12.07.2015 Views

Download PDF - American College of Chest Physicians

Download PDF - American College of Chest Physicians

Download PDF - American College of Chest Physicians

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

22 SLEEP MEDICINE JANUARY 2011 • CHEST PHYSICIANHome Testing for Sleep Apnea Not InferiorBY SUSAN LONDONElsevier Global Medical NewsVANCOUVER, B.C. – Recent researchon the use <strong>of</strong> home testing for the diagnosis<strong>of</strong> obstructive sleep apnea and initiation<strong>of</strong> therapy suggests that “hometesting is here to stay,” Dr. Charles W.Atwood Jr., FCCP, said at CHEST 2010,the annual meeting <strong>of</strong> the <strong>American</strong><strong>College</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Chest</strong> <strong>Physicians</strong>.For more than 30 years, physicianshave relied on the traditional polysomnographyperformed in the sleeplaboratory to diagnose sleep apnea, accordingto Dr. Atwood. But with growingawareness <strong>of</strong> the condition and its prevalence,the number <strong>of</strong> people needingtesting could overwhelm capacity.“If you take the millions and millionsand millions <strong>of</strong> people in the UnitedStates alone who have sleep apnea andtry to feed them through the relativelysmall funnel <strong>of</strong> traditional sleep labs,then you are going to have big bottlenecks,”he said, adding that such bottlenecksalready exist in some areas.However, home-testing devices mustmeet certain key requirements before theyare ready for widespread use. For example,CLASSIFIEDSAlso available at www.imngmedjobs.comPROFESSIONAL OPPORTUNITIESMetro South CarolinaHospital employed joining well establishednine physician Pulmonary/CCgroup in desirable Blue Ridge Metroarea two hours to Atlanta and Charlotteassociated with a growing 450 bed hospitalsystem. 1-10 call. Excellent negotiablesalary, bonus and benefits. DONO-HUE AND ASSOCIATES 800-831-5475F: 314-984-8246E/M: donohueandassoc@aol.comPulmonology/CriticalCare <strong>Physicians</strong>Practice Opportunity for BC/BE Pulmonology/CriticalCare <strong>Physicians</strong> inBeautiful Hendersonville, Western NorthCarolina. Sleep Medicine preferred butnot required. Full-time or Part-time availability.Competitive salary & benefits. NoVisa sponsorship available. For consideratione-mail CV to:lilly.bonetti@pardeehospital.orgor Fax CV to 828-694-7722.Moving?Look to Classified Notices for practicesavailable in your area.For Deadlines and MoreInformation Contact:Rhonda Beamer443-512-8899 Ext 106FAX: 443-512-8909Email: rhonda.beamer@wt-group.comthey have to be simpler than those used inthe lab. “Perhaps we can get by withfewer [physiological] signals, but we needto understand what the key signals are,”commented Dr. Atwood, a pulmonologistand sleep medicine specialist with the VAPittsburgh Healthcare System and theUniversity <strong>of</strong> Pittsburgh Medical Center.Home testing devices will also need tobe accurate, with high sensitivity andspecificity, and “there is no single deviceI would say today that is perfect in boththese regards,” he noted. Finally, theymust be easy to use and durable, giventhe demands <strong>of</strong> in-home use.Roughly 95 studies conducted between1990 and 2006 evaluated home testing(also called portable monitoring) for thediagnosis <strong>of</strong> obstructive sleep apnea. Collectively,they had some limitations, suchas their single-site nature, small andusually homogeneous populations, andvarying degrees <strong>of</strong> rigor in design.“And they frequently focused on thehighest-risk subjects: These were middleagedmen who were overweight, snored,and were sleepy, so [they were] the verylow-hanging fruit for typical sleep apnea,”Dr. Atwood said.These studies showed some mixed re-Pulmonary/Critical CareThe VA Medical Center in Milwaukee,Wisconsin is a large tertiary care facilityaffiliated with the Medical <strong>College</strong> <strong>of</strong>Wisconsin. Openings exist for pulmonaryand critical care medicine physicians tojoin the section <strong>of</strong> Pulmonary, CriticalCare Medicine and Sleep Medicine.Qualified candidates must be Board certifiedor eligible in Pulmonary Diseaseand Critical Care Medicine and have thequalifications for a Faculty appointmentat the Medical <strong>College</strong> <strong>of</strong> Wisconsin.Fellowship training in sleep medicine isa plus. Pr<strong>of</strong>essional and academic opportunitiesexist through the Medical <strong>College</strong><strong>of</strong> Wisconsin and the Department <strong>of</strong>Veterans Affairs. Interested candidatesshould send a current Curriculum Vitae,referencing Pulmonary, to: Clement J.Zablocki VA Medical Center, Human ResourcesAttn: Prudy Kitterman, 5000 W.National Avenue, Milwaukee, WI 53295,prudy.kittermann@va.gov fax to 414-382-5296. Additional inquiries should bedirected to Andreea Antonescu, MD at414-384-2000 X42765 or email