Culture & Identity
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
Minds Matter Magazine Volume III Issue I
Table Of Contents<br />
Letter from the Theme Advisor ...Pg 4<br />
Cover Artist<br />
Statement<br />
<strong>Culture</strong> and identity are two facets of our human experience that are intrinsic to our being. How<br />
we communicate and engage reflect this essence. In this issue, we explore mental health when<br />
expressed through culture and/or identity.<br />
As a photographer, my medium is my camera and my canvas is life around me. Colours, their<br />
subtle details and even their absence create a variety of emotions and responses that I use in my<br />
photographs. Our cover features a simple image of a female profile. It consists of three distinct<br />
forms overlapping one another, to reflect our varied attitudes towards mental health. Within the<br />
image, some layers are seen in absolute contrast, to reflect our sometimes-contradictory views,<br />
while others are in grayscale, to reflect uncertainty. Black and white or gray imagery represent<br />
traditional or mainstream methods or expressions of understanding mental health. The brightly<br />
colored image reflects a creative and novel approach to representing mental health conditions<br />
that are often stereotyped with negative light.<br />
Adley Lobo<br />
Adley is a UTSC alumnus who gratuated with a Bachelor of Arts in History<br />
Letter from the Editor ...Pg 6<br />
‘Where do I belong?’ and other challenging questions ...Pg 8<br />
What does recovery mean? ...Pg 12<br />
When I was institutionalized ...Pg 16<br />
Stories of mental illness from the West Indies ...Pg 19<br />
What’s in the name of a diagnosis? ...Pg 22<br />
‘We never grew up with our culture’ ...Pg 25<br />
The language of my discontent ...Pg 28<br />
Recognizing education culture and its role in mental health ...Pg 31<br />
Ill and abroad ...Pg 35<br />
Masthead ...Pg 38<br />
Acknowlegdements ...Pg 39<br />
UTSC Navigator ...Pg 40<br />
Trigger warning:<br />
This term intends to help people navigate content that may be explicit or could provoke intense and possibly<br />
harmful emotional reactions. They primarily deal with topics that may cause someone to relive trauma, or<br />
experience painful emotions. These are specific terms related to words, stories, pictures or ideas that can<br />
commonly cause acute trauma.
Minds Matter Magazine Volume III Issue I <strong>Culture</strong> & <strong>Identity</strong><br />
Theme<br />
Advisor<br />
Over the past three years, I have had the pleasure of engaging with the impressive group of UTSC<br />
students and alumni who have dedicated themselves to the Minds Matter Magazine (MMM)<br />
project. I have been consistently impressed by the MMM team’s commitment to their mission<br />
of promoting awareness about mental health by focusing on student perspectives. In addition<br />
to putting together impressive collections of written and multi-media content, they have successfully<br />
helped to foster greater dialogue about mental health issues on the UTSC campus and<br />
beyond. It was my honour and pleasure to work with the MMM team as theme advisor on this<br />
issue.<br />
In 2014, the Lancet Commission on <strong>Culture</strong> and Health declared: “The systematic neglect<br />
of culture in health and health care is the single biggest barrier to the advancement of the highest<br />
standard of health worldwide.” This is a powerful statement, and one which is particularly<br />
relevant to issues of mental health, which are intimately tied to questions of identity, self, and<br />
personhood. As a clinical psychologist, researcher, and teacher with a focus on culture and mental<br />
health, I spend a lot of time thinking about how cultural context intersects with mental health<br />
and illness. Research across multiple disciplines clearly demonstrates the myriad ways in which<br />
cultural and identity factors are profoundly involved in the ways that people experience, think<br />
about, talk about, and seek to address psychological distress. People’s cultural backgrounds and<br />
context can inform what types of symptoms are most salient and distressing; when and with<br />
whom it is appropriate to seek care; the types of labels and metaphors used to describe mental<br />
illness; and the implications of stigma associated with labels and diagnoses. This is a challenging<br />
topic, which requires openness to diverse perspectives and nuanced examination of complex<br />
phenomena. Nevertheless, as suggested in the quote above, building a culturally-informed approach<br />
to mental health - which promotes an understanding of individuals in context - is crucial<br />
to advancing the field.<br />
Although I am well versed in the ways that academics approach this topic area, I have been<br />
pleasantly surprised and impressed by the varied ways in which the MMM journalists and artists<br />
have chosen to tackle this issue’s theme. This issue includes broad and diverse interpretations<br />
of notions of identity and culture. There are pieces that draw on expert opinion and research<br />
to help examine and clarify relevant constructs. There are also intimate, personal pieces about<br />
lived experience of mental illness, which help to foster a greater understanding of individuals<br />
in context. Topics range from an examination of complex identities in multicultural contexts, to<br />
varied perspectives about stigma and its impact, to the impact of colonization and reclamation<br />
of Indigenous culture. A recurring theme throughout the issue is the desire to promote greater<br />
understanding and openness, and to foster conversations about mental health that recognize<br />
identity and cultural factors as fundamentally important. In this way, the pieces included in this<br />
issue speak to larger, ongoing efforts in the field to emphasize the central place of culture and<br />
identity in mental health. I hope and expect that the content of this issue will spark questions,<br />
reflections, and discussion.<br />
Jessica Dere, Ph.D., C. Psych<br />
Assistant Professor, Teaching Stream<br />
Department Of Psychology<br />
University of Toronto Scarborough<br />
5
Minds Matter Magazine Volume III Issue I <strong>Culture</strong> & <strong>Identity</strong><br />
Letter from the<br />
Editor<br />
This year was one of incredible growth for Minds Matter Magazine. We grew to 41 members,<br />
including three new editors, two new peer facilitators (an editorial role we introduced this year)<br />
and eleven new writers. This was also the first year we used Story Circles, our in-house, stepby-step<br />
writing class, to create our articles. Our e-Issue has almost double the stories than ever<br />
before. In this time of great change, it is fitting that our theme is <strong>Culture</strong> and <strong>Identity</strong>.<br />
I was also delighted by the passion I saw at our Story Circles. I worried about loading more<br />
classes on already-burdened students. But I was met with consistent excitement, dedication<br />
and a hunger to learn about storytelling. It made teaching for the first time - an idea that once<br />
seemed impossible to me as someone with a severe anxiety disorder - an encouraging opportunity<br />
for my own growth, for which I am extremely grateful.<br />
As you read our e-Issue, I invite you to challenge your ideas of what mental health means<br />
in the context of culture and identity, as my own views were by the brilliant people that make up<br />
our masthead. With the guidance of the amazing Jessica Dere, who inspires me each time I see<br />
her, we have created an issue that I am proud and excited to share with you.<br />
Alexa Battler<br />
Alexa is a fourth year student specializing in journalism and minoring in political science<br />
more. Their interpretations of this theme are creative, vast and captivating.<br />
<strong>Culture</strong> has a massive influence on the way we view the world - including others and ourselves.<br />
Mental health and mental illness, and the ways we understand and respond to them, are<br />
fundamentally intertwined in the culture we observe. This, in turn, changes the way we view,<br />
unravel and treat ourselves.<br />
When one thinks of the intersection of culture and mental health, they may think of the<br />
ways certain cultures devalue or heavily stigmatize mental illness. I have seen it many times<br />
within mental health communities and academic settings. Even a quick Google search of ‘culture<br />
and mental health’ pulls up pages of sources criticizing poor or stigmatizing mental health care<br />
