09.10.2018 Views

The Weekly Times - TWT - 10th October 2018

The Weekly Times - TWT - is a campaigning, crusading, truth-seeking, death defying, Aussie battler-aligned, one-eyed-Tiger-led news organisation dedicated to Sydney's north west. This flip book - or digital edition/replica - is the 10th October 2018 edition of TWT. You can direct people to TWT's 10th October 2018 edition by using this shareable link: https://weeklytimes.com.au/the-weekly-times-twt-10th-october-2018/ And the most current edition of TWT is always reachable using this short address: bit.ly/OurTWT

The Weekly Times - TWT - is a campaigning, crusading, truth-seeking, death defying, Aussie battler-aligned, one-eyed-Tiger-led news organisation dedicated to Sydney's north west. This flip book - or digital edition/replica - is the 10th October 2018 edition of TWT.

You can direct people to TWT's 10th October 2018 edition by using this shareable link:

https://weeklytimes.com.au/the-weekly-times-twt-10th-october-2018/

And the most current edition of TWT is always reachable using this short address: bit.ly/OurTWT

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

PETCH VERDICT NEARS<br />

BY OUR COURT REPORTER<br />

A verdict is nearing in another farcical ICAC ‘blackmail’ court case with Ryde Emeritus<br />

Mayor Ivan Petch on trial in the NSW District Court for allegedly blackmailing Acting Ryde<br />

Council General Manager Danielle Dickson.<br />

<strong>The</strong> court has been told that Danielle Dickson used her key to<br />

access former Mayor Ivan Petch’s office, to “snoop” around<br />

with fellow council officer Roy Newsome, looking for incriminating<br />

documents for ICAC.<br />

Ivan Petch is on trial for allegedly blackmailing Danielle Dickson in<br />

May 2013, three months after Petch appointed her in the role of<br />

Ryde Council’s Acting GM.<br />

Court costs had been accrued in legal action initiated by Ryde<br />

Council against councillors, to restrain them from taking any action<br />

to terminate former GM John Neish in mid-2012.<br />

Mr Neish eventually left his role under a Deed of Release with Ryde<br />

Council, after he was found downloading porn on his laptop using<br />

council resources.<br />

His departure brought an end to legal proceedings, leaving the<br />

mat-ter of legal costs incurred by the affected councillors,<br />

outstanding.<br />

Despite expert legal advice from Bryan Belling of K&L Gates<br />

and Stefano Laface of AJL Legal, that council’s insurance policy<br />

with Zu-rich should be used to reimburse councillors, Ms Dickson -<br />

who had been delegated responsibility to resolve the matter - did<br />

not discon-tinue the ongoing Supreme Court matter.<br />

Mr Petch’s repeated efforts to have Ms Dickson reimburse councillors<br />

in accordance to what they were entitled to, are central to<br />

the “blackmail” allegation.<br />

Defence barrister Graham Turnbull SC has asked the jury to<br />

consid-er whether the pair›s four-minute discussion in the mayoral<br />

chamber was blackmail or «fatherly advice, about reimbursement».<br />

«<strong>The</strong>re is no way in the wide world this is a demand, that it›s<br />

an unwarranted demand, it›s made with menaces or that it was<br />

capable of affecting anybody›s capacity to do what they thought<br />

was right,» he said.<br />

THE VERDICT is expected very soon. Check <strong>TWT</strong> Online for a<br />

esult. Details next week in <strong>The</strong> <strong>Weekly</strong> <strong>Times</strong>.<br />

Mr Turnbull also argued that Ms Dickson “was well acquainted”<br />

ith the Independent Commission Against Corruption before her<br />

onversation with Petch and her subsequent contact with ICAC<br />

nvestigators.<br />

“Ms Dickson was in the habit of making notes, making notes almost<br />

s soon as things occurred,” he told the jury.<br />

“She was also, you may find.. in the habit of speaking with ICAC both<br />

efore this event and afterwards.”<br />

In her closing address on Monday, crown prosecutor Donna Daleo<br />

said the then-mayor made “a threat of something detrimental or unpleasant”<br />

to Ms Dickson.<br />

Hundreds of villages<br />

represented!<br />

As <strong>The</strong> <strong>Weekly</strong> <strong>Times</strong> was going to press this week, Mr Turnbull<br />

