Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
Table 4.<br />
Comparison of Contact Seals to Non-Contact Seals<br />
The table below shows the most important advantages of Non-Contact Seals compared with<br />
lip seals.<br />
Criteria Lip seal Non-Contact Seal<br />
Wear by friction none<br />
Power loss by friction none --> savings of energy<br />
--> may lead to smaller driving<br />
units<br />
Temperature<br />
increase<br />
yes none<br />
Speed limit depending on material none<br />
Live limited by wear unlimited<br />
Lubrication required at the sealing location no lubrication required for the seal<br />
Mating parts Hardening and grinding required for<br />
the shaft at higher speeds to reduce<br />
wear<br />
Temperature<br />
range<br />
Space<br />
requirement<br />
Field of<br />
applications<br />
limited due to material (plastic or<br />
rubber)<br />
Hardening and grinding not<br />
necessary<br />
from very low to very high<br />
- 40° C - 140° C (plastic material)<br />
- 40° F - 340° F (metallic material<br />
steel + aluminium)<br />
small formerly large - customer designed<br />
labyrinth seals;<br />
Grease lubrication Grease lubrication<br />
Oil lubrication Oil lubrication if oil level below<br />
sealing diameter<br />
Oil mist lubrication<br />
water - limited, as water may increase<br />
the friction at sealing location<br />
fine and coarse granular<br />
contamination not possible, as this<br />
environment causes rapid wear of the<br />
lips<br />
water - with the use of rust proof<br />
materials and level below sealing<br />
diameter<br />
fine and coarse granular<br />
contamination can be sealed<br />
reliably if applied to horizontal<br />
shaft.<br />
Because of the friction, contacting seals will raise the temperature of the system and therefore<br />
cannot be considered for the majority of machine tool <strong>spindle</strong>s. Thus, in general, contacting seals<br />
are used only where low speeds are involved<br />
dN value below 200.000<br />
- 30 -