The Weekly Times - TWT - 10th October 2018
The Weekly Times - TWT - is a campaigning, crusading, truth-seeking, death defying, Aussie battler-aligned, one-eyed-Tiger-led news organisation dedicated to Sydney's north west. This flip book - or digital edition/replica - is the 10th October 2018 edition of TWT. You can direct people to TWT's 10th October 2018 edition by using this shareable link: https://weeklytimes.com.au/the-weekly-times-twt-10th-october-2018/ And the most current edition of TWT is always reachable using this short address: bit.ly/OurTWT
The Weekly Times - TWT - is a campaigning, crusading, truth-seeking, death defying, Aussie battler-aligned, one-eyed-Tiger-led news organisation dedicated to Sydney's north west. This flip book - or digital edition/replica - is the 10th October 2018 edition of TWT.
You can direct people to TWT's 10th October 2018 edition by using this shareable link:
https://weeklytimes.com.au/the-weekly-times-twt-10th-october-2018/
And the most current edition of TWT is always reachable using this short address: bit.ly/OurTWT
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
PETCH VERDICT NEARS<br />
BY OUR COURT REPORTER<br />
A verdict is nearing in another farcical ICAC ‘blackmail’ court case with Ryde Emeritus<br />
Mayor Ivan Petch on trial in the NSW District Court for allegedly blackmailing Acting Ryde<br />
Council General Manager Danielle Dickson.<br />
<strong>The</strong> court has been told that Danielle Dickson used her key to<br />
access former Mayor Ivan Petch’s office, to “snoop” around<br />
with fellow council officer Roy Newsome, looking for incriminating<br />
documents for ICAC.<br />
Ivan Petch is on trial for allegedly blackmailing Danielle Dickson in<br />
May 2013, three months after Petch appointed her in the role of<br />
Ryde Council’s Acting GM.<br />
Court costs had been accrued in legal action initiated by Ryde<br />
Council against councillors, to restrain them from taking any action<br />
to terminate former GM John Neish in mid-2012.<br />
Mr Neish eventually left his role under a Deed of Release with Ryde<br />
Council, after he was found downloading porn on his laptop using<br />
council resources.<br />
His departure brought an end to legal proceedings, leaving the<br />
mat-ter of legal costs incurred by the affected councillors,<br />
outstanding.<br />
Despite expert legal advice from Bryan Belling of K&L Gates<br />
and Stefano Laface of AJL Legal, that council’s insurance policy<br />
with Zu-rich should be used to reimburse councillors, Ms Dickson -<br />
who had been delegated responsibility to resolve the matter - did<br />
not discon-tinue the ongoing Supreme Court matter.<br />
Mr Petch’s repeated efforts to have Ms Dickson reimburse councillors<br />
in accordance to what they were entitled to, are central to<br />
the “blackmail” allegation.<br />
Defence barrister Graham Turnbull SC has asked the jury to<br />
consid-er whether the pair›s four-minute discussion in the mayoral<br />
chamber was blackmail or «fatherly advice, about reimbursement».<br />
«<strong>The</strong>re is no way in the wide world this is a demand, that it›s<br />
an unwarranted demand, it›s made with menaces or that it was<br />
capable of affecting anybody›s capacity to do what they thought<br />
was right,» he said.<br />
THE VERDICT is expected very soon. Check <strong>TWT</strong> Online for a<br />
esult. Details next week in <strong>The</strong> <strong>Weekly</strong> <strong>Times</strong>.<br />
Mr Turnbull also argued that Ms Dickson “was well acquainted”<br />
ith the Independent Commission Against Corruption before her<br />
onversation with Petch and her subsequent contact with ICAC<br />
nvestigators.<br />
“Ms Dickson was in the habit of making notes, making notes almost<br />
s soon as things occurred,” he told the jury.<br />
“She was also, you may find.. in the habit of speaking with ICAC both<br />
efore this event and afterwards.”<br />
In her closing address on Monday, crown prosecutor Donna Daleo<br />
said the then-mayor made “a threat of something detrimental or unpleasant”<br />
to Ms Dickson.<br />
Hundreds of villages<br />
represented!<br />
As <strong>The</strong> <strong>Weekly</strong> <strong>Times</strong> was going to press this week, Mr Turnbull<br />
