11 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that: thedwelling would, if permitted, be unduly prominent in the landscape and would therefore resultin a detrimental change to the rural character of the countryside.AGENT DETAILSMr J Richardson , 9 Shanecracken, Markethill, Co Armagh, BT60 1TSITEM NO 46APPLIC NO O/2007/0777/F Full Date Valid 02/10/2007APPLICANT Mr Mc ClellandAPPLIC ADDRESS19 Ballybrolly Road, Tassagh, Co. Armagh, BT60 2QGLOCATION200m N.E of 14 Cargaclougher Road, Racarbry, KeadyPROPOSAL Variation of Condition 6 of granted outline O/2005/1364/OREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSCornett Design Associates, 4 Hartford Place,, The Mall,, Armagh, BT619BJ20 March 2008 Page 24 of 55

ITEM NO 47APPLIC NO O/2007/0778/F Full Date Valid 05/10/2007APPLICANT Mr B BeaganAPPLIC ADDRESS240 Newtownhamilton Road, Armagh, BT60 2QPLOCATION30 metres south east of 15 Killyfaddy Road, ArmaghPROPOSAL Erection of a dwelling house.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY1 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that there is apresumption against development throughout the countryside and it does not merit beingconsidered an exception to the policy nor are there any overriding reasons why thisdevelopment is essential and could not be located within a settlement.2 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY10 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that: theproposed site lacks long established natural boundaries and is unable to provide a suitabledegree of enclosure for the building to integrate into the landscape.AGENT DETAILSMr N. Mckee , 34 Foley Road,, Armagh., BT60 2QXITEM NO 48APPLIC NO O/2007/0782/RM Reserved Date Valid 02/10/2007APPLICANTAPPLIC ADDRESSMr & Mrs M Grew85 Ballygassoon Road, Armagh, BT61 8ADLOCATION150 metres north of no.19 Moore Island Road, LoughallPROPOSAL Erection of dwelling.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr E Mccallan McCallan Building Design, 1 Main Street, Carrickmore,Omagh, BT79 9AY20 March 2008 Page 25 of 55

ITEM NO 49APPLIC NO O/2007/0793/F Full Date Valid 10/10/2007APPLICANT Mr & Mrs S CrozierAPPLIC ADDRESS100 Seagahan Road, Collone, Armagh, BT60 2BJLOCATION300 metres north west of 39 Foley Road, Armagh.PROPOSAL Erection of dwelling.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr N. Mckee , 34 Foley Road,, Armagh., BT60 2QXITEM NO 50APPLIC NO O/2007/0801/F Full Date Valid 09/10/2007APPLICANT Mr N AdairAPPLIC ADDRESS55 Fedney Road, Banbridge, BT34 3PNLOCATION140 metres east of 47 Tandragee Road, Markethill.PROPOSAL Erection of dwelling and garage.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies CTY 1 of Draft PPS 14, Sustainable Development in theCountryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement and does not merit being consideredas an exceptional case as the stated need for this dwelling does not justify a relaxation of thestrict planning controls in the countryside.2 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY11 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that thedwelling would, if permitted result in a build-up of development when viewed with existing andapproved buildings and the dwelling would, if permitted create or add to a ribbon ofdevelopment and would therefore result in a detrimental change to the rural character of thecountryside.3 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY10 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that theproposed site lacks long established natural boundaries is unable to provide a suitable degreeof enclosure for the building to integrate into the landscape and therefore would not integrateinto this area of the countryside.AGENT DETAILSMessrs T.J Dreaning T.J Dreaning, 135 Banbridge Road,, Donaghcloney,,Craigavon, BT66 7PJ20 March 2008 Page 26 of 55

ITEM NO 51APPLIC NO O/2007/0802/O Outline Date Valid 05/10/2007APPLICANT Mr B HughesAPPLIC ADDRESS183 Castleblayney Road, Drumherney, Keady, BT60 3HYLOCATIONLands adjacent to no.8 Drumherney Road, Keady, Armagh, BT60 3AT.PROPOSAL Site for dwelling and detached garage.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies CTY1 of Draft PPS 14, Sustainable Development in theCountryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement and does not merit being consideredas an exceptional case as the stated need for this dwelling does not justify a relaxation of thestrict planning controls in the countryside.2 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY10 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that theproposed site lacks long established natural boundaries and is unable to provide a suitabledegree of enclosure for the building to integrate into the landscape and therefore would notintegrate into this area of the countryside.AGENT DETAILSMs F Cleland , Tower House, Sheils Houses, Tower Hill, Armagh, BT619DWITEM NO 52APPLIC NO O/2007/0813/RM Reserved Date Valid 09/10/2007APPLICANTAPPLIC ADDRESSMr L Mcclelland147 Dundrum Road, Tassagh, Armagh, BT60 2MGLOCATIONAdjoining and north east of 143 Tassagh Road, Ballybrolly, Armagh.PROPOSAL Erection of dwelling and garage.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSCornett Design Associates, 4 Hartford Place,, The Mall,, Armagh, BT619BJ20 March 2008 Page 27 of 55

ITEM NO 53APPLIC NO O/2007/0817/F Full Date Valid 12/10/2007APPLICANT Mr N ChambersAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSALC/o Agent23 Kilmachugh Road, Markethill.Extension to dwelling to provide ground floor sunroom and porch andproposed garage.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSPrestige Homes, Prestige Homes, 1 Lismore Road, Ballygawley, BT702ND20 March 2008 Page 28 of 55

ITEM NO 54APPLIC NO O/2007/0819/F Full Date Valid 15/10/2007APPLICANT Mr & Mrs S MoleyAPPLIC ADDRESS11 Ashbrook Mews, Newry, Co.Down, BT34 1SJLOCATION30m South-west of 17 Ballyvally Road, Loughgilly. Co.Armagh. BT60 2DH.PROPOSAL Erection of dwelling house.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies (CTY1) (CTY2) (CTY3) (CTY4) (CTY5) of Draft PPS 14,Sustainable Development in the Countryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement anddoes not merit being considered as an exceptional case as the stated need for this(dwelling/farmworkers dwelling/ farm retirement dwelling/employees dwelling/ replacementdwelling) does not justify a relaxation of the strict planning controls in the countryside.2 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY10 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that theproposed dwelling is a prominent feature in the landscape and therefore would not integrateinto this area of the countryside.3 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY11 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that thedwelling would, if permitted, be unduly prominent in the landscape; the dwelling would, ifpermitted result in a build-up of development when viewed with existing and approvedbuildings; the dwelling would, if permitted create or add to a ribbon of development; and wouldtherefore result in a detrimental change to the rural character of the countryside.4 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY12 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that thedevelopment would, if permitted, result in the creation of ribbon development along theBallyvally Road and would therefore adversely affect the visual amenity and character of thecountryside.AGENT DETAILSMr N. Mckee , 34 Foley Road,, Armagh., BT60 2QX20 March 2008 Page 29 of 55

