08.11.2018 Views

TN Musician Vol. 71 No. 1

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

The Official Publication of the Tennessee Music Education Association<br />

Approaching the<br />

Sight-Reading<br />

Component for<br />

Festival/Contest<br />

by Joe D. Moore<br />

p. 19<br />

When Helping Hurts:<br />

Developmentally<br />

Appropriate<br />

Teacher Mentoring<br />

by Michael A. Raiber<br />

p. 26<br />

Classroom<br />

Classical<br />

Guitar<br />

by Matthew Hinsley<br />

p.30<br />

VOLUME <strong>71</strong>, NO. 1


Tennessee Music Education Assocation | www.tnmea.org | 1


TENNESSEE MUSICIAN EDITORIAL STAFF<br />

Michael W. Chester<br />

Managing Editor and Advertising Manager<br />

Justin T. Scott<br />

Associate Editor<br />

Anna Laura Williams<br />

E-Newsletter Editor<br />

PUBLISHED BY SLATE GROUP<br />

6024 45th Street<br />

Lubbock, Texas 79407<br />

(800) 794-5594 office<br />

(806) 794-1305 fax<br />

Rico Vega<br />

Director of Creative Services<br />

Kasey McBeath<br />

Graphic Design<br />

Ian Spector<br />

Account Executive<br />

THE TENNESSEE MUSICIAN<br />

The Official Publication of the Tennessee<br />

Music Education Association<br />

The Tennessee Music Education Association (TMEA)<br />

was officially formed in 1945 as a voluntary, non-profit<br />

organization representing all phases of music education at<br />

all school levels. The mission of TMEA is to promote the<br />

advancement of high quality music education for all. Active<br />

TMEA membership is open to all persons currently teaching<br />

music and others with a special interest or involvement<br />

in music education. Collegiate membership and retired<br />

memberships are available. Membership applications are<br />

available on the TMEA web site, www.tnmea.org.<br />

The Tennessee <strong>Musician</strong> was founded in 1948 with J.<br />

Clark Rhodes appointed by the TMEA Board of Control as<br />

inaugural editor. Tennessee <strong>Musician</strong> was preceded by an<br />

earlier publication, Tennessee Music Editors’ Downbeat,<br />

which was discontinued by the TMEA Board of Control at<br />

the spring board meeting, held in Chattanooga, Tennessee<br />

in 1948. Tennessee <strong>Musician</strong> is published by Slate Group –<br />

Lubbock, Texas and is mailed to members four times each<br />

year at an annual subscription rate of $6.00 (included in<br />

dues). <strong>No</strong>n-member subscription rate (includes S&H): $30.00<br />

per school year; single copies: $10.00 per issue<br />

All editorial materials should be sent to: Michael Chester, Managing<br />

Editor (615-873-0605) E-mail: editor@tnmea.org.<br />

Submit materials by e-mail in Microsoft Word format.<br />

Advertising: Information requests and ad orders should be<br />

directed to: Michael Chester, Managing Editor (615-<br />

873-0605) e-mail: editor@tnmea.org. All advertising<br />

information is on the TMEA web site, www.tnmea.org.<br />

Deadlines for advertisement orders and editorial materials:<br />

Issue <strong>No</strong>. 1 – Deadline: September 15 (in home delivery<br />

date October 15); Issue <strong>No</strong>. 2 – Deadline: <strong>No</strong>vember 15<br />

(in home delivery date December 15); Issue <strong>No</strong>. 3 – Deadline:<br />

February 15 (in home delivery date March 15); Issue<br />

<strong>No</strong>. 4 – Deadline: April 15 (in home delivery date May 15)<br />

Postmaster: Send address changes to: Tennessee <strong>Musician</strong>,<br />

c/o National Association for Music Education<br />

(NAfME), 1806 Robert Fulton Drive, Reston, VA<br />

20191-4348.<br />

TABLE OF CONTENTS | 2018 | VOLUME <strong>71</strong>, NO. 1<br />

Prelude - A Message from the Editor 6<br />

Michael Chester<br />

TMEA President’s Message 8<br />

Lafe Cook.<br />

TMEA Members in Washington D.C. 10<br />

COLUMNS<br />

TMEA State General Music Chair’s Message 12<br />

Linzie Mullins<br />

TMEA State Choral Chair’s Message 15<br />

Reachel Hudgins<br />

TMEA State Higher Education Chair’s Message 16<br />

Barry Kraus, DMA.<br />

TMEA State Collegiate NAfME Chair’s Message 18<br />

David M. Royse, Ph.D<br />

FEATURED ARTICLES<br />

Approaching the Sight-Reading Component for Festival/Contest 21<br />

Joe D. Moore<br />

When Helping Hurts: Developmentally 28<br />

Appropriate Teacher Mentoring<br />

Michael A. Raiber<br />

Classroom Classical Guitar 32<br />

Matthew Hinsley<br />

Tennessee <strong>Musician</strong> Advertiser Index 37<br />

TMEA Back Then 38<br />

<strong>No</strong>n-Profit 501(c)(3) Organization U.S. Postage Paid<br />

at Lubbock, Texas. ISSN Number 0400-3332; EIN<br />

number 20-3325550<br />

Copyright © 2018 Tennessee Music Education<br />

Association . Reproduction in any form is illegal<br />

without the express permission of the editor.<br />

2 | TENNESSEE MUSICIAN | 2018 | <strong>Vol</strong>ume <strong>71</strong>, <strong>No</strong>. 1


AUDITION DATES<br />

Friday, February 1, 2019<br />

Saturday, February 16, 2019<br />

Saturday, February 23, 2019<br />

CAREERS IN MUSIC DAY<br />

Tuesday, <strong>No</strong>vember 6, 2018<br />

• Competitive<br />

scholarships available<br />

• Music ensembles from<br />

symphony to salsa<br />

• 200+ music<br />

events per year<br />

• 8 undergraduate<br />

music programs<br />

• 8 graduate<br />

music programs<br />

• Music living/learning<br />

community on campus<br />

• 36 full-time and<br />

40 part-time faculty<br />

• University Honors<br />

College courses<br />

SCHOOL OF MUSIC<br />

MTSU Box 47<br />

Murfreesboro, <strong>TN</strong> 3<strong>71</strong>32<br />

615-898-2469<br />

mtsumusic.com<br />

0918-6565 / Middle Tennessee State University does not discriminate on the basis of race, color, national origin, sex, or disability. See our full policy at mtsu.edu/titleix.


TMEA BOARD AND COUNCIL<br />

NATIONAL EXECUTIVE BOARD<br />

(NATIONAL ASSOCIATION<br />

FOR MUSIC EDUCATION)<br />

SOUTHERN DIVISION PRESIDENT<br />

Dian Eddleman<br />

deddleman@usjbruins.org<br />

TMEA PUBLICATIONS EDITOR AND<br />

ADVERTISING MANAGER:<br />

Michael Chester<br />

editor@tnmea.org<br />

TMEA PUBLICATIONS ASSOCIATE EDITOR:<br />

Justin Scott<br />

ETGMEA PRESIDENT-ELECT<br />

Amanda McMahan<br />

amanda.mcmahan@knoxschools.org<br />

ETVA PRESIDENT:<br />

Stephanie Coker<br />

scoker@acs.ac<br />

<strong>TN</strong> ALL-STATE SSAA CHORALE CHAIR:<br />

Kelly Davenport<br />

davenportK@wcde.org<br />

<strong>TN</strong> ALL-STATE TTBB CHORUS CHAIR:<br />

Lauren Ramey<br />

lauren.ramey@wcs.edu<br />

TMEA OFFICERS<br />

TMEA EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR:<br />

Ron Meers<br />

execdirector@tnmea.org.org<br />

TMEA PRESIDENT<br />

Lafe Cook<br />

president@tnmea.org<br />

TMEA PRESIDENT-ELECT:<br />

Alexis Yatuzis-Derryberry<br />

pres-elect@tnmea.org<br />

TMEA IMMEDIATE PAST-PRESIDENT:<br />

Johnathan Vest, Ed. D.<br />

past-president@tnmea.org<br />

justin.scott@tcsedu.net<br />

TMEA COUNCIL<br />

WTGMEA PRESIDENT:<br />

Frances Miller<br />

wtgmeamemphis@yahoo.com<br />

WTGMEA PRESIDENT-ELECT:<br />

Ray Mullins<br />

wtgmeamemphis@yahoo.com<br />

WTVMEA PRESIDENT:<br />

Emily Taylor<br />

etaylor@colliervilleschools.org<br />

WTVMEA PRESIDENT-ELECT:<br />

Sharon Morris<br />

ETVA PRESIDENT-ELECT:<br />

Deborah Gouge<br />

debgouge@charter.net<br />

ETSBOA PRESIDENT:<br />

Alan Hunt<br />

ahunt@bradleyschools.org<br />

ETSBOA PRESIDENT-ELECT:<br />

Donald Benton<br />

dbenton@bradleyschools.org<br />

CONFERENCE MANAGEMENT TEAM<br />

TMEA CONFERENCE CO-CHAIR:<br />

Brad Turner<br />

brad.turner@acsk-12.org<br />

<strong>TN</strong> ALL-STATE 9TH - 10TH GRADE STRING ORCHES-<br />

TRA CHAIR:<br />

Nichole Pitts<br />

pitts_stephanie@hcde.org<br />

<strong>TN</strong> ALL-STATE 11TH - 12TH GRADE SYMPHONIC OR-<br />

CHESTRA CHAIR:<br />

Gary Wilkes<br />

gwilkes428@gmail.com<br />

<strong>TN</strong> ALL-STATE 9TH - 10TH GRADE CONCERT BAND<br />

CHAIR:<br />

Carter <strong>No</strong>blin<br />

noblinc@wcschools.com<br />

<strong>TN</strong> ALL-STATE 11TH - 12TH GRADE CONCERT BAND<br />

CHAIR:<br />

BOARD OF DIRECTORS<br />

TMEA STATE GENERAL MUSIC CHAIR:<br />

Linzie Mullins<br />

linziemullins9@gmail.com<br />

TMEA STATE CHORAL CHAIR:<br />

Reachel Hudgins<br />

choralchair@tnmea.org<br />

TMEA STATE ORCHESTRA CHAIR:<br />

Anna Maria Miller<br />

orchestrachair@tnmea.org<br />

TMEA STATE BAND CHAIR:<br />

Megan Christian<br />

megan.christian@knoxschools.org<br />

TMEA STATE HIGHER EDUCATION CHAIR:<br />

Barry Kraus, DMA<br />

higheredchair@tnmea.org<br />

TMEA STATE COLLEGIATE NAFME CHAIR:<br />

David Royse, Ph. D.<br />

droyse@utk.edu<br />

TMEA SOCIETY FOR MUSIC TEACHER EDUCATION/<br />

RESEARCH CHAIR:<br />

Jamilia McWhirter, Ph. D.<br />

jamila.mcwhirter@mtsu.edu<br />

TMEA STATE EDUCATIONAL TECHNOLOGY CHAIR:<br />

John Womack<br />

webmaster@tnmea.org<br />

TMEA ADVOCACY AND GOVERNMENT RELATIONS CHAIR:<br />

Christopher Dye, Ed. D.<br />

christopher.dye@mtsu.edu<br />

smorris@lced.net<br />

WTSBOA PRESIDENT:<br />

Ollie Liddell<br />

ollie_liddell@hotmail.com<br />

WTSBOA PRESIDENT-ELECT:<br />

Jennifer Cupples<br />

jennifer.cupples@chestercountyschools.org<br />

MTGMEA PRESIDENT:<br />

Rachel Lapinski<br />

lapinskir@rcschools.net<br />

MTGMEA PRESIDENT-ELECT:<br />

Corynn York<br />

corynn.york@cityschools.net<br />

MTVA PRESIDENT:<br />

Lia Holland<br />

liaholland@mtcscougars.org<br />

MTVA PRESIDENT-ELECT:<br />

Gerald Patton<br />

pattong@rcschools.net<br />

MTSBOA PRESIDENT:<br />

Debbie Burton<br />

president@mtsboa.org<br />

MTSBOA PRESIDENT-ELECT:<br />

Justin Scott<br />

justin.scott@tcsedu.net<br />

ETGMEA PRESIDENT:<br />

Marcus Smith<br />

marcus.smith@knoxschools.org<br />

TMEA CO-CONFERENCE CHAIR:<br />

Paul Waters<br />

paulwaters.tmea@gmail.com<br />

TMEA CONFERENCE EXHIBITS CHAIR:<br />

Jo Ann Hood<br />

jhood10105@aol.com<br />

TMEA CONFERENCE REGISTRATION CHAIR:<br />

Mark Garey<br />

mgarey86@comcast.net<br />

TMEA CONFERENCE PERFORMANCE GROUP CHAIR:<br />

John Mears<br />

mearsj@rcschools.net<br />

ALL-STATE MANAGEMENT TEAM<br />

<strong>TN</strong> ALL-STATE CHORAL GENERAL CHAIR:<br />

Amanda Ragan<br />

aragan@ortn.edu<br />

<strong>TN</strong> ALL-STATE INSTRUMENTAL GENERAL CHAIR:<br />

Todd Shipley<br />

todd.shipley@mnps.org<br />

ENSEMBLE CHAIRS<br />

TREBLE HONOR CHOIR CHAIR:<br />

Tiffany Barton<br />

tntreblechoir@gmail.com<br />

<strong>TN</strong> ALL-STATE SATB CHOIR CHAIR:<br />

Amanda Short<br />

amandalovellshort@gmail.com<br />

J.R. Baker<br />

john.baker@rcstn.net<br />

<strong>TN</strong> ALL-STATE JAZZ BAND CHAIR:<br />

Cord Martin<br />

corderyl.martin@gmail.com<br />

PROJECT CHAIRS<br />

TMEA JAZZ EDUCATION POLICY CHAIR:<br />

Richard Ripani, Ph. D.<br />

richard.ripani@mnps.org<br />

TMEA MUSIC MERCHANTS INDUSTRY CHAIR:<br />

Rick DeJonge<br />

rick.dejonge@khsmusic.com<br />

TMEA WEBMASTER:<br />

John Womack<br />

webmaster@tnmea.org<br />

TMEA TRI-M CHAIR:<br />

Anna Laura Williams<br />

anna.laura.williams@outlook.com<br />

TMEA MUSIC IN OUR SCHOOLS MONTH CHAIR:<br />

Tiffany Barton<br />

tntreblechoir@gmail.com<br />

TMEA RETIRED TEACHERS CHAIR:<br />

Bobby Jean Frost<br />

bjfrost@aol.com<br />

4 | TENNESSEE MUSICIAN | 2018 | <strong>Vol</strong>ume <strong>71</strong>, <strong>No</strong>. 1