was due to complete his closing address. This was to be followed<br />

by Judge Nicole Noman’s summing up before the jury retired to<br />

consider a verdict.<br />

<strong>The</strong> present trial comes more than a year after John Goubran was<br />

cleared on blackmail charges and Mr Petch was consequently also<br />

cleared on accessory charges.<br />

Magistrate Beverley Schurr, in June 2017, had ruled ICAC’s centrepiece<br />

allegation, used to justify its Ryde investigation, fell short<br />

of the requisite standard of proof, with the prosecution case flawed<br />

with major inconsistencies.<br />

<strong>The</strong> supposed plot, according to ICAC, involved a threat to ex-Ryde<br />

Council GM John Neish’s job if the Civic Centre proposal was not<br />

delayed until after the September 2012 council elections.<br />

But Magistrate Schurr found a fatal flaw in the allegation was the<br />

inability to establish an offence under NSW law which amounted to<br />

influencing Neish’s exercise of public duty, as he did not have the<br />

necessary delegations.<br />

<strong>The</strong> prosecution case was already in disarray after much of its evidence<br />

was ruled inadmissible by Magistrate Beverley Schurr, following<br />

200 separate challenges to evidence by legal representatives for<br />

both Mr Goubran and Mr Petch, in <strong>October</strong> 2016.<br />

Counsel for Mr Goubran, Maurice Neil QC, at the time said “as little<br />

as five per cent” of one key witness’ evidence was admissible and<br />

the court had been “dumped with a massive amount of material held<br />

by a tribunal not bound by the rules of evidence. It shouldn’t happen.”<br />

We’ll have more in next week’s edition of <strong>The</strong> <strong>Weekly</strong> <strong>Times</strong>.<br />

MCC Board third attempt<br />

to change Constitution<br />

<strong>The</strong> current Constitution dates back<br />

to 2002 and warrants change. However,<br />

the “sticking point” which Board members<br />

have to live with, is a history of<br />

seven years of disgracefully unethical<br />

behaviour by CEOs and irresponsible<br />

directors.<br />

Fortunately for the College, there are<br />

enough members determined not to allow<br />

history to repeat itself.<br />

In March 2015 Chairman Sue Murray<br />

and newly appointed CEO <strong>The</strong>resa Collignon<br />

sought to change the Constitution<br />

to include proxy voting.<br />

Previously, the College was under<br />

ASIC which overruled the Constitution.<br />

However in 2014, the governing body<br />

was changed from ASIC to the ACNC<br />

which gave the Constitution full authority<br />

with no proxy voting.<br />

At the March 2015 EGM proxy voting<br />

was rejected outright because former<br />

CEO June Heinrich had previously<br />

By <strong>The</strong> <strong>Weekly</strong> <strong>Times</strong> Special Team of Investigative Reporters (<strong>TWT</strong> STIR Team)<br />

Members of Macquarie Community College have been invited to<br />

a third Extraordinary General Meeting to change the College Constitution<br />

in just over three years.<br />

used proxies to stack the membership<br />

with hundreds of new members who<br />

gave their proxy votes without question.<br />

This scam was made even worse<br />

when the following year Chairman<br />

Sue Murray resigned mid- term amid<br />

screams of discontent from members<br />

and re-elected herself for two years<br />

with eighty proxy votes she gave herself.<br />

At the AGM held in May this year another<br />

attempt was made to change the<br />

Constitution. On this occasion proxy<br />

voting was removed and instead, the<br />

Board composition was changed to allow<br />

for four appointees, another misuse<br />

of the Constitution to stack the Board,<br />

making governance a farce. That attempt<br />

to change the Constitution was<br />

rejected also.<br />

Now, members are being asked to<br />

vote for a third time to change the Con-<br />

Alex McAndrew Memorial at Epping<br />

<strong>The</strong> late Alex McAndrew will be honoured with the unveiling of a<br />

memorial at Loftus Park Square in Epping this Saturday <strong>October</strong> 13.<br />

