Regency Auction 29

THE REGENCY AUCTION 29 

SAN ANTONIO 

NOVEMBER 15 | HYATT REGENCY RIVERWALK 

Dear Numismatic Enthusiast! 

Welcome to the final Regency Auction of 2018! We are proud of the major offering of RARE, high end coins. Featuring over 480 lots 

of hand selected U.S. coins, this sale has lots of coins that will fit into any collection at any price point. 

The sale starts out with a great offering of copper coins, including GEM and SUPERB GEM Indian and Lincoln cents and two cent 

pieces. High end nickels, dimes, quarters and halves follow. Lots of great dollars feature some great Morgans. A fantastic offering of 

gold coins from the S.S. Central America recovery starts off our gold coin selection. Lots of rare date and condition census gold coins 

follow with our largest selection of high-grade Commemoratives closing out the sale. There is something for everyone in this sale, just 

take a look at these highlights: 

Lot 11. 1C 1814 Crosslet 4. PCGS MS66 

Lot 42. 1C 1910 PCGS PR67+ RD CAC 

Lot 73. 5C 1912-D PCGS MS67 

Lot 131. 20C 1878 PCGS PR66+ CAC 

Lot 134. 25C 1835 PCGS PR63 

Lot 189. 50C 1919-D PCGS MS64+ CAC 

Lot 213. $1 1840 PCGS MS63+ CAC 

Lot 233 $1 1882-O/S Strong. PCGS MS65+ 

Lot 263. $1 1891 PCGS PR67 CAM CAC 

Lot 266. $1 1921 Chapman Proof. PCGS PR67 

Lot 278. $5 1857-S PCGS MS63+ CAC Ex. S.S. Central America 

Lot 285. $20 1857-S PCGS MS67 CAC Ex S.S. Central America 

Lot 297. $2.50 1876 PCGS PR67 DCAM 

Lot 333. $5 1914 PCGS PR67 CAC 

Lot 352. $20 1852-O PCGS MS61 CAC 

Lot 376. $20 1872 PCGS PR63 DCAM 

Lot 415. 50C 1893 Columbian Expo. PCGS MS67+ CAC 

Lot 470. $50 1915-S Pan-Pac Octagonal. PCGS MS62 

As always, we are here to assist in any way. Contact us today if you have any questions. We are always looking for quality 

consignments. Starting in 2019 we will be conducting 6 Regency Auctions. If you have any coins you would like to consign to our 

January 2019 Regency Auction, we are accepting consignments until Monday, December 3. Contact your favorite consignment 

specialist today! 

Happy hunting, 

Julie Abrams 

President Legend Rare Coin Auctions

TERMS AND CONDITIONS 

This is a public auction, conducted in accordance with these Terms and Conditions of Sale, by Legend Rare Coin Auctions 

(hereinafter referred to as “LRCA”). By bidding on any lot offered by LRCA, the bidder indicates acceptance of the following 

Terms and Conditions of Sale. Bidders are to comply with the Terms and Conditions of Sale, posted on LegendAuctions.com, at the 

time of the auction in which they are participating. 

BUYER’S PREMIUM 

A 17.5% buyer’s premium will be added to all successful bids, and is payable by the winning bidder as part of the total purchase cost. 

SALES TAX 

All sales are subject to applicable state and local taxes. Any lots that are picked up and/or delivered in the state of of The Regency 

Auction are subject to applicable state and local taxes. 

PAYMENT 

All merchandise must be paid for within TEN (10) days of the date of sale. We reserve the right to cancel any unpaid order after 

that time and to ban the bidder from future sales. Credit cards (Visa, MasterCard and Discover) are accepted for auction payments 

up to $2,500.00 per invoice. Invoices and/or balances over $2,500.00 must be paid via personal or certified check, money order, or 

wired funds. Personal checks, money orders and cashier’s checks may be held for up to 10 business days in order to allow time for 

them to clear appropriate banking channels. Please email info@legendauctions.com for bank-wiring instructions and/or to provide 

numismatic references. 

E-check Payments 

E-check payments now available. Please email form to info@legendauctions.com 

International Buyers 

Foreign buyers, unknown to us, are required to deposit 25% of their anticipated expenditures before bidding. Please contact us in 

advance of bidding for bank wiring instructions. 

Extended Payment Terms 

For all items $15,000.00 and over, LRCA is now offering Extended Payment Terms. Please advise us at least 48 hours before 

bidding or purchasing the item in question. Pre-approval is required. 

RETURN POLICY 

All lots are sold “as is.” Lots graded by PCGS, NGC or other third-party grading services, or any lot viewed by the buyer or anyone 

on buyer’s behalf prior to the auction, may not be returned. This is not an approval sale. All sales of lots to the highest bidder are 

final. Bidders are strongly advised and encouraged to research any lots upon which they plan to bid, and to determine bids, based 

upon their own evaluation. Bidders assume all risks concerning and related to the grade, quality, appearance, condition, history and 

origin of any lot. Bidders acknowledge that coin grading is not an exact science, that it can be subjective and inconsistent and that 

it is possible that two parties might assess or grade the same coin differently. LRCA makes every effort to accurately describe all 

items offered in its sales. All items will be available for preview prior to the auction. 

SHIPPING 

Shipping costs will be billed separately and are non-refundable. Items will usually ship within 5-10 business days after payment 

has been received and/or funds have cleared. Coins will be shipped via Fed Ex or USPS or transported via armored carrier. 

The shipping charge includes fees for our third-party insurance coverage, as well as any costs incurred through the USPS or 

Federal Express. Any shipments made via armored carrier (Brinks, Dunbar, etc.) will be calculated and assessed at the time of 

shipment. 

INTERNATIONAL SHIPPING 

It is not possible for LRCA to ship to some countries. Please email questions to info@legendauctions.com. Payment for all

international orders is required in US funds. Please contact julie@legendauctions.com for bank wiring instructions. 

Customs requirements for each country are the responsibility of the buyer. All packages shipped outside of the United States will 

include the required customs declaration and full value of the invoice. 

BIDS VIA TELEPHONE 

An absentee bidder may also participate live, during the auction, via telephone. Requests for phone bidding must be received at 

least three days prior to the auction date. Please fill out our phone bidding request form online or call 732-935-1168 to request a 

call from one of our representatives during the live auction. LRCA cannot guarantee phone lines, but will make every effort to 

accommodate those who wish to participate via this method. 

RIGHTS & RESPONSIBILITIES 

The auctioneer will determine the highest bidder. The auctioneer, alone, has the right to reopen the bidding for an item, if deemed 

necessary. LRCA and its representatives reserve the right to remove any attendees who impede the preview and/or the auction. Title 

to all merchandise shall pass to the winning bidder after receipt of good funds by LRCA. Bidders will be held responsible for their 

bids, including those bids placed incorrectly. PLEASE VERIFY BIDS BEFORE SUBMITTING THEM. In order to have a bid 

removed or corrected, bidder must contact LRCA prior to start of the auction. Bidder waives auctioneer’s responsibility and holds 

LRCA harmless for failure to recognize, accept, receive or execute any lost or missing bids by internet, telephone, email, floor 

bid, fax, mail or other means. LRCA reserves the right to postpone or cancel an auction without notice. Lots may be withdrawn at 

LRCA’s discretion, without prior notice. Lots may carry a reserve. A reserve is a price below which the auctioneer will not sell an 

item, or will re-purchase the item on behalf of the consignor or for LRCA. LRCA permits bids to be placed by the auctioneer, or 

an employee of the auctioneer, up to the pre-determined reserve set by the consignor. Legend Rare Coin Auctions’ partner, Legend 

Numismatics, reserves the right to bid on items, for its own account and for the accounts of its clients. 

DISCLAIMER AND WARRANTIES 

No warranty of merchantability or fitness for a particular purpose is made or implied on any lot. No warranty, whether expressed or 

implied, is made with respect to any lot except for warranty of title, and in the case of title, auctioneer is selling only that right or 

title to the lot that the consignor may have as of the auction sale date. All lots are sold “as is” and with all faults. Purchaser hereby 

assumes all risks concerning and related to the grading, quality, description, condition, authenticity, and provenance of a lot. 

a. Coins and currency listed in this catalog graded by PCGS, NGC, or any other third party grading service or examined by the buyer 

prior to the auction sale may not be returned for any reason whatsoever by any buyer, except for claims related to authenticity. 

b. For non-certified coins that have not been examined by the Buyer prior to the Auction Sale: if it is determined in a review by 

LRCA that there is a material error in the catalog description of a non-certified coin or the LRCA no later than seventy-two (72) 

hours of delivery of the lots in question, and such lots are returned and received by LRCA, in their original, sealed containers, no 

later than fourteen (14) calendar days after delivery, in the same condition the lot(s) were delivered to the Buyer, time being of the 

essence. 

c. If an item or items are returned pursuant to the terms herein, they must be housed in their original, sealed and unopened 

container. 

d. Late remittance or removal of any item from its original container, or altering a coin constitutes just cause for revocation of all 

return privileges. 

e. Grading or condition of rare coins may have a material effect on the value of the item(s) purchased, and the opinion of others 

(including independent grading services) may differ with the independent grading services opinion or interpretation of LRCA. 

LRCA shall not be bound by any prior, or subsequent opinion, determination or certification by any independent grading service. 

f. Questions regarding the minting of a coin as a “proof” or as a “business strike” relate to the method of manufacture and not to 

authenticity. 

g. All oral and written statements made by LRCA and its employees or agents (including affiliated and related companies) are

statements of opinion only, and are not warranties or representations of any kind, unless stated as a specific written warranty, and 

no employee or agent of LRCA has authority to vary or alter these Terms and Conditions of Auction Sale. LRCA reserves the right 

to vary or alter the Terms of Sale, either generally or with respect to specific persons or circumstances, in its sole discretion. Any 

variation or alteration shall be effective only if in writing and signed by an officer of LRCA authorized to do so. 

h. LRCA is acting as an auctioneer. Title to the lots purchased passes directly from the Consignor to the Buyer. Accordingly, LRCA 

is not making, and disclaims, any warranty of title. 

i. Bidder acknowledges that the numismatic market is speculative, unregulated and volatile, and that coin prices may rise or fall over time. 

LRCA does not guarantee or represent that any customer buying for investment purposes will be able to sell for a profit in the future. 

j. Bidder acknowledges and agrees that neither LRCA, nor its employees, affiliates, agents, third-party providers or consignors 

warrant that auctions will be unimpaired, uninterrupted or error free and accordingly shall not be liable for such events. 

WAIVER AND RELEASE 

Bidder, for himself, his heirs, agents, successors and assignees, generally and specifically waives and releases, and forever 

discharges LRCA, and its respective affiliates, parents, officers, directors, shareholders, agents, subsidiaries, employees, managers 

and members and each of them, and their respective successors and assignees from any and all claims, rights, demands and causes 

of actions and suits, of whatever kind or nature, including but not limited to claims based upon Auctioneer’s negligence, whether in 

law or equity, tort or otherwise, whether known or unknown, suspected or unsuspected (a “Claim”), which Bidder may assert with 

respect to and/or arising out of, or in connection with any challenge to the title to or authenticity of any goods purchased, the sale 

itself, any lot bid upon or consigned, and/or the auction, except where such Claim is otherwise expressly authorized in these Terms 

of Sale. It is the intention of Bidder that this waiver and release shall be effective as a bar to each and every Claim that may arise 

hereunder or be related to the Auction Sale. 

DISPUTES 

If a dispute arises concerning ownership of a lot or concerning proceeds of any sale, LRCA reserves the right to commence a 

statutory inter-pleader proceeding at the expense of the Consignor and Buyer and any other applicable party, and in such event shall 

be entitled to its reasonable attorneys’ fees and costs. LRCA reserves the right to cancel or postpone the Auction Sale or any session 

thereof for any reason whatsoever. No Bidder shall have any claim as a result thereof, including for incidental or consequential 

damages. Neither LRCA nor any affiliated or related company shall be responsible for incidental or consequential damages arising 

out of any failure of the Terms of Sale, the auction or the conduct thereof and in no event shall such liability exceed the purchase 

price, premium, or fees paid. Rights granted to Bidders under the within Terms and Conditions of Auction Sale are personal and 

apply only to the Bidder who initially purchases the lot(s) from LRCA. The rights may not be assigned or transferred to any other 

person or entity, whether by sale of the lot(s), operation of law or otherwise. Any attempt to assign or transfer any such rights shall 

be absolutely void and unenforceable. No third party may rely on any benefit or right conferred by these Terms and Conditions of 

Auction Sale. 

Any dispute arising out of or related to these Terms of Sale, the Auction Sale or any lot, with the sole exception of actions by Legend 

Rare Coin Auctions to collect amounts owed to it and other damages, shall be submitted to binding arbitration pursuant to the 

commercial arbitration rules of the American Arbitration Association, with any arbitration hearing to occur in Monmouth County, 

New Jersey. Absent an agreement of the parties, the arbitrator shall limit discovery to that which is necessary to enable the hearing 

to proceed efficiently. The arbitrator shall not have the power to award punitive or consequential damages, nor alter, amend modify 

any of the terms of this Agreement. The award by the arbitrator, if any, may be entered in any court having jurisdiction thereof. Each 

party shall pay one-half the costs of the arbitration. Bidder acknowledges and agrees that the competent courts of the State of New 

Jersey shall have exclusive in personam jurisdiction, subject to the requirement to arbitrate, over any dispute(s) arising hereunder, 

regardless of any party’s current or future residence or domicile. Bidder further agrees that venue of the arbitration proceeding shall 

be in Monmouth County, New Jersey; and any court proceeding shall be in the Monmouth County Superior Court, in the State of New 

Jersey, and in each case waive any claim of Forum Non Conveniens. Bidder agrees that any arbitration or legal action with respect to 

this Auction Sale is barred unless commenced within one (1) year of the date of this Auction Sale. 

Auction participants expressly waive any right to trial by jury.

LISTED BID INCREMENTS 

Bid increments are to serve as a general guideline. Actual increments are at the auctioneer’s discretion. 

$0 - $199 

$10 

$200 - $999 

$25 

$1,000 - $1,999 

$50 

$2,000 - $4,999 

$100 

$5,000 - $9,999 

$250 

$10,000 - $19,999 

$500 

$20,000 - $39,999 

$1,000 

$40,000 - $99,999 

$2,500 

$100,000 - $199,999 

$5,000 

$200,000 - $399,999 

$10,000 

$400,000 - $999,999 

$25,000 

$1,000,000 - $1,999,999 

$50,000 

$2,000,000 and up 

$100,000 

OUR ESTIMATES 

The estimates you see published in this catalog are based on HAMMER. Keep in mind that a coin 

could be either low or high end for the grade, have stunning color or be dull, all of which radically 

affect a coin’s value. Yes, there can be huge price differences within a grade, and we offer estimates 

as a guide so Collector’s can have a better idea of value. One thing we will never do is offer low ball 

estimates in order to claim stronger sales. 

These published estimates represent what Legend Rare Coin Auctions determines to be an 

approximate high wholesale value for the coin. The numbers are based upon current market values, 

similar trades, auction prices, published prices, and a consideration of the coin’s quality. There is no 

guarantee that the estimated prices are minimums or are exactly what you can expect to get if you 

attempt to resell them wholesale. 

We always advise you to view the coins you are interested in and calculate what you’ll pay using as 

much information as possible. If you have any questions, please feel free to ask us. We are here to 

help you!

PRINCIPALS 

Laura was raised in Highland Park, NJ. During high school, the coin bug hit her hard. Her trip to the 

1976 NYC ANA left a lasting mark and huge desire for her to own and handle the greatest rarities. While 

attending Monmouth University, Laura attended coin shows more than classes. After college, she started 

LSS RCI, a wholesale coin company. In 1986, she realized the need for a “better” coin retailer and teamed 

up in 1986 with George Huang to form Legend Numismatics. 

In 1996 Bruce Morelan became a partner and since then Legend has exclusively built or assisted in 

assembling this generation’s greatest collections. In 2012 Laura saw the need for a smaller, boutique 

auction firm, and created Legend-Morphy with Dan Morphy, whom she split with in 2014. Today, Laura 

is also a leading consumer advocate for coins. The passion has never subsided, and she keeps a beautiful 

Proof Walker on her desk to this day. 

Laura Sperber 

Partner 

Bruce started collecting coins when he was only six years old and by the time he was in high school his 

dream was to be a coin dealer. But life intervened and instead, Bruce went into business. By chance, he 

became Legend Numismatics’ financial backer in 1996. His great grandmother had given him three coins 

when he was young, one of which being a Trade Dollar, so he set out to build the finest Trade Dollar 

set. After a few years with ultra rarities, Bruce returned to his love of dollars and completed both a set of 

Gobrechts and a set of Seated Dollars. 

After selling those sets, Bruce recently returned to dollars with a new Gobrecht set and a spectacular early 

dollar set capped by his dream coin, the Amon Carter 1794 Dollar. Not many collector’s can say they have 

completed not only the finest 1794-1885 Dollar Sets and have over the years owned such coins as two 

1913 Liberty Head Nickels, an 1894-S Dime, 1876-CC Twenty Cent piece, 1827 Original and Restrike 

Quarters, 1838-O Half Dollar, two 1885 Trade Dollars and four 1884 Trade Dollars! 

Bruce Morelan 

Partner 

Julie Abrams started in numismatics in 1986 when she joined up with Bernard Rome and launched 

Teletrade, the first computerized auction company. Teletrade developed a unique coin trading method, 

utilizing state-of-the-art digitized voice board technology to run live auctions before the advent of the 

internet. As President of Teletrade, Julie helped expand the company, increasing the frequency of auctions 

and expanding annual sales to $24 million within a few years. In 1999, GMAI, a publicly traded company, 

purchased Teletrade and Ms. Abrams became Executive Vice President of Sales for the parent company. Her 

job responsibilities included continuing her role as CEO for Teletrade as well as marketing to buyers and 

consignors, with the goal of maintaining a balance between inventory and sales while growing the business. 

Julie Abrams 

President 

In 2004 she joined Stacks-Bowers, an old world traditional auction house where she worked to expand 

their e-commerce presence, including the development of an online bidding platform for the firm. She 

also marketed Stacks’ programs to secure consignments from dealers and institutions such as banks, 

museums and universities. 

Julie is a member of the American Numismatic Association, the Central States Numismatic Association 

and Florida United Numismatists. 

STAFF 

Matt Bell 

Executive Vice 

President 

Serena Myers 

Director of 

Administration 

Greg Cohen 

Senior Numismatist 

Jessica Berkman 

Consignment 

Coordinator 

Patrick Braswell 

Art Director 

Ann Marie Van Pelt 

Office Manager 

AUCTIONEER| Bradley Karoleff | PHOTOGRAPHY | John Emerson 

AUCTION COORDINATOR | Jose Campos | CATALOGER | Mitch Battino

Official Auctioneer of the PCGS Members Only Show 

Thursday, November 15, 2018 | 5:30PM CT 

Auction Room: Medina 

LOCATION 

Hyatt Regency San Antonio Riverwalk - At the PCGS Members Only Show 

Auction Room: Medina 

123 Losoya Street | San Antonio, Texas 78205 

LOT VIEWING 

Tuesday, November 13th 

1PM-6PM CT | Appointment Only | Location: Rio Grande Ballroom 

Wednesday, November 14th 

9AM-6:00PM CT | Location: Rio Grande Ballroom 

Thursday, November 15th 

9AM-4:30PM CT | Rio Grande Ballroom 

LOT PICKUP & SETTLEMENT 

Friday, November 16th 

9AM-11AM CT | Location: Rio Grande Ballroom 

ON LOCATION PHONE NUMBER: 732-233-0719 

17.5% Buyer’s Premium 

Legend | Rare Coin Auctions • legendauctions.com 

P.O. Box 9, Lincroft NJ 07738 • info@legendauctions.com • Tel. 732-935-1168 

Fax 732-935-1807 | Hours: Open M-F / 9AM-5PM ET



SAN ANTONIO 

NOVEMBER 15 | HYATT REGENCY RIVERWALK 

LOT 1 

FUGIO 1787 PCGS MS64 BN CAC 

STATES UNITED, 4 Cinquefoils, Pointed Rays 

type; Newman 13-X, W-6855 variety, rated as R-2. 

Struck under the authority of the American 

Congress, the Fugio coppers, also referred to as 

Cents, are among the most popular “colonial” 

issues, and one of the few that, thanks to the 

Bank of New York Hoard, can be obtained with 

little difficulty in Mint State. The design is very 

symbolic, relating directly to Continental Currency 

notes from 1776 and inspired by Benjamin 

Franklin. 

The present near-GEM likely traces its origin to that source. Steely brown surfaces are even and devoid of any serious marks or lines, and 

totally free of any kind of environmental damage. Glimpses of orange cling to the upper left rings of the reverse chain. Sharply struck 

from clashed dies, the eye appeal is excellent. 

PCGS 87, NGC 40, CAC 32. This coin last sold in the 2017 FUN auction for $3,995. Earlier, it realized $4,888 in the 2011 FUN auction. 

The current PCGS value is listed at $4,850 and this near-GEM will see very strong bidding indeed. This coin represents a lot of history! 

PCGS# 883 | ESTIMATE: $4,000+ 

8


LOT 2 

1/2C 1793 PCGS AU53 CAC 

A “GEM” of an AU! Among the first coins struck for 

circulation from the fledgling Philadelphia mint, the 1793 

half cent is a very important and extremely popular issue, a 

one-year only type that is highly sought by collectors in all 

grades, from environmentally damaged low grade examples 

to GEM Mint State. Very RARE in high quality collector 

grades like this, even more so with such amazing eye appeal. 

This coin has only the lightest traces of circulation. A few 

stray marks can be seen on otherwise smooth, hard copper 

surfaces. Unlike most of the examples of this date we 

see either in auction or on the bourse, which come with 

extensive wear or environmental issues, this coin has a 

very pleasing medium brown coloration, with only a touch 

of wear. There are a few tiny marks and scratches that 

can be seen under a glass, and they mostly blend into the 

surrounding chocolate brown and olive iridescent toning. 

The devices are sharply impressed into the planchet, the 

eye appeal is superior to the vast majority of the known 

survivors of the date. 

The 35,334 half cents struck in this first year were all coined 

between May and July 1793. The design, featuring Liberty’s 

head facing left with a liberty cap on top of a pole is directly 

related to the 1781 Libertas Americana medals struck in 

Paris on designs suggested by Ben Franklin. According to 

Walter Breen, a who’s who of early mint employees are 

thought to have worked on the designs, including David 

Rittenhouse, Robert Birch, and Adam Eckfeldt. The present 

coin is from the Breen-3, Cohen-3 die pairing. 

PCGS 13, NGC 10, CAC 1. This coin has the incorrect 

PCGS # on the insert, listed as 1001 for a 1793 with the RB 

designation. No CAC-approved example has ever sold in 

auction in AU53. The current PCGS Price Guide value is 

listed at $40,000 and with its CAC-endorsement and high 

end look, this coin should realize in excess of that! A very 

desirable numismatic trophy from the infant years of the 

republic. Bound for a wonderful collection of half cents or 

early type coins. 

PCGS# 1001 | ESTIMATE: $35,000+ 

9


LOT 3 

1/2C 1794 PCGS XF45 CAC 

C-1a, Large Edge Letters. A coin 

that deserves many WOWS! 

This would be a highlight in any 

collection of circulated grade 

early copper! To call this coin 

a “GEM” XF does not even 

begin to describe the quality; 

perhaps the only thing that will 

fully pass the message along 

is this: LAURA SPERBER 

LOVES THIS COIN! She is 

obsessed with it! First off, the 

color is even and light brown 

with golden accents at the 

periphery. You do not need a 

vivid imagination to see hints of 

surviving gloss. The details were deeply rendered by a strong blow from the screw press. Ms. Liberty’s tresses are boldly delineated 

as are the dentils, the letters, and the leaves on the reverse. The surfaces are hard and with a very strong glass revealing only minor 

contact from circulation. There is no porosity, corrosion, or environmental damage that usually plagues these early copper coins. 

Needless to say this coin is PQ+++ and is a real stunner! 

PCGS 27, NGC 13 CAC 6. Only one CAC-approved XF45 ever sold in auction, realizing $7,475 way back in December 2010. Clearly 

these DO NOT appear with frequency, or with this kind of high end quality. We totally believe that this coin will force the folks at 

Collector’s Universe to adjust their Price Guide value upward. Remember--an AU50 will cost $10,000 or more! 

PCGS# 1003 | ESTIMATE: $6,500+ 

LOT 4 

1/2C 1804 PCGS MS64 BN CAC 

B-11, C-12. Crosslet 4, Stemless. Presented is a highly 

compelling early half cent, a great coin not just for the 

specialist, but for the type collector as well. Lustrous brown 

surfaces are smooth and free of any distracting marks or 

flecks. Nicely struck up, the devices show a crisp definition 

on both sides, and the strike is even, which is not always the 

case for this die marriage. Hints of original red cling to the 

peripheries and some of the protected areas of the design. 

There are also accents of steely blue that come out when 

rotated in the light. The only mark of significance we can 

see is a small dig in the obverse field that is so old and toned 

over you really cannot see it without a glass. The eye appeal is excellent! 

PCGS 16, NGC 3, CAC 5. The last one to sell realized $4,560 in the recent 2018 ANA auction and one sold in February 2018 for $4,994. 

The present coin, which is clearly very fresh to the market will delight any collector. The current Collector’s Universe value is listed at 

$6,250 and it would not shock if this near-GEM came close. A 65 will cost $25,000-$30,000! Note: this coin is incorrectly numbered on 

the holder, it is PCGS # 1072 for the Crosslet 4, No Stems type, not PCGS 1063 (on insert) for Plain 4, No Stems. 

PCGS# 1072 | ESTIMATE: $4,000+ 

10


LOT 5 

1/2C 1829 PCGS MS64 RB CAC 

C-1, the only die marriage used to strike the entire mintage of 

1829 half cents. This near-GEM quality example has a full, 

vibrant luster with about 50% original mint red color that has 

mellowed with accents of violet. The devices are sharply struck 

up and the eye appeal is spectacular for the grade. 

PCGS 6, NGC 2, CAC 1. No PCGS example has sold in 

auction ever, while the last NGC coin sold in May 2003. The 

current PCGS Price Guide value is $2,600 and that really is just 

conjecture, as none have sold. The Newcomb-Green-Boyd-Newman-Missouri 

Cabinet coin, a PCGS MS65 RB CAC sold for 

$18,400 in January 2015. This coin will see very serious bidding 

from half cent collectors! 

PCGS# 1154 | ESTIMATE: $2,400+ 

LOT 6 

1/2C 1855 PCGS MS66 BN CAC 

Quality-wise, this SUPERB quality GEM is a near twin to the 

one we just sold for $2,233 in our September 2018 Regency 

Auction 28. 

Highly lustrous, medium chocolate brown shows accents of 

orange-red in the protected areas of the peripheries. There is a 

touch of a violet overtone that gives this sharply struck GEM a 

great look. 

PCGS 11, NGC 14, CAC 7. The most recent example was the 

one we just sold. for $2,233 and the current PCGS Price Guide 

value lists a value of $2,150. There are NONE finer in the BN 

designation at either service and this coin has an amazing 

visual allure! 

PCGS# 1233 | ESTIMATE: $1,800+ 

11


LOT 7 

L1C 1793 WREATH, VINE AND BARS. PCGS MS63 

BN CAC 

A marvelous fully CHOICE 1793 Wreath cent. An 

impressive Condition Census grade S-8. Visually one 

of the higher end examples of this R-3- variety easily 

identifiable by the horizontal twig on the branch of leaves 

under Liberty’s truncation and the triangle shaped bow 

on the reverse wreath. It goes without saying just how 

RARE these are in Mint State grades, especially so with 

CAC-approval and the amazing eye appeal that this 

coin possesses. 

Sharply struck on both sides, Liberty’s flowing tresses 

are distinctly defined, standing out with full 3-D effect. 

Likewise, the details of her profile are deeply rendered, 

with full definition in her eye, nose, and lips. Each bead at 

the border is complete and well centered on the planchet. 

The reverse design elements are also very crisply struck 

up. Both sides exhibit smooth, hard copper surfaces 

without any evidence of corrosion, pitting, or other 

environmental damage. A close examination reveals a 

single contact near the rim by hair curl 2. The coloration 

ranges from rich, milk chocolate brown to pale olive-tan in 

areas with pleasing golden accents that come to life under a 

light. The eye appeal is exceptional! 

PCGS 7, NGC 3, CAC 1. The most recent PCGS MS63 

BN to sell was in the 2018 Central States auction and 

realized $78,000 (it was NOT CAC). Prior to that, one sold 

in November 2008 for $115,000. Clearly these DO NOT 

appear with any frequency and the current Collector’s 

Universe value of $100,000 may well be exceeded when 

this beauty crosses the block. We know that early types like 

this will always command strong bidding from type and 

early copper collectors alike. What a wonderful coin for an 

advanced type set! 

PCGS# 1347 | ESTIMATE: $90,000+ 

12


LOT 8 

L1C 1794 HEAD OF 1794. PCGS VF35 

S-44, Die State III. Easily identifiable by the die crack on the 

obverse through the 17 and the one on the reverse that goes between 

STATES OF through the top of the wreath, into N 

of ONE. 

A very pleasing, mid-grade 1794 large cent in a highly collectible 

grade. The details are very well defined, and there are only the most 

minor of marks from circulation. The planchet stock is of good 

overall quality with just some minor micro porosity seen with a very 

strong glass on the reverse, noted for total disclosure. The naked eye 

appeal is very nice. 

The large cents of 1794 were struck from many different combinations of dies, creating a date that is very popular among the members 

of EAC to study and collect. Let this interesting S-44 start you off on your own specialized collection. 

PCGS 103, NGC 93. The most recent VF35 graded by PCGS was a S-65, struck on a porous planchet and showing more roughness to 

the surfaces than the present S-44, realizing $2,220 in April 2018; prior to that a PCGS VF35 S-46 sold for $3,360 in February 2018. 

The current PCGS value is listed at $3,300. 

LOT 9 

L1C 1794 HEAD 

OF 1794. PCGS 

AU58 CAC 

A “GEM” AU58 

S-65. While a 

relatively common 

variety, it is very 

scarce in such a 

lofty grade. For a 

1794 large cent, 

this coin is ever 

so close to a full 

Mint State grade, 

and possesses an 

extremely high 

end look. 

PCGS# 901374 | ESTIMATE: $2,500+ 

First, the surfaces 

are solid and hard, 

devoid of any serious pitting or corrosion that often comes on large cents of the 1790s. The details are fully struck up with crisp, clean 

definition in Liberty’s hair curls and facial features. Pleasing, even, medium brown with golden and chestnut highlights show off a 

lovely glossiness. There are no serious marks, ticks, or other issues that affect the overall eye appeal of this HIGH END piece. Very 

choice and extremely eye appealing. 

PCGS 44, NGC 12, CAC 7. This is the coin that sold in the 2012 ANA auction for $21,150. There really is a wide range of APRs for 

PCGS graded AU58s sold in auction, depending on variety, pedigree, and eye appeal. The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed 

at $15,000 which is a suitable average, and this one will yet again see bidding in excess of that level when the hammer drops. What a 

great E.A.C. coin for an advanced type or date set! 

PCGS# 901374 | ESTIMATE: $18,000+ 

13


LOT 10 

L1C 1814 CROSSLET 4. 

PCGS AU58+ CAC 

This is the FINEST 

CIRCULATED 1814 Crosslet 4 

graded by PCGS, and a coin that 

is just on the cusp of a full Mint 

State grade! 

The surfaces show off a wealth 

of glowing, frosty luster on 

medium brown surfaces. There 

are accents of burnt orange and 

violet-teal that come out when 

rotated in a light. The closest 

inspection with a strong glass 

betrays just the slightest hint of 

contact. This coin is of very high 

quality, not only for the date and type, but for the assigned grade. We have seen Mint State coins that do not have the visual allure of 

this GEM AU! 

PCGS 26, NGC 22, CAC 4. This is the ONLY AU58+ graded at either service. This is not a date that usually comes nice, even in the 

higher grade examples. Mint State coins are indeed VERY RARE and AU58s are always in demand. The most recent regular AU58 

sold in our January 2018 Regency Auction for $7,050. The most recent PCGS/CAC coin in Mint State grade to sell was an MS62 BN 

that sold for $10,575 over three years ago. Take this info and bid accordingly. 

PCGS# 1573 | ESTIMATE: $6,500+ 

OUR ESTIMATES 













help you! 

14


LOT 11 

1C 1814 CROSSLET 4. PCGS MS66 BN 

The SOLE FINEST certified in the BN category, this GEM 

S-294 is of exceptional quality in every way! 

For the date and type, this wonderful GEM retains as much 

ORIGINAL cartwheel luster as you could ever imagine, 

especially for a coin with the BN designation. Accents 

of brick red blend with rich chocolate brown, violet, and 

tinges of olive and apricot/rose. The devices are knife sharp 

on both sides. Each of the details in the hair, face, stars, 

dimples, and wreath are very sharp and fully defined. The 

eye appeal is superb. The final issue of the “early” large 

cents, the second to last Sheldon-numbered die variety. 

These Classic head large cents, designed by John Reich were 

rarely saved at the time of issue, and most are found in lower 

grades. Even those graded Mint State do not display the type 

of lustrous surfaces that this one has. This is the FINEST 

numerically graded in ANY color designation, and the finest 

RB is a 65+. PCGS has graded a total of ZERO in RED. 

This issue is so tough to find in nice enough grades that 

it was missing from the D. Brent Pogue Collection. We 

are pleased to present this extremely important 1814 large 

cent; suited for any serious cabinet of early copper or any 

SUPERB type set. 

PCGS 1, NGC 1. This is NOT the NGC MS66 BN from 

the Gene Gardner Collection sold in May 2015. Collector’s 

Universe lists a value of $90,000. This GEM has a great look 

and will see very strong bidding from type or Large Cent 

collectors wanting the very finest piece for their collection! 

PCGS# 1573 | ESTIMATE: $75,000+ 

15


LOT 12 

L1C 1820 LARGE DATE. PCGS MS65 BN 

A very eye appealing GEM from the Randall Hoard. Bold, 

copper luster shines from all over with an icy steel-blue overtone. 

There is so much RED we were surprised the insert did not say 

RB. Sharply struck from an extensively cracked obverse die. 

With its superb eye appeal, this coin really would make a great 

representative for the type. 

PCGS 158, NGC 127. The three most recent APRs are for CAC 

approved examples which have realized $2,280 to $2,400 and the 

current PCGS price is $2,350. This GEM, despite not being CAC 

approved will bring a strong price for its great look! 

PCGS# 1615 | ESTIMATE: $1,750+ 

LOT 13 

L1C 1827 PCGS MS63+ BN CAC 

Here is a very impressive 1827 large cent in wonderful CHOICE 

Mint State grade. Rich bronze surfaces show a brick-red and 

medium chocolate-brown with violet overtones. Lustrous 

surfaces show off sharply struck devices. The surfaces show 

a few tiny marks, none that are singularly distracting, and we 

believe PCGS was spot on with the 63+ grade. 

PCGS 45, NGC 7, CAC 12. This is the only MS63+ BN graded 

at PCGS, and it has not sold in auction. This is not the NGC 

coin that sold in January 2016 in a weak market for $2,233. A 

regular PCGS/CAC MS63 BN sold for $2,585 in June 2017 and in the same sale a PCGS/CAC MS64 sold for $8,225. The current 

Collector’s Universe value is listed at $2,600 and this coin should easily surpass that level when it crosses the block. This is a really 

great looking representative example. 

PCGS# 1651 | ESTIMATE: $2,700+ 

LOT 14 

1C 1858 SMALL LETTERS. PCGS MS65 CAC 

This is truly a gorgeous GEM with a stunning, totally 

original look! 

Impressive, radiating cartwheel luster rolls with a strong 

brilliance along the surfaces of both sides. The sharply struck up 

devices stand out against the smooth, defect free high end fields. 

Mostly a rich orange-tan with olive and gold accents, the eye 

appeal is very strong for the grade. 

PCGS 98, NGC 72, CAC 32. The most recent example to sell 

in auction realized $3,360 and the current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $3,800. RARE any finer, with fewer than two dozen 

graded finer. 

PCGS# 2020 | ESTIMATE: $2,800+ 

16


LOT 15 

1C 1856 FLYING 

EAGLE. PCGS 

PR64 CAC 

We are thrilled to 

have this high end 

and beautifully 

toned example 

of the first small 

cent struck by the 

US mint. 

Exquisite surfaces 

are generally 

clean and smooth 

overall. Nice 

reflective mirrors 

beam from all 

over, giving life 

to the wonderful 

swirling colors. Both sides have a even coating of totally original tan, pale golden brown,pale blue, violet, and olive that blend in a 

very eye appealing way over the smooth mirrored surfaces. Every detail is pinpoint sharp in strike and boldly stands out. The eye 

appeal really is exceptional! You will likely never see another one that has such a wonderfully colorful look! 

PCGS 218, NGC 122, CAC 54. The last PCGS CAC piece to sell in auction brought $21,735 in a February 2018 auction event. The 

current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $20,500. Since this piece offered here is so nice, we expect it to bring a little more. 

PCGS# 2037 | ESTIMATE: $17,500+ 

LOT 16 

1C 1871 PCGS MS65 RB CAC 

A vibrant swirling luster rolls with a strong brilliance on both 

sides. The color is a golden-brown with ample original red 

lustrous tones. Sharply struck design elements stand out against 

the smooth surfaces. The eye appeal is very high end and a 

delightful GEM for any specialist collector. 

PCGS 79, NGC 85, CAC 19. The current PCGS Price Guide 

value is listed at $2,500 and that is what the last example 

hammered for in our June 2017 Premier Session. A great looking 

coin like this will see spirited bidding for sure. 

PCGS# 2101 | ESTIMATE: $2,000+ 

LOT 17 

1C 1873 OPEN 3. PCGS MS65 RB CAC 

Just slightly mellowing from a blazing original red, the surfaces 

have an amazing mint bloom that glows around the reliefs. 

Sharply impressed from a deep blow from the dies, the details are 

nice and crisp. There is a minor mark hidden on the obverse, not 

noticeable to the naked eye. Very pleasing eye appeal overall with 

a great GEM look. 

PCGS 87, NGC 28, CAC 23. The most recent PCGS/CAC 

example to sell in auction brought $1,170 in July 2018 and in 

the ANA auction a NON-CAC coin sold for $1,560. The current 

PCGS value is listed at $1,550. The quality of the present coin 

will entice lots of bidding for sure. 

PCGS# 2107 | ESTIMATE: $1,100+ 

17


LOT 18 

1C 1889 PCGS MS66 RD CAC 

Brilliant, glowing coppery lustrous surfaces glow 

throughout this high grade GEM. Tied for finest graded 

at PCGS. The devices are sharply struck that stand 

out with crisp definition in the Indian’s headdress 

and the leaves in the reverse wreath. There are a few 

micro-flecks that can only be seen with a powerful glass. 

Rosy-red with salmon pink overtones, this coin has a 

great, lustrous look, worthy of its lofty grade. 

PCGS 16, NGC 1, CAC 5. The last one to sell was CAC 

approved and sold for $6,756 in March 2017 and one 

sold prior to that in September 2016 for $8,225. The 

current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $8,500. Tied for FINEST graded, this coin will fit nicely in any high ranking set of Indian 

Head cents! 

LOT 19 


We look at this coin with total amazement as to how it has 

survived 126 years in such a pristine condition. Plus, it enjoys 

its original GEM Mint red color. Exceedingly clean surfaces just 

amaze us. Even using a strong glass there are no imperfections 

anywhere. The surfaces also have a light satiny texture. There 

is a softer yet glowing type of luster. Miss Liberty and all of the 

details are exceptionally well struck. This coin has really great 

eye appeal! 

PCGS# 2174 | ESTIMATE: $6,000+ 

PCGS 19, NGC 4, CAC 5. The last 1892 MS66 RD to sell was 

NOT CAC and it brought $3,000. The current Collector’s Universe Value is $3,750. We can see strong bidding for this lovely GEM 

RED Mint State Indian Cent. 

PCGS# 2183 | ESTIMATE: $3,000+ 

LOT 20 

1C 1894 PCGS MS66+ RD CAC 

WOW! Did we say WOW? We could not believe our 

eyes when we first saw this coin. No joke, this coin 

looks as fresh as if it just came off the dies. Of course 

it is SUPER HIGH END and well worthy of its lofty 

designation. Remarkable surfaces are just that. We 

looked over this coin hard and there really are NO flaws 

or even microscopic problems. The luster is incredibly 

bold! We have never seen any pre-1895 as lustrous. 

Both sides are an incredible SUPERB GEM Mint Red 

color. What is more amazing, is how stone bold original 

everything . There is a super slight hint of some toning 

dots-really visible with a glass only. The strike is full 

and you do not need a glass to see all the Indians feathers. You do NOT need a glass to see the fullness of all the details. The eye 

appeal is beyond amazing! 

PCGS 40, NGC 12, CAC 12. PCGS has graded 7 in MS66+ RD and just one coin higher. We cannot find any auction records for a 66+ 

RD, though there is a Collector’s Universe value of $11,500. Note that while PCGS has graded a single coin finer, this coin is tied with 

the High Desert, Perfection 1, and Wright Collections, all ranking at the top of the PCGS CoinFacts census! Adding this SUPERB coin 

to your set puts you in very distinguished company indeed! 

PCGS# 2189 | ESTIMATE: $8,000+ 

18


LOT 21 


This coin looks like it just left the bank 118 years ago! Amazing 

surfaces are ultra clean and and smooth. Even when using a 

strong glass you will still be more then impressed as only a few 

pinpoint ticks can be found. A full glowing luster really makes 

the totally original GEM Mint Red colors stand out. There is 

a tiny toning dot in the date. Miss Liberty and every detail are 

sharply struck and have delicate frost. 

PCGS 151, NGC 52, CAC 26. PCGS has graded 30 coins MS66+ 

RD. The most recent example sold in our September 2018 for 

$2,530. The next step up would cost way more, if you could even 

find one! We assure you, this coin ranks on the very top end of 

the scale-the quality and eye appeal are unbeatable! 

PCGS# 2204 | ESTIMATE: $2,400+ 

LOT 22 

1C 1899 PCGS MS67 RD 

A remarkable SUPERB RED GEM Indian cent! Brilliant--no- 

-BLAZING red luster beams on satiny smooth surfaces that are 

devoid of contact on both sides. The devices are fully and crisply 

struck up with very strong definition on both sides. The eye appeal 

is superb to say the very least! This really is a MONSTER GEM! 

PCGS 26, NGC 19. There are only four coins graded finer at 

PCGS. The last one to sell realized $5,040 in a November 2017 

sale. The current CU value is $6,500. Keep in mind none of the 

MS67+s have ever sold in auction, and the last MS68 sold for 

$97,750 nearly a decade ago. This is one has a great look and 

should see strong bidding. 

PCGS# 2204 | ESTIMATE: $4,500+ 

LOT 23 


An AMAZING, blazing RED cent, clearly among the top twenty 

examples graded by PCGS. A glowing, flaming RED luster shines 

brightly on both sides. Sharply struck up with essentially full, 

crisp devices. The surfaces are without flaw, and the eye appeal is 

excellent. We suspect this coin came fresh from an original roll. 

PCGS 19, NGC 3. There is just a single 67+ RD finer. These 

used to be five-figure coins! Lately they have been selling in the 

$4,800 to $6,463 range; the most recent realized $6,756 in our 

July 2018, and the current CU price is $6,250.With just a single 

coin finer, anyone vying for a top tier Registry Set should bid 

fiercely for this impressive jewel! 

PCGS# 2207 | ESTIMATE: $4,500+ 

LOT 24 


We love this SUPERB GEM piece. It is way superior to the 

typical “low end or just made it” coins you will see. It excited 

us first look-then every look! Overall, the surfaces are clean and 

smooth. There are some light frost breaks on the left obverse. A 

booming headlight type ORIGINAL luster enhances the absolute 

GEM ORIGINAL Mint red color. There is one tiny well hidden 

toning dot to be found using a strong glass. All of the details are 

lightly frosted and sharply struck. 

PCGS 67, NGC 58, CAC 18. PCGS has graded 7 coins MS66+. 

The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $6,500. PCGS 

has graded only 2 coins higher with one selling for $19,975 in 

2013 (and it was a NON CAC). Also, the coin offered here has an 

Eagle Eye photo seal. There is very little copper fully endorsed 

by PCGS , CAC and Eagle Eye! This coin has the look and walk 

of a TRUE MS66++++, so if you are building the ultimate 1C or 

Type set, this coin is a “must buy”! 

PCGS# 2222 | ESTIMATE: $4,600+ 

19


LOT 25 


We can’t believe the looks and superior quality of this coin. It 

looks the coin just left the bank. 

Remarkable surfaces are incredibly clean and smooth. Even 

using a strong glass there are ZERO imperfections to be found. 

A surprising radiant luster does beam boldly from all over. This 

coin displays a wicked neat deeper reddish gold on the rims that 

opens into bold coppery centers. This coin is NOT turning and 

there are NO major spots or discolorations. Miss Liberty and the 

details are fully struck. The eye appeal is remarkable! 

PCGS 45, NGC 35, CAC 13. The current Collector’s Universe 

Value is $2,500. With this coin’s amazing looks, originality, and 

quality, we can see it selling for much more! Be prepared! This 

coin is far superior to your typical 1906. 

LOT 26 


This is a SUPERB 1908 cent! Everything about it today looks 

about as brilliant and RED as it did when it came off the dies. 

Sharply struck up, the devices show full, complete definition and 

the luster beams all over giving the radiant RED luster a fiery look. 

It really is hard to imagine what a finer example looks like! 

PCGS 108, NGC 34, CAC 25. There are 17 graded MS66+ RD, 

and two finer. The last one sold in the 2018 ANA auction for 

$3,360 and prior to that, these sold for $2,820 to $3,123. The 

current PCGS Price Guide value is $4,000 and any of the 67s will 

likely sell for $20,000-$25,000! A coin that is destined for the 

FINEST of Indian Head cent collections! 

PCGS# 2231 | ESTIMATE: $2,700+ 

PCGS# 2225 | ESTIMATE: $1,800+ 

LOT 27 

1C 1873 CLOSED 3. PCGS PR65 RD CAC 

This is a coin that will grade PR 65 RD every time! 

Deep mirrors are vividly reflective and beam from all over. Both 

sides are a SUPERB GEM original Mint Red. A few microscopic 

toning dots are visible-as well as a line of toning on the face 

(NOT a cut). Miss Liberty and every detail are frosty and are 

needle sharp in strike. The eye appeal is great! 

PCGS 33, NGC 6, CAC 6. We sold one in our January 2018 

Regency Auction for $3,878 and the only other PCGS CAC 

piece to ever sell in auction brought $4,112 in a November 2017 

auction. Add our nod of approval and you know this coin is as 

good as any GEM 1873 RD! 

PCGS# 2308 | ESTIMATE: $3,500+ 

LOT 28 

1C 1877 PCGS PR65 RB CAC 

A beautiful and highly reflective GEM. Indeed, if PCGS graded 

CAMEOS in the RB designation, we think this would qualify! The 

fields are highly reflective and have bold coppery mirror reflection. 

They are smooth and glassy with a brilliant sheen that is a delight 

to behold. The devices are sharply struck and stand out with 

impressive sharpness, standing out wonderfully against the smooth 

fields. The color is a beautiful mix of original red, golden orange, 

and accents of violet. The 1877 is one of the important key date 

issues in the series. While the mintage of 900 proofs is in line with 

other dates, the cost of a Mint State example has always put very 

strong demand on the proofs that other dates do not have. 

PCGS 82, NGC 68, CAC 30. The last one to sell realized $8,225 

in our May 2018 Regency Auction. Other examples have sold in 

the $5,000 to $7,500 range, and the current PCGS Price Guide 

value is listed at $8,000. VERY RARE any finer, this impressive 

GEM will delight any Proof Indian cent collector! 

PCGS# 2319 | ESTIMATE: $6,000+ 

20


LOT 29 

1C 1883 PCGS PR67 BN CAC 

When Proof Indian cents tone up like this, they are among the 

most pretty copper coins we get to handle. This one is SUPERB 

in every way! The surfaces are ultra smooth with bold icy 

sleekness. Hints of reddish gold can be seen among the overtones 

of wonderful violet-brown. The eye appeal is exceptional. 

PCGS 21, NGC 17, CAC 8. The last PCGS/CAC coin to sell in 

auction was the “Perfection 2” coin that sold in the 2016 FUN 

auction for $2,820. More recently a PCGS without CAC sold for 

$2,160 The current Collector’s Universe value is listed at $2,850 

and this one should bring well in excess given its amazing look! 

PCGS# 2336 | ESTIMATE: $1,800+ 

LOT 30 

1C 1883 PCGS PR67+ BN CAC 

We could see this coin one day in a PR68 BN holder, but no 

promises though. PCGS showed this coin NO mercy! 

Intense mirrors beam boldly all over, offering extreme clarity, 

remarkable cleanliness, and the reflection is so bold it can light 

up a room. If you twirl the coin, the mirrored fields look like 

a rolling wave of water. Both sides are a gorgeous and totally 

original brown/pale blue color. This coin has NOT been messed 

with in any way. Every detail is needle sharp in strike and has 

thick frost. The appeal is amazing! 

PCGS 26, NGC 18, CAC 8. PCGS has graded 5 coins in PR 67+ 

BN. Does not matter what the color, this coin is clearly one of 

the finest 1883 Proofs you will ever see! The current Collector’s 

Universe Value is listed at $5,750 and we think this coin will set a 

price record! Good luck! 

PCGS# 2336 | ESTIMATE: $4,000+ 

LOT 31 

1C 1884 PCGS PR66+ BN 

A beautifully toned GEM 1884 Proof Indian cent. Rich brick red 

in the fields meet with a wonderful teal-blue and magenta-violet. 

The eye appeal is SUPERB in every way! 

PCGS 39, NGC 29. This is the SOLE PR66+ BN graded at either 

service, and there are only a dozen finer in the BN designation. 

The current CU value is listed at $1,450 and this coin will attract 

monster bids from collectors of monster toners. 

PCGS# 2339 | ESTIMATE: $900+ 

LOT 32 

1C 1885 PCGS PR65 RD 

Here is a brilliant RED Proof 1885 Indian cent. The obverse has 

bright orange-red reflective mirrors that shine on with strong 

brilliance, while the reverse has richer, brick red accents. The 

sharply struck devices stand out against the mirrored fields. There 

are a few tiny micro specks that are noted, but none are singularly 

distracting to the very pleasing eye appeal. Housed in a first 

generation “rattler” holder. 

PCGS 20, NGC 5. The last three have sold in the $881 to $1,293 

range, and the current Collector’s Universe value is listed at 

$1,350. Rare any finer with just 14 coins graded higher in the 

designation. Totally fresh to the market, we anticipate this GEM 

bringing serious bidding. 


21


LOT 33 

1C 1885 PCGS PR65 RD CAC 

An awesome, bright red, highly reflective, GEM Proof! This 

coin’s mirrors are like a beaming headlight! Sharply struck and 

offering SUPERB looks, we think this coin is conservatively 

graded in its ancient first generation slab. 

PCGS 20, NGC 5, CAC 2. The last PCGS/CAC coin to sell in 

auction brought $1,528 in a June 2015 auction; prior to that the 

same coin sold for $2,115 in the Gene Gardner Collection sale. 

Worthy of a very strong bid, this GEM will delight even the 

pickiest collector! 

PCGS# 2344 | ESTIMATE: $1,600+ 

LOT 34 

1C 1886 VARIETY 1. PCGS PR67 BN CAC 

This coin is ULTRA high end! The fields have a bold flashy 

reflection that captivate the viewer. The surfaces are icy 

smooth and essentially flawless in every way. A rich underlying 

chocolate brown has a gentle overtone of violet and teal that is 

very attractive. We know that the original tissue paper that came 

with the original proofs can tone the cents this way. The eye 

appeal is just stunning! 

PCGS 16, NGC 3, CAC 1. There are only two coins graded 

finer. NO CAC approved example has sold in auction. The 

current PCGS value is listed at $2,250. The single PR68 BN graded by PCGS had very similar look and sold for over $10,000 over 

two years ago. We think this coin will exceed the PCGS price by a substantial margin! 

PCGS# 2345 | ESTIMATE: $2,200+ 

LOT 35 

1C 1909 V.D.B. PCGS MS67+ RD CAC 

An AMAZING example! Clearly this one is among the FINEST 

examples that survives from the first Lincoln cent issue. 

Amazing original RED copper color is magnificently brought to 

life with a glowing ember-like fiery luster. Boasting superlative 

eye appeal, this uber-GEM features fully struck devices and 

pristine surfaces. 

PCGS 238, NGC 88, CAC 59. There are 39 graded MS67+ RD, 

and there is just a single coin graded higher. We sold the most 

recent PCGS/CAC example that brought $3,960 in our August 

2018 Premier Session. The two most recent were NOT CAC and brought $4,560 and $6,000. The current CU value is $5,000. 

PCGS# 2425 | ESTIMATE: $3,200+ 

22


LOT 36 

1C 1909-S V.D.B. PCGS 

MS66 RD 

Bankroll FRESH! A beautiful 

original RED GEM! 

Bold swirling cartwheel luster 

rolls over this KEY Lincoln 

cent issue. A spectacular coin 

for any collector, the present 

coin is nicely struck from worn 

dies, you can see crumbling at 

the rims on both sides. Brilliant 

mint RED color has taken on 

some subtle and very attractive 

rose-gold tones. As expected 

for the assigned grade, the 

surfaces are devoid of any 

serious marks or flecks, anywhere. 

PCGS 234, NGC 38. The S VDB is among the most famous of all U.S. coins and always in demand, regardless of condition. 

Recently a small group was slowly submitted for grading, which included many pristine GEMS, this coin may well be from that 

holding. The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $9,950 and prices in 2018 auctions range from $6,200 to $14,400. This 

coin will likely hammer somewhere in the middle of that range. For many collectors, this date was the capstone in their sets; if you 

still need a GEM ‘09-S VDB, be sure to bid on this one! 

PCGS# 2428 | ESTIMATE: $6,500+ 

LOT 37 


This is an amazing looking 

SUPERB GEM! Rich fiery 

red color blazes with a bold 

lustrous gleam. This coin has 

such an awe inspiring look. 

Accents of gold add dimension 

to the depth of the beautiful 

red color. There are no carbon 

flecks or any serious marks 

worthy of mention, the eye 

appeal is amazing. 

PCGS 13, NGC 1. The record 

for the date is $21,850 realized 

a dozen years ago. More 

recently these have sold in the 

$7,050 to $9,400 range and the current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $10,000. 

PCGS# 2452 | ESTIMATE: $6,000+ 

23


LOT 38 

1C 1931-D PCGS MS65 RD 

Mellow salmon-rose tone is dusted over the brilliant red mint 

luster. Sharply struck, this gem has a neat look in its first 

generation PCGS holder. Lightly toned at the lower obverse rim, 

it is only noticeable at certain angles in a bright light. The eye 

appeal is neat! 

PCGS 157, NGC 50. The last two non-CAC coins sold for 

$1,020 and the current CU value is listed at $1,050. RARE any 

finer, this gem is a great coin for any budget minded Lincoln 

cent collector. 


LOT 39 

1C 1955 DOUBLED DIE. PCGS MS63 RB 

An original CHOICE Mint State Doubled Die cent. This famed 

issue has been a popular variety since its discovery and the 

doubling is visible to the naked eye. Housed in an early, first 

generation PCGS encapsulation, this lovely coin shows accents 

of red around the peripheries, otherwise the surfaces are toned to 

a lustrous steely-brown with accents of olive-tan and pale blue. 

Both sides are well struck and pleasing. 

PCGS 265, NGC 115. The last one sold for $3,720 in the 2018 

ANA auction. Prior to that, one sold in June 2018 for $3,600 and 

one in April brought $3,360. The current PCGS value is listed at 

$3,750. We anticipate strong bidding for this popular variety. 

PCGS# 2826 | ESTIMATE: $2,800+ 

LOT 40 

1C 1909 LINCOLN. PCGS PR66+ BN CAC 

This lovely, original GEM Matte Proof Lincoln is the second 

highest graded at PCGS! 

Rich medium brown surfaces show hints of original red along 

with accents of mahogany and aubergine highlights. This superb 

quality GEM is well preserved and devoid of any flaws. 

PCGS 19, NGC 4, CAC 7. This coin has never appeared in 

auction and is not the one that sold in our May 2017 auction for 

$1,350 hammer. Unpriced in 66+, it is certainly worth well in 

excess of the $1,500 listed in the Collector’s Universe guide for a 

66 BN. There is just a single PR67 BN graded finer in 

the designation. 

PCGS# 3303 | ESTIMATE: $1,800+ 

LOT 41 

1C 1909 LINCOLN. PCGS PR67 BN 

This is the SOLE FINEST 1909 Matte Proof Lincoln in the 

Brown color category at PCGS. The first year of the Matte Proof 

Lincolns, a series that was not appreciated at the time of issue, 

but today has a strong following among collectors saw a mintage 

of 2,198. The sharply struck up design elements stand out nicely 

against the sand blast surfaces. Rich brown surfaces are accented 

by a lovely teal-blue overtone. The surfaces are smooth and show 

no distracting marks or unevenness in the toning. The eye appeal 

is quite nice. 

PCGS 1, NGC 1. Neither this coin, nor the NGC coin have ever 

sold in auction. Indeed the finest BN graded 1909 Matte Proof to 

sell in auction was a PR66 BN. PCGS does not even list a value 

in its Price Guide. If you collect beautiful toned Matte Proof 

Lincoln cents, you need to bid on this FINEST certified example. 

PCGS# 3303 | ESTIMATE: $2,800+ 

24


LOT 42 

1C 1910 PCGS PR67+ RD CAC 

A mix of heaven meeting earth here. This coin is so wild it 

does not deserve to even exist! 