NEW<br />

Total<br />

Percussion<br />

Series<br />

Sound. Quality. Design.<br />

At Yamaha, we believe that the first<br />

instrument in one's musical journey must<br />

provide excellent quality and tuning<br />

consistency. With that in mind, the new<br />

YX-230 xylophone is designed for the<br />

beginning percussion student. Featuring<br />

professionally tuned Padauk wood bars,<br />

this instrument produces a beautiful<br />

Yamaha sound that has been familiar to<br />

music educators for over 30 years.<br />

Weighting only 22 lbs. and just over 45"<br />

in length, this xylophone offers a 3 octave<br />

range (C52-C88) with 1- 1 /2" wide bars.<br />

A pair of ME-103 mallets are included<br />

along with a cover to protect the<br />

instrument from dust and scratches.<br />

An optional stand (YGS-70) and soft case<br />

(PCS-YX230) are sold separately.<br />

YX-230 Xylophone<br />

Visit 4wrd.it/TotalPerc for complete details


PRELUDE - A MESSAGE FROM THE EDITOR<br />

Michael Chester // Stewarts Creek High School<br />

For the last seventy-one years, the Tennessee<br />

<strong>Musician</strong> has served as a chronicle of the<br />

evolution of music education in Tennessee.<br />

Seventy-one marks the current volume of the Tennessee<br />

<strong>Musician</strong>. It might seem hard to imagine but for seventyone<br />

years the Tennessee <strong>Musician</strong> has been a constant of<br />

TMEA members since 1948. While most might see this as<br />

just another magazine that gets delivered, put aside, glanced<br />

at and then quickly discarded, the importance of this quarterly<br />

publication should not be underestimated. For the last seventyone<br />

years, the Tennessee <strong>Musician</strong> has served as a chronicle of<br />

the evolution of music education in Tennessee. What started as a<br />

means of keeping members of TMEA apprised of events and news<br />

affecting music educators has become a record of our progress<br />

and of our failings as music educators. The Tennessee <strong>Musician</strong><br />

has published the messages of thirty-six presidents and will<br />

now add to its annals the messages of our thirty-seventh TMEA<br />

President, Lafe Cook.<br />

One of the more enjoyable aspects of the editorship of this<br />

publication is combing through previous volumes and issues.<br />

Having always enjoyed history, I thought it important that as<br />

we move forward as an association, that we not forget where we<br />

came from and how we got here. Thus, the column “TMEA Back<br />

Then” was born. I’ve heard from several members of TMEA that<br />

find it enjoyable to read and for some it is their favorite part of the<br />

publication. We are now in an age where the mantle of leadership<br />

is beginning to change generations. Having been asked to serve by<br />

the TMEA Board as the sixteenth editor, I realized that it was not<br />

something to be taken lightly. While most others might assume that<br />

a publication like the Tennessee <strong>Musician</strong> is outdated, obsolete,<br />

and should be formatted as all-digital only, or in some cases,<br />

eliminated altogether, I vehemently disagree. In fact, one of our<br />

goals was to find a way to bridge the communication gap between<br />

publication cycles and information that needed to go out to the<br />

membership in a timelier manner and yet expand the offerings of<br />

the Tennessee <strong>Musician</strong> with more articles that involve academic<br />

research and pedagogic insights. Our TMEA E-Newsletter,<br />

now under the direction of Anna Laura Williams, gives our<br />

membership the need to know information about happenings<br />

across the state each month. In addition, columns such as “By<br />

the Numbers/Verbatim” which were introduced by contributing<br />

editor Matthew Clark, brought us interesting data-at-a-glance<br />

on topics regarding music education and also some inspiring<br />

quotes to share with parents, students, and administrators. As we<br />

continue to advance the cause of music education in Tennessee, it<br />

is so important that we all become informed and knowledgeable.<br />

The TMEA leadership is making some very valuable and key<br />

connections with our own state legislators. In a time like this,<br />

it is important for us to decide if we as members of TMEA will<br />

join together to determine the best outcomes for our students<br />

and for us as a music education profession. This goes beyond<br />

mere grassroots activism or social media campaigning. It’s about<br />

smart, well-informed, and objective rhetoric that allows us to get<br />

the message across to all stakeholders. <strong>No</strong>w, more than ever, is<br />

when we need advocacy on a state-wide level.<br />

While it is true that our attempts at state-wide advocacy are<br />

still in their early stages, we as an informed membership need<br />

to realize that the job of advocacy is not up to somebody else. We<br />

need to change the mentality of music education advocacy as<br />

being somebody else’s job. It takes all of us to cultivate and nurture<br />

strong relationships with members of our administration and<br />

our local school boards. It takes all of us to inform our local civic<br />

electorate how what we do in our classroom contributes to making<br />

better citizens. We must not be afraid to create relationships with<br />

our elected officials. We all know the most powerful tool we have<br />

is the right to vote.<br />

It for those very reasons that I want to continue to provide<br />

informative articles and columns designed to engage and<br />

empower TMEA members so that all of us, when the time comes,<br />

can join the cause of statewide advocacy.<br />

Seventy-one years is a longtime for most periodicals. While<br />

we continue to honor the traditions of this noble publication’s<br />

past, we will also look for ways in which to serve the needs of its<br />

members, in a professional, courteous, and informative approach<br />

as we continue to raise the bar moving forward.<br />

For those and for several other reasons, I stand committed<br />

to continuing to make the Tennessee <strong>Musician</strong> the very best<br />

quarterly publication for Tennessee’s music educators.<br />

Michael Chester<br />

Publications Editor<br />

Tennessee Music Education Association<br />

6 | TENNESSEE MUSICIAN | 2018 | <strong>Vol</strong>ume <strong>71</strong>, <strong>No</strong>. 1


Training the modern musician.<br />

Our flexible programs let you<br />

study what you love, traditional<br />

or folk, with curriculum designed<br />

to teach you what you need.<br />

Synthesize your music degree<br />

with courses in<br />

• Music Entrepreneurship<br />

• Performance Production<br />

• Arts and Society<br />

• and more<br />

DEGREE OPTIONS INCLUDE<br />

Bachelor of Arts: Music<br />

With minors including:<br />

• nonprofit management<br />

• psychology<br />

• business<br />

Bachelor of Music: Performance<br />

Bachelor of Music: Education<br />

AUDITIONS FOR 2019<br />

February 23<br />

March 23<br />

Visit utc.edu/music for details.<br />

UTC is a comprehensive, community-engaged campus of the UT System. UTC is an EEO/AA/Titles VI & IX/Section 504/ADA/ADEA institution.


TMEA PRESIDENT’S MESSAGE<br />

Lafe Cook || Dobyns-Bennett High School<br />

The Future of Music Education Advocacy . . .<br />

According to my marching band<br />

parent crew, there are no marching<br />

band props in heaven. They<br />

even made matching hats with<br />

this very slogan! If you teach high<br />

school marching band, it sometimes feels<br />

like props are a must; it’s written in a book<br />

somewhere that it’s basically required.<br />

Worrying about props is certainly a distraction<br />

from our real job, teaching music.<br />

For those of you who teach competitive<br />

marching band, you probably understand<br />

these feelings. For those of you who don’t<br />

teach competitive marching band, congrats<br />

on adding a couple of years back to<br />

your life!<br />

But those band parents who commit to<br />

helping build and move marching band<br />

props can tell you a lot about the impact<br />

your music program has on your school<br />

community and the impact you are have<br />

on the kids in your classroom.<br />

YOU ARE MORE THAN A MUSIC<br />

TEACHER, YOU ARE A LEADER<br />

AND ROLE MODEL FOR YOUR<br />

KIDS AND THEIR FAMILIES.<br />

It is humbling to represent these kind<br />

of teachers, Tennessee’s music educators.<br />

It is also a privilege to work with other<br />

leaders in music education from across<br />

Tennessee. The officers of our state’s regional<br />

music education associations are<br />

amazing! In addition to carving out time<br />

for family and friends, summer professional<br />

development experiences and summer<br />

rehearsals, your leaders in the music education<br />

profession from across Tennessee<br />

have also come together multiple times to<br />

discuss the future of music education in<br />

Tennessee.<br />

It is inspirational to witness the amount<br />

of time music teachers will give in their<br />

precious “off-time” to discuss ideas and<br />

initiatives that positively impact their students.<br />

These summer conversations centered<br />

around the question what more can<br />

TMEA do for its members and how do we<br />

make membership more attractive to those<br />

teachers that currently are not joining.<br />

AS WITH ANY ORGANIZATION,<br />

IT IS TMEA’S RESPONSIBILITY<br />

TO PROVIDE VALUE TO ITS<br />

MEMBERSHIP.<br />

I believe anyone who has had students<br />

make an All-State ensemble or selected<br />

for the Tennessee Treble Honor Choir understands<br />

what those TMEA experiences<br />

mean for students. Hopefully those music<br />

teachers who have attended the TMEA<br />

Professional Development Conference<br />

also have a positive view of what TMEA<br />

strives to provide teachers, with regards to<br />

continued training and educational inspiration.<br />

However, we as TMEA leaders and members<br />

need to do a better job of communicating<br />

the value and importance of membership<br />

to those music teachers in Tennessee<br />

that are not joining our organization, either<br />

because it is cost prohibitive for them to do<br />

so or because they are not aware of the value<br />

in membership. The state of Tennessee<br />

has roughly 2000 music teachers. TMEA<br />

membership is about 1100. That means<br />

about half of Tennessee’s music educators<br />

are joining our professional association, a<br />

statistic that I was initially pleased with,<br />

until you consider who those 1100 music<br />

teachers are. The 1100 music teachers with<br />

TMEA memberships are almost without<br />

exception, secondary instrumental and<br />

vocal program directors for whom TMEA<br />

membership is mandatory if their students<br />

are going to be eligible for region or state<br />

honors ensembles.<br />

We must find a way to make TMEA<br />

membership more appealing to ALL of our<br />

state’s music teachers!<br />

In recent years it has become much<br />

easier to answer the question “what does<br />

TMEA membership do for me?” Perhaps<br />

the most tangible new benefit of membership<br />

is that TMEA, in cooperation with<br />

regional associations, pays for a lobbyist in<br />

Nashville to monitor education legislation<br />

that might impact music education class<br />

time. We are entering our third year with<br />

this lobbyist and this legislative monitoring<br />

has already had a positive impact. We<br />

became proactive by communicating with<br />

legislators regarding a potential change<br />

in the proposed 2017 Tennessee’s history<br />

course requirement. This change would<br />

have had huge repercussions on music<br />

classroom time.<br />

The retaining of a lobbyist is an advo-<br />

8 | TENNESSEE MUSICIAN | 2018 | <strong>Vol</strong>ume <strong>71</strong>, <strong>No</strong>. 1


Belmont’s School of Music is a place where you can fully develop your talent and see how far it can take you.<br />

To join our creative community and explore your artistry, visit BELMONT.EDU/CREATIVECOMMUNITY.<br />

AUDITION DATES FOR ADMISSION FALL 2019<br />

UNDERGRADUATE: 10.27.18 • 11.3.18 • 1.12.19 • 1.26.19 • 2.8.19<br />

GRADUATE: 10.27.18 • 11.3.18 • 1.18.19 • 2.18.19 • 2.22.19<br />

cacy effort that represents real value to<br />

music teachers. When combined with the<br />

opportunity for professional development<br />

at our conference and student access to<br />

TMEA sponsored events membership is<br />

clearly worth every penny of TMEA’s low<br />

$35.00 dues!<br />

But the reality is that a Tennessee music<br />

teacher cannot join TMEA without also<br />

joining the National Association for Music<br />

Education. We often hear from Tennessee<br />

music teachers who teach in urban or rural<br />

areas of our state that the total combined<br />

dues of TMEA and NAfME (a minimum<br />

amount $148 depending on your regional<br />

association dues) is a stretch for them or<br />

their school districts. TMEA leadership<br />

completely understands this and is working<br />

to find ways to reduce these amounts.<br />

At a meeting last month in Nashville of<br />

state leaders of the National Association<br />

for Music Education’s Southern Division<br />

there was much discussion with NAfME<br />

staff and National Executive Board members<br />

about ways in which state affiliate<br />

music education associations might be<br />

able to reduce the dues amount we are<br />

required to send to NAfME. Your TMEA<br />

leaders were not the only voices speaking<br />

up about the challenges the current dues<br />

structure creates.<br />

There is no denying that NAfME is an<br />

important voice for music education at<br />

the federal level. But it is also true that<br />

the ESSA Legislation shifts power from<br />

the federal level to the state level. TMEA’s<br />

current financial realities do not allow us<br />

to advocate for our school music programs<br />

at the level that would be possible if we had<br />

more dues revenue to keep in state.<br />

THE FUTURE OF MUSIC<br />

EDUCATION ADVOCACY<br />

IN TENNESSEE IS AT THE<br />

GRASSROOTS LEVEL!<br />

I encourage you and your music teacher<br />

colleagues in your school district or region<br />

to have conversations about what more<br />

TMEA could do for you and your students.<br />

Let your regional association officers or any<br />

member of the TMEA board know about<br />

your ideas. I also encourage you to find<br />

those teachers in your area who are not<br />

TMEA members and tell them about the<br />

value of membership.<br />

As we continue to look ahead at providing<br />

the very best membership experience in<br />

TMEA, take some time to reflect upon the<br />

wonderful work that is taking place in your<br />

classroom or rehearsal hall right now. It’s<br />

the work that you are doing on behalf of<br />

your students. Try to never lose sight of the<br />

passion and joy of teaching music. The <strong>No</strong>vember<br />

and December holidays are right<br />

around the corner, and undoubtedly with<br />

that comes the many hours of preparation<br />

for programs and performances. We all<br />

know how this time of the year can drain<br />

both our energy and resolve. Though at<br />

times it may not always seem as such, just<br />

know that the positive impact of teaching<br />

music can change a child’s life.<br />

-Lafe Cook<br />

President<br />

Tennessee Music Education Association<br />

Tennessee Music Education Assocation | www.tnmea.org | 9


TMEA MEMBERS IN WASHINGTON D.C.<br />

ON JUNE 28TH, of this year members of the Tennessee Music<br />

Education Association’s Board of Directors convened with the<br />

leadership delegations of other federated state music education<br />

associations in Washington D.C. for the National Association<br />

for Music Education’s (NAfME) National Leadership Assembly.<br />

In addition to several meetings that were focused on issues<br />

surrounding the current climate of music education in America’s<br />

schools, the Tennessee delegation participated in NAfME’s annual<br />

Hill Day. Meetings with the Tennessee’s United States House of<br />

Representatives and Senate staff focused on specific initiatives<br />

for music education, including the Guarantee Access to Arts and<br />

Music Education (GAAME) Act (H.R. 6137) which encouraged<br />

school districts to use their Title I-A funds (school-wide and<br />

targeted assistance grants) to help provide music education for<br />

disadvantaged students. Additional topics of discussion centered<br />

on requests of introducing a companion bill of the GAAME Act into<br />

the U.S. Senate and fully funding the Every Student Succeeds Act’s<br />

(ESSA) authorized levels for well-rounded education programs,<br />

including:<br />

» Title IV-A, $1.6 billion<br />

» Title I-A, $15.46 billion<br />

» Title II-A, $2.3 billion<br />

The TMEA delegation were joined by five collegiate members who<br />

were identified as emerging leaders and who were selected by their<br />

respective colleges and universities to attend this event.<br />

TMEA President-Elect Alexis Yatuzis-Derryberry and TMEA Editor<br />

Michael Chester at the NAfME National Leadership Assembly.<br />

TMEA President Lafe Cook meets with staff members<br />

from Diane Black’s (<strong>TN</strong>-6th) office.<br />

TMEA Leadership Delegation meets at<br />

Capitol Hill in Washington D.C.<br />

L to R, Ebonee Woodland, Mackenzie<br />

Kelly, TMEA Immediate Past-President<br />

Jonathan Vest, Andrew Layne, TMEA<br />

President Lafe Cook, Reginald Coleman,<br />

TMEA Advocacy and Government<br />

Relations Chair Dr. Christopher Dye,<br />

TMEA President-Elect Alexis Yatuzis-<br />

Derryberry, TMEA Executive Director<br />

Ron Meers, and Lauren Mills.<br />

TMEA delagates meet with Congressman<br />

David Kustoff (<strong>TN</strong>-8th)<br />

10 | TENNESSEE MUSICIAN | 2018 | <strong>Vol</strong>ume <strong>71</strong>, <strong>No</strong>. 1


