SURVEY DRAFT SHORTFOR BMM
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
EXHIBITOR FEEDBACK<br />
SUMMARY
100% WOULD LIKE TO EXHIBIT AT MASTERPIECE 2016<br />
(OF THE 116 EXHIBITORS WHO ANSWERED)<br />
Year % Exhibitors wanting to re exhibit the following year<br />
(based on survey responses)<br />
• 2015 94%<br />
• 2014 94%<br />
• 2013 90.5%<br />
• 2012 85%<br />
• 2011 90%<br />
• 2010 95%<br />
13% have requested to increase their stand size<br />
Lampronti Gallery - Fantastic fair! We look forward to participating<br />
next year!<br />
H. Blairman & Sons Ltd - Thank you for arranging an excellent event, and<br />
do invite us back next year!<br />
Rupert Wace Ancient Art - The fair continues to go from strength to<br />
strength with more and better quality visitors each year. It is clearly now<br />
a fixture on the summer circuit. We also felt that coinciding with London<br />
Art Week was extremely beneficial to both this year. There was a real art<br />
buzz in town that week.<br />
Adrian Sassoon - I fear a samey-ness but the formula is marvellous and<br />
still after all these years fine people are coming for the first time so that<br />
is great. Bravo for the great handling of the visitors.<br />
Wallace Chan - Masterpiece is a young and dynamic and fast growing<br />
fair. We invited many Chinese collectors and art lovers from the Chinese<br />
communities in London. They all appreciated very much visiting the fair<br />
and some came several time to visit all the stands. We are confident to<br />
have more Chinese visitors next year. Well done and bravo to the whole<br />
team!<br />
Modernity - Exceptionally professional, beautiful, and perfect<br />
management.<br />
GRIMA - We are surprised that there are still so many Londoners who<br />
have never heard of Masterpiece. Great fair. Thank you all very much.
SALES<br />
PATRON & CURATOR EVENING<br />
46% MADE SALES DURING THE PATRON & CURATOR EVENING<br />
9% increase on 2015<br />
(Based on 99 exhibitors who answered this question)<br />
PREVIEW DAY<br />
78% OF EXHIBITORS MADE SALES ON PREVIEW DAY<br />
same as 2015<br />
(Based on 99 exhibitors who answered this question)<br />
THROUGHOUT THE FAIR<br />
90% OF EXHIBITORS MADE SALES DURING MASTERPIECE 2016<br />
a 5% decrease on 2015<br />
(Based on 99 exhibitors who answered this question)<br />
ANNUAL SALES<br />
Average 0f 13% of exhibitors' sales per year made at Masterpiece 2016<br />
Same as 2015
REPORTED SALES<br />
742 sales reported via the survey, an average of 10.4 sales per exhibitor.<br />
(820 in 2015 and an average of 10.5 sales per exhibitor)<br />
Average of £369,151.51 in sales per exhibitor<br />
Average of £244,357.50 in post fair sales per exhibitor<br />
TOP QUANTITIES OF SALES<br />
Adrian Sassoon - 70<br />
Robert Young - 58<br />
W.W. Warner Antiques - 54<br />
SJ Phillips - 40<br />
Stockspring - 40<br />
Finch & Co - 30<br />
Carter Marsh - 25<br />
Katie Jones - 20<br />
Koopman Rare Art - 20<br />
NOTES ON SALES MADE<br />
Adrian Sassoon - A great range of our contemporary works of art and<br />
some specialised fine 18th century porcelains also.<br />
