The TSSSA Newsletter
Winter 2013 Issue - Texas Social Studies Supervisors Association
Winter 2013 Issue - Texas Social Studies Supervisors Association
- No tags were found...
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
<strong>The</strong> <strong>TSSSA</strong> <strong>Newsletter</strong><br />
Texas Social Studies Supervisors Association<br />
Inside this Issue<br />
President’s Message 1-4<br />
Legislative Bill Watch 4<br />
TEA Update 5<br />
Message from TCSS 6<br />
Nice Map! Now What? 7-10<br />
Officer Interest Form 11<br />
Spring Conference<br />
Schedule<br />
Our Mission<br />
12<br />
Help Us Fill In the State 13<br />
<strong>TSSSA</strong> 2012 Spring<br />
Conference Form<br />
14<br />
Call for Presenter Form 15<br />
Rosemary Morrow<br />
Supervisor of the Year<br />
Nomination Form<br />
<strong>TSSSA</strong> Membership<br />
Application<br />
16<br />
17<br />
Executive Board 18<br />
<strong>The</strong> Texas Social<br />
Studies Supervisors<br />
Association<br />
pledges to promote<br />
lifelong<br />
learning through<br />
social studies education<br />
and to support<br />
effective instruction<br />
in Texas<br />
schools.<br />
Standing Strong for Social Studies!<br />
President’s Message - Marci Deal<br />
What an opportunity we<br />
have to stand strong for<br />
social studies. This year<br />
our state legislators will<br />
have to make some tough<br />
decisions in regards to the<br />
state budget. One of the<br />
tough decisions involves<br />
what role Social Studies<br />
plays in Texas students’<br />
education. You may or may not know that the<br />
role of social studies might be diminished in<br />
importance after this legislative session. We<br />
need to think about our role as leaders in social<br />
studies and plan accordingly for the future<br />
of our core subject here in Texas.<br />
Will a child be well educated without an emphasis<br />
on history, geography, government,<br />
economics, citizenship, culture, social studies<br />
skills, inventiveness and impact (science, technology,<br />
and society)? I think we know that<br />
answer, which is a resounding NO. As leaders<br />
of social studies we need to start talking to our<br />
legislators about the importance of social<br />
studies and what role it plays in a student’s<br />
education. To contact your legislator go to<br />
http://www.fyi.legis.state.tx.us/Home.aspx to<br />
find your representative.<br />
One of the legislative issues being discussed<br />
is the downsizing of the number of STAAR/<br />
EOC tests that students will take. “No Child<br />
Left Behind” requires school districts to<br />
monitor English, and Math. With this in<br />
mind, Science and Social Studies will be an<br />
obvious place to possibly cut if you are looking<br />
at things strictly through the lens of an<br />
accountant. On the surface you may say<br />
“thank goodness” but, let’s stop and think<br />
about the ripple effect of this decision. As an<br />
educator we know that in order to produce a<br />
well-rounded, educated person then we must<br />
teach, and I believe, measure social studies.<br />
<strong>The</strong>re is at least one house bill (HB 640) and<br />
one Senate Bill (SB 240) that we need watch.<br />
(Continued on page 2—President’s Message)<br />
Questions for TEA for the 2013 Spring Conference<br />
Questions can be submitted through the below web address. No log-in is required<br />
but please include your name and school district either before the questions<br />
or in the name section. Without this information the questions can not be<br />
submitted to TEA. http://todaysmeet.com/spring2013_TEAQuestions<br />
Mark Your Calendars—Up-coming Conference Dates<br />
March 20th-21st, 2013—Spring <strong>TSSSA</strong> Conference—Airport Hilton<br />
October 24, 2013—Fall <strong>TSSSA</strong> Conference—San Antonio<br />
March 27th-28th, 2014—Spring <strong>TSSSA</strong> Conference—Airport Hilton<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>TSSSA</strong> <strong>Newsletter</strong> 1 Volume 1, Issue 65
President’s Message Continued<br />
(Continued from page 1 - President’s Message)<br />
Both of these bills are calling for no EOC’s for Social Studies….. If that happens any creditability we had with<br />
other subject areas, parents and our local administration will certainly diminish. Remember what is measured is<br />
treasured…<br />
If you want to send Dianne Patrick (the author of the House Bill) or Latecia Van de Putte (the author of the Senate<br />
