PSSC-08-22-LB - Armagh City and District Council

ARMAGH CITY AND DISTRICT COUNCILAPPENDIX AMinutes of Proceedings of a Meeting of thePUBLIC SERVICES SCRUTINY COMMITTEEheld in the Council Chamber, Council Offices,The Palace Demesne, Armagh, onMonday, 3 March, 2008 at 7.50 pm_______________________________________PRESENT:Presiding Chairperson:Other Members:Councillor T G O’HanlonCouncillors:P L Berry Mrs M H Black P BranniganMiss M E Bratton J B Campbell P CorriganMrs F E Donnelly N Donnelly Miss S HaugheyG Mallon D McNally Mrs S F A McRobertsC Rollston E Speers J SpeersR W TurnerG WilsonApologies:Councillors:Mrs M E Doyle W G Irwin Mrs C A RaffertyN J SheridanIn Attendance:Strategic Director of Corporate ServicesDemocratic Services Officer (L P Brown)Mrs Helen Stoops, DRD Planning Service1.0 APOLOGIESApologies were received and accepted from Councillors Mrs Doyle, Irwin, Mrs Raffertyand Sheridan.2.0 DECLARATIONS OF INTERESTApplication No O/2007/0931/F in the Name of Mr M MallonThe Chair, Councillor O’Hanlon, declared an interest in the above application being anephew of the Applicant.Application No O/2007/1014/RM in the Name of P CampbellCouncillor Miss Bratton, declared an interest in the above application.Application No O/2006/0339/O in the Name of Miss HaugheyCouncillor Miss Haughey declared an interest in the above application.1

3.0 PLANNING MATTERS3.1 Office Meetings – Friday 22 February 2008 (21PL12)PREVIOUSLY CIRCULATED: report of the Office Meetings held on Friday 22February 2008, PSSC-08-21-LB.NOTED.3.2 Planning Applications – March 2008 - (PSSC-08-22-LB - Previously Circulated) -(21PL12)(i) Applications Recommended for ApprovalAGREED: acceptance to the opinion of Planning Service in relation to approvedapplications, PSSC-08-22-LB.Application O/2003/1231/O and O/2006/1030/RMCouncillor E Speers REPORTED that he had received a copy letter from objectors tothe above applications in respect of the erection of a dwelling and detached garageadjacent to and north of 207 Mowhan Road, Glenanne. He advised that he had spokento Mrs Stoops prior to the meeting regarding the applications which had previously beenapproved.NOTED.(ii) Applications Recommended for RefusalAGREED: acceptance to the opinion of Planning Service in relation to refusedapplications subject to the following:Application No O/2006/0474/O in the Name of Mrs A ReillyApplication No O/2006/0530/O in the Name of Mr D HillApplication No O/2006/0566/O in the Name of Mr & Mrs D BlackApplication No O/2006/0627/O in the Name of Ms G McGeownApplication No O/2006/0797/O in the Name of Ms E PaynterApplication No O/2006/0900/O in the Name of Mr G EwartApplication No O/2006/1223/F in the Name of Mr HamiltonApplication No O/2007/0079/O in the Name of F OliverApplication No O/2007/0131/O in the Name of Mr S McCrillyApplication No O/2007/0308/F in the Name of Mr W DrakeApplication No O/2007/0329/F in the Name of Mr B BellApplication No O/2007/0394/F in the Name of Mrs E WilliamsonApplication No O/2007/0736/F in the Name of Mr & Mrs SmythApplication No O/2007/0789/O in the Name of Ms P ToddApplication No O/2007/0792/O in the Name of Mr P ToddApplication No O/2007/0816/O in the Name of ToddApplication No O/2007/0818/F in the Name of Mr P SmythAGREED: that the above applications, being presented with an opinion to refuse underPPS 14, be deferred for reconsideration following the implementation of the new policy.2

Application No O/2007/0233/O in the Name of Mr J DonaldsonFollowing representations from Councillor J Speers, Councillor E Speers brieflyexplained the background to the above application and advised that the Agent had beenpresent prior to the meeting but had since left. He would be contacting Planning Servicethe following day.Mr Stoops confirmed that she had spoken to the Agent, he had undertaken to contactPlanning Service the following day and a meeting would be arranged. Councillor ESpeers would be invited to the meeting.NOTED.Application No O/2006/0522/O in the Name of Mr M QuinnThe Agent sought clarification regarding the Minister’s statement which referred to thedate applications were received rather than the date they were validated. He pointed outthat the above application was received by Planning Service on 10 March 2006.Mrs Stoops confirmed that Planning Service had received a letter from Mr Lindsay anda formal response would be issued before the end of the week. She pointed out that, interms of the legislation, it was a submission until it was validated and only then did itbecome an application. The application under consideration when initially submittedfell sort in terms of the fee and then the red line had been reduced with the result that itfell under the provisions of dPPS 14.Mr Lindsay felt that the process was unfair as it wasn’t issued throughout all ofNorthern Ireland as it was only issued in Ballymena, Craigavon and Belfast PlanningOffices.Councillor J Speers stated that in the past the Council had accepted the PlanningService’s explanation on the assumption that it was a policy applicable across the boardbut that it now transpired it was not and was specific only to some planning areas. Headded that the Council had previously considered applications that had missed thedeadline by just one day. He felt that clarity should be sought as to whether or not thepolicy was a Departmental Policy; where it was issued to; was it issued at the same timeand was it introduced at the same time.Councillor Berry fully sympathised with the Agent, believing it to be a genuine case.He agreed with Councillor J Speers and felt that the issue should be raised directly withthe Minister and clarity sought in order to ensure that constituents were notdiscriminated against.Councillor Miss Haughey concurred with all that had been said in relation to this veryimportant issue. She referred to a number of applications, of which the Council wasaware, that had been sent back for matters of detail. In referring to the policy, whichreferred to applications ‘received’ she queried why the validation date was accepted.She felt that this case should be fought.Councillor Wilson believed that valid points had been made and supported clarificationbeing sought.Mrs Stoops referred to previous cases where representations had been made to theDepartment and to the response issued. She pointed out that the statement was from the3

Minister and that it was the legislation that determined what constituted a validapplication. In the case under consideration there had been a short-fall in the fee. Shesuggested that the way forward was to correspond with the Minister.Councillor J Speers reiterated his biggest concern and stated that he felt the statementwas irrelevant, but that what was relevant was whether or not the Planning Service wasdemanding the policy to be effective right across the province; if it wasn’t why not andwhy some areas and not others?Councillor Miss Haughey pointed out that this was the first time that the statement hadbeen pointed out.AGREED: that clarification be sought from both the Minister and the Department,with a copy to the Agent.Application No O/2007/0986/O in the Name of Mr F McNallyNOTED: in response to a request for clarification from Councillor Campbell, that if apetition of support had been lodged in respect of the above application it would beconsidered again.Application No O/2008/0004/F in the Name of Mrs B QuinnIn response to a request from Councillor Campbell, Mrs Stoops advised that, if it wasthe wish of the Council, Planning Service would agree to an office meeting with theDepartment in respect of the above application.The Council supported deferral of the application for an office meeting with PlanningService.AGREED: deferral of the above application pending an office meeting with PlanningService.Application No O/2003/0948/O in the Name of Stevenson & CummingDevelopment Services LtdApplication No O/2005/0823/F in the Name of Mr J HaffeyNOTED: that the above applications had been withdrawn.Application No O/2006/0059/RM in the Name of Mrs J HughesApplication No O/2006/0361/F in the Name of Mr K BoydNOTED: that Planning Service had received additional information which satisfied thecriteria for deferral of the above applications.Planning Service AGREED to deferral of the above applications for furtherconsideration.Application No O/2006/0347/O in the Name of Mr & Mrs P DonnellyNOTED: that Planning Service had received additional information which satisfied thecriteria for deferral of the above application for consideration at an office meeting, ifthis was the wish of the Council.4

The Council supported deferral of the application for an office meeting.AGREED: deferral of the above application pending consideration at an officemeeting.Application No O/2006/0351/F in the Name of Mr J E LockhartMrs Stoops advised that Planning Service had received correspondence indicating thatadditional information would be submitted by the end of the week and that she couldagree to hold the applications for 10 days to allow this further information to beprovided for consideration.AGREED: that the above applications be held for 10 days.Application No O/2007/0602/F in the Name of Mr S DowhardNOTED: that Planning Service had received additional information which satisfied thecriteria for deferral of the above application for consideration at an office meeting, ifthis was the wish of the Council.The Council supported deferral of the application for an office meeting.AGREED: deferral of the above application pending consideration at an officemeeting.Application No O/2006/05428/O in the Name of Mr N McAlisterNOTED: that Planning Service had received additional information which satisfied thecriteria for deferral of the above application for consideration at an office meeting, ifthis was the wish of the Council.The Council supported deferral of the application for an office meeting.AGREED: deferral of the above application pending consideration at an officemeeting. The office meeting to be convened following receipt of comments fromDARD.Application No O/2006/0611/RM in the Name of Mr D McLaughlinApplication No O/2007/0241/F in the Name of Mr B SmythNOTED: that Planning Service had received additional information which satisfied thecriteria for deferral of the above applications.Planning Service AGREED to deferral of the above applications for furtherconsideration.Application No O/2007/0391/F in the Name of Mr N WoodsNOTED: that Planning Service had not received additional information in respect ofthe above application, however, an office meeting had taken place on 28 February.5

Mrs Stoops advised that the as a result of the office meeting additional information wasto be submitted to the Department.NOTED.Councillor Mrs McRoberts retired from the meeting at 8.07 pm.Application No O/2007/0493/F in the Name of Www EnterpriseSince no additional information had been received by Planning Service and no oneattended the meeting the above application was NOTED.Application No O/2007/0645/F in the Name of Mr J FinleyApplication No O/2007/0668/F in the Name of Mr S HamiltonNOTED: that Planning Service had received additional information which satisfied thecriteria for deferral of the above applications for consideration at office meetings, if thiswas the wish of the Council.The Council supported deferral of the applications for office meetings.AGREED: deferral of the above applications pending consideration at office meetings.Application No O/2007/0862/F in the Name of Mr G ReidNOTED: that Planning Service had received additional information which satisfied thecriteria for deferral of the above application.Planning Service AGREED to deferral of the above application for furtherconsideration.Application No O/2007/1031/F in the Name of Marks & Spencer PlcApplication No O/2008/0007/F in the Name of Marks & Spencer PlcNOTED: that Planning Service had received additional information which satisfied thecriteria for deferral of the above applications.Planning Service AGREED to deferral of the above applications for furtherconsideration.In response to a query from Councillor J Speers, Mrs Stoops advised that Roads Servicehad guaranteed that it would reconsider the information submitted in order that it couldbe presented to the next meeting.NOTED: that Mrs Stoops undertook to keep Councillor J Speers appraised ofdevelopments in respect of this application.Adoption of ReportAGREED: that the Planning Schedule for March 2008, PSSC-08-22-LB, be accepted,subject to the above.6

3.3 Planning Appeals Lodged – March 2008(21PL10)PREVIOUSLY CIRCULATED: report of Planning Appeals Lodged for March 2008.(PSSC-08-23-LB)NOTED.3.4 Planning Appeal Decisions Notified – March 2008 (21PL10)PREVIOUSLY CIRCULATED: report of Planning Appeal Decisions Notified for March2008. (PSSC-08-24-LB)NOTED.3.5 Non-determination Appeals Under Article 33 of the Planning (NI) Order 1991(21PL09)PREVIOUSLY CIRCULATED: the following correspondence from Planning Serviceadvising that non-determination appeals under Article 33 of the Planning (NI) Order 1991had been lodged with the Planning Appeals Commission (PAC) in relation to the undernotedproposals. The Department was required to inform relevant interests of its view onthe proposals. The Department’s view on the proposals was that planning permissionshould be refused and the reasons for refusal were detailed.• dated 21 February 2008, Re: Application No O/2006/0375 in the Name of MrGerald Mackle - Application to vary time condition on Outline Planning ApprovalReference O/2000/1021/O adjacent to No 65 Crossnenagh Road, Derrynoose,Keady• dated 21 February 2008, Re: Application No O/2006/0524/O in the Name of MrGerald Mackle - Application to vary time condition on outline approvalO/2001/0528/O 70m NW of 65 Crossnenagh Road, Derrynoose.NOTED.3.6 Planning Office MeetingsThe Chair REPORTED that there would be no Planning Office Meetings in March and thatthe next round of Planning Office meetings would be held on Friday 25 April 2008. In theevent of their being two days required the second would be Wednesday 23 April 2008.NOTED: that the necessary documentation would be issued in due course.4.0 ANY OTHER RELEVANT BUSINESS4.1 Painting of Roadside Kerbs (21RD02/21ES05)Councillor Campbell reported that it had been brought to his attention that roadside kerbs atRed Lion Crossroads had been painted. This had been painted over by someone toobliterate the original painting, however, it had since been repainted. He requested that theCouncil write to Chief Inspector Mawhinney asking that attention be given to this area andto Roads Service asking for the painting to be removed before the matter becamecontentious. He reported that there was good cross community relations in this area.7

AGREED: that representations be made to PSNI and Roads Service.The business having been completed, the meeting concluded at 8.12 pm.Mayor:_______________________________Clerk andChief Executive: ________________________________Date:_________________________________8

PSSC-08-21-LBARMAGH CITY AND DISTRICT COUNCILPLANNING OFFICE MEETING22 FEBRUARY 2008O/2006/0088/FGlen BuildingCo300m SE ofDunesmullanRoad, MarkethillErection ofreplacement dwellingand garageSP6 & HOU13 – Visual impactPlanningMrs Helen StoopsApplicantMr H HodgenAgentRobert M MartinArchitecturalDesignCouncillorsBerry, MissHaughey, O’Hanlonand TurnerNOTED:• site prominent• replacement dwelling• similar sites approved in the areaAGREED:• Agent to forward other planningreference numbers• H Stoops to visit the site and go backto the AgentO/2007/0246/O Mr R Moore 200m S of No 9Maytone Road,GlenanneSite for dwelling andgarageCTY 1 of PPS 14 – the statedneed does not justify a relaxationof the strict planning control inthe countryside.PlanningMrs Helen StoopsApplicantMrs Moore(mother)AgentMr D DiamondCouncillorsBerry, Campbell, NDonnelly, MissHaughey, MrsMcRoberts,O’Hanlon, J Speers,Turner and WilsonNOTED:• letters already submitted• family circumstances• no site specific reasons• very rural areaAGREED:• Mrs Stoops undertook to take back andreconsider