across the world. There is an underlying suggestion that a Western, often medical approach to<br />
mental health care is inherently correct.<br />
While a critical approach to mental health is of course important, a narrow approach can<br />
pigeonhole and stereotype understandings of mental health, instead of opening a productive<br />
dialogue that may unite us as we pursue wellness. As we approached the theme, I worried about<br />
reinforcing a condescending or judgmental approach from the Western-dominated perspectives<br />
I have so often seen.<br />
But our writers and artists explored this topic through an array of lenses. We explored<br />
mental health and culture through its relationship to technology, education, language, and many<br />
7
‘Where do I belong?’<br />
and other changing questions<br />
Shadi Laghai<br />
<strong>Identity</strong> grows more multifaced as multiculturalism develops.<br />
Image By Brian Lau<br />
Minds Matter Magazine Volume III Issue I <strong>Culture</strong> & <strong>Identity</strong><br />
When making sense of one’s identity, questions<br />
include, “Who are you?” “Where do<br />
you belong?,” and the related question, “How<br />
do you treat others?” Is it possible to answer<br />
these questions in ways that satisfy our human<br />
need to belong, without the cost of dividing<br />
humanity into problematic<br />
categories?<br />
<strong>Identity</strong> questions, and the identity crisis<br />
that comes with it, are new.<br />
Yoel Inbar, a social psychology professor<br />
at the University of Toronto (U of T), says<br />
that until recent years, people inherited their<br />
parents’ occupations and lived in more ethnically<br />
homogenous communities. He says people<br />
did not question who they were and what<br />
they were supposed to do, because their<br />
futures were predetermined.<br />
Now, as the global community diversifies,<br />
Inbar says “there’s a universe of choices<br />
that you might feel obliged to optimize that in<br />
the past you didn’t even have to worry about.”<br />
But the freedom of forming our own<br />
identity, suggests Inbar, can have a cost on<br />
our mental health. Anxiety and depression increase<br />
without a strong sense of who you are<br />
and what you should do.<br />
Children of immigrant and multicultural<br />
families can feel the effects of inconsistent<br />
identity most strongly.<br />
Kimia Sedig, a student at Western University,<br />
only started having identity crises in<br />
her teens. She says this is because she did not<br />
understand the complexity of the world as a<br />
child.<br />
“I was like, ‘I am Kimia, and that’s all<br />
there is to it,’” she says.<br />
It did not occur to her that her parents’<br />
Jewish and Iranian culture would have a significant<br />
impact on her identity.<br />
As adults, simple personality identities<br />
do not cut it anymore. When Shakib Mohsin,<br />
a student at U of T, is asked where he is from,<br />
he feels answering “Canada” is insufficient.<br />
To those asking, he is different, and they are<br />
looking for classification.<br />
“It felt like you had to be a part of something<br />
that you didn’t really identify with,”<br />
Mohsin says.<br />
Though Mohsin’s parents are from Bangladesh,<br />
his relatives would mock him for not<br />
speaking Bengali. He also did not identify with<br />
Bengali norms, like loving the taste of fish.<br />
Sedig describes a similar dilemma. She<br />
says it felt like she was “hanging in a limbo<br />
between two nicely boxed cultures” because<br />
she did not have a strong sense of belonging<br />
to either one.<br />
Sedig experienced subtle discrimination<br />
for not being a typical Canadian. At the<br />
same time, because she was not fluent in Farsi<br />
and did not know enough of her cultural<br />
history and its traditions, she felt she was not<br />
“enough” to wholly identify with her parents’<br />
Jewish and Iranian cultures.<br />
Not only did Mohsin and Sedig feel torn<br />
between their cultures, Mohsin says he likes<br />
learning and feeling a connection with many<br />
things, including cultures that he did not<br />
9
Minds Matter Magazine Volume III Issue I <strong>Culture</strong> & <strong>Identity</strong> Minds Matter Magazine Volume III Issue I <strong>Culture</strong> & <strong>Identity</strong><br />
inherit by genetics or circumstance.<br />
“The world isn’t just one thing so why<br />
should I be,” he says.<br />
Mohsin describes this fluid identity as a<br />
“wanderer.” This is similar to what Sedig says<br />
is part of growing up: you realize there are<br />
parts of you predetermined to have specific<br />
social connotations - like the way you look<br />
and where you come from that shape the way<br />
you experience the world.<br />
Having had a culturally mixed experience<br />
growing up, she realized that she had to<br />
manoeuvre through cultural aspects and realize<br />
what elements she really wanted to keep<br />
and which elements may not have been appropriate<br />
to incorporate into her life.<br />
Manoeuvring is different from wandering.<br />
Though flexible and evolving, manoeuvring<br />
implies structure and method. It means<br />
following, and building, a framework of expectations<br />
about the world and how you should<br />
be.<br />
According to the identity development<br />
model from the book Counselling American<br />
Minorities, people have a fulfilled identity<br />
when they can objectively view cultural values,<br />
and have the internal knowledge and<br />
skills to navigate their personal freedom.<br />
This internal value system, or framework,<br />
allows us to navigate the world and relates<br />
to social identities.<br />
Humans need the structure and connection<br />
that group identity gives.<br />
“The stronger your group, the happier<br />
you will be, all else (being) equal,” Inbar says.<br />
He says a superseding group identity<br />
that unites diverse people “should be a group<br />
that really has some punch to it in terms of<br />
a strong goal, a strong sense of group identity,<br />
a strong set of group norms that we care<br />
about.”<br />
Sedig says she has found this in the<br />
Bahá’í Faith, a world religion founded by<br />
Bahá’u’lláh. Its basic principles and core values<br />
include the oneness of humankind and<br />
universal education. Its activities, the aim<br />
of which is the social transformation of the<br />
world, are global, and applied locally through<br />
a systematic learning culture. It promotes the<br />
belief that we are of one human body and<br />
that diversity is to be celebrated.<br />
By fitting cultural aspects of her life<br />
within the encompassing framework of her<br />
primary identity, Sedig says she has found a<br />
degree of peace.<br />
“I don’t feel like I constantly need to be<br />
defining myself with these secondary identities<br />
and, as such, I don’t feel like a fraud laying<br />
claim to any of them,” she says. The elements<br />
that make up who she is -like her Persian,<br />
Jewish, and Canadian cultures- are still being<br />
put together, but the framework of universal<br />
humanity makes it whole.<br />
Whatever your primary identity, the<br />
qualities and aspirations that unite us need to<br />
be prioritized over cultural differences. Socially<br />
constructed categorizations can be messy<br />
and incompatible and there is more to life<br />
than can be defined by the labels that will<br />
always fall short of fully encompassing who<br />
we are.<br />
“We’re not titles, we’re not labels.<br />
We’re people. We’re human beings,” says<br />
Mohsin.<br />
That is the heart of the human framework,<br />
our primary identity.<br />
10<br />
11
What does recovery mean?<br />
Ioana Arbone<br />
Minds Matter Magazine Volume III Issue I <strong>Culture</strong> & <strong>Identity</strong><br />
One of the most popular ideas in mental<br />
health is something that we can hardly define<br />
- recovery.<br />
Our ideas of recovery seem to constantly<br />
change. Recovery is now part of international<br />
and Canadian policy on mental<br />
health. Yet it is difficult to understand what<br />
recovery is. The idea varies across mental<br />
illnesses, addictions and treatment methods.<br />
Across the world, there are different<br />
answers to these questions: What does it<br />
mean to recover from mental illness or addiction?<br />
How can people recover from mental<br />
illness or addiction? And even, can people<br />