Bill) your concerns, their contact information can be found at http://www.house.state.tx.us/news/press-releases/?<br />
id=4182&session=83&district=94&bill_code=4050<br />
Please also keep an eye on who is part of the Public Education Committee. (If these bills make it out of committee<br />
as is then we will have a much larger fight on our hand)<br />
http://www.capitol.state.tx.us/Committees/MembershipCmte.aspx?LegSess=83R&CmteCode=C400 (House Side)<br />
<strong>The</strong> House hasn’t appointed their members as of 1/24/13<br />
http://www.capitol.state.tx.us/Committees/MembershipCmte.aspx?LegSess=83R&CmteCode=C530 (Senate Side)<br />
<strong>The</strong> Senate has appointed its members.<br />
Our role as educators is to provide students with a course of study that will produce an appreciative citizen, a citizen<br />
who knows how to get involved at the state, national and local level, a citizen who can compete in the global<br />
economy and one who is knowledgeable about the past and present and can make rational decisions. As a social<br />
studies leader, my fear right now centers around the unintended consequences of the lack of testing.<br />
As a curriculum coordinator several questions are running through my mind if we take away EOC tests in social<br />
studies, such as:<br />
1. Will our credibility as a core subject be diminished with parents, community and administration if we are<br />
no longer part of the equation?<br />
2. What type of monitoring will take place to verify that a student is being held to high expectations of learning<br />
in the field of social studies?<br />
3. Now that school districts are allotted money for instruction from the state, how much will the area of social<br />
studies be given for the next round of textbooks/instructional materials? (District choice on how to<br />
spend the money – remember “what is measured is treasured”)<br />
4. Will we lose ground on ensuring that the best teachers are hired to teach social studies if there isn’t a test<br />
for our subject area and if social studies will not be part of the rating for a campus/school districts?<br />
5. Will we lose even more ground on the teaching of social studies in elementary school?<br />
6. Will we lose emphasis on vertical alignment in the social studies, an emphasis we have enjoyed for the<br />
last several years to ensure student success on state exams?<br />
7. Since there isn’t a class size limit in secondary classrooms will the social studies classes get larger while<br />
the tested subjects’ classes get smaller?<br />
Of all groups we know how politics work! <strong>The</strong> more they hear from us the more they will listen. Make sure that<br />
you email and write your legislators. Emails generally go to staffers and letters take a different route; both are<br />
counted, but in different manners. Please join me in writing, emailing and visiting our legislators and fight to<br />
“Stand Strong for Social Studies”!<br />
We are currently looking into a correlated effort to talk to legislators in March at our annual <strong>TSSSA</strong> meeting in<br />
Austin. <strong>The</strong> details haven’t been completely worked out, but that opportunity will be available for those of you<br />
who feel comfortable going and talking to State legislators. However, please keep in mind we need to start our<br />
writing, emailing and visiting campaign now – by March the bill may have moved out of committee, which will<br />
make our struggle even harder.<br />
Sincerely,<br />
`tÜv| fÅ|à{ WxtÄ<br />
Marci Smith Deal<br />
<strong>TSSSA</strong> President<br />
(Continued on page 3)<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>TSSSA</strong> <strong>Newsletter</strong> 2 Volume 1, Issue 65
President’s Message Continued<br />
(Continued from page 2)<br />
*Listed below is the current Texas Education Code (Mission and Objectives) I have highlighted the areas that<br />
relate directly to social studies.<br />
TEXAS EDUCATION CODE<br />
TITLE 2. PUBLIC EDUCATION<br />
SUBTITLE A. GENERAL PROVISIONS<br />
CHAPTER 4. PUBLIC EDUCATION MISSION, OBJECTIVES, AND GOALS<br />
Sec. 4.001. PUBLIC EDUCATION MISSION AND OBJECTIVES. (a) <strong>The</strong> mission of the public<br />
education system of this state is to ensure that all Texas children have access to a quality education that enables<br />
them to achieve their potential and fully participate now and in the future in the social, economic, and educational<br />
