FROM THE HELMSTEVE MORRELL, EDITORThe Over-Inspection MentalityJust before press date, I read about New York boaters (seepage 34) getting over-inspected, with one boater stoppedfour times in four miles by four different agencies. It wassupposed to be for power plant security, yet marine officersmentioned inspections to ensure everyone hadenough life jackets. Yeah, right.This all made me think of the over-inspections we getin Florida. But here, I am talking about sailboats. Sure, wehave problems on the water, but the majority of them havenothing to do with cruising sailboats. The real problemsare: powerboats going too fast; drinking and powerboatsgoing too fast; powerboaters blaring loud music, disturbingthe peace and quiet of others; boaters going out inrough waters, or too far, or at night, or just going out withoutenough boating knowledge—again, almost all powerboaters.These actions impinge on the rights of others orend up in search and rescue by others.How many times, though, do sailors/cruisers causeproblems? What are the statistics? Almost all the problemsand reports are from unwarranted inspections and interactionswith the police. The police complain about sailboatsnot having certain papers, or fire extinguishers, or enoughlife jackets, or the Y-valve not shut properly—problemsthey find after they are inspected. How many times havethere been accidents without enough life jackets onboard asailboat—or even just on a sailboat’s dinghy? How manytimes has an out-of-date fire extinguisher caused a problemon a sailboat? How many times have a boat’s papersbeen wrong? Let’s have the statistics on these, not just thenumber. Is it one in 10,000 or what? Let’s have some perspective.Sailors aren’t cruising around drunk at highspeeds killing people. But they are easy targets; they goslow and the police can stop them easily. When you have100 powerboats going 20-25 mph and one sailboat going 5knots, who are the police going to want to stop? The easytarget. Yet it’s the target that does the least harm, statistically,by far.We don’t need the police going around and makingPENSACOLAS AFFORDABLE BOATYARDTake Advantage of our “Short Haul Special” – $199 up to 43'Haulout – Hang to Inspect – SplashDealer for Northern Lights,Beta Marine, PCM & Nor-ProCONVENIENTLY LOCATED ON BAYOU CHICO – 40 AUDUSSON AVE.(850) 453-3471 www.pelicansperchmarina.comsure everything is absolutely correct and we have everythingperfect. These are victimless crimes. You can’t do thaton land. If we allowed home inspections to be carried outlike this for such important safety features, such asbad/illegal wiring, bad/illegal gas connections, weak/illegalrailings, etc., etc., etc.—most of the people in the countrywould be getting citations and fines, including many ofthese police officers doing these unwarranted inspections.They are doing them because they can—not because theyare justified or whether they are right or wrong. Andbecause it is department policy.Some marine police will say boaters need to beinspected because they could be dumping human waste inthe water. They say they have to keep the waters clean,even though I know no beach ever closed in Florida forany other reason than human waste that originated onland, meaning the millions of gallons “accidentally”dumped annually in Florida’s waters from sewage systems,or the seepage they get in the Keys from oldcesspools, old leach fields and septic tanks. That meansthat the typical policeman’s own waste is more likely to bethe cause of closing a beach than that of a boater’s. So, howabout a little perspective on these raids? Educate thesepolice on what really fouls our waters, instead of usingthat as an excuse for what I bet many of these officers findenjoyment out of—being able to inspect any boat anytimethey want for any reason they want wherever they want.It’s bad enough having the marine police in someareas stop and inspect sailors/cruisers so often that otherscringe when they just see a police boat, but the supremeinsult to our rights are the unwarranted nighttime boatraids. I can’t think of any one action that the marine policedo that generates more hatred and distrust of them than anighttime raid with bullhorns blaring and floodlights glaring.All to inspect a toilet. This goes especially for thosewho have experienced one, or who have had a friend experienceone. But it also goes for those of us who can visualizehow truly vicious such a raid can be, particularly in asociety where such an unwarranted raid on a car or on ahome on land would be abhorred and totally illegal.Perhaps it is because I have such an imagination that Iwon’t give up on publicizing these “raids” until they areended as a policy by all the marine police.There is no room in America for any police officer whobelieves that it is acceptable to raid a boat at night with noprobable cause just to see if the boater is possibly doingsomething wrong. Any officer who believes that is acceptableshould be barred from doing any police work in thecountry anywhere ever again. Such a person doesn’t havea clue about our rights and shouldn’t be carrying a gun forthe law.So—what can you do? Contact me with all instances ofunwarranted boat inspections. I will publicize and criticizetheir existence until it ends. editor@southwindsmagazine.com.8 September 2011 SOUTHWINDS www.southwindsmagazine.com
LETTERS“Freedom of the press is limited to those who own one.”A.J. LieblingIn its continuing endeavor to share its press, SOUTHWINDSinvites readers to write in with experiences & opinions.E-mail your letters to editor@southwindsmagazine.comLOWER PRICES ON MOORING FIELDSOR BOATERS WILL JUST GO FARTHER OUTThe FWC got the go-ahead from the Legislature to findworkable solutions/ordinances to Florida’s anchoringchallenges. The FWC produced the mooring field pilotprogram. Five Florida areas are involved — St. Augustine,Stuart/Martin County, Monroe County (Key Largo to KeyWest), Sarasota, and St. Petersburg. These areas get to trynew ordinances that affect ALL boaters, liveaboards andnon-liveaboards alike. Those new laws and the pilot programexpire July 2014.Yes, there is federal maritime law that says don’t messwith boats in navigation and that anchoring is intrinsic tonavigation. Yes, there is a public trust doctrine that says thenavigable waters of our nation are held in the public trustfor the free use of citizens.The pilot program has as its principal goal “to promotethe establishment and use of public mooring fields.” Thebalance of the goals—improve the environment, improvenavigation, etc.—can be reached when boaters use publicmooring fields. There is no question that public mooringfields are assets to both the boating community and theshoreside community. They provide efficiency, safety, controlsand services. But how a pilot program and fresh lawsin Key Largo (Monroe County) promote use of public mooringfields in Boot Key (also in Monroe County) is a mystery.The focus seems to be to create more laws to furtherrestrict anchoring in any given area. More laws are seen asthe means to promote public mooring fields. What’s reallyhappening is more laws are generating anchor sprawl. Lessaffluent boaters anchor beyond the reaches of the new laws.In St. Augustine, we have some 30 boats displaced by thepermitted mooring fields, beyond municipal reaches andbeyond the convenient use of the pump-out boat, wherethey properly, prudently, reasonably and lawfully enjoytheir United States’ Rights of Navigation.A public mooring field ideally could include, accept,invite, willing boaters into the safety, efficiency, convenience,and order IF rates accommodated the less financially able.Municipalities see public mooring fields as a revenue stream,not as a public service or a means to improve our waterways.Jay Bliss, USCG-licensed CaptainSt. Augustine Port Commissioner Seat 5Jay,Yes, I agree—it appears the municipalities are in the profit businessinstead of the public service business. They will get the highestprice they can get to make as much money as possible, andthese boats will move farther and farther away. Some will movefarther because they just won’t pay, and others will move fartherbecause they can’t afford it. If it were a public service, priceswould be at cost and more would use the mooring fields, becauseof the good services, like shore facilities, dinghy docks, location.See LETTERS continued on page 10The Bradenton Yacht Club presentsThe 29th AnnualKickoff RegattaSeptember 23-25, 2011SPINNAKER - NON-SPINNAKERMULTIHULL - CRUISINGRACER/CRUISERONE-DESIGN(One-design on separate course with additional races)This is the first event for the Suncoast Boatof the Year Series and the second event inthe Sarasota Bay Boat of the Year SeriesENTRY FEE INCLUDES:2 T-Shirts, Cap, 2 Saturday Dinner Tickets, Free Beerall days (while it lasts), Party with Live MusicSaturday Night, Continental Breakfast Sat. & Sun.,Complimentary Dockage Friday-Sunday.Single point hoist (4000-lbs. maximum),mast crane, and ramp available for boat launchingFor more information, go towww.bradentonyachtclub.comFIND US ON FACEBOOK:“Bradenton Yacht Club Kickoff Regatta”or call Jeff Walden (941) 776-9653Dock Reservations : (941) 722-5936, ext. 212or Dockmaster Cell: (941) 374-2310News & Views for Southern Sailors SOUTHWINDS September 2011 9