O/2007/0609/F Mr A Topley Adj No 82Ballymore Road,Tandragee, CoArmaghO/2006/0907/F Mr J Best 300m NE of No 3GlassdrummanRoad, ActonO/2006/0359/F Mr P Hughes Off KnappaghRoad, Killylea,260m E of itsjunction withAnnaghanannyRoad, KillyleaRemoval of old farmout buildings anderection offarmworkersdwelling withdetached garageErection of dwellingand garageErection of dwellingand garageCTY1 and CTY2 of dPPS 14 – Ithas not been demonstrated that theproposed dwelling is essential tomeet the needs of the farmCTY12 of dPPS 14 – Extension ofribbon developmentCTY11 of dPPS 14 – Build upCTY1 of Draft PPS 14 – Does notmerit being considered as anexception to the policy nor arethere any overriding reasons whythis development is essential andcould not be located within asettlement.Prejudice safety and convenienceof road users since adequate sightlines cannot be provided withinthe application siteSP6, SP19 & DES5 – Suburbanform of roadside developmentSP6 & DES6 – Build upPrejudice the safety andconvenience of road users –visibility cannot be provided;adequate forward sight distance isnot available and the gradient ofthe access would not comply withthe standardsPlanningMrs Helen StoopsApplicantA TopleyMark Segar (vet)AgentMr B McKevittCouncillorsBerry, Campbell, NDonnelly, MissHaughey,O’Hanlon, J Speersand TurnerPlanningMrs Helen StoopsApplicantNot in attendanceAgentMr B McKevittCouncillorsBerry, Campbell, NDonnelly, MissHaughey,O’Hanlon, J Speersand TurnerPlanningMrs Helen StoopsRoadsMr D SheardApplicantNot in attendanceAgentMr J RollstonMr J RichardsonCouncillorsCampbell, Corrigan,N Donnelly, MrsMcRoberts,O’Hanlon andWilsonNOTED:• removing old buildings• within exceptions of PPS 14• extensive farm buildings• pig farmer all his life• labour intensiveAGREED: that H Stoops take back andreconsider the case.NOTED:• amended to read farm workersdwellingAGREED: that Planning Service• consult DARD• reconsider to applicationNOTED:• roads matters resolved• no other replacement opportunities• well screened, down a laneAGREED:• new drawings to be submitted• H Stoops to look out• willing to reduce, if necessary

O/2006/0874/FMessrs ADLGroup LtdNos 227-229Battleford Road,Aughantarraghand Corr, ArmaghO/2007/0496/F Ms L Murphy 45 St MatthewsEstate, KeadyDemolition ofexisting buildingsand erection ofwarehouse extension,sales and officebuilding and lightindustrial unitsExtension to dwellingand erection of newgarage/storedPPS 4 – Industrial DevelopmentPolicy IBD 11 – Adverse impacton the environment and thecharacter of the rural roadsInappropriate for development forindustrial commercial purposesIncrease in traffic to and from thesite causing harm to the livingconditions of residents alongBattleford RoadCTY1 of dPPS 14 – Nooverriding reasons why thisdevelopment is essential andcould not be located within asettlementSP18, SP19 and HOU16 – Scaleand form and impact on thecharacter and appearance of thesurrounding area and the loss ofprivate garden areaPlanningMrs Helen StoopsRoadsMr D SheardApplicantNot in attendanceAgentWilliam ShannonArchitectCouncillorsBerry, Campbell,Corrigan, NDonnelly, Mallon,Mrs McRoberts,O’Hanlon, J Speersand WilsonPlanningMrs Helen StoopsApplicantMr & Mrs MurphyAgentNOTED:• develop business• 16 new jobs created• Roads require traffic assessment• this is second application• business operating on this site for 30years• enhancement of what is on site• new access will be benefitAGREED:• traffic to be clarified• Mrs Stoops to visit and meeting to beheldNOTED:• facility is recommended by OTDepartment• red line needs to be extendedCouncillorsCampbell, Corrigan,Mallon, MrsMcRoberts,O’Hanlon, J Speersand WilsonAGREED:• Mrs Stoops to look at and speak toAgent

ITEM NO 2APPLIC NO O/2004/0925/F Full Date Valid 08/07/2004APPLICANT Mr T GilpinAPPLIC ADDRESS85 Mullalelish Road, Richhill, BT61 9LTLOCATIONSites 4 & 6 Beauwood, Derryhale Road, DerryhalePROPOSAL Change of house typeREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr C Mulqueeny JRJ Consultants, 11c Magowan Buildings, West Street,Portadown, Co.Armagh, BT62 3PNITEM NO 3APPLIC NO O/2005/0338/F Full Date Valid 14/03/2005APPLICANT Mr D HarrisonAPPLIC ADDRESS97 Mullalelish Road, RichhillLOCATIONLands opposite 90 Mullalelish Road, RichhillPROPOSAL Erection of dwelling and garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr J. Donaldson D & D Design, 51 Newry Road,, Armagh,, Co. Armagh.,BT60 1ER15 February 2008 Page 2 of 71

ITEM NO 4APPLIC NO O/2005/0823/F Full Date Valid 31/08/2005APPLICANT Mr J HaffeyAPPLIC ADDRESSc/o AgentLOCATIONDobbin Farm within Castledillon Estate, Portadown Road, Armagh.PROPOSAL Erection of dwelling and renovation of existing outbuilding.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 Having notified the agent and applicant under Article 7 (4) of the Planning (GeneralDevelopment) Order (Northern Ireland) 1993 that further details were required to allow theDepartment to determine the application, and having not received sufficient information, theDepartment refuses this application as it is the opinion of the Department that this informationis material to the determination of this application.AGENT DETAILSMr Mcmaster David McMaster Architect, 12a Mahon Industrial Estate,Portadown, BT62 3EHITEM NO 5APPLIC NO O/2005/1199/F Full Date Valid 09/09/2005APPLICANT Messrs Tyr Arm LtdAPPLIC ADDRESS210 Battleford Road, ArmaghLOCATION128 Tassagh Road, Tassagh, ArmaghPROPOSAL Housing development - erection of 25 dwellingsREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr J A Kelly J Aidan Kelly MBIAT (Ltd), 9 Georges Street, Dungannon,BT70 1BP15 February 2008 Page 3 of 71

ITEM NO 6APPLIC NO O/2006/0059/RM Reserved Date Valid 16/01/2006APPLICANTAPPLIC ADDRESSMrs J Hughes1 Magee Terrace, Belleeks, Newry, BT35 7PWLOCATIONAdjacent to and south of 37 Friary Road, Cladybeg, ArmaghPROPOSAL Erection of dwelling & garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 Having notified the agent and applicant under Article 7 (4) of the Planning (GeneralDevelopment) Order (Northern Ireland) 1993 that further details were required to allow theDepartment to determine the application, and having not received sufficient information, theDepartment refuses this application as it is the opinion of the Department that this informationis material to the determination of this application.AGENT DETAILSJ Rollston , 88 Fellowshall Road, Killylea, Armagh, BT60 4LZITEM NO 7APPLIC NO O/2006/0148/F Full Date Valid 27/01/2006APPLICANT Mr BinghamAPPLIC ADDRESSc/o AgentLOCATION4m East of 10 Tannyoky Road, Poyntzpass, Newry.PROPOSAL Conversion of existing stone building to residential dwellingREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSA3 Architecture Design Planning Ltd, 43-45 Church Street, Portadown,BT62 3EU15 February 2008 Page 4 of 71

ITEM NO 8APPLIC NO O/2006/0225/O Outline Date Valid 21/02/2006APPLICANT Mr SmythAPPLIC ADDRESS14 Kinnego Road, Mullaghmore, Loughgall, Armagh, BT61 8LRLOCATION120 metres West of No.14 Kinnego Road, Mullaghmore, LoughgallPROPOSAL Site for dwelling and garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSITEM NO 9APPLIC NO O/2006/0230/F Full Date Valid 22/02/2006APPLICANT S.J. Mc ClellandAPPLIC ADDRESSc/o The AgentLOCATION148 Aghorey Road, AghoreyPROPOSAL Housing development - erection of 22 dwellings (Amended Scheme)REPRESENTATION 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr C Stewart McAdam Stewart Architects, Banbridge Enterprise Centre,Scarva Road, Banbridge, Co.Down, BT32 3QDITEM NO 10APPLIC NO O/2006/0249/O Outline Date Valid 27/03/2006APPLICANT Mr M LaveryAPPLIC ADDRESS58 Valley Lane, Corcreeny, Lurgan, BT66 7SFLOCATION20M West of 24 Maydown Road, Kilmatroy, ArmaghPROPOSAL Site for dwelling and garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILS15 February 2008 Page 5 of 71

ITEM NO 11APPLIC NO O/2006/0298/O Outline Date Valid 07/03/2006APPLICANT D MccartanAPPLIC ADDRESS10 Donnelly Hill Rd,, Tullymore,, BenburbLOCATION20m south of 20 Wilsontown Road, KilcarnPROPOSAL Site for dwelling and garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSM Lavery , 58 Valley Lane, Corcreeny, Lurgan, BT66 7SFITEM NO 12APPLIC NO O/2006/0309/F Full Date Valid 06/03/2006APPLICANT Mr & Mrs M GrewAPPLIC ADDRESSC/O AgentLOCATION220m east of 138 Maydown Road, Drumduff, BenburbPROPOSAL Erection of dwelling and garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr S Nugent , 27 Loughgall Road, Armagh, Co Armagh, BT61 7NXITEM NO 13APPLIC NO O/2006/0336/O Outline Date Valid 10/03/2006APPLICANT Mr M QuinnAPPLIC ADDRESS97 Marlacoo Road,, Ballynewry, BT60 1JNLOCATIONEast of and opposite 185 Marlacoo Road, Marlacoo BegPROPOSAL Site for dwelling and garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr C Lindsey C T Lindsay, The Studio, 66 Marlacoo Road, Richhill,Co.Armagh, BT62 3JW15 February 2008 Page 6 of 71

ITEM NO 14APPLIC NO O/2006/0338/O Outline Date Valid 10/03/2006APPLICANT Mrs CarrAPPLIC ADDRESS32 Armaghbrague Road,, NewtownhamiltonLOCATION40M East of 32 Armaghbrague Road, NewtownhamiltonPROPOSAL Site for dwelling and garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr Bell Bell Design Services, 123 Crosskeys Road, Armagh, BT60 3LDITEM NO 15APPLIC NO O/2006/0339/O Outline Date Valid 10/03/2006APPLICANT Miss HaughyAPPLIC ADDRESS174 Granmore Road,, Tullybrone, ArmaghLOCATIONOpposite & 20m NE of 18 Slaterock Road, ArmaghbraguePROPOSAL Site for dwelling and garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr Bell Bell Design Services, 123 Crosskeys Road, Armagh, BT60 3LD15 February 2008 Page 7 of 71

ITEM NO 16APPLIC NO O/2006/0347/O Outline Date Valid 06/03/2006APPLICANT Mr & Mrs P DonnellyAPPLIC ADDRESSC/O AgentLOCATIONAdjacent and south of No. 17 Newry Road, Poyntzpass, NewryPROPOSAL Site for dwelling and garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies SP6, SP19, HOU8 and DES5 of the Department's 'APlanning Strategy for Rural Northern Ireland' in that a building on this site would not integrateinto the countryside, as the site is unable to provide a suitable degree of enclosure due to thelack of sufficient boundaries or any other means of achieving satisfactory integration, and asa consequence would, if permitted, have an adverse impact on the landscape by reason of itsundue prominence.2 The proposal is contrary to Policies SP6, DES6 and HOU8 of the Department's PlanningStrategy for Rural Northern Ireland in that the development when considered in the context ofexisting development, would, if permitted, result in a detrimental change to the rural characterof this area of countryside by reason of build-up of development.3 The proposed development would, if permitted, prejudice the safety and convenience of roadusers since it would not be possible within the application site to provide adequate sight lineswhere the existing private laneway joins the minor road.AGENT DETAILS Mr R M Martin Robert M. Martin Architectural Design, 'Rathmourne', 17Tullyhinan Road, Banbridge, Co.Down, BT32 4EY15 February 2008 Page 8 of 71

ITEM NO 17APPLIC NO O/2006/0351/F Full Date Valid 10/03/2006APPLICANT Mr Je LockhartAPPLIC ADDRESS58 Coolmillish Road,, Markethill, Co. Armagh, BT60 1SHLOCATION110m south of 19 Gosford Road, MarkethillPROPOSAL Erection of dwellingREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies SP6, DES6, HOU8 of the Department's Planning Strategyfor Rural Northern Ireland in that the development when considered in the context of existingdevelopment, would, if permitted, result in a detrimental change to the rural character of thisarea of countryside by reason of build-up of development.2 The proposal is contrary to Policies DES7, SP6 and HOU8 of the Department's PlanningStrategy for Rural Northern Ireland in that the development would, if permitted, adverselyaffect the visual amenity and character of the countryside by the creation of ribbondevelopment along this private laneway.3 The proposal is contrary to Policy SP19, DES5 and HOU8 of the Department's PlanningStrategy for Rural Northern Ireland in that the design of the dwelling is unacceptable in thiscountryside location by reason of its form, scale and proportions and would, if permitted, beincongrous in the local landscape.AGENT DETAILSMr Warwick Warwick Architects, 892 Antrim Road, Templepatrick, BT39 0AHITEM NO 18APPLIC NO O/2006/0361/F Full Date Valid 10/03/2006APPLICANT Mr K BoydAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATION60 Main Street, Killylea, ArmaghCammagh Road, Derrynoose, Armagh - 150 metres north east of junction withDrumhillery RoadPROPOSAL Erection of dwelling & garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 Having notified the agent and applicant under Article 7 (4) of the Planning (GeneralDevelopment) Order (Northern Ireland) 1993 that further details were required to allow theDepartment to determine the application, and having not received sufficient information, theDepartment refuses this application as it is the opinion of the Department that this informationis material to the determination of this application.AGENT DETAILSJ Rollston , 88 Fellowshall Road, Killylea, Armagh, BT60 4LZ15 February 2008 Page 9 of 71

ITEM NO 19APPLIC NO O/2006/0390/F Full Date Valid 10/03/2006APPLICANT Mr E ConroyAPPLIC ADDRESS35 Culdee Drive, Armagh, Co. ArmaghLOCATIONAdjacent to and south of 55 Annahagh Road, KilmorePROPOSAL Erection of dwelling and garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr Bell Bell Design Services, 123 Crosskeys Road, Armagh, BT60 3LDITEM NO 20APPLIC NO O/2006/0413/F Full Date Valid 15/03/2006APPLICANT Mr M FeganAPPLIC ADDRESS44 Tassagh Road, Keady, Co.ArmaghLOCATION350 metres south of 54 Ballymacauley Road, SeaghanPROPOSAL Erection of dwelling & garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr Bell Bell Design Services, 123 Crosskeys Road, Armagh, BT60 3LDITEM NO 21APPLIC NO O/2006/0420/O Outline Date Valid 10/03/2006APPLICANT Mr CecilAPPLIC ADDRESS21 Tannyoky Road, Lisraw, NewryLOCATION21 Tannyoky Road, LisrawPROPOSAL Site for replacement dwelling and garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr Bell Bell Design Services, 123 Crosskeys Road, Armagh, BT60 3LD15 February 2008 Page 10 of 71

ITEM NO 22APPLIC NO O/2006/0428/F Full Date Valid 15/03/2006APPLICANT Mr C GaffneyAPPLIC ADDRESS35 Ard-Na-Graine, Armagh, Co. ArmaghLOCATION10 Rawes Road, Derrynoose, Co. Armagh.PROPOSAL Erection of replacement dwellingREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr Bell Bell Design Services, 123 Crosskeys Road, Armagh, BT60 3LDITEM NO 23APPLIC NO O/2006/0435/F Full Date Valid 15/03/2006APPLICANT HydeAPPLIC ADDRESS72 Armagh Rd,, Newtownhamilton, BT35 0E2LOCATION360m North East of 24 Slate Rock Road, NewtownhamiltonPROPOSAL Erection of dwelling and garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSCollins & Collins, 18 Margaret Street, Newry, Co. Down, BT34 1DF15 February 2008 Page 11 of 71