ITEM NO 55APPLIC NO O/2007/0825/RM Reserved Date Valid 12/10/2007APPLICANTAPPLIC ADDRESSJ RiceC/O AgentLOCATIONAdjacent to 29 Ballynagalliah Road, Armagh.PROPOSAL Erection of dwelling and associated works.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMcCreanor & Co Architects, 85 Plantation Road, Ballydougan, Craigavon,BT63 5NJITEM NO 56APPLIC NO O/2007/0832/O Outline Date Valid 18/10/2007APPLICANT Mr P MckinneyAPPLIC ADDRESSC/o AgentLOCATION60metres north east of 9 Laurelvale Road, Tandragee.PROPOSAL Site for private dwelling.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies CTY1 of Draft PPS 14, Sustainable Development in theCountryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement and does not merit being consideredas an exceptional case as the stated need for this dwelling does not justify a relaxation of thestrict planning controls in the countryside.AGENT DETAILSMr L Warren ML Design & Management, 25-27 Edward Street, Portadown,Co Armagh, BT62 3NE20 March 2008 Page 30 of 55

ITEM NO 57APPLIC NO O/2007/0838/F Full Date Valid 19/10/2007APPLICANT Mr P O'HareAPPLIC ADDRESS113 Newtownhamilton Road, Lisnadill, Armagh, BT60 2QULOCATION80M West of 8 Latmacollum Road, Lisnadill, ArmaghPROPOSAL Variation of condition 4 of Granted outline: O/2004/0634/O.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY10 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that: -theproposed dwelling is a prominent feature in the landscape;-the proposed site lacks longestablished natural boundaries and is unable to provide a suitable degree of enclosure for thebuilding to integrate into the landscape;and therefore would not integrate into this area ofthe countryside.2 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY11 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that: -thedwelling would, if permitted, be unduly prominent in the landscape;-the dwelling would, ifpermitted result in a build-up of development when viewed with existing and approvedbuildings;and would therefore result in a detrimental change to the rural character of thecountryside.AGENT DETAILSCornett Design Associates, 4 Hartford Place,, The Mall,, Armagh, BT619BJITEM NO 58APPLIC NO O/2007/0843/F Full Date Valid 19/10/2007APPLICANT Mrs O HughesAPPLIC ADDRESSC/o JpmLOCATIONHughes Bar & Lounge, Main Street, Middletown, Co. Armagh.PROPOSAL Change of use of rear store to off-licence.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr J Kerr JPM Kerr Chartered Surveyors, First Floor, 21A Railway Street,Armagh, BT61 7HP20 March 2008 Page 31 of 55

ITEM NO 59APPLIC NO O/2007/0854/F Full Date Valid 24/10/2007APPLICANT Mr P GildernewAPPLIC ADDRESSCrievelough, The Brantry, DungannonLOCATION100m North-East of 266 Monaghan Road, Doogary Tynan, Armagh.PROPOSAL Erection of Dwelling House.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSJ Aidan Kelly Ltd, 50 Tullycullion Road, Dungannon, BT70 3LYITEM NO 60APPLIC NO O/2007/0871/F Full Date Valid 30/10/2007APPLICANT Mr A RedpathAPPLIC ADDRESS17 Linen Green, Milford, ArmaghLOCATION140 metres east of 8 Latmacollum Road, Armagh, BT60 2AP.PROPOSAL Erection of dwelling and private garage.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY1 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that there is apresumption against development throughout the countryside and it does not merit beingconsidered an exception to the policy nor are there any overriding reasons why thisdevelopment is essential and could not be located within a settlement.2 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY10 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that theproposed site lacks long established natural boundaries and is unable to provide a suitabledegree of enclosure for the building to integrate into the landscape, the design of theproposed dwelling is inappropriate for the site and its locality and therefore would notintegrate into this area of the countryside.AGENT DETAILSMr Jr Rollston John Rollston, 88 Fellows Hall Road, Killylea, Armagh,BT60 4LZ20 March 2008 Page 32 of 55

ITEM NO 61APPLIC NO O/2007/0872/O Outline Date Valid 30/10/2007APPLICANT Mr S GarveyAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONKnappagh Road, Killylea, ArmaghFronting Annaghananny Road, Killylea, Armagh, adjoining and north of itsjunction with Knappagh Road.PROPOSAL Site for dwelling and private garage.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY1 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that there is apresumption against development throughout the countryside and it does not merit beingconsidered an exception to the policy nor are there any overriding reasons why thisdevelopment is essential and could not be located within a settlement.AGENT DETAILSMr Jr Rollston John Rollston, 88 Fellows Hall Road, Killylea, Armagh,BT60 4LZITEM NO 62APPLIC NO O/2007/0876/O Outline Date Valid 31/10/2007APPLICANT J DowzellAPPLIC ADDRESS11 Essex Ridge, Laurelvale, BT62 2LLLOCATION80m South-East of 170 Moy Road, Portadown.PROPOSAL Site for dwelling and Garage.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY1 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that there is apresumption against development throughout the countryside and it does not merit beingconsidered an exception to the policy nor are there any overriding reasons why thisdevelopment is essential and could not be located within a settlement.2 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY10 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that theproposed site lacks long established natural boundaries/ is unable to provide a suitable degreeof enclosure for the building to integrate into the landscape and therefore would not integrateinto this area of the countryside.3 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY11 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that thedwelling would, if permitted result in a build-up of development when viewed with existing andproposed buildings and would therefore result in a detrimental change to the rural characterof the countryside.AGENT DETAILS20 March 2008 Page 33 of 55

ITEM NO 63APPLIC NO O/2007/0880/O Outline Date Valid 31/10/2007APPLICANT Mr A W WrightAPPLIC ADDRESS10 Ridgeway Park North, Portadown, Craigavon, BT62 3DGLOCATION22 Teaguy Road, Portadown, Craigavon, BT62 1NJ.PROPOSAL Site for replacement dwelling and domestic garage.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr J Woods Homeplan, 9A Tartaraghan Road, Portadown, Co.Armagh,BT62 1RQITEM NO 64APPLIC NO O/2007/0881/F Full Date Valid 02/11/2007APPLICANT Mr C.J.R BellAPPLIC ADDRESS236 Monaghan Road, Middletown, Armagh, BT60 4HQLOCATION40 Breaghey Road, Tynan. Co.Armagh. BT60 4SF.PROPOSAL Erection of replacement Dwelling.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILS20 March 2008 Page 34 of 55