This coin looks like it was just minted! Phenomenal to the 

nth degree surfaces are fully satiny and bold matte like 

in texture. There is not a single imperfection to be found 

anywhere. A bold and glowing unbroken luster flames all 

over. The color is a stunning rich GEM Mint Red with 

highlights of pale gold. Lincoln and every detail look like 

they were carved out by a doctor’s scalpel. The eye appeal is 

so incredible we doubt you’ll ever forget this coin! 

PCGS 6, NGC 2, CAC 4. There is just one other graded 

PR67+ RD and this is the first one ever graded. It is MORE 

than worthy of its designation. The current Collector’s 

Universe value is listed at $53,000 and this coin brought 

$41,125 in our July 2017 Regency Auction. We do believe 

it should score a “runaway” price. Legend has owned the 

magnificent 1C 1909 VDB PCGS PR67+ RB CAC piece 

(universally acknowledged to be the FINEST of any Matte 

Proof 1C). This coin is the only Matte Proof we have ever 

seen that ranks #2 to that. If you are an advanced Matte 

Lincoln collector, or have been searching for an out of this 

world special coin, this piece represents an opportunity of 

a lifetime! 

PCGS# 3308 | ESTIMATE: $40,000+ 

25


LOT 43 

1C 1915 PCGS PR67 BN 

When Matte Proof Lincoln cents were left to tone 

naturally in the original tissue paper. We believe this 

SUPERB GEM sat undisturbed in the paper for a 

long time. The color is beautiful, with ample rosy-red/ 

brown color with accents of brilliant violet and aqua 

overtones. Sharply struck devices stand out against 

the impressive matte surfaces, which are FLAWLESS. 

Ranking among the FINEST graded, this impressive 

beauty will see fierce bidding for sure! 

PCGS 7, NGC 2. The most recent example, realizing 

$5,520 in the 2018 FUN auction did not have the eye 

appeal of this impressive beauty. This coin realized 

$7,500 in our May 2017 Regency Auction. The current PCGS value is listed at $10,500 and this coin should see very active bidding 

for sure! 

LOT 44 

1C 1937 PCGS PR66+ RD CAM CAC 

This electric coin really just arrests the viewer’s 

eyes! The look is simply AMAZING! We have 

seen modern proofs that do not look like this! 

This is a very high end and RARE CAM! 

Ultra deep, wildly reflective mirrors are the 

ultimate in clarity. The surfaces are spotless; 

there is nothing worthy of mention visible to 

the naked eye. The entire coin is an intense, 

totally original SUPERB GEM RED. Lincoln 

and every detail are fully struck and have 

thick, iridescent frost. The eye appeal is heart 

pounding! 

PCGS# 3321 | ESTIMATE: $5,000+ 

PCGS 32, NGC 19, CAC 13. There are currently five coins graded PR66+ RD CAM at PCGS. The last PCGS/CAC example to sell 

in auction realized $8,813 in our December 2015 Regency Auction. There are a mere four coins finer. This SUPERB GEM will see 

considerable bidding, and will probably sell for more than the current Collector’s Universe value of $6,250. Bound for a great set! 

PCGS# 83338 | ESTIMATE: $6,500+ 

LOT 45 


What a great looking SUPERB GEM! 

Brilliant, flashy, beaming fully RED surfaces blaze with intense 

clarity. Lincoln and every detail are fully struck and there is 

question as to this coin’s very high end eye appeal. 


value is listed at $2,250 and the most recent PCGS/CAC coin to 

sell in auction brought $1,815 in our July 2018 auction. This is 

another HIGH END example that will see strong bidding. 

PCGS# 3341 | ESTIMATE: $1,500+ 

26


LOT 46 


One of the FINEST examples of 

this WWII era Proof cent, that 

is surprisingly rare in such high 

grade. Most 1941 proofs have 

a very funky look from poor 

storage, and this one is tied for 

FINEST graded! 

The color is AMAZING, the 

surface quality SUPERB, and the 

overall look sublime. The ultra 

bold mirrors beam from all over 

with extreme clarity and brilliance. 

There is not a flaw anywhere to 

be found on either side. The eye 

appeal is beyond description! 

PCGS 10, NGC 11, CAC 6. In our December 2016 Regency Auction, the most recent example sold, realizing $14,688; only two other 

CAC coins to sell realized $14,100 in April 2016 and one realized $28,200 in November 2013. The current PCGS Price Guide value is 

$12,000. Bound for one of the BEST sets of Proof Lincoln cents and worthy of a very strong bid! 

PCGS# 3350 | ESTIMATE: $11,000+ 

LOT 47 

2C 1864 LARGE MOTTO. PCGS MS66 BN CAC 

Not your typical so/so 2C MS piece. This piece has lots of life 

and color. 

Incredibly clean surfaces are a joy to behold. We even used 

a really strong glass and found zero impairments of any size, 

anywhere. A strong luster shows off the wonderful and totally 

original GEM faded Mint red/pale brown/pale blue colors. Every 

detail is frosty and is sharply struck. The eye appeal 

is phenomenal! 


Value is $1,150. We can’t see why a GEM 153-year-old Civil War 

era copper coin is not worth at least $2,500. This coin will be a 

great addition to any GEM set. 

PCGS# 3576 | ESTIMATE: $1,000+ 

LOT 48 

2C 1868 PCGS MS66 RB CAC 

One of the FINEST in the Red Brown designation, with just a 

single coin finer. Lustrous surfaces have an exceptional light 

toning over the majority RED surfaces. The devices are fully and 

crisply formed from a sharp strike, and the very eye appealing 

color and luster combine to create a SUPERB look. 

PCGS 11, NGC 9, CAC 8. The most recent one sold in our 

November 2017 Premier Session for $4,290 and prior to that, 

there are records at $5,170 and $6,463. We sold the FINEST 

RB in our December 2017 Regency Auction for $5,758, a coin 

graded just marginally finer, MS66+ RB. The current PCGS Price 

Guide value is listed at $5,500. Bound for a great set, keep in 

mind a RED in 66 would cost $25,000+ and none of them have 

been approved by CAC. 

PCGS# 3598 | ESTIMATE: $4,200+ 

27


LOT 49 


A bold, beaming, brilliant RED mirrored GEM. Totally 

original surfaces beam with a strong reflective mirrored 

brilliance. The eye appeal is SUPERB and superior to so 

many examples we have seen. 

Only 600 proofs were minted. PCGS 46, NGC 14, CAC 6. 

Only TWO PCGS/CAC coins have ever sold in auction: one 

in $2,820 in January 2015 and the other in August 2011 for 

$3,738. This GEM is worthy of inclusion in any high end set. 

Good luck! 

PCGS# 3641 | ESTIMATE: $2,800+ 

LOT 50 

2C 1871 PCGS PR66+ 

RD CAC 

WOW! What a highly 

eye appealing and truly 

impressive PQ GEM! This 

beauty is tied with perhaps 

2 others for FINEST 

graded in the RED 

designation. Brilliant and 

fiery RED mirrors beam 

from all over! The mirrors 

are totally uninterrupted 

by any visually distracting 

imperfections. The devices 

are quite frosty and crisply 

embossed by an exacting 

blow from the dies. The 

eye appeal is very high 

end and will delight even the pickiest of collectors! 

Only 960 were struck. PCGS 21, NGC 7, CAC 10. There are 3 coins graded PR66+ RD at PCGS and NONE are graded higher at 

PCGS in the RD designation. The only other one sold for $12,338 in April 2016. We sold one in our January 2018 Regency Auction 

for $11,750. There is a record for a PR67 RD in a first generation PCGS holder that sold in the 2005 FUN auction for $51,750 but that 

coin is no longer on the pop report and we believe that it is now in a PR67 RD CAM holder. The current PCGS Price for a PR66+ RD 

is listed at $12,500 and that may need to be adjusted upward when bidding closes on this SUPERB GEM! 

PCGS# 3647 | ESTIMATE: $9,000+ 

28


LOT 51 

2C 1871 PCGS PR66 RD 

CAM CAC 

HOLY COW! One glance 

at this amazing GEM and 

you clearly see how it is the 

second FINEST GRADED 

by PCGS! All the technical 

qualities are there and the 

visual appeal is all there 

and then some! Stunningly 

flashy, bold, beaming mirrors 

dance and glitter in the light. 

The depth of the reflection is 

spectacular making the frosted 

reliefs pop in a full 3-D effect. 

The surfaces on both sides 

show no haze and only the 

lightest dusting of iridescent red-violet can be seen on the reverse. The eye appeal is stunning and this coin is truly a delight to behold! 

Only 960 Proofs were struck. PCGS 1, NGC 1, CAC 2. There is a record from August 2010 for one selling for $24,438. It is hard to 

tell from the photo if these are the same coin, but odds are quite likely that they are. There is one finer, a PCGS PR67 RD CAM, that 

last sold in March 2012 that realized $54,500. This remarkable GEM will be a highlight in any high end set. If all 2 cent pieces looked 

like this, they would be so much more popular indeed. 

PCGS# 83647 | ESTIMATE: $18,000+ 

LOT 52 

2C 1873 CLOSED 3. PCGS PR66 BN CAC 

The final date of this odd denomination also happens to be a PROOF 

ONLY issue. VERY flashy mirrors beam from the fields. Both 

sides show lots of ORIGINAL mint red that blend in with stunning 

blushes of magenta and violet toning. This is a coin where the 

color designation does not do the coin justice--there really is not 

much brown anywhere to be seen! The fields are ice-smooth, and 

close inspection does not reveal a single mark and only the most 

insignificant of microscopic flecks are found with the a strong glass. 

Only 600 examples were struck. PCGS 11, NGC 9, CAC 10. 

None are graded finer in the BN designation at either service. 

The most recent example to sell in auction was a PCGS/CAC 

coin that sold for $4,700 in June 2015. In this cataloger’s opinion 

this coin has a better visual appeal with much more original mint 

red color. The current Collector’s Universe value is $5,600 and 

these really are VERY RARE in such lofty grades. Be sure to bid 

liberally if you appreciate great color and eye appeal. 

LOT 53 

2C 1873 CLOSED 3. PCGS PR65 RB CAC 

This is a gorgeous, high end, fresh, and totally original 

coin-whew! Surprising mirrors beam from all over. The mirrors 

have remarkable cleanliness and clarity. The reflection is 

seriously above average and can be seen from a distance. Both 

sides are a totally original pale red/pale brown color. Only ONE 

TONING dot can be seen on the reverse. Every detail is sharply 

struck and has light frost. The eye appeal is super! 

ONLY 600 were minted of this PROOF ONLY issue. PCGS 112, 

NGC 61, CAC 42. The last PCGS/CAC piece to sell brought 

$3,878 in May 2018. Prior to that one sold in February 2018 for 

$4,920. The current Collector’s Universe value is listed at $4,300. 

We assure you, this coin will more than please the fussiest buyer. 

We highly recommend building a PR65-66 RB Proof Date set. It 

can be completed! 

PCGS#3652 | ESTIMATE: $3,600+ 

PCGS# 3651 | ESTIMATE: $4,200+ 

29


LOT 54 

3CS 1853 PCGS MS67 CAC 

One of the top survivors for the date! This coin is a SUPERB 

GEM without any question. This bold, GEM has just a dusting of 

totally original deep pewter and silver color on both sides of this 

satiny lustrous beauty. The surfaces are super smooth and mark 

free. Well struck and lacking the clash marks that so often plague 

this series. 

PCGS 14, NGC 12, CAC 12. There are only 3 coins graded 67+, 

and one is marginally finer. We assure you this coin is one of the 

finest examples of 1853 that we have ever seen-almost equal to 

the killer 1853 PCGS MS67+ CAC Ipswich coin we just sold for 

$8,518 in our January Regency Sale. If you think about it, this 

is a date and grade you rarely ever see. In our opinion, a coin 

like this should be worth $7,500-$10,000 today. Time will make 

it happen. No matter what, this is a great Type coin, or a superb 

example for a top level MS 3CS registry set. 

PCGS# 3667 | ESTIMATE: $4,000+ 

LOT 55 

3CS 1857 PCGS MS65+ CAC 

What a wonderful example of a date that is not so easy to find in 

GEM. We do agree fully with the + and consider this coin HIGH 

END! Impressive surfaces are exceedingly clean and smooth, 

even using a strong glass you can’t even find any ticks or hits. A 

decent and glowing type of luster beams from all over. Totally 

original cardboard holder type toning of russet/deep magenta/ 

navy/golden brown colors swirl all over. Every detail is sharp in 

strike. The eye appeal is terrific! 

PCGS 32, NGC 35, CAC 9. PCGS has graded only this coin 

MS65+. NO + from any service has ever been sold via auction. 

A MS65 PCGS CAC sold for $3,600 in November 2017 and we 

sold a MS66 PCGS/CAC in July 2018 for $10,281. If you are 

building a GEM Mint State 3CS set, Type, or just buy cool coins, 

this is a coin for you! 

PCGS# 3673 | ESTIMATE: $3,200+ 

LOT 56 

3CS 1858 PCGS MS67 

If there is one series that our founder, 

Laura Sperber has made a truly lasting 

mark on, it is the three cent silver series. 

Having built the top three collections 

ever of trimes, she knows how each 

date comes. This SUPERB GEM is 

remarkable in terms of its quality and 

eye appeal! 

The surfaces are pretty much perfect. 

Even using a strong glass the only thing 

you will find are mint made clash marks. 

A billowing, brilliant satin luster beams 

through the beautifully toned obverse 

and reverse. They are evenly toned with 

a deeper mix of blues, teals, reds, golds, and iridescent pearly silver. Every detail is fully struck and the eye appeal is very pleasing! 

PCGS 11, NGC 14. The last one sold in a weak market, at the 2016 FUN auction, bringing $16,450. Prior to that, a CAC approved coin 

sold for $21,738. The current PCGS value is listed at $21,250 and with just three coins graded MS67+ finer, which have never sold in 

auction, this SUPERB coin will delight any advanced collector demanding the FINEST! Good luck! 

PCGS# 3674 | ESTIMATE: $15,000+ 

30


LOT 57 

3CS 1860 PCGS MS65+ CAC 

WOW! Did we say WOW?! Because this coin is a serious WOW 

SUPERB GEM! While we will not make any promises, we see no 

reason why PCGS only graded this coin an MS65. The surfaces 

are absolutely immaculate. Even if you use a strong glass you 

will hold he same opinion. A strong glowing luster beams from 

all over. Gorgeous and totally original colors of pale olive/green/ 

gold/violet shimmer all over. There are no spots or discolorations. 

Most important, EVERY detail is fully struck and stands out. Yet, 

there is practically no die clashing which is unusual. Regardless 

the eye appeal is jaw dropping! 

LOT 58 

3CS 1864 PCGS AU58 CAC 

What a neat Civil War era trime! PCGS hit the grade exactly right 

on this one just the lightest touch of rub on the highest points, 

visible really on the reverse. Beautiful blue toning has a touch of 

gold at the center. It is not dark or dull in any way. Only 12,000 

were struck. 

PCGS 9, NGC 1, CAC 1. This coin brought $1,821 in the 2016 

FUN auction. A great “everyman” set coin! Good luck! 

PCGS# 3684 | ESTIMATE: $1,500+ 

PCGS 30, NGC 19, CAC 11. This was the NGC coin that sold in 

Sotheby’s for $2,750 in May 2018. The owner gives up. We think 

they should not (again, NO promises). A regular PCGS MS65 

CAC sold for $2,520 in November 2017. If you are very picky 

and demand high quality and gorgeous color-here you go! 

PCGS# 3678 | ESTIMATE: $2,500+ 

LOT 59 

3CS 1873 PCGS PR65 CAM CAC 

A Proof Only and FINAL year of the type. Wonderfully toned on 

both sides, the mirrors offer a strong reflection with nice clarity 

that beams through the lovely original patina. The frosted reliefs 

do stand out with a strong contrast against the fields. The quality 

and eye appeal are both high end for the grade. 

Only 600 examples were struck. PCGS 21, NGC 14, CAC 15. 

The last one that sold in auction realized $2,530, but prior to that, 

one sold in the 2013 ANA auction for $2,820. The current CU 

value is listed at $3,250. A great coin for the specialist collector. 

Very pleasing and totally original! 

PCGS# 83724 | ESTIMATE: $2,400+ 

LOT 60 

3CN 1888 PCGS MS65 CAC 

A beautiful GEM housed in a first generation PCGS holder. In 

our opinion this coin is undergraded (we make no guarantees) 

and is very high end. Billowing nickel-silver, pale gold surfaces 

have a strong luster amplifying the sharply struck up devices. 

The surfaces are high end quality and are virtually flawless for 

the grade. 

PCGS 75, NGC 61, CAC 8. There has not been a PCGS /CAC 

coin sold since 2012. The current PCGS value is listed at $650. 

The value nearly doubles in 66. This beauty is great for a type or 

date set of GEMS. 


31


LOT 61 

3CN 1871 PCGS PR67+ CAC 

BRUCE SCHER 

We can’t say enough about this stunning 

SUPERB GEM. It is the FINEST graded 

1871 Proof 3CN. 

Exciting deep mirrors are a joy to 

behold. The mirrors beam boldly from 

all over. They enjoy supreme clarity and 

cleanliness. Even putting a strong glass 

to the coin yields zero imperfections. 

The contrast is close to Cameo. Miss 

Liberty and the details are fully struck 

and do have light frost. This is far 

superior to the typical 1871 you will 

typically see. The eye appeal is tremendous! 

PCGS 1, NGC 1, CAC 2. This is the ONLY PR67+ graded. We don’t even see a Collector’s Universe Value for it. A 147-year-old coin 

like this in the ultimate state of preservation, in our opinion, should be worth closer to $10,000.00 (which is what this coin once traded 

for). Today, for sure, the market has chosen to overlook these. If you are building a SUPERB GEM 3CN set, this is a must have! 

LOT 62 

3CN 1872 PCGS PR65 DCAM 

A wonderful, deeply contrasted GEM with bold, reflective mirrors and 

well struck frosty devices. The mirrored fields are generally devoid of 

any toning and there are no serious hairlines or marks. 

PCGS# 3767 | ESTIMATE: $7,500+ 

Only 950 were struck. PCGS 2, NGC 0. While the Collector’s 

Universe value is listed at $4,250, there are no auction prices in PR65 

DCAM. This is a very rare DCAM--what a great opportunity for the 

advanced 3CN Proof collector! 

PCGS# 93768 | ESTIMATE: $4,500+ 

LOT 63 

3CN 1877 PCGS PR67+ CAM CAC 

This is an “out of this world” 

magnificent coin that is tied for FINEST 

graded. It absolutely is worthy of this 

lofty designation. 

Pristine surfaces are wonderful to see. 

Even using a strong glass there are no 

negatives. The mirrors are deep and 

beam boldly from all over. Plus, the 

mirrors are crystal clear. There are 

ZERO spots or discolorations. The 

contrast is bold. Miss Liberty and the 

details are fully struck and thickly 

frosted. The eye appeal is magnificent! 

PCGS 15, NGC 22, CAC 17. PCGS has graded only 2 in PR67+ cameo. There are NO coins graded higher. Of course, there are no 

auction records for either coin ever selling. There is a $12,000 Collector’s Universe Value. This is a terrific SUPERB GEM to that will fit 

in ANY high-end set. 

PCGS# 83773 | ESTIMATE: $10,000+ 

32


LOT 64 

3CN 1877 PCGS PR66 DCAM CAC 

This PQ PROOF example of this 

important ONLY DATE is tied for 

FINEST GRADED at PCGS! This 

remarkable SUPERB GEM has a great 

eye appeal! Deeply mirrored fields beam 

from all over! They are icy smooth and 

offer strong gleaming clarity and strong 

mirrors. Frosty devices offer a stunning 

contrast against the reflective surfaces. 

You can see the eye appeal screaming 

from across the room! 

Only 510 proofs of this PROOF ONLY 

date were struck. PCGS 3, NGC 0, CAC 

1. NONE ARE GRADED HIGHER. A 

PCGS PR66 DCAM sold in the 2017 FUN auction for $11,456. The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $9,775. Here is a great 

coin for inclusion in the FINEST set! 

PCGS# 93773 | ESTIMATE: $8,000+ 

LOT 65 

3CN 1880 PCGS PR65 CAC 

A gorgeous GEM with the look of an even higher grade. 

Pleasing surfaces show off very high end eye appealing 

qualities. Sharply struck, wonderfully preserved, we have seen 

coins graded higher that do not have the great eye appeal this 

GEM does. 

PCGS 388, NGC 360, CAC 43. These have just become way 

too cheap! What a great series to collect at today’s levels. 

Take a look at this coin and see what we mean by the great 

opportunity today’s market values present to collectors looking 

for a new project. 


LOT 66 

3CN 1889 PCGS PR67+ CAC 

A magnificent and SUPERB example with a strong eye appeal! 

Sharply struck throughout, the fields have a lovely watery 

essentially lustrous texture and both sides boast a delicate pastel 

iridescence that is just ever so gently dusted on the surfaces. 

The eye appeal is superb. The final year of the denomination, 

and very RARE finer! 

PCGS 73, NGC 51, CAC 35. There are a mere 3 coins graded 

PR67+ at PCGS and there are just two coins finer. NO PR67+ 

has ever sold in auction. The current CU value is listed at 

$1,550. THe most recent PR67 we sold brought $940 in our 

July 2018 Regency Auction. A non-CAC PR68 sold for $5,581 

in the 2017 FUN auction. This SUPERB coin should bring 

fierce bidding for those demanding perfection! 

PCGS# 3786 | ESTIMATE: $1,300+ 

33


LOT 67 

3CN 1889 PCGS PR67 CAM CAC 

We could not see this SUPERB GEM ever grading any thing less 

than PR67 CAM. Somehow, this 129 year old coin has survived 

in top condition. We consider that amazing! 

Bold mirrors have lots of flash with bold clarity and reflection. 

There is a faint hint of original lilac/gold colors. Sharply struck 

and frosty with a neat contrast and total original surfaces, 

imparting a great look. 

PCGS 25, NGC 12, CAC 20. The most recent PCGS/CAC coin 

to sell in auction realized $1,560 June 2018. The current PCGS 

Price Guide value is listed at $1,300. Only five are finer, with a 

single PR68 CAM finest. This will be a great coin to add to any 

GEM set! 

LOT 68 

5C 1866 RAYS. PCGS MS65 

Beautiful rings of rainbow toning forms a concentric almost 

target pattern that is enlivened by bold, flashy luster on the 

obverse and a frosty, satiny glow on the reverse. A few major 

die cracks on both sides show why the design was changed in 

1867. Sharply struck on both sides in most places though, there 

is some weakness which is natural in light of the hardness of the 

copper-nickel alloy.. 

PCGS 165, NGC 174. The last few examples to sell in auction 

realized in the $1,100 to $1,200 range and the current PCGS 

value is listed at $1,550. Very rare any finer, this first year of the 

nickel will be a great way to start off a Shield nickel set. 

PCGS# 3790 | ESTIMATE: $1,000+ 

PCGS# 83786 | ESTIMATE: $1,600+ 

OUR ESTIMATES 

The estimates you see published in this catalog are based on 

HAMMER. Keep in mind that a coin could be either low or 

high end for the grade, have stunning color or be dull, all of 

which radically affect a coin’s value. Yes, there can be huge 

price differences within a grade, and we offer estimates as 

a guide so Collector’s can have a better idea of value. One 

thing we will never do is offer low ball estimates in order to 

claim stronger sales. 

LOT 69 

5C 1875 PCGS PR66 CAC 

Wonderfully brilliant, reflective mirrored fields beam from all 

over, with a wonderful flash. Surfaces of icy blue with touches of 

light gold grace both sides of this chrome-like steely reflective. A 

strong glass reveals a few tiny flecks, but they do not intrude on 

the great eye appeal. 


example sold in February 2017 for $1,528 and the current PCGS 

value is listed at $1,300. Worthy of any collection of Shield 

nickels, a series that has come down in value a bit in the last few 

years, making it a great time to start a set. 

These published estimates represent what Legend Rare Coin 

Auctions determines to be an approximate high wholesale 

value for the coin. The numbers are based upon current 

market values, similar trades, auction prices, published 

prices, and a consideration of the coin’s quality. There is 

no guarantee that the estimated prices are minimums or are 

exactly what you can expect to get if you attempt to resell 

them wholesale. 

We always advise you to view the coins you are interested in 

and calculate what you’ll pay using as much information as 

possible. If you have any questions, please feel free to ask us. 

We are here to help you! 

PCGS# 3829 | ESTIMATE: $1,100+ 

34


LOT 70 

5C 1877 PCGS PR66 CAM 

CAC 

A borderline DCAM for sure! 

This is a PROOF ONLY 

DATE with a mintage of only 

510 reported--clearly this 

SUPERB GEM presents a 

great opportunity for anyone 

building a set! 

Intense deep mirrors 

powerfully explode from all 

over and are the ultimate in 

clarity, cleanliness, and of 

course reflection. If you twirl 

the coin it looks like a fresh 

sheet of ice hitting just right. 

There are no spots or stains. The contrast is stunning. Every detail is sharply struck and coated with frost that makes it look 3-D. The 

eye appeal is really what bold! 

PCGS 50, NGC 62, CAC 33. We make no bones about the fact our sister firm paid strong for this coin near miss DCAM GEM. It 

WILL mesmerize you! The current Collector’s Universe value is $6,000 and this coin is a spectacular example bound for any great set! 

PCGS# 83831 | ESTIMATE: $5,500+ 

LOT 71 

5C 1880 PCGS PR67 CAM CAC 

This coin is seriously above average. It looks like a little 

medal! We do not see why PCGS did not + it. 

Bold mirrors blaze from all over. The mirrors have 

exceptional depth, cleanliness, and are crazy flashy. 

When you twirl the coin the mirrors look like a freshly 

made sheet of glass. This coin clearly was never messed 

with. All of the details are sharply struck and are thickly 

frosted. The eye appeal is tremendous! 

PCGS 24, NGC 18, CAC 14. The last PCGS/CAC piece 

to sell brought $1,762 in September 2014! Hard to 

believe no others have sold in auction in the last 4 years. The current Collector’s Universe value is $2,000. Obviously, the pops are to 

be disregarded here. Opportunity knocks loud here! 

PCGS# 83835 | ESTIMATE: $1,750+ 

35


LOT 72 

5C 1907 PCGS MS67 CAC 

WOW! This is a true MONSTER 1907 nickel! 

EVERYTHING about it screams SUPERB GEM! In fact, 

we’re surprised PCGS did not + it (but this is what a real 

MS67 looks like). 

Incredible surfaces are mind boggling to behold. Even 

using a strong glass you will find NO imperfections of 

any size (zero flecks). The surfaces have thick satiny 

texture. A bold glowing luster beams boldly from all over. 

Mother Nature did an awesome job on this coin. She 

bathed it evenly with light flowing original colors of pale 

plum, lilac, and rose. No one ever tops Mother Nature’s 

work! Every detail is pinpoint sharp in strike. The eye 

appeal is phenomenal! 

PCGS 2, NGC 0, CAC 1. There are no price records 

of any sales for either coin. There are NO price guides 

either (that are correct). We compared it to a 1910 (also 

PCGS pop 2). The last one of those sold $25,760 in 2008! 

Legend Auctions is proud to offer this magnificent Mint 

State Liberty Nickel. It is worthy of the finest Type or 

Nickel Collection. 

PCGS# 3868 | ESTIMATE: $17,500+ 

36


LOT 73 

5C 1912-D PCGS MS67 

The FINEST certified 1912-D nickel at PCGS--NOT tied for 

finest, this is the SOLE FINEST--POP 1; NONE FINER! 

While coining operations began in Denver in 1906, it took 

six years until nickels were struck. Nearly 8.5 million 

were struck, and these are generally common in Mint State 

grades, even MS65. They become scarce in MS66 and it is 

UNIQUE in 67. This coin is truly SUPERB in every way. 

Highly lustrous surfaces show off swirling cartwheels on 

both sides. Incandescent yellow-gold, icy-blue, and rich 

orange-peach tone glows with extreme brilliance on both 

sides. We really love the color, and would rank it among the 

top 1% of toned Mint State Liberty nickels we have ever 

handled. The devices are very crisp in definition, with an 

almost razor-like sharpness. Needless to say, this makes a 

great example for the first Denver mint issued nickel! 

PCGS 1, NGC 2. Remember, that after 32 years of grading 

coins, this is the ONLY MS67 graded at PCGS. That should 

speak volumes as to how RARE truly beautiful SUPERB 

quality examples are! This is NOT one of the NGC coins 

sold this decade; and the current PCGS value is way too 

low! For a coin of this technical and visual quality and rarity 

at this grade, the sky is the limit. Expect this beauty to bring 

“beyond moon money!” 

PCGS# 3874 | ESTIMATE: $30,000+ 

37


LOT 74 

5C 1883 NO CENTS. PCGS PR65 CAC 

This watery-reflective GEM is totally original and FRESH to the 

market, graded 30+ years ago, and housed in a first generation 

holder. Lovely iridescent tone is seen on both sides, and the 

surfaces are clean for the grade. A lovely eye appeal. 

PCGS 310, NGC 249, CAC 31. The current PCGS value is $550 

and this one, should realize around that. A very affordable GEM 

Proof of this one year only type. 


LOT 75 

5C 1885 PCGS PR66+ 

Wonderfully reflective fields show a touch of swirling luster that 

glows on both sides of this GEM Lib nickel. The 1885 is the 

KEY issue among circulation strikes, putting strong demand on 

the Proofs to fill a difficult hole in a GEM set. A delicate golden 

iridescent tone gently caresses both sides.. The details show 

needle-point precision and the surfaces are defect free overall. 

PCGS 10, NGC 2. There has not been one sold since 2015, and the 

market has changed since then. The current PCGS value is listed at 

$2,300. Rare any finer, with fewer than 30 coins graded higher. 

PCGS# 3883 | ESTIMATE: $1,600+ 

LOT 76 


To sort of quote a favorite 

oldie song we love: “Ah sugar, 

sugar, oh honey, honey, you 

are my candy girl....” This 

coin for sure is a SUPERB 

sugary treat! 

Yummy, yummy, this coin 

has strong mirrors that 

beam all over. Even using 

a strong glass, you can see 

how delectably sweet and 

completely smooth and clean 

the surfaces are. Mother 

nature just loves her sweets! 

She created a masterpiece of 

delicious colors all over. Vivid and totally original shades of lilac/amber/pale violet/lime/light pearl green swirl everywhere. Miss Liberty 

and the details are needle sharp in strike and have delicate frost. The eye appeal is heavenly awesome! 

PCGS 3, NGC 1, CAC 3. The last PCGS PR 68 to sell was a NON-CAC. And it was forever ago back in 2003. That coin brought 

$14,375. Fast forward, these are impossible to find-especially with beautiful candy colors like this coin has. This piece will be a stand out 

in any GEM Type or PR Liberty set. Good luck! 

PCGS# 3898 | ESTIMATE: $9,000+ 

38


LOT 77 


A SUPERB GEM! Deeply reflective surfaces are clean, smooth 

and are deeply and brilliantly mirrored, and they contrast very 

nicely against the frosted and sharply struck devices, just shy of a 

CAM designation. Beautiful, reflective nickel-silver has a 

great look. 

PCGS 16, NGC 20, CAC 8. The most recent example realized 

$2,115 in June 2017. Just three coins are graded finer, only one 

of which has ever sold in auction bringing $3,600 in November 

2017. This beauty is very high end and will bring a strong price. 

PCGS# 3904 | ESTIMATE: $1,500+ 

LOT 78 


Highly reflective fields are icy smooth and ultra glassy. Sharply 

struck and fully frosted devices. Light gold and steely silver-blue 

tone adds to the high end eye appeal. 

PCGS 68, NGC 83, CAC 38. The most recent example to sell 

in auction brought $1,200 in the 2018 ANA auction. Other CAC 

approved PR67s have sold for $935, $780, and $1,380 in the last 

few months. A great looking like this should see very 

active bidding. 


LOT 79 


Beautiful icy blue and tangerine, emerald and gold toning is 

dusted over highly reflective fields and frosted, sharply impressed 

giving this GEM a superb look that makes it special in terms of 

eye appeal. 

PCGS 46, NGC 82, CAC 14. The last one sold for $1,064 in July 

2018, well above the current CU value of $550. This Premium 

GEM will delight any collector of Proof Liberty nickels. 


LOT 80 

5C 1913-S TYPE 1. PCGS MS67 CAC 

This coin is superb in every respect! Incredible surfaces are the 

epitome in cleanliness-to the point of sheer perfection. You can 

use a microscope and look for days and find NO imperfections. 

There is just one tiny tick hidden on the neck which could be 

what keeps this piece from an MS68 designation. A fresh and full 

booming luster illuminates light totally natural gold/nickel colors. 

There are NO spots or discolorations anywhere. Every detail is so 

fully struck you do not need a glass to see the fine points. The eye 

appeal is totally heart pounding! 


Value is $7,500. The quality of this piece should make it worth 

more! It is so far above and beyond the majority of MS67’s 

you will ever see. Opportunity knocks loud for the intense 

Buffalo specialist. 

PCGS# 3917 | ESTIMATE: $6,250+ 

39


LOT 81 

5C 1913 TYPE 2. PCGS 

MS67 CAC 

This is truly an ultra eye 

appealing and high end 

SUPERB GEM! 

Boldly lustrous fields yield to 

a light pastel iridescent toning 

when rotated in a light. hints 

of peach, gold and rose hues 

can be seen throughout. Fully 

struck, this first year Buffalo 

nickel has a superb eye appeal. 

PCGS 31, NGC 7, CAC 14. 

There has not been a PCGS/ 

CAC MS67 sold in auction 

since August 2015, where an example sold for $9,400 in the ANA sale. The current Collector’s Universe value is listed at $6,500. Only 

six examples graded MS67+ are finer, including the Angel Dee’s coin which we sold in December 2016 for $10,281. We anticipate lots of 

bidding action on this one! 

PCGS# 3921 | ESTIMATE: $5,000+ 

LOT 82 

5C 1917 PCGS MS66+ CAC 

A superb example of this early date Buffalo nickel. While not rare 

in an absolute sense, they are rare in SUPERB grades. A vibrant 

luster glows in the fields, accenting the sharply struck up design 

elements and bringing the pastel peach and teal tone to life, 

imparting a wonderful, original eye appeal. 

PCGS 211, NGC 49, CAC 42. There are 16 graded in MS66+ and 

the last CAC-approved example realized $1,560 in the 2018 FUN 

auction. Just two dozen graded finer, the current PCGS value in 

66+ is $1,550. 

PCGS# 3934 | ESTIMATE: $1,350+ 

LOT 83 

5C 1919 PCGS MS67 

No doubt that this impeccable SUPERB GEM is one of the 

finest graded 1919 nickels. Radiant, pearly, mint luster beams 

with a strong vibrancy on both sides. Sharply struck up on 

the obverse, there is a touch of bluntness noted on the central 

reverse, especially on the buffalo’s haunches. Pearly nickel 

silver and light iridescent hues can be seen in the fields, 

accenting the reliefs. A nice looking SUPERB GEM! 

PCGS 21, NGC 6. The most recent example to sell in auction 

realized $5,520 in the 2018 ANA Auction, and the current 

Collector’s Universe value is listed at $7,750. Only three coins 

are graded finer, all MS67+, the most recent of which sold for 

$17,038 in our December 2016 Regency Auction. 

PCGS# 3941 | ESTIMATE: $4,500+ 

40


LOT 84 

5C 1919-S NGC MS66 

An exceptional quality GEM that is tied for FINEST graded 

at either service! 

A remarkably strong strike for the date, this coin is highly 

appealing for the advanced buffalo nickel collector. Full 

and vibrant satin luster does not yield to any scuffs or 

other distracting marks. Fully brilliant with only a light 

hint of blue and russet-gold tone on the obverse. As fine an 

example that any collector could hope to acquire for their 

advanced set. 

PCGS 3, NGC 3. There is a single MS66+ graded finer 

at NGC. A major condition rarity in this conditionally 

challenging series. Most of the mint state coins are clustered 

at the MS63 and M64 levels, in MS65 the date is rare, and in 

66 as here, virtually unobtainable! This coin sold previously 

in April 2008 for $92,000! A PCGS-graded example, sold in 

November 2016 for $82,250. This is a major opportunity for 

the Buffalo nickel collector! 

PCGS# 3943 | ESTIMATE: $55,000+ 

41


LOT 85 


TIED for FINEST GRADED! 

Clearly this coin has been kept 

safe from any possible damage 

since the moment it came off 

the dies and boasts a wonderful 

eye appeal. The luster booms 

from all over accentuating the 

well struck devices. Except 

for some minor flatness on 

the Indian’s hair, every detail 

is bold and chiseled! A clear, 

icy-powder blue and soft lilac 

and gold tone adds to this 

coin’s SUPERB eye appeal. 


The Collectors Universe Price is $6,000, but this coin is so high end it should easliy bring in excess of that! If you are building a top set of 

Buffalo nickels bid liberally for this moose! 

PCGS# 3960 | ESTIMATE: $6,750+ 

LOT 86 

5C 1936-S PCGS MS67 CAC 

This is a lovely example of this late date Buffalo nickel. 

Billowing mint luster in the fields provides a backlight for the 

delicate pastel tone that can be seen as you rotate the coin. 

Sharply struck, only a few tiny lines can be seen with a powerful 

loupe, noted only for the sake of full disclosure. 

PCGS 94, NGC 24, NGC 17. The last PCGS/CAC sold for 

$1,323 in July 2018 and the current PCGS value is listed at 

$1,500. With only a half dozen coins are graded MS67+ as finest, 

this coin is destined for a high ranking PCGS Registry Set. 

PCGS# 3979 | ESTIMATE: $1,100+ 

LOT 87 

5C 1937-D 3 LEGS. NGC MS63 CAC 

A lovely, originally toned CHOICE 3 Legged nickel. Rose and 

gold accents are dusted over pleasing frosted surfaces. Nicely 

struck for one of these. An always popular and well known 

variety, it was created when a mint employee filed off some 

clash marks from the die, accidentally removing the front leg of 

the bison. 

PCGS 352, NGC 297, CAC 68. We cannot find a record of an 

NGC/CAC coin having been sold in auction since June 2014 

for $3,819. The current PCGS Price Guide value is $3,800. This 

key date issue is bound for a fine set! 

PCGS# 3982 | ESTIMATE: $3,100+ 

42


LOT 88 

5C 1937-D 3 LEGS. PCGS MS65+ CAC 

A fantastic GEM example of one of the most famous of 

all coins in American numismatics! Everyone has heard 

about the rare 3 Legged Buffalo nickel, a coin that is 

scarce in all grades, but in Gem Mint State as here, they 

are incredibly rare! 

This truly is a very high end coin, BOTH technically and 

aesthetically. The eye appeal is truly high end! A brilliant 

lustrous bloom accents the totally original iridescent tones 

that grace both sides. All of the details are sharply struck. 

LRCA is pleased to have been able to offer some of the 

finest examples to cross the auction block in the last year 

and half, including 3 MS65+, a PCGS MS66, and the 

PCGS MS66+ CAC. This one is, simply put, among the 

best looking of this magnificent trio of GEMS. It truly is 

that beautiful with only a few tiny ticks that prevent an even 

higher grade, and is more than worthy of its superlative 

grade and coveted CAC sticker. This popular variety was 

created when an employee of the Denver Mint discovered 

that the dies were seriously clashed. In an effort to remove 

the clash marks, the inexperienced worker took an emery 

board and without realizing removed not just the marks, but 

also removed one of the buffalo’s legs. 

PCGS 62, NGC 58, CAC 30. There are only nine coins 

graded MS65+ at PCGS. The most recent example sold in 

our auctions realized $43,475 in our Regency Auction XXIII 

(October 2017). The current PCGS Price Guide value is 

listed at $41,500 and needless to say, this is extremely rare 

any finer! 

PCGS# 3982 | ESTIMATE: $32,000+ 

43


LOT 89 

5C 1938-D BUFFALO. PCGS MS67+ CAC 

Everything about this high end SUPERB GEM is exceptional! A 

strong luster sets the beautiful toning aflame giving this sharply 

struck coin an incredible eye appeal! 

PCGS 2039, NGC 2569, CAC 198. In MS67+, PCGS has graded 

122, and NGC 32. The last PCGS MS67+ CAC sold for $960 in our 

May 2018 Regency sale and one sold for $1,410 (2017 ANA). There 

are only 33 coins graded finer and this coin has a very high end look 

and will not bust the budget--sounds like a great combination! 


LOT 90 

5C 1938-D BUFFALO. 

PCGS MS68 

A beautifully toned and 

highly lustrous SUPERB 

GEM example of this final 

Buffalo nickel date. This 

beauty sat unmolested since 

it left the mint and was 

able to acquire magnificent 

rim toning. Shades of 

rose, gold, icy-blue blend 

magnificently over the 

highly lustrous surfaces. 

Nicely struck up in the 

centers, the eye appeal is 

very high end. While not a 

rare date, it is certainly rare 

in this lofty state of preservation. 

PCGS 31, NGC 22. There are only two coins graded finer, both MS68+. The current PCGS value is listed at $7,500 and we sold 

one in October 2017 for $12,338 and one in December 2017 for $8,813. A great coin for type collectors or worthy of a superb set of 

Buffalo nickels. 

PCGS# 3984 | ESTIMATE: $6,500+ 

LOT 91 


We’ve actually seen several pieces graded higher that don’t look 

anywhere near as good as this! Superior, undipped, full matte surfaces 

are clean and have a bold luster. A faint, original, spotless nickel, rose, 

sky blue, and rich gold color is evenly spread all over. Every detail is 

pinpoint sharp and the eye appeal is fabulous. 


in the 2018 ANA auction. Another example sold in March 2018 for 

$2,040. The current PCGS Price Guide is listed at $2,750. With this 

GEM’s great look, we can see it bringing close to that figure! We truly 

love Proof Buffalo nickels, they do make a great short set to collect! 

PCGS# 3991 | ESTIMATE: $2,000+ 

44


LOT 92 


We love GEM Proof Buffalo 

Nickels especially when they 

look like this! This coin is VERY 

high end quality. This coin mixes 

BOTH quality with cool looks. 

Using a powerful glass, you will 

immediately see the surfaces are 

flawless. Not even a teeny speck or 

tick can be found. They also have a 

great Matte texture that is enlivened 

by a very strong luster. A gentle 

coating of light totally original pale 

lilac/ gold colors swirl all over. All 

of the details are sharply struck. The 

eye appeal is fantastic! 

PCGS 62, NGC 31 CAC 38. The most recent example to sell in auction realized $5,040 in April 2018. These certainly are NOT 

at their peak values! Plus, you CAN very much complete a set of these. Opportunity knocks loud here! 

PCGS# 3992 | ESTIMATE: $5,000+ 

LOT 93 

5C 1936 SATIN. PCGS PR67 CAC 

We are totally mesmerized by the high end look! What an 

amazingly toned SUPERB GEM Proof nickel, and while we have 

handled higher grade examples, the presently offered coin is truly 

memorable! Rich golds and blues, blend with light orange, apricot, 

and pale rose accents. Needless to say the eye appeal is exceptional 

and the technical qualities are all there and then some! 

PCGS 312, NGC 152, CAC 124. The last PCGS PR67 CAC sold 

for $1,920 in the 2018 ANA auction, and the current PCGS value 

is listed at $2,200. A great looking coin like this is worthy of a 

premium bid! 

PCGS# 3994 | ESTIMATE: $1,800+ 

NOTES 

45


LOT 94 

5C 1936 SATIN. PCGS PR68 CAC 

Virtually PERFECT, indeed to call 

this coin a SUPERB GEM just 

seems inadequate to fully describe 

its wonderful quality! The devices 

on both sides are fully struck 

up and crisply rendered from an 

exacting blow from the dies. The 

satiny finish is uninterrupted by 

any post mint issue, indeed both 

sides are without flaw. Adding 

to the allure is a light dusting 

of icy blue and clear gold that 

gently adhere to the otherwise 

shimmering silver surfaces. 

PCGS 45, NGC 25, CAC 15. The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $9,000 and these have sold in the general $7,800 

to $14,100 range. A great coin for any collection, and Proof Buffalo nickels make for a very cool “side project” in between 

collections or while you wait for that very hard to find coin still missing from your main collection. 

PCGS# 3994 | ESTIMATE: $9,000+ 

LOT 95 

5C 1936 BRILLIANT. PCGS PR67 CAC 

A fabulous example, this SUPERB GEM has a remarkable look! 

Vibrantly flashy, highly watery mirrors have a bold, gleaming 

reflection. Icy blue and clear gold frames the razor sharp 

devices and accents the wonderful mirrored fields. The eye 

appeal is superb. 

PCGS 166, NGC 100, CAC 94. The last two PCGS/CAC coins 

sold in the April 2018 CSNS auction for $3,120 and $2,640. The 

current PCGS value is $3,000. Very scarce any finer, and this 

SUPERB GEM is a great looking coin worthy of any set. 

PCGS# 3995 | ESTIMATE: $2,600+ 

LOT 96 

5C 1939-D REVERSE OF 1940. PCGS MS67 FS 

The epitome of perfection for an early Mint State Jefferson 

nickel. Impeccable surfaces show off a bold, billowing luster 

that blooms from all over. The devices are very sharply struck 

up and the details are completely visible. There is a minor 

tick or two that can be seen with a strong glass, but none 

are distracting or can be seen, but none are distracting to the 

unaided eye. The eye appeal is elevated by the dusting of 

wonderful clear-gold. 

PCGS 7, NGC 2. Only two have sold recently in auction, 

realizing $2,820 in January 2017 and $3,055 in October 2015 

and the current PCGS value is listed at $3,750. Only three are 

finer, all MS67+ FS and none have sold in auction, making 

this SUPERB coin one of the finest available to Registry Set 

collectors. Good luck! 

PCGS# 894005 | ESTIMATE: $2,600+ 

46


LOT 97 

5C 1944-D NGC MS68 FS 

The SOLE FINEST example of this date at NGC, this high end 

and very attractive coin is bound to be loved by any Registry Set 

collector. Sharply struck, NGC notes 5 Full Steps on their insert. 

Blazing mint luster booms on both sides bringing life to the 

delicate rose, gold, sky-blue, and icy silver toning. A very strong 

glass reveals a tiny tick or two, none of which are noticeable to 

the naked eye, nor do they detract from the SUPERB eye appeal. 

Worthy of the FINEST Jefferson nickel set. 

PCGS 4, NGC 1. This is NOT the coin that brought $3,290 in 

April 2016; this coin’s eye appeal is much stronger. This coin 

will see very strong bidding when it crosses the block and we 

anticipate it will bring more. Good luck! 

PCGS# 84023 | ESTIMATE: $3,000+ 

LOT 98 

5C 1946-D PCGS MS67 FS 

SUPERB! This coin has a look that far surpasses its grade! 

Exceptionally lustrous, beaming brilliant surfaces give both 

sides a blazing look. Spectacular rainbow toning at the 

peripheries show concentric circles of pastel toning. Shades of 

gold, emerald, topaz-blue, lilac, and rose blend nicely on both 

sides, suggesting long term album storage. You cannot beat this 

coin’s amazing eye appeal. 

PCGS 14, NGC 1. There are four coins graded finer at PCGS, 

all MS67+ FS. The current PCGS value is $950. Keep in 

mind that the most recent finer example sold for $2,585 in our 

December 2016 Regency Auction. Bound for an amazing set! 

PCGS# 84029 | ESTIMATE: $850+ 

LOT 99 

5C 1949-D PCGS MS67+ FS 

The SOLE FINEST GRADED 

1949-D nickel--the ultimate 

example for the Registry Set 

collector. 

Exceptional luster and strike are 

just a part of the total package, 

brought all together by the 

stunning rainbow toning that 

graces both sides. The eye appeal 

is simply SUPERB, and were it 

not for a few tiny ticks, this coin 

may well have graded higher! 

PCGS 1, NGC 0. This is the first 

time this coin is appearing in auction as a 67+ FS. This coin did sell as a 67 FS for $6,000, a record price realized in the last 

decade (in June 2008 one sold for $6,900). Collector’s Universe does not list a value in 67+ FS, and as the FINEST GRADED, 

the top ranking Registry collectors will certainly enter a fierce bidding war to take home this colorful prize! 

PCGS# 84038 | ESTIMATE: $6,000+ 

47


LOT 100 

H10C 1795 PCGS MS64 CAC 

Lovely! We marvel every time we see a small 18th century 

silver type coin in such a high state of preservation! 

This very eye appealing and beautiful, near-GEM LM-8 

is housed in an OGH. Bluntly struck on both sides, 

typical of the date, with some hints of weakness in areas. 

A light satiny luster blooms on both sides in the silken 

smooth fields. A pearly lustrous surface accents the icy 

blue and lilac accents that blend with the antique golden 

toning. Very original. 

PCGS 28, NGC 30, CAC 10. The most recent one to sell 

was the Gardner LM-10 which sold for a very strong 

$36,425. Prior to that one, this coin realized $22,325 in 

February 2014. The current PCGS Price Guide value is 

listed at $27,000. This is a great early half dime for any 

type or date collector, and worthy of a serious bid from 

the serious collector! Good luck. 

PCGS# 4251 | ESTIMATE: $25,000+ 

48


LOT 101 


LM-1. This is a very high end 

quality, fully CHOICE example 

of this early half dime. A very 

important coin for type collectors. 

The first thing that catches your 

eye is the highly appealing original 

toning that graces both sides. Classic 

old collection type toning, imparted 

by long term storage in an old 

envelope. Sharply struck up devices 

are accented by the olive-gold, 

russet-tan, and iridescent pastel hued 

color. Every detail is wonderfully 

impressed on both sides. The subtle 

differences in color come out when the brilliant, satiny mint frost catches the light. Close examination with a strong glass does reveal a 

stray tick or two which account for the assigned grade. The eye appeal is however very strong and high end for an early half dime. 

PCGS 19, NGC 2, CAC 7. The last PCGS/CAC example to sell was the Simpson coin, which we sold for $17,625 in our December 

2015 Regency Auction. The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $20,000 and these are very RARE any finer, and they 

rarely appear in auction. This is great coin for any type set or collection or early half dimes and will bring a very strong price when 

it crosses the block! 

PCGS# 4264 | ESTIMATE: $16,000+ 

LOT 102 


We have fallen for this GEM! The eye appeal is superior to so 

many examples we have seen in the market place. 

The sharply struck devices stand out with with a razor sharp 

definition against the frosty, satin glow that radiates on both 

sides. Adding to this jewel’s stunning look is the totally original 

covering of golden brown/reddish gold obverse toning and rose/ 

crimson/emerald tone on the reverse. There are zero flaws we can 

find, even when using a strong glass. Rarely do Capped Bust half 

dimes come this nice! 

PCGS 47, NGC 54, CAC 19. The most recent PCGS/CAC sold 

in December 2014 for $4,113 and before that, an NGC/CAC from 

the Newman Collection brought $4,994. The current PCGS value 

is listed at $4,350. The value will more than double in 67! This is 

a fantastic type coin or for a date set of Capped Bust half dimes! 

PCGS# 4279 | ESTIMATE: $3,500+ 

LOT 103 

H10C 1838 NO DRAPERY. PCGS MS66 CAC 

This truly is a resplendent GEM. Everything about it is totally 

PQ! 

Sharply struck devices are brought out by a superlative 

satin mint frost. Both obverse and reverse show a stunning 

polychromatic, pastel patination. Shades of rosy pink, teal-blue, 

and champagne-gold blend together over the satin smooth 

surfaces. You really cannot picture a more beautifully toned 

SUPERB GEM example of this early Seated half dime. 

PCGS 28, NGC 44, CAC 16. So much prettier than the last one 

we sold, which realized $2,938 in October 2017. Indeed, this 

GEM looks a lot like the pulchritudinous PCGS MS66+ CAC in 

the May 2017 Regency Auction for $6,756. What a great type or 

date collector! 

PCGS# 4317 | ESTIMATE: $2,600+ 

49


LOT 104 

H10C 1839 NO DRAPERY. NGC MS65 CAC 

A beautifully toned and well struck early Seated half dime. 

Everything about this coin is of GEM quality and the eye 

appeal cannot be beat. A bold mint luster beams with a glowing 

brilliance under a layer of amber, teal, and salmon coloration. 

Each device is fully formed from a precision blow from the 

dies. Housed in an old NGC “fatty” holder. 

PCGS 23, NGC 37, CAC 9. The last one to sell was a PCGS/ 

CAC coin sold in our July 2018 Regency Auction for $1,704 

and it did NOT have the exceptional, colorful look that this coin 

does. Worthy of a strong bid, the current PCGS value is listed at 

$1,600 and this coin, with its strong eye appeal will see intense 

bidding from collectors. Good luck! 

PCGS# 4319 | ESTIMATE: $1,200+ 

LOT 105 


A visually seductive little jewel! Everything about this half 

dime is immaculate and superb! A bold vibrant luster beams 

from under a dusting of rich, teal-cobalt and orange-gold 

toning. Sharply struck devices stand out with bold crispness. 

The surfaces are smooth and we cannot find a single tick 

or mark worthy of mention that would take away from the 

awesome eye appeal. 

PCGS 13, NGC 12, CAC 17. It has been over three years since 

the last CAC approved example sold, the Eliasberg-Gardner 

coin that realized $3,290 in October 2015. Prior to that, one sold 

for $3,819 in July 2014. The current Collector’s Universe value 

is listed at $3,500 and this coin should bring somewhere around 

that. We sold a 67+ CAC coin in May 2018’s Regency Auction 

for $5,405. A great example for a type set or for a SUPERB set 

of half dimes. 

PCGS# 4371 | ESTIMATE: $3,000+ 

LOT 106 

H10C 1859 NGC PR64 CAC 

A lovely toned jewel of a Seated half dime! Concentric rings 

of blue, teal, amber, gold, and coppery orange kiss the highly 

reflective mirrored fields. There a few tiny lines that keep the 

grade limited at PR64, but the eye appeal is very high end for 

the grade. 

Only 800 Proofs were struck. PCGS 75, NGC 63, CAC 14. The 

most recent CAC-approved coin was graded by PCGS and sold 

for $1,200 in the 2018 FUN auction. Prior to that, one sold in 

$1,293 in June 2017. The current CU value is listed at $1,500. 

Worthy of a premium bid. 

PCGS# 4438 | ESTIMATE: $1,000+ 

LOT 107 

10C 1805 4 BERRIES. PCGS VF20 

JR-2. Here is a pleasing collector grade example with even lilac 

dove and light silver-gray on both sides. Some light marks can 

be seen on the obverse, none of which are obtrusive or have a 

serious effect on the eye appeal. 

PCGS 33, NGC 9. The three most recent examples to sell in 

auction brought between $1,500 and $1,650 and the current 

PCGS value is listed at $1,800. A neat collector coin that will 

suit any budget minded numismatist. 

PCGS# 4477 | ESTIMATE: $1,350+ 

50


LOT 108 

10C 1832 PCGS MS65 

JR-4. Sharply struck, everything about this GEM screams 

originality and high end visual allure! 

Every detail is fully and crisply struck up, with razor sharp 

definition throughout. A radiating silver luster booms all over, 

giving this jewel a great look. Bluish and gold tones blend at the 

rims, framing both sides. While a strong glass reveals a few minor 

marks, but none are distracting from very nice eye appeal. 

PCGS 21, NGC 8. The most recent example sold for only $4,320 

in the 2018 ANA auction; prior to that, one sold in March 2018 for 

$5,160. The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $8,500. 

VERY RARE any finer, this GEM is well suited for any type set. 

PCGS# 4521 | ESTIMATE: $4,000+ 

LOT 109 

10C 1840 NO DRAPERY. PCGS MS65 CAC 

A beautiful and exceptionally well preserved GEM example of 

this early Seated dime. Sharply struck with a satiny underlying 

luster that brings out a beautiful pallet of color on both sides. 

Rich golden tone shows accents of amber-orange, pleasing 

purple, and olive hues that cover both sides with an even 

and gorgeous tone. Sharply struck up, the details are all fully 

rendered and this coin is truly marvelous! 

PCGS 7, NGC 11, CAC 5. This is a date that is surprisingly rare 

to find in auction, the last PCGS CAC MS65 sold in September 

2010! More recently a 65+ sold for $3,290 in the 2016 ANA 

auction. The current PCGS value is listed at $3,750 and with 

this coin’s awesome look, it should bring about that or more! 

PCGS# 4573 | ESTIMATE: $3,000+ 

LOT 110 

10C 1853 ARROWS. PCGS MS65 

A superior quality GEM, we are not sure what CAC saw that 

they did not sticker this one. The surfaces have a distinctive 

semi-Prooflike flash that gives them a sparkling brilliance 

around the sharply struck and frosted devices. A pearly-silver 

gold iridescent toning on both sides, giving this GEM a totally 

original look. 

PCGS 76, NGC 77. The last examples sold in the $1,000 to 

$1,763 range and the current PCGS Price Guide value is listed 

at $1,500. A great looking, short-lived type that will delight any 

collector. 

LOT 111 

10C 1874 ARROWS. PCGS MS65 

Here is a wonderful GEM 74 Arrows dime, with a satiny lustrous 

look. A delicate touch of gold glows in the fields. The design 

elements are crisply rendered and fully defined throughout. and 

the eye appeal is strong. Housed in an old green tag holder. 

PCGS 30, NGC 23. The last two coins to sell in auction were 

CAC approved, selling for $2,760 and $3,120 in July and March 

2018 respectively. The current PCGS value is listed at $3,450. 

Very scarce any finer, this one will fit nicely in any GEM type set. 

PCGS# 4668 | ESTIMATE: $2,500+ 

PCGS# 4603 | ESTIMATE: $1,000+ 

51


LOT 112 


WOW! Almost identical to the 

PCGS MS68 CAC we sold last 

year. This coin for sure is the 

epitome of what HIGH END and a 

+ means! There is no question this 

coin sat totally undisturbed for over 

139 years. 

