The Light English Edition December 2017 issue
Organ of the Worldwide Ahmadiyya Association for the Propagation of Islam. Preaching Islam as taught by the Holy Prophet Muhammad (s) - a tolerant, peaceful. loving, inclusive, rational and tolerant Islam.
Organ of the Worldwide Ahmadiyya Association for the Propagation of Islam. Preaching Islam as taught by the Holy Prophet Muhammad (s) - a tolerant, peaceful. loving, inclusive, rational and tolerant Islam.
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
ِ ی م م الرَّح<br />
ن<br />
ِ<br />
سب ا ہللِ الرَّْحم ٰ<br />
ْ م ِ<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Light</strong><br />
International Organ of the Centre for the Worldwide<br />
Ahmadiyya Anjuman Ishaat Islam<br />
<strong>2017</strong><br />
April<br />
2016<br />
<strong>December</strong><br />
<strong>The</strong> only Islamic organisation upholding the finality of prophethood.<br />
Germany<br />
Guyana<br />
India<br />
Sweden<br />
UK<br />
USA<br />
Webcasting on the world’s first real-time Islamic service at<br />
Editors<br />
Amir Aziz<br />
Abd ul Muqtadir Gordon<br />
Gowsia Saleem & Prof. Shahab<br />
Shabbir<br />
Kaleem Ahmed<br />
Shahid Aziz & Mustaq Ali<br />
Zainib Ahmad<br />
www.virtualmosque.co.uk<br />
Interesting external links<br />
‣ Is Secularism a Threat to Islam?<br />
‣ Embracing Islam in India<br />
‣ A Star of the Abrahamic Faiths<br />
‣ Stop Exploiting Islam to Advance Political Motives.<br />
Contents<br />
<strong>The</strong> Call of the Messiah 2<br />
Jihadist Ideology in Pakistan and 5<br />
Javed Ahmad Ghamidi’s Counter<br />
Narrative by Abdul Rauf<br />
How did the Muslim world fall behind 11<br />
on science by Daniel Bardsley<br />
Broadcasts (UK time)<br />
1. Skype Urdu lecture: Sunday 09:00<br />
2. Live on www.virtualmosque.co.uk<br />
‣ Friday Sermon 13:00<br />
‣ First Sunday of month lecture 15:00.<br />
3. Radio Virtual Mosque<br />
Websites<br />
1. International HQ<br />
2. Research and History<br />
3. <strong>The</strong> Woking Mosque and Mission<br />
4. <strong>The</strong> Berlin Mosque and Mission<br />
5. Quran search<br />
6. Blog<br />
‣ Dating of the Jesus' Tomb<br />
‣ Duse Mohamed Ali - An Early Missionary of Islam<br />
in the UK<br />
‣ Muslims can Pray in Churches and Synagoges<br />
- Saudis.<br />
‣ Sexual Abuse Covered up in Pakistani Religios<br />
Schools.<br />
‣ Robotics - A Muslim Heritage<br />
External Links<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Light</strong> is not responsible for the content<br />
of external sites. <strong>The</strong> inclusion of a link to an external<br />
website should not be understood to be<br />
an endorsement of that website, the views it expresses<br />
or the site's owners (or their products/services).<br />
Some links may have research, which disagrees<br />
with our beliefs. It is for us to consider<br />
such material and provide a rebuttal. Ignoring it<br />
will not make it go away.<br />
We welcome all scholarly contributions to<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Light</strong>.<br />
I Shall Love All Mankind.
<strong>December</strong> <strong>2017</strong> <strong>The</strong><br />
<strong>Light</strong> 2<br />
<strong>The</strong> Call of the<br />
Messiah<br />
by Hazrat Mirza Ghulam<br />
Ahmad<br />
<strong>The</strong> Promised Messiah and Mahdi<br />
(Translator's Note: In 1892 Hazrat Mirza<br />
Ghulam Ahmad called on his followers to hold a<br />
gathering at the end of <strong>December</strong> every year.<br />
Among its stated objectives was that members<br />
would gain in spiritual knowledge and understanding,<br />
strengthen fraternal bonds, plan ways<br />
and means of the propagation of Islam, and dedicate<br />
themselves afresh to the cause of the Movement.<br />
Some of the literalist Ulama, who had no eye<br />
for the great objects of the Movement, denounced<br />
the holding and organisation of such meetings as<br />
un-Islamic. <strong>The</strong>y pronounced that, according to<br />
Islam, a journey was only allowed to one of the<br />
three sacred mosques of Islam, or one or two<br />
other places, all other travel being prohibited to a<br />
Muslim. Today it is inconceivable how such absurd<br />
rulings could have been <strong>issue</strong>d, especially<br />
given the fact that the same Ulama now travel to<br />
all parts of the world, attending conferences and<br />
meetings. Here we reproduce selected extracts<br />
from the reply given by Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad<br />
to these critics, published on <strong>December</strong> 17th,<br />
1892. This translation was first published in <strong>The</strong><br />
<strong>Light</strong>, November-<strong>December</strong> 1992 <strong>issue</strong>. It has<br />
been edited and expanded here.)<br />
Last year it was decided, according to the<br />
opinion of the majority of friends, that members<br />
of our Jamaat should come to meet this humble<br />
servant at least once a year, to derive benefit as<br />
regards the needs of<br />
the religion and to hold<br />
consultations regarding<br />
the propagation of<br />
Islam. At that time of<br />
discussion, it was also<br />
decided as being appropriate that the best date for<br />
coming to Qadian for this purpose would be <strong>December</strong><br />
27th because it is during the holidays, and<br />
people in employment are free at this time. Also,<br />
being in the winter, these days are suitable for<br />
travelling. As a result, our sincere members were<br />
pleased to agree to this view, considering it the<br />
best course of action.<br />
<strong>The</strong>refore, on <strong>December</strong> 7th, 1892, I sent a<br />
letter consisting of a printed announcement to all<br />
members, the summary of its contents being that<br />
one of the main aims of this gathering (Jalsa) is<br />
I Shall Love All Mankind.<br />
that every sincere person should get the<br />
opportunity to benefit spiritually by a face-to-face<br />
meeting, to increase his religious knowledge, and<br />
to develop his understanding of matters spiritual.<br />
Now we have heard that some person, to<br />
prove that such work is tantamount to adding a<br />
novelty (bid‛at) into Islam, in fact, a sin, has<br />
requested a religious judgment from a Maulvi<br />
Rahim Bakhsh, imam of the Cheenia-wali mosque<br />
in Lahore, as to what is the teaching of Islam about<br />
travelling from afar to such a meeting on an<br />
appointed day?. . .<br />
In reply to this request, Maulvi Rahim Bakhsh<br />
has produced a lengthy writing referring to a<br />
hadith which is not relevant to the subject, the<br />
summary of which is that it is an unlawful<br />
innovation (bid‛at), rather a sin, to go to attend<br />
such a gathering, and that to propose the holding<br />
of such meetings is a later invention for which<br />
there is no basis in the Quran and Sunnah. Moreover,<br />
the man who creates such an institution in Islam<br />
is to be condemned (mardūd).<br />
Reply<br />
This journey (to the Jalsa) shall be undertaken<br />
by every sincere one with the<br />
intention of seeking knowledge.<br />
Fair-minded people should now answer<br />
truthfully whether the existence in Islam of such<br />
maulvis and muftis is a sign of the tribulations of<br />
the end of the world (qiyamat) or not. O good man,<br />
do you not know that travelling for the sake of<br />
religious knowledge is not only allowed but is<br />
incumbent according to the Quran and the Holy<br />
Prophet, so much so that the one who<br />
intentionally neglects it is guilty of a serious sin,<br />
and to insist on refusal deliberately is an act of<br />
disbelief in some cases? Do you not know that it<br />
has been urged with great emphasis (in Hadith)<br />
that “the seeking of<br />
knowledge is incumbent<br />
upon<br />
every Muslim male<br />
and female”, and it<br />
has been said:<br />
“Seek knowledge, even though it may be in China”.<br />
Now considering that I wrote in my<br />
announcement, in the clearest and plainest words<br />
possible, that this journey (to the Jalsa) shall be<br />
undertaken by every sincere one with the<br />
intention of seeking knowledge, just think how far<br />
from honesty, integrity, justice, virtue and piety it<br />
is to pronounce the ruling that the man who<br />
institutes such a practice in Islam must be<br />
