17.11.2015 Views

DRAFT

LowRise_Guidelines_Oct29_2015_ForPrint1

LowRise_Guidelines_Oct29_2015_ForPrint1

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Draft Oct 2015<br />

TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE<br />

APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

URBAN DESIGN<br />

GUIDELINES<br />

2015


TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

City of Toronto<br />

Townhouse and Low-rise Apartment Guidelines Core Team<br />

Harold Madi, Director of Urban Design<br />

Diana Birchall, Program Manager, Urban Design<br />

Leo DeSorcy<br />

Maaja Eichfus-Clarke<br />

Emilia Floro<br />

Victor Gottwald<br />

Anthony Hommik<br />

Jack Krubnik<br />

Mladen Kukic<br />

Peggy Lee<br />

Joseph luk<br />

Deanne Mighton<br />

James Parakh<br />

Xue Pei<br />

Andrea Reaney<br />

Allison Reid<br />

Michael Sakalauskas<br />

Derrick Wong<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

Townhouse and Low-rise Apartment Guidelines online:<br />

www.toronto.ca/lowriseguidelines


Table of Contents<br />

Introduction<br />

Background – Evolution of the Townhouse in Toronto<br />

Definitions<br />

Zoning<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

By-law 569-2013<br />

Purpose of the Guidelines<br />

How and Where the Guidelines Apply<br />

Guilding Principles<br />

Quality of Life and Livability<br />

Design Excellence<br />

Sustainable Design<br />

Heritage Conservation<br />

Organization of Guidelines<br />

1.1 Context Analysis and Planning for Larger Sites<br />

1.2 Public Realm Framework<br />

1.2.1 Street and Block Pattern<br />

1.2.2 Public Parks and Open Spaces<br />

1.3 Heritage<br />

2.1 Streets, Mews and Walkways<br />

2.2 Shared Outdoor Amenity Space<br />

2.3 Building Placement<br />

2.4 Building Address<br />

2.5 Site Servicing, Access and Parking<br />

2.5.1 Site Servicing, Access and Parking for Smaller Street-Related Townhouse Sites<br />

3.1 Fit and Transition in Scale<br />

3.2 Separation Distances, Stepbacks and Orientation<br />

3.3 Building Relationship to Grade and Street<br />

3.4 Building Entrance and Front Yard<br />

3.5 Private Outdoor Amenity Space<br />

1.0 Site Context<br />

2.0 Site Organization<br />

3.0 Building Design<br />

TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES


4.0 Public Realm<br />

TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

4.1 Streetscape, Landscape and Stormwater Management<br />

4.1.1 Streetscape<br />

4.1.2 Landscape<br />

4.1.3 Stormwater Management<br />

4.2 Site Elements Design<br />

4.3.1 Lighting<br />

4.3.2 Shared Facilities<br />

4.3 Building Elements<br />

4.5.1 Windows, Doors and Roofs<br />

4.5.2 Materials<br />

4.4 Public Art<br />

5.0 Bringing it all Together<br />

5.1 Building Types and Configurations<br />

5.1.1 Townhouse<br />

5.1.2 Stacked Townhouse<br />

5.1.3 Back to Back Townhouse<br />

5.1.4 Stacked and Back to Back Townhouse<br />

5.1.5 Apartment Building<br />

5.1.6 Hybrid Building<br />

5.2 Development Scenarios<br />

5.2.1 Shallow Mid-Block Parcel<br />

6.0 Case Studies<br />

5.2.2 Deep Mid-Block Parcel<br />

5.2.3 Parcel Adjacent to or with Heritage Resource<br />

5.2.4 Parcel with Multiple Building Blocks<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

5.2.5 Large Parcel with Tower and Neighbourhood Edge<br />

5.2.6 Large Development with multiple Development Blocks<br />

7.0 Glossary


Introduction<br />

Background – Evolution of the Townhouse in Toronto<br />

Definitions<br />

Zoning By-law 569-2013<br />

Purpose of the Guidelines<br />

How and Where the Guidelines Apply<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

Guiding Principles<br />

Quality of Life and Livability<br />

Design Excellence<br />

Sustainable Design<br />

Heritage Conservation<br />

Organization of Guidelines<br />

INTRODUCTION | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

Credit: Quadrangle Architects Limited<br />

5


INTRODUCTION | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

Introduction<br />

To assist with the implementation of Official Plan policies<br />

and provide specific design direction, the City of Toronto has<br />

developed city-wide "Townhouse and Low-rise Apartment<br />

Guidelines". The purpose of the guidelines is to assist in<br />

achieving the appropriate design of low-rise (primarily<br />

residential) buildings for a range of building types from<br />

townhouses, through to stacked and back-to-back townhouses<br />

and low-rise apartment buildings up to 4 storeys in height. The<br />

Guidelines will build upon and replace the "Infill Townhouse<br />

Guidelines" (2003) which have been in use by the City of<br />

Toronto for over 10 years. They will address infill townhouse<br />

developments as well as developments on larger sites and the<br />

more complex and intense types of low-rise, multi-unit housing<br />

in terms of: site context; site organization; building massing;<br />

detailed design, and the semi-private and public realms.<br />

BACKGROUND – EVOLUTION OF THE TOWNHOUSE<br />

IN TORONTO<br />

The City of Toronto has a long, rich history of townhouse or<br />

row house development. Traditional Toronto townhouses<br />

are generally 2 ½ to 3 ½ storeys high and are typically of a<br />

Georgian, Victorian, Edwardian or Arts and Crafts character.<br />

Townhouses of this nature have been a common and successful<br />

form of residential development since the mid-1800's.<br />

In the post-war period, townhouses were developed in new lot<br />

and block configurations of grade-related housing, promoted<br />

by the Canadian Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC) as<br />

good for families. Typically these were laid out on large blocks<br />

near higher density forms of housing, schools and shopping<br />

centres. They were often rental housing with the site remaining<br />

in private ownership. This type of townhouse was organized<br />

around private streets or pedestrian mews. Vehicle parking was<br />

accommodated in small parking lots at the edges of the site or<br />

integral to the townhouse with access gained from a private<br />

street.<br />

Over time, new types of housing units emerged within the<br />

townhouse form that introduced new relationships between the<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

individual unit, vertical circulation and grade.<br />

In the early years of amalgamation, the City of Toronto<br />

introduced the “Infill Townhouse Guidelines” (2003) to<br />

help assess the large and growing volume of townhouse<br />

development applications on small, infill sites. The infill<br />

guidelines responded to, among other things, the decline in the<br />

quality of streetscapes by the erosion of areas for landscaping<br />

and street trees created by the market for narrow frontage<br />

towns with integral front parking and garages.<br />

6CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

Cabbage Town Townhouse<br />

The City’s Official Plan, which was approved by Council in<br />

2002, requires new developments to take their address and<br />

access from public streets. To support this policy goal, Council<br />

adopted, in 2005, the Development Infrastructure Policy &<br />

Standards (DIPS). The DIPS standards place limits on the<br />

creation and design of private residential streets and establish<br />

clear directions for the layout and design of new public<br />

residential streets.


Example of low-rise buidlings in the form of garden apartments/courtyard walk-ups.<br />

Since the adoption of these earlier standards, the demand for<br />

low-rise grade related housing has remained strong. Over<br />

the past ten years, land and construction prices have risen.<br />

Increasingly, townhouses and low-rise multi-unit residential<br />

buildings are now being constructed on large sites with<br />

underground parking garages. These larger sites are often<br />

found at the edges of "tower in the park" apartment areas and<br />

on lands being converted from employment and institutional<br />

uses. As well, low-rise residential intensification continues to<br />

take place on smaller infill sites. There has evolved, along with<br />

the conventional townhouse, a variety of taller, denser and<br />

more complex forms of multi-unit, low-rise housing. (see below<br />

for a description of types).<br />

Townhouses and low-rise buildings are common in many parts of the City.<br />

The “Infill Townhouse Guidelines” (2003), which speak to<br />

townhouse developments on public streets and short private<br />

mews, and the DIPS (2005) standards for new residential<br />

streets fail to cover some of the more pressing questions of<br />

organization and fit that arise in many of today's development<br />

applications. The Guidelines in this document have been<br />

developed to ensure that the wider range of planning<br />

considerations presented by the current forms of low-rise<br />

residential intensification are fully addressed. The objectives<br />

of the Guidelines are to produce building designs and<br />

development layouts that reflect the broader land use planning<br />

goals of the Official Plan and which, in the process, create an<br />

attractive public realm and comfortable private living spaces of<br />

the highest achievable quality.<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

INTRODUCTION | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

Spruce Court Apartments (completed in the 1920s), is one of the earliest examples of publically supported, affordable, Low-Rise Multi Unit Housing in Toronto. The "Garden City" influence is<br />

prevalent through the use of large grassy, sunlit, courtyards and play areas which were accessible to all units. (Photo Credit: Spruce Court c1920, City of Toronto Archives, Fonds 1244, Item 43.)<br />

7


INTRODUCTION | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

8CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

DEFINITIONS<br />

Low-rise, multi-unit residential buildings take many forms:<br />

Townhouses are generally 2 to 3 1/2-storey structures that<br />

share a sidewall with a neighbouring unit and have at least three<br />

housing bays. They typically have a front and a back.<br />

Stacked Townhouses share a sidewall and have units stacked<br />

vertically (typically two or three). Like the townhouse type they<br />

have a front and a back.<br />

Back to Back Townhouses share a rear wall as well as a<br />

sidewall and have two fronts. Each unit has its own entrance to<br />

grade.<br />

Stacked, Back to Back Townhouses share a rear wall as well<br />

as a sidewall and have units stacked vertically. This can include<br />

three units located on top of each other, two-level units stacked<br />

on top of one-level units, or two-level units stacked on top of<br />

two-level units. Other layout solutions may be possible. Each<br />

unit has its own entrance to grade.<br />

Low-rise Apartment Buildings are less than 4 storeys high and<br />

share interior corridors, vertical circulation and entrances, and<br />

have multiple units stacked vertically. Typically units are located<br />

on both sides of a corridor (double-loaded) and, sometimes,<br />

only on one side of a corridor (single-loaded).<br />

Hybrid Buildings combine lower units with direct access to<br />

grade as well as upper units that gain access from a shared<br />

corridor, vertical circulation and entrance.<br />

The types of residential units described above are typically<br />

constructed in rows or blocks. The Official Plan allows these<br />

residential forms in lands with Mixed Use, Regeneration and<br />

Apartment Neighbourhoods designations. They often fit<br />

under the four-storey height limit for residential development<br />

in designated Neighbourhood areas but policies regarding<br />

neighbourhood fit may impose restrictions. It is important<br />

that the more intensive forms of low-rise, multi-unit<br />

residential development fit harmoniously within the existing<br />

neighbourhood context. (See Section 5 – Bringing It All<br />

Together for more detail on the various types of low-rise, multiunit<br />

residential buildings).<br />

Zoning By-law 569-2013<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

Townhouse and Low-rise Apartment buildings take many<br />

forms, but can generally be understood as predominantly<br />

residential buildings, up to four storeys tall.<br />

The City-wide Comprehensive Zoning By-law 569-2013, as<br />

amended, defines and regulates residential building types within<br />

zone categories. Residential building types set out in the Bylaw<br />

that relate to the scope of these Guidelines mainly include<br />

Townhouse and Apartment Buildings and to a lesser degree<br />

Triplexes and Fouplexes<br />

"Back-to-Back" and "Stacked Townhouses" are not defined<br />

residential building types in Zoning By-law 569-2013. However,<br />

these popular design and marketing terms are commonly used<br />

when reviewing development applications to better describe the<br />

types of units and building configurations seen within the lowrise<br />

"Apartment Building" typology.


PURPOSE OF GUIDELINES<br />

The purpose of the “Townhouse and Low-rise Apartment<br />

Guidelines” is to replace the “Infill Townhouse Guidelines”<br />

(2003) and to illustrate how the public realm and built form<br />

policy objectives of the Official Plan can be addressed by:<br />

• Identifying strategies to enhance the quality of the living<br />

environment through improved spatial relationships,<br />

design and materials<br />

• Establishing a balance between the protection of stable<br />

residential neighbourhoods and heritage features<br />

while allowing for appropriate infill development and<br />

intensification.<br />

• Providing best practices for use by stakeholders,<br />

particularly land developers, architects, and landscape<br />

architects, and to provide guidance to municipal planners<br />

in effectively evaluating the acceptability of an application<br />

HOW AND WHERE THE GUIDELINES APPLY<br />

The City of Toronto Official Plan seeks to direct and manage<br />

growth city-wide and managing change is different in different<br />

parts of the City. While the Official Plan directs major and<br />

sustained incremental growth to the City’s Centres, Avenues,<br />

Employment Districts and the Downtown, fully three-quarters<br />

of the City’s land area is taken up by watercourses, ravines,<br />

parks and neighbourhoods where little growth is intended to<br />

take place. As they evolve and change, these stable residential<br />

neighbourhoods will continue to experience modest physical<br />

change. Low-rise, multi-unit buildings will often be located<br />

adjacent to and sometimes within stable residential areas and<br />

as such, it is important to ensure that new development will<br />

enhance and fit within the local area context.<br />

The “Townhouse and Low-rise Apartment Guidelines” apply<br />

to the design, review, and approval of new low-rise, multi-unit<br />

building developments that are 4 storeys or less. The Guidelines<br />

will normally be applied through the evaluation of development<br />

proposals and design alternatives in Official Plan Amendments,<br />

Zoning By-law Amendments, Plans of Subdivision, and Site<br />

Plan Control applications. The Guidelines are intended to be<br />

read together with the relevant Official Plan policies, applicable<br />

Zoning By-laws, Secondary Plans, Heritage Conservation<br />

District Plans, the Toronto Green Standard, the Toronto<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

Development Guide, as well as any other applicable regulations,<br />

policies and guidelines.<br />

The Guidelines are intended to provide a degree of certainty and<br />

clarity of common interpretation. Each guideline requirement<br />

should be weighed across the board with the other guidelines<br />

and "work together" to determine whether a development<br />

application has successfully met the overall intent of these<br />

Guidelines and the Official Plan. However, when implementing<br />

the Guidelines, it is important to recognize that exceptions<br />

may sometimes be warranted and that at times a project<br />

that strives for excellence in design can demonstrate that a<br />

particular guideline is not appropriate in that instance. It is the<br />

responsibility of the designer/developer/builder to demonstrate<br />

to the City where such an exception exists and it as at the<br />

discretion of the City to support or not support a justification. In<br />

cases where the City requires further review of applications, the<br />

City’s Design Review Panel may assist in the process.<br />

9<br />

INTRODUCTION | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES


INTRODUCTION | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

10<br />

GUIDING PRINCIPLES<br />

The guidelines are based on the following guiding principles<br />

which build on and will help implement policies and directions<br />

from the City's Official Plan:<br />

1. Protect and enhance significant natural and man-made<br />

features such as mature vegetation, topography, heritage<br />

structures and open spaces.<br />

2. Create high quality public and private realm on sites<br />

that connect with local streets, parks and open spaces,<br />

community and retail services.<br />

3. Encourage active living with a safe, comfortable, accessible,<br />

vibrant and attractive public realm.<br />

4. Promote harmonious fit and compatibility with the existing<br />

and planned context through appropriate scale, placement,<br />

setbacks and visual relationships.<br />

5. Ensure a high quality living environment through excellent<br />

architecture, landscape and urban design.<br />

6. Ensure good living conditions, including access to public<br />

and private open space, sunlight, natural ventilation and<br />

privacy for building occupants.<br />

7. Minimize the impact of service areas and elements on the<br />

public realm.<br />

The substance of the Guidelines was informed by an inventory<br />

of relevant past planning applications, site tours, selected case<br />

studies and a review of best practices. This brought to light<br />

a number of key issues that require particular attention when<br />

considering development applications for townhouses and lowrise<br />

apartments, including:<br />

• improving the “fit” and transition with existing<br />

neighbourhoods and, at a smaller scale, the transition<br />

from the public realm (streets, parks and other open<br />

spaces) to the private realm (front yards, private amenity<br />

spaces and entrances)<br />

• ensuring more generous separation distances between<br />

facing units to allow for adequate access to sunlight and<br />

sky view and an appropriate level of privacy<br />

• avoiding situations where front yards face back yards or<br />

where backyards face the street<br />

• imposing adequate setback requirements to enable<br />

suitable areas for soft landscaping and to provide<br />

sufficient soil for trees to be planted and flourish<br />

• ensuring the adequate provision of safe and attractive<br />

parks, accessible open space and walkways as community<br />

focal points and, where appropriate, integrating these<br />

spaces into a larger network of streets, parks and other<br />

community spaces such as school yards<br />

• maximizing the usability, comfort and appearance of front<br />

yards and building entrances (porches and stoops) and<br />

private outdoor amenity spaces (balconies and terraces)<br />

while minimizing the negative impacts of overlook on<br />

public and private realms<br />

• improving the overall quality of design in terms of<br />

site layout, architecture and landscaping, with the<br />

accompanying use of higher quality materials<br />

• ensuring servicing activities (such as vehicle parking,<br />

garbage storage and collection, loading, utility meters and<br />

drop-off areas) are located underground, internally or to<br />

the rear of the building away from the public realm and<br />

public view<br />

• relating developments directly to the existing or “natural”<br />

grade and avoiding the creation of artificial grades.<br />

QUALITY OF LIFE AND LIVABILITY<br />

Many aspects of urban design and approaches to city form are<br />

based on the concept of livability. These approaches recognize<br />

that design and structure can be very influential in the life of<br />

a town or city and the building of community. Part of what<br />

makes Toronto livable is access to a wide array of amenities<br />

and attractions, including natural areas in the city, cultural<br />

and social events, urban parks, the urban tree canopy, vibrant<br />

districts and unique, thriving neighborhoods. As our City grows<br />

and matures, we need to create a more beautiful environment,<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

healthy and vibrant communities and greater prosperity by<br />

making choices that improve our quality of life. This includes a<br />

focus on neighborhoods and main streets, so that everyone has<br />

access within biking or walking distance of the basic services<br />

and amenities offered in the City’s most livable neighborhoods.<br />

DESIGN EXCELLENCE<br />

Low-rise, multi- unit buildings have an important role in<br />

defining the image of Toronto and should embody design<br />

excellence and innovation. Urban design excellence in the<br />

spaces and quality of shared public spaces, landscape and<br />

architectural design includes the effective use of resources,<br />

high-quality materials, innovative building and landscape<br />

design and construction, as well as a sensitive and thoughtful<br />

response to context and the impacts of the development.


SUSTAINABLE DESIGN<br />

Sustainable design is an approach to developing sites and<br />

buildings to be less resource intensive and to improve the<br />

economic, social, and natural environment we live in. Low-rise,<br />

multi-unit developments should demonstrate a heightened<br />

awareness of green innovation and accomplish sustainable<br />

linkages between good urban design, architecture, and<br />

landscape.<br />

There are technical aspects relating to building performance,<br />

materials and construction methods, water management,<br />

landscaping, and the quality of the internal environment. There<br />

are also site and building design measures, including organizing<br />

buildings for maximum passive solar gain, which can be<br />

applied to improve the sustainability and energy performance<br />

of buildings. Sustainable design should be identified at the<br />

project’s initial or site planning stage when fundamental<br />

design decisions are being made. By following an integrated<br />

design process and ensuring that all design and construction<br />

disciplines are involved from the beginning, low-rise, multi-unit<br />

buildings can achieve better overall performance results.<br />

The City of Toronto both requires and encourages sustainable<br />

design through the Official Plan and the Toronto Green<br />

Standard (TGS). The TGS sets out performance measures for<br />

buildings and sites and specifies strategies that can be used to<br />

achieve cost effective, environmentally and socially responsible<br />

end results. Planning applications submitted since January<br />

2014 in the City of Toronto must meet Tier 1 of the Toronto<br />

Green Standard (TGS) performance measures.<br />

Applicants are also required to adhere to the City of Toronto<br />

Wet Weather Flow Management Policy which provides direction<br />

on how to manage wet weather flow on a watershed basis.<br />

HERITAGE CONSERVATION<br />

The City of Toronto values its heritage properties and requires<br />

that they be protected and that new development conserve<br />

the integrity of their cultural heritage value, attributes, and<br />

character, consistent with accepted principles of good heritage<br />

conservation.<br />

Sustainable design solutions are integrated into the landscape design. Credit: PWL<br />

Partnership Landscape Architect Inc.<br />

areas with a concentration of heritage properties and distinct<br />

historic character. The character and values of HCDs will be<br />

conserved to ensure that their significance is not diminished by<br />

incremental or sweeping change.<br />

There are heritage properties that can work in harmony with<br />

new development. In these cases, development should strive<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

for the long term protection, integration, and re-use of heritage<br />

properties. Heritage properties should be used to inform the<br />

scale and contextual treatment of the new development. If welldesigned<br />

and sited in appropriate locations, low-rise, multi-unit<br />

buildings can make a positive contribution within historical<br />

settings.<br />

INTRODUCTION | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

Low-rise buildings must be compatible with conserving<br />

heritage properties on or adjacent to a development site or<br />

within a Heritage Conservation District (HCD). HCDs are special<br />

11


INTRODUCTION | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

ORGANIZATION OF THE GUIDELINES<br />

The Townhouse and Low-rise Building Guidelines are organized<br />

into the following sections:<br />

Introduction<br />

1.0 Site Context<br />

2.0 Site Organization<br />

3.0 Building Massing and Design<br />

4.0 Pedestrian Realm – Creating Pride in Place<br />

5.0 Bringing It All Together - Building Types and<br />

Development Scenarios<br />

6.0 Apendices + Case Studies<br />

7.0 Glossary<br />

Appendix A – Case Studies<br />

Individual design guidelines with supporting illustrations, photos,<br />

rationales, and selected related references, such as Official Plan<br />

policies and TGS performance measures, are provided for each<br />

aspect of developments identified within sections 1.0 through 4.0.<br />

Section 5.0 provides descriptions of the building types covered<br />

by these Guidelines as well as demonstrations of how the various<br />

building types come together on sites with different conditions.<br />

Section 6.0 Case Studies provides some recent examples of mostly<br />

built projects across the City.<br />

Section 7.0 Grossary provides definitions to the terminology used<br />

within the Guidelines.<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

12


1.0 Site Context<br />

1.1 Context Analysis and Planning for Larger Sites<br />

1.2 Public Realm Framework<br />

1.2.1 Street and Block Patterns<br />

1.2.2 Public Parks and Open Spaces<br />

1.3 Heritage<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

SITE CONTEXT | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

13


1.1 CONTEXT ANALYSIS AND PLANNING FOR LARGER SITES<br />

SITE CONTEXT | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

14<br />

Evaluate the existing and planned context and demonstrate how the proposed<br />

development responds to this context. For larger sites with multiple buildings<br />

and the potential for new public realm elements, coordinate development through<br />

a Master Plan.<br />

a. Include a “Walkable” context analysis, showing the building<br />

proposal, and illustrating through text and graphics at an<br />

appropriate scale:<br />

• Official Plan land use designations and zoning<br />

permissions<br />

• 250m and 500m "walkability" radii from the site<br />

• major streets and blocks (patterns, size, location)<br />

• open space networks (parks, open space, natural<br />

features)<br />

• pedestrian/cycling routes and connections<br />

• transit routes, stations, and stops (including distance to<br />

rapid transit nodes)<br />

• area amenities and destinations (community centres,<br />

trails, libraries, schools, retail areas, etc.)<br />

• Diagrams of movement network(s) that give priority<br />

consideration to pedestrians<br />

b. Include in the Planning Rationale or application a “Block”<br />

context analysis, showing the proposal and illustrating<br />

through text and graphics at an appropriate scale:<br />

• size of blocks and arrangement of parcels or lots<br />

• location, size and organization of public streets, laneways,<br />

sidewalks, transit stops, and other pedestrian or cycling<br />

routes and connections<br />

• location and size of parks and open space if applicable<br />

• adjacent and on-site heritage properties and identified<br />

heritage views from the public realm if applicable<br />

• adjacent and on-site mature trees<br />

• existing topography and proposed grading on site and its<br />

relationship to adjacent sites and features<br />

• important or identified views from the public realm<br />

• existing and planned building footprints<br />

• ground floor uses, setbacks and general location of<br />

building entrances, street trees and site circulation/<br />

servicing on the development site and on adjacent sites<br />

• proposed building heights and separation distances<br />

and their relationship to the height of existing context<br />

buildings within the same block and/or across the street,<br />

as well as the relationship to open spaces<br />

• planned location and orientation of buildings, parks, and<br />

open space to maximize sunlight access, sky view, and<br />

energy efficiency<br />

• approach to providing building types with a range of<br />

housing options<br />

• approach to site and building environmental sustainability<br />

• for small infill developments, a "Block" context analysis<br />

may be sufficient<br />

c . For sites covering an area of one hectare or more, provide a<br />

Master Plan identifying the following aspects in addition to<br />

1.1(a) and (b) above:<br />

• a phasing plan, schedule and interim landscape plan<br />

where appropriate<br />

• a hierarchy of street and open space types with different<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

characteristics based on their importance regarding their<br />

role as a place and as part of the movement network<br />

• a community focal point(s) within the development that is<br />

easy to walk to for residents and which is integrated with<br />

other open spaces as part of a network<br />

• location of site servicing, vehicular circulation and major<br />

utility connections including shared systems such as<br />

vehicular circulation and district/community energy<br />

systems<br />

d. Development proposals on sites where the minimum<br />

building setbacks and stepbacks cannot be achieved and/<br />

or where the development cannot be successfully integrated<br />

into its context will require a redesign of the proposal<br />

to meet the minimum requirements contained in these<br />

guidelines.<br />

Continued on next page…


An illustration of a conceptual Master Plan<br />

for a larger development area containing<br />

multiple buildings, new streets and parks.<br />

New buildings are to<br />

consider context and provide<br />

appropriate transition to<br />

adjacent neighborhoods<br />

RATIONALE<br />

Context refers to the development site and the setting for that<br />

development, including both the existing physical surroundings<br />

and the planned vision for the future of the area. The planned<br />

context includes planning regulations that apply to the site,<br />

most notably the Official Plan land use designation(s) and<br />

zoning controls. The intent of the context analysis is to identify<br />

patterns, opportunities, and challenges and to demonstrate how<br />

the layout and design of the proposed development will fit with<br />

and respond appropriately to its context.<br />

The context analysis should inform many key design decisions:<br />

• Is the site one which will use existing street frontage to<br />

provide access and address for new buildings? Or is it a<br />

larger site which needs opening up by the addition of such<br />

public realm features as streets and open space?<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