All are invited for the ceremony between 10.30 am to 11.30am with<br />

morning tea to follow.<br />

Alex McAndrew was a highly regarded local resident, author and<br />

historian. His work included writing illustrated books depicting the<br />

history of various districts he had a passion for including Epping,<br />

Carlingford Mobbs Hill, Conjola, Ryde and Mollymook. Alex was also<br />

a long serving member of Epping Civic Trust and founded the Loftus<br />

Square Park Committee.<br />

stitution, this time incorporating both proxies and four<br />

appointees to a thirteen member Board. <strong>The</strong> very issues<br />

which were contentious previously have now<br />

both been included. <strong>The</strong> logic beggars belief!<br />

Contrary to whatever rationale is proposed, the obvious<br />

motivation for changing the Constitution is the<br />

determination of the CEO to ensure her continued<br />

employment irrespective of performance. Naturally,<br />

with assets of $10million despite six losses in seven<br />

years, the College has obvious appeal.<br />

(8hb 2 cols)<br />

<strong>The</strong> EGM is to be held on the College campus at 263<br />

Marden Road Carlingford at 7pm on Wednesday <strong>October</strong><br />

17.<br />

Incorporating Resort Living for the Over 55’s<br />

10am - 3pm both days FREE ADMISSION<br />

Wednesday 10 <strong>October</strong>, <strong>2018</strong> THE WEEKLY TIMES 5<br />

Vale Former Mayor<br />

Bruce Edelman OAM<br />

Former Hunters Hill Mayor Bruce<br />

Edelman OAM passed away last<br />

Sunday after a recent illness.<br />

Dr Edelman (79) was the Mayor of<br />

Hunters Hill from 1985 until 1987.<br />

He was also the founder of Hunters<br />

Hill’s State Emergency Services Unit<br />

and the first Controller, establishing the<br />

unit back in 1991 with another former<br />

Hunters Hill Mayor Sue Hoopmann and<br />

Ken Iles.<br />

A notable oral surgeon in Sydney’s<br />

Eastern Suburbs, Dr Edelman<br />

was praised by Hunters Hill Council<br />

in <strong>The</strong> <strong>Weekly</strong> <strong>Times</strong> in 2005.<br />

“On forming the Hunters Hill SES 21<br />

years ago Dr Edelman used his home<br />

as a base and directed resident calls<br />

for assistance to Lane Cove or Ryde.”<br />

“To set up the SES he was given a small<br />

utility truck and a garage behind Henley<br />

Cottage on Victoria Road.<br />

“<strong>The</strong> house opposite Henley Cottage<br />

– now the Long Day Care Centre<br />

– was offered by Council to<br />

serve as the SES headquarters.<br />

“Hunters Hill SES is now in the Old<br />

Store of the Gladesville Hospital and is<br />

shared by St John’s Ambulance Service,<br />

centrally located behind the Gladesville<br />

Police Station.”<br />

A long standing member of the Hunters<br />

Hill community, he is survived by<br />

his wife Christine and daughter Sally.<br />

Funeral details are yet to be announced.<br />

HUNTER’S HILL COUNCIL<br />

HUNTER’S HILL COUNCIL<br />

NOTIFICATION OF DEVELOPMENT APPLICATION<br />

In accordance with the provisions of Part 6.1<br />

Notification Policy of Hunters Hill Consolidated<br />

Development Control Plan 2013, notice is hereby<br />

given that Council is in receipt of the following Section<br />

8.2 Application modifying the previous Development<br />

Application.<br />

DA No. Site Proposal<br />

2008-1096-1<br />

27 Nelson Parade,<br />

Hunters Hill<br />

Section 8.2 -<br />

Retrospective<br />

approval of<br />

unauthorised<br />

works<br />

<strong>The</strong> plans and supporting documentation may be<br />

inspected at the Customer Service Centre between<br />

8.30am and 4.30pm, Monday to Friday. Written<br />

submissions will be received up until 4.00pm<br />

9 November <strong>2018</strong> and all enquiries may be directed<br />

to Senior Development Officer, Mr Kerry Smith on<br />

9879 9400.<br />

Lisa Miscamble<br />

GENERAL MANAGER<br />

Looking for information on retirement living? Visit the<br />

Sydney Retirement Village Expo<br />

Sunday 21st & Monday 22nd <strong>October</strong><br />

<strong>The</strong> Epping Club - Rawson St, Epping (3 mins walk from the station)<br />

This is the big one! On display will be the latest resort style developments as well as established<br />

villages from many different organisations. All offering a wide range of services & facilities,<br />

sizes, prices and locations, all under one roof.<br />

www.retirementexpo.com.au

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!