Phenomenal surfaces are both 

satiny and have strong traces of 

semi-prooflike mirrors. There are 

no impairments to be found-even 

by using a strong glass. A moderate 

luster is enlivened by the slight 

flash of the mirrors. Both sides 

enjoy the ultimate in totally original toning-bull’s eye toning. The obverse has a gorgeous circle of aqua blue/violet that opens into 

champagne centers. The reverse has stunning blue/green/violet circular toning. Miss Liberty and the details are fully struck. The 

eye appeal is remarkable! 

PCGS 27, NGC 42, CAC 12. PCGS has graded only 3 in MS67+. PCGS has graded 3 in MS68. One sold for $25,850 in 2017. The 

current Collector’s Universe Value for the MS67+ is $5,000. Seems cheap to us. We doubt you will ever see more than a handful of 

ANY date Mint State Seated Dime surviving in such a pristine condition like this! Oh does opportunity knock loud here! 

LOT 113 


This impressive SUPERB GEM is tied 

with just a single other for FINEST 

GRADED at PCGS. Everything about 

this coin is GORGEOUS and high end! 

PCGS# 4687 | ESTIMATE: $4,500+ 

A radiant, satiny luster has a forceful 

vibrance. The obverse fields have a 

subtle prooflike flash, particularly 

around the date. Stunning pastel teal, 

gold, peach-rose toning dusts the 

surfaces, the various tinges of color 

coming out as you rotate the lustrous 

surfaces under a light. Sharply struck 

up, every device is fully and crisply 

rendered by a forceful blow from the dies. The eye appeal is very high end and you will be hard pressed to find a more 

beautiful example. 

PCGS 18, NGC 26, CAC 12. There are two coins graded MS67+ and none are finer. Neither of these have ever sold via auction! 

We sold a PCGS MS67 CAC (no “+”) for $2,585 in our July 2017 Regency Auction. An NGC MS68 sold in July 2005 for $5,750. 

The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $5,500. A great coin for a type or date set of Seated dimes. if you collect the 

FINEST, this is your coin for sure! 

PCGS# 4690 | ESTIMATE: $4,000+ 

52


LOT 114 

10C 1866 PCGS PR65+ DCAM 

One look at this GEM and there is no question to the DCAM 

classification! The mirrors are deep and beaming and offer the 

boldest of awesome reflection. The mirrored surfaces offer a stark 

contrast to the highly frosted and fully rendered devices. A light 

blush of the clearest of gold toning. We not a single obverse line 

in the field that would account for CAC not stickering this GEM. 

PCGS 5, NGC 2. This is the ONLY PR65+ DCAM at PCGS and 

there are only three coins graded finer. The last regular PR65 

DCAM sold for $2,585 in December 2015, while a PR66 DCAM 

sold for $9,200 in September 2010. A very eye appealing Proof 

Seated dime, worthy of any collection of CAM and DCAM coins. 

PCGS# 94759 | ESTIMATE: $3,500+ 

LOT 115 


Truly a spectacular SUEPRB GEM Proof Seated dime. The 

contrast borders on the ULTRA CAMEO, especially on the 

obverse. The sharply struck design elements are fully frosted 

with a cloud-like white frostiness and the mirrors are deep, 

clear, and beaming from all over. They have a strong headlight 

flash that is blinding when viewed in a light, really you will 

need sunglasses to look at this one! 

PCGS 9, NGC 8, CAC 9. There has not been a PCGS/CAC coin 

sold since April 2013, where one realized $4,700. That was five 

long years ago! The current Collector’s Universe value is listed 

at $3,500. There is just a single CAM graded finer, a toned 

PR68 CAM that last sold for $8,400. This stunning blast silver 

white SUPERB GEM will fit into any really high end set! 

PCGS# 84780 | ESTIMATE: $3,000+ 

LOT 116 


This SUPERB GEM is unbeatable in every respect. It has 

superior quality and is really rare. Deep mirrors beam boldly 

from all over. They are crystal clear, clean, and are loaded with 

nearly blinding flash. When you twirl the coin, the mirrors look 

like a flowing river of flash. Both sides are white with a trace of 

nearly invisible gold on the reverse. Miss Liberty and every detail 

are crisply struck and stand out with thick frost. 

Only 832 were minted. PCGS 3, NGC 6, CAC 5. PCGS has 

graded only one coin-a PR67+ CAC higher (it sold for $8,700 

in April 2018). An NGC piece just brought $3,360 in June 2018. 

It is our strong opinion, coins like this are grossly UNDER 

valued in today’s market. After 30+ years of grading by PCGS 

and there are only possibly 4 in PR67 and NO PR68’s? We can’t 

see why this is not a $4-$5,000 coin. Opportunity does not just 

knock here, it pounds deafening loud! 

LOT 117 

10C 1894 PCGS MS65 

A satiny, original gem with a totally unique look. This coin is 

housed in a first generation holder, and has a frosty luster and 

mottled, multi-hued toning that blends with the pleasing, pearly 

iridescent silver surfaces. We note a mark or two. The eye appeal is 

very nice. 

PCGS 30, NGC 20. Remarkably RARE any finer, with just a dozen 

coins graded. Two sold earlier this year, one for $900 and one for 

$1,020 and the current CU value is $1,050. 


PCGS# 84785 | ESTIMATE: $3,500+ 

53


LOT 118 

10C 1906-D PCGS MS65 CAC 

Bold lustrous surfaces have a strong gleaming effect in the 

fields, accented by crimson-orange rim toning imparted likely 

from storage in an album. The devices are crisply struck up and 

the surfaces are exceptionally clean, even for a GEM grade. 

PCGS 17, NGC 21, CAC 7. Only two CAC-coins have ever 

sold in auction: an NGC as part of the Newman Collection in 

November 2013 for $1,645 and a PCGS back in the 2008 FUN 

Auction for $1,380. The current CU value is listed at $1,500. 

Rather scarce any finer and this one with its great look will 

command a strong price. 

PCGS# 4839 | ESTIMATE: $1,200+ 

LOT 119 

10C 1908-O PCGS MS66 CAC 

Wonderfully original and pretty! Satiny lustrous surfaces glow 

from under a delicate dusting of an amber-gold and olive-russet 

hues that yield before the highly lustrous silver in the centers. 

Sharply struck details add to this coin’s great look! 

PCGS 10, NGC 12, CAC 7. While this date is very scarce 

in MS66 and finer, it is remarkably affordable--just goes to 

show how great a bargain the Barber Dime series has become. 

The last one to sell was a dull gray color that brought only 

$1,140. Prior to that, even non-CAC coins were selling in the 

$1,500-$2,000 range. The current CU value is listed at $1,650 

and with this coin’s great look bidding should exceed that 

amount. Note only 7 grade higher on the PCGS Population 

reports, making this GEM a great addition for any set. 

PCGS# 4848 | ESTIMATE: $1,200+ 

LOT 120 

10C 1899 NGC PF67 CAC 

A fantastic, classic SUPERB GEM housed in an early NGC 

encapsulation. Totally original, the richness of the toning comes 

out as you rotate the highly reflective, deeply mirrored surfaces 

in a light, the beautiful blue, teal, and rose hues show off the 

strong definition of the devices. The eye appeal is spectacular. 

PCGS 18, NGC 25, CAC 14. DO NOT let the population figures 

fool you, the most recent NGC PR67 CAC sold in April 2009! 

That coin sold for $3,738. More recently in January 2018, we 

sold a PCGS/CAC example for $3,055, which is well above the 

current Collector’s Universe value of $2,450. This remarkable 

SUPERB GEM will delight any Barber dime collector. 

PCGS# 4883 | ESTIMATE: $2,300+ 

LOT 121 

10C 1900 PCGS PR67+ CAC 

In the realm of Proof Barber dimes, there are GEMS and then 

there are SUPERB GEMS--this one is beyond SUPERB! The 

mirrors offer a bold watery reflection under wonderful pastel 

toning. Shades of blue, violet, teal, gold, peach and magenta all 

blend together beautifully. The sharply struck, frosted portrait 

stands out remarkably, giving this SUPERB GEM a great look. 

Every trait about this coin is worthy of its lofty grade and 

accolades from CAC. 

Only 912 Proofs were struck for collectors. PCGS 14, NGC 16, 

CAC 5. PCGS has only graded 3 in 67+ with exactly one coin 

finer in the designation. In 67+ PCGS has assigned a $4,500 Price 

Guide value. Worthy of a strong bid from an advanced Barber 

Proof collector. Good luck! 

PCGS# 4884 | ESTIMATE: $2,400+ 

54


LOT 122 

10C 1916-D MERCURY. PCGS VF20 CAC 

The perfect VF example! Really this coin just shows even, honest 

wear and is handsome and very pleasing. The eye appeal is 

exceptional for the assigned grade. Lightly toned over light lines 

on the reverse doe not detract. 

This is a classic key issue of the 20th century series and always in 

demand regardless of grade. This VF has a great look and will find 

itself at home in any budget minded set. 


in November 2016--that is two years ago and the current PCGS value is $3,600. 

PCGS# 4906 | ESTIMATE: $3,400+ 

LOT 123 

10C 1916-D MERCURY. PCGS 

MS63 

The key date of the Mercury 

dime series had a low mintage of 

264,000. A few coins were saved at 

the time of issue, but the majority 

went into circulation where they 

would stay until they were heavily 

worn. Any example graded Mint 

State is a prize for collectors. 

The present frosty and CHOICE 

example has a pearly-silver sheen 

with delicate gold accents. The 

strike is mostly there, just slightly 

soft in the central devices, which 

keeps this one from getting a Full Band designation. There are a few microscopic lines that can be seen with a strong glass, but none 

detract from the nice eye appeal. This is a coin that anyone building a Mint State set and needing this important issue. 

PCGS 18, NGC 12. The most recent example sold in auction brought $12,925 in July 2017 and prior to that a non-CAC example has 

not sold since the 2015 FUN auction, bringing $13,513. The current PCGS value is $18,000 and according to our data base, going 

back to 2005, the average APR for a 63 is nearly $15,000. This coin should see very active bidding. 

LOT 124 

10C 1919-D PCGS MS64 FB CAC 

With a mintage of nearly 10 million, the 1919-D dime is not a 

particularly rare issue, but with a full strike, that includes all 

three bands being split and rounded, this date is among the keys. 

Near-Gem quality, this lively coin has a rich mint frost that accents 

the sharply struck devices. Original, pearly silver are undisturbed by 

any serious marks or ticks, offering a strong eye appeal overall. 

PCGS# 4906 | ESTIMATE: $11,500+ 

PCGS 96, NGC 36 CAC 15. We sold the most recent PCGS/CAC 

example in our September 2016 Regency Auction for $3,878 and 

more recently a non-CAC coin sold in June 2018 for $4,080. The 

current Collector’s Universe value is listed at $5,000. Keep in mind that a 65 will cost $30,000+, making this an excellent value for 

any collector. 

PCGS# 4925 | ESTIMATE: $3,600+ 

55


LOT 125 

10C 1931-D PCGS MS67 FB CAC 

Everything about this fabulous Mercury Dime suggests 

perfection. The pristine surfaces have a satiny smooth texture, 

while a strong luster brings out the definition of the razor sharp 

struck devices. The lustrous surfaces are flawless and the eye 

appeal is as fresh today as it was in 1931 when it fell off the 

dies in Denver. 

PCGS 58, NGC 12, CAC 16. We sold a non-CAC coin in our 

January 2018 Regency Auction for $1,704, and one sold in 

April 2018 for $1,680. The current PCGS value is $2,150. Only 

five examples are graded MS67+ FB, this SUPERB GEM is 

worthy of any great set of Mercury dimes! 

PCGS# 4985 | ESTIMATE: $1,550+ 

LOT 126 

10C 1937-D PCGS MS68 CAC 

What a marvelous SUPERB GEM. It is indeed the epitome of 

virtual perfection! Highly lustrous surfaces show off a delicate 

iridescent tone that is totally original. Sharply struck, if it 

were just a touch stronger on the central band, this coin would 

be designated FB and would rank among the FINEST in that 

designation, as it sits, it is tied for FINEST non-FB graded at 

PCGS, and is the only one endorsed by CAC. 

PCGS 2, NGC 0, CAC 1. The other one sold in February 2007 

for $1,725. This one has not sold in auction that we can find. 

The current CU value is listed at $1,500. With a FB designation, 

this coin would be worth $3,000+. 


LOT 127 

10C 1938-S PCGS MS67+ FB CAC 

WOW! What else can we say when viewing this beauty! 

This is a SUPERB late date Mercury dime, looking a lot like 

those 39-Ds from that hoard. Rich red, orange, gold, magenta, 

olive, emerald, and icy silver-blue hues are augmented by a 

strong mint brilliance. Both sides are smooth, clean, and the 

devices are well struck. Even if you do not collect Mercury 

dimes you really should take a look at this amazing coin! 

PCGS 187, NGC 70, CAC 64. There are 14 in 67+ and there 

are only 6 coins finer. You can probably toss out the price 

guide values, as this coin rivals the eye appeal of the monster 

1923 we just sold. Worthy of a any set of MONSTER toned 

Mercury dimes! 

LOT 128 

10C 1944-S PCGS MS67+ FB CAC 

This is an exceptional Mercury dime. A common enough coin 

in MS67 FB and lower grades, it is scarce in 67+ FB and RARE 

in MS68 FB. A wealth of frosty luster glows below a dusting of 

peripheral golden toning. The devices are sharply rendered by a 

deep blow from the dies and the surfaces, as expected are satin 

smooth. 


value is listed at $1,250. This coin is worthy of a very premium 

bid from the specialist collector. 


PCGS# 5015 | ESTIMATE: $2,800+ 

56


LOT 129 


This is an awesome looking SUPERB GEM! Displaying full, 

beaming mirrored fields, the reverse is framed by a bold band of 

amber-honey gold tone. The beaming mirrors on this jewel have 

exceptional eye appeal, as expected for its lofty grade. 

PCGS 89, NGC 124, CAC 58. Prices have been all over the place 

for examples of this grade. VERY RARE finer, this coin is a great 

coin for any high end Mercury Proof dime set. 

PCGS# 5077 | ESTIMATE: $1,500+ 

LOT 130 

10C 1959-D PCGS MS68 FT 

Tied for FINEST graded, this 

SUPERB GEM has a look that is 

essentially PERFECTION! 

Very nicely toned, with bold, 

vibrant satin mint luster that brings 

out the olive-gold, icy-blue, and 

rosy hues on both sides. The eye 

appeal is totally original and even 

with a strong glass, we cannot find 

any flaws anywhere. 

PCGS 3, NGC 4. None have sold 

in auction. Other dates with similar 

populations have APRs all over the 

place. The current CU value is listed at $8,500. We can see many Registry Set collectors bidding this coin to the stratosphere. A real 

prize for the Roosevelt dime collector. 

PCGS# 85119 | ESTIMATE: $5,000+ 

OUR ESTIMATES 













help you! 

57


LOT 131 


Not only is this coin SUPERB in terms of eye appeal, but 

it is also top notch in terms of technical quality. It is one 

of the FINEST in the designation graded by PCGS, with 

just a single coin finer. 

Ultra deep mirrors beam from below a blanket of wildly 

iridescent shades of totally original blue, purple and rose 

gold patina. The devices are exceptionally well struck 

with an exacting crispness in the definition. The mirrored 

surfaces are essentially flawless and stand up to intense 

scrutiny. No doubt this monster GEM is one of the nicest 

we have seen! 

Only 600 Proofs were struck in this final year of the 

denomination. PCGS 14, NGC 22, CAC 3. There are 

three in PR66+ none of which have sold via auction. The 

current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $22,000 and 

there is no doubt that this impressive coin will surpass 

that level. A real prize for the advanced collector of this 

obsolete type. 

PCGS# 5306 | ESTIMATE: $20,000+ 

58


LOT 132 

20C 1875-S PCGS MS66+ CAC 

This is a wonderful example of 

this odd denomination in SUPERB 

GEM. Clearly this coin has been 

lovingly cared for for 143 years! 

The surfaces are of impeccable 

quality! Both sides are wonderfully 

lustrous with a lovely pearly hue 

that is dusted delicately over 

smooth fields and sharply struck 

devices. While there is a touch of 

weakness, as usually seen on the 

reverse, the definition is much 

stronger than usually seen on 

examples of this date. The eye 

appeal is spectacular for the grade. 

PCGS 77, NGC 51, CAC 21. There are 11 graded in MS66+ and just a half dozen graded higher. LRCA has had the pleasure 

of selling the last two in auction, one that sold for $9,075 in February 2018 and one in December 2017 for $9,694. The current 

Collector’s Universe value is listed at $9,950. Any finer and it would cost you $30,000; and none are CAC approved! Good luck! 

PCGS# 5298 | ESTIMATE: $9,000+ 

LOT 133 

25C 1806 NGC MS62 

A Condition Census B-9. Sharply 

struck devices stand out against the 

superbly satiny surfaces. The dies 

had shattered by the time this nearly 

CHOICE Mint State quarter was 

struck with multiple cracks on the 

obverse and numerous minor cuds 

on the reverse rim. Multiple die 

clashes. Beautiful hues of rose, blue, 

olive, teal, emerald, and gold give 

this coin a bold, original look. 

Ranking toward the bottom of the 

Tompkins Condition Census, this 

coin is ex ANR, July 2005, lot 1052. 

It is not listed in the Rory Rea, et al Census. 

PCGS 12, NGC 12. The most recent NGC graded coin sold in April 2015 for $9,400 and prior to that, one sold for $14,100 in 

November 2013. The current Collector’s Universe value is listed at $15,500. This wonderful looking coin will delight any early 

quarter collector. 

PCGS# 5314 | ESTIMATE: $10,000+ 

59


LOT 134 

25C 1835 PCGS PR63 

B-7, considered R-7+ as a Proof, with five known from 

this die pair. 

We are proud to offer this impressive early Proof quarter. 

Deeply toned with a dappled patina of golden brown 

hues with accents of lavender-dove and olive-tan that 

just sparkles when the highly reflective underlying 

mirrors catch the light. The rich patina is not too dark 

that it impairs the vivacity of the flash and clarity of the 

mirrored fields. The devices are razor sharp in definition. 

Upon close inspection there are a few grade defining 

marks in the obverse field in front of the profile, which 

serve as a pedigree marker. 

PCGS 1, NGC 0. The present coin is ex Lester Merkin, 

February 1971, lot 574; RARCOA’s session of Auction 

‘82, lot 717; ANR’s September 2003 Auction, lot 266; 

Heritage, December 2005, lot 607; Stack’s January 

2009, lot 317; Heritage, August 2013, lot 5577, where it 

realized $25,850. The current PCGS Price Guide lists a 

value of $33,000 and keep in mind that any early Proof 

quarter is a major rarity that is very under appreciated and 

under valued in today’s market; despite its more modest 

grade, this coin is a true American numismatic treasure 

that very few lucky collectors will ever have the chance 

to own! 

PCGS# 5383 | ESTIMATE: $25,000+ 

60


LOT 135 

25C 1838 NO DRAPERY. PCGS MS65+ CAC 

When we first saw this SUPERB GEM, our hearts raced. 

It is one of the BEST pieces we have ever seen for the 

Type! The quality is clearly VERY high end! In fact, we 

unhesitatingly state this coin is BETTER than the MS66 

that sold in Pogue for only $54,050 (and was NOT CAC). 

Had the Pogue coin been nice and CAC-it easily would 

have brought $65,000+. 

Exquisite surfaces are a collector’s delight. Only if you 

use a strong glass and look really hard will find a pinpoint 

tick or two and that is it. Overall, the surfaces are clean 

and satiny smooth. A glowing type luster illuminates 

the beautiful toning. Moderate and very pretty shades of 

totally original purple/gold/pale blue/deep champagne 

swirl all over. Miss Liberty and the details are frosty and 

are boldly struck. The eye appeal is seriously gorgeous! 

PCGS 3, NGC 6, CAC 3. PCGS has only graded THIS 

coin a MS65+. It is nearly impossible to find this date 

really nice like this. The last PCGS MS65 CAC sold in 

auction for $32,900 in June 2014. Even though PCGS 

has graded 3 higher-only ONE is CAC. We cannot stress 

enough the beauty and superior quality of this piece. If 

you are building a GEM Mint State Quarter or Type set, 

this coin will easily fit in! 

PCGS# 5391 | ESTIMATE: $32,000+ 

61


LOT 136 


This totally original SUPERB GEM is just outstanding in every 

way! If the toning were a little more colorful, we could easily 

see this coin grade MS67. 

Full prooflike mirrors beam all over. When you twirl the coin in 

the right light, at first glance it looks like a toned proof. Beside 

the PL, there is a good luster. Both sides are evenly covered in a 

totally original “old time” moderate mix of color. This is NOT a 

dull or drab coin. Miss Liberty and the details are sharply struck 

and have light frost. The eye appeal is excellent! 

PCGS 25, NGC 21, CAC 10. PCGS has only graded two in 

MS66+. Finding TRUE GEM coins like is NOT easy these 

days. GEM Mint State Seated coins like this are just too cheap. 

PCGS# 5523 | ESTIMATE: $4,000+ 

LOT 137 

25C 1884 PCGS PR66+ CAM CAC 

What a tremendous GEM! You can’t ask for a more “in your 

face” glittering mirrored coin! Superior deep, crystal clear, 

remarkably clean, and highly reflective mirrors are nearly 

blinding with reflection. The mirrors have that deep water 

“liquid mercury” like swagger you can twirl all day and never 

get tired of watching There is a slight hint of gold by the rims. 

. Miss Liberty and the details are thickly frosted and have full 

strikes. The eye appeal is intense! 

ONLY 875 were minted. PCGS 11, NGC 11, CAC 6. This is the 

only PCGS PR66+ Cameo graded. It sold for $4,113 way back 

in November 2012. A regular PR66 Cameo brought $3,055 back 

in April 2014. As you clearly can see, these do not appear in 

auction often at all. We think this kind of standout coin is really 

cheap and over looked today. Good luck! 

PCGS# 85585 | ESTIMATE: $3,500+ 

LOT 138 


A visually impressive PQ GEM that looks as fresh today as it 

did when it came off the dies in 1892. Representing the first year 

of this series, this blast white example is sharply struck, offers a 

bold luster, and defect free surfaces. The eye appeal is excellent. 


value is listed at $1,525 and the most recent PCGS MS66 CAC 

sold for $2,100 in November 2017; prior to that, one sold for 

$1,998 in the 2016 ANA auction. This is a PQ GEM that is 

worthy of any Gem set. 

PCGS# 5601 | ESTIMATE: $1,100+ 

LOT 139 


An amazing GEM example of this first year of issue. We have 

looked this coin over and over and cannot find anything that 

should keep it out of an even higher grade. Perhaps if the satin 

luster was a touch more vibrant it would grade higher. Generous 

amounts of pastel iridescent toning graces both sides of this Type 

2 Reverse quarter. 

PCGS 131, NGC 86, CAC 59. There are 14 coins graded 66+ 

at PCGS, and the last one two to sell in auction were in LRCA 

sales: $2,035 in July 2018 and $2,510 in May 2018. The current 

PCGS value is listed at $2,650. The eye appeal of this GEM 

will delight any collector and may inspire a new collector to 

embark on building a set! 

PCGS# 5601 | ESTIMATE: $1,800+ 

62

LOT 140 

25C 1892-O PCGS MS67 

While somewhat common in Mint 

State, this SUPERB GEM is tied 

for second FINEST graded, bested 

by only a single MS67+ (which is 

housed in the R.S.D. Collection, 

built by a collector client of 

Legend Numismatics). 


We are proud to offer this beauty, 

which is one of only four graded 

MS67. Well struck and boldly 

lustrous, this coin is virtually 

flawless. The satiny surfaces have a 

semi-reflective flash and the crisply 

struck devices stand out with a nice 

contrast. Light iridescent toning attests to the originality of this impressive Barber quarter. We note only one tiny tick in the center 

of the obverse, totally unobtrusive and does not affect the amazing eye appeal. 

PCGS 4, NGC 1. The last NON-CAC coin to sell in auction was sold 19 years ago--nearly TWO DECADES ago! More recently a 

PCGS/CAC coin sold for $9,106 in October 2015. The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $11,800. With the sole FINEST 

now impounded in an important collection, this will likely be the FINEST available to collectors for quite some time! Good luck! 

PCGS# 5602 | ESTIMATE: $6,500+ 

LOT 141 

25C 1898-O PCGS MS64 CAC 

This is a totally original, high end example for the grade. 

Rich autumnal toning is brought out by a flashy brilliant mint 

luster. The details are fully struck up and have full definition. 

A strong glass does not reveal even the slightest mark or tick, 

and we think if the obverse luster was a touch more lustrous we 

would not flinch if it was housed in a higher grade holder (no 

guarantees). 

PCGS 16, NGC 9, CAC 6. The most recent example to sell in 

auction realized $2,640 in the 2018 ANA auction. Five years 

have passed between that coin selling and the one prior to that, 

which realized $2,703 in the 2013 ANA auction. The current 

Collector’s Universe value is listed at $3,400. This is a VERY 

RARE date any finer, so a high end 64 like this will delight any 

Barber collector who wants a CAC approved example that does 

not want to spend $10,000+ for a CAC MS66. 

LOT 142 


Wow! What an amazing, totally original SUPERB GEM! 

A bold luster has a bold and brilliantly strong satin frost that 

brings out the wonderful peach-gold and lavender toning. 

Generally well struck throughout and the surfaces are extremely 

clean. The eye appeal is exceptional and really does stand out! 

PCGS 30, NGC 5, CAC 8. This is just one of two graded 

MS66+ at PCGS and it sold for $4,230 in June 2016. 

EXTREMELY RARE any finer, with just three coins graded 

MS67 at PCGS. This coin will attract extreme interest from 

advanced Barber quarter collectors--if you are building a set, 

prepare to bid liberally! 

PCGS# 5631 | ESTIMATE: $3,600+ 

PCGS# 5620 | ESTIMATE: $2,400+ 

63


LOT 143 

25C 1892 PCGS PR65+ DCAM CAC 

You WILL need a pair of Ray Bans to view this MONSTER 

with. The coin is also SUPER HIGH END! If this has been in a 

PR66 DC holder we would no have flinched. PCGS showed NO 

mercy on this coin. The mirrors are deeper than most DCAM 

coins. They do intensely beam from all over, and are crystal clear 

and are super clean. Only using a really strong glass can you find 

a few stray lines. The contrast is way off the charts! Miss Liberty 

and every detail are fully and are thickly frosted and iridescent 

white. It looks like he features were carved from a frozen block 

of ice. The eye appeal is insane! 

PCGS 3, NGC 1, CAC 3. PCGS has graded only this coin in 

PR 65+ DCAM. It has never been sold via auction. Another 

interesting note: NO PR66 DCAM has ever been sold via 

auction. The current Collector’s Universe Value is only $3,200. 

We know the market will set the price for this MONSTER. The 

intense Black and White look matches what you see on PR68’s! 

Seeing IS believing. Good luck! 

LOT 144 


This is an unquestionable SUPERB GEM that is totally original. 

Strong mirrors beam from both sides. The mirrors are perfect, 

have great clarity, and are nicely reflective. If you twirl the coin 

the mirrors look like a freshly made sheet of glass. The obverse 

has a moderate mix of totally original deep evergreen/blue 

while the reverse is a more muted purple/blue/green (probably 

from sitting on felt). Miss Liberty and the details are frosty and 

have needle sharp strikes. The eye appeal is excellent! 

ONLY 777 were minted. PCGS 9, NGC 16, CAC 10 (we 

believe there are some repeats). The last PR67 to sell at auction 

brought $3,120 in August 2018. The current PCGS Price Guide 

value is listed at $5,250 and there are just two coins finer, none 

of which have ever sold. NOTE: these are NOT common at all. 

This date is a silent stopper in any Barber series in proof. 

PCGS# 5688 | ESTIMATE: $2,800+ 

PCGS# 95678 | ESTIMATE: $3,000+ 

LOT 145 


A truly SUPER nice and VERY HIGH END 

SUPERB GEM! 

Superb mirrors are bold and do flash from all 

over. The mirrors do have great clarity and 

cleanliness. Technically, this coin could grade 

PR68 (we make NO promises). When you twirl 

this coin you do see some rolling flash. Both 

sides have a moderate mix of lavender/gold/ 

silver colors-all totally original. Miss Liberty 

and the details are fully struck and have delicate 

frost. There is some light contrast (note: PCGS 

has NO Cameo’s graded in PR66 or finer). The 

eye appeal is very nice!ONLY 675 were minted. 

PCGS 22, NGC 29, CAC 18. PCGS has graded 4 in PR67+. How cheap is too cheap? This coin is waaaay too cheap! This should 

be a $5,000++ coin. The Collector’s Universe is still at $5,000-which in our opinion seems totally correct. We think this coin “fell 

through the cracks”. Legend Numismatics bought his coin from a dealer, not any auction.We cannot stress enough the extreme 

great value this coin offers. 

PCGS# 5692 | ESTIMATE: $3,500+ 

64


LOT 146 


This is a fully mirrored HIGH END GEM Proof. Deep and 

almost endless mirrors beam from all over. The mirrors dance 

with supreme clarity and cleanliness. They do borderline ultra 

deep. Both sides have light original and peripheral splashes of 

green/gold/russet colors. The contrast is dramatic. Miss Liberty 

and the details are needle sharp in strike and are covered by 

sugary white frost. The eye appeal is tremendous! 

ONLY 551 minted. PCGS 22, NGC 9, CAC 7. The last PCGS 

CAC piece to sell in auction brought only $1,762.50 in March 

2017. Prior to that you had to go all the way back to 2010 where 

one sold for $2,585. With only 551 minted, these are NOT 

nearly as easy to find as you think. In our opinion they have 

become way too cheap. Opportunity Knocks loud here! 

PCGS# 85696 | ESTIMATE: $1,700+ 

LOT 147 


A visually impressive SUPERB GEM! Everything about this 

coin is high end and the eye appeal is tremendous! 

Soft iridescent toning is dusted over watery mirrored fields. The 

tone is pretty and original, and even on the reverse, while the 

obverse is a touch more mottled. The strike is razor sharp and 

the eye appeal bold. 

Only 380 were struck, the lowest mintage of the series. PCGS 

15, NGC 14, CAC 9. Surprisingly enough these do not seem to 

bring a premium. This coin matches the toning pattern on the 

Eric Newman Collection coin that sold for $4,406 as an NGC/ 

CAC coin in November 2013. NOTE: NO PCGS/CAC coin has 

ever sold in auction! Only five coins are graded finer at PCGS, 

making this a true prize for any high ranking set. 

PCGS# 5700 | ESTIMATE: $3,750+ 

LOT 148 

25C 1916 STANDING LIBERTY. 

PCGS AU53 CAC 

One of the most popular KEY 

date issues of the 20th century, the 

1916 Standing Liberty quarter was 

struck to the tune of only 52,000, all 

produced in December 1916. The 

first design featured a bare breasted 

Liberty, which was changed part 

way through 1917, where she was 

covered up with chain mail. 

In demand from collectors in all 

grades, this very pleasing, totally 

original AU53 has a great look. Well 

struck, only the slightest hint of 

friction appears on the highest points. A delicate golden tone clings to both sides, attesting to originality and adds to the visual allure. 

PCGS 51, NGC 14, CAC 7. The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $11,000 and the last PCGS/CAC AU53 sold in our July 

2018 Regency Auction for $9,694 . This example has a similar look and is worthy of a strong bid for sure! 

PCGS# 5704 | ESTIMATE: $9,000+ 

65


LOT 149 

25C 1916 

STANDING 

LIBERTY. PCGS 

AU58 CAC 

With just a touch of 

rub on the highest 

points of the design 

elements, this totally 

original example 

of the first year of 

Standing Liberty 

quarter has a superb 

look. Boasting 

nearly fully lustrous 

surfaces, both 

sides have a lovely 

dusting of iridescent 

pastel toning. This 

eye appealing example is amazing. With only 52,000 struck, this super-slider has a great look, that is NOT your typical dipped and 

stripped AU coin. 

PCGS 122, NGC 57, CAC 19. The most recent example to sell in auction realized $11,163 in our January 2018 Regency Auction. 

The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $13,000. The last MS60 sold in January 2013 for $14,100. This remarkable coin 

will look great in any set of high end Standing Liberty quarters. 

PCGS# 5704 | ESTIMATE: $9,500+ 

LOT 150 

25C 1919-D PCGS MS63 FH 

An important Condition Rarity! VERY 

RARE in CHOICE or finer grades with 

Full Head definition. Sharply struck 

details throughout. Brilliant white 

luster gleams with a light steely-pewter 

overtone on the reverse. The eye appeal 

is very nice. 

PCGS 20, NGC 2. The most recent 

example sold in the 2017 ANA auction 

for $7,638. The current PCGS value is 

listed at $7,500 and keep in mind that 

a 64 would cost $16,000-$18,000! This 

exceptional example will see strong 

bidding for sure. 

PCGS# 5731 | ESTIMATE: $6,500+ 

66


LOT 151 

25C 1919-S PCGS MS62 FH 

In our opinion, we do not know why 

this coin is “only” a 62, and why 

CAC did not approve it is beyond us. 

For a coin of such a modest grade, 

the eye appeal is amazing. Sharply 

struck throughout, this coin has FULL 

head detail, and complete definition 

throughout. A brilliant, silver luster 

beams in the fields accenting a light 

dusting of gold tone. 

PCGS 11, NGC 3. In the 2017 ANA 

auction, the first example to sell since 

July 2008. That coin sold for $6,463 

and in 2008, one sold $6,613. The current Collector’s Universe value is listed at $7,500. This date is VERY RARE any finer. A 

great coin that would have sold as fully CHOICE a generation ago. 

PCGS# 5733 | ESTIMATE: $5,750+ 

LOT 152 


A GLORIOUS GEM! Brilliant silver 

white luster glows with a superb 

radiance on both sides accenting the 

sharply struck up devices. Every detail 

is crisply rendered with an exacting 

strike even on the shield the brads 

are fully visible. Aside from a minor 

reeding mark on the reverse, this coin 

is essentially flawless, and would have 

likely graded higher. The eye appeal is 

excellent. 

PCGS 34, NGC 12. This is a date that 

is very rarely offered in such high 

grade. Another date that has a wide range of APRs, the more recent sold in October 2016 for $5,170 and prior to that in the 2015 

ANA auction, one sold for $10,575. The current Collector’s Universe value is $8,500 and this date is VERY RARE graded higher. 

A very attractive coin that will see strong bidding when it crosses the block. Good luck. 

PCGS# 5737 | ESTIMATE: $7,500+ 

67


LOT 153 


Brilliantly lustrous surfaces show off a clear gold iridescent 

toning on both sides. Sharply struck on the head and nicely 

defined on on the shield. Housed in an old green tag holder, this 

very clean coin has a classic, old time look. 

PCGS 87, NGC 49. There is a wide range of prices realized 

in auction, ranging from $1,080 to $3,055. The current PCGS 

value of $1,900 is a very suitable average, and this PQ example 

should realize somewhere around that figure. 

PCGS# 5749 | ESTIMATE: $1,200+ 

LOT 154 

25C 1924-S PCGS MS64 FH CAC 

This is a date that is very tough to find with a fully struck head. 

This lustrous, near-GEM has good head detail, with all three 

leaves and full outline of the hairline and profile. All but two of 

the brads are fully brought up by a better strike. There are a few 

minor ticks and lines that keep this one form a GEM grade. 

PCGS 86, NGC 57, CAC 18. The last three PCGS/CAC 

examples sold for $2,585 and the current PCGS Price Guide 

value is listed at $3,000. Very difficult to find any finer, 

especially with CAC approval. 

PCGS# 5751 | ESTIMATE: $2,200+ 

68


LOT 155 

25C 1926-S PCGS MS66 FH 

Anyone who collects Standing Liberty quarters with full 

heads knows that the 26-S is one of the hardest dates to 

find with a full, crisp head. In GEM grades, it is one of 

the KEY dates to the series, and is highly sought after, 

rarely appearing on the market, usually only when a set is 

broken up. 

The present GEM has a bold strike for the date, all three 

leaves are crisply rendered and just a couple of the brads 

are not fully brought up. There is just a slight touch of 

weakness in the center of Liberty’s torso. A glowing luster 

blooms on both sides accenting the design elements and 

bringing life to the pale golden accents over the otherwise 

brilliant silver surfaces. The eye appeal is very nice. 

PCGS 10, NGC 1. The current PCGS Price Guide value 

is listed at $37,500 and the most recent example to sell in 

auction was in February 2012, a CAC coin that brought 

$37,375. The finest is a single 66+ FH that was ex Just 

Having Fun Collection that sold for $48,175 in February 

2013. This is a coin that is worthy of any high end 

collection of Standing Liberty quarters and will see very 

strong bidding when it crosses the block! 

PCGS# 5759 | ESTIMATE: $30,000+ 

69


LOT 156 


It is amazing what Mother Nature and cardboard can do! This 

coin is all about the killer colors. 

Technically this coin is all there and then some. The colors are 

totally original (cardboard Mint set holder type toning). 

The obverse has circular rings of pearl green/amber/violet that 

open into a moderate gold center. We rank the obverse colors 

are 9+ on our 1-10 color scale (10 is the best). The reverse is 

just gorgeous too. There is a partial circle of pearl green/violet 

that opens into light sky blue color. There is a strong luster 

illuminating these colors. The eye appeal is tremendous! 

The last PCGS CAC piece to sell that was toned brought a 

whopping $11,500 in April 2013. The toner buyers for sure 

will determine the value of this coin. Our estimate is only a 

guesstimate. We know there will be crazy strong bidding here! 

LOT 157 

25C 1958 PCGS PR68+ DCAM 

It is amazing that a coin housed in the original cellophane 

holder could survive in such spectacular condition! Not only is 

this coin SUPERB in every way, it is also among the absolute 

finest known! Ultra deep mirrors contrast against the highly 

frosted devices. Visually FLAWLESS, even with a powerful 

loupe, there are ZERO imperfections! 

PCGS 1, NGC 0. Only five coins are graded finer. While this 

SUPERB GEM has not sold in auction, a PR69 sold for $6,300 

in February 2018. We think this coin will sell for a price over 

the suggested PCGS Price Guide value of $1,850. Good luck! 

PCGS# 95990 | ESTIMATE: $1,800+ 

PCGS# 5851 | ESTIMATE: $3,500+ 

LOT 158 

50C 1801 OVERTON 101. PCGS 

XF45 

Anyone who collects this series knows 

how difficult the 1801 half dollar 

is to find in attractive XF; most are 

lightly cleaned and are dull. This coin 

is a happy exception overall. Light 

silver-gray surfaces have a delicate, 

somewhat dappled rose, pewter, and 

coppery-gold toning on both sides. 

Accents of surviving luster adds a 

depth to the eye appeal in the recesses 

of the design elements. There are a 

few tiny ticks here and there but none 

are detracting to the overall good eye 

appeal. 

PCGS 20, NGC 11. The last one to sell sold very cheaply, considering previous auction results, bringing $5,280 in the 2018 ANA 

auction. A CAC-approved coin brought $9,000 in a May 2017 Internet only auction. The current PCGS value is listed at $9,250. 

Keep in mind that an AU coin is worth about $13,000-$15,000. 

PCGS# 6064 | ESTIMATE: $5,000+ 

70


LOT 159 

50C 1807 DRAPED BUST. NGC 

AU58 

A lovely, high Condition Census 

O-103. A brilliant frosty luster glows 

on both the obverse and reverse. A 

dusting of pale pearly-silver, gray and 

gold toning takes up the majority of 

the surfaces, while the peripheries, 

especially on the right sides show 

a deeper rose, gold and light blue 

iridescent toning. As typical for the 

date, there is some light weakness of 

strike in the center of the obverse, but 

the corresponding area of the reverse is 

fully rendered by a precise blow from 

screw press. Struck from a heavily clashed state of the dies, but before the dies began to crack, as listed for O-103a. 

PCGS 67, NGC 72. We believe this to be the Queller coin, listed as CC#2 in the Spring 2018 revision of the AMBPR. The two 

most recent NGC AU58s were a different variety, both selling in 2014 for $6,463. The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at 

$7,250. Keep in mind, these are very scarce in Mint State. 

PCGS# 6079 | ESTIMATE: $5,000+ 

LOT 160 

50C 1808/7 PCGS AU50 

O-101. A wonderful, collector oriented grade, with medium 

pewter and lilac toning that yields to olive, gold and powder 

blue. Sharply struck up devices show off good definition despite 

some minor friction. There are a few minor scratches that 

we note under the tone and are totally unobtrusive to the eye 

appeal. This is NOT a dull example, like so many happen to be. 

PCGS 29, NGC 12. The current PCGS Price Guide value is 

listed at $1,775 and the most recent example sold in February 

2018 for $1,500. As the first overdate variety in the Capped 

Bust series, this pleasing AU coin will fit nicely in any Red 

Book set of collector grade Bust halves. 

LOT 161 

50C 1809 XXX EDGE. PCGS XF40 

O-102. Easliy identifiable by the row of segments above the 

eagle. Delicately toned over lightly worn surfaces. The eye 

appeal is nice for the grade. 

PCGS 38, NGC 2. The last one to sell was CAC-approved and 

realized $1,020 in June 2018. This eye appealing example will 

bring somewhere around that level. The current CU value is 

listed at $1,250. 


PCGS# 6091 | ESTIMATE: $1,200+ 

71


LOT 162 

50C 1811/10 PCGS AU58 

O-101. A later state of the dies the stars and legends drawn to 

the edges with little to no milling left on both sides. Lustrous 

silver surfaces are brilliant in the centers and there is a dusting 

of gold iridescence and richer pewter-dove. Boldly struck 

devices show only the slightest hint of friction keeps this lovely 

1811/10 out of a Mint State holder. 

PCGS 20, NGC 10. The current PCGS Price Guide value is 

listed at $6,500 and the most recent examples have sold in the 

general $4,000-$6,000 range. A good looking coin like this will 

see strong bidding from early half dollar specialists. 

PCGS# 6099 | ESTIMATE: $4,000+ 

LOT 163 

50C 1811 SMALL 8. PCGS AU58 

O-106. A frosty, lustrous AU58 with all the attribution points for 

this R-3 variety clearly visible. A few stray lines are perhaps the 

reason CAC did not bean this flashy early date Bust half. The 

eye appeal is very nice and is not a dull AU coin. 


listed at $2,700 and the most recent example to sell in auction 

was CAC-approved and realized $3,410 in January 2018. 

Non-CAC coins have sold in the $1,500-$2,000 range. This one 

will be a great addition to any set of Capped Bust half dollars or 

an AU58 type set. 

PCGS# 6097 | ESTIMATE: $1,300+ 

LOT 164 

50C 1812 PCGS AU58 

O-105a. Offering near full mint luster on both sides, this frosty 

AU58 has a vibrance that you norally only see on Mint State 

coins. Nicely struck, the devices show only the lightest touch of 

friction. Struck from a shattered obverse die with multiple die 

cracks, this coin has a lot of charm and good looks, enhanced by 

a touch of delicate gold-peach at the rims. 

PCGS 132, NGC 86. The last one to sell realized $1,560 in 

June 2018 and the current PCGS value is listed at $2,150. An 

excellent example for any collector. 

PCGS# 6100 | ESTIMATE: $1,350+ 

LOT 165 

50C 1834 SMALL DATE, SMALL LETTERS. PCGS MS63 

CAC 

O-109. This is a truly noteworthy Mint State Capped Bust 

half dollar. Well struck with fully formed devices and legends. 

Fully frosted with medium lilac-dove toning with subtle 

golden highlights. A thoroughly pleasing example of this very 

popular type. 


lists value at $2,250. We last sold an example of this date at 

auction in December 2016 where it realized $2,350 which was 

NOT CAC. A pleasingly original and high-end coin for the 

Bust Half enthusiast. 

PCGS# 6166 | ESTIMATE: $1,500+ 

72


LOT 166 


A condition census O-103, which is a scarce R-4 variety. FRESH 

to the market and housed in a first generation PCGS slab. 

Wonderfully original, this coin has the initial look of a higher 

grade. The devices are sharply struck and there are are no major 

marks, lines or any distractions on the satiny surfaces. Rich album 

toning rings both sides, and the eye appeal is exceptional. NOTE: 

The old PCGS encapsulation has a few cracks. 

PCGS 86, NGC 76, CAC 11. The last PCGS/CAC example sold 

for $1,528 in February 2017. More recently all PCGS MS62s have 

sold for more and the current PCGS value is listed at $2,150. We think this example should bring a very strong price. 

PCGS# 6142 | ESTIMATE: $1,500+ 

LOT 167 

50C 1843 PCGS 

MS65 

WOW, what a 

great looking 

GEM early 

Seated half! 

Totally original, 

this impressive, 

near-Gem early 

Seated half was 

boldly struck on 

both sides, with 

full definition 

of the devices 

impressed on both 

sides. A strong 

mint frost comes 

through the light 

pastel toning in 

shades of gold, olive, sky-blue, emerald, and peach coloration. This GEM has a great old-time collection look, reminiscent of what 

you would see on an Eliasberg or Norweb coin. Worthy of a superb set of Seated Liberty halves or type coins. 

PCGS 5, NGC 3. Just two coins are graded finer. This GEM appears to be the former NGC MS66 from the Gene Gardner auction 

of October 2015, which realized $12,925. Gene’s duplicate was a PCGS MS65 CAC that sold for $8,225--a coin he paid $11,750 in 

July 2013. The current PCGS value is listed at $10,500. With just two examples graded finer at PCGS, this GEM will delight any 

picky collector. Good luck! 

PCGS# 6243 | ESTIMATE: $7,500+ 

73


LOT 168 


What a great time keeper of our Civil War era 

coinage. This coin is a dazzling HIGH END 

piece. How this survived the Civil War and 157 

years is beyond comprehension. Not only did 

it survive, it did so in such an awesome way! 

Splendid surfaces have just a tiny scattered 

tick or two that can only be seen with a glass. 

The surfaces have a thick satiny texture. A 

surprising strong luster beams from all over. 

Absolutely gorgeous toning consisting of 

original moderate hues of green, blue, gold, 

rose, pale magenta swirl all over on both sides. 

You want a 157 years old GEM to look like 

this. Miss Liberty and the details are delicately frosted and are fully struck. The eye appeal is beautiful! 

PCGS 17, NGC 3, CAC 12 (hmmm there was clearly a resub on a coin). The last PCGS CAC piece to sell in auction brought 

$13,513 in our December 2015 Regency Auction. These do no exactly grow on trees! This will make a great addition to any GEM 

MS Seated set, Civil War set, or Type set. We sure do not see these often. 

LOT 169 

50C 1873 ARROWS. PCGS MS64 CAC 

For the assigned grade, this 1873 half dollar is gorgeous and totally 

original. We love the look! First the obverse fields have a touch of 

reflective sparkle that bursts from under the highly attractive blue, 

green, rose, and gold toning. Crisply and fully struck up with full 

definition on both sides. A strong glass reveals a few minute lines, 

that limit the grade, but not the excellent eye appeal. 

PCGS# 6302 | ESTIMATE: $12,500+ 

PCGS 44, NGC 19, CAC 13. The most recent example realized 

$3,000 in the 2018 ANA auction and the current PCGS price is 

$2,850. There are records in the $4,000+ range from 2016 and 

earlier in 2018. Worthy of a strong bid from type or date collectors, we love the look of this near-GEM. 

PCGS# 6343 | ESTIMATE: $2,600+ 

LOT 170 


Visually, this 1877 half dollar is beyond 

incredible and high end! It has a stunning, totally 

original look, and its quality is all there and then 

some!A bold frosted, satin sheen glows with a 

pearly brilliance on the obverse. A dusting of 

clear-gold, opal-like glow. A rim tone with a 

richer golden hue, orange and magenta accents. 

While not PL, the highly frosted fields do stand 

out with almost a cameo like effect when viewed 

at different angles. The reverse has a much more 

flashy mint luster that radiates from all over. This 

coin has a stunning look that any collector, even 

the most jaded, will fall in love with! 

PCGS 30, NGC 11, CAC 15. There are 11 graded 66+ (likely including duplication), and just two coins graded finer at PCGS. The 

most recent example to sell realized $6,900 in April 2018. Prior to that, there were three sold in 2017 for $6,300 and $7,050. The 

current PCGS value is listed at $8,950. The two finer PCGS coins have never sold in auction, so this is currently the FINEST you will 

be able to buy! Not only would advanced Seated Liberty half dollar collectors go crazy for the high end SUPERB GEM possesses! 

PCGS# 6355 | ESTIMATE: $5,750+ 

74


LOT 171 


A truly amazing and high end 

SUPERB GEM Seated half that 

has been carefully stored since 

it left the mint! It is tied for 

FINEST graded! 

Immaculate surfaces are 

smooth and have not even the 

smallest distraction anywhere. 

Using a strong glass will 

only impress you even more. 

A strong luster enhances the 

totally original colors of olive/ 

pale evergreen/light purple 

that dominate the obverse. The 

reverse has the same shades 

only darker (probably sat on felt). Miss Liberty and the details are frosty and are fully struck. The eye appeal is terrific. 

PCGS 5, NGC 0, CAC 3. PCGS has graded just two in MS66+ as the FINEST they have seen, and NGC has not graded anything 

higher than MS65. This was the last PCGS CAC coin to sell in auction, bringing $12,925 as a 66 in April 2017. Prior to that, it 

brought $21,150 in June 2014. In MS66+ the current PCGS value is listed at $20,000. You’re certainly not going to see the others 

being offered in any frequency! This is a GEM bound for the FINEST of sets! 

PCGS# 6358 | ESTIMATE: $16,000+ 

LOT 172 

50C 1884 PCGS MS66 

The original mintage of only 

4,400 these 1884 halves often 

come with bold Prooflike 

surfaces. This one is quite 

reflective, and depending on 

the angle that you view it, it 

could be mistaken for a moment 

for a Proof. Sharply struck 

devices stand out with a nearly 

cameo-like look on the reverse. 

There is a dusting of silvery/ 

pearly iridescent tone with 

accents of clear gold. The eye 

appeal is very pleasing. 

PCGS 19, NGC 12. These do 

not come up for sale that often, the last non-CAC example sold in October 2015, during Part 4 of the Gene Gardner Collection; 

that coin brought $5,170. More recently the 2017 ANA auction a CAC approved example sold for $7,050. The current PCGS Price 

Guide value is listed at $6,750. There are a dozen coins graded finer at PCGS. This coin will be a wonderful addition to any set! 

PCGS# 6366 | ESTIMATE: $6,500+ 

75


LOT 173 


An AMAZING SUPERB GEM! 

Clearly this beautifully toned 

example is one of the FINEST 

KNOWN of this low mintage 

date. With only 12,000 struck, 

this was a rarity from day one. 

Exceptionally lustrous fields 

are aglow under a sumptuous 

melange of rainbow iridescent 

toning that gently coats both 

sides. Impressive violet, blue, 

gold, orange, and teal hues 

blend together inspiring a 

wonderful eye appeal. Satin 

smooth surfaces and sharply 

struck up devices show no imperfections, even when carefully viewed under a strong glass. What an amazing coin! 

PCGS 5, NGC 5, CAC 3. Every bit as nice (or nicer) as the Malibu Collection coin sold in November 2010 for $31,625. This coin 

sold more recently for $22,800 making the current Collector’s Universe value of $17,500 useless for a high end coin like this! 

There is just a single MS67+ finer, a coin which has never sold in auction. A great coin for any Seated half dollar set or high end 

type set, we can see this coin selling well in excess of our estimate range! 

PCGS# 6372 | ESTIMATE: $18,000+ 

LOT 174 

50C 1862 PCGS PR64+ CAM CAC 

Sharply impressed with full squared rims and strong details. The 

mirror fields glitter and contrast nicely with frosted central design 

elements. Light golden-blue toning attests to this coin’s careful 

long-term storage. Most proof coinage in the 1850’s and 1860’s is 

scarce, including the 1862 of which 550 were produced. 

PCGS 14, NGC 9, CAC 4. PCGS has graded only a single 

PR64+CAM. Only 22 have been graded higher. PCGS 

price guide lists value as $4,000. A PCGS PR64CAM CAC 

appeared at auction in January 2014 and sold for $4,348. A rare 

opportunity for the Seated Liberty and Civil War specialist. 

PCGS# 86416 | ESTIMATE: $4,000+ 

LOT 175 


The first year of the Barber series is not rare in an absolute 

sense, but it is somewhat scarce in GEM. However, demand for 

a first year of issue has always kept this date very popular. The 

present GEM is ever so close to an even higher grade, perhaps 

the minor reeding mark on Liberty’s neck is all that keeps it 

from a 66. The surfaces have a rich, brilliant mint luster that 

ranges from satiny with a bold frost to areas of the reverse that 

are somewhat reflective with a near PL sheen. Both sides are 

untoned with a shimmering pearly-silver that is just wonderfully 

original and highly eye appealing. 

PCGS 118, NGC 81, CAC 34. There are only FOUR coins 

graded MS65+ at PCGS. The most recent PCGS MS65 CAC 

sold for $1,800 in June 2018 and a PCGS MS66 CAC sold for 

$3,080 in our July 2018 Premier Session. In 65+ the PCGS 

Price Guide value is listed at $2,450. Worthy of a home in any 

GEM Set and a great way to start a new collection! 

PCGS# 6461 | ESTIMATE: $1,500+ 

76


LOT 176 


Totally original and what a marvelous GEM example of this date. 

Obviously the first thing that attracts your attention is th original 

toning. Light iridescent teal-lilac, russet-rose, and olive-gold patina 

drapes over the entire surface of the obverse. The satin-frosty 

luster below the toning brings out the subtle differences in the hues 

on the obverse. The reverse has more of a strong, rolling cartwheel 

luster with some flashy accents. The devices are sharply struck 

and frosty. A halo of gold tone frames the reverse giving it a very 

stunning look. There are only a few tiny marks on the cheek. The 

eye appeal is very high end and this has a really classic look! 

PCGS 21, NGC 9, CAC 6. The ONLY PCGS CAC MS65 to sell 

in auction was back in March 2009! Even nearly a decade ago, 

that coin brought $3,738. The most recent PCGS coin sold for 

$3,960 and was NOT CAC (in the 2018 ANA auction). Only 11 

coins are graded finer, and this one will command a premium bid. 

LOT 177 


We like the look of this pleasing CHOICE Mint State Barber 

half. A very bold, luster, which is very vibrant for the assigned 

grade. Icy silver brilliance has some frosty, some satiny, and 

some cartwheel accents combining to give this coin a look that 

is far superior to what you would expect of a 63. The details are 

wonderfully crisp, and the reverse is framed by a lovely dappled 

eggplant and russet tone. The eye appeal is superb. 

PCGS 38, NGC 21, CAC 4. The last PCGS/CAC coin sold in 

June 2015 for $1,704 and the current CU value is listed at $1,500. 

Scarce any finer, this coin has a great look for the grade. 

PCGS# 6473 | ESTIMATE: $1,300+ 

PCGS# 6471 | ESTIMATE: $2,800+ 

OUR ESTIMATES 

The estimates you see published in this catalog are based on 

HAMMER. Keep in mind that a coin could be either low or 

high end for the grade, have stunning color or be dull, all of 

which radically affect a coin’s value. Yes, there can be huge 

price differences within a grade, and we offer estimates as 

a guide so Collector’s can have a better idea of value. One 

thing we will never do is offer low ball estimates in order to 

claim stronger sales. 

LOT 178 

50C 1896-O NGC AU55 CAC 

WOW, is this fully CHOICE AU 96-O half totally ORIGINAL. 

A very pleasing collector graded example that has a rich 

olive-pewter gray coloration with tinges of old gold. The wear is 

limited to just a touch of light friction on the high points and in 

the fields. 

PCGS 11, NGC 7, CAC 5. The only CAC-approved coins sold in 

2011 and 2012--that is a long time for one to not appear, the most 

recent was an NGC/CAC coin to sell in $2,990 which was in July 

2012. The current Collector’s Universe value is $5,000, and the 

value nearly doubles in AU58. 

These published estimates represent what Legend Rare Coin 

Auctions determines to be an approximate high wholesale 

value for the coin. The numbers are based upon current 

market values, similar trades, auction prices, published 

prices, and a consideration of the coin’s quality. There is 

no guarantee that the estimated prices are minimums or are 

exactly what you can expect to get if you attempt to resell 


We always advise you to view the coins you are interested 

in and calculate what you’ll pay using as much information 

as possible. If you have any questions, please feel free to ask 

us. We are here to help you! 

PCGS# 6475 | ESTIMATE: $2,800+ 

77


LOT 179 

50C 1898 PCGS MS67 

An amazing Barber half dollar, tied with just a single coin 

as FINEST GRADED, and this coin is a real SUPERB 

GEM! 

A beautiful, bold, and brilliant satin mint frost blooms all 

over on this impressive MS67. The surfaces, as expected, 

are satiny smooth and display zero imperfections visible 

to the naked eye; even under the closest scrutiny with 

a strong glass, you cannot find anything more than 

a tiny tick or two, mostly hidden under the delicate 

pastel toning. Shades of light blue, lilac, olive, gold, 

and pearlescent iridescence dusts both sides, giving a 

wonderful dimension to the coin, accenting the sharply 

struck up devices. Every detail is rendered to its finest 

advantage. The eye appeal is without a doubt stunning 

and totally original; everything about this coin screams 

high end quality and you will be hard pressed to find a 

better one! 

PCGS 2, NGC 0. The only other MS67 is the Dale 

Friend-Greensboro coin that sold in the 2009 FUN 

Auction for $57,500 before selling for $37,600 in the 

weak market of October 2015. The current PCGS Price 

Guide value is listed at $48,500. This coin is truly worthy 

of any top ranking PCGS Registry set of Barber half 

dollars. If you are the high bidder on this SUPERB GEM, 

we congratulate you for putting an amazing coin into 

your collection, well done! 