Larger sites require<br />

new open spaces<br />

for the community<br />

and neighbourhood<br />

Public Transit<br />

Route<br />

Arterial Roads<br />

Collectors and Local<br />

Streets<br />

Development Site<br />

Walkability Radii<br />

• Is the site adjacent to a park or open space which could<br />

be extended into the site and become an integral and<br />

supportive part of the new development?<br />

• Is the site adjacent to a rail corridor where a pedestrian<br />

and cycling trail could be provided within the setback<br />

area from the rail corridor. Or is it adjacent to a ravine or<br />

hydro corridor to which pedestrian/cycling connections<br />

can be made?<br />

• What are the appropriate building types for the context?<br />

• How should buildings be placed and organized to<br />

define and support the existing and proposed streets,<br />

and provide appropriate relationships to neighbouring<br />

properties?<br />

• What is the appropriate height and character of<br />

buildings?<br />

SITE CONTEXT | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

Continued on next page…<br />

15


SITE CONTEXT | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

16<br />

• Are there heritage resources on or adjacent to the site<br />

which will influence the layout, scale and character of the<br />

development?<br />

• Are there mature trees and existing topographical features<br />

which should be incorporated into the site design?<br />

• Are at-grade non-residential uses appropriate on certain<br />

frontages?<br />

In addition to the above, important contextual considerations<br />

may include existing uses such as public open space,<br />

community centres, schools, grocers, other retail and active<br />

commercial uses. Significant infrastructure elements to be<br />

considered include transit, cycling and pedestrian connections,<br />

sidewalks and community energy systems.<br />

The 250 and 500 metre radii are generally accepted measures<br />

for “walkability” and are roughly equivalent to a 5 and 10<br />

minute walk.The intent of the context analysis at a "walkable"<br />

scale is to develop an understanding of how the proposed<br />

development will fit with and reinforce existing or planned built<br />

form patterns and respond appropriately to changes in land use<br />

and scale. Connectivity to important area amenities, such as<br />

transit, public open space, and living and working destinations<br />

is also a key design consideration.<br />

The block scale analysis allows for a closer examination of the<br />

immediate existing and planned context. This analysis informs<br />

site organization including: open space allocation; building<br />

massing and placement; ground floor uses, and the design and<br />

character of the proposed development and the public realm.<br />

A Master Plan provides a planning and design framework to<br />

guide the incremental development of large or complex areas<br />

with multiple buildings, new streets, parks and open spaces.<br />

The Plan should provide a vision for the development of the<br />

entire site area, including how new streets, pedestrian and<br />

cycling routes, parks, and publicly accessible and private open<br />

spaces will be organized. These Guidelines should be applied to<br />

ensure that building blocks are appropriately located on the site<br />

and of a size suited to accommodate building types that will fit<br />

within the existing and planned context of buildings and uses.<br />

A Master Plan may not be required if there is a Secondary Plan<br />

that applies to the site, with associated Context or Precinct<br />

Plans that include comparable information and detail.<br />

Context analysis should identify gateways and important public spaces.<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

Identify important community, cultural, and places of significance.<br />

Official Plan Reference<br />

2.2 Structuring Growth in the City: Policy 1 and 2<br />

2.2.1 Downtown: The Heart of Toronto: Policy 4<br />

2.3.1 Healthy Neighbourhoods: Policy 1, 2, 3 and 6<br />

2.4 Bringing the City Together: Policy 2 and 8<br />

3.1.1 The Public Realm: Policy 1c, 1d, 1e, 5, 6, 9, 11, 12, 13, 14, 16, 17,<br />

18, 19 and 20<br />

3.1.2 Built Form: Policy 1and 2| 3.1.4<br />

3.1.5 Heritage Resources: Policy 3, 4 and 17<br />

3.3 Building New Neighbourhoods: Policy 1, 2 and 3<br />

3.4 The Natural Environment: Policy 3<br />

4.1 Neighbourhoods: Policy 5, 6, 7 and 9<br />

4.2 Apartment Neighbourhoods: Policy 2 and 3<br />

4.5 Mixed Use Areas: Policy 2<br />

5.1.3 Site Plan Control: Policy 2 and 3<br />

Related Standards, Guidelines & Studies:<br />

Toronto Green Standard | Toronto Walking Strategy | Standard<br />

Construction for Roads


1.2 PUBLIC REALM FRAMEWORK<br />

Create connections through developments to enhance public access to transit,<br />

parks, open spaces, amenities and other neigbourhood destinations.<br />

1.2.1 STREET AND BLOCK PATTERNS<br />

a. Provide safe, direct, universally accessible pedestrian and<br />

cycling links through new development to destinations such<br />

as parks, schools, transit, community facilities, local retail<br />

areas, and utilizing areas alongside rail/hydro corridors and<br />

ravines to extend the network of connections.<br />

b. Use existing public streets where possible, for address and<br />

access to new buildings.<br />

c. Extend and connect public streets, sidewalks, and public<br />

realm to integrate new development into the surroundings.<br />

d. Provide new public streets in accordance with the City's<br />

Development Infrastructure Policy and Standards (DIPS) for<br />

access and address to buildings which cannot be accessed<br />

from existing streets.<br />

e. Where public streets are deemed by staff to not be possible,<br />

private streets will only be permitted where:<br />

• the site is under 1 hectare in size<br />

• the site does not have the potential to be connected to<br />

adjacent properties through a new vehicular access<br />

• parking is provided underground for all development that<br />

takes its access from the private street(s)<br />

• small sites which cannot accommodate a public street,<br />

with underground garages may use a vehicular mews or<br />

pedestrian mews as alternatives<br />

• townhouses on small sites and which cannot<br />

accommodate the scale of a public street with a turnaround<br />

may use a vehicular mews street<br />

f. Incorporate traffic calming features, such as on-street<br />

parking, bulb-outs, textured materials and crosswalks to<br />

create a pedestrian friendly environment.<br />

RATIONALE<br />

Streets are a significant part of the City’s open space system,<br />

delineating development blocks providing mobility as well<br />

as creating linear open spaces within the City. They provide<br />

a setting for social interaction and neighbourhood activities.<br />

Conceptual diagram of access and connection through development area.<br />

They provide street address for individual buildings or units and<br />

grade related uses. Streets also allow for sunlight and daylight<br />

to reach buildings and outdoor amenity spaces. The layout of<br />

the new public realm consisting of streets, mews, parks and<br />

open spaces is the structure upon which a walkable community<br />

is organized and must not be a secondary consideration after<br />

laying out building blocks and servicing functions efficiently.<br />

When sites are large and new buildings and individual grade<br />

related apartment units cannot take their address from existing<br />

streets, new streets and walkways will be needed. In general,<br />

the pattern of existing local streets should be extended into the<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

new site. New streets should be laid out to reduce the impact of<br />

additional traffic on surrounding neighbourhoods.<br />

New streets should be public and conform to the City’s<br />

standards of quality. Standard public street right-of-way widths<br />

accommodate space needs for essential municipal services<br />

and utilities above and below grade, sidewalks, street lighting,<br />

landscaping and trees. They must accommodate space for the<br />

maintenance of this infrastructure and for snow, storage and<br />

garbage collection.<br />

Please refer to City of Toronto "Development Infrastructure<br />

Policy and Standards" (DIPS) for Public Local Residential<br />

Streets and Private Mews. Also, where it is necessary for a<br />

medium-sized site to be bisected by a street, it may prove<br />

acceptable to create a private street(s) to enable underground<br />

parking to be provided. (See also Section 2.1).<br />

17<br />

SITE CONTEXT | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

Privately Owned<br />

Pedestrian Connection<br />

pace (POPS)<br />

Public Street


1.2.2 PUBLIC PARKS AND OPEN SPACES<br />

SITE CONTEXT | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

Locate parks and open spaces to provide focal points for the development and<br />

integrate well into a larger network of streets, parks and open spaces.<br />

Townhouse units are oriented facing open space to frame and strengthen the public realm.<br />

a. Locate and design new parks and open spaces to be visible<br />

and easily accessible.<br />

b. Design and provide high quality parks and open space that<br />

provide for safety, user comfort, accessibility and yearround<br />

use.<br />

c. Enhance the experience of "place", providing experiential and<br />

educational opportunities to interact with the natural world.<br />

d. Protect access to existing parks and open spaces, as well as<br />

expanding the system of open spaces and developing open<br />

space linkages.<br />

e. Promote the inclusion of recreational facilities, including<br />

areas suitable for community or allotment gardens, to<br />

supplement the City's parks, facilities and amenities.<br />

f. The City's Park, Forestry and Recreation Division will<br />

determine whether new or expanded parks are needed<br />

through the development approval process. Using the tools<br />

of the Official Plan, new parks, where appropriate, will be<br />

sited, secured and designed for public use.<br />

g. Extend parks and open space networks into new<br />

development areas to expand the scale and function of these<br />

spaces, where possible.<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

h. Co-locate parks and open spaces with other public<br />

amenities, community buildings, schools, and shops.<br />

The requirement for new park area will be determined by local<br />

need, and opportunities for new park area will be sought which:<br />

• enhances the function of an existing park by adding new<br />

contiguous park lands<br />

• improves the visibility and access to a park by increasing<br />

street frontage<br />

• provides opportunities for movement through a block<br />

between streets or gives further access to ravines, school<br />

yards and other accessible open spaces<br />

RATIONALE<br />

With new development and growth, additional parks and<br />

publicly accessible open spaces will be necessary to provide<br />

18<br />

Continued on next page…


Pedestrian walkways through park lead to children play around and direct visitors to prominent views.<br />

community gathering spaces for walking, meeting, recreation<br />

and other aspects of public life. On smaller infill sites, these<br />

will be provided within the existing framework of parks and<br />

open spaces. Larger sites will be reviewed to consider the<br />

opportunities to provide new appropriately sized, located and<br />

designed parks and open spaces. Smaller sites over a certain<br />

size threshold and development type will be reviewed to explore<br />

opportunities for shared amenity spaces.<br />

Each development application should be reviewed with the<br />

goal of enhancing the community's network of parks and open<br />

spaces. The review should look at opportunities to increase<br />

the visibility and accessibility to parks and open spaces. Where<br />

appropriate, opportunities to enlarge or create new parks and<br />

open spaces should be pursued. Adding to variety, in terms<br />

of the character, function and range of experiences offered by<br />

the local network of parks and open spaces, should be another<br />

important consideration. Good quality parks and open spaces,<br />

which are attractive, inviting, safe and well-maintained, are<br />

key elements of the character of the community and play an<br />

important role in enhancing the quality of life for new and<br />

existing residents. Parks and open spaces can also define the<br />

identity of an area, establish a sense of place and set the tone<br />

for the entire community.<br />

The structure of streets, parks and open spaces,<br />

along with appropriately located, sized and detailed buildings,<br />

and their ground floor uses will, in part, determine the safety,<br />

enjoyment and the quality of these open spaces.<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

Parks are the focal points of communities and should be located centrally to provide ease<br />

of access and visibility.<br />

Official Plan Reference<br />

2.3.2 Toronto's Green Space System and Waterfront: Policy 1b<br />

and 3b | 3.1.1 The Public Realm: Policy 19 and 20 | 3.1.2 Built<br />

Form: Policy 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 and 6| 3.2.3 Parks and Open Spaces:<br />

Policy 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 and 8<br />

Related Standards, Guidelines & Studies:<br />

Toronto Green Standard<br />

SITE CONTEXT | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

19


1.3 HERITAGE<br />

SITE CONTEXT | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

Locate and design buildings to respect and complement the scale, character, form<br />

and setting of on-site and adjacent heritage properties and Heritage Conservation<br />

Districts (HCDs).<br />

Provide front yard<br />

setback to align with<br />

adjacent built form<br />

Transition to fit-in with<br />

adjacent built forms<br />

and frame street<br />

a. Conserve and integrate heritage properties into<br />

developments in a manner that is consistent with accepted<br />

principles of good heritage conservation. Building proposals<br />

with adjacent or on-site heritage properties or within an HCD<br />

are required to provide a Heritage Impact Assessment as<br />

part of a complete application.<br />

b. Conserve the integrity of the cultural heritage values,<br />

attributes, character, and three-dimensional form of an<br />

on-site heritage building or structure or property within an<br />

HCD. Façade retention alone is not an acceptable method of<br />

heritage preservation.<br />

c. When a proposed building is adjacent to a lower-scale<br />

heritage property:<br />

Respect and enhance<br />

architectural features<br />

and rhythms of<br />

heritage building<br />

Preserve prominent<br />

views of heritage<br />

building with strategic<br />

building setback and<br />

stepbacks<br />

Incorporate heritage<br />

landscape design as part<br />

of conservation strategy<br />

d. Ensure that Low-rise, multi-unit buildings do not visually<br />

impede the setting of properties on the heritage register<br />

inventory. The objective for the long-term preservation,<br />

integration, and re-use of heritage properties may mean<br />

that not all sites with or adjacent to heritage properties<br />

are appropriate for this form of development.<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

• design new buildings to respect the urban grain, scale,<br />

setbacks, proportions, visual relationships, topography,<br />

and materials of the historic context<br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

• integrate the existing heritage character into the building<br />

through high-quality, contemporary design cues<br />

• ensure consistency with applicable HCD Plan<br />

requirements<br />

Heritage building<br />

carefully transformed<br />

into townhouse<br />

development.<br />

20<br />

Continued on next page…


Adaptive re-use of heritage building for grade related low-rise apartments.<br />

RATIONALE<br />

The City of Toronto values its heritage properties and<br />

Heritage Conservation Districts (HCDs) and requires that<br />

they be protected and, where appropriate, integrated into<br />

new development in a manner that is consistent with<br />

accepted principles of good heritage conservation.<br />

There may be instances where conservation principles<br />

outweigh the goals of intensification and redevelopment,<br />

and may limit the construction of buildings or require<br />

additional “breathing space” to preserve the integrity<br />

of an HCD, heritage property, or specific attributes. In<br />

locations where proposed developments are considered<br />

appropriate, heritage properties should be referenced<br />

to inform the scale and contextual treatment of the new<br />

development. If well designed and appropriately sited, new<br />

development buildings can make a positive contribution to an<br />

historical setting.<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

Low-rise, multi-unit building development proposals containing<br />

heritage properties on or adjacent to the development site are<br />

required to provide a Heritage Impact Assessment as part of<br />

the application review process. The impact of the proposed<br />

development or site alteration on the heritage property will<br />

be evaluated and an overall approach recommended for<br />

conservation of these resources that mitigates the negative<br />

impacts a development may have on the heritage asset.<br />

SITE CONTEXT | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

Official Plan Reference<br />

2.2.1 Downtown: The Heart of Toronto: Policy 5 and 6<br />

2.3.1 Healthy Neighbourhoods: Policy 1 and 2<br />

3.1.5 Heritage Resources: Policy 1, 2, 4, 10b, 10c, 11,12, 26,<br />

28, 29, 30, 31, 43<br />

Related Standards, Guidelines & Studies<br />

Guidelines, #4 | Parks Canada: Standards and Guidelines for the<br />

Conservation of Historic Places in Canada<br />

21


SITE CONTEXT | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

22


2.0 Site Organization<br />

2.1 Streets, Mews and Walkways<br />

2.2 Shared Outdoor Amenity Space<br />

2.3 Building Placement<br />

2.4 Building Address<br />

2.5 Site Servicing, Access and Parking<br />

2.5.1 Site Servicing, Access and Parking for Smaller Street-<br />

Related Townhouse Sites<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

SITE ORGANIZATION | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

23


2.1 STREETS, MEWS AND WALKWAYS<br />

SITE ORGANIZATION | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

Provide new streets, mews and walkways for safe, comfortable and direct access<br />

and address for all new buildings.<br />

Appropriately scaled buildings help to frame streets and provide a comfortable pedestrian environment. Credit: Tact Architecture Inc.<br />

a. Locate and design public streets, private streets, private<br />

vehicular mews, pedestrian mews and walkways to:<br />

• provide safe, direct, universally accessible, landscaped<br />

pedestrian and cycling connections to destinations within<br />

and through the new development including links to<br />

schools, transit, community facilities, and retail areas<br />

• extend and connect to the local street network with<br />

multiple access points to avoid dead-end routes<br />

• provide through-lanes (public or private) to minimize<br />

vehicle turnarounds.<br />

• be publicly accessible and designed to invite public access<br />

• locate access on secondary streets and consolidate<br />

access points when possible to minimize curb cuts.<br />

• coordinate and consolidate servicing, parking access and<br />

utilities to maximize efficiency and minimize negative<br />

impacts on neighbouring properties and interruptions to<br />

the public realm<br />

• create attractive and comfortable, year-round pedestrian<br />

environments with landscaping including canopy trees,<br />

pedestrian scale lighting and other amenities<br />

• provide and connect pedestrian and cycling pathways<br />

alongside ravines, open spaces, and rail corridors where<br />

the opportunities exist<br />

RATIONALE<br />

Streets, mews and walkways form the fundamental site<br />

organizational element in low-rise developments. Locate<br />

buildings and design sites to encourage walking and cycling<br />

as viable transportation options for building occupants.<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

Encouraging these forms of active transportation will promote<br />

a healthier citizenry. High-quality pedestrian and cycling routes<br />

should be well-connected to existing infrastructure, such<br />

as transit, bicycle lanes, parking facilities, and the sidewalk<br />

network.<br />

More than just circulation routes, streets, mews and walkways<br />

are place-making opportunities that can provide a sense of<br />

place and allow communities to connect with each other. These<br />

routes have the potential to be attractive and enjoyable publicly<br />

accessible environments to enhance the experience and quality<br />

of life.<br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

24<br />

Official Plan Reference<br />

3.1.1 Public Realm: Policy 5, 6, 13, 14, 16, 17, 18 | 3.1.2 Built Form: Policy 5 | 3.3 Building New Neighbourhoods: Policy 1a, 2b and 3a |<br />

5.1.3 Site Plan Control: Policy 3a<br />

Related Standards, Guidelines & Studies:<br />

Toronto Green Standard | Standard Construction Drawings for Roads | Streetscape Manual | Privately Owned Publicly-Accessible Space<br />

Design Guidelines<br />

Continued on next page…


Public<br />

Sidewalk<br />

Pedestrian<br />

Walkway<br />

Public<br />

Sidewalk<br />

2.1 STREETS, MEWS AND WALKWAYS CONT.<br />

The following public/private street, private vehicular and pedestrian mews, lane/driveway, and walkway sections with associated<br />

setbacks and permitted encroachments are typical access elements for townhouse and low-rise apartment buildings. (See also<br />

Section 1.2 Public Realm Framework)<br />

Public Street - the design standards are specified in Development Infrastructure Policy and Standards (DIPS). Where front integral<br />

garage parking is provided, the minimum front yard setback is 4.5m from the property line (with the garage portion of the building<br />

setback 6.0m); where parking is underground or at the rear, the minimum setback is 3.0m.<br />

Well-proportioned public streets create framework for attractive<br />

neighbourhoods and streetscapes.<br />

Max<br />

1.8m<br />

Front Yard<br />

Setback<br />

Without Front<br />

Integral Garage<br />

Min<br />

3.0m<br />

Max<br />

1.8m<br />

PL<br />

Min<br />

2.1m<br />

Right of Way<br />

Varies<br />

(Refer to DIPS)<br />

Public Street<br />

Min 8.0m with<br />

on street parking<br />

Min 6.0m without<br />

on street parking<br />

Min<br />

2.1m<br />

PL<br />

Max<br />

1.8m<br />

Front Yard<br />

Setback<br />

with Front<br />

Integral Garage<br />

Min 6.0m to<br />

Garage Door<br />

Private Street - a privately owned and maintained street, where the required parking must be located underground, the minimum<br />

front yard setback is 4.0m as measured from the inside of the adjacent sidewalk. (See Section 1.2.1 e. Access and Connection for<br />

the conditions under which a Private Street would be permitted)<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

Min<br />

4.5m<br />

SITE ORGANIZATION | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

Porch<br />

&<br />

Landscaped<br />

Area<br />

Private Street<br />

with Emergency<br />

Vehicular Access<br />

Min<br />

4.0m<br />

Min<br />

2.1m<br />

Min<br />

2.0m<br />

Private street dominated by large stairway encroachments into<br />

insufficient setbacks affecting otherwise good streetscape<br />

design.<br />

Continued on next page…<br />

25


Pedestrian<br />

Walkway<br />

2.1 STREETS, MEWS AND WALKWAYS CONT.<br />

SITE ORGANIZATION | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

Private Vehicular Mews - the design standards are specified in DIPS. A private vehicular mews is a privately owned and maintained<br />

street where front integral parking is provided and where the maximum length of the private mews is 45.0m from the curb of the existing<br />

public street and contains a maximum of 10 units (not counting units that front onto an existing public street). The minimum front yard<br />

setback is 6.0m as measured from the inside of the adjacent sidewalk.<br />

Utectus, conseque oditiatur sam, quaerchicia iusandi orerum et et perumquae quatem.<br />

Tatecus animus reris eat ame es<br />

Max<br />

1.8m<br />

Front Setback<br />

with Front<br />

Integral Garage<br />

Min<br />

6.0m<br />

Min<br />

2.1m<br />

See 3.2 Separation Distances<br />

and Setbacks for details.<br />

Mews Street<br />

Lane/Driveway – a road surface that provides vehicular access to a parking garage/area and/or service area, and which does not provide<br />

pedestrian access to or address for buildings. Where vehicles can enter and exit a site travelling in one direction the lane/driveway may<br />

be a minimum of 4.5m in width.<br />

Min<br />

8.0m<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

Laneway<br />

Access<br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

Units and associated terraces overlook a well-designed laneway with landscaped areas<br />

and carefully located utilities.<br />

Min<br />

1.0m<br />

Min<br />

6.0m<br />

Min<br />

1.0m<br />

26<br />

Continued on next page…


Pedestrian<br />

Walkway<br />

Thru-Block<br />

Pedestrian<br />

Walkway<br />

Pedestrian Mews - a privately owned and maintained pedestrian route visible from the street which provides public access and<br />

address to individual buildings and units within a larger development site. (For separation distances between buildings see Section<br />

3.2 Separation Distances, Setbacks and Orientation)<br />

See 3.2 Separation Distances<br />

and Setbacks for details.<br />

Max<br />

1.8m<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

Min<br />

Min Min Min<br />

1.5m - Max<br />

3.0m 3.0m 2.1m 3.0m<br />

Pedestrian mews with central green space and pedestrian walkways framing the<br />

shared area.<br />

Walkway - a privately owned and maintained pedestrian path.<br />

Employ minimum walkway dimensions as follows:<br />

and pedestrian scale lighting.<br />

Landscaped<br />

Area<br />

Landscaped<br />

Area<br />

Max<br />

1.8m<br />

Min<br />

1.5m - Max<br />

3.0m<br />

• when the walkway is the primary access to units, provide a minimum building separation of 6.0m and a clear path width of at<br />

least 2.1m landscaping and pedestrian scale lighting.<br />

• for a walkway providing a mid-block connection between two streets or to site features, provide a minimum building<br />

separation of 4.5m and a clear path of at least 2.1m landscaping and pedestrian scale lighting.<br />

• for a walkway that does not provide direct access to a unit or is not a mid-block connection, but provides access to a<br />

parking or service area, provide a minimum building separation of 3.0m and a clear path width of at least 1.5m landscaping<br />

SITE ORGANIZATION | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

Side-to-Side<br />

Condition<br />

Generous walkway through the building massing frames<br />

views and creates a gateway.<br />

Narrow walkway between building blocks with<br />

landscaped area.<br />

Landscaped Area<br />

Min<br />

2.1m<br />

Varies<br />

Landscaped Area<br />

27


2.2 SHARED OUTDOOR AMENITY AREAS<br />

SITE ORGANIZATION | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

28<br />

Design open spaces and shared outdoor amenity areas to be publicly accessible<br />

community focus areas.<br />

High quality, centrally located, and sun filled amenity spaces are focal points of communities. Credit: David Peterson Architect Inc. Triumph Developments. Photo by: Ben Rahn, A-Frame.<br />

a. Maximize and create high-quality landscaped open space on<br />

the site. Opportunities may include hard and soft landscaped<br />

features such as courtyards and children's play space.<br />

b. Integrate existing natural attributes and topography within<br />

the development site and, where appropriate, make a public<br />

feature of these elements.<br />

c. Preserve and protect existing healthy trees.<br />

d. Animate and frame open spaces with appropriate building<br />

massing, elements and uses. (Eg. Entrances, windows, and<br />

active uses at-grade).<br />

e. Locate open space to maximize frontages on streets, mews<br />

and walkways to provide prominence, visibility and access.<br />

f. Complement and connect with open space on neighbouring<br />

properties, where possible.<br />

g. Locate children's playgrounds overlooked by residents to<br />

enhance informal supervision.<br />

h. Provide direct visual and easily accessible physical<br />

connections to streets, mews and walkways and create<br />

attractive views and community focal points.<br />

i. Locate and design amenity spaces for maximum access to<br />

sunlight.<br />

j. When required by the Zoning By-law, locate interior amenity<br />

facilities adjacent to shared outdoor amenity areas and<br />

provide windows and doors for direct physical and visual<br />

access between these spaces.<br />

k. Provide shared play space for children in developments<br />

with 20 or more units if no backyards are provided and in<br />

developments on sites of 1.0 hectare or more.<br />

l. Meet safety and universally accessible standards in the<br />

public realm.<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

m. Locate parking, mechanical equipment and servicing areas<br />

away from amenity areas.<br />

n. Avoid locating shared amenity areas in isolated, irregularly<br />

shaped, inaccessible, and/or residual areas.<br />

Types of shared amenity area may include:<br />

Courtyards - landscaped open space, located in the centre of a<br />

single or consolidated block with no direct street frontage with<br />

potential for children's play space.<br />

Forecourts - landscaped open space between the public<br />

sidewalk and the main entrance of a building.<br />

Plazas - animated gathering place with predominantly hard<br />

surfaced landscape features flanking a public street.<br />

Urban Gardens - landscaped space, usually of intimate<br />

scale, open to a public street, located and oriented to provide<br />

maximum sunlight during midday with potential for children's<br />

play space.