toandreea.antonescu-turcu@va.govDisclaimer<strong>Chest</strong> Physician assumes the statementsmade in classified advertisements are accurate,but cannot investigate the statementsand assumes no responsibility or liabilityconcerning their content. ThePublisher reserves the right to decline,withdraw, or edit advertisements. Every effortwill be made to avoid mistakes, butresponsibility cannot be accepted for clericalor printer errors.sults when it came to the diagnosticperformance <strong>of</strong> home testing relative tolab testing. “There is no perfect study, atleast so far, in this area, but some havecome pretty close,” he commented.Three more-recent studies suggest thathome testing is at least not inferior to labtesting for sleep apnea diagnosis and initiation<strong>of</strong> continuouspositive airwaypressure (CPAP)therapy, accordingto Dr. Atwood.In the first study,conducted in 68people with a highlikelihood <strong>of</strong> sleepapnea, the apneahypopneaindex onCPAP and Sleep Apnea Quality <strong>of</strong> Life Indexscores at 3 months did not differ significantlybetween a sleep lab and anambulatory approach (Ann. Intern. Med.2007;146:157-66). The rate <strong>of</strong> adherenceto CPAP was better with the latter.In the second study, which involved102 patients with sleep apnea symptomsand no major comorbidities, all <strong>of</strong> a variety<strong>of</strong> sleep and quality <strong>of</strong> life outcomesafter 4 weeks <strong>of</strong> CPAP weresimilar with a standard lab diagnosis andtreatment approach vs. a home approach(<strong>Chest</strong> 2010;138:257-63).The third study, the Veterans SleepApnea Treatment Trial (VSATT), is thelargest study <strong>of</strong> home testing in NorthAmerica to date, according to Dr. Atwood,one <strong>of</strong> the principal investigators.“The VA is ill equipped to managesleep apnea in a conventional way becausewe have relatively few numbers <strong>of</strong>traditional sleep labs,” he noted.“Our study differed from basically all <strong>of</strong>the other studies in the literature in thatwe had very broad inclusion criteria andvery nonrestrictive exclusion criteria,”Dr. Atwood noted. For example, patientswith comorbidities could participate aslong as their condition was stable.Patients were randomized to lab testingor home testing, followed by initiation <strong>of</strong>CPAP for those with positive results.Among the 223 who were started onCPAP, the home and lab groups had‘Functionalimprovement withCPAP for sleepapnea is not worsewhen treated inthe home settingvs. the sleep lab.’DR. ATWOODsimilar demographics. The average apneahypopneaindex was 41 for the former and45 for the latter. The Functional Outcomes<strong>of</strong> Sleep Questionnaire (FOSQ)total score was about 15 in each group.Results showed that the mean adjustedimprovement in FOSQ total score betweenbaseline and 3 months was identicalin the twogroups, at 1.79points. And withineach group, patientshad significantimprovementsin the total score aswell as its individualcomponents.Both home andlab groups also hadsignificant improvements on the EpworthSleepiness Scale (–2.6 and –2.9, respectively),the mental health component<strong>of</strong> the 12-item Short Form Health Survey(+2.5 and +3.0), and the Center for EpidemiologicStudies–Depression scale(–1.4 and –2.2). Neither group improvedsignificantly on the psychovigilance taskor the physical health component <strong>of</strong> the12-item Short Form Health Survey.When it came to adherence, whichwas monitored with smart cards, themean adjusted number <strong>of</strong> CPAP hoursdaily was 3.42 in the home group and2.99 in the lab group, a difference thatwas not significant. Cost-effectivenessanalyses are still ongoing.“We concluded that the functional improvementwith CPAP for sleep apnea isnot worse when treated in the home settingvs. the sleep lab,” Dr. Atwood said.“We believe ... home-based sleep apneadiagnosis and initiation <strong>of</strong> CPAP therapyis an effective way to treat sleep apnea.”While home testing won’t entirely replacelaboratory polysomnography, Dr.Atwood suggested trying to “integratehome sleep testing with full polysomnographyin a clinically rational way.”Dr. Atwood reported that he receivedresearch support from Embla, Resmed,and Respironics, and is a consultant toEmbla and Itamar Medical, all <strong>of</strong> whichmanufacture testing and treatment devicesfor sleep disorders.■Satisfaction With Medicine Low Among U.S. <strong>Physicians</strong>New ZealandNorwayNetherlandsUnited KingdomSwedenItalyFranceCanadaUnited StatesAustraliaD A T A W A T C H36545454495449596668SatisfiedVerysatisfiedGermany 34 50 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%Note: Data collected from 10,320 primary care physicians from February to July 2009.Source: The Commonwealth Fund1215302127183535822ELSEVIER GLOBAL MEDICAL NEWS

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!