BusinessDay 16 Apr 2018
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
NEWS YOU CAN TRUST I **MONDAY <strong>16</strong> APRIL <strong>2018</strong> I VOL. 15, NO 33 I N300 @ g<br />
Cement makers’ profits drop to<br />
5-year low as tax credits expire<br />
BALA AUGIE<br />
A<br />
curious thing is happening<br />
to Nigerian<br />
Cement makers.<br />
While revenues<br />
are surging, profits<br />
are dropping, signalling falling<br />
margins and higher tax<br />
expenses.<br />
The firms analysed by <strong>BusinessDay</strong><br />
are Dangote Cement<br />
Plc, Cement Company of Northern<br />
Nigeria (CCNN) Plc and<br />
Lafarge Africa Plc, which control<br />
about 90 percent of the Nigerian<br />
cement market.<br />
Cement maker’s revenues<br />
surged to a five year high in 2017,<br />
however profits (net income)<br />
are down from the highs of 2013<br />
largely as a result of a dominant<br />
player in the sector (Lafarge<br />
Africa) recording a loss, and<br />
expiration of pioneer tax credits.<br />
Lafarge Africa profits were<br />
juiced in 20<strong>16</strong> by an income tax<br />
credit of N39.7 billion, while<br />
Dangote Cement received tax<br />
credits of N5.69 billion the same<br />
year (20<strong>16</strong>) and N10.43 billion in<br />
tax credits for 2013.<br />
The cumulative combined<br />
sales of the three largest producers<br />
of the building material hit<br />
N1.12 trillion in December 2017<br />
as against N607.56 billion recorded<br />
in 2013 as they leveraged<br />
a hike in the price of products and<br />
Nigeria’s infrastructure deficit.<br />
However, combined profits<br />
for the firms fell to an all-time<br />
low of N172.87 billion as at<br />
December 2017 from a profit of<br />
N263.71 billion recorded in 2013.<br />
Combined profits for the 3<br />
firms was N196.08 billion in<br />
2014, N209.52 billion in 2015 and<br />
N204.77 billion in 20<strong>16</strong>.<br />
Investors and shareholders<br />
will be bemused at industry<br />
performance in spite of the fact<br />
that the market is largely an<br />
oligopoly.<br />
Dangote Cement with a mar-<br />
Continues on page 4<br />
L-R Adaora Umeoji, deputy managing director; Peter Amangbo, GMD/CEO; Jim Ovia, chairman, and Ebenezer Onyeagwu, deputy managing<br />
director, all of Zenith Bank plc, at the 27th annual general meeting of the bank in Abuja, at the weekend.<br />
Adeosun reassigns<br />
portfolios in SEC,<br />
Mary Uduk takes<br />
over as acting DG<br />
... demands explanation from<br />
SEC on communications with<br />
NSE on Oando<br />
ONYINYE NWACHUKWU, Abuja<br />
The Minister of Finance,<br />
Kemi Adeosun, on Friday<br />
approved the reassignment<br />
of portfolios in the Securities and<br />
Exchange Commission (SEC).<br />
Mary Uduk will assume the<br />
Continues on page 46<br />
Lagos-Badagry 2019<br />
rail completion<br />
doubtful as hoodlums<br />
take over tracks<br />
MIKE OCHONMA<br />
There are very strong indications<br />
that the 2019<br />
delivery timeline for the<br />
on-going road expansion that<br />
provides for the rail mass transit<br />
Continues on page 46<br />
Inside<br />
I&E window success snaps<br />
Nigeria’s dependence on<br />
CBN dollar supply P. A2
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
2 BUSINESS DAY
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
BUSINESS DAY<br />
3
4 BUSINESS DAY<br />
C002D5556<br />
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
Commodities<br />
Brent Oil<br />
$70.61<br />
Cocoa<br />
US $2,524.00<br />
NSE<br />
Biggest Gainer Biggest Loser<br />
Seplat<br />
Intbrew<br />
N698.3 4.99pc N50 -6.80pc<br />
40,928.70<br />
businessday market monitor<br />
Bitcoin<br />
Everdon Bureau De Change<br />
2,827,022.17 +8.81pc<br />
Powered by<br />
$-N<br />
£-N<br />
€-N<br />
BUY SELL<br />
360.00 363.00<br />
501.00 511.00<br />
435.50 445.00<br />
FOREIGN EXCHANGE TREASURY BILLS<br />
Market Spot $/N 3M 6M<br />
I&E FX Window 360.32 0.00 -0.01<br />
CBN Official Rate 305.55 13.18 14.31<br />
FMDQ Close<br />
5 Years<br />
-0.27%<br />
13.24%<br />
FGN BONDS<br />
10 Years<br />
-0.10%<br />
13.51%<br />
20 Years<br />
-0.18%<br />
13.34%<br />
Azura IPP deploys 450mw full capacity to national grid<br />
... as generation loss hits 1940mw<br />
OLUSOLA BELLO<br />
The country’s yearning<br />
for improved electricity<br />
generation<br />
inched closer to reality<br />
at the weekend<br />
as Azura Independent Power<br />
project (IPP) successfully deployed<br />
all it three turbines with<br />
combined generating capacities<br />
of 450 megawatts on the national<br />
grid.<br />
This is expected to improve<br />
power generation a great deal<br />
and subsequently impact positively<br />
on electricity supply generally<br />
across the country.<br />
This happened a day after the<br />
power sector suffered partial<br />
system collapsed and a severe<br />
generation drop by 606 megawatts<br />
hour (MWh/h) leading<br />
to all the generating stations<br />
sending out on the average<br />
3,370602MWh/hour last week<br />
Thursday.<br />
There was nothing to suggest<br />
that the situation was much better<br />
on Friday even after Azura<br />
had deployed its 450 mw to the<br />
national grid, as power supply<br />
to Lagos and its environs has<br />
been poor in the last few days.<br />
According to a presidency<br />
source 1325.5MW was not generated<br />
due to unavailability of<br />
gas while lack of transmission<br />
infrastructure was responsible<br />
for 40MW not generated.<br />
Another 485MW was not<br />
generated due to high frequency<br />
resulting from unavailability<br />
of distribution infrastructure<br />
just as reduced water level at<br />
the hydro at power stations<br />
also caused the loss of 190 MW,<br />
thereby indicating that there is<br />
a shortfall of 1940mw in generation.<br />
On the whole the power<br />
sector lost an estimated<br />
N979,000,000 on <strong>Apr</strong>il 12, <strong>2018</strong><br />
due to insufficient gas supply,<br />
distribution and transmission<br />
infrastructure as well as water<br />
reserves.<br />
The Federal Government<br />
through the Nigerian Bulk Electricity<br />
Trading Plc (NBET) recently<br />
paid Azura Power the<br />
sum of N8m being twelve percent<br />
of about N66 million for<br />
test power sent to the national<br />
grid in January, sources with<br />
knowledge about the transaction<br />
told <strong>BusinessDay</strong>.<br />
Meanwhile, Nigeria’s other<br />
generating companies (Gen-<br />
Cos) will today hear judgement<br />
on a suit they filed against the<br />
Federal Government for prioritising<br />
settlement of its commitment<br />
to Azura Power in the<br />
N701billion power guarantee<br />
instituted to assuage DisCos<br />
failure to settle market invoices.<br />
The rest of the GenCos have<br />
received settlement up till October<br />
2017 and since then their<br />
invoices have remained unsettled<br />
according to Joy Ogaji,<br />
the executive secretary of Association<br />
of Power Generation<br />
Companies (APGN).<br />
“The situation remains the<br />
same, we still have not received<br />
payment for our invoices since<br />
October last year,” she told <strong>BusinessDay</strong><br />
by phone.<br />
Ogaji said that the legacy<br />
power plants which have<br />
the capacity to generate over<br />
7,000MW of electricity were denied<br />
a sovereign risk guarantee<br />
only for the Federal Government<br />
to give Azura the same<br />
guarantee including a partial<br />
risk guarantee from the World<br />
Bank even when it has capacity<br />
to generate only 450MW.<br />
But Jubril Kareem, energy<br />
analyst at EcoBank does not<br />
agree with this view.<br />
“Part of the reason the Azura<br />
project was able to get funding<br />
and construction started was<br />
because the government committed<br />
to it and it has a very<br />
solid power purchase agreement<br />
based on the realities on<br />
ground.<br />
“Nigeria is one of the most<br />
expensive places to generate<br />
power and if they are being<br />
paid according to the terms of<br />
the power purchase agreement,<br />
there is nothing wrong with that.<br />
Kareem further said, “The<br />
agreement with Azura was so<br />
tight that if government defaulted<br />
on payment it has serious<br />
implications. This is unlike<br />
the other power plants which<br />
were mostly acquired from the<br />
government, it was built brand<br />
new and they had the time to<br />
mitigate all risk about not being<br />
paid.”<br />
Azura Power is the first Nigerian<br />
power project to benefit<br />
from both the World Bank’s<br />
“Partial Risk Guarantee” structure<br />
($237 million of debt used<br />
to build the plant) and the political<br />
risk insurance supplied<br />
by the Multilateral Investment<br />
Guarantee Agency.<br />
Azura delivered on budget<br />
ahead of schedule by 7 months<br />
and could increase Nigeria’s<br />
peak generation from 5,155MW<br />
to over 5,500MW.<br />
However, analysts are concerned<br />
about the ability of the<br />
Federal Government to sustain<br />
payment for Azura Power considering<br />
the huge cost involved<br />
in settling the test power for one<br />
month..<br />
Azura secured a $900m debt<br />
financing from a consortium<br />
of 15 banks from 9 different<br />
countries, including most of the<br />
European development finance<br />
institutions to build a 450MW<br />
Open Cycle Gas Turbine in Benin<br />
City, Edo State,<br />
Last month, it sent NBET, the<br />
market bill for test power from a<br />
single turbine of 153MW delivered<br />
to the grid on December<br />
20, 2017.<br />
L-R: Ladi Balogun, group chief executive, FCMB Group plc; Tinuade Awe, executive director, regulations, Nigerian<br />
Stock Exchange (NSE); Oladipupo Jadesimi, chairman, FCMB Group plc; Olusegun Odubogun, non-executive<br />
director, FCMB Group plc, and Olutola Mobolurin, non-executive director, during the closing gong ceremony in<br />
commemoration of the newly appointed chairman of FCMB Group plc, at the Exchange in Lagos.<br />
Cement makers see profits drop to 5 year...<br />
Continued from page 1<br />
ket capitalisation of N4.4 trillion<br />
has gained 13 percent year to date<br />
and trades at a price to book ratio<br />
of 5.4xs, according to Bloomberg<br />
data.<br />
Lafarge Africa has a market<br />
capitalisation of N385.96 billion,<br />
has returned -0.87 percent ytd,<br />
and trades at a price to sales ratio<br />
of 0.87Xs.<br />
Data gleaned by <strong>BusinessDay</strong><br />
shows the major drag on industry<br />
profit growth is Large Africa Plc,<br />
a company grappling with rising<br />
costs and leverage that eroded<br />
margins.<br />
For the year ended December<br />
2017, Lafarge Africa posted a loss<br />
after tax of (N34.60 billion) from<br />
a profit position of N<strong>16</strong>.89 billion<br />
the previous year, the lowest in five<br />
years since <strong>BusinessDay</strong> started<br />
compiling data.<br />
Lafarge profits for 2014, 2015<br />
and 20<strong>16</strong> were N34.66 billion,<br />
N26.98 billion and N<strong>16</strong>.89 billion<br />
respectively.<br />
Lafarge had finance costs or<br />
interest expense of N43.02 billion<br />
for the period, the highest in 7<br />
years, brought on by interest on<br />
borrowing incurred while paying<br />
the loans of subsidiary company,<br />
UNICEM.<br />
A breakdown of the combined<br />
profit in the period under review<br />
(2017) showed Dangote Cement Plc,<br />
the largest producer of the building<br />
material recorded net income of<br />
N204.24 billion, flat from the N201.19<br />
billion recorded in 2013.<br />
Dangote’s 2014, 2015 and<br />
20<strong>16</strong> profits were N159.50 billion,<br />
N181.52 billion and N186.62 billion<br />
respectively.<br />
CCNN’s profit after tax stood<br />
at N3.22 billion as at December<br />
2017, representing a 106.50 percent<br />
surge from the N1.56 billion<br />
recorded five years ago.<br />
Industry experts are upbeat<br />
that economic growth underpinned<br />
by an increase in crude<br />
oil price and production and the<br />
introduction of foreign exchange<br />
system that help curb the crippling<br />
dollar shortage will boost<br />
future earnings of firms operating<br />
in the sector as they expect an<br />
uptick in the demand for building<br />
materials.<br />
The gross domestic product of<br />
Africa’s largest oil producer expanded<br />
for three straight quarters<br />
last year after a 1.6 percent contraction<br />
in 20<strong>16</strong>, with year-on-year<br />
growth reaching 1.9 percent in the<br />
final three months of 2017.<br />
The International Monetary<br />
Fund (IMF) has projected that<br />
Nigeria’s economy will grow by 2.1<br />
percent in <strong>2018</strong>.<br />
The forecast which represents<br />
0.2 percent increase from the<br />
1.9 percent projected in October<br />
2017.<br />
“We expect revenue growth<br />
to be sustained amid a faster<br />
recovery in Nigeria, thanks to<br />
increased government infrastructure<br />
spending ahead of the 2019<br />
general election notwithstanding<br />
stiff competition,” said analysts at<br />
United Capital.<br />
President Muhammadu Buhari<br />
has presented a record budget<br />
of N8.60 trillion to the National<br />
Assembly for <strong>2018</strong>.<br />
Out of the total budget figure,<br />
N2.4 trillion has been earmarked<br />
for capital spending.<br />
Nigeria has infrastructure deficit<br />
of $2 trillion, according to the<br />
Africa Finance Corporation.<br />
Also, the 17 million housing<br />
deficit is a low hanging fruit for cement<br />
makers to grow sales volume.<br />
“We estimate that an additional<br />
two million housing units<br />
by 2020e from the public sector<br />
alone (as highlighted in the economic<br />
recovery plan), will unlock<br />
about 20-24 million tonnes (mt) of<br />
cement over <strong>2018</strong>e-2020e,” said<br />
analysts at RMBNS, in a recent report<br />
on Nigeria’s cement industry.<br />
Lafarge Africa is spending<br />
more to produce each unit of<br />
product as cost to income ratio<br />
increased to 83.03 percent, the<br />
highest in 5 years; driven by the<br />
construction of Mfamsong evacuation<br />
road at UNICEM in Calabar<br />
which failed as well as a full impairment<br />
taken on a Pre-heater<br />
project in ASHAKACEM which<br />
the cement maker hinted it has<br />
discontinued.<br />
The company is working to<br />
reduce energy and transportation<br />
costs as part of a turnaround plan,<br />
according to Michel Puchercos,<br />
the Chief Executive Officer of<br />
Lafarge Holcim Plc.
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
BUSINESS DAY<br />
5
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
6 BUSINESS DAY
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
BUSINESS DAY<br />
7
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
8 BUSINESS DAY
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
BUSINESS DAY<br />
9
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
10 BUSINESS DAY<br />
C002D5556<br />
COMMENT<br />
comment is free<br />
Send 800word comments to comment@businessdayonline.com<br />
Severe head injuries (trust, deception and good neighbours)<br />
BASHORUN J.K RANDLE<br />
Randle is Chairman/Chief<br />
ExecutiveJK Randle Professional<br />
Services Chartered Accountants<br />
While we may differ<br />
over the coup<br />
d’état of 15th January<br />
1966 and the<br />
counter coup of<br />
29thJuly, 1966, forensic auditors<br />
have submitted their cryptic report:<br />
“The Nation Was Left With Severe<br />
Head Injuries”<br />
That is what prompted Bill<br />
Gates, the second richest man in<br />
the world who was at the Special<br />
Session of the National Economic<br />
Council held at the Presidential<br />
Villa on Thursday March 22, <strong>2018</strong>,<br />
to declare as follows:<br />
“Nigeria is one of the most dangerous<br />
places in the world to give<br />
birth, with the fourth worst maternal<br />
mortality rate in the world,<br />
ahead of only Sierra Leone, Central<br />
African Republic, and Chad. One in<br />
three Nigerian children is chronically<br />
malnourished.”<br />
“The Nigerian government’s<br />
Economic Recovery and Growth<br />
Plan identifies “investing in our<br />
people” as one of three “strategic<br />
objectives.” But the “execution priorities”<br />
don’t fully reflect people’s<br />
needs, prioritizing physical capital<br />
over human capital.”<br />
Here you can see Nigeria’s per<br />
capita GDP growth from 2000 until<br />
today. If current education and<br />
health trends continue—if you<br />
spend the same amount in these<br />
areas and get the same results—per<br />
capita GDP flatlines, with economic<br />
growth just barely keeping<br />
up with population growth.<br />
In 1978, Dr. OlikoyeRansome-<br />
Kuti, who later became the Nigerian<br />
minister of health, helped<br />
establish primary health care as<br />
the global standard.Tragically,<br />
40 years after Dr. Ransome-Kuti<br />
helped other countries set a<br />
course for the future, the Nigerian<br />
primary health care system is broken.<br />
The evidence for this can be<br />
found in the epidemic of chronic<br />
malnutrition, or stunting.”<br />
We also have the following<br />
front page report from “The Nigerian<br />
Tribune” newspaper of 26th<br />
March, <strong>2018</strong>:<br />
Headline: “How CBN moved<br />
over N100 billion to Jonathan’s<br />
residence ahead of 2015 poll” –<br />
Presidency Sources<br />
This is nothing but desperation<br />
– Jonathan’s aide<br />
“Few days after Vice-President<br />
Yemi Osinbajo alleged that billions<br />
of naira were withdrawn<br />
by former President Goodluck<br />
Jonathan-led government and<br />
shared a few days before the 2015<br />
elections, more details are emerging,<br />
showing how several tranches<br />
of funds were illegally removed.<br />
According to a Presidency<br />
source, some new but dramatic<br />
details of how some of the funds<br />
were illegally transported from the<br />
Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) to<br />
the private residence of the former<br />
President Jonathan had now<br />
emerged.<br />
In that particular case, the<br />
former NSA [National Security<br />
Adviser] personally supervised<br />
the physical transfer of the money<br />
from the CBN vaults to the private<br />
residence of the former president.<br />
“In one particular instance,<br />
over N70 billion was released in<br />
parts from the national treasury<br />
between January 8 and February<br />
25, 2015. The over $289 millionwhich<br />
was also referenced last<br />
week by the vice president is said<br />
to be included in this particular<br />
“Nigeria is one of the most<br />
dangerous places in the<br />
world to give birth, with<br />
the fourth worst maternal<br />
mortality rate in the world,<br />
ahead of only Sierra Leone,<br />
Central African Republic,<br />
and Chad. One in three<br />
Nigerian children is<br />
chronically malnourished.”<br />
series of illegal transactions,” the<br />
source stated.<br />
The Presidency source also said<br />
minutes of the CBN board meeting of<br />
August 25, 2014 indicated the board’s<br />
approval of another N60 billion<br />
requested by the former president<br />
and released later by the apex bank.<br />
A Presidency source said the<br />
sum, which was okayed by the CBN<br />
board, was not tied to any project<br />
or procurement and was meant and<br />
disbursed purely for campaign purposes,<br />
through the office of the then<br />
NSA and the State Security Services<br />
(SSS) leadership at the time.<br />
Specifically that N6o billion that<br />
was okayed by the CBN on August<br />
25, 2014was said to have been shared<br />
between the two security agencies<br />
thus: N40 billionwent to the NSA<br />
while N20billion was released to the<br />
SSS,” it added.<br />
While some of these newly<br />
emerging fund disbursements have<br />
been traced to the former NSA,<br />
there were indications that some of<br />
the funds were unconnected to the<br />
ongoing defence contract trials of<br />
the former NSA.<br />
The $289 million mentioned<br />
by the vice president last week at<br />
the seventh Presidential Quarterly<br />
Business Forum for private sector<br />
stakeholders was released on February<br />
25, 2015.<br />
“Documents, including<br />
cash vouchers, indicate that<br />
$289,202,382 was released in cash<br />
to the NIA by the Central Bank of<br />
Nigeria from the Joint Venture (JV)<br />
Cash Call Account No. 000-0000-<br />
1<strong>16</strong>58-366 of the NNPC/NAPIMS<br />
with JP Morgan Chase Bank, New<br />
York, USA.<br />
At the exchange rate then of<br />
N199 to a dollar, $289 million is<br />
equivalent to about N60 billion. But<br />
had the money not been stolen, it<br />
would be at today’s rate over N104<br />
billion,” it added.<br />
According to the Presidency<br />
source, another set of illegal fund<br />
was withdrawn under one week<br />
between January 8 and <strong>16</strong>, 2015.<br />
It said the sum of N1.5 billion<br />
was released in three tranches of<br />
N300 million, N400 million and<br />
N800 million.<br />
“This money was released from<br />
the MEA Research Library Account<br />
to the Join-trust Dimension,” an official<br />
source with knowledge of the<br />
transaction disclosed.<br />
The source further said the sum<br />
was transferred to their various political<br />
associates, which included a<br />
former minister.<br />
Further findings showed that<br />
N350 million was allegedly transferred<br />
to one of President Goodluck<br />
Jonathan’s ministers on February<br />
2, 2015 and another N250 million<br />
was allegedly transferred to him on<br />
February 19, 2015.<br />
A document further showed<br />
that yet another N10 billion was<br />
released to the Office of the NSA<br />
by the CBN on September 15, 2015.<br />
The money was said to have<br />
been released in tranches of foreign<br />
exchange of $47 million, $5<br />
million, 4 million euros and 1.6<br />
million euros.<br />
A letter from the Office of the<br />
NSA in November 2014 further<br />
showed that the money was released<br />
by the CBN as ‘funds for<br />
special services’.<br />
Findings also showed that this<br />
particular CBN release of N10 billion<br />
was sourced in November 2014<br />
from a N40 billion CBN released<br />
funds meant for Corporate Social<br />
Responsibility (CSR).<br />
It was this N10 billion that the<br />
source claimed former President<br />
Jonathan instructed the CBN governor<br />
and the then NSA to deliver<br />
to him personally in a private residence<br />
in Abuja.<br />
Sources said the money was illegally<br />
transferred using CBN van<br />
for the use of “PDP presidential<br />
primaries.”<br />
Responding to the allegations,<br />
special assistant on new media<br />
to Dr. Goodluck Jonathan, Reno<br />
Omokri, said “this is nothing<br />
but the desperate last throes of a<br />
government that came in through<br />
propaganda and is about to go out<br />
because of a lack of proper agenda.”<br />
In a statement on Sunday night,<br />
Omokori said the allegation was<br />
false, adding that the former administration<br />
was acknowledged<br />
globally for its anti-corruption<br />
drive.<br />
“President Jonathan’s administration<br />
has the enviable record of<br />
advancing Nigeria’s anti-corruption<br />
war and delivered results to<br />
the point where we made our best<br />
ever improvement in Transparency<br />
International’s CPI in 2014, when<br />
we moved eight places forward<br />
from 144 to 136,” he said.<br />
He said there was nobody involved<br />
in ensuring the emergence<br />
of President Muhammadu Buhari<br />
who had not secretly or openly regretted<br />
it, adding that “even his<br />
own wife, Aisha, is full of regrets<br />
and has not hidden it.”<br />
Send reactions to:<br />
comment@businessdayonline.com<br />
BISI ADEYEMI<br />
Bisi Adeyemi is the Managing Director of<br />
DCSL Corporate Services Limited. For<br />
comments and reactions, kindly contact<br />
badeyemi@dcsl.com.ng.<br />
Executives inevitably see<br />
themselves as responsible<br />
for the success of<br />
their organizations - and<br />
perhaps blame the microeconomic<br />
environment and other<br />
factors when they fail. This sense<br />
of accomplishment oftentimes<br />
comes with a surreal feeling<br />
of invincibility and executives<br />
sometimes have a sense that with<br />
all the responsibility on their<br />
shoulders, Non-Executive Directors<br />
should not question their<br />
proposals as that would only distract<br />
them.Thus, they sometimes<br />
tend to take excessive risks which<br />
could put shareholders value at<br />
risk. Where these pay off, they<br />
feel justified to “extract” excessive<br />
Preventing ethical misconduct<br />
compensation.<br />
However, there is a thin line<br />
between excessive risk taking<br />
and unethical conduct. In<br />
the continuous effort to align<br />
shareholder value with those of<br />
Managers, the Board seeks ways<br />
of linking executive compensation<br />
to corporate performance.<br />
Performance bonuses based on<br />
profit and other metrics, share<br />
options and grants are incentives<br />
that seek to achieve this<br />
alignment. For the most part,<br />
these are effective. However,<br />
where the Board has not hired<br />
executives with high ethical<br />
values, these tend to engender<br />
bad behavior- performance at<br />
all cost.<br />
This is not to say that all that<br />
is required is seeking and hiring<br />
“honest, morally upright<br />
and good people”. Executives<br />
with a track record of “moral<br />
uprightness” have been known<br />
to “turn coat” or “succumb to<br />
temptation”. In the same vein,<br />
formulating a detailed written<br />
statement of ethics or specific<br />
documented policies do not<br />
necessarily prevent ethical misconduct.<br />
The 65-page Enron<br />
Corporate Code of Ethics was intended<br />
to help guide employees in<br />
“conducting the business affairs…<br />
in accordance with all applicable<br />
laws and in a moral and honest<br />
manner.” Things didn’t quite pan<br />
out as envisaged.<br />
What then should the Board do?<br />
Typically, the start point is for the<br />
Board to define the culture of the<br />
organization. This is a major responsibility<br />
of the Board which it cannot<br />
delegate to Management. Clearly,<br />
drilling down across the organization<br />
will be the responsibility of Management<br />
and monitored periodically by<br />
the Board. What values do we want<br />
to espouse? What kind pf people do<br />
we want to be? How do we want to<br />
do business? Once the Board has<br />
clarity on this, it needs to have this<br />
documented in the form of a Code of<br />
Ethics, which provides guidance on<br />
compliance expectations. As much<br />
as possible, the Code should provide<br />
examplesto guide employees and<br />
clarify expectations. A Whistle Blowing<br />
Policy and appropriatemechanism<br />
for implementation should also<br />
be put in place.<br />
The Board then needs to set the<br />
appropriate “tone at the top” by<br />
demonstrating a commitment to<br />
the ethical values it has defined.<br />
Designating a corporate ethics<br />
officer of sufficient seniority, reporting<br />
to the Board (this is critical)<br />
and an ethics management<br />
team to manage Corporate Ethical<br />
Culture is an indication of the<br />
Board’s commitment and sends a<br />
message that the Code of Ethics<br />
and related policies are not perfunctory.<br />
In addition,hiring and<br />
firing decisions must incorporate<br />
the organization’s values. The<br />
performance appraisal process<br />
must tie reward systems to indicators<br />
of integrity as well as to other<br />
measurements of productivity.<br />
Furthermore, it is important to<br />
consistently reward integrity and<br />
to make sure that these instances<br />
are publicized throughout the<br />
organization. It is also important<br />
that a transparent disciplinary<br />
process is in place to deal with<br />
violations.There should be no<br />
“sacred cows” and decisive action<br />
should be taken where violation<br />
is established – at whatever level.<br />
The Board should ensure that<br />
there is on-goingethicaltraining,<br />
not just for employees, but for<br />
third parties the organization<br />
deals with – vendors, suppliers,<br />
consultants, regulators, etc. As<br />
much as possible, practical sessions<br />
should beincorporated into<br />
the training programs to ensure<br />
clarity.<br />
Having set out the ground<br />
rules, the appropriate tone, there<br />
should be asystem in place to<br />
monitoremployee conduct to<br />
ensure there is alignment with<br />
expectations. A periodic review<br />
of the various decision-making<br />
systems and critical points where<br />
the organization may be vulnerable<br />
should be undertaken. The<br />
Board should ensure that the<br />
Whistle Blowing Mechanism<br />
continues to be effective and that<br />
whistle blowers are adequately<br />
protected. It is good practice to<br />
outsource the whistle blowing<br />
mechanism to ensure confidentiality<br />
and encourage employees<br />
to use it. To ensure that it is not<br />
perceived as a “feel good” or<br />
“nice to have”, it is imperative that<br />
decisive action is taken against<br />
ethical misconduct – no matter<br />
who the culprit is.<br />
Send reactions to:<br />
comment@businessdayonline.com
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
COMMENT<br />
C002D5556<br />
BUSINESS DAY<br />
11<br />
comment is free<br />
Send 800word comments to comment@businessdayonline.com<br />
Buhari’s insincerity on corruption portends future failure<br />
OLADIRAN OLA BELLO<br />
Dr. Bello, holds MPhil and PhD<br />
degrees from Cambridge University<br />
and is the Executive Director of Good<br />
Governance Africa (GGA).<br />
Analysts are likely to<br />
look back in a decade<br />
from now and<br />
adjudge President<br />
Buhari’s floundering<br />
anti-graft efforts as a case-study in<br />
how not to fight corruption. This is<br />
given all the challenges – many endemic,<br />
some recently self-inflicted<br />
– that Nigeria continues to grapple<br />
with. Issues that have hampered<br />
the ongoing attempts to tackle<br />
theft and wilful mismanagement<br />
of the country’s resources are legion.<br />
They range from operational<br />
lapses including institutional<br />
gaps, wrong tooling, a proclivity<br />
for media spectacle instead of<br />
serious investigative work, and a<br />
counter-productive tendency to<br />
disregard due process. This is not<br />
mentioning the political failings<br />
evident in the government’s lack<br />
of political will, balance, sincerity,<br />
and the naked politicisation that<br />
has created sacred cows to the detriment<br />
of Buhari’s very credibility.<br />
Whilst the above needlessly<br />
hobble government efforts to rein<br />
in corruption, the absence of an<br />
informed and engaged citizenry<br />
has also not helped. We must be<br />
more willing to transcend the ethnic<br />
and the other distractions better<br />
to maintain effective vigilance<br />
over our public functionaries. The<br />
immediate spur for this article is<br />
the N1.4tn, which according to<br />
the junior oil minister, is now being<br />
spent annually on oil subsidy<br />
outside the regular budget. Essentially,<br />
the difference between the<br />
N171 cost of importing petrol per<br />
litre and the regulated N145 pump<br />
price is being funded from the accounts<br />
of the Nigerian National<br />
Petroleum Company (NNPC) as<br />
“under recovery”.<br />
We have simply moved from<br />
a not very transparent subsidy<br />
system under the previous administration<br />
to an extremely opaque<br />
one in the current dispensation.<br />
The NNPC spends what is effectively<br />
billions of dollars on petrol<br />
subsidy, without any detailed<br />
account being rendered publicly<br />
or the underlying mechanisms<br />
transparently explained. Little<br />
wonder that the NNPC has quietly<br />
stepped away from its widely commended<br />
move in 20<strong>16</strong> towards the<br />
monthly publication of its detailed<br />
financial position. With much of<br />
the earmarked subsidy disappearing<br />
into private pockets in years<br />
past, Nigeria now has even less of a<br />
chance at ensuring accountability<br />
with the present arrangement. The<br />
extant NNPC subsidy programme<br />
and the obfuscation over how it<br />
is financed away from legislative<br />
oversight is the biggest economic<br />
corruption scandal that Nigeria<br />
has seen in the past three years.<br />
And that is leaving aside the currency<br />
subsidy in the form of the<br />
N285 concessional rate at which<br />
the NNPC accesses dollars from<br />
the central bank for fuel importation.<br />
Faulty foundation<br />
Evidence of the logical and<br />
procedural flaws in Nigeria’s<br />
battle against graft are littered<br />
all around us and threatening<br />
to drown the nation. The Buhari<br />
government’s lack of consistent<br />
attention to strengthening procedural<br />
accountability remains<br />
all-too-central to the difficulty<br />
dogging fiscal administration and<br />
reform. Changing this will be vital<br />
to improve our perception in the<br />
Transparency International ranking.<br />
For a government that prides<br />
itself on its anticorruption stance,<br />
the “invisible” subsidy represents<br />
a regrettable step backwards in<br />
terms of embedding transparency<br />
in the workings of government.<br />
What is most pressing is not loot<br />
recovery or naming and shaming<br />
perpetrators. It is the reshaping<br />
of institutions and fine-tuning<br />
of processes throughout government<br />
to make it difficult to divert<br />
or intentionally mismanage public<br />
funds in the first place.<br />
Just this week, a call went out<br />
from the administration for the<br />
EFCC and ICPC to investigate violations<br />
of the Public Procurement<br />
Act of 2007. Many observers doubt<br />
the sincerity or even the political<br />
neutrality of this sudden show of<br />
interest in regularising procurement.<br />
It normally should be a<br />
routine, institutionalised process<br />
overseen by empowered bodies<br />
such as the Auditor-General’s<br />
office. The latter though remains<br />
of marginal relevance even as<br />
Nigerians agitate unsuccessfully<br />
for the public disclosure of the<br />
emolument package of national<br />
lawmakers. Neither the demand<br />
side petitions using Nigeria’s<br />
Freedom of Information Act of<br />
2011 nor the supply side relying<br />
on the discretion of the Auditor-<br />
General’s office have led to this<br />
information being published.<br />
The Public Complaints Commission<br />
(the Ombudsman) remains<br />
moribund, which arguably suits<br />
errant functionaries.<br />
Meanwhile, the limitations of<br />
the Revenue Mobilisation and<br />
Fiscal Allocation Commission<br />
Board have been exposed with<br />
the March<strong>2018</strong> revelation by<br />
Senator Shehu Sanni of the unappropriated<br />
“running expenses”<br />
of N13.5m paid to each Nigerian<br />
senator monthly and a slightly<br />
lesser sum given to those in the<br />
lower legislative house. This was<br />
just one in a series of revelations<br />
that should normally cause outrage<br />
among Nigerians. Citizens<br />
though have failed consistently<br />
to leverage the sort of opportunity<br />
for mass action for change that<br />
such occasions present. The bar<br />
for anti-corruption has been set<br />
so low in Nigeria that citizens<br />
Why didn’t the squabbling<br />
political actors save face by<br />
requesting the secondment<br />
of a suitably qualified anticorruption<br />
technocrat from<br />
the UK to replace Magu?...<br />
Nothing is more injurious to<br />
Nigeria’s bid to instil discipline,<br />
probity and accountability<br />
than a government<br />
which undermines the law<br />
in its ill-conceived and incompetent<br />
pursuit of justice<br />
willingly credit Buhari’s mediocre<br />
achievement on graft.<br />
The dominant incentive pattern<br />
determines the morality of a<br />
society. Alleged mismanagement<br />
of Nigeria’s treasury is left unpunished.<br />
From the outgone president,<br />
Goodluck Jonathan, to his<br />
predecessors, all remain immune.<br />
It is inconceivable that we could<br />
deter would-be offenders when<br />
current and past misdeeds are papered<br />
over. A bold anti-corruption<br />
leader would take risks in seeking<br />
exemplary prosecutions that touch<br />
errant public office holders from all<br />
of Nigeria’s geopolitical zones.<br />
That surely would give the lie<br />
to politicians who have always<br />
exploited our dysfunctionality<br />
and ethnic and religious fractiousness<br />
to allege that anti-corruption<br />
prosecutions are sectional or biased.<br />
Brazil’s former president<br />
Lula began a twelve year jail term<br />
this week after being convicted<br />
for corruption. Jacob Zuma, South<br />
Africa’s immediate past president,<br />
is being swiftly brought to justice.<br />
In Nigeria, meanwhile, those who<br />
pocketed multiples of Zuma’s corruption<br />
proceeds still walk free.<br />
Stuck in a rot<br />
The false foundations and procedural<br />
weaknesses in President<br />
Buhari’s anti-corruption war have<br />
been glaring from his first weeks<br />
in office. He started well by implementing<br />
the treasury single<br />
account initiative began by his<br />
predecessors. Buhari’s government<br />
then controversially introduced<br />
multiple windows for foreign exchange.<br />
This remains one of the<br />
biggest opportunities for unearned<br />
income and large-scale financial<br />
transfers ever seen in Nigeria. The<br />
damage is only being partly mitigated<br />
by the recently introduced<br />
and more transparent investors and<br />
exporters segment. In legislative<br />
terms, the idea of a special anticorruption<br />
court has been mooted<br />
but its lethargic consideration by<br />
our lawmakers contrasts sharply<br />
with their enthusiastic pursuit of<br />
the death sentence for kidnapping<br />
and hate speech crimes leading to<br />
the loss of victims’ lives.<br />
Evidence of the duplicity in<br />
Buhari’s anti-graft fight continues<br />
to mount. This includes cases such<br />
as that of Babachir Lawal, former<br />
scribe to the government, and his<br />
alleged diversion of N220 million<br />
intended for those displaced by<br />
Boko Haram in the northeast.<br />
Ambassador Ayo Oke, former<br />
head of the National Intelligence<br />
Agency, allegedly hid $43million<br />
of government’s fund in a Lagos<br />
apartment. The National Health<br />
Insurance Scheme’s boss, Professor<br />
Usman Yusuf, was reinstated<br />
despite being under investigation<br />
for fraud involving N919 million.<br />
Abdulrasheed Maina, who escaped<br />
being arrested for a N2.7 billion<br />
pension scam, was brazenly<br />
reinstated into the civil service<br />
with a promotion. Although directives<br />
have been given by President<br />
Buhari that all personalities<br />
involved in the cases should be<br />
investigated, the delayed action<br />
from the top came mostly after<br />
public pressure.<br />
For those seeking serious examples<br />
in prosecuting graft, the<br />
recent announcement of a partial<br />
and politicised list of so called<br />
treasury looters by Nigeria’s information<br />
minister is unlikely<br />
to inspire much confidence. By<br />
contrast, Ghana’s president set a<br />
good example in his surprising<br />
appointment of Martin Amidu, a<br />
respected and uncompromising<br />
anti-corruption crusader from<br />
the rank of the country’s opposition,<br />
to head his new anti-graft<br />
agency. With this appointment,<br />
Ghana’s president won the public<br />
over, sending out an unequivocal<br />
message about the genuineness<br />
of his effort. A few public figures<br />
once considered untouchable<br />
from both side of Ghana’s great<br />
political divide have since been<br />
hauled before the special courts<br />
for corruption.<br />
Ghana’s achievement here is<br />
not a one-off. The revelation in<br />
2015 by a brave investigator, Anas<br />
Aremeyaw Anas, who secretly<br />
filmed justices receiving bribes,<br />
led to the jailing and the premature<br />
termination of the career<br />
of several judicial functionaries.<br />
Nigeria, by contrast, was lethargic<br />
in dealing with revelation of<br />
justices stashing away corruptly<br />
obtained funds, including in a<br />
bathroom in one of the cases. The<br />
best that Nigerians got was obfuscation<br />
and a rare guard action<br />
of the sort that has effectively left<br />
disciplinary procedures for errant<br />
justices in the hand of the National<br />
Judicial Council. The body itself is<br />
perceived by many to be far from<br />
neutral and it can, in any case, only<br />
dismiss judicial officers. Its power<br />
does not extend to meting out<br />
sentences for wrong doers. What<br />
incentive patterns are being created<br />
when incidents of corruption<br />
involving judges cannot be prosecuted<br />
in normal courts presided<br />
over by one of their own peers but<br />
hushed away within disciplinary<br />
procedures?<br />
Try a new tack<br />
Nigeria continues to sustain<br />
serious economic damage owing<br />
to the unwillingness of those in<br />
government to launch a no-holdsbarred<br />
anti-corruption war. After<br />
clashing over the EFCC head,<br />
Ibrahim Magu, Nigeria’s presi-<br />
dent and lawmakers began a long<br />
standoff which prevented the Central<br />
Bank’s monetary policy committee<br />
from meeting for months<br />
as lawmakers refused to conduct<br />
confirmation hearings for nominees<br />
to a slew of public offices.<br />
Why didn’t the squabbling political<br />
actors save face by requesting<br />
the secondment of a suitably<br />
qualified anti-corruption technocrat<br />
from the UK to replace Magu?<br />
The UK’s Serious Fraud Office has<br />
been almost exclusively in charge<br />
of all the high corruption cases<br />
successfully pursued against Nigerian<br />
functionaries in the past two<br />
decades. British prosecutors led<br />
the prosecution of Nigerian politicians<br />
from Alameseigha to Dariye,<br />
through Ibori to Deizani Alison-<br />
Madueke. The latter’s case is still<br />
ongoing in London. A top level<br />
international hire to lead the EFCC<br />
will likely inspire the younger generation<br />
of Nigerian prosecutors to<br />
high professionalism. Exposure<br />
to a different managerial culture<br />
at the helm may encourage them<br />
to properly prioritise water-tight<br />
investigations before indictments<br />
are unsealed.<br />
Defects in the EFCC’s operational<br />
culture reflects the background<br />
of its headsto date. From<br />
Nuhu Ribadu to Farida Waziri all<br />
the way to Ibrahim Lamorde and<br />
Ibrahim Magu, each has been<br />
a career police officer. Leading<br />
the EFCC effectively requires<br />
skillsets beyond the core policing<br />
functions. Serious damages have<br />
been incurred as government unwisely<br />
side-steps the rule of law.<br />
Examples include the continuing<br />
detention of Sambo Dasuki, former<br />
National Security Advisor, in<br />
disregard of court orders. Nothing<br />
is more injurious to Nigeria’s bid<br />
to instil discipline, probity and<br />
accountability than a government<br />
which undermines the law in its<br />
ill-conceived and incompetent<br />
pursuit of justice.<br />
A foreign EFCC head will operate<br />
in the full glare of the international<br />
community, likely<br />
enhancing their immunity from<br />
