Frei dit Frey et al.12345678910111213141516171819202122232425262728293031323334may contribute to control cytosolic Ca 2+ levels during flg22 responses. Intriguingly, ACA12localizes to the plasma <strong>membrane</strong> and can interact with the RKs BRI1 and CLV1 (Figure1A). ACA12, however, failed to associate with FLS2, which may hamper possiblecompensatory effects in flg22 responses.ACA8 and ACA10 contribute to plant immunityTo examine a possible role <strong>of</strong> ACA8 and ACA10 in plant anti-bacterial immunity, allgenotypes were spray-inoculated with virulent Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato DC3000(PtoDC3000), an infection that is defeated utilizing the FLS2 pathway (Zipfel et al., 2004).Bacterial growth and disease symptom development were monitored three and five days postinoculation, respectively. PtoDC3000 multiplied to high titers in aca8 and aca10 single aswell as in aca8 aca10 double mutants, which was comparable to those detected in immunecompromisedfls2 mutants (Figure 5A). This enhanced susceptibility was reduced to wild typelevels in the transgenic ACA8-GFP complementation line. Moreover, disease symptomdevelopment <strong>of</strong> aca8 and aca10 single and double mutants was correlated with the enhancedsusceptibility phenotype (Figure 5B). Despite 35S-driven ectopic expression <strong>of</strong> ACA8-GFP,no increased resistance against PtoDC3000 could be detected in the transgenic line. Aca8 andaca10 single mutants were as affected as the aca8 aca10 double mutant upon PtoDC3000infection. Thus, ACA8 and ACA10 both, individually and equally contribute to plantimmunity in bacterial infections.DiscussionIt is well known that MAMPs induce a rapid and transient increase <strong>of</strong> [Ca 2+ ] in thecytosol through the function <strong>of</strong> plasma <strong>membrane</strong> resident Ca 2+ channels (Blume et al., 2000;Ranf et al., 2011), but despite its presumed importance in plant immunity, our currentunderstanding <strong>of</strong> how the MAMP-induced Ca 2+ burst is regulated is rather limited (Ranf et al.,2008; Kudla et al., 2010). Though DND1 is <strong>important</strong> for cytosolic Ca 2+ elevation in responseto bacterial lipopolysaccharides (LPS) and endogenous danger peptides (Ma et al., 2009; Qi etal., 2010), it is not required for flg22 and elf18 activation <strong>of</strong> Ca 2+ (Jeworutzki et al., 2010).Similarly, the recently suggested GLR-type Ca 2+ channels have been implicated incryptogein- and flg22-triggered responses by pharmacological approaches, however, geneticevidence for their involvement in MAMP signalling is still lacking (Kwaaitaal et al., 2011;Michard et al., 2011; Vatsa et al., 2011). Ca 2+ homeostasis is also controlled through the10
Frei dit Frey et al.12345678910111213141516171819202122232425262728293031323334function <strong>of</strong> Ca 2+ <strong>ATPases</strong>, and our data show that FLS2 forms a complex with ACA8. It ispossible that FLS2 transphosphorylates the Ca 2+ ATPase to regulate its activity, as ACA10 isdifferentially phosphorylated upon flg22 treatment (Benschop et al., 2007).Based on our mutant loss-<strong>of</strong>-function data, ACA8 and ACA10 co-function topositively regulate the MAMP-induced Ca 2+ burst. Because <strong>of</strong> their function as Ca 2+ pumps,Ca 2+ <strong>ATPases</strong> mediate efflux <strong>of</strong> Ca 2+ ions out <strong>of</strong> the cytosol. Therefore, loss <strong>of</strong> Ca 2+ ATPasefunction should result in an enhanced and prolonged Ca 2+ burst (Romani et al., 2004). In linewith this assumption, Ca 2+ fluxes triggered by the MAMP cryptogein in N. benthamiana wereincreased in amplitude and duration when ER-localized NbCA1 was silenced (Zhu et al.,2010). Our data on ACA8 and ACA10 unexpectedly revealed a reduction in the MAMPinducedCa 2+ burst. We cannot exclude the possibility that other members <strong>of</strong> the ACA familysuch as ACA12 and ACA13 may substitute at least partially for ACA8 and ACA10 functionin the mutant backgrounds as evidenced by the increased ACA12 and ACA13 transcript levelsupon flg22 elicitation. This would indicate that the observed phenotypes <strong>of</strong> aca8 aca10mutants <strong>are</strong> rather an indirect effect. However, ACA12 did not associate with FLS2 in ourBiFC analysis, ACA12 and ACA13 transcript levels were not generally increased in aca8aca10 mutants, and our transcriptome data did not point at obvious expression changes <strong>of</strong> anyother member <strong>of</strong> the ACA family. Alternatively, it is possible that the enhanced transcriptlevels <strong>of</strong> CaM-like genes in aca8 aca10 plants reflect a mechanism to compensate forelevated steady-state levels <strong>of</strong> cytosolic Ca 2+ . This may in turn lead to the decreased influx <strong>of</strong>Ca 2+ into the cytosol, because CaM-like proteins were shown to regulate cyclic nucleotidegatedchannels (CNGCs), a class <strong>of</strong> cation channels with a documented role in Ca 2+ influx(Ali et al., 2007; Boursiac and Harper, 2007). CaM-like proteins can also activate Ca 2+<strong>ATPases</strong> and <strong>are</strong> thus key regulators <strong>of</strong> Ca 2+ homeostasis (Boursiac and Harper, 2007).However, we cannot exclude a yet unknown modality <strong>of</strong> Ca 2+ ATPase function implying adirect rather than indirect action. Based on current knowledge it is possible to speculate thatFLS2 may transiently down-regulate ACA8 and ACA10 activities upon flg22 treatmentsthereby allowing a cytosolic Ca 2+ burst, possibly masked by investigating stable loss-<strong>of</strong>functionmutants.Flg22-induced ROS production was decreased in aca8 aca10 mutants, which is inagreement with a reduction <strong>of</strong> the flg22-triggered Ca 2+ burst. Likewise, chemical inhibition <strong>of</strong>Ca 2+ ATPase function resulted in reduced ROS production in response to the fungal MAMPoligogalacturonide, placing ACA proteins upstream <strong>of</strong> RbohD (Romani et al., 2004). As Rbohproteins contain two EF hand motifs in their N-terminal domains (Ogasawara et al., 2008), an11