Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
6 M a r c h 1 ' 1 8 h a N N A / C o r o n a t i o n / S t e t t l e r , A b . E C A r e v i e w<br />
<br />
Guest editorial<br />
Canada is facing<br />
a crisis of quality<br />
journalism<br />
V I E W P O I N T S<br />
The opinions expressed are not necessarily<br />
the opinions of this newspaper.<br />
by John Honderich<br />
“We should all be very concerned by<br />
the crisis facing quality journalism.”<br />
The Trudeau government has either<br />
ignored or rejected virtually all the<br />
recommendations proposed to help<br />
support newspapers. What particularly<br />
stings is that the vast majority<br />
would not cost taxpayers anything.<br />
Reporters are being laid off in<br />
droves, many smaller communities<br />
are now “news deserts” with no local<br />
newspaper, and the amount of serious<br />
investigative journalism is declining<br />
sharply.<br />
And if you believe, as I do, that a vigorous,<br />
investigative press is essential<br />
for a strong democracy, we should all<br />
be very concerned.<br />
“<br />
Ottawa’s advertising<br />
strategy had resulted in a<br />
“misalignment” of the<br />
reality that many<br />
Canadians still rely on<br />
traditional media.<br />
At the beginning of its mandate, the<br />
Trudeau government seemed to share<br />
that concern. It commissioned the<br />
Public Policy Forum, under the direction<br />
of veteran editor and journalist Ed<br />
Greenspon, to study the issue.<br />
The final report, entitled “The<br />
Shattered Mirror,” was released a year<br />
ago. It outlined in vivid detail the crisis<br />
and put forward 12 core<br />
recommendations.<br />
The government also commissioned<br />
the Commons committee on Canadian<br />
Heritage, under Vancouver MP and<br />
former journalist Hedy Fry, to conduct<br />
a parallel investigation. After months<br />
of hearings and dozens of witnesses, it<br />
came up with 20 practical<br />
recommendations.<br />
Now that the Trudeau government is<br />
more than halfway through its mandate,<br />
what has been its response?<br />
My view? Studied indifference.<br />
Across the board, the Trudeau government<br />
has either ignored or rejected<br />
virtually all the recommendations.<br />
What particularly stings is that the<br />
vast majority would not cost taxpayers<br />
anything.<br />
To make matters worse, in<br />
announcing her government’s decisions,<br />
Heritage Minister Mélanie Joly<br />
emphasized her government wasn’t<br />
R<br />
R<br />
R<br />
R<br />
R<br />
Published by<br />
Coronation<br />
Review<br />
Limited<br />
interested in bailing out “industry<br />
models that are no longer viable.”<br />
Left starkly unclear was where<br />
quality journalism would then originate.<br />
And newspaper executives,<br />
myself included, were left asking: if<br />
this is what the Trudeau government<br />
really thinks, then why did we go<br />
through this lengthy process?<br />
To illustrate the point, let me chronicle<br />
the fate of 10 recommendations:<br />
1. Copyright protection for newspapers:<br />
Under Canadian copyright law,<br />
original content from Canadian newspapers<br />
can be easily duplicated and<br />
distributed on the internet for free.<br />
This has become a real annoyance,<br />
particularly when aggregators, bloggers<br />
or others use original material<br />
without permission or fee.<br />
The Public Policy Forum recommended<br />
Ottawa amend the law to help<br />
newspapers protect their content “for a<br />
reasonable time.” Newspapers, understandably,<br />
have also argued they<br />
should be paid for their content.<br />
The result? Nothing to date.<br />
2. Facebook and Google: These two<br />
multinational giants now control more<br />
than 70 per cent of all digital advertising<br />
in Canada. Yet the playing field<br />
is patently unfair for Canadian media.<br />
Under Canadian tax law, companies<br />
can deduct the cost of advertising only<br />
if ads are placed in Canadian publications.<br />
Yet this law does not apply to the<br />
internet.<br />
So not only do Facebook and Google<br />
not pay corporate tax or GST/HST,<br />
b<strong>eca</strong>use they are headquartered outside<br />
Canada, but they accept ads on the<br />
same basis as Canadian media.<br />
The list of countries that have<br />
sought to address similar concerns is<br />
impressive: New Zealand, Norway,<br />
South Korea, Japan, Switzerland,<br />
South Africa and Israel, as well as the<br />
European Union. Last month<br />
Australia launched its own<br />
investigation.<br />
Both the Public Policy Forum and<br />
many media groups have asked<br />
Ottawa to do the same.<br />
The result? Nothing to date.<br />
3. Federal government advertising:<br />
For the past several years, Ottawa has<br />
