18.01.2016 Views

January 18, 2016

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Monday, <strong>18</strong> <strong>January</strong>, <strong>2016</strong><br />

Notes from the city of the not allowed<br />

A film too far<br />

It is a wise culture that can disguise its revolutions as homage<br />

to the past. Or even as innocuous routine. The Indian subcontinent<br />

seems to be an expert in both. It is well-known that the<br />

Sankaracharya, a real game-changer in philosophy, presented his<br />

most influential perceptions as mere commentaries on the earliest<br />

texts in the culture. This was perceived as the epitome of humility,<br />

a virtue particularly valued by traditionalists. Today there can be<br />

little doubt that the strategy of humility was born of radiant cunning.<br />

Much later, in familiar times, the former prime minister, P.V.<br />

Narasimha Rao, chose to cloak the liberalization of India's economy<br />

by depicting reform as the last stage of Nehruvianism. And now<br />

Arun Jaitley, who heads the information and broadcasting ministry,<br />

has decided to follow in the illustrious footsteps of such masters<br />

from the past. The Central Board of Film Certification's decision<br />

to allow frontal nudity is actually as revolutionary in the land<br />

of ready scissors and quick bans as the dismantling of India's<br />

licence permit raj. Yet Mr Jaitley has brought about the change<br />

unheralded. Perhaps the intriguing case of The Danish Girl - the<br />

CBFC passed the film's depictions of nudity, transsexuality and<br />

kissing without cuts - is a bit like a trial balloon loosed to gauge<br />

the temperature of a cultural environment threatened constantly<br />

by vigilante thugs on the one hand and intrusive, paternalistic<br />

laws on the other. Since male nudity in the film is unquestionably<br />

fundamental to the story of sex-change and its psychology, it offers<br />

a neat opportunity to fly the balloon innocuously. Mr Jaitley's<br />

strategy may establish the rationale for the rating system for films,<br />

while ending the absurd reign of arbitrary censorship - the CBFC<br />

decides what is good and what is bad for adult citizens - or it may<br />

cause an embarrassing or unmanageable fallout. In that case, there<br />

is always the option of representing it as a one-off case, the one<br />

that just got away. It is unlikely that the minister would risk the<br />

fate that befell M.F. Husain, who was hounded out of his homeland<br />

by vigilantes for his depiction of Hindu deities. On the positive<br />

side, though, Mr Jaitley could recall the 'One Country, Two<br />

Systems' principle formulated by Deng Xiaoping in China. A political<br />

union can allow its territories with distinct cultural legacies<br />

to enjoy a certain autonomy. Why cannot, then, there be one rule<br />

for Hollywood and one for Bollywood? But even at its most positive,<br />

change takes place in droplets in India. Cultural shifts, changes<br />

in attitude, a discrimination in taste, and the confidence these require,<br />

spread slowly. Besides, the ladies of the Bombay film industry<br />

would be in no hurry for the full monty, for reasons more delicate<br />

and selfish than just antagonizing the conservative milieu.<br />

Opportunistic Indian Politicians<br />

Put Tradition Above Law<br />

Elections, which are the lifeblood<br />

of democracy, reveal their<br />

negative side when politicians<br />

abandon ethical convictions for the<br />

sake of playing to the gallery. Pandering<br />

to the various predilections<br />

of the electorate ranging from the<br />

distribution of cash, clothes or liquor<br />

to appealing to their religious/<br />

sectarian instincts has been an unfortunate<br />

feature of Indian elections.<br />

Tactics of this nature have<br />

sometimes proved successful as<br />

has been demonstrated by the<br />

BJP’s use of the divisive Ram temple<br />

