ARC Capital Holdings Ltd
ARC Capital Holdings Ltd
ARC Capital Holdings Ltd
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
JIADELI HOLDBACK<br />
Due Date of Payment: October 2011<br />
Initial Investment Cost: US$17.7 million<br />
Investment Instrument: Holdback Payment<br />
Shareholding: n/a<br />
Date of Exit: n/a<br />
Exit Type: n/a<br />
Current Value: US$17.6 million (1)<br />
1. As at 30 June 2012. Difference in value versus cost due to RMB<br />
fluctuation.<br />
Transaction Description<br />
• As part of the sale of Jiadeli Supermarkets to HNA Group on 11<br />
October 2010 for a total consideration of RMB1.1 billion<br />
(equivalent to US$164.8 million), it was agreed that a holdback<br />
of RMB100 million was to be paid to <strong>ARC</strong>H 12 months after<br />
closing, subject to completion of a post closing audit.<br />
• In March 2011, the audit was completed by RSM China, a<br />
domestic accounting firm appointed by HNA Group, which<br />
indicated a net loss of RMB34m compared to a net profit of<br />
RMB34m as audited by Deloitte & Touche (Jiadeli’s auditors). As<br />
a result, HNA Group has not released the holdback.<br />
• In August 2011, <strong>ARC</strong>H and HNA Group engaged Ernst & Young<br />
as the mediator to review the alleged discrepancies.<br />
BRIDGE LOAN TO “DCSI”<br />
Date of Investment: December 2011<br />
Initial Investment Cost: US$15.9 million<br />
Investment Instrument: Debt<br />
Shareholding: n/a<br />
Date of Exit: n/a<br />
Exit Type: n/a<br />
Current Value: US$15.9 million (1)<br />
1. As at 30 June 2012<br />
Transaction Update<br />
Transaction Description<br />
Quarterly Newsletter Q2 2012<br />
• In late June 2012, E&Y reported that its work was inconclusive<br />
due to certain discrepancies found in the figures presented by<br />
HNA Group.<br />
• On 25 July 2012, <strong>ARC</strong>H met with HNA’s management to<br />
discuss the settlement. Negotiations are ongoing however HNA<br />
and <strong>ARC</strong>H may agree to a compromise to facilitate an early<br />
settlement.<br />
• The Manager will keep shareholders updated on any<br />
developments.<br />
Valuation<br />
• The holdback is valued at cost. <strong>ARC</strong>H’s Valuation Committee<br />
will review the situation and make appropriate adjustments as<br />
necessary, pending progress of ongoing discussions with HNA’s<br />
management.<br />
• As part of the sale of Orient Home Retail to a domestic Chinese<br />
strategic investor (“DCSI”), <strong>ARC</strong>H provided DCSI with a oneyear,<br />
RMB100m bridge loan.<br />
• The loan was to be used by DCSI to meet Orient Home Retail’s<br />
urgent short term working capital needs during the transition of<br />
ownership.<br />
• DCSI will repay this loan once it has successfully renewed Orient<br />
Home Retail’s bank loans and has injected additional capital into<br />
the company.<br />
• The interest rate for the loan is 8% per annum<br />
• No material changes have occurred.<br />
Valuation<br />
• The loan is valued at cost.<br />
www.arch-fund.com ©2012 <strong>ARC</strong>H Page 6 of 10