followed a “digital-first” strategy in<br />
placement of federal ads.<br />
That, in turn, has led to a reduction<br />
in the proportion of federal spending<br />
for daily newspaper ads by 96 per cent<br />
and for community newspaper ads by<br />
21 per cent. These figures, importantly,<br />
come directly from the Department of<br />
Canadian Heritage.<br />
Turn to Democracy, Pg 7<br />
“<br />
72 pt<br />
East Central Alberta<br />
EVIEW<br />
60 pt<br />
48 pt<br />
36 pt<br />
LETTERS POLICY • Letters to the Editor are<br />
welcomed • Must be signed and a phone<br />
number included so the writer’s identity can be<br />
verified. • ECA Review reserves the right to edit<br />
letters for legal considerations, taste and brevity.<br />
Letters and columns submitted are not<br />
necessarily the opinion of this newspaper.<br />
Member of:<br />
Office Hours Mon. - Fri. 9 am - 5 pm<br />
R<br />
30 pt<br />
Subscriptions:<br />
4921 - Victoria Avenue<br />
$42.00 in Canada; $74.20 in US;<br />
Tel. (4<strong>03</strong>) 578-4111<br />
R<br />
24 pt<br />
$135.15 Overseas. (All prices include GST) Mail: Box 70, Coronation, AB Canada, T0C 1C0 Website ECA<strong>review</strong>.com<br />
<br />
Disaster zone in<br />
short order<br />
by Herman Schwenk<br />
In the mid sixties when John<br />
Diefenbaker was the Prime Minister of<br />
Canada, a book was written about him.<br />
This book, “ A Renegade in Power”<br />
was very critical of Diefenbaker.<br />
He was a very domineering and<br />
forceful leader. He was a person who<br />
could not be intimidated. If he decided<br />
on a course of action that was what<br />
was done even if it was a wrong<br />
decision.<br />
During his reign as leader of the<br />
conservative party there was considerable<br />
conflict. The cancelation of the<br />
Avro Arrow was a high profile<br />
example of conflict in the party.<br />
I got thinking about that book this<br />
past week when I was reading about<br />
our current Prime Ministers latest<br />
shenanigans.<br />
Most of the mainstream media still<br />
seem to regard Justin Trudeau as<br />
their poster boy. He has such a nice<br />
gregarious personality. What is there<br />
to not like about him?<br />
They seem not to take notice of the<br />
non-sensical stuff that comes out of his<br />
mouth both now and before he b<strong>eca</strong>me<br />
the Prime Minister.<br />
His unrealistic political correctness<br />
really came to the forefront a couple<br />
weeks ago when he attempted to correct<br />
a woman at a town hall who used<br />
the term mankind when asking him a<br />
question.<br />
He said that she should have said<br />
“peoplekind, b<strong>eca</strong>use it is more inclusive<br />
than mankind.”<br />
That exchange went viral all over<br />
the world, and the responses have not<br />
PrairieView<br />
Alberta Press Council<br />
Do you have a concern or<br />
complaint about a<br />
newspaper article or ad?<br />
If after bringing your<br />
concerns to the attention of<br />
this newspaper, you are not<br />
satisfied, you may contact<br />
the Alberta Press Council at<br />
www.albertapresscouncil.ca<br />
or toll free in Alberta at<br />
1-888-580-4104 for<br />
information.<br />
been kind to Trudeau. He is basically a<br />
laughing stock the world over, as he<br />
should be.<br />
Can you imagine the response of the<br />
media if Andrew Scheer were to utter<br />
something that stupid?<br />
The above example is only one of the<br />
many gaffes recently committed by<br />
Trudeau.<br />
“<br />
You may r<strong>eca</strong>ll a couple of his other<br />
gaffs from before he b<strong>eca</strong>me Prime<br />
Minister, his statement that the budget<br />
would balance itself and his comment<br />
about how he liked China’s basic dictatorship<br />
b<strong>eca</strong>use they could make<br />
decisions much faster than we could.<br />
A recent gaffe had to do with the<br />
returning ISIS fighters. He compared<br />
them to Italian families settling in<br />
Montreal after the Second World War<br />
and how they were discriminated<br />
against due to their dress and religion.<br />
Turn to Trudeau’s, Pg 7<br />
Joyce Webster<br />
Publisher/Editor<br />
publisher@ECA<strong>review</strong>.com<br />
There are many<br />
countries in the world<br />
today with dictators who<br />
are just as clueless as he<br />
[Trudeau] is. Each one of<br />
those countries is a<br />
disaster zone.<br />
YvoNNe Thulien<br />
Manager<br />
office@ECA<strong>review</strong>.com<br />
Gayle Jaraway<br />
Marketing 4<strong>03</strong>-578-4111<br />
advertise@ECA<strong>review</strong>.com<br />
BoNNy WilliaMS<br />
Circulation Manager<br />
Lisa Myers-sortland<br />
Graphic Artist<br />
LISA Joy<br />
Marketing/Reporter 4<strong>03</strong>-307-3398<br />
contact@ECA<strong>review</strong>.com<br />
“<br />
R<br />
18 pt