was due to complete his closing address. This was to be followed<br />
by Judge Nicole Noman’s summing up before the jury retired to<br />
consider a verdict.<br />
<strong>The</strong> present trial comes more than a year after John Goubran was<br />
cleared on blackmail charges and Mr Petch was consequently also<br />
cleared on accessory charges.<br />
Magistrate Beverley Schurr, in June 2017, had ruled ICAC’s centrepiece<br />
allegation, used to justify its Ryde investigation, fell short<br />
of the requisite standard of proof, with the prosecution case flawed<br />
with major inconsistencies.<br />
<strong>The</strong> supposed plot, according to ICAC, involved a threat to ex-Ryde<br />
Council GM John Neish’s job if the Civic Centre proposal was not<br />
delayed until after the September 2012 council elections.<br />
But Magistrate Schurr found a fatal flaw in the allegation was the<br />
inability to establish an offence under NSW law which amounted to<br />
influencing Neish’s exercise of public duty, as he did not have the<br />
necessary delegations.<br />
<strong>The</strong> prosecution case was already in disarray after much of its evidence<br />
was ruled inadmissible by Magistrate Beverley Schurr, following<br />
200 separate challenges to evidence by legal representatives for<br />
both Mr Goubran and Mr Petch, in <strong>October</strong> 2016.<br />
Counsel for Mr Goubran, Maurice Neil QC, at the time said “as little<br />
as five per cent” of one key witness’ evidence was admissible and<br />
the court had been “dumped with a massive amount of material held<br />
by a tribunal not bound by the rules of evidence. It shouldn’t happen.”<br />
We’ll have more in next week’s edition of <strong>The</strong> <strong>Weekly</strong> <strong>Times</strong>.<br />
MCC Board third attempt<br />
to change Constitution<br />
<strong>The</strong> current Constitution dates back<br />
to 2002 and warrants change. However,<br />
the “sticking point” which Board members<br />
have to live with, is a history of<br />
seven years of disgracefully unethical<br />
behaviour by CEOs and irresponsible<br />
directors.<br />
Fortunately for the College, there are<br />
enough members determined not to allow<br />
history to repeat itself.<br />
In March 2015 Chairman Sue Murray<br />
and newly appointed CEO <strong>The</strong>resa Collignon<br />
sought to change the Constitution<br />
to include proxy voting.<br />
Previously, the College was under<br />
ASIC which overruled the Constitution.<br />
However in 2014, the governing body<br />
was changed from ASIC to the ACNC<br />
which gave the Constitution full authority<br />
with no proxy voting.<br />
At the March 2015 EGM proxy voting<br />
was rejected outright because former<br />
CEO June Heinrich had previously<br />
By <strong>The</strong> <strong>Weekly</strong> <strong>Times</strong> Special Team of Investigative Reporters (<strong>TWT</strong> STIR Team)<br />
Members of Macquarie Community College have been invited to<br />
a third Extraordinary General Meeting to change the College Constitution<br />
in just over three years.<br />
used proxies to stack the membership<br />
with hundreds of new members who<br />
gave their proxy votes without question.<br />
This scam was made even worse<br />
when the following year Chairman<br />
Sue Murray resigned mid- term amid<br />
screams of discontent from members<br />
and re-elected herself for two years<br />
with eighty proxy votes she gave herself.<br />
At the AGM held in May this year another<br />
attempt was made to change the<br />
Constitution. On this occasion proxy<br />
voting was removed and instead, the<br />
Board composition was changed to allow<br />
for four appointees, another misuse<br />
of the Constitution to stack the Board,<br />
making governance a farce. That attempt<br />
to change the Constitution was<br />
rejected also.<br />
Now, members are being asked to<br />
vote for a third time to change the Con-<br />
Alex McAndrew Memorial at Epping<br />
<strong>The</strong> late Alex McAndrew will be honoured with the unveiling of a<br />
memorial at Loftus Park Square in Epping this Saturday <strong>October</strong> 13.<br />
All are invited for the ceremony between 10.30 am to 11.30am with<br />
morning tea to follow.<br />
Alex McAndrew was a highly regarded local resident, author and<br />
