Amsterdam
EIB Q1 09.qxp - ACAI
EIB Q1 09.qxp - ACAI
- No tags were found...
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
European Investment Bulletin<br />
Spring 2009<br />
Prime yield decompression per sector (yoy)<br />
Rents in decline in line with business sentiment<br />
200<br />
CBD offices Warehouses Shopping Centres<br />
European average prime office rental growth<br />
Business climate indicator (Euro area)<br />
175<br />
12%<br />
4<br />
150<br />
125<br />
100<br />
75<br />
50<br />
25<br />
0<br />
Brussels<br />
Paris<br />
Frankfurt<br />
Athens<br />
Dublin<br />
Milan<br />
<strong>Amsterdam</strong><br />
Oslo<br />
Warsaw<br />
Lisbon<br />
Madrid<br />
Stockholm<br />
Istanbul<br />
London<br />
9%<br />
6%<br />
3%<br />
0%<br />
-3%<br />
-6%<br />
-9%<br />
-12%<br />
2002 Q1<br />
Q3<br />
2003 Q1<br />
Q3<br />
2004 Q1<br />
Q3<br />
2005 Q1<br />
Q3<br />
2006 Q1<br />
Q3<br />
2007 Q1<br />
Q3<br />
2008 Q1<br />
Q3<br />
3<br />
2<br />
1<br />
-1<br />
-2<br />
-3<br />
-4<br />
Source: Savills<br />
Source: Savills<br />
“Investors are looking for realistically priced deals, especially<br />
through distressed sales. Normal investment activity can only<br />
recover when the confidence in the banking sector is restored.<br />
Under current market conditions good property fundamentals and<br />
secure income are key.”<br />
Giles Wilcox - European Investment Director<br />
The Eurozone economy officially fell into recession<br />
during the second half of 2008, and latest data and<br />
business surveys since then indicate the economy<br />
will continue to contract until the second half of<br />
2009.<br />
The interbank market remains nervous, reflected in<br />
the lending rate margin above the Euribor rate. In<br />
most markets the spread has more than doubled<br />
and LTV rates have dropped compared to a year<br />
ago keeping investment activity subdued.<br />
Following the deterioration of economic<br />
fundamentals we expect occupier demand to<br />
weaken further. Rental growth should remain<br />
negative and more incentives are expected to be<br />
offered by landlords.<br />
The risk premium for prime CBD offices over the<br />
long term interest rates has risen compared to the<br />
height of the capital markets in 2007. However, it is<br />
overall still lower compared to the previous slump<br />
of investor confidence in 2003.<br />
Property is beginning to look better value especially<br />
where re-pricing has been stronger such as in the<br />
office markets of London, Paris, Madrid and Dublin.<br />
London in particular, due to the exchange rate is<br />
even more attractively priced in terms of Euro<br />
currency.<br />
Negative economic outlook and restricted lending<br />
should lead to lower capital values especially for<br />
secondary assets. The falling trend of base rates<br />
and government bond yields, imply that at least<br />
prime yield decompression may reach its bottom by<br />
the end of 2009.