ETSU MUSIC DAYS:<br />

Open House<br />

and Auditions for<br />

Fall 2019 Enrollment<br />

Friday, <strong>No</strong>vember 16, 2018<br />

Tuesday, February 19, 2019<br />

Friday, March 22, 2019<br />

Saturday, March 23 2019<br />

(Vocal only)<br />

@GoETSUMusic<br />

www.Facebook.com/ETSUMusic<br />

www.etsu.edu/music<br />

Join the<br />

ETSU<br />

Music<br />

Family<br />

Department of Music<br />

etsu.edu/music<br />

The ETSU Department of Music<br />

is fully accredited by the National<br />

Association of Schools of Music.<br />

Tennessee Music Education Assocation | www.tnmea.org | 11


TMEA STATE GENERAL MUSIC CHAIR’S MESSAGE<br />

Linzie Mullins // Snowden School<br />

PLEASE TRY TO COME TO THE<br />

CONFERENCE THIS YEAR! WE<br />

HAVE AMAZING CLINICIANS AND<br />

AMAZING SESSION TOPICS...<br />

WOW, ANOTHER SCHOOL YEAR IS OFF AND RUNNING,<br />

which means another conference is being planned.<br />

Please try to come to the conference this year! We have<br />

amazing clinicians and amazing session topics, and I<br />

cannot wait to fill up the rooms full of Tennessee’s best<br />

music teachers. Our clinicians include: Artie Almeida,<br />

Cheryl Lavender, Richard Lawton, and our <strong>TN</strong> Treble Choir clinician<br />

is Maribeth Yoder-White. And, that’s not all! Our full list of clinicians<br />

and sessions will be out soon, so keep an eye out.<br />

I always try to share little insights in my columns, so here it is! In the<br />

back of Artie Almeida’s Mallet Madness book, she shares ideas, and one<br />

in particular has changed my classroom exponentially. My co-teacher<br />

brought it up to me, and I am so glad she did. Every year I love walking<br />

into my classroom with my xylophones in pitch order, metals on one<br />

side, woods on the other, and the drums against another wall. Organization<br />

is key, right? Well, wrong! This year we have our instruments set up<br />

in four rows with our drums, xylophones, and metallophones all mixed<br />

up. Basses not even close to each other, drums in between two xylophones,<br />

etc. This way, when my students get to the instrumentarium,<br />

they get a new instrument just about every time. And, we rotate one<br />

instrument to the left or right, depending on which row they are in (we<br />

have tape arrows on the floor for direction), they get to play all sizes and<br />

pitches in just one class period. Why are your instruments set up a particular<br />

way? Are all of your students getting the same opportunities? I<br />

know personally that I did not have a way to keep up with which children<br />

played which instrument, and my students did not play drums<br />

near as often as they do now. We teach up to 60 children at one time,<br />

and they are all extremely engaged and having a good time, ready to rotate<br />

to the next instrument. <strong>No</strong> more students upset about which instrument<br />

they were assigned, and no more excuses for not having<br />

enough instruments for every student. This has been a life saver, and<br />

classroom management hasn’t been easier. Try it out and let me know<br />

how it goes! See you at the conference!<br />

An educational festival for<br />

elementary, middle, and<br />

high school students in band,<br />

choir, and orchestra<br />

2019:<br />

April 12<br />

April 26<br />

May 3<br />

2020:<br />

April 3<br />

April 7<br />

April 24<br />

www.SMMFestival.com<br />

or call:1-855-766-3008<br />

12 | TENNESSEE MUSICIAN | 2018 | <strong>Vol</strong>ume <strong>71</strong>, <strong>No</strong>. 1


Some are born with<br />

in their souls<br />

If authenticity had a<br />

soul,<br />

you would find it<br />

in Memphis.<br />

Creativity<br />

flows through our veins.<br />

This is the kind of city and<br />

university where original<br />

people are elevating the art<br />

of music in unforgettable<br />

ways. If you were born<br />

with music in your blood,<br />

you belong at the UofM.<br />

DEGREES OFFERED<br />

B.M., M.M., D.M.A., Ph.D.<br />

AUDITION DATES<br />

Dec. 1, 2018<br />

Feb. 2, 2019<br />

Feb. 16, 2019<br />

Feb. 23, 2019<br />

memphis.edu/music<br />

901.678.3766


LEARN, PERFORM, PERFECT<br />

“The Maryville College music<br />

program has proven to be a<br />

superb foundation and<br />

place of growth for<br />

students who wish to<br />

become better musicians.”<br />

ROBBY CLEMENS ’20<br />

Maryville, Tenn.<br />

Recipient of the<br />

Presidential Scholarship<br />

and Choral Award<br />

Located in the new $47-million Clayton Center for the Arts, the<br />

Maryville College Music Department offers a comprehensive,<br />

NASM-accredited music curriculum within the college’s<br />

acclaimed liberal arts experience. Because of its size,<br />

Maryville College provides students with nearly endless<br />

opportunities to perform — in choirs, ensembles,<br />

bands, orchestras, musicals and opera scenes.<br />

Degree opportunities:<br />

B.A. in Music<br />

| B.M. in Music Education<br />

B.M. in Vocal Performance<br />

B.M. in Music Theory/Composition<br />

Music scholarships are available,<br />

and worth up to full tuition.<br />

Contact<br />

Jordan McCullough<br />

at 865.981.8092<br />

for details.<br />

MARYVILLECOLLEGE.EDU<br />

502 E. LAMAR ALEXANDER PKWY., MARYVILLE TENNESSEE 37804


TMEA STATE CHORAL CHAIR’S MESSAGE<br />

Reachel Hudgins || Dyer County High School<br />

I KNOW THAT<br />

WITH THESE<br />

CHANGES, OUR<br />

STUDENTS WILL<br />

BE THOROUGHLY<br />

PREPARED<br />

FOR ALL STATE<br />

PERFORMANCES<br />

WITH<br />

SIGNIFICANTLY<br />

LESS STRESS.<br />

Hudgins and I am your new State<br />

Choral Chair under the leadership<br />

of TMEA President Lafe Cook. It<br />

is my privilege and honor to serve<br />

HELLO EVERYONE, I am Reachel<br />

the students and teachers of Tennessee<br />

in this capacity. I grew up in Dyer<br />

County in West Tennessee and I am proud<br />

to teach choir at my alma mater, Dyer County<br />

High School, as well as <strong>No</strong>rthview Middle<br />

School, both in Newbern, Tennessee.<br />

I hope that everyone had a restful summer<br />

and that you have all had a great start<br />

to your school year. I know that it is going to<br />

be a very busy year and like me, you are all in<br />

preparation for auditions for your regional<br />

honor choirs. It is my sincere hope that your<br />

auditions run smoothly and your regional<br />

performances are a success.<br />

At our vocal caucus in April, we discussed<br />

a couple of important topics. Firstly,<br />

we discussed extending the deadline for 2nd<br />

Tier Testing for our all-state vocal students.<br />

The deadline for testing has been extended<br />

to March 1st so that students will have<br />

more time to learn the advanced repertoire.<br />

Also, our fantastic All-State General Choral<br />

Chair, Amanda Ragan, has been hard at work<br />

making sure that repertoire and part tracks<br />

are available to you sooner. I know that with<br />

these changes, our students will be thoroughly<br />

prepared for all-state performances<br />

with significantly less stress.<br />

Freshman eligibility for all state was another<br />

important subject discussed during<br />

our April caucus. Unfortunately, we were<br />

not able to come to a consensus and did not<br />

take an official vote. Next April, during the<br />

vocal caucus, we will have a final vote. In<br />

the meantime, the board is working to get<br />

input from as many directors as possible<br />

on this issue. Please be on the lookout for a<br />

new survey dealing with freshman eligibility<br />

and what that might look like at the all<br />

state level. I encourage you to respond and<br />

to do so thoughtfully. If you have any comments<br />

or suggestions, please be kind in your<br />

responses.<br />

Lastly, I’d like to discuss the new National<br />

Core Arts Standards. Recently, the<br />

new National Standards were linked with<br />

our Tennessee State Standards for all Fine<br />

Arts areas. You can access the original core<br />

standards at www.nationalartsstandards.<br />

org. On the Tennessee Department of Education<br />

website, the four core standards are<br />

discussed and linked by grade level. I would<br />

encourage each of you to go to https://<br />

www.tn.gov/education/instruction/academic-standards/arts-education.html<br />

and<br />

download the new standards. There are also<br />

links to resources for all fine arts areas.<br />

In closing, I am excited to serve as your<br />

State Choral Chair and I am looking forward<br />

to meeting as many of you as possible over<br />

the next couple of years. If you have any<br />

questions for me or if you have anything<br />

you’d like me to share with our colleagues<br />

across the state, please don’t hesitate to contact<br />

me at choralchair@tnmea.org. I hope<br />

you all have a wonderful school year and I<br />

can’t wait to hear from you!<br />

Tennessee Music Education Assocation | www.tnmea.org | 15


TMEA STATE HIGHER EDUCATION CHAIR’S MESSAGE<br />

Barry Kraus, DMA || Belmont University<br />

Directors should select one student from each section<br />

in the ensemble rather than multiple students from<br />

each section. The band will consist of approximately<br />

100 students who will receive a participant badge and<br />

free admission to the convention.<br />

2019<br />

Intercollegiate<br />

Band<br />

Information<br />

The fourth TMEA All-Collegiate Band<br />

will take place at the 2019 Conference<br />

in Nashville. Collegiate wind, brass,<br />

and percussion students (music and<br />

non-music majors) are eligible to participate.<br />

The director, who must be a member of<br />

NAFME, may nominate up to 10 students for<br />

the band. Students should be the strongest<br />

musicians in the program, and nominations<br />

should reflect a complete instrumentation.<br />

Ideally, directors should select one student<br />

from each section in the ensemble rather<br />

than multiple students from each section.<br />

The band will consist of approximately<br />

100 students who will receive a participant<br />

badge and free admission to the convention.<br />

Directors will receive notification of acceptances<br />

(based upon instrumentation and<br />

experience), and the cost per student will be<br />

$50. Participation fees may be paid by check<br />

individually by the students or collectively<br />

by the school. If students are paying individually,<br />

all checks for the school should be<br />

sent at the same time to the organizer (Barry<br />

Kraus). Please note that not all students may<br />

be accepted; however, additional students<br />

may be requested from schools depending<br />

upon instrumentation needs. Directors<br />

or applied teachers from participating<br />

schools should plan to serve as judges for the<br />

part-placement auditions prior to the first<br />

rehearsal. Students must provide their own<br />

transportation and lodging. TMEA cannot<br />

cover the cost of housing and travel; however,<br />

housing options in Nashville will be provided<br />

upon notification of acceptance.<br />

DEADLINES:<br />

• December 15 – deadline for online<br />

nominations<br />

• January 11 – acceptance notifications<br />

sent to directors<br />

• February 1 – payment deadline ($50<br />

per student)<br />

For more information about the all-collegiate<br />

band, please visit the <strong>TN</strong>MEA web page<br />

and find the Higher Education page under<br />

the ‘Blog’ menu.<br />

CYNTHIA JOHNSTON TURNER is in demand as a<br />

conductor, conducting and ensemble clinician,<br />

and speaker in the United States, Australia,<br />

Latin America, Europe, and Canada.<br />

Before her appointment at the Hodgson<br />

School at the University of Georgia, Cynthia<br />

was Director of Wind Ensembles at Cornell<br />

University. Earlier in her career Cynthia<br />

2019 TMEA Intercollegiate Band Conductor,<br />

Cynthia Johnston Turner.<br />

was a high school music educator, taught<br />

middle school beginning instrumental music<br />

in Toronto and choral music in Switzerland.<br />

She currently serves as a conductor<br />

with the Syracuse Society of New Music, the<br />

Austrian Festival Orchestra, and the Paris<br />

Lodron Ensemble in Salzburg.<br />

Among other recent engagements, Cynthia<br />

has guest conducted the National Youth<br />

Wind Ensemble of Great Britain, the Syracuse<br />

Symphony (“Symphoria”), the National<br />

Youth Band of Canada, Concordia Santa<br />

Fe, the Ithaca College Wind Ensemble, the<br />

Eastman Wind Ensemble, the Latin American<br />

Honor Band, the National Band of Costa<br />

Rica, the National Orchestra of Heredia,<br />

and numerous state honor bands. Cynthia<br />

has been invited to present her research<br />

with teaching and technology, innovative<br />

rehearsal techniques, and service-learning<br />

and music performance at numerous conferences<br />

nationally and internationally. She is<br />

published in such journals as Music Educators<br />

Journal, Interdisciplinary Humanities,<br />

International Journal of the Humanities,<br />

Journal of the World Association of Bands<br />

and Ensembles, Fanfare Magazine, and Canadian<br />

Winds, and has recorded CDs with<br />

the Innova and Albany labels.<br />

Cynthia serves as a board member with<br />

WASBE, and is an active member of CDBNA,<br />

Conductor’s Guild, College Music Society,<br />

Humanities Education and Research Association,<br />

the National Association for Music<br />

Education, and National Band Association.<br />

As Director of Bands and Professor of Music<br />

at the Hodgson School, Cynthia conducts<br />

the Wind Ensemble, teaches conducting,<br />

leads the MM and DMA programs in conducting,<br />

and oversees the entire Hodgson<br />

band program.<br />

16 | TENNESSEE MUSICIAN | 2018 | <strong>Vol</strong>ume <strong>71</strong>, <strong>No</strong>. 1