political pressure, manipulation<br />
or even blackmail. This is not to<br />
suggest that Nigeria lacks suitably<br />
qualified citizens who can do the<br />
job or that a foreign recruit will<br />
approximate a saint. Rather, it is<br />
a call for the closing of the circle,<br />
to welcome direct and constructive<br />
inputs from better-equipped<br />
partners that have given Nigeria<br />
copious anti-corruption support<br />
in recent years. UK prosecutors<br />
are especially well-positioned<br />
with the unrivalled wealth of financial<br />
intelligence they possess<br />
on corrupt Nigerian individuals. If<br />
Buhari dared, he might have found<br />
in a foreign anti-corruption czar an<br />
invaluable ally and wise counsel<br />
that could boost his ostensible bid<br />
to save Nigeria from corruption.<br />
That might also strike fear into a<br />
few incorrigibly corrupt figures in<br />
high places.<br />
Send reactions to:<br />
comment@businessdayonline.com
12 BUSINESS DAY C002D5556 Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
Editorial<br />
PUBLISHER/CEO<br />
Frank Aigbogun<br />
EDITOR-IN-CHIEF<br />
Prof. Onwuchekwa Jemie<br />
EDITOR<br />
Anthony Osae-Brown<br />
DEPUTY EDITORS<br />
John Osadolor, Abuja<br />
Bill Okonedo<br />
NEWS EDITOR<br />
Patrick Atuanya<br />
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR,<br />
SALES AND MARKETING<br />
Kola Garuba<br />
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, OPERATIONS<br />
Fabian Akagha<br />
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, DIGITAL SERVICES<br />
Oghenevwoke Ighure<br />
ADVERT MANAGER<br />
Adeola Ajewole<br />
MANAGER, SYSTEMS & CONTROL<br />
Emeka Ifeanyi<br />
HEAD OF SALES, CONFERENCES<br />
Rerhe Idonije<br />
SUBSCRIPTIONS MANAGER<br />
Patrick Ijegbai<br />
CIRCULATION MANAGER<br />
John Okpaire<br />
GM, BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT (North)<br />
Bashir Ibrahim Hassan<br />
GM, BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT (South)<br />
Ignatius Chukwu<br />
HEAD, HUMAN RESOURCES<br />
Adeola Obisesan<br />
Sexual predators as academics in Nigeria<br />
Last week, a voice recording<br />
allegedly suggesting<br />
that a professor<br />
of Management<br />
and Accounting at<br />
the Obafemi Awolowo University,<br />
Ile-Ife, Richard Akindele,<br />
was demanding sex in return<br />
for grade rocked the social as<br />
well as mainstream media. The<br />
academic who is also a reverend<br />
gentleman, was overhead in the<br />
tape demanding five rounds or<br />
five days of sex from the hapless<br />
lady, a final year student who<br />
failed his course, to upgrade her<br />
marks to a pass. Of course, the<br />
University has come out blazing,<br />
describing the alleged act as “totally<br />
and morally reprehensible.”<br />
It also set up a high-powered<br />
committee to investigate the<br />
allegation and submit its report<br />
within one week promising to<br />
deal decisively with anyone<br />
found culpable.<br />
The reaction is expected<br />
especially since the recording<br />
is now trending on social media<br />
and the image of the school is being<br />
smeared. But we must state<br />
that sexual harassment in our<br />
universities is more widespread<br />
than the authorities would admit<br />
and they have failed to tackle the<br />
problem or lay down stringent<br />
rules to prevent its occurrence.<br />
ASUU also, that has now made the<br />
organisation of strike actions to<br />
protest government underfunding<br />
of the universities as its main<br />
goal, has turned a blind eye to the<br />
vice of sexual harassment that is<br />
destroying our universities and<br />
turning them into a caricature of<br />
what a university should be.<br />
In 2012, a pilot ICPC/NUC<br />
University System Study and Review<br />
(USSR) of corruption in the<br />
university system was undertaken<br />
and the review identified a series of<br />
infractions including admissions<br />
racketeering, misapplication and<br />
embezzlement of funds, sale of<br />
examination questions, inducement<br />
to manipulate awards of<br />
degrees, direct cheating during<br />
examinations, deliberate delays<br />
in the release of results, victimization<br />
of students by officials, lack of<br />
commitment to work by lecturers,<br />
and above all, sexual harassment<br />
and exploitation of students by<br />
lecturers. At the presentation of<br />
the report in 2012, the ICPC Chairman,<br />
Mr Ekpo Nta, was quoted as<br />
saying: “we have uncovered many<br />
corrupt practices in our universities.<br />
Sexual harassment seems to<br />
rank extremely very high among<br />
corrupt practices in our universities.<br />
Our report is based on the<br />
quantum of petitions we have<br />
received on this corrupt practice.<br />
We’re emphasizing this because<br />
sexual harassment has to do with<br />
the immediate challenge we need<br />
to address.”<br />
In fact, the rampant cases of<br />
reported cases of sexual harassment<br />
in our tertiary institution<br />
forced the Senate in 20<strong>16</strong>, to propose<br />
a bill, known as the Sexual<br />
Harassment in Tertiary Education<br />
Institution Bill, which prescribes<br />
a 5 year jail term for lecturers and<br />
educators convicted of sexual<br />
harassment of either their male<br />
or female students and also ban<br />
lecturer-student relationships<br />
altogether.<br />
According to the sponsor of the<br />
Bill, Senator Ovie Omo-Agege,<br />
there was virtually no family in<br />
Nigeria that does not have someone<br />
who had been harassed or<br />
approached by a lecturer in an<br />
institution of higher learning in<br />
Nigeria. As he puts it: “Indeed<br />
there is no family in Nigeria<br />
where you don’t find a victim of<br />
sexual harassment...It is either<br />
your wife when she was younger<br />
or your daughter, your sister<br />
or even a niece who has gone<br />
through the tertiary education<br />
system at one point or the other...<br />
You will find out that they have<br />
had this brush with these lecturers<br />
who continue to see these<br />
young women as perquisite of<br />
their office as lecturers. We feel<br />
that is unacceptable. We have to<br />
put a stop to it.”<br />
At a time when progressive<br />
universities are outlawing any<br />
form of sexual or romantic relationships<br />
between students<br />
and teachers, our universities<br />
are being turned to centres of<br />
sexual harassment, rape and<br />
transactional sex. Pray, how<br />
can any meaningful knowledge<br />
be learnt and transmitted in<br />
such an environment? It is not<br />
surprising therefore that our<br />
universities are bereft of any serious<br />
academic endeavours and<br />
our so-called academics are lost<br />
in the conversations within their<br />
disciplines and have resorted to<br />
conversing among themselves in<br />
beer parlors and eateries at university<br />
staff clubs.<br />
This is a major problem in our<br />
universities and not just the underfunding<br />
because even when the<br />
universities are properly funded,<br />
we will be faced with a bigger problem<br />
– total lack of academics worth<br />
their salt but only sexual predators<br />
and lay-abouts pretending to be<br />
academics. ASUU needs to do a<br />
thorough introspection!<br />
EDITORIAL ADVISORY BOARD<br />
Dick Kramer - Chairman<br />
Imo Itsueli<br />
Mohammed Hayatudeen<br />
Albert Alos<br />
Funke Osibodu<br />
Afolabi Oladele<br />
Dayo Lawuyi<br />
Vincent Maduka<br />
Wole Obayomi<br />
Maneesh Garg<br />
Keith Richards<br />
Opeyemi Agbaje<br />
Amina Oyagbola<br />
Bolanle Onagoruwa<br />
Fola Laoye<br />
Chuka Mordi<br />
Sim Shagaya<br />
Mezuo Nwuneli<br />
Emeka Emuwa<br />
Charles Anudu<br />
Tunji Adegbesan<br />
Eyo Ekpo<br />
ENQUIRIES<br />
NEWS ROOM<br />
08022238495<br />
08034009034}Lagos<br />
08033<strong>16</strong>0837 Abuja<br />
ADVERTISING<br />
01-2799110<br />
081<strong>16</strong>759801<br />
08082496194<br />
SUBSCRIPTIONS<br />
01-2799101<br />
07032496069<br />
07054563299<br />
www.businessdayonline.com<br />
The Brook,<br />
6 Point Road, GRA, Apapa,<br />
Lagos, Nigeria.<br />
01-2799100<br />
LEGAL ADVISERS<br />
The Law Union<br />
MISSION<br />
STATEMENT<br />
To be a diversified<br />
provider of superior<br />
business, financial and<br />
management intelligence<br />
across platforms accessible<br />
to our customers<br />
anywhere in the world.<br />
OUR CORE VALUES<br />
<strong>BusinessDay</strong> avidly thrives on the mainstay of our core values of being The Fourth Estate, Credible, Independent,<br />
Entrepreneurial and Purpose-Driven.<br />
• The Fourth Estate: We take pride in being guarantors of liberal economic thought<br />
• Credible: We believe in the principle of being objective, fair and fact-based<br />
• Independent: Our quest for liberal economic thought means that we are independent of private and public interests.<br />
• Entrepreneurial: We constantly search for new opportunities, maintaining the highest ethical standards in all we do<br />
• Purpose-Driven: We are committed to assembling a team of highly talented and motivated people that share<br />
our vision, while treating them with respect and fairness.<br />
www.businessdayonline.com
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
BUSINESS DAY<br />
13
14 BUSINESS DAY C002D5556<br />
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
In Association With<br />
A little hope in Sierra Leone<br />
Sierra Leone’s new president has made big promises<br />
But he may not have the money to keep them<br />
JULIUS MAADA BIO wasted<br />
no time before being sworn<br />
in as president of Sierra Leone.<br />
Just an hour and a half after<br />
his narrow election victory<br />
was announced on <strong>Apr</strong>il 4th,<br />
Mr Bio took the oath of office,<br />
forgoing the state house for a<br />
dimly lit room at the Radisson<br />
Blu hotel. The unusual circumstances<br />
were prompted by security<br />
concerns. During a long<br />
and tense campaign Mr Bio<br />
had accused the All People’s<br />
Congress (APC), the party of<br />
his opponent, Samura Kamara,<br />
of trying to assassinate him. Mr<br />
Kamara, for his part, said the<br />
vote was rigged.<br />
The election was Sierra Leone’s<br />
fourth since its civil war<br />
ended in 2002. Memories of<br />
the brutal 11-year conflict<br />
still linger. Tensions based on<br />
ethnic, political and regional<br />
divisions simmered throughout<br />
the campaign, then boiled<br />
over when the result was announced.<br />
Supporters of Mr<br />
Bio’s Sierra Leone People’s Party<br />
(SLPP) attacked followers of<br />
the APC, which previously held<br />
the presidency. Much of the<br />
violence has taken place in the<br />
SLPP’s southern strongholds.<br />
But more than 100 people have<br />
also fled Kono, a volatile swing<br />
state in the east.<br />
Mr Bio, a former general<br />
who participated in two coups<br />
in the 1990s, and who briefly<br />
took power himself in 1996,<br />
has tried to calm things down.<br />
“No Sierra Leonean should feel<br />
threatened by my ascension<br />
to power,” he has said, even<br />
promising to let APC supporters<br />
stay in their government<br />
jobs. He has called on Sierra<br />
Leone’s 7m people to reject<br />
tribalism and regionalism,<br />
which have poisoned the country’s<br />
politics. He has set a good<br />
example himself, reaching out<br />
to Mr Kamara (who still plans<br />
to challenge the result of the<br />
election). The president will<br />
need to work with the APC,<br />
which has a majority in parliament.<br />
Though it has huge mineral<br />
and diamond deposits, Sierra<br />
Leone faces big economic challenges.<br />
It is still recovering from<br />
an outbreak of Ebola in 2014,<br />
which killed 4,000 people and<br />
scared away investors. A slump<br />
in global commodity prices in<br />
2015 deepened its woes. And<br />
the APC did not help matters.<br />
During its decade-long hold<br />
on power, the party looted the<br />
country’s coffers. A government<br />
audit recently revealed<br />
that much of the money earmarked<br />
for fighting Ebola during<br />
the crisis is unaccounted<br />
for.<br />
To the delight of voters, Mr<br />
Bio pledged to tackle corruption<br />
by launching a commission<br />
to investigate past crimes<br />
and creating a special division<br />
in the country’s high court to<br />
focus on cases of graft. All<br />
government revenues will<br />
flow into a single pot, he says,<br />
making the country’s finances<br />
easier to audit.<br />
Education is another problem.<br />
Three out of five adults<br />
in Sierra Leone are unable to<br />
read or write. Though primary<br />
schools are free in theory,<br />
parents often cannot afford<br />
the books and uniforms. Mr<br />
Bio vows to provide all that,<br />
and free secondary education,<br />
with money saved by<br />
“reducing leakages”. That<br />
may be unrealistic, given the<br />
state of government finances.<br />
His transition team is taking<br />
stock of the situation. Rumours<br />
abound that the kitty<br />
is empty.<br />
So Mr Bio must convince<br />
foreign donors, such as the<br />
IMF, to trust him with their aid,<br />
much of which has been suspended<br />
or restricted because<br />
of the previous government’s<br />
failure to implement economic<br />
reforms. Funds from a $224m<br />
loan package negotiated last<br />
summer with the IMF were<br />
withheld over the APC’s failure<br />
to achieve stricter enforcement<br />
of import taxes and collection<br />
of market-rate royalties on<br />
mineral exports. Mr Bio has<br />
already made progress in both<br />
of these areas.<br />
Most Sierra Leoneans are<br />
hopeful that Mr Bio will make<br />
good on his campaign slogan,<br />
“Salone foh betteh” (Sierra<br />
Leone must improve), which<br />
continues to be heard on the<br />
streets of Freetown, the capital.<br />
If he can curb corruption a bit,<br />
then Sierra Leone may indeed<br />
get better.<br />
Mr Zuckerberg goes to Washington<br />
If Facebook will<br />
not fix itself, will<br />
Congress?<br />
The light grilling the company’s boss<br />
received on Capitol Hill suggests not<br />
“<br />
THEY ‘trust me’…dumb fucks,”<br />
Mark Zuckerberg, the boss of<br />
Facebook, wrote in an instant<br />
message to a friend in 2004, after<br />
boasting that he had personal data,<br />
including photos, e-mails and addresses,<br />
of some 4,000 of his social<br />
network’s users. He offered to share<br />
whatever information his friend<br />
wanted to see. Mr Zuckerberg may<br />
use less profane language today, but<br />
many feel he has not yet outgrown<br />
his wilful disregard for users’ privacy.<br />
On <strong>Apr</strong>il 11th he testified before testy<br />
politicians in Washington about the<br />
firm’s latest privacy controversy,<br />
first to a joint hearing of two Senate<br />
committees that lasted around four<br />
hours, and then again on <strong>Apr</strong>il 12th<br />
to a House of Representatives committee.<br />
Not since the 1990s, when<br />
Microsoft was taken to task for its<br />
monopolistic behaviour, has there<br />
been such “intense public scrutiny”<br />
of a technology firm in Washington,<br />
as Orrin Hatch, a Republican senator,<br />
informed Mr Zuckerberg.<br />
Some of his inquisitors appeared<br />
annoyed by Mr Zuckerberg’s rehearsed<br />
responses, but that did not<br />
stop many onlookers from being<br />
chuffed by his smooth, slightly robotic,<br />
performance. Facebook’s share<br />
price closed 5.7% higher after his two<br />
days on Capitol Hill. Investors may be<br />
betting that the worst of “Facegate”<br />
could be over, but it is too soon to<br />
count on it.<br />
The immediate scandal is the<br />
most acute and far-reaching crisis<br />
in Facebook’s 14-year history. Last<br />
month it was revealed by Britain’s<br />
Observer and the New York Times<br />
that a researcher from Cambridge<br />
University, Aleksandr Kogan, had<br />
obtained information about some<br />
300,000 Facebook users by encour-<br />
Continues on page 15
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
C002D5556<br />
BUSINESS DAY<br />
15<br />
In Association With<br />
Brittle Britain<br />
British productivity is rising at last<br />
On its current path, the country will remain a growth laggard<br />
LOW productivity growth<br />
has plagued Britain’s<br />
economy since the financial<br />
crisis. From 2010 to 20<strong>16</strong> output<br />
per hour grew, on average,<br />
by just 0.2% a year, down from<br />
2.5% between 1950 and 2007. In<br />
the G7 group of rich countries,<br />
only Italy has done worse. Productivity<br />
drives a country’s living<br />
standards in the long term. It is<br />
a relief, then, that the stagnation<br />
may at last be coming to an<br />
end. In the second half of 2017<br />
productivity grew at an annual<br />
rate of 3.4%, the fastest growth<br />
since 2005.<br />
Accelerating productivity is<br />
the latest, and most important,<br />
piece of good news on Britain’s<br />
economy. Capital spending is<br />
improving. As a share of GDP,<br />
total investment is a percentage<br />
point above its average since the<br />
crisis. Foreign firms are readily<br />
investing. A tenth of global mergers<br />
and acquisitions announced<br />
so far in <strong>2018</strong> have involved a<br />
British target. Wage growth is<br />
picking up in nominal terms<br />
and, with inflation falling, real<br />
wages may soon start to grow<br />
again.<br />
The strength of Britain’s labour<br />
market stands out. America<br />
may have a lower official unemployment<br />
rate, but nearly a fifth<br />
of people there aged between<br />
25 and 54 are not even looking<br />
for work, meaning they are not<br />
counted in the figures. Not so<br />
in Britain, where the employment<br />
rate for this age group is<br />
84%, among the highest of large<br />
economies.<br />
Inevitably in a country still<br />
riven by the referendum decision<br />
to leave the European Union,<br />
Britain’s economic performance<br />
is analysed through the prism of<br />
Brexit. Those in favour of leaving<br />
the EU gleefully recall predictions,<br />
made by the Treasury and<br />
others, of a collapse in confidence<br />
after the referendum, and then a<br />
recession. Not only have those<br />
forecasts proved wrong but, some<br />
Brexiteers say, Brexit may actually<br />
be helping the economy. On<br />
their view, productivity is rising<br />
because falling net migration<br />
from Europe has led to a tighter<br />
labour market, spurring firms to<br />
find ways to do more with less.<br />
Too soon to celebrate<br />
Not so fast. The reasons for<br />
the rise in productivity are not<br />
yet clear (see article). But there<br />
are two ways in which the recent<br />
economic news must be put into<br />
perspective.<br />
The first is that the aftermath<br />
of the referendum has coincided<br />
with a broad, sustained rise<br />
in global growth. Against that<br />
backdrop, it is not surprising<br />
that Britain’s economy has performed<br />
better than anticipated.<br />
It has nonetheless slowed. The<br />
economy grew by only 1.4% in<br />
the year to the end of 2017, down<br />
from 2% a year earlier. And it has<br />
slipped sharply relative to others.<br />
Not long ago Britain had the fastest<br />
growth in the G7 group of rich<br />
countries. Now it has the slowest.<br />
Comparing Britain’s growth with<br />
that of the world economy, one<br />
estimate puts the running cost of<br />
Brexit at 1.3% of GDP, or £300m<br />
($426m) a week. Had the global<br />
economic cycle not turned in<br />
2017, some of the more bloodcurdling<br />
forecasts made before<br />
the referendum might not have<br />
looked quite so silly.<br />
Second, the biggest downside<br />
to Brexit was never going to be<br />
immediate economic pain. If<br />
Britain leaves the single market<br />
and customs union in an<br />
orderly manner, the short-term<br />
shock should be manageable. But<br />
there is still the swingeing cost to<br />
longer-term growth from higher<br />
trade barriers. Firms selling to<br />
the continent will gradually cut<br />
Britain out of their supply chains.<br />
Britain’s workers and capital will<br />
have to be redirected to produce<br />
things that previously were imported<br />
more cheaply. Britain’s<br />
exports to Europe will cost more.<br />
With free movement curtailed, it<br />
will be harder for knowledge to<br />
flow across borders. The economy<br />
will be less efficient.<br />
Brexiteers retort that economists<br />
have been proved wrong<br />
once and will be proved wrong<br />
again. Yet the profession is much<br />
better at predicting trade flows<br />
than it is at guessing how investors<br />
will respond to events. Few<br />
economic models have had as<br />
much success in explaining the<br />
real world as the one saying that<br />
as distance between trading<br />
partners doubles, trade flows<br />
fall by roughly half. There is no<br />
replacement for frictionless trade<br />
with a single market of 450m<br />
people on Britain’s doorstep,<br />
whatever the government’s hopes<br />
for trade deals with countries, like<br />
America, that are oceans away.<br />
Reliable trade models predict<br />
long-term losses from Brexit of<br />
up to 10% of GDP, depending on<br />
how it is conducted. According to<br />
analysis by civil servants, even if<br />
Britain retained tariff-free access<br />
to the single market and maintained<br />
free movement of people,<br />
as Norway does, the eventual hit<br />
to GDP per person could be as<br />
high as 2.6%—enough to undo its<br />
growth during 2017 almost three<br />
times over.<br />
In theory, investment could<br />
boost productivity enough to<br />
outweigh the effect of lost trade.<br />
Policymakers are, slowly, getting<br />
some things right. Government<br />
investment, as a share of GDP,<br />
may soon reach its highest sustained<br />
level for 40 years. Philip<br />
Hammond, the chancellor of<br />
the exchequer, is saying some<br />
sensible things about solving<br />
Britain’s housing shortage.<br />
Yet the government is walking<br />
down a train that is speeding<br />
in the opposite direction. The<br />
effects of merely tinkering with<br />
policy will be of a different order<br />
of magnitude to those of upending<br />
Britain’s trading relationships<br />
with its neighbours. For productivity,<br />
as for so much else, how<br />
Brexit is conducted is the thing<br />
that matters most.<br />
If Facebook will not fix<br />
itself, will Congress?<br />
Continued from page 14<br />
aging them to download an app and<br />
take a survey in 2012. He then shared<br />
these data with Cambridge Analytica,<br />
a political consultancy, which reportedly<br />
made them available to others,<br />
including Donald Trump’s campaign.<br />
Some 87m Facebook users are affected,<br />
because Facebook’s policies<br />
at the time were so loose that people<br />
using a third-party’s app often shared<br />
details not only about themselves but<br />
also about their friends without their<br />
knowledge. Facebook changed its<br />
policies in 2014.<br />
These revelations are especially<br />
damning because Facebook first<br />
learned about this problem in 2015<br />
and did little to address it. In fact,<br />
instead of focusing on Cambridge<br />
Analytica’s bad behaviour, Facebook<br />
threatened to sue the Guardian Media<br />
Group, which owns the Observer,<br />
if it published the exposé. Only after<br />
a media backlash and public outcry<br />
did Facebook begin to take action. It<br />
has started making it easier for users<br />
to control their privacy settings,<br />
reduced the amount of data that are<br />
shared with third parties, and promised<br />
to audit suspicious third-party<br />
apps. But these are things that many<br />
of its users wrongly believed Facebook<br />
had long been doing anyway.<br />
Politicians and users want to<br />
know more about how Facebook will<br />
adequately safeguard people’s privacy<br />
and offer enough transparency<br />
about how it operates. While encouraging<br />
its users to overshare minutiae<br />
from their own lives, the firm has<br />
been guarded in the past about sharing<br />
details of how its extensive datacollection<br />
machine works and what it<br />
tracks beyond the data users provide<br />
directly. The company’s business<br />
depends on observing users’ online<br />
behaviour and selling their attention<br />
to advertisers, who pay money to<br />
reach specific groups of users based<br />
on minute details gleaned about their<br />
identities, their interests and where<br />
they are. This requires a delicate balancing<br />
act between catering to users,<br />
whose attention Facebook must keep,<br />
and advertisers, who pay the bills.<br />
To date the firm has mostly favoured<br />
growth over careful checks that its<br />
“community”, as it calls its 2.1bn users,<br />
is being properly protected.
<strong>16</strong> BUSINESS DAY C002D5556<br />
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
In Association With<br />
“<br />
Escaping the maize<br />
African governments are having doubts about their staple crop<br />
Relying on maize for half one’s calories is risky—and makes for a boring diet<br />
IT’S what our forefathers<br />
used to eat,” says Kennedy<br />
Kapami, a Zambian<br />
phone salesman, rolling a<br />
ball of stiff maize porridge<br />
in his fingers. Maize is the staple<br />
food in eastern and southern<br />
Africa, where in some countries<br />
it provides over half of calories<br />
consumed. But Mr Kapami is<br />
wrong about his forefathers, or<br />
at least, his distant ones. Until<br />
the 20th century they mostly<br />
ate sorghum and millet. Maize<br />
came to Africa with the colonists.<br />
Governments now fret about its<br />
dominance.<br />
Portuguese slavers were the<br />
first to bring it to Africa. Sometimes<br />
the crop took roundabout<br />
routes. Swahili-speakers know it<br />
as mahindi (of India). Bambaraspeakers<br />
in Mali call it kaba, after<br />
the sacred site in Mecca, from<br />
where pilgrims returned with<br />
exotic foods.<br />
In southern Africa maize was<br />
grown on large estates by white<br />
settlers. After independence,<br />
governments doled out maize<br />
seed and fertiliser, even where<br />
soils were unsuitable. Towering<br />
maize stalks filled fields<br />
like Roman legions; in Zambia,<br />
the entrance to the farmers’<br />
union is held up by two columns<br />
sculpted into cobs.<br />
But using land to grow a<br />
single crop increases the risk<br />
from pests and weather. And a<br />
diverse diet is more nutritious.<br />
In February Edgar Lungu, the<br />
president of Zambia, asked<br />
“whether maize should be the<br />
ultimate crop for survival as a<br />
people”. Cultivating several different<br />
crops reduces stunting<br />
in children, says Rhoda Mofya-<br />
Mukuka of the Indaba Agricultural<br />
Policy Research Institute,<br />
a Zambian think-tank, although<br />
growing too many makes small<br />
farms inefficient.<br />
Zambia now gives farmers an<br />
electronic voucher to buy whatever<br />
farm inputs they choose.<br />
Meanwhile, in the gleaming labs<br />
of the Zambia Agricultural Research<br />
Institute, a government<br />
agency, researchers nurture<br />
shoots of disease-resistant cassava<br />
in test tubes. They have cultivated<br />
bitter-tasting sorghum,<br />
which birds don’t like but brewers<br />
do. And they have improved<br />
maize itself, developing orange<br />
varieties rich in vitamin A.<br />
The biggest push to diversify<br />
comes from climate change. In<br />
2010 researchers from Columbia<br />
and Stanford universities<br />
estimated that, by mid-century,<br />
global warming could reduce<br />
maize production in Africa by a<br />
fifth. Cassava copes better with<br />
drought and is shaking off its<br />
status as “a poor man’s crop”. But<br />
many Africans love maize, and<br />
tastes change slowly. Mr Kapami<br />
has never tried sorghum or millet.<br />
As they say in neighbouring<br />
Malawi, “Maize is life.”<br />
Shake it off<br />
The outlook for US government debt<br />
The bond-market doomsters are overstating their case<br />
THE bond market used to be<br />
the prime exhibit for those<br />
predicting low long-term<br />
economic growth. In the summer<br />
of 20<strong>16</strong> the ten-year Treasury<br />
yield briefly dipped below 1.5%, as<br />
expectations for growth and inflation<br />
sagged. Things have changed.<br />
Earlier this year the ten-year yield<br />
briefly went higher than 2.9%. Even<br />
after recent share-price gyrations, it<br />
remains around 2.8%, well up since<br />
the start of <strong>2018</strong>. The rebounding<br />
interest rate partly reflects higher<br />
confidence in global growth. Inevitably,<br />
a new set of pessimists<br />
now voice a fresh worry: that bond<br />
yields might go on rising for less<br />
welcome reasons.<br />
They point to three threats. The<br />
first is monetary policy. The Federal<br />
Reserve has raised short-term<br />
interest rates by 1.5 percentage<br />
points since December 2015. At<br />
their March meeting, rate-setters<br />
slightly upgraded forecasts of how<br />
far rates should eventually rise. Last<br />
October the Fed began shrinking its<br />
$4.5trn portfolio of assets, mostly<br />
government debt, amassed since<br />
the start of the financial crisis.<br />
Quantitative easing (QE) supposedly<br />
worked by depressing longterm<br />
interest rates. Unwinding it<br />
could push them back up.<br />
American policymakers are not<br />
the only ones tightening. Britain<br />
raised interest rates in November,<br />
and many investors expect the<br />
European Central Bank to end its<br />
QE programme this year. Economists<br />
increasingly think the “term<br />
premium”—the reward investors<br />
demand for locking their money<br />
away—is determined globally.<br />
The expectation of tighter money<br />
abroad could push American rates<br />
up, too.<br />
The second threat is fiscal policy.<br />
President Donald Trump’s tax<br />
cuts, which are expected to cost<br />
around $1trn over a decade, have<br />
deepened the hole in America’s<br />
public finances. A budget deal<br />
in March raises annual spending<br />
by at least $143bn (0.7% of GDP).<br />
Pension and health-care costs are<br />
rising. On <strong>Apr</strong>il 9th official budgetwatchers<br />
projected deficits greater<br />
than 4% of GDP every year for the<br />
next decade. Primary dealers—<br />
middlemen between governments<br />
and investors in the public-debt<br />
market—expect almost $1trn of<br />
net issuance of new debt in the 12<br />
months to September <strong>2018</strong>.<br />
The third threat comes from<br />
abroad. China and America have<br />
engaged in several rounds of setting<br />
or threatening tit-for-tat tariffs<br />
on each other’s exports. If a trade<br />
war erupts, one way China could<br />
retaliate might be to reduce its<br />
holdings of Treasuries, currently<br />
about $1.2trn.<br />
So there is much to worry the<br />
bond bears. But all three threats are<br />
somewhat overblown. Start with<br />
China. If it dumped dollar assets,<br />
it would push down the greenback,<br />
boosting American exports. That<br />
would be a strange move in a trade<br />
war. It has been reported that China<br />
could do the opposite—boost its<br />
exports by devaluing the yuan—<br />
though this too is improbable. A<br />
big devaluation would damage<br />
China’s authority around the world,<br />
and might trigger another round<br />
of capital outflows. The Chinese<br />
government has fought hard to stop<br />
these over the past two years.<br />
The Fed, meanwhile, signalled<br />
its plans to shrink its balance-sheet<br />
well in advance, so the effects of reversing<br />
QE should mostly be priced<br />
in. And the loose consensus among<br />
economists is that asset purchases<br />
brought down the ten-year yield by<br />
only about a percentage point. Not<br />
all think the effect on the way out<br />
will be as large.<br />
As for fiscal laxity, net new borrowing<br />
of nearly $1trn is relatively<br />
small compared with the gross<br />
amount of debt America regularly<br />
rolls over. (In the year to February,<br />
the Treasury issued securities<br />
worth over $9trn.) That interest<br />
rates remain low despite plentiful<br />
public borrowing indicates that<br />
safe assets are still in demand.<br />
Thank structural shifts in the world<br />
economy, such as rising life expectancy<br />
that causes more saving for<br />
retirement.
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
BUSINESS DAY<br />
17
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
18 BUSINESS DAY
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
COMPANIES<br />
& MARKETS<br />
Company news analysis and insight<br />
BUSINESS DAY 19<br />
Abbey Mortgage Bank<br />
recurring loss up N212.3<br />
million in FY 2017<br />
Pg. 20<br />
Wema bank records single digit<br />
profit growth in 2017<br />
Dipo Oladehinde<br />
Why the early<br />
season results<br />
shows<br />
tier one sized<br />
banks are hitting<br />
double digits growth, tier<br />
two banks are hitting single<br />
digits as Wema Bank hits a<br />
single digit profit of N2.26 billion<br />
in full year 2017.<br />
<strong>BusinessDay</strong> investigation<br />
showed Wema Bank recorded<br />
a drop in its profit before tax by<br />
7.38 percent to N3.01 billion<br />
in the period under review<br />
of 2017 from N3.25 billion in<br />
20<strong>16</strong>. Also, the profit after tax<br />
went down by 11.72 percent<br />
to N2.26 billion in 2017 from<br />
N2.56 billion in 20<strong>16</strong>.<br />
“Despite the slow start to<br />
the year, 2017 recorded significant<br />
progress, highlighted by<br />
the introduction of the Investor<br />
& Exporters (I&E) window<br />
and recovery in oil prices,”<br />
Segun Oloketuyi, Managing<br />
Director and CEO of Wema<br />
Bank said.<br />
“Our target market is the<br />
upwardly mobile youth segment,<br />
the young entrepreneurs,<br />
the young professionals<br />
and the financially excluded,<br />
where we continue to leverage<br />
incremental innovation<br />
and integral capabilities,” the<br />
Wema Bank MD said.<br />
Analysts are concern if<br />
other midsized banks will<br />
continue in the single digit<br />
profit like Wema as another<br />
midsized bank First City Monument<br />
Bank (FCMB) recorded<br />
a single digit profit of N9.4 billion<br />
in its full financial year of<br />
2017 compare to N14.3 billion<br />
in 20<strong>16</strong>.<br />
During the year under<br />
review, Wema Bank’s loan<br />
to deposit ratio was 84.82<br />
percent from 70.86 percent as<br />
at December 20<strong>16</strong>, while the<br />
Non-Performing Loans (NPL)<br />
Ratio closed at 3.52 percent in<br />
2017 against 5.07 percent as at<br />
December 20<strong>16</strong>.<br />
Also, the NPL Coverage<br />
Ratio was 136.98 percent as at<br />
December 31, 2017 compared<br />
with 100 percent as at December<br />
20<strong>16</strong>, while the Capital<br />
Adequacy Ratio (CAR) stood<br />
at 14.32 percent in the period<br />
under review.<br />
Total assets depreciated<br />
by 8.46 percent to N388.15<br />
billion in 2017 from N424.04<br />
billion in 20<strong>16</strong> while customers’<br />
deposits declined by 10.18<br />
percent to N254.46 billion<br />
in 2017 from N283.30 billion<br />
in 20<strong>16</strong>.<br />
The bank’s earnings<br />
from non-interest income<br />
remained strong, growing by<br />
24.44 percent from N9.80 billion<br />
in 20<strong>16</strong> to N12.19 billion<br />
in 2017; surpassing its 2017<br />
guidance of 19 percent growth<br />
rate. Also, shareholders’ funds<br />
increased in 2017 by 2.31 percent<br />
to N49.62 billion in 2017<br />
from N48.50 billion in 20<strong>16</strong>.<br />
Interest income of the<br />
bank grew by 19.10 percent<br />
to N53.07 billion as against<br />
N44.56 billion reported in<br />
20<strong>16</strong>. Net Interest Income<br />
also increased from N18.65<br />
billion in 20<strong>16</strong> to N19.77 billion<br />
in 2017. Trading income<br />
for the reporting period grew<br />
by over 100 percent to N4.98<br />
billion as against N2.12 billion<br />
in 20<strong>16</strong>.<br />
The innovative bank, which<br />
launched ALAT, Africa’s first<br />
fully digital bank, confirmed<br />
the growth of its gross earnings<br />
by 20.07 percent from N54.36<br />
billion in FY20<strong>16</strong> to N65.27<br />
billion in FY2017.<br />
The growth was supported<br />
by the launch of ALAT,<br />
enhancing Wema Bank’s<br />
already existing alternate<br />
platforms which recorded<br />
a combined growth rate of<br />
205.67 percent in transactions<br />
executed and with an<br />
estimated 30,000 accounts<br />
opened monthly.<br />
“We approached the money<br />
market in November 2017 to<br />
raise N25 billion in two series<br />
under a commercial paper<br />
program; series 1 N10 billion<br />
– 182-day tenor and series 2:<br />
N15 billion- 270-day tenor.<br />
Given the relative decline in<br />
interest rates and possible<br />
growth within the economy,<br />
the bank will be re-opening<br />
the 2nd series of its N50 billion<br />
debt issuance program. This<br />
should commence from the<br />
second quarter of the year,”<br />
Oloketuyi added.<br />
In recent times, there<br />
have been concerns raised<br />
about the status of midsized<br />
banks operating in Nigeria<br />
as foreign financial agencies<br />
and state owned Central<br />
Bank of Nigeria (CBN) are<br />
worried about the survival<br />
of small and mid-size banks<br />
in the country, they express<br />
concern about its over exposure<br />
to the oil industry,<br />
which is still recovering from<br />
the 2014 price crash and the<br />
recent recession.<br />
In its recent Credit Outlook,<br />
Moody’s said Nigeria’s midsize<br />
banks face greater risk of<br />
losing business to financial<br />
technology (fintech) companies<br />
because they tend to<br />
provide retail banking and<br />
payment services to individuals<br />
and small and midsize<br />
enterprises.<br />
According to Moody’s,<br />
these financial institutions’<br />
lower capital over the years<br />
constrain their ability to grow<br />
their business in key sectors of<br />
the nation’s economy.<br />
The report by Moody’s<br />
pointed out that mid-size<br />
banks in Nigeria were limiting<br />
their loss-absorption capacity<br />
against unexpected losses,<br />
and that this would restrain<br />
their asset growth and revenue<br />
generation.<br />
“These financial institutions’<br />
lower capital over the<br />
years constrains their ability<br />
to grow their business in<br />
key sectors of the nation’s<br />
economy,” Moody noted.<br />
Fitch Ratings in February<br />
this year disclosed a number<br />
of Nigeria’s tier-2 banks (banks<br />
with total assets less than N2<br />
trillion) will fall below the capital<br />
adequacy ratio of the CBN<br />
should the Naira depreciate to<br />
N450 per dollar.<br />
Also, International Monetary<br />
Fund (IMF) last month<br />
released its Nigeria country<br />
report, noting that tier-I<br />
banks’ capital adequacy ratio<br />
had declined to 10.8 per cent<br />
in September 2017 from <strong>16</strong>.3<br />
per cent in December 20<strong>16</strong><br />
and 17.1 per cent in 2013, and<br />
was now at its lowest level in<br />
the past five years.<br />
IMF has advised the CBN<br />
to carry an asset quality review<br />
of Nigerian banks to determine<br />
their potential capital<br />
need.<br />
Recall, the Washington<br />
DC-based agency had last<br />
year advised the Nigerian<br />
regulator to recapitalise the<br />
banking industry against the<br />
backdrop of the capital deterioration<br />
the industry had<br />
experienced as a result of the<br />
2015 fall in global oil prices and<br />
the recession.<br />
Also last Tuesday, the<br />
CBN released its bank stress<br />
test results, which showed<br />
the banking system’s capital<br />
vulnerability is driven by<br />
midsize banks’ weaker capital<br />
conditions.<br />
The CBN said the decline<br />
in the CARs was attributable<br />
to the challenges in the oil and<br />
gas sector coupled with the<br />
slow recovery in the domestic<br />
economy, which resulted to a<br />
rise in NPLs and capital deterioration.<br />
The Nigerian banking industry<br />
has about 30 per cent<br />
of loan portfolio in the oil and<br />
gas sector.<br />
NNPC to support local investors on advancement of technology<br />
HARRISON EDEH, Abuja<br />
The Group Managing<br />
Director of the Nigerian<br />
National Petroleum<br />
Corporation<br />
(NNPC), Maikanti Baru, has<br />
said that the corporation was<br />
committed to supporting local<br />
investors towards growing the<br />
engineering profession, even<br />
as he noted that this would<br />
in turn ensure technological<br />
advancement of the nation’s<br />
oil and gas industry.<br />
Baru disclosed this while<br />
speaking at the induction ceremony<br />
of the Group Managing<br />
Director of ARCO Group, Alfred<br />
Irabor Okoigun, with the Honourary<br />
Fellowship of the Nigerian<br />
Academy of Engineering<br />
(NAE), in Lagos, recently.<br />
“NNPC will continue to<br />
support ARCO Group and<br />
many other indigenous companies<br />
alike so that your story<br />
and the story of others will<br />
continue to be savoured by<br />
generations yet unborn,” Baru<br />
said in a statement.<br />
Okoigun established ARCO<br />
Petrochemical Engineering<br />
Company Ltd in 1980 after<br />
a two-year stint as a Material<br />
Management Officer with<br />
NNPC’s Warri Refinery and<br />
Petrochemical Company<br />
(WRPC).<br />
The company has since<br />
grown over the last three decades<br />
to become a conglomerate<br />
that not only deals in<br />
engineering and maintenance,<br />
but has also diversified into<br />
marine logistics, maritime<br />
security, pipelines & facilities<br />
inspection, property development<br />
and consumer power<br />
generation.<br />
Congratulating Alfred on<br />
his fellowship by the nation’s<br />
foremost engineering academy,<br />
Baru said he was a leading<br />
example in the development<br />
and promotion of engineering<br />
education in the country.<br />
“This fellowship is a testament<br />
of your distinguished<br />
leadership and contribution<br />
to the Engineering profession<br />
as well as your outstanding<br />
achievements and contributions<br />
towards the well-being<br />
of the society at large,” Baru<br />
added. He also commended<br />
the NAE for promoting policies<br />
that ensure the advancement of<br />
Science, Engineering, Technology<br />
and Innovation for a better<br />
economy and society.<br />
He said in the academy’s<br />
twenty-one years of existence,<br />
it has proven to be the national<br />
“Think Tank” for Engineering<br />
and Technology, adding that<br />
“we in the NNPC are proud to<br />
be associated with you.”<br />
Speaking earlier, the President<br />
of the Academy, J. O.<br />
Maduka described the fellowship<br />
conferred on Okoigun as<br />
well-deserved following his<br />
contributions to the development<br />
of Engineering education<br />
in Nigeria.<br />
She charged him to be a<br />
good ambassador of the Academy<br />
by striving to do more for<br />
the Engineering profession as<br />
several young engineers are<br />
looking up to him for his remarkable<br />
achievements.<br />
In his lecture at the occasion,<br />
former Vice Chancellor<br />
of University of Lagos, Oyewusi<br />
Ibidapo-Obe called on innovators<br />
in the Engineering profession<br />
to look towards providing<br />
solutions that would make the<br />
world a better place for all.