ITEM NO 65APPLIC NO O/2007/0890/O Outline Date Valid 07/11/2007APPLICANT H AndersonAPPLIC ADDRESS15 Marlacoo Road, Hamiltonsbawn, ArmaghLOCATION130m West of No.15 Marlacoo Road, Hamiltonsbawn. Co.Armagh.PROPOSAL Site for Dwelling.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY1 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that there is apresumption against development throughout the countryside and it does not merit beingconsidered an exception to the policy nor are there any overriding reasons why thisdevelopment is essential and could not be located within a settlement.2 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY10 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that theproposed dwelling is a prominent feature in the landscape,the proposed site lacks longestablished natural boundaries is unable to provide a suitable degree of enclosure for thebuilding to integrate into the landscape and therefore would not integrate into this area of thecountryside.3 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY11 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that thedwelling would, if permitted result in a build-up of development when viewed with existingbuildings and would therefore result in a detrimental change to the rural character of thecountryside.4 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY12 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that thedevelopment would, if permitted, result in the creation of ribbon development along MarlacooRoad and would therefore adversely affect the visual amenity and character of thecountryside.5 The proposal is contrary to Policy PSU8 of the Department's Planning Strategy for RuralNorthern Ireland in that the development lies within a cordon sanitaire of a Sewage TreatmentWorks and would, if permitted, result in unacceptable living conditions for residents in theproposed dwelling by reason of severe odours [and noise] nuisance.AGENT DETAILSMr N Cornett , Cornett Design Associates, 4 Hartford Place, The Mall,Armagh, BT61 9BJ20 March 2008 Page 35 of 55

ITEM NO 66APPLIC NO O/2007/0895/RM Reserved Date Valid 06/11/2007APPLICANTAPPLIC ADDRESSMr B Donaghy10 Coolreena Road, LurganLOCATION130 Metres south of 33 Annvale Road, Armagh.PROPOSAL Erection of dwelling and garage.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr Bell Bell Design Services, 123 Crosskeys Road, Armagh, BT60 3LDITEM NO 67APPLIC NO O/2007/0907/RM Reserved Date Valid 09/11/2007APPLICANTAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONMr C Donaldson19 Ballybreagh Road, Portadown, BT62 3SZ60 metres South of No.4, and South East of access to No.4 Ballybreagh Road,Portadown. BT62 3SZ.PROPOSAL Erection of Farm workers dwelling, Garage and farm equipment store.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr L Sankey K.W.S. Design Services, 3 Mandeville Manor, Craigavon,Co.Armagh, BT62 3UP20 March 2008 Page 36 of 55

ITEM NO 68APPLIC NO O/2007/0964/RM Reserved Date Valid 26/10/2007APPLICANTAPPLIC ADDRESSG Kilpatrick217 Mowhan Road, Glenanne, Markethill, County ArmaghLOCATION60m East of 217 Mowhan Road, Glenanne. County Armagh.PROPOSAL Erection of Replacement Dwelling and integrated Garage.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSWoodwell Design, 8 Ballylane Road, Glenanne, Co. Armagh, BT60 2LQITEM NO 69APPLIC NO O/2007/0965/F Full Date Valid 30/11/2007APPLICANT Mr & Mrs D AstonAPPLIC ADDRESS77 Tandragee Road, MarkethillLOCATION77 Tandragee Road, Markethill.PROPOSAL Erection of replacement Dwelling with new vechicular access.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 1 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr N Cornett , Cornett Design Associates, 4 Hartford Place, The Mall,Armagh, BT61 9BJITEM NO 70APPLIC NO O/2007/0983/F Full Date Valid 07/12/2007APPLICANTAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATION4 Brambee Cottage,, Windmill Road,, Newry, BT34 2QW70M South and opposite No. 22 Corrinare Road, Loughgilly, Armagh, BT60 2DNPROPOSAL Change of house type from previously approved O/2004/1392/RMREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr M Bailie , 28 Cathedral Park, Downpatrick, BT30 6GF20 March 2008 Page 37 of 55

ITEM NO 71APPLIC NO O/2007/0992/RM Reserved Date Valid 06/12/2007APPLICANTAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONMr C Feely20 Cloghogue Road, Cullyhanna, Newry, BT35 9RF160 metres South East of 21 Corkley Road, Tassagh, Armagh, Co. Armagh,BT35 9RF.PROPOSAL Erection of dwelling and garage.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr J Collins Collins & Collins, 18 Margaret Street, Newry, Co Down, BT341DFITEM NO 72APPLIC NO O/2007/1000/RM Reserved Date Valid 14/12/2007APPLICANTAPPLIC ADDRESSMr D Hamilton2a Desert Road, NewryLOCATIONOpposite and 280 metres North of 80 Kilmahugh Road, Markethill.PROPOSAL Erection of dwelling and detatched garage.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr Mk Kearney Architectural Design Services, 20 Upper Burren Road,Warrenpoint, Co.Down, BT34 3PT20 March 2008 Page 38 of 55

ITEM NO 73APPLIC NO O/2007/1006/F Full Date Valid 17/12/2007APPLICANT Mr J HaganAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSAL16 Lislaslea Road, Moy, Co.Armagh, BT71 6TA145 Rock Road, Ballinahone Beg, Armagh.Alteration of condition No.3 from previous approval O/2005/0500/O to allow a7.5 metre Dwelling, and removal of condition No.4 to allow for an increasedfloor area.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY10 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that: -theproposed dwelling is a prominent feature in the landscape;-the proposed site lacks longestablished natural boundaries and is unable to provide a suitable degree of enclosure for thebuilding to integrate into the landscapeand therefore would not integrate into this area ofthe countryside.AGENT DETAILSP.M. Mckernan , 25 Keady Road, Armagh, BT60 4AAITEM NO 74APPLIC NO O/2007/1013/RM Reserved Date Valid 17/12/2007APPLICANTAPPLIC ADDRESS95a Villawood Road,, Dromore, BT25 1LQLOCATION60M South of No.12 Drumatee Road, MarkethillPROPOSAL Erection of dwelling and garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr P K Skelly P S Design, 49 Hillsborough Road, Carryduff, BT8 8HS20 March 2008 Page 39 of 55