Overview and market fundamentals<br />
European investment market overview<br />
2008 was the year that signalled the end of the strong<br />
yield compression trend that the commercial property<br />
markets across Europe experienced over the past four<br />
years. The economic and financial turmoil that followed<br />
the credit crisis in the US has limited the liquidity in the<br />
debt markets restricting leveraged investors, who were<br />
the driving force in the investment market. The drop in<br />
investment demand for commercial property coupled<br />
with falling economic and business sentiment has led<br />
to falling capital values.<br />
The Eurozone economy officially fell into recession<br />
during the second half of 2008, and latest data and<br />
business surveys since then indicate the economy will<br />
continue to contract until the second half of 2009. With<br />
the recession deepening and inflation falling sharply<br />
the European Central Bank (ECB) has significant<br />
scope for large cuts in interest rates. The ECB has<br />
already brought rates down to 2% from 4.25% in mid-<br />
2008, but rates remain above those in other major<br />
economies. The ECB has indicated that it would be<br />
reluctant to cut rates too fast as it wants to retain some<br />
room for manoeuvre, yet our economists expect them<br />
to fall to 1% by mid-2009.<br />
Although these policies aim to restore confidence in<br />
the banking sector, the effect on lending activity has<br />
been small until now. The interbank market remains<br />
nervous, reflected in the lending rate margin above the<br />
Euribor rate. In most markets margins have more than<br />
doubled compared to a year ago and they are up to<br />
200 basis points above the Euribor rate. The volume of<br />
property investment dropped further in the final quarter<br />
of 2008, with debt-backed buyers remaining<br />
constrained by liquidity issues and equity buyers<br />
looking for true market value. Banks are reluctant to<br />
lend and if they do they focus on existing clients. Loan<br />
to Value (LTV) rates have dropped from more than<br />
80% last year to 60-65% with the maximum size of<br />
loan in the region of €50-€70m. Investors have<br />
reassessed their risk premiums upwards, reflecting the<br />
economic uncertainty and the negative impact it has<br />
on tenant strength and rental growth. Well located,<br />
high quality properties with strong cash-flow, fully let<br />
on a long lease to a financially strong tenant are now<br />
key prerequisites.<br />
Market fundamentals<br />
The impact on the real economy is gradually reflected<br />
in weakening occupational demand and higher tenant<br />
default risk. On the other hand higher cost of debt has<br />
restricted construction activity, therefore slowing down<br />
the development cycle. However, consolidation and<br />
rationalisation is leading to lower net absorption rates<br />
and rising availability, which gives more negotiation<br />
power to the tenants. Total office take up has dropped<br />
by around 10% in our survey area (26 markets) in<br />
2008, while the vacancy rate has increased slightly<br />
from 7.9% to 8.0%.<br />
Eurozone GDP growth and ECB interest rates<br />
5.0<br />
4.0<br />
3.0<br />
2.0<br />
1.0<br />
0.0<br />
-1.0<br />
-2.0<br />
Sources: European Commission, Oxford Economics<br />
European prime property yield curve<br />
9%<br />
8%<br />
7%<br />
6%<br />
5%<br />
4%<br />
Source: Savills<br />
2008 vs 2007 office take-up (selected markets)<br />
2,800<br />
2,400<br />
2,000<br />
1,600<br />
1,200<br />
800<br />
400<br />
0<br />
Source: Savills<br />
Eurozone GDP growth (% pa) ECB key interest rates (%)<br />
2002 Q1<br />
Q2<br />
Q3<br />
Q4<br />
2003 Q1<br />
Q2<br />
Q3<br />
Q4<br />
2004 Q1<br />
Q2<br />
Q3<br />
Q4<br />
2005 Q1<br />
Q2<br />
Q3<br />
Q4<br />
2006 Q1<br />
Q2<br />
Q3<br />
Q4<br />
2007 Q1<br />
Q2<br />
Q3<br />
Q4<br />
2008 Q1<br />
Q2<br />
Q3<br />
Q4<br />
2009 Q1<br />
Q2<br />
Q3<br />
Q4<br />
Prime office yields Prime warehousing yields Prime shopping centre yields<br />