TMEA STATE COLLEGIATE NAfME CHAIR’S MESSAGE<br />

David M. Royse, Ph. D. || University of Tennessee at Knoxville<br />

A professional resume is a summary of<br />

the academic qualifications, professional<br />

experiences, accomplishments, and<br />

activities of a person. But it’s more than the words on paper<br />

that matter. The content of the resume informs the reader (or<br />

hiring principal) about the commitment level of this person.<br />

I<br />

AM PLEASED TO BEGIN A TWO-YEAR<br />

term as Tennessee C-NAfME State<br />

Advisor. We have many exciting activities<br />

planned for the year. These began<br />

with the annual C-NAfME Fall Kickoff<br />

on Saturday, September 29, 2018,<br />

on the campus of the University of Tennessee,<br />

Knoxville. Our other major gathering<br />

for the year will be at the TMEA In-Service<br />

Conference in Nashville during April.<br />

Both of these events offer music education<br />

majors state-wide the opportunity for professional<br />

growth by attending clinics and<br />

workshops, interacting with master music<br />

teachers, networking with their peers, and<br />

serving the profession.<br />

As advisors we often state that being a<br />

member of C-NAfME is important for students<br />

to “build their resumes.” But what<br />

does that really mean? A professional resume<br />

is a summary of the academic qualifications,<br />

professional experiences, accomplishments,<br />

and activities of a person.<br />

But it’s more than the words on paper that<br />

matter. The content of the resume informs<br />

the reader (or hiring principal) about the<br />

commitment level of this person. I’m reminded<br />

of the saying, the only predictor of<br />

future performance is past performance.<br />

If it’s clear that a person applying for a<br />

school music position has only done the<br />

minimum in preparation for a professional<br />

teaching career, who wants to hire that<br />

person when other applicants have obviously<br />

done more? I’ve asked my own students<br />

many times, “Do you want an 80%<br />

teacher for your child? That’s passing isn’t<br />

it?” I don’t. I want a 110% person, someone<br />

who will go the extra mile to ensure<br />

student success. Someone who is always<br />

looking for new and better ways to reach<br />

young people. Someone who stays current<br />

in the field, and who is eager to learn and<br />

experience innovative teaching approaches.<br />

Someone who seeks out leadership opportunities<br />

to serve and develop organizational<br />

skills. Someone who is curious and<br />

questioning, seeking answers to complex,<br />

philosophical and pedagogical challenges.<br />

Someone who understands that mentors<br />

abound in the profession and that they are<br />

there as a resource for those who will seek<br />

them out. It is through these experiences<br />

that a resume is built and glowing recommendations<br />

follow. Active participation in<br />

C-NAfME is one pathway to reach such<br />

success.<br />

All of us who mentor pre-service teachers<br />

are faced with the question of how this<br />

can be done affordably? First of all, none<br />

of us can do everything and attend everything.<br />

It’s not humanly possible, and a reasonable<br />

balance between one’s personal<br />

and professional lives must be found to<br />

avoid burnout. Still, professional priorities<br />

must be set and one of those should be<br />

membership in professional associations<br />

like C-NAfME. That’s just the cost of doing<br />

business. And it will never be cheaper<br />

than while a student, to be a member and<br />

attend professional conferences. Many of<br />

my finest students who have gone on to<br />

amazing careers were some of the savviest,<br />

penny-pinching travelers I ever saw.<br />

They had an incredibly mature focus for<br />

what they wanted to achieve and experience,<br />

and they used every available resource<br />

to make it happen. They carpooled,<br />

stayed with family, used church networking<br />

for housing, and so forth. As I reflect on<br />

those exceptional young people, I believe<br />

they all shared common characteristics.<br />

They were passionate about being music<br />

teachers, were committed to their art, and<br />

were willing to pay the price to make their<br />

dreams come true. C-NAfME can help.<br />

Feel free to contact me if I may of service<br />

in any way at droyse@utk.edu.<br />

18 | TENNESSEE MUSICIAN | 2018 | <strong>Vol</strong>ume <strong>71</strong>, <strong>No</strong>. 1


TMEA SOCIETY FOR MUSIC TEACHER EDUCATION/<br />

RESEARCH CHAIR’S MESSAGE<br />

Jamila L. McWhirter, Ph. D. || Middle Tennessee State University<br />

The <strong>TN</strong>SMTE Symposium<br />

2018 was held on<br />

September 22, 2018 on<br />

the campus of MTSU in<br />

the Wright Music Building.<br />

Dr. Cynthia Taggart, Professor<br />

and Coordinator of Music<br />

Education at Michigan State<br />

University, delivered the keynote<br />

address and helped facilitate<br />

discussion through the<br />

course of the day. She presented<br />

information on the Michigan<br />

Arts Education Instruction<br />

and Assessment Program<br />

Dr. Cynthia Taggart at the <strong>TN</strong>SMTE Symposium at Middle (MAIA), with a special focus<br />

Tennessee State University.<br />

on the assessment portion. A<br />

thirty minute discussion of<br />

the program followed. Several participants met with Dr. Taggart over lunch at The<br />

Boulevard before the beginning of the afternoon session. The afternoon sessions focused<br />

on how MAIA might be used as a resource for K-12 music educators in the state<br />

of Tennessee. The day concluded with the formation of a 5 person committee who will<br />

examine where MAIA may be aligned with the newly implemented Tennessee State<br />

Music Education Standards. Once this work is completed, links to MAIA and the<br />

TDOE websites with suggested assessments will be placed on the SMTE/Research<br />

page on the TMEA website. If this work is completed by the TMEA Professional Development<br />

Conference, then a session on how K-12 music educators may implement<br />

these assessments with the Tennessee State Music Education Standards will be presented.<br />

Future goals include developing additional assessments for identified gaps<br />

between MAIA and the Tennessee State Music Education Standards.<br />

TMEA 2019 Research/Best Practice Call for Proposals<br />

The TMEA 2019 Call for Research/Best Practice Poster Session and Presentation<br />

Sessions is now open. Visit the TMEA website, go to the Conference Tab, then select<br />

TMEA Research/SMTE. TMEA will sponsor a research and best practice poster session<br />

plus three research/best practice presentation sessions at the state professional<br />

development conference. In-service teachers, graduate students, and university faculty<br />

are encouraged to submit a proposal for consideration.<br />

Research may be quantitative, qualitative, or mixed methods. Research should be<br />

completed and related to music teaching and learning. In-service teachers conducting<br />

action research in their classrooms are encouraged to submit these projects for consideration.<br />

Best practice submissions should describe programs or practices that are<br />

effectively meeting important goals in music<br />

education. Proposals should include a specific<br />

justification and/or rationale for the program<br />

or practice, and a description of the context in<br />

which it has been implemented.<br />

All submissions must meet the Code of Ethics<br />

published in the Journal of Research in<br />

Music Education. The deadline for submission<br />

is February 1, 2019. Submissions will<br />

only be accepted through the online form.<br />

TMEA will sponsor<br />

a research and<br />

best practice<br />

poster session<br />

plus three<br />

research/<br />

best practice<br />

presentation<br />

sessions at the<br />

state professional<br />

development<br />

conference.<br />

Tennessee Music Education Assocation | www.tnmea.org | 19


APPROACHING THE SIGHT-READING<br />

COMPONENT FOR FESTIVAL/CONTEST<br />

by Joe D. Moore<br />

A<br />

vital skill for any musician or ensemble<br />

is the ability to sight-read. In addition to<br />

contributing to musical growth of both the<br />

individual and the ensemble, it is often a<br />

required component of assessment events<br />

such as contests or festivals. With the emphasis<br />

placed on testing in the academic world, sightreading<br />

is the musical equivalent of an exam. The<br />

purpose of this article is to provide suggestions<br />

which may help directors develop a systematic<br />

approach to sight-reading with their ensembles.<br />

When the director and students are comfortable<br />

with a familiar routine that is also efficient, sightreading<br />

becomes much less daunting. Forming<br />

habits requires repetition, so it is important to<br />

include sight-reading throughout the year rather<br />

than introducing the process just prior to the<br />

evaluation event. In addition to strengthening<br />

the skills of both conductor and students, the<br />

process of reading new literature can add variety<br />

to rehearsals.<br />

PREPARATION<br />

Before developing your routine, it is vital<br />

that you understand the procedures and<br />

requirements for the event. These may<br />

vary by state but can usually be found on<br />

organizational websites and handbooks.<br />

Research the following information:<br />

What grade level will your ensemble sightread<br />

and what is the criteria for that level?<br />

• Some state-level events publish the required<br />

criteria for each grade level including:<br />

» keys and number of key changes<br />

» meters and number of meter changes<br />

» basic rhythms patterns encountered<br />

(including those for percussion only)<br />

» maximum durations of the pieces<br />

What criteria do the adjudication sheets contain?<br />

• Components usually include:<br />

» Sound quality (tone, pitch, blend, balance)<br />

» Technical accuracy (technique, rhythm)<br />

» Musicality (style, dynamics, expression,<br />

phrasing)<br />

» Communication (response to fellow players,<br />

response to conductor)Deportment<br />

(attitude, discipline, appearance, use of<br />

time)<br />

• How much time is allowed?<br />

• What are the rules (singing, tuning timpani,<br />

etc.)?<br />

If you are a new teacher or have relocated to a new<br />

district, remember that experienced teachers<br />

from that region can be an invaluable resource<br />

in addition to your research online and through<br />

handbooks.<br />

Include the non-musical logistics as part of<br />

your system so that they become a familiar part of<br />

the routine to your students:<br />

• Balance – In sections with more than one part,<br />

assign strong players to each part to help maintain<br />

proper balance in the ensemble sound. If<br />

students sit in chair order for the stage performance,<br />

they simply change their order as they<br />

enter the sight-reading location.<br />

» 1st chair = 1st part<br />

» 2nd chair = 2nd part<br />

» 3rd chair = 3rd part<br />

» 4th chair = 1st part<br />

» 5th chair = 2nd part<br />

» 6th chair = 3rd part<br />

• Pointers – Having students point to the music<br />

during the allotted discussion time helps<br />

to rein force your comments as well as keeping


Flute<br />

Oboe<br />

Clarinet in Bb 1<br />

Clarinet in Bb 2<br />

Alto Saxophone<br />

Tenor Saxophone<br />

Baritone Saxophone<br />

Trumpet in Bb 1<br />

Trumpet in Bb 2<br />

Horn in F<br />

Baritone Horn<br />

Trombone<br />

Tuba<br />

°<br />

& bb œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ Uœ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ Uœ<br />

& bb U U<br />

œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ Œ<br />

U<br />

U<br />

& œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ Œ<br />

U<br />

U<br />

& œ œ œ œ œ œ# œ œ# j œ œ œ œ œnœ œ œ œ œ œ#œ œ œ Œ<br />

& # U U<br />

œ œ œ œ œ œ# œ œ# J œ<br />

œ œ œ œnœ œ œ œ œ œ#œ œ œ Œ<br />

U<br />

U<br />

& œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ Œ Œ<br />

œ œ œ œ œ œ œ# œ Œ<br />

¢ & # U U<br />

œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ<br />

œ<br />

Œ Œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ# œ Œ<br />

°<br />

U<br />

U<br />

& œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ Œ<br />

U<br />

U<br />

& œ œ œ œ œ œ# œ œ# j œ œ œ œ œnœ œ œ œ œ œ#œ œ œ Œ<br />

U<br />

U<br />

&b œ œ œ œ œ œ# œ œ# J œ<br />

œ œ œ œnœ œ œ œ œ œnœ œ œ Œ<br />

? b b<br />

œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ Uœ U<br />

Œ Œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œn œ Œ<br />

œ U<br />

U<br />

?<br />

œ<br />

b b<br />

œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ Œ<br />

?<br />

¢ b b œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ<br />

Key is G harmonic minor<br />

(raised 7th degree)<br />

Figure 1: Key/Mode Example<br />

U<br />

œ<br />

Œ<br />

Œ<br />

U<br />

œ œ œ œ œ œ œn œ<br />

Forming habits requires repetition, so it is important to include sight-reading throughout<br />

the year rather than introducing the process just prior to the evaluation event<br />

Œ<br />

Œ<br />

students engaged. For example, having them touch the key signature<br />

on the page when you address it. Where two students share<br />

a music stand, you should experiment whether you want both or<br />

just one of them to point.<br />

• Percussion Assignments – Decide in advance which student will<br />

cover which instrument. Although assignments should rotate<br />

during the semester so that each student has opportunity to play,<br />

decide on the strongest player for each instrument for the evaluated<br />

event. When there are more students than there are parts to<br />

cover, you might consider assigning a non-playing percussionist<br />

to stand beside those who are playing (if it does not violate procedures).<br />

• Folders – Using a set of sight-reading folders allows the distribution<br />

and collection of music to be more efficient. This also<br />

creates the habit of having the students put their concert folders<br />

under the chair and receive a sight-reading folder which duplicates<br />

the actual experience.<br />

• Techniques – Establish and routinely utilize a counting system<br />

for speaking rhythmic patterns. There are several effective<br />

versions, but you should decide on one and use it consistently so<br />

that you and your students are comfortable with it. In addition, a<br />

system of articulating while moving keys/valves/slides without<br />

producing a musical tone is necessary. Both techniques should be<br />

employed on a regular basis so that students are confident with<br />

the process and actively engaged in the activity.<br />

• Time Management – Deciding how you proportion your given<br />

time will depend on the ability and maturity levels of the ensemble,<br />

as well as the difficulty of the music. You may decide to<br />

allow less time for individual study and questions with a younger<br />

group. Having the judge or a timekeeper announce how much<br />

time is left can be distracting to both you and the group. Consider<br />

taking an adult with you who has a timer and a set of flash cards<br />

that can stand in the back of the room and hold up signs indicating<br />

how many minutes are remaining so your instructions are<br />

not interrupted.<br />

22 | TENNESSEE MUSICIAN | 2018 | <strong>Vol</strong>ume <strong>71</strong>, <strong>No</strong>. 1