ITEM NO 75APPLIC NO O/2007/1025/F Full Date Valid 21/12/2007APPLICANT Mr W AtkinsonAPPLIC ADDRESS2 Dunesmullen Road, MarkethillLOCATION2 Dunesmullen Road, MarkethillPROPOSAL Erection of porch and garage conversion to granny flatREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSBell Design Services, 123 Crosskeys Road, Armagh, BT60 3LDITEM NO 76APPLIC NO O/2007/1026/F Full Date Valid 20/12/2007APPLICANT Mr & Mrs L McatarsneyAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSAL37 Creenagh Road, Loughgall100M NW of 56 Kilmacanty Road, Kilmore, PortadownVariation of condition no. 5 of approved outline reference O/2004/0624/O forerection of a new dwelling.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY10 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that: theproposed site lacks long established natural boundaries and is unable to provide a suitabledegree of enclosure for the building to integrate into the landscape and therefore would notintegrate into this area of the countryside.2 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY11 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that: thedwelling would, if permitted, be unduly prominent in the landscape and would therefore resultin a detrimental change to the rural character of the countryside.AGENT DETAILSAmy Mcgookin , 6 Knockmoyle Road, Antrim, BT41 1HE20 March 2008 Page 40 of 55

ITEM NO 77APPLIC NO O/2007/1029/F Full Date Valid 27/12/2007APPLICANT McclincheAPPLIC ADDRESSC/O AgentLOCATION15 Drumart Road, Tandragee, Co. Armagh, BT60 1RJPROPOSAL Erection of replacement dwelling and garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 1 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies CTY1 and CTY5 of Draft PPS 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement and does notmerit being considered as an exceptional case as the stated need for this replacementdwelling does not justify a relaxation of the strict planning controls in the countryside.2 The proposal is contrary to Policies CTY1 and CTY5 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14,Sustainable Development in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement anddoes not merit being considered as an exceptional case in that;the proposed replacementdwelling would have a visual impact significantly greater than the existing dwelling;theproposed replacement dwelling is not sited within the established curtilage of the existingdwelling and it has not been demonstrated that the alternative position nearby would result inclear landscape, heritage, access or amenity benefits;the overall size of the new dwellingdoes not allow it to integrate into the surrounding landscape.3 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY10 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that: theproposed dwelling is a prominent feature in the landscape; the proposed site lacks longestablished natural boundaries and is unable to provide a suitable degree of enclosure for thebuilding and therefore would not integrate into this area of the countryside.4 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY11 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that: thedwelling would, if permitted, be unduly prominent in the landscape and would therefore resultin a detrimental change to the rural character of the countryside.AGENT DETAILSMr D Whiteside , 9 Bessbrook Road, Markethill, Co.Armagh, BT60 1RJ20 March 2008 Page 41 of 55

ITEM NO 78APPLIC NO O/2007/1035/F Full Date Valid 27/12/2007APPLICANT Mr & Mrs J RiceAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSALC/O AgentAdjacent to 29 Ballynagalliagh Road, Armagh.Non compliance with condtion 4 ( siting restriction) attached to outlineplanning permission granted under file reference O/2003/1293/O.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSKb Barry McCreanor & Co. Architects, 85 Plantation Road, Craigavon,BT63 5NJITEM NO 79APPLIC NO O/2008/0005/RM Reserved Date Valid 27/12/2007APPLICANTAPPLIC ADDRESSMr T McclinchieC/O AgentLOCATION50m South of no 15 Drumart Road, TandrageePROPOSAL Erection of dwelling and attached garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr D Whiteside , 9 Bessbrook Road, Markethill, Co.Armagh, BT60 1RJITEM NO 80APPLIC NO O/2008/0006/RM Reserved Date Valid 27/12/2007APPLICANTAPPLIC ADDRESSMr M JohnstonHillcrest Farm, Springhill Road, Upper Lisdrumchor, GlenanneLOCATIONHillcrest Farm, Springhill Road, Upper Lisdrumchor, Glenanne.PROPOSAL Erection of replacement dwelling and private garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSJ Rollston , 88 Fellowshall Road, Killylea, Armagh, BT60 4LZ20 March 2008 Page 42 of 55

ITEM NO 81APPLIC NO O/2008/0008/RM Reserved Date Valid 31/12/2007APPLICANTAPPLIC ADDRESSMr S Mcsherry37 Springhill Road, Glenanne, Co.ArmaghLOCATION80 Metres South West of 37 Springhill Road, Glenanne.PROPOSAL Erection of new Dwelling and Detached Garage.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr A O'Hare O'Hare Associates, The Master's House, Abbey Yard, Newry,Co Down, BT34 2EGITEM NO 82APPLIC NO O/2008/0033/F Full Date Valid 10/01/2008APPLICANT Mr & Mrs G OatesAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSAL19 Ballymoran Road, Latmacollum, Armagh, BT60 2AW19 Ballymoran Road, Latmacollum, Armagh.Erection of single storey rear Extension, Entrance Porch and installation ofSolar panels.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMs F Cleland , Tower House, Shiels' Houses, Tower Hill, Armagh, BT619DW20 March 2008 Page 43 of 55

ITEM NO 83APPLIC NO O/2008/0040/RM Reserved Date Valid 10/01/2008APPLICANTAPPLIC ADDRESSMr J Woods5 Ivy Park, Middletown, ArmaghLOCATION110 Metres South East of 22 Drumahean Road, Middletown, Armagh.PROPOSAL Erection of Bungalow and Garage.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr Bell Bell Design Services, 123 Crosskeys Road, Armagh, BT60 3LDITEM NO 84APPLIC NO O/2008/0046/RM Reserved Date Valid 14/01/2008APPLICANTAPPLIC ADDRESSW.G. Carson14 Ballygroobany Road, Richhill, Co.Armagh, BT61 9NHLOCATION280 Metres South West of No.6 Ballyloughan Road, Hamiltonsbawn.PROPOSAL Erection of Dwelling and Garage.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr J Richardson , 9 Shanecracken, Markethill, Co Armagh, BT60 1TSITEM NO 85APPLIC NO O/2008/0047/F Full Date Valid 11/01/2008APPLICANT P & P Cullen & JordanAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSAL74 Tullysaran Road, Armagh, BT61 8HE74 Tullysarran Road, Drumbee, Co ArmaghConstruction of an underground slurry tank to comply with with the farmnutrient management scheme & erection of cow house accomodation.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILS20 March 2008 Page 44 of 55