recover from mental illness or addiction?<br />
Studies in the 1970s showed that<br />
most individuals diagnosed with schizophrenia<br />
go on to live meaningful and productive<br />
lives. This idea is at the core of the recovery<br />
movement. One of the achievements of the<br />
recovery movement is the integration of people<br />
with lived experience as part of the overall<br />
mental health and addiction system, and<br />
training opportunities for mental health and<br />
addiction staff to learn about recovery. Some<br />
of the movement’s values are less murky. In<br />
the recovery movement, “recovery” does not<br />
mean symptoms or struggles disappear forever.<br />
It means personal or psychological recovery<br />
- learning to lead a meaningful life, while<br />
still living with mental illness and its symptoms.<br />
Understanding revovery across cultures is a goal driving a global movement.<br />
Image By Adley Lobo<br />
The pursuit of definitive answers to<br />
these questions have given rise to the recovery<br />
movement. The recovery movement is a<br />
social movement working to change understanding<br />
of mental illness across the world,<br />
according to Larry Davidson, a Yale University<br />
professor and author of Roots of the Recovery<br />
Movement.<br />
It is not clear specifically how or where<br />
the recovery movement developed, but Davidson<br />
says that the recovery model is very<br />
Western, and focuses on the individual. He<br />
says we need to be mindful of other cultures<br />
who are focused more on the community<br />
than the individual.<br />
“One of the shortcomings of the concept<br />
of recovery and the recovery movement<br />
is that it’s hazy,” says Sean Kidd, a clinical<br />
psychologist with the Centre for Addiction<br />
and Mental Health.<br />
In this, recovery includes focusing on<br />
strengths, while acknowledging weaknesses.<br />
It encourages people to take calculated risks<br />
towards leading a meaningful life.<br />
(Wellbeing, Recovery and Mental Health,<br />
Chapter 9, page 102)<br />
Recovery lies in decreasing and preventing<br />
symptoms or unwanted behavior,<br />
while increasing and promoting wellbeing<br />
and strengths. Studies have supported the<br />
benefit of focusing on strengths instead of<br />
avoiding things that trigger symptoms - including<br />
in mental health services.<br />
13
Minds Matter Magazine Volume III Issue I <strong>Culture</strong> & <strong>Identity</strong> Minds Matter Magazine Volume III Issue I <strong>Culture</strong> & <strong>Identity</strong><br />
Davidson says common mental health<br />
stigma, like expectations of instability,<br />
unpredictability and dangerousness,<br />
decrease the opportunities for those with<br />
mental illness to lead a meaningful life.<br />
Mike Slade, a professor at the University<br />
of Nottingham, says there is a gap between<br />
policy and reality for recovery. He says<br />
individuals with mental illness, even in mental<br />
health settings, are still not viewed as full<br />
citizens. He says they are not seen as “one<br />
of us” by those without mental illness. But<br />
disability rights-advocate Patricia Deegan<br />
believes recovery should not mean sacrificing<br />
identity.<br />
When she was 18 years old, a hospital<br />
psychiatrist told Deegan, who lives with<br />
chronic schizophrenia, “If you take medications<br />
for the rest of your life and avoid stress,<br />
then maybe you can cope.“ To her, recovery<br />
did not mean becoming “normal.” Deegan<br />
pursued a doctoral degree and became one<br />
of the leading figures of the recovery movement.<br />
Kidd explains that this stigma also<br />
exists at a systemic level. He says legal and<br />
bureaucratic policies reinforce stigmatizing<br />
ideas, like dangerousness or criminality.<br />
“When the police are called to bring<br />
someone to the hospital, no crime is committed,<br />
nonetheless, there is a documentation<br />
- a police file,” he said.<br />
Systematic issues also exist within<br />
treatment itself, says Kidd. He says that not<br />
every doctor approaches a patient with the<br />
idea that recovery is possible.<br />
“(This message runs) counter to the<br />
evidence,” he says.<br />
He highlighted schizophrenia as a field<br />
where doctors may approach a patient assuming<br />
they will not be able to recover. Yet,<br />
he says, most people with schizophrenia are<br />
able to make major progress in their recovery.<br />
Many are able to have a family, job, or<br />
volunteer position, whether they still hear<br />
voices or not.<br />
Identifying and addressing this approach<br />
is another goal of the recovery movement.<br />
“We have to assume (that all patients)<br />
are probably one of the larger group of people<br />
that has some potential (to recover),” he<br />
says.<br />
Bill White, an emeritus senior researcher<br />
consultant, focuses on recovery<br />
from addiction and substance use.<br />
“(The recovery movement) can inject<br />
the experiential knowledge of more than<br />
23,000 Americans in long-term recovery into<br />
research, clinical, and policy discussions,”<br />
White says. “If there is an untold story within<br />
the addictions arena at public, policy, and<br />
clinical levels, it is the story of long-term<br />
recovery.”<br />
Though experts agreed that there<br />
is great progress made, they all expressed<br />
that is a long way to go - particularly when it<br />
comes to stigma.<br />
Both Kidd and Slade said one of the<br />
best ways to combat stigma is through<br />
contact with those with mental illness. Especially<br />
when the experience defies stereotypes.<br />
Slade also encouraged people<br />
to engage in “one conversation at a time.”<br />
In ther words, every conversation we have<br />
about mental health is important and reducing<br />
stigma is not something that can change<br />
overnight.<br />
Davidson and White emphasized the<br />
importance of community supports and positive<br />
educational campaigns, without misleading<br />
negative portrayals of individuals with<br />
mental illness.<br />
Hope is one of the main messages of<br />
the recovery movement and that this is what,<br />
at least in part, made the movement popular.<br />
Yet, it is still not clear how to best implement<br />
and think about recovery.<br />
14<br />
15
When I was institutionalized<br />
Jessica Barrera<br />
I left with a new understanding of mental care, and myself.<br />
HYPERLINK TRIGGER WARNING: sexual abuse, violence, physical and verbal<br />
abuse<br />
Image By Clark McRorie<br />
Minds Matter Magazine Volume III Issue I <strong>Culture</strong> & <strong>Identity</strong><br />
I step out of a hot shower and into warm,<br />
comfortable clothes. I quietly walk down the<br />
hallway, into a room where the news plays<br />
on TV. I walk to the bookshelf and choose A<br />
Million Little Pieces by James Frey from rows<br />
of novels. I take the book to my room and<br />
quietly read. I am about four pages in when<br />
I hear a knock on my door. My nurse has arrived<br />
to bring me my medication.<br />
Years of controversial treatments, mystery<br />
induced fear, and media misrepresentations<br />
have created a cultural perception in<br />
Western society that psychiatric institutions<br />
are full of padded cells, arm restraints and<br />
forced medication injections. There is also a<br />
widely held perception of psychiatric inpatients<br />
being dangerous and violent.<br />
My experience being institutionalized<br />
was vastly different. In late April 2017, I was<br />
admitted to the Centre for Addiction and<br />
Mental Health (CAMH), in downtown Toronto<br />
to be treated for a bipolar manic episode.<br />
What was a scary situation at first became a<br />
positive experience.<br />
In Western media and popular cultural<br />
perception, psychiatric institutions have been<br />
portrayed as frightening, confining buildings<br />
only for those who are severely ill or dangerous.<br />
The location where I stayed first opened<br />
as a provincially-run mental health facility in<br />
1850. It was called the Provincial Lunatic Asylum.<br />
In 1998, CAMH first formed as part of<br />
rovince-wide efforts to redesign healthcare.<br />
One of their four key challenges to address<br />
was stigma.<br />
Jennifer Bazar, a curator at Humber<br />
College’s Lakeshore Grounds Interpretive<br />
Centre, says the average Canadian today still<br />
“assumes the worst” when they think about<br />
psychiatric institutions. She says that psychiatric<br />