ITEM NO 24APPLIC NO O/2006/0438/O Outline Date Valid 16/03/2006APPLICANT Mr N McalisterAPPLIC ADDRESS33 Old Road, Loughgall, Co.ArmaghLOCATION180 metres north west of 33 Old Road, LoughgallPROPOSAL Site for dwelling and garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies SP6, SP19, HOU8 and DES5 of the Department's 'APlanning Strategy for Rural Northern Ireland' in that a building on this site would not integrateinto the countryside, as the site is unable to provide a suitable degree of enclosure due to thelack of sufficient boundaries or any other means of achieving satisfactory integration, and asa consequence would, if permitted, have an adverse impact on the landscape as it is undulyconspicuous.2 The proposed development may, if permitted, prejudice the safety and convenience of roadusers since the site as submitted does not include the means of access to the public road.AGENT DETAILSMs A Daly O'Neill & Associates, 23 William Street, Portadown,Co.Armagh, BT62 3NXITEM NO 25APPLIC NO O/2006/0459/O Outline Date Valid 22/03/2006APPLICANT Mr R GreeneAPPLIC ADDRESS37 Crossdened Row, Keady, Co.ArmaghLOCATION280 metres north west of 20 Cashel Road, Tassagh, ArmaghPROPOSAL Site for dwelling & garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr Bell Bell Design Services, 123 Crosskeys Road, Armagh, BT60 3LD15 February 2008 Page 12 of 71

ITEM NO 26APPLIC NO O/2006/0474/O Outline Date Valid 24/03/2006APPLICANT Mrs A ReillyAPPLIC ADDRESS 6 Ely Green, Old Court Road, Fairhouse, Dublin 24LOCATION60m South West of No.8 Moore Island Road, ArmaghPROPOSAL Site for dwelling and garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies CTY1 of Draft PPS 14, Sustainable Development in theCountryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement and does not merit being consideredas an exceptional case as the stated need for this dwelling does not justify a relaxation of thestrict planning controls in the countryside.2 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY10 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that theproposed site lacks long established natural boundaries and is unable to provide a suitabledegree of enclosure for the building to integrate into the landscape and therefore would notintegrate into this area of the countryside.3 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY11 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that the thedwelling would, if permitted result in a build-up of development when viewed with existing andapproved buildings and would, if permitted not respect the traditional pattern of settlementexhibited in that area and would therefore result in a detrimental change to the rural characterof the countryside.AGENT DETAILSMr S Mcgeary , 20 Aghinlig Road, Dungannon, Co. Armagh, BT71 6SRITEM NO 27APPLIC NO O/2006/0522/O Outline Date Valid 05/04/2006APPLICANT Mr M QuinnAPPLIC ADDRESS97 Marlacoo Road, Ballynewry, Richhill, BT60 1JNLOCATIONTo the rear of and adjacent to no. 97 Marlacoo Road, Ballynewry, RichhillPROPOSAL Erection of dwelling and garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY1 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that there is apresumption against development throughout the countryside and it does not merit beingconsidered an exception to the policy nor are there any overriding reasons why thisdevelopment is essential and could not be located within a settlement.AGENT DETAILSMr C Lindsey C T Lindsay, The Studio, 66 Marlacoo Road, Richhill,Co.Armagh, BT62 3JW15 February 2008 Page 13 of 71

ITEM NO 28APPLIC NO O/2006/0523/F Full Date Valid 03/04/2006APPLICANT MccallAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSAL27b Ballymacauley Road, Collove, Armagh120m North of 100 Seagahan Road Collone ArmaghVariance of time condition no. 1 on outline planning permissionO/2002/1293/OREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr E Morton , 104 Navan Fort Road, ArmaghITEM NO 29APPLIC NO O/2006/0530/O Outline Date Valid 07/04/2006APPLICANT Mr D HillAPPLIC ADDRESS20a Seagahan Road, Collone, ArmaghLOCATION290 metres south east of 20 Seagahan Road, Collone, ArmaghPROPOSAL Site for dwelling with detached garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies (CTY1) (CTY2) (CTY3) (CTY4) (CTY5) of Draft PPS 14,Sustainable Development in the Countryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement anddoes not merit being considered as an exceptional case as the stated need for this(dwelling/farmworkers dwelling/ farm retirement dwelling/employees dwelling/ replacementdwelling) does not justify a relaxation of the strict planning controls in the countryside.2 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY10 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that: is unableto provide a suitable degree of enclosure for the building to integrate into the landscape andtherefore would not integrate into this area of the countryside.AGENT DETAILSMr W. J. Cornett Cornett Design Associates, 4 Hartford Place, The Mall,Armagh, BT61 9BJ15 February 2008 Page 14 of 71

ITEM NO 30APPLIC NO O/2006/0566/O Outline Date Valid 21/04/2006APPLICANT Mr & Mrs D BlackAPPLIC ADDRESS7 Bann Manor, Hamiltonsbawn, Armagh, BT60 1LTLOCATION210m East of 41 Tirnascobe Road, Tirnascobe, ArmaghPROPOSAL Site for dwelling and garageREPRESENTATION 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies CTY1 of Draft PPS 14, Sustainable Development in theCountryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement and does not merit being consideredas an exceptional case as the stated need for this dwelling does not justify a relaxation of thestrict planning controls in the countryside.AGENT DETAILSMr W. J. Cornett Cornett Design Associates, 4 Hartford Place, The Mall,Armagh, BT61 9BJITEM NO 31APPLIC NO O/2006/0609/O Outline Date Valid 10/05/2006APPLICANT Messrs Select Vestry Lisnadill Parish ChurchAPPLIC ADDRESSC/o AgentLOCATIONAdjacent to and south of 96 Newtownhamilton Road, ArmaghPROPOSAL Site for dwelling and garageREPRESENTATION 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr J Atkinson , 8 Letmacollum Road, Armagh15 February 2008 Page 15 of 71

ITEM NO 32APPLIC NO O/2006/0611/RM Reserved Date Valid 16/03/2006APPLICANTAPPLIC ADDRESSMr D Mclaughlin9 Westlake, Enagh, Derry, BT47 6WELOCATIONAdjacent to and north of 173 Crosskeys Road, ArmaghPROPOSAL Erection of dwelling and detached garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies SP19, DES5 and HOU8 of the Department's PlanningStrategy for Rural Northern Ireland in that the design of the dwelling is unacceptable in thiscountryside location by reason of its form, scale, proportions and architectural style andwould, if permitted, be incongrous in the local landscape.2 Having notified the agent and applicant under Article 7 (4) of the Planning (GeneralDevelopment) Order (Northern Ireland) 1993 that further details regarding revisions to thehouse design submitted were required to allow the Department to determine the application,and having not received sufficient information, the Department refuses this application as it isthe opinion of the Department that this information is material to the determination of thisapplication.AGENT DETAILSMr W. J. Cornett Cornett Design Associates, 4 Hartford Place, The Mall,Armagh, BT61 9BJ15 February 2008 Page 16 of 71

ITEM NO 33APPLIC NO O/2006/0627/O Outline Date Valid 19/05/2006APPLICANT Ms G McgeownAPPLIC ADDRESS135 Newtownhamilton Road, Armagh, BT60 2QULOCATIONAdjcent and South of 135 Newtownhamilton RoadPROPOSAL Site for dwellingREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 1 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY1 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that there is apresumption against development throughout the countryside and it does not merit beingconsidered an exception to the policy nor are there any overriding reasons why thisdevelopment is essential and could not be located within a settlement.2 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY10 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that theproposed site lacks long established natural boundaries/ is unable to provide a suitable degreeof enclosure for the building to integrate into the landscape and therefore would not integrateinto this area of the countryside.3 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY11 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that thedwelling would, if permitted result in a build-up of development when viewed with existing andapproved buildings and would therefore result in a detrimental change to the rural characterof the countryside.4 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY12 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that thedevelopment would, if permitted, result in the creation of ribbon development along theNewtownhamilton Road and would therefore adversely affect the visual amenity andcharacter of the countryside.AGENT DETAILSMckinney , 48 Demesne Park, Rock Road, ArmaghITEM NO 34APPLIC NO O/2006/0705/F Full Date Valid 26/06/2006APPLICANT Mrs A McdonnellAPPLIC ADDRESSDiamond Designs, Main Street, CastleblaneyLOCATION2 Victoria Street, ArmaghPROPOSAL Alteration to provide no.6 apartmentsREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSda architects ltd, Unit 6, Armagh Business Park, Hamiltonsbawn Road,Armagh, BT60 1HW15 February 2008 Page 17 of 71

ITEM NO 35APPLIC NO O/2006/0712/F Full Date Valid 08/06/2006APPLICANT Mr K BurkeAPPLIC ADDRESS73 Kingsmills Road, Whitecross, NewryLOCATIONAdjacent to & south of 271 Mowhan Road, GlenannePROPOSAL Erection of dwelling and garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr J Collins Collins & Collins, 18 Margaret Street, Newry, Co Down, BT341DFITEM NO 36APPLIC NO O/2006/0742/O Outline Date Valid 22/06/2006APPLICANT Mr L DawsonAPPLIC ADDRESS2 Corcreevy Close, Richhill, Co Armagh, BT61 9OWLOCATION150m South West of 69 Keady Road, ArmaghPROPOSAL Site for replacement dwelling and garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr I Donaldson D.A. LTD., Unit 6, Armagh Business Park, HamiltonsbawnRoad, Armagh, BT60 1HWITEM NO 37APPLIC NO O/2006/0780/F Full Date Valid 07/07/2006APPLICANT Mr & Mrs M O'CallaghanAPPLIC ADDRESS6 Tullybrone Road, Tassagh, Co.Armagh, BT60 2NRLOCATION6 Tullybrone Road, Tassagh, ArmaghPROPOSAL Erection of replacement dwellingREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr N Mckee , NW Designs, 34 Foley Road, Armagh, BT60 2QX15 February 2008 Page 18 of 71

ITEM NO 38APPLIC NO O/2006/0797/O Outline Date Valid 07/07/2006APPLICANT Ms E PaynterAPPLIC ADDRESS31 Linseys Hill, Armagh, Co Armagh, BT61 9HDLOCATIONAdjacent to 40 Markethill Road, Drumgaw, ArmaghPROPOSAL Erection of BungalowREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY1 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that there is apresumption against development throughout the countryside and it does not merit beingconsidered an exceptional case as the stated need for this dwelling does not justify arelaxation of the strict planning controls in the countryside.2 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY11 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that: thedwelling would, if permitted result in a build-up of development when viewed with existing andapproved buildings and the dwelling would, if permitted create or add to a ribbon ofdevelopment and would therefore result in a detrimental change to the rural character of thecountryside.3 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY12 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that thedevelopment would, if permitted, result in the extension of ribbon development along MarkethillRoad and would therefore adversely affect the visual amenity and character of thecountryside.4 The proposal is contrary to Planning Policy Statement 3, Development Control: RoadsConsiderations in that it would, if permitted, result in the intensification of use of an existingaccess onto a Main Traffic Route (Protected Route), thereby prejudicing the free flow oftraffic and conditions of general safety.AGENT DETAILSITEM NO 39APPLIC NO O/2006/0837/F Full Date Valid 21/07/2006APPLICANT Messrs Wrk Developments LtdAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSALC/o AgentMowhan Road, Glenanne (land adjacent to 280 Mowhan Road)Housing development - erection of 41 dwellings and associated works(revised scheme)REPRESENTATION 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr S Houston McCreanor & Co. Architects, 85 Plantation Road,Craigavon, BT63 5NJ15 February 2008 Page 19 of 71

ITEM NO 40APPLIC NO O/2006/0839/O Outline Date Valid 24/07/2006APPLICANT Mr J KnipeAPPLIC ADDRESS26, Baltarrn Road, Ballyrea, Armagh, BT604 LFLOCATIONAdjacent to 26, Baltarran Road, Ballyrea, ArmaghPROPOSAL Site for retirement dwellingREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSITEM NO 41APPLIC NO O/2006/0894/F Full Date Valid 15/08/2006APPLICANT Mr B ClarkeAPPLIC ADDRESS93 Crosskeys Road, Keady, BT60 3JULOCATION75-83 Kinelowen Street, KeadyPROPOSAL Housing development - erection of 15 No. dwellingsREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr A Miller HPA Ltd, Unit 4 Seagoe Industrial Estate, Portadown,Co.Armagh, BT63 5QD15 February 2008 Page 20 of 71

ITEM NO 42APPLIC NO O/2006/0900/O Outline Date Valid 22/08/2006APPLICANT Mr G EwartAPPLIC ADDRESS20 Tullycallidy Road, Killylea, Armagh, BT60 4NELOCATION220m North West of Tullycallidy Road, KillyleaPROPOSAL Site for farm workers dwelling and garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies CTY1 and CTY2 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14,Sustainable Development in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement anddoes not merit being considered as an exceptional case, in that it has not been demonstratedthat the proposed dwelling is essential for the proper functioning of the farm for a worker tobe readily available at most times and as other dwellings/development opportunities on thefarm holding have previously been sold off.2 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY10 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that theproposed site lacks long established natural boundaries/ is unable to provide a suitable degreeof enclosure for the building to integrate into the landscape and therefore would not integrateinto this area of the countryside.3 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY11 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that thebuilding would, if permitted, be unduly prominent in the landscape and would therefore resultin a detrimental change to the rural character of the countryside.AGENT DETAILSMr E Ewart Geoffrey Ewart, 20 Tullycallidy Road, Killylea, Armagh, BT604NEITEM NO 43APPLIC NO O/2006/0947/F Full Date Valid 14/09/2006APPLICANTAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSALC/o AgentDarkley Road, Keady (land adjacent to 1 Upper Darkley Road)Housing development - erection of 15No. dwellings and associated works(revised scheme)REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr A Knox McCreanor + Co. Architects, 85 Plantation Road, Craigavon, CoArmagh, BT63 5NJ15 February 2008 Page 21 of 71

ITEM NO 44APPLIC NO O/2006/0962/F Full Date Valid 22/09/2006APPLICANT Mr D DrummAPPLIC ADDRESS61 Castleblaney Road, Keady, Co.ArmaghLOCATIONAdjacent to & south of 61 Castleblaney Road, KeadyPROPOSAL Erection of replacement dwellingREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSITEM NO 45APPLIC NO O/2006/1223/F Full Date Valid 04/12/2006APPLICANT Mr HamiltonAPPLIC ADDRESS11 Church Hill Cottages, CaledonLOCATION140 metres South East of 15 Mullan Road TynanPROPOSAL Erection of dwelling, garage and stablesREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY1 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that there is apresumption against development throughout the countryside and it does not merit beingconsidered an exception to the policy nor are there any overriding reasons why thisdevelopment is essential and could not be located within a settlement.AGENT DETAILSMr R Gillespie Prestige Homes, 1 Lismore Road, Ballygawley, BT70 2ND15 February 2008 Page 22 of 71

