An Analysis of Student Comments in Comprehensive Editing

Applied ResearchAlbers and Marsellaediting from the author’s point of view. TechnicalCommunication, 55, 140–166.Eaton, A., Brewer, P., Portewig, T., & Davidson, C.(2008b). Examining editing in the workplace fromthe author’s point of view: Results of an onlinesurvey. Technical Communication, 55, 111–139.Farkas, D., & Poltrock, S. (1995). Online editing,mark-up models, and the workplace lives of editorsand writers. IEEE Transactions on ProfessionalCommunication, 38, 110–117.Gerich, C. (1994). How technical editors enrich therevision process. Technical Communication, 41,59–70.Grady, H., Mayweather, E., Davis, B., & LaPlume, A.(2004). Strategies for working with authors: Howto foster productive author-editor relationships.Proceedings of the 51st Annual STC Conference(pp. 428–435). Arlington, VA: STC.Hart, G. (2004). Helping authors work with you.Intercom, 51(7), 38.Hart, G. (2005). Softening the blow: Taking the stingout of editorial and other reviews. Intercom, 52(8),25–27.Hayhoe, G. (2002). Core Competencies: The essence oftechnical communication. Technical Communication,49, 397–398.Lanier, C. (2004). Electronic editing and the author.Technical Communication, 51, 526–536.Mackiewicz, J. (2005). Hinting at what they mean:Indirect suggestions in writing tutors’ interactionswith engineering students. IEEE Transactions onProfessional Communication, 48, 365–376.Mackiewicz, J., & Riley, K. (2003) The technical editoras diplomat: Linguistic strategies for balancingclarity and politeness. Technical Communication, 50,83–94.Riley, K. & Mackiewicz, J. (2003). Resolving thedirectness dilemma in document review sessionswith nonnative speakers. IEEE Transactions onProfessional Communication, 46, 1–16.Rude, C. D. (2005). Technical editing (4th ed.). NewYork, NY: Pearson.Samson, D. (1993). Editing technical writing. New York,NY: Oxford.Walkowski, D. (1991). Working successfully withtechnical experts—From their perspective. TechnicalCommunication, 38, 65–67.Willen, M. (2004). Teaching effective feedback skills.Intercom, 51(4), 21–22.Windsor, D. (1993). Owning corporate text. Journal ofBusiness and Technical Communication, 7, 179–195.Zimmerman, D., & Taylor, C. (1999). Technicaleditors: Are we our own worst enemies? Strategiesfor working with authors Proceedings of the 46stAnnual STC Conference (pp. 351–354). Arlington,VA: STC.About the AuthorsMichael J. Albers is an associate professor at EastCarolina University (ECU), where he teaches in theprofessional writing program. In 1999, he completedhis PhD in technical communication and rhetoricfrom Texas Tech University. Before coming to ECU, hetaught for 8 years at the University of Memphis. Beforeearning his PhD, he worked for 10 years as a technicalcommunicator, writing software documentation andperforming interface design. His research interestsinclude designing information focused on answeringreal-world questions and online presentation of complexinformation.John F. Marsella received degrees from The CulinaryInstitute of America in Hyde Park, New York (AOS,Culinary Arts) and Auburn University in Auburn,Alabama (B.A., English Literature; Creative Writing).He is currently studying biological sciences at theUniversity of Colorado in Fort Collins, Colorado,pursuing of candidacy for a Professional VeterinaryMedicine program.Manuscript received 19 November 2009; revised 22 October2010; accepted 5 January 2011.Volume 58, Number 1, February 2011 l Technical Communication 67