Dickinson - Two of the smaller least expensive items on the stand. Both<br />
sales under £100k mark.<br />
Finch & Co - Some important sales made to new and existing clients.<br />
Wallace Chan - To both existing and new clients.<br />
Wartski - Wide range from small stick pins to larger pieces of jewellery,<br />
some works by Faberge and miscellaneous objects.<br />
Osborne Samuel - Across the board, to UK, USA, Hong Kong,<br />
Switzerland. Old and new clients.<br />
Michele Beiny - I sold across the board, both old and new porcelain and<br />
glass although none of my Renaissance jewelry this year
VISITORS<br />
82% of exhibitors rated the potential for Masterpiece visitors to buy as<br />
good or very good. (84% in 2015)<br />
68% of exhibitors rated the potential for Masterpiece visitors to buy post<br />
fair as good or very good. (67% in 2015)<br />
84% of exhibitors rated the potential for a long term relationship with<br />
Masterpiece visitors as good or very good. (74% in 2015)<br />
OTHER FAIRS<br />
Exhibitors mentioned 49 other fairs they take part in<br />
70 exhibitors answered this question<br />
• 31 exhibitors including Dutko Gallery, Verdura, Philip Mould, Galery<br />
Chenel, MacConnal Mason, Blairman & Sons and Robertaebasta said<br />
MASTERPIECE is the most important fair for their business<br />
• 25 exhibitors including Dickinson, Hemmerle, Stair Sainty, Somlo,<br />
Alessandra di Castro and Stephen Ongpin said TEFAF is the most<br />
important fair for their business<br />
• 4 exhibitors (Aktis Gallery, Mayoral, Galerie Marcilhac and Galerie<br />
Sismann) said the BIENNALE DES ANTIQUAIRES is the most important<br />
fair for their business<br />
• 2 exhibitors (Mazzoleni and Anne Autegarden) said THE SALON ART<br />
+ DESIGN is the most important fair for their business<br />
• 2 exhibitors (Robert Young and Elle Shushan) said the WINTER AN-<br />
TIQUES SHOW is the most important fair for their business<br />
• 1 exhibitor (Whitford Fine Art) said BRAFA is the most important fair<br />
for their business<br />
• 1 exhibitor (Lampronti Gallery) said FRIEZE MASTERS is the most<br />
important fair for their business
MUSEUM CURATORS & DIRECTORS<br />
EXHIBITORS SAW AT THE FAIR<br />
OVER 200 MUSEUM CURATORS AND DIRECTORS ATTENDED IN 2016<br />
Art Institute of Chicago<br />
Ashmolean Museum<br />
Atopos Foundation<br />
(Director Stamos<br />
Fafalios)<br />
Bowes Museum<br />
Charles Saumerez Smith<br />
Cleveland Museum<br />
Cooper Hewitt Museum<br />
(Sarah Coffin)<br />
Dallas Art Museum<br />
Dallas Museum<br />
Dr Mark Collins<br />
Dr Susan Jenkins<br />
Fitzwilliam Museum<br />
Georgia O'Keefe<br />
Museum<br />
Getty Museum<br />
Houston Museum of<br />
National Science (Tom<br />
Hardwick)<br />
Japanese Museums<br />
LACMA<br />
Metropolitan Museum of<br />
Art (Carlos Picon, Luke<br />
Syson)<br />
MFA Boston<br />
MFA Houston (Dr Helga<br />
Kessler Aurisch)<br />
Minneapolis Institute of<br />
Art<br />
National Gallery of<br />
Victoria (Matthew<br />
Martin)<br />
National Gallery of<br />
Wales<br />
National Portrait Gallery<br />
(Lucy Wood)<br />
Natural History Museum<br />
New Orleans Museum of<br />
Art<br />