ITEM NO 46APPLIC NO O/2006/1262/F Full Date Valid 14/12/2006APPLICANT Mr B McataveyAPPLIC ADDRESSC/o AgentLOCATION160 metres west of 68 Glassdrummond Road, Fergot, MiddletownPROPOSAL Erection of replacement dwelling & garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr E Morton , 104 Navanfort Road, Armagh, BT60 4PSITEM NO 47APPLIC NO O/2007/0017/F Full Date Valid 22/12/2006APPLICANT Mr K KernanAPPLIC ADDRESS3 Hillside Terrace, Benburb, DungannonLOCATION106 Carrickaness Road, Benburb, DungannonPROPOSAL Erection of replacement dwelling and detached garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr N Cornett , Cornett Design Associates, 4 Hartford Place, The Mall,Armagh, BT61 9BJ15 February 2008 Page 23 of 71

ITEM NO 48APPLIC NO O/2007/0079/O Outline Date Valid 22/01/2007APPLICANT F OliverAPPLIC ADDRESS42 Navan Fort Road, Armagh, BT60 4PNLOCATION20 Tirnascobe Road, ArmaghPROPOSAL Site for replacement dwellingREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY1 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that there is apresumption against development throughout the countryside and it does not merit beingconsidered an exception to the policy nor are there any overriding reasons why thisdevelopment is essential and could not be located within a settlement.2 The proposal is contrary to Policies CTY1 and CTY5 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14,Sustainable Development in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement anddoes not merit being considered as an exceptional case in that the residential use has beenabandoned.AGENT DETAILS15 February 2008 Page 24 of 71

ITEM NO 49APPLIC NO O/2007/0131/O Outline Date Valid 12/02/2007APPLICANT Mr S MccrillyAPPLIC ADDRESSKnockaconey Road, Armagh, BT61 8DULOCATIONLand between 21 and 29 Knockaconey Road, ArmaghPROPOSAL Site for 6 no. 2 storey semi-detached and 4 no. 2 storey detached dwellings.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY1 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that there is apresumption against development throughout the countryside and it does not merit beingconsidered an exception to the policy nor are there any overriding reasons why thisdevelopment is essential and could not be located within a settlement.2 The proposal is contrary to Policies CTY6 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement and does notmerit being considered as an exceptional case, in that it has not been demonstrated that aneed has been identified by the NI Housing Executive which cannot be met with an existingsettlement in the locality.3 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY10 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that theproposed site lacks long established natural boundaries is unable to provide a suitable degreeof enclosure for the building to integrate into the landscape4 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY11 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that thedevelopment would, if permitted result in a build-up of development when viewed with existingbuildings and would therefore result in a detrimental change to the rural character of thecountryside.5 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY12 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that thedevelopment would, if permitted, result in the extension of ribbon development alongKnocnaconey Road and would therefore adversely affect the visual amenity and character ofthe countryside.AGENT DETAILSMr E Mccallan McCallan Building Design, 1 Main Street, Carrickmore,Omagh, BT79 9AY15 February 2008 Page 25 of 71

ITEM NO 50APPLIC NO O/2007/0171/F Full Date Valid 27/02/2007APPLICANT Mr & Mrs MccallAPPLIC ADDRESS'Cairnview', 25 Ballymacainley Road,, Collone,, Armagh, BT60 2BPLOCATIONLands 400M South East of No. 166 Seaghan Road, SeagahnPROPOSAL Erection of single dwelling for retirement of farmerREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMs Fc Clelland , Tower House, Charles Shiels Houses, Tower Hill,ArmaghITEM NO 51APPLIC NO O/2007/0178/F Full Date Valid 28/02/2007APPLICANT J WhyteAPPLIC ADDRESS57 Fargot Rd,, Derrynoose,, ArmaghLOCATION33 Tivenacree Road, Derrynoose, ArmaghPROPOSAL Erection of replacement dwelling and private garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSJ Rollston , 88 Fellowshall Road, Killylea, Armagh, BT60 4LZITEM NO 52APPLIC NO O/2007/0211/RM Reserved Date Valid 08/03/2007APPLICANTAPPLIC ADDRESSMr T Wilson160 Tirnascobe Road, Richhill, Armagh, BT61 9RFLOCATIONAdjacent (to North of) 160 Tirnascobe Road, Richhill, ArmaghPROPOSAL Erection of dwelling and garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILS15 February 2008 Page 26 of 71

ITEM NO 53APPLIC NO O/2007/0233/O Outline Date Valid 15/03/2007APPLICANT Mr J DonaldsonAPPLIC ADDRESS57 Cormeen Road, Killylea, Co Armagh, BT60 4NDLOCATION70m South of 57 Cormeen Road, KillyleaPROPOSAL Site for dwelling for a retired farmerREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY10 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that theproposed site lacks long established natural boundaries and is unable to provide a suitabledegree of enclosure for the building to integrate into the landscape and therefore would notintegrate into this area of the countryside.AGENT DETAILSMr J. Donaldson D & D Design, 51 Newry Road,, Armagh,, Co. Armagh.,BT60 1ERITEM NO 54APPLIC NO O/2007/0241/F Full Date Valid 16/03/2007APPLICANT Mr B SmythAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSAL10 Laurencevale, Laurencetown, Craigavon60m North East of 197 Coolmillish Road, Ballymacnab Road, ArmaghChange of house type (non-compliance Condition 7 of O/2003/0245/O)amendment of sitting (at reduced level) and revised access arrangementREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies SP6, SP19, HOU8 and DES5 of the Department's 'APlanning Strategy for Rural Northern Ireland' in that a building on this site would not integrateinto the countryside, as the site is unable to provide a suitable degree of enclosure due to thelack of sufficient boundaries or any other means of achieving satisfactory integration, and asa consequence would, if permitted, have an adverse impact on the landscape by reason of itsundue prominence.2 The proposal is contrary to Policies SP19, DES5, HOU8 of the Department's Planning Strategyfor Rural Northern Ireland in that the design of the dwelling is unacceptable in this countrysidelocation by reason of its scale and massing and would, if permitted, be dominant in the locallandscape.AGENT DETAILSMr Bell Bell Design Services, 123 Crosskeys Road, Armagh, BT60 3LD15 February 2008 Page 27 of 71

ITEM NO 55APPLIC NO O/2007/0308/F Full Date Valid 11/04/2007APPLICANT Mr W DrakeAPPLIC ADDRESSC/o AgentLOCATION58 metres NW of 17 Derrygavad Road Portadown.PROPOSAL Erection of 2 No. dwellings with garages.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY1 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that there is apresumption against development throughout the countryside and it does not merit beingconsidered an exception to the policy nor are there any overriding reasons why thisdevelopment is essential and could not be located within a settlement.2 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY11 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that thedevelopment would, if permitted result in a build-up of development when viewed with existingand approved buildings and would therefore result in a detrimental change to the ruralcharacter of the countryside.3 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY12 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that thedevelopment would, if permitted, result in the creation of ribbon development along theproposed private laneway and would therefore adversely affect the visual amenity andcharacter of the countryside.AGENT DETAILSMr S Rogan , 10A Lurgan Road, Banbridge, Co.Down, BT32 4LU15 February 2008 Page 28 of 71

ITEM NO 56APPLIC NO O/2007/0329/F Full Date Valid 20/04/2007APPLICANT Mr B BellAPPLIC ADDRESS40 Breahey Road, Tynan, BT60 4SFLOCATION320m SW of junction of Hanslough Road/ Creevekeeran Road, ArmaghPROPOSAL Erection of a farm house and garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies CTY1 and CTY2 of Draft PPS 14, Sustainable Developmentin the Countryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement and does not merit beingconsidered as an exceptional case as the stated need for this farm dwelling does not justify arelaxation of the strict planning controls in the countryside.2 The proposal is contrary to Policies CTY1 and CTY2 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14,Sustainable Development in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement anddoes not merit being considered as an exceptional case, in that it has not been demonstratedthat the proposed dwelling is essential to meet the needs of the farm; as there are otherdwellings/development opportunities on the farm holding.3 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY10 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that theproposed dwelling is a prominent feature in the landscape; the proposed site lacks longestablished natural boundaries/ is unable to provide a suitable degree of enclosure for thebuilding to integrate into the landscape; the design of the proposed dwelling is inappropriatefor the site and its locality and therefore would not integrate into this area of the countryside.4 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY11 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that thedwelling would, if permitted, be unduly prominent in the landscape and would therefore resultin a detrimental change to the rural character of the countryside.AGENT DETAILSITEM NO 57APPLIC NO O/2007/0338/F Full Date Valid 24/04/2007APPLICANT Mr G FosterAPPLIC ADDRESS36 Cormeen Road, Killylea, ArmaghLOCATION36 Cormeen Road, Killylea, ArmaghPROPOSAL Erection of replacement dwellingREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr J Rollston , Drum Cottage, Drum Lane, Killylea, Co Armagh, BT60 4LZ15 February 2008 Page 29 of 71

ITEM NO 58APPLIC NO O/2007/0368/RM Reserved Date Valid 01/05/2007APPLICANTAPPLIC ADDRESSMr P MccannC/o AgentLOCATION70m South West of 24 Grange Blundell Road, ArmaghPROPOSAL Erection of new dwellingREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr S Nugent , Gillis Yard, Loughgall Road, Armagh, BT61 7NXITEM NO 59APPLIC NO O/2007/0377/F Full Date Valid 08/05/2007APPLICANT Mr J BeltonAPPLIC ADDRESS16 Carryhugh Road, ArmaghLOCATIONNo. 16 Carryhugh Road, ArmaghPROPOSAL Erection of replacement dwellingREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr Bell Bell Design Services, 123 Crosskeys Road, Armagh, BT60 3LD15 February 2008 Page 30 of 71

ITEM NO 60APPLIC NO O/2007/0391/F Full Date Valid 10/05/2007APPLICANT Mr N WoodsAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSAL18-22 Main Street, Richill50 Portadown Road, TandrageeExtension to existing supermarket to provide off-license, additional store, officeand WCREPRESENTATION 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to the Department's Planning Policy Statement 5, Retailing and TownCentres in that the development would, if permitted, have a detrimental impact in terms ofdesign and proximity to the neighbouring residential dwellings in Linvara by reason ofovershadowing and proximity.AGENT DETAILSClarman Ltd, Lineside House, Lineside, Coalisland, BT71 4LPITEM NO 61APPLIC NO O/2007/0394/F Full Date Valid 11/05/2007APPLICANT Mrs E WilliamsonAPPLIC ADDRESS9 Castleraw Road, Loughgall, Co.ArmaghLOCATION9 Castleraw Road, LoughgallPROPOSAL Erection of replacement dwellingREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies CTY1 and CTY5 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14,Sustainable Development in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement anddoes not merit being considered as an exceptional case in that the proposed replacementdwelling would have a visual impact significantly greater than the existing dwelling and theproposed replacement dwelling is not sited within the established curtilage of the existingdwelling and it has not been demonstrated that the alternative position nearby would result inclear landscape, heritage, access or amenity benefits.AGENT DETAILSMr E Morton , 104 Navanfort Road, Armagh, BT60 4PS15 February 2008 Page 31 of 71

ITEM NO 62APPLIC NO O/2007/0403/F Full Date Valid 15/05/2007APPLICANT Mr R DavidsonAPPLIC ADDRESS189 Mowhan Road, Markethill, Co.ArmaghLOCATION197 & 199 Mowhan Road, MarkethillPROPOSAL Erection of 2 No. replacement dwellingsREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr Bell Bell Design Services, 123 Crosskeys Road, Armagh, BT60 3LDITEM NO 63APPLIC NO O/2007/0468/F Full Date Valid 06/06/2007APPLICANT Miss L CurtisAPPLIC ADDRESSC/o AgentLOCATION70 Aghory Road, PortadownPROPOSAL Conversion of existing barn to dwelling.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 2 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr C Lindsay ct Lindsay, The Studio, 66 Marlacoo Road, Richhill, CoArmagh, BT60 1JWITEM NO 64APPLIC NO O/2007/0472/F Full Date Valid 11/06/2007APPLICANT Mr M SmythAPPLIC ADDRESSC/o AgentLOCATION40 Lagan Road, KeadyPROPOSAL Erection of replacement dwelling and garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr D Cairns Greeves Kelly Architects, 9 The Linen Green, Moygashel,Dungannon, BT71 7HB15 February 2008 Page 32 of 71

ITEM NO 65APPLIC NO O/2007/0485/F Full Date Valid 12/06/2007APPLICANT Mr P NugentAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSAL7 Ridgeway Avenue, Moy, BT71 7TENo.5 Abbey Street, ArmaghChange of use from domestic dwelling to office accommodation includingexternal lift shaftREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr J Austin Holmes and Doran, First Floor Old Savings Bank, 1 VictoriaStreet, Armagh, BT62 9DSITEM NO 66APPLIC NO O/2007/0488/F Full Date Valid 14/06/2007APPLICANT Mr R AuldAPPLIC ADDRESSThe Beeches Stud, Temple Road, Ballinderry Upper, BT78 2PDLOCATION54 Crosskeys Road, ArmaghPROPOSAL Erection of replacement dwelling and garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr Jr Rollston John Rollston, 88 Fellows Hall Road, Killylea, Armagh,BT60 4LZ15 February 2008 Page 33 of 71

ITEM NO 67APPLIC NO O/2007/0493/F Full Date Valid 14/06/2007APPLICANT Www EnterpriseAPPLIC ADDRESSC/o AgentLOCATIONBetween numbers 35 and 39 The Oaks, Derryhale, PortadownPROPOSAL Erection of 4 apartments.REPRESENTATION 6 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policy QD1 (a, c, g & h) of the Department's Planning PolicyStatement 7 - Quality Residential Environments in that the applicant has failed to demonstratethat the proposal will create a quality and sustainable residential environment.2 The proposed development would, if permitted, be out of keeping with the general characterof existing development in this area, by reason of its scale, height & massing.3 The proposed development would, if permitted, harm the living conditions of residents innumbers 35 & 39 Derryhale Road by reason of overlooking & consequent lack of privacy, andovershadowing.4 The proposal is contrary to the Department's Quality Initiative in that the development would, ifpermitted, be unacceptable by reason of its design and layout.AGENT DETAILSA3 Architecture Design Planning Ltd, 43-45 Church Street, Portadown,BT62 3EUITEM NO 68APPLIC NO O/2007/0513/O Outline Date Valid 25/06/2007APPLICANT Mr T McardleAPPLIC ADDRESS16 Rockstown Road, CladybegLOCATION50m West of 18 Rockstown Road, CladybegPROPOSAL Site for 2 Storey Replacement dwelling and garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr M Bailie Martin Bailie, Architectural Services Ltd, 19 Newry Street,Rathfriland, Co Down, BT34 5PY15 February 2008 Page 34 of 71