DEVISING YOUR STRATEGY<br />

Once you have researched procedures<br />

and requirements and have addressed the<br />

logistics involved, you are ready to develop<br />

the system you want your ensemble to<br />

use when sight-reading. Your system<br />

will consist of three components: Study,<br />

Discussion, and Questions.<br />

I. Study<br />

Before beginning the study segment,<br />

make certain that everyone has the correct<br />

musical selection and part (Baritone BC<br />

vs. Baritone TC, etc.). Ask students to<br />

adjust their chairs and stands so that they<br />

have good visual contact with you. Adjust<br />

row if necessary to replicate the set-up in<br />

which they are accustomed.<br />

When establishing a process for the<br />

students to follow, some find it helpful to<br />

use acronyms such as STAR (Signatures:<br />

key and time; Tempo; Accidentals;<br />

Roadmap: repeats, D.S., etc.). Regarding<br />

accidentals, the mistake is usually not<br />

missing the accidental itself since it is<br />

clearly marked. The mistake usually<br />

occurs with a repetition of the note within<br />

the same measure or the return of the<br />

note to the previous state in the following<br />

measure.<br />

When establishing your own process<br />

as conductor, it is helpful to have a few<br />

materials in place: metronome, music<br />

dictionary, paper clips (for find pages on<br />

a repeat), and a pad of small post-it notes.<br />

Use the post-it notes to mark things in the<br />

score you find in your own study that you<br />

want to call attention to in your discussion<br />

time. You may find it helpful to step off<br />

the podium and glance over the 1st Flute<br />

part before you open the score. This will<br />

give you an overview of the structure and<br />

any repeats that might be missed in the<br />

many pages of a full score. When you begin<br />

your score study, look for the following<br />

elements:<br />

» Key Changes (including modality –<br />

minor keys often involve numerous<br />

accidentals, raised 7th in particular,<br />

as shown in figure 1)<br />

» Meter Changes<br />

» Tempo Changes<br />

» Repeats<br />

» Fermatas/Releases<br />

» Dynamics<br />

» Style<br />

» Texture (soli sections, balance issues)<br />

» Ending<br />

Decide how fermatas are to be treated,<br />

(release, no release) and plan to rehearse<br />

those spots. Pay particular attention to<br />

staggered entrances which occur in figure<br />

2. If there are soli sections or sudden<br />

thinning of the texture as shown in figure<br />

3, include those areas in your discussion.<br />

You can imagine if you were the snare<br />

drummer and suddenly the rest of the<br />

ensemble stopped playing and you were<br />

continuing to play. If you did not know<br />

that it was a soli section for percussion you<br />

might think you were in the wrong place<br />

and just stop playing. Identify potential<br />

balance issues based on the scoring as<br />

illustrated in figure 4 where the melody is<br />

given to low voices with the remainder of<br />

the ensemble playing the accompaniment<br />

(particularly if your uppers voices<br />

outnumber the low voices). Be sure that<br />

you do not run out of time before studying<br />

the ending of the composition. That is the<br />

last musical impression you will leave<br />

with the adjudicator. A solid, confident<br />

ending is important to help everyone feel<br />

good about their performance.<br />

II. Discussion<br />

Maintain a calm demeanor throughout<br />

the process. Students will pick up on both<br />

verbal and non-verbal cues from you. Pace<br />

your speaking so that you are not frantic,<br />

but also do not run out of time. Monitor the<br />

engagement of your students during your<br />

explanations. They should be pointing<br />

to things you mention as well as being<br />

actively engaged in counting, singing, etc.<br />

Refer to the areas you marked with post-it<br />

notes during your study time. Never try to<br />

go measure by measure but highlight the<br />

major areas you marked to cover. Have the<br />

wind players silently finger the scales of<br />

the key centers (noting in particularly the<br />

4th degree of flat keys and the 7th degree<br />

of sharp keys). Emphasize the importance<br />

of good tone quality and musicality. If<br />

dynamic markings are sparse, exaggerate<br />

the ones that are present and look for<br />

opportunities to be expressive.<br />

III. Questions<br />

How much time to devote to questions<br />

or even the decision of whether to allow<br />

questions will depend on the age level<br />

and maturity of your group. If you do<br />

allow questions, you will need to coach<br />

your students concerning how to ask<br />

them efficiently. Remind them to form<br />

the question before they begin speaking<br />

and to be specific with bar numbers<br />

(allowing you to find it in the score since<br />

your part looks very different from theirs).<br />

With mature groups, you might consider<br />

allowing discussion among themselves<br />

for things you might not have covered or<br />

specific instructions from section leaders/<br />

principal players.<br />

If allowed, have the ensemble play a<br />

few notes or a brief chord progression.<br />

This helps the embouchures after a time<br />

of not playing. It also helps you to get an<br />

idea of the room acoustics. This should be<br />

a part of your routine and not something<br />

unexpected to the ensemble.<br />

EVALUATE AND REFINE<br />

As you utilize your system throughout the<br />

year, implement the following strategies<br />

to monitor effectiveness and offer methods<br />

for improvement:<br />

• Solicit both positive and negative feedback<br />

from your students.<br />

• Video record the sessions to evaluate the<br />

following:<br />

» Effectiveness of your instruction<br />

» Engagement of the students<br />

» Efficiency of student questions<br />

• Expose students to playing thinner textures<br />

through participation in chamber<br />

ensembles or playing full ensemble<br />

chorales but omitting various families of<br />

instruments.<br />

• Strengthen your non-verbal communication<br />

skills through your conducting<br />

during the daily warm-up time by<br />

focusing on:<br />

» style<br />

» phrasing<br />

» dynamics<br />

» expressiveness<br />

» gradual and sudden tempo changes<br />

• Simulate the adjudication factor by<br />

bringing in colleagues to critique the<br />

sight-reading sessions.<br />

• Consider having the band sight-read on a<br />

concert. I have found this to be informative<br />

and enjoyable for the audience<br />

in addition to simulating the pressure<br />

Tennessee Music Education Assocation | www.tnmea.org | 23


Figure 2: Fermata with Staggered Pick-ups<br />

Deciding how<br />

you proportion<br />

your given time<br />

will depend on<br />

the ability and<br />

maturity levels<br />

of the ensemble,<br />

as well as the<br />

difficulty of the<br />

music<br />

Flute<br />

Oboe<br />

Clarinet in Bb 1<br />

Clarinet in Bb 2<br />

Alto Saxophone<br />

Tenor Saxophone<br />

Baritone Saxophone<br />

Trumpet in Bb 1<br />

Trumpet in Bb 2<br />

Horn in F<br />

Baritone Horn<br />

Trombone<br />

Tuba<br />

°<br />

& bb œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ Uœ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ Uœ<br />

Œ<br />

& bb U U<br />

œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ Œ<br />

U<br />

U<br />

& œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ Œ<br />

U<br />

U<br />

& œ œ œ œ œ œ# œ œ# j œ œ œ œ œnœ œ œ œ œ œ#œ œ œ Œ<br />

& # U U<br />

œ œ œ œ œ œ# œ œ# J œ<br />

œ œ œ œnœ œ œ œ œ œ#œ œ œ Œ<br />

U<br />

U<br />

& œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ Œ Œ<br />

œ œ œ œ œ œ œ# œ Œ<br />

¢ & # U U<br />

œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ<br />

œ<br />

Œ Œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ# œ Œ<br />

°<br />

&<br />

&<br />

U<br />

U<br />

œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ Œ<br />

U<br />

U<br />

œ œ œ œ œ œ# œ œ# j œ œ œ œ œnœ œ œ œ œ œ#œ œ œ Œ<br />

& b U U<br />

œ œ œ œ œ œ# œ œ# J œ<br />

œ œ œ œnœ œ œ œ œ œnœ œ œ Œ<br />

? b b<br />

œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ Uœ U<br />

Œ Œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œn œ Œ<br />

œ U<br />

U<br />

?<br />

œ<br />

b b<br />

œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ Œ<br />

?<br />

¢ b b<br />

U<br />

U<br />

œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ Œ Œ<br />

Œ<br />

œ<br />

œ œ œ œ œ œ œn œ<br />

Low voices enter two beats later<br />

performers may feel during the actual event.<br />

• Past sight-reading band arrangements used for UIL contests are<br />

published by RBC Publishing and available for purchase through<br />

J.W. Pepper. These arrangements provide excellent material to<br />

use for ensemble sight-reading preparation. You might consider<br />

inviting several colleagues to join you and purchase an arrangement<br />

to share with each other.<br />

FINAL THOUGHTS<br />

As groups prepare for state evaluations it is easy to neglect the<br />

sight-reading component in lieu of working up the prepared<br />

selections. If there is an effective system in place which is utilized<br />

throughout the year, sight-reading can be enjoyable for students<br />

and directors instead of something to be dreaded. As a result, both<br />

individual players and the ensembles which they participate in<br />

will become musically stronger.<br />

Sight-reading Materials<br />

• 14 Weeks to a Better Band (Barnhouse)<br />

• 101 Rhythmic Rest Patterns (Warner Bros)<br />

• 202 Progressive Sight Reading Tunes (Gore)<br />

• Exercises for Ensemble Drill (Warner Bros)<br />

• Foundations for Superior Performance (Kjos)<br />

• Hal Leonard Intermediate and Advanced Methods (Hal Leonard)<br />

• Harmonized Rhythms (Kjos)<br />

• I Recommend (Ployhar)<br />

• Rhythm Master (Southern)<br />

• Rubank Advanced Methods (Rubank)<br />

• Sight Reading for Band Series (Southern)<br />

• Symphonic Band Technique (Southern)<br />

• TIPPS for Band (Warner Bros)<br />

• TRI –Technique, Rhythm, Intonation (Southern)<br />

• Winning Rhythms (Kjos)<br />

Other Resources<br />

• 16 Bach Chorales, arr. Lake<br />

• 66 Famous and Festive Bach Chorales, arr. Erickson<br />

• https://www.sightreadingfactory.com/<br />

• Band arrangements by RBC Publications for UIL sight-reading<br />

events are available through JW Pepper.<br />

JOE D. MOORE is Director of Athletic Bands and Associate Director<br />

of Bands at East Tennessee State University where he directs the<br />

Marching Band and Basketball Pep Bands, conducts the Concert Band,<br />

and teaches courses in Marching Band Methods, Brass Methods,<br />

Orchestration and Arranging, and Music Fundamentals. He is the<br />

former Director of Bands at Delta State University after teaching for<br />

sixteen years in the public schools of Tennessee, Virginia, and Georgia.<br />

He earned a Bachelor of Music Education from East Tennessee State<br />

University, Master of Music in Music Education from the University<br />

of Miami (FL), and a Doctor of Musical Arts in Wind Band Conducting<br />

from the University of Kentucky.<br />

24 | TENNESSEE MUSICIAN | 2018 | <strong>Vol</strong>ume <strong>71</strong>, <strong>No</strong>. 1


Figure 3: Soli Example<br />

Flute<br />

Oboe<br />

Clarinet in Bb 1<br />

Clarinet in Bb 2<br />

Alto Saxophone<br />

Tenor Saxophone<br />

Baritone Saxophone<br />

Trumpet in Bb 1<br />

Trumpet in Bb 2<br />

Horn in F<br />

Trombone<br />

Euphonium<br />

Tuba<br />

Timpani<br />

Snare Drum<br />

Percussion<br />

Cymbals<br />

°<br />

& b œ œ œ œ ˙ ˙ > œ<br />

4<br />

& b 4 œ œ œ œ ˙ ˙ ∑<br />

><br />

œ Œ Ó œ œ œ œ œ œ ˙ ˙<br />

><br />

œ Œ Ó<br />

& # 4 œ œ œ œ ˙ > œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ ˙<br />

˙<br />

œ œ œ œ œ œ ˙ ˙<br />

><br />

œ Œ Ó<br />

& # 4 œ œ œ œ œ œ ˙ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ ˙ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ ˙<br />

><br />

œ Œ Ó<br />

& # # ><br />

><br />

4<br />

œ œ œ œ œ œ ˙ œ Œ Ó ∑ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ ˙ œ Œ Ó<br />

& # 4<br />

˙<br />

œ ∑<br />

œ œ œ<br />

˙<br />

><br />

œ Œ Ó<br />

œ œ œ œ œ œ ˙<br />

˙<br />

><br />

œ Œ Ó<br />

¢ & # # ><br />

><br />

4 œ œ œ ˙ ˙ œ Œ Ó ∑ œ œ œ<br />

œ<br />

œ œ œ ˙ ˙ œ Œ Ó<br />

°<br />

& # 4 œ œ œ œ ˙ ˙<br />

><br />

œ Œ Ó ∑ œ œ œ œ œ œ ˙ ˙<br />

><br />

œ Œ Ó<br />

& # 4 œ œ ∑<br />

œ œ œ œ ˙<br />

><br />

œ Œ Ó œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ ˙<br />

><br />

œ Œ Ó<br />

><br />

><br />

& 4 œ œ œ œ œ œ ˙ œ Œ Ó ∑ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ ˙ œ Œ Ó<br />

? œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ ˙ > œ<br />

œ œ œ œ œ œ ><br />

b 4<br />

Œ Ó<br />

∑<br />

œ œ ˙ œ<br />

Œ Ó<br />

? ˙<br />

><br />

><br />

b 4<br />

œ œ œ œ<br />

˙ œ Œ Ó ∑ œ œ œ œ œ œ ˙<br />

˙ œ Œ Ó<br />

? ¢ b 4<br />

˙<br />

œ œ œ œ<br />

˙<br />

><br />

œ<br />

Œ<br />

Œ<br />

Ó<br />

Ó<br />

∑<br />

∑<br />

œ œ œ œ œ œ ˙ ˙ > œ<br />

œ œ œ œ œ œ ˙<br />

° ? ¢ b 4<br />

Œ Ó<br />

∑<br />

œ œ ˙ ˙ ˙<br />

><br />

œ<br />

˙ œ œ ˙ ˙ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ<br />

œ œ œ œ<br />

><br />

°<br />

/ 4 Ͼ<br />

œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ æ œ Œ Ó ∑ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ æœ œ œ œ œ œ æœ œ œ œ œ œ<br />

><br />

/ 4 ˙ œ œ ˙ œ œ œ Œ Ó ∑ œ œ œ œ ˙ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ<br />

><br />

¢ / 4 w ∑ œ Œ Ó ∑ w w œ œ ˙ œ œ ˙<br />

˙<br />

><br />

œ<br />

Œ<br />

Œ<br />

Ó<br />

Ó<br />

∑<br />

∑<br />

∑<br />

∑<br />

∑<br />

∑<br />

∑<br />

∑<br />

∑<br />

∑<br />

∑<br />

∑<br />

∑<br />

Monitor the<br />

engagement of<br />

your students<br />

during your<br />

explanations.<br />

They should<br />

be pointing<br />

to things<br />

you mention<br />

as well as<br />

being actively<br />

engaged<br />

in counting,<br />

singing, etc<br />

Flute<br />

Oboe<br />

Clarinet in Bb 1<br />

Clarinet in Bb 2<br />

Bass Clarinet<br />

in Bb<br />

Alto Saxophone<br />

Tenor Saxophone<br />

Baritone Saxophone<br />

Trumpet in Bb 1<br />

Trumpet in Bb 2<br />

Horn in F<br />

Baritone Horn<br />

Trombone<br />

Tuba<br />

°<br />

&b b œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ ˙<br />

4<br />

mf<br />

&b b 4 œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ ˙<br />

mf<br />

& 4 œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ ˙<br />

mf<br />

& 4 œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ ˙<br />

mf<br />

& 4<br />

œ œ<br />

œ œ œ œ ˙ œ œ œ œ œ œ ˙<br />

f<br />

& # 4 œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ ˙ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ ˙<br />

mf<br />

& 4<br />

œ<br />

f<br />

¢ & # 4 œ<br />

f<br />

°<br />

&<br />

4 œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ ˙<br />

mf<br />

&<br />

4 œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ ˙<br />

mf<br />

&b<br />

4 œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ ˙ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ ˙<br />

mf<br />

? b b<br />

4 œ<br />

f<br />

? b b<br />

4 œ<br />

f<br />

? ¢ b b4<br />

œ<br />

f<br />

œ<br />

œ<br />

œ<br />

œ<br />

œ<br />

Figure 4: Potential Balance Problems<br />

œ œ œ œ ˙ œ œ œ œ œ œ ˙<br />

œ œ œ œ ˙ œ œ œ œ œ œ ˙<br />

œ œ œ œ ˙ œ œ œ œ œ œ ˙<br />

œ œ œ œ ˙ œ œ œ œ œ œ ˙<br />

œ œ œ œ ˙ œ œ œ œ œ œ ˙<br />

Tennessee Music Education Assocation | www.tnmea.org | 25


MUSIC AT<br />

Milligan produces life-long learners and lovers of music, as well as accomplished performers. The program’s<br />

faculty consists of knowledgeable and experienced musicians who also are dedicated and caring educators<br />

focused on helping students achieve their musical goals.<br />

MAJORS<br />

Music Performance<br />

Music Business<br />

music education<br />

(Instrumental, Vocal)<br />

Musical Theatre<br />

fine arts (MUSIC EMPHASIS)<br />

worship leadership<br />

MINORS<br />

music Performance<br />

Musical Theatre<br />

Worship leadership<br />

ENSEMBLES<br />

Concert Choir<br />

Women’s Chorale<br />

Orchestra<br />

String Quartet<br />

Civic Band<br />

Johnson City Symphony<br />

Orchestra<br />

Heritage<br />

Herd Mentality<br />

SCHOLARSHIPS<br />

Scholarships are available, regardless of a student’s intended<br />

major. To schedule an audition, call 423.461.8723, or email<br />

music@milligan.edu.<br />

FACULTY SPOTLIGHT<br />

Dr. Carrie Klofach Musical Theatre<br />

|<br />

Leading Milligan’s new musical theatre major this fall, Klofach has extensive<br />

experience playing lead theatrical roles, singing in operatic productions, and<br />

helping manage productions behind the scenes. She holds a bachelor’s in<br />

music from Grand Canyon University and both<br />

a master’s in musical theatre performance and<br />

doctorate in vocal performance from Arizona<br />

State University.<br />

Klofach has premiered several musicals<br />

including the world premiere of “The<br />

Quiltmaker’s Gift,” playing the Quiltmaker at<br />

Phoenix Theatre in Phoenix, Arizona. She also<br />

appeared in the First National Tour of “Veggie<br />

Tales Live” as Marcy.<br />

LEARN MORE<br />

MILLIGAN.EDU/MUSIC<br />

26 | TENNESSEE MUSICIAN | 2018 | <strong>Vol</strong>ume <strong>71</strong>, <strong>No</strong>. 1<br />