condemned. …<br />
Open and read the Sahih Bukhari, and see the<br />
glad tidings given for a journey undertaken to
<strong>December</strong> <strong>2017</strong> <strong>The</strong><br />
<strong>Light</strong> 3<br />
seek knowledge. It is as follows: “Whoever undertakes<br />
a journey to seek knowledge, Allah eases for<br />
him the way to paradise”.<br />
O you unjust Maulvi,<br />
show some fairness. And<br />
consider that you have<br />
called your brother a<br />
condemned one, who,<br />
like you, professes the<br />
Kalima, belongs to the people of the Qibla and<br />
believes in Allah and the Messenger, and you have<br />
declared him as utterly deprived of the mercy of<br />
God and the intercession of the Holy Prophet<br />
Muhammad, . . . giving the reason that I had <strong>issue</strong>d<br />
such an announcement and invited people to the<br />
Jalsa. Open your eyes and read what that announcement<br />
of <strong>December</strong> 7th, 1892 says. It calls<br />
our community together for the purposes of acquiring<br />
knowledge, seeking solutions to the problems<br />
faced by the religion, helping the cause of Islam,<br />
and meeting one’s brothers. Does it mention<br />
any festivity, entertainment, music or song? . . .<br />
Fixing a date<br />
If there is misgiving in someone’s heart as to<br />
why a particular date has been fixed for this religious<br />
gathering, and whether such practice is<br />
traceable to the Holy Prophet or his Companions,<br />
the reply is that you should look in Bukhari and<br />
Muslim. Bedouins used to come to the Holy<br />
Prophet to ask questions about religious matters<br />
at times when they were free, and some of them<br />
came to him in particular months when they were<br />
free. <strong>The</strong>re is a report in Bukhari that a delegation<br />
from the tribe of Abdul Qais came to the Holy<br />
Prophet and said that as they come from afar, they<br />
can only attend his company during a certain<br />
month. <strong>The</strong> Holy Prophet accepted what they said.<br />
This hadith shows that those who wish to meet<br />
their spiritual guide to seek knowledge or for religious<br />
purposes can appoint a certain date in<br />
accordance with their free time when they can attend<br />
conveniently and without loss to themselves.<br />
This is just the case with <strong>December</strong> 27th because<br />
it is during the holidays and those in employment<br />
can easily come at that time. . . .<br />
Bukhari has included a special chapter in his<br />
Sahih about appointing a date for holding a class<br />
for receiving religious education. Its title is “He<br />
who appoints certain days for those seeking<br />
knowledge”, indicating that this practice is traceable<br />
to some Companions. In support of this, Bukhari<br />
quotes a report to the effect that Abdullah<br />
(Ibn Mas‛ud) had fixed Thursday as the day on<br />
which to give religious instruction, and on that<br />
I Shall Love All Mankind.<br />
day people used to attend his lecture.<br />
Quran allows organisation and arrangement.<br />
It must also<br />
be remembered<br />
that Allah has instructed<br />
us in the<br />
Holy Quran to<br />
make plans and<br />
arrangements,<br />
and ordered us to put into action the best-devised<br />
schemes which we consider to be expedient for<br />
the service of Islam and to be effective in overcoming<br />
the opponents. In this regard, He says:<br />
“And prepare for them (the enemy) whatever<br />
force you can” (8:60). In other words, make every<br />
kind of preparation that you can against the<br />
opponents of the faith, and exert all the strength<br />
that you can for the propagation of Islam. . .<br />
With the changing times Islam faces ever<br />
newer types of problems, or the opponents<br />
attack us in new types of ways, so<br />
we have to adopt new means as well.<br />
Modern methods must be used in new times<br />
Those who ponder over this verse can realise<br />
that in accordance with the hadith “Actions are<br />
judged by intention”, to devise some suitable system<br />
for the service of Islam is not an unlawful novelty<br />
or evil. As with the changing times, Islam faces<br />
ever newer types of problems, or the opponents<br />
attack us in new types of ways, so we have to<br />
adopt new means as well. <strong>The</strong>refore, if we conceive<br />
of some method or remedy to combat these<br />
attacks which is appropriate for the present time,<br />
that constitutes the making of a plan and has nothing<br />
to do with bringing innovations into Islam.<br />
It is possible that, due to the enormous<br />
changes of the times, we may face certain new<br />
problems of a kind which even the Holy Prophet<br />
Muhammad did not face in the same form. For instance,<br />
we cannot fight wars of the present day in<br />
the earlier ways which are in the Sunnah because<br />
the techniques of warfare have completely<br />
changed in this age. Weapons used previously are<br />
now ineffective, and new weapons have been<br />
invented for fighting. Now if Muslim rulers were<br />
to consider the taking up and deployment of these<br />
weapons to be an unlawful novelty, and, listening<br />
to maulvis like Rahim Bakhsh, believe it to be a sin<br />
and evil to use these modern implements of war,<br />
and argue that this is a manner of fighting never<br />
undertaken by the Holy Prophet Muhammad, nor<br />
the Companions, nor the next generation, the only<br />
result would be that they would lose their already<br />
decrepit kingdoms with ignominy and the enemy<br />
would be triumphant. <strong>The</strong>refore, wherever the<br />
making of plans and arrangements is required, for<br />
example, whether in case of physical or spiritual
<strong>December</strong> <strong>2017</strong> <strong>The</strong><br />
<strong>Light</strong> 4<br />
warfare, whether the battle is by the sword or the<br />
pen, the verse quoted above is sufficient for our<br />
guidance. . . .<br />
Foolish friends invite ridicule upon Islam<br />
Every Muslim ought to pray that God rid Islam<br />
soon of those maulvis who show such treachery.<br />
For, this is a critical time for Islam, and these foolish<br />
friends wish to make Islam a target of ridicule<br />
and mockery by making statements which every<br />
person, with his light of reason, finds to be untrue.<br />
May Allah have mercy on Imam Bukhari! He has<br />
also included a chapter regarding this in his book,<br />
in which he writes: “Ali, may God be pleased with<br />
him, said: Tell people things which they understand;<br />
or do you like to have Allah and His Messenger<br />
rejected?” In the commentary on Bukhari,<br />
this is explained as follows: “Speak to people<br />
according to the scope of their understanding”. In<br />
other words, explain to people those injunctions<br />
of Allah and the Messenger which they can<br />
comprehend and which appear to them to be<br />
reasonable; otherwise, you will needlessly have<br />
them repudiating Allah and the Messenger.<br />
Now it is obvious that when an opponent of<br />
Islam hears that the maulvis have <strong>issue</strong>d a ruling<br />
declaring all travel to be unlawful (for a Muslim)<br />
except to the Sacred Mosque, the Mosque of the<br />
Holy Prophet, the Aqsa Mosque, and one or two<br />
other places, he will ridicule Islam and get the<br />
chance to find fault with the teaching of the Holy<br />
Prophet. He will not be aware that this pronouncement<br />
is merely the mischief of a maulvi,<br />
out of a grudge, or his ignorance; he will directly<br />
attack the Holy Prophet Muhammad. . . .<br />
Many maulvis, for the sake of their livelihood,<br />
travel all around the east and the west, ostensibly<br />
for preaching. Yet, such journeys are not<br />
considered objectionable, nor does anyone <strong>issue</strong><br />
rulings that they have added novelties into Islam,<br />
or that they are evil-doers and sinners. But when<br />
this humble servant, having been appointed to call<br />
to the truth by Divine permission and command,<br />
invites his followers to come to gain knowledge,<br />
such travel is declared unlawful, and for this act, I<br />
am dubbed a reprobate. Is this the way of virtue<br />
and godliness?<br />
Progress is not unlawful innovation<br />
Regrettably, these unwise people do not even<br />
