Evaluation form for external referees (co-referees) of doctoral theses
Evaluation form for external referees (co-referees) of doctoral theses
Evaluation form for external referees (co-referees) of doctoral theses
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
2Name <strong>of</strong> the candidate:.....................................Questions <strong>co</strong>ncerning the thesisHow do you judge the thesis with respect to in<strong><strong>for</strong>m</strong>ative value <strong>of</strong> title &abstractorganisationgrammar and syntaxhandling <strong>of</strong> literature (breadth <strong>of</strong> <strong>co</strong>verage, previous studies,bibliography)illustrations (quality, in<strong><strong>for</strong>m</strong>ation value, ac<strong>co</strong>rdance with text)separation <strong>of</strong> data and interpretationappropriateness <strong>of</strong> methods usedquality <strong>of</strong> experiments and resultsinterpretation <strong>of</strong> the data and <strong>co</strong>nsistency <strong>of</strong> the argumentationimportance <strong>of</strong> the scientific problem, progress towards a solutionacceptableunacceptableDoes the scientific <strong>co</strong>ntent <strong>of</strong> the work <strong>co</strong>rrespond to the standard<strong>of</strong> a <strong>doctoral</strong> dissertation? (Yes/No)Does this thesis show evidence <strong>of</strong> a substantial independentscientific achievement by the candidate? (Yes/No)Further <strong>co</strong>mments (if any).……..……..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................☐ I re<strong>co</strong>mmend the Vetsuisse Faculty to accept the present work as inaugural thesis <strong>for</strong> thedegree <strong>of</strong> doctor <strong>of</strong> veterinary medicine.☐ I do not re<strong>co</strong>mmend the Vetsuisse Faculty to accept the present work as inaugural thesis<strong>for</strong> the degree <strong>of</strong> doctor <strong>of</strong> veterinary medicine.Location, Date:Signature:
Change language