Ohio Museums<br />
Pallant House<br />
Rienzi Museum (Director<br />
Christine Gervais,<br />
Katherine Howe)<br />
Rory O'Donnell<br />
Sainsbury Centre<br />
Sévres Factory<br />
Shakespeare Trust<br />
St Louis Art Museum<br />
(David Conradsen)<br />
Sydney University<br />
Museums (Michael<br />
Turner)<br />
Tate<br />
Temple Newsam (Rachel<br />
Conroy )<br />
The British Museum<br />
(Marcel Maree, Hugo<br />
Chapman, Stephen<br />
Coppel)<br />
The Bruce Museum<br />
The Groeningemuseum<br />
The Lord Cormack<br />
The Royal Collection<br />
Trust (Caroline de<br />
Guitaut)<br />
Timothy Clifford<br />
Toronto Museum of Art<br />
Victoria & Albert<br />
Museum (Dr Mark Evan,<br />
Tessa Murdoch)<br />
Virginia Museum<br />
Waddesdon Manor<br />
Wallace Collection<br />
Winterthur Museum of<br />
Art (Tom Savage, Leslie<br />
Grigsby)<br />
Yale Center for British<br />
Art (Director Amy
INTEREST FROM OR SALES TO<br />
MUSEUMS DURING MASTERPIECE?<br />
43% REPORTED MUSEUM INTEREST AT MASTERPIECE 2016<br />
(49% in 2015)<br />
Modernity - Hopefully to a London museum but nothing is finalised yet.<br />
Thomas Gibson Fine Art - Interest from The Museum of Fine Arts<br />
Houston<br />
John Mitchell Fine Paintings - Interest from three different US museums<br />
but no significant sales<br />
Butchoff Antiques - No sales but we had some interest from St Louis Art<br />
Museum on one piece<br />
Robert Young - No sales this year, but we have some interest from a<br />
British institution. Also, we have made successful sales to Museums from<br />
Masterpiece in the past.<br />
Aktis Gallery - We have work being sent on approval to MFA Boston, but<br />
it is a client who is buying and donating.<br />
Robert Zehil Gallery - We sold a piece that was part of our exhibition<br />
catalogue to a museum. This museum had contacted us before<br />
Masterpiece.<br />
THE FOLLOWING EXHIBITORS ALSO REPORTED<br />
INTEREST FROM MUSEUMS AT MASTERPIECE 2016:<br />
Adrian Sassoon; Apter-Fredericks; Galerie Chenel; Charles Ede; Finch &<br />
Co; Agnews; Patrick & Ondine Mestdagh; W.W. Warner Antiques; Lampronti<br />
Gallery; Katie Jones; Stockspring Antiques; Michele Beiny; Rupert<br />
Wace Ancient Art; Repetto Gallery; Peter Petrou; Burzio; Wartski; Senger<br />
Bamberg Kunsthandel; Piano Nobile; Koopman Rare Art; Ronald Phillips;<br />
Mallett; Paolo Antonacci; Elle Shushan; Anthony Outred Ltd
PRESS & MARKETING<br />
86% OF EXHIBITORS WERE PLEASED WITH THE<br />
PR CAMPAIGN (question answered by 92 exhibitors)<br />
91% in 2015, 70% in 2014, 75% in 2013, 44% in 2012, 29% in 2011, 85% in 2010<br />
79% followed Masterpiece on Instagram/Twitter/Facebook<br />
Wallace Chan - We appreciate very much the team, so dynamic, efficient<br />
and friendly. It's a true pleasure to work with you!<br />
Adrian Sassoon - I think the PR needs a little more inspiration from the<br />
exhibitors.<br />
John Mitchell Fine Paintings - It seemed wider than last year's coverage<br />
and we noticed more features in the bigger papers.<br />
Long-Sharp Gallery - I was not "displeased" with the PR. I simply felt<br />
that the editorial coverage was not as good as it had been in previous<br />