historian. His work included writing illustrated books depicting the<br />
history of various districts he had a passion for including Epping,<br />
Carlingford Mobbs Hill, Conjola, Ryde and Mollymook. Alex was also<br />
a long serving member of Epping Civic Trust and founded the Loftus<br />
Square Park Committee.<br />
stitution, this time incorporating both proxies and four<br />
appointees to a thirteen member Board. <strong>The</strong> very issues<br />
which were contentious previously have now<br />
both been included. <strong>The</strong> logic beggars belief!<br />
Contrary to whatever rationale is proposed, the obvious<br />
motivation for changing the Constitution is the<br />
determination of the CEO to ensure her continued<br />
employment irrespective of performance. Naturally,<br />
with assets of $10million despite six losses in seven<br />
years, the College has obvious appeal.<br />
(8hb 2 cols)<br />
<strong>The</strong> EGM is to be held on the College campus at 263<br />
Marden Road Carlingford at 7pm on Wednesday <strong>October</strong><br />
17.<br />
Incorporating Resort Living for the Over 55’s<br />
10am - 3pm both days FREE ADMISSION<br />
Wednesday 10 <strong>October</strong>, <strong>2018</strong> THE WEEKLY TIMES 5<br />
Vale Former Mayor<br />
Bruce Edelman OAM<br />
Former Hunters Hill Mayor Bruce<br />
Edelman OAM passed away last<br />
Sunday after a recent illness.<br />
Dr Edelman (79) was the Mayor of<br />
Hunters Hill from 1985 until 1987.<br />
He was also the founder of Hunters<br />
Hill’s State Emergency Services Unit<br />
and the first Controller, establishing the<br />
unit back in 1991 with another former<br />
Hunters Hill Mayor Sue Hoopmann and<br />
Ken Iles.<br />
A notable oral surgeon in Sydney’s<br />
Eastern Suburbs, Dr Edelman<br />
was praised by Hunters Hill Council<br />
in <strong>The</strong> <strong>Weekly</strong> <strong>Times</strong> in 2005.<br />
“On forming the Hunters Hill SES 21<br />
years ago Dr Edelman used his home<br />
as a base and directed resident calls<br />
for assistance to Lane Cove or Ryde.”<br />
“To set up the SES he was given a small<br />
utility truck and a garage behind Henley<br />
Cottage on Victoria Road.<br />
“<strong>The</strong> house opposite Henley Cottage<br />
– now the Long Day Care Centre<br />
– was offered by Council to<br />
serve as the SES headquarters.<br />
“Hunters Hill SES is now in the Old<br />
Store of the Gladesville Hospital and is<br />
shared by St John’s Ambulance Service,<br />
centrally located behind the Gladesville<br />
Police Station.”<br />
A long standing member of the Hunters<br />
Hill community, he is survived by<br />
his wife Christine and daughter Sally.<br />
Funeral details are yet to be announced.<br />
HUNTER’S HILL COUNCIL<br />
HUNTER’S HILL COUNCIL<br />
NOTIFICATION OF DEVELOPMENT APPLICATION<br />
In accordance with the provisions of Part 6.1<br />
Notification Policy of Hunters Hill Consolidated<br />
Development Control Plan 2013, notice is hereby<br />
given that Council is in receipt of the following Section<br />
8.2 Application modifying the previous Development<br />
Application.<br />
DA No. Site Proposal<br />
2008-1096-1<br />
27 Nelson Parade,<br />
Hunters Hill<br />
Section 8.2 -<br />
Retrospective<br />
approval of<br />
unauthorised<br />
works<br />
<strong>The</strong> plans and supporting documentation may be<br />
inspected at the Customer Service Centre between<br />
8.30am and 4.30pm, Monday to Friday. Written<br />
submissions will be received up until 4.00pm<br />
9 November <strong>2018</strong> and all enquiries may be directed<br />
to Senior Development Officer, Mr Kerry Smith on<br />
9879 9400.<br />
Lisa Miscamble<br />
GENERAL MANAGER<br />
Looking for information on retirement living? Visit the<br />
Sydney Retirement Village Expo<br />
Sunday 21st & Monday 22nd <strong>October</strong><br />
<strong>The</strong> Epping Club - Rawson St, Epping (3 mins walk from the station)<br />
This is the big one! On display will be the latest resort style developments as well as established<br />
villages from many different organisations. All offering a wide range of services & facilities,<br />
sizes, prices and locations, all under one roof.<br />
www.retirementexpo.com.au