ITEM NO 86APPLIC NO O/2008/0048/F Full Date Valid 15/01/2008APPLICANT Mrs A StewartAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSALLittle Lodge, Kitty's Lane, Annareagh Road, RichhillLand's adjacent to Course Lodge, 98 metres North East of junction ofAnnareagh Road, and Kitty's Lane, Richhill.Variation of approval O/2006/0680/rm (condition 2) to limit occupancy conditionto a period of 5 years.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr H Turner Turner Associates, 1 Acre Fold, Addingham, Ilkley, WestYorkshire, LS29 OTHITEM NO 87APPLIC NO O/2008/0054/RM Reserved Date Valid 14/01/2008APPLICANTAPPLIC ADDRESSW.G. Carson14 Ballygroobany Road, Richhill, Co.Armagh, BT61 9NHLOCATION300 Metres South West of No.6 Ballyloughan Road, Hamiltonsbawn.PROPOSAL Erection of Dwelling and GarageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr J Richardson , 9 Shanecracken, Markethill, Co Armagh, BT60 1TS20 March 2008 Page 45 of 55

ITEM NO 88APPLIC NO O/2008/0057/F Full Date Valid 16/01/2008APPLICANT Northern Ireland ElectricityAPPLIC ADDRESSCarn Industrial Estate, Portadown, BT63 5QJLOCATIONRear of 92 Markethill Road, Collone, Armagh.PROPOSAL Overhead single phase line on wooden poles.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMs P Mckenna Northern Ireland Electricity, Connect, Carn IndustrialEstate, Portadown, Co. Armagh, BT63 5QJITEM NO 89APPLIC NO O/2008/0063/F Full Date Valid 18/01/2008APPLICANT Vinecash Presbyterian ChuchAPPLIC ADDRESSC/O Rev R I A Allely, 11 Mandeville Manor, Portadown, BT62 3UPLOCATION7 Battlehill Road, Ballintaggart, RichhillPROPOSAL Proposed extension and alterations to existing church and church hall.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSCornett Design Associates, 4 Hartford Place,, The Mall,, Armagh, BT619BJITEM NO 90APPLIC NO O/2008/0070/RM Reserved Date Valid 21/01/2008APPLICANTAPPLIC ADDRESSMr S Martin28 Terryhoogan Road, ScarvaLOCATIONOpposite 33 Terryhoogan Road, Scarva.PROPOSAL Erection of 1 no dwelling.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr S R Rogan Stephen Rogan, Architectual Design, 1 Riverview, HuntlyRoad, Banbridge20 March 2008 Page 46 of 55

ITEM NO 91APPLIC NO O/2008/0081/RM Reserved Date Valid 23/01/2008APPLICANTAPPLIC ADDRESSR Bain97 Annvale Road, Keady, ArmaghLOCATION140 metres South East of 203 Dundrum Road, Tassagh, Armagh.PROPOSAL Erection of replacement dwelling and garage.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSBell Design Services, 123 Crosskeys Road, Armagh, BT60 3LDITEM NO 92APPLIC NO O/2008/0087/F Full Date Valid 28/01/2008APPLICANT Mrs L RitchieAPPLIC ADDRESS49 Mullalelish Road, Richhill, BT61 9JZLOCATION49 Mullalelish Road, Richhill.PROPOSAL Erection of extension.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr K Mcelroy , McElroy House, 119 Bridge Street, PortadownITEM NO 93APPLIC NO O/2008/0088/F Full Date Valid 28/01/2008APPLICANT Mr B B BeattieAPPLIC ADDRESS142 Tirnascobe Road, Richhill, Co ArmaghLOCATION142 Tirnascobe Road, Richhill, Co ArmaghPROPOSAL Creation of vehicular accessREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr I Lenaghan Ian Lenaghan Design, 30 Moss Park, Richhill, Co Armagh,BT61 9PT20 March 2008 Page 47 of 55

ITEM NO 94APPLIC NO O/2008/0093/F Full Date Valid 30/01/2008APPLICANT Mr R L LeetchAPPLIC ADDRESS73 Mullanasilla Road, Armagh, BT61 9HNLOCATION140m East of No.55 Mullansilla Road, ArmaghPROPOSAL Installation of a 15 metre high wind turbineREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMcguigan Horizon Renewables, Unit 2,, 3 Blackstaffway,, Belfast, BT119DSITEM NO 95APPLIC NO O/2008/0095/F Full Date Valid 30/01/2008APPLICANT Mr J RaffertyAPPLIC ADDRESS9 Tullynacross Road, PoyntzpassLOCATION9 Tullynacross Road, Poyntzpass.PROPOSAL Extension to Dwelling.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILS Gj Mitchell Architectural Design GJ Mitchell Architectural Design, 16Eleastan Park, Kilkeel, Co.Down, BT34 4DAITEM NO 96APPLIC NO O/2008/0097/F Full Date Valid 31/01/2008APPLICANT Mr Gmcf Mc FarlandAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSALC/O Agent, 15 Stranmillis Road, Belfast, BT9 5AF11A Grove Terrace, Armagh.Erection of 2 storey rear extension to existing dwelling to allow kitchen/utility onground floor with bedroom cover.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSLeighton Johnston Associates, 15 Stranmillis Road, BT9 5AF20 March 2008 Page 48 of 55

ITEM NO 97APPLIC NO O/2008/0101/F Full Date Valid 01/02/2008APPLICANT Mr W GeorgeAPPLIC ADDRESS28 Cabragh Road, Armagh, Co.Armagh, BT61 8EYLOCATION28 Cabragh Road, ArmaghPROPOSAL Alterations and Extension to Dwelling.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr I Lenaghan Ian Lenaghan Design, 30 Moss Park, Richhill, Co Armagh,BT61 9PTITEM NO 98APPLIC NO O/2008/0108/F Full Date Valid 06/02/2008APPLICANT Northern Ireland ElectricityAPPLIC ADDRESSCarn Industrial Estate, Portadown, BT63 5QJLOCATION68 Salters Grange Road, Salters Grange, Armagh. BT61 8EN.PROPOSAL Overhead single phase line on Wooden Poles.(07/17485).REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSP Mc Kenna Connect, Carn Industrial Estate, Portadown, BT63 5QJITEM NO 99APPLIC NO O/2008/0114/F Full Date Valid 08/02/2008APPLICANT Ms CullyAPPLIC ADDRESS7 Neills Villa, Loughgilly, ArmaghLOCATIONSite adjacent to 44 Tullyallen Road, Co Armagh BT60 2HSPROPOSAL Erection of new dwelling and garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSWarwick Stewart Architects, 892 Antrim Road, Templepatrick, Co. Antrim,BT39 0AH20 March 2008 Page 49 of 55