know that planning and organisation do not fall in<br />
the category of innovations. Every time and age<br />
requires new ways of organisation. If new types of<br />
problems arise, what can we do other than devise<br />
new types of plans? When the true Sunnah has<br />
I Shall Love All Mankind.<br />
been safely preserved, and for the defence of that<br />
very Sunnah we need to use certain means, will<br />
they be called innovations? God forbid, certainly<br />
not.<br />
An innovation (bid‛at) is one which in essence<br />
deviates from, and is contrary to, the Sunnah of<br />
the Holy Prophet, and the doing of which has been<br />
condemned and warned against in the teaching<br />
left behind by the Holy Prophet. If merely modern<br />
ways of working and new types of schemes are<br />
called innovations, then the number of innovations<br />
in Islam will be countless. <strong>The</strong> fields of grammar,<br />
literature and theology, and the writing of<br />
Hadith and its compilation, would all be innovations.<br />
Likewise, travelling by railway train, wearing<br />
manufactured clothing, sending letters by mail,<br />
learning news by telegram, and fighting with guns<br />
and cannons, would all be in the category of innovations.<br />
In fact, to use guns and cannons will be<br />
not only an innovation but a major sin because, according<br />
to an authentic hadith, it is strictly forbidden<br />
to kill anyone by means of fire.<br />
Who could be a more strict follower of the<br />
Sunnah than the Companions of the Holy Prophet?<br />
Even they did not consider the Sunnah to have the<br />
meaning which Rahim Bakhsh has given it. <strong>The</strong>y<br />
carried out many new works of planning and organisation<br />
which were neither done by the Holy<br />
Prophet nor mentioned in the Holy Quran. Just<br />
consider the new institutions established by Hazrat<br />
Umar, a list of which would fill a book. He<br />
introduced the Hijri calendar for Islam, appointed<br />
police constabulary for the security of cities, set<br />
up a proper office for the public treasury, devised<br />
rules and regulations for joining military service<br />
and obtaining leave from that service, prescribed<br />
codes of behaviour for the conduct of war, prepared<br />
special instructions for dealing with<br />
financial lawsuits, and promulgated many regulations<br />
for the safety of the public. . . .<br />
I did nothing new of this kind. All I did was to<br />
propose a gathering to acquire knowledge, holding<br />
consultations on how to support the cause of<br />
Islam, and meeting of the brethren.<br />
Lastly, I wish to announce that if Maulvi<br />
Rahim Bakhsh still does not rescind his ruling, I<br />
place him under oath in the name of Allah that if<br />
he is a seeker after truth, he must come to see me<br />
in Qadian for a clarification of this matter. I will<br />
pay his travel expenses and will place books before<br />
him, and show him the Quran and Hadith, to
<strong>December</strong> <strong>2017</strong> <strong>The</strong><br />
<strong>Light</strong> 5<br />
prove that his ruling is entirely false and an enticement<br />
by the devil.<br />
(<strong>The</strong> published announcement, from which<br />
the above extracts are translated, is dated 17 <strong>December</strong><br />
1892 and it was also included as an appendix<br />
in his book Ainah Kamalat-i Islam).<br />
(Return to contents)<br />
FWU Journal of Social Sciences, Summer <strong>2017</strong>,<br />
Vol.11, No.1, 27-33<br />
Jihadist Ideology in Pakistan<br />
and Javed Ahmad Ghamidi’s<br />
Counter-Narrative 1<br />
Introduction<br />
Abdul Rauf<br />
University of Peshawar<br />
Jihadist ideology<br />
in the religious intellectual<br />
discourse,<br />
accelerated in the<br />
recent years in Pakistan,<br />
is having its<br />
roots in an atomistic Javed Ahmad Ghamidi<br />
approach to the<br />
holy texts and a narrative which sanctified the<br />
killing of non-Muslims and their Muslim collaborators<br />
alike. Ghamidi (b. 1951), an ardent religious<br />
scholar, challenged the Jihadists ideology<br />
in its bases. <strong>The</strong> counter-narrative of Ghamidi<br />
on Jihad, Muslims and non-Muslims relations,<br />
Islamic state/relation of religion with politics<br />
and many other <strong>issue</strong>s cannot be easily ignored<br />
intellectually. His views are ingrained in the<br />
main Muslim religious treatise and have a profound<br />
divergence from the contemporary exclusivist<br />
interpretation/narrative of the Muslims.<br />
Ghamidi’s views, embedded in Farahi-Islahi<br />
school of South Asia, a relatively unknown religious<br />
trend, is upholding a holistic approach to<br />
Quran based on structural and thematic coherence<br />
in Quran (Nazm-i-Quran) against the disjointed<br />
and isolationist approach of the domi-<br />
nant religious discourse that sometimes appeared<br />
in the shape of religious militancy. Pakistani<br />
society ridden with an armed religious<br />
conflict cannot overwhelm the militant elements<br />
through the use of force unless it is an<br />
encounter with a stronger ideological counternarrative.<br />
Ghamidi’s work is relevant to societies<br />
elsewhere in the Muslim world also. In this<br />
paper roots and standing of Ghamidi against the<br />
dominant religious discourse in Pakistan is<br />
investigated and evaluated in the light of his<br />
publications and his presentation in electronic<br />
media while the same was adopted for the<br />
Jihadist ideology and added with the stories<br />
narrated among the masses through the<br />
interaction of the researcher with the conflictridden<br />
areas in the north-western part of<br />
Pakistan called Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and FATA.<br />
Pakistan, a geo-strategic important country<br />
of South Asia, witnessed the worst kind of conflict<br />
resulting in the killing of thousands of people<br />
more than any other country including the<br />
US since 9/11. 2 <strong>The</strong> menace has its roots in the<br />
region since the coming of the Sour Revolution,<br />
popularly known as the communist revolution<br />
in Kabul in 1978, the subsequent resistance by<br />
the people of Afghanistan and support of all major<br />
non-Communist regimes in the world particularly<br />
the USA during the Cold War years. 3 <strong>The</strong><br />
Middle Eastern Arab states were the other major<br />
actors in the region. <strong>The</strong> Afghan resistance<br />
movement was carried out with an ideology<br />
emanating from the modern Islamic revivalist<br />
thoughts in the 20 th century- a conglomeration<br />
of thoughts of Abul Ala Mawdudi of Pakistan,<br />
Sayyed Qutub of Egypt, Salafis (non-conformists<br />
of Saudi Arabia) and Deobandis (originated<br />
in India in the 1860s). <strong>The</strong> regional and international<br />
actors also found it appealing to safeguard<br />
their own national interests by curtailing<br />
the Soviet expansionism in the region. For<br />
twenty years the religious discourse was dominated<br />
by a Jihadist ideology till the Soviet Union<br />
unglued in 1991. <strong>The</strong> Jihadist Ideology was<br />
thought to be wind up after the fall of Najib government<br />
in Kabul in April 1992. But it was not<br />
easy to uproot an ingrained militant ideology,<br />
1 Correspondence concerning this article should be addressed<br />
to Professor Abdul Rauf, Department of Political Science, University<br />
of Peshawar abdulrauf@upesh.edu.pk. This paper is<br />
based on a presentation in the International National Conference<br />
“Narrative of Peace and Conflict” in July 1-3, 2015 in Liverpool<br />
Hope University. <strong>The</strong> writer expresses acknowledgements<br />
to the Higher Education Commission (HEC) of Pakistan<br />
for the travel grants to attend this conference.<br />
I Shall Love All Mankind.<br />
2 In the last thirteen years Pakistan suffered 13,721 terrorist<br />
incidents which left 56,156 dead and more than 200,000 critically<br />
injured (National Counter Terrorism Authority), Dawn,<br />
Karachi, March, 2015.<br />
3 Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher and President Ronald<br />
Reagan were among those who appreciated the Afghan militant<br />
against the Soviet Union forces in Afghanistan in early<br />
1980s.