opportunities of our state and nation. That mission is grounded on the conviction that a general diffusion of knowledge<br />
is essential for the welfare of this state and for the preservation of the liberties and rights of citizens. It is<br />
further grounded on the conviction that a successful public education system is directly related to a strong, dedicated,<br />
and supportive family and that parental involvement in the school is essential for the maximum educational<br />
achievement of a child.<br />
(b) <strong>The</strong> objectives of public education are:<br />
OBJECTIVE 1: Parents will be full partners with educators in the education of their children.<br />
OBJECTIVE 2: Students will be encouraged and challenged to meet their full educational potential.<br />
OBJECTIVE 3: Through enhanced dropout prevention efforts, all students will remain in school until<br />
they obtain a high school diploma.<br />
OBJECTIVE 4: A well-balanced and appropriate curriculum will be provided to all students.<br />
OBJECTIVE 5: Educators will prepare students to be thoughtful, active citizens who have an appreciation<br />
for the basic values of our state and national heritage and who can understand and productively function in a<br />
free enterprise society.<br />
OBJECTIVE 6: Qualified and highly effective personnel will be recruited, developed, and retained.<br />
OBJECTIVE 7: <strong>The</strong> state's students will demonstrate exemplary performance in comparison to national<br />
and international standards.<br />
OBJECTIVE 8: School campuses will maintain a safe and disciplined environment conducive to student<br />
learning. (I interpreted this as part of teaching about the rule of law and civic expectations!)<br />
OBJECTIVE 9: Educators will keep abreast of the development of creative and innovative techniques<br />
in instruction and administration using those techniques as appropriate to improve student learning.<br />
(Continued on page 4)<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>TSSSA</strong> <strong>Newsletter</strong> 3 Volume 1, Issue 65
President’s Message Continued<br />
(Continued from page 3)<br />
OBJECTIVE 10: Technology will be implemented<br />
and used to increase the effectiveness of student<br />
learning, instructional management, staff development,<br />
and administration.<br />
I’m Just A Bill<br />
<strong>The</strong> popular School House Rock videos explains<br />
the process of a bill becoming a law.<br />
But if there was a prequel to the video it<br />
would show all the other bills that are proposed<br />
but never become laws.<br />
As the legislative sessions opens many bills<br />
will be proposed. Several will relate to education<br />
and possibly social studies. Keeping<br />
track of them isn’t an easy task.<br />
<strong>TSSSA</strong> will do its part in keeping you, our<br />
membership, up to date on what is happening<br />
with these bills. At the spring conference<br />
we normally will receive an update on<br />
key bills but we also want to let you know<br />
how to track and follow any bill that you<br />
may find of interest.<br />
At http://www.capitol.state.tx.us/ you can<br />
search for a bill by its number or key words.<br />
<strong>The</strong>n from the site you can set up the system<br />
to notify you on the status of the bill as it<br />
works through the house and senate.<br />
Added by Acts 1995, 74th Leg., ch. 260, Sec. 1, eff.<br />
May 30, 1995. Amended by Acts 2003, 78th Leg., ch.<br />
82, Sec. 1, eff. Sept. 1, 2003.<br />
Sec. 4.002. PUBLIC EDUCATION ACA-<br />
DEMIC GOALS. To serve as a foundation for a wellbalanced<br />
and appropriate education:<br />
GOAL 1: <strong>The</strong> students in the public<br />
education system will demonstrate exemplary performance<br />
in the reading and writing of the English language.<br />
GOAL 2: <strong>The</strong> students in the public<br />
education system will demonstrate exemplary performance<br />
in the understanding of mathematics.<br />
GOAL 3: <strong>The</strong> students in the public<br />
education system will demonstrate exemplary performance<br />
in the understanding of science.<br />
GOAL 4: <strong>The</strong> students in the public<br />
education system will demonstrate exemplary performance<br />
in the understanding of social studies.<br />
Added by Acts 1995, 74th Leg., ch. 260, Sec. 1, eff.<br />
May 30, 1995.<br />
To get you started please refer to a list that<br />
the Science Teachers Association of Texas<br />
