07.10.2015 Views

mmbackgrounder

  • No tags were found...

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Introduction<br />

Bon Secours Richmond Health System<br />

Bon Secours and the Redskins Name Change<br />

The Bon Secours Richmond Health System is a system of doctors, hospitals and long­term care<br />

facilities dedicated to serving the people of Richmond. Bon Secours was started by the Sisters of<br />

Bon Secours during the French Revolution. Soon after, the Sisters of Bon Secours came to the<br />

United States where they focused on providing care to the poor and sick. Bon Secours Richmond<br />

Health System began expanding with the opening of St. Mary’s Hospital in 1966. Currently, Bon<br />

Secours operates four hospitals as well as a college of nursing, a school of medical imaging and<br />

two family practice residency programs. Bon Secours is the only not for profit health system in<br />

Richmond, helping those in need regardless of ability to pay.<br />

Bon Secours Richmond Health System and The Redskins<br />

In 2012, Bon Secours Richmond Health System partnered with the Redskins to bring the team,<br />

and fans, to Richmond. Hourigan Construction worked with Bon Secours and the Redskins to<br />

draw up plans for a state­of­the­art training center that houses the summer training camp for the<br />

team. In addition to the football training camp, the center houses a sports medicine and men’s<br />

health clinic open to all men. The Redskins training camp draws fans to Richmond for a three<br />

week period each summer to watch the team practice for the upcoming season.<br />

The Issue<br />

In 2013, controversy over the Redskins’ name resurfaced in the first major initiative aimed at<br />

changing the name since 1999. Many fans, activists, and media outlets believe that the Redskins<br />

name is an offensive racial slur towards Native Americans. Some have insisted that the Redskins<br />

change their name to something more neutral to avoid offending anyone. The owner of the<br />

Redskins has publicly said that he will not change the name, maintaining that he believes the<br />

name honors Native Americans. Currently, the name remains the same, but some media outlets<br />

have recently said they will not use the name ‘Redskins’ in any broadcast or article. A decision<br />

about the issue has not been reached, and both sides of the argument continue to maintain their<br />

position.<br />

Timeline of the Redskins’ Name Controversy<br />

1972​: 11 representatives of Native American organizations come together and present<br />

Edward Bennett Williams, president of the Redskins, a list of demands, including,<br />

“change the ‘derogatory racial epithet, Redskins.’”


1972: ​Williams says the team will remain “The Redskins.”<br />

1992:​About 2,000 people protest the Redskins at the 1992 Super Bowl.<br />

1999: ​Trademark Trial and Appeal Board judges cancel federal registration of the<br />

Redskins name.<br />

2013:​Smithsonian’s National Museum of the American Indian holds an event on the<br />

Redskins name change.<br />

2013: ​The Oneida Indian Nation of New York uses radio ads in cities where the Redskins<br />

play to encourage name change.<br />

2014​: TTAB judes again cancel six trademarks held by the Redskins.<br />

Bon Secours Redskins Training Camp Statistics<br />

●​ ​The training camp center was completed in 2013.<br />

●​ ​The cost of building the facility was $10 million.<br />

●​ ​Bon Secours paid $3.2 million for naming rights to the facility.<br />

●​ ​The facility will generate an expected $8.5 million annually.<br />

●​ ​The training center generated $40 million in new private investment in the city of Richmond.<br />

●​ ​In its first year, the training camp broke the NFL training camp attendance record with more<br />

than 165,000 fans attending.<br />

●​ ​The center contains a men’s health and sports medicine clinic that is open to the public.<br />

●​ ​A tent on the training camp grounds sells Redskins merchandise to fans.<br />

●​ ​Bon Secours invested in advertising on all platforms that includes the unique Redskins­Bon<br />

Secours logo.<br />

Possible Outcomes<br />

●​ ​The Redskins change their name as many groups are insisting. Bon Secours rebrands the training<br />

center and any advertisements that include the Redskins’ name or logo. Costs have not been<br />

analyzed, but will likely exceed $1 million.<br />

●​ ​The Redskins keep their name. Bon Secours keeps Redskins’ name and logo on the building and<br />

any advertisements.<br />

Public Opinion and Polls


●​ ​23% of Americans think the name should be changed, compared to the 8% in 1992, and up nine<br />

percentage points in the last year alone.<br />

●​ ​Of 1,019 Americans polled in Aug. 2014, 71% think the name should be kept, which is down<br />

from 89% in 1992.<br />

●​ ​68% think the name is not disrespectful towards Native Americans.<br />

●​ ​9% say the name is “a lot” disrespectful to Native Americans.<br />

●​ ​54% think the name is unlikely to be changed.<br />

●​ ​42% think the name will be changed<br />

●​ ​4% have no opinion on the likelihood of the name change<br />

●​ ​In a non scientific poll of NFL players, 58% of players believe the name should not be changed,<br />

while 42% think the name should be changed.<br />

●​ ​In a survey of 51 Redskins players, 26 said the name should be changed and 24 did not want to<br />

answer.<br />

●​ ​89% of Republicans and 88% of people who consider themselves conservative think the name<br />

should not be changed.<br />

●​ ​58% of Democrats and 53% of people who consider themselves liberal think the name should<br />

not be changed.<br />

●​ ​83% of Republicans, 68% of independents, and 57% of Democrats see no disrespect in the<br />

name.<br />

●​ ​In 2004, a poll of 768 people who consider themselves Native American found that 90% said the<br />

name did not bother them.<br />

●​ ​Former Attorney General Eric Holder, Senator Harry Reid and former Secretary of State Hillary<br />

Clinton have urged Dan Snyder to change the name.<br />

Summary<br />

Bon Secours Richmond Health System’s Redskins Training Camp is a state­of­the­art facility<br />

that draws fans to Richmond, creates business and provides health services to men. The<br />

controversy over the name could impact various corporate sponsors of the team, including Bon<br />

Secours. The effect on Bon Secours Richmond Health System would be strictly related to<br />

business.<br />

Sources<br />

"Bon Secours Washington Redskins Training Center | Hourigan Construction." ​Bon Secours<br />

Washington Redskins Training Center​. Web. 15 Sept. 2014.


"Training Center Information | Redskins Training Camp 2013." ​Bon Secours Washington<br />

Redskins Training Center​. Web. 15 Sept. 2014.<br />

Fiske, Warren, and Nancy Madsen. "Mayor Jones Says Redskins Training Camp Deal."<br />

PolitiFact​. Richmond Times­Dispatch, 4 Mar. 2014. Web. 15 Sept. 2014.<br />

Cushing, Nathan. "A Look at the Redskins Summer Training Camp ­ RVANews." ​RVANews​.<br />

RVANews, 11 Feb. 2013. Web. 15 Sept. 2014.<br />

"Poll: 71 Percent Say Keep Redskins." ​ESPN​. ESPN Internet Ventures, 2 Sept. 2014. Web. 30<br />

Sept. 2014.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!