institutions evoke fear of the unknown<br />
and that, similar to people fascinated with<br />
exploring abandoned buildings, there is a<br />
sense of mystery behind the closed doors of<br />
institutions.<br />
“A lack of understanding perpetuates<br />
assumptions,” Bazar says. “Often our minds<br />
go to the most radical assumptions.” Ideas<br />
of institutionalization have also been widely<br />
popularized by classic films like Silence of the<br />
Lambs and One Flew over the Cuckoo’s Nest.<br />
Recent adaptations include those in American<br />
Horror Story and Pretty Little Liars.<br />
Clark McRorie, a film student at Ryerson<br />
University, says these shows and movies<br />
traditionally portray psychiatric wards in a<br />
negative light. He argues they often include<br />
“some form of torture.”<br />
“They use this setting for a horror story<br />
vibe, where you see people getting electric<br />
shock therapy or drowned in ice water, or<br />
being forced to take medication,” he says.<br />
This narrative can lead people to fear<br />
psychiatric institutions. But the week I spent<br />
at CAMH was one of the most transformative,<br />
challenging and positive experiences I<br />
have ever had.<br />
CAMH is one of the leading teaching<br />
and research institutes for mental health in<br />
the world. The morning after I was admitted,<br />
a physician gave me a physical examination<br />
- an important reminder that healing is both<br />
mental and physical. There were scheduled<br />
17
18<br />
Minds Matter Magazine Volume III Issue I <strong>Culture</strong> & <strong>Identity</strong><br />
activities throughout weekdays, like art and<br />
yoga classes, smoothie-making workshops,<br />
access to the fitness center and trips to the<br />
gym across the street to play basketball.<br />
I spent my stay writing poetry, relaxing,<br />
making friends, but most importantly, I<br />
spent time being sick.<br />
Inpatient care felt like the first time I<br />
was allowed to be mentally ill, and for that, I<br />
was grateful. For years leading up to my stay,<br />
I had been denying or trying to justify the<br />
emotions I felt, attempting to appear stable<br />
for my friends and family. The way people<br />
responded to my feelings in inpatient care<br />
was different than anything I had experienced<br />
before.<br />
One patient saw me upset and said<br />
only, “I’m sorry you’re crying Jessica.” That<br />
was all. There was no questioning, no embarrassment<br />
and no shame - only understanding.<br />
That compassion was one of the most<br />
helpful aspects of my stay. I was surrounded<br />
by people going through similar things, and<br />
had a support team of nurses, medical doctors,<br />
dietitians, and psychiatrists who were<br />
all there to help us.<br />
Not all institutionalization experiences<br />
are like mine. Around the world, some psychiatric<br />
institutions are as horrific as some<br />
films portray them. In recent years, institutions<br />
in (hyperlink trigger warning) Shanghai<br />
and Guatemala had been found to be using<br />
the same forced injections and physical<br />
restraints seen in popular films. This type<br />
of abuse has been found even in California,<br />
where a federal review in 2015 found rampant<br />
abuse in five mental health institutions.<br />
But the more that we discuss and normalize<br />
conversations about institutionalization,<br />
the more we normalize our perceptions<br />
of what institutionalization should be. This<br />
leads to widespread empowerment to challenge<br />
abuse as something inherently wrong<br />
within the mental health care system.<br />
Curiosity and communication are<br />
important in understanding topics like institutionalization.<br />
It’s easy to be afraid of<br />
the unknown and form opinions based on<br />
movies and TV shows. Bazar points out the<br />
importance of hearing all sides of the story,<br />
recognizing the history and realizing that we<br />
must “accept that (the conversation) is<br />
uncomfortable.”<br />
Conversations about mental health<br />
must be open. We must understand that<br />
while some are afraid, there are distinct reasons<br />
behind their fear - in this case, decades<br />
of misconception and misrepresentation.<br />
McRorie said that in recent years,<br />
some media representation has shifted. The<br />
dehumanizing of people with mental illnesses<br />
is not seen as much, and characters<br />
are portrayed as less scary and dangerous,<br />
but more as real people. This can be seen<br />
in movies like Silver Linings Playbook and A<br />
Beautiful Mind, where people with mental<br />
illnesses are portrayed in a more realistic<br />
way.<br />
“We are talking more, and willing to<br />
talk more. I think we just have miles to go,”<br />
says Bazar.<br />
Stories of mental illness<br />
from the West Indies<br />
Victoria Gibson Billings<br />
Exploring the intersection of cultural stigma and modern mental health through<br />
stories.<br />
Image By Adley Lobo
Minds Matter Magazine Volume III Issue I <strong>Culture</strong> & <strong>Identity</strong> Minds Matter Magazine Volume III Issue I <strong>Culture</strong> & <strong>Identity</strong><br />
Traditional culture in the West Indies often<br />
does not include conversations about mental<br />
illness. For some, an overwhelming cultural<br />
expectation to be easygoing leaves little<br />
room for illnesses like depression or anxiety.<br />
A 2012 study of inpatients in West<br />
Indian hospitals found that 12 per cent of<br />
inpatients needed psychiatric care, but that<br />
only 1.5 per cent of hospital patients were<br />
ever referred. The study found that one of<br />
the primary reasons for the low rates were<br />
doctors worrying that their patients would<br />
be offended or stigmatized by a referral.<br />
Once people leave the West Indies, it<br />
may be harder to grasp the concepts of mental<br />
health without associating it with cultural<br />
stigma.<br />
The following are a collection of<br />
quotes from people still living in the Caribbean,<br />
as well as first and second generation<br />
Canadians with East Indian roots. All of those<br />
interviewed struggle with some degree of<br />
mental illness.<br />
“It’s possible that the mental health services<br />
for people in the (millennial) age group are<br />
good in terms of care. Down here, a lot of<br />
people with mental health problems tend to<br />
be people a lot older on the streets who are<br />
there because they went insane from drug<br />
abuse.”<br />
-16 year old, living in St. Vincent<br />
“I think people down here are oblivious to<br />
the fact that people down here may be mentally<br />
unstable, because you don’t see a lot of<br />
cases.”<br />
-18 year old, living in St. Vincent<br />
20<br />
“Crazy home pick me up.”<br />
-18-year-old resident of mental health<br />
facility, living in St. Vincent<br />
“I needed support. I should be coping better,<br />
but I didn’t ask for support.”<br />
-45 year old, first generation Canadian<br />
“Vow to not keep things from my parents,<br />
but do it factually.”<br />
-45 year old, first generation Canadian<br />
“I’m pregnant now, and I know that I will<br />
raise my child in a household where it is<br />
okay to talk to a psychiatrist, it doesn’t mean<br />
you’ve gone crazy.”<br />
-31 year old, second generation Canadian<br />
“Didn’t want to seem weak, like I couldn’t<br />
manage my kids.”<br />
-28 year old, first generation Canadian<br />
“Being on medication was top secret. I took a<br />
leave from work and did not tell my parents<br />
until two months in. At first, my Mum was<br />
angry that I didn’t inform her, but I think she<br />
started to understand”<br />
-45 year old, first generation Canadian<br />
“Never used the words depression or anxiety,<br />
because then it would seem too real.”<br />
-19 year old, second generation Canadian<br />
“It’s not episodic, I will struggle with this for<br />
the rest of my life. It’s not over, and I think<br />
they would like for it to just be over.”<br />
-45 year old, first generation Canadian<br />
“They have a better time accepting it when it<br />
is associated with something else, like I was<br />
starting my first year of university so it makes<br />
sense for me to be anxious. They would<br />
never acknowledge that I have a generalized<br />
anxiety disorder, something doctors<br />
diagnosed me with almost a year later.”<br />
-22 year old, first generation Canadian<br />
“Not warm and fuzzy like the parents of<br />
other people I knew.”<br />