<strong>December</strong> <strong>2017</strong> <strong>The</strong><br />
<strong>Light</strong> 6<br />
particularly when the global actors turned off<br />
their attention, and Pakistan was left alone to<br />
deal with the threat. Pakistan did not have capability<br />
and capacity to face the after effects of<br />
the 15-year war conflict in the region.<br />
<strong>The</strong> overthrow of Taliban government in<br />
Kabul by the US-led NATO coalition forces, and<br />
installation of Karzai regime in 2001 met the<br />
same response from the Taliban resistance<br />
forces. Taliban and their sympathisers elsewhere<br />
in the world, particularly in Pakistan,<br />
launched a resistance movement using the<br />
same religious slogans against the US and its allies<br />
as they did against the Russians. But this<br />
time the reaction of the third generation of the<br />
militants in Pakistan was more brutal against<br />
the military and civilians than their earlier ones.<br />
<strong>The</strong>y devastated the government and non-government<br />
institutions on the one hand and annihilated<br />
the already poor infrastructure particularly<br />
in the north-west of Pakistan including<br />
Federally Administered Tribal Areas (FATA).<br />
<strong>The</strong> stubborn resistance of the militants to<br />
the security forces of Pakistan is based on a particular<br />
religious narrative which justifies all<br />
kind of violence including the killing of innocent<br />
people/children, lethal encounter and suicide<br />
bombing on one hand and beheading, imputation<br />
and display of dead bodies in public places<br />
on the other. After analysing statements, communique<br />
, videos and literature of the militant<br />
groups it can be attributed to a particular approach<br />
to the religious texts; Quran, hadith and<br />
athar 4 and fiqh verdicts which are constantly<br />
used to justify their ‘noble’ actions.<br />
What is this Jihadist ideology?<br />
<strong>The</strong> contemporary Jihadist ideology believes<br />
in the categorisation of entire humanity<br />
into two groups; Muslims and ‘infidels’, ‘good<br />
and evil’, the party of God (Hizb u Rehman) and<br />
a party of Satan (Hizb u shetan). Since the dawn<br />
of humanity, these two groups are at perpetual<br />
war with each other. Hence it is incumbent<br />
upon the Muslims to continue this holy war<br />
against the ‘infidels’. This holy war will continue<br />
till kufr (infidelity) became subservient to<br />
Islam everywhere on the earth as stated in the<br />
Holy Quran (Al-Tuba, 112, 123; Al-Baqra, 190).<br />
<strong>The</strong>y uphold the opinion that the holy war is<br />
forever and it will continue till the doomsday as<br />
it is enunciated in the hadith (Sunan-i-Abi<br />
Dawood, 2170; Sahih Bukhari, 2801).<br />
<strong>The</strong> Jihadists looks all political, economic,<br />
diplomatic and strategic events in the world<br />
dominated by the Western/Christian world<br />
with a perennial war prism and citing the<br />
events in Kashmir, Palestine, Chechnya, Balkan,<br />
East Timor, Iraq and Afghanistan from the<br />
pulpit 5 to instigate people which ultimately<br />
helps in enlisting support for the militants and<br />
their violent activities. Certain events happened<br />
in the West on the pretext of freedom of thought<br />
and expression is narrated as iconoclasm<br />
against Prophet Muhammad (S) and Islam. If<br />
there is any reference to the solution of problems<br />
through the offices of UN, they term this<br />
body as incompetent when comes to Muslims.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Muslim countries accepted U.N. resolutions<br />
more than any other country in the world. With<br />
the support of US and other international<br />
actors, the UN failed to implement its resolutions<br />
on Israel and Kashmir. When the USA says<br />
that Al-Qaida is in the tribal areas 6 and planning<br />
to attack the Americans in the US, the local<br />
people ask questions. How the Americans can<br />
be trusted as it were the Americans who<br />
claimed the presence of WMD in Iraq but later<br />
on nothing was found, and one million Muslims<br />
have been killed in Iraq (Hamid Mir, 2009,<br />
March 30). <strong>The</strong> militants and common people<br />
think that the Americans and other non-Muslims<br />
cannot face us on the ground so they sent<br />
these machines (drones) to kill the innocent<br />
people. <strong>The</strong> Americans are ‘coward’ and do not<br />
have the courage to face us in the war. <strong>The</strong> sympathetic<br />
intellectuals in media frequently cited<br />
examples of the patronage of certain figures<br />
such as Suleiman Rushdie and Taslima Nasrin<br />
whose writings against the holy personalities of<br />
Islam hurts the feelings of Muslims. <strong>The</strong> caricature<br />
episode in the West fomented the already<br />
unreceptive feelings of the Muslims. <strong>The</strong>y applauded<br />
those Muslims who reacted violently<br />
against the value of freedom. Newspapers,<br />
magazines and journals and speeches from the<br />
pulpits and public platform are full of news depicting<br />
the West as the place where morality 7 is<br />
4 Traditions narrated from the companions of Prophet Muhammad<br />
(S).<br />
5 Particularly in the Friday sermons, funeral ceremonies and<br />
after daily prayer the dua which an imam sought.<br />
6 It refers to the border areas between Pakistan and Afghanistan<br />
which enjoy relative autonomy from the state institutions<br />
I Shall Love All Mankind.<br />
and remained safe places for the militants during the Afghan<br />
war in 1980s.<br />
7 When they use the term morality (Ikhlaq) they mean laxity<br />
in opposite sex relations.