PCGS# 6480 | ESTIMATE: $30,000+ 

78


LOT 180 


A glittering near-GEM! Intense cartwheel luster 

rolls smoothly on both sides, accenting a moderately 

reflective texture in the fields. The sharply struck 

devices are frosted and do stand out with a strong 

vibrance. Copper-russet tones are delicately scattered 

on the surfaces giving this beauty its amazing look. A 

tiny tick or two are all that keep this remarkable coin 

from a FULL GEM grade and a five-figure price tag. 

Despite a generous mintage of over 2.5 million, this 

date is surprisingly rare in such a high grade. 

PCGS 23, NGC 9, CAC 10. This is the only MS64+ 

graded at PCGS and is NOT the 64+ reported at NGC. That coin sold for $4,818 in July 2017. The current PCGS Price Guide value 

is listed at $4,750 and keep in mind the last PCGS/CAC MS65 sold for $11,163 in June 2017. Bound for a GEM set, as the eye 

appeal is all there and then some! 

PCGS# 6488 | ESTIMATE: $4,250+ 

LOT 181 

50C 1904-S PCGS MS64 

We are pleased to present this 

choice 1904-S half dollar. 

Scarcer than you would think 

based on the mintage, the 04-S 

is a major condition rarity in 

the Barber half dollar series. 

This date always attracts lots of 

attention in Mint State grades, 

especially as you climb the 

ladder. One theory we have 

read on this is the major 1906 

San Francisco earth quake and 

fires were responsible for large 

numbers of banks, homes, and 

businesses being destroyed, and 

along with them, perhaps large 

quantities of these half dollars. 

The surfaces are smooth and devoid of all but the most insignificant little ticks that can only be seen with the aid of a powerful 

loupe. Lightly toned with pastel iridescent hues that gently form a halo on the obverse rim. As you rotate the pearly-lustrous 

surfaces in a light,the subtle hues come out. The eye appeal is very pleasing. 

PCGS 36, NGC 3.VERY RARE any finer! The last time a non-CAC PCGS coin sold in auction was back in November 2009, 

realizing $18,400. The two most recent were CAC approved and sold for $20,400. The current Collector’s Universe value is listed 

at $25,000. These are extremely rare any finer, with just nine coins finer at PCGS. A great addition to any set of Barber halves, 

good luck! 

PCGS# 6500 | ESTIMATE: $16,000+ 

79


LOT 182 


This is a very appealing 

near-GEM example. While 

1,250,000 were struck, most 

were placed directly into 

circulation and are very rare in 

MS64 or finer grades. Radiating 

mint luster blooms on both sides 

that swirls with bold rolling 

cartwheels. The only reason we 

can see that this brilliant silver 

coin is not graded higher are a 

few minor marks on Liberty’s 

cheek, but the eye appeal 

is overall very nice for the 

assigned grade. 

PCGS 9, NGC 8, CAC 2. The last CAC-approved example sold in auction back in March 2014 selling for $6,463. More recently 

two non-CAC coins sold for $7,315 and $7,638 (that the most recent in April 2015). The current PCGS value is listed at $8,500. 

VERY RARE finer, just 18 are graded finer at PCGS. 

LOT 183 


A lower mintage date, with only 604,000 struck and needless to 

say, this is a conditionally RARE issue with few that survive in 

GEM or finer grades. This coin is very pleasing and satiny with a 

great pearly-silver and gold look. Sharply struck up, the surfaces 

show only the slightest hint of contact with other coins that can 

be seen with a strong glass. None of these have any impact on the 

superb eye appeal. 

PCGS# 6511 | ESTIMATE: $5,250+ 

PCGS 13, NGC 18, CAC 5. This is the ONLY MS65+ graded 

at either service and has not sold in auction. There has not been 

a PCGS MS65 sold in auction in almost nine years--we told you they are rare! The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at 

$5,000 and keep in mind that a PCGS/CAC MS66 would likely cost $15,000. This coin presents a great value as well as great look 

and will fit in very nicely into any GEM set of Barber halves. 


LOT 184 


Beautiful, GEM CAMEO Barber half! Fully frosted devices stand 

out against deeply reflective mirrored fields; in fact the reverse 

borders on a DCAM classification if taken on its own. A touch of 

peripheral toning at the rims frames both sides and gives the eye 

appeal a little extra “pop.” 

Only 912 proofs were struck. PCGS 20, NGC 7, CAC 6. The most 

recent example to sell in auction realized $1,939 in our July 2018 

Regency Auction. Prior to that even non-CAC coins were selling in 

the $2,280 to $2,760 range. The current PCGS Price Guide value is 

listed at $3,150. A nice, original coin like this will attract strong bidding. 

PCGS# 86547 | ESTIMATE: $1,800+ 

80


LOT 185 


Original and flashy in every 

way! what an amazing looking 

1902 half dollar! SUPERB 

quality icy mirrors beam 

with an intense shimmering 

reflective brilliance. Splashes 

of multicolored toning graces 

the essentially FLAWLESS 

surfaces. Blues, golds, tans, 

olives, and amber tones 

all blend together, clearly 

imparted from long term 

storage in the original paper 

wrapper. The eye appeal is 

very cool and high end. 

Only 777 were struck. PCGS 9, NGC 14, CAC 12. We sold a similar looking non-CAC coin in our June 2015 Regency Auction 

for $7,931 and in September 2014 a PCGS/CAC sold for $7,638. Keep in mind that none are graded finer than PR67+ and the 

most recent to sell realized over $15,000! Bound for the finest set of Barber proofs! 

PCGS# 6549 | ESTIMATE: $7,250+ 

LOT 187 


A totally original example of this early date, conditionally scarce 

Walker. Vibrant, satiny surfaces show off a wonderful blend of 

gold and iridescent lilac-silver hues. Showing a better than average 

striking definition, this near-gem quality 18-S has a great look that 

will delight any collector of early Walkers. 

PCGS 641, NGC 242, CAC 59. The last two PCGS/CAC examples 

sold for $2,640 the 2018 ANA being the most recent. The current 

PCGS Price Guide value is $2,350. VERY RARE in GEM grades, 

the last PCGS/CAC MS65 sold for $38,400! This coin represents a 

great value for the collector! 

PCGS# 6576 | ESTIMATE: $2,000+ 

LOT 186 


From our Regency Auction V, December 2013, lot 140, where it was 

described as: 

“Totally magnificent! You can tell the collector who consigned 

this coin had a very good eye. The mirrors are super deep, crystal 

clear, incredibly reflective, and have amazing clarity. A killer mix of 

original golden brown/ honey/ blue/ pale green swirls all over. Miss 

Liberty and the details are frosted a silvery white and have needle 

sharp strikes. This is a really special 1907 Proof Barber Half!” 

Only 575 proofs were struck. PCGS 18, NGC 36, CAC 7. This coin is the only CAC-approved example to sell in auction, realizing 

$4,600 in the December 2013 Regency Auction. The Proof Barber half dollar values have come down since then, BUT, this beauty’s 

eye appeal and high end quality will vault it to another very strong final bid! 

PCGS# 6554 | ESTIMATE: $3,200+ 

81


LOT 188 


The booming wartime economy required lots 

of coins in circulation, and the mint obliged 

with over 10 million half dollars churned out of 

the San Francisco mint in 1918. While not rare 

in low grades, it becomes scarce in MS64 and 

progressively rarer the higher on the grading 

scale you go. The present 64+ is a great coin for 

the collector. 

Brilliant, satiny mint luster blooms throughout 

the surfaces, which are of essentially GEM 

quality. We see no distracting marks or lines, but 

the central devices show some typical weakness 

of strike. The eye appeal is nice for the grade. 

PCGS 520, NGC 254, CAC 60. There are 59 graded MS64+, the most recent of which sold in August 2017 for $3,525. The current 

PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $4,350. Keep in mind that a PCGS/CAC example sold in the 2018 ANA auction for $38,400. 

What an amazing opportunity for the collector looking for a near GEM example. Good luck! 

PCGS# 6576 | ESTIMATE: $3,200+ 

82


LOT 189 

50C 1919-D PCGS MS64+ CAC 

Sometimes we wonder what the services were thinking 

when a coin crosses the grader’s desk. What did they see 

when grading this coin? To us, 64+ looks conservative! 

While we make no guarantees, we think this 1919-D is 

closer to MS65 grade than MS64. One look at this high 

quality example and you will agree its very HIGH END! 

This is a major condition rarity in this series! A strong 

luster gleams and glows from all over on this totally 

original early Walker. The satiny surfaces are smooth and 

incredibly clean. If this was a common date, it would 

have likely graded higher. The devices are all sharply 

struck up, there is just a hint of the slightest weakness 

on Liberty’s head. There is a tiny tick in the obverse 

but it does not affect the amazing eye appeal. The luster 

brings out the subtle lilac, icy blue, pale gold and light 

rose comes out in the light. Overall this is one of nicest 

examples we have had the pleasure of offering! 

PCGS 91, NGC 77, CAC 22. There are seven coins listed 

in 64+, and we believe that there is some duplication 

in the pops. The Population in MS65 is 11 and 1 in 66. 

While MS64+s have sold in the $32,000 to $41,125 range 

these are $200,000+ coins in MS65. This one, being so 

high end for the grade is certainly worthy of a premium 

bid and will sell for more than the current PCGS value of 

$42,500. A great coin for any PCGS Registry Set. 

PCGS# 6578 | ESTIMATE: $45,000+ 

83


LOT 190 

50C 1920-D PCGS AU58+ 

CAC 

If not for the most minute touch 

of rub, really only seen on a 

few of the eagle’s feathers, 

this coin would have graded a 

full Mint State grade! Sharply 

struck devices, this iridescent 

toned example has a bold, 

nearly full, satiny luster. The 

eye appeal is amazing! 


There are only three graded 

58+, none of which have ever 

sold in auction. We expect that 

this coin will far surpass any 

price guide values from the everyman collecting contingent. Good luck! 

PCGS# 6581 | ESTIMATE: $2,700+ 

LOT 191 

50C 1920-S PCGS MS64+ 

CAC 

If this coin were handed to 

us in a MS65 holder, we 

would not flinch. We fully 

grade this coin MS64.8+++. 

Prior to certification, we can 

see this coin being called an 

MS65. Obviously, we are more 

pinpoint today. 

Extremely clean surfaces are 

a delight to behold. Even the 

dreaded right obverse field 

is clean. All the surfaces are 

super clean and are satiny. A 

full booming luster screams 

out from all over. Both sides are a booming white. Miss Liberty and the details are above average in strike. You do not need a 

glass to see her head or thumb’s fullness. The eye appeal is jaw dropping for a 20-S! 

PCGS 186, NGC 102, CAC 24. PCGS has graded 19 pieces in MS64+. Prior to this one selling in our July 2018 Regency 

Auction for $7,344, the last one to sell in auction brought $8,700 in February 2018. If you are a stickler for luster, strike, and 

color, check this coin out. We assure you it beats many MS65’s. Opportunity knocks loud here! 

PCGS# 6582 | ESTIMATE: $5,750+ 

84


LOT 192 

50C 1927-S PCGS MS65+ 

CAC 

This is a very scarce coin that 

is rarely offered in such a high 

grade. This beautiful GEM 

has a thick frosty luster that 

blooms with a vibrant satiny 

brilliance. The strike is about 

as strong as you can ever 

expect to see for a 27-S and 

the surfaces are clean and free 

of any distracting marks. A 

cool bisecting die crack is seen 

on the reverse adding to this 

coin’s charms. The eye appeal 

is SUPERB. 

PCGS 83, NGC 37, CAC 25. The last one to sell was the Duckor coin that brought $9,600 in the 2018 FUN auction and he 

bought it for $10,869 in April 2015. There was one sold in July 2014 for $12,925. This coin will delight any advanced collector, 

and keep in mind that a 66 will cost $25,000+--if you can find one. The current Collector’s Universe value is listed at $12,000 

and this one could well bring that or more when it crosses the block! Good luck! 

PCGS# 6587 | ESTIMATE: $9,000+ 

LOT 193 


Truly a special 34-S! While 

the sharp strike and brilliant 

satin luster are both dynamic 

characteristics of this GEM, 

what is really special about this 

AMAZING coin is the bold, 

beautiful multicolored toning 

that adorns both sides. Shades 

of blue, gold, rose, orange, and 

magenta frame the obverse, 

while a swath of sky blue 

dramatically graces the central 

obverse. The reverse is dusted 

with a pastel blue iridescent 

toning that really delights the 

eye. 

PCGS 305, NGC 112, CAC 31. Here is a coin that you can just toss out the price guides and ignore the auction records, except 

for the $7,931 that this coin that sold in our May 2018 Regency Auction. With toning as lovely as this, it is UNIQUE and should 

be regarded as an opportunity of the utmost import for the advanced collector of toned Walkers. The only reason why this 

magnificent GEM is available is because the collector has decided to change directions. 

PCGS# 6594 | ESTIMATE: $5,500+ 

85


LOT 194 


Clearly an impeccable GEM 34- 

S--everything about this coin is 

exceptional and the quality truly 

borders on SUPERB! 

The sharply struck and the satin smooth 

fields that surround the devices are 

enlivened by a pearly, brilliant luster 

that glows all over Every detail is 

RAZOR sharp, with bold definition all 

over. Every line in the drapery, even 

Liberty’s thumb. Dusted over with a 

delicate pastel iridescent tone, the eye 

appeal is remarkable and memorable 

for its SUPERB look! 

PCGS 170, NGC 56, CAC 40. PCGS has graded 26 in MS66+ with just nine MS67s graded finer. The last PCGS/CAC example 

sold in the 2018 ANA auction for $9,600. Keep in mind that a PCGS/CAC MS67 will cost $25,000+. A real prize for the advanced 

collector of Walkers, this amazing 34-S will find itself at home in one of the finest sets! 

LOT 195 


There is no question this high end Walker sat undisturbed 

from the day it left the Mint. The pristine surfaces show only 

some raised dye lines, but nothing in the dreaded right field. 

Impeccable blazing silver mint brilliance is blinding with a 

white hot glow. Miss Liberty and the details are sharply struck 

throughout, and the eye appeal is wonderful! 

PCGS# 6594 | ESTIMATE: $6,000+ 

PCGS 197, NGC 119, CAC 98. PCGS has graded 17 in 67+ and 

only 2 finer. The most recent example to sell in auction brought 

$4,080 in the 2018 FUN auction. Prior to that, one sold in the 2017 

ANA auction for $4,935. The current PCGS value is listed at $3,500. Keep in mind that the last 68 sold in 1990! Good luck! 

PCGS# 6598 | ESTIMATE: $3,500+ 

LOT 196 


Doubtless, this is one of the FINEST 1938 

Walkers that survives! 

The eye appeal is AMAZING! Frosty, 

satin luster shines brilliantly with a 

pearly texture. Untoned, save for a band 

of crimson-gold toning at the rims, this 

remarkable survivor has a bold strike and 

is bested by only a single coin. 

PCGS 105, NGC 41, CAC 34. PCGS 

has graded only five coins in 67+ with a 

sole coin finer. The most recent example 

realized $8,400 in the 2018 FUN auction, but the one prior to that realized $15,600 in September 2017. Keep in mind the sole 

MS68 has not made any recent appearances. Good luck. 

PCGS# 6604 | ESTIMATE: $9,000+ 

86


LOT 197 


Tied for FINEST graded 

at PCGS. A superb, silky, 

brilliant virtually perfect 

SUPERB GEM! All of the 

design elements are fully 

and crisply rendered by an 

exacting, precision blow from 

the dies. Lovingly cared for 

since the coin came off the 

dies, the surfaces are pristine 

and immaculate. The luster is 

absolutely brilliant throughout. 

A delicate dusting of iridescent 

toning attests to the amazing 

originality and adds to the 

already SUPERB eye appeal. 

PCGS 27, NGC 18, CAC 23. The most recent PCGS/CAC MS68 sold for $8,400 in the 2018 FUN auction. There are NONE 

graded finer and we expect very strong bidding to take this MARVELOUS GEM home! Bound for the FINEST set of Walkers! 

PCGS# 6609 | ESTIMATE: $7,000+ 

LOT 198 


A marvelous, brilliant silver example. This is a true SUPERB 

GEM example with ultra clean surfaces and billowing frosty 

luster. Every details is sharply rendered from a bold, forceful 

blow from the dies. The eye appeal is quite nice, the coin looks 

like it was struck moments ago! 

PCGS 249, NGC 178, CAC 124. There are 25 graded MS67+ 

and just a SINGLE MS68 finer. The last two PCGS/CAC 

MS67+s to sell in auction were in our May and September 2018 

Regency Auctions, realizing $11,163 and $3,408 respectively. 

They were both toned, unlike this SUPERB coin that is as 

brilliant white silver as the day it was coined. A wonderful 

addition to ANY Walker set! 

PCGS# 6612 | ESTIMATE: $3,500+ 

LOT 199 


Impeccably preserved and intensely lustrous SUPERB GEM. A 

vibrant, glowing, mint blooms on both sides bringing the satin 

smooth surfaces to life and accenting the delicate lilac-gold 

toning. The devices are boldly impressed, showing crisply 

defined details. Extremely rare any finer! 

PCGS 370, NGC 373, CAC 196. The PCGS Population in 67+ 

is 32, and only half a dozen coins have graded finer, all MS68. 

The most recent MS67+ to sell in auction was a PCGS/CAC 

coin that sold in our May 2018 Regency Auction for $2,350 

and the current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $2,750. The 

last MS68 sold for $16,450 and that was nearly five years ago! 

Good luck! 

PCGS# 6614 | ESTIMATE: $1,800+ 

87


LOT 200 

50C 1943-S PCGS MS67 

Here is a wonderfully lustrous and SUPERB 43-S half. The 

sharply struck devices are accented by a visually impressive luster 

that beams from the fields on both sides. A touch of pastel toning 

forms an arch of color at the upper obverse periphery. We note just 

a tiny touch of softness in strike in the centers and a strong glass 

reveals a tiny mark on the eagle’s chest. 

PCGS 45, NGC 26. The last non-CAC example to sell in auction 

brought $5,738 in our September 2015 Regency Auction. The 

current Collector’s Universe value is listed at $5,000. There is just 

a SINGLE coin finer at PCGS, graded 67+. This SUPERB GEM will attract fierce bidding to be sure! Good luck! 

LOT 201 


One of just seven graded MS67+ with NONE 

FINER, this remarkable SUPERB GEM has a 

spectacular look! 

PCGS# 6620 | ESTIMATE: $3,600+ 

This is a truly amazing and SUPERB GEM. 

Boasting swirling, brilliant mint frost blazes 

on both sides, the obverse has a stunning 

arch of rich crimson and pine-green. Looking 

at this coin with a strong glass you will be 

unable to find even the slightest flaw of any 

kind! The details are fully struck up and the 

eye appeal is excellent! 

PCGS 119, NGC 131, CAC 58. There are only seven coins graded MS67+ and the last CAC-approved example sold for $9,600 

in June 2018 and prior to that, one brought $10,575 in April 2017. Neither of those had the stunning looks imparted by the 

impressive luster and toning. Worthy of a very strong bid indeed! 

PCGS# 6628 | ESTIMATE: $8,000+ 

LOT 202 


Mother Nature got a hold of this piece 

and did some of her best work here. Plus, 

technically this coin is all there and then 

some! You can clearly see the surfaces 

are smooth and have no problems. A full 

glowing luster also beams all over. Miss 

Liberty and every detail are so sharply 

struck you do NOT need a glass to see 

them with. There is no question this 

coin has sat totally undisturbed for 71 

years -most likely in a cardboard Mint 

Set holder. For sure this coin has never 

been messed with. Now for the absolute 

highlight of this coin-its incredible 

colors. Both sides enjoy moderate shades of totally original reddish brown/reddish gold/pearl green/violet/amber colors that are 

evenly spread all over. The colors are iridescent and are far from dull. The eye appeal is just jaw dropping! 

PCGS 80, NGC 70, CAC 25. PCGS has graded 6 pieces in MS67+ The last one to sell in auction brought $9,400 in February 

2015 (this coin had no colors anywhere close to the coin offered here). We expect fierce bidding on this killer toned Walker. 

Don’t forget, it’s a real MS67+ too! 

PCGS# 6630 | ESTIMATE: $10,000+ 

88


LOT 203 

50C 1941 PCGS PR68 

SUPERB! WOW! This beautiful example is totally original 

and offering a wonderful look. The mirrors are deep and bold, 

offering an exceptional clarity below the iridescent tone. 

Remarkably well preserved and we are not exactly sure why 

CAC did not sticker this handsome coin. 

PCGS 27, NGC 51. The last example to sell without CAC 

approval realized $6,463 in July 2017. The current PCGS Price 

Guide value is $6,500 and there are just three coins graded 

higher, all PR68+ (and one of those sold for $18,800 in our May 

2018 Regency Auction). A highly appealing coin that would be 

a great addition to any set of Proof Walkers. 

PCGS# 6641 | ESTIMATE: $4,000+ 

LOT 204 

50C 1959-D PCGS MS66+ FBL CAC 

Among the finest certified examples, this Premium Quality GEM 

has a great look. Highly lustrous surfaces coin has multicolored, 

dappled toning on the rims and brilliant silver on the central 

obverse, while the central reverse has wonderful orange, rose, 

red, gold, and green melange. The surfaces are essentially pristine 

and the eye appeal is very high end and original. 

PCGS 172, NGC 42, CAC 29. There are only 15 in MS66+ 

FBL with just a 67 and a 67+ finer. We sold an example in our 

December 2016 Regency Auction for $1,645. This coin brought 

$1,560 in March 2018. The current PCGS value is $2,000 and 

keep in mind that the two finer examples have never sold in 

auction, and may not for quite some time! 

PCGS# 86677 | ESTIMATE: $1,200+ 

LOT 205 


Blistering mirrors dance in the light and provide dramatic 

contrast to the frosty white reliefs. The eye appeal is superb, 

and keep in mind that in DCAM this date is very rare. 

PCGS 78, NGC 213, CAC 50. In the Cameo designation, there 

is just a SINGLE coin numerically finer at PCGS. The last two 

PCGS/CAC coins sold in our October 2017 auctions, realizing 

$1,028 and the PCGS Price Guide is listed at $1,050. Keep in 

mind that a PR68 DCAM would cost $10,000+. 

PCGS# 86695 | ESTIMATE: $1,000+ 

LOT 206 

50C 1964-D PCGS MS67+ 

A truly SUPERB GEM J.F.K. half dollar! With just four others 

graded MS67+ and a single coin graded finer, this is among the 

absolute FINEST 64-D halves in existence! 

Highly lustrous surfaces gleam with a a visually arresting 

vibrance. Pastel salmon, lime, and olive tone accents the boldly 

struck devices. It is amazing how few SUPERB GEMs survive, 

despite the huge mintage. 

PCGS 5, NGC 1. Only two have ever sold in auction, one for 

$2,101 and the other brought $5,405. A single MS68 has ever 

been graded, selling for a record $22,325 in our February 2016 

Regency Auction. Bidding for this super JFK will see intense 

bidding for sure. 

PCGS# 6707 | ESTIMATE: $2,000+ 

89


LOT 207 

50C 1964 PCGS PR69 DCAM 

A PERFECT example of the final 90% 

regular issue half dollar. After President 

Kennedy was killed in 1963, legislation 

was passed to replace the Franklin half 

with one featuring JFK’s portrait. This 

beautiful example is tied for finest graded, 

there are NONE graded PR70 DCAM. The 

DEEP mirrored fields are FLAWLESS. 

Studying them closely with a strong glass 

you cannot find anything. 

PCGS 100, NGC 131. The current PCGS 

Price Guide value is listed at $1,250 and 

the most recent example brought $1,560 

in the 2018 ANA auction. We sold one in our January 2018 Regency Auction for $2,233. A great example for a type set or to start a 

set of Proof Kennedy halves. 

LOT 208 

50C 1966 S.M.S. PCGS SP67 DCAM 

First off, this highly reflective SUPERB GEM looks like a real 

proof, not the hybrid that these Special Mint Set issues actually 

are. Bold, deep, watery reflective mirrors are certainly without 

flaw contrasting wonderfully against the frosted mirrors. 

PCGS 38, NGC 205. The most recent example realized $870, 

but earlier these were selling for $1,440 and $1,260. The current 

PCGS value is listed at $1,850. RARE any finer, this coin will 

see strong bidding. 

PCGS# 96846 | ESTIMATE: $1,000+ 

PCGS# 96800 | ESTIMATE: $1,500+ 

LOT 209 

50C 1967 S.M.S. PCGS SP68 DCAM 

A SUPERLATIVE example with ULTRA 

deep mirrors that shine against the 

frosted devices. The SMS coins were a 

sort of hybrid between business strikes 

and proofs in an era when the mint was 

not producing proofs. This FLAWLESS 

beauty, at first glance does look like a 

full proof! 

PCGS 18, NGC 20. The most recent 

example brought $3,000 in the 2018 

ANA auction (it may represent a buy 

back, as we sold $4,818 in our October 

2017 Regency Auction, and the current 

CU value is listed at $6,750. There are NONE graded finer in the DCAM designation. Good luck! 

PCGS# 96847 | ESTIMATE: $3,500+ 

90


LOT 210 

1C-50C 1942 6-PIECE PROOF SET. PCGS PR64 

A very cool set housed in FIRST GENERATION PCGS holders. Clearly a set that was graded 30+ years ago and just recently offered to 

us for auction. Each coin is totally original and has a great look, well matched, and graded PR64. For some reason (perhaps the obverse 

toning dots), the Type 1 nickel and the dime did not garner a CAC bean, all other coins have a green bean. The current combined PCGS 

Price Guide value is listed at $915, but a set like this, in the first generation PCGS slabs should attract strong bidder participation--this lot 

is as FRESH as can be! 


LOT 211 

$1 1798 LARGE EAGLE. PCGS XF40 

B-25, BB-123. A very cool variety, noted as the Blundered Stars 

Reverse, where the stars were punched too high up in the design. 

Struck from Die state III, with multiple obverse and reverse die 

breaks. Deep pewter and dove gray tone gives this large silver coin 

a great look. Despite the moderate wear the details show off a crisp 

strike that must have been nearly complete when the dies came 

together. There are a few unobtrusive, minor marks, all natural to 

the amount of wear this coin possesses. 

PCGS 250, NGC 148. The most recent example realized $3,300 

in our May 2018 Premier Session auction, and we sold one in 

November 2017 for $3,740. The current PCGS value is listed at $4,000. A great type coin! 

PCGS# 6873 | ESTIMATE: $2,800+ 

OUR ESTIMATES 

The estimates you see published in this catalog are based on HAMMER. Keep in mind that a coin could be either low 

or high end for the grade, have stunning color or be dull, all of which radically affect a coin’s value. Yes, there can be 

huge price differences within a grade, and we offer estimates as a guide so Collector’s can have a better idea of value. 

One thing we will never do is offer low ball estimates in order to claim stronger sales. 

These published estimates represent what Legend Rare Coin Auctions determines to be an approximate high 

wholesale value for the coin. The numbers are based upon current market values, similar trades, auction prices, 

published prices, and a consideration of the coin’s quality. There is no guarantee that the estimated prices are 

minimums or are exactly what you can expect to get if you attempt to resell 


We always advise you to view the coins you are interested in and calculate what you’ll pay using as much information 

as possible. If you have any questions, please feel free to ask us. We are here to help you! 

91


LOT 212 

$1 1801 PCGS AU58 CAC 

Ex. Flannagan Collection. This is one of the FINEST B-1, 

BB-211 dollars that exist! 

This is not an AU55 scrubbed up to be an AU58! This 

coin is a VERY real AU58 1801dollar! We can not stress 

enough the extreme rarity of this date in this condition. 

Remember,our sister firm, Legend Numismatics, 

exclusively built the all time FINEST EVER Mint State 

Bust Dollar set-The Legend Collection. We know how 

these should come in AU and higher! This date does 

not come all that nice! This coin is from the Flannagan 

Collection -a complete set (yes, an 1804 $1 was in it) we 

exclusively built and sold via auction in 1999!Overall, 

this coin has a remarkably clean and remarkably smooth 

surfaces. Even using a strong glass will only impress 

you more. A surprising luster beams from all over. Both 

sides are a totally original golden brown/deep pewter/ 

purple coloration. Most important, the high points 

display minimal light wear/rub. There really are NO 

major discolorations. Miss Liberty and he details are 

extremely well defined and do stand out. The eye appeal 

is wonderful! 

PCGS 23, NGC 18, CAC 5. NO PCGS CAC piece have 

ever been sold via auction, but we know this coin last 

sold in March 2009 for $27,000 according to the PCGS 

Cert verify page. We can not stress enough how many 

Bust Dollars have been cleaned or played with over the 

years. Plus, gradeflation has made so many nice coins 

into so/so weak pieces. This 1801 if the real deal. Good 

luck finding another! 

PCGS# 6893 | ESTIMATE: $27,000+ 

92


LOT 213 

$1 1840 PCGS MS63+ CAC 

Legend Rare Coin Auctions is pleased to represent one 

of the greatest toned Seated Dollars it has ever seen. 

Not only does this coin have killer colors, it has VERY 

high-end quality. 

Using a strong glass, we can see there are a few tiny 

ticks in the right obverse field. The balance of the coin’s 

surfaces are exceedingly clean and smooth. A glowing 

luster can be seen all over. Of course, the luster enhances 

the toning. The obverse is blessed with magical and 

totally original colors of navy/evergreen/violet/gold 

which over 2/3 of the surfaces. The reverse has some 

plashes of toning. These are NOT dull or drab colors. 

Miss Liberty and the details are sharply struck. The eye 

appeal is amazing! 

PCSG 8, NGC 8, CAC 4. PCGS has graded 2 in MS63+ 

(both handled by Legend at one time-including this 

coin). Of course, neither MS63+ has sold via auction. 

The current Collector’s Universe Value is $23,000. The 

last MS64 we handled sold in excess of $65,000! Keep 

in mind, this special piece not only a real VERY HIGH 

END MS63+, it has something you ever ever see-real 

sparkling original colors. This coin would enhance any 

Type or Mint State Seated Dollar Collection. We assure 

you, there is nothing else like it (remember our sister 

company Legend Numismatics has built the world’s 

FINEST EVER Mint State collections, and have seen it 

all). Opportunity knocks so loud you really need to be 

prepared here! 

PCGS# 6926 | ESTIMATE: $22,000+ 

93


LOT 214 

$1 1855 PCGS MS62 

This is a brilliant, frosty Mint 

State example of this scarce 

Seated Dollar date. Only 26,000 

were struck and precious few 

were saved at the time of issue, 

this date is RARE in any Mint 

State grade. 

Struck with the typical 

weakness seen on the wings, 

this lustrous coin has a great 

look. The grade in our opinion 

is spot on, with just a few light 

lines that keep it from a full 

CHOICE grade. The surfaces 

have a pearly-silver luster with 

a pale, shimmering iridescent type of look that is better than decent. 

PCGS 12, NGC 7. The last one to sell was CAC-approved and sold for $14,400. A non-CAC PCGS coin sold in the 2017 FUN 

auction for $13,513. We sold a PCGS/CAC MS61 in our April 2017 Premier Session for $12,000 hammer. The current Collector’s 

Universe value is listed at $16,500 and keep in mind these are VERY RARE any finer! This is a great opportunity to add a nice 

Mint State piece for their date or type set. 

LOT 215 

$1 1860-O PCGS MS64+ 

This is a very lovely example 

of this final New Orleans 

mint Seated dollar date. Many 

of the Mint State survivors 

were discovered in bags that 

were discovered in a treasury 

basement vault. Most survivors 

were heavily bag marked and 

grade MS60-MS62. Near-Gem 

examples like this are VERY 

RARE indeed! 

PCGS# 6943 | ESTIMATE: $10,000+ 

Pearly silver lustrous surfaces 

glint in the light. Sharply 

struck devices stand out on the 

smooth surfaces. There is only 

the slightest hint of contact on both sides. The eye appeal is decent overall and should fit nicely in any set of Seated dollars. 

PCGS 1, NGC 5. The last regular MS64 was CAC and sold for $13,750 in an online only auction. F.Y.I. Legend paid $65,000 

for a 65 in 2013. We think the current PCGS value of $9,500 may well prove to be low! Good luck! 

PCGS# 6950 | ESTIMATE: $8,000+ 

94


LOT 216 

$1 1873 SEATED. NGC PR65* CAC 

Visually, this coin is worthy of its coveted “Star” 

designation for eye appeal. The obverse of this highly 

reflective beauty is a full cameo. The details are sharply 

struck up and have full white frost on them. A beautiful 

halo of blue and gold toning frame the brilliantly flashy, 

glass-like mirrors on the obverse. The reverse mirrors 

are likewise watery, but have much more depth to the 

overtone of blue and rose tones. The eye appeal is very 

strong, so it is easy to overlook the ancient lines on 

Liberty’s torso. A delightful GEM that will be a real 

prize for the Seated dollar collector. 

Only 600 were struck. PCGS 12, NGC 15, CAC 2. This 

coin recently sold for $12,000 in the 2018 ANA auction 

and the other CAC coin, also an NGC-graded coin sold 

in June 2014 for $11,750. Anything finer is going to 

cost about double (or more!), so this represents a great 

opportunity to acquire a great example of the final year 

of the series. 

PCGS# 7021 | ESTIMATE: $11,000+ 

95


LOT 217 

$1 1873-CC TRADE. PCGS MS64 

Legend Rare Coin Auctions is proud to offer one of the 

FINEST GRADED 73-CC Trade Dollars! This is a series 

that we are very intimately familiar with, as our sister 

firm, Legend Numismatics, helped our partner, Bruce 

Morelan build the FINEST set. We know how each date 

comes. With that expertise and experience in mind, we 

can say with confidence that this coin is really all there! 

A brilliant underlying mint luster blooms through the 

dappled, multihued blue, gold, peach, rose, and lilac-silver 

toning. The eye appeal is augmented by a crisp strike with 

just a hint of softness on the eagle. Only under intense 

scrutiny can you see any marks, but they are tiny, hidden, 

and essentially invisible to the naked eye. 

The Trade Dollar was introduced as a way to convert 

excess silver supplies being mined from the Comstock 

Lode in Nevada. In 1873, the mintage of silver dollars 

for domestic use was ended, and the Trade Dollar 

was introduced to export silver to the Far East, where 

Mexican Pesos were the dominant trade coin. In all 

124,500 Trade Dollars were produced in Carson City in 

1873. This is a fairly available date in circulated grades, 

in Choice Mint State or finer, this date is VERY RARE. 

PCGS 6, NGC 7. This coin last sold as an NGC MS64 

in April 2018, realizing $38,400. It is very visually 

alluring, and should bring more than the frosty silver 

example that brought $31,200 in the 2018 ANA auction. 

The NGC MS64 CAC that sold in the 2018 FUN auction 

for $55,200 has also since crossed to PCGS. The current 

PCGS Price Guide lists a value of $56,500. Only a single 

coin is finer (The Vermeulle-Morelan Collection coin) 

PCGS/CAC MS65 is now residing in the Black Cat 

Collection and will not be available anytime soon. Bound 

for a GREAT collection of Trade Dollars, this near-GEM 

will see very spirited bidding. 

Good luck and congratulations! 

PCGS# 7032 | ESTIMATE: $37,500+ 

96


LOT 218 

T$1 1877 TRADE. PCGS MS64 CAC 

Here is a very high end Trade dollar for the type or date 

collector. Showing off a frosty mint luster that blooms on 

both sides (unusual for an 1877). Delicately toned with a hint 

of pearly clear gold tone that dusts over the highly lustrous 

surfaces. Each detail is fully rendered from an exacting blow 

from the dies and the surfaces show only a few light marks, that 

are only visible with a strong glass. The eye appeal is very nice, 

great for any collection. 

PCGS 80, NGC 63, CAC 16. There has not been a PCGS/CAC 

example sold in auction since April 2013, when one sold for 

$3,819 and another for $3,290. A great looking coin like this does 

not appear very often and this date is VERY RARE any finer! 

PCGS# 7044 | ESTIMATE: $3,000+ 

LOT 219 

T$1 1877-S TRADE. PCGS MS63 CAC 

This coin is not only SUPER HIGH END, but it is also FULL 

Legend quality, and even full Bruce Morelan quality (former 

owner of the #1 all-time Mint State set). If all MS63’s looked 

like this, they be $5,000 coins! The surfaces are amazing. Ticks 

and lines are so few that unless you look really hard, you don’t 

see any. You will still be impressed by the smooth surfaces and 

cleanliness even when using a strong glass. The luster is bold and 

you can see the totally unbroken cartwheel from across the room. 

There is a slight hint of auburn like toning on the rims only. The 

balance of the coin is a vibrant silvery white. Clearly this coin has 

never been messed with. ALL of the details are heavily frosted 

and are fully struck. The eye appeal is super gorgeous! 

PCGS 221, NGC 143, CAC 21. The last PCGS CAC piece 

to sell in auction brought $1,410 in August 2017. We will 

challenge this coin’s quality and eye appeal vs ANY MS63! 

Even if you do not collect Trade Dollars and wanted one special 

really nice coin-here it is! Seeing is believing! 

PCGS# 7046 | ESTIMATE: $1,100+ 

LOT 220 

T$1 1878 TRADE. PCGS PR66 CAM 

CAC 

This is a beautiful Premium Quality GEM 

78 Trade Dollar in a spectacular grade. 

What an amazing Proof! Dusky gold 

and rose shades cover both sides with a 

regal elegance seldom found and always 

appreciated. The rims offer deeper blue 

which lightens to crimson and russet in the 

fields. Glorious reflectivity in the fields 

which is undiminished by handling marks! 

The mirrors offer a bold, flashy, watery 

reflection that is stunning. Only 900 Proofs 

were struck and this is one of the absolute 

FINEST, not just in terms of technical 

quality, but in terms of eye appeal as well! Only six are graded this high with a cameo designation with a scant three finer! That gives 

the buyer a pretty clear indication of how rare this Trade Dollar is when found so well preserved. 

PCGS 6, NGC 3, CAC 1. This is the only CAC coin at this grade level with the CAMEO designation. We sold this GEM in our 

October 2015 Regency Auction for $10,869 and there was a previous record for this coin at $11,750.00 (1/15) which we feel is 

too low! The current PCGS value is listed at $14,000 and in the CAM designation, PCGS has graded just two coins finer. Just 

one look at this impressive Trade dollar, and you will fall in love for sure! 

PCGS# 87058 | ESTIMATE: $10,000+ 

97


LOT 221 

T$1 1881 TRADE. NGC PR65 

Here is a totally original, GEM 1881 Trade dollar. After 1878, all 

Trade dollars were struck in Proof format for collectors only, none 

were struck for circulation or the far east trade. This example has 

vibrant, rich, watery mirrors that flash from below a layer of thick, 

multicolored toning. Clearly this coin was left alone in an old collector 

envelope or case where it was able to take on the deep blues, greens, 

purples, and pewter tones that attest to the originality of this wonderful 

Proof type coin. 

Only 960 Proofs were struck. PCGS 38, NGC 39. The last examples 

sold in the $4,000 to $5,000 range and the current Collector’s Universe value is listed at $7,000. Rare any finer. A neat type coin. 

PCGS# 7061 | ESTIMATE: $4,000+ 

LOT 222 

$1 1878 7TF REVERSE OF 1878. 

PCGS MS65 DMPL 

A boldly struck and highly reflective 

GEM DMPL of this first year of the 

Morgan dollar series. The mirrors 

are deep, bold, and highly flashy in 

the fields. Both sides have a light 

silver-white iridescent tone that graces 

both sides. The sharply struck devices 

are clean and fully frosted, this beauty 

has a great cameo-like contrast. There 

are a few minor signs of contact, which 

are exaggerated by the deep, 8” mirrors. 

PCGS 27, NGC 10. This coin sold in the 

2018 FUN auction for $5,520. Prior to that an example sold in November 2016 for $9,400 and we sold one in our February 2015 auction 

for $6,756. The current PCG value is $8,000 and this one should see very active bidding when it crosses the block. Only two coins are 

graded finer, making this one of the best available for the collector. Good luck. 

PCGS# 97075 | ESTIMATE: $5,000+ 

LOT 223 

$1 1878-CC PCGS MS66 

The first Carson City Morgan dollar issue, always popular among 

collectors and this one has a great look. Brilliant mint luster swirls 

around both sides of this sharply struck GEM. A soft pearly-satin 

sheen has a silver white brilliance in the fields and Ms. Liberty 

and the Eagle are well struck and fully frosted. We note a few 

microscopic ticks, scattered and most need a glass to locate. 

PCGS 342, NGC 201. The most recent PCGS MS66 to sell in 

auction realized $4,080 and the current PCGS Price Guide value 

is listed at $4,950. RARE any finer, this date is always popular 

among collectors. 

PCGS# 7080 | ESTIMATE: $3,500+ 

98


LOT 224 

$1 1878-CC PCGS MS66 PL 

CAC 

Ranking towards the top of the 

PCGS and NGC Populations, 

this wonderfully contrasted 

Prooflike PQ GEM will be 

a delight for any advanced 

Morgan Dollar collector. The 

first year of issue of this heavily 

collected and very popular 

series from the historic Carson 

City mint. 

Bold, brilliant, radiating 

lustrous surfaces are blast white 

with a blazing reflective look 

and 5”+ mirrors. Sharply struck 

through out, the devices are wonderfully frosted and have bold contrast. The surfaces are clean and smooth without any serious 

marks. The eye appeal is superb! 

PCGS 9, NGC 8, CAC 3. There is just a single coin finer. The only PCGS/CAC coin to sell in auction brought $12,000 in 

December 2017. Even a non-CAC example brought just shy of $10,000 in our sale of the PFM Collection in May 2018. The current 

Collector’s Universe value is listed at $12,750 and this one could exceed that level. The sole finer 66+ PL has never sold in auction. 

A true prize for any advanced Morgan collection, and an opportunity not to be taken lightly! 

PCGS# 7081 | ESTIMATE: $10,000+ 

LOT 225 

$1 1879 PCGS MS65 PL 

The present GEM has a highly reflective mint bloom on both 

sides, the mirrors gleam with a strong vivacity. The devices are 

remarkably smooth for the assigned grade and have a wonderful 

frosty white look. Indeed, at first glance at a certain angle, this 

GEM looks like a watery finished Proof. Sharply struck up the 

eye appeal is very nice. Housed in an OGH. 

PCGS 24, NGC 16. The last two sold for $2,100 and $2,115 and 

the current Collector’s Universe value is listed at $2,750. Bound 

for a nice collection of Prooflike Gems! 

PCGS# 7085 | ESTIMATE: $1,800+ 

LOT 226 

$1 1879-O PCGS MS65 CAC 

An uber impressive GEM with full rolling cartwheel luster that 

accents a crisp, sharp strike and exceptional, PQ surface quality. 

The devices are very nicely frosted and the cheek is very clean, 

pleasing to even the pickiest of collectors! The eye appeal is 

tremendous for the grade. 

PCGS 467, NGC 139, CAC 77. The most recent example sold 

for $3,840 in July 2018, while the Stone Collection coin, sold 

in May 2018 realized a whopping $10,625. The most recent 

PCGS/CAC MS65 that we sold was in July 2017, realizing 

$3,760. Scarce any finer, the RanJack coin (PCGS MS65+ 

CAC) sold in our July 2018 Regency Auction brought $5,405 

and the P.F.M. Collection coin (PCGS MS66) sold in our May 

2018 Regency Auction brought $9,106. A conditionally scarce 

date that will see intense bidding when it crosses the block. 

PCGS# 7090 | ESTIMATE: $3,500+ 

99


LOT 227 

$1 1880/79-O VAM 

4.CROSSBAR PCGS MS64+ 

PL CAC 

This borderline GEM is 

absolutely among the FINEST 

PL-certified examples of this 

issue. Rich watery mirrors are 

are a full 4”+ in clarity with 

bold, frosty design elements. 

Both sides display a crispness 

and flash typically associated 

with coins struck in San 

Francisco. The eye appeal is 

exceptional, and is perhaps only 

a tiny tick away from a full 

GEM grade. 

PCGS 24, NGC 6, CAC 12. There are 8 graded 64+ PL at PCGS and the most recent sold for $8,225 in our July 2017 Regency 

Auction. The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $10,500. EXCESSIVELY RARE any finer, one of only 2 MS65 PLs with 

a CAC sticker sold for $48,938 in our May 2018 Regency sale. A real prize for any advanced collector! 

PCGS# 7117 | ESTIMATE: $7,000+ 

LOT 228 

$1 1881 PCGS MS66 

We sit and marvel at the originality of this GEM. After rotating 

the coin in a bright light and looking at it under a glass, we 

think that one tiny mark on the reverse is all that kept this coin 

from getting a CAC bean. 

A bold, radiating mint luster beams from the fields, offering a 

wonderful silver flash. The razor sharp devices are frosty and 

even the cheek is clean and free of any serious marks. The 

surfaces show off an iridescent silvery gold on both sides attest 

to the originality. We do like the look and since this date is VERY 

RARE any finer, it will find itself at home in any GEM set. 

PCGS 203, NGC 51. The last non-CAC example brought 

$1,800 in September 2018, and one sold for $1,440 in August 

2018. The current PCGS value is listed at $1,750. 

PCGS# 7124 | ESTIMATE: $1,250+ 


$1 1881-CC PCGS MS66 PL CAC 

We saw this coin from the table next door. At first we thought it 

was a full MS66 DMPL (we have seen worse in holders). When 

it was passed over to us, we were WOWed. This is one VERY 

high end MS66PL!Extremely deep mirrors are near miss 8” and 

DMPL status. They blaze bold from all over. The mirrors are 

also super clean and super clear. The cameo contrast is really 

strong. The minor grease dot (from striking) is light. Miss 

Liberty and the details and thickly frosted and are fully struck. 

What can we say? At first glance it looks like a DMPL. The eye 

appeal is great! 

PCGS 29, NGC 14, CAC 11. The last one to sell in auction 

brought $3,240 in the 2018 FUN auction. Because of its flash 

and quality, we paid much more then that! 

PCGS# 7127 | ESTIMATE: $3,200+ 

100


LOT 230 

$1 1881-O PCGS MS66 

If we owned CAC, we really 

would have stickered this coin. 

To us, we just do not see what 

they did-but of course they win. 

Remarkably clean and sleek 

surfaces are a joy to behold. We 

have seen countless examples 

of this date hacked up with 

deep bag marks. This coin only 

displays some minor lines and 

a few widely scattered tiny 

ticks. The luster on this piece 

is amazing. It’s like a full 

booming sky light you can see 

from yards away. Both sides 

are a beautiful classic white color. This coin does not look like it was messed with in any way. Miss Liberty and every detail are 

sharply struck and have lots of frost. Her check is way above average in cleanliness. The eye appeal is remarkable! 

PCGS 45, NGC 9. The last PCGS MS66 to sell in auction brought $6,756 in July 2018. The current Collector’s Universe Value is 

$10,000. We can see this coin easily enjoy strong bidding-especially from people who see it in hand. We invite you to check it out! 

PCGS# 7128 | ESTIMATE: $6,000+ 

OUR ESTIMATES 












101


LOT 231 

$1 1881-O PCGS MS66+ CAC 

Tied for FINEST graded! This coin has such an original 

look, it will delight any collector that wants their coins to 

have character! 

Extremely clean surfaces show off a strong, blazing mint 

luster that rolls from all over. The boldly struck devices 

are quite crisp for an O-mint, with just the slightest touch 

of weakness in the hair curls above Liberty’s ear and 

eagle’s breast feathers; everything else is fully and crisply 

struck up and fully rendered. The surfaces are especially 

clean and free of any marks, and the only lines are mint 

made die striations on the reverse. A dusting of toning on 

the obverse and reverse, the most eye catching of which 

is a tab of rainbow over DOLLAR. 

PCGS 51, NGC 8, CAC 7. There are only MS66+ graded 

at PCGS as FINEST for the date. The only one to have 

ever sold in auction is the Coronet Collection coin that we 

sold for $39,950 in our June 2015 Regency Auction. This 

coin has a totally different look, that coin having been 

blast white. The current PCGS value is listed at $35,000. 

This lightly toned example will entice strong bidding 

from collectors looking for the FINEST Morgans graded! 

PCGS# 7128 | ESTIMATE: $28,500+ 

102


LOT 232 

$1 1881-O PCGS MS64+ DMPL CAC 

Whoa! The mirrors on this sharply struck DMPL 81-O really 

catch the light and have a seriously bold flash. The raised reliefs 

have a great frost, that provide a decent contrast against the 

mirrored fields. The delicate nature of the DMPL surfaces does 

amplify the few tiny scuffs, but nothing is serious to negatively 

affect the high end eye appeal. 

PCGS 456, NGC 131, CAC 110. PCGS has graded 57 in 

MS64+ DMPL. The last few specimens that have sold in 

auction realized between $1,400 and $1,800. The current PCGS 

Price Guide value is $1,750 and keep in mind that the value 

jumps to $11,000 in MS65 DMPL! Good luck! 


103


LOT 233 

$1 1882-O/S STRONG. PCGS MS65+ 

Legend Rare Coin Auctions is proud to offer the FINEST 

graded 1882-O/S Morgan. Think about it-it took 33 + 

years for this coin to surface. 

We do agree this coin is worthy of its lofty grade. The 

surfaces are exceedingly clean and smooth. Even using 

a strong glass, we found NO serious issues-only a light 

frost break or two. For an O/S the luster is above average 

and is glowing and unbroken. A thin band of original 

blue/deep gold frames the rimes. The centers are a creamy 

white that mixes with gold colors. The strike is so full and 

sharp you do not need a glass to see anything-including 

the O/S. Miss Liberty’s cheek is also exceptionally clean 

and rounded. The eye appeal is great! 

PCSG 2, NGC 1. This is the ONLY MS65+ graded. The 

current Collector’s Universe Value is $75,000. If you are 

building the best Morgan set, this coin is must have. Even 

in MS65, the last example of one of those sold way back 

in 2012. We assure you, this coin is NOT any retread or 

that coin! This coin represents and amazing opportunity! 

PCGS# 7138 | ESTIMATE: $60,000+ 

104


LOT 234 

$1 1882-S PCGS MS67+ CAC 

No question, this is a real MS67+. 

Overall the surfaces are very clean and sleek. Only with a 

strong glass can you find a microscopic hidden tick or grease 

dot. Nothing stands out. Not only does this piece have full 

booming luster, it has light semi-prooflike mirrors. Both sides 

are a totally original creamy white. Miss Liberty and the details 

are fully struck and have delicate frost. Her check is very clean 

too. The eye appeal is terrific! 


MS67+. The last one to sell in auction brought $1,560 in 

February 2018. These are not as common as an 80-S (PCGS 

287). This coin will be great to add to any GEM Morgan set. 

LOT 235 

$1 1883 PCGS MS67 

A bold, beautiful, and brilliant SUPERB GEM. Sharply 

struck up with full, crisp definition and fully frosted devices 

throughout. Bold eye appeal, this beauty has a clean cheek that 

will please any picky collector. 

PCGS 156, NGC 129. The most recent example sold in July 

2018 for $2,040 and the Cajun-PFM coin sold in our May 

Regency Auction for $1,821. The current PCGS value is $2,250 

and this date is VERY RARE any finer. 

PCGS# 7142 | ESTIMATE: $1,500+ 

PCGS# 7140 | ESTIMATE: $1,200+ 

LOT 236 

$1 1883-CC NGC MS67* 

While not noted on the holder, this SUPERB GEM, with its 

textile pattern toning, most likely came out of a GSA holder. 

Rich olive-green patina blends with gold, teal, crimson, and 

violet accents. The color ranks as an 8 on our color scale, and 

we rarely see 83-CCs with attractive toning, normally it is a dull 

gold overtone. The underlying luster is bold on the obverse with 

accents of semi-PL reflection, while the reverse is more frosty. 

The details are all nicely impressed and have a neat frost. 

PCGS 232, NGC 120. This coin has a great look, so previous 

auction prices will not be a great guide to the value for this 

SUPERB GEM. Worthy of a strong bid from collectors of bag 

toned Carson City Morgan dollars. 

LOT 237 

$1 1883-CC PCGS MS65 DMPL CAC 

The mirrors and luster are blinding! The mirrors have full 8” 

reflection that contrast against the sharply struck and frosted 

devices. Ms. Liberty and the eagle, and all the details are razor 

sharp and the cheek and fields are remarkably clean and smooth. 

The eye appeal is great! 

PCGS 833, NGC 198, CAC 88. The last PCGS/CAC coin to sell 

brought $1,050 in June 2018. The most recent we sold realized 

$1,150 hammer in our August 2017 Premier Session auction. 

The currently listed PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $1,350. 

We think this coin could hit that level--it is that nice! 

PCGS# 97145 | ESTIMATE: $1,000+ 

PCGS# 7144 | ESTIMATE: $3,000+ 

105


LOT 238 

$1 1884-CC NGC MS67* 

This is a whirlwind of color! Very rarely do you ever see 84-CCs 

with this kind of color! The colors are rich, but not dark. Shades of 

emerald, gold, ruby, amber, smoky -topaz, and aquamarine all blend 

together across the lustrous obverse. The entire surface is awash in 

this dramatic blend of color, which ranks as an 8 on our 10-point 

scale. The devices are sharply struck and even using a strong glass we 

cannot find anything more than the typical tiny tick or two. 

PCGS 127, NGC 135. The most recent examples sold for $2,640 

in September 2018 an the current CU value is listed at $4,500. This 

dramatically toned 84-CC will delight anyone working on a colorful set of Morgans. 

LOT 239 

$1 1884-CC PCGS MS67 PL CAC 

This coin is a monster near miss DMPL! 

There is not even a teeny reason to not 

call it fully prooflike! 

PCGS# 7152 | ESTIMATE: $2,000+ 

Full 4” + mirrors beam boldly all over. 

The mirrors are remarkably clean. You 

can see only a few minor and widely 

scattered ticks and lines (like you would 

on any flashy DMPL). When you twirl 

this coin you really do gets tons of 

swirling flash all over. Miss Liberty and 

the details are thickly frosted and have 

tremendous full strikes. Her cheek will 

please the pickiest buyer. The eye appeal 

is nothing less than phenomenal! 

PCGS 2, NGC 9, CAC 1. This coin has never been sold in auction. An FYI, there is only 1 MS67 CAC DMPL-and that has never sold in 

auction (we figure that to be worth $40G++). The coin listed here has a current Collector’s Universe Value of $10,000. We can see a great 

HIGH-END coin like this easily exceeding that price. Be prepared, we expect really strong interest and bidding on it! 

PCGS# 7153 | ESTIMATE: $8,000+ 

LOT 240 

$1 1885 PCGS MS66 DMPL CAC 

GEM DMPL dollars approved by CAC are a rare commodity indeed. 

Anytime one pops up in our auctions, they disappear into the black 

hole of collections. Travel around any bourse floor and you know how 

dry the supply is! 

Offering a classic look with brilliant, beaming mint luster shows 

a blinding reflection in the fields with a deeply mirrored sheen. 

The cartwheel luster is brilliant and brings out the definition of the 

sharply struck and fully frosted reliefs. The mirrors show a full 8” 

clear reflection. 

PCGS 97, NGC 51, CAC 23. The last PCGS/CAC example sold for $5,288 in our December 2017 Regency Auction and the one prior 

to that was the awesome toned Northern Lights coin we sold in 2016 for $8,225. Housed in a somewhat older PCGS blue tag holder, we 

cannot find an auction appearance for this coin. Good luck! 

PCGS# 97159 | ESTIMATE: $3,000+ 

106


LOT 241 


A beautiful, rainbow toned GEM. Arching bands of aubergine, 

gold, emerald, sapphire, and ruby cover about 60% of the 

lustrous surfaces of the obverse. An 8+ on our color scale where 

10 is the best. Worthy of a premium bid and is a very nice 

example for the collector. 

PCGS# 7162 | ESTIMATE: $1,250+ 

LOT 242 

$1 1885-S PCGS MS65 

A crisply struck and vibrantly lustrous, this GEM 1885-S is 

visually very impressive. We are not entirely sure why it did not 

receive a CAC bean! The frosty cheek has a couple of minor 

ticks, but the eye appeal is wonderful! 

PCGS 611, NGC 243. The current PCGS Price Guide value 

is listed at $1,700 and most examples have sold in the 

$1,000-$1,500 range. Rare any finer, this exceptional GEM will 

be a delight for any Morgan collector. 

PCGS# 7164 | ESTIMATE: $1,000+ 

LOT 243 


A blazingly lustrous GEM! Bold, swirling cartwheels roll 

unimpeded on both sides, bringing out the impressive definition 

to the razor sharp strike. Ms. Liberty is frosty and her cheek is 

especially clean. Honestly, we can see this coin (no guarantees) 

grading higher one day. The eye appeal is exceptional. 

PCGS 648, NGC 244, CAC 54. There are only 39 graded 

MS65+ at PCGS, the most recent of which sold for $2,880 in 

June 2018. Keep in mind that the value goes up in 66, we sold 

one in July for $4,465 and one in May for $5,405. This coin, 

with its CAC endorsement, will realize a very strong price. 

Good luck! 

PCGS# 7164 | ESTIMATE: $2,200+ 

LOT 244 

$1 1887-S PCGS MS66 

Ex. M.J.O. Collection, as noted on the insert. 

Sharply struck and offering a bold rolling cartwheel luster this 

coin ranks among the top three dozen examples graded by 

PCGS. A halo of mottled amber, blue, gold, and olive-russet 

frames the brilliant silver center of the obverse, the reverse 

totally untoned with a delicate touch of semi-PL reflection. A 

strong glass reveals a tiny tick or two on the otherwise frosted 

and clean cheek. The eye appeal is very nice. 

PCGS 31, NGC 9. There are just five coins graded finer. The 

last one sold in our May 2018 Regency Auction for $5,053 

and prior to that, there were two APRs in 2018 for $3,900 and 

$4,080. The current PCGS value is listed at $6,000 and keep in 

mind that we sold two MS66+ examples this year for $28,200 

in January and $44,650 in July. This coin does present a great 

opportunity to the advanced Morgan dollar collector. 

Good luck! 