RATIONALE<br />

Residential developments zoned as apartments (primarily<br />

stacked and back-to-back townhouses and low-rise apartments)<br />

are required to provide a shared outdoor amenity area for<br />

developments with 20 or more units. Although this type of<br />

amenity space is typically privately-owned and maintained, it is<br />

to be designed as publicly accessible and appropriate for yearround<br />

use, particularly when part of its function is a pedestrian<br />

connection through the site.<br />

On-site shared outdoor amenity areas complement the public<br />

park system and provide additional gathering space to support<br />

community life. Townhouses and low-rise, multi-unit buildings<br />

are popular with families with children and pets owners.<br />

Developments with well-designed and located shared amenity<br />

areas with children's play space, facilities for pets and other<br />

shared elements allow residents to experience and share their<br />

collective property.<br />

The location of open spaces on a site, along with the type,<br />

size, and intended use of the space, may vary depending<br />

upon building use, the nature of the planned community, site<br />

characteristics and the range of existing open spaces within an<br />

easy walk. Providing well located, appropriately scaled, open<br />

space within a building site can help the new development fit<br />

with the existing context. These considerations are particularly<br />

important in areas when there is a shortage of public park<br />

space.<br />

The design should also create a micro-climate that supports<br />

pedestrian comfort, biodiversity, and meet or exceed public<br />

standards for universal accessibility, sunlight, sustainability and<br />

safety.<br />

A formal garden with good access to sunlight and sky view provides a place for pause.<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

A courtyard with seating areas, mature shade trees and planting.<br />

SITE ORGANIZATION | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

Official Plan Reference<br />

2.3.2 Toronto's Green Space System and Waterfront: Policy 1b and 3b |<br />

3.1.1 The Public Realm: Policy 13a, 14, 15, 19 and 20 | 3.1.2 Built Form:<br />

Policy 1d, 3f, 5b, 5d and 6 | 3.2.3 Parks and Open Space: Policy 1a, 1c<br />

and 1d | 3.3 Building New Neighbourhoods: Policy 2a and 2d | 3.4 The<br />

Natural Environment: Policy 18a and 18f | 5.1.3 Site Plan Control: Policy<br />

3b and 3e<br />

Related Standards, Guidelines & Studies:<br />

Toronto Green Standard | Toronto Green Roof By-law | Bird-<br />

Friendly Development Guidelines<br />

A shared amenity space along the rail corridor.<br />

29


2.3 BUILDING PLACEMENT<br />

SITE ORGANIZATION | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

Locate the buildings to frame the edges of streets, parks, and open space,<br />

to fit harmoniously with the existing context, and to provide opportunities for<br />

high-quality landscaped open space on-site.<br />

a. In general, build parallel to the street and extend the building<br />

the length of the site along the edges of streets, parks, and<br />

open space with front doors on the primary facade facing<br />

these areas.<br />

b. Under certain circumstances, it may be appropriate to<br />

define the edge of a street with the ends of building blocks<br />

provided that these "fingers" contribute to forming a street<br />

wall of primary façades with front doors.<br />

c. On larger sites, consider a combination of “parallel” and<br />

“fingers” orientations to provide variation along the street<br />

and within the site, while ensuring visibility and accessibility<br />

to the interior building blocks from the street(s).<br />

d. On larger sites where a new pattern of public realm is<br />

created, organize buildings to provide definition and support<br />

existing and new edges of streets, parks, and open spaces.<br />

e. Locate unit entrances so that they are directly visible and<br />

accessible from the public sidewalk.<br />

f. Where the existing setback pattern is consistent and not<br />

planned to change, align new buildings with neighbouring<br />

building frontages to allow new development to fit within the<br />

context.<br />

g. When existing setbacks are well-established, but vary on<br />

either side of a proposed development, locate and design<br />

the building setback to resolve the differences.<br />

h. Provide upgraded side elevations with windows and details<br />

consistent with front elevations when the side elevation is<br />

facing or visible to a street, mews, pedestrian mews, park or<br />

open space.<br />

i. On blocks where a consistent setback pattern does not exist<br />

or is planned to change, locate the building at the required<br />

setback line (see also 2.1 Streets, Mews, Pedestrian mews<br />

and Walkways, 4.1 Streetscape).<br />

j. On corner sites, align the building to the setback pattern of<br />

neighbouring buildings on both streets.<br />

Buildings placed parallel to street provide definition to street edge and help to reinforce the<br />

public realm. Credit: Tact Architecture Inc.<br />

k. Generally, provide breaks between buildings every 6-8 units.<br />

l. Provide greater building setbacks at strategic points or<br />

along the entire frontage, as appropriate, for architectural<br />

interest and to improve pedestrian amenity, including more<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

space for tree planting, wider sidewalks, forecourts, plazas,<br />

and other publicly accessible open spaces.<br />

m. Maintain the character of existing soft landscaped<br />

streetscapes by providing generous setbacks for trees and<br />

plantings.<br />

n. On deep sites, setback buildings from side and rear yards of<br />

neighbouring properties to reduce the impact of shadow and<br />

overlook.<br />

o. On these deeper sites, organize buildings to define and<br />

support the new public realm in a manner that eliminates<br />

back-to-front facing relationships (such as front doors<br />

facing rear yards on the site or on neighbouring properties).<br />

p. Also on these deeper sites, where back to back units result<br />

in one side of the building facing an area that cannot be<br />

seen from a street, locate all entrances facing the street or<br />

use a through unit type instead.<br />

30<br />

Continued on next page…


Buildings frame the public realm.<br />

RATIONALE<br />

Toronto’s traditional urban pattern is of buildings aligned<br />

parallel to the street with a consistent setback from the front<br />

property line. Well-placed buildings can create a coherent<br />

streetscape and fit with existing neighbours. Where the setback<br />

pattern is not consistent or planned to change, the placement<br />

of buildings at the required setback line, parallel to the street,<br />

helps establish a pedestrian-oriented context for the future.<br />

Where the required setback line is at or very close to the<br />

property line, greater building setbacks at strategic points or<br />

along the entire frontage may be encouraged to expand the<br />

public realm and improve pedestrian comfort and amenity.<br />

On deeper sites where buildings deeper in the site are<br />

considered, they need to be setback appropriately from the<br />

neighbouring buildings to fit within existing and planned<br />

patterns avoiding overlook, shadows and inappropriate<br />

relationships to neighbouring properties. At the same time<br />

these buildings should be sited to provide appropriate definition<br />

for the new public realm layout in the site.<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

Placement of townhouse units reference the neighbourhood character.<br />

SITE ORGANIZATION | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

Official Plan Reference<br />

2.3.1 Healthy Neighbourhoods: Policy 1 and 2 | 3.1.1 The Public Realm: Policy 1d and 9 | 3.1.2 Built Form: Policy 1, 2, 3, 5a, 5b and 5c |<br />

3.3 Building New Neighbourhoods: Policy 3b | 4.2 Apartment Neighbourhoods: Policy 2b, 2c and 3e | 4.5 Mixed Use Areas: Policy 2e |<br />

5.1.3 Site Plan Control: Policy 3c<br />

Related Standards, Guidelines & Studies:<br />

Accessibility Design Guidelines<br />

31


2.4 BUILDING ADDRESS<br />

SITE ORGANIZATION | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

Locate and organize buildings to frame and support existing or new streets,<br />

mews, pedestrian mews, parks and open spaces. Ensure front entrances are<br />

clearly visible and directly accessible from these spaces.<br />

a. Provide appropriate setbacks from the streets to allow for<br />

transition from the public realm to private development.<br />

b. Provide soft landscaping, walkways and projecting elements<br />

such as porches and canopies within the setback area.<br />

c. Depending on the type of the street and the elements within<br />

the setback area, the minimum setback may need to be<br />

increased to allow for sufficient soil volume to support large<br />

growing shade trees, respect the existing context, enhance<br />

the public realm/streetscape or provide privacy to units.<br />

(See Section 2.1 Streets, Mews and Walkways for minimum<br />

building setbacks from streets)<br />

d. Buildings on public/private streets, mews and accessble<br />

open spaces with residential uses at grade should have:<br />

• a primary entrance to the unit(s) with a front door clearly<br />

visible and directly accessible from the sidewalk via a<br />

walkway<br />

• primary windows facing the street or walkway<br />

• a prominent entrance with a well-detailed front entry<br />

porch or stoop (see Section 3.4 Building Entrances and<br />

Front Yard)<br />

• front yard landscaping including high branching<br />

deciduous trees and foundation planting<br />

h. Where building entrances are located within a pedestrian<br />

mews or courtyard, maintain high visibility and direct,<br />

generous, universal access from the public sidewalk.<br />

i. On corner or double-fronting sites, locate building fronts<br />

and entrances facing both streets. Buildings on corner sites<br />

require additional attention to building's corner treatment.<br />

Good example of corner expression on building addressing both the public street and<br />

pedestrian walkway.<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

32<br />

n. Where building entrances take their address from courtyards<br />

and pedestrian mews rather than streets, a way-finding<br />

system additional to the street address system needs to be<br />

provided.<br />

o. Where retail uses are part of the development, provide a<br />

separate entrance to each ground floor retail unit that is<br />

identifiable and directly accessible from the public sidewalk.<br />

Ab il inci ime sim eaque in natiatquiate necae non pro dolupta vollanim quis aut lamus dis<br />

Continued on next page…


RATIONALE<br />

Streets, urban parks and accessible open spaces are like A “back yard” condition between the building and the street<br />

public living rooms. Appropriately located, sized and detailed shall be avoided. Below-grade and at-grade terraces and<br />

buildings, and their ground floor uses, define the edges and exterior basement stairwells often have a negative impact<br />

help to determine the safety, use and quality of these spaces. on the public realm by preventing adequate landscaping in<br />

Aspects that need to be considered include:<br />

setback areas as well as reducing privacy for the resident<br />

in the lower unit (particularly with the minimal setback<br />

• Setbacks<br />

areas associated with the more intense forms of low-rise<br />

• Height<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

development).<br />

• Transition<br />

• Building relationship to grade<br />

• Window and entrance details<br />

• Façade elements and materials<br />

• Landscaping<br />

The space between the building facade and the public boulevard<br />

is an important part of the image and character of the public<br />

realm. The setback and related elements provide the connection<br />

between the public realm of the sidewalk and the private realm<br />

within the buildings. Well-designed entrances, facades and<br />

landscaping, create an arrival experience and identity for the<br />

building. Typically, the most vibrant and interesting streets are<br />

lined with active, street-related uses where access is gained by<br />

a series of entrances connected to the public sidewalk. Clear,<br />

visible entries and views from building interiors to the street<br />

provide security for building occupants and pedestrians. Welldesigned<br />

landscaping, and moderate level changes can create<br />

an interesting and comfortable sidewalk and privacy within the<br />

residential unit. Further, in order to fully function as a front<br />

entrance, the interior of a residential unit at grade should have a<br />

foyer and a coat closet at the entrance.<br />

Setbacks allow for projecting elements such as porches,<br />

canopies, and landings. These elements add visual interest to<br />

the front façade, enhance the prominence of the entrances,<br />

provide transition in scale from the sidewalk to the main wall of<br />

the building, and often help the new development fit better with<br />

the existing neighbourhood context.<br />

A series of street-related entrances promote interaction between the building interior and<br />

adjacent public realm.<br />

Consider landscape and architectural treatments to the transitional space between the<br />

walkway, private outdoor amenity space, and building interior to provide privacy between<br />

residences and adjacent public realm.<br />

SITE ORGANIZATION | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

Official Plan Reference<br />

3.1.1 The Public Realm: Policy 1d, 1e, 6, 12, 13, 14, 16 and 17 |<br />

3.1.2 Built Form: Policy 1a, 1b, 1c, 4 and 5c | 4.1 Neighbourhoods: Policy 5e and 9c |<br />

4.2 Apartment Neighbourhoods: Policy 2g and 3f<br />

Related Standards, Guidelines & Studies:<br />

Accessibility Design Guidelines |<br />

Toronto Green Standard<br />

Continued on next page…<br />

33


2.5 SITE SERVICING, ACCESS, AND PARKING<br />

SITE ORGANIZATION | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

Locate “back of house” activities, such as loading, servicing, utilities, and vehicle<br />

parking, underground, internally or in the rear, away from the public realm and<br />

public view.<br />

Public realm can be vastly improved when underground garage ramps and garbage storage areas are internalized into the building. Credit: Audax Archtiecture. Photo: Joy von Tiedemann.<br />

a. Incorporate parking garage ramps and access stairs,<br />

garbage collection areas and loading areas into the building.<br />

b. Provide access to site servicing and parking at the rear of<br />

the building or site, from a lane or from a shared driveway, if<br />

possible.<br />

c. Minimize the extent of site area dedicated to servicing and<br />

vehicular access through the use of shared infrastructure<br />

and efficient layouts.<br />

d. Minimize surface parking and drop off areas:<br />

• provide sufficient and convenient visitor parking<br />

underground and/or dispersed on site on streets via<br />

parallel parking<br />

• with the exception of front integral garage driveways,<br />

avoid locating parking between the building and public<br />

sidewalk or street (front yard areas)<br />

e. Provide pedestrian and cyclist access to and from parking<br />

access/areas that is clearly visible, well-lit, convenient, and<br />

easily accessible from the street.<br />

parking in accordance with the Toronto Green Standard<br />

and Guidelines for the Design and Management of Bicycle<br />

Parking Facilities.<br />

h. Recess, screen, and minimize the size of garage doors and<br />

service openings visible from public streets and public or<br />

private open space. Use high-quality doors and finishes.<br />

i. Encroachment of below-grade parking structures beyond the<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

front face of the building and/or into the front yard setback<br />

is not permitted.<br />

j. Where below-grade parking structures encroach beyond the<br />

footprint of the building elsewhere on the site, provide high<br />

quality un-compacted soil for a minimum 1.5 metre depth<br />

below grade to support opportunities for tree planting and<br />

other soft landscaping.<br />

k. For surface parking lots refer to Design Guidelines for<br />

'Greening' Surface Parking Lots.<br />

l. For laneways providing access to parking, provide<br />

landscaping and lighting.<br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

34<br />

f. Where long-term bicycle parking is located above grade,<br />

provide a visible and weather-protected parking areas.<br />

g. Locate short-term and long-term bicycle parking with<br />

direct access from the public street and near entrances to<br />

buildings and other pedestrian infrastructure. Design bicycle<br />

m. Offset access from the street rather than centred on the<br />

property in order to consolidate space for landscaping,<br />

where applicable.


2.5.1 SITE SERVICING, ACCESS AND<br />

PARKING FOR SMALLER STREET-RELATED<br />

TOWNHOUSE SITES<br />

a. Eliminate front driveways and garages in street-related<br />

townhouses generally and consider only when a unit is 6.0m<br />

or wider.<br />

b. In these cases:<br />

• the driveway width (including a walkway leading to the<br />

front door) is to be a maximum width of 3.0m for access<br />

to a single car garage in the front wall of the unit.<br />

• Ensure a minimum soil volume of 30m 3 to support mature<br />

tree growth in the soft landscaped portion of the front<br />

yard. (Depending on the type of the street and the setback<br />

elements within the setback area, the minimum setback<br />

may need to be increased to allow for sufficient soil<br />

volume to support street trees.)<br />

• Locate the garage door face a minimum of 6.0m from the<br />

inside edge of the sidewalk on a vehicular mews and from<br />

the property line on a public street<br />

• Recess the garage door face from the front wall plane<br />

c. Provide a minimum of 6.0m between individual driveways to<br />

accomodate on-street parking.<br />

d. Ensure that 50% of the lot frontage along the street<br />

comprises landscaping.<br />

e. Construct driveways with permeable paving and/or high<br />

albedo surface materials.<br />

f. Where possible, provide for garbage and recycling bin<br />

storage in the parking garage or in surface garages.<br />

g. Garbage pick-up on public streets will be provided in<br />

accordance to "The City of Toronto Requirements for<br />

Garbage, Recycling and Organics Collection Services<br />

for New Developments and Redevelopments" (Revised<br />

05/2012).<br />

Ab il inci ime sim eaque in natiatquiate necae non pro dolupta vollanim quis aut lamus dis<br />

Well designed garbage screening at the front of a unit facing the street.<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

SITE ORGANIZATION | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

h. Where garbage pickup occurs on streets for individual units,<br />

provide garbage bin storage screening that hides the bins<br />

from view from the sidewalk.<br />

i. Public garbage pick-up for individual units from a lane is<br />

preferred when possible.<br />

Ab il inci ime sim eaque in natiatquiate necae non pro dolupta vollanim quis aut lamus dis<br />

Continued on next page…<br />

35


SITE ORGANIZATION | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

RATIONALE<br />

Multi-unit, low-rise, buildings accommodate two types of<br />

activities at grade:<br />

“Front of house” activities, such as front entrances, primary<br />

rooms and landscaping, and “back of house” activities, such as<br />

parking, loading, and servicing.<br />

“Back of house” activities include, but are not limited to:<br />

• vehicle access, parking, parking ramps and access stairs<br />

• drop-off areas<br />

• garbage storage and collection<br />

• vents, utility meters, transformers, and other site utilities<br />

and servicing infrastructure<br />

“Back of house” activities are essential to the efficient<br />

functioning of new development. When these activities are<br />

concealed within and behind buildings, it promotes a safer,<br />

more comfortable and attractive public realm and pedestrian<br />

environment.<br />

Using the building or high-quality architectural elements and<br />

landscape design to screen vehicular access and site servicing,<br />

can help to mitigate noise, air quality concerns, and unattractive<br />

views within the building site and on adjacent streets, public or<br />

private open spaces, and neighbouring properties.<br />

Parking for low-rise, multi-unit buildings should not dominate<br />

the streetscape, but instead be located in underground shared<br />

garages or to the rear of buildings. Each curb-cut and driveway<br />

for service, parking and pedestrian drop-off creates a potential<br />

conflict with pedestrians. Multiple curb-cuts and driveways<br />

jeopardize landscaping opportunities and safety and comfort for<br />

pedestrians and reduce space for curbside parking. Buildings<br />

with front integral garages, which occupy the majority of the<br />

ground floor create an undesirable condition.<br />

Incorporate garage entrance into building.<br />

Avoid laneways like above without accommodation for utilities, landscaping and<br />

quality design, especially when amenity spaces overlook the area.<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

Avoid freestanding underground garage ramps and access stairs.<br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

36<br />

Official Plan Reference<br />

2.2 Structuring Growth in the City: Policy 3c | 2.3.1 Healthy Neighbourhoods: Policy 2d | 2.4 Bringing the City Together: Policy 2c, 7b and 8b<br />

3.1.1 The Public Realm: Policy 1d, 1e, 2 and 6b | 3.1.2 Built Form: Policy 1d, 2, and 5 | 3.4 The Natural Environment: Policy 18a, 18f and 20 |<br />

4.1 Neighbourhoods: Policy 9d | 4.2 Apartment Neighbourhoods: Policy 2d, 2e, 3d, 3g, and 3i | 4.5 Mixed Use Areas: Policy 2i and 2j | 5.1.3<br />

Site Plan Control: Policy 3a, 3b and 3h<br />

Related Standards, Guidelines & Studies:<br />

Toronto Green Standard | Guidelines for the Design and Management of Bicycle Parking Facilities | Bird-Friendly Development Guidelines |<br />

Design Guidelines for 'Greening' Surface Parking Lots


3.0 Building Design<br />

3.1 Fit and Transition in Scale<br />

3.2 Separation Distances, Stepbacks and Orientation<br />

3.3 Building Relationship to Grade and Street<br />

3.4 Building Entrance and Front Yard<br />

3.5 Private Outdoor Amenity Space<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

BUILDING CONFIGURATION AND MASSING | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

37


BUILDING CONFIGURATION AND MASSING | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

3.1 FIT AND TRANSITION IN SCALE<br />

Ensure buildings fit within the existing or planned context and provide<br />

appropriate downward transitions in scale to lower-scaled buildings, parks,<br />

and open space.<br />

a. For new buildings where the adjacent context is lower in<br />

scale and not anticipated to change, provide a transition<br />

in the building height down to the lower-scale neighbours.<br />

Match at least the first building, unit or bay immediately<br />

adjacent to the lower- scaled context to the scale and height<br />

of neighbouring buildings.<br />

b. At the site scale, promote fit and transition in scale by:<br />

• accommodating all aspects of fit and transition within the<br />

development site<br />

• including buildings that relate directly to the height and<br />

typology of the existing or planned streetwall context<br />

• ensuring that new buildings respect the planned and<br />

existing building wall height for parks and open spaces<br />

Figure 1: Transition downward in<br />

height and scale to lower-scale area.<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

c. For sites including or adjacent to heritage properties, design<br />

the scale and height of the building to respect and reinforce<br />

the height established by the historic context.<br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

Avoid abrupt transitions in scale.<br />

38<br />

Continued on next page…


Horizontal facade transitioning<br />

to existing streetwall<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

Porches, bays and other elements<br />

provide transition to adjacent lower<br />

scale development<br />

Figure 2: Step building massing or add porches, bays and other elements to provide transition to adjacent lower scale development.<br />

RATIONALE<br />

Appropriate fit and transition is achieved when new buildings<br />

• planned intensity of use and scale of development<br />

are integrated with the height, scale and character of<br />

• proximity and scale of adjacent built form<br />

neighbouring buildings and reinforce the city structure.<br />

Considerations of fit and transition should also take into<br />

• location or size of adjacent streets, parks and open space<br />

account the impact of a development on adjacent parks, open<br />

• potential impact on privacy, daylight, sky view, sunlight/<br />

spaces and streets in terms of maintaining a consistent base<br />

shadow for the public realm and neighbouring properties<br />

building wall height and access to sunlight and sky view.<br />

• potential impact on heritage properties and/or Heritage<br />

Conservation Districts<br />

On sites that are adjacent to or across the street from lower<br />

• potential impact on identified important views from the<br />

buildings, the massing of new low-rise buildings should step<br />

public realm<br />

down or include lower scaled building elements that respond to<br />

the building height and mass of the neighbouring buildings.<br />

• environmental sensitivity of adjacent natural features<br />

Figures 1 and 2 illustrate typical scenarios of building fit and<br />

(woodlots, ravines.)<br />

transition. The actual design approach and methods used to<br />

achieve appropriate fit and transition will be determined on a<br />

site-by-site basis and may vary according to the:<br />

• regulatory framework (e.g. Secondary Plans)<br />

• existing and planned context<br />

• size of the development site<br />

BUILDING CONFIGURATION AND MASSING | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

Official Plan Reference<br />

2.3.1 Healthy Neighbourhoods: Policy 1, 2a, 2b, 2c 3, and 8a | 3.1.2 Built Form: Policy 1, 3 and 4 | 3.1.5 Heritage Resources: Policy 2 and 5 |<br />

3.3 Building New Neighbourhoods: Policy 3b | 4.1 Neighbourhoods: Policy 5 and 9 | 4.2 Apartment Neighbourhoods: Policy 2a, 2b and 3d |<br />

4.5 Mixed Use Areas: Policy 2c and 2d<br />

39


BUILDING CONFIGURATION AND MASSING | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