ITEM NO 100APPLIC NO O/2008/0117/F Full Date Valid 08/02/2008APPLICANT Ms P McadamAPPLIC ADDRESS33 Thornleigh, Armagh, BT60 1HTLOCATION33 Thornleigh, Ballyhone, Armagh. BT60 1HT.PROPOSAL 2 Storey rear Extension to Dwelling.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMs Fc Clelland , Tower House, Charles Shiels Houses, Tower Hill,ArmaghITEM NO 101APPLIC NO O/2008/0121/F Full Date Valid 11/02/2008APPLICANT M MontgomeryAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSAL13 Richmond Heights, Richhill, Co.Armagh, BT61 9NJ13 Richmond Heights, Richhill, Co.Armagh.Erection of domestic Garage in substitution for previous ApprovalO/2005/1497/F.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSITEM NO 102APPLIC NO O/2008/0123/F Full Date Valid 11/02/2008APPLICANT Mr P DonnellyAPPLIC ADDRESS50 Battleford Road, Armagh, Co.Armagh, BT61 8BRLOCATION50 Battleford Road, Armagh. BT61 8BR.PROPOSAL Retention of Detached Garage.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILS20 March 2008 Page 50 of 55

ITEM NO 103APPLIC NO O/2008/0124/F Full Date Valid 12/02/2008APPLICANT M DohertyAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSAL14 Legar Hill, Armagh, BT60 4BX150 metres north west of 49 Moy Road, Allistragh, ArmaghVariations to Conditions 4 (single storey) & 5 (Ridge Height of 5.5m) of OutlinePlanning approval O/2004/0652/O.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr K Edgar Holmes & Doran, 1ST Floor, The Old Savings Bank, 1 VictoriaStreet, Armagh, BT61 9DSITEM NO 104APPLIC NO O/2008/0126/F Full Date Valid 12/02/2008APPLICANT Mr & Mrs J B BeggsAPPLIC ADDRESS100 Drumilly Road, Loughgall, BT61 8JHLOCATION100 Drumilly Road, Loughgall, Co Armagh, BT61 8JF.PROPOSAL Erection of enclosed porch & disabled persons shower & toilet facilities.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr C Gordon Cliff Gordon, 23 Cloughan Road, Armagh, BT61 8JRITEM NO 105APPLIC NO O/2008/0130/F Full Date Valid 13/02/2008APPLICANT Mr G M MasonAPPLIC ADDRESS8 Cusher Green, Mountnorris, Co Armagh, BT60 2TTLOCATION8 Cusher Green, Mountnorris, Co Armagh, BT60 2TT.PROPOSAL Erections of alterations & extensions to dwelling.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr I Lenaghan Ian Lenaghan Design, 30 Moss Park, Richhill, Co Armagh,BT61 9PT20 March 2008 Page 51 of 55

ITEM NO 106APPLIC NO O/2008/0131/F Full Date Valid 14/02/2008APPLICANT N CarrAPPLIC ADDRESS17 Crossmore Green, KeadyLOCATION8 Main Street, Darkley.PROPOSAL Rear Ground Floor and First Floor Extension.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr E Morton , 104 Navanfort Road, Armagh, BT60 4PSITEM NO 107APPLIC NO O/2008/0133/F Full Date Valid 14/02/2008APPLICANT Mr M McilwaineAPPLIC ADDRESS157 Mullalelish Road, Portadown, Co.Armagh., BT62 3TQLOCATION157 Mullalelish Road, Portadown, Co.Armagh. BT62 3TQ.PROPOSAL Alterations and Extension to Dwelling including Roof Space Conversion.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSIan Lenaghan Design, 30 Moss Park, Richhill, Co. Armagh, BT61 9PTITEM NO 108APPLIC NO O/2008/0135/F Full Date Valid 15/02/2008APPLICANT Mr D LeeAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSALC/O 68 Moy Road, Armagh, Co.Armagh, BT61 8DW59 Edenvale, Ballynahone, Armagh, Co.Armagh. BT60 1JF.Extension to dwelling and retention of decking area and store to rear of garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr M Sloane Sloane Design Services, 68 Moy Road, Armagh, BT61 8DW20 March 2008 Page 52 of 55

ITEM NO 109APPLIC NO O/2008/0137/F Full Date Valid 19/02/2008APPLICANT G MolloyAPPLIC ADDRESS185 Monaghan Road, ArmaghLOCATIONAdjacent to 117 Dernalea Road, Armagh.PROPOSAL Erection of Dwelling.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr E Morton , 104 Navanfort Road, Armagh, BT60 4PSITEM NO 110APPLIC NO O/2008/0142/F Full Date Valid 19/02/2008APPLICANT MckearneyAPPLIC ADDRESS21 Edward Street, Armagh, BT61LOCATIONNo.21 Edward Street, Armagh.PROPOSAL Erection of Two storey rear Extension to Dwelling.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr J Kerr JPM Kerr Chartered Surveyors, First Floor, 21A Railway Street,Armagh, BT61 7HPITEM NO 111APPLIC NO O/2008/0148/F Full Date Valid 20/02/2008APPLICANT N I EAPPLIC ADDRESSCarn Industrial Estate, Portadown, BT63 5QJLOCATION105 Drumhillery Road, Derrynoose, Keady.PROPOSAL Overhead single phase line on wooden polesREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILS20 March 2008 Page 53 of 55

ITEM NO 112APPLIC NO O/2008/0149/RM Reserved Date Valid 19/02/2008APPLICANTAPPLIC ADDRESSMr K Owen21a Annagora Road, Portadown, BT62 4JELOCATIONLands between 21 and 21a Annagora Road, Portadown. BT62 4JE.PROPOSAL Erection of Dwelling and Garage.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr G Owen The Designworks Studio, 21 Annagora Road, Portadown,Co.Armagh, BT62 4JEITEM NO 113APPLIC NO O/2008/0159/RM Reserved Date Valid 20/02/2008APPLICANTAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONMr E P Pillow111 Tirnascobe Road, Richhill, BT61 9HXShewis, Richhill, 140 metres South West of 111 Tirnascobe Road, Richhill,BT61 9HX.PROPOSAL Erection of dwelling & garage.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr Wc Cornett Cornett Design Associates, 4 Hartford Place, The Mall,Armagh, BT61 9BT20 March 2008 Page 54 of 55