<strong>December</strong> <strong>2017</strong> <strong>The</strong><br />
<strong>Light</strong> 7<br />
eroding day and night. A reactionary attitude<br />
among the Muslims pushed some of them to the<br />
extreme and thus were not ready to accept any<br />
good in the Americans and in the West because<br />
of their double standard in the international relations.<br />
Writers and speakers refer that when<br />
the Oklahoma bombing occurred, within<br />
minutes, western media reported having a<br />
connection with the Middle East. Investigation<br />
afterwards proved it incorrect, and nobody<br />
termed it Christian fundamentalism while it<br />
had a connection to Christianity. 8 <strong>The</strong>se learned<br />
men pointed out the subjectivity of the Western<br />
media which portray Pakistan’s Atomic Bomb<br />
as an Islamic Bomb, but they never termed the<br />
Indian atomic bomb as a Hindu Bomb or Jewish<br />
or Christian Bomb elsewhere in the world. <strong>The</strong><br />
statements of George W. Bush referring to the<br />
American war on terrorism as a crusade only<br />
reinforce the Jihadists’ analogy to the crusades<br />
(SAIS Review). <strong>The</strong> success of Mujahidin against<br />
the Soviet forces in Afghanistan became religious<br />
symbols of the Muslim resistance<br />
struggle, and Jihadists use this notion in their<br />
addresses in mosques and public gatherings. In<br />
Pakistani society, common people are influenced<br />
more by the clergy on the religious<br />
knowledge and attitudes as one of the Gallup<br />
surveys shows in its reports. According to the<br />
report, 71 % of the people of Pakistan have been<br />
influenced by the local cleric (imam-i-masjid) for<br />
their religious knowledge and belief while the<br />
same was 79 % in 1980 when the Jihadist ideology<br />
was in the offing in the region (Murad<br />
Javid).<br />
Following is the narrative based on militants’<br />
understanding of religion and explanation<br />
of their violent actions in Pakistan. On the<br />
question of targeting the Muslim military<br />
whether they are in Afghanistan or Pakistan,<br />
they blatantly declared them liable to death as<br />
they are collaborators with the ‘infidels’ as<br />
Quran is condemning friendship with Jews and<br />
Christians. In terrorist actions, if civilians including<br />
children, women and old people get<br />
lost, the terrorists felt no excuse because such<br />
innocent people will be awarded paradise<br />
promised by God to the martyrs (Geo TV, 2014,<br />
Dec 21). When asked why they are conducting<br />
jihad in Afghanistan their answer is if jihad in<br />
the 1980s was obligatory against the Soviet<br />
then why it is not obligatory against the Americans<br />
now who are occupying Afghanistan?<br />
When it is said that attacks on the rulers of Pakistan<br />
are un-Islamic as they are Muslims? <strong>The</strong>y<br />
reply that the then president of Afghanistan (Dr<br />
Najibullah) was also a Muslim then why was he<br />
targeted by the then mujahidin? When Najib<br />
was collaborating with the Russians, so is the<br />
case of Pakistani rulers. When it is asked: why<br />
are you killing the policemen and military soldiers?<br />
Who are only earning bread for their<br />
children and thus should not be killed? <strong>The</strong> soldiers<br />
in Afghanistan and soldiers in Kashmir are<br />
also earning their livelihood so why were they<br />
targeted? When it is said - due to the actions of<br />
Taliban hundreds of civilians are killed in<br />
Pakistan. <strong>The</strong>y would say that the same civilians<br />
are killed in Kashmir, Iraq and Afghanistan by<br />
the ‘enemies’ of Islam (Jang, 2013, November<br />
19). When it is said that due to suicide bombing<br />
innocent people are killed, and thus Taliban are<br />
responsible for their killing. Here came a unique<br />
and interesting argument. <strong>The</strong>y said if these victims<br />
are innocent then they will go to paradise<br />
and thus the Taliban are doing good to them by<br />
sending them to the paradise (Geo TV, 2014,<br />
Dec 21). When they are asked why they are targeting<br />
the barber shops, they would reply that<br />
it is evil and there is saying of the Prophet to<br />
stop an evil with force. 9 When asked why they<br />
are targeting schools particularly girls school?<br />
<strong>The</strong>y will term these schools as the centre of<br />
spreading western values and cultures and that<br />
girls should remain within the walls of their<br />
houses.<br />
Intellectual Support from Political Islam<br />
<strong>The</strong> literature on political Islam that<br />
emerged and spread after the end of the colonial<br />
rule in South Asia, is considered to be the<br />
main source of support to the Taliban’s plea to<br />
declare Pakistan as an un-Islamic state. Unconditional<br />
obedience to such a state is not binding<br />
upon the Muslims. <strong>The</strong> concept of establishment<br />
of an Islamic rule as mandatory for the<br />
Muslims is articulated in the contemporary revivalist<br />
literature and thus greatly supported<br />
militants in receiving logistic, cash and human<br />
resource assistance from the sympathisers of<br />
this thought.<br />
8 <strong>The</strong> episode was also mentioned by Edward Said as an example<br />
how the media is reporting terrorism of different people<br />
associated with different religions differently (<br />
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fVC8EYd_Z_g ) visited<br />
on November 27, 2016.<br />
I Shall Love All Mankind.<br />
9<br />
“Whomever among you sees an evil, then let him stop it with<br />
his hand. Whomever is not able, then with his tongue, and<br />
whomever is not able, then with his heart. That is the weakest<br />
of faith.” (Jami` at-Tirmidhi Hadith, 2172)
<strong>December</strong> <strong>2017</strong> <strong>The</strong><br />
<strong>Light</strong> 8<br />
Increased complaints against governments,<br />
failure of civil servants in service delivery, Pakhtun<br />
ethnic and cultural susceptibilities and<br />
peasants class grievances especially in Swat<br />
also contributed to the on-going Jihadist narrative.<br />
However, the most important factor used<br />
by the militants is an upsurge for Islam in the<br />
modern world. <strong>The</strong>se militants effectively manipulated<br />
the reliable religious signs and emblems<br />
(mainly from history) that carry great appeal<br />
to several people who accept it on the<br />
promise of the establishment of a religious society<br />
free from social inequality and every kind of<br />
injustice and on the other a ‘promised’ permanent<br />
happy life in the hereafter. <strong>The</strong>y refer to the<br />
Islamists’ failure of the peaceful political struggle<br />
to bring a change in society, e.g. Algeria in<br />
1991 and Ghaza in 2006, these militants<br />
emphasise on the accuracy of their tools and<br />
methods (militancy) for the establishment of a<br />
‘paradise’ on earth, i.e. Islamic State. <strong>The</strong> argument<br />
proved to be a very important mobilising<br />
factor by the militants and its diffusion among<br />
the apparently peaceful Islamic organisations<br />
such as Tablighi Jamaat and particularly Jamaati-Islami<br />
by the use of modern technology such as<br />
the internet, mobile, social media and video<br />
clips. Looking to the Jihadist ideology, some<br />
scholars substantiate the opinion that Islam is<br />
inherently violent and they brought evidence<br />
from the texts and actions of these militant<br />
Muslims.<br />
<strong>The</strong> greatest target of Jihadist ideology is democracy<br />
and freedom. In the latest video of<br />
Mullah Fazlullah (leader of the Tehrik-i-Taliban<br />
Pakistan) ridicules western life, branding democracy<br />
a lie and forbidden and declared it kufr<br />
and Haram (Mirror news). <strong>The</strong>y do not endorse<br />
the concept of popular sovereignty and consider<br />