2004 Q1<br />
Q2<br />
Q3<br />
Q4<br />
2005 Q1<br />
Q2<br />
Q3<br />
Q4<br />
2006 Q1<br />
Q2<br />
Q3<br />
Q4<br />
2007 Q1<br />
Q2<br />
Q3<br />
Q4<br />
2008 Q1<br />
Q2<br />
Q3<br />
Q4<br />
Brussels<br />
2007 office take-up 2008 office take-up ('000 sqm)<br />
Paris<br />
Berlin<br />
Frankfurt<br />
Athens<br />
<strong>Amsterdam</strong><br />
Warsaw<br />
Madrid<br />
London WE<br />
European Investment Bulletin - Spring 2009 2
Yields<br />
In the final quarter of 2008 we saw the first signs of<br />
falling rents in the office markets in the countries that<br />
were hit more by the economic crisis, such as the UK,<br />
Spain and Ireland. The average annual prime office<br />
rental growth was -2.6% in Q4 2008 compared to<br />
11.2% in Q4 2007. The average prime warehousing<br />
rental growth for last year was almost 0.0% because<br />
some markets (eg Poland) still show some positive<br />
growth.<br />
Consumer and retail trade sentiment indicators<br />
Consumer sentiment Retail trade sentiment<br />
10.0<br />
5.0<br />
0.0<br />
-5.0<br />
-10.0<br />
-15.0<br />
Rental growth still remains positive for prime retail<br />
properties. However the retail markets are exposed to<br />
declining consumer confidence and retail sales,<br />
caused by the fear of rising unemployment and falling<br />
housing markets. Therefore we expect rents to come<br />
under pressure in 2009, especially in markets with<br />
higher development pipelines, such as Italy, Portugal,<br />
Spain and Istanbul.<br />
-20.0<br />
-25.0<br />
-30.0<br />
01/01/1999<br />
01/01/2000<br />
01/01/2001<br />
01/01/2002<br />
01/01/2003<br />
Source: European Commission<br />
01/01/2004<br />
01/01/2005<br />
01/01/2006<br />
01/01/2007<br />
01/01/2008<br />
01/01/2009<br />
Following the deterioration of economic fundamentals<br />
in recent months and the forecasts for negative<br />
economic growth in the major European economies<br />
we expect occupier demand to weaken further. Rental<br />
growth should remain negative and more incentives<br />
are expected to be offered by landlords.<br />
Yields<br />
The yield decompression that started at the end of<br />
2007 continued in 2008 and yields across all sectors<br />
were on average 95 to 115 basis points (bp) higher in<br />
Q4 2008 compared to a year before. Yield correction<br />
was steeper in the office sector with the achievable<br />
average prime yield for our survey area at 6.5% and<br />
the average secondary yield at 7.2%. Currently the<br />
average prime cap rates for offices are 440 basis<br />
points higher than the Euribor rate. This gap had<br />
narrowed down to less than 100 bp in 2007, during the<br />
time of the strongest yield compression. Historically<br />
(since 2000) this spread has been on average around<br />
320 basis points. Currently the Euribor rates are<br />
trending downward and we believe that the spread<br />
with property rates could narrow again; as long as the<br />
confidence in the banking system is restored in order<br />
to provide the liquidity that will enable a more active<br />
investment market.<br />
Euribor rate - Prime office yield gap<br />
Euribor (12M) Average prime office yield (%)<br />
8.0<br />
6.0<br />
4.0<br />
2.0<br />
0.0<br />
01/01/2001<br />
20/06/2001<br />
05/12/2001<br />
31/05/2002<br />
15/11/2002<br />
10/05/2003<br />
19/10/2003<br />
16/04/2004<br />
27/09/2004<br />
20/03/2005<br />
31/08/2005<br />
21/02/2006<br />
15/08/2006<br />
30/01/2007<br />
19/07/2007<br />
08/01/2008<br />
27/06/2008<br />
12/12/2008<br />
Sources: Euribor, Savills<br />
Prime office yield convergence (selected markets)<br />
Paris CBD Milan CBD <strong>Amsterdam</strong> CBD Warsaw CBD<br />
Madrid CBD London WE Dublin CBD Frankfurt CBD<br />
9%<br />
8%<br />
7%<br />
Over the course of 2008 we have noticed a<br />
convergence in European yields. In Q3 2007 the yield<br />
gap between the lowest and the highest achievable<br />
prime yield across all sectors and markets of our<br />
survey area was ranging between 300 and 500 basis<br />
points, as the yield compression in some markets was<br />