-26 year old, second generation Canadian<br />
“I softened the blow with telling my parents<br />
by giving them articles. This had a dual<br />
purpose - of showing them that other<br />
people struggle like I do, and it’s not<br />
something to be ashamed of. Mum Googled,<br />
and gave them to my dad to read. The issue<br />
now was their interpretation of the articles.”<br />
-45 year old, first generation Canadian<br />
“I tell my kids now they can ask for anything,<br />
and tell me anything.”<br />
-45 year old, first generation Canadian<br />
“Being on top of my own daughter’s mental<br />
health. I’ve taken her to every single person<br />
under the sun. I don’t want her to spend 10<br />
years of not knowing. She can openly talk<br />
about her feelings.”<br />
-45 year old, first generation Canadian<br />
“I never thought the way I was feeling was<br />
a real thing. I couldn’t tie it to one particular<br />
instance in my life, and I think that’s why<br />
my parents had a hard time grasping it. My<br />
depression just came on hard and fast, and I<br />
couldn’t say why.”<br />
-31 year old, second generation Canadian<br />
“I also didn’t need to be handled with child<br />
gloves, I am still a functioning adult. Just<br />
functioning with bipolar disorder. I think it<br />
was hard for my family to group the two<br />
together.”<br />
-45 year old, first generation Canadian<br />
“Lack of education surrounding mental<br />
illness is a huge factor. I don’t blame my<br />
parents for not understanding my depression<br />
because I don’t think my mother even faced<br />
her own depression.”<br />
-28 year old, first generation Canadian<br />
21
What’s in the name<br />
of a diagnosis?<br />
Gina Nicoll<br />
Would a diagnosis by another name carry the same ideas?<br />
Image By Phoebe Maharaj<br />
Minds Matter Magazine Volume III Issue I <strong>Culture</strong> & <strong>Identity</strong><br />
Imagine you are meeting Hiromi, a 22-yearold<br />
Japanese man. He has integration disorder,<br />
which can affect his thoughts and perceptions.<br />
Sometimes, what he experiences does<br />
not reflect reality. But with the right help, he<br />
can recover and lead a normal life.<br />
What is your first impression of Hiromi? Would<br />
you be open to being friends with him?<br />
Would your view of him change if you knew<br />
he actually had schizophrenia?<br />
This thought experiment is the reality<br />
in Japan. In 2002, the Japanese medical system<br />
changed Seishin-Bunretsu-Byo - which<br />
translates to “mind-split disease” - to Togo-Shitcho-Sho<br />
or integration disorder. Mindsplit<br />
disease is the same diagnosis as schizophrenia,<br />
which comes from the Greek words<br />
for “split” and “mind.”<br />
Along with the name change, Japanese<br />
psychiatrists created new associations for integration<br />
disorder. It is no longer a debilitating<br />
and hopeless disease leading to decline and<br />
discrimination. Under a vulnerability-stress<br />
model, they rebranded it as a disorder where<br />
recovery is possible with the right medication<br />
and support.<br />
If you hear “schizophrenia” and think<br />
of threat and aggression, you are not alone.<br />
A 2001 study of Quebecois individuals found<br />
that 54 per cent of respondents considered<br />
people with schizophrenia dangerous and violent.<br />
However, people with schizophrenia<br />
are 14 times more likely to be victims of violence<br />
than perpetrators of it. Reports also<br />
indicate that 99.97 per cent of people with<br />
schizophrenia are not convicted of serious<br />
violence in a year.<br />
Our public perceptions of schizophrenia<br />
are not just wrong; they are actively<br />
harmful. A 2014 study examined how changing<br />
the name of schizophrenia could change<br />
perception. The study found that treatment<br />
outcomes for schizophrenia are poorer in<br />
the Western world - where only one in three<br />
people with schizophrenia recover - than in<br />
Nairobi, Kenya, where one in two people recover.<br />
One of the main reasons for this is said<br />
to be the stigma associated with schizophrenia<br />
in the Western world.<br />
In a different survey, two-thirds of<br />
people with schizophrenia did not pursue<br />
treatment because of the anticipated stigma.<br />
Another survey cited in the study found that<br />
the majority of Western people with schizophrenia<br />
view the discrimination that comes<br />
from having schizophrenia more negatively<br />
than the symptoms of the disorder itself.<br />
In Japan, before the name of the diagnosis<br />
changed, there were similar associations<br />
between schizophrenia, unpredictability,<br />
and violence. Many doctors would not<br />
inform people of their diagnosis for fear of<br />
inflicting stigma and discrimination, which<br />
would affect their treatment.<br />
Since the name change, the diagnosis<br />
is viewed as less stigmatizing. Within two<br />
years, 33 per cent more people were informed<br />
of their diagnosis, and 86 per cent of<br />
psychiatrists surveyed said the change made<br />
it easier to tell family and friends about the<br />
diagnosis and helped introduce education<br />
23
Minds Matter Magazine Volume III Issue I <strong>Culture</strong> & <strong>Identity</strong><br />
and treatment. The new name and concept<br />
have also reduced associations with violence<br />
and increased the number of people who<br />
ould have a relationship with someone with<br />
schizophrenia.<br />
them that?<br />
We never grew up<br />
with our culture<br />
Nicole Royle<br />
But what about the West? Could we<br />
change the name and understanding of<br />
schizophrenia as Japan did? Initial studies<br />
with people from the United Kingdom and<br />
Ireland show that it could have positive<br />
effects. The name “integration disorder”<br />
decreases the discriminatory attitudes toward<br />
someone who has recovered from the<br />
acute phase of illness. With the new name,<br />
participants were more likely to say they<br />
would employ, work with, rent to, or become<br />
friends with the person.<br />
A name change would not be an automatic<br />
win. It would have to accompany correct<br />
information about integration disorder,<br />
instead of perpetuating the same stereotypes<br />
of danger and violence that come with<br />
schizophrenia.<br />
Some critics of a prospective name<br />
change in the West say that we need to<br />
address the root cause of the issue, rather<br />
than a mere symptom. It would not change<br />
the larger stigma against mental illness in<br />
our society. But it would be an opportunity<br />
to correct the concept of the disorder, like<br />
Japan did. As other researchers say, a name<br />
change is not just a new label but “an entirely<br />
different way of thinking about people<br />
with schizophrenia.”<br />
When we have miscast them as violent<br />
criminals, despite evidence to the contrary,<br />
and impeded their recovery, don’t we owe<br />
24<br />
One person’s separation and journey to reconnect with their Indigenous roots.<br />
TRIGGER WARNING: OVERDOSE, DRUGS, DEATH, RESIDENTIAL SCHOOLS<br />
Image By Adley Lobo
Minds Matter Magazine Volume III Issue I <strong>Culture</strong> & <strong>Identity</strong> Minds Matter Magazine Volume III Issue I <strong>Culture</strong> & <strong>Identity</strong><br />
Although born in the Northwest Territories<br />
rich in Inuit culture, Nanook (Nook) Fareal<br />
was raised in a predominantly white town in<br />
Nova Scotia. At 23, Fareal is finding herself<br />
piecing together a sense of identity.<br />
Fareal was born from an Inuit mother<br />
and white father. Her parents separated<br />
when she was three and her father moved<br />
her and her brother across Canada, consequently<br />
away from their Inuit culture.<br />
“We never grew up with our culture,<br />
and I always felt like I was white,” Fareal said.<br />
“I grew up around all white people. I was a<br />
white person up until a few years ago.”<br />
Fareal felt like there was something<br />
missing. She struggled for a long time with<br />
mental illness and drug addiction, not knowing<br />
who she was scared her and left her<br />
uncomfortable with life. When she moved to<br />
Toronto in her twenties, she had an opportunity<br />
to learn.<br />
She looked into her Inuit culture and<br />
became invested in the LGBTQ community–<br />
where she connected to others struggling<br />
with their own identity. At the same time, a<br />
Native friend began learning about his family’s<br />