years.<br />
Philip Mould & Company - Wasn't enough contact with PR staff at the fair<br />
regarding sales. Little or no coverage produced.<br />
Rolleston - Very good social media coverage
DINING<br />
54% OF EXHIBITORS ATE AT LE CAPRICE AT MASTERPIECE 2016<br />
43% OF EXHIBITORS ATE AT SCOTT'S BAR AT MASTERPIECE 2016<br />
47% OF EXHIBITORS ATE AT THE MOUNT STREET DELI<br />
31% OF EXHIBITORS ATE AT THE IVY BAR AT MASTERPIECE 2016<br />
18% OF EXHIBITORS USED THE PERRIER-JOUET CHAMPAGNE<br />
TERRACE<br />
59% OF EXHIBITORS ATE AT THE EXHIBITOR LOUNGE<br />
46% OF EXHIBITORS SAID THAT THEY MISSED THE CHAMPAGNE<br />
TROLLEY<br />
Exhibitors commented on the high standard at the restaurants<br />
(Anthony Outred, Warner Antiques, Adrian Sassoon, Patrick Bourne).<br />
Negative comments focused on the poor selection and quality of food<br />
in the Exhibitor Lounge (Tornabuoni. Thomas Gibson, Stair Sainty,<br />
Apter-Fredericks, Peter Petrou, Rupert Wace, Wartski, Patrick Bourne).<br />
Apter- Fredericks - Must improve exhibitors cafe.<br />
Modernity - Very good with so many restaurants that are so varied.<br />
Adrian Sassoon - Very good for exhibitors and brilliant for the visitors.<br />
Rupert Wace Ancient Art - The food in the exhibitors' lounge was worse<br />
than ever this year and totally ran out during set up. Also coffee etc etc<br />
was expensive in there<br />
Jonathan Cooper - The food was delicious at the Le Caprice and the<br />
restaurant was very well run.<br />
Patrick Bourne & Co - Wonderful dining experience at Le Caprice and<br />
Scott's. The exhibitors cafe could do with improving.<br />
Hemmerle - The Terrace was to often closed for private events<br />
Wartski- There should be a wider choice of sandwiches in the exhibitors'<br />
lounge and it was very difficult to find seating at the Mount Street Deli at<br />
peak times
THE WEBSITE<br />
96% of exhibitors uploaded works to their page on the Masterpiece<br />
website, a 19% increase on the previous year.<br />
59% of the exhibitors who answered this question directed<br />
clients to the Masterpiece website, a 4% decrease on the<br />
previous year.<br />
COMMENTS ON THE WEBSITE<br />
Berko Fine Paintings - We are very satisfied<br />
Adrian Sassoon - Very good indeed - tells one clearly what one is trying<br />
to find out<br />
Butchoff Antiques - There seems be quite a long delay in the time from<br />
uploading images to them showing on my dealer page<br />
Charles Ede - Again, I find it dull. Too brown/beige. Not visually<br />
stimulating. Also why doesn't it show images from this year rather than<br />
last year? It's not kept up to date enough.<br />
Jonathan Cooper - It is not easy to move artworks on ones own exhibitor<br />
page.<br />
Modernity - Over all very good - good looking and clear and easy to<br />
navigate.<br />
Robert Young - I think it could be more "alive" particularly in the<br />
immediate lead up and during the run of the show.<br />
Ronald Phillips - No new images or activity<br />
The Silver Fund - Would be nice to have an occasional photo showing<br />
the glamour and social aspect of the fair.