has created about some of the education<br />
bills that have been filed that you may want<br />
to follow.<br />
http://statweb.org/billreport.pdf<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>TSSSA</strong> <strong>Newsletter</strong> 4 Volume 1, Issue 65
TEA Curriculum Update January 2013<br />
Julie Brelsford<br />
Statewide Social Studies Coordinator<br />
Happy New Year, fellow social studies educators! I really enjoyed being with you at the<br />
<strong>TSSSA</strong> conference. I hope you found the presentation useful. If you have questions<br />
about anything in the presentation, please contact me and I will try to help you find the<br />
answers.<br />
At the November 2012 SBOE meeting, the board approved one set of new personal<br />
financial literacy materials. <strong>The</strong> social studies website has been updated to reflect the<br />
addition. <strong>The</strong> board also discussed HB 1942, which requires the SBOE to include student<br />
expectations for bullying prevention in the health education Texas Essential<br />
Knowledge and Skills (TEKS). <strong>The</strong> agency is working with the Texas School Safety<br />
Center to provide recommendations for student expectations with a specific strand for<br />
grades 4 - 8 for the board’s consideration at the January SBOE meeting.<br />
I have some good news regarding the social studies OnTRACK lessons! U.S. History<br />
lessons are now available on Project Share, and staff is in the process of reviewing<br />
grade 8 lessons as well as additional lessons for the tested high school social studies<br />
courses. It bears remembering that the lessons are not designed to cover every student<br />
expectation in the TEKS for the corresponding SBOE-approved course. I hope<br />
you will find them a valuable resource for students in need of additional instruction or<br />
remediation or just for general classroom use. <strong>The</strong> online Bible Literacy course is also<br />
being reviewed and will be available soon.<br />
As a reminder, the 2013 SBOE meeting dates are as follows:<br />
January 30, 31, and February 1, 2013<br />
April 17 – 19, 2013<br />
July 17 – 19, 2013<br />
September 18 – 20, 2013<br />
November 13 – 15, 2013<br />
I know that the rest of the school year will be “fast and furious” for students and teachers<br />
alike. Please feel free to contact me if I can be of service. Have a wonderful second<br />
semester and thank you for all you do for the students of Texas.<br />
<strong>TSSSA</strong> Gone Social???<br />
On a daily bases many of us may not check the <strong>TSSSA</strong> webpage. But how many of us<br />
check our Facebook (at home) or text messages? To better help keep <strong>TSSSA</strong> in touch<br />
with the membership we are working to develop Facebook and Twitter accounts.<br />
Please join us as we learn these new communication tools.<br />
“Friend” Texas Social Studies<br />
Supervisors Association<br />
@TX<strong>TSSSA</strong><br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>TSSSA</strong> <strong>Newsletter</strong> 5 Volume 1, Issue 65
Greetings and Happy New Year<br />
from TCSS President Bev Smith<br />
As 2013, gets underway some of our<br />
biggest challenges will come from the Texas<br />
Legislature. Social Studies education is being<br />
attacked from many different factions. <strong>The</strong><br />
one remaining constant in all of this is our<br />
unity as supervisors and educators. TCSS and<br />
<strong>TSSSA</strong> remain the stalwarts of social studies<br />
educational support, but in order to remain<br />
strong we must continue to grow our organizations.<br />
<strong>The</strong> “Just One” campaign was created<br />
and launched two years ago to increase membership<br />
in both TCSS and <strong>TSSSA</strong>. Both<br />
TCSS and <strong>TSSSA</strong> exist for the sole purpose of<br />
supporting and promoting Social Studies education.<br />
<strong>The</strong> motto "there is strength in numbers"<br />
is so appropriate today given what we<br />
have recently endured as social studies educators<br />
and might possibly face in the future. <strong>The</strong><br />
future looks bleak for education in general, so<br />
why not come together as a group and show<br />
our solidarity. TCSS and <strong>TSSSA</strong> may be your<br />
only resource for state updates and support for<br />
implementation of the new standards and EOC.<br />
Membership gives you access to <strong>The</strong> Texan<br />