40<br />

3.2 SEPARATION DISTANCES AND SETBACKS<br />

Locate and design buildings to ensure sunlight and sky views and reduce overlook<br />

conditions between buildings and neighbouring properties<br />

a. For front to front and back to back building blocks, generally<br />

provide a separation distrance of 15.0m or in accordance<br />

with the chart on this page.<br />

b. In order to ensure sunlight into lower units, additional<br />

separation distance is required for below-grade entrances<br />

and/or private outdoor amenity spaces.<br />

c. Setbacks and stepbacks between buildings assist in<br />

achieving the above objectives and in creating desirable<br />

public/private amenity spaces on the development site and<br />

appropriate relationships to adjacent properties:<br />

• For front to front and back to back building blocks, fit<br />

buildings within a 45 degree angular plane originated from<br />

the top of the main wall of the building. (The main wall<br />

height is measured from the average grade of the building<br />

frontage at the walkway abutting unit entrances to the top<br />

of the main wall)<br />

• Provide a minimum 7.5m rear yard setback from the<br />

property line<br />

• Provide a 45 degree angular plane measured both from<br />

the rear property line of an adjacent residence and/or<br />

lands designated Neighbourhoods and/or Parks and Open<br />

Space Area<br />

Roof/<br />

Roof Access<br />

45°<br />

Separation Distance See<br />

Chart for Dimensions<br />

Main Wall<br />

Height<br />

45°<br />

Approx. no. of<br />

Storeys<br />

Roof/<br />

Roof Access<br />

Required Minimum<br />

Separation Distance<br />

9.0m or less 2.5 11.0m*<br />

9.0-10.5m 3-3.5 13.0m*<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

12.0m 3.5-4.0 15.0m*<br />

*Additional separation distance is required when belowgrade<br />

entrances and/or below-grade private outdoor amenity<br />

spaces are provided adjacent to units.<br />

On one (1) side of the pedestrian<br />

mews<br />

On both sides of the pedestrian<br />

mews<br />

Separation Distances between Front to Front and Back to Back Buildings<br />

1.0m<br />

2.0m<br />

Continued on next page…


Landscaped<br />

Setback<br />

Min<br />

4.45m<br />

Min<br />

2.1m<br />

Min<br />

4.45m<br />

Landscaped<br />

Buffer Area<br />

Min<br />

4.45m<br />

Pedestrian<br />

Walkway<br />

Min<br />

2.1m<br />

Separation Distance of<br />

11.0m to 12.0m<br />

Landscaped<br />

Buffer Area<br />

Min<br />

4.45m<br />

Min 1.5m to<br />

Max 3.0m<br />

Separation Distance of<br />

11.0m to 12.0m<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

Separation Distance between 11.0 - 12.0m in a Pedestrian Mews<br />

Separation Distance Greater than 12.0m in a Pedestrian Mews<br />

Pedestrian Walkway<br />

and<br />

• Where a public laneway Landscaped abuts a site, the laneway may be<br />

Buffer Area<br />

included for the purposes of establishing the setback and<br />

angular plane<br />

• Provide a minimum of 7.5m between the faces of a<br />

building Min 1.5m containing to primary living spaces<br />

Varies<br />

Min such 1.5m to as living<br />

Max 3.0m<br />

Max 3.0m<br />

and dining and the side of another building or side<br />

Separation Distance of<br />

property line<br />

Greater than 12.0m<br />

• When integrating new single unit townhouses into an<br />

existing context, use the same side yard setbacks as the<br />

Sufficient separation distance allows for attractive landscaping between buildings, good<br />

neighbouring properties<br />

access to sunlight and sky views. Avoid more than 3-5 steps up or 8-9 steps down to the<br />

units to further improve the shared spaces between buildings.<br />

d. Locate and orient windows, decks and balconies to limit<br />

overlook into nearby windows and amenity spaces of<br />

adjacent properties while enabling "eyes on the street" for<br />

common public areas.<br />

e. Ensure visual privacy between residential units including<br />

balconies, porches, terraces and private amenity spaces.<br />

This can be accomplished through the design of units (such<br />

as off-setting the location of windows in facing walls) and<br />

by the use of landscaping or screening<br />

devices.<br />

45°<br />

Angular<br />

f. Avoid building element projections, such as balconies, into<br />

Plane<br />

setback areas, streets, mews, and amenity areas to protect<br />

access to light and sky view. Private<br />

Neighbourhood<br />

Driveway/Outdoor<br />

Designation<br />

Amenity<br />

Private Outdoor<br />

Amenity Space Area<br />

Private Outdoor<br />

Amenity Space Area<br />

Private Outdoor<br />

Amenity Space Area<br />

Pedestrian Walkway<br />

and<br />

Landscaped<br />

Buffer Area<br />

Varies<br />

Separation Distance of<br />

Greater than 12.0m<br />

Private Outdoor<br />

Amenity Space Area<br />

Min 1.5m to<br />

Max 3.0m<br />

BUILDING CONFIGURATION AND MASSING | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

PL<br />

Min<br />

1.5m<br />

6.0m<br />

7.5m<br />

Minimum Rear Yard<br />

Setback<br />

Appropriate spaces and landscaping between buildings provides adequate light, view and<br />

privacy conditions.<br />

Continued on next page…<br />

41


BUILDING CONFIGURATION AND MASSING | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

3.2 SEPARATION DISTANCES, SETBACKS AND ORIENTATION CONT.<br />

RATIONALE<br />

The former City of Toronto and the CMHC guidelines for Light,<br />

View and Privacy prescribe a minimum 15m facing distance<br />

or separation. Experience and analysis of employing the<br />

15.0m separation standard through the City's Infill Townhouse<br />

Guidelines (2003) confirm the appropriateness of upholding the<br />

application of this performance measure. However, the formula<br />

to determine the recommended separation distance is tied to<br />

the building height which will typically generate separation<br />

distances from 11.0 to 15.0m. These Guidelines establish<br />

minimum separation distances between buildings to ensure<br />

that three critical aspects of design are adequately addressed -<br />

sunlight inside a dwelling and to open spaces, reasonable view<br />

from a unit, and privacy.<br />

When the appropriate separation distance is combined with<br />

good building orientation and effective angular planes, buildings<br />

that face east, west, and south, five hours of direct sunlight<br />

during the solstices can be achieved within the units. The<br />

minimum separation distances contained in the chart on page<br />

40, were created by multiplying 1.25 times the main wall height.<br />

The main wall height plus the remainder of the building height<br />

under the 45˚ angular plane generally achieves a 1:1 ratio of<br />

building height to separation distance. This ratio is the same as<br />

that used for mid-rise buildings to achieve five hours of sunlight<br />

on south facing sidwalks on the opposite side of the street.<br />

Direct sunlight, can penetrate into the lowest units and trees<br />

and vegetation have the opportunity to thrive, improving the<br />

usability and enjoyment of outdoors.<br />

Angular planes are a commonly applied measure to achieve<br />

acceptable transitions in scale between taller and lower<br />

buildings or areas. By applying an angular plane, adverse<br />

shadowing effects and the intrusion of overlook from a building<br />

can be limited. In the absence of other applicable in-force<br />

planning regulations, a 45 degree angular plane, measured<br />

from the relevant property line(s) at grade, is typically used to<br />

achieve a transition in scale between taller and lower buildings<br />

or areas (such as stable residential Neighbourhoods).<br />

Ab il inci ime sim eaque in natiatquiate necae non pro dolupta vollanim quis aut lamus dis<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

Limit projections into the open space to ensure that natural light is not restricted<br />

to areas below. Narrow facing distances between buildings and stacked private<br />

amenity spaces create poor light, new + privacy conditions as in the example above.<br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

42<br />

Official Plan Reference<br />

3.1.1 Public Realm: Policies 1d, 1e and 2 | 3.1.2 Built Form: Policy 3d, 3e, 3f, and 4 | 3.2.3 Parks and Open Space: Policy 3 | 4.1 Neighbour<br />

hoods: Policy 5e, 5f and 9b | 4.2 Apartment Neighbourhoods: Policy 2a, 2b, 3d and 3e | 4.5 Mixed Use Areas: Policy 2d and 2e


3.3 BUILDING RELATIONSHIP TO GRADE AND STREET<br />

Developments should relate directly to the existing or ‘natural’ grade and blend in<br />

with the context of the neighbourhood.<br />

a. Maintain the existing natural grade at property lines.<br />

b. Avoid artificially raised or lowered grades and drainage<br />

swales, or low-lying areas where water collects. (These may<br />

have an adverse affect on adjacent properties, open spaces<br />

or use of amenity areas, and may require retaining walls.)<br />

c. To avoid a long barrier-like flight of stairs up to the porch or<br />

stoop, raise the front entrance to the first floor no more than<br />

approximately 3 to 5 steps above the grade of the sidewalk<br />

directly at the front of the entrance. (See also Section 2.2<br />

Building Relationship to the Public Realm and Section 3.4<br />

Building Entrance, Front Yard and Private Outdoor Amenity<br />

Space).<br />

d. If there is a significant grade difference across a site, step<br />

buildings or segments of buildings in order to maintain the<br />

appropriate relationship to grade.<br />

e. Avoid significant changes in grade (greater than 4% slope)<br />

between the public sidewalk and pedestrian access and<br />

circulation routes. Ensure that routes across grade changes<br />

are universally accessible.<br />

f. Limit the maximum grades on landscaped areas to<br />

33% (3:1) or less to ensure that grassed slopes can be<br />

maintained.<br />

g. Limit the use of retaining walls, particularly along street<br />

frontages, parks, ravines and other areas of the public<br />

realm.<br />

h. Where retaining walls cannot be avoided, provide them in<br />

the form of low terraces with the total height not to exceed<br />

1.0 metre. Incorporate intensive soft landscaping in these<br />

low terraces and construct with durable and attractive<br />

materials.<br />

i. When appropriate, use the existing site topography to<br />

enhance the screening of service areas.<br />

j. Provide a site grading plan compatible with the stormwater<br />

management approach selected for the site (see also 4.2.1<br />

Stormwater Management).<br />

Good Example of Building relationship to Grade.<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

Grade alterations create negative impact on adjacent properties.<br />

RATIONALE<br />

Raising development above the level of natural grade or the<br />

grade of abutting properties creates problematic conditions for<br />

adjacent properties, abutting streets and open spaces. These<br />

problems relate to issues of drainage, pedestrian access, and<br />

the quality of the public realm. Where it is necessary to resolve<br />

grade differences, stepped terraces are the preferred solution.<br />

To the extent possible, new developments should establish<br />

a conventional relationship to grade with a moderate grade<br />

change to differentiate the public and private realms. Any<br />

additional steps required to gain access to the first floor level<br />

should be within the unit.<br />

Official Plan Reference<br />

2.3.1 Healthy Neighbourhoods: Policy 1 | 3.1.1 The Public<br />

Realm: Policy 13 | 3.1.2 Built Form: Policy 1c<br />

43<br />

BUILDING CONFIGURATION AND MASSING | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES


BUILDING CONFIGURATION AND MASSING | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

3.4 BUILDING ENTRANCE AND FRONT YARD<br />

Ensure well-designed front entrances and and front yards.<br />

Limit the number of below-grade entrances to reduce impact to the public<br />

realm.<br />

a. Provide a transition from the public realm to private space<br />

with visual cues such as a change in materials, grade,<br />

landscaping, and architectural elements.<br />

b. Design building entrances and private outdoor amenity<br />

spaces to:<br />

• be integrated with the building massing/design, landscape<br />

features, and surrounding neighbourhood characteristics<br />

• maximize usability and comfort by enhancing quality of<br />

space with attention to building detail<br />

c. Allow encroachment of stoop or porch into minimum front<br />

yard setback to a maximum of 1.8m from main building face<br />

and up to a maximum of 50% of the front yard setback area.<br />

d. Finish canopy soffits and floors with durable and attractive<br />

materials to avoid exposing building structure (eg.<br />

unfinished concrete floor slabs).<br />

Maximize landscape area<br />

and ensure sufficient soil<br />

volume for tree growth<br />

g. Maintain high visibility and direct, generous, universal<br />

access from the public sidewalk to entrances located within<br />

a pedestrian mews or courtyard.<br />

h. On corner or double-fronting sites, locate building fronts<br />

and entrances facing both streets. Buildings on corner sites<br />

require additional attention to detail in order to enhance the<br />

corner.<br />

Max 1.5m<br />

Below Established<br />

Grade<br />

Window Well<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

i. Where building entrances take their address from courtyards<br />

and pedestrian mews rather than streets, provide a wayfinding<br />

system additional to the street address system.<br />

j. Where retail uses are part of the development, provide a<br />

separate entrance to each ground floor retail unit that is<br />

identifiable and directly accessible from the public sidewalk.<br />

Porch - a raised platform projected from the building face at the<br />

level of the entrance that may be open or covered<br />

Max 1.2m<br />

Entrance Area<br />

Width<br />

Max 1.2m<br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

e. Provide prominent, well-designed and integrated building<br />

entrances such as porches, porticos or canopies along the<br />

building frontage.<br />

f. Avoid multiple entrances to units completely recessed into<br />

the building and consider only in areas where minimal<br />

setbacks are appropriate and only when a very high level of<br />

architectural and landscape detail is applied.<br />

a. Design porches to:<br />

• be a maximum height above grade of 0.9m<br />

• allow encroachment of stoop or porch into front setback<br />

to a maximum of 1.8m from main building face and up to<br />

a maximum of 50% of the minimum front yard setback<br />

• be open or covered with opaque or translucent railings<br />

with hedges and foundation planting<br />

44<br />

Continued on next page…


Stoop - a small landing and/or steps in front of and at the level<br />

of the building entrance<br />

a. Design stoops to:<br />

• be a maximum height above grade of 0.9m<br />

• have railings, where required and foundation planting<br />

• have an awning or other weather protecting feature over<br />

the entrance<br />

Below-grade Entrance- an entrance to a below-grade unit with<br />

stairs<br />

a. Design below-grade entrance to:<br />

• have a maximum horizontal width and depth of 1.2m<br />

including the stair access and landing area.<br />

• have a maximum vertical depth of 1.5m from the grade of<br />

the adjacent sidewalk.<br />

b. Below-grade entrances are permitted along public and<br />

private streets provided that the soft landscaped area within<br />

the required building setback area has adequate soil volume<br />

to support mature public and private street trees and other<br />

plantings.<br />

RATIONALE<br />

The design of a building's front entrance and front yard is<br />

important due to its function and as a point of focus, transition,<br />

and entry for each visitor. The design, location, materiality,<br />

and scale of the entrance is also important in establishing the<br />

character for the building.<br />

Well-designed entrances and front yards maintain a level of<br />

formality and provide transition between the public and private<br />

realm.<br />

Limiting the size, location and encroachment of entrances and<br />

stairs and terraces will help to ensure that sufficient soil volume<br />

is available to support trees growth and other planting within<br />

the front yard setback.<br />

Limiting the number of stairs and the height of the porch or<br />

stoop is important to ensure that the front yard area is not<br />

overwhelmed by these elements and there is sufficient space<br />

for landscaping.<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

Well-designed building<br />

entrance with raised<br />

porch, landscaped area,<br />

and canopy.<br />

Avoid excessive<br />

protruding architectural<br />

elements such as<br />

balcondies, roof lines,<br />

canopies, stairs, and<br />

below-grade terraces<br />

create an unpleasant<br />

pedestrian environment<br />

between buildings and<br />

over shadow amenity<br />

spaces below.<br />

Carefully composed<br />

and detailed facade,<br />

entrance, and<br />

fenestration design<br />

combined with high<br />

quality materials create<br />

a positive impression on<br />

the public realm.<br />

BUILDING CONFIGURATION AND MASSING | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

Official Plan Reference<br />

3.1.1 Public Realm: Policies 1d and 1e | 3.1.2 Built Form: Policy 1b, 3a, 3b, 5b, 5c and 6 |<br />

Related Standards, Guidelines & Studies<br />

Toronto Green Standard |<br />

Continued on next page…<br />

45


BUILDING CONFIGURATION AND MASSING | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

3.5 PRIVATE OUTDOOR AMENITY SPACE<br />

Maximize and enhance the usability, comfort and appearance of front entrances<br />

and private outdoor amenity spaces.<br />

Design roof top private<br />

amenity spaces to limit<br />

overlook into adjacent<br />

neighbourhood<br />

Inset balconies to avoid<br />

encroaching into facing<br />

distance and create<br />

negative impacts to<br />

units below<br />

a. Design private outdoor amenity spaces to:<br />

• provide an entrance to only one unit<br />

• have access to sunlight<br />

• provide functional outdoor space with greater than 1.5m<br />

in horizontal depth<br />

• design family-sized units to have views and access onto<br />

outdoor play area where possible<br />

• mitigate impacts on the public realm and neighbours -<br />

increased separation distances between buildings may be<br />

required to reduce impacts<br />

Grade-related private<br />

amenity spaces permitted<br />

on local streets only when<br />

raised & screened<br />

Private outdoor amenity spaces in low-rise, multi-unit buildings<br />

typically take the following forms:<br />

Balcony - an outdoor elevated platform projected from or<br />

integrated into a building which extends the interior living space<br />

and is enclosed by a parapet or railing (French/Juliette balcony<br />

while a useful attribute does not constitute private outdoor<br />

amenity space)<br />

Below-grade private amenity<br />

spaces are permitted internal to<br />

the site with max vertical depth<br />

of 1.5m<br />

Provide indoor amenity<br />

space and connect with the<br />

outdoor amenity space<br />

where possible<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

a. Inset or partially inset to offer greater privacy and shelter<br />

from wind, reduce the building bulk and minimize the<br />

impact of shadow on other amenity spaces below.<br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

46<br />

b. No private outdoor amenity space for dwelling units may be<br />

located below-grade or at-grade in the setback area adjacent<br />

to a public or private street.<br />

c. Private outdoor amenity space may be provided on an<br />

existing or new residential public street (as shown on the<br />

Official Plan Land Use maps and as defined by DIPS) or a<br />

private street, when raised above-grade as part of the porch.<br />

b. Project no more than 0.75m beyond the face of the building<br />

(eg. in the form of a French or Juliette balcony) when there<br />

is private outdoor amenity space below and/or within a<br />

pedestrian mews and walkway.<br />

c. Provide railings that are solid or translucent glass to<br />

increase privacy and reduce bird strikes.<br />

Continued on next page…


Min1.5m - Max 3.0m<br />

From Building Face<br />

Inset balcony reduces impact of the overhang for terrace below.<br />

Below-Grade Private<br />

Outdoor Amenity<br />

Space<br />

Max 1.5m<br />

Below Established<br />

Grade<br />

Min 2.0m<br />

Landscape Area<br />

with Min 30m 3 Soil<br />

Volume<br />

Terrace - an outdoor area adjacent to a unit located abovegrade,<br />

at-grade, below-grade, or on a portion of the roof area<br />

on a building<br />

Above-Grade Terrace<br />

a. May be located adjacent to a public/private street or mews.<br />

b. Raise terrace a minimum of 0.6m and a maximum of 0.9m<br />

above grade.<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

c. Provide transitional landscape area with planting and<br />

landscape features.<br />

At-Grade and Below-Grade Terrace<br />

a. May be located internal to development site in pedestrian<br />

mews and not along public/private street, mews, and lane<br />

frontage.<br />

BUILDING CONFIGURATION AND MASSING | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

b. Limit the vertical depth of the below-grade terrace to a<br />

maximum of 1.5m from grade.<br />

c. Provide a minimum horizontal depth of 1.5m and a<br />

maximum of 3.0m from the main building face to the belowgrade<br />

terrace wall.<br />

d. Provide railings and hedging at the level of the walkway in<br />

order to provide visual privacy between pedestrians and<br />

occupants on the terrace.<br />

Landscaping at the level of the terrace and the sidwalk provide privacy for occupants of the<br />

outdoor amenity area.<br />

47


BUILDING CONFIGURATION AND MASSING | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

Roof Top Terrace<br />

a. Setback roof top terrace a minimum of 1.0m from the<br />

building face.<br />

b. Provide railings or walls that are translucent or solid to<br />

reduce overlook onto neighbouring properties.<br />

c. Program a shared terrace to accommodate outdoor<br />

activities such as seating and barbequing in a welllandscaped<br />

environment.<br />

RATIONALE<br />

For townhouses and low-rise, multi-unit residential<br />

developments, private outdoor amenity space is required in the<br />

Zoning By-law and/or desired as part of the development.<br />

Balconies and terraces can provide an important extension<br />

to the livable space of a dwelling unit. Under limited<br />

circumstances, terraces can act as an entrance into a unit as<br />

well. Care needs to be taken to ensure that the privacy of the<br />

occupants as well as those in nearby properties is maintained<br />

and public/private open space is not compromised.<br />

The placement and design of balconies and terraces can have a<br />

major impact on the real and perceived bulk of a building and, if<br />

poorly located and designed, may overly clutter the face of the<br />

building and add to the impact of shadowing, reduced privacy<br />

and loss of sky view.<br />

Private outdoor amenity space, such as balconies, gardens and<br />

roof terraces, should have access to sunlight, be comfortable<br />

and designed to afford a level of privacy. The needs of families<br />

with children and pet owners must also be considered.<br />

Energy efficiency considerations should factor into the design<br />

of balconies in terms of their location and the materials used in<br />

their construction. Furthermore, transparent glass balconies are<br />

generally discouraged, since they can pose a collision risk for<br />

migratory birds and do little to hide the household items often<br />

stored on them.<br />

Provide landscaped<br />

transition area to<br />

distinguish public<br />

and private realm<br />

Diagram showing apprpriate relationship between private outdoor amenity space and the<br />

public realm.<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

Ab il inci ime sim eaque in natiatquiate necae non pro dolupta vollanim quis aut lamus dis<br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

48<br />

Official Plan Reference<br />

3.1.2 Built Form: Policy 1b, 3a, 3b, 5b, 5c and 6 | 3.4 The Natural Environment: Policy 18f | 3.2.3 Parks and Open Space: Policy 1d<br />

3.3 Building New Neighbourhoods: Policy 2e | 5.1.3 Site Plan Control: Policy 3<br />

Related Standards, Guidelines & Studies<br />

Toronto Green Standard | Toronto Green Roof By-law


4.0 Public Realm - Creating Pride in Place<br />

4.1 Streetscape, Landscape and Stormwater Management<br />

4.1.1 Streetscape<br />

4.1.2 Landscape<br />

4.1.3 Storm Water Management<br />

4.2 Site Elements Design<br />

4.3.1 Lighting, mailboxes and Other Shared Elements (Garbage<br />

chutes, parking garage access stair and elevators)<br />

4.4 Public Art<br />

4.3 Detailed Design<br />

4.5.1 Building Elements Design<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

4.5.2 Windows, Doors and Roofs<br />

4.5.3 Materials<br />

PEDESTRIAN REALM - CREATING PRIDE IN PLACE | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

49


4.1 STREETSCAPE, LANDSCAPE AND STORMWATER MANAGEMENT<br />

PEDESTRIAN REALM - CREATING PRIDE IN PLACE | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

50<br />

Provide high-quality, sustainable streetscape and landscape between the building<br />

and adjacent streets, parks and open space. The attractiveness and amenity of<br />

everyday landscapes are important to the quality of people's lives.<br />

Streetscape with high quality materials, pedestrian amenities, and landscape design.<br />

4.1.1 STREETSCAPE<br />

a. Create a strong visual and physical connection between the<br />

building setback and public streetscape through the use of<br />

consistent materials, grades, and design elements.<br />

b. Organize streetscape and landscape elements to support<br />

safe and comfortable pedestrian movement, highlight<br />

important building features, such as entrances, screen<br />

less attractive elements, such as parking access and utility<br />

equipment.<br />

c. Emphasize front entrances with high quality architectural<br />

and landscape design and materials, including lighting of<br />

paths and entries.<br />

d. Provide sustainable streetscape and landscape in<br />

accordance with the Toronto Green Standard and Urban<br />

Forestry practices including:<br />

• use species that are hardy, drought and salt-tolerant, and<br />

resistant to the stresses of compacted soils and weather<br />

exposure; plant trees at least 1.0 m from street curbs<br />

• providing sufficient sidewalk space<br />

• planting high-branching deciduous trees evenly spaced<br />

at 8.0-10.0 metre intervals to form a canopy, with a<br />

minimum volume of 30m 3 of high quality soil per tree. The<br />

minimum soil volume can be 20m 3 per tree where the soil<br />

volume is shared<br />

• avoid monocultures of street trees for extended segments<br />

which can be susceptible to disease<br />

• using high albedo and permeable materials to manage the<br />

urban heat island effect and stormwater<br />

• maximizing on-site stormwater infiltration, capture and<br />

re-use<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

• providing energy efficient, pedestrian-scale lighting with<br />

shielded fixtures and automatic shut-off devices<br />

• providing bicycle parking<br />

e. On streets characterized by soft landscape setbacks or<br />

where residential ground floor uses require more privacy<br />

from the adjacent sidewalk, provide additional landscaping<br />

between the building face and public sidewalk. Such<br />

treatment may include tree and shrub planting, minor grade<br />

changes, railings, curbs, lighting and seating.<br />

f. Coordinate space for tree planting with utility locations and<br />

other city infrastructure. Where street trees and utilities<br />

conflict, additional building setbacks may be required to<br />

provide space for street trees.<br />

g. Provide lot frontage landscaping in accordance with City<br />

of Toronto Zoning By-law 569-2013.