ITEM NO 69APPLIC NO O/2007/0518/F Full Date Valid 26/06/2007APPLICANT Mr D HughesAPPLIC ADDRESS70 Cortamlet Road, NewtownhamiltonLOCATION120m S.W of 'Outlack House' 8 Outlack Road, ArmaghPROPOSAL Erection of dwelling and detached garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr N Cornett , Cornett Design Associates, 4 Hartford Place, The Mall,Armagh, BT61 9BJITEM NO 70APPLIC NO O/2007/0524/F Full Date Valid 27/06/2007APPLICANT Mr E LenaghanAPPLIC ADDRESS15 Hillside Park, Hamiltonsbawn, Co.ArmaghLOCATION105 Derryraine Road, Drumachee, ArmaghPROPOSAL Erection of replacement dwellingREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr I Lenaghan Ian Lenaghan Design, 30 Moss Park, Richhill, Co Armagh,BT61 9PTITEM NO 71APPLIC NO O/2007/0535/O Outline Date Valid 02/07/2007APPLICANT Mr P LoughranAPPLIC ADDRESSC/o 91 Maheraville Road, Armagh, BT60 3PLLOCATION27, Clady Road, Clady, Mowhan, ArmaghPROPOSAL Replacement dwelling and detached garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr O'Reilly , 1 Old Mill Court, Milford, Armagh15 February 2008 Page 35 of 71

ITEM NO 72APPLIC NO O/2007/0551/F Full Date Valid 10/07/2007APPLICANT Mr B RowntreeAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSALNorthern Ireland Water, 34 College Street, Belfast, BT1 6DRSeagahan WTW, Ballymacnab Road, Co Armagh, Northern IrelandRemoval of one Slow Sand Filter adjacent to existing GAC Building, to bereplaced with new building (similar to existing building) to house new DAFplant for upgrade of the Water Treatment WorksREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMs S Walker Jacobs, Rochester Building, 28 Adelaide Street, Belfast, BT28GBITEM NO 73APPLIC NO O/2007/0574/F Full Date Valid 16/07/2007APPLICANT Mr J KeysAPPLIC ADDRESS180 Markethill Road, Portadown, Co.Armagh, BT62 3SLLOCATION180 Mullalelish Road, PortadownPROPOSAL Refurbishment and extension to existing dwellingREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMcCollum Building Surveying, 42 Farlough Road, Dungannon, CoTyrone, BT71 4DU15 February 2008 Page 36 of 71

ITEM NO 74APPLIC NO O/2007/0575/LB Listed Building Date Valid 16/07/2007APPLICANT Mr J KeysAPPLIC ADDRESS180 Markethill Road, Portadown, Co.Armagh, BT62 3SLLOCATION180 Mullalelish Road, PortadownPROPOSAL Conservation of thatched, clay built dwelling with new rear extensionREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMcCollum Building Surveying, 42 Farlough Road, Dungannon, CoTyrone, BT71 4DUITEM NO 75APPLIC NO O/2007/0580/F Full Date Valid 16/07/2007APPLICANT Mr R ReaneyAPPLIC ADDRESS45 Killycopple Road, Armagh, BT60 2AGLOCATION360m SE of 87 Ballymoran RoadPROPOSAL Erection of wind turbineREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILS15 February 2008 Page 37 of 71

ITEM NO 76APPLIC NO O/2007/0602/F Full Date Valid 25/07/2007APPLICANT Mr S DowhardAPPLIC ADDRESSC/o AgentLOCATION22 Cladymilltown Road, MarkethillPROPOSAL Erection of new carport & stores ancillary to existing private dwellingREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policy HOU16 of the Department's Planning Strategy for RuralNorthern Ireland in that the proposed garage would, if permitted, adversely affect theamenities of the area by reason of its unsympathetic scale and its impact on the character andappearance of the surrounding area.2 The proposal is contrary to EXT 1 (Residential Extensions and Alterations) of the AddendumPPS 7 (Residential Extensions and Alterations) in that the proposal is not subordinate and dueto the detached form, scale, height, length and design, it does not integrate into the site andsurrounding rural area; and would result in the erosion of rural character.AGENT DETAILSWarwick Stewart Architects, 892 Antrim Road, Templepatrick, BT39 0AHITEM NO 77APPLIC NO O/2007/0611/F Full Date Valid 31/07/2007APPLICANT Mr & Mrs HillAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSAL12 Ballysheil Road, Clare, Tandragee, BT622HXAdjacent to No.17 Mavevemacullen Road, Clare, TandrageeConstruction of a slurry storage tank and a round roof midden, to comply withFNMS requirements.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr G Mcneill , 79 Bridge Street, Portadown, Co Armagh, BT63 5AA15 February 2008 Page 38 of 71

ITEM NO 78APPLIC NO O/2007/0618/F Full Date Valid 03/08/2007APPLICANT Mr F DonnellyAPPLIC ADDRESS3 Ivy Park, MiddletownLOCATION49 Mill Road, Coolhill, ArmaghPROPOSAL Erection of replacement dwellingREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSCornett Design Associates, 4 Hartford Place,, The Mall,, Armagh, BT619BJITEM NO 79APPLIC NO O/2007/0623/F Full Date Valid 06/08/2007APPLICANT Mr N ChapmanAPPLIC ADDRESS55 Mulladry Road, Richhill, BT619LPLOCATION67 Mulladry Road, Richhill, Co.ArmaghPROPOSAL Erection of Replacement Two Story Dwelling House and GarageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSR E Quinn Architects, 14 Princes Street, Dromore, BT25 1AYITEM NO 80APPLIC NO O/2007/0637/F Full Date Valid 15/08/2007APPLICANT Mr D MurphyAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSAL27 Keelmount Grange, Portadown136 Lislasly Road, DungannonErection of replacement dwelling and garage (within settlement limit ofCollegeland)REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILST J Lavery, 19 Five Acres, Portadown, Co.Armagh, BT63 5UH15 February 2008 Page 39 of 71

ITEM NO 81APPLIC NO O/2007/0645/F Full Date Valid 20/08/2007APPLICANT Mr J FinleyAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSAL23 Main Street, Middletown, Co. Armagh, BT 60 4JF23 Main Street, Middletown, Co. Armagh BT604JFProposed replacement of existing single storey rear return, with two storeyextension and sun lounge.REPRESENTATION 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policy DES 2 of the Department's Planning Strategy for RuralNorthern Ireland in that the development would, if permitted, be out of scale andunsympathetic to the original building by reason of its size relationship with each other.2 The proposed development would, if permitted, harm the living conditions of the residents innumber 19 by reason of overshadowing.3 Having notified the agent under Article 7 (4) of the Planning (General Development ) Order(Northern Ireland) 1993 that further details were required to allow the Department to determinethe application, and having not received sufficient information, the Department refuses thisapplication as it is the opinion of the Department that this information is material to thedetermination of this application.AGENT DETAILSMr J Kerr JPM Kerr Chartered Surveyors, First Floor, 21A Railway Street,Armagh, BT61 7HP15 February 2008 Page 40 of 71

ITEM NO 82APPLIC NO O/2007/0668/F Full Date Valid 30/08/2007APPLICANT Mr S HamiltonAPPLIC ADDRESS29 Ballysheil Road, Tandragee, Co.ArmaghLOCATIONSite 65m South of 40 Clare Road, Tandragee, Co.ArmaghPROPOSAL Erection of domestic dwelling and garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies SP 6, SP 19, HOU 8 and DES 5 of the Department's 'APlanning Strategy for Rural Northern Ireland' in that a building on this site would not integrateinto the countryside, as the site is unable to provide a suitable degree of enclosure due to thelack of sufficient boundaries or any other means of achieving satisfactory integration, and asa consequence would, if permitted, have an adverse impact on the landscape by reason of itsundue prominence.2 The proposal is contrary to Policies SP 6, DES 6, HOU 8 of the Department's Planning Strategyfor Rural Northern Ireland in that the development when considered in the context of existingdevelopment, would, if permitted, result in a detrimental change to the rural character of thisarea of countryside by reason of build-up.AGENT DETAILSMr Jy Young J+T Consultants, 40 Clare Road, Tandragee, Co.Armagh,BT62 2EZITEM NO 83APPLIC NO O/2007/0679/F Full Date Valid 04/09/2007APPLICANT Messrs Crossfire TrustAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONDarkley House, 95 Darkley Road, Keady, BT60 3AYThe Garages, Darkley House, 95 Darkley Road, Keady, Co.Armagh, BT60 3AYPROPOSAL Erection of flats developmentREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr E Quinn R E Quinn Architects, 14, Princes Street, Dromore, Co.Down,BT25 1AY15 February 2008 Page 41 of 71

ITEM NO 84APPLIC NO O/2007/0689/F Full Date Valid 04/09/2007APPLICANT Sally McnallyAPPLIC ADDRESSC/o AgentLOCATION91 Markethill Road, PortadownPROPOSAL Alteration and refurbishment of existing Public House and OfficesREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr L Warren ML Design & Management, 25-27 Edward Street, Portadown,Co Armagh, BT62 3NEITEM NO 85APPLIC NO O/2007/0690/RM Reserved Date Valid 10/09/2007APPLICANTAPPLIC ADDRESSS Courtney21 Dundrum Road, Tassagh, ArmaghLOCATION23 Dundrum Road, Tassagh, ArmaghPROPOSAL Erection of replacement dwelling and garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr Bell Bell Design Services, 123 Crosskeys Road, Armagh, BT60 3LDITEM NO 86APPLIC NO O/2007/0696/F Full Date Valid 10/09/2007APPLICANT Messrs Drumeen ConstructionAPPLIC ADDRESSC/O AgentLOCATIONTo the rear of 90 to 96 Market Street, Ballymore, TandrageePROPOSAL Erection of office/Light Industrial UnitREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSC T Lindsay Chartered Architect , The Studio,, 66 Marlacoo Road, Richhill,County Armagh, BT62 3JW15 February 2008 Page 42 of 71

ITEM NO 87APPLIC NO O/2007/0709/F Full Date Valid 14/09/2007APPLICANT WhiteAPPLIC ADDRESSC/O AgentLOCATION177 Battleford Road, ArmaghPROPOSAL Erection of Replacement dwellingREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr E Morton , 104 Navanfort Road, Armagh, BT60 4PSITEM NO 88APPLIC NO O/2007/0727/F Full Date Valid 19/09/2007APPLICANT Messrs Floorform LtdAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSALUnit 16, Loughbrook Industrial Estate, Newry, BT35 7EESite at junction of Edenaveys Road & Markethill Road, ArmaghErection of light industrial unit for manufacture & storage of flooring materials &associated offices, service yard & car parkingREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSITEM NO 89APPLIC NO O/2007/0732/RM Reserved Date Valid 20/09/2007APPLICANTAPPLIC ADDRESSMr K ScottC/o AgentLOCATION450 metres north of No.8 Glebe Lane, LoughgallPROPOSAL Erection of dwellingREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr J Richardson , 9 Shanecracken, Markethill, Co Armagh, BT60 1TS15 February 2008 Page 43 of 71

ITEM NO 90APPLIC NO O/2007/0736/F Full Date Valid 21/09/2007APPLICANT Mr & Mrs SymthAPPLIC ADDRESSC/o AgentLOCATIONRetention of dwelling adjacent to 53a Blackwatertown Road, ArmaghPROPOSAL Retention of single storey dwellingREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY1 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that there is apresumption against development throughout the countryside and it does not merit beingconsidered an exception to the policy nor are there any overriding reasons why thisdevelopment is essential and could not be located within a settlement.2 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY11 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that thedwelling would, if permitted result in a build-up of development when viewed with existing andapproved buildings and would therefore result in a detrimental change to the rural characterof the countryside.3 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY12 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that thedevelopment would, if permitted, result in the creation of ribbon development alongBlackwatertown Road and would therefore adversely affect the visual amenity and characterof the countryside.AGENT DETAILSMr J Kerr JPM Kerr Chartered Surveyors, First Floor, 21A Railway Street,Armagh, BT61 7HPITEM NO 91APPLIC NO O/2007/0738/F Full Date Valid 21/09/2007APPLICANT Mr & Mrs CallaghanAPPLIC ADDRESSC/o AgentLOCATION104 Battlehill Road, Richhill, Co ArmaghPROPOSAL Erection of replacement dwellingREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr C Lindsay ct Lindsay, The Studio, 66 Marlacoo Road, Richhill, CoArmagh, BT60 1JW15 February 2008 Page 44 of 71

ITEM NO 92APPLIC NO O/2007/0776/RM Reserved Date Valid 01/10/2007APPLICANTAPPLIC ADDRESSVillage Construction20 Cannagola Beg Road, Portadown, BT62 1RRLOCATION250metres south west of 1 Shillinghill Road, Lisnagat, ArmaghPROPOSAL Erection of Dwelling.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr N Cornett , Cornett Design Associates, 4 Hartford Place, The Mall,Armagh, BT61 9BJITEM NO 93APPLIC NO O/2007/0789/O Outline Date Valid 08/10/2007APPLICANT Ms P ToddAPPLIC ADDRESS5 Hawthorne Hill, Portadown, Co.Armagh, BT63 5XULOCATION220 metres north west of 42 Tullymore Road, Kilmore, ArmaghPROPOSAL Site for dwelling and domestic garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies CTY1 of Draft PPS 14, Sustainable Development in theCountryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement and does not merit being consideredas an exceptional case as the stated need for this dwelling does not justify a relaxation of thestrict planning controls in the countryside.AGENT DETAILS15 February 2008 Page 45 of 71

ITEM NO 94APPLIC NO O/2007/0792/O Outline Date Valid 08/10/2007APPLICANT Mr P ToddAPPLIC ADDRESS170 Moy Road, Portadown, BT62 1SBLOCATION170 metres north east of No.33 Bloomhill Road, Kilmore, ArmaghPROPOSAL Site for dwelling and domestic garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies CTY1 of Draft PPS 14, Sustainable Development in theCountryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement and does not merit being consideredas an exceptional case as the stated need for this dwelling does not justify a relaxation of thestrict planning controls in the countryside.2 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY10 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that theproposed dwelling is a prominent feature in the landscape and therefore would not integrateinto this area of the countryside.AGENT DETAILSITEM NO 95APPLIC NO O/2007/0796/F Full Date Valid 09/10/2007APPLICANT Mr T LeyburnAPPLIC ADDRESS10 Glassdrummond Road, MiddletownLOCATION160m south east of 10 Glassdrummond Road, Middletown.PROPOSAL Erection of 1 No. wind turbine 33m high with associated site works.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSCornett Design Associates, 4 Hartford Place,, The Mall,, Armagh, BT619BJ15 February 2008 Page 46 of 71