EVENTS<br />
97% OF EXHIBITORS WERE AWARE OR PARTIALLY AWARE<br />
OF EVENTS TAKING PLACE AT MASTERPIECE 2016<br />
(93% in 2015)<br />
35% INVITED CLIENTS TO EVENTS AND TALKS AT<br />
MASTERPIECE 2016<br />
(not asked in 2015)<br />
41
THE MASTERPIECE MAGAZINE<br />
56% OF EXHIBITORS DISTRIBUTED THE MAGAZINE TO<br />
CLIENTS BEFORE THE FAIR<br />
In 2015 68% distributed the magazine pre-fair<br />
COMMENTS<br />
Modernity, Anthony Outred, Tornabuoni, Senger Bamberg, Grima, Long-<br />
Sharp Gallery and Wallace Chan all made positive comments about the<br />
magazine.<br />
Some exhibitors commented that they would prefer the fair to publish a<br />
more traditional style catalogue (Finch & Co, Berko Fine Paintings, Wartski).<br />
A few said that they found the magazine un-exciting (Michele Beiny,<br />
Charles Ede, Adrian Sassoon). Peter Petrou, Paolo Antonacci, Patrick<br />
Mestdagh and Rolleston said that they would like to see more space dedicated<br />
to the exhibitors.<br />
Wallace Chan - Very interesting; well done!<br />
SECTION<br />
SPONSORS & PARTNERS<br />
Charles Ede - I find it visually uninteresting, which is bad as we are working<br />
in a highly developed visual world. It's confused and looks and feels<br />
old fashioned.<br />
Paolo Antonacci - Too much space for advertiments and to little for<br />
exhibitors
SPONSORS & PARTNERS<br />
96% OF EXHIBITORS SAID THEY ARE AWARE OR<br />
PARTIALLY AWARE OF THE FAIR'S SPONSORS & PARTNERS<br />
(90% in 2015)<br />
COMMENTS<br />
Adrian Sassoon - I have never seen a sale made thanks to the RBC<br />
private banking sponsor and their guests. I think that Coutts with its<br />
British customers across the UK would make a much better partner/<br />
sponsor - you bank with them and several of us dealers do also.<br />
Finch & Co - This is a good idea Could it be expanded to include<br />
European sponsors?<br />
Grima - RBC who exhibited our multicoloured necklace as a 5th plinth<br />
exhibit were incredibly enthusiastic and did a great job in promoting<br />
the piece.<br />
Modernity - I just wonder if it is good to have the Canadian bank as a<br />
main sponsor. Do they have a significant business in London and do<br />
they have many London clients that they can invite? Would it not be<br />
better with a bank like Coutts bank, or any other prime bank?<br />
PRESS<br />
COVERAGE
SERVICES<br />
STAND BUILDING<br />
97% of the exhibitors who answered this question were either satisfied<br />
or very satisfied with stand building at Masterpiece 2016.<br />
(a 3% increase on 2015)<br />
FLOORING<br />
88% of the exhibitors who answered this question were either satisfied or<br />
very satisfied with flooring at Masterpiece 2016.<br />
(a 4% decrease on 2015)<br />
ELECTRICS<br />
99% of the exhibitors who answered this question were either<br />
satisfied or very satisfied with stand electrics at Masterpiece<br />
2016. (a 2% increase on 2015)<br />
INTERNET<br />
89% of the exhibitors who answered this question were either satisfied or<br />
very satisfied with flooring at Masterpiece 2016.<br />
(a 2% increase on 2015)
CLOAKROOM<br />
89% of the exhibitors who answered this question were either satisfied or very<br />
satisfied with cloakroom at Masterpiece 2016.<br />
(a 2% increase on 2015)<br />
BATHROOM FACILITIES<br />
71% of the exhibitors who answered this question were either satisfied or very<br />
satisfied with the bathroom facilities at Masterpiece 2016.<br />
AIR CONDITIONING<br />
81% of the exhibitors who answered this question were either satisfied or very satisfied<br />
with the airconditioning at Masterpiece 2016.<br />
PRESS<br />
COVERAGE
PREFERRED WEEKDAY OPENING HOURS<br />
56% said they would prefer the fair to close at 20.00 rather<br />
than 21.00 on weekday evenings<br />
PREFERRED WEEKEND OPENING HOURS<br />
54% said they would prefer the fair to close at 19.00 rather<br />
than 18.00 on weekend evenings<br />
PRESS<br />
OPENING HOURS<br />
COVERAGE
VETTING<br />
A number of exhibitors made positive comments about vetting, noting<br />
that the process was good, rigorous, smoothly organised and serious.<br />
Negative comments focused on individual cases (Peter Petrou, Jonathan<br />
Cooper, Maison d'Art, Frank Partridge) and a few exhibitors expressed<br />
their opinion that exhibitors should not be permitted on the<br />
vetting committees (N&I Franklin, Finch & Co, Paolo Antonacci)<br />