20<br />
BUSINESS DAY<br />
COMPANIES & MARKETS<br />
Abbey Mortgage Bank recurring loss<br />
up N212.3 million in FY 2017<br />
C002D5556<br />
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
Endurance Okafor<br />
Abbey Mortgage Bank<br />
Plc, one of the listed<br />
firm in the Nigeria<br />
Stock Exchange<br />
(NSE) recorded loss<br />
for the Full Year ended December<br />
31, 2017. This is the second<br />
consecutive year the Mortgage<br />
Bank recorded a loss after it<br />
reported profit in 2015.<br />
It reported loss after tax expense<br />
of N212.3 million for the<br />
year 2017. This was 44.4 million<br />
or 26 percent increase of loss<br />
when compared to the reported<br />
loss of N<strong>16</strong>7.9 million recorded<br />
in the fiscal year 20<strong>16</strong>, as compiled<br />
from company’s financial<br />
statement.<br />
The Mortgage Bank’s recurring<br />
losses can be traced<br />
to its low operating income<br />
compared to a high operating<br />
expense.<br />
The Mortgage bank’s operating<br />
income for the year 2017 was<br />
up N919.2 million, an increase<br />
of about N44.7 million when<br />
compared toN874.5 million<br />
recorded in 20<strong>16</strong>, however, its<br />
operating expense was N929.1<br />
million in the year under review,<br />
compared to a lower operating<br />
expense in the previous year at<br />
N907.1 million.<br />
Analysis by <strong>BusinessDay</strong><br />
shows that the Mortgage bank’s<br />
low revenue could be as a result<br />
of low patronage from Nigerians,<br />
meaning not many people go<br />
to take mortgage loans from<br />
the bank. This is evident in the<br />
interest income.<br />
A breakdown of the financial<br />
report revealed a record of<br />
N1.2 billion as interest income<br />
in 2017 compared to its N960.8<br />
million recorded in the financial<br />
year 20<strong>16</strong>. Its interest expense<br />
for the year under review was<br />
N490.7 million compared to<br />
N344.4 million recorded in the<br />
previous year<br />
This brought the net interest<br />
income to N764.9 million in<br />
2017 as against N6<strong>16</strong>.4 million<br />
net interest incomes reported<br />
in comparable period of 20<strong>16</strong>.<br />
Experts in the mortgage<br />
industry also linked the bank’s<br />
performance to lack of general<br />
liquidity, short term deposits<br />
for long term funds, and accumulated<br />
non-performing loans<br />
which are running into billions<br />
in the sector.<br />
Abbey Mortgage Bank however,<br />
recorded N 177.9 million<br />
losses before taxation in contrast<br />
to N134.4 million recorded<br />
in the previous year.<br />
Meanwhile, the bank acquired<br />
total assets worth N12.2<br />
billion. This is slightly below the<br />
N12.4billion assets it acquired<br />
in the previous year.<br />
Its total liabilities for the<br />
year remained almost the same<br />
as that of 20<strong>16</strong> at N6.0 billion.<br />
Experts in the sector stressed<br />
that the Nigeria Mortgage Refinance<br />
Company (NMRC)<br />
seems to have failed in its mandate<br />
to raise long-term funds<br />
from the domestic and foreign<br />
capital market, as it public<br />
purpose is in developing the<br />
primary and secondary mortgage<br />
markets.<br />
Although, the fact that the<br />
real estate sector was still in<br />
recession could not be ignored<br />
when <strong>BusinessDay</strong> spoke to<br />
analysts about the performance<br />
of the Mortgage Banks in the<br />
country.<br />
Growth in the Mortgage<br />
industry is seen to be at a slow<br />
pace. Aside the difficulty of low<br />
liquidity in the sector, the problem<br />
of Nigerians not earning<br />
enough income to qualify them<br />
to take up a mortgage is another<br />
setback witnessed in the sector.<br />
Analyst advised the inclusion<br />
of the informal sector into<br />
the mortgage industry in order<br />
for them to breakthrough, as the<br />
larger market are in the informal<br />
sector.<br />
Abbey Mortgage Bank is one<br />
of the seven national Primary<br />
Mortgage Banks (PMB) licensed<br />
by the Central Bank of Nigeria<br />
and Federal Mortgage Bank of<br />
Nigeria (FMBN). The recent<br />
recapitalization exercise saw the<br />
down size from 105 mortgage<br />
banks to only 34 now surviving.<br />
Abbey Mortgage Bank Plc<br />
focuses on providing economical<br />
housing units for interested<br />
home seekers, developers and<br />
cooperatives who desire a wellstructured<br />
mortgage offer.<br />
MTNF, Kaduna partner to tackle infant, maternal mortality<br />
Lanatu Shelton<br />
The Kaduna State government<br />
and the MTN<br />
Foundation, alongside<br />
other relevant healthcare<br />
agencies, recently pledged<br />
to work collaboratively to tackle<br />
the menace of infant and maternal<br />
mortality in the state.<br />
The partnership, announced<br />
at the MTNF Yellow Heart<br />
Health Forum in Kaduna, is a<br />
demonstration of MTNF’s commitment<br />
to reduce maternal and<br />
child mortality by increasing<br />
awareness of the phenomenon<br />
in Nigeria and aligning with<br />
global efforts to meet the health<br />
targets of Sustainable Development<br />
Goals (SDGs).<br />
Speaking on MTNF’s decision<br />
to support the Kaduna<br />
State on this initiative, Danladi<br />
Mohammed, director, MTNF,<br />
said, “The Foundation is indeed<br />
excited to go into a partnership<br />
that brightens the lives of<br />
people, especially within the<br />
community where it operates.<br />
“We take out time to identify<br />
with the plight of members of<br />
the community where we carry<br />
out our operations and we are<br />
sensitive to these plights. It is<br />
because of this that the Foundation<br />
created a mandate to<br />
spend towards improving the<br />
state of healthcare, education<br />
and economic empowerment.<br />
“Kaduna State is part of the<br />
six states selected for the MTNF<br />
Yellow Heart initiative, it is a<br />
laudable initiative and we are<br />
looking forward to a healthy<br />
collaboration with the Government<br />
and the good people of<br />
Kaduna state. We hope to use<br />
the Yellow Heart initiative to address<br />
predominant issues such<br />
as attitude and cultural practice<br />
that hinder women and children<br />
from accessing healthcare<br />
services in the society.”<br />
While appreciating the<br />
Foundation for the yellow heart<br />
initiative, Paul Dogo, commissioner<br />
for health, Kaduna<br />
State, said the state was happy<br />
to partner the Foundation on<br />
the initiative.<br />
The commissioner, represented<br />
by the permanent secretary,<br />
Kaduna State Ministry of<br />
Health, Shehu Usman, said the<br />
initiative aligned with what the<br />
state government was doing to<br />
improve healthcare.<br />
“For the first time in the history<br />
of the state, we have a government<br />
that is equipping and<br />
renovating 255 healthcare facilities<br />
across the state. When the<br />
government came on board the<br />
first bill that was passed was the<br />
bill to have primary health care<br />
under one roof, that is through<br />
an integrated approach. Since<br />
then, the state government has<br />
created specialised hospitals to<br />
cater to the varying healthcare<br />
needs of the people.<br />
“These are some of the initiatives<br />
of the state Government<br />
towards improving healthcare<br />
in the state and we are happy<br />
about the yellow heart initiative<br />
which we promise to give our<br />
best support,” he said.<br />
Commenting on what the<br />
partnership means for the state,<br />
wife of the deputy governor,<br />
Ladi Barnabas, said the initiative<br />
would immensely help to<br />
improve the health and survival<br />
rate of women and children in<br />
the state, while urging women to<br />
take full advantage of the intervention<br />
and come out en-masse<br />
for the health awareness walk.<br />
The Yellow heart launch<br />
in Kaduna featured a workshop<br />
where experts encouraged<br />
mothers and expectant mothers<br />
to exclusively breastfeed<br />
their newborns and ensure<br />
adequate routine immunisation<br />
for them to protect them<br />
from preventable childhood<br />
diseases, distribution of delivery<br />
kits to pregnant women, as well<br />
as an awareness walk tagged<br />
“Walk for Life.”
Monday 09 <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
COMPANIES & MARKETS<br />
BUSINESS DAY 21<br />
Business Event<br />
L-R: Leke Pitan; MD, Bank of Industry , Gloria Elemo, DG/CEO, Federal Institute of Industrial<br />
Research, Oshodi, Dele Oyeku, director, extension & linkage, FIIRO, Lanre Shonekan, MD/CEO,<br />
Lashone Link Communications,. Okeowo Oderinde, director, finance & accounts, FIIRO, during<br />
a courtesy visit to BoI recently in Lagos.<br />
L-R: Olufunwa Akinmade, group head, retail and SME; Titilayo Abraham, group head, corporate<br />
planning and strategy; Bonaventure Okhaimo, general manager,product and channels directorate,<br />
and Ebenezer kolawole, executive director, finance and operations all of Unity Bank during the official<br />
launch of ’’Unifi’’ by the bank in Lagos.<br />
Pic by Pius Okeosisi<br />
L-R:Samuel Ikhuoriah, manager, personal lending, Page Financials; Olajumoke Olusoga, head of<br />
strategy and corporate transformation, Page Financials; Sorinmade Adebayo, MD/CEO, Blue Bond<br />
Projects and Services; Segun Akintemi, chief executive officer, Page Financials, and Samuel Zion,<br />
manager, Kedi Healthcare, at the official unveiling of Page Financials Branch Office and launch<br />
of Page Credit Card In Opebi, Lagos.<br />
L-R: Aniete Ichie, head, sponsorship, HR Expo Africa; Dayo Olomu, Vice chairman, Chartered<br />
Institute of Personnel & Development, South London; Kunbi Adeoti, divisional director, human<br />
resources, Leadway Assurance, and Taiwo Ajayi, member, steering committee, HR Expo Africa,<br />
at the opening day of the HR Expo Africa, at Landmark Event Centre in Lagos.
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
22 BUSINESS DAY<br />
Live @ the Stock exchange<br />
Prices for Securities Traded as of Friday 13 <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
Company<br />
Company<br />
Market cap(nm) Price (N) Change Trades Volume Market cap(nm) Price (N) Change Trades Volume<br />
PRICES FOR MAIN BOARD SECURITIES (Equities)
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
BUSINESS DAY<br />
23
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
24 BUSINESS DAY<br />
Access Bank Rateswatch<br />
KEY MACROECONOMIC INDICATORS<br />
Indicators Current Figures Comments<br />
GDP Growth (%) 1.92 Q4 2017 — higher by 0.52% compared to 1.40% in Q3 2017<br />
Broad Money Supply (M2) (N’ trillion) 24.02 Increased by 0.79% in Feb’ <strong>2018</strong> from N23.83 trillion in Jan <strong>2018</strong><br />
Credit to Private Sector (N’ trillion) 22.62 Increased by 2.88% in Feb’ <strong>2018</strong> from N21.99 trillion in Jan <strong>2018</strong><br />
Currency in Circulation (N’ trillion) 1.94 Decreased by 0.42% in Feb’ <strong>2018</strong> from N1.95 trillion in Jan <strong>2018</strong><br />
Inflation rate (%) (y-o-y) 13.34 Declined to 13.34% in Mar’ <strong>2018</strong> from 14.33% in Feb’<strong>2018</strong><br />
Monetary Policy Rate (%) 14 Raised to 14% in July ’20<strong>16</strong> from 12%<br />
Interest Rate (Asymmetrical Corridor) 14 (+2/-5) Lending rate changed to <strong>16</strong>% & Deposit rate 9%<br />
External Reserves (US$ million) 46.75 <strong>Apr</strong>il 9, <strong>2018</strong> figure — an increase of 0.52% from <strong>Apr</strong>il start<br />
Oil Price (US$/Barrel) 68.14 <strong>Apr</strong>il 13, <strong>2018</strong> figure - a decrease of 1.30% from the prior week<br />
Oil Production mbpd (OPEC) 1.81 Mar’ <strong>2018</strong> figure — an increase of 1.12% from Feb’<strong>2018</strong> figure<br />
STOCK MARKET<br />
Indicators Friday Friday Change(%)<br />
13/04/18 6/04/18<br />
NSE ASI 40,928.70 40,841.14 0.21<br />
Market Cap(N’tr) 14.78 14.75 0.21<br />
Volume (bn) 0.17 0.50 (66.70)<br />
Value (N’bn) 2.04 5.85 (65.11)<br />
MONEY MARKET<br />
NIBOR<br />
Tenor Friday Rate Friday Rate Change<br />
(%) (%) (Basis Point)<br />
13/04/18 6/04/18<br />
OBB 2.33 3.67 (134)<br />
O/N 2.92 4.00 (108)<br />
CALL 4.94 8.94<br />
(400)<br />
30 Days 14.43 14.90 (47)<br />
90 Days 15.27 15.68 (41)<br />
FOREIGN EXCHANGE MARKET<br />
Market Friday Friday<br />
1 Month<br />
BOND MARKET<br />
AVERAGE YIELDS<br />
Tenor Friday Friday<br />
Change<br />
(%) (%) (Basis Point)<br />
13/04/18 6/04/18<br />
3-Year 0.00 0.00 0<br />
5-Year 13.33 13.56 (23)<br />
7-Year 12.95 13.72 (77)<br />
10-Year 13.35 13.62 (28)<br />
20-Year 13.42 13.65 (23)<br />
Disclaimer<br />
This report is based on information obtained from various sources believed to be<br />
reliable and no representation is made that it is accurate or complete. Reasonable care<br />
has been taken in preparing this document. Access Bank Plc shall not take responsibility<br />
or liability for errors or fact or for any opinion expressed herein .This document is for<br />
information purposes and private circulation only and may not be reproduced,<br />
distributed or published by any recipient for any purpose without prior express consent<br />
of Access Bank Plc.<br />
Sources: CBN, Financial Market Dealers Association of Nigeria, NSE and<br />
Access Bank Economic Intelligence Group computation.<br />
NIGERIAN INTERBANK TREASURY BILLS TRUE YIELDS<br />
Tenor Friday Friday Change<br />
(%) (%) (Basis Point)<br />
13/04/18 6/04/18<br />
1 Mnth 12.91 13.90 (99)<br />
3 Mnths 13.12 13.20 (9)<br />
6 Mnths 13.76 14.67 (91)<br />
9 Mnths 14.32 14.59 (27)<br />
(N/$) (N/$) Rate (N/$) 12 Mnths 14.86 14.90 (3)<br />
13/04/18 6/04/18 13/03/18<br />
Official (N) 305.55 305.60 305.75<br />
Inter-Bank (N) 337.27 336.48 335.37<br />
BDC (N) 360.00 359.81 360.00<br />
Parallel (N) 363.00 362.00 362.00<br />
COMMODITIES MARKET<br />
Indicators 13/04/18 1-week YTD<br />
Change Change<br />
(%) (%)<br />
Energy<br />
Crude Oil $/bbl) 68.14 (1.30)<br />
5.71<br />
Natural Gas ($/MMBtu) 2.70 0.00 (11.65)<br />
Agriculture<br />
Cocoa ($/MT) 2,555.00 4.20 31.97<br />
Coffee ($/lb.) 120.00 2.17 (7.83)<br />
Cotton ($/lb.) 83.45 1.11 7.68<br />
Sugar ($/lb.) 12.20<br />
(1.53) (20.42)<br />
Wheat ($/bu.) 491.50 5.02 13.38<br />
Metals<br />
Gold ($/t oz.) 1,337.39 0.37 1.51<br />
Silver ($/t oz.) <strong>16</strong>.53 0.92 (3.84)<br />
Copper ($/lb.) 305.55 (0.02) (6.79)<br />
ACCESS BANK NIGERIAN GOV’T BOND INDEX<br />
Indicators Friday Friday Change<br />
(%) (%) (Basis Point)<br />
13/04/18 6/04/18<br />
Index 2,644.27 2,623.02 0.81<br />
Mkt Cap Gross (N'tr) 8.88 8.81 0.79<br />
Mkt Cap Net (N'tr) 5.81 5.75 1.03<br />
YTD return (%) 7.65 6.78 0.87<br />
YTD return (%)(US $) -47.46 -48.35 0.89<br />
TREASURY BILLS (MATURITIES)<br />
Tenor Amount Rate (%) Date<br />
(N' million)<br />
91 Day 9,520 11.75 4-<strong>Apr</strong>-<strong>2018</strong><br />
182 Day 17,601 12.7 4-<strong>Apr</strong>-<strong>2018</strong><br />
364 Day 68,080 13.04 4-<strong>Apr</strong>-<strong>2018</strong><br />
Market Analysis and Outlook: <strong>Apr</strong>il 13 - <strong>Apr</strong>il 20, <strong>2018</strong><br />
Global Economy<br />
In the Eurozone, the trade surplus with the rest of<br />
the world widened in February as imports saw a<br />
faster decline than exports. According to the<br />
European Union's statistics agency (Eurostat),<br />
exports of goods from the single currency area fell<br />
2.3% from January, the second straight month of<br />
decline. However, imports of goods fell more<br />
rapidly - by 3.1% - leaving the Eurozone with a<br />
surplus of 21.0 billion euros ($25.9 billion), up from<br />
20.2 billion euros in January. In a separate<br />
development, Japanese business sentiment<br />
worsened for the first time in two years in the first<br />
quarter. The Bank of Japan's Tankan report - a<br />
quarterly survey of about 10,000 companies -<br />
s h o w e d a r e a d i n g o f 2 4 a m o n g m a j o r<br />
manufacturers in its March survey against 26 in<br />
the December report. Confidence fell among<br />
chemicals, electrical machinery makers and other<br />
exporters, likely due to the Yen’s recent<br />
appreciation. In another development, India’s<br />
consumer inflation eased to the lowest level in five<br />
months in March as food and fuel prices cooled,<br />
government data showed. The consumer-price<br />
index rose 4.28% from a year earlier, slowing from<br />
February’s 4.44% increase. Food prices climbed<br />
2.81% from a year earlier, decelerating from a<br />
3.26% rise in February while fuel prices rose<br />
5.73%, slower than February’s 6.8% increase.<br />
Despite the decline, the current level of inflation<br />
remains higher than the Reserve Bank of India's<br />
(RBI) 4% medium-term target. Elsewhere,<br />
Moody's rating agency affirmed Brazil's 'Ba2'<br />
credit rating and raised the country's outlook to<br />
'stable' from 'negative. In a statement, Moody's<br />
said it made the revision mainly because of the<br />
higher-than-expected short and medium-term<br />
economic growth prospects in the country as well<br />
as the expectation that the winner of this year's<br />
election in October will approve fiscal reforms to<br />
cut government spending.<br />
Local Economy<br />
The Consumer Price Index (CPI) which measures<br />
inflation rose by 13.34% year-on-year in the<br />
month of March <strong>2018</strong>, which is 0.99% points less<br />
than the 14.33% recorded in February <strong>2018</strong>. This<br />
represents the fourteenth consecutive month of<br />
decline in the rate of inflation since January 2017.<br />
The food index rose by <strong>16</strong>.08% (year-on-year) in<br />
March, slightly lower than 17.59% recorded in<br />
February, thus indicating declining pressure in the<br />
prices of food items. The core sub-index, which<br />
excludes prices of farm produce increased by<br />
11.2%, 0.5% points lower than 11.7% in February.<br />
During the month, the highest increases were<br />
recorded in prices of clothing materials, garments<br />
and other articles of clothing and clothing<br />
accessories, vehicle spare parts, fuel and<br />
lubricants for personal transport equipment,<br />
actual and imputed rentals for housing, passenger<br />
transport by road, hairdressing salons and<br />
personal grooming establishments, shoe and<br />
other footwear, maintenance and repair of<br />
personal transport equipment and paramedical<br />
services. In a separate development, the monthly<br />
business expectations survey report by CBN<br />
showed that optimism by firms for the month of<br />
March was higher compared to the previous<br />
month. The business outlook index improved to<br />
2 4 . 5 f r o m 1 4 . 5 r e c o r d e d i n F e b r u a r y .<br />
R e s p o n d e n t s f r o m s e r v i c e s , i n d u s t r i a l ,<br />
wholesale/retail trade and construction sectors<br />
expressed optimism on own operations in the<br />
current month with indices of 3.4, 2.2, 1.2 and 0.5,<br />
respectively when compared with 1.9, 2.5, -0.3<br />
and -0.5 in February <strong>2018</strong>, respectively. The<br />
outlook on the volume of total order, business<br />
activity and financial conditions (working capital)<br />
stood at <strong>16</strong>.0, 13.3, and 7.6 index points<br />
respectively, indicating an improvement in<br />
relation to its outlook in February <strong>2018</strong> which was<br />
2.2, 7.1, and 3.8 respectively. Insufficient power<br />
supply, high interest rate, unfavourable economic<br />
climate, unclear economic laws, financial<br />
problems, insufficient demand and unfavourable<br />
political climate were identified as the major<br />
factors constraining business activity in the<br />
current month. The exchange rate is also<br />
expected to appreciate in the current and next<br />
months, borrowing rates to rise while inflation is<br />
expected to fall.<br />
Stock Market<br />
Trading activities at the local bourse improved<br />
marginally in the week ended <strong>Apr</strong>il 13, <strong>2018</strong>. The All<br />
Share Index (ASI) gained marginally by 0.2% or<br />
87.56 points to close at 40,928.70 points from<br />
40,841.14 points the previous week. Similarly,<br />
market capitalization rose by 0.2% to close at<br />
N14.78 trillion from N14.75 trillion the previous<br />
week. The positive performance in the market was<br />
aided by stocks in the industrial goods, banking<br />
and oil & gas sectors. This week we expect bargain<br />
hunting to continue as attractive entry<br />
opportunities remain in the market.<br />
Money Market<br />
Money market rates moderated for the third<br />
consecutive week due to inflow from retail<br />
Secondary Market Intervention Sales (SMIS)<br />
refund of about N100 billion. Short-dated<br />
placements such as Open Buy Back (OBB) and<br />
Over Night (O/N) rates further declined to<br />
2.33% and 2.92% from 3.67% and 4%<br />
respectively the previous week. Longer dated<br />
placements also trended downwards. The 30-<br />
day and 90-day NIBOR closed lower at 14.43%<br />
and 15.27% from 14.90% and 15.68% the prior<br />
week. This week, rates may trend upwards due<br />
to expected Open Market Operation (OMO)<br />
auction.<br />
Foreign Exchange Market<br />
The naira-dollar exchange rate at the interbank<br />
window depreciated marginally by 79kobo to close<br />
at N337.27/$ from N336.48/$ the previous week.<br />
At the parallel market, the local currency also<br />
depreciated marginally by N1 to N363/$ from the<br />
previous week’s rate of N362/$. The naira<br />
however appreciated slightly at the official market<br />
to N305.55/$ from N305.60/$ the previous week.<br />
The relative stability of the naira to the dollar may<br />
be attributed to the sustained intervention of the<br />
apex bank. This week, we expect the naira will<br />
remain around prevailing levels.<br />
Bond Market<br />
Bond yields trended downwards for the second<br />
consecutive week due to increase in demand and<br />
sustained moderation in inflation. Yields on the<br />
five-, seven-, ten- and twenty- year debt papers<br />
settled at 13.33%, 12.95%, 13.35% and 13.42%<br />
from 13.56%, 13.72%, 13.62% and 13.65%<br />
respectively the previous week. The Access Bank<br />
Bond index rose by 21.24 points or 0.81% to close<br />
at 2,644.27 points from 2,623.02 points the<br />
previous week. This week, the direction of yields<br />
would likely be determined by the new bond<br />
auction calendar.<br />
Commodities Market<br />
Oil prices climbed last week as rising tensions in<br />
the Middle East continued to stoke concerns over<br />
potential supply disruptions in the region. The<br />
price of the Organization of the Petroleum<br />
Exporting Countries (OPEC) basket of crudes<br />
added $3.55, or 5.45%, to $68.73 a barrel, settling<br />
th<br />
at its highest since January 25 , <strong>2018</strong>. In a similar<br />
vein, precious commodities prices surged as<br />
escalating geopolitical risks saw investors seeking<br />
safe haven assets. Gold prices ascended by $4.93<br />
to $1,337.39 an ounce, while silver price grew by<br />
15 cents to $<strong>16</strong>.53. This week we anticipate oil<br />
prices will remain close to prevailing levels amidst<br />
rising tensions over military escalation in Syria. For<br />
precious metals, a combination of concerns over<br />
ongoing trade tensions between the U.S. and<br />
China and the prospect of a U.S. military strike in<br />
Syria will sustain safe haven demand and push<br />
prices higher.<br />
MONTHLY MACRO ECONOMIC FORECASTS<br />
Variables <strong>Apr</strong>’18 May’18 June’18<br />
Exchange Rate<br />
(Official) (N/$) 336.72 337.38 337.90<br />
Inflation Rate (%) 12.67 11.89 11.5<br />
Crude Oil Price<br />
(US$/Barrel) 68 67 67<br />
For enquiries, contact: Rotimi Peters (Team Lead, Economic Intelligence) (01) 2712123 rotimi.peters@accessbankplc.com
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
BUSINESS DAY<br />
25
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
26 BUSINESS DAY
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
C002D5556<br />
BUSINESS DAY<br />
27
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
28 BUSINESS DAY<br />
This is M NEY<br />
A daily guide to your Personal Finance<br />
• Savings<br />
• Travel<br />
• Debt & Borrowing<br />
• Utilities<br />
• Managing your Tax<br />
Reasons why you should<br />
have health insurance<br />
As important<br />
and beneficial<br />
as health insurance<br />
is, it is sad<br />
to find that the<br />
level of penetration in Nigeria<br />
is still less than 5 percent.<br />
It appears that the major<br />
reason for this is ignorance.<br />
Many Nigerians have never<br />
heard about health insurance,<br />
have no idea how it<br />
works – let alone its benefits<br />
– and therefore have<br />
not made any attempt to<br />
purchase it for themselves<br />
or their families.<br />
Here are the top seven<br />
reasons why you should<br />
have health insurance:<br />
You’re Protected When<br />
You Need Urgent and Unexpected<br />
Medical Attention<br />
Sickness and injuries do<br />
not always give advance<br />
notice. With a health insurance<br />
policy in place it is<br />
comforting to know that<br />
you can have access to good<br />
quality medical care when<br />
you fall ill unexpectedly,<br />
or when you’re injured in<br />
an accident and require<br />
urgent medical attention.<br />
Especially if this happens<br />
at a time when you’re not<br />
financially buoyant or in a<br />
position to be able to pay<br />
your hospital bill from your<br />
pocket.<br />
You Have Access To Better<br />
Quality Health Service<br />
With a health insurance<br />
policy in place, you are<br />
exposed to a wide range<br />
of options of care providers<br />
(medical facilities) to<br />
choose from. You can decide<br />
to choose an upscale provider<br />
(depending on your<br />
particular plan) which you<br />
might ordinarily not be able<br />
to afford on a pay-as-you-go<br />
basis.<br />
It Helps In Your Personal<br />
Financial Planning<br />
Your personal financial<br />
planning is made much<br />
easier when you are able to<br />
budget in advance for (at<br />
least a significant portion)<br />
of your healthcare expenditure.<br />
Health insurance gives<br />
you this advantage.<br />
It Is Cheaper For You On<br />
The Long Run<br />
A health insurance policy<br />
tends to be aggregately<br />
cheaper than a pay-as-yougo<br />
arrangement, especially<br />
when you have a tendency<br />
to fall ill often, as might<br />
sometimes happen. A oneoff<br />
premium payment covers<br />
you for the full period<br />
of the policy. You also have<br />
an opportunity to choose a<br />
plan to cover more serious<br />
medical procedures like<br />
minor surgeries and caesarian<br />
sections, which would<br />
otherwise be very expensive<br />
if you had to pay for them<br />
from your pocket.<br />
You Can Present It As A<br />
Gift Or Employee Benefit<br />
For employers of labour,<br />
health insurance is one of<br />
the most valuable employee<br />
benefits you can give to your<br />
employees. It does a great<br />
deal for employee moral<br />
when they know that the<br />
burden of healthcare costs<br />
is off their family budgets.<br />
You can also purchase<br />
a health insurance policy<br />
and present as a gift to your<br />
friends, parents and other<br />
loved ones. That’s certainly<br />
something to think about!<br />
It Will Help Develop<br />
The Health And Medical<br />
A good, effective and<br />
affordable health insurance<br />
system helps the society to<br />
move closer to universal access<br />
to healthcare, which is one<br />
of the ways to aggregately<br />
raise the quality of life of the<br />
citizens irrespective of their<br />
income group<br />
Sector<br />
As the demand for health<br />
insurance grows and more<br />
people get signed up, this<br />
will stimulate growth for<br />
the health sector in general<br />
as investors and medical<br />
entrepreneurs will be encouraged<br />
to build more hospitals,<br />
health facilities and<br />
diagnostic centres, more<br />
doctors and medical workers<br />
will need to be trained.<br />
Not only will the standard<br />
and quality of medical services<br />
for the citizens improve,<br />
it will become more<br />
accessible to many more<br />
people.<br />
It Allows Equitable Distribution<br />
of Health Costs<br />
Across Different Income<br />
Groups<br />
Health insurance serves<br />
as one of the ways of re-distributing<br />
wealth within the<br />
society. It helps in reducing<br />
the gap in the quality of life<br />
between the rich and the<br />
poor, because it enables<br />
the poor to also have access<br />
to a reasonably good<br />
and affordable quality of<br />
healthcare.<br />
A good, effective and affordable<br />
health insurance<br />
system helps the society to<br />
move closer to universal<br />
access to healthcare, which<br />
is one of the ways to aggregately<br />
raise the quality of life<br />
of the citizens irrespective of<br />
their income group.If you do<br />
not already have a health<br />
insurance policy, what are<br />
you waiting for?<br />
Unclaimed money recovery: Is it a scam or an opportunity?<br />
Have you been personally<br />
targeted<br />
by ads offering<br />
to help you find<br />
“unclaimed” money? If you<br />
immediately wrote them<br />
off as scams, you were wise<br />
— but that doesn’t mean<br />
unclaimed money itself is a<br />
scam. The US government<br />
estimates that billions of dollars<br />
each year go unclaimed,<br />
just as the advertisements<br />
say — and your name could<br />
be on some of it.<br />
No one says no to money<br />
that belongs to them. This<br />
is the reason unclaimed<br />
money scams are so widespread.<br />
Even if there’s only<br />
a slim chance you’ve inherited<br />
a fortune, you may be<br />
entitled to anything from<br />
a few dollars to a few hundred<br />
dollars — money that<br />
could go toward a savings<br />
goal, paying off debt, or just<br />
enjoying a nice dinner out.<br />
If you’re interested in reconnecting<br />
with your longlost<br />
dollars, it’s important<br />
to know how to recognize<br />
the scams and find legitimate<br />
sources. But, first, let’s<br />
discuss where all this unclaimed<br />
money comes from.<br />
Sometimes, people deposit<br />
a small sum in a savings<br />
account and forget<br />
about it, overpay a utility<br />
bill, or qualify for an unexpected<br />
tax refund. If they<br />
move and fail to leave a<br />
forwarding address, it can<br />
be impossible for the issuing<br />
party to locate them<br />
— especially if they move<br />
out of state. After a year,<br />
unclaimed property laws<br />
usually dictate that this<br />
money is returned to the<br />
state, where the sum is held<br />
until it can be returned to its<br />
rightful owner
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
This is M NEY<br />
A daily guide to your Personal Finance<br />
C002D5556<br />
BUSINESS DAY<br />
• Savings<br />
• Travel<br />
• Debt & Borrowing<br />
• Utilities<br />
• Managing your Tax<br />
29<br />
Worried about bank charges,<br />
here is how to reduce them<br />
Kenneth Doghudge<br />
Are bank charges<br />
causing you<br />
to have sleepless<br />
nights?<br />
Are you wondering<br />
why you must pay<br />
every time you perform a<br />
transaction? Seeing your<br />
bank charges add up to<br />
substantial sums can be irritating<br />
and annoying. The<br />
bank might provide poor<br />
service, or worse still refuse<br />
to support you. “And I still<br />
have to pay bank charges?”<br />
might be the question on<br />
your mind.<br />
So can we totally eliminate<br />
these charges? No.<br />
Banks provide financial<br />
services to the public. They<br />
are expected to charge customers<br />
and make a profit<br />
in return. Bank charges<br />
therefore represents compensation<br />
for services rendered.<br />
Alas without it no<br />
bank would be able to survive,<br />
let alone thrive.<br />
Bank charges may differ<br />
from country to country.<br />
There are certain climes<br />
where the government collects<br />
stamp duty, a type of<br />
tax on banking transactions<br />
in addition. Bank<br />
charges, like death and<br />
taxes have now become a<br />
fact of life. You can hardly<br />
fight or refuse to pay them.<br />
Banks take the money out<br />
of your account monthly.<br />
In fact, the more transactions<br />
you undertake the<br />
greater your bank charges.<br />
While bank charges are<br />
here to stay certain steps<br />
can be taken to reduce<br />
them to the barest minimum.<br />
You need to do the<br />
following:<br />
Acquaint thyself with<br />
your current exposure to<br />
bank charges<br />
Come to terms with<br />
your bank charges by making<br />
a detailed study of your<br />
statement. Request your<br />
statement from the bank<br />
and check, on a line by line<br />
basis transactions done<br />
in the month. Also check<br />
what your total charges<br />
amount to. You could be<br />
in for a rude awakening. I<br />
recently did, and it wasn’t<br />
a pleasant experience. I<br />
didn’t have a clue that I<br />
was spending so much<br />
on charges. You can only<br />
make changes when you<br />
understand the magnitude<br />
of the problem. Determine<br />
to reduce them<br />
Acquaint thyself with<br />
the number of transactions<br />
you initiate regularly<br />
How many bank transactions<br />
do you make in a<br />
day? Did you know that<br />
each time you use the<br />
ATM, POS machines, mobile<br />
and internet banking<br />
is one banking transaction?<br />
Each usage may have<br />
fees attached. Electronic<br />
deposits into your account<br />
also attract charges.<br />
Scan your bank statement<br />
to identify why so many<br />
transactions. Try to understand<br />
the reason behind<br />
each transaction to see if it<br />
could be stopped in subsequent<br />
periods.<br />
Paying recurring bills<br />
in cash<br />
It’s advisable to keep<br />
some loose cash to pay<br />
smaller and regular bills.<br />
At the beginning of the<br />
week withdraw certain<br />
amounts to cover all your<br />
recurring expenses. Petrol,<br />
Transport, Lunch,<br />
Telephone etc should be<br />
planned for. This will cause<br />
you to avoid whipping out<br />
your card to pay for these<br />
items thus causing your<br />
bank charges to skyrocket.<br />
Leave plastic cards at<br />
home whenever possible.<br />
Carrying your plastic<br />
cards everywhere you go is<br />
not a good idea. You should<br />
leave them at home from<br />
time to time. Planning what<br />
you want to spend on in advance<br />
can help minimise<br />
spending. You could then<br />
carry only the money for<br />
your planned spending on<br />
you. Try to make it a little<br />
bit harder to access your<br />
money wherever you go.<br />
Earmark several days<br />
as “no spending days”<br />
Plan and mark several<br />
days in your calendar as<br />
days where you won’t be<br />
spending any money. Start<br />
out with marking one day<br />
a week which could grow<br />
to several days a week.<br />
No spending amounts to<br />
no charges. So challenge<br />
yourself not to spend.<br />
You’re not going to die if<br />
you don’t spend I can assure.<br />
Having no spend<br />
days will help you manage<br />
your money better.<br />
Seek and use accounts<br />
with lower bank charges<br />
Currently there is a<br />
wide variety of bank account<br />
products. In the<br />
past it used to be only current<br />
and savings accounts.<br />
There are accounts for<br />
small and big businesses,<br />
children, students, retired<br />
people, high net worth individuals<br />
and so on. In addition<br />
there are accounts<br />
for investments, fixed deposits,<br />
mutual funds etc.<br />
Please research and weigh<br />
the pros and cons before<br />
you sign up for any account.<br />
Be constantly on<br />
the lookout for accounts<br />
with lower fees that best<br />
matches your requirements<br />
such as lower bank<br />
charges.<br />
Use debt wisely<br />
Be careful when you use<br />
debt. Especially when it is<br />
not for purposes that will<br />
bring more money into<br />
your pocket. For instance<br />
when you use your credit<br />
card to pay for items. If<br />
you don’t pay back within<br />
the time limit the bank will<br />
charge interest on the debt<br />
plus several fees for using<br />
the card. The same occurs<br />
when you have a loan facility.<br />
Interest rates and bank<br />
charges usually change<br />
in favor of the lender, not<br />
the lendee. Taking on debt<br />
usually causes your bank<br />
charges to increase significantly.<br />
Trim down the number<br />
of accounts you have<br />
The more accounts you<br />
operate/keep the more<br />
bank charges you pay out,<br />
pure and simple. Most<br />
people keep plenty of accounts.<br />
Some might have<br />
even gone dormant. I’m<br />
sure when you calculate<br />
your total bank charges<br />
in one year you might realise<br />
the level of wastage<br />
you have been exposed<br />
to. It’s time to streamline<br />
the number of accounts<br />
you have. There are several<br />
debates on how many accounts<br />
someone should<br />
have. I urge you to be<br />
mindful and not duplicate<br />
similar accounts unnecessarily.<br />
Permit me to re-emphasize<br />
that immediately<br />
after reading this you<br />
should get all your account<br />
statements. Work out how<br />
much you have been paying<br />
as bank charges in the<br />
last 1 year. Take time to<br />
implement all 8 key points<br />
listed above to reduce fees<br />
paid going forward. This<br />
is guaranteed to save you<br />
thousands yearly. Now<br />
who wouldn’t be happy<br />
with that?<br />
Kenneth promotes<br />
Moneytalk, a knowledge<br />
based organization committed<br />
to dispensing financial<br />
intelligence that leads<br />
to financial freedom.<br />
You can reach him with<br />
your feedback on money@<br />
moneytalkng.com or 070<br />
6337 3391 if you would like<br />
him to facilitate Money<br />
talks and lessons at your<br />
events, seminars or conferences<br />
over the weekend<br />
in the Lagos area.<br />
You can also visit www.<br />
moneytalkng.com for additional<br />
resources on financial<br />
intelligence.<br />
Taking firm decision about your retirement planning<br />
Pension and retirement<br />
funds<br />
are crucial to<br />
everybody. But<br />
unfortunately it<br />
is one of the least financial<br />
planning we think about.<br />
Eventually everybody has<br />
to stop working. After years<br />
of hard work you should be<br />
able to put your feet up and<br />
enjoy some peace.<br />
That is not the time to<br />
be worrying about your<br />
bills and other things that<br />
you need money to accomplish.<br />
So what happens to<br />
your expenses? They don’t<br />
go away. In fact, your essential<br />
expenditures may<br />
become more expensive if<br />
you factor in inflation. It is<br />
time to take action and if<br />
you have just started working,<br />
you can start early.<br />
Early planning is best<br />
for pension savings. A<br />
regular amount put away<br />
yields a lump sum amount<br />
through the years. There<br />
are many examples where<br />
a disciplined investment<br />
started early has proved<br />
to be more beneficial than<br />
chaotic lumps at irregular<br />
intervals. So start early.<br />
Subsequently is regarding<br />
the amount to be saved<br />
each month. How much is<br />
sufficient? Well, that depends<br />
on your ability to<br />
pay. Try to put away a fixed<br />
amount. As it is always said<br />
pay yourself first when you<br />
receive your salary or income<br />
each month.<br />
If you are employed try<br />
to save in work linked pen-<br />
sion plans in which your<br />
employer contributes some<br />
amount. This is beneficial<br />
as these pension schemes<br />
are invested in government<br />
bonds and offer good returns<br />
with stability.<br />
Many things have to be<br />
considered when picking<br />
a pension plan. Find out<br />
how much of your pension<br />
is taxable and at what<br />
percentage. It pays to take<br />
the advice of your personal<br />
financial planners or legal<br />
adviser who has experience<br />
and knowledge in<br />
pension and retirement<br />
program. They are not part<br />
of any one organization<br />
pushing those plans. They<br />
will work individually with<br />
you to provide the best plan<br />
exclusively based on your<br />
needs.<br />
Find out if the pensions<br />
or at least a part of it will go<br />
to your spouse or dependents.<br />
So not blindly trust<br />
that it will automatically go<br />
to them. Read the fine print!<br />
Take charge and do not be<br />
a passive participant.<br />
Usually pension money<br />
is retained with the employer<br />
till a worker retires.<br />
It is good to know whether<br />
this money is safe and in<br />
the event of employer declaring<br />
bankruptcy or going<br />
out of business what<br />
happens to the money.<br />
Always ask relevant questions<br />
and never assume<br />
things. The stakes are simply<br />
too high.<br />
You should also start<br />
investing in bonds and<br />
share market early on in<br />
your career.