it contrary to the supremacy of God. <strong>The</strong><br />
rule of democracy is the rule of disbelief, and<br />
any call to it is a call to kufr system. <strong>The</strong>y are<br />
against all kinds of democracy and uphold the<br />
idea of a universal caliphate. <strong>The</strong>y do not<br />
recognise the territorial demarcation of the<br />
modern state and consider it the legacy of the<br />
European colonialism. <strong>The</strong> ranks and file of<br />
these militants include Chechens, Uzbeks, Arabs<br />
(from Saudi Arabia, UAE, Egypt, Palestine<br />
and African countries), Kashmiris, Chinese, Tajiks,<br />
and Afghanis fought against Pakistani<br />
forces. In the Jihadists’ narrative, freedom is<br />
restricted to the limits demarcated within the<br />
Sharia laws. Freedom in the west is portrayed<br />
with lewdness. Freedom of expression and faith<br />
is selectively allowed. A person who left Islam<br />
is an apostate and thus is liable to be put to<br />
death as stated in the hadith. 10 In many cases<br />
when as accused of blasphemy when attacked<br />
by the mob, the Jihadists implicitly supported<br />
them. <strong>The</strong> women folk were specially targeted<br />
in society. In their dominated areas girls were<br />
not allowed to attend schools and whenever<br />
they were in the position they either closed<br />
those schools or destroyed them. In the Jihadist<br />
narrative, for women, there are only two places;<br />
either home or grave (khaza ya da kur da ya da<br />
gure da).<br />
Basis of the Jihadist Ideology in the Religious<br />
Text<br />
<strong>The</strong> Jihadist narrative in Pakistan and elsewhere<br />
in the world is based on an atomist approach<br />
to the religious texts. According to this<br />
approach, a passage is taken from the Holy<br />
Scripture and is interpreted in the light of tradition<br />
literature and practices of the early companions<br />
of Prophet Muhammad (S). Applying<br />
this method, the Jihadists concluded, for<br />
example, Jews and Christians cannot be your<br />
friends. 11 <strong>The</strong> Holy Prophet instructed to<br />
eliminate all non-believers from the earth. 12<br />
Jihad (war) is obligatory upon Muslims. 13 Those<br />
who leave Islam (apostate) are liable to be<br />
punished by death. 14 Non-Muslims are not<br />
10<br />
"Execute the person who changes his faith." (Bukhari: Kitab<br />
Istatabatul-Murtaddeen)<br />
11<br />
O You who have attained to faith! Do not take the Jews and the<br />
Christians for your allies: they are but allies of one another and<br />
whoever of you allies himself with them becomes, verily, one of<br />
them; behold, God does not guide people who are unjust.<br />
(Quran 5:51)<br />
12<br />
Narrated Ibn ‘Umar: Allah’s Apostle said: "I have been ordered<br />
(by Allah) to fight against the people until they testify that none<br />
has the right to be worshipped but Allah and that Muhammad is<br />
Allah’s Apostle, and offer the prayers perfectly and give the obligatory<br />
charity, so if they perform all that, then they save their<br />
lives and property from me except for Islamic laws, and then their<br />
reckoning (accounts) will be done by Allah." ( Sahih Bukhari 25, 26)<br />
I Shall Love All Mankind.<br />
13<br />
“And slay them wherever ye catch them, and turn them out<br />
from where they have Turned you out; for tumult and oppression<br />
are worse than slaughter; but fight them not at the Sacred<br />
Mosque, unless they (first) fight you there; but if they fight you,<br />
slay them. Such is the reward of those who suppress faith (Quran,<br />
2-191)”<br />
14<br />
“Those who leave their faith kill them” reported by Abdullah<br />
bin Abbas in Sahih Bukhari. <strong>The</strong> militant in Pakistan declared<br />
Muslims of the Pakistan military as apostate and therefore<br />
fighting against them and killing them is lawful (Ahya-i-Khilafat<br />
organ of the Tehrik-i-Taliban Pakistan, November 2014, p.16)<br />
https://ia601405.us.archive.org/21/items/IhyaeKhilafatUrduMagazine9/Ihyae%20Khilafat%20Urdu%20Magazine%209.pdf<br />
visited September 6, 2015.
<strong>December</strong> <strong>2017</strong> <strong>The</strong><br />
<strong>Light</strong> 9<br />
equal citizens; they should wear an emblem to<br />
show that they are zimis. 15 Women are half of<br />
the men. 16 If a married couple committed<br />
adultery, they would receive the punishment of<br />
rajam (put to death by stoning (‘Almi Idara-i-<br />
Fikr-i-Islami, 1997)). It is the responsibility of<br />
each Muslim to uphold good and suppress evil<br />
in the society even if it requires the use of force<br />
(June 28, 2015). Interpretation of the texts disjointedly<br />
always led to conclusions which suit<br />
the Jihadists narrative. Though the Jihadist narrative<br />
dominated the present religious<br />
discourse, there was, and there is always a divergent<br />
opinion on all these self-claimed ‘settled<br />
<strong>issue</strong>s’ in Islam. 17<br />
Ghamidi’s Counter-Narrative or Ideology<br />
Javed Ahmad Ghamidi (b. 1951) is one of<br />
the religious scholars who challenge the Jihadist<br />
narrative persistently in the last 25 years and<br />
suffered in the hands of militants. <strong>The</strong> militants<br />
have targeted his house in Lahore but before the<br />
detonator went off the culprits were arrested.<br />
<strong>The</strong> militants brutally murdered one of his very<br />
close associates, Dr Farooq Khan, who was also<br />
vice chancellor of the newly established Swat<br />
University and a very multifaceted personality<br />
in October 2010. 18 <strong>The</strong> second editor of his<br />
monthly Ishraq, Mr Manzoor ul Hassan, was shot<br />
outside of the office Al-Mawrid in Lahore, but he<br />
survived the injuries. Another associate, Dr<br />
Habib ur Rahman, was shot dead in Karachi.<br />
Some of his associates, for example, Dr Khalid<br />
Zaheer, was threatened and had to leave the<br />
country for some time. His students and associates<br />
in Pakistan are going through the same<br />
19<br />
Hamiddudin Farahi was important religious scholar born in<br />
1863 in Pariha (UP), India. His stay in Aligarh College as a student,<br />
and Sind Madrasa, Karachi and Allahabad University as faculty<br />
member exposed him to the modern education and the orientalscared<br />
situation. Ghamidi himself despite his<br />
reluctance was persuaded by his colleagues and<br />
associates to leave the country, and until this<br />
time he is residing in Malaysia. In such a dangerous<br />
situation Ghamidi did not stop his work<br />
and continued to challenge the Jihadist ideology<br />
on their religious bases.<br />
Some Muslim groups have also encountered<br />
jihadist ideology in Pakistan like the Berailvis,<br />
and other non-religious political and non-political<br />
groups on their ideological orientation are<br />
having little relevance to sources of religion.<br />
Ghamidi’s case is different because he encounters<br />
them in the religious precepts which the<br />
militants produce in their support. Ghamidi inferred<br />
differently from the same sources with<br />
apparently convincing arguments and thus left<br />
little space for the exclusivist ideology of the Jihadists.<br />
Ghamidi’s counter-narrative is humane,<br />
pluralistic and all-inclusive. Ghamidi’s discourse<br />
is revolving around the principles of understanding<br />
of religion from its scriptures primarily<br />
based on the Farah-Islahi hermeneutics.<br />
Hamiddudin Farahi (1863-1930) 19 , an exegete<br />
of the first quarter of the 20 th century, educated<br />
in religious discipline from the ulama of that<br />
time 20 and modern education from Aligarh college,<br />
the prime modern educational institution<br />
of the Muslims of South Asia, who later on also<br />
became a teacher in the Allahabad University<br />
and Sind Madrast ul Islam.<br />
He propounded a new school among the<br />
Muslims emphasising upon adopting a coherent<br />