issue to move from the fringe of<br />

national politics to centre-stage.<br />

The Bharatiya Janata Party’s claim<br />

in the early stages of the temple<br />

agitation was that the judiciary had<br />

no right to interfere in matters of<br />

faith. The party’s chief minister in<br />

Uttar Pradesh at the time, Kalyan<br />

Singh, courted arrest with a proud<br />

smile for having defied the Supreme<br />

Court’s orders on protecting<br />

the Babri masjid, which was<br />

pulled down by a saffron mob in<br />

1992 to make way for the proposed<br />

temple. A similar show of defiance<br />

can be seen in Tamil Nadu Chief<br />

Minister J Jayalalithaa’s call to the<br />

Centre to promulgate an ordinance<br />

to negate the Supreme Court’s ban<br />

on the jallikattu programme which<br />

involves taming bulls. In response<br />

to the petitions of animal rights activists,<br />

a judicial ban on the practice<br />

has been in force for four years.<br />

But next year’s assembly elections<br />

in Tamil Nadu have awakened the<br />

state’s politicians to the need to<br />

protect the ‘ancient tradition’ of<br />

jallikattu, which marks the Pongal<br />

festival in Tamil Nadu. By themselves,<br />

the politicians would not<br />

have imposed the ban since animal<br />

rights are not high on their list of<br />

priorities. Moreover, if such a supposedly<br />

effeminate concept conflicts<br />

with the gory, feudal customs<br />

preferred by the unwashed masses,<br />

there can be no doubt as to whose<br />

side the politicians will take. For<br />

SCRIPSI<br />

Jayalalitha, the outpouring of respect<br />

after a lapse of four years for<br />

a tradition which has elements of<br />

cruelty and sadism has apparently<br />

been necessitated by the recent devastating<br />

floods in Chennai caused<br />

by incessant rain, which exposed<br />

the failures of the administration<br />

and the degradation of natural water<br />

bodies by the builders’ lobby.<br />

Although her principal opponent in<br />

the state, the DMK is not in the best<br />

of health under 92-year-old M<br />

Karunanidhi, she cannot be too<br />

sure of the success of her own, oneperson<br />

AIADMK. In any event,<br />

since she cannot afford to take any<br />

chances in these uncertain days of<br />

volatile voters - the DMK, after all,<br />

has a 28 percent vote share - she<br />

has evidently decided that a show<br />

of respect for tradition will serve her<br />

well. While Jayalalitha’s compulsions<br />

are understandable, what is<br />

odd is why the BJP, which virtually<br />

has no presence in Tamil Nadu,<br />

should have taken up the cudgels<br />

for the chief minister. Is it cozying<br />

up to Jayalalitha for a tie-up in the<br />

state or is it for the sake of the<br />

AIADMK’s cooperation in parliament<br />

for the passage of the reform<br />

bills? The BJP is apparently so upset<br />

by her umbrage that it wants the<br />

chairman and vice-chairman of the<br />

Animal Welfare Board to resign for<br />

having approached the Supreme<br />

Court about the government’s pro-<br />

Jallikattu notification. So much<br />

for the ruling party’s respect for<br />

institutional autonomy! Perhaps<br />

we will now see a couple of saffron<br />

apparatchiki appointed to<br />

these posts who are not too sensitive<br />

about the modern fad<br />

about the ‘rights’ of dumb creatures.<br />

Not surprisingly, Union<br />

Minister Nirmala Sitharaman, who<br />

was born in Madurai in Tamil Nadu<br />

although she currently represents<br />

Andhra Pradesh in the Rajya Sabha,<br />

has said that the Centre had no objections<br />

to the state promulgating<br />

an ordinance.<br />

How to live in a world with which you disagree? How to live with<br />

people when you neither share their suffering nor their joys? When you<br />

know that you don't belong among them?... our century refuses to acknowledge<br />