30 BUSINESS DAY<br />
C002D5556<br />
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
SMART MONEY with Arese<br />
What is killing Nigeria’s earning potential?<br />
During his visit<br />
to Nigeria, Bill<br />
Gates made<br />
some remarks<br />
to Nigerian<br />
leaders about the economy.<br />
The central message was:<br />
invest in human capital to<br />
achieve sustained prosperity,<br />
which should be a no<br />
brainer; a skilled labor force<br />
has a significant impact on<br />
growth because skilled workers<br />
are more productive.<br />
However, it got me thinking<br />
about a more specific problem<br />
with the Nigerian education<br />
system and its effect on<br />
our ability to earn.<br />
When it comes to education,<br />
the emphasis is usually<br />
on giving more people access<br />
at different levels of schooling.<br />
However, the greater<br />
reality we have to face is that,<br />
the quality of the students we<br />
are churning out, especially<br />
at the tertiary stage is subpar<br />
and this has a monumental<br />
effect on our economy.<br />
An under qualified labor<br />
force can’t solve complex<br />
problems and ironically,<br />
the no 1-finance question<br />
millennials ask is how can<br />
I make more money? However,<br />
one’s earning power is<br />
directly linked to the complexity<br />
of the problem they<br />
are able to solve. There in lies<br />
the problem because three<br />
things seem to be missing.<br />
1. The Adoption of Critical<br />
thinking<br />
When I was in secondary<br />
school, I was a top three<br />
student in subjects like economics<br />
and government.<br />
I loved these subjects; so<br />
naturally, in my mind I was<br />
a superstar! I attended Igbinedion<br />
Education Centre,<br />
which was considered one<br />
of the best private schools in<br />
the 90s but Imagine my surprise<br />
when I subsequently<br />
went to The British School of<br />
Lome and discovered that in<br />
actual fact, I knew nothing! I<br />
was shocked and confused.<br />
You see in Nigerian<br />
schools, we learn to cram<br />
theory and regurgitate definitions,<br />
so we can pass ex-<br />
Arese Ugwu<br />
ams but we don’t learn to<br />
truly understand, analyze<br />
and apply. So even though<br />
I knew the definitions of<br />
demand and supply, my<br />
teachers in BSL were not<br />
impressed. They didn’t care<br />
about the fact that I could<br />
recite the definitions of several<br />
economic terms exactly<br />
as they were in the textbooks;<br />
they were more concerned<br />
with my inability to understand<br />
the concepts and apply<br />
them to real world scenarios.<br />
My thoughts on how a war in<br />
Bottom line we<br />
need more vocational<br />
schools!<br />
Lets stop pushing<br />
people into professions<br />
they can<br />
never thrive in<br />
Iraq would impact Nigeria’s<br />
income were more relevant<br />
to them than definitions.<br />
Another shocking concept<br />
for me in this journey of critical<br />
thinking was the fact that<br />
we could actually challenge<br />
our teachers! What a wawuu!<br />
Dr Sindall actually expected<br />
us to question the validity<br />
of his answers because according<br />
to him there were<br />
no wrong responses to his<br />
questions, just different perspectives<br />
and proper justifications<br />
for the assumptions<br />
that we made.<br />
Meanwhile in Nigeria,<br />
our teachers were always<br />
right and in most cases any<br />
variation from the teacher’s<br />
prescribed answer was classified<br />
as wrong, which left little<br />
room for original thought.<br />
Nothing highlights the folly<br />
in this teaching style and<br />
its unfortunate impact on<br />
the productivity of Nigerian<br />
youths like the phrase ‘This<br />
is how we do it here’.<br />
When I first moved back<br />
to Nigeria, nothing frustrated<br />
me more than this<br />
phrase! Let me explain! It is<br />
extremely important to put<br />
processes in place so that<br />
there is structure in a business<br />
but it must never be at<br />
the expense of encouraging<br />
people to use their initiative.<br />
Most staff are taught 1+1 =2<br />
so when they see that sum,<br />
they are clear on how to solve<br />
the problem. However, if they<br />
encounter the same problem<br />
with different elements to the<br />
sum i.e. 6 minus 4 equals 2,<br />
they are thrown for a loop<br />
because in their minds, only<br />
1 +1 can equal 2.<br />
If we really want to increase<br />
the productivity of<br />
businesses and subsequently<br />
the economy, critical thinking<br />
must be employed to<br />
boost our ability to solve<br />
problems and understand<br />
logical connections between<br />
ideas.<br />
2. Leverage social media<br />
and technology as tools<br />
for teaching<br />
Social media gets a bad rep,<br />
especially in corporate Nigeria.<br />
There’s the perception<br />
that millennials are so<br />
preoccupied with things like<br />
Big Brother Naija and other<br />
frivolities on social media,<br />
which is true. However, I<br />
think it’s more important<br />
to convert that engagement<br />
and preoccupation into gold<br />
by using it as a medium to<br />
educate. Instead of being<br />
so focused on highlighting<br />
the dangers of social media,<br />
companies need to be leveraging<br />
it as a medium to re<br />
educate their staff and educate<br />
their customers about<br />
their products and services.<br />
Technology has made the<br />
world a smaller place, so<br />
education is basically at your<br />
fingertips and there’s access<br />
to the best practices from all<br />
over the globe. But are we<br />
using it effectively?<br />
3. Can we get over our obsession<br />
with certificates?<br />
When all is said and done<br />
we like book in this country<br />
sha! No one is cockier than a<br />
Nigerian that is armed with<br />
several degrees and qualifications.<br />
It has become an obsession<br />
with us! But what do<br />
these degrees really mean?<br />
When the people who are<br />
chasing them are not seeking<br />
a deeper understanding<br />
or application of the knowledge<br />
but are caught up in<br />
the chase of what these certificates<br />
could mean for their<br />
job prospects. At this point<br />
the degrees become hollow.<br />
It’s a pretty regular occurrence<br />
to find people who<br />
went to university, to pursue<br />
a degree they despised, because<br />
their parents wanted<br />
them to. However, what has<br />
become even sadder is meeting<br />
people who are pursuing<br />
professional qualifications of<br />
their own volition, in fields<br />
they have zero interest in,<br />
because it might improve<br />
their job prospects. I’m all<br />
for continued learning because<br />
no matter how intelligent<br />
you are, constantly<br />
improving your expertise<br />
and sharpening your skills<br />
is key to success but can I<br />
ask a question? Why are so<br />
many people studying for<br />
ACCA and ICAN when they<br />
have no interest in becoming<br />
accountants? It is counter<br />
productive! Why not spend<br />
time on something you are<br />
actually passionate about<br />
and are in the best position to<br />
get good at instead becoming<br />
mediocre at something you<br />
have zero interest in.<br />
Now I haven’t figured out<br />
whom to blame for this phenomenon,<br />
the employers?<br />
Who demand these excessive<br />
qualifications that have<br />
no bearing on the job in<br />
question or the labor force?<br />
Who haven’t figured out that<br />
there’s little point in chasing<br />
hollow qualifications they<br />
have no passion for and<br />
that most people who thrive<br />
and become successful, put<br />
themselves in situations<br />
where they have matched<br />
their interests with their skill<br />
set and focus on being the<br />
best at it.<br />
Bottom line we need more<br />
vocational schools! Lets stop<br />
pushing people into professions<br />
they can never thrive in!
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
BUSINESS DAY<br />
31<br />
CITYFile<br />
A scene of an accident at Maryland in Lagos on Friday.<br />
Lagos pays N36bn pension<br />
to retirees in 3 years<br />
JOSHUA BASSEY<br />
Lagos State Government says about<br />
N35.9 billion has been remitted to<br />
the Retirement Saving Accounts<br />
(RSAs) of 8,731 retirees, deceased<br />
and withdrawn staff of the state<br />
public service between August 2015 and date.<br />
However, in the last one year, May 2017<br />
to March <strong>2018</strong>, the state paid N9.3 billion<br />
pension to 2,466 retirees.<br />
Akintola Oke, the commissioner for<br />
establishment, training and pensions, who<br />
released the figures during a session with<br />
media to mark the present administration’s<br />
three years in office, said the sums were paid<br />
to the beneficiaries through Lagos State Pension<br />
Commission (LASPEC).<br />
He said there has been continued significant<br />
reduction in outstanding backlog of terminal<br />
entitlements of retired public servants.<br />
Offa robbery: Kwara to acquire additional APCs<br />
To beef up security in Offa and strategic<br />
locations across Kwara, the state<br />
governor, Abdulfatah Ahmed, says<br />
his government will procure additional<br />
Armoured Personnel Carriers (APCs),<br />
and as well build a new police station for Offa<br />
within the next 45 days.<br />
The governor however, urged well-meaning<br />
citizens of the state to resist attempt by<br />
anyone to use the unfortunate Offa robbery<br />
attack for political purposes.<br />
Ahmed, who stated this during the<br />
swearing-in of a new Khadi of the state<br />
Shariah Court of Appeal, Mas’ud Adebayo<br />
Oniye, frowned at utterances made to score<br />
political gain.<br />
According to the governor, “those utterances<br />
do not reflect our values as Kwarans<br />
and should stop, out of respect for the dead<br />
According to the commissioner, the<br />
current administration commenced and<br />
maintained the trend of paying terminal<br />
entitlements of retired employees monthly,<br />
since August 2015.<br />
“The ministry will continue to sensitise<br />
retirees on activities of pension fraudsters so<br />
that they will get their entitlements without<br />
hitch,” he said, adding that about 8,000 pensioners<br />
aged above 70 have been identified<br />
to receive packages from the state government<br />
this year.<br />
On the payment of death benefit, he said<br />
that 80 beneficiaries of deceased employees<br />
in the state were paid N220.7 million within<br />
the period.<br />
The commissioner said that the state’s<br />
Public Service Staff Development Centre<br />
trained 3, 737 officers in the last one year.<br />
The training, he said provided solutions<br />
to problems on human capacity through<br />
learning and development initiatives, using<br />
... as ACF urges FG to equip Nigeria Police<br />
SIKIRAT SHEHU, Ilorin<br />
and the injured”.<br />
Ahmed assured Kwarans that government<br />
will do everything within its power to<br />
ensure that the people of Offa and Kwara<br />
State never experience such a tragedy again.<br />
“For the avoidance of doubt, let me<br />
reassure Kwarans that the culprits will be<br />
apprehended and brought to justice swiftly.<br />
“Presently, the police and other security<br />
agencies in the country have begun a vigorous<br />
manhunt for the perpetrators of the<br />
dastardly and horrid attack on the peaceful<br />
and industrious people of Offa,” he said<br />
Ahmed advised that “our people must<br />
be vigilant and security conscious as part<br />
of community involvement in effective<br />
policing”.<br />
“Those who perpetrated this evil have<br />
saddened and inflicted pain on us but they<br />
cannot break our spirit. I assure you that<br />
those behind this wicked act will soon be<br />
NAN<br />
technology-driven resources.<br />
“The essence is not only for self-development,<br />
but for the skills and knowledge<br />
acquired to be deployed on the job for impactful<br />
service delivery to teeming populace<br />
of Lagos State,” he said.<br />
The commissioner, who commended the<br />
17 labour unions in the state public service,<br />
said “it is historic to note that in the last three<br />
years, this administration has not witnessed<br />
any form of crisis, protests or agitations by<br />
labour unions.”<br />
He said the unions’ National Joint Negotiating<br />
Council (NJNC) met and interacted<br />
with government four times yearly to take<br />
decisions on issues pertaining to workers’<br />
welfare and promote industrial harmony.<br />
He assured that government would intensify<br />
efforts towards motivating and training<br />
the civil servants for better service delivery<br />
and protection of interest of residents of<br />
the state.<br />
apprehended and brought to justice swiftly”,<br />
he added.<br />
Meanwhile, the Arewa Consultative<br />
Forum (ACF) has called on the Federal Government<br />
to properly equip the Nigeria Police<br />
Force to enable it to effectively discharge its<br />
responsibilities.<br />
Mohammed Ibrahim, the national publicity<br />
secretary of the Forum, in a statement<br />
in Kaduna, weekend, that the group was<br />
shocked by the attacks on some banks in<br />
Offa which left about 30 people and several<br />
others injured.<br />
“It was most unfortunate that innocent<br />
persons and security personnel were killed<br />
by the armed robbers while some persons<br />
sustained injuries.<br />
“We are, however, heartened by the<br />
prompt action of the Inspector General of<br />
Police (IGP) in deploying units of Mobile<br />
Police which led to arrest of some of the<br />
perpetrators of this heinous crime and the<br />
restoration of normalcy in Offa town.<br />
8 Boko Haram kingpins<br />
arrested in Borno<br />
The Nigeria Security and Civil Defence<br />
Corps (NSCDC) said it has<br />
arrested 8 Boko Haram kingpins<br />
who fled Borno.<br />
The Corps also said last weekend in<br />
Abuja that over 100 suspected vandals of<br />
critical infrastructure also apprehended<br />
between January and March, are presently<br />
facing prosecution.<br />
Abdullahi Gana, the commandantgeneral<br />
of the Corps, disclosed this<br />
when he received participants of course<br />
40/<strong>2018</strong> of the National Institute for Policy<br />
and Strategic Studies (NIPSS) Kuru, led by<br />
Humphrey Okpala<br />
Gana explained that the successes<br />
recorded by the NSCDC were as a result<br />
of the collaborative efforts of the Civilian<br />
Joint Task Force which he said had proved<br />
to be one of the useful tools for community<br />
policing.<br />
He said the corps was not in rivalry<br />
with sister agencies, but “rather cherishes<br />
and always works in synergy with<br />
other agencies in combating crimes in<br />
the country.”<br />
“This synergy has worked in the North-<br />
East where the Corps’ personnel arrested<br />
Boko Haram members and handed them<br />
over to the army.<br />
“In states like Taraba, Plateau and<br />
Jigawa, armed robbers and rapists were<br />
arrested recently, and were handed over<br />
to the police,” he said.<br />
AVM Okpala told the NSCDC boss that<br />
the visit was to find out the Corps’ position<br />
on the ongoing research directed by<br />
the Federal Government to strengthen the<br />
nation’s internal security framework and<br />
community policing.<br />
“The institute was mandated to carry<br />
out the research in order to come up with<br />
strategy to tackle burning issues through<br />
interaction with stakeholders with a view<br />
to reporting back to the President accordingly,”<br />
he said.<br />
Malaria: CRS adopts Edo<br />
style of net distribution<br />
The Country Representative, Catholic<br />
Relief Services (CRS), Rebecca Hallam,<br />
says the organisation has adopted the<br />
Edo Government model of distribution of insecticidal<br />
nets for other states in the country.<br />
Hallam said in Benin when she visited<br />
the Edo deputy governor, Philip Shaibu, in<br />
Benin.<br />
“We have learnt some new formula in the<br />
course of the assignment which we will use<br />
in other states. I commend Edo government<br />
for her swift response in addressing challenges<br />
encountered during the exercise and<br />
call on other states to emulate Edo,’’ she said.<br />
Responding, Shaibu said the state government’s<br />
commitment was part of her<br />
resolve to reposition primary healthcare and<br />
strengthening the health sector.<br />
Shaibu acknowledged that the net distribution<br />
was an avenue for both parties<br />
to share ideas, as the state team also learnt<br />
some models from the CRS team.<br />
“The exercise is also a means for the state<br />
government to obtain data to implement<br />
other programmes in the primary healthcare<br />
sector. The remaining nets from the exercise<br />
will be distributed to areas not covered during<br />
the exercise, after proper data analysis of<br />
the previous exercise to cover the remaining<br />
12 per cent,’’ Shuaibu said.<br />
The deputy governor called on other state<br />
governments to learn from Edo where chief<br />
executives personally monitor the distribution<br />
to ensure its success. NAN
32<br />
BUSINESS DAY<br />
C002D5556<br />
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong>
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
BUSINESS DAY<br />
33
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
34 BUSINESS DAY
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
C002D5556<br />
BUSINESS DAY 35<br />
Stocks Currencies Commodities Rates + Bonds Economics Funds Week Ahead Watchlist P.E<br />
Yield curve flattens on Fiscal and<br />
monetary policy synchronisation<br />
FSDH sees Nigeria inflation slowing for<br />
fourteen successive months to 13.49%<br />
Page 36 Page 36<br />
ECONOMY<br />
Dangote Cement, CCNN beat industry<br />
average as Lafarge gets red flag<br />
BALA AUGIE<br />
Dangote Cement,<br />
CCNN beat industry<br />
average<br />
as Lafarge gets<br />
red flag BALA<br />
AUGIE percent, according<br />
to data compiled by <strong>BusinessDay</strong>.<br />
However, Lafarge<br />
Africa’s <strong>16</strong>.<strong>16</strong> gross margins<br />
were below the above average<br />
as the company continues<br />
to grapple with rising cost<br />
of production brought on by<br />
spiraling variable costs and<br />
costs incurred on evacuation<br />
at UNICEM. Dangote Cement<br />
and CCNN have a better<br />
energy mix as they were<br />
able to develop coal fire plant.<br />
That explains why they have<br />
spent less in producing each<br />
unit of product. While Dangote<br />
Cement and CCNN’s<br />
net margin of 25.35 percent<br />
and <strong>16</strong>.45 percent were above<br />
the industry average of 10.08<br />
percent, Lafarge’s huge loss<br />
of 34.01 billion validates its<br />
negative retained earnings<br />
of 11.45 percent. Lafarge is<br />
highly indebted or highly<br />
geared as its debt to equity<br />
ratio of <strong>16</strong>3.25 percent is<br />
the highest in the industry.<br />
Lafarge (WAPCO) Plc had a<br />
Year-To-Date (YTD) return<br />
at the negative trajectory at<br />
-0.87 percent. This is way<br />
below the NSE ASI of 7.02<br />
percent as market close for<br />
the week, Friday, <strong>Apr</strong>il 13,<br />
<strong>2018</strong>. Dangote Cement Plc<br />
gained 13.04 percent on YTD<br />
return basis, 6.02 percentage<br />
point higher than the NSE<br />
ASI of 7.02 percent.<br />
CCNN Plc was the best<br />
performing stock with the<br />
highest return YTD on the Nigerian<br />
Stock Exchange (NSE).<br />
It has gained 105.43per cent<br />
alone so far this year. CCNN<br />
The Cement Company of<br />
Northern Nigeria (CCNN)<br />
Plc’s profit after tax stood at<br />
N3.22 billion as at December<br />
2017, representing a 106.50<br />
percent surge from the N1.56<br />
billion recorded five years<br />
ago. Revenue followed the<br />
same growth trajectory, hitting<br />
N19.58 billion in December<br />
2017. This represented a<br />
29.83 percent increase from<br />
the N15.31 billion recorded in<br />
December 2013. The company’s<br />
shares have gained 71.31<br />
percent since January 2, 2015,<br />
to close at N17.80 at close of<br />
trading day on Wednesday<br />
<strong>Apr</strong>il 6, <strong>2018</strong>. The relative<br />
peace in the northern part<br />
of the country and low competition<br />
where the company<br />
supplies cement were major<br />
drivers of utilisation rates for<br />
the company.<br />
The cement maker is efficient<br />
in deploying shareholders’<br />
resources in generating<br />
higher profit as net profit<br />
margins hit <strong>16</strong>.25 percent<br />
in the period under review,<br />
a 0.60 point increase from<br />
10.23 percent recorded five<br />
years ago.<br />
Lafarge<br />
Lafarge Africa Plc is grappling<br />
with spiralling cost of<br />
production as rising interest<br />
on borrowing wiped out all of<br />
earnings, leaving the cement<br />
maker in a loss position. For<br />
the year ended December<br />
2017, Lafarge Africa posted<br />
a loss after tax of N34.60<br />
billon from a profit position<br />
of N<strong>16</strong>.89 billion the previous<br />
year, the worst results in<br />
five years since <strong>BusinessDay</strong><br />
started compiling data. A<br />
N43.02 billion finance costs<br />
or interest expense in the<br />
income statement in the<br />
period under review swallowed<br />
all of operating profit<br />
of N7.88 billion, which inevitably<br />
resulted in the loss. It is<br />
glaring that Lafarge Africa is<br />
exposed to financial risk as<br />
its debt pile has resulted in<br />
increased interest payment<br />
hence suppressing bottom<br />
line (profit). Consequently,<br />
risk of stockholders return<br />
is increased. Times interest<br />
coverage is 0.18 times operating<br />
profit in the period<br />
under review, which means<br />
the cement maker’s ability to<br />
meet interest expenses are<br />
questionable.<br />
Dangote Cement<br />
A breakdown of the combined<br />
profit in the period<br />
under review showed Dangote<br />
Cement Plc, the largest<br />
producer of the building<br />
material recorded a net income<br />
of N204.24 billion, from<br />
N159.50 billion recorded in<br />
2013. The largest producer<br />
of the building material in<br />
Africa’s largest economy has<br />
utilized each unit of sales<br />
in generating higher profit<br />
as margins improved. This<br />
means it is efficient amid<br />
a tough and unpredictable<br />
macroeconomic environment.<br />
Earnings before interest<br />
and tax (EBIT) margin<br />
increased to 37.76 percent<br />
in December 2017 as against<br />
29.66 percent as at December<br />
20<strong>16</strong>. Gross profit margins<br />
moved to 56.39 percent in<br />
the period under review as<br />
against 47.35 percent the<br />
previous year. Net margin<br />
increased to 25.35 percent<br />
in the period under review<br />
as against 23.22 percent as<br />
at December 20<strong>16</strong>. Cost of<br />
sales ratio fell to 43.66 percent<br />
in the period under review<br />
from 52.64 percent the previous<br />
year as the company<br />
switched to coal, a cheap<br />
source of energy to power<br />
plant at the factory. Dangote<br />
Cement’s sales grew<br />
by 30.96 percent to N805.58<br />
Continues on page 36<br />
SHORT TAKES<br />
25 kobo<br />
Nigerian Aviation Handling<br />
proposes final dividend of<br />
25 kobo per ordinary share<br />
for period ended December<br />
31, 2017.<br />
34 percent<br />
Nigeria’s state oil<br />
company NNPC’s<br />
engineering subsidiary<br />
on Friday<br />
reported a 34 percent<br />
fall in 2017<br />
profit before tax to<br />
N3.26 billion ($10.4<br />
million) compared<br />
with the previous<br />
year.<br />
Foreign exchange<br />
gains of 56 percent<br />
before tax in 20<strong>16</strong><br />
fell to 4.8 percent<br />
in 2017, NNPC<br />
spokesman Ndu<br />
Ughamadu said in<br />
a statement.<br />
N237.8 MILLION<br />
Guinea Insurance posts<br />
rise in full year December<br />
2017 profit before taxation<br />
of N237.8 million versus<br />
N176.2 million a year ago.<br />
It recorded full year net<br />
premium income of N747<br />
million naira versus N649.5<br />
million a year ago<br />
<strong>BusinessDay</strong> MARKETS INTELLIGENCE (Team lead: BALA AUGIE - Analyst: DIPO OLADEHINDE, ENDURANCE OKAFOR, BUNMI BAILEY Graphics: DAVID OGAR )<br />
BMI provides in-depth analysis and data on industries, companies, stocks, currencies, fixed income/credit, economics, regulation and factors that influence investor’s decision-making<br />
Email the BMI team patrick.atuanya@businessdayonline.com
36 BUSINESS DAY C002D5556 Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
ECONOMY<br />
ENDURANCE OKAFOR<br />
Source: NSE,<strong>BusinessDay</strong><br />
port Group Plc with a market<br />
capitalisation of N8.879<br />
billion, traded at N 2.65 per<br />
share in the NSE and recorded<br />
105.43percent gain as<br />
it YTD return. Making it the<br />
third best performing stock<br />
in the nation’s bourse.<br />
NPF Microfinance Bank<br />
Plc made the list of Business-<br />
Day’s best five performing<br />
stock YTD as it gained some<br />
61.60 percent as at the close<br />
of market Friday, <strong>Apr</strong>il 13,<br />
<strong>2018</strong>.<br />
Markets Intelligence<br />
These stocks made money<br />
for investors last week<br />
The stocks of Cement<br />
CO. of North<br />
Nig. Plc, Caverton<br />
Offshore Support<br />
Group Plc, Unity<br />
Bank Plc, NPF Microfinance<br />
Bank Plc, and Wema Bank<br />
Plc were the best performing<br />
stocks on a year-to-date<br />
(YTD) basis, as they had the<br />
highest return at market close<br />
Friday, <strong>Apr</strong>il 13, <strong>2018</strong>.<br />
Cement CO. of North Nig.<br />
Plc was the best performing<br />
stock with the highest return<br />
YTD on the Nigerian Stock<br />
Exchange (NSE). It gained<br />
112.63 percent alone so far<br />
this year and it close the market<br />
with N20.20 per share and<br />
has a market capitalisation of<br />
N25.385 billion.<br />
Unity Bank Plc is one of the<br />
best stocks so far for this year<br />
among lenders. Shares gained<br />
109.43 per cent to date.<br />
The bank which provides<br />
a range of financial products<br />
and services to personal<br />
and business customers has<br />
a market capitalization of<br />
N12.975 billion and traded<br />
N1.11 per share, as at market<br />
close for the week.<br />
Caverton Offshore Sup-<br />
Dangote Cement, CCNN beat<br />
industry average...<br />
Five states hardest hit by rising inflation amid potential food shortage in March<br />
DIPO OLADEHINDE<br />
Nasarawa, Ebonyi,<br />
Bauchi, Kaduna and<br />
Gombe states are the<br />
top five states in March <strong>2018</strong><br />
that have recorded the highest<br />
level of inflation rates compared<br />
to the previous month of February,<br />
data from Nigeria Bureau of<br />
Statistics (NBS) showed.<br />
According to the NBS data,<br />
the state with the highest inflation<br />
rate Month on Month was<br />
Nasarawa State with inflation<br />
rate of 2.20 percent, followed<br />
closely by Ebonyi State with an<br />
inflation rate of 2.10 per cent,<br />
while Bauchi, Kaduna and<br />
Gombe states had 1.87 percent,<br />
1.76 percent, and 1.57 percent<br />
inflation rate respectively to<br />
complete list of top five states<br />
with the highest level of inflation<br />
in March <strong>2018</strong>.<br />
Dolapo Ashiru, CEO of<br />
Mega Capital Financial services<br />
Limited said the high cost of<br />
doing business in these states<br />
is the reason for the high level<br />
of inflation and further tasked<br />
the government to do more in<br />
increasing investment.<br />
“Basically, it has to do with<br />
government driving investment<br />
in infrastructure, power, technology<br />
and other important<br />
amenities with the purpose of<br />
bringing down the cost of doing<br />
business in these states,”<br />
Dolapo told <strong>BusinessDay</strong> by<br />
Phone.<br />
Speaking on how states<br />
can generate more revenue,<br />
Ashiru added,” State government<br />
should drive their IGR<br />
and implement policies that<br />
will drive investment in area<br />
of specialization or strength,<br />
also Government need to cut<br />
wastage and reduce recurrent<br />
expenditure.”<br />
<strong>BusinessDay</strong>’s investigations<br />
showed food inflation<br />
Month on Month was highest in<br />
Nasarawa State at 3.22 percent<br />
followed closely by Ebonyi state<br />
with 2.97 percent, while Jigawa<br />
state had 2.37 percent respectively<br />
to make up the top three<br />
states with highest food inflation<br />
rate among the 36 states in<br />
Nigeria while Kebbi, Imo. Niger,<br />
Kwara, Lagos, Rivers and Yobe<br />
states all recorded food price<br />
The microfinance Bank<br />
which provides a wide range<br />
of banking products and<br />
services to consumers traded<br />
at N2.20 per share in the NSE<br />
and it has a market capitalization<br />
of N4.619billion.<br />
Wema Bank Plc was one of<br />
the lenders that made the list<br />
also as the bank gained 76.92<br />
percent as it YTD return. The<br />
bank with a market capitalization<br />
of N 35.489 billion,<br />
traded at N 0.92, as compiled<br />
from the Bloomberg data.<br />
deflation or negative inflation<br />
which is the general decrease in<br />
the general price level of goods<br />
and services or a negative inflation<br />
rate in March <strong>2018</strong>.<br />
Food security is an aspect<br />
of government that no nation<br />
that is worth its salt can afford to<br />
take for granted. It is defined by<br />
the United Nations’ Committee<br />
on World Food Security, as the<br />
condition in which all people,<br />
at all times, have physical, social<br />
and economic access to sufficient<br />
safe and nutritious food<br />
that meets their dietary needs<br />
and food preferences for an<br />
active and healthy life.<br />
Benue State, the famed Food<br />
Basket of Nigeria, for instance<br />
has in recent times suffered<br />
unimaginable setbacks oc-<br />
The Nigerian Stock Exchange<br />
All Share Index (NSE<br />
ASI) appreciated Friday, <strong>Apr</strong>il<br />
13, <strong>2018</strong>, as it recorded a gain<br />
of 0.29 percent to close at<br />
40,928.70 points<br />
Similarly, the Market<br />
Capitalization appreciated<br />
by 0.29 percent to close at<br />
N14.78trn, compared with<br />
the marginal depreciation<br />
of 0.09 percent recorded the<br />
previous day. Week-on-week,<br />
the NSE ASI appreciated by<br />
0.21 percent.<br />
casioned by frequent farmers<br />
and herders’ clashes, so much<br />
that fears have been expressed<br />
that if not checked, we might be<br />
running a serious risk of famine<br />
in the near future.<br />
The National Economic<br />
Council (NEC) at one of its<br />
meetings had said that there will<br />
be food crisis in Nigeria unless<br />
the displacement of farmers resulting<br />
from incessant conflicts<br />
between them and pastoralists<br />
is immediately addressed.<br />
The Council after a closed<br />
door meeting at the Presidential<br />
Villa reportedly said it was worried<br />
about the displacement of<br />
farmers and felt that unless it was<br />
immediately addressed, there<br />
would be shortage of food in the<br />
entire country in the near future.<br />
Continued from page 35<br />
billon in December 2017<br />
from N615.10 billion as at December<br />
20<strong>16</strong>. A breakdown<br />
of sales by region shows the<br />
Nigerian business make up<br />
68.59 percent (N552.36 billion<br />
) of total revenue while<br />
Pan Africa make up 32.08<br />
percent (N258.44 billion).<br />
The company’s cement<br />
volume stood at 21.22 million<br />
metric tonnes as at December<br />
2017, which represents<br />
5.81 percent drop from 22.53<br />
million metric tonnes for last<br />
year. Cement production<br />
capacity increased slightly by<br />
2.35 percent to 43.55 million<br />
metric tonnes in the period<br />
under review from 42.55 million<br />
metric tonnes.<br />
Dangote Cement<br />
A breakdown of the combined<br />
profit in the period<br />
under review showed Dangote<br />
Cement Plc, the largest<br />
producer of the building<br />
material recorded a net income<br />
of N204.24 billion, from<br />
N159.50 billion recorded in<br />
2013. The largest producer<br />
of the building material in<br />
Africa’s largest economy has<br />
utilized each unit of sales<br />
in generating higher profit<br />
as margins improved. This<br />
means it is efficient amid<br />
a tough and unpredictable<br />
macroeconomic environment.<br />
Earnings before interest<br />
and tax (EBIT) margin<br />
For the 14th consecutive<br />
time since January 2017, inflation<br />
rate inched closer to the<br />
single digits target set by both<br />
monetary and fiscal authorities<br />
for the economy.<br />
Latest figures released on<br />
Thursday by NBS showed Consumer<br />
Price Index (CPI), which<br />
measures inflation level in the<br />
economy, increased by 13.34<br />
per cent between March 2017<br />
and March <strong>2018</strong>.<br />
The statistics agency said<br />
the new figure was about 0.99<br />
per cent points less than the<br />
14.33 per cent rate recorded in<br />
February <strong>2018</strong>.<br />
During the last Monetary<br />
Policy Committee (MPC) meeting<br />
last week in Abuja, the Central<br />
Bank of Nigeria (CBN)<br />
Governor, Godwin Emefiele,<br />
said members resolved to retain<br />
all controlling policy rates at<br />
prevailing levels until inflation<br />
rate dropped to the single digits<br />
zone.<br />
Apart from Monetary Policy<br />
Rate (MPR), also known as<br />
lending rate, which was retained<br />
at 14 per cent, liquidity<br />
rate was maintained at 30 per<br />
cent.<br />
Also, cash reserve requirement,<br />
the amount of cash the<br />
banks are allowed to keep in<br />
their reserves, was kept at 22.5<br />
per cent.<br />
The Asymmetric corridor<br />
was left at +200 and -500 basis<br />
points around the MPR as it was<br />
during the previous meeting in<br />
November 2017.<br />
increased to 37.76 percent<br />
in December 2017 as against<br />
29.66 percent as at December<br />
20<strong>16</strong>. Gross profit margins<br />
moved to 56.39 percent in<br />
the period under review as<br />
against 47.35 percent the<br />
previous year. Net margin<br />
increased to 25.35 percent<br />
in the period under review<br />
as against 23.22 percent<br />
as at December 20<strong>16</strong>. Cost<br />
of sales ratio fell to 43.66<br />
percent in the period under<br />
review from 52.64 percent<br />
the previous year as the<br />
company switched to coal,<br />
a cheap source of energy to<br />
power plant at the factory.<br />
Dangote Cement’s sales<br />
grew by 30.96 percent to<br />
N805.58 billon in December<br />
2017 from N615.10 billion<br />
as at December 20<strong>16</strong>.<br />
A breakdown of sales by<br />
region shows the Nigerian<br />
business make up 68.59<br />
percent (N552.36 billion )<br />
of total revenue while Pan<br />
Africa make up 32.08 percent<br />
(N258.44 billion).<br />
The company’s cement<br />
volume stood at 21.22 million<br />
metric tonnes as at December<br />
2017, which represents<br />
5.81 percent drop from 22.53<br />
million metric tonnes for last<br />
year. Cement production<br />
capacity increased slightly by<br />
2.35 percent to 43.55 million<br />
metric tonnes in the period<br />
under review from 42.55 million<br />
metric tonnes.<br />
In the NBS report, composite<br />
food index, which highlights<br />
the average of some food items,<br />
majorly staple foods, rose by<br />
<strong>16</strong>.08 per cent (year on<br />
year) in March <strong>2018</strong>, down<br />
from the 17.59 per cent rate<br />
recorded in February.<br />
The Federal Government,<br />
which represents the fiscal<br />
authorities, had equally set the<br />
target of single digits inflation<br />
rate.<br />
This is just as it continues<br />
the pursuit of policies and programmes<br />
to strengthen the economic<br />
recovery which analysts<br />
say remains fragile since the<br />
recent exit from recession.<br />
Nigeria’s Purchasing Managers’<br />
Index (PMI), rose strongly<br />
in March from 54.7 percent<br />
to 59.4 percent, the production<br />
level index for the manufacturing<br />
sector grew for the<br />
thirteenth consecutive month<br />
in March <strong>2018</strong>.The index indicated<br />
a faster growth and expansion<br />
in the current month,<br />
when compared to its level in<br />
the preceding month.<br />
The Naira remained stable<br />
in the period under review at<br />
the CBN official rate of N305 to<br />
the dollar.<br />
Looking ahead, dynamics<br />
in the oil sector will be vital to<br />
encouraging a faster recovery<br />
and higher oil prices should fuel<br />
stronger growth in <strong>2018</strong>. However,<br />
still-high inflation, a weak<br />
business climate and security<br />
risks continue to cast a shadow<br />
over the country’s prospects.
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
Start-Up Digest<br />
In<br />
association with<br />
BUSINESS DAY<br />
37<br />
Oluwatoyin Onigbanjo: From<br />
journalism to food processing<br />
Stories by ODINAKA ANUDU<br />
Oluwatoyin Onigbanjo<br />
is a journalist, but her<br />
enterprise poses a big<br />
challenge to men and<br />
women of the pen profession.<br />
The thinking of the majority of<br />
people is that journalists are only<br />
spectators and reporters of events,<br />
but Oluwatoyin and a few others are<br />
proving this notion to be false.<br />
She is today the founder and head<br />
cook of August Secrets, which produces<br />
baby foods such as Veggie<br />
Beans, Nutty Meal, Fish Powder and<br />
Crayfish Powder. She is also exporting<br />
these packaged baby foods to Ghana;<br />
New York and Atlanta in the United<br />
States, and other countries.<br />
Like all entrepreneurs, Oluwatoyin’s<br />
story is unique. After having a<br />
baby abroad, she returned to Nigeria<br />
only to notice that the child was reluctant<br />
to eat the available food. She<br />
started sharing her experience with<br />
neighbours and church members<br />
who offered different pieces of advice.<br />
A matron in one of the hospitals suggested<br />
two local foods she could give<br />
the child, and this worked.<br />
“At the end of the day, I realised<br />
that there was a lot of gap,” she tells<br />
Start-Up Digest.<br />
“I said to myself, ‘Why not package<br />
all of these foods and give them<br />
to Nigerian children?’ In the process<br />
of doing that, I realised that a lot of<br />
Austin Okere, the serial entrepreneur,<br />
has launched<br />
the long-awaited Ausso<br />
Leadership Academy<br />
(ALA) in Lekki, Lagos.<br />
ALA is an experiential entrepreneurship<br />
academy, which<br />
mentors and takes care of senior<br />
executives in large enterprises,<br />
multinationals and conglomerates<br />
as well as founders of big<br />
businesses.<br />
Speaking at the launch of the<br />
academy in Lagos last Thursday,<br />
Austin Okere, CEO of ALA, said<br />
many of the champions (established<br />
entrepreneurs) he had<br />
spoken to agreed that they wanted<br />
to have an opportunity to mentor<br />
people of that calibre all along but<br />
had no medium to do so.<br />
Okere said he had three reasons<br />
for setting up the leadership<br />
and entrepreneurship academy.<br />
“I wanted to advise others the<br />
same way I would have advised<br />
my younger self. If I had that<br />
kind of advice at the time I was<br />
starting my business, I would<br />
probably have avoided some of<br />
my mistakes.<br />
“The second inspiration was<br />
that I wanted to be for others, the<br />
Oluwatoyin Onigbanjo<br />
ing the next set of raw materials and<br />
setting up the factory. Fewer than<br />
two years down the line, this revenue<br />
of this firm (in the last 12 months) is<br />
about $100,000.<br />
“We are selling in about 24 Nigerian<br />
cities and states of the country now. We<br />
sell in Ghana; we sell in Atlanta, and<br />
we sell in New York. We sell outside<br />
Nigeria. It is amazing that we now take<br />
our foods to places where we bring in<br />
mothers also had the same problem.<br />
A lot of them wanted foods that were<br />
natural and from the African soil.<br />
That was a lot of motivation for me,”<br />
she explains.<br />
The entrepreneur started this<br />
business officially in July 20<strong>16</strong> and<br />
has had a very good experience. The<br />
first raw materials she bought cost<br />
her N20, 000. She then spent between<br />
N200, 000 and N500, 000 on purchasour<br />
foods from,” she says.<br />
Oluwatoyin has 24 direct and indirect<br />
staff members and 24 distributors<br />
across the country.<br />
“We decided to fill in the gap when<br />
we realised that about 90 percent of<br />
what the Nigerian children ate were<br />
imported and were foreign goods. We<br />
are producing Nigerian foods, nutritious<br />
foods that are attractive and also<br />
nourish the Nigerian children across<br />
Africa,” she states.<br />
The entrepreneur has always been<br />
a good cook and loves children. In<br />
fact, before Oluwatoyin set up the<br />
food processing factory, she had<br />
established a kids’ store.<br />
“The interesting part for me is that<br />
I love coking and I love food. This is<br />
something I am passionate about,<br />
and right from time, I have always run<br />
a kids’ store. Even as a journalist, I run<br />
a children’s store for children that are<br />
malnourished. It is one thing to have<br />
a passion and another thing to do the<br />
right thing,” she explains.<br />
It was not completely easy for her<br />
when she started. She had to wade<br />
through the challenge of getting<br />
necessary certifications such as the<br />
National Agency for Food and Drug<br />
Administration and Control (NAF-<br />
DAC0 approval. Setting up the factory<br />
and office were no child’s play.<br />
The entrepreneur believes that<br />
there are more grounds to cover.<br />
According to her, a lot of produce<br />
from farmers are wasting away and<br />
need off-takers and people who will<br />
market them.<br />
Austin Okere launches Ausso Leadership Academy<br />
mentor I wish I had.<br />
“The third reason, which is<br />
personal, is to mentor entrepreneurs<br />
to scale their businesses<br />
geometrically. We need to create<br />
something that will bring back<br />
our children from abroad. If we<br />
all put our hands together, there<br />
will be jobs for our children to<br />
come back to,” he said.<br />
He said many Nigerians had<br />
contacted him, asking to attend<br />
the academy free. However, doing<br />
this would make people take<br />
ALA for granted and the academy<br />
would be unsustainable, he said.<br />
Okere is the founder Computer<br />
Warehouse Group (CWG),<br />
which is today the largest computer<br />
security firm in the Nigerian<br />
Stock Exchange.<br />
According to him, there was a<br />
need for Nigerian entrepreneurs<br />
to invest more in human capital<br />
as noted by Bill Gates.<br />
Okere said ALA was not a<br />
business school but a practical<br />
and experiential complement<br />
from experiences in business<br />
schools.<br />
“A billionaire is not necessarily<br />
someone who has amassed<br />
a billion dollars, but someone<br />
Austin Okere<br />
who has touched a billion lives,”<br />
he stated. Ernest Ndukwe, former<br />
executive vice chairman<br />
of the Nigeria Communication<br />
“The link between the farmers and<br />
the market is very weak. There are still<br />
a lot of issues in logistics. We also<br />
have a lot of market gap, and there is<br />
a gap in warehousing.<br />
Being a journalist, Oluwatoyin<br />
believes in the power of the digital<br />
media. Through various platforms<br />
made available by technology, she<br />
reaches 100,000 mothers at the moment.<br />
She is a strong believer in the<br />
made-in-Nigeria brands and wants<br />
the citizens to appreciate and buy<br />
locally made goods.<br />
“We are taking advantage of the<br />
digital media and it has really helped<br />
us. We are able to reach more people.<br />
Without digital media, we can hardly<br />
reach Ghana and other places.” Being<br />
a married woman, the entrepreneur<br />
appreciates the role played by her<br />
family and says a big ‘thank you’ to<br />
them.<br />
She says cost of production is high,<br />
but her firm has adopted a strategy<br />
to cut it.<br />
“It has really been tough. What<br />
we try to do is to watch when there is<br />
power and we quickly run our production,”<br />
she discloses.<br />
Oluwatoyin says moving from<br />
journalism to manufacturing was<br />
not easy and adds that she needs assistance<br />
in terms of technology and<br />
machinery. “We are looking to get<br />
support in terms of machines and the<br />
technology we need for production,”<br />
she tells Start-Up Digest.<br />
She has some pieces of advice for<br />
the upcoming entrepreneurs.<br />
“I was not cut out to be an entrepreneur.<br />
I would rather be in my<br />
house and string stories together as<br />
a journalist. But I realised that people<br />
needed my services. If you know how<br />
to cook, cook it, put it together and<br />
give it those who need it. Don’t just<br />
stay in your house. If anybody told me<br />
that I would be going out to speak in<br />
conferences and talk to people about<br />
entrepreneurship, I would not believe<br />
that,” she advises.<br />
Commission (NCC), who was<br />
chairman of the event, pointed<br />
out that there was a general<br />
agreement that business execution<br />
could be taught.<br />
Ndukwe said mentoring was<br />
a process, rather than a day’s affair,<br />
urging mentors or champions<br />
at ALA to make themselves<br />
available for the prospective<br />
mentees.<br />
He said he was now involved<br />
in raising a crop of leaders who<br />
would understood the intricacies<br />
of governance and global<br />
issues in a digital economy.<br />
Leo Stan Eke, chairman of<br />
Zinox Technologies Limited,<br />
said what made someone a billionaire<br />
was not the billions he<br />
or she acquired but legacies.<br />
Eke said this was time for<br />
old entrepreneurs to go back to<br />
entrepreneurship schools and<br />
gain knowledge of the modern<br />
system.<br />
Tosin Runsewe, chief operating<br />
officer of AXA Mansard Insurance<br />
Plc, said as Nigeria’s population<br />
kept growing, challenges<br />
also continued rising. Runsewe<br />
said the population could be a<br />
gift if properly harnessed, adding<br />
that the launch of the ALA<br />
would go a long way in enhancing<br />
the quality of manpower in<br />
the country.