approach to the Holy Quran, very rarely referred<br />
in the past (Ahsan, 1993). His student,<br />
Amin Ahsan Islahi 21 forwarded the concept into<br />
15<br />
Obeying this opinion Taliban during their rule in Kabul asked the<br />
non-Muslims to wear distinctive dress to be distinguished from<br />
the Muslims in public places.<br />
16<br />
As stated in the Quran, “Men are in charge of women by [right<br />
of] what Allah has given one over the other and what they spend<br />
[for maintenance] from their wealth” (4-34) and that their testimony<br />
is half of men, “And call to witness two men from among<br />
you. If two men are not available, then one man and two women<br />
whose testimony is acceptable to all-if one of them fails to remember,<br />
the other would remind her (2-282)<br />
17<br />
In Muslim history there always existed non-popular views and<br />
so Ghamidi is not an exception.<br />
18<br />
<strong>The</strong> responsibility was accepted by Al Azam Brigade, a group<br />
of the Tehrik-i-Taliban Pakistan.<br />
I Shall Love All Mankind.<br />
ists’ scholarship and scepticism about Islam. He thus concentrated<br />
his research on the holy Quran and recorded his findings<br />
in books (mostly unfinished) in Arabic except one which is in<br />
Urdu. He closely worked in the establishment of Usmania University,<br />
Hyderabad and Dar ul Mussanifin, Luknow. In his last days<br />
he devoted all his time in teaching Quran in the Madrsat ul Islah<br />
in Sarai Mir. He breathed his last in 1930 (See for more details,<br />
Dr. Sharfuddin Islahi, Zikr-i-Farahi (Lahore: Dar ul Tazkir, 2002).<br />
20<br />
For example, he studied religious disciplines from Mawlana Faiz<br />
ul Hassan Seharanpuri and Mawlana Shibli Numani who was also<br />
his cousin.<br />
21<br />
Amin Ahsan Islahi (1904-97) for an interval joined Jamaat-i-Islami<br />
and emerged as the second important ideologue after Abdul<br />
Ala Mawdudi (1903-79) but he had to quit after having differences<br />
with Mawlana Mawdudi. Certain views of Islahi have been<br />
incorporated in the state structure for example the status of non-<br />
Muslims and thus got free Pakistan from the narrow approach on<br />
the <strong>issue</strong> of the traditionalist ulama in Pakistan. During Zia ul Haq<br />
period (1979-88) when an adultery case was decided in the light<br />
of Islahi’s views, the traditionalists raised hue and cry throughout
<strong>December</strong> <strong>2017</strong> <strong>The</strong><br />
<strong>Light</strong> 10<br />
Taking up of arms against the non-<br />
Muslims to convert them to Islam is<br />
forbidden; an armed struggle for<br />
bringing change in state and society<br />
is creating disorder particularly<br />
after the coming of democracy.<br />
a whole system and completed his nine-volume<br />
exegesis, Tadabbur-i-Quran on the same principles.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Farahi-Islahi religious thought was<br />
moved forward and reinvigorated by Javed Ahmad<br />
Ghamidi when he applied these principles<br />
to the contemporary socio-political and economic<br />
<strong>issue</strong>s of the Muslims and thus deter the<br />
traditionalist approach to religion demonstrated<br />
in the shape of militancy in Pakistan.<br />
According to Farahi-Islahi principles of understanding<br />
the Holy Quran, the concept of<br />
Nazm (coherence) is the fundamental principle.<br />
According to Islahi to understand Quran the following<br />
principles which are of two kinds must<br />
be followed: i. internal and ii. external. In the<br />
internal principles, he included the language of<br />
the Quran, Nazm (coherence) and tafsir-i-Quran<br />
bil Quran (clarification with the help of the<br />
Quran). While the external principles include;<br />
Sunnat-i-mutawatirah (constant practices of the<br />
Holy Prophet), hadith and athar-I Sahaba, shani-nazul,<br />
previous exegeses, previous Holy<br />
Scriptures and Arab history (Islahi, Tadabbur-i-<br />
Qur’an). Ghamidi adopted and followed Farahi<br />
and Islahi in interpreting the text of the Quran<br />
and other religious precepts and thus reached<br />
to certain conclusions mostly contradictory to<br />
the Jihadist interpretation of the Quranic verses.<br />
Another distinctive and important point of<br />
deviation of Ghamidi is the law of Itmam-i-Hujjat<br />
(finality of testimony). Ghamidi extensively<br />
applies the law originally derived by Islahi in<br />
the socio-political realm of affairs and thus lead<br />
not only to different but in some cases even opposite<br />
to the common understanding of religion.<br />
According to this law, God sent among His<br />
prophets (anbia) a particular section, rasul<br />
(apostle) who were not only messengers of God<br />
but also a testimony to bestow the wrath of God<br />
upon those who reject the message of God willingly.<br />
<strong>The</strong>refore, the tenents of the rasul cannot<br />
be extended to the non rasul period in human<br />
history. Prophet Muhammad was a rasul, and<br />
thus many of his actions are confined to his lifetime<br />
only. <strong>The</strong> specification of the addressee in<br />
the Holy Quran thus drastically changes the<br />
meaning of a verse in the Quran.<br />
Applying the principle of coherence in<br />
Quran (nazm-i-Quran) and the law of finality of<br />
testimony (itmam-i-Hujjat), Ghamidi’s stance<br />
can be narrated like this. Taking up of arms<br />
against the non-Muslims to convert them to<br />
Islam is forbidden (Ghamdi, Videos); an armed<br />
struggle for bringing change in state and society<br />
is declared Fasad fil Ardh (creating disorder on<br />
earth) particularly after the coming of<br />
democracy. Jihad cannot be done by private<br />
militant groups, and Jihad is the duty of the<br />
state and can be waged only if there is persecution<br />
(particularly religious) of people whether<br />
they are Muslims or non-Muslims. 22 <strong>The</strong>re is no<br />
compulsion in religion, and thus death for the<br />
apostate was confined only to the time of<br />
Prophet Muhammad (S) (Renaissance). Islam<br />
and state was declared separate. It is individual<br />
who is the addressee of Islam and not state. It is<br />
individual who will be accountable before God.<br />
Ghamidi declared that the modern state is having<br />
no religion (Ghamidi, Jang 2015) and thus<br />
the non-Muslims should have an equal footing<br />
while deciding the nature of a state. However,<br />
the decision of any government in ordinary<br />
matters should be carried out on the principle<br />
of majority (Ghamidi, Jang 2015). <strong>The</strong> role of religious<br />
scholars in society is very much deviated<br />
what God has inscribed for them in Quran. 23<br />
Conclusion<br />
Javid Ahmad Ghamidi is among those few<br />
religious scholars in Pakistan who tried to disentangle<br />
the domain of profane life from the religious<br />
life and thus confront the Jihadist who<br />
tries to intermingle religion with the worldly<br />
matters and raise hue and cry as ‘Islam is in<br />
danger’. He in his discourse challenged the plea<br />
of the Jihadist in the very context of religion, i.e.<br />
Quran and Sunnah. His ideas greatly appealed<br />
the country and the then regime had to change the very organization<br />
of the court, induct new judges and accept the traditionalists<br />
understanding of religion.<br />
22<br />
<strong>The</strong> holy jihad can be conducted against the Muslims also if<br />
they are persecuting non-Muslims.<br />
I Shall Love All Mankind.<br />
23<br />
<strong>The</strong> main function of the ulama is Inzar i.e. reminding and<br />
warning to the ruling and non-ruling elite as it is stated in the holy<br />
Quran, “And it is not for the believers to go forth [to battle] all at<br />
once. For there should separate from every division of them a<br />
group [remaining] to obtain understanding in the religion and<br />
warn their people when they return to them that they might be<br />
cautious” (9: 122).