4.1.2 LANDSCAPE<br />

To promote safe and comfortable use in open spaces and on pathways, provide<br />

high quality and attractive landscaping including lighting, tree and shrub<br />

planting, decorative paving, seating etc.<br />

a. Retain and protect existing trees, vegetation, natural slopes<br />

and native soils to integrate these features into the overall<br />

landscape plan.<br />

b. Distribute landscaping throughout the site to soften and<br />

screen services areas, reinforce circulation routes, create<br />

pleasant pedestrian conditions and maximize shade and<br />

stormwater benefits.<br />

c. Landscaped areas should be designed to accommodate the<br />

following:<br />

• Urban Forestry's Guidelines such as Plant A Tree, Grow<br />

Toronto's Urban Forest and Ravine Tree Planting along<br />

with Toronto Green Standard requirements<br />

• high-branching, deciduous shade and ornamental trees<br />

planted at intervals (or as appropriate to the selected<br />

species) to quickly establish continuous canopy coverage<br />

d. Select plant material that is suitable to the growing<br />

environment of the site:<br />

• include a minimum of 50% suitable native species<br />

• avoid planting invasive species, particularly near ravines<br />

and other natural areas, where only native species should<br />

be used<br />

• consider sun, shade and irrigation requirements. Where<br />

possible, collect rainwater from rooftops and other<br />

surfaces for plant irrigation. Identify storage reservoirs<br />

and other applicable irrigation elements on the Landscape<br />

Plan. Locate valves and other maintenance controls in<br />

discrete, yet accessible areas.<br />

• incorporate a variety of deciduous and coniferous trees<br />

and shrubs for year-round interest, texture, shape,<br />

seasonal colour and variety within each plant type<br />

e. Where landscaping may have an impact on motorist/<br />

pedestrian sight lines, keep shrubs below 0.85m in height<br />

and prune trees so that the lowest branches will be at least<br />

2.0m above ground level. Limit any other landscape features<br />

that might cause obstructions to a maximum height of 1.0<br />

metre.<br />

Example of good landscaping.<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

Ratain and protect existing trees.<br />

f. Maintain overhanging branches of trees or shrubs adjacent<br />

to pedestrian pathways for a clear pedestrian zone of at least<br />

2.0 m.<br />

g. Provide a landscaped area with a minimum width of 3.0m<br />

between surface parking and public and private streets<br />

and a minimum of 3.0m between all surface parking,<br />

streets, mews and lanes and an abutting property. Consult<br />

the applicable Zoning By-law for additional setback<br />

requirements.<br />

h. Provide adequate snow storage on site according to City<br />

requirements.<br />

51<br />

PEDESTRIAN REALM - CREATING PRIDE IN PLACE | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES


4.1.3 STORMWATER MANAGEMENT<br />

PEDESTRIAN REALM - CREATING PRIDE IN PLACE | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

Integrate innovative stormwater management strategies into new developments<br />

to create functional and attractive landscapes.<br />

Green roof with native sedum mix. Credit: PWL Partnership Landscape Architects Inc.<br />

a. refer to the Toronto Green Standard and the Wet Weather<br />

Flow Management Guidelines for water balance targets and<br />

recommended stormwater management strategies.<br />

b. Minimize the extent of impermeable surfaces for hard paved<br />

areas; use permeable paving.<br />

c. Manage rainwater and snowmelt on-site with best practice<br />

designs that encourage infiltration, evapo-transpiration and<br />

water re-use:<br />

• apply a “treatment train” approach<br />

• plant trees, shrubs and other absorbent landscaping to<br />

provide shade and places for water uptake<br />

• create bio-retention areas, such as swales and vegetated<br />

areas<br />

• incorporate opportunities to harvest rainwater (active<br />

or passive) from rooftops and other hard surfaces for<br />

landscape irrigation<br />

RATIONALE<br />

Well-designed and vibrant streetscapes and landscapes are<br />

vital to the character and quality of the building site and the<br />

surrounding public realm, as well as to the livability of the City.<br />

Public streets, parks, and open space must safely and<br />

comfortably accommodate pedestrian movement, with street<br />

furnishings, lighting, bicycle parking, and landscaping. (as<br />

outlined in the City of Toronto Streetscape Manual, and<br />

Toronto Green Standard). All streets should have sidewalks<br />

and trees. When planting trees, it is beneficial to have as much<br />

appropriate planting medium as possible to enable the tree<br />

to grow to maturity. Less space reduces the life expectancy<br />

of the tree and the benefit that the tree will provide to the<br />

environment.<br />

High quality landscape design, material and maintenance,<br />

throughout the site, also plays a critical role in the success<br />

of a development. Good streetscaping and landscaping in<br />

a development contributes in a substantial way to citizens'<br />

quality of life and:<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

• has a relatively low cost but a high impact on the<br />

appearance<br />

• helps to reduce wind and weather impacts<br />

• helps to reduce the heat island effect and heating and<br />

cooling costs<br />

• can offer aesthetic enjoyment, escape, tranquility, and a<br />

sense of belonging to an area<br />

• is often an important element in providing privacy and in<br />

making the transition from public to private areas<br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

d. Where installed, bio-retention areas should be appropriately<br />

designed and located to filter, store and/or convey the<br />

expected stormwater flows from surrounding paved areas.<br />

Note: Bio-retention areas do not take the place of shared<br />

outdoor amenity area on site but can be integrated into the<br />

development, enhancing the open space.<br />

An ideal pedestrian environment includes trees for shade and<br />

greenery, plantings for seasonal variety and interest, pedestrian<br />

scale lighting for safety and appearance and permeable paving<br />

and soft landscaping for water infiltration.<br />

Allowance for pedestrians, cycling, motorist safety (as in<br />

sightlines) and maintenance need to be included.<br />

52


Public Sidewalk<br />

Edge Zone<br />

Stormwater refers to rainwater and melted snow that flows<br />

over roads, parking lots, lawn and other sites. Under natural<br />

conditions, stormwater is intercepted by vegetation and then<br />

absorbed into the ground and filtered and eventually replenishes<br />

aquifers or flows into streams and rivers. Later, part of it is<br />

returned to the atmosphere in the form of evapotranspiration.<br />

In urbanized areas, however, impervious surfaces such as<br />

streets and roofs prevent precipitation from naturally soaking<br />

into the ground. Instead, the water runs rapidly into storm<br />

drains, municipal sewers and drainage ditches and on its way,<br />

picks up pesticides, road salts, heavy metals, oils, bacteria, and<br />

other harmful pollutants and transports them through municipal<br />

sewers into streams, rivers and lakes.<br />

The Toronto Green Standard and the Wet Weather Flow<br />

Management Guidelines provide guidance on water balance<br />

targets and stormwater management strategies such as<br />

rainwater harvesting, green roofs, bio-retention, permeable<br />

pavement, soakaways and swales, to help ensure the continued<br />

health of aquifers, streams, rivers, lakes, fisheries and<br />

terrestrial habitats in our watersheds.<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

Front Yard<br />

Setback<br />

Min<br />

3.0m<br />

PL<br />

Min<br />

2.1m<br />

Min<br />

6.0m<br />

Planting &<br />

Furniture Zone<br />

Public Street<br />

PEDESTRIAN REALM - CREATING PRIDE IN PLACE | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

Bio retention feature integrated into development. Credit: PWL Partnership Landsape<br />

Architects Inc.<br />

Rooftop urban agriculture. Credit: PWL Partnership Landscape Architects Inc.<br />

Official Plan Reference<br />

Related Standards, Guidelines & Studies<br />

2.3.1 Healthy Neighbourhoods: Policy 5<br />

Urban Design Streetscape Manual | Toronto Green Standard |<br />

3.1.1 The Public Realm: Policy 1d, 5, 6, 7, 12, 13, 14, 16, 17, and 18 |<br />

Vibrant Streets | Toronto Walking Strategy |<br />

3.1.2 Built Form: Policy 1d, 2b, 5a, 5b, 5d, 5e, 5g and 6 |<br />

Percent for Public Art Program Guidelines |<br />

3.4 The Natural Environment: Policy 1aiii, 1d, 18a and 18f |<br />

Wet Weather Flow Management Guidelines |<br />

4.1 Neighbourhoods: Policy 5f, 5g, 5h, 9b and 9c |<br />

Design Guidelines for 'Greening Surface Parking Lots'<br />

4.2 Apartment Neighbourhoods: Policy 2c, 3d, 3e, 3f and 3h |<br />

4.5 Mixed Use Areas: Policy 2e, 2f | 5.1.3 Site Plan Control: Policy 3b, 3d, 3e and 3g<br />

53


4.2 SITE ELEMENTS DESIGN<br />

PEDESTRIAN REALM - CREATING PRIDE IN PLACE | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

Careful selection, placement, and design of site elements help to elevate the<br />

quality and the daily experience of the development.<br />

Good lighting provides improved comfort and sense of safety in the public realm.<br />

4.2.1 LIGHTING<br />

a. Provide a comprehensive Lighting Plan for the site. Lighting<br />

should help to create an identity for the development,<br />

enhance adjacent streets and pedestrian environments and<br />

be appropriate to the location, context and scale of the areas<br />

being lit.<br />

b. Select different luminaires with a coordinated appearance to<br />

light pedestrian pathways, building and site entrances and<br />

other relevant features.<br />

c. Provide pedestrian-scaled lighting, such as bollards or<br />

lower-scale pole fixtures along pedestrian routes.<br />

d. Balance the need for safety and security with the reduction<br />

of energy consumption and light pollution:<br />

• ensure all circulation routes are well-lit<br />

• install lighting that is appropriately scaled to its purpose,<br />

i.e. avoid “over lighting”<br />

Bicycle parking rings with high quality design.<br />

• incorporate opportunities for off-grid power generation,<br />

e.g. solar, wind, etc.<br />

• provide a photometric drawing which illustrates both<br />

horizontal (at grade) and vertical (at 1.8m above grade)<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

lighting level<br />

e. Consider lighting elements for their aesthetic and design<br />

value, as well as their lighting function cost or ease of<br />

maintenance.<br />

f. Coordinate the location of lighting with pedestrian<br />

clearways, tree planting and other landscaping.<br />

4.2.2 MAILBOXES AND OTHER SHARED<br />

ELEMENTS (Garbge chutes, parking<br />

garage access tairs and elevators)<br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

• direct light downward, with shielded fixtures to avoid light<br />

overspill on adjacent properties, streets and open spaces.<br />

Strive for vertical lighting along property lines to be 0 foot<br />

candles<br />

• use energy-efficient bulbs<br />

a. Integrate bicycle parking, parking garage ramps and access<br />

stairways, mailboxes, garbage chutes, generally within the<br />

building, and other applicable site elements such as public<br />

art into the site design and layout. Indicate the location of<br />

these elements on the Site Plan.<br />

54<br />

Continued on next page…


. Where integrating site elements within the building is<br />

deemed to not be possible by City Staff, conveniently locate<br />

site elements in attractive, well-designed structures with<br />

high quality materials and landscaping and incorporate<br />

sustainable materials and technologies whenever possible.<br />

d. Locate site elements in highly visible, well-lit, accessible<br />

and weather protected areas with well-landscaped pathways<br />

leading to the areas.<br />

e. Provide address numbers for each unit and way-finding<br />

signage where appropriate.<br />

f. Locate ventilation shafts and grates, away from the public<br />

sidewalk and walkways (especially the pedestrian clearway)<br />

and public or private open spaces.<br />

g. Locate transformers, utility metres and other site and<br />

building mechanical/equipment within a building, at the rear<br />

of the property, underground and/or ensure that they are not<br />

visible from the street or other public/private space:<br />

• locate individual HVAC units (heating, ventilation, air<br />

conditioning) equipment either on the roof, screened from<br />

view of the public realm or integrated into the building<br />

away from outside seating areas and building entrances.<br />

h. Where it is not technically feasible to integrate “back of<br />

house” activities underground or within the building mass,<br />

locate these activities to limit negative impacts on the safety,<br />

comfort, and quality of the public realm. Where appropriate,<br />

use high-quality architectural elements and landscape<br />

design to screen these activities from public view. Options<br />

include insets into building facades and screening with<br />

landscaping or low walls.<br />

i. Utility locations should not interfere with the viability of tree<br />

maturity or with stormwater treatment device.<br />

Well-designed seating bench integrated into landscaped planting bed.<br />

Good example of mail area integrated into building design with lighting and canopy.<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

Locate and integrate utility meters in recessed coves and/or screen with landscape<br />

plantings to help maintain an attractive streetscape.<br />

PEDESTRIAN REALM - CREATING PRIDE IN PLACE | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

j. Locate all elements on site plan drawings<br />

Official Plan Reference<br />

3.1.1 The Public Realm: Policy 1d, 6, 12 and 14<br />

3.1.2 Built Form: Policy 2c, 2d, 3b, 3d, 5c|<br />

4.2 Apartment Neighbourhoods: Policy 2d, 2e, 3g and 3i<br />

4.5 Mixed Use Areas: Policy 2j | 5.1.3 Site Plan Control: Policy 3g<br />

Related Standards, Guidelines & Studies<br />

Toronto Green Standard<br />

Poorly located utilities and mechanical systems adjacent to front entrance and street<br />

frontage negatively impact the quality and comfort of the public realm.<br />

55


4.3 BUILDING ELEMENTS<br />

PEDESTRIAN REALM - CREATING PRIDE IN PLACE | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

Ensure attention to the quality of architectural design, materials, building<br />

articulation, and placement of mechanical and utilities.<br />

Section 4.5 focuses on various elements of the building<br />

envelope and site (see also Section 4.3 Site Elements Design)<br />

that contribute to the composition of the external appearance<br />

and that help create character and identity for development. It<br />

aims to provide guidance and practical solutions to issues that<br />

arise regarding design during the application stage. Overall,<br />

while each building may have its own distinct architectural<br />

identity, all buildings should be designed to provide a collective<br />

sense of cohesion and harmony.<br />

a. Ensure the highest quality of materials and detailing,<br />

particularly where there is an immediate interface with the<br />

public realm.<br />

b. The building elements which require careful attention to<br />

locations and design include:<br />

• doors, windows, roofs<br />

• retaining walls<br />

• railings<br />

• porches<br />

• flues, ventilation pipes and covers<br />

• flashings, gutters, pipes and other rainwater details<br />

• garage doors<br />

• ironmongery and decorative features<br />

• gas regulators, hydro meters, HVAC<br />

c. Anticipate the need and design for building elements early<br />

on in the design process.<br />

d. Provide variations in architectural design between building<br />

blocks for multiple block developments to create interest<br />

and character.<br />

Carefully composed and detailed facade, entrance, and fenestration design combined with<br />

high quality materials create a positive impression on the public realm.<br />

4.3.1 WINDOWS, DOORS AND ROOFS<br />

The position, shape and size of windows, doors and roofs<br />

have a profound effect on the elevation and are important to<br />

consider.<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

a. Variation in the design and articulation of each building<br />

façade is encouraged to provide visual interest and to<br />

respond to design opportunities and differing facing<br />

conditions.<br />

b. Vary the design and articulation of each façade to respond<br />

to changes in solar orientation. Where appropriate,<br />

adjust internal layouts, glazing ratios, balcony placement,<br />

fenestration, and other aspects of the design to manage<br />

passive solar gain and improve building energy performance<br />

(see also 3.4 Building Entrances and Front yard).<br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

56<br />

Detailed design of canopy<br />

and railing help provide<br />

unique building character.<br />

c. Ensure that windows and doors are of an appropriate scale<br />

in the façade and that each element in the façade has some<br />

relationship to each other and reflects the floor hierarchy.<br />

d. Distinguish building units and unit types by alternating<br />

roof types and color schemes to add variety and unit<br />

individuality.


Roofs<br />

The following elements should be considered regarding roofs:<br />

• Primary and secondary roofing materials<br />

• Construction form and detailing<br />

• Roof pitch and shape such as plain, gable, hip, flat,<br />

monopitch etc.<br />

• Fire break walls<br />

• Eaves, fascias and soffits<br />

• Dormers and sky lights<br />

• Parapets<br />

• Photo voltaic panels<br />

• Roof top amenity space access<br />

a. A limited range of roof types should be used per<br />

neighbourhood particularly if roofs are to be one of the<br />

devices to establish an identity for a neighbourhood.<br />

b. Developments should not just include the traditional pitched<br />

roof but particularly on key frontages should consider<br />

incorporating alternative styles such as mono-pitch, flat,<br />

dutch gable and curved as they can help create a more<br />

distinctive character.<br />

c. Pitched or mansard roofs which over-dominate the building<br />

should generally be avoided, but particularly on larger<br />

buildings (i.e. stacked and back to back townhouses and<br />

low-rise apartments as the scale of these building types<br />

does not relate to house-form buildings). Instead consider a<br />

step back of the top floor.<br />

d. Where possible, organize roof slopes so that they can<br />

accommodate photo voltaic panels.<br />

e. Avoid lengthy stretches of pitched roof on buildings at the<br />

same ridge and eave and height and provide articulation to<br />

emphasize the individual quality of the units. At the same<br />

time, avoid roofs that are overly complicated.<br />

Well positioned and high quality doors, windows, and architectural details such as canopy,<br />

railing, screen, and planting areas all work together to enhance the public realm.<br />

Example of building facade over cluttered with rainwater leaders, air conditioning<br />

units, utilities, and vents.<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

f. Roof material, shape, texture and colors should be<br />

compatible with the overall architectural style of the<br />

buildings.<br />

g. Careful consideration must be given to the use of dormers.<br />

They can clutter the roofscape and detract from the<br />

proportions of the building if they are used excessively,<br />

made too large, too small, poorly organized and overcomplicated<br />

in design. Conversely a well-designed dormer<br />

and placed can add interest and quality to the building.<br />

h. Building elements that provide access to roof top amenity<br />

spaces should be for this purpose only and not used for<br />

living space.<br />

i. Consider the detailed design of the roof parapet firewall<br />

breaks in pitched roofs as they are often visible from the<br />

street.<br />

PEDESTRIAN REALM - CREATING PRIDE IN PLACE | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

j. Rooftop building systems (i.e., mechanical and electrical<br />

equipment, satellite dishes) should be screened from all<br />

key observation points by integrating them into the building<br />

design with parapets, screens or other methods.<br />

k. Consider the design and location of chimneys to ensure<br />

that they do not have a negative impact on neighbours and<br />

complement the overall building design.<br />

Continued on next page…<br />

57


4.3.2 MATERIALS<br />

PEDESTRIAN REALM - CREATING PRIDE IN PLACE | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

58<br />

High quality materials and carefully detailed design work together to create attractive building. Credit: Teeple Architects Inc.<br />

The application process will provide a greater level of clarity on g. To retain the coherence of an elevation or street frontage (to<br />

the external design of buildings:<br />

avoid it being untidy or too busy), it is generally a good idea<br />

a. Design buildings on both sides of the street holistically with<br />

a small selection of materials so that they can be “read as<br />

one”.<br />

b. Design buildings to blend in visually with buildings in the<br />

immediate surroundings, particularly those along the same<br />

street.<br />

c. Use materials that are of high quality, wear well with age<br />

and last a long time with low embodied energy and locally<br />

sourced if possible.<br />

d. Traditional materials such as brick are strongly encouraged<br />

and can be used effectively in both contemporary and<br />

traditional designs.<br />

e. Use materials with contrasting grain as well as colour for<br />

example brick, metal and wood.<br />

f. Exterior Insulation and Finish System (EIFS) and stuccotextured<br />

foam trim molding are discouraged on main<br />

facades.<br />

to:<br />

• restrict the number of materials and to employ the same<br />

material in different parts of the façade or frontage<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

• generally use no more than three facing materials per<br />

elevation or street frontage. This is particularly important if<br />

materials are to be the key feature used to give identity to a<br />

neighbourhood<br />

h. The design, detailing and material quality of elements such<br />

as railings, windows, doors, trim, eaves, and steps are<br />

critical to displaying a building's overall quality.<br />

i. Changes in materials and color generally should not occur<br />

in the same plane as this may result in a "thin" or applied<br />

quality. Changes that correspond to variations in building<br />

mass or are separated by a building element achieve greater<br />

emphasis on the massing.<br />

Continued on next page…


RATIONALE<br />

The City of Toronto in these Guidelines, is not advocating<br />

and being prescriptive about a particular style of building or<br />

landscape for new residential development. Nor does it want to<br />

constrain design skills and creativity. However, good public<br />

realm demands high quality materials and design for buildings,<br />

streetscape and landscape.<br />

If Toronto has a traditional building material, it would be<br />

red and buff brick. Although a wide variety of materials have<br />

been used throughout the City's development, brick remains<br />

a durable and attractive material in both contemporary and<br />

traditional designs.<br />

Consideration should be given to the choice of materials for<br />

a development by determining the dominant character of<br />

materials in the surrounding area and whether this contributes<br />

to the character or identity of the street and/or area.<br />

As a general principle, the appearance of buildings and sites<br />

should reflect Toronto’s ethos of a forward thinking, innovative<br />

and unique city. New developments should provide an exemplar<br />

architecture that reflects this. Buildings should 'be of their<br />

time and place’. Poor quality buildings with a pastiche of<br />

architectural styles and details will not be supported as they<br />

do not help to create a coherent identity for the development<br />

and by extension, the City. Good contemporary design can<br />

sit alongside existing traditional development if appropriately<br />

designed. The key with all buildings is good quality architecture<br />

and materials.<br />

Official Plan Amendment 66 provides the City of Toronto with<br />

new powers over the exterior design of buildings as well as the<br />

inclusion of sustainable building features under paragraphs<br />

2(iv) and (v) of Section 114(5) site plan control. These<br />

provisions will help the City to achieve the objectives in this<br />

section.<br />

A simple palette of materials carefully detailed is designed to wear well with age.<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

PEDESTRIAN REALM - CREATING PRIDE IN PLACE | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

Official Plan Reference<br />

3.1.1 The Public Realm: Policy 1d and 1e |<br />

3.1.2 Built Form: Policy 3b, d and 6 |<br />

5.1.3 Site Plan Control: 1, 2 and 3<br />

Related Standards, Guidelines & Studies<br />

Toronto Green Standard<br />

59


4.4 PUBLIC ART<br />

PEDESTRIAN REALM - CREATING PRIDE IN PLACE | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

Pursue public art opportunities and funding strategies on large building sites, or<br />

adjacent public lands, to enhance the quality of the development, the public realm<br />

and the city.<br />

Public art animates an under-utilized space in a new development. Credit: Shoreline Commemorative, Paul Raff Studios. Photo by: Scott Narsworthy.<br />

a. Where applicable, provide adequate building setbacks and<br />

space around public art so that it can be properly viewed<br />

and experienced from the public realm.<br />

RATIONALE<br />

Public art enriches the public realm by making buildings and<br />

open spaces more interesting, engaging, and memorable.<br />

When considered early in the project planning stages, the most<br />

effective locations and opportunities for public art can often be<br />

identified and secured.<br />

Public art opportunities on low-rise, multi-unit building sites<br />

may include:<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

Public art integrated with landscape elements.<br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

60<br />

• a conceptual framework to organize open spaces<br />

including parks, plazas, setbacks, or streetscapes<br />

• an independent sculpture or two-dimensional work that<br />

marks an entryway, corner, feature area, or view terminus<br />

• a combination of visual arts with the building elements,<br />

including façades, canopies, floors, and lighting.<br />

• visual arts combined with landscape design, functional,<br />

and decorative elements of a site, such as water features,<br />

lighting, seating, paving, walls, fences, entrances and<br />

exits.<br />

Public art located in the vehicular drop-off area provides placemaking opportunity.<br />

Official Plan Reference<br />

3.1.2 Built Form: Policy 5g | 3.1.4 Public Art: Policy 1d and 1e<br />

Related Standards, Guidelines & Studies<br />

Percent for Public Art Program Guidelines


5.0<br />

Bringing it all together - Building Types and Development Scenarios<br />

5.1 Building Types<br />

5.1.1 Townhouse<br />

5.1.2 Stacked Townhouse<br />

5.1.3 Back to Back Townhouse<br />

5.1.4 Stacked and Back to Back Townhouse<br />

5.1.5 Apartment Building<br />

5.1.6 Hybrid Building<br />

5.2 Development Scenarios<br />

5.2.1 Shallow Mid-Block Parcel<br />

5.2.2 Deep Mid-Block Parcel<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

5.2.3 Parcel Adjacent or with Heritage Resource<br />

5.2.4 Parcel with Multiple Building Blocks<br />

5.2.5 Large Parcel with Tower and Neighbourhood Edge<br />

5.2.6 Large Development with Multiple Development Blocks<br />

BRINGING IT ALL TOGETHER - EXAMPLE OF TYPES AND DEVELOPMENT SCENARIOS | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

Credit: Quadrangle Architects Limited<br />

61


Bringing it all together - Example of Types and Development Scenerios | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

5.1 BUILDING TYPES<br />

Section 5.1 Building Types, describes and provides the typical characteristics and appropriate site conditions for townhouses, stacked,<br />

back to back and stacked and back to back townhouses and low-rise apartments including hybrid buildings. (For information on how<br />

the townhouse and low-rise apartment types relate to the building types set out in Zoning By-law 569-2013, see the Introduction on<br />

page 9 of this document).<br />

5.1.1 TOWNHOUSE<br />

Townhouses share a side walls with<br />

neighbouring units.<br />

Building Type Characteristics<br />

• 2 to 3 1/2 storeys<br />

• Shares side walls with neighbouring units<br />

• Individual unit entrance to grade at the front of building<br />

• Distinct front and back side of building<br />

• Private outdoor space, rear yard or deck<br />

• Front or rear integral garages, or garage as<br />

separate structure<br />

• Underground garage is sometime provided as part of<br />

larger development<br />

Appropriate Site Conditions<br />

Rear Access Garage<br />

Appropriate when:<br />

• Vehicular access from public or private lane at the<br />

rear of the site<br />

• Adequate landscape area and setbacks<br />

are provided to screen adjacent property from lane<br />

Separated Garage<br />

Appropriate when:<br />

• Vehicular access from public or private lane at the<br />

rear of the site<br />

• Consistent with existing condition along public or<br />

private lane<br />

• Rear yards can be accommodated for units<br />

Rear Access Garage<br />

Townhouse<br />

Variation 1<br />

Townhouse<br />

Variation 1<br />

Unit entrances at front of building only.<br />

Unit entrances at front of building only.<br />

Garage at the rear of the building accessed<br />

Townhouse<br />

throught public lane or private driveway<br />

Variation Garage 1at the rear of the building accessed<br />

throught public lane or private driveway<br />

Separated Unit entrances Garageat front of building only.<br />

Garage at the rear of the building accessed<br />

throught public lane or private driveway<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

Front Integral Townhouse Garage<br />

Variation 2<br />

Townhouse<br />

Variation 2<br />

Townhouse<br />

Variation 2<br />

A<br />

A<br />

A<br />

A<br />

A<br />

A<br />

B<br />

Appropriate site conditions:<br />

Sites where all unit entrances can fro<br />

Sites where all unit entrances can f<br />

Sites where front integral garages ar<br />

Appropriate Sites where site front conditions:<br />

integral garages a<br />

Access to public rear lane or private<br />

Sites Access where to public all unit rear entrances lane or can privat fro<br />

Sites where front integral garages ar<br />

Access to public rear lane or private<br />

B<br />

B<br />

B<br />

Appropriate site conditions:<br />

B<br />

B<br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

Front Integral Garage<br />

Avoid wherever possible, only appropriate when:<br />

• No vehicular access can be accommodated at the<br />

rear of the site<br />

• Adequate front yard landscaped setbacks and soil<br />

volume for street trees can be achieved<br />

• Unit width is a minimum of 6.0m<br />

A<br />

A<br />

A<br />

B<br />

B<br />

B<br />

62<br />

Townhouse<br />

Variation 3<br />

Townhouse<br />

Appropriate site conditions:<br />

Appropriate site conditions:<br />

Sites where all unit entrances can fro


ions:<br />

A A<br />

A A<br />

A A<br />

A A<br />

B B<br />

B B<br />

nces ont onto can onto public front onto street public with with access street with to to public access lane lane to to public or or private lane driveway or or private at driveway at the the rear rear of at at of site the the site rear of of site site<br />

A<br />

A<br />

A<br />

A<br />

re not not appropriate due due to to neighbourhood character such such as as front front yard yard landscaped setbacks or B or street type type<br />