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
38 BUSINESS DAY<br />
C002D5556<br />
Start-Up Digest<br />
‘Nigerian start-ups need grants<br />
to scale through hurdles’<br />
Elizabeth Anuoluwapo Dike is the executive director of Lizanu Indelible Needles, a firm that<br />
designs clothes for clients and helps them get the kind of designs they want. Elizabeth holds<br />
Bachelor of Science (Bsc) degree in Social Studies from Tai Solarin University of Education,<br />
Ogun State, Nigeria. In this interview with BUNMI BAILEY, the young entrepreneur talks about<br />
her business, challenges and how government can help young entrepreneurs like herself.<br />
Tell me about your<br />
business, when you<br />
started and your<br />
background.<br />
My name is Elizabeth<br />
Anuoluwapo Dike. I am a fashion<br />
entrepreneur and my business<br />
name is Lizanu Indelible Needles.<br />
What I do is to help clients bring<br />
their designs to reality. There are<br />
people who prefer to have their<br />
own designs instead of having<br />
something common. So, what I<br />
do is to help them have the kind of<br />
design they want for themselves.<br />
I also create designs for clients.<br />
I started this business properly<br />
in the 20<strong>16</strong>. I have actually been<br />
doing it for a while, but I got to<br />
understand the business side of<br />
it properly in the year 20<strong>16</strong>.<br />
What inspired you to set up<br />
the business?<br />
I learnt how to make clothes<br />
as a teenager. The experience was<br />
what inspired this business. I was<br />
also helped by my mum. Initially<br />
I thought it was all about making<br />
clothes, but then I started seeing<br />
that there was more to it than<br />
just making clothes. I decided to<br />
design since I could be creative,<br />
moderately.<br />
What was your initial start-up<br />
capital?<br />
The United States Consulate<br />
General Lagos in collaboration<br />
with Field of Skills and<br />
Dreams VTE Academy has<br />
trained 121 budding entrepreneurs<br />
in Port Harcourt, Rivers State. It was<br />
the second edition of the Conference<br />
for Emerging Entrepreneurs<br />
and it took place last Wednesday.<br />
The up-and-coming entrepreneurs,<br />
selected from across Nigeria,<br />
learned how to transform their<br />
ideas into practical business plans,<br />
Elizabeth Anuoluwapo Dike<br />
U.S. Consulate, FSD Academy train 121<br />
emerging entrepreneurs in Port Harcourt<br />
ODINAKA ANUDU<br />
manage business risks, navigate<br />
difficult moments, seek capital, and<br />
develop partnerships to help their<br />
businesses grow.<br />
F. John Bray, United States consul<br />
general, declared the workshop<br />
open and was joined by Ipalibo<br />
Harry Banigo, Rivers State deputy<br />
governor, and Ndowa Lale, vicechancellor<br />
of the University of Port<br />
Harcourt.<br />
In his welcoming remarks, F.<br />
John Bray explained that one of<br />
U.S. Mission Nigeria’s primary goals<br />
was to support Nigeria’s economic<br />
development. According to him,<br />
the U.S. Department of State always<br />
supported entrepreneurs all over the<br />
world through training and mentoring,<br />
while working with governments<br />
to create enabling environments and<br />
entrepreneurial cultures.<br />
“There is growing evidence that<br />
entrepreneurs the world over are<br />
the drivers of job growth. The United<br />
States government is firmly convinced<br />
that in addition to creating<br />
jobs and expanding economic<br />
opportunities, entrepreneurship<br />
contributes to political stability<br />
and a vibrant civil society,” Consul<br />
General Bray said.<br />
Leading business leaders including<br />
Tonye Cole, Sahara Group<br />
co-founder; Stella Okoli, Emzor<br />
Pharmaceutical CEO; Iyin Aboyeji,<br />
Andela co-founder; a Zizi Cardow,<br />
award-winning designer, and senior<br />
executives of prominent commercial<br />
banks mentored and trained the<br />
participating young entrepreneurs.<br />
The Conference was organised<br />
with a view to equipping the entrepreneurs<br />
with the requisite skills<br />
and entrepreneurial know-how to<br />
enhance their success in the business<br />
world. The first edition was<br />
held in Lagos in March 2017.<br />
I cannot give a specific amount<br />
because it was a gradual process<br />
for me. I got my tools and other<br />
things little by little. Like I mentioned<br />
earlier, patience was key.<br />
How would you say your business<br />
has grown since starting?<br />
I will say it is still growing. It<br />
has not grown to the kind of level<br />
I want, but there has been some<br />
improvement. So I will say that<br />
it is still growing because even<br />
growth does not just happen. It is<br />
The government<br />
can help<br />
by encouraging<br />
young entrepreneurs<br />
with<br />
grants. If I am<br />
able to get a<br />
grant, I could<br />
help others as<br />
I had always<br />
wanted to<br />
a gradual process. I have a bigger<br />
picture of where I want my business<br />
to be and I hope to achieve<br />
that soon.<br />
You have over a year experience<br />
in entrepreneurship. Why<br />
do you think most start-ups fail<br />
after five years of being birthed?<br />
Most start-ups need some<br />
years to actually make headway or<br />
have a breakthrough in businesses.<br />
So, if in about five years the<br />
business is tired or the person in<br />
charge is not patient, determined,<br />
zealous or even strong enough<br />
to hold his/her ground, then the<br />
business would simply not fly.<br />
Lack of patience, determination,<br />
focus and strength could cause a<br />
five-year-old start-up to fail.<br />
What are the challenges confronting<br />
your business?<br />
One of the challenges facing<br />
my business is lack of funds.<br />
Another is time and distance. If<br />
I have a trainee and the person’s<br />
location is really far from mine,<br />
it slows business and training<br />
down.<br />
How can these challenges be<br />
addressed?<br />
The government can help by<br />
encouraging young entrepreneurs<br />
with grants. If I am able to<br />
get a grant, I could help others<br />
as I had always wanted to. But if<br />
I do not have enough resources<br />
to even teach people, those who<br />
want to learn most times do not<br />
even have enough to pay to learn.<br />
So, if I have resources and can<br />
teach for free, that will be a whole<br />
lot of help, not just for me but for<br />
the people I wish to help too.<br />
What would you tell your<br />
younger self?<br />
I would tell my younger self<br />
to keep going, do not stop moving;<br />
be creative; be energetic; be<br />
focused and always be ready. Opportunities<br />
will not wait for you<br />
to get ready. So always be ready.<br />
Tech4Dev, Microsoft collaborate to train<br />
500,000 youth on digital skills<br />
JOSEPHINE OKOJIE<br />
Tech4dev and Microsoft<br />
have partnered to train over<br />
500,000 youths on digital<br />
skills through its Basic<br />
Digital Education Initiative (BDEI).<br />
In a statement made available<br />
to <strong>BusinessDay</strong>, Joel Ogunsola,<br />
executive director, Tech4Dev said<br />
that the initiative is an experimental<br />
learning program that is supported<br />
by Microsoft Nigeria to train young<br />
individuals in primary, secondary<br />
and tertiary institutions on foundational<br />
digital skills.<br />
Ogunsola noted that the move<br />
have become imperative in order<br />
to equip young minds with the<br />
requisite skills for the 21st century.<br />
“We are making ample investment<br />
in digital skills education<br />
over the decade through support<br />
from Microsoft Philanthropy to<br />
train the next generation of young<br />
individuals looking to be part of<br />
the fourth industrial revolution as<br />
well as adults who very much need<br />
the skills to fully benefit from new<br />
opportunities being presented by<br />
the fourth industrial revolution,”<br />
he said.<br />
He noted that the initiative was a<br />
result of Tech4Dev and Microsoft’s<br />
mission to solve the world’s biggest<br />
problems through technology.<br />
Also speaking during the training<br />
event, Akin Banuso, general<br />
manager, Microsoft Nigeria said,<br />
“in a world where digital skills are<br />
fundamental to success in so many<br />
environments, leaving people in the<br />
dark about this major part of their<br />
world amounts to an unacceptable<br />
gap in their education. We believe<br />
technology should be an equalising<br />
force in the world—inclusive,<br />
not divisive.”<br />
“So, we are investing our greatest<br />
assets—our technology, grants,<br />
people, and voice—to advance a<br />
more equitable world where the<br />
benefits of technology are accessible<br />
to everyone,” Banuso said.<br />
In his key note speech, Olusegun<br />
Mimiko, former governor of Ondo<br />
State encouraged the younger<br />
generation to join the advocacy<br />
and push for democratization of<br />
education at all levels. He further<br />
advocated for more female participation<br />
in tech fields.<br />
“It’s a time of intellectual domination.<br />
Women have begun to<br />
dominate, and they should get more<br />
involved,” Mimiko said.
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
Olawumi Ogunbode<br />
How Olawumi Ogunbode<br />
makes money from<br />
soaps, shea butter, honey<br />
Angel James<br />
dients such as egg white<br />
and lemon. In 2013, she<br />
commercialised her<br />
products and created<br />
awareness on them. Ever<br />
since then, her sales<br />
have gone beyond her<br />
expectation. She is<br />
happy to have attracted<br />
many Nigerians to her<br />
Nigerians<br />
do not<br />
appreciate<br />
their<br />
own locally<br />
made<br />
products<br />
because<br />
we do not<br />
believe in<br />
each other<br />
products.<br />
The young entrepreneur<br />
did not stop there.<br />
She committed time and<br />
resources to learning<br />
about black soap and<br />
she now has her own<br />
recipe, which is different<br />
from others.<br />
“I started my business<br />
with less than N5,<br />
000, which I used to<br />
buy materials. My black<br />
soap business alone is<br />
worth over N100, 000.<br />
I have two employees<br />
and source materials<br />
from factories where<br />
they are produced in the<br />
country. My black soaps<br />
are unique because I<br />
check the skin texture<br />
and complexion coupled<br />
with other requirements<br />
before production,” she<br />
says.<br />
The entrepreneur<br />
believes that time will<br />
come when she will go<br />
into mass production<br />
and will have general<br />
products for oily skin<br />
and dry skin, among<br />
others.<br />
Olawumi has been<br />
able to create awareness<br />
through word of mouth,<br />
social media, her website<br />
and referrals.<br />
She says the business<br />
is lucrative as women<br />
will always want their<br />
skins to glow without<br />
wearing makeup, adding<br />
that men also patronise<br />
her because of the quality<br />
of the products.<br />
The entrepreneur has<br />
long-term customers<br />
and says that Nigerians<br />
have not learnt to believe<br />
in their own products.<br />
“I do not really have<br />
problem with the shea<br />
butter and other products<br />
I make, but my major<br />
concern which is<br />
the black soap. I notice<br />
that people prefer to buy<br />
soaps from Ghana and<br />
the UK, but my soap is<br />
as original as those ones<br />
from abroad,” she states.<br />
The young entrepreneur<br />
is planning to expand<br />
across the country<br />
and ensure that every<br />
household uses her<br />
products.<br />
“My long-term plan is<br />
to run the business and<br />
be the leading brand.<br />
Nigerians do not appreciate<br />
their own locally<br />
made products because<br />
we do not believe in<br />
each other. We do not<br />
know the efficacy and<br />
worth of our local made<br />
products,” she notes.<br />
She urges the government<br />
to empower<br />
local entrepreneurs to<br />
produce more, while<br />
calling for a better business<br />
environment for<br />
entrepreneurs.<br />
Josephine Okojie<br />
Kenechukwu Chibuikem<br />
Okafor is<br />
a Mechanical Engineering<br />
graduate<br />
of Landmark University. He is<br />
the founder and CEO of Ezra<br />
Footwear, a start-up shoe<br />
manufacturing business.<br />
Kenechukwu was inspired<br />
to establish his business by<br />
his parents and his love<br />
for leather products. The<br />
achievements of his parents<br />
motivated him on a daily<br />
basis and in 20<strong>16</strong>, he established<br />
Ezra Footwear. He<br />
is also the founder of Ezra<br />
farms.<br />
The young engineer<br />
started the business with his<br />
entire savings. According to<br />
Kenechukwu, his business<br />
has grown since starting and<br />
demand for his products is<br />
also rising.<br />
He tells Start-Up Digest<br />
that he sources his raw materials<br />
from local markets<br />
across the country and also<br />
imports some of them.<br />
“We source for most of our<br />
materials from local markets<br />
and also import from Indonesia,”<br />
the footwear maker says.<br />
Kenechukwu recently won<br />
the Entrepreneurs Organisation’s<br />
Global Students Entrepreneurship<br />
Awards (EOG-<br />
SEA) (Nigeria chapter) and<br />
represented the country at<br />
the global finals in Germany.<br />
Kenechukwu states that<br />
the footwear industry has<br />
Start-Up Digest<br />
Ol awumi<br />
Ogunbode<br />
is the CEO<br />
of Jarah, a<br />
subsidiary<br />
of Shadonai Resources<br />
Limited that produces<br />
skin products such as<br />
soap, honey, carrot oil,<br />
coconut oil and shea<br />
butter, popularly known<br />
as ‘Ori’. A graduate of<br />
English from Olabisi<br />
Onabanjo University,<br />
Ago Iwoye, Ogun State,<br />
Olawumi started her<br />
business while a student.<br />
Her desire has always<br />
been to be part<br />
of the made-in-Nigeria<br />
project.<br />
“I started my business<br />
in 2013 with the desire to<br />
change the type of soaps<br />
in the market, which often<br />
contain harsh chemicals<br />
that could cause<br />
skin irritation. I noticed<br />
that most of the bathing<br />
soaps in the market were<br />
produced using chemicals<br />
that were harsh on<br />
the skin. I decided not<br />
use any soap that I did<br />
not know how it was<br />
produced. Then I started<br />
working on my skin and<br />
people started coming<br />
to me for advice,” she<br />
explains.<br />
The young entrepreneur<br />
had been using<br />
black soap since 2001<br />
until she decided to incorporate<br />
natural ingrethe<br />
potential to diversify the<br />
country’s economy away<br />
from oil and earn huge foreign<br />
exchange for Nigeria,<br />
adding that what is required<br />
is the support from government.<br />
The young entrepreneur<br />
assures that the country has<br />
what it takes in terms of raw<br />
materials and the needed<br />
skills to be footwear manufacturing<br />
hub in Africa.<br />
When asked about his<br />
expansion plans, he says, “I<br />
have scheduled a lot of expansion<br />
plans which I have<br />
already started working on<br />
through the help of my parents<br />
who has been supporting<br />
me from the beginning.<br />
Currently I am making efforts<br />
in securing more machines<br />
for production and also expand<br />
the factory space.”<br />
“I also intend to start<br />
training other youths on<br />
footwear manufacturing. I<br />
am saving towards achieving<br />
all this within the shortest<br />
possible time,” says<br />
Ekenechukwu.<br />
Answering questions on<br />
the challenges the business<br />
is facing, Kenechukwu replies<br />
that rising cost of raw<br />
materials remains the major<br />
issue. He adds that prices of<br />
every material needed for<br />
production of footwear has<br />
risen in recent times.<br />
This has increased his<br />
production cost at a point<br />
when customers are reluctant<br />
to pay more. Also, he<br />
stresses that his inability<br />
to meet up with the huge<br />
demand for his product is a<br />
challenge.<br />
The young entrepreneur<br />
wants the government to<br />
improve on the ease of doing<br />
business so that cost of<br />
production can decline and<br />
BUSINESS DAY<br />
39<br />
‘Start-ups need to be<br />
competitive to increase survival’<br />
We source<br />
for most of<br />
our materials<br />
from local<br />
markets<br />
and also<br />
import from<br />
Indonesia,”<br />
the footwear<br />
maker<br />
the country’s products will<br />
become more competitive.<br />
He states that the issue of<br />
competitiveness has been<br />
a major factor hindering<br />
the growth of the country’s<br />
footwear industry as a lot of<br />
foreign shoes are cheaper<br />
than locally produce ones.<br />
The engineer-turnedentrepreneur<br />
said when<br />
production cost is cheaper,<br />
Nigeria’s shoes will compete<br />
favourably with the<br />
imported ones.<br />
Kenechukwu also urges<br />
the government to assist<br />
start-ups with finance. “A<br />
lot of Nigerian youths have<br />
wonderful business ideas<br />
but the finance to bring them<br />
to bear is what is lacking,<br />
forcing many to never establish<br />
their businesses.<br />
But if government can start<br />
supporting start-ups with<br />
finance, many of them will<br />
establish their business,”<br />
he says.<br />
He states that government<br />
has not given enough<br />
support to the leather sector,<br />
stressing that a lot of footwear<br />
makers in the country<br />
have shut down due to harsh<br />
operating environment and<br />
lack of government support.<br />
“A lot of people started<br />
footwear production line<br />
and were forced to close<br />
down because they could<br />
not cope with the economic<br />
situation. The footwear industry<br />
can be a good source<br />
of export for Nigeria with<br />
much support from the government,”<br />
he says.<br />
On advice to other entrepreneurs,<br />
he says, “We<br />
all go through bad days. I<br />
have been through a lot of<br />
bad times, but what matters<br />
is not how hard you fell but<br />
how you got back up.”
40 BUSINESS DAY<br />
C002D5556 Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
MondayMorning<br />
In association with<br />
Harvard<br />
Business<br />
Review<br />
Becoming more conscientious<br />
STEFANO TASSELLI,<br />
MARTIN KILDUFF AND<br />
BLAINE LANDIS<br />
Ma n y<br />
people,<br />
including<br />
some<br />
experts,<br />
see personality as relatively<br />
stable over time.<br />
In other words, you are<br />
who you are, and while<br />
you may evolve a little,<br />
once you become an<br />
adult your major traits —<br />
your extraversion, agreeableness,<br />
neuroticism,<br />
openness and, yes, conscientiousness<br />
— won’t<br />
change much.<br />
But this widespread<br />
belief in the immutability<br />
of personality is<br />
misplaced. People can<br />
positively change their<br />
personalities by increasing<br />
their engagement in<br />
Welcoming an employee back from medical leave<br />
ANNE SUGAR<br />
Employees take leaves<br />
of absence for all sorts<br />
of reasons, from dealing<br />
with a cancer diagnosis to<br />
caring for a sick child. Here are<br />
some specific actions that will<br />
help ensure a smooth transition<br />
for your employee and<br />
you.<br />
REMEMBER TO CHECK IN.<br />
Plan to check in periodically<br />
with your team member on<br />
leave. A good starting point is<br />
checking in on a monthly basis,<br />
but of course this depends<br />
on the length of the leave.<br />
Keeping up even occasional<br />
communication will help your<br />
team member feel valued and<br />
engaged when they are out of<br />
the office, and it demonstrates<br />
your confidence in and support<br />
of their work.<br />
activities that fit three<br />
criteria: They feel important,<br />
are enjoyable and<br />
accord with their values.<br />
With this in mind,<br />
think about why you<br />
may struggle to act conscientiously.<br />
See if you<br />
You can talk with your employee<br />
to find the method<br />
of communication that best<br />
suits them, whether it’s quick<br />
emails, phone calls, or perhaps<br />
an occasional face-to-face<br />
meetup if they’re on extended<br />
leave and their situation allows<br />
for it.<br />
REACH OUT RIGHT BE-<br />
FORE THEIR RETURN. Even<br />
more important than a brief<br />
check-in is the communication<br />
right before the staff<br />
member returns to the office. It<br />
is important to ask about how<br />
they would like their return<br />
announced. Sometimes the<br />
employee might want to return<br />
without a lot of fanfare. It is<br />
important to honor privacy in<br />
terms of what the staff member<br />
wants to divulge, so prepare for<br />
a brief conversation.<br />
THINK THROUGH THE<br />
can identify what is getting<br />
in your way, and<br />
discuss it with your boss.<br />
She may be able to explain<br />
why a task that<br />
seems unimportant to<br />
you is important to the<br />
success of the business,<br />
DETAILS. As a first step, consider<br />
how you can create<br />
meaningful touchpoints that<br />
create a welcoming experience.<br />
For instance, you might<br />
meet the employee at the door<br />
when they arrive at the office,<br />
or have flowers or some other<br />
welcoming item waiting for<br />
them at their desk. End the<br />
first day early so that your employee<br />
can ease back into the<br />
workflow.<br />
PROVIDE A PHASED<br />
TRANSITION. Recognize that<br />
because of medical appointments<br />
or fatigue, your employee’s<br />
schedule might need to<br />
be different than before. With<br />
these parameters in mind, focus<br />
on some small, quick-win<br />
projects to jump-start the employee’s<br />
work in a meaningful<br />
manner.<br />
CHECK IN FREQUENTLY.<br />
or willing to assign you<br />
to tasks that are a better<br />
fit for your abilities.<br />
If you can’t change the<br />
tasks you’re assigned, try<br />
to change how you think<br />
about them. For example,<br />
if you can remind<br />
With your returning employee,<br />
think about providing additional<br />
attention, as if you had<br />
a new employee joining the<br />
team. The most important<br />
meeting to facilitate is with the<br />
yourself that timeliness<br />
is part of high-quality<br />
work, you may find it<br />
easier to let go when the<br />
deadline approaches.<br />
Do you value collaboration<br />
and helpfulness?<br />
Building relationships?<br />
Teamwork? If you learn<br />
to see a task in a way that<br />
matches your values,<br />
you will have an easier<br />
time completing it well.<br />
You can also enhance<br />
your conscientiousness<br />
by enhancing your interactions<br />
with co-workers,<br />
inside or outside the<br />
workplace. Research<br />
shows that investment<br />
in activities with colleagues<br />
is associated<br />
with an increase in a<br />
person’s conscientiousness.<br />
Even recreational<br />
activities can help you<br />
become more detail-oriented<br />
by boosting your<br />
team member who took over<br />
the employee’s work while<br />
they were out.<br />
Remember that transition<br />
scheduling should be fluid<br />
since each employee has a<br />
sense of belonging and<br />
obligation to your work<br />
community.<br />
Importantly, showing<br />
your willingness to become<br />
conscientious may<br />
be just as important as<br />
actually doing it. From<br />
an organizational perspective,<br />
leaders should<br />
evaluate their employees<br />
not only on their<br />
current behavior and<br />
performance but also<br />
on how adaptable those<br />
employees are.<br />
(Stefano Tasselli is an<br />
assistant professor at<br />
the Rotterdam School<br />
of Management, Erasmus<br />
University. Martin<br />
Kilduff is a professor at<br />
the UCL School of Management.<br />
Blaine Landis<br />
is an assistant professor<br />
at University College<br />
London.)<br />
unique experience and situation<br />
returning to the workplace.<br />
(Anne Sugar is an executive<br />
coach and speaker.)<br />
(C) (2017) Harvard Business Review. Distributed by New York Times Syndicate
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
C002D5556<br />
BUSINESS DAY<br />
41<br />
Harvard<br />
Business<br />
Review<br />
MondayMorning<br />
In association with<br />
Presenting in English when you’re not a native speaker<br />
DEBORAH GRAYSON RIEGEL<br />
Being compelled<br />
to speak in your<br />
non-native language<br />
can lead to feelings<br />
of frustration pressure,<br />
and insecurity.<br />
Add to that the burden<br />
of making formal business<br />
presentations in<br />
front of superiors, decision-makers<br />
and key<br />
stakeholders in your<br />
non-native language,<br />
and the anxiety is significantly<br />
greater.<br />
My co-author Ellen<br />
Dowling and I interviewed<br />
many leaders<br />
in this situation, and<br />
asked them to share<br />
their experiences. Here<br />
are three strategies nonnative<br />
English speakers<br />
can employ to help<br />
them feel more confident<br />
before, during and<br />
after a presentation:<br />
SPEND SIGNIFI-<br />
CANTLY MORE TIME<br />
PRACTICING YOUR<br />
DELIVERY THAN PER-<br />
FECTING YOUR DECK.<br />
The goal here is “overlearning”<br />
your presentation<br />
— pushing on<br />
with practice even when<br />
it seems like you’ve<br />
done enough. This will<br />
help your presentation<br />
to become embedded<br />
in your long-term memory<br />
and therefore less<br />
susceptible to the effects<br />
of stress. It will also<br />
help you speak spontaneously.<br />
DON’T AGONIZE<br />
ABOUT YOUR AC-<br />
CENT, BUT DO SLOW<br />
YOUR SPEAKING<br />
SPEED. An unfamiliar<br />
accent is particularly<br />
problematic in the first<br />
minute or two of your<br />
presentation when<br />
your audience must<br />
initially strain to understand<br />
you. Choose your<br />
opening words deliberately<br />
and pronounce<br />
them carefully. The au-<br />
dience will slowly develop<br />
an ear for your<br />
accent and find it easier<br />
to understand what you<br />
are saying.<br />
PAUSE EARLY AND<br />
OFTEN. Understanding<br />
accented speech requires<br />
listeners to draw<br />
on additional cognitive<br />
resources, not only to<br />
understand and remember<br />
what has been<br />
said but also to manage<br />
other information or<br />
tasks while listening to<br />
accented speech.<br />
For both native and<br />
non-native English<br />
speakers, perfection<br />
is overrated. But with<br />
some extra attention,<br />
effort and commitment,<br />
non-native English<br />
speakers can present<br />
with confidence,<br />
competence and cultural<br />
comfort.<br />
(Deborah Grayson<br />
Riegel is a principal at<br />
The Boda Group.)<br />
Why email is so stressful<br />
DORIE CLARK<br />
It’s easy to feel overwhelmed<br />
with the<br />
crush of email. In fact,<br />
one study showed the average<br />
professional spends<br />
4.1 hours per day responding<br />
to work messages.<br />
I undertook an experiment.<br />
For two weeks, I<br />
tracked, recorded and<br />
categorized every email<br />
I received, splitting them<br />
into categories like “client<br />
communication” and<br />
“networking or event invitation.”<br />
Everything that<br />
made it directly into my<br />
inbox was tallied — 1,<strong>16</strong>1<br />
messages over a two-week<br />
period.<br />
Here are three important<br />
lessons I learned from<br />
the process, which may<br />
be valuable as you think<br />
about how to make the<br />
time you spend on email<br />
more efficient, as well.<br />
EACH “YES” LEADS TO<br />
MORE WORK. Saying no<br />
is a challenge for any professional:<br />
You don’t want<br />
to disappoint people, and<br />
any given opportunity may<br />
lead to positive outcomes.<br />
But analyzing the emails I<br />
received taught me an important<br />
lesson about why<br />
it’s essential to exercise<br />
stringent judgment: Each<br />
“yes” leads to a cascade<br />
of (typically unforeseen)<br />
work. Recognizing the<br />
downstream consequences<br />
and impact on one’s<br />
time is essential when<br />
evaluating your decision.<br />
IT’S EASIER TO SAY<br />
“NO” WHEN YOU REAL-<br />
IZE HOW MANY PEOPLE<br />
ARE ASKING. It was stunning<br />
to me how many<br />
messages I received — a<br />
full 12% of my overall<br />
emails — that were people<br />
asking me to do things. In<br />
some cases, it was easy to<br />
say no. But many requests<br />
were harder to navigate,<br />
including 75 messages<br />
from colleagues asking for<br />
favors, whether it was a<br />
book endorsement, an introduction<br />
to someone, or<br />
a request to connect me to<br />
a contact of theirs.<br />
In total, I received 69<br />
requests per week, or<br />
nearly 10 per day. It takes<br />
extreme willpower to say<br />
no, but it became easier<br />
when taking the aggregate<br />
numbers into account. As<br />
the old saying goes, “Your<br />
inbox is someone else’s<br />
to-do list for you.” When I<br />
thought about how much<br />
energy I’d be spending<br />
doing 69 people’s bidding<br />
per week, it helped<br />
me refocus and recognize<br />
that I could only make an<br />
impact if I focused on my<br />
own priorities.<br />
I’ll suggest that the truly<br />
essential emails were<br />
client communication<br />
and inquiries about potential<br />
new engagements.<br />
Using that metric, only<br />
10.5% of the messages I received<br />
over the two-week<br />
period qualified.<br />
Spending more time<br />
fielding messages, time<br />
spent away from our own<br />
priorities, isn’t a sustainable<br />
answer. And asking<br />
people to take you off of<br />
mailing lists or leave you<br />
off of “reply all” threads is<br />
a losing battle. (Just save<br />
your time and don’t respond.)<br />
Instead, by understanding<br />
the signal-to-noise<br />
ratio of our inboxes, and<br />
recognizing how easy it is<br />
for others to make (often<br />
onerous) requests for our<br />
time, we can make smarter<br />
choices about where to focus<br />
our attention.<br />
(Dorie Clark is a marketing<br />
strategist and professional<br />
speaker who<br />
teaches at Duke University’s<br />
Fuqua School of<br />
Business.)<br />
Brought to you courtesy of First Bank Nigeria
42 BUSINESS DAY<br />
C002D5556 Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
REAL SECTOR WATCH<br />
Understanding Nigeria’s industrial strategy<br />
ODINAKA ANUDU<br />
One of the barely<br />
discussed concepts<br />
in modern development<br />
economics<br />
today is industrial<br />
strategy or blueprint. But it is hard<br />
to identify any upper middleincome<br />
or advanced economy<br />
that did not propel its growth or<br />
development through a clear-cut<br />
industrial strategy.<br />
China, for instance, is exportoriented.<br />
It is the largest exporter<br />
of steel, shipping 73.3 million<br />
metric tonnes to the world in<br />
2017. The country is also world’s<br />
largest exporter of textiles and a<br />
number of other products. Even<br />
the ‘Go-Out Policy’ introduced by<br />
the country in 2009 is a reflection<br />
of its outwardly looking industrial<br />
strategy, targeted at exporting finished<br />
products to the world and<br />
investing overseas.<br />
India is following the same<br />
development pattern.<br />
Import-substitution, on the<br />
other hand, was adopted by Latin<br />
American countries, including<br />
Argentina, Chile, Uruguay and<br />
Venezuela, in the 1930s up to<br />
1980s. It was hugely successful in<br />
these countries.<br />
It is a strategy in which local<br />
industries are established with<br />
a view to producing goods that<br />
replace imported ones. It means,<br />
for instance, encouraging the formation<br />
or establishment of fruit<br />
juice manufacturing companies<br />
in Nigeria to ensure that fruit juice<br />
is no longer imported. It is more<br />
inward-looking than outward.<br />
It requires imposition of tariffs,<br />
quotas and exchange controls to<br />
protect local industries from foreign<br />
competitors and make foreign<br />
goods expensive.<br />
Export- oriented or substitution<br />
industrialisation, on the other<br />
hand, is a strategy of exporting<br />
goods for which a country has<br />
a comparative advantage. This<br />
strategy has worked miracles for<br />
the Asian Tigers.<br />
Some countries have also adopted<br />
foreign private investment<br />
strategy, whereby incentives are<br />
put in place to attract multinationals<br />
and foreign direct investors. A<br />
typical example of a country with<br />
this policy is Ethiopia, even though<br />
it may be argued that the East African<br />
country is export-oriented or a<br />
mix of export-orientation and foreign<br />
private investment strategies.<br />
Some analysts argue that Nigeria<br />
does not have a specific industrial<br />
strategy and needs any of the<br />
three discussed above.<br />
Speaking at this year’s Manufacturing<br />
& Equipment Expo<br />
organised by MAN and Clarion<br />
Event West Africa, Aliyu Suleiman<br />
of the Dangote Group said the an<br />
industrial strategy had become<br />
important for Nigeria as new<br />
governments spent half of their<br />
tenures devising plans, with little<br />
room for implementation.<br />
“Last year, the United Kingdom<br />
produced a revised manufacturing<br />
strategy— a definitive roadmap. We<br />
can do that in Nigeria and MAN is<br />
in the best position to do this,” he<br />
stated.<br />
According to him, the industrial<br />
strategy should include the aspiration<br />
of industry in terms of how<br />
much GDP contribution targeted;<br />
where to play, with regard to areas<br />
of priority, and how to win, in terms<br />
of becoming competitive.<br />
Others have also pointed out<br />
that the country’s industrial strategy<br />
is vague, if it ever exists.<br />
There is another school of<br />
thought that believes that the country<br />
has never had any well-defined<br />
industrial strategy over the years.<br />
But a close look at Nigeria’s<br />
industrial history shows that the<br />
country adopted import-substitution<br />
strategy between 1960 and<br />
1985. However, the objectives were<br />
never realised.<br />
According to Udo N. Ekpo of the<br />
Department of Economics, Akwa<br />
Ibom State University, inputs such<br />
as raw materials, machines, spare<br />
parts and the skilled manpower<br />
used in the local industries were<br />
imported. As a result of this, rather<br />
than cut imports, external dependence<br />
or save foreign exchange<br />
as expected, the policy hiked<br />
imports, perpetuated external<br />
dependency of industrial sector,<br />
and drained foreign exchange.<br />
More so, the envisaged transfer<br />
of technical skill and technology,<br />
which could have resulted in technological<br />
development in Nigeria<br />
and consequently boost industrial<br />
development, did not materialise<br />
because strategic technical position<br />
in existing manufactured<br />
firms were manned by foreigners,<br />
he added.<br />
At various times in the past,<br />
Nigeria made efforts to attract<br />
foreign manufacturers and multinationals<br />
to create jobs and utilise<br />
local raw materials.<br />
Olusegun Obasanjo and<br />
Goodluck Jonathan’s eras saw<br />
Like in the importsubstitution<br />
era in<br />
Nigeria, many of<br />
the raw materials<br />
are still imported<br />
today, even though<br />
local input sourcing<br />
is already over<br />
50 percent<br />
ministers doing road shows outside<br />
the country to woo investors.<br />
There were also controversial<br />
waivers and incentives which<br />
several foreign companies got,<br />
especially during the Jonathan’s<br />
administration, targeted at promoting<br />
foreign investments.<br />
Currently, many government<br />
officials have used the expression<br />
‘import-substitution’ many<br />
times, pushing analysts to wonder<br />
whether this is the country’s current<br />
strategy.<br />
However, the crash in Nigeria’s<br />
biggest foreign exchange<br />
earner—crude oil— in 2015 and<br />
20<strong>16</strong> pushed public officials into<br />
campaigning for export of Nigerian<br />
agro and finished products. The<br />
reason was not far-fetched: Oil<br />
price was low and consequently<br />
dollar inflows could not meet the<br />
demands of manufacturers who<br />
needed to import inputs; fuel<br />
importers who wanted to bring in<br />
refined fuel, among others.<br />
Like in the import-substitution<br />
era in Nigeria, many of the raw<br />
materials are still imported today,<br />
even though local input sourcing is<br />
already over 50 percent. This is why<br />
many think that Nigeria’s industrial<br />
strategy is either non-existent or it<br />
is import-substitution.<br />
However, checks show that<br />
there has been a new industrial<br />
policy in the country since 2014. In<br />
the Nigeria Industrial Revolution<br />
Plan prepared by the Goodluck<br />
Jonathan administration, adopted<br />
by the present government, the<br />
country’s strategy is what is called<br />
‘resource-based industrialisation’.<br />
This means the use of locally<br />
available resources, such as raw<br />
materials, man power and natural<br />
resources, to grow domestic<br />
production. This has seen some<br />
success with local input sourcing<br />
ranging between 52 and 60 percent<br />
since the second half of 20<strong>16</strong>,<br />
according to numbers from MAN.<br />
However, the craze for export<br />
to earn foreign exchange and the<br />
constant use of ‘import substitution’<br />
in the industrial circles are<br />
blurring this vision. Nigeria’s nonoil<br />
export today is still dominated<br />
by cocoa, rubber, sesame seeds,<br />
shea nuts, animal skins/leather<br />
and vegetables, which ordinarily<br />
should feed local industries.<br />
Frank Udemba Jacobs, president<br />
of MAN, believes on the focus<br />
is on import-substitution, exportorientation<br />
and resource-based industrialisation.<br />
Jacobs said export<br />
was important because of the need<br />
for foreign exchange in the country,<br />
adding that export would create<br />
more demand locally.<br />
“Our industrial strategy is clear.<br />
It is resource-based industrialisation.<br />
But all others are important.<br />
What we do not want is exporting<br />
commodities without adding<br />
value,” he said.<br />
Jacobs said the prices of Nigerian<br />
products were not low owing<br />
to high cost of inputs and power.<br />
Muda Yusuf, director-general of<br />
the Lagos Chamber of Commerce<br />
and Industry (LCCI), pointed out<br />
most industries focused on both<br />
the local and export markets because<br />
the latter was bigger.<br />
Yusuf said import- substitution<br />
and export promotion could<br />
go together. He explained that<br />
resource-based industrial was<br />
more competitive because local<br />
resources were utilised, citing an<br />
example with the bright performance<br />
of food and beverage subsector<br />
which got most of its inputs<br />
locally as a case study.<br />
Oladapo Abiodun, chairman<br />
of LCCI SME Group, noted that<br />
import-substitution and export<br />
promotion could not be separated<br />
as one depended on the other for<br />
success.<br />
“The whole world is a global<br />
market. For you to enjoy economies<br />
of scale, you need to produce<br />
at an optimal level, satisfy<br />
the local market and export,”<br />
Abiodun said.<br />
He said a clear industrial<br />
strategy could only be noticed<br />
when the environment was good<br />
enough for businesses.<br />
Experts say what Nigeria<br />
needs is to further develop essential<br />
raw materials for industries<br />
by bringing back petrochemical<br />
industries, rejigging Ajaokuta<br />
Steel and attracting deep-pocket<br />
investors to the solid minerals<br />
sector. They say unless efforts are<br />
made in these directions, input<br />
importation will continue and<br />
resource-based industrialisation<br />
will become a will-o-the-wisp.