<strong>December</strong> <strong>2017</strong> <strong>The</strong><br />
<strong>Light</strong> 11<br />
to the modern educated<br />
minds of Pakistan to see<br />
Islam, not as a religion of<br />
violence and terror but a<br />
peaceful religion for the<br />
entire humanity. He also<br />
raised his voice against<br />
the marginalized classes<br />
in society such as women<br />
and non-Muslims, something<br />
very rare from a<br />
Muslim religious scholar.<br />
Because of his ‘innovative’ ideas he and his associates<br />
faced irritation of the religious people<br />
which resulted even in an attempt on his life<br />
and his associates in Lahore, Karachi and Mardan.<br />
However, this did not help to silence his<br />
voice. <strong>The</strong> alternative religious narrative of Ghamidi<br />
may provide such a ground to all those elements<br />
who wants to end the conflict having its<br />
roots in religion. <strong>The</strong> current Muslim religious<br />
scholarship and Pakistan’s policy makers need<br />
to give attention to this counter narrative<br />
against the popular Jihadist narrative in Pakistan.<br />
However, the acceptance of Ghamidi’s<br />
counter narrative depends on many socio-political<br />
and international factors as well. <strong>The</strong> geostrategic<br />
dimension of the conflict in the region<br />
is subsiding to a great extent the alternative<br />
narrative in Pakistan.<br />
(Return To Contents)<br />
How did the Muslim world<br />
fall behind on science –<br />
and how can it thrive again?<br />
Debate comes as research and development<br />
spending rises in Gulf states<br />
By Daniel Bardsley<br />
It is a question that has long vexed researchers<br />
from this region: why did the Muslim world,<br />
which once led the way in science, fall behind?<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>issue</strong> is as pertinent now as ever, with the<br />
Middle East still lagging behind the global average<br />
when it comes to spending on research and<br />
development and concerns continuing over a<br />
regional “brain drain”.<br />
To look for answers, earlier this year a task<br />
force on “Culture of Science in the Muslim<br />
World” was set up, bringing together nearly a<br />
“Baghdad was among the epicentres<br />
of these activities and the famous<br />
Bayt Al Hikma [House of<br />
Wisdom, a library] was the Mecca<br />
of scientific research and where<br />
all the scientists from all over the<br />
world and all faiths came to study<br />
and contribute to that enlightenment.”<br />
I Shall Love All Mankind.<br />
dozen Muslim scholars,<br />
several of them scientists,<br />
based in countries<br />
including the UAE, Pakistan,<br />
Malaysia, Lebanon<br />
and Australia. <strong>The</strong> task<br />
force met to discuss its<br />
findings at the World<br />
Science Forum, held recently<br />
at the Dead Sea in<br />
Jordan.<br />
A key area of interest is why the innovation<br />
of the Islamic Golden Age, which ran from about<br />
the eighth to the 13th centuries, was not carried<br />
through until later periods.<br />
“I think the Golden Age started in the seventh<br />
century or the beginning of the eighth century<br />
and it was energised by our theologians<br />
taking the Greek philosophy, the rationalist philosophy<br />
as a means to work out quarrels they<br />
were having about the divine text, the Quran,”<br />
said Professor Jelel Ezzine, a professor of systems<br />
theory and control at the University of Tunis<br />
El Manar in Tunisia and one of the task<br />
force’s members. “Baghdad was among the epicentres<br />
of these activities and the famous Bayt<br />
Al Hikma [House of Wisdom, a library] was the<br />
Mecca of scientific research and where all the<br />
scientists from all over the world and all faiths<br />
came to study and contribute to that enlightenment.”<br />
Prof Ezzine feels that scientists are particularly<br />
suited to coming up with answers about<br />
what happened because they have “some understanding<br />
of science and the practice of science”.<br />
<strong>The</strong>y can cast “a neutral look”.<br />
“One has to have a reasonable methodology,<br />
be as objective as possible, leaving biases as far<br />
as possible, and limit ones analysis to key<br />
events that we call bifurcation points or events<br />
that might look at the time insignificant, but can<br />
really help to facilitate the emergence of large<br />
dynamics,” he said.<br />
Such large dynamics could have had consequences<br />
that last until the present day. Globally,<br />
spending on research and development averaged<br />
2.23 per cent of GDP in 2015, according to
<strong>December</strong> <strong>2017</strong> <strong>The</strong><br />
<strong>Light</strong> 12<br />
World Bank figures, but in most of the Middle<br />
East, it is far lower.<br />
In the UAE, for example, the figure in 2015<br />
was 0.87 per cent of GDP, while in Saudi Arabia,<br />
it was 0.82 per cent in 2013, the most recent<br />
year for which data is published. In Kuwait,<br />
2013’s figure was just 0.30 per cent, while<br />
Oman recorded 0.25 per cent in 2015.<br />
Many other Arab countries, especially those<br />
in turmoil because of conflict, have much lower<br />
R&D spending. However, investments in R&D in<br />
the Arab world are increasing, with the UAE’s<br />
2015 figure almost double that of four years<br />
earlier, while in Saudi Arabia there was a 10-<br />
fold increase in research and development<br />
spending between 2003 and 2013. Spending<br />
worldwide has increased much more modestly,<br />
from 1.97 per cent of GDP in 2015 to 2.23 per<br />
cent in 2015.<br />
When it comes to understanding why the<br />
Muslim world fell behind at the end of the Islamic<br />
Golden Age, Prof Ezzine says that three<br />
factors should be considered. He describes<br />
them as “the rulers, the religious and the rationalists”,<br />
which equates to religion, politics and<br />
science. Understanding how those in power regarded<br />
science helps to explain trends.<br />
Among the key historical figures is Al Ghazali,<br />
a Persian philosopher born in the 11th century.<br />
“He refused the existence of cause and effect<br />
outside the divine will,” said Prof Ezzine,<br />
who shares the view of many observers that Al<br />
Ghazali limited scientific progress in the Islamic<br />
world.<br />
Although the Marrakesh-born 12th-century<br />
polymath Averroes forcefully took a different<br />
view in his writings, defending the philosophy<br />
of the likes of Aristotle against attacks by Al<br />
Ghazali, Prof Ezzine feels that the course had<br />
been set. “It was extremely difficult to rebound<br />
I Shall Love All Mankind.<br />
from Al Ghazali’s spell,” he said. It was, he says,<br />
“the interaction between the church, the scientists<br />
and the politicians” that enabled the West<br />
to pull ahead after a long period of trailing the<br />
Muslim world.<br />
While researchers will continue to have different<br />
interpretations of why the Islamic<br />
world’s pre-eminence in science was lost, Prof<br />
Ezzine is clear that the achievements of the Islamic<br />
Golden Age are often inadequately recognised.<br />
He cites Ibn Khaldun, an Arab intellectual<br />
born in Tunis in 1332 whose writings covered<br />
many subjects. Prof Ezzine says that much of<br />
what was written by Adam Smith, the Scottish<br />
author of the highly influential <strong>The</strong> Wealth of<br />
Nations, was influenced by Ibn Khaldun.<br />
“<strong>The</strong> western world took a lot from that period,”<br />
he said. “He came at the end of the Golden<br />
Age, but he’s also a modern man. He came at the<br />
junction between the end of the Golden Age and<br />
the beginning of the modern age, so he’s a great<br />
witness to this metamorphosis, a must to read.”<br />
Prof Ezzine says that new areas of science<br />
can offer insights into historical events and<br />
could encourage better outcomes in the modern<br />
world.<br />
“It’s a very, very wide problem and there’s a<br />
need to do something much deeper … [to] analyse<br />
things in an objective scientific manner using<br />
the new sciences of psycho-cognition, complex<br />
dynamic systems and other new fields to<br />
[develop] more relevant conclusions,” said Prof<br />
Ezzine.<br />
“<strong>The</strong> objective is to reignite the practice of<br />
science in the Muslim world for the benefit of<br />
Muslims and the rest of the world and for peace<br />
on Earth.” (Return_to content)<br />
Ahmadiyya Anjuman Isha‘at Islam Lahore (UK)<br />
Founders of the first Islamic Mission in the UK, established 1913 as the Woking Muslim Mission.<br />
Dar-us-Salaam, 15 Stanley Avenue, Wembley, UK, HA0 4JQ<br />
Centre: 020 8903 2689 ∙ President: 01793 740670 ∙ Secretary: 07737 240777 ∙ Treasurer: 01932 348283<br />
E-mail: info@aaiil.uk<br />
Thank you for helping us improve<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Light</strong>.<br />
Websites: www.aaiil.org/uk | www.ahmadiyya.org | www.virtualmosque.co.uk<br />
Donations: https://www.cafonline.org/charityprofile/aaiiluk