very strong (eg London, Paris, Dublin, Madrid) while<br />
now it does not exceed 300 bp. Prime achievable<br />
yields (Q4 2008) are above 5.0% across all sectors,<br />
with the German markets being the most expensive<br />
and Istanbul the cheapest market across all sectors in<br />
our survey area. The UK has been one of the first<br />
markets to experience a fast and significant yield<br />
decompression, being a highly leveraged and<br />
transparent market.<br />
6%<br />
5%<br />
4%<br />
3%<br />
2004 Q1<br />
Q2<br />
Q3<br />
Source: Savills<br />
Q4<br />
2005 Q1<br />
Q2<br />
Q3<br />
Q4<br />
2006 Q1<br />
Q2<br />
Q3<br />
Q4<br />
2007 Q1<br />
Q2<br />
Q3<br />
Q4<br />
2008 Q1<br />
Q2<br />
Q3<br />
Q4<br />
European Investment Bulletin - Spring 2009 3
Outlook<br />
Currently the risk premium for prime CBD offices over<br />
the long term interest rates in the office markets shown<br />
in the table on the right has risen to 150bp compared<br />
to 50bp at the height of the capital markets in 2007.<br />
However, it is still lower compared to the previous<br />
slump of investor confidence in 2003, when the risk<br />
premium had risen to an average of 210bp for these<br />
markets. The current economic outlook is worse than<br />
in 2003, when the major economies of the world<br />
avoided recession and recovered quite quickly. Under<br />
the current conditions investors may continue to apply<br />
a higher risk premium until the first signs of economic<br />
recovery become apparent. The only markets where<br />
the risk premium for prime offices has exceeded the<br />
last high level are London West End, Dublin and<br />
Madrid implying that yield decompression in these<br />
markets may be closer to an end.<br />
When we compare current achievable prime office<br />
yields with the 10 year historic averages, we notice<br />
that <strong>Amsterdam</strong> and Brussels CBD yields are still<br />
below the historic average, which could imply that<br />
these markets may still experience some further yield<br />
softening, while London WE, Madrid and Paris are<br />
above their respective long term averages, which<br />
reflects investor concerns for the exposure of these<br />
markets to the financial crisis.<br />
Outlook<br />
The outlook for the real economy and the impact on<br />
the fundamentals of the property market on the one<br />
hand and the future of the banking sector and the<br />
impact on lending activity and market liquidity on the<br />
other will be the main determinants for the European<br />
property investment market for 2009. Following a<br />
difficult second half of 2008, our economists expect all<br />
major European economies to continue to contract<br />
significantly until the second half of 2009. UK,<br />
Germany, Italy and Spain are likely to see GDP fall by<br />
2%, with France only a little better, contracting by<br />
1.6%. Job losses will be widespread, pushing<br />
Eurozone unemployment towards 10%. Central and<br />
Eastern European economies are also going to<br />
experience subdued growth.<br />
Risk premium over long term interest rates for<br />
prime office properties<br />
(in basis points)<br />
Sources: Savills, European Commission<br />
*2003 for most markets<br />
**for 3/6/9 year leases<br />
Current and long term average prime office yield<br />
7.0%<br />
10 year<br />
average<br />
risk<br />
premium<br />
Current prime office CBD yield<br />
Last<br />
highest<br />
risk<br />
premium*<br />
10 year average prime office yield<br />
Current<br />
risk<br />
premium<br />
London West End 0 100 120<br />
Paris CBD 90 190 160<br />
Madrid CBD 80 160 180<br />
Frankfurt CBD 80 200 120<br />
Brussels CBD** 180 260 170<br />
Milan CBD 110 220 140<br />
<strong>Amsterdam</strong> CBD 220 310 160<br />
Stockholm CBD 90 200 160<br />
Dublin CBD 30 130 170<br />
These conditions are expected to have a negative<br />
impact on the occupational markets, which should be<br />
led by consolidation and rationalisation, thus leading to<br />
lower net absorption rates. Although new<br />
developments are being put on hold, the development<br />