B<br />

garages are are not not appropriate due to to neighbourhood character such as as front yard landscaped setbacks or or street type<br />

e or driveway or private where driveway appropriate where appropriate building setback building and and setback landscape and screening landscape can screening can be be provided<br />

can be be provided<br />

ns:<br />

nt onto public street with access to public lane or private driveway at the rear of site<br />

ces can front onto public street with access to public lane or private driveway at the rear of site<br />

not appropriate due to neighbourhood character such as front yard landscaped setbacks or street type<br />

arages are not appropriate due to neighbourhood character such as front yard landscaped setbacks or street type<br />

riveway where appropriate building setback and landscape screening can be provided<br />

or private driveway where appropriate building setback and landscape screening can be provided<br />

A A<br />

A A<br />

A<br />

A<br />

A A<br />

A<br />

B B<br />

B<br />

A A<br />

A<br />

B B<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

B<br />

A generous landscape area along the rear property line provides<br />

buffer for adjacent property from new townhouses and garage and<br />

enhances the views from the townhouses<br />

Separate garages are integrated into the design of the building,<br />

landscape and laneway.<br />

Bringing it all together - Example of Types and Development Scenerios | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

A A<br />

A A<br />

A A<br />

A A<br />

B B<br />

B B<br />

Avoid front integral garages that dominate the building facade and<br />

streetscape leaving little room for landscaping and front yards.<br />

ions:<br />

A<br />

A<br />

A<br />

A<br />

B<br />

ront nces onto can onto public front onto street public but but no street no access but but to no no to public access lane lane to to public or or private lane driveway or or private at driveway at the the rear rear of at at of site the the site rear of of site site<br />

B<br />

63<br />

garages l re acceptable are are acceptable and and appropriate and appropriate amounts of of amounts front front yard yard of of landscape front yard area/soil landscape volumn area/soil can can volumn be be achieved<br />

can be be achieved


Bringing it all together - Example of Types and Development Scenerios | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

5.1.2 STACKED TOWNHOUSE<br />

Stacked townhouses share side walls and have units stacked vertically. All units<br />

have direct access to grade from the front of the building, allowing the rear of the<br />

site to be used as shared or private amenity space.<br />

Building Type Characteristics<br />

• Share side walls and have units stacked vertically<br />

• Units have direct access to grade at the front of building<br />

• Distinct front and back sides<br />

• Underground parking typical<br />

Appropriate Site Conditions<br />

Appropriate when:<br />

• Rear yard to rear yard building relationship is preferred<br />

to interface with new or existing neighbourhood<br />

• Underground parking is provided<br />

• Servicing and loading areas are integrated into the<br />

building<br />

• Shadow, overlook, and privacy concerns are mitigated<br />

• No below-grade or at-grade private outdoor amenity<br />

spaces are provided along public street frontage<br />

Design Considerations<br />

• Provide prominence to the entry area by including<br />

canopy and stoop or porch<br />

• Detail the entrance area carefully with high quality,<br />

durable materials, attention to detail and lighting<br />

• Provide distingishing features in multiple block<br />

developments to improve wayfinding and variety to<br />

building design<br />

Typical Layout<br />

A<br />

C<br />

A<br />

B<br />

Various forms of stacked townhouses exist. Some arrangements have a single level at-grade units with<br />

a two-storey upper unit.<br />

B<br />

A<br />

Typical Layout<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

B<br />

A<br />

B<br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

64<br />

C<br />

Stacked Townhouse<br />

Variation 1<br />

Unit entrances on one side of the building<br />

Below-grade outdoor amenity spaces are not permitted along street frontage.<br />

Units stack on top of one another with<br />

grade-related entrances<br />

Stacked Townhouse<br />

Variation 1<br />

Unit entrances on one side of the building<br />

Units stack on top of one another with<br />

grade-related entrances<br />

Approp<br />

Small s<br />

Site wh<br />

Large s<br />

Parking<br />

Appropri<br />

Small site<br />

Site where<br />

Large site


ith<br />

Appropriate site conditions:<br />

B<br />

A<br />

B<br />

A<br />

B<br />

A<br />

B<br />

A<br />

C<br />

B<br />

A<br />

B<br />

A<br />

A<br />

Small sites with shallow depths where all unit entrances can be seen from public street.<br />

ng Appropriate site conditions:<br />

C<br />

C<br />

Site where a rear to rear condition is the preferred building condition.<br />

Small sites with shallow depths where all unit entrances can be seen from public street.<br />

Large Appropriate site with site multiple conditions: blocks where rear to rear condition is desired along edge of sites as transition.<br />

Site where a rear to rear condition is the preferred building condition.<br />

B<br />

Parking is provided underground<br />

A<br />

Small sites with shallow depths where all unit entrances can be seen from public street.<br />

Large site with multiple blocks where rear to rear condition is desired along edge of sites as transition.<br />

ng<br />

C<br />

Site where a rear to rear condition is the preferred building condition.<br />

Parking is provided underground<br />

Appropriate site conditions:<br />

Large site with multiple blocks where rear to rear condition is desired along edge of sites as transition.<br />

Small sites with shallow depths where all unit entrances can be seen from public street.<br />

n from public street.<br />

Parking is provided underground<br />

Site where a rear to rear condition is the preferred building condition.<br />

.<br />

Large site with multiple blocks where rear to rear condition is desired along edge of sites as transition.<br />

d along edge of sites as transition.<br />

B<br />

A<br />

C<br />

B<br />

A<br />

C<br />

B<br />

B<br />

A<br />

B<br />

A<br />

B<br />

A<br />

Accessible units are desirable in a stacked townhouse form. Internalize<br />

stairs to the upper units to reduce impact on streetscape and public realm.<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

B<br />

C<br />

B<br />

C<br />

B<br />

A<br />

A<br />

A<br />

B<br />

B<br />

C<br />

C<br />

Avoid building frontage that is dominated by paving, stairs and entrances.<br />

Consolidate stairs where possible and provide landscaping to screen<br />

below-grade entrances, enhance front yard, and streetscape.<br />

B<br />

B<br />

A<br />

A<br />

A<br />

A<br />

65<br />

Bringing it all together - Example of Types and Development Scenerios | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES


Sites where entrances at the rear of the build<br />

Bringing it all together - Example of Types and Development Scenerios | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

5.1.3 BACK TO BACK TOWNHOUSE<br />

Back to back townhouses share side and back walls with neighbouring units.<br />

and can have two frontages.<br />

Building Type Characteristics<br />

• Shares side and back walls with neighbouring units<br />

• Units have direct access to grade often on more<br />

than one side of the building<br />

• Underground parking<br />

Appropriate Site Conditions<br />

Appropriate when:<br />

• All individual unit entrances can be seen from a<br />

public street<br />

• No privacy and overlook concerns to adjacent<br />

property<br />

• Direct connections to public sidewalk are<br />

accommodated on multi-block sites by streets or<br />

pedestrian mews<br />

Design Considerations<br />

• In multiple front buildings, design all primary<br />

frontages of the building to address private/public<br />

streets, pedestrian mews, or open spaces<br />

• Provide prominence to the entry area by including<br />

canopy and stoop, or porch<br />

• Detail the entrance area carefully with high quality,<br />

durable materials, attention to detail, and lighting<br />

• Provide distingishing features in multiple block<br />

developments to improve wayfinding and variety to<br />

building design<br />

• Grade related units can have private amenity space<br />

provided they are designed with appropriate<br />

relationships to adjacent streets or buildings<br />

Type 1 - Back to Back, Mulitple Fronts<br />

Type 2 - Back to Back, Single Front<br />

Back to Back Townhouse<br />

Variation 1<br />

-Unit entrances on both sides of building<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

B<br />

A<br />

B<br />

A<br />

Appropriate site condition<br />

Small sites with two frontag<br />

Sites with no privacty conce<br />

Large site with multiple bloc<br />

Parking is provided undergr<br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

66<br />

Back to Back Townhouse<br />

Variation 2<br />

-Unit entrances on front of building only<br />

Appropriate site conditions:<br />

Small mid-block sites where all unit entrance


e all unit entrances can be seen from public street.<br />

d not facing the rear of adjacent building or property.<br />

ating pedestian mews with direct connection to public street.<br />

A<br />

A<br />

B<br />

A<br />

B<br />

B<br />

Provide generous building setback to align with prevailing neighbourhood characteristics and<br />

patterns.<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

A<br />

A<br />

B<br />

B<br />

Bringing it all together - Example of Types and Development Scenerios | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

B<br />

A<br />

re all unit entrances can be seen from public street.<br />

d not facing the rear of adjacent building or property.<br />

ating pedestian mews with direct connection to public street.<br />

67


Bringing it all together - Example of Types and Development Scenerios | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

5.1.4 STACKED AND BACK TO BACK TOWNHOUSE<br />

Stacked and back to back townhouses share a rear wall as well as a side wall and<br />

have multiple units stacked vertically. This building type is complex and requires<br />

special attention to site organization, building placement, and unit access.<br />

Building Type Characteristics<br />

• Share side and back walls and have units stacked<br />

vertically<br />

• Unit entrances have direct access to grade<br />

often on more than one side of the building<br />

• Underground parking<br />

Appropriate Site Conditions<br />

Appropriate when:<br />

• All individual unit entrances can be seen from<br />

public street<br />

• No privacy and overlook concerns to adjacent<br />

property<br />

• Direct connections to public sidewalk are<br />

accommodated on multi-block sites by streets or<br />

pedestrian mews<br />

• No below-grade or at-grade private outdoor<br />

amenity spaces are provided along public street<br />

frontage<br />

Design Considerations<br />

• In multiple front buildings, design all primary<br />

frontages of the building to address private/public<br />

streets, pedestrian mews, or open spaces<br />

• Careful design of pedestrian mews and/or private<br />

streets are required to provide comfortable, safe, and<br />

attractive environments for residents<br />

• Provide prominence to the entry area by including<br />

canopy, stoop, or porch<br />

• Detail the entrance area carefully with high quality,<br />

durable materials, attention to detail, and lighting<br />

• Provide distingishing features in multiple block<br />

developments to improve wayfinding and variety to<br />

building design<br />

D<br />

A<br />

C<br />

B<br />

Type 1 - Stacked and Back to Back, Multiple Fronts<br />

E<br />

D<br />

D<br />

A<br />

A<br />

C<br />

B<br />

C<br />

B<br />

E<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

C<br />

Type 2 - Stacked and B Back to Back, Single Front<br />

A<br />

Stacked Back to Back Townhouse<br />

Variation 2<br />

A<br />

D<br />

C<br />

B<br />

Unit entrances on both sides of building<br />

Units stack on top of one another with<br />

grade-related entrances<br />

Stacked Back to Back Townhouse<br />

Variation 2<br />

Unit entrances on both sides of building<br />

Units stack on top of one another with<br />

grade-related entrances<br />

Appropriate site c<br />

Small sites with two<br />

Sites with no privac<br />

Large site with mult<br />

Parking is provided<br />

Appro<br />

Small s<br />

Sites w<br />

Large s<br />

Parking<br />

68


nditions:<br />

B<br />

C<br />

C<br />

B<br />

C<br />

B<br />

B<br />

D<br />

A<br />

D<br />

A<br />

A<br />

B D<br />

C<br />

A<br />

A<br />

D<br />

B<br />

C<br />

B<br />

C<br />

B<br />

A<br />

D<br />

A<br />

D<br />

B<br />

A<br />

B<br />

C<br />

B<br />

C<br />

C<br />

A<br />

B<br />

A<br />

D<br />

E<br />

B<br />

C<br />

D<br />

E<br />

A<br />

D<br />

B<br />

B<br />

C<br />

ll unit entrances can be seen from public Astreet.<br />

rontages where all unit entrances A can be seen from public street.<br />

D<br />

priate site conditions:<br />

E<br />

ot facing the rear of Dadjacent building E or property.<br />

concerns and not facing the rear of adjacent building or property.<br />

ites with two frontages where all unit entrances can be seen from public A street.<br />

g pedestian mews with direct connection to public street.<br />

le blocks creating pedestian mews with direct connection to public street.<br />

D<br />

E<br />

onditions:<br />

ith no privacty concerns and not facing the rear of adjacent building or property.<br />

nderground<br />

ite frontages with multiple where blocks all unit creating entrances pedestian can be mews seen from with public direct street.<br />

ere all unit entrances can be seen from public street. connection to public street.<br />

ty is concerns provided<br />

Appropriate and underground not site facing conditions: the rear B of adjacent building C or property.<br />

nd not facing the rear of adjacent building or property.<br />

B<br />

iple blocks Small creating sites with pedestian two frontages mews where with direct all unit connection entrances to can public be seen street. from public street.<br />

ating pedestian mews with direct connection A to public street.<br />

underground Sites with no privacty concerns and D not facing the rear of adjacent building or property.<br />

Large site with multiple blocks creating pedestian mews with direct connection to public street.<br />

Parking is provided underground<br />

A<br />

D<br />

C<br />

B<br />

D<br />

A<br />

D<br />

C<br />

A<br />

C<br />

B<br />

E<br />

C<br />

D<br />

C<br />

A<br />

C<br />

D<br />

C<br />

B<br />

A E<br />

A<br />

D<br />

C<br />

B<br />

A<br />

D<br />

E<br />

A<br />

B<br />

A<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

B<br />

D<br />

C<br />

D<br />

C<br />

D<br />

B<br />

A<br />

C<br />

D<br />

B<br />

cus, susae. Um exceate A ommodi tem fugia pa por autectibeari<br />

C<br />

Duciisit, erchit, cum voloribus eatibus D elicipsus et ut ut ma qui si as<br />

C<br />

E<br />

C<br />

B<br />

Porem fugiam faccum qui debis ex ex eum qui testiorest dolorer<br />

E<br />

rovitat A iberoviditas et, autectur? Itaturit, et qui quam estius dolut<br />

C D<br />

B<br />

E<br />

D<br />

C<br />

B<br />

E<br />

A<br />

D<br />

C<br />

B<br />

A<br />

C<br />

D<br />

B<br />

A<br />

D<br />

Dipsapero et et, quat a ventia net hillaborero quia niscium repra<br />

quaspe ommoditium explabo. Ficia cus aut aut eius ist laceritia etur<br />

Bringing it all together - Example of Types and Development Scenerios | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

69


Bringing it all together - Example of Types and Development Scenerios | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

5.1.5 LOW-RISE APARTMENT BUILDING<br />

Low-rise apartment buildings have a single main entrance providing access to<br />

all units through internal vertical access and corridors. This building type is<br />

preferred in locations where individual at-grade entrances are not desired.<br />

Building Type Characteristics<br />

Typical Layout<br />

• Multiple units stacked vertically and horizontally<br />

• A single main entrance to building providing access to<br />

all units internally<br />

• Unit entrances accessed through internal corridors<br />

and vertical circulation<br />

B<br />

• Underground parking<br />

Appropriate Site Conditions<br />

Appropriate when:<br />

A<br />

• Site is along major arterial road and/or individual unit<br />

entrances are not appropriate<br />

• The neighbourhood context has existing low-rise<br />

apartment buildings with similar built form<br />

• The building does not create shadow, privacy, and<br />

overlook concerns<br />

Design Considerations<br />

• Provide prominence to the entry area by increasing<br />

Apartment<br />

Appropriate site conditions:<br />

Variation 1<br />

visibility and direct connection to public sidewalk<br />

Site along major arterial roads where at<br />

• Detail the entrance area carefully with high quality,<br />

Units stack on top of one another<br />

entrances are not desired<br />

durable materials, attention to detail, and lighting<br />

Entrance to units are accessed through<br />

• Provide distingishing features in multiple block<br />

common lobby and hallways<br />

developments to improve wayfinding and variety to<br />

building design<br />

Units at grade may have access to exterior<br />

from unit<br />

• Grade related units can have private amenity space<br />

provided they are designed with appropriate<br />

Parking is provided underground<br />

relationships to buildings<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

adjacent streets or<br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

70


e<br />

Considerations:<br />

A B A<br />

This building type can have many variations and can be<br />

adapted to various situations.<br />

A<br />

B<br />

Several low-rise apartment buildings are arranged to frame the a courtyard internal to the site.<br />

Credit: Quadrangle Architects Limited.<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

B<br />

Bringing it all together - Example of Types and Development Scenerios | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

Apartment buildings can take various forms with different internal arrangements. Central courtyard framed by graderelated<br />

units and open air corridors create a unique building layout in the example above. Credits: Scott Torrence<br />

Landscape Architecture.<br />

71


B<br />

D<br />

Bringing it all together - Example of Types and Development Scenerios | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

5.1.6 HYBRID BUILDING<br />

Upper Floor<br />

Upper Flo<br />

The hybrid building type combines lower units with direct at-grade access and upper units that gain<br />

access from a single main entrance and shared corridor and vertical circulation. This arrangement of<br />

Ground Floor<br />

units is acceptable in certain circumstances and provides consolidated access for upper units, while<br />

D<br />

allowing landscape areas and grade related accesses to animate the public realm on lower levels.<br />

A<br />

Ground F<br />

When many unit entrances are to be located in ped<br />

Hybrid<br />

Appropriate site conditions:<br />

Variation Type 1 1 - Stacked and Back to Back, Multiple Fronts<br />

Site along major arterial roads where unit Upper entrance Flo<br />

Building Type Characteristics<br />

Units Astack on C top of one another<br />

Grade-related unit entrances on both sides of<br />

• Multiple units stacked vertically and horizontally<br />

Ground F<br />

building accessed<br />

C<br />

at grade<br />

Narrow sites where access to unit entrances at gra<br />

Ground Floor<br />

• Lower units have direct access to grade<br />

• Upper units gain access through shared entrance into Upper unit entrances accessed through<br />

Deep sites where location unit entrances are better<br />

B<br />

common lobby at grade with elevator access<br />

building with vertical circulation and corridor<br />

Hybrid to upper level hallway<br />

Appropriate Parking is provided site conditions:<br />

underground<br />

Variation 1<br />

• Underground or rear integrated parking<br />

B<br />

Site along major<br />

Upper<br />

arterial<br />

Floor<br />

roads where unit entrance<br />

Units stack on top of one another<br />

When many unit entrances are to be located in ped<br />

Upper Floor<br />

Grade-related unit entrances on both sides of<br />

Appropriate Site Conditions<br />

building accessed at grade<br />

Narrow sites where access to unit entrances at gra<br />

Appropriate when:<br />

Upper unit entrances accessed through<br />

Deep sites where location unit entrances are better<br />

D<br />

common lobby at grade with elevator access<br />

• Site is along major arterial street and/or individual unit to upper level hallway<br />

Parking is provided underground<br />

entrances are not appropriate<br />

D<br />

• A reduction in individual unit access to grade is desired<br />

Up<br />

A<br />

• Site is too restricted to accommodate all unit entrances<br />

within pedestrian mews or walkways<br />

Gro Up<br />

A<br />

Ground Floor<br />

Upper Flo<br />

Design Considerations<br />

Gr<br />

Type 2 - Stacked, Single Front<br />

Ground Floor<br />

Hybrid<br />

Appropriate site conditions: Ground F<br />

• Hybrid buildings can be designed in different<br />

B<br />

Variation 1<br />

configurations. Consider site and neighbourhood context<br />

when proposing this building type<br />

Units Hybrid stack on top of one another<br />

Variation 1<br />

• Provide shared lobby entrance along public street with<br />

Grade-related unit entrances on both sides of<br />

good visibility<br />

building Units stack accessed on top at of grade one another<br />

• Individual unit entrances to have direct view to public<br />

Upper Grade-related unit entrances unit entrances accessed on through both sides of<br />

street<br />

common building accessed lobby at grade at grade with elevator access<br />

to upper level hallway<br />

• Detail the entrance area carefully with high quality,<br />

B<br />

Upper unit entrances accessed through<br />

buildings<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

relationships to adjacent streets or<br />

•<br />

durable materials, attention to detail, and lighting<br />

Provide distingishing features in multiple block<br />

common lobby at grade with elevator access<br />

to upper level hallway<br />

developments to improve wayfinding and variety to<br />

building design<br />

• Grade related units can have private amenity space<br />

provided they are designed with appropriate<br />

Site along major arterial roads where unit en<br />

Appropriate site conditions:<br />

When many Upper unit Floor entrances are to be located<br />

Site along major arterial roads where unit en<br />

Narrow sites where access to unit entrances<br />

When many unit entrances are to be Upper located Flo<br />

Deep sites where Figure: location unit entrances are<br />

Narrow sites where access to unit entrances<br />

Parking is provided underground Ground F<br />

Deep sites where location unit entrances are<br />

Parking is provided underground<br />

Upper Floor<br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

72<br />

A<br />

B<br />

Ground Floor<br />

Up<br />

Gro Up<br />

B<br />

Gr


per Floor<br />

Upper Floor<br />

Ground Floor<br />

r Floor<br />

unit entrances are not desired<br />

ocated in pedestrian mews<br />

rances<br />

ound Floor<br />

at grade is challenging<br />

ces are better located closer to public street<br />

Upper Floor<br />

te site conditions:<br />

B<br />

C<br />

C<br />

B<br />

D<br />

A<br />

D<br />

A<br />

Considerations:<br />

Upper Floor<br />

This building type allows some unit entrances to be centralized<br />

within the building accessed throught a common lobby and hallway.<br />

This results in improved A building design, D streetscape, safety, and<br />

Ground Flooraccessibility.<br />

Consider the following when designing this building type:<br />

- access to at grade units<br />

- etc......<br />

A<br />

major arterial roads where unit entrances are not desired<br />

This building type allows some unit entrances to be centralized<br />

Ground Floor<br />

within the building accessed throught a common lobby and hallway.<br />

nd y unit Floor entrances are to be located in pedestrian mews<br />

This results in improved building design, streetscape, safety, and<br />

C<br />

C accessibility.<br />

B<br />

es where access to unit entrances at grade is challenging<br />

D<br />

site conditions:<br />

Considerations:<br />

the following when designing this building type:<br />

D<br />

where location unit entrances are better located closer to public<br />

A<br />

street<br />

jor arterial roads where unit entrances are not desired<br />

This - access building to type at grade allows units<br />

C<br />

some unit entrances to be centralized<br />

provided underground<br />

C<br />

within - etc...... the building accessed throught a common lobby and hallway.<br />

B<br />

C<br />

B<br />

nit entrances are to be located in pedestrian mews<br />

This results in improved building design, streetscape, C safety, and<br />

D<br />

Upper Floor<br />

B<br />

accessibility.<br />

D<br />

A<br />

D<br />

nsiderations:<br />

where access to unit entrances at grade Bis challenging<br />

C<br />

The hybrid building type can be employed when a reduction in individual unit<br />

A<br />

D<br />

A<br />

C<br />

Ground Upper Floor<br />

Consider the following when designing access this building to grade type: is desired.<br />

Floor<br />

B<br />

B<br />

s ere building location type unit allows entrances some are unit better entrances located to be closer centralized to public street<br />

D<br />

Upper Floor<br />

B<br />

in the building accessed throught a common - access to at grade units<br />

A lobby and Dhallway.<br />

A<br />

s vided results underground<br />

in Ground improved Floor building design, streetscape, safety, and<br />

- etc......<br />

A<br />

A<br />

essibility. Considerations:<br />

Ground Floor<br />

Considerations:<br />

sider This building the following type allows when designing some unit this entrances building to type: be centralized<br />

where within unit the entrances building accessed are not desired throught a common lobby This building and hallway. type allows some unit entrances to be centralized<br />

within Considerations:<br />

the building accessed throught a common lobby and hallway.<br />

cess This to results at grade in improved units building design, streetscape, safety, and<br />

to be located in pedestrian mews<br />

This results in improved building design, streetscape, safety, and<br />

c...... accessibility.<br />

where unit entrances are not desired<br />

accessibility.<br />

This building type allows some unit entrances to be centralized<br />

nit entrances at grade is challenging<br />

within the building accessed throught a common lobby and hallway.<br />

to Consider be located the in following pedestrian when mews designing this building<br />

Consider This type: results the in following improved when building designing design, this streetscape, building type: safety, and<br />

B<br />

entrances are better located closer to public street accessibility.<br />

unit - access entrances to at at grade units is challenging Upper Floor<br />

- access to at grade units<br />

d- etc......<br />

- Consider etc...... the following when designing this building type:<br />

entrances are better located closer to public street<br />

A<br />

Ground Floor - access to at grade units<br />

nd<br />

- etc......<br />

B<br />

A<br />

B<br />

C<br />

C<br />

Considerations:<br />

D<br />

B<br />

C<br />

B<br />

D<br />

A<br />

C<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

A<br />

D<br />

B<br />

Bringing it all together - Example of Types and Development Scenerios | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

B<br />

Upper Floor<br />

Upper Floor<br />

B<br />

Ground Floor<br />

A<br />

A<br />

Internalizing parking garage into the building with private amenity space above<br />

Upper Floor<br />

B<br />

is acceptable only if negative impacts such as shadow, privacy and overlook on<br />

adjacent properties can be limited and resolved.<br />

A<br />

B<br />

Upper Floor<br />

B<br />

B<br />

Ground Upper Floor Floor<br />

A<br />

B<br />

A<br />

A<br />

B<br />

73<br />

Ground Floor<br />

A<br />

A


Bringing it all together - Example of Types and Development Scenerios | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