PCGS# 7180 | ESTIMATE: $4,000+ 

107


LOT 245 

$1 1889-CC PCGS MS63 DMPL CAC 

We grade the obverse a full MS63+ DMPL and the 

reverse a full MS64 DMPL. PCGS says NO, 63 DMPL. 

The mirrors are a full 8”+. There are NO shiny dead 

mirror patches anywhere. Just a few tiny and widely 

scattered ticks can be seen. There is nothing to draw your 

eye to that is negative. When you twirl the coin, you are 

nearly blinded by the mirror’s blast. This coin has major 

league pop! Miss Liberty and every detail are fully struck 

and boldly stand out with thick frost. No question this 

coin was never messed with in any way. 

The eye appeal is stunning! 

PCGS 50, NGC 32, CAC 12. The last PCGS CAC MS63 

DMPL to sell in auction brought $75,000 in May 2018. 

We’d be shocked if this HIGH END coin did not bring at 

least that. We know of an MS64 DMPL PCGS CAC that 

traded hands privately last year for $135,000 (we had just 

missed out on it). If you notice true DMPL’s -especially 

CAC DMPL’s do NOT appear with any frequency. This 

coin offers tremendous opportunity to any CC or Morgan 

Collector. Good luck! 

PCGS# 97191 | ESTIMATE: $62,500+ 

108


LOT 246 


A superb GEM BU 90-S Morgan! A strong, booming, brilliant 

cartwheel luster swirls with a stunning radiance on both sides 

of this impressive example. Tied for second finest graded, there 

are only 8 coins graded higher. Untoned on both sides and the 

smooth, clean surfaces are devoid of any distracting marks or 

ticks. Nicely struck throughout, and extremely rare finer. 

PCGS 262, NGC 60, CAC 89. There are 41 coins graded MS66+ 

and only 8 finer. Generally these have sold in the $4,000-$5,000 

range, the last one selling in 2018 ANA auction for $4,080. The 

current PCGS Price Guide is $5,200 and keep in mind that the 

last 67 was NOT CAC, and realized nearly $17,000! Here is a 

great coin for any serious Morgan dollar collector. 

PCGS# 7202 | ESTIMATE: $3,800+ 

LOT 247 

$1 1891-S PCGS MS66 CAC 

What an incredible, HIGH END GEM! Bold, brilliant, 

cartwheel luster rolls along both sides accenting the sharply 

struck and frosty devices. A dusting of the most subtle, clear 

gold can be seen on both sides and the reverse shows hints of 

light reflectivity aiding in a very high end eye appeal. 

PCGS 99, NGC 21, CAC 38. This is the former PFM Collection 

coin which sold in our May 2018 Regency Auction for $4,465. 

Literally days layer in New York, The Stone Collection coin 

which was NOT CAC sold for $6,000. Today, the PCGS Price 

Guide value is listed at $3,750, which is still too low for a 

CAC-approved example and we anticipate this PQ GEM will 

sell for a very strong price! 

PCGS# 7210 | ESTIMATE: $3,750+ 

LOT 248 


Bright white and completely bathed in satin luster. As usual, the 

central strike is limp with the central area of Liberty’s ear and 

curl above poorly brought up. There are some feathers partially 

defined on the eagle’s breast. Again, the 1892-O is one of the 

most notoriously weakly struck Morgan Dollars of the series, so 

expecting to find a bold center is likely not going to happen! 

PCGS 2,528, NGC 1,508, CAC 264. In MS64+ PCGS has 

graded 188 examples. With the populations dropping off 

dramatically in MS65, it is highly likely that there is a large 

number of resubmissions trying to obtain an MS65 grade. 

Most MS64+ examples in PCGS/CAC holders bring in the 

$900-$1,500 range; the most recent example we sold was in 

October 2017, realizing $1,469; the current CU value is $1,350. 

Keep in mind the next step up will cost about double! 

LOT 249 

$1 1893-S PCGS VG8 CAC 

The KEY date circulation strike Morgan dollar. Only 100,000 

were ever struck, and unlike most other Morgans, there were no 

mint bags discovered in the 1950s or 1960s. Today, the 93-S is 

scarce and in demand in all grades, and this VG is perfect for 

the grade with no signs of damage or serious flaws of any kind. 

Just wholesome, honest wear. Many lower grade pieces have 

signs of harsh cleaning or some other major problem. This one 

is a great example for the budget minded collector. 

PCGS 684, NGC 314, CAC 37. The last PCGS/CAC coin sold 

in our March 2017 Premier Session for $2,400 hammer and the 

current CU value is listed at $3,000. 

PCGS# 7226 | ESTIMATE: $2,400+ 

PCGS# 7216 | ESTIMATE: $1,000+ 

109


LOT 250 


In the aftermath of the Panic 

of 1893, the mintages of silver 

dollars dropped dramatically. 

Every issue from 1893 to 1895 

is considered either a KEY or 

semi-key date in the series. With 

a mintage of only 400,000, the 

95-S is a semi-key that is scarce 

in Mint State grades. 

Flashy and brilliant lustrous 

surfaces beam from all over. 

Well struck devices do stand 

out, but there are a few bag 

marks which account for the 

grade, evenly distributed on 

the obverse, none of which are singularly distracting. Both sides are accented by a flashy, semi-reflective texture to the fields. The 

quality is above average for what you might expect for the grade level. 

PCGS 257, NGC 139, CAC 16. There are only four PCGS MS62+ graded at PCGS. None have ever sold in auction. The current 

PCGS value is $5,450. The last PCGS/CAC MS62 sold back in August 2013 for $5,288 and a PCGS/CAC MS63 sold in the recent 

ANA auction for $6,000. A coin that will certainly delight anyone looking to add a nice Mint State 95-S dollar to their set. 

Good luck. 

PCGS# 7238 | ESTIMATE: $4,500+ 

LOT 251 

$1 1896 PCGS MS66 DMPL 

Highly reflective DMPL luster beams in 

the fields. The flashy mirrors are deep and 

have a bold clarity. Standing out against 

the mirrors with a bold contrast are the 

frosted, well struck up devices. The initial 

look is almost that of a full Proof. PCGS 

has graded just a single MS67 DMPL 

finer, making this one of the FINEST 

available to collectors. 

PCGS 23. NGC 3. The most recent 

example sold for $6,875 This coin sold 

for $4,320 in December 2017. The current 

PCGS value is $6,000 and with just a 

single coin finer, this is a coin that will see strong bidding from DMPL collectors. 

PCGS# 97241 | ESTIMATE: $4,500+ 

110


LOT 252 


Tied for FINEST graded, this 

SUPERB GEM is clearly 

worthy of its lofty grade! 

Frosty devices and impeccably 

struck devices stand out 

and are the epitome of 

cleanliness and flawlessness. 

The cartwheel luster has a 

vibrant satiny glow that is 

totally untoned and SUPERB! 

A powerful glass will reveal 

a tiny tick, the only thing 

that keeps it from likely a 

higher grade. This amazing 

coin sits at the apex of the 

Population and will delight any 

demanding collector looking to build the BEST quality Morgan dollar set. 

PCGS 299, NGC 187, CAC 90. PCGS graded 14 coins in 67+ with NONE finer. The most recent to sell in auction was the 

RanJack coin that sold in our July 2018 Regency Auction that brought $12,338 on an estimate of $8,500 to $9,500. Prior to that 

we sold another in December 2015’s Regency Auction for the same amount. The current PCGS Price Guide value is $10,000 

and this one will rank up there with the other two we had the pleasure of selling. Good luck! 

PCGS# 7254 | ESTIMATE: $10,000+ 

LOT 253 

$1 1900-O/CC PCGS MS66 

Intense mint luster rolls with a fiery brilliance on 

both sides. This O/CC has a stunning eye appeal 

imparted by the impressive luster that glows in 

the generally clean fields and among the razor 

sharp struck up devices. Liberty’s hair curls and 

eagle’s feathers are all crisply defined. There are 

a few minor marks which do not detract from the 

otherwise impressive look. This is a great coin 

for any Morgan collector, keep in mintd that it is 

extremely rare any finer! 

PCGS 138, NGC 11. The last two sold for $4,560 

(June and July 2018 and the current PCGS value 

is listed at $4,250. There are only 14 coins graded finer. Good luck! 

PCGS# 7268 | ESTIMATE: $3,800+ 

111


LOT 254 


Ex Jackson Hole. 

This stunning coin sold in 

our December 2017 Regency 

Auction where it was sold as part 

of the Bubba Bells Collection, lot 

41, and described as: 

“Virtual perfection! It is hard 

to imagine a finer 03-O! A very 

strong cartwheel luster rolls 

along the exceptionally smooth 

and seductive surfaces. Ms. 

Liberty and the details offer 

fully struck and crisply defined 

devices. A pale silver-white 

iridescent tone attests to its unmolested originality. The oft-told story about this coin’s former rarity shows how things in the market can 

change instantaniously if a hoard is found. The 03-O was one of the rarest dates in mint state in the Morgan series, that was until the 

Treasury found a hoard of original bags in a vault, and released them into circulation in the early 1960s. Luckily today for collectors, it is 

a generally available date in most Mint State grades that has a neat historical story.” 

PCGS 91, NGC 49, CAC 24. On an estimate of $3,500-$3,800, this coin realized $8,519. Since then the RanJack PCGS MS67 CAC sold 

for $8,225, far exceeding the current CU value is listed at $4,000. Again, this beauty should certainly see its bids exceed that level when it 

crosses the block. PCGS has graded only a single MS67+ finer, which has never sold in auction. For a top ranking Registry Set, this 03-O 

will certainly help elevate your collection. 

LOT 255 


Ex Cajun Collection. 

PCGS# 7286 | ESTIMATE: $7,500+ 

This is a SUPERB GEM Morgan from the 

PFM Collection sold by Legend Auctions 

in May 2018. The owner had a change of 

heart. Exquisite surfaces have no real hits. 

A few trivial frost breaks/light ticks are all 

you can see. The surfaces are super sleek 

and smooth. For an O Mint, the luster is 

unusually bold and is full cartwheel like. 

Both sides are mostly white with a splash 

of pale gold. Miss Liberty and the details 

are sharply struck and do stand out. The 

eye appeal is wonderful! 

PCGS 50, NGC 32, CAC 17. PCGS has graded NONE higher. This is really hard to believe, the last PCGS CAC piece to sell in 

auction (not the toned Northern Lights coin which realized $39,000) brought $5,405 in our 2015 Coronet Collection sale. Prior 

to that, the last one sold in 01/2011. It is a myth this is a commoner date- especially in such a lofty grade! 

This piece realized $4,700.00 in the May 2018 Regency Sale. If you missed it then, you have a better chance now! 


112


LOT 256 

$1 1878 8 TAIL FEATHERS. 

PCGS PR64+ CAM CAC 

What an engaging high end 

Proof Morgan! The grade 

could not be more spot on! 

Super deep mirrors beam 

forcefully from all over. The 

mirrors exhibit bold clarity, 

are super clean, and are so 

reflective you almost need Ray 

Bans on view the coin. You 

don’t even have to twirl the 

coin to see the stunning “liquid 

mercury” like rolling of he 

mirrors. There is some light 

original golden brown toning 

around the rims and are some faint gold toning in the centers.This coin does have a silvery black and white cameo appearance. 

Miss Liberty and the details are thickly frosted and are fully struck. The eye appeal is tremendous! 

ONLY 500 were minted. PCGS 9, NGC 5, CAC 7. There are four graded PR64+ CAM at PCGS and we are highly suspect 

this coin has been in a few times seeking a PR65 designation. Examples of the 8 TF in PR64 and higher have so few 

auction appearances at all since 2004. Finding a PCGS CAC piece-impossible! In fact, the last PR64 Cameo (no +) Legend 

Numismatics sold, was in 2015 for $15,000 from a long time dealer who was buying it for his personal collection. This coin 

presents a welcome opportunity for any serious Proof Morgan collector to enhance their set. We know the price is fair-especially 

when you consider all the facts about how many have ever appeared! 

PCGS# 87311 | ESTIMATE: $12,500+ 

LOT 257 

$1 1880 PCGS PR67+ CAC 

WOW! At first glance this 

cataloger began humming “Blue 

Velvet” when this virtually 

perfect, richly toned SUPERB 

GEM came across his desk! 

Obviously the first thing that 

catches your gaze is the deep 

variegated blue and violet hues. 

Rose and orange-salmon hues 

blend with the varied blue/ 

teal/violet tones. Once you get 

up close, you see the depth, 

vibrance, clarity, and smoothness 

of the underlying mirrors. They 

are clean, free of any lines or 

anything that can distract from the stunning eye appeal. This coin is TOTALLY original and very high end for the grade, everything about 

this coin is appropriate for the lofty designation and and is among the highest graded in the designation. 

PCGS 22, NGC 28, CAC 7. There are four graded PCGS PR67+ and only four are graded higher. The last regular PCGS PR67 was NOT 

CAC and sold in our July 2013 Regency Auction for $17,250 and a PCGS/CAC PR68 sold for $38,188 in the 2015 ANA auction. An 

NGC PR67+ CAC sold in April 2013 for just a hair under $20,000. The current PCGS value is listed at $21,000 and it is worthy of a very 

strong bid and is fresh to the auction market, it is NOT a retread or recent upgrade, cross over, etc. This SUPERB GEM will delight any 

Proof Morgan collector! 

PCGS# 7315 | ESTIMATE: $16,500+ 

113


LOT 258 

$1 1880 PCGS PR66+ CAM CAC 

This is a fantastic CAMEO Proof 

Morgan that borders on DCAM quality. 

It is also very high end for the assigned 

grade, essentially SUPERB in technical 

quality--you can be assured that it is 

superb in terms of eye appeal! Deep, 

highly chromatic reflective mirrored fields 

have a blazing clarity and boldness. They 

are sleek and have a stunning flash. The 

highly frosted and sharply struck devices 

stand out with intense contrast, as noted, 

bordering on a DCAM category. The 

surfaces are totally untoned and brilliant. 

There is an amazing visual allure with this 

coin and there are virtually no visible anything on the surfaces, save for a mint made lint mark. 

PCGS 31, NGC 33, CAC 14. PCGS has graded just three coins in PR66+ CAM and the most recent example to sell in auction was this 

coin, selling over four years ago in the 2014, realizing $12,926. Prior to that, one sold for $18,400 in August 2011. Today’s Collector’s 

Universe value is listed at $12,500. We sold a non-CAC PR67 CAM in our recent Regency Auction for $15,863. 

LOT 259 

$1 1881 PCGS PR64 CAC 

Wonderful watery-reflective mirrors offer a bold flash under the warm 

autumnal toning. Both sides are awash in a dappled melange of russet, 

olive, rose, and pale blue toning. The devices are sharply struck and the 

eye appeal is quite nice for the grade. This coin is totally original too! 

PCGS# 87315 | ESTIMATE: $12,500+ 

Only 984 Proofs were struck. PCGS 80, NGC 55, CAC 9. The current 

PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $3,750 and this near-gem coin is a 

very nice Proof Morgan for the budget minded collector. 

PCGS# 7316 | ESTIMATE: $3,000+ 

LOT 260 

$1 1885 PCGS PR66 CAM CAC 

A marvelous GEM 1885 Proof Morgan, 

with an extremely dramatic contrast that 

borders on the DCAM category. 

The fields are deeply mirrored and have an 

ultra bold depth of clarity. They are sleek 

and icy with a chrome-like brilliance that is 

blinding in the light. The design elements 

are razor sharp in strike and richly frosted. 

The visual allure of this seductive PQ 

GEM is incredible! 

Only 930 Proofs were struck. PCGS 18, 

NGC 13, CAC 11. This coin is so high end 

it sold in its last auction appearance for $15,600. While the current PCGS value is listed at only $10,500, clearly this impressive coin is 

worthy of a strong bid! Keep in mind DCAMS are extremely rare, so a borderline DCAM like the present coin will excite many collectors 

and will see fierce bidding! 

PCGS# 87320 | ESTIMATE: $12,000+ 

114


LOT 261 

$1 1885 PCGS PR66+ CAM 

CAC 

A coin that is totally unlike 

what you normally see for an 

1885. This coin has a SUPERB 

look with exceptionally deep 

contrast. The eye appeal is 

very high end! Deep, highly 

reflective mirrored fields 

beam from all over and have 

a headlight-like blazing look 

when viewed in a light. The 

highly frosted devices are 

razor sharp in strike and stand 

out vividly from the fields. 

Totally untoned, both sides are 

a blistering brilliant silver. The 

eye appeal is very high end and wonderful! 

Only 930 Proofs were struck. PCGS 22, NGC 13, CAC 11. There are only TWO PCGS PR66+ CAMs on the Population Report; 

the last one to sell in auction was CAC approved and brought $14,688 in the 2017 FUN auction. The only other one to sell in 

auction was back in October 2012 for $14,100 (was not CAC). Only three examples have graded finer, the finest being a single 

PR68 CAM. The finest to ever sell was a PR67 CAM, a coin that did not have CAC approval A great coin for any collector of 

high end Proof Morgans. 

PCGS# 87320 | ESTIMATE: $12,500+ 

LOT 262 

$1 1889 PCGS PR65 CAM 

CAC 

A gloriously toned and highly 

reflective GEM Proof Morgan 

dollar. Every thing about this coin 

screams high end quality and 

originality. 

The fields are highly reflective 

with a bold clarity and brilliant 

depth. The surfaces are glassy 

smooth and devoid of any 

distracting marks or lines. Richly 

and deeply toned surfaces are 

not too dark, and offer beautiful 

violet, blue, orange-gold, and 

rose tone. The sharply struck 

devices are frosty and stand out wonderfully against the mirrored fields. The contrast is great! 

Only 811 Proof dollars were struck in 1889. PCGS 17, NGC 9, CAC 5. Two examples in November 2017 realizing $6,300 and $5,880. 

This GEM sold in March 2012 for $6,613 and the current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $7,750. There are a mere 14 coins graded 

finer in the CAMEO designation at PCGS. A real prize for the Proof Morgan collector. 

PCGS# 87324 | ESTIMATE: $5,500+ 

115


LOT 263 

$1 1891 PCGS PR67 CAM CAC 

WOW, WOW, WOW! This outstanding coin has multiple 

WOW factors going for it. The quality is just amazing! 

Incredible deep mirrors boom (not just beam) from all 

over. The mirrors have tremendous clarity and are super 

clean. When you twirl this coin, the mirrors look like 

free-flowing liquid mercury rolling around. The flash 

of the mirrors is nearly blinding too. The contrast is 

awesome. You can see some faint gold by the rims. Miss 

Liberty and the details are sharply struck and do stand out 

with extra thick frost. The eye appeal is tremendous! 

Only 650 were ever minted. PCGS 2, NGC 15, CAC 2. 

PCGS has graded one 67+ and 2 PR68’s. The last time a 

PR67 Cameo crossed the auction block-2010. That was 

8 years ago! At the time that coin brought only $20,700. 

Today the current Collector s Universe Value is only 

$25,000 and we think it’s WRONG! Because none have 

traded no one has bothered to update the value. Keep in 

mind, there are probably many collections that need this 

date and grade. Be prepared for strong bidding! 

PCGS# 87326 | ESTIMATE: $22,000+ 

116


LOT 264 

$1 1892 PCGS PR65+ CAM 

CAC 

A premium quality GEM Proof 

1892 Morgan dollar. This is 

a highly reflective and ultra 

flashy with a blinding mirrored 

finish to the fields. Smooth, 

icy mirrored fields boast 

the epitome of quicksilver 

brilliance. They are deep and 

beaming offering a strong 

contrast to the frosted struck 

devices. The eye appeal 

is quite nice, with just the 

slightest hint of clear gold that 

frames both sides. 

PCGS 9, NGC 17, CAC 6. There are two PCGS PR65+ CAM graded, neither has ever sold in auction. The last PCGS/CAC 

PR65 CAM sold in January 2013 for $11,750 and no PCGS PR66 CAM CAC ever sold in auction. The current PCGS value is 

listed at $7,500 and we think this one could sell in excess of that amount. 

PCGS# 87327 | ESTIMATE: $6,750+ 

LOT 265 


Here is a wonderfully eye 

appealing GEM 1902 dollar. 

Starting in 1902 the mint 

changed the way Proof dies were 

prepared, and rather than having 

a frosty devices and highly 

polished mirrored fields, the 

entire surface of the dies were 

polished, leaving every part of 

the design reflective. 

This stunning PR65 has a great 

look! The fields are richly 

mirrored and the devices are 

sharply struck up. There are a 

couple of tiny toning dots on the 

reverse which will identify it for posterity. 

Only 777 Proofs were struck. PCGS 27, NGC 45, CAC 8. The most recent PCGS/CAC PR65 to sell in auction realized $6,900 in 

October 2011. This coin ahs been off the market since 2012. This impressive GEM will delight any Proof Morgan collector, keep in mind 

these are not as common as you might think. The current Collector’s Universe value is $5,750. Rare any finer. 

PCGS# 7337 | ESTIMATE: $5,000+ 

117


LOT 266 

$1 1921 CHAPMAN. PCGS PR67 

118


LOT 266 

$1 1921 CHAPMAN. PCGS PR67 

Legend Numismatics and Legend Rare Coin Auctions are proud to have accepted this MONSTER Chapman Proof for our 

November Regency Sale. We all unhesitatingly pronounce this coin to be unquestionably the FINEST EVER Chapman Proof 

that exists. 

Full proof mirrors beam endlessly from all over. The mirrors enjoy great clarity and cleanliness. In fact the only mark we can 

find-is on the holder. All the die polishing marks are as light as we have ever seen (you really need a strong glass to see them). 

The contrast on this coin is amazing and here too we don’t see why it is not called cameo. Miss Liberty and every detail are 

sharply struck. These features also have silvery white frost. The eye appeal is amazing, and your jaw will drop and lock! 

It is estimated only 40 were minted by special request by the Chapman Brothers, coin dealers in Philadelphia in the late 

1800s and early 1900s. Like Farran Zerbe, who also had specially issued Morgan dollars in 1921, they had connections in the 

Philadelphia mint, and they were obliged. The Chapman Proofs look more like the Proofs that were struck in 1878-1904, while 

the Zerbe Proofs (which are more “common” have more of a “Specimen” finish. 

PCGS 1, NGC 1. We believe this is the same coin as the NGC PR67. And get this-the LAST PR66 to sell, sold for $60,375 

in 2000! Think these are incredibly rare or what? If you are building a top or #1 Proof set, this is your only chance at a great 

Chapman Proof. The current Collector Universe Value is $275,000. We can see this coin easily reaching that number. Even if 

you offered $500,000, you have zero chance of another appearing. Good luck and be prepared! 

PCGS# 7342 | ESTIMATE: $225,000+ 

119


LOT 267 

$1 1921 PEACE, HIGH 

RELIEF. PCGS MS66 CAC 

This is the amazing coin that was 

in an intense bidding war that 

brought $18,252.50 in 05/2018. 

Here is what the description said: 

“What a terrific HIGH END 

piece to start this GEM set with. 

Like with his $10 Indians, each 

coin in this set was handpicked 

for its quality and outstanding 

eye appeal. You will NOT be 

disappointed here! Amazing 

surfaces are satiny smooth and 

are super clean. Even using a 

strong glass reveals no flaws- just 

a microscopic tick here and there. A warm glowing luster beams from all over. The surfaces are mostly creamy white and have a hint of 

gold. The obverse clearly offers the great “deep dish” appearance. Miss Liberty and the details are thickly frosted and are fully struck. The 

eye appeal is magnificent! 

PCGS 183, NGC 84, CAC 37. The last PCGS CAC piece to sell in auction brought $12,338 12/2017. We fully expect strong bidding on 

this magnificent GEM 1921 Peace Dollar. Do not be fooled by the pops, these are NOT seen for sale much at all anymore.” 

Obviously other bidders in the room agreed, hence the record price! The current owner has totally changed direction and is moving on. 

LOT 268 

$1 1922 PCGS MS64 

We’ve handled some of the 

world’s greatest toned Morgan 

and Peace Dollars. When this 

coin came into our office, our 

eyes popped out and rolled 

around. In fact it took us a day 

to catch them and put them 

back in. The colors and the 

color scheme are unbelievable 

and best of ANY we have 

ever seen for a Peace Dollar. 

Also, technically, the quality is 

SUPER HIGH END. 

PCGS# 7356 | ESTIMATE: $10,000+ 

We do NOT know why CAC 

did not sticker this coin, but 

we do know CAC (as well as several other known toned experts-including us) all agree the toning is 100% original. Peter Max (the 

world-famous wild color artist) could not have created the patterns of color that coin has. Both the obverse and reverse have mind 

boggling rings of electric violet/amber/pearl green/lime/sky blue that open into white centers with some awesome gold sprays all over. 

Some might consider this bulls eye toning. This really is not a rare coin, its more like a wildly colored masterpiece you frame and put 

on your wall. 

We have never seen anything remotely close to these colors or the color pattern on a Peace Dollar before. There are no printed prices 

anywhere that would even be within 1000% of what this coin is worth. The value is totally in the colors. We sort of equate this to the 

runaway 50C 1958 PCGS MS67 CAC we just sold for $129,250.00. Its near impossible to figure its worth. If you are a toned Peace 

buyer, you will know to figure this coin incredibly strong. We unhesitatingly pronounce this coin to be a once-in -a -lifetime opportunity! 

PCGS# 7357 | ESTIMATE: $6,500+ 

120


LOT 269 


This coin is a high beam 

headlight! For a Peace dollar 

this coin has a BLAZING mint 

luster! Bold cartwheels roll with 

a strong brilliance on both sides. 

The surfaces are very clean and 

free of all but the most minute 

marks and ticks. The eye appeal 

is fantastic. We have marveled at 

it since it came into the office! 


The most recent sold in the 

2018 ANA auction for $11,400. 

Prior to that we sold one in our 

May 2018 Regency Auction for 

$9,400. The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $6,500 and this one will bring in excess of that amount. RARE any finer, this is a 

real prize for any serious Peace dollar collector. Do not pass this opportunity by! 

PCGS# 7364 | ESTIMATE: $5,500+ 

LOT 270 


Despite a mintage of over 

1,000,000 the 34-S is a tough 

date to find in Mint State. In 

MS64 and finer grades it is truly 

very scarce. This very pleasing 

near-GEM example has a 

vibrant, frosty luster that glows 

in the fields and on the devices. 

The design elements are crisply 

rendered and fully brought up 

by a forceful blow of the dies. 

Iridescent silver-white tone 

yields to the lightest pastel tone. 

Minimally marked, the surfaces 

are wonderfully preserved and 

the eye appeal is excellent. 

PCGS 670, NGC 315, CAC 139. PCGS has graded 48 in MS64+. The most recent PCGS/CAC example brought $5,760 in September 

2018. In recent months we sold two examples, one in our August Premier Sessions for $5,775 and one in our July Regency Auction for 

$6,756. The current Collector’s Universe value is listed at $7,450. Very scarce any finer, the most recent CAC-approved MS65 was an 

NGC coin that brought $13,200 in June 2018. 

PCGS# 7377 | ESTIMATE: $5,500+ 

121

SHIP OF GOLD COLLECTION 

Legend Rare Coin Auctions is proud to offer this incredible 

selection of gold coins from the famed “Ship of Gold” the 

S.S. Central America. Included are pieces that are among the 

FINEST KNOWN examples of their respective issues that, if 

not for the time capsule, preserved at the depths of the Atlantic 

Ocean off of the Carolinas, collectors would never be able to 

obtain such high-grade specimens for their collections! 

The story of the sidewheel steamer Central America is 

well known among collectors, ever since the treasure was 

discovered on September 11, 1987. Much has been written 

about the shipwreck, volumes of pages, many articles, etc. 

Here is the brief story. 

After gold was discovered in the America River at Sutter’s 

Mill, California in 1848, a mass migration of people went 

west, looking to stake their claims and reap fortunes in the 

gold fields. Those lucky enough to find gold needed a way to 

convert the raw gold into currency. The overland journey to 

the closest federal mint would take months, so enterprising 

business men established local assay offices and coining 

operations. Some of these were legitimate firms whose 

coins were widely accepted, while others were downright 

fraudulent. Something needed to be done, so in 1854, a federal 

mint was established in San Francisco, tasked with churning 

out millions of gold coins per year from freshly mined ore, 

and gold from other sources (such as earlier “territorial” coins 

that were assayed and converted to federal coinage). 

Travel was very primitive, with overland treks being taken in 

Conestoga and other covered wagons and coaches. Taking this 

route would involve lots of risks, including starvation, disease, 

and possible attacks from Native American tribes. The trip 

could take months over uninviting terrain and hostile areas. The 

other option favored by many was to take a steam ship from 

San Francisco to Panama. A newly completed rail line crossed 

the isthmus at its narrowest point, and another ship would take 

passengers along the eastern route, through the Gulf of Mexico to 

Cuba, then to the Eastern coast of the United States. 

One of the ships that made the eastern leg was the side-wheel 

steamer, the S.S. Central America. The 272-foot ship had 

made the voyage 43 times before, and its September 1857 

trip should have been routine. Carrying a massive cargo of 

gold, valued at $1.6 million dollars in 1857 dollars, and 578 

passengers and crew members, it was heading to New York 

City. The gold was to be delivered in an effort to shore up 

eastern and northern financial institutions that had been caught 

in a speculative bubble involving rail roads and insurance. 

While sailing up the eastern seaboard from Havana, Cuba, 

the ship encountered a massive hurricane off the Carolina 

coast. On September 12, 1857, the ship foundered, taking on 

too much water that put out the fires in the boilers. The ship 

went down, taking with it all that gold and 425 souls. The 

loss caused a massive panic on Wall Street, with a major run 

on the banks. Without the precious cargo of gold coins, many 

banks had to close. The Panic of 1857 was one of the worst 

financial crises in the history of the United States. As the panic 

deepened, it further drove a wedge between the industrial 

and commercial interests of the north and the agrarian based 

economy of the south. Less than four years later, these 

122

differences led to the Civil War. 

In the 1980s, a team of deep-water explorers using state of the 

art equipment searched for the wreckage of the S.S. Central 

America, and nearly 130 years to the day, they found the 

shipwreck. Within a year or two, three tons of gold had been 

recovered. The find proved to be an excellent time capsule, 

revealing much about the coins and ingots of gold that were 

used between banks, as well as what was in people’s personal 

possessions. Awe inspiring amounts of gold, from sacks of 

gold dust, individual rare coins from various U.S., Territiorial, 

and even foreign issues, to large quantities of double eagles 

direct from the mint, to gold bricks assayed by various San 

Francisco firms that weighed from a few to hundreds of 

ounces, were discovered. 

A long legal battle took place. The successor firms of those 

that insured the ship wanted to recover their payout. Finally, in 

1999, the first coins and ingots hit the market in a December 

auction conducted by Sotheby’s in New York City. A second 

sale, conducted by Christie’s and Spink America took place 

in December the following year. The remaining coins, 

mostly 1856 and 1857 double eagles from the San Francisco 

mint were sold by a group of major dealers that formed the 

California Gold Marketing Group. A big splash was made at 

various numismatic conventions in 2000 with the Ship of Gold 

display, one of the most popular exhibits at that year’s ANA 

convention in Philadelphia. 

Another expedition took place in 2014. Again, after much 

legal drama, additional coins were brought up, and again, 

conserved by the experts at PCGS. This time, only 3,154 coins 

total were salvaged. Our sister firm, Legend Numismatics, was 

given an opportunity to buy some of the FINEST examples 

from this second round, including the majority of the 

CAC-approved pieces, and many sold quickly. We have been 

honored with a consignment of coins from this second round. 

Included in this sale are some of the best known examples 

of 1856-S gold dollar, 1857-S quarter eagle, 1857-S half 

eagle, eagle, and double eagle. However, to this cataloger, the 

coolest, most historic piece is the near-Mint State 1853 U.S. 

Assay Office of Gold $20. 

Lots of great information is out there for collectors. In 2002, 

Q. David Bowers authored a 1,000+ page tome, A California 

Gold Rush History, featuring treasure from the S.S. Central 

America, that was published by the California Gold Marketing 

Group. The leader of the expeditions, Tommy Thompson 

wrote about the shipwreck and its recovery in a wonderfully 

illustrated book called America’s Lost Treasure. A more 

novel-like read is Gary Kinder’s colorfully titled, Ship of 

Gold in the Deep Blue Sea, gives a fuller, more descriptive 

accounting of the saga. 

The lots that follow represent relics from one of the most 

historically relevant shipwrecks in American history. While 

all shipwreck recovered coins attract lots of attention from 

advanced collectors and non-numismatic buyers as well, few 

have had the historical impact of the S.S. Central America. 

This is the last group to come up from the ocean floor, so this 

is your last opportunity to acquire these genuine treasure 

ship coins! 

123

THE SHIP OF GOLD COLLECTION 

LOT 271 

G$1 1856-S PCGS AU58+ 

CAC EX S.S. CENTRAL 

AMERICA 

From the second round of 

recovery from the Ship of Gold, 

the S.S. Central America. 

This truly is a wonderful 

example from the shipwreck 

recovery. Regardless of where 

it came from, the 56-S is a very 

scarce date coin with a mintage 

of only 24,600. 

This lightly circulated coin was 

recovered after spending 157 

years on the floor of the Atlantic 

Ocean off the Carolina coast. Surprisingly clean surfaces do have only a few extremely light ticks and giggles. There are no problems that 

are eye catching A bold luster beams from all over. Both sides are a brilliant yellow gold color. There are no spots or discolorations. Miss 

Liberty and the details are incredibly struck and do standout. The eye appeal is super sweet! 

These are in a class all their own. PCGS has graded all the coins from the 2014 recovery, and only 5 1856-S gold dollars recovered graded 

AU58+, and there are only 17 coins graded finer. Regardless of whether it was from the S.S.C.A. or not, no AU58+ has ever sold via 

auction. The last regular AU 58 to sell was NOT CAC approved and sold for $5,400 and it has been 18 years since the last MS61 sold! 

This is a very rare opportunity to acquire a coin that likely was in the pocket of one of the passengers of the ship, not one of the coins that 

was weighing down the cargo hold. The eye appeal is awesome an this is a wonderful historic relic! 

PCGS# 670730 | ESTIMATE: $8,500+ 

LOT 272 

G$1 1856-S/S PCGS 

AU58+ EX S.S. CENTRAL 

AMERICA 

FS-501, the popular repunched 

mintmark variety. While not a 

rarity, this is the ONLY AU58+ 

of the variety that was found on 

the shipwreck. 

Sharply struck the details of this 

Type 2 gold dollar really do stand 

out. Even S/S variety is clearly 

seen with the naked eye. Bold 

luster blooms near the peripheries 

with accents of a reflective flash. 

The light friction in the fields can 

be seen with a glass, but none are 

too distracting. The obverse was shattered when this one was made, with several die cracks that are noted. 

Only four 1856-S/S were recovered and graded by PCGS: AU53; this one; MS62; and MS64. The current PCGS value for an AU58 

1856-S/S is $5,950. With its historic provenance, this coin should bring close to that! Good luck! 

PCGS# 670837 | ESTIMATE: $3,500+ 

124


LOT 273 

G$1 1856-S PCGS MS64 CAC EX S.S. CENTRAL 

AMERICA 

It is amazing to know that even after over a century and 

a half at the bottom of the Atlantic Ocean that a coin like 

this can survive in such PRISTINE condition. Indeed, 

when the powerful hurricane struck the sidewheel 

steamer in September 1857 it created a time capsule, 

which luckily for collectors preserved some of the 

FINEST examples of these rare gold coins. The finest 

known 1856-S gold dollars came from this source. 

This coin looks like it was just struck! The luster is 

dramatic and flashy. Bold satiny fields are generally 

smooth and offer a great brilliant golden look. A strong 

glass reveals only the lightest tick, otherwise anything 

else in the fields are mint made, including some 

roughness in the central reverse, clash marks, and die 

cracks. Every detail is crisply struck up and the eye 

appeal is exceptional! 

PCGS graded just this single MS64 from the ship wreck 

and just two finer, a 64+ and a 65+. PCGS lists a value 

of $72,500 for a non-S.S.C.A. example, but does not 

list a value for a recovery coin. No doubt a coin like 

this is truly worthy of a premium bid from the advanced 

collector. This may be a once in a lifetime opportunity! 

PCGS# 670730 | ESTIMATE: $80,000+ 

125


LOT 274 

$2.50 1856-S PCGS AU58+ 

CAC EX S.S CENTRAL 

AMERICA 

Here is super historical piece 

from a real treasure ship that 

won’t break your budget! The 

quality is more than pleasing. 

A few small ticks can be seen 

scattered around, none are 

serious or harm the grade at 

all. Remember this coin was 

under the sea buried in muck 

for 155+ years. A full booming 

luster beams from all over. Both 

sides are a brilliant yellow gold 

color. There are no spots or 

discolorations. Miss Liberty and the details are frosty and are sharply struck. The eye appeal is excellent! 

For this date and grade in PCGS , only 5 with 19 more were found. The regular PCGS pop is 24 in AU58 and one in AU58+. CAC has 

beaned 13 total in AU58. In the end, these are not really common or even close. The opportunity here to own a Ship Wreck coin with little 

to no premium is rarer the the coin! 

PCGS# 670753 | ESTIMATE: $3,500+ 

126


LOT 275 

$2.50 1856-S PCGS MS64+ CAC EX S.S CENTRAL 

AMERICA 

It is not hard to see why this is one of the absolute 

finest 1856-S quarter eagles that survives to this day. 

The quality is SUPERB! What is surprising is that after 

spending 155 years on the ocean floor, it can exist in 

such a pristine state of preservation. 

Just a few tiny ticks keep this coin from a full MS65 

designation. Overall, the surfaces are pretty clean. A 

full booming luster beams all over. Both sides are a 

brilliant gold color. There are NO spots or discolorations 

(remember this coin had sea floor crust all over it). 

Miss Liberty and the details are sharply struck and do 

standout. The eye appeal is great! 

The PCGS Ship Wreck pop for this coin 1 with only 2 

higher. The regular PCGS pop is 0. CAC has beaned 

total of 4 coins (Ship wreck and non ship wreck 

included). The extreme rarity of this date and grade are 

more then proven. 

PCGS# 670753 | ESTIMATE: $28,000+ 

127


LOT 276 

$2.50 1857-S PCGS AU58 

CAC EX S.S. CENTRAL 

AMERICA 

If this coin had not been in a ship 

wreck holder, you would never 

know it sat at the bottom of the 

Atlantic Ocean for 155+ years. 

The coin is HIGH END.There 

are just a few tiny ticks scattered 

around. The surfaces do appear 

clean and smooth to the naked 

eye. A bold luster beams from 

all over. Both sides are a brilliant 

gold color. There are NO spots or 

discolorations. Miss Liberty and 

the details are frosty and are well 

struck (all wear is super light and is well hidden). The eye appeal is great! 

For this date from the Ship, PCGS has graded 9, with 31 higher. A regular non ship wreck PCGS pop is 18 in AU58. NO regular PCGS 

CAC piece has ever been sold via auction. CAC has beaned a total of 13 coins in AU 58 (Central America included). A coin like this 

represents a great value for the collector of rare date gold that has the added cache of being from the Ship of Gold! 

PCGS# 670754 | ESTIMATE: $3,600+ 

OUR ESTIMATES 












128


LOT 277 

$2.50 1857-S PCGS MS64+ CAC EX S.S CENTRAL 

AMERICA 

Forget about this coin being a treasure ship find; 

regardless it is tied for being the FINEST 1857-S $2.50! 

This date and grade are as rare as any classic rarity. The 

quality is absolutely stunning! Surprising fully prooflike 

surfaces have deep mirrors that beam all over. Only 

under a strong glass can you see a little roughness of 

the planchet from where they took off 155+ years of 

muck. The color is a deeper orange gold and there are 

NO discolorations. Miss Liberty and the details are so 

sharply struck thy look sculpted. The eye appeal is jaw 

dropping for sure! 

The Ship Wreck pop is 2 , none higher. The regular 

NON Ship Wreck pop is 1 in MS64 with NONE higher. 

CAC has beaned 2 in MS64 (obviously this coin is one). 

The rarity of this date can not be disputed. Its amazing 

this coin even exists. If you are building a great $2.5 

Collection, this coin is a “must buy:”. For its rarity, there 

really is no premium. The other MS64+ is in the #1 Ship 

Wreck Type set that is being shopped around for insane 

money and will be sold only as a set. Once this coin here 

is sold, you will never find another. Good luck! 

PCGS# 670754 | ESTIMATE: $50,000+ 

129


LOT 278 

$5 1857-S PCGS MS63+ CAC EX S.S. CENTRAL 

AMERICA 

Forget about is being a Ship Wreck piece, this is one 

HIGH END and really neat coin! Not only is it fully 

CHOICE, it has a superb look! 

Only a few trivial ticks and marks can be seen and they 

do not stand out-you really need a glass to see them. 

Indeed, they only show up because the surfaces are fully 

prooflike, and no, the prooflike mirrors are not from the 

conservation. Obviously several of these pieces were 

early strikes and there actually is a touch of contrast. Miss 

Liberty and the details have thick frosting and are sharply 

struck. The eye appeal is fabulous! 

This is the ONLY MS63+ from the wreck. In higher 

grades from the ship PCGS has graded only 7 more. It 

should be noted that regular MS63 pieces are a pop of 4. 

The Collector’s Universe Value for those is only $29,000, 

which seems very cheap to us; for this coin, Collector’s 

Universe suggests a value of $32,500, which again, seems 

cheap. The historic importance of this shipwreck on 

American history really should add a strong premium! 

PCGS# 670803 | ESTIMATE: $35,000+ 

130


LOT 279 

$10 1857-S PCGS MS64 CAC EX S.S. CENTRAL 

AMERICA 

Wow! This coin is simply amazing. Its bold, booming 

luster swirls around the surfaces like a 1901-S! The 

surfaces are exceptionally clean and were it not for a 

single thin hairline and a strike through on the cheek, we 

believe this coin would have at least gotten a “+”. The 

strike is simply AMAZING, with full definition to the 

devices. As mentioned the only real mark of consequence, 

we believe was made by the mint; there might have been 

a scrap of metal or other debris on the die that was struck 

into the cheek and then fell out. This is not a scratch, the 

texture is not smooth or shiny. The color is brilliant and 

bright yellow-gold with a superb look! 

The shipwreck population is 1, with just a single MS64+ 

finer. Collector’s Universe value is listed at $90,000 and 

keep in mind that the last MS64 to sell was from the first 

round of S.S. Central America recovery coins, that was 

not CAC and it sold for $53,188 nearly a decade ago! 

Bested by just a single coin, this is worthy of the FINEST 

$10 Lib set, not just ship wreck coins! 

PCGS# 670818 | ESTIMATE: $60,000+ 

131


LOT 280 

$20 1855-S 14C S TILTED RIGHT. PCGS 

AU53 

Ex S.S. CENTRAL AMERICA. Housed in the 

original gold foil holder with cert # 6382.This 

is a sharply struck example with bold details on 

both sides. The initial eye appeal is of a higher 

grade coin for sure. There is a strong eye appeal 

especially for a coin of this grade, that often does 

not possess so much surviving luster. There are 

some minor marks, easy to forgive on a coin that 

was lightly circulated before going down with 

the ship. 

PCGS 151, NGC 182. Cert# 6386, also AU53 

sold in June 2011 for $6,900, and that appears to be the most recent example to sell in auction. A great opportunity to add a very 

cool early S-mint $20 with a very historic provenance. 

LOT 281 

$20 1856-S 17J SPLIT SERIF. PCGS AU53 

Ex S.S. Central America and housed in the original 

gold foil slab with cert# 5304.Very high end for 

the assigned grade, there is just the slightest hint of 

friction on the highly lustrous surfaces. There is a 

bold luster that still survives in the fields and has 

a distinctive reflective texture that you just do not 

often see on a no motto double eagle in 53. There 

is some shipwreck residue on the reverse, showing 

how mildly conserved these were when they were 

brought up off the ocean floor. There are a few 

minor marks, but nothing you would not expect for 

a mildly circulated early double eagle. 

PCGS# 70041 | ESTIMATE: $4,250+ 

PCGS 288, NGC 192. As a shipwreck coin, the market value exceeds that of the PCGS price, the most recent APR we can find for an ex 

S.S.C.A. AU53 was in June 2015, where one sold for $4,700. Very much worthy of any collection of double eagles or a specialized collection 

of shipwreck gold coins. What a neat and historic relic! 

PCGS# 70019 | ESTIMATE: $4,200+ 

LOT 282 

$20 1857-S 20E BROKEN A. PCGS MS60 

Ex S.S. Central America, housed in the original 

gold foil holder, cert# 2618.Much nicer than 

the modest MS60 grade might suggest! Highly 

lustrous with flashes of mild reflection in the 

fields. The devices are very sharply struck up and 

have a great look, despite the small scuffs and 

ticks. The eye appeal really is very nice for the 

grade. The Broken A is clearly a scarcer variant of 

57-S. The number graded pales in comparison to 

the Spike Shield varieties which made up a large 

number of double eagles recovered. 

PCGS 83, NGC 8. PCGS has graded 8 from this 

variety in MS60. No MS60 has sold in auction before. The current PCGS value is listed at $5,600. This is a much better looking coin than the 

grade might suggest. A very neat coin for any gold collector. The appeal of this coin is high end and should garner lots of bidding activity. 

PCGS# 70004 | ESTIMATE: $4,500+ 

132


LOT 283 

$20 1857-S 20A, SPIKED 

SHIELD. PCGS MS62 

Ex S.S. Central America and 

housed in the original gold foil 

holder with cert # 3726. 

Glowing satin luster beams with 

ultra strong radiating surface. 

This one was likely stored in a 

bag where other 57-S double 

eagles had contact with the 

surfaces, but none of the minor 

marks or scuffs have an overly 

negative effect on the CHOICE 

eye appeal. Sharply struck up 

devices stand out against the rich 

orange gold color. The eye appeal 

is excellent for the assigned grade. 

PCGS 542, NGC 22. The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $6,500 and it is interesting to note that none of the recent MS62s 

that have sold recently are housed in the original S.S.C.A. holders. A very historic relic of this important shipwreck. A great coin for any 

double eagle collector, gold stacker, or any collector of shipwreck relics. 

PCGS# 70000 | ESTIMATE: $5000+ 

LOT 284 

$20 1857-S 20A SPIKED 

SHIELD. PCGS MS64 

Ex S.S. Central America. 

Housed in the original gold foil 

holder from the first recovery of 

the ship wreck. With 

cert# A1637. 

This is a highly lustrous, near 

GEM example. Having a rich 

orange-gold color that comes to 

life with the radiating, glowing, 

incandescent luster. The strike is 

razor sharp, and the eye appeal 

is not marred by the few tiny 

ticks that can be seen. You might 

imagine that a coin that sank to 

the bottom of the ocean would have been much more hacked up. This one is not and the look is great! 

PCGS 1087, NGC 103 in all designations. The last one sold for $8,700 and it did not have the exceptional eye appeal of this one. The 

current PCGS value is listed at $10,500. A great coin for any holding of double eagles or shipwreck gold. 

PCGS# 70000 | ESTIMATE: $8,250+ 

133


LOT 285 

$20 1857-S PCGS MS67 CAC EX S.S. CENTRAL 

AMERICA 

Legend Rare Coin Auctions is proud to offer this 

magnificent and extremely historical SUPERB GEM 

Type 1 $20. We shake our heads in bewilderment that this 

coin actually sat on the ocean floor for so many years and 

survived in an unheard of condition like this defies logic! 

We consider this coin to be a legit MS67.9+! We can 

not imagine a finer Type 1 Double Eagle could ever 

exist (none do).Clearly this is one of the FINEST Type 1 

Double Eagles that exists! 

Unbelievable surfaces are exactly that. Even using a 

strong glass and skimming the satiny surfaces for a few 

minutes will yield you NO imperfections-not even tiny 

ones. A full glowing luster beams boldly from all over. 

Both sides have a crisp and deeper orange gold on the 

rims that opens into lighter yellow gold centers. There are 

NO spots or discolorations. Miss Liberty and every detail 

are frosty and are fully struck. The eye appeal is jaw 

dropping and then some! 

For this group from the wreck, the PCGS pop is 3 with 

just the + as higher. The pre 2014 dive pop is PCGS 8, 

NGC 0. CAC has beaned a total of only 3 coins. Our 

sister firm, Legend Numismatics, has sold one MS67 

from the original batch and one from this new batch. 

There is this coin, another and the MS67+ (for crazy 

money) that are the only MS67’s available. ALL coins 

are now graded and are accounted for. Prior to this wreck 

being discovered, there was no such thing as even an 

MS64! Clearly this is a once in a life time opportunity. 

PCGS# 670713 | ESTIMATE: $165,000+ 

134


LOT 286 

$20 1853 U.S.A.O.G. 900 FINE. PCGS AU58+ CAC 

EX S.S. CENTRAL AMERCIA. 

The U.S. Assay Office of Gold essentially operated as 

a provisional U.S. mint from 1851 to 1853, first under 

the supervision of Moffat & Co and Augustus Humbert, 

then under Curtis, Perry, and Ward after Moffat retired in 

early 1852. With their strong reputation, the U.S.A.O.G. 

churned out millions of coins, according to Kagin, from 

March 1853 to October 1853, about 2.5 million were 

struck. This K-18 variety was struck from a large number 

of dies, which were destroyed during the Great Fire of 

1906. While the mintage was very large, many of these 

$20 gold pieces were returned to the mint and melted, 

then restruck into federal issued double eagles. 

This is a great example of a very popular type that really 

should be considered a federally issued coin. While more 

than four years had passed between the time the coin was 

struck and the S.S. Central America sank, the present 

coin saw virtually no circulation. We highly believe that 

it was in the pocket of some poor soul who went into 

the turbulent, storm tossed waters in September 1857, 

perhaps as a good luck charm. Both sides show a full, 

glowing, satiny lustrous frost that rolls uninterrupted 

across the obverse. Sharply struck up devices show full 

definition in all of the details. This large coin is devoid 

of any major scuffs or scrapes. The eye appeal of this 

awesome territorial is very high end! 

The Ship Wreck had a PCGS pop of 4 in AU58+ and only 

4 coins higher. In regular NON Ship Wreck, the PCGS 

AU58+ pop is zero. We estimate CAC has beaned only 

2 in AU58+ (and we have the other). It should be noted 

the last PCGS AU58 (no +) CAC piece to sell in auction 

brought $13,200 in April 2018, and that coin did not have 

the cache of being from this historic ship wreck. 

PCGS# 675717 | ESTIMATE: $18,000+ 

135


LOT 287 

G$1 1849-D PCGS MS62 CAC 

This is a great coin for the gold 

coin collector. The gold dollar was 

authorized in 1849, and the first 

year of issue in Dahlonega, saw a 

fairly generous mintage of 21,588, 

making this the most available in 

Mint State (although they are quite 

scarce). PCGS CoinFacts estimates 

35 Mint State coins survive, which 

is probably on the lower side, as 

there are more certified examples 

than that.The presently offered 

coin is almost fully Prooflike on 

the obverse and the reverse is a 

little more frosty. The devices are 

sharply struck and Longacre’s Liberty Head is frosted and stands out with a cameo-like appeal. Struck from clashed and cracked dies, 

this beauty has a very high end and totally original look. Very rare any finer, this MS62 looks better than the grade would suggest and 

will be a delightful addition to any set! 

PCGS 30, NGC 30, CAC 6. We think there is quite a bit of duplication in the population reports, where coins have been cracked and 

crossed and their tags not returned. Based on auction appearances, there are probably less than 50 individual examples in 62. Four 

PCGS/CAC coins have sold in the $6,169 to $11,163 range, with the last two bringing $8,2252 and $7,500. The current Collector’s 

Universe value of $7,400 reflects the lower prices that non-CAC coins have sold for. This coin is truly worthy of a strong bid and will 

delight any collector of Southern branch gold. 

PCGS# 7507 | ESTIMATE: $7,000+ 

LOT 288 

G$1 1851-D PCGS XF45 CAC 

While the mintage was only 9,882, the 51-D gold 

dollar is one of the more available dates in the 

series. That said, many 51-D’s have been cleaned, 

damaged, or conserved that are not as visually 

alluring as the present CHOICE XF. Graded ages 

ago, and encapsulated in a first generation PCGS 

slab, a wealth of luster survives in the protected 

areas. Light wear can be seen on the highest points 

of the obverse, but the details are bold and crisp. 

Rich orange-gold patina graces both sides and we 

see only a light mark in the obverse field, which we 

note for accuracy. The eye appeal is excellent for 

the assigned grade. 

PCGS 12, NGC 4, CAC 1. There is a record for a PCGS/CAC coin selling for $2,185 in 2011, but that is not this coin. The current 

PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $2,600, and this coin is totally fresh to the market and worthy of a strong bid! 


136


LOT 289 

G$1 1851-O PCGS MS65 

A lovely GEM example of this 

New Orleans mint gold dollar. 

Vibrantly lustrous surfaces have 

a satiny/frosty glow that gives 

the obverse a lovely contrast 

between the devices and the 

smooth, surrounding fields. Both 

sides are indeed crisply struck 

up with very little weakness 

seen anywhere. The surfaces 

are clean and free of any marks, 

lines, or discolorations. There 

is a minor planchet flake on 

the reverse, which may be why 

CAC did not bean this GEM. 

The eye appeal, otherwise, is 

very high end. 

PCGS 24, NGC 14. The last non-CAC approved example sold in auction back in August 2010--seems like yesterday, but was eight 

years ago! The most recent example to sell was a CAC-approved coin that brought $12,925 in August 2015. The current PCGS Price 

Guide value is $9,500. RARE any finer with just half a dozen examples graded higher, this is a great choice for any gold dollar or 

New Orleans gold collector. 

PCGS# 7516 | ESTIMATE: $8,000+ 

LOT 290 

G$1 1883 NGC MS67 CAC 

This really is a high end GEM! Boasting frosty gold mint luster 

radiates on both sides of this rich amber-orange gold two tone 

gold dollar. Well struck and even with a strong glass we are hard 

pressed to find ANY flaws worth mention. 

PCGS 125, NGC 71, CAC 52. The last NGC/CAC coin sold in 

auction in June 2016 for $4,713. More recently PCGS/CAC coins 

sold in the $3,000-$3,760 range. Clearly the current Collector’s 

Universe value is negatively affected by low APRs for non-CAC 

coins. A great late date with a low mintage of 10,800 and would 

make a nice representative of the type in a well chosen gold type set. 

PCGS# 7584 | ESTIMATE: $2,900+ 

137



G$1 1887 PCGS MS68 CAC 

At first glance, this coin looks like a Proof! In our 

opinion, this coin is closer to a 69, than a 68. Really! 

Remarkable deep mirrors beam boldly from all over. The 

mirrors are ultra clean and have amazing clarity. The 

pop/flash is intense. When you twirl this coin all you see 

are rolling mirrors and nearly blinding flash. Still hard 

to believe it is MS and not a proof. Both sides enjoy a 

gorgeous and totally original yellow gold color. There are 

NO spots or discolorations. Miss Liberty and every detail 

are needle sharp in strike. They have frost so thick it 

looks like it was carved from a frosted block of polished 

gold. The eye appeal is totally jaw dropping! 

PCGS 4, NGC 4, CAC 5. The last PCGS MS68 CAC to 

sell in auction brought $35,250 in August 2015. We can 

see this monster of a GEM bringing that or more today! 

Be prepared! 

PCGS# 7588 | ESTIMATE: $30,000+ 

138



$2.50 1846-O NGC 

MS63+ CAC 

This coin ranks 

among the FINEST 

KNOWN of this 

very scarce New 

Orleans mint quarter 

eagle. Estimates 

suggest that about 

nine and twelve 

Mint State coins 

survive and this one 

ranks as third finest 

graded at NGC, 

PCGS has graded 

just two coins finer. 

This is a particularly 

attractive, fully 

CHOICE example. 

Boasting a very strong strike for the date, the details are each very well defined, except for some light weakness on the central reverse. 

Even with that, it is very crisp for a 46-O. The surfaces are delicately toned and there are just a few minor scuffs and ticks that account 

for the assigned grade, but none are distracting. The eye appeal is very high end! 

PCGS 1, NGC 3, CAC 2. It is interesting to note that NO PCGS coin in MS63 or MS64 has sold in auction since 2004. An NGC 

MS63 sold in the 2017 FUN auction for $12,925 and an NGC MS64 in October 2011 for $23,000. The current Collector’s Universe 

value is listed at $21,000. This may well be the FINEST example that you will be able to obtain in quite some time. NGC has graded a 

64 and a 66 finer; PCGS has graded a 64 and 65 finer, but these all seem to be locked away in advanced collections. Truly worthy of a 

great collection! 

PCGS# 7743 | ESTIMATE: $18,000+ 


$2.50 1847-D PCGS AU58 

From an original mintage of 15,784, PCGS CoinFacts estimates 

about 225 survive in all grades today. While “common” in terms 

of Dahlonega quarter eagles, it is rare in AU58 and VERY rare in 

Mint State. 

Just a touch of friction on the highest points and in the 

semi-reflective luster in the fields. Satiny throughout, the strike 

is strong and contrasts with the richness of the orange gold color. 

There are a few minor marks, the most serious of which is seen on 

the reverse. 

PCGS 21, NGC 44. The most recent example sold in August 2015 for $4,994 and the current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at 

$5,000. Prior to that, one sold for $6,325. Only 22 coins are graded finer at PCGS. This one has not sold in auction for at least eight 

years. Good luck! 

PCGS# 7746 | ESTIMATE: $4,500+ 

139



$2.50 1848 CAL. PCGS MS62+ CAC 

LRCA is proud to offer this almost once in a lifetime 

amazing coin. Between us and our sister company Legend 

Numismatics, we have only seen two others total in our 

40+ year career in Mint State (and one was the MS68 we 

badly regret not buying many years ago). In addition to 

being ultra-rare, this coin is a no question SUPER HIGH 

END piece. 

Amazing prooflike surfaces catch your attention 

unexpectedly. The surfaces are remarkably clean and 

smooth. Only if you use a strong glass can you find a few 

light lines and a small tick on the lower right obverse. 