ITEM NO 96APPLIC NO O/2007/0800/F Full Date Valid 08/10/2007APPLICANT Mr A MackleAPPLIC ADDRESS40 Corrigan Hill Road, Moy, Dungannon, Co.Tyrone, BT71 6SLLOCATION40 Corrigan Hill Road, Moy, Dungannon, Co.Tyrone.PROPOSAL Replacement dwelling house and garage.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr Mccorry Shane McCorry Architects, 43 Church Place, Lurgan, BT666EUITEM NO 97APPLIC NO O/2007/0803/F Full Date Valid 09/10/2007APPLICANT Mr R HamiltonAPPLIC ADDRESS92 Markethill Road, Collone, ArmaghLOCATION190 metres north east of 92 Markethill Road, Collone, Armagh.PROPOSAL Erection of 1 no organic free range chicken house and associated site works.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSCornett Design Associates, 4 Hartford Place,, The Mall,, Armagh, BT619BJITEM NO 98APPLIC NO O/2007/0806/F Full Date Valid 11/10/2007APPLICANT Lauren Developments Ltd.APPLIC ADDRESS35 Dungannon Street, Moy, Co. Tyrone, BT71 7SHLOCATION2 Benburb Street, Blackwatertown, Co. Armagh.PROPOSAL Change of house type at no's 18, 20 & 22 from 3 storey to 2 storey.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr Cd Donaghy Lauren Developments Ltd, 35 Dungannon Street, Moy,Co. Tyrone, BT71 7SH15 February 2008 Page 47 of 71

ITEM NO 99APPLIC NO O/2007/0816/O Outline Date Valid 08/10/2007APPLICANT ToddAPPLIC ADDRESS11 Old Mill,, Tandragee, BT62 2JHLOCATION120M South East of 170 Moy Road, PortadownPROPOSAL Site for dwelling and domestic garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies CTY1 of Draft PPS 14, Sustainable Development in theCountryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement and does not merit being consideredas an exceptional case as the stated need for this dwelling does not justify a relaxation of thestrict planning controls in the countryside.2 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY10 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that theproposed site lacks long established natural boundaries/ is unable to provide a suitable degreeof enclosure for the building to integrate into the landscape and therefore would not integrateinto this area of the countryside.AGENT DETAILSITEM NO 100APPLIC NO O/2007/0818/F Full Date Valid 15/10/2007APPLICANT Mr P SmythAPPLIC ADDRESS37 Carrickduff Road, Carnagh, ArmaghLOCATION150 metres north west of 32 Carrickduff Road, Carnagh, ArmaghPROPOSAL Erection of dwelling and garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies CTY1 of Draft PPS 14, Sustainable Development in theCountryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement and does not merit being consideredas an exceptional case as the stated need for this dwelling does not justify a relaxation of thestrict planning controls in the countryside.AGENT DETAILSMr Bell Bell Design Services, 123 Crosskeys Road, Armagh, BT60 3LD15 February 2008 Page 48 of 71

ITEM NO 101APPLIC NO O/2007/0820/RM Reserved Date Valid 11/10/2007APPLICANTAPPLIC ADDRESSMr & Mrs S DonnellyC/o AgentLOCATION120 metres south east of 19 Milltown Road, Benburb, Co. Tyrone.PROPOSAL Erection of a storey and a half dwelling and detached garage.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr J Kerr JPM Kerr Chartered Surveyors, First Floor, 21A Railway Street,Armagh, BT61 7HPITEM NO 102APPLIC NO O/2007/0853/F Full Date Valid 24/10/2007APPLICANT Mr M HughesAPPLIC ADDRESS252 Newtownhamilton Road, ArmaghLOCATION10 Kinelowen Street, Keady.PROPOSAL Change of use from former off-license to fast food take away.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr E Morton , 104 Navanfort Road, Armagh, BT60 4PS15 February 2008 Page 49 of 71

ITEM NO 103APPLIC NO O/2007/0859/F Full Date Valid 25/10/2007APPLICANT Mr S McguiganAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATION164 Granemore Road, Tassagh, Armagh, BT60 2NL150 metres due south from 164 Granemore Road, Tassagh, Armagh+PROPOSAL Erection of two 14.65m high wind turbinesREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr J Mcg Mcguigan , 164 Granemore Road, Tassagh, Armagh, BT60 2NLITEM NO 104APPLIC NO O/2007/0862/F Full Date Valid 26/10/2007APPLICANT Mr G ReidAPPLIC ADDRESS76 Ballygroobany Road, Ballynahinch, Richhill, Co. ArmaghLOCATION76 Ballygroobany Road, Ballynahinch, Richhill, Co. Armagh.PROPOSAL Alterations and extension to dwelling.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies (SP12/GB.CPA 1/GB.CPA3) and HOU16 of theDepartment's Planning Strategy for Rural Northern Ireland in that the site lies in the ArmaghCountryside Policy Area and the extension would if permitted, create an unacceptable impactharming the visual amenities in this area of strict control by reason of scale, dominance anddesign.AGENT DETAILSMr I Lenaghan Ian Lenaghan Design, 30 Moss Park, Richhill, Co Armagh,BT61 9PT15 February 2008 Page 50 of 71

ITEM NO 105APPLIC NO O/2007/0902/RM Reserved Date Valid 08/11/2007APPLICANTAPPLIC ADDRESSMr P H Hughes57 Ballytrodden Road, Benburb, Armagh, BT71 7LTLOCATION260m N/E of 59 Ballytrodden Road, Benburb, ArmaghPROPOSAL New bungalow and garage.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSDesigns Services Architectural Designs Service, 16 Derrloiste Road,Craigavon, BT66 6PSITEM NO 106APPLIC NO O/2007/0903/RM Reserved Date Valid 07/11/2007APPLICANTAPPLIC ADDRESSJ Bell62 Carryhugh Road, Camagh, AramghLOCATION90 Meters North West of 21 Cargalisgorran Road Drumhillery Armagh.PROPOSAL Erection of a dwelling.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr E Morton , 104 Navanfort Road, Armagh, BT60 4PS15 February 2008 Page 51 of 71

ITEM NO 107APPLIC NO O/2007/0918/F Full Date Valid 15/11/2007APPLICANT Northern Ireland Housing Executive.APPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSALMarlborough House, Central Way, Craigavon, BT64 1AJ16 St. Matthews Estate, Keady. (C'Type).Internal improvements - W.C and Hall extension to rear Oil Fired centralheating.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr Rh Hylands Harry Dornan D+PS Manager, NIHE Marlborough House,Central Way, Craigavon, BT64 1AJITEM NO 108APPLIC NO O/2007/0931/F Full Date Valid 19/11/2007APPLICANT Mr M MallonAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSAL63 Teeraw Road, Armagh135 / 137 Railway Street, ArmaghDemolition and replacement of existing Amusement Gaming Arcade andadjacent Hot Food Bar with four number Flats overREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr Bell Bell Design Services, 123 Crosskeys Road, Armagh, BT60 3LDITEM NO 109APPLIC NO O/2007/0938/F Full Date Valid 21/11/2007APPLICANT W P LindsayAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSAL11 Brentwood Park, Richhill, BT61 9JG11 Brentwood Park, Richhill, Co ArmaghRetention of single storey extension (extension to kitchen, utility room andsunroom.)REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSR Walker , 38 Brentwood Park, Richhill, Co Armagh, BT61 9JG15 February 2008 Page 52 of 71

ITEM NO 110APPLIC NO O/2007/0951/F Full Date Valid 27/11/2007APPLICANT Mr McnallyAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSAL80 Castleblaney Road,, Keady,, Armagh, BT60 3QTApprox 250m West of 31 Edenard Road, Mowhan, Armagh BT60 2HGErection of 15m high, 6KW proven wind turbine for domestic use at newdwelling 250m west of 31 Edenard RoadREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSITEM NO 111APPLIC NO O/2007/0957/RM Reserved Date Valid 27/11/2007APPLICANTAPPLIC ADDRESSMr J Bell236 Monaghan Road, Middletown, Co.Armagh, BT60 4HQLOCATION300 metres south of 222 Monaghan Road, MiddletownPROPOSAL Erection of dwelling & garageREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSITEM NO 112APPLIC NO O/2007/0962/F Full Date Valid 30/11/2007APPLICANT Mr & Mrs D ReaneyAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSALC/O Agent11 Portadown Road, ArmaghTwo storey side Extension to semi - detached Dwelling to extend Kitchen onlower ground floor and living on ground.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSDes Ewing Residential Architects, The Studio, 13 Bangor Road,Holywood, BT18 0NU15 February 2008 Page 53 of 71

ITEM NO 113APPLIC NO O/2007/0963/LB Listed Building Date Valid 29/11/2007APPLICANT Armagh City And District CouncilAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSALThe Palace Demense, Armagh, BT60 4EL40 AND 40A Upper English Street, ArmaghAlterations to T.I.C Courtyard to comply with current DDA requirements. Worksto include new Handrails / Balustrades, tactile indication, colour contrastingDisc inserts to stair treads, automated doors, the replacement of the existingglazed screen to the rear of the T.I.C building to match existing and thereplacement / regrading of paving.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr V Trueman Wheelan & Co., 17 Dromore Road, Lurgan, Craigavon,BT66 7LDITEM NO 114APPLIC NO O/2007/0969/F Full Date Valid 30/11/2007APPLICANT Rev E SweeneyAPPLIC ADDRESSParochial House, 42 Abbey Street, Armagh, BT61 7DZLOCATIONSt Catherine's College, Convent Road, ArmaghPROPOSAL Erection of one temporary mobile replacement classroomREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSPhp Architects PHP Architects, 22 Mount Charles, Belfast, BT7 1NZ15 February 2008 Page 54 of 71

ITEM NO 115APPLIC NO O/2007/0970/F Full Date Valid 30/11/2007APPLICANT Mr J Mc CannAPPLIC ADDRESSC/o AgentLOCATIONAdjacent and south of 107 Portadown Road, ArmaghPROPOSAL Proposed below ground slurry storage tankREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr M Sloane Holmes and Doran Surveyors, Ist Floor, The Old SavingsBank, 1 Victoria Street, Armagh, BT61 9DSITEM NO 116APPLIC NO O/2007/0976/F Full Date Valid 06/12/2007APPLICANT Miss B JordanAPPLIC ADDRESS68 Tullysaran Road, ArmaghLOCATION74 Tullysaran Road, Armagh.PROPOSAL Alterations and Extension to DwellingREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSBell Design Services, 123 Crosskeys Road, Armagh, BT60 3LDITEM NO 117APPLIC NO O/2007/0980/F Full Date Valid 07/12/2007APPLICANT N.I.H.E.APPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONMarlborough House, Central Way, Craigavon, BT64 1AJFront of No's 33-36 St Brigid's Hill and side of No.28 Drumbreda Avenue,Armagh.PROPOSAL Extension of Housing Estate Car Parking.REPRESENTATION 2 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr Rh Hylands Harry Dornan D+PS Manager, NIHE Marlborough House,Central Way, Craigavon, BT64 1AJ15 February 2008 Page 55 of 71

ITEM NO 118APPLIC NO O/2007/0982/F Full Date Valid 07/12/2007APPLICANT Armagh City And District CouncilAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSALThe Palace Demesne, Armagh, BT60 4EL40 and 40 a Upper English Street, Armagh, BT61 7BA.Alterations to Tourist Information Centre courtyard to comply with currentDisablity Discrimination Act requirements. Works to include newhandrailing/balustrades, tactile indication, automated doors, replacement ofpaving to existing levels.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr V Trueman Wheelan & Co., 17 Dromore Road, Lurgan, Craigavon,BT66 7LDITEM NO 119APPLIC NO O/2007/0984/F Full Date Valid 10/12/2007APPLICANT Mr M Mc NieceAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSAL38 A Annaghmore Road, Portadown, BT62 1NATo the rear of 38a Annaghmore Road, Portadown, BT62 1NA.Retention of new access to accomodate new dwelling previously approvedunder ref O/2006/0269/F.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILS15 February 2008 Page 56 of 71

ITEM NO 120APPLIC NO O/2007/0986/O Outline Date Valid 10/12/2007APPLICANT Mr F Mc NallyAPPLIC ADDRESS35a Derrykeeran Road, PortadownLOCATIONOpposite 92 Teaguy Road, Annaghmore, Portadown, BT62 1LX.PROPOSAL Site for Public Bar.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY1 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that there is apresumption against development throughout the countryside and it does not merit beingconsidered an exception to the policy nor are there any overriding reasons why thisdevelopment is essential and could not be located within a settlement.2 The Proposal is contrary to Policy CTY 13 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that thedevelopment would, if permitted, harm the rural setting of Annaghmore by reason of urbansprawl.3 The proposal is contrary to the Department's Planning Policy Statement 5, Retailing and TownCentres in that the site lies outside the development limits of Annaghmore as designated in theArmagh Area Plan and no special need has been demonstrated to justify relaxation of thestrict planning controls exercised in the countryside.AGENT DETAILSKarl McElroy, McElroy House, 119 Bridge Street, PortadownITEM NO 121APPLIC NO O/2007/0990/F Full Date Valid 07/12/2007APPLICANT Mr M FeganAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSAL6 Mallview Terrace, Armagh17 Lower English Street, Armagh.2 Storey Extension to the rear, and alterations to the Dormer window to therear.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr J Bell Holmes and Doran Surveyors, 1st Floor, The Old Savings Bank,1 Victoria Street, Armagh, BT61 9DS15 February 2008 Page 57 of 71

ITEM NO 122APPLIC NO O/2007/0998/F Full Date Valid 13/12/2007APPLICANT P H HewittAPPLIC ADDRESSClontilew House, Clontilew Road, PortadownLOCATIONAdjacent to 13 Clontliew Road, Portadown.PROPOSAL Proposed conversion of car port into garage.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr H Mc Aleer HD DESIGN, 3 Bannview Road, Banbridge, BT32 3RLITEM NO 123APPLIC NO O/2007/0999/F Full Date Valid 13/12/2007APPLICANT Marks And Spencer Plc.APPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONProperty (TP4.1), The Point, 37 North Wharf Road, London, W2 1AFMarks and Spencer, Simply food, Unit 2, Spires Retail Park, Moy Road,Armagh.PROPOSAL Erection of two shopping trolley bays and shelters.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSNathaniel Lichfield & Partners Ltd, 14 Regents Wharf, All Saints Street,London, N1 9RLITEM NO 124APPLIC NO O/2007/1001/F Full Date Valid 14/12/2007APPLICANT Mrs E CrozierAPPLIC ADDRESS27 Drumman Heights, Portadown Road, Armagh, BT61 9SJLOCATION27 Drumman Heights, Portadown Road, Armagh.PROPOSAL Construction of Bedroom above existing Garage.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILS15 February 2008 Page 58 of 71

ITEM NO 125APPLIC NO O/2007/1003/F Full Date Valid 14/12/2007APPLICANT Gosford Housing AssociationAPPLIC ADDRESS1 Barrack Hill, Armagh, BT60 1BLLOCATION 2A, 2, 13, 14, 19, 20, 21,25, 27, 29 Lisanally Lane, Armagh. BT61 7HE. 1, 7, 9,13, 17 Railway Street, Armagh. BT61 7HP.PROPOSALMEI Works to 15No. Dwellings, including demolition and replacement of rearExtensions including boundary walls.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr D Press WH Stephens, Stephens House, 63 Malone Road, Belfast,BT9 6SAITEM NO 126APPLIC NO O/2007/1004/F Full Date Valid 14/12/2007APPLICANT Northern Ireland Housing ExecutiveAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSALThe Housing Centre, 2 Adelaide Street, Belfast, BT2 8BP28 Lonsdale Road, Armagh.Refurbishment of Existing Aluminium Bungalow to include re-cladding existingdwelling Walls with render system and new roof covering etc.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr Wh Hall W&M Given Architects, Beresford House, 2 Beresford Road,Colraine, BT52 1GE15 February 2008 Page 59 of 71