anyone's right to disagree with the world... All that remains<br />

of such a place is the memory, the ideal of a cloister, the dream of a<br />

cloister.<br />

- MILAN KUNDERA<br />

The 'this will do' culture<br />

I am going to describe three situations that,<br />

as far I know, could only happen in today's Calcutta.<br />

At the risk of sounding classist, elitist<br />

and a whole host of other non- hoi polloi labels,<br />

I'm putting these down as indicators of a deeprooted<br />

malaise that spreads far beyond the context<br />

of the scenes that follow.<br />

Scene One: A friend and I decide to have a<br />

coffee at one of the small new cafes that have<br />

opened up around Hindustan Park. We know<br />

everyone claims to have 'espresso' on their<br />

menu and that many of these joints even have<br />

proper espresso machines, but it's still a minor<br />

risk, tasting an unknown espresso at an unknown<br />

café. Regardless, we sit and order. The<br />

young waitress takes our order: two double espressos<br />

with a small jug of hot milk on the side,<br />

to my companion's mind and mine a no-brainer<br />

of an order that you can get anywhere in any<br />

Indian metro. The young woman comes back<br />

and tells us, ' oita hobey na', 'it's not possible'.<br />

Why not? We are 'not allowed' to give milk with<br />

an espresso. It takes us a couple of minutes to<br />

understand that 'not allowed' means 'not free',<br />

so we say just bring us a small amount of milk<br />

and charge us extra. The coffee comes with two<br />

jugs of milk. The coffee is decent and genuine,<br />

not great, but perfectly drinkable, and the milk<br />

is also fine. The bill, when it comes, tells a story:<br />

each coffee is Rs 80, but we've been charged for<br />

two tiny jugs of milk at Rs15 each.<br />

Scene Two: This time I'm at a big branch of<br />

one of the older, well-known coffee-café-chains,<br />

not far from the new place mentioned above. I'm<br />

with a different friend and I tell him the story of<br />

the expensive, 'not-allowed' milk. Both of us are<br />

old veterans of Bangali/Kolkataiya perversity<br />

and we laugh at my little story. ' Eikhaaney ora<br />

totally cool, there will no such problem!' Here<br />

they're totally cool, he informs me while waving<br />

grandly at the waiter. I order the same, a double<br />

espresso with a bit of warm milk on the side.<br />

The waiter doesn't blink. He goes off and, in<br />

due course, returns with our order. All seems<br />

right with the world until I notice that the coffee<br />

is in a small espresso cup that is full to the brim.<br />

I call the waiter back and request him to pour<br />

the coffee into a larger cup so that I can add the<br />

milk to it. He goes off and comes back with another<br />

waiter who might even have been the<br />

manager of the branch. 'Syaar, otaa hobey na,<br />

oi boro cup- ta.' Sir, we can't do that, the big cup<br />

you asked for. By now my coffee is getting cold<br />

and my friend's brain and mine are getting hot.<br />

'Keno hobey na? Hobey na keno?' Why not?<br />

Why can't you do it?' 'Sir, it's not allowed. We<br />

have CCTV cameras. If we are caught doing<br />

we are 77 percenters, that is, satisfied with almost<br />

doing a job, with more or less finishing<br />

something, tending to give up as we approach<br />

the end of a task. From a Calcutta point-of-view,<br />

Gopinath (who has lived in this city) must have<br />

been speaking of the south or of Bombay perhaps,<br />

or even Delhi; in Calcutta, we have successfully<br />

created what one might call a 'Forty-<br />

Four Percent Culture'. We don't even bother to<br />

get half the job done before reaching for the<br />

eita cholbe flag, for the ' this will do' banner.<br />

There is no explanation, otherwise, for this man,<br />

an intelligent person who is clearly quite proud<br />

of his café's ambience and menu, to take his eye<br />

off the ball on such a simple thing as serving<br />

properly warmed food.<br />

In the coffee places, something else is at play,<br />

connected to the 44-percent-ness, but additionally<br />

about ignorance and fear. Here, the fault lies<br />

not with this young serving staff but with the<br />

oppressive idiots who employ them. The owners,<br />

or employers, or managers of the cafes clearly<br />

want to cash in on the aspirational aspects of a<br />

modern café, of Italian-style coffee which can be<br />

madly over-priced, but they're unwilling to let<br />

their employees (who are all clearly from a less<br />

privileged class) in on the culture from where<br />

these cafes derive, a culture which is about relaxation,<br />

about absence of tension, about 'adjusting'<br />

so that everyone can have a peaceful or<br />

laughter-filled time. In this, again, I would point<br />

my finger at what certain zones of Bengal and<br />

Calcutta have become: exploitative and arrogant<br />

'masters' controlling their employees through<br />

various levers of fear; the employees, in turn,<br />

lacking the security, the confidence and the selfrespect<br />

to make even micro-decisions on their<br />

own. For the kind of things that one experienced<br />