Nothing stands out. The mirrors beam from all over and 

actually are highly reflective. No question this coin is 

original and never has been messed with. Miss Liberty 

and every detail has been fully struck and stands out. The 

CAL is amazing to see. There actually is slight contrast 

on this coin too. The eye appeal is exceptional! 

An incredibly historic and important coin, a classic in 

the the annals of American numismatics. After gold was 

discovered in the America River in California in 1848 

near Sutter’s Mill, 228 ounces were sent back east in 

December of that year by the military governor, Col. 

R.B. Mason, directed to the Secretary of War, William 

Marcy. The gold was to be used to strike gold medals for 

General Zachary Taylor and General Winfield Scott--any 

remaining metal was to be used to strike quarter eagles, 

with “CAL.” stamped in the field to recognize the 

historical significance of the source of the gold, resulting 

in a mintage of 1,389 pieces. The gold rush that ensued 

created one of the largest mass migrations in history, and 

changed the course of not just American history, but also 

world history. 

PCGS 7, NGC 3, CAC 1. This is the ONLY MS62+-and 

the ONLY MS62 that is CAC. In MS63 PCGS has 

graded 3 with 3 beans (where heck are they) and 5 in 

MS64-NONE beaned and of course the sick MS68-which 

would bean. In true Mint State you have very few to 

choose from. That is why cleaned AU58’s sell for as 

much as $75,000 -there are no Mint State pieces to be 

found. It is our strong opinion, this coin is a once in a 

few years piece. Think hard to when the last time was you 

saw ANY Mint State piece especially one that was CAC. 

Opportunity knocks loud here! 

PCGS# 7749 | ESTIMATE: $130,000+ 

140



$2.50 1879 PCGS MS65 

This is lovely, satiny, frosty GEM, with rich orange-peach-golden 

tone. Sharply struck and highly lustrous, there are less than a 

dozen examples graded finer. A few minor microscopic lines keep 

this coin from a higher grade. 

PCGS 25, NGC 20. The most recent non-CAC example to sell in 

auction realized $3,055 over two years ago and the current PCGS 

value is listed at $3,900. The value more than doubles the next 

grade up. 

PCGS# 7830 | ESTIMATE: $2,700+ 


$2.50 1906 NGC MS67 CAC 

A superb example, with a frosty mint bloom that shines on 

both sides, and a soft satiny glow that surrounds the sharply 

struck devices. The surfaces are clean, smooth and free of any 

distracting marks or lines. The eye appeal is SUPERB. 

PCGS 73, NGC 79, CAC 32. The last CAC-approved example 

to sell in auction realized $5,175 in December 2011. DO NOT 

LET THE CAC POPS FOOL YOU. These do appear at auction 

with any regularity. The current Collector’s Universe value is 

listed at $2,850. 

PCGS# 7858 | ESTIMATE: $3,000+ 

141



$2.50 1876 PCGS PR67 DCAM 

We can unhesitatingly call this SUPERB 1876 quarter 

eagle as the FINEST KNOWN. Truly a treasure of the 

centennial year, a coin that is always popular among 

collectors. Only 45 Proofs were struck, more than double 

that of the 1875 and 1877; but these appear about as 

often in auction; John Dannreuther opines that perhaps 

in celebration of the centennial, non-numismatic buyers 

bought Proofs from the mint, and they were not cared 

for in the same way those bought by collectors were, so 

today, about 20-25 are thought to survive in all grades. 

The deep beaming mirrors and stunning ultra cameo 

contrast arrest the viewer’s gaze from a mile away. Traces 

of orange-peel texture in the fields remain, suggesting 

that this was a somewhat later strike when the initial 

finish on the dies wore off. The mirrors are deep and 

bold, with a clarity that is uninterrupted by any lines. 

A very powerful glass reveals a couple of natural, mint 

made planchet flakes that do not detract from the simply 

stunning and SUPERB eye appeal. The devices are razor 

sharp in strike and are fully frosted, which developed the 

exciting cameo contrast that is about as complete as can 

be imagined. This coin is so beautifully preserved it can 

be called a miracle. 

PCGS 1, NGC 1. Obviously the majority of ALL Proof 

Liberty Head quarter eagles in SUPERB grades are from 

the 1890s and 1900. For a major RARITY like this, you 

cannot look at type prices. The Collector’s Universe value 

is listed at $120,000. This is an AMAZING opportunity 

for any advanced collector! Do not let it pass you by! 

This is could be a once in a generation chance to add this 

coin to your collection! Good luck! 

PCGS# 97902 | ESTIMATE: $85,000+ 

142



$2.50 1888 PCGS PR66 CAM CAC 

The FINEST CAMEO graded at PCGS, and one of the 

highest numerically graded 1888 Proof quarter eagle that 

exists. We are proud to offer this numismatic treasure, a 

coin that is bound to excite any serious collector. 

Deeply mirrored fields gleam with a bold and highly 

desirable orange peel effect. Even at arm’s length, the 

facets of the textured surfaces glimmer, glint, and gleam 

from all over. The razor sharp devices show a delicate 

frostiness that stands out in stark contrast with the 

surrounding mirrors. Clearly a coin that comes from an old 

holding, the surfaces show a touch of iridescent haze over 

the rich orange-gold patina attesting to the originality. A 

strong glass reveals no serious marks of any kind; this coin 

really is a delight to behold and look at. You will have a 

hard time putting this coin down. 

Only 92 Proofs were struck, perhaps 35-45 examples 

survive for collectors today. PCGS 1, NGC 0, CAC 1. 

There is only one PR67 CAM at NGC, which does not 

appear to be this coin. There is one PR66 (no mention of 

designation) at PCGS, that has not sold in 15 years. In 

PR66 DCAM, PCGS has graded 3 and one in 67 DCAM 

(none of these have ever sold in auction). The only relevant 

APRs we can find are as follows: PCGS PR65+ CAM 

CAC that sold in the November 2010 Stack’s Sale of the 

W.C. Carson Collection, which realized $27,600 and the 

aforementioned NGC PR67 CAM that brought $39,950 

in May 2016 (a weaker market). The current PCGS Price 

Guide value is listed at $50,000 and we can see this one 

selling for a level near that when the gavel finally drops. A 

real prize for the advanced collector, this GEM Proof $2.50 

will be a highlight in any collection it graces. 

PCGS# 87914 | ESTIMATE: $35,000+ 

143



$2.50 1894 PCGS PR67 DCAM CAC 

As we have said forever “Proof gold is the caviar of 

numismatics”. This coin more than proves that! 

Exceedingly deep mirrors seem endless. The mirrors 

enjoy bold clarity and are super clean. The reflectivity of 

this coin nearly blinds you. Miss Liberty and every detail 

are needle sharp in strike and are fully struck. The details 

are bathed in thick golden frost. The eye appeal is 

heart pounding! 

Only 122 were minted. PCGS 3, NGC 6, CAC 3. The 

last one to sell in auction brought $39,950 in April 2015. 

With a pop of only 3 (and NONE higher) these, certainly 

do NOT grow on trees! It probably will take a few years 

before you have an opportunity to buy another PR67 

DCAM like this! We expect strong bidding here, 

good luck! 

PCGS# 97920 | ESTIMATE: $35,000+ 

144


LOT 300 

$2.50 1896 PCGS PR67+ DCAM CAC 

Wow! Every time we go to the vault we have to take 

this beauty out and look at it. It really is the epitome of 

perfection! The WOW factor here is beyond sanity, it truly 

is heaven sent! 

Mega MONSTER, ultra-deep mirrors beam boldly from 

all over. The mirrors have remarkable depth, clarity, 

cleanliness, and yes, you do need to wear Ray Bans when 

viewing the coin (The flash is that blinding). When you 

twirl the coin, the mirrors look like a freshly made sheet of 

glass. The contrast is phenomenal. Miss Liberty and every 

detail look like they were carved from a frosted block of 

gold. The eye appeal is insane! 

ONLY 132 were minted. PCGS 4, NGC 5, CAC 2. PCGS 

has graded only 1 coin higher. We scratch our heads as to 

how the Collector’s Universe value could only be $45,500 

then. We think the coin is worth more! Good luck finding 

crazy looking Proof Gold like this! A great coin for any 

high end Proof Gold type set, or date set of quarter eagles. 

PCGS# 97922 | ESTIMATE: $42,500+ 

145


LOT 301 


A VERY HIGH END and stunning SUPERB GEM piece. 

One look and you’ll agree why Proof Gold is considered 

the “caviar of numismatics.” 

Amazing super deep mirrors beam boldly from all over. 

The mirrors are remarkably clean, have intense clarity, 

and are of course intensely reflective. When you twirl the 

coin, the mirrors run like a watery river of gold from side 

to side. The contrast is dramatic. Both sides are a brilliant 

gold color; there are no spots or discolorations. Miss 

Liberty and the details are thickly frosted and are pinpoint 

sharp in strike. It looks like this coin was carved from a 

block of frosted gold. The eye appeal is simply 

breath taking! 

ONLY 205 minted. PCGS 8, NGC 8, CAC 11. Prior to 

this one selling in our July 2018 Regency Auction for 

$37,600, the last PCGS CAC piece to sell in auction 

brought $39,950 in the 2018 FUN auction. Our collector 

has upgraded this type in his set and is selling this one 

again. But as time goes on, Proof Gold has turned out 

to be one of the most difficult types of coins to find. 

You can’t beat buying unmessed with better gold at any 

premium! This coin will be a stand out in ANY GEM 

Proof $2.50 set or any Type set. It’s also okay just to buy 

as one heck of a neat coin! 

PCGS# 97926 | ESTIMATE: $32,000+ 

146


LOT 302 


WOW! THIS IS GODZILLA! What a sensational Ultra 

Black and Gold Proof piece. We have no idea why this 

coin is not at the very least a +. Ultra deep and virtually 

endless mirrors explode from all over. The mirrors display 

the ultimate in clarity and cleanliness. You can’t ask for 

any more flash. When you twirl the coin, the mirrors look 

like an intense river of molten yellow gold streaming 

around the surfaces. The contrast is mind boggling! Miss 

Liberty and every detail are needle sharp in strike and have 

GEMMY thick iridescent gold frost. Your eyes will pop out 

and roll all over when the lay eyes on this monster! This 

is the final date that was struck with the heavily polished 

fields and frosted reliefs, starting in 1902, the method 

of preparation of Proof dies changed, making them the 

polished brilliant look from 1902 to 1907. 

ONLY 223 minted. PCGS 8, NGC 9, CAC 7. Hard to 

believe PCGS may have graded 2 in PR68 DCameo-WOW 

(neither are beaned)! We can’t say enough how desirable 

all PCGS GEM Proof gold is these days. This coin will 

improve ANY SUPERB GEM set while creating a higher 

bar of quality and eye appeal! 

PCGS# 97927 | ESTIMATE: $35,000+ 

147


LOT 303 

$2.50 1908 PCGS MS65 

A GEM example of the first year of Bela Pratt’s unique, incuse 

Indian Head design. Lovely olive-gold accents over rose-gold 

fields, this frosty quarter eagle has a great look. Only a few tiny 

ticks are noted, but none that are distracting. Fresh to the market, 

housed in a first generation PCGS holder. 

PCGS 565, NGC 354. The last one sold in June 2018 for $2,400; 

prior to that, one sold in March for $2,040. The current PCGS 

value is $2,500 and these are very scarce finer. 

PCGS# 7939 | ESTIMATE: $2,000+ 

LOT 304 

$2.50 1911 PCGS MS65+ CAC 

This is a special 1911 quarter eagle, among the FINEST graded, 

just a single MS66 finer at PCGS. 

We love the coin’s look! Satiny brilliance can be seen on both 

sides accentuating the smooth fields. The details are crisply 

impressed into the planchet. The eye appeal is excellent. 

PCGS 162, NGC 163, CAC 56. There are fifteen graded in 65+ 

with a SINGLE MS66 finer. There hasnt been a PCGS MS65+ 

CAC sold in auction since February 2016, which realized 

$5,405. Since then, two PCGS MS65 CAC have sold in excess 

of that, one from the AJ Vanderbilt collection that brought 

$9,000 in March 2018 and one in November 2017 for $7,200. 

Today, if the MS66 was to sell in auction it would likely sell for 

$45,000-$50,000! What a great opportunity for the advanced 

collector of Indian Head quarter eagles. 

PCGS# 7942 | ESTIMATE: $6,500+ 

LOT 305 

$2.50 1912 PCGS MS64 CAC 

A vibrant golden luster blooms on both sides of this pleasing, 

well struck, near-GEM example. Some minor contact and a single 

toning spot on the obverse but the eye appeal is very strong for 

the assigned grade. 


example to sell in auction realized $2,056 in July 2018 and before 

that one sold for $2,880 in December 2017 and the prior one sold 

in November 2016 for $3,055. The current PCGS price is $2,350. 

Keep in mind at PCGS/CAC MS65 will cost $11,000 or more! If 

you are building a set of $2.50 Indians, this 1912 will fit nicely in 

any GEM set without breaking the bank. 

PCGS# 7944 | ESTIMATE: $1,800+ 

LOT 306 

$2.50 1914-D PCGS MS64 

Here is a nice example of this semi-scarce date--it is common 

in lower grade Mint State, but RARE in GEM, making MS64 a 

great level for most collectors. The present coin is just a single 

abrasion from CAC approval and perhaps an even higher grade. 

Frosty surfaces show a honey wheat gold with accents of olive 

that contrast with the sharply struck, incuse devices. 

PCGS 800, NGC 1044. The current Collector’s Universe value is 

$2,250 and the most recent to sell brought $1,680 in September 

2018. Keep in mind that the CU value in MS65 is $20,000! This 

handsome coin will fit nicely in any Mint State set. 

PCGS# 7947 | ESTIMATE: $1,500+ 

148


LOT 307 

$2.50 1915 PCGS MS65+ CAC 

An exceptional GEM example. While not a rare date, they are 

scarce in MS65 and RARE any finer. Indeed, only six coins have 

been graded finer at PCGS. A glowing, radiant mint luster blooms 

brilliantly on both sides in smooth surfaces and the deeply 

impressed devices. Boasting a wonderful eye appeal, this coin has 

an amazing fresh look. 

PCGS 201, NGC 199, CAC 62. PCGS has graded 13 in MS65+ 

and only six finer. The last PCGS/CAC coin to sell in auction 

realized $5,760 in September 2017. The current PCGS Price 

Guide value is listed at $5,250. Keep in mind a PCGS/CAC 

MS66 will likely cost $25,000+ if you could find one! This is a 

great coin for any advanced collector. 

LOT 308 

$2.50 1927 PCGS MS65 

Satiny luster blooms on the GEM quality surfaces. Sharply 

impressed, the incuse devices are crisp and fully rendered. 

Wonderful, highly original surfaces have a rich golden-orange 

hue, we are not 100% sure why CAC did not bean this one. 

Housed in a first generation PCGS slab. 

PCGS 514, NGC 429. The current Collector’s Universe value 

is listed at $1,750 and the recent APRs are $1,680; $1,560; and 

$1,800. This old holdered GEM should bring in that range. 

PCGS# 7951 | ESTIMATE: $1,500+ 

PCGS# 7948 | ESTIMATE: $4,500+ 

OUR ESTIMATES 












149


LOT 309 

$2.50 1908 PCGS PR67 

Representing the first major Quarter Eagle design change 

since 1840, only 236 Proofs were struck in 1908. The 

surfaces on this SUPERB GEM are virtually perfect, with 

the classic mustard hue and finely granular matte surface 

undisturbed! A high fin or wire edge is seen around most 

of the coin, both obverse and reverse. An absolutely 

extraordinary example of this rare Proof coin. 

The matte surface is completely different from anything 

done at the Philadelphia Mint before. Up until this time 

proof coins had always been “shiny”, with the fields 

offering mirror reflectivity and the devices offset by 

frosted texture. Here on this 1908 Quarter Eagle the 

fields and devices were completely uniform in color and 

texture. A strong loupe reveals minute interlocking facets 

that create the “sandblast” texture and appearance. When 

examined under a light, these facets flash and twinkle 

like a galaxy of stars! Of course this radical change, 

introduced at other world Mints soon after 1900, was met 

with stiff resistance in America, as collectors had grown 

used to the bright and flashy proofs of the past. Hence 

sales declined year after year starting in 1909 through the 

end of Proof production. Today with the benefit of time 

and artistic appreciation, modern collectors highly covet 

these exceptional matte proof coins, especially when they 

are found so perfectly preserved! 

PCGS 6, NGC 29 The last one sold for $40,800 in the 

recent ANA auction. Prior to that, we sold one in our 

September 2015 Regency Auction for $58,750. Even a 

non-CAC 66+ sold in February for $42,888. The current 

PCGS value is listed at $55,000 and this one should 

bring a bid near that, as it possesses an AMAZING look. 

NONE are graded finer at PCGS, making this a real prize 

for anyone building a set of Matte Proof Indian Heads, or 

wanting an example for a type set! 

PCGS# 7957 | ESTIMATE: $55,000+ 

150


LOT 310 

$2.50 1909 PCGS PR65 CAC 

LRCA is honored to have the chance to offer a real GEM 

example of one of the rarest Proof Indians that exist. we 

marvel every time we look at this coin. No question this 

coin is SUPER HIGH END too. 

Outstanding surfaces are evenly covered by a pure Roman 

finish. There are NO defects or shiny spots to be found. 

After examining it closely with a strong glass we see no 

reason why PCGS just graded it a PR 65. We can’t ever 

promise it will grade higher, but this coin certainly looks 

much better than its current grade. The surfaces are a 

deep original Roman gold color. There are ZERO spots or 

imperfections. If you ever want to see what the dreaded 

reverse right field should look like-check this coin out. 

Every detail is pinpoint sharp in strike. The eye appeal is 

phenomenal! 

Only 139 were minted. PCGS 3, NGC 9, CAC 1. PCGS 

has graded only 1 coin higher (a 66+) but CAC has beaned 

none. It is our extreme opinion that ALL pricing guides are 

plain wrong. They have thrown imaginary numbers out for 

a coin that last possibly appeared in 2006! So we call the 

current Collectors Universe value ridiculous. We’re sure 

this date and grade is a hole in all sets. Considering after 

all the years now CAC has been in business, and this is 

still the lone CAC piece, that is tremendous proof as to its 

extreme rarity. We can see this as a six figure coin. All we 

can say to prospective bidders, don’t think cheap and be 

prepared to bid strong! Good luck, it is unlikely you will 

get another chance any time soon! 

PCGS# 7958 | ESTIMATE: $80,000+ 

151


LOT 311 

$2.50 1910 PCGS PR66+ CAC 

A majestic example of this very popular Proof Indian 

$2.50. The quality is off the charts, and the eye appeal is 

simply stunning. NOTE: THIS IS NOT THE NGC PR66+ 

CAC that we sold in May 2018. 

Ranking among the TOP THREE graded at PCGS, this 

coin has all the hallmarks of a SUPERB GEM! The 

delicate satin finish is totally intact, uninterrupted by 

any surface disturbance or flaw that we can see with 

our powerful loupes. Every detail is fully embossed in 

the surfaces, and crisply defined throughout the incuse 

design. The rich, totally original orange-gold color is as 

fresh and pleasing as the day it came off the dies. 

The mintage of 1910 Proof quarter eagles was reported 

at 682, a whopping sum for any Proof gold coin. It is 

said that many of these may have been spent by their 

owners as no 1910 circulation strike quarter eagles were 

produced until the end of the year. Obviously the number 

of coins that went into circulation, or melted as unsold 

were never taken out, or there could have been a mistake 

in reporting. The current combined PCGS and NGC 

populations come to about 200 pieces, and the recent 

Proof Gold reference by John Dannreuther suggests that 

90-110 survive. 

PCGS 12, NGC 31, CAC 14. This is the SOLE PR66+ 

graded at PCGS, and there are two at NGC. The ONLY 

PR66+ to sell was the coin mentioned above, graded by 

NGC in our May 2018 Regency Auction, that realized 

$43,475. A PCGS/CAC PR66 (no +) sold for $45,825 in 

March 2016. The most recent non-CAC PCGS PR67 sold 

for $64,625 in the 2015 FUN auction. The current PCGS 

value is listed at $52,500, but this coin will surpass that 

amount when it crosses the block; it is SUPERB, and will 

certainly attract huge attention from specialists. Good 

luck finding a better one in a PCGS/CAC holder! 

PCGS# 7959 | ESTIMATE: $50,000+ 

152


LOT 312 

$3 1860-S PCGS AU53 CAC 

This is one of the rarest and most UNDER 

rated dates in better grades (AU and higher). 

The quality of this coin is VERY HIGH 

END! Overall, the surfaces appear clean. 

Only with a strong glass can you find a 

scattered tiny tick or two along with a light 

old cut on the face. Nothing is major or 

stands out. A surprising luster mixes with 

semi-prooflike mirrors and beams boldly 

from all over. That is unusual for a 60-S. Both 

sides are an original deep gold/orange color. 

There are NO spots or discolorations. Miss 

Liberty and the details are well struck and do 

have strong frost. The eye appeal is fantastic! 

PCGS 12, NGC 12, CAC 3. The last PCGS AU 53 to sell in auction brought $5,875 in December 2015-a long time ago! The current 

Collectorís Universe Value is $7,900. We expect this beautiful coin to bring closer to the CU value. 

PCGS# 7981 | ESTIMATE: $6,000+ 

LOT 313 

$3 1874 PCGS MS64+ CAC 

Exquisite! This “common” $3 is anything but in GEM 

grade. This 64+ is oh so close to GEM quality and we 

have seen coins in 65 holders that look the same. We 

think PCGS got this one 100% right! 

The luster is blistering in its fiery brilliance. The 

dramatic satin sheen grabs the viewer from accross 

the room. Up close, the radial luster rolls along with 

a superb vibrance. Impressive striking definition 

on both sides, the dies imparted full details with an 

exacting blow. The glowing fields are marred by just 

the most microscopic ticks that are only visable using 

a strong glass, but none of these have any affect on the exceptional eye appeal. 

PCGS 106, NGC 74, CAC 25. PCGS has graded just 9 in MS64+, the most recent of which sold in March 2014 in an online only 

auction for $8,250. More recently a regular MS64/CAC sold for $11,400 in March 2018 and a PCGS MS65 CAC sold in November 

2017 for $12,000. We know the current PCGS value is too low for this coin! A great example for the date or type! 

LOT 314 

$3 1878 PCGS MS64 

The $3 gold series is full of low mintage issues, leaving only a few 

dates that in Mint State, are considered type coins, and the 1878 is 

one of them. This one is a pleasing deep orange-gold with hints of 

rose and steely blue. Well struck and very eye appealing, there are 

just the slightest of tiny ticks noted under close scrutiny. Bold and 

satiny, this coin has a great look! 

PCGS# 7998 | ESTIMATE: $6,000+ 

PCGS 788, NGC 438. The most recent PCGS-graded coin to sell 

brought $4,800 in the recent ANA auction, and the current PCGS 

value is listed at $4,850. This original coin should find itself at home 

in a nice gold type set. 

PCGS# 8000 | ESTIMATE: $3,800+ 

153


LOT 315 

$3 1888 PCGS PR66+ CAM CAC 

WOW, WOW, WOW! The WOW factor here is off the 

charts! What a stunning HIGH-END GEM this coin is. It is 

tied for FINEST graded by PCGS in the CAMEO category. 

Intense deep mirrors blaze from all over; they have 

sensational clarity, cleanliness, and have the ultimate in 

reflection. When you twirl the coin, the mirrors roll like a 

river of molten gold. The contrast is mind boggling too! 

Some light gold toning can be seen on the reverse. There 

is NO haze here. Miss Liberty and every detail are thickly 

frosted and are fully struck. The eye appeal is spectacular! 

291 were struck. PCGS 8, NGC 9, CAC 5. PCGS has 

graded only 2 in PR66+ CAM and NONE ARE FINER in 

the designation!. The current Collectorís Universe value 

is $65,000. With so little GEM PCGS CAC gold around, 

we can see this coin easily selling for that. We know at 

the major shows we have attended this year; Proof Gold 

certainly was not anything we saw much of at all! 

PCGS# 88052 | ESTIMATE: $57,500+ 

154


LOT 316 

$5 1795 SMALL EAGLE PCGS MS62 CAC 

BD-3. If all 1795 $5 looked like this, they’d be $250,000 

coins. We think so much of this coin we even put it on 

the cover of this saleís catalog! The quality is as SUPER 

HIGH END as you get. We wonder if it had been sent to 

PCGS on a bad day. We know that our sister company 

thinks extremely highly of this coin, as when it was last in 

auction, they were the underbidder. They graded it MS62+ 

(we make no promises). 

Remarkable surfaces appear clean and smooth to the naked 

eye. When using a strong glass you can see light lines 

and some scattered ticks. NONE stand out in any way. 

The surfaces are slightly semi prooflike too. A surprising 

strong glowing luster beams boldly from all over. There is 

actually light cameo contrast on both sides. Miss Liberty 

and every detail look amazing. They are thickly frosted and 

are strong strikes. The eye appeal is like everything else 

about this coin phenomenal! 

PCGS 28, NGC 22, CAC 3. It is important to note: the 

last PCGS auction record was for a NON-CAC piece that 

brought $120,000. A PCGS CAC piece has not sold since 

2012-according to our records. The current Collectorís 

Universe Value is $135,000. This coin really is far superior 

to almost all 1795’s in MS62. We have seen MS63’s that 

look worse! This coin will make a fantastic addition to 

ANY choice set! You can’t buy a stunning SUPER HIGH 

END coin like this cheap. 

PCGS# 8066 | ESTIMATE: $120,000+ 

155


LOT 317 

$5 1800 PCGS AU58 CAC 

BD-5, a moderately scarce variety rated as 

R-3+ in the Bass Dannreuther reference. 

This is a great looking slider early $5. The 

surfaces seem to be totally unmessed with 

and unmolested. Natural, honey gold with 

nice overtones of olive-green and orange-gold 

stand out when the satin sheen is brought 

out in a light. Both sides display the slightest 

hint of friction on the surfaces. The strike is 

bold throughout with strong definition to the 

devices. A few ancient, miniscule, stray marks 

are acceptable for a 218 year old gold coin 

that saw brief use in circulation. 

PCGS 49, NGC 69, CAC 20. Many have been conserved, cleaned, or are otherwise not original. The most recent PCGS/CAC example to 

sell via auction was back in the 2016 ANA auction bringing $13,513 and the current PCGS value is listed at $14,500. Scarce in all grades, 

even more so in CHOICE AU and finer. A great type coin for any collector wanting an affordable and high end example 

LOT 318 

$5 1803/2 NGC XF45 CAC 

BD-3. A scarce R-4 variety, this one presents 

very nicely. Light wear has not taken away all 

vestiges of the original mint luster, including 

some reflective accents that survive in the 

protected areas of the devices. There are 

some light friction lines and a few ticks, all 

appropriate for an early $5 in this XF45 grade. 

PCGS# 8082 | ESTIMATE: $12,500+ 

PCGS 31, NGC 13, CAC 7. The most recent 

NGC/CAC coin to sell in auction brought 

$8,700 in February 2018 and the current 

Collector’s Universe value is listed at $10,250. 

CAC approved early gold is quite scarce and 

always in demand! 

PCGS# 8084 | ESTIMATE: $7,500+ 

LOT 319 

$5 1803/2 NGC AU58 

BD-1, considered to be R-4 with perhaps 

150-200 known in all grades. Pleasing khaki 

gold color with ample olive accents that 

grace both sides. Generally attractive with 

hints of original bloom that come out in the 

protected areas of the nicely struck devices. 

Some old friction can be seen with a glass. 

The reverse was struck from a later die 

state with a number of bold die cracks that 

transect that side. 

PCGS 77, NGC 88. The last AU58 to sell 

was a PCGS coin that brought $10,800. The 

current Collector’s Universe value is listed at 

$14,500. A nice collector example of this early $5--perfect for a type or date collection. 

PCGS# 8084 | ESTIMATE: $11,000+ 

156


LOT 320 

$5 1811 BD-2. SMALL 5. PCGS MS64 CAC 

This coin really is super HIGH END! We truly love 

everything about this near miss GEM! 

Remarkable surfaces are pretty clean and smooth to the 

naked eye. Only using a strong glass can you see a few 

microscopic ticks and a frost break or two. We assure 

you, there is very little holding this coin back from FULL 

GEM MS65 status. There even are very faint traces of 

semi-prooflike mirrors towards the centers. The luster is 

unusually strong and beams vividly from all over. Both 

sides have unquestionable and totally original “skin” 

colors of deep yellow gold/orange gold (by the date) and 

faint greenish gold on the reverse. There are NO spots or 

discolorations anywhere. Miss Liberty and every detail are 

frosted and are sharply struck. The eye appeal is 

fully wonderful! 

PCGS 17, NGC 12, CAC 8. The last one to sell in auction 

brought $46,201 in April 2018. Prior that PCGS/CAC coin 

sold in July 2013 for $64,625. The current PCGS Price 

Guide value is listed at $57,500 and there are only four coins 

marginally finer, graded MS64+ at PCGS. This coin is a 

great coin for a type or date set of early gold. One look and 

you will love this near-GEM as much as we do! 

PCGS# 8109 | ESTIMATE: $45,000+ 

157


LOT 321 

$5 1836 PCGS MS64 CAC 

This is a gorgeous Classic Head half eagle! As a type, these 

rarely come so fine. The short lived series, struck from 1834 

to 1838, can be quite the challenge to collect in Choice Mint 

State, especially with a CAC bean. The Classic Head design 

by William Kneass is a transitional type, straddling the old 

tenor gold coins (1795-1834) and the long running Liberty 

head series. By the 1820s, the value of gold in the half eagle 

exceeded the $5 face value. The majority of the mintages 

were exported and melted, the profit pocketed. In 1834, the 

content of gold coins was changed, and the design changed. 

The Classic Head half eagle saw much more extensive 

circulation than the earlier types, so finding a CHOICE Mint 

State piece is indeed a challenge. 

The present coin has a great look. Sharply struck devices 

stand out with a strong definition, on both sides. The 

obverse die had broken by the time this one was struck 

with a bold bisecting die crack. The golden surfaces are 

frosty and offer a strong satin sheen to them, accented by a 

swirling cartwheel bloom. There are a few minor hints of 

contact, which are not serious and do not detract from the 

otherwise stunning eye appeal. This near-GEM is bested 

by perhaps as many as four coins graded at PCGS, making 

this one perfect for any high grade type set or specialized 

set of Classic Head fives. 

PCGS 16, NGC 7, CAC 3. The only PCGS/CAC coin to 

ever sell in auction realized $25,201 in June 2018. The 

current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $26,000. The 

Pogue coin was just marginally finer, graded MS64+. A 

GEM will cost $70,000+! Good luck! 

PCGS# 8174 | ESTIMATE: $22,000+ 

158


LOT 322 

$5 1846-C PCGS AU55+ CAC 

Looks are deceiving. At first glance we thought his 

coin was Uncirculated. No, we don’t need stronger 

glasses. The coin actually looks that good. It is HIGH 

END for sure. Amazing surfaces are almost full Mint 

State quality. Save for one small tick, the surfaces 

are super clean. The surfaces also have a thick satiny 

texture. A surprising luster beams vividly from all 

over. You can tell nothing has ever been done to this 

coin. Both sides are a wonderful and totally original 

deeper yellow gold color. The clear reason why this is 

not an AU 58+, there is some weakness in the strike 

on the eagleís neck. All other details are super frosty 

and are fully struck. The eye appeal is beyond exceptional especially since this is C mint! 

PCGS 7, NGC 12, CAC 3. This is the ONLY PCGS AU55+ graded. It has never been sold via auction. The consignor told us it is fresh 

to the market. It should be known that the last AU55 sold in 2006! The rarity of this date and grade cannot be disputed. We think the 

Collectorís Universe estimate of $7,900 is way off as are all the AU values. If you collect C Mint $5 or just $5, this is a coin that will thrill 

you. It belongs in a great collection! 

PCGS# 8227 | ESTIMATE: $7,500+ 

LOT 323 

$5 1846-D PCGS AU53 

This is a rare AU survivor of this difficult date. PCGS CoinFacts 

estimates a survival of 140 examples in all grades, and David 

Akers and Doug Winter both observed that most survivors are 

VF or XF grade. This example shows just a few minor marks, the 

most noticeable is on Liberty’s cheek. A bright golden color shows 

ample surviving satiny luster in the fields. The devices are sharply 

struck up and the eye appeal is better than most you will see, as this 

date often comes highly abraded and many have been cleaned or 

otherwise impaired. 

PCGS 16, NGC 18. There has not been one sold in auction since October 2011, realizing $4,169. The current PCGS Price Guide value 

is $4,500. Rarely appearing in auction any finer, the last AU55 graded by PCGS sold in July 2006 and the last PCGS AU58 sold in 

March 2006! If you are collecting AU half eagles from the Dahlonega mint, be sure to bid on this one! 

LOT 324 

$5 1850-D NGC AU55 CAC 

Here is a highly collectible, and very scarce southern branch mint 

half eagle. Anyone who has studied Dahlonega and Charlotte 

mint gold coins knows that they are extremely hard to find in 

ORIGINAL, uncleaned, dipped, and/or conserved condition. This 

is evidenced by the CAC population figures, as well as notes from 

David Akers, Doug Winter, and other authorities. This nice AU55 

has a great look overall, with great orange-gold coloration with 

accents of olive patination in the fields. Nicely struck up in most 

places, there is just a touch of weakness, as usual at the right left 

obverse periphery. There are some minor marks from its brief stay in 

commerce, none of which impede the wonderful eye appeal. 

PCGS# 8228 | ESTIMATE: $3,600+ 

PCGS 16, NGC 28, CAC 4. This coin sold for $6,000 in November 2017 before selling in April 2018 for $5,520.; as the ONLY 

CAC-approved AU55 to sell in auction, we think it really should sell for more; the current Collector’s Universe value is $6,500. A 

very challenging issue that displays a look that even the pickiest of collectors will enjoy! 

PCGS# 8245 | ESTIMATE: $5,000+ 

159


LOT 325 

$5 1901 NGC MS66 

Bright, shimmering with light yellow gold luster that gleams all 

over. Satiny-smooth surfaces are generally free from distraction and 

possess a great eye appeal. 

PCGS 19, NGC 25. The most recent example to sell in auction 

realized $2,520 in February 2018 and the current CU value is listed 

at $3,750. VERY RARE any finer. 

PCGS# 8402 | ESTIMATE: $2,800+ 

LOT 326 

$5 1881 PCGS PR61 CAM 

This is a very affordable, and very pleasing for 

the more modest grade Proof Gold Rarity! Only 

42 examples were struck, all delivered on March 

26, 1881, and today, perhaps 16-20 survive 

in all grades, two of which are permanently 

impounded in institutional collections, one in the 

N.N.C. at the Smithsonian and one at the ANS. 

Rich, reflective mirrors survive despite the 

light mishandling. It is likely that someone 

unknowingly spent it, and shortly after, a sharp 

eyed collector recognized the different finish to 

the surfaces, saving it for posterity. There are a 

few minor nicks and lines, but the eye appeal is certainly aided by the bold mirror sheen and frosted devices that stand out with nice 

contrast. The eye appeal is much stronger than you might expect at this grade level. 

PCGS 1, NGC 0. We cannot trace this coin in auction, and it may be a coin that was purchased over the counter in a coin shop, 

graded, and held by the owner, before making its way into the marketplace. Proof Gold coins are the caviar of numismatics, and this 

important rarity is certainly in the budget range of most advanced collectors. If you never dreamed you could afford an earlier, larger 

denomination proof gold coin here is your opportunity. The current Collector’s Universe value is listed at $8,750, and this one should 

bring around that amount. 

PCGS# 88476 | ESTIMATE: $7,000+ 

LOT 327 

$5 1908 INDIAN. NGC MS65 CAC 

A lovely GEM Indian Head half eagle! 

Anyone who has collected gold coins knows 

that these are VERY difficult to find in GEM. 

The present example has a nice light gold 

tone over highly lustrous surfaces. The 

incuse devices are deeply impressed into the 

planchet, offering full definition of all the 

details. A strong glass reveals a tiny tick or 

two, but none that are distracting. Even the 

dreaded field above the eagle is clean! How 

rare is that! 

PCGS 237, NGC 111, CAC 50. The last two 

NGC/CAC coins to sell realized $9,600, one was in our April 2018 Premier Session and the other in a June 2018 auction. The prices 

for CAC coins are much higher than those for non-CAC and this is one series where it does make a huge difference! 

PCGS# 8510 | ESTIMATE: $9,000+ 

160


LOT 328 

$5 1910-S PCGS MS64 

Despite a mintage of 770,200, this is a VERY RARE date 

in MS64 and is excessively so any finer. with fewer than 10 

graded higher at PCGS. 

The present near-GEM 10-S half eagle is very high end 

for the grade and has a great orange-gold glow. Satiny 

brilliance brings out the details in the fully rendered incuse 

devices. The fields are generally very clean and free of 

anything more than a few tiny ticks seen with a strong 

glass. The eye appeal is very nice. 

PCGS 20, NGC 18. The last PCGS coin without CAC 

approval sold in 2007. The most recent example sold in 

September 2018 for $36,500. This is not the NGC coin that 

sold in the 2018 FUN auction. The current PCGS Price 

Guide value is listed at $40,000. This date is excessively 

rare any finer, with just nine coins so graded. This coin 

presents an important opportunity for the Indian Head half 

eagle collector looking for a high grade example for their 

set. We know this coin will see intense bidding. Good luck! 

PCGS# 8519 | ESTIMATE: $25,000+ 

161



$5 1913 PCGS MS64 CAC 

Beautiful and totally original, this Indian Head half eagle 

has a great look. Housed in a first generation PCGS slab, 

this coin is satiny and exceptionally well struck; a few 

microscopic marks kept it from grading higher. 

PCGS 620, NGC 435, CAC 104. The most recent CAC 

example was sold for $2,145 in our June 2018 Premier 

Session. The bid for CAC-approved coins is $2,200. 

Good luck! 

PCGS# 8525 | ESTIMATE: $1,800+ 

LOT 330 

$5 1914-D PCGS MS64+ CAC 

A very pleasing example of the type or the date. 

Only 247,000 were stuck and precious few survive in 

GEM, making a 64+ like this a great option for 

most collectors. 

Rich, totally original golden surfaces have a warm 

lustrous glow. The incuse devices are sharp and 

essentially fully impressed. Both sides show some 

very minor ticks, but they are accounted for in the 

assigned grade and the eye appeal is wonderful. 

PCGS 297, NGC 254, CAC 47. PCGS has graded 

40 in MS64+ and only 16 in MS65, making us think that there is a good number of resubmissions of the same coin in hopes of getting 

a 65 grade. The last PCGS to sell was not CAC and realized $4,700 in June 2017. A CAC approved example sold in August 2016 for 

$7,873. The current CU value is listed at $6,100, and remember the value jumps to $20,000+ in 65--if you can find one, there has not 

been one sold in nearly 6 years! 

PCGS# 8528 | ESTIMATE: $4,000+ 

LOT 331 


With just a touch of rub in the fields, this pleasing AU has 

all the hallmarks of a PQ example. Good glossy luster and 

nicely preserved surfaces show no serious marks. 

PCGS 134, NGC 254, CAC 8. This PQ example should 

bring well in excess of the current CU value of $785, and 

the only CAC-approved example to sell was NGC-graded 

and brought $718 in a January 2017 internet only auction. 

PCGS# 8529 | ESTIMATE: $800+ 

162


LOT 332 

$5 1913 PCGS PR66+ CAC 

What an amazing PQ Matte Proof. Everything about this 

coin SCREAMS quality and eye appeal. We are so proud to 

offer this important rarity in this auction! 

From an original mintage of just 99, all delivered on January 

13, 1913, perhaps a total of 60-75 survive today, which 

include those impounded in institutional collections such 

as the Smithsonian and American Numismatic Society. 

PCGS and NGC have combined graded 52 examples and 

likely includes duplication. This one is tied for second finest 

graded at PCGS. 

Awesome orange-gold coloration is the epitome of 

originality. Sharply struck devices are impressively pressed 

into the planchet. The sand blast finish leaves the surfaces 

with thousands of sparkling facets. A strong glass reveals 

perhaps one or two minor lines that do not detract and can 

only be seen at certain angles and we mention this only for 

full disclosure. 

PCGS 11, NGC 11, CAC 10. There are 3 listed in 66+ on 

the population report, but it is doubtful that three separate 

examples exist. Only 3 are graded finer. This is NOT the one 

that sold in the 2017 ANA auction. The current Collector’s 

Universe value is listed at $79,500 and while PCGS has 

graded 3 finer, all PR67, none have sold in nearly a dozen 

years! This coin, and the 1914 that follows presents a very 

rare opportunity for the advanced Proof gold collector. Who 

knows when you will have another chance to buy these two 

amazing 20th century rarities! 

PCGS# 8544 | ESTIMATE: $70,000+ 

163


LOT 333 


What an honor it is for LRCA to offer this stunning beauty! 

This is such an impressive SUPERB GEM Matte Proof Half 

Eagle. Tied for second FINEST graded, and one look at this 

AMAZING coin, and you can easily see why! 

This is a very RARE date, from an original mintage of only 

125, and perhaps today, around 60-75 survive in all grades. 

Keep in mind that at least three examples are permanently 

impounded in museum collections. 

The matte surfaces are wonderful with their fine, sand blast 

texture; the thousands of tiny facets sparkle when they are 

hit by the light. It is also totally original showing off a great, 

olive gold color with rich tan overtones. This is not your 

typical bright yellow conserved example that has lost all 

of its original character. Every detail is sharply struck and 

the eye appeal cannot be beat. For the advanced collector 

of 20th century gold, this amazing coin presents a very rare 

bidding opportunity. 

PCGS 2, NGC 5, CAC 2. ONLY a single PCGS PR67 CAC 

has ever sold in auction, realizing $111,625 in November 

2015. There is a single PCGS PR68 CAC that sold in March 

2017 for nearly $250,000. This coin has a SUPERB stunning 

look, that will delight even the most jaded of collectors--we 

have had a hard time putting it down--you will too! After 

30+ years of operations, the fact PCGS has only graded two 

examples this high and one finer speaks volumes to the rarity 

of this date and the infrequency they appear in auction! 

Congratulations to the winning bidder, you just bought an 

amazing gold rarity! 

PCGS# 8545 | ESTIMATE: $100,000+ 

164


LOT 334 

$10 1847-O PCGS AU58 CAC 

This exceptional quality 47-O eagle 

has a totally original array of rich 

orange-gold and olive accents over the 

satiny lustrous surfaces. Nicely struck 

devices show just the slightest hint of 

rub on both sides, but the details show 

essentially full definition. There is some 

slight friction in the fields, but we do not 

see any distracting marks or anything 

that would displease even the pickiest of 

collectors. This date is relatively easy to 

find in grades up to AU53, but it is scarce 

in AU58 and as the Population Reports 

show that CAC-approved examples are 

extremely rare. 

PCGS 13, NGC 97, CAC 5. NO CAC approved example has ever sold in auction! There is a record for a non-CAC PCGS example in 

February 2018 for $5,520. If you collect CAC-approved New Orleans mint gold coins, you know how difficult they can be to obtain, even 

on the so-called “common” dates. This is a great example that has never been conserved and will fit nicely in any amazing set. 

PCGS# 8598 | ESTIMATE: $5,000+ 

LOT 335 


This is a truly eye appealing and CHOICE AU 

48-O eagle. The coin is totally original and 

this date is rare in AU and higher grades. The 

surfaces show a light trace of wear, and the eye 

appeal is better than you might expect for a 50. 

Olive-green patinated gold has a light satiny 

look. There are no serious marks, just a few stray 

ticks from its time in commerce. The crustiness 

of the surfaces give this coin a truly superb look 

for the grade. 

PCGS 17, NGC 21, CAC 4. The most recent 

example sold for $5,040 in the recent ANA 

auction. Prior to that, even a non-CAC example sold for $5,280 in February 2018. The current Collector’s Universe value is listed 

at $4,500 . A 53 will cost around $6,000 if you can find a CAC-approved example. What a great opportunity to add this rare date to 

your set! 

PCGS# 8600 | ESTIMATE: $4,500+ 

165


LOT 336 

$10 1854 PCGS MS62 CAC 

This is a major condition rarity in the No 

Motto Liberty series. 

There is just something about No Motto 

eagles from the 1850s that are very 

charming. They are truly conditionally 

scarce coins, the vast majority 

disappearing into circulation during 

the Antebellum, with very few quality 

pieces for collectors to pursue. The 1854 

is a great example, the original mintage 

was modest, only 54,250 were struck. 

David Akers wrote that the “1854 is a 

rare date in any condition, and in AU or 

uncirculated condition it is very rare.” 

Between PCGS and NGC there are about two dozen Mint State coins graded, including some likely duplication. The presently offered 

coin has a choice look! A thick mint frost blooms with a warm glow on original surfaces. The fields and devices show some very minor 

ticks that account for the assigned grade. The design elements on both sides are generally crisp in definition. The eye appeal is excellent 

for the modest grade, and a true prize for the specialist! 

PCGS 6, NGC 1, CAC 3. The most recent example to sell in auction realized $18,001 in April 2018, and in August 2016 one sold for 

$15,275. The current Collector’s Universe value is listed at $19,000 and there are only two coins finer at PCGS, all MS64 and none have 

ever sold in auction. This is about as fine as you will ever see. Good luck! 

LOT 337 

$10 1860-O PCGS AU55 

The final New Orleans mint $10 

struck before the Civil War, the 

1860-O had a mintage of only 11,100. 

Like many AU and higher survivors, 

there is a distinctly reflective luster 

in the fields. The light friction is 

accentuated by the semi-PL nature 

of the luster. The devices are fully 

struck up and the definition is very 

sharp. A stray line or two are noted 

for full disclosure. The eye appeal is 

better than usually seen and we really 

do like the look of this CHOICE AU 

1860-O $10! 

PCGS# 8613 | ESTIMATE: $14,000+ 

PCGS 17, NGC 39. The most recent non-CAC example sold in October 2016 for $4,935; we sold one for $6,169 in our June 2015 

Regency Auction. The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $6,750. This one is housed in an older blue tag holder and has 

not appeared in any auction we can find. Keep in mind that any grade higher is RARE and will cost into the five figures based on 

the PCGS values. A great No Motto $10! 

PCGS# 98631 | ESTIMATE: $5,000+ 

166


LOT 338 

$10 1868 PCGS AU55 CAC 

Due to a limited mintage of 10,630, this date is VERY RARE in any 

grade. The present orange-gold toned example is very pleasing and 

high end with only a touch of rub on the surfaces. Accents of peach, 

orange, and rose impart a strong, original eye appeal. This coin is very 

high end and worthy of a great collection of Liberty $10s. 

PCGS 19, NGC 25, CAC 6. The last PCGS/CAC example sold 

back in April 2012, bringing $4,025. The current PCGS value is 

listed at $3,800 and it would not come as a shock if this RARE 

$10 brings a price in excess of that. Keep in mind that the 

Hall-Simpson Collection contained an AU58, and the finest is only MS62. 

PCGS# 8653 | ESTIMATE: $3,200+ 

LOT 339 

$10 1869 PCGS AU55 

Here is a VERY RARE early 

Motto eagle, one of the FINEST 

graded from an original mintage 

of 1,830 and PCGS estimates a 

total survival of 57. Typically 

seen in VF and XF grades, there 

are just three examples graded 

higher than the present AU55 

at PCGS. 

While the fields show some 

friction and marks from 

circulation and bag storage, 

they do show a wealth of 

reflective sparkle that you 

would expect to see on a coin 

that saw such a low mintage. The devices show bold striking definition with barely any perceptible wear on the reliefs. Olive-peach hues 

over orange-gold patinated surfaces give this coin a totally original and high end look. 

PCGS 7, NGC 7. The last one to sell realized $12,925 in the 2016 ANA auction. More recently an NGC example, from the Admiral 

Collection, realized $10,200. The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $14,000. of Extreme Rarity any finer, this is about as fine as 

any collector could ever hope to own. Bound for an advanced collection and worthy of a serious bid. 

PCGS# 8655 | ESTIMATE: $9,000+ 

OUR ESTIMATES 

The estimates you see published in this catalog are based on HAMMER. Keep in mind that a coin could be either low or 

high end for the grade, have stunning color or be dull, all of which radically affect a coin’s value. Yes, there can be huge 

price differences within a grade, and we offer estimates as a guide so Collector’s can have a better idea of value. One thing 

we will never do is offer low ball estimates in order to claim stronger sales. 

These published estimates represent what Legend Rare Coin Auctions determines to be an approximate high wholesale 

value for the coin. The numbers are based upon current market values, similar trades, auction prices, published prices, and 

a consideration of the coin’s quality. There is no guarantee that the estimated prices are minimums or are exactly what you 

can expect to get if you attempt to resell them wholesale. 

We always advise you to view the coins you are interested in and calculate what you’ll pay using as much information as 

possible. If you have any questions, please feel free to ask us. We are here to help you! 

167


LOT 340 

$10 1874-CC NGC VF35 CAC 

This is a visually impressive collector grade coin! We love 

the natural tone over the moderately worn surfaces. There is 

a remarkable amount of retained luster that survives in the 

fields. There is a wealth of detail to the design elements with 

just honest wear on the surfaces. While a more available date 

than others from Carson City, only 16,767 were stuck. 

PCGS 31, NGC 8, CAC 5. NO NGC VF35 has ever sold in 

auction; the last two CAC-approved auction appearances 

sold for $4,320, one in August and one in February 2018. 

This is an affordable early CC mint ten that will attract 

serious attention from the collector. Good luck! 

PCGS# 8670 | ESTIMATE: $4,000+ 

LOT 341 


A low mintage date, only 9,200 were struck, and 

today perhaps about 275 survivors are estimated 

known in all grades. Scarce in AU grades, this one 

is very original with a nice, old time collection look. 

Under the “crusty” (not a negative term) tone, a rich 

olive-green and golden hue glows with a shimmering 

luster. The devices are razor sharp, despite the minor 

wear on the highest points. The eye appeal is quite 

nice for the grade, and worthy of a premium bid from 

the specialist collector. 

PCGS 27, NGC 25, CAC 4. The last one to sell was 

in the 2018 ANA auction, realizing $4,920. We sold a non-CAC AU50 in our November 2016 for a hammer price of $5,750. High end 

examples like this are worthy of placement in a high end collection! 

PCGS# 8689 | ESTIMATE: $4,600+ 

LOT 342 

$10 1894 PCGS MS64+ CAC 

With such a large mintage, you would think these would be 

more common in GEM grade. Would you believe that in 

30+ years of grading PCGS has graded only a single MS65 

finer! This MS64+ is truly deserving of its near-GEM 

grade. Brilliant cartwheel luster boldly rolls over the 

honey-gold toned surfaces on both sides. The devices are 

sharply struck and are boldly defined. A strong glass reveals 

just the slightest sign of contact, none of the microscopic 

ticks impair the wondrous eye appeal. 

PCGS 207, NGC 442, CAC 31. There are 14 graded 64+ 

at PCGS. Back when there were three MS64+s graded, this near-GEM sold for $4,600 in November 2011. They have been selling 

between $1,880 and $2,820 in 2017 (none have sold in 2018). The current PCGS value is listed at $3,250 and we think this coin could 

well bring close to that. The SOLE PCGS MS65 is CAC approved and sold in April 2011 for $26,450--a gorgeous 64+ is a great value 

at today’s levels! 


168


LOT 343 

$10 1907 NO MOTTO. PCGS MS65 CAC 

A lustrous GEM example of this first year issue. 

A radiant satin frost sets the smooth surfaces 

aglow in golden vibrance. Well struck, with 

crisp definition throughout. A small patch of 

deeper, reddish toning at the reverse rim serves 

to identify this beauty. 

PCGS 243, NGC 318, CAC 65. The last one 

sold in our July 2018 Regency Auction for 

$8,225 and prior to that one sold for $8,555 in 

an online auction. The current CU value is listed 

at $8,500. What a great type coin or way to start 

your set! Good luck! 

PCGS# 8852 | ESTIMATE: $7,500+ 

LOT 344 

$10 1908-D NO MOTTO. PCGS MS63 

This is a rather scarce issue, despite a mintage of 210,000. Overall, 

the surfaces are very clean for the assigned grade. Both sides show 

off a pleasing satin frost, clearly above average in quality. Using a 

strong glass does not reduce the strong choice quality. Both sides 

are a beautiful even original gold color, and there are no spots or 

discoloration. Miss Liberty and the details are sharply struck and do 

stand out. The eye appeal is excellent! 

PCGS 128, NGC 39. The most recent example sold cheap at the 

ANA auction, realizing $3,840. Examples sold earlier this year 

brought between $4,080 and $5,520 with the current Collector’s Universe value being listed at $6,150. Anything finer is going to 

cost into the five figures, making a CHOICE coin like this worthy of any Mint State set of Indian Head $10s. 

LOT 345 

$10 1909-S PCGS MS64+ CAC 

This coin is SUPER HIGH END! 

Only a tiny “strike through” piece of lint 

(MINT MADE) on the reverse is all we see 

as keeping this coin from being a full MS65. 

Overall, the surfaces are really immaculate and 

have a satiny texture. A full luster shows off the 

gorgeous, even, and totally original gold colors. 

There are NO spots or stains. Miss Liberty and 

the details are lightly frosty and have crisp full 

strikes. Her face is NOT hacked up like you 

typically see. The eye appeal is super! 

PCGS# 8854 | ESTIMATE: $3,600+ 

PCGS 47, NGC 33, CAC 6. How is this for hard to find? The last PCGS CAC piece to sell in auction brought $9,987 January 2013! 

Recently, Legend WHOLESALED a nice regular MS64 (no plus) for $8,500 This coin isn’t really priced at any super premium even 

though there actually is a large quality difference. A PCGS CAC MS65 would cost at least $20,000.00-and NONE have ever been 

sold via auction. The price list values for a coin like this are all wrong (lack of trades). We know we do NOT see any at all (if we did, 

we would buy them)! If you are building a great $10 Indian set, here is a beauty! 

PCGS# 8864 | ESTIMATE: $8,750+ 

169


LOT 346 

$10 1910-D PCGS MS66+ CAC 

This is an excellent, high end 1910-D Eagle. No question 

this coin has been lovingly cared for since it came off 

the dies! 

The superb quality surfaces are exceedingly clean and 

smooth; indeed only with a strong glass can you see some 

very light and scattered small contact. The coin looks more 

like a P Mint then a D Mint. A strong luster beams from all 

over. Both sides enjoy a stunning golden allure and there 

are NO spots or discolorations. Miss Liberty and every 

detail are sharply struck. The eye appeal is wonderful! 


MS66+. The most recent example sold in our October 

2017 Regency Auction and was part of the Crow River 

Collection for $29,375. Extremely RARE any finer, with 

just three coins graded MS67 finer, the last one selling in 

2010 for $86,250. This is about as fine as you can ever 

hope to get for your world class collection, and will see 

very strong bidding! Good luck! 

PCGS# 8866 | ESTIMATE: $22,000+ 

170


LOT 347 

$10 1911-D PCGS AU58+ CAC 

The definition of a SUPER 

SLIDER! The 11-D $10, like 

the $2.50 and $5 of this date is 

a key date issue, only 30,100 

were struck and there are just 

not enough to go around in Mint 

State. Even AUs are very scarce 

and popular for collectors. The 

presently offered example has 

just the slightest touch of friction 

on the highest points, barely 

detectable to the naked eye. The 

surfaces are nicely patinated with 

an olive-gold that accents the 

nicely struck up devices. There is 

a minor mark or two that we note for accuracy, but they do not detract from the eye appeal. A perfect coin for the 

“everyman” collector. 

PCGS 185, NGC 276, CAC 52. There are only TWO AU58+ graded at PCGS. The last one to sell brought $6,600 in July 2018 and the 

other one sold for $7,800 in September 2017. The current Collector’s Universe value is $8,000 and with Mint State coins being so scarce, 

this coin will delight many collectors looking for a high end piece to fill the hole. Good luck! 

PCGS# 8869 | ESTIMATE: $6,000+ 

LOT 348 

$10 1911-D PCGS 

MS62 

A RARE date in Mint 

State, as most of the 

30,100 mintage went 

into circulation. We 

believe that there is 

duplication in the 

Population Reports 

at this grade level in 

hopes of getting a 63 

grade. 

The present coin has 

a glowing satin luster 

that beams all over. 

Light honey-gold with 

a light rose coloration 

accents the sharply struck up design elements. Typical surface quality as expected for the grade, with a few tiny ticks and lines seen, but 

none of them are singularly distracting or take away from the essentially CHOICE eye appeal. 

PCGS 92, NGC 59. There are a wide range of prices realized just in 2018, two sold in March 2018, realizing $10,200 and $19,200 and 

one in June 2018 for $12,600. The current PCGS value is listed at $17,000. A 63 will cost in the $20,000-$25,000 range. 

PCGS# 8869 | ESTIMATE: $12,000+ 

171


LOT 349 

$10 1911-D PCGS MS63 

We looked really hard all over to see why CAC did 

not bean it. We are still wondering. However, they saw 

something, and they are firm. This is not your typical 11-D. 

Also, we do rate it VERY high end. 

This coin is seriously superior to the typically dull and 

crusty 11-Ds we usually see. We looked really hard and 

saw exceedingly clean and smooth surfaces. There is some 

luster that sort of glows off the coin. Both sides are a deep 

gold color. There are zero spots or imperfections. Miss 

Liberty and the details are sharply struck and do stand out. 

The eye appeal is great especially for this date. 

PCGS 42, NGC 11. The last one to sell in auction 

brought $21,600 in August 2018. The current Collectorís 

Universe Value is $29,000. If you think you want a higher 

grade-good luck and expect to pay a ton (an MS64 NO 

CAC sold for $70,500 in April 2017). We invite you or 

your representative to inspect this coin. If you are building 

a set, opportunity sure knocks loud here! 