pipeline in the office and retail sectors in particular,<br />
should put some further pressure on rents. Following<br />
the decompression of yields during the course of 2008,<br />
property is beginning to look better value relative to<br />
the peak of the capital markets cycle, especially where<br />
re-pricing has been stronger such as in the office<br />
markets of London, Paris, Madrid and Dublin. London<br />
in particular, due to the exchange rate is even more<br />
attractively priced in terms of Euro currency.<br />
6.5%<br />
6.0%<br />
5.5%<br />
5.0%<br />
4.5%<br />
4.0%<br />
3.5%<br />
3.0%<br />
London WE<br />
Source: Savills<br />
Paris<br />
Madrid<br />
Frankfurt<br />
Brussels<br />
Milan<br />
<strong>Amsterdam</strong><br />
Stockholm<br />
Dublin<br />
European Investment Bulletin - Spring-2009 4
Outlook<br />
In order to assess the current pricing levels we should<br />
also take into consideration the local market<br />
fundamentals, as these cities’ economies are likely to<br />
suffer more during the downturn. According to Oxford<br />
Economics economic activity in the international financial<br />
centres is driven by a mixture of domestic demand and<br />
the impact of world credit and investment cycles on<br />
financial services activity. As both are expected to<br />
contract sharply in 2009, most major cities, including<br />
Frankfurt, London, Madrid and Stockholm, are expected<br />
to see sharper than average contractions in GDP.<br />
However, experience of past recessions suggests<br />
Europe’s largest cities should recover strongly over the<br />
medium to long term, supported by a favourable<br />
industrial mix, highly skilled workforce and strong<br />
connectivity to global markets.<br />
The other major driver of the property investment market<br />
is the cost and availability of capital. The latest ECB<br />
survey shows that credit conditions have been tightened<br />
by euro-zone lenders during the course of 2008 and the<br />
majority expects to tighten them further. Less available<br />
debt should keep the investment markets subdued and<br />
lead to lower capital values as potential buyers will have<br />
to use higher levels of equity. Opportunities may arise<br />
from distressed or highly leveraged investors and<br />
developers who acquired assets at the top of the market.<br />
Tighter financing conditions may also lead to some sale<br />
and leaseback deals. Although some forced sales may<br />
be inevitable under the current circumstances, it is<br />
apparent that in many cases the banks are renegotiating<br />
the terms of their loans with property owners, especially<br />
those clients with a good track record. By doing this they<br />
avoid taking back properties they have no desire to<br />
manage and forced sales are thereby avoided. This is<br />
especially the case with large unwieldy portfolios.<br />
Opportunity funds, national institutional investors, private<br />
investors for small lot sizes and selective german open<br />
ended and spezial funds, are expected to be the main<br />
types of buyers in 2009. National investors account for<br />
an increasing share of transactions over cross-border<br />
investors. High quality assets, in terms of location, tenant<br />
covenant and lease terms, at attractive pricing are the<br />
main targets, at the expense of secondary properties<br />
and locations. Secure, long term defensive income is<br />
key in the current market conditions. According to the<br />
IPD data even for the past five years that the markets<br />
experienced a strong yield compression, the main<br />
component of total returns in the European markets was<br />
income return.<br />
The negative economic outlook and the uncertainty in<br />
the interbank market keep the investment market<br />
inactive indicting that yields can soften further in 2009<br />
especially for secondary assets with shorter leases.<br />
Based on the falling trend of base rates and government<br />
bond yields, which can be used as the main indicators of<br />
the direction that property yields can go, we can<br />