in the small café and the coffee-chain would hardly<br />

happen in Bombay or Delhi, where the waiter or<br />

the waitress would simply solve the problem to<br />

the best of their ability, not least in order to ensure<br />

a good tip and a return visit from a customer<br />

who might remember them positively. This may<br />

feel like I'm enlarging small events to a station<br />

beyond their significance, but it's not: in Bombay<br />

or Delhi, the waiter would be confident that<br />

if the employee was an oppressive idiot, there<br />

were a number of similar jobs available with other<br />

employees who were better, who didn't, for example,<br />

threaten to fire people because they<br />

changed the size of the cup at a customer's own<br />

request. Here, in this city striped with dirty white<br />

and the deepest blues, a person is reminded of<br />

the chasms and gaps and all that is verboten<br />

even as he takes a sip of tepid coffee from the<br />

not-allowed sized cup.<br />

Govt To Announce Friendly Tax<br />

Regime For Startups In Budget<br />

The government will also launch Stand Up India scheme under which,<br />

bank branches will lend to entrepreneurs of SC/STs and women.<br />

Government in the Budget next month will<br />

announce a friendly tax regime that will encourage<br />

setting up of startups in the country, Finance<br />

Minister Arun Jaitley said on Saturday. “We have<br />

already worked upon an entrepreneur-friendly<br />

taxation regime. There are some steps, which can<br />

be taken up by notifications, which would be taken<br />

forthwith. Others require legislative provisions,<br />

which can only come as part of the Finance Bill<br />

when Budget is presented in order to create a<br />

friendly taxation regime for startups,” he said at<br />

the Start Up India conference here. Recognising<br />

the need to encourage startups, a fund was suggested<br />

in the Budget last year, he said. He assured<br />

the startups that both the banking system<br />

and the government will make the resources available<br />

to them. Besides Start Up, the Finance Minister<br />

said the government will launch Stand Up<br />

India scheme under which, bank branches will<br />

lend to entrepreneurs belonging to SC/STs and<br />

women. “On Independence Day, Prime Minister<br />

(Narendra Modi) announced the Stand Up India<br />

scheme. The Stand Up India would be separately<br />

launched. It is a programme, which envisages<br />

women entrepreneurs and entrepreneurs belonging<br />

to the SC, STs (to get funding from banks).<br />

These were the segments which were not throwing<br />

up entrepreneurs. “Each bank branch, public<br />

sector or private sector, would actually adopt one<br />

in the SC/ST category and one in the women category.<br />

So they will adopt two such entrepreneurs<br />

and fund them to set up establishments,” he said.<br />

By funding trading or manufacturing establishment<br />

of this segment, almost 3,00,000 new entrepreneurs<br />

over the next two years will be created,<br />

he said. To promote startups, the Finance Minister<br />

said the government is easing the process of<br />

doing business. “Another very significant difference<br />

of what makes it a landmark event is a final<br />

break or the ultimate break that you have with the<br />

conventional licence Raj of India,” he said. “We<br />

did well to break off from it in 1991 but it was only<br />

partial. It was partial because who would be<br />

funded there was an invisible role of state, con-<br />

that, we'll lose our jobs.' 'What?? All of you???'<br />

'No, sir, only the waiter who pours it from the<br />

small cup to the big cup. If the camera catches<br />

him, he'll be fired. You see, it's not allowed to pour<br />

any espresso into a big cup.' My friend and I<br />

shake our heads, we scratch them, we almost<br />

bang them together in the frustration-marinaded<br />

knowledge that all our lives we have tried to escape<br />

this city but, with both our advanced years,<br />

perhaps we never will, not spiritually or psychically,<br />

at any rate. Finally, a solution is arrived at.<br />

'Okay,' I say, 'please just bring us a large cup.<br />

Bring it to this table.' 'Yes,' says my friend, 'I want<br />

to pour my tea into two large cups.' Both the waiters<br />

nod happily and vigorously - this they can<br />

do, this way they can get out of jail free. A large<br />

cup is duly brought. The uniformed t-shirts look<br />

away while I pour the now completely tepid coffee<br />

into the large cup and add the lukewarm milk.<br />

The waiters look relieved: customer is not throwing<br />

a tantrum and neither is the CCTV camera.<br />

Scene Three: The cutest little café-snack bar,<br />

again in south Kol. With a courtyard, even, that's<br />

open to the sky. A menu that looks both unpretentious<br />

and good. A friend and I order motorshutir<br />

kochuri and alur dom for lunch. The food<br />

comes, the kochuri element is hot, the alur dom is<br />

completely cold, something that would be sacrilegious<br />

and unheard of in a street-side stall or<br />

pice-hotel-type place. After a little discussion, the<br />