ITEM NO 114APPLIC NO O/2008/0161/RM Reserved Date Valid 25/02/2008APPLICANTAPPLIC ADDRESSS L LeeHillcrest, Deanyraine Road, ArmaghLOCATION30 metres North East of 102 Killylea Road, Armagh.PROPOSAL Erection of dwelling & garage.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr E Morton , 104 Navan Fort Road, Armagh20 March 2008 Page 55 of 55

APPLICATIONS DEFERRED FROM PREVIOUS MEETINGITEM NO D 1APPLIC NO O/2004/0695/O Outline Date Valid 21/05/2004APPLICANT Mr G MckennaAPPLIC ADDRESS 58 Lisdown Road, Armagh, BT60 4PULOCATION80 metres north of 35 Lisdown Road ArmaghPROPOSAL Site for dwelling (Readvertisement)REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr J Rollston , Drum Cottage, Drum Lane, Killylea, Co Armagh, BT60 4LZITEM NO D 2APPLIC NO O/2005/0598/F Full Date Valid 28/04/2005APPLICANT Mr A MccammonAPPLIC ADDRESS130a Portadown Road, Armagh, BT61 9HLLOCATIONAdjacent to and east of no. 130 Portadown Road, ArmaghPROPOSAL Erection of replacement dwellingREPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSJ Rollston , 88 Fellowshall Road, Killylea, Armagh, BT60 4LZITEM NO D 3APPLIC NO O/2005/1584/O Outline Date Valid 21/12/2005APPLICANT Mr I MallonAPPLIC ADDRESS38 Marlacoo Road,, Corry, Hamiltonsbawn, BT60 1JWLOCATIONAdjacent to No. 34 Marlacoo Rd, CorryPROPOSAL Site for a dwelling and detached garageREPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr J Kerr JPM KERR, 11 Middlebrook, Middletown, Co. Armagh, BT60 4JP21 March 2008 Page 1 of 7

ITEM NO D 4APPLIC NO O/2005/1587/O Outline Date Valid 21/12/2005APPLICANT Mr I MallonAPPLIC ADDRESS38 Marlacoo Road, Corry, Hamiltonsbawn, BT60 1JWLOCATION180M'S East of No. 34 Marlacoo Road, Corry, HamiltonsbawnPROPOSAL Site for dwelling and attached garageREPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies SP6, HOU8 and DES5 of the Department's 'A PlanningStrategy for Rural Northern Ireland' in that a building on this site would not integrate into thecountryside, as the site is unable to provide a suitable degree of enclosure due to the lack ofsufficient boundaries or any other means of achieving satisfactory integration, and as aconsequence would, if permitted, have an adverse impact on the landscape (by reason of itsundue prominence.2 The proposal is contrary to Policies SP6, DES6 and HOU8 of the Department's PlanningStrategy for Rural Northern Ireland in that the development when considered in the context ofexisting development, would, if permitted, result in a detrimental change to the rural characterof this area of countryside by reason of build up.AGENT DETAILSMr J Kerr JPM KERR, 11 Middlebrook, Middletown, Co. Armagh, BT60 4JPITEM NO D 5APPLIC NO O/2006/0088/F Full Date Valid 25/01/2006APPLICANT MessrsAPPLIC ADDRESS c/o AgentLOCATION300m South East of Dunesmullan Road, MarkethillPROPOSAL Erection of replacement dwelling and garage.REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies SP6/HOU13 of the Department's Planning Strategy forRural Northern Ireland in that the development would, if permitted, create a greater visualimpact than the dwelling to be replaced by reason of its significant increase in size.AGENT DETAILS Mr R M Martin Robert M. Martin Architectural Design, 'Rathmourne', 17Tullyhinan Road, Banbridge, Co.Down, BT32 4EY21 March 2008 Page 2 of 7

ITEM NO D 6APPLIC NO O/2006/0157/O Outline Date Valid 15/03/2006APPLICANT Mr K MorganAPPLIC ADDRESS98 Red Lion Road, LoughgallLOCATION98 Red Lion Road, LoughgallPROPOSAL Site for agricultural storage & distribution warehouseREPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policy IDB10 of the Department's Draft Planning Policy Statement 4,Industrial Development, in that the development would, if permitted, have an adverse impacton the environment by virtue of the significant increase in the site area of the enterprise, theadditional building work on a site located in the Countryside Policy Area and its lack of visualintegration into the rural landscape.AGENT DETAILSMr D O'Neill McKeown & Shields, 1 Annagher Road, Coalisland, BT71 4NEITEM NO D 7APPLIC NO O/2006/0215/O Outline Date Valid 20/02/2006APPLICANT Mr S JohnstonAPPLIC ADDRESS 107 Carnreagh, Craigavon, BT64 3ALLOCATION50m South of 28 Annagora Road, PortadownPROPOSAL Site of dwelling and garageREPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr D Clarke Derek Clarke, 47 Derrygally Road, Dungannon, Co Tyrone, BT716LZ21 March 2008 Page 3 of 7

ITEM NO D 8APPLIC NO O/2006/0272/O Outline Date Valid 01/03/2006APPLICANT Mr HughesAPPLIC ADDRESS261 Newtownhamilton Road,, ArmaghLOCATION90m West of 181 Tassagh Road, ArmaghPROPOSAL Site for dwelling and garageREPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies SP6, HOU8 & DES6 of the Department's Planning Strategyfor Rural Northern Ireland in that the development when considered in the context of existingdevelopment, would, if permitted, result in a detrimental change to the rural character of thisarea of countryside by reason of build up.2 The proposal is contrary to Policies SP6, SP19, HOU8 and DES5 of the Department's 'APlanning Strategy for Rural Northern Ireland' in that a building on this site would not integrateinto the countryside, as the site is unable to provide a suitable degree of enclosure due to thelack of sufficient boundaries or any other means of achieving satisfactory integration, and asa consequence would, if permitted, have an adverse impact on the landscape as it is undulyconspicuous.AGENT DETAILSMr Bell Bell Design Services, 123 Crosskeys Road, Armagh, BT60 3LDITEM NO D 9APPLIC NO O/2006/0351/F Full Date Valid 10/03/2006APPLICANT Mr Je LockhartAPPLIC ADDRESS 58 Coolmillish Road,, Markethill, Co. Armagh, BT60 1SHLOCATION110m south of 19 Gosford Road, MarkethillPROPOSAL Erection of dwellingREPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies SP6, DES6, HOU8 of the Department's Planning Strategyfor Rural Northern Ireland in that the development when considered in the context of existingdevelopment, would, if permitted, result in a detrimental change to the rural character of thisarea of countryside by reason of build-up of development.2 The proposal is contrary to Policies DES7, SP6 and HOU8 of the Department's PlanningStrategy for Rural Northern Ireland in that the development would, if permitted, adverselyaffect the visual amenity and character of the countryside by the creation of ribbondevelopment along this private laneway.AGENT DETAILSMr Warwick Warwick Architects, 892 Antrim Road, Templepatrick, BT39 0AH21 March 2008 Page 4 of 7