74<br />

5.2 DEVELOPMENT SCENARIOS<br />

Section 5.2 Development Scenarios, provides hypothetical examples of how site plans and site elements can come together<br />

successfully at different scales and with different site conditions.<br />

5.2.1 SHALLOW MID-BLOCK PARCEL<br />

On shallow sites, orient buildings and entrances parallel to public streets where<br />

maintaining the rear of the site for private and/or shared amenity space.<br />

a. Provide a primary building face with unit entrances or a<br />

single shared entrance facing and parallel to a street. Do<br />

B<br />

D<br />

Public Street<br />

Public Street<br />

A<br />

d. Provide shared outdoor amenity/open space in areas with<br />

sunlight and access to indoor amenity space when provided.<br />

not provide unit entrance(s) at the rear of the building where<br />

Small, shallow mid-block parcel<br />

e. Enhance landscape areas along edge of the site by planting<br />

they do not have street frontage or where they face the rear<br />

shrubs and shade producing trees.<br />

A - Provide or building sides face of adjacent and unit entrance properties. facing street or a single entrance to a lobby with unit access through<br />

internal hallway. Do not provide unit entrance at the rear of the building where entrances f. do Integrate not have driveways, public vehicular access ramps, garbage<br />

street<br />

b.<br />

frontage<br />

Provide<br />

and<br />

walkway(s)<br />

facing the rear<br />

to connect<br />

or sides of<br />

the<br />

adjacent<br />

rear of<br />

properties.<br />

the site to<br />

storage, loading, and servicing areas internally within the<br />

B - Provide the walkway public to sidewalk. connect the rear Areas of the along site the to the property public sidewalk. lines are Landscape areas along the property<br />

building.<br />

lines are landscaped to be provided to to provide buffer development a green buffer from adjacent to adjacent properties. properties When adjacent properties are<br />

expected and to enhance develop, coordinate the environment developments for to people work together inhabiting to provide and connections. g. Setback/stepback building to align with neighbouring<br />

C - Provide overlooking shared outdoor these amenities spaces. spaces in areas with sunlight and access to indoor amenity buildings. space when<br />

provided.<br />

D - Provide<br />

c. When<br />

enhanced<br />

adjacent<br />

landscape<br />

properties<br />

areas along<br />

are<br />

edge<br />

expected<br />

of the site.<br />

to redevelop,<br />

E - Integrate coordinate and consolidate developments garbage storage, to work loading, together and servicing to provide areas internally within the building massing.<br />

F - Integrate connections.<br />

driveways and vehicular access into the massing of the building and setback/stepback building to<br />

align with existing building.<br />

E<br />

F<br />

G<br />

C<br />

Existing Building<br />

On Site<br />

Townhouse or<br />

Low-Rise<br />

Primary Building<br />

Face<br />

Pedestrian<br />

Connection<br />

Enhanced<br />

Landscape Area<br />

Shared Amenity<br />

Space<br />

Location of Private<br />

Amenity Area<br />

Tree Protection<br />

Area<br />

Individual Unit<br />

Entrance<br />

Shared Lobby<br />

Entrance<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong>


Well landscaped walkways<br />

provide access to public<br />

sidewalks and help connect to<br />

adjacent developments<br />

RATIONALE<br />

Many of Toronto's streets are lined with narrow lots, but<br />

over time consolidation of lots have created larger sites with<br />

wider public street frontages. To successfully develop these<br />

sites with low-rise buildings, consideration must be given<br />

to the impact of site organization and built form on adjacent<br />

properties.<br />

There can be challenges to redeveloping these sites especially<br />

with the stacked and back to back townhouse type. Dependent<br />

on the character of the neighbourhood, this building type<br />

can work well to frame the edges of streets and reinforce the<br />

street wall. It is important to recognize the character of the<br />

neighbourhood to determine the appropriate relationship the<br />

building should have with its neighbour.<br />

At grade private<br />

amenity space for<br />

rear facing units<br />

Locate outdoor amenity<br />

space in areas with<br />

good sunlight<br />

New development is setback<br />

a minimum of 7.5m from<br />

rear of adjacent properties<br />

and much adhere to the<br />

appropriate angular plane<br />

It is possible for a building to employ an internal organization<br />

where single or multiple entrances are located fronting a public<br />

street, which retains the rear of the site as shared or private<br />

outdoor amenity space and landscaped area.<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

Bringing it all together - Example of Types and Development Scenerios | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

Individual unit entrances facing the rear yards of abutting<br />

properties should be avoided due to the lack of visual<br />

connections to a public street, safety and way-finding concerns<br />

for residents and visitors. Locating entrances at the rear also<br />

creates atypical building relationships which are not desirable<br />

or consistent with Toronto's urban structure.<br />

New apartment building development respects neighbourhood context by providing front<br />

yard setback consistent with adjacent buildings. Credit: Audax Architecture. Photo by:<br />

Joy von Tiedemann.<br />

75


Bringing it all together - Example of Types and Development Scenerios | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

A -<br />

B -<br />

C -<br />

D -<br />

E -<br />

F -<br />

5.2.2 DEEP MID-BLOCK PARCEL<br />

Use appropriate building type on deep mid-block sites to reduce travel distance to<br />

unit entrance from public streets. Consider apartment or hybrid building type to<br />

limit negative pedestrian experience to entrance along the sides of buildings.<br />

F<br />

street frontage – eg. Residential uses in residential areas<br />

Small, deep mid-block parcel<br />

and retail in Avenue or mixed use areas where appropriate.<br />

B<br />

A<br />

G<br />

F<br />

C<br />

Public Street<br />

Existing Building<br />

On Site<br />

Townhouse or<br />

Low-Rise<br />

Primary Building<br />

Face<br />

Pedestrian<br />

Connection<br />

Enhanced<br />

Landscape Area<br />

Shared Amenity<br />

Space<br />

Location of Private<br />

Area<br />

D<br />

E<br />

Tree Protection<br />

Area<br />

Individual Unit<br />

Entrance<br />

Shared Lobby<br />

Entrance<br />

Public Street<br />

a. Orient building frontage parallel to street and align with<br />

e. Provide private and shared outdoor amenity spaces where<br />

neighbouring buildings. Provide grade-related uses along<br />

appropriate.<br />

f. Provide landscaped and well-lit pedestrian walkway to<br />

individual unit entrances with visual connection to public<br />

Provide building frontage parallel to street with grade-related <strong>DRAFT</strong>Amenity<br />

uses along street.<br />

b. For deep mid-block sites, provide building entrance to a<br />

street.<br />

For small, deep mid-block sites, provide building entrance to a shared lobby and hallway access to units.<br />

shared lobby with internal corridor and vertical circulation<br />

Avoid locating unit entrances where residents and visitors will have to travel deep into the rear of the site for<br />

access<br />

access.<br />

to units. Avoid locating unit entrances which cannot<br />

be Integrate seen from vehicular a public access sidewalk.<br />

into the building massing and internalize underground entrances and service/load<br />

ing areas within building massing.<br />

c. Integrate vehicular access ramps, garbage storage, service<br />

Provide enhanced landscape areas along the edge of the site by planting shade-producing trees and<br />

and loading areas into the building massing. Provide<br />

shurbs/bushes..<br />

vehicular access through private driveway under building<br />

Provide private outdoor amenity spaces where appropriate.<br />

when<br />

Provide<br />

required.<br />

vehicular access throught private driveway.<br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

d. Provide enhanced landscaped areas and screening along<br />

the edge of the site by planting shade-producing trees and<br />

shurbs.<br />

76


Integrate ramps, garbage<br />

storage and service areas<br />

into the building<br />

RATIONALE<br />

Deep sites with narrow public street frontage present significant<br />

site organization challenges in redevelopment. These sites<br />

typically have difficulty providing individual unit access to<br />

grade, vehicular access, loading and servicing areas, and<br />

adequate landscaped setback areas.<br />

When units are facing toward the side of the property, generous<br />

landscaped setbacks are required to allow sky view and<br />

light into the units, provide a pleasant aspect for residents,<br />

and screening from adjacent properties. When a pedestrian<br />

walkway is providing access to individual unit entrances along<br />

the sides of a building, the walkway must be well-lit with high<br />

quality landscape design to create a comfortable pedestrian<br />

environment. When the site is very deep and the travel distance<br />

required to access a unit entrance from a public street is greater<br />

than 6-8 units, consider the apartment building type which<br />

provides access to individual units via an entrance lobby at<br />

the public street with shared internal corridors and vertical<br />

circulation.<br />

Orient building parallel to<br />

street and align with<br />

adjacent buildings<br />

Limit the number of<br />

individual access to grade<br />

to improve public realm<br />

be designed to have the characteristics of a public street.<br />

Landscaped setbacks are especially challenging in narrow and<br />

deep sites. It is important to provide landscaped areas with<br />

adequate soil volume to sustain large growth trees to screen<br />

adjacent properties.<br />

Upper units accessed via entrance<br />

lobby with shared corridors and<br />

vertical circulation improve<br />

accessibility and public realm<br />

Enhance pedestrian<br />

walkway to entrances by<br />

providing high quality<br />

landscape design and<br />

planting materials<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

Bringing it all together - Example of Types and Development Scenerios | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

Vehicular access, loading and servicing areas for deep sites are<br />

to be integrated into the building and the width of the access<br />

is to be kept to a minimum to reduce impact to public realm.<br />

When a private street or vehicular mews is proposed, they must<br />

Pedestrian walkway and shared amenity space work together to provide access<br />

to grade-related units and gathering space for residents. Credits: David Peterson<br />

Architect Inc., Triumph Developments. Photo by: Ben Rahn/A-Frame.<br />

77


Bringing it all together - Example of Types and Development Scenerios | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

78<br />

5.2.3 PARCEL ADJACENT OR WITH HERITAGE RESOURCE<br />

Conserve and maintain prominence of heritage properties and Heritage<br />

Conservation Districts (HCDs) by respecting and responding to heritage features<br />

in new development.<br />

Public Street<br />

a. Respect heritage building and landscapes by setting new<br />

B<br />

C<br />

D<br />

A<br />

E<br />

I<br />

F<br />

Public Street<br />

Public Lane<br />

Existing Building<br />

On Site<br />

Townhouse or<br />

Low-Rise<br />

Primary Building<br />

Face<br />

Pedestrian<br />

Connection<br />

Enhanced<br />

Landscape Area<br />

Shared Amenity<br />

Space<br />

Location of Private<br />

Amenity Area<br />

Tree Protection<br />

Area<br />

Individual Unit<br />

Entrance<br />

Shared Lobby<br />

Entrance<br />

f. Provide landscaped and well-lit pedestrian connection<br />

buildings back to provide prominence to heritage site.<br />

through site.<br />

Small parcel with heritage resource<br />

b. Integrate underground garage ramp, service and loading g. Use rear lane access for parking where possible.<br />

A - Integrate underground garage ramp, service/loading areas into building massing.<br />

areas into building massing.<br />

B - Provide primary unit entrances facing public streets. For back-to-back, h. and Setback stacked townhouses, and transition avoid building in height to align with<br />

c. Provide locating individual primary unit entrance entrances at the facing back of public the building. streets. For<br />

adjacent buildings and context.<br />

C - stacked Place and/or new back building to parallel back townhouses, public street avoid to frame locating streets and unit public spaces.<br />

D -<br />

i. Enhance landscape area along the edges of site to screen<br />

entrances<br />

Respect<br />

at the<br />

heritage<br />

back<br />

building.......<br />

of the building.<br />

E - Locate shared amenity spaces central to the development and provide indoor new amenity development spaces adjacent from existing to properties.<br />

d. Place new outdoor buildings spaces. parallel to public streets to frame<br />

F - streets Provide and public pedestrian spaces. connection through site.<br />

G - Lane access, rear parking where possible.<br />

e. H - Provide Setback and locate and transition shared building outdoor to align amenity with adjacent spaces buildings central to and context.<br />

I - the development Provide front in yard areas setback with to sunlight align with and adjacent access building. to indoor<br />

J - amenity Enhance space landscape when provided. area along the edges of site to screen new development from existing properties.<br />

G<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

H


RATIONALE<br />

New developments have to be carefully designed to protect<br />

and conserve the character of a heritage asset. Where<br />

redevelopment occurs on or near a site with heritage assets,<br />

various strategies can be employed to respect and complement<br />

the scale, character, form and setting of the heritage resource.<br />

In locations where redevelopment is considered appropriate,<br />

heritage properties should be referenced to inform the scale<br />

and contextual treatment of the new development. "Breathing<br />

space" or setbacks between the new development and the<br />

heritage property help maintain the prominence of the heritage<br />

building and allow for preservation of heritage features such as<br />

windows and cornices which would otherwise be hidden. An<br />

on-site heritage building or structure should be conserved in its<br />

three-dimensional form. Protect and frame views to heritage<br />

features such as steeples, roof lines, and other identifying<br />

heritage features to help preserve the heritage value of these<br />

properties.<br />

Transition to Fit In with<br />

Adjacent Built Forms<br />

and Frame Street<br />

Provide Front Yard<br />

Setback to Align with<br />

Adjacent Built Form<br />

Respect and Enhance<br />

Architectural Features<br />

and Rhythms of<br />

Heritage Building<br />

Incorporate Heritage<br />

Landscape Design as<br />

part of Conservation<br />

Strategy<br />

Preserve Prominent<br />

Views of Heritage<br />

Building with Strategic<br />

Building Setback and<br />

Stepbacks<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

Design of the new development is informed by the character of the adjacent Victorian<br />

townhouses. Extra care must be taken to maintain and enhance the neighbourhood<br />

characteristics such as front yard landscape and entrance design.<br />

Bringing it all together - Example of Types and Development Scenerios | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

79


Bringing it all together - Example of Types and Development Scenerios | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

80<br />

5.2.4 PARCEL WITH MULTIPLE BUILDING BLOCKS<br />

Consider building location to avoid creating undesirable site conditions on<br />

multiple building block sites. Arrange buildings to allow direct views from public<br />

streets to pedestrian mews, unit entrances, and amenity spaces.<br />

Public Street<br />

a. Provide building face and unit entrances facing streets.<br />

b. Place new building parallel to public streets and align with<br />

setbacks of adjacent buildings.<br />

Parcel with multiple building blocks<br />

A<br />

B<br />

C<br />

D<br />

K<br />

F<br />

Public Street<br />

Public Street<br />

g. Integrate and consolidate garbage storage, loading, and<br />

servicing areas internally within the building.<br />

Existing Building<br />

On Site<br />

Townhouse or<br />

Low-Rise<br />

Primary Building<br />

Face<br />

Pedestrian<br />

Connection<br />

Enhanced<br />

Landscape Area<br />

Shared Amenity<br />

Space<br />

Location of Private<br />

Amenity Area<br />

Tree Protection<br />

Area<br />

Individual Unit<br />

Entrance<br />

Shared Lobby<br />

Entrance<br />

h. For building blocks with a building facing a side yard, locate<br />

unit entrances on one side of the building with greatest visibility<br />

c. Provide streets to access deeper sites . If the street is private,<br />

A - Provide building face and unit entrance facing street<br />

and accessibility to pedestrian mews and/or street.<br />

B -<br />

design<br />

Place<br />

street<br />

new<br />

to<br />

building<br />

have characteristics<br />

parallel to public<br />

of<br />

street<br />

public<br />

and<br />

streets<br />

provide<br />

with<br />

entrances with views to public streets.<br />

C - pedestrian Provide sidewalks, private driveway street to trees, access and deep pedestrian sites and amenities.<br />

design to have character i. Private of public outdoor streets with amenity pedestrian spaces can be provided for new<br />

sidewalks, trees, and pedestrian amenities.<br />

developments adjacent to side yard of the adjacent property,<br />

d. Provide well-designed pedestrian mews by incorporating<br />

D - Provide well designed pedestrian mews by incorporating landscape areas, lighting provided , and that entrance appropriate designs. building setback and landscape<br />

landscape areas, lighting, and articulated entrances within the<br />

E - Provide landscape area to buffer new development from adjacent sensitive land screening uses such can as be designated achieved.<br />

development site.<br />

Neighbourhoods, school, or parks and open spaces.<br />

F - Locate indoor amenity spaces to connect with the outdoor amenity space<br />

j.<br />

.<br />

Enhance landscape areas along edge of the site by planting<br />

e. Provide landscape area to screen new development<br />

shrubs and shade-producing trees.<br />

from adjacent sensitive land uses such as designated<br />

G - Locate shared amenity spaces in areas with sunlight and central to the development block for better place<br />

Neighbourhoods, schools, and/or parks and open spaces.<br />

k. Protect and avoid damage to existing trees on or adjacent to<br />

making opportunities.<br />

development site.<br />

f. H - Provide Private and locate driveways shared should outdoor be designed amenity to look spaces like public central streets to with sidewalks, generous landscaping areas<br />

the development<br />

and street trees.<br />

in areas with sunlight and access to indoor<br />

I - Integrate and consolidate garbage storage, loading, and servicing areas internally within the building massing.<br />

amenity space when provided.<br />

J - For building blocks with building facing side yard, locate unit entrances on one side of the building with<br />

greatest vibility and accessiblity to pedestrian mews.<br />

K- Rear yards can be provided for new development block facing the side yard of the adjacent property, provided<br />

that an appropriate building setback can be achieved.<br />

L- Provide enhanced landscape areas along the edge of the site.<br />

G<br />

H<br />

E<br />

I<br />

J<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong>


Provide well-designed<br />

pedestrian mews with<br />

generous facing distance<br />

for access to units<br />

RATIONALE<br />

Locate shared outdoor<br />

amenity spaces in areas<br />

with good sunlight and<br />

central to the development<br />

Small communities are created when multiple building blocks<br />

are developed on a site. These developments are large enough<br />

to form a distinctive character of their own, but too small to<br />

become their own neighbourhoods. Parcels with multiple<br />

building blocks should look at the site's configuration and<br />

neighbourhood character to identify the appropriate site<br />

organization, building type and public realm design to strike a<br />

balance between fitting-in and creating a sense of place.<br />

Buildings can be placed parallel to the public street on shallow<br />

multi-block sites when no buildings are behind another. On<br />

deep multi-block sites, buildings are better arranged when<br />

perpendicular to public streets where unit entrances have direct<br />

view to public streets. The pedestrian mews on deep sites<br />

serve as the main access for units and must be designed with a<br />

high quality pedestrian experience in mind. When the visibility<br />

Locate unit entrances to<br />

have greatest visibility and<br />

accessibility to pedestrian<br />

mews and/or street<br />

Design private streets<br />

to have characteristics<br />

of public streets<br />

Integrate and<br />

consolidate garbage<br />

storage, loading, and<br />

servicing areas internally<br />

Enhance landscape areas<br />

along edge of the site by<br />

planting shrubs and<br />

shade producing trees<br />

of entrances from public streets is compromised, apartment or<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

hybrid building type may be more appropriate for the site.<br />

Building types may vary throughout the development dependent<br />

on the location of the particular building block. For example,<br />

blocks directly adjacent to another property may be better<br />

suited with a built form where the rear of the building faces<br />

the side. This relationship is more appropriate than having the<br />

front of a building facing the side of another. Internal to the<br />

development site, buildings should have front to front facing<br />

relationships with adequate facing distance between blocks.<br />

Below-grade terraces should be limited to allow room for<br />

landscaping and soil volume for large trees.<br />

Bringing it all together - Example of Types and Development Scenerios | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

81


Bringing it all together - Example of Types and Development Scenerios | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

82<br />

5.2.5 LARGE PARCEL WITH TOWER AND NEIGHBOURHOOD EDGE<br />

"Tower in the Park " sites which are able to accommodate low-rise building development<br />

can re-establish neighbourhood scale along street edge, improve existing site/building<br />

conditions, and incorporate enhanced on site amenities for the residents and public.<br />

Public Street<br />

B<br />

C<br />

D<br />

F<br />

Public Street<br />

K<br />

G<br />

D<br />

K<br />

A<br />

H<br />

Location of Private<br />

Area<br />

J<br />

Tree Protection<br />

Area<br />

E<br />

Individual Unit<br />

N<br />

Entrance<br />

M<br />

Shared Lobby<br />

Entrance<br />

Public Street<br />

a. Improve existing tower site and building frontage by enhancing h. Improve garbage storage, loading, and servicing areas of the<br />

landscape design and public realm. Existing pedestrian walkways,<br />

existing building by providing internal and integrate garbage<br />

driveways, Large parcel surfacing with parking tower and and other neighbourhood landscape features should edge<br />

and loading areas. These areas can be consolidated and shared<br />

be considered as part of redevelopment of site.<br />

between the new and existing buildings when possible.<br />

A - Provide building face and unit entrance facing street<br />

b. B - Place new Place buildings new building parallel parallel to public to public streets street and and locate provide entrances entrances with i. views Create to public new streets. and improved private outdoor areas for existing ground<br />

with views to public streets.<br />

floor apartments at grade.<br />

C - Provide shared outdoor amenity spaces for new development and locate indoor amenity spaces to connect<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong>Amenity<br />

c. Provide with shared the outdoor space amenity where space appropriate. in a visible and accessible j. Protect and avoid damage to existing trees on or adjacent to<br />

D - area and Improve locate existing indoor amenity pedestrian spaces walkways to connect and provide with new the outdoor connections to enhance development connectivity site. of Preserve the site to existing mature plantings and trees<br />

space. surrounding neighbourhood.<br />

and improve planting conditions where appropriate.<br />

E - New development along Neighbourhood edge are to be designed to compliment and respect the prevailing<br />

d. Improve existing pedestrian walkways and provide new<br />

k. Remove under-used surface parking and driveways. Surface<br />

connections built form, to enhance scale, and connectivity character of of the the neighbourhood.<br />

site to surrounding<br />

parking located along public street frontage is to be removed and<br />

F - neighbourhoods Integrate underground and amenities. garage Ensure ramps walkways into the new are building accessible, where possible replaced or integrate with other well uses designed such as landscape areas.<br />

well-lit, indoor and well-landscaped.<br />

amenity spaces to create new community focus.<br />

l. Provide shade producing trees and shrubs to screen surface<br />

G - Improve amenity spaces and facilities for existing residents.<br />

e. New development along Neighbourhood edge are to be designed<br />

parking area from view.<br />

H -<br />

to compliment<br />

Improve<br />

and<br />

garbage<br />

respect<br />

storage,<br />

the prevailing<br />

loading, and<br />

built<br />

servicing<br />

form, scale,<br />

areas of<br />

and<br />

the existing building by providing internal and<br />

character integrate of the neighbourhood.<br />

garbage and loading areas. Service areas can be of the existing m. Setback building and the transition new development built form to align with adjacent building<br />

can be consolidated when appropriate.<br />

setbacks and heights.<br />

f. Integrate underground garage ramps into the new building where<br />

I - Improve existing landscaped areas including pedestrian walkways, driveways,<br />

possible or integrate other uses such as indoor amenity spaces to n. Consider<br />

surfacing<br />

the<br />

parking<br />

location<br />

and<br />

of any<br />

other<br />

new buildings to allow good access to<br />

landscape features.<br />

create new community focus.<br />

sunlight and sky view for existing and new residents.<br />

J - Protect and accommodate existing trees on site by placing new buildings and construction away from<br />

g. Improve protection amenity zone. spaces and facilities for existing residents.<br />

K- Remove as much surface parking and driveways as possible. Surface parking located at the front of the<br />

building facing a public street are to be removed and replaced with landscape areas.<br />

L- Provide shade producing trees and shrubs to screen surface parking area from view.<br />

K<br />

I<br />

L<br />

J<br />

D<br />

J<br />

J<br />

Existing Building<br />

On Site<br />

Townhouse or<br />

Low-Rise<br />

Primary Building<br />

Face<br />

Pedestrian<br />

Connection<br />

Enhanced<br />

Landscape Area<br />

Shared Amenity<br />

Space


RATIONALE<br />

The "Tower in the Park" design principle was widely used in<br />

many parts of Toronto. The design principle placed towers<br />

away from the public streets and set buildings centrally within<br />

the site, promising large open green spaces for its residents.<br />

However, these types of developments were often "Towers<br />

in the Parking Lots" instead and disrupted the pedestrianoriented<br />

scale and character of many traditional Toronto<br />

neighbourhoods.<br />

Provide generous setback<br />

between existing tower<br />

and new low-rise building<br />

Provide shared outdoor<br />

amenity space in visible<br />

and accessible area<br />

Some tower sites can accommodate low-rise building<br />

developments to spur improvements to existing site conditions<br />

and re-establish connections to its neighbourhood context. In<br />

this example, new buildings are oriented parallel to the street<br />

with front yard setbacks consistent with adjacent properties to<br />

redefine the street edge. Primary unit entrances are located to<br />

be highly visible from the public street to ensure the safety and<br />

security of the residents and community.<br />

New buildings should also begin to frame outdoor amenity<br />

spaces within site and create urban 'rooms' to contain various<br />

activities. Introduce programmed amenity spaces to encourage<br />

a variety of different uses and users. Physical and visual<br />

connections through site to public streets are important and<br />

integral to creating a safe and attractive place for people.<br />

Improve existing condition<br />

of tower and site as part<br />

of redevelopment<br />

Reduce surface<br />

parking and improve<br />

onsite vehicular and<br />

pedestrian circulation<br />

Setback and transition<br />

built form to align with<br />

adjacent building in<br />

setback and height<br />

Through the development process, issues regarding vehicular<br />

access, loading, servicing, garbage storage and collection<br />

activities must be resolved to eliminate existing negative site<br />

conditions. Replace vehicular accesses and surface parking<br />

areas with new landscaped green space to offset the impacts<br />

from development of the site. Existing landscaping and<br />

amenities should be enhanced to improve the quality of the<br />

remaining open space. Loading, servicing, garbage storage<br />

and collection areas are to be integrated and internalized into<br />

the existing or new building. Ramps to underground garages<br />

should be integrated within the new building massing. In some<br />

situations, integrating other functions such as amenity spaces<br />

to an underground ramp can be accepted.<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

It is imperative to address the negative conditions of "Tower in<br />

the Park" buildings when considering redevelopment with lowrise<br />

buildings. As the tower(s) is often in 'slab' form and can<br />

cast a considerable shadow on its site, it is important to avoid<br />

locating new development in the shadow of the tower.<br />

Bringing it all together - Example of Types and Development Scenerios | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

83


Bringing it all together - Example of Types and Development Scenerios | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

84<br />

5.2.6 LARGE DEVELOPMENT WITH MULTIPLE DEVELOPMENT BLOCKS<br />

Large sites with multiple blocks require a master plan to locate new streets,<br />

buildings, and parks/open spaces in order to integrate the new community into<br />

the surrounding neighbourhood.<br />

M<br />

B<br />

M<br />

C<br />

A<br />

D<br />

E<br />

A. Provide a new public street to provide address and access to<br />

development and improve visibility and access to the existing park.<br />

Align with existing public streets where possible.<br />

B. Provide building face and unit entrances facing the street and<br />

provide appropriate building setbacks by looking at existing and<br />

future planned context.<br />

C. Protect and accommodate existing trees on site by placing new<br />

buildings and construction away from protection zone.<br />

D. Consolidate underground garage access, service and loading<br />

areas on site and minimize impact by providing landscaping and<br />

screening.<br />

E. Internalize ramps, loading spaces, and garbage storage within the<br />

building.<br />

F. Design and integrate new development into the existing<br />

neighbourhood by providing appropriate building setbacks,<br />

stepbacks, and built form. Provide a mix of building types on large<br />

developments with multiple blocks.<br />

G. Provide parking access from public lanes or shared driveways<br />

where possible.<br />

G<br />

F<br />

Public Street<br />

H<br />

New Public Street<br />

I<br />

J<br />

K<br />

C<br />

Existing Building<br />

On Site<br />

Townhouse or<br />

Low-Rise<br />

Primary Building<br />

Face<br />

Pedestrian<br />

Connection<br />

Enhanced<br />

Landscape Area<br />

Shared Amenity<br />

Space<br />

Location of Private<br />

Amenity Area<br />

Tree Protection<br />

Area<br />

Individual Unit<br />

Entrance<br />

Shared Lobby<br />

Entrance<br />

H. Create place making opportunities by providing well-designed<br />

accessible amenities in a central and visible location.<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

L<br />

I. Provide well designed pedestrian mews by incorporating landscape<br />

areas, lighting, and entrance designs.<br />

J. Provide enhanced landscape areas along the edge of site to<br />

screen new development from adjacent properties. Properties<br />

where change of land use designation occurs (ie. transportation<br />

corridors, ravines, employment uses), require additional attention<br />

to landscape in order to provide appropriate landscape buffer.<br />

K. Orient buildings to frame edges of parks and open spaces to<br />

provide visibility and animation. Avoid orienting buildings with the<br />

rear facing park.<br />

L. Locate POPS and shared amenity spaces in areas with good access<br />

to sunlight and coordinate design with adjacent parks and open<br />

spaces to expand usability.<br />

M. Protect for future public street and pedestrian connections to<br />

adjacent sites.