A TOP COLLEGE & BEST VALUE.<br />

–U.S. NEWS


WHEN HELPING<br />

HURTS<br />

DEVELOPMENTALLY<br />

BY MICHAEL A. RAIBER<br />

APPROPRIATE TEACHER MENTORING<br />

DaLaine Chapman, Ph. D.<br />

28 | TENNESSEE MUSICIAN | 2018 | <strong>Vol</strong>ume <strong>71</strong>, <strong>No</strong>. 1


ALTHOUGH WE IN MUSIC TEACHER EDUCATION<br />

work diligently to prepare young music educators<br />

during their preservice education,<br />

we must also recognize that “most of the<br />

learning to teach music occurs in the first<br />

years” (Conway, 2010, p. 268). During this<br />

time, many young music educators seek<br />

the advice of mentors. These mentoring<br />

relationships are sometimes formal, such<br />

as school district or state sponsored programs<br />

that pair entry-level music educators<br />

with more experienced teachers. Other<br />

mentoring relationships are informal<br />

and include more spontaneous meetings<br />

like those with a colleague at a conference<br />

or convention. <strong>No</strong> matter what type of<br />

relationship, mentors can have a substantial<br />

influence on young music teachers<br />

who value mentor’s insights and expertise<br />

(Conway, 2010).<br />

Research suggests, however, that all<br />

mentoring is not created equal (Drafall,<br />

1991; Glickman, 1985; Glickman, Gordan<br />

& Ross-Gordon, 1995). Before providing<br />

feedback or advice, effective mentors consider<br />

the developmental level of the educator<br />

they are intending to help. These<br />

mentors use this information to ‘package’<br />

the feedback they are providing in ways<br />

that will be understood by the mentee.<br />

This research suggests when mentors fail<br />

to match their supervisory approach with<br />

a teacher’s developmental level, intended<br />

help is often misunderstood and/or ignored.<br />

Before providing<br />

feedback or advice,<br />

effective mentors<br />

consider the<br />

developmental level of<br />

the educator<br />

they are intending<br />

to help.<br />

teachers often have concerns about personal<br />

adequacy or being ‘cut out’ to teach.<br />

MUSIC TEACHER DEVELOPMENT<br />

A number of approaches have been used<br />

to investigate teacher development. However,<br />

a ‘teacher concerns’ model (Fuller<br />

& Bown, 1975) has attracted significant<br />

attention in recent music education research<br />

on this subject (Killian, Dye & Wayman,<br />

2013; Miksza & Berg, 2013; Powell,<br />

2014). This model suggests that development<br />

is reflected by shifts in teacher concerns.<br />

These concerns are defined by the<br />

elements that garner a teacher’s primary<br />

attention or their most pressing psychological<br />

need at any given moment. Fuller<br />

and Bown classified these concerns into<br />

three levels of teacher development, a)<br />

self- or survival concerns, b) teaching or<br />

task concerns, and c) student-learning or<br />

student-impact concerns. While Fuller<br />

and Bown provide clear definitions and<br />

lists of characteristics for each level, they<br />

also recognize teachers will most often<br />

share concerns on multiple levels. They<br />

additionally note context can have significant<br />

impact on teachers’ concerns. In<br />

a new context or setting, young teachers<br />

tend to revert to task concerns or self-concerns<br />

even if they were previously operating<br />

at student-learning concerns levels in<br />

more familiar contexts. It is, therefore, the<br />

preponderance of concerns shared by the<br />

teacher that will help mentors focus their<br />

feedback.<br />

Self-concerns are characterized by a<br />

teacher’s need to establish his or her sense<br />

of self as a teacher rather than a student.<br />

These teachers often have concerns about<br />

personal adequacy or being ‘cut out’ to<br />

teach. They are easily influenced by their<br />

perceptions of student acceptance and<br />

external evaluations concerning their<br />

teaching performance. When talking with<br />

teachers operating at this developmental<br />

level, their comments often begin with<br />

“I.” Common statements might include, “I<br />

hope the students like me” or “I don’t want<br />

to be the mean teacher.”<br />

Those functioning at a task concerns<br />

level focus on mastery of teaching techniques<br />

and the day-to-day work of teaching.<br />

These music educators are most concerned<br />

with issues like planning lessons or<br />

rehearsals, mastering materials, and applying<br />

teaching strategies. These teachers<br />

will share thoughts like, “I am concerned<br />

that I talk too much in rehearsal” or “I need<br />

to know more about grade 2 repertoire.”<br />

These teachers are often very lesson plan<br />

oriented. If their plan contains several<br />

steps of instruction, they will follow those<br />

steps without regard to student needs. The<br />

goal is to present or teach the plan.<br />

Music educators who are primarily concerned<br />

with student learning will share<br />

comments and questions like, “I am having<br />

trouble balancing individual student<br />

needs within my classroom”, or “How do<br />

I help my more advanced performers stay<br />

engaged while I provide more remedial<br />

instruction to the students who need it?”<br />

These teachers are most concerned with<br />

student achievement, student engagement,<br />

motivation for learning, and the personal<br />

well-being of their students. One will find<br />

these teachers ‘come off their plans’ when<br />

it is necessary to meet the needs of the students<br />

in the classroom. While they do not<br />

lose sight of desired learning outcomes,<br />

they are willing to arrive at those outcomes<br />

in various ways and will allow the learner<br />

to at least partially define the means and<br />

methods to get there.<br />

DEVELOPMENTAL SUPERVISION<br />

Glickman (1985) developed a supervisory<br />

model that accounts for teacher development.<br />

The goal of this model is to match<br />

the supervisory approach with the teacher<br />

developmental level so the mentored<br />

teacher both understands the information<br />

being provided and uses the information to<br />

further his or her development. Glickman’s<br />

model was intended to facilitate in-service<br />

teacher development, but Drafall (1991)<br />

successfully applied the model to facilitate<br />

pre-service music teacher development as<br />

well. Glickman’s model places supervisory<br />

behaviors in three categories, a) directive<br />

behaviors, b) collaborative behaviors, and<br />

c) non-directive behaviors.<br />

Using directive supervisory behaviors,<br />

the mentor will choose the goals for the<br />

teacher and direct the teacher to implement<br />

specific actions. The mentor may ask<br />

for and consider teacher feedback but remains<br />

the source of information while of-<br />

Tennessee Music Education Assocation | www.tnmea.org | 29


fering alternatives from which the teacher<br />

may choose a course of action. This supervisory<br />

approach is appropriate to use when<br />

time is short and concrete actions need to<br />

be taken or when the teacher lacks needed<br />

knowledge, skills, or experience necessary<br />

to affect change. To be effective, the<br />

teacher must view the mentor as a credible<br />

source and the mentor must be willing to<br />

take responsibility for the actions of the<br />

teacher. This suggests that effective mentors<br />

who find a directive approach necessary<br />

develop relationships with those they<br />

supervise. They work with these teachers<br />

over time and provide additional feedback<br />

when needed.<br />

Mentors who choose to use a collaborative<br />

approach may do so for several<br />

reasons. They may determine the teacher<br />

being advised is functioning at a moderate<br />

level. The teacher demonstrates the ability<br />

to make effective decisions, but may<br />

not have the confidence to implement actions<br />

with authority. Additionally or alternatively,<br />

the mentor may determine the<br />

teacher’s knowledge base is similar to his<br />

or her own and both mentor and teacher<br />

are invested in the decision being considered.<br />

Often, when a collaborative approach<br />

is used, both the mentor and the teacher<br />

are equally committed to solving the problem.<br />

A collaborative approach requires the<br />

mentor and teacher openly discuss possible<br />

solutions and reach an agreed-upon decision<br />

regarding how to improve instruction<br />

that is genuinely acceptable with both<br />

parties. As a result the teacher is affirmed<br />

in his or her ideas about teaching.<br />

When an effective mentor determines<br />

the teacher is functioning at a high level<br />

and possesses most of the knowledge and<br />

expertise necessary to be effective, he or<br />

she will often choose to use a non-directive<br />

supervisory approach. In doing so the<br />

mentor will start by asking open-ended<br />

questions to guide the teacher’s thinking,<br />

but decision-making and implementation<br />

remains the sole responsibility of<br />

the teacher. The mentor will not interject<br />

ideas, but only clarify the thoughts or<br />

ideas provided by the teacher. The goal of<br />

this approach is to assist the educator in<br />

thinking through alternatives that help the<br />

teacher reach his or her own conclusions.<br />

DEVELOPMENTALLY APPROPRIATE MENTORING<br />

Matching a teacher’s developmental<br />

level (Fuller & Bown, 1975) with a specific<br />

supervisory approach (Glickman, 1985) is<br />

As the mentor and<br />

teacher work together<br />

to find answers to<br />

the issues at hand,<br />

effective mentors<br />

steer conversations<br />

away from teaching<br />

concerns and focus<br />

on student learning.<br />

likely to provide the most effective mentoring<br />

outcomes for all involved. This<br />

suggests a directive approach would be<br />

most effective for teachers operating at a<br />

self-concerns level. At this point, mentor<br />

feedback should not only provide solutions<br />

to immediate issues, but also help direct<br />

the teacher’s concerns away from self<br />

and more toward teaching. As teaching<br />

concerns become the educator’s primary<br />

focus, mentoring should change to a more<br />

collaborative approach. As the mentor and<br />

teacher work together to find answers to<br />

the issues at hand, effective mentors steer<br />

conversations away from teaching concerns<br />

and focus on student learning. In<br />

effect, mentors model this concern for the<br />

teacher. As the teacher’s concerns become<br />

centered on student learning, the effective<br />

mentor moves to a non-directive approach,<br />

coaching the teacher as he or she<br />

makes decisions for themselves. In general,<br />

as teachers become increasingly aware<br />

of their impact, they are provided greater<br />

autonomy.<br />

A note of caution is necessary at this<br />

point, because the process outlined above<br />

appears to suggest that effective mentoring<br />

is very systematic with teachers consistently<br />

moving from one concerns level to<br />

the next. Fuller and Bown note, however,<br />

that teacher development is not linear, but<br />

fluid, as teacher concerns tend to revolve<br />

rather than evolve depending upon context.<br />

Therefore, the mentoring approach<br />

must be fluid as well. Even if the mentoring<br />

approach has been non-directive, it<br />

is not uncommon to find it necessary to<br />

provide a directive approach when teachers<br />

are in new environments or have new<br />

information to apply to their teaching.<br />

Additionally, a teacher may be at different<br />

stages of development in different environments.<br />

For example, a young band director’s<br />

concerns may be focused on student<br />

learning in the concert ensemble, but due<br />

to lack of experience, he or she is self-concerned<br />

when working with a jazz ensemble.<br />

Effective mentors will match their supervisory<br />

approach to the developmental<br />

level demonstrated by the teacher at any<br />

given time.<br />

Mentors have had and will continue to<br />

have a tremendous effect on young music<br />

educators. When mentors effectively assess<br />

a teacher’s developmental level and<br />

match their supervisory approach to that<br />

assessment, they are likely to find their<br />

feedback and advice to be increasingly effective.<br />

The outcome will benefit many,<br />

but most importantly, students in music<br />

classrooms will be the primary beneficiaries<br />

of effective teacher mentoring.<br />

REFERENCES<br />

Conway, C. (2010). Issues facing music<br />

teacher education in the 21st century:<br />

Developing leaders in the field. In H. S.<br />

Abeles & L. A. Custodero (Eds.), Critical<br />

issues in music education: Contemporary<br />

theory and practice, (pp. 259-275).<br />

New York: Oxford University Press.<br />

Drafall, I. E. (1991). The use of developmental<br />

clinical supervision with student<br />

teachers in secondary choral music:<br />

Two case studies. Available from<br />

ProQuest Dissertations and Theses database.<br />

(UMI <strong>No</strong>. 9210787)<br />

Fuller, F. F. & Bown, O. H. (1975). Becoming<br />

a teacher. In K. Ryan (Ed.), Teacher<br />

education 74th yearbook of the National<br />

Society for the Study of Education, part<br />

II (pp. 25-52). Chicago: University of<br />

Chicago Press.<br />

Glickman, C. D. (1985). Supervision of instruction:<br />

A developmental approach.<br />

Boston: Allyn & Bacon.<br />

Glickman, C. D., Gordon, S. P. & Ross-Gordon,<br />

J. M. (1995). Supervision of instruction:<br />

A developmental approach<br />

(3rd ed.). Boston: Allyn & Bacon.<br />

30 | TENNESSEE MUSICIAN | 2018 | <strong>Vol</strong>ume <strong>71</strong>, <strong>No</strong>. 1