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
C002D5556 BUSINESS DAY 43<br />
REAL SECTOR WATCH<br />
Steel firms expand capacity, tap<br />
export opportunity to earn FX<br />
Stories by ODINAKA ANUDU<br />
Nigerian steel<br />
firms are expanding<br />
capacity<br />
and tapping<br />
into export opportunity<br />
in the neighbouring<br />
markets to earn foreign<br />
exchange.<br />
Aarti Steel Nigeria Limited,<br />
which recently completed<br />
a 120,000- tonnes capacity<br />
cold-rolled mill in Ota, Ogun<br />
State, exports steel to Togo<br />
and Mali and plans to expand<br />
to Central Africa, Ivory Coast<br />
and Benin to boost capacity,<br />
earn more foreign exchange<br />
and tap the growth potential<br />
in the continent’s market.<br />
Aniket Singal, Aarti’s vice<br />
chairman, told <strong>BusinessDay</strong><br />
that the company was looking<br />
at expanding its export<br />
footprints, but said there<br />
was a need for a policy that<br />
would keep substandard roofing<br />
sheets at bay. African<br />
Industries, in October 20<strong>16</strong>,<br />
exported finished steel products<br />
to Morocco, Ghana and<br />
other parts of Africa for the<br />
first time.<br />
The company said its export<br />
of finished steel products<br />
would save the country over<br />
$650 million yearly. Alok<br />
Gupta, group managing director,<br />
African Industries<br />
Group, said that the quality<br />
of steel products of African Industries<br />
was at par with steel<br />
from Ukraine, if not better,<br />
adding that the company had<br />
become internationally competitive<br />
in exporting products<br />
Nigerian Breweries expanding local input sourcing operations, says MD<br />
The Nigerian<br />
Breweries (NB)<br />
says it is committed<br />
to raising<br />
its current<br />
50 percent local raw materials<br />
sourcing to 60 percent<br />
before 2020.<br />
Speaking at the annual<br />
general meeting held last<br />
Wednesday in Lagos, Jordi<br />
Borrut Bel, managing<br />
director of NB, said the<br />
brewer would continue<br />
to improve on its value<br />
extraction from local raw<br />
materials, including cassava<br />
and sorghum.<br />
Bel stated that the company<br />
was determined to<br />
improve the sorghum value<br />
chain in the country.<br />
The brewer’s profit after<br />
tax (PAT) on the financial<br />
year ended December 31,<br />
2017, surged to N33 billion,<br />
from N28.4 billion reported<br />
in the correspond-<br />
A cross section of participants trained by Nigerian-American Chamber of Commerce (NACC) on “Customer Relationship<br />
Management” in Lagos recently<br />
ers.<br />
He said the firm had<br />
cut water consumption for<br />
production by 28 percent<br />
in the last 10 years, sourcing<br />
100 percent of its packfrom<br />
Nigeria.<br />
He called for Export Expansion<br />
Grant to enable the<br />
company to sustain its exports.<br />
He added that freight<br />
cost from Ukraine to Ghana<br />
was $40 per metric tonne<br />
(MT) while that of Nigeria to<br />
Ghana is $65/MT, which was<br />
expensive.<br />
Uche Iwuamadi, executive<br />
director of the group, said the<br />
company’s operational capacity<br />
was below 70 percent,<br />
stating that there would likely<br />
be excess steel in the country<br />
when African Industries<br />
reached 100 percent capacity.<br />
African Industries has 12<br />
subsidiaries, including six big<br />
ing period of 2017, representing<br />
a <strong>16</strong> percent rise.<br />
Revenue for the period was<br />
N344 billion, as against<br />
N313 billion recorded in<br />
the previous year, representing<br />
approximately 10<br />
percent increase.<br />
Bel said the board of<br />
directors of NB recommended<br />
dividend of N33<br />
billion to shareholders,<br />
which was highest in the<br />
company’s history.<br />
The recommendation<br />
amounts to a total dividend<br />
of N4.13 per share<br />
for the 2017 operating year.<br />
Bell explained that the<br />
brewer gave out 100 per<br />
cent dividend as part of its<br />
dividend policy, consistent<br />
in its robust balance sheet.<br />
He explained that the<br />
company’s stable growth<br />
amid economic headwinds<br />
was a result of the company’s<br />
ability to cut cost.<br />
steel plants such as African<br />
Steel Mills, Ikorodu Steel Mills,<br />
African Foundries, and Abuja<br />
Steel Mills.<br />
“We produce one million<br />
tonnes of steel per year and<br />
our target is to export between<br />
200,000MT and 400,000 MT<br />
this year. You can see we are<br />
earning foreign exchange<br />
when others are demanding<br />
it from the government,” Uche<br />
Iwuamadi, group executive<br />
director, African Industries,<br />
told <strong>BusinessDay</strong>.<br />
Standard Metallurgical<br />
Company Limited (SMC) is<br />
planning to launch a billet mill<br />
to produce standard wire rods<br />
in Nigeria for the local and<br />
ECOWAS market.<br />
Mohammed Saade, managing<br />
director, SMC, said was<br />
producing 300,000 tonnes of<br />
wire rods per year.<br />
“With phase two, we would<br />
produce 260,000 tons of billets<br />
in Nigeria. Nigeria today<br />
is a big market and we are<br />
committed to meeting local<br />
demands and the surplus can<br />
go to the ECOWAS market,”<br />
Saade said.<br />
Nigeria, Africa’s biggest<br />
economy, spends about $3.3<br />
billion on steel imports every<br />
year. Eighteen of the 30 steel<br />
manufacturers in Nigeria produce<br />
about 2.2 million tons a<br />
year with scraps and billets<br />
Bel explained that the<br />
foreign exchange situation<br />
improved last year, but<br />
pointed out that double<br />
digit inflation impacted<br />
businesses and consum-<br />
imported mainly from China.<br />
An average of steel products<br />
such as standard plates,<br />
hot-rolled coil, cold-rolled<br />
coil and rebar is $464.7 using<br />
Chinese prices, which means<br />
Nigeria imports roughly 7.1<br />
million metric tonnes of steel<br />
annually. Many of the exports<br />
are still scraps, billets, and<br />
nails .<br />
The publicly-owned Ajaokuta<br />
Steel Complex is in<br />
disrepair after government<br />
sinking over $5 billion into the<br />
plant. The government has<br />
been slow in handing over<br />
the behemoth to a private investor<br />
despite interests from<br />
foreigners.<br />
aging materials locally.<br />
Bell noted that development<br />
of employees was<br />
important for sustainable<br />
company performance,<br />
adding that early signs<br />
of improvement in the<br />
macro-economic condition<br />
were yet to reflect on<br />
consumer confidence.<br />
He said the firm remained<br />
committed to the<br />
market in the long term as<br />
the fundamentals of the<br />
beer market were strong<br />
and attractive in the both<br />
medium and long term.<br />
He pointed out that<br />
firm was well positioned<br />
to trade through difficult<br />
times by leveraging its<br />
innovative brands across<br />
different market segments.<br />
NB sources its sorghum<br />
through a company known<br />
as Psaltry International<br />
Limited, located at Alayide<br />
village, Ado Awaiye near<br />
Iseyin, Oyo State,<br />
Initiate policies to<br />
revive moribund<br />
textile mills,<br />
NTGTEA tells FG<br />
The Nigeria Textile,<br />
Garment and Tailoring<br />
Employers<br />
Association (NT-<br />
GTEA) has urged the Federal<br />
Government to initiate<br />
steps to revive moribund<br />
textile mills in Nigeria.<br />
By 1985, Nigeria had over<br />
180 textile mills employing<br />
more than one million<br />
Nigerians. Some of the<br />
mills were United Nigerian<br />
Textile Limited (UNTL),<br />
Aswani Textile, Afprint,<br />
Asaba Textile Mills, and Edo<br />
Textile Mills, among others,<br />
but there are fewer than<br />
three full-fledged healthy<br />
textile mills in Africa’s biggest<br />
economy and most<br />
populous country today.<br />
Speaking in a telephone<br />
interview, Hamma Kwajaffa,<br />
director-general of NTG-<br />
TEA, said unbridled importation<br />
of cheaper but substandard<br />
textile products<br />
killed local firms, stating<br />
that 95 percent of the textile<br />
market in the country today<br />
is dominated by China.<br />
Kwajaffa said the very<br />
few surviving textile firms<br />
are struggling and cannot<br />
compete with China and India,<br />
whose production costs<br />
in their home countries are<br />
much lower than Nigeria’s.<br />
“Energy costs four cents<br />
per kilowatt in other African<br />
countries but 20 cents per<br />
kilowatt in Nigeria. So how<br />
can a struggling textile firm<br />
compete? We need government<br />
intervention to be<br />
able to compete,” he asked.<br />
The textile industry in<br />
Nigeria is currently made<br />
up of fabrics makers, cotton<br />
producers, rug and carpet<br />
manufacturers as well as<br />
fashion and designers.<br />
“We can produce military<br />
uniforms. We have bed<br />
sheets, blankets, towels<br />
and handkerchiefs. We can<br />
make good products, but<br />
there is a need for incentives<br />
for the industry,” he<br />
said.<br />
In the first quarter of<br />
20<strong>16</strong>, Aisha Abubakar,<br />
minister of state for industry,<br />
trade and investment,<br />
toured three textile firms,<br />
which include Lucky Fibres<br />
Nigeria Plc, Spintex Mills<br />
and Nichemtex Plc in Lagos<br />
and Ogun states, promising<br />
to draw government attention<br />
to the challenges in the<br />
industry.<br />
However, smuggling,<br />
high production cost, poor<br />
patronage and lack of quality<br />
control on imports, which<br />
are age-old problems in<br />
the industry, continue with<br />
little or minimal government<br />
response.
44<br />
BUSINESS DAY<br />
ABUJACITYBUSINESS<br />
COMPREHENSIVE COVERAGE OF NATION’S CAPITAL<br />
PenCom sensitizes prospective<br />
retirees on ease of accessing benefits<br />
HARRISON EDEH, Abuja<br />
National Pension<br />
Commission<br />
(Pen-<br />
Com) has<br />
carried out<br />
sensitisation awareness to<br />
prospective retirees on ease<br />
of accessing their retirement<br />
benefits from the Contributory<br />
Pension Scheme (CPS)<br />
under the Pension Reform<br />
Act, 2014.<br />
Prior to the reform, Public<br />
Sector operated Defined<br />
Benefit (DB) Scheme which<br />
was unfunded to the tune of<br />
N2.3 trillion pension liability<br />
as at 2004; marred by weak,<br />
inefficient and poor administration,<br />
prone to fraud and<br />
riddled with endless and<br />
painful annual physical verification<br />
of pensioners.<br />
On the other hand, the<br />
L-R: Ye Shuijin,<br />
president, China<br />
Chamber of Commerce<br />
in Nigeria<br />
(CCC); Chiedu<br />
Osakwe, chief<br />
trade negotiator/dg<br />
Nigerian Office for<br />
Trade Negotiations<br />
(NOTN), and Zhang<br />
Wenfeng, md/ceo,<br />
China Harbour Engineering<br />
Company<br />
Limited, during the<br />
presentation of Office<br />
Equipment/Items by<br />
the CCC to NOTN in<br />
Abuja.<br />
Pic by Tunde Adeniyi<br />
Private Sector pension was<br />
characterized by low coverage<br />
as most employers did<br />
not have pension arrangements<br />
and Retirement benefit<br />
under the NPF/NSITF<br />
scheme were very low.<br />
Section 4 of the Pension<br />
Reform Act 2014, stipulates<br />
the minimum rates of contributions<br />
of 10% and 8% for<br />
employers and employees<br />
respectively in both public<br />
and private sectors; monthly<br />
pension contributions in the<br />
core civil service are centrally<br />
deducted by the Office of the<br />
Accountant General of the<br />
Federation (OAGF) as advised<br />
by the Budget Office of the<br />
Federation based on budgeted<br />
total personnel costs<br />
with effect from July 2004.<br />
At a recent sensitisation<br />
meeting held in Kaduna, the<br />
officials of the National Pension<br />
Commission explained<br />
in a presentation made<br />
available to <strong>BusinessDay</strong>,<br />
requisite steps as well as the<br />
benefits of the contributory<br />
Pension scheme.<br />
According to the Commission,<br />
“Contributory<br />
Pension Scheme seeks to,<br />
amongst others, ensure that<br />
every worker receives his<br />
retirement benefits as and<br />
when due.”<br />
Also, retirement benefits<br />
administration is the last<br />
phase of the process/activities<br />
put place to achieve the<br />
above objectives of the Pension<br />
reform.<br />
The two models of withdrawal<br />
under the Contributory<br />
Pension scheme are:<br />
‘Programmed withdrawal’<br />
and the ‘Purchase of retiree<br />
life annuity. Besides, there are<br />
also benefits for the beneficiaries<br />
of a deceased contributor.<br />
Through the Programmed<br />
Withdrawal,<br />
beneficiaries are entitled to<br />
monthly pension of at least<br />
50% of terminal monthly<br />
emolument subject to lumpsum<br />
taken and RSA balance<br />
may be enhanced at regular<br />
intervals subject to returns<br />
on investment; balance in<br />
RSA is re-invested by PFA<br />
for maximum growth and<br />
bequeaths inheritance if<br />
death occurs at any time.<br />
In the same vein, Retiree<br />
Life Annuity provides opportunity<br />
for retirees, access<br />
to a financial product offered<br />
by Insurance companies<br />
for a regular income in<br />
consideration for payment<br />
of premium from a retiree;<br />
regular pension payments<br />
for life so long as the retiree<br />
is alive.<br />
FCT Minister seeks National Assembly<br />
approval for N40.3bn priority budget<br />
LAIDE AKINBOADE-ORIERE<br />
Federal Capital Territory<br />
Administration<br />
(FCTA) has defended<br />
its <strong>2018</strong> National<br />
Priority Budget proposal<br />
of N40,297,122,872<br />
before the Senate.<br />
Muhammad Bello, FCT<br />
Minister who presented the<br />
budget to the Senate Committee<br />
on Federal Capital<br />
Territory (FCT), at the National<br />
Assembly in Abuja,<br />
explained that the proposal<br />
was in accordance with<br />
the N40.3 billion envelope<br />
given to the FCT as its National<br />
Priority Budget by the<br />
Federal Ministry of Budget<br />
and National Planning.<br />
According to Bello,<br />
27 critical infrastructure<br />
projects totalling<br />
N40,297,122.27 have been<br />
prioritized for action under<br />
the proposal.<br />
These include the B6,<br />
B12 and Circle roads traversing<br />
the National Stadium,<br />
Villa and back to<br />
the Stadium; the Greater<br />
Abuja Water Works project<br />
as well as the Extension of<br />
Inner Southern Expressway<br />
(ISEX) from the Central<br />
Bank/National Christian<br />
Centre to Galadimawa<br />
Roundabout.<br />
Provisions totalling N1.2<br />
billion were also made for in<br />
infrastructure development<br />
at major satellite towns of<br />
Kubwa, Karshi and Bwari<br />
to help stave off the weight<br />
of expansion being witnessed<br />
in the city. In addition,<br />
major utilities and<br />
social services covering<br />
education, water supply as<br />
well as security at the UN<br />
building have been effectively<br />
provided for.<br />
The Minister disclosed<br />
that the N40.3 billion FCT<br />
<strong>2018</strong> Budget, is an improvement<br />
on the N30.4 billion<br />
that was allocated to the FCT<br />
for capital projects in 2017.<br />
H e s a i d<br />
N12,198,561,434.40 representing<br />
40.1 percent of the<br />
total sum has so far been<br />
released and expended.<br />
He expressed his appreciation<br />
to the National Assembly<br />
for extending the window<br />
of expenditure for the 2017<br />
Budget and stated that it will<br />
allow for more releases to be<br />
made to offset some critical<br />
infrastructural bills in the FCT.<br />
Bello disclosed that the<br />
FCTA is working to overcome<br />
the budget shortfall<br />
through its recently reconstituted<br />
FCT Internal Revenue<br />
Service.<br />
Speaking earlier, Dino<br />
Melaye, chairman, Senate<br />
Committee on FCT,<br />
lamented that the FCT National<br />
Priority Budget has<br />
declined from N109 billion<br />
in the recent past to N30.4<br />
in 2017 and N40.3 billion<br />
in <strong>2018</strong>.<br />
C002D5556<br />
KEHINDE AKINTOLA, HARRISON<br />
EDEH & CYNTHIA EGBOBOH, Abuja<br />
The Organised Private<br />
Sector (OPS),<br />
Nigerian Labour<br />
Congress (NLC)<br />
and other key economic<br />
stakeholders want the Federal<br />
Government to prioritize<br />
enforcement of rules of<br />
Origin in the African Continental<br />
Free Trade Area<br />
Agreement (CFTA) saying<br />
that this is the only way the<br />
Nigerian economy could<br />
harvest the full benefit in<br />
the deal.<br />
They also tasked African<br />
Heads of States and Government<br />
on the need to<br />
fast-track provision of requisite<br />
infrastructure such as<br />
road, rail infrastructure that<br />
will aid interconnectivity<br />
of member states; protect<br />
local market and ensure<br />
that CFTA strictly include<br />
goods produced within the<br />
region as part of measures<br />
aimed at turning Africa into<br />
dumping ground.<br />
Speaking to Business-<br />
Day exclusively, Frank<br />
Jacobs, President of the<br />
Manufacturers Association<br />
of Nigeria (MAN) affirmed<br />
that the consultation initiated<br />
by Federal Government<br />
has been fruitful and<br />
took note of various concerns<br />
including enforcement<br />
of the rules of Origin<br />
and Market Access.<br />
“We hope that the committee<br />
that would harmonise<br />
the reports would reflect<br />
our submissions accordingly,”<br />
Jacobs noted.<br />
On his part, Tony Ejinkonye,<br />
Vice President of<br />
National Association of<br />
Commerce, Industry Mines<br />
and Agriculture (NACI-<br />
MA), told <strong>BusinessDay</strong><br />
that: “In market access<br />
for instance, stakeholders<br />
have made their submissions<br />
to the government<br />
stating that products from<br />
African countries gaining<br />
market access must adhere<br />
to specified percentage (of<br />
local content) according to<br />
the CFTA.<br />
“In the case of Cement<br />
for instance, that must be<br />
certain percentage of the<br />
local content specifying that<br />
the local content and other<br />
materials making up the<br />
Cement are produced in Africa,<br />
otherwise there would<br />
be sanctions. This is what<br />
is meant by enforcement<br />
of the rules of Origin and<br />
Market Access so that there<br />
is no exploitation of local<br />
industry producers, hence<br />
they are well protected,”<br />
While giving update on<br />
the level of consultation<br />
with NLC, Ayuba Wabba,<br />
NLC President expressed<br />
optimism that the ongoing<br />
consultation on African<br />
Continental Free Trade<br />
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
CFTA: OPS, NLC, MAN want FG to prioritize market<br />
access, enforcement of rules of Origin in CFTA deal<br />
Agreement will be beneficial<br />
and provide safeguard<br />
for Nigeria.<br />
Wabba who stated this<br />
in a chat with <strong>BusinessDay</strong>,<br />
maintained that the decision<br />
of Nigeria and South<br />
Africa as the largest economies<br />
in the continent to decline<br />
signing the agreement<br />
in Kigali, Kenya, was commendable<br />
as it provides<br />
opportunities for relevant<br />
stakeholders to make input<br />
into government policies<br />
and programmes.<br />
He observed that opening<br />
of borders for free flow<br />
of goods across African<br />
continent, should involve<br />
provision of relevant infrastructure<br />
and level playing<br />
ground for reciprocity,<br />
competition and products<br />
produced within African<br />
continent.<br />
“We saw that it was the<br />
voice of Esau but I think,<br />
the hands of Jacob.<br />
So clearly speaking, we<br />
said let us also make sure<br />
that we are able to protect<br />
our markets. Because<br />
there’s a push somewhere<br />
and we thought we should<br />
be able to expose that push<br />
but importantly, putting<br />
safeguards to make sure that<br />
Africa does not become a<br />
dumping ground for other<br />
countries because we have<br />
the population, we have<br />
what it takes and therefore<br />
we must work towards industrialisation<br />
of Africa.<br />
“If you look at Africa<br />
today, how many countries<br />
are into production that really<br />
we can be able to trade<br />
among African countries,<br />
even within West African<br />
sub-region? Clearly speaking,<br />
this is what we want,<br />
yes. Free trade agreement<br />
is good especially among<br />
African countries, but it<br />
must be done within the<br />
context of reciprocity and<br />
also within the fact that<br />
we are the same pedestal<br />
where Nigeria can be competitive.<br />
We can be able to<br />
also produce.<br />
“Two, is the issue of infrastructure<br />
of doing trade.<br />
Today, trade is being facilitated<br />
in all the European<br />
countries and other countries<br />
around them because<br />
they have infrastructure<br />
and there’s interconnectivity.<br />
For us, to move within<br />
West African countries is<br />
really is nightmare, sometimes<br />
you have to go to<br />
Europe before you can connect<br />
African countries.<br />
“The first thing is to put<br />
infrastructure in place that<br />
can be able to facilitate<br />
trade where countries have<br />
connecting roads and rails.<br />
For you to go to Cameroon<br />
from here, you know the<br />
difficulty it will take to arrive<br />
there, only going to<br />
Dakar.
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong> C002D5556 BUSINESS DAY<br />
45
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
46 BUSINESS DAY<br />
C002D5556<br />
NEWS<br />
L-R: Aliyu Abdulhameed, managing director, Nigerian Incentive-Based Risk Sharing System for<br />
Agricultural Lending (NIRSAL); Zainab Ahmed, minister of state, budget and national planning,<br />
and Laoye Jaiyeola, CEO, Nigerian Economic Summit Group (NESG), at a workshop on low<br />
carbon investment opportunities in Nigeria, organised by NESG in Lagos, at the weekend.<br />
Pic by Olawale Amoo<br />
Lagos-Badagry 2019 rail completion...<br />
Continued from page 1<br />
system along the Lagos-<br />
Badagry axis, referred as<br />
the blue line may no longer<br />
be feasible.<br />
Awarded to the China<br />
Civil Engineering Construction<br />
Corporation<br />
(CCECC), with advisory<br />
services being provided by<br />
CPCS Transcom Limited,<br />
the blue line project is being<br />
financed solely by the<br />
Lagos state government.<br />
The slow pace of work<br />
on the on-going blue rail<br />
project linking Marina and<br />
Okokomaiko to meet with<br />
the proposed integrated<br />
transportation system initiative<br />
and the lack of push<br />
to deliver it on record time<br />
has been described as one<br />
of the factors piling up<br />
traffic along the corridor<br />
which has become a recurring<br />
decimal.<br />
Meanwhile, many motorists<br />
and other road<br />
users have continued to<br />
narrate their harrowing<br />
experiences of deadly attacks<br />
by some criminal<br />
elements and destitutes<br />
who lay siege at the newly<br />
constructed Lagos-Badagry<br />
rail terminals.<br />
A visit to the railway<br />
terminals reveals the occupants<br />
had fixed mosquito<br />
nets and curtains at their<br />
respective sleeping corners,<br />
while clothes were<br />
littered all over the floor.<br />
Occupants used stones<br />
and similar objects to<br />
carve out their spaces.<br />
Ijeoma Goldie, a petty<br />
trader who hawks mineral<br />
drinks and water along<br />
the corridor, said she had<br />
witnessed a lot of crimes<br />
perpetrated by hoodlums<br />
using the rail terminal at<br />
Mile 2 and Suru-Alaba as<br />
their target points.<br />
About two weeks ago<br />
during a traffic gridlock,<br />
the criminals attacked<br />
many vehicles and<br />
smashed the windscreen<br />
and made away with their<br />
belongings.<br />
A Chinese supervisor<br />
working for the CCECC<br />
at the site who did not<br />
give his name said it was<br />
not their responsibility to<br />
chase away the hoodlums<br />
and other occupants of the<br />
railway terminals.<br />
According to him, “Our<br />
job is to fix the project and<br />
getting protected from<br />
these people is government’s<br />
responsibility. I<br />
believe, after completion<br />
of the construction, their<br />
activities here will be over.”<br />
In <strong>Apr</strong>il 2008 during<br />
the administration of former<br />
governor Babatunde<br />
Fashola, the Lagos state<br />
government approved<br />
N70 billion (Out of the<br />
estimated N220 billion)<br />
for construction of the<br />
Okokomaiko-Iddo-Marina<br />
Line, with an estimated<br />
completion date of 2011.<br />
However, the project<br />
has suffered many delays<br />
due to funding shortfalls<br />
with the completion date<br />
being revised to June 2013,<br />
then December 20<strong>16</strong>, then<br />
2017. As at November<br />
20<strong>16</strong>, only <strong>16</strong> km of the<br />
27 km blue line had been<br />
completed.<br />
Comparing the Lagos<br />
rail project to similar ones<br />
in other parts of Africa<br />
shows that Ethiopia managed<br />
deliver the first modern<br />
light rail project in<br />
Sub-Saharan Africa which<br />
opened in the capital Addis<br />
Ababa in 2015.<br />
Ethiopia’s rail project<br />
was delivered on time despite<br />
being longer than<br />
the Lagos – Badagry rail<br />
line currently under construction.<br />
Addis Ababa’s two line<br />
34-kilometre systems was<br />
built by the China Railway<br />
Engineering Corporation<br />
(CREC) and cost $475m, 85<br />
percent of which was covered<br />
by China’s Exim bank.<br />
Lagos has a population<br />
of about 20 million<br />
people, compared to Addis<br />
Ababa’s 5 million.<br />
The Ethiopian light rail<br />
has a capacity to carry 60,000<br />
passengers a day across the<br />
capital of Africa’s second<br />
most populous nation.<br />
Ethiopia was able to<br />
complete the project despite<br />
its $50 billion GDP<br />
being about half the Lagos<br />
economy.<br />
Lagos currently doesn’t<br />
have enough infrastructure<br />
to move its teeming<br />
population, with choked<br />
roads and bridges sometimes<br />
leading to 4 hour “go<br />
slows” or traffic jams.<br />
Speaking with <strong>BusinessDay</strong><br />
on telephone,<br />
Kola Ojelabi, LAMATA’s<br />
head of media and communications,<br />
said the project<br />
was stopped for almost<br />
three years because of<br />
various problems of obstruction<br />
on the right of<br />
way (RoW).<br />
Reacting to the menace<br />
of hoodlums living on the<br />
rail lines harassing motorists<br />
and other road users,<br />
he explained that, it is<br />
illegal for anybody under<br />
any guise to live on the<br />
rail tracks, not to talk of<br />
turning themselves into<br />
criminals and causing a<br />
breach to public safety.<br />
According to him, the<br />
state government is exploring<br />
the option of lighting<br />
up the entire stretch<br />
or highway and erecting<br />
a protective safety fence<br />
along the entire Lagos-<br />
Badagry rail corridor when<br />
completed.<br />
“It is true that we have<br />
given different completion<br />
dates for the project but<br />
one of the challenges that<br />
we had was that the train<br />
was originally to go to the<br />
Iddo Railway Terminus,<br />
but the Railway Act did not<br />
allow us to do such.’’<br />
“Since we could not<br />
take the train station to<br />
Iddo, we had to change the<br />
alignment, and in changing<br />
that, there were a lot of<br />
obstructions on the way.’’<br />
Among these challenges<br />
was a fertiliser plant<br />
around Ijora belonging to<br />
the Federal Government.<br />
The state government had<br />
to negotiate to use the<br />
compound, so that it could<br />
take away the warehouse<br />
and build another warehouse<br />
for them.<br />
Moving into the lagoon,<br />
there were two major<br />
Adeosun reassigns portfolios in SEC, Mary...<br />
Continued from page 1<br />
position of Acting Director-General<br />
of the Commission.<br />
Uduk’s appointment is<br />
governed by the provisions<br />
of the Investments and Securities<br />
Act (ISA), 2007 and<br />
the conditions of service<br />
applicable to the Director-<br />
General of the Commission.<br />
The Minister, in a letter<br />
dated 13th <strong>Apr</strong>il, <strong>2018</strong>,<br />
said Uduk’s appointment<br />
had become necessary to<br />
ensure effective regulation<br />
of the Capital Market. Her<br />
appointment will, subject<br />
to satisfactory performance,<br />
subsist until further notice.<br />
The Minister also announced<br />
the redeployment<br />
of the former acting Director-General<br />
of the Commission,<br />
Abdul Zubair, to External<br />
Relations Department.<br />
She further made the following<br />
reassignment of the<br />
under-mentioned persons<br />
- Reginald C. Karawusa – Acting<br />
Executive Commissioner,<br />
Legal and Enforcement; Isiyaku<br />
Tilde – Acting Executive<br />
Commissioner, Operations;<br />
Henry Roland Adekunle –<br />
Acting Executive Commissioner,<br />
Corporate Services.<br />
The new Acting Director-<br />
General joined the Commission<br />
in 1986 as an assistant<br />
financial analyst.<br />
Her career as a regulator<br />
has spanned many functions<br />
and departments in<br />
the Commission, from corporate<br />
finance, administration,<br />
to providing structural,<br />
policy and due diligence for<br />
capital market transactions.<br />
She has also been responsible<br />
for managing<br />
several landmark capital<br />
market projects, including<br />
challenges, including the<br />
relocation of gas link, a<br />
gas pipe underneath the<br />
lagoon, which also took<br />
some time.<br />
There was the wreckage<br />
of a ship that was at the<br />
bottom of the lagoon that<br />
also had to be removed.<br />
These delayed the time<br />
line for the delivery of the<br />
project, Ojelabi of LA-<br />
MATA explained.<br />
“From the initial plan<br />
of the Lagos State Government,<br />
this rail project<br />
ought to have been delivered<br />
in 2012 or 2013,’’<br />
he said.<br />
Ojelabi explained that<br />
LAMATA lost about three<br />
years to the recovery of RoW,<br />
adding that, the state government<br />
had to bear the<br />
additional costs, which were<br />
not in the initial budget.<br />
This, according to him<br />
was to ensure that the<br />
structures were solid because<br />
rail infrastructure<br />
the registration of Capital<br />
Market Operators, articulating<br />
rules for bonds and<br />
equities; Mergers, acquisitions<br />
and Takeovers, and<br />
managing the banking and<br />
insurance industry consolidations<br />
between 2005-2007.<br />
Uduk served as the pioneer<br />
Head of the Operations<br />
Division in the Lagos Zonal<br />
Office, and has headed the<br />
following Departments in<br />
the Commission: Internal<br />
Control, Investment Management,<br />
Financial Standards<br />
and Corporate Governance<br />
and Securities, and<br />
Investment Services Department,<br />
among others.<br />
Meanwhile, the Federal<br />
Ministry of Finance has requested<br />
for a formal explanation<br />
from the SEC of the<br />
recent communications between<br />
the Commission and<br />
the Nigerian Stock Exchange<br />
(NSE), which adversely impacted<br />
market confidence.<br />
is expected to last a minimum<br />
of 100 years.<br />
When completed, the<br />
rail project will cover a<br />
distance of 27.5 km from<br />
Marina to Okokomaiko,<br />
with 13 stations and an<br />
end-to-end journey time<br />
of 35 minutes.<br />
The entire blue line will<br />
operate over a secure and<br />
exclusive right-of-way,<br />
with no level crossings and<br />
no uncontrolled access by<br />
pedestrians or vehicles.
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
US Nigeria Mission reiterates commitment<br />
to deepen ties with Nigeria<br />
US Consulate General,<br />
John Bray, has<br />
reiterated the commitment<br />
of the US<br />
Nigeria Mission to deepen<br />
bilateral ties with Nigeria for<br />
sustainable development.<br />
The mission recently<br />
graduated 20 young Nigerians<br />
of the Carrington Youth<br />
Fellowship Initiative (CYFI),<br />
an initiative geared towards<br />
promoting civic engagement,<br />
economic empowerment,<br />
and education and health<br />
care delivery.<br />
Launched in 2011, the<br />
CYFI works to bring together<br />
Nigerian youth to design<br />
and implement projects<br />
focused on societal innovation.<br />
These projects centre<br />
on broader themes championed<br />
by Ambassador Walter<br />
Carrington, for whom the initiative<br />
is named.<br />
Bray in his message to<br />
the graduates urged them<br />
to remain in touch with<br />
their cohort and maintain<br />
the strength of the bond<br />
they have formed together<br />
through collaboration.<br />
“Our objective at the US<br />
Consulate General in Lagos<br />
is to support efforts that address<br />
Nigerian issues, par-<br />
Kachikwu named as one of 100<br />
most influential Africans of 2017<br />
Minister of State<br />
for Petroleum<br />
Resources,.<br />
Emmanuel<br />
Ibe Kachikwu, has been<br />
named by the New African,<br />
a London-based magazine,<br />
as one of the 100<br />
Most Influential Africans<br />
of 2017 in the category of<br />
Business and Finance.<br />
In a letter signed by<br />
Omar Ben Yedder, group<br />
publisher and managing<br />
director, congratulating<br />
Kachikwu, the magazine’s<br />
publisher said their organisation<br />
was ‘’dedicated<br />
to changing the African<br />
narrative and fighting for<br />
its interests, and hope to<br />
continue on this journey<br />
ticularly economic development,<br />
access to healthcare,<br />
peace and security, transparency<br />
and good governance.<br />
To that end, the CYFI program<br />
is an incredibly valuable<br />
program, in that it allows<br />
some of the most promising<br />
young people in Nigeria who<br />
are passionate about these<br />
issues to affect real, positive<br />
change.<br />
“Always remember that<br />
you are a select few chosen<br />
from a pool of the most<br />
talented and driven young<br />
people in Nigeria. The friendships<br />
and partnerships<br />
you’ve developed over your<br />
year with CYFI will become<br />
some of the most rewarding.<br />
“As you’ve learned this<br />
year, you can run into all<br />
kinds of challenges in the<br />
course of implementing real<br />
and meaningful change.<br />
I hope that the successes<br />
you have had this year have<br />
shown you that the importance<br />
and impact of your efforts<br />
far outweigh the trials<br />
and tribulations you sometimes<br />
face in the course of<br />
enacting this change,” Bray<br />
said, urging them to stay<br />
committed and passionate<br />
to societal innovation and<br />
change in their society, even<br />
in the face of opposition.<br />
alongside people engaged<br />
in transformational roles<br />
across the continent such<br />
as your goodself.”<br />
According to Yedder, it<br />
has become the tradition<br />
of the publishing outfit to<br />
dedicate its annual year<br />
end edition to ‘’celebrating<br />
and reflecting on what<br />
shaped the African continent<br />
in the past year and<br />
highlighting the men and<br />
women who were changemakers<br />
and influencers in<br />
a number of sectors and<br />
industries’’. It is in accordance<br />
with that tradition<br />
that Kachikwu was spotlighted<br />
as one of the greatest<br />
influencers of the continent,<br />
last year.<br />
C002D5556<br />
BUSINESS DAY<br />
47<br />
NEWS<br />
ICRC pledges commitment to successful implementation of port concession<br />
MICHEAL ANI<br />
The importance of<br />
ensuring Public<br />
Private Partnerships<br />
(PPP) in the<br />
country are executed without<br />
undue encumbrances<br />
was highlighted last week,<br />
when a delegation from the<br />
Infrastructure Concession<br />
Regulatory Commission<br />
(ICRC) visited Josepdam<br />
port concession site in Lagos,<br />
as part of its monitoring<br />
activities.<br />
ICRC is a commission<br />
established in 2005, and<br />
saddled with the responsibility<br />
of monitoring and<br />
SEYI JOHN SALAU<br />
… embarks on fact finding to Josepdam concession project<br />
ensuring the efficient execution<br />
of all PPP projects<br />
entered into by Ministries,<br />
Departments and Agencies<br />
(MDAs) on behalf of the<br />
Federal Government.<br />
Chidi Izuwah, acting<br />
director-general, ICRC,<br />
who led the delegation, expressed<br />
delight at the site,<br />
which shows the potentials<br />
of PPP for making the<br />
economy more vibrant and<br />
improving the country’s indices<br />
as it pertained to port<br />
operations.<br />
According to Izuwah,<br />
the commission is aware of<br />
some of the challenges currently<br />
being faced by Josepdam,<br />
which range from the<br />
challenge of having third<br />
party and equipment occupying<br />
more than 25 percent<br />
of their terminal land mass,<br />
court injunction brought<br />
against Jospdam port services<br />
by third party and inability<br />
to meet covenanted<br />
GMT target as stated in the<br />
agreement due to certain<br />
challenges.<br />
Izuwah however maintained<br />
that all disagreements<br />
relating to concession<br />
exercises at the ports<br />
must therefore be resolved<br />
in order to make Nigerian<br />
ports the hub for international<br />
shipping trade in the<br />
West and Central African<br />
sub-region.<br />
To him, the commission<br />
is working tirelessly to ensure<br />
that all of such challenges<br />
be resolved.<br />
“It is on this premise<br />
that the ICRC decided to<br />
embark on this monitoring<br />
exercise to brainstorm with<br />
your management and the<br />
NPA on the way forward.<br />
“As the regulator of the<br />
lease agreement, we can-<br />
not fold our hands and<br />
leave you to struggle it out<br />
alone,” he said.<br />
“Under the President<br />
Muhammadu Buhari-led<br />
administration, there is a<br />
will to address this issue<br />
and effort is being made to<br />
resolve it to create a winwin<br />
situation for all parties,”<br />
he said.<br />
Simon Travers, managing<br />
director, JBS, urged the<br />
commission to assist in<br />
finding an amicable settlement<br />
on the issue of the<br />
third party presence at the<br />
terminal, which was hindering<br />
its operations.<br />
He recommended that<br />
the NPA should review and<br />
extend the lease agreement<br />
for years lost due to<br />
the third party interference<br />
and also appealed to the<br />
government to repair the<br />
access road to the port.<br />
Prior to the ports exercise<br />
and subsequent<br />
concession of terminals<br />
in 2006, the nation’s ports<br />
were known for inefficiency<br />
and decaying infrastructure<br />
resulting in the delay<br />
in cargo clearance and several<br />
other malpractices.
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
BUSINESS DAY<br />
A1
A2<br />
NEWS<br />
BUSINESS DAY<br />
C002D5556<br />
Business<br />
confidence index<br />
rises to 24.5 point<br />
in March - CBN<br />
HOPE MOSES-ASHIKE<br />
Nigerian businesses<br />
are showing more confidence<br />
in the macro<br />
economy as the overall<br />
Confidence Index (CI)<br />
rose to 24.5 index point<br />
in March, from 14.5 index<br />
points recorded in<br />
February <strong>2018</strong>.<br />
The March <strong>2018</strong> Business<br />
Expectations Survey<br />
(BES) was carried out by<br />
the Central Bank of Nigeria<br />
(CBN) between March<br />
12 and 22, with a sample<br />
size of 650 businesses<br />
nationwide. A response<br />
rate of 91.8 percent was<br />
achieved, and the sample<br />
covered the services,<br />
industry, wholesale/retail<br />
trade and construction<br />
sectors.<br />
The respondent firms<br />
were made up of small,<br />
medium and large organisations<br />
covering<br />
both import- and exportoriented<br />
businesses.<br />
The optimism in the<br />
current month was driven<br />
by the opinion of respondents<br />
from services<br />
(13.9 points), industrial<br />
(7.5 points) construction<br />
(1.8 points) and wholesale/retail<br />
trade sectors<br />
(1.2), while the drivers<br />
of the optimism for next<br />
month were services<br />
(38.5 points), industrial<br />
(<strong>16</strong>.8 points), construction<br />
4.9 points) and<br />
wholesale/retail trade<br />
(4.0 points) sectors. The<br />
positive outlook by type<br />
of business in March<br />
<strong>2018</strong> was driven by businesses<br />
that are both import-<br />
and export-oriented<br />
(29.1 points), those<br />
that are neither importnor<br />
export-oriented<br />
(25.9 points), businesses<br />
that are export-related<br />
(23.5 points), and those<br />
that are import- oriented<br />
(17.7 points).<br />
However, the surveyed<br />
firms identified insuffi-<br />
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
I&E window success snaps Nigeria’s dependence on CBN dollar supply<br />
LOLADE AKINMURELE …as deals hit $<strong>16</strong>.6bn in <strong>2018</strong><br />
Some $<strong>16</strong>.6 billion<br />
worth of deals have<br />
been done on Nigeria’s<br />
Investors<br />
and Exporters (I&E)<br />
window year to date, the latest<br />
sign that Africa’s largest<br />
economy is recovering from<br />
a paralyzing dollar shortage<br />
that curbed growth and<br />
hurt businesses in need of<br />
the greenback for critical<br />
imports.<br />
What is perhaps more<br />
telling is that the success of<br />
the I & E window in attracting<br />
autonomous supplies<br />
is helping the foreign ex-<br />
change market be relatively<br />
less dependent on central<br />
bank supplies upon which<br />
it was heavily reliant in 20<strong>16</strong><br />
after independent sources<br />
gummed up in reaction to<br />
capital controls.<br />
According to data provided<br />
by trading platform,<br />
FMDQ, the total value of<br />
trades recorded on the I & E<br />
window for the week-ended<br />
<strong>Apr</strong>il 6, <strong>2018</strong> was $1.34 billion,<br />
a 3.9 percent increase<br />
from the previous week.<br />
Those I&E deals accounted<br />
for 80 percent of trading<br />
activity in the Spot FX market<br />
between the commercial<br />
banks and their clients that<br />
same week, which stood at<br />
$1.656 billion, an indication<br />
that the foreign exchange<br />
market is growing less dependent<br />
on CBN supply,<br />
which traders say account<br />
for less than 15 percent of<br />
dollar supply on the I&E<br />
window.<br />
The CBN supplied nearly<br />
80 percent of dollars to the<br />
foreign exchange market in<br />
the thick of a brutal scarcity<br />
in 20<strong>16</strong>, burning through its<br />
external reserves at blistering<br />
pace to keep up with the<br />
dollar demand of households<br />
and businesses.<br />
When those antics<br />
proved no more than a<br />
drop in an ocean, following<br />
a demand backlog that has<br />
grown in excess of $7 billion,<br />
the apex bank unveiled the I<br />
& E window in <strong>Apr</strong>il 2017, as<br />
part of a sweeping reform to<br />
lure dollars back to its shores<br />
in the wake of acute shortages<br />
created by a plunge in the<br />
global price and production<br />
of oil and capital controls<br />
that curbed foreign investment<br />
inflows in 20<strong>16</strong>.<br />
This time, the central<br />
bank would allow the market<br />
to determine the exchange<br />
rate at which to<br />
trade, in a departure from<br />
the false float in June 20<strong>16</strong><br />
after which the apex bank<br />
continued to manipulate the<br />
market in defense of the naira<br />
value against the dollar,<br />
despite announcing to limit<br />
its interventions.<br />
The move turned out<br />
successful, with the window<br />
attracting some $42 billion<br />
since inception, according<br />
to FMDQ data.<br />
For context, that amount<br />
is the same as Egypt had in<br />
its external reserves as of<br />
February <strong>2018</strong> and is more<br />
than double the level of Nigeria’s<br />
external reserves in<br />
20<strong>16</strong> and is only $4 billion<br />
behind the current reserves<br />
of $46 billion.<br />
In that period, the naira<br />
has been relatively stableaveraging<br />
N360 per US dollar-<br />
while the stock market<br />
has rallied to a 3-year high,<br />
as foreign portfolio investors<br />
lap up Nigerian assets from<br />
stocks to bonds.