Provide unit entrance<br />

facing park to animate<br />

the park edge<br />

RATIONALE<br />

Public streets, parks, open spaces, and built form all work<br />

together to define a new public realm for large sites with<br />

multiple development blocks. The success of these new<br />

communities depends in part on how well it accomplishes the<br />

interface with its context. The organization of the building<br />

blocks on large sites is critical in creating a transition<br />

between existing and new communities. It is vital that new<br />

developments respect the positive characteristics of its context<br />

and further enhance these attributes to create a cohesive<br />

neighbourhood.<br />

Public streets are one of the fundamental building blocks to city<br />

building. On large sites, new public streets are often required to<br />

provide access to the new community. By aligning new streets<br />

to existing ones, they help stitch together the communities.<br />

Public streets and pedestrian connections beyond the site<br />

should also be identified, considered, and opportunities for<br />

future extensions should be protected.<br />

Design POPS or shared<br />

amenity spaces to enhance<br />

with adjacent park and<br />

open space<br />

Design building to<br />

address the corner at<br />

corner sites<br />

Orient buildings to<br />

frame edges of parks<br />

and open spaces<br />

centrally within easy access to the community with prominent<br />

public street frontage, access to sky view and sunlight.<br />

Opportunities to expand public parks are encouraged. POPS<br />

should work together with existing open spaces to increase the<br />

possible activities and uses for the park.<br />

Configure new public street to<br />

improve visibility to existing<br />

parks and open spaces<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

Bringing it all together - Example of Types and Development Scenerios | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

Public parks and open spaces are central to each new<br />

neighbourhood and can be used as an organizational element<br />

for large sites. They are civic spaces and place-makers which<br />

bring a community together. Public parks should be located<br />

Large blocks of townhouses can integrate well into established neighbourhoods by<br />

enhancing pedestrian connections and positive chracteristics of its context.<br />

85


Bringing it all together - Example of Types and Development Scenerios | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

86


6.0 Case Studies<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

APPENDICES | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

87


APPENDICES | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

Trinity Towns<br />

250 Manning Avenue – South District<br />

Elevation<br />

Developer: Urban Capital / 3s<br />

Architect: Richard Wengles<br />

Builder: Shram Homes<br />

Project Statistics<br />

General Description: 45 Freehold Townhouses with Common Element<br />

Type: Townhouse<br />

Building Height: 12m<br />

Site Area: 4,082 sq. m<br />

Total GFA: 7781.96<br />

Site Coverage: 1.91 FSI<br />

No. of units: 45<br />

Separation distances between blocks: 8.5m<br />

Setbacks: 3 rd Storey Stepback<br />

No. of parking spaces and location: 45 underground<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

Common Amenity Area: None<br />

Vertical Circulation: Stair<br />

Surrounding Land Use: Residential<br />

Process and Status: Completed<br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

Context Plan<br />

Townhouse Block Plan<br />

88


DESCRIPTION<br />

Introduction<br />

• Project consists of 45 3-storey townhouses on formerly<br />

vacant Catholic Elementary School lands. All townhouses<br />

front onto a public street<br />

Site Context<br />

• The property is in, and is surrounded on all sides by a<br />

Neighbourhoods designation<br />

Site Organization<br />

• Site is organized in a linear pattern with fenced rear-yard<br />

amenity space<br />

• Lot frontages range from 4-5.8m are consistent with<br />

properties to the north<br />

• 45 parking spaces provided below grade, visitor parking onstreet<br />

and in a new 43-space Toronto Parking Authority<br />

directly south of site<br />

• Garbage is picked up at curb by the City, each unit has a<br />

specific screened location at front for storage of bins<br />

Building Massing and Design<br />

• Project design is in-line with existing physical character and<br />

streetscape of the neighbourhood<br />

• The 3 rd storey of the townhouse is set back further from the<br />

front building line to reduce the perceived height of the<br />

building at the sidewalk level<br />

• Front elevation building mass is broken up through building<br />

material articulation and glass and metal stair hand railings<br />

Front Elevation at Night<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

Landscaped Side Access<br />

APPENDICES | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

• Setbacks along public streets are planted with shade trees,<br />

shrubs, grasses and perennials to enhance the architecture of<br />

the townhouses<br />

Side Elevation<br />

89


APPENDICES | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

Wallace Walk<br />

362 Wallace Avenue – South District<br />

Perspective<br />

Developer: Sommerset Wallace Development<br />

Architect: Kregg Fordyce Architect<br />

Landscape Architect: Harrington McAvan<br />

Project Statistics<br />

General Description: Infill on Brownfield Site<br />

Type: Stacked and Back to Back<br />

Building Height: 13 m<br />

Site Area: 12 634 sq. m<br />

Total GFA: 18, 150 sq. m<br />

Site Coverage: 1.54 FSI<br />

No. of units: 167 residential; 20 non-residential<br />

Separation distances between blocks:12 m<br />

Setbacks:<br />

No. of parking spaces and location: 179 + 22 Visitor Underground +<br />

19 on-street<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

Common Amenity Area: 475 sq. m Community Facility<br />

Vertical Circulation: Stairs<br />

Surrounding Land Use: Residential & Rail Corridor<br />

Process and Status: Under Construction<br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

Context Map<br />

Section<br />

90


DESCRIPTION<br />

Introduction<br />

• Project consists of 167 stacked and back to back<br />

townhouses, 20 non-residential condominium units, a new<br />

public street, an extension of Macaulay Avenue to the new<br />

street and a new community facility at 362 Wallace Avenue<br />

Site Context<br />

• The site is bounded by Employment Areas to the north, as<br />

well as Neighbourhoods to the north, east and south, and the<br />

West Toronto Railpath to the west of the site<br />

Site Organization<br />

•Sousa Mendes Street, a new street, runs north/south from the<br />

southern end of Edwin Avenue to Wallace Avenue<br />

• Macaulay Avenue extends westward to meet Sousa Mendes<br />

Street. On the west side of Sousa Mendes Street are 20, 2-<br />

storey non-residential condominium units with 40 underground<br />

parking spaces containing offices, small scale retail, workshops<br />

and studios<br />

• On the east side of Sousa Mendes Street are 167 stacked and<br />

back to back townhouse units, 13m in height arranged in<br />

blocks of 13-21 units, with 3 blocks located north of the<br />

MaCaulay Avenue extension and 6 blocks located south<br />

• 179 resident parking, 22 visitor parking spaces underground<br />

and 19 on-street parking spaces.<br />

• A 475 square metre community facility on the northwest<br />

corner of the site, which will be operated by a non-profit<br />

agency on behalf of the City<br />

Site Plan<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

Perspective<br />

APPENDICES | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

Building Massing and Design<br />

• Private amenity space provided in the form of balconies and<br />

roof terraces<br />

• A variety of trees, shrubs and perennials provided between<br />

units at entrances, along streetscape and between blocks<br />

•Design varies per Townhouse block, is contemporary with a<br />

mix of brick, aluminum panelling and window glazing<br />

Elevation<br />

91


APPENDICES | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

Dwell City Towns<br />

2 Holiday Drive – Etobicoke York District<br />

Townhouse block elevation<br />

Townhouse Block Elevation<br />

Developer: Menkes Developments Ltd.<br />

Architect: Turner Fleisher<br />

Landscape Architect: NAK Design Group<br />

Project Statistics<br />

General Description: The proposed development will be constructed<br />

in a variety of forms including stacked townhouses and back to back<br />

units arranged in 13 blocks with a central common amenity area.<br />

Type: Stacked Townhouses and Back-to-Back Townhouses<br />

Building Height: 13m<br />

Site Area: 21,824.71 sq.m<br />

Total GFA: 25,355 sq.m<br />

Lot Coverage: 35%, 1.2 FSI<br />

No. of units: 196<br />

Separation distances between blocks,<br />

between end units: 12m-15m<br />

Setbacks: 2m-14m<br />

No. of parking spaces and location: 278; 269 below grade and 9<br />

above grade<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

Common Amenity Area: yes<br />

Vertical Circulation:<br />

Surrounding Land Use: Located in a Mixed Use Area surrounded by<br />

Neighbourhoods<br />

Process and Status: Rezoning and Site Plan Approval<br />

(both complete)<br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

Built Form Separation<br />

Front Elevation<br />

92


DESCRIPTION<br />

Introduction<br />

• In 2008 the previous owner rezoned the property to permit<br />

the development of 4 residential apartment buildings.<br />

• The buildings ranged in height from 19 to 24 storeys with a<br />

total of 887 units & a maximum Gross Floor Area of<br />

80,841m2, resulting in an FSI of 3.7<br />

• In 2012 Menkes Developments Ltd. Initiated a zoning by-law<br />

amendment to permit 196 townhouse units<br />

Site Context<br />

• The site has a mixed use designation and it is bounded by<br />

Apartment Neighbourhoods to the north, south and west.<br />

Hwy. 427 is directly east of the site<br />

• South of Holiday Drive, opposite this development, is<br />

another townhouse development with a private driveway<br />

providing site access and circulation.<br />

Site Organization<br />

• The site has13 stacked and back-to-back townhouse blocks<br />

located over an underground parking garage<br />

•Blocks are organized around an internal private driveway. It<br />

provides access to the underground parking, services for<br />

waste pick-up, and doubles as a fire route. A single point of<br />

access is provided off Holiday Drive<br />

• The blocks are generally organized around the private<br />

driveway, landscaped walkways, and a centrally located<br />

landscaped open space<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

Site Plan<br />

APPENDICES | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

Building Massing and Design<br />

• The unit mix is varied and ranges in height from<br />

4 storeys to 3 storeys in height<br />

•Terraces are located predominantly on the roof top or the<br />

top level. Grade related terraces are located away from the<br />

driveway, adjacent to internal walkways.<br />

• The design is contemporary with the use of brick and vision<br />

glass with secondary materials of spandrel and aluminum<br />

Architectural Rendering<br />

93


APPENDICES | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

Southshore<br />

120 Twenty Fourth Street – Etobicoke York District<br />

Streetview Looking East<br />

Developer: Diamondcorp with Minto<br />

Communities<br />

Architect: Guthrie Muscovitch Architects and<br />

Giannone Petricone Associates<br />

Landscape Architect: NAK Design Strategies<br />

Project Statistics<br />

General Description: 7 north-south oriented blocks<br />

Type: Stacked and back-to-back Townhouses<br />

Building Height: 13.5m<br />

Site Area: 12,820 sq.m<br />

Total GFA: 15,810.23 sq.m<br />

Site Coverage: 1.23<br />

No. of units: 148<br />

Separation distances between blocks: varies from 13.3m-14.2m<br />

Setbacks:<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

No. of parking spaces and location: 185 spaces underground<br />

Common Amenity Area: None<br />

Vertical Circulation: Stair<br />

Surrounding Land Use: Neighbourhoods and Parks with Local Rail<br />

Lines and Employment to the immediate north<br />

Process and Status: Completed<br />

Interior Pathway<br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

94


DESCRIPTION<br />

Introduction<br />

• 148 stacked and back to back townhouses in 7 blocks with<br />

a mix of 2 and 3 bedroom units<br />

• Residential infill redevelopment of a former industrial site<br />

(Sico Paints) on a 1.3 hectare irregularly shaped lot, with 44<br />

units facing 3 public streets, remaining units front onto<br />

internal walkways<br />

Site Context<br />

• The property abuts a rail corridor to the north, a park to the<br />

west and residential to the south and east.<br />

• 18 existing mature trees on the site were preserved<br />

Site Organization<br />

• A 25m landscaped setback along the CN rail corridor runs<br />

the length of the north property line, and also includes the<br />

ramp to the underground garage, loading space and two<br />

garbage storage buildings<br />

• Pedestrian circulation through the site is by internal<br />

pathway accented by trees, benches and bollard lighting<br />

• 155 resident, 30 visitor parking spaces and 20 bicycle<br />

parking spaces are accessed by a single ramp<br />

Building Massing and Design<br />

• Unit entrances organized so that most entry ways provide<br />

access to 4 units<br />

• Three townhouse blocks have flat roofs with building<br />

heights between 10.5 and 11.5m, remaining blocks have<br />

peaked roofs with building heights of 13.5m.<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

Site Plan<br />

APPENDICES | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

• Building material is predominantly brick, with private<br />

outdoor amenity spaces dominated by black metal handrails<br />

Front yard landscaping<br />

95


APPENDICES | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

TEN88<br />

1088 Progress Avenue – East District<br />

Internal Street Perspective<br />

Developer: Pace Developments Inc.<br />

Architect: Kohn Partnership Architects<br />

Landscape Architect: Marton Smith<br />

Landscape Architects<br />

Project Statistics<br />

General Description: The proposed development will consist of 3<br />

blocks of back-to-back townhouses with south-facing end units on<br />

the southern end of the property<br />

Type: Stacked back-to-back townhouses<br />

Building Height: 9.6-10.1m (to roof terrace)<br />

Site Area: 5,580 sq.m<br />

Total GFA: 8,798 sq.m, 1.58 FSI<br />

Site Coverage: 38%<br />

No. of units: 105<br />

Separation distances between blocks: 21.6m, (8.3-15.9 between end<br />

unit blocks)<br />

Setbacks: 5.1m to building face from Progress Avenue<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

No. of parking spaces and location: 129 (21 V), underground<br />

Common Amenity Area: Playground, Centre Green, outdoor seating<br />

and arbours<br />

Vertical Circulation: Stairs<br />

Surrounding Land Use: Located in an Apartments Neighbourhood<br />

with Neighbourhoods to the south, Mixed-Use to the west, Parks to<br />

the east, and Apartments Neighbourhood to the north<br />

Process and Status: Site Plan Approval<br />

Context Map<br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

96<br />

Section Through Buildings


DESCRIPTION<br />

Introduction<br />

• The project consists of 105 units in 3 townhouse blocks 3<br />

and 4 storeys in height on the south end of a 2 phase<br />

development with two condominium towers to the north. The<br />

0.93 ha site is currently vacant<br />

Site Context<br />

• The property is designated Apartment Neighbourhoods, and<br />

is bounded by Apartment Neighbourhoods to the North, Parks<br />

to the east, Neighbourhoods to the South and Mixed Use to<br />

the west. The property is also bounded by three streets,<br />

Sheppard Avenue, Progress Avenue and Orchard Place Drive,<br />

and a new public street is proposed<br />

Site Organization<br />

• The site is organized in a linear arrangement to provide<br />

access to the parking ramp and shared outdoor amenity<br />

space and provide visibility to unit entrances from streets<br />

• 130 parking spaces provided underground including 21<br />

visitor<br />

Building Massing and Design<br />

• End units on Orchard Place Drive are grade related while<br />

north-south units have multiple stairs to entrances<br />

• Private amenity space provided in courtyards and rooftop<br />

terraces<br />

• Shared amenity space provided as a landscaped Centre<br />

Green, arbours and playground<br />

Site Plan<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

North Elevation<br />

APPENDICES | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

• Building materials consist of two colours of brick,<br />

contrasting window fenestration and horizontal wood rail<br />

articulation at the ground plane. Black stair and balcony<br />

handrails dominate the facade<br />

Architectural Rendering<br />

97


APPENDICES | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

98


7.0 Glossary<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

GLOSSARY AND FOOTNOTES | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE BUILDING GUIDELINES<br />

99


GLOSSARY AND FOOTNOTES | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

Glossary<br />

Address - a building with ‘address’ means its front door faces<br />

the public street<br />

Above-grade - space that is above ground level<br />

At-grade - space that is on the same level as the ground<br />

Amenity - those architectural and landscape elements in, and at<br />

the edges of, open space that promote the comfortable use of a<br />

space<br />

Angular Plane – angular planes provide build-to envelopes to<br />

maintain and define the character of the street; ensure adequate<br />

access to sun and sky views; and govern relationships between<br />

adjacent differing built forms<br />

Articulation - the layout or pattern of building elements<br />

including walls, doors, roofs, windows, cornices and belt<br />

courses<br />

Back of House Activities - Activities, essential to the efficient<br />

function of the development, that are commonly situated at the<br />

rear of the buildings (eg. garbage storage and vehicle access)<br />

Balcony - an outdoor elevated platform projected from or<br />

integrated into a building, enclosed by a parapet or railing<br />

Bay - in architecture, any division of a building between<br />

vertical lines or planes, especially the entire space included two<br />

adjacent supports<br />

Below-grade - space that is below ground level<br />

historic or cultural significance<br />

Courtyard – a landscaped open space, located in the centre of a<br />

single or consolidated block with no direct street frontage<br />

Development Infrastructure Policy and Standards (DIPS) -<br />

standards that establish clear directions for the layout and<br />

design of new public residential streets<br />

Driveway - an paved vehicular access that typically leads from<br />

the street to a private or shared garage or service area<br />

Façade - the exterior parts of the building visible to the public,<br />

usually shown in elevation drawings, that represents the<br />

building, tells people about the building, what it is, how to<br />

enter, the nature of the interior uses and their relationship with<br />

adjacent buildings, streets and open spaces<br />

Forecourts - landscaped open space between the public<br />

sidewalk and the main entrance of a building.<br />

Freehold - a privately owned property without shared or<br />

common elements<br />

Frontage – the portion of a development parcel or lot facing a<br />

street, park or other publicly accessible open space<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

Harmonious - having the elements arranged in a proportionate,<br />

orderly and pleasing method<br />

Heritage Conservation District (HCD) - an area of the city that is<br />

protected by policies and guidelines to ensure its conservation<br />

and careful management. HCDs are designated based on their<br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

100<br />

Common Element Condominium - as described in subsection<br />

138(2) of the Condominium Act, 1998,<br />

S.O. 1998, chapter 19<br />

Corner Treatment - a situation where two planes meet and<br />

present a three-dimensional view of the building and where the<br />

architectural treatment acknowledges the building's prominence<br />

on the street in terms of views and presence<br />

Human Scale – the quality of the physical environment which<br />

reflects a sympathetic proportional relationship to human<br />

dimensions and which contributes to the citizen's perception<br />

and comprehension of buildings or buildings or other features<br />

of the built environment<br />

Infill Townhouse Guidelines - design guidelines introduced<br />

in 2003 by the City of Toronto to address townhouse<br />

developments on public streets and short private mews


Landscaped Open Space – outdoor area characterized by hard<br />

and/or soft landscape treatment, but excluding driveways and<br />

vehicular parking areas. On-site landscaped open space may be<br />

publicly accessible or privately shared common outdoor space<br />

at-grade<br />

Landscaped Setback- the space between the public sidewalk<br />

and building face characterized by hard or soft landscape<br />

treatment<br />

Massing - the size and shape of a building above grade<br />

the entrance<br />

Main Wall - the predominant exterior vertical wall face of a<br />

building<br />

Mews Street - a privately owned and maintained street which<br />

provides for the full range of roles of a public street. A mews<br />

provides access and address at all times<br />

Overlook Condition - condition in which above-grade<br />

apartments or balconies have a view of private or public<br />

outdoor amenity spaces below them<br />

Pattern of Alignment - the repeated location of the front face of<br />

buildings in relationship to the property line<br />

Pattern of Building - the repeated physical characteristics of<br />

buildings within an area, on a street or block, including the<br />

building footprint, organization and massing<br />

Pavilion – the opposite of a streetwall building, a building that<br />

stands distinctly on its own surrounded by landscaping<br />

Pedestrian amenity - architectural and landscape elements,<br />

including lighting, trees, four season landscaping, decorative<br />

paving, seating, public art, water features, etc., that promote the<br />

safe and comfortable use of streets and open spaces<br />

Pedestrian Mews - a privately owned and maintained pedestrian<br />

street which provides access and address to individual<br />

buildings and units within a larger development site. A mews is<br />

open to the public and accessible at all times.<br />

Pedestrian scale - the quality of the physical environment<br />

which reflects a sympathetic proportional relationship to human<br />

dimensions and which contributes to a person's perception and<br />

comprehension of buildings and or other features in the built<br />

environment<br />

Plazas - animated gathering place with predominantly hard<br />

surfaced landscape features flanking a public street.<br />

Porch - a raised area projecting from the building at the level of<br />

Permeable Paving - pavement that allows water movement<br />

through its surface<br />

Private Mews - a small privately owned and maintained street<br />

which provides for the full range of roles of a public street,<br />

providing access and address at all times<br />

Private Shared Driveway - a paved vehicular access under<br />

private ownership, from a street and used as a circulation<br />

route through a development either with or without parking; for<br />

services and access to garages; does not provide pedestrian<br />

access or address for buildings<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

Public Realm – streets, lanes and walkways, parks and other<br />

open spaces and the accessible parts of public buildings<br />

Public Street - a public way or thoroughfare in a City or town,<br />

usually with sidewalks<br />

Setbacks – refers to the distance between a property line and<br />

the front, side or rear of a building<br />

Separation Distance - distance between the face of a building<br />

and the face of another building or property line<br />

Siting / Building Orientation - the location, positioning and<br />

orientation of a building on its site, generally taking into<br />

account its relationship to adjoining properties, building and<br />

street boundaries<br />

101<br />

GLOSSARY AND FOOTNOTES | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES


GLOSSARY AND FOOTNOTES | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

Siting / Building Orientation – the location, positioning and<br />

(Open space on the block tends to be in the middle of the block<br />

orientation of a building on its site, generally taking into account and is typically fenced for private uses, for service or parking,<br />

its relationship to adjoining properties, building and street<br />

or for use as a lane)<br />

boundaries<br />

Transition Between Zones of Intensity - on sites that are<br />

Soft Landscaping – open, unobstructed area that supports the adjacent to lower height limits either on the block or across the<br />

growth of vegetation such as grass, trees, shrubs, flowers or street, the massing and shape of new development should step<br />

other plants, and that permits water infiltration into the ground down to the adjacent height limit forming a base building at<br />

that height. Stepping the taller parts of the development away<br />

Stepbacks – refers to the setting back of the upper storeys of from the lower height area provides a transition from areas of<br />

a building. Front and side stepbacks help to create a transition differing intensity<br />

between built form of varying heights and provide appropriate Treatment Train - a system designed to treat stormwater run<br />

separation between adjacent buildings and/or open spaces off for water quality benefits and to reduce stormwater runoff<br />

peaks and volumes<br />

Storey – a habitable level within a building, excluding raised<br />

basements<br />

Urban Design - the analysis and design of the city’s physical<br />

form<br />

Stoop - a small landing in front of and at the level of the<br />

building entrance<br />

Urban Garden - a landscaped open space of intimate scale<br />

providing a tranquil setting adjacent to a city street<br />

Storey - a habitable level within a building, excluding raised<br />

basements<br />

Urban Tree Canopy - the layer of leaves, branches, and stems of<br />

trees that cover the ground when viewed from above<br />

Street - a significant part of the City’s open space system. In<br />

their role as connective linear open spaces, streets provide<br />

Walkway - a street level exterior publicly accessible pedestrian<br />

vehicular, pedestrian and utility access, address and light to<br />

way through the middle of a city block<br />

individual lots and blocks within the urban fabric. In addition<br />

they are landscaped and lit in the evening and provide a setting<br />

for social interaction and neighbourhood activities. A street may<br />

be private if it performs the many roles of a public street<br />

Streetwall - occurs where the sides of buildings touch each<br />

other and the building facades visually join together into one<br />

long wall defining a street space<br />

<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

Street Proportion - the ratio of the height of buildings along<br />

the edges of the street and the width of the space between the<br />

building faces on each side of the street (includes setbacks)<br />

Terrace - an outdoor sitting area which extends the interior<br />

living space and is either adjacent to or on top of a building<br />

CITY OF TORONTO<br />

2014 / 2015<br />

Traditional Block - divided into lots; on these, individual<br />

buildings are sited close to the perimeter streets with private<br />

open space at the rear and sometimes the side of buildings.<br />

102


<strong>DRAFT</strong><br />

GLOSSARY AND FOOTNOTES | TOWNHOUSE AND LOW-RISE APARTMENT GUIDELINES<br />

103

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!