Killian, J. N., Dye, K. G. & Wayman, J. B. (2013). Music student<br />

teachers: Pre-student teaching concerns and post-student<br />

teaching perceptions over a 5-year period. Journal of Research<br />

in Music Education, 61(1), 63-69.<br />

Miksza, P. & Berg, M. (2013). A longitudinal study of preservice<br />

music teacher development: Application and advancement of<br />

the Fuller and Bown teacher concerns model. Journal of Research<br />

in Music Education, 61(1), 44-62.<br />

Powell, S. (2014). Examining preservice music teacher concerns<br />

in peer and field teaching settings. Journal of Research in Music<br />

Education, 61(4), 361-378.<br />

DEPARTMENT OF MUSIC<br />

DR. MICHAEL RAIBER is a Professor of<br />

Music and holds the Busey Chair<br />

in Music Education at Oklahoma<br />

City University. For the sixteen<br />

years previous, he taught undergraduate<br />

and graduate courses<br />

at the University of Oklahoma<br />

and Oklahoma State University.<br />

His public school teaching experience<br />

includes thirteen years at<br />

schools in Missouri and Oklahoma.<br />

Mike is native Oklahoman. He attended high school in the<br />

Tulsa area and then earned both a BME and MME from the University<br />

of Tulsa. He completed his Ph.D. in music education at the<br />

University of Oklahoma. Music teacher education is his passion<br />

and his chief focus. His greatest desire is to help prepare quality<br />

music educators who will inspire the next generation of music<br />

students.<br />

In addition to his teaching, Mike serves at the primary conductor<br />

and Director of Teacher Support for El Sistema Oklahoma<br />

(ESO). <strong>No</strong>w in it second year, this program serves the families of<br />

over 180 children in Oklahoma City. Modeled after the successful<br />

endeavors in Venezuela, ESO seeks to enable social action<br />

through music.<br />

Dr. Raiber is also an active author and researcher. His co-authored<br />

textbook, The Journey from Music Student to Teacher: A<br />

Professional Approach was published by Routledge in January<br />

2014. Equally founded in research and practice, this book espouses<br />

a new approach to preparing music education students as they<br />

become quality professional music educators. Mike is currently<br />

the primary researcher for El Sistema Oklahoma investigating the<br />

programs impact on all stakeholders involved. He was the primary<br />

investigator on the collaborative research team for Oklahoma A+<br />

Schools® (OAS) that produced a five-volume report on the implementation<br />

of the OAS school reform model in Oklahoma schools.<br />

Mike is the President of the Oklahoma Music Educators Association.<br />

His professional affiliations include, the National Association<br />

for Music Education, Oklahoma Music Educators Association,<br />

and the Society for Music Teacher Education.<br />

This article originally appeared in Ala Breve, the official publication<br />

of the Alabama Music Educators Association, August/<br />

September, 2015. Reprinted with permission.<br />

BACHELOR OF MUSIC<br />

Concentrations include:<br />

• Guitar Performance<br />

• Instrumental Performance<br />

• Keyboard Performance<br />

• Vocal Performance<br />

• Composition<br />

• Music Education<br />

Choral/K-12 General Music<br />

Instrumental/K-12 General Music<br />

BACHELOR OF ARTS/SCIENCE<br />

Customizable music degree plans for a<br />

variety of music and music-related careers<br />

MASTER OF MUSIC<br />

Concentrations include:<br />

• Instrumental Performance<br />

• Vocal Performance<br />

• Instrumental Conducting<br />

• Choral Conducting<br />

• Music Education (with licensure option)<br />

Graduate assistantships are<br />

available.<br />

Tuition waivers are available<br />

to out-of-state students.<br />

Audition dates are available at<br />

www.apsu.edu/music/graduate/auditions<br />

www.apsu.edu/music/undergraduate/auditions<br />

FOR INFORMATION, CONTACT:<br />

Department of Music<br />

P: 931-221-7818 • music@apsu.edu or<br />

visit www.apsu.edu/music<br />

Austin Peay State University does not discriminate on the basis of race, color, religion, creed, national origin, sex, sexual orientation,<br />

gender identity/expression, disability, age, status as a protected veteran, genetic information, or any other legally protected class<br />

with respect to all employment, programs and activities sponsored by APSU. http://www.apsu.edu/policy. Policy 6:003<br />

AP58//8-18/3<br />

Tennessee Music Education Assocation | www.tnmea.org | 31


CLASSROOM CLASSICAL GUITAR<br />

Our biggest challenge was not yet apparent in 2001 when we first began the Educational Outreach Program of the Austin Classical<br />

Guitar Society (ACGS). ACGS, a nonprofit organization with broad community-based classical guitar programs, had<br />

received a financial contribution to support expert teachers to visit what was then one of two classroom guitar programs in<br />

Austin, Texas schools. Our teachers were to provide individual instruction for dedicated low-income students.<br />

Almost immediately, the school’s program<br />

director – a choir director by training,<br />

who was a classical guitar enthusiast<br />

– invited our teachers to assist with classroom<br />

direction in addition to individual instruction.<br />

Our instructors noticed a degree<br />

of misalignment between what they felt<br />

to be a proper sequence of classical guitar<br />

instruction and what was actually happening<br />

in the classroom. The main problem<br />

was that there was no vast library of carefully<br />

graded ensemble music for guitar—<br />

unlike what had been developed over the<br />

last century for choir, orchestra and band<br />

programs. So, with determination, elbow<br />

grease, talent, and creativity, our teachers<br />

began a collaboration to come up with sequenced<br />

repertoire solutions - some originally<br />

composed and some fashioned from<br />

existing literature - that would allow them<br />

to teach the classes effectively.<br />

The program operated in this manner<br />

for three years. During this time, it grew<br />

from 15 to 85 students and a nearby middle<br />

school began a program with our help as<br />

well. They had 13 students in the first class.<br />

Six graduates had already been accepted to<br />

college with scholarship offers. By 2004,<br />

ACGS found itself more or less responsible<br />

for the musical education of about 100<br />

young people. But we were reinventing the<br />

wheel each semester. It was at that point<br />

that our biggest challenge became apparent:<br />

We needed to develop a comprehensive,<br />

A to Z, curricular solution for classroom<br />

classical guitar.<br />

The wish list was a long one: Develop a<br />

strictly ensemble solution that would allow<br />

a teacher to teach from the podium while,<br />

at the same time, engaging each student in<br />

a common music-making experience; develop<br />

a graded sequence mirroring widely<br />

accepted methods for teaching individuals,<br />

but tailored to the special concerns, especially<br />

pacing and common technical pit-<br />

by Matthew Hinsley<br />

HOW CURRICULUM<br />

DEVELOPMENT AND TEACHER<br />

TRAINING TRANSFORMED<br />

CLASSROOM CLASSICAL<br />

GUITAR IN CENTRAL TEXAS<br />

AND BEYOND, AND, IN<br />

THE PROCESS, ENGAGED<br />

THOUSANDS OF MIDDLE AND<br />

HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS IN<br />

SCHOOL-BASED FINE ARTS<br />

FOR THE FIRST TIME.<br />

32 | TENNESSEE MUSICIAN | 2018 | <strong>Vol</strong>ume <strong>71</strong>, <strong>No</strong>. 1


falls, that relate to teaching in large groups; maintain a musically<br />

expressive focus at all times in the classroom—from the very first<br />

notes on the very first day; create a solution for the common eventuality<br />

that single classes will contain students with a wide variety<br />

of skill levels that need to be meaningfully engaged at the same<br />

time; develop theory worksheets and exam components relating<br />

directly to the ensemble repertoire at each stage of graduated student<br />

development; create graded ensemble sight-reading exercises<br />

for all levels; write a comprehensive pedagogical sequence document;<br />

and develop a comprehensive library of stylistically varied<br />

ensemble music to support instruction at each level.<br />

THE ENSEMBLE SOLUTION<br />

While visiting many guitar classrooms, both in Austin and beyond,<br />

we observed a wide variety of quality and success. The least<br />

successful (from a classical guitar pedagogical standpoint) were<br />

classes that employed a wide stylistic focus. These classes tended<br />

to operate more like “guitar clubs” than guitar classes. Students<br />

were rarely developing the kinds of skills one would associate with<br />

a quality school-based music program: music literacy, sight-reading,<br />

attention to dynamic/expressive markings, high quality rehearsal<br />

and performance skills, etc. And in no cases did we find<br />

that these types of classes yielded consistent results in terms of<br />

classical guitar technical development. The best technical results<br />

we observed involved teachers who led their classes through established<br />

method books with all students playing the same thing<br />

together. While students in these classes tended to move well<br />

and show discipline, the results were not particularly musically<br />

fulfilling, and the lack of ensemble playing made entry into these<br />

“group individual lesson” environments strikingly different than<br />

entry into orchestra classes where students were making beautiful<br />

music together. Our solution, we concluded, would have to be<br />

entirely ensemble-oriented. We settled on a system of three-part<br />

guitar ensemble music for all beginning and intermediate repertoire,<br />

including sight-reading.<br />

A GRADED SEQUENCE<br />

One of our greatest frustrations when reviewing the published<br />

literature for pedagogically appropriate ensemble music, was<br />

that while an individual part of a piece of music may be relatively<br />

“easy” for the first 30 measures or so, it would often depart into a<br />

technically challenging section for the next 30 measures! In some<br />

cases, it seemed composers had a general sense of the level they<br />

were writing for but, understandably, more often the musical result<br />

they were seeking would take precedence over staying within<br />

any sort of strict technical guidelines. While occasional technical<br />

departures might be manageable when coaching a talented<br />

ensemble of three or four players who have private instruction,<br />

trying to teach a class of 15 high school students, with no private<br />

instruction is only possible when parts strictly adhere to appropriate<br />

technical specifications.<br />

We developed a curriculum of nine graduated levels of advancement.<br />

With all the music we would create, we would be sure that<br />

any part could fit snugly into one of these nine levels. In summary,<br />

the skills presented in each level break down as follows:<br />

» Level 1 - Open string reading with “fixed” fingers in the right<br />

hand and minimal left hand rote elements<br />

Tennessee Music Education Assocation | www.tnmea.org | 33


» Level 2 - Reading on strings 1, 2 and<br />

3 in first position (right hand fingers<br />

still fixed)<br />

» Level 3 - im alternation and string<br />

crossing (no new notes) Classroom<br />

Classical Guitar<br />

» Level 4 - Bass notes on strings 4, 5<br />

and 6<br />

» Level 5 - Combined skills of Levels<br />

1-4 with complexity, add simple slurs<br />

» Level 6 - Simple arpeggios<br />

» Level 7 - Complex arpeggios and<br />

barring<br />

» Level 8 - Moderate upper position<br />

reading and rest stroke<br />

» Level 9 - Advanced upper position<br />

reading<br />

The most troubling technical problems<br />

we observed during our survey of classroom<br />

students related to the right hand.<br />

Problematic right hands were tense, too<br />

low, bent down from the wrist, did not<br />

“string cross,” had fingers plucking “up and<br />

away” instead of moving naturally into the<br />

hand, or some combination of all of these<br />

things. These issues are hard enough to address<br />

one-on-one with students, and they<br />

are far more challenging in large class environments.<br />

In developing our sequence, we<br />

particularly sought precautions to allow<br />

teachers maximum facility in developing<br />

right-hand technique. Our solution was to<br />

dedicate the first two levels to “fixed finger”<br />

positions with the emphasis on hand<br />

position and stroke quality, followed by an<br />

entire level. Level 3 would focus solely on<br />

finger alternation and string crossing - two<br />

techniques that must be introduced with<br />

great care.<br />

TEACHING MUSICIANSHIP<br />

As concerned as we were with careful technical<br />

sequencing, we were even more concerned<br />

– thanks to the advice of Robert Duke,<br />

founder of the Center for Music and Human<br />

Learning at the University of Texas at Austin<br />

- with engaging young people in the joy of<br />

music-making from the very first notes in every<br />

class. We had visited a few classes where<br />

talented and earnest young guitar teachers<br />

were doggedly leading their classes through<br />

a series of technical exercises and pieces of<br />

music that were thinly veiled technical exercises.<br />

In these classes, we heard little that<br />

could be described as beautiful, expressive<br />

music.<br />

In his book, Intelligent Music Teaching,<br />

Duke wrote, “Learning efficiency is maximized<br />

when all of the elements of [musicianship]<br />

are introduced and practiced in<br />

contexts that are as much like the final goal<br />

as possible. In other words, students learn<br />

best when each learning opportunity closely<br />

resembles the long-term goal itself .” 1<br />

In developing our library of music in accordance<br />

with our nine-level technical sequence,<br />

therefore, our guiding principle at<br />

all times was to write music, no matter how<br />

technically simple, that would be expressively<br />

engaging, and that carried ample dynamic<br />

expressive indications at all times.<br />

Duke recently said: “ACGS has made a<br />

signal contribution to the world of guitar<br />

pedagogy. Working from well-grounded underlying<br />

principles of human learning and<br />

behavior change, and focused on the goal of<br />

expressive and refined music-making, the<br />

organization has developed a curriculum for<br />

instruction that engages learners from their<br />

first experiences with the guitar, emphasizing<br />

beauty of sound and effective communication<br />

throughout the development of technical<br />

capacity.”<br />

TEACHING TO MULTIPLE SKILL LEVELS<br />

One of the toughest nuts to crack is the<br />

issue of dealing with students at multiple<br />

skill levels in the same class. This sometimes<br />

occurs because school administration<br />

can allow for only one section of guitar to be<br />

taught meaning that “last year’s” level 4 students<br />

begin their second year of study in the<br />

same room as the current level 1 beginners!<br />

We often observed talented students who had<br />

studied privately training for years before entering<br />

one of our guitar classes. Then, all of<br />

a sudden we had level 8 or 9 students, combined<br />

with intermediate students and even<br />

beginners.<br />

Our solution to this problem was to develop<br />

a comprehensive library of guitar ensemble<br />

music instructing our composers to write<br />

multiple versions of each part appropriate<br />

to multiple skill levels. The result? We could<br />

have several “part ones” in multiple levels,<br />

any one of which could combine with any of<br />

the multiple “part twos” we had, that could in<br />

turn combine with any of the “parts threes,”<br />

yielding countless level combinations! We<br />

even asked Web developers to load the entire<br />

database online and create a search function<br />

wherein our teachers could enter their individual<br />

classroom makeup and have scores<br />

and parts returned instantly to them, allowing<br />

them to meaningfully engage every member<br />

of their class at the same time.<br />

THE RESULTS<br />

Observing the transformation of classroom<br />

classical guitar instruction over the<br />

past eight years in Central Texas has been<br />

a remarkable experience. While the project<br />

is constantly being revised and expanded,<br />

the ACGS curriculum was primarily developed<br />

between 2004 and 2008. We have built<br />

programs in 17 public, private and charter<br />

schools, and have supplied our curriculum<br />

to many additional cities throughout the<br />

United States and Canada. In Austin alone,<br />

our affiliate programs accommodate about<br />

750 students each day. Our educators buzz<br />

from location to location directing classes,<br />

team-teaching, training teachers, planning<br />

recitals, and working with small ensembles.<br />

We now provide more than 10 hours a week<br />

of individual lessons for low-income students,<br />

and ACGS owns more than 80 guitars<br />

that are on free loan to schools and individuals<br />

in need.<br />

Jeremy Osborne, our assistant director of<br />

education, describes his experience in this<br />

way, “I have to constantly change my role in<br />

the classroom virtually each period of the<br />

day. One hour I will be working directly with<br />

kids and will have complete control over<br />

what is being taught in the class. The next<br />

hour, I will be taking a backseat, observing<br />

another teacher, quietly straightening student<br />

wrists, and interjecting with concepts<br />

when absolutely necessary. Transitioning between<br />

being a teacher and a consultant presents<br />

me with a unique set of challenges that,<br />

when met, yield the reward of solid progress<br />

in a new frontier of music education. The<br />

most inspiring part of my work with ACGS<br />

is knowing that, through the development of<br />

guitar education, we are successfully creating<br />

new opportunities for students to have a<br />

meaningful relationship with music and art.”<br />

Our enrollment is extremely diverse. We<br />

have strong programs in middle and high<br />

schools in economically disadvantaged areas<br />

of Austin. About 65 percent of our enrolled<br />

students are Hispanic and 40 percent are<br />

female. Perhaps most interesting, however,<br />

is that, according to a poll we conducted<br />

in 2009, almost 90 percent of our students<br />

are attending school-based performing arts<br />

classes for the first time in middle and high<br />

school through guitar class. We are not seeing<br />

kids that were band, orchestra, or choir<br />

students, or “music kids” who have decided<br />

to go play guitar instead of, or in addition to,<br />

their other musical endeavors. Nearly all of<br />

the young people we see are trying performing<br />

arts in middle and high school for the first<br />

time because they are drawn to guitar.<br />

34 | TENNESSEE MUSICIAN | 2018 | <strong>Vol</strong>ume <strong>71</strong>, <strong>No</strong>. 1