with resources galore, and to the many contacts<br />
in both these organizations that will provide<br />
the support necessary to manage the new<br />
STAAR testing. Many school districts have<br />
been forced to eliminate coordinator and specialist<br />
positions for Social Studies. TEA has<br />
reorganized and many support staff are now<br />
without jobs. This alone prompts us to be<br />
more interdependent. So join or renew now!<br />
Have you renewed your memberships<br />
to TCSS and <strong>TSSSA</strong>? If not, we need you! If<br />
you have, thank you for your support. But<br />
with membership comes responsibility and<br />
here is where you can come to the aid of TCSS<br />
and <strong>TSSSA</strong>. Recruitment.<br />
Encourage and sign up as many of your<br />
social studies staff and colleagues as humanly<br />
possible. Please go to www.txcss.org. and<br />
www.tsssa.org for membership forms for both<br />
organizations. <strong>TSSSA</strong> is not just for supervisors,<br />
it is for any leader in social studies.<br />
My challenge to all of you is to sign up<br />
one new member before the TCSS 2013 fall conference<br />
to be held in San Antonio, Oct. 25-27, at<br />
the Grand Hyatt Riverwalk. Our membership<br />
campaign motto is "Just One". Make a difference:<br />
join, renew, and recruit.<br />
For the first time ever the TCSS executive<br />
board will be hosting the TCSS conference in San<br />
Antonio. <strong>The</strong> theme this year is Educational Missions<br />
in Texas: Cultural Diversity, STARR, Multilingualism,<br />
Professional Development, and Differentiation.<br />
With so many topics to choose from,<br />
I know there are many of you who could bring<br />
your expertise to the conference, so think about<br />
offering a presentation proposal for the conference.<br />
While challenging, the board hopes it can<br />
count on its members to help in this endeavor. If<br />
you have not considered serving on a TCSS executive<br />
committee please agree to serve on one. You<br />
will find the committee reference form on the<br />
TCSS website at www.txcss.org. <strong>The</strong> first committee<br />
meeting of 2013 will take place on Saturday,<br />
March 23 at the TCSS spring board meeting<br />
following the <strong>TSSSA</strong> spring conference at the<br />
Austin Hilton Airport Hotel. If you are already a<br />
committee member, thank you for serving and<br />
mark your calendars for this important work.<br />
I want to personally thank all of you for<br />
your support in our efforts to keep Social Studies<br />
in the forefront. Please do not hesitate to contact<br />
me at anytime about council business. I look forward<br />
to working with you.<br />
Remember: 2013 TCSS fall conference – Grand<br />
Hyatt Riverwalk, San Antonio<br />
Respectfully, Bev Smith<br />
TCSS President, Beverly_smith@lovejoyisd.net or<br />
burnslid@verizon.net<br />
Lovejoy ISD Social Studies Curriculum Specialist<br />
259 Country Club Rd.<br />
Allen, TX 75002<br />
469-742-8035 - work<br />
469-742-8073 – fax<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>TSSSA</strong> <strong>Newsletter</strong> 6 Volume 1, Issue 65
Nice map! Now what?<br />
Thoughts on Mapping the 2012 World Geography End-of-Course Exam Results<br />
Jeff Lash, University of Houston-Clear Lake<br />
Late last summer I made a map. Actually I<br />
made two related maps (see Figure 1). <strong>The</strong><br />
process started with a simple question: how did<br />
high school world geography students do on<br />
the Spring 2012 end-of-course exam?<br />
Throughout the fall I displayed and discussed<br />
the maps with colleagues around the state.<br />
Most discussions went something like this:<br />
“Great map<br />
Jeff!”<br />
“Thanks. I<br />
enjoyed<br />
making it.”<br />
“Can you<br />
send me a<br />
copy?”<br />
“Sure,” I<br />
would respond.<br />
“What are<br />
you going<br />
to do with<br />
the map?”<br />
“I’m going<br />
to compare<br />
my district<br />
to others.”<br />
“Okay.<br />
What are<br />
you going<br />
to do with the map after that?” I would ask.<br />
And then the conversation would screech to a<br />
halt. Many individuals spoke in vague terms of<br />
wanting to improve local achievement, but no<br />
one seemed to have any long-term plans for<br />
how to use state-wide results to improve geographic<br />
literacy for all students. So, I have<br />
been asking myself “Now what?” How can<br />