waiter goes off and nukes our alur dom in the<br />

microwave; by the time he's back, the kachoris<br />

are cold. The waiter is a nice guy, polite, friendly,<br />

no bad attitude, but completely unmoved by the<br />

fact that he's delivered faulty fooding-goods to<br />

the only customers in an almost empty eatery.<br />

Let's start with the last one first. C.Y. Gopinath<br />

wrote a piece in a newspaper a few years ago<br />

where he talked about how thoroughly people in<br />

Thailand, China and Taiwan did their jobs, including<br />

the most tedious and menial ones. Describing<br />

how he saw some workers clean a space,<br />

Gopinath remarked that in these cultures people<br />

were '100 percenters', meaning they didn't give<br />

up or stop till a place was absolutely spotless, or<br />

some other job was fully and unquestionably accomplished.<br />

In India, Gopinath pointed out sadly,<br />

trol over land permissions, foreign investment<br />

proposal and of course unless the political nods<br />

came to venture into newer areas which involved<br />

a lot of capital, a lot of energy going into it and an<br />

entrepreneur or investors was normally reluctant,”<br />

he said. Emphasising that the government has<br />

limited potential to create jobs, Jaitley said, the<br />

private sector has its own challenges.“The private<br />

sector own expansion itself is throwing up a<br />

challenge because they have over-stressed themselves<br />

and their stress in turn gets reflected on<br />

our banking system, something which the RBI<br />

and the government working in tandem, and over<br />

the next few months are going to add to the bankers<br />

ability to improve and be able to lend with a<br />

greater amounts,” he said. Under these circumstances,<br />

the government had to explore new areas<br />

and it is among those newer areas that it conceived<br />

of the MUDRA scheme. Pradhan Mantri<br />

Micro Units Development Refinance Agency<br />

(MUDRA) Yojana that the government conceived<br />

of, is intended to target 25 per cent of the bottom<br />

part of India’s population. “So people get loans<br />

from refinance agencies, public and private sector<br />

banks and other agencies. Earlier, they were<br />

being exploited by lenders at very high rates and<br />

now they get at bank rate and I must say the<br />

programme has been reasonably successful. In<br />

the last 4-5 months, almost 1.73 crore entrepreneurs<br />

have been enabled with loans,” he said.<br />

He expressed hope that the figure would be<br />

significantly higher by the end of this financial<br />

year. “We are going to roll over that programme<br />

year after year and smaller entrepreneurs are being<br />

created by that process,” he added. On the<br />

economy, Arun Jaitley observed that India has<br />

its own challenges despite being the fastest growing<br />

large economy in the world. “Unquestionably,<br />

the world economy has slowed down. Now we<br />

can take a limited satisfaction that even in a crisis<br />

like situation in the world, we are growing much<br />

faster. The world recognises us as probably the<br />

fastest growing among the major economies, but<br />

then we are not without our own challenges,” he<br />

said. “We are fully conscious of the adverse situation<br />

in which we are. We are struggling to keep<br />

respectable growth rate (despite) certain advantages<br />

like we have a booming services sector, we<br />

have a manufacturing sector slowly growing, we<br />

have increased our public spending, we have<br />

opened our doors wide enough and foreign investment<br />

is coming in a big way, at least in the<br />

urban areas we can see an increasing demand,”<br />

he said. These are the engines that are keeping<br />

this growth rate alive, he said. Talking about<br />

headwinds to economic growth, the finance minister<br />

said, slow agriculture production due to<br />

weak monsoon and subdued private investment<br />

are a few challenges. “If you look at the direction<br />

in which the conventional global economy<br />

is moving today, we almost are moving from a<br />

crisis situation literally by the day. Nobody really<br />

can envisage looking down the tunnel as to<br />

what the situation of the world economy, one<br />

year or two year from now is going to be. Nobody<br />

can seriously predict as to what the emerging<br />

challenges down the few months are going<br />

to be,” he said.<br />

“Earlier crisis like situation came once a decade,<br />

today it may emerge twice in a day. You may<br />

have the impact of Chinese economy and their<br />

currency on one part of the world and you may<br />

have the oil prices striking you at the other part<br />

of the world and you will have a global impact<br />

simultaneously of these challenges,” he added.<br />

THE NATIONAL DAWN Printed, Published & Owned by Vikramrao Sanas and Printed at Bhaskar Printing Press, B-129 A.B. Central Road, No-12 Udhana, Surat (Gujarat) & Published at - S-30 Kanaknidhi Complex, Opp.<br />

Gandihi Smruti Bhavan, Nanpura, Surat-395001 (Guj) Editor- Vikram Sanas is Responsible for the News Published in PRB. ACT

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!