PCGS# 8869 | ESTIMATE: $18,000+ 

172


LOT 350 

$10 1914 PCGS MS66+ CAC 

What an amazing SUPERB GEM piece. The quality 

absolutely is SUPER high end! Remarkable surfaces look 

like they have never been touched. Only using a strong 

glass and looking hard, can you find a small light tick on 

the reverse (which is all that keeps this GEM from MS67). 

There are no whacks or other issues typical to this date. A 

strong luster enlivens the crisp totally original deep yellow/ 

orange gold color. Miss Liberty and the details are sharply 

struck and do stand out. The eye appeal is awesome! 

PCGS 12, NGC 10, CAC 10. PCGS has graded only 5 in 

MS66+ and 3 in MS67. The last MS66+ PCGS CAC to sell 

in auction brought $36,425 in our October 2017 sale of the 

Crow River Collection. Prior to that, one realized $44,650 

in April 2016 (this is not that coin). We can’t stress enough 

how impossible pieces like this are to find today-especially 

with demand so strong. If you are building a SUPERB GEM 

$10 set, this is a coin you do not want to miss! 

PCGS# 8875 | ESTIMATE: $37,500+ 

173


LOT 351 

$10 1915 PCGS MS66 CAC 

Our sister firm, Legend Numismatics, has built the top 2 

$10 Indian sets ever (one is not registered). We know our 

GEM Indians! Do not think this date and grade are easy to 

find. 

This coin is nothing but fabulous! We think only a tiny 

tick on the reverse keeps this coin from being an MS67. 

Overall, the surfaces are satiny and do appear clean. A 

strong unbroken luster beams from all over. Both sides are 

a two tone original gold/deeper gold color. Miss Liberty 

and the details are sharply struck and stand out. The eye 

appeal is terrific! 

PCGS 11, NGC 23, CAC 11. PCGS has graded 5 higher 

of which NONE are beaned in MS67. Prior to this coin 

selling, the last 1915 to sell in auction brought: $29,375 

in the 2017 ANA auction, and another brought $30,550 in 

the 2017 FUN auction. As you can see, there is a dip in the 

market. With gold off, now is the time to buy coins like 

this. Opportunity could not knock any louder! 

PCGS# 8878 | ESTIMATE: $21,000+ 

174


LOT 352 


All New Orleans mint double eagles are RARE in Mint 

State grades, the present date is no exception! This coin 

ranks among the FINEST graded at PCGS, with just 

eight coins graded finer. In all, Doug Winter has opined 

that there are 15-20 Uncirculated survivors, and PCGS 

CoinFacts suggests 13. There is likely duplication in the 

population reports, and as they sit, the number of Mint 

State coins graded at both services is very small. 

The present coin has a light golden-orange hue that glows 

with a semi-reflective prooflike luster that beams in the 

fields. The devices are sharply struck up and nicely frosted. 

We note some minor lines on the fields, but they do not 

detract from the superb eye appeal. 

PCGS 7, NGC 7, CAC 1. While this may be one of the 

more available dates from this mint, it is very rare in Mint 

State. No PCGS MS61 has sold in the last decade. The 

Bass-Gilded Age coin, a non-CAC PCGS coin sold in 

the 2014 ANA auction for $94,000. In MS61, the current 

Collector’s Universe value is listed at $55,000 and this 

one, with CAC endorsement should bring a premium bid! 

Worthy of one of the finest collections of double eagles! 

PCGS# 8907 | ESTIMATE: $55,000+ 

175


LOT 353 

$20 1853/’2’ PCGS MS61 CAC 

The only “overdate” in the double eagle series, the 53/2 

is a very popular variety for advanced collectors. VERY 

RARE in high grade, this MS61 is tied for FINEST graded 

at PCGS. 

Rich and totally original olive and “dirty” orange-gold 

toning on both sides. Clearly a coin that sat for a long time 

in either an old collector envelope or in a European bank 

hoard, as it boasts surfaces that possess what this cataloger 

refers to as “vault dust.” Some minor bag marks are noted, 

but the surfaces are not as hacked up or choppy as you 

would expect on a coin of such modest Mint State grade. 

The details are full, and they do not show any signs of 

wear. There is a lovely mint frosty bloom that can be seen 

in the fields that gives vibrance to the surfaces. 

Walter Breen claims to have discovered this variety in 1959 

and described it in his Complete Encyclopedia published in 

1988. There is some recutting or something else seen under 

the three, leading to the 3/2 overdate. There is some debate 

as to whether it is a true overdate today. Dave Bowers says it 

is not, Doug Winter includes it in his book on Type I Double 

Eagles, but says he can see merit in both sides. PCGS for 

its part continues to list it as a separate variety, but puts the 

underdigit in quotes. This condition Census example will 

delight any advanced collectors. 

PCGS 10, NGC 3, CAC 6. The most recent example 

sold for $26,400 in June 2018. Prior to that, the “Pueblo 

Collection” coin, which sold in the 2012 ANA auction 

realized $46,000. The current PCGS value is listed at 

$34,000 and we think this one will bring closer to that 

amount; its purley original look will delight any advanced 

$20 collector. Good luck! 

PCGS# 8909 | ESTIMATE: $25,000+ 

176


LOT 354 

$20 1858 PCGS AU58 CAC 

This is NOT a dull, lifeless AU 

coin, nor is it horribly hacked 

up like so many examples 

you see. While over 200,000 

were struck, most went into 

circulation. Unlike other Type 1 

twenties that were recovered in 

the last 20 or so years from ship 

wrecks, no large hoard of 1858 

double eagles has ever come 

out. This date is actually VERY 

RARE in Mint State. This one 

has a lot of surviviing luster 

that bring the surfaces of this 

impressive coin to life, and it 

does look better than many low 

end MS graded coins we have seen. 

PCGS 33, NGC 96, CAC 13. Two PCGS/CAC 1858 double eagles sold in 2018, one in February for $10,200 and another in June 

for $8,100. The current Collector’s Universe value is listed at $9,250. Quite RARE in any Mint State grade, this is about as high a 

grade as most collectors will ever hope to own. Best of luck in bidding, this GEM AU will delight any collecor of gold coins! 

PCGS# 8923 | ESTIMATE: $7,000+ 

LOT 355 

$20 1859-S PCGS MS61 

This is your typical survivor of 

the 59-S, which almost always 

comes with abrasions. There are 

a few that we see on the obverse, 

which account for the grade. 

The frosty lustrous surfaces 

glow throughout the fields and 

in the design elements, the 

pale orange-gold color is very 

pleasing. Typical bluntness of 

strike is seen, and should not be 

confused with wear, this coin is 

free of any actual wear and the 

eye appeal is really not at 

all bad. 

There are perhaps 40-50 examples known in Mint State, but only one of those is from the wrecks of either the Brother Jonathan or 

the Republic. 

PCGS 26, NGC 9. The most recent example to sell in auction realized $11,400 in June 2018. Prior to that the sole CAC-approved 

example brought $14,100 in February 2018. The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $17,500 and the value jumps to $25,000 

in MS62. NONE are graded finer than MS63. 

PCGS# 8928 | ESTIMATE: $9,500+ 

177


LOT 356 

$20 1860 PCGS MS61 

WOW! For “only” a MS61, this coin has a look that in 

the days before grading would have been described as 

CHOICE BU! Take the image of a hacked up, baggy 

double eagle out of your mind, this is NOT that coin! 

The highly lustrous surfaces show only a few minor lines 

and ticks, none that are singularly distracting nor do they 

impair the bold Mint State eye appeal. 

PCGS 42, NGC 27. This date is VERY RARE any 

finer, with just about two dozen graded higher at PCGS 

(including, no doubt, resubmissions). Three examples 

have sold in 2018, between $4,800 and $5,000. Prior to 

that, these were selling, consistantly, for between $7,000 and $8,000 (which is the current CU value). Anything finer will likely be a five 

figure rarity. A great antebellum Mint State double eagle that is not from the S.S. Central America. 


LOT 357 

$20 1864 PCGS 

AU58 

Civil War date 

gold, especially 

double eagles 

are always 

popular; while 

not as scarce as 

the 1862 and 

1863 issues, in 

high grade, the 

1864 is a very 

tough coin to 

find! Until the 

discovery of the 

S.S. Republic, 

there were 

precious few 

to go around. 

Today, including those, about 275-280 examples in all AU grades are estimated to survive. 

The fields are highly lustrous and have a sparkling, nearly prooflike flash as you rotate the coin in a light. A few minor abrasions are 

noted, but we really do not see any actual wear on the highest points, indeed, in the days before PCGS and NGC, it is likely this coin 

would have sold as Brilliant Uncirculated. The eye appeal is exceptional, better than normally seen. 

PCGS 38, NGC 66. The most recent PCGS-graded coin had a CAC bean and brought $18,000 in June 2018. The current PCGS Price 

Guide value is listed at $20,000. VERY RARE in Mint State, this beautiful coin will delight any collector of Civil War numismatics or 

double eagles. 

PCGS# 8941 | ESTIMATE: $15,000+ 

178


LOT 358 

$20 1864 PCGS AU58 CAC 

A very impressive example of this important Civil War 

double eagle! Offering a very original high end look, this 

coin has just the slightest touch of rub from a Mint State 

grade. Like most known examples, the surfaces are mildly 

abraded with a few minor marks, the most serious of which 

is in the lower right reverse. The surfaces are otherwise 

totally unlike many that you see, in that the surfaces are 

not conserved and show a rich, orange-gold with a superb 

glowing satin mint luster that gleams in the fields and in 

the protected devices. The eye appeal of this, despite the 

marks on the reverse, are extremely high end, and will fit 

into any advanced collection of Liberty Head double eagles, 

especially those focused on Civil War era coins. 

PCGS 38, NGC 66, CAC 9. The most recent example sold 

in June 2018 for $18,000; prior to that a non-CAC example 

sold in March 2016 for $17,625. The current PCGS Price 

Guide value is listed at $20,000 and this date is very rare in 

Mint State grades. We can see this highly desirable double 

eagle bringing a very strong price when it crosses the block. 

Good luck! 

PCGS# 8941 | ESTIMATE: $18,000+ 

179


LOT 359 

$20 1866-S NO MOTTO. PCGS AU55 CAC 

A very RARE and highly desirable double eagle issue, 

the last of the Type Ones. While the reported mintage was 

120,000, many experts believe that a large number were 

melted and never released and while we may never know 

for sure how many were released into circulation, what we 

know is there are very few to go around in all grades (PCGS 

CoinFacts estimates about 300, while Doug Winter estimates 

175-225). Regardless, this GEM AU55 ranks among the top 

20 graded by PCGS. These were all struck in February 1866, 

before the new With Motto dies arrived. 

The surfaces show a light friction in the fields and the 

highest portions of the devices, artifacts of a brief stay in 

commerce. A few ancient stray ticks can be noted, but they 

do not detract the eye. A bold satiny mint frost blooms on 

the obverse, while the luster on the reverse is distinctly 

reflective with a very attractive, semi-prooflike flash. 

PCGS 10, NGC 24, CAC 3. The other PCGS/CAC sold in 

auction in November 2013 for $88,125 and that is the only 

other recorded auction price for a PCGS AU55. The current 

PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $87,500. There are 

only eight coins graded finer at PCGS; a PCGS AU58 is a 

six-figure coin, the last one sold back in 2009 and the finest 

is the ex Saddle Ridge Hoard example that graded MS62. 

This is a real prize for any advanced double eagle specialist, 

among the finest PCGS coins available in the open market. 

We wish every interested bidder luck as there will be 

intense bidding competition for this beauty--and we offer, in 

advance, a hearty congratulations to the successful bidder! 

PCGS# 8945 | ESTIMATE: $65,000+ 

180


LOT 360 

$20 1866-S MOTTO. PCGS 

AU58 CAC 

This is a great match to the 

previous lot, and would make 

a great transitional pair for 

the advanced gold collector. 

Early in 1866, the design was 

modified slightly to include 

IN GOD WE TRUST in the 

circle of stars on the reverse, 

however, the new reverse dies 

did not arrive in San Francisco 

until after some older No Motto 

dies were employed and coins 

put out into circulation. 

The present near-Mint State 

coin is really a wonderful “super slider.” Rich orange-gold color dominates with areas of lighter gold that contrasts. The luster 

is essentially unbroken and glows over the satiny surfaces. Really the evidence of any time in circulation is so microscopic, the 

friction is barely noticeable on either side. There are a few tiny contact marks that we can see only with the help of a strong glass, 

none of which are inappropriate for the grade, nor do they affect the superb eye appeal. 

PCGS 39, NGC 116, CAC 14. Typically these have been selling in the $13,000-$15,000 range and the current PCGS Price Guide 

value is listed at $15,000. As expected this date is RARE any finer, and a CHOICE AU58 will fit nicely in any carefully selected set. 

PCGS# 8950 | ESTIMATE: $12,500+ 

LOT 361 

$20 1867 PCGS AU55 

A lovely, original Choice AU example with just a touch of 

friction on the highest surfaces. Nicely struck and possessing a 

pleasing olive-gold patina on both sides. There are very few lines 

or marks to distract the eye. This date is scarcer in AU than you 

might expect for the mintage of 251,015. 

PCGS 39, NGC 42. The last example sold in March 2018, 

which was CAC, and realized $2,640 and the current PCGS 

value is $3,000. With its wholesome look, this piece should see 

a similar result. A nice addition to any holding of With Motto 

Double Eagles. 

PCGS# 8951 | ESTIMATE: $2,200+ 

LOT 362 


Very eye appealing for the grade, this Type II double eagle is 

totally original and offers a great look. Rich orange-gold color 

comes to life with a pleasing satiny sheen. Well executed in 

terms of strike, the details are nicely rendered. The surfaces 

show just a touch of friction and there are only a few tiny ticks 

noted under a strong glass, typical for the grade. 

PCGS 127, NGC 364, CAC 31. Do not let the populations 

fool you, these do not come up for auction too often. The most 

recent PCGS/CAC example to sell in auction realized $2,468 

in June 2017. The current PCGS value is listed at $3,000. A 

collection of Philadelphia and San Francisco mint Type II 

double eagles in CHOICE AU grades would make a very neat 

short set to work on. 

PCGS# 8956 | ESTIMATE: $2,000+ 

181


LOT 363 

$20 1872 PCGS AU58 CAC 

A very attractive, near Mint State 1872 Double Eagle with a 

lovely orange gold color and nearly complete mint luster. The 

grade is accounted for more by moderate contact marks than 

actual wear, which can be seen only with the most determined 

viewing with a glass. Most coins of this date assigned low Mint 

State grades will be nearly indistinguishable from this one! 


value is listed at $2,750, and recent APRs are right in that range. 

Typically the best one can hope for is a choice AU such as the 

present coin, or a low mint state coin that will be only marginally 

better. AU58 represents a great value and should be bid accordingly. 

PCGS# 8963 | ESTIMATE: $2,500+ 

LOT 365 


While not a rare date in the absolute 

sense, it is scarce in MS61, and 

incredibly RARE any finer. Dave 

Akers and Ron Guth both say that you 

can find an example, but to find a nice 

one is very difficult, a fact borne out 

by the CAC populations. 

LOT 364 

$20 1872 PCGS AU58 CAC 

If you are looking for a really sweet and HIGH END Type II 

$20, here you go! The totally original surfaces display some 

scattered ticks from bag storage. A surprisingly strong original 

and unbroken luster beams boldly from all over. The surfaces 

are a refreshing original gold color. This is NOT a dirty coin 

and there are no spots or discoloration anywhere. Miss Liberty 

and the details are well struck. The eye appeal is really great! 

PCGS 132, NGC 263, CAC 34. The last PCGS CAC piece to 

sell in auction brought $2,760 in the 2018 ANA auction. The 

current Collectors Universe Value is $2,750. We can’t say 

enough how we rarely see these as clean and colorful as this 

coin. Good luck! 

PCGS# 8963 | ESTIMATE: $2,500+ 

The present coin is totally original, 

with the dusty look of a coin that was 

recently brought out of a European or 

South American holding. Remember, 

lots of double eagles were used for 

overseas payment and in many cases 

have been held in bank vaults ever 

since. There are a few minor abrasions from bag storage, but they are totally appropriate for the assigned grade and do not detract from the 

excellent eye appeal that this lovely Mint State example possesses. This is what a natural Liberty Double eagle looks like! 

PCGS 75, NGC 92, CAC 12. This date is VERY, VERY RARE any finer! PCGS has graded just 10 coins finer, the finest being a single 

MS63. The last PCGS/CAC coin sold in auction back in June 2011, that is AGES ago! Even then, it realized $4,888. More recently an NGC/ 

CAC sold in 2013 FUN auction for $7,638. The current Collector’s Universe value is listed at $4,250. Anything finer is clearly a five figure 

coin, so if you need a Mint State example but do not want to pay $10,000+ here is a great coin for you! 

PCGS# 8965 | ESTIMATE: $3,600+ 

182


LOT 366 

$20 1874-CC PCGS XF45 

A popular collector grade early date CC $20. While many of 

the gold coins from Carson City are very scarce to very rare in 

all grades, the 1874-CC saw a mintage of 115,085, making it a 

great representative for the mint. 

Decent quality surfaces show only moderate wear. The 

honey-wheat gold coloration shows rich accents of orange tone 

in areas. A glass reveals some minor old bag marks acquired 

during its stay in commerce, but it is not at all hacked up or 

unappealing visually in any way. 

PCGS 286, NGC 282. A very cool piece for any gold coin 

holding, and keep in mind most other dates from this mint will 

cost much more in this grade. The current PCGS value is listed 

at $4,150. Good luck! 

LOT 367 

$20 1882-CC PCGS XF45 CAC 

A pleasing Choice XF Carson City double eagle that will 

delight any collector. The eye appeal is excellent for an XF, 

which normally comes cleaned or hacked up. This coin just 

shows some minor friction in the fields and light wear on the 

devices. The quality is beyond what you normally see. 

PCGS 190, NGC 132, CAC 16. NO PCGS/CAC example has 

ever sold in auction. Only 4 NGC/CAC coins have ever sold, 

selling in the $3,400-$4,100 range since 2013. The most recent 

PCGS coin brought $3,480 in September 2018. The current CU 

value is $3,750. CC gold is always popular and adding some to 

any collection of U.S. gold is a great idea! 

PCGS# 8997 | ESTIMATE: $3,200+ 

PCGS# 8971 | ESTIMATE: $3,500+ 

LOT 368 

$20 1884-CC PCGS AU58 CAC 

This is a gorgeous, high end for the 

AU58 grade 84-CC $20. Exhibiting 

nearly full mint brilliance in the fields, 

the surfaces show just the most minute 

touch of rub. The details are fully 

rendered and have bold definition 

throughout. Accents of rose caress the 

rich golden color on both sides. There 

are a few minor ticks from bag storage 

none of which are distracting or affect 

the “GEM AU” eye appeal. If you 

are looking for a single $20 from the 

Carson City mint, the 84-CC is a great 

year, as it is one of the more readily 

available; but in AU58 it is truly 

scarce, and Mint State coins are even more so. 

PCGS 228, NGC 474, CAC 57. There must be much duplication in the population figures in attempts to garner a Mint State grade. The 

current PCGS Price is $7,500 and there are a wide range of auction prices realized for PCGS/CAC examples; the most recent of which sold 

for $6,360 and others have sold in the $7,000-$8,000 range. This is a great looking coin that will realize a strong bid! 

PCGS# 9001 | ESTIMATE: $7,000+ 

183


LOT 369 

$20 1889-CC PCGS AU58 CAC 

There is something extremely 

romantic about Carson City double 

eagles; big gold coins that have the 

aura of the wild west and the myths 

of bandits, bank robberies, stage 

coach chases, and the like. 

This eye appealing AU58, combines 

that romance with a numismatic 

quality that will entice any collector. 

Nice underlying luster has nearly 

full rolling cartwheels on both sides. 

There is just the slightest touch of 

friction on the highest points of the 

well struck devices. There are a few 

minor contact marks, common enough on such a large gold coin. The eye appeal is excellent for the grade. 

PCGS 123, NGC 238, CAC 25. The last PCGS/CAC coin sold in auction for $9,900 in February 2018. Prior to that, an NGC/CAC 

coin sold for $12,925 in April 2017. The current PCGS value is listed at $10,500 and this coin will see fierce bidding when it crosses 

the block! 

PCGS# 9011 | ESTIMATE: $8,000+ 

LOT 370 

$20 1892-CC PCGS XF40 CAC 

Here is another “common” Carson City $20, that is not as 

common as the populations might have you think. This date and 

grade is very rare with CAC endorsement, there are only TWO 

on their population report. 

The surfaces show light to moderate wear and a very pleasing 

orange-olive tone on the surfaces. The eye appeal is great and 

totally original! 

PCGS 62, NGC 40, CAC 2. NONE have ever sold in auction. 

The current PCGS value is listed at $3,650 and this coin, with its 

exceptionally high end eye appeal should bring close to that! 

PCGS# 9020 | ESTIMATE: $2,800+ 

LOT 371 

$20 1893-CC PCGS AU55 

Here is a sharply struck, lustrous example of the final double 

eagle issue coined at this popular western mint. All the romance 

of the wild west that is associated with the Carson City mint 

makes any coin from this mint popular with collectors, and the 

large double eagles particularly so. This AU55 has a wonderful 

look with deep orange-gold color, vibrant luster and just a hint 

of friction that we see in the fields and on the high points. There 

are some minor friction lines which we note, but this coin is 

certainly not hacked up or conserved as normally seen. 


listed at $7,500. While the most recent example brought only 

$4,800 sold in July 2017 for $5,875 and one sold in January 

2017 for $6,463. This is a very popular issue and the presently 

offered coin is worthy of any gold coin collection. 

PCGS# 8963 | ESTIMATE: $5,000+ 

184


LOT 372 


A lovely, fresh, borderline GEM Liberty $20. High end for the 

assigned grade, with a bold, frosty luster and very pleasing 

surfaces. Just a few bag marks are noted, which account for the 

grade, none of which affect the eye appeal overall. 

PCGS 1490, NGC 1176, CAC 187. The current CU value is listed 

at $2,300 and the most recent PCGS/CAC example to sell in 

auction brought $2,640 in the recent ANA auction. Very scarce 

in GEM, this coin will make a nice addition to any collection of 

gold coins. 

PCGS# 9034 | ESTIMATE: $2,200+ 

LOT 373 

$20 1900 PCGS MS65 CAC 

Superb surfaces are semi satiny and are surprisingly clean 

overall. There are a few light frost breaks and a small scuff/ 

frost break you can only see using a strong glass. A strong 

glowing luster shows off totally original yellow/pale greenish 

gold colors. There are NO spots or discolorations-save for a 

tiny speck of mint grease on the obverse. Miss Liberty and the 

details are frosty and are well struck. We grade the reverse an 

easy MS65+. The eye appeal is super! 

PCGS 357, NGC 345, CAC 36. The last PCGS CAC sold in 

auction brought $4,080 in the 2018 ANA auction; prior to that, 

there has not been one sold in auction since March 2015 for 

$5,170. There is no big premium for this date over the 1904, 

which has a much bigger population in GEM. Gold bugs know 

the timing is right to buy coins like these. 

PCGS# 9037 | ESTIMATE: $4,200+ 

185


LOT 374 

$20 1903 PCGS MS66+ 

Here is a truly SUPERB and special $20 Liberty! It is also 

the SOLE FINEST graded for the date. 

Thick satiny surfaces are remarkably free of any major 

marks. Only using a strong glass and really looking around 

can you find a light scuff or two-NONE are visible to 

the naked eye. We grade the reverse a full MS67. A thick 

satiny luster is unbroken and beams from all over. The 

colors are a rich original gold/deeper gold. Miss Liberty 

and the details are frosty and are fully struck. The eye 

appeal is mesmerizing! 

PCGS 1, NGC 0. Not even a non-+ MS66 has ever sold 

in auction. The current Collectors Universe Value shows 

$75,000. This coin will be major addition to any GEM set 

of $20 Libs! 

PCGS# 9043 | ESTIMATE: $50,000+ 

186


LOT 375 

$20 1906 PCGS MS66 

An ULTRA HIGH END ‘06 $20--vastly superior to 

virtually all 1906 double eagles we have seen. Tied for 

SECOND FINEST graded, there is just one coin graded 

finer at PCGS. 

The surfaces are exceptionally clean and devoid of any 

marks, lines, or ticks of any size. The wonderful, velvety 

surfaces show off a dramatic luster that brings out a totally 

ORIGINAL rich, orange-gold patina. The well struck 

devices are extremely frosty. The eye appeal is beyond 

reproach and impeccable! 

PCGS 2, NGC 1. The most recent example to sell was 

CAC approved and sold for $64,625 in our July 2018 

Regency Auction.Prior to that, there has not been one sold 

since September 2006! The current Collector’s Universe 

value is listed at $75,000. A real prize for the advanced 

Liberty Head double eagle collector and a very important 

opportunity that is not to be missed! 

PCGS# 9049 | ESTIMATE: $65,000+ 

187


LOT 376 

$20 1872 PCGS PR63 DCAM 

There is something truly majestic looking at deep cameo 

Proof double eagles. The visual impression these large gold 

coins leave you with is quite striking, and you really have 

to be ultra jaded to not sit in awe. Most collectors, if they 

are lucky enough to even hold one, usually see the more 

“common” dates of 1896-1900, or the ultra rare Proof-Only 

dates of 1881-1884. The 1872 is an unsung rarity, with 

about 10-12 known from an original mintage of 30 pieces. 

The current certification figures of NGC and PCGS prove 

this, as there are 11 certified in all grades and designations 

between the two firms combined. We are proud to offer this 

wildly contrasted, visually stunning double eagle. 

Upon first impression, this coin has a MONSTER look. 

Deeply mirrored fields are blindingly reflective and 

provide a dramatic and eye arresting contrast with the 

frosted golden devices. The fields have a superb orange 

peel texture and rich orange-gold coloration. A patch of 

lines, we are calling “cabinet friction” on the cheek and in 

the field facing Liberty’s profile account for the assigned 

grade, BUT, these lines are only visible at certain angles. 

Do not let the grade fool you, the eye appeal is simply 

stunning, despite the more modest grade; it really is a 

seductive and highly enticing coin of great 

numismatic importance! 

PCGS 2, NGC 0. There is only one auction record in the 

2010 decade, when this coin sold for $58,750 in the 2015 

FUN auction; that sale was held during a weak market. 

Prior to that, one sold in July 2009 for $71,875. The 

current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $78,500. This 

extremely rare coin is even rarer in any higher grade, with 

just 2 DCAMs graded finer at PCGS, a 64 DCAM and a 

66 DCAM, neither of which have ever sold in auction, and 

none of which are approved by CAC. This is an incredibly 

important opportunity for the advanced collector of Proof 

gold to acquire a major, underrated rarity, there is no 

reason why a coin like this should be valued less 

than $100,000! 

PCGS# 99087 | ESTIMATE: $55,000+ 

188


LOT 377 

$20 1911 NGC MS64 CAC 

A delectable very CHOICE example of this conditionally rare 

date! Any finer and the rarity of this date increases dramatically. 

The coin itself has a great satin-like luster that blooms under a 

great honey gold patina. The surfaces are very pleasing and clean, 

boasting a very original, European bank hoard look! 

PCGS 530, NGC 389, CAC 64. The last NGC/CAC coin sold in 

November 2014 for $4,406. We just sold a PCGS/CAC coin for 

$4,818 in our September Regency Auction. This coin should see 

very spirited bidding. Keep in mind the value more than doubles 

in the next step up! 

PCGS# 9157 | ESTIMATE: $3,800+ 

LOT 378 

$20 1914 PCGS MS64+ CAC 

This is a wonderful example of a much tougher date to find in 

true GEM. 

There is no question this coin is totally not messed with. The 

surfaces do offer a strong luster and have no major problems. 

Both sides are a pleasing natural gold color. There are no spots 

or discolorations. The eye appeal is great! 

PCGS 560, NGC 311, CAC 60. PCGS has graded 50 in MS64+. 

The last one to sell in auction brought $5,760 August 2018. 

Prior to that, one sold in December 2017 for $7,800. The current 

PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $6,250. Keep in mind that 

this date is VERY RARE in GEM, with a PCGS MS65 CAC 

going to cost $20,000-$25,000. This near-GEM presents a great 

opportunity for the collector! 

PCGS# 9164 | ESTIMATE: $5,000+ 

OUR ESTIMATES 

The estimates you see published in this catalog are based on HAMMER. Keep in mind that a coin could be either low or 

high end for the grade, have stunning color or be dull, all of which radically affect a coin’s value. Yes, there can be huge 

price differences within a grade, and we offer estimates as a guide so Collector’s can have a better idea of value. One thing 

we will never do is offer low ball estimates in order to claim stronger sales. 

These published estimates represent what Legend Rare Coin Auctions determines to be an approximate high wholesale 

value for the coin. The numbers are based upon current market values, similar trades, auction prices, published prices, and 

a consideration of the coin’s quality. There is no guarantee that the estimated prices are minimums or are exactly what you 

can expect to get if you attempt to resell them wholesale. 

We always advise you to view the coins you are interested in and calculate what you’ll pay using as much information as 

possible. If you have any questions, please feel free to ask us. We are here to help you! 

189


LOT 379 

$20 1916-S PCGS MS66+ CAC 

Tied for FINEST and what a very HIGH END Premium 

Quality GEM this is! It really is SPECTACULAR! While 

not a rare date, there are not, after over 30 years of grading, 

any MS67s at PCGS! 

This coin has a wonderful, high end luster that glows 

all over the impressive, clean, and beautifully colored 

surfaces. A rich orange-gold, with subtle greenish hues 

that comes to life at certain angles in a light. Careful 

inspection reveals nothing but the slightest tiny tick or 

two, seen only under strong magnification. This coin is 

truly beautiful! This coin is about as close to SUPERB as 

you are going to get, and the quality and eye appeal are 

all there and then some! 

PCGS 192, NGC 146, CAC 30. Of those at PCGS, just 

four are graded MS66+. NONE have ever sold in auction, 

and keep this in mind, of the four, one is impounded in the 

Bob Simpson Collection and the other in the D.L. Hansen 

Collection, immediately making the possible population of 

4 really no more than 2! This remarkable GEM will sell for 

very strong money. If you are building a SUPERB set of 

Saints, you need this coin. Being tied with the Simpson and 

Hansen coins, you know it is in rarified company indeed! 

Good luck! 

PCGS# 99087 | ESTIMATE: $22,500+ 

190


LOT 380 

$20 1923-D PCGS MS65 

A very pretty, totally original GEM housed in a first generation 

PCGS holder. Offering a brilliant mint bloom with rich orange 

vibrance this coin has a great look. We note a tiny tick or two, 

which are normal for the assigned grade; we are not sure why 

CAC did not sticker this gem. 

PCGS 2628, NGC 1641. A wonderful coin for any gold holding. 

With premiums at historic lows, it is a great time to add hand 

selected generic gold pieces to any holding. The current CU value 

is $1,825. 

PCGS# 9176 | ESTIMATE: $1,700+ 

LOT 381 

$20 1924 PCGS MS66 CAC 

This coin has exceptional quality. 

Unless you look really hard using a strong glass, there are NO 

serious problems anywhere. The surfaces have a satiny smooth 

appearance. A bold luster shows off the totally original gold 

colors. There are NO spots or discolorations. Miss Liberty and 

the details are well struck and have light frost. The eye appeal 

is vivid! 

PCGS 9613, NGC 5204, CAC 630. The current WHOLESALE 

sight UNSEEN bid is $3,500. Legend is a major marketer of 

PCGS MS66 Saints. We can state for a fact our bids rarely get 

hit. These go off the market as fast as they appear. Go to any 

major show-you just won’t see PCGS CAC Saints around. 

PCGS# 9177 | ESTIMATE: $3,400+ 

191


LOT 382 

$20 1924-S PCGS MS64+ CAC 

Our sister company, Legend Numismatics, has 

exclusively built the #1+2 (#2 not listed) Saint sets. We 

know how they should come. This coin almost never 

come like this! We do grade it a MS64.8+++. It IS of full 

Legend quality! 

Remarkable surfaces are exceedingly clean and smooth 

looking. In fact, they have a thick satiny texture. Even 

when using a strong glass, all you can find if you look 

hard are a few tiny frost breaks. It is amazing this coin 

is not bag marked up like many of the others we see. 

A strong (for a 24-S) luster beams from all over. Both 

sides are a fully original gold color. There are no spots or 

discolorations anywhere. Miss Liberty and the details are 

frosty and are well struck. The eye appeal is wonderful! 

PCGS 116, NGC 118, CAC 23. PCGS has graded 12 

in MS64 + (we‘d bet this coin has been tried more than 

once). NOTE: PCGS has graded 6 in MS65 and only 1 

is beaned. The last PCGS CAC piece to sell in auction 

brought $44,063 in March 2013-5 LONG years ago. In 

today’s dry market we can see this bringing much more. 

Even the low Collectors universe Value of $43,500 shows 

this date and gradeís value has not been upgraded. If you 

are building a GEM set, you won’t want to miss this coin! 

PCGS# 9179 | ESTIMATE: $40,000+ 

192


LOT 383 

$20 1927 PCGS MS65 CAC 

Housed in a first generation PCGS holder, this is what GEMS 

should look like. Brilliant luster, very clean surfaces, sharply 

struck devices and a great color all combine to make one 

gorgeous Saint in a quality that you don’t often see in coins that 

are graded 65 today; indeed we have seen MS66s that do not 

have the bold eye appeal of this one! 

Out of nearly 50,000 graded between PCGS and NGC in MS65, 

only 1584 are CAC approved, which explains the premium CAC 

examples command. 

PCGS# 9186 | ESTIMATE: $1,650+ 

LOT 384 

$20 1927 PCGS MS66 CAC 

A VERY pleasing MS66 and VERY HIGH END Saint.Superb 

surfaces are clean and smooth overall. Just a few trivial frost 

breaks and extremely pinpoint ticks can be found using a strong 

glass. The luster is strong and is glowing. There is actually 

some light semi prooflike mirrors on the upper obverse. Both 

sides are pretty deeper gold/pale pinkish gold color. There are 

NO spots or stains. Miss Liberty and the details are frosty and 

are sharply struck. the eye appeal is superb! 

PCGS 6278, NGC 2605, CAC 513. The current WHOLESALE 

BID is $3,525. All of the sudden there are multiple bidders for 

these. Looks like demand is picking up again. 

PCGS# 9186 | ESTIMATE: $3,400+ 

LOT 385 

$20 1928 PCGS MS67 

Clearly this coin hit CAC on a 

bad day. We’ve seen many similar 

looking coins beaned. BUT they 

have made their decision and we 

will all live with it. We do like the 

coin-or else we would not have 

taken it for the auction. 

The surfaces are surprisingly 

natty (clean and smooth). Even 

using a strong glass all you can 

find a few tiny light frost breaks 

scattered about. A very good luster 

beams from all over. Both sides 

are a beautiful even original deeper 

yellow gold color. Miss Liberty and the details are frosty and are sharply struck. They even glow with a dusting of pinkish gold. There 

are NO spots or discolorations. The eye appeal is really wonderful! 

PCGS 89, NGC 91. The last PCGS (NO CAC) to sell in auction brought a strong $15,600 in August 2018. No fluke, another non CAC 

brought $14,400 in a different August 2018 auction. We assure you, this coin is at least equal (and probably better) then either of those 

coins that sold. True SUPERB GEM MS67 Saints are impossible to find these days. 

PCGS# 9189 | ESTIMATE: $10,000+ 

193


LOT 386 

25C 1893 ISABELLA. PCGS MS65 

A classic look with multihued antique patina, that shows a very 

pleasing vibrance on the obverse. Blue tinged, golden-russet 

surfaces blend nicely and are brought together by the semi-reflective 

underlying luster. The details are fully rendered on both sides 

and the eye appeal is very nice. 

PCGS 507, NGC 431. Non-CAC examples have sold in 2018 

from $900 to $2,875 and the current PCGS value is $1,700. The 

only quarter in the classic series and this one would fit nicely in 

any GEM set. 

PCGS# 9220 | ESTIMATE: $1,000+ 

LOT 387 

25C 1893 ISABELLA. PCGS MS66 CAC 

This Isabella’s eye appeal is off the charts! A brilliant 

luster brings out the awe inspiring blue, violet, green, and 

amber-orange. The luster gleams with bold rolling cartwheels 

on both sides. Sharply struck up details are full and the eye 

appeal is quite exceptional. 

PCGS 267, NGC 139, CAC 97. The current PCGS value is 

listed at $2,650 and this one is truly worthy of a strong bid! 

Recent PCGS/CAC APRs are in the $2,500 to $3,360 range. 

This coin was crossed from an NGC “*” holder, truly worthy of 

that accolade for its high end eye appeal. 

PCGS# 9220 | ESTIMATE: $2,000+ 

LOT 388 

$1 1900 LAFAYETTE. PCGS MS64 

The unique silver dollar commemorative struck in the early years, 

the Lafayette dollar has always been in demand from collectors. 

Only 36,026 were struck and the average coin grades in the 

MS63-MS64 range. This one however does not look like your 

average example, with a lovely blue, red, gold, pewter melange 

of color that graces both sides over the sharply struck design 

elements and satiny lustrous fields. 

PCGS 1000, NGC 735. The most recent example realized $1,680 

in the 2018 ANA auction and one sold for $2,400 in the Central 

States auction. The current PCGS value is listed at $2,200 and 

this one could see bidding to that level when it crosses the block. 

PCGS# 9222 | ESTIMATE: $1,500+ 

LOT 389 

50C 1921 ALABAMA 2X2. PCGS MS66+ CAC 

Among the 20 finest graded 2X2 Alabamas at PCGS, this gorgeous 

Premium Quality GEM screams originality! A band of beautiful 

toning forms a partial halo around the obverse, the subtle variations 

of color show wonderful coppery reds, deep blue, and autumnal 

brown-gold. The remainder of the surfaces are a pearly-satiny 

silver that are boldly awash in a brilliant lustrous sheen. Very well 

struck up devices stand out and just a few tiny ticks can be found 

under intense scrutiny with a strong glass. From a mintage of only 

6,000 this is one of the scarcer early commems. 

PCGS 147, NGC 87, CAC 51. PCGS has only graded 10 

examples in MS66+ with a mere 9 coins finer. The most recent 

PCGS MS66+ CAC to sell in auction realized $3,300 in our 

April 2017 Premier Session. A PCGS MS66 CAC (not a +) 

sold in April 2018 and it did not have the attractive toning 

this SUPERB quality GEM possesses. The current Collector’s 

Universe value is $3,100 and it jumps to $16,500 in MS67. A 

great coin for any commemorative collector. 

PCGS# 9225 | ESTIMATE: $2,800+ 

194


LOT 390 

50C 1936 ALBANY. PCGS MS67+ CAC 

What can we say about this Albany, other than it is SUPERB! 

With only three coins finer, this beautiful coin ranks among 

the VERY FINEST examples available to collectors. Sharply 

struck throughout, the devices are crisp and the satiny luster is 

flawlessly drenched on both sides. 

PCGS 216, NGC 158, CAC 89. There are only 23 graded MS67+ 

at PCGS. The range of APRs is wide for PCGS/CAC MS67+s, the 

most recent selling for $1,440 in the 2018 ANA auction; one sold for 

$2,585 in the 2017 FUN auction. The current Collector’s Universe 

value is listed at $1,650 and this one, with its amazing looks can 

easily surpass that level. Keep in mind that a 68 will cost $20,000+! 

PCGS# 9227 | ESTIMATE: $1,400+ 

LOT 391 

50C 1937 ANTIETAM. PCGS MS67 CAC 

This is a great looking Antietam! Awash in iridescent toning on 

both sides, more so on the obverse than reverse, the eye appeal 

is awesome! Highly lustrous and well struck, this coin will 

delight any collector of classic commems. 

PCGS 368, NGC 183, CAC 140. The most recent example to 

sell in auction realized $3,600 in June 2018 and in the same 

auction one brought $1,140. An NGC/CAC sold for $4,920 in 

April 2018. CU obviously has not taken into account the eye 

appeal, and is listed at only $1,150. This SUPERB GEM will 

bring fierce bidding for sure! 


LOT 392 

50C 1937 ANTIETAM. PCGS MS67+ CAC 

Of all the commemorative issues, those that relate to the Civil 

War are among the most popular. While the designs of many 

commems are rather plain and in lower relief, the conjoined 

heads of General Lee and General McClellan and the Burnside 

Bridge and Antietam Creek are struck in a relief that is higher 

and they stand out. This beautifully toned example shows nothing 

but the most insignificant tick or two, which are all only visible 

with a strong glass. Both sides have a rich, totally original toning 

imparted from long term strorage in the original holder, and the 

luster booms with an amazing brilliance through the color. 


and only 24 finer. The most recent PCGS/CAC example brought 

a very strong $9,000 in the 2018 CSNS auction. A similar toned 

coin sold in the 2016 ANA auction for $3,290. This one will see 

fierce bidding for sure, from any commem collector looking for a 

SUPERB TONED GEM! 

LOT 393 

50C 1936-S BAY BRIDGE. PCGS MS67 CAC 

SUPERB in every respect! A beautifully toned, well struck, 

and lustrous Bay Bridge. The surfaces are flawless and totally 

original with a very high end look! One of the more popular 

issues thanks to a great reverse design. 

PCGS 205, NGC 89, CAC 102. The most recent PCGS MS67 

CAC examples sold in the April 2018 CSNS auction, realizing 

$1,560, $2,160, and $2,400 each. We sold one in our July 2017 

Regency Auction for $1,704. This one will see very fierce 

bidding when it crosses the block. 

PCGS# 9254 | ESTIMATE: $1,500+ 


195


LOT 394 

50C 1935-S BOONE. PCGS MS67 CAC 

This is a beautifully toned SUPERB GEM Boone. Rings of rich 

violet, crimson, royal blue, and deep amber-gold ring around 

frosty silver central reverse devices, while the obverse has just a 

touch of iridescent silver and touches of gold at the rim. The eye 

appeal is superb, you will be hard pressed to find another with a 

look like this! 

PCGS 40, NGC 32, CAC 20. The last PCGS/CAC example 

realized $2,291 in our May 2017 Regency Auction. This coin’s 

eye appeal is stronger and should realize a stronger price. The 

current PCGS value does not take into account this coin’s 

stunning looks! 

PCGS# 9260 | ESTIMATE: $1,500+ 

LOT 395 

50C 1937 BOONE. PCGS MS67+ CAC 

Bested by only three coins, this SUPERB GEM ranks among 

the very FINEST known examples, and even a cursory look will 

prove that! The surfaces are gloriously smooth, and brilliantly 

lustrous. The superb luster glows in the fields under a dusting 

of icy blue, steely olive, and pale gold that is richer towards the 

rims. The devices are sharply struck and the reverse is especially 

crisp. The eye appeal is simply stunning, and cannot be beat! 

PCGS 136, NGC 55, CAC 54. PCGS has graded only 18 in 

MS67+ and the most recent CAC-approved example realized 

$3,120 in April 2018. Prior to that, the only ones to sell in auction 

were back in 2016. Only three examples, all MS68 are graded 

finer, and the most recent 68 sold for $9,106 in 2014. A real prize 

for any discerning commem collector demanding the best. 

PCGS# 9270 | ESTIMATE: $1,500+ 

LOT 396 

50C 1937 BOONE. PCGS MS67+ CAC 

This glorious SUPERB GEM is tied for second finest graded at 

PCGS and it is truly a very high end example of the type. 

A screaming luster on the obverse beams from all throughout the 

fields, giving the portrait of Daniel Boone, with its bold frosted 

look, a halo of amber-gold and icy-silver blue. The reverse has a 

nice frosty, pearly silver look. This coin really is one or two tiny 

ticks away from an even higher grade. 


at PCGS and only three coins finer. The most recent example 

realized $3,120 in April 2018. If you could find a 68--and that is a 

big if--it would cost $10,000 or more! 

LOT 397 

50C 1937-S BOONE. PCGS MS67 CAC 

A very cool Boone half dollar, with a distinctive, semi-prooflike 

flash in the fields. Icy-lustrous fields show off a steely-blue and 

clear gold toning on both sides. Sharply struck up, this SUPERB 

GEM has a great look that will delight any serious collector. 

PCGS 45, NGC 26, CAC 18. EXTREMELY RARE any finer, with 

just eight such coins graded at PCGS. The last PCGS MS67 CAC 

to sell brought $1,440 in the 2018 FUN auction. This coin’s great 

look will make it bring around the current CU value of $1,500. 

PCGS# 9272 | ESTIMATE: $1,100+ 

PCGS# 9270 | ESTIMATE: $2,200+ 

196


LOT 398 

50C 1925-S CALIFORNIA. PCGS MS67 CAC 

Glorious and SUPERB in every way! An incandescent luster 

glows and swirls in the problem free and smooth surfaces 

surrounding the sharply impressed devices. Delicate and 

original pastel iridescent earth tones of gold, pewter, olive, 

pearl, and tan. Everything is awesome about the eye appeal of 

this California! 

PCGS 121, NGC 138, CAC 73. We sold the most recent PCGS/ 

CAC example for $2,233; prior to that, one sold in November 

2017 for $3,600. The current PCGS value is $1,850 and this one 

is so beautifully preserved that level will be surpassed quickly 

for sure! 

LOT 399 

50C 1936-D CINCINNATI. PCGS MS67 CAC 

High end and totally original with a light pastel iridescent 

toning that is brought out by a rich, frosty satin luster. The 

surfaces are essentially flawless, only a powerful loupe reveals 

a light tick or two. 

Only 5,005 were struck. PCGS 48, NGC 32, CAC 28. The most 

recent example to sell realized $2,585 in March 2017. The 

current PCGS Price is $2,300 and this date is very difficult to 

find in any higher grade. 

PCGS# 9284 | ESTIMATE: $2,000+ 

PCGS# 9281 | ESTIMATE: $2,000+ 

LOT 400 

50C 1936 CLEVELAND. NGC MS67+ CAC 

A stunning Cleveland! Highly lustrous surfaces gleam bursting 

forth from below a layer of rose, emerald, and earthy violet tones. 

The surfaces are the epitome of cleanliness and are totally devoid 

of any distracting marks of any kind or size. The eye appeal is 

wonderful. 

PCGS 86, NGC 59, CAC 50. NGC has graded only 3 in 67+ 

and four coins finer. None of the NGC coins have ever sold in 

auction. A PCGS/CAC coin sold in March 2016 for $2,115 and 

the current Collector’s Universe value is listed at $2,600. NGC 

has graded just four MS68s finer. Bound for a great set of Classic 

Commemorative half dollars. 

LOT 401 

50C 1936-S COLUMBIA. PCGS MS67+ CAC 

An exquisitely preserved SUPERB GEM. A great looking coin 

with a flashy luster, sharply struck devices, and touches of 

golden color at the rims. The eye appeal is amazing. 

PCGS 128, NGC 130, CAC 74. There are 14 graded MS67+ at 

PCGS, and only 13 coins are finer. There has not been one sold 

in auction since September 2015, where one realized $999 and 

the current PCGS value is listed at $1,400. A great looking coin 

that is deserving of a place in a high caliber set. 


PCGS# 9288 | ESTIMATE: $1,500+ 

197


LOT 402 

50C 1892 COLUMBIAN. NGC MS67 

The Columbian Expo half dollar is the first issue in the extensive 

series of classic commemorative half dollars; as such is it is 

always popular. Gems are available, but scarcer than the high 

mintage of nearly 1 million might suggest. In MS67, as here, they 

are quite rare indeed! 

Offering a luster that has both brilliant and semi-prooflike traits, 

this coin has a wonderful look. The dappled tones on both sides 

give the sharply struck devices some dimension and the smooth 

surfaces a depth. The eye appeal is wonderful. 

PCGS 31, NGC 35. This is the first NGC MS67 sold in auction 

since 2016, selling for $2,400 in February 2018. The current 

PCGS value is listed at $3,000. VERY RARE any finer, this 

superb example will be a great fit in any high grade set! 

LOT 403 

50C 1893 COLUMBIAN PCGS MS66 

This is the first of our mini-hoard of 1893 Columbian Expo 

halves. This is a totally fresh deal of ORIGINAL examples, just 

graded by PCGS. All have a great, matched look. 

Nicely toned with classic blue, gold, russet, olive and tan 

overtones are evenly dusted over highly lustrous surfaces. 

Every detail is chiseled in its sharpness and only under a strong 

glass can we detect a minor scuff or two, which are toned over 

and cannot be seen without the aid of a glass. 

PCGS 237, NGC 147. A coin like this is truly worthy of a 

premium bid. With a coin this FRESH, you can toss out the 

price guide. 

PCGS# 9297 | ESTIMATE: $800+ 


LOT 404 


Another GEM MS66 from our mini-hoard of 1893 Columbian 

Expo halves. This is a totally fresh deal of ORIGINAL, 

well-matched examples, just graded by PCGS. . 

Nicely toned with classic melange of color, similar to the lot 

above, accenting the highly lustrous central surfaces. Every 

detail bold in its sharpness. We don’t understand why CAC did 

not sticker this GEM! 

PCGS 237, NGC 147. A coin like this is truly worthy of a 

premium bid. With a coin this FRESH, you can toss out the 

price guide. 

LOT 405 


This is a semi-reflective GEM example from our mini-hoard of 

Columbian Expo halves. The razor sharp devices stand out with a 

great look. Rich azure and crimson hues blend with violet and gold, 

particularly at the periphery, the obverse more richly toned than the 

reverse. The eye appeal is certainly enhanced by the vibrancy of 

the luster. 

PCGS 237, NGC 147. Another ultra fresh gem that is worthy of a 

premium bid! 



198


LOT 406 


This example sat undisturbed for a long time in a paper 

envelope or album where it was able to acquire a wonderful 

melange of toning on both sides, the reverse deeper than the 

obverse. The luster brings the subtle differences in hues as you 

rotate the the coin in a light. 

PCGS 237, NGC 147. Another highly eye appealing and totally 

original GEM from thsi mini-hoard. Worthy of a premium bid! 


LOT 407 

50C 1893 COLUMBIAN PCGS MS66 CAC 

This is another beautifully toned Columbian Expo half dollar 

from this same source. The eye appeal is very high end! 

Richly lustrous, reflective surfaces have a bold look with rich 

peripheral toning from long term album storage. You can’t beat 

the look for the value. 

PCGS 237, NGC 147, CAC 121. The last example sold for 

$1,320. A fully GEM + coin like this should bring a strong bid! 


LOT 408 


Here is another wonderful CAC-approved MS66 from this small 

grouping. Beautifully toned, the eye appeal is very high end! 

Richly lustrous, reflective surfaces have a bold look with rich 

peripheral toning from long term album storage. You can’t the 

look for the value. 


$1,320. A fully GEM + coin like this should bring a strong bid! 


LOT 409 


A borderline-SUPERB example! Everything about this beauty 

is original and pleasing! Sharply struck and vibrantly satiny 

with lovely original tone. The surfaces are nice and smooth 

without any serious marks or scuffs. 


$1,320. An original coin like this is certainly worthy of a 

strong bid. 


199


LOT 410 

50C 1893 COLUMBIAN PCGS MS66+ CAC 

Very high end for the grade, we really do like the look of this 

impressive GEM. Flashy mint luster on both sides accents the 

sharply struck devices and multicolored peripheral toning. There 

are no noticeable marks or scuffs, the eye appeal is great. 

PCGS 280, NGC 155, CAC 121. Only 43 are graded in MS66+. 

The current CU value is listed at $1,500 but this FRESH 

SUPERB GEM should bring more. The most recent sold for 

$2,040 in April 2018. We think a coin like this should bring that 

much or more! 


LOT 411 

50C 1893 COLUMBIAN PCGS MS66+ CAC 

Another excellent, FRESH GEM + coin! Well matched to the 

others in this mini-hoard, this one boasts lovely toning over the 

satiny smooth and lustrous surfaces. 

PCGS 280, NGC 155, CAC 121. Only 43 are graded in MS66+. 

The current CU value is listed at $1,500 but this FRESH 

SUPERB GEM should bring more. The most recent sold for 

$2,040 in April 2018. We think a coin like this should bring that 

much or more! 


LOT 412 


Wow! This is truly a SUPERB example. Even after close 

examination, we cannot understand what CAC saw that 

precluded it from getting a green bean! Sometimes they can be 

so picky! 

Highly lustrous surfaces glow and gleam from all over, 

especially in the central reverse which is a bright untoned silver. 

The peripheral tone of blue, amber, and gold really does come 

out with the bold luster. The strike is full and complete and you 

cannot beat the awesome eye appeal! 

LOT 413 


A richly toned and very high end SUPERB GEM example. 

Satiny lustrous surfaces have a radiating swirl from under the 

toning. The luster gives life to the variegated hues on both sides 

and the sharply struck up devices. 


listed at $3,500. VERY RARE any finer, PCGS has just five coins 

graded finer, all MS67+. 



listed at $3,500. VERY RARE any finer, PCGS has just five 

coins graded finer, all MS67+. 


200


LOT 414 

50C 1893 COLUMBIAN PCGS 

MS67 CAC 

This is a great looking SUPERB 

GEM--truly deserving of its bean 

from CAC. Highly lustrous surfaces 

bring out the wonderful toning on 

both sides. The toning is not dark, it 

is just rich. Swirling blues and golds 

blend with violet shades. Possessing 

a stunning eye appeal, this coin is 

perfect for any high end set! 

PCGS 36, NGC 32, CAC 20. The 

current Collector’s Universe value is 

listed at $3,500, but the last PCGS/ 

CAC sold for $4,113 in the 2017 

FUN auction.. VERY RARE any finer, PCGS has just five coins graded finer, all MS67+. 


LOT 415 

50C 1893 

COLUMBIAN PCGS 

MS67+ CAC 

Legend Rare Coin 

Auctions is proud to 

offer one of the FINEST 

Columbian Expo half 

dollars to survive. This 

remarkable SUPERB 

GEM is the final coin 

from our mini-hoard, and 

it is a stunning example! 

The surfaces are pristine 

and virtually flawless. 

A strong luster blazes 

across the surfaces on 

both sides, accenting the 

SUPERB multicolored toning that is uniform on both sides, well matched in hue to the other coins in this FRESH group. You really 

cannot beat the amazing eye appeal and glorious visual allure of this SUPERB GEM! 

PCGS 41, NGC 33, CAC 20. This is one of only FIVE graded MS67+ at PCGS and none are finer! Think about that: after nearly 33 

years of grading, there are so few actual SUPERB coins that survive from a mintage of over 1.5 million! No MS67+ has ever sold in 

auction though the PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $22,500. If you are building the FINEST set of classic commemorative halves, 

you NEED this SUPERB GEM. We can see it shattering the previous record for the type, which was achieved in 2003 for a PCGS 

MS67 for $16,100! Good luck! 


201


LOT 416 

50C 1935 CONNECTICUT. PCGS MS67 

A beautifully toned SUPERB GEM Connecticut. Highly lustrous 

surfaces show off sharply impressed devices. Lovely pastel 

iridescent toning graces both sides and the surfaces are essentially 

flawless. We have looked this SUPERB GEM over and again 

with a strong glass and cannot find anything that would preclude 

CAC approval--we are not sure what they saw. 

PCGS 96, NGC 78. The current PCGS value is listed at $1,800 

and recent auction prices realized fall in the $1,080 to $2,280 

range. This beauty has a great eye appeal, and this one should 

bring a strong bid. 


LOT 417 

50C 1935 CONNECTICUT. PCGS MS67 CAC 

A beautifully toned SUPERB GEM. Lots of gorgeous blues, 

golds, and greens frame both sides, brought out by a vivid luster 

and adding depth to the details especially among the leaves of 

the Charter Oak. 

PCGS 98, NGC 79, CAC 52. This high end and lustrous GEM 

is truly worthy of a serious bid. A similar coin sold in our July 

2018 Regency Auction for $2,585 and the current PCGS value 

is listed at only $1,800--clearly this superior quality SUPERB 

GEM is worthy of a strong bid! 


LOT 418 

50C 1936 DELAWARE. NGC MS67+ CAC 

This is a truly wonderful, SUPERB GEM tab-toned Delaware. 

Beautifully toned and awesomely preserved, the details are ultra 

sharp in definition. A boldly frosted luster blooms in the fields, 

the eye appeal is essentially unmarred, by all but the most tiny 

reeding mark. We love the look of this SUPERB GEM and it is 

worthy of the finest of commem sets! 

PCGS 173, NGC 103, CAC 66. NGC has graded five examples 

in 67+. Only one has ever sold in auction, realizing $1,140 in 

July 2018 and it does not have the stunning eye appeal of this 

beauty. The current Collector’s Universe value is listed at $2,500. 

NGC has graded four in MS68 the most recent of which brought 

$10,800 in April 2018. This is a great opportunity to buy one of 

the FINER known examples without breaking the bank! 

LOT 419 

50C 1936 ELGIN. PCGS MS67 CAC 

A beautifully toned SUPERB GEM! This coin has such a great 

look! A thick, luxurious frosty sheen drenches both sides. The 

obverse has a ring of seductive coppery-orange, azure, magenta, 

violet, and gold that surrounds the pioneer’s head which has a 

nearly matte-like frosty texture. The reverse is toned in a more 

pastel-iridescent hue. This coin is of superior quality and has a 

very high end look. 

PCGS 232, NGC 128, CAC 88. This coin brought $1,140 in 

December 2017, a testament to its superior eye appeal. We 

suspect it will bring a similar price today. Good luck. 


PCGS# 9301 | ESTIMATE: $1,300+ 

202


LOT 420 

50C 1936 ELGIN. PCGS MS67+ 

Wonderfully and originally toned, this coin clearly sat in an 

album, with frosty silver centers surrounded by olive, gold, and 

blue-green toning. Lustrous and nicely preserved, the eye appeal 

is excellent, we cannot find anything more than a tiny tick and a 

line or two that would keep this SUPERB GEM from receiving a 

CAC sticker. 

PCGS 44, NGC 5. The most recent examples, going back over 

two years were all CAC approved, realizing in the $1,700 and 

$2,100 range, and the current Collector’s Universe value is listed 

at $1,650. We think this GEM will see very active bidding and it 

will find itself at home in a great commem collection! 