the world geography end-of-course exam results<br />
be used to improve geographic literacy<br />
for all students across the state? More on that<br />
question later. First, let’s discuss the maps<br />
themselves.<br />
Ask any cartographer about how to make a<br />
map and the<br />
conversation<br />
will soon<br />
turn to the<br />
issue of data.<br />
Does the data<br />
exist?<br />
Can you get<br />
your hands<br />
on it?<br />
Is the data in<br />
good shape<br />
or does it<br />
need to be<br />
cleaned up?<br />
Once these<br />
questions are<br />
resolved, cartographers<br />
display the<br />
data so as to<br />
make propositions,<br />
arguments,<br />
and<br />
suggest authority.<br />
Figure 1<br />
Maps, then, become representations that leverage<br />
words. In this case, I wanted to make<br />
maps that supported claims about how best to<br />
improve geography education in Texas.<br />
And so, last spring I was really excited because<br />
I knew that, under contract from the<br />
(Continued on page 8)<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>TSSSA</strong> <strong>Newsletter</strong> 7 Volume 1, Issue 65
Nice map! Now what?<br />
continued<br />
(Continued from page 7)<br />
Texas Education Agency, Pearson would be<br />
using the STAAR World Geography End-of-<br />
Course exam to collect geographic literacy<br />
data from 9 th graders across the state. May<br />
arrived and the state administered Pearson’s<br />
exam. Yippee! Now wait and wait until early<br />
June when the exam results, the data, started<br />
trickling out to school districts. I waited for<br />
results to be posted online. In August, when<br />
this finally happened, I was disappointed to<br />
find the data presented as PDF “Summary<br />
Reports.” I found a page summarizing statewide<br />
results, pages for each educational service<br />
center region, each district, and each<br />
campus. What was not available was a data<br />
file that would allow an analysis of geographic<br />
literacy across the state. In other<br />
words, if I wanted to compare student performance<br />
across the state, I had to tackle the<br />
data management nightmare of transforming<br />
thousands of individual PDF files (there are<br />
about 1,000 school districts in the state and<br />
about 1,500 public high schools) into a single<br />
useable database. Once I started this task, it<br />
didn’t take long before I started to tell myself<br />
that there must be a better way…<br />
And indeed there is: pay computer programmers<br />
at the TEA to aggregate the raw student<br />
data for you. TEA received the raw student<br />
data from Pearson, that’s all. No aggregated<br />
data files. No pre-packaged analysis for anyone<br />
to use to help understand the results. So,<br />
in order to obtain the data, I had to submit an<br />
Open Records Request to TEA and then wait<br />
for a response. When the response came, I<br />
found out that TEA would provide the data<br />
but would charge for the service. Specifically,<br />
if I wanted spring 2012 World Geography<br />
EOC data aggregated by region, district,<br />
and campus, I would have to pay for: one<br />
data CD ($1); the labor cost of locating, compiling,<br />
manipulating and reproducing the<br />
data (12 hours @ $15/hour); an overhead<br />
charge (20% of labor charge); a labor charge<br />
for programming (40 hours @ $28.50/hour);<br />
and an overhead charge for programming<br />
(20% of labor charge for programming); for<br />
a total of $1,585 with a deposit of 50% due<br />
to initiate the work. Thanks to funding from<br />
the Texas Alliance for Geographic Education,<br />
my $1,500 data CD arrived in mid-<br />
December. As I write, I am anxious to dive<br />
into the data and see what it says about geographic<br />
literacy across the state. Stay<br />
tuned…<br />
In the meantime, recall Figure 1. <strong>The</strong> figure<br />
presents two maps of student performance;<br />
one by region and one by school district.<br />
Please note that I did not include private or<br />
charter school data in my analysis. Why not?<br />
Geography! Private and charter school students<br />
do not live in a defined geographic<br />
area, and therefore mapping the data is impossible.<br />
That said, for both maps, I divided<br />
the scores into quintiles (see Tables 1 and 2)<br />
and then symbolized the average scaled score<br />
for Texas’ twenty Educational Service Centers<br />
(ESC) as well as for each district. Now<br />