anticipate at least prime yield decompression to reach its<br />
bottom by the end of 2009, especially in markets that are<br />
ahead in the cycle, such as the office markets in the UK<br />
and France.<br />
Eurozone GDP growth and employment growth<br />
3%<br />
2%<br />
1%<br />
0%<br />
-1%<br />
-2%<br />
Source: European Commission<br />
Forecasts for selected European cities 2012 - 2020<br />
4.0%<br />
3.5%<br />
3.0%<br />
2.5%<br />
2.0%<br />
1.5%<br />
1.0%<br />
0.5%<br />
0.0%<br />
2004<br />
2005<br />
Source: Oxford Economics<br />
IPD average annual office returns (5 year)<br />
10.0%<br />
9.0%<br />
8.0%<br />
7.0%<br />
6.0%<br />
5.0%<br />
4.0%<br />
3.0%<br />
2.0%<br />
1.0%<br />
0.0%<br />
-1.0%<br />
-2.0%<br />
-3.0%<br />
-4.0%<br />
-5.0%<br />
London WE<br />
Brussels<br />
Paris CBD<br />
Paris<br />
Sources: Experian, IPD<br />
GDP growth<br />
2006<br />
GDP growth City<br />
Madrid<br />
Frankfurt<br />
2007<br />
Capital value growth<br />
Frankfurt<br />
Berlin<br />
Dublin<br />
Employment growth<br />
Brussels<br />
2008<br />
GDP growth National<br />
Milan<br />
Income return<br />
Milan<br />
<strong>Amsterdam</strong><br />
2009<br />
Madrid<br />
<strong>Amsterdam</strong><br />
Stockholm<br />
2010<br />
Stockholm<br />
London WE<br />
European Investment Bulletin - Spring 2009 5
Summary table (Q4 2008)<br />
City Prime CBD offices Prime warehouses Prime shopping centres<br />
Yield Rental growth Yield Rental growth Yield Rental growth<br />
<strong>Amsterdam</strong> 5.75% -1.3% 7.5% 0.0% 6.5% 0.0%<br />
Athens 7.0% 0.0% 8.25% 0.0% 6.75% -12.0%<br />
Barcelona 6.0% -5.6% 7.25% -2.9% 6.5% 0.0%<br />
Brussels 6.0% -3.4% 6.5% 0.0% 6.0% 0.0%<br />
Dublin 6.0% -19.7% 7.0% 0.0% N/A N/A<br />
Frankfurt 5.3% 5.5% 6.8% 0.0% 5.6% N/A<br />
Istanbul 7.75% 0.0% 8.25% -2.7% 7.5% -25.0%<br />
Lisbon 6.5% 0.0% 7.75% -0.8% 6.0% 0.0%<br />
London, City 6.75% -27.6% N/A N/A 7.0% 0.0%<br />
London, West End 5.75% -27.8% N/A N/A 7.0% 0.0%<br />
Madrid 6.0% -9.5% 7.25% N/A 6.5% 0.0%<br />
Milan 5.85% 8.7% 6.7% 3.3% 6.0% 0.0%<br />
Munich 4.5% 3.6% N/A N/A 5.0% N/A<br />
Oslo 6.75% -8.8% 7.6% 0.0% 7.2% -11.2%<br />
Paris 5.75% -6.4% 8.0% -1.9% 5.25% 0.0%<br />
Rome 6.0% 0.0% 7.25% -20.0% 6.75% 0.0%<br />
Stockholm 5.5% 0.0% 7.0% 0.0% 5.5% 2.2%<br />
Warsaw 5.75% -14.3% 7.5% 6.5% 6.75% -14.3%<br />
Note 1: All costs are in €/sqm/year<br />
Note 2: Prime offices refer to modern, minimum 1,000sqm, fully let, standard leased building<br />
Note 3: Prime warehouses refer to modern properties, minimum 10,000sqm<br />
Note 4: Prime shopping centre rental growth refers to a standard unit in a prime regional shopping centre<br />
Note 5: Athens, Dublin, London and Stockholm yields are quoted ‘Net’<br />
For further information please contact<br />
Giles Wilcox<br />
European Investment<br />
+44 20 7409 8864<br />
gwilcox@savills.com<br />
Lydia Brissy<br />
European Research<br />
+44 20 7016 3776<br />
lbrissy@savills.com<br />
Eri Mitsostergiou<br />
European Research<br />
+30 210 6996311<br />
emitso@savills.com<br />
Savills plc is a leading international property services company with a full listing on the London Stock Exchange. The company has undergone<br />
dynamic growth in recent years establishing itself as a powerful player on the international stage with offices and associates throughout the UK,<br />
Europe, Asia Pacific and Africa. In addition, Savills is the trading name for the property service subsidiaries of Savills plc which advise on commercial,<br />
rural, residential and leisure property. Other services include corporate finance advice, property and venture capital funding and a range of property<br />
related financial services.<br />
This bulletin is for general informative purposes only. Whilst every effort has been made to ensure its accuracy, Savills accepts no liability whatsoever<br />
for any direct or consequential loss arising from its use. The bulletin is strictly copyright and reproduction of the whole or part of it in any form is<br />
prohibited without written permission from Savills Research. (c) Savills Ltd February 2009