ITEM NO D 10APPLIC NO O/2006/0357/O Outline Date Valid 10/03/2006APPLICANT F MallonAPPLIC ADDRESS130 Ballygasson Road,, LoughgallLOCATIONAdjacent to and 60m East of 7 Grange Blundel Road, LoughgallPROPOSAL Site for dwelling with detached garageREPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies SP6, HOU8 and DES5 of the Department's 'A PlanningStrategy for Rural Northern Ireland' in that a building on this site would not integrate into thecountryside, as the site is unable to provide a suitable degree of enclosure due to the lack ofsufficient boundaries or any other means of achieving satisfactory integration, and as aconsequence would, if permitted, have an adverse impact on the landscape as it is undulyconspicuous.2 The proposal is contrary to Policies SP6, DES6 and HOU8 of the Department's PlanningStrategy for Rural Northern Ireland in that the development when considered in the context ofexisting development, would, if permitted, result in a detrimental change to the rural characterof this area of countryside by reason of build-up of development.AGENT DETAILSMr W. J. Cornett Cornett Design Associates, 4 Hartford Place, The Mall,Armagh, BT61 9BJITEM NO D 11APPLIC NO O/2006/0361/F Full Date Valid 10/03/2006APPLICANT Mr K BoydAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATION60 Main Street, Killylea, ArmaghCammagh Road, Derrynoose, Armagh - 150 metres north east of junction withDrumhillery RoadPROPOSAL Erection of dwelling & garageREPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSJ Rollston , 88 Fellowshall Road, Killylea, Armagh, BT60 4LZ21 March 2008 Page 5 of 7

ITEM NO D 12APPLIC NO O/2006/0983/O Outline Date Valid 21/09/2006APPLICANT Mr J BinghamAPPLIC ADDRESSC/O AgentLOCATIONNo.10 Tannyoky Road, Poyntzpass, NewryPROPOSAL Site for replacement dwellingREPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSA-Three Architecture Design Planning, 43 - 45 Church Street, Portadown,BT62 3EUITEM NO D 13APPLIC NO O/2007/0506/F Full Date Valid 20/06/2007APPLICANT Mr K SheridanAPPLIC ADDRESS15 Ballycrummy Road, Armagh, BT60 4LBLOCATION3&4 Navan Cottages, Navan Fort Road, Armagh, BT60 4PWPROPOSAL Erection of replacement dwellings(Amended Designs)REPRESENTATIONS 3 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr Wc Cornett Cornett Design Associates, 4 Hartford Place, The Mall,Armagh, BT61 9BTITEM NO D 14APPLIC NO O/2007/0609/F Full Date Valid 30/07/2007APPLICANT Mr A TopleyAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSALC/o AgentAdjacent No.82 Ballymore Road, Tandragee, Co.ArmaghRemoval of old farm out buildings and erection of farmworkers dwelling withdetached garageREPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr M Doyle B & D Property Services Ltd, 261 Dublin Road, Killeen, Newry,BT35 8RY21 March 2008 Page 6 of 7

ITEM NO D 15APPLIC NO O/2007/0862/F Full Date Valid 26/10/2007APPLICANT Mr G ReidAPPLIC ADDRESS76 Ballygroobany Road, Ballynahinch, Richhill, Co. ArmaghLOCATION76 Ballygroobany Road, Ballynahinch, Richhill, Co. Armagh.PROPOSAL Alterations and extension to dwelling.REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr I Lenaghan Ian Lenaghan Design, 30 Moss Park, Richhill, Co Armagh,BT61 9PTITEM NO D 16APPLIC NO O/2007/1031/F Full Date Valid 27/12/2007APPLICANT Marks & Spencer PlcAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONProperty (TP4.1), The Point, 37 North Wharf Road, London, W2 1AFMarks & Spencer Simply Food, Unit 2, Spires Retail Park, Moy Road, Armagh.PROPOSAL Elevational alterations, canopy, lift and bollardsREPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSNathaniel Lichfield & Partners Ltd, 14 Regents Wharf, All Saints Street,London, N1 9RLITEM NO D 17APPLIC NO O/2008/0007/F Full Date Valid 03/01/2008APPLICANT Marks & Spencers PlcAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONProperty (TP4.1), The Point, 37 North Wharf Road, London, W2 1AFMarks & Spencers Simply Food, Unit 2, Spires Retail Park, Moy Road, ArmaghPROPOSAL Proposed plant, enclosure and barrierREPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSNathaniel Lichfield & Partners Ltd, 14 Regents Wharf, All Saints Street,London, N1 9RL21 March 2008 Page 7 of 7

PSSC-08-29-LBAPPEALS LODGED WITH PACCOUNCILArmaghITEM NO 1APPLIC NO O/2004/0785/O PAC NO 2006/A2266APPLICANTMr P FinniganLOCATIONAdjoining and west of 37 Ballymacnab Road, Ballymacnab, ArmaghPROPOSALSite for dwelling and garageAPPEAL TYPE Plg RefusalITEM NO 2APPLIC NO O/2004/1347/F PAC NO 2006/A2271APPLICANTMay ConstructionLOCATION120m South of 52 Derryraine Road, ArmaghPROPOSALErection of dwelling with attached garageAPPEAL TYPE Plg RefusalITEM NO 3APPLIC NO O/2004/1478/O PAC NO 2006/A1789APPLICANTMr P. Kelly,LOCATION15m South East of No. 52 Blackwatertown Road, ArmaghPROPOSALSite for dwelling and garageAPPEAL TYPE Plg Refusal20 March 2008 Page 1 of 1

PSSC-08-30-LBAPPEAL DECISIONS NOTIFIEDCOUNCILArmaghITEM NO 1APPLIC NO O/2006/0292/O PAC NO 2006/A0828RESULT OF APPEAL DismissedAPPLICANTLOCATIONPROPOSALMr S Hughes160m South East of no. 119 Markethill Road, ArmaghSite for dwellingITEM NO 2APPLIC NO O/2006/0299/O PAC NO 2006/A0762RESULT OF APPEAL UpheldAPPLICANTLOCATIONPROPOSALMr S Hughes170m North East of no. 119 Markethill Road ArmaghSite for dwelling

20 March 2008 Page 1 of 1