the fun part: reading the maps!<br />
Read the ESC map. What do you learn? Regions<br />
6, 10, 11, and 13 (Quintile 5) are doing<br />
“the best,” while regions 1, 2, 5, 18 (Quintile<br />
1) are doing “the worst.” Our first proposition!<br />
Regions 14-17 (Quintile 3) are somewhere<br />
in the middle; or so one could argue.<br />
Now look at Table 2. 71% of students in<br />
ESC regions 1, 2, 5, and 18 (Quintile 1)<br />
achieved Level 2 performance. In other<br />
words, 71 % of all students in Quintile 1<br />
ESC regions are sufficiently prepared for careers<br />
and college. While in the Quintile 5 regions<br />
84% are sufficiently prepared. But<br />
wait, Table 2 also indicates that over twenty<br />
thousand students in Quintile 5 did not pass.<br />
This suggests a gap in performance in urban<br />
(Continued on page 9)<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>TSSSA</strong> <strong>Newsletter</strong> 8 Volume 1, Issue 65
Nice map! Now what?<br />
continued<br />
(Continued from page 8)<br />
areas. Another proposition.<br />
Now turn your attention to the map of scaled scores by district. With a change of scale, the pattern<br />
illustrated by the ESC map disappears. Numerous orange and red districts are adjacent to<br />
blue districts in ESC Regions 6, 10, 11, and 13. Two new propositions: geographic literacy varies<br />
widely within regions, and districts don’t collaborate. Perhaps an argument should be made<br />
for increased coordination within regions? Question: Why no blue in South Texas? Poorly prepared<br />
teachers? A higher percentage of school-dependent students (kids with little to no support<br />
for education outside the school)? Poverty? A well-organized anti-geography coalition? Table 1<br />
doesn’t help us answer any of these questions, it simply raises more questions. Based on the<br />
Table 1. Spring 2012 World Geography EOC Quintile Ranges for School Districts<br />
Quintile<br />
Scaled Score Range<br />
% of Students Achieving<br />
Level 2<br />
Number of Students Who Did<br />
Not Pass<br />
Quintile 1 3334-3717 64 11,964<br />
Quintile 2 3718-3797 74 18,379<br />
Quintile 3 3798-3868 78 13,381<br />
Quintile 4 3869-3950 84 5,742<br />
Quintile 5 3951-4407 91 10,475<br />
Table 2. Spring 2012 World Geography EOC Data for ESC Regions<br />
Quintile<br />
Average Scaled Score<br />
Range<br />
% of Students Achieving<br />
Level 2<br />
Number of Students Who Did<br />
Not Pass<br />
Quintile 1 3724-3791 71 11,998<br />
Quintile 2 3792-3830 77 6,431<br />
Quintile 3 3831-3848 78 3,406<br />
Quintile 4 3849-3923 82 20,394<br />
Quintile 5 3924-4001 84 20,098<br />
distribution of inadequately prepared students (those who did not pass), do professional development<br />
organizations mobilize resources in light blue districts? Or focus on tan districts? <strong>The</strong>se<br />
are just of few of the questions that come to my mind. I’m sure you have questions of your own.<br />
Great! Now what?<br />
By “now what” I mean how do we use the maps to increase geographic literacy in Texas? I<br />
have two immediate thoughts and one long-term dream. <strong>The</strong> first thought is to make the maps<br />
and data widely available. Most educators understand that standardized tests are useful when<br />
the results are understood and are used as a diagnostic tool to improve instruction. <strong>The</strong> Texas<br />
Alliance for Geographic Education and the Center for Social Studies Education University of<br />
Texas at Arlington have both expressed an interest in hosting websites and/or sponsoring work-<br />
(Continued on page 10)<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>TSSSA</strong> <strong>Newsletter</strong> 9 Volume 1, Issue 65
Nice map! Now what?<br />
continued<br />
(Continued from page 9)<br />
shops and reports to help fill the void of publically available data. <strong>The</strong> second thought is to explore<br />
how geographic and social factors combine to predict geographic literacy. In other words,<br />
how do variables such as location, gender, socio-economic status, class size, teacher experience,<br />
financial resources, and curriculum design influence geographic literacy as measured by the<br />
World Geography End-of-Course exam? My long-term dream emerges from a pair of phrases I<br />
first encountered in <strong>The</strong> Fourth Way – a book that presents an inspiring future for educational<br />
change. “Responsibility precedes and supersedes accountability.” “Accountability is the remainder<br />