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
FT FINANCIAL TIMES<br />
C002D5556<br />
BUSINESS DAY<br />
A3<br />
World Business Newspaper<br />
Security and plane costs<br />
hit $9m as Zuckerberg<br />
tours US<br />
Why don’t more<br />
deputies get a shot<br />
at the top job?<br />
Sidekicks play a vital role that deserves more recognition<br />
PILITA CLARK<br />
Which chief executive wrote<br />
this last week: “There is no<br />
such thing as a free lunch.<br />
We will have to fight to succeed and my<br />
team and I are ready to do so. Because<br />
it’s worth it!”<br />
I doubt it will help much if I tell you<br />
it was the boss of one of the world’s<br />
biggest banks, because the words<br />
came from Christian Sewing, Deutsche<br />
Bank’s new CEO, in a message he<br />
sent to staff about his appointment<br />
on Monday.<br />
Outside banking circles, Mr Sewing<br />
is not a big name in his native<br />
Germany, let alone anywhere else. He<br />
joined Deutsche as a teenager in 1989<br />
and has been quietly plugging away<br />
there for all but two years ever since.<br />
I have no idea if he will be the answer<br />
to the bank’s plummeting share<br />
price or years of annual losses. But<br />
I rather hope he will be because Mr<br />
Sewing — formerly one of Deutsche’s<br />
deputy chief executives — is an example<br />
of something you do not see every<br />
day: a deputy who got the top job.<br />
I am biased because, although I<br />
have never had a job remotely as important<br />
as any of Mr Sewing’s, I have<br />
been a serial deputy, most recently this<br />
paper’s deputy news editor. And as is<br />
well known, this is often an excellent<br />
way to make sure you do a lot of thankless<br />
work and never get the boss’s job.<br />
In my case, this was not a problem.<br />
I am rarely gripped by the urge to run<br />
anything and have mostly been a deputy<br />
to pleasant, hard-working people<br />
who made their offsider’s life easy.<br />
At the same time, I decided I<br />
never wanted another job with the<br />
word “deputy” in the title. I agree with<br />
Richard Hytner, one of the few people<br />
to have written a book (Consiglieri)<br />
about the under-studied role of the<br />
sidekick. When people hear the word<br />
“number two”, he says, they often think<br />
“also-ran, loser, couldn’t hack it as<br />
number one”.<br />
And in my experience, they do. It<br />
was no surprise to see a survey last<br />
year showing the number of deputy<br />
chief executives in the 100 largest<br />
UK companies had dwindled to zero.<br />
Even deputies themselves dislike the<br />
Fastest expansion in loan books since Trump’s election<br />
ALISTAIR GRAY<br />
US banks have finally reopened<br />
the lending taps to corporate<br />
America, expanding their loan<br />
books at the fastest pace since Donald<br />
Trump’s election resulted in a lengthy<br />
credit stagnation.<br />
While the industry data published<br />
on Friday reflect only one month of<br />
recovery, bankers said they were an<br />
Page A4<br />
title. Two friends of mine who recently<br />
became a number two did something<br />
smart I wish I had thought of. They<br />
insisted on being called an “executive”<br />
so-and-so, rather than a deputy.<br />
Mr Hytner, a former deputy chairman<br />
of the Saatchi & Saatchi advertising<br />
group, thinks the deputy’s sorry<br />
reputation is unfair. Support acts are<br />
often happy to be number two and play<br />
a vital role in their organisations that<br />
he thinks deserves more recognition.<br />
I agree, but I am more interested in<br />
why deputies are so often passed over<br />
for the top job in favour of an outsider<br />
or thrusting insider.<br />
This is annoying for several reasons.<br />
First, the deputy usually has a<br />
proven record of running an organisation<br />
because they often have to do it<br />
when the boss is busy or away. They<br />
also usually do this without one of the<br />
big advantages the boss has: a deputy.<br />
Promoting people to be a deputy is<br />
also a helpful way to groom talented<br />
staff and create a pool of potential<br />
leaders who can be considered alongside<br />
outside candidates when a new<br />
chief is needed.<br />
These number twos have one big<br />
advantage over external hires: they<br />
are a known quantity. Outsiders who<br />
look terrific on paper and have stellar<br />
records elsewhere are not guaranteed<br />
the same success in new organisations.<br />
The corporate landscape is littered<br />
with examples of high-fliers raided<br />
from rival organisations who falter.<br />
Few fall to ground as quickly as<br />
John Browett, the former boss of the<br />
Dixons electronics chain who lasted<br />
less than a year as Apple’s head of retail.<br />
But they can be just as disruptive.<br />
This is no argument against the<br />
often excellent outside hire. Carolyn<br />
McCall, the former boss of the Guardian<br />
Media Group, was dismissed as a<br />
media luvvie when she was picked to<br />
run easyJet in 2010.<br />
By the time she left seven years<br />
later, the company’s share price had<br />
quadrupled and its passenger numbers<br />
had soared to records.<br />
There are plenty of other examples<br />
like her. Would deputies have ever<br />
done as well? It is impossible to say<br />
because, as is so often the case, they<br />
never got the chance to lead.<br />
US banks open lending taps to corporate America<br />
encouraging sign and predicted a more<br />
sustained pick up as US business gets<br />
more comfortable about taking on<br />
more debt.<br />
“You saw a decent pick up in March<br />
and we’re seeing that in our pipeline,”<br />
said Bill Demchak, chairman and chief<br />
executive of PNC Financial Services, the<br />
sixth-biggest US retail bank by assets.<br />
Continues on page A4<br />
Tighter interest rates<br />
raise fears of central<br />
bank exposure<br />
Second fiddle: Julia Louis-Dreyfus as US vice-president Selina Meyer in ‘Veep’ © HBO<br />
Berlin’s airport travails bruise German engineering pride<br />
Project nears completion, almost a decade late and regarded as national joke<br />
GUY CHAZAN<br />
It has been such a mess that one<br />
senior Lufthansa executive recently<br />
predicted it would have to be torn<br />
down and rebuilt.<br />
But after years of scandal and<br />
controversy, Berlin’s new airport is finally<br />
inching towards completion. The<br />
€5.3bn building will begin operations<br />
in October 2020, nearly a decade later<br />
than planned. Germany’s biggest national<br />
joke is readying for primetime.<br />
Engelbert Lütke-Daldrup, boss of<br />
the airport operating company, knows<br />
many will view the new deadline, first<br />
unveiled last December, with scepticism.<br />
Since work began on BER, as it<br />
is known, its official opening has been<br />
postponed six times.<br />
But on a recent press tour of the<br />
building, he promised there would be<br />
no more delays. “We’ve deliberately<br />
gone for a date that’s reliable, that has<br />
Americas find common cause in attack on Maduro<br />
Trump is the first US president to miss Americas Summit in its 24-year history<br />
GIDEON LONG<br />
Latin America found rare common<br />
ground with the US in<br />
criticising Nicolás Maduro,<br />
Venezuela’s president, at a fractious<br />
Summit of the Americas marked by<br />
Donald Trump’s decision to stay<br />
at home to deal with the conflict<br />
in Syria.<br />
Mr Trump pulled out just three<br />
days before the start of this weekend’s<br />
summit in Lima, becoming<br />
the first US president to miss the<br />
event in its 24-year history. Some<br />
Latin Americans said his no-show<br />
proved how little he cared about<br />
the region.<br />
The US leader sent Mike Pence,<br />
vice-president, in his place, but a<br />
White House faux pas served only<br />
to raise Latin American hackles<br />
further. In a note to journalists, Mr<br />
Pence’s office said he would attend<br />
a banquet hosted by Pedro Pablo<br />
Kuczynski, who resigned as Peru’s<br />
president last month.<br />
Trade tension between the US<br />
and China also cast a shadow over<br />
Page A5<br />
sufficient reserves built in to cover all<br />
unforeseen circumstances,” he said. “It<br />
means we’ll all have to be a bit more<br />
patient — the public too.”<br />
Mr Lütke-Daldrup whisked journalists<br />
through the new terminal<br />
building, a cavernous, light-filled<br />
space the size of eight football fields.<br />
Eerily empty now, it will one day<br />
swarm with travellers: by 2040, BER<br />
will be capable of processing up to 55m<br />
passengers a year.<br />
“With BER the city will finally get<br />
the airport it deserves,” said Burkhard<br />
Kieker, head of VisitBerlin, which promotes<br />
tourism to the German capital.<br />
But it’s questionable whether it will<br />
ever be able to shake off its reputation<br />
as a national embarrassment. “BER is<br />
not exactly a glorious chapter in the<br />
history of German engineering and<br />
construction,” Mr Lütke-Daldrup said.<br />
That is an understatement. Dogged<br />
by technical snafus, poor planning<br />
the summit. Latin American companies<br />
export billions of dollars<br />
in raw materials to both countries<br />
and are wary of any threat of further<br />
tariffs.<br />
But on Venezuela, most nations<br />
of the Americas were in agreement.<br />
With the exception of a few<br />
leftwing countries, notably Cuba,<br />
they expressed concern about the<br />
exodus of Venezuelans fleeing hyperinflation,<br />
hunger and crime in<br />
their homeland.<br />
“It’s incredible that [Mr Maduro]<br />
remains in a state of denial when<br />
faced with such a clear crisis, when<br />
the whole world can see with its<br />
own eyes how his people are physically<br />
dying of hunger,” said Juan<br />
Manuel Santos, president of Colombia,<br />
which has borne the brunt<br />
of the exodus. Colombia, Chile<br />
and Argentina said they would not<br />
recognise the results of Venezuela’s<br />
presidential election, arguing the<br />
May 20 contest would be neither<br />
free nor fair.<br />
“The elections are not democratic,<br />
they’re not transparent, they<br />
and dizzying management changes,<br />
BER has become a byword for incompetence.<br />
When work on the site began in<br />
September 2006, the opening was set<br />
for 2011. That has since been repeatedly<br />
pushed back, while the project’s<br />
budget has more than doubled from<br />
€2.5bn to €5.3bn.<br />
Thorsten Dirks, a senior executive<br />
at Lufthansa, said last month that all<br />
the equipment the airline had installed<br />
in BER was now hopelessly out of date.<br />
“My prediction: the thing will be pulled<br />
down and rebuilt,” he said.<br />
Critics think the 2020 deadline<br />
will go the way of all the others. “This<br />
is the same team that never managed<br />
to get it up and running on time and<br />
crashed all the previous deadlines,”<br />
said Dieter Faulenbach da Costa, an<br />
airport planner who has been one of<br />
BER’s harshest critics. “Why should it<br />
be any better this time?”<br />
don’t comply with the minimum<br />
standards of a truly democratic society,”<br />
said Sebastián Piñera, Chile’s<br />
president. “No country that truly<br />
believes in democracy in my opinion<br />
should recognise these elections.”<br />
Mr Pence described Venezuela<br />
as “essentially a failed state” and the<br />
government in Caracas as a “corrupt<br />
dictatorship”. “The responsibility for<br />
the Venezuelan people’s suffering<br />
can be laid at the feet of one man:<br />
Nicolás Maduro,” he said.<br />
With Mr Maduro barred from the<br />
summit, the defence of Caracas fell<br />
to Havana, and at times the exchanges<br />
between Bruno Rodríguez, Cuba’s<br />
foreign minister, and Mr Pence were<br />
reminiscent of the darkest days of<br />
the cold war.<br />
Mr Rodríguez accused the Trump<br />
administration of promoting “hate,<br />
division, selfishness, calumny, racism,<br />
xenophobia and lies”. The<br />
thawing of relations between the two<br />
nations under Barack Obama had<br />
been reversed, he said, and Cuba<br />
“will not cede one millimetre” in the<br />
way it conducts its internal affairs.
A4 BUSINESS DAY<br />
C002D5556 Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
FT<br />
NATIONAL<br />
US poised to support $13bn capital increase for World Bank<br />
Package would see big lending reforms and rise in China’s shareholding<br />
SHAWN DONNAN AND SAM FLEMING<br />
The Trump administration is<br />
poised to back a $13bn capital<br />
increase for the World Bank in<br />
a package that would see significant<br />
lending reforms and an increase in<br />
China’s shareholding.<br />
Barring last-minute hiccups, US<br />
Treasury secretary Steven Mnuchin is<br />
set to tell fellow World Bank shareholders<br />
at next week’s spring meetings in<br />
Washington that he will support an<br />
increase in the bank’s capital, a senior<br />
Treasury official confirmed to the<br />
Financial Times on Friday. The move<br />
would be a significant shift in the US<br />
administration’s attitudes towards<br />
multilateral institutions.<br />
“I think we are moving in that<br />
direction. We have been working for<br />
months on reforms at the bank and<br />
they have made a lot of progress,” the<br />
senior official said.<br />
The turnround in White House<br />
views on the World Bank marks a major<br />
win for its president, Jim Yong Kim,<br />
who was first nominated for the role by<br />
former President Barack Obama. He<br />
has worked hard to build a relationship<br />
with the new administration and<br />
aligned himself with Ivanka Trump,<br />
the president’s daughter, who was behind<br />
a $150m women’s empowerment<br />
fund launched by the bank last year.<br />
The administration, which expressed<br />
reservations about World<br />
Bank lending to China and other<br />
middle-income countries at last October’s<br />
annual meetings, had been wary<br />
of the plans for a capital increase and<br />
expectations for an agreement at next<br />
week’s meetings were muted.<br />
However, Scott Morris, a former<br />
Treasury official now at the Center for<br />
Global Development, a Washington<br />
think-tank, said: “I’m hearing a lot<br />
of positive sentiment both from the<br />
Bank side and the US side. That’s pretty<br />
remarkable.”<br />
US banks open lending<br />
taps to corporate America...<br />
Continued from page A11<br />
“That should set us up well for the rest<br />
of the year.”<br />
Commercial and industrial loan balances<br />
swelled at a seasonally adjusted<br />
rate of 9.3 per cent last month to hit a<br />
record $2.13 trillion, according to the<br />
Federal Reserve figures.<br />
That was by far the biggest increase<br />
since the 20<strong>16</strong> election. In only two<br />
other months since the vote has the rate<br />
of growth been higher than 3 per cent.<br />
The protracted period of weakness<br />
had called into question how businesses<br />
feel about the Trump administration’s<br />
agenda and uncertainty about tax<br />
reform in particular, suggesting they<br />
were nervous about the direction of<br />
the economy.<br />
Commercial loan volumes have<br />
been among the biggest concerns to<br />
investors in US banks, who are otherwise<br />
upbeat about a profit-boosting<br />
mix of higher interest rates and financial<br />
deregulation.<br />
Analysts have offered some technical<br />
explanations for the corporate lending<br />
sluggishness: instead of borrowing<br />
from banks large companies have been<br />
tapping capital markets, for instance.<br />
However, bankers have identified<br />
policy uncertainty from Washington as<br />
a primary factor, arguing it held made<br />
companies hold back on expansion<br />
plans.<br />
Presenting quarterly earnings on<br />
Friday, executives said business was<br />
feeling more comfortable — especially<br />
now that tax reform had passed. John<br />
Gerspach, Citigroup’s chief financial<br />
officer, said the “best is yet to come”<br />
from the tax cuts.<br />
Marianne Lake, chief financial officer<br />
at JPMorgan Chase, said the bank<br />
was “expecting growth in the mid-single<br />
digits” in commercial and industrial<br />
loan balances for the year. They rose 5<br />
per cent in the first quarter compared<br />
with a year ago.<br />
She added, though, that the bank<br />
would “continue to be very selective and<br />
cautious” — especially in commercial<br />
real estate, where “pricing has become<br />
fiercely competitive”.<br />
Earnings season continues on Monday<br />
with results from Bank of America,<br />
which is also forecast to benefit from<br />
a pick-up in loan demand. Analysts<br />
have pencilled in a 40 per cent year-onyear<br />
rise in first quarter net income to<br />
$6.<strong>16</strong>bn, according to estimates collated<br />
by Bloomberg.<br />
The recent commercial lending<br />
recovery has helped banks compensate<br />
for weakness in other areas, notably<br />
mortgages. Higher interest rates have<br />
led to a slump in demand for refinancings.<br />
Wells Fargo has been particularly<br />
hard hit, reporting a 24 per cent decline<br />
in mortgage banking income in the first<br />
quarter.<br />
Security and plane costs hit $9m as Zuckerberg tours US<br />
Surge in costs for safety picked up by company for founder worth estimated $66bn<br />
TIM BRADSHAW<br />
Facebook shareholders picked up<br />
a $9m bill for chief executive Mark<br />
Zuckerberg’s personal security<br />
detail and private aircraft usage last year,<br />
as he took on a “personal challenge” to<br />
visit every US state.<br />
Mr Zuckerberg, whose net worth<br />
is estimated at $66bn, spent much of<br />
2017 criss-crossing the US, from Alaska<br />
to Louisiana, as part of an effort to “get<br />
out and talk to more people about how<br />
they’re living, working and thinking<br />
about the future”.<br />
While the grand tour was styled by<br />
Mr Zuckerberg as the latest in a series<br />
of “personal challenges” designed to<br />
help him “grow outside of my work”,<br />
Facebook’s shareholders were left to pick<br />
up the tab for much of the travel.<br />
Mr Zuckerberg, who receives a notional<br />
$1 annual salary, saw his “other<br />
compensation” jump by more than 50<br />
per cent, from $5.8m in 20<strong>16</strong> to $8.9m<br />
MATTHEW GARRAHAN<br />
After almost two weeks of swirling<br />
speculation about his future, it<br />
still came as a shock late on Saturday<br />
night when WPP announced that<br />
Martin Sorrell, its chief executive of more<br />
than three decades, would be stepping<br />
down following an investigation into<br />
an unspecified misconduct allegation.<br />
Company and man have been inextricably<br />
linked since 1987 when he was<br />
appointed to lead what was then known<br />
as Wire & Plastic Products, a small maker<br />
of shopping baskets until Sir Martin and<br />
a business partner bought a minority<br />
stake. They set about transforming it into<br />
a global marketing services company<br />
and with Sir Martin running the show<br />
and masterminding deal after deal, WPP<br />
ascended to the summit of the advertising<br />
industry.<br />
last year, according to a regulatory filing<br />
released on Friday afternoon.<br />
The figure includes $7.3m in personal<br />
security fees both at home and on his<br />
travels, up from $4.8m in the prior year,<br />
and $1.5m for “costs related to personal<br />
usage of private aircraft” — a 75 per cent<br />
increase on 20<strong>16</strong>’s flight costs.<br />
The disclosure comes at the end<br />
of a bruising week for Mr Zuckerberg,<br />
as he faced questions from dozens of<br />
lawmakers in Washington DC about<br />
Facebook’s handling of personal privacy<br />
and electoral interference.<br />
During Mr Zuckerberg’s walkabout,<br />
he posted on his Facebook page about<br />
driving a tractor in Wisconsin, fishing for<br />
salmon with Native Alaskans, and petting<br />
a service dog in Montana’s Glacier<br />
National Park.<br />
He has also spoken about meeting<br />
recovering drug addicts in Ohio and<br />
visiting a church in Charleston, South<br />
Carolina, where a shooting in 2015 killed<br />
nine people.<br />
The local families and community<br />
Martin Sorrell’s empire building reshaped adland<br />
The former Saatchi & Saatchi finance<br />
director created the model of<br />
an advertising holding company with<br />
a conglomerate-style structure where<br />
individual media buying, creative,<br />
public relations and digital services<br />
businesses coexisted under one roof. A<br />
flurry of deals saw J. Walter Thompson,<br />
Ogilvy & Mather, Young & Rubicam and<br />
Grey added to WPP’s portfolio. Other<br />
companies, such as the media buying<br />
giant GroupM, were created in-house.<br />
“You can’t underestimate what he<br />
achieved,” said Alex DeGroote, media<br />
analyst with Cenkos Securities. “He<br />
took a cash shell that had zero value and<br />
turned it into an established FTSE 100<br />
name over a 30-year period, acquiring<br />
the global marketing services industry’s<br />
biggest names. I don’t think anyone will<br />
be capable of doing it again.”<br />
The impact on the ad landscape<br />
groups he flew to visit were often given<br />
only a few hours’ notice of his arrival, in<br />
order to ensure his security.<br />
Facebook said in its proxy filing that<br />
the company paid the security costs due<br />
to “specific threats” to Mr Zuckerberg’s<br />
safety that arise “directly as a result of<br />
his position” as Facebook’s founder and<br />
chief executive.<br />
“We require these security measures<br />
for the company’s benefit because of the<br />
importance of Mr. Zuckerberg to Facebook,<br />
and we believe that the costs of this<br />
overall security program are appropriate<br />
and necessary,” the company said in the<br />
filing. Using private aircraft is part of the<br />
security programme, it added.<br />
The proxy filing also disclosed that<br />
Facebook’s other executives saw their<br />
cash bonuses fall in 2017 compared<br />
with the previous year. Sheryl Sandberg,<br />
Facebook’s chief operating officer, received<br />
a bonus payout of $640,378, less<br />
than half the amount she received in<br />
2017, after a reduction in her “individual<br />
performance” rating.<br />
His impact on the industry was profound but not everyone was a fan of his approach<br />
was profound as rivals such as Publicis<br />
and Omnicom followed WPP’s model,<br />
consolidating what had been a large and<br />
disparate industry into a handful of holding<br />
companies. But not everyone was a<br />
fan of his approach — or of the changes<br />
wreaked on the ad industry by WPP and<br />
Sir Martin, who declined to comment.<br />
When WPP acquired Ogilvy &<br />
Mather in 1989, the late David Ogilvy<br />
called him an “odious little shit”. He also<br />
upset some within advertising’s creative<br />
community: Ogilvy employees were<br />
not happy in 1992 when WPP uprooted<br />
them from central London to a new<br />
office in Canary Wharf — an area not<br />
exactly rich in inspiration for advertising<br />
creatives. “There was a period, probably<br />
in the first four or five years, when<br />
it could have killed the agency,” Paul<br />
O’Donnell, Ogilvy’s former UK head,<br />
told the Financial Times in 2014.<br />
Donald Trump creates<br />
task force to scrutinise<br />
postal service<br />
President seeks report on pricing linked to<br />
USPS contract with Amazon<br />
BARNEY JOPSON AND<br />
KADHIM SHUBBER<br />
Donald Trump has begun to<br />
act on his complaints that<br />
the US Postal Service is losing<br />
out on shipments for Amazon<br />
by ordering an official review of<br />
the mail agency’s pricing of package<br />
deliveries.<br />
After amplifying his longstanding<br />
dissatisfaction over Amazon’s<br />
delivery contract with the post<br />
office, Mr Trump late on Thursday<br />
created a task force to evaluate the<br />
“operations and finances” of the<br />
post office.<br />
The move caught Washington<br />
by surprise as it had been unclear<br />
how Mr Trump would act on his<br />
contested claims that delivering<br />
packages for Amazon was contributing<br />
to the postal service’s<br />
substantial losses.<br />
An executive order creating the<br />
task force — to be led by Treasury<br />
secretary Steven Mnuchin — said<br />
it would examine “the expansion<br />
and pricing of the package delivery<br />
market and the USPS’s role in<br />
competitive markets”.<br />
Despite Amazon’s high-tech<br />
credentials, it relies on about<br />
230,000 postal workers to deliver<br />
millions of packages along the<br />
“last mile” to many American<br />
homes.<br />
As concern about the power of<br />
big tech companies escalates in<br />
Washington, Mr Trump has turned<br />
Amazon into the target of a personal<br />
crusade even as Congress is<br />
preoccupied with Facebook, hauling<br />
its founder Mark Zuckerberg in<br />
to testify this week.<br />
Package deliveries for ecommerce<br />
have been a source of<br />
revenue growth for the postal<br />
service, going some way towards<br />
offsetting a sharp decline in letter<br />
volume. But the post office has<br />
still posted a net loss in each of the<br />
past 11 years, including a $2.7bn<br />
loss in 2017.<br />
The executive order says: “The<br />
USPS is on an unsustainable<br />
financial path and must be restructured<br />
to prevent a taxpayerfunded<br />
bailout.”<br />
In one tweet this month, Mr<br />
Trump said: “I am right about Amazon<br />
costing the United States Post<br />
Office massive amounts of money<br />
for being their Delivery Boy.”<br />
His discontent over the alliance<br />
of the postal service with Amazon<br />
appears to have become entangled<br />
with its founder Jeff Bezos’s ownership<br />
of the Washington Post<br />
— one of the president’s least<br />
favourite media outlets.<br />
Allies of the postal service said<br />
it cannot be losing money on its<br />
work for Amazon since it is barred<br />
by law from charging its customers<br />
less than the cost of delivery.
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
FINANCIAL TIMES<br />
COMPANIES & MARKETS<br />
@ FINANCIAL TIMES LIMITED<br />
Corporate America poised<br />
to unveil record buybacks<br />
Companies likely to boost dividends to fresh high on back of tax cuts, JPMorgan says<br />
C002D5556<br />
BUSINESS DAY<br />
A5<br />
ROBIN WIGGLESWORTH<br />
US companies are expected<br />
to shower investors with a<br />
record amount of share buybacks<br />
in the current earnings season,<br />
as corporate executives take<br />
advantage of major tax cuts and a<br />
faltering stock market to increase<br />
their repurchase programmes.<br />
S&P 500 companies have already<br />
announced about $<strong>16</strong>7bn of<br />
new buyback authorisations this<br />
year, and analysts at JPMorgan<br />
predict that trend will accelerate<br />
this quarter as boardrooms digest<br />
the full scale of the tax cuts passed<br />
in December.<br />
“We are expecting record buyback<br />
announcements during this<br />
earnings season given further clarity<br />
on tax reform, equity multiples<br />
are broadly attractive, and companies<br />
likely to replenish buyback<br />
programmes after the recent selloff,”<br />
noted Dubravko Lakos-Bujas,<br />
an analyst at JPMorgan.<br />
Overall, US companies will buy<br />
back about $800bn of their stock<br />
this year, the bank forecasts, up<br />
from $525bn in 2017, and boost<br />
dividend payouts by about 10 per<br />
cent to a record $500bn.<br />
President Donald Trump and<br />
the Republican-controlled Congress<br />
have lauded a potential upswing<br />
in investment by US companies<br />
following the tax cuts, but<br />
strategists at Goldman Sachs expect<br />
a heftier increase in buybacks and<br />
dividends.<br />
The buyback and dividend bonanza<br />
would be a welcome boost<br />
to the US stock market, which has<br />
become more volatile this year over<br />
concerns that global economic<br />
The UK pension industry will<br />
undergo a “fundamental shift”<br />
over the next three years, curtailing<br />
new business growth for asset<br />
managers hired to provide sophisticated<br />
investment strategies to final<br />
salary retirement schemes.<br />
A growing number of UK defined<br />
benefit (DB) pension schemes have<br />
adopted liability driven investment<br />
strategies (LDIs) over the past 20<br />
years to reduce the risk that they may<br />
be unable to meet retirement payments<br />
that stretch for decades ahead.<br />
Demand for LDIs will slow markedly<br />
by 2021, said London consultancy<br />
Hymans Robertson. It predicted<br />
that this shift would also significantly<br />
affect the UK government bond<br />
market.<br />
LDIs provide protection against<br />
unforeseen changes in interest rates,<br />
inflation and life expectancy while<br />
also helping DB pension schemes to<br />
increase assets.<br />
Insight, a division of BNY Mellon,<br />
Legal & General Investment Management<br />
and BlackRock are the three<br />
biggest players in the LDI market.<br />
BMO of Canada, Schroders and<br />
River & Mercantile each run more<br />
than 100 mandates that are significantly<br />
smaller in combined assets<br />
growth is slowing and international<br />
trade tension are escalating.<br />
“I find it hard not to be excited<br />
about equities,” said Marco Pirondini,<br />
head of US equities at Amundi<br />
Pioneer Asset Management. “Companies<br />
are super profitable, and<br />
have money to increase investments,<br />
buybacks and dividends.”<br />
David Kostin, chief US equity<br />
strategist at Goldman Sachs, said<br />
that a surge in corporate share buybacks<br />
helped turn round markets<br />
after the turmoil of early February,<br />
and thinks that a renewed pick-up<br />
will put the S&P 500 back on track<br />
for a 10 per cent gain by the end of<br />
the year.<br />
While US companies will lift<br />
their spending on investments,<br />
research and development by 11<br />
per cent to more than $1tn this year,<br />
shareholder returns in the form of<br />
buybacks and dividends will grow<br />
by 21.6 per cent to nearly $1.2tn, Mr<br />
Kostin predicted.<br />
“I’m willing to bet that as soon<br />
as companies start buying shares<br />
again [after the earning season<br />
blackout] that we will see the market<br />
volatility fall again,” Mr Pirondini<br />
said. “The geopolitical temperature<br />
is going up, and that’s not a good<br />
thing. But it is the economic cycle<br />
that will drive markets, and the<br />
global economy looks good.”<br />
The buyback spree will also lift<br />
the amount of profit companies<br />
make per share. S&P 500 companies<br />
are expected to report earnings<br />
growth of 17.1 per cent in the first<br />
quarter, which would the highest<br />
growth since the start of 2011,<br />
according to FactSet. That is up<br />
sharply from the rate of 11.3 per<br />
cent that was projected at the start<br />
of the year.<br />
UK pensions industry faces ‘fundamental shift’<br />
Consultancy predicts liability driven investment demand<br />
to be saturated by 2021<br />
CHRIS FLOOD<br />
than the LDI operations of each of<br />
the big three.<br />
A survey by Hymans found<br />
that more than three-quarters of<br />
the £1.5tn total assets held by DB<br />
schemes already employed some<br />
form of LDI, suggesting that new demand<br />
could become exhausted over<br />
the next three years.<br />
“We will reach the age of peak LDI<br />
by 2021 at the latest,” said Jon Hatchett,<br />
a partner with Hymans. “Pension<br />
schemes have added about £100bn of<br />
notional hedging [via LDIs] annually<br />
over the past three years and will not<br />
materially hedge above asset levels<br />
of £1.5tn.”<br />
If new demand for LDIs was to<br />
drop to £50bn a year, then the market<br />
would not reach saturation point<br />
until 2026.<br />
Robert Gall, head of market strategy<br />
at Insight Investment, said it would<br />
take “many years” before the hedging<br />
requirements of pension funds could<br />
be fully met.<br />
“We expect the fundamental<br />
demand for LDI to persist for the<br />
foreseeable future,” said Mr Gall.<br />
Professor David Blake, director of<br />
the pensions institute at Cass Business<br />
School, London, said demand<br />
for LDIs would depend on changes<br />
in central banks’ policies as interest<br />
rates were rising in the UK and US.<br />
Monetary policymakers are starting to wean bond markets off the support provided through quantitative easing<br />
Tighter interest rates raise fears of central bank exposure<br />
Officials responsible for asset portfolios worry about prospect of steep losses<br />
CLAIRE JONES<br />
Officials responsible for managing<br />
central banks’ vast asset<br />
portfolios fear exposure<br />
to steep losses as their policymaking<br />
counterparts tighten interest<br />
rates on the back of a global economic<br />
expansion.<br />
Central banks are some of the<br />
biggest investors in markets for government<br />
and highly rated corporate<br />
bonds, making their portfolios sensitive<br />
to changes in interest rates.<br />
In a poll of central bank reserve<br />
managers, responsible for assets<br />
worth $5.5tn, most said rising rates<br />
posed the biggest threat to their<br />
performance over the next year.<br />
The US Federal Reserve is expected<br />
to raise rates three times<br />
this year, and the European Central<br />
Bank set to follow suit around mid-<br />
2019. Rates are at or close to historic<br />
lows, a legacy of central banks’ response<br />
to the financial crisis of 2008<br />
that left global markets teetering.<br />
Higher rates are expected to<br />
push up yields on government<br />
bonds and other relatively safe assets.<br />
With yields moving in the opposite<br />
direction to price, that would<br />
lower the value of the sort of assets<br />
that central banks tend to own.<br />
In the poll of reserve managers<br />
at 79 central banks conducted<br />
by Central Banking Publications,<br />
a trade publisher, and HSBC, just<br />
over three-quarters of respondents<br />
thought rising interest rates would<br />
be one of the biggest threats over<br />
the next year, with 59 per cent saying<br />
it was the most important risk.<br />
The reserve managers signalled<br />
they would respond to tighter<br />
monetary policy by buying more<br />
short-term debt for now, in a sign<br />
they expect bonds with longer-term<br />
maturities to offer higher yields<br />
in the coming years as monetary<br />
policymakers raise rates.<br />
The prospect of rate rises comes<br />
at a time when monetary policymakers<br />
are beginning to wean<br />
bond markets off the support they<br />
have provided through quantitative<br />
easing. Monetary policymakers<br />
across advanced economies<br />
bought trillions of dollars of assets<br />
as part of “quantitative easing”<br />
programmes aimed at restoring<br />
economic growth and staving off<br />
deflation.<br />
While the policies are credited<br />
with spearheading the global economic<br />
recovery, critics have said<br />
policymakers have inflated bubbles<br />
in asset prices.<br />
Assets bought by banks under<br />
QE are not included as central<br />
banks’ reserves, as policymakers<br />
are not expected to hold on to these<br />
over the longer term. The Federal<br />
Reserve has started to unwind its<br />
QE operations while the European<br />
Central Bank is expected to halt<br />
fresh asset purchases under its<br />
€2.4tn programme at the end of<br />
this year.<br />
Reserves are usually amassed<br />
through central banks’ attempts to<br />
control the value of their currency<br />
through purchases of the main<br />
global reserve currencies such as<br />
dollars or euros.<br />
Central banks tend to invest<br />
their reserves in safe government<br />
or corporate bonds, as well as gold,<br />
though some invest in equities.<br />
Most assets are denominated in<br />
dollars or euros.<br />
Central banks hold reserves<br />
worth $10.8tn according to IMF<br />
data. Asian central banks are responsible<br />
for the biggest reserve<br />
stockpiles.<br />
Maiden Cloudcover women in business forum holds, challenges females to aim higher<br />
The maiden edition of Women<br />
in Business, a networking session<br />
for women in all sectors of<br />
the economy powered by Cloudcover<br />
Limited, an innovative company delivering<br />
constant internet connectivity to<br />
Nigerians, has held in Lagos with a call<br />
on women to always aim high and not<br />
be limited by their situations.<br />
The interactive session brought together<br />
women from diverse industries<br />
and organisations, and addressed issues<br />
concerning women in all areas of<br />
economic endeavour.<br />
Featuring women entrepreneurs,<br />
professionals, businesswomen and<br />
budding entrepreneurs, the event held<br />
at Brown’s Cafe, Victoria Island, and<br />
had the co-founder of She Leads Africa,<br />
Afua Osei as keynote speaker.<br />
Afua Osei, an Entrepreneur, Investor,<br />
and a seasoned Public Speaker, urged<br />
women not to be overwhelmed by the<br />
harsh economic environment that seeks to<br />
limit them from attaining greater heights.<br />
According to her, “It’s a tough society<br />
with series of odds stacked against<br />
women but we must never give up. We<br />
will find it hard going alone but our<br />
strength is in our unity. When we collectively<br />
face challenges, we will achieve<br />
more. We should network more, share<br />
insights more and seek solutions together.<br />
We must not be overwhelmed by<br />
the institutional and cultural hurdles in<br />
our paths, we must refuse to be limited.”<br />
Osei who had also served in the office<br />
of America’s ex-First Lady, Michelle<br />
Obama, added that “this is a unique opportunity<br />
that has been offered to us by<br />
Cloudcover, we should do well to seize it<br />
and also look into offerings by the company<br />
that can assist us in our respective<br />
endeavours. Whether entrepreneur,<br />
professional or businesswomen, we will<br />
find the device invaluable.”<br />
In her brief remarks, Group Chief<br />
Operating Officer of Cloudcover Limited,<br />
Eleanor Potter, explained that<br />
the aim of the interaction was to help<br />
women surmount cultural and institutional<br />
hurdles they face in realizing<br />
their career and business goals through<br />
quality networking.<br />
She said that Cloudcover recognises<br />
the huge but underappreciated<br />
roles women have been playing in the<br />
Nigerian business landscape and will<br />
continue to offer them innovative<br />
solutions that will give them a head<br />
start and make their tasks easier in<br />
whichever sector of the economy they<br />
are playing in.<br />
Potter said: “We recognise the<br />
thousands of women playing in different<br />
sectors of the economy and who<br />
need help to further progress along.<br />
No matter whom you are; established<br />
entrepreneur, up and coming one, a<br />
professional, Cloudcover will empower<br />
you to do more through these networking<br />
sessions and our innovative internet<br />
and data solutions like the Cloudcover<br />
CC1 MiFi device that makes use of dynamic<br />
network roaming to give users<br />
seamless and constant internet connectivity<br />
across seven network providers in<br />
Nigeria. With the CC1 device, women<br />
and indeed everybody no longer have<br />
to own multiple SIMs and MiFi as the<br />
device uses virtual sim technology.<br />
These and more are ways by which we<br />
will continue to help women grow.”<br />
Co-founder of Cloudcover Limited,<br />
Uchenna Agbo, disclosed that being<br />
women themselves, they understand<br />
the challenges businesswomen, entrepreneurs<br />
and professionals are facing<br />
in Nigeria, hence their resolve to create<br />
a platform to help as many as possible.
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
A6 BUSINESS DAY
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
BUSINESS DAY<br />
A7
A8<br />
NEWS<br />
New technologies<br />
key to driving<br />
Africa’s growth<br />
MIKE OCHONMA<br />
BUSINESS DAY<br />
C002D5556<br />
Chun-Yuan Gu,<br />
president, ABB,<br />
Asia, Middle East<br />
region, says Africa<br />
has an historic opportunity<br />
to accelerate growth and<br />
development by tapping<br />
into the potential that new<br />
technologies holds in the<br />
continent.<br />
Delivering a speech at<br />
the ABB Customer World<br />
Africa <strong>2018</strong> conference in<br />
Johannesburg, South Africa,<br />
Chun-Yuan Gu noted<br />
that the digital revolution<br />
had already transformed<br />
the lives of millions of people<br />
through mobile phone<br />
and Internet access, saying<br />
these technologies had allowed<br />
Africans to leap over<br />
fixed-line telephone usage<br />
and use financial services<br />
without “setting foot in a<br />
bank.”<br />
“Now, those technologies<br />
are transforming industry,<br />
and Africa is the<br />
place that stands to benefit<br />
most, by leapfrogging older<br />
technologies on to a sustainable<br />
path to growth and<br />
development,” he said.<br />
Underlining Africa’s opportunities<br />
and ABB’s key<br />
role in unlocking value for<br />
its customers through automation<br />
is the 40% rise<br />
in the group’s 2017 orders<br />
across all its divisions, subregions<br />
and channels, Gu<br />
said.<br />
“Africa has the world’s<br />
most youthful population.<br />
This, combined with improving<br />
economic fundamentals,<br />
makes the continent<br />
ideally positioned<br />
to take advantage of new<br />
technologies. Training and<br />
preparing the next generation<br />
of engineers is pivotal.”<br />
He pointed out that Africa<br />
had the tools and the<br />
means to compete in global<br />
markets, adding that by<br />
taking advantage of ABB’s<br />
digital offering, ABB Ability,<br />
Africa would be capable<br />
of building robust industries<br />
that can compete<br />
with rivals in other parts of<br />
the globe.<br />
ABB Ability, which was<br />
launched last year, works<br />
by gathering and analysing<br />
data from customers’ operations<br />
and applying to that<br />
data, knowledge and expertise<br />
gained from ABB’s<br />
vast global installed base<br />
of 70-million connected<br />
devices and 70 000 control<br />
systems.<br />
“It helps customers in<br />
utilities, industry, transport<br />
and infrastructure<br />
develop new processes<br />
and advance existing ones<br />
by providing insights and<br />
optimising planning and<br />
controls for real-time operations,”<br />
Gu said.<br />
Nigeria tops countries with<br />
highest death sentences in SSA<br />
KELVIN UMWENI<br />
Though no execution<br />
was recorded<br />
in Nigeria, the total<br />
number of death<br />
penalty recorded<br />
at the end of 2017 stood at<br />
621, the second highest in<br />
the world after China, while<br />
2,285 people were known to<br />
be under death sentence.<br />
This is according to a report<br />
released <strong>Apr</strong>il 12, by<br />
Amnesty International, a<br />
global movement for the protection<br />
of human rights.<br />
The report noted that in<br />
Nigeria, 68 persons were<br />
commuted, 17 pardons were<br />
granted while 28 persons under<br />
death sentence were exonerated<br />
in 2017, the highest<br />
in the world.<br />
Global death sentences<br />
decreased by 17 percent to<br />
over 2,591 in 2017 from 3,117<br />
recorded in the previous year<br />
with over 21,919 people under<br />
death sentence as of yearend<br />
2017.<br />
In the same vein, the total<br />
number of executions carried<br />
out by countries around<br />
the world (excluding China)<br />
in 2017 was down for the<br />
second consecutive time by<br />
4 percent to 993 compared<br />
with 1,032 executions recorded<br />
in 20<strong>16</strong>.<br />
The Middle East countries<br />
of Iran, Saudi Arabia,<br />
Iraq and Pakistan accounted<br />
for 84 percent of all recorded<br />
executions globally in 2017;<br />
Iran alone accounted for 51<br />
percent of this figure.<br />
China, with over 1,000 recorded<br />
executions, remains<br />
the country with the highest<br />
number of executions worldwide,<br />
though the Chinese<br />
government still classifies<br />
figures as “a state secret,” thus<br />
making it difficult to obtain<br />
complete official statistics.<br />
The report noted that the<br />
United States of America<br />
(USA) was the only country<br />
to carry out executions in<br />
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
the Americas, while Guyana,<br />
Trinidad and Tobago and the<br />
USA were the only country<br />
in the region that imposed<br />
death sentences.<br />
Eleven countries of USA,<br />
China, Vietnam, Saudi Arabia,<br />
Iran, Iraq, Somalia, Japan,<br />
North Korea, Afghanistan<br />
and Malaysia, excluding<br />
Syria and Libya, were fingered<br />
by Amnesty International<br />
to have persistently<br />
executed in the last five years<br />
(2013 – 2017).