Agnew's - Rigorous, which is good and appropriate.<br />
Finch & co - There are issues with exhibitors also acting as vetters<br />
N&I Franklin - We maintain that exhibitors should not vet as there could<br />
be a conflict of interest. Although we feel the vetting is efficent.<br />
Paolo Antonacci - I personally do not agree that other exhibiting dealer<br />
should that part of the vetting team<br />
Hemmerle - We do feel that our pieces should not be vetted as they are<br />
our own creations - That why haute joaillerie is exempted from vetting at<br />
TEFAF<br />
John Mitchell Fine Paintings - As a vetter in my speciality, I would like<br />
the non-exhibitors to perhaps manage their expectations about what is<br />
actually available in today's market rather than the 'golden years' of the<br />
1990s. Supply of quality and market fresh pieces worthy of Masterpiece is<br />
increasingly scarce and a more positive attitude - and in general to what<br />
the exhibition is striving to achieve- from the 'old hands' would be welcome.<br />
Robertaebasta - Everyone very professional.<br />
Koopman Rare Art - It was far more satisfactory this year. There were<br />
no real issues. The ability to discuss with the dealer before a decision is<br />
PRESS<br />
made works well<br />
OPENING HOURS<br />
COVERAGE
ADDITIONAL COMMENTS<br />
RECURRING THEMES EXHIBITORS COMMENTED ON ARE OUTLINED BELOW<br />
PATRON PROGRAMME/EVENING<br />
Some exhibitors expressed dissatisfaction with the format of the Patron & Curator Evening (Agnews, Galerie Chenel, John Mitchell Fine Paintings, Patrick<br />
Bourne, Paolo Antonacci)<br />
Agnew's - The Patron's evening was lacking atmosphere and poorly attended. It should be rolled into the VIP preview the following day.<br />
Galerie Chenel - We really think that it would be much better to have only one vernissage. Not one patrons/ One vernissage/ One first day openning. Everything<br />
on the same day like<br />
Hemmerle - We are very happy with the Patrons card - but feel that the early access to Patrons was not used and therefore should open at 11. would be much<br />
better and will give more result.<br />
John Mitchell Fine Paintings - We are more than satisfied with the fair in general and congratulate all involved in making it such a classy and elegant event, yet<br />
again. Our only reservation is that the 'curator' Tuesday evening preview does not appear to work in its present format. There aren't people to give the exhibition<br />
an atmosphere of buzz/ excitement that such a prestigious fair merits. In our opinion, if the Tuesday event is to continue, then it would be better to make<br />
it the official opening.<br />
Patrick Bourne & Co - Another comment that might be helpful is to let you know that our clients who attended the Patrons evening were a bit confused by the<br />
concept - because it is so exclusive, it doesn't have the buzz of a private view, and they all asked us whether it was particularly quiet due to BREXIT! We felt<br />
they might have enjoyed the Private View day more. Finally, the exhibitors cafe ought to offer much better catering facilities and options.<br />
VISITORS<br />
Stair Sainty - Overall a good experience but could do with attracting more serious paintings buyers, it runs the risk of being too much of a party destination<br />
and not a place for serious collectors.<br />
Paolo Antonacci - All very good. Lack of overseas visitors in particular Americans, South Americans and Gulf people, few foreigners in general . I was embarassed<br />
to understand that the 6 couples of clients that I gave the names for the Patrons Evening received the VIP card without nowing that it was me to<br />
invited them!! Two were even upset that I didn't sent them an invitation. The name of the exhibitor should be mentioned on the card!!<br />
Robert Zehil Gallery - We feel that the potential of visitors in 2016 was unsatisfactory. Most of them were not buyers.<br />
BREXIT<br />
Thomas Gibson Fine Art - I think this year was tricky due to Brexit - last year was good for us with strong sales to new clients - this year was tough! Not as<br />
many people and not as many good conversations. I would like to see the quality of picture dealers to improve<br />
Berko Fine Paintings - It is always a pleasure to participate at Masterpiece, even this year despite BREXIT.<br />
A FULL REPORT SHOWING ALL EXHIBITOR COMMENTS WILL BE CIRCULATED POST MEETING