ITEM NO 127APPLIC NO O/2007/1005/F Full Date Valid 17/12/2007APPLICANT E MckennaAPPLIC ADDRESS37 Crossmore Road, KeadyLOCATION37 Crossmore Green, Keady.PROPOSAL Rear Kitchen Extension to Dwelling.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr E Morton , 104 Navanfort Road, Armagh, BT60 4PSITEM NO 128APPLIC NO O/2007/1007/F Full Date Valid 18/12/2007APPLICANT Northern Ireland ElectricityAPPLIC ADDRESSCarn Industrial Estate, Portadown, BT63 5QJLOCATION52 Foyarr Road, Killylea, Caledon.PROPOSAL Erection of Overhead Single Phase Line on wood poles. (07/13202).REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMs P Mckenna Northern Ireland Electricity, Connect, Carn IndustrialEstate, Portadown, Co. Armagh, BT63 5QJITEM NO 129APPLIC NO O/2007/1012/F Full Date Valid 19/12/2007APPLICANT Governers & Guardians Armagh Public LibraryAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSALC/O Agent49 Ogle Street, ArmaghDemolision of single storey rear return and construction of new two storey rearreturn with internal alterations.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMs F Cleland , Tower House, Sheils Houses, Tower Hill, Armagh, BT619DW15 February 2008 Page 60 of 71

ITEM NO 130APPLIC NO O/2007/1014/RM Reserved Date Valid 17/12/2007APPLICANTAPPLIC ADDRESSP CampbellC/O JPM KerrLOCATION80m West of 18 Drumcullen Road, Blackwatertown, Armagh.PROPOSAL Erection of Two-storey Dwelling and detached double Garage.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr J Kerr JPM Kerr Chartered Surveyors, First Floor, 21A Railway Street,Armagh, BT61 7HPITEM NO 131APPLIC NO O/2007/1016/RM Reserved Date Valid 18/12/2007APPLICANTAPPLIC ADDRESSJ Gray20 Drumhirk Road, ArmaghLOCATION300m West of 34 Breaghey Road, Tynan, Armagh.PROPOSAL Erection of Dwelling and Garage.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSBell Design Services, 123 Crosskeys Road, Armagh, BT60 3LDITEM NO 132APPLIC NO O/2007/1028/F Full Date Valid 27/12/2007APPLICANT Mr & Mrs M AgnewAPPLIC ADDRESSC/O AgentLOCATION20 Mullaghbrack Road, HamiltonsbawnPROPOSAL Erection of extensions and alterations to existing dwellingREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr C Lindsay ct Lindsay, The Studio, 66 Marlacoo Road, Richhill, CoArmagh, BT60 1JW15 February 2008 Page 61 of 71

ITEM NO 133APPLIC NO O/2007/1030/F Full Date Valid 27/12/2007APPLICANTAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONCouncil Offices, The Palace Demesne, Armagh, BT60 4ELThomas Street, Scotch street, McCrums Court, Market Street and UpperEnglish Street, ArmaghPROPOSAL Fitting of PA Speakers and associated cabling to 16 premises in streets notedREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr P Beattie , Council Offices, The Palace Demesne, Armagh, BT60 4ECITEM NO 134APPLIC NO O/2007/1031/F Full Date Valid 27/12/2007APPLICANT Marks & Spencer PlcAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONProperty (TP4.1), The Point, 37 North Wharf Road, London, W2 1AFMarks & Spencer Simply Food, Unit 2, Spires Retail Park, Moy Road, Armagh.PROPOSAL Elevational alterations, canopy, lift and bollardsREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposed development would, if permitted, prejudice the safety and convenience of roadusers since provision cannot be made clear of the highway for the parking, turning, loadingand unloading of vehicles which would be attracted to the premises.AGENT DETAILSNathaniel Lichfield & Partners Ltd, 14 Regents Wharf, All Saints Street,London, N1 9RL15 February 2008 Page 62 of 71

ITEM NO 135APPLIC NO O/2007/1034/A Advertisement Date Valid 27/12/2007APPLICANT Marks & Spencer PlcAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONProperty (TP4.1), The Point, 37 North Wharf Road, London, W2 1AFMarks & Spencer Simply Food, Unit 2, Spires Retail Park, Moy Road, Armagh.PROPOSAL Erection of fascia sign, wall mounted sign and totem signs.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSNathaniel Lichfield & Partners Ltd, 14 Regents Wharf, All Saints Street,London, N1 9RLITEM NO 136APPLIC NO O/2008/0001/F Full Date Valid 28/12/2007APPLICANT Psni Estate Service Building UnitAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSAL8th Floor, River House, 48 High Street, Belfast, BT1 2BECarrigatuke Hill, Slaterock Rock, Armagh, Co Armagh. The closest postcode isBT60 2NT and the Carrigatuke Road is 350 metres.Removal of the existing radio mast and replacement with a new 40 metre radiocommunicatins tower for the use of the Northern Ireland Emergency Services.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSAmey Business Services, 11th Floor River House, 48 High Street,Belfast, BT1 2RY15 February 2008 Page 63 of 71

ITEM NO 137APPLIC NO O/2008/0002/F Full Date Valid 28/12/2007APPLICANT Mrs E LivingstoneAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSAL15 College Hall Lane, Tynan, Armagh15 College Hall Lane, Tynan, Armagh.Retention of single storey extension to dwelling (to provide facilities fordisabled person) amended proposal.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr Jr Rollston John Rollston, 88 Fellows Hall Road, Killylea, Armagh,BT60 4LZITEM NO 138APPLIC NO O/2008/0004/F Full Date Valid 02/01/2008APPLICANT Mrs B QuinnAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSAL55 Harringay Road, Tottenham, London, N15 3HU20 Metres North West of 32 Milltown Road, Benburb, Armagh. BT71 7NJ.To vary Condition 7 on Approval No. O/2003/0364/O to 20 Metres North West of32 Milltown Road, (7 Metres more North West than Approval).REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policy CTY10 of Draft Planning Policy Statement 14, SustainableDevelopment in the Countryside, and the accompanying Ministerial Statement in that theproposed dwelling is a prominent feature in the landscape, the proposed site lacks longestablished natural boundaries and is unable to provide a suitable degree of enclosure for thebuilding to integrate into the landscape and therefore would not integrate into this area of thecountryside.AGENT DETAILSMr J Mcalinden Architectural Design Services, 16 Derryloiste Road,Craigavon, BT66 6PS15 February 2008 Page 64 of 71

ITEM NO 139APPLIC NO O/2008/0007/F Full Date Valid 03/01/2008APPLICANT Marks & Spencers PlcAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONProperty (TP4.1), The Point, 37 North Wharf Road, London, W2 1AFMarks & Spencers Simply Food, Unit 2, Spires Retail Park, Moy Road, ArmaghPROPOSAL Proposed plant, enclosure and barrierREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposed development would, if permitted, prejudice the safety and convenience of roadusers since provision cannot be made clear of the highway for the parking, turning, loadingand unloading of vehicles which would be attracted to the premises.AGENT DETAILSNathaniel Lichfield & Partners Ltd, 14 Regents Wharf, All Saints Street,London, N1 9RLITEM NO 140APPLIC NO O/2008/0010/F Full Date Valid 04/01/2008APPLICANT Northern Ireland ElectricityAPPLIC ADDRESSCarn Industrial Estate, Portadown, BT63 5QJ.LOCATION140 Metres South East of 15 Kilmachugh Road, Mowhan, Armagh.PROPOSAL Overhead Single Phase line on Wood Poles.(07/00031)REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMs P Mckenna Northern Ireland Electricity, Connect, Carn IndustrialEstate, Portadown, Co. Armagh, BT63 5QJ15 February 2008 Page 65 of 71

ITEM NO 141APPLIC NO O/2008/0012/F Full Date Valid 07/01/2008APPLICANT Northern Ireland Housing ExecutiveAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSALThe Housing Centre, 2 Adelaide Street, Belfast, BT2 8BPNo's 2 & 19 Daires Willows, Armagh, BT61 8AL.Refurbishment of existing aluminium bungalows to include re-claddingexisting dwelling walls with render system and new roof covering etc.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr Wh Hall W&M Given Architects, Beresford House, 2 Beresford Road,Colraine, BT52 1GEITEM NO 142APPLIC NO O/2008/0013/F Full Date Valid 07/01/2008APPLICANT Northern Ireland Housing ExecutiveAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSALThe Housing Centre, 2 Adelaide Street, Belfast, BT2 8BPNo's 1,3,5,6,7, & 10 Mourneview Park, Tandragee. BT62 2BA.Refurbishment of existing Aluminium Bungalows to include re-claddingexisting Dwelling Walls with render system and new Roof covering etc.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr Wh Hall W&M Given Architects, Beresford House, 2 Beresford Road,Colraine, BT52 1GEITEM NO 143APPLIC NO O/2008/0024/F Full Date Valid 08/01/2008APPLICANT Mr K GalloglyAPPLIC ADDRESS1 Folly Lane, ArmaghLOCATION1 Folly Lane, Armagh.PROPOSAL Alterations and Extensions to Dwelling and erection of Garage.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSBell Design Services, 123 Crosskeys Road, Armagh, BT60 3LD15 February 2008 Page 66 of 71

ITEM NO 144APPLIC NO O/2008/0030/F Full Date Valid 09/01/2008APPLICANT Northern Ireland Housing ExecutiveAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSALThe Housing Centre, 2 Adelaide Street, Belfast, BT2 8BPNo's 9, 10, 12,13, 14, 16, 17, 18, 19 and 20 Lonsdale Gardens, Armagh.Refurbishment of existing Aluminium Bungalows to include re-claddingexisting Dwelling walls with render system and new Roof covering etc.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr Wh Hall W&M Given Architects, Beresford House, 2 Beresford Road,Colraine, BT52 1GEITEM NO 145APPLIC NO O/2008/0031/F Full Date Valid 09/01/2008APPLICANT Northern Ireland Housing ExecutiveAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSALThe Housing Centre, 2 Adelaide Street, Belfast, BT2 8BPNo's1,3,4,5,7,8,10,11,12,13,14,15,16,17,18,19,21,22,23,25,27,28,29,30,33,34,35,38,39, & 40 Lisnally Gardens, Armagh.Refurbishment of existing aluminium bungalows to include re-claddingexisting dwelling walls with new render system and new roof covering etc.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr Wh Hall W&M Given Architects, Beresford House, 2 Beresford Road,Colraine, BT52 1GE15 February 2008 Page 67 of 71

ITEM NO 146APPLIC NO O/2008/0041/F Full Date Valid 11/01/2008APPLICANT A KearneyAPPLIC ADDRESS3 Navan Manor, Armagh, BT61 7APLOCATION3 Navan Manor, Armagh.PROPOSAL Erection of 2 storey extension to dwelling.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr M Lavery , 58 Valley Lane, Corcreeny, Lurgan, Co.Armagh, BT66 7SFITEM NO 147APPLIC NO O/2008/0042/F Full Date Valid 11/01/2008APPLICANT P RiceAPPLIC ADDRESS4 Navan Manor, Armagh, BT61 7APLOCATION4 Navan Manor, Armagh.PROPOSAL Erection of Ground Floor Extension to dwelling.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSM Lavery , 58 Valley Lane, Corcreeny, Lurgan, BT66 7SFITEM NO 148APPLIC NO O/2008/0049/F Full Date Valid 14/01/2008APPLICANT Gosford Housing AssociationAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSAL1 Barrack Hill, Armagh, BT60 1BL15 and 18 Lisanally Lane, Armagh. BT61 7HE.MEI Works to 2No. Dwellings, including demolition and replacement of 2No.rear Extensions including boundary walls.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr D Press WH Stephens, Stephens House, 63 Malone Road, Belfast,BT9 6SA15 February 2008 Page 68 of 71

ITEM NO 149APPLIC NO O/2008/0050/RM Reserved Date Valid 14/01/2008APPLICANTAPPLIC ADDRESSN Adair55 Febney Road, Banbridge, BT32 3PNLOCATION180 metres North East East of No Tandragee Road, Markethill.PROPOSAL Erection of dwelling and garage.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMessrs T.J Dreaning T.J Dreaning, 135 Banbridge Road,, Donaghcloney,,Craigavon, BT66 7PJITEM NO 150APPLIC NO O/2008/0056/F Full Date Valid 16/01/2008APPLICANT Northern Ireland ElectricityAPPLIC ADDRESSCarn Industrial Estate, Portadown, BT63 5QJLOCATIONKillycopple Quarry, Outlack, Colone, Armagh.PROPOSAL Erection of overhead 3 phase line on wooden poles (07/01952).REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMs P Mckenna Northern Ireland Electricity, Connect, Carn IndustrialEstate, Portadown, Co. Armagh, BT63 5QJITEM NO 151APPLIC NO O/2008/0059/F Full Date Valid 17/01/2008APPLICANT Mr & Mrs R Mc ClellandAPPLIC ADDRESS21 Turnberry Green, TandrageeLOCATION21 Turnberry Green, Tandragee.PROPOSAL Retention of existing sunlounge & utility room extension.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSKarl McElroy, McElroy House, 119 Bridge Street, Portadown15 February 2008 Page 69 of 71

ITEM NO 152APPLIC NO O/2008/0060/F Full Date Valid 16/01/2008APPLICANT McgearyAPPLIC ADDRESS26 Tallbridge Road, Portadown, BT62 1SFLOCATION26 Tallbridge Road, PortadownPROPOSAL Proposed extensionREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSITEM NO 153APPLIC NO O/2008/0064/F Full Date Valid 18/01/2008APPLICANT Mr & Mrs B Mc G Mc GurganAPPLIC ADDRESSC/O 100 Magheraville Road, Millford, Armagh, BT60 3PLLOCATION22 Magheraville Road, Millford, ArmaghPROPOSAL Extension to dwellingREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr J Mcaleavey , 100 Magheraville Road, Milford, Armagh, BT60 3PLKITEM NO 154APPLIC NO O/2008/0067/F Full Date Valid 18/01/2008APPLICANT Northern Ireland Housing Executive.APPLIC ADDRESSMarlborough House, Central Way, Craigavon, BT64 1AJLOCATIONFront of No's 5a - 5d Crossmore Green, Keady.PROPOSAL Additional parking area.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr C Sloan NIHE, Marlborough House, Central Way, Craigavon, BT64 1AJ15 February 2008 Page 70 of 71