that is left when responsibility has been subtracted.” <strong>The</strong>se two phrases guide my<br />
thinking about the STAAR WG EOC.<br />
When I look at the maps I see places where responsibility for geographic education has been<br />
abdicated. I also see accountability in the form of a legislated standardized exam. Texas legislators<br />
are sending a message: “If you’re not going to take responsibility for educating future citizens,<br />
we will!” Perhaps the most important element of STAAR is neither the exams nor the data<br />
they generate, but rather the renewed sense of responsibility assumed by all elements of the social<br />
studies education ecosystem.<br />
My dream then is of an educational system that does not need STAAR. I dream of an educational<br />
system where students, parents, teachers, administrators, and the public at large, all take<br />
responsibility for the education of all American students. If we all take our individual responsibilities<br />
seriously and work together in a spirit of cooperation not competition, then the WG<br />
EOC will be characterized as a first step toward “positive accountability” and a step away from<br />
“punitive accountability.” In the end, society will have assumed collective responsibility for the<br />
education of all students.<br />
If you have any comments, questions, or want to see a particular piece of data mapped, please<br />
contact me (lash@uhcl.edu).<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>TSSSA</strong> <strong>Newsletter</strong> 10 Volume 1, Issue 65
WE WANT YOU!<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>TSSSA</strong> <strong>Newsletter</strong> 11 Volume 1, Issue 65
Below is a draft of the general schedule for the spring conference. A full schedule<br />
with specific breakout sessions will be available the day of the conference.<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>TSSSA</strong> <strong>Newsletter</strong> 12 Volume 1, Issue 65
HELP US FILL IN THE STATE<br />
Chances are if you are reading this newsletter then you are already a member of <strong>TSSSA</strong>. But what<br />
about surrounding you? Help us reach all the social studies supervisors in the state. Share with them<br />
the benefits of joining <strong>TSSSA</strong> and about attending the conference in the spring.<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>TSSSA</strong> <strong>Newsletter</strong> 13 Volume 1, Issue 65
<strong>The</strong> <strong>TSSSA</strong> <strong>Newsletter</strong> 14 Volume 1, Issue 65
<strong>The</strong> <strong>TSSSA</strong> <strong>Newsletter</strong> 15 Volume 1, Issue 65
<strong>The</strong> <strong>TSSSA</strong> <strong>Newsletter</strong> 16 Volume 1, Issue 65
<strong>The</strong> <strong>TSSSA</strong> <strong>Newsletter</strong> 17 Volume 1, Issue 65
MEET YOUR BOARD<br />
<strong>TSSSA</strong> Executive Board<br />
2012-2013<br />
Marci Smith-Deal– President<br />
Hurst Euless Bedford ISD<br />
1849 Central Drive<br />
Bedford, TX 76022<br />
Work 817-399-2068<br />
marcideal@hebisd.edu<br />
Teresa Francis – President Elect<br />
Mansfield ISD<br />
1016 Magnolia St.<br />
Mansfield, TX 76063<br />
Work 817-299-4388<br />
teresafrancis@misdmail.org<br />
Erin Bown – Executive Secretary<br />
Grapevine-Colleyville ISD<br />
3051 Ira E. Woods Ave.<br />
Grapevine, TX 76051<br />
Work 817-251-5637<br />
erin.bown@gcisd.net<br />
Janie McClam - Vice President & Membership<br />
7113 Doswell Lane<br />
Austin, TX 78739<br />
jalommc@msn.com<br />
Julie Hyman – Treasurer<br />
Birdville ISD<br />
3120 Carson Street<br />
Haltom City, Texas 76117<br />
Work: (817) 547-5807<br />
Julia.hyman@birdvilleschools.net<br />
Barbara Vrana – Past President<br />
Denton ISD<br />
1212 Bolivar<br />
Denton, Texas 76201<br />
Work 940-.369-0660<br />
bvrana@dentonisd.org<br />
Pete Yackus – <strong>Newsletter</strong><br />
Fort Bend ISD<br />
16431 Lexington Blvd.<br />
Sugar Land, TX 77479<br />
Work 281-634-1256<br />
Pete.yackus@fortbendisd.com<br />
Bev Smith – TCSS President<br />
Lovejoy ISD<br />
259 Country Club Road<br />
Allen, TX 75002<br />
Work 469-742-8035<br />
Beverly_smith@lovejoyisd.net<br />
Julie Brelsford –Director of Social Studies<br />
Texas Education Agency<br />
1701 N. Congress<br />
Austin, TX 78701<br />
Work 512-463-9581<br />
julie.brelsford@tea.state.tx.us<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>TSSSA</strong> <strong>Newsletter</strong> 18 Volume 1, Issue 65