history and culture. His interest was<br />
contagious and Fareal started joining him at<br />
Native community centres and events.<br />
He died of a drug overdose before he<br />
could teach Fareal everything he knew about<br />
their shared culture, so she continued to pursue<br />
her identity on her own. It was difficult<br />
for her, but his spirit remained an inspiration<br />
to move forward.<br />
“There was a reason why he was<br />
searching for his culture more,” said Fareal.<br />
“So I also started pushing myself forward and<br />
getting more into it.”<br />
The more she learned, the worse she<br />
felt for her people, what they have been<br />
through and what those still living in Northern<br />
Canada continue to face every day. Fareal<br />
decided to help.<br />
Last year during the holiday season<br />
Fareal started the Feeding Canada project,<br />
which sends canned food and care packages<br />
to Northern Indigenous communities. With<br />
the help of friends, Fareal set up a GoFund-<br />
Me page with images of the shockingly high<br />
food prices in Northern Canada.<br />
Brenda Megannety, a retired yoga<br />
instructor, is among those who have helped<br />
with the Feeding Canada project. Megannety<br />
was introduced to Fareal through mutual<br />
friends and, like so many others, was moved<br />
by her spirit and passion.<br />
“I met her a few times and I just really<br />
liked her. I liked her energy and her drive,”<br />
Meganetty said.<br />
After reaching out to Fareal last year<br />
during the first shipment of goods to the<br />
North, Megannety wanted to be more involved.<br />
Megannety became an asset to the<br />
project and continues to be involved.<br />
“I guess it was when I looked and saw<br />
the prices up in Nunavut. It’s insane. That really<br />
just got me going,” Megannety said. “And<br />
I thought, there is so much going on in the<br />
world and so much money we can give. Why<br />
not just give them home? Why not give our<br />
own country?”<br />
When she was 22, Fareal reached out<br />
to her mother for the first time since the<br />
divorce. She learned her mother had been<br />
placed in a residential school as a young girl.<br />
This resonated with Fareal; suddenly she was<br />
personally involved and the horrific past of<br />
her people became too real.<br />
“Imagine all the abuse they went<br />
through. It just hit me really hard,” Fareal<br />
said, looking away as she recounted the time<br />
she learned about her mother’s past. “I felt<br />
so hopeless. I decided to start the project, I<br />
needed to help in some way.”<br />
After Feeding Canada’s first year, Fareal<br />
managed to send boxes to six different<br />
families and eight care packages to a food<br />
bank in Nunavut– with the highest food<br />
prices in Canada.<br />
Fareal has decided to expand the campaign<br />
in the next years. Wanting to involve<br />
more of herself and her own identity into her<br />
project, Fareal is beginning to plan an LGBTQ<br />
fashion show to fundraise for her cause. She<br />
wants to showcase LGBTQ designers from<br />
Canada and the U.S. and incorporate Native<br />
fashion designers as well.<br />
All of Feeding Canada’s donations go<br />
into the contents of the care packages and<br />
shipping costs. Fareal wants to do more to<br />
help entire communities and increase her<br />
success from six families.<br />
“I was thinking of using the money to<br />
go up there and give it to the hunters,” Fareal<br />
said thinking of the possibilities. “And then<br />
they’ll bring back the food and then they can<br />
feed their whole community.”<br />
The fundraising and project have<br />
helped Fareal learn about her culture and<br />
herself. Learning more about Native history<br />
has led Fareal to see what Indigenous people<br />
are capable of surviving– what she is capable<br />
of and what she can survive.<br />
“I feel like I’ve come a long way in the<br />
last couple years with finding my identity,”<br />
Fareal said smiling to herself. “Although, I<br />
know it’s a long process.”<br />
26<br />
27
Minds Matter Magazine Volume III Issue I <strong>Culture</strong> & <strong>Identity</strong><br />
In the language<br />
of my discontent<br />
Samantha Lauby<br />
Psychiatric Language must coexist with the ways we talk about our mental<br />
health experiences.<br />
TRIGGER WARNING: SUICIDE ATTEMPT, DEATH<br />
Image By Phoebe Maharaj<br />
Coming out of the rabbit hole is not easy.<br />
It involves motivation, patience, a touch of<br />
creativity and one rule: don’t let the Queen<br />
of Hearts take your head.<br />
I tell my experiences with mental<br />
health as metaphors because experiences<br />
are beyond the limits of our language. I identify<br />
with Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland<br />
because the timing of the recent adaptation<br />
coincided with a major transition in my<br />
life. I was leaving my hometown to pursue<br />
post-secondary education. I was going to a<br />
new environment—one that would provide<br />
the structure to let me thrive.<br />
I did not want to go.<br />
I had a small network of therapists,<br />
psychiatrists and medical doctors I knew I<br />
would lose if I moved away. Steeped in the<br />
language of psychiatry, I was convinced that<br />
my death would be under my control - a<br />
suicide attempt that I couldn’t survive. The<br />
aura of hopelessness that the language<br />
provided made recovery seem impossible<br />
and distress inescapable. I did not think I<br />
would live beyond my twenty-fifth birthday.<br />
Almost two years after entering University,<br />
I was in recovery. Over my recovery, I<br />
have adopted another metaphor: The Matrix.<br />
I have chosen to take the red pill by reducing<br />
psychotropic medications to a minimum and<br />
shedding the language of psychiatry. This is<br />
not an easy transition, but I am already reaping<br />
the rewards.<br />
With my own language, I can advocate<br />
for my needs and learn to live with quirks<br />
that people called a “disorder.” It is organized<br />
chaos, thank you very much.<br />
Along this 13-year journey, I was plastered<br />
with labels like “generalized anxiety d<br />
isorder,” “depression with psychotic features,”<br />
“borderline personality disorder,”<br />
and, most recently, “schizoaffective disorder.”<br />
Though I cannot think of myself as having<br />
these labels today, they will stick with me for<br />
the rest of my life, shrouding the beauty of<br />
my inner world.<br />
I have experienced more stigma in<br />
recovery than while I was suffering under<br />
these labels. If I express any distress, people<br />
- especially medical professionals - start to<br />
question my recovery. While it is optional to<br />
talk to acquaintances about my stresses, it is<br />
required to talk, and be judged by, a professional<br />
stranger. This stigma is amplified when<br />
they know I am on a medication diet.<br />
The language of psychiatry spreads<br />
with the biomedical model - the view that<br />
mental health conditions are caused by<br />
abnormalities in the brain. I fear that this<br />
stigma I experience will become more widespread.<br />
It does not matter if the finger of<br />
blame is pointed at my actions, my mind,<br />
or my brain - if the language that surrounds<br />
these labels (e.g., “deficit,” “faulty wiring,”<br />
“inflexible”) does not change, we all suffer.<br />
Katie Kilroy-Marac, an anthropology<br />
professor at University of Toronto Scarborough,<br />
also fears that a strict biomedical approach<br />
can ignore our experiences and how<br />
we can grow from them.<br />
But Kilroy-Marac says this language<br />
may help some narrate their experiences.<br />
29
Minds Matter Magazine Volume III Issue I <strong>Culture</strong> & <strong>Identity</strong><br />
“For people dealing with mental health<br />
issues, a diagnosis... can be a key step in feeling<br />
better,” Kilroy-Marac said.<br />
<strong>Culture</strong> has sway on the language surrounding<br />
psychiatric labels. The way we think<br />
about the brain may reflect how we cope<br />
with imperfections within it.<br />
society, behaviour, and health, I now know<br />
what to do if I wander too far or get too<br />
distressed. I simply need to wake up and<br />
connect with the outside environment.<br />
Recognizing education culture<br />
and its role in mental health.<br />
Elanna Clayton<br />
Kilroy-Marac noted that if we thought<br />
of the brain as a garden, we may be more<br />
likely to think about self-care and healing<br />