ITEM NO 155APPLIC NO O/2008/0071/F Full Date Valid 22/01/2008APPLICANT Armagh City & District CouncilAPPLIC ADDRESSThe Palace Demesne, Armagh, BT60 4ELLOCATION90 metres North East of 4 Castleview Road, Markethill, ArmaghPROPOSAL Erection of lifesize metal sculptures of a cow & calf on a raised plinth.REPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr P Beattie , Council Offices, The Palace Demesne, Armagh, BT60 4ECITEM NO 156APPLIC NO O/2008/0072/F Full Date Valid 22/01/2008APPLICANT Armagh City And District CouncilAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATIONPROPOSALThe Palace Demesne, Armagh, BT60 4EL50 m north east of 1 Forest View, Markethill, ArmaghErection of lifesize metal sculptures of two cows on a raised comcrete plinthbehind the wall.REPRESENTATION 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr P Beattie , Council Offices, The Palace Demesne, Armagh, BT60 4ECITEM NO 157APPLIC NO O/2008/0078/F Full Date Valid 24/01/2008APPLICANT Ms S GillespieAPPLIC ADDRESS1 Navan Cottages, Armagh, BT60 4PWLOCATION1 Navan Cottages, ArmaghPROPOSAL Change in existing roof covering from asbestos to tilesREPRESENTATION 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr K Mc Elroy KM Construction Services, 119 Bridge Street, Portadown,Co.Armagh, BT63 5AA15 February 2008 Page 71 of 71

APPLICATIONS DEFERRED FROM PREVIOUS MEETINGITEM NO D 1APPLIC NO O/2004/1488/O Outline Date Valid 14/12/2004APPLICANT Mr J. Whitten,APPLIC ADDRESS 15 Poyntzpass Road,, Scarva.LOCATION100m NW of No. 11 Terryhoogan Road, ScarvaPROPOSAL Site for dwelling and garageREPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSStephen Rogan, 51 Church Street, Banbridge, Co.Down, BT32 4AAITEM NO D 2APPLIC NO O/2005/1030/O Outline Date Valid 20/07/2005APPLICANT Mr HodgenAPPLIC ADDRESS21 Druminure Road, Clare, TandrageeLOCATION60m South of 23 Druminure Road, TandrageePROPOSAL Site dwelling and garageREPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr B. Mckevitt B & D Property Services Ltd.,, 261 Dublin Road,, Killeen,,Newry,, Co. Down., BT35 8RYITEM NO D 3APPLIC NO O/2005/1551/F Full Date Valid 14/12/2005APPLICANT Mr KilpatrickAPPLIC ADDRESS83 Cladymiltown Road, MarkethillLOCATION270m N. N. E of 5 Cladymore Road, MarkethillPROPOSAL Erection of dwelling and garageREPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies SP6/HOU8 and DES5 of the Department's 'A PlanningStrategy for Rural Northern Ireland' in that a building on this site would not integrate into thecountryside, as the site is unable to provide a suitable degree of enclosure due to the lack ofsufficient boundaries or any other means of achieving satisfactory integration, and as aconsequence would, if permitted, have an adverse impact on the landscape as it is undulyconspicuous.AGENT DETAILSMr I Lenaghan Ian Lenaghan Design, 30 Moss Park, Richhill, Co Armagh,BT61 9PT15 February 2008 Page 1 of 7

ITEM NO D 4APPLIC NO O/2006/0090/O Outline Date Valid 25/01/2006APPLICANT Mr R RedpathAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATION15 Rathview, Banbridge, Co.Down, BT32 4PY340 metres south-south-west of junction of Druminure Road & TullymacanRoad, TandrageePROPOSAL Site for dwelling & domestic garageREPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr J Richardson , 9 Shanecracken, Markethill, Co Armagh, BT60 1TSITEM NO D 5APPLIC NO O/2006/0128/O Outline Date Valid 02/02/2006APPLICANT Mr McardleAPPLIC ADDRESS 18 Rathcumber Road, Derrynoose, BT60 3DZLOCATION180m South East of 38 Glassdrummond Road, Glassdrummond, ArmaghPROPOSAL Site for dwelling and detached garageREPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies SP6, SP19, HOU8 and DES5 of the Department's 'APlanning Strategy for Rural Northern Ireland' in that a building on this site would not integrateinto the countryside, as the site is unable to provide a suitable degree of enclosure due to thelack of sufficient boundaries or any other means of achieving satisfactory integration, and asa consequence would, if permitted, have an adverse impact on the landscape by reason of itsundue prominence.AGENT DETAILSMr J Kerr JPM KERR, 11 Middlebrook, Middletown, Co. Armagh, BT60 4JPITEM NO D 6APPLIC NO O/2006/0213/F Full Date Valid 20/02/2006APPLICANT Mr D HughesAPPLIC ADDRESS75 Cortamlet Road, NewtownhamiltonLOCATION250m N/NE of the junction with Ballynaleck Lane PoyntzpassPROPOSAL Erection of dwelling and garageREPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr W. J. Cornett Cornett Design Associates, 4 Hartford Place, The Mall,Armagh, BT61 9BJ15 February 2008 Page 2 of 7

ITEM NO D 7APPLIC NO O/2006/0253/F Full Date Valid 22/02/2006APPLICANT Mr S LappinAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATION191 Granemeore Road, Tassagh, Armagh, BT60 2RDKeady Road, Newtownhamilton (180 metres North West of the ArmaghbragueTownland Boubndary with Tullyvallen)PROPOSAL Erection of dwelling and garageREPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies, SP6, SP19, HOU8 and DES5 of the Department's 'APlanning Strategy for Rural Northern Ireland' in that a building on this site would not integrateinto the countryside, as the site is unable to provide a suitable degree of enclosure due to thelack of sufficient boundaries or any other means of achieving satisfactory integration, and asa consequence would, if permitted, have an adverse impact on the landscape as it is undulyconspicuous.2 The proposal is contrary to Policies SP6, SP19, & DES5 of the Department's Planning Strategyfor Rural Northern Ireland in that a building on this site would, if permitted, have an adverseimpact on the landscape as this suburban form of development does not respect the traditionalpattern of settlement in the countryside.AGENT DETAILSMr J.A Murphy , 43 New Road, Silverbridge, Newry, BT35 9NBITEM NO D 8APPLIC NO O/2006/0360/O Outline Date Valid 13/03/2006APPLICANT Mr MurphyAPPLIC ADDRESS 73 St. Mathews Estate,, Keady,, BT60 3SGLOCATION120m south east of no. 5 Crossmenagh Rd, DerrynoosePROPOSAL Site for dwelling and detached garageREPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies SP6, DES6 & HOU8 of the Department's Planning Strategyfor Rural Northern Ireland in that the development when considered in the context of existingdevelopment, would, if permitted, result in a detrimental change to the rural character of thisarea of countryside by reason of build-up.AGENT DETAILSMr J Kerr JPM KERR, 11 Middlebrook, Middletown, Co. Armagh, BT60 4JP15 February 2008 Page 3 of 7

ITEM NO D 9APPLIC NO O/2006/0401/O Outline Date Valid 11/03/2006APPLICANT Ms A McbrideAPPLIC ADDRESS245 Monaghan Road, ArmaghLOCATION200 metres south of 243 Monaghan Road, ArmaghPROPOSAL Site for dwelling and detached garageREPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies SP6, SP19, HOU8 and DES5 of the Department's 'APlanning Strategy for Rural Northern Ireland' in that a building on this site would not integrateinto the countryside, as the site is unable to provide a suitable degree of enclosure due to thelack of sufficient boundaries or any other means of achieving satisfactory integration, and asa consequence would, if permitted, have an adverse impact on the landscape by reason of itsundue prominence and as it is unduly conspicuous.2 The proposal is contrary to Policies SP6, DES6 & HOU8 of the Department's Planning Strategyfor Rural Northern Ireland in that the development when considered in the context of existingdevelopment, would, if permitted, result in a detrimental change to the rural character of thisarea of countryside by reason of build-up.AGENT DETAILSMr N Cornett , Cornett Design Associates, 4 Hartford Place, The Mall,Armagh, BT61 9BJITEM NO D 10APPLIC NO O/2006/0406/O Outline Date Valid 13/03/2006APPLICANT Miss McginnttyAPPLIC ADDRESS 19 Mullyward Rd,, Derrynoose,, Keady, BT60 3HHLOCATION120m North West of No. 19 Mullyard Road, DerrynoosePROPOSAL Site for storey and a half dwelling & detached garage. (re-advertisement)REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies SP6, SP19, HOU8 and DES5 of the Department's 'APlanning Strategy for Rural Northern Ireland' in that a building on this site would not integrateinto the countryside, as the site is unable to provide a suitable degree of enclosure due to thelack of sufficient boundaries or any other means of achieving satisfactory integration, and asa consequence would, if permitted, have an adverse impact on the landscape as it is undulyconspicuous.AGENT DETAILSMr J Kerr JPM KERR, 11 Middlebrook, Middletown, Co. Armagh, BT60 4JP15 February 2008 Page 4 of 7

ITEM NO D 11APPLIC NO O/2006/0437/O Outline Date Valid 16/03/2006APPLICANT Mrs B McneiceAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATION30 Tall Bridge Road, Ardress East, PortadownOpposite 26 Tall Bridge Road and 40 metres east of No.24 Tall Bridge Road,Ardress EastPROPOSAL Site for dwelling and garageREPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr H Daly Daly,O'Neill and Associates, 23 William Street, Portadown, Co.Armagh, BT62 3NXITEM NO D 12APPLIC NO O/2006/0445/F Full Date Valid 15/03/2006APPLICANT Mr HydeAPPLIC ADDRESS 66 Armagh Road, Newtownhamilton, Newry, BT35 OE2LOCATION100m south, southwest of 66 Armagh Road, Newtownhamilton, Co. DownPROPOSAL Erection of dwelling and garageREPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr J Collins Collins & Collins, 18 Margaret Street, Newry, Co Down, BT341DFITEM NO D 13APPLIC NO O/2006/0447/O Outline Date Valid 10/03/2006APPLICANT LucianiAPPLIC ADDRESS5 Mullabrack Terrace, MarkethillLOCATION120m West of 16 Drumsavage Road, Collone, ArmaghPROPOSAL Site for dwelling and garageREPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr I Lenaghan Ian Lenaghan Design, 30 Moss Park, Richhill, Co Armagh,BT61 9PT15 February 2008 Page 5 of 7

ITEM NO D 14APPLIC NO O/2006/0479/O Outline Date Valid 13/03/2006APPLICANT Mr G MckeownAPPLIC ADDRESSC/o AgentLOCATIONAdjacent to 32 Annaghmore Road, PortadownPROPOSAL Site for chalet dwelling (2500 sq. ft.)REPRESENTATIONS 1 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONREFUSAL1 The proposal is contrary to Policies SP6, SP19, HOU8 and DES5 of the Department's 'APlanning Strategy for Rural Northern Ireland' in that a building on this site would not integrateinto the countryside, as the site is unable to provide a suitable degree of enclosure due to thelack of sufficient boundaries or any other means of achieving satisfactory integration, and asa consequence would, if permitted, have an adverse impact on the landscape by reason of itsundue prominence.2 The proposal is contrary to Policies SP6, DES6 and HOU8 of the Department's PlanningStrategy for Rural Northern Ireland in that the development when considered in the context ofexisting development, would, if permitted, result in a detrimental change to the rural characterof this area of countryside by reason of build-up of development.3 The proposal is contrary to Policies SP6, SP19, DES5 and HOU8 of the Department's PlanningStrategy for Rural Northern Ireland in that a building on this site would, if permitted, have anadverse impact on the landscape as this form of back land development does not respect thetraditional pattern of settlement in this part of the countryside.4 The proposal is contrary to Policies DES7, SP6 and HOU8 of the Department's PlanningStrategy for Rural Northern Ireland in that the development would, if permitted, adverselyaffect the visual amenity and character of the countryside by the extension of ribbondevelopment along Annaghmore Road and the special circumstances presented do not justifya relaxation of the planning controls exercised in this area.AGENT DETAILSMr M Shaw Shaw Design, 34 Grange Road, Dungannon, BT71 7EQITEM NO D 15APPLIC NO O/2006/1181/F Full Date Valid 20/11/2006APPLICANT Mr D StarrettAPPLIC ADDRESS105 Drummanmore Road, Armagh, BT61 8RNLOCATIONOpposite 25 Mullansilla Road, ArmaghPROPOSAL Provision of underground slurry storage tank.REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr J Woods Homeplan, 9A Tartaraghan Road, Portadown, Co.Armagh, BT621RQ15 February 2008 Page 6 of 7

ITEM NO D 16APPLIC NO O/2007/0717/F Full Date Valid 17/09/2007APPLICANT Mr & Mrs C HamiltonAPPLIC ADDRESSC/o AgentLOCATION108 Markethill Road, Edenknappagh, Co. Armagh BT601LFPROPOSAL Extension to dwelling and associated internal alterations.REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr C Lindsey C T Lindsay, The Studio, 66 Marlacoo Road, Richhill,Co.Armagh, BT62 3JWITEM NO D 17APPLIC NO O/2007/0915/A Advertisement Date Valid 15/11/2007APPLICANT G MolloyAPPLIC ADDRESSLOCATION185 Monaghan Road, Armagh, BT60 4EZ110m North East and 85m South West of junction of Deranalea Road andMonaghan Road, Armagh.PROPOSAL Erection of Hoarding.REPRESENTATIONS 0 Objections 0 Support 0 Petition of Objection 0 Support PetitionsOPINIONAPPROVALAGENT DETAILSMr E Morton , 104 Navanfort Road, Armagh, BT60 4PS15 February 2008 Page 7 of 7

PSSC-08-23-LBAPPEALS LODGED WITH PACCOUNCILArmaghITEM NO 1APPLIC NO O/2004/1012/O PAC NO 2006/A1672APPLICANTMr J O'NeillLOCATIONRenewal for site 32m South West of 73 Knappagh Road, ArmaghPROPOSALSite for domestic dwellingAPPEAL TYPE Plg RefusalITEM NO 2APPLIC NO O/2005/0096/O PAC NO 2006/A1940APPLICANTMr A KellyLOCATION120m North of 22 Lagan Road, KeadyPROPOSALDwelling houseAPPEAL TYPE Plg Refusal15 February 2008 Page 1 of 1

PSSC-08-24-LBAPPEAL DECISIONS NOTIFIEDCOUNCILArmaghITEM NO 1APPLIC NO O/2003/1464/O PAC NO 2006/A1002RESULT OF APPEAL UpheldAPPLICANTLOCATIONPROPOSALMr W J McclellandSouth of and adjacent to No 33 Crewmore Road, PoyntzpassSite for dwelling and garageITEM NO 2APPLIC NO O/2004/1051/O PAC NO 2006/A1263RESULT OF APPEAL DismissedAPPLICANTLOCATIONPROPOSALMr J Best120 metres south east of no 72 Acton Road, PoyntzpassSite for dwelling and garageITEM NO 3APPLIC NO O/2004/1565/O PAC NO 2006/A1434RESULT OF APPEAL DismissedAPPLICANTLOCATIONPROPOSALMr J. Bingham,120m South-West of 10 Tannyoky Road, PoyntzpassSite for dwellingITEM NO 4APPLIC NO O/2005/0392/F PAC NO 2006/A1458RESULT OF APPEAL Invalid AppealAPPLICANTLOCATIONPROPOSALMr D VallelyLands at juntion of Summerisland Road and Derrycraw Road, ArdressAmended external finish to dwelling, rustic red brick as opposed to smoothcement finish15 February 2008 Page 1 of 1