The supplier can propose a CT with threemagnetic cores and secondary tappings to meetthe 200 A or 1000 A need at the primary.However, such a CT is hard to manufacturebecause to obtain 15 VA-class 0.5 and10 VA-5P20 on 200/1 ratios, you need5 x 15 VA-class 0.5 and 5 x 10 VA-5P20 on1000/1 ratios! Moreover, the supplier mustcomply with class X for both ratios!In point of fact, class X concerns only the 1000/1ratio (for busbar differential protection). The200/1 ratios concern metering and the traditionalprotections (see fig. 7 ). The CT to bemanufactured is then easier, less bulky, cheaperand definitely feasible. This example shows thatthe lack of information shared between thoseinvolved is a source of errors and of<strong>no</strong>n-optimisation. A consultation that does <strong>no</strong>tbegin properly may result in a CT that can<strong>no</strong>t bemanufactured.c Taking into account the relay impedance R h forcalculation of real load (see fig. 8 ) in the CTcalculation for overcurrent or in the calculationfor CTs in class X.A word of warning: R h is only considered whencalculating CTs for zero sequence current l h (see<strong>Cahier</strong> Technique <strong>no</strong>. 194).For high impedance differential protections, inthe calculation of V k given by:2 I f (R ct +2 R L +R a ),where R a = other loads, R h must <strong>no</strong>t intervene.This is the load of one phase (we assume that<strong>no</strong> current flows through the neutral).a - The CT manufacturer's understanding200/11000/1Cl. Xb - The real need200/1200/11000/1 1000/115 VA Cl. 0.5 10 VA-5P201000/1200/1200/1Cl. X 15 VA Cl. 0.5 10 VA-5P20Fig. 7 : example of poor understanding between thecustomer and the CT manufacturer.R ct R wiring R O/C relayR ctR ctR wiringR wiringR O/C relayR O/C relayR hFig. 8 : internal and load impedances of a CT.V k is indeed calculated for relay stabilityconditions, i.e. <strong>no</strong> phase or earth fault, in theprotected zone, <strong>no</strong> incorrect unbalance,therefore, in the differential connection I = 0 andthe voltage of that connection = 0.Differential protections and class XFor these applications, the most usual errors are:c Asking the CT manufacturer to supply CTswith the greatest V k that he can build using astandard mould.This occurs when the differential protection relay(make, type) is <strong>no</strong>t defined.There are three consequences:v overcost,v possibility of high overvoltages andovercurrents at the CT secondary which can leadto destruction of the circuit and the relay,v with <strong>no</strong> requirements for the CT R ct , it is <strong>no</strong>tcertain that the V k expression corresponding tothe relay used, will be complied with.To illustrate this case, let us take the example ofa high impedance busbar differential protection.The CT supplied is a 2000/5 where V k = 400 Vand R ct = 2.5 Ω.For the relay used, the expression to be satisfiedis: V k u 200 R ct + 20, i.e. 520 V.The V k = 400 V is <strong>no</strong>t sufficient!More serious still, the requirement of too high aV k may lead to the manufacturing of a <strong>no</strong>nstandardCT (see the first two consequencesabove) requiring a specially designed stabilisingresistance and an overvoltage limitor as well asthe use of a deeper panel!c Error on the through currentThis error is very common. Let us take theexample of a high impedance differentialprotection where the switchboard I sc is taken into<strong>Cahier</strong> Technique <strong>Schneider</strong> <strong>Electric</strong> <strong>no</strong>. <strong>195</strong> / p.10
account instead of the maximum through current.The aim is to protect a motor, the CTs have aratio of 100/1.v Result obtained with the through current(7 I n of CT):V k u 14 (R ct + 2 R L ).v Result obtained with switchboard I sc(I sc = 40 kA):V k u 800 (R ct + 2 R L )It is <strong>no</strong>t necessary to go into too much detail tounderstand the importance of choosing the rightparameter!The table in figure 9 gives the through currentvalues to be taken into account when thethrough current is the CT calculation base (see<strong>Cahier</strong> Technique <strong>no</strong>. 194).c With line differential protections, taking intoaccount the pilot wires in the calculation of R wiring .In point of fact, R L is given by the wiring linkingthe CTs to the relay located on the same side(end) of the line (see fig. 10 ).You must <strong>no</strong>t take into account the length of thepilot wires which run from one end to the other ofthe protected line.RemindersWith respect to high impedance differentialprotections:c For the calculation of min. V k , take account ofthe through current (see fig. 9).c Calculation of the stabilising resistance R st is afunction of min. V k and of the relay settingcurrent.c Calculation of peak voltage (V p ) is based onthe internal I sc of the protected zone and on thereal V k of the CT.Applications Through Imax Excess through CommentsImaxBB differential Switchboard real I scSwitchboard I thTake real I scif <strong>no</strong>protectionincrease possible. Elsetake I thMotor differential Motor starting I 7 I n(motor) If you k<strong>no</strong>w neither theprotection otherwise starting I <strong>no</strong>r the motor I n,7 x I n(CT) take 7 x I n(CT)Generator differential Generator I sccontribution 7 I n(generator) X’’ = generatorprotection only, i.e. I n(100 / X’’) otherwise subtransient reactance7 x I n(CT) as a %. If unk<strong>no</strong>wn, weassume X’’ % u 15i.e. 100/15 = 6.67(7 is taken by excess)Restricted earth fault I scseen at the CT If P aunk<strong>no</strong>wn, we P a= upstream shortdifferentialprotection primary for a fault at the take circuit power and P t=transformer secondary, P sc= P tpower limited byi.e. I sc= P sc/Ue P t= P n(100 / Z sc) transformerP sc= (P t.P a) / (P t+ P a)Z sc% = transformershort-circuit impedanceLine differential I scat 80 % of line Switchboard I thby Switchboard I thbyprotection default defaultFig. 9 : determining the through current properly.R LPilot wires (several kilometers)R LFig. 10 : R L is given by the wiring between the CT and the relays located on the same side of the line.<strong>Cahier</strong> Technique <strong>Schneider</strong> <strong>Electric</strong> <strong>no</strong>. <strong>195</strong> / p.11