Travis Marcum has directed ACGS Education and Outreach Programs<br />

since 2005: “Over the past five years, I have seen a complete<br />

shift in Austin’s music education environment. Music teachers<br />

that once resisted change in the traditional school curriculum have<br />

embraced the guitar as a vehicle for reaching a more diverse group<br />

of students who would otherwise never experience music making.<br />

Thousands of students, many at risk of underperforming scholastically,<br />

dropping out, or even entering the juvenile justice system, have<br />

changed their attitudes about learning because of guitar class. They<br />

are making beautiful music on the guitar and transferring these skills<br />

to other parts of their lives. These students are going to conservatory,<br />

teaching in the community, performing at Austin’s local venues and<br />

around the world. Each day in the classroom, I feel like I am part of<br />

something progressive, meaningful. and life-changing for these students.”<br />

In 2009, the University of Texas, School of Social Work conducted<br />

a social impact study on the program’s effects on students in three<br />

schools. The study, under the direction of Calvin Streeter, focused on<br />

a measurement technique called concept mapping, which seeks to<br />

accurately relate the effect of a program through the recipient’s own<br />

words. Sixty-seven statements were made by students in our program<br />

that were then sorted, categorized, and evaluated by the entire student<br />

population.<br />

We learned a number of interesting things during the course of the<br />

study. One of the more interesting aspects was that “selfesteem,” as a<br />

concept, was ranked as the most important overall by both teachers<br />

and students. Common themes included: “The class gave me many<br />

new experiences;” “I like playing in front of people;” “It’s given me<br />

more confidence;” “It gives me a feeling of accomplishment;” and “I<br />

feel proud of myself.” Another concept that ranked high on the list,<br />

“unique learning environment.” This included such statements as:<br />

“This class has more interaction with the teachers – everyone gets<br />

attention;” “It’s easier to ask for help in this class;” “It doesn’t make<br />

you feel dumb if you don’t get it;” “It’s okay in this class if you don’t understand;”<br />

“I like that we play in pieces or sections, so we are all needed;”<br />

and “Everyone messes up in this class sometimes, so it doesn’t<br />

feel bad to mess up in this class.” Improved self-esteem, feelings<br />

of belonging, and safety in music class are things that we, as music<br />

teachers, intuitively know to be natural results of great music education.<br />

It was great to see these ideas reflected so clearly in the work of<br />

independent tresearchers.<br />

OBSERVATIONS<br />

Once we decided to venture into curriculum development, it<br />

didn’t take long to develop an outline for what we hoped to accomplish.<br />

It seemed reasonable to expect, given enough time and the<br />

resources of talented educators, that we would be able to create<br />

the materials we envisioned. What we were not prepared for, however,<br />

was the degree to which diverse, modern young Americans<br />

would flock to the classical guitar, stick with it, and become passionately<br />

engaged with it. Indeed, in 2003, many people we spoke<br />

with thought we were crazy to promote a purely classical guitar<br />

curriculum. The sentiment we encountered, and still often run<br />

into, was that very few young people would be interested in the<br />

guitar unless they were playing classic rock or pop music.<br />

What we’ve learned in the intervening years, however, is that<br />

classical music on the guitar has a powerful ability to attract and<br />

retain diverse students to school-based music study. Some students<br />

we’ve encountered are playing music for the first time, some<br />

have played classical guitar before, and others play rock and pop<br />

styles on the guitar casually or with private teachers. For the vast<br />

majority of students, the beauty, intricacy, and challenge of learning<br />

expressive music on the classical guitar, combined with the<br />

contextualizing structure of performances or competitions, develops<br />

a deep, permeating passion for the art form. While excellent<br />

and pedagogically-sound courses in pop guitar playing do exist, we<br />

now know that classroom classical guitar classes, when administered<br />

appropriately, can be incredibly potent vehicles for bringing<br />

new and diverse students to school-based fine arts. Over the 10<br />

years that ACGS has been involved in public school guitar education,<br />

we have become aware of a number of remarkable, inventive,<br />

passionate, and successful educators who have been building similar<br />

programs in other parts of the United States. The stories we<br />

hear, from California to Nevada to New Mexico to Oklahoma to<br />

Florida to Virginia, are similar: large numbers of students, from<br />

diverse backgrounds coming to music study – and sticking with<br />

it – through guitar classes. A community-based nonprofit organization<br />

involved in curriculum and training, we are overjoyed by<br />

the number of choir, orchestra and band directors (and non-guitarists)<br />

from across <strong>No</strong>rth America who have become successful<br />

class guitar instructors. They are adding guitar sections to their<br />

course loads and substantially building their enrollments. We’re<br />

also thrilled to see new jobs created for classical guitarists who<br />

are certified educators, as schools begin hiring full time guitar instructors<br />

to meet the rising demand.<br />

Several years ago, an education reporter from a local Austin<br />

newspaper attended a class at a brand new program and wrote a<br />

front page story on what she saw. She ended the article with a<br />

quote from a senior classman who was taking guitar for the first<br />

time: “It’s the first thing that’s really interested me,” he said, “it<br />

just motivates me to come to school because I want to come to this<br />

class.”<br />

MATTHEW HINSLEY, PH.D., was trained as a classical<br />

guitarist and vocalist at the Interlochen<br />

Arts Academy, the Oberlin Conservatory<br />

of Music, and the University of Texas at<br />

Austin. Beyond perform- ing and scholarly<br />

pursuits, Hinsley has cultivated two primary<br />

professional interests: to enhance the<br />

way young classical guitarists are trained<br />

in America, and to transform the way arts<br />

organiza- tions serve our diverse communities.<br />

As executive director of the Austin<br />

Classical Guitar Society, Hinsley has raised<br />

well beyond $1.5 million in support of broad<br />

concert, outreach and educational programming. He was a lead author in<br />

the ACGS’ curriculum (GuitarCurriculum.com) that serves thousands of<br />

young students throughout <strong>No</strong>rth America, and founded the ACGS performance<br />

outreach program. Hinsley’s private studio has produced students<br />

who have three-times advanced to the final round of the prestigious Guitar<br />

Foundation of America International youth competition, including the<br />

winner in 2006.<br />

Reprinted with permission from American String Teacher, vol. 61, no. 2.<br />

Copyright © 2011 by American String Teachers Association.<br />

Tennessee Music Education Assocation | www.tnmea.org | 35


MusicatTech<br />

2019 Audition Dates:<br />

Fri., February 15, 2019<br />

Fri., February 22, 2019<br />

Fri., March 15, 2019<br />

Cody Hoenie, a junior from Knoxville, Tennessee, studies with Dr. Colin J. Hill. PHOTO BY WARREN LAFEVER.<br />

You have dreams, goals, plans for your future. You want to teach;<br />

you want to perform; you want to study with a world–class faculty . . .<br />

• We offer degrees in music education<br />

(K–12 with instrumental or vocal licensure),<br />

as well as performance degrees in winds,<br />

percussion, strings, piano, voice, jazz, and<br />

music composition.<br />

• Scholarships are available for both music<br />

majors and non–music majors. Please visit<br />

our website to apply.<br />

Member of<br />

NASM<br />

since 1967<br />

• Hundreds of events each year feature our<br />

bands, choirs, orchestras, and chamber<br />

groups as well as student, faculty, and<br />

guest artist recitals.<br />

• Call, write, or schedule a campus visit.<br />

We’d love to meet you and answer your<br />

questions.<br />

www.tntech.edu/music<br />

Tennessee Tech University<br />

School of Music<br />

Box 5045<br />

Cookeville, <strong>TN</strong> 38505<br />

(931) 372–3161<br />

music@tntech.edu<br />

Tennessee Tech does not condone and will not tolerate discrimination against<br />

any individual on the basis of race, religion, color, creed, sex, age, national<br />

origin, genetic information, disability, veteran status, and any other basis protected<br />

by federal and state civil rights law. Tennessee Tech complies with Title<br />

IX and prohibits discrimination on the basis of sex in education programs and<br />

activities, admissions or employment. For inquiries regarding non-discrimination<br />

policies, contact equity@tntech.edu; for Title IX, TitleIX@tntech.edu The TTU<br />

policy on nondiscrimination can be found at www.tntech.edu/ideaa.


TENNESSEE MUSICIAN ADVERTISER INDEX | VOLUME <strong>71</strong>, <strong>No</strong>. 1<br />

A very special<br />

thank you to all<br />

of our advertisers<br />

who support the<br />

work of music<br />

educators at all<br />

levels in the State<br />

of Tennessee.<br />

ADVERTISER<br />

Austin Peay State University 31<br />

Belmont University 9<br />

Bob Rogers Travel 27<br />

East Tennessee State University 11<br />

Lee University<br />

Inside Front Cover<br />

Lipscomb University<br />

Back Cover<br />

Maryville College 14<br />

Middle Tennessee State University 3<br />

Milligan College 26<br />

NAMM Foundation 40<br />

Slate Group<br />

Inside Back Cover<br />

Smoky Mountain Music Festival 12<br />

Tennessee State University 17<br />

Tennessee Technological University 36<br />

University of Memphis 13<br />

University of Tennessee at Chattanooga 7<br />

University of Tennessee at Knoxville Bands 39<br />

University of Tennessee at Knoxville School of Music 20<br />

University of Tennessee at Martin 15<br />

Yamaha Corporation of America 5<br />

Tennessee Music Education Assocation | www.tnmea.org | 37


TMEA BACK THEN<br />

• The cover of this particular issue of<br />

the Tennessee <strong>Musician</strong> featured a<br />

photograph of the Nashville All-City<br />

Grade School Symphony Orchestra.<br />

Started in 1950, the Nashville City<br />

Schools (presumably) purchased over<br />

100 violins, and then added cellos<br />

and other instruments over the next<br />

years. The ensemble, made up of 126<br />

students ranging in ages between 9<br />

and 14, met on Saturday’s and would<br />

later be featured in a local television<br />

production This is Nashville. The<br />

ensemble performed in Nashville’s War<br />

Memorial Auditorium. The instructional<br />

staff included Arthur Kleine, Horace<br />

C. Beasley, James Doster, Mary Laura<br />

Cannon, Floyd H. Rogers, Howard<br />

F. Brown, Marie Louise Farnham,<br />

Mrs. Robert Johnson, Raymond<br />

Gill, Lee Hillis, Jr., and D.F. Bain.<br />

• Then conductor of the Nashville<br />

Symphony Guy Taylor had an article<br />

that detailed the upcoming plans and<br />

season of the Nashville Symphony.<br />

The article noted the organization of<br />

the Nashville Symphony (at that time<br />

the organization was governed by the<br />

Nashville Civic Music Association)<br />

and its subsequent other ensembles<br />

including the Symphonette, Choral<br />

Society, and Youth Orchestra. Among<br />

the special plans of the season, Aaron<br />

Copland was scheduled to appear at a<br />

concert on April 28 and in subsequent<br />

seminars held at Peabody College<br />

(now Vanderbilt University). Howard<br />

Hanson was also scheduled to appear as<br />

an invited guest composer-conductor.<br />

• State Music Consultant Alfred W.<br />

Humphries, (presumably with the<br />

Tennessee Department of Education)<br />

contributed an article on the current<br />

status of the Tennessee State-Wide<br />

Music Program. This article is a<br />

fascinating read, especially for its<br />

historical account of the origins and<br />

partnerships of this initiative with<br />

several of Tennessee’s universities<br />

and colleges and the Tennessee Music<br />

Education Association.<br />

• Then TMEA President N. Taylor Hagan,<br />

of East Nashville High School, wrote a<br />

rather eloquent message in his column.<br />

Taylor made several observations<br />

about the power of music education<br />

and its role in American society. His<br />

column referenced thinking of the day,<br />

with calls for education to focus on<br />

“moral and spiritual values.” He goes<br />

on to discuss the State-Wide Music<br />

Program, which was launched by the<br />

Tennessee Department of Education<br />

in 1948, with the goal, among many,<br />

to give access to music education to<br />

all students across Tennessee. Hagan<br />

called the initiative “grassroots”,<br />

advocating for more regional assistance<br />

and support for the campaign.<br />

• The city of Chattanooga was selected<br />

as a host for the Southern Division<br />

Conference of the Music Educators<br />

National Conference (MENC - now<br />

NAfME). The conference, which took<br />

place on April 10-13, 1953, celebrated its<br />

thirtieth anniversary. Edward Hamilton<br />

of Knoxville City Schools and a pastpresident<br />

of TMEA, served as Southern<br />

Division President. According to the<br />

press release, the Southern Division of<br />

MENC was reported to have been first<br />

organized at a meeting in Nashville,<br />

Tennessee some thirty-years prior.<br />

38 | TENNESSEE MUSICIAN | 2018 | <strong>Vol</strong>ume <strong>71</strong>, <strong>No</strong>. 1<br />

THE TENNESSEE MUSICIAN<br />

(OCOTBER 1952)<br />

<strong>Vol</strong>ume 5, <strong>No</strong>. 1 – 12 pgs.<br />

N. Taylor Hagan, TMEA President | Floyd H. Rodgers, Editor


Celebrating 20 Years of<br />

Commitment to Music Education<br />

The NAMM Foundation’s Best Communities for Music Education<br />

(BCME) national recognition program is in its 20th year of honoring schools<br />

and districts that demonstrate a strong commitment to continuing<br />

and growing their music education programs.<br />

Get The National Recognition Your Music Program Deserves!<br />

Apply by January 31, 2019 at NAMMFoundation.org/BCME<br />

Photo Credit: Rob Davidson<br />

NAMMFOUNDATION.ORG<br />

NAMMF_20thBCME_TMEA_8x5.12Final.indd 1<br />

9/7/18 4:55 PM<br />

NAfME BACKPACK<br />

Be ready for whatever the school year brings<br />

with NAfME in your backpack!<br />

Visit: bit.ly/NAfMEBackpack


you work hard at<br />

sounding good<br />

we work hard at<br />

looking<br />

good<br />

SLATE GROUP SUPPORTS<br />

MUSIC EDUCATION<br />

THROUGH WHAT WE DO BEST.<br />

PUBLICATION DESIGN<br />

PRINT<br />

DISPLAY GRAPHICS<br />

CONTACT IAN SPECTOR TODAY<br />

800.794.5594 | ian@slategroup.com<br />

slategroup.com


Tennessee Music Education Association<br />

129 Paschal Drive<br />

Murfreesboro, Tennessee 3<strong>71</strong>28<br />

Lipscomb University’s School of Music<br />

welcomes new Director of Instrumental Studies Dr. Ben Blasko.<br />

Dr. Ben Blasko<br />

D.M.A. Wind Conducting<br />

• Winner of the World Music Conducting<br />

Competition in the United States - 2017<br />

• Recording engineer for over 20 albums<br />

• Compositions released on Klavier, Mark<br />

Custom, Naxos and Sparrow Record Labels<br />

For information about how your students<br />

can train with us in Music City, email Ben at:<br />

bablasko@lipscomb.edu.<br />

Lipscomb University School of Music<br />

615-966-5932<br />

music@lipscomb.edu

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!