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
BUSINESS DAY<br />
A9
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
A10 BUSINESS DAY
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
BUSINESS DAY<br />
A11
A12<br />
NEWS<br />
BUSINESS DAY<br />
C002D5556<br />
Adeosun, Emefiele join economic experts to<br />
discuss global issues at IMF/World Bank meeting<br />
Minister of finance,<br />
Kemi<br />
Adeosun, and<br />
Central Bank of<br />
Nigeria (CBN) governor, Godwin<br />
Emefiele, left Nigeria for<br />
Washington DC on Sunday to<br />
join other economic experts<br />
from around the world to discuss<br />
issues affecting global<br />
economy. Discussions would<br />
take place under the auspices<br />
of the World Bank Group and<br />
the International Monetary<br />
Fund (IMF).<br />
The Spring Meetings of the<br />
IMF and the World Bank will<br />
bring together central bankers,<br />
ministers of finance and<br />
development, parliamentarians,<br />
private sector executives,<br />
representatives from civil society<br />
organisations and the<br />
academia.<br />
The experts will discuss<br />
issues of global concern, including<br />
the world economic<br />
outlook, poverty eradication,<br />
economic development and<br />
aid effectiveness.<br />
There will also be seminars,<br />
regional briefings, press<br />
conferences and many other<br />
events with focus on global<br />
economy, international development<br />
and the world’s<br />
financial system. The meetings<br />
will hold between <strong>Apr</strong>il<br />
<strong>16</strong> and <strong>Apr</strong>il 22, <strong>2018</strong>.<br />
Nigeria attends the meet-<br />
ing each year because of the<br />
quantum of investments and<br />
assistance it receives from<br />
both the IMF and the World<br />
Bank.<br />
Although Nigeria currently<br />
has zero loans with the IMF,<br />
it enjoys technical support<br />
from the organisation.<br />
The World Bank Group on<br />
the other hand is helping to<br />
fight poverty and improve living<br />
standards in the country<br />
through 33 Core Knowledge<br />
Product Reports and 29 ongoing<br />
National and Regional<br />
projects. This is in addition to<br />
about 60 Trust Funds.<br />
The World Bank Group<br />
since 1958 supported Nigeria<br />
with loans and International<br />
Development Association<br />
(IDA) credits worth about<br />
$14.2 billion.<br />
The group in 2017 fiscal<br />
year alone committed $1.51<br />
billion to the country, and so<br />
far in <strong>2018</strong>, it already spent<br />
$486 million on different development<br />
projects across the<br />
country. Some of the projects<br />
include Electricity Transmission<br />
Project, Agro-Processing,<br />
Productivity Enhancement<br />
and Livelihood Improvement<br />
Support Project, Polio<br />
Eradication Support Project<br />
and Housing Finance Development<br />
Programme, among<br />
Capital market plan to top discussions as<br />
SEC holds first CMC meeting for <strong>2018</strong><br />
ONYINYE NWACHUKWU, Abuja<br />
Progress made so<br />
far on the capital<br />
market master<br />
plan implementation<br />
and other<br />
market initiatives will top<br />
discussions as the Securities<br />
and Exchange Commission<br />
(SEC) holds its first<br />
Capital Market Committee<br />
(CMC) meeting for <strong>2018</strong>.<br />
The meeting is scheduled<br />
to hold in Lagos from<br />
<strong>Apr</strong>il 19 to 20.<br />
The ten-year plan for the<br />
Nigerian capital market,<br />
which is expected to help<br />
refocus and double the<br />
market size as well as grow<br />
the economy, was unveiled<br />
November 2014.<br />
The Commission has so<br />
far implemented some initiatives<br />
in the Master Plan<br />
with the aim of attracting<br />
more investors to the market.<br />
Some of the initiatives<br />
include direct cash settlement,<br />
dematerialisation<br />
and e-Dividend Registration,<br />
as they promote<br />
transparency, protect and<br />
enhance investors’ confidence<br />
in the capital market.<br />
Mary Uduk, who was<br />
appointed last Friday by<br />
minister of finance, Kemi<br />
Adeosun, to take over as<br />
SEC’s acting director-general,<br />
is expected to chair<br />
the meeting.<br />
Uduk took over from<br />
Abdul Zubair, who Adeosun<br />
redeployed to external<br />
relations department of the<br />
SEC.<br />
Those who have been<br />
invited to attend the expanded<br />
session are chief<br />
executive officers (CEOs)<br />
of all registered capital<br />
market firms, including<br />
Broker Dealer, Capital Market<br />
Solicitors, Custodians,<br />
Fund Managers, Issuing<br />
Houses, Rating Agencies,<br />
Registrars, Reporting Accountants,<br />
Trustees, and<br />
Consultants, etc.<br />
Others are CEOs of the<br />
Nigerian Stock Exchange<br />
(NSE), National Association<br />
of Securities Dealers<br />
(NASD), The Financial<br />
Markets Dealers Quotations<br />
(FMDQ), Africa Exchange<br />
Holdings (AFEX),<br />
Nigeria Commodity Exchange<br />
(NCX), Central Securities<br />
Clearing System<br />
(CSCS), Chartered Institute<br />
of Stockbrokers (CIS); as<br />
well as representatives of<br />
relevant Financial Services’<br />
Agencies, among others.<br />
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
Kenya Airways sacks 86% of<br />
its Nigerian employees<br />
... unions to picket airline operations<br />
IFEOMA OKEKE<br />
East African carrier,<br />
Kenya Airways,<br />
weekend, sacked 22<br />
out of its 26 Nigerian<br />
employees, representing<br />
86.4 percent of the affected<br />
workers.<br />
A source close to the airline<br />
told <strong>BusinessDay</strong> that<br />
the staff members were issued<br />
the disengagement<br />
letters at the airline’s office<br />
in Lagos, in the presence<br />
of stern looking police officers<br />
that were engaged by<br />
the airline to scare away the<br />
affected staff and prevent<br />
possible breakdown of law<br />
and order.<br />
Only four of its Nigerian<br />
staff members are retained<br />
by the management of the<br />
airline after the purging<br />
exercise. Those retained<br />
are Afeez Balogun, country<br />
manager, the station manager,<br />
and two other staff.<br />
The source disclosed that<br />
the affected workers were<br />
only given four weeks wages<br />
on disengagement, a situation<br />
the industry unions are<br />
already frowning at.<br />
It was gathered that the<br />
abrupt sack of the Nigerian<br />
workers happened when<br />
the airline was still negoti-<br />
ating the new condition of<br />
service with the industry<br />
unions.<br />
The source said the carrier’s<br />
management took the<br />
decision without taking into<br />
consideration the Nigerian<br />
Labour Laws, which kick<br />
against unilateral decision<br />
by employers when disengaging<br />
workers.<br />
It was learnt that plans<br />
had also reached an advanced<br />
stage by the management<br />
of the airline to<br />
replace the sacked workers<br />
with casuals, as it had already<br />
contracted engagement<br />
of new workers to a<br />
general sales agent in the<br />
country.<br />
However, there are indications<br />
that the sack of<br />
the workers may cause disruption<br />
to the smooth operations<br />
of the airline today<br />
(Monday), as the unions<br />
have prepared to picket the<br />
operations of the airline.<br />
Olayinka Abioye, general<br />
secretary, National Union<br />
of Air Transport Employees<br />
(NUATE), confirmed the<br />
sack of the 22 workers, saying<br />
however that the unilateral<br />
sack of the workers<br />
by the airline would not be<br />
allowed to stand by the industry<br />
unions.
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
BUSINESS DAY<br />
A13
A14<br />
NEWS<br />
BUSINESS DAY<br />
C002D5556<br />
‘Only Nigerians with creative, innovative<br />
mindset can push frontier of growth’<br />
KELECHI EWUZIE<br />
ships between buyers and<br />
sellers.” Like a typical MBA<br />
curriculum, The Chairman’s<br />
Empire is designed to teach<br />
business tactics and strategic<br />
thinking and the fundamentals<br />
of maintaining a healthy<br />
cash flow in order to avoid<br />
bankruptcy.<br />
“The game is designed<br />
to act as a guide on how to<br />
invest big to reap big and become<br />
the chairman of a vast<br />
business/economic empire,<br />
and inspire and contribute<br />
to your world through engagement<br />
in corporate social<br />
responsibility projects, etc,”<br />
she said. The game set up is<br />
structured like a typical business<br />
with players/investors<br />
why ply different sectors of<br />
the economy. It also has a<br />
central bank or the banks<br />
from which players obtain<br />
loans/credit for investment.<br />
The ‘investor’ must be<br />
careful to invest in sectors<br />
with low risk, but with potential<br />
for higher returns on<br />
investment.<br />
“The Chairman’s Empire<br />
was developed by HIIMA<br />
Edutainment, a Nigerian<br />
company and an arm of<br />
Distinct Integrated Services<br />
Limited, as an exciting business<br />
education game, which<br />
enables players catch up with<br />
the ever evolving business<br />
world.<br />
Zinox merges Konga,<br />
Yudala operations<br />
JUMOKE AKIYODE-LAWANSON<br />
Zinox Group has announced<br />
the merging<br />
of e-commerce<br />
operations between<br />
Konga and<br />
Yudala, as earlier predicted<br />
after Zinox acquired Konga,<br />
one of Nigeria’s largest online<br />
malls a few months ago.<br />
The merger, which takes<br />
effect from May 1, will see<br />
both companies operate on<br />
the ‘Konga’ brand name and<br />
is likely to give the company<br />
a stronger hold on Nigeria’s e-<br />
commerce market.<br />
In a statement, Zinox says<br />
the decision will see both<br />
Yudala and Konga leverage<br />
the combined strengths of<br />
both platforms, which is expected<br />
to further broaden<br />
the scope of organised retail<br />
and e-commerce in Nigeria<br />
and deliver more value to<br />
customers and merchants.<br />
“Combining forces to<br />
power the new Konga will<br />
enable us effectively achieve<br />
our goals of platform expansion<br />
and accelerated growth,<br />
as we embark on an ambitious<br />
journey to redefine the<br />
retail ecosystem with the<br />
industry’s most advanced<br />
technology,” Olusiji Ijogun,<br />
the newly appointed chairman<br />
of Konga, said.<br />
“Effective from May 1, Yudala<br />
will now operate under<br />
the name Konga, with dual<br />
CEOs in the persons of Nick<br />
Imudia who will be in charge<br />
of online among others and<br />
Prince Nnamdi Ekeh who will<br />
be responsible for offline. This<br />
merger will further strengthen<br />
our position in the Nigerian<br />
retail market as we creatively<br />
position Konga as the first<br />
profitable e-commerce company<br />
in Africa.<br />
“The efficiency of Konga’s<br />
cutting-edge online platform,<br />
access to thousands of merchants<br />
and Yudala’s expansive<br />
network of fully stocked<br />
offline stores is poised to give<br />
our customers the best shopping<br />
experience imaginable.<br />
We will be working closely<br />
with all our combined clients,<br />
customers, merchants<br />
and employees to make the<br />
integration process as seamless<br />
as possible and thereafter<br />
make public our road map to<br />
sustain our leadership on the<br />
continent,” Ijogun said.<br />
One of the exciting benefits<br />
of this merger is the possibility<br />
it offers prospective<br />
shoppers to order online, pay<br />
and pick-up the product(s)<br />
at the nearest Konga offline<br />
store. There are also increasing<br />
business opportunities for<br />
merchants nationwide.<br />
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
Medview explains rationalisation of<br />
staff, denies debt to service providers<br />
IFEOMA OKEKE<br />
Industry experts in the<br />
business and education<br />
sectors have warned that<br />
in the coming decade,<br />
the only assurance for Nigerians<br />
to remain relevant and<br />
push the frontier of growth is<br />
to be creative and innovative<br />
in their decision making.<br />
Ima Mariam Agunbiade-<br />
Etiebet, chief executive of<br />
Distinct Integrated Services<br />
Limited, said it was important<br />
that Nigerians learn financial<br />
discipline, planning and<br />
management as this would<br />
help them develop entrepreneurial,<br />
creative and innovative<br />
mindset to see possibilities<br />
and opportunities.<br />
Agunbiade-Etiebet stated<br />
this at the unveiling of the<br />
Chairman’s Empire, an innovative<br />
board game in Lagos.<br />
The Chairman’s Empire<br />
is a thrilling board game<br />
that can be played by two or<br />
more people, and takes players<br />
through the nitty-gritty of<br />
modern business practice. It<br />
is designed to be enjoyed by<br />
both adults and children of<br />
seven years old and above.<br />
According to Agunbiade-<br />
Etiebet, “The Chairman’s<br />
Empire, among other things,<br />
helps the players understand<br />
the dynamics of doing business,<br />
including the relation-<br />
Managing director<br />
of<br />
Medview Airlines,<br />
Muneer<br />
Bankole, says the airline<br />
had to undergo rationalisation<br />
of 52 staff members,<br />
both professional and administrative<br />
wise, as part of<br />
efforts to re-align its operations.<br />
Furthermore, Bankole<br />
says the airline is not indebted<br />
to any of its international<br />
service providers.<br />
Speaking at a press conference,<br />
weekend, Bankole<br />
said the airline had paid<br />
January salaries and had<br />
paid up 60 percent of staff<br />
in February, and was not indebted<br />
as those rationalised<br />
had to undergo the company’s<br />
processes but would be<br />
paid soon.<br />
According to Bankole,<br />
“Today, I will tell you that<br />
Medview is carrying out<br />
staff rationalisation and<br />
that is normal in any business.<br />
We came back in January<br />
and we announced to<br />
staff that we had to carry<br />
out this exercise. In January,<br />
we didn’t owe anyone and<br />
in February we had paid 60<br />
percent of our colleagues,<br />
including our pilots, but<br />
those that were laid off were<br />
52 and we are still doing it.<br />
“We had to rationalise<br />
their salaries because they<br />
have to meet the processes<br />
and procedures of disengagement,<br />
because when<br />
we give them letters, they<br />
have to go through Human<br />
Resources, return their<br />
Identification card and we<br />
check their books to see if<br />
they are not on loan and<br />
then they are paid their final<br />
packages.<br />
“In January, we had paid<br />
all and paid 60% in February<br />
and we are doing the<br />
exercise simultaneously. It<br />
affects captains, engineers,<br />
handlers and it affects those<br />
who have cases and those<br />
indicted for disciplinary of<br />
fences are equally affected.”<br />
On alleged debts to service<br />
providers, he said if<br />
they were owing any of their<br />
foreign service providers,<br />
the airline would not last six<br />
months.<br />
The airline, according to<br />
Bankole, is also realigning<br />
its operations to ensure its<br />
long-term sustainability by<br />
strengthening its domestic<br />
operations.<br />
“The 777 is undergoing<br />
C-Check and will be back<br />
by May but this affected<br />
our scheduled operations.<br />
When you have two aircraft<br />
outside, you restructure<br />
your operations and plan<br />
your schedule.
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
NEWS<br />
L - R: Ivy Ojigbede,<br />
group retail<br />
sales manager,<br />
Investment One<br />
Financial Services;<br />
Oluyori Ezekiel,<br />
managing director,<br />
Investment One<br />
Stockbrokers<br />
International<br />
Limited, and<br />
Oluchi Amorha,<br />
communications<br />
officer, Investment<br />
One Financial<br />
Services, after<br />
the launch of the<br />
company’s All Stars<br />
League initiative<br />
in Lagos, at the<br />
weekend<br />
C002D5556<br />
BUSINESS DAY<br />
A15<br />
fivethings<br />
for your new week<br />
Fascinating business facts<br />
35<br />
Zimbabwe is to sell shares in 35 state-owned firms,<br />
including telecoms and mining entities in the latest<br />
step to revive the economy under new political<br />
leadership, Finance Minister Patrick Chinamasa said on<br />
Friday. Targeted firms include mobile carriers NetOne<br />
and Telecel, fixed line operator TelOne and savings<br />
bank POSB, all owned by the state. Shares in 17<br />
government-run mines would also be sold. Like most<br />
parastatals, the mines, which mainly produce gold,<br />
have struggled over the years due to lack of capital<br />
and mismanagement, forcing some to close.<br />
Stakeholders pick holes in FG’s<br />
attempt to sell Yola Disco, Afam plant<br />
OLUSOLA BELLO<br />
Stakeholders in the<br />
power sector say it<br />
is improper for the<br />
Federal Government<br />
to put Yola<br />
Electric Distribution Company<br />
up for sale, given that<br />
it is performing better than<br />
most of the other Discos<br />
that are privatised.<br />
They wonder if the real<br />
value of the Disco would<br />
be realised if it is sold now<br />
in view of the fact that the<br />
circumstances that made<br />
the core investor to return<br />
it to the government, which<br />
was insecurity, is still very<br />
much prevalent.<br />
They also frown at the<br />
situation in which the government<br />
is yet to refund the<br />
core investors, Integrated<br />
Energy and Distribution<br />
Marketing Company<br />
(IEDM), the $80.5 million<br />
that was the value negotiated<br />
after the return of the<br />
company, and is putting it<br />
put for sale.<br />
A former managing director<br />
of Ikeja Electric said:<br />
“It is crazy to want to sell<br />
Yola Disco now considering<br />
the performance of the<br />
sold ones. Presently Yola<br />
is performing better than<br />
most Discos despite the<br />
fact that it is still being run<br />
by civil servants. If the government<br />
had given the old<br />
management a third of the<br />
over N1 trillion intervention<br />
fund it has pumped<br />
into the system since privatisation<br />
could country<br />
would have been singing a<br />
different song.”<br />
Another executive director<br />
of one of the Discos<br />
queried the rationale<br />
behind the government<br />
selling the asset while still<br />
owing the former core investors,<br />
and described the<br />
action of the government<br />
capable of causing disincentive<br />
to other investors.<br />
“Whoever wants to buy<br />
the asset must be seeing<br />
what others are not seeing.<br />
I only hope that they do<br />
proper due diligent before<br />
throwing themselves into<br />
it,” he said.<br />
According to some others<br />
that spoke with <strong>BusinessDay</strong>,<br />
the Boko Haram<br />
insurgency is big challenge<br />
to any investor, as it seems<br />
intensified, even though the<br />
government claimed that<br />
the group has been technically<br />
defeated. They also<br />
cited the problems of the<br />
Fulani herdsmen, another<br />
major factor threatening investments<br />
in that region.<br />
The Fulani’s herdsmen<br />
problem has led to displacement<br />
of a number of<br />
people in Taraba and Adamawa<br />
states, which were<br />
considered as relatively<br />
peaceful before now. They<br />
said it would be difficult for<br />
any investor to want stake<br />
his money on the company,<br />
given the level of uncertainty<br />
prevailing in the<br />
areas covered by the distribution<br />
company.<br />
Efforts to get the reaction<br />
Bureau of Public Enterprise<br />
(BPE) on the views<br />
expressed by stakeholders,<br />
especially on why the refund<br />
of N80.5 million the<br />
former core investor is being<br />
delayed, was not successful.<br />
40<br />
National Microfinance Bank (NMB), Tanzania’s biggest<br />
bank by market capitalisation, is ready to participate<br />
in a needed consolidation of Tanzania’s fragmented<br />
banking sector, its chief executive said. Tanzania’s<br />
banking sector, hit by bad loans and low lending,<br />
would be healthier if smaller banks were taken over<br />
by larger ones, Ineke Bussemaker told Reuters. The<br />
East African nation has about 40 licensed banks, but<br />
the sector is dominated by a handful of big lenders.<br />
Netherlands-based Rabobank Group is NMB’s biggest<br />
shareholder with a 34.9 percent stake, while the<br />
Tanzanian government owns 31.9 percent.<br />
$3.5bn<br />
Kenya’s second-biggest infrastructure project since<br />
independence five decades ago, a $3.5 billion inter-city<br />
expressway, will be delayed amid concerns by lawmakers<br />
that East Africa’s largest economy is taking on too<br />
much debt, the company building it said. The nation’s<br />
debt could rise to 58 percent of gross domestic product<br />
by the end of June, from 40.6 percent in the 2011-12 fiscal<br />
year, according to World Bank estimates.<br />
$100m<br />
Russian IT services company IBS has postponed its<br />
planned initial public offering due to the Moscow market<br />
volatility caused by imposition of fresh US sanctions<br />
against the country. IBS said last week it would launch<br />
a flotation on the Moscow exchange and was said to be<br />
raising $100m by selling 30-35 per cent of its enlarged<br />
capital. Two days after that announcement, Washington<br />
said it was placing sanctions on seven Russian<br />
oligarchs, 12 of their companies and 17 Russia officials,<br />
leading to a run on the rouble and the largest daily fall<br />
in the Moscow stock market since 2014.<br />
$71.50<br />
With oil at above $71 a barrel, OPEC is beginning to<br />
reformulate its target in terms of upstream investment<br />
rather than oil inventories, according to an<br />
analysis of recent statements made by ministers<br />
from member countries. “There is no such thing as a<br />
target price by Saudi Arabia,” the kingdom’s energy<br />
minister, Khalid al-Falih, told reporters on Wednesday<br />
(“Saudi Arabia happy with oil market, won’t let<br />
another glut form”, Reuters
A<strong>16</strong><br />
NEWS<br />
Coronation Merchant Bank records<br />
66% growth in gross earnings<br />
HOPE MOSES-ASHIKE<br />
We will not betray your confidence<br />
in us, Buhari tells Nigerians<br />
TONY AILEMEN, Abuja<br />
BUSINESS DAY<br />
C002D5556<br />
In spite of the tough operating<br />
environment<br />
witnessed in the financial<br />
market in 2017,<br />
Coronation Merchant Bank<br />
Group recorded 66 percent<br />
increase in gross earnings to<br />
N25.5 billion in full year 2017<br />
financial result, as against<br />
N15.2 billion recorded in the<br />
previous year.<br />
Aside the strong earnings<br />
performance, the Group recorded<br />
a significant growth<br />
in its balance sheet in 2017.<br />
Total assets increased by<br />
28 percent to N136.7 billion<br />
from N106.6 billion in<br />
December 20<strong>16</strong>, and shareholder’s<br />
funds increased to<br />
N29.5 billion from N25.9 billion<br />
- a valid testament to the<br />
resilience of the Group’s operations<br />
and its adaptability<br />
to current market realities<br />
and challenges.<br />
“The impressive results<br />
of the bank in the last three<br />
years demonstrate the effectiveness<br />
of our strategy, the<br />
quality of our past decisions<br />
and the commitment of our<br />
board and management to<br />
maximise shareholder value<br />
whilst actively expanding<br />
our franchise in select, high<br />
growth markets where we<br />
believe we have a competitive<br />
advantage,” Abu Jimoh,<br />
CEO of the bank, said.<br />
The bank’s interest income<br />
growth of 67 percent<br />
year/year and non-interest<br />
income growth of 57 percent<br />
in 2017 reaffirm the sustain-<br />
President Muhammadu<br />
Buhari has assured<br />
Nigerians living<br />
in the United Kingdom<br />
(UK) that his administration<br />
will work to justify<br />
Nigerian’s confidence in his<br />
administration.<br />
The President speaking in<br />
London on Sunday while receiving<br />
the Buhari Diaspora<br />
Support Organisation, led by<br />
Efe Sylvester, assured, “We<br />
will do our best to justify your<br />
trust in us, and that confidence<br />
won’t be abused.”<br />
A statement by special<br />
adviser to the President on<br />
media and publicity, Femi<br />
Adesina, said the President<br />
expressed happiness that the<br />
country had people who were<br />
ready to defend her.<br />
“You have shown courage<br />
and sacrifice. I assure you that<br />
your confidence in us won’t<br />
be abused, we will do our best<br />
to justify it,” he said.<br />
The group, a new force<br />
set up to counter the activities<br />
of other Nigerians who<br />
had been engaging in protest<br />
against the President at the<br />
Nigeria House in London,<br />
had expressed their confidence<br />
in the current administration’s<br />
efforts to rebuild the<br />
country.<br />
ability of its core business<br />
growth. “We will continue<br />
to gain momentum in our<br />
efforts to achieve more diversified<br />
earnings, as we<br />
strengthen our subsidiaries<br />
offerings,” Jimoh said at the<br />
annual general meeting held<br />
at the weekend in Lagos.<br />
Despite the high inflation<br />
rate, cost-to-income ratio<br />
increased marginally by 90<br />
basis points to 46.1 percent<br />
compared to 45.2 percent in<br />
December 20<strong>16</strong>, reaffirming<br />
the bank’s commitment to<br />
rein in costs while improving<br />
operating efficiency.<br />
“We remain committed<br />
to providing our clients with<br />
superior financial services<br />
whilst generating attractive<br />
and sustainable returns for<br />
shareholders.”<br />
The bank recorded<br />
growth in loan book by 42<br />
percent to N32.3 billion in<br />
2017 from N22.7 billion in<br />
20<strong>16</strong>.<br />
“While general economic<br />
conditions and the regulatory<br />
environment remain<br />
tight, we believe that our<br />
new business and lending<br />
strategies, embedded risk<br />
management culture and<br />
continuous cost savings<br />
will enable us stand firm<br />
throughout this period”.<br />
“In the coming years, we<br />
will focus on the disciplined<br />
implementation of our<br />
growth strategy to drive efficiency<br />
in all segments of our<br />
business leveraging fintech<br />
and process re-engineering,”<br />
Jimoh said.<br />
The President, who noted<br />
that Nigeria was gifted with<br />
tremendous human and natural<br />
resources, however, regretted<br />
that “failure of some of<br />
the leadership we had in the<br />
past led to our not being able<br />
to capitalise on resources to<br />
improve the lot of the people.”<br />
For him, “wicked people<br />
plundered the country, and<br />
kept Nigerians poor. Looking<br />
at the condition in which the<br />
current administration met the<br />
country, without savings and<br />
the economy badly vandalised,<br />
“we have not done too badly.”<br />
He reiterated that the<br />
damage done to the Nigerian<br />
economy in the years of plunder<br />
was massive, and that government<br />
was doing its best to<br />
recover some of the loot, but<br />
noted that it was impossible<br />
to identify and recover all.<br />
“If they had used 50% of<br />
the money we made, when<br />
oil prices went as high as<br />
$143 dollars per barrel, and<br />
stabilized at $100 dollars<br />
with production at 2.1 million<br />
barrels per day for many<br />
years, Nigerians would have<br />
minded their businesses. You<br />
could almost grow food on<br />
our roads, as they were abandoned.<br />
The stealing was so<br />
much, and they were so inept<br />
that they could not even cover<br />
the stealing properly.”<br />
Emefiele says AGSMEIS funds<br />
to reach N60bn by June<br />
… 358 entrepreneurs benefit as CBN, Bankers’ Committee commence disbursement<br />
HOPE MOSES-ASHIKE & ONYINYE NWACHUKWU<br />
Funds pooled by the<br />
commercial lenders<br />
under the Agribusiness/Small<br />
and<br />
Medium Enterprises<br />
Investment Scheme (AGS-<br />
MEIS) is already in excess of<br />
N26 billion, and is expected<br />
to exceed N60 billion by June<br />
<strong>2018</strong>, CBN governor, Godwin<br />
Emefiele, said as disbursements<br />
of the funds began in<br />
Abuja, last week.<br />
The flag off saw the disbursement<br />
of about N118<br />
million to 358 beneficiaries<br />
under the scheme that seeks<br />
to reasonably cut the present<br />
high unemployment rates in<br />
the country.<br />
The beneficiaries are<br />
youths who have been<br />
trained on various entrepreneurship,<br />
vocational and<br />
management skills across the<br />
country by Entrepreneurship<br />
Development Institutions<br />
Paga celebrates<br />
9th year<br />
anniversary<br />
Paga is celebrating<br />
its ninth anniversary<br />
as Nigeria’s first<br />
and leading mobile<br />
money company. Founded<br />
by CEO, Tayo Oviosu in<br />
<strong>Apr</strong>il 2009, Paga has provided<br />
easy means for simple<br />
mobile money transfers,<br />
bill payments and<br />
provision of financial services<br />
to over 8 million users<br />
on their platform through<br />
the years.<br />
Since 2009, Paga has<br />
created meaningful financial<br />
technology that has led<br />
the drive for financial inclusion<br />
which aims to bank<br />
over 70 million unbanked<br />
and underbanked Nigerians<br />
leveraging its web<br />
channels, mobile apps and<br />
short code (*242#).<br />
Paga has pioneered the<br />
mobile money industry<br />
objective by creating what<br />
is recognized as the single<br />
largest shared active agent<br />
network in Nigeria with<br />
over 14,000 agents. These<br />
agent outlets are widespread<br />
across the 36 states<br />
in Nigeria and they enable<br />
millions of Nigerians<br />
to perform simple money<br />
transfers and pay bills for<br />
life and business.<br />
Notable businesses and<br />
organizations like Dangote<br />
foundation, Ikeja Electric,<br />
Eko Distribution Company,<br />
JAMB, WAEC, UK<br />
Immigration among many<br />
more companies have leveraged<br />
the reach and impact<br />
of Paga to achieve payment<br />
collections and bulk<br />
disbursements.<br />
and Centres, such as Fate<br />
Foundation, Lagos Business<br />
School, House of Tara and<br />
Thrive Agric.<br />
The Bankers’ Committee<br />
had, at its meeting on February<br />
9, 2017, came up with<br />
the AGSMEIS to improve<br />
access to affordable financing<br />
for MSMEs, particularly<br />
those operating in the informal<br />
sector of the economy,<br />
and to support the Federal<br />
Government’s efforts and<br />
policy measures to promote<br />
sustainable economic development<br />
and employment<br />
generation.<br />
As a commitment to the<br />
successful implementation<br />
of the scheme, all deposit<br />
money banks, voluntarily<br />
agreed to set aside and<br />
contribute 5 percent of their<br />
profit after tax (PAT) annually<br />
to finance eligible projects<br />
under the scheme.<br />
Quoting data from the<br />
National Bureau of Statistics<br />
(NBS), Emefiele said the rate<br />
of unemployment in Nigeria<br />
worsened marginally during<br />
the third quarter of 2017, and<br />
that this raised concerns and<br />
risks for the collective peace<br />
and progress across the nation.<br />
He noted that one of the<br />
most effective ways to tackle<br />
this scourge was through entrepreneurship<br />
development<br />
and easy access to affordable<br />
financing, which according<br />
to him, has been a huge challenge<br />
to entrepreneurship<br />
development in the country<br />
today.<br />
He regretted the financial<br />
intermediaries’ apathy to<br />
youth entrepreneurship and<br />
start-ups, which are usually<br />
perceived as being too risky,<br />
lacking relevant managerial<br />
skills and not possessing adequate<br />
collaterals acceptable<br />
for conventional credit.<br />
He said the situation<br />
therefore led the Bankers’<br />
Monday <strong>16</strong> <strong>Apr</strong>il <strong>2018</strong><br />
Committee Retreat, to design<br />
and fund a suitable scheme<br />
that will not only reduce the<br />
huge financing gap for Macro<br />
Small and Medium Enterprises<br />
(MSMEs), but also<br />
fully commits to the pursuits<br />
of job creation, financial inclusion<br />
and inclusive growth<br />
for Nigerians, particularly the<br />
teeming youth population.<br />
The AGSMEIS has been<br />
designed to be implemented<br />
in three broad components,<br />
namely Direct, Indirect and<br />
Developmental components.<br />
Under the Direct component<br />
of the AGSMEIS, beneficiaries<br />
can access loans to a<br />
limit of N10 million, at interest<br />
rate of 5 percent per annum<br />
and a maximum tenor<br />
of up to seven years. There is<br />
also a moratorium period of<br />
18 months on principal and<br />
six months on interest element,<br />
depending on the nature<br />
of the business.
BUSINESS DAY<br />
Opinion<br />
NEWS YOU CAN TRUST I MONDAY <strong>16</strong> APRIL <strong>2018</strong><br />
CHOGM <strong>2018</strong>: Nigeria, Commonwealth and the London summit<br />
C002D5556<br />
This week, from<br />
today Monday<br />
<strong>16</strong> to Friday 20<br />
<strong>Apr</strong>il, the 25th<br />
biennial summit<br />
of the Commonwealth,<br />
the Commonwealth Heads<br />
of Government Meeting<br />
(CHOGM), will take place<br />
in London. It is the first<br />
time the event is held in<br />
the UK since 1997. As a<br />
proud Londoner, with a<br />
longstanding relationship<br />
with the Commonwealth,<br />
I cannot but comment on<br />
thehistoric event, even<br />
more so because of the<br />
importance of this week’s<br />
summitandthe role that<br />
Nigeria should play in it.<br />
But before we get into all<br />
that, let’s remind ourselves<br />
of Nigeria’srelationship<br />
with the Commonwealth.<br />
Nigeria joined the<br />
Commonwealth at independence<br />
in 1960. For<br />
most part, since that time,<br />
we have been an enthusiastic<br />
member of the organisation.<br />
We produced<br />
its third Secretary-General,<br />
since the office was<br />
established in 1965, in the<br />
person of the globally respected<br />
elder statesman,<br />
Chief Emeka Anyaoku,<br />
who led the organisation<br />
for ten years, from 1990<br />
to 2000. On any visit to<br />
the Commonwealth Secretariat,<br />
I never cease to<br />
admire Chief Anyaoku’s<br />
larger than life portrait in<br />
his traditional Nigerian<br />
attire. He was an iconic<br />
and highly successful secretary<br />
general!<br />
I attended my first<br />
CHOGM in Abuja in December<br />
2003. I had been<br />
asked by the Commonwealth<br />
Business Council<br />
to be the rapporteur for<br />
the Business Forum during<br />
the summit. With both<br />
the Hilton and Sheraton<br />
hotels cordoned off to<br />
accommodate the guests,<br />
including the Queen and<br />
her entourage, and with<br />
several colourful social<br />
and cultural activities,<br />
it was a very memorable<br />
event for many of the foreign<br />
visitors.<br />
Of course, Nigeria will<br />
always pull out all the<br />
stops to organise spectacular<br />
events to impress<br />
GLOBAL PERSPECTIVES<br />
OLU FASAN<br />
Dr Fasan, a London-based lawyer and<br />
political economist, is a Visiting Fellow at<br />
the London School of Economics. email:<br />
o.fasan@lse.ac.uk,<br />
He tweets @olu_fasan<br />
Anyaoku<br />
foreigners. Sadly, it lacks<br />
the ability and/or the willingness<br />
to organise its<br />
own affairs. For instance,<br />
despite its enthusiasm for<br />
the Commonwealth, Nigeria<br />
falls far short of meeting<br />
its goals. Of the three<br />
Commonwealth goals –<br />
development, democracy<br />
and peace – Nigeria is<br />
certainly nowhere near<br />
attaining at least two, development<br />
and peace, not<br />
with widespread poverty,<br />
inequality, political tension<br />
and insecurity in the<br />
country.<br />
However, its internal<br />
deficiencies notwithstanding,<br />
Nigeria has always<br />
been an active member<br />
of the Commonwealth.<br />
The only exception was<br />
during the Abacha dictatorship<br />
when, following<br />
the execution of Ken<br />
Saro-Wiwa, Nigeria was<br />
ejected from the organisation<br />
in 1995. This was<br />
particularly embarrassing<br />
because, at that time, a<br />
Nigerian, Chief Anyaoku,<br />
was secretary-general of<br />
the Commonwealth. Abacha<br />
turned a deaf ear to<br />
Anyaoku’s entreaties, rejected<br />
Mandela’s pleas,<br />
and killed Saro-Wiwa.<br />
Nigeria crossed the Rubicon,<br />
its behaviour was<br />
beyond the pale, and had<br />
to be sent out of the Commonwealth.<br />
But no member wants<br />
to be ostracised from the<br />
Commonwealth for too<br />
long. Every member suspended<br />
from the organisation<br />
always applied to<br />
be readmitted when the<br />
time became auspicious,<br />
as Nigeria did in 1999 after<br />
returning to democracy,<br />
and as The Gambia and<br />
Zimbabwe are currently<br />
doing after Yahya Jammeh<br />
and Robert Mugabe were<br />
replaced by more civilised<br />
leaders.<br />
So, why is the Commonwealth<br />
that important?<br />
Well, I would say there<br />
are two main reasons. The<br />
first is its functional value.<br />
The Commonwealth, a<br />
club of mostly former British<br />
colonies, is the only<br />
plurilateral organisation<br />
in the world whose membership<br />
spans the globe.<br />
Its 53 member-countries<br />
spread across Africa, Asia,<br />
the Caribbean, the Americas,<br />
Europe and the Pacific.<br />
It is also the only<br />
monwealth Charter,<br />
agreed on 14 December<br />
2012, sets out <strong>16</strong> core<br />
principles to which all<br />
members are committed.<br />
These range from democracy,<br />
human rights and<br />
peace and security to rule<br />
of law, good governance,<br />
gender equality as well as<br />
health, education, food<br />
and shelter. Of course, as<br />
Nigeria shows, not every<br />
Commonwealth member<br />
adheres to all these<br />
principles, or fully to any.<br />
However, the principles<br />
are benchmarks against<br />
which the behaviour of<br />
Indeed, can the trade minister, Okechukwu<br />
Enelamah, freely engage in<br />
such bilateral trade talks when President<br />
Buhari can easily overrule him<br />
(a la AfCFTA!)? What’s more, would<br />
Nigeria embrace a more economic<br />
Commonwealth with greater push for<br />
a commitment to free trade? Or would<br />
it be one the refuseniks? The latter, of<br />
course, is more likely, which reflects<br />
the regressive state of policy-making in<br />
Nigeria.<br />
such organisation with<br />
membership encompassing<br />
developed, developing,<br />
small and vulnerable<br />
states. These global<br />
reach and diversity enable<br />
the Commonwealth to<br />
leverage support for its<br />
members and their citizens<br />
through institutional<br />
development, capacity<br />
building, technical cooperation<br />
and professional<br />
development.<br />
Then, there is the normative<br />
value. The Com-<br />
every member-country<br />
can be measured, and<br />
therefore serve as a powerful<br />
source of normative<br />
pressure.<br />
For instance, all eyes<br />
will be on Nigeria next<br />
year as it holds its general<br />
elections. It will be<br />
expected to conduct<br />
the elections in an environment<br />
“where there<br />
is confidence, transparency<br />
and accountability<br />
in the electoral process,<br />
and where voters are free<br />
to exercise an informed<br />
choice between alternative<br />
candidates for office”.<br />
Following the success of<br />
the 2015 elections, Nigeria<br />
would be expected to<br />
strengthen its democracy<br />
and enhance the credibility<br />
of its electoral process<br />
by conducting free, fair<br />
and peaceful elections.<br />
Commonwealth election<br />
observers would, of<br />
course, be on the ground<br />
to see if Nigeria passes the<br />
electoral test. It is a test<br />
that Nigeria must not fail!<br />
So, the Commonwealth<br />
is a relevant organisation<br />
that provides valuable<br />
public good. But it<br />
is now facing pressure<br />
to do more, to become<br />
somewhat an economic<br />
bloc! Which brings me<br />
to why this week’s London<br />
summit is important.<br />
The summit,which comes<br />
just a year before Britain<br />
leaves the EU (Brexit), will<br />
have a significant impact<br />
on the future of the Commonwealth.<br />
It is not surprising<br />
that the theme of<br />
the CHOGM <strong>2018</strong> is “Towards<br />
a common future”.<br />
Simply put, the Commonwealth<br />
will be different<br />
post-Brexit. This is because<br />
the UK is very keen<br />
to secure trade deals with<br />
as many Commonwealth<br />
countries as possible, with<br />
Nigeria among its priority<br />
countries. In fact, British<br />
officials had hoped that<br />
trade talks would form a<br />
key part of the CHOGM<br />
agenda, but other Commonwealth<br />
members resisted<br />
turning the summit<br />
into a trade round. But the<br />
issue will still dominate<br />
discussions on the margins<br />
of the summit. As one<br />
British minister said, “We<br />
are hoping that through<br />
the bilateral discussion<br />
that will take place there<br />
would be huge opportunities<br />
to advance trade talks”.<br />
Sadly, Nigeria is unlikely<br />
to engage constructively<br />
in such talks, given its<br />
reflex defensive attitude<br />
to trade issues. Indeed,<br />
can the trade minister,<br />
Okechukwu Enelamah,<br />
freely engage in such bilateral<br />
trade talks when<br />
President Buhari can<br />
easily overrule him (a la<br />
AfCFTA!)? What’s more,<br />
would Nigeria embrace a<br />
more economic Commonwealth<br />
with greater push<br />
for a commitment to free<br />
trade? Or would it be one<br />
the refuseniks? The latter,<br />
of course, is more likely,<br />
which reflects the regressive<br />
state of policy-making<br />
in Nigeria.<br />
Nevertheless, trade and<br />
investment issues, if not<br />
actual trade talks, will still<br />
dominate the CHOGM<br />
agenda, particularly its<br />
Business Forum, from<br />
<strong>16</strong> to 18 <strong>Apr</strong>il, where the<br />
discussion will focus on,<br />
among others, advancing<br />
intra-Commonwealth<br />
trade and strengthening<br />
the “Commonwealth advantage”.<br />
In 2015, the Commonwealth<br />
Secretariat invited<br />
me to join a panel of experts<br />
to review its flagship<br />
trade publication, “The<br />
Commonwealth in the<br />
Unfolding Global Trade<br />
Landscape”. The study<br />
showed that there is a<br />
“Commonwealth Advantage”,<br />
which helps to increase<br />
trade by 20%, and<br />
reduce the cost of doing<br />
business by up to 19%,<br />
between Commonwealth<br />
countries than between<br />
them and non-Commonwealth<br />
countries. These<br />
findings will shape discussions<br />
at the Commonwealth<br />
Business Forum.<br />
But the CHOGM will<br />
not all be about business<br />
talks. One subject that<br />
might also be broached<br />
is the next head of the<br />
Commonwealth after<br />
the Queen. Of course,<br />
the Queen is universally<br />
adored, so much so that,<br />
according to media reports,<br />
some Commonwealth<br />
high commissioners<br />
want to nominate her<br />
for the Nobel Peace Prize.<br />
But after her, who next?<br />
Obviously, the Queen’s<br />
successor to lead the<br />
organisation should be<br />
Prince Charles when he<br />
becomes king, but the role<br />
is not hereditary, and, in<br />
principle, nothing should<br />
be taken for granted!<br />
Yet, for me, the present<br />
informal arrangement<br />
whereby the symbolic<br />
head of the Commonwealth<br />
is the British<br />
monarch, who is also<br />
head of state of <strong>16</strong> Commonwealth<br />
countries,<br />
while the chief executive<br />
of the organisation, i.e.<br />
the secretary-general,<br />
is rotated among other<br />
Commonwealth members,<br />
currently held by<br />
Patricia Scotland from<br />
Dominica, seems to work<br />
perfectly well. Surely,<br />
when the time to take<br />
that decision comes,<br />
Nigeria should support<br />
Prince Charles for the<br />
role!<br />
So, this week’s CHOGM<br />
is an interesting one for<br />
the Commonwealth and<br />
all its well-wishers. I look<br />
forward to it, and hope<br />
Nigeria takes active part<br />
in deciding the organisation’s<br />
“common future”,<br />
including on economic<br />
cooperation.<br />
Published by BusinessDAY Media Ltd., The Brook, 6 Point Road, GRA, Apapa, Lagos. Ghana Office: Business Day Ghana Ltd; ABC Junction, near Guinness Ghana Limited, Achimota – Accra, Ghana.<br />
Tel: +233243226596: email: mail@businessdayonline.com Advert Hotline: 081<strong>16</strong>759801, 08082496194. Subscriptions 01-2950687, 07045792677. Newsroom: 08022238495<br />
Editor: Anthony Osae-Brown. All correspondence to BusinessDAY Media Ltd., Box 1002, Festac Lagos. ISSN 1595 - 8590.