LOT 421 

50C 1936 GETTYSBURG. PCGS MS65 CAC 

Commemorating the 75th anniversary of this pivotal battle of 

the Civil War, the Gettysburg half is always one of the more 

popular types in the series. Sharply struck and nicely original, 

with just a touch of golden toning on both sides, this one is 

housed in an OGH and is worthy of its CAC bean. 

PCGS 1824, NGC 1328, CAC 249. The current CU value is 

$700 and we sold one for $798 in our September 2018 

Premier Sessions. 


PCGS# 9303 | ESTIMATE: $1,300+ 

LOT 422 

50C 1922 GRANT. NGC MS67+ 

Tied for FINEST graded Grant without Star at both grading 

services. There is no question how high end this SUPERB 

GEM is! 

Satiny smooth surfaces show off a frosty satin luster that glows 

from all over. Even using a strong glass there is not a single 

tick, mark, or line that we can find even using a strong glass. 

Both sides show off an original pastel toning that comes out 

when rotated in a light. The eye appeal is very high end. 

PCGS 9, NGC 8. Only two of these have sold in auction, this 

one being the most recent selling for $3,055 in the 2016 FUN 

auction. NONE of the PCGS coins have sold in auction. The 

current Collector’s Universe value is listed at $12,000 which is 

speculation, considering no PCGS coin has ever sold in auction. 

LOT 423 

50C 1922 GRANT STAR. PCGS MS65 CAC 

One of the toughest classic commemorative half dollar issues, the 

Grant With Star saw a mintage of only 4,256. Gem survivors, like 

this old holdered coin, are very scarce indeed, and normally come 

dull and gray. This satiny GEM is the opposite, with considerable 

gold tone at the rims. The surfaces are devoid of any contact 

worthy of mention. The devices are sharply struck up and the eye 

appeal and quality are worthy of the CAC endorsement and will 

entice strong bidding from commemorative collectors. 

PCGS 181, NGC 223, CAC 29. Rare any finer, the last PCGS 

MS65 CAC sold in April 2018 for $5,280. The current CU 

value is listed at $4,700 and remember that in 66 the value 

jumps to $8,000. 

PCGS# 9307 | ESTIMATE: $4,000+ 

PCGS# 9306 | ESTIMATE: $3,500+ 

203


LOT 424 

50C 1928 HAWAIIAN. PCGS MS65 

Here is a wonderfully toned and original GEM Hawaiian. This is 

not a dull or drab looking coin like the way many come, nor does 

it have that bright yellow-gold tone as seen on so many others. 

Rich sea-green blends with just a touch of yellow-gold, olive, 

and lavender-pewter tones. We do think this one may have come 

from the famed Bank of Hawaii Hoard, which attests to the color. 

There are a few tiny ticks here and there, but we are not exactly 

sure why this GEM did not sticker at CAC--the eye appeal is very 

nice indeed. 

PCGS 546, NGC 355. The last two non-CAC examples sold in 

June 2018 for $2,640 and $2,880, the current PCGS value is listed 

at $3,750. With a mintage under 10,000 the Hawaiian is a key in 

the series and always popular thanks to its beautiful design. 

LOT 425 

50C 1928 HAWAIIAN. PCGS MS65 CAC 

A lovely silver lustrous GEM example at this KEY date 

commem. A glowing, frosty, glossy luster rolls on both sides of 

this well struck Hawaiian. Worthy of its endorsement by CAC, 

this coin is high end for the grade and we can see only a tick or 

two using a strong glass. 

PCGS 547, NGC 355, CAC 140. The last one sold for $3,120 in 

June 2018. Four others have sold this year for the same amount. 

We sold one for $3,878 in our December 2017 Regency Auction 

and the current Collector’s Universe value is listed at $3,750. 

Bound for a GEM set of classic commems. 

PCGS# 9309 | ESTIMATE: $2,800+ 

PCGS# 9309 | ESTIMATE: $2,500+ 

LOT 426 

50C 1928 HAWAIIAN. PCGS MS65+ CAC 

A delightfully toned GEM! Everything about this GEM is 

original and very pleasing. High end everything! 

Sharply struck devices are brought out by a glittering 

underlying luster. Shades of yellow-gold, pastel green, crimson, 

amber, olive, russet-tan. The eye appeal is excellent. 

PCGS 562, NGC 360, CAC 140. Only 15 examples have graded 

in MS65+ at PCGS. Totally original and wonderfully toned, 

this GEM is worth more than the $4,250 listed by CU. A great 

looking coin for any set! 

LOT 427 

50C 1935 HUDSON. PCGS MS66 CAC 

Ex. AGW Collection, as noted on the insert. 

A very pretty and high end GEM Hudson. Ultra-lustrous, surfaces 

are very clean and free of any distracting marks. Brick-red tone 

clings to the peripheries and adds to the wonderful eye appeal. 

PCGS 286, NGC 153, CAC 114. We sold one in our Regency 

Auction 27 for $1,410, and the current PCGS value is listed at 

$1,300. With its great look, this one is worthy of a strong bid. 

PCGS# 9312 | ESTIMATE: $1,200+ 

PCGS# 9309 | ESTIMATE: $5,000+ 

204


LOT 428 

LOT OF TWO GOLD CAC STICKER CLASSIC COMMEMORATIVES 

Lot includes: 

50C 1924 HUGUENOT PCGS MS63 GOLD CAC in an OGH-- Spectacular toning for a Huguenot half and an amazing eye appeal 

for a 63, clearly a coin that is ultra conservatively graded--there are 65s that don’t look this good! 

1936 YORK NGC MS65 GOLD CAC “fatty” holder--Exceptionally lustrous with a brilliant satin sheen with rich gold tab toning. 

We have seen MS66s without such a great look! 

This pair is destined to start off a collection of awesome classic commemoratives. They are not the finest graded, but they are truly 

SUPERB! This lot will see very active bidding! 



50C 1946 IOWA. NGC MS68 CAC 

For a lack of better term, and not to sound cliche, this coin is 

SUPERB and is unbelievably high end and wonderful! 

Brilliant swirling mint luster beams from all over giving life 

to the beautiful reds and blues and brings out the subtle greens 

and golds that blend in. The mixture of colors is extremely eye 

appealing and the grade is spot on! We see no flaws of any kind 

and the devices are very sharply struck up. 

PCGS 75, NGC 40, CAC 48. Prices are all over the place, based 

on the eye appeal. We know this one will bring a strong price 

for sure! The current Collector’s Universe value is listed at 

$1,800. A somewhat more dappled but beautifully toned PCGS 

MS68 CAC sold for $2,300 in our June 2017 Regency Auction. 

This great coin should sell for close to that. Good luck! 

PCGS# 9316 | ESTIMATE: $1,200+ 

LOT 430 

50C 1925 LEXINGTON. PCGS MS66+ CAC 

Truly a superior quality Lexington. The surfaces are brilliantly 

lustrous and the devices are especially crisp and sharply rendered. 

The fields are free of any distracting marks or ticks. There is just 

a touch of iridescent toning across the surfaces. This is a great 

example with a full complete strike. 

PCGS 459, NGC 224, CAC 123. There are only 41 coins graded 

MS66+ at PCGS, 15 at NGC. RARE any finer, with just 28 

graded (MS67+ finest). There is a very wide range of APRs in 

MS66+ for PCGS/CAC coins: recent examples have sold in the 

$840-$2,350 range, with the most recent selling in June 2018 

for $1,800 The $2,350 was realized in our May 2016 Regency 

Auction. The current PCGS value is listed at $1,200 and this one 

should easily surpass that level. 

PCGS# 9318 | ESTIMATE: $1,200+ 

205


LOT 431 

50C 1918 LINCOLN. NGC MS67+* 

One of the absolute FINEST Lincolns we have seen! The surfaces 

are blindingly brilliant with bold cartwheels and hints of semi 

prooflike reflection, particularly in the obverse fields. Lincoln’s 

portrait stands out with a very bold definition and the reverse 

eagle and arms are all beautifully defined as well. Every detail 

is crisply defined. The obverse is beautifully toned with rich 

reddish-copper tones that really highlight the awesome quality of 

the surfaces. Truly a prize for the commemorative collector, and 

well deserving of its lofty designation. 

PCGS 139, NGC 70. This is the ONLY NGC MS67+ graded and 

is not the one that sold in 2015. The most recent example PCGS 

graded example sold for $4,080 in the 2018 FUN auction. The 

current Collector’s Universe value is listed at $3,750. NGC has 

graded 4 in MS68 finer, none of which have sold since 2007! This 

is one of the FINEST that exists and should see a very strong 

price realized based solely on its amazing look! 

PCGS# 9320 | ESTIMATE: $2,500+ 

LOT 432 

50C 1936 LYNCHBURG. PCGS MS67+ 

Ex San Diego Collection. With just a single coin graded finer, 

this beautifully toned Lynchburg is a more vividly toned than 

the beauty that we sold in our recent Regency Auction 28 sale. 

Wonderful orange and gold tone is met with pearly-silversea 

green color and brought out by the SUPERB underlying 

luster. The sharply struck devices stand out against the smooth 

surfaces and there is just a single line worthy of mention, 

visible with a glass. 

PCGS 134, NGC 103. There are only 15 graded in MS67+. The 

most recent examples were CAC approved, you have to go back 

over three years to get a non-CAC coin. The current Collector’s 

Universe value is listed at $3,000. Only a single MS68 finer, a 

coin that never sold in auction, making this beauty one of the 

FINEST available to collectors. We anticipate strong bidding 

for this colorful SUPERB GEM! 

PCGS# 9324 | ESTIMATE: $2,500+ 

LOT 433 

50C 1934 MARYLAND. PCGS MS67 

The obverse is beautifully toned with soft pastel blue at the rims 

and a coppery-peach hue in the center all brought out by a brilliant 

mint luster the reverse has a light dusting of the faintest gold tone 

adding dimension to the SUPERB surfaces and well struck devices. 


listed at $1,750 and the most recent example we sold was 

CAC approved and realized $2,115 in our July 2018 Regency 

Auction. Only 12 coins are graded finer at PCGS, all MS67+. A 

great coin for any serious collector of classic commemoratives! 

PCGS# 9328 | ESTIMATE: $1,000+ 

LOT 434 

50C 1921 MISSOURI. PCGS MS65+ CAC 

This is not your typical dull, lackluster Missouri! Sharply struck 

devices stand out with the aid of highly frosted fields. A light 

dusting of golden-tan, and olive-gold toning graces the surfaces 

of both the obverse and reverse. The surfaces are especially clean 

and very attractive--this coin is PQ! 

PCGS 305, NGC 307, CAC 63. There are only 14 coins graded in 

MS65+ at PCGS. The last three PCGS/CAC examples sold in the 

$2,585 to $2,820, these sold from October 2014 to April 2018. 

Keep in mind that a PCGS/CAC MS66 would likely cost $6,000+ 

if you can find one, making this one a great value for a collector 

of GEM commems! 

PCGS# 9330 | ESTIMATE: $2,200+ 

206


LOT 435 

50C 1923-S MONROE. PCGS MS66 

A true GEM Monroe half. This is a commemorative that often 

is highly lacking in terms of quality and eye appeal. This 

one is highly eye appealing with a satin luster and delicate, 

delightful pastel toning. As you rotate the surfaces in a light, 

peach-orange, aqua-blue, and olive-gold accent the smooth, 

problem free surfaces. The strike is better than usually seen on 

this notoriously FLAT type. This one is an exception with full 

detail on the reverse. 

PCGS 108, NGC 60. The current PCGS value is listed at $2,000 

and there is a wide range of prices realized in the last two 

years, ranging from $1,080 to $2,585; the most recent selling 

for $1,920 in April 2018. A beauty like this will realize a strong 

price for sure, this is a great coin for the Commemorative 

collector. VERY RARE finer! 

PCGS# 9333 | ESTIMATE: $1,200+ 

LOT 436 

50C 1938 NEW ROCHELLE. PCGS MS67+ 

A beautiful TAB toned SUPERB GEM. The original holder 

imparted magenta, gold, orange, and sea-green tone about the 

peripheries on on the obverse, while the reverse is blanketed 

by a dusting of sky blue and clear gold. The central obverse is 

a brilliant silver that gleams with a strong brilliance. The eye 

appeal is excellent and we are not sure why CAC did not bean it. 

PCGS 257, NGC 86. PCGS has graded 47 in 67+, which must 

represent much duplication of submissions. This impeccable 

SUPERB GEM realized $2,400 when it sold in April 2018. 

The current PCGS price is listed at $2,750. While there are 7 

coins graded numerically higher at PCGS, NONE have ever 

sold in auction. This is a wonderfully original coin worthy of a 

premium bid and inclusion in a great commem set.! 

PCGS# 9335 | ESTIMATE: $2,000+ 

LOT 437 

50C 1938 NEW ROCHELLE. PCGS 

SP66+ CAC 

We have been honored to offer a good 

number of these Specimen Strike New 

Rochelle half dollars over the last few 

years, and each time we marvel at the 

dramatic flash the surfaces have! 

A very rare variant to the New 

Rochelle half dollar. During the 

production run, mint employees struck 

50 examples on polished planchets 

after polishing the dies. What keeps 

them from being full PROOFS, is that 

each coin was struck only once, rather 

than two or more times as required for striking proofs. As expected for the 66+ grade level, this coin has no hairlines, ticks, marks or 

carbon spotting. The strike is full and the fields are fully PL and display deep mirrors. 

PCGS 3, NGC 4, CAC 4. There are just two graded SP66+ at PCGS. We sold the other one in February 2017 for $12,925. A great coin 

to add to any advanced classic commemorative set, and we anticipate strong bidding when it comes to the block. Good luck! 

PCGS# 99335 | ESTIMATE: $9,000+ 

207


LOT 438 

50C 1936 NORFOLK. PCGS MS68 CAC 

Virtual perfection in every way! Rich copper-gold with colorful 

tinges of greenish and pinkish iridescence is noted at the rims 

giving this SUPERB GEM a beautiful look. Put a loupe to this 

one if you want to know what spectacular quality really is, for 

few coins of any series come this well preserved. There simply 

are no distracting marks to be found. The strike is full and 

complete, and the eye appeal unending. 

PCGS 201, NGC 88, CAC 86. The most recent example sold for 

$1,680 in the 2018 ANA auction, and before that, one sold for 

$1,800 in June 2018. This coin will certainly bring well above the 

CU value of $1,250. A wonderful addition to any set! 

PCGS# 9337 | ESTIMATE: $1,500+ 

LOT 439 

50C 1926-S OREGON. PCGS MS67+ CAC 

We love this design! It is one of the most beautiful of the 

classic commems, and when they are of exceptional quality as 

here, you will be hard pressed not to love it too.The impressive 

album toning is the first thing that catches your eye! Blue, gold, 

and orange peripheral tone accents the sharply struck up devices 

and boldly lustrous surfaces. We cannot find anything worthy of 

mention anywhere. This is such an amazing looking SUPERB 

GEM that will delight any commem collector! 

PCGS 201, NGC 173, CAC 129. There are only 26 graded 

MS67+ at PCGS. The most recent PCGS/CAC example to sell 

brought $4,320 in April 2018. A non-CAC NGC coin brought 

the same in the 2018 FUN auction. Clearly of late, this date/ 

grade has demand that exceeds the supply and the $1,800 CU 

value needs to be updated. Only a dozen are finer, with a 68 

being worth around $10,000. Good luck! 

PCGS# 9341 | ESTIMATE: $2,000+ 

LOT 440 

50C 1937-D OREGON. PCGS MS67 CAC 

High end for the grade, and totally original we love the look of this 

well struck and frosty SUPERB GEM housed in a first generation 

PCGS holder. 

PCGS 703, 540, 344. The current CU value is $525 and keep in 

mind that we sold a marginally higher grade example for $1,375 in 

our August 2018 Premier Session internet only auction. 


LOT 441 

50C 1937-D OREGON. PCGS MS68 CAC 

The word superb just does not convey the message for this 

37-D Oregon. It is a killer piece! Sharply struck up devices 

and uber-smooth surfaces are enhanced by a satiny mint frost. 

The luster is wonderful, giving off a pearlescent look over the 

majority of the surfaces yielding to vivid blue and burnt orange at 

the periphery. The eye appeal is exceptional in every way. 

PCGS 61, NGC 73, CAC 36. PCGS/CAC coins, when you do 

not count the $9,106 that the superbly toned Bruce Schur- Aurora 

Borealis coin brought in our July 2018 Regency Auction, sales are 

in the $1,500-$2,500 range. Collector’s Universe is listed at $1,750 

and this one should bring well in excess of that amount. Good luck! 

PCGS# 9347 | ESTIMATE: $1,750+ 

208


LOT 442 

50C 1938-S OREGON. PCGS MS66 CAC 

A lovely PQ GEM in a first generation PCGS slab. Frosty mint 

luster accents the sharply struck devices and original toned 

surfaces. The eye appeal is quite nice. 

PCGS 600, NGC 513, CAC 115. The last PCGS/CAC example 

brought $300 and the current CU value is $285; this one should 

bring more. 


LOT 443 

50C 1939-S OREGON. PCGS MS65 CAC GOLD STICKER 

Conservatively graded in a first generation PCGS encapsulation, 

this GEM really has a look that rivals MS67s that we have 

seen in the market (no guarantees). What we can attest to is the 

wonderful original look, razor sharp strike, and satin mint frost. 

The eye appeal is amazing. 

PCGS 416, NGC 238, CAC 42. CAC has given FIVE 

CAC-gold stickers at this grade level. The CU grade in MS66 

is $675 and a similar looking MS67 sold for $1,145 in our July 

2018 Regency Auction. This GEM looks great and will see 

strong bidding for sure. Good luck! 


LOT 444 

50C 1915-S PAN-PAC. PCGS MS65+ CAC 

A beautiful GEM! The central devices are brilliantly lustrous and 

bright silver while the peripheries have a band of teal, olive, and 

gold hues that bring out the definition to the sharply struck devices. 

The eye appeal is great. 

PCGS 582, NGC 502, CAC 127. There are only 14 in MS65+ at 

PCGS, 15 at NGC. The current PCGS value is listed at $1,650 and 

this one should see fierce bidding for its great quality. 

PCGS# 9357 | ESTIMATE: $1,100+ 

LOT 445 

50C 1920 PILGRIM. PCGS MS67 

For a Pilgrim, the present example is SUPERB. We are not 

exactly sure why CAC did not sticker this one. Its surfaces are 

of wonderful quality and eye appeal, imparted by a bold satin 

bloom, sharp strike, and totally original color. 

PCGS 51, NGC 20. The most recent to sell was a similarly 

toned CAC-approved coin that realized $2,703 in the July 2018 

Regency Auction. The most recent non-CAC coin sold for $2,040 

in April 2018 and the current CU value is listed at $2,000. VERY 

RARE any finer, this one will delight any serious commem 

collector for sure! 

PCGS# 9359 | ESTIMATE: $1,500+ 

209


LOT 446 

50C 1936-D RHODE ISLAND. PCGS MS67 CAC 

What an amazing SUPERB GEM Rhode Island half dollar! It 

is incredible to think that there are seven coins finer at PCGS! 

Every detail is exquisite in its execution and definition. Bold 

and brilliant, the luster simply sparkles all over with a strong 

vibrance. Stupendous rainbow bands are seen at the peripheries, 

and the eye appeal is just gorgeous. An AMAZING coin! 

PCGS 72, NGC 38, CAC 33. More beautiful than the ex Paul 

Denby coin that we sold in our July 2018 Regency Auction for 

$1,234. This SUPERB coin is a real prize for any colorfully toned 

commemorative coin collector! 

PCGS# 9364 | ESTIMATE: $1,000+ 

LOT 447 

50C 1936-D RHODE ISLAND. PCGS MS67+ CAC 

One of the sharpest struck 36-D Rhode Island we have seen 

and the quality is excellent! A bold glowing luster beams from 

all over amplifying the subtle gold and icy blue that accent 

the pearly silver surfaces. The eye appeal is just amazing and 

deservingly sits near the top of the PCGS Population Report! 

PCGS 78, NGC 39, CAC 34. Only 5 have been graded with a “+:” 

No PCGS MS67+ has ever sold in auction. There is a giant gap 

between the last MS67 and MS68 that have sold in auction, both in 

recent LRCA auctions. The last PCGS/CAC MS67 old for $1,234 

in July 2018 and the only MS68 PCGS/CAC sold for $43,475 in 

our May 2018 Regency Auction. The current Price Guide value in 

67+ is listed at $2,500 and this one will likely surpass that amount 

easily! Bound for one of the FINEST sets that exists! 

PCGS# 9364 | ESTIMATE: $1,800+ 

LOT 448 

50C 1937 ROANOKE. NGC MS68 CAC 

Everything about this coin is beautiful! It is essentially perfect in 

every way. Well struck, highly lustrous, and richly toned and with 

a superb look, this Roanoke has it all! Red, orange, royal blue, and 

deep violet are brought to life by the radiating luster that gleams 

and beams in the fields. Taking a close look at the surfaces with a 

strong glass proves that this coin is as close to perfection as you 

can hope to get, we see no marks anywhere. Needless to say, the 

eye appeal is stunning--you will have a hard time putting this 

beauty down. 

PCGS 26, NGC 29, CAC 16. This coin has a great look. The most 

recent CAC-approved coin was PCGS graded and sold for $7,800 

in the 2018 ANA auction. The only NGC/CAC coin to ever sell 

in auction realized $4,259 in the 2014 FUN auction, and we think 

this one has a better look. The current Collector’s Universe value is 

listed at $4,500. NONE ARE GRADED FINER at NGC. 

PCGS# 9367 | ESTIMATE: $3,000+ 

LOT 449 

50C 1936 ROBINSON. PCGS MS67 CAC 

Lovely pastel iridescent toned surfaces are brought out by a vivid 

satin luster giving both sides a supple, velvety look. Violet tinges 

blend with pewter in the centers and a dusting of golden-tan at 

the peripheries; the color is certainly richer on the reverse than 

on the obverse. The surfaces are totally devoid of any marks that 

we can find. Under inspection with a glass, there is nothing that 

impairs the exceptional eye appeal. 

PCGS 88, NGC 30, CAC 27. The most recent example to sell in 

auction realized $2,040 in ANA 2018 auction, and prior to that, 

one sold in April 2018 for $1,920. Only a half dozen examples 

graded finer at PCGS, NONE of which have sold since February 

2005! This one will clearly see fierce bidding from the advanced 

collector when it crosses the block! 

PCGS# 9369 | ESTIMATE: $1,600+ 

210


LOT 450 

50C 1936-D SAN DIEGO. PCGS MS67 CAC 

We wish all San Diego half dollars looked like this! Blisteringly 

lustrous with a vibrance that grabs the viewer from across the 

room. But its glorious luster is just part of the story of this 

stunner--the other is the gorgeous toning at the rims on both sides 

that display the full spectrum of rainbow color that frames the 

brilliant silver centers. The eye appeal really is off the charts with 

this one! 

PCGS 102, NGC 49, CAC 62. The most recent PCGS coin to sell 

was CAC approved and sold for $3,840 and was the Bruce Schur 

coin. This amazing coin has a very similar look and is worthy of 

a premium bid. 

PCGS# 9372 | ESTIMATE: $2,000+ 

LOT 451 

50C 1926 SESQUICENTENNIAL. PCGS MS65+ CAC 

A beautifully toned GEM example of this popular and important 

condition rarity in the classic commemorative series. While 141,120 

pieces were struck, they do not survive in great quantity in MS65 

or finer grades. Even fewer have killer original toning. Lustrous 

surfaces are smooth and defect free. 

PCGS 389, NGC 294, CAC 94. In MS65+, PCGS has graded 

19 pieces, the most recent of which sold for $3,525 in our July 

2018 Regency Auction. Prior to that one sold for $7,500 in 

April 2018. The current PCGS Price Guide value is $4,500. 

Only a dozen examples are graded finer at PCGS, all MS66. We 

sold a CAC-approved example for $22,325 in our December 

2017 Regency Auction. This one will see considerable bidding 

when it crosses the block, the eye appeal is SUPERB! 

PCGS# 9374 | ESTIMATE: $3,200+ 

LOT 452 

50C 1935 SPANISH TRAIL. PCGS MS67+ 

This piece is seriously above and beyond what you typically see. 

We rank this as a VERY high end MS67+. 

Virtually perfect surfaces are smooth all over. A moderate (good) 

luster glistens from the surfaces. Light pastel like colors of lilac/ 

pale green/amber swirl all over. There are no discolorations or 

spots. All of the details are sharply struck and stand out. The eye 

appeal is gorgeous! 

PCGS 164, NGC 107. PCGS has graded 21 coins in MS67+. The 

last MS67+ to sell in auction brought $2,880 in December 2017. 

The current Collectorís Universe Value is $3,500. We predict 

strong bidding for this marvelous Commem! 

PCGS# 9376 | ESTIMATE: $3,000+ 

LOT 453 

50C 1925 STONE MOUNTAIN. NGC MS67+ CAC 

VERY HIGH END! Satin, frosty mint luster blooms in the fields. 

The surfaces are clean and free of any distracting marks, as 

you would expect for a SUPERB GEM of this lofty grade. The 

details are very sharply struck up with all the details of Stonewall 

Jackson and Robert E. Lee crisply defined. Pleasing pale gold 

tone attests to the awesome originality! 

PCGS 290, NGC 186, CAC 98. There are only seven MS67+’s 

graded at NGC and none have sold in auction since March 2011. 

More recently a PCGS/CAC example sold in the 2018 FUN auction 

for $2,040 and the current Collector’s Universe value is listed at 

$2,500. There are 13 graded MS68 at NGC finer. What a great 

opportunity to add a wonderful example without spending $5,000+. 

PCGS# 9378 | ESTIMATE: $1,800+ 

211


LOT 454 

50C 1934 TEXAS. PCGS MS67+ CAC 

This is a truly stunning Texas half, indeed the eye appeal is as 

huge as the state this coin commemorates! 

This coin is about as high end and beautifully toned as you 

could hope for. A narrow band of rainbow toning at the extreme 

periphery blends to golden-lavender in the center. Sharply struck 

up, the eye appeal is very high end and very pleasing. 

PCGS 110, NGC 65, CAC 61. There are only 14 graded MS67+. 

The last one to sell realized $3,995 in the 2017 FUN auction; 

prior to that one sold for $2,820 in August 2013. The current 

PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $1,600. Only two coins are 

finer, and none have sold in auction in the last 14 years! 

LOT 455 

50C 1935-D TEXAS. PCGS MS67+ CAC 

Flashy! The obverse fields have a distinct, semi-PL reflection 

to the luster. The eagle and star stand out with a dramatic 3-D 

effect. The reverse is very well struck and each detail is frosty 

and boldly rendered. The obverse is framed with a lovely original 

halo of toning. 

PCGS 288, NGC 174, CAC 156. Three are 26 reported in MS67+ 

at PCGS. Only 10,007 were struck, so we think there is a lot of 

duplication in the population figures. We sold two in June 2015 

for $1,469 and $2,468. This SUPERB coin has a great look and 

should realize well in excess of the $1,000 PCGS value. 

PCGS# 9383 | ESTIMATE: $1,000+ 

PCGS# 9381 | ESTIMATE: $1,000+ 

LOT 456 

50C 1937 TEXAS. PCGS MS67+ CAC 

A brilliantly satiny SUPERB GEM is virtually perfect. Using 

a strong glass we cannot find a single mark worthy of mention 

on the lustrous, pearly-hued surfaces. Nicely struck up, the eye 

appeal is great. 

PCGS 148, NGC 81, CAC 80. There are 20 coins on the PCGS 

Population Report as MS67+. The most recent example brought 

$1,080 and prior to that, these were selling between $1,175 

and $1,645 and the current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at 

$1,500. Only five coins are graded higher, with a single MS68+ 

as finest. This very appealing coin will see extremely strong 

bidding from commem collectors. 

PCGS# 9390 | ESTIMATE: $1,000+ 

LOT 457 

50C 1925 VANCOUVER. NGC MS67+ CAC 

A SUPERB looking Vancouver. Totally original in all respects, 

a dusting of coppery-tan, powder-blue, rosy-peach, and pale 

lilac toning that clings to the sharply struck devices and satin 

smooth fields. A bold luster shows a strong vibrance throughout 

imparting a stunning visual allure. No doubt that this coin is 

clearly worthy of being tied for FINEST at NGC! 

PCGS 78, NGC 54, CAC 37. NGC has graded four in 67+ and 

none are finer. The only NGC 67+ that ever sold in auction was 

in our October 2017 Regency Auction. In July 2018 we sold a 

PCGS example for $4,348. The current Collector’s Universe 

value is listed at $5,750. Only three PCGS graded coins are finer, 

and none have sold in the last seven plus years, making this one 

one of the FINEST available to collectors! Good luck! 

PCGS# 9399 | ESTIMATE: $2,500+ 

212


LOT 458 

50C 1927 VERMONT. NGC MS67* 

One look at this SUPREB GEM and it is readily apparent why 

NGC bestowed it with its star designation for eye appeal! A frosty 

satin sliver luster gleams all over, bringing out the sensational 

golden overtones and accents of reddish-orange and pastel 

iridescence on the obverse. The surfaces are free of all but the 

most insignificant marks, visible only with a strong glass. The 

eye appeal is great! 

PCGS 58, NGC 24. We sold a PCGS/CAC coin that did not 

have the beautiful toning of this coin for $6,169 in our July 2017 

Regency Auction. The current Collector’s Universe value is 

$4,500. Superior in eye appeal to many that we have seen and 

will bring a strong price. 

LOT 459 

50C 1946-D BOOKER T. WASHINGTON. PCGS MS66+ 

CAC 

An amazing Booker T! Brilliant silver centers contrast with a 

stunning violet-brick toning at the rims. Sharply struck up, highly 

lustrous, and SUPERB quality surfaces all combine to make this 

one stunning B.T.W. 

PCGS 406, NGC 278, CAC 79. There are only 21 in 66+ graded 

at PCGS. This beautiful coin is worthy of any collection of 

spectacular toned commems, pay no attention to the previous 

APRs or CU value, this coin will bring a very strong bid! 


PCGS# 9401 | ESTIMATE: $2,000+ 

LOT 460 

50C 1946-D BOOKER T. WASHINGTON. PCGS MS67 CAC 

A magnificently toned Booker T. Washington! One of the more 

common classic commems, but they are anything but when they 

possess the vivid toning on both sides like this one. Reds, golds, 

greens, and blues blend beautifully across the entire obverse. 

Impressively struck devices are accented by the bold underlying 

frost and the entire “package” is exceptional! 

PCGS 55, NGC 47, CAC 68. This is the NGC/CAC coin that 

brought a very strong $2,280 in the 2018 Central States auction, 

and another dramatically toned PCGS/CAC coin sold for $3,840; 

both well beyond the current CU value of $800. 

LOT 461 

50C 1952 WASHINGTON-CARVER. NGC MS67 

A very pretty blend of blue, violet, rose, and red hues are evenly 

dusted across the SUPERB GEM surfaces on both sides. Sharply 

struck, this is a very well preserved Washington-Carver half. The 

eye appeal is exceptional. 

PCGS 24, NGC 26. The last NGC coin to sell brought $684, but 

it did NOT have the stunning eye appeal of this one. The current 

Collector’s Universe value is listed at $1,500 and this one with its 

great look should bring a very serious bid. Good luck! 


PCGS# 9405 | ESTIMATE: $2,000+ 

213


LOT 462 

50C 1952-S WASHINGTON- 

CARVER. PCGS MS67+ 

CAC 

Ranking at the top of the 

PCGS Population Report, 

this STUNNING example is 

the final issue of the classic 

commemorative series. Only 

8,006 were distributed and 

NONE have graded higher than 

this coin! Not only is it high end 

in terms of grade, in terms of 

eye appeal this coin CANNOT 

BE BEAT! 

Rich aubergine tone with 

accents of peach and emerald 

is all brought to life by a gleaming, brilliant, swirling mint luster. Every detail is fully struck up and the surfaces are totally and 

completely without flaw. The eye appeal is simply stunning! 

PCGS 13, NGC 23, CAC 17. There are three graded MS67+ at PCGS and NONE are graded finer. None of these three have ever sold 

in auction. A wonderfully toned MS67 without CAC sold for $11,163 in March 2013. In MS67+, the current Collector’s Universe 

value is listed at $12,500. Worthy of the FINEST classic commemorative set! Good luck! 

PCGS# 9436 | ESTIMATE: $10,000+ 

LOT 463 

50C 1936 WISCONSIN. PCGS MS67 CAC 

This Wisconsin is SUPER HIGH END! At one time this colorful 

GEM traded for $7,500! At the very least it should have been a 

MS67+ (PCGS obviously does not think so). 

The main attraction of this coin are its dramatic colors. It is close 

to being the equivalent of any Northern Lights Dollar. You can 

see plenty of GEM original red/purple/pearl green/gold and other 

“Christmas” like colors swirling around all over. We do rank the 

colors a 8+ on our 1-10 color scale (10 is the best). You know that 

Wisconsins RARELY come with this kind of original color. 

PCGS 512, NGC 361, CAC 243. Realizing a strong price, 

this SUPERB GEM realized $3,410 in our May 2018 Premier 

Session. Again, this coin is about the colors, if you are building 

a very pretty colorful commem set, this is a coin you do not want 

to miss! 

PCGS# 9447 | ESTIMATE: $2,800+ 

LOT 464 

50C 1936 YORK. PCGS MS68 CAC 

Absolutely PRISTINE! This remarkable SUPERB GEM is visual 

perfection. A wonderful cartwheel luster glows with an unusual 

amount of vivacity. A delicate sky blue iridescence blends with 

the clearest of gold toning around the peripheries. The simple 

details are sharply impressed with razor sharp definition. The eye 

appeal is AMAZING! 

PCGS 31, NGC 31, CAC 13. Remarkably, PCGS reports four 

coins graded higher. The most recent PCGS/CAC example 

to sell in auction realized $3,302 back in the January 2015 

FUN auction--a sale that took place during a weak point in the 

market. Prior to that, one sold in September 2014 for $4,113. 

The eye appeal is exceptional and we can see this coin selling 

for way more than the current $2,200 PCGS Price Guide value. 

NOTHING FINER has ever sold in auction! Bound for a world 

class commem set! 


214


LOT 465 

G$1 1903 LA PURCHASE, 

JEFFERSON. PCGS MS67+ 

CAC 

A virtually perfect example, 

and tied for FINEST GRADED 

at PCGS! 

Sharply struck throughout 

with exceptional definition of 

the devices on both sides. A 

stunning and bold satiny golden 

mint bloom shines all over the 

flawless surfaces. Lovely dual 

tone golden colors add to the 

outstanding visual allure of this 

SUPERB GEM! 

PCGS 143, NGC 93, CAC 60. There are 13 coins graded MS67+ at PCGS, with NONE finer. We believe that a number of these 

represent the same coin being submitted a few times in hopes of a higher grade. NGC has graded 2 in MS67+ and a MS68 finer. The 

current CU value is listed at $7,000 and the most recent CAC example in 67+ to sell realized $6,169 in the 2016 ANA auction. The 

record for one selling is $8,226 in the 2016 CSNS. The sole NGC 68 sold for $15,600 in September 2017. We sold one in our January 

2018 Regency Auction for $7,931. Anyone building a top ranking set of golden commemoratives, should seriously consider bidding 

on this beauty. Be ready for fierce bidding competition! 

PCGS# 7443 | ESTIMATE: $6,000+ 

LOT 466 

G$1 1903 LA PURCHASE 

PCGS MS67+ CAC 

A visually and technically 

STUNNING superb GEM. 

This little jewel is just oozing 

with rich originality. Among 

the finest graded by PCGS, this 

piece boasts a brilliant golden 

surface that drips with a reddish 

hue over exceptionally gorgeous 

gold color. Every tiny detail is 

struck up with full precision and 

is exacting in its definition. Even 

the tiny mint made die polish 

lines are visible in the fields, 

suggesting an early striking 

before they wore off the surface. 

Although 125,000 were initially authorized, the reported net mintage is listed at 17,500 and the remaining pieces were melted due to 

poor sales. 

PCGS 132, NGC 120, CAC 66. PCGS has graded 11 in MS67+ with a mere two coins finer (the most recent MS68 to sell brought a 

robust $25,850 last year). The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $8,500 and this coin is truly worthy of a premium bid! If 

you are working on a top quality set, this coin should definitely be added to your collection! 

PCGS# 7444 | ESTIMATE: $7,000+ 

215


LOT 467 

$2.50 1926 SESQUICENTENNIAL. PCGS MS64 

Conservatively graded, we are not sure why CAC chose not to 

bean this one--we have seen coins in MS65 that do not look as 

CHOICE! Needless to say, this coin is very high end for the grade. 

Brilliantly lustrous, great color, and needle sharp strikes. There are 

a few tiny marks, but none that are inappropriate for the grade, and 

we have seen higher graded coins that do not look this nice! 

PCGS 4505, NGC 2619. While the CU value of a 64 is $650, we 

really think this coin will end up around the prices realized for 

MS65s, which is in the $1,000-$1,500 range. 

LOT 468 

$2.50 1926 SESQUICENTENNIAL. 

NGC MS66 CAC 

A truly GLORIOUS GEM Sesqui 

quarter eagle. Bold, satin frosty mint 

luster blooms all over, and has a brilliant 

radiance over the smooth surfaces that 

are found on both sides. Totally original 

golden-orange with a rose-gold sheen 

that accents the crisply struck up devices. 

The eye appeal is wonderful and totally 

original. Housed in an NGC “Fatty” 

holder. 


PCGS 183, NGC 108, CAC 17. Only a 

single CAC-coin has ever sold in auction, 

realizing $10,925 way back in July 2009! That coin was PCGS graded. These have really been beaten in value over the last few years, 

but this impressive GEM is truly worthy of a great collection of gold commems. This is a type that is excessively rare any finer, and 

we suspect that a good number of the coins on the pops are duplicate submissions. 

PCGS# 7466 | ESTIMATE: $6,250+ 

LOT 469 

$2.50 1926 

SESQUICENTENNIAL. 

PCGS MS66+ CAC 

What an AMAZING, superb 

GEM quality Sesqui quarter 

eagle! A brilliant satin luster 

blooms from all over with very 

flashy, radiating cartwheel luster. 

Every design element is sharply 

struck showing full definition. 

A medium orange golden-glow 

shows some areas of light rose 

toning, giving this beauty a 

stunning look. Only under the 

magnification of a strong loupe 

can you see any tiny ticks. 

PCGS 190, NGC 108, CAC 17. Only six coins have been graded 66+ at PCGS, none at NGC. The ONLY CAC-approved one sold in 

January 2018 for $19,200. There is a SINGLE MS67 graded finer at PCGS, a coin that has not sold in auction in over 18 years! This is 

a great coin, a real prize for the gold commem collector! 

PCGS# 7466 | ESTIMATE: $16,000+ 

216


LOT 470 

$50 1915-S PANAMA-PACIFIC. OCTAGONAL. PCGS 

MS62 

Regardless of grade, the Pan-Pac $50 gold pieces are 

impressive--one of the most impressive of all U.S. coin 

designs. The design, with allegorical representations of 

wisdom, strength, power are presented with Minerva on 

the obverse and her owl on a pine branch on the reverse. 

In the corners are swimming dolphins representing the 

connecting of the Atlantic and Pacific via the newly opened 

canal in Panama. Only 645 of these octagonal “slugs” 

were sold at the Pan-Pac expo, and after. With such a low 

mintage and unique design, this is one of the “blue chips” 

of American numismatics. 

For such a modest grade Mint State coin, this coin has a 

great deal of eye appeal. A heavy coin like this (contains 

nearly 2.5 ounces of gold), is bound to obtain some minor 

marks and ticks, and there are a few microscopic ones 

that can only be seen with a glass. The eye appeal is very 

choice for the grade! 

PCGS 105, NGC 63. The last example realized $75,000 

in July 2018 and prior to that, in the 2018 FUN auction, 

two NGC coins sold for $75,000 and $87,000. The current 

PCGS value is listed at $80,000. This impressive coin will 

delight any commemorative collector or someone building 

a collection of great gold type coins. Good luck! 

PCGS# 7452 | ESTIMATE: $62,500+ 

217


LOT 471 

G$1 1852 J-145. PCGS PR66 CAC 

An intriguing concept. In an effort to make the gold dollar 

a bit easier to handle, the mint experimented with this 

annular form design. The mint made the planchet wider 

and punched a hole in the center to make the weight proper 

for the $1 denomination. With so little metal, the design 

elements are simple, UNITED STATES OF AMERICA and 

1852 around the obverse with a scalloped border around 

the hole, and DOLLAR at the top of the reverse with a 

tight wreath at the bottom. There are a number of restrikes 

known, but the present coin struck on a thick planchet is 

considered to be one of the originals. Listed as Low R-6, 

this is a very rare type, but is one of the few “common” 

patterns struck in gold. 

The present SUPERB GEM is one of the finer known 

examples. A wealth of coppery-orange gold color is seen 

on the tiny bit of actual planchet. The even smaller amount 

of open fields has a bold beaming mirrored golden finish. 

Everything about this coin is very cool and high end, a 

delight for any pattern collection! 


value is listed at $40,000 and there is just a single PR67+ 

finer, a coin which has never sold in auction. This is a real 

prize for any collector of gold patterns! 

PCGS# 11602 | ESTIMATE: $34,000+ 

218


LOT 472 

10C 1863 J-326. PCGS PR65 CAC 

This piece is an R-8 with 1-3 known. This is struck in 

copper. It is what is known as a “Postage Pattern”. These 

were struck to one day be exchanged for postage. 

We marvel at this coin every time we see it. The coin is 

nothing less than AWESOME! We do not see why PCGS 

only grade it a 65. At minimum a + would be very fitting-in 

our opinion. Seeing is believing (note the image may not 

fully represent the pop and colors of this coin). 

Outrageous mirrors beam intensely from all over. Even 

though this is a smaller coin, you can see the flash from 

yards away. There is for sure an electricity about this coin. 

The mirrors are also very clean and have remarkably clarity. 

Phenomenal totally original iridescent colors of pale lime/ 

purple/violet/tangerine/gold colors swirl all over. There 

are some tiny TONING dots scattered around-not flecks or 

problems. Every detail is fully struck and appears boldly. 

The eye appeal is incredible! 

PCGS 1, NGC 0, CAC 1. A mystery PR64 sold in 2014 for 

$17,625. All we can say if by any long shot this was the 

coin-it sure should NOT have been graded a 64. We think 

this coin should be an MS65+ (no promise made though). 

There is a Collectorís Universe Value of $17,500 for a 

64-NONE for a 65. The rarity of this coin cannot be over 

stated. We consider this a once in a life time opportunity! 

PCGS# 60484 | ESTIMATE: $20,000+ 

219


LOT 473 

25C 1869 J-729. PCGS PR66 RD CAC 

This is an R-7 (4-12 minted) Standard Pattern Type. This coin is 

struck in copper. 

We believe this coin is tired for finest graded. 

True GEM RD Patterns are VERY rare-even for Standards. This 

coin has remarkable surfaces that are clean and do exhibit strong 

reflection. There is no haze anywhere. The color is a full original 

GEM soft Mint Red. Miss Liberty and the details are needle sharp 

in strike. The eye appeal is pretty neat! 

PCGS 2, NGC 0, CAC 1. There is not a Collectors Universe Guide value for this coin. We do know similar patterns in copper sell 

for $5,000-$6,000. We know whatever is paid for this coin will be the market price! Adding a wicked cool different metal pattern to 

any collection is value and neatness added! 

PCGS# 80956 | ESTIMATE: $4,750+ 

LOT 474 

50C 1869 J-752. PCGS PR64 C 

A very rare, R-7- (7-12 minted). Liberty head right with no star on 

diadem. Standard Silver reverse. Struck in aluminum with a 

reeded edge. 

A very neat Standard Silver pattern. First the mirrors are strong and 

beaming with only a touch of iridescence visible, not at all hazy like 

many aluminum patterns ended up. The strike is bold throughout with 

just a hint of weakness on the coronet and hair curls. Struck from a 

cracked reverse die and there are some mint made planchet flaws on 

the reverse. High end for a 64 and approaching a cameo like contrast. 

PCGS 5, NGC 1, CAC 1. This is the NGC/CAC coin we sold in May 2018, where it brought $2,468. The collector who bought it has 

changed directions. It has since clearly crossed over. The current Collector’s Universe value is listed at $3,250 and this is a very rare 

opportunity to acquire this RARE pattern! Worthy of a great pattern collection! 

PCGS# 60981 | ESTIMATE: $2,400+ 

LOT 475 

50C 1869 J-753. PCGS PR62 CAC 

ULTRA RARE! This is an R-7+ (4-6 minted). Liberty head right 

with no star on diadem. Standard Silver reverse. Struck in aluminum 

with a plain edge. 

Sharply struck across the entire design types. Dove toning dusts both 

sides of this reflective example. Struck with such force that the wire 

rims are VERY high. 

PCGS 1, NGC 1, CAC 1. The current Collector’s Universe value is 

listed at $2,500. VERY RARE in any grade, the finest is the Simpson 

coin we sold for $10,281 in January 2017. 

PCGS# 60982 | ESTIMATE: $1,500+ 

220


LOT 476 

10C 1870 J-848. PCGS PR66 CAC 

A VERY RARE Standard Silver Pattern Dime! 

R-7+ (4-6 minted). Liberty head right, no star on tiara; Standard 

Silver agricultural wreath reverse. Struck in aluminum with a 

plain edge. 

Extremely RARE. This coin has no oxidation or haze (atypical 

to aluminum coins) to impact the deep, clean, clear mirrors that 

boast a powerful reflection. There actually is decent contrast, 

although a near miss CAMEO. Miss Liberty and the details are 

fully struck and have gorgeous thick frosting. The eye appeal is great! 

PCGS 2, NGC 2, CAC 4. Only two coins have ever sold in auction. A PR66 (ex Simspon-Stonewall Collections) sold for $5,875 in 

November 2012 and an NGC coin sold in July 2008 for $12,650. The current PCGS Price Guide value is listed at $5,500 and one coin, 

a PR66+ is finer. Good luck! 

PCGS# 61092 | ESTIMATE: $3,800+ 

LOT 477 

25C 1870 J-888. PCGS PR67 

CAC 

A SUPERB J-888, the FINEST 

graded by PCGS and a real prize 

for the Pattern collector! 

This is an R-5 (31-75 minted) 

Standard Silver quarter. Capped 

head of Liberty with 3 stars. 

Standard Silver agricultural 

wreath reverse. Struck in silver 

with a reeded edge. 

Ultra high end quality with deep 

beaming mirrors that gleam 

from all over. They are bold and 

watery giving the wonderful 

toning a great backlit effect when viewed in a light. Wonderful, rich, totally original toning from old paper envelope storage. You 

cannot find a single flaw with the naked eye and the quality holds up under close inspection. 

PCGS 1, NGC 1, CAC 2. This coin does not appear to have sold in auction previously and there are no recent records for the 

NGC-graded coin. If you are working on a collection of SUPERB Pattern type coins, know this, this coin is finer than the Simpson 

coin, which is the finest collection of patterns ever assembled. 

PCGS# 61132 | ESTIMATE: $6,000+ 

221


LOT 479 

25C 1870 J-916. PCGS PR67 

CAM CAC 

Ex Simpson Collection. 

R-7+ (4-6 minted). Liberty 

wears a tiara with no stars. 

Stuck in aluminum with a 

reeded edge. 

What an amazing SUPERB 

GEM! Clearly the FINEST 

extant example of this VERY 

RARE Judd number! 

Deep and watery like mirrors 

beam from all over. The mirrors 

have no oxidation. There is a 

small area of roughness in the planchet in the obverse right field (mint made). Miss Liberty and the details are sharply struck and 

have thick frost. The eye appeal is excellent! 

PCGS 1, NGC 0, CAC 1. This is the FINEST J-916 known. In fact, overall in ANY Aluminum Pattern design there are very few 

PR67’s. There is a $10,000 Collector’s Universe Value, but of course, NONE have ever sold in auction. Mr. Simpson paid $15,000 

for this coin in the 2008 mega Pattern deal. Opportunity knocks loud here! 

PCGS# 800009 | ESTIMATE: $8,000+ 

LOT 478 

25C 1870 J-911. PCGS 

PR66+ CAM CAC 

Ex Denali Collection. 

The FINEST KNOWN 

example of this very rare 

R-7+ Standard Silver Pattern. 

Struck in aluminum with a 

plain edge. There were many 

varieties of Standard Silver 

coins produced between 1869 

and 1871 in various different 

metals and with differing 

designs. This variety has a 

capped bust of Liberty facing 

right with three stars on the 

band. The reverse wreath 

is made of one branch each of laurel and oak. This simple design looks fantastic on the highly reflective and contrasted aluminum 

planchet. Indeed, the coin is blinding when viewed under a light. Most of these off metal strikings were produced as part of special 

sets made for VIP mint clients to a very limited extent. Untoned and only the slightest bit of haze, but never dipped or conserved. As 

pretty today as the moment it was carefully removed from the dies. 

PCGS 1, NGC 0, CAC 1. This is the finest example known, and sold in our Regency XI Auction as lot 347 for $7,931. In January 

2016ís Regency Auction XX, the Bob Simpson example, graded PR65 CAC sold for $7,931. Anyone building a collection of Standard 

Silver patterns should really take a good, hard look at this one and plan to bid liberally. 

PCGS# 800067 | ESTIMATE: $8,000+ 

222


LOT 480 

50C 1870 J-951. PCGS PR64 CAC 

A wonderful, entry level pattern, considered to be R-5 (31-75 

minted). Liberty head with a plain tiara. Standard Silver reverse. 

Struck in silver with a reeded edge. 

A very pleasing example of this very scarce Standard Silver 

pattern, very close to GEM quality. Highly reflective and offering 

a wonderful, original eye appeal. Some softness in the obverse 

center, as sometimes encountered. Housed in a second generation 

PCGS “Doily” holder. 

PCGS 9, NGC 4, CAC 2. Going back to 1997, every PCGS coin 

has sold in the $1,840 to $2,415 range and the current PCGS 

Price Guide is $2,250. We can see this coin selling on the high 

end of the range! Good luck! 

PCGS# 61197 | ESTIMATE: $2,200+ 

LOT 481 

50C 1870 J-952. PCGS PR65 CAC 

A very RARE Standard Silver pattern. R-7- (7-12 minted). 

Liberty head with no star on diadem. Standard Silver agricultural 

wreath reverse. Struck in silver with a plain edge. 

Multicolored iridescent pastel toning in variegated shades really 

come out with a vibrant, bold watery mirrored reflection in the 

fields. The eye appeal is SUPERB and totally original! 

PCGS 1, NGC 0, CAC 1. This is the finest in the designation 

graded by PCGS. This coin last sold for $2,820 in our May 2018 

Regency Auction; previously selling for $3,525 in February 2015 

and for $3,819 in September 2014. The Simpson coin was PCGS 

PR66 CAM CAC that sold for $6,169. This exceptionally eye 

appealing GEM of this RARE Standard Silver pattern half dollar 

will delight any pattern collector! 

PCGS# 61198 | ESTIMATE: $2,800+ 

LOT 482 

50C 1870 J-956. PCGS PR66 

CAM CAC 

This coin is a very high 

R-7 (4-7 Minted). Struck in 

aluminum with a plain edge. It 

is the FINEST known. 

There are less than half a 

dozen known of this issue and 

this coin is the finest certified! 

For a trial striking, a lot of 

effort went into making this 

exceptional quality piece. 

Overall, the planchet was 

problem free, so when it was 

struck, there are practically 

NO imperfections. Glorious 

watery mirror fields that offer extraordinary quality and preservation. This issue has a plain edge and is boldly struck on all the devices 

with snow white frost glistening over the mirror fields. No spots or lines detract! Undoubtedly this is the finest known of this rare and 

seldom seen pattern issue. 

PCGS 1, NGC 0, CAC 1. The ONLY other specimen we are aware of is the PR 64+ Cameo in the all time finest ever Pattern 

Collection-the Simpson Collection. This coin sold in December 2017 for $9,400. There are NO accurate price guides for this coin. Do 

keep in mind, if it was a regular 1870 Half in PR66 Cameo CAC it would easily cost $10,000+. Good luck! 

PCGS# 800036 | ESTIMATE: $8,000+ 

223


LOT 483 

50C 1870 J-991. PCGS PR67 

CAM CAC 

This is the FINEST 

J-991 graded at PCGS, 

and is likely the FINEST 

KNOWN example of this 

Rarity-8 Standard Sliver 

Pattern. FINER than the 

Denali-Simpson coin we sold 

last year, this coin is simply 

SUPERB in every way! 

Liberty wears a diadem with 

a single star and LIBERTY 

inscribed on her headband. 

Sharply struck in aluminum 

with a reeded edge. 

The mirrors are bold, deep, and offer a stunning chrome like flash. Every detail is crisply struck up and frosted creating an amazing 

contrast and eye appeal. The surfaces are without flaw including any oxidation that is often seen. 

PCGS 1, NGC 1, CAC 1. The only record we can find for a CAMEO is the aforementioned Simpson coin, a PR66 CAM (no CAC) 

that brought $9,106 in January 2017. As the FINEST KNOWN, this beauty will find itself in any world class collection of patterns! 

PCGS# 412231 | ESTIMATE: $11,000+ 

224


LOT 484 

$1 1870 J-1018. PCGS PR67 CAC 

This is undoubtedly, by a long margin, the FINEST J-1018 

and there are just TWO graded at PCGS of this Rarity-8 

Longacre dollar. 

Struck aluminum with a reeded edge, this beautiful pattern 

dollar has Longacre’s gorgeous Seated Indian Princess 

design paired with the regular proof reverse die. 

First, as noted, the design is gorgeous. Longacre’s creation, 

showing Lady Liberty dressed as an Indian Princess sits on 

a rock, supporting a globe inscribed LIBERTY and holding 

a pole with a liberty cap on top. What an improvement this 

design would have been if it had been adopted! 

The mirrors are sleek, and have a stunning deep flashing 

bold reflection that is just fantastic. While aluminum is a 

soft and reactive metal, there is not a single hairline, scratch, 

mark, or any type of corrosion that often plague coins struck 

in this metallic content. Every detail stands out in its full, 

higher relief definition. They are frosted, and this coin is 

truly a borderline CAMEO with impeccable surface contrast. 

There are a number of old auction appearances listed in the 

Pollock pattern reference, but the old photo plates (if they 

even have plates) make it hard to trace the provenance. For 

the entire J-1018, PCGS has graded two examples, this one 

the absolute finest, and the PR64 that is impounded in the 

Simpson Collection. 

PCGS 1, NGC 1, CAC 1. We do not doubt that this and the 

NGC coin are both the same coin. NGC has two coins in 

PR64 reported, likely the same example which is now in 

the Simpson collection. This may very well be a once in 

a generation opportunity for any advanced pattern dollar 

collector. There are no accurate guides nor is any fifteen year 

old APR relevant today for a coin graded much lower! The 

10th edition of Judd (2009) has a value of $52,500 in PR65 

and nothing is priced higher. This is a very cool coin that we 

have had a hard time putting down since it came in, and we 

think you will have the same problem when you see it! 

PCGS# 61266 | ESTIMATE: $65,000+ 

225


LOT 485 

$1 1871 J-1148. PCGS PR66 RB CAC 

Too bad this design never made it into coinage--it is 

beautiful! The obverse features James Longacreís Seated 

Indian figure of Liberty and the reverse is the standard proof 

die for the year. This coin is extremely high end. 

R-7+ 4-6 Minted. Struck in copper with a plain edge. 

Outstanding deep mirrors vividly beam from all over. 

Copper coins rarely offer powerful mirrors like this-- totally 

clean and clear. A bold mix of violet, red, and magenta hues 

are totally original and blaze from both sides. Very similar 

surfaces to bronzed copper medals produced at the mint. 

There are NO spots or discolorations. Miss Liberty and 

every detail is sharply struck and have thick frost. The eye 

appeal is awesome! 

PCGS 3, NGC 1, CAC 3. You can’t top the electricity of 

the colors and the flash of the mirrors here. A near twin 

to the one that sold in our July 2017 Regency Auction for 

$31,725 and the current Collector’s Universe value is listed 

at $34,500. This is a supreme example of a tough Longacre 

design that was a near miss to become a regular US coin 

design. This will be a stunning fit in any superb pattern 

collection. 

PCGS# 71410 | ESTIMATE: $23,000+ 

226


LOT 486 

10C 1879 J-1589. PCGS PR65+ RB CAC 

A beautiful Morgan dime pattern. The famous Morgan 

Liberty head on the obverse makes this look like a 

mini-Morgan dollar in copper. The reverse has ONE DIME 

inside a beaded circle with E PLURIBUS UNUM above 

and an olive wreath around. Struck in copper with a reeded 

edge, it is listed as Low R-7, with fewer than 12 examples 

believed to have been minted. 

This AMAZING looking pattern dime is the CoinFacts 

plate coin and for good reason! Its look is dramatic. Rich 

red mirrored fields have a bold contrast against the frosted 

devices. Violet overtones can be seen when rotated in a light, 

but coin is mostly brilliant RED. Sharply struck up, every 

detail is sharply rendered. The beauty and elegance of this 

design makes us wish that the mint adopted it. 

PCGS 2, NGC 2, CAC 3. This is the only 65+ RB graded, 

and we think that the populations reflect this coin as both a 

65 and 65+. PCGS has graded 8 in all color and CAMEO 

designations total, this one among the FINEST numerically 

graded and is a true prize for any pattern collector. The 

Collector’s Universe Price Guide does not list a value in 

65+RB, but is listed at $11,500 in 65 and $16,500 in 66 RB; 

we think this GEM will cause the price guide to be rewritten 

when the hammer falls. Good luck! 

PCGS# 71966 | ESTIMATE: $13,000+ 

227

Regency Auction 29

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

Delete template?

Save as template?