Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
end of an era<br />
US Medical Colleges End<br />
Animal Laboratory Practice<br />
By Benjamin Goodin<br />
Recently, a momentous event quietly transpired as many of us<br />
were preparing to celebrate our country’s independence. In<br />
late June, just weeks after the medical school at Johns Hopkins<br />
University made a similar decision, the University of Tennessee<br />
discontinued the use of live animal laboratories in its medical school.<br />
With the end of this final program, live animal laboratories are officially<br />
no longer required at any American or Canadian medical schools.<br />
Live animal laboratories were a common fixture in medical<br />
schools until the last two decades, when their use and popularity<br />
declined significantly. Live animal laboratories were commonly<br />
used to acquaint medical students with surgical and internal procedures<br />
on living anatomy. While first-hand familiarity with anatomy is<br />
vital knowledge for a future surgeon or practitioner of professional<br />
medicine on humans, there have been longstanding concerns by<br />
many parties as to the ethical nature of using live animals.<br />
Common practice dictated that laboratory subjects, typically<br />
dogs, sheep, and pigs, be anesthetized during procedures per-<br />
’Thank You<br />
Thank you for donating items to<br />
Sojourn Shelter & Services during<br />
Thanksgiving In July, and supporting our<br />
Run for Prevention 5K, to aid Health Missions.<br />
We’re proud to serve your family with all your<br />
chiropractic care and overall wellness <strong>need</strong>s.<br />
Dr. Bryne Willey<br />
<strong>Springfield</strong> Chiropractor<br />
Family Friendly<br />
Chiropractic Healthcare<br />
2025 West Iles Avenue,<br />
<strong>Springfield</strong> IL 62704<br />
217-787-7500<br />
chiropractorspringfield.org<br />
’<br />
formed in animal laboratories, however, they were generally euthanized<br />
at the conclusion of the lab experience. The euthanasia was<br />
considered a kindness for the laboratory animals, which would be<br />
greatly injured during these exploratory and practice procedures.<br />
The majority of live animal laborites were required curriculum for<br />
medical students and, until recent decades, could not be opted<br />
out of or replaced with alternative curriculum. Should a student<br />
have ethical compunctions with the requirements of the laboratory<br />
curriculum, they would often be dismissed from their program for<br />
failing to complete the animal laboratory prerequisite.<br />
Although firsthand experience is undoubtedly the best way<br />
for any learning to take place, the affordability and adaptability<br />
of programs used to instruct medical students were the primary<br />
concerns of many training institutions. Recent advancements in<br />
medical, materials, and computer sciences have made realistic<br />
simulation software, tools, and environments a viable and affordable<br />
alternative to instruct medical students. Instituting advanced<br />
simulation environments that can accurately model human physiology<br />
has made animal laboratories a less affordable and less accurate<br />
model for instructing internal medicine.<br />
Pairing simulation and practice environments with clinical experiences,<br />
wherein a medical student observes and assists experienced<br />
professionals, is not only better aligned to the goals of medical learning<br />
curriculum, but may cost less, financially and ethically, over time.<br />
Although the use of animal laboratories persists in medical<br />
research fields and in some advanced surgical training programs,<br />
there is some hope that the advanced technical and simulation<br />
models of the near future will outdate experimentation on live animals<br />
in these fields as well.<br />
Sources available upon request.<br />
Photo credit: annedde/iStock<br />
Page 28 — Healthy Cells Magazine — Mid-Illinois <strong>Springfield</strong> / Decatur — September 2016