than our current thinking of the brain as a<br />
computer.<br />
“With the computer metaphor, we<br />
have ideas about switches, overloads, wiring,<br />
and fixes,” she said.<br />
I have faith that psychiatry can co-exist<br />
with other languages and explanations<br />
of mental health. The key term, of course,<br />
is co-exist. If psychiatry can remember that<br />
they are the servants of the people in distress,<br />
and listen to them without the biomedical<br />
filter, then I have hope that incidences<br />
of recovery will outpace the number of<br />
people diagnosed with mental health conditions.<br />
With the introduction and acceptance<br />
of mindfulness (a philosophy associated with<br />
Asian-area religions) as a therapy, psychiatrists<br />
are moving in this direction.<br />
Unlike the 2010 movie adaptation,<br />
Lewis Carroll’s original Alice’s Adventures in<br />
Wonderland does not show Alice coming out<br />
of the rabbit hole. She simply wakes up.<br />
30<br />
As I explore the wonders of language,<br />
Our early stages in education can change the ways we view and understand mental<br />
health for the rest of our lives.<br />
TRIGGER WARNING: SELF-HARM, SUICIDE<br />
Image By Phoebe Maharaj
Minds Matter Magazine Volume III Issue I <strong>Culture</strong> & <strong>Identity</strong> Minds Matter Magazine Volume III Issue I <strong>Culture</strong> & <strong>Identity</strong><br />
A culture without early mental health education<br />
can leave youth isolated and confused.<br />
They may not know what they are experiencing<br />
or how to reach out for help.<br />
Elizabeth Baker was diagnosed with<br />
depression and anxiety in her first year of<br />
university, but it was in Grade six that she<br />
first thought about self-harm.<br />
Baker attended Good Shepherd Catholic<br />
Elementary School from 2003 to 2009.<br />
She says she does not remember the school<br />
teaching about mental illnesses or mental<br />
health. She feels this will influence her for<br />
the rest of her life.<br />
The first time Baker learned about<br />
mental health was in Grade 9 health class, at<br />
the age of 14.<br />
“I remember feeling kind of weird,”<br />
she says. “It was the first time I’d heard of it,<br />
and it was all kind of scary stuff.”<br />
But the introduction to this education<br />
was late in Baker’s experience with mental<br />
illness. She was in Grade 10 when her selfharm<br />
hit a peak.<br />
“I found that when I started to get<br />
angry or upset about anything, I didn’t know<br />
how to cope with it,” she says. “That’s why I<br />
turned to self-harm.”<br />
Baker’s experience reflects a generational<br />
gap in mental health education. Her<br />
parents were not understanding when it<br />
came to mental illness. In high school, the<br />
only teacher she confided in then told her<br />
parents. Feeling judged and isolated, Baker<br />
decided to keep her mental health issues<br />
secret.<br />
“Elementary schools need to prepare<br />
students for what they’re going to face and<br />
the different people they’re going to meet<br />
and the issues they’re going to go through.<br />
There needs to be some discussion.”<br />
In an article exploring how education<br />
should be taught in Canadian schools, psychiatrist<br />
Stanley Kutcher says that mental health<br />
should be introduced in Grade 8, as that is<br />
when most mental disorders begin to manifest.<br />
Yet, according to the Canadian Mental<br />
Health Association of Toronto, suicide is the<br />
second leading cause of death for Canadians<br />
between the ages of 10 - when children in<br />
Ontario are in Grade 4 - and 24.<br />
Canadian psychiatrist Alexa Bagnall reported<br />
that adolescents who seek help often<br />
know very little about mental illness. A BMC<br />
Public Health study found that mental health<br />
was a factor in 24 per cent of teenagers who<br />
dropped out of high school. One of the largest<br />
factors in this are high rates of anxiety<br />
and a lack of understanding on healthy methods<br />
of dealing with stress.<br />
Full-time elementary school students<br />
spend around 195 days per year in school.<br />
At around six hours every day, at least 13 per<br />
cent of a child’s life is spent in school every<br />
year. Discussing mental health in classrooms<br />
will allow the normalization of mental health<br />
discussion, rather than isolating and addressing<br />
only the individual who experiences<br />
mental health issues. These<br />
students then grow to create a culture of<br />
adults that are educated and comfortable<br />
with mental health.<br />
School boards across Ontario are now<br />
realizing the importance of early mental<br />
health education. Ontario Shores has begun<br />
funding a curriculum in the Durham Region<br />
aimed at increasing awareness about mental<br />
illnesses. Their goal is to expand this curriculum<br />
across the rest of Ontario.<br />
In 2011, the Government of Ontario<br />
released Open Minds, Healthy Minds: Ontario’s<br />
Comprehensive Mental Health and<br />
Addictions Strategy, which introduced more<br />
mental health programming, tailored from<br />
childhood to old age. The implementation of<br />
their plan began with early intervention and<br />
support for children and youth in Ontario.<br />
It required school boards across Ontario to<br />
create specific mental health action plans.<br />
The Toronto District School Board<br />
(TDSB) created a 30-page five-year plan in<br />
2013, following a survey they had released<br />
the year before. In the survey, staff identified<br />
that a stronger approach to mental health<br />
was necessary for the students’ well being.<br />
Their plan aims to help educators recognize<br />
when students are experiencing distress and<br />
how to support them in their pathway to<br />
better mental health. It also gives suggestions<br />
on how to discuss mental health with<br />
parents and students at both the elementary<br />
and secondary level to maintain the support<br />
throughout education.<br />
The Durham District School Board<br />
(DDSB) released a 36-page five-year plan in<br />
2013. The plan was implemented in support<br />
of the board’s decisions to implement first<br />
aid in mental health, fight stigma, and establish<br />
a mental health committee by partnering<br />
with mental health organizations. By June<br />
2013, the school board planned for each<br />
elementary and secondary school to have<br />
at least one staff member trained in mental<br />
health first aid.<br />
But Baker’s elementary school, Good<br />
Shepherd Catholic Elementary School, is in<br />
the Durham Catholic District School Board.<br />
The school board’s action plan, released in<br />
2014, is only eight pages long with no lesson<br />
plans or outlines.<br />
Baker says if mental health had been<br />
addressed earlier, she “would like to think<br />
maybe things would have been different.”<br />
32<br />
33
Minds Matter Magazine Volume III Issue I <strong>Culture</strong> & <strong>Identity</strong><br />
Ill and abroad<br />
Tiffany Lieu<br />
How travelling and studying abroad can benefit mental health.<br />
Image By Rimsha Aziz<br />
Some aspects of travel can be wonderful, like<br />
exploring the unfamiliar and experiencing<br />
new cultures. Other aspects can be difficult,<br />
particularly when mental illness is involved.<br />
When I was younger, I hated being<br />
away from home. Sleepovers with friends or<br />
vacations with family were scary and stressful<br />
to me. I did not like to stray from my<br />
comfort zone.<br />
As I got older, my travel anxiety lessened<br />
and I learned to enjoy my time away.<br />
Being out of my comfort zone benefitted my<br />
mental well-being – I became fond of encountering<br />
various cultures and experiencing<br />
life elsewhere in the world. Particularly, my<br />
first solo trip to Europe did wonders for lessening<br />
my anxiety.<br />
I was nervous – I was travelling across<br />
the ocean and away from familiarity of my<br />
home, my culture, and my family and friends.<br />
But the moment I got off the plane, my fears<br />
began to fade and I became fascinated with a<br />
culture so different than my own.<br />
Travelling with anxiety is not as easy<br />
for some, but it is not impossible. Giselle*,<br />
a 19-year-old student, wanted to see the<br />
world, and aimed to overcome the struggle<br />
of travelling with anxiety and depression.<br />
“Travelling with mental illness taught<br />
me to be outside of my comfort zone and<br />
rely on myself,” says Giselle. “(When I travel),<br />
I can develop more self-confidence and independence,<br />
(and see that) my mental illness<br />
doesn’t define me.”<br />
Giselle encourages people with mental<br />
illness to travel.<br />
“It is a way to push the limits of your<br />
comfort zone while getting to know yourself<br />
better, which is extremely important when<br />
dealing with mental illness,” she said.<br />
But there is a difference in travelling<br />
for pleasure and studying abroad.<br />
“I think nowadays, there’s a societal<br />
pressure innocently placed on young people<br />
growing up in the West to travel while you’re<br />
young, a feeling only intensified by Instagram<br />
and Snapchat,” says Ary Maharaj, current<br />
grad student at the University of Toronto.<br />
Maharaj experienced a depressive episode<br />
while in Western Europe through the<br />
Woodsworth College’s Summer Abroad program<br />
in 2013.<br />
“I tried to push myself to go out and<br />
‘not waste’ the time that I earned through<br />
hard work, but quickly realized that it wasn’t<br />
bringing me any joy.”<br />
Yoel Inbar, a psychology professor from<br />
the University of Toronto, said taking semesters<br />
in new places can bring life experiences<br />
and personality development together, especially<br />
when social relationships are a factor.<br />
“There are some benefits to travelling,<br />
especially for longer periods,” Inbar said.<br />
Inbar referenced a 2013 study that<br />
tracked university students that studied<br />
abroad short term (one semester) and long<br />
term (one academic year). It examined how<br />
the experience influenced positive effects on<br />
35
Minds Matter Magazine Volume III Issue I <strong>Culture</strong> & <strong>Identity</strong><br />
the “Big Five” personality traits - a psychology<br />
theory that identifies five core traits that<br />
define an individual.<br />
The study found that travelling increased<br />
the trait “Openness,” which includes<br />
creativity, willingness to try new things and<br />
abilities to tackle new challenges. It also<br />
found that “Agreeableness,” which includes<br />
empathy and interest in other people, increased.<br />
Decreases were found in “Neuroticism,”<br />
which includes anxiety, stress and<br />
mood swings. These positive influences<br />
increased the longer students were abroad.<br />
As Inbar said, a major factor in the<br />
positive influences was social interaction and<br />
support. Social interactions during travelling<br />
benefited both personality development<br />
and mental well-being. Travel left a lasting<br />
influence - daily life experiences after returning<br />
were connected with the experiences<br />
learned through their travels.<br />
“Travelling can be a nerve wracking<br />
experience,” Giselle concludes. “But it shows<br />
you that mental illness can’t stop you from<br />
achieving your goals.”<br />
*Name has been changed to protect<br />
privacy<br />
Read below for some tips from MMM’s Ary<br />
Maharaj for travelling with mental illness:<br />
Find a bathroom<br />
Sometimes with anxiety, social or general,<br />
you need to know where the closest bathroom<br />
is, a plan for where you’re going next,<br />
and an escape route from every situation.<br />
Many of us have gotten used to either having<br />
data in our home country, or at least know<br />
the locations of popular places to get free<br />
Wifi (McDonalds, Starbucks, libraries).<br />
In many countries, this safety net may<br />
not be possible! Thankfully, even if we don’t<br />
unlock our phone, many providers have<br />
made it possible to download offline maps.<br />
One such app is MAPS.ME, which I used in<br />
Western Europe to download maps to my<br />
phone beforehand. This particular app allows<br />
me to keep my location services on without<br />
using data, and also allows you to search the<br />
area for key amenities like big tourist attractions,<br />
restaurants, and bathrooms.<br />
Don’t forget to care for yourself<br />
My depressive episode while travelling Central<br />
Europe was hard to navigate. It was my<br />
first major trip away from home, I was by<br />
myself, and although I was excited in the lead<br />
up to going, I was lonely when I arrived.<br />
I took two nights to stay in and do<br />
what I’d normally do back home to self-care:<br />
watch some YouTube, read a book, and drink<br />
some tea. That, coupled with some breathing,<br />
reflection of what I was going through in<br />
the moment, and some daily gratitude (three<br />
things about myself and three things about<br />
my environment) really helped me forgive<br />
myself for what I was going through. I then<br />
kept up my gratitude exercise (and paired<br />
it with daily pictures on my phone!) for the<br />
rest of the trip, which I’m thankful for now.<br />
The tip: know what your self-care routine is<br />
back home and try your best to incorporate it<br />
wherever you are!<br />
36
Subscribe<br />
Like<br />
Follow<br />
Instgram<br />
Masthead<br />
Nicole Royle<br />
Claudia Kwok<br />
Gina Nicoll<br />
Ioana Arbone<br />
Azayah Ferguson<br />
Bobby Hristova<br />
Frances Amilhasan<br />
Fatah Awil<br />
Jessica Barrera<br />
Elanna Clayton<br />
Victoria Gibson-Billings<br />
Christina Gizzo<br />
Shagun Kanwar<br />
Shadi Laghai<br />
Tiffany Lieu<br />
Lea Sheffield<br />
Sarah Strachan<br />
Leon Tsai<br />
Adley Lobo<br />
Jenny Ann Soriano<br />
Phoebe Maharaj<br />
Marian Sia<br />
Rimsha Aziz<br />
Brian Lau<br />
Shiyang (Alice) Shen<br />
Stephanie Soimu<br />
Ananta Sriram<br />
Felipe Templonuevo<br />
Fareha Nishat<br />
Gregory Allen<br />
Rohma Falak<br />
Sarah Balkhi<br />
Neeilan Selvalingam<br />
Leanna Oki<br />
Sunny Raval<br />
Managing Editor<br />
Alexa Battler<br />
Editorial Team<br />
Creative Team<br />
Operations Team<br />
Copy Editor<br />
Editor<br />
Editor<br />
Story Circle Coordinator<br />
Peer Facilitator<br />
Peer Facilitator<br />
Journalist<br />
Journalist<br />
Journalist<br />
Journalist<br />
Journalist<br />
Journalist<br />
Journalist<br />
Journalist<br />
Journalist<br />
Journalist<br />
Journalist<br />
Journalist<br />
Creative Director<br />
Creative Director<br />
Creative Director<br />
Graphic Designer<br />
Illustrator<br />
Illustrator<br />
Illustrator<br />
Operations Team Lead<br />
Operations Team Lead<br />
Social Media Coordinator<br />
Director of Communications<br />
Champions Lead<br />
Marketing & Promotions Coordinator<br />
Financial Officer<br />
Application Developer<br />
Communications Assistant<br />
Executive Assistant<br />
Note: We are not a service provider. If you are in crisis, here are some recommended resources:<br />
UTSC Wellness Centre, Good2Talk, call 911, your nearest emergency department for assistance,<br />
Ontario Mental Health Helpline.<br />
Theme Advisor: Dr. Jessica Dere<br />
Fall 2017 Volume III Issue I: <strong>Culture</strong> & <strong>Identity</strong><br />
Minds Matter Magazine (MMM) is a community platform focusing on student perspectives so we can all think,<br />
talk, and take action on matters related to mental health.<br />
This issue is available online at: MindsMatterMagazine.com and was helped made possible with the financial<br />
support of: The office of Business Development at the University of Toronto Scarborough and the Development<br />
& Alumni Relations Office at the University of Toronto Scarborough.<br />
Advisory Board: Liza Arnason, Toni De Mello, Jessica Dere, Jeffrey Dvorkin, Roger Francis, Andrew Hercules,<br />
Nancy Johnston, Katie Kilroy-Marac, Maureen Murney, Perry Sheppard<br />
Special Thanks: Andrew Arifuzzaman, Marah Ayad, Debbie Belinski, Don Campbell, Vishakha Chakravarti, Mark<br />
Church, Kevin Connery, George Cree, Gerald Cupchik, Kristina Doyle, John Dias, Pat Dixon, Andrew Echevarria,<br />
Allyssa Fernandez, Chris Garbutt, Manny Gitterman, Gray Graffam, Rick Halpern, Kevin Healey, Tomeo Ho, Antu<br />
Hossain, Eva Huang, Anastacia Jiang, Sarah King, Elsa Kiosses, Danielle Klein, Kira Laurin, Samer Lazkani, David<br />
Lucatch, Brian MacKinnon, Clark McRorie, Ary Maharaj, Josh Miller, Jenkin Mok, Josh Oliver, Jessica Orellana,<br />
Moshiur Rahman, Simone Robinson, Nilab Safi, Susan Schellenberg, Samantha Seon, Kosan Shafaque, Gaurav<br />
Sharma, Serena Soleimani, Taamannae Taabassum, Lynn Tucker, Kimberly Tull, Andrew Westoll, Andrew Young,<br />
Karen Young, Muzhen Zhang, Hema Zbogar.<br />
Wanna send a letter to the editor? Contact